Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

The MVP Approach to Market Validation

1. Introduction to MVP and Market Validation

The concept of a Minimum Viable product (MVP) is central to the lean startup methodology, which emphasizes the importance of learning and iteration over meticulous planning. An MVP is the simplest version of a product that can be released to the market with enough features to attract early adopters. The feedback from these users is then used to guide future development. This approach allows companies to validate their market fit quickly and efficiently, minimizing the resources spent on products that do not meet market needs.

From the perspective of a startup founder, the MVP is a tool to test hypotheses about the business model. It answers critical questions such as whether the problem being addressed is significant enough that customers will pay for a solution, or if the solution proposed effectively solves the problem. For investors, an MVP demonstrates the team's ability to execute and gives a tangible product to evaluate. Customers, on the other hand, get an early look at an innovative solution and the opportunity to shape its development.

Here are some in-depth insights into the mvp and market validation process:

1. Identifying Core Features: The first step is to determine the essential functions that solve the core problem for your target customers. For example, if you're developing a task management app, the ability to create, edit, and check off tasks might be your core features.

2. Building the MVP: Once the core features are identified, the next step is to build the MVP. This should be done as quickly and inexpensively as possible. Using the task management app example, this could mean creating a simple web-based interface without any advanced features like tagging or file attachments.

3. Launching to Early Adopters: The MVP is then released to a small group of users who are most likely to feel the pain point the product aims to solve and provide feedback. Dropbox, for instance, initially launched a video demonstrating their product's concept to gauge user interest.

4. Gathering Feedback: Collecting and analyzing feedback is crucial. This can be done through surveys, interviews, or studying user behavior. The key is to understand what users like and dislike, what features they use the most, and what is missing.

5. Iterating Based on Feedback: With feedback in hand, the product is refined. This might mean adding new features, tweaking existing ones, or even pivoting entirely if the feedback suggests a different direction.

6. validating the Market fit: The ultimate goal is to reach a point where the product is meeting the needs of the market. This is often measured by metrics such as user retention, conversion rates, and word-of-mouth referrals.

7. Scaling Up: Once market fit is validated, the focus shifts to scaling the product and business model. This could involve seeking additional funding, expanding the team, and ramping up marketing efforts.

Through this iterative process, startups can minimize risk and build a product that truly meets the needs of their customers. The MVP and market validation are not one-time events but ongoing processes that continue throughout the lifecycle of the product.

Introduction to MVP and Market Validation - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

Introduction to MVP and Market Validation - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

2. Features and Functionality

When embarking on the journey of creating a Minimum Viable product (MVP), it's crucial to strike the right balance between simplicity and functionality. The MVP is a version of a new product that allows a team to collect the maximum amount of validated learning about customers with the least effort. It's not just about minimizing the product's features for the sake of a quick launch, but about finding the core features that define your product's value proposition. This process involves careful consideration of which features will demonstrate your product's potential to solve real problems and fulfill user needs without overcomplicating the initial offering. It's a delicate dance of prioritizing what's essential for market entry and what can be developed later, based on user feedback and market demand.

From the perspective of a startup founder, the MVP must address the primary problem their venture aims to solve. For a product manager, it's about defining the scope of the product while keeping in mind the constraints of time and resources. Meanwhile, a developer looks at the MVP as a project with clear, manageable goals that can be achieved without over-engineering. Each viewpoint contributes to a more rounded understanding of what the MVP should entail.

Here are some key considerations for defining your MVP's features and functionality:

1. Identify the Core Problem: Your MVP should focus on solving a core problem for your target audience. For example, if you're developing a task management app, the ability to create, edit, and track tasks would be essential.

2. Prioritize Features: Use a framework like MoSCoW (Must have, Should have, Could have, Won't have) to prioritize features. Must-haves are non-negotiable, such as secure login for a banking app.

3. Simplicity is Key: Aim for the simplest version that provides value. Take Dropbox, for instance; its MVP was a simple file-syncing service without the bells and whistles of file sharing or mobile access, which came later.

4. Feedback Loop: Incorporate a mechanism to gather user feedback. This could be as straightforward as a feedback form within the app or direct customer interviews.

5. Measure Success: Define what success looks like for your MVP. This might be a certain number of sign-ups, a level of user engagement, or specific customer actions.

6. Iterate Quickly: Be prepared to iterate based on feedback. The original MVP of Facebook was limited to Harvard students, but it quickly expanded based on user demand and feedback.

7. Technical Feasibility: Ensure that the features you include can be developed with the resources available. For example, a video streaming service must have a robust infrastructure from the start to handle the data load.

8. legal and compliance: Consider any legal and compliance issues that could affect your MVP. A health app, for instance, must comply with HIPAA regulations from the outset.

9. Market Fit: Test your MVP's features against market needs. Airbnb started with renting air mattresses on a floor during a conference when hotels were fully booked, proving a market need.

10. Scalability: Plan for scalability. Your MVP's architecture should not be a roadblock to future growth. Twitter, for example, had to overhaul its infrastructure to handle rapid user growth.

Defining your MVP is a strategic process that requires input from various stakeholders and a clear understanding of your target market. By focusing on core features, prioritizing effectively, and being prepared to iterate, you can create an MVP that not only validates your market but also lays the foundation for future development and success. Remember, the MVP is just the beginning of a product's lifecycle, and its evolution is contingent upon the insights gained from real-world use and user interaction.

Features and Functionality - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

Features and Functionality - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

3. Identifying Your Target Audience

understanding who your target audience is and what they want is crucial to the success of any product or service. This is especially true in the context of employing a minimum Viable product (MVP) for market validation. An MVP, which is a product with just enough features to attract early adopter customers and validate a product idea early in the product development cycle, relies heavily on feedback from its initial users to guide future development. Therefore, identifying the right target audience can make the difference between insightful, actionable feedback and irrelevant data that leads your product development astray.

1. Demographic Analysis: Start by gathering demographic information such as age, gender, income level, education, and occupation. For example, a budgeting app might target young professionals aged 22-35 who have recently entered the workforce and are looking to manage their finances better.

2. Psychographic Segmentation: Understand the psychological attributes of your audience, including their personality, values, opinions, attitudes, interests, and lifestyles. A fitness app, for instance, might focus on individuals who value health and wellness and are committed to maintaining an active lifestyle.

3. Behavioral Insights: Look at the behaviors of potential customers, such as their purchasing patterns, brand interactions, and product usage. For a meal-kit delivery service, the target audience might be busy professionals who frequently shop online and are looking for convenient cooking options.

4. Needs and Pain Points: Identify the specific needs and problems that your product or service aims to address. If you're developing a language learning platform, your target audience might include people who are planning to travel abroad and need to learn a new language quickly.

5. customer Feedback and surveys: Use surveys and feedback tools to gather information directly from your potential audience. This can help refine your understanding of their needs and expectations. For instance, a survey for a new music streaming service could reveal that high-quality audio is a top priority for your target audience.

6. competitor analysis: Examine who your competitors are targeting and how they position themselves in the market. This can help you find a niche or underserved market segment. If competitors are focusing on high-end, professional graphic designers, a new design tool might find success with amateur designers or students.

7. market Trends and research: stay informed about the latest market trends and research reports that can shed light on emerging audience segments. An eco-friendly product line might target environmentally conscious consumers who are influenced by global sustainability trends.

8. Social Media Engagement: analyze social media data to understand the interests and preferences of potential customers. A fashion brand might use Instagram trends to identify popular styles and preferences among its target demographic.

9. User Personas: Create detailed user personas that represent the different segments of your target audience. For a travel booking website, personas might range from budget solo travelers to luxury vacationers.

10. Pilot Testing and Iteration: Finally, use your MVP to conduct pilot tests with select audience groups and iterate based on the feedback. A tech gadget company might release a prototype to tech enthusiasts in online forums to gauge interest and gather suggestions.

By combining these strategies, businesses can develop a comprehensive understanding of their target audience, ensuring that their MVP resonates with the right users and garners the feedback necessary for successful market validation. Remember, the goal is not just to identify any audience, but the right audience whose needs align with the value proposition of your MVP. This alignment is what ultimately drives product-market fit and long-term success.

Identifying Your Target Audience - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

Identifying Your Target Audience - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

4. Setting Clear Goals for Market Validation

In the journey of bringing a new product to market, setting clear goals for market validation is a pivotal step that can significantly influence the success or failure of the venture. This process involves establishing measurable and attainable objectives that will guide entrepreneurs through the validation phase, ensuring that the product not only meets the needs of the target audience but also resonates with them on a level that encourages adoption and loyalty. By setting these goals, businesses can focus their efforts, resources, and time on activities that directly contribute to learning about the market's response to the product, thus optimizing the MVP (Minimum Viable Product) approach.

From the perspective of a startup founder, the primary goal might be to determine whether the product solves a problem for a sufficient number of users to make it commercially viable. For a product manager in an established company, the goal could be more nuanced, such as understanding how the new product fits within the existing product ecosystem and the impact it has on the company's brand perception.

Here are some in-depth steps to consider when setting goals for market validation:

1. define Success metrics: Establish what success looks like for your MVP. This could be a certain number of sign-ups, a specific level of engagement, or a set amount of revenue within a time frame.

2. Identify Key Assumptions: List out the assumptions that are critical to the success of your product. These could be about user behavior, market size, or pricing strategy.

3. Develop Hypotheses: Turn your assumptions into testable hypotheses. For example, if you assume that users want a faster way to order food, your hypothesis could be that a user will use your app at least twice a week.

4. Create a Testing Plan: Decide how you will test each hypothesis. Will you conduct surveys, A/B tests, or in-person interviews?

5. Set Milestones: Break down your main goal into smaller, achievable milestones. This helps in tracking progress and maintaining momentum.

6. gather and Analyze data: Collect data through your MVP and analyze it to see if your hypotheses hold true.

7. Iterate Based on Feedback: Use the insights gathered to refine your product and goals.

For instance, a B2B SaaS company might set a goal to acquire 100 active users for its MVP within the first three months post-launch. To validate this goal, they could offer a free trial period to encourage sign-ups and track user activity to measure engagement levels.

In contrast, a consumer mobile app might focus on user retention as a validation metric. They could set a goal that 40% of new users return to the app within the first week. They might use push notifications or email reminders to re-engage users who have dropped off.

By setting clear goals and following a structured approach to market validation, businesses can make informed decisions that align with their vision and market needs, ultimately leading to a product that stands a better chance of success in the competitive marketplace. Remember, the key is not just to validate that there is a market, but to understand the depth and nuances of that market's needs and behaviors.

Setting Clear Goals for Market Validation - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

Setting Clear Goals for Market Validation - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

5. Tips and Best Practices

building a Minimum Viable product (MVP) is a critical step in the lean startup methodology, allowing entrepreneurs to test their business concepts with minimal resources. The goal is to quickly get a product into the hands of early adopters, gather feedback, and iterate before investing heavily in full-scale development. This approach not only conserves resources but also ensures that the product is shaped by actual user needs and demands, rather than assumptions.

1. Define Your Core Value Proposition: The most important aspect of your MVP is its value proposition. What problem does it solve? Why should people care? For example, Dropbox's MVP was a simple video demonstrating their file-syncing solution, which clearly communicated its value proposition and generated significant interest.

2. Identify Key Features: Focus on a small set of features that address the core problem for your users. When Twitter started, it focused solely on the ability to post short messages, or "tweets," which was the fundamental feature that attracted users.

3. Build with Scalability in Mind: Even though an MVP is minimal, it should be built in a way that allows for easy scaling. Instagram began as a simple photo-sharing app but was designed to handle rapid growth, which was crucial when its user base exploded.

4. Use Lean Resources: Utilize tools and platforms that allow for quick and cost-effective development. Airbnb's MVP was a basic website that let people rent out space in their homes, using existing technology to keep costs low.

5. Measure and Learn: Establish metrics to evaluate the success of your MVP. For instance, Spotify measured engagement through the number of playlists created per user to gauge the MVP's effectiveness.

6. Iterate Based on Feedback: Be prepared to pivot or make changes based on user feedback. The original MVP of Amazon was an online bookstore, but customer feedback led to its expansion into a vast array of products.

7. Keep the design User-centric: The design of your MVP should focus on user experience. Even with limited features, the design should be intuitive and appealing, as seen with the clean and simple interface of the initial Google search page.

8. legal and Ethical considerations: Ensure that your MVP complies with all relevant laws and ethical standards. For example, when developing health-related apps, compliance with HIPAA regulations is essential.

9. Budget for Marketing: Don't forget to allocate resources for marketing your MVP. Tesla's initial marketing for its Roadster model created a buzz that helped establish the brand.

10. Plan for post-MVP development: Have a roadmap for further development post-MVP launch. Facebook's MVP was limited to Harvard students, but there was a clear plan for expanding to other universities and eventually the public.

An MVP is not just about building a product; it's about learning what your customers truly want and creating a foundation for future growth. By focusing on these best practices, you can maximize the chances of your MVP leading to a successful, market-validated product.

6. Strategies for Initial Rollout

launching a Minimum Viable product (MVP) is a pivotal moment for startups and entrepreneurs. It marks the transition from the conceptual phase to real-world application, where the product meets its first users. The initial rollout of an MVP is not just about making the product available; it's a strategic move that sets the tone for future development and market positioning. This phase is critical because it provides the first set of actionable data that can validate or refute your business hypotheses. It's a time for learning, adapting, and understanding the market's response to your offering.

From the perspective of a product manager, the focus is on collecting and analyzing user feedback to prioritize feature development. A marketing specialist, on the other hand, might concentrate on crafting messages that resonate with early adopters and creating buzz around the product. Meanwhile, a developer is likely to be on the lookout for bugs and technical issues that users encounter. Each viewpoint contributes to a comprehensive rollout strategy that can make or break the MVP's success.

Here are some strategies to consider for your MVP's initial rollout:

1. identify Your Target audience: Before launching, it's crucial to define who your early adopters will be. These are the users who are most likely to try your product and provide valuable feedback. For example, Dropbox initially targeted tech-savvy users who understood the value of cloud storage and were willing to test a new solution.

2. Create a Feedback Loop: Establish channels for users to report their experiences, whether it's through surveys, social media, or direct communication. This feedback is gold for improving your product. Slack, for instance, used extensive beta testing and direct communication with users to refine its product before a wider release.

3. set Clear goals: Determine what success looks like for your MVP launch. Is it a certain number of sign-ups, a level of engagement, or specific user actions? Having clear metrics helps in measuring the impact of your rollout.

4. Leverage Influencers: Partner with influencers who can advocate for your product to their followers. This can provide a significant boost in visibility and credibility. For example, when Instagram was launched, it quickly gained popularity in part due to influencers who shared their photos on the platform.

5. Iterate Quickly: Be prepared to make rapid changes based on user feedback. The ability to iterate quickly is one of the main advantages of an MVP. This approach helped Twitter evolve from a simple status-update tool to a global communication platform.

6. Focus on Core Features: Ensure that the core features of your MVP are solid and deliver on your value proposition. Users are more forgiving of missing ancillary features if the main functionality meets their needs.

7. Plan for Scalability: Even though it's an MVP, make sure your infrastructure can handle an influx of users without compromising performance. This foresight can prevent negative user experiences due to technical issues.

8. monitor Key metrics: Keep an eye on analytics to understand how users are interacting with your product. This data will guide future development and marketing efforts.

9. Educate Your Users: Sometimes, innovative products require a bit of user education. Use tutorials, guides, and FAQs to help users understand how to get the most out of your MVP.

10. Manage Expectations: Communicate clearly with your users about the nature of an MVP. Let them know that the product is in its early stages and that their input is valuable for its growth.

The initial rollout of your MVP should be approached with a blend of excitement and strategic planning. By considering different perspectives and focusing on user feedback, you can navigate this critical phase effectively, setting the stage for future success and market validation.

Strategies for Initial Rollout - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

Strategies for Initial Rollout - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

7. Collecting and Analyzing User Feedback

Collecting and analyzing user feedback is a cornerstone of the MVP (Minimum Viable Product) approach to market validation. This process is not just about gathering data; it's about understanding the needs, preferences, and pain points of your target audience. It involves actively listening to what users are saying, interpreting their feedback, and using that information to make informed decisions about product development. The goal is to create a feedback loop where insights from users directly influence the iteration of the product. This iterative process helps in refining the product to better meet the market's needs while also validating the product's value proposition.

From the perspective of a startup founder, user feedback is invaluable. It provides a reality check against assumptions and helps pivot or persevere with greater confidence. For product managers, feedback is the compass that guides the product roadmap. It helps prioritize features and improvements that will deliver the most value to users. Designers view user feedback as a tool to enhance user experience, ensuring that the product is not only functional but also enjoyable to use.

Here are some in-depth insights into the process of collecting and analyzing user feedback:

1. Surveys and Questionnaires: These are structured tools that can provide quantitative data about user preferences and satisfaction levels. For example, using a Likert scale to rate different aspects of the product can give a clear picture of its strengths and weaknesses.

2. User Interviews: One-on-one conversations can uncover qualitative insights that surveys may miss. For instance, a user might reveal that they find a particular feature confusing, which could lead to a redesign for better clarity.

3. Usability Testing: Observing users as they interact with the product can highlight usability issues. An example would be noticing that users frequently miss a call-to-action button, indicating the need for a more prominent design.

4. Analytics: Data analytics tools can track user behavior within the product, providing insights into which features are most and least used. For example, a high drop-off rate on a signup page might suggest the need for a simplified signup process.

5. social Media and online Forums: Monitoring discussions about the product on social media platforms and forums can offer unfiltered user opinions. A trend of users requesting a particular feature on Twitter could signal a market demand.

6. Feedback Widgets: Embedding feedback tools within the product allows users to give immediate feedback. For example, a 'Was this helpful?' widget on a help page can gauge the effectiveness of the support content.

7. net Promoter score (NPS): This metric measures user loyalty and the likelihood of them recommending the product to others. A low NPS might indicate underlying issues with the product that need addressing.

8. customer Support interactions: Support tickets and chat logs can be a goldmine of feedback. For example, a common complaint about a feature can trigger a deeper investigation into its functionality.

9. Beta Testing Groups: Engaging a group of users to test new features before a full rollout can prevent widespread issues. An example is a beta group identifying a critical bug in a new update.

10. A/B Testing: Comparing different versions of a feature to see which performs better can provide direct feedback on user preferences. For instance, A/B testing two different landing pages to see which leads to more conversions.

Collecting and analyzing user feedback is not a one-time task but an ongoing commitment. It's about building a relationship with your users where their voice shapes the evolution of the product. By embracing this approach, businesses can ensure that their MVP not only enters the market but continues to grow and succeed in alignment with user expectations.

Collecting and Analyzing User Feedback - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

Collecting and Analyzing User Feedback - The MVP Approach to Market Validation

8. Iterating Your MVP Based on Market Response

iterating your Minimum viable Product (MVP) based on market response is a critical step in the lean startup methodology. It's the process where you take the initial feedback from your early adopters and use it to refine your product. The goal is to learn what resonates with your customers and what doesn't, and then make informed decisions about product development. This iterative cycle is driven by the build-measure-learn feedback loop, where you build a version of the product, measure how the market responds, and learn from the results.

1. Customer Feedback: The most direct way to iterate your MVP is by analyzing customer feedback. This can come from surveys, user testing sessions, or even direct conversations. For example, Dropbox started as a minimal service and expanded its features based on user suggestions and needs.

2. Usage Data: Analyzing how users interact with your product can provide insights into what features are popular and which ones are ignored. Instagram, initially a check-in app called Burbn, pivoted to photo-sharing after noticing that feature's popularity.

3. sales and Conversion rates: These metrics can indicate whether your value proposition is strong enough. If conversions are low, it may be time to iterate on your MVP. A/B testing different aspects of your product can be particularly useful here.

4. Competitive Analysis: Keep an eye on your competitors and the market. If a competitor releases a new feature that's gaining traction, consider how it might be integrated into your product. However, always weigh this against your unique value proposition.

5. Technological Advances: New technologies can open up possibilities for your MVP. For instance, the advent of AI and machine learning has allowed many apps to offer personalized experiences, which were not possible before.

6. Regulatory Changes: Sometimes, changes in regulations can force you to iterate your MVP. For example, privacy laws like GDPR have made data security and user consent critical features for any digital product.

7. Financial Metrics: Keep track of your burn rate and runway. If your MVP isn't financially sustainable, it's a clear sign that iteration is necessary. This might mean pivoting, cutting down features, or finding new revenue streams.

8. Stakeholder Input: Investors, advisors, and partners can offer valuable insights that can help shape your MVP's next iteration. Their experience and outsider perspective can be invaluable.

By continuously iterating on your MVP based on market response, you ensure that your product evolves in a way that meets market needs and remains competitive. This approach can significantly increase your chances of building a successful and sustainable business. Remember, the key is not to fear failure but to learn from it and move forward with those lessons in mind. Iteration is the heart of innovation.

9. Next Steps After Market Validation

Having completed the market validation process using the Minimum Viable Product (MVP) approach, it's crucial to understand that this is not the end, but rather a pivotal point in the product development journey. The insights gathered from market validation serve as a compass for future development, highlighting what features resonate with users and which ones require rethinking or removal. It's a moment of reflection and strategic planning, where the data collected informs the next steps in a product's lifecycle. Whether it's scaling up, pivoting, or enhancing the product, the actions taken after market validation are critical in maintaining the momentum gained during this phase.

1. Analyze Feedback Thoroughly: Every piece of feedback, whether positive or negative, is invaluable. For instance, if customers praised the user-friendly interface of an MVP, it indicates a strong design direction for future iterations.

2. Prioritize Feature Development: Based on feedback, prioritize features that align with customer needs. For example, if users frequently request a specific functionality, it should move up the development queue.

3. Plan for Scaling: If the MVP has been well-received, prepare for scaling. This includes ensuring that the infrastructure can handle increased user loads, as seen when Dropbox's waitlist sign-ups skyrocketed after their MVP launch.

4. Consider a Pivot: Sometimes, market validation reveals that the original product concept isn't viable. In such cases, a pivot might be necessary, similar to how Slack transformed from a gaming platform to a communication tool.

5. enhance the Business model: Reflect on the MVP's monetization strategy. If users are willing to pay for premium features, like LinkedIn's subscription model, it may be time to introduce them.

6. continuous User engagement: Keep the dialogue open with early adopters. Their ongoing feedback is crucial, as seen with the evolution of Instagram from a simple photo-sharing app to a social media giant.

7. refine Marketing strategies: Use the validation phase to identify the most effective marketing channels. For example, if a particular social media campaign drove significant engagement, it should be expanded.

8. Secure Funding: With validation data, approach investors confidently. Demonstrating market interest, like the initial traction of Uber, can be pivotal in securing the necessary capital for growth.

9. Develop Partnerships: Look for strategic partnerships that can enhance the product's value proposition. A partnership, like the one between Spotify and Facebook, can open new avenues for user acquisition.

10. Prepare for Iteration: Market validation is not a one-time event. Be prepared to iterate on the product continuously, incorporating user feedback and adapting to market changes.

The steps taken after market validation are as varied as they are vital. They require a balanced approach of data-driven decision-making and creative innovation, always with the end-user in mind. The journey from mvp to a full-fledged product is iterative and dynamic, and each step forward should be taken with the lessons learned from market validation firmly in hand.

Read Other Blogs

Randomness: Embracing Uncertainty: Randomness in the Realm of Subjective Probability

Randomness pervades our lives in ways that are often underappreciated, misunderstood, or outright...

The Lean Launchpad Strategy

Lean Startup Principles are a systematic, scientific approach for creating and managing successful...

Brand storytelling: Customer Insights: Gathering Customer Insights to Inform Your Storytelling

Storytelling has been an integral part of human culture since the dawn of time. It's how we've...

Lien: The Intricacies of Lien Prioritization in Intercreditor Agreements

Lien prioritization is a critical aspect of intercreditor agreements, where the order of payment in...

Market Access: Market Access: Your Gateway to Uncharted Business Territories

Venturing into new markets is akin to a voyage into uncharted waters. It requires a blend of...

Product demonstrations: Product Education: Product Education: The Role of Demos in Learning

Product demonstrations have long been a cornerstone in the realm of education, serving as a bridge...

Creating Effective Feedback Loops for Continuous Startup Improvement

Feedback loops are integral to the growth and development of startups. They serve as critical...

Strategies for Aspiring Incubator Entrants

The incubator landscape is a dynamic and multifaceted domain, where the interplay of innovation,...

Hospital fundraising event: Startups and Hospital

The synergy between startups and hospitals in fundraising events is a testament to the power of...