-
NPA Hierarchy for Quantum Isomorphism and Homomorphism Indistinguishability
Authors:
Prem Nigam Kar,
David E. Roberson,
Tim Seppelt,
Peter Zeman
Abstract:
Mančinska and Roberson~[FOCS'20] showed that two graphs are quantum isomorphic if and only if they are homomorphism indistinguishable over the class of planar graphs. Atserias et al.~[JCTB'19] proved that quantum isomorphism is undecidable in general. The NPA hierarchy gives a sequence of semidefinite programming relaxations of quantum isomorphism. Recently, Roberson and Seppelt~[ICALP'23] obtaine…
▽ More
Mančinska and Roberson~[FOCS'20] showed that two graphs are quantum isomorphic if and only if they are homomorphism indistinguishable over the class of planar graphs. Atserias et al.~[JCTB'19] proved that quantum isomorphism is undecidable in general. The NPA hierarchy gives a sequence of semidefinite programming relaxations of quantum isomorphism. Recently, Roberson and Seppelt~[ICALP'23] obtained a homomorphism indistinguishability characterization of the feasibility of each level of the Lasserre hierarchy of semidefinite programming relaxations of graph isomorphism. We prove a quantum analogue of this result by showing that each level of the NPA hierarchy of SDP relaxations for quantum isomorphism of graphs is equivalent to homomorphism indistinguishability over an appropriate class of planar graphs. By combining the convergence of the NPA hierarchy with the fact that the union of these graph classes is the set of all planar graphs, we are able to give a new proof of the result of Mančinska and Roberson~[FOCS'20] that avoids the use of the theory of quantum groups. This homomorphism indistinguishability characterization also allows us to give a randomized polynomial-time algorithm deciding exact feasibility of each fixed level of the NPA hierarchy of SDP relaxations for quantum isomorphism.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Quantum Sabidussi's Theorem
Authors:
Arnbjörg Soffía Árnadóttir,
Josse van Dobben de Bruyn,
Prem Nigam Kar,
David E. Roberson,
Peter Zeman
Abstract:
Sabidussi's theorem [Duke Math. J. 28, 1961] gives necessary and sufficient conditions under which the automorphism group of a lexicographic product of two graphs is a wreath product of the respective automorphism groups. We prove a quantum version of Sabidussi's theorem for finite graphs, with the automorphism groups replaced by quantum automorphism groups and the wreath product replaced by the f…
▽ More
Sabidussi's theorem [Duke Math. J. 28, 1961] gives necessary and sufficient conditions under which the automorphism group of a lexicographic product of two graphs is a wreath product of the respective automorphism groups. We prove a quantum version of Sabidussi's theorem for finite graphs, with the automorphism groups replaced by quantum automorphism groups and the wreath product replaced by the free wreath product of quantum groups. This extends the result of Chassaniol [J. Algebra 456, 2016], who proved it for regular graphs. Moreover, we apply our result to lexicographic products of quantum vertex transitive graphs, determining their quantum automorphism groups even when Sabidussi's conditions do not apply.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2024; v1 submitted 19 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Transitive Nonlocal Games
Authors:
Prem Nigam Kar,
Jitendra Prakash,
David E Roberson
Abstract:
We study a class of nonlocal games, called transitive games, for which the set of perfect strategies forms a semigroup. We establish several interesting correspondences of bisynchronous transitive games with the theory of compact quantum groups. In particular, we associate a quantum permutation group with each bisynchronous transitive game and vice versa. We prove that the existence of a C*-strate…
▽ More
We study a class of nonlocal games, called transitive games, for which the set of perfect strategies forms a semigroup. We establish several interesting correspondences of bisynchronous transitive games with the theory of compact quantum groups. In particular, we associate a quantum permutation group with each bisynchronous transitive game and vice versa. We prove that the existence of a C*-strategy, the existence of a quantum commuting strategy, and the existence of a classical strategy are all equivalent for bisynchronous transitive games. We then use some of these correspondences to establish necessary and sufficient conditions for some classes of correlations, that arise as perfect strategies of transitive games, to be nonlocal.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Quantum automorphism groups of trees
Authors:
Josse van Dobben de Bruyn,
Prem Nigam Kar,
David E. Roberson,
Simon Schmidt,
Peter Zeman
Abstract:
We give a characterisation of quantum automorphism groups of trees. In particular, for every tree, we show how to iteratively construct its quantum automorphism group using free products and free wreath products. This can be considered a quantum version of Jordan's theorem for the automorphism groups of trees. This is one of the first characterisations of quantum automorphism groups of a natural c…
▽ More
We give a characterisation of quantum automorphism groups of trees. In particular, for every tree, we show how to iteratively construct its quantum automorphism group using free products and free wreath products. This can be considered a quantum version of Jordan's theorem for the automorphism groups of trees. This is one of the first characterisations of quantum automorphism groups of a natural class of graphs with quantum symmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Asymmetric graphs with quantum symmetry
Authors:
Josse van Dobben de Bruyn,
David E. Roberson,
Simon Schmidt
Abstract:
We present a sequence of finite graphs with trivial automorphism group and non-trivial quantum automorphism group, which are the first known examples of graphs with this property. The examples are based on solution groups to (binary) linear systems. We first show that the dual of every solution group occurs as the quantum automorphism group of some graph, and then construct an infinite sequence of…
▽ More
We present a sequence of finite graphs with trivial automorphism group and non-trivial quantum automorphism group, which are the first known examples of graphs with this property. The examples are based on solution groups to (binary) linear systems. We first show that the dual of every solution group occurs as the quantum automorphism group of some graph, and then construct an infinite sequence of systems whose solution groups are nontrivial but perfect, i.e., they have trivial abelianizations. We also prove a weak quantum analog of Frucht's theorem, namely that every classical finite group $Γ$ can occur as the quantum automorphism group of a graph. Moreover there are graphs $G_1$ and $G_2$ such that $\mathrm{Aut}(G_1) \cong Γ\cong \mathrm{Aut}(G_2)$, but $\mathrm{Qut}(G_1) \not \cong \mathrm{Qut}(G_2)$ for any finite group $Γ$. This allows us to answer several open questions from the literature, such as proving that there do not exist any "quantum excluding groups". Additionally, we present a procedure that allows us to decolor the vertices of any vertex-colored graph while preserving its quantum automorphism group.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2024; v1 submitted 8 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Lasserre Hierarchy for Graph Isomorphism and Homomorphism Indistinguishability
Authors:
David E. Roberson,
Tim Seppelt
Abstract:
We show that feasibility of the $t^\text{th}$ level of the Lasserre semidefinite programming hierarchy for graph isomorphism can be expressed as a homomorphism indistinguishability relation. In other words, we define a class $\mathcal{L}_t$ of graphs such that graphs $G$ and $H$ are not distinguished by the $t^\text{th}$ level of the Lasserre hierarchy if and only if they admit the same number of…
▽ More
We show that feasibility of the $t^\text{th}$ level of the Lasserre semidefinite programming hierarchy for graph isomorphism can be expressed as a homomorphism indistinguishability relation. In other words, we define a class $\mathcal{L}_t$ of graphs such that graphs $G$ and $H$ are not distinguished by the $t^\text{th}$ level of the Lasserre hierarchy if and only if they admit the same number of homomorphisms from any graph in $\mathcal{L}_t$. By analysing the treewidth of graphs in $\mathcal{L}_t$ we prove that the $3t^\text{th}$ level of Sherali--Adams linear programming hierarchy is as strong as the $t^\text{th}$ level of Lasserre. Moreover, we show that this is best possible in the sense that $3t$ cannot be lowered to $3t-1$ for any $t$. The same result holds for the Lasserre hierarchy with non-negativity constraints, which we similarly characterise in terms of homomorphism indistinguishability over a family $\mathcal{L}_t^+$ of graphs. Additionally, we give characterisations of level-$t$ Lasserre with non-negativity constraints in terms of logical equivalence and via a graph colouring algorithm akin to the Weisfeiler--Leman algorithm. This provides a polynomial time algorithm for determining if two given graphs are distinguished by the $t^\text{th}$ level of the Lasserre hierarchy with non-negativity constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2023; v1 submitted 21 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Oddomorphisms and homomorphism indistinguishability over graphs of bounded degree
Authors:
David E. Roberson
Abstract:
We introduce (weak) oddomorphisms of graphs which are homomorphisms with additional constraints based on parity. These maps turn out to have interesting properties (e.g., they preserve planarity), particularly in relation to homomorphism indistinguishability.
Graphs $G$ and $H$ are *homomorphism indistinguishable* over a family $\mathcal{F}$ if $\hom(F,G) = \hom(F,H)$ for all…
▽ More
We introduce (weak) oddomorphisms of graphs which are homomorphisms with additional constraints based on parity. These maps turn out to have interesting properties (e.g., they preserve planarity), particularly in relation to homomorphism indistinguishability.
Graphs $G$ and $H$ are *homomorphism indistinguishable* over a family $\mathcal{F}$ if $\hom(F,G) = \hom(F,H)$ for all $F \in \mathcal{F}$, where $\hom(F,G)$ is the number of homomorphisms from $F$ to $G$. A classical result of Lovász says that isomorphism is equivalent to homomorphism indistinguishability over the class of all graphs. In recent years it has been shown that many homomorphism indistinguishability relations have natural algebraic and/or logical formulations. Currently, much research in this area is focused on finding such reformulations. We aim to broaden the scope of current research on homomorphism indistinguishability by introducing new concepts/constructions and proposing several conjectures/questions. In particular, we conjecture that every family closed under disjoint unions and minors gives rise to a distinct homomorphism indistinguishability relation.
We also show that if $\mathcal{F}$ is a family of graphs closed under disjoint unions, restrictions to connected components, and weak oddomorphisms, then $\mathcal{F}$ satisfies a certain maximality or closure property: homomorphism indistinguishability over $\mathcal{F}$ of $G$ and $H$ does not imply $\hom(F,G) = \hom(F,H)$ for any $F \notin \mathcal{F}$. This allows us to answer a question raised over ten years ago, showing that homomorphism indistinguishability over graphs of bounded degree is not equivalent to isomorphism.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Quantum symmetry vs nonlocal symmetry
Authors:
David E. Roberson,
Simon Schmidt
Abstract:
We introduce the notion of nonlocal symmetry of a graph $G$, defined as a winning quantum correlation for the $G$-automorphism game that cannot be produced classically. Recent connections between quantum group theory and quantum information show that quantum correlations for this game correspond to tracial states on $C(\text{Qut}(G))$ -- the algebra of functions on the quantum automorphism group o…
▽ More
We introduce the notion of nonlocal symmetry of a graph $G$, defined as a winning quantum correlation for the $G$-automorphism game that cannot be produced classically. Recent connections between quantum group theory and quantum information show that quantum correlations for this game correspond to tracial states on $C(\text{Qut}(G))$ -- the algebra of functions on the quantum automorphism group of $G$. This allows us to also define nonlocal symmetry for any quantum permutation group. We investigate the differences and similarities between this and the notion of quantum symmetry, defined as non-commutativity of $C(\text{Qut}(G))$. Roughly speaking, quantum symmetry vs nonlocal symmetry can be viewed respectively as non-classicality of our model of reality vs non-classicality of our observation of reality.
We show that quantum symmetry is necessary but not sufficient for nonlocal symmetry. In particular, we show that the complete graph on five vertices is the only connected graph on five or fewer vertices with nonlocal symmetry, despite a dozen others having quantum symmetry. In particular this shows that the quantum symmetric group on four points, $S_4^+$, does not exhibit nonlocal symmetry, answering a question from the literature. In contrast to quantum symmetry, we show that two disjoint classical automorphisms do not guarantee nonlocal symmetry. However, three disjoint automorphisms do suffice. We also give a construction of quantum permutation matrices built from a finite abelian group $Γ$ and a permutation $π$ on $|Γ|$ elements. Computational evidence suggests that for cyclic groups of increasing size almost all permutations $π$ result in nonlocal symmetry. Surprisingly, the construction never results in nonlocal symmetry when $\mathbb{Z}_2^3$ is used. We also investigate under what conditions nonlocal symmetry arises when taking unions or products of graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2021; v1 submitted 24 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Graph isomorphism: Physical resources, optimization models, and algebraic characterizations
Authors:
Laura Mančinska,
David E. Roberson,
Antonios Varvitsiotis
Abstract:
In the $(G,H)$-isomorphism game, a verifier interacts with two non-communicating players (called provers) by privately sending each of them a random vertex from either $G$ or $H$, whose aim is to convince the verifier that two graphs $G$ and $H$ are isomorphic. In recent work along with Atserias, Šámal and Severini [Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B, 136:89--328, 2019] we showed that a ver…
▽ More
In the $(G,H)$-isomorphism game, a verifier interacts with two non-communicating players (called provers) by privately sending each of them a random vertex from either $G$ or $H$, whose aim is to convince the verifier that two graphs $G$ and $H$ are isomorphic. In recent work along with Atserias, Šámal and Severini [Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B, 136:89--328, 2019] we showed that a verifier can be convinced that two non-isomorphic graphs are isomorphic, if the provers are allowed to share quantum resources. In this paper we model classical and quantum graph isomorphism by linear constraints over certain complicated convex cones, which we then relax to a pair of tractable convex models (semidefinite programs). Our main result is a complete algebraic characterization of the corresponding equivalence relations on graphs in terms of appropriate matrix algebras. Our techniques are an interesting mix of algebra, combinatorics, optimization, and quantum information.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Quantum isomorphism is equivalent to equality of homomorphism counts from planar graphs
Authors:
Laura Mančinska,
David E. Roberson
Abstract:
Over 50 years ago, Lovász proved that two graphs are isomorphic if and only if they admit the same number of homomorphisms from any graph [Acta Math. Hungar. 18 (1967), pp. 321--328]. In this work we prove that two graphs are quantum isomorphic (in the commuting operator framework) if and only if they admit the same number of homomorphisms from any planar graph. As there exist pairs of non-isomorp…
▽ More
Over 50 years ago, Lovász proved that two graphs are isomorphic if and only if they admit the same number of homomorphisms from any graph [Acta Math. Hungar. 18 (1967), pp. 321--328]. In this work we prove that two graphs are quantum isomorphic (in the commuting operator framework) if and only if they admit the same number of homomorphisms from any planar graph. As there exist pairs of non-isomorphic graphs that are quantum isomorphic, this implies that homomorphism counts from planar graphs do not determine a graph up to isomorphism. Another immediate consequence is that determining whether there exists some planar graph that has a different number of homomorphisms to two given graphs is an undecidable problem, since quantum isomorphism is known to be undecidable. Our characterization of quantum isomorphism is proven via a combinatorial characterization of the intertwiner spaces of the quantum automorphism group of a graph based on counting homomorphisms from planar graphs. This result inspires the definition of "graph categories" which are analogous to, and a generalization of, partition categories that are the basis of the definition of easy quantum groups. Thus we introduce a new class of "graph-theoretic quantum groups" whose intertwiner spaces are spanned by maps associated to (bi-labeled) graphs. Finally, we use our result on quantum isomorphism to prove an interesting reformulation of the Four Color Theorem: that any planar graph is 4-colorable if and only if it has a homomorphism to a specific Cayley graph on the symmetric group $S_4$ which contains a complete subgraph on four vertices but is not 4-colorable.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2019; v1 submitted 15 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Algebras, graphs and thetas
Authors:
Marcel K. de Carli Silva,
Gabriel Coutinho,
Chris Godsil,
David E. Roberson
Abstract:
We extend the clique-coclique inequality, previously known to hold for graphs in association schemes and vertex-transitive graphs, to graphs in homogeneous coherent configurations and 1-walk regular graphs. We further generalize it to a stronger inequality involving the Lovász theta number of such graphs, and some theta variants, including characterizations of the equality.
We extend the clique-coclique inequality, previously known to hold for graphs in association schemes and vertex-transitive graphs, to graphs in homogeneous coherent configurations and 1-walk regular graphs. We further generalize it to a stronger inequality involving the Lovász theta number of such graphs, and some theta variants, including characterizations of the equality.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Cores of Cubelike Graphs
Authors:
Laura Mančinska,
Irene Pivotto,
David E. Roberson,
Gordon Royle
Abstract:
A graph is $\textit{cubelike}$ if it is a Cayley graph for some elementary abelian $2$-group $\mathbb{Z}_2^n$. The core of a graph is its smallest subgraph to which it admits a homomorphism. More than ten years ago, Nešetřil and Šámal (On tension-continuous mappings. $\textit{European J. Combin.,}$ 29(4):1025--1054, 2008) asked whether the core of a cubelike graph is cubelike, but since then very…
▽ More
A graph is $\textit{cubelike}$ if it is a Cayley graph for some elementary abelian $2$-group $\mathbb{Z}_2^n$. The core of a graph is its smallest subgraph to which it admits a homomorphism. More than ten years ago, Nešetřil and Šámal (On tension-continuous mappings. $\textit{European J. Combin.,}$ 29(4):1025--1054, 2008) asked whether the core of a cubelike graph is cubelike, but since then very little progress has been made towards resolving the question. Here we investigate the structure of the core of a cubelike graph, deducing a variety of structural, spectral and group-theoretical properties that the core "inherits" from the host cubelike graph. These properties constrain the structure of the core quite severely --- even if the core of a cubelike graph is not actually cubelike, it must bear a very close resemblance to a cubelike graph. Moreover we prove the much stronger result that not only are these properties inherited by the core of a cubelike graph, but also by the orbital graphs of the core. Even though the core and its orbital graphs look very much like cubelike graphs, we are unable to show that this is sufficient to characterise cubelike graphs. However, our results are strong enough to eliminate all non-cubelike vertex-transitive graphs on up to $32$ vertices as potential cores of cubelike graphs (of any size). Thus, if one exists at all, a cubelike graph with a non-cubelike core has at least $128$ vertices and its core has at least $64$ vertices.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Perfect strategies for non-signalling games
Authors:
M. Lupini,
L. Mancinska,
V. I. Paulsen,
D. E. Roberson,
G. Scarpa,
S. Severini,
I. G. Todorov,
A. Winter
Abstract:
We unify and consolidate various results about non-signall-ing games, a subclass of non-local two-player one-round games, by introducing and studying several new families of games and establishing general theorems about them, which extend a number of known facts in a variety of special cases. Among these families are {\it reflexive games,} which are characterised as the hardest non-signalling game…
▽ More
We unify and consolidate various results about non-signall-ing games, a subclass of non-local two-player one-round games, by introducing and studying several new families of games and establishing general theorems about them, which extend a number of known facts in a variety of special cases. Among these families are {\it reflexive games,} which are characterised as the hardest non-signalling games that can be won using a given set of strategies. We introduce {\it imitation games,} in which the players display linked behaviour, and which contains as subclasses the classes of variable assignment games, binary constraint system games, synchronous games, many games based on graphs, and {\it unique} games. We associate a C*-algebra $C^*(\mathcal{G})$ to any imitation game $\mathcal{G}$, and show that the existence of perfect quantum commuting (resp.\ quantum, local) strategies of $\mathcal{G}$ can be characterised in terms of properties of this C*-algebra, extending known results about synchronous games. We single out a subclass of imitation games, which we call {\it mirror games,} and provide a characterisation of their quantum commuting strategies that has an algebraic flavour, showing in addition that their approximately quantum perfect strategies arise from amenable traces on the encoding C*-algebra. We describe the main classes of non-signalling correlations in terms of states on operator system tensor products.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Vector Coloring the Categorical Product of Graphs
Authors:
Chris Godsil,
David E. Roberson,
Brendan Rooney,
Robert Šámal,
Antonios Varvitsiotis
Abstract:
A vector $t$-coloring of a graph is an assignment of real vectors $p_1, \ldots, p_n$ to its vertices such that $p_i^Tp_i = t-1$ for all $i=1, \ldots, n$ and $p_i^Tp_j \le -1$ whenever $i$ and $j$ are adjacent. The vector chromatic number of $G$ is the smallest real number $t \ge 1$ for which a vector $t$-coloring of $G$ exists. For a graph $H$ and a vector $t$-coloring $p_1,\ldots,p_n$ of a graph…
▽ More
A vector $t$-coloring of a graph is an assignment of real vectors $p_1, \ldots, p_n$ to its vertices such that $p_i^Tp_i = t-1$ for all $i=1, \ldots, n$ and $p_i^Tp_j \le -1$ whenever $i$ and $j$ are adjacent. The vector chromatic number of $G$ is the smallest real number $t \ge 1$ for which a vector $t$-coloring of $G$ exists. For a graph $H$ and a vector $t$-coloring $p_1,\ldots,p_n$ of a graph $G$, the assignment $(i,\ell) \mapsto p_i$ is a vector $t$-coloring of the categorical product $G \times H$. It follows that the vector chromatic number of $G \times H$ is at most the minimum of the vector chromatic numbers of the factors. We prove that equality always holds, constituting a vector coloring analog of the famous Hedetniemi Conjecture from graph coloring. Furthermore, we prove a necessary and sufficient condition for when all of the optimal vector colorings of the product can be expressed in terms of the optimal vector colorings of the factors. The vector chromatic number is closely related to the well-known Lovász theta function, and both of these parameters admit formulations as semidefinite programs. This connection to semidefinite programming is crucial to our work and the tools and techniques we develop could likely be of interest to others in this field.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Oddities of quantum colorings
Authors:
Laura Mančinska,
David E. Roberson
Abstract:
We study quantum analogs of graph colorings and chromatic number. Initially defined via an interactive protocol, quantum colorings can also be viewed as a natural operator relaxation of graph coloring. Since there is no known algorithm for producing nontrivial quantum colorings, the existing examples rely on ad hoc constructions. Almost all of the known constructions of quantum $d$-colorings start…
▽ More
We study quantum analogs of graph colorings and chromatic number. Initially defined via an interactive protocol, quantum colorings can also be viewed as a natural operator relaxation of graph coloring. Since there is no known algorithm for producing nontrivial quantum colorings, the existing examples rely on ad hoc constructions. Almost all of the known constructions of quantum $d$-colorings start from $d$-dimensional orthogonal representations. We show the limitations of this method by exhibiting, for the first time, a graph with a 3-dimensional orthogonal representation which cannot be quantum 3-colored, and a graph that can be quantum 3-colored but has no 3-dimensional orthogonal representation. Together these examples show that the quantum chromatic number and orthogonal rank are not directly comparable as graph parameters. The former graph also provides an example of several interesting, and previously unknown, properties of quantum colorings. The most striking of these is that adding a new vertex adjacent to all other vertices does not necessarily increase the quantum chromatic number of a graph. This is in stark contrast to the chromatic number and many of its variants. This graph also provides the smallest known example (14 vertices) exhibiting a separation between chromatic number and its quantum analog.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Nonlocal Games and Quantum Permutation Groups
Authors:
Martino Lupini,
Laura Mančinska,
David E. Roberson
Abstract:
We present a strong connection between quantum information and quantum permutation groups. Specifically, we define a notion of quantum isomorphisms of graphs based on quantum automorphisms from the theory of quantum groups, and then show that this is equivalent to the previously defined notion of quantum isomorphism corresponding to perfect quantum strategies to the isomorphism game. Moreover, we…
▽ More
We present a strong connection between quantum information and quantum permutation groups. Specifically, we define a notion of quantum isomorphisms of graphs based on quantum automorphisms from the theory of quantum groups, and then show that this is equivalent to the previously defined notion of quantum isomorphism corresponding to perfect quantum strategies to the isomorphism game. Moreover, we show that two connected graphs $X$ and $Y$ are quantum isomorphic if and only if there exists $x \in V(X)$ and $y \in V(Y)$ that are in the same orbit of the quantum automorphism group of the disjoint union of $X$ and $Y$. This connection links quantum groups to the more concrete notion of nonlocal games and physically observable quantum behaviours. We exploit this link by using ideas and results from quantum information in order to prove new results about quantum automorphism groups, and about quantum permutation groups more generally. In particular, we show that asymptotically almost surely all graphs have trivial quantum automorphism group. Furthermore, we use examples of quantum isomorphic graphs from previous work to construct an infinite family of graphs which are quantum vertex transitive but fail to be vertex transitive, answering a question from the quantum group literature.
Our main tool for proving these results is the introduction of orbits and orbitals (orbits on ordered pairs) of quantum permutation groups. We show that the orbitals of a quantum permutation group form a coherent configuration/algebra, a notion from the field of algebraic graph theory. We then prove that the elements of this quantum orbital algebra are exactly the matrices that commute with the magic unitary defining the quantum group. We furthermore show that quantum isomorphic graphs admit an isomorphism of their quantum orbital algebras which maps the adjacency matrix of one graph to that of the other.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2018; v1 submitted 5 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Quantum and non-signalling graph isomorphisms
Authors:
Albert Atserias,
Laura Mančinska,
David E. Roberson,
Robert Šámal,
Simone Severini,
Antonios Varvitsiotis
Abstract:
We introduce a two-player nonlocal game, called the $(G,H)$-isomorphism game, where classical players can win with certainty if and only if the graphs $G$ and $H$ are isomorphic. We then define the notions of quantum and non-signalling isomorphism, by considering perfect quantum and non-signalling strategies for the $(G,H)$-isomorphism game, respectively. In the quantum case, we consider both the…
▽ More
We introduce a two-player nonlocal game, called the $(G,H)$-isomorphism game, where classical players can win with certainty if and only if the graphs $G$ and $H$ are isomorphic. We then define the notions of quantum and non-signalling isomorphism, by considering perfect quantum and non-signalling strategies for the $(G,H)$-isomorphism game, respectively. In the quantum case, we consider both the tensor product and commuting frameworks for nonlocal games. We prove that non-signalling isomorphism coincides with the well-studied notion of fractional isomorphism, thus giving the latter an operational interpretation. Second, we show that, in the tensor product framework, quantum isomorphism is equivalent to the feasibility of two polynomial systems in non-commuting variables, obtained by relaxing the standard integer programming formulations for graph isomorphism to Hermitian variables. On the basis of this correspondence, we show that quantum isomorphic graphs are necessarily cospectral. Finally, we provide a construction for reducing linear binary constraint system games to isomorphism games. This allows us to produce quantum isomorphic graphs that are nevertheless not isomorphic. Furthermore, it allows us to show that our two notions of quantum isomorphism, from the tensor product and commuting frameworks, are in fact distinct relations, and that the latter is undecidable. Our construction is related to the FGLSS reduction from inapproximability literature, as well as the CFI construction.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2017; v1 submitted 29 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Graph Homomorphisms via Vector Colorings
Authors:
Chris Godsil,
David E. Roberson,
Brendan Rooney,
Robert Šámal,
Antonios Varvitsiotis
Abstract:
In this paper we study the existence of homomorphisms $G\to H$ using semidefinite programming. Specifically, we use the vector chromatic number of a graph, defined as the smallest real number $t \ge 2$ for which there exists an assignment of unit vectors $i\mapsto p_i$ to its vertices such that $\langle p_i, p_j\rangle\le -1/(t-1),$ when $i\sim j$. Our approach allows to reprove, without using the…
▽ More
In this paper we study the existence of homomorphisms $G\to H$ using semidefinite programming. Specifically, we use the vector chromatic number of a graph, defined as the smallest real number $t \ge 2$ for which there exists an assignment of unit vectors $i\mapsto p_i$ to its vertices such that $\langle p_i, p_j\rangle\le -1/(t-1),$ when $i\sim j$. Our approach allows to reprove, without using the Erdős-Ko-Rado Theorem, that for $n>2r$ the Kneser graph $K_{n:r}$ and the $q$-Kneser graph $qK_{n:r}$ are cores, and furthermore, that for $n/r = n'/r'$ there exists a homomorphism $K_{n:r}\to K_{n':r'}$ if and only if $n$ divides $n'$. In terms of new applications, we show that the even-weight component of the distance $k$-graph of the $n$-cube $H_{n,k}$ is a core and also, that non-bipartite Taylor graphs are cores. Additionally, we give a necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of homomorphisms $H_{n,k}\to H_{n',k'}$ when $n/k = n'/k'$. Lastly, we show that if a 2-walk-regular graph (which is non-bipartite and not complete multipartite) has a unique optimal vector coloring, it is a core. Based on this sufficient condition we conducted a computational study on Ted Spence's list of strongly regular graphs and found that at least 84% are cores.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2019; v1 submitted 31 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Homomorphisms of Strongly Regular Graphs
Authors:
David E. Roberson
Abstract:
We prove that if $G$ and $H$ are primitive strongly regular graphs with the same parameters and $\varphi$ is a homomorphism from $G$ to $H$, then $\varphi$ is either an isomorphism or a coloring (homomorphism to a complete subgraph). Therefore, the only endomorphisms of a primitive strongly regular graph are automorphisms or colorings. This confirms and strengthens a conjecture of Cameron and Kaza…
▽ More
We prove that if $G$ and $H$ are primitive strongly regular graphs with the same parameters and $\varphi$ is a homomorphism from $G$ to $H$, then $\varphi$ is either an isomorphism or a coloring (homomorphism to a complete subgraph). Therefore, the only endomorphisms of a primitive strongly regular graph are automorphisms or colorings. This confirms and strengthens a conjecture of Cameron and Kazanidis that all strongly regular graphs are cores or have complete cores. The proof of the result is elementary, mainly relying on linear algebraic techniques. In the second half of the paper we discuss implications of the result and the idea underlying the proof. We also show that essentially the same proof can be used to obtain a more general statement.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2016; v1 submitted 5 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Universal completability, least eigenvalue frameworks, and vector colorings
Authors:
Chris Godsil,
David E. Roberson,
Brendan Rooney,
Robert Šámal,
Antonios Varvitsiotis
Abstract:
An embedding $i \mapsto p_i\in \mathbb{R}^d$ of the vertices of a graph $G$ is called universally completable if the following holds: For any other embedding $i\mapsto q_i~\in \mathbb{R}^{k}$ satisfying $q_i^T q_j = p_i^T p_j$ for $i = j$ and $i$ adjacent to $j$, there exists an isometry mapping the $q_i$'s to the $p_i$'s for all $ i\in V(G)$. The notion of universal completability was introduced…
▽ More
An embedding $i \mapsto p_i\in \mathbb{R}^d$ of the vertices of a graph $G$ is called universally completable if the following holds: For any other embedding $i\mapsto q_i~\in \mathbb{R}^{k}$ satisfying $q_i^T q_j = p_i^T p_j$ for $i = j$ and $i$ adjacent to $j$, there exists an isometry mapping the $q_i$'s to the $p_i$'s for all $ i\in V(G)$. The notion of universal completability was introduced recently due to its relevance to the positive semidefinite matrix completion problem. In this work we focus on graph embeddings constructed using the eigenvectors of the least eigenvalue of the adjacency matrix of $G$, which we call least eigenvalue frameworks. We identify two necessary and sufficient conditions for such frameworks to be universally completable. Our conditions also allow us to give algorithms for determining whether a least eigenvalue framework is universally completable. Furthermore, our computations for Cayley graphs on $\mathbb{Z}_2^n \ (n \le 5)$ show that almost all of these graphs have universally completable least eigenvalue frameworks. In the second part of this work we study uniquely vector colorable (UVC) graphs, i.e., graphs for which the semidefinite program corresponding to the Lovász theta number (of the complementary graph) admits a unique optimal solution. We identify a sufficient condition for showing that a graph is UVC based on the universal completability of an associated framework. This allows us to prove that Kneser and $q$-Kneser graphs are UVC. Lastly, we show that least eigenvalue frameworks of 1-walk-regular graphs always provide optimal vector colorings and furthermore, we are able to characterize all optimal vector colorings of such graphs. In particular, we give a necessary and sufficient condition for a 1-walk-regular graph to be uniquely vector colorable.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Fractional Zero Forcing via Three-color Forcing Games
Authors:
Leslie Hogben,
Kevin F. Palmowski,
David E. Roberson,
Michael Young
Abstract:
An $r$-fold analogue of the positive semidefinite zero forcing process that is carried out on the $r$-blowup of a graph is introduced and used to define the fractional positive semidefinite forcing number. Properties of the graph blowup when colored with a fractional positive semidefinite forcing set are examined and used to define a three-color forcing game that directly computes the fractional p…
▽ More
An $r$-fold analogue of the positive semidefinite zero forcing process that is carried out on the $r$-blowup of a graph is introduced and used to define the fractional positive semidefinite forcing number. Properties of the graph blowup when colored with a fractional positive semidefinite forcing set are examined and used to define a three-color forcing game that directly computes the fractional positive semidefinite forcing number of a graph. We develop a fractional parameter based on the standard zero forcing process and it is shown that this parameter is exactly the skew zero forcing number with a three-color approach. This approach and an algorithm are used to characterize graphs whose skew zero forcing number equals zero.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Deciding the existence of perfect entangled strategies for nonlocal games
Authors:
Laura Mančinska,
David E. Roberson,
Antonios Varvitsiotis
Abstract:
First, we consider the problem of deciding whether a nonlocal game admits a perfect entangled strategy that uses projective measurements on a maximally entangled shared state. Via a polynomial-time Karp reduction, we show that independent set games are the hardest instances of this problem. Secondly, we show that if every independent set game whose entangled value is equal to one admits a perfect…
▽ More
First, we consider the problem of deciding whether a nonlocal game admits a perfect entangled strategy that uses projective measurements on a maximally entangled shared state. Via a polynomial-time Karp reduction, we show that independent set games are the hardest instances of this problem. Secondly, we show that if every independent set game whose entangled value is equal to one admits a perfect entangled strategy, then the same holds for all symmetric synchronous games. Finally, we identify combinatorial lower bounds on the classical and entangled values of synchronous games in terms of variants of the independence number of appropriate graphs. Our results suggest that independent set games might be representative of all nonlocal games when dealing with questions concerning perfect entangled strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
A new property of the Lovász number and duality relations between graph parameters
Authors:
Antonio Acín,
Runyao Duan,
David E. Roberson,
Ana Belén Sainz,
Andreas Winter
Abstract:
We show that for any graph $G$, by considering "activation" through the strong product with another graph $H$, the relation $α(G) \leq \vartheta(G)$ between the independence number and the Lovász number of $G$ can be made arbitrarily tight: Precisely, the inequality \[
α(G \times H) \leq \vartheta(G \times H) = \vartheta(G)\,\vartheta(H) \] becomes asymptotically an equality for a suitable seque…
▽ More
We show that for any graph $G$, by considering "activation" through the strong product with another graph $H$, the relation $α(G) \leq \vartheta(G)$ between the independence number and the Lovász number of $G$ can be made arbitrarily tight: Precisely, the inequality \[
α(G \times H) \leq \vartheta(G \times H) = \vartheta(G)\,\vartheta(H) \] becomes asymptotically an equality for a suitable sequence of ancillary graphs $H$.
This motivates us to look for other products of graph parameters of $G$ and $H$ on the right hand side of the above relation. For instance, a result of Rosenfeld and Hales states that \[
α(G \times H) \leq α^*(G)\,α(H), \] with the fractional packing number $α^*(G)$, and for every $G$ there exists $H$ that makes the above an equality; conversely, for every graph $H$ there is a $G$ that attains equality.
These findings constitute some sort of duality of graph parameters, mediated through the independence number, under which $α$ and $α^*$ are dual to each other, and the Lovász number $\vartheta$ is self-dual. We also show duality of Schrijver's and Szegedy's variants $\vartheta^-$ and $\vartheta^+$ of the Lovász number, and explore analogous notions for the chromatic number under strong and disjunctive graph products.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2016; v1 submitted 6 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Orthogonal Representations, Projective Rank, and Fractional Minimum Positive Semidefinite Rank: Connections and New Directions
Authors:
Leslie Hogben,
Kevin F. Palmowski,
David E. Roberson,
Simone Severini
Abstract:
Fractional minimum positive semidefinite rank is defined from $r$-fold faithful orthogonal representations and it is shown that the projective rank of any graph equals the fractional minimum positive semidefinite rank of its complement. An $r$-fold version of the traditional definition of minimum positive semidefinite rank of a graph using Hermitian matrices that fit the graph is also presented. T…
▽ More
Fractional minimum positive semidefinite rank is defined from $r$-fold faithful orthogonal representations and it is shown that the projective rank of any graph equals the fractional minimum positive semidefinite rank of its complement. An $r$-fold version of the traditional definition of minimum positive semidefinite rank of a graph using Hermitian matrices that fit the graph is also presented. This paper also introduces $r$-fold orthogonal representations of graphs and formalizes the understanding of projective rank as fractional orthogonal rank. Connections of these concepts to quantum theory, including Tsirelson's problem, are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2015; v1 submitted 30 January, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Conic Formulations of Graph Homomorphisms
Authors:
David E. Roberson
Abstract:
Given graphs $X$ and $Y$, we define two conic feasibility programs which we show have a solution over the completely positive cone if and only if there exists a homomorphism from $X$ to $Y$. By varying the cone, we obtain similar characterizations of quantum/entanglement-assisted homomorphisms and three previously studied relaxations of these relations. Motivated by this, we investigate the proper…
▽ More
Given graphs $X$ and $Y$, we define two conic feasibility programs which we show have a solution over the completely positive cone if and only if there exists a homomorphism from $X$ to $Y$. By varying the cone, we obtain similar characterizations of quantum/entanglement-assisted homomorphisms and three previously studied relaxations of these relations. Motivated by this, we investigate the properties of these "conic homomorphisms" for general (suitable) cones. We also consider two generalized versions of the Lovász theta function, and how they interact with these conic homomorphisms. We prove analogs of several results on classical graph homomorphisms as well as some monotonicity theorems. We also show that one of the generalized theta functions is multiplicative on lexicographic and disjunctive graph products.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Graph Homomorphisms for Quantum Players
Authors:
Laura Mančinska,
David E. Roberson
Abstract:
A homomorphism from a graph $X$ to a graph $Y$ is an adjacency preserving mapping $f:V(X) \rightarrow V(Y)$. We consider a nonlocal game in which Alice and Bob are trying to convince a verifier with certainty that a graph $X$ admits a homomorphism to $Y$. This is a generalization of the well-studied graph coloring game. Via systematic study of quantum homomorphisms we prove new results for graph c…
▽ More
A homomorphism from a graph $X$ to a graph $Y$ is an adjacency preserving mapping $f:V(X) \rightarrow V(Y)$. We consider a nonlocal game in which Alice and Bob are trying to convince a verifier with certainty that a graph $X$ admits a homomorphism to $Y$. This is a generalization of the well-studied graph coloring game. Via systematic study of quantum homomorphisms we prove new results for graph coloring. Most importantly, we show that the Lovász theta number of the complement lower bounds the quantum chromatic number, which itself is not known to be computable. We also show that some of our newly introduced graph parameters, namely quantum independence and clique numbers, can differ from their classical counterparts while others, namely quantum odd girth, cannot. Finally, we show that quantum homomorphisms closely relate to zero-error channel capacity. In particular, we use quantum homomorphisms to construct graphs for which entanglement-assistance increases their one-shot zero-error capacity.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2016; v1 submitted 7 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
