-
Two-dimensional correlation propagation dynamics with a cluster discrete phase-space method
Authors:
Kazuma Nagao,
Seiji Yunoki
Abstract:
Nonequilibrium dynamics of highly-controlled quantum systems is a challenging issue in statistical physics and quantum many-body physics, relevant to recent experimental developments of analog and digital quantum simulations. In this work, we develop a discrete phase-space approach for general SU($N$) spin systems that utilizes cluster mean field equations, which capture non-trivial quantum correl…
▽ More
Nonequilibrium dynamics of highly-controlled quantum systems is a challenging issue in statistical physics and quantum many-body physics, relevant to recent experimental developments of analog and digital quantum simulations. In this work, we develop a discrete phase-space approach for general SU($N$) spin systems that utilizes cluster mean field equations, which capture non-trivial quantum correlations inside each cluster, beyond the capability of the standard discrete truncated Wigner approximation for individual classical spins. Our formalism, based on a cluster phase-point operator, makes it possible to realize scalable numerical samplings of cluster phase-space variables, where the total number of noise variables for a direct product state is independent of the choice of the separation into finite regions of clusters. We numerically demonstrate that the cluster discrete truncated Wigner approximation (C-dTWA) method can reproduce key results in a recent experiment on the correlation propagation dynamics in a two dimensional Bose-Hubbard system. We also compare the results of C-dTWA for clusters of $2\times 2$ sites with those of a two-dimensional tensor network method and discuss that both approaches agree very well in a short time region, where the energy is well conserved in the tensor network simulations. Since we formulate the C-dTWA method in a general form, it can be potentially applied to various dynamical problems in isolated and open quantum systems even in higher dimensions.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2024; v1 submitted 29 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Semiclassical descriptions of dissipative dynamics of strongly interacting Bose gases in optical lattices
Authors:
Kazuma Nagao,
Ippei Danshita,
Seiji Yunoki
Abstract:
We develop semiclassical methods for describing real-time dynamics of dissipative Bose-Hubbard systems in a strongly interacting regime, which can be realized in experiments with ultracold gases. Specifically, we present two kinds of SU(3) truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) for solving an effective Lindblad master equation of the systems. The first one employs the discrete TWA for finite levels…
▽ More
We develop semiclassical methods for describing real-time dynamics of dissipative Bose-Hubbard systems in a strongly interacting regime, which can be realized in experiments with ultracold gases. Specifically, we present two kinds of SU(3) truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) for solving an effective Lindblad master equation of the systems. The first one employs the discrete TWA for finite levels or spin systems and is based on a classical equation of motion in which the onsite dissipation term, as well as the onsite interaction term, is linearized in the phase space variables. The other approach utilizes a stochastic Langevin equation, including decoherence effects in terms of nonlinear drift force and stochastic force terms, in which the initial conditions of trajectories are weighted with a quasiprobability distribution for a typical initial quantum state. We apply these methods to the systems with two-body losses and compare their results with the exact numerical solutions for a small system. We show that the former approach can simulate correctly longer-time dynamics than the latter one. We also calculate the time evolution for a large size setup that is comparable to experiments. We numerically demonstrate that the discrete TWA approach is able to qualitatively capture the continuous quantum Zeno effect on dynamics subjected to a gradual change of the ratio between the hopping amplitude and the onsite interaction across the superfluid-Mott insulator crossover, which has been observed experimentally.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024; v1 submitted 30 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
What gives a "theory of Initial Conditions" ?
Authors:
Holger Bech Nielsen,
Keiichi Nagao
Abstract:
The present work contains a review of some of the work we have done on complex action or non-Hermitian Hamiltonian theory, especially the result that the anti-Hermitian part of the Hamiltonian functions by determining the actual solution to the equations of motion, that should be realized; this means it predicts the initial conditions. It should be stressed that a major result of ours is that the…
▽ More
The present work contains a review of some of the work we have done on complex action or non-Hermitian Hamiltonian theory, especially the result that the anti-Hermitian part of the Hamiltonian functions by determining the actual solution to the equations of motion, that should be realized; this means it predicts the initial conditions. It should be stressed that a major result of ours is that the effective equations of motion will in practice -- after long time -- be so accurately as if we had indeed a Hermitian Hamiltonian, and so there is at first nothing wrong in assuming a non-Hermitian one. In fact it would practically seem Hermitian anyway! A major new point is that we seek by a bit intuitively arguing to suggest some cosmologically predictions from the mentioned initial conditions predicted: We seek even by assumming essentially nothing but very general properties of the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian that we in practice should find a bottom in the (effective Hermitian) Hamiltonian and that the Universe at some moment should pass through a (multiple) saddle point very closely, so that the time spent at it would be very long.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Automatic hermiticity for mixed states
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
We previously proposed a mechanism to effectively obtain, after a long time development, a Hamiltonian being Hermitian with regard to a modified inner product $I_Q$ that makes a given non-normal Hamiltonian normal by using an appropriately chosen Hermitian operator $Q$. We studied it for pure states. In this letter we show that a similar mechanism also works for mixed states by introducing density…
▽ More
We previously proposed a mechanism to effectively obtain, after a long time development, a Hamiltonian being Hermitian with regard to a modified inner product $I_Q$ that makes a given non-normal Hamiltonian normal by using an appropriately chosen Hermitian operator $Q$. We studied it for pure states. In this letter we show that a similar mechanism also works for mixed states by introducing density matrices to describe them and investigating their properties explicitly both in the future-not-included and future-included theories. In particular, in the latter, where not only a past state at the initial time $T_A$ but also a future state at the final time $T_B$ is given, we study a couple of candidates for it, and introduce a ``skew density matrix'' composed of both ensembles of the future and past states such that the trace of the product of it and an operator ${\cal O}$ matches a normalized matrix element of ${\cal O}$. We argue that the skew density matrix defined with $I_Q$ at the present time $t$ for large $T_B-t$ and large $t-T_A$ approximately corresponds to another density matrix composed of only an ensemble of past states and defined with another inner product $I_{Q_J}$ for large $t-T_A$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2023; v1 submitted 23 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Reality from maximizing overlap in the periodic complex action theory
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
We study the periodic complex action theory (CAT) by imposing a periodic condition in the future-included CAT where the time integration is performed from the past to the future, and extend a normalized matrix element of an operator $\hat{\mathcal O}$, which is called the weak value in the real action theory, to another expression…
▽ More
We study the periodic complex action theory (CAT) by imposing a periodic condition in the future-included CAT where the time integration is performed from the past to the future, and extend a normalized matrix element of an operator $\hat{\mathcal O}$, which is called the weak value in the real action theory, to another expression $\langle \hat{\mathcal O} \rangle_{\mathrm{periodic}~\mathrm{time}}$. We present two theorems stating that $\langle \hat{\mathcal O} \rangle_{\mathrm{periodic}~\mathrm{time}}$ becomes real for $\hat{\mathcal O}$ being Hermitian with regard to a modified inner product that makes a given non-normal Hamiltonian $\hat{H}$ normal. The first theorem holds for a given period $t_p$ in a case where the number of eigenstates having the maximal imaginary part $B$ of the eigenvalues of $\hat{H}$ is just one, while the second one stands for $t_p$ selected such that the absolute value of the transition amplitude is maximized in a case where $B \leq 0$ and $|B|$ is much smaller than the distances between any two real parts of the eigenvalues of $\hat{H}$. The latter proven via a number-theoretical argument suggests that, if our universe is periodic, then even the period could be an adjustment parameter to be determined in the Feynman path integral. This is a variant type of the maximization principle that we previously proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2022; v1 submitted 15 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Blind quantum computation with a heralded single photon source
Authors:
Kurumiko Nagao,
Tomoyuki Horikiri,
Toshihiko Sasaki
Abstract:
Blind quantum computation is a scheme that adds unconditional security to cloud quantum computation. In the protocol proposed by Broadbent, Fitzsimons, and Kashefi, the ability to prepare and transmit a single qubit is required for a user (client) who uses a quantum computer remotely. In case a weak coherent pulse is used as a pseudo single photon source, however, we must introduce decoy states, o…
▽ More
Blind quantum computation is a scheme that adds unconditional security to cloud quantum computation. In the protocol proposed by Broadbent, Fitzsimons, and Kashefi, the ability to prepare and transmit a single qubit is required for a user (client) who uses a quantum computer remotely. In case a weak coherent pulse is used as a pseudo single photon source, however, we must introduce decoy states, owing to the inherent risk of transmitting multiple photon. In this study, we demonstrate that by using a heralded single photon source and a probabilistic photon number resolving detector, we can gain a higher blind state generation efficiency and longer access distance, owing to noise reduction on account of the heralding signal.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Formalism of a harmonic oscillator in the future-included complex action theory
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
In a special representation of complex action theory that we call ``future-included'', we study a harmonic oscillator model defined with a non-normal Hamiltonian $\hat{H}$, in which a mass $m$ and an angular frequency $ω$ are taken to be complex numbers. In order for the model to be sensible some restrictions on $m$ and $ω$ are required. We draw a phase diagram in the plane of the arguments of…
▽ More
In a special representation of complex action theory that we call ``future-included'', we study a harmonic oscillator model defined with a non-normal Hamiltonian $\hat{H}$, in which a mass $m$ and an angular frequency $ω$ are taken to be complex numbers. In order for the model to be sensible some restrictions on $m$ and $ω$ are required. We draw a phase diagram in the plane of the arguments of $m$ and $ω$, according to which the model is classified into several types. In addition, we formulate two pairs of annihilation and creation operators, two series of eigenstates of the Hamiltonians $\hat{H}$ and $\hat{H}^†$, and coherent states. They are normalized in a modified inner product $I_Q$, with respect to which the Hamiltonian $\hat{H}$ becomes normal. Furthermore, applying to the model the maximization principle that we previously proposed, we obtain an effective theory described by a Hamiltonian that is $Q$-Hermitian, i.e. Hermitian with respect to the modified inner product $I_Q$. The generic solution to the model is found to be the ``ground'' state. Finally we discuss what the solution implies.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2019; v1 submitted 4 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Reality from maximizing overlap in the future-included theories
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
In the future-included complex and real action theories whose paths run over not only the past but also the future, we briefly review the theorem on the normalized matrix element of an operator $\hat{\cal O}$, which is defined in terms of the future and past states with a proper inner product $I_Q$ that makes a given Hamiltonian normal. The theorem states that, provided that the operator…
▽ More
In the future-included complex and real action theories whose paths run over not only the past but also the future, we briefly review the theorem on the normalized matrix element of an operator $\hat{\cal O}$, which is defined in terms of the future and past states with a proper inner product $I_Q$ that makes a given Hamiltonian normal. The theorem states that, provided that the operator $\hat{\cal O}$ is $Q$-Hermitian, i.e. Hermitian with regard to the proper inner product $I_Q$, the normalized matrix element becomes real and time-develops under a $Q$-Hermitian Hamiltonian for the past and future states selected such that the absolute value of the transition amplitude from the past state to the future state is maximized. Discussing what the theorem implicates, we speculate that the future-included complex action theory would be the most elegant quantum theory.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Complex action suggests future-included theory
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
In quantum theory its action is usually taken to be real, but we can consider another theory whose action is complex. In addition, in the Feynman path integral, the time integration is usually performed over the period between the initial time $T_A$ and some specific time, say, the present time $t$. Besides such a future-not-included theory, we can consider the future-included theory, in which not…
▽ More
In quantum theory its action is usually taken to be real, but we can consider another theory whose action is complex. In addition, in the Feynman path integral, the time integration is usually performed over the period between the initial time $T_A$ and some specific time, say, the present time $t$. Besides such a future-not-included theory, we can consider the future-included theory, in which not only the past state $| A(T_A) \rangle$ at the initial time $T_A$ but also the future state $| B(T_B) \rangle$ at the final time $T_B$ is given at first, and the time integration is performed over the whole period from the past to the future. Thus quantum theory can be classified into four types, according to whether its action is real or not, and whether the future is included or not. We argue that, if a theory is described with a complex action, then such a theory is suggested to be the future-included theory, rather than the future-not-included theory. Otherwise persons living at different times would see different histories of the universe.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2018; v1 submitted 28 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Reality from maximizing overlap in the future-included real action theory
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
In the future-included real action theory whose path runs over not only past but also future, we demonstrate a theorem, which states that the normalized matrix element of a Hermitian operator $\hat{\cal O}$ defined in terms of the future state at the final time $T_B$ and the fixed past state at the initial time $T_A$ becomes real for the future state selected such that the absolute value of the tr…
▽ More
In the future-included real action theory whose path runs over not only past but also future, we demonstrate a theorem, which states that the normalized matrix element of a Hermitian operator $\hat{\cal O}$ defined in terms of the future state at the final time $T_B$ and the fixed past state at the initial time $T_A$ becomes real for the future state selected such that the absolute value of the transition amplitude from the past state to the future state is maximized. This is a special version of our previously proposed theorem for the future-included complex action theory. We find that though the maximization principle leads to the reality of the normalized matrix element in the future-included real action theory, it does not specify the future and past states so much as in the case of the future-included complex action theory. In addition, we argue that the normalized matrix element seems to be more natural than the usual expectation value. Thus we speculate that the functional integral formalism of quantum theory could be most elegant in the future-included complex action theory.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2017; v1 submitted 3 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Reality and hermiticity from maximizing overlap in the future-included complex action theory
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
In the complex action theory whose path runs over not only past but also future we study a normalized matrix element of an operator $\hat{\cal O}$ defined in terms of the future state at the latest time $T_B$ and the past state at the earliest time $T_A$ with a proper inner product that makes normal a given Hamiltonian that is non-normal at first. We present a theorem that states that, provided th…
▽ More
In the complex action theory whose path runs over not only past but also future we study a normalized matrix element of an operator $\hat{\cal O}$ defined in terms of the future state at the latest time $T_B$ and the past state at the earliest time $T_A$ with a proper inner product that makes normal a given Hamiltonian that is non-normal at first. We present a theorem that states that, provided that the operator $\hat{\cal O}$ is $Q$-Hermitian, i.e., Hermitian with regard to the proper inner product, the normalized matrix element becomes real and time-develops under a $Q$-Hermitian Hamiltonian for the past and future states selected such that the absolute value of the transition amplitude from the past state to the future state is maximized. Furthermore, we give a possible procedure to formulate the $Q$-Hermitian Hamiltonian in terms of $Q$-Hermitian coordinate and momentum operators, and construct a conserved probability current density.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2015; v1 submitted 2 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Momentum relation and classical limit in the future-not-included complex action theory
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
Studying the time development of the expectation value in the future-not-included complex action theory, we point out that the momentum relation (the relation analogous to $p=\frac{\partial L}{\partial \dot{q}}$), which was derived via the Feynman path integral and was shown to be correct in the future-included theory in our previous papers, is not valid in the future-not-included theory. We provi…
▽ More
Studying the time development of the expectation value in the future-not-included complex action theory, we point out that the momentum relation (the relation analogous to $p=\frac{\partial L}{\partial \dot{q}}$), which was derived via the Feynman path integral and was shown to be correct in the future-included theory in our previous papers, is not valid in the future-not-included theory. We provide the correct momentum relation in the future-not-included theory, and argue that the future-not-included classical theory is described by a certain real action. In addition, we provide another way to understand the time development of the future-not-included theory by utilizing the future-included theory. Furthermore, properly applying the method used in our previous paper to the future-not-included theory by introducing a formal Lagrangian, we derive the correct momentum relation in the future-not-included theory.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2019; v1 submitted 15 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Correspondence between future-included and future-not-included theories
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
We briefly review the correspondence principle proposed in our previous paper, which claims that if we regard a matrix element defined in terms of the future state at time $T_B$ and the past state at time $T_A$ as an expectation value in the complex action theory whose path runs over not only past but also future, the expectation value at the present time $t$ of a future-included theory for large…
▽ More
We briefly review the correspondence principle proposed in our previous paper, which claims that if we regard a matrix element defined in terms of the future state at time $T_B$ and the past state at time $T_A$ as an expectation value in the complex action theory whose path runs over not only past but also future, the expectation value at the present time $t$ of a future-included theory for large $T_B-t$ and large $t-T_A$ corresponds to that of a future-not-included theory with a proper inner product for large $t-T_A$. This correspondence principle suggests that the future-included theory is not excluded phenomenologically.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2012; v1 submitted 30 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Theory Including Future Not Excluded -- Formulation of Complex Action Theory II --
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
We study a complex action theory (CAT) whose path runs over not only past but also future. We show that if we regard a matrix element defined in terms of the future state at time $T_B$ and the past state at time $T_A$ as an expectation value in the CAT, then we are allowed to have the Heisenberg equation, the Ehrenfest's theorem and the conserved probability current density. In addition we show th…
▽ More
We study a complex action theory (CAT) whose path runs over not only past but also future. We show that if we regard a matrix element defined in terms of the future state at time $T_B$ and the past state at time $T_A$ as an expectation value in the CAT, then we are allowed to have the Heisenberg equation, the Ehrenfest's theorem and the conserved probability current density. In addition we show that the expectation value at the present time $t$ of a future-included theory for large $T_B-t$ and large $t- T_A$ corresponds to that of a future-not-included theory with a proper inner product for large $t- T_A$. Hence the CAT with future explicitly present in the formalism and influencing in principle the past is not excluded phenomenologically, because the effects are argued to be very small in the present era. Furthermore we explicitly derive the Schrödinger equation and Hamiltonian for the future state via path integral, and confirm that the Hamiltonian is given by the Hermitian conjugate of the Hamiltonian for the past state.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2019; v1 submitted 16 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Momentum and Hamiltonian in Complex Action Theory
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
In the complex action theory (CAT) we explicitly examine how the momentum and Hamiltonian are defined from the Feynman path integral (FPI) point of view based on the complex coordinate formalism of our foregoing paper. After reviewing the formalism briefly, we describe in FPI with a Lagrangian the time development of a $ξ$-parametrized wave function, which is a solution to an eigenvalue problem of…
▽ More
In the complex action theory (CAT) we explicitly examine how the momentum and Hamiltonian are defined from the Feynman path integral (FPI) point of view based on the complex coordinate formalism of our foregoing paper. After reviewing the formalism briefly, we describe in FPI with a Lagrangian the time development of a $ξ$-parametrized wave function, which is a solution to an eigenvalue problem of a momentum operator. Solving this eigenvalue problem, we derive the momentum, Hamiltonian, and Schrödinger equation. Oppositely, starting from the Hamiltonian we derive the Lagrangian in FPI, and we are led to the momentum relation again via the saddle point for $p$. This study confirms that the momentum and Hamiltonian in the CAT have the same forms as those in the real action theory. We also show the third derivation of the momentum relation via the saddle point for $q$.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2018; v1 submitted 6 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
Formulation of Complex Action Theory
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
We formulate a complex action theory which includes operators of coordinate and momentum $\hat{q}$ and $\hat{p}$ being replaced with non-hermitian operators $\hat{q}_{new}$ and $\hat{p}_{new}$, and their eigenstates ${}_m <_{new} q |$ and ${}_m <_{new} p |$ with complex eigenvalues $q$ and $p$. Introducing a philosophy of keeping the analyticity in path integration variables, we define a modified…
▽ More
We formulate a complex action theory which includes operators of coordinate and momentum $\hat{q}$ and $\hat{p}$ being replaced with non-hermitian operators $\hat{q}_{new}$ and $\hat{p}_{new}$, and their eigenstates ${}_m <_{new} q |$ and ${}_m <_{new} p |$ with complex eigenvalues $q$ and $p$. Introducing a philosophy of keeping the analyticity in path integration variables, we define a modified set of complex conjugate, real and imaginary parts, hermitian conjugates and bras, and explicitly construct $\hat{q}_{new}$, $\hat{p}_{new}$, ${}_m <_{new} q |$ and ${}_m <_{new} p |$ by formally squeezing coherent states. We also pose a theorem on the relation between functions on the phase space and the corresponding operators. Only in our formalism can we describe a complex action theory or a real action theory with complex saddle points in the tunneling effect etc. in terms of bras and kets in the functional integral. Furthermore, in a system with a non-hermitian diagonalizable bounded Hamiltonian, we show that the mechanism to obtain a hermitian Hamiltonian after a long time development proposed in our letter works also in the complex coordinate formalism. If the hermitian Hamiltonian is given in a local form, a conserved probability current density can be constructed with two kinds of wave functions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2012; v1 submitted 18 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Automatic Hermiticity
Authors:
Keiichi Nagao,
Holger Bech Nielsen
Abstract:
We study a diagonalizable Hamiltonian that is not at first hermitian. Requirement that a measurement shall not change one Hamiltonian eigenstate into another one with a different eigenvalue imposes that an inner product must be defined so as to make the Hamiltonian normal with regard to it. After a long time development with the non-hermitian Hamiltonian, only a subspace of possible states will ef…
▽ More
We study a diagonalizable Hamiltonian that is not at first hermitian. Requirement that a measurement shall not change one Hamiltonian eigenstate into another one with a different eigenvalue imposes that an inner product must be defined so as to make the Hamiltonian normal with regard to it. After a long time development with the non-hermitian Hamiltonian, only a subspace of possible states will effectively survive. On this subspace the effect of the anti-hermitian part of the Hamiltonian is suppressed, and the Hamiltonian becomes hermitian. Thus hermiticity emerges automatically, and we have no reason to maintain that at the fundamental level the Hamiltonian should be hermitian. If the Hamiltonian is given in a local form, a conserved probability current density can be constructed with two kinds of wave functions. We also point out a possible misestimation of a past state by extrapolating back in time with the hermitian Hamiltonian. It is a seeming past state, not a true one.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2011; v1 submitted 2 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
