Stock appreciation rights: How to give your employees the benefit of stock price increase without issuing shares

1. Understanding Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)

1. What Are stock Appreciation rights (SARs)?

Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) are a form of equity compensation that allows employees to benefit from the increase in a company's stock price over a specified period. Unlike stock options, which grant the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price, SARs provide employees with the monetary equivalent of the stock price appreciation.

2. How Do SARs Work?

- Granting Process: Companies grant SARs to eligible employees as part of their compensation package. The grant typically specifies the number of SARs awarded.

- Vesting Period: SARs have a vesting period, during which employees must remain with the company to receive the benefit. Vesting can be time-based (e.g., four years with a one-year cliff) or performance-based (linked to company performance metrics).

- Settlement Options:

- Cash Settlement: Upon exercise, employees receive the difference between the stock price at exercise and the grant price in cash.

- Phantom Shares: Employees receive a notional number of shares (phantom shares) equivalent to the SARs' value. These shares are not actual shares but represent the economic benefit.

- exercise price: The exercise price (also called the base price) is the stock price at the time of grant. When employees exercise their SARs, they receive the appreciation above this base price.

3. Advantages of SARs:

- No Out-of-Pocket Cost: Unlike stock options, employees don't need to buy shares upfront. They receive the appreciation without investing their own money.

- Cash Settlement: Employees receive cash, making SARs more attractive for those who prefer liquidity.

- Alignment with stock performance: SARs directly tie employee rewards to the company's stock price performance.

4. Considerations and Challenges:

- Dilution: While SARs don't dilute shareholders directly (as no new shares are issued), they still impact the company's overall equity pool.

- Tax Implications: Tax treatment varies by country. In the U.S., SARs are taxed as ordinary income upon exercise.

- Communication: Clear communication about SARs is crucial to ensure employees understand their benefits.

5. Example Scenario:

- Company X grants SARs to an employee with a base price of $50 per share.

- Over the vesting period, the stock price increases to $80 per share.

- The employee exercises the SARs and receives $30 per share ($80 - $50) in cash.

In summary, SARs provide a flexible way to reward employees based on stock price appreciation. Companies can tailor SARs to their specific needs, balancing employee motivation, retention, and shareholder interests. Remember, each company's SAR program may have unique features, so consult with legal and financial experts for precise guidance.

Don't know how to estimate your startup value?

FasterCapital's experts work with you on valuing your startup through applying different valuation methods and planning for your coming rounds

Join us!

2. What Are Stock Appreciation Rights?

1. What Are Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)?

Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) are a form of equity-based compensation that allows employees to benefit from the increase in a company's stock price over a specified period. Unlike stock options, which grant the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price, SARs provide employees with the monetary equivalent of the stock price appreciation.

2. How Do SARs Work?

- Granting Process: Companies grant SARs to eligible employees as part of their compensation package. The number of SARs awarded depends on factors such as job level, performance, and tenure.

- Vesting Period: SARs typically have a vesting period during which employees must remain with the company to receive the full benefit. Vesting can be time-based (e.g., three years) or performance-based (linked to specific goals).

- Settlement Options:

- Cash-Settled SARs: Upon exercise, employees receive a cash payout equal to the difference between the stock price at exercise and the grant price.

- Phantom Stock SARs: Similar to cash-settled SARs, but the payout is based on a hypothetical number of phantom shares.

- Equity-Settled SARs: Employees receive actual company shares upon exercise.

- Exercise Price: Unlike stock options, SARs have no exercise price. Employees receive the appreciation value directly.

- Expiration: SARs have an expiration date (usually after the vesting period). If not exercised, they expire.

3. Advantages of SARs:

- No Out-of-Pocket Cost: Employees don't need to buy shares; they receive cash or stock directly.

- Alignment with Shareholders: SARs tie employee compensation to stock performance, aligning interests.

- Flexibility: Companies can tailor SARs to fit their specific needs (e.g., performance conditions).

- Retention Tool: Vesting encourages employee retention.

4. Considerations and Challenges:

- Dilution: SARs don't dilute existing shareholders directly, but they still impact the company's equity pool.

- Accounting Complexity: Companies must account for SARs as a liability or equity, affecting financial statements.

- Tax Implications: Tax treatment varies by country and type of SAR. Employees may face income tax upon exercise.

- Communication: Clear communication about SARs is crucial to ensure employees understand their benefits.

5. Example Scenario:

- Company X grants SARs to its top executives.

- Grant: 1,000 SARs with a grant price of $50.

- Vesting: Over three years.

- Stock Price at Exercise: $70.

- Cash-Settled: Upon exercise, executives receive $20,000 (1,000 SARs × ($70 - $50)).

- Equity-Settled: Alternatively, they receive 1,000 actual shares.

In summary, Stock Appreciation Rights provide an innovative way to reward employees while avoiding share issuance. Companies must carefully design their SAR programs, considering legal, accounting, and communication aspects. Whether you're an employer or an employee, understanding SARs can enhance your knowledge of equity compensation.

An entrepreneur assumes the risk and is dedicated and committed to the success of whatever he or she undertakes.

Victor Kiam

3. Advantages of SARs for Employees

1. Financial Upside Without Ownership Burden:

- SARs allow employees to benefit from the appreciation in the company's stock price without actually owning the shares. This is particularly advantageous for employees who may not want to hold company stock directly due to diversification concerns or other reasons.

- Example: Imagine an employee, Jane, who receives SARs as part of her compensation package. If the company's stock price increases, Jane can exercise her SARs and receive the difference between the grant price and the market price in cash or additional shares.

2. Retention and Motivation:

- SARs serve as powerful retention tools. When employees have a stake in the company's success, they are more likely to stay with the organization.

- Example: John, a talented software engineer, receives SARs tied to the company's stock performance. As the stock price rises, John's vested SARs become more valuable, motivating him to contribute to the company's growth.

3. Flexibility in Timing:

- Unlike stock options, which have specific exercise windows, SARs offer flexibility. Employees can choose when to exercise them, allowing them to optimize tax implications and market conditions.

- Example: Maria holds SARs that vest over several years. She decides to exercise them when the stock price reaches an all-time high, maximizing her gains.

4. No Out-of-Pocket Cost:

- SARs do not require employees to pay an exercise price upfront. They receive the appreciation value without any initial investment.

- Example: David, a marketing manager, receives SARs as part of his annual bonus. When the stock price rises, David can cash in the appreciation without spending his own money.

5. Performance-Driven Compensation:

- SARs tie rewards directly to company performance. Employees benefit when the company thrives, fostering a sense of ownership and alignment.

- Example: Sarah, a sales executive, receives SARs linked to revenue growth. As the company achieves sales targets, Sarah's SARs gain value, reinforcing her commitment.

6. Avoiding Dilution:

- Unlike stock options, which dilute existing shareholders when exercised, SARs do not result in additional shares being issued. This is beneficial for both employees and shareholders.

- Example: The company grants SARs to its top executives. As the stock price appreciates, the executives receive cash settlements without affecting the overall share count.

7. Tax Efficiency:

- SARs are typically taxed as ordinary income upon exercise. However, this simplicity can be advantageous for employees who prefer straightforward tax treatment.

- Example: Tom, a finance manager, exercises his SARs and receives cash. The tax withholding is straightforward, and Tom can plan accordingly.

In summary, Stock Appreciation Rights provide employees with a stake in the company's success, financial rewards, and flexibility—all without the complexities of direct stock ownership. By understanding these advantages, companies can design effective compensation programs that motivate and retain their workforce while preserving shareholder interests. Remember, the key lies in thoughtful implementation and clear communication to ensure employees fully appreciate the benefits of SARs.

4. Designing an Effective SAR Program

1. Understanding Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs):

- Definition: SARs are a form of equity compensation that provides employees with the right to receive the appreciation in the company's stock value over a specified period.

- Mechanism: Unlike stock options, which grant the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price (strike price), SARs don't require employees to buy shares. Instead, they receive cash or additional shares equivalent to the stock price increase.

- Flexibility: SARs can be structured as "phantom" or "cash-settled" plans, where employees receive cash, or as "equity-settled" plans, where they receive additional shares.

2. Design Considerations:

- Vesting Schedule: Companies must decide on the vesting period (e.g., 3 years) and cliff (initial waiting period). Longer vesting encourages retention.

- Performance Metrics: Link SARs to performance metrics (e.g., stock price growth, revenue, EBITDA) to align with company goals.

- Eligibility Criteria: Define eligibility based on job roles, tenure, or performance levels.

- Communication: Transparently communicate SAR terms to employees to foster understanding and buy-in.

3. Pros and Cons:

- Advantages:

- Retention: SARs encourage employees to stay with the company to realize the appreciation.

- No Dilution: No need to issue new shares, preserving existing shareholders' ownership.

- cash Flow friendly: Cash-settled SARs don't require immediate cash outflow.

- Challenges:

- Complexity: Employees may find SARs harder to grasp than stock options.

- Accounting Impact: Equity-settled SARs affect financial statements.

- Market Volatility: Stock price fluctuations impact SAR value.

4. Example Scenarios:

- Startup Scenario:

- Company X, a tech startup, grants SARs to early employees. As the company grows, SARs appreciate significantly. Employees exercise them, receiving cash or additional shares.

- Mature Corporation Scenario:

- Company Y, an established manufacturer, implements SARs for senior executives. The SARs vest over 4 years, tied to revenue growth. Executives stay motivated to drive company performance.

5. Tax Implications:

- Tax Timing: Employees pay taxes upon SAR exercise (cash-settled) or upon sale of shares (equity-settled).

- Section 409A: Comply with IRS regulations to avoid penalties.

- Global Considerations: Different tax treatments worldwide.

6. Employee Education and Engagement:

- Workshops: Conduct workshops explaining SAR mechanics, tax implications, and long-term benefits.

- Regular Updates: Keep employees informed about stock performance and SAR value.

- Link to Goals: Show how SARs align with individual and company objectives.

In summary, designing an effective SAR program involves balancing complexity, communication, and alignment with organizational goals. By tailoring SARs to your company's unique context, you can create a powerful incentive that benefits both employees and shareholders. Remember, the success of any compensation program lies in its thoughtful design and seamless execution.

5. Eligibility and Vesting

1. Understanding Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)

Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) are a form of equity compensation that allows employees to benefit from the increase in a company's stock price over a specified period. Unlike stock options, SARs do not grant actual shares; instead, they provide a cash payout equal to the appreciation in stock value.

2. Eligibility for SARs: Who Qualifies?

- Employees: Typically, SARs are granted to employees, including executives, managers, and other staff. Consultants and contractors may also be eligible, depending on company policy.

- Performance Criteria: Companies often tie SAR grants to performance metrics, such as tenure, job level, or individual performance. high-performing employees may receive larger SAR grants.

- Vesting Schedule: Eligibility is closely linked to the vesting schedule. Employees must remain with the company until the SARs fully vest to realize the benefits.

3. Vesting Period and Cliff: The Waiting Game

- Vesting Period: SARs vest over time, usually spanning three to five years. Vesting can be linear (e.g., 20% per year) or cliff-based (e.g., 100% after three years).

- Cliff Vesting: Some companies use cliff vesting, where SARs vest entirely after a specific period (e.g., three years). This encourages employee retention.

- Golden Handcuffs: By linking vesting to tenure, companies create "golden handcuffs," incentivizing employees to stay longer.

4. Accelerated Vesting: When Things Change

- Change of Control: If the company undergoes a merger, acquisition, or IPO, SARs may accelerate. Employees receive the full benefit even if they haven't completed the vesting period.

- Good Leaver vs. Bad Leaver: Companies define "good leavers" (e.g., retirement, disability) and "bad leavers" (e.g., termination for cause). Good leavers often retain vested SARs, while bad leavers forfeit them.

5. Example Scenarios:

- Scenario 1: John's Journey

- John joins XYZ Corp and receives SARs with a four-year vesting period. After two years, he leaves for personal reasons.

- Result: John keeps the vested portion but forfeits unvested SARs.

- Scenario 2: Company Acquisition

- ABC Inc. Acquires XYZ Corp. All employees' SARs accelerate due to the change of control.

- Result: Employees receive the full benefit immediately.

6. Tax Implications:

- Phantom Income: Employees pay taxes on the SARs' appreciation, even if they haven't sold any shares.

- Withholding: Companies often withhold taxes at vesting to cover the liability.

- Capital Gains: Upon exercise, SARs become taxable as capital gains.

7. Communication Matters:

- Transparency: Clear communication about SARs, vesting, and tax implications is crucial. Employees need to understand the mechanics.

- Education: Regular sessions or written materials can educate employees about SARs and their benefits.

Remember, each company's SAR program may vary, so it's essential to consult legal and financial experts when implementing SARs. By granting SARs strategically, companies can align employee interests with long-term company success while avoiding share dilution.

Raising capital is challenging. We can help!

FasterCapital's team works on matching you with the right funding sources and presents your startup to them through warm introductions

Join us!

6. Valuation and Calculation of SARs

### Understanding Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)

Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) are a form of equity compensation that allows employees to benefit from the increase in a company's stock price over a specified period. Unlike stock options, which grant the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price (the exercise price), SARs don't require employees to buy shares. Instead, they receive the monetary equivalent of the stock price appreciation.

#### How SARs Work

1. Granting SARs:

- Companies grant SARs to key employees as part of their compensation package.

- SARs can be awarded individually or as part of a broader incentive plan.

- The grant terms specify the number of SARs, vesting schedule, and exercise conditions.

2. Vesting and Exercise:

- SARs typically vest over a specific period (e.g., three years) to encourage employee retention.

- Once vested, employees can exercise their SARs.

- Exercise can be in cash (cash-settled SARs) or shares (equity-settled SARs).

3. Calculation of SAR Value:

- The value of SARs depends on the stock price increase.

- The formula for calculating SAR value is straightforward:

```

SAR Value = (Stock Price at Exercise - Stock Price at Grant) × Number of SARs

```

- Example: Suppose an employee has 1,000 SARs granted when the stock price is $50, and the stock price at exercise is $70. The SAR value would be:

```

SAR Value = ($70 - $50) × 1,000 = $20,000

```

4. Tax Implications:

- Tax treatment varies by country and plan design.

- In the United States, cash-settled SARs are taxed as ordinary income upon exercise.

- Equity-settled SARs may have capital gains tax implications.

5. Employee Perspective:

- Employees appreciate SARs because they don't need to invest their own money.

- SARs align their interests with shareholders by linking rewards to stock performance.

- However, employees should understand the tax implications.

6. Company Perspective:

- Companies use SARs to retain talent, motivate employees, and conserve shares.

- SARs can be tailored to specific performance metrics or goals.

- Dilution is avoided since no new shares are issued.

7. Challenges and Considerations:

- setting the exercise price appropriately to ensure meaningful rewards.

- Balancing the desire for simplicity with effective communication.

- Monitoring stock price volatility and adjusting grant levels accordingly.

In summary, SARs provide a win-win scenario: employees benefit from stock price appreciation, and companies retain flexibility in managing their equity structure. As with any compensation tool, thoughtful design and clear communication are essential for maximizing the impact of SARs.

Remember, the success of SARs lies not only in their financial mechanics but also in fostering a sense of ownership and alignment between employees and the company's long-term goals.

7. Tax Implications of SARs

From the perspective of employees, SARs can be a valuable incentive as they provide the opportunity to share in the company's success and financial growth. When the stock price rises, employees with SARs can receive a cash payment or additional shares based on the increase in value. This can serve as a motivation for employees to contribute to the company's performance and align their interests with those of the shareholders.

From a tax perspective, the treatment of SARs can vary depending on the jurisdiction and specific circumstances. Generally, SARs are subject to taxation at the time of exercise or settlement. The taxable amount is typically calculated as the difference between the fair market value of the stock at the time of exercise and the exercise price. This amount is considered as ordinary income and is subject to income tax and potentially other applicable taxes, such as social security or medicare taxes.

It's important to note that tax laws and regulations can be complex and may change over time. Therefore, it is advisable for both employers and employees to consult with tax professionals or experts to fully understand the tax implications of SARs in their specific situation.

Got no clue how to start your funding round?

FasterCapital helps you in making a funding plan, valuing your startup, setting timeframes and milestones, and getting matched with various funding sources

Join us!

8. Communication and Employee Engagement

1. Understanding the Basics of SARs:

- Stock appreciation rights (SARs) are a form of equity compensation that allows employees to benefit from the increase in the company's stock price without actually owning the shares.

- Unlike stock options, which grant the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price, SARs provide employees with the equivalent monetary value of the stock price appreciation.

- Communication about SARs should begin during the grant process. Employees need to comprehend the mechanics, vesting schedule, and tax implications.

2. Transparency and Clarity:

- Employees appreciate transparency. Clearly communicate the purpose of SARs, how they align with company goals, and how they contribute to overall compensation.

- Avoid jargon and complex terms. Use simple language to explain SARs, emphasizing their benefits.

- Regularly update employees on the stock performance and the impact on their SARs. transparency builds trust.

3. Engaging Employees in the Process:

- involve employees in decision-making. Seek their input on matters related to stock-based compensation.

- Conduct town hall meetings, webinars, or workshops specifically dedicated to SARs. Encourage questions and discussions.

- share success stories of employees who have benefited from SARs. personal narratives resonate well.

4. Educating Employees:

- Not all employees are financially savvy. Provide educational resources on stock markets, stock valuation, and SARs.

- Explain the difference between vested and unvested SARs. Help employees understand the potential financial gains.

- Use relatable examples: "Imagine if you had SARs during the last stock surge—here's how much you would have gained."

5. Timely Communication:

- Keep employees informed about stock price fluctuations. Regular updates prevent surprises.

- Announce significant milestones, such as hitting all-time highs or achieving performance targets.

- Use multiple channels: emails, intranet, mobile apps, and even physical posters.

6. Incentivizing Performance:

- Tie SARs to performance metrics. When employees see a direct link between their efforts and SAR value, engagement increases.

- Recognize outstanding performance by granting additional SARs. Acknowledge contributions publicly.

- Consider team-based SARs to foster collaboration and a sense of collective ownership.

7. Addressing Concerns:

- Employees may worry about stock market volatility. Assure them that SARs protect against downside risk.

- Discuss tax implications. Employees need to understand the tax treatment upon exercise or payout.

- Be empathetic. Some employees may face financial constraints and might need to cash out early.

8. Feedback Loop:

- Create a feedback mechanism for employees to express their thoughts on SARs.

- Use surveys or focus groups to gather insights. Act on constructive feedback.

- Continuously improve communication strategies based on employee responses.

Remember, effective communication isn't a one-time event—it's an ongoing process. By fostering open dialogue, educating employees, and celebrating their successes, organizations can maximize the benefits of SARs while keeping employees engaged and motivated.

Feel free to reach out if you'd like further elaboration or additional examples!

9. Successful Implementation of SARs in Companies

1. Introduction to Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)

Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) are a powerful tool that allows companies to grant employees the economic benefits of stock price appreciation without actually issuing shares. Unlike stock options, which provide the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price, SARs offer cash or stock payouts based on the increase in the company's stock value over a specified period.

2. Case Study: Tech Startup "InnovateTech"

Background:

- InnovateTech, a high-growth tech startup, wanted to retain top talent while conserving equity.

- The company's founders were wary of diluting ownership by issuing additional shares.

Implementation:

- InnovateTech introduced a SARs program for key employees.

- Employees received SARs tied to the company's stock performance.

- When the stock price surged after a successful product launch, employees reaped the benefits.

Outcome:

- Employees felt a sense of ownership without actual equity ownership.

- InnovateTech retained valuable team members who contributed to its growth.

- The SARs program aligned employee interests with shareholder value.

3. Case Study: Established Manufacturer "Global Motors"

Background:

- Global Motors, a traditional manufacturing company, faced challenges in attracting and retaining talent.

- The company wanted to reward long-serving employees without issuing new shares.

Implementation:

- Global Motors granted SARs to senior executives and middle managers.

- SARs vested over a five-year period, linked to the company's stock performance.

- Employees received cash payouts equivalent to the stock price increase.

Outcome:

- Employee morale improved as they participated in the company's success.

- Global Motors avoided share dilution and maintained control.

- The SARs program became a retention tool during economic downturns.

4. Case Study: Financial Services Firm "CapitalEdge"

Background:

- CapitalEdge, a financial services firm, sought a flexible compensation strategy.

- The company aimed to incentivize performance without issuing additional shares.

Implementation:

- CapitalEdge designed a tiered SARs program for different employee levels.

- Executives received SARs with longer vesting periods, while junior staff had shorter vesting.

- The company periodically adjusted the SARs strike price based on market conditions.

Outcome:

- CapitalEdge attracted top talent by offering competitive compensation.

- The SARs program allowed the company to adapt to changing business needs.

- Employees appreciated the alignment between their efforts and financial rewards.

5. Key Takeaways

- Flexibility: SARs provide companies with flexibility in structuring rewards.

- Retention: SARs can retain employees during market volatility.

- Alignment: SARs align employee interests with shareholder value.

- No Dilution: Companies avoid share dilution while still rewarding employees.

Remember, these case studies illustrate the versatility and effectiveness of SARs, but each company's situation is unique. When implementing SARs, it's crucial to consider legal, tax, and accounting implications. As we conclude this section, let's celebrate the ingenuity of companies that have harnessed SARs to create win-win scenarios for employees and shareholders alike!