Abstract
In the present paper, we study the discovery of the chemical element number 23, Erythronium/Vanadium (E/V), as an early example of the modern process of validating knowledge claims in México. We examined the published work between 1802 and 1832 of Andrés Manuel del Río (AMR) in the Royal Mining Seminar of México and contrasted the styles of argument and forms of certification between his teaching and experimental writings concerning his claim to the paternity of E/V discovery. We also analyze the respective papers of European authors that replicated, rediscovered and certified AMR’s finding. We use a combination of bibliometric, sociotechnical network and literary critical analysis in order to show that the certification of E/V spawned an emerging mode for producing and validating new knowledge in the American continent and particularly in México. In turn, this approach supports AMR’s claim to the discovery of E/V from the production process of the lead brown ore in Zimapán, México.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ayers, G. (2008). The evolutionary nature of genre: An investigation of the short texts accompanying research articles in the scientific journal Nature. English of Specific Purposes, 27, 22–41.
Barton, D., & Papen, U. (2010). The anthropology of writing: writing as social and cultural practice. What is the anthropology of writing? The anthropology of writing. Understanding textually-mediated worlds (pp. 1–33). London: Continuum International Publishing Group. ISBN 978-1441108852.
Bazerman, C. (1984). Modern evolution of the experimental report in physics—Spectroscopic articles in physical-review, 1893–1980. Social Studies of Science, 2(14), 163–196.
Bazerman, C. (1988a). Shaping written knowledge. The genre and activity of the experimental article in science. Madison, WI: The University of Wisconsin Press.
Bazerman, C. (1988b). Physicists reading physics. Schema-laden purposes and purpose-laden schema. Shaping written knowledge. The genre and activity of the experimental article in science (pp. 235–253). Madison, WI: The University of Wisconsin Press.
Bazerman, C. (1988c). Reporting the experiment. The changing account of scientific doings in the philosophical transactions of the royal society, 1665–1800. Shaping written knowledge. The genre and activity of the experimental article in science (pp. 59–79). Madison, WI: The University of Wisconsin Press.
Bazerman, C. (1988d). Theoretical integration in experimental reports in twentieth-century physics. Spectroscopy articles in physical review, 1893–1980. Shaping written knowledge. The genre and activity of the experimental article in science (pp. 153–186). Madison, WI: The University of Wisconsin Press.
Bazerman, C. (2008). Theories of the middle range in historical studies of writing practices. Written Communication, 25(3), 298–318.
Berzelius, J. J. (1831a). A new metal discovered. Extracted of a letter from M. Berzelius to M. Dulong, read before the Academy of Natural Sciences, Paris. Philosophical Magazine, 10(July–December), 151–152.
Berzelius, J. J. (1831b). On Vanadium. Philosophical Magazine, 10(November), 321–337.
Berzelius, J. J. (1831c). Traité de Chimie. Vanadium Addition aux volumes II et III. Paris: Firmin Didot Freres.
Berzelius, J. J. (1831d). New metal Vanadium. Extracted of a letter from M. Dulong, read before the Academy of Natural Sciences. American Journal of Science and Arts, 20(July), 386.
Berzelius, J. J. (1832). New metal Vanadium. Extracted of a letter from M. Berzelius to M. Dulong, read before the Academy of Natural Sciences. The Journal of the Royal Institution of Great Britain, 1(May), 562.
Bourdieu, P. (2003). El oficio de científico. Ciencia de la ciencia y reflexividad. Barcelona: Anagrama.
Castillo-Matos, M. (2005). Creadores de la ciencia moderna en España y América. Ulloa, los Delhuyar y del Río descubren el platino, el wolframio y el vanadio. Sevilla: Muñoz Moya Editores Extremeños.
Caswell, L. R. (2003). Erythronium and oryctognosy: The life and works of Andrés Manuel Del Río. Abstracts of Papers of the American Chemical Society, 219: U710-U710, Part: 1, Meeting Abstract: 36-HIST.
Ceccarelli, L. (2001). Rhetorical criticism and the rhetoric of science. Western Journal of Communication, 65(3), 314–329.
Collazo-Reyes, F., Luna-Morales, M. E., & Vélez-Cuartas, G. (2010). Rise of the scientific practices of collaboration in the Mexican science with cover in the international indices. REDES, 19, 143–167.
Collazo-Reyes, F., Luna-Morales, M. E., Russell, J. M., & Pérez-Angón, M. A. (2011). Emergence and convergence of scientific communication in a developing country: México 1900–1979. In Proceedings of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics. Durban, South Africa, July 4–8, pp. 155–162.
Collet-Descotils, H. (1805). Analyse de la mine brune de plomb de Zimapán, dans le royaume du Mexique, et dans laquelle M. Del Río dit avoir decouvert un noveau metal. Annali di Chimica, 53, 268–271.
Cueto, M. (1989). Excelencia científica en la periferia. Lima: Grade-Concytec.
Dear, P. (1985). Totius in verba. Rhetoric and authority in the Early Royal Society. ISIS, 76, 145–161.
Fahnestock, J., & Secor, M. (1991). The rhetoric of literacy criticism. In C. Bazerman & J. Paradis (Eds.), Textual dynamics of the professions. Historical and contemporary studies of writing in professional communities (pp. 76–96). Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
Fairclough, N. (1999). Critical discourse analysis: the critical study of language. New York: Longman.
Fa-ti, F. (2012). The global turn in the history of science. East Asian Science, Technology and Society: An international Journal, 6, 249–258.
Ferris, T. (2002). On scientific writing. Physics in Perspective, 4, 3–12.
Finnegan, D. A. (2008). The spatial turn: Geographical approaches in the history of science. Journal of the History of Biology, 41, 369–388. doi:10.1007/s10739-007-9136-6.
Galindo, S., & Rodríguez-Meza, M. A. (2011a). Buenaventura Suárez, SJ (1679–1750). Part 1: Telescope maker, Jovian satellites observer. Revista Mexicana de Física E, 57(2), 121–133.
Galindo, S., & Rodríguez-Meza, M. A. (2011b). Buenaventura Suárez, SJ (1679–1750). Part 2: His book, lunario. Revista Mexicana de Física E, 57(2), 144–151.
Gilbert, G. N. (1976). The transformation of research findings into scientific knowledge. Social Studies of Science, 6, 281–306.
Gunn, S. (2001). The spatial turn: Changing history of space and place. In Simon Gunn & Robert J. Morris (Eds.), Identities in space: contested terrains in the Western city science 1850 (pp. 1–14). New Jersey: Ashgate Publishing Company.
Holmes, F. L. (1987). Scientific writing and scientific discovery. ISIS, 78(2), 220–235.
Hunter, M. C. W. (1995). Science and shape of orthodoxy: Intellectual change in late seventeenth-century Britain. New York: Boydell & Brewer Inc.
Hyland, K., & Salager-Meyer, F. (2009). Scientific writing. Annual Review of Information Science and Technology, 42(1), 297–338.
Jacob, J. R., & Jacob, M. C. (1980). The anglican origins of modern science: The Metaphysical Foundations of the Whig Constitution. ISIS, 71, 251–267.
Johnston, J. F. W. (1831). Some notices regarding Vanadium. Edinburgh Journal of Science, 5(April–October), 318–323.
Kauffman, G. B. (1998). Jons Jacob Berzelius—A man of influence. Chemistry & Industry, 24, 1027.
Kreimer, P. (1998). Understanding scientific research on the periphery: Towards a new sociological approach. EASST Review, 17(4), 13–21.
Luna-Morales, M. E., Collazo-Reyes, F., Russell, J. M., & Pérez-Angón, M. A. (2009). Early patterns of scientific production by Mexican Researchers in Mainstream Journals: 1900–1950. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 60(7), 1337–1348.
Marshall, J. L., & Marshall, V. R. (2014). Rediscovery of the elements: The second discovery of Vanadium. Indianapolis, Indiana, pp 46–50. UNT Digital Library. Available in http://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc111200/
Myers, G. (1989). Texts as knowledge claims: The social constructions of two biological articles. Social Studies of Science, 15(4), 593–630.
Patricio, A. A. L. (2004). Suárez a father of South American Astronomy. Physics Today, 57, 18.
Pickstone, J. V. (2011). A brief introduction to ways of knowing and ways of working. History of Science, xlix, 235–245.
Pontille, D. (2002). La Signature Scientifique. Authentification et Valeur Marchande. Actes de la Recherche en Sciences Sociales, 2(141), 72–78.
Pontille, D. (2003). Format´s D´Ecriture Et Mondes Scientifiques: Le Cas de la Sociologie. Questions Communications, 3, 55–67.
Pontille, D., & Torny, D. (2015). From manuscript evaluation to article valuation: The changing technologies of journal peer review. Human Studies, 38, 57–79.
Ramírez, S. (1891). Biografía del Sr. D. Andrés Manuel del Río: primer catedrático de Mineralogía del Colegio de Minería. México: Imp Del Sagrado Corazón de Jesús.
Richardson, L. (2000). New writing practices in qualitative research. Social of Sport Journal, 17(1), 5–20.
Sandoval-Vallarta, M., & Arnáiz y Freg, A. (1947). The name of element 23. Nature, 160(4057), 163–164.
Sefstrom, G. N. (1831). Ueber das Vanadin, ein Neues Metall, gefunden im Stangeneisen von Eckershalm, ainer Eisenhutte, die ihr Erz von Taberg in Sinaland bezieth. Annalen der Physik, 97(1), 43–49.
Shapin, S. (1984). Pump and circumstance: Robert Boyle’s literary technology. Social Studies of Science, 14(4), 481–520.
Shapin, S., & Schaffer, S. (1985). Leviathan and the air-pump. Hobbes, Boyle and the experimental life (p. 448). Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Sigusch, V. (2008). The birth of sexual medicine: Paolo Mantegazza as pioneer of sexual medicine in the 19th century. The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 5(1), 217–222.
Sollaci, L. B., & Pereira, M. G. (2004). The introduction, methods, results, and discussion (IMRAD) structure: A fifty-year survey. Journal of the Medical Library Association, 92(3), 364–371.
Swales, J. M. (1990). Genre analysis: English in academic and research settings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Taylor, P. J., Hoyler, M., & Evans, D. M. (2008). A geohistorical study of the rise of modern science: Mapping scientific practice through urban networks, 1500–1900. Minerva, 46, 391–410.
Upton, T. A., & Cohen, M. A. (2009). An approach to corpus-based discourse analysis: The move analysis as example. Discourse Studies, 11(5), 585–605.
Uribe-Salas, J. A. (2006). Labor de Andrés Manuel del Río en México: profesor en el Real Seminario de Minería e innovador tecnológico en minas y ferrería. Asclepio. Revista de Historia de la Medicina y de la Ciencia, 58(2), 231–260.
Uribe-Salas, J. A., & Cortes-Zavala, M. T. (2006). Andrés Del Río, Antonio Del Castillo and José G. Aguilera en el desarrollo de la ciencia mexicana del siglo XIX. Revista de Indias, 66(237), 491–518.
Vande-Kopple, W. J. (2002). From the dynamics style to the synoptic style in spectroscopic articles in the physical review. Written Communication, 19(2), 227–264.
Van-Dijk, T. (2001). Critical discourse analysis. In Deborah Tannen & Heidi E. Hamilton (Eds.), Deborah Schiffrin (pp. 352–371). Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishers Inc.
Vélez-Cuartas, G. (2010). Las redes de sentido de las redes sociales: un estudio cienciométrico. Dc Sci. Tesis, Universidad Iberoamericana Santa Fe. Available in http://revista-redes.rediris.es/webredes/novedades/tesis.pdf
Zappen, J. P. (1991). Scientific rhetoric in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. In C. Bazerman & J. Paradis (Eds.), Textual dynamics of the professions. Historical and contemporary studies of writing in professional communities (pp. 145–167). Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Zhang, L. (2012). Grasping the structure of journal articles: Utilizing the functions of information units. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 63(3), 469–480.
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge support from CONACYT (México); we also appreciate the collaboration of Gerardo Herrera in translating the German texts.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Collazo-Reyes, F., Luna-Morales, M.E., Russell, J.M. et al. Emergence of modern scientific discourse in the American continent: knowledge claims in the discovery of Erythronium/Vanadium in Mexico (1802–1832). Scientometrics 110, 1505–1521 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-016-2220-y
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-016-2220-y