Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

1. Introduction to Employer Branding and Referral Programs

Employer branding and referral programs are two pivotal elements in the strategic framework of any startup looking to attract and retain top talent. In a landscape where competition for skilled professionals is fierce, a strong employer brand sets a company apart, signaling to potential employees that it's a desirable place to work. This brand is not just a reflection of the company's values and culture; it's also a promise of the employee experience. On the other hand, referral programs leverage the networks of existing employees, who can vouch for the company's culture and opportunities, thus attracting candidates who are likely to be a good fit. When these two strategies are intertwined, they create a powerful synergy that can significantly enhance a startup's appeal to prospective hires.

1. Defining employer branding: employer branding is the identity of a company as an employer. It encompasses the company's reputation, the value it offers to its employees, and the messaging that communicates this to both current and potential staff. For example, Google is renowned for its employer branding, emphasizing innovation, a collaborative environment, and exceptional benefits.

2. The Role of referral programs: Referral programs incentivize current employees to recommend qualified candidates for open positions. These programs often offer bonuses or other rewards for successful hires, which not only encourages participation but also helps ensure that the referred candidates are a good match for the company's culture and needs.

3. integrating Referral programs with Employer Branding: To effectively integrate referral programs into employer branding, companies must ensure that their employees understand and believe in the brand. This way, when they refer candidates, they're genuinely endorsing the company. For instance, Salesforce has successfully integrated its referral program with its employer brand by creating an inclusive culture that employees are eager to share with their networks.

4. benefits of a Strong Employer brand: A strong employer brand can reduce recruitment costs, decrease time-to-hire, and improve the quality of candidates. It also plays a crucial role in employee retention, as employees are more likely to stay with a company that has a positive image.

5. Challenges in Employer branding and Referral programs: One of the main challenges is ensuring consistency in the brand message across all platforms and touchpoints. Additionally, maintaining the quality of hires through referral programs can be difficult, as it relies heavily on the judgment of employees.

6. Measuring the Impact: The success of employer branding and referral programs can be measured through various metrics, such as the number of applicants per opening, the quality of hire, employee turnover rates, and the percentage of hires through referrals.

7. Continuous Improvement: Both employer branding and referral programs require ongoing attention and refinement. Gathering feedback from employees and new hires can provide valuable insights into how these initiatives can be improved.

Employer branding and referral programs are not just HR initiatives; they are strategic business tools that can drive a startup's growth and success. By investing in a strong employer brand and a robust referral program, startups can create a virtuous cycle of attracting, hiring, and retaining the best talent in the industry.

Introduction to Employer Branding and Referral Programs - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Introduction to Employer Branding and Referral Programs - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

2. The Role of Employee Referrals in Branding Strategy

Employee referrals have become a cornerstone in shaping the branding strategy of many successful startups. This approach not only leverages the existing workforce to attract talent but also serves as a testament to the company's culture and values. When employees recommend their acquaintances for positions within the company, it's a clear indication that they trust and take pride in their workplace. This implicit endorsement is powerful; it's personal, credible, and resonates more authentically with potential candidates than corporate advertising ever could. Moreover, it reflects positively on the brand, suggesting a healthy, positive work environment that people are eager to be a part of.

From the perspective of marketing, employee referrals are a form of word-of-mouth promotion, one of the most effective and trusted forms of advertising. Here's how they can impact your branding strategy:

1. enhanced Brand perception: Candidates referred by current employees are likely to have a more favorable view of the company, based on the positive things they've heard from someone they trust.

2. Cost-Effective Recruitment: Referrals can reduce the need for expensive job ads and recruitment agencies. This budget efficiency can be redirected into improving employee benefits, which further enhances the brand.

3. Quality Hires: Referred employees often fit the company culture better and have a shorter ramp-up time, leading to higher productivity and longer tenure, which speaks volumes about the brand's stability and growth potential.

4. Employee Engagement: A referral program can boost morale and foster a sense of community. When employees feel involved in the growth of their company, they're more likely to be engaged and satisfied with their job.

5. Real Stories, Real People: Authentic narratives from employees about their experiences at the company can be used in branding materials, providing a genuine insight into the company culture.

For example, consider a startup like Zapier, which operates remotely. They have a robust referral program that encourages employees to refer candidates by offering substantial bonuses. The success stories of referred employees are shared in their monthly newsletters and on social media, showcasing the company's commitment to building a team that's not just skilled but also culturally cohesive. This strategy has helped Zapier maintain a strong employer brand that attracts top talent from around the globe.

Employee referrals are not just a hiring tactic; they are a strategic branding tool that can shape the external perception of a company. By integrating referrals into your employer branding strategy, you can build a brand that attracts, retains, and engages top talent, driving your startup's success.

The Role of Employee Referrals in Branding Strategy - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

The Role of Employee Referrals in Branding Strategy - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

3. Designing an Effective Referral Program

designing an effective referral program is a strategic endeavor that requires a nuanced understanding of both human psychology and business dynamics. At its core, a referral program is a systematic approach that companies use to incentivize existing employees to recommend qualified candidates for job openings. The success of such a program hinges on its ability to tap into the networks of its workforce, leveraging the trust and personal endorsements of its members. From the perspective of employer branding, a well-crafted referral program not only fills the talent pipeline with high-caliber candidates but also reinforces the company's image as a desirable workplace. It's a testament to the positive internal culture when employees are willing to vouch for the company, suggesting a level of satisfaction and engagement that resonates with potential recruits.

Here are some in-depth insights into designing an effective referral program:

1. Clear Communication of Benefits: Employees should be clearly informed about the benefits of participating in the referral program. This includes not just the rewards for successful referrals but also the impact their contribution has on the company's growth and success.

2. Tiered Incentive Structure: Implement a tiered reward system that provides greater incentives for roles that are harder to fill or are of higher priority. For example, referring a candidate for a senior executive position might yield a higher reward than for entry-level roles.

3. Streamlined Process: The referral process should be straightforward and user-friendly. If it's too complicated, employees might not bother. For instance, a simple online form or a dedicated email address for submissions can make the process more accessible.

4. Feedback Loop: Keep the referrers updated on the status of their referrals. Whether the candidate was accepted, rejected, or still under consideration, timely feedback is crucial for maintaining engagement and trust in the program.

5. Recognition: Publicly recognize successful referrals. This not only rewards the referring employee but also encourages others to participate. A monthly "Referral Star" award can be a good example.

6. Training for Effective Referrals: Provide guidance on what makes a good referral. This could include training sessions or materials that help employees understand the ideal candidate profile.

7. Diversity and Inclusion: Ensure the referral program encourages diversity. This might involve extra incentives for referrals that enhance the diversity of the workforce or explicit communication about the company's commitment to an inclusive workplace.

8. Regular Review and Adaptation: The referral program should not be static. Regularly review its performance and make adjustments based on feedback and changing company needs.

For example, a tech startup might implement a referral program where employees receive points for each referral, which can be redeemed for various rewards. If an employee refers a candidate who gets hired and stays with the company for more than six months, they receive bonus points, emphasizing the value of long-term fits over quick hires.

An effective referral program is more than just a recruiting tool; it's a reflection of the company's values and an extension of its employer brand. By thoughtfully designing the program with a focus on simplicity, transparency, and recognition, startups can harness the power of their existing workforce to attract like-minded individuals who will thrive in their culture and contribute to their success.

Designing an Effective Referral Program - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Designing an Effective Referral Program - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

4. Incentivizing Employees for Successful Referrals

Employee referrals have become a cornerstone of talent acquisition strategies, particularly within startups where each hiring decision can significantly impact the company's trajectory. By incentivizing employees for successful referrals, startups not only expedite the hiring process but also often end up with hires who are a better cultural fit, exhibit higher job satisfaction, and have longer tenures. This symbiotic approach leverages the existing workforce's network, rewarding them for contributing to the company's growth and fostering a culture of collaboration and shared success.

From the perspective of HR professionals, the benefits are manifold. A well-structured referral program can reduce the cost-per-hire and time-to-hire metrics, crucial for startups operating on lean budgets and timelines. For employees, the incentives serve as a tangible acknowledgment of their valuable input and can take various forms, from monetary bonuses to extra vacation days, or even non-monetary perks like parking spots or public recognition.

Here's an in-depth look at how startups can structure their referral incentives:

1. Monetary Bonuses: The most straightforward incentive is a cash bonus. For example, a startup might offer $1,000 for a referral that leads to a hire, with the sum paid out after the new employee completes their probationary period.

2. Tiered Rewards: To encourage quality over quantity, companies can implement a tiered reward system where the referrer receives a higher bonus if the hire stays with the company for predetermined milestones, such as one year or two years.

3. Non-Monetary Perks: Some startups get creative with rewards like extra vacation days, a prime parking spot for a month, or a feature in the company newsletter. These can be particularly appealing to employees who value recognition and work-life balance over cash incentives.

4. Charitable Donations: For employees motivated by altruism, companies can offer to make a donation to a charity of the employee's choice upon a successful referral.

5. career Development opportunities: Offering professional development opportunities, such as a conference ticket or an online course subscription, can be a powerful incentive for employees invested in their career growth.

6. Raffles and Contests: To add an element of fun, some companies enter all referrers into a raffle for a larger prize, such as a trip or tech gadget, regardless of whether their referral was hired.

7. equity options: Particularly in startups, offering equity or stock options can be a long-term incentive, aligning the employee's interests with the company's success.

For instance, a tech startup might offer a referral bonus of $500, but if the referred candidate has a rare skill set, such as expertise in artificial intelligence, the bonus could increase to $1,500. Another example is a startup that introduced 'Referral Fridays', where employees who made a referral that week could leave early on Friday, fostering a culture of engagement and participation in the company's growth.

Incentivizing employees for successful referrals is a multifaceted strategy that can yield significant benefits for startups. By carefully considering the types of incentives that align with their company culture and employees' values, startups can create a referral program that not only attracts top talent but also enhances their employer brand.

Incentivizing Employees for Successful Referrals - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Incentivizing Employees for Successful Referrals - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

5. Integrating Referral Programs with Your Brands Values

In the competitive landscape of startup growth, referral programs have emerged as a powerful tool for not only attracting top talent but also for reinforcing a brand's core values. When effectively integrated, these programs can serve as a testament to the company's commitment to its culture and ethos. employees become brand ambassadors, and their referrals are a reflection of the brand's resonance with its workforce. This alignment between referral programs and brand values is not just about incentivizing employees; it's about creating a symbiotic relationship where the company's principles are echoed through its most valuable asset—its people.

From the perspective of an HR leader, the integration of referral programs with brand values is a strategic move towards sustainable employer branding. It's a way to ensure that the talent brought into the fold is not just skilled but also a cultural fit. For marketing professionals, this integration is an opportunity to showcase authenticity, leveraging word-of-mouth to build brand credibility. Meanwhile, from an operational standpoint, it streamlines recruitment and onboarding processes, as referred candidates often require less training and adapt more quickly to the company culture.

Here are some in-depth insights into integrating referral programs with your brand's values:

1. define Clear brand Values: Before launching a referral program, ensure that your company's values are clearly defined and communicated. This clarity will help employees understand what kind of candidates align with the brand.

2. Align Referral Incentives with Values: If sustainability is a core value, consider offering eco-friendly rewards. For example, Patagonia's referral program could offer experiences or products that align with environmental conservation.

3. Employee Education: Conduct workshops to educate employees on how to identify potential candidates who embody the brand's values. This empowers them to make referrals that enhance the company culture.

4. Feedback Loop: Create a system where employees can provide feedback on the referral process. This can help in fine-tuning the program to better reflect the brand's values.

5. Recognition: Publicly recognize successful referrals. This not only motivates employees but also reinforces the brand's appreciation for community and collaboration.

6. Storytelling: share stories of successful referrals and how they have contributed to the brand's mission. This can inspire more employees to participate actively in the program.

7. Diversity and Inclusion: Ensure that the referral program promotes diversity and inclusion, reflecting a brand value that resonates with a broad spectrum of talent.

8. Measure Success: Use metrics to measure the program's success in terms of retention rates, employee satisfaction, and alignment with brand values.

By weaving these elements into the fabric of your referral program, you create a cohesive narrative that not only attracts talent but also fortifies your brand's identity in the market. For instance, when Airbnb launched its referral program, it didn't just look for hosts; it sought individuals who shared its vision of a world where anyone can belong anywhere. The program was designed to attract people who were not just offering a space but were also committed to providing a sense of belonging—a core value of the Airbnb brand.

Integrating referral programs with your brand's values is not a one-off task but a continuous effort that evolves with your brand. It's about creating a living, breathing ecosystem where your values are not just words on a website but are lived experiences, shared and celebrated by your employees and, by extension, their networks. This strategic alignment can transform your referral program from a mere recruitment tool into a powerful extension of your brand's narrative.

Integrating Referral Programs with Your Brands Values - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Integrating Referral Programs with Your Brands Values - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

6. Utilizing Social Media to Amplify Your Referral Program

In the competitive landscape of startup growth, leveraging social media to amplify your referral program can be a game-changer. It's not just about increasing visibility; it's about creating an ecosystem where your employees, customers, and followers become advocates for your brand. By integrating social media strategies into your referral program, you're tapping into the power of personal networks and the trust that comes with peer recommendations. This approach can significantly enhance your employer branding, as potential recruits see real people endorsing your company as a great place to work.

From the perspective of a marketing strategist, the key is to create shareable, engaging content that employees and customers want to spread across their networks. human Resources experts might emphasize the importance of recognizing and rewarding employees who actively participate in the referral program, thus encouraging a culture of advocacy. Meanwhile, a social media influencer would focus on the potential reach and impact of a well-crafted message when shared by individuals with a large following.

Here's how you can utilize social media to amplify your referral program effectively:

1. Create Shareable Content: Develop content that is easy to share and resonates with your audience. For example, Dropbox's referral program offered extra storage space for both the referrer and the referee, which users eagerly shared online.

2. Leverage Employee Advocacy: Encourage your employees to share their positive experiences working at your startup. LinkedIn is a prime platform for this, where employees can share job postings along with a personal note about their experience at the company.

3. Use Hashtags Strategically: Create a unique hashtag for your referral program to track its reach and engagement. For instance, #WorkAtStartupX can become a recognizable tag that aggregates all related posts.

4. Engage with Followers: Respond to comments and messages promptly. This interaction not only boosts the post through algorithms but also shows that your company values its community.

5. Monitor and Analyze: Use social media analytics tools to track the performance of your referral-related posts. Understanding what works and what doesn't allows you to refine your strategy over time.

6. Collaborate with Influencers: Partner with influencers who align with your brand values to extend your reach. They can share their genuine experiences with your company, lending credibility to your referral program.

7. Run Targeted Ads: Social media platforms offer powerful targeting options. Use them to promote your referral program to a broader yet relevant audience.

8. Highlight Success Stories: Share testimonials and stories of employees who joined through referrals. This not only humanizes your brand but also illustrates the success of the referral program.

By implementing these strategies, startups can create a robust referral program that not only attracts top talent but also strengthens their employer brand. Remember, the goal is to make sharing as natural and rewarding as possible, turning your workforce and customer base into a thriving community of brand ambassadors.

Utilizing Social Media to Amplify Your Referral Program - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Utilizing Social Media to Amplify Your Referral Program - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

7. Measuring the Success of Your Referral Initiatives

measuring the success of referral initiatives is a critical component of any employer branding strategy, particularly for startups where each hiring decision can significantly impact the company's culture and growth trajectory. A well-implemented referral program not only enriches the talent pool with qualified candidates but also serves as a testament to the positive internal perception of the company. To gauge the effectiveness of such programs, it's essential to look beyond the surface-level metrics of hires made and delve into the nuances of performance, retention, and employee satisfaction.

From the perspective of HR analytics, the success of referral programs can be quantified through various KPIs. Here's a detailed exploration:

1. Referral Rate: This measures the percentage of employees participating in the referral program. A high referral rate indicates a workforce that's engaged and believes in the company enough to recommend it to others.

2. Conversion Rate: The ratio of referred candidates who are hired versus the total number of referrals. A higher conversion rate suggests that the referrals are of high quality.

3. Time-to-Hire: Comparing the time-to-hire for referred candidates against other sourcing channels can reveal the efficiency of the referral process. Typically, referrals have a faster time-to-hire due to the pre-existing trust and knowledge about the company.

4. Retention Rate: Long-term employee retention is a strong indicator of a successful referral. If referred employees stay with the company longer than average, it suggests they're a good fit culturally and professionally.

5. Cost-per-Hire: Referrals can significantly reduce hiring costs. By comparing the cost-per-hire from referrals to other sources, companies can assess the financial impact of their referral program.

6. Employee net Promoter score (eNPS): This metric gauges employees' willingness to recommend the company as a place to work. A high eNPS among those who were hired through referrals can indicate the program's success in attracting committed employees.

7. Quality of Hire: Assessing the performance of referred employees over time helps in understanding the quality of hire. This can be measured through performance reviews, productivity metrics, and contributions to team goals.

For example, a startup tech company implemented a referral program and noticed a 30% increase in their referral rate within six months. Not only did the conversion rate improve by 15%, but the new hires also had a 10% higher retention rate after one year compared to non-referred employees. Moreover, the eNPS among referred employees was consistently high, reflecting their satisfaction and alignment with the company's values.

A multifaceted approach to measuring the success of referral initiatives provides a comprehensive understanding of their impact. By considering various perspectives and metrics, startups can fine-tune their programs to attract top talent, foster a positive work environment, and ultimately, strengthen their employer brand.

Measuring the Success of Your Referral Initiatives - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Measuring the Success of Your Referral Initiatives - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

8. Successful Referral Programs in Startups

Referral programs have become a cornerstone in the growth strategies of many successful startups. These programs leverage the networks of a company's employees, customers, or partners to identify and attract top talent or new customers, often with remarkable effectiveness. By turning stakeholders into brand ambassadors, startups not only expand their reach but also build a community of engaged and invested individuals who are likely to contribute positively to the company's culture and success. The power of personal recommendation cannot be overstated; it comes with an inherent trust that no advertisement can buy. From a recruitment perspective, referred employees often fit better with the company culture and have higher retention rates, while from a sales standpoint, referred customers tend to have a higher lifetime value.

1. Dropbox's Referral Program: Perhaps one of the most cited examples is Dropbox. They incentivized users to refer friends by offering additional storage space for both the referrer and the referee. This simple yet effective strategy resulted in a 60% increase in sign-ups, with a significant portion of their user base coming from referrals.

2. Uber's Dual-Sided Incentives: Uber's referral program offered benefits to both the referrer and the new user, which helped the company rapidly expand its customer base. This approach not only encouraged current users to spread the word but also made the first ride more accessible to newcomers.

3. Airbnb's Tailored Referrals: Airbnb took a more personalized approach by allowing its hosts to send referral links to their guests. This strategy capitalized on the positive experiences of guests, who were then likely to become hosts themselves, thus growing the platform's offerings.

4. Evernote's Tiered Rewards: Evernote's referral program rewarded users with points that could be used for premium features. The more friends a user referred, the more points they earned, creating a tiered system that encouraged ongoing engagement.

5. Tesla's Experiential Rewards: Tesla's referral program went beyond monetary incentives by offering unique experiences, such as exclusive events or the opportunity to drive a Tesla Roadster in space. This created a buzz and fostered a community of enthusiasts.

These case studies demonstrate that a well-designed referral program can be a powerful tool for startups. It's not just about the incentives offered, but also about how those incentives align with the company's brand and the values of its community. When implemented thoughtfully, referral programs can significantly amplify a startup's growth and enhance its employer branding strategy.

Successful Referral Programs in Startups - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Successful Referral Programs in Startups - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

9. Sustaining Growth Through Strategic Referrals

In the dynamic landscape of startup growth, strategic referrals stand as a cornerstone, not just for expanding the customer base, but also for enhancing the employer brand. This symbiotic relationship between a company's market perception and its internal culture is fueled by the power of referrals. They serve as a testament to the company's values, mission, and the satisfaction of those who are part of it. By leveraging the networks of current employees, startups can tap into a rich vein of potential talent that is often well-aligned with the company's ethos. This alignment is crucial, as it ensures that new recruits are not just skilled, but are also cultural fits who will thrive in the startup environment, further driving growth and innovation.

From the perspective of current employees, the act of referring a candidate is a reflection of their belief in the company. It's a vote of confidence in the startup's future and an endorsement of its culture. For the referred candidates, it's an opportunity to become part of a vision they already have a connection to, through someone they trust. This pre-established trust accelerates the integration process, making it smoother and more effective.

Here are some in-depth insights into sustaining growth through strategic referrals:

1. Quality of Hire: Referrals often lead to higher quality candidates because they come pre-vetted by current employees who understand the company's needs and culture. For example, Google reported that their referral program helped them maintain high hiring standards while growing rapidly.

2. Reduced Time-to-Hire: A referral program can significantly cut down the hiring timeline. Referred candidates are typically faster to recruit and onboard than those sourced through traditional channels.

3. Employee Retention: Employees who come through referrals tend to stay longer. A study by Deloitte found that referred employees have a 42% retention rate after one year, compared to 32% from job boards.

4. Cost Efficiency: referral programs can be more cost-effective than other sourcing methods. The cost of a referral bonus is often lower than the fees paid to recruitment agencies or the costs associated with prolonged vacancies.

5. Enhanced Employer Brand: When employees refer friends or former colleagues, they're effectively acting as brand ambassadors. This not only helps in attracting talent but also in building the startup's reputation as a desirable workplace.

6. Diversity and Inclusion: Thoughtfully designed referral programs can support diversity initiatives by encouraging employees to refer candidates from underrepresented groups.

To illustrate the impact of strategic referrals, consider the case of a startup like Dropbox. They implemented a referral program that rewarded employees with both financial bonuses and creative incentives, leading to a significant increase in high-quality hires. This approach not only filled their talent pipeline but also reinforced a culture of ownership and collaboration, essential ingredients for sustained growth.

Strategic referrals are more than just a hiring tactic; they are a growth engine for startups. By integrating referrals into the employer branding strategy, startups can create a self-reinforcing cycle of attraction, retention, and advocacy that fuels their journey towards success and innovation.

Sustaining Growth Through Strategic Referrals - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Sustaining Growth Through Strategic Referrals - Implementing Referral Programs in Your Startup s Employer Branding Strategy

Read Other Blogs

Sand Dune Driving Engineering: Driving Change: How Sand Dune Engineering Transforms Startup Landscapes

In the realm of startup ecosystems, innovation is as unpredictable and ever-changing as the winds...

Alternate Recipient: Guaranteeing Your Assets Find a Suitable Home

When it comes to estate planning, many individuals focus solely on the distribution of their...

Incorporating Experience Blueprints into User Journey Mapping

User Journey Mapping and Experience Blueprints are pivotal tools in the world of user experience...

Decentralized Finance: DeFi: Uniswap and DeFi: Revolutionizing Finance in the Digital Age

Decentralized Finance, commonly known as DeFi, represents a shift from traditional, centralized...

Neurodiversity advocacy organizations: Inclusive Innovation: How Neurodiversity Drives Business Success

Neurodiversity is a term that recognizes the natural variation in human cognition and behavior. It...

Formula Auditing: Formula Auditing: Ensuring Accuracy Beyond FIXED in Excel

Formula auditing in Excel is a critical process for anyone who relies on the accuracy and integrity...

Data VPN service: Data VPN Services: Safeguarding Your Business s Confidential Information

In the digital era, where data breaches are not just a possibility but a common occurrence, the...

Time Consciousness: Time Horizon: Time Horizon: Planning for the Short and Long Term

In the realm of time consciousness, the notion of a temporal perspective is pivotal. It...

Psychological Triggers for Startup Growth

Social proof is a psychological phenomenon where people assume the actions of others in an attempt...