License: arXiv.org perpetual non-exclusive license
arXiv:2403.00760v1 [math.NT] 01 Mar 2024
Faulhaberβs formula, Bernoulli numbers and the equation
Chai Wah Wu
IBM Research
IBM T. J. Watson Research Center, Yorktown Heights, NY, USAβ β thanks: cwwu@us.ibm.com
(March 1, 2024)
Abstract
In modern usage the Bernoulli numbers and polynomials follow Eulerβs approach and are defined using generating functions. We consider the functional equation and show that a solution can be derived from Faulhaberβs formula for the sum of powers. We show how these solutions provide a characterization of Bernoulli numbers and related results.
1 Introduction
We consider the functional equation described by
|
|
|
(1) |
A purpose of this brief note is to show that Faulhaberβs formula for the sums of powers (which initiated the study of Bernoulli numbers) can be used to derive a solution to this equation and leads to a characterization of Bernoulli numbers, Bernoulli polynomials and related identities.
2 Faulhaberβs formula
Faulhaberβs formula (also known as Bernoulliβs formula) equates the sum of powers of consecutive integers to a polynomial involving Bernoulli numbers. It was discovered by various people including Takanaga, Faulhaber, and Bernoulli.
In particular, for and nonnegative integers,
|
|
|
(2) |
where are the Bernoulli numbers of the second kind.
There are in general two conventions when defining Bernoulli numbers, with the only difference being the sign of . In particular, , whereas
the Bernoulli numbers of the first kind are identical to except for . has been used in modern textbooks although recently there are discussions on whether , which was used in the past, should be favored. Computer algebra software such as Mathematica
currently use to denote Bernoulli numbers. However, the bernoulli
function in Sympy
which until very recently also returns has changed from returning to starting from version 1.12. Note that the number of terms in the left hand side is while it is on the right hand side, meaning that the computation of is more efficient using the right hand side when .
The Bernoulli numbers are defined in modern usage via the generating functions [1]:
|
|
|
(3) |
|
|
|
(4) |
They also satisfy the following recursive definitions [1]:
Lemma 1.
|
|
|
(5) |
|
|
|
(6) |
Where is the Kronecker delta function defined as if and otherwise.
2.1 A variant of Faulhaberβs formula
Eq. (2) expresses the sum of powers using Bernoulli numbers of the second kind . The following formula gives a variant of Faulhaberβs formula using Bernoulli numbers of the first kind [2].
Theorem 1.
If , then
|
|
|
(7) |
Proof.
By Eq. (2),
|
|
|
For , the corresponding term is whereas .
This means that and the conclusion follows.
β
Note that the formula in Eq. (7) is almost identical to the formula in Eq. (2) except for using rather than and shifting the base of the powers from to .
3 A solution to the equation
Define , then the above discussion shows that . Note that , the -th Bernoulli polynomial.
We show that the converse is also true among polynomials in the following sense.
Suppose that is a minimal degree polynomial that satisfied Eq. (1). Clearly must have degree larger than or equal to .
If has degree , then the coefficient of does not match in Eq. (1). Therefore, must be of degree or larger.
Consider the case where has degree written as .
Then Eq. (1) can be written as
.
Matching the coefficients results in the following equations
for
and . This last equation can be simplified as:
, i.e. .
The equation for is the identity .
The remaining equations for uniquely determines the other coefficients . In particular, ,
i.e. for ,
|
|
|
This implies that
.
Let or equivalently
. This implies that and .
After straightforward algebraic manipulations we get the following identity regarding
βsβ:
for which is exactly the recursive definition of the Benoulli number in Lemma 1.
Thus we have shown that
Proposition 1.
The first Bernoulli numbers are defined by the coefficients of the minimal degree polynomial that satisfies the functional equation via the equation .
Define , a -degree polynomial with rational coefficients. Then Eqns 2-7 show that
.
An analogous derivation shows that
Proposition 2.
The first Bernoulli numbers are defined by the coefficients of the minimal degree polynomial that satisfies the functional equation via the equation .
Since the Bernoulli polynomials form an Appell sequence [4], i.e., it satisfies the differential equation , it is clear that
is an Appell sequence as well. This implies that it satisfies Appellβs identity: , i.e. . This simplifies to the equation
.
References
-
[1]
Wikipedia, βBernoulli number β Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.β
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bernoulli%20number&oldid=1198154404,
2024.
[Online; accessed 01-February-2024].
-
[2]
N.Β D. Larson, The Bernoulli Numbers: A Brief Primer.
Whitman College, 2019.
-
[3]
K.Β Ireland and M.Β Rosen, A classical introduction to modern number
theory, vol.Β 84 of Graduate texts in mathematics.
Springer, 1982.
-
[4]
Wikipedia, βAppell sequence β Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.β
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Appell%20sequence&oldid=1194111356,
2024.
[Online; accessed 01-February-2024].
-
[5]
D.Β E. Knuth, βJohann Faulhaber and sums of powers,β Mathematics of
Computation, vol.Β 61, pp.Β 277β294, July 1993.
-
[6]
A.Β F. Beardon, βSums of powers of integers,β The American Mathematical
Monthly, vol.Β 103, no.Β 3, pp.Β 201β213, 1996.
-
[7]
P.Β H.Β N. Luschny, βAn introduction to the Bernoulli function.β
arXiv:2009.06743, 2021.
-
[8]
B.Β C. Kellner, βFaulhaber polynomials and reciprocal Bernoulli
polynomials,β Rocky Mountain J. Math., vol.Β 53, pp.Β 119β151, 2023.