-
Positron annihilation and binding in aromatic and other ring molecules
Authors:
E. Arthur-Baidoo,
J. R. Danielson,
C. M. Surko,
J. P. Cassidy,
S. K. Gregg,
J. Hofierka,
B. Cunningham,
C. H. Patterson,
D. G. Green
Abstract:
Annihilation spectra are presented for aromatic and heterocyclic ring molecules resolved as a function of incident positron energy using a trap-based positron beam. Comparisons with the vibrational mode spectra yield positron-molecule binding energies. Good to excellent agreement is found between the measured binding energies and the predictions of an \textit{ab initio} many-body theory that takes…
▽ More
Annihilation spectra are presented for aromatic and heterocyclic ring molecules resolved as a function of incident positron energy using a trap-based positron beam. Comparisons with the vibrational mode spectra yield positron-molecule binding energies. Good to excellent agreement is found between the measured binding energies and the predictions of an \textit{ab initio} many-body theory that takes proper account of electron-positron correlations including virtual-positronium formation. The calculations elucidate the competition between permanent dipole moments and $π$ bonds in determining the spatial distribution of the bound-state positron density. The implications of these results and the role of multimode features in annihilation in these molecules, including Fermi resonances, are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Gaussian-basis many-body theory calculations of positron binding to negative ions and atoms
Authors:
J. Hofierka,
B. Cunningham,
C. M. Rawlins,
C. H. Patterson,
D. G. Green
Abstract:
Positron binding energies in the negative ions H$^-$, F$^-$, Cl$^-$ and Br$^-$, and the closed-shell atoms Be, Mg, Zn and Ca, are calculated via a many-body theory approach developed by the authors [J.~Hofierka \emph{et al.} Nature~{\bf 608}, 688-693 (2022)]. Specifically, the Dyson equation is solved using a Gaussian basis, with the positron self energy constructed from three infinite classes of…
▽ More
Positron binding energies in the negative ions H$^-$, F$^-$, Cl$^-$ and Br$^-$, and the closed-shell atoms Be, Mg, Zn and Ca, are calculated via a many-body theory approach developed by the authors [J.~Hofierka \emph{et al.} Nature~{\bf 608}, 688-693 (2022)]. Specifically, the Dyson equation is solved using a Gaussian basis, with the positron self energy constructed from three infinite classes of diagrams that account for the strong positron-atom correlations that characterise the system including the positron-induced polarization of the electron cloud, screening of the electron-positron Coulomb interaction, virtual-positronium formation and electron-hole and positron-hole interactions. For the negative ions, binding occurs at the static level of theory, and the correlations are found to enhance the binding energies by $\sim$25--50\%, yielding results in good agreement with ($\lesssim$5\% larger than) calculations from a number of distinct methods. For the atoms, for which binding is enabled exclusively by correlations, most notably virtual-Ps formation, the binding energies are found to be of similar order to (but $\sim$10--30\% larger than) relativistic coupled-cluster calculations of [C. Harabati, V.~A.~Dzuba and V.~V. Flambaum, Phys.~Rev.~A {\bf 89}, 022517 (2014)], both of which are systematically larger than stochastic variational calculations of [M.~Bromley and J.~Mitroy, Phys.~Rev.~A {\bf 73} (2005); J.~Mitroy, J.~At.~Mol.~Sci.~{\bf 1}, 275 (2010)].
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Many-body Theory Calculations of Positron Binding to Halogenated Hydrocarbons
Authors:
J. P. Cassidy,
J. Hofierka,
B. Cunningham,
C. M. Rawlins,
C. H. Patterson,
D. G. Green
Abstract:
Positron binding energies in halogenated hydrocarbons are calculated \emph{ab initio} using many-body theory. For chlorinated molecules, including planars for which the interaction is highly anisotropic, very good to excellent agreement with experiment and recent DFT-based model-potential calculations is found. Predictions for fluorinated and brominated molecules are presented. The comparative eff…
▽ More
Positron binding energies in halogenated hydrocarbons are calculated \emph{ab initio} using many-body theory. For chlorinated molecules, including planars for which the interaction is highly anisotropic, very good to excellent agreement with experiment and recent DFT-based model-potential calculations is found. Predictions for fluorinated and brominated molecules are presented. The comparative effect of fluorination, chlorination and bromination is elucidated by identifying trends within molecular families including dihaloethylenes and halomethanes based on global molecular properties (dipole moment, polarizability, ionization energy). It is shown that relative to brominated and chlorinated molecules, fluorinated molecules generate a less attractive positron-molecule potential due to larger ionization energies and smaller density of molecular orbitals close to the HOMO, resulting in very weak, or in most cases loss of, positron binding. Overall, however, it is shown that the global molecular properties are not universal predictors of binding energies, exemplified by consideration of CH$_3$Cl vs.~\emph{cis.}-C$_2$H$_2$F$_2$: despite the latter having a larger dipole moment, lower ionization energy and similar polarizability its binding energy is significantly smaller (25 meV vs.~3 meV, respectively), owing to the important contribution of multiple molecular orbitals to, and the anisotropy of, the positron-molecule correlation potential.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2023; v1 submitted 9 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Many-Body Theory Calculations of Positron Scattering and Annihilation in H$_2$, N$_2$ and CH$_4$
Authors:
C. M. Rawlins,
J. Hofierka,
B. Cunningham,
C. H. Patterson,
D. G. Green
Abstract:
The recently developed ab initio many-body theory of positron molecule binding [J. Hofierka et al., Nature, 606, 688 (2022)] is combined with the shifted pseudostates method [A. R. Swann and G. F. Gribakin, Phys. Rev. A 101, 022702 (2020)] to calculate positron scattering and annihilation rates on small molecules, namely H$_2$, N$_2$ and CH$_4$. The important effects of positron-molecule correlati…
▽ More
The recently developed ab initio many-body theory of positron molecule binding [J. Hofierka et al., Nature, 606, 688 (2022)] is combined with the shifted pseudostates method [A. R. Swann and G. F. Gribakin, Phys. Rev. A 101, 022702 (2020)] to calculate positron scattering and annihilation rates on small molecules, namely H$_2$, N$_2$ and CH$_4$. The important effects of positron-molecule correlations are delineated. The method provides uniformly good results for annihilation rates on all the targets, from the simplest (H$_2$, for which only a sole previous calculation agrees with experiment), to larger targets, where high-quality calculations have not been available.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Many-body theory of positron binding in polyatomic molecules
Authors:
J. Hofierka,
B. Cunningham,
C. M. Rawlins,
C. H. Patterson,
D. G. Green
Abstract:
Positrons bind to molecules leading to vibrational excitation and spectacularly enhanced annihilation. Whilst positron binding energies have been measured via resonant annihilation spectra for $\sim$90 molecules in the past two decades, an accurate \emph{ab initio} theoretical description has remained elusive. Of the molecules studied experimentally, calculations exist for only 6, and for these, s…
▽ More
Positrons bind to molecules leading to vibrational excitation and spectacularly enhanced annihilation. Whilst positron binding energies have been measured via resonant annihilation spectra for $\sim$90 molecules in the past two decades, an accurate \emph{ab initio} theoretical description has remained elusive. Of the molecules studied experimentally, calculations exist for only 6, and for these, standard quantum chemistry approaches have proved severely deficient, agreeing with experiment to at best 25% accuracy for polar molecules, and failing to predict binding in nonpolar molecules. The mechanisms of binding are not understood. Here, we develop a many-body theory of positron-molecule interactions and uncover the role of strong many-body correlations including polarization of the electron cloud, screening of the positron-electron Coulomb interaction by molecular electrons, and crucially, the unique non-perturbative process of virtual-positronium formation (where a molecular electron temporarily tunnels to the positron): they dramatically enhance binding in polar molecules and enable binding in nonpolars. We also elucidate the role of individual molecular orbitals, highlighting the importance of electronic $π$ bonds. Overall, we calculate binding energies in agreement with experiment (to within 1% in cases), and we predict binding in formamide and nucleobases. As well as supporting resonant annihilation experiments and positron-based molecular spectroscopy, the approach can be extended to positron scattering and annihilation $γ$ spectra in molecules and condensed matter, to provide fundamental insight and predictive capability required to properly interpret materials science diagnostics, develop antimatter-based technologies (including positron traps, beams and positron emission tomography), and understand positrons in the galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2021; v1 submitted 14 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
