-
On the Circuit Diameter Conjecture
Authors:
Steffen Borgwardt,
Tamon Stephen,
Timothy Yusun
Abstract:
From the point of view of optimization, a critical issue is relating the combinatorial diameter of a polyhedron to its number of facets $f$ and dimension $d$. In the seminal paper of Klee and Walkup [KW67], the Hirsch conjecture of an upper bound of $f-d$ was shown to be equivalent to several seemingly simpler statements, and was disproved for unbounded polyhedra through the construction of a part…
▽ More
From the point of view of optimization, a critical issue is relating the combinatorial diameter of a polyhedron to its number of facets $f$ and dimension $d$. In the seminal paper of Klee and Walkup [KW67], the Hirsch conjecture of an upper bound of $f-d$ was shown to be equivalent to several seemingly simpler statements, and was disproved for unbounded polyhedra through the construction of a particular 4-dimensional polyhedron $U_4$ with 8 facets. The Hirsch bound for bounded polyhedra was only recently disproved by Santos.
We consider analogous properties for a variant of the combinatorial diameter called the circuit diameter. In this variant, the walks are built from the circuit directions of the polyhedron, which are the minimal non-trivial solutions to the system defining the polyhedron.
We are able to prove that circuit variants of the so-called non-revisiting conjecture and $d$-step conjecture both imply the circuit analogue of the Hirsch conjecture. For the equivalences in [KW67], the wedge construction was a fundamental proof technique. We exhibit why it is not available in the circuit setting, and what are the implications of losing it as a tool.
Further, we show the circuit analogue of the non-revisiting conjecture implies a linear bound on the circuit diameter of all unbounded polyhedra - in contrast to what is known for the combinatorial diameter. Finally, we give two proofs of a circuit version of the $4$-step conjecture. These results offer some hope that the circuit version of the Hirsch conjecture may hold in general.
A challenge in the circuit setting is that different realizations of polyhedra of the same combinatorial structure may have different diameters. We adapt the notion of simplicity to work with circuits in the form of C-simple and wedge-simple polyhedra. We show that it suffices to consider such polyhedra.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2018; v1 submitted 23 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Algorithms for Colourful Simplicial Depth and Medians in the Plane
Authors:
Olga Zasenko,
Tamon Stephen
Abstract:
The colourful simplicial depth of a point x in the plane relative to a configuration of n points in k colour classes is exactly the number of closed simplices (triangles) with vertices from 3 different colour classes that contain x in their convex hull. We consider the problems of efficiently computing the colourful simplicial depth of a point x, and of finding a point, called a median, that maxim…
▽ More
The colourful simplicial depth of a point x in the plane relative to a configuration of n points in k colour classes is exactly the number of closed simplices (triangles) with vertices from 3 different colour classes that contain x in their convex hull. We consider the problems of efficiently computing the colourful simplicial depth of a point x, and of finding a point, called a median, that maximizes colourful simplicial depth.
For computing the colourful simplicial depth of x, our algorithm runs in time O(n log(n) + k n) in general, and O(kn) if the points are sorted around x. For finding the colourful median, we get a time of O(n^4). For comparison, the running times of the best known algorithm for the monochrome version of these problems are O(n log(n)) in general, improving to O(n) if the points are sorted around x for monochrome depth, and O(n^4) for finding a monochrome median.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Circuit diameter and Klee-Walkup constructions
Authors:
Tamon Stephen,
Timothy Yusun
Abstract:
Consider a variant of the graph diameter of a polyhedron where each step in a walk between two vertices travels maximally in a circuit direction instead of along incident edges. Here circuit directions are non-trivial solutions to minimally-dependent subsystems of the presentation of the polyhedron. These can be understood as the set of all possible edge directions, including edges that may arise…
▽ More
Consider a variant of the graph diameter of a polyhedron where each step in a walk between two vertices travels maximally in a circuit direction instead of along incident edges. Here circuit directions are non-trivial solutions to minimally-dependent subsystems of the presentation of the polyhedron. These can be understood as the set of all possible edge directions, including edges that may arise from translation of the facets.
It is appealing to consider a circuit analogue of the Hirsch conjecture for graph diameter, as suggested by Borgwardt et al. [BFH15]. They ask whether the known counterexamples to the Hirsch conjecture give rise to counterexamples for this relaxed notion of circuit diameter. We show that the most basic counterexample to the unbounded Hirsch conjecture, the Klee-Walkup polyhedron, does have a circuit diameter that satisfies the Hirsch bound, regardless of representation. We also examine the circuit diameter of the bounded Klee-Walkup polytope.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Computational Lower Bounds for Colourful Simplicial Depth
Authors:
Antoine Deza,
Tamon Stephen,
Feng Xie
Abstract:
The colourful simplicial depth problem in dimension d is to find a configuration of (d+1) sets of (d+1) points such that the origin is contained in the convex hull of each set (colour) but contained in a minimal number of colourful simplices generated by taking one point from each set. A construction attaining d^2+1 simplices is known, and is conjectured to be minimal. This has been confirmed up t…
▽ More
The colourful simplicial depth problem in dimension d is to find a configuration of (d+1) sets of (d+1) points such that the origin is contained in the convex hull of each set (colour) but contained in a minimal number of colourful simplices generated by taking one point from each set. A construction attaining d^2+1 simplices is known, and is conjectured to be minimal. This has been confirmed up to d=3, however the best known lower bound for d at least 4 is ((d+1)^2)/2.
A promising method to improve this lower bound is to look at combinatorial octahedral systems generated by such configurations. The difficulty to employing this approach is handling the many symmetric configurations that arise. We propose a table of invariants which exclude many of partial configurations, and use this to improve the lower bound in dimension 4.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Counting inequivalent monotone Boolean functions
Authors:
Tamon Stephen,
Timothy Yusun
Abstract:
Monotone Boolean functions (MBFs) are Boolean functions $f: {0,1}^n \rightarrow {0,1}$ satisfying the monotonicity condition $x \leq y \Rightarrow f(x) \leq f(y)$ for any $x,y \in {0,1}^n$. The number of MBFs in n variables is known as the $n$th Dedekind number. It is a longstanding computational challenge to determine these numbers exactly - these values are only known for $n$ at most 8. Two mono…
▽ More
Monotone Boolean functions (MBFs) are Boolean functions $f: {0,1}^n \rightarrow {0,1}$ satisfying the monotonicity condition $x \leq y \Rightarrow f(x) \leq f(y)$ for any $x,y \in {0,1}^n$. The number of MBFs in n variables is known as the $n$th Dedekind number. It is a longstanding computational challenge to determine these numbers exactly - these values are only known for $n$ at most 8. Two monotone Boolean functions are inequivalent if one can be obtained from the other by renaming the variables. The number of inequivalent MBFs in $n$ variables was known only for up to $n = 6$. In this paper we propose a strategy to count inequivalent MBF's by breaking the calculation into parts based on the profiles of these functions. As a result we are able to compute the number of inequivalent MBFs in 7 variables. The number obtained is 490013148.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Embedding a pair of graphs in a surface, and the width of 4-dimensional prismatoids
Authors:
Francisco Santos,
Tamon Stephen,
Hugh Thomas
Abstract:
A prismatoid is a polytope with all its vertices contained in two parallel facets, called its bases. Its width is the number of steps needed to go from one base to the other in the dual graph. The first author recently showed that the existence of counter-examples to the Hirsch conjecture is equivalent to that of $d$-prismatoids of width larger than $d$, and constructed such prismatoids in dimensi…
▽ More
A prismatoid is a polytope with all its vertices contained in two parallel facets, called its bases. Its width is the number of steps needed to go from one base to the other in the dual graph. The first author recently showed that the existence of counter-examples to the Hirsch conjecture is equivalent to that of $d$-prismatoids of width larger than $d$, and constructed such prismatoids in dimension five. Here we show that the same is impossible in dimension four. This is proved by looking at the pair of graph embeddings on a 2-sphere that arise from the normal fans of the two bases.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
An Euler characteristic proof that 4-prismatoids have width at most 4
Authors:
Tamon Stephen,
Hugh Thomas
Abstract:
We show that there is no 4-dimensional analogue of the 5-prismatoids used in Santos' recent counterexample to the Hirsch conjecture.
We show that there is no 4-dimensional analogue of the 5-prismatoids used in Santos' recent counterexample to the Hirsch conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2011; v1 submitted 16 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Expected Crossing Numbers
Authors:
Bojan Mohar,
Tamon Stephen
Abstract:
The expected value for the weighted crossing number of a randomly weighted graph is studied. A variation of the Crossing Lemma for expectations is proved. We focus on the case where the edge-weights are independent random variables that are uniformly distributed on [0,1].
The expected value for the weighted crossing number of a randomly weighted graph is studied. A variation of the Crossing Lemma for expectations is proved. We focus on the case where the edge-weights are independent random variables that are uniformly distributed on [0,1].
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
More Colourful Simplices
Authors:
Antoine Deza,
Tamon Stephen,
Feng Xie
Abstract:
We show that any point in the convex hull of each of (d+1) sets of (d+1) points in general position in \R^d is contained in at least (d+1)^2/2 simplices with one vertex from each set. This improves the known lower bounds for all d >= 4.
We show that any point in the convex hull of each of (d+1) sets of (d+1) points in general position in \R^d is contained in at least (d+1)^2/2 simplices with one vertex from each set. This improves the known lower bounds for all d >= 4.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2010; v1 submitted 25 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
A quadratic lower bound for colourful simplicial depth
Authors:
Tamon Stephen,
Hugh Thomas
Abstract:
We show that any point in the convex hull of each of (d+1) sets of (d+1) points in R^d is contained in at least floor((d+2)^2/4) simplices with one vertex from each set.
We show that any point in the convex hull of each of (d+1) sets of (d+1) points in R^d is contained in at least floor((d+2)^2/4) simplices with one vertex from each set.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2007; v1 submitted 16 December, 2005;
originally announced December 2005.
-
The Colourful Feasibility Problem
Authors:
Antoine Deza,
Sui Huang,
Tamon Stephen,
Tamás Terlaky
Abstract:
We study a colourful generalization of the linear programming feasibility problem, comparing the algorithms introduced by Barany and Onn with new methods. We perform benchmarking on generic and ill-conditioned problems, as well as as recently introduced highly structured problems. We show that some algorithms can lead to cycling or slow convergence, but we provide extensive numerical experiments…
▽ More
We study a colourful generalization of the linear programming feasibility problem, comparing the algorithms introduced by Barany and Onn with new methods. We perform benchmarking on generic and ill-conditioned problems, as well as as recently introduced highly structured problems. We show that some algorithms can lead to cycling or slow convergence, but we provide extensive numerical experiments which show that others perform much better than predicted by complexity arguments. We conclude that the most efficient method for all but the most ill-conditioned problems is a proposed multi-update algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2005;
originally announced November 2005.
-
Colourful Simplicial Depth
Authors:
Antoine Deza,
Sui Huang,
Tamon Stephen,
Tamás Terlaky
Abstract:
Inspired by Barany's colourful Caratheodory theorem, we introduce a colourful generalization of Liu's simplicial depth. We prove a parity property and conjecture that the minimum colourful simplicial depth of any core point in any d-dimensional configuration is d^2+1 and that the maximum is d^(d+1)+1. We exhibit configurations attaining each of these depths and apply our results to the problem o…
▽ More
Inspired by Barany's colourful Caratheodory theorem, we introduce a colourful generalization of Liu's simplicial depth. We prove a parity property and conjecture that the minimum colourful simplicial depth of any core point in any d-dimensional configuration is d^2+1 and that the maximum is d^(d+1)+1. We exhibit configurations attaining each of these depths and apply our results to the problem of bounding monochrome (non-colourful) simplicial depth.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2006; v1 submitted 1 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
A majorization bound for the eigenvalues of some graph Laplacians
Authors:
Tamon Stephen
Abstract:
It is conjectured that the Laplacian spectrum of a graph is majorized by its conjugate degree sequence. In this paper, we prove that this majorization holds for a class of graphs including trees. We also show that a generalization of this conjecture to graphs with Dirichlet boundary conditions is equivalent to the original conjecture.
It is conjectured that the Laplacian spectrum of a graph is majorized by its conjugate degree sequence. In this paper, we prove that this majorization holds for a class of graphs including trees. We also show that a generalization of this conjecture to graphs with Dirichlet boundary conditions is equivalent to the original conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2004;
originally announced November 2004.
-
The distribution of values in the quadratic assignment problem
Authors:
Alexander Barvinok,
Tamon Stephen
Abstract:
We obtain a number of results regarding the distribution of values of a quadratic function f on the set of nxn permutation matrices (identified with the symmetric group S_n) around its optimum (minimum or maximum). In particular, we estimate the fraction of permutations sigma such that f(sigma) lies within a given neighborhood of the optimal value of f. We identify some ``extreme'' functions f (…
▽ More
We obtain a number of results regarding the distribution of values of a quadratic function f on the set of nxn permutation matrices (identified with the symmetric group S_n) around its optimum (minimum or maximum). In particular, we estimate the fraction of permutations sigma such that f(sigma) lies within a given neighborhood of the optimal value of f. We identify some ``extreme'' functions f (there are 4 of those for n even and 5 for n odd) such that the distribution of every quadratic function around its optimum is a certain ``mixture'' of the distributions of the extremes and describe a natural class of functions (which includes, for example, the objective function in the Traveling Salesman Problem) with a relative abundance of near-optimal permutations. In particular, we identify a large class of functions f with the property that permutations in the vicinity of the optimal permutation (in the Hamming metric of S_n) tend to produce near optimal values of f (such is, for example, the objective function in the symmetric Traveling Salesman Problem) and show that for general f, just the opposite behavior may take place: an average permutation in the vicinity of the optimal permutation may be much worse than an average permutation in the whole group S_n.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2001;
originally announced April 2001.
