Author's personal copy
Paläontol Z
DOI 10.1007/s12542-012-0155-z
RESEARCH PAPER
Thanetian gastropods from the Mesopotamian high folded zone
in northern Iraq
Mathias Harzhauser • İzzet Hoşgör
Jean-Michel Pacaud
•
Received: 1 May 2012 / Accepted: 24 September 2012
Ó Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2012
Abstract An assemblage of gastropods from the Thanetian of the Kolosh Formation from the Zakho region in
northern Iraq is documented for the first time. The ten
species represent the families Campanilidae Douvillé 1904,
Potamididae H. & A. Adams 1854, Batillariidae Thiele
1929, Thiaridae Gill 1871, Pachychilidae Fischer & Crosse
1892, Cerithiidae Fleming 1822 and Pseudolividae de
Gregorio 1880, suggesting a littoral to shallow sublittoral
depositional environment. Six of the species are new and
five are formally described as new species. At least seven
species are also known from the Thanetian and/or Early
Ypresian of the Ankara region in Turkey. Only a single
species occurs also in the Paleocene of the Paris Basin. No
relation to Paleocene and Eocene faunas of Pakistan and
India is detectable. This points to a considerably bioprovincialism along the northern coast of the Tethys. Consequently we suppose the existence of an Anatolian Province
in the Thanetian/Ypresian Mediterranean Region of the
Tethys Realm, represented by rather homogeneous mollusc
faunas from western Turkey and northern Iraq. Campanile
M. Harzhauser (&)
Geological-Paleontological Department, Natural History
Museum Vienna, Burgring 7, 1010 Vienna, Austria
e-mail: mathias.harzhauser@nhm-wien.ac.at
İ. Hoşgör
TransAtlantic Petroleum Turkey Ltd., Viking Int. Ltd.,
TR-06680 Ankara, Turkey
e-mail: izzet.hosgor@viking-intl.com
J.-M. Pacaud
Centre de Recherche sur la Paléobiodiversité et les
Paléoenvironnements, Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle,
UMR 7207 du CNRS, Case postale 38, 57 rue Cuvier,
75231 Paris cedex 05, France
e-mail: pacaud@mnhn.fr
zakhoense nov. sp., Pyrazopsis hexagonpyramidalis nov.
sp., Pachymelania islamogluae nov. sp., ‘‘Faunus’’ dominicii nov. sp. and Pseudoaluco mesopotamicus nov. sp. are
introduced as new species. Varicipotamides Pacaud &
Harzhauser nov. nom. is proposed as the replacement name
for Exechestoma Cossmann (1889) non Brandt (1837).
Keywords Gastropoda Thanetian Tethys
Biogeography Anatolian Province Iraq
Kurzfassung Erstmals wird eine Gastropoden-Vergesellschaftung aus dem Thanetium der Kolosh-Formation in
der Zakho Region des Nordiraks dokumentiert. Die 10
Arten sind Vertreter der Campanilidae Douvillé 1904,
Potamididae H. & A. Adams 1854, Batillariidae Thiele
1929, Thiaridae Gill 1871, Pachychilidae Fischer & Crosse
1892, Cerithiidae Fleming 1822 und Pseudolividae de
Gregorio 1880, was auf litorale bis flach sublitorale Ablagerungsbedingungen hinweist. Sechs der Arten sind neu
und fünf davon werden formal als neue Arten beschrieben.
Zumindest sieben Arten treten auch im Thanetium und/
oder unterem Ypresium der Region um Ankara in der
Türkei auf. Lediglich eine einzige Art ist auch aus dem
Paleozän des Pariser Beckens bekannt, während keinerlei
Beziehungen zu den paleozänen und eozänen Faunen von
Pakistan und Indien feststellbar sind. Dies deutet auf eine
beachtliche Bioprovinzialisierung entlang der nördlichen
Tethys Küste. Daher wird die Existenz einer Anatolischen
Provinz innerhalb der thanetisch-ypresischen Mediterranen
Region des Tethys Realms diskutiert. Diese zeichnet sich
durch relative homogene Zusammensetzung der Molluskenfaunen von der westlichen Türkei bis in den Nordirak
aus. Campanile zakhoense nov. sp., Pyrazopsis hexagonpyramidalis nov. sp., Pachymelania islamogluae nov. sp.,
‘‘Faunus’’ dominicii nov. sp. und Pseudoaluco
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
mesopotamicus nov. sp. werden als neue Arten eingeführt.
Varicipotamides Pacaud & Harzhauser nov. nom. wird als
Ersatzname für Exechestoma Cossmann (1889) non Brandt
(1837) vorgeschlagen.
al-Mosul area, which lies ca. 50–80 km SES of the Zakho
region. Although the herein presented assemblage comprises only a small collection of shells and few species, it is
the first contribution dealing with Paleocene gastropods
from northern Iraq.
Schlüsselwörter Gastropoda Thanetium Tethys
Biogeographie Anatolische Provinz Irak
Geological setting and age of the gastropod assemblage
Introduction
Our knowledge on the Paleocene and Eocene mollusc
faunas of Eurasia is strongly based on the extraordinary
rich, diverse and well-preserved assemblages of the Paris
Basin. These were largely described already during the
nineteenth and early twentieth centuries in a wealth of
monographs and became the standard for all comparisons
with other Paleocene and Eocene faunas. During the last
decades, the faunas of the North Sea and the polar region
became increasingly well known as well (e.g. Kollmann
and Peel 1985; Pacaud and Schnetler 1999; Schnetler and
Petit 2010; Schnetler 2001). Additional data on Paleocene
faunas from the Ukraine and Poland were provided by
Arkhanguelskt (1904), Makarenko (1969, 1976), Moroz
(1972) and Krach (1963, 1969).
In the western Tethys region, classical Eocene faunas
from Italy and the Balkans became known by numerous
contributions of de Gregorio (1880; 1866), Oppenheim
(e.g. 1894; 1896/1897; 1901; 1912) and Dainelli (1915)
among several others. Soon after, a series of papers
focussed on the Paleocene and Eocene of Pakistan and
India, representing the eastern branch of the Tethys coast
(e.g. Douvillé 1928, 1929; Cox 1930). The huge area in
between, comprising the Arabian and Anatolian plates, has
remained poorly studied, and monographs, comparable to
the French and Italian milestone papers, are completely
missing. After a first description of Eocene molluscs from
Turkey by d’Archiac in Tchihatcheff (1866) and Armenia
by Abich (1882), little attention has been paid to the faunas
up to the first synthesis of Stchépinsky (1946). Only during
the last years, several new papers of Okan and Hoşgör
(2008; 2009), Hoşgör and Okan (2011) and İslamoğlu et al.
(2011) tried to shed light on the Thanetian and Ypresian
mollusc faunas of Western-Central Turkey. Recently,
Hoşgör and Kosták (2012) provided a more detailed
overview on the Upper Cretaceous to Lower Eocene successions in the Hakkari area of SE Turkey. Even less
known is the Iraqi Kurdistan area from where the herein
described assemblage derives. Although the presence of
molluscs is frequently mentioned in reports on the geology
of Iraq, the Paleocene mollusc fauna of the Kolosh formation is nearly unknown. An exception is the description
of a teredinid bivalve by Elliott (1963) from the Duhok and
123
The study area is located in the northern part of Iraq on the
northern Arabian Platform (Fig. 1). Paleogene sediments
are exposed in the northern, western and eastern parts of
northern Iraq. These deposits are well developed in surface
and subsurface sections in northern and northeastern Iraq
(Kassab et al. 1986; Al-Qayim et al. 2008; Sharbazheri
et al. 2009), separated by thrusts and fault zone systems
(Buday 1980) (Fig. 1). Paleocene-Lower Eocene sediments
are most widespread and comprise clastic and carbonate
sediments. These sediments were first identified by Henson
(1951) and Dunnington (1958) who designated a section at
Kolosh, north of Koi Sanjak in the High Folded Zone, as
the type area of the Kolosh formation (Buday 1980). They
described two sedimentary cycles with frequent discontinuous sedimentation in most parts of the basin (Al-Ameri
1996). The Aaliji, Kolosh and Sinjar Limestone Formations
belong to the Paleocene-Lower Eocene cycle and the
Jaddala Formation belongs to the upper Lower EoceneUpper Eocene cycle of the Iraqi platform area (Buday
1980).
The herein described gastropods derive from the
Kolosh Formation. This is an about 180-m-thick alternation of thin sandstone layers with thick shale interlayers.
It is underlain by pelagic marlstone and marly limestone
of the Upper Cretaceous Shiranish Formation (Fig. 1).
Paleontological evidence indicates the occurrence of a
stratigraphic gap that extends from the uppermost Maastrichtian to the Lower Thanetian (Al-Qayim et al. 2008).
The Kolosh Formation is overlain by the Sinjar Limestone
Formation, which displays some interfingering with the
Kolosh Formation in its upper parts (Buday 1980). Its
depositional environment is interpreted as marginal marine to shallow marine (Al-Qayim et al. 1988; 2008). The
sediments of the Kolosh Formation are known also from
other areas of north and northeastern Iraq and are considered to represent a Flysch facies of the Paleogene
Foreland Basin (Dunnington 1958; Bellen et al. 1959; AlQayim et al. 2008).
The herein studied Zakho section is close to Shiranish
village, which is located about 10 km north of Zakho
(Fig. 1). It comprises green to yellow shales, irregularly
alternating with sandstone beds. The shales are rich in
well-preserved calcitic pseudomorphoses of gastropods.
These gastropod-bearing strata of the Kolosh Formation
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
Fig. 1 Geographical and geological setting of the Zakho site (modified from Al-Qayim et al. 2008)
crop out only in the northeastern part of the Zakho area,
along a road strip of 1–2 km width (NW Shiranish Village). To the east, towards the basin margin, gastropods
become increasingly rare and lithologies gradually change
to marginal claystones and sandstones (lower parts of the
Kolosh Formation). The gastropods were collected from
the uppermost fine-grained siliciclastic units (Fig. 2).
The biostratigraphy of the Kolosh Formation was studied by Kassab (1976, 1978) and Kassab et al. (1986) at the
type locality and other locations in the north and northeast
of Iraq. Its age is confirmed by the occurrence of planktonic and benthic foraminifers, which indicate a MiddleLate Paleocene age (Bellen et al. 1959; Kassab 1976, 1978;
Buday 1980; Kassab et al. 1986; Al-Qayim et al. 2008;
Sharbazhari et al. 2009). According to these results, the
formation developed mainly during Middle to early Late
Paleocene times (Al-Qayim et al. 1988), suggesting a
Thanetian age of the gastropod assemblage.
Abbreviations
NHMW
MTA
Naturhistorisches Museum Wien, Austria
Geological Research Department of General
Directorate of Mineral Research and Exploration
of Ankara, Turkey
Systematic paleontology
Class Gastropoda Cuvier 1795
Subclass Caenogastropoda Cox 1960
unassigned order
(formerly as Architaenioglossa Haller 1892, which is
invalid according to Harasewych et al. 1998)
Superfamily Campaniloidea Douvillé 1904
Family Campanilidae Douvillé 1904
Genus Campanile Bayle in Fischer 1884
Type species Cerithium leve Quoy & Gaimard 1834 [non
Perry 1811] by subsequente designation [=Cerithium symbolicum Iredale 1917 nomen novum]. Recent, Australia.
Campanile zakhoense nov. sp. (Fig. 3C, D)
1942
2008
2011
Cerithium (Campanile) sp.—Erünal: 128, 131,
fig. 14
Campanile tchihatcheffi d’Archiac 1850.—Okan &
Hoşgör: 792, fig. 6c [non Cerithium Tchihatcheffi
d’Archiac 1866]
Campanile giganteum (Lamarck 1804).—İslamoğlu
et al.: 312, fig. 5G [non Cerithium giganteum
Lamarck 1804]
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
Fig. 2 Position of the studied samples within the Zakho section
123
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
Holotype NHM 2012/0103/0001,
112 mm, width: 70 mm, sample 93.
(Fig. 3d):
height:
Paratype NHM 2012/0103/0002 (Fig. 3c): 1: height:
75 mm, width: 47 mm, sample 91.
Etymology
Referring to the Zakho area, Iraq.
Type locality
Iraq.
Northeastern Zakho area, Zakho section,
Type horizon Green-grey shale and mudstone of the
Kolosh Formation.
Age
Thanetian
Other material Early Ypresian of Macunköy, Turkey
(MTA-Y-2007-19).
Description Stout conical shell with a spire angle of ca.
35°. The teleoconch whorls are broad and very low, causing a
slightly gradate outline. Early spire whorls are weakly convex whilst the last 2–3 whorls are nearly flat sided. Indistinct
axial swellings on early whorls develop into axially elongate
nodes on later whorls. These nodes are most prominent at the
upper suture and fade out in the middle part of the whorls.
The much weaker spiral sculpture consists of numerous,
slightly wavy, delicate spiral grooves also crossing the axial
sculpture. This spiral sculpture becomes obsolete on the last
whorls. The sigmoidal growth lines are well developed on
the last whorl and consist of an opisthocline upper part and a
steeply prosocyrt lower part. These prosocyrt growth lines
cover the base and coincide with the margin of the outer lip.
The aperture is low, moderately wide; the inner lip forms a
thin callus; no columellar fold is visible in the preserved part
of the aperture but might be present inside; all other parts
have been destroyed.
Remarks The two available shells from Iraq and the
specimen from Macunköy in Turkey (illustrated in İslamoğlu et al. 2011) represent a new, moderately sized
species. It is characterised by the broad and very low teleoconch whorls and the slightly gradate outline. Boussac
(1912: pl. 9, fig. 6) illustrated specimens of Campanile
auvertianum (d’Orbigny 1850) from the Bartonian of
France with a gradate spire, barrel-shaped last whorl and
nodes at the upper suture. Aside from the considerable
stratigraphic gap between both taxa, the Bartonian species
differs in its strongly reduced sculpture on the last teleoconch whorls, the then even more gradate outline and the
more elongate shell. Campanile defrenatum (de Gregorio
1896), from the Bartonian of Roncà (Italy), differs from the
Iraqi species in its extraordinary low spire whorls. The
Lutetian Campanile cornucopiae cornucopiae (Sowerby, J.
1818) from Cotentin (France) and Campanile cornucopiae
benechi (Bayan 1870b) from the Paris Basin (see Boussac
1912: pl. 4, fig. 3 and pl. 7, fig. 2) have a comparable spiral
sculpture and the axial nodes may occur along the upper
suture in early stages of growth. They are clearly distinguished from the Iraqi species by the convexity of the last
two whorls. The otherwise comparable Campanile lachesis
(Bayan 1870a) differs mainly in the position of the nodes,
which appear in a more median position in C. lachesis and
not at the suture. Campanile vicetinum (Bayan 1870a),
which has a comparable sculpture, is also more slender and
its whorls are slightly scalate (see Bayan 1870b and
Oppenheim 1896/97). Campanile leymeriei (d’Archiac
1850), from the Eocene of Safranbolu in northern Anatolia
and Hasanfaki in NW Turkey (Güngör 1975), is also very
similar concerning the shell outline. This species is known
so far only from internal casts but seems to be characterised
by a keel-like adsutural swelling of the last whorl and thus
is clearly distinguished from the Iraqi species.
Distribution Only known so far from the Thanetian of
Northern Iraq and the Late Thanetian to Early Ypresian of
Macunköy in the Haymana-Polatlı Basin in Turkey.
Order Sorbeoconcha Ponder & Lindberg 1997
Superfamily Cerithioidea Fleming 1822
Family Potamididae H. & A. Adams 1854
Genus Eotympanotonus Chavan 1952
Type species Cerithium conarium Bayan 1873 (=Cerithium trochiforme Deshayes 1824 non Lamarck 1804).
Eocene, France.
Eotympanotonus is treated as subgenus of Potamides
Brongniart 1810 by Reid et al. (2008) and as subgenus of
Tympanotonos Schumacher 1817 by Le Renard & Pacaud
(1995). Herein, we treat this taxon as a full genus, which is
well represented by numerous species during the Paleocene-Eocene of Eurasia.
Eotympanotonus nov. sp. (Fig. 4A, B)
Material Two shells from samples 92 and 91 (NHMW
2012/0103/0003); height: 42 mm; width: 17 mm.
Description A rather slender shell consisting of [8
teleoconch whorls with an apical angle of 27°. Early spire
whorls are high and barrel-shaped, slightly gradate and
bear four prominent spiral cords, separated by narrow and
deep grooves. The one at the upper suture bears small
nodes; the one below has weaker and spirally elongate
nodes, whilst the lower two cords are smooth. Within the
third and fourth (preserved) whorl, the interspace between
the two adapical cords becomes wider and the nodes on the
second cord increase in strength. Subsequently, these nodes
become most prominent and the outline of the whorl is
slightly convex with the maximum diameter coinciding
with this spiral cord. Simultaneously, the adsutural nodes
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
123
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
b Fig. 3 Thanetian gastropods from Zakho (Iraq). A, B: Pyrazopsis
hexagonpyramidalis nov. sp., A: holotype (NHM 2012/0103/0006),
B: paratype: NHM 2012/0103/0007). C, D; Campanile zakhoense
nov. sp., C: paratype (NHM 2012/0103/0002), D: holotype (NHM
2012/0103/0001). Scale bar corresponds to 10 mm
become weaker and the separating interspace grades into a
wide and smooth concavity. The last whorl is moderately
convex with a rather straight-sided lower part, which passes rapidly into the convex base. A weak posterior notch
coincides with the second spiral cord, which now forms a
weak angulation. Aperture largely destroyed; columella
concave; inner lip poorly demarcated from the base.
Remarks The early spire whorls, with the beaded adsutural upper spiral cord and the smooth lower spiral cords,
are reminiscent of the French Early Eocene Eotympanotonus funatus rillyensis (Cossmann 1889) and E. turris
(Deshayes 1833). The ontogenetic change from the adsutural spiral cord to the second spiral cord as the main spiral
element is a unique feature of the Iraqi species and distinguishes it from all French Eocene species described by
Cossmann and Pissarro (1911) and others. A specimen
from the Late Thanetian to Early Ypresian of Macunköy in
the Haymana-Potatlı Basin in Turkey, described as Batillaria diacanthina Cossmann 1898 by Okan and Hoşgör
(2008), might be conspecific with the Iraqi species.
Distribution
Iraq.
Only known from the Thanetian of northern
Family Batillariidae Thiele 1929
Genus Vicinocerithium Wood 1910
Type species Vicinocerithium parallelum Wood 1910
(=Cerithium bouei Deshayes 1833). Eocene, Paris Basin.
Vicinocerithium seni İslamoğlu, Dominici & Kowalke
2011. (Fig. 4D–H)
*2011
Vicinocerithium seni n. sp.—İslamoğlu et al.: 322,
figs 7E, G, I
Material Six shells from sample 92 (NHMW 2012/0103/
0004); maximum height: 42 mm, diameter: 21 mm.
Description Conical shells with an apical angle of ca.
30°. The early 4–5 teleoconch whorls bear wide spaced,
blunt, axial ribs, roughly aligned on successive whorls. On
later whorls, the axial sculpture of each whorl has a slight
offset in respect to the preceding whorl. On the last four
teleoconch whorls, these axial ribs disintegrate into axially
arranged nodes. A weaker row of nodes appears near the
upper suture, adjoined by a more prominent row of pointed
and spirally elongate nodes in the middle of the whorls.
This row forms the periphery of the whorls and is separated
from the upper one by a deep concavity on the last whorl.
The densely spaced spiral cords override the axial ribs on
early whorls. Later, the spiral cords become weak in the
upper half of the whorls and form 4–5 prominent cords in
the lower part below the middle row of nodes. The suture is
moderately incised and wavy because of the adsutural
nodes. The last whorl is somewhat allometric, slightly
broader than the spire whorls; it contracts rapidly into the
short and convex base. Inner lip well developed, glossy and
well demarcated from the base. Outer lip and siphonal
canal are destroyed.
Remarks The full generic rank of Vicinocerithium was
proposed by Pacaud (2007) and Ozawa et al. (2009) and is
followed herein. Although formerly intermingled with
Batillaria, a purely Indo-West Pacific (IWP) genus, Ozawa
et al. (2009) pointed out that the indeterminate growth
allows a clear separation of both taxa. The Early Eocene
French Vicinocerithium subacutum (d’Orbigny 1850) bears
some resemblance to the Turkish-Iraqi species. Especially
the two spiral rows of spiny nodes and the broad concavity
between them appear in both species. A clear difference is
the much broader apical angle and the prominent axial ribs
on early spire whorls of V. seni.
The Lutetian-Bartonian Vicinocerithium calcitrapoides
britannum (Vasseur 1881) is comparable in shape and also
develops relatively broad shells but lacks the conspicuous
adsutural row of nodes. The wide concavity between the adapical suture and the prominent spiral row of nodes in the
middle of the last whorl is also developed by the Eocene
Vicinocerithium sieberi (Kochansky-Devidé 1956). This Croatian species, however, is very slender and lacks spiral cords.
Distribution This species was recently described from
the Ypresian of the Ankara region in Turkey.
Vicinocerithium sp. (Fig. 4C)
1942
1946
2011
Batillaria subacuta d’Orbigny.—Erünal: 128, 131,
figs 11–12
Batillaria subacuta d’Orbigny.—Stchépinsky: 55,
pl. 22, figs 19–20 (non Cerithium subacutum
d’Orbigny 1850)
Vicinocerithium cf. subacutum (d’Orbigny 1850).—
İslamoğlu et al.: 321, fig. 6B–F (non Cerithium
subacutum d’Orbigny 1850)
Material One fragmentary specimen from sample 95
(NHMW 2012/0103/0005); diameter: 19.8 mm, height:
39.5 mm.
Description A high conical shell of more than 8 teleoconch whorls and an apical angle of 26°. Juvenile
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
123
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
b Fig. 4 Thanetian gastropods from Zakho (Iraq). A, B: Eotympanot-
onus nov. sp. (NHMW 2012/0103/0003); C: Vicinocerithium sp.
(NHMW 2012/0103/0005); D–H: Vicinocerithium seni İslamoğlu,
Dominici & Kowalke 2011 (NHMW 2012/0103/0004); I: Pseudobellardia ankaraensis (İslamoğlu, Dominici & Kowalke 2011)
(NHMW 2012/0103/0008). Scale bar corresponds to 10 mm
teleoconch whorls are moderately convex with incised
sutures and low axial ribs. These are crossed by five spiral
cords causing a beaded sculpture. After 3–4 whorls the
upper two spiral cords become wide spaced and develop
spiny nodes. The lower of these spiral rows of nodes
becomes most prominent and shifts into the middle of the
rather flat whorls. Consequently, the remaining three spiral
cords become densely crowded and slightly irregularly
wavy. Similarly, the now only weakly incised suture is
wavy. The base is very short and covered by about six
faintly granulose spiral cords. A moderately deep shoulder
sinus coincides with the spiral row of nodes on the last
whorl, expressed by strong growth lines on the last three
whorls. The aperture is destroyed.
Remarks This species differs from Vicinocerithium seni,
which is otherwise quite similar, in the flat-sided teleoconch whorls and the indistinct, weakly incised suture.
Moreover, early spire whorls lack the predominant axial
ribs of V. seni and the nodes are spiny instead of rounded.
A comparison with the specimens from the Ypresian of the
Ankara region, described by İslamoğlu et al. (2011) as
Vicinocerithium cf. subacutum (d’Orbigny 1850), suggests
that they are conspecific with the Iraqi shell. Indeed,
Vicinocerithium subacutum (d’Orbigny 1850) [=Cerithium
acutum Deshayes 1833 non Potamides acutus Sowerby, J.
1822], as illustrated by Cossmann & Pissarro (1911: pl. 29,
fig. 152–3), seems to be morphologically related. However,
it differs in its higher base and keel-like median spiral cord
on early spire whorls. Moreover, the specimen originally
described by Deshayes (1833) as Cerithium acutum is more
slender and lacks the spiny nodes at the suture.
Distribution This species is known from the Thanetian
of northern Iraq and from the Ypresian of the Ankara
region in Turkey (Stchépinsky 1946; İslamoğlu et al.
2011).
Genus Pyrazopsis Akopjan 1972
Type species Muricites pentagonatus von Schlotheim
1820, Eocene, Italy.
Pyrazopsis hexagonpyramidalis nov. sp. (Fig. 3A, B)
2008
Cerithium fodicatum Bellardi 1852.—Okan &
Hoşgör: 792, fig. 6h [non Cerithium fodicatum
Bellardi 1852]
Holotype NHM 2012/0103/0006,
77.2 mm, width: 36.0 mm.
(Fig. 3a):
height:
Paratype NHM 2012/0103/0007 (Fig. 3b): 1: height:
61.5 mm, width: 41.0 mm.
Etymology
pyramid.
Referring to the shape of a hexagonal
Type locality
Iraq.
Northeastern Zakho area, Zakho section,
Type horizon Green-grey shale and mudstone of the
Kolosh Formation.
Age
Thanetian
Description A very characteristic shell with a hexagonal
cross section consisting of more than eight teleoconch whorls
(protoconch and earliest teleoconch are missing). The nearly
completely flat whorls form six continuous flanks, separated
by weakly rounded edges, which continue along the entire
shell; the sutures are indistinct. Only the first ca. 4–5 spire
whorls, though also completely flat, lack the hexagonal flanks.
On late teleoconch whorls, the flanks tend to become even
slightly concave and the angulations are weakly droplet-like
and swollen. The apical angle is quite variable, ranging from
30–40°. The transition from flanks into the moderately convex
base is abrupt. No additional sculpture is visible because of the
preservation. The aperture is largely destroyed, showing a
moderately concave columella and narrow inner lip; broad
and indistinct spiral cords cover the base. A cross section of
one of the specimens revealed a completely smooth columella
without folds or twist and an ovoid-subquadratic cross section
of the spire whorls.
The Iraqi specimens lack the aperture. This, however, is
partly preserved in a specimen from the Late Thanetian or
Early Ypresian of Macunköy in Turkey (Okan and Hoşgör
2008). The following additions are based on that specimen:
The last whorl has convex flanks and slightly raised axial
ribs, which are separated by weakly concave interspaces.
The base contracts rapidly and is only slightly convex.
Remarks The unusual shape of a hexagonal pyramid is
unique. Nevertheless, without proper information on the
aperture, the systematic placement of this strange species
remains problematic. The columellar structure fits best to
the Batillariidae sensu Ozawa et al. (2009). Among these,
only Pyrazisinus Heilprin 1887 and Pyrazopsis Akopjan
1972 develop comparable morphologies with robust shells
and a wide apical angle. Pyrazisinus is represented by its
type species P. campanulatus Heilprin 1887, from the
Early Miocene of Florida, and by P. monstrosus, from the
Oligocene and Early Miocene of France, Italy and Greece
(Lesport and Cahuzac 2002; Harzhauser 2004). These
species have low and convex spire whorls with numerous,
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
more or less prominent axial ribs. No tendency to align the
ribs on successive whorls is documented from this genus.
This feature, however, is observed in some species of
Pyrazopsis Akopjan 1972 (=Gantechinobathra Kowalke
2001, type species: Muricites pentagonatus von Schlotheim 1820 is invalid; junior objective synonym). Akopjan
(1972) included the French Eocene Muricites pentagonatus
von Schlotheim 1820 and Murex angulatus Solander in
Brander 1766 in his new genus and Ozawa et al. (2009)
added Pyrazus expansus Douvillé 1928 (Paleocene, Pakistan), Pyrazus khani Iqbal 1969 (Eocene, Pakistan) and
Pyrazus fresvillensis (Cossmann & Pissarro 1902) (Eocene,
France). Pyrazus nuttalli Douvillé 1929 (Paleocene, Pakistan), Cerithium polygonum Leymerie 1846, Cerithium
spectabilis Deshayes 1864, Pyrazus angustus Doncieux
1908, Faunus farinensis Doncieux 1908, Pyrazus praeangulatus Doncieux 1908, Pyrazus vidali Doncieux 1908,
Potamides plateaui Cossmann 1889 and Cerithium laterostrictum Boussac 1911, from the Eocene of France, are
further species that belong to Pyrazopsis. All these species
tend to arrange the axial ribs in line on successive whorls.
Especially Pyrazopsis expansus (Douvillé 1928) is also
comparable in respect to the broad apical angle and large
size. The strong axial sculpture of all these species clearly
differs from the Iraqi species and thus the generic assignment remains doubtful. Pyrazopsis arapovicensis (Oppenheim 1909), from the Eocene of Bosnia, has strongly raised
axial ribs but is otherwise comparable concerning the strict
alignment of the axial elements.
Among the Potamididae, only Telescopium Montfort
1810, with the Extant IWP-type species Telescopium
telescopium (Linnaeus 1758), has a comparable broad
conical shell. The strong columellar fold of Telescopium,
however, excludes an assignment of the Iraqi species to this
genus. The morphologically closest species is Campanile
brookamani Cox 1930 from the Thanetian of Pakistan. It
has the same broad apical angle, lacks incised sutures and
has no significant sculpture. The circular outline of the
whorls, however, is clearly different from the hexagonal
one of the Iraqi species. Moreover it develops two columellar folds. The absence of columellar folds is not a strict
criterion to exclude this species from the Campaniloidea as
the Extant C. symbolicum (Iredale 1917) also has a smooth
columella (Sälgeback and Savazzi 2006). Nevertheless, as
columellar folds are typical in Paleogene representatives of
Campanile, a closer relation seems unlikely. Benoistia
pyramidata Cossmann 1906, from the Pyrenean Eocene, is
also pyramidal with flat flanks but is very stout, much
smaller and develops spiral rows of granules.
Okan and Hoşgör (2008) described this species as
Cerithium fodicatum from the Late Thanetian or Early
Ypresian of the Haymana-Polatlı Basin in Turkey. Whilst
123
the Turkish specimens are undoubtedly conspecific with
those from Iraq, they are definitely not comparable with
Cerithium fodicatum Bellardi 1852 from the Bartonian of
Nice in France. The French species is slender and has
prominent axial ribs, which are not arranged in line on
successive whorls.
Distribution Only known so far from the Thanetian of
northern Iraq and the Late Thanetian or Early Ypresian of
the Haymana-Polatlı Basin in Turkey.
Family Thiaridae Gill 1871
Genus Pseudobellardia Cox 1931
[=Gantmelanatria Kowalke 2001]
Type species Muricites auriculatus von Schlotheim 1820.
Middle Eocene, Northern Italy.
Pseudobellardia ankaraensis (İslamoğlu, Dominici &
Kowalke 2011) nov. comb. (Fig. 4I)
* 2011
Bellatara ankaraensis n. sp.—İslamoğlu et al.:
316, figs. 6G, S
Material One fragmentary shell from sample 96
(NHMW 2012/0103/0008); maximum diameter: 18.5 mm;
height: [37 mm.
Description The specimen consists of a conical spire of
[7 weakly convex whorls with an apical angle of 31°. Its
sculpture is strongly reduced and comprises very indistinct
and low axial swellings, which are most prominent close to
the upper and lower sutures. The last whorl is stout, barrelshaped with subparallel flanks passing via a weak angulation into the short base. A keel-like swelling develops
somewhat below the suture on the dorsal side of the last
whorl. This swelling bears six spiny nodes that increase in
size toward the aperture. About six beaded spiral cords
appear below the keel and several weaker spiral cords
cover the base. The ovoid aperture is partly destroyed. The
posterior part consists of a thick callus, which coincides
with the last node of the keel. A narrow slit-like posterior
canal is incised into this callus. The inner lip is also thick
and is separated by a narrow chink from the base.
Remarks The available specimen agrees well with
Pseudobellardia ankaraensis from the Ypresian of Turkey.
A comparison with type material from Ankara showed that
the Turkish specimens form more prominent nodes on the
last whorl and well-developed axial ribs on the spire whorls.
In respect to the variability of this group, these differences in
sculpture might well range within the morphological range
of this species. Nevertheless, the identification remains
somewhat doubtful unless more Iraqi material is available.
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
The generic affiliation of the Iraqi and Turkish shells is
also questionable as the aperture is only partly known. The
Turkish species was originally described as Bellatara
Strand 1928 by İslamoğlu et al. (2011). All species of this
large-sized genus have a superficial similarity with
Pseudobellardia but lack the thiarid aperture with the
callous or deeply incised posterior canal (see Sälgeback
and Savazzi 2006) but develop a conspicuous anterior
canal (cf. Woodring 1957). Moreover, the dense axial
sculpture of the much shorter spire is untypical for all
known species of Bellatara. Pseudobellardia auriculata
(von Schlotheim 1820) lacks the prominent callus of the
aperture and its last whorl is convex instead of barrelshaped. Pseudobellardia manfredi (Oppenheim 1909),
from the Eocene of Bosnia, might be a related species. It
has a comparable outline, with a keeled and nodulose last
whorl, conical spire and strongly callous adapical part of
the aperture. It is distinguished from the Iraqi specimen by
its conspicuous axial ribs on the spire whorl and the wider
apical angle. Pseudobellardia delphinus (Oppenheim
1901), from the Eocene of Bosnia, has a coeloconoid spire
and a smooth shell surface.
The type species of Pseudobellardia Cox 1931 is Muricites auriculatus von Schlotheim 1820 (as illustrated by
Oppenheim 1894, Dainelli 1915 and Sälgeback and Savazzi 2006). Kowalke (2001) has chosen the same species as
the type for Gantmelanatria, which is thus a junior
objective synonym.
Distribution Pseudobellardia ankaraensis is known
from the early Ypresian of western Turkey and the Thanetian of northern Iraq.
Genus Pachymelania Smith 1893
Type species Nerita aurita Müller 1774; by typification
of replaced name (nom. nov. pro Claviger Haldeman 1842
non Preyssler 1790 [Insecta]. Recent, Angola.
Pachymelania islamogluae nov. sp. (Fig. 5e–h)
Material
Four specimens from sample 96.
Holotype NHM 2012/0103/0009,
39.6 mm, width: 19.8 mm.
(Fig. 5E):
height:
Paratype NHM 2012/0103/0010, (Fig. 5f): 1: height:
32.8 mm, width: 20.6 mm.
Additional material Two fragments NHM 2012/0103/
0011 (Figs 5g, h); the largest fragment suggests a maximum height of ca. 55–60 mm height and has a maximum
diameter of 24 mm.
Etymology In honour of the palaeontologist Yesim
İslamoğlu (MTA, Ankara).
Type locality
Iraq.
Northeastern Zakho area, Zakho section,
Type horizon Green-grey shale and mudstone of the
Kolosh Formation.
Age
Thanetian
Description Medium-sized shells with strongly scalate
outline (sensu Beu and Maxwell 1990). Early spire whorls
(ca. 5) are conical with more or less flat flanks, which are
subparallel to the axis. At that stage, the spire is gradate
and the whorls bear prominent axial ribs, which are crossed
by four spiral cords. The lower three spiral cords form
spirally elongate nodes at the intersections with the axial
ribs, whilst the upper spiral develops rounded nodes. The
last 2–3 whorls become strongly scalate with spiny nodes
at the shoulder, which delimits a narrow sutural shelf.
Seven to eight of these strongly protruding nodes are
developed on the last whorl; the nodes are trigonal in apical
view and are oriented perpendicular to the axis. The spiral
cords increase in number to 9–10 on the last whorl and are
slightly wavy because of the intersections with the now less
distinct axial ribs. A weak concavity appears below the
shoulder and the weakly convex base contracts slowly into
a moderately long, twisted canal. Aperture elongate ovoid
with short posterior canal; inner lip well developed; columella strongly concave in the upper half and convex at the
transition into the anterior canal. The available specimens
suggest some variability concerning the height/width ratio,
the height of the whorls and the strength of the spiral
sculpture, which may be strongly reduced.
Remarks The change in sculpture and outline from
juvenile to adult teleoconchs is comparable with that of the
extant Pachymelania fusca (Gmelin 1791) from West
Africa and the Cretaceous Pachymelania wyomingensis
(Meek 1873) (see Hartman 1998). The assignment to
Pachymelania remains questionable as the presence of a
distinct siphonal canal is untypical for extant representatives of this genus. Bandel and Kowalke (1999) describe
the typical Pachymelania aperture as ovate to subangular
with a narrow anterior canal and a broad basal notch. This
anterior indentation of the aperture is best developed in P.
aurita (Müller 1774), P. byronensis (Wood 1828) and P.
fusca but never attains the shape of the Thanetian species.
Few species with comparably scalate spires and prominent
nodes at the shoulder have been described so far from the
Eurasian Paleogene. Melanoides thezanensis (Doncieux
1903), from the Thanetian of Thézan-des-Corbières in
S-France, is comparable but differs clearly in its very
slender shell and much higher spire whorls. The systematic
placement of this species is unclear as the anterior part of
the aperture is unknown (see Doncieux 1903, p. 317, pl. 2,
figs 1a–f; Cossmann 1909, p. 128, pl. 2, fig. 24). Cerithium
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
123
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
b Fig. 5 Thanetian gastropods from Zakho (Iraq). A–D: ‘‘Faunus’’
dominicii nov. sp. (NHMW 2012/0103/0012); E–H: Pachymelania
islamogluae nov. sp., E: holotype (NHM 2012/0103/0009), F:
paratype (NHM 2012/0103/0010), G–H: additional material (NHM
2012/0103/0011). Scale bar corresponds to 10 mm
Locality
Horizon Green-grey shale and mudstone of the Kolosh
Formation.
Age
puigcercosense sensu İslamoğlu, Dominici & Kowalke
2011 (misidentification) [non Cossmann 1898], from the
Ypresian of the Anakara region in Turkey, is morphologically very close to Melanoides thezanensis Doncieux
1903 and thus differs from the Iraqi species also in its
very slender shell and the long and barrel-shaped last
whorl. The Turkish shells, which were considered as
conspecific with the Spanish Eocene Batillaria puigcercosensis Cossmann 1898 by İslamoğlu et al. (2011), are
clearly unrelated with that small, conical Spanish species
with its short last whorl (see Cossmann 1898, pl. 8,
figs 1–4). It might rather be related to Cerithium deprati
Oppenheim 1909 from the Eocene of Bosnia, which
seems to differ only in the less scalate whorls. Cerithium
jablaui Oppenheim 1909 from the Eocene of Bosnia
might represent a related species but is less gradate.
Terebralia (Gravesicerithium) labiata (Deshayes 1833)
also displays a change in sculpture from a beaded-granulose subadult shell to a rather smooth adult shell with
prominent adsutural spines but lacks the gradate spire and
is slender (see Belliard and Gain 2007).
Distribution Known so far only from the Thanetian of
northern Iraq.
Family Pachychilidae Fischer & Crosse 1892
Genus Faunus auctores non Montfort, 1810
‘‘Faunus’’ dominicii nov. sp. (Figs. 5A–D, 6)
1964
2011
Batillaria loparense Oppenheim.—Čičič: 151, pl.
10, figs. 3–5
‘‘Cerithiid’’ indet.—İslamoğlu et al.: 316, fig. 7H
Holotype NHMW 2008z0310/0004 (Fig. 6): height:
51.6 mm, width: 24.9 mm.
Etymology In honour of the palaeontologist Stefano
Dominici. (Museo di Storia Naturale, Università di
Firenze).
Type locality
Mucanköy, SW Ankara, Turkey
Type horizon
Grey siltstone, Kırkkavak Formation
Age
Ypresian
Additional material Four fragmentary shells (NHMW
2012/0103/0012) from samples 91, 92 and 95; height:
47 mm, diameter: 26; the largest fragment suggests a total
height of more than 70 mm.
Northeastern Zakho area, Zakho section, Iraq.
Thanetian
Description Large, turreted shells with slender early teleoconch and an apical angle of ca. 25°. The early teleoconch whorls are moderately convex with incised sutures.
Five very prominent convex axial ribs are crossed by 6–8
sharp and distinct spiral cords. The interspaces between the
axial ribs are about two times wider than the axial ribs. The
arrangement of the axial ribs may be nearly aligned on
successive whorls, forming a slightly oblique line across
the entire shell in some specimens. On the last whorls, this
arrangement is less strict or completely lost. A secondary
spiral cord is intercalated between each pair of primary
spiral cords on later whorls, and tertiary threads occur as
well. All these spiral cords become very prominent on the
last teleoconch whorls and are strongest when intersecting
with the axial ribs. The convexity of the whorls increases in
late stages of growth and on the last two whorls the axial
ribs start to form protuberant nodes in the middle of the
whorls. This causes a narrow sutural ramp with a wavy
suture. The aperture is wide and ovoid with a wide outer lip
and narrow inner lip. The columella is convex and passes
into the slightly twisted anterior canal. The angulation of
the last whorl, which bears strong nodes, coincides with a
deep notch. This is also indicated on earlier parts of the last
whorl by a sinus of the growth lines.
Remarks A comparison with the specimen illustrated by
İslamoğlu et al. (2011, p. 316, fig. 7H) as ‘‘Cerithiid’’ indet., stored in the NHMW collection, suggests that the Iraqi
specimens are conspecific with that species. As this species
is much better preserved than the Iraqi shells, we propose
the Turkish shell as holotype. A difference is the less
pronounced spiral sculpture of the Turkish shell, which is
only a matter of preservation.
This species is close to a group of Paleogene species,
which were usually treated as Melanatria Bowdich 1822
(e.g. Pacaud and Le Renard 1995; Pacaud 2007) with
Melania cuvieri Deshayes 1825 as typical representative.
Recently, Köhler and Glaubrecht (2010) documented that
the widely used names Pirena and Melanatria are junior
synonyms of Faunus Montfort 1810. Neither the TurkishIraqi Paleocene-Eocene species nor Melania cuvieri Deshayes 1825 can be placed in Faunus, which has smooth
shells and a conspicuous anterior siphonal notch. Köhler
and Glaubrecht (2010) introduced Madagasikara as new
genus rank name for the Extant species that were traditionally treated as Melanatria and showed that this Madagascan lineage did not evolve before Oligocene or even
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
Fig. 6 Holotype of ‘‘Faunus’’ dominicii nov. sp., (NHMW 2008z0310/0004) from the Early Ypresian of Mucanköy, SW Ankara, Turkey. Scale
bar corresponds to 10 mm
Miocene times. Therefore, the much older Eurasian taxa
cannot be placed in Madagasikara as well. Consequently,
Pacaud and Harzhauser (submitted) propose Moniquia as a
new genus for several Paleocene and Eocene species, such
as Cerithium suzanna d’Orbigny 1850 and Cerithium fodicatum Bellardi 1852. Unfortunately, this paper is still
unpublished and the new genus name not yet available.
Therefore, we decided to treat the new species provisionally as ‘‘Faunus’’.
A characteristic feature of this species is the deep posterior notch at the angulation of the last whorl. This feature
also allows a separation of the Asian pachychilid Brotia
Adams 1866, which was frequently used for European
fossil species. A somewhat reminiscent species is ‘‘Faunus’’ vulcanicus (von Schlotheim 1820) from the Eocene of
Italy, which also has prominent nodes on the last whorl
(Dainelli 1915; Turco Stella 1976). It differs from ‘‘F.’’
dominicii in the comparatively more adsutural position and
the distinct adapical orientation of the nodes. Moreover, it
lacks nodes on the penultimate whorl.
Specimens from the Middle Eocene of Bosnia described
by Čičič (1964) as Batillaria loparense Oppenheim seem
to be conspecific with ‘‘F.’’ dominicii and agree in outline
and sculpture. The preservation of the Bosnian shells,
123
however, is too fragmentary for a clear identification. In
any case, they are not conspecific with Cerithium (Batillaria) loparense Oppenheim 1901, which is more slender,
has a reduced spiral sculpture and lower whorls. Cerithium
(Batillaria) loparense of Oppenheim 1912 is a Vicinocerithium, which differs from ‘‘F.’’ dominicii especially in its
angulated early teleoconch whorls and the two spiral cords
in the middle of the late teleoconch whorls.
The species is reminiscent of members of the batillariid
genus Pyrazopsis Akopjan 1972. Many of its species tend
to arrange the axial ribs in line on successive whorls and
have a wide, flaring aperture with a well-developed
siphonal canal. None of them, however, develop a posterior
notch at the angulation of the last whorl. A second genus
that develops comparable morphologies is the potamidid
genus Exechestoma Cossmann (1889) with the type species
Cerithium angulosum Lamarck 1804 from the Eocene of
the Paris Basin. This large-sized and usually strongly
sculptured genus comprises a large number of Eocene
species (see Cossmann 1897; Pacaud and Le Renard 1995;
Belliard and Gain 2007). Especially the spiny morphs of
E. angulosum (Lamarck 1804) and E. armoricus (Vasseur
1882) are reminiscent of the Iraqi species. Aside from
differences in the sculpture of the early spire whorls, the
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
circular aperture of Exechestoma clearly differs from the
Turkish type specimen of ‘‘Faunus’’ dominicii.
Type species Cerithium jussieui Mayer-Eymar 1876.
Middle Eocene, Paris Basin.
Distribution Only known so far from the Thanetian of
northern Iraq and the Early Ypresian of the Ankara region
in western Turkey.
Pseudoaluco mesopotamicus nov. sp. (Fig. 7A, B)
A note on Varicipotamides Pacaud & Harzhauser nom.
nov. pro Exechestoma Cossmann (1889) non Brandt
(1837)
Exechestoma was introduced by Cossmann (1889) as a new
section with Cerithium angulosum Lamarck 1804 as type
species [Exechostoma Cossmann & Pissarro 1911 [non
Exochostoma Macquart 1842, Insecta] is an incorrect
subsequent spelling of Exechestoma Cossmann 1889]. The
taxon was introduced by Cossmann (1889) to separate a
group of species with shells decorated by varicose ribs
from Potamides (s.str.). The taxon name Exechestoma,
however, was already preoccupied by Brandt (1837) for a
subgenus of the Medusozoa genus Aequorea. Therefore,
we propose Varicipotamides as new name, referring to the
typical sculpture of most species of this genus. Sälgeback
and Savazzi (2006) treated the type species of Exechestoma
as Potamides. In contrast, Ozawa et al. (2009) accepted the
genus-level rank and considered this species group as
belonging to the Potamididae based on the presence of
spire varices, which contradict a placement in Batillariidae.
The type species is Varicipotamides angulosus (Lamarck
1804) from the Bartonian of the Paris Basin.
Family Cerithiidae Fleming 1822
Genus Pseudoaluco Clark & Durham 1946
Material
Two specimens from sample 95.
Holotype NHM 2012/0103/0013
40.0 mm, width: 14.9 mm.
(Fig. 7a):
height:
Paratype NHM 2012/0103/0014 (Fig. 7b): 1: height:
36.0 mm, width: 14.4 mm.
Etymology
Referring to ancient Mesoptomia.
Type locality
Iraq.
Northeastern Zakho area, Zakho section,
Type horizon Green-grey shale and mudstone of the
Kolosh Formation.
Age
Thanetian.
Description Slender conical shells with an apical angle
of 25°. The more than eight teleoconch whorls are flat and
separated by weak sutures, causing a slightly gradate outline. Blunt axial ribs with convex backs are the predominant sculpture. Four weaker spiral cords cross the axial ribs
on the early teleoconch, forming spirally elongate nodes at
the intersections. Within the 4–5th teleoconch whorl, the
axial ribs start to develop nodes at the upper suture and two
or three weaker nodes below. A broad concavity with
indistinct secondary spiral threads is developed between
the upper two rows of nodes on the last two whorls. The
middle row of nodes becomes more prominent on the last
Fig. 7 Thanetian gastropods from Zakho (Iraq). A, B: Pseudoaluco mesopotamicus nov. sp., A: holotype (NHM 2012/0103/0013), B: paratype
(NHM 2012/0103/0014); C1–3: Popenoeum primum (Defrance 1827) (NHMW 2012/0103/0015). Scale bar corresponds to 10 mm
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
whorl, coinciding with the maximum diameter. Its convex
base is covered by numerous spiral cords. The aperture is
wide ovoid with a short posterior canal, adjoined by a weak
parietal swelling; the columella develops a well-defined
inner lip. The outer lip and siphonal canal are destroyed.
Remarks The aperture with the denticle-like parietal
swelling supports an assignment to Pseudoaluco. The type
species Pseudoaluco jussieui (Mayer-Eymar 1876) is
clearly distinguished from the Iraqi species by its pupoid
outline and delicate sculpture (see Cossmann and Pissarro
1911). Pseudaluco obesus (Deshayes 1833) as originally
described by (Deshayes 1833, p. 378, pl. 56, figs 7–8) is
broader; its axial ribs are weaker and fade out within the
upper half of the whorls, which develop a weak angulation
close below the upper suture. Bouniol (1981) presents a
Pseudoaluco obesus (Deshayes 1833) from the Thanetian of
France, which has an overall comparable shape but is distinguished by its higher last whorl, the more gradate spire
and the lack of adsutural nodes. The Paleocene Pseudoaluco carolinus (d’Orbigny 1850) of the Paris and Belgian
basins is comparable with the Iraqi species concerning the
axial sculpture but is more slender and has convex whorls
[Cerithium bellovacinum Deshayes 1864 is a subjective
synonym of Cerithium carolinus d’Orbigny 1850].
Distribution Only known so far from the Thanetian of
northern Iraq.
Order Caenogastropoda Cox 1960
Superfamily Muricoidea Rafinesque 1815
Family Pseudolividae de Gregorio 1880
Genus Popenoeum Squires in Squires, Zinsmeister &
Paredes-Mejia 1989
Type species Popenoeum maritimus Squires, Zinsmeister
& Paredes-Mejia 1989. Paleocene, California.
Popenoeum primum (Defrance 1827). (Fig 7C)
* 1827
1911
1970
1998
1999
2009
Struthiolaria prima Defrance: 158
Pseudoliva prima Defrance.—Cossmann &
Pissarro, pl. 37, fig. 177–4
Pseudoliva prima (Defrance).— Villatte: 23, pl.
1, figs 1–10 (cum syn.)
Popenoeum primum (Defrance 1827).— Pacaud:
19, fig. 14
Popenoeum primum (Defrance 1827).— Pacaud
& Schnetler: 56
Popenoeum primum (Defrance 1827).— Pacaud:
6
Material One fragmentary shell from sample 95 (NHMW
2012/0103/0015); diameter: [22 mm, height: [35 mm.
123
Description Medium sized, ovoid shell. The early spire
whorls are gradate and flat sided; the flanks are subparallel
to the shell axis. Prominent, rather sharp axial ribs form the
sculpture, crossed by much weaker spiral threads. Rounded
nodes appear on the adapical tips of the axial ribs on the
last spire whorl and a second weak row of nodes appears
close to the lower suture. On the last whorl, these nodes
become very prominent whilst the axial ribs between the
nodes are weak and finally obsolete. The upper row of
nodes coincides with a strong shoulder that delimitates a
canaliculate sutural shelf. This bears strong, prosocline
axial ledges, which amalgamate into regularly spaced ribs
close to the aperture. The flank is moderately convex; only
the area between the shoulder nodes and the lower row of
nodes is slightly concave. A deep mid-whorl spiral groove,
as typical for many pseudolivids, marks the transition from
the flank into the slowly contracting, weakly convex base.
A dense spiral pattern of slightly wavy spiral threads
covers the last whorl. The aperture is largely destroyed; the
columella is weakly convex and passes into a slightly
twisted siphonal canal; the inner lip develops a thin, sheetlike callus that covers parts of the base.
Remarks Villatte (1970), Pacaud (1998; 2009) and
Pacaud and Schnetler (1999) describe this species as quite
variable in shape and sculpture. The specimen from Iraq
differs from most of the western European specimens in its
less slender shape, the very prominent nodes and the welldeveloped second row of nodes. Therefore, it might represent a spiny eastern subspecies or even species. The
fragmentary preservation and the lack of any apertural
features, however, do not allow clarifying this problem.
Popenoeum lacunosum Pacaud & Schnetler 1999 from the
Paleocene of West Greenland differs in its ovoid shape and
conical spire. It lacks nodes and has a prominent spiral
sculpture. Popenoeum bajaensis Squires, Zinsmeister &
Paredes-Mejia 1989 from the Thanetian of California has a
comparable outline with a gradate spire but has blunt and
slightly sigmoidal axial ribs without nodes.
Distribution Popenoeum primum is a widespread species
during the Danian and Thanetian. Along the northern
Tethys coast it is recorded from France, Austria, Poland
and Russia (Villatte 1970). Pacaud (1998) also mentioned
occurrences from Morocco and Libya as occurrences from
the southern Tethys coast.
Discussion and conclusions
The small assemblage of only ten species is the first record
of Thanetian gastropods from the Mesopotamian High
Folded Zone. All species suggest a littoral to shallow
sublittoral depositional environment. Especially the extant
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
species of the Batillaridae and Potamididae prefer sandy
mudflats in warm-temperate to tropical regions (Ozawa
et al. 2009; Sälgeback & Savazzi 2006). The Recent
Campanile symbolicum is also typically found on sandy
bottoms in the shallow sublittoral zone (Houbrick 1984).
Its fossil congeners seem to have preferred comparable
environments (Sälgeback and Savazzi 2006). Modern
species of Pachymelania are found in mangrove habitats
and estuaries, where they can stand strong fluctuations in
salinity (Bandel and Kowalke 1999). Similarly, Kowalke
(2004) interpreted the preferred habitat of the extinct
Pseudobellardia (=Gantmelanatria) as a calm coastal
swamp/lagoon facies.
Eight of the species have been documented from other
localities. These are Campanile zakhoense nov. sp., Vicinocerithium seni İslamoğlu, Dominici & Kowalke 2011,
Vicinocerithium sp., Pseudobellardia ankaraensis (İslamoğlu, Dominici & Kowalke 2011), Pyrazopsis hexagonpyramidalis nov. sp., ‘‘Faunus’’ dominicii nov. sp. and
maybe Eotympanotonus sp., which are also known from
coeval Thanetian or slightly younger Ypresian deposits of
western Turkey. Popenoeum primum (Defrance 1827) is a
widespread species during Paleocene times in the entire
(western) Tethys Sea and the North Sea. The other species
are so far known only from the Thanetian of the Zakhos
region. Hence, the biogeographic relation toward the west,
e.g. with the assemblages from the Paris Basin or the Veneto in Italy, is very poor. Interestingly, the younger
Eocene assemblages of the Balkans, as described by
Oppenheim (1901; 1909; 1912), bear morphologically
similar but not con-specific taxa, which might point to
some evolutionary relationships. Even less contact is evident with eastern assemblages from India and Pakistan.
These Paleocene and Eocene faunas, described by Cossmann and Pissarro (1909), Douvillé (1928; 1929) and Cox
(1930; 1931), comprise ecologically comparable taxa but
have no species in common with the Iraqi assemblage. This
pattern contradicts a homogenous biogeography along the
northern coasts of the Paleocene and Early Eocene Tethys.
Popov (1993) suggested a biogeographic separation of the
Eocene Tethys Realm (sensu Harzhauser et al. 2002) in
western Eurasia into an Indo-African Region and a Mediterranean Region. This was based on the similarities of the
southern Tethyan bivalve faunas of Egypt, Somalia and
India compared to those from the northern Tethyan ones
from Italy and southeastern France. The herein discussed
Turkish and Iraqi assemblages were not known at that time
and consequently were not incorporated in the concept. The
similarities between the assemblage from western Turkey
(Okan and Hoşgör 2008; İslamoğlu et al. 2011) and the
Iraqi one and their dissimilarity with neighbouring areas
suggest the existence of an Anatolian Province within
Popov’s Mediterranean Region during Thanetian and early
Ypresian times. Modern descriptions of assemblages from
the eastern Mediterranean and Balkans areas in the west
and from the Arabian Platform in the east are completely
missing to date. Thus, a formal definition of this new
biogeographic entity, including designations of a type area
and a type assemblage and the definition of exact palaeogeographic boundaries toward adjoining entities, is
impossible to date.
Acknowledgments We thank Oleg Mandic (Natural History
Museum Vienna) for help with the literature and fruitful discussion
and Alexander Nützel (Bavarian State Collection of Palaeontology
and Geology, Munich, Germany) and Kai Ingemann Schnetler
(Langå, Denmark) for their helpful reviews. This article contributes to
the FWF Project P–23492: Mediterranean Oligo–Miocene stratigraphy and palaeoecology.
References
Abich, H. 1882. Geologische Forschungen in den Kaukasischen
Ländern II. Geologie des Armenischen Hochlands, I. Westhälfte,
1–478. Wien: A. Hölder.
Adams, H. 1866. Description of a new genus and a new species of
mollusks. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
1866: 150–151.
Adams, H., and Adams, A. 1853, 1854. The genera of recent mollusca
arranged according to their organization. 1: 1–256 and
257–484, 2: 1–661, London: John Van Voorst.
Akopjan, V.T. 1972. On a new cerithioidean family. Izvestia
Academii nauk Armiansko i SSR. Nauki o Zemie 25: 3–14.
Al-Ameri, T.K. 1996. The environmental and stratigraphical significance of early tertiary palynomorphs, Northern Iraq. Iraqi
Journal of Science 37(2): 661–686.
Al-Qayim, B., S. Al-Shaibani, and B. Nissan. 1988. Stratigraphic
evolution of paleogene sequence, Haibat Sultan, Northeast Iraq.
Journal of the Geological Society of Iraq 21(2): 51–65.
Al-Qayim, B.A., M.M. Al-Mutwali, and B.Y. Nissan. 2008. FlyschMolasse sediments of the Paleogene foreland basin of north
Arabia, Shiranish area, Northern Iraq. Iraqi Bulletin of Geology
and Mining 4: 1–20.
Arkhanguelskt, A.D. 1904. Dépots paléocènes de la région volgienne
du gouvernement de Saratov et leur faune. Materialien zur
Geolgie Russlands 22: 1–207.
Bandel, K., and T. Kowalke. 1999. Gastropod fauna of the
Cameroonian coast. Helgoland Marine Research 53: 129–140.
Bayan, F. 1870a. Sur les terrains tertiaires de la Vénétie. Bulletin de la
Socie´te´ Ge´ologique de France 2(27): 444–486.
Bayan, F. 1870b. E´tudes faites dans la collection de l’E´cole des Mines
sur des fossiles nouveaux ou mal connus. 1er fascicule.
Mollusques tertiaires, 1–81. Paris: Savy.
Bayan, F. 1873. E´tudes faites dans la collection de l’E´cole des Mines
sur des fossiles nouveaux ou mal connus. 2e fascicule, 82–164.
Paris: Savy.
Bayle, C.E. 1884. in Fischer, P. Manuel de conchyliologie et de
pale´ontologie conchyliologique ou Histoire naturelle des mollusques vivants et fossils 7: 609–688.
Bellardi, L. 1852. Catalogue raisonné des fossiles nummulitiques du
Comté de Nice. Me´moires de la Socie´te´ ge´ologique de France,
Deuxie`me Se´rie 4: 205–300.
Bellen, R.C. van, Dunnington, H., Wetzel, R., and Morton, D. 1959.
Lexique Stratigraphique International, 3, Asie, 10a, Iraq, 1–333.
Paris: CNRS.
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
Belliard, L., and Gain, O. 2007. Description des espèces. In: Belliard,
L., Dugué, O. & Gain, O., Note sur les couches éocènes à
Cerithioidea du Coteau de Vauville à Fresville (Manche).
Me´moires de la Socie´te´ nationale des Sciences naturelles et
mathe´matiques de Cherbourg 65, 19–113.
Beu, A.G., and B.A. Maxwell. 1990. Cenozoic mollusca of New
Zealand. New Zealand Geological Survey, Palaeontological
Bulletin 58: 1–518.
Bouniol, P. 1981. Contribution des Cérithidéss. I. (Prosobranchia) à la
stratigraphie du Paléocène d’Europe occidentale et essai de
Phylogenèse. Bulletin d’Information des Ge´ologues du Bassin de
Paris 18(2): 21–33.
Boussac, J. 1911. Études paléontologiques sur le Nummulitique
Alpin. Me´moires pour servir à l’explication de la carte
ge´ologique de´taille´e de la France 1–439, Paris: Ministère des
Travaux Pubics.
Boussac, J. 1912. Essai sur l’evolution des cérithidés dans le
Mésonummulitique du Bassin de Paris. Annales He´bert. Annales
de Stratigraphie et de Pale´ontologie du Laboratoire de Ge´ologie
6: 1–93.
Bowdich, E. 1822. Part 1, Univalves. Elements of conchology
including the fossil genera and the animals, 1–83. London:
Treuttel & Würtz.
Brandt, M. 1837. Remarques sur quelques modifications dans
l’arrangement de l’ordre des Acalèphes discophores ou ombrellifères. Bulletin Scientifique de l’Acade´mie Impe´riale des
Sciences de St. Pe´tersbourg 1(24): 185–191.
Brongniart, M. 1810. Sur des terrains qui paroissent avoir été formés
sous l’eau douce. Annales du Muse´um d’Histoire Naturelle Paris
15: 357–405.
Buday, T. 1980. The regional geology of Iraq. Stratigraphy and
paleogeography, 1–445. Baghdad: GEOSURV.
Chavan, A. 1952. Quelques intéressants types de Cérites. Cahiers
Ge´ologiques de Thoiry 15: 103–104, 113–114, 128.
Čičič, S. 1964. Geološki sastav I tektonika sjeveroistočnog dijela
planine Majevice s naročitim osvrtom na geološko-ekonomski
značaj ležišta mrkog uglja. Geoloski glasnik 6: 3–173.
Clark, B.L., and J.W. Durham. 1946. Eocene Faunas from the
Department of Bolivar, Colombia. Geological Society of America Memoir 16: 1–126.
Cossmann, M. 1889. Catalogue illustré des coquilles fossiles de
l’Éocène des environs de Paris faisant suite aux travaux
paléontologiques de G.-P. Deshayes. 4ème fascicule. Annales de
la Socie´te´ royale Malacologique de Belgique 24: 1–385.
Cossmann, M. 1897. Mollusques éocèniques de la Loire-inférieure, 3.
Bulletin de la Socie´te´ Naturelles de l’Ouest de la France 7(4):
297–358.
Cossmann, M. 1898. Estudio de algunos moluscos eocenos del
Pirineo catalán. Boletin de la Comision del Mapa Geolôgico de
España 2(3): 167–198.
Cossmann, M. 1906. Estudio de algunos moluscos eocenicos del
Pirineo catalán. Boletin de la Comision del Mapa Geolôgico de
Espana 2(8): 135–151.
Cossmann, M. 1909a. Essais de Pale´oconchologie compare´e, vol. 8,
1–248. Paris: l’Auteur et FR de Rudeval.
Cossmann, M., and G. Pissarro. 1902. Faune éocènique du Cotentin
(Mollusques). Bulletin de la Socie´te´ Ge´ologique de Normandie
21: 27–181.
Cossmann, M., and Pissarro, G. 1909. The mollusca of the Ranikot
series. Part 1. Cephalopoda and gastropoda. Memoirs of the
Geological Survey of India. Palaeontologia Indica, N.S. 8(1):
1–83.
Cossmann, M., and Pissarro, G. 1911. Iconographie comple`te des
coquilles fossiles de l’E´oce`ne des environs de Paris, Tome 2, pl.
XXVI–XLV. Paris: Hermann).
123
Cox, L.R. 1930. The fossil fauna of the Samana range and some
neighbouring areas. Part VIII. The mollusca of the Hangu
Shales. Memoirs of the Geological Survey of India, new series
15: 129–222.
Cox, L.R. 1931. A contribution to the molluscan fauna of the Laki and
basal Khirthar Groups of the Indian Eocene. Transactions of the
Royal Society of Edinburgh 57(2): 25–92.
Cox, L.R. 1960. Thoughts on the classification of the Gastropoda.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 33: 239–261.
Cuvier, G. 1795. Second Mémoire sur l’organisation et les rapports
des animaux à sang blanc, dans lequel on traite de la structure
des Mollusques et de leur division en ordre, lu à la société
d’Histoire Naturelle de Paris, le 11 prairial an troisième [30 May
1795]. Magazin Encyclope´dique, ou Journal des Sciences, des
Lettres et des Arts 2: 433–449.
Dainelli, G. 1915. L’eocene friulano. Monografia geologica e
paleontologica. Memorie Geografiche 1915: 1–721.
d’Archiac, A. 1850. Histoire des progre`s de la ge´ologie de 1834 à
1849. Tome 3: Formation nummulitique, Roches igne´es ou
pyroge`nes des e´poques quaternaire et Tertiaire, 1–624. Paris:
Société Géologique de France.
d’Archiac, A. 1866. Faune tertiaire inférieure. In: Asie Mineure.
Description physique de cette contre´e. Pale´ontologie 4, ed. de
Tchihatcheff P, 105–234. Paris: L. Gérin.
d’Orbigny, A. 1850. Prodrome de Pale´ontologie stratigraphique
universelle des animaux mollusques et rayonne´s, vol. 2, 1–428.
Paris: Masson.
de Gregorio, A. 1896. Description des Faunes Tertiaires de la
Vénétie. Monographie de la faune éocènique de Roncà avec un
appendice sur les fossiles de M. Pulli. Annales de Ge´ologie et de
Pale´ontologie 21: 1–163.
Defrance, F. 1827. Dictionnaire des sciences naturelles, vol. 51,
1–531. Strasbourg: Levrault.
Deshayes, G.-P. 1824–1837. Description des coquilles fossiles des
environs de Paris. Tome 2, 1–80 (1824), 81–162 (1825), 163–290
(1832), 291–429 (1833), 430–494 (1834), 495–780 (1835),
781–814 (1837). Paris: l’Auteur, Baudouin, Béchet, Treuttel.
Deshayes, G.-P., 1861–1864. Description des Animaux sans verte`bres
de´couverts dans le Bassin de Paris pour servir de supple´ment à
la description des coquilles fossiles des environs de Paris,
comprenant une revue ge´ne´rale de toutes les espe`ces actuellement connues, 2. Mollusques ace´phales monomyaires et brachiopodes, mollusques ce´phales, 1. 1–432 (1861), 433–640
(1862), 641–920 (1863), 921–968 (1864). Paris: Baillière.
Doncieux, L. 1903. Monographie ge´ologique et pale´ontologique des
Corbie`res orientales, 1–182. Lyon: A. Rey.
Doncieux, L. 1908. Cataloque descriptif des fossiles Nummulitiques
de l’Aude et de l’He´rault, vol. 1, 1–291. Lyon: A. Rey.
Douvillé, H. 1904. Paléontologie mollusques fossiles. In Mission
scientifique en Perse. vol.3, E´tudes ge´ologiques. Partie IV.
Pale´ontologie Mollusques fossiles, ed. de Morgan J, 191–380.
Paris: E. Leroux.
Douvillé, H. 1928. Les couches a Cardita beaumonti. I. Les couches a
Cardita beaumonti dans le Belouchistan. Memoirs of the
geological Survey of India. Palaeontographica Indica, n.s.
10(3): 1–25.
Douvillé, H. 1929. Les couches a Cardita beaumonti. II. Les couches
a Cardita beaumonti dans le Sind. Memoirs of the geological
Survey of India. Palaeontographica Indica, n.s. 10(3): 27–73.
Dunnington, H. 1958. Generation, migration, accumulation, and
dissipation of oil in Northern Iraq. In Habitat of Oil. American
Association of Petroleum Geologist Memoir, 18, ed Weeks GL,
1194–1251.
Elliot, G.F. 1963. A Palaeocene teredinid (Mollusca) from Iraq.
Palaeontology 6: 315–317.
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
Erünal, L. 1942. Sivrihisar-Polatlı Mıntakasının Paleosen Faunası
[Faune paléocene de la region de Sivrihisar-Polatlı]. Revue de
l’Institut d’Etudes et de Recherches Minieres de Turquie 1:
126–132.
Fischer, P., and Crosse, H. 1892. Mission scientifique au Mexique et
dans l’Amérique Centrale. Recherches zoologiques 7, 2(13):
117–392.
Fleming, J. 1822. Philosophy of zoology; or a general view of the
structure, functions, and classifications of animals, vol. 2, 1–618.
Edinburgh: Hurst.
Gill, T. 1871. Arrangement of the families of mollusks. Smithsonian
Miscellaneous Collections 227: I–XVI ? 1–49.
Gmelin, J.F. 1791 In Systema Naturae per Regna Tria Naturae,
Secundum Classes, Ordines, Genera, Species, cum Characteribus, Differentiis, Synonymis, Locis, 1(6), ed Linnaeus C,
3021–3910, 13th Edn. Lyon: J.B. Delamolliere.
Gregorio, A. de 1880. Fauna di S. Giovanni Ilarione (Parisiano).
Parte 1: Cefalopodi e Gasteropodi. I–XXVIII ? 1–106.
Palermo: P. Montaina & C.
Güngör, A. 1975. Etude des Espèces du Genre Campanile Bayle (in
Fischer), 1884, de l’Éocene de la Région d’Ankara-Haymana.
Bulletin of the Mineral Research and Exploration Institute of
Turkey 84: 31–35.
Haldeman, S.S. 1842. Corrections. American Journal of Science and
Arts 42(1): 216.
Haller, B. 1892. Die Anatomie von Siphonaria gigas Less., eines
opisthobranchiaten Gastropoden. Arbeiten aus den Zoologischen
Instituten der Universität Wien und der Zoologischen Station in
Triest 10: 71–100.
Harasewych, M.G., S.L. Adamkewicz, M. Plassmeyer, and P.M.
Gillevet. 1998. Phylogenetic relationships of the lower Caenogastropoda (Mollusca, Gastropoda, Architaenioglossa, Campaniloidea, Cerithioidea) as determined by partial 18S rDNA
sequences. Zoologica Scripta 27: 361–372.
Hartman, J.H. 1998. The stratigraphy of the Mesozoic and Early
Cenozoic nonmarine molluscs of Colorado. Proceedings of the
Denver Museum of Natural History, series 3(14): 1–14.
Harzhauser, M. 2004. Oligocene gastropod faunas of the Eastern
Mediterranean (Mesohellenic Trough/Greece and Esfahan-Sirjan
Basin/Central Iran). Courier Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg
248: 93–181.
Harzhauser, M., W.E. Piller, and F.F. Steininger. 2002. Circummediterranean oligo/miocene biogeographic evolution—the gastropods’ point of view. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology,
Palaeoecology 183: 103–133.
Heilprin, A. 1887. Explorations on the West Coast of Florida and in
the Okeechobee Wilderness, with special reference to the
geology and zoology of the Floridian Peninsula. Transactions
of the Wagner Free Institute of Science, Philadelphia 1: 1–134.
Henson, F.R.S. 1951. Observations on the geology and petroleum
occurrences of the Middle East. 3rd World Petroleum Congress,
Proceedings 1: 118–140.
Hoşgör, I., and Kosták, M. 2012. Occurrence of the Late Cretaceous
belemnite Belemnitella in the Arabian Plate (Hakkari, SE
Turkey) and its palaeogeographic significance. Cretaceous
Research, doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2012.02.014.
Hoşgör, I., and Y. Okan. 2011. A new species of angariid gastropod
from the early Thanetian of the Haymana-Polatlı Basin, Turkey.
Turkish Journal of Earth Sciences 20: 243–253.
Houbrick, R.S. 1984. The giant creeper, Campanile symbolicum
Iredale, an Australian relict marine snail. In Living fossils, ed.
N. Eldridge, and S. Stanley, 232–235. Berlin: Springer.
Iqbal, M.W.A. 1969. Mega-fauna from the Ghazij formation (Lower
Eocene) Quetta Shahrig area, West Pakistan. Memoirs of the
Geological Survey of Pakistan Palaeontologica Pakistanica 5:
1–40.
Iredale, T. 1917. More molluscan name-changes, generic and specific.
Proceedings of the Malacological Society of London 12(6):
322–330.
İslamoğlu, Y., S. Dominici, and T. Kowalke. 2011. Early eocene
caenogastropods (Mollusca, Gastropoda) from Haymana-Polatli
Basin, Central Anatolia (Turkey): taxonomy and palaeoecology.
Geodiversitas 33(2): 303–330.
Kassab, I.I.M. 1976. Planktonic foraminiferal ranges in the type
Kolosh Formation (Middle-Upper Paleocene) of NE Iraq.
Journal of the Geological Society of Iraq 9: 54–99.
Kassab, I.I.M. 1978. Planktonic foraminiferal of the subsurface lower
tertiary of northern Iraq. Journal of the Geological Society of
Iraq 11: 119–159.
Kassab, I.I.M., F.S. Al-Omari, and N.M. Al-Safawee. 1986. The
cretaceous tertiary boundary in Iraq (represented by the subsurface section of Sasan well No. 1, N.W. Iraq). Journal of the
Geological Society of Iraq 19: 129–167.
Kochansky-Devidé, V. 1956. Eozäne Cerithien von Mečenčani bei
Kostajnica (Kroatien, Jugoslavien). Acta Geologica 1: 80–82.
Köhler, F., and M. Glaubrecht. 2010. Uncovering an overlooked
radiation: Molecular phylogeny and biogeography of Madagascar’s endemic river snails (Caenogastropoda: Pachychilidae:
Madagasikara gen. nov.). Biological Journal of the Linnean
Society 99: 867–894.
Kollmann, H.A., and J.S. Peel. 1985. Paleocene gastropods from
Nûgssuaq, West Greenland. Grønlands Geologiske Undersøgelse, Bulletin 146: 1–115.
Kowalke, T. 2001. Cerithoidea (Caenogastropoda: Cerithiimorpha) of
Tethyan coastal swamps and their relations to modern mangal
communities. Bulletin of the Czech Geological Survey 76: 253–271.
Kowalke, T. 2004. Evolution of the Pachychilidae Troschel, 1857
(Caenogastropoda, Cerithioidea)—from the Tethys to modern
tropical rivers. Zitteliana A44: 41–50.
Krach, W. 1963. Mollusca of the Babica Clays (Paleocene) of the
middle Carpathians. Part 1: Gastropoda. Studia Geologica
Polonica 14: 1–128.
Krach, W. 1969. Mollusca of the Babica Clays (Paleocene) of the
middle Carpathians. Part 2: Pelecypoda. Studia Geologica
Polonica 29: 1–79.
Lamarck, J-B.P.A. de M. de 1804. Suite des mémoires sur les fossiles
des environs de Paris. Annales du Museum d’Histoire Naturelle
5: 28–36, 91–98, 179–188, 237–245, 349–357.
Le Renard, J., and J.-M. Pacaud. 1995. Révision des mollusques
paléogènes du Bassin de Paris II—Liste des références primaires
des espèces. Cossmanniana 3(3): 65–132.
Lesport, J.-F., and B. Cahuzac. 2002. Sur un Potamididae méconnu du
Miocène inférieur d’Aquitaine: Pyrazisinus monstrosus (Grateloup, 1847) [Mollusques Gastéropdes]; discussion générique.
Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie Abhandlungen
223: 1–52.
Leymerie, A. 1846. Mémoire sur le terrain à Nummulites (épicrétacé)
des Corbières et de la Montagne Noire. Me´moires de la Socie´te´
Ge´ologique de France 1(2): 337–373.
Linnaeus, C. (1758). Systema naturae, Ed. X. (Systema naturae per
regna tria naturae, secundum classes, ordines, genera, species,
cum characteribus, differentiis, synonymis, locis. Editio decima,
reformata) 1: 1–824. Holmiae.
Macquart, M. 1842. Description d’un nouveau genre d’insectes diptères.
Annales de la Socie´te´ Entomologique de France 11: 41–44.
Makarenko, D.E. 1969. Correlations of the Paleocene deposits of the
northern Ukraine and Denmark by mollusk fauna. Dopovidi
Akademiyi Nauk Ukrayins’koyi RSR B 12: 1627–1631. (in
Russian).
Makarenko, D.E. 1976. Gastropody nizhnego paleotsena Severnoy
Ukrany. Akademya Nauk Ukrainskoy SSR Institut Geologichykh
Nauk. Kiev Haukova Dumka, 1–180 (in Russian).
123
Author's personal copy
M. Harzhauser et al.
Mayer-Eymar, C. 1876. Systematisches Verzeichniss der Versteinerungen des Parisian der Umgegend von Einsiedeln, 1–100.
Zürich: Caesar Schmidt. [Also published as Mayer-Eymar, C.
1877. Paläontologie der Pariserstufe von Einsiedeln und seinen
Umgebungen. Beiträge zur Geologischen Karte der Schweiz 14
(2): 1–100].
Meek, F.B. 1873. Preliminary paleontological report, consisting of
lists and descriptions of fossils, with remarks on the rocks in
which they were found. Sixth Annual Report of the United States
Geological Survey of Territories, 431–518.
Montfort, D. de 1810. Conchyliologie syste´matique, et classification
me´thodique des coquilles; offrant leurs figures, leur arrangement
ge´ne´rique, leurs descriptions caracte´ristiques, leurs noms; ainsi
que leur synonymie en plusieurs langues. Ouvrage destine´ à
faciliter l’e´tude des coquilles, ainsi que leur disposition dans les
cabinets d’histoire naturelle. Coquilles univalves, non cloisonne´es, 2: 1–676. Paris: Schœll.
Moroz, S.A. 1972. Fauna mollyuskov paleotsena Dnjeprovsko–
Donetskoy vpadiny. Izdatelstvo Kievskogo Universiteta, 1–139
(in Russian).
Müller, O.F. 1774. Vermivm terrestrium et fluviatilium, seu animalium infusoriorum, helminthicorum, et testaceorum, non marinorum, succincta historia. Voluminis Imi pars altera. 1–72,
Havniæ & Lipsiæ: Heineck & Faber.
Okan, Y., and I. Hoşgör. 2008. The Ampullinid Gastropod Globularia
(Swainson 1840) from the Late Thanetian-Early Ilerdian
Kırkkavak Formation (Polatlı-Ankara) of the Tethyan Realm.
Turkish Journal of Earth Science 17: 785–801.
Okan, Y., and İ. Hoşgör. 2009. Early Eocene (middle-late Cuisian)
Molluscs Assemblage from the Harpactocarcinid Beds, in the
Yoncalı Formation of the Çankırı Basin, Central Anatolia, and
Implications for Tethys Paleogeography. Geological Bulletin of
Turkey 52(1): 1–30.
Oppenheim, P. 1894. Die eocäne Fauna des Mt. Pulli bei Valdagno im
Vicentino. Zeitschrift der deutschen geologischen Gesellschaft
46: 309–445.
Oppenheim, P. 1896/97. Die Eocaenfauna des Monte Postale bei
Bolca im Veronesischen. Palaeontographica 43: 125–222.
Oppenheim, P. 1901. Ueber einige alttertiäre Faunen der österreichisch-ungarischen Monarchie. Beiträge zur Paläontologie und
Geologie Österreich-Ungarns und des Orients 13: 145–296.
Oppenheim, P. 1909. Über eine Eocänfaunula von Ostbosnien und
einige Eocänfossilien der Herzegowina. Jahrbuch der k.k.
geologischen Reichsanstalt 58: 311–344.
Oppenheim, P. 1912. Neue Beiträge zur Eozänfauna Bosniens.
Beiträge zur Paläontologie und Geologie Österreich-Ungarns
und des Orients 25: 88–149.
Ozawa, T., F. Köhler, D.G. Reid, and M. Glaubrecht. 2009. Tethyan
relicts on continental coastlines of the northwestern Pacific
Ocean and Australasia: Molecular phylogeny and fossil record of
batillariid gastropods (Caenogastropoda, Cerithioidea). Zoologica Scripta 38: 503–525.
Pacaud, J.-M. 1998. Nouvelles données sur le genre Popenoeum
(Mollusca, Pseudolividae). Remarques taxonomiques sur une
espèce ubiquiste du Paléocène inférieur, Popenoeum ambiguum
(Binkhorst, 1861: Pyrula), nov. comb. Cossmanniana 5 (1–2): 1–28.
Pacaud, J.-M. 2007. Nouveautés nomenclaturales et taxinomiques
introduites par Alcide d’Orbigny dans le Prodrome (1850, 1852)
pour les espèces du Paléocène et de l’Éocène. Geodiversitas
29(1): 17–85.
Pacaud, J.-M. 2009. Maralsenia, un nouveau genre de Pseudolividae
(Gastropoda, Muricoidea) du Paléogène inférieur des régions
nord-africaine et sud-américaine. Bulletin de l’Institut scientifique de Rabat, section Sciences de la Terre 31: 1–7.
Pacaud, J.-M., and Harzhauser, M. Jponsia, Moniquia et Eginea, trois
nouveaux
genres
de
Pachychilidae
(Gastropoda,
123
Caenogastropoda) du Paléogène européen. Annales de Pale´ontologie (submitted).
Pacaud, J.-M., and J. Le Renard. 1995. Révision des mollusques
paléogènes du Bassin de Paris IV—liste systématique actualisée.
Cossmanniana 3(4): 151–187.
Pacaud, J.-M., and K.I. Schnetler. 1999. Revision of the gastropod
family Pseudolividae from the Paleocene of West Greenland and
Denmark. Bulletin of the Geological Society of Denmark 46:
53–67.
Perry, G. 1811. Conchology or the natural history of shells:
containing a new arrangement of the genera and species,
illustrated by coloured engravings, executed from natural
specimens, and including the latest discoveries, I–IV ? 61.
London: William Miller.
Ponder, W.F., and D.R. Lindberg. 1997. Towards a phylogeny of
gastropod molluscs—a preliminary analysis using morphological
characters. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 19:
83–265.
Popov, S.V. 1993. Zoogeography of the late eocene basins of Western
Eurasia based on bivalve mollusks. Stratigraphy and Geological
Correlation 2(6): 103–118.
Preyssler, J.D. 1790. Verzeichnis böhmischer Insecten, 1–108. Prag:
Schönfeld-Meißner.
Quoy, J., and Gaimard, A. 1834. Animaux Mollusques. In: Voyages
de decouvertes de l’Astrolabe exkecutes par orde du Roi,
pendant les annees 1826–29, sous le commandement de M.J.
Dumont d’Urville. Zoologie, Paris 3: 559–625.
Rafinesque, C.S. 1815. Analyse de la nature ou tableau de l’univers et
des corps organise´s. Le nature es mon guide, et Linne´us mon
maıˆtre, 1–224. Palermo (privately published).
Reid, D.G., P. Dyal, P. Lozouet, M. Glaubrecht, and S.T. Williams.
2008. Mudwhelks and mangroves: The evolutionary history of
an ecological association (Gastropoda: Potamididae). Molecular
Phylogenetics and Evolution 47: 680–699.
Sälgeback, J., and E. Savazzi. 2006. Constructional morphology of
cerithiform gastropods. Paleontological Research 10: 233–259.
Schnetler, K.I. 2001. The Selandian (Paleocene) mollusc fauna from
Copenhagen, Denmark: The Poul Harder 1920 collection.
Geology of Denmark Survey Bulletin 37: 1–85.
Schnetler, K.I., and R.E. Petit. 2010. Revision of the gastropod family
Cancellariidae from the Paleocene of Nuussuaq, West Greenland. Cainozoic Research 7: 3–26.
Schumacher, H.C.F. 1817. Essais d’un Nouveau Syste`me des
Habitations des Vers Testace´s, 1–287. Copenhagen: Schultz.
Sharbazhari, K.M., I.M. Ghafor, and Q.A. Muhammed. 2009.
Biostratigraphy of the cretaceous/tertiary boundary in the Sirwan
Valley (Sulaimani Region, Kurdistan, NE Iraq). Geologica
Carpathica 60: 381–396.
Smith, E.A. 1893. On the generic name to be applied to the Nerita
aurita of Müller and other allied species. Conchologist 2:
141–142.
Solander D.C. 1766. Descriptiones specierum, in Brander G., Fossilia
Hantoniensia collecta, et in Musaeo Brittannico deposita a
Gustavo Brander, 9–43. London (privately published).
Sowerby J. 1818, 1822. The mineral conchology of Great Britain; or
coloured figures and descriptions of those remains of testaceous
animals or shells which have been preserved at various times
and dephts in the Earth, 3: 187–203, 4: 319–383. London:
Arding & Merrett.
Squires, R.L., W.J. Zinsmeister, and L.M. Paredes-Mejı́a. 1989.
Popenoeum, new Pseudolivine gastropod genus: Widespread and
most diversified during the Paleocene. Journal of Paleontology
63: 212–217.
Stchépinsky, V. 1946. Fossiles caractéristiques de Turquie. Institut
d’E´tudes et de Recherches Minie`res de Turquie, 1–151. Ankara:
MTA.
Author's personal copy
The Mesopotamian high folded zone
Strand, E. 1928. Miscellanea nomenclatorica zoologica et paleontologica. Archiv für Naturgeschichte I ? II. 92A: 30–75.
Thiele, J. 1929. Handbuch der Systematischen Weichtierkunde, vol. 1,
1–376. Jena: Gustav Fischer.
Turco Stella, A.M. 1976. Distribuzione stratigrafica e relazioni
filogenetiche nei ceritidi dell’Eocene inferiore e medio dell’Italia
nord-orientale. Memoire degli Istituti di Geologia e Mineralogia
dell’ Università di Padova 30: 1–27.
Vasseur G. 1881. Recherches ge´ologiques sur les terrains tertiaires
de la France occidentale. 1ere partie: Bretagne, 1–432. Paris:
Masson.
Vasseur G. 1882. Recherches géologiques sur les terrains tertiaires de
la France occidentale. Atlas pale´ontologique, pls 1–11 et 19.
Toulouse: Quinsac.
Villatte, J. 1970. Deux Olividae identiques: Pseudoliva prima
(Defrance) et Pseudoliva poursanensis Doncieux. Bulletin de
la Societe´ d’Histoire Naturelle de Toulouse 106: 22–27.
von Schlotheim, E.F. 1820. Die Petrefactenkunde auf ihrem jetzigen
Standpunkte durch die Beschreibung seiner Sammlung versteinerter und fossiler Überreste des Thier-und Pflanzenreichs der
Vorwelt erläutert, 1–437. Gotha: Beckersche Buchhandlung.
Wood, E. 1910. The phylogeny of certain Cerithiidae. Annals of the
New York Academy of Sciences 20: 1–92.
Wood, W. 1828. Supplement to the Index Testaceologicus; or a
catalogue of shells, British and Foreign. Illustrated with 480
figures, I–VI ? 1–59. London: Richard Taylor.
Woodring, W.P. 1957. Geology and paleontology of the Canal Zone
and adjoining parts of Panama. Description of Tertiary mollusks
(Gastropods: Trochidae to Turritellidae). U.S. Geological Survey
Professional Paper 306-A: 1–145.
123