Page-24
RNI JKENG/2018/77291
Rs-30/=
PRIME POST
Vol- 1 Issue-16
01-15 June, 2019
News | Opinion | Analysis
Indian Politics 2019
A cocktail of Development and Nationalism Worked
A combination of nationalist rhetoric, subtle religious polarisation and a slew of welfare
programmes helped Mr Modi to coast to a second successive win.
Primepost
MOHD ISHAQ SHAHDr. Swadesh Singh
Vo
l
Pr
Vol-1 Issue-16
01-15 June, 2019
-1
E
Iss
ue
-
11
im
Ne
w
s|
16
-3
1M
arch
, 20
19
e
Op
on
Rs
-
Po
st
le
ct
2k ion
s
io
n
19
|A
30
/-
Pa
ge
na
ly
si
s
- 24
Tit
le
Cod
e-
JK
EN
G12
69
___
___
___
_
__F_ rom _____
___ '
___ Pa ____
___ pp __
___ u ___
___ ' T
___ o ____
___ 'Ch __
_
___ o
___ wk ____
___ id __
___ ar ___
___ ' C
___ h ____
___ or
___ H _____
___ ai
_
___
_
EDITOR
M. Akbar Reshi
MANAGING EDITOR
Deepak Rana
CONTENT
ASSOCIATE EDITOR
Mudassir Reshi
REFLECTION
HARDLINE
KASHMIR BUREAU
Muzamil Wagay
JAMMU BUREAU
Tousif Bhat
MOHD ISHAQ SHAH
Umesh Chaurasia
Today's Cashmeres:
A Lost Generation
UTTER PARDESH
I M PACT
DELHI BUREAU
M. Feizal
ENTERTAINMENT
Pallavi Talvar
Junaid Choudhary
Touseef Hamid
UNDERSTANDING :
The Article 370
EDITORIAL/BUSINESS
OFFICES
CONFLICT
Wazir Bagh LD Hospital Rd,
Srinagar 19008
+91 7006087699
Satwari Jammu Cantt,
180003
+91 9086000778
Ganjiwara Anantnag
192101
+91 7006331410
Email: editorprimepost@gmail.com
+91 9906171735
Www.theprimepost.com
VIEWS
Syed Mujtaba
PRINTED & PUBLISHED
M. Akbar Reshi
DR. JOHN MOHAN RAZU
2019 INDIAN POLLS
"ORWELLIAN 1984":
FUTURE TOTALITARIAN STATE
DR.MASOON AHMAD BEIG
Meer Abass
Happiness Lies In
Helping Others
OPINION
Dr. Swadesh Singh
Revisiting Ambedkar's
Idea of Nationalism
HALF WIDOWS
THE
AND MARGINALIZED
V I EINVISIBLE
WS
GROUP OF KASHMIRI WOMEN
KIDZEE
Brain Teasers
Art and Craft
REFLECTION
Today's Cashmeres:
A Lost Generation
Politics has become a gambling rather than
statesmanship. Leaders now seem gamblers more
and leaders less. They have self interests in politics
rather than what was known in olden days a
service to nation.
M
MOHD ISHAQ SHAH
01-15 June,2019
Y memory compels me
to recollect that I have
read a concept during my
Research on a renounced post
Wo r l d - w a r a u t h o r - E a r n e s t
Hemingway. The concept is
manifested in the title here ie; lost
generation. It was Gertrude Strain
who confined this term to mean the
generation that has come of an age
during world war 1 and Hemingway
exploited the term in full length in
his first novel " The Sun Also Rises''.
On the surface level the novel
exhibits a mismatch between jack
and his wife. Jack has been left
4
impotent by a wound
during war and his wife
has been already married
many times before she
would marry jack. Her
extra marital affairs
cause jack's mental
trauma as he feels
humiliated before the
public. It is a common
belief that every writer is
the byproduct of his age
and same was the case
with Hemingway who
himself participated in
world war-ii, this way or
that way.
So for my observations
during the years this
political turmoil has been
going on here in
Kashmir, I could perceive that the
people here have everything except
metal peace and calm. Civic as well
as war crimes are increasing at an
alarming rate and day by day. Sexscandals, rapes, murders, loot and
plunder have become the order of the
day. Rape and murder incident of
Kathua in Jammu division is just
before eyes. Recently some more
incidents about rapes with the minor
girls have been reported from north
Kashmir. In addition, domestic
violence is no less than the primitive
days. Women are still treated in an ill
way.
Employment opportunities are at
zero level. A report compiled in 2017
by centre for monitoring Indian
economy and in collaboration with
Bombay stock exchange reveals
that Jammu and Kashmir has highest
PRIMEPOST
REFLECTION
rate of unemployment 12-13% as
compared to some other states
Kerala{9.6 % Assam{8.60%}Punjab
and Haryana{7.16%}.The national
unemployment level is
4.7%.Conseuently the youth are
frustrated and in an anguishing mode.
One may perchance conclude that it is
the future prospects of the state that
compels educated youth to take either
stones or guns in their hands. It has
become a preference to gun over pen.
Joining of some prominent scholars
with the militant ranks is indicative of
this very prospect. Lack of private
sector jobs adds fuel to the fire. It
seems all dark to an educated young
fellow when he leaves the college or
university. Corruption being at peak
has a special role to play in
traumatizing the educated youth
mentally as unfair selection lists by
recruiting agencies has become here
now common experience.
Politics has become a gambling rather
than statesmanship. Leaders now
seem gamblers more and leaders less.
They have self interests in politics
rather than what was known in olden
days a service to nation. Booth
capturing, diverted EVMs and other
types frauds in election have become
now routine of the day. I may give you
reminder that in recent past days a
01-15 June,2019
truck caught fire at Quazigund area
and when the public went to
extinguish the fire, they were
astounded to see that the truck was
loaded with currency notes worth
crores. The irony of the fact being that
instead of preserving the pubic wealth
the public herself looted it and those
who missed the chance would curse
their fate and destiny. And all of us are
well aware that on the next day there
were lok-saba elections to
be held in Anantnag
constituency.
Relations are now only
material bonds. A father is
here father only till he
feeds his children and a
son is here son only if he
pays money to his
parents. Brothers remain
brothers only if accounts
are balanced between the
two. Superstitious beliefs
are still prevailing despite
the expansion of knowledge and
information. Still it is the belief of a
Saaasu-Maaan that all ill omens have
been brought in the home by newly
bride{Bahu.}
The first news that comes to our ears,
when we rise from the bed, is that an
encounter has started, internet has
been suspended, many people have
died and what is then our expectation
that it will be shut down for three, four
or five days. There is only bloodshed
and violence everywhere in Kashmir.
Govt forces are hell bent on operation
all out. But the irony of the fact being
that despite clearing militancy they
seem to add to the problem as with the
death one militant two more join their
ranks. When this trend going to end.
The most tragic thing is that civilians
are not even spared now. The last year
hot rendering incident at LarooKulgam is an eye opener for all stake
5
holders.
The first news that
comes to our ears, when
we rise from the bed, is
that an encounter has
started, internet has
been suspended, many
people have died and
what is then our
expectation that it will
be shut down for three,
four or five days. There is
only bloodshed and
violence everywhere in
Kashmir.
I can't imagine what has made us
believe that war and weapon is our
protection. G.B Shaw in his play
"Arms and the Man'' puts that soldiers
need chocolates more than that of
cartridges. Realism in contradiction
with the fanaticism. The fake
nationalism has worsened the
situation more. Being a nationalist
doesn't mean that we must trample
down others? Then the fact is that
nationalism transcends all the narrow
domestic walls like communalism
and religious prejudice. Collectively
all the selfish attempts of today's man
has turned this valley into Eliot's
waste land.The only hope left with us
God only if He is happy with us.
Andaaaze bayaan shokh naheen hay mera,
Par shayed ab ki otter jayee dil ma teray meri
baat
AUTHOR IS A TEACHER
PRIMEPOST
HARDLINE
2019 INDIAN POLLS "ORWELLIAN 1984": FUTURE TOTALITARIAN STATE
DR. JOHN MOHAN RAZU
Professor, Social Ethics
ijmrazu@yahoo.in
A
mixed bag of feelings,
perceptions and opinions
keep surfacing from cross
sections of people across the world.
Some say that the results were
'stunning', while others say
'expected'. It is in such a context,
particularly in the emergent political
landscape in India, I am reminded of
George Orwell, a renowned
futurologists, satirists and dystopian
predicted in his novel Nineteen
Eighty Four written 70 years ago
which became seminal and relevant
and eternal moving beyond times
and space. For India in the Post-poll
2019 and the years to come
"Orwellian 1984 shall be the guide
post and goal post that is fixed at
least of the next five-yearsnot
changing of the goal post. This is the
beauty of those who in their own
ways envision and thus
communicate, nuance and put their
concepts in such ways that makes the
readers and analysts to peel layer by
layer in order to derive meaning and
essence.
an Razu.
thics
01-15 June,2019
"Orwellian" is an adjective, defining
a situation, idea, or societal
condition that George Orwell
identified as destructive to the
welfare of a free and open society.
Post-2019 is going to be a defining
moment for Indiafor some their
hopes and aspirations be fulfilled in
consolidating their identity politics
being projected in number of ways,
but for many the current scenario
presents hopelessness, despair and
anxiety. Orwell precisely identifies
and thus predicts the emergent
factors that bear destructive trends to
a multi-cultural, free and open
Indian society. He describes a
political system in which the
government tries to control every
facet and part of people's lives,
similar to that described in the novel
Nineteen Eighty Four.
George Orwell is best known for his
1949 dystopian novel 1984 with its
theme of social injustices and a
controlling authoritarian
government. 1984 elucidates the
real-life situations that are
reminiscent of a kind of state control
and surveillance carried out by "Big
Brother" could perhaps be expected
in India in the coming days.
Governme
nt in a
totalitaria
n setting
could go
to any
extent that
crosses its
limit by
abusing its
absolute
6
power. The BJP government at the
Centre in due course of time could
get involved in watching or listening
or following its citizens who it
suspects or goes against it in tapping
the phone calls or watch closely the
writing or speeches or whatever may
be the modes of communication can
best be described as Orwellian.
The government that has been just
elected under the leadership of Modi
enjoys absolute majority and vested
with absolute power and so the
power leverage if not moderated
could lead to totalitarian dynamic.
The emergent landscape is perhaps
the most dangerous template
wherein power in absolute terms
dominates in which the power cliché
vis-à-vis the cronies and fringes
eventually takes over "power" in
totality and thus unleash at those
who they consider as "others" and
"they" as "non-entities". Their only
justifying point would therefore be
the tags that have been constructed
as "majoritarian" and "we"; we the
"nationalist" and others "against the
nation and our brand of 'nationalism'
and thus be called as "betrayers".
This is indeed 'Orwellian'.
PRIMEPOST
MALALA YOUSUFZAI
&
KASHMIRI GIRLS!
Syed Mustafa
Malala Yousafzai is a stone in front of difficulties;
Because she always looks for the waiting opportunities.
She is a common girl like others but with the different qualities;
And she works in the villages not in the cities.
She overcomes every obstacle and makes her own way;
Because she knows that if she loses then a majority of people will call it a day.
She walks and walks for a greater cause so that life gets some divine ray;
But she is targeted whenever she wants to say.
In our lives, the river is going backwards;
Because the Kashmiri girls don't know the worth of words.
They like to come on the roads without having the depth of geometrical chords;
And at the end of the day, the truth is something different and beat their heads against the rods.
For a greater cause, emotional strength and optimism are the basic building blocks;
But I am amazed that they(the Kashmiri girls) are always busy in useless talks.
Introspection is the foremost rung of the ladder of development among the worldly folks;
And they hate to go for the beneficial jogging but are in the front when it comes to the useless walks.
What have we done at the collective level?
Empty slogans, lethargy, selfish and the works of a dreadful devil.
The purpose of all the lives is to be a civil;
But the civility is gone and we are heading for a different travel.
Creativity should be the concern of our girls in the long run;
Because our lives aren't all about the fake fun.
In the present era ,your responsibilities are more than the responsibilities of a sun!
And if the work is done, say it is undone.
Blocking highways and shouting abusive slogans in the colleges will make your future insecure;
Because the foresightedness is not present in you ,so look for a cure.
All of you want the system of the Caliphate but it has to endure;
Because in this system ,the dirty will be set apart from the pure.
Work collectively and try to bring a real social change;
Because all of you have got an infinite range.
Malala is doing this job in the world, called the strange;
And what has happened to all of us who are not in a position to manage.
No rape will happen if you will stand like the necessary human being;
Because when anyone among you come down from the top ,she is only for seeing!
The threads of bondage are very knotty but all of you should look for freeing;
And when all of you are ready, the curtains of ignorance will begin lifting.
Inconvenience is regretted and for the sake of one, don't make the lives of crores of people hellish;
Because you disturb others and name it the best relish.
Girls all around the world are progressing especially the Welsh;
But all of you are mature but very childish.
I can't compare and contrast Malala with all of you in reality;
But I am on the run and looking for some variety.
syedmustafaahmad9@gmail.com
01-15 June,2019
7
PRIMEPOST
IMPACT
UNDERSTANDING : The Article 370
Touseef Hamid
touseef680.th@gmail.com
I
Historical Background:mmediately after the independence
of Pakistan and India, Confronted
with the chances of losing Kashmir
to Pakistan, Maharaja Hari Singh
requested help from India. Immediately,
Patel's aid V P Menon arrived in
Srinagar and told the Maharaja that India
could take action only if Kashmir
acceded to India. It is widely believed
that Maharaja wanted to keep Kashmir
independent but reluctantly acceded to
India due to the grave situation at that
time as per him. Thus, on October 26,
1947, Maharaja Hari Singh signed the
Instrument of Accession.
Here, we need to note that the accession
was partly provisional. For example,
clause 7 of this instrument read that
Maharaja was NOT committed to accept
the future constitution of India.
Similarly, clause 8 said that nothing in
the instrument affected the sovereignty
of the Kashmir. The subjects that were
surrendered to India included Defence,
01-15 June,2019
External Affairs, Communications and
some ancillary subjects such as elections
and jurisdiction of courts in these three
m
a
t
t
e
r
s
.
With such an instrument in hands, India
had sent its forces to Kashmir. Later,
Sheikh Abdulla, who was under custody,
was released by Maharaja Hari Singh.
Abdullah, although condemned the
invader's attack on Kashmir yet asserted
the sovereign right of the people of
Kashmir to decide their future. In 1948,
he was made the prime minister of
Kashmir.
Meanwhile, Kashmir issue was taken to
By 1949, Sheikh Abdullah and Maharaja
Hari Singh decided that Kashmir should
remain united with India with maximum
possible autonomy. India granted a
special status to Kashmir in article 306A
of the draft constitution. This special
status was given as per clause 7 of the
Instrument of Accession. At that time,
Hasrat Mohani had objected the special
status. But he also expressed hope that in
due course Kashmir would become ripe
for the same kind of integration as
similar to other states. The Article 306A
was enshrined as Article 370 in the
constitution as a "temporary provision".
the UN by Nehru and the issue was given
a tag of an international dispute between
India and Pakistan. Not only that, but
India also made a promise of plebiscite
in Kashmir.
Sheikh Abdullah did not want that to be a
temporary provision and insisted for his
iron-clad guarantee of autonomy but
India did not accept that.
8
PRIMEPOST
IMPACT
I n t r o d u c t i o n : Article 370 of the Indian constitution
is an article that gives autonomous
status to the state of Jammu and
Kashmir. The article is drafted in Part
XXI of the Constitution: Temporary,
Transitional and Special Provisions.
The Constituent Assembly of Jammu
And Kashmir, after its establishment,
was empowered to recommend the
articles of the Indian constitution that
should be applied to the state or to
abrogate the Article 370 altogether.
After the J&K Constituent Assembly
later created the state's constitution
and dissolved itself without
recommending the abrogation of
Article 370, the article was deemed to
have become a permanent feature of
the Indian Constitution.
The state of Jammu and Kashmir's
original accession, like all other
princely states, was on three matters:
defense, foreign affairs, and
communications. All the princely
states were invited to send
representatives to India's Constituent
Assembly, which was formulating a
constitution for the whole of India.
They were also encouraged to set up
constituent assemblies for their own
states. Most states were unable to set
up assemblies in time, but a few states
did, in particular, Saurashtra Union,
Travancore-Cochin and Mysore. Even
though the States Department
developed a model constitution for the
states, in May 1949, the rulers and
chief ministers of all the states met and
agreed that separate constitutions for
the states were not necessary. They
accepted the Constitution of India as
their own constitution. The states that
did elect constituent assemblies
suggested a few amendments which
were accepted. The position of all the
01-15 June,2019
states (or unions of states) thus became
equivalent to that of regular Indian
provinces. In particular, this meant
that the subjects available for
legislation by the central and state
governments was uniform across
India.
However, in the case of Jammu and
Kashmir, the representatives to the
Constituent Assembly requested that
only those provisions of the Indian
Constitution that corresponded to the
original Instrument of Accession
should be applied to the State.
Accordingly, the Article 370 was
incorporated into the Indian
Constitution, which stipulated that the
other articles of the Constitution that
gave powers to the Central
Government would be applied to
Jammu and Kashmir only with the
concurrence of the State's constituent
assembly. As per Article 35A of the
constitution is concerned it is only the
derivative of Article 370, which allows
the Jammu and Kashmir Assembly to
define who is a permanent resident,
who is eligible to vote and work for/in
the state, who can own land and so on.
Thus, under this article, residents of
the state live under a separate set of
laws, relating to ownership of property
and fundamental rights.
Most states were unable to set
up assemblies in time, but a
few states did, in particular,
Saurashtra Union, TravancoreCochin and Mysore. Even
though the States Department
developed a model constitution
for the states, in May 1949, the
9
rulers and chief ministers of all
the states met and agreed that
separate constitutions for the
states were not necessary. They
accepted the Constitution of
India as their own constitution.
The states that did elect
constituent assemblies
suggested a few amendments
which were accepted.
Why 370 is temporary?
There is no doubt that article 370 was
among the temporary provisions of the
Indian constitution not because the
state on the verge of integration with
India but because as J&K is a disputed
territory and was on the agenda of the
United Nations. The position remains
same and Jammu and Kashmir was
and is yet to see its final solution.
It is necessary to mention here that
even Indian Constitution
acknowledges this fact through a
provision to Article 253.
As article 253 of the Indian
Constitution gives overriding powers
to the Center in the domain of
lawmaking for the sake of
implementation of International
treaties irrespective of the distribution
of legislative power between the
Union and the States. The Union is
authorized to make laws even on those
subjects that are otherwise placed
within the state list.
So, In context of J&K the Article 253
makes it clear "that after the
commencement of the constitution
(application to Jammu and Kashmir)
Order, 1954, no decision affecting the
disposition of state of Jammu and
Kashmir shall be made by the
PRIMEPOST
IMPACT
government of India without the
consent of Government of that state."
Constitution Application Order, 48, Sec
2 (6) (e)
Since this disposition is yet to take
place, therefore, Article 370 continues
to be a temporary Article and will
continue to be so unless Jammu and
Kashmir reach its final settlement. And
since this was a "temporary provision"
in that its applicability was intended to
last till the formulation and adoption of
the State's constitution. However, the
State's constituent assembly dissolved
itself on 25 January 1957 without
recommending either abrogation or
amendment of Article 370. Thus the
Article has become a permanent feature
of the Indian constitution, as confirmed
by various rulings of the Supreme court
of India and The High Court Of Jammu
and Kashmir, the latest of which was in
April 2018.
Need for concurrence:Jammu and Kashmir acceded to India
by the Maharaja's Instrument of
Accession on October 26, 1947, in
respect only of three subjects: defense,
foreign affairs, and communications.
Article 370 "limited" the powers of
Parliament to those three subjects. The
President was empowered to make an
order extending to Kashmir these three
subjects and the federal structure in
" co n s u ltatio n " w ith th e S tate
government. But its "concurrence" was
required if additional subjects or other
provisions of the Constitution were to
be applied to Kashmir. There was one
overriding proviso. That concurrence
was subject to ratification by the
Constituent Assembly of Jammu and
Kashmir (Article 370 [2]).
This was made clear beyond doubt by
N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar, the mover
of Article 370 in India's Constituent
Assembly on October 17, 1949.
01-15 June,2019
“
We have also agreed that the
will of the people through the
instrument of the Constituent
Assembly will determine the
Constitution of the State as well
as the sphere of Union
jurisdiction over the State. …You
will remember that several of
these clauses provide for the
concurrence of the Government
of Jammu and Kashmir State.
Now, these relate particularly to
matters which are not
mentioned in the Instrument of
Accession, and it is one of our
commitments to the people and
Government of Kashmir that no
such additions should be made
except with the consent of the
Constituent Assembly which may
be called in the State for the
purpose of framing its
Constitution.
"
Once Kashmir's Constituent Assembly
was "convened" on October 31, 1951,
the State government lost all authority
to accord any "concurrence" to the
Union. With the Assembly's dispersal
on November 17, 1956, after adopting
the Constitution of Jammu and
Kashmir, vanished the only authority
that alone could cede (i) more powers to
the Union and (ii) accept Union
institutions other than those specified
in the Instrument of Accession. So, All
additions to Union powers since then
are unconstitutional.
However, the abuse reduces Jammu
and Kashmir to an inferior position.
For, while in relation to other States, an
amendment to the Constitution would
require a two-thirds vote by both
Houses of Parliament plus ratification
by the States (Article 368), for
Kashmir, mere executive orders by the
President have sufficed since 1953 and
10
God forbid can continue until
doomsday. "Nowhere else, as far as I
can see, is there any provision
authorizing the executive government
to make amendments in the
Constitution," President Rajendra
Prasad pointed out to Prime Minister
Nehru on September 6, 1952. Is this the
state of things we wish to perpetuate?
Presidential orders and their validity:As In exercise of the powers conferred
by clause (1) of article 370 of the
Constitution, certain presidential
orders were made by the president of
India viz; presidential order of 1950,
1952, 1954, 1956……to February
1994. But the main point in it is that up
to 1954 the orders were issued with the
concurrence of constituent assembly
but after 1956 to 1994 all the
presidential orders were issued with the
concurrence of the Government of the
State instead of the constituent
assembly (which ceased to exist from
25th January 1957) and basically many
orders were issued between 11th
February 1956 to 1994 which makes
various other provisions of the
Constitution of India applicable to
Jammu and Kashmir. And moreover, all
these orders were issued with the
'concurrence of the Government of the
State' without any Constituent
Assembly. And as it is clear that any
constitutional order of the president has
to get the prior approval of the
constituent assembly of the state.
Which ceases to exist from January
1957. So whatever constitutional
orders were made after 1957 had the
concurrence of the state legislature. So
it is clear that the validity of the
constitutional order is disputed.
Though the Supreme Court of India
validated these constitutional orders in
Sampat Prakash and Mohd. Maqbool
Damnoo v. State Of Jammu And
PRIMEPOST
IMPACT
Kashmir. 1972 AIR 963, 1972 SCR
(2)1014, cases, yet there remain so many
questions as to the legality of these Orders.
The Supreme Court judgments pertaining
to the validity of these orders were given in
an era when the idea of the basic structure
of the Constitution had not yet evolved.
Supreme Court during those days
perceived amending powers of the
parliament vis-à-vis Constitution of India
was unfettered. Whole of the Indian
constitution in its opinion could be
amended by the Indian parliament. Now,
when it is settled that amending powers of
the Indian parliament can't touch the basic
structure, the principle mutatis mutandi
applies in the context of the state legislature
of Jammu and Kashmir. It does not and
cannot have the same powers as that of the
Constituent Assembly of the state. Once
this issue is settled the validity of all those
constituent application orders becomes
disputed which were pronounced with the
concurrence of the state legislature after the
dissolution of the State Constituent
Assembly in 1957. The concurrence is
required to be given by an elected Sadre
Reyasat. Can a nominated governor be a
substitute for an elected Sadre Reyasat,
raise a similar question about the
Constitution Application Orders enacted
after 1964?
Calls for the abrogation and who has the
power to amend it?
There have been many attempts for the said
article's abrogation beginning in 1956,
1961, 1970 but petitions challenging the
Article 370 were dismissed by the court.
The contemporary debate began after an
RSS-linked NGO challenged it by filing a
PIL in the Supreme court of India on
December 2015 on grounds that Article
370 was added to the constitution through
amendment under Article 368 , that is,
through presidential order and was never
presented before parliament, which the
court admitted and is likely to hear on this
m
a
t
t
e
r
.
Let us take this case into account; if the
Article 370 is a violation of the Article 368
and is unconstitutional then several other
laws that were extended to the state through
presidential orders also need to repealed.
01-15 June,2019
Thus scrapping of this article make all
other presidential orders from 1950
onwards, invalid and nullifies all the 41
subsequent presidential orders, making
various other provisions of the Constitution
of India applicable to Jammu and Kashmir.
Prior to the insertion of Article 35A, the
Governor and the Chief Minister of Jammu
and Kashmir were addressed as the Sadr-eRiyasat (President) and Wazir-e-Azam
(Prime Minister). Its repeal must then lead
back to the same arrangement.
we can say that all such objections are
without substance. The justification behind
the attempts of abrogation is flawed. It is a
gimmick to dump the Kashmir Issue once
for the all. With its abrogation, the people
of Jammu and Kashmir would not only lose
their residency and property rights but it
would trigger a demographic change that
will have a negative impact on the UN
resolutions that promise "plebiscite". It is,
in fact , a well planned conspiracy to
integrate Jammu and Kashmir completely
with India that has acceded to India
conditionally.
Now as we all know that the Indian
Constitution can be amended through
procedures provided under Article 368. But
It has been made clear that the Article 370
can't be amended through procedures
provided in 368. The Article can be
amended and abrogated through a
presidential order with concurrence of the
State which involves the approval of the
Constituent Assembly. It is obvious that
amendment of 370 is not within the domain
of legislative or constituent powers of the
Indian parliament. It can be done by
President of India through a notification
but only after concurrence of the State
Constituent Assembly (which has seized to
exist). But now for a moment if a new
Constituent Assembly is formed that means
current constitution of state along with its
provisions including the one which declare
the state of Jammu and Kashmir to be part
of Indian Union will get dissolved. Will
India take such risk? When in recent past
Kosovo declared independence through
a resolution of similar assembly which
was recognized both by the UN
Security Council and International Court
of Justice.
11
In October 2015, Even the High Court of
Jammu and Kashmir has ruled that the
Article 370 cannot be "abrogated, repealed
or even amended." It explained that the
clause (3) of the Article conferred power to
the State's Constituent Assembly to
recommend to the President on the matter
of the repeal of the Article. Since the
Constituent Assembly did not make such a
recommendation before its dissolution in
1957, the Article 370 has taken on the
features of a "permanent provision" despite
being titled a temporary provision in the
Constitution.On 3 April 2018, the Supreme
Court of India gave a similar opinion
declaring that the Article 370 has acquired
a permanent status. It stated that, since the
State Constituent Assembly has ceased to
exist, the President of India would not be
able to fulfil the mandatory provisions
required for its abrogation.
Personal note:I would like to end it on a Personal note that
Article 370 is the only constitutional or
legal link between J & K and India. And its
abrogation is next to impossible. As it can
be only abrogated with the concurrence of
constituent assembly which however has
ceased to exist from 1957. However if India
tries to abrogate it by one way or other {in
legal perspecillegally}.There will be
serious consequences for India like If
article 370 is abrogated then tive article 1 in
its application to Kashmir will also get
abrogated. And obviously Kashmir will
drop down from schedule 1 (territory).
Then the result will be that the Kashmir will
become independent de jure (legally) if not
de facto (actually). In short we can say that
If Article 370 was abrogated, then
technically and legally the foundation of
Jammu and Kashmir's accession to India
would cease to exist. And More over these
calls for abrogation by one party/N.G.O or
by the other are only politically motivated
calls. My Advice to these people
(politicians/NGO'S) will be to stop this
drama As you all know the reality that there
are only two options in front of you (India)
viz; either J & K's accession to India would
cease to exist Or article 370 will still be part
of Indian constitution.
PRIMEPOST
COVERSTORY
Indian Politics 2019
A cocktail of Development and Nationalism Worked
He's seen as the man who scripted
the BJP's thumping wins in 2014
and 2019 - and who helped the
party make inroads in states such as
West Bengal where they barely had
a presence earlier.
The new cabinet is largely upper
caste - and has few ministers from
the south
Nine of the 25 new cabinet
ministers are Brahmins, who are at
the top of India's tenacious caste
hierarchy.
Despite the fact that 131 seats in the
Lok Sabha are reserved for
members of Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes, who are among
the country's most vulnerable
communities, only 10 of them have
been appointed ministers. Even
fewer made it to the cabinet.
Only three of the cabinet ministers
- Ms Seetharaman, Mr Jaishankar
and Sadanand Gowda - are from
India's five southern states, which
send 119 MPs to parliament.
Only one Muslim made the ranks
16-31 May,2019
Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, the BJP's
only Muslim minister, is an MP
from the upper house or Rajya
Saha, which is not directly elected.
A long-time member of the BJP, he
has been a minister in the previous
government too but this is his first
cabinet post. He has been
appointed minister of minority
affairs.
Aligned to this, deftly, was
the promise of development.
Mr Modi's targeted welfare
schemes for the poor - homes,
toilets, credit, cooking gas have used technology for
speedy delivery. However, the
quality of these services and
how much they have helped
ameliorate deprivation is
debatable.
Mr Naqvi is the only Muslim
member of the new cabinet
This should not be too surprising
since the new Lok Sabha has just
26 Muslim MPs - three more than
in 2014. The BJP contested 437
seats but only fielded seven
12
Muslim candidates. And none of
them won.
Thirty two of the main opposition
Congress party's 423 candidates
were Muslim - only four of them
won.
Modi 2.0, as it has been
dubbed by the Indian media,
lost two veteran politicians in
former finance minister Arun
Jaitley and former foreign
minister Sushma Swaraj who
opted out because of poor
health.
The mystery of India's 'missing'
Muslim politicians
Muslim political representation in
India's parliament has been
steadily falling. While the
community's population in India
has more than doubled from 68
million in 1981 to 172 million in
2011, the number of Muslim MPs
has nearly halved from 49 in 1980
to 22 in 2014.
PRIMEPOST
OPINION
Revisiting Ambedkar's Idea of Nationalism
Ambedkar stood with the most downtrodden and deprived sections of the Indian society; the sections which had no voice in public life. The social
mobilization of these sections by Ambedkar helped in the national freedom movement. As the Chairman of the Drafting Committee, Ambedkar
advocated a strong nation-state.
Dr. Swadesh Singh
Introduction
Over thousands of years, human
civilization organized itself first in the
form of family, then as religion and
today we are organized as nationstate. It makes you wonder which
institution would the future
generations be living in? I posed this
question to a well-known social
16-31 May,2019
scientist during a discussion on
globalization. He weighed several
ideas but concluded that in the present
context nation-state is still the most
enduring institution and likely to be
the organisational unit for the coming
generations too.
Today we live within this institution
of nation-state. Foremost of our
thoughts and actions, it serves as a
centre of gravity, obvious at some
time and obscure at others. It is one of
the most organised, well designed
institutions which has an organic
relationship with mankind and where
universal ideas like freedom, equality
and democracy have a good chance to
flourish. Western thinkers like
Gellner, Anderson and Hobsbawm
dealt with the idea of nation,
nationalism and nationhood which
13
developed in the region over the last
400 years after the Treaty of Westfalia
in 1648.
The Bhartiya concept of Rashtra
could be considered a parallel to the
western term 'Nation' but both are also
different on several counts. The
primary difference between the two
stems from the fact that Rashtra is
more of an ethic-spiritual concept
while Nation is a cultural concept.(1)
Many Indian leaders like Sri Arvindo,
Gandhi, Nehru, Tilak, Tagore and
Deen Dayal Upadhyay delved into the
idea of Indian nation and nationalism.
Their ideas are either spiritual, metaphysical or statist. In this article we
will try to trace Dr. Bhim Rao
Ambedkar's ideas and reflections on
Nationalism. He is the most
celebrated Indian leader, thinker and
PRIMEPOST
OPINION
and social philosopher of the 21st
century who contributed in the 20th
century. Large-scale celebrations
marking his 125th birth anniversary
were concluded recently. Observers
felt that these celebrations were more
wide-spread than those in his
centenary year. One of the leading
mainstream magazines termed him as
the greatest leader of Modern India.
Over the years, ideas of Ambedkar
have become stronger and more
relevant to the contemporary
discourse.
Ambedkar and his Narrative of
Freedom
At any given point of time, several
parallel narratives can coexist.
However, only one grand narrative at
a time can push the discourse forward.
Before the Indian Independence, the
grand narrative was the freedom of
India while several other narratives
did exist. One such narrative was
prescribed by the Congress party. It
emphasized on freedom from the
British colonisers. It can be said that
this was the dominating narrative of
the time. There were also other,
though weaker or marginalized in
comparison. One such narrative was
that of the Rashtriya Swayamsewak
Sangh (RSS) which saw India as a
glorious nation since time
immemorial land targeted
reconstruction of the Indian nation by
strengthening its socio-cultural
institutions. It wanted to arouse the
national consciousness of every
common Indian. The core belief in
this case was that once the society
becomes strong no one could enslave
it.
Another narrative of the time was
given by Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar. He
talked about freedom of India from
social inequality and untouchability.
This could be understood as a
01-15 June,2019
subaltern narrative about the
upliftment of downtrodden, deprived
and marginalised sections of the
society; the section that did not have
any participation in public life of
colonial India. Dr. Ambedkar became
the voice of these 60 million
deprived section known as
Scheduled Castes (the term Dalit
e v o l v e d l a t e r ) . Wi t h o u t
emancipation of these deprived
people, Indian freedom struggle
was not deemed to be complete.
The Indian national struggle in the
first half of the century was not
merely a struggle to wrest political
power from foreign rule but also a
struggle to lay the foundation of a
modern India by purging the
society of outmoded social
institutions, beliefs and attitudes.
Ambedkar's struggle constituted a
part of the internal struggle, one of
the divergent and sometimes
conflicting currents all of which
helped to secure 'freedom' from
external and internal oppression
and enslavement.
The feeling of nationality
may be present and yet the
feeling of nationalism may be
quite absent. That is to say,
nationality does not in all
cases produce nationalism.
For nationality to flame into
nationalism two conditions
must exist. First, there must
arise the will to live as a
nation.
Without Ambedkar's opposition to
mainstream nationalism, the
process of internal consolidation
of the nation would not have been
carried out sufficiently enough to
strengthen and broaden the social
base of Indian nationalism.(2)
14
Ambedkar's idea of Nationalism
Ambedkar elaborated on the idea
of Nationality and Nationalism in
his book Pakistan or the Partition
of India. He describes nationality
as a, "consciousness of kind,
awareness of the existence of that
tie of kinship" and nationalism as
"the desire for a separate national
existence for those who are bound
by this tie of kinship." It is true that
there cannot be nationalism
without the feeling of nationality.
But, it is important to bear in mind
that the converse is not always
true. The feeling of nationality
may be present and yet the feeling
of nationalism may be quite
absent. That is to say, nationality
does not in all cases produce
nationalism. For nationality to
flame into nationalism two
conditions must exist. First, there
must arise the will to live as a
nation. Nationalism is the
dynamic expression of that desire.
Secondly, there must be a territory
which nationalism could occupy
and make it a state, as well as a
cultural home of the nation.
Wi t h o u t s u c h a t e r r i t o r y,
nationalism, to use Lord Acton's
phrase, would be a soul as it were
wandering in search of a body in
which to begin life over again and
dies out finding none.(3)
Expanding Social Base of
Nationalism
Ambedkar had immense faith in
the bright future and evolution of
this country. Even when he spoke
of attaining freedom for India, his
ultimate goal was to unite the
people. He said, "So far as the
ultimate goal is concerned, none
of us have any apprehension or
doubt. Our difficulty was not
about the ultimate thing but how to
PRIMEPOST
OPINION
spiritual aspect of Indian texts and codes
but not with its ritualistic aspects which
had developed in last 1200 years. He
talked about Annihilation of Caste not
Dharma. He understood the importance
of Dharma in India and when the time of
conversion came as he had declared
earlier, he chose Buddhism and not any
other Abrahamic religion. He also had the
option of declaring him as an Atheist but
his rootedness in Indian ethos compelled
him to choose Buddhism.
Strengthening Nationalism through
Constitution
Ambedkar opposed insertion of Article
370 which gives special status to the state
of Jammu & Kashmir but Nehru still went
ahead with it to appease Sheikh Abdullah.
Ambedkar wrote to Sheikh Abdullah on
Article 370, "You wish India should
protect your borders, she should build
roads in your area, she should supply you
food grains, and Kashmir should get
equal status as India. But Government of
India should have only limited powers
and Indian people should have no rights
in Kashmir. To give consent to this
proposal would be a treacherous thing
against the Interest of India and I, as the
Law Minister of India, will never do
it."(9)
Justice K. Ramaswamy while probing
into the legal aspects of nationalism likes
to call Ambedkar a true democrat, a
nationalist to the core and a patriot of
highest order on various grounds.(10) He
was the author and principal actor to
make the 'Directive Principles' as part of
the constitutional scheme. When it was
criticized that the directive principles
could not be enforced in a court of law,
Ambedkar answered that though they
were not enforceable, the succeeding
majority political party in Parliament or
Legislative Assembly would be bound by
them as an inbuilt part of their economic
program in the governance, despite their
policy in its manifesto and are bound by
the Constitution. Ambedkar, in his
Constitutional schema of nationalism,
01-15 June,2019
undertook the task of strengthening the
upper castes, while Brahmins provided
Executive in particular and the notion of
him vital help at key moments in his life;
'Integrated Bharat' in general.
he dismissed the historical theory of the
Rising above the regional, linguistic and
Aryan invasion of the Indian
communal barriers in a true republican
subcontinent. He apparently also
spirit, Ambedkar invented a democratic
promised "shuddhikaran" or purification
nationalism consisting of Uniform Civil
for those Dalits who had converted to
Code for India. His views of Uniform
Islam in Hyderabad state in 1947Civil Code were radically different from
48."(13)
his contemporaries including Nehru who
It is evident from the above discussion
in principles accepted Hindu Code Bill
that Ambedkar was neither an antiand Uniform Civil Code but in practice,
national nor just a leader of the Scheduled
failed to get the Bill passed in one go, in
Castes. He was a national leader who
spite of being in Government with
understood the problems of the most
majority. Ambedkar on the other hand
exploited communities and tried to bring
made it a point to add the word 'fraternity'
them into the main stream. He expanded
in the Preamble to the Constitution in
the social base of Indian nationalism
order to inculcate the sense of common
which helped first to attain freedom and
brotherhood of all Indians, of Indians
later to put the country on path of
being one people; it is the principle which
progress. Today, when all thought
gives unity and solidarity to social life.
converges around inclusive politics,
He was also critical of Muslim Personal
Ambedkar has become more relevant
Law and tried his best to abolish it in
than ever.
favour of Uniform Civil Code.
Nationalism is a dynamic process of
Conclusion
social assimilation and therefore
There is no doubt that Ambedkar was
nationalism is to receive its perfect
vehemently opposed to the unjust social
harmony in the realization of social
stratification in India, but to say that he
brotherhood of men irrespective of caste,
was against the nation is wholly wrong.
colour and creed. Nationalism is not
He was definitely against the Congress
antithetical to humanism or
version of Nationalism. Ambedkar says,
individualism. One can enjoy complete
"I know my position has not been
individual freedom within a nationalist
understood properly in the country. I say
framework. Everyone needs a space to
that whenever there has been a conflict
think, to grow and liberate. In the present
between my personal interests of the
point in time, Nation is the best institution
country as a whole, I have always placed
we have to fulfil this purpose. We do need
the claims of the country above my
a grand narrative which includes the last
personal claims. I have never pursued the
woman in the queue. Dr. Ambedkar did
path of private gain... so far as the
give us a grand-narrative of "equality in
demands of the country are concerned, I
socio-economic life along with political
have never lagged behind'.(12)
equality".
Last year, In a seminar organised in New
About Author:
Delhi, Dr. Krishna Gopal (Jt. General PhD from Jawaharlal Nehru University,
Secretary, RSS) claimed, "Besides being
New Delhi and PG Diploma in Mass
a champion of the untouchables, Communication from Indian Institute
Ambedkar was, first and foremost, a of Mass Communication, New Delhi.
Currently I teach Political Science in
nationalist, a virulent anti-Communist
Satyawati College, Delhi University,
and had immense faith in Hinduism; he
New Delhi.
was against Brahminical structures but
some of his closest friends were from
15
PRIMEPOST
OPINION
unite the heterogeneous mass that we
are today to take a decision in
common and march in a cooperative
way on that road, which is bound to
lead us to unity."(4)
Ambedkar clearly spoke in a
felicitation program of his 55th birth
anniversary, "I have loyalty to our
people inhabiting this country. I have
also loyalty to this country. I have no
doubt that you have the same. All of
us want this country to be free. So far
as I am concerned my conduct has
been guided by the Consideration
that we shall place no great
difficulties in the way of this country
achieving its freedom."(5)
Ambedkar was not against the idea
of nationalism but against the
Congress's version which entailed
freedom of India from British
colonialism but not from
Brahminical imperialism under
which millions of Scheduled Castes
had been yoked for hundreds of
years. It was Ambedkar's political
challenge which compelled the
Congress to appreciate the national
significance of the problem of castes
and to adopt measures which
significantly contributed towards
broadening and strengthening the
social base of Indian nationalism.
Ambedkar's Challenge to 'Congress
Nationalism'
Indian nationalism in its initial
stages, by the very nature of its
historical development, was an
upper class (upper castes)
phenomenon, reflecting the interests
and aspirations of its members.
Naturally when nationalists spoke in
terms of national interest they
certainly meant their own (class)
interests. The evocation of 'nation'
was a necessary ritual to ensure the
much needed popular support for an
essentially partisan cause. This
01-15 June,2019
sectarian approach to nationalism
could be seen in the writings of none
other than Pt. Nehru who later
singled out as an example of a 'left
liberal' view. He writes in his
seminal work Discovery of India that
mixture of religion and philosophy,
history and tradition, custom and
social structure, which in its wide
fold included almost every aspect of
the life of India, and which might be
called Brahminism or (to use a later
word) Hinduism, became the symbol
of nationalism. It was indeed a
national religion.
“
Without social union, political
unity is difficult to be
achieved. If achieved, it would
be as precarious as a summer
sapling, liable to be uprooted
by the gust of a hostile wind.
With mere political unity, India
may be a State
The sectarian character of Indian
nationalism persisted even after the
nascent upper castes' movement
developed into a truly masssupported anti-imperialist national
liberation movement enlisting the
support of millions of people cutting
across the traditional social
divisions. And, it is this failure to
change its basically pro-upper
class/castes orientation despite a
basic shift in its underlying social
base that Indian national movement
in due course helped the rise of new
sectarian socio-political currents,
running parallel to the mainstream
national movement. Ambedkar's
emergence on the Indian political
scene in 1920s, commencing the
advent of Dalit (the scheduled
castes) politics, was simply the
manifestation of the same
16
process.(6)
Ambedkar's Dalit politics posed no
really significant threat to the overall
domination of the traditional ruling
class, yet it certainly exposed the
hollowness of the Congress's
nationalist claim to represent the
w h o l e n a t i o n . F i n a l l y, t h e
unwillingness of the nationalist
leadership to attack the long
unresolved social contradictions at
the base of the Hindu social order
propelled people like Ambedkar to
contest the claim of the Indian
National Congress to represent the
scheduled castes. (7)
It was in the backdrop of this escapist
attitude of the Congress brand of
nationalism that an alternative
subaltern nationalism was born
through Ambedkar. Ambedkar took
up this question from social below
and elevated it to a political high by
linking this social question of caste
with the political question of
democracy and nationalism. Such an
effort to prioritize society over polity
and then linking them together was
unprecedented in India before
Ambedkar. Gandhi can be said to
have made such an effort but his
approach was obscure and primitive.
According to Ambedkar,
"Without social union, political
unity is difficult to be achieved. If
achieved, it would be as precarious
as a summer sapling, liable to be
uprooted by the gust of a hostile
wind. With mere political unity,
India may be a State. But to be a State
is not to be a nation and a State,
which is not a nation, has small
prospects of survival in the struggle
for existence."(8)
Ambedkar's Faith in 'Bharat'
Ambedkar had faith in ancient
Indian institutions and texts except
caste. He was convinced with the
PRIMEPOST
OURTURN
Happiness Lies In Helping Others
What we give to others is our biggest investment because it will be returned back to us manifold by the Bank of God!
Meer Abass
Assistant Professor
Department of English
Govt Degree College Handwara
Meerabas32@gmail.com
T
here is a Chinese saying that
goes: "If you want happiness
for an hour, take a nap. If you
want happiness for a day, go fishing.
If you want happiness for a year,
inherit a fortune. If you want
happiness for a lifetime, help
somebody." For centuries, the
greatest thinkers have suggested the
same thing: Happiness is found in
helping others.
And so we learn early: It is better to
give than to receive. The venerable
aphorism is drummed into our heads
from our first slice of a shared
birthday cake. But is there a deeper
truth behind the truism?
The resounding answer is yes.
Scientific research provides
compelling data to support the
anecdotal evidence that giving is a
powerful pathway to personal
growth and lasting happiness.
Through MRI technology, we now
01-15 June,2019
know that giving activates the same
parts of the brain that are stimulated
by food and sex. Experiments show
evidence that altruism is hardwired
in the brain
and it's
pleasurable
. Helping
others may
just be the
secret to
living a life
that is not
o n l y
happier but
also healthier, wealthier, more
productive, and meaningful.
But it's important to remember that
giving doesn't always feel great. The
opposite could very well be true:
Giving can make us feel depleted and
taken advantage of. Our passion
should be the foundation for our
giving. It is not how much we give,
but how much love we put into
giving. It's only natural that we will
care about this and not so much about
that, and that's OK. It should not be
simply a matter of choosing the right
thing, but also a matter of choosing
what is right for us. The gift of time is
often more valuable to the receiver
and more satisfying for the giver than
the gift of money. We don't all have
the same amount of money, but we
all do have time on our hands, and
can give some of this time to help
others whether that means we devote
our lifetimes to service, or just give a
few hours each day or a few days a
year. Selfless giving, in the absence
17
of self-preservation instincts, easily
becomes overwhelming.
We have all felt the dread that comes
from being cajoled into
giving, such as when
friends ask us to donate to
their fundraisers. In these
cases, we are more likely to
give to avoid humiliation
rather than out of
generosity and concern.
This type of giving doesn't
lead to a warm glow
feeling; more likely it will
lead to resentment. Instead we
should set aside time, think about our
options, and find the best charity for
our values. I don't want to discourage
people from giving to good causes
just because that doesn't always
cheer us up. If we gave only to get
something back each time we gave,
what a dreadful, opportunistic world
this would be! Yet if we are feeling
guilt-tripped into giving, chances are
we will not be very committed over
time to the cause.
It's easy to get so
wrapped up in fixing
your own life that you
forget about helping
others. And while it's
important to put yourself
first sometimes, it's even
more important to help
others whenever you
can.
It's easy to get so wrapped up in
PRIMEPOST
OURTURN
fixing your own life that you forget
about helping others. And while it's
important to put yourself first
sometimes, it's even more
important to help others whenever
you can.
Being generous isn't even always
about altruism becoming more
generous and compassionate will
have real tangible benefits in your
own life,
We live in a world where both
kinds of people live, the people
who spend their lives lavishly and
the people who hardly get three
meals a day. The second kind of
people cannot even afford the basic
requirements. One cannot make
these kinds of people sumptuous
but at least ease them by lending a
helping them. We can assist the
poor to achieve the essentials of
life. We live in a world which is full
of humanitarian needs; numerous
people are dying of hunger every
minute. Helping a single person to
get food to eat and place to live can
bring wonders to their life.
It is the 21st century but the social
era persisted from early times. No
matter how strong someone is; at
some or the other point, he has to
seek for some kind of help from
others. Offering a helping hand to
the needy is the greatest job one
can do to achieve inner peace and
satisfaction. There are many
people who are deprived of even
the basic needs. On the other
hand, there even is a huge crowd
that has plentiful luxuries. In
India, the rich get richer while the
poor get poorer.
01-15 June,2019
How to help the Poor and Needy
?
better place to be at.
Not only in monetary terms but
apart from financial conditions,
there are eclectic people who seek
for help and needs to be helped too.
Happiness grows when it is shared.
A sense of sharing needs to be
developed in every individual for
both personal and social uplifting.
This has to be inculcated in every
person right in the beginning ages
of growth and maturity. Kids
should be taught how to help the
people who are not well off as
them. Working class should take a
step ahead to help their colleagues
understand the areas they are not
that good at. Old aged people
should impart their experiences to
the younger generation those who
are in real need of it.
We live in a world where
both kinds of people live,
the people who spend their
lives lavishly and the people
who hardly get three meals a
day. The second kind of
people cannot even afford
the basic requirements. One
cannot make these kinds of
people sumptuous but at
least ease them by lending a
helping them.
Help can be of any type; it is a
personal choice to opt for it. A selfcentered and shrewd attitude might
take you ahead in the career graph
or let you achieve personal
development; but, satisfaction and
content can be achieved only when
there is a social development.
Collective efforts of being a help to
the neighborhood of the needy
ones will surely broaden the
perspective of people and sow a
better future, a better world and a
The Joy of Helping Needy !!
Some simple tasks could be carried
out in everyday life by every
individual will surely help the
needy ones. Children should
donate their old toys and clothes to
the kids those who are poor and
cannot afford to have all these
luxuries. They should save some
portion of their pocket money and
offer it to abandoned or orphan
fellow kids. People at offices
should consider their house
keeping staff, catering staff,
transport staff etc and be nice to
them. Home makers should engage
some part of their time in teaching
academically deprived students. A
couple who is pretty rich can take
the responsibility of educating a
poor child who has immense
potential.
There are several ways in which
one can be a help for the other. All
that is to be done is understand its
importance and follow your
positive instincts.
17
PRIMEPOST
CONFLICT
HALF WIDOWS
THE INVISIBLE AND MARGINALIZED GROUP OF KASHMIRI WOMEN
DR.MASOON AHMAD BEIG
T
he derailment of the
normalcy in Kashmir started
in the year 1989 and
the last 30 years of conflict
brought the painful currents,
unforgettable tragic
memories, heavy loss of life
and property. Some of the
victims are very much visible,
where some others are silent
therefore invisible and
marginalized .Such silent
victims of Kashmir violence
include the half widows- a
new frame of reference first
time employed in any conflict
zone.
well to do people or opt for some
other much lesser important jobs in
various small establishments which
never are well paid. Thus, their
financial needs remain half
addressed besides being
unsatisfactory.
in future health issues. In a vicious
cycle of, the worsening mental and
physical health of half widows has
adverse effects on their socioeconomic situation as well as
mental health.
The various socio-economic
pressures do affect the psyche of
half widows that largely go as
unaddressed. Most of the half
widows report anxiety (often
described in terms of speeding up or
palpitations) sleeps disorders and
lack of interest in daily activities.
Many of half widows exhibit post
The various socio-economic
pressures do affect the
psyche of half widows that
largely go as unaddressed.
Most of the half widows
report anxiety (often
described in terms of
speeding up or palpitations)
sleeps disorders and lack
of interest in daily
activities. Many of half
widows exhibit post
traumatic stress disorder
(PTSD), anxiety attacks
may be triggered by
memories of the
disappearance. Half
widows are known as self
medicated consuming
easily available
antidepressants resulting
in future health issues.
The fate of the half widows is
totally different from that of
widows. Half widows go
through identity crisis owing
to the disappearances of their
husbands which lead them to
be designated as half widows.
Half widows are struggling
hard to provide food and
education to their children.
They find it difficult to
muddle through these additional
complex responsibilities. Majority
of half-widows are illiterate and
therefore do some menial jobs like
washing dishes, to work as part time
domestic helpers in the families of
01-15 June,2019
traumatic stress disorder (PTSD),
anxiety attacks may be triggered by
memories of the disappearance.
Half widows are known as self
medicated consuming easily
available antidepressants resulting
19
A half widow is shorn of the
property rights, only death of her
husband gives her the legal
property rights. Under Islamic
law a widow with children gets
one eighth of her husband's
property , a widow without
children gets one fourth of her
husband's property , but a half
widow gets nothing till her
husband is declared dead.
The field experimentation and
personal observation of the
researcher reveals that "half
widows" of the Kashmir are the
unidentified faces who suffer from
PRIMEPOST
CONFLICT
widows who had opted for
re-marriage are not happy
because their children
have suffered a lot.
unidentified faces who suffer from
economic and social crisis. The case
study of the half widows of Kashmir
whose economic conditions are very
unsupportative reveals that half
widows are living in a despondent
condition. They have become the
victims of various psychological
disorders. In most of the cases it was
found that the poor economic
condition is responsible for their ill
health and psychological problems.
The half widows of Kashmir are
struggling hard to fulfill their basic
requirements. The "Ulmas" and
religious scholars have passed
"Fatwas" in favour of half widows
that a half widow can re-marry after
four years of disappearance of her
husband.
It was also observed by the
experimentation that these half
widows are not ready for remarriage because of their children.
Most of the half widows are still
living with the hope that their
husbands are alive and may return
one day. Some half widows who had
01-15 June,2019
opted for re-marriage are not happy
because their children have suffered
a lot.
The half widows of Kashmir
are struggling hard to fulfill
their basic requirements.
The "Ulmas" and religious
scholars have passed
"Fatwas" in favour of half
widows that a half widow
can re-marry after four
years of disappearance of
her husband.
It was also observed by the
experimentation that these
half widows are not ready
for re-marriage because of
their children. Most of the
half widows are still living
with the hope that their
husbands are alive and may
return one day. Some half
20
Half widows are emotionally
disturbed and socially unhinged.
Suffering from post traumatic
stress disorders (PTSD) they do
not sleep and have nightmares.
Not only has this but they also
experience stressful events
which led them to emotional
instability and strain. With the
result they are prone to addiction
of tranquilizers, sedatives and anti
depressants. Most of the half
widows are still waiting for their
disappeared husbands which have
stopped them from remarriage, but
this status have also put grave
impacts on their physical and mental
health. Half widows live a very
traumatic life under stress and strain
and are living under fear and in the
state of insecurity and inadequacy.
Author Teaches Geography at
Govt. Degree College Kulgam and
has worked on Half- Widows of
Kashmir Valley.
PRIMEPOST
VIEWS
Traffic Mess: A Daily Affair
of Common Kashmiri !
Muneer Sheikh
sheikhmuni13@gmail.com
I
n the recent times every citizen
must have experienced the worst
traffic jams. It is an inescapable
condition. Sometimes one gets
caught for hours together. In the 21st
c e n t u r y, w h e r e
people were
expecting to travel
desired places in a
calculated time but
it is like building
castles in air . Even
to travel a
kilometre here
fetches an hour.
Such is our plight.
Traffic mess is the
hottest topic of
discussion in every
social gathering. It
stems from the widespread desires of
people to pursue certain goals that
inevitability overload existing roads
and transit systems everyday.
Congestion has become part of
commuters daily leisure time and it
seems to stay that way.
What is the cause of this mess and can
01-15 June,2019
it be remedied or ameliorated ?The
various causes may include
disproportionate growth ratio
between roads and vehicles , illegal
occupation of footpaths , insufficient
parking slots, inadequate vehicle
stands and so on. However one of the
most important cause is lack of traffic
sense and mass education about it.
Last but not the least is unpleasant
security scenario restricting the free
movement on all roads etc.
Disproportionate growth ratio
between vehicle And roads. The
number of vehicles plying on roads
are now competing with the
population growth. Almost each
member in a family owns a vehicle.
Roads are same but new vehicles are
added to traffic system at alarming
rate. The roads have reached a
saturation point consequently traffic
mess is the result. Next comes illegal
occupation of footpaths .Footpaths
are invariably under illegal
occupation forcing the pedestrians to
21
The various causes may
include disproportionate
growth ratio between roads
and vehicles , illegal
occupation of footpaths ,
insufficient parking slots,
inadequate vehicle stands and
so on. However one of the
most important cause is lack of
traffic sense and mass
education about it.
Walk on the roads. In some places
almost half of the road on either side
is used by shopkeepers to display
their wares. Most disappointing is
double sided parking nearly on all
roads, consequently the
driving space gets
shrunk and results in a
mess. Other interesting
cause is mushrooming
of fountains at road
crossings. Already we
have inadequate road
space why are such
decorative pieces
constructed at such
sites. They can be
tucked on some
selected spots on the
road sides. The reason
behind is such fountains obstruct the
drivers view. Finally the unpleasant
security scenario restricting the free
movement on all roads is one of the
i m p o r t a n t f a c t o r. U n w a n t e d
barricades at crossings ,bridges etc.
Flyovers are meant for reducing the
traffic congestion but we have one
PRIMEPOST
VIEWS
paradigm so called Jahangir ChowkRambagh flyover. It has increased
the worries of common people as its
prolong construction has made the
surrounding roads worst traffic jam
hit spots. Hope it gets completed this
year and help to some extent not only
in controlling the traffic congestion
of the adjoining areas but also help in
saving our precious time.
Other aspect is traffic sense and
knowledge of rules. The less said
about it, the better. Fast lane, yellow
line , Zebra crossings etc. And similar
other words of traffic terminology
are not only unknown to common
people but the constables monitoring
and directing the vehicular
movement at different places. The
other sad side is one doesn't need
technical or other knowledge to get a
driving licences. It can be delivered
at your home provided you have
means and resources. Age criteria
doesn't matter here.
Now the question is can it be
remedied or ameliorated ? Yes is the
qualified answer.
Something like concept of ring roads
01-15 June,2019
can be productive. Keeping Check on
the alaraming increase of vehicles in
traffic system can reduce the mess.
Implementation of strict traffic rules
can be the good step. Proper and
standard procedure for getting a
traffic licences can be good enough.
Moreover accidents can be avoided
by this initiative. New spacious roads
need to be constructed. Traffic
awareness programs can be helpful.
Parking slots are the need of the hour.
Shopkeeper's need to be dealt
according to law if found gulity.
Public transport need to be used
more. Traffic police need to be made
active and accountable and surely
more personnel's need to be recruited
in traffic Police.
Swift measures and initiatives need
to be taken. People who are at the
helm of affairs need to ponder on in
order to get away from this dynamic
and grave problem of Traffic Morass.
Author is Pursuing BE Civil at
SSM College of Engineering and
Technology.
MODERN BOOK
CENTRE & STATIONERS
WHOLESALE & RETIAL
All kinds of stationery items, Academic Books, School Bags, Islamic Books, Gift Items, Photostat, Lamination, DTP Work.
MODERN NEWS AGENCY
All Types of Newspapers & Magazines Distribution, Advertisements (Print, Electronic) & much more
MAIN MARKET HMT ZAINAKOTE SGR - 190012
Ph.No: 9622539711,9797182304, 9596277469 EMAIL-ID: mbcstationers1999@gmai.com
22
PRIMEPOST
KIDZEE
Art and Craft » Scary Skeleton T-shirts
Brain Teasers
Bus Driver
You are driving a bus. Ten people
entered the bus and three got off
at the first stop. Five girls
entered the bus and seven girls got off the bus at the
college stop. Later three old men along with four couples
entered the bus. In the railway station stop, 6 men got off.
What was the colour of the driver's eyes?
Scary Skeleton T-shirt
Glow-in-the-dark paint and glitter work brilliantly for a trick or
treat party or whenever the lights are turned out. The paint and
sparkle goes a long way, so it is ideal for several friends to have
a go at creating decorations or their own scary skeleton T-shirt.
Things you need
White paper
Pencils (ordinary and white)
Scissors
Black T-shirt (preferably long sleeved)
Sticky tape
White fabric paint
Paintbrush
Glow in the dark paint
Instructions
Draw bone shapes on white paper: ten sausages for ribs, seven
rough circles for back vertebrae and elbows, and four traditional
cylinders with a bulb at each end of the arms. Cut them out and
position them on the front of the T-shirt. Tape them down so
they do not move. Draw around the shapes with a white pencil.
Remove the sticky tape and paper bones, and place a piece of
paper inside the T-shirt to make sure the paint does not go
through to the back of the fabric. Paint the bone shapes with
white fabric paint.
When the paint is completely dry (leave it overnight to be sure),
lightly paint over the bones with glow-in-the-dark paint. Add a
second coat of paint for an even better effect if you wish.
Variations
Rain and Dry Hair
It rained heavily. Mr. Ray walked with no umbrella. While he
was completely wet and soaked in water by rain, not a
single hair became wet. He neither wore a cap nor covered
his head. How is that possible?
Read with no light
It was a new moon day. A girl was sitting on the balcony at
8 pm. There was no power in the house and the entire
street was dark. She was reading in the dark. How?
Word Power
When you read a word normally or upside down, it remains
the same. Name the word!
How many children
Mr. Sinha has 7 daughters. Each daughter has a brother.
Now, tell me how many children Mr. Sinha has?
Death!
A thief was imprisoned for stealing precious jewelry and
was brought in a King's court for punishment. The king
asked for his one last desire; expect the desire that he
should be discharged from the punishment. The thief was
silent for a while and said, 'I have no desire'. The merciful
aging king asked him how he would like to die. After
hearing his answer the king happily freed him. What did the
thief tell the king?
Night sky
Glittery glow-in-the-dark stars, moons, and planets are very
effective party decorations. Simply fasten them on a wall or
window with a sticky tape or hang them from a piece of cord.
Party invitations
Make a party
invitation by
sticking your motif
to a card and
complete it with a
glow in the dark
writing. Give clear
instructions on the
envelope that it
must be opened in
the dark.
A Stranger in the car
A man and his wife were driving to the nearby city. Since
the lady screamed for her life, the man halted the car and
rushed to seek help from the neighbors. When he returned
back to the car, he saw his wife in a critically bad condition,
near to death's door, accompanied by a stranger that he
had never seen before. The police arrived to the place and
never questioned the stranger. How?
01-15 June,2019
23
PRIMEPOST
24