ANALISIS DE ESTABILIDAD POR EL METODO ORDINARIO O FELL

DATOS
Tipo de presa: Homogénea
Peso específico saturado: gsat =
Peso específico natural o seco: gnat =
Angulo de fricción interna del material: f =
Cohesión: c =

1. ANALISIS CON EMBALSE LLENO AGUAS ABAJO

CALCULO DEL FACTOR DE SEGURIDAD F

a h' h" h P α T
Dovela
(m) (m) (m) (m) (ton/m) (°) (ton/m)
1 3.50 0.85 2.71 3.56 27.06 57.86 22.91
2 3.50 5.08 4.83 9.91 78.17 49.78 59.69
3 3.50 8.10 6.91 15.01 118.83 42.92 80.92
 4 3.50 10.43 9.00 19.43 153.76 36.76 92.02
5 3.50 12.11 9.70 21.81 173.02 31.07 89.29
6 3.50 13.27 8.82 22.09 176.30 25.71 76.48
7 3.50 14.07 6.95 21.02 169.27 20.58 59.50
8 3.50 14.47 6.83 21.30 171.75 15.61 46.22
9 3.50 14.49 5.88 20.37 164.93 10.77 30.82
10 3.50 14.18 4.93 19.11 155.35 6.01 16.27
11 3.50 13.54 4.03 17.57 143.36 1.28 3.20
12 3.50 12.56 3.17 15.73 128.80 -3.43 -7.71
13 3.50 11.25 2.35 13.60 111.77 -8.17 -15.88
14 3.50 9.56 1.60 11.16 92.06 -12.97 -20.66
15 3.50 7.51 0.90 8.41 69.70 -17.86 -21.38
16 3.50 5.03 0.29 5.32 44.38 -22.89 -17.26
17 3.50 1.86 0.18 2.04 16.95 -28.12 -7.99

2. ANALISIS CON EMBALSE LLENO AGUAS ARRIBA

 CALCULO DEL FACTOR DE SEGURIDAD F
a h' h" h P α T
Dovela
(m) (m) (m) (m) (ton/m) (°) (ton/m)
1 3.50 1.02 0.00 1.02 8.54 -30.28 -4.31
2 3.50 5.42 0.00 5.42 45.53 -24.91 -19.18
3 3.50 8.56 0.00 8.56 71.90 -19.75 -24.30
4 3.50 11.30 0.00 11.30 94.92 -14.77 -24.20
5 3.50 13.67 0.00 13.67 114.83 -9.89 -19.72
6 3.50 15.71 0.00 15.71 131.96 -5.09 -11.71
7 3.50 17.43 0.00 17.43 146.41 -5.32 -13.58
8 3.50 18.82 0.00 18.82 158.09 4.44 12.24
9 3.50 19.90 0.00 19.90 167.16 9.24 26.84
10 3.50 20.60 0.00 20.60 173.04 14.10 42.16
11 3.50 18.55 2.48 21.03 174.05 19.07 56.87
12 3.50 16.33 4.71 21.04 171.79 24.19 70.39
13 3.50 13.67 6.95 20.62 165.91 29.54 81.80
14 3.50 10.48 9.08 19.56 154.77 35.18 89.17
15 3.50 6.70 9.70 16.40 127.58 41.26 84.13
16 3.50 2.09 8.57 10.66 80.55 47.97 59.83
17 3.50 0.00 3.79 3.79 27.86 55.76 23.03

3. ANALISIS CON EMBALSE VACIO AGUAS ABAJO

 CALCULO DEL FACTOR DE SEGURIDAD F
a h' h" h P α T
Dovela
(m) (m) (m) (m) (ton/m) (°) (ton/m)
1 3.50 0.85 2.71 3.56 26.17 57.86 22.16
2 3.50 5.08 4.83 9.91 72.84 49.78 55.62
3 3.50 8.10 6.91 15.01 110.32 42.92 75.13
4 3.50 10.43 9.00 19.43 142.81 36.76 85.47
5 3.50 12.11 9.70 21.81 160.30 31.07 82.73
6 3.50 13.27 8.82 22.09 162.36 25.71 70.44
7 3.50 14.07 6.95 21.02 154.50 20.58 54.31
8 3.50 14.47 6.83 21.30 156.56 15.61 42.13
9 3.50 14.49 5.88 20.37 149.72 10.77 27.98
10 3.50 14.18 4.93 19.11 140.46 6.01 14.71
11 3.50 13.54 4.03 17.57 129.14 1.28 2.88
12 3.50 12.56 3.17 15.73 115.62 -3.43 -6.92
13 3.50 11.25 2.35 13.60 99.96 -8.17 -14.21
14 3.50 9.56 1.60 11.16 82.03 -12.97 -18.41
15 3.50 7.51 0.90 8.41 61.81 -17.86 -18.96
16 3.50 5.03 0.29 5.32 39.10 -22.89 -15.21
17 3.50 1.86 0.18 2.04 14.99 -28.12 -7.07
4. ANALISIS CON EMBALSE VACIO AGUAS ARRIBA

CALCULO DEL FACTOR DE SEGURIDAD F

a h' h" h P α T
Dovela
(m) (m) (m) (m) (ton/m) (°) (ton/m)
1 3.50 1.02 0.00 1.02 7.47 -30.28 -3.77
2 3.50 5.42 0.00 5.42 39.84 -24.91 -16.78
3 3.50 8.56 0.00 8.56 62.92 -19.75 -21.26
4 3.50 11.30 0.00 11.30 83.06 -14.77 -21.17
5 3.50 13.67 0.00 13.67 100.47 -9.89 -17.26
6 3.50 15.71 0.00 15.71 115.47 -5.09 -10.24
7 3.50 17.43 0.00 17.43 128.11 -5.32 -11.88
8 3.50 18.82 0.00 18.82 138.33 4.44 10.71
9 3.50 19.90 0.00 19.90 146.27 9.24 23.49
10 3.50 20.60 0.00 20.60 151.41 14.10 36.89
11 3.50 18.55 2.48 21.03 154.57 19.07 50.50
12 3.50 16.33 4.71 21.04 154.64 24.19 63.37
13 3.50 13.67 6.95 20.62 151.56 29.54 74.72
14 3.50 10.48 9.08 19.56 143.77 35.18 82.83
15 3.50 6.70 9.70 16.40 120.54 41.26 79.49
16 3.50 2.09 8.57 10.66 78.35 47.97 58.20
17 3.50 0.00 3.79 3.79 27.86 55.76 23.03
ORDINARIO O FELLENIUS (SUECO)

2.4 ton/m3
2.1 ton/m3
30 °
0.5 ton/m2

R DE SEGURIDAD F SD
N l u U (N - U)tanf C= c*l T=
(ton/m) (m) (ton/m ) (ton/m)
2
(ton/m) (ton/m) P*senα
14.39 6.58 0.45 2.98 6.59 3.29 22.91
50.48 5.42 3.28 17.78 18.88 2.71 59.69
87.02 4.78 5.93 28.35 33.87 2.39 80.92
 123.19 4.37 8.36 36.51 50.05 2.18 92.02
148.20 4.09 10.37 42.39 61.09 2.04 89.29
158.84 3.88 11.96 46.45 64.89 1.94 76.48
158.47 3.74 13.17 49.25 63.06 1.87 59.50
165.41 3.63 13.94 50.65 66.26 1.82 46.22
162.03 3.56 14.23 50.72 64.27 1.78 30.82
154.49 3.52 14.10 49.63 60.54 1.76 16.27
143.32 3.50 13.54 47.39 55.39 1.75 3.20
128.57 3.51 12.54 43.96 48.85 1.75 -7.71
110.64 3.54 11.14 39.38 41.14 1.77 -15.88
89.72 3.59 9.32 33.46 32.48 1.80 -20.66
66.34 3.68 7.15 26.29 23.13 1.84 -21.38
40.89 3.80 4.63 17.61 13.44 1.90 -17.26
14.95 3.97 1.64 6.51 4.87 1.98 -7.99
suma 708.80 34.58 486.44
F:S. = 1.53

A
R DE SEGURIDAD F SD
N l u U (N - U)tanf C= c*l T=
(ton/m) (m) (ton/m ) (ton/m)
2
(ton/m) (ton/m) P*senα
7.38 4.05 0.88 3.56 2.20 2.03 -4.31
41.29 3.86 4.92 18.97 12.89 1.93 -19.18
67.67 3.72 8.06 29.96 21.77 1.86 -24.30
91.78 3.62 10.93 39.55 30.16 1.81 -24.20
113.12 3.55 13.47 47.85 37.69 1.78 -19.72
131.44 3.51 15.65 54.99 44.14 1.76 -11.71
145.78 3.52 17.35 61.01 48.95 1.76 -13.58
157.61 3.51 18.76 65.87 52.97 1.76 12.24
164.99 3.55 19.64 69.65 55.05 1.77 26.84
167.83 3.61 19.98 72.10 55.27 1.80 42.16
164.50 3.70 17.53 64.93 57.49 1.85 56.87
156.71 3.84 14.90 57.16 57.48 1.92 70.39
144.34 4.02 11.89 47.85 55.71 2.01 81.80
126.50 4.28 8.57 36.68 51.86 2.14 89.17
95.90 4.66 5.04 23.45 41.83 2.33 84.13
53.93 5.23 1.40 7.32 26.91 2.61 59.83
15.67 6.22 0.00 0.00 9.05 3.11 23.03
suma 661.41 34.22 429.47
F:S. = 1.62
R DE SEGURIDAD F SD
N l u U (N - U)tanf C= c*l T=
(ton/m) (m) (ton/m2) (ton/m) (ton/m) (ton/m) P*senα
13.92 6.58 0.45 2.98 6.32 3.29 22.16
47.03 5.42 3.28 17.78 16.89 2.71 55.62
80.79 4.78 5.93 28.35 30.28 2.39 75.13
114.41 4.37 8.36 36.51 44.98 2.18 85.47
137.31 4.09 10.37 42.39 54.80 2.04 82.73
146.29 3.88 11.96 46.45 57.64 1.94 70.44
144.64 3.74 13.17 49.25 55.07 1.87 54.31
150.78 3.63 13.94 50.65 57.81 1.82 42.13
147.08 3.56 14.23 50.72 55.64 1.78 27.98
139.69 3.52 14.10 49.63 51.99 1.76 14.71
129.11 3.50 13.54 47.39 47.18 1.75 2.88
115.41 3.51 12.54 43.96 41.25 1.75 -6.92
98.95 3.54 11.14 39.38 34.39 1.77 -14.21
79.93 3.59 9.32 33.46 26.83 1.80 -18.41
58.83 3.68 7.15 26.29 18.79 1.84 -18.96
36.02 3.80 4.63 17.61 10.63 1.90 -15.21
13.22 3.97 1.64 6.51 3.88 1.98 -7.07
suma 614.39 34.58 452.77
F:S. = 1.43
R DE SEGURIDAD F SD
N l u U (N - U)tanf C= c*l T=
(ton/m) (m) (ton/m ) (ton/m)
2
(ton/m) (ton/m) P*senα
6.46 4.05 0.88 3.56 1.67 2.03 -3.77
36.13 3.86 4.92 18.97 9.91 1.93 -16.78
59.22 3.72 8.06 29.96 16.89 1.86 -21.26
80.31 3.62 10.93 39.55 23.53 1.81 -21.17
98.98 3.55 13.47 47.85 29.52 1.78 -17.26
115.01 3.51 15.65 54.99 34.66 1.76 -10.24
127.56 3.52 17.35 61.01 38.42 1.76 -11.88
137.91 3.51 18.76 65.87 41.59 1.76 10.71
144.37 3.55 19.64 69.65 43.14 1.77 23.49
146.85 3.61 19.98 72.10 43.16 1.80 36.89
146.09 3.70 17.53 64.93 46.86 1.85 50.50
141.06 3.84 14.90 57.16 48.45 1.92 63.37
131.86 4.02 11.89 47.85 48.50 2.01 74.72
117.51 4.28 8.57 36.68 46.67 2.14 82.83
90.61 4.66 5.04 23.45 38.78 2.33 79.49
52.46 5.23 1.40 7.32 26.06 2.61 58.20
15.67 6.22 0.00 0.00 9.05 3.11 23.03
suma 546.86 34.22 400.86
F:S. = 1.45
SEGURA
SEGURA
FALLA
FALLA
SOLUCION

DATOS
Peso específico saturado: gsat =
Peso específico natural o seco: gnat =
Angulo de fricción interna del material: f =
Cohesión: c =

1. ANALISIS CON EMBALSE LLENO AGUAS ABAJO

CALCULO DEL FACTOR DE SEGURIDAD F

a h' h" h P α T
Dovela
(m) (m) (m) (m) (ton/m) (°) (ton/m)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Σ
 FSD =
2. ANALISIS CON EMBALSE LLENO AGUAS ARRIBA

CALCULO DEL FACTOR DE SEGURIDAD F

a h' h" h P α T
Dovela
(m) (m) (m) (m) (ton/m) (°) (ton/m)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Σ

FSD =
3. ANALISIS CON EMBALSE VACIO AGUAS ABAJO
 CALCULO DEL FACTOR DE SEGURIDAD F
a h' h" h P α T
Dovela
(m) (m) (m) (m) (ton/m) (°) (ton/m)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Σ

FSD =
4. ANALISIS CON EMBALSE VACIO AGUAS ARRIBA

CALCULO DEL FACTOR DE SEGURIDAD F

a h' h" h P α T
Dovela
(m) (m) (m) (m) (ton/m) (°) (ton/m)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Σ

FSD =
 2.4 ton/m3
2.1 ton/m3
30.0 °
0.5 ton/m2

R DE SEGURIDAD F SD
N l u U (N - U)tanf
(ton/m) (m) (ton/m2) (ton/m) (ton/m)

Σ Σ
R DE SEGURIDAD F SD
N l u U (N - U)tanf
(ton/m) (m) (ton/m2) (ton/m) (ton/m)

Σ Σ
R DE SEGURIDAD F SD
N l u U (N - U)tanf
(ton/m) (m) (ton/m2) (ton/m) (ton/m)

Σ Σ

R DE SEGURIDAD F SD
N l u U (N - U)tanf
(ton/m) (m) (ton/m2) (ton/m) (ton/m)
Σ Σ