Date Palm in Pakistan, Current Status and
Prospective
Written by
Dr. Adel Ahmed Abul-Soad
Foreign Professor & Consultant
Date Palm Research Institute, Shah Abdul Latif University,
Khairpur, Sindh, Pakistan
For
USAID Firms project
2011
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Table of Contents
Page
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Introduction
Dates in Balochistan
Date‟s City, Khairpur
Flood Affected Date Palms
Protection from Monsoon Rains
Flood Affected Date Palms Mitigation Plan
6.1. Cultivation of Early Cultivars
6.2. Introduce Rain Resistant Cultivars
6.3. Using Cost-Effective Covering Material to Protect the Fruit Bunches
6.4. Support the Research to Use Artificial Dehydrators
6.5. Soil Elevation
6.6. Establishment and Promoting the Date Palm Nurseries
7. Establishment and Management of the Date Palm Nursery
7.1. Offshoots Selection and Detachment
7.2. Offshoots Cultivation and Nursery Management
8. Date Palm Tissue Culture
8.1. Advantages of Date Palm Tissue Culture Plants
8.2. Micropropagation Using Inflorescence Portion (Explants)
8.3. Plantation of Tissue Culture Date Plants in Orchard.
9. Constraints Facing the Development of Date Palm in Pakistan
9.1. Low Quality Cultivars
9.1.1. Perspective Date Palm Cultivars and their Susceptibility to Rain
9.2. Poor Farm Management
9.2.1. Orchard Layout
9.2.2. Fertilization
9.2.3. Irrigation
9.2.3.1.
Flood Irrigation System
9.2.3.2.
Groundwater Irrigation System
9.2.3.2.1.
Irrigated Plantations (Furrow and Basin Irrigation)
9.2.3.2.2.
Non-Irrigated Plantations
9.2.4. Fronds Pruning and Dethorning
9.2.5. Pollination
9.2.5.1.
Pollination Techniques
9.2.5.1.1.
Fresh Male Strands
9.2.5.1.2.
Pollen Suspension
9.2.5.1.3.
Dried Pollen
9.2.5.1.3.1.
Cotton Swab
9.2.5.1.3.2.
Use of a Puffer
9.2.5.1.3.3.
Aircraft Pollination
Page 2 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.2.5.1.3.4.
Mechanical Pollination
9.2.5.2.
Pollen Harvest and Handling
9.2.5.3.
Storage of Pollen
9.2.5.3.1.
Male Flower Clusters
9.2.5.3.2.
Mechanical Pollen Extractor and Collector
9.2.5.4.
Pollination Time
9.2.5.5.
Factors Affect Pollination
9.2.5.6.
Effect of Rain on Pollination
9.2.5.7.
Xenia and Metaxenia
9.2.6. Fruit Harvest and Handling
9.3. Pests and Diseases
9.3.1. Wilt Disease (Sudden Decline) at Khairpur, Symptoms and Remedy
9.3.1.1.
Symptoms
9.3.1.2.
Cause (s) of the Problem
9.3.1.3.
Remedy
9.3.1.3.1.
Cultural Practices
9.3.1.3.2.
Foliar Application
9.3.1.3.3.
Soil Application
9.3.1.3.4.
Fertilizer Application
9.3.1.3.5.
Isolation and Identification of Actual Pathogen
9.3.2. Preventive and Curative Methods to Control Red Palm Weevil Problem
9.3.3. Integrated Pest Management (IPM) of Date Palm
9.3.3.1.
Monitoring
9.3.3.2.
Set Action Thresholds
9.3.3.3.
Prevention
9.3.3.4.
Control
9.3.4. International Methods to Control Red Palm Weevil (RPW)
9.3.4.1.
Plant Quarantine
9.3.4.2.
Cultural Control
9.3.4.3.
Mechanical Control
9.3.4.4.
Trapping the Weevils
9.3.4.5.
Biological Control
9.3.4.6.
Chemical Control
9.3.4.7.
Training and Education
9.3.5. Severe Infestation of Scale pest to the Fronds
9.3.6. Rodents Damaging Date Palm Orchards in Balochistan
9.4. Processing
9.4.1. Dates Quality Standards
9.4.2. Growth of Yeast and Molds in Stored Dates
Page 3 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.4.3. Using Methyl Bromide and its Alternatives to Reduce Pest Infestation of
Stored Dates
9.5. Insufficient Research and Development Activities
10. Modern Techniques in Other Countries
10.1.
Fruit Bunch Covering in USA
10.2.
Drip Irrigation in Egypt
10.3.
Dates Processing in UAE
11. Bibliography
Page 4 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
List of Tables
Page
Table 1: Area, Production, Yield and Ranking of Dates in Pakistan (2007-08)
Table 2: General Recommendation for the Annual Requirements per a Date Palm Tree
during Different Growth Stages
Table 3: Export Quantity, Value, Ton Value and Kg Value of Pakistan Compared to
Number of Dates Exporters in the World (FAO, 2007)
Table 4: Number of Date Fruit in 500 Grams Weight
Table 5: Quality Factors of Dates Fruit Moisture Content, Size and Mineral Impurities
Table 6: Definition of Defects for Dates Fruit
Page 5 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Table of Figures
Page
Figure 1: Intercropping Banana and Rice Crops under the Shade of Date Palm at
Khairpur
Figure 2: Fruit at Khalal stage of the Predominant Cultivar „Halawi‟ at Jhang in Punjab
Figure 3: Date Palm Plantations Are Threatened by Sand Dunes at Desert Area of
Hamun-e-Mushkale in Baluchistan
Figure 4: Edible Fruit of the „Shandishkand‟ Cultivar in the West Northern Area of
Balochistan
Figure 5: Growing „Muzafati‟ Tree at Yak Mach with Covering Bag „Baat‟ Placed on the
Fruit Bunch(s)
Figure 6: Curing Boiled Date Fruit at „Khalal‟ Stage on Mats under Sun and Open Air
for 5-6 Days
Figure 7: Flooded Date Palm Orchards at Khairpur during Monsoon Rain in 2010
Figure 8: Flood Disturbed People Life and Water Has Reached to Palms inside Houses
Figure 9: The Settlements of Affected Flood Migrants beneath the Shade of Date Palms
Figure 10: Deleterious Impact of Rain on Cured Dates on Mats which Used as Animal
Fodder.
Figure 11: Palm Trees after Flood Waters Receded at Protected Areas in October, 2010
Figure 12: Dates Dehydrators Installed by Pakistan Agriculture Research Council
(PARC) project at Khairpur using Solar EnergyFigure 13: Cracks of Date Fruit
Epicarp Caused by Rainfall for Intermittent Few Hours Accompanied Ambient
Humid Climate
Figure 14: Aseel Dates Covered with Bituminized Brown Papers to Protect Fruit from
Monsoon Rains at Khairpur
Figure 15: Protection of the Fruit Bunches form Monsoon Rains by DuPont Tyvek®
Bags
Figure 16: Date Palm Offshoot Detachment
Figure 17: Mortality of the Small Date Palm Trees after Establishment Due to Diplodia
Disease Infection at Khairpur
Figure 18: Date Palm Nursery at New Valley in Egypt
Figure 19: In Vitro Date Palm Laboratory of DPRI, SAL University, Khairpur.
Figure 20: Tissue Culture Date Palm (9-Months Old) of 10 Cultivars Were Successfully
Produced in the Greenhouse of DPRI
Figure 21: Large Quantity Planned Plantations of Tissue Culture-Derived Palms at East
Owainat, located in the far southwest of Egypt
Figure 22: Fruiting of „Husaini‟ (Left Photo) and „Koozan Abad‟ (Right Photo) Cultivars
at the Collection Farm of DPRI, Khairpur
Figure 23: Fruit Development of „Medjool‟ (Left Photo) and „Safawi‟ (Right Photo) at
Sindh in Early July.
Page 6 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 24: Top Dates Cultivars in the World Now Are „Barhee‟, „Ammri‟, „Medjool‟,
„Saji‟ and „Deglet Noor‟ (Deglet Nour).
Figure 25: Soil Salinization at Khairpur in Winter
Figure 26: Furrow and Basin Irrigation System of Irrigated Date Palm Plantations at
Balochistan
Figure 27: Non-Irrigated Date Palm Plantations in Balochistan which Rely on Shallow
Groundwater
Figure 28: Fresh Spathes Market at Khairpur as a Source for Pollen Grains
Figure 29: Mechanical Pollinator Has Donated by FAO to Date Palm Growers in 2010
Figure 30: Fruit Harvesting Practice in Khairpur
Figure 31: Sorting the „Rabie‟ Dates to Three Categories According to Size and Free
from Blemishes
Figure 32: Warehouses in Dates Market at Khairpur
Figure 33: Normal (Left Tree) and Infected (Right Tree) Date Palm Tree with Sudden
Decline Disease in Pakistan
Figure 34: Frond Symptoms of Date Palm Decline Disease
Figure 35: The Decline Disease Selectivity to Date Palm Trees in the Backyard Garden
of HEJ, Karachi University in 2010Figure 36: The Disease Incidence of Date
Palm Decline at Different Locations of Khairpur
Figure 37: Infection during Fruiting (Left Photo) and Remedy Treatment Application
(Right Photo)
Figure 38: Symptoms of RPW Infection to Young Trees (8-10 Years), Brown Sap Along
with Bad Smell
Figure 39: Infestation with RPW since Few Months for the Mother Tree and Adjacent
Offshoots
Figure 40: The Larvae and Adult Insect of RPW Were Collected from Infested Tree
Figure 41: Tools Required for Remedy Are the Tree Borer Tool, Pesticide, Plastic Tubes
(1 Inch × 1 Foot), and Phostoxin Tablets
Figure 42: Cleaned Date Palm from RPW Phases and Pesticide & Phostoxin Tablets
Were Applied
Figure 43: Controlled Date Palm Tree after Remedy Application
Figure 44: White Scale Pest Infestation on Date Tree Leaflets at Khairpur
Figure 45: Rodent Attack to Date Palm Trees at Gualishtop, Balochistan
Figure 46: Machinery Sorting of Dates According to their Sizes in Al-Saad Factory
Figure 47: Packaging of Dates to Fulfill the Wide Variety of Consumers Demand.
Figure 48: Pakistan Export Figure as Compared to Five Dates Countries (FAO, 2007)
Figure 49: Value of Pakistani Dates Export per Ton Compared to Iran, Iraq, Egypt, UAE
and USA (FAO, 2007)
Figure 50: Defects of Dirt and Damaged Dates Processed in Khairpur
Figure 51: Carob Moth Pest and its Pupae Infect the Flower and Fruit of Date Palm Tree
Page 7 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 52: Barhee Dates that Will Turn Yellow Sometime in August at California, USA.
The Brown Paper Bag Keeps the Rain off the Fruit (Brown Date Garden)
Figure 53: Date Palm Farm of Barhee Cultivar under Drip Irrigation System through
Ground Water in Desert in Egypt
Figure 54: Date Palm Superb Fruit and Tree of „Zaghloul‟ Date Palm Cultivar (Soft
Cultivar)
Page 8 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
1. Introduction:
This booklet is an attempt to provide basic information on the description of date
palm cultivation in Pakistan, major flood affected date palms and fruit, protection
from monsoon rains, major date palm problems in Pakistan including diseases and
pests with emphasis on Khairpur area, in addition to some successful instances of date
palm countries like Egypt, USA and UAE. It should serve as a brief reference and a
source of information for date palm farmers, specialists and anyone interested in the
date palm.
Date Palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.) or „Khajoor‟ in Urdu language dubbed the „tree of
divine providence‟ by many people who depend on it in their life. The date palm tree
provides communities in the desert oases and rural areas with many benefits. For
thousands of years people travelling across the desert have carried dates with them as
high-energy food. Wood from the tree was used to build homes, to make artifacts and
burned for fuel. During Ramadan, Muslims break their fast each day by eating dates.
Palm fronds are used by Christians of their celebration of Palm Sunday and in Jews in
their celebration of the Feast of the Tabernacles (Booths) [1].
Date flesh of all cultivars showed high level of total sugars (62.60-83.32%) and small
amounts of protein (2.3-3.85%), ash (2.15-3.46%) and fat (0.1-0.46%) on dry matter
basis. Although the mineral contents varied widely, all cultivars could be an
important source of potassium [2].
Pakistan is the fifth largest producer of dates with 680107 tons in 2007/08 and is rated
among the largest producers of date palm in the world with different cultivars. The
major countries importing both fresh and dried dates from Pakistan are India, USA,
UK, Canada, Germany, Denmark, Malaysia and Indonesia. The major cultivars are
Begum Jangi of Balochistan, Aseel of Sindh and Dhakki of Dera Ismail Khan.
Dates are growing in all four provinces of Pakistan. The main dates producing areas
of Pakistan are Turbat and Panjgoor (Baluchistan), Khairpur and Sukkur (Sindh),
Muzaffar Garh, Jhang, Multan and D.G Khan (Punjab) and D.I. Khan (KPK).
Comparison of production, area and yield of dates in Pakistan [3] and its share is
given below (Table 1):
Table 1: Area, Production, Yield and Ranking of Dates in Pakistan (2007-08).
Area
Balochistan
Sindh
Punjab
Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa
Area
(Hectar
e)
50800
32000
5900
1400
Production
(Metric
Ton)
249700
253100
44300
10400
Page 9 of 86
Yield per
Hectare
(kg)
4915
7909
7525
7429
%
Area
56.4
35.5
6.6
1.5
%
Productio
n
44.8
45.4
7.9
1.9
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Pakistan
90100
557500
6189
Date Palm is an important crop of Sindh, mainly growing in Khairpur and Sukkur
districts. Almost 85% of the Sindh dates are produced only in Khairpur. In Khairpur,
maximum benefit was achieved through intercropping of other crops under the shade
of the trees (temperature exceeds 50 oC in summer). Date palms allow other species
such as maize, banana, wheat, rice and vegetables to thrive in terms of growth (Fig.
1). Some of these species needs full sun light such as rice, wheat, etc. and frequent
irrigation. Subsequently the distance among adult date palms was increased to reach
30 feet to allow light penetration to those cereals crops (Fig. 1). The productivity of
adult trees none significantly decreased. Newly established date palms of 3-4 years
have dramatically influenced. Flood irrigation has caused water entrance to the heart
of young trees and fungal infection with Diplodia disease.
There is no contradiction between the date palm tree and intercropped species
regarding fertilizer applications. Growers used to ignore any application for palm tree
while they apply for other intercropped species. Date palm can positively respond to
the lateral addition of organic and inorganic fertilizer but, best system for irrigation is
long intervals with huge irrigation.
Furthermore, a suspicion that short intervals of frequent irrigation and water logging
could be one of the reasons that cause date palm decline disease at Khairpur where
the intercropping is a common practice. Persisted water could enhance the soil borne
pathogen of Fusarium solani to infect the trees.
Intercropping with fruit crops such as Banana, Citrus etc, is preferable than cereals
and maize crops which require frequent water supplement.
Figure 1: Intercropping Banana and Rice Crops under the Shade of Date Palm at
Khairpur.
Date palm at D.I. Khan is widely cultivated crop and there is rapidly growing demand
for the offshoots of local cultivars such as „Dhakki‟. On the other side, date palm
cultivation is narrow at Jhang and „Halawy‟, „Hellawi‟ or „Halawi‟ is the common
cultivar at this area (Fig. 2). Tissue culture is a good mean to provide the initially
disease and pest free plants.
Page 10 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 2: Fruit at Khalal stage of the Predominant Cultivar „Halawi‟ at Jhang in
Punjab.
2. Dates in Balochistan
The Baluchistan area has a dry hot weather during the season. Annual rainfall is
below 100 mm and the wind speed is mostly high and charged with dust. Date palm
plantations are spread in the areas where the groundwater is shallow (15 feet), mainly
around the Hamun-e-Mashkhel and the belt along the border with Iran where the
Tahlab river basin joins the Hamun-e-Mashkhel. Sand Dunes, drought periods, poor
management and labor are current problems in such areas (Fig. 3).
Figure 3: Date Palm Plantations Are Threatened by Sand Dunes at Desert Area of
Hamun-e-Mushkale in Baluchistan.
The predominant cultivars are „Begum Jangi‟, „Muzafati‟ or „Mazafati‟ and „Rabie‟
which accounts for more than 90% percent of the population, followed by the 10% of
other cultivars that are „Carba‟, „Drage Trownge‟, „Shandishkand‟ (Fig. 4), and
„Ringno‟, etc. The state of the art is „Shandishkand‟ which is crisp and tasty fruit,
however, population is so limited and no attached offshoots. The average annual
Page 11 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
production of the preferred cultivars is 50-70 kg/tree. Most of the cultivars are semidry.
Figure 4: Edible Fruit of the „Shandishkand‟ Cultivar in the West Northern Area of
Balochistan.
Farmers utilize „Baat‟ or „Sondh‟ (Fig. 5), i.e. baskets made from the leaflets of date
palm fronds to protect the developing fruit from strong wind waves loaded with sand
particles and getting wasted. Every 1-3 fruit bunches were covered with „Baat‟. At
the time of harvest, the practice is to cut the „Baat‟ along with upper leaf to which the
Baat is tied to.
Figure 5: Growing „Muzafati‟ Tree at Yak Mach with
Covering Bag „Baat‟ Placed on the Fruit Bunch(s).
3. Date’s City, Khairpur
During the harvest season in Khairpur, a new city is developed with different
activities of date palm having age of not more than two months. Many people earn
their livelihood from Date Palm. It is like a big festival which can be seen everywhere
in the area. The farmers are picking the “Rutab” fruit of different cultivars, harvesting
Page 12 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
the “Khalal” fruit for making “Chohara1” by boiling then curing them on mats made
from the fronds of palm tree, and trucks transferring the crop within the area. The
settlements of temporary immigrants from surrounded areas who are coming to earn
some money are the common sign of Khairpur. Also, the smell of “Chohara” can be
easily determined from the air during these months at Khairpur. The city of dates
becomes the cynosure of date‟s exporters to look for a business chance to export
Khairpur dates abroad while the international demand is increasing.
Near to the end of the festival, another activity based on „date‟s processing‟ has to be
started. There are few plants working on dates processing at the „date‟s city‟,
however, the standards of the processed dates in these processing units need to be
improved. It is one of the challenges in front of the industry to increase the price of
Pakistani dates to resist the competent prices of the international market. But, fund is
still the main hindrance facing the research institutes to continue in this sector and
conduct the required research whether on the product of current plants or establish a
world-model small processing plant
Prices of early season dates are always expensive than the mid season dates. In UAE,
price differs according to the cultivar also. One kg of „Naghal‟ dates equals 200 UAE
Dirham whereas the price has decreased to 20 Dirham (US Dollar equals 3.7 UAE
Dirham). For the farm prices, „Medjool‟, „Khalas‟ and „Barhee‟ were on the top and
price reached 11-13 thousand UAE Dirham per ton of the fresh dates. In Karachi
market the price of 400 grams box of packed Medjool equals 350 Pak Rupees while
the one kg of Aseel reached 80 Rupees for cured dates in October. Sometimes price
of Aseel reached to 120 at the maximum in Sukker Market in December. The range of
dried dates is 2000-7000 per 40 kgs in the Sukker Market which is the biggest market
in Pakistan for dried dates in terms of boiled dates which is called „Chuhara‟ or
„Shohara‟(Fig. 6). Keeping in consideration US Dollars equals 85 Pak Rs at that time.
Figure 6: Curing Boiled Date Fruit at „Khalal‟ Stage on Mats under Sun and Open
Air for 5-6 Days.
1
The local name that has given to the boiled date fruit at Khalal stage (before ripening) in order to harvest
early to avoid the monsoon rain threat in July and August.
Page 13 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
There are more than 300 cultivars of dates in Khairpur, Sindh, Pakistan and this is the
biodiversity center of dates [4, 5]. Province wise elite date cultivars of Sindh include:
„Aseel‟, „Karbalian‟, „Fasli‟, „Dedhi‟, „Kupro‟, „Gajjar‟, „Kachoo wari‟, „Began‟,
„Mithri‟, „Bhedir‟, „Khar‟, „Autaqin‟ and „Asul khurmo‟. Only Aseel and Karbaline
are good enough to be promoted as international cultivars.
4. Flood Affected Date Palms
Flood hit Pakistan in August, 2010. A torrent of water has threatened date palm trees
mostly at Khairpur. Flood water covered 1-3 meters of tree‟s trunk at some areas of
Khairpur (Fig. 7). The impact on the tree and fruit was recorded. Some of young trees
(offshoots) of new plantations were died while attached offshoots to adult trees had
less impact. However, adult date palm tree has the ability to continue growth while its
base was entirely covered with water.
The large air pockets in the tissue of roots are apparently playing a role in the
respiratory system of the date palm tree [6].
Figure 7: Flooded Date Palm Orchards at Khairpur during Monsoon Rain in 2010.
As date palm is the corner stone for livelihood of people at Khairpur, while flood has
hindered the whole life over there during and after the monsoon rain.. Water has
covered date palms at houses vicinity as well (Fig. 8). Moreover, crop of short trees
bearing fruit bunches wasted due to increasing the water level to immerse whole
bunches. As well as, it stopped all activities of harvesting and dates curing under sun
heat.
Page 14 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 8: Flood Disturbed People Life and Water Has Reached to Palms inside
Houses.
At the time of flood, significant number of people who were living at unprotected
areas was settled by the Government and other relief agencies in the date palm
orchards (Fig. 9). Date trees provided them a shelter to live under. Some of those
people were the seasonal labor was working in date palm industry at Khairpur during
harvesting season to harvest, transfer crop on trucks, making “Chohara” and cure the
dates on mats.
Figure 9: The Settlements of Affected Flood Migrants beneath the Shade of Date
Palms.
Moreover, rain had deleterious impact on boiled fruit on mats which were near to be
proportionally dried „Chuhara‟ and caused fermentation (Fig. 10). These fruit were
collected and used as fodder to the grazing animals.
Page 15 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 10: Deleterious Impact of Rain on Cured Dates on Mats which Used as
Animal Fodder.
Some areas of Khairpur were protected by mud belts made from the soil mixed with
the stones to avoid the water overflow during the flood. Date palms confronted heavy
rainfall for many days during flood. A positive impact occurred and trees appeared
flush green through the photosynthesis process of green fronds which expectedly has
enhanced after showering by rain water. Furthermore, soil conditions were expectedly
improved after flood waters receded through leaching of excess salt. In addition, river
bed silt sedimentation after flood mostly is good sources of nutrients particularly trace
elements. Crop of the next season in 2011 is optimistically going to be fruitful.
No any disease symptoms were exceptionally emerged particularly the wilt disease
(or as known here in Pakistan sudden decline disease of date palm). After 1-2 months
of flood waters receded, the regular agricultural activities have started for
intercropping under the shade of date palm trees (Fig. 11).
Figure 11: Palm Trees after Flood Waters Receded at Protected Areas in October,
2010.
Page 16 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Date fruit takes 180-210 days approximately from fruit set till maturity. The sensitive
stage to rainfall is from full maturity (Khalal stage) up to ripening (Rutab and Tamer
stages). Summer monsoon rains cause always a problem for date palm crop
particularly during July and August, whether fruit still on the tree or during curing
process on the mats. Alternative ways are to cure date fruit artificially in controlled
champers or dehydrators. It is necessary in order to dehydrate Rutab fruit to reach
Tamar stage (dates) where the fruit moisture content less than 24%. Nevertheless, the
used dehydrators units are not enough to dry considerable amounts of dates during the
season (Fig. 12).
Figure 12: Dates Dehydrators Installed by Pakistan Agriculture Research Council
(PARC) project at Khairpur using Solar Energy.
5. Protection from Monsoon Rains
Date palm is usually growing in the dry land and arid zone where the hot dry summer
and little rainy winter climate prevails. However, few countries are facing the
monsoon rains during the fruit ripening season in July, August and September, such
as Pakistan, Oman, Sahara Desert (Sahel) in Africa and USA (California and
Arizona). Rain fall deteriorates the fruit within 1-2 days only. Rain fall for
intermittent few hours caused crakes in the epicarp at late „Khalal‟ stage of „Otakin‟
cultivar at Khairpur (Fig. 13), whereas other cultivars which were at early green
„Khalal‟ stage showed more resistance to such condition.
Page 17 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 13: Cracks of Date Fruit Epicarp Caused by Rainfall for Intermittent Few
Hours Accompanied Ambient Humid Climate
The major damage caused by rain occurs when either the rain is early, or the dates are
late in ripening. In fact, rain does not seriously damage the dates when they are still at
the early Khalal stage, but rather has a beneficial effect by washing away all dust and
sand particles from the fruits. Rain can however cause severe checking and cracking
in the Kimri and late Khalal stages. It is worth mentioning that the amount of any
particular rain is of less importance than the conditions under which it occurs. A light
shower accompanied by prolonged periods of cloudy weather and high relative
humidity may cause more damage than heavy rain followed by clear weather and dry
winds [7].
In many dates growing areas rainfall right after the pollination which may cause
reduce the fruit setting or rain during fruit ripening will cause the fruit to crack and
ferment then mold will develop. In order to protect the date fruit from monsoon rains,
few types of covering material have been used like Bituminized paper [8], nylon
bags, Punched paper etc. Rain fall near harvesting lowers the temperature which
delays the ripening [6]. No significant difference in chemical composition was
recorded between covered and un-covered fruit bunches with Bituminized paper (Fig.
14).
Bunch covering is, however not only practiced against rain damage, but traditionally
is also used in the form of coarsely woven well ventilated baskets “Sund” to protect
the maturing fruit from birds and prevent early ripening fruit from falling to the
ground. Bunch covering against rain or sun burn increasing the temperature may
benefit maturation [7]. In Balochistan, „Baat‟, covering basket made from the date
palm leaflets has been used to cover the date fruit bunches and protect them from the
hot and dry winds bearing sand particles to fall on the ground or to fail reaching
maturity (Fig. 5).
Page 18 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 14: Aseel Dates Covered with Bituminized Brown Papers to Protect Fruit
from Monsoon Rains at Khairpur.
A unique type of bags2 (Tyvek®) recently has appeared in the Pakistani market which
is been used on other fruit crops for similar purposes. This type of bags could be
feasible to cover date‟s fruit bunches. However, the optimal usage of such bags to
protect the date‟s fruit against monsoon rains mainly, the appropriate time to cover
fruit bunches at different places in Khairpur was investigated by DuPont Pakistan and
Agribusiness Support Fund (ASF) by the aid of Date Palm Research Institute, Shah
Abdul Latif University, Khairpur (DPRI).
The preliminary results of the first year evaluation of 2010 were reported [9]. It is
observed that the climate varies within Khairpur area itself which may affect covered
fruit bunches, where the covered fruit of date palm near to mountain area is matured
earlier than other areas due to the dry weather and hot air. Early ripening cultivars of
dates always get the advantage to gain higher revenue as they reach to the market
first. The miss use of Tyvek bags by farmers may produce unexpected results. The
usual harvesting time of a cultivar must be taken in consideration while farmer is
going to harvest the covered fruit bunches (Fig. 15). The covered fruit bunches of
Fasli cultivar must be harvested one week at least earlier than the traditional harvest
time. Otherwise, moisture and molds is subsequently going to increase inside the bag
and wasted fruit rates will increase.
2
DU PONT Company, Pakistan.
Page 19 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 15: Protection of the Fruit Bunches form Monsoon Rains by DuPont Tyvek®
Bags.
Size of the covering bag might need optimization to fit the variable sizes of fruit
bunches. Moisture is expected to increase if small fruit bunches covered with wide
bags. A tied bag from base is prohibited and the lower portion of the fruit bunch must
be exposed to fresh air. Fruit bunches can be safely covered 1-3 weeks before
harvesting. Early covering had a positive impact on the fruit ripening during non
rainy season from June and July, 2010 (an intermittent rain fall). Both sides of the
Tyvek bag were used where the inner face inverted to test its profitability to rain
water with no difference as compared to outer face of the bag. Covering of fruit
bunch is a time-consuming process, however, a tree needs an effort of 1-2 persons for
30-45 minutes at least. Fear from moisture accumulation inside the bag remains the
main concern of farmers to cover their fruit bunches in the last season. The impact
assessment experiment for coming season could eliminate this fear and protect date
bunches against monsoon rains.
Generally, fruit covering is a positive practice for protection from monsoon rains,
birds, pests and dust which should be performed with a complete package of the
proper usage instruction according to the different local cultivars, cultivation area,
and time of covering.
6. Flood Affected Date Palms Mitigation Plan
Most of date palm areas in Pakistan are suffering from monsoon rains. Consequently,
a plan should be prepared for a mitigation procedure to minimize the loss in date
palm industry. The suggested plan includes:
6.1. Cultivation of early cultivars that can be harvested earlier and escape from
monsoon rains. For example, „Gajjar‟ and „Kasho Wari‟ are two early local
cultivars of Khairpur and internationally is „Al Mehtari from Iran and „Naghal‟
which reaches to the Khalal and Rutab stage in May under the Sultanate of Oman
conditions which is quite similar to Khairpur conditions [10]. Also, „Naghal‟ is a
Page 20 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
luxury cultivar of UAE and earliest one to produce „Tamer‟ in June. Plant Tissue
Culture is a powerful and secure tool to support Pakistan with its needs from
such cultivars. Utilizing the late cultivars could not succeed to escape from
monsoon rains at a hot areas of Pakistan since the heat units requirements is
expected to be fulfilled within the range of monsoon rain.
6.2. Introduce rain resistant cultivars. Only few cultivars in the world possess a
relative resistance against the adverse impact of rain like „Orabi‟ in the Northern
Part of Egypt. The harvest season of this soft cultivar is from the late October to
Early January due to its high content of Tannins during „Khalal‟ stage. The
edible stage of this cultivar is the „Rutab‟.
6.3. Using cost-effective covering material to protect the fruit bunches. This
practice was successfully being used at USA and the Sultanate of Oman. In the
last season, a quantity of 300 000 Tyvek bags have been subsidized by
Agribusiness Support Fund (ASF) and disseminated in 2010 by DuPont Pakistan
to date palm farmers in all over Pakistan. The assessment impact study of these
bags is being carried by DuPont, Pakistan & DPRI, Khairpur.
6.4. Support the research to use artificial dehydrators to dehydrate the un-ripened
fruit by dehydrators machines and under controlled conditions. Few types of
dehydrators using solar energy and a little fuel for operation were installed for
the date palm farmers in Khairpur and D.I. Khan since 2-3 years. Nevertheless an
optimization of the usage is required by conducting a research in order to make a
model trial for other farmers as well. Moreover, the machinery development also
should be adopted to maintain paramount quantities and high quality during the
short season.
6.5. Soil elevation to 2-3 feet is suggested to provide a new medium for the roots
away from stagnant subsoil water particularly for the saline soils. River bed silt is
a good source for soil elevation after the flood waters receded. On the other side,
this process is necessary for the intercropped species and been followed at North
of Egypt as a method for reclamation of the saline soils which are close to the
Mediterranean Sea. Mango, Apple and Veggies have been successfully
established by annual or biannual soil elevation.
6.6. Establishment and promoting the date palm nurseries is of a prime
importance. The sensitive small offshoots should be cultivated in established
nurseries at protected areas instead of direct cultivation in open field in order to
reduce the mortality after cultivation.
Due to the importance of the above mentioned points, a brief detail on the related
issues is necessary to date palm farmers and specialists as a post-flood management.
As well as, a focus on the obstacles and key factors of date‟s industry improvement in
Pakistan such as low quality cultivars, pests and diseases, etc. will be discussed.
Page 21 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
7. Establishment and Management of the Date Palm Nursery:
Nursery, in horticulture, is an establishment or area for the propagation and early
cultivation of plants. Some plants are now propagated from cells grown in a sterile
medium then shifted to the nursery (Tissue Culture Plants). The modern nursery
staffed by horticulture experts and equipped with facilities for mass production.
In general, the date palm nursery concept is not a practice in Pakistan for getting the
offshoots which are ready for successful field cultivation with low mortality. Date
palm farmers used to get their need from the old orchards by detaching the small
offshoots then cultivating them directly in the field with mortality may reach 80%.
For transferring these offshoots to far areas, the outer fronds were trimmed and
offshoots of different sizes were shipped in trucks. Overwhelming majority of farmers
used to establish new cultivation during the months of June and July (in the mid of
summer). This is contrary with the procedure everywhere in the world which is
recommending spring or autumn months to avoid high temperature and cold stress
during summer and winter seasons. It could be reasonable practice under current
situation in Pakistan and high infestation rates of Red Palm Weevil (RPW) in winter.
7.1. Offshoots Selection and Detachment
However, the date palm nursery is managed to provide special care during the initial
stage of the offshoot growth without complete roots. Also, the nursery is saving the
time consumed to grow date palm trees before fruiting for a period of 4-5 years, and
minimize the number of missed plants after direct cultivation in the permanent place
(Fig. 16). These gaps of missed plants mostly were replaced by other younger
offshoots. The homogeneity of fruiting depends mainly on the uniformity of the
initial offshoots during an orchard establishment. Nursery can provide farmers with
uniform plants, their required number, complete root and free from symptoms of
disease and insects.
Figure 16: Date Palm Offshoot Detachment.
Page 22 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Farmers at Khairpur used to cultivate the detached offshoots at the same orchard
among the adult date palms which reduced the distance between the trees and
increased the moisture. Subsequently the scales insects and leaf spot diseases rapidly
increased. The ideal distance between palms should be 24 feet. Recently, the farmer
trends to establish new date palm cultivation and specify a limited area for a small
nursery. Improper practice was performed by intercropping vegetables in conjunction
with frequent flood irrigation. Consequently, a big portion of the already 2-3 years
established trees have devastated due to Diplodia disease (Diplodia phoenica)
infection. This hits the offshoot and causes a substantial proportion of the new
cultivation mortality (Fig. 17).
Figure 17: Mortality of the Small Date Palm Trees after Establishment Due to
Diplodia Disease Infection at Khairpur.
In order to establish a date palm nursery, few specifications and precautions should be
taken in consideration. First is the group of instructions to select an ideal offshoot
which include:
Age must be not less than 3 years.
Weight is 10-25 kg and diameter of the wider part of stem is 0.5-1.0 foot.
Healthy and having a separate root system, and clear from any disease or pest
symptoms.
For the successful nursery establishment as concerned to the offshoot selection, the
second group of instructions for the detachment process includes:
Offshoots from an infected area with an epidemic disease are forbidden.
Removal of the early fruit bunches, if any (in the first year only to save food
for further vegetative growth).
Cut surface should be plain and clean.
Sterilization of the tools before detaching an offshoot with any available
Fungicide solution.
Page 23 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Determination of the connection point between an offshoot and its mother
palm by soil removal.
Cutting-off the non-erect (suspended) outer fronds and trim other fronds and
ties them with a rope.
Carful detachment with a sharp metal tool.
Dipping or spraying the offshoot with copper-based fungicides (Benomyl
(Bavistin), Thiophanate Methyl (Topsin M) and Bordeaux mixture) has been
found effective against the Diplodia disease. The procedure is to immerse the
offshoot base in the fungicide solution 3-5 grams per liter of water for 4-5
minutes then leave for a while to heal the wound.
Avoiding any hits to the offshoot heart.
Moistening the offshoot with water every day until cultivation as soon as
possible.
Clothe the base of the offshoot with wetted piece of cloth and covering the
fronds if possible.
Spraying with any available pesticide and Malathion is preferred due to its bad
smell the cut surfaces which made in the mother palm or the offshoot is
compulsory to avoid RPW attack since the smell of fresh palm tissue attracts
the insect.
How do you differentiate between offshoot coming from the nursery and another one
freshly detached from a mother tree? It is a prime importance for the farmer to
distinguish between these two types to avoid cheating. These differences include:
The nursery offshoot is erect but the separated offshoot is almost curved.
The nursery offshoot having roots from everywhere at the base but detached
offshoot does not have roots on the cut surface portion.
7.2. Offshoots Cultivation and Further Nursery Management
Two types of cultivation are on terraces and ditches or on a plain land. Cultivation on
terraces (Fig. 18) keeps indirect contact between the irrigation water and the offshoot
which gave good results compared to direct contact through the flood irrigation. Drip
irrigation is a better choice for regular irrigation supplement. The cultivation
procedure as follows:
Land preparation. Distance among offshoots should be 3-4 feet.
Digging holes about 2-3 square feet and plant the offshoot in such a manner that
the wider part of it is at the soil surface level to prevent water entrance inside the
heart which may cause rot infection (Diplodia disease).
Pressing soil perfectly around the offshoot. Keeping fronds tied for few months.
Frequent and plausible irrigation for 4-5 weeks after cultivation. After then as per
need according to soil type and climate conditions.
Pressing of soil around the stem to give a strong foot hold to the offshoots in the
nursery.
Page 24 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Fertilization is prohibited after offshoot cultivation for 3-4 months until new
central fronds formation.
Light manual hoeing to keep the soil loose and pulverize for root development
and to control the weeds on ridges, flat land etc.
Figure 18: Date Palm Nursery at New Valley in Egypt
The offshoots must be kept at nursery for 1 year at least until new root formation and
emergence of the new fronds. The place of the nursery could be under the shade of
taller date palm trees or other spaces away from the direct sun light. As a sign for
successful cultivation, the central fronds can be easily pulled out by hand after 2
weeks if the offshoot heart has infected and died (Fig. 17). Eventually, the offshoot
selection, detachment process, cultivation and the maintenance were the four factors
which are involved for successful nursery establishment.
On the other side, date palm derived from tissue culture can be cultivated directly in
the permanent place or site while their age is 1-4 years. Detailed discussion will be
given elsewhere.
8. Date Palm Tissue Culture
Date palm being a dioecious plant is conventionally propagated through its offshoots
because propagation through its seeds will not bring the true to type progeny of Date
Palm. The development of tissue culture techniques for the mass propagation of date
palm plants has revolutionized the date palm industry in the World.
Plant tissue culture is practicing in many date palm growing regions in the world, and
recently in Sindh. On both commercial and research levels without a specified fund,
the Biotechnology Laboratory of DPRI, SAL Univ., Khairpur has succeeded to
produce few thousand of 7 Pakistani cultivars and 3 international in 2010 (Fig. 19, 20).
These were „Dahkki‟, „Gulistan‟, „Dedhi‟, „Kasho Wari‟, „Gajar‟ and „Kurh‟ while
international were „Barhee‟, „Zaghloul‟ and „Partamoda‟ [11, 12].
Page 25 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
The production of tissue cultured palms takes 4-6 years and involves three sequential
phases:
Laboratory-based plant production (In vitro plants) for 2-3 years (Fig. 19).
Plant establishment in a greenhouse (Ex vitro plants) for 1 year (Fig. 20).
A growing-on phase in a shaded nursery or net house before field cultivation
(In vivo plants) for 1-2 years.
Figure 19: In Vitro Date Palm Laboratory of DPRI, SAL University, Khairpur.
After the full cycle of tissue culture production period, plants are ready to be cultivated in
the permanent place and fruiting expectedly within 1-2 years. Date palm tissue culture
plants are providing the following advantages compared to traditional offshoot
cultivation.
8.1. Advantages of Date Palm Tissue Culture Plants:
Required cultivars are available on demand around the year in large numbers
including the international with reasonable prices.
Free from devastating pests such as RPW and diseases such as Decline disease.
Healthy and early crop within 1-2 years where growing rapidly in the open field.
It is easy to be transferred from a place to another in terms of volume, weight and
health status.
High survival percentage after cultivation in open field may reach to 100% due to
the complete roots.
Large quantity planned plantations simultaneously with uniform growth (Fig. 21).
Page 26 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
8.2. Micropropagation Using Inflorescence Portion (Explants):
In DPRI, process of date palm micropropagation was started since 3 years with hope
to produce the best cultivars in the world such as „Medjool‟, „Khalas‟ and „Deglet
Noor‟. Shoot tip portion (Explant) of offshoots and the innovative technique of
inflorescence explants that has been transferred by Dr. Adel A. Abul-Soad, consultant
from Egypt were used (Fig. 19).
It is important to mention that the quality and reliability of the product is essential
[11, 13]. For this reason the in vitro and ex vitro plant samples were subjected to
fingerprinting to ensure the genetic stability before fruiting in the open field which
may need further 2-3 years.
Figure 20: Tissue Culture Date Palm (9-Months Old) of 10 Cultivars Were
Successfully Produced in the Greenhouse of DPRI.
Inflorescence-based micro propagation holds a great potential for the multiplication
of recalcitrant male and female date palm individual trees and cultivars of commercial
interests with limited populations. The female individual that rose from seeds and
explored superior crop is great repository for new cultivars. This can be accomplished
in a short time with minimal efforts as compared to the traditional practice of using
shoot tip explants. The aim of this technique is to pave the way to use the
inflorescence explants to micro propagate date palm by direct formation of organs in
conjunction with low effort. The pilot production trials in DPRI revealed that 1-2
immature spathes were enough to produce thousands of the plants while about 100
offshoots may require producing similar number of plants using the traditional
explant shoot tip. Using the inflorescence explant is a dream of any laboratory in the
word to micropropagate date palm. The achievement of DPRI could be a
breakthrough in the date palm world.
Page 27 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
8.3. Plantation of Tissue Culture Date Palms in Orchard
The ex vitro palms should be protected especially from high temperature whether
cleared from the airport or from a local source (A laboratory). If plants imported, they
must be taken out from their carton boxes for watering and kept in a net house or a
shaded place. Plants should be kept for 2-4 weeks in their pots to gradually adapt to
local conditions before cultivation. There are 2 methods may be followed for growing
on the plants according to plant age, i.e. size:
The first method: Plants less than one year old (Torpedo pots) should be shifted to
larger pots of 30-40 cm in length for 12-18 months under a net to allow more growth
and reduce the root shock when they will be planted in the permanent place. A
suitable potting mixture is that one provides an open structure for good drainage. The
ideal soil mixture is peat moss, perlite, vermiculite at ratio (1:1:1) or locally Sindh
river bed silt, desert sand (Polari) at ratio 1:1[14, 15]. Plants with good growing
conditions should reach a height of 80 cm (including pots) and feathered fronds. On
contrary, plants can be left without shifting to larger pots, however, for 3-6 months
only. The containers must be placed on loose stone chippings, 10-15 cm deep or
wooden carriers to allow free drainage. It is observed that the accumulation of
drainage water caused burnt root tip.
The second method: When date palm plants are in appropriate age of 2-4 years with
complete feathery fronds. Mostly this large size plants can be brought from a local
source and can be planted directly after 4 weeks adaptation period at the permanent
place. Plants grown on using this method will be very robust at the time of field
cultivation with uniform growth.
After cultivation, frequent irrigation with fertilization is demanded through drip
irrigation or any available way with NPK chemical fertilizer ( 17-17-17) with Mg and
foliar application of the trace elements. Cultivation distance is 18-24 feet and fruiting
expected within 2-3 years according to the cultivar (Fig. 21).
The above mentioned information may vary according to the plant size, cultivar, and
climatic conditions.
Figure 21: Large Quantity Planned Plantations of Tissue Culture-Derived Palms at
East Owainat, located in the far southwest of Egypt
Page 28 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9. Constraints Facing the Development of Date Palm in Pakistan
Date palm cultivation in Khairpur has a long history, yet the efforts exerted by the
GOs and NGOs on research and development, although significant, are still
insufficient and fall below expectations. In general, the product quality is still low,
the field and post-harvest losses are high and the date products and by products
utilization need improvement. Lake of knowledge and training programs are required
for date palm farmers. To address the above mentioned constrains, the government
and research institutes should rank date palm as one of the high research priorities and
offer the fund for researchers and subsides for farmers, processors and traders.
Several problems and constraints might affect the future of the Pakistan date palm
industry. Such problems include:
9.1. Low Quality Cultivars
Establishment of a collection farm at every date palm place can be a center for date
palm cultivation. This collection farm (Germplasm unit) should include most of elite
cultivars whether from other areas inside the country or from outside the country to
conduct evaluation programs. The research activity in DPRI indicated high quality
fruiting of some domestic cultivars from Baluchistan like „Husaini‟ under the
Khairpur conditions (Fig. 22). Moreover, two categories of „Husaini‟ were
recognized to fruit at different times. The fruit of the first matured in the mid of July
and the second in the beginning of August. The other successful cultivars were
„Shakri‟, „Ab-Dandan‟, „Koozan Abad‟ (Fig. 22) and „Gogna‟.
Figure 22: Fruiting of „Husaini‟ (Left Photo) and „Koozan Abad‟ (Right Photo)
Cultivars at the Collection Farm of DPRI, Khairpur.
As well as, introduction of new cultivars with international marketing value is
substantial. It is worth to mention that some progressive farmers in different areas of
Pakistan and particularly in Sindh have established a successful cultivation of
international cultivars such as „Medjool‟ (Fig. 23) and „Barhee‟. Also in DPRI,
„Ajwa‟, „Amber‟, „Safawi‟ (Fig. 23) cultivars of Saudi Arabia are under the
Page 29 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
evaluation process with promising results. The preliminary evaluation of „Ajwa‟ and
„Safawi‟ indicated early fruit maturation under the conditions of Khairpur. Fruit of
„Ajwa‟ harvesting started from the third week of June. Also, the fruit quality was
similar to that fruit in „Al-Madden‟ at Saudi Arabia. Such advantage may be useful
for the early fruiting to escape from monsoon rains.
As international cultivars as concerned to rain, date cultivars differ in their
susceptibility to rain and humidity. „Dayri‟, „Khastawi‟, „Thoory‟, „Khadrawi‟, and
„Sayer‟, under Coachella Valley conditions, were found to be the least damaged of
sixteen cultivars [16]. Zahidi, Khalas and Barhee cultivars had average damage, while
Deglet Noor, Yatima, Hayani and Ghars were the most sensitive. Both very early (Al
Mehtari/Iran) and late cultivars (Khissab and Hilali/Iraq) escape the rain and
consequently their fruits are not affected [7].
Figure 23: Fruit Development of „Medjool‟ (Left Photo) and „Safawi‟ (Right Photo)
at Sindh in Early July.
Nevertheless, more work has to be carried out on the elite cultivars of the world
which are „Medjool‟, „Deglet Noor‟, „Khalas‟, „Barhee‟, „Sewi/Saidy‟, „Ammri‟,
„Khadrawi‟, „Saji‟ etc. (Fig. 24).
The wide variation of the climate in Pakistan allows cultivation of most of the elite
date cultivars of world Change in the cultivars structure is a need of today to increase
the export and to improve dates industry while a single Kg of „Ajwa‟ equals the
income of 150 Kg of „Aseel‟.
Page 30 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 24: Top Dates Cultivars in the World Now Are „Barhee‟, „Ammri‟,
„Medjool‟, „Saji‟ and „Deglet Noor‟ (Deglet Nour).
Page 31 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.1.1. Perspective Date Palm Cultivars and their Susceptibility to
Rain
The world fame cultivars of date could be „Medjool‟,‟Khalas‟, „Barhee‟, „Deglet
Nour‟, „Khadrawy‟, „Sukkari‟, „Sakii‟, „Dubas‟, „Zahdi‟, „Sewi‟, etc. Date fruit of
such cultivars is internationally demanded. But it needs fruiting evaluation under
different areas of Pakistan. Nevertheless, it seems local climate may allow the
majority to give good fruit because of the average daily temperature of 35-40
centigrade and moisture less than 60% from March to August in 90% of date palm
cultivation areas in Pakistan. There is no single cultivar can its fruit resist the rain but
it could be moderately tolerant.
Therefore, dates cultivars differ in their susceptibility to rain and humidity. „Dayri‟,
„Khastawi‟, „Thoory‟, „Khadraoui/Khadrawy‟, and „Sair/Sayer‟, under Coachella
Valley conditions, were found to be the least damaged of sixteen cultivars [16].
„Zahidi‟, Khalas and Barhee cultivars had average damage, while Deglet Nour,
Yatima, Hayani and Ghars were the most sensitive. Both very early (Al Mehtari/Iran)
and late varieties (Khissab and Hilali/Iraq) escape the rain and consequently their
fruits are not affected [7].
The large scale multiplication and plantation of international renowned cultivars is
essential for reaching the international market and getting high value from the
plantation. Local clones, which are exclusively of seed-origin, must be assessed for
their suitability for commercial production. Some of these seedlings show signs of
measuring up to the best internationally renowned cultivars, such as Medjool,
Barhee, Khalas, Deglet Nour, etc. These seedlings must be thoroughly evaluated
before large scale multiplication and planting can be initiated [7]. In some private
farms in Pakistan, distinguishable date palm clones arose from seeds and needs
micropropagation.
9.2. Poor Farm Management
It is starting from the first point of cultivation, the source of new plantation, the
offshoot. Farmers in entire Pakistan used to get the new offshoots from old orchards
by direct detachment of the small offshoots. The mortality after establishment was
high may reach 80% more or less.
9.2.1. Orchard Layout
Unfortunately, in Pakistan the spacing among date palms is not planned since
beginning. But, mostly growers cultivate date palm from 15 feet by 15 feet apart to
30 feet by 30 feet with no conscious for the future plan. Most of date palm growers
in Khairpur are planting new offshoots in between bearing tall palms which reduce
the distance and reduce light penetration to the younger growing plants. Only in case
Page 32 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
of intercropping the wheat and rice, growers eradicate some trees to increase the
distance. Recently some growers were increasing the space for the future
intercropping. The modern trends are applying 20 by 20 feet [17].
In Balochistan, the moderate yield in some of the areas in Balochistan (30-50 kg)
can be attributed mainly to the lack of proper maintenance and management of the
plantations. The principal reason may be the shortage of skilled labor required for
new cultivation, orchard management including pruning, pollination, intercropping,
harvest and post-harvest practices which increases the cost of production. The price
of the product is also not very attractive in view of the lower quality. With lower
profitability, it is not surprising that the growers tend to neglect or even abandon
their plantations in some areas. Improving the cultivation practices can increase the
productivity of the date palm trees. Selection and micropropagation of powerful
males and IPM to control pest and diseases mostly will improve the productivity.
9.2.2. Fertilization
Date palm has similar fertilizer requirements to other cultivated crops. Intercropping
with vegetables and other crops in Sindh and un-managed date palm plantations in
Balochistan made chemical fertilization is not visible. The fertilization included
mainly the addition of the farm manure in winter only in Sindh. Nevertheless, there
is indirect application of the chemical fertilization through the intercropped chemical
fertilization with N-P-K. It is important to mention that the soil of Sindh has Mg
deficiency which requires exogenous application with source for this major element.
Fortunately, date palm can be grown in a wide range of soil types. Deep sandy soils
with a good moisture supply are best [18]. Good drainage and aeration are the main
soil requirements for ideal production. Date palm tree will grow in heavier soils, but
care must be taken not to waterlog these soils. It will grow in soils that are high in
alkali and salt content, but growth and productivity will be affected. More sandy
soils with their great drainage require more fertilization, as fertilizers are more easily
leached out by irrigation.
Therefore, the initial land and orchard preparation aims at preparing the soil for
establishment of the young tissue culture date palm or offshoots, but does not ensure
proper establishment and growth after transplanting. A fertilization program should
be included in the date plantation establishment phase for optimum growth.
In order to ensure strong, healthy plants for transplanting and to shorten the period in
the nursery, a fertilization program is recommended in Table 2. The fertilization
program starts at the time prior to transplanting, during the land preparation phase.
At that stage, attention is to be given to the improvement of the soil which may have
a direct influence on the utilization of certain nutrients which are necessary for the
palm growth.
Page 33 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Actions that precede this phase include the initial hole preparation, application of
lime/gypsum/organic material, and a leaching program in the case of saline soils.
The recommended range of organic materials is 10-15 kg for each hole. Salt is
mostly accumulated on the soil surface during January when irrigation water is
routinely stopped and no water in the main irrigation canals of Sindh River (Fig. 25).
Salt accumulation is increasing in lower level lands. Heavy irrigation for 1-2 times is
required for leaching the salt of such land in Sindh Valley.
Figure 25: Soil Salinization at Khairpur in Winter.
Smaller 1-2 planting hole (± 2x2x2 feet) in two directions is prepared and the
fertilizers are mixed with the soil from this hole before it is put back at transplanting.
In the following year the planting holes will be dig in the opposite directions. Instead
of digging, fertilizers can be mixed with the soil. Every year the exact amounts and
types of fertilizers to be applied will be determined by soil, water and frond analysis.
Generally 1.5-3 kg of nitrogen, 0.5kg of phosphorus and 2-3kg of potassium per tree
yearly is recommended to maintain optimum growth of palm tree in Iraq [19].
However, the recommendation presented for the estimated amounts in the following
table can be used as an example.
Due to the high pH of soil in Pakistan (alkali) which may reach 7-8.5, the preferred
formulas of chemical fertilizers could be Nitrogen in the form of Ammonium
Sulphate (21% N), Phosphorus in the form of Calcium Super-Phosphate (45-47%
P2O5), Potassium in the form of Potassium Sulphate (50% K2O), and Magnesium in
the form of Magnesium Sulphate (27-33% MgO).
Page 34 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Table 2: General Recommendation for the Annual Requirements per a Date Palm
Tree during Different Growth Stages.
Growth Stage
Nutrients
Estimated
Quantity (grams)
1. Growing offshoots in the nursery
Nitrogen
250-400
Phosphorus
200
Potassium
200-300
Magnesium
200-250
Manure (matured 5000
and dry)
2. After transplanting
Nitrogen
300-400
Phosphorus
200-300
Potassium
500-800
Magnesium
200-300
Manure (matured 5000-10000
and dry)
3. After spathes emergence
Nitrogen
500-1000
Phosphorus
300-400
Potassium
800-1000
Magnesium
300-400
Manure (matured 10000-15000
and dry)
4. Adult productive tree
Nitrogen
Page 35 of 86
1000-1500
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Phosphorus
400-500
Potassium
1500-2000
Magnesium
300-500
Manure (matured 15000-25000
and dry)
Time of application, organic manure is to be added in December to January. Each
year N fertilizer is to be added in three equal doses, in the mid of March (before
flowering), mid of May (fruit setting) and eventually in June to July (fruit maturity).
The P fertilizer is to be added approximately twice a year, in the winter with the
organic material and in the mid of April. The K fertilizer is to be added mainly near
to fruit maturity in June. All used chemical fertilizers can be divided to unequal
amounts and disseminated around the year but, higher amount should be added
according to mentioned dates according to growth stage and fruit development phase
in the Northern Hemisphere.
Long-term experiments on the use of chemical fertilizers in different areas of date
palm in Pakistan are needed.
9.2.3. Irrigation
Poor irrigation is practicing during intercropping with other vegetables which may
increase the decline disease infection. Most of the nutrients were given through
chemical fertilization of the intercropped species. The common irrigation system for
date palm plantation in Pakistan can divided into two types:
9.2.3.1. Flood Irrigation System
This is the practiced irrigation system in Khairpur and Sukker at Sindh province.
This irrigation method is the oldest method known, and is also the method most
widely used in date palm culture.
It has, however, advantages low running costs and easy to apply and initial costs are
low if the area is fairly flat. As well as disadvantages which are low efficiency
(percolation, time and wasted area among trees), labor intensive and not well suited
for sandy soils [7].
9.2.3.2. Groundwater Irrigation System
This source is mainly used in Balochistan where the desert cultivation is prevalent.
Furthermore, the groundwater depth (availability) has the major impact on the
productivity of date palm in the desert areas of Balochistan. Drop of water level to
Page 36 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
25-30 feet caused drought impact on the date palm forcing the growers to pump
deeper groundwater for irrigation of the trees. The annual rainfall varied between 50
and 250 mm which recharge the aquifers.
Water requirement of one healthy date palm tree in such areas is estimated at150
m3/year according to a study was undertaken by the Kuwait University at similar
areas [20]. The water requirement does not depend on the source of the water, and is
same for the irrigated as well as non-irrigated plantations. The minimum water
requirement for one tree throughout the year for survival is estimated at 25 m3. This
quantity of water is enough for minimal vegetative growth and yield. The minimum
productivity of one date palm tree from the dominant „Rabie‟ cultivar at Northern
West of Balochistan was estimated at 10 kg/year.
The newly planted offshoots in these areas are, however, manually irrigated for a
period of 2-3 years until the young trees are able to extend their roots to access the
groundwater. The extent of date palm plantations is dispersed to isolated plantations
due to the availability of the groundwater or concentrated areas in South part of
Balochistan. Thus, the plantations can be divided into two categories:
9.2.3.2.1. Irrigated Plantations (Furrow and Basin
Irrigation)
Where the plantations are irrigated, the date palm tree will not extend its roots for
more than 2 meters below the surface. If there is a deficit in irrigation water, the tree
will extend its roots to access the water in the range of its root system.
In these areas where the plantations are irrigated, the groundwater is at a depth of
over 50 feet. The mature trees rely exclusively on the pumped groundwater to
provide the irrigation water, with the root systems adapted to the depth at which the
water is available. The groundwater is deeper and appears to be supported by the
availability of cheap electricity and diesel fuel. Pumps powered by diesel engines are
used, while some of the pumps are powered by electricity available from Iran. The
water is delivered to the date palm plantations through unlined surface channels
connected to a holding basin or a small reservoir which is fed by a pump.
Figure 26: Furrow and Basin Irrigation System of Irrigated Date Palm Plantations at
Balochistan.
Page 37 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Electricity procured from Iran by the Pakistan government is presently being
provided to the farmers at a fixed charge of Rs 3-4 thousand/month. There are
indications that the fixed charges will be raised substantially in the near future to
account for the cost of electricity purchased from Iran, which is likely to make the
irrigated agriculture uneconomic. In the irrigated areas, the plantations are irrigated
approximately twice a week in the summer and once a week in the winter.
9.2.3.2.2.
Non-Irrigated Plantations
The depth of groundwater mostly is less than 12 feet in these areas where the mature
trees depend on the shallow groundwater and are not irrigated. The date palm trees
can easily extend their roots to access the groundwater.
Figure 27: Non-Irrigated Date Palm Plantations in Balochistan which Rely on
Shallow Groundwater.
Introduction of improved irrigation systems for the date palm plantations whether in
Sindh River Basin or desert areas at Balochistan such as Drip Irrigation, Sprinkler
and Micro Irrigation. However, water management will have to take into account the
Page 38 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
level of skills available, and will require training and education of the growers.
Farmer organizations could be organized for the collective benefit of the growers,
and the district authorities may have to be involved to organize the training,
production, and marketing, and to settle conflicts among date palm growers.
9.2.4. Fronds Pruning and Dethorning
Pruning in date palm is in general the removal of yellow or nearly dead fronds on a
regular basis. This will include dead, dying, and broken fronds. Depending on
variety and cultural conditions, date palm fronds can remain alive for at least seven
years. A date palm may have between 90 to 180 fronds up to 16 feet long. As the
fronds do not drop of their own accord, they must then be cut off manually, keeping
in view the necessity for ease in fruit harvesting. On well-grown date palms, the
removal of a few more green fronds will not be detrimental to the plant. Under good
agro-environmental conditions, functional fronds are those found below the current
year‟s flowers. After the mature fronds are 3 to 4 years old, they slowly begin to die.
Once the pinnae begin to yellow from tip towards the base of the frond, it is time to
remove them.
Sharp pruning for other reasons such as handmade and fruit boxes etc.,
indiscriminately hack at palm. All green fronds produce the food needed to grow
properly, producing a healthy palm tree. The reduction of the green frond area
reduces food production, and in turn, the health and growth of the palm is placed in
jeopardy. Pruning is desirable in order to improve date fruit quality and also enhance
the bearing capacity. For each bunch approximately 7-8 fronds are required for an
appropriate fruit growth and development [21].
Furthermore, unpruned dead fronds probably compete with the fruit, and create
favorable sites for diseases and pests [7]. This may also hinder the process of
climbing the tree for manual harvesting and pollination.
In other countries, growers could use Ladders, non-spike climbing gear, and
hydraulic lifts [17].
There are various procedures for pruning that followed by growers at different
countries. In Pakistan, growers mostly going for frond pruning of adult trees after
harvest in August and before spathes emergences in January. They also do pruning
for the attached offshoots in winter which increase RPW attack. Third time is during
pollination in March and April. The lower 2-3 whorls of fronds were cut and their
base of half foot was left as steps for the common practice of manual pruning.
Simultaneously 2-3 frond whorls were retained on the tree beneath the place of
current year spathes (fruit bunches in future). Thus that fronds can help in carrying
the heavy fruit bunches to avoid bunch break in most of the cultivars. In some
cultivars, bunches are remained free without tying to the bases of fronds (Zaghloul
Cv. in Egypt).
Page 39 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
In other countries pruning could also be realized at any convenient time between the
harvesting and the flowering season (thinning period is recommended) and because
of the greater ease in cutting [7, 18].
Considerable evidence shows that, other conditions being equal, the fruit bearing
capacity of a date palm is in proportion to the number of green fronds it carries [7,
18].
During the pruning operation, unwanted offshoots should also be removed to foster
the growth of rooted off shoots on the palm for further propagation, to make access
to the palm easier and to promote growth and bearing of the parent palm. In very
dense offshoots growth, some of the small plants may be seedlings rather than true
offshoots, and must be discarded. However, where there is any fear of frost in the
coming winter, no pruning is recommended and the fronds are left for the protection
from the cold of the young tender fronds. No frond pruning is to be practiced during
the first two years (only fronds that touch the ground could be removed), [7, 18].
Since the fungus usually enters the palm through wounds made during pruning or
cutting when removing the offshoots, one precaution is to disinfect all tools and cut
surfaces. Frond pruning should be coupled with treatment with Bordeaux mixture or
any large spectrum fungicide (Mancozeb, Cupric Hydroxide, and Copper
Oxychloride). Pruning normally keeps pest populations at tolerable levels.
Another important pruning process is the removal of spines, also called thorns. Date
spines are usually removed from the new growth of fronds in the crown of the palm
just before the pollination season to allow easy access to the date spathes as they
emerge. A total of about 26 to 36 fronds are dethroned every year. Such an operation
will ensure a safe approach to the spathes for their pollination and also avoid any
risk of injury to laborers during other technical practices (tying down, protection of
bunches, harvesting, etc.).
For pruning and dethorning, a pruning knife mounted on a wooden handle 30 to 45
cm long, or a sickle type blade with a sharp cutting edge were usually used.
Generally in Pakistan dethorning is carried out before or at the time of pollination.
9.2.5. Pollination
Date palm is a dioecious species bearing male and female flowers on separate
individual trees. The male palm produces the pollen and the female palm produces
the fruit. The flower stalks are produced from the axils of the fronds in similar
positions to those in which offshoots are produced. The inflorescence covered with
protective sheath and consists of a set of spikelets which are short in male and long
in female at the time of bursting. One adult female palm, on average, produces 15 25 spathes that contain 150 to 200 spikelets each. The male flowers are borne single
and are waxy white, while the female flowers are borne in clusters of three and are
yellowish green in color.
Page 40 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Natural pollination by wind, bees and insects is found to yield a fair fruit set in
various areas of the date growing countries. In the absence of such natural
pollination, female flowers are not fertilized. This leads to the development of
carpels and consequently parthenocarpic fruits without any commercial value are
obtained. Date growers are aware of the need of the artificial pollination and
pollination techniques for better fruit set and yield.
Commercial date production requires artificial pollination which ensures good
fertilization and overcomes disadvantages of dichogamy (different opening time for
male and female spathes) and also reduces the number of male palms (with no fruit
production).
In most of date palm countries including Pakistan, the traditional pollination
technique is to place few male spikelets in the center of the opened female spathe.
The male/female ratio normally is 1/25 but, in a modern plantation is 1/50. Artificial
pollination could be considered according to a traditional method or by using a
mechanized device [7, 18]. Number of spikes depends on the cultivar. For „Aseel‟
Cv., 4-5 spikelets were used but, for good fruit quality some growers used merely 23 spikelets to get less fruit number along with bigger size. In Egypt, low rate of fruit
set in „Barhee‟ Cv. derived from the tissue culture was observed especially during its
initial stage of cultivation. Thus, rows of male trees were cultivated alternatively
with the productive trees.
Page 41 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 28: Fresh Spathes Market at Khairpur as a Source for Pollen Grains.
Fruit quality is dependent mainly on the pollen grain source. Farmers used to get the
male spathes in the beginning of the season from the market with wide variation of
quality. In advanced Arab World Countries, „Ghanami‟ and other many famous male
trees are used as good pollinator‟s source. [39].
In Khairpur and most of date palm areas in Pakistan, growers used to buy the male
spathes from a market which held annually in spring (Fig. 28). Nevertheless, three
pollination techniques can be used depending on the type of pollen available [7].
9.2.5.1. Pollination Techniques
9.2.5.1.1.
Fresh Male Strands
The most common practice of pollination is to cut the strands of male flowers from a
freshly opened male spathe and place two to three of these strands, lengthwise and in
an inverted position, between the strands of the female inflorescence. This should be
done after some pollen has been shaken over the female inflorescence [22]. In order
to keep the male strands in place and also to avoid the entanglement of the female
cluster's strands during their rapid growth, it is recommended to use a twine (a strip
torn from a palm leaflet or a string) to tie the pollinated female cluster 5 to 7 cm
from the outer end.
9.2.5.1.2.
Pollen Suspension
Laboratory and field experiments on three varieties from Saudi Arabia (Khalas,
Ruzaiz and Shishi) have shown that a pollen grain suspension, containing 10 %
sucrose and 20 Part per Million (ppm) Gibberellic Acid (GA3) could be used for
pollination [23]. Pollination sprays were found to be as good as hand pollination in
relation to fruit setting. Fruit set was 80 % using this suspension technique while
only 60 % was obtained when using the classical hand pollination technique. On the
other hand, a suspension solution containing pollen grains, sucrose, boron, glycerine
and GA3 did not match the results of hand pollination [24].
Page 42 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.2.5.1.3.
Dried Pollen
This pollination technique is more economical and allows proper use of the pollen as
well as adequate control of the timing of pollination. Dried pollen could originate
from the last season, from early maturing males of the same season, or from few
days old male flowers. There are several techniques to apply dry pollen:
9.2.5.1.3.1.
Cotton Swab: The most common technique of
using dry pollen is to dust it on cotton pieces about the size
of a walnut and place one or two pieces between the strands
of female inflorescences.
9.2.5.1.3.2.
Use of a puffer: A small manual insecticide duster,
known as a 'puffer' is also used to apply dry pollen. This
technique is used either alone or in addition to the cotton
pieces technique [25].
9.2.5.1.3.3.
Aircraft pollination: Experiments with pollinating
of dates with an aircraft were conducted in the Coachella
Valley of California on Deglet Nour cultivar [26]. Results
showed that even though temperatures and weather
conditions were favorable, both the helicopter and fixedwing methods of application yielded less fruit sets than the
hand pollination method. This technique was abandoned as it
required at least 4 to 5 times the amount of pollen
traditionally used, and was also found to be not economically
feasible.
9.2.5.1.3.4.
Mechanical pollination: Mechanical pollination
was developed mostly in the New World of date palm (USA)
where labor is expensive and not always available. It consists
of pollinating freshly opened female spathes from the ground
with the use of a special apparatus [Fig. 29]. Mechanical
pollination has been one of the most important alternatives
when the labor has been reduced by 50 - 70 % [27, 28]. It is
estimated that a man must climb a date palm few times from
the time of pollination through to crop harvesting.
Mechanical pollination from ground level for three times and
with 1:4 (pollen/filler ratio) was recommended to achieve
high yielding of most date varieties [28]. It seems that the
frequencies of mechanical pollination as well as the suitable
concentration of pollen/filler ratio are the most important
factors in date palm pollination.
Page 43 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Also, mechanization in planned farms would be useful for some cultivars. FAO has
donated a pollinator machine to DPRI and other progressive farmers (Fig. 29). A
plan is set for next season to study the impact of such machine.
Figure 29: Mechanical Pollinator Has Donated by FAO to Date Palm Growers in
2010.
A ground-level duster is capable of pollinating 24 to 32 ha per season. In order to
accommodate the palm height and also to direct the pollen delivery tube near the
bloom area of each palm, the machine is equipped with a variable height platform
capable of 4.5 m vertical movement. The duster is driven along one side of the date
row and then returns on the opposite side to finish the pollination cycle [29]. Such
mechanical pollination will require two laborers and could be realized according to
two approaches:
Pollination of each freshly opened female spathe or.
Spraying of the whole female frond canopy just above the opened spathes.
The first approach is the more accurate one, but requires the farmer to have good
knowledge of his plantation as well as good record- keeping ensuring the pollination
of all spathes. The second technique is economically feasible and saves time.
However, a high rate of aborted fruits could occur when this technique is used.
During early season pollination, or when the pollination season is characterized by
low normal temperatures, it is recommended to alternate pollination of sides of the
palm at 4 to 7- day intervals. This overlapping of pollination was shown to yield
more reliable results than full palm pollination at one time [28].
The advantages of mechanical pollination could be summarized as follows:
Reduction of labor and duration of pollination, both are contributing to the
reduction of the cost of pollination. Furthermore, it does not require a highly
trained labor as with the traditional technique.
Page 44 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
The possibility of pollinating a palm at several times in a short period of time
is assured.
The use of a mixture of pollen originating from different sources is
permitted, thus ensuring good fertilization.
The risk of accidents occurring as with the old method of climbing a palm
several meters high is eliminated.
9.2.5.2. Pollen Harvest and Handling
A male spathe that is ready to split assumes a brown color and a soft texture.
Immediately after the spathe opens longitudinally, the male inflorescence reaches its
maturity and male flower clusters must be cut at this stage. To prevent wind or bees
from causing loss of pollen it is recommended that the freshly-opened spathe be cut
early in the morning [7].
Date growers traditionally harvest the male spathes one or two days after their
opening and place them in a shaded and moisture-free area for drying. Strands are
then detached and stored till needed for the pollination of female inflorescences.
Transport of strands for a long distance (between two date plantations) must be
handled with maximum care. The use of paper bags is recommended to preserve the
pollen and avoid losses.
The common practice of cutting the male spathe a day or two before its natural
opening as practiced in the Old World (Middle East and North Africa) is not
recommended because it requires a high level of experience and familiarity with the
male palms [28]. The technique is to press the middle or lower part of the male
spathe between the thumb and forefinger. If a crackling noise is heard, it is a sign of
maturity of flowers. In such a case the spathe could be cut and flowers taken to the
storage room for drying. A pollen-handling protocol necessitates the rapid and
efficient dehydration of moist pollen before its storage.
High temperatures have a negative effect on pollen drying and storing processes.
Pollen exposed to direct sunlight or placed near a source of heat, will rapidly
deteriorate and lose viability (also called vitality). Viability is defined as the ability
of a pollen grain to germinate and develop [30].
It is well known that, depending on climatic conditions, a date grower could face a
season where a heavy early female bloom develops. Consequently, the storage of
pollen within the pollination season (2 to 3 months) or from one season to another is
necessary. Freshly opened male flowers contain a high level of moisture;
consequently if they are not to be used immediately, their prompt drying is important
in order to avoid the destruction of pollen by moulds. There are various ways and
techniques to store the pollen depending on the quantity to be stored, storage
conditions and the duration of storage [7, 18].
Page 45 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.2.5.3. Storage of Pollen
It is a simple way to store a small quantity of pollen; strands are separated and
spread in a thin layer on paper in a shallow tray in a shaded/protected area.
9.2.5.3.1.
Male Flower Clusters
Clusters are put on top of screen-wire trays or shelves with a container beneath to
catch the dry pollen that falls from the flowers; Note that the pollen quality remains
unchanged even though the flowers turn dark within 3 to 7 days. This storage
technique is mostly used for handling larger quantities of pollen. Date growers in
Iraq [31] and in Egypt [32] conserve the pollen by placing the flowers, usually dried
and crushed, in a muslin bag and left in a well dried-ventilated area.
9.2.5.3.2.
Mechanical Pollen Extractor and Collector
The machine can daily handle up to 450 male flower clusters and collects
approximately 40 % more pollen than any other extraction method. The pollen
viability and longevity were found to be unaffected by such mechanical extraction.
Once the pollen is well dried and cold stored in an airtight container, it could be
safely re-used during the next season with very little loss of viability. It can be kept
in container and placed in the refrigerator at 4 centigrade.
To maintain zero per cent humidity, dry pollen is placed in an open jar within a
larger airtight container (a dessicator) in the bottom of which are well dried lumps of
calcium chloride (CaCl2) as a dehydrating agent. Other absorbents that can also be
used are saturated solutions of zinc chloride (ZnCl2), calcium nitrate (N(CaO)³)²4H²O) and potassium chloride (KCl). Approximately 500 g of calcium chloride is
enough for 2-3 kg of pollen.
9.2.5.4. Pollination Time
Satisfying pollination results are obtained within 2 or 4 days after the female spathe
has opened. February and March is the normal pollination period in Pakistan.
Variety and season could delay or advance the opening of the flowers.
9.2.5.5. Factors Affect Pollination
Seedling males are highly variable in their growth vigor, spathe characteristics and
pollen quality. Also, the amount of pollen grains produced by spathe varied greatly
from one male to another (0.02 - 82.29 g/spathe), [33]. It is well known that different
varieties of date palm require different amounts of pollen [22]. Using fresh male
strands, the number required for pollinating a female spathe may vary from 1 to 10
depending on variety. Most of the male date palms used throughout the world's date
growing areas are of seedling-origin with a great variation regarding pollen quality.
Page 46 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
The capacity of pollen to germinate and grow normally is known as viability. The
assessment of viability of freshly collected as well as stored pollen is often desirable
before using them for pollination. Applying enough pollen does not guarantee a
good fruit set unless the pollen used is viable with a high germination percentage.
Environmental conditions such as high temperature, low humidity, salinity build up
and UV radiation may influence pollen viability.
The length of the receptivity period of the pistillate flowers could, in general, vary
up to 8 or 10 days depending on the variety [34] and prevailing environmental
conditions in the region.
High temperatures inhibit the development of spathes resulting in a delay of the
pollination season. Low temperatures, usually early in the season, also have a
negative effect on the fruit set. However, if female flowers open early in the season
and their pollination is essential, then the sets could be improved by placing paper
bags over the female inflorescence at the time of pollination. During the pollination
season, it is recommended not to pollinate in the early morning or late afternoon,
because of the negative effect of low temperatures on the fruit sets. At locations
where daily maximum temperatures during pollination are frequently less than 24°C,
mechanical pollination method is not recommended [35].
In most date growing areas the latter part of the pollination season is usually
characterized by severe hot and dry wind which dries out the stigmas of the female
flowers. Cold winds disturb the pollen germination. This could be the predominant
climate in West Northern part of Balochistan and causing varied fruit set along with
groundwater depth.
In North of Balochistan, most of the growers bring the pollen grains from other areas
where the male trees have flowered earlier and the quality of pollen grains is better
as the male spathes have been able to avoid the adverse impact of the winter. It was
also observed that a number of trees produced non-pollinated fruits as the male
spathes were spoiled by the extreme and prolonged winter in 2007-2008.
Boron is an essential nutrient in pollination and the subsequent reproduction
processes, i.e. the formation and growth of flowers and fruits. It also plays a role in
the uptake of calcium, magnesium and potassium [18, 36].
9.2.5.6. Effect of Rain on Pollination
There is controversy concerning the effect of rain on fruit set. Some consider rain
that occurs just after pollination as a washing agent that takes away most of the
applied pollen before it plays its role. In such a case, it is necessary to repeat
pollination after the rain has ended. Other people consider the negative effect of rain
on fruit set as an indirect effect via low temperatures that accompany or follow rain.
If temperatures are between 25 and 28°C, most of the pollen tubes reach the base of
the style of Hayani variety flowers within 6 hours [37]; while at 15°C, pollen tubes
Page 47 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
do not reach the base of the style even after 8 hours. A third explanation of the effect
of rain is the reduction of the pistillate flowers' receptivity by contact with water.
Rain is also responsible for increasing the relative air humidity which favors attacks
by cryptogamic diseases that result in the rotting of inflorescences. This high relative
humidity is also associated with reducing the pollen's blow out.
In conclusion, date growers must assume that rain can cause all the above effects,
and any pollination operation immediately followed by rain must be repeated in
time. There is a limited period (4 to 6 hours either before or after pollination) during
which, if rain occurs, pollination and fruit sets are affected and the pollination
operation must then be repeated.
9.2.5.7. Xenia and Metaxenia
It is well known that the pollen not only affects the size of the fruit and seed
(affected more by fruit thinning) but also the time of ripening [38]. Metaxenia is not
to be confused with Xenia, which is the effect of the pollen on the endosperm
(embryo and albumen). The effect of pollen on the time of fruit ripening was proven
to be beneficial and is actually considered as the most important practical application
of Metaxenia. Producing and selling date fruits at high prices early in the season,
along with the aim of having more uniform and short ripening period (avoiding a
prolonged harvest) are the two main objectives of using selected pollen of high
Metaxenia effect. A third useful application of Metaxenia is where the development
period of the plant is characterized by an insufficient sum total of heat for the fruit
ripening of late varieties [7].
It is worth mentioning that Metaxenia effect could also be successfully used to speed
up the fruit maturity and consequently escape the rain damage that is usually
expected at the end of the fruit development period (Pakistan, Algeria, Tunisia,
USA, etc.)
9.2.6. Fruit Harvest and Handling
The key problem in the Pakistani date‟s industry is the fruit harvesting which made
Pakistan occupied the position number 72 among world dates exporters in regard to
export value (FAO, 2007).
Dates harvest means physically collecting the fruit from the head of the palm.
Harvesting is according to differences which are both visible, such as the fruit color
and the degree of ripeness; and invisible, such as the percentage of water and sugar.
Whole dates are harvested and marketed at three stages of their development. The
choice for harvesting at one or another stage depends on varietal characteristics,
climatological conditions and market demand. The three stages are as follows [7]:
Khalal: Physiological mature, hard and crisp, moisture content: 50-85 %,
bright yellow or red in color, perishable;
Page 48 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Rutab: Partially browned, reduced moisture content (30-45 %), fibers
softened, perishable;
Tamar: Color from amber to dark brown, moisture content further reduced
(below 25 % down to 10% and less), texture from soft pliable to firm to hard,
protected from insects it can be kept without special precautions over longer
periods.
In general, when dates reach the Khalal stage, they are regarded to be ready for
trading as "fresh" fruit. Dates in Khalal stage are the first in the harvesting season
and therefore have a ready market. Only date varieties with a low amount of tannin
at Khalal stage are suitable for consumption. In Pakistan, these cultivars are few
such as „Dedhi‟, „Mathri‟ and „Gulistan‟.
The low amount of tannin results in low astringency. Furthermore, it is important
that the fruit is sweet and not bitter. Internationally, date varieties suitable for
marketing at Khalal stage are „Barhee‟, „Zaghloul‟, „Hayany‟ and „Khalas‟. Of these
varieties, only „Barhee‟ is sold in England, France and Australia, while the other two
are mostly consumed locally [7].
Experience in most date producing countries showed that a well matured Rutab,
handled with care, is one, if not the most, appreciated form in which the dates is
consumed and which gives the grower the highest rate of return. However, Rutab has
three serious setbacks:
It is produced in comparatively short periods with the tendency of production
peaks.
It is highly perishable.
It is delicate, which makes handling and transport difficult and expensive.
Major commercial date varieties harvested at Rutab stage are Deglet Nour
and Medjool.
The polluted date with mud which is mostly present on the packed Pakistani dates
was due to the poor handling of fruit during harvest rather than processing. The
manual harvesting practice in the biggest two areas is different. In Khairpur, growers
were used to manually pick the early ripening fruit of „Aseel‟ and other cultivars by
shaking the bunch few times before the final cut of fruit bunch. The fallen fruit were
collected in baskets or shallow trays and loaded down by aid of a robe to another
person receiving fruit on the ground (Fig. 30).
Page 49 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 30: Fruit Harvesting Practice in Khairpur.
The harvested fruit at early Rutab stage were extended on mats made from the
leaflets of date palm fronds. After 5-6 days of sun curing, partially dried dates were
usually collected in wooden boxes. Cracks of outer fruit skin (Pericarp) and curing
date fruit over the mats extended on dusty place without any conscious to avoid the
contamination caused technical problem to clean these fruit in processing factories.
It is important to mention that the majority of harvested date fruit were occurred
during Khalal stage while fruit is not edible yet. But, fruit is usually harvesting at
early stage to avoid monsoon rains. Thus, harvested fruit were subjected to boiled
water for 15-20 minutes, then draying on mats for 4-5 days to get this type which is
called „Chohara‟. Pakistan is occupied advance position with about 60 thousand ton
(FAO, 2008) due to exported „Chohara‟ to India which is the biggest importer of
dates in the World (FAO, 2007) mainly for celebration purposes not for eating. This
type of boiled date fruit can‟t be acceptable for eating in most of dates import
countries.
In Balochistan particularly in the Western Northern part, growers utilize „Baat‟ to
protect the growing fruit from hot sandy wind. The weight of one bunch of „Rabie‟
cultivar ranges from 3-6 kg. The “Baat” is tied with the one or two fronds from
upper edge and rests on one or two lower fronds. The matured fruit is cut by a
specially made tool.
Harvesting starts in July in the Mashkhel area located towards the south of the
Hamun-e-Mashkhel, and the harvesting time varies slightly from area to area due to
the climatic conditions. Harvesting in areas located towards the north of the Hamune-Mashkhel such as Gualishtop, Rajai, and Wadian starts around the end of the first
week of August.
For the plantations that depend on groundwater the productivity of the date palm
trees increases as the level of groundwater rises, which is the expected trend for the
date palm. The average of productivity of a date palm tree in the Brouhook where
the depth of water is 1.5 m is 20-40 kg/palm/year, as compared to 10-30
Page 50 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
kg/palm/year for other non-irrigated locations. The average of total yield of date
palm increases to 50 kg/palm/year in the irrigated areas of Tahlab and Washab. Most
of the cultivars are semi-dry and dry cultivars which is harvesting in Tamar stage.
Fruit harvested at Tamar stage is non-perishable, i.e. micro-organisms cannot grow
on it, moisture uptake and its consequences, and changes in colour and taste occur
during storage. Most of the dates of „Dayri‟, „Halawy‟, „Khadrawy‟, „Thoori‟,
„Zahidi‟ and „Sayer‟ cultivars are harvested after the fruit has undergone the process
of ripening and drying on the palms [7].
Fruit at the Tamar stage is ideal for marketing as dried dates. This fruit is used for
preservation and year-round consumption and also for the production of various
types of products, e.g. cakes, sauces and components of granules or date honey.
Harvesting the fruit entails the use of experienced workers, or investment in
aluminium ladders, in attaching ladders to the palms permanently or in purchasing
mechanical appliance to lift workers to the top of the palm.
Harvesting must be faultless and clean, since it significantly affects the rest of the
process (packing and marketing). Harvesting the fruit straight into containers
suitable for transport to the packinghouse prevents the infection of the fruit by the
soil and sand under the palm and ensures that the fruit arrives in good condition, and
that it is not crushed [7].
The harvested fruit in advanced dates countries is transferred into containers (large
plastic bins) for transport to the packing station. Large wooden, plastic or cardboard
cases of various sizes are also used, focusing on the need to prevent damage to the
fruit (especially to soft and sensitive fruit). Baskets, sacks (for very dry fruit), and
trays are also used. It is desirable to separate damaged fruit which is not destined for
the market, while still at the site. Dates that are rotten, sour, with remains of insects,
crushed, shriveled up, unfertilized, or unripe fruit which are not intended for
artificial ripening should be removed from the plantation. These fruits should be
destroyed or fed to animals, in order to maintain sanitation of the plantation [7].
When transporting the fruit one must also take into account its sensitivity, and the
importance of every link in the chain in the treatment of the fruit. Dates harvested at
the Khalal stage must be transported as soon as possible to receive appropriate
treatment, whether it is for local consumption or for export. The fruit must be
transported in the early hours of the morning to avoid the heat; if the distance is
great, refrigeration during transport is advisable. Speedy transport will also prevent
infection by pests which attack the fruit during the post- harvesting period [7].
Once cured dates arrived to dates factories in Khairpur, which collected in the
beginning of Rutab stage and extended on mats, and washed from the dust, labor are
classifying them into 3 categories according to size and blemishes existence into
small, medium and large fruit (Fig. 31). Most of factories are using few cultivars
Page 51 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
whether produced in Pakistan such as „Aseel‟, „Begum Jangi‟ „Dhakki‟, „Rabie‟ and
„Muzafati‟, or imported from Iran and Iraq such as „Zahdi‟, „Sayer „and „Rabie‟.
Figure 31: Sorting the „Rabie‟ Dates to Three Categories According to Size and
Free from Blemishes.
In Pakistan, no facilitated warehouses are present. The cured Rutab are always
packed in wooden boxes or hand-made baskets. On the other hand, the dried dates of
boiled „Chohara‟ are collected in wooden boxes or fiber sacks (Fig. 32), and then
transferred to the market for auction by brokers to be exported mainly to India. In the
market, the transferred dried dates were subjected to sorting process by labor
according to their size and free from blemishes at the market place (Fig. 32). The
usual measurement unit for dates selling in Pakistan is 40 Kgs which is mostly equal
to 1500-6000 Pak Rs., (70 USD). Production of a single tree of „Aseel‟ (100-120
Kgs fresh fruit) can give 40-50 Kgs dried dates of „Chuahara‟.
Figure 32: Warehouses in Dates Market at Khairpur.
In various countries there are several kinds of contracts between growers and the
packinghouse. Family packinghouses may be small or large, built in or near the
Page 52 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
plantation, and they are owned by the grower. In such a packinghouse there is
continuity and coordination between the activities at the plantation and in the
packinghouse. Workers at the plantation supply the fruit in accordance with the
potential of the packinghouse and the relevant installations to receive it, for instance
for fumigation, refrigeration and storage. The packinghouse also adapts itself to the
constraints of harvesting, such as the speed of ripening of varieties harvested at the
Khalal stage, adding another shift when necessary, increasing its workforce
(temporarily), renting storage space and operating fumigation rooms continuously
[7].
Handling the crop after harvest is lacking the experience. Subsequently the microbial
load of the dates was dramatically increased before processing and storage which
caused problems for processors.
From the above discussion, it is noticed that date palm tree in Pakistan does not
receive great attention as far as fertilization and other agricultural practices which
resulted in low growth rate and low production. A national program for date palm
maintenance and improvement is recommended in order to increase the productivity
and fruit quality consequently the export value of Pakistani dates.
9.3. Pests and Diseases
9.3.1. Wilt Disease (Sudden Decline) at Khairpur, Symptoms and
Remedy
Date palm trees at Sindh particularly Khairpur are suffering from a critical disease
which is the sudden decline syndrome (Fig. 33). The date palm sudden decline
disease could resemble some symptoms of similar wilt diseases in the world such as
Palm Lethal Yellowing caused by Phytoplasma which is a fatal disease of Coconut
and also infectious to date palm [40, 41, 42]. The drying manner of fronds displayed
similar symptoms of Bayoud (Fusarium wilt) disease caused by Fusarium oxysporum
Schlechtendahl f.sp.albedinis in Morocco and Algeria [43, 44].
Page 53 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 33: Normal (Left Tree) and Infected (Right Tree) Date Palm Tree with
Sudden Decline Disease in Pakistan
9.3.1.1. Symptoms
The symptoms are starting with orange yellowish coloring of the lower part of the
fronds midrib (rachis) then drying out the fronds from outside toward central fronds.
Draying starting from the leaflets (pinnae) of a frond base on one side up to the tip
then twists to the leaflets of the opposite side. Eventually, draying out the entire
frond is occurred. Fronds drying sequence is in order and gradually not all fronds
drying at the same time. This is a prominent symptom of such disease (Fig. 34).
Figure 34: Frond Symptoms of Date Palm Decline Disease
Infection can be occurred at any time of the year. The most elusive thing is the
selective behavior of the disease to individual palms among many trees in the
orchard, i.e. the synchronization (Fig. 33). Rarely all palms in an orchard found
infected at same time. Furthermore, the decline symptoms can appear on different
Page 54 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Infection at early stage of fruit development caused fruit drop and failure to reach
maturity stage. Fruit bunches drying if the disease attacked the date palm at late
Khalal and Rutab stages. Overall drying affects fronds and fruit together. Fruiting
breakdown or cessation occurred when trees have infected before spathes emergence.
The breakdown of trees dramatically occurred within 3-6 months to reach to
complete drying of the entire tree. But, sometimes, it takes 1-2 years during which
trees stopped fruiting.
9.3.1.2. Cause(s) of the Problem
The problem has started approximately since 10 years in Pakistan, still it is not
epidemic problem. The problem was recorded in Khairpur district and other areas of
Sindh province. Since that time and a controversial was started. In the beginning
some opinions attributed this problem to the Termites infestation where it is a
problem for the date palm in Pakistan. The support to this opinion came through
some local recipes made from a mixture contained the extract of Neem Tree
(Azadirachta indica) followed by relative recovery of the tree after the foliar
application in some instances. However, so many trees are suffering right now and in
the past with no such symptoms.
A haphazard estimate was delivered by some agricultural officers with no real
scientific background who have visited the affected areas and mentioned that this is
a viral disease! Other specialists from different institute have taken samples but with
no feedback remedy for their problem which is inflaming day after day.
Furadan is the trade name of Carbofuran which is insecticide-nematicide suggested
by National Nematology Research Center. Their findings were "heavy infection of
Plant Parasitic and Root Knot Nematodes in the root zone". Application of
Nematicide is recommended for nematodes control. Unfortunately, field application
with Furadan was frustrating trial when applied at HEJ, Karachi University backyard
garden where some date palm trees are falling one after another (Fig. 35).
Page 55 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 35: The Decline Disease Selectivity to Date Palm Trees in the Backyard Garden
of HEJ, Karachi University in 2010.
Crop Disease Research Institute (CDRI), Pakistan Agriculture Research Council,
Karachi University Campus, their findings indicated that Pathogenic Fungi
associated with the bark disease of tree were isolated frequently from the plant
samples. In visual examination it was noticed that all samples were severely infested
with insect pests. Root-knot nematode and other Tylenchida3 observed. The
suggestion was Topsin-M or Carbendazim which used as bud drenching and soil
drenching. Three to Four grams of Carbofuran have been recommended.
Unfortunately, this treatment had no effect. Eventually, the treated trees died and
symptoms started to appear on the adjacent trees associated with the common
symptoms of the disease. DPRI has established an activity with hope to find quick
and active remedy. DPRI way to treat such problem has applied as will be discussed.
9.3.1.3. Remedy
All these trials pressurized DPRI, SAL Univ., to conduct a comprehensive study to
initially apply all pesticides and fungicides which are available in the market since 3
years to the infected trees with hope for a quick remedy. Two fungicides applications
with Bavistin (a broad-spectrum systemic fungicide of the benzimidazole group) and
Topsin M (Thiophanate Methyl) gave good results and trees up to high extent
recovered, i.e. started to produce spathes and its fruiting was normal and drying out
entirely stopped but, yellowish of the outer fronds midrib didn‟t not changed.
As an initiative the group of DPRI has recommend the following four-tiered
approach as a remedy for the trees showing same symptoms:
3
An order of nematodes is consisting of many species which are plant parasites. Female worms lay eggs
that hatch either in soil or in the host plant.
Page 56 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.3.1.3.1.
Cultural Practices
The infected fronds that showing such symptoms must cut and burnt but, there is no
need for cut if they are at the initial stage of the infection showing the yellowish
midrib (sometimes the inner heart fronds turned into pale green yellowish color
particularly with the 5-7 years trees).
As the drainage water as noticed to be in conjunction with any field having the
infected trees, irrigation water percolation should be optimized. The majority of the
infected trees were found planted on the terraces of irrigation canals or at areas with
low level land. For garden palms, daily irrigation for surrounded grass must be
suspended and replaced by periodical irrigation with enough quantity of water
according to climatic conditions, soil, etc.
DPRI has made a survey of seventeen locations at Khairpur viz., Noor pur, Ahmed
Pur, Machyoon, Baberloe, Garhi Mori, Kot Mir Mohammad, Piryalo, Hadal Shah,
Drib Mahesar, Munghan wary, Khan Pur, Maher Ali Shah, Rupri, Shadi Shaheed,
Therhi, Noonari and Nizamani to estimate the incidence and mortality of date palm
decline disease and to collect disease samples from affected trees. The disease
intensity was greatly varied from location to location and ranging from 0.25 to
50.17% (Fig. 36). The highest disease incidence of date palm decline was recorded at
Noor pur (50.17%) followed by Baberloe (35.58%) and Ahmed Pur (32.47%) [45].
Figure 36: The Disease Incidence of Date Palm Decline at Different Locations of
Khairpur.
Page 57 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.3.1.3.2.
Foliar Application
Three foliar sprays with Cupper Oxychoride (A contact fungicide and fertilizer)
solution 5 grams per liter of water through 10 days intervals alternatively with
Bavistin solution 3 ml per liter of water.
9.3.1.3.3.
Soil Application
Three soil application of Topsin M dissolved with the irrigation water around the
tree. Infected and adjacent trees which showing no symptoms must treated with
Topsin M solution 3 grams per liter of water (0.3%) applied as three fortnightly soil
or foliar application.
9.3.1.3.4.
Fertilizer Application
Tree is infected and needs special care regarding fertilization, while most of date
palm farmers did not apply chemical fertilizers to the affected trees.. Two
applications of 250 grams each per palm N-P-K fertilizer 17-17-17 on monthly soil
application 2-3 feet away from the trunk should be applied.
It is worth to mention that the above procedure has applied on an infected tree during
fruiting and all fruit bunches dried out at Khalal stage and failed to reach Rutab
stage. Once the tree was affected, the lower 2-4 whorls and old fronds started drying
and dangled down within 2 months. A tree with dangling dried fronds and yellowish
to central young fronds is a general symptom of the latent infection. The remedy
treatment stopped the drying out of remained green fronds at the center (Fig. 37).
Figure 37: Infection during Fruiting (Left Photo) and Remedy Treatment
Application (Right Photo).
Page 58 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.3.1.4. Isolation and Identification of Actual Pathogen
Based on the positive results of an urgent remedy experiment, the isolation and
identification of the pathogens from infected parts of the plants was started through a
Ph.D study of a DPRI member (Mr. Wazir Ali Miatlo) under the supervision of Dr.
Adel A. Abul-Soad and Dr G.S. Markhand in collaboration with Dr. Mumtaz Ali
Pathan and Abdul Mubeen Lodhi from Pathology Dept., Tando Jam Agricultural
Univ., Hyderabad in 2007 with preliminarily results showed that the pathogen is the
soil born fungus Fusarium Solani.
In recent years several reports on the isolation of Fusarium species from roots, fronds
and trunks of date palm trees showed wilt and decline.
Fusarium oxysporum and F.solani were the most frequent and most abundant in the
roots of date palm trees showing decline in middle of Iraq [46]. Fusarium
monliforme and F. solani were found associated with declined date palm trees in
Egypt [47]. In Iraq, a similar disease symptoms caused by F. solani have been
reported recently [48]. More recently, a serious disease of date palm was reported
caused by F. solani associated with yellowing and death of the fronds. The disease
occurred in date palm groves in Kazeron district, west of Fars province in Iran [49].
An investigation was reported on the incidence of date palm disease in Saudia Arabia
and in particular in Al Qassim and Medina Al Monawara regions, several trees
showed symptoms of wilt and dieback very similar to those caused by Fusarium
oxysporum albedinis. Three Fusarium species were isolated from the infected fronds
and roots of the date palm trees. These identified as F. proliferatum, F. solani and F.
oxysporum [50]. All previously mentioned reports are in agreement with the findings
of DPRI group, however, more work has to be done on the side of remedy.
Real effort with sanitary procedures should be taken to prevent the transmission of
the disease to other production areas and finding cost effective and innovative
solutions to control this disease.
9.3.2. Preventive and Curative Methods to Control Red Palm
Weevil Problem
The Red Palm Weevil (RPW) is widely considered the most devastating insect to
attack palms. In addition to Pakistan, RPW causes severe problems in many areas of
the world including the Arabian Peninsula, Northern Africa, USA, Spain, France,
Italy, Greece, Iran, India, Southeast Asia, and the Caribbean. In addition to date
palm, RPW can attack and kill ornamental, coconut, oil, and sago palms.
In Date Palm Research Institute, Shah Abdul Latif University, Khairpur during 2009
a study has carried out on an extensive survey of tissue boring pest of date palm, Red
Palm Weevil (Rhynchophorus ferrugineus Oliver). The survey covered 46 orchards
of 8 different locations at Khairpur area. The results of the survey indicated that 219
date palms (5.81 %) were infested by red palm weevil. The pest incidence indicated
that the maximum infestation percentage by red palm weevil was 9.29 % and
Page 59 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
occurred in the tree group age of 8-10 years, followed by 7.96 % in 11-15 years tree
group age. However, trees of 35-40 years old had very low infestation incidence
(0.02 %) [51].
The deleterious phase is the larvae which bore tunnels through palm trunk as they
feed, eventually may kill the tree. Adult weevils can spread by flying up to 4 miles
in 3-5 days. One infested tree may maintain 164 larvae in addition to other insect
phases. Infestation is occurring around the year, however, infestation increases in
winter months.
The infestation area mostly located at the basal portion of the offshoot where it joins
the mother tree. Brown sap is secreting from the infestation area with bad smell (Fig.
38). Infection rate is high during winter season accompanies the regular pruning
process in the beginning of December. Cutting surfaces and distinguishable
fragrance of cut fronds attracts the insect to make new infestation. Preventive
methods include spray on cut surfaces and entire fronds are strongly recommended
to repel the RPW until the dryness of cut surfaces. Also, cleaning the area around the
productive trees and removal of the ready offshoots to be separated could help for
early discovering of new infestation.
Figure 38: Symptoms of RPW Infection to Young Trees (8-10 Years), Brown Sap
Along with Bad Smell.
Although the strict tree monitoring of date palm orchard remains the only viable way
to protect your trees, the control of RPW includes:
Preventive methods: The prophylactic or preventive methods are
meant to delay or prevent the entry of the palm weevil into new palms
or orchards. For this purpose most vulnerable stages of the palms are
treated with pesticides, cultural practices like leaf cutting are modified,
phytosanitation, plant quarantine besides use of pheromone trapping
system to attract and kill the adult weevils.
Page 60 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Curative methods: After detection of infestation, most suitable
method of control should be applied [52].
Date palm tree could maintain all fronds green while it is infested with RPW. Mostly
the outer suspended fronds change its color to yellow after few months of the
infestation when contain pupa ready to produce new adults for a new infestation
somewhere else (Fig. 39). The procedure of RPW control in case of discovering an
infestation of RPW (Fig. 38) could be as follows:
In the beginning, the colored fronds were pruned and the adjacent offshoots were
separated. During this process, only one offshoot was infested at its base (Fig. 38),
while other offshoots were free. The infested tissues were chipped to pieces and
treated with pesticide or gasoline, then buried deeply in a hole of 4-5 feet depth.
Good sanitation practices are needed to prevent RPW escape and spreading from
infested palms.
Figure 39: Infestation with RPW since Few Months for the Mother Tree and
Adjacent Offshoots.
Cleaning the base of mother tree from the superficial larvae and pupa by
removing the outer leaf bases to uncover the decayed tissue (Fig. 40).
Page 61 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 40: The Larvae and Adult Insect of RPW were Collected from Infested Tree.
Phostoxin gassing tablets which contain aluminium phosphide were placed in
the entrance of larval galleries and the stem is entirely covered with clay mixed
with the pesticide Thiodan (Endosulfan) 5 ml per liter water (Fig. 41).
Aluminium phosphide reacts with normal atmospheric moisture to liberate
phosphine (hydrogen phosphide) gas. Aluminium phosphide is a highly toxic
substance and the phosphine gas which it liberates is lethal to all animals at low
concentrations in the air in nests, warrens and burrows. Before working with
Phostoxin, users must be given musk and not to breathe the gas. Tablet has no
residual effect on the soil, nor will it in any way harm plant life in the treated
area.
Figure 41: Tools Required for Remedy Are the Tree Borer Tool, Pesticide, Plastic
Tubes (1 Inch × 1 Foot), and Phostoxin Tablets.
Holes of one inch in diameter were dug in the trunk by the tree borer tool (Fig.
42). A plastic tube one foot in length was inserted in the trunk 0.5-1.0 foot above
the infestation place. The tube filled with the diluted pesticide with water at the
Page 62 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
ratio 1:3 (v/v). Number of used tubes is depending on the infestation size.
Mostly the number ranges from 3-9 tubes distributed around the trunk on
different levels. Orchard should not be irrigated before the curative process,
however, after along with chemical fertilization.
Figure 42: Cleaned Date Palm from RPW Phases and Pesticide & Phostoxin Tablets
Were Applied.
Almost 1-2 offshoots were left joint their mother tree for its balance and
survival. Moreover, supporting may require in case of severe infestation as a
result of tending the mother tree, otherwise it may fall down.
Spray the cut surfaces of remaining offshoots and pruned fronds with different
pesticide Malathion (organophosphate insecticide) 5 ml per liter of water as
foliar application to repel RPW. Lot of care should be taken during detachment
process which may fall down the tree due the decayed tissue. In such scenario, if
the tree started to tend to any side, the process of detachment should be banned
and supports the trunk.
After all infested trees were curatively controlled (Fig. 43), a spray with a
pesticide for all trees in the orchard every 2 weeks intervals for 3 times. The
pesticide must be changed to avoid natural resistance.
It is so difficult to understand the behavior of this pest. In some cases the
adjacent offshoots of infested palm were found free from infestation while the
head of mother plant fallen down! The incomplete destruction of its future food
materials indicating planned feeding policy for such insect. Simultaneously
creates more pressure on the control policy. Also, cultivar preference was
detected where the RPW was selecting preferably „Dedhi‟ cultivar from among
25 cultivars are there. The prominent characters of this cultivar are the wide
trunk, soft tissue and sweet fruit at Khalal stage.
Page 63 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 43: Controlled Date Palm Tree after Remedy Application
There is advanced machinery tools can be used for artificial infection of the
trunk. Also, pheromone traps are effective tool to capture the insects of RPW
and to give an indicator for the population inside the orchard. It‟s worth to
mention that control of date palm weevil is so difficult process and needs an
integrated set of methods. The machinery injection and pheromone is unlikely
not applied in Pakistan compared to advanced date palm countries. In order to
successfully implement RPW management the cooperation and interaction of the
farmer is necessary. IPM of RPW is the need of a viable control in conjunction
with the environment protection.
9.3.3. Integrated Pest Management (IPM) of Date Palm
Integrated Pest Management (IPM) is an effective and environmentally sensitive
approach to pest management that relies on a combination of common-sense
practices. IPM programs use current, comprehensive information on the life cycles
of pests and their interaction with the environment. This information, in combination
with available pest control methods, is used to manage pest damage by the most
economical means, and with the least possible hazard to people, property, and the
environment.IPM takes advantage of all appropriate pest management options
including, but not limited to, the judicious use of pesticides [53].
IPM is not a single pest control method but, rather, a series of pest management
evaluations, decisions and controls. In practicing IPM, farmers who are aware of the
potential for pest infestation follow a four-tiered approach. The four steps include:
Page 64 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.3.3.1. Monitoring
The monitoring removes the possibility that pesticides will be used when they
are not really needed or that the wrong kind of pesticide will be used.
Pheromone traps could be the most suitable way for monitoring.
9.3.3.2. Set Action Thresholds
Before taking any pest control action, IPM first sets an action threshold, a point
at which pest populations or environmental conditions indicate that pest control
action must be taken. Sighting a single pest does not always mean control is
needed. The level at which pests will either become an economic threat is
critical to guide future pest control decisions.
9.3.3.3. Prevention
As a first line of RPW control, IPM program work to manage the crop to prevent
RPW from becoming a threat. This may mean using cultural and mechanical
means. These control methods can be very effective and cost-efficient and
present little to no risk to people or the environment.
9.3.3.4. Control
Once monitoring and action thresholds indicate that pest control is required, and
preventive methods are no longer effective or available, IPM program then
evaluate the proper control method both for effectiveness and risk. Effective,
less risky pest controls are chosen first, including highly targeted chemicals,
such as pheromones to disrupt pest mating, or mechanical control. If further
monitoring, identifications and action thresholds indicate that less risky controls
are not working, then additional pest control methods would be employed, such
as targeted spraying of pesticides. Broadcast spraying of non-specific pesticides
is a last resort.
Mass trapping has been used to reduce Red Palm Weevil densities. In this
instance, aggregation pheromones are loaded into bucket traps along with palm
material and granular insecticides. RPW adults are attracted by the pheromones
and the plant material and fly into buckets. Once inside the bucket trap, the
pesticide kills the weevils before they can escape. Biological control is the use of
natural enemies, like predators, parasites, and pathogens to kill a pest. Red Palm
Weevil is attacked by a cultivar of different natural enemies including parasites
and small predators that attack weevil eggs, while bacteria, fungi, and nematodes
can kill weevil larvae. Many of these biological control agents do not provide
adequate control of Red Palm Weevil in the field. Host plant resistance can
reduce the ability of Red Palm Weevil to damage palms because the weevil is
unable to effectively exploit these hosts. The California fan palm, Washingtonia
filifera, which is native to southern California and western Arizona, and the
Page 65 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
European fan palm, Chamaerops humilis, appear to be resistant to Red Palm
Weevil infestations [1].
With these steps, IPM is best described as a continuum. The goal is to move farmers
further along the continuum to using all appropriate IPM techniques.
9.3.4. International Methods to Control RPW
9.3.4.1. Plant Quarantine
The transport of offshoots as cultivation material from infested areas can
contribute to the spread of the pest. Strict quarantine at international and national
levels should be applied.
9.3.4.2. Cultural Control
Field sanitation and cultural practices are one of the important components to
prevent weevil infestation through:
Clean the crown of palms periodically to prevent decaying of organic
debris in leaf axils.
Avoid cuts and injuries.
As palms affected by leaf rot and bud rot diseases are more prone to
weevil infestation, they are to be treated with suitable fungicides; after
that, application of any insecticide to prevent egg laying by weevils is
essential.
9.3.4.3. Mechanical Control
Destroy all discarded palm tissues which may harbor the pest by chipping to
small pieces and burning.
9.3.4.4. Trapping the Weevils
Trapping the weevils and destroying them is another method by which weevil
populations can be brought down.
9.3.4.5. Biological Control
No effective biological agent, which can be employed for the biological control
of the pest, has been found.
9.3.4.6. Chemical Control
Preventive and curative methods (discussed above).
Page 66 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.3.4.7. Training and Education
For any large scale pest management program to succeed, it is imperative that
the farmer cooperate and involve himself at the operational level. This can be
achieved by making him aware of the seriousness of the problem and training
him in various IPM skills.
The trunk of the palm needs to be split open and all stages destroyed. Burning the
head does not kill the stages in the middle of the trunk. Thus, the whole trunk should
be chopped and burned [54].
9.3.5. Severe Infestation of Scale Pest to the Fronds
White scale insect is widely infected green fronds of date trees in Khairpur. The
symptoms are white scales on the leaflets of the fronds. Nymphs and adults suck the
sap of the fronds and spots turns brown then fronds drying. Brown spots are
extending to cover the entire fronds of the date palm tree which delay the
photosynthesis and vegetative growth. Heavy infestation causes leaflets to turn
yellow and contributes to the premature death of the fronds then the production (Fig.
44).
Figure 44: White Scale Pest Infestation on Date Tree Leaflets at Khairpur.
White scale, caused by Parlatoria blanchardii Targ., is widely present in most date
palm growing areas of the world. It is considered a serious pest in Algeria, Kuwait,
Libya, Mauritania, Morocco and Tunisia. Iraq, Oman, Saudi Arabia and Sudan
consider this pest a moderate one, while Egypt, Jordan, UAE and Yemen consider it
a minor pest. Damage by white scale is very serious on young palms between two to
eight years of age, but even under severe attacks, the palm and its offshoots do not
die. Chemical control appears to be conducted occasionally in young plantations.
Page 67 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Mineral oils are used [7]. Distance in between trees works to avoid integration of
fronds and transfer the pest faster within the orchard. Collecting the infested fronds
and burning them reduces the infestation size.
9.3.6. Rodents Damaging Date Palm Orchards in Balochistan
The villagers in Gualishtop near to Nok-Kundi claim that within the last decade a
rodent that has an appearance of a big rat has become a threat to the date palm
plantations in this area (Fig. 45A). The author has made a study at these areas in
2009 and recorded that the rodent moves in tunnels of 0.3-0.6 m in diameter
burrowed by it, extending to more than a hundred meters (Fig. 45B). The rodent
digs these tunnels in sandy soil approximately 0.3 m below the surface, and reaches
the pith of date palm tree. The rodent damages the fronds at the base of the young
date palms (10-15 years), which leads to a fungal infection (Fig. 45C) and
consequential devastate the tree. In mature trees the rodent is said to eat the sweet
and soft bulb of the trunk, again resulting in death of the tree.
The rodent attacks date palm trees has recorded in Nok-Kundi, Mashkel and
Dalbandin causing complete destruction for both adult and small offshoots (Fig.
45D). This exotic pest mostly became principal pest due to some change in the
equilibrium of natural forces particularly because of prolonged drought periods may
reach 4-5 years in this arid region of the province.
Vertebrate Pest Control Institute, Karachi Univ. Campus has made a study covered
the area of Nok-Kundi and Dalbandin. Their salient findings indicated that mole rat
(Nesokia sp.) has a narrow feeding niche, and in non-crop lands of Balochistan is
largely herbivorous in diet. The food habit studies shows that rodent throughout the
season feeds principally upon the date-palm fruits, stem, grasses and roots but datepalm pith was the main component of the diet.
Rodenticides bait and trapping were used to eliminate the rodents. Underground
modified PVC pipe bait station was suitable to place the rodenticides bait. Highest
mortality was obtained by the use of 5g sachet of milk powder as bait base
containing 0.22% Sodium monofluroacetate (1080) which were inserted deep into
the live burrows of rodents. Aluminum phosphide tablets also used to reduce rodent
activity because of the sufficient moisture in the soil increased the release of
Phosphine gas in the burrows. Brodifacoum and Zinc phosphide burrow baiting gave
also encouraging results and reduction in rodent activity [55].
Page 68 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 45: Rodent Attack to Date Palm Trees at Gualishtop, Balochistan.
These attempts to control the rodents were not successful hitherto. Therefore, used
Rodenticides baiting was not safe for grazing ruminants and livestock. Recognizing
the damage caused and the risk of the threat of spreading to Rajai, Wadian and other
areas, further studies are needed to understand the nature of the problem and to
develop control techniques like launch augmentation program for natural predator
Barn Owl. This is necessary in order to rescue the date palm plantation in
Balochistan from this new menace.
In the international scenario, the only control measure was by using poison. It is
composed from a mixture of zinc phosphate at 30 to 50 g with 1 kg of millet flour
and 3 % of cooking oil. The paste is to be placed around the palms at the entry to the
galleries. A chemical product „Finale‟ gave excellent results at the Eersbegin project
(Namibia). It is highly active anticoagulant bait at 0.025 g/kg as an active ingredient.
The death of rodents takes 4 to 12 days. The chemical was used (July and August
1997) in both the Eersbegin and Naute date plantations (Namibia) with a sound
success rate against Mus musculus [7].
Page 69 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
9.4. Processing
9.4.1. Dates Quality Standards
Processing of such dates can be improved through a good treatment for curing away
from boiling process „Chohara‟. Subsequently, grading the fruit according to their
size is very important for marketing. There are nowadays modern machines for
grading by optical methods (Fig. 46).
Figure 46: Machinery Sorting of Dates According to their Sizes in Al-Saad Factory,
UAE.
An index for the different grades should be developed through a research institute for
each cultivar to Grade A, B and C according to size and clearance from defects.
Number of dates in kg will be accounted accordingly. Packaging in different shapes
of containers whether carton, metal or plastic made package (Fig. 47).
These types have market even inside Pakistan due to the growing local consumption
of dates. The turnover of dates in Karachi city reached 40,000 tons during holy
Ramadan in 2010 [56].
Page 70 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 47: Packaging of Dates to Fulfill the Wide Variety of Consumers Demand.
Table 3: Export Quantity, Value, Ton Value and Kg Value of Pakistan Compared to
Number of Dates Exporters in the World (FAO, 2007)
Export (2007)
Quantity
(ton)
Value
(1000$)
1 Ton
Value
($)
1 Kg
Value
($)
Cyprus
6
121
20166.67
20.17
Bahrain
2
27
13500.00
13.50
Occupied
Palestinian
Territory
18
131
7277.78
7.28
United States
of America
3259
18863
5787.97
5.79
China
258
402
1558.14
1.56
Jordan
2806
2924
1042.05
1.04
Egypt
4704
3014
640.73
0.64
Pakistan
104090
38271
367.67
0.37
Iraq
37063
9532
257.18
0.26
Libyan Arab
Jamahiriya
20
4
200.00
0.20
Page 71 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Dates have vast potential of export, but efforts are required to apply post-harvest
management and processing techniques to qualifying the international standards. A
number of countries have formulated and applied date standards at the national level,
which include the US, Canada, Algeria, Tunisia, Oman and Israel, both for locally
produced and imported dates. Therefore, Pakistan has to follow such type of systems
and standards. According to latest statistics of FAO in 2007, Pakistan is the second
exporter after Iran (Fig. 48).
Figure 48: Pakistan Export Figure as Compared to Five Dates Countries (FAO,
2007).
Nevertheless, the value per ton equals $ 367.67 compared to the highest value in the
world Cyprus $ 20166.67 (Table 3) or even famous dates producers such as Iran, Iraq,
Egypt, UAE and USA (Fig. 49). This amount made Pakistan to occupy the position
number 73 of the highest values per ton of dates.
Page 72 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 49: Value of Pakistani Dates Export per Ton Compared to Iran, Iraq, Egypt,
UAE and USA (FAO, 2007).
There are technical regulations issued by international organizations such as (FAOCodex Standard For Dates Codex Stan 143-1985/WTO-SPS agreement); EU
regulations, and European Good Agricultural Practices (Euro-GAP) developed by
chain stores associations in Europe.
According to FAO, this standard applies to commercially prepared-whole dates in
pitted or un-pitted styles packed ready for direct consumption. These styles may also
included the pressed (dates which are compressed into layers using mechanical force),
un-pressed/loose (dates which are free-flowing or packaged without mechanical force
or compression) and clusters (dates with the main bunch stem attached). It does not
apply to other forms such as pieces or mashed dates or dates intended for industrial
purposes.
Dates may be designated as to size names i.e., small, medium and large sizes,
however, it is optional (Table 4).
Table 4: Number of Date Fruit in 500 Grams Weight.
Size
Small
Medium
Large
Un-pitted Dates
More than 100
80-100
Less than 80
Pitted Dates
More than 110
90-110
Less than 90
Quality factors includes general requirements in which dates shall be prepared from
such fruit and under such practices that the finished product shall possess a
characteristic color and flavor for the cultivar and type, be of proper stage of ripeness,
be free of live insects and insect eggs and mites and meet the following additional
requirements (Table 5).
Page 73 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Table 5: Quality Factors of Dates Fruit Moisture Content, Size and Mineral
Impurities.
Moisture content
Cane Sugar Cultivars
Not Processed Deglet Noor
Invert Sugar Cultivars
Maximum
26%
30%
30%
Size
Un-pitted Dates
Pitted Dates
Minimum
4.75 grams
4.0 grams
Mineral Impurities
Not more than 1 gram/kg
Page 74 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Table 6: Definition of Defects for Dates Fruit.
1
Blemishes
Scars, discoloration, sunburn, dark spots, black nose or
similar abnormalities in surface appearance affecting an
aggregate area greater than that of a circle 7 mm in
diameter.
2
Damaged
(Un-pitted dates only) dates affected by mashing and/or
tearing of the flesh exposing the pit or to such an extent
that it significantly detracts from the visual appearance of
the date.
3
Unripe dates
Dates which may be light in weight, light in color, have
shriveled or little flesh or a decidedly rubbery texture.
4
Un-pollinated
dates
Dates not pollinated as evidenced by thin flesh, immature
characteristics and no pit in un-pitted dates.
5
Dirt
Dates having embedded organic or inorganic material
similar to dirt or sand in character and affecting an
aggregate area greater than that of a circle 3 mm in
diameter.
6
Insects
mites
7
Scouring
Breakdown of the sugars into alcohol and acetic acid by
yeasts and bacteria.
8
Mold
Presence of mould filaments visible to the naked eye.
9
Decay
Dates that are in a state of decomposition and very
objectionable in appearance.
and Dates damaged by insects or mites or contaminated by
damage and contamination the presence of dead insects or
mites, fragments of insects or mites or their excreta.
Unfortunately, the processed dates in the big factories of Pakistan are still in a need to
apply the mentioned quality standard and to minimize the defects (Fig. 50).
Page 75 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 50: Defects of Dirt and Damaged Dates Processed in Khairpur.
Allowance for Defects:
The maximum allowances for the defects defined above (Table 6) shall be:
A total of 7% by count of dates with defect (1)
A total of 6% by count of dates with defects (2), (3) and (4)
A total of 6% by count of dates with defects (5) and (6)
A total of 1% by count of dates with defects (7), (8) and (9)
Utilization of instructions required by shipping organizations, forwarders and
insurance companies may be applied such as Transport Information Services (TIS).
9.4.2. Growth of Yeast and Molds in Stored Dates
Inappropriate post-harvest treatments and poor storage conditions of dates made a
problem for processors in Pakistan. „Carba‟ cultivar is growing in Balochistan and
widely used in processing plants. Such dates have a tendency to grow mold/mould4
during storage and sometimes it goes up to 250×103 cfu (colony forming units per
gram or square inch) per gram when tested in the laboratory. The preferable level of
mold is 102 cfu g-1 and max 103 cfu g-1. However, it should not increase in any case
by 104 cfu g-1. The problem can also come up with the temperature fluctuations
during the storage period or even starts before the time of receive in the factory.
Good Post-harvest practices are necessary to prevent or reduce the infection after
harvest in open field.
4
Mostly Canadian English uses „ou‟ instead of „o‟ in word like mould, colour, flavour, etc. In addition, in
USA is mold and UK uses mold.
Page 76 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Moulds are microscopic fungi that live on plant or animal matter. Most are
filamentous (threadlike) organisms and the production of spores is characteristic of
fungi in general. These spores can be transported by air, water, or insects [57].
Ozone is a strong oxidant and potent disinfecting agent. There are numerous
application areas of ozone in food industry such as sanitation of food plant
equipments, surface hygiene and reuse of waste water. The promising results
indicated the efficacy of ozone to reduce the microbial populations in date fruits.
Escherichia coli and S. aureus were not found on cultured plates inoculated with the
treated samples after treatment with 5 ppm in 60 min [58].
On June 26, 2001, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) released an official
determination on the permissible use of ozone as an antimicrobial agent for the
treatment, storage and processing of foods in gas and aqueous phases in direct
contact with foods, including raw and minimally processed fruits and vegetables
[59]. The main purposes of ozone application at the postharvest stage are
inactivation of bacteria and prevention of fungal decay.
9.4.3. Using Methyl Bromide and its Alternatives to Reduce Pest
Infestation of Stored Dates
Since infestation begins in the field, methyl bromide (MeBr) is used to rapidly
fumigate harvested dates on arrival at processing plants on a daily basis. Most
fumigation occurs over several weeks, during the peak production season, as the
bulk of the harvest moves from the field into storage and shipping channels. Upon
arrival from the field, each load is fumigated with methyl bromide in preparation for
processing and shipment to national and international markets. Any one load of dates
is fumigated with methyl bromide only once.
Sulfuryl fluoride indicates that this fumigant is a likely methyl bromide alternative
for most commodities. In Dates, MeBr is used primarily to control the carob moth
(Ectomyelois ceratoniae, Zeller) and other insects infesting dates. Sulfuryl fluoride is
currently labeled for use on dried dates. The California Date Commission reports
that it is currently testing the efficacy of Sulfuryl Fluoride on dates, with preliminary
results showing less than adequate egg kill, even when the amount used is twice that
needed for comparable methyl bromide fumigation.
Page 77 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 51: Carob Moth Pest and its Pupae Infect the Flower and Fruit of Date Palm
Tree.
Carob moth was found in date palm orchards (Fig. 51). The larva of the Carob moth
attacks dates in plantations, packing houses and stores. Eggs are laid on the dates and
hatching begins four days later. The larval period is about three weeks in warm
months and eight weeks in colder months. The pupae period is about five days.
Taking into account the moth's life cycle, it is recommended to protect the fruit
bunches, to clean the plantation from wind-fallen fruits and to fumigate harvested
and stored dates. The use of pheromone traps will not only help to determine the
emergence of moths but also to estimate the population level. The rate of infestation
could be lowered by spraying the infested fruits with Bacillus thuringiensis [7].
9.5. Insufficient Research and Development Activities
There is a need of extensive research for better quality and yield of dates so that
quality could match with international requirements of sanitary and phyto-sanitary
(SPS) measures; selection of disease-free plants; screening out of bad cultivars pre
and post-harvest management, processing and behavioral trainings of the staff for
their role in the system, processing, packing, marketing and export of dates and date
products [12].
The shortage in national qualified and trained staff & labors delays the date‟s
industry in Pakistan to come up with similar industries in date palm countries.
Training programs and documentary materials mostly will be viable way to improve
the awareness of Pakistani farmers toward such important methods.
Cooperation between Pakistan and the Scientific Institutions dealing with date palm
studies is decisive to face the economical competition with other developed date
palm countries in the world. Large steps to modernize dates production, storage and
Page 78 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
processes need to be taken to make date palm cultivation is more beneficial to the
growers, processors, and exporters in Pakistan.
10.Modern Techniques in Other Countries
10.1.
Fruit Bunch Covering in USA
Deglet Noor is the major date cultivar grown and packed in the United States. The
crop is increasingly attacked by insects while ripening on the palm, especially carob
moth. These pests are presently a serious threat to the livelihood of both conventional
and organic date farmers. Infestation rates already average 10% to 20%. Malathion,
the only insecticide registered for use on dates, is ineffective because the insects have
developed resistance. A physical barrier in the form of cloth bag to exclude insects
was used. This date-bunch cover also protects the on-tree crop from birds, heavy rain,
high winds, and sunburn. The cover is composed of a flexible fabric, preferably
white, woven, open-mesh polyester, which allows free circulation of air throughout
the fruit cluster. Layering the fabric on top of the bunch provides rain protection.
Accordingly, many advantages over prior art are realized in terms of effect upon the
fruit and economy of use. The manner and time of installation are crucial. The cover
is durable, light-weight and reusable [60].
Another type of Punched Paper Bags was used to hasten the ripening of date fruit. It
is recommended to cover the bunches directly after fertilizing with punched paper
bags and to be kept for 45 days in order to obtain earlier ripening as well to
improving their physical and chemical specifications [61].
Medjool, Barhee and Deglet Noor date trees were wrapped in July and August with
large brown paper bags around each date bunch in order to keep off the rain
(occasionally there is some rain in the desert) and also to deter birds, sunshine and
insects from ruining the soft mature dates (Fig. 52). Also, wrap a nylon mesh bag
around some date cultivars; the nylon bags completely block out insects, dust, rain,
and birds.
Figure 52: Barhee Dates that Will Turn Yellow Sometime in August at California,
USA. The Brown Paper Bag Keeps the Rain off the Fruit (Brown Date Garden).
Page 79 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Deglet Noor date trees are about 55' to 60' tall. Each field worker can "bag" 14 trees
per day; this requires climbing a 48' ladder from the ground to get to the bottom of the
20' ladder that is tied to the top of each 55'-60' Deglet Noor date tree [62].
10.2.
Drip Irrigation in Egypt
The total area of date palm cultivation in Pakistan is about 93.3 thousand hectares
with 680 thousand Mt and thus Pakistan stands at fourth position in the world in
terms of date‟s production. If this figure is compared to the ever biggest country in
the world for date‟s production Egypt, a gap between the production and cultivated
area will appear in terms of production and quality. The total production of Egypt is
about 1300 thousand Mt produced only from 87 thousand hectares.
As date palm is a salt and drought tolerant plant, Egypt has established by private
and governmental sector a large number of date palm plantings. The water source of
such plantings is the ground water. Drip irrigations system is the appropriate choice
for this type of cultivation (Fig. 53).
Page 80 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
Figure 53: Date Palm Farm of Barhee Cultivar under Drip Irrigation System through
Ground Water in Desert in Egypt.
Tissue culture derived palms of valuable cultivars like Barhee, Nabout Sief, Medjool,
etc. provided a large number of the offshoots that uniform in growth to establish new
farms (Fig. 53).
Zaghloul is one of the large size fruit cultivar in Egypt (Fig. 54). It is widely
cultivated at the Middle and North of Egypt. Fruit is red with crispy and sweet test.
Figure 54: Date Palm Superb Fruit and Tree of „Zaghloul‟ Date Palm Cultivar (Soft
Cultivar)
9.1. Dates Processing in UAE
Dates are the UAE's major crop and this country is the seventh largest producer in
the world after Egypt, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Pakistan, and Algeria. The highest
population of date palms is believed to be concentrated in various oases of Al Ain
Page 81 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
region. The total number of date palm trees has grown to nearly 41 million,
stretching over an area of 1.85 million hectares.
Equipments to process fruit dates before packaging by FUMIGATING to eradicate
insects and pest from the fruits, WASHING by pressurized spray, DRYING by hot
air, SORTING manually picking spoiled fruits in conveyor, PASTE PRODUCTION
of dates fruits by STEAMING, SEED EXTRACTION AND MASHING BY
STRONG CENTRIFUGE to produce paste mass of date.
As an example, Al-Saad factory equipped with machinery. The factory utilizes the
best selected, fumigated, washed and graded varieties of the fruit from the farms
located in different parts of the UAE. A team of experienced professionals and
engineers supervise the functioning of the factory, including date processing under
strict quality control standards and hygienic measures.
The factory has been producing a wide range of products, many of which are made
as per the customer's requirements. Dates are packed in cardboard boxes, foam
plates, plastic boxes, and tissue bags to accommodate different quantities from 250
grams to 25 Kgs. Other products include filled coated date sweets, vacuum dates,
pressed dates, date paste, date syrup, date jam, mudabbas, ground pits, sparkling
dates drink, fancy dates for gift packages, and dry date pulp.
The factory is marketing products that include vinegar, chocolate wafers, medical
alcohol, liquid sugar, sparkling drink, pitted coffee, and animal feed. These products
are available in the UAE market and they are very well received by the customers.
Some studies were being conducted to change certain products in accordance with
the public demand for finding ways to enhance the production and sales of the
factory.
Eight different popular types of dates are used in the factory to make different
products. These types include „Khalas‟, „Lulu‟, „Barhee‟, „Rezaiz‟, „Buma'an‟,
„Jabri‟, „Fardh‟, and „Khuneiz‟.
The quality control and hygiene are the core of the factory management philosophy,
therefore the quality of product and process are frequently checked at all stages of
processing by highly qualified quality control personnel, production is fully outstand
also by controlling the quality and the standards of dates as the major input as well
as the ingredients used, in addition to packaging materials, health and physical
fitness of the personnel and systemized technology to maintain, the uniformity and
sustainability of the end products to achieve the full satisfaction of the consumer,
traders and industrial companies.
In order to produce and maintain high quality products, factory has HACCP System
certificate by DET NORSKE CERATAS (DNV) and 1S0 9001 (2002) by Lloyd‟s
Register Quality Assurance.
Page 82 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
11.Bibliography
1. Center for Invasive Species Research. 2010.
http://cisr.ucr.edu/red_palm_weevil.html.
2. Hasnaoui, A., M.A. Elhoumaizi, A. Asehraou, M. Sindic, C. Deroanne and A.
Hakkou. 2010. Chemical composition and microbial quality of dates grown in
figuig oasis of morocco. International journal of agriculture & biology. 09–
407/AWB/2010/12–2–311–314. http://www.fspublishers.org
3. Year Book of Pakistan. 2008. Statistics Division, Government of Pakistan,
Agricultural Department.
4. Mahar, A.Q. 2007. Post-harvest studies of different cultivars of Date Palm
(Phoenix dactylifera L.) fruits, their protection, identification, processing and
preservation at district Khairpur, Sindh, Pakistan. Ph.D Thesis, Date Palm
Research Institute, Shah Abdul Latif University, Khairpur, Sindh, Pakistan.
5. Markhand, G.S., A.A. Abul-Soad. 2010. Fruit characterization of Pakistani dates.
Pak. J. Bot., 42(6): 3715-3722.
6. Barreveld, W. H. 1993. Date Palm Products. FAO Agricultural Services Bulletin
No. 101.
7. Zaid, A. and de Wet, P.F. 2002. Pollination and bunch management. Chapter 8 In:
A. Zaid (ed.), Date Palm Cultivation. FAO Plant Production and Protection. Vol.
156.
8. Abul-Soad, A.A., A.Q. Mahar, G.S. Markhand and S.M. Mahdi. 2011. Effect of
Bituminized paper on fruit bunches of date palm. Pakistan Journal of Botany. In
press.
9. Abul-Soad, A.A., G.S. Markhand and S. Memon. 2010. DuPont Tyvek® Bags
Impact on Dates. The Final Report. DuPont Pakistan Operations (Pvt.) Ltd., 2G-4,
Johar Town, Canal Bank Road, Lahor-54790, Pakistan.
10. Al-Yahyai, R. and S. Al-Khanjari. 2008. Biodiversity of Date palm in the
Sultanate of Oman. African Journal of Agricultural Research. Vol. 3 (6): 389-395.
11. Abul-Soad, A.A. and S.M. Mahdi .2010. Commercial production of tissue culture
date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.) by inflorescence technique. Journal of Genetic
Engineering and Biotechnology. In press.
12. Abul-Soad, A.A. 2007. Study of processing development problems of dates in
Egypt. Fourth Symposium on Date Palm in Saudi Arabia, King Faisal University,
Al-Hassa. 5-8 May. Abstracts Book, p. 406.
13. Abd-Allah, B.M., A.Y. Mohamed, A.A. Abul-Soad, L.A. El-Kholy .2008.
Behavior study of some dry-date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.) cultivars derived
from tissue culture under Aswan conditions. Procde. book of 3rd international
conference on date palm. Faculty of Agriculture and Environmental Science, Suez
Canal University, North Sinai, Egypt, 25-27 April. pp. 231-240.
14. Abul-Soad, A.A., G.S. Markhand and N. Akhtar. 2010. Effect of Different Soil
Types on Survival of Transplanted Banana (Grand Naine cv.) into Greenhouse.
28th International Horticulture Congress, Lisbon, Portugal. Abstracts Book Page
754.
Page 83 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
15. Abul-Soad, A.A., I.A. Ibrahim, N.R. El-Sherbeny and S.I. Baker. 1999. In vitro
and ex vitro optimization for rooting and acclimatization of date palm. The 1st
International Conference in Egypt on Plant Tissue Culture and Its Application,
12-14 September, Egypt. Pp. 227-241.
16. Nixon, R.W. 1950. Imported cultivars of dates in the United States. Washington
DC: USDA Cir. No. 834, 144 pages.
17. M. L. Robinson, Brian Brown, C. Frank Williams. 2002. The Date Palm in
Southern Nevada. University of Nevada, Cooperative Extension.
18. Abul-Soad, A. A., Mounir A., Amar, M., Rashid, M. and Fahim, S. 2008. Date
Palm: Field operations and pests and diseases. www.agrarianculture.net, ISBN:
977-302-198-X
19. AL-Rawi, A.A.H. 1996. Fertilization of date palm tree (Phoenix dactylifera) in
Iraq. IPA Agric. Res. Center P. O. Box 39094 Baghdad, Iraq.
20. Abdul Salam, M and S Al Mazrooei. 2003. Crop water and irrigation water
requirements of date palm (Phoenix dactylifera) in the loamy sands of Kuwait.
ISHS Acta Horticulturae 736: III International Date Palm Conference
21. Abdulla, K.M., M.A. Meligi and S.Y. Risk. 1982. Influence of crop load and
frond/bunch ratio on yield and fruit properties of Hayany dates. Proc. 1st. Symp.
On date palm in Saudi Arabia, pp: 222-232.
22. Dowson, V.H.W. 1982. Date production and protection with special reference to
North Africa and the Near East. FAO Technical Bulletin No. 35. pp 294.
23. Ahmed, H.S. and M.A. Jahjab. 1985. The pollination of date palm with pollen
grains suspension. Date Palm J.4 (1): 33-40.
24. Hussain, F.A., S.M. Bader, K.M. Segab and E.N. Samarmed. 1984. Effect of
spraying the inflorescences of date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.) with pollen
grains suspended in Boron, GA3, and Glycerin solutions on fruit set and yield.
Date Palm J. 3(1): 5-21.
25. Nixon, R.W. 1966. Growing dates in the United States. Agric. Inf. Bull., USDA
no 207, pp 56.
26. Brown, R.M. and E.G.V. Perkins. 1972. Experiments with aircraft methods for
pollinating dates. The Punjab Fruit J. 119: 116 - 127.
27. Galeb, H.H., E.A. Mawlood, M.J. Abbass and S. Abdelsalam. 1987. Effect of
different pollinators on fruit set and yield of Sayer and Hallawy date palm
cultivars under Basrah conditions. Date Palm J. 5(2): 155 - 173.
28. Nixon, R.W. and J.B. Carpenter. 1978. Growing Dates in the United States. U.S.
Dept. of Agriculture, Agric. Information Bulletin No. 207: USDA. Technical
Document 63 pp.
29. Perkins, R.M. and P.F. Burkner. 1973. Mechanical pollination of date palms. Date
Growers' Inst. Report 50: 4-8.
30. Gerard, B. 1932. The effect of heat on the germination of date pollen. Date
Growers' Inst. Report 9:15.
31. Dowson, V.H.W. 1921. Dates and date cultivations of Iraq. Part I - The
cultivation of the date palm on the Schatt-al-Arab. Ag. Directorate of
Mesopotamia, Memoir III, Heffer, Cambridge.
Page 84 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
32. Brown, T.W. and W. Bahgat. 1938. Date palm in Egypt. Min. Agri, Hort. Sec.
Booklet No 24, 117 pp.
33. Nasr, T.A., M.A. Shaheen, & M.A. Bacha. 1986. Evaluation of seedling male
palms used in pollination of the Central Region, Saudi Arabia. Date Palm J. 4(2):
163 - 173.
34. Albert, D.W. 1930. Viability of pollen and receptivity of pistillate flowers. Date
Growers' Inst. Report 7: 5-7.
35. Brown, G.K., R.M. Perkins and E.G. Vis. 1969. Temperature and heat unit
occurrences during date pollination in the Coachella Valley of California. Date
Growers' Inst. Report 46: 21 - 24.
36. Klein, P. and A. Zaid. 2002. Land preparation, planting operation and fertilization
requirements. Chapter 6 In: A. Zaid (ed.), Date Palm Cultivation. FAO Plant
Production and Protection. Vol. 156.
37. Reuveni, O., S. Abu and S. Golobvitz. 1986. Date palm Pollen germination and
tube elongation on pistillate flowers cultured at different temperatures. Acta
horticulturea 175: 91 - 95.
38. Swingle, W.T. 1928. Metaxenia in the date palm. J. Heredity. 19: 257 - 268.
39. Hadi, L.A., M.F. Abbas, K.I. Abbas and A.A. Abul-Soad. 2010. Effect of Pollen
Parent on Protein Pattern during Growth and Ripening of Date Palm Fruit Cv.
Hellawi. Egyptian Journal of Horticulture, No: 37-2.
40. Thomas, D.L. 1974. Possible link between declining palm species and lethal
yellowing of coconut palms. Proc. Fla. State Hort.Soc. 87:502-504.
41. Al Awadhi, H.A., A. Hanif, P. Suleman and M.S. Montasser. 2002. Molecular
and microscopical detection of Phytoplasma associated with yellowing disease of
date palm Phoenix dactylifera L. in Kuwait. Kuwait J. Sci. Engin. 29:87-109.
42. Ammar, M.I., M.A. Amer and M.F. Rashed. 2005. Detection of Phytoplasma
associated with yellow streak disease of date palms (Phoenix dactylifera L.) in
Egypt. Egyptian J. Virology 2:74-86.
43. Killian, C. and R. Maire. 1930. Le bayoud maladie du dattier. Bull.Soc. Hist. Na.
Afr.No. 21:89-101
44. Djerbi, M. 1982. Bayoud disease in North Africa, history, distribution, diagnosis
and control. Date Palm Journal. 1:153-197
45. Mitlo, W.A., G.S. Markhand, A.A. Abul-Soad, M.A. Pathan and A.M. Lodhi.
2011. Prevalence of Sudden Decline of Date Palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.) in
Sindh, Pakistan. Under publication.
46. Sarhan, A.R.T. 2001. A study on the fungi causing decline of date palm trees in
middle of Iraq 2nd Int. Conf. Date Palm, 25-27 March, Al Ain, UAE pp 424-430.
47. Rashed, M.F. and Abdel Hafeez, N.E. 2001. Decline of date palm trees in Egypt.
2nd International Conference on Date Palm, 25-27 March Al Ain, UAE, P. 401407.
48. Al Yaseri, I.I., A.Z. Ismail and A.A. Mohammed. 2006. A preliminary study on
spread of date palm pests in Iraq. 9th Arab Cong. Plant Prot. 19-23 November,
Damascus, Syria (Abstract).
Page 85 of 86
Date Palm in Pakistan, current status and prospective
Abul-Soad A. A., 2010
49. Mansoori, B. and M.H. Kord. 2006. Yellow death: A disease of date palm in Iran
caused by Fusarium solani. J. Phytopathology. 154:125-127
50. Abdalla, M.Y., A. Al Rokiba, A. Moretti and G. Mule. 2000. Pathogenicity of
toxigenic Fusarium proliferatum from date palm in Saudi Arabia. Plant Disease
84:321-324.
51. Maitlo, W.A., A.A. Abul-Soad, G.S. Markhand, S.A. Memon and R.A. Jiskani.
2011. Survey of red palm weevil (Rhynchophorus ferrugineus Oliver) infestation
on different cultivars of date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.) in Khairpur, Pakistan.
Under publication.
52. http://blog.redweevil.com/management-of-red-palm-weevil/10.
53. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
http://www.epa.gov/pesticides/factsheets/ipm.htm
54. http://www.redpalmweevil.com
55. Vertebrate Pest Control Institute, Karachi Univ. Campus, Pakistan.
56. Thepost.com.pk, on 22\9\2008.
57. Food World Program.
http://foodquality.wfp.org/Default.aspx?PageContentMode=1&tabid=316
58. Mohammad, B., H. Najafi, M.H. Khodaparast. 2009. Efficacy of ozone to reduce
microbial populations in date fruits. Food Control 20 (2009) 27–30.
www.elsevier.com/locate/foodcont.
59. Guzel-Seydim, Z.B., A.K. Greene and A.C. Seydim. 2004. Use of 197 ozone in the
food industry. Lebensm.-Wiss. U. – Technol., 37, 198 453–460.
60. WWW.oasisdategardens.com
61. Alshariqi, A.K. 2010. Study covering the Bunches with Punched Paper Bags on
the Fertilization and the Specifications of Dates in the Early and late Ripening
Stages. Agricultural Research Station, Al Hemrania, Northern Agricultural Region,
UAE.
62. Brown Gardens. 2010. California, USA.
Page 86 of 86