Helen Godwin - ECU*
Professor Sandra Carr - UWA
Associate Professor Annette Mercer - UWA
Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry and Health Sciences: Education Centre
* This research was undertaken
as a Masters student at UWA.
Is midwifery competence afected by
working in a Western Australian rural health area?
Aim
a bachelor degree qualiication. Over 68 per cent of WA
midwives have more than 15 years experience, suggesting
an ageing workforce. The study revealed subtle differences
between midwives in urban and rural settings in self-assessed
competence and conidence for essential midwifery skills.
To describe Western Australian (WA) midwives’ perceptions of
competence and continuing competence and contrast these
perceptions for midwives practicing in rural and low risk urban
settings.
Background
WA midwives regularly attend professional development
education. Rural midwives favour multi-professional emergency
skills courses. Urban midwives were more likely to complete
annual mandatory competencies (statistically signiicant
difference at p=<0.001).
Dispersal of health service providers is uneven throughout
this geographically isolated State. Budget constraints, stafing
issues and distance could mean rural midwives may ind it
dificult to attend appropriate education programs required for
registration.
Western Australia (WA) is a geographically
isolated state. It is the largest state in
Australia, covering 2,526,786 square
kilometres, and is the fourth highest
populated state of Australia. On average 23
per cent of babies are born in the rural area.
In 2012 over 7,000 babies out of 33,920
births in WA were born in a rural location.
Implications for education, practice and policy
Rural midwives are generalist nurse-midwives who practise
in isolated, small, low risk maternity centres. The transfer
of high-risk women to a tertiary centre minimises midwifery
exposure to complex maternity care.
The study suggests the issue is not whether competence and
conidence differs between the urban and rural setting but that
the comparison groups have different needs. Recommendations
include a standardisation of annual mandatory competencies
across all public hospitals, implementation of mentoring models
of education for less experienced midwives to beneit from the
wealth of knowledge gained by experienced midwives.
Methods
This study used descriptive research and a mixed method
approach. A questionnaire gathered the information from the
participants. The response rate from the urban midwives was
28 per cent (n=66) and rural 32 per cent (n= 63). Information
included the characteristics of WA midwives and perceptions of
competence.
Methodology and instrument
This descriptive mixed method study was based on a previous
study conducted in Scotland 2007:
Hundley, V. A., Tucker, J. S., van Teijlingen, E., Kiger, A.,
Ireland, J. C., Harris, F., Farmer, J., Caldow, J. L.,Bryers, H.
Midwives’ competence: is it affected by working in a rural
location?
Key indings
Contrary to current literature, slightly more rural midwives (51
per cent) than urban midwives (45 per cent) reported having
Perceived Competence in Antenatal
Skills.
Midwives Perceived Competence in
Intrapartum Skills
Midwives Perceived Competence
in Postnatal Skills
Midwives Perceived Competence
in Newborn Skills
While no statistically signiicant difference
was found for perceived competence for
antenatal skills between urban and rural
midwives, there are some noteworthy
indings. See the graph below.
While no statistically signiicant difference
was found for perceived competence for
antenatal skills between urban and rural
midwives there are some noteworthy
indings. See the graph below.
Midwives perceived competence in
postnatal skills revealed no statistically
signiicant difference for the comparison
groups. See the graph below.
Midwives perceived competence in
newborn skills revealed no statistically
signiicant difference for the two
groups. See graph below.
120
120
120
120
100
100
100
100
80
80
80
80
60
60
60
60
40
SIDS prevention
Fluid requirements
Discharge
40
67
31
52
36
62
17
31
13
24
80
70
Urban
Rural
60
50
40
30
20
10
2. Further qualitative
research projects to
examine inter-hospital
communication issues.
3. Explore future direction
in education and training
for midwives in different
settings.
Lack of appropriate training
Lack of support from
management
Staff not sharing the
information from courses
Negative attitude of
senior staff in the unit
Getting staff cover
0
Recommendations
1. Standardisation of
mandatory competency
requirements across WA
hospital sites.
At CS
Initial exam
Resuscitation
Contraception
Debriefing parents
PN exercises
The results showed a
statistically signiicant
difference in distance to
training of p <0.001, with
more rural midwives (70
per cent n=44) than urban
midwives (19 per cent
n=12) believing distance to
training was a barrier.
See graph on the right.
46
Lack of motivation/interest
Attendance at three speciic multidisciplinary courses.
Barriers to Continuous
Professional
Development (CPD)
Attendance by rural
midwives
n
%
27
Distance to training
Attendance at an external venue within the last 12 months:
• Urban midwives 88 per cent (n=58) had attended an
external session and 81 per cent (n=57) of the rural
midwives.
Advanced Life Support Obstetrics
(ALSO) Statistically signiicantly
different p=0.022
Neonatal Resuscitation Program (NRP)
Advanced Foetal Monitoring Course at
King Edward Memorial Hospital (AFM)
Getting funding to attend
Attendance at education sessions within their own facility
within last 12 months:
• Urban midwives reporting 86 per cent (n=57) and 86 per
cent (n=52) of the rural midwives.
Attendance by
urban midwives
n
%
Family commitments
Professional Development
Course
CPD is not seen as
a priority for me
A statistically signiicant
difference at p <0.0001 was
show in completion of annual
mandatory competencies in
the previous 12 months. Urban
midwives were more likely
82 per cent (n=54) than rural
midwives 48 per cent (n=300 to
complete mandatory competency
requirements within their facility.
20
Number of midwives attending ALSO, NRP and AFM courses
Lack of time
Annual Mandatory
Competencies
Urban
Rural
0
Breastfeeding
Support person support
Repair of perineum
PPH
Foetal monitoring
interpretation
Non - pharmacology
pain relief
Breech birth
Shoulder dystocia
Pre-term birth
Pre-term labour
Using a Pinnard
0
Parent education classes
0
S&S of pre-eclampsia
0
Transferring out
20
Management of APH
20
Identifying at risk patient
20
40
Urban
Rural
Self care post CS
Urban
Rural
40
Scrub at CS
Urban
Rural
40