INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Development of nutritious snacks by incorporation of amaranth seeds, watermelon
seeds and their flour
Paul Virginia, Ruchi, Paul Ajit
Department of Foods and Nutrition, Ethelind School of Home Science, Sam Higginbottom Institute of Agriculture,
Technology and Sciences, Allahabad – 211007 (U.P.) India.
Abstract
Introduction
Methodology
Results
Conclusion
References
Citation
Tables / Figures
Corresponding Author
Address for Correspondence: Paul Virginia, Department of Foods and Nutrition, Ethelind School of Home
Science, Sam Higginbottom Institute of Agriculture, Technology and Sciences, Allahabad – 211007 (U.P.) India.
E Mail ID: vpaul17@gmail.com
Citation
Virginia P, Ruchi, Ajit P. Development of nutritious snacks by incorporation of amaranth seeds, watermelon
seeds and their flour. Indian J Comm Health. 2014;26, Suppl S1:93-94
Source of Funding : Nil Conflict of Interest: None declared
Abstract
The present study was carried out with the objectives to find out the sensory acceptability, the nutrient content
and cost of prepared products. The products prepared were “Biscuits”, “Mathri” and “Laddoo” by incorporation
of amaranth seeds, watermelon seeds and their flour in different proportions (10:10, 20:10, and 30:10) served as
treatments T1, T2 and T3 respectively T0, without incorporation of amaranth seeds, watermelon seeds and their
flour served as control. The products were organoleptically evaluated by using Nine point Hedonic scale. The data
obtained during study were analyzed statistically using analysis of variance and C.D techniques. The prepared
products were analyzed for nutrient content using the standard method of AOAC (2005).It was concluded that in
case of “Biscuits” and “Mathri” with incorporation level 20 percent amaranth seeds flour and 10 percent
watermelon seeds flour scored highest while in case of “Laddoo” with incorporation level 20 percent amaranth
seeds and 10 percent watermelon seeds scored highest, with regard to colour and appearance, body and texture,
taste and flavour and over all acceptability, However all the treatments were found to be acceptable. It is therefore
concluded that amaranth seeds and watermelon seeds can be suitably incorporated in various developed
products. “Laddoo” had maximum carbohydrate (64.49g/100g), protein (13.59g/100g) calcium (100.1mg/100g)
and iron (3.33mg/100g) content. The content of Protein (14.46g/100g), carbohydrate (59.90) Calcium
(59.90mg/100g), were increased as compared to control in “Biscuits”. “Mathri” was rich in Protein, Fat,
carbohydrate and calcium content (11.10g/100g, 38.56g/100g, 38.83g/100g, and 53.95mg/100g). Cost of products
on the basis raw ingredients per 100g ranged between Rs 6.33-12.45 for “Biscuits”, Rs 16.06-30.07, Rs 12.27-18.19
for “Mathri” and Rs.6.42-12.26 for “Laddoo”. On the basis of findings it is concluded that amaranth seeds,
watermelon seeds and their flour can be incorporated in the preparation of different products as well as improve
their nutritional composition.
Key Words
Nutrition; Organoleptically
countries. In India 44% of children under the age of
5 are underweight. 72% of infants and 52% of
married women have anaemia. Amaranth is good
source of protein, soluble fibre, calcium, iron,
magnesium, zinc, vitamin A, C and several B vitamins.
It contains about four times as much calcium as
wheat and twice as much iron and magnesium.
Flavonoids (such as rutin and some phenolic acids as
gallic acid, p-Hydroxybenzoic acid and vanillic acid)
Introduction
The prevalence of underweight children in India is
among the highest in the world, and is nearly double
that of Sub-Saharan Africa with dire consequences
for mobility, mortality, productivity and economic
growth. Almost all the hungry people, 852 million,
live in developing countries, representing 15 percent
of the population of developing countries. There are
16 million people undernourished in developed
93
INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
with anti-oxidant effects also occur in amaranth
seedssand sprouts. Amaranth is gluten-free and easy
to digest. The health benefits attributed to amaranth
include decreasing plasma cholesterol levels
protecting the heart, stimulating the immune
system, exerting an anti-cancer activity, reducing
blood glucose levels and improving conditions of
hypertension and anaemia. In addition, it has been
reported to possess anti-allergic and anti-oxidant
properties. The most common use of amaranth grain
is grinding it into flour, or popped in a similar way to
popcorn or used as flakes. The flour is commonly
used in cereals, pastas, pancakes, crackers, breads,
cookies and other baked goods, and can be
combined with other types of flours. Nutritive value
of Amaranth seeds (100g) consists of Energy
319kcal, Protein 14.7g, Fat 1.9 g, Carbohydrate
60.7g, Calcium 510mg, Phosphorus 397mg, Iron
11.0mg,Minerals 3.1g,Moisture 10.0g,Crude Fibre
9.6g, (Gopalan et al.2007). Watermelon seeds are
very high in protein; it consists of nine essential
amino acids, including tryptophan, glutamic acid,
and lysine. The seeds are low in carbohydrate but
high in calories, so roasted watermelon seeds can be
a good choice for supporting athletes activities.
Watermelon seeds are also loaded with several of
the B vitamins like thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, vitamin
B6 and pantothenic acid, which are necessary for
converting food into energy and other important
bodily functions. The most prevalent B vitamin in
watermelon seeds is niacin. Niacin is important for
maintaining the nervous system, digestive system
and promotes skin health. Magnesium is the most
abundant mineral. It helps regulate blood pressure.
Other important minerals in watermelon seeds are
phosphorous, iron, potassium, sodium, copper,
manganese and zinc. Iron is a vital nutrient your body
needs for proper oxygen delivery throughout your
body and cell growth. It also contains saturated fat,
monounsaturated fats, polyunsaturated fats, and
omega-6 fatty acids which can help in the reduction
of high blood pressure. Polyunsaturated fats may
help improve your cholesterol levels and reduce your
risk of both heart disease and type 2 diabetes.
Watermelon seeds are effective in recovering health
after illness and sharpening your memory Nutritive
value of Water melon seeds (100g) Energy 628kcal,
Protein 34.1g, Fat 52.6 g, Carbohydrate 4.5g,
Calcium 100mg, Phosphorus 937mg, Iron
7.4mg,Minerals 3.7g,Moisture 4.3g,Crude Fiber 0.8g,
(Gopalan et al.2007).Globally, wheat is the leading
source of vegetable protein in human food, having a
higher protein content than other major cereals,
maize (corn) or rice. The whole grain can be milled to
leave just the endosperm for white flour. The byproducts of this are bran and germ. The whole grain
is a concentrated source of vitamins, minerals, and
protein, while the refined grain is mostly starch. Raw
wheat can be ground into flour or, using hard durum
wheat only, can be ground into semolina;
germinated and dried creating malt; crushed or cut
into cracked wheat; parboiled (or steamed), dried,
crushed and de-branned into bulgur also known as
groats. Wheat is a major ingredient in such foods as
bread, porridge, crackers, “Biscuits”, Muesli,
pancakes, pies, pastries, cakes, cookies, muffins,
rolls, doughnuts, gravy, boza (a fermented
beverage), and breakfast cereals (e.g., Wheatena,
Cream of Wheat, Shredded Wheat, and Wheaties).
Nutritive value of wheat flour (100g) Energy 348kcal,
Protein 11.0g, Fat 0.9g, Carbohydrate 73.9g, Calcium
23mg, Phosphorus 121mg, Iron 2.7mg, (Gopalan et
al.(2007). In a country like India, with increasing
development and commercialization people are
concentrating more on snack rather than regular
meals, reason being they can be easily prepared
without taking much time and are equally filling. The
present topic is chosen keeping in mind the
enhancement of nutritional value of these snacks. In
India protein energy malnutrition is the major
nutritional problem among children, and women
with lower socio economic group have the deficiency
of iron, calcium and magnesium. Calcium deficiency
is more common in women after menopause. So for
reducing malnutrition and minerals deficiency, one
method is best that is the use of unconventional
seeds and cereal like grains as a source of protein and
minerals.
Aims & Objectives
Objectives were to develop and standardize recipes
by incorporation of amaranth seeds, watermelon
seeds and their flour, to find out the sensory
acceptability and to determine the nutrient content
and cost of the prepared products.
Material and Methods
The study was conducted in the Nutrition Research
Laboratory, Department of Foods and Nutrition,
Ethelind School of Home science, Sam Higginbottom
Institute of Agriculture, Technology & Sciences,
(Deemed to be University), (Formerly Allahabad
Agricultural Institute) Allahabad. Wheat, water
94
INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
melon seeds, amaranth seeds of mix flour and other
raw materials was purchased from the local market
of Allahabad, U.P. The standard procedure was
slightly modified for the preparation of amaranth
seeds flour and watermelon seed flour was followed
as per the Muyonga et al. (2008) and Ubbor and
Akobundu, 2009 respectively. Three food products
(“Biscuits”, “Mathri”and “Laddoo”) were prepared
with the incorporation of amaranth seeds,
watermelon seeds and their flour.For each product,
the basic recipe (control T0) had three variations, T1,
T2, T3 respectively, where the amount of one or
more ingredients was varied.
Details of treatments
(1) “Biscuits” -:Control (T0): “Biscuits” prepared from
wheat flour refined.Treatment (T1): “Biscuits”
prepared from mixture of wheat flour refined,
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour in
the ratio of 80:10:10.Treatment (T2): “Biscuits”
prepared from mixture of wheat flour refined,
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour in
the ratio of 70:20:10.Treatment (T3): “Biscuits”
prepared from mixture of wheat flour refined,
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour in
the ratio of 60:30:10.
(2) “Mathri”-:Control (T0): “Mathri” prepared from
wheat flour refined.Treatment (T1): “Mathri”
prepared from mixture of wheat flour refined,
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour in
the ratio of 80:10:10.Treatment (T2): “Mathri”
prepared from mixture of wheat flour refined,
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour in
the ratio of 70:20:10.Treatment (T3): “Mathri”
prepared from mixture of wheat flour refined,
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour in
the ratio of 60:30:10.
(3) “Laddoo”-: Control (T0): “Laddoo” prepared from
semolina. Treatment (T1): “Laddoo” prepared from
mixture of semolina, amaranth seeds and
watermelon seeds in the ratio of 80:10:10.
Treatment (T2): “Laddoo” prepared from mixture of,
semolina, amaranth seeds and watermelon seeds in
the ratio of 70:20:10.Treatment (T3): “Laddoo”
prepared from mixture of semolina, amaranth seeds
and watermelon seeds in the ratio of 60:30:10.
Control and each of the treatments for each product
were replicated three times. Sensory evaluation of
the food products for their acceptability was done by
a panel of judges. The score card based on the 9
point Hedonic Scale was used for sensory evaluation
on the basis of evaluation of attributes like Color and
Appearance, Texture, Taste & Flavour and Overall
Acceptability. (Srilakshmi, 2007). Proximate analysischemical estimation of moisture, ash, protein, fat
and carbohydrate content was done by using
standard procedures. (AOAC, 2005). Calcium and
iron were estimated by AOAC (2005) using standard
procedures. The cost of the products was
determined on the basis of price of raw ingredients
at the prevailing market price.
The data obtained from sensory evaluation were
statistically analyzed by using analysis of variance
technique (one way classification). Significant
difference between the treatments was determined
by using CD (critical difference) techniques and t-test
was used to analyse the data. (Gupta et. al, 2002)
Results & Discussion
The results obtained from the analysis are presented
and discussed under the following sub headings.
A. ORGANOLEPTIC CHARACTERISTICS OF THE
PREPARED PRODUCTS
The table 1 shows the mean scores of “Biscuits” in
relation to colour which indicates that T2 (wheat
flour refined + amaranth seeds flour + watermelon
seeds flour 70:20:10) had the highest score followed
by T0 (wheat flour refined 100), T1 (wheat flour
refined + amaranth seeds flour + watermelon seeds
flour 80:10:10) and T3 (wheat flour refined +
amaranth seeds flour + watermelon seeds flour
60:30:10) respectively. Scoring shows that the
treatment T2 was liked very much while control and
T0, T1, and T3 were moderately liked by the panel of
judges. The texture of “Biscuits” clearly indicates
that the treatment T2 had the highest score for the
texture of “Biscuits” T0, T1 and T3 respectively. The
mean score of “Biscuits” in relation to taste and
flavour was obtained by T0 and T1, T2, T3
respectively indicating that T2 gave the best taste
and flavour to, “Biscuits”. The mean scores of
“Biscuits” in relation to overall acceptability indicate
that the treatment T2 scored maximum followed by
treatment T0.T1 and T3 respectively. It is seen that
addition of 20% amaranth seeds flour and 10%
watermelon seeds flour in the treatment T2
improved overall acceptability of “Biscuits”.
The ANOVA shows that the calculated value of F (62)
was higher than the table value F (4.76) at 5%
probability level. This shows that there is significant
difference between the control and treatments of
colour indicating that the addition of different
proportions of amaranth seeds flour and
95
INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
watermelon seeds flour (10:10, 20:10, 30:10 for T1,
T2, T3 respectively) affect the colour of the prepared
product. The colour of biscuits becomes lightly
darker and more acceptable at the ratio of 20:10 (T2)
whereas the product was not acceptable at the ratio
of 10:10 and 30:10. This shows that there is
significant difference between the control and
treatments of taste and flavour indicating that the
addition of different proportions of amaranth seeds
flour and watermelon seeds flour affect the taste &
flavour of the prepared product, the taste &flavour
becomes delicious and more acceptable as the
amount of amaranth seeds flour and watermelon
seeds flour increases.It is therefore concluded than
the average score for Taste and flavour of “Biscuits”
differs significantly, which may be ascribed to
different ratios of amaranth seeds flour and
watermelon seeds flour in “Biscuits”.The result is
supported by the findings of Singh (2009). The result
obtained showed that the incorporation of bajra and
maize flour up to 15% was acceptable and improved
the taste and flavour of “Biscuits”, but at 20% of
incorporation level bajra flour at high level made the
product crunchy, it may be due to low gluten and
high fiber content. The ANOVA shows that there is
significant difference between the control and
treatments of overall acceptability indicating that
the addition of different proportions of amaranth
seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour affect the
overall acceptability of the prepared product, the
overall acceptability improve and becomes more
acceptable as the amount of amaranth seeds flour
and watermelon seeds flour increases.
On
comparing the average scores for “Biscuits” from
different treatments using critical difference the
variations in the “Biscuits” can seen as the difference
in the mean value of T2, T3 (2.51); was greater than
CD (1.26) therefore the difference was significant.
The difference in the mean value of T1, T3 (1.60); was
greater than CD, (1.26) therefore the difference was
significant. The difference in mean value of T0, T3
(1.47) was greater than CD, (1.26) therefore the
difference was significant. It is therefore concluded
that the average score for overall acceptability of
“Biscuits” differ significantly, which may be ascribed
to different ratios of amaranth seeds flour and
watermelon seeds flour in “Biscuits”. The result is
supported by the findings of Marwein et al., (2010)
wherein the mean scores of drop “Biscuits” in
relation to overall acceptability, which indicate that
the treatment T2 (8.35) scored maximum followed
by treatment T1 and T3 at 8.70 and T0 (7.87)
respectively. So it can be concluded that the addition
of 60% cassava and 10% pumpkin flour improved the
overall acceptability of drop “Biscuits”.
The table 2 shows the mean scores of “Mathri” in
relation to colour which indicates that T2 (wheat
flour refined + amaranth seeds flour + watermelon
seeds flour 70:20:10) had the highest score followed
by T0 (wheat flour refind 100 ), T1 (wheat flour
refined + amaranth seeds flour + watermelon seeds
flour 80:10:10 ) and T3 (wheat flour refined
+amaranth seeds flour + watermelon seeds flour
60:30:10) respectively. Scoring shows that the
treatment T2 was liked very much while control and
T0, T1, and T3 were moderately liked by the panel of
judges.The texture of “Mathri” clearly indicates that
the treatment T2 had the highest score for the
texture of “Mathri” T0, T1 and T3 respectively.The
mean score of “Mathri” in relation to taste and
flavour was obtained by T0 and T1, T2, T3
respectively indicating that T2 gave the best taste
and flavour to, “Mathri”. The mean scores of
“Mathri” in relation to overall acceptability indicate
that the treatment T2 scored maximum followed by
treatment T0.T1 and T3 respectively. It is seen that
addition of 20% amaranth seeds flour and 10%
watermelon seeds flour in the treatment T2
improved overall acceptability of “Mathri”.The result
is supported by the findings of Anu et al. (2007)
prepared Biscuits sweet Biscuits (A) and sweet and
salty Biscuits (B) using the flour of refined wheat,
blanched pearl millet (pennicitium glacicum L.) and
green gram phaseolusaureus) in the ratio of 50
percent, 40 percent, 10 percent (Type 1) and
30:60:10 (Type 2) and control containing 100 percent
refined wheat flour. Both types of Biscuits are liked
very much by the panelist. The ANOVA shows that
the calculated value of F (25.27) was higher than the
table value F (4.76) at 5% probability level. This
shows that there is significant difference between
the control and treatments, colour becomes golden
brown and more acceptable as the amount of
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour
increases. It is therefore concluded that the average
score for colour of “Mathri” differ significantly. The
result is supported by the findings of Singh et al.,
(2009) wherein the difference in the mean value of
(T0 and T3), (T1 and T3), (T1 and T4), (T2 and T3)
were less than C.D. 0.49 therefore the difference was
significant. The ANOVA shows that there is
significant difference between the control and
96
INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
treatments of texture indicating that the addition of
different proportions of amaranth seeds flour and
watermelon seeds flour affect the texture of the
prepared product, the texture becomes crunchy and
more acceptable as the amount of amaranth seeds
flour and watermelon seeds flour increases. On
comparing the average scores for “Mathri” from
different treatments using critical difference. the
variations in the “Mathri” can seen as the difference
in the mean value of T2, T3 (2.27); T2, T1 (0.8) was
greater than CD (0.70) therefore the difference was
significant. The difference in the mean value of T0,
T3 (1.6); was greater than CD (0.70) therefore the
difference was significant. The difference in mean
value of T1, T3 (1.47) was greater than CD, (0.70)
therefore the difference was significant. It is
therefore concluded that the average score for body
and texture of “Mathri” differ significantly, which
may be ascribed to different ratios of amaranth
seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour in “Mathri”.
The result is supported by the findings of Watters
(2007) explained that the defatted peanut, soybean
and field pea flour cover used to replace 10, 20 and
30 percent of the wheat flour in sugar cookies. The
ANOVA shows that there is significant difference
between the control and treatments of taste and
flavour indicating that the addition of different
proportions of amaranth seeds flour and
watermelon seeds flour affect the taste & flavour of
the prepared product, the taste & flavour becomes
salty and more acceptable as the amount of
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour
increases. On comparing the average scores for
“Mathri” from different treatments using critical
difference in table 4.2. (f). The variations in the
“Mathri” can be seen as the difference in the mean
value of T2, T3 (2.27); T2, T1 (0.74) and T2, T0 (0.94)
was greater than CD (0.77) therefore the difference
was significant. It is therefore concluded than the
average score for Taste and flavour of “Mathri”
differs significantly, which may be ascribed to
different ratios of amaranth seeds flour and
watermelon seeds flour in “Mathri” .The ANOVA that
there is significant difference between the control
and treatments of overall acceptability indicating
that the addition of different proportions of
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour
affect the overall acceptability of the prepared
product, the overall acceptability improve and
becomes more acceptable as the amount of
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour
increases. The variations in the “Mathri” can be seen
as the difference in the mean value of T2, T3 (2.45);
T2, T0 (1.07) and T2, T1 (0.85) was greater than CD
(0.58) therefore the difference was significant. The
difference in the mean value of T1, T3 (1.6); was
greater than CD, (0.58) therefore the difference was
significant. The difference in mean value of T0, T3
(1.38) was greater than CD, (0.58) therefore the
difference was significant. It is therefore concluded
that the average score for overall acceptability of
“Mathri” differ significantly, which may be ascribed
to different ratios of amaranth seeds flour and
watermelon seeds flour in “Mathri”. Boobier W.J.
(2007) studied physico- chemical properties and
functional properties of the buckwheat flour had
higher least gelation concentration (32 percent) as
compared to wheat flour (20 percent) the
concentration of buckwheat flour increased, spread
ratio of Biscuits decreased.
The table 3 and Figure 3 shows the mean scores of
“Laddoo” in relation to colour which indicates that
T2 (semolina + amaranth seeds + watermelon seeds
70:20:10) had the highest score followed by T0
(Amaranth seeds 100), T1 (semolina + amaranth
seeds + watermelon seeds 80:10:10 ) and T3
(semolina + amaranth seeds + watermelon seeds
60:30:10) respectively. Scoring shows that the
treatment T2 was liked very much while control and
T0, T1, and T3 were moderately liked by the panel of
judges.The texture of “Laddoo” clearly indicates that
the treatment T2 had the highest score for the
texture of “Laddoo” T0, T1 and T3 respectively.The
mean score of “Laddoo” in relation to taste and
flavour was obtained by T0 and T1, T2, T3
respectively indicating that T2 gave the best taste
and flavour to, “Laddoo”.The mean scores of
“Laddoo” in relation to overall acceptability indicate
that the treatment T2 scored maximum followed by
treatment T0.T1 and T3 respectively. It is seen that
addition of 20% amaranth seeds and 10%
watermelon seeds in the treatment T2 improved
overall acceptability of “Laddoo”. The ANOVAshows
that the calculated value of F (13.63) was higher than
the table value F (4.76) at 5% probability level. This
shows that there is significant difference between
the control and treatments of colour indicating that
the addition of different proportions of amaranth
seeds and watermelon seeds affect the colour of the
prepared product, the colour becomes lightly darker
and more acceptable as the amount of amaranth
seeds and watermelon seeds increases.The result is
97
INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
supported by the findings of Singh et al., (2011). On
comparing the average scores for “Laddoo” from
different treatments using critical difference it was
found that the variations in the “Laddoo” can be
seen as the difference in the mean value of T2 T3
(2.27); T2,T1 (1.2); T2,T0 (1.4) was greater than CD
(0.30) therefore the difference was significant. The
difference in the mean value of T0, T3 (0.87); was
greater than CD, (0.30) therefore the difference was
significant. The difference in mean value of T1, T3
(1.07) was greater than CD, (0.30) therefore the
difference was significant. It is therefore concluded
that the average score for overall acceptability of
“Laddoo” differ significantly, which may be ascribed
to different ratios of amaranth seeds and
watermelon seeds in “Laddoo”. The ANOVA shows
that the calculated value of F (52.4) was higher than
the table value F (4.76) at 5% probability level. This
shows that there is significant difference between
the control and treatments of texture indicating that
the addition of different proportions of amaranth
seeds and watermelon seeds affect the texture of
the prepared product, the texture becomes fragile
and more acceptable as the amount of amaranth
seeds and watermelon seeds increases.On
comparing the average scores for “Laddoo” from
different treatments using critical difference the
variations in the “Laddoo” can be seen as follows The
difference in the mean value of T2, T3 (2.27); T2, T1
(1); T2, T0 (1.33) was greater than CD (0.44)
therefore the difference was significant. The
difference in the mean value of T0, T3 (0.94); was
greater than CD, (0.44) therefore the difference was
significant. The difference in mean value of T1, T3
(1.27) was greater than CD, (0.44) therefore the
difference was significant. It is therefore concluded
that the average score for texture of “Laddoo” differ
significantly, which may be ascribed to different
ratios of amaranth seeds and watermelon seeds in
“Laddoo”. The result is supported by the findings of
Singh et al., (2011). The result obtained showed that
the calculated value of F (2.67) was higher than the
table value of F (3.01) at 5% probability level. It
indicates that the treatment have significant
influence on the texture of “Laddoo” from mahua
flower flour, soya and wheat flour. The ANOVA table
4.3. (e) Shows that the calculated value of F (28.5)
was higher than the table value F (4.76) at 5%
probability level. This shows that there is significant
difference between the control and treatments of
taste and flavour indicating that the addition of
different proportions of amaranth seeds and
watermelon seeds affect the taste & flavour of the
prepared product, the taste & flavour becomes
delicious and more acceptable as the amount of
amaranth seeds and watermelon seeds increases.
On comparing the average scores for “Laddoo” from
different treatments using critical difference in table
4.3. (f). the variations in the “Laddoo” can be seen as
the difference in the mean value of T2, T3 (2.34); T2,
T1 (1.07); T2,T0 (1.54) was greater than CD (0.63)
therefore the difference was significant. The
difference in the mean value of T0, T3 (0.8); was
greater than CD, (0.63) therefore the difference was
significant. The difference in mean value of T1, T3
(1.27) was greater than CD, (0.63) therefore the
difference was significant. It is therefore concluded
that the average score for taste and flavour of
“Laddoo” differ significantly, which may be ascribed
to different ratios of amaranth seeds and
watermelon seeds in “Laddoo”. The ANOVA shows
that the calculated value of F (42.35) was higher than
the table value F (4.76) at 5% probability level. This
shows that there is significant difference between
the control and treatments of overall acceptability
indicating that the addition of different proportions
of amaranth seeds and watermelon seeds affect the
overall acceptability of the prepared product, the
overall acceptability improve and becomes more
acceptable as the amount of amaranth seeds and
watermelon seeds increases.On comparing the
average scores for “Laddoo” from different
treatments using critical difference. The variations in
the “Laddoo” can be seen as the difference in the
mean value of T2, T3 (2.32); T2, T1 (1.09); T2, T0
(1.41) was greater than CD (0.50) therefore the
difference was significant. The difference in the
mean value of T0, T3 (0.90); was greater than CD,
(0.50) therefore the difference was significant. The
difference in mean value of T1, T3 (1.23) was greater
than CD, (0.50) therefore the difference was
significant.It is therefore concluded that the average
score for overall acceptability of “Laddoo” differ
significantly, which may be ascribed to different
ratios of amaranth seeds and watermelon seeds in
“Laddoo”.
B. AVERAGE NUTRIENT CONTENT OF PREPARED
PRODUCTS
On the basis of sensory evaluation the best
treatment from each treatment of prepared i.e.
Treatment T2 with wheat flour refined or semolina,
amaranth seeds or its flour, and watermelon seeds
98
INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
or its flour in the ratio of 70:20:10 were identified
and chemical analysis of those treatments T0 and T2
were carried out with the reference of ash, moisture,
protein, fat, carbohydrate, calcium, and iron
content.
Table 4 shows the nutrient concentration per 100g
of the product. This shows that the moisture content
of biscuits T0 (4.6) was high in comparison to, T2
(4.5). The ash content of T0 (2.73) was high in
comparison to, T2 (2.47). The protein content of T2
(14.46) was high in comparison to, T0 (7.2). Fat
content of T2 (25.67) was high in comparison to, T0
(20.79). Calcium content of T2 (59.90) was high in
comparison to, T0 (17.43). Iron content of T2 (5.01)
was high in comparison to, T0 (1.90). Carbohydrate
content of T0 (63.21) was high in comparison to, T2
(59.90). The fat, protein, calcium, and iron content
was increased in T2 as compared to T0, this is due to
addition of amaranth seeds flour and watermelon
seeds flour in treatment T2. The result is supported
by the findings of Sampaio et al. (2009) Moisture
adsorption isotherms from a new “Biscuits”
considered as functional food were determined
using a gravimetric static method at 25 and 40C and
over a range of relative humidity from 0.112 to
0.903. The “Biscuits” had 2.5, 3.3, 10.0 and 31.0% of
ash, fiber, protein and fat, respectively, and 4.7%
moisture content. The equilibrium moisture content
of the “Biscuits” (kg/kg) increased when the storage
temperature at any given water activity (Aw) was
reduced. The experimental data were analyzed using
different models, namely Guggenheim–Anderson–
de Boer (GAB) (three-parameter relationships),
Henderson and Oswin (both models with two
parameters), which exhibited a sigmoid shape at the
studied temperatures. The maximum isosteric heat
of sorption was 21.6 kJ/mol, which exponentially
decreased when the moisture content was
increased. The GAB model was found to be the most
suitable for describing the adsorption characteristics
at the temperature and Aw range studied, according
to the relative error and the coefficient
determination. In Mathari the moisture content of
T0 (5.99) was high in comparison to, T2 (5.76). The
ash content of T2 (3.37) was high in comparison to,
T0 (3.36). The protein content of T2 (11.10) was high
in comparison to, T0 (8.63). Fat content of T2 (38.56)
was high in comparison to, T0 (29.56). Calcium
content of T2 (53.95) was high in comparison to, T0
(17.34). Iron content of T2 (3.82) was high in
comparison to, T0 (1.5). Carbohydrate content of T2
(38.83) was high in comparison to, T0 (50.27). The
protein, fat, calcium and iron content was increased
in T2 as compared to T0, this is due to addition of
amaranth seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour in
treatment T2. The result is supported by the findings
of John H. Muyonga et al. (2008) reported that
amaranth grains are high in protein and the proteins
are of high quality. The grains are also rich in
unsaturated fatty acids, especially linoleic acid, and
contain
substantial
levels
of
essential
micronutrients. Grain amaranth was also found to
make acceptable soups, fried and baked products.
Feeding trials so far show that grain amaranth leads
to improved growth among children. The moisture
content of laddo T2 (6.66) was high in comparison to,
T0 (5.32). The ash content of T2 (7.29) was high in
comparison to, T0 (6.46). The protein content of T2
(13.59) was high in comparison to T0 (9.70). Fat
content of T0 (9.30) was high in comparison to, T2
(7.30). Calcium content of T2 (100.1) was high in
comparison to, T0 (17.40). Iron content of T2 (3.33)
was high in comparison to, T0 (1.2). Carbohydrate
content of T2 (64.49) was low in comparison to, T0
(65.033). The protein, calcium and iron content was
increased in T2 as compared to T0, this is due to
addition of amaranth seeds and watermelon seeds in
treatment T2. The result is supported by the findings
of Kaul et al.(2011) reported that watermelon
(Citrullus vulgaris) seeds are high in protein and fat,
on enriching protein, it can find application as a
protein source in various food formulations. The
seeds were a moderate source of iron and zinc. The
percent bio accessibility of all the minerals were
found to correlate (R ¼ 0.97e0.99) with the
concentration of phytate, tannin and oxalate
contents.
C. COST OF THE PRODUCTS BASED ON THE RAW
MATERIALS
Cost is very important factor, which affects the
marketability of the products and needs to be
considered while manufacturing of the food
products. It is the basis for price fixation and
determining the profit on the cost of production. The
cost has been calculated on the basis of prevailing
price of raw materials. The cost of the “Biscuits” per
100gm of dry ingredients at the prevailing cost of the
raw materials was Rs.6.53 T0 control, Rs 9.53 for T1,
Rs. 11.07 for T2, and Rs. 12.45 for T3. This shows that
as the incorporation level of amaranth seeds flour
and watermelon seeds flour increased the cost also
increased marginally. The cost of the “Mathri” per
99
INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
100gm of dry ingredients at the prevailing cost of the
raw materials was Rs.12.27 T0 control, Rs 15.43 for
T1, Rs. 16.81 for T2, and Rs. 18.19 for T3. This shows
that as the incorporation level of amaranth seeds
flour and watermelon seeds flour increased the cost
decreased marginally. The cost of the “Laddoo” per
100g of RAW ingredients at the prevailing cost of the
raw materials was Rs.6.42 T0 control, Rs 9.54 for T1,
Rs. 10.9 for T2, and Rs. 12.26 for T3. This shows that
as the incorporation level of amaranth seeds and
watermelon seeds increased the cost increased
marginally.
the daily dietaries in addition to their nutritional
benefits and the amaranth seeds flour and
watermelon seeds flour can be used out of season as
well.
References
(Vancouver Style – PubMed preferred)
1.
Anu. S.S. and Kwatra A. (2007) “Use of pearl millet and
green gram flour in biscuits and their sensory and
nutritional quality” Journal of Food Science and
Technology.44(1):536-538.
2. AOAC (2005). Official methods of analysis of the association
of official analytical chemistry. Ed. 18th..
3. Boobier W.J. (2007) “Development of health biscuit”
Journal of health and social science (55) (7):
4. Gopalan, C. J., Balasubramamian, C. S., and Sastri Rama, V.
B. (2007) “Nutritive Value of India Foods”. IVth edition,
printed by National Institute of Nutrition (NIN), ICAR .47-51.
5. John H. Muyonga, Dorothy Nabakabya, Dorothy N.
Nakimbugwe and Dorothy Masinde (2008) “Efforts to
promote amaranth production and consumption in uganda
to fight malnutrition”International Union of Food Science &
Technology.
6. Kaul Purnima and lakshmi A. Jyothi (2011) “Nutritional
potential,bioaccessibility of minerals and functionality of
watermelon (Citrullus vulgaris) seeds” Journal of Food
Science and Technology;44: 1821-1826.
7. Marwein, Wisbansbuntilynelong; Dubey, R.P; Neerubala;
Sheikh.S; Paul, Anupriya, (2010). “Utilization of cassava
flour, pumpkin flour and wheat flour for the preparation of
snacks”. Master’s Thesis, Food Nutrition and Dietetics,
Ethelind School of Home Science. ;25-80.
8. Singh. Neeraj; Neerubala; Verma. Anisha; Sheikh.S;
Chandra. Ramesh. (2009). Use of potato flour for product
development. Master’s Thesis, Food Nutrition and
Dietetics, Ethelind School of Home Science. pp: 20-75.
9. Singh. Shalinee; Prasad. Ranu; Verma. Anisha; Sheikh.
Sarita; Masih. Shalini. (2011). Incorporation of mahua
flower flour for the preparation of products. Master’s
Thesis, Food Nutrition and Dietetics, Ethelind School of
Home Science. pp: 25-41.
10. Srilakshmi,B (2007). “Evaluation of Food Quality, Sensory
evaluation” New Age International Publishers, Food
Sciences. Ed. 4th. pp: 56.
11. Watters, K.H. (2007) “ Use of peanut and cowpea flours in
selected fried and Baked food Plant protein;Application”,
Biological effect and chemistry, 2 (1): 8-18
Conclusion
It is concluded that amaranth seeds, watermelon
seeds and their flour can be successfully
incorporated in “Biscuits”, “Mathri” and “Laddoo”.
On the basis of sensory evaluation T2 (amaranth
seed flour and watermelon seed flour in the ratio of
20:10) as found best in “Biscuits”, “Mathri” and
“Laddoo”with regards colour and appearance, body
and texture, taste and flavor and overall
acceptability. Nutritive value of the prepared
products indicate that protein, fat, carbohydrate,
calcium and iron content increased in enriched
“Biscuits”, , “Mathri” and “Laddoo” as compared to
control. Cost of the three products namely “Biscuits”
(Rs. 6.53-12.45), “Mathri” (Rs.12.27-18.19) “Laddoo”
(6.42-12.26 ) increased significantly as the ratio of
amaranth seeds, watermelon seeds and their flour
increased.
Recommendation
Incorporation of different proportions of amaranth
seeds flour and watermelon seeds flour for value
addition in traditional recipes can be encouraged
and popularized in order to improve intake of
protein, fat, calcium, carbohydrate and iron.These
products can also be helpful for providing variety in
Tables
TABLE 1 AVERAGE SENSORY SCORE OF DIFFERENT PARAM ETERS IN CONTROL AND TREATED SAMPLE OF
“BISCUITS”.
T0
T1
T2
T3
Statistical Analysis
Parameters
Mean± SE
Mean±SE
Mean±SE
Mean±SE
Colour and Appearance
7.46±0.06
8±0.11
8.86±0.06
6±0.23
F =62(4.76) S*
CD=1.67
Body and Texture
7.6±0.29
7.4±0.06
8.46±0.06
6.06±0.24
F =4.90(4.76) S*
CD=1.56
Taste and Flavor
7.6±0.11
7.6±0.06
8.53±0.24
6.2±0.13
F=43.77(4.76)S*
CD=2.26
Overall Acceptability
7.57±0.14
7.7±0.04
8.61±0.05
6.1±0.15
F=80.75(4.76) S*
CD=1.26
100
INDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY HEALTH / VOL 26 / SUPP 01 / NOV 2014
Development of nutritious… | Virginia P et al
TABLE 2 AVERAGE SENSORY SCORES OF DIFFERENT PARAMETERS IN CONTROL AND TREATED SAMPLE OF
“MATHRI”
T0
T1
T2
T3
Parameters
Statistical Analysis
Mean± SE
Mean±SE
Mean±SE
Mean±SE
Colour and appearance
7.2±0.30
7.73±0.24
8.6±0.11
5.86±0.17
F =25.27(4.76) S*
CD=0.78
Body and texture
7.73±0.37
7.6±0.23
8.4±0
6.13±0.06
F=22(4.76) S*
CD=0.78
Taste and flavor
7.46±0.40
7.66±0.17
8.4±0.13
6.13±0.06
F=17.59(4.76) S*
CD=0.77
Overall Acceptability
7.43±0.32
7.65±0.13
8.50±0.02
6.05±0.07
F=35.57(4.76) S*
CD=0.58
TABLE 3 AVERAGE SENSORY SCORES OF DIFFERENT PARAMETERS IN
“LADDOO”.
Parameters
T0
T1
T2
Mean± SE
Mean±SE
Mean±SE
Colour and Appearance
7.13±0.29
7.33±0.13
8.53±0.06
CONTROL AN D TREATED SAMPLE OF
T3
Mean±SE
6.26±0.29
Body and Texture
7.2±0.11
7.53±0.17
8.53±0.13
6.26±0.17
Taste and Flavor
7.06±0.13
7.53±0.13
8.6±0.11
6.26±0.40
Overall Acceptability
7.12±0.16
7.45±0.06
8.54±0.05
6.22±0.26
TABLE 4 THE AVERAGE NUTRIENT CONTENT OF
NUTRIENTS
Biscuits
T0
T2
Mean ± SE
Mean ± SE
Moisture %
4.6±0.16
4.5±0.15
Ash (g)
2.73±0.18
2.47±0.07
Protein (g)
7.2±0.26
14.46±0.142
Fat (g)
20.79±0.29
25.67±0.22
Total
63.21±0.06
59.90±0.375
carbohydrate (g)
Calcium (mg)
17.43±0.573
59.90±0.375
Iron (mg)
1.90±0.053
5.01±0.089
Sensory Acceptability
F =13.63(4.76) S*
CD=0.30
F=52.4(4.76) S*
CD=0.44
F=28.5(4.76) S*
CD=0.63
F=42.35(4.76)
S*
CD=0.50
“VALUE AD DED SNACKS” PER
Mathari
T0
T2
Mean ± SE
Mean ± SE
5.99±0.11
5.76±0.28
3.36±0.166
3.37±0.255
8.63±0.24
11.10±0.06
29.56±0.68
38.56±0.203
50.27±0.032
38.83±0.55
Laddo
T0
T2
Mean ± SE
Mean ± SE
5.32±0.071
6.66±0.416
6.46±0.212
7.293±0.116
9.70±0.14
13.59±0.220
9.30±0.29
7.30±0.26
65.033±0.812
64.49±0.61
17.34±0.08
1.5±0.192
17.40±0.492
1.2±0.057
101
53.95±0.135
3.82±0.27
100 G.
100.1±0.32
3.33±6.081