Abstract
The high-energy sources known as anomalous X-ray pulsars (AXPs) and soft γ-ray repeaters (SGRs) are well explained as magnetars: isolated neutron stars powered by their own magnetic energy. After explaining why it is generally believed that the traditional energy sources at work in other neutron stars (accretion, rotation, residual heat) cannot power the emission of AXPs/SGRs, I review the observational properties of the 20 AXPs/SGRs currently known and describe the main features of the magnetar model. In the last part of this review, I discuss the recent discovery of magnetars with low external dipole field and some of the relations between AXPs/SGRs and other classes of isolated neutron stars.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Some authors distinguish between these two designations, calling SGRs only the sources which showed episodes of many repeated and intense bursts. In this review, I will not make such a distinction and I refer to the whole group of objects as AXPs/SGRs.
The moment of inertia of a NS with mass M and radius R is in the range ∼ (0.5 − 1) × 1045 (\(M/M_{\odot }\)) (\(R/10 ~km)^{2}\) g cm2 for most equations of state.
Only one pulsar more energetic than the Crab is currently known: the 16-ms pulsar in the Large Magellanic Cloud PSR J0537–6960, which has Ė rot = 5 × 1038 erg s−1.
Some AXPs/SGRs reach quiescent luminosity levels below their Ė rot , but during outburst they are as luminous as the persistent ones.
Sco X-1 was the second observed NS, the first one being the NS in the Crab nebula, shining as a 16-magnitude object in the visible band. Both were clearly understood as NSs only after the discovery of radio pulsars in 1968.
Another energy source is provided by nuclear reactions. This powers the type I bursts observed in many accreting low-mass X-binaries. The properties of SGR bursts are very different from those of type I bursts.
The giant flares (Section 3.1) in which up to ∼ 1046 ergs can be released, are energetically more challenging. This limits the number of such events that a magnetar can emit in its lifetime.
B d is the value on the star surface at the magnetic equator. The surface field at the pole is a factor of two larger.
See [41] for a different interpretation in terms of an accretion-based model.
Here and in the following, we quote luminosities for isotropic emission.
\(B_{QED}\) is the magnetic field for which the energy of the first Landau level of the electron equals its rest mass. It was often regarded as the boundary between normal pulsars and magnetars, although there is no real physical reason or threshold effect to motivate this.
Two isolated bursts were detected in October and November 2001 from 1E 1048.1−5937 [59], but 1E 2259 + 586 in June 2002 emitted more than 80 bursts in 4 h, associated to an increase of the persistent flux and a glitch.
Unless interaction with a residual disk is invoked [3].
Despite the lack of a radio detection, which could be due to an unfavorable orientation of the radio beam.
Also known with the “Magnificent Seven” nickname.
References
D.N. Aguilera, J.A. Pons, J.A. Miralles, ApJ. 673, L167 (2008)
M.A. Alpar, ApJ. 554, 1245 (2001)
M.A. Alpar, Ü. Ertan, Ş. Çalıskan, ApJ. 732, L4 (2011)
H. An, V.M. Kaspi, R. Archibald, A. Cumming, ApJ. 763, 82 (2013)
G.E. Anderson, B.M. Gaensler, P.O. Slane et al, ApJ. 751, 53 (2012)
R.L. Aptekar, T.L. Cline, D.D. Frederiks et al, ApJ. 698, L82 (2009)
R.L. Aptekar, D.D. Frederiks, S.V. Golenetskii et al, ApJS. 137, 227 (2001)
J. Arons, ApJ. 589, 871 (2003)
J.-L. Atteia, M. Boer, K. Hurley et al, ApJ . 320, L105 (1987)
A.M. Beloborodov, ApJ. 703, 1044 (2009)
F. Bernardini, G.L. Israel, L. Stella et al, A&A. 529, A19 (2011a)
F. Bernardini, R. Perna, E.V. Gotthelf et al, MNRAS. 418, 638 (2011b)
S.E. Boggs, A. Zoglauer, E. Bellm et al, ApJ. 661, 458 (2007)
N. Bucciantini, in IAU Symposium, vol. 279, IAU Symposium (2012), pp. 289–296
D.N. Burrows, M.M. Chester, V. D’Elia et al, GRB Coordinates Network. 12914, 1 (2012)
P.B. Cameron, P. Chandra, A. Ray et al, Nature. 434, 1112 (2005)
F. Camilo, S.M. Ransom, J.P. Halpern, J. Reynolds, ApJ. 666, L93 (2007a)
F. Camilo, S.M. Ransom, J.P. Halpern et al, Nature. 442, 892 (2006)
F. Camilo, J. Reynolds, S. Johnston, J.P. Halpern, S.M. Ransom, ApJ. 679, 681 (2008)
F. Camilo, J. Reynolds, S. Johnston et al, ApJ. 659, L37 (2007b)
G. Cavallo, M.J. Rees, MNRAS. 183, 359 (1978)
P. Chatterjee, L. Hernquist, R. Narayan, ApJ. 534, 373 (2000)
R. Ciolfi, V. Ferrari, L. Gualtieri, MNRAS. 406, 2540 (2010)
S. Dall’Osso, G.L. Israel, L. Stella, A. Possenti, E. Perozzi, ApJ. 599, 485 (2003)
B. Davies, D.F. Figer, R.-P. Kudritzki et al, ApJ. 707, 844 (2009)
A. De Luca, in American Institute of Physics Conference Series, ed. by C. Bassa, Z. Wang, A. Cumming, V.M. Kaspi. 40 Years of Pulsars: Millisecond Pulsars, Magnetars and More, vol. 983 (2008), pp. 311-319
A. De Luca, D. Salvetti, A. Sartori et al, MNRAS. 421, L72 (2012)
C.P. de Vries, J. Vink, M. Méndez, F. Verbunt, A&A. 415, L31 (2004)
A.T. Deller, F. Camilo, J.E. Reynolds, J.P. Halpern, ApJ. 748, L1 (2012)
P.R. den Hartog, L. Kuiper,W. Hermsen, A&A. 489, 263 (2008a)
P.R. den Hartog, L. Kuiper, W. Hermsen et al, A&A. 489, 245 (2008b)
V.S. Dhillon, T.R. Marsh, S.P. Littlefair et al, MNRAS. 416, L16 (2011)
V.S. Dhillon, T.R. Marsh, S.P. Littlefair et al, MNRAS. 394, L112 (2009)
R. Dib, V.M. Kaspi, F.P. Gavriil, ApJ. 673, 1044 (2008)
R. Dib, V.M. Kaspi, F.P. Gavriil, ApJ. 702, 614 (2009)
R.C. Duncan, C. Thompson, ApJ. 392, L9 (1992)
M. Durant, O. Kargaltsev, G.G. Pavlov, ApJ. 742, 77 (2011)
T. Enoto, Y.E. Nakagawa, N. Rea et al, ApJ. 693, L122 (2009)
T. Enoto, N. Rea, Y.E. Nakagawa et al, ApJ. 715, 665 (2010)
Ü. Ertan, K.Y. Ekşi, M.H. Erkut, M.A. Alpar, ApJ. 702, 1309 (2009)
Ü. Ertan, M.H. Erkut, K.Y. Ekşi, M.A. Alpar, ApJ. 657, 441 (2007)
P. Esposito, M. Burgay, A. Possenti et al (2009a)
P. Esposito, G.L. Israel, N. Rea et al, The Astronomer’s Telegram, 1763, 1 (2008a)
P. Esposito, G.L. Israel, R. Turolla et al, MNRAS. 416, 205 (2011)
P. Esposito, G.L. Israel, R. Turolla et al, MNRAS. 405, 1787 (2010)
P. Esposito, G.L. Israel, S. Zane et al, MNRAS. 390, L34 (2008b)
P. Esposito, S.Mereghetti, A. Tiengo et al, A&A. 476, 321 (2007)
P. Esposito, A. Tiengo, S. Mereghetti et al, ApJ. 690, L105 (2009b)
P. Esposito, A. Tiengo, N. Rea et al, MNRAS. 429, 3123 (2013)
R. Fernández, C. Thompson, ApJ. 660, 615 (2007)
M. Feroci, G.A. Caliandro, E. Massaro, S. Mereghetti, P.M. Woods, ApJ . 612, 408 (2004)
L. Ferrario, D. Wickramasinghe, MNRAS. 367, 1323 (2006)
D.A. Frail, S.R. Kulkarni, J.S. Bloom, Nature. 398, 127 (1999)
D.D. Frederiks, S.V. Golenetskii, V.D. Palshin et al, Astron. Lett. 33, 1 (2007)
B.M. Gaensler, C. Kouveliotou, J.D. Gelfand et al, Nature. 434, 1104 (2005)
F.P. Gavriil, R. Dib, V.M. Kaspi, in American Institute of Physics Conference Series, ed. by C. Bassa, Z. Wang, A. Cumming, V.M. Kaspi. 40 Years of Pulsars: Millisecond Pulsars, Magnetars and More, vol. 983 (2008a), pp. 234-238
F.P. Gavriil, R. Dib, V.M. Kaspi, ApJ. 736, 138 (2011)
F.P. Gavriil, M.E. Gonzalez, E.V. Gotthelf et al, Science . 319, 1802 (2008b)
F.P. Gavriil, V.M. Kaspi, P.M. Woods, Nature. 419, 142 (2002)
F.P. Gavriil, V.M. Kaspi, P.M. Woods, ApJ. 607, 959 (2004)
J.D. Gelfand, B.M. Gaensler, ApJ. 667, 1111 (2007)
R. Giacconi, H. Gursky, F.R. Paolini, B.B. Rossi, Phys. Rev. Lett. 9, 439 (1962)
R. Gill, J.S. Heyl, MNRAS. 407, 1926 (2010)
E. Gogus, P. Woods, C. Kouveliotou, The Astronomer’s Telegram. 1677, 1 (2008)
M.E. Gonzalez, R. Dib, V.M. Kaspi et al, ApJ. 716, 1345 (2010)
E.V. Gotthelf, F.P. Gavriil, V.M. Kaspi, G. Vasisht, D. Chakrabarty, ApJ. 564, L31 (2002)
E.V. Gotthelf, J.P. Halpern, Ap&SS. 308, 79 (2007)
E.V. Gotthelf, J.P. Halpern, J. Alford, ApJ. 765, 58 (2013)
D. Götz, S. Mereghetti, S. Molkov, et al, A&A. 445, 313 (2006a)
D. Götz, S. Mereghetti, A. Tiengo, P. Esposito, A&A. 449, L31 (2006b)
E. Göğüş, G. Cusumano, A.J. Levan et al, ApJ. 718, 331 (2010)
E. Göğüş, P.M. Woods, C. Kouveliotou et al, ApJ. 532, L121 (2000)
J. Granot, E. Ramirez-Ruiz, G.B. Taylor et al, ApJ. 638, 391 (2006)
C. Guidorzi, F. Frontera, E. Montanari et al, A&A. 416, 297 (2004)
J.P. Halpern, E.V. Gotthelf, ApJ. 725, 1384 (2010a)
J.P. Halpern, E.V. Gotthelf, ApJ. 709, 436 (2010b)
J.P. Halpern, E.V. Gotthelf, ApJ. 710, 941 (2010c)
J.P. Halpern, E.V. Gotthelf, J. Reynolds, S.M. Ransom, F. Camilo, ApJ. 676, 1178 (2008)
A.K. Harding, I. Contopoulos, D. Kazanas, ApJ. 525, L125 (1999)
D.J. Helfand, S. Chatterjee, W.F. Brisken et al, ApJ. 662, 1198 (2007)
J.S. Heyl, L. Hernquist, ApJ. 489, L67 (1997)
W.C.G. Ho, MNRAS. 414, 2567 (2011)
M.M. Hohle, F. Haberl, J. Vink et al, A&A. 498, 811 (2009)
R.-Y. Hu, Y.-Q. Lou, MNRAS. 396, 878 (2009)
F. Hulleman, A.F. Tennant, M.H. van Kerkwijk et al, ApJ. 563, L49 (2001)
F. Hulleman, M.H. van Kerkwijk, S.R. Kulkarni, A&A. 416, 1037 (2004)
K. Hurley, T. Cline, E. Mazets et al, Nature. 397, 41 (1999a)
K. Hurley, P. Li, C. Kouveliotou et al, ApJ. 510, L111 (1999b)
A.I. Ibrahim, C.B. Markwardt, J.H. Swank et al, ApJ. 609, L21 (2004)
U.S. Inan, N.G. Lehtinen, S.J. Lev-Tov et al, Geophys. Res. Lett. 26, 3357 (1999)
K. Ioka, S. Razzaque, S. Kobayashi, P. Mészáros, ApJ. 633, 1013 (2005)
G. Israel, S. Covino, R. Mignani et al, A&A. 438, L1 (2005a)
G.L. Israel, T. Belloni, L. Stella et al, ApJ. 628, L53 (2005b)
G.L. Israel, S. Campana, S. Dall’Osso et al, ApJ. 664, 448 (2007a)
G.L. Israel, S. Covino, L. Stella et al, ApJ. 580, L143 (2002)
G.L. Israel, D. Götz, S. Zane et al, A&A. 476, L9 (2007b)
G.L. Israel, S. Mereghetti, L. Stella, ApJ. 433, L25 (1994)
G.L. Israel, N. Rea, V. Mangano et al, ApJ. 603, L97 (2004)
G.L. Israel, N. Rea, E. Rol et al, The Astronomer’s Telegram. 1909, 1 (2009)
G.L. Israel, P. Romano, V. Mangano et al, ApJ. 685, 1114 (2008)
D.L. Kaplan, D. Chakrabarty, Z. Wang, S. Wachter, ApJ. 700, 149 (2009)
O. Kargaltsev, C. Kouveliotou, G.G. Pavlov et al, ApJ. 748, 26 (2012)
V.M. Kaspi, Ap&SS. 308, 1 (2007)
V.M. Kaspi, F.P. Gavriil, P.M.Woods et al, ApJ. 588, L93 (2003)
B. Kern, C. Martin, Nature. 417, 527 (2002)
R. Kothes, T. Foster, ApJ. 746, L4 (2012)
C. Kouveliotou, S. Dieters, T. Strohmayer et al, Nature. 393, 235 (1998)
C. Kouveliotou, A. Tennant, P.M. Woods et al, ApJ. 558, L47 (2001)
L. Kuiper, P.R. den Hartog, W. Hermsen, The Astronomer’s Telegram. 1921, 1 (2009)
L. Kuiper, W. Hermsen, A&A. 501, 1031 (2009)
L. Kuiper, W. Hermsen, P.R. den Hartog, W. Collmar, ApJ. 645, 556 (2006)
L. Kuiper, W. Hermsen, P.R. den Hartog, J.O. Urama ApJ. 748, 133 (2012)
L. Kuiper, W. Hermsen, M. Mendez, ApJ. 613, 1173 (2004)
H.S. Kumar, S. Safi-Harb, ApJ. 725, L191 (2010)
R.C. Lamb, D.W. Fox, D.J. Macomb, T.A. Prince ApJ. 574, L29 (2002)
J.G. Laros, E.E. Fenimore, M.M. Fikani, R.W. Klebesadel, C. Nature. 322, 152 (1986)
L. Levin, M. Bailes, S. Bates et al, ApJ. 721, L33 (2010)
J.-C. Leyder, R. Walter, G. Rauw, A&A. 477, L29 (2008)
X. Li, F. Lu, Z. Li, ApJ. 682, 1166 (2008)
L. Lin, C. Kouveliotou, E. Goğuş et al, Apj. 740, L16 (2011)
M.A. Livingstone, V.M. Kaspi, F.P. Gavriil ApJ. 710, 1710 (2010)
M.A. Livingstone, P. Scholz, V.M. Kaspi, C.-Y. Ng, F.P. Gavriil ApJ. 743, L38 (2011)
Y. Lyubarsky, D. Eichler, C. Thompson, ApJ. 580, L69 (2002)
M. Lyutikov, MNRAS. 367, 1594 (2006)
M. Lyutikov, F.P. Gavriil MNRAS. 368, 690 (2006)
M. Malheiro, J.A. Rueda, R. Ruffini, PASJ. 64, 56 (2012)
E.P. Mazets, R.L. Aptekar, P.S. Butterworth et al, ApJ. 519, L151 (1999a)
E.P. Mazets, T.L. Cline, R.L. Aptekar et al, Astron. Lett. 25, 635 (1999b)
E.P. Mazets, S.V. Golenetskij, Y.A. Guryan Sov. Astron. Lett. 5, 343 (1979a)
E.P. Mazets, S.V. Golentskii, V.N. Ilinskii, R.L. Aptekar, I.A. Guryan Nature. 282, 587 (1979b)
M.B. McGarry, B.M. Gaensler, S.M. Ransom, V.M. Kaspi, S. Veljkovik, ApJ. 627, L137 (2005)
S. Mereghetti, ApJ. 455, 598 (1995)
S. Mereghetti, A&A. 15, 225 (2008)
S. Mereghetti, P. Esposito, A. Tiengo et al, A∓A. 450, 759 (2006a)
S. Mereghetti, P. Esposito, A. Tiengo et al, ApJ. 653, 1423 (2006b)
S. Mereghetti, D. Götz, I.F. Mirabel, K. Hurley, A&A. 433, L9 (2005a)
S. Mereghetti, D. Götz, A. von Kienlin et al, ApJ. 624, L105 (2005b)
S. Mereghetti, D. Götz, G. Weidenspointner et al, ApJ. 696, L74 (2009)
S. Mereghetti, G.L. Israel, L. Stella, MNRAS. 296, 689 (1998)
S. Mereghetti, L. Stella, ApJ. 442, L17 (1995)
S.Mereghetti, A. Tiengo, P. Esposito et al, ApJ. 628, 938 (2005c)
S. Mereghetti, A. Tiengo, P. Esposito et al, Adv. Space Res. 47, 1312 (2011)
M. Morii, R. Sato, J. Kataoka, N. Kawai, PASJ. 55, L45 (2003)
M. Morini, N.R. Robba, A. Smith, M. van der Klis, ApJ. 333, 777 (1988)
M.P. Muno, J.S. Clark, P.A. Crowther et al, ApJ. 636, L41 (2006)
M.P. Muno, B.M. Gaensler, J.S. Clark et al, MNRAS. 378, L44 (2007)
A.P. Nickolaenko, I.G. Kudintseva, O. Pechony et al, Ann. Geophys. 30, 1321 (2012)
L. Nobili, R. Turolla, S. Zane, MNRAS. 389, 989 (2008)
J.-F. Olive, K. Hurley, T. Sakamoto et al, ApJ. 616, 1148 (2004)
F. Pacini, Nature. 216, 567 (1967)
D.M. Palmer, S. Barthelmy, N. Gehrels et al, Nature. 434, 1107 (2005)
R. Perna, J.A. Pons ApJ. 727, L51 (2011)
A.L. Piro, C.D. Ott ApJ. 736, 108 (2011)
J.A. Pons, U. Geppert, A&A. 470, 303 (2007)
J.A. Pons, J.A. Miralles, U. Geppert, A&A. 496, 207 (2009)
J.A. Pons, R. Perna, 741, 123 (2011)
J.A. Pons, N. Rea, ApJ. 750, L6 (2012)
A. Possenti, R. Cerutti, M. Colpi, S. Mereghetti, A∓A. 387, 993 (2002)
N. Rea, P. Esposito, in High-Energy Emission from Pulsars and their Systems, ed. by D. F. Torres , N. Rea, (2011), p. 247
N. Rea, P. Esposito, R. Turolla et al, Science. 330, 944 (2010)
N. Rea, G.L. Israel, P. Esposito et al, ApJ. 754, 27 (2012)
N. Rea, G.L. Israel, J.A. Pons et al, ArXiv e-prints. (2013)
N. Rea, G.L. Israel, R. Turolla et al, MNRAS. 396, 2419 (2009)
N. Rea, E. Nichelli, G.L. Israel et al, MNRAS. 381, 293 (2007)
N. Rea, T. Oosterbroek, S. Zane et al, MNRAS. 361, 710 (2005)
T.A. Sato, R. Nakamura, M. Ishida, PASJ. 62, L33 (2010)
P. Scholz, C.-Y. Ng, M.A. Livingstone et al, ApJ. 761, 66 (2012)
S.J. Schwartz, S. Zane, R.J.Wilson et al, ApJ. 627, L129 (2005)
A. Spitkovsky, ApJ. 648, L51 (2006)
L. Stella, S. Dall’Osso, G.L. Israel, A. Vecchio, ApJ. 634, L165 (2005)
T.E. Strohmayer, A.L. Watts ApJ. 632, L111 (2005)
M. Sugizaki, F. Nagase, K. Torii et al, PASJ. 49, L25 (1997)
Y.T. Tanaka, J.-P. Raulin, F.CP. Bertoni et al, ApJ. 721, L24 (2010)
T. Terasawa, Y.T. Tanaka, Y. Takei et al, Nature. 434, 1110 (2005)
V. Testa, N. Rea, R.P. Mignani et al, A&A. 482, 607 (2008)
C. Thompson, R.C. Duncan MNRAS. 275, 255 (1995)
C. Thompson, R.C. Duncan ApJ. 473, 322 (1996)
C. Thompson, R.C. Duncan ApJ. 561, 980 (2001)
C. Thompson, R.C. Duncan, P.M. Woods et al, ApJ. 543, 340 (2000)
C. Thompson, M. Lyutikov, S.R. Kulkarni ApJ. 574, 332 (2002)
W.W. Tian, D.A. Leahy MNRAS. 421, 2593 (2012)
A. Tiengo, P. Esposito, S. Mereghetti, ApJ. 680, L133 (2008)
A. Tiengo, P. Esposito, S. Mereghetti et al, MNRAS, L295 (2009)
A. Tiengo, S. Mereghetti, R. Turolla et al, A&A. 437, 997 (2005)
A. Tiengo, G. Vianello, P. Esposito et al, ApJ. 710, 227 (2010)
D.F. Torres, N. Rea, P. Esposito et al, ApJ. 744, 106 (2012)
J.E. Trümper, K. Dennerl, N.D. Kylafis, Ü. Ertan, A. Zezas, ApJ. 764, 49 (2013)
R. Turolla, in Astrophysics and Space Science Library, ed. by W. Becker. Astrophysics and Space Science Library, vol. 357 (2009), p. 141
R. Turolla, P. Esposito, ArXiv e-prints. (2013)
R. Turolla, S. Zane, J.A. Pons, P. Esposito, N. Rea, ApJ. 740, 105 (2011)
V.V. Usov ApJ. 410, 761 (1993)
A.J. van der Horst, V. Connaughton, C. Kouveliotou et al, ApJ. 711, L1 (2010)
M.H. van Kerkwijk, D.L. Kaplan, G.G. Pavlov, K. Mori, ApJ. 659, L149 (2007)
G. Vasisht, E.V. Gotthelf ApJ. 486, L129 (1997)
M. Vietri, L. Stella, G.L. Israel ApJ. 661, 1089 (2007)
D. Viganò, J.A. Pons MNRAS. 425, 2487 (2012)
Z. Wang, D. Chakrabarty, D.L. Kaplan Nature. 440, 772 (2006)
A.L. Watts ArXiv e-prints. (2011)
C.A.Wilson, S. Dieters, M.H. Finger, D.M. Scott, J. van Paradijs, ApJ. 513, 464 (1999)
P.M. Woods, V.M. Kaspi, F.P. Gavriil, C. Airhart, ApJ. 726, 37 (2011)
P.M. Woods, V.M. Kaspi, C. Thompson et al, ApJ. 605 , 378 (2004)
P.M. Woods, C. Kouveliotou, M.H. Finger et al, ApJ. 654, 470 (2007)
P.M. Woods, C. Kouveliotou, F.P. Gavriil et al, ApJ. 629, 985 (2005)
P.M. Woods, C. Kouveliotou, J. van Paradijs et al, ApJ. 524, L55 (1999)
P.M.Woods, C. Kouveliotou, J. van Paradijs et al, ApJ. 519, L139 (1999)
P. M. Woods, C. Thompson, Soft Gamma Repeaters and Anomalous X-ray Pulsars: Magnetar Candidates (Compact Stellar X-ray Sources) (2006), pp. 547–586
C. Yu, ApJ. 757, 67 (2012)
V. E. Zavlin, in Astrophysics and Space Science Library, ed. by W. Becker. Astrophysics and Space Science Library, vol. 357 (2009), p. 181
W. Zhu, V.M. Kaspi ApJ. 719, 351 (2010)
Acknowledgments
I thank Paolo Esposito and Roberto Turolla for their careful reading of this work and useful comments.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mereghetti, S. Pulsars and Magnetars. Braz J Phys 43, 356–368 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13538-013-0137-y
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13538-013-0137-y