Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                
Sociology of Health & Illness Vol. xx No. xx 2018 ISSN 0141-9889, pp. 1–2 doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.12755 Book Review de Rond, M. Doctors at War: Life and Death in a Field Hospital. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. 2017. 176pp (hbk) $21.95 ISBN 9781501705489 In his recent book, Mark de Rond takes on an extremely difficult task, joining a surgical team deployed at a medical facility in Afghanistan. Rather than aiming to engage in an ‘academic’ and conceptual discussion about the experience, de Rond intends to provide an account of what it is like to be there, that is, ‘what is it really like to be a doctor at war?’ (p. xvii). I took on the task to read this book a bit reluctantly and, at the same time, with curiosity. I was unsure whether I would be able to complete reading the book and write a review, bearing the goriness I was anticipating. I thought I would resign from my task if the book presented human suffering in a very explicit way, like a horror movie that I am never inclined to watch. The fact that I am actually writing this review is proof of one of the aspects in which de Rond’s book is so accomplished. Overall, the book is very accessible and, on occasions, much to my surprise, even enjoyable for a reluctant reader like myself. At the same time, it conveys the horror and complexity of war through the work of a team of surgeons deployed to save lives. In more specific terms, there are two aspects of the book that particularly merit highlighting. First, de Rond takes the reader on a journey involving the main characters of the team, as well as how the work at the ward is organised. His description provides the necessary information in order to understand the life of a team both inside and outside the ward, in the context of lives confined to a space framed by war. The book vividly presents the disjuncture of the everyday concerns and the constant state of emergency that involves responding to military and civilian causalities from both sides of the conflict. Related to this, the book also shows the efforts made by the team, and also by de Rond, to maintain a sense of stability and resign themselves to the realisation that going back to normality outside of the deployment period will not be easy, perhaps even impossible. Second, de Rond’s book presents a clear picture of what it takes to medically manage the horror of human suffering and helps to make sense of the logic behind medical responses in a way that allows one to understand such logics and modes of care. The descriptions of the causalities presented thorough its various chapters offer a brief presentation of each medical case, the type and extent of injures (including the way in which the injury was produced), and some biographical details of each patient. de Rond also provides a concise and balanced account of the reasoning of team members as they face providing medical responses to treat injured persons and, in doing so, decided on the fate of those who came to the ward. Whilst the book offers a clear picture of the various complexities of this working environment, I still felt a sense of frustration since the reader never finds out what happens to the people that have been treated at the ward. It is clear that de Rond is focusing on the experiences of doctors at war – and he masterfully explores this work in a deeply dehumanised context of war, documenting the limits of their engagement beyond the immediacy of the medical emergency care. And yet the child, the man, the US soldier, the Afghan soldier – each of these mutilated bodies is presented with realism, but each one left me wanting to know more about their lives. Another surprise is the large absence of women throughout the book. The reader learns about male victims, perpetrators, and doctors, yet women only appear as nurses in very general and secondary terms (women are not named but men are, for example). Some further reflection on this from de Rond would have been appreciated. Nonetheless, the book as a whole represents an excellent contribution to what can be called the genre of ethnographies of war, a genre that one can only hope will not grow. If humanity ever gets © 2018 Foundation for the Sociology of Health & Illness. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd., 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA 2 Book Review back to its senses and war situations became rare events, de Rond’s work will then stand, most likely, as the best amongst the few. © 2018 Foundation for the Sociology of Health & Illness Lorena Nunez Carrasco University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg