N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
Luis Burriel Bielza
PhD. Arch. / Estudio SOMOS.Arquitectos / Guest Associate Professor ENSA Paris-Belleville
Lburri@somosarquitectos.es
Iteration, repetition and internal coherence within Le Corbusier’s
creative process
Abstract:
Architectural practice is without any doubt based in a constant enquiry over the
project. Even more important would be the fact that this process bounces off in two
opposite directions: from the context onto the project and from the building onto the
surrounding frame of reference. Both these two extremes are confronted in an active
dialogue and to a certain extent, they both perform as “mirrors”. However, in the case
of Le Corbusier, these questions do not only revolve around these two poles but even
further, they do so in relation to his whole career. If we look closely at his works, we
will find out that several ideas, concepts and strategies are transferred from one
project to another as a tool able to trigger the creative process, thus unfolding
through subsequent iterations. As part of this method, his own experiences and
education during travels and visits help him to conform a synthesizing regard over the
world.
Keywords: Le Corbusier, process, Firminy, Chandigarh, design strategy
135
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
Profiles
"Watching the dome from the Piazza del Duomo where we are constantly dancing on
one leg over the other to avoid a tram, a cab, a bike, or a funeral, and watching the
dome when arriving to Florence, watching it just as the foreigners from the Middle
Ages did so, when they reached the top of a hill and suddenly in the blue morning
mist a monster stone arouse, larger than those nearby hills because it had an internal
order of his own, are two singularly different things. […] I saw it that way from the
train, for a long period, four times and those four times in the loving early mist, I
1
should have been certainly dumb not to understand it!"
FIG.1. Le Corbusier. Sketch of Santa Maria del Fiore, 1911. FLC_D_1979-R
These are the words Le Corbusier addressed to his master, Charles l’Eplattenier right
1
Le Corbusier, letter to Charles l’Eplattenier, Venice, 28th October 1907
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
after his visit to Santa Maria del Fiore on his first trip to Italy, in 1907. Cutout against
the sky, it expressed human will and power against the forces of nature, the creation
of a domesticated landscape engaging into a fruitful and moving dialogue with the
surrounding topography. In fact, this characteristic urban profile would soon be
enriched with some others, each one depicting the true spirit of a specific city, mainly
2
discovered through his Trip to the East in 1911 . This experience in Florence must have
been crucial for the architect as he took the time to sketch up this magical encounter
(Fig.01), where the ethereal atmosphere is masterfully achieved. It certainly conveys
the subjective impression of the beholder through an active manipulation of the real
image in order to reinforce his point of view. Even further, he acquired a postcard to
be found in his personal collection portraying the Dome as seen from the Boboli
Gardens (to the southwest of the city) (Fig.02) pretty much following the way in
which he has imagined the arrival to Florence during the Middle Ages.
FIG.2. Postcard of the Dome from Le Corbusier collection.
The same feeling pervades his account of the city of Rome, again nestled between
hills with the stark silhouette of Saint-Peter marking the right angle. In one of the
2
FLC C-B2 20 648. These were published in the first volume of his Oeuvre Complète.
137
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
pages of his notebook, he wrote down: “What I would like to show is this long
horizontal line denounced by this accident in the middle, and this end by 1 great
3
geometrical form, simple but rich in itself, aristocratic” . The subject in question is
the urban scenario of the Vatican Gardens. To the left, the enormous cupola of St.
Peter's Basilica. The complex of the Vatican museums extends throughout the whole
composition; to the right, the patio of Bramante's Belvedere. This reflection will be
repeated in the following page, a constant, a mechanism that Le Corbusier gathers
and verifies all over the classical city: “An urban landscape to compose// vertical /
4
horizontal" (Fig.03).
FIG.3. Le Corbusier, sketch of the urban scenario of Vatican Gardens.
In 1933, when talking about the project for a new urban extension in Stockholm, he
stated: “Modern city planning “sculpts” the site, making the outline and the
modelling of the landscape appear. Silhouettes are eloquent and ever varied.
Sculptural “volume” has seized the city. A (reduced) prototype of these plastic events
already exists: the Vatican in Rome, particularly as seen from the Castel Sant’
5
Angelo” . Quite surprisingly, that first drawing made in Florence bears and
extraordinary resemblance with this other from Sugar Loaf Mountain in Rio de Janeiro
3
(Le Corbusier, 1987, 134). A later version of this drawing is used to illustrate the chapter
“Classement et choix” in Ozenfant/Le Corbusier (1924), L’Esprit Nouveau. Revue internationale
illustrée de l’activité contemporaine, nº22. avril
4
Le Corbusier, Les carnets du Voyage d’Orient, op. cit.
5
(Le Corbusier, 1935, 298)
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
(Fig.04) taken in 1929 during his South American tour. He must have found it quite
appealing, there is another similar sketch further reinforced by the presence of a
photograph of himself, where this huge mass stands up in the background. As it
happened in Italy, two specific ideas were here found once again: the vertical against
the horizontal composing the figure of the right angle and its profile providing the
specific character and atmosphere for an urban settlement.
FIG.4. Le Corbusier. Sketch of Sugar Loaf Mountain in Rio de Janeiro. FLC_Carnet B4_279(1929)
Both of them were in mind, many years later, when designing the Capitol complex in
Chandigarh. In fact, the dialogue established between the Secretariat and the
Assembly Palace exactly follows this urban strategy. Not too much attention has
been given to the first original basic design, where we are already able to find this
relation. At the beginning, The Assembly Palace was a horizontal volume
accompanied by the Secretariat envisaged as a slender tower (Fig.05).
139
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
FIG.5. Le Corbusier drawing of Capitol complex in Chandigarh
Reasons are not clear, but probably due to the inherent technological issues regarding
its construction in such local circumstances, Le Corbusier inverses the layout using
the High Chamber to provide the vertical counterpart of the composition, while the
Secretariat turned into an elongated low volume. ¿How can we so surely relate the
final solution certainly inspired by the cooling towers with the cupola idea learned in
Florence and Rome, being both so different in formal terms? Because it is the
architect himself who invokes this source in one of the design sketches for the High
Chamber (Fig.06). It’s there, on the right hand side of this piece of paper; besides the
section, a clear parallel between both projects is brought up. The symbolic dimension
of the cupola clearly stands out, a believe which is fully understood when reading
some of the notes Le Corbusier wrote down on the urban extension planned for
Bogota, planned in 1950: “In our plan for Bogota there is nothing more than squared
rooms because there is nothing else than enterprises, business and homes. We are
6
missing the dome in its various forms that marks the seat of the spirit or the gods” .
While undoubtedly this vertical-horizontal dialogue is less powerful in the finished
building, this other photograph taken by René Burri during construction stages and
stocked in the archives of FLC (Fig.07) powerfully conveys the true sense behind this
arrangement of volumes.
6
Le Corbusier’s Sketchbooks, FLC W1-2-82
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
FIG.6. Le Corbusier sketch for the Assembly Palace in Chandigarh. FLC-28992
FIG.7. Le Corbusier sketch for the Assembly Palace in Chandigarh.
The role of the profile in the definition of the urban character was first discovered by
Le Corbusier in his 1907 trip to Italy and in 1924, he explicitly addresses this question
through nature itself, thereby presenting his subsequent works of architecture as
141
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
man-made organisms directly rooted to natural laws. Upon observing a leaf in his
hands against the sun, he will say: “one becomes aware of what is a clear
organization, of what harmoniously, without clash nor rupture, is born from the
inside, spreads out, clearly runs and stops in an edge, this limit of contour which is a
character, this contour which creates a visage completely full with its concentration
7
vis-a-vis the external events” . This contour is the measurement of its character.
Even more, we can translate this same feature from a plant onto specific buildings
like the Parthenon or the Breton houses, whose volume is synthesized and
understood with just a few strokes (Fig.08).
FIG.8. Le Corbusier sketch’s of Breton houses. AAM-85
In Chandigarh, Le Corbusier traces the long complete elevations of the Capitol
complex, where the profile of each building is filled with a grey shade, offering a
range of masses against the white backdrop of the sky and the silhouette of the
7
(Le Corbusier, 1924)
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
Himalaya. In the Assembly Palace, he had imagined people ascending through a long
ramp up to the roof level, where the sloped profile of the High Chamber would shine
under the sun. It is quite amazing to see he had even planned to settle up paths and
specific areas in order to reveal particular locations: “on the roof = grass with some
paving stones 5cm laid on the grass (japan-like) = paths for photographers, at the
culminating points” (Fig.09).
FIG.9. Le Corbusier sketch’s of the Assembly Palace. FLC-Carnet P60_P620.
This taste for conducting people and controlling accesses in order to enhance certain
qualities of his own works is clearly found in the Marseilles Unité (1945-52), where the
elevator hall, the position of the stairs and ventilation shafts are determined to
143
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
highlight once again the profile of these elements under the sun (Fig.10): “Roof, it is
necessary that upon arriving from the elevator hall to the summit, we must see stair
8
A” . As in his purist paintings, the different architectural constituents are arranged
and placed so as to compose a specific scenario.
FIG.10. Le Corbusier sketch’s for Marseilles Unité. FLC_Carnet D17_297 (11.1950)
Once again, these two ideas are present in one of his latest projects, the parish church
9
of Saint-Pierre of Firminy . While working on my PhD research specifically based on
10
this design , I had the chance to prove that it was possible to find traces of the
church in several of Le Corbusier’s former projects and conversely, that the opposite
direction was also a way to understand Saint-Pierre. At Firminy, the complex will be
built in different stages, but the culminating point arrives with the commission for
the church, made in 1960 by the town major, a close friend of the architect: EugèneClaudius Petit, also a key person for the Marseilles Unité. Here, the main public
buildings are placed right at the spot where the old mining town and the new green
extension meet. The area is charged with a deep meaning for the community,
because it stands in the crater left by an abandoned strip mining. The
vertical/horizontal dialogue is assured by the presence of two different volumes: the
8
Le Corbusier’s Sketchbooks, FLC W1-2-297 (11.11.1950)
Church of Saint-Pierre of Firminy; designed by Le Corbusier, architect, Jose Oubrerie, assistant
(1960-1965); realization by Jose Oubrerie, architect (1970-2006).
10
(Bielza, 2010)
9
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
Parish Church and the House of Culture (Fig.11). The cone of the church raising up to
33 meters strives to mark the place of the spirit and the gods but also, reinforcing
and establishing an active dialogue with the inherent qualities of the site, a valley
nestled up in hills.
FIG.11. Le Corbusier. Parish Church and the House of Culture
On August 16th 1961, with the church still in its first mumblings, an west-east section
through the whole complex reveals the will to establish a dialogue between the
different pieces in order to propose a completely fixed urban landscape (Fig.12).
145
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
FIG.12. Le Corbusier sketch’s of Parish Church and the House of Culture. EGFY 16824
At the bottom, we read the following handwritten sentence: “New section on
transverse axis through Stadium/SILHOUETTE church swimming pool, benches
stadium youth house". The silhouette of the South facade begins to find its
appropriate shape. At first, it was conceived as an inflexible cylinder, the one whose
perfection already incarnated the church of Le Tremblay. Later, a tenuous inclined line
shows an advance towards the final definition of its future geometry. The play of
diagonals in the church responds to the limits of the site as well to the inclined
surface of the House of Culture on the opposite side. It is important to notice this
first approach, because the slopes that define the limits of the West and East
facades are drawn exactly opposite to those seen on the 1963 final project. Another
hint on the usual way of working on the Sèvres Studio through opposite movements,
11
until he’s able to find the perfect equilibrium . During the first stages of the project,
particular attention is put onto the West façade silhouette. Under a series of
sketches like this one (Fig.13) we can study operations to “unveil” the character of the
church through its pointed profile, in order to establish the necessary height in a
balance of masses: concrete and sky. No attention is given to the small openings of
the shell, to abstract the plastic quality where voids and solids play together. Quite a
surprising decision, in a volume so powerful and difficult to understand in its spatial
complexity without the rest of the elevations. It is clear that reducing the building to
its contour becomes a tool of analysis against the surrounding area of Firminy, a tool
that works as an interface. The upper part will be sliced by an oblique surface and Le
Corbusier will later explain this decision as the right solution so as to collect and drain
rainwater from the top. This oblique plane was also to be found in the High Chamber
of the Assembly Palace. However, in 1964 he will also offer a second and most
important relation: “Mount Dent du Midi et mount Catogne in the Rhône Valley of
Valais (canton of Valais at the end of Lake Léman) give us the energy for the play of
12
diagonals” . This profile recreates the contours of the mountains in front of her
mother’s house, relating the design of this church with them, thus invoking the
11
For a precise account on the meaning of final slopes of the concrete shell, see (Oubrerie,
1999)
12
See (Le Corbusier, 1964)
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
forces of nature and his own past. A few pages afterwards, he will reinforce this idea:
13
“First inspiration of the church: its form within the landscape”
FIG.13. Le Corbusier collage of the West façade silhouette of the church of Le Tremblay
This same play of built masses would be later used for the unbuilt Bagdad Stadium
(Fig.14) where radial walls supporting the seating will be analyzed as timber ribs from
a ship. This “Marriage of Contours” technique was initially developed in his secret
laboratory: painting. In the “Poem of the Right Angle” (1955), paper cutouts of
different contours and sizes are used throughout: moving, transforming and relating
to others through superposition.
13
Le Corbusier, The development by Le Corbusier of the Design for l’Eglise de Firminy a church in
France
147
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
FIG.14. Le Corbusier collage of the unbuild Bagdad Stadium
This modus operandi by means of background-figure contrast is especially intense
and visible in the last years of his career, as research work carried in the Atelier shows
through the use of scale models. These series of pictures were taken by Lucien Hervé
in the Atelier Rue de Sèvres 35. I want to bring them up here, because they perfectly
illustrate a technique that freely moves between three completely different projects:
the church of Firminy-Vert (1960-07) (Fig.15), the Visual Arts Center in Harvard
University (1961-65) (Fig.16) and the unbuilt French Embassy in Brasilia (1964-65)
(Fig.17). The image of a cloudy sky is used as a background against which the volumes
of each proposal stand out. A wooden easel allows to support the photography, while
the white scale model moves and turns to show the complexity of each elevation. In
the case of the church, all the façades of the plaster scale model are captured. We are
surprised to see how this technique might be applied in so different situations, and
most of it, in a project like the Visual Arts Center in Harvard, a building fitted within a
completely built context where this type of connotations is strongly minimized
because of the visual integration within the surroundings. These photographs had
never been shown to the public, revealing therefore its experimental role as a working
and inspirational tool. Only the church of Firminy will do so in the magazine
“Progressive Architecture” of February, 1965, but the images will be edited so as to
eliminate de wooden easel, thus proposing the notion of a photomontage. In spite of
this apparently particular late experience, the concept that underlies behind this
technique has important precedents, like other photos Lucien Hervé took for the
plaster scale model of the Chapel of Ronchamp right on top of the vaults of Le
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
14
Corbusier’s own apartment , cut up against the blue sky.
FIG.15. Le Corbusier model for the church of Firminy-Vert (1960-07)
FIG.16 and 17. Le Corbusier models for the Visual Arts Center in Harvard University (1961-65) and
the unbuilt French Embassy in Brasilia (1964-65)
RULED SURFACES
Working with ruled surfaces was another strategy to crystallize the space created in
the transition between two planar figures held in parallel planes. It is widely known
than the church of Saint-Pierre was based on an older project sketched in June 1929
for the parish church of Le Tremblay, in the outskirts of Paris. It is Le Corbusier
himself who quotes this direct filiation when explaining the main concepts behind the
14
For example, picture R-22258-2002-r41b21-erl-10. Lucien Herve’s photographic archive
currently held at the J. Paul Getty Museum Research Institute, Los Angeles, CA (USA), which I
had the opportunity to study in May 2009 with the help of a Library Research Grant.
149
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
15
1960 project . A perfect square-based prism, the formal basis for Le Tremblay was
linked with the platonic solids appearing in the chapter of “Rome’s lesson”: the
cylinder, the pyramid, the cube, the rectangular prism and the sphere. However, in the
case of Firminy, a new volume is composed, synthesizing two planar figures: the
square and the circle. They are deeply rooted upon the symbolic tradition: the square
belongs to the earth, the tangible, the static; the circle is connected with heaven,
spirits, and gods. It is a fusion raising along the vertical axis and uniting both worlds.
16
Those two figures appear in Le Corbusier’s painting Swastika , from 1930 (Fig.18).
FIG.18. Le Corbusier painting “Swastika”
To the left, a distorted circle, to the right, a square; right between them, a swastika
15
See Le Corbusier, The development by Le Corbusier of the Design for l’Eglise de Firminy a
church in France
16
FLC 240
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
whose vertical and horizontal sections are marked with black lines. This painting, read
from left to right, reflects the foundation rite of a temple: a circle is drawn with a rod
stuck in the ground. Following the position of the sun and its shadow, we can
determine the Cardo (north-south) and the Decumanus (East-West) axis. The figure
corresponds to a cross, which reveals a special relationship with the Christian temple:
"this term stems from the root tem- (divide). Etruscan soothsayers divided the sky by
two straight lines cut at an angle above their heads […] Therefore, the earthly temple
is an image of the heavenly temple and the first lines which dominate its
17
construction are those of order and orientation” . From the cross, we get the base of
the square. This is how squaring of the circle is produced. "The man, the center of
creation, synthesizes and establishes a link between the High (Essence-Sky) and the
Low (Substance-Earth); and this relationship is symbolized precisely by the sign of
18
the cross” .
FIG.19. Le Corbusier model of the geometrical transformation between the square and the
circle.
17
(Cirlot, 2005)
(Hani, 2004) Le Corbusier will quote this link between Earth and Sky at the consecration
ceremony for the church of the monastery of Sainte-Marie de La Tourette: “We have made a
house, where, I think, up and down, Earth and Sky join together”, Le Corbusier, interviewed on
the journal “Le Progrès: le journal de Lyon”, dated October, 20th, 1960.
18
151
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
Thus, by incorporating oriented axes, the building plan is connected with the cosmos.
When studying the geometry, this model expresses like no other else this true
transition between both figures (Fig.19). A simple stool, some thick wire and a string
help to unravel this connection. In the past, this transition between a square base and
a circular figure at the top has been solved through pendentives, but here, this
element has been dissolved in order to produce a volume whose boundaries, whose
transition between two elements wishes to vanish in the air. Right there, between
these two opposed surfaces, ineffable space opens up.
Le Corbusier is fully aware of the use of ruled surfaces, which are in the base of
Antoine Pevsner’s artworks. For his exhibition in New York in 1947, the architect will
write quite an interesting presentation dealing with the Synthesis of Major Arts.
Among some other issues, he mentions: "large shapes made of ruled surfaces of an
intelligent geometry [...] I have looked after the man who, like the former builder of
cathedrals, will put up and join the frames and the planks to construct formworks in
19
which the concrete of unexpected statues will be poured" . Antoine Pevsner’s
sculptures made in copper, bronze, brass and plastic unfold within the gallery space
generating sensitive, permeable and open bodies whose different sections morph in a
continuous movement of translation. These ruled surfaces are quite appealing to Le
Corbusier not only because of its spatial properties but because of their possibility to
be composed through straight lines able to be constructed with wooden formworks.
Another appealing fact comes from this approach: these ruled surfaces are intimately
connected with the new material, concrete, whose plasticity and malleability open up
unexpected ways to construct volumes that we were only able to make before with
our hands. In his very beginnings, the architect was wondering about the new formal
system attached to this material, but he was certainly tied up to the beam and post
system that he will get rid of in projects such as the Philips Pavilion or the Firminy
church. In an interview held in 1962, he stated: "When you get a new resource, a tool
that produces new things, curved surfaces, ruled surfaces etc., that you could not do
in stone or wood or in any other material you wanted to, but which reinforced
concrete allows you to do with planks, which obeys to free forms, conoids, etc.. All
those things that the wooden formwork or steel formwork allows you, I went with it! I
used those formworks! Instead of staying closely attached to concrete buildings at
right angles, well, I did all sorts of things, when the project was favorable, and it
20
worked exclusively in Ronchamp" .
19
20
(Dreier, et all. 1947)
(Le Corbusier, 2007)
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
It is not quite surprising the fact that he mentions Ronchamp when dealing with
ruled surfaces. We all remember these wonderful axonometric views drawn by André
Maissonnier for the roof beam system. But a new reading brought up by Le Corbusier
himself changes our point of view regarding the spatial mechanism for this project.
At Firminy we were talking about two sections which are confronted in order to find a
connection able to put them in harmony. This intermediary space is exactly the same
used in the Ronchamp chapel, but here produced along a horizontal line. We are used
to understand this project through two complementary but independent masses: the
base, conceived as walls following a complex geometry responding to the surrounding
context, conceptually built with the stones and rubble for the original chapel; the roof,
this crab shell, this dark grey cloud hovering over the latter. This approach also seems
to be reinforced by the construction system, superposing both masses. However, the
architect brings up a new way of looking at it. In a book published in 1957, he draws
this cryptic design where two trapezoidal forms are joined through an intermediate
space, just as he indicates with his own handwriting: “The surface BB1 joins the
21
surface A, A1, A2, A3 like a rising wave” (Fig.20)
FIG.20 Le Corbusier studie for Ronchamp
Of course, when dealing with this translation between two planar figures and the use
of ruled surfaces, the shell of the High Chamber of the Assembly at Chandigarh
remains the most direct referent. Inevitably, behind this powerful geometry, the
discourse of the engineer Iannis Xénakis is quite present, because of his crucial
21
(Le Corbusier, 1957)
153
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
contribution to its geometric definition. The imposing cooling towers of the electric
power plant close to Sabarmati river, near Ahmedabad, are the main source for this
decision, although he had already seen this typology in an article from the Dominican
22
magazine L’Art Sacré, appealingly titled “New forms” and written in 1950 by his
friend father Marie-Alain Couturier, where a couple of cooling towers appeared along
with his Marseilles Unité. At Firminy, the original form is further manipulated and
warped following and equilibrium of forces between the different pieces of the
complex and the inner space. Chandigarh proposed a much more straightforward
reading of the hyperboloid surface. The subsequent beheading of the upper part
might be confusing in order to understand the original source, but the strict
geometrical construction prevails over any modification. The huge wooden lattice
model of the High Chamber will remain at the Atelier for many years, appearing in the
pages of the Oeuvre Complète. On one hand, as a mute reminder of the efforts of the
Greek engineer, on the other, as an objet-à-réaction-poétique to be manipulated
under the creative genius of Le Corbusier.
FIG.21. Le Corbusier drawings for The facilities building for the lock at Kembs-Kniffer
This transition between two flat surfaces will be repeated in two subsequent projects.
This and other episodes developed in this text reveal how Le Corbusier transferred
22
(Couturier, 1950, 23).
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
strategies from one project to another with completely different scales. The facilities
building for the lock at Kembs-Kniffer (Fig.21), designed and completed between
1959-1962. It is a small complex made up with two pieces. Again, the right angle
shown in the Capitol and Firminy is found within the dialogue between two
contrasting volumes. The first one is a guard tower overlooking the river area, while
the second one comprises a small service building located on one side of the channel.
A horizontal prism with a waving roof is formed within the transition established
between two side trapezoidal walls of similar proportions. Cross sections taken every
meter fully convey the shipbuilding system analogy, where a continuous sequence of
frames builds up the final volume. It is important to emphasize that the main
purpose behind this geometrical form is to design a roof projected as a giant funnel,
able to collect rainwater, the same idea behind the cutout of the upper part of the
Firminy church. We could certainly unravel a new approach of Le Corbusier’s
architecture following the shape and purpose of his roofs, another research which
would provide further evidence for this internal coherence we are here presenting. The
second example is the Congress Palace in Strasbourg, unbuilt design developed in
1964 (Fig22), where this roof solution is transferred onto a much larger building, a
true container, following a homothetic transformation.
FIG.22. Le Corbusier model of the Congress Palace in Strasbourg
Of course, this attention to ruled surfaces was first triggered and inspired in Antonio
Gaudi´s architecture but he continued to study their formal possibilities, because of
their possibility to cover large spaces. This is deeply connected with the umbrella-type
building, thoroughly developed during many years in some of the following works: the
French Pavilion for the Water Exhibition at Liège (1937), the demountable exhibition
building at Porte Maillot (1950), the Ahrenberg Palace in Stockholm (1962) and the
155
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
Heidi-Weber Pavilion (1960-1967). A more tangible proof is to be found in his personal
library, whose contents are now being fully revealed, uncovering the architect’s wide
range of interests. The book “Structures of Warped Surfaces, Combinations of Units
23
of Hyperbolic Paraboloids” , from the Argentinian architect Eduardo F. Catalano
clearly stands out. In a very straightforward and pedagogical style, it portraits a
catalog of different roofing solutions using hyperbolic modules, a classification of
different examples, all fully represented by photographs of wooden models. It was
published by the Raleigh School of Design, exactly the same editor which four years
later would launch the first book based on the Firminy church. Even though
Catalano’s publication was dated 15/7/1963 by the architect himself, its pages offer
very valuable hints regarding possible solutions for the Strasbourg Congress Palace
already included here.
Form
As it happens in the case of the fountain designed for the chapel at Ronchamp, the
High Court at Chandigarh and the monastery of Sainte-Marie de La Tourette at
Eveux-sur-l’Abresle (Fig.23), some of these transfers between different projects are
formal resolutions which are cut and pasted with absolute freedom. We do know that
the Oeuvre Complète was one of the few books with open access at the Atelier Rue de
Sèvres, a source of inspiration which presented in the most compact way the findings
of a whole life. As we have proved before, in some cases, the original model comes
from within the tradition, as it happens in the case of the pulpit placed in the outside
area of Ronchamp (Fig.24). Surprisingly enough, it happens to be based on another
one appearing in the pages of the Dominican magazine L’Art Sacré, a wooden version
found in an abandoned unidentified church in the surrounding area of Lartigues, Lot24
et-Garonne . The similarities are striking, the different elements composing the
pulpit are recognizable entities, each one portraying its own identity, all assembled
like a collage: stair, cube and pillar, nearly platonic solids. Eventually, this same idea
would later be incorporated inside the nave of the parish church of Saint-Pierre.
23
(Catalano, 1960) FLC Z 043. Mr. Catalano was a practicing architect and professor at the
Technological Institute of Massachusetts,
24
(Couturier, 1950)
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
FIG.23 Le Corbusier transfers of the fountain designed in the chapel at Ronchamp, the High
Court at Chandigarh and the monastery of Sainte-Marie de La Tourette at Eveux-sur-l’Abresle
FIG.24. Le Corbusier. The original model case of the pulpit placed in the outside area of
Ronchamp comes from within the tradition.
We have mentioned the transition from the square to the circle when dealing with
conceptual and formal basis behind the parish church, but in the final years of his life,
we are able to find a profile which goes between both figures, a square with rounded
edges. Any detached vertical shaft related to fluids such as water, smoke or heat
follows this shape (Fig.25). We find it in the Brazilian Pavilion at the University in
Paris: the steel covered column at ground level; also in the Jaoul houses: in the
chimney air intake appearing right in front of the entrance door to the main bedroom;
157
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
later on, in the Chandigarh Assembly: the two massive rain pipes carrying all the
water from the roof; (Fig.26) in 1961, in the monastery of La Tourette: the shaft
coming from the heating system installed under the church; in 1962, the initial stages
of the Firminy church: acting as a draining system and structural support for the
stairs leading up to the choir and finally, split up in half showing its inner shape, in
the already mentioned lock at Kembs-Kniffer, also taking the rainwater to the
ground.
FIG.25. Le Corbusier. Profiles which go between both figures, a square with rounded edges.
Brazilian Pavilion at the University; Jaoul houses; and Chandigarh Assembly
FIG.26. Le Corbusier. which go between both figures, a square with rounded edges. Monastery
of La Tourette; Firminy church; and Kembs-Kniffer
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
All of them transform this air-ground connection into a formal event of its own. This
man-made frame highlights and makes visible this transition between the sky and
the earth. It draws our attention to a meaningful phenomenon which happens to reestablish the natural balance. I have introduced this meaningful term, balance,
because it is behind another explanation for this choice, this time given by one of his
closest collaborators, André Wogenscky: “One day his hand draws a square, but
rounded. It is a kind of intermediary between a square and a circle. A square whose
corners are curved. A circle where some opposing arches flatten. He says he loves this
shape and that he finds it beautiful following the precision we want to give it. […] It is
a precise dosage related to a hand gesture, a kind of balance found in the swing which
25
goes from the square to the circle and comes back” .
As we have seen in these case studies, some design strategies and obsessions are
transferred from one project to the other. What’s most appealing of all, is precisely
this inner coherence which allows us to discover hidden relations between projects set
apart in time and space. Key “solutions” are reworked over and over. Of course,
merged with changing contextual conditions and program requirements, they might
arrive to design stage, to execution project stage or to the built oeuvre. Several
strategies and tools find themselves intermingled in different projects. As part of this
process, his own experiences and education during travels and visits help him to
conform a synthesizing regard over the world. His architecture unfolds through
different associative layers able to evoke history, emerging as a result of this
equilibrium of forces, in fact “re-creation” rather than “creation” ex nihilo. Iteration
and repeated testing of similar ideas are in the base of his working process. This inner
coherence performs as a powerful conceptual substratum which will also endue his
works with a double dimension: on one hand, they are perfectly able to suit XXth
century man’s needs but also, they become fully immersed within the tradition. All
these examples are here presented willing to prove that this hypothesis might stand
out as a valuable tool which should serve to other researchers in order to find hidden
connections between the many designs accomplished during his life. Most of the
documents produced during the different design stages are nowadays stocked in the
archives of La Fondation Le Corbusier and this fact shall be crucial so as to evaluate
this approach, unfolding this strategy at all levels.
25
(Wogenscky, 2006)
159
Theme I - Knowledge
N 11 / 2014
AE... Revista Lusófona de Arquitectura e Educação
Architecture & Education Journal
References:
Burriel Bielza, Luis (2010), Saint-Pierre of Firminy: the building as an object-àréaction-poétique, unpublished PhD Thesis, School of Architecture of Madrid, Spain
Wogenscky, André (2006), Les mains de Le Corbusier, Collection Questions
d’architecture Paris: Editions Le Moniteur,
Catalano, Eduardo F (1960), Structures of warped surfaces, Raleigh, N.C: The student
publications of the School of Design.
Cirlot, Juan Eduardo (2005), Diccionario de símbolos, Madrid: Ediciones Siruela.
Couturier, Marie-Alain (1950), Au régime de la pauvreté, in Journal L’Art Sacré, nº11-12,
June-August
Couturier, Marie-Alain (1950), Devant l’art profane, in journal L’Art Sacré, nº5-6
January-February.
Dreier, K.S. - Le Corbusier - Giedion - Welcker, C. (1947), Exposition Antoine Pevsner,
19 Junio-12 Julio 1947, New York.
Hani, Jean (2004), Symbolism of the Christian Temple, Barcelona: José J. Olañeta
Jose Oubrerie (1999) Architecture before geometry in Assemblage 39, August.
Le Corbusier (1924) “Formation de l’optique moderne”, in L’Esprit Nouveau, Revue
internationale illustrée de l’activité contemporaine, Paris, nº21, Avril.
Le Corbusier (1935) La Ville Radieuse; éléments d’une doctrine d’Urbanisme pour
l’équipement de la civilisation machiniste, Boulogne-sur-Seine: Éditions de
l’Architecture d’aujourd’hui.
Le Corbusier (1957), Les carnets de la Recherche Patiente: nº2 Ronchamp, Zurich:
Verlag Gerd Hatje
Le Corbusier (1964), The development by Le Corbusier of the Design for l’Eglise de
Firminy a church in France, North Carolina: Student publications of the School of
Design North Carolina State, edited by the University of North Carolina at Raleigh,
Volume 1 number 2.
Le Corbusier (1987) Les carnets du Voyage d’Orient, Paris: Electa-Fondation Le
Corbusier, carnet 4.
Le Corbusier (2007), Le Corbusier: entretiens avec Georges Charensol (1962) et Robert
Mallet (1951), Vincennes: Fremeaux et Associes.
Fourth International Conference on Architectural Research by Design (ARbD’14)