Credit risk modeling Excel: How to Use Excel for Credit Risk Analysis

1. Introduction to Credit Risk Modeling in Excel

credit risk modeling is a crucial aspect of financial analysis, particularly in the realm of lending and investment. In this section, we will delve into the fundamentals of credit risk modeling using Excel, providing valuable insights from various perspectives.

1. understanding Credit risk:

Credit risk refers to the potential loss that a lender or investor may face due to the failure of a borrower or counterparty to fulfill their financial obligations. It is essential to assess and quantify this risk accurately to make informed decisions.

2. key Components of credit Risk Modeling:

A. Probability of Default (PD): PD measures the likelihood of a borrower defaulting on their obligations within a specific time frame. It is typically expressed as a percentage.

B. Loss Given Default (LGD): LGD represents the potential loss incurred if a borrower defaults. It is expressed as a percentage of the exposure at default.

C. Exposure at Default (EAD): EAD refers to the total amount of exposure a lender or investor has to a borrower at the time of default.

D. recovery rate: Recovery rate signifies the percentage of the exposure that can be recovered in the event of default.

3. data Collection and preparation:

To build an effective credit risk model in Excel, it is crucial to gather relevant data, including historical financial statements, credit ratings, industry trends, and macroeconomic indicators. Once collected, the data should be cleaned, organized, and formatted appropriately for analysis.

4. Model Development:

A. Statistical Techniques: Excel offers a range of statistical functions and tools that can be leveraged to develop credit risk models. These include regression analysis, probability distributions, and hypothesis testing.

B. credit scoring Models: credit scoring models assign a numerical score to borrowers based on various factors such as credit history, income, and debt levels. Excel can be used to develop and implement these models effectively.

5. model Validation and testing:

It is crucial to validate and test credit risk models to ensure their accuracy and reliability. This involves comparing model outputs with actual outcomes and assessing the model's performance using metrics such as accuracy, precision, and recall.

6. Sensitivity Analysis:

Sensitivity analysis helps assess the impact of changes in input variables on the model's outputs. Excel's data tables and scenario manager can be utilized to perform sensitivity analysis and understand the model's robustness.

2. Gathering and Preparing Data for Credit Risk Analysis

Gathering and preparing data for credit risk analysis is a crucial step in assessing the potential risks associated with lending and making informed decisions. In this section, we will delve into the various aspects of data collection and preparation, providing insights from different perspectives.

1. Identify relevant Data sources: To begin with, it is essential to identify the relevant data sources that can provide valuable information for credit risk analysis. These sources may include internal databases, credit bureaus, financial statements, customer records, and industry-specific data.

2. Data Cleaning and Validation: Once the data is collected, it needs to be cleaned and validated to ensure its accuracy and reliability. This involves removing duplicate entries, correcting errors, and verifying the consistency of the data. data cleaning techniques such as outlier detection and missing value imputation can be employed to enhance the quality of the dataset.

3. feature engineering: Feature engineering plays a crucial role in credit risk analysis as it involves transforming raw data into meaningful features that can capture the underlying patterns and relationships. This can be achieved through techniques such as variable transformation, aggregation, and creation of new variables based on domain knowledge.

4. Credit scoring models: Credit scoring models are used to assess the creditworthiness of borrowers and predict the likelihood of default. These models utilize statistical techniques such as logistic regression, decision trees, or machine learning algorithms to analyze the prepared dataset and generate credit scores. These scores help in categorizing borrowers into different risk categories.

5. stress testing: Stress testing is an important aspect of credit risk analysis that involves assessing the impact of adverse scenarios on the credit portfolio. By subjecting the dataset to various stress scenarios, such as economic downturns or changes in interest rates, the resilience of the portfolio can be evaluated, and potential vulnerabilities can be identified.

6. Model Validation: It is crucial to validate the credit risk models to ensure their accuracy and reliability. Model validation involves assessing the model's performance against historical data, conducting sensitivity analysis, and comparing the model's predictions with actual outcomes. This helps in identifying any limitations or biases in the model and making necessary adjustments.

7. Ongoing Monitoring: Credit risk analysis is an ongoing process, and it is important to continuously monitor the credit portfolio and update the models as new data becomes available. Regular monitoring helps in identifying emerging risks, detecting changes in borrower behavior, and making timely adjustments to the risk management strategies.

In summary, gathering and preparing data for credit risk analysis involves identifying relevant data sources, cleaning and validating the data, performing feature engineering, building credit scoring models, conducting stress testing, validating the models, and ongoing monitoring. These steps are essential in assessing credit risk and making informed lending decisions.

3. Building Credit Scoring Models in Excel

Building Credit Scoring Models in Excel is a crucial aspect of credit risk analysis. In this section, we will delve into the intricacies of constructing credit scoring models using Excel.

To begin, it is important to understand that credit scoring models aim to assess the creditworthiness of individuals or entities based on various factors. These factors may include credit history, income, debt-to-income ratio, and other relevant financial indicators. By analyzing these variables, credit scoring models provide insights into the likelihood of default or delinquency.

Now, let's explore the key steps involved in building credit scoring models in Excel:

1. Data Collection and Preparation: The first step is to gather relevant data, such as credit reports, financial statements, and other pertinent information. Once collected, the data needs to be organized and cleaned to ensure accuracy and consistency.

2. Feature Selection: In this step, we identify the most influential variables that impact creditworthiness. This can be done through statistical techniques like correlation analysis or domain expertise.

3. Model Development: Excel offers a range of statistical functions and tools that can be utilized to develop credit scoring models. Techniques such as logistic regression, decision trees, or neural networks can be implemented to create predictive models.

4. Model Validation: After developing the credit scoring model, it is crucial to validate its performance. This involves assessing the model's accuracy, reliability, and predictive power using historical data or cross-validation techniques.

5. Model Interpretation: Understanding the insights provided by the credit scoring model is essential. Excel allows for the creation of visualizations, such as charts or graphs, to aid in interpreting the model's results.

6. Model Deployment: Once the credit scoring model is validated and interpreted, it can be deployed for practical use. This involves integrating the model into existing systems or workflows to automate credit risk analysis processes.

Remember, these steps provide a general framework for building credit scoring models in Excel. The specific approach may vary depending on the context and requirements of the analysis.

4. Assessing Probability of Default (PD) in Excel

One of the key components of credit risk modeling is the estimation of the probability of default (PD) of a borrower or a portfolio of borrowers. PD is the likelihood that a borrower will fail to repay their debt obligations in full or in part within a specified time horizon. PD is usually expressed as a percentage or a decimal number between 0 and 1. PD is influenced by various factors, such as the borrower's credit history, financial situation, macroeconomic conditions, industry trends, and contractual terms.

In this section, we will explore how to use Excel for assessing PD in different scenarios. We will cover the following topics:

1. How to calculate PD from historical default rates using the average or the cohort method.

2. How to estimate PD from credit ratings using the rating transition matrix and the marginal default rate approach.

3. How to derive PD from market data using the Merton model or the reduced-form model.

4. How to apply PD to credit risk metrics such as expected loss, unexpected loss, and credit value at risk.

Let's start with the first topic: how to calculate PD from historical default rates.

## How to calculate PD from historical default rates

Historical default rates are the observed frequencies of defaults in a given population of borrowers over a certain period of time. For example, if out of 100 loans issued in 2020, 5 defaulted in 2021, then the historical default rate for 2020-2021 is 5%. Historical default rates can be used to estimate PD for future periods, assuming that the default behavior of the borrowers remains stable and consistent.

There are two common methods to calculate PD from historical default rates: the average method and the cohort method.

### The average method

The average method is the simplest way to calculate PD from historical default rates. It involves taking the arithmetic mean of the default rates over a number of periods. For example, if the default rates for 2018-2019, 2019-2020, and 2020-2021 are 4%, 5%, and 6%, respectively, then the average PD for 2021-2022 is (4% + 5% + 6%) / 3 = 5%.

The average method assumes that the default rates are independent and identically distributed over time, which may not be realistic in practice. The average method also ignores the effects of survivorship bias, which means that the borrowers who survive in one period are more likely to survive in the next period, thus lowering the default rate.

To calculate PD using the average method in Excel, we can use the AVERAGE function. For example, if the default rates are in cells B2:B4, then we can enter the formula `=AVERAGE(B2:B4)` in cell B5 to get the average PD.

### The cohort method

The cohort method is a more refined way to calculate PD from historical default rates. It involves tracking the performance of a group of borrowers who entered the portfolio at the same time (a cohort) over a number of periods. For example, if we have 100 loans issued in 2018, and 4 of them defaulted in 2019, 3 of them defaulted in 2020, and 2 of them defaulted in 2021, then the cohort default rates for 2018-2019, 2018-2020, and 2018-2021 are 4%, 7%, and 9%, respectively.

The cohort method accounts for the effects of survivorship bias, as it only considers the borrowers who are still active in the portfolio at the end of each period. The cohort method also captures the dynamics of default behavior over time, as it reflects the changes in the credit quality of the borrowers.

To calculate PD using the cohort method in Excel, we can use the COUNTIF and COUNTA functions. For example, if the loan IDs are in cells A2:A101, the issue dates are in cells B2:B101, and the default dates are in cells C2:C101, then we can enter the formula `=COUNTIF(C2:C101,"<=2021")/COUNTIF(B2:B101,"<=2018")` in cell D2 to get the cohort PD for 2018-2021. We can then copy the formula to cells D3 and D4 to get the cohort PD for 2019-2021 and 2020-2021, respectively.

Get matched with over 155K angels worldwide!

FasterCapital uses warm introductions and an AI system to approach investors effectively with a 40% response rate!

Join us!

5. Estimating Loss Given Default (LGD) in Excel

One of the key components of credit risk modeling is estimating the loss given default (LGD), which is the percentage of exposure that is not recovered by the lender in the event of a default. LGD depends on various factors, such as the type of loan, the collateral, the recovery process, and the economic conditions. In this section, we will show you how to use Excel to estimate LGD based on historical data and some assumptions. We will cover the following steps:

1. collect and organize the data: You will need data on the exposure at default (EAD), the recovery amount, and the recovery time for each defaulted loan in your portfolio. You can use Excel's data tools to import, filter, and sort the data as needed.

2. Calculate the LGD for each loan: You can use the formula `LGD = 1 - (Recovery Amount / EAD)` to calculate the LGD for each loan. You can also adjust the recovery amount for the time value of money by using the formula `Recovery Amount = Recovery Amount * (1 + Discount Rate) ^ (-Recovery Time)`, where the discount rate is the opportunity cost of capital for the lender.

3. Analyze the distribution of LGD: You can use Excel's descriptive statistics and charting tools to explore the distribution of LGD across your portfolio. You can calculate the mean, median, standard deviation, and percentiles of LGD, and plot histograms, box plots, and scatter plots to visualize the data. You can also segment the data by loan characteristics, such as loan type, collateral type, industry, etc., and compare the LGD across different segments.

4. Estimate the LGD for new loans: You can use Excel's regression and forecasting tools to estimate the LGD for new loans based on the historical data and some explanatory variables. You can use linear regression, logistic regression, or other models to fit the data and generate predictions. You can also use scenario analysis, sensitivity analysis, and simulation techniques to account for the uncertainty and variability of LGD.

6. Calculating Exposure at Default (EAD) in Excel

One of the key components of credit risk modeling is the exposure at default (EAD), which measures the amount of credit that a borrower owes to a lender at the time of default. EAD is influenced by various factors, such as the type of credit facility, the repayment schedule, the interest rate, the collateral value, and the borrower's behavior. In this section, we will show you how to calculate EAD in Excel using different methods and assumptions. We will also discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each method and provide some tips on how to improve the accuracy and reliability of your EAD estimates.

To calculate EAD in Excel, you need to have some basic information about the credit facility, such as the initial amount, the maturity date, the interest rate, the frequency of payments, and the type of amortization. You also need to have some assumptions about the default scenario, such as the default date, the recovery rate, the prepayment rate, and the collateral value. Depending on the type of credit facility, you can use one of the following methods to calculate EAD in Excel:

1. Simple method: This method assumes that the EAD is equal to the outstanding balance of the credit facility at the default date. This method is easy to implement and suitable for credit facilities that have no prepayments, no interest payments, and no collateral. However, this method may overestimate or underestimate the EAD for credit facilities that have these features. For example, if the borrower prepays some of the principal before the default date, the EAD will be lower than the outstanding balance. Conversely, if the borrower pays interest only and does not reduce the principal, the EAD will be higher than the outstanding balance. To use this method, you need to calculate the outstanding balance of the credit facility at the default date using the Excel function `PV(rate, nper, pmt, [fv], [type])`, where `rate` is the interest rate per period, `nper` is the number of periods, `pmt` is the payment amount per period, `fv` is the future value, and `type` is 0 for end-of-period payments or 1 for beginning-of-period payments. For example, if the initial amount of the credit facility is $100,000, the maturity date is 5 years, the interest rate is 10% per year, the frequency of payments is monthly, the type of amortization is constant, and the default date is 3 years, the outstanding balance at the default date is `=PV(0.1/12, 24, -100000*(0.1/12)/(1-(1+0.1/12)^-60), 0, 0)`, which is $83,291. The EAD is then equal to this amount.

2. discounted cash flow method: This method assumes that the EAD is equal to the present value of the expected cash flows from the credit facility after the default date, discounted at the interest rate. This method is more accurate and realistic than the simple method, as it takes into account the prepayments, the interest payments, and the collateral value. However, this method is more complex and requires more assumptions and calculations. To use this method, you need to estimate the expected cash flows from the credit facility after the default date, which include the principal repayments, the interest payments, the prepayments, and the collateral liquidation. You also need to apply the recovery rate to the cash flows, as not all of them will be recovered in case of default. Then, you need to discount the cash flows at the interest rate using the Excel function `NPV(rate, value1, [value2], ...)`, where `rate` is the interest rate per period and `value1, value2, ...` are the cash flows per period. For example, if the initial amount of the credit facility is $100,000, the maturity date is 5 years, the interest rate is 10% per year, the frequency of payments is monthly, the type of amortization is constant, the default date is 3 years, the recovery rate is 50%, the prepayment rate is 10% per year, and the collateral value is $20,000, the expected cash flows after the default date are:

| Period | principal | Interest | prepayment | Collateral | Total |

| 37 | 1,667 | 833 | 8,329 | 0 | 10,829 | | 38 | 1,667 | 792 | 7,996 | 0 | 10,455 | | 39 | 1,667 | 750 | 7,654 | 0 | 10,071 | | 40 | 1,667 | 708 | 7,304 | 0 | 9,679 | | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | | 59 | 1,667 | 167 | 1,670 | 0 | 3,504 | | 60 | 1,670 | 0 | 0 | 20,000 | 21,670 |

The present value of the cash flows at the default date is `=NPV(0.1/12, B38:G60)`, which is $77,787. The EAD is then equal to this amount multiplied by the recovery rate, which is $38,894.

7. Stress Testing and Scenario Analysis in Credit Risk Modeling

One of the most important aspects of credit risk modeling is to assess the impact of adverse events or scenarios on the credit portfolio. stress testing and scenario analysis are two complementary techniques that can help credit risk managers to measure and manage the potential losses and risks arising from extreme but plausible situations. In this section, we will discuss the concepts, methods, and applications of stress testing and scenario analysis in credit risk modeling using Excel. We will also provide some insights from different perspectives, such as regulators, banks, and investors, on how to use these techniques effectively.

Stress testing and scenario analysis can be defined as follows:

- Stress testing is the process of applying a single or a set of shocks to one or more risk factors that affect the credit portfolio, and evaluating the resulting changes in the portfolio value, risk measures, or performance indicators. For example, a stress test can examine the impact of a sudden increase in interest rates, a decline in GDP growth, or a default of a large borrower on the credit portfolio.

- Scenario analysis is the process of constructing and analyzing a coherent and consistent story of a possible future state of the world, and its implications for the credit portfolio. A scenario can include multiple shocks to various risk factors, as well as the interactions and feedback effects among them. For example, a scenario analysis can explore the consequences of a global pandemic, a geopolitical crisis, or a financial market crash on the credit portfolio.

Both stress testing and scenario analysis can help credit risk managers to:

- Identify and quantify the sources and drivers of credit risk in the portfolio

- Evaluate the adequacy and effectiveness of the existing risk management policies and strategies

- enhance the risk awareness and preparedness of the organization and its stakeholders

- comply with the regulatory requirements and expectations

- communicate and report the credit risk profile and performance to the senior management, board of directors, regulators, investors, and other external parties

To perform stress testing and scenario analysis in credit risk modeling using Excel, we can follow these general steps:

1. Define the scope and objectives of the analysis. This includes specifying the credit portfolio to be analyzed, the risk factors to be stressed or varied, the scenarios to be considered, the time horizon and frequency of the analysis, and the output and reporting format.

2. Collect and organize the data and information required for the analysis. This includes the historical and current data on the credit portfolio, such as the exposure, rating, maturity, collateral, and recovery rate of each loan or instrument; the data on the risk factors, such as the interest rates, exchange rates, macroeconomic indicators, and market prices; and the data on the correlations and dependencies among the risk factors and the portfolio components.

3. Build and calibrate the credit risk model that captures the relationship between the risk factors and the credit portfolio. This can be done using various methods, such as the credit risk scorecard, the structural model, the reduced-form model, or the credit portfolio model. The credit risk model should be able to estimate the key credit risk metrics, such as the probability of default (PD), the loss given default (LGD), the exposure at default (EAD), and the expected loss (EL), as well as the unexpected loss (UL), the value at risk (VaR), and the credit value adjustment (CVA), under different scenarios or stress conditions.

4. Apply the shocks or variations to the risk factors, and run the credit risk model to generate the output. This can be done using various tools, such as the data table, the scenario manager, the solver, or the monte Carlo simulation, in Excel. The output should show the changes in the credit risk metrics and the portfolio value or performance under each scenario or stress condition, as well as the comparison and ranking of the scenarios or stress conditions based on their severity or probability.

5. Analyze and interpret the output, and draw conclusions and recommendations. This involves identifying and explaining the main drivers and sources of credit risk and loss in the portfolio, evaluating the sensitivity and resilience of the portfolio to different scenarios or stress conditions, assessing the adequacy and effectiveness of the current risk management policies and strategies, and suggesting possible actions or improvements to mitigate or reduce the credit risk and loss in the portfolio.

6. Communicate and report the results and findings of the analysis to the relevant parties. This involves presenting and explaining the methodology, assumptions, data, model, output, analysis, and conclusions of the stress testing and scenario analysis in a clear, concise, and consistent manner, using appropriate charts, tables, and graphs, in Excel. The report should also highlight the limitations and uncertainties of the analysis, and provide the recommendations and follow-up actions for the credit risk management.

8. Validating and Backtesting Credit Risk Models in Excel

Validating and backtesting credit risk models in Excel is a crucial aspect of credit risk analysis. In this section, we will delve into the various perspectives and insights related to this topic.

1. Importance of Validation:

validating credit risk models is essential to ensure their accuracy and reliability. It involves assessing the model's performance against historical data and comparing its predictions with actual outcomes. By validating the model, financial institutions can gain confidence in its ability to assess credit risk effectively.

2. Backtesting Techniques:

There are several backtesting techniques used to evaluate credit risk models in Excel. One commonly employed method is the "out-of-sample" testing, where the model's performance is assessed on data that was not used during the model's development. This helps to gauge the model's predictive power and assess its robustness.

3. Metrics for Evaluation:

To evaluate credit risk models, various metrics can be utilized. These include the accuracy ratio, which measures the proportion of correctly predicted defaults, and the discrimination power, which assesses the model's ability to differentiate between good and bad credit risks. Additionally, metrics like the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC-ROC) can provide insights into the model's overall performance.

4. Stress Testing:

Stress testing is another important aspect of credit risk model validation. It involves subjecting the model to extreme scenarios to assess its resilience and ability to handle adverse conditions. By simulating various stress scenarios, financial institutions can evaluate the model's performance under different economic conditions and identify potential vulnerabilities.

5. Examples:

Let's consider an example to highlight the concept of backtesting credit risk models in Excel. Suppose a bank has developed a model to predict the likelihood of default for its loan portfolio. By comparing the model's predictions with the actual default outcomes over a specific period, the bank can assess the model's accuracy and make necessary adjustments if required.

Validating and backtesting credit risk models in Excel is a crucial step in credit risk analysis. It helps financial institutions assess the reliability and accuracy of their models, ensuring effective risk management. By utilizing various techniques and metrics, institutions can gain valuable insights into the performance of their credit risk models.

9. Reporting and Interpretation of Credit Risk Analysis Results in Excel

One of the most important aspects of credit risk modeling in Excel is reporting and interpreting the results of the analysis. This section will provide some guidelines and tips on how to present and explain the outcomes of your credit risk models, such as the probability of default (PD), loss given default (LGD), exposure at default (EAD), and expected loss (EL). You will also learn how to use various excel features and functions to create effective and informative reports and charts. Here are some steps to follow when reporting and interpreting your credit risk analysis results in Excel:

1. Summarize the main findings and conclusions of your analysis. You should start your report with a brief summary of the purpose, scope, and methodology of your credit risk modeling, as well as the key results and implications. For example, you can state the overall PD, LGD, EAD, and EL of your portfolio, and compare them with the industry benchmarks or historical averages. You can also highlight the most risky or profitable segments, customers, or products in your portfolio, and suggest some recommendations or actions to improve your credit risk management.

2. Use tables and charts to display your data and results. Excel offers a variety of tools and options to create and format tables and charts that can help you visualize and communicate your data and results. For example, you can use pivot tables and slicers to summarize and filter your data, conditional formatting and sparklines to highlight trends and outliers, and data validation and drop-down lists to create interactive reports. You can also use different types of charts, such as pie, bar, line, scatter, or bubble charts, to show the distribution, relationship, or comparison of your data and results. You should choose the appropriate table or chart type that best suits your purpose and audience, and use clear and consistent labels, titles, legends, and colors to make your tables and charts easy to understand and interpret.

3. Explain the assumptions, limitations, and uncertainties of your analysis. No credit risk model is perfect, and there are always some assumptions, limitations, and uncertainties involved in your analysis. You should acknowledge and explain these factors in your report, and discuss how they may affect the validity and reliability of your results. For example, you can mention the sources and quality of your data, the choice and calibration of your model, the sensitivity and scenario analysis, and the margin of error and confidence interval of your estimates. You should also provide some caveats and qualifications when interpreting your results, and avoid making definitive or absolute statements or claims that may not be supported by your data or model.

4. Provide references and sources for your data and model. You should always cite and acknowledge the references and sources for your data and model in your report, and provide links or attachments to the original or supporting documents or files. This will enhance the credibility and transparency of your analysis, and allow your readers or users to verify, reproduce, or modify your data and model if needed. You should also include a disclaimer or a statement of responsibility in your report, indicating that the data and model are provided for informational or educational purposes only, and that you are not liable for any errors, omissions, or losses that may arise from the use of your data and model.