ABSTRACTS
ORAL PRESENTATION 1
Vascular Anatomy of the Presacral Space in Unembalmed
Female Cadavers
C. K. Wieslander, D. D. Rahn, S. I. Marinis, C. Y. Wai, J. I. Schaffer,
and M. M. Corton OBGYN, University of Texas Southwestern
Medical Center at Dallas, Dallas, TX
Objectives: To characterize the vascular anatomy of the female
presacral space and to correlate these findings to the abdominal
sacrocolpopexy.
Materials and Methods: The vascular boundaries and contents
of the presacral space were dissected in 32 unembalmed female
cadavers. Distances from the midline of the sacral promontory (MSP)
to the closest cephalad and lateral vessels, aortic bifurcation, middle
sacral artery and vein, and presacral venous anastomosis were
recorded. All middle sacral and venous anastomotic vessels greater or
equal to one millimeter were included.
Results: Thirty Caucasian and two African American cadaver specimens
with a mean BMI of 20.7 kg/m2 (11.8 –33.3 kg/m2) were dissected. In
97% of cadavers, the left common iliac vein was the closest cephalad
vessel, with a mean distance of 27.5 mm (9.0 –51.5 mm) from the
MSP. The closest vessel lateral to the MSP was also the left common
iliac vein (41%), followed by the right internal iliac artery (24%). The
average distance from the MSP to the closest lateral major vessel was
24.3 mm (13.0 –34.5 mm). The average distance from the MSP to the
aortic bifurcation was 55.5 mm (26.0 – 89.5 mm). The average distance
from the MSP to the caudal venous anastomosis was 30.3 mm
(4.0 – 86.0 mm). A middle sacral artery was present in 100% of
cadavers. The average width of this vessel was 1.7 mm (1.0 –3.0 mm).
In the majority of cadavers (60%), the middle sacral artery was found
to the left of the MSP. It was noted to the right of the MSP in 37% of
specimens, and crossing the midline in 3% of specimens. The average
distance of the middle sacral artery from the MSP was 5.0 mm
(0 –15.0 mm). A middle sacral vein was not identified in 10% of
cadavers; two vessels were noted in 10% of specimens. The mean
width of the middle sacral vein was 1.7 mm (0.8 –3.8 mm). This vessel
was more frequently noted to the right (45%) than to the left (38%) of
the MSP. It crossed the midline in 7% of cadavers. The average distance
of the middle sacral vein from the MSP was 6.7 mm (0 –16.5 mm).
Conclusion: Anatomic location of the vascular boundaries and
contents of the presacral space in reference to the MSP is highly
variable. The left common iliac vein was the closest major vessel
identified cephalad to the MSP. It is possible that vasodilation of veins
from increased volume status and body temperature in the living
patient may further reduce the distance of this vessel from the sacral
promontory. In addition, identification of veins by palpation is more
difficult than that of the arteries and hemorrhage from venous
bleeding is more cumbersome to control. Understanding the proximity of the left common iliac vein to the MSP, an area exposed
during an abdominal sacrocolpopexy, is essential to avoid injury to
this vessel. Middle sacral vessels are variably found on either side of
the MSP and vascular anastomosis between the middle and lateral
sacral veins are frequently found within 3 cm caudal to the upper
border of the sacral promontory. Therefore, careful dissection of the
presacral space and good exposure of the anterior longitudinal
ligament of the sacrum should minimize potentially life threatening
vascular complications.
Key Words: sacrocolpopexy, anatomy, presacral space, vascular injury
Disclosure - Grant/Research Support, Speaker Bureau: Joseph I. Schaffer,
Eli Lilly, Yamanouchi/GlaxoSmith/Klein; none: Cecilia K. Wieslander,
none, David D. Rahn, none, Spyridon I. Marinis, none, Marlene M.
Corton, none, Clifford Y. Wai, none.
ORAL PRESENTATION 2
A Randomized Trial Comparing Methods of Vaginal Cuff Closure
at Vaginal Hysterectomy and the Effect on Vaginal Length
B. J. Vassallo1, C. Culpepper2, J. L. Segal3, M. D. Moen1, and M. B.
Noone1 1Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Illinois at Chicago/
Illinois Urogynecology, Park Ridge, IL; 2Obstetrics and Gynecology,
Southview Hospital, Dayton, OH; 3Obstetrics and Gynecology, St.
Barnabas Medical Center, Livingston, NJ
Objectives: To compare the effect of horizontal versus vertical
closure of the vaginal cuff during vaginal hysterectomy on vaginal
length.
Materials and Methods: Forty-three women were randomized to
horizontal (n ⫽ 23) or vertical (n ⫽ 20) vaginal cuff closure during
vaginal hysterectomy at a community hospital. The primary outcome
of vaginal length before and after surgery was compared by the
Student t test and the Paired t test.
Results: Pre-operatively, mean vaginal lengths in the horizontal and
vertical groups were statistically similar (7.76 ⫾ 1.23 cm vs 8.28 ⫾ 1.39
cm, respectively; p ⫽ 0.21). Post-operatively, the groups statistically
differed (6.63 ⫾ 1.02 cm vs 7.93 ⫾ 1.18 cm, p ⬍ 0.001). The mean
change in vaginal length was ⫺1.13 ⫾ 1.15 cm and ⫺0.35 ⫾ 0.91 cm,
respectively, (p ⫽ 0.01). Within group comparisons revealed a statistical
difference between pre vs post mean vaginal length in the horizontal
group (7.76 ⫾ 1.23 cm vs 6.63 ⫾ 1.02 cm; p ⬍ 0.001) and no difference
within the vertical group (8.28 ⫾ 1.39 cm vs 7.93 ⫾ 1.18 cm; p ⫽ 0.11).
Conclusion: Closing the vaginal cuff vertically is superior to horizontal
closure for the purpose of preserving vaginal length.
Key Words: vaginal surgery, vaginal hysterectomy, vaginal length
Disclosure - Consultant: B. Vassallo, Gynecare, Inc., M. Moen, Gynecare, Inc.
ORAL PRESENTATION 3
Sensory Nerve Injury After Uterosacral Ligament Suspension
M. Flynn1, C. Amundsen2, and A. Weidner2 1Obstetrics and gynecology,
University of Rochester, Rochester, NY; 2Obstetrics and Gynecology, Duke
University Medical center, Durham, NC
Objectives: Uterosacral ligament suspension is a technique commonly
performed to suspend the prolapsed vaginal apex. This review describes
our experience with the clinical presentation and management of lower
extremity sensory nerve symptoms in several subjects after uterosacral
ligament suspension.
Materials and Methods: Hospital and office medical records from
our two institutions were reviewed from Jan 2002–August 2005 and
all subjects who underwent uterosacral ligament suspension through a
vaginal approach were identified. Records were reviewed and subjects
with symptoms of buttock and posterior thigh pain during the 6 week
postoperative period were identified. Detailed clinical information was
abstracted from the charts of these subjects. Preoperative, intraoperative and postoperative findings were reviewed.
Results: Of 169 uterosacral ligament suspensions, we identified 7
subjects with lower extremity pain. Age ranged from 42 to 70 years. Two
subjects had a preoperative history of back pain and one of these also
had a history of sciatic pain requiring steroid injections. Concurrent
procedures included 6 vaginal hysterectomies, 5 anterior repairs, 4
posterior repairs, 2 slings and 1 bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy. All
procedures were performed with subjects in high lithotomy position
using padded Allen stirrups. Sutures were placed through the both
uterosacral ligaments at the level of the ischial spine. Within 24 hours of
the surgical procedure, all subjects experienced similar, substantial sharp
buttock pain and numbness that radiated down the center of the
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
65
posterior thigh to the popliteal fossa. Five subjects had pain only in the
right thigh, one subject only in the left thigh and one subject in both. Six
of seven subjects experienced exacerbation of the pain with walking,
standing, or sitting. Neurologic exam documented in six of seven
subjects showed no motor deficits and confirmed decreased sensation
over the involved dermatome. Pelvic exams were nonspecific in 4
subjects; however, in the other 3 subjects the pain was exacerbated
by pulling on the ipsilateral uterosacral suture. In these subjects, the
ipsilateral uterosacral ligament suture was removed within 2 days of
surgery. These subjects had immediate subjective reduction in their
pain and complete resolution of pain by 6 weeks, although the
numbness persisted beyond 6 weeks. The remaining 4 subjects were
treated with gabapentin and narcotics. Three had resolution of their
pain by 12–14 weeks postoperatively and the last subject’s pain
resolved gradually by 6 months.
Conclusion: Women undergoing uterosacral ligament suspension are
at risk of developing postoperative pain and numbness in a sciatic
distribution. These symptoms appear to be related to placement of
uterosacral ligament sutures and may be relieved either by prompt
removal of the ipsilateral uterosacral ligament suture or with prolonged medical therapy.
6.6 and was significantly correlated with depression as measured by
the PHQ (r ⫽ ⫺0.52, p ⫽ 0.0002). The PISQ-12 and FISI scores did not
correlate and PISQ-12 scores were similar among the three continence
groups. None of the individual PISQ-12 items including pain with
intercourse or fear of incontinence during intercourse (either urine or
stool) were different among the continence groups. Of women who
underwent an “overlapping” sphincteroplasty 24% reported that they
“always” or “usually” felt pain during intercourse compared to 4% of
those having an “end-to-end” sphincteroplasty (p ⫽ 0.04).
Conclusion: Sexual function as measured by PISQ-12 is not associated
with type or severity of anal incontinence. Dyspareunia was more
common after an “overlapping” than an “end-to-end” sphincteroplasty.
Anal continence rates five years after anal sphincteroplasty are disappointing but similar to previously reported series. 75% of patients have
incontinence of liquid or solid stool and these symptoms have a
significant impact on physical function and quality of life.
Key Words: sexual function, anal sphincteroplasty, quality of life,
anal incontinence
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
Key Words: vaginal prolapse, postoperative pain, nerve injury
Disclosure - research grant: Cindy Amundsen, Life-Tech, Inc, Cindy
Amundsen, American Medical Systems, Cindy Amundsen, NDI Medical,
Cindy Amundsen, Pfizer; consultant: Cindy Amundsen, Allergan.
ORAL PRESENTATION 4
Sexual Function, Quality of Life, and Severity of Anal Incontinence
Following Anal Sphincteroplasty
E. R. Trowbridge, D. M. Morgan, J. O. Delancey, and D. E. Fenner
Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI
Objectives: To determine the severity of anal incontinence and its
impact on quality of life and sexual function in women following anal
sphincteroplasty.
Materials and Methods: 84 women who underwent anal sphincteroplasty during the years 1993–2004 were mailed validated survey
instruments to evaluate health-related quality of life. Questionnaires
included the Fecal Incontinence Severity Index (FISI), the Colorectal
Anal Impact Questionnaire (CRAIQ), Patient Health Questionnaire
(PHQ) to screen for depression with higher scores in each scale
reflecting worse disease or impact severity. Also included were the
Pelvic Organ Prolapse/Urinary Incontinence Sexual Questionaire-12
(PISQ-12) and the Medical Outcomes Study Short Form (SF-12) with
higher scores reflecting better function. Demographic and perioperative data were obtained from patient charts. Statistical analysis
was performed with chi-square, paired t-tests, ANOVA or Pearson’s
correlations.
Results: 59 patients responded to the survey (response rate ⫽ 70%).
Mean age was 48.1 ⫾ 11.5 years and mean length of follow-up was
5.6 ⫾ 3.0 years. Mean FISI score (0 –57) was 23 ⫾ 15.7, with 6 (11%)
women being totally continent (group 1), 8 (15%) being incontinent
of flatus only (group 2), and 45 (75%) being incontinent of liquid,
solid stool or both (group 3). Analysis of medical co-morbidities
showed that women with irritable bowel syndrome had a higher mean
FISI score compared to women without irritable bowel syndrome (28.2 ⫾ 15.3 vs. 19.3 ⫾ 14.7, p ⫽ 0.04). FISI score correlated
with CRAIQ score (r ⫽ 0.66, p ⬍ 0.0001) and the physical scale of
the SF-12 (r ⫽ ⫺0.39, p ⫽ 0.005). The FISI score did not correlate
with age, length of follow-up, age at the time of surgery, or procedure
type (“end-to-end” vs. “overlapping”). 46 women were sexually active
(78%). Sexually active women were younger than those who were not
sexually active (45.9 ⫾ 10.6 vs. 56.5 ⫾ 11.5 years; p ⫽ 0.002), but
they were not different with respect to BMI, FISI score, or procedure
type (“end-to-end” vs. “overlapping”). Mean PISQ-12 score was 34.1 ⫾
66
ORAL PRESENTATION 5
The Decision to Perform Lymphadenectomy in Advanced Stage
Ovarian Cancer: Room for Improvement
W. Cliby, G. D. Aletti, and K. Podratz Obstetrics and Gynecology,
Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN
Objectives: There is limited objective data supporting or refuting the
value of lymphadenectomy in patients with advanced stage ovarian
cancer. As a result, no clear guidelines exist for the intra-operative
management of lymph nodes. This lack of standardization can result in
wide differences in surgical practice without sound reason for these
differences. To better understand the factors that are important in the
decision to perform lymph node assessment (LNA) in ovarian cancer
we undertook this study.
Materials and Methods: All consecutive patients with Stage IIIC or
IV epithelial ovarian cancer were included during the 5 year period
1994 –1998. Patients who were upstaged to IIIC solely by virtue of
lymphatic involvement were excluded as LNA is clearly recommended
in the staging of presumably early ovarian cancer. Records were
reviewed for specific procedures performed, pathology and overall
survival (OS). Simple statistics, univariate and multivariable analysis
was performed.
Results: 215 patients met inclusion criteria and had sufficient
information available from the operative notes to determine the type
of LNA performed. Only 89/215 (41.4%) had LNA performed. The
subtypes of LNA assessment performed were: 58/89 (65%) underwent
complete pelvic (Pe) and para-aortic (Pa) lymphadenectomy (LND)
and the remaining 31 (35%) underwent a more limited lymph node
sampling (LNS). To first determine the importance of LNA in
outcomes, we considered overall survival for the subgroup of patients
undergoing LNA. In this group, the performance of radical surgery,
LND (vs. LNS) and low RD were all important in univariate analysis.
However, only residual disease (RD) was an independent predictor of
overall survival. We then determined which factors correlated with
the decision to perform LNA. We observed that although multiple
factors were significantly correlated with the decision to perform LNA
in univariate analysis, only surgeon (p ⬍ 0.001), low RD (p ⫽ 0.004),
ASA1/2 (p ⫽ 0.002), and carcinomatosis (p ⫽ 0.01) were important in
multivariable analysis. Further, if LNA was performed, the decision to
do LND vs. LNS was independently associated with surgeon (p ⬍
0.001), low RD (p ⫽ 0.002) and patient age ⬍65 (0.003). In all,
surgeon preference appeared to be the most important factor for
whether LNA, and extent of LNA. Finally, when considering survival
of the subgroup undergoing LNA, we observed a significantly shorter
survival for those with lymphatic involvement. However, when
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
considering only those with positive lymph nodes, we observed no
survival benefit for those undergoing LND relative to LNS: the only
independent predictor of survival was RD.
Conclusion: The decision to perform LNA in advanced stage ovarian
cancer in our series appears based on several intuitively logical
factors: low RD, ASA status of the patient. However, the most
important factor was individual surgeon preference. We believe the
role of LNA and the recommendations for LNA are poorly defined for
advanced ovarian cancer. This area represents an opportunity for
standardization and improvement in surgical practice of gynecologic
oncology.
Key Words: surgery, ovarian cancer, lymphadenectomy
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
ORAL PRESENTATION 6
Is Intraoperative Frozen Section Analysis of Pelvic Lymph
Nodes Accurate After Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy in Patients
With Cervical Cancer?
A. A. Bader1, K. F. Tamussino1, G. Pristauz1, F. Moinfar2, and R.
Winter1 1Department of Obstetrics/Gynecology, Medical University of
Graz, Graz, Austria; 2Department of Pathology, Medical University of
Graz, Graz, Austria
Objectives: Intraoperative frozen section examination of pelvic lymph
nodes is frequently used to tailor the extent of lymphadenectomy or
select individual treatment strategies in patients with cervical cancer,
some of whom may have received neoadjuvant chemotherapy (NACT).
NACT can cause necrosis, fibrosis, or keratinization of tumor deposits in
extirpated lymph nodes and it is unclear whether intraoperative frozen
section analysis of extirpated nodes is accurate after NACT. We analyzed
the accuracy of frozen section examination of pelvic lymph nodes in
patients after NACT.
Materials and Methods: We reviewed 134 patients with invasive
cervical cancer who underwent surgery including systematic pelvic
lymphadenectomy with intraoperative frozen section examination of
pelvic lymph nodes. Results of frozen section examination were
related to definitive histology and compared between patient groups
of NACT and primary surgery.
Results: A total of 1670 pelvic lymph nodes were evaluated
intraoperatively by frozen section examination and 6689 pelvic lymph
nodes were analyzed by final histopathology. We observed 9 false
negative cases out of 53 patients with positive lymph nodes (false
negative rate 16.9%). After NACT, two false negative diagnoses out of
twelve patients with node metastases were recorded (false negative
rate 16.7%) (table). No false positive cases were noted.
TABLE 1. Accuracy of Frozen Section Examination as a
Diagnostic Test for Predicting the Final Node Status in
Patients After NACT and Primary Surgery of 134 Patients
With Cervical Cancer, Oral Presentation 6
True-positive
True-negative
False-negative
Sensitivity
Specificity
Positive predictive
value
Negative predictive
value
NACT
(No. of Patients)
Primary Surgery
(No. of Patients)
10
9
2
83%
100%
100%
34
72
7
83%
100%
100%
82%
91%
Conclusion: NACT does not appear to compromise the diagnostic
accuracy of intraoperative frozen section examination of pelvic lymph
nodes in patients with cervical cancer.
Key Words: cervical cancer, lymph nodes, frozen section, neoadjuvant chemotherapy
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
ORAL PRESENTATION 7
Clinical Anatomy and Surgical Skills Training (CASST)
K. Kenton1,2, S. Graziano1, E. Mueller2,1, L. Oldham3, and F. Turner4
1
Obstetrics and Gynecology, Loyola University Medical Center,
Maywood, IL; 2Urology, Loyola University Medical Center, Maywood,
IL; 3Obstetrics and Gynecology, Rush University Medical Center,
Chicago, IL; 4Obstetrics and Gynecology, Illinois Masonic Medical
Center, Chicago, IL
Objectives: Resident surgical training is increasingly challenging due to
limited work hours, decreased surgical volume, and increasing clinical
demands of academic faculty. Innovative, cost effective programs must be
developed to teach junior residents anatomy and basic surgical skill (SS).
The aim of this program was to develop multicenter, multidisciplinary
anatomy and SS training program for junior residents in Ob/Gyn and
urology.
Materials and Methods: We administered a needs assessment on
knowledge of basic SS and clinical anatomy to junior residents from 4residency training programs in Chicago. We then developed 5, 3-hour
workshops, including didactics, SS laboratories, and cadaver dissections to teach basic SS and anatomy. A program budget was
developed for a single residency program with 6 juniors and
compared to the budget for 4 residencies.
Faculty included physicians from gynecology and urology from 3
different academic medical centers. A pre-test was given prior to the
first session to assess baseline knowledge. The same test will be
administered at the conclusion of the 5th session and at the end of
the academic year to help determine short and long term program
retention. The needs assessment and some pretest results are
presented here.
SPSS (Vesion 13) was used for data entry and analysis. Chi-square
test of association was used for nominal data. Data were considered
significant at the .05 level.
Results: Thirty-two residents participated in the program. The perresident cost of the program with 4 participating sites was approximately
$800 for models, cadavers, surgical instruments and supplies. When only
1 site with 6 residents was used, the per-resident cost increased to
approximately $1700.
Ninety-three percent of participants preferred hands-on surgical models
or cadavers to didactic lectures. 100% of participants agreed or strongly
agreed that they would benefit from more formal training in basic SS
before entering the operating room, and 86% thought that prosected
cadavers would increase their knowledge of anatomy.
Over half of residents thought their knowledge and/or skills in all areas
surveyed (except knot tying) were marginal or poor. A significantly
higher percentage of R2s felt their knot tying skills were excellent or
adequate (p ⫽ .009). Urology residents were significantly more likely to
report that their knowledge of pelvic anatomy and hysterectomy was
poor compared to gynecology residents (p ⫽ .001 and p ⫽ .012,
respectively).
On pretest assessment 27% could correctly identify 3 branches of the
pudendal nerve and 40% accurately described differences between 1st4th degree perineal lacerations. Only 10% knew the 3 most common
sites of ureteral injury during hysterectomy, while another 33% could
name 2 sites. 50% selected an appropriate suture type to close fascia,
subcutaneous tissues and skin.
Conclusion: We have developed a unique multicenter, multidisciplinary program to train junior residents in clinical anatomy and
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
67
surgical skills. By including multiple centers and disciplines, we were
able to reduce costs to individual programs and maximize faculty
teaching time and effort. Objective outcomes of the program will be
assessed at 2 time points to assess short and long term program
efficacy.
ORAL PRESENTATION 9
The Expectations of Surgical Patients: Are We Talking the Same
Language?
Disclosure - Grant/Research: Kim Kenton, Allergan, Pfizer, Q Med,
Life-Tech, Astellas, Elizabeth Mueller, Allergan, Astellas.
V. T. Mallett1, L. Brubaker2, L. Hammontree5, A. Stoddard3, L. Hall6, D.
Borello-France4, S. Tennstedt2, for the Urinary Incontinence Treatment
Network7 1Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Tennessee,
Memphis, TN; 2Obstetrics and Gynecology, Loyola University,
Chicago, IL; 3New England Research Institute, Boston, MA;
4
Obstetrics and Gynecology, McGee Women’s Hospital University of
Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA; 5University of Alabama, Birmingham, AL;
6
University of California San Diego, San Diego, CA; 7NIDDK,
National Institute of Health, Bethesda, MD
ORAL PRESENTATION 8
Is Trans-Obturator Tape as Effective as Tension-Free Vaginal
Tape in Patients With a Borderline Maximal Urethral Closure
Pressure?
Objectives: To assess patient expectations of surgical outcome
following standardized pre-surgical video presentation of surgical
procedures in a randomized trial comparing pubovaginal sling (PVS)
and Burch colposuspension.
Key Words: surgical education, sugical skills, clinical anatomy
J. Miller1, S. M. Botros1, M. N. Akl2, R. P. Goldberg1, and P. K. Sand1
1
Division of Urogynecology, Evanston Continence Center, Northwestern
University, Evanston, IL; 2Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Hurley
Medical Center, Michigan State University, Flint, MI
Objectives: Few clinical studies compare the trans-obturator tape
(TOT) with the tension-free vaginal tape (TVT) and none address
whether routine preoperative evaluation of urethral function is
warranted. Most TOT failures happen in patients with maximum
urethral closure pressure (MUCP) ⱕ40 cm H2O (Guerette, et al. Int
Urogyn J 2005 16(S2): S120 关abstract兴 ). The purpose of this study was
to compare TOT to TVT in that population.
Materials and Methods: Retrospective cohort analysis of fourteenweek outcomes in 145 subjects (TOT ⫽ 85; TVT ⫽ 60). All patients
had routine urodynamics including urethral pressure profiles
preoperatively and fourteen weeks after surgery. All patients had
routine cystoscopy at the time of surgery. Outcome variables included
urodynamic stress incontinence (USI), subjective stress incontinence,
bladder perforations estimated blood loss, and other intraoperative
complications. Patients with preoperative MUCP ⱕ42 and ⬎42 cm
H2O were included in separate sub-analyses of USI outcomes. A new
cutpoint was used because initial subanalysis with a cutpoint of 40 cm
H2O failed to show significance. Student’s T-test compared mean
baseline characteristics and follow-up times. Pearson 2-tests of
statistical significance and relative risks (RR) were calculated for
outcomes.
Results: Patients in the TOT and TVT groups did not differ
significantly in baseline characteristics or follow-up time. In subanalysis of patients with a pre-operative MUCP ⱕ42 cm H2O, USI
persisted in 7/44 (16%) patients with TOT and in 1/37 (3%) patients
with TVT (RR 5.89; 1.02–33.90, 95% CI). In patients with MUCP ⬎42
cm H2O, USI persisted in 1/41 (2%) patients with TOT and in 1/23
(4%) patients with TVT (RR 0.57; 0.04 – 8.44, 95% CI). Overall, USI
persisted in 8/85 (10%) patients with TOT and 2/60 (3%) patients
with TVT (RR 2.85; 0.67–12.07, 95% CI). Subjective complaint of any
stress incontinence after surgery was absent in 52/60 (87%) patients
with TVT and 74/85 (87%) patients with TOT (RR 0.97; 0.94 –1.01,
95% CI). There was one bladder perforation (2%) with TVT and none
with TOT (p ⫽ 0.41); other intraoperative complications including
estimated blood loss also were similar between groups.
Conclusion: In patients with a MUCP ⱕ42 cm H2O, the TOT is
nearly six times more likely to fail than TVT. Long-term follow-up and
randomized controlled trials are needed.
Key Words: stress incontinence, transobturator tape, tension-free vaginal tape, maximal urethral closure pressure, urethral pressure profile,
surgery
Disclosure - Advisor: Peter Sand, Novasys; Investigator: Peter Sand,
Mentor; Investigator, Advisor, Lecturer: Peter Sand, Alza/OrthoMcNeil,
Peter Sand, American Medical Systems, Peter Sand, Indevus Pharmaceuticals, Peter Sand, Astellas.
68
Materials and Methods: Participants were randomized to Burch or
PVS in an NIH sponsored multi-center trial. Prior to surgery, trial
participants watched a video explaining, purpose, risks and benefits as
well as the likelihood for eliminating stress incontinence.
Preoperatively, a validated questionnaire was used to assess
expectations for the effects of surgery on UI-related symptom relief,
resolution of current limitations in activity, and change in emotions.
The domains were examined on a 5 point Likert-type scale. The
expectation score was computed as the average of expectations (0 –5)
for the resolution of symptoms, limitations or negative emotions
reported. Type and severity of incontinence were assessed preoperatively using the Medical, Epidemiologic and Social Aspects of
Aging (MESA) questionnaire, Urinary Distress Inventory (UDI),
incontinence impact questionnaire (IIQ), baseline health measures and
urodynamic parameters. Bivariate and multivariable associations with
expectation were explored using logistic regression analysis.
Results: The study included 650 eligible randomized women (age
27– 81; mean:51.9). Mean and median expectation scores were 4.4 of
5 and 87% of women had a score ⬎4. Because the scores were highly
skewed, women were categorized by score ⬎4 (higher expectations)
and ⬍4 (lower expectations). Symptoms were recorded first followed
by expected resolution of the symptom. The most frequent symptoms
were urine leakage (98%) followed by embarrassment (88%).
Frequency, reduced physical activity, and urgency were reported by
74%, 72%, and 70% respectively. Limitations on sexual and social
activities were reported by less than 44%. Expectation for near or
complete improvement was most frequent for urine leakage (98%). Of
the 70% of patients reporting urgency, 92% had an expectation of the
symptom becoming much better or completely better. Moreover, of
the 74% reporting frequency, 83% expected substantial symptom
relief. There was no association between expectation and IIQ,
urodynamics and baseline health measures. Women who reported a
greater impact of their incontinence on the UDI stress subscale had
higher expectations. Among women with lower expectations (score
less than 4), mean baseline UDI-stress score was 71.8 while among
women with high expectations the mean was 79.3 (p ⬍ 0.01).
Conclusion: Patients’ expectation for the outcome of anti-stress
incontinence surgery is uniformly high. Even with standard
counseling about expected outcome and benefits of the two
procedures patients have expectation regarding resolution of
irritative symptoms that are unrealistic and may ultimately impact
patient satisfaction.
Key Words: surgery, incontinence, patient expectation, patient satisfaction
Disclosure - grant: Veronica T. Mallett, Watson, Yamanouchi, Gynecare,
Linda Brubaker, Liley pharmaceuticals.
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
ORAL PRESENTATION 10
Bowel Symptoms in Women Planning Surgery for Pelvic Organ
Prolapse
C. S. Bradley, and ... for the Pelvic Floor Disorders Network
University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, IA
Objectives: Bowel symptoms are common and often attributed to
pelvic organ prolapse (POP). Our objective was to correlate bowel
symptoms and level of vaginal descent in women with prolapse.
Materials and Methods: This analysis used baseline data from the
Colpopexy and Urinary Reduction Efforts (CARE) study, a randomized
trial of sacrocolpopexy with or without Burch colposuspension in
stress continent women with Stages II – IV POP. Participants
completed validated questionnaires, including the Colorectal-anal
Distress Inventory (CRADI) and the Colorectal-anal Impact
Questionnaire (CRAIQ) and underwent Pelvic Organ Prolapse
Quantification (POP-Q). POP-Q points Bp, Ba and C assessed descent
of the posterior, anterior and apical vagina, respectively. Subject
characteristics were compared between prolapse stages using the chisquare test.
Results: The CARE trial enrolled 322 women with mean age 61.3 ⫾
10.2 years and median parity of 3. POP-Q stages included II (n ⫽ 44,
13.7%), III (n ⫽ 217, 67.4%) and IV (n ⫽ 61, 18.9%). Posterior repair had
been performed in 71 women (22.0%). When examining individual
symptom questions on the CRADI, women with Stages III and IV
prolapse tended to have similar levels of symptoms, while women with
Stage II prolapse were more symptomatic. (Table) Summary scores for
the CRADI (Stage II, median score 58.3; Stage III, score 47.6; and Stage
IV, score 48.0; p ⫽ 0.08) and CRAIQ (Stage II, median score 112.6; Stage
III, score 102.3; and Stage IV, score 108.0; p ⫽ 0.09) showed a similar
pattern.
Conclusion: In conclusion, although bowel symptoms are common
in women planning sacrocolpopexy, these symptoms and focused
questionnaire scores do not have a linear association with the stage of
prolapse in the posterior or other pelvic compartments. We suggest
that the CRADI, CRAIQ and POP-Q examination measure
complementary, different and not necessarily related aspects of pelvic
organ prolapse.
Key Words: POP-Q, pelvic organ prolapse, bowel dysfunction, anorectal symptoms
Disclosure - Grant/Research Support: Catherine Bradley, Astellas; Speaker
Bureau: Catherine Bradley, Pfizer.
TABLE 1. Oral Presentation 10
Symptoms
Splinting
Straining
Incomplete emptying
Stage II
N ⴝ 44
Stage III
N ⴝ 217
Stage IV
N ⴝ 61
19 (44.2%)
23 (53.5%)
25 (59.5%)
53 (25.1%)
72 (34.1%)
88 (41.9%)
17 (28.3%)
18 (30.0%)
26 (43.3%)
ORAL PRESENTATION 11
Posterior Vaginal Wall Prolapse Does Not Correlate With Fecal
Symptoms or Objective Measurements of Anorectal Function
G. Da Silva, B. Gurland, A. Sleemi, and G. Levy Maimonides Medical
Center, Brooklyn, NY
Objectives: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the relationship
between the degree of posterior vaginal wall prolapse, anorectal
symptoms, and physiology.
Materials and Methods: This is a prospective IRB approved study
including all patients evaluated at a Multidisciplinary Pelvic Floor Center
by a urogynecologist and colorectal surgeon. A standardized bladder and
TABLE 1. Oral Presentation 11
Symptoms
Obstructive Defecation
Wexner Fecal Incontinence
Score ⬎9
Feeling of anal blockage
Anal digitation
BM ⬍3/week
Group
I%
Group
II %
P
value
41.9
30.6
40
20
NS
NS
17.7
12.9
11.3
20
12.9
4.3
NS
NS
NS
bowel function questionnaire and POP-Q clinical examination was
performed on all patients. Anal physiologic testings (anorectal
manometry, transanal ultrasound (US), surface electromyography and
pudendal nerve terminal latencies-PNTML) were selectively performed
based on bowel symptoms. Defecography was performed on patients
with constipation and to rule out rectal prolapse. Patients were divided
into 2 groups based on posterior vaginal wall prolapse Group I: Ap/Bp ⬍
⫺1, and Group II Ap/BP ⱖ ⫺1. Patient information was entered into a
centralized database and statistical analysis was performed using Fisher’s
Exact T-test and p value ⬍0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Results: One hundred and thirty-two patients with a mean age of 63
(range: 24 –90) years old were evaluated. Sixty-two (47%) in Group I
and 70 (52%) in Group II. Overall, obstructive defecation was present
in 40.9%, a Wexner fecal incontinence score ⬎9 in 25%, a feeling of
anal blockage in 18.9%, digitation in 12.9%, evacuation less than 3
BM/week in 7.6%. Bowel symptoms are summarized in Table 1.
Ninety-seven patients underwent physiologic tests. At manometry,
both resting (RP) and squeeze pressures (SP) were significantly higher
in patients Group II (RP: 63.1 vs. 36.6, SP 86.3 vs. 51, respectively;
p ⬍ .001). There was no association between rectal capacity, first
sensation, urgency and the degree of prolapse. US demonstrated
anterior sphincter defect in 21.9% and a perineal body ⬍10 mm in
67.1% of the patients, with no correlation with the degree of
prolapse. There was no association between EMG and PNTML tests
results and the degree of prolapse. On defecography, 28% of the
patients had concomitant enterocele and 21.3% intussusception, with
no correlation with the severity of prolapse.
Conclusion: Anorectal symptoms do not correlate to the degree of
posterior vaginal wall prolapse nor does the presence of prolapse
equate to abnormal physiologic studies. However, elevated resting and
squeeze sphincter pressures in patients with higher degree of posterior
vaginal wall prolapse may help to explain the pathogenesis of posterior
wall prolapse. When the sphincter pressures are elevated, a defect in the
rectovaginal septum provides a “path of least resistance.”
Key Words: posterior vaginal wall prolapse, physiology, anorectal
symptoms
Disclosure - Speakers Bureau: Gil Levy, Ortho Pharamaceutical.
ORAL PRESENTATION 12
Rectocele Repair: A Randomized Trial of Three Surgical
Techniques Including Graft Augmentation
M. R. Paraiso, M. D. Barber, T. W. Muir, and M. D. Walters OBGYN,
The Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, OH
Objectives: To compare anatomic and functional outcomes of 3
different surgical techniques for treating rectoceles.
Materials and Methods: 106 women with stage 2 or greater
posterior vaginal wall prolapse were randomized to one of three
treatments: traditional posterior colporrhaphy (n ⫽ 37), site-specific
rectocele repair (n ⫽ 37), or site-specific rectocele repair augmented
with a porcine small intestinal submucosa bioengineered collagen
matrix (Fortagen™). Subjects underwent a physical examination that
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
69
included POPQ and completed the Pelvic Floor Distress Inventory-20
(PFDI-20), the Pelvic Floor Impact Questionnaire-7 (PFIQ-7), and the
Prolapse and Urinary Incontinence Sexual Questionnaire-12 (PISQ-12)
at baseline, 6 months, 1 year and 2 years after surgery. Anatomic
failure was defined as POPQ point Bp ⬎ ⫺1 at one year follow-up.
Functional failure was defined as a worsening in prolapse or
colorectal symptoms as assessed by the PFDI-20.
Results: Of 106 subjects who enrolled in this study, 105 underwent
surgery and 99 subjects (93%) returned for follow-up with a mean
follow-up of 16 ⫹ 7 months (range 3.5 to 32 mos.). At baseline, 44
subjects (42%) had stage 2 posterior vaginal wall prolapse; 56 (53%)
had stage 3; and 5 (5%) had stage 4. Mean operating time, change in
hematocrit, and length of stay were similar between groups.
Intraoperative and postoperative complications were infrequent and
similar between groups. After one year of follow-up, subjects who
received a site-specific repair with graft augmentation had a significantly
greater anatomic failure rate (9/27; 33%) than those who received a sitespecific repair alone (5/37; 13.5%) or a traditional posterior colporraphy
(3/33; 9%), p ⫽ 0.035. Three percent (1/33) of those in the traditional
posterior colporraphy group, 5% (2/35) in the site-specific group, and
14% (4/29) in the graft augmentation group had posterior vaginal
prolapse to or beyond the hymen at one year, p ⫽ 0.22. There were
significant improvements in the prolapse and colorectal scales and overall
summary scores of the PFDI-20 and PFIQ-7 after surgery in all groups
(p ⬍ .0001 for each) with no differences between groups. The
proportion of subjects with functional failures was 15% (15/99) overall,
and not significantly different between groups. At baseline, 64% of
subjects were sexually active. Of these, 48% (31/64) complained of
dyspareunia prior to surgery. There was no significant change in the rate
of dyspareunia one year after surgery and there were no differences
between groups. Overall sexual function as measured by the PISQ-12
improved significantly in all groups postoperatively (p ⬍ .01), with no
differences between groups.
Conclusion: Traditional posterior colporraphy and site-specific
rectocele repair result in similar anatomic and functional outcomes.
Graft augmentation with a porcine-derived acellular collagen matrix
does not improve and may worsen anatomic outcomes. All three
methods of rectocele repair result in significant improvements in
prolapse and bowel symptoms, quality of life, and sexual function
with no overall change in the rate of dyspareunia.
Key Words: prolapse, vaginal surgery, rectocele, site-specific repair,
graft augmentation, posterior colporrhaphy
Disclosure - Consultant: Marie Fidela R. Paraiso, Gynecare and AMS,
Mark D. Walters, AMS; Grant/Research Support: Marie Fidela R.
Paraiso, Organogenesis, Inc., Matthew D. Barber, Eli-Lilly and AMS.
ORAL PRESENTATION 13
Histologic Evaluation and Biomechanical Measurements of
Implanted Graft Material in a Rabbit Vaginal and Abdominal
Model
W. S. Hilger1, A. J. Walter3, M. Zobitz2, P. Magtibay1, and J. Cornella1
1
Gynecology, Mayo Clinic Arizona, Scottsdale, AZ; 2Orthopedic
Biomechanics, Mayo Clinic Rochester, Rochester, MN; 3Urogynecology,
Kaiser Sacramento, Sacramento, CA
Objectives: The purpose of this study is to describe histologic and
biomechanical changes of vaginally and abdominally implanted graft
materials (human cadaveric dermal allograft (Repliform), porcine
dermal xenograft (Pelvisoft), porcine collagen coated polypropylene
mesh (Pelvitex) and autologous fascia) in New Zealand white rabbits.
Materials and Methods: Twenty Retired New Zealand Breeder rabbits
underwent abdominal and vaginal surgery. Each rabbit had four materials
randomly placed in the abdomen and vagina (autologous, Repliform,
Pelvisoft, Pelvitex or Pelvisoft). The rabbits underwent harvesting of the
graft material at 6 and 12 weeks after implantation. Biomechanical testing
70
on a tensiometer measured the maximum strength of the tissue (Ultimate
Stress MPa) and the tissue elasticity (Elastic Modulous MPa). We
performed 2-way ANOVA (Sites X Material) to assess magnitude of
decline from baseline contributed by sites and materials. Histologic
evaluation assessed the extent of inflammatory response, neovascularization, and collagen deposition.
Results: Ultimate stress declined from baseline in all materials and
was dependent on material used and anatomic site (99% CI, P ⬍ 0.05
and 94% CI, P ⫽ 0.057). The decline in ultimate stress for abdominally
implanted materials from baseline were: autologous 0.19 MPa,
Pelvisoft 3.54 MPa, Pelvitex 0.96 MPa and Repliform 10.3 MPa. The
decline in ultimate stress for each vaginally implanted materials from
baseline were: autologous 0.26 MPa, Pelvisoft 3.84 MPa, Pelvitex 4.00
MPa and Repliform 13.1 MPa.
Elastic modulous was found to be dependent on the material (99%
CI, P ⬍ 0.05) but not anatomic site (P ⫽ 0.73). The decline in Elastic
Modulous for abdominally implanted materials from baseline were:
autologous 0.29 MPa, Pelvisoft 20.1 MPa, Pelvitex 0.75 MPa and
Repliform 25.5 MPa. The decline in elastic modulous for vaginally
implanted materials from baseline were: autologous 0.56 MPa,
Pelvisoft 18.1 MPa, Pelvitex 0.66 MPa, Repliform 29.0 MPa.
Histologic evaluation noted minimal inflammatory response in
autologous and Pelvitex, and moderate to strong inflammatory
response in Pelvisoft and Repliform. Minimal neovascularization was
noted in all materials. Minimal collagen ingrowth was noted in
Repliform and Pelvisoft. Collagen ingrowth was moderate in
autologous and Pelvitex but encapsulation was noted in Pelvitex. The
histologic findings were not affected by graft site.
Conclusion: All implanted materials demonstrated a decline in ultimate
stress and elastic modulous from baseline. The changes in ultimate stress
were affected by the anatomic site, with the vaginally implanted materials
showing a greater decline. Autologous and Pelvitex had minimal
inflammatory response but the collagen ingrowth differed. Repliform and
Pelvisoft showed greater inflammatory response and less collagen
ingrowth. Future studies should determine what factors contribute to the
host response to graft materials and how they effect graft performance.
Key Words: graft material, vagina, rabbit model
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
ORAL PRESENTATION 14
Can Advanced Stages of Anterior or Posterior Vaginal Wall
Prolapse Occur Without Apical Involvement?
K. Rooney1, E. R. Mueller2,1, K. Kenton1,2, M. P. Fitzgerald1,2, S. Shott3,
1
and L. Brubaker1,2
Obstetrics/Gynecology, Loyola University
Medical Center, Maywood, IL; 2Urology, Loyola University Medical
Center, Maywood, IL; 3Obstetrics/Gynecology, Rush University
Medical Center, Chicago, IL
Objectives: An increasing number of surgical techniques have been
developed for anterior vaginal wall prolapse. Some of these techniques
address the apex while others may not. Our objective was to determine
the associations between the most prolapsed portion of the anterior and
posterior vaginal wall and the apex.
Materials and Methods: After obtaining IRB approval, we retrospectively reviewed the charts of all new patients who presented to our
tertiary care urogynecology practice from January 2004 to February 2005.
We extracted demographic data, previous surgical history and physical
exam findings including pelvic organ prolapse quantification (POP-Q).
POP-Q points Ba, C, and Bp, measured the anterior, apical and posterior
segments of the vaginal respectively. Data were analyzed using SPSS
version 13 software. Correlations between variables were analyzed using
a Spearman’s analysis.
Results: Three hundred twenty-five women had completed POP-Q
measurements that allowed for analysis. The mean age was 60 years
and 81% were Caucasian. Thirty-nine percent of the women had a
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
FIGURE 1.
previous hysterectomy. The position of the cervix or vaginal cuff
(POP-Q point C) strongly correlated with POP-Q point Ba (most distal
position of the anterior wall) (r ⫽ 0.835, p ⬍ 0.001). There was a
moderate correlation between the position of the apex and the
posterior wall (r ⫽ 0.556, p ⬍ 0.001). The following scatter plot
demonstrates the relationship between point C (the cervix or vaginal
apex) and point Ba (the most distal portion of the anterior wall). The
relationship is strongly linear and using linear regression the following
equation can be developed; C ⫽ Ba (1.4) ⫺ 4.4 (r ⫽ 0.869). Using
this equation we can predict that when the anterior wall is at the
hymen (point Ba ⫽ 0) the equation calculates C at ⫺4.4. Seventy-five
percent of the women in this study had point C at ⫺4 or greater
when point Ba was at 0 (n ⫽ 153).
Conclusion: Anterior vaginal wall prolapse is strongly associated
with apical prolapse. Anterior vaginal wall defects that are being
surgical repaired often require a concomitant repair of the apical
defect.
Key Words: anterior prolapse, apical prolapse, posterior prolapse
Disclosure - Grant /Research: Elizabeth R. Mueller, Allergan, Astellas; Grant/
Research: Kimberly Kenton, Allergan, Astellas, Yamanouchi, Lifetech, Pifzer;
Grant/Research: Mary Pat FitzGerald, Allergan, Yamanouchi, Lifetech;
GrantResearch, Linda Brubaker, Allergan, Astellas, Yamanouchi, Lifetech,
Pifzer.
Results: After a primary repair, 48 women had complete healing of
their fistulas (48/95 ⫽51%) with 39 women being dry (39/95 ⫽ 41%)
and 9 having urinary incontinence (9/95 ⫽ 9%). Failed fistula repair
was noted in 19 (19/95 ⫽ 20%) and 28 patients were lost to follow
up (28/95 ⫽ 29%). If all patients lost to follow up are assumed wet,
our failure rate is 49% (47/95). Secondary repairs were performed on
18 of the 19 known failed primary repairs. A second vaginal repair
was performed in 15 patients, and an abdominal procedure was
undertaken in 3 patients. Healing of the fistulas occurred in 39%
(7/18) of surgeries with 3 (17%) women becoming dry and 4 (22%)
having urinary incontinence. A second failed surgery occurred in 7
(39%) women and 4 (22%) of patients were lost to follow up. Three
of the failed repairs underwent a third surgery with no known
successes. A fourth repair was attempted in two patients with one
patient having a successful closure and being dry.
Conclusion: Success rates for vesico-vaginal fistula repairs have been
controversial with questions remaining regarding staging and follow
up. Our report confirms the best chance of successful fistula repair,
regardless of stage, location or size, is with the initial repair. This
series also demonstrates that when all patients appearing with a fistula
are included in the reported surgical series, the success rates are less
than the impression of reported experiences. We tabulated all patients
lost to follow up as failed repairs and wet. While this method,
counting patients lost to follow up as wet, is controversial, we feel
our data is made more accurate in this manner.
Key Words: birth trauma, vesico-vaginal fistulas, urinary incontinence,
obstructed labor
ORAL PRESENTATION 15
Repair of Obstetrical Vesico-Vaginal Fistulas in Africa
M. L. Roenneburg1,2, R. Genadry2, and C. R. Wheeless2 1The
Weinberg Center for Women’s Health & Medicine, Mercy Medical
Center, Baltimore, MD; 2Dept of Gynecology & Obstetrics, Johns
Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD
Objectives: Obstetrical fistulas in sub-Sahara Africa result from
obstructed labors. Our intent is to report on a series of vesico-vaginal
fistula repairs in an ongoing program for repair of obstetrical trauma in
Niger, Africa.
Materials and Methods: From October 2003 to April 2005, 95
patients presented with vesico-vaginal fistulas and no previous repair.
Patients ranged in age from 14 to 51. Their fistulas were variable in
location and ranged from 0.5 cm to 7 cm in size. All patients were
offered surgical repair regardless of stage and circumstances. Vaginal
repairs were performed in 89 patients (94%). Abdominal transvesical
repairs were utilized in 6 patients (6%).
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
ORAL PRESENTATION 16
A Comparison of Outcomes of Transurethral Versus Suprapubic
Catheterization After Urogynecologic Procedures
T. S. Dunn1, L. Hurt2,1, and B. Hessler2 1Obstetrics and Gynecology,
Denver Health Medical Center, Denver, CO; 2Obstetrics and
Gynecology, University of Colorado Health Science Center, Denver,
CO; 3Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Colorado Health
Science Center, Denver, CO
Objectives: To determine if there were any differences in outcomes in
patients undergoing urogynecologic procedures when suprapubic or
transurethral catheter was used for post-operative bladder drainage.
Materials and Methods: This was an IRB approved randomized
controlled study comparing suprapubic to transurethral catheterization
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
71
TABLE 1. Oral Presentation 17
Prolapse
Reduction
Method
Pessary
Hand
Swab
Forceps
Speculum
Stress
Leakage at
UDS
Control, N (%)
Incontinent after
ASC Only
Burch, N (%)
Incontinent after
ASC and Burch
Benefit
(⫺)
(⫹)
(⫺)
(⫹)
(⫺)
(⫹)
(⫺)
(⫹)
(⫺)
(⫹)
19 of 46 (41%)
1 of 2 (50%)
18 of 53 (34%)
4 of 8 (50%)
22 of 63 (35%)
11 of 14 (79%)
20 of 41 (49%)
4 of 8 (50%)
17 of 42 (40%)
11 of 20 (55%)
8 of 37 (22%)
1 of 3 (33%)
13 of 50 (26%)
5 of 11 (45%)
12 of 63 (19%)
5 of 18 (28%)
5 of 36 (14%)
3 of 13 (23%)
7 of 41 (17%)
8 of 15 (53%)
19%
17%
8%
5%
16%
50%
35%
27%
23%
2%
in patients undergoing procedures for pelvic prolapse, or stress
urinary incontinence. Patients were included from 1/2002 through
1/2005. A two-sample T-test power analysis was performed and a
sample size of 51 and 51 to achieve 93% power to detect a difference
was calculated. Ten patients were added to cover for patients in case
of loss to follow-up, incomplete records or inability to place catheter.
The attending surgeon was the same in all cases. A randomization
card was opened in the Operating Room designating whether a
transurethral or suprapubic catheter should be placed. A visual analog
scale was used for evaluation of postoperative pain. A 16 French Foley
was then placed either transurethrally or suprapubically. Extracted
data included patient demographics, blood loss, operating room
time, incidence of urinary tract infection, pain scores, and length
of hospital stay (for patients undergoing procedures requiring a
stay). Fishers exact test and Wilcoxon rank sum analysis were used
when indicated.
Results: One hundred and ten charts were reviewed, and 104
patients were included; 51 in the transurethral group and 53 in the
suprapubic group. Demographics were similar in each group relating
to age, ethnicity, menopausal status, body mass index, and type of
procedure. There were no differences in blood loss, urinary tract
infections, length of hospital stay or length of catheterization in either
group. There was an increased length of operative time when the
suprapubic catheter was placed (mean 11 minutes) but was not
statistically significant (p ⫽ .1). There was a statistical difference in
pain perception on a visual scale, which was significantly less in the
supra-pubic group (mild vs. severe) p ⫽ .01.
Conclusion: There was no significant difference in outcomes for
transurethral versus suprapubic catheterization in patients undergoing
urogynecologic procedures. Patients did have significantly less pain
when a suprapubic catheter was used, and should be considered
when undertaking urogynecologic procedures requiring postoperative
bladder drainage.
Key Words: urogynecologic, transurethral catheter, suprapubic
catheter
Objectives: Our objective was to determine, in stress continent
women undergoing sacrocolpopexy, whether urodynamics with prolapse
reduction predicts postoperative stress incontinence.
Materials and Methods: 322 stress-continent women with Stage
II–IV prolapse underwent standardized urodynamics with water-based
transducers. Five prolapse reduction methods were tested, two at
each site and both performed for each subject. At sacrocolpopexy
(ASC), participants were randomized to Burch colposuspension or no
Burch (control). Clinicians were masked to urodynamic results. Pvalues were computed by two-tailed Fisher’s exact test.
Results: Preoperatively, 12 of 313 (4%) subjects demonstrated
urodynamic stress incontinence (USI) without prolapse reduction. The
order of prolapse reduction methods did not affect detection of USI with
reduction, 16% with 1st method versus 22% with 2nd. Preoperative
detection of USI with prolapse reduction at 300 ml was, in ascending
order: pessary, 6% (5 of 88); hand, 16% (19 of 122); swab, 19% (32 of
168); ring forceps, 21% (21 of 98); and speculum, 30% (35 of 118).
As seen in the table below, the Benefit column estimates the
decrease in postoperative stress incontinence when the prolapse
reduction method is used preoperatively. In evaluating test
characteristics of the prolapse reduction methods, the highest benefit
was seen with the swab technique, with high positive predictive value
(PPV) in controls, followed by low PPV in the Burch group. In
addition, incontinence was always lower after negative urodynamic
testing.
In the control group, the swab technique of prolapse reduction
had the highest positive predictive value for postoperative SUI, and
the highest benefit between Burch and control groups.
Conclusion: In stress continent women with prolapse undergoing
sacrocolpopexy, the addition of Burch colposuspension reduced
postoperative stress incontinence symptoms whether or not preoperative
urodynamic stress incontinence was diagnosed with reduction testing.
However, preoperative USI with prolapse reduction (regardless of
method) was associated with a higher likelihood of postoperative stress
incontinence, compared to subjects who did not leak with prolapse
reduction during urodynamics.
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
Key Words: urodynamics, prolapse, CARE Trial, stress incontinence,
sacrocolpopexy
ORAL PRESENTATION 17
The Role of Pre-Operative Urodynamic Testing in Stress
Continent Women Undergoing Sacrocolpopexy: The Colpopexy
and Urinary Reduction Efforts (CARE) Randomized Surgical
Trial
A. G. Visco1, for the Pelvic Floor Disorders Network2 1Obstetrics
and Gynecology, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel
Hill, NC; 2U01 HD41249, U10 HD41268, U10 HD41248, U10
HD41250, U10 HD41261, U10 HD41263, U10 HD41269, and U10
HD41267, NICHD, Bethesda, MD
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
72
ORAL PRESENTATION 18
Do Pessaries Improve Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms?
J. Schaffer1, G. W. Cundiff2, C. L. Amundsen3, A. Bent5, K. W. Coates6,
K. Strohbehn4, and D. D. McIntire1 1Obstetrics and Gynecology, UT
Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX; 2Johns Hopkins Bayview
Medical Center, Baltimore, MD; 3Duke University, Durham, OH;
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
4
Dartmouth Hospital, Hanover, NH; 5IWK Health Care, Halifax, NS,
Canada; 6Scott & White Clinic, Temple, VA
Objectives: To determine the effects of pessary use on lower urinary
tract symptoms in patients with symptomatic pelvic organ prolapse
and to compare symptoms in Gellhorn and ring with support users.
Materials and Methods: This study was a sub-analysis of data
collected during a multi-center randomized cross-over trial comparing
the Gellhorn and ring with support pessaries in the relief of prolapse
symptoms. Subjects with symptomatic pelvic organ prolapse at 6
institutions were randomized to one pessary for three months,
followed by the other pessary for 3 months. The Pelvic Floor Distress
Inventory (PFDI) was administered at baseline and after completion of
3 months with each pessary. The urinary scale of the PDFI is divided
into 3 subscales: Obstructive/Discomfort, Irritative, and Stress. For this
sub-analysis we evaluated pessary effects on urinary symptoms by
comparing the baseline subscales with the subscales after 3 months of
pessary use. We also calculated the Urinary Distress Inventory score
before and after pessary use. Only patients with complete PFDI data
after 3 months of pessary use were included. All pessary patients were
analyzed as one group. Additionally, analysis was performed
comparing urinary symptoms in subjects using the Gellhorn vs. the
ring with support. Statistical analysis included paired student’s t-test
and McNemar chi-square.
RESULTS: 134 patients were enrolled in the study and 97 patients
completed the first 3 months of the trial and had complete PFDI data.
Of the completers, 68% were White, 14% African-American, 14%
Hispanic and 3% other. The mean age was 62 years (range 30 – 89).
There was a reduction in urinary symptoms from baseline to 3
months: urinary frequency (49% to 38%, p⫽0.04), urgency (54% to
42%, p ⫽ 0.04), leakage with cough (48% to 38%, p ⫽ 0.03). All 3
urinary subscales, as well as the urinary distress inventory, showed
significant reduction in urinary symptoms after 3 months of pessary
use. The Obstructive/Discomfort subscale had a baseline mean value
of 20.32 which improved to 8.61 after 3 months (p⬍ 0.0001). The
Irritative subscale went from an initial mean of 15.85 to 10.59
(p⫽0.0005). The Stress subscale went from a mean of 15.55 to a
mean of 12.24 after pessary use (p ⫽ 0.04). The Urinary Distress
Inventory improved from a mean of 51.31 at baseline to 31.45 (p ⬍
0.0001). There were no significant differences in reduction of urinary
symptoms between subjects with the Gellhorn and ring with support
pessaries.
Conclusion: In subjects with symptomatic pelvic organ prolapse who
complete 3 months of pessary use with the Gellhorn or the ring with
support there is a modest but significant reduction in obstructive,
irritative and stress symptoms. Based on this evidence, pessaries should
be included in the armamentarium of treatments for symptomatic
prolapse patients with lower urinary tract symptoms.
Key Words: prolapse, incontinence, pessary, urinary symptoms
Disclosure - Research: K Strobehn, Duramed, Eli Lilly; Research,
Consultant: C Amundsen, Life Tech, AMS, NDI Medical, Pfizer,
Allergan; Research, Consultant, Advisory Board: GW Cundiff, Cook
Ob/Gyn, Bard, Eli Lilly; Research, Speakers Bureau: JI Schaffer, Cook
Ob/Gyn, Eli Lilly, GSK, Novartis, Yamanouchi; Research, Speakers
Bureau, Consultant, Advisory Board: AE Bent, Eli Lilly, Q-Med Scand,
Cook ObGyn, Gynecare.
ORAL PRESENTATION 19
Randomized Crossover Trial of Ring and Gelhorn Pessaries:
Satisfaction Outcomes
G. W. Cundiff1, C. L. Amundsten2, A. E. Bent3, K. Coates4, and J.
Schaffer5 1Gynecology and Obstetrics, Johns HOpkins School of Medicine,
Baltimore, MD; 2Obstetrics and Gynecology, Duke University Medical
Center, Durham, NC; 3Obstetrics and Gynecology, IWK Health Care,
Halifax, NS, Canada; 4Obtetrics and Gynecology, Scott & White Hospital,
Temple, TX; 5Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Texas Southwestern
Medical Center, Dallas, TX
Objectives: The aim of this randomized crossover trial was to
compare patient satisfaction and symptom relief between the ring
with support and gelhorn pessaries.
Materials and Methods: Subjects were women presenting with
symptomatic pelvic organ prolapse. They were randomized to one
pessary for 3 months. After collection of outcome data, subjects
switched to the other pessary for 3 months. They could quit either
pessary at any time. Outcome data included a visual analog satisfaction
score, and quality of life data using the Pelvic Floor Distress Inventory
Pelvic Floor Impact Questionnaire, and Pelvic Organ Prolapse/Urinary
Incontinence Sexual Function Questionnaire. Analysis included paired
t-test for continuous data, Chi squared for nonparametric and ordinal
data, and logistical regression.
Results: Subjects had a mean age of 61 (30 – 89) and were primarily
white, parous, postmenopausal women with 26% on ERT. The
majority described their lifestyle as active. The median POPQ stage
was 3 (stg 2 ⫽ 48%, stg 3 ⫽ 42%, stg 4 ⫽ 10%). Prior surgeries
included hysterectomy (45%), incontinence surgery (10%), and
prolapse surgery (9%). 134 subjects were enrolled with 63 initially
randomized to a ring and 71 to a gelhorn. 18 subjects could not be
fitted (ring pessary ⫽ 7, gelhorn ⫽ 5, neither 6), and 56 did not
complete one of the 3-month trials. This included 26 who quit the
ring pessary (5 moved to gelhorn, and 21 quit the study, 4 to have
surgery), while 30 quit the gelhorn pessary (10 moved to the ring,
and 20 quit the study, 4 to have surgery). There were an additional 6
subjects lost to follow-up. Subjects who would not wear a pessary for
3 months tended to be younger (57 v. 66, p ⫽ 0.0004) and were less
apt to be white (p ⫽ 0.006). 62 subjects had satisfaction scores for
both pessaries. There was no difference between the mean
satisfaction scores for the ring (6.2, 0 –10, sd 4.05) and gelhorn (6.4,
0 –10, sd 4.09) yet only 22 (35%) had high satisfaction scores with
both pessaries. The 36 (58%) subjects that reported high satisfaction
with the ring pessary tended to be older (p ⫽ 0.036), more parous (p ⫽
0.024), and non-white(p ⫽ 0.001). The 39 (63%) who reported a high
satisfaction score with the gelhorn pessary were less apt to have had a
hysterectomy (p⫽ 0.035) or prior prolapse surgery (p ⫽ 0.014). The
9 (15%) subjects who were not satisfied with either pessary tended to
be white (p ⫽ 0.067), and were more likely to have had prior
prolapse surgery (p ⫽ 0.009). Women with stage II prolapse were
more likely to report dissatisfaction with either pessary (p ⫽ 0.196).
Conclusion: While most women (87%) can be fitted with a pessary,
the majority of women in this trial (55%) did not use a pessary for 3
months and 7% of women were unsatisfied with either pessary. Younger
women and those with prior prolapse surgery are less likely to be
satisfied with a pessary. For those who liked pessaries there were clear
preferences between the ring and gelhorn. Women reporting high
satisfaction with a ring pessary tend to be older and more parous, while
women who report high satisfaction with a gelhorn were those without
a prior hysterectomy or prolapse surgery.
Key Words: pelvic organ prolapse, ring pessary, gelhorn pessary,
PESSRI trial
Disclosure - GW Cundiff, Cook Ob/GYN, Bard, Eli Lilly; Research,
Consultant, Advisory Board: AE Bent, Eli Lilly, Q-Med Scand, Cook
Ob/GYN, Gyncare: JI Schaffer, Cook Ob/GYN, Eli Lilly, GSK, Novartis,
Yamanouchi; Research, Speakers Bureau, Consultant, Advisory Board.
ORAL PRESENTATION 20
Quantification of Levator Ani Cross-Sectional Area Differences
Between Women With and Without Prolapse
Y. Hsu1, L. Chen2, M. Huebner1, J. A. Ashton-Miller2, and J. O. Delancey1
1
Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI;
2
Biomechanical Engineering, Univ. of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
73
FIGURE 1.
Objectives: An ongoing project has established that women with
prolapse are four times more likely to have a major defect detected in
MR imaging in the pubic portion of the levator ani (LA) muscle
compared to women with normal support. Measurement of crosssectional area (CSA) perpendicular to muscle fiber direction is the
preferred estimate of maximal muscle contraction strength. The present
study was undertaken to compare CSA as a function of prolapse status
and defect status in the ventral and dorsal components of the pubic
portion of the levator ani muscle.
Materials and Methods: Thirty women with prolapse were selected
from an ongoing study with 10 having no levator ani defects, 10 minor,
and 10 major defects. The severity of LA defects was established using
MR images and a previously validated visual scoring system. A similar
group of 30 controls with normal support were selected with 10 patients
in each of the three defect status groups. Additionally, groups were ageand parity-matched (mean age: prolapse ⫽ 61.9 ⫾ 1.6 years, controls ⫽
61.3 ⫾ 1.4 years; mean vaginal parity: prolapse ⫽ 2.7 ⫾ 0.3, controls ⫽
3.7 ⫾ 0.4). All patients had pelvic MR scans performed in the supine
position. 3-D models of the levator ani muscles were made using 3-D
slicer (version 2.1b1) using bi-planar reconstruction (axial and coronal) to
reduce partial volume averaging artifacts in individual scan planes. The
pubic portion (which includes the pubovisceralis and the puborectalis
muscles) of the levator ani muscle was isolated from the iliococcygeal
portion. Using I-DEAS®, cross-sections for the pubic portion were
measured perpendicular to a fiber direction line from the pubic origin to
the middle of the visceral insertion at equally spaced points. CSA from
the ventral and dorsal components of the muscle were analyzed separately. One-way analysis of variance was performed.
Results: In the ventral component of the muscle, women with major
LA defects had 37% smaller CSA and women with minor LA defects
had a 30% smaller CSA compared to women with no defects
regardless of prolapse status (F2,57 ⫽ 9.579, p ⬍ 0.001). In the dorsal
component of the muscle, there were significant differences in CSA
found according to defect status (F2,57 ⫽ 5.53, p ⫽ 0.01). Women
with major LA defects had the largest CSA compared to the other
defect groups (Fig. 1). For each defect severity level (none, minor,
major), there were no significant differences in CSA when women
with normal support were compared to women with prolapse.
Conclusion: 1.) Women with visible LA defects on MR imaging had
significantly smaller CSA in the ventral component of the pubic portion
of the muscle compared to women with intact muscles. 2.) Dorsally,
women with prolapse and severe LA defects have larger levator CSA than
women with minor or no defects. Comments: The ventral component of
74
pubic portion of the LA is comprised of the pubovisceralis (which is
known to be damaged during birth); in the dorsal component the
puborectalis predominates. The finding that women with prolapse and
major defects have larger CSA in the dorsal region of the levator ani may
be due to an attempt by the puborectal muscle to compensate for birthinduced ventral muscle loss.
Key Words: pelvic organ prolapse, levator ani muscle defect,
cross-sectional area
Disclosure - Advisory Board: John DeLancey, Eli Lilly; Consultant: John
DeLancey, SuRx, Kimberly Clark, Johnson & Johnson, Gynecare, John
DeLancey, Shaw Science, James Ashton-Miller, Johnson & Johnson,
BioLogic Engineering, Cybernet, James Ashton-Miller, NFL.
ORAL PRESENTATION 21
Effect of Hospital Volume on Operative Outcomes Following
Urogynecologic Procedures
V. W. Sung1, M. L. Rogers2, C. R. Rardin1, and D. L. Myers1 1Obstetrics
and Gynecology, Brown Medical School, Providence, RI; 2Center for
Gerontology and Health Care Research, Brown University,
Providence, RI
Objectives: To estimate the effect of urogynecologic hospital volume
on operative outcomes following urogynecologic procedures.
Materials and Methods: We conducted a retrospective cohort study
utilizing data from the Nationwide Inpatient Sample from 1998 –2003.
Urogynecologic cases were identified using urogynecologic ICD-9-CM
procedure-diagnosis code combinations. Hospital volume was expressed
as the average number of urogynecologic cases per year. Hospitals were
ranked by volume and then categorized into three groups: low, medium
and high volume. These groups were defined by choosing cutoff points
for annual hospital volume that most closely sorted the number of
patients into three equal groups. Cut-off points were established
before outcomes were examined. Outcome measures included inhospital mortality, peri-operative complications, and non-routine
discharges, defined as patients who were not directly discharged
home. Patient and hospital characteristics were abstracted from the
database. To adjust for case-mix, comorbidities were compiled into a
weighted index based on the Dartmouth-Manitoba method.
Descriptive statistics and univariate analyses were performed as
appropriate. Multivariable logistic regression was performed to obtain
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
TABLE 1. Adjusted Odds Ratios (95% CI) for the Effect Of Hospital Volume on
Outcomes Following Urogynecologic Procedures, Oral Presentation 21
Outcome
Death
Complication
Non-routine
discharge
Low volume
Hospital volume
Medium volume
High volume*
1.77 (1.04, 3.02)
1.06 (1.03, 1.10)
1.60 (1.40, 1.85)
1.08 (0.62, 1.88)
1.03 (0.99, 1.10)
1.17 (1.05, 1.29)
1.00
1.00
1.00
Adjusted for age, race, number of procedures, comorbidity, and hospital characteristics
using multivariable logistic regression.
*Reference group.
adjusted odds ratios estimating the relative risks of death,
complication, and non-routine discharge by hospital volume, adjusting
for confounders.
Results: There were 315,035 women in our study population and
2,569 hospitals. Overall in-hospital mortality risk was 0.04%, complication risk was 14.4%, and non-routine discharge risk was 1.0%.
Low-volume hospitals (LVH) performed ⬍92 cases/year, mediumvolume hospitals (MVH) performed 92–185 cases/year, and highvolume hospitals (HVH) performed ⬎185 cases/year. Mortality risk
decreased with increasing hospital volume (LVH, 0.02%; MVH, 0.01%;
HVH, 0.01%; p ⬍ 0.05). This inverse relationship was also observed
for complications (p ⬍ 0.01) and non-routine discharges (p ⬍ 0.01).
After adjusting for potential confounders, LVHs were associated with
an increased risk of death 关LVH, OR 1.77 (1.04, 3.02); MVH, OR 1.08
(0.62, 1.88)兴 compared to HVHs. Low-volume hospitals were also
associated with an increased risk of complications 关LVH, OR 1.06
(1.03, 1.10); MVH, OR 1.03 (0.99, 1.10) and non-routine discharges
关LVH, OR 1.60 (1.40, 1.85); MVH, OR 1.17 (1.05, 1.29)兴 compared to
HVHs.
Conclusion: The overall risks following urogynecologic procedures
are low. However, differences in hospital volume of urogynecologic
procedures may contribute to variations in mortality and morbidity
risks.
Key Words: pelvic floor disorders, morbidity, mortality, hospital
volume, urogynecologic surgery
Disclosure - Consultant: Charles R. Rardin, Gynecare; Speaker Bureau:
Charles R. Rardin, Pfizer, Charles R. Rardin, Novartis.
ORAL PRESENTATION 22
Neuropathic Injury to the Levator Ani Occurs in 1 in 4
Primiparous Women
A. C. Weidner1, V. Branham1, M. M. South1, K. L. Borawski2, and A. A.
Romero1 1OBGYN, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC;
2
Urology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC
Objectives: We measured levator ani neuromuscular function before
and after the first obstetric delivery to identify the location, timing,
and mechanism of injury.
Materials and Methods: Fifty eight primiparous women recruited in
the early third trimester underwent concentric needle electromyographic (EMG) exam of the levator ani at four sites (right and left,
lateral and medial) during voluntary muscle contraction. Exams were
repeated 6 weeks and 6 months post partum. Data were saved
digitally and analyzed using a quantitative EMG analysis program to
assess muscle function at rest, moderate, and maximal contraction.
Turns/amplitude analysis was used, measuring the relationship
between density of the muscle recruitment pattern (represented by
electrical turns in direction around the baseline) and amplitude of the
motor unit potentials in V. This method yielded an XY plot of
number of turns vs. log(amplitude) as previously described.1
Turns/amplitude data from all 58 subjects at the antepartum visit were
pooled to create a normal range through the full muscle effort from
rest to maximum contraction. Individual subjects with ⱖ10% of
observed data points outside 95% confidence intervals of the normal
range were considered abnormal. We calculated percent outliers for
each subject at both 6 weeks and 6 months post partum at each
muscle site and assessed relationships between mode of delivery and
extent of injury. Appropriate obstetrical and demographic data were
collected.
Results: Of the 58 subjects, 36 had spontaneous vaginal delivery, 8
operative vaginal delivery, 11 cesarean sections in labor, and 3
elective cesareans without labor. Forty one self identified as
Caucasian, 11 African American, and 6 Hispanic or Asian. Body mass
index at 6 months post partum was 26 ⫾ 5.6 kg/m2. Neonatal weight
was 3337 ⫾ 590 g. At 6 weeks post partum, 14/58 (24.1%) had EMG
evidence of abnormal muscle function with 9 of 14 recovering by 6
months. At 6 months post partum, 17/58 (29.3%) were abnormal,
including 12 new injuries that were not evident at 6 weeks. Subjects
having cesarean in labor had the greatest proportion of levator injury
at 6 weeks, while subjects having vaginal delivery had a slightly
greater proportion of injury at 6 months. Subjects having elective
cesarean had virtually no injury. Analysis by muscle site showed injury
across all sites. Women who had either spontaneous vaginal delivery
or cesarean in labor sustained more injury to lateral muscle sites,
whereas operative vaginal delivery was associated with greater injury
to the medial muscle, particularly on the right.
Conclusion: Obstetrical delivery is frequently associated with EMG
evidence of neuropathic injury to the levator ani both in the early and
late post partum period. While some spontaneous recovery occurs,
new observations of abnormal muscle at 6 months are consistent with
the established mechanism of recovery from a neuropathic injury and
emphasize the lengthy time course of muscle repair. Our observed
localization of injury indicates that the entire levator ani complex is at
risk and that cesarean in labor is not protective.
Key Words: electromyography, levator ani, obstetrical delivery
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
REFERENCE
1. Nandedkar et al. Muscle Nerve 9(5):423– 430.
ORAL PRESENTATION 23
Obesity and Retropubic Surgery for Stress Incontinence: Is There
Really an Increased Risk of Intra-Operative Complications?
R. Rogers1, U. Lebkuechner1, D. N. Kammerer-Doak2, P. K.
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
75
Thompson3, and M. D. Walters4 1University of New Mexico,
Albuquerque, NM; 2Lovelace Sandia Health Systems, Albuquerque,
NM; 3Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX; 4Cleveland Clinic,
Cleveland, OH; 5University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA
Objectives: To evaluate the impact of obesity on length of surgery,
blood loss and intra-operative complications in women who underwent
retropubic surgery for stress urinary incontinence (SUI).
Materials and Methods: Of 449 women participating in a multi
center randomized trial evaluating antibiotic prophylaxis in women
with suprapubic catheters, 250 women underwent retropubic anti
incontinence procedures. This is a prospective nested cohort study of
these women; 79 (32%) of whom were obese (BMI ⬎ 30) and 171
(68%) overweight or normal weight (BMI ⬍ 30). Data collected
included demographic variables, past medical history, physical exam
recording prolapse severity and intraoperative and postoperative
complications. Data were analyzed with Fisher’s Exact for dichotomous
variables, t tests for continuous variables and ANOVA for multivariate
analysis. Significance was set at P ⬍ .05.
Results: Obese women undergoing SUI surgery were younger than
non-obese women (48.7 vs. 51.9 years, respectively, P ⬍ .019), and
Hispanic women were more likely to be obese than all other
ethnicities (P ⫽ 0.005). Severity of anterior, apical or posterior
prolapse was similar between groups. (P ⫽ NS) The number and type
of additional surgeries performed were similar between groups with
the exception that obese women were less likely to undergo
abdominal apical suspensions (P ⫽ .006) or abdominal paravaginal
repairs (P ⫽ .001); therefore all comparisons are adjusted for the
performance of these procedures. Estimated surgical blood loss was
greater for obese women (344 vs. 284 P ⫽ .027) however, change in
hematocrit (preoperative minus postoperative hematocrit) was lower
for obese than non-obese women (6.6 vs 7.3, P ⫽ 0.048). Mean length
of surgery was 20 minutes longer in obese women (P ⫽ 0.024).
Length of hospital stay did not vary between groups. (P ⫽ NS) Major
intraoperative complications were uncommon (14 (6%)) with no
difference between weight groups. Incidence of postoperative urinary
tract infection, wound infections or postoperative major complications
were likewise similar between groups (all P ⬎ .05).
Conclusion: In this nested prospective cohort study, retropubic anti
incontinence surgery did not increase intra-operative risk for obese
patients when compared to non-obese women. Surgery takes longer
for obese patients, but blood loss as recorded by change in hematocrit
is lower. Major complications were rare and similar between weight
groups, as were infectious complications.
The Applied GelPort™ is an advanced access device that combines
the advantages of a self-retaining wound retractor with the benefits and
option of laparoscopy, particularly hand-assisted laparoscopy. A standard
kit is comprised of an incision template, a 100 millimeter GelSeal™ Cap,
a wound retractor base, and an Alexis™ wound retractor.
This technique relies on the presence a mobile, unilocular, and
anteriorly located ovarian cyst. After placing the patient in modified
dorsal lithotomy, a small transverse or vertical 2–3 centimeter suprapubic
incision is made with the aide of the incision template and a scalpel. This
incision is carried all the way through into the peritoneal cavity and the
Alexis™ wound retractor is subsequently placed along with the wound
retractor base. A circular area of self-retraction with superior exposure is
created. Visual and manual inspection of the cyst and pelvis can occur at
this time in addition to obtaining pelvic washings. The area of the ovarian
cyst that is visible through the self-retaining retractor is carefully dried
with a Ray-Tec™. A Tegaderm™ transparent dressing sheet large enough
to cover the entire Alexis™ wound retractor is then secured to the cyst
wall surface with Dermabond™, a sterile surgical glue. A Behrman needle
attached to wall suction is used to puncture and drain the ovarian cyst in
a “leak proof” fashion thereby minimizing the risk of intra-peritoneal
spillage. Once decompressed, the pathologic ovary can be exteriorized
through the mini-laparotomy incision and either an ovarian cystectomy or
salpingo-oophorectomy performed. Should malignancy be encountered
after a frozen section is obtained, the GelSeal™ Cap can be attached to
the Alexis™ wound retractor. The case is then readily converted to a
laparoscopy with the ability to place either a trocar or hand through the
specialized cap.
Results: We have used this advanced access technique in a variety of
cases. Patients were able to undergo either an ovarian cystectomy or
salpingo-oophorectomy through the mini-laparotomy incision as an outpatient when pathology was benign. In cases of malignancy, the Applied
GelPort™ allowed for the conversion to and completion of a laparoscopic staging with the option of hand-assistance.
Conclusion: The use of the Applied GelPort™ advanced access device
allows for the management of large ovarian cysts without compromising
the benefits of minimally invasive surgery or the surgical management of
a malignancy.
Key Words: laparoscopy, surgical technique, ovarian cysts, mini-laparotomy
Disclosure - Advisory Board: Arnold Advincula, SurgRx; Consultant:
Arnold Advincula, Gyrus Medical; Grant/Research Support: Arnold
Advincula, Intuitive Surgical.
Key Words: obesity, stress urinary incontinence, surgery,
complications
Disclosure - Grant/Research Support: Rebecca Rogers, Wyeth, Mark
Walters, Pfiser; Grant/Research support: Rebecca Rogers, Pfiser; Lecturer:
Mark Walters, American Medical Systems.
TIPS & TRICKS 1
A Novel Technique for the Minimally Invasive Management of
Large Ovarian Cysts
A. P. Advincula, W. M. Burke, and R. K. Reynolds Obstetrics & Gynecology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI
Objective: We sought to develop a minimally invasive technique for the
management of large ovarian cysts with a low suspicion for malignancy
and not amenable to laparoscopy by using the Applied GelPort™.
Materials and Methods: The management of large ovarian cysts (⬎10
centimeters) by laparoscopy is particularly challenging because of a
limited surgical field and concerns for cyst rupture with intra-peritoneal
spillage. As a result, traditional laparotomy continues to be considered
the standard despite the vast majority of these returning benign on
final pathology.
76
TIPS & TRICKS 2
Teaching Salpingo-Oophorectomy With Vaginal Hysterectomy
P. A. Riss Gynecology & Obstetrics, Landesklinikum Thermenregion
Moedling, Moedling, Austria
Objective: To improve the teaching and performance of salpingooophorectomy at the time of vaginal hysterectomy, using a step-bystep approach based on optimal exposure.
Description: (for the left side).
Step 1
The uterus has been removed. The assistant places traction on the
ovarian pedicles and on the stay suture at the posterior peritoneum
and vaginal fornix.
Step 2
The surgeon places a pack (10 x 30 cm) at 3 o’clock, pushing it
upward towards the pelvic brim along the infundibulopelvic ligament.
Step 3
A long Breisky retractor (3 x 15 cm) is inserted between the pack and
the adnexae. The Breisky blade retracts the small bowel medially and
upward to expose the adnexae.
Step 4
A second, smaller and shorter Breisky (2.5 x 11 cm) is introduced on
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
top of the first Breisky, and is rotated clockwise.
Step 5
The adnexae are grasped with a ring forceps and pulled downwards
and medially. The tip of the anterior Breisky rests on the extended
infundbuilopelvic ligament.
Step 6
The ovarian vessels - which lie in the medial part of the extended
infundibulopelvic ligament - are ligated with a Deschamps needle. The tip
of the Deschamps needle is introduced into the avascular triangle formed
by the ovarian vessels medially, the pelvic sidewall laterally, and the
adnexae below. The ureter is safely located at the pelvic sidewall. The
suture is passed, retrieved and tied.
Step 7
The ovarian pedicle is cut below the tie.
Step 8
A curved clamp is placed on the base of the adnexae and this pedicle
is ligated.
Good exposure is achieved with the following maneuvers:
- Intraabdominal placement of a 10 x 30 cm pack which is held
medially with the long Breisky speculum.
- Insertion of the second Breisky.
- Medial and downward traction on the adnexae which are grasped
with ring forceps to pull the ovarian vessels and the supporting
peritoneum medially into the cavity of the small pelvis.
Conclusion: The method presented here emphasizes good exposure
before actually beginning with salpingo-oophorectomy. A step-by-step
approach facilitates teaching and learning of this adjunct to vaginal
hysterectomy.
Key Words: vaginal surgery, adnexectomy, teaching, salpingo-oophorectomy
Disclosure - Eli Lilly, Gynecare: Paul A Riss, Speaker Bureau, Advisory
Board/Eli Lilly-BI.
TIPS & TRICKS 3
Fascia-Synthetic Graft Seam Technique for Sacrocolpopexy
P. M. Fine 1Obstetrics & Gynecology, Baylor College of Medicine,
Houston, TX; 2Urology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX
Objective: The fascia-synthetic graft seam technique is a technical
trick to minimize graft erosion and maximize graft durability in the
performance of sacrocolpopexy. A recent and extensive published
review of the ASC literature cited a 0.5–5% incidence of mesh erosion
with various synthetic materials and no erosions with autologous or
cadaveric fascia.1 Anterior rectus fascia, although easily harvested at
abdominal wall entry, often lacks adequate width or length for
optimum technical placement. Attachment of harvested autologous
abdominal fascia first to the vaginal cuff and then lengthening the
graft by attachment of a synthetic graft using a seam of sutures allows
adequate sacral attachment without tension.
Description: The abdomen is opened with the incision of choice
down to the anterior rectus fascia. A strip of 10 x 2 cm fascia is
harvested and placed in antibiotic solution of choice. The vaginal cuff
is prepared in the standard fashion with opening of the pelvic
peritoneum and dissecting the bladder from the proximal anterior
vaginal wall. Each end of the harvested fascial graft is cut vertically in
the midline about 1.5 cm to create a wider Y shaped configuration for
attachment to the anterior and posterior vaginal walls. Interrupted
permanent sutures of choice attach each end of the, now folded over
on itself, fascial graft to the anterior and posterior vaginal walls and
vaginal cuff. A 2 cm wide piece of synthetic mesh of choice is sutured
to the now proximal (cephalad) elbow of folded fascia with 4 –5
interrupted permanent sutures. These seam sutures penetrate both
folded sheets of fascia and include about 3 mm of fascia to minimize
possibility of pullout. The proximal (cephalad) portion of the synthetic
mesh is trimmed and attached to the sacral promontory with standard
technique of choice. Closure of the peritoneum over the graft is then
performed.
Conclusion: The author has successfully used this technique for
about 25 years in over 100 patients. Because charts from his former
private practice were lost in transfer, storage, or conversion to
electronic medical record by the university, specific detail of followup unfortunately cannot be given. Anecdotally there were no known
vaginal erosions or infectious complications with most patients
followed over 3 years, and some over 15 years. Only a couple of
patients required repeat pelvic reconstructive surgery and none of
these were apical failures. There were no known incisional hernias.
Attachment of harvested autologous abdominal fascia first to the
vaginal cuff and then lengthening the graft by attachment of a synthetic
graft using a seam of sutures has the following advantages: 1) a
shorter length of fascia can be used, 2) allows more flexibility in
length to attach the graft to the sacrum and 3) it eliminates the risk of
erosion if a total (rather than supracervical) hysterectomy is performed or
in the case of thin and atrophic post-hysterectomy vaginal cuff.
Key Words: sacrocolpopexy, autologous rectus fascia, seam technique
Disclosure - Nothing to disclose.
REFERENCE
1. Nygaard et al. Abdominal Sacrocolpopexy: A Comprehensive Review.
Obstet Gynecol Oct 2004;104:805– 823.
ORAL POSTER 1
Impact of Transdermal Oxybutynin on Sexual Function in
Patients With Overactive Bladder: Results From the Matrix
Study
P. K. Sand1, R. Goldberg1, and M. McIlwain2 1Feinberg School of
Medicine, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL; 2Watson Laboratories,
Morristown, NJ
Objectives: This analysis was conducted to assess the impact of
treatment with transdermal oxybutynin on sexual function in patients
with overactive bladder (OAB) in a large, community-based population.
Materials and Methods: The Multicenter Assessment of Transdermal
Therapy in Overactive Bladder with Oxybutynin (MATRIX) study was a
cohort analysis trial of community-dwelling adults diagnosed with
overactive bladder (OAB). Patients were treated with transdermal
oxybutynin for up to 6 months and evaluated for safety and patientreported outcomes. The King’s Health Questionnaire® (KHQ) and Beck
Depression Inventory®-II (BDI-II) were used to assess OAB impact on
patients’ interest in sexual intimacy. The KHQ, a quality of life instrument
specific to OAB, is scored from 0 (best) to 100 (worst), while the BDI-II,
which measures depression symptoms, is scored from 0 (best) to 63
(worst), with scores ⬎12 indicating clinical depression. P values were
based on chi-squared test.
Results: The MATRIX study enrolled 2878 patients (mean age, 62.5y ⫾
14.8y; 2508 关87.1%兴 women, 2406 关83.6%兴 Caucasian). At baseline,
1334 patients (46.4%) reported experiencing OAB symptoms for ⱖ4
years, while 346 patients (12.0%) had experienced symptoms for ⱕ1
year. Of 2859 patients who responded, 1632 (57.1%) had been treated
before for OAB. At baseline, KHQ responses indicated that 1845/2571
(71.8%) were embarrassed by their bladder problems. In 586/2534
(23.1%) patients, OAB affected their sex life; in 622/2555 (24.4%),
OAB affected their relationships with their partners. Baseline
responses to the BDI-II indicated that 1219/2341 (52.1%) patients
experienced decreased interest in sex: 589 (25.2%) less interest, 228
(9.7%) much less interest, 402 (17.2%) complete loss of interest. By
end of study, paired patient responses showed significant (P ⬍ .0001)
improvement in embarrassment (828/2330 关35.5%兴 improved; 235
关10.1%兴 worsened), in OAB effects on sex life (429/2250 关19.1%兴
improved; 251 关11.2%兴 worsened), in relationships with partners
(444/2269 关19.6%兴 improved; 271 关11.9%兴 worsened), and in interest
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006
77
in sex (472/2018 关23.4%兴 improved; 246 关12.2%兴 worsened). Patients
reported significant (P ⬍ .0001) improvement from baseline to end of
study in symptoms that may impact sexual intimacy. Intercourse incontinence, experienced by 569/2493 (22.8%) patients at baseline,
improved in 277/2190 patients (12.6%) and worsened in 165 (7.5%).
Frequent UTIs, 931/2467 (37.7%) at baseline, improved in 450/2164
patients (20.8%) and worsened in 242 (11.2%). Bladder pain, experienced
by 1092/2505 (43.6%) patients at baseline, improved in 553/2211 (25.0%)
and worsened in 240 (10.9%).
Disclosure - Advisory Board: Karl Tamussino, Lilly Boehringer; Consultant: Karl Tamussino, Gynecare.
Conclusion: The degree to which OAB symptoms affect sexual
function may be influenced by physiologic, psychosocial, or socioeconomic factors, in addition to disease severity. Specific bladder
symptoms may cause embarrassment and a resultant decrease in
sexual interest. Many of these sexual function symptoms significantly
improved in patients who were treated for up to 6 months with
transdermal oxybutynin in this study.
S. Minaglia1, B. Ozel1, N. M. Gatto2, D. R. Mishell1, Jr., and D. A.
Miller1 1Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Southern California,
LosAngeles, CA; 2Preventive Medicine, University of Southern California,
Los Angeles, CA
Key Words: incontinence, urinary incontinence, sexual function, oxybutynin, urge incontinence, quality of life
Disclosure - Consultant, Advisory Board: Peter Sand, Watson Pharma,
Inc; employee: Marilyn McIlwain, Watson Laboratories.
ORAL POSTER 2
Quality of Life and Continence One Year After the Tension-Free
Vaginal Tape (TVT) Operation
V. Bjelic-Radisic, M. Dorfer, E. Greimel, A. Frudinger, P. Kern, and K.
Tamussino OB/GYN, Medical University of Graz, Graz, Austria
Objectives: To evaluate changes in quality of life (QoL) and
continence rates one year after the Tension-free vaginal tape (TVT)
operation.
Materials and Methods: We evaluated clinical outcomes and quality
of life in 95 of 116 consecutive patients who underwent a retropubic
TVT procedure (Gynecare) between May 2002 and June 2004. Before
and 12 months after surgery patients underwent clinical assessment
with cystometry and urethral profilometry and completed Germanlanguage versions of the Kings Health questionnaire and the SF-36. 47
(50%) of women had undergone previous surgery for incontinence or
prolapse. 66 (74%) TVTs were performed as isolated procedures, 29
(26%) with concomitant operations. Cronbachs alpha coefficients
were calculated for KHQ subscales. Scale responsiveness was
examined by comparing mean differences in the KHQ domains before
and after treatment in relationship to the results of the cough stress
test.
Results: Overall the objective continence rate at 1 year was 82% and
did not differ significantly between women undergoing TVT alone or
in combination (84% vs. 68%, respectively). Significant improvements
were seen in the following domains of the KHQ: incontinence impact,
role limitations, physical limitations, emotions, severity measures and
overactive bladder; no significant changes were seen in the domains
general health perception, social limitations, personal relationships
and sleep/energy. Similar but less prononced improvements in QOL
were seen in women with no change or worsening of continence
postoperatively. The SF-36 showed changes only in the domain
general health.
Conclusion: The TVT operation is associated with improved conditionspecific QOL in women with stress urinary incontinence. Changes in
QOL do not necessarily correlate with the objective continence status of
continent/incontinent. The condition-specific KHQ is more appropriate
than the generic SF-36 for evaluating treatment results in women treated
for stress incontinence. Apparently urinary incontinence can be perceived as a nuisance rather than as as an illness.
Key Words: stress incontinence, tension-free vaginal tape, quality of
life
78
ORAL POSTER 3
Decreased Rate of Obstetrical Anal Sphincter Laceration
Reflects Change in Obstetric Practice
Objectives: To estimate the rate of obstetrical anal sphincter laceration in a large cohort of women undergoing vaginal delivery and to
identify characteristics associated with this complication, including
modifiable risk factors.
Materials and Methods: Information from a computerized database
that included all deliveries occurring between January 4, 1996 and
December 8, 2004 at one institution was used to calculate the rate of
anal sphincter laceration as well as to compare women with and
without an anal sphincter laceration at vaginal delivery. T-tests and
chi-square tests were used to identify factors associated with anal
sphincter laceration including maternal age, gestational age, birth
weight, vacuum or forceps delivery, episiotomy, estimated blood loss
at delivery, presence of shoulder dystocia, use of epidural anesthesia,
and use of oxytocin. Generalized estimating equations were used to
identify significant independent risk factors for anal sphincter lacerations
as well as estimate odds ratios associated with each factor while
accounting for repeated measures in women with multiple births at the
hospital.
Results: Mean age (SD) years was 27.1 (6.5), and the women were
87.7% Hispanic, 6.1% African American, 3.2% Asian Pacific Islander,
2.7% Caucasian, and 0.03% other or unknown. 1,703 (10.2%) third
and fourth-degree lacerations occurred among 16,667 vaginal deliveries: 857 (17.5%) occurred among 4891 primiparas and 846 (7.2%)
occurred among 11,776 multiparas. All factors considered were
individually significant predictors of anal sphincter lacerations at p ⬍
0.0001. Women with an anal sphincter laceration were significantly
more likely to have a fetus of higher gestational age or increased birth
weight. Results from regression models suggested that episiotomy (OR
1.35; 95% CI 1.16, 1.57), vacuum delivery (OR 3.20; 95% CI 2.70,
3.80), and forceps delivery (OR 2.79; 95% CI 1.94, 4.02) were all
associated with increased risk of anal sphincter laceration. Increasing
parity (OR 0.64; 95% CI 0.61, 0.68) and use of epidural anesthesia (OR
0.86; 95% CI 0.76, 0.97) each demonstrated a protective effect. Year
of delivery was also associated with a decreased risk of anal sphincter
laceration (OR 0.94; 95% CI 0.91, 0.96) with the rate of laceration
decreasing from 11.2% to 1.1% during the study period.
Conclusion: This report demonstrates a high rate of anal sphincter
laceration in a predominantly Hispanic population. Episiotomy and
operative vaginal delivery are significant, modifiable risk factors for
obstetrical anal sphincter laceration. Changes in obstetric practice
such as increased cesarean delivery and decreased episiotomy may
have contributed to the dramatic reduction in anal sphincter laceration during the study period.
Key Words: fecal incontinence, obstetrical anal sphincter laceration,
cesarean section, vacuum delivery, forceps delivery, episiotomy
Disclosure - Advisory Board: Daniel R. Mishell, Jr., Barr, Organon; Advisory
Board, Speaker Bureau: Steven Minaglia, OrthoMcNeil; Consultant: Steven
Minaglia, American Medical Systems, Daniel R. Mishell, Jr., Pfizer; Research
Support, Advisory Board: Daniel R. Mishell, Jr., Berlex; Speaker Bureau:
Steven Minaglia, Pfizer.
Journal of Pelvic Medicine & Surgery • Volume 12, Number 2, March/April 2006