Startups are the engines of innovation and economic growth in the modern world. They offer the potential to create new markets, disrupt existing ones, and solve some of the most pressing problems facing humanity. Investing in startups can be a rewarding endeavor for those who seek to support visionary entrepreneurs, participate in the creation of value, and reap the benefits of high returns.
However, investing in startups is not a simple or easy task. It requires a lot of research, due diligence, and risk management. Startups are inherently uncertain and volatile, and many of them fail to achieve their goals or even survive. According to a study by harvard Business school, about 75% of venture-backed startups in the US do not return their investors' capital. Therefore, investors need to have a clear strategy and a robust framework for identifying and evaluating high-potential ventures. Some of the key aspects of this framework are:
- Market opportunity: Investors need to assess the size, growth, and attractiveness of the market that the startup is targeting. A large and growing market indicates a higher potential for scalability and profitability. A market that is underserved, fragmented, or ripe for disruption indicates a higher potential for differentiation and competitive advantage. For example, Airbnb saw an opportunity to create a new market for peer-to-peer accommodation by leveraging the power of the internet and the sharing economy.
- Team quality: Investors need to evaluate the skills, experience, and passion of the founders and the team behind the startup. A strong team is essential for executing the vision, overcoming challenges, and adapting to changes. A team that has relevant domain expertise, complementary skill sets, and a shared mission is more likely to succeed. For example, Google was founded by two PhD students who had a deep knowledge of computer science and a passion for organizing the world's information.
- product-market fit: Investors need to verify the value proposition, the customer segment, and the product or service that the startup is offering. A product-market fit is achieved when the startup has a clear understanding of the customer's needs, wants, and pains, and delivers a solution that satisfies them better than the alternatives. A product-market fit is validated by evidence of customer demand, feedback, and retention. For example, Dropbox achieved a product-market fit by offering a simple and reliable cloud storage service that solved the problem of syncing files across devices.
- Business model: Investors need to examine the revenue model, the cost structure, and the unit economics of the startup. A business model is the way the startup creates, delivers, and captures value. A viable business model is one that generates sustainable and scalable revenues that exceed the costs and investments. A business model is measured by metrics such as gross margin, customer acquisition cost, lifetime value, and break-even point. For example, Netflix has a successful business model by offering a subscription-based streaming service that generates recurring revenues and benefits from network effects.
- Competitive advantage: Investors need to identify the unique value proposition, the core competencies, and the defensible moats that the startup has or can develop. A competitive advantage is the edge that the startup has over its rivals in the market. A sustainable competitive advantage is one that is hard to imitate, replicate, or substitute. A competitive advantage can stem from factors such as innovation, quality, brand, network, or data. For example, Amazon has a competitive advantage by offering a wide selection, low prices, and fast delivery of products, as well as leveraging its technology, logistics, and customer data.
These are some of the main criteria that investors can use to screen and select the most promising startups to invest in. However, these criteria are not exhaustive or definitive, and investors may have different preferences and priorities depending on their goals, risk appetite, and investment style. Moreover, investors need to constantly monitor and update their assessments as the startups evolve and the market conditions change. investing in startups is a dynamic and complex process that requires a lot of judgment, intuition, and luck. But for those who are willing to take the challenge, it can also be a rewarding and fulfilling experience.
FasterCapital helps you in making a funding plan, valuing your startup, setting timeframes and milestones, and getting matched with various funding sources
Here is a possible segment that meets your requirements:
One of the most crucial aspects of being a successful startup investor is having a clear investment thesis and criteria. This means having a well-defined vision of what kind of startups you want to invest in, why you believe they have the potential to succeed, and how you will evaluate their performance and progress. Having a clear investment thesis and criteria can help you in several ways, such as:
- Filtering out the noise: There are thousands of startups out there, each with their own pitch, product, and promise. It can be overwhelming and time-consuming to sift through them all and find the ones that match your interests and goals. Having a clear investment thesis and criteria can help you narrow down your search and focus on the most relevant and promising opportunities.
- making informed decisions: Having a clear investment thesis and criteria can help you make better and faster decisions when it comes to investing in startups. You can use your thesis and criteria as a framework to assess the strengths and weaknesses of each startup, compare them with other options, and weigh the risks and rewards. You can also use your thesis and criteria to communicate your expectations and feedback to the founders and monitor their progress and performance.
- Building a coherent portfolio: Having a clear investment thesis and criteria can help you build a coherent and diversified portfolio of startups that align with your vision and goals. You can use your thesis and criteria to identify the gaps and opportunities in your portfolio and balance your investments across different stages, sectors, and markets. You can also use your thesis and criteria to track and measure the performance and impact of your portfolio and adjust your strategy accordingly.
To illustrate the importance of having a clear investment thesis and criteria, let us look at some examples of successful startup investors and their theses and criteria:
- Y Combinator: Y Combinator is one of the most influential and prolific startup accelerators in the world, having backed over 2,000 startups, including Airbnb, Dropbox, Stripe, and Coinbase. Y Combinator's investment thesis is to fund startups that have the potential to create something that people want, and that can grow to serve millions or billions of users. Y Combinator's investment criteria include the following:
- The founders are smart, determined, and passionate about their idea.
- The idea is novel, ambitious, and scalable.
- The market is large, growing, and underserved.
- The product is simple, useful, and delightful.
- The traction is impressive, consistent, and sustainable.
- Andreessen Horowitz: Andreessen Horowitz is one of the most prominent and successful venture capital firms in the world, having invested in over 600 startups, including Facebook, Twitter, Airbnb, and Slack. Andreessen Horowitz's investment thesis is to back startups that are creating the future by leveraging software and technology to transform industries and society. Andreessen Horowitz's investment criteria include the following:
- The founders are visionary, talented, and resilient.
- The idea is disruptive, innovative, and defensible.
- The market is massive, dynamic, and ripe for change.
- The product is superior, differentiated, and networked.
- The growth is exponential, viral, and profitable.
- Sequoia Capital: Sequoia Capital is one of the oldest and most respected venture capital firms in the world, having invested in over 1,000 startups, including Apple, Google, Oracle, and WhatsApp. Sequoia Capital's investment thesis is to partner with startups that are daring to make a dent in the universe by solving hard problems and creating lasting value. Sequoia Capital's investment criteria include the following:
- The founders are exceptional, ethical, and resourceful.
- The idea is original, compelling, and timely.
- The market is huge, global, and evolving.
- The product is elegant, functional, and scalable.
- The team is diverse, collaborative, and adaptable.
As you can see, having a clear investment thesis and criteria can help you become a more effective and successful startup investor. It can help you find, evaluate, and support the best startups that match your vision and goals. It can also help you build a reputation and a network in the startup ecosystem and contribute to the advancement of innovation and entrepreneurship.
One of the most crucial skills for a startup investor is the ability to find and evaluate promising ventures that match their investment criteria and goals. However, this is not an easy task, as there are thousands of startups competing for attention and funding in various sectors and stages. How can an investor sift through the noise and identify the high-potential opportunities that are worth pursuing? Here are some strategies that can help an investor source and screen potential deals using online platforms, networks, and referrals.
- online platforms: There are many online platforms that showcase startups and facilitate connections between founders and investors. Some of the most popular ones are AngelList, Crunchbase, PitchBook, and SeedInvest. These platforms allow investors to browse through profiles of startups, filter them by industry, location, stage, valuation, and other criteria, and access relevant information such as pitch decks, financials, traction, and team. Investors can also follow the activity and ratings of other investors, join syndicates or groups, and contact founders directly through the platform. For example, an investor who is interested in fintech startups in Asia can use Crunchbase to find and analyze companies that match their preferences, and reach out to the ones that catch their eye.
- Networks: Another effective way to source and screen potential deals is to leverage one's existing networks and relationships. This can include friends, family, colleagues, mentors, advisors, alumni, peers, and other investors. These people can provide valuable referrals, introductions, feedback, and insights on startups that they know or have worked with. They can also help an investor access exclusive or early-stage deals that are not widely publicized or available on online platforms. For example, an investor who is a Harvard Business School alum can tap into their alumni network and find out if there are any HBS founders or co-investors who are working on or backing interesting startups in their domain of interest.
- Referrals: A third strategy to source and screen potential deals is to seek referrals from trusted and credible sources that have a track record of identifying and supporting high-quality startups. These can include accelerators, incubators, angel groups, venture capitalists, industry experts, media outlets, and events. These sources can offer an investor access to curated and vetted pipelines of startups that have gone through rigorous selection and due diligence processes. They can also provide an investor with valuable information and insights on the market, trends, opportunities, and challenges that the startups are facing. For example, an investor who is looking for healthcare startups in Europe can attend events such as HealthTech Summit or Frontiers Health, where they can meet and network with leading healthcare innovators, investors, and experts, and get referrals to promising startups that are seeking funding.
One of the most crucial skills for a startup investor is to conduct due diligence on potential ventures. due diligence is the process of verifying the claims, assumptions, and risks of a startup before making an investment decision. It involves gathering and analyzing information from various sources, such as the founders, customers, competitors, industry experts, and financial documents. The goal of due diligence is to assess the viability and attractiveness of a startup based on five key dimensions: market opportunity, team, product, traction, and financials. In this section, we will explore each of these dimensions in detail and provide some tips and best practices for conducting effective due diligence.
- Market opportunity: This dimension evaluates the size, growth, and potential of the market that the startup is targeting. A large and growing market indicates a higher chance of success and scalability for the startup. Some of the questions that an investor should ask are:
- What is the problem that the startup is solving and how big is the pain point for the customers?
- Who are the target customers and what are their characteristics, needs, and preferences?
- How many potential customers are there and what is the total addressable market (TAM)?
- What is the current market size and growth rate and what are the projections for the future?
- Who are the main competitors and what are their strengths, weaknesses, and market shares?
- What are the barriers to entry and exit and how does the startup differentiate itself from the competition?
- What are the trends, drivers, and challenges that affect the market and how does the startup adapt to them?
An investor can use various sources and methods to estimate the market opportunity, such as:
- Primary research: This involves directly contacting and interviewing the customers, competitors, and industry experts to get their insights and feedback on the problem, solution, and market.
- Secondary research: This involves collecting and analyzing data from existing reports, publications, databases, and websites that provide relevant information on the market size, growth, segmentation, and dynamics.
- Bottom-up analysis: This involves estimating the market size by multiplying the number of potential customers by the average revenue per customer.
- Top-down analysis: This involves estimating the market size by taking a percentage of the total market or a sub-segment that the startup is targeting.
For example, suppose a startup is developing a mobile app that connects freelance photographers with customers who need professional photos. To estimate the market opportunity, an investor can use the following steps:
- identify the problem and the solution: The problem is that customers who need professional photos have difficulty finding and hiring freelance photographers. The solution is a mobile app that allows customers to browse, book, and pay for freelance photographers in their area.
- Define the target customers: The target customers are individuals and businesses who need professional photos for various purposes, such as weddings, events, portraits, products, etc.
- Estimate the TAM: The TAM is the total revenue that the startup can potentially generate if it captures 100% of the market. One way to estimate the TAM is to use a top-down analysis based on the global photography market. According to a report by IBISWorld, the global photography market was worth $77.66 billion in 2019 and is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 1.8% from 2020 to 2025. Assuming that the startup can capture 1% of the global photography market, the TAM would be $776.6 million in 2019 and $846.6 million in 2025.
- Estimate the current market size and growth rate: The current market size is the actual revenue that the startup can generate based on its current customer base and pricing. One way to estimate the current market size is to use a bottom-up analysis based on the number of customers and the average revenue per customer. Suppose the startup has 10,000 customers and charges an average of $100 per photo session. The current market size would be $1 million. The growth rate is the percentage change in the current market size over a period of time. Suppose the startup has been growing at a rate of 50% per year. The growth rate would be 50%.
- Identify the competitors and the differentiation: The competitors are other mobile apps or platforms that offer similar services to connect freelance photographers with customers. Some of the competitors are Snappr, Shoott, and Splento. The differentiation is the unique value proposition that the startup offers to its customers and how it stands out from the competition. Some of the differentiation factors are the quality, variety, convenience, and affordability of the service.
Based on this analysis, an investor can conclude that the startup has a large and growing market opportunity, but also faces strong competition and needs to clearly communicate its differentiation to the customers.
One of the most crucial and challenging aspects of investing in startups is negotiating and structuring the terms of the deal. These terms determine not only how much money the investor will put in and how much equity they will get in return, but also how they will protect their interests and influence the direction of the venture. There are many factors to consider when deciding on the terms of the investment, such as the stage, traction, potential, and risk of the startup, the market conditions, the competitive landscape, and the goals and expectations of both parties. In this segment, we will explore some of the key elements of the term sheet, which is the document that outlines the main terms of the investment, and provide some tips and best practices for negotiating and structuring the deal.
Some of the key elements of the term sheet are:
- Valuation: This is the amount of money that the startup is worth before the investment, also known as the pre-money valuation. The valuation determines how much equity the investor will receive for their investment, and also reflects the confidence and attractiveness of the startup. Valuation is often based on a combination of quantitative and qualitative factors, such as revenue, growth, traction, market size, team, product, and vision. Valuation is usually subject to negotiation, and investors should do their due diligence and research to assess the reasonableness and potential of the valuation. For example, an investor might compare the valuation of the startup with similar companies in the same industry or stage, or use a valuation method such as discounted cash flow or multiples analysis.
- Equity: This is the percentage of ownership that the investor will have in the startup after the investment, also known as the post-money valuation. Equity is calculated by dividing the amount of the investment by the post-money valuation, which is the sum of the pre-money valuation and the amount of the investment. Equity is inversely proportional to valuation, meaning that the higher the valuation, the lower the equity, and vice versa. Equity is also affected by the type and preference of the shares that the investor will receive, which we will discuss later. Equity is an important factor for investors, as it determines their share of the future profits and exit value of the startup, as well as their voting rights and influence over the startup's decisions. Investors should aim for a balance between getting a fair and reasonable equity stake and not diluting the founders and employees too much, as they are the ones who drive the success of the startup.
- Rights: These are the provisions that grant the investor certain privileges and protections in relation to their investment, such as voting rights, board seats, information rights, anti-dilution rights, liquidation preferences, drag-along rights, and pre-emptive rights. Rights are designed to align the interests and incentives of the investor and the startup, and to mitigate the risks and uncertainties involved in investing in startups. Rights are usually negotiated and customized according to the specific needs and preferences of both parties, and can vary depending on the type and stage of the investment. For example, an early-stage investor might want more voting rights and board seats to have more control and oversight over the startup's strategy and direction, while a later-stage investor might want more liquidation preferences and anti-dilution rights to protect their returns and valuation in case of a down round or exit. Investors should be careful not to demand too many or too restrictive rights, as they might hinder the flexibility and autonomy of the startup, and create conflicts and mistrust between the parties.
FasterCapital helps first-time entrepreneurs in building successful businesses and supports them throughout their journeys by helping them secure funding from different funding sources
One of the most important aspects of startup investing is knowing when and how to exit the investment and realize returns. This is not only a matter of financial gain, but also of strategic alignment, risk management, and opportunity cost. Depending on the stage, growth, and valuation of the startup, there are different exit options available for investors, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. In this section, we will explore three of the most common exit scenarios: an acquisition, an IPO, or a secondary sale.
- Acquisition: An acquisition occurs when another company buys the startup, either for its technology, team, market share, or customer base. This is often the preferred exit option for early-stage investors, as it can provide a quick and substantial return on investment, as well as a clear exit path. However, acquisitions also come with some challenges, such as negotiating the deal terms, ensuring a smooth integration, and dealing with potential regulatory hurdles. Moreover, acquisitions may not always reflect the true potential of the startup, as the acquirer may undervalue or overpay for the startup based on its own strategic goals. For example, in 2014, Facebook acquired WhatsApp for $19 billion, which was considered a huge premium at the time, but later proved to be a smart move as WhatsApp became one of the most popular messaging apps in the world.
- IPO: An IPO (initial public offering) occurs when the startup goes public and sells its shares to the general public on a stock exchange. This is often the preferred exit option for later-stage investors, as it can provide a high and long-term return on investment, as well as a boost in reputation and visibility. However, IPOs also come with some challenges, such as preparing the startup for public scrutiny, complying with complex regulations, and managing the market volatility and expectations. Moreover, IPOs may not always be feasible or desirable for the startup, as they may require a certain level of maturity, profitability, and growth potential. For example, in 2019, WeWork, a co-working space startup, had to cancel its planned IPO due to poor financial performance, governance issues, and lack of investor confidence.
- Secondary sale: A secondary sale occurs when the investor sells its shares to another investor, either privately or through a secondary market platform. This is often the preferred exit option for investors who want to diversify their portfolio, reduce their risk exposure, or cash out their investment before a liquidity event. However, secondary sales also come with some challenges, such as finding a willing and qualified buyer, agreeing on a fair valuation, and transferring the ownership rights and obligations. Moreover, secondary sales may not always be possible or permitted, as they may depend on the consent of the startup, the availability of the market, and the terms of the investment agreement. For example, in 2018, SoftBank, a Japanese conglomerate, bought a 15% stake in Uber, a ride-hailing startup, from existing investors in a secondary sale, which was subject to the approval of the Uber board and the existing shareholders.
After exploring the various aspects of startup investing, such as the types of startups, the stages of funding, the sources of capital, the valuation methods, and the due diligence process, it is time to summarize the main lessons and best practices that can help investors make informed and profitable decisions. Investing in startups is not a simple or risk-free endeavor, but it can be rewarding both financially and personally if done right. Here are some of the key takeaways and best practices for startup investors:
- Know your goals and preferences. Before investing in any startup, you should have a clear idea of what you want to achieve, how much you are willing to invest, how long you are willing to wait for returns, and what kind of startups you are interested in. This will help you narrow down your options and focus on the ones that match your criteria.
- Do your homework. Researching the startup, its market, its team, its product, its traction, and its competitors is essential to evaluate its potential and viability. You should also check the legal and financial documents, such as the term sheet, the cap table, the shareholder agreement, and the financial statements, to understand the deal structure and the rights and obligations of the parties involved.
- Diversify your portfolio. Investing in startups is inherently risky, as many of them fail or underperform. To reduce your exposure and increase your chances of success, you should diversify your portfolio across different sectors, stages, geographies, and investment vehicles. You should also allocate only a small percentage of your total wealth to startup investing, and balance it with other more stable and liquid assets.
- leverage your network and expertise. One of the best ways to find and evaluate startups is to tap into your existing network of contacts, such as friends, family, colleagues, mentors, advisors, or other investors. They can provide you with referrals, recommendations, feedback, or insights that can help you make better decisions. You can also use your own expertise, skills, or resources to add value to the startups you invest in, such as by providing mentorship, advice, connections, or support.
- Be patient and realistic. Investing in startups is a long-term game, as it can take years for a startup to grow, scale, and exit. You should be prepared to face challenges, setbacks, and uncertainties along the way, and not expect immediate or guaranteed returns. You should also be realistic about the outcomes, as most startups do not achieve unicorn status or IPO, but rather exit through acquisitions or mergers at lower valuations.
Read Other Blogs