1. What is a circular supply chain and why is it important for the environment?
2. What are the different types of circular supply chains and how do they work?
3. How to design, implement and evaluate circular supply chain practices?
4. What are some successful cases of circular supply chains in various industries and regions?
5. What are the environmental, social and economic impacts of circular supply chains?
One of the most pressing challenges of the 21st century is how to manage the increasing demand for resources while minimizing the environmental impact of production and consumption. A circular supply chain (CSC) is a model that aims to achieve this goal by transforming the linear flow of materials and energy into a closed-loop system that reduces waste, emissions, and resource depletion. A CSC is based on the principles of the circular economy, which advocates for designing out waste and pollution, keeping products and materials in use, and regenerating natural systems. By applying these principles to the logistics sector, a CSC can offer significant benefits for the environment, such as:
- reducing greenhouse gas emissions. A CSC can lower the carbon footprint of logistics activities by optimizing transport routes, modes, and loads, using renewable energy sources, and implementing reverse logistics for product recovery and recycling. For example, a study by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation estimated that a CSC could reduce CO2 emissions from the European mobility sector by 79% by 2030 compared to 2012 levels.
- Saving natural resources. A CSC can conserve the finite and scarce resources that are used to produce goods and services by extending the lifespan of products, components, and materials, reusing and repairing them, and recovering and recycling them into new products or raw materials. For example, a report by the world Economic forum found that a CSC could save 100 million tonnes of material inputs in the consumer goods sector by 2025, equivalent to $1.1 trillion in annual material cost savings.
- Preventing waste generation and pollution. A CSC can prevent the accumulation of waste and pollution in landfills, oceans, and the atmosphere by designing products that are durable, modular, and easy to disassemble, using biodegradable or recyclable materials, and adopting eco-friendly packaging and labeling. For example, a case study by the World Business Council for Sustainable Development showed that a CSC could eliminate 90% of plastic packaging waste by 2025, avoiding 80 million tonnes of plastic leakage into the environment.
One of the main objectives of the circular economy is to reduce waste and resource consumption by designing products and processes that can be reused, repaired, remanufactured, or recycled. This requires a shift from the traditional linear supply chain model, where materials flow from extraction to production to consumption to disposal, to a circular supply chain model, where materials flow in loops and cycles that preserve their value and functionality. There are different types of circular supply chain models, depending on the nature and source of the materials, the actors and stakeholders involved, and the strategies and technologies applied. Some of the common types of circular supply chain models are:
- Closed-loop supply chain: This is a supply chain model where the end-of-life products or components are collected from the customers and returned to the original manufacturer for reuse, repair, remanufacturing, or recycling. This creates a closed loop of material flows within the same supply chain, reducing the need for new materials and minimizing waste. An example of a closed-loop supply chain is Dell's asset Resale and Recycling program, where customers can return their old computers and accessories to Dell for refurbishment or recycling, and receive a credit or a donation to a charity of their choice.
- Reverse logistics: This is a supply chain model where the end-of-life products or components are collected from the customers and transferred to a third-party service provider for reuse, repair, remanufacturing, or recycling. This creates a reverse flow of material from the consumption stage to the production stage, but involves different actors and stakeholders than the original supply chain. An example of reverse logistics is Apple's Trade In program, where customers can trade in their old devices for a credit or a gift card, and Apple sends the devices to a partner company for recycling or refurbishment.
- Industrial symbiosis: This is a supply chain model where the waste or by-products of one industry or company are used as inputs or resources for another industry or company. This creates a network of material exchanges and collaborations among different industries or companies, reducing waste and resource consumption. An example of industrial symbiosis is the Kalundborg Eco-Industrial Park in Denmark, where various companies share water, energy, and materials, such as using the excess heat from a power plant to warm up a fish farm, or using the gypsum from a coal-fired plant to produce plasterboards.
- Product-service system: This is a supply chain model where the customers pay for the use or performance of a product, rather than the ownership or possession of the product. This creates a service-oriented relationship between the provider and the customer, where the provider retains the ownership and responsibility of the product, and the customer benefits from the functionality and convenience of the product. This encourages the provider to design products that are durable, efficient, and easy to maintain, and to optimize the use and reuse of the products. An example of a product-service system is Zipcar, a car-sharing service that allows customers to rent cars by the hour or the day, and provides insurance, gas, and maintenance.
One of the main challenges of implementing circular supply chain practices is to design them in a way that aligns with the principles of the circular economy and the goals of resource efficiency. A circular supply chain is not simply a linear supply chain with some recycling or reuse activities added at the end. Rather, it is a system that aims to minimize waste, emissions, and resource consumption throughout the entire life cycle of a product or service, from production to consumption to recovery. To achieve this, circular supply chain strategies need to consider the following aspects:
- The product design: The product should be designed with circularity in mind, meaning that it should be durable, repairable, modular, upgradable, and easy to disassemble and recycle. The product should also use renewable, recycled, or biodegradable materials whenever possible, and avoid hazardous substances that could harm the environment or human health. For example, a circular product design could be a smartphone that has a modular structure, allowing users to replace or upgrade individual components instead of buying a new device. The smartphone could also use recycled metals and plastics, and have a standardized interface for connecting to different accessories and chargers.
- The business model: The business model should shift from a traditional ownership-based model to a service-based or sharing-based model, where the value of the product is maintained or increased over time, and the customer pays for the use or access rather than the ownership of the product. The business model should also incentivize the customer to return the product after use, or to participate in maintenance, repair, or refurbishment activities. For example, a circular business model could be a car-sharing service that offers customers access to a fleet of electric vehicles that are regularly maintained and upgraded by the service provider. The customers could pay per use or per subscription, and the service provider could recover and recycle the vehicles at the end of their life cycle.
- The supply chain network: The supply chain network should be optimized to reduce the distance and transportation costs between the different stages of the product life cycle, and to facilitate the flow of information, materials, and energy among the supply chain actors. The supply chain network should also involve multiple stakeholders, such as suppliers, manufacturers, distributors, retailers, customers, and waste management companies, who collaborate and coordinate their actions to achieve circular outcomes. For example, a circular supply chain network could be a local food system that connects farmers, processors, retailers, and consumers within a geographic area, and uses digital platforms and smart packaging to track and trace the quality and origin of the food products. The food system could also use renewable energy sources, such as solar or wind power, to operate the processing and distribution facilities, and compost or anaerobically digest the organic waste generated by the system.
In my job, as head of the International Trade Centre, I have the privilege to meet entrepreneurs from across the world almost on a daily basis.
One of the main challenges of implementing circular supply chains is to design products and processes that minimize waste, maximize resource efficiency, and enable reuse and recycling. However, some companies have successfully adopted circular supply chain practices in various industries and regions, demonstrating the benefits of greener logistics. Here are some examples:
- Apple: The technology giant has committed to achieving a net-zero carbon footprint by 2030, and one of its strategies is to use more recycled materials in its products and packaging. For instance, the iPhone 12 uses 100% recycled rare earth elements in its magnets, and the MacBook Air uses 100% recycled aluminum in its enclosure. Apple also operates a trade-in program that allows customers to return their old devices and receive credit for new ones, or donate them to be refurbished or recycled. Apple claims that it recycles 100% of the trade-in devices, and uses robots such as Daisy and Dave to disassemble and recover valuable materials from them.
- H&M: The fashion retailer has set a goal to use only recycled or sustainably sourced materials by 2030, and to become climate positive by 2040. To achieve this, H&M has launched several initiatives to promote circularity in its supply chain, such as the Garment Collecting program, which collects unwanted clothes from any brand and in any condition, and either reuses, remakes, or recycles them. H&M also collaborates with innovators such as Renewcell, a Swedish company that produces a new textile fiber called Circulose from recycled cotton and viscose, and Worn Again Technologies, a UK-based company that develops a chemical recycling process that can separate and extract polyester and cotton from mixed fabric waste.
- IKEA: The furniture giant aims to become a circular business by 2030, meaning that all its products will be designed to be reused, repaired, or recycled, and that it will use only renewable or recycled materials. IKEA has implemented various circular solutions in its operations, such as the Buy Back service, which allows customers to sell back their old IKEA furniture in exchange for store vouchers, and the Circular Hub, which is a dedicated area in its stores where customers can find second-hand, repaired, or refurbished IKEA products at discounted prices. IKEA also works with partners such as RetourMatras, a Dutch company that recycles mattresses into new materials, and Morssinkhof Rymoplast, a European company that converts plastic waste into granules for new products.
One of the main objectives of circular supply chains is to minimize the environmental, social and economic impacts of resource extraction, production, consumption and disposal. By adopting circular principles, such as reducing waste, reusing materials, recycling products, and regenerating natural systems, circular supply chains can contribute to greener logistics and more sustainable development. Some of the impacts of circular supply chains are:
- Environmental impacts: Circular supply chains can reduce greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, water use, land use, and pollution by optimizing the use of resources and minimizing waste generation. For example, a study by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation estimated that circular supply chains in the European Union could reduce CO2 emissions by 48% by 2030 and 83% by 2050 compared to the current linear model. Another example is the case of Dell, which has implemented circular practices such as using recycled plastics and ocean-bound plastics in its packaging and products, saving 2.1 million kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent and 42.5 million liters of water in 2019.
- Social impacts: Circular supply chains can improve the well-being, health, and safety of workers, consumers, and communities by reducing exposure to hazardous substances, creating decent jobs, and enhancing social inclusion and equity. For example, a report by the World Economic Forum and Accenture found that circular supply chains could create 6 million net new jobs by 2030 and lift 100 million people out of poverty. Another example is the case of Patagonia, which has implemented circular practices such as repairing, reselling, and recycling its clothing, extending the lifespan of its products, reducing waste, and supporting local communities and environmental causes.
- Economic impacts: Circular supply chains can increase the efficiency, productivity, and competitiveness of businesses, industries, and economies by reducing costs, increasing revenues, and creating new markets and opportunities. For example, a study by the McKinsey Global Institute estimated that circular supply chains could add $4.5 trillion to global GDP by 2030 and $25 trillion by 2050. Another example is the case of Philips, which has implemented circular practices such as offering lighting as a service, leasing medical equipment, and refurbishing and remanufacturing its products, generating new sources of income, reducing capital expenditure, and enhancing customer loyalty and satisfaction.
The article has explored the concept and benefits of circular supply chains, as well as the challenges and opportunities for their implementation in the logistics sector. Based on the analysis, the following are some of the main takeaways and recommendations for circular supply chain practitioners and policymakers:
- Circular supply chains can enhance resource efficiency, reduce environmental impacts, and create value for businesses and society. By adopting circular principles such as reduce, reuse, recycle, repair, and remanufacture, logistics providers can optimize their operations, lower their costs, and improve their competitiveness and resilience.
- Circular supply chains require a systemic and collaborative approach, involving multiple stakeholders across the value chain. Logistics providers need to align their strategies and objectives with their customers, suppliers, and partners, and foster a culture of innovation and learning. Policymakers need to create an enabling environment for circular supply chains, by providing clear and consistent regulations, incentives, and standards, as well as supporting research and development, education, and awareness.
- Circular supply chains face several barriers and challenges, such as lack of data and information, high upfront investments, technical and operational complexities, and behavioral and institutional resistance. To overcome these obstacles, logistics providers and policymakers need to adopt a holistic and adaptive perspective, and address the technical, economic, social, and environmental aspects of circularity. Some of the possible actions include:
1. Developing and implementing circular supply chain assessment tools and indicators, to measure and monitor the performance and impacts of circular practices, and to identify areas for improvement and innovation.
2. Investing in circular supply chain infrastructure and technologies, such as reverse logistics networks, smart packaging, digital platforms, and advanced recycling and recovery systems, to enable efficient and effective material flows and information exchange.
3. Promoting circular supply chain business models and practices, such as product-as-a-service, sharing and leasing, product life extension, and closed-loop recycling, to generate new revenue streams and customer value, and to reduce waste and emissions.
4. Engaging and empowering circular supply chain stakeholders, such as employees, customers, suppliers, and communities, to raise awareness and understanding of circular principles, and to encourage participation and collaboration in circular initiatives.
By implementing these recommendations, circular supply chain practitioners and policymakers can contribute to the transition towards a circular economy and a greener logistics sector, and to the achievement of the sustainable development goals.
Read Other Blogs