-
Transformations preserving the effective spectral radius of a matrix
Authors:
Jean-François Delmas,
Dylan Dronnier,
Pierre-André Zitt
Abstract:
We discuss transformations on matrices that preserve the effective spectrum and/or the effective spectral radius.
We discuss transformations on matrices that preserve the effective spectrum and/or the effective spectral radius.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Vaccinating according to the maximal endemic equilibrium achieves herd immunity
Authors:
Jean-François Delmas,
Dylan Dronnier,
Pierre-André Zitt
Abstract:
We consider the simple epidemiological SIS model for a general heterogeneous population introduced by Lajmanovich and Yorke (1976) in finite dimension, and its infinite dimensional generalization we introduced in previous works. In this model the basic reproducing number $R_0$ is given by the spectral radius of an integral operator. If $R_0>1$, then there exists a maximal endemic equilibrium. In t…
▽ More
We consider the simple epidemiological SIS model for a general heterogeneous population introduced by Lajmanovich and Yorke (1976) in finite dimension, and its infinite dimensional generalization we introduced in previous works. In this model the basic reproducing number $R_0$ is given by the spectral radius of an integral operator. If $R_0>1$, then there exists a maximal endemic equilibrium. In this very general heterogeneous SIS model, we prove that vaccinating according to the profile of this maximal endemic equilibrium ensures herd immunity. Moreover, this vaccination strategy is critical: the resulting effective reproduction number is exactly equal to one. As an application, we estimate that if $R_0 = 2$ in an age-structured community with mixing rates fitted to social activity, applying this strategy would require approximately 29% less vaccine doses than the strategy which consists in vaccinating uniformly a proportion $1 - 1/R_0$ of the population.
From a dynamical systems point of view, we prove that the non-maximality of an equilibrium $g$ is equivalent to its linear instability in the original dynamics, and to the linear instability of the disease-free state in the modified dynamics where we vaccinate according to $g$.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The effective reproduction number: convexity, concavity and invariance
Authors:
Jean-François Delmas,
Dylan Dronnier,
Pierre-André Zitt
Abstract:
Motivated by the question of optimal vaccine allocation strategies in heterogeneous population for epidemic models, we study various properties of the \emph{effective reproduction number}. In the simplest case, given a fixed, non-negative matrix $K$, this corresponds mathematically to the study of the spectral radius $R_e(η)$ of the matrix product $\mathrm{Diag}(η)K$, as a function of…
▽ More
Motivated by the question of optimal vaccine allocation strategies in heterogeneous population for epidemic models, we study various properties of the \emph{effective reproduction number}. In the simplest case, given a fixed, non-negative matrix $K$, this corresponds mathematically to the study of the spectral radius $R_e(η)$ of the matrix product $\mathrm{Diag}(η)K$, as a function of $η\in\mathbb{R}_+^n$. The matrix $K$ and the vector $η$ can be interpreted as a next-generation operator and a vaccination strategy. This can be generalized in an infinite dimensional case where the matrix $K$ is replaced by a positive integral compact operator, which is composed with a multiplication by a non-negative function $η$.
We give sufficient conditions for the function $R_e$ to be convex or a concave. Eventually, we provide equivalence properties on models which ensure that the function $R_e$ is unchanged.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Optimal vaccinations: Cordons sanitaires, reducible population and optimal rays
Authors:
Jean-François Delmas,
Dylan Dronnier,
Pierre-André Zitt
Abstract:
We consider the bi-objective problem of allocating doses of a (perfect) vaccine to an infinite-dimensional metapopulation in order to minimize simultaneously the vaccination cost and the effective reproduction number $R_e$, which is defined as the spectral radius of the effective next-generation operator.
In this general framework, we prove that a cordon sanitaire, that is, a strategy that effec…
▽ More
We consider the bi-objective problem of allocating doses of a (perfect) vaccine to an infinite-dimensional metapopulation in order to minimize simultaneously the vaccination cost and the effective reproduction number $R_e$, which is defined as the spectral radius of the effective next-generation operator.
In this general framework, we prove that a cordon sanitaire, that is, a strategy that effectively disconnects the non-vaccinated population, might not be optimal, but it is still better than the "worst" vaccination strategies. Inspired by graph theory, we also compute the minimal cost which ensures that no infection occurs using independent sets. Using Frobenius decomposition of the whole population into irreducible sub-populations, we give some explicit formulae for optimal ("best" and "worst") vaccinations strategies. Eventually, we provide some sufficient conditions for a scaling of an optimal strategy to still be optimal.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2022; v1 submitted 15 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Optimal vaccination: Various (counter) intuitive examples
Authors:
Jean-François Delmas,
Dylan Dronnier,
Pierre-André Zitt
Abstract:
In previous articles, we formalized the problem of optimal allocation strategies for a (perfect) vaccine in an infinite-dimensional metapopulation model. The aim of the current paper is to illustrate this theoretical framework with multiple examples where one can derive the analytic expression of the optimal strategies. We discuss in particular the following points: whether or not it is possible t…
▽ More
In previous articles, we formalized the problem of optimal allocation strategies for a (perfect) vaccine in an infinite-dimensional metapopulation model. The aim of the current paper is to illustrate this theoretical framework with multiple examples where one can derive the analytic expression of the optimal strategies. We discuss in particular the following points: whether or not it is possible to vaccinate optimally when the vaccine doses are given one at a time (greedy vaccination strategies); the effect of assortativity (that is, the tendency to have more contacts with similar individuals) on the shape of optimal vaccination strategies; the particular case where everybody has the same number of neighbors.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Effective reproduction number: Convexity, invariance and cordons sanitaires
Authors:
Jean-François Delmas,
Dylan Dronnier,
Pierre-André Zitt
Abstract:
We consider the problem of optimal allocation strategies for a (perfect) vaccine in an infinite-metapopulation model (including SIS, SIR, SEIR,. . .), when the loss function is given by the effective reproduction number Re, which is defined as the spectral radius of the effective next generation matrix (in finite dimension) or more generally of the effective next generation operator (in infinite d…
▽ More
We consider the problem of optimal allocation strategies for a (perfect) vaccine in an infinite-metapopulation model (including SIS, SIR, SEIR,. . .), when the loss function is given by the effective reproduction number Re, which is defined as the spectral radius of the effective next generation matrix (in finite dimension) or more generally of the effective next generation operator (in infinite dimension). We give sufficient conditions for Re to be a convex or a concave function of the vaccination strategy. Then, following a previous work, we consider the bi-objective problem of minimizing simultaneously the cost and the loss of the vaccination strategies. In particular, we prove that a cordon sanitaire might not be optimal, but it is still better than the "worst" vaccination strategies. Inspired by the graph theory, we compute the minimal cost which ensures that no infection occurs using independent sets. Using Frobenius decomposition of the whole population into irreducible sub-populations, we give some explicit formulae for optimal ("best" and "worst") vaccinations strategies. Eventually, we provide equivalence properties on models which ensure that the function Re is unchanged.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Targeted Vaccination Strategies for an Infinite-dimensional SIS Model
Authors:
Jean-François Delmas,
Dylan Dronnier,
Pierre-André Zitt
Abstract:
We formalize and study the problem of optimal allocation strategies for a (perfect) vaccine in the infinite-dimensional SIS model. The question may be viewed as a bi-objective minimization problem, where one tries to minimize simultaneously the cost of the vaccination, and a loss that may be either the effective reproduction number, or the proportion of the infected population in the endemic state…
▽ More
We formalize and study the problem of optimal allocation strategies for a (perfect) vaccine in the infinite-dimensional SIS model. The question may be viewed as a bi-objective minimization problem, where one tries to minimize simultaneously the cost of the vaccination, and a loss that may be either the effective reproduction number, or the proportion of the infected population in the endemic state. We prove the existence of Pareto optimal strategies, describe the corresponding Pareto frontier in both cases, and study its convexity and stability properties. We also show that vaccinating according to the profile of the endemic state is a critical allocation, in the sense that, if the initial reproduction number is larger than 1, then this vaccination strategy yields an effective reproduction number equal to 1.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2021; v1 submitted 17 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
An Infinite-Dimensional SIS Model
Authors:
Jean-François Delmas,
Dylan Dronnier,
Pierre-André Zitt
Abstract:
In this article, we introduce an infinite-dimensional deterministic SIS model which takes into account the heterogeneity of the infections and the social network among a large population. We study the long-time behavior of the dynamic. We identify the basic reproduction number $R_0$ which determines whether there exists a stable endemic steady state (super-critical case: $R_0>1$) or if the only e…
▽ More
In this article, we introduce an infinite-dimensional deterministic SIS model which takes into account the heterogeneity of the infections and the social network among a large population. We study the long-time behavior of the dynamic. We identify the basic reproduction number $R_0$ which determines whether there exists a stable endemic steady state (super-critical case: $R_0>1$) or if the only equilibrium is disease-free (critical and sub-critical case: $R_0\leq1$). As an application of this general study, we prove that the so-called ``leaky'' and ``all-or-nothing'' vaccination mechanism have the same effect on $R_0$. This framework is also very natural and intuitive to model lockdown policies and study their impact.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
