-
The FluidFlower International Benchmark Study: Process, Modeling Results, and Comparison to Experimental Data
Authors:
Bernd Flemisch,
Jan M. Nordbotten,
Martin Fernø,
Ruben Juanes,
Holger Class,
Mojdeh Delshad,
Florian Doster,
Jonathan Ennis-King,
Jacques Franc,
Sebastian Geiger,
Dennis Gläser,
Christopher Green,
James Gunning,
Hadi Hajibeygi,
Samuel J. Jackson,
Mohamad Jammoul,
Satish Karra,
Jiawei Li,
Stephan K. Matthäi,
Terry Miller,
Qi Shao,
Catherine Spurin,
Philip Stauffer,
Hamdi Tchelepi,
Xiaoming Tian
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Successful deployment of geological carbon storage (GCS) requires an extensive use of reservoir simulators for screening, ranking and optimization of storage sites. However, the time scales of GCS are such that no sufficient long-term data is available yet to validate the simulators against. As a consequence, there is currently no solid basis for assessing the quality with which the dynamics of la…
▽ More
Successful deployment of geological carbon storage (GCS) requires an extensive use of reservoir simulators for screening, ranking and optimization of storage sites. However, the time scales of GCS are such that no sufficient long-term data is available yet to validate the simulators against. As a consequence, there is currently no solid basis for assessing the quality with which the dynamics of large-scale GCS operations can be forecasted.
To meet this knowledge gap, we have conducted a major GCS validation benchmark study. To achieve reasonable time scales, a laboratory-size geological storage formation was constructed (the "FluidFlower"), forming the basis for both the experimental and computational work. A validation experiment consisting of repeated GCS operations was conducted in the FluidFlower, providing what we define as the true physical dynamics for this system. Nine different research groups from around the world provided forecasts, both individually and collaboratively, based on a detailed physical and petrophysical characterization of the FluidFlower sands.
The major contribution of this paper is a report and discussion of the results of the validation benchmark study, complemented by a description of the benchmarking process and the participating computational models. The forecasts from the participating groups are compared to each other and to the experimental data by means of various indicative qualitative and quantitative measures. By this, we provide a detailed assessment of the capabilities of reservoir simulators and their users to capture both the injection and post-injection dynamics of the GCS operations.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Visual Ensemble Analysis of Fluid Flow in Porous Media across Simulation Codes and Experiment
Authors:
Ruben Bauer,
Quynh Quang Ngo,
Guido Reina,
Steffen Frey,
Bernd Flemisch,
Helwig Hauser,
Thomas Ertl,
Michael Sedlmair
Abstract:
We study the question of how visual analysis can support the comparison of spatio-temporal ensemble data of liquid and gas flow in porous media. To this end, we focus on a case study, in which nine different research groups concurrently simulated the process of injecting CO2 into the subsurface. We explore different data aggregation and interactive visualization approaches to compare and analyze t…
▽ More
We study the question of how visual analysis can support the comparison of spatio-temporal ensemble data of liquid and gas flow in porous media. To this end, we focus on a case study, in which nine different research groups concurrently simulated the process of injecting CO2 into the subsurface. We explore different data aggregation and interactive visualization approaches to compare and analyze these nine simulations. In terms of data aggregation, one key component is the choice of similarity metrics that define the relation between the different simulations. We test different metrics and find that a fine-tuned machine-learning based metric provides the best visualization results. Based on that, we propose different visualization methods. For overviewing the data, we use dimensionality reduction methods that allow us to plot and compare the different simulations in a scatterplot. To show details about the spatio-temporal data of each individual simulation, we employ a space-time cube volume rendering. We use the resulting interactive, multi-view visual analysis tool to explore the nine simulations and also to compare them to data from experimental setups. Our main findings include new insights into ranking of simulation results with respect to experimental data, and the development of gravity fingers in simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023; v1 submitted 26 January, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
A sustainable infrastructure concept for improved accessibility, reusability, and archival of research software
Authors:
Timo Koch,
Dennis Gläser,
Anett Seeland,
Sarbani Roy,
Katharina Schulze,
Kilian Weishaupt,
David Boehringer,
Sibylle Hermann,
Bernd Flemisch
Abstract:
Research software is an integral part of most research today and it is widely accepted that research software artifacts should be accessible and reproducible. However, the sustainable archival of research software artifacts is an ongoing effort. We identify research software artifacts as snapshots of the current state of research and an integral part of a sustainable cycle of software development,…
▽ More
Research software is an integral part of most research today and it is widely accepted that research software artifacts should be accessible and reproducible. However, the sustainable archival of research software artifacts is an ongoing effort. We identify research software artifacts as snapshots of the current state of research and an integral part of a sustainable cycle of software development, research, and publication. We develop requirements and recommendations to improve the archival, access, and reuse of research software artifacts based on installable, configurable, extensible research software, and sustainable public open-access infrastructure. The described goal is to enable the reuse and exploration of research software beyond published research results, in parallel with reproducibility efforts, and in line with the FAIR principles for data and software. Research software artifacts can be reused in varying scenarios. To this end, we design a multi-modal representation concept supporting multiple reuse scenarios. We identify types of research software artifacts that can be viewed as different modes of the same software-based research result, for example, installation-free configurable browser-based apps to containerized environments, descriptions in journal publications and software documentation, or source code with installation instructions. We discuss how the sustainability and reuse of research software are enhanced or enabled by a suitable archive infrastructure. Finally, at the example of a pilot project at the University of Stuttgart, Germany -- a collaborative effort between research software developers and infrastructure providers -- we outline practical challenges and experiences
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Evaluation of tools for describing, reproducing and reusing scientific workflows
Authors:
Philipp Diercks,
Dennis Gläser,
Ontje Lünsdorf,
Michael Selzer,
Bernd Flemisch,
Jörg F. Unger
Abstract:
In the field of computational science and engineering, workflows often entail the application of various software, for instance, for simulation or pre- and postprocessing. Typically, these components have to be combined in arbitrarily complex workflows to address a specific research question. In order for peer researchers to understand, reproduce and (re)use the findings of a scientific publicatio…
▽ More
In the field of computational science and engineering, workflows often entail the application of various software, for instance, for simulation or pre- and postprocessing. Typically, these components have to be combined in arbitrarily complex workflows to address a specific research question. In order for peer researchers to understand, reproduce and (re)use the findings of a scientific publication, several challenges have to be addressed. For instance, the employed workflow has to be automated and information on all used software must be available for a reproduction of the results. Moreover, the results must be traceable and the workflow documented and readable to allow for external verification and greater trust. In this paper, existing workflow management systems (WfMSs) are discussed regarding their suitability for describing, reproducing and reusing scientific workflows. To this end, a set of general requirements for WfMSswere deduced from user stories that we deem relevant in the domain of computational science and engineering. On the basis of an exemplary workflow implementation, publicly hosted at GitHub (https:// github.com/BAMresearch/NFDI4IngScientificWorkflowRequirements), a selection of different WfMSs is compared with respect to these requirements, to support fellow scientists in identifying the WfMSs that best suit their requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
An Environment for Sustainable Research Software in Germany and Beyond: Current State, Open Challenges, and Call for Action
Authors:
Hartwig Anzt,
Felix Bach,
Stephan Druskat,
Frank Löffler,
Axel Loewe,
Bernhard Y. Renard,
Gunnar Seemann,
Alexander Struck,
Elke Achhammer,
Piush Aggarwal,
Franziska Appel,
Michael Bader,
Lutz Brusch,
Christian Busse,
Gerasimos Chourdakis,
Piotr W. Dabrowski,
Peter Ebert,
Bernd Flemisch,
Sven Friedl,
Bernadette Fritzsch,
Maximilian D. Funk,
Volker Gast,
Florian Goth,
Jean-Noël Grad,
Sibylle Hermann
, et al. (18 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Research software has become a central asset in academic research. It optimizes existing and enables new research methods, implements and embeds research knowledge, and constitutes an essential research product in itself. Research software must be sustainable in order to understand, replicate, reproduce, and build upon existing research or conduct new research effectively. In other words, software…
▽ More
Research software has become a central asset in academic research. It optimizes existing and enables new research methods, implements and embeds research knowledge, and constitutes an essential research product in itself. Research software must be sustainable in order to understand, replicate, reproduce, and build upon existing research or conduct new research effectively. In other words, software must be available, discoverable, usable, and adaptable to new needs, both now and in the future. Research software therefore requires an environment that supports sustainability. Hence, a change is needed in the way research software development and maintenance are currently motivated, incentivized, funded, structurally and infrastructurally supported, and legally treated. Failing to do so will threaten the quality and validity of research. In this paper, we identify challenges for research software sustainability in Germany and beyond, in terms of motivation, selection, research software engineering personnel, funding, infrastructure, and legal aspects. Besides researchers, we specifically address political and academic decision-makers to increase awareness of the importance and needs of sustainable research software practices. In particular, we recommend strategies and measures to create an environment for sustainable research software, with the ultimate goal to ensure that software-driven research is valid, reproducible and sustainable, and that software is recognized as a first class citizen in research. This paper is the outcome of two workshops run in Germany in 2019, at deRSE19 - the first International Conference of Research Software Engineers in Germany - and a dedicated DFG-supported follow-up workshop in Berlin.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020; v1 submitted 27 April, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
DuMu$^\text{x}$ 3 -- an open-source simulator for solving flow and transport problems in porous media with a focus on model coupling
Authors:
Timo Koch,
Dennis Gläser,
Kilian Weishaupt,
Sina Ackermann,
Martin Beck,
Beatrix Becker,
Samuel Burbulla,
Holger Class,
Edward Coltman,
Simon Emmert,
Thomas Fetzer,
Christoph Grüninger,
Katharina Heck,
Johannes Hommel,
Theresa Kurz,
Melanie Lipp,
Farid Mohammadi,
Samuel Scherrer,
Martin Schneider,
Gabriele Seitz,
Leopold Stadler,
Martin Utz,
Felix Weinhardt,
Bernd Flemisch
Abstract:
We present version 3 of the open-source simulator for flow and transport processes in porous media DuMu$^\text{x}$. DuMu$^\text{x}$ is based on the modular C++ framework Dune (Distributed and Unified Numerics Environment) and is developed as a research code with a focus on modularity and reusability. We describe recent efforts in improving the transparency and efficiency of the development process…
▽ More
We present version 3 of the open-source simulator for flow and transport processes in porous media DuMu$^\text{x}$. DuMu$^\text{x}$ is based on the modular C++ framework Dune (Distributed and Unified Numerics Environment) and is developed as a research code with a focus on modularity and reusability. We describe recent efforts in improving the transparency and efficiency of the development process and community-building, as well as efforts towards quality assurance and reproducible research. In addition to a major redesign of many simulation components in order to facilitate setting up complex simulations in DuMu$^\text{x}$, version 3 introduces a more consistent abstraction of finite volume schemes. Finally, the new framework for multi-domain simulations is described, and three numerical examples demonstrate its flexibility.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Benchmarks for single-phase flow in fractured porous media
Authors:
Bernd Flemisch,
Inga Berre,
Wietse Boon,
Alessio Fumagalli,
Nicolas Schwenck,
Anna Scotti,
Ivar Stefansson,
Alexandru Tatomir
Abstract:
This paper presents several test cases intended to be benchmarks for numerical schemes for single-phase fluid flow in fractured porous media. A number of solution strategies are compared, including a vertex and a cell-centered finite volume method, a non-conforming embedded discrete fracture model, a primal and a dual extended finite element formulation, and a mortar discrete fracture model. The p…
▽ More
This paper presents several test cases intended to be benchmarks for numerical schemes for single-phase fluid flow in fractured porous media. A number of solution strategies are compared, including a vertex and a cell-centered finite volume method, a non-conforming embedded discrete fracture model, a primal and a dual extended finite element formulation, and a mortar discrete fracture model. The proposed benchmarks test the schemes by increasing the difficulties in terms of network geometry, e.g. intersecting fractures, and physical parameters, e.g. low and high fracture-matrix permeability ratio as well as heterogeneous fracture permeabilities. For each problem, the results presented by the participants are the number of unknowns, the approximation errors in the porous matrix and in the fractures with respect to a reference solution, and the sparsity and condition number of the discretized linear system. All data and meshes used in this study are publicly available for further comparisons.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
The Dune FoamGrid implementation for surface and network grids
Authors:
Oliver Sander,
Timo Koch,
Natalie Schröder,
Bernd Flemisch
Abstract:
We present FoamGrid, a new implementation of the DUNE grid interface. FoamGrid implements one- and two-dimensional grids in a physical space of arbitrary dimension, which allows for grids for curved domains. Even more, the grids are not expected to have a manifold structure, i.e., more than two elements can share a common facet. This makes FoamGrid the grid data structure of choice for simulating…
▽ More
We present FoamGrid, a new implementation of the DUNE grid interface. FoamGrid implements one- and two-dimensional grids in a physical space of arbitrary dimension, which allows for grids for curved domains. Even more, the grids are not expected to have a manifold structure, i.e., more than two elements can share a common facet. This makes FoamGrid the grid data structure of choice for simulating structures such as foams, discrete fracture networks, or network flow problems. FoamGrid implements adaptive non-conforming refinement with element parametrizations. As an additional feature it allows removal and addition of elements in an existing grid, which makes FoamGrid suitable for network growth problems. We show how to use FoamGrid, with particular attention to the extensions of the grid interface needed to handle non-manifold topology and grid growth. Three numerical examples demonstrate the possibilities offered by FoamGrid.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
