Cost: How to Calculate the Cost of Employee Turnover

1. What is employee turnover and why does it matter?

One of the most important metrics that every business should track is employee turnover. This refers to the rate at which employees leave the organization, either voluntarily or involuntarily, within a given period of time. Employee turnover can have significant impacts on the performance, productivity, and profitability of a business, as well as its reputation and culture. Therefore, understanding the causes and consequences of employee turnover, and how to measure and reduce it, is essential for any business leader.

There are several reasons why employee turnover matters for a business, such as:

- Cost: Replacing an employee can be expensive, as it involves costs such as recruitment, training, onboarding, severance, and lost productivity. According to a study by the Society for human Resource management (SHRM), the average cost of hiring a new employee is $4,129, and the average time to fill a position is 42 days. Moreover, the cost of replacing an employee can vary depending on their level, role, and industry. For example, a 2012 study by the Center for American Progress estimated that the cost of replacing a high-skilled employee can be up to 213% of their annual salary.

- Quality: Losing an employee can also affect the quality of work and service that the business provides, as it may result in a loss of skills, knowledge, experience, and customer relationships. This can lead to lower customer satisfaction, loyalty, and retention, as well as increased errors, complaints, and rework. For instance, a 2015 study by Cornell University found that a 1% increase in employee turnover can lead to a 0.5% decrease in customer satisfaction.

- Morale: Employee turnover can also have a negative impact on the morale and engagement of the remaining employees, as it may create uncertainty, stress, workload, and resentment. This can in turn affect their performance, motivation, and commitment, as well as their likelihood of leaving the organization themselves. For example, a 2014 study by Glassdoor found that a 10% increase in employee turnover can increase the probability of an employee leaving by 2.9%.

Attracting investors is not an easy mission

FasterCapital's internal network of investors works with you on improving your pitching materials and approaching investors the right way!

Join us!

2. Recruitment, hiring, training, and severance expenses

One of the most obvious and measurable impacts of employee turnover is the cost associated with replacing the departing workers. These costs can be divided into four main categories: recruitment, hiring, training, and severance. Each of these categories involves different types of expenses and activities that affect the organization's bottom line and productivity. Let's take a closer look at each of these categories and how they contribute to the total cost of employee turnover.

- Recruitment costs are the expenses related to finding and attracting potential candidates for the vacant positions. These costs may include advertising fees, job board subscriptions, referral bonuses, travel expenses, screening tools, and recruiter fees. Depending on the level and complexity of the position, the recruitment process can take from a few weeks to several months, during which the organization may incur additional costs due to lost productivity and reduced output. For example, if a sales manager leaves the company, the sales team may not be able to meet their targets and generate revenue until a new manager is hired and onboarded.

- Hiring costs are the expenses related to selecting and hiring the best candidates from the pool of applicants. These costs may include background checks, drug tests, assessments, interviews, relocation expenses, signing bonuses, and administrative fees. The hiring process can also be time-consuming and labor-intensive, requiring the involvement of multiple stakeholders such as hiring managers, human resources, and senior executives. For example, if a software engineer leaves the company, the hiring team may have to conduct several rounds of technical interviews and coding tests to assess the skills and fit of the candidates, as well as negotiate the salary and benefits package.

- Training costs are the expenses related to providing the necessary knowledge, skills, and tools for the new hires to perform their roles effectively. These costs may include orientation programs, on-the-job training, coaching, mentoring, e-learning courses, certifications, and equipment. The training process can also affect the productivity and quality of work of both the new hires and their trainers, as they may need to spend time away from their core tasks and adjust to the new work environment and expectations. For example, if a customer service representative leaves the company, the new hire may have to undergo several weeks of training to learn the company's policies, procedures, systems, and products, as well as receive feedback and guidance from their supervisor and peers.

- Severance costs are the expenses related to terminating the employment relationship with the departing workers. These costs may include severance pay, unemployment benefits, outplacement services, legal fees, and exit interviews. The severance process can also have emotional and psychological impacts on both the departing workers and the remaining employees, as they may experience stress, anxiety, anger, sadness, or guilt. For example, if a marketing manager leaves the company, the organization may have to pay them a lump sum or a series of payments based on their length of service, as well as provide them with career counseling and job search assistance.

Often times I have been asked about the attributes for success, and I have said that you need two attributes for succeeding as an entrepreneur: one, courage, second, luck.

N. R. Narayana Murthy

3. Lost productivity, reduced morale, knowledge gaps, and customer dissatisfaction

Besides the direct costs of employee turnover, such as recruitment, training, and severance expenses, there are also indirect costs that can have a significant impact on the organization's performance and profitability. These indirect costs are often hidden or overlooked, but they can be measured and reduced with proper strategies and policies. Some of the indirect costs of employee turnover are:

1. Lost productivity: When an employee leaves, the organization loses not only their skills and experience, but also their contribution to the team's output and efficiency. The remaining employees may have to take over the tasks of the departed employee, which can increase their workload and stress levels, and reduce their focus and quality of work. Moreover, the new hire may take some time to reach the optimal level of productivity, depending on their learning curve and adaptation process. For example, according to a study by the Center for American Progress, the average cost of replacing an employee who earns less than $30,000 per year is 16.1% of their annual salary, which includes the lost productivity during the vacancy and the ramp-up time of the new hire.

2. Reduced morale: Employee turnover can also affect the morale and engagement of the remaining employees, especially if the turnover rate is high or the reasons for leaving are negative. Employees may feel insecure, dissatisfied, or demotivated by the frequent changes in their work environment and relationships. They may also lose trust and confidence in the management and the organization's vision and goals. This can lead to lower levels of commitment, loyalty, and performance, as well as higher absenteeism and turnover intentions. For example, a Gallup survey found that 51% of employees who are actively looking for a new job are not engaged at work, and 13% are actively disengaged.

3. Knowledge gaps: Another indirect cost of employee turnover is the loss of knowledge and expertise that the departing employee possessed. This can create gaps in the organization's intellectual capital, which can affect its innovation, competitiveness, and customer service. The departing employee may have had valuable insights, contacts, or relationships that are difficult to replace or transfer. The organization may also face challenges in retaining and accessing the information and documents that the departing employee created or managed. For example, a study by the Society for Human Resource Management estimated that it can cost up to 213% of a senior executive's salary to replace them, due to the loss of strategic and operational knowledge.

4. Customer dissatisfaction: Finally, employee turnover can also have a negative impact on the organization's customers and stakeholders, who may experience a decline in the quality and consistency of the products or services they receive. The departing employee may have had a strong rapport and trust with the customers, who may feel frustrated or dissatisfied by the change of personnel or the lack of continuity. The new hire may not have the same level of competence, experience, or understanding of the customer's needs and expectations, which can lead to errors, delays, or complaints. For example, a harvard Business review article reported that a 5% increase in customer retention can increase profits by 25% to 95%, depending on the industry and the customer lifetime value.

4. The formula and examples

One of the key factors that influences the cost of employee turnover is the employee turnover rate, which is the percentage of employees who leave an organization within a given period of time. Measuring the employee turnover rate can help employers understand the reasons behind employee attrition, the impact of turnover on organizational performance, and the strategies to reduce turnover and retain talent. Here are some steps to measure the employee turnover rate:

1. Define the time period for measuring turnover. This can be monthly, quarterly, annually, or any other interval that suits the organization's needs and goals. For example, an organization may want to measure the turnover rate for the first quarter of 2024.

2. Identify the number of employees at the start and end of the time period. This can be done by using payroll records, human resource information systems, or other sources of employee data. For example, an organization may have 500 employees at the start of the first quarter and 480 employees at the end of the first quarter.

3. Calculate the number of employees who left the organization during the time period. This can be done by subtracting the number of employees at the end of the time period from the number of employees at the start of the time period. For example, an organization may have 20 employees who left during the first quarter (500 - 480 = 20).

4. Divide the number of employees who left by the average number of employees during the time period. The average number of employees can be obtained by adding the number of employees at the start and end of the time period and dividing by two. For example, an organization may have an average of 490 employees during the first quarter ((500 + 480) / 2 = 490).

5. Multiply the result by 100 to get the percentage. This is the employee turnover rate for the time period. For example, an organization may have a turnover rate of 4.08% for the first quarter (20 / 490 x 100 = 4.08%).

Using this formula, an organization can measure the employee turnover rate for different time periods, departments, roles, or other segments of the workforce. For example, an organization may want to compare the turnover rate of sales staff versus customer service staff, or the turnover rate of new hires versus tenured employees. By doing so, an organization can identify the patterns and trends of employee turnover, and the areas that need improvement or intervention.

Obviously, many people may remember me as the first winner of 'The Apprentice,' but prior to that, I was an entrepreneur. I started my first business when I was in college, and then getting my lucky break was when Donald Trump hired me on.

Bill Rancic

5. The factors and methods

Employee turnover is a significant challenge for many organizations, as it can result in lower productivity, reduced morale, increased recruitment and training costs, and loss of valuable knowledge and skills. Therefore, it is important to understand how to estimate the cost of employee turnover and what factors and methods are involved in the calculation.

There are different ways to estimate the cost of employee turnover, depending on the level of detail and accuracy required. However, most methods involve the following steps:

1. Identify the positions that have experienced turnover and the number of employees who left each position.

2. Calculate the direct costs of turnover, which include the expenses related to hiring, training, and onboarding new employees, as well as the costs of severance, unemployment, and benefits for the departing employees.

3. Calculate the indirect costs of turnover, which include the impacts of lower productivity, quality, and customer satisfaction, as well as the costs of lost knowledge, skills, and relationships.

4. Add the direct and indirect costs of turnover to obtain the total cost of turnover for each position.

5. Divide the total cost of turnover by the number of employees who left each position to obtain the average cost of turnover per employee.

6. Multiply the average cost of turnover per employee by the annual turnover rate to obtain the annual cost of turnover for each position.

7. Sum up the annual costs of turnover for all positions to obtain the total annual cost of turnover for the organization.

For example, suppose a company has 100 employees and experiences a 20% annual turnover rate. The company estimates that the direct costs of turnover are $10,000 per employee and the indirect costs of turnover are $15,000 per employee. The company can use the following formula to estimate the cost of employee turnover:

$$\text{Total annual cost of turnover} = \text{Number of employees} \times \text{Turnover rate} \times (\text{Direct cost per employee} + \text{Indirect cost per employee})$$

$$\text{Total annual cost of turnover} = 100 \times 0.2 \times (10,000 + 15,000)$$

$$\text{Total annual cost of turnover} = 500,000$$

This means that the company spends $500,000 per year on employee turnover, which is equivalent to 25% of its total payroll.

How to reach more users for your product?

FasterCapital's team of sales reps feeds your sales funnel and helps with lead generation by contacting and following up with potential users

Join us!

6. The best practices and strategies

Employee turnover is a costly problem for any organization, as it affects not only the productivity and performance of the remaining staff, but also the recruitment and training expenses of hiring new employees. Therefore, it is essential to implement effective strategies and practices to reduce employee turnover and retain the best talent. Some of the ways to achieve this are:

1. Offer competitive compensation and benefits. Employees are more likely to stay with an organization that pays them fairly and provides them with attractive benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, paid leave, flexible work arrangements, and so on. A compensation and benefits package that matches or exceeds the market rate can also help attract and retain high-quality candidates. For example, a recent study by Glassdoor found that 45% of employees who quit their jobs cited salary as the main reason, and that a 10% increase in base pay could reduce the likelihood of turnover by 1.5%.

2. Provide opportunities for career growth and development. employees want to feel that they are valued and have a future with the organization. They want to learn new skills, take on new challenges, and advance their careers. Therefore, it is important to provide them with regular feedback, recognition, coaching, mentoring, training, and education. It is also beneficial to create clear career paths and promote from within whenever possible. For example, a survey by LinkedIn found that 94% of employees would stay with an organization longer if it invested in their career development, and that lack of career growth was one of the top reasons for leaving a job.

3. foster a positive and supportive work culture. Employees are more likely to stay with an organization that has a strong and positive work culture, where they feel respected, appreciated, and engaged. A positive work culture can be cultivated by promoting trust, communication, collaboration, diversity, inclusion, and wellness among employees. It can also be enhanced by organizing social events, team-building activities, and recognition programs. For example, a study by Gallup found that employees who are highly engaged at work are 59% less likely to look for a job elsewhere, and that engaged employees are more productive, profitable, and loyal than disengaged ones.

4. Hire the right people for the right roles. Employee turnover can be reduced by hiring the right people for the right roles, who fit the organization's vision, values, and culture. Hiring the right people can be achieved by using effective recruitment methods, such as referrals, assessments, interviews, and background checks. Hiring the right people can also be facilitated by having a clear and realistic job description, expectations, and goals. For example, a study by Harvard Business Review found that 80% of employee turnover was due to bad hiring decisions, and that hiring the wrong person could cost up to 2.5 times the person's annual salary.

5. Conduct exit interviews and surveys. Exit interviews and surveys can help identify the reasons why employees leave the organization, and what can be done to improve retention. Exit interviews and surveys can provide valuable insights into the employees' satisfaction, motivation, engagement, and feedback. They can also help uncover any issues or problems that may have caused the employees to quit, such as poor management, low morale, lack of support, or unfair treatment. For example, a study by Work Institute found that 77% of employee turnover could be prevented by addressing the issues that employees raised during exit interviews and surveys.

7. The benefits and incentives

One of the most effective ways to reduce the cost of employee turnover is to retain your existing employees. This means creating a work environment that fosters loyalty, engagement, and satisfaction among your staff. There are many benefits and incentives that you can offer to your employees to achieve this goal. Some of them are:

- Competitive compensation and benefits. Paying your employees fairly and according to the market standards is essential to retain them. You should also provide them with attractive benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, paid leave, and flexible work arrangements. These benefits can help your employees feel valued and secure in their jobs.

- Recognition and rewards. Recognizing and rewarding your employees for their achievements and contributions can boost their morale and motivation. You can use various methods such as verbal praise, public recognition, bonuses, gift cards, or other perks to show your appreciation. For example, you can create a monthly award program to honor the best performers in your team or department.

- career development and growth. Providing your employees with opportunities to learn new skills, take on new challenges, and advance their careers can help them stay engaged and loyal. You can offer them training, mentoring, coaching, feedback, and career paths to help them grow professionally and personally. For example, you can sponsor your employees to attend workshops, seminars, or courses that are relevant to their roles or interests.

- Employee engagement and involvement. Engaging and involving your employees in your organization's vision, mission, values, and goals can help them feel connected and committed. You can communicate with them regularly, solicit their feedback, involve them in decision-making, and encourage them to share their ideas and opinions. For example, you can create a suggestion box, a survey, or a focus group to gather your employees' input on various issues or initiatives.

- Work-life balance and wellness. Supporting your employees' well-being and happiness can help them cope with stress, prevent burnout, and improve their performance. You can promote a healthy work-life balance by respecting your employees' personal time, offering flexible work options, and providing wellness programs. For example, you can offer your employees telecommuting, flextime, or compressed workweek options to suit their preferences and needs. You can also provide them with wellness resources such as fitness classes, counseling services, or health screenings.

8. The key takeaways and recommendations

Employee turnover is a costly phenomenon that affects both the performance and the morale of an organization. Understanding the factors that contribute to turnover and the ways to reduce it can help managers and leaders to retain their valuable human capital and improve their bottom line. In this article, we have discussed how to calculate the cost of employee turnover, and what are some of the direct and indirect costs involved. We have also provided some tips and best practices to lower the turnover rate and increase employee engagement and loyalty. In this final section, we will summarize the key takeaways and recommendations from our analysis.

Some of the main points to remember are:

- Employee turnover is the percentage of employees who leave an organization within a given period of time, either voluntarily or involuntarily.

- The cost of employee turnover can be divided into two categories: direct costs and indirect costs. Direct costs are the expenses associated with hiring, training, and severance of new and departing employees. Indirect costs are the losses in productivity, quality, customer satisfaction, and organizational culture that result from employee turnover.

- The average cost of employee turnover varies depending on the industry, the level of the position, and the skill and experience of the employee. However, a common rule of thumb is that it costs about 33% of an employee's annual salary to replace them.

- To calculate the cost of employee turnover, one can use the following formula:

\text{Cost of turnover} = \text{Number of employees who left} \times \text{Average cost per employee}

- To reduce the cost of employee turnover, one can implement some of the following strategies:

- Hire the right people from the start, using effective recruitment and selection methods, and providing realistic job previews.

- Provide competitive compensation and benefits, and offer opportunities for career growth and development.

- foster a positive and supportive work environment, where employees feel valued, respected, and appreciated.

- Conduct regular performance reviews and feedback sessions, and recognize and reward employees for their achievements and contributions.

- Conduct exit interviews and surveys, and analyze the data to identify the reasons for employee turnover and the areas for improvement.

By following these recommendations, organizations can not only save money, but also enhance their reputation, attract and retain top talent, and achieve their goals and objectives. Employee turnover is not inevitable, but it can be managed and minimized with proper planning and action.