Nian Rebellion: Difference between revisions

Nian Rebellion
	; Map of Nian Rebellion
Date	1851–1868
Location	Northern China
Result	Qing victory
Belligerents
Qing dynasty Supported by:; United Kingdom; France; United States	Nian militias Five Banner alliance (1856–58); "Army of the Taipings"; Henan armies; Co-belligerents:; Taiping Heavenly Kingdom; White Lotus rebels
Commanders and leaders
Zeng Guofan; Li Hongzhang; Zuo Zongtang; Sengge Rinchen †	Zhang Lexing †; Lai Wenguang; Zhang Zongyu; Ren Zhu; Miao Peilin ; Fan Ruzeng ; Niu Hongsheng
Strength
~500,000	~200,000
Casualties and losses
	100,000+ killed overall

Browse history interactively

← Previous edit Next edit →

Content deleted Content added

VisualWikitext

Inline

Revision as of 17:20, 9 June 2019

The Nian Rebellion (Chinese: 捻亂; pinyin: Niǎn Luàn)^[7] was an armed uprising that took place in northern China from 1851 to 1868, contemporaneously with Taiping Rebellion (1851–1864) in South China. The rebellion failed to topple the Qing dynasty, but caused immense economic devastation and loss of life that became major long-term factors in the collapse of the Qing regime in the early 20th century.

Origin

Nian is a word borrowed from the Huaibei dialect, a form of Central Plains Mandarin, where it was used to refer to loosely affiliated gangs or groups or “bandits”.^[8] The Nian movement was formed in the late 1840s by Zhang Lexing and, by 1851, numbered approximately 40,000. Unlike the Taiping Rebellion movement, the Nian initially had no clear goals or objectives, aside from criticism of the Qing government. Their slogan was "'kill the rich and aid the poor.'"^[9] However, the Nian were provoked into taking direct action against the Imperial regime following a series of environmental disasters.

The 1851 Yellow River flood deluged hundreds of thousands of square miles and caused immense loss of life. The Qing government slowly began cleaning up after the disaster but could not provide effective aid, as government finances had been drained during a recent Second Opium War with the British Empire and the ongoing slaughter of the Taiping Rebellion. The damage created by the disaster had still not been repaired when, in 1855, the river burst its banks again, drowning thousands and devastating the fertile province of Jiangsu. Along with the destruction caused by the floods famine spread.^[6] At the time, the Qing government was trying to negotiate a deal with the European powers, and as state finances had been so severely depleted, the regime was again unable to provide effective relief. This enraged the Nian movement, which blamed the Europeans for contributing to the nation troubles, and increasingly viewed the Qing government as incompetent.

The Nian rebels seemed to have been influenced by the previous 1794 White Lotus Rebellion, recruiting from secret societies and sects such as the White Lotus, and actively borrowing their terminology and symbols, examples being the practice of sworn brotherhood, five colours of banners, flags with eight trigrams, and the widespread use of units of woman warriors. Zhang Lexing, leader of the rebellion, used the title "Bright King of the Great Han", an address reminiscent of White Lotus leadership positions.^[10]

Political scientists Valerie Hudson and Andrea den Boer suggest that the rebellion was fueled, at least in part, by decades of female infanticide caused by the flood-related economic misery, leading to a large population of frustrated young men without any women to marry, perhaps as many as a quarter of all young men in the area being in this category of "bare branches".^[11]^[12]

The conflict

The Nian rebels were to a large degree desperate and poor peasants that banded together in bandit groups simply to survive. However, as natural disasters grew worse, these bandit groups grew increasingly large, and eventually became armies that were able to directly challenge the government. Nevertheless, the main interest of most Nian members remained plundering communities that were better off, as well as resisting taxation.^[13]

Religious motifs likewise were of little importance to the Nian rebels.^[5] While the Nian forces possibly inherited some of their symbols such as red turbans and Eight Trigram flags from the White Lotus,^[14] the overall influence of spiritual movements such as the White Lotus or the God Worshipping Society on them was low. For example, White Lotus rebels sometimes fought alongside Nian groups, but the latter sometimes also attacked the former in hopes of plunder.^[5]

On average, the Nian groups in Henan remained more similar to mere bandits than the Nian in Anhui.^[3] Overall, the Nian movement "remained primarily the expression of mundane strategies of survival" according to historian Elizabeth J. Perry.^[15] They were never revolutionaries,^[16] and besides slogans that called for death of government officials and the rich,^[17] as well as hopes for a more just society,^[15] they lacked clear, well-defined goals.^[6] That some Nian armies became actual rebel movements was mostly due to the ambitions of individual Nian leaders who wanted to become legitimate rulers.^[18]

The Nian utilized cavalry in part to aid in looting, which served to support both the Nian's forces and their home communities.^[19] In contrast to their mobile cavalry, the Nian's defensive tactics were based on the so-called "earthwall communities" they controlled.^[20] Support of the peasantry proved crucial and provided the true base of the Nian's power.^[21]

In 1851, the Nian began raiding the grain stores and silver caches of villages.^[22] Upon the seizure of Nanjing by the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, some Nian leaders sought an alliance with the Taiping.^[23] While Hong Xiuquan bestowed titles upon the Nian leaders and the Nian and the Taiping occasionally cooperated, full coordination between the two rebellions was never achieved.^[24] Cases in which Nian armies submitted or even fully joined the Taipings remained rare,^[4] as most remained bandit armies that were only interested in imminent profit and survival.^[15]

In 1855, Zhang Lexing took direct action by launching attacks against government troops in central China. By the summer, the fast-moving Nian cavalry and equipped with modern firearms purchased from foreigners, had cut the lines of communication between Beijing and the government armies fighting the Taiping rebels in the south. Qing forces were badly overstretched as rebellions broke out across China, allowing the Nian armies to conquer large tracts of land and gain control over economically vital areas. The Nian fortified their captured cities and used them as bases to launch cavalry attacks against Qing troops in the countryside, prompting local towns to fortify themselves against Nian raiding parties. This resulted in constant fighting which devastated the previously rich provinces of Jiangsu and Hunan.

In 1856, several Nian bands formed an alliance led by Zhang Lexing, organizing themselves into a loose confederation of five armies. Each army was identified by a colored banner, operated largely autonomous, and recruited mostly people belonging to a single clan.^[25]^[26]^[27]^[28] As result, each banner army had a core area which consisted of a number of villages whose inhabitants were related to each other. Due to the widely differing numbers of the involved clans, the banner armies were accordingly smaller or bigger: The yellow banner army, led by Zhang himself, drew its forces from 18 villages; the white banner army of Kung Teh from 13; the red banner army of Hou Shih-wei from 12; the blue banner army of Han Lao-wan from just six; and the black banner army of Su T'ien-fu from one hundred villages.^[29] Though Zhang tried to impose more order and coordination upon the alliance, he enjoyed only limited success in this regard.^[30] Internal differences caused the alliance to quickly fall apart, and by 1858 it was effectively dissolved.^[31]

In early 1856, the Qing government sent the Mongol General Senggelinqin, who had recently crushed a large Taiping army, to defeat the Nian. Senggelinquin's army captured several fortified cities and destroyed most of the Nian infantry, and killed Zhang Lexing himself in an ambush in 1863. However, in late 1864, the Nian movement survived as skilled Taiping commanders Lai Wenguang (賴文光) (1827–1868) and Fan Ruzeng (1840–1867) arrived to take control of the Nian forces, and the bulk of the Nian cavalry remained intact. Senggelinquin's infantry-based army could not stop the fast moving cavalry from devastating the countryside and launching surprise attacks on Imperial troops.

In late 1865, Senggelinquin and his bodyguards were ambushed by Nian troops and killed, in the Battle of Goulawjai, depriving the government of its best military commander. The Qing regime sent General Zeng Guofan (曾国藩) to take command of Imperial forces protecting the capital Beijing, and provided him with modern artillery and weapons, purchased from the Europeans at exorbitant prices. Zeng's army set about building canals and trenches to hem in the Nian cavalry, an effective but slow and expensive method. General Zeng was relieved of command after Nian infantry broke through one of his defense lines, and he was replaced by Generals Li Hongzhang and Zuo Zongtang equipped with more crushingly expensive European artillery and firearms.^{[citation needed]}

In late 1866, the remaining Nian forces split into two, with the Eastern Army, under command of Lai Wenguang, stationed in central China whilst the Western Army advanced on Beijing. The Western Army, commanded by Zhang Zongyu, Zhang Lexing's brother's son, was defeated southwest of Beijing by Qing troops, leaving large swathes of Nian territory exposed to a Qing counter-attack. By late 1867, Li Hongzhang's and Zuo Zongtang's troops had recaptured most Nian territory, and in early 1868, the remnants were crushed by the combined forces of the government's troops and the Ever Victorious Army.

Military Equipment

The Nian rebels were equipped with guns (including modern Western guns), muskets, and a significant quantity of cannons up to 5000 pounds in weight.^[32]

Assessment

The Nian rebellion failed to topple the Qing dynasty largely because it failed to make alliances with other rebels, especially the Taiping movement. The Nian only symbolically supported Taiping efforts by accepting the Taiping king's "appointments", but refusing to follow his orders. Had the Nian and Taipings joined forces, the Qing government would have been faced with a formidable threat, in spite of its alliances with European powers.

Despite the Nians' failure to seize power, the events of the rebellion dealt a severe blow to the Qing dynasty. The environmental disasters of 1851 and 1855 devastated the richest provinces of China, depriving the Qing regime of tax income and trade duties. The endless fighting between Nian troops and Qing forces, who made widespread use of scorched earth tactics, ruined the countryside and resulted in countless deaths. Although the Nian rebellion was smaller than that of the Taiping, it severely drained government finances, devastated the richest areas of China, and left China's economy in a very precarious state. In the long term, the Nian rebellion was to become one of the major factors in the collapse of Qing China.

References

Citations

^ Perry (1980), pp. 128–130, 140–145.
^ Perry (1980), p. 121.
^ ^a ^b Perry (1980), pp. 145, 146.
^ ^a ^b Perry (1980), pp. 120, 121.
^ ^a ^b ^c Perry (1980), p. 150.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Jowett (2013), p. 11.
^ 陳華. 捻亂之研究 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). 國立臺灣大學出版中心. p. 8. OCLC 19479110.
^ Billingsley, Phil. Bandits in Republican China.
^ Pamela Kyle Crossley, The Wobbling Pivot: China Since 1800 108 (2010)
^ Perry, Elizabeth J. (15 August 2016). "Worshipers and Warriors". Modern China. 2 (1): 4–22. doi:10.1177/009770047600200102. JSTOR 188811.
^ Hudson, Valerie M., Andrea Den Boer. "A Surplus of Men, A Deficit of Peace: Security and Sex Ratios in Asia's Largest States". Archived from the original on September 27, 2007. Retrieved 2008-06-22. {{cite web}}: Unknown parameter |deadurl= ignored (|url-status= suggested) (help)CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
^ Hutton, Will (2007-03-24). "Shortage of women leaves surplus of disaffected men". New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 2008-06-22.
^ Perry (1980), pp. 147–149.
^ Pamela Kyle Crossley, The Wobbling Pivot: China Since 1800 108 (2010)
^ ^a ^b ^c Perry (1980), p. 148.
^ Perry (1980), pp. 147, 148.
^ Chesneaux, Jean. Peasant Revolts in China, 1840–1949 p. 33 (C. A. Curwen trans. 1973)
^ Perry (1980), pp. 150, 151.
^ Siang-tseh Chiang, The Nien Rebellion p. viii (1954)
^ Siang-tseh Chiang, The Nien Rebellion p. viii-ix (1954)
^ Siang-tseh Chiang, The Nien Rebellion p. ix (1954)
^ Pamela Kyle Crossley, The Wobbling Pivot: China Since 1800 108 (2010)
^ Pamela Kyle Crossley, The Wobbling Pivot: China Since 1800 108 (2010)
^ Pamela Kyle Crossley, The Wobbling Pivot: China Since 1800 108-09 (2010)
^ Perry (1980), pp. 128–132.
^ Michael Dillon (15 September 2012). China: A Modern History. I.B.Tauris. pp. 85–. ISBN 978-1-78076-381-1.
^ Stewart Lone (January 2007). Daily Lives of Civilians in Wartime Asia: From the Taiping Rebellion to the Vietnam War. Greenwood Publishing Group. pp. 21–. ISBN 978-0-313-33684-3.
^ Jonathan D. Spence (1991). The Search for Modern China. Norton. pp. 185–. ISBN 978-0-393-30780-1.
^ Perry (1980), p. 131.
^ Perry (1980), pp. 130, 131.
^ Perry (1980), pp. 140–145.
^ Elleman, Bruce A. (2005). Modern Chinese Warfare, 1795-1989. Routledge. p. 61. ISBN 1134610092.

Sources

Jowett, Philip S. (2013). China’s Wars: Rousing the Dragon 1894-1949. Oxford: Osprey Publishing. ISBN 978-1782004073. {{cite book}}: Invalid |ref=harv (help)
Perry, Elizabeth J. (1980). Rebels and Revolutionaries in North China, 1845-1945. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. {{cite book}}: Invalid |ref=harv (help)

@@ Line 61: / Line 61: @@
 In 1851, the Nian began raiding the grain stores and silver caches of villages.<ref>Pamela Kyle Crossley, The Wobbling Pivot: China Since 1800 108 (2010)</ref> Upon the seizure of [[Nanjing]] by the [[Taiping Heavenly Kingdom]], some Nian leaders sought an alliance with the [[Taiping_Rebellion|Taiping]].<ref>Pamela Kyle Crossley, The Wobbling Pivot: China Since 1800 108 (2010)</ref> While [[Hong Xiuquan]] bestowed titles upon the Nian leaders and the Nian and the Taiping occasionally cooperated, full coordination between the two rebellions was never achieved.<ref>Pamela Kyle Crossley, The Wobbling Pivot: China Since 1800 108-09 (2010)</ref> Cases in which Nian armies submitted or even fully joined the Taipings remained rare,{{sfnp|Perry|1980|pp=120, 121}} as most remained bandit armies that were only interested in imminent profit and survival.{{sfnp|Perry|1980|p=148}}
-In 1855, [[Zhang_Lexing|Zhang Lexing]] took direct action by launching attacks against government troops in central China. By the summer, the fast-moving Nian [[cavalry]] and equipped with purchased modern firearms from foreigners, had cut the lines of communication between [[Beijing]] and the government armies fighting the [[Taiping_Rebellion|Taiping]] rebels in the south. Qing forces were badly overstretched as rebellions broke out across China, allowing the Nian armies to conquer large tracts of land and gain control over economically vital areas. The Nian fortified their captured cities and used them as bases to launch cavalry attacks against Qing troops in the countryside, prompting local towns to fortify themselves against Nian raiding parties. This resulted in constant fighting which devastated the previously rich provinces of [[Jiangsu]] and [[Hunan]].
+In 1855, [[Zhang_Lexing|Zhang Lexing]] took direct action by launching attacks against government troops in central China. By the summer, the fast-moving Nian [[cavalry]] and equipped with modern firearms purchased from foreigners, had cut the lines of communication between [[Beijing]] and the government armies fighting the [[Taiping_Rebellion|Taiping]] rebels in the south. Qing forces were badly overstretched as rebellions broke out across China, allowing the Nian armies to conquer large tracts of land and gain control over economically vital areas. The Nian fortified their captured cities and used them as bases to launch cavalry attacks against Qing troops in the countryside, prompting local towns to fortify themselves against Nian raiding parties. This resulted in constant fighting which devastated the previously rich provinces of [[Jiangsu]] and [[Hunan]].
 In 1856, several Nian bands formed an alliance led by Zhang Lexing, organizing themselves into a loose confederation of five armies. Each army was identified by a colored banner, operated largely autonomous, and recruited mostly people belonging to a single clan.{{sfnp|Perry|1980|pp=128–132}}<ref name="Dillon2012">{{cite book|author=Michael Dillon|title=China: A Modern History|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=4aAk2rduE9wC&pg=PA85&lpg=PA85&dq=nian+five+banner&source=bl&ots=gI_4_q1Rb3&sig=qCqoHJDlSW9kOS88t4eNHys8sQU&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjXxfmR0eXNAhVDkx4KHTG9CCMQ6AEILTAC#v=onepage&q=nian%20five%20banner&f=false|date=15 September 2012|publisher=I.B.Tauris|isbn=978-1-78076-381-1|pages=85–}}</ref><ref name="Lone2007">{{cite book|author=Stewart Lone|title=Daily Lives of Civilians in Wartime Asia: From the Taiping Rebellion to the Vietnam War|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=qmSnTIAPnoUC&pg=PA21&lpg=PA21&dq=nian+five+banner&source=bl&ots=ezgWu1LFjd&sig=JanUgbUpazh1ymQybGRRhkPnBV0&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjXxfmR0eXNAhVDkx4KHTG9CCMQ6AEIMDAD#v=onepage&q=nian%20five%20banner&f=false|date=January 2007|publisher=Greenwood Publishing Group|isbn=978-0-313-33684-3|pages=21–}}</ref><ref name="Spence1991">{{cite book|author=Jonathan D. Spence|title=The Search for Modern China|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=vI1RRslLNSwC&pg=PA185&lpg=PA185&dq=nian+five+banner&source=bl&ots=pxQ5KlJmba&sig=wTAk44NetHVI20NSyhArKj1yi4Q&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjXxfmR0eXNAhVDkx4KHTG9CCMQ6AEIOTAF#v=onepage&q=nian%20five%20banner&f=false|year=1991|publisher=Norton|isbn=978-0-393-30780-1|pages=185–}}</ref> As result, each banner army had a core area which consisted of a number of villages whose inhabitants were related to each other. Due to the widely differing numbers of the involved clans, the banner armies were accordingly smaller or bigger: The yellow banner army, led by Zhang himself, drew its forces from 18 villages; the white banner army of Kung Teh from 13; the red banner army of Hou Shih-wei from 12; the blue banner army of Han Lao-wan from just six; and the black banner army of Su T'ien-fu from one hundred villages.{{sfnp|Perry|1980|p=131}} Though Zhang tried to impose more order and coordination upon the alliance, he enjoyed only limited success in this regard.{{sfnp|Perry|1980|pp=130, 131}} Internal differences caused the alliance to quickly fall apart, and by 1858 it was effectively dissolved.{{sfnp|Perry|1980|pp=140–145}}