Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

1. The Importance of Customer Support in Business Success

In the competitive landscape of modern business, customer support stands as a pivotal pillar that not only defines the customer experience but also significantly impacts the overall success and sustainability of a company. It is the frontline where businesses can either build enduring relationships or witness the swift departure of their clientele. The importance of customer support extends beyond mere problem-solving; it encompasses the entire journey of a customer with a product or service, shaping their perception, influencing their loyalty, and ultimately determining their lifetime value to the business.

From the perspective of a startup, robust customer support can be the differentiator that sets them apart in a sea of options. For established enterprises, it's an essential component that maintains their reputation and nurtures their customer base. Across industries, customer support serves as a critical feedback loop, providing invaluable insights into product performance, customer needs, and market trends.

1. First Contact Resolution (FCR): A key metric in customer support, FCR refers to resolving a customer's issue during their first interaction. High FCR rates are indicative of efficient support teams and contribute to higher customer satisfaction. For instance, a software company that manages to solve a user's technical issue in a single live chat session not only saves time for both parties but also leaves a positive impression that can lead to word-of-mouth referrals.

2. Omnichannel Support: Customers today expect to reach out through various channels—email, phone, social media, live chat, and more. An omnichannel approach ensures a seamless experience, where the conversation can continue across different platforms without loss of context. A classic example is a retailer that integrates their support system with social media, allowing customers to initiate a return process via Twitter, which is then smoothly handled through email correspondence.

3. Proactive Support: Anticipating customer issues and addressing them before they escalate is a hallmark of excellent customer service. This could be as simple as a FAQ section on a website or as complex as AI-driven predictive support that identifies potential product failures. A home appliance manufacturer, for example, might use smart diagnostics to alert customers to maintenance needs before a breakdown occurs.

4. Personalization: Tailoring support to individual customer preferences and history can significantly enhance the support experience. Personalization can range from addressing customers by name to customizing solutions based on past interactions. A mobile phone carrier that remembers a customer's previous data issues and offers a personalized data plan is practicing effective personalized support.

5. Training and Empowerment: Investing in the training and empowerment of support staff is crucial. Well-trained representatives equipped with the right tools and authority can make informed decisions that benefit both the customer and the company. For example, a hotel chain that empowers its staff to offer on-the-spot compensation for service lapses can turn a negative experience into a positive one.

6. Feedback Loop: A robust mechanism for capturing and acting on customer feedback can lead to continuous improvement in products and services. This could involve post-interaction surveys or more sophisticated voice-of-customer programs. A software company that iteratively improves its product based on user feedback is leveraging this feedback loop effectively.

Customer support is not just a department; it's a mindset that permeates every aspect of a business. It's about understanding that each interaction is an opportunity to reinforce the brand promise and contribute to a narrative of excellence. Companies that excel in customer support don't just resolve issues; they create advocates and drive business growth through exceptional service.

The Importance of Customer Support in Business Success - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

The Importance of Customer Support in Business Success - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

2. Profiling and Personas

In the realm of customer support, truly understanding your customer is the cornerstone of providing exceptional service. It's not just about resolving tickets; it's about empathizing with your customers, anticipating their needs, and creating a support experience that feels personal and thoughtful. This deep understanding begins with two key practices: profiling and developing personas. Profiling involves gathering and analyzing data to create a detailed picture of your customer base, while personas are semi-fictional characters that represent your ideal customers. These tools are not just theoretical concepts; they are practical, actionable, and incredibly insightful when applied correctly.

1. Customer Profiling: At its core, customer profiling is about data. It's about collecting information on demographics, purchasing behaviors, interaction histories, and preferences. But it's not enough to just collect this data; you must analyze it to uncover patterns and trends. For example, a SaaS company might find that their most engaged users are small business owners in the urban areas who value time-saving features over cost.

2. Creating Personas: Personas take the data from profiling and bring it to life. They are detailed descriptions of imaginary customers based on your real customer data. For instance, "Entrepreneur Emma" could be a persona for the SaaS company mentioned earlier. She's 35, runs a boutique marketing firm, and is always looking for tools that streamline her workflow.

3. Applying Insights to Support: With profiles and personas in hand, you can tailor your support strategy. If "Emma" represents a significant portion of your customer base, you might create support materials that address common workflow challenges or offer live chat support during her typical business hours.

4. Continuous Improvement: Understanding your customer is not a one-time task. It requires ongoing effort and refinement. Regularly update your profiles and personas with new data to ensure your support strategy remains relevant and effective.

By integrating customer profiling and personas into your support strategy, you're not just solving problems—you're building relationships. And in today's competitive market, those relationships are invaluable.

3. Structure and Roles

Establishing a robust support team is a critical step in ensuring the success of your product in the market. The structure and roles within your support team must be carefully considered to provide efficient and effective service to your customers. A well-organized team can mean the difference between a satisfied customer and a lost sale. From the frontline support agents who interact directly with customers, to the managers who oversee operations and strategy, each member plays a vital role in the customer support ecosystem. It's essential to have a clear understanding of the different perspectives within the team, such as the technical expertise of the support engineers, the empathetic approach of customer service representatives, and the analytical skills of the support managers. By aligning these diverse viewpoints towards a common goal, you can create a support team that not only resolves issues but also contributes to the overall customer experience and product improvement.

1. Frontline Support Agents: These are the team members who interact directly with customers. They need to have strong communication skills, product knowledge, and the ability to empathize with customers. For example, a frontline agent might use their in-depth knowledge of the product to guide a user through a complex setup process, ensuring a positive experience.

2. Technical Support Engineers: They provide the next level of support, dealing with more complex issues that frontline agents escalate. Their role requires a deep technical understanding of the product and problem-solving skills. An engineer might, for instance, debug a recurring software issue that has been causing disruptions for multiple customers.

3. customer Service representatives: Often the first point of contact, they handle general inquiries and issues. They must be adept at managing customer expectations and providing clear, concise information. A representative might assist a customer by explaining the different subscription plans available, helping them choose the best option for their needs.

4. Support Managers: They oversee the support team's operations, including staffing, training, and adherence to service level agreements (SLAs). They analyze performance data to identify areas for improvement. A support manager might implement a new training program to reduce the average handle time of support tickets.

5. Quality Assurance Specialists: These team members ensure that all customer interactions meet the company's standards. They monitor and evaluate support calls and emails, providing feedback to improve service quality. For instance, a QA specialist might review a batch of support calls to ensure that all agents are providing accurate and helpful information.

6. Product Liaisons: They act as a bridge between the support team and the product development team. They gather customer feedback and communicate it to the developers to inform future product updates. A product liaison might compile a report on the most requested features from customer feedback and present it to the development team.

7. Training Coordinators: Responsible for onboarding new support team members and providing ongoing education. They must understand the skills required at each support level and develop training materials accordingly. An example would be a coordinator developing an interactive e-learning module for new agents.

8. Data Analysts: They play a crucial role in examining support interaction data to uncover trends and insights that can drive strategic decisions. For example, a data analyst might use customer satisfaction scores to determine the impact of a new support policy.

By considering these roles and structuring your support team accordingly, you can ensure that each customer interaction is handled with the utmost care and professionalism. This not only leads to higher customer satisfaction but also to valuable insights that can drive product innovation and improvement. Remember, the goal is to create a support experience that feels seamless and personalized, turning customers into advocates for your product.

Structure and Roles - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

Structure and Roles - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

4. Skills and Knowledge Development

In the realm of customer support, the pursuit of excellence is not merely a goal but a continuous journey that hinges on the development of both skills and knowledge. This journey is akin to crafting a fine piece of art where every stroke matters, and it is the meticulous attention to detail that ultimately creates a masterpiece. In this context, training is the palette from which customer support professionals draw their colors, blending various hues of expertise to deliver a service experience that resonates with quality and efficiency.

From the perspective of a newly hired support agent, training is the foundation upon which they will build their career. It equips them with the necessary tools to handle the complexities of customer interactions with confidence and poise. For instance, a support agent must learn the art of active listening—a skill that allows them to understand not just the words of the customer, but the emotions and intentions behind them. This skill is honed through role-playing exercises that simulate real-life scenarios, enabling agents to practice and perfect their responses.

From the standpoint of a seasoned manager, training is an investment in the team's future. It's about fostering an environment where knowledge sharing becomes second nature, and where continuous learning is embedded in the team's ethos. A manager might introduce cross-training sessions where team members step into each other's roles, gaining a 360-degree view of the customer support process and appreciating the challenges faced by their peers.

Here are some in-depth insights into the key areas of skills and knowledge development:

1. Product Knowledge: Comprehensive understanding of the product is paramount. Regular training sessions should be conducted to keep the support team updated on new features, bug fixes, and workarounds. For example, a SaaS company might use weekly webinars to deep-dive into product updates.

2. Communication Skills: Clear and empathetic communication can resolve issues swiftly. Workshops focusing on verbal and written communication, including tone, clarity, and brevity, can significantly enhance customer interactions.

3. problem-Solving techniques: Equip the team with various problem-solving frameworks like S.T.A.R. (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to approach and resolve customer issues methodically.

4. Technology Proficiency: Familiarity with support tools and platforms is essential. Interactive tutorials and hands-on sessions can help agents navigate CRM software or ticketing systems more effectively.

5. emotional intelligence: Training on emotional intelligence can help agents manage stress, empathize with customers, and maintain a positive attitude even in challenging situations.

6. Cultural Competence: In a global marketplace, understanding cultural nuances can lead to better customer relations. Scenario-based training can prepare agents for a diverse clientele.

7. Feedback Mechanisms: Constructive feedback is a powerful tool for growth. Implementing peer review sessions and customer feedback analysis can pinpoint areas for improvement.

To illustrate, consider the case of a telecommunications company that introduced a gamified training program. Agents earned points and badges for completing training modules, which not only made the learning process engaging but also fostered a competitive spirit that drove performance.

training for excellence in customer support is a multifaceted endeavor that requires a strategic approach to skills and knowledge development. By embracing a culture of continuous learning and adapting to the evolving needs of both customers and support agents, organizations can ensure that their customer support strategy is not just effective but exemplary.

Skills and Knowledge Development - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

Skills and Knowledge Development - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

5. Building an Efficient Support System

In the realm of customer support, the backbone of any effective strategy lies in the technology and tools employed to streamline processes and enhance the customer experience. The integration of advanced support systems not only simplifies the resolution of customer issues but also empowers support teams with a wealth of data and insights, enabling them to deliver personalized and efficient service. From ticketing systems that organize and prioritize customer inquiries to AI-powered chatbots that provide instant responses, the technological landscape of customer support is rich with tools designed to optimize every interaction.

1. Ticketing Systems: At the core of any support system is a robust ticketing platform. For example, Zendesk offers a suite of features that allow support teams to track, prioritize, and respond to customer inquiries efficiently. This ensures that no customer query falls through the cracks and that the most urgent issues are addressed promptly.

2. Live Chat Software: Live chat tools like Intercom facilitate real-time communication with customers. This immediacy can significantly boost customer satisfaction as it mirrors the quick response times of in-person service.

3. Knowledge Bases: A well-structured knowledge base, such as the one provided by Freshdesk, acts as the first line of defense in customer support. By allowing customers to find answers to common questions themselves, it reduces the overall volume of support tickets.

4. AI Chatbots: AI-driven chatbots can handle a multitude of simple queries without human intervention, freeing up support agents to tackle more complex issues. For instance, IBM's Watson Assistant can be trained to understand and resolve frequently asked questions with a high degree of accuracy.

5. customer Relationship management (CRM) Systems: CRM platforms like Salesforce integrate various aspects of customer support, sales, and marketing, providing a 360-degree view of the customer journey. This holistic approach ensures that support is not a siloed operation but a key part of the overall customer experience.

6. social Media Management tools: With the rise of social media as a support channel, tools like Hootsuite allow teams to monitor and respond to customer inquiries across different platforms from a single dashboard.

7. analytics and Reporting tools: Data is invaluable in refining the support process. Analytics tools embedded within support software can track key performance indicators (KPIs), such as response time and customer satisfaction scores, to inform continuous improvement.

By leveraging these technologies, businesses can create a support ecosystem that not only resolves customer issues efficiently but also gathers insights to prevent future problems. For example, a telecom company might use analytics from their CRM to identify common service outages and proactively address them, thereby reducing the volume of related support tickets.

The judicious selection and implementation of support technologies can transform the customer service landscape, making it more responsive, personalized, and proactive. As businesses continue to evolve, so too will the tools at their disposal, promising even greater advancements in the art of customer support.

Building an Efficient Support System - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

Building an Efficient Support System - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

6. Choosing the Right Platforms for Your Customers

In the realm of customer support, the adage "meet your customers where they are" takes on a literal meaning. choosing the right communication channels is not just about convenience; it's about understanding the preferences and behaviors of your customer base. The digital age has ushered in a plethora of platforms, each with its own set of norms, expectations, and user demographics. From the immediacy of live chat to the formality of email, each channel offers a unique way to build relationships with customers. But it's not just about being present on multiple platforms; it's about selecting the ones that align with your brand's voice, your product's nature, and your customers' lifestyles.

1. Email: The stalwart of digital communication, email remains a preferred channel for detailed inquiries and formal interactions. It allows for comprehensive responses, document attachments, and a record of correspondence. For instance, a B2B software company might prioritize email to provide thorough support for complex issues.

2. Social Media: Platforms like Twitter and Facebook are not just for marketing; they're increasingly used for real-time customer service. They offer a public forum for quick queries and demonstrate your brand's commitment to transparency and engagement. A fashion retailer, for example, might use Instagram's direct messaging feature to address customer concerns while also showcasing their products.

3. Live Chat: For immediate assistance, live chat is unparalleled. It provides the convenience of real-time interaction without the commitment of a phone call. E-commerce sites often integrate chatbots for initial triage, followed by human support for more complex issues.

4. Phone Support: Sometimes, only a human voice will do. Complex or sensitive issues are often best handled over the phone, where tone and empathy can be conveyed directly. A healthcare provider might rely on phone support to deliver personalized care instructions.

5. Self-Service Portals: Knowledge bases, FAQs, and forums empower customers to find answers independently. tech-savvy users, in particular, may prefer this route for its speed and autonomy. A software company might develop an extensive online help center to cater to this preference.

6. Messaging Apps: WhatsApp, WeChat, and other messaging apps have become popular customer service channels, especially in regions where they dominate communication. They offer a blend of text and multimedia messaging, appealing to users who want a more conversational support experience.

7. Video Calls: For products that require visual demonstration or for customers who prefer face-to-face interaction, video calls can be effective. A home appliance brand might use video calls to guide customers through installation processes.

The key to selecting the right communication channels lies in understanding your customer demographics, their communication preferences, and the nature of their inquiries. By aligning your channels with these factors, you can create a seamless and satisfying support experience that not only resolves issues but also strengthens customer loyalty.

Choosing the Right Platforms for Your Customers - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

Choosing the Right Platforms for Your Customers - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

7. Key Performance Indicators and Metrics

In the realm of customer support, the adage "what gets measured gets managed" is particularly pertinent. Measuring success is not just about tracking any numbers; it's about identifying the right key performance indicators (KPIs) and metrics that align with your business goals and customer satisfaction objectives. These indicators serve as a compass, guiding your support team towards continuous improvement and helping you to understand the impact of your customer support strategy on your overall business health.

From the perspective of a customer support manager, KPIs such as First Response Time (FRT) and customer Satisfaction score (CSAT) are vital. They reflect how quickly and effectively a team responds to customer inquiries and how satisfied customers are with the service they receive. For instance, a low FRT can indicate a highly responsive team, but if paired with a low CSAT, it may suggest that the quality of support needs to be addressed.

Support agents, on the other hand, might focus on metrics like Ticket Volume and Resolution Time. These metrics provide insights into the workload and efficiency of the support team. For example, a sudden spike in ticket volume could indicate a widespread product issue or a successful marketing campaign driving new user inquiries.

From a financial standpoint, the Cost per Ticket and Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) are crucial. They help in understanding the direct costs associated with providing support and the long-term value of a customer to the company. A high cost per ticket might necessitate a review of support processes or tools to find more cost-effective solutions without compromising service quality.

Here's a deeper dive into some of these KPIs and metrics:

1. First Response Time (FRT): This is the average time it takes for a customer support agent to respond to a customer inquiry. A shorter FRT is generally better, as it can lead to higher customer satisfaction. For example, a company that reduces its FRT from 24 hours to 2 hours might see a corresponding increase in its CSAT scores.

2. Customer Satisfaction Score (CSAT): Typically measured through post-interaction surveys, CSAT reflects how customers feel about the support they received. It's often expressed as a percentage, with 100% being complete satisfaction. A company might track CSAT over time to gauge the effectiveness of new support strategies or training programs.

3. Net Promoter Score (NPS): NPS measures the likelihood of customers to recommend your product or service to others. It's a strong indicator of customer loyalty and can be impacted by both product quality and customer support experiences.

4. Ticket Volume: Monitoring the number of support tickets helps in planning resources and can also signal issues with the product or service. For example, a software company might notice an increase in tickets after a new version release, indicating potential bugs that need to be addressed.

5. Resolution Time: This metric tracks the average time it takes to resolve a customer's issue. It's important for assessing the efficiency of the support team and ensuring that customers aren't left waiting for solutions.

6. Cost per Ticket: By dividing the total cost of running the support department by the number of tickets handled, businesses can assess the financial efficiency of their support operations.

7. Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): CLV estimates the total revenue a business can expect from a single customer account. It helps in understanding the long-term impact of customer support on revenue and can justify investments in improving the customer experience.

By carefully selecting and monitoring these KPIs and metrics, businesses can create a robust framework for evaluating the success of their customer support strategy. This, in turn, enables them to make informed decisions that not only enhance customer satisfaction but also contribute to the company's bottom line. Remember, the ultimate goal is to foster a positive customer experience that leads to retention and growth.

Key Performance Indicators and Metrics - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

Key Performance Indicators and Metrics - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

8. Learning and Improving from Customer Interactions

In the realm of customer support, the feedback loop is an essential mechanism that not only gauges customer satisfaction but also serves as a critical learning tool for continuous improvement. This iterative process involves collecting feedback, analyzing it, making informed decisions, and implementing changes that lead to service enhancement. It's a dynamic and ongoing conversation between a product and its users, where each interaction holds the potential to refine and elevate the user experience.

From the perspective of a customer support representative, the feedback loop provides direct insights into customer needs and pain points. It's a firsthand account of how users interact with the product, which can be invaluable in identifying areas for improvement. For product managers, this feedback is the compass that guides product development, ensuring that updates and new features align with user expectations. Meanwhile, from a business standpoint, the feedback loop is a strategic asset. It not only helps in retaining customers by showing that their opinions are valued and acted upon but also attracts new customers through positive word-of-mouth.

Here's an in-depth look at how to harness the power of the feedback loop:

1. Collecting Feedback: The first step is to gather feedback through various channels such as surveys, social media, customer support interactions, and product usage data. For example, a SaaS company might use in-app prompts to ask users for feedback after they use a new feature.

2. Analyzing Feedback: Once collected, the feedback must be analyzed to identify common themes and actionable insights. Advanced tools like sentiment analysis can be employed to gauge the emotional tone behind the feedback.

3. Closing the Loop: Responding to feedback is crucial. Whether it's a thank-you message for positive feedback or a solution to a problem, customers need to know they're heard. A case in point is when a user reports a bug, and the company not only fixes it but also follows up with the user to confirm the resolution.

4. Implementing Changes: Based on the feedback, changes should be made to improve the product or service. This could range from small tweaks to major overhauls. For instance, if multiple users find a particular feature complex, simplifying its design would be a wise move.

5. Measuring Impact: After implementing changes, it's important to measure their impact on customer satisfaction and product performance. This can be done through follow-up surveys or analyzing usage patterns.

6. Iterating: The feedback loop is never complete. It's a cycle that keeps on spinning, with each turn bringing new insights and opportunities for growth.

An example of the feedback loop in action can be seen in the tech industry, where agile development practices incorporate user feedback at every stage. When a popular project management tool received feedback that users were overwhelmed by its complex interface, the company rolled out a simplified version and saw a significant increase in user engagement.

The feedback loop is not just a process but a philosophy that places the customer at the heart of product evolution. It's about building a relationship where every customer interaction is an opportunity to learn and improve, thereby fostering a product that continually resonates with its user base.

Learning and Improving from Customer Interactions - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

Learning and Improving from Customer Interactions - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

9. Integrating Customer Support into Your Overall Business Strategy

In the realm of business, customer support is often viewed as a standalone function, relegated to the sidelines of the main commercial activities. However, this perspective is rapidly changing as companies recognize the integral role that customer support plays in the overall business strategy. It's not just about resolving issues; it's about building relationships, fostering loyalty, and gathering invaluable insights directly from those who use your products or services.

integrating customer support into your business strategy means aligning it with your sales, marketing, product development, and other core functions. It's about creating a seamless experience for the customer at every touchpoint. For instance, when a customer support team is fully integrated, feedback collected during support interactions can directly influence product improvements, which in turn can lead to increased customer satisfaction and sales.

Here are some in-depth insights into how this integration can be achieved:

1. feedback Loop creation: Establish a system where customer feedback collected by support teams is systematically shared with the product development team. For example, Slack, the messaging platform, has dedicated channels where customer feedback is discussed, allowing for quick iterations and improvements.

2. Cross-Functional Training: Train your customer support team not just on troubleshooting, but also on the broader business objectives and product knowledge. This empowers them to understand customer needs in the context of your business goals.

3. customer Journey mapping: Work with the marketing team to map out the customer journey, identifying key touchpoints where support can add value. For example, Apple's Genius Bar provides support that's consistent with the brand's premium image and customer-centric approach.

4. Data-Driven Decisions: Use data analytics to understand customer behavior and preferences. This can inform not just support strategies but also product development and marketing campaigns.

5. Proactive Support: Shift from a reactive to a proactive support model. Anticipate customer issues and reach out before they do. Amazon's anticipatory shipping model, where they ship products before customers even order them based on predictive analytics, is a prime example of proactive strategy.

6. Support as a Sales Channel: Train support staff to identify upselling and cross-selling opportunities. For example, when a customer calls in with a problem, the support representative can offer an upgraded service that would prevent such issues in the future.

7. Brand Advocacy: Encourage and train your support team to be brand advocates. Their positive interactions with customers can lead to word-of-mouth marketing and enhanced brand reputation.

By weaving customer support into the fabric of your business strategy, you create a holistic approach that not only solves problems but also drives growth, innovation, and customer loyalty. It's a strategic move that acknowledges the importance of every customer interaction in the broader narrative of your business's success.

Integrating Customer Support into Your Overall Business Strategy - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

Integrating Customer Support into Your Overall Business Strategy - Developing a Customer Support Strategy for Your Product

Read Other Blogs

Inspiration Boosters: Mind Expansion: Mind Expansion: Broadening Horizons for Greater Inspiration

Embarking on the path to expanding one's mind is akin to setting sail on a vast ocean of potential....

Google Mobile First Indexing readiness: Mobile First Indexing and SEO: A Must Know for Business Owners

Mobile-first indexing is a term that refers to how Google crawls and ranks web pages based on their...

Make your startup more innovative by making it harder

In today's business world, the pressure to be innovative is immense. Companies are constantly...

Collateral: Using Assets to Secure a Bail Bond update

When a loved one gets arrested, navigating the legal system can be a daunting and stressful...

Impact Bonds: Maximizing Impact: How ESG Funds and Impact Bonds Are Changing the Game

In recent years, the investment landscape has witnessed a seismic shift towards strategies that...

Exit strategy: How to plan for and execute your exit from the business

Assessing Your Business's Value is a crucial aspect when planning for and executing your exit from...

Procrastination Solutions: Digital Detoxing: Detox Digitally to Ditch Procrastination

In the age where digital devices are entwined with every aspect of our lives, the battle against...

Social sharing initiatives: Social Media Management: Managing the Buzz: Effective Social Media Management

In the realm of digital marketing, social sharing initiatives have emerged as a cornerstone...

Women s entrepreneurship and development: Investing in Women: The Future of Business

In recent years, the entrepreneurial landscape has witnessed a significant shift as an increasing...