-
Robust Lambda-quantiles and extreme probabilities
Authors:
Xia Han,
Peng Liu
Abstract:
In this paper, we investigate the robust models for $Λ$-quantiles with partial information regarding the loss distribution, where $Λ$-quantiles extend the classical quantiles by replacing the fixed probability level with a probability/loss function $Λ$. We find that, under some assumptions, the robust $Λ$-quantiles equal the $Λ$-quantiles of the extreme probabilities. This finding allows us to obt…
▽ More
In this paper, we investigate the robust models for $Λ$-quantiles with partial information regarding the loss distribution, where $Λ$-quantiles extend the classical quantiles by replacing the fixed probability level with a probability/loss function $Λ$. We find that, under some assumptions, the robust $Λ$-quantiles equal the $Λ$-quantiles of the extreme probabilities. This finding allows us to obtain the robust $Λ$-quantiles by applying the results of robust quantiles in the literature. Our results are applied to uncertainty sets characterized by three different constraints respectively: moment constraints, probability distance constraints via Wasserstein metric, and marginal constraints in risk aggregation. We obtain some explicit expressions for robust $Λ$-quantiles by deriving the extreme probabilities for each uncertainty set. Those results are applied to optimal portfolio selection under model uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Factor risk measures
Authors:
Hirbod Assa,
Peng Liu
Abstract:
This paper introduces and studies factor risk measures. While risk measures only rely on the distribution of a loss random variable, in many cases risk needs to be measured relative to some major factors. In this paper, we introduce a double-argument mapping as a risk measure to assess the risk relative to a vector of factors, called factor risk measure. The factor risk measure only depends on the…
▽ More
This paper introduces and studies factor risk measures. While risk measures only rely on the distribution of a loss random variable, in many cases risk needs to be measured relative to some major factors. In this paper, we introduce a double-argument mapping as a risk measure to assess the risk relative to a vector of factors, called factor risk measure. The factor risk measure only depends on the joint distribution of the risk and the factors. A set of natural axioms are discussed, and particularly distortion, quantile, linear and coherent factor risk measures are introduced and characterized. Moreover, we introduce a large set of concrete factor risk measures and many of them are new to the literature, which are interpreted in the context of regulatory capital requirement. Finally, the distortion factor risk measures are applied in the risk-sharing problem and some numerical examples are presented to show the difference between the Value-at-Risk and the quantile factor risk measures.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Antinetwork among China A-shares
Authors:
Peng Liu
Abstract:
The correlation-based financial networks, constructed with the correlation relationships among the time series of fluctuations of daily logarithmic prices of stocks, are intensively studied. However, these studies ignore the importance of negative correlations. This paper is the first time to consider the negative and positive correlations separately, and accordingly to construct weighted temporal…
▽ More
The correlation-based financial networks, constructed with the correlation relationships among the time series of fluctuations of daily logarithmic prices of stocks, are intensively studied. However, these studies ignore the importance of negative correlations. This paper is the first time to consider the negative and positive correlations separately, and accordingly to construct weighted temporal antinetwork and network among stocks listed in the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges. For (anti)networks during the first 24 years of the 21st century, the node's degree and strength, the assortativity coefficient, the average local clustering coefficient, and the average shortest path length are analyzed systematically. This paper unveils some essential differences in these topological measurements between antinetwork and network. The findings of the differences between antinetwork and network have an important role in understanding the dynamics of a financial complex system. The observation of antinetwork is of great importance in optimizing investment portfolios and risk management. More importantly, this paper proposes a new direction for studying complex systems, namely the correlation-based antinetwork.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Limited or Biased: Modeling Sub-Rational Human Investors in Financial Markets
Authors:
Penghang Liu,
Kshama Dwarakanath,
Svitlana S Vyetrenko,
Tucker Balch
Abstract:
Human decision-making in real-life deviates significantly from the optimal decisions made by fully rational agents, primarily due to computational limitations or psychological biases. While existing studies in behavioral finance have discovered various aspects of human sub-rationality, there lacks a comprehensive framework to transfer these findings into an adaptive human model applicable across d…
▽ More
Human decision-making in real-life deviates significantly from the optimal decisions made by fully rational agents, primarily due to computational limitations or psychological biases. While existing studies in behavioral finance have discovered various aspects of human sub-rationality, there lacks a comprehensive framework to transfer these findings into an adaptive human model applicable across diverse financial market scenarios. In this study, we introduce a flexible model that incorporates five different aspects of human sub-rationality using reinforcement learning. Our model is trained using a high-fidelity multi-agent market simulator, which overcomes limitations associated with the scarcity of labeled data of individual investors. We evaluate the behavior of sub-rational human investors using hand-crafted market scenarios and SHAP value analysis, showing that our model accurately reproduces the observations in the previous studies and reveals insights of the driving factors of human behavior. Finally, we explore the impact of sub-rationality on the investor's Profit and Loss (PnL) and market quality. Our experiments reveal that bounded-rational and prospect-biased human behaviors improve liquidity but diminish price efficiency, whereas human behavior influenced by myopia, optimism, and pessimism reduces market liquidity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2024; v1 submitted 16 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Precision measurement of the return distribution property of the Chinese stock market index
Authors:
Peng Liu,
Yanyan Zheng
Abstract:
This paper systematically conducts an analysis of the composite index 1-min datasets over the 17-year period (2005-2021) for both the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges. To reveal the difference between the Chinese and the mature stock markets, here we precisely measure the property of return distribution of composite index over the time scale $Δt$ ranging from 1 min up to almost 4,000 min. The…
▽ More
This paper systematically conducts an analysis of the composite index 1-min datasets over the 17-year period (2005-2021) for both the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges. To reveal the difference between the Chinese and the mature stock markets, here we precisely measure the property of return distribution of composite index over the time scale $Δt$ ranging from 1 min up to almost 4,000 min. The main findings are as follows. (1) Return distribution presents a leptokurtic, fat-tailed, and almost symmetrical shape, which is similar to that of mature markets. (2) The central part of return distribution is well described by the symmetrical Lévy $α$-stable process with a stability parameter comparable with the value of about 1.4 extracted in the U.S. stock market. (3) Return distribution can be well described by the student's t-distribution within a wider return range than the Lévy $α$-stable distribution. (4) Distinctively, the stability parameter shows a potential change when $Δt$ increases, and thus a crossover region at 15 $< Δt <$ 60 min is observed. This is different from the finding in the U.S. stock market where a single value of about 1.4 holds over 1 $\le Δt \le$ 1,000 min. (5) The tail distribution of returns at small $Δt$ decays as an asymptotic power-law with an exponent of about 3, which is a value widely existing in mature markets. However, it decays exponentially when $Δt \ge$ 240 min, which is not observed in mature markets. (6) Return distributions gradually converge to Gaussian as $Δt$ increases. This observation is different from the finding of a critical $Δt =$ 4 days in the U.S. stock market.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2023; v1 submitted 18 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Ordering and Inequalities for Mixtures on Risk Aggregation
Authors:
Yuyu Chen,
Peng Liu,
Yang Liu,
Ruodu Wang
Abstract:
Aggregation sets, which represent model uncertainty due to unknown dependence, are an important object in the study of robust risk aggregation. In this paper, we investigate ordering relations between two aggregation sets for which the sets of marginals are related by two simple operations: distribution mixtures and quantile mixtures. Intuitively, these operations ``homogenize" marginal distributi…
▽ More
Aggregation sets, which represent model uncertainty due to unknown dependence, are an important object in the study of robust risk aggregation. In this paper, we investigate ordering relations between two aggregation sets for which the sets of marginals are related by two simple operations: distribution mixtures and quantile mixtures. Intuitively, these operations ``homogenize" marginal distributions by making them similar. As a general conclusion from our results, more ``homogeneous" marginals lead to a larger aggregation set, and thus more severe model uncertainty, although the situation for quantile mixtures is much more complicated than that for distribution mixtures. We proceed to study inequalities on the worst-case values of risk measures in risk aggregation, which represent conservative calculation of regulatory capital. Among other results, we obtain an order relation on VaR under quantile mixture for marginal distributions with monotone densities. Numerical results are presented to visualize the theoretical results and further inspire some conjectures. Finally, we provide applications on portfolio diversification under dependence uncertainty and merging p-values in multiple hypothesis testing, and discuss the connection of our results to joint mixability.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2021; v1 submitted 24 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Change of measure under the hard-to-borrow model
Authors:
Peng Liu
Abstract:
As the Securities and Exchange Commission(SEC) has implemented a new regulation on short-sellings, short-sellers are required to repurchase stocks once the clearing risk rises to a certain level. Avellaneda and Lipkin proposed a fully coupled SDE system to describe the mechanism which is referred as Hard-To-Borrow(HTB) models. Guiyuan Ma obtained the PDE system for both American and European optio…
▽ More
As the Securities and Exchange Commission(SEC) has implemented a new regulation on short-sellings, short-sellers are required to repurchase stocks once the clearing risk rises to a certain level. Avellaneda and Lipkin proposed a fully coupled SDE system to describe the mechanism which is referred as Hard-To-Borrow(HTB) models. Guiyuan Ma obtained the PDE system for both American and European options. There is a technical error in Guiyuan Ma where two correlated Brownian motion should be converted before change of measure. In this paper, I will provide supplement conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Risk Premia and Optimal Liquidation of Credit Derivatives
Authors:
Tim Leung,
Peng Liu
Abstract:
This paper studies the optimal timing to liquidate credit derivatives in a general intensity-based credit risk model under stochastic interest rate. We incorporate the potential price discrepancy between the market and investors, which is characterized by risk-neutral valuation under different default risk premia specifications. We quantify the value of optimally timing to sell through the concept…
▽ More
This paper studies the optimal timing to liquidate credit derivatives in a general intensity-based credit risk model under stochastic interest rate. We incorporate the potential price discrepancy between the market and investors, which is characterized by risk-neutral valuation under different default risk premia specifications. We quantify the value of optimally timing to sell through the concept of delayed liquidation premium, and analyze the associated probabilistic representation and variational inequality. We illustrate the optimal liquidation policy for both single-named and multi-named credit derivatives. Our model is extended to study the sequential buying and selling problem with and without short-sale constraint.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2012; v1 submitted 2 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
