arXiv:1302.4392v1 [cond-mat.stat-mech] 18 Feb 2013 Comment on “Cooling by Heating: Refrigerator Powered by Photons” Armen E. Allahverdyan 1,4) , Karen V. Hovhannisyan 2) and Guenter Mahler 3) 1) Laboratoire de Physique Statistique et Syst` emes Complexes, ISMANS, 44 ave. Bartholdi, 72000 Le Mans, France 2) ICFO-Institut de Ciencies Fotoniques, 08860 Castelldefels (Barcelona), Spain 3) Universitat Stuttgart, 1. Institut fr Theoretische Physik, Pfaffenwaldring 57, 70550 Stuttgart, Germany 4) Yerevan Physics Institute, Alikhanian Brothers Street 2, Yerevan 375036, Armenia Results obtained recently in Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 120603 (2012) by Cleuren et al. apparently contradict to the third law of thermodynamics. We discuss a scenario for resolving this contradiction, and show that this scenario is pertinent for clarifying the general message of the third law. 1. A recent interesting letter by Cleuren et al. presents a model for a refrigerator operating between two thermal baths at temperatures T c and T h , T c <T h [1]. Among other findings, Cleuren et al. report on a low-T c regime, where the heat ˙ Q c taken per time-unit from the low- temperature bath scales as ˙ Q c ∼ T c . (1) If (1) is assumed to hold for all temperatures down to T c → 0, it would invalidate (for this model example) the third law of thermodynamics [2]. This law states that the rate of cooling of the low-temperature bath goes to zero. The challenge of saving the third law amounts to showing why (1) cannot hold down to very low temperatures T c . A proposal on why this might be the case for the model studied in [1] was recently made by Levy et al. [2]. 2. The purpose of the present note is to explain why to our opinion the proposal by Levy et al. cannot be accepted as a fundamental reason for saving the third law, and then make our own attempt of arguing against the validity of (1) at very low temperatures. We stress that we do not make any claim on the invalidity of the results by [1] within their model. It is the applicability of the model for low temperatures that is questioned. 3. The contradiction between (1) and the third law is deduced via routine thermodynamic considerations: (i) the low-temperature thermal bath stays in overal equi- librium despite of its interaction with the refrigerator. Hence it will respond to the refrigerator by lowering its temperature. (ii) The rate at which its temperature ˙ T c is lowered can be evaluated within the linear response, since the energy taken out due to refrigeration is much smaller than the energy of the bath. Hence [2] ˙ T c = ˙ Q c c(T c ) , (2) and taking into account that for T c → 0 the constant- volume heat capacity c(T c ) behaves at least as c(T c ) ∼ T c for reasonable thermal baths (including the electron bath studied in [1]), one concludes that ˙ T c will be at least constant for T c → 0, which contradicts to the third law. 4. To save the third law, Levy et al. propose that the Hamiltonian of the refrigerator employed in [1] is supple- mented by another, physically well motivated term that invalidates (1) for a low T c [2]. This salvation of the third law is not satisfactory for the following reason. Any model of refrigerator must describe its specific function. This description necessarily involves taking “limits”, i.e. letting certain parameters in the respec- tive Hamiltonian go to zero. We distinguish two types of such asymptotic behavior: 1. “Circumstantial limits” strengthen the functional charateristics of the model. Applying such limits is a natural desire of building better devices. Indeed, good devices do have rather special Hamiltonians. As the evo- lution of room refrigerators shows, even when their the- oretical operating principles are clear, it still takes many years and substantial engineering efforts to built good devices, precisely because many unwanted terms in their Hamiltonians are to be eliminated. 2. “Dysfunctional” limits would suppress the desired function of the device (asymptotically). Now Levy et al. based their arguments on an circum- stantial limit as a potential reason of violating the third law. It may be difficult to implement this limit in prac- tice, but nothing in the analysis by Levy et al. shows that the term they propose cannot in principle be made as small as desired. This viewpoint on the salvation of the third law would suggest that this law is not funda- mental, but it holds due to imperfections present in the Hamiltonian. In contrast, we are going to argue that the violation of the third law by Cleuren et al. relates to a dysfunctional limit: if it is applied down to very low temperatures, the basic functional characteristics of the model (its power of refrigeration) will be harmed. 5. Now we explain why the weak-coupling master- equation-based refrigerator model by Cleuren et al. gets limited at low T c . An essential feature of such Markov models is the detailed balance with respect to each ther- mal bath. Due to this, for T c = T h = T (equal tem- perature baths) the refrigerator density matrix ρ has the Gibbs form ρ ∝ e -H/T , where H is the refrigerator’s Hamiltonian. For T → 0 this predicts that the refrig- erator itself will be in its pure ground state. Such a conclusion is impossible for a system permanently cou- pled to a thermal bath, provided that both the system- bath interaction Hamiltonian and its commutator with the full Hamiltonian stay finite (non-zero); see e.g. [3].
2 The model studied in [1] belongs to this class. The usual way of understanding the low-temperature limit of the Gibbs density matrix for an open system is to assume that simultaneously with T → 0 the coupling to the bath is made progressively smaller. However, for the present situation this limiting process for justifying the Gibbs density matrix down to low temperatures does not work, since any refrigerator should have a finite cou- pling to the baths for ensuring a finite power of its oper- ation. While the argument strictly speaking applies only for T c = T h = T , it should be clear that there are low-T c validity limits of the weak-coupling master equation also for T c <T h . Hence if the weak-coupling master equation is forced to apply for all T c → 0, its coupling to the low- temperature bath should be made progressively weaker nullifying ˙ Q c /T c in (1). 6. The above argument on the inapplicability of the usual Markov models at low temperatures suggests that the analysis of the low-temperature refrigeration will cer- tainly benefit from being carried out in a set-up, where the refrigerator bath interaction is treated exactly, with- out any assumption on progressively weak refrigerator- bath interactions. Now one should and can ensure that the power of refrigeration stays finite down to T c = 0. Such a model-dependent analysis has been carried out re- cently showing that albeits the regime (1) is reproduced by sufficiently good devices at moderate and low values of T c , it is broken down for very low temperatures holding the third law [4]. Our conclusion is that a proposition like (1) should always be supplemented by demanding that the power of refrigeration stays finite. Then presumably it cannot hold down to very low temperatures, as the model studied in [4] shows. If such a proposition could be shown to hold down to T c = 0 with only circumstantial limits involved, it would constitute a a “real” violation of the third law. [1] B. Cleuren, B. Rutten and C. Van den Broeck, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 120603 (2012). [2] A. Levy, R. Alicki and R. Kosloff, Comments on cooling by heating: Refrigeration powered by Photons, arXiv:1208.2600 [quant-ph]. [3] Th.M. Nieuwenhuizen and A.E. Allahverdyan, Phys. Rev. E 66, 036102 (2002). [4] A. E. Allahverdyan, K. Hovhannisyan and G. Mahler, Phys. Rev. E 81, 051129 (2010).
Comment on “Cooling by Heating: Refrigerator Powered by Photons”
Armen E. Allahverdyan1,4), Karen V. Hovhannisyan2) and Guenter Mahler3)
1)
arXiv:1302.4392v1 [cond-mat.stat-mech] 18 Feb 2013
Laboratoire de Physique Statistique et Systèmes Complexes,
ISMANS, 44 ave. Bartholdi, 72000 Le Mans, France
2)
ICFO-Institut de Ciencies Fotoniques, 08860 Castelldefels (Barcelona), Spain
3)
Universitat Stuttgart, 1. Institut fr Theoretische Physik, Pfaffenwaldring 57, 70550 Stuttgart, Germany
4)
Yerevan Physics Institute, Alikhanian Brothers Street 2, Yerevan 375036, Armenia
Results obtained recently in Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 120603 (2012) by Cleuren et al. apparently
contradict to the third law of thermodynamics. We discuss a scenario for resolving this contradiction,
and show that this scenario is pertinent for clarifying the general message of the third law.
1. A recent interesting letter by Cleuren et al. presents
a model for a refrigerator operating between two thermal
baths at temperatures Tc and Th , Tc < Th [1]. Among
other findings, Cleuren et al. report on a low-Tc regime,
where the heat Q̇c taken per time-unit from the lowtemperature bath scales as
Q̇c ∼ Tc .
(1)
If (1) is assumed to hold for all temperatures down to
Tc → 0, it would invalidate (for this model example) the
third law of thermodynamics [2]. This law states that the
rate of cooling of the low-temperature bath goes to zero.
The challenge of saving the third law amounts to showing
why (1) cannot hold down to very low temperatures Tc .
A proposal on why this might be the case for the model
studied in [1] was recently made by Levy et al. [2].
2. The purpose of the present note is to explain why
to our opinion the proposal by Levy et al. cannot be
accepted as a fundamental reason for saving the third
law, and then make our own attempt of arguing against
the validity of (1) at very low temperatures. We stress
that we do not make any claim on the invalidity of the
results by [1] within their model. It is the applicability
of the model for low temperatures that is questioned.
3. The contradiction between (1) and the third law is
deduced via routine thermodynamic considerations: (i)
the low-temperature thermal bath stays in overal equilibrium despite of its interaction with the refrigerator.
Hence it will respond to the refrigerator by lowering its
temperature. (ii) The rate at which its temperature Ṫc
is lowered can be evaluated within the linear response,
since the energy taken out due to refrigeration is much
smaller than the energy of the bath. Hence [2]
Ṫc =
Q̇c
,
c(Tc )
(2)
and taking into account that for Tc → 0 the constantvolume heat capacity c(Tc ) behaves at least as c(Tc ) ∼ Tc
for reasonable thermal baths (including the electron bath
studied in [1]), one concludes that Ṫc will be at least
constant for Tc → 0, which contradicts to the third law.
4. To save the third law, Levy et al. propose that the
Hamiltonian of the refrigerator employed in [1] is supplemented by another, physically well motivated term that
invalidates (1) for a low Tc [2]. This salvation of the third
law is not satisfactory for the following reason.
Any model of refrigerator must describe its specific
function. This description necessarily involves taking
“limits”, i.e. letting certain parameters in the respective Hamiltonian go to zero. We distinguish two types of
such asymptotic behavior:
1. “Circumstantial limits” strengthen the functional
charateristics of the model. Applying such limits is a
natural desire of building better devices. Indeed, good
devices do have rather special Hamiltonians. As the evolution of room refrigerators shows, even when their theoretical operating principles are clear, it still takes many
years and substantial engineering efforts to built good
devices, precisely because many unwanted terms in their
Hamiltonians are to be eliminated.
2. “Dysfunctional” limits would suppress the desired
function of the device (asymptotically).
Now Levy et al. based their arguments on an circumstantial limit as a potential reason of violating the third
law. It may be difficult to implement this limit in practice, but nothing in the analysis by Levy et al. shows
that the term they propose cannot in principle be made
as small as desired. This viewpoint on the salvation of
the third law would suggest that this law is not fundamental, but it holds due to imperfections present in the
Hamiltonian.
In contrast, we are going to argue that the violation of
the third law by Cleuren et al. relates to a dysfunctional
limit: if it is applied down to very low temperatures, the
basic functional characteristics of the model (its power of
refrigeration) will be harmed.
5. Now we explain why the weak-coupling masterequation-based refrigerator model by Cleuren et al. gets
limited at low Tc . An essential feature of such Markov
models is the detailed balance with respect to each thermal bath. Due to this, for Tc = Th = T (equal temperature baths) the refrigerator density matrix ρ has the
Gibbs form ρ ∝ e−H/T , where H is the refrigerator’s
Hamiltonian. For T → 0 this predicts that the refrigerator itself will be in its pure ground state. Such a
conclusion is impossible for a system permanently coupled to a thermal bath, provided that both the systembath interaction Hamiltonian and its commutator with
the full Hamiltonian stay finite (non-zero); see e.g. [3].
2
The model studied in [1] belongs to this class.
The usual way of understanding the low-temperature
limit of the Gibbs density matrix for an open system is
to assume that simultaneously with T → 0 the coupling
to the bath is made progressively smaller. However, for
the present situation this limiting process for justifying
the Gibbs density matrix down to low temperatures does
not work, since any refrigerator should have a finite coupling to the baths for ensuring a finite power of its operation. While the argument strictly speaking applies only
for Tc = Th = T , it should be clear that there are low-Tc
validity limits of the weak-coupling master equation also
for Tc < Th . Hence if the weak-coupling master equation
is forced to apply for all Tc → 0, its coupling to the lowtemperature bath should be made progressively weaker
nullifying Q̇c /Tc in (1).
6. The above argument on the inapplicability of the
usual Markov models at low temperatures suggests that
the analysis of the low-temperature refrigeration will certainly benefit from being carried out in a set-up, where
the refrigerator bath interaction is treated exactly, without any assumption on progressively weak refrigeratorbath interactions. Now one should and can ensure that
the power of refrigeration stays finite down to Tc = 0.
Such a model-dependent analysis has been carried out recently showing that albeits the regime (1) is reproduced
by sufficiently good devices at moderate and low values of
Tc , it is broken down for very low temperatures holding
the third law [4].
Our conclusion is that a proposition like (1) should
always be supplemented by demanding that the power
of refrigeration stays finite. Then presumably it cannot
hold down to very low temperatures, as the model studied
in [4] shows. If such a proposition could be shown to hold
down to Tc = 0 with only circumstantial limits involved,
it would constitute a a “real” violation of the third law.
[1] B. Cleuren, B. Rutten and C. Van den Broeck, Phys. Rev.
Lett. 108, 120603 (2012).
[2] A. Levy, R. Alicki and R. Kosloff, Comments on
cooling by heating: Refrigeration powered by Photons,
arXiv:1208.2600 [quant-ph].
[3] Th.M. Nieuwenhuizen and A.E. Allahverdyan, Phys. Rev.
E 66, 036102 (2002).
[4] A. E. Allahverdyan, K. Hovhannisyan and G. Mahler,
Phys. Rev. E 81, 051129 (2010).
Keep reading this paper — and 50 million others — with a free Academia account
Used by leading Academics
Francisco Caruso
Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas Físicas
Florentin Smarandache
University of New Mexico
Alexandros Karam
National Institute of Chemical Physics and Biophysics
επιλέχθηκε από τα συμμαχικά έθνη για τη συγκέντρωση και στέγαση του σερβικού στρατού μετά την αποχώρησή του από την Αλβανία. 140.000 άνδρες αποβιβάστηκαν εκεί στην αποτρόπαια κατάσταση που έχει περιγραφεί συχνά. Η δημιουργία μιας υγειονομικής μονάδας επιβλήθηκε και επιλέχθηκε η περιοχή του Αχίλλειον, παλιά παλάτι διακοπών του αυτοκράτορα της Γερμανίας.
Nalbinding uses short lengths of yarn and a single needle to careful construct knotted stitches to form solid, warm and durable textiles. But how was this ancient craft done in the past?
Let's take a look shall we and learn about the archaeological examples that have inspired people to investigate more about this endangered craft! Let's find out what Nalbinding means to folks nowadays, and start to understand its place as an Endangered Heritage Craft.
For this free lecture, please go to my YouTube Channel:
@nidavellnirnalbindinguk
A opção de fazer day-trade é um grande atrativo para quem se interessa no mercado de ações. Ao se remover a variável humana e emocional do sistema de tomada de decisão, é possı́vel automatizar e otimizar esse tipo operação, fazendo grande uso das ferramentas computacionais atualmente disponı́veis. Neste trabalho é proposto um sistema de tomada de decisão, com opção de aguardar, comprar ou vender ativos dentro de um cenário de day-trade. Divergindo da maioria dos trabalhos existentes, esta estratégia é focada no uso de indicadores técnicos na operação de contratos futuros de mini ı́ndice Bovespa, com granularidade de 15 minutos, levando em consideração as particularidades desse tipo de ativo. Os experimentos envolvem a comparação com modelos clássicos, como buy and hold, sugerindo que a proposta é lucrativa, apresentando assertividade superior a 65%. Keywords—Automação de investimentos; indicadores técnicos; day trade; mini contratos futuros.
Background: Tibial Plateau Fracture is one of the most common case seen in orthopaedics and the most classification system used is Schaetzker Classification. This classification is using X ray photograph to classify the fracture and it has limitation to describing a posterior column in tibial plateau fracture since X-ray is a 2D projection. Nowadays surgeon over the world start to using Three Column concept classification because it has a better image of 3D visualization of tibial plateau.
Purpose: To know which one classification is more accurate in describing tibial plateau fracture in Dr. Soetomo Hospital period January 2015 until September 2017.
Methods: This study is retrospective study, we collected data of patients with Tibial Plateau fracture that has been operated in Dr. Soetomo hospital from January 2015 – September 2017.
Results: From the study found 24 patients that match with inclusion criteria. All patients are classified with Schaetzker and Three Column Classification. The most type of fracture based on Schaetzker Classification is Type 2 (7 patients) and based on Three Column Classification is type Three Column (11 patients) and the most action in Three Column type is Internal Fixation with double plate insertion (55 %).
Conclusion: Three Column Classification is more accurate to describe type fracture in posterior part than Schaetzker. Three Column Classification is recommended to make easier decision for Tibial Plateau fracture treatment and prevent any loss of correction.
Music, the Market, and the Marvellous examines féerie, the French fairy play, in the last third of the nineteenth century. It is among the first book-length studies on the genre, the first in a language other than French, and the first from a musicological perspective. Sabbatini demonstrates that, contrary to conventional wisdom, féerie was still thriving during the fin de siècle, giving rise to innovations such as composerly féerie and scientific féerie. The plays, the theatre industry, and urban geography are discussed together, as befits a commercial genre where the marvellous was shaped by the market. Recovering this forgotten — but once hugely influential — repertoire provides an occasion to rethink generic taxonomies of Parisian theatre and the ontology of nineteenth-century 'popular' theatre.
El p re se n te tra b a jo se p ro p u so com o ob je tivo e xam in a r el nivel de in fluencia de los D e te rm inan tes Sociales de la Salud en la a tenc ión clínica en el H ospita l O do n to ló g ico U n ive rs ita rio de la FOUNLP. Se realizó un es tu d io descrip tivo s o b re variables: a) " n iv e ld e instrucc ión"; b) "nivel de au tonom ía"; c) "g rup o etario". Se reg is tró una encuesta cerrada, vo lu n ta ria , an ón im a y p o r a u to rre p o rte a una m uestra azarosa de 150 pacientes cuyas edades com p ren d ía n e n tre 51 y 60 años. El tra ta m ie n to y análisis estadís tico fu e rea lizado m e d ian te el SSPS 15. En re lac ión con la p rim e ra va riab le el segm en to "sólo p rim a rio co m p le to " (G rupo 2) reg is tró 43 pacientes (28.7%), m ien tras que e ls e g m e n to "secunda rio c o m p le to " (G rupo 4) d e te rm in ó 4 8 pacientes (32.0%), p>0.05. En relación con la evaluación de la au ton om ía...
Este trabajo trata el fenomeno de la combinatoria de tiempos verbales en espanol, una de cuyas posibilidades es la consecutio temporum, si bien no la unica. Existe consecutio cuando el tiempo del verbo subordinado esta condicionado por el del verbo principal y no por el momento de la enunciacion. A lo largo de los diversos apartados comprobamos en que medida intervienen diversos factores en el fenomeno de la combinatoria de tiempos en espanol, a saber: el tiempo verbal, considerado de acuerdo con la distincion de esfera temporal de presente y de pasado, el modo y el aspecto. Asimismo, demostramos el papel fundamental que desempenan las restricciones lexicas impuestas por la semantica del verbo principal. Desde esta perspectiva, se muestra que los significados de anterioridad, simultaneidad y posterioridad de los verbos subordinados con relacion al verbo principal deben ser tratados segun la esfera de presente o de pasado en que se situen.