GENETICS SOCIETY OF NIGERIA
(GSN)
GENETICS AND THE FUTURE
Proceedings of the 37th Annual Conference of the Genetics Society of Nigeria.
Edited By
E.H. KWON-NDUNG, D. M. OGAH AND A. YAKUBU
DATE:
20th TO 24th OCTOBER, 2013
LAFIA
Copy Right 2013: GENETICS SOCIETY OF NIGERIA
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form
or by any means, electronic, electrostatic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise,
without the prior permission from the Genetics Society of Nigeria.
1
ISBN = 0189-9686
Published by the Genetics Society of Nigeria.
2
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COUNCIL OF THE GENETICS SOCIETY OF NIGERIA
1.
Prof. W. Akin-Hassan
President
2.
Dr. G.A. Iwo
Vice President I
3.
Dr. Ahmadu Usman Dahiru
Vice President II
4.
Dr. (Mrs) Ngozi E. Abu
Secretary General
5.
Dr. Udensi Ogbu
Assistant Secretary General
6.
Rakiya O. Abdulmalik
Treasurer
7.
Dr. Macauley Asim Ittah
Business Manager
8.
Dr. D.M. Ogah
Public Relations/Welfare Officer
9.
Dr. O.F. Owolade
Financial Secretary
10.
Dr. Bassey Okon
Internal Auditor
11.
Dr. S.A. Olakojo
Editor In Chief
12.
Dr. Inuwa Shehu Usman
Associate Editor I
13.
Dr. Fayeye T. Rotimi
Associate Editor II
14.
Prof. Gbadebo Olaoye
Ex-Officio I
15.
Prof. Ikenna S. Omeje
Ex-Officio II
3
CENTRAL WORKING COMMITTEE
1.
Prof. E.H. Kwon-Ndung
2.
Dr. D.M. Ogah
4.
Mr. A. Yakubu
5.
Miss M.C. Owoseni
Chairman
Secretary
Member
Treasurer
FUND RAISING SUB-COMMITTEE
1.
Dr. M.M. Ari
2.
Prof. E.H. Kwon-Ndung
4.
Prof. R. Ega
5.
Dr. D. M. Ogah
6.
Dr. M.M. Adua
7.
Dr. I.M. Haruna
8.
Mr. I.M. Ogara
9.
Mrs. H. Kana
10.
Mr. E.G. Luka
11.
Dr. A. Chuku
Chairman
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Secretary
SCIENTIFIC/TECHNICAL SUB-COMMITTEE
1.
Prof. E.H. Kwon-Ndung
Chairman
2.
Prof. N.I. Dim
Member
3.
Dr. O.J. Jayeoba
Member
5.
Dr. O.M. Momoh
Member
6.
Mr. A. Yakubu
Secretary
4
PROTOCOL/PUBLICITY SUB-COMMITTEE
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
8.
9.
Dr. D.M. Ogah
Mr. I.D. Hassan
Mr. S. Onah
Mr. A.M. Abe
Mr. S.E. Alu
Mr. E.G. Luka
Mr. S.A. Okunsebor
Mr. K.O. Idahor
Mr. G.A. Obande
Mr. G.F. Akomolafe
Chairman
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Secretary
WELFARE SUB-COMMITTEE
1.
Dr. A.O. Agbon
2.
Dr. R. Pam
3.
Dr. O. Okon
4.
Mr. O. Abimiku
5.
Mr. N.D. Yusuf
6.
Mr. G. Liman
7.
Mr. F. Bello
8.
Mr. S.T. Vincent
9.
Mr. D. Gambo
10.
Miss O. A. Dedeke
11.
Mr. P. T. Terna
12.
Mrs. C.N. Shailong
Chairman
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Secretary
5
LIST OF REVIEWERS
1. Prof. E.H. Kwon-Ndung
2. Prof. G. Olaoye
3. Dr. V.M.O. Okoro
4. Dr K. Omokhafe
5. Dr. G A Iwo
6. Dr. A.O. Raji
7. Dr. S.1. Daikwo
8. Dr. D.M. Ogah
9. Mr. T.D. Imgbiam
10. Mr. A. Yakubu
11. Prof W A Hassan
6
SCIENTIFIC PAPERS
S/NO
TITLE
NAME OF AUTHORS
OPENING CEREMONY AND PLENARY PAPERS
KEYNOTE
ADDRESS
Potentials of genetics in strengthening Dr. Shettima Mustafa, Ph.D, OFR, CON.
agriculture and enhancing the Nigerian
economy in the 21st century
LEAD PAPER
Genetics and the future
LEAD PAPER
Animal breeding and genetics in Nigeria Prof. S.T. Mbap, Ph.D
and the future
Prof. Omotoye Olorode, B.Sc. (Ife),
M.A., Ph.D. (Kansas).
ANIMAL GENETICS AND BREEDING (AGB)
AGB01
AGB02
AGB03
AGB04
AGB05
Direct and Percentage Heterosis of
Growth traits in crosses involving
Indigenous and Exotic breeds of pigs in
Nigeria
Differential
Diagnosis
(Elisa)
of
Different Breeds of ASF Recovered Pigs
and their Offspring
Relationship between Body Measurement
and Carcass Characteristics of Muscovy
Ducks using Canonical Correlation
Analysis
Okoro, V.M.O., Ogundu, U.E., Okoro,
C.L., Oke, U.K. and Ibe, S. N.
Breed
and
Parity
effects
on
Reproductive Performance of Rabbits
in Zaria, Nigeria
Genetic Parameters of Hyla F1 New
Zealand Purebred Rabbits using Animal
Models
Kabir, M., Akpa, G.N., Nwagu, B.I.
and Adeyinka, I.A.
Adeoye, A.A., Rotimi, E.A., Ajayi,
B.A., Olugasa, B.O., Ikeobi, C.O.N.
and Adebambo, O.A.
Babatunde, O., Dim, N.I. and Ogah,
D.M.
Akinsola,
O.M.,
Nwagu,
B.I.,
Orunmuyi, M., Shoyombo, A.J.,
Adeyinka, I.A., Abanikannda, O.T.F.
and Yakubu, A.
AGB06
Evaluation of the Dairy Potential of Ogundipe, R.I., Adeoye, A.A., Rotimi,
Friesian, Wadara and their crossbreds in E.A. and Dim, N.I.
Bauchi State
AGB07
Determination of the best non-linear
growth model for indigenous sheep in
Nigeria.
Heritability Estimates of Litter Body
Weight in a Population of Non-Descript
Breeds of Domestic Rabbits Raised in a
Humid
Tropical Environment
of
Southern Nigeria
Heritability and Repeatability Estimates
for
Growth
and
Body
Linear
AGB08
AGB09
7
Raji, A.O., Okoro, V.M.O. and Aliyu,
J.
Sorhue, G.U., Mmereole, F.U.C. and
Irekefe-Ekeke, P.
Badmus, K.A., Kabir, M., Adeyinka,
I.A. and Sekoni, A.A.
AGB10
AGB11
AGB12
AGB13
AGB14
AGB15
AGB16
AGB17
AGB18
AGB19
AGB20
AGB21
AGB22
AGB23
AGB24
AGB25
Measurements in Male and Female
Broiler Lines
Selection response of reproductive traits
at different generation interval in quail
under the tropical conditions of Nigeria
Repeatability of Clutch size and
Hatchling size in traditionally-managed
Yoruba and Fulani ecotype chickens.
Heterosis,
General
and
Specific
Combining Ability of two Breeds of
Rabbit and their Crosses under Prevailing
Southern Guinea Savanna Environmental
Conditions of Nigeria
Genetic Relationship between Clarias
anguillaris
and
Heterobranchus
bidorsalis from three Ecological Zones in
Nigeria
Multifactorial analyses of morphological
traits of helmeted guinea fowls Numidia
meleagris.
The Effects of Genotype, Proximate
Composition and Characteristics of Three
Strains of Layer Turkeys on Egg Quality
Traits
Relations between age and weight at first
egg and egg production traits of Japanese
quails.
Tilapia Genetic Resource Conservation
in Nigeria
Polymerase Chain Reaction Detection of
ASFV genome in Nigerian Indigenous
pigs
Okuda,
E.U.,
Adeyinka,
I.A.,
Orunmuyi, M., Akinsola, O.M.
Shoyombo, A.J. and Yakubu, H. 2,
Fayeye, T.R., Sola-Ojo, F.E., Ojo, V.,
Alagbe, O.F. and Owoeye, B.
Egena, S. S. A., Akpa, G. N.,
Alemede, I. C. and Aremu, A.
*Onyia, L.U., Ladu, B.M.B. and
Olufeagba, S. O.
Adedibu, I.I., Ayorinde, K.L., Musa,
A.A., Orunmuyi, M. and Kabir, M.
Isidahomen, C.E., Adomeh, E.E. and
Raji, A.O.
Raji, A.O., Idahor,
Mohammed, G.
K.O.
and
Megbowon, I.
Oluwole, O. O. and Omitogun, G.O.
Physiological Evaluation of Pre-Weaning Oluwole, O.O., Tiamiyu, A.K.,
Olorungbounmi, T.O., Oladele, M.B.
Growth Traits in NIP Crossbreds
and Akintoye, N.A.
Growth Performance of Monosex and Yisa, M., Osiki, S., Olufeagba, S.O.,
Mixed Population of Oreochromis Adebayo, A. and Nwangwu, D.C.
Niloticus
Relationship between Body weight and Ojo, V., Fayeye, T.R., Ayorinde, K.L.
Linear Body Measurements in Japanese and Olojede, H.
quail (Coturnix coturnix japonica)
Genetic
Parameters
of
Weekly
Bodyweight in Japanese Quail
Genetic Distance between Populations of
the Tiv Local Chicken in the Derived
Guinea Savannah Zone of Nigeria
Improving Egg Production in the Normal
Feathered Native Chickens of Nigeria
using the Naked Neck Gene
Dimorphism of Body Weight in Two
8
Daikwo, S.I., Dim, N.I. and Momoh,
O.M.
Gwaza, D.S. and Chia, S.S.
Egahi, J.O., Dim, N.I. and Momoh, O.M.
Ige, A.O. and Salako, A.E.
AGB26
BT01
BT02
BT03
BT04
BT05
BT06
BT07
BT08
BT09
BT10
BT11
BT13
BT14
EG01
EG02
Types of Nigerian Indigenous Chicken in
Derived Savannah Zone
Ecotypes of indigenous chickens in Usman, B. and Hassan, W.A.
sokoto south local government area:
variation in weights of birds and eggs
BIOTECHNOLOGY (BT)
Preliminary Report on the Use of Androgen Olufeagba, S.O.
for the Production of All- Male Oreochromis
niloticus.
An Overview of Fish Genomic Manipulation Nwangwu, D.C., Yisa, M. and
and Production Techniques
Yahaya, M.
The Challenges and Prospects of Genetically Akomolafe, J.F., Falusi, O.A.,
Modified Crops through Biotechnology in Olawuyi,
P.O.,
Durojaiye,
A.,
Nigeria
Oluwajobi, O.A. and Akinola, A.R.
Mushroom Biotechnology : Implications for Asemota, U.K. and Ogbadu, G.H.
Food Security, Environment, Public Health
– A Review
Production of all Male Clarias gariepinus Nwachi, O.F. and Zelibe, S. A. A.
Using Hormone Treated Feed
Nucleotide Sequence and Variation of the Ogah, D.M., Kabir, M. and Nigussie,
Insulin like Growth Factor -1 Gene Exon 4 H.
in
Bovidae Species
Utilization of Cellulosic Cassava Waste for Elemike, E.E., Ezeani, C. and Okoye,
Bio-Ethanol Production
A.C.
Current
Developments
in
Avian Ejere, V.C.
Cytotaxonomy: implications for African
Ornithology – A Review
In Silico Molecular Analysis of the Yakubu, A., Faith, E.A., Peters, S.O.,
Evolution and Differentiation of Lactoferrin Takeet, M.I., De Donato, M. and
Gene in Some Ruminant and Non-Ruminant Imumorin, I.G.
Animals
Computational Genome-Wide Analysis of Yakubu, A., Musa-Azara, I.S.,
Microrna Genetic Variability in Some Yakubu, B.N.S., Daikwo, S.I.,
Vertebrates
Vincent, S.T., Momoh, O.M. and Dim,
N.I.
Bioinformatics: Current Trend in Plant Gumi, A.M.
Genomics and Molecular Plant Biology
Haematological
Characteristics
of Nwachi, O.F. and Akanmu, O.A.
Synodontis nigrita of the Lower Niger River
Effects of Preservation Time and Method on Agaviezor, B.O., Ajayi, F.O. and
Semen Quality of Local and Exotic Chicken Dumoye, V.
ENVIRONMENTAL GENETICS (EG)
Behavioural Response of Intensively Popoola M.A., Bolarinwa M.O.,
Managed West African Dwarf Goats to Aderinlewo A.Y. and Ishola M.A.
Variations in Diurnal Temperature
A Review on Pteridophytes (Ferns) as Akomolafe, G.F., Dedeke, O. A. and
Remediators of Heavy Metal Contaminated Sirajo, S. A.
Sites (Pterido-Remediation) and Tolerance
9
Mechanisms
HG01
PGB01
PGB02
PGB03
PGB04
PGB05
PGB06
PGB07
PGB08
PGB09
PGB10
PGB11
PGB12
HUMAN GENETICS (HG)
Sickle Cell Allellic Frequencies in the Galadima, M.A., Akpa, G.N., Nwagu,
Northern Guinea- Savannah of Nigeria
B.I., Adamu, A.K., Kabir, M., Shehu,
D.M. and Adejo-Ubani, E.O.
PLANT GENETICS AND BREEDING (PGB)
Varietal Response of Potato (Solanum Acharreng, S. and Kwon-Ndung, E.H.
tuberosum L.) to Irrigation Regimes in Jos,
Plateau State, Nigeria.
Evaluation
of
Cytogenotoxic
and Akinboro, A., Baharudeen , I.,
Antimutagenic Potency of Water Extract of Mohamed, K.B. and Asmawi, M.Z.
Centella asiatica Linn using the Allium cepa
Assay
Induced
Genetic
Variability
in Gado, A.A., Falusi, O.A., Muhammad,
Sesame(Sesamum indicum(l)var.kenana -4) L.M., Daudu, O.A.Y. and Abejide,
using Fast Neutron Irradiation and Sodium D.R.
Azide
Growth and Reproductive Characteristics of Nwonuala, A.I. and Opukiri, B.S.
Inbred
Fluted
Pumpkin
(Telfairia
occidentalis Hook.)
Genotypic Potential for Germination Kwajaffa, A.M., Olaoye, G. and
Capacity, Growth and Yield in Sugarcane Zakari, T.
(Saccharum officinarum L.) Germplasm
Accessions in a Savanna Ecology of Nigeria
Rice Blast Pathogenicity and its Effect on
Some Rice Cultivars in Nigeria
Genotype assessment and grouping of
selected maize on yield and stability of
performance across wet and dry seasons in
ogbomoso, southern guinea savanna
agroecology of Nigeria
Cytotoxic and Genotoxic Evaluation of
Aqueous Leaf, Root and Seed Extracts of
Carica papaya L. Using Allium Test.
Genetic Studies of Duration to Anthesis in
Some Nigeria Kenaf (Hibiscus cannabinus
L.) Collections.
Development of New Sweet Potato
Varieties: Evaluation of Advance Sweet
Potato Breeding Lines at the Uniform Yield
Trial Stage in Contrasting Agro-Ecologies in
Nigeria.
Combining ability for maize grain yield,
agronomic traits and Striga hermonthica
resistance under artificial Striga infestation.
Gana. A.S., Dangana, D.S., Tsado,
E.K. and Maji, E.A.
Opeyemi, A.S.
Abu, N.E. and Nweze, C.C.
Adeyinka, O.S. and Balogun, M.O.
Afuape, S.O., Njoku, J.C., Njoku, D.
N. and Nwankwo, I.I.M.
Haliru, B.S., Abubakar, L., Ado, S.G.,
Shehu, K. and Singh, A.
Comparative Effects of Hormone Induced Opukiri, B.S. and Nwonuala, A.I.
seeds on Germination and Sexual Expression
of Fluted Pumpkin (Telfairia occidentalis
Hook) in the Humid Tropics of Southern
10
PGB13
PGB14
PGB15
PGB16
Nigeria.
Studies on explants of pepper (capsicum sp) Wachukwu, C.P. and Kwon-Ndung,
treated with designated hormones.
E.H.
Screening of Cowpea Lines for Drought Bolarinwa, K.A., Ogunkanmi, L.A.,
Tolerance
Adetumbi, J.A., Akinyosoye, S.T.,
Akande, S.R. and Amusa, O.D.,
Evaluation of Turmeric (Curcuma longa L) Amadi, C.O., Olojede, O. A., Eleazu,
Accessions in Nigeria
C., Obasi, C., Nwokocha, C. and
Ironkwe, A.
Disease and Agronomic Performance of Six Njoku, D.N., Obidiegwu, J.E., Afuape,
Cassava Genotypes (Manihot esculenta S.O. and Nwankwo, I.
Crantz) across Two Diverse Agroecologies
in Nigeria
PGB17
Hormonal Induction of Seedlings from Leaf Jayeoba, F.M., Awotoye, O.O. and
Subculture in Sesame Sesamum Indicum L. Ogunbanjo, O.R.
Genotypes.
PGB18
Olaoye, G., Olaoye, J.O., Takim, F.O.
Assessment of pollen fertility, Cane yield and Idris, A.M.
and Ethanol content in Sugarcane Progenies
Developed by the Modified Polycross
Method
Field Performance and Selection of Iwo. G.A. and Amadi, C.O.
Advanced M4 Mutant Lines of Ginger
PGB19
PGB20
PGB21
Characterization of Mini Core Collection of Alunyo, G.I., Omoigui, L.O., Kalu,
Cowpea Accession for Striga Resistance B.A., Kamara, A.Y., and Ousmane, B.
using SSR and AFLP-Derived SCAR
Markers
Assessment of Genetic Diversity in Nigerian Alege, G. O. and Mustapha, O. T.
Sesame using Morphological Markers
PGB22
Physico-chemical and pasting properties of Obidiegwu, J.E., Njoku,
tubers in some lesser known yams
Chilaka, C.A. and Asiedu, R.
PGB23
Provenance Variation for Morphological
Traits and Oil Content in Some Jatropha
curcas L. Provenances
Phenotypic variation shows 10 distinct
clusters of water yam (D. alata) germplasm
in Nigeria
PGB24
PGB25
PGB26
D.N.,
Usman, M., Echekwu, C.A., Yeye, M.,
Bugaji, S.M., Usman, A. and Yahaya,
A.I.
Obidiegwu, J.E., Njoku, D.N. and
Asiedu, R.
Genetic
Variability
of
Striga Ibrahim, H., Omoigui, L.O., Bello,
gesnerioides (Willd) in Northern Nigeria
L.L., Kamara, A.Y. and Mohammed,
S.G.
Heritability
estimate
in
Sugarcane Abubakar, L., Ibrahim, N.D., Aliero,
(Saccharum officinarum L.) genotypes for A.A., Bubuche, T.S. and Ibrahim, R.
yield and yield components.
PGB27
Umar, I.D. and Kwon-Ndung, E. H.
Assessment of Phenotypic Variations in 10
11
PGB28
PGB29
PGB30
PGB31
PGB32
PGB33
Finger Millet (Eleusine Coracana (L)
Gaertn) Landraces Germplasm Collected
from Northern Nigeria
Evaluation of genetic variance and Olawuyi, O.J.,
heritability of agronomic and yield traits in Babalola, B.J.
pigeon pea- Cajanus cajan (L.) Millsp
(Fabaceae)
Heritability
estimates
for
Biomass
Production in local Sorghum (Sorghum
bicolor L. Moench) of some selected States
in North-Western Nigeria
Relationships
between
Normalized
Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and
Other Traits of Tropical Testcross Maize
Hybrids under Drought and Well-Watered
Conditions
Evaluation of yield and yield components of
castor (Ricinus communis L.) germplasm
from Rain Forest and Southern Guinea
Savannah Agro-Ecological Zones of Nigeria
A graphic determination of gene action of
five yield and yield related characters of
sellected castor accessions in a 5x5 diallel
crosses
Effect of Ground and Unground Pepper
(Capsicum annum) in the Control of Cowpea
Weevils (Callosobruchus maculatus) among
Some Cowpea Varieties (Vigna unguiculata
l. Walp) During Storage
Fawole,
I.
and
Abubakar, L. and Bubuche, T.S.
Adebayo, M.A., Menkir, A., and
Hearne, S.
Gila, M.A.
Gila, M.A.
Ogbaji, M. I. and Adamu, I.
PGB34
Effects of Different Pepper Varieties in the Ogbaji, M.I. and Fayinminu, A.O.
Control of Cowpea Weevil (Callosobruchus
maculatus) in Some Varieties of Cowpea
(Vigna Unguiculata L.Walp)
PGB35
Searching for SSR Markers Associated with Ugbaa, M.S., Omoigui, L.O., Bello,
Alectra vogelii Resistance Gene in Cowpea L.L., Gowda, B.S. and Timko, M.P.
[Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp] Using Bulk
Segregant Analysis
PGB36
Evaluation
of
the
Morphological Edu, N.E., Ibiang,Y.B., Ekanem, B.E.
Performance and Micronutrients Content of and Ekpo, P.B.,
Three Varieties of Sweet Potato (ipomoea
batatas l.) Grown in calabar Nigeria
PGB37
Cytological Effects of the Plant Root Nwakanma, N.M.C. and Okoli, B.E.
Extracts of Telfairia occidentalis Hooker Fil
on Root Tips of Crinum jagus (Thomps)
Dandy in Nigeria
PGB38
Collection and Evaluation of Roselle Daudu, O.A.Y., Falusi, O.A., Kwon(Hibiscus sabdariffa L) Germplasm in ndung, H.E., Dangana, M.C.,Yusuf,
12
Nigeria
PGB39
PGB41
L., Gado, A.A., Yahaya, S.A. and
Abejide, D.R.,
Genotypes x Treatment x Concentration Olawuyi, O.J., Odebode, A.C. and
Interaction and Characters Association of Olakojo, S.A.
Maize (Zea mays L) under Arbuscular
Mycorrhizal Fungi and Striga lutea Lour
Morphological Variability Pattern among Adeniji, O.T., Reuben, S.W.O.M. and
Accessions of Solanum macrocarpon L Kusolwa, P.
(Gboma eggplant)
PGB42
Characterization of Four Nigeria Sesame Ogah, O.G. and Ogah, D. M.
(Sesamumindicum L.)
Landraces using
Agronomic and Morphometric Traits
PGB43
Effects of Seed Size on Weevils Ogbaji, M. I. and Alye, J.N.
(Callosobruchus maculates F.) Damage
during Storage of Cowpea (Vigna
unguiculata L.Walp)
PGB44
Effect of Seed Colour on Weevil Damage Ogbaji, M. I. and Kukwa, Q. T.
(Callosobruchus maculatus) on Cowpea
PGB45
PGB46
(Vigna unguiculata L.Walp)
Registration of Crop Varieties in Nigeria
Omokhafe, K.O., Nasiru, I., Emuedo,
O.A., Uzuniugbe, E.O. and Ohikhena,
F.U.
Studies on the Effect of Different Olawuyi, P.O., Falusi, O.A., Kolo,
Concentrations of Sodium Hypochlorite J.T., Abubakar, A., Azeez, R.D. and
Solution on Pollen Parameters of Corchorus Titus, S.D.
olitorius
PGB47
Introgression of Alleles from Maize Meseka, S., M. Fakorede, M., Ajala,
Landraces to improve Drought Tolerance in S., Badu-Apraku, B. and Menkir, A.
an Adapted Germplasm
PGB48
Induced Mutation for Improved Yield Nura, S., Adamu, A.K., Mu’Azu, S.,
Associated Traits in Sesame (Sesamum Dangora, D.B. and Shehu, K.
indicum L.)
PGB49
Morphological Evaluation of Sesame
(Sesamum indicum) Germplasm from North
Central Zones of Nigeria
Some Morphological and Reproductive
Characters in Phaseolus vulgaris L. After
Treatment with Doses of Sodium Azide
Centre of Diversity of Tetracarpidium
Conophorum
Yahaya, S.A., Falusi, O.A., Gado,
A.A., Daudu, O.A.Y. and Abdulkarim,
B.M.
Liamngee, S. and Kwon-Ndung, E.H.
Hybrid Vigour and Genetic Control of Some
Quantitative Traits of Tomato (Lycopersicon
esculentum)
Application of Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strip for
Screening of Resistance for Maruca vitrata
13
Amaefula, C., Agbo, C.U. and Nwofia,
G.E.
PGB52
PGB56
PGB58
PGB60
Ajiboye, T.O. and Aladele, S.E.
Mohammed, B.S., Ishiyaku, M.F. and
Sami, R.A.
PGB61
PGB62
PGB63
PGB64
PGB65
in Cowpea
Character Relationship and Genetic
Correlation for Selecting Characters for
Tuber Dry Matter Yield Improvement
Evaluation of Yield Parameters of some
pepper (Capsicum spp) land races in Niger
State
Advances in Cotton Breeding Techniques
Nwankwo, I.I.M., Eka, M.J., Okocha,
P.I., Nwaigwe, G.O. and Njoku, D.
Onoja, B.E., Falusi, O.A., Yahaya,
S.A. and Gado, A.A.
Yahaya, A.I., Usman, M., Bugaje,
S.M., Ibrahim, D.A. and Usman, A.
Shailong, C.N. and Ugwuona, F.U.
Assessment of Consumption, Utilization and
Nutrient Composition of Spices Consumed
in North Central Nigeria.
Morphological diversity of acha (fonio) Kwon-Ndung, E.H. and Odeyemi, F.
(Digitaria exilis and Digitaria iburua)
germplasm and evaluation of genetic
variations using rapd-pcr techniques in
nigeria
14
KEYNOTE ADDRESS DELIVERED AT THE 37TH ANNUAL CONFERENCE OF GENETICS
SOCIETY OF NIGERIA.
POTENTIALS OF GENETICS IN STRENGTHENING AGRICULTURE AND ENHANCING THE
NIGERIAN ECONOMY IN THE 21ST CENTURY
SHETTIMA MUSTAFA, Ph.D, OFR, CON.
B.Sc (ABU)., PGD Appl Biol (Cantab), Ph.D (ABU)
Fellow, Genetics Society of Nigeria;
Fellow, Agricultural Society of Nigeria;
Fellow (Hon), Entomological Society of Nigeria;
Member, Agronomy Society of America;
Member, Crop Science Society of America;
INTRODUCTION
When I received the invitation to give a keynote address on Genetics at today’s occasion, I asked myself;
Shettima! What do you know about genetics anymore? I silently answered; Not much! Again I asked myself
why then did you accept the invitation? Well! I told myself; if nothing else, it will give me the opportunity to
open the books on genetics once more; will make me read my own postgraduate theses after so many years; I
will use the opportunity to remind myself how much farther away I have been from plant breeding and
genetics and more importantly I shall have the opportunity to interact with my very up-to-date colleagues
from whom I shall learn more of latter day developments in that field. So I ventured into accepting the
invitation.
Well! Accepting is one thing and getting down to write something and even how to start the writing became
something else. Be that as it may, I reminded myself that, as a cotton breeder, there must be something in the
pool of the researches my colleagues and I had left behind to pick from and kick-start this paper. I then ran to
my Ph.D thesis, despite the fact that it has aged as I also have myself, but strictly speaking, knowledge never
gets old. I found some relevant portions in it to use as the launching pad for this paper.
EXAMPLES OF WORK DONE PREVIOUSLY
For my Ph.D project, I studied the genetic and environmental factors affecting earliness in Cotton
(Gossypium hirsutum L.). I used seven varieties of cotton from diverse backgrounds with wide range of
characteristics.
The genetic work entailed individual crosses as well as a 7 x 7 diallel (reciprocal) hybridization between
selected cotton varieties of different traits from diverse backgrounds while the agronomic studies involved
different fertilizer regimes, sowing dates, insecticide sprayed versus non sprayed and other variables of
interest. A wide range of characteristics were studied – earliness of maturity indices, yield, lint qualities,
disease resistance, insect tolerance, plant height, flowering/fruiting habits and a few other traits. Data were
collected over a three to four year period and analysed using appropriate statistical methods.
15
Variety 2421 was from Azerbeijan in the former USSR introduced into Nigeria in 1970, Stripper and
Arkansas were from the University of Arkansas, USA; all the three varieties were early maturing but short
stature, short staple with poor levels of resistance to bacterial blight (caused by the bacterium Xanthomonas
malvacearum L.). Their yield levels were not impressive compared to some of our Samaru varieties. Two of
the varieties, Samaru 71 and Samaru 72, were bred in Samaru, Nigeria, for the north-west and north-east
cotton growing zones, respectively. Samaru 71 was a high seedcotton yielder while Samaru 72 was a high
lint quality type. Both of them were intermediate in maturity. Of the remaining two, Samaru 26J, was bred in
Nigeria and released for cultivation all over the country in 1959. It is tall, short-staple with fair yield and
resistance to blight but late maturing. The last of them was UK66, introduced into Nigeria from Tanzania in
1970. It is medium height, short-staple, fair resistance to blight but very late maturing.
We came across very interesting observations and concluded that those studies have shown that earlinesss as
measured by the various traits studied could be bred for, at least initially by breeding methods which utilize
additive or general combining ability effects. Most of the F1 hybrids involving the early parents showed
considerable earliness over their late parents or over the mid-parental value. It was also possible to combine
earliness with yield and related characters.
These observations encouraged us to recommend that future improvements could be obtained using some of
these varieties and their derivatives. We went further to recommend that the poor levels of resistance to
blight could equally be improved by incorporating into the breeding programme another line from a family
developed at Samaru code-named RASA (Reba x Samaru Allen) from which the variety named SAMARU
77 was developed and released for cultivation in 1977. I do not have the details of further progress from the
research but I was informed that some of the present day cotton varieties like SAMCOT 8, SAMCOT 9,
SAMCOT 10, SAMCOT 11, SAMCOT 12 and SAMCOT 13 emanated from varieties including SAMARU
71, SAMARU 72 and SAMARU 77, plus the derivatives of some of the lines developed at Samaru in the
1970s which I had the privilege of being part of the team of researchers that developed and/or released them
to Nigerian farmers for cultivation. I must acknowledge the contributions, leadership and guidance of the
staff of the British Cotton Research Corporation (CRC) as well as my indigenous Nigerian colleagues at the
Institute for Agricultural Research, ABU, Samaru, Zaria.
FUTURE OUTLOOK
In discussing the potentials of genetics in contributing to the future agricultural development of Nigeria, let
us look at some practical issues that will necessitate enormous enhancement or shall I say quantum jump in
our capacity and capability to produce crops and animals not only for food but also for industrial uses as well
as for export.
SCENARIO I
Going by the 2006 census, Nigeria’s population was 140,000,000 people. Nowadays one hears projected figures
of 150,000,000 or even 160,000,000, occasionally you even see 167,000,000 being mentioned in the papers. Let
us for the purpose of ease of calculation take 150 million for year 2013. On average, we all eat food at least once
a day; nay, in reality a minimum of two times a day. Considering what goes into our average meal – some
grains/carbohydrates, meat/proteins, beans/legumes, oil, spices and vegetables, etc, each one of us eats about one
kilogram of these items all put together (inclusive of wastage – such as peels, barks, etc) per meal. That means
two kilograms for the two meals per day per person. Add to these some assorted fruits, eggs, tea, beverages,
sugar, even kolanuts and so on and so forth. For 150 million people, you are talking of 300 miilion kilograms
(300,000 metric tonnes) per day. That means in one calendar year we may be eating up to 109,500,000 (109.5 x
106) say 110 million tonnes of assorted food items.
SCENARIO II
Now consider also the domestic animal population. You may add another 100 million made up of cattle, sheep,
goats, donkeys, horses, dogs, cats, camels, chickens and the rest of them which we must feed since we are
keeping them on our farms or backyards as the case may be. I do not want to speculate but for sure some of these
16
animals eat probably more than twice what we humans can eat at any given time. For this, you may also add
nearly as much quantity (or at least 200,000 metric tonnes) of food items – that works out to about 500,000
metric tonnes per day totaling to about 180 million tonnes per year approximately.
The figures above are all for ease of argument. In actual fact an average beef/milking cow if optimal
performance is expected from her, should be fed about 12kg of assorted materials per day. V/Admiral Murtala
Nyako, Governor of Adamawa, published a pamphlet on his “Vision” for the Empowerment of Farming
Populace Through Agriculture …in Adamawa State titled “ MISSIVE (1) TO THE PEOPLE OF
ADAMAWA STATE. In it he gave the following figures for dual purpose cow that produces both dairy and
beef, the feed requirement is a feed mixture of 12kg/day made up of: 6kg of maize; 2.5kg soya beans; 1.8kg of
cotton cake; 1.2kg groundnut cake and 0.5kg premix. For 10,000 cows you require 36,600 tons and for
million cows, 3,660,000 tons. This is just for one million slightly improved varieties of cows. In the same
document, for 2,500,000 chicken, Nyako gave an annual feed requirement of 139,975 (approximately 140,000)
tons of assorted feed materials. You can now imagine the quantities we require to enhance our food and
agricultural production in Nigeria. Added to the above will be the quantities of water that we and our animals
drink or use to prepare food with or wash with.
SCENARIO III
Let me bring in another angle. You know nowadays nobody walks naked in this country; even an infant gets
wrapped up in pampers and some warm clothing. By the nature of our traditional dresses – the kaftaan, agbada
complete with jumper and sokoto and matching caps, or even the foreign dresses we wear such as suits, jackets
and safaris consume quantities of clothing materials. For example, a set of a gentleman’s or lady’s complete
dress will require a minimum of five (5) or ten (10) meters of materials. Most of us here and elsewhere I know
we own more than one set of kaftaan and babban riga or lady’s gowns and wrappers. That means an average
man or woman in Nigeria could have at least 20 meters of clothing material per year on average. If you multiply
this by 150 million, you will find it to be about 3,000,000,000 (150 x 20 x 106) meters of cloth of assorted types.
In addition, we also have a whole range of items at home (and offices) comprising mattresses, bedsheets, pillow
cases, rugs, carpets, towels, dusters, settees, curtains and so on and so forth – all of which require one kind of
clothing materials or the other, mostly cotton.
Consider the tonnage of cotton or even artificial fibres that are required to supply a billion meters of clothing
materials; the farm sizes, the number of farmers, quantities of inputs required, farm power needed, service
providers and a whole paraphernalia of items needed to produce, process, market and handle all these quantities.
Then think of all the tailors, the spinners, weavers – in short textile mills of all descriptions, crude, native or
modern, the colouring materials for the prints and designers, transporters, advertisers, hawkers, sellers, buyers,
etc, ad infinitum, that could benefit from such an effort. Can you now imagine the volume of business
transactions that these chains of activities could generate? Who will provide all these materials for us? Or, with
due apologies, are we waiting for the Chinese, the Indians, Brazilians or other “lovers” of Nigeria in foreign
lands to come and feed us, clothe us and run all this business for us? Are we then going to go on an importation
spree of items that we can produce comfortably and economically in Nigeria. I think as a nation we should
endeavour to produce our needs by ourselves and resort to importation only as filling the obvious gap. It is a
challenge for us and not for the nationals of other countries. In any case what does Nigeria, as a nation,want?"
WAY FORWARD
Going by the present day best yield performances of our commodities (both crops and animals) of 2.5 tonnes
per hectare of rice produced more or less once in a year, may be 3 or 4 tonnes of maize per hectare again
produced more or less once in a year, hardly one tonne of seedcotton per hectare, 250 to 350 kilogrammes
live weight of cows, may be 300 to 400 litres of milk per lactation from the local cow, etc. How about the
way we go about throwing up children every year, that way, we may, if care is not taken, hit the 250 million
mark population by 2040 or 2050. When this is juxtaposed against our nonchalant attitude towards the
development of top scientists in the various fields of agriculture, more especially breeders, I wonder how
long will it take us to meet the stage of self sufficiency in food and other agricultural commodity needs of the
17
nation? That is where a quantum jump phenomenon comes into the picture and in all seriousness quantum
jumps do not simply happen without the proper planning and application of genetics and biotechnology to
improve the performance of Nigeria’s agriculture. This can then guarantee the attainment of our future goal.
Under a conventional breeding regime, starting from the crosses (hybridization) through selecting progenies,
strains, lines, and testing them first under research fields then out in the different environments likely to use
these lines ultimately and then producing breeders seed, foundation seed and finally certified seeds takes a
long time. These steps are far more than simply designing experiments to examine straight forward
inheritance of simple characters or experiments to show the adaptation of a variety to a given environment.
For instance, the SAMARU 77 Variety I referred to earlier was code-named AASA(71)114 in our research
record – this meant that after all the crossing works and initial screenings, it was first selected as a progeny
in 1971. It went through various tests as a strain, a line, a breeders seed, and a foundation seed before
being released for cultivation by farmers in the Gombe area in 1977 – minimum of seven (7) years or so.
Let us now bring in the advanced biotechnology into our breeding programme, as in the case of bt cotton, or
any other transgenic exercise. It will be recalled that following the realization of the problems posed to
cotton by the bollworm (Helicoverpa armigera – American bollworm; Pectinophora gossipiella – pink
bollworm; and Earias vitella –spotted bollworm) complex, scientists discovered from a bacterium Bacillus
thuringiensis a chemical that could kill the larvae of these insects. So, they set forth to transfer the gene to a
variety of cotton – which eventually became bt cotton having good measure of resistance to pests. Details of
the methods adopted will not be discussed in this paper but for the sake of clarity let me briefly mention
some of the steps.
You start from the identification and isolation of the required gene, go through with its transfer to your plant
or tissue culture using the medium of an agrobacterium or a gene gun or whatever. Then you start developing
that plant or tissue culture to the level you will incorporate it into your breeding programme. Subsequently,
you go through various tests, screening, selection, etc, before you can conveniently claim that you have
succeeded in the transfer of the required gene for a sustainable long term future usage. This exercise could
take up to ten (10) years. Details can be found in an article on the Bollgard variety of cotton developed in
Australia in which two genes (Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab) were transferred into this variety (anonymous writer on
bt cotton in the internet). Another example can be found in an article titled “Transgenic Bt Cotton” –
Technical Bulletin CGIR No. 22, Central Institute for Cotton Research, Nagpur, India, written by Indian
authors – C. D. Mayee, P. Singh, A. B. Dongre and Sheo Ray.
In between, we shall not fail to mention the other variants of biotechnology from the age old
budding/grafting as in fruit trees to tissue culturing and cloning in both animals and plants. These
technologies, no doubt, have contributed, and are still contributing, their quota to the development of our
agricultural varieties.
In all of the above, geneticists and other related scientists have a crucial role to play as they are responsible
for the development of the improved varieties which if put under the right husbandry conditions they can
perform maximally. Our farmers must be helped to increase the productivity of their commodities per unit of
production – be it field, water, green house or whatever.
RECRUITMENT AND TRAINING OF BREEDERS AND OTHER SCIENTISTS
In order to meet this quantum jump or leap, there is need to embark on a sustained recruitment and training
of agricultural scientists generally but in particular breeders. However, the present system of recruitment,
training and promotion of breeders in this country, makes me feel like breeders are an endangered species.
Since they are predominantly part of the university or agricultural research institutes systems, they are very
much governed by the “publish or perish” syndrome and this is not helpful to the breeder. So if developing
an improved variety takes you seven years or more, then you cannot easily meet that publish syndrome. In
any case, as a breeder your pride and satisfaction is the variety you released for cultivation with positive
18
results. Considering the situation of developing improved varieties described above, one can appreciate the
predicament of the breeder compared to some of his/her fellow scientists.
Apart from this, the study of breeding (both plant and animal) entails what is ordinarily described as the
“hard stuff” – pure genetics, applied genetics, statistical genetics, pure statistics, a bit of mathematics and
then relatively some physiology, entomology, pathology and even environmental science.
When I was at IAR, I tried recruiting some graduates to train them as cotton breeders but when each one took
a good look at the involvements and the subject matter, they would simply say bye – bye. As at today, I am
not sure if IAR or any of our agricultural research institutes can boast of adequate number of breeders or
other required agroscientists.
A more favourable condition for recruitment, training and promotion of breeders and indeed other scientists
should be developed even if that would entail some sort of prioritization of the disciplines required over a
period of time. For instance, what cadre of expertise shall we require say in the next three (3) to five (5)
years, or five (5) to seven (7) years, etc, and then go ahead and design a recruitment and training programme
for them. You can then shift your priorities and emphasize other set/s of priorities without compromising the
ones promoted earlier
CONCLUSION
In order to bridge these gaps due to low productivity, poor postharvest handling, lack of adequate
encouragement of producers, processors and marketers or general handlers of farm produce and our
supposed target for 2030, 2040 or 2050, the right policy instruments should be developed now for the
adoption of strategies which combine improvements in agricultural production and productivity through
relevant and effective research and appropriate husbandry practices. This should be coupled with effective
control of wastages (in all their ramifications – rotting, pest damages, etc).
In order to achieve these aims, some mutually reinforcing approaches should be pursued. Among which are:
i.
Strengthening of research and the development of appropriate technologies to fully exploit the
genetic, biotechnological and agronomic potentials of agricultural commodities;
ii.
Recruitment of relevant scientists and sustained training backed up with the necessary incentives so
that young people can build their career;
iii.
Extension be fully revived, workers recruited and adequately trained. In fact, the Local Government
Councils should be made to offer extension services, while private sector supported extension should
be encouraged;
iv.
Effective linkages must be provided and strengthened between research – extension – input/service
provider – farmer;
v.
Intensive cultivation using all the modern technology backed methods supported by realistic and
implementable policies and incentives (in their broad sense) to contribute a greater percentage to the
envisaged demand through increased yield per unit of production;
vi.
Some element of extensive cultivation or horizontal expansion should be encouraged especially
since such a massive production must involve opening new land or land reclamation, and the
development of new farms as well as entry of new farmers;
vii.
Ensuring that our farm produce have been adequately processed and preserved and where
appropriate export them; and
viii
That producers, processors and all other relevant participants should be adequately trained to
develop their respective skills.
19
Finally, let me end this address with a teaser. To a large extent the success of the work of a scientist and his
satisfaction is determined or influenced by the politician who is the boss, the determiner of policies
governing the work of the scientist and who takes the political decision for the implementation of the
research result. If he/she procrastinates or takes the wrong decision or simply refuses to implement even the
decision he/she has taken, then we are stuck. THIS ISSUE IS BEYOND THE REALM OF GENETICS
AND BIOTECHNOLOGY.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I wish to express my appreciation to the leadership of the Genetics Society of Nigeria and the organizers of
this Conference for the opportunity given to me to address this distinguished gathering of scientists. I hope
my not being too up-to-date in this field can be pardoned. Let me also thank all those who have helped in the
production of this paper as well as the audience who listened to this address - I say a big THANK YOU."
REFERENCES
Anonymous. How Was Bt Cotton Produced in Australia – Downloaded from the Internet;
Mayee, C. D., Singh, P., Dongre, A. B. and Ray, Sheo (2013). Transgenic Bt Cotton, Technical
Bulletin CGIR. No. 22.
Central Institute for Cotton Research, Nagpur, India;
Murtala H. Nyako. (2013). Missive (1) to the People of Adamawa State – A Vision for the
Empowerment of Farming Populace of the State Through Agriculture Within the
Context of Nigeria’s VISION 20:20:20.
Mustafa, S. (1979). Investigations of the Environmental and Genetic Factors Affecting
Earliness in Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.). Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Agriculture,
Ahamdu Bello University, Zaria, in Partial Fulfillment of theRequirements for the Degree of Doctor
of Philosophy.
20
GENETICS AND THE FUTURE1
Omotoye Olorode, B.Sc. (Ife), M.A., Ph.D. (Kansas)
Department of Plant Science and Applied Zoology
Olabisi Onabanjo University,
Ago-Iwoye, Nigeria.
ABSTRACT
Every phenomenon, including Genetics and its ambience, has a future that will be determined by its
present which itself is the product of the past. Broadly, our subject deals with organisms and their
environment and, for good or bad, in a context in which the pursuit of knowledge is not only
increasingly and narrowly anthropocentric, but also distanced from collective purpose. Mendelism
and the ancillary subjects had, especially since 1900 or so, contributed immensely to our
understanding of the biosphere, to crop and livestock improvement, and to human health. The
advent and progress in DNA science and technology has opened almost limitless possibilities for,
and created new concerns about, the manipulation of life on earth, including the capacity of humans
to manipulate their own genetics. First, an overview of the development of genetics shows that a
critical engagement with the past of the subject had enabled, and will enable, deeper insights into
the problems and the prospects of the future as the synergy of genomics with the past has shown.
Secondly, as the increasing knowledge of epigenetic forces have shown, a renewed interest in
general biology, natural history, ecology, behavioural science and systematic biology have become
imperative and urgent in our environment where so much remains to be known about our flora and
fauna. Thirdly, having regards to the products of science, their ownership and the consequences of
these for the production and reproduction of knowledge and of humans themselves and their
societies, geneticists and indeed all scientists need to, as a minimum, engage social and related
questions such as Intellectual Property Rights.
INTRODUCTION
We need to start by clarifying what issues the theme of this conference suggest or entail and then try
to harmonize the issues into some coherent perspective. In doing this, I hope to highlight the
tremendous multiplication of specialized areas into which Genetics has developed, the almost
complete isolation of some of these areas and the imperative for developing the nationalist instincts
and practices of professional biologists. Well, if that is, we want to harvest the fruits of the myriads
of specializations.
The theme of this conference can be contemplated, first, simply as the future of genetics as an
academic discipline; the prospects and limits of what we know, what we can know and the
consequences of what we know and can know generally for the biosphere—the entire gamut of
organisms and their interactions with their labile biotic and abiotic environments. The second
apprehension of the theme is related to the first. It is about genetics and the future of human society
as they are going to the affected or shaped by genetics in terms of provisioning human needs for
reproducing herself and for reproducing his societies. We must hasten to say here that this not just
1
Invited lead paper [resented at the 37th Annual Conference of the Genetics Society of Nigeria hosted by the Faculty
of Science of Federal University, Lafia Nigeria on 22nd October, 2013
21
about knowledge per se but also about politics, economics and political economy. And, thirdly, the
theme may lead us to apprehend the future (of man) narrowly in terms of human extant biological
capabilities, limitations and disabilities as all these are prescribed by his genome and circumscribed
by the plethora of epigenetic forces that man has developed almost unlimited propensity to unleash.
Obviously, the foregoing is a daunting agenda for this whole conference not to talk of a single lead
paper by a single author who is in an equally obvious narrow specialty. Notwithstanding, I find it
auspicious that we have this opportunity to “scan” this vast territory as it were.
PHILOSOPHERS, SPECIALISTS AND SORCERERS
From time immemorial, synthetic philosophers and specialists have always existed
contemporaneously. Often times, specialists have also often been synthetic philosophers. In more
recent times the sheer expansion of human knowledge and our accumulation of knowledge as
collective human intellectual heritage have fractured intellectual into varying degrees of isolated
specialties such that while we have gained from depth, we have lost, or we are losing, the advantage
of synthesis and breadth. Ensuring some balance in the foregoing regards seems desirable.
Within the foregoing paradigms, specialists in the frontiers of science and technology tend to be
especially vulnerable. While this vulnerability is, strictly, not their fault, it is desirable that they
ameliorate this vulnerability by paying attention to history and to ancillary disciplines and
specialties vis a vis their specialist concerns. Lack of this attention, in these regards, has
considerably slowed the advancement of knowledge.
One of the consequences of the isolation and the allure of frontiers of science and technology,
especially as they now tend to confer power and profit (biological weapons industry, genetic
engineering and gene patenting etc.) is that they begin to appear like cults and their business
acquires the image of some “sorcery” (Nicholls, 1994). In this regards, the inability or
unwillingness by many of us to be “synthetic” in our approach to knowledge and pedagogy
entrenches the “difficult-area-of-study” image of genetics generally!
FROM MENDELISM TO DNA DOUBLE HELIX HYPOTHESIS
As we all know, Gregor Mendel, the “father of genetics” established the mechanisms of the
transmission of hereditary (genetic) factors in 1865 although the appertaining basic principles were
not re-discovered to become generally publicized until 1900. Many geneticists today consider
Mendelism a “revolution”, if not “the revolution” in genetics (Snustad and Simmons, 2003). But if
we reflect on the works of overlapping generations of geneticists and workers in ancillary areas
(cytogenetics, biochemistry, immunology, agriculture, physiology, mutation sciences, medicine,
systematic biology, ecology, etc. etc.), we will agree that the progress of genetics arose from
“revolutions inside revolutions”.
Arising from this “Pandora box” paradigm we may mention the various categories of scientists
(Strickberger, 1976; Snustad and Simmons, 2003; Ryan, 2009). These include the contributions of
the biometricians (Sutton, Galton, Fisher, etc.) the cytologists and cytogeneticists regarding the
chromosome theory (Sutton and Boveri), the cytogeneticists of linkage and recombination (Morgan,
Sturtevant, Bridges), workers in a population genetics and (Wright, Fisher, Haldane, Hardy and
Weinberg), workers in medicine, biochemistry and hereditary diseases (Garrod, Herric, Lyons,
Landsteiner, Beadle and Tatum), researchers on the nature of the genetic material (Avery,
MacCleod and McCarthy), research on control of gene action (McClintock), workers in evolution of
genomes (Stebbins, Blakeslee, Ohno, Jackson etc.) and those in genetics and sexuality and bacteria
(Lederberg and others). The foregoing constitutes a sample of findings, in more or less
chronological order, each of which constituted a revolution per se (Peters, 1959). These land-mark
22
advances in the study of genetics, needless to say are, of course, the results of synergies, synthesis,
extrapolations and explications of the sequential leaps in genetics and other areas of biology; of
chemistry, physics, mathematics (statistics); of travels and explorations around the world; of
demography and epidemics, and even of wars and peace!
Without doubt, the Watson-Crick double-helix model of DNA of 1953 was also a major
breakthrough especially as a foundation for molecular genetics (Watson, 1976; Weaver, 2005). The
model satisfied the two dialectical elements of the genetic material: on one hand, the
autocatalysis/heterocatalysis opposites, and on the other hand, the stability/mutability opposites.
Three years before, in 1950, Erwin Chargaff already observed certain constancies in the 1:1 ratio of
pyrimidines and purines and constancy of G + C/A + T ratios in each species.
It is left to be said that as foundational and pivotal as Darwin’s Origin of Species (Darwin, 1859)
was to the work of geneticists, it had been the subsequent evidence of the mechanisms of heredity
(including the sources of variation and encompassing mutation and mutagenesis) that rescued
Darwinism from much of the controversy, not to talk of the hostilities that greeted its enunciation.
RECOMBINANT DNA, DNA TECHNOLOGY AND GENETIC ENGINEERING
From the early 1970s i.e. in the last forty years or so, advances in recombinant DNA science and
technology have opened hitherto unimaginable vistas in genetic studies. This is true especially in
regard to molecular characterization of genomes and genes, the location and processes of gene
action. Consequently, even though traditional Mendelian principles and related and ancillary
knowledge (as we apprehended earlier) continue to make valuable contributions to plant and animal
breeding, medicine, plant and animal protection, biodiversity conservation etc. (GSN, 1999; 2009);
especially pure and, applied, genetics have virtually become exclusively construed as, and
coterminous with molecular genetics and DNA technology (Taylor, Green and Stout, 1997).
Most biologists and, especially, geneticists are familiar and must be familiar, with the progress of
molecular genetics and its various applications of genetic engineering and what is now generally
circumscribed as genomes sequencing, gene cloning and production of transgenic organisms,
amelioration of debilitating human conditions, the nature and initiation of epidemics, degrees of
genomic identities among different evolutionary groups and life forms, identities of molecular/maps
and traditional physical gene maps, control and mechanics of control of gene actions by the socalled bureaucratic genes, the role of telomeres and telomerases (Figure 1) in aging and
oncogenesis, molecular characterization of plant and animal accessions, legal and forensic medicine
etc., and evolution of elements of genomes such as the evolution of, and divergence between X and
Y chromosomes, (Figure 2; The Arabidopsis Genome Initiative, 2000; Snustad and Simmons, 2003;
Ryan, 2009). A rather elegant circumscription of the term “genomics” was given in Snustad and
Simmons (Ibid) as follows:
……the genomics sub-discipline was divided into structural genomics—the study of
genome structure—and functional genomics—the study of genome function, which,
includes analyses of the transcriptome, the complete set of RNAs transcribed from a
genome, and the proteome, the complete set of proteins encoded by a genome.
Indeed, functional genomics has spawned an entirely new subdiscipline,
proteonomics, which has as its goal the determination of the structures and functions
of all proteins in living organisms.
Having apprehended the “practical” implications of what we know in genetics and, what these
portend for how we are likely to approach the frontiers of genetics and biology, how do those things
we know limit what we can know and what forces limit what we can know? Even if we cannot
answer these questions now, we need at least to keep them in view.
23
One hundred years or so (1868-1965) after Miescher discovered nucleic acids, and about twenty
years after Avery’s team showed that DNA is the genetic material, Holley sequenced the RNA of
yeast and the revolution of sequencing whole genomes of organism took off. Since then the
techniques and efficiency of sequencing the genomes of organism developed by leaps and bounds.
The publication of the draft of human genome on February 15, 2000 and February 16, 2000 by the
public International Human Genome Sequencing Consortium and a private Celera Genomics in
Nature and Science respectively constituted a watershed in a way.
MATTERS ARISING FROM THE SIZES, IDENTITIES AND DIFFERENCES IN THE
GENOMES OF ORGANISMS.
Two major surprises that arose from a scrutiny of human genome are the relatively, small number
of genes of humans compared with lower levels of organismal forms (bacteria, insects, worms,
etc.), and the large numbers of genes shared with these lower organismal forms. Ryan (2009 pp.2-3)
summarized these surprises as follows:
The first surprise was the modest size of human genome at about 20,000 genes … we
have only ten times as many genes as a bacterium, a third more than a fruit fly and
not many more than a nematode worm…..Most revealing of all was the confirmation
of our common inheritance with other forms of life on Earth. For example we share
2,758 of our genes with the fruitfly, 2,031 with the nematode worm—Indeed all
three of us, human, fly and worm, have 1, 523 genes in common.
Perhaps a third surprise which is related to the question of shard genes is that a large proportion of
the human genome (about 9%) is shared with retroviruses—the endogenous human retroviruses
(EHRVs) with their long terminal repeats (LTRs) which are known to perform bureaucratic control
of gene action while another 3% are DNA transposons. A related matter here is the comparatively
smaller amount of the human genome shared with other vertebrates (about 1.5%) while about
52.5% of the DNA are unknown 13% and 21% of human genome are long, and short, interspersed
repeat nuclear elements (LINEs and SINEs) respectively (Figure 3; 3i).
From various reflections and actual experimental work of various biologists, it had always been
known or conjectured that, life is a web and that the evolution of life at different levels of
complexity are vertical, horizontal or reticulate. We see many of these in the homology of
organelles (chromosomes, mitochondria, ribosomes, chloroplasts etc.) organs, organisms and life
forms; many of these homologies are conserved so to speak. With this intellectual heritage behind
us and the new insights from genomics, a number of important facts have emerged. These include
insights into the dynamic of the web of evolution as it relates in particular to control of gene action,
syntheny, the evolution of genomes, and the phenomenon of epigenetics.
One of the most important matters that have arisen from the revelations of genomics is the role
symbiosis and co-evolution especially of viruses have played in the evolution of the genomes of
higher organisms, the reinforcement of the notion of common genomic ancestry of organisms
(including, preeminently viruses) and the role of retroviral genes (and other bureaucratic genes) in
the activation and deactivation of genes and the processes of development in the more complex
organisms. Genomics has also enabled us to more confidently see the commonality of genetic
endowments especially through studies of conserved syntheny in related animals and related plants
(Chowdary, Raudshipp, Fronicke, and Scherthan, 1998; Gale, 1998; Snustad and Simmons, 2003;
Figures 4, 5, 6).
The implications of the evolution of symbiosis between retroviruses and eukaryotic cells and the
consequent enlargement of eukaryotic genomes point to the importance of symbiosis and
24
hybridizations (and evolution of sexual, mechanisms and sexuality) as critical mechanisms of
genomic creativity and potentials for natural selection and evolution. Ryan (2009) referred to the
creative genomic mechanisms of symbiosis and hybridization as symbiogenesis and
hybridogenensis as mechanisms that are different from, but complement, mutation whose
occurrence and consequences are random.
EPIGENETICS AND EPIGENETIC INTERACTIONS
Epigenetics is the study of changes (internal, external, behavioural etc) in cells, tissues, organs and
whole organisms independently of DNA sequences. In this regard contain elements of the genome
that can receive and process signals from the internal or the external biotic and abiotic environments
of the organism are themselves stretches of DNA such as the LTRs. They respond by switching on
or switching off certain genes exploring varied mechanisms as DNA methylation, modification of
histones etc, all of which interact in complex and coordinated ways to control gene action—hence
the term bureaucratic genes (Figure 7).
The bureaucratic genes function in specific tissues, at particular points of development by
responding to the internal and external environments of the gene to induce, alter, increase certain
gene products that mediate morphology (development of secondary sexual. Characteristics,
flowering, leaf abscission and shedding, tropic and taxis movements, transitions from juvenile to
adult forms such as moulting and juvenile – adult leaf transitions) and even behaviours like
migration, homing instincts, aggression and fear, hallucinations etc., etc. perhaps one of the most
spectacular example of environmentally – induced epigenetic phenomena is the story of sex change
in Caribbeans of fish species – the blue-headed wrasse (Ryan, 2009: pp319-321; Figure 8).
REMEMBERING THE PAST FOR UNDERSTANDING THE PRESENT AND THE
FUTURE
For whatever it is worth, I think we can proceed on the assumption that scientific progress is
desirable especially if we also agree that we must strive constantly to humanize knowledge
generally.
As we have seen, modern genetics, with its capacity to look at whole genomes and how genes and
their expressions are controlled, grow, from Darwinism Medelism, cytogenetics, and knowledge of
DNA structure; it grew from the knowledge of biochemical, behavioural and morphological (endoand-exo-) end products or phenotypes of genotypes. Darwimsm and Mendelism themselves and the
related foundations of genetics developed from general biology (systematics, anatomy and
histology, histochemistry and biochemistry, physiology, biology of microbes, general ecology and
biogeography, and animal behaviour etc., etc.). A lot of observations and studies that today direct
our attention to the modes of gene action especially in the growing area of epigenetics as
demonstrated by the example of sex change in wrasse, the consequence of the large retroviral dose
of the DNA of Y-chromosomes in man derive from elements of the knowledge established in the
foundations of genetic studies (see Figure 7 again) and of our own observations on the transition of
juvenile leaf forms to adult leaf forms in angiosperms (Figure 9; Olorode, 2012). Indeed, the
homeobox gene model (Snustad and Simmons, 2003) has been invoked by various workers for the
differences between simple leaves and compound leaves and for the transitions from simple
juvenile for compound adult leaves (Olorode, 2012).
In the foregoing regards, we are saying that we need to pay very close attention to the general
biology (taxonomy, behaviour, physiology, ecology and phenology) of our floral and fauna. This is
because every constellation of floral and fauna is unique in its temporal and spatial character and is
thus capable of giving unique insights into the genome and genetic processes in the constellation.
25
What those mean is that the conservation of flora and fauna, the vessels in which genes are
sequestered, must become a matter of national priority (Hawkes, 1990; Olorode, 2004).
In regard to the study, conservation and utilization of genes and genetic material, the undying
concern had been festering about private and corporate profit interests on one hand and public
purpose on the other in regard to access of peoples and territories to the products of improved food
and health facilities. This is obviously a political/ideological matter. Sine the earlier 1910s
improvements in crop and animal yield have produced the paradox of high yield and high corporate
profit on one hand, and poverty and hunger or other forms of malnutrition (such as obesity) on the
other. Various critical and informed views have, since, been published on the question of who owns
genes (especially genes of wild and domesticated animals and plants) and whether genes can be
patented (Fedder, 1976; George, 1979; Mooney, 1983; Juma, 1989; Lesser, 1994; Olorode, 2006).
Partly because of the triumph of neo-liberal and “market forces” ideology (Kargalitsky, 2001;
Amin, 2004) the balance of political forces have been in favour of private corporate profit of seed
companies and genomics companies. Consequently private seed and genomics companies have
been having a field day in spite of the strident campaigns against hunger and the so-called “food
crisis” even by organizations that instigate, rationalize and valorize market and private-profit such
as the World Bank and related organizations.
The phenomena of gene-hunting and gene prospecting (Mooney, 1983; Juma, 1989; Lesser, 1994)
access to, and use of data from bioinformatics and the related controversies of gene patenting and
intellectual property rights will continue to attract attention and generate debate. As these are
matters of power and economic-interest relations inside nations, across social classes and across
national and regional boundaries, we can assert that no position is, or can be, neutral. Suffice it to
say that geneticists, as intellectuals, have the responsibility to lay bare all the contending positions
and issues.
The controversies surrounding gene prospecting and gene patenting have been particularly strident
since the completion of the sequencing of human genome in the mid-2000s raising questions and
objections among citizens and meedics concerning informed consent and presumed consent of the
owners of the human genes even where genomics companies (like deCODE Genetics and
pharmaceutical companies (like the Swiss “giant” Hoffman-Laroche in the case of the identification
of the “familiar essential tremor” gene in Iceland) agree to compensate the owners of the gene
(Snustad and Simmons, 2003: pp. 514-515).
As in many of the wars among giant corporations like the “computer wars” (Ferguson and Morris,
1994), the legal theatre not to talk of heavy-purse and political-power arenas, have been active in
the controversy concerning gene prospecting and gene patenting. In a recent expose in New York
Times, Joseph E. Stiglitz (2013) reviewed extensively the supreme court (USA) judgement which
recently decided (Stiglitz, 2013) in regard to the legal tussle between Association of Molecular
Pathology and Myriad Genetics (a private company):
…ruled unanimously, that the genes (BRCA1 and BRCA2) cannot be patented,
though synthetic DNA created in the laboratory can be.
The genes BRCA1 and BRCA2 are said to predispose their carriers to breast cancer and knowledge
of their existence can be useful in early diagnosis, and prevention of the cancer. In his article, How
intellectual Property reinforces inequality, Stiglitz (2013) was categorically (all emphases are
mine) on various elements of IPR, public welfare, alleged promotion of “incentive” and competition
by IPR:
26
The case (Association of Molecular Pathology v. Myriad) was a battle between those
who would privatize good health …. and those who see it as a right for all—and a
central component of a fair society and well-functioning economy. Even more
deeply, it was about the way inequality is shaping our politics, legal institutions and
the health of our population.
…... Genetic researchers have argued that the patent actually prevented the
development of better tests, and so interferes with the advancement of science. All
knowledge is based on prior knowledge, and by making prior knowledge less
available, innovation is impeded. Myriad’s own discovery—like in any science—
used technologies and ideas that were developed by others….Advocates of
intellectual, property rights have overemphasized their role in promoting innovation.
Most of the key innovations—from the basic ideas underlying the computer, to
transistors, to lasers, to the discovery of DNA—were not motivated by pecuniary
gain.
The importance of all of these for the galloping development of underdevelopment in the
peripheries of neo-liberalism like Nigeria ought to be quite obvious. Let me add that Stiglitz is, to
the best of my knowledge, not a communist—he was actually an economist with the World Bank
and, at different times, an advisor to one or two recent tenants of the White House in Washington
DC.
CONCLUSION
I did not set out in this presentation to tell you anything you didn’t know or suspected. I have tried
only to share with you my reflections on general biology and the specialty of genetics and the
future: the “future” in a robust sense of the world. Let us thing globally and act nationally and
locally – There are so many things that remain unknown in our environment – things we must know
before, they disappear, things whose knowledge will contribute immensely to global and national
intellectual heritage in biology and genetics. While building capacity for engaging in the probes of
the frontiers, let us understand that the proximate and the distal (the frontier) are dialectically
united.
REFERENCES
Amin, Samir. 2004. The Liberal Virus: Permanent War and the Americanization of the World.
Pluto, London.
Center
for
Comparative
Genomics,
Murdoch
University,
Central
Australia.
http://ccg.murdoch.edu.au/index.php/What_is_Comparative_Genomics. Accessed October,
3, 2013.
Chowdary, B.P., T. Raudsepp, L. Fronicke and H. Scherthan. 1998. Emerging patterns in
comparative genome organization in some mammalian species as revealed by Zoo-FISH.
Genome Research 8, 577-589.
Darwin, Charles. 1859. Origin of Species. Washing Square Press, New York (1963).
Fedder, E. 1976. Strawberry Imperialism: An Inquiry into the Mechanism of Dependency in
Mexican Agriculture. Institute of Social Studies, The Hague.
Ferguson, C.H. and Morris, C.R.1994. Computer Wars: The Fall of IBM and the Future of Global
Technology. Times Books Random House, New York.
Gale, M.O. and K.M. Davos. 1998. Comparative genetics of grasses. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA.
95, 1971-1974.
George, Susan. 1979. Feeding the Few: Corporate Control of Food. Institute for Policy Studies,
Washington D.C.
GSN (Genetic Society of Nigeria). 1999. Genetics and Food Security in Nigeria in the Twenty-first
Century: A 25 Year Commemorative Publication of the Genetics Society of Nigeria. Gbade
Olaoye and D.O. Ladipo (Editors).
27
GSN. 2009. Genetics in the Service of Mankind: Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Conference.
Morakinyo, J.A., G. Olaoye, M.A Belewu & T.R. Fayeye (Editors).
Hawkes, G.J. 1990. What are genetic resources and why should they be conserved? Impact of
Science on Society. No. 15B. UNESCO, Paris, pp. 97-106.
Juma, Calistus. 1989. The Gene Hunters: Biotechnology and the Scramble for Seeds. Zed Book Ltd.,
London and Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J.
Kagarlitsky B. 2000. The Twilight of Globalization. Pluto, London.
Lesser, W. 1994. Institutional Mechanisms Supporting Trade in Genetic Materials: Issues under
Biodiversity Convention and GATT/TRIPs. UNEP (Environment and Trade). Geneva.
Mooney, P.R. 1983. The Law of the Seed: Another Development and Plant Genetic Resources.
Development Dialogue 1-2. Dag Harmarskjold Foundation. Uppsala.
Olorode, O. 2004. Conservation of Plant Genetic Resources Afr. J. Trad. CAM. 1, 4-15.
Olorode, O. 2007. Biodiversity, Globalisation and Poverty. Afr. J. Trad. CAM. 4(4), 532-540.
Olorode, O. 2012. Conservation and Utilization of Plant Genetic Resources: the increasing Role of
the impractical. Key Note Paper at the 2012 Annual Conference of Botanical Society of
Nigeria (BOSON) at Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife. 3rd – 7th June, 2012.
Peters, J.A. (Ed.). 1959. Classic Papers in Genetics Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliff., N.J.
Ryan, F. 2009. Virolution. Collins, London.
Snustad, D.P. and M.J. Simmons, 2003. Principles of Genetics. John Wiley & Sons.
Stiglitz, J.E. 2013. How intellectual Property Reinforces Inequality. New York Times Company.
Taylor, D.J., N.P.O. Green & G.W. Stout. 1997. Biological science Cambridge University Press.
New York.
The Arabidopsis Genome Initiative. 2000. Analysis of the genome sequence of the flowering plant
Arabidopsis thaliana. Nature 408, 796-815.
Watson, J.D. 1976. Molecular Biology of the Gene. W.A. Benjamin Inc. California.
Weaver, R.E. 2005. Molecular Biology. McGraw-Hill New York.
28
Gene X
RFLP1
RFLP2
Gene y
Gene z
RFLP3
Figure 2i: Congruence of genetic, cytological and physical maps.
Figure 2:
Cytological and genetic maps of X and Y human chromosomes indicating a
paracentric inversion in Y, genetic identities and high heterochromatin component of
Y chromosome. (Modified from Snustad et al. op. cit., 2009).
29
Figure 5:
Conserved syntheny in humans, pigs and cattle. (Snustad et al., op. cit., 2009).
Figure 6: Comparative gene maps and chromosome homology/syntheny in seven
species of cereal crops. (Modified after Snustad and Simmons, op. cit., 2009).
30
Figure 7:
AZFa region and azoospermy in Y-chromosomes
(Modified after Ryan, 2009: p.171)
31
Figure 8: Gene-phenotype pathway and the influences of epigenetic factors
32
Figure 9:
Juvenile-adult leaf transition in Angiosperms: internal and external
epigenetic factors
33
ANIMAL BREEDING AND GENETICS IN NIGERIA AND THE FUTURE
S.T. Mbap, Ph.D/Professor of Animal Genetics and Breeding
Animal Production Programme, School of Agriculture and Agricultural Technology, Abubakar
Tafawa Balewa University Bauchi
SUMMARY
Domestication of plants and animals using rudimentary genetics started even before written history.
In Nigeria most domestic animals are kept by traditional pastoralists. These animals appear to have
developed over the years into different breeds especially cattle, sheep and goats. Breed development
however does not appear to have been obvious in poultry e.g. chickens. The husbandry and
performance of the Nigeria livestock and poultry had not been adequate therefore they have not met
sufficiently the animal protein need of the populace. Animal Breeding and Genetics utilizes the
science of genetics to the improvement of animals through mainly selection and breeding especially
crossbreeding. Breeding improvement utilizes statistics to estimate the genotypic values of animals
using phenotypic information. The most appropriate genotypes are then selected and bred to form
the next generation. Through adequate use of statistics genetic animal improvement has advanced
adequately in the developed world e.g. in America. Genetic improvement however has been slower
in Nigeria in comparison. To fast track genetic animal improvement in Nigeria the country must
learn from the progress made in other places and apply all the appropriate genetic improvement
steps that have been found useful. Of recent Molecular Genetics-Genetic Engineering in particular
has been applied to animal improvement with some successes. Procedures such as marker-assisted
selection and transgenesis including cloning have shown great promises and should also be applied
to the Nigerian situation.
Developments of specialized breeds are usually direct products of advancement in genetic
improvement. Some animals would therefore be less used or may fall out of the usual production
cycle and become extinct. Efforts must be made to conserve or protect all species of farm animals
including their wild ancestors and relatives because changed circumstance in the future may require
their utilization.
An Invited Paper Presented at the 37th Animal Conference of the Genetic Society of Nigeria, 20-24th
October 2013, Lafia, Nasarawa State, Nigeria
INTRODUCTION
Rudimentary use of genetics had allowed man to gather plant and animal food materials, discard
those that do not meet his needs and domesticate some even before recorded history (Hartwell, et
al., 2000). In Nigeria most domestic animal especially species used for food have been in the hands
of farmers/pastoralists who have little exposure to the science of modern Breeding and Genetics.
They have acquired their animals mostly through ancestry but have maintained them with dignity.
These livestock owners however are breeders and geneticists in their own right. For, over the years,
they have developed herds/flocks of true breeding (true to type) species-cattle, sheep, goats and
pigs. They have maintained their purity and distinctive characteristics especially colouration and
productivity, probably through trait preference and genetic separation (natural and artificial) until
recently when careless crossbreeding disturbed the status quo. Some genes, especially those for
colour therefore became fixed until recently. Today multicoloured livestock are found all over
Nigeria which are direct consequences of uncontrolled breeding (that the appearance of some
multicolours in livestock could be due to crossbreeding can easily be demonstrated). It appears
however, that distinctive breed development did not take place among most local poultry species,
especially chickens as multicolouration has always been the order among them.
34
Natural selection has also reasonably adapted the Nigerian domestic animals to their environment.
They are therefore able to withstand (survive) the vagaries-fluctuations and challenges of the
environment and feed, grow, reproduce and maintain some levels of productivity. The artificial
selection by traditional farmers over the years might not have been obvious. Selection is however
carried out by farmers when males are castrated, bulls identified for breeding and unthrifty or sick
animals culled or sold out. These processes however were not vigorously carried in systematic and
sustained manner. Thus improvement progress has been slow and generally there has been low
productivity. This is compounded by the overbearing effect of the relatively uncontrolled
environment. Attempts have definitely been made by traditional animal owners over the years to
control the environment such as little housing for smaller species e.g. sheep, goats and poultry.
Deticking, a very ancient practice and, nomadism and transhumance etc are all efforts to control the
environment as had been alluded to by Williamson and Payne (1978). All these have contributed to
the domestic animals found around today. The authors indicated that tropical and hence Nigerian
animals grow slowly, utilize food and reproduce inefficiently and therefore are unable to satisfy the
animal protein demand of the society. Nigerians over the years consequently have consumed and
utilized animal protein below the expected FAO (1990) recommended level of 34g per caput. Meat
and eggs are a luxury in some societies and milk, of course, if available is known to be poorly
utilized by 70% of adult human population due to lack of intestinal lactase to digest its high lactose
content (Robinson and Mc Evoy, 1993, Montaldo, 2006). This is expected to change with future
application of the science of Breeding and Genetics.
To relate Animal Breeding and Genetics to the future, it is necessary to first appreciate its position
in the past and present.
THE SCIENCE OF ANIMAL BREEDING AND GENETICS AND, THE PAST AND
PRESENT
Animal and Breeding and Genetics is a science of animal improvement that is researchable, taught
in schools, colleges and tertiary institutions and practised on the field. Its basic scope which varies,
is exposure to the science of genetics (Hartwell et al., 2006) and the art of application to the
improvement of animals (some people argue that the art comes before the science). Selection is its
basic, albeit not the only, tool. Animals are assessed and the best selected to form future generations
based on some criteria which may be objective or subjective. Thus once the criteria have been spelt
out the next step is finding animals that fit them. Since genetic characteristics may but, in most
cases, are not observed in animals on the outside, there must be a way of knowing the genetic make
up based on the outside. Breeders therefore embark, through selection, on “blind” search for desired
genetic make up-genotype using outside appearance-phenotype which may not tell much. Over the
years breeders have relied on statistics to resolve the problem and the subject of statistics became so
ingrained into the science of Animal Breeding and Genetics that it became difficult to appreciate the
science without statistics. When mention is made of Fisher, Wright, Lush, Haldane, Dickerson,
Kemp thorne, Searle, Falconer, Hill, Henderson etc with regard to work in breeding and genetics it
is sometimes difficult to know whether they were breeders applying statistics as a tool to the science
of Breeding and Genetics or they were Mathematicians/Statisticians using breeding and genetics in
Statistics. The convergence in this respect became almost absolute.
With the aid of statistics therefore, the blind search is reduced to estimating observable values to
give insight into genetic values or merits or better still breeding values of animals. This is the so
called traditional (but scientific) animal breeding or improvement method using phenotype and
genealogical information. Breeders therefore talk about true mean values, least squares means, best
estimates and predictions etc whose elucidation may require linear modelling and matrix algebra
(Searle, 1965; Henderson, 1975).
35
It is not uncommon therefore that Least Squares of different kinds, Maximum likelihood, Best
Prediction (Estimation)(BP), Best Linear and Unbias Prediction (BLUP) procedures etc applied to
mixed models (Henderson, 1975) are utilized to get the best animals for selection. The Americans at
Iowa and Cornell in particular have applied these procedures and made dramatic improvement in
their livestock species over the past 80 years. Procedures such as daughter dam comparisons, sire
evaluation and sire studs for artificial insemination (AI), use of pedigree information, progeny
testing herdmate comparison and simulation 1, nucleus breeding scheme, central breeding system
and testing stations were applied to aid selection. The selection was carried out in various ways to
maximize progress. Crossbreeding was also applied when quick and further improvements were
desired and to benefit from the effect of heterosis. There were also various grading up policies and
development of new breeds through crossbreeding. Today, animal protein in the form of meat, milk
and egg is easily available in America and in many parts of the developed world and derived from
different species and specialized breeds.
THE PAST AND PRESENT STATE OF ANIMAL BREEDING AND GENETICS IN
NIGERIA
The Nigeria’s genetic animal improvement situation is different from the Americas. The science of
Animal Breeding and Genetics was slow in coming and poorly appreciated. Animal improvement
was first considered in terms of nutrition and healthy. This is not completely inappropriate as
genetic attributes are better appreciated only after environmental influences have been reduced.
The first crop of Nigerians to be trained in Animal Breeding and Genetics was in 1960’s and early
1970’s. Earlier however, the first livestock farm had been established in 1914 at Allagarno in
today’s Borno State to start some improvement efforts. It was closed due to lack of improved
production despite improved management (Knudsen and Sohael, 1970). The Vom Livestock
Investigation and Breeding Centre was established in 1920; Shika and Agege farms followed
closely with others all over Nigeria, including Universities subsequently. The first few farms started
with local breeds, mainly cattle.
The first recorded selection in Nigeria started at Vom in 1939 on a strain of White Fulani called
Kurum Baji. It is not clear which selection procedures were followed but probably mass or
individual in view of lack of adequate records and the low state of the science of breeding and
genetics in the country at that time. It is on record however that the selection process was not
properly executed (Knudsen and Sohael, 1970). It even became more difficult at the advent of the
Second World War. The colonialists wanted plenty of butter to prosecute the war, especially during
the winter. The large amount of butter required was obviously not met from home production.
Colonies were looked up to. Cows were therefore retained in the Vom herd irrespective of
production to boost butter quantity. Selection was again resumed in 1948 but there was poor result.
It was decided at Vom and in many of the other farms that European cattle genotypes in the farms
of bulls and semen should be imported to crossbreed the local herds (which have not been
adequately selected) and later to form pure exotic herds. There was in addition the well known
exotic cockerel exchange programme of the 1970’s in most parts of Africa aimed at crossbreeding
the local chickens. Sheep, goats and pigs were not spared as there have been crossbreeding on them
about the same time as poultry. Therefore the Nigerian Livestock and bird population did not pass
through the expected initial period of intense and sustained selection.
It has been difficult since then to convince some Nigerians to start genetic improvement through
selection. To them, genetic improvement became synonymous to crossbreeding. Some of my
students would want to crossbreed and quickly expose pastoralists to the crosses. My response has
always been, “wait a bit”. When they insist I would advise that only elite farms that can handle the
36
crosses should have them. This is because, if a pastoralist’s herd/flock is crossbred and he is not
well prepared for them, they would die and he is ruined. Even some Agricultural Development
Programmes (ADP’s) and elites in the society who should know better advocate immediately
crossbreeding stressing that the crosses look and perform better; but on whose herd, at what cost
and for how long? They also add that they have waited too long for genetic improvement, in
Nigeria, through selection. My bitter experience at Butura Livestock Farm near Bokkos in Plateau
State, 1977-82, might have been responsible for my present staunched perhaps stern stand. I had the
unpleasant and unhappy privilege of witnessing about 80 pure Friesians and crosses with White
Fulani, under my watch, perished due to dermatophilosis. The farm was not well prepared against
ticks and other ectoparasites. It is only fair to mention that at the same time, the Vom herd was able
to maintain similar stock with some level of productivity (Mbap and Ngere, 1989). Similarly elite
poultry farms have raised exotic breeds with some levels of success, although costs of production
have been quite high.
STEPS IN ANIMAL BREEDING AND GENETICS
Genetic improvement should have strong elements of selection, especially on traits of high
heritabilities, such as those associated to productivity. Williamson and Payne (1978) had indicated
that animal improvement in the tropics and hence Nigeria could (or in certain places had been)
carried out successfully through selection, crossbreeding, grading up or rearing of pure exotic
herds/flocks. However they quickly added that successes would depend on appropriateness or
method, prevailing weather and management conditions. The steps may include the following:
(i) Characterization- know the phenotype, genotype and worth
(ii) Selection
(iii)Crossbreeding between local or between local and exotic breeds
(iv) Grading up, new breed development and rearing of pure exotic breeds
The last three may follow if selection results in inadequate improvement. Crossbreeding should
never be the first step. Nigerian animals are poorly genetically improved today probably because of
wrong concepts and steps. Part of the National Animal Production Research Institute (NAPRI)
mandate is to carry out genetic animal improvement. It is gratifying that steps have been taken to
include characterization, selection, crossbreeding and grading up with some successes, especially in
the development of the well known NAPRI layer.
THE SCIENCE OF ANIMAL BREEDING AND GENETICS IN NIGERIA AND THE
FUTURE
There have been avoidable shortcomings in genetic animal improvement in Nigeria in the past or
rather the process has been relatively slow. The future state of Nigeria’s livestock and poultry and
contribution to living standard, health, Gross Domestic Products (GDP) and national development
would depend on steps taken now and in the future. Now that the constraints of health, nutrition and
other environmental conditions of animal are vigorously being tackled through research and
development, sustained genetic improvement must follow. There are many attributes of the
Nigerian animals that could be exploited in breeding. The fast growth and good meat conformation
of the Gudali’s could be utilized in beef cattle development. The breed also has good temperament
for milk production. The Wadara also has some potentials for milk production. Among the sheep
breeds, the Balami and Uda have high birth and mature weights and fast growth that could be
utilized. The West African dwarf has the advantage of high litter production as twinning and triplets
37
are common features of the breeds, enabling quick herd formation and fast turnover on selection. If
also selected for survivability (a very important constraint in their production) quick progress could
be made in goat meat production, a product highly cherished by a large proportion of the Nigerian
society. There are heavy chicken ecotypes, for example the Fulani ecotype (Atteh, 1990) that could
be utilized in broiler production. The early maturity among Nigerian poultry is a trait that could also
be used in both broiler and layer production. If selected against broodiness, egg production could be
enhanced. These are just but few traits among many that could be utilized in future breed genetic
improvement and development.
It might sound naive that we are talking about applying the basics of breeding improvement in the
21st century and post genomics. However we must get it right, carry out genetic improvement
properly and be patient for results which may not come readily. Today, there is general renaissance
and intensified work among breeders to properly characterize the Nigerian domestic Livestock
(Moruppa and Ngere, 1986; Nwosu, 1979; Rege, 1992, Mbap and Zakar, 2000; Mancha, 2004;
Egashi, 2011, Wamagi, 2012) in view of the aforementioned potentials. The other enumerated
improvement steps should also follow and at national level. The Federal Livestock Department
(FLD), Nigeria Institute of Animal Science (NIAS), National Agricultural Research Project
(NARP) should lead and ensure rapid and sustainable genetic progress. The NAPRI should in
addition to the NAPRI layer, develop more specialized breeds among other livestock species.
Procedures followed by the Americans should be reviewed, adapted and utilized. This is especially
when human population is growing and available space dwindling. In 1991 the late Dr. J.N. Bincan,
Director Livestock in the Federal Ministry of Agriculture (FMA) initiated a programme for
improvement of all Nigerian domestic animal breeds, at a national level, through selection using the
nucleus breeding scheme and other procedures. He died shortly after in 1992 and the programme
also died. I call on the FMA to revisit such ingenious initiatives. The FMA should dig the archives
to find out what actually happened to this particular programme and reinitiate it. As inferred earlier,
traits currently considered in genetic improvement are those that emphasize increased productivity.
The improvement criteria or traits to improve in the future may change. This is in view of changing
environment and human population. While traits such as fast growth, early maturity, egg size and
number etc may always be retained, it is possible that animal size among others may be selected
against in future, in view of space constraints and other changing demands, including increase in
periurban agriculture.
THE USE OF MOLECULAR GENETICS
Nigeria should not lag in the application of modern technologies in genetic animal improvement. As
alluded to, the Science of Breeding and Genetics, at certain levels, was so akin to statistics that it
was difficult to appreciate the difference. Increasingly the science is becoming more molecular.
Any serious student or practitioner of Breeding and Genetics would not cope without proper
exposure to Molecular Genetics. Thus teaching and research in Animal Breeding and Genetics and,
application to the improvement of animals in Nigeria must of necessity emphasize the molecular
aspect (without diminishing the conventional methods). The Animal Breeding and Genetics
Laboratory of today and the future should not only be data banks and store houses for computer
facilities. They should also have genetic resource banks and should contain equipment for
molecular genetics and biotechnology. These facilities will expose students and researchers alike to
the rudiments of the fields preparatory to stronger application in animal improvement. At Abubakar
Tafawa Balewa University (ATBU) Bauchi, a course in Genetic Engineering is compulsory to all
postgraduate students of Breeding and Genetics. Indeed some few universities in the country have
extended it to all undergraduate Breeding and Genetics students.
38
The application of Molecular Genetics in Animal Breeding and Genetics is wide, varied and
complex. It will only be briefly discussed to underscore its usefulness to Nigeria in the future.
When Molecular Genetics in the form of Genetic Engineering or Recombinant DNA technology is
applied for the improvement of animals, it would appear that it is not blind such for the right
animals any longer. Genetic Engineering allows breeders to identify, replicate, modify and transfer
genetic materials (Montaldo, 2006). They range from DNA components to complete organisms.
The physical map (linkage map) of special DNA’s, major genes or markers, compound genes or
genetic loci for production traits called quantitative trait loci (QTL) may be known through linkage
disequilibrium studies in mating experiments and use of polymorphic microsatellites (Malau-Aduli,
2003) within some confidence limit. The animals that are thought to have them are then selected.
However since the existence, exact location on the chromosome, function and passage of QTL to
subsequent generations are still a matter of probability, phenotypic and genealogical information
and hence traditional selection procedures are applied (but highly enhanced). Furthermore, as is
well known, different genes may produce the same phenotype, most economic traits are due to
multiple gene (or polygenic) action and attendant interactions and, complications such a linkage and
plieotropy. In addition traits are also controlled by the environment. All these vitiate the initial
enthusiasm that greeted the discovery of QTL. Nonetheless, even recently, it has been stated that the
identification of QTL has potentials to significantly increase rate of genetic improvement through
the use of Marker-Assisted Selection (MAS) (MacNeil and Gross, 2002). (The MAS being
extension of traditional selection procedure using QTL). However, in view of the limitations, the
use of MAS in breeding improvement is not a revolution as such but an evolution of the traditional
genetic improvement (Montaldo, 2006). Although the expected gain using MAS may not be as high
as initially anticipated, it is a step forward and where possible, it should be applied in future
Nigerian breeding situation. The MAS is most useful for traits of low heritabilities, expressed late in
life, sex limited, expensive to measure or controlled by a few genes (Davis and DeNise, 1998;
Montaldo, 2006).
TRANSGENESIS AND CLONING
Transgenesis which is an introgressive procedure, in genetic engineering, makes it possible to alter
an animal genetically for particular purposes e.g. disease resistance by introducing a gene or part of
a DNA. Cloning of a full animal, an extreme form of transgenesis is carried out through nuclear
transfer. Genetically identical individuals are produced e.g. the Dolly Sheep (Wilmut et al., 1997).
While cloning is novel in higher animals it is the norm in some plants and lower animals. Cloning
has therefore brought this type of reproduction to the remit of all living organisms. Transgenesis
(cloning) if properly applied could be useful tools in the hands of breeders. With appropriate
knowledge of gene combinations and functions, new and useful population could be created within
a short time for the benefit of man. Again cloning is a step forward but not a panacea to all animal
improvement problems. Differences still exist between clones due to the environment and the
variation could be as high or even higher than 50% of total (Van Vleck, 1999). Therefore selection
is still appropriate amongst them. However in selection using clonal individuals, additive and non
additive genetic differences could be utilized (Visscher et al, 2000) thus increasing genetic gain.
This is unlike non clonal selection where non additive variations are not utilized.
The current drawbacks to transgenesis especially cloning are low success rate, cost and some
unapparent health problems amongst clones. Another dilemma is ethical and practical applicability
in a country like Nigeria which has high religious culture and illiteracy rate. The negative reactions
of sceptics are also not helpful. On the whole therefore, genetic engineering in animal improvement
has not replaced the classical improvement procedures but aided them. However when MAS and
transgenesis are applied in Nigeria in conjunction to older reproductive technologies such as
39
artificial insemination, semen and ova preservation, multiple ovulation and embryo transfer, semen
and embryo sexing, in vitro oocyte maturation and Fertilization (Robinson and McEvoy, 1993),
rapid overall progress could be made. The much needed animal protein for growth and development
would be met. Furthermore, the potential of the country to export animal products in view of large
number of animal species and high population would enhanced. This is particularly important as
Nigeria is looked up to by many surrounding countries for support. That Nigeria sometimes imports
animals for meat from other smaller neighbouring countries is not acceptable.
ANIMAL GENETIC RESOURCE AND BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION
Genetic resource and biodiversity conservation or protection has recently become a much discussed
topic. It would even be a more important concept in future breeding work. The year 2010 was
declared International year of Biodiversity by the United Nations. This came at the heels of the
adoption of the Global Plan of Action for Animal Genetic Resources (AnGR) three years earlier
[Editorial; Animal Genetic Resources, 2010;47]. This 47th volume of the journal was published as a
special edition to mark the year and all the 12 (invited) papers were on the Global Plan for Action.
Conservation of genetic resources is necessary to ensure their continuous use. For those that are not
presently being used, change circumstances may require their utilization. Indeed the future food
supply depends to a large extent on how the present generation handles conservation. The concept
would surely gain momentum in Nigeria in view of increasing emphasis and concern about food
security. Therefore, a major component of conservation is sustainable use i.e. handling genetic
resources in a manner that diversity does not decline.
In general, animal genetic resources could be conserved in two ways (FAO, 1998).
(i) Maintaining the population or endangered species/breeds in the production cycle.
(ii) Cryo preservation or – conservation of gametes, embryos, somatic cells or even life animals
Initially prioritization for conservation was arrived at through phenotypic characterization. Species,
breeds strains etc were evaluated for current or potential values or uses to determine those to pay
more attention to. Of recent, molecular genetics -genetic engineering has been applied to enhance
decision making. Genetic engineering provides in depth information on the genetic merit of animal
population (Hill, 2000). There is, in addition, more accurate information retrieval. Relatedness and
genetic distances are more accurately assessed, enabling better characterization. If it becomes a
matter of decision on which genotype to conserve in view of storage space/facility limitations,
choices could be concentrated between more, than less related individuals, thus reducing diversity
erosion.
The earlier genotypic efforts/procedures utilized protein and blood type analysis using
electrophoresis and immunological studies in conjunction to protein markers. Protein markers
however vary with development, environment and selection (Talle et al., 2005). Today, gene
mapping has become a particularly useful procedure in conservation. The existence of DNA
sequence polymorphism enables the identification and use of different techniques/markers in
conservation. Those currently in use are mitochondrial DNA markers, restriction fragment length
polymorphism, amplified fragment length polymorphism, random amplified polymorphic DNA,
microsatellites/micro satellites studies, DNA sequencing, single nucleotide polymorphism as
individuals or in array etc (Adebambo et al., 2004; Talle et al., 2005; Agaviezor et al., 2011).
It is being argued that conservation should not be limited to domestic plants and animals but also
their wild ancestors and relatives. This is because there may be reasons in the future to revert to
40
them for some important genes or gene combinations. Since bioresource or biodiversity
conservation may feature prominently in future Nigerian breeding and genetic work, the country
should join and become an active participant in the global biodiversity initiative.
REFERENCES
Adebambo, O.A., Williams, J.L., Blott, S. and Urquhart, B. (2004) Genetic relationships between
native sheep breeds in Nigeria based on microsatellite DNA polymorphisms.
Anim.Genet.Res.Inf. 34:27-39
Agaviezor, B.O., Adefenwa, M.A, Adebambo, O.A., Okpeku, M., Peters, S.O., Ikeobi, C.O.N.,
Ilori, M., Wheto, M. and Immorin, I.G.(2011). Mitochondrial analysis of genetic structure in
Nigerian sheep. Proc. 16th Ann. Conf. ASAN, 12-15th September 2011 KSU,
Anyigba,
Nigeria
Davis G.P and DeNise, S.K. (1998). The impact of genetic markers on selection J.Anim.Sci
76:2331-2339.
Editorial: Anim. Genet. Res. 2010: 47
Egashi, J.O., Dim, N.I. and Mabrama, B.D. (2011) Body weight and body dimension in free range
West African Dwarf goat in guinea Savannah. Proc. Ann. Conf. ASAN 12-15th September,
KSU Anyigba, Nigeria.
FAO(1998) Primary Guidelines for Development of National Farm Animals Genetic Resources
Management Plans, FAO, Rome
Hartwell, L.H., Hood, L., Goldberg, M.L., Reynolds, A.E., Silver, L.M. and Veres, R.C.(2000)
Genetics: From Genes to Genomes, McGraw-Hill Higher Education N.Y. USA
Henderson, C.R.(1975) Best linear unbiased estimation and prediction under selection model.
Biomet. 31: 423-447 (www.researchgate.net/.../21980267)
Hill, W.G.(2000) Maintenance of quantitative genetic variation in animal breeding programmes
Livest.Prod. Sci. 63(2):99-109
Knudsen, P.D. and Sohael, A.S.(1970) The Vom herd: A study of performance of a mixed
Friesian/Zebu herd in a tropical environment. Trop.Agric. (Trinidad) 47:189-203
MacNeil, M.D. and Grosz, M.D.(2002) Genome-wide scans for QTL affecting carcass traits in
Hereford composite double backcross populations. J. Anim. Sci. 80:2316-2324.
Malau-Aduli, A.E.D., Niibagashi, T.,Kojima, T., Oshima, K. and Komatsu, M.(2003). Genome
wide scanning for QTL: Mapping methodology and detected QTL in cattle. J. Anim. Genet.
30(2): 3-16
Mancha, Y.P.(2004) Characterization of Local Chicken in Northern Parts of Jos Plateau.
PhD Thesis, Animal Production Programme, School of Agriculture and Agricultural
Technology, ATBU, Bauchi
Mbap, S.T. and Ngere, L.O.(1989) Productivity of Friesian cattle in a subtropical environment.
Trop. Agric. (Trinidad) 66(2) 121-124
Mbap, S.T. and Zakar, H (2000) Characterization of local chicken in Yobe State, Nigeria. In. The
Role of Agriculture in Poverty Alleviation: Abubakar, M.M., Adegbola, T.A and Butswat, I.S. R.
(Eds). Proc. 34th Ann. Conf. ASAN, 15-19th October, 2000, Bauchi, Nigeria.
Montaldo, H.M (2005) Genetic engineering applications in animal
breeding.http://www.ejbiotechnology.info/content/vol/9/issue2full/ 7/
Moruppa, S.M and Ngere, L.O.(1986) Biometric studies on Bornu White and Red Sokoto
(Maradi) goat breeds. Paper presented at the 11th
Ann. Conf., NS/AP, 23-27th March,
1986, ABU, Zaria.
Nwosu C.C. (1979) Characterization of the local chicken of Nigeria and its potential for egg and
meat production. In: Poultry Production in Nigeria. Proc. 1st Nat. Sem. Poult. Prod., 1979,
41
Zaria Rege, J.E.O (1992) Background to ILCA’s AnGR characterization project, project
objectives and agenda for the research planning
workshop. African Animal Genetic
Resources. Their
characterization, conservation and utilization. Proc. Res. Plan Works.
19-21st February 1992, ILCA, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Robinson, J.J. and McEvoy, T.G. (1993) Biotechnology-the possibilities. Anim.Prod. 57: 335-352
Searle, S.R 1966 Matrix Algebra for the Biological Sciences (including Applications in
Statistics) John Wiley & Sons, Inc. New York
Talle, S.B., Chenyabuga, W.S., Finland, E., Syrstad, O., Meuwissen, T. and Klungland, H.
(2005) Use of DNA technologies for the conservation of animal genetic resources: A
review, Acta Agric. Scand. Sect. A, 55:1-8.
The history of Genetic Evaluation Methods in Dairy Cattle
(www.aps.uoguelph.ca/~/rs/GROSU/ALMAB.pdf)
Van Vleck, L.D (1999). Implications of cloning for breed improvement strategies: Are
traditional methods of animal improvement obsolete? J. Anim. Sci. 77(2) 111-121.
Visscher, P, Pong-wong, R., Whittemore, C. and Haley C. (2000). Impact of biotechnology
on (cross) breeding programmes in pigs Livest. Prod. Sci. 65:57-70
Wamagi, T.I. (2012) Phenotypic characterization of sheep and goats in southern part of Kaduna
State. Unpublished M.Sc Thesis, Animal Production Programme, School of Agriculture and
Agricultural Technology, ATBU, Bauchi.
Williamson, G. And Payne, W.J.A (1978). An Introduction to Animal Production in the Tropics 3rd
Edition, Longman Group Ltd, UK.
Wilmut, I., Schnieke, A.E., Mcwhir, J., Kind, A. J. and Campbell, K.H.S. (1997). Viable offspring
sderived from fetal and adult mammalian cells. Nat. 385(6619) 810-813.
42
ANIMAL GENETICS AND BREEDING (AGB)
AGB01
DIRECT AND PERCENTAGE HETEROSIS OF GROWTH TRAITS IN CROSSES
INVOLVING INDIGENOUS AND EXOTIC BREEDS OF PIGS IN NIGERIA
Okoro, V.M.O.1*, Ogundu, U.E.1, Okoro, C.L.2, Oke, U.K.3 and Ibe, S. N.3
1
Department of Animal Science and Technology, Federal University of Technology, Owerri,
Nigeria.
2
Department of Agriculture, Owerri Municipal Council, Owerri, Nigeria.
3
Department of Animal Breeding and Genetics, Michael Okpara University of Technology,
Umudike, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail : melavicong4real@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Crossbreeding in pigs in order to exploit heterosis has been the common practice in commercial pig
production since better average performance of crossbred animals is achieved over their purebred
counterparts. A total of 72 progenies generated from a cross involving the West African Indigenous
(WAI), Landrace (LR) and Large White (LW) breeds were used to estimate the direct and
percentage heterosis on bodyweight (BW) and morphometric traits such as Ear length (EL), Tail
length (TL), Heart girth (HG), Height-at-withers (HW), Snout length (SL) and Body length (BL) at
56, 84, 112 and 140 days of age. Positive direct heterosis was reported on BW at 56 days for
LRxLW and LRxWAI crosses only, while at 84, 112 and 140 days, negative direct heterosis were
recorded for the other crosses. The morphometric traits also showed more positive direct heterosis,
particularly for EL, TL, HG, HW, SL and BL at various ages and crosses than negative heterosis at
other ages and crosses. The percentage heterosis ranged from 7.72% to 55.91% for BW at different
ages and crosses, while for morphometric traits, it ranged from 0% to 32.00% in EL, 1.14% to
15.4% in TL, 0.77% to 21.18% in HG, 0.76% to 29.53% in HW, 0% to 13.59% in SL and 0.76% to
19.66% in BL at different ages and crosses, respectively. This implies that for those traits that
exhibit positive heterosis, the exploitation of non-additive gene action such as dominance could
bring about more rapid genetic improvement, while the high percentage heterosis (BW) implies that
selection for such trait will lead to more rapid genetic improvement. However, low percentage
heterosis recorded for some of the BW and all the morphometric traits shows that selection for these
traits cannot result in rapid genetic improvements.
Keywords: Crossbreeding, growth traits, morphometric, reciprocal cross, heterosis.
INTRODUCTION
Swine breeding and genetics has advanced tremendously with rapid crossbreeding in order to
exploit heterosis. Desirable characteristics of different breeds can be utilized if some breeds can be
identified as good maternal breeds and others as good paternal breeds (Buchanan et al., 2005). The
diallel cross is commonly used in plant and animal breeding for evaluating the genetic structure of a
population of pure-bred lines. An accurate analysis of this mating design is therefore not only of
theoretical but also of economic importance and has been dealt with by many authors (Virk et al.,
43
1985; Okoro et al., 2012a). A common assumption underlying most analyses of the diallel cross is
the absence of any reciprocal differences, which are primarily caused by sex-linkage and maternal
effects. Although the effects of such differences on the analysis of diallel crosses have been
examined by many authors (Wearden, 1964; Durrant, 1965; Topham, 1966, and Mather and Jinks
1982); these investigators were primarily concerned with testing the significance of possible effects
and with determining the probable cause of heterosis and reciprocal effects.
There is a dearth of information on systematic breeding plans in pig breeding as well as poor
husbandry practices in the methods of pig production in Nigeria. Since reciprocal and heterotic
effects are important in deciding on the lines of sire or dam to be used in a cross for developing
commercially-superior crossbred progeny in terms of growth and reproductive characteristics; there
is dearth of information on direct heterotic effects on the cross of the three major breeds commonly
used for production – Large White (LW), Landrace (LR) and West African Indigenous (WAI)
breeds in the tropical rainforest environment of Nigeria.
This study was therefore conducted to estimate the direct and percentage heterosis on growth traits
in crosses of pigs (LW, LR and WAI breeds) in tropical rainforest zone of Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A modified 3x3 diallel cross comprising three breeds of pigs, namely Large White (LW), Landrace
(LR) and West African Indigenous (WAI) breeds was conducted. The matings were as follows:
Main cross: LW (♂) x LR (♀); LW (♂) x WAI (♀), and LR (♂) x WAI (♀).
Reciprocal cross: LR (♂) x LW (♀); WAI (♂) x LW (♀); WAI (♂) x LR (♀).
Three boars of each breed were mated to six sows of the three breeds, randomly sampled from the
population maintained in the farm. Piglets were generated from the crosses which comprised 2
parities per cross, totaling 12 litters. Data generated were replicated based on parities in order to
estimate a reliable standard error of mean for crosses.
The parameters measured were growth traits which included:
1. Weaning and post weaning weight at 56 and 84 days of age (measured using 50 kg weighing
scale ® Salter England)
2. Body weight towards the end of growth period at 112 and 140 days of age (measured using
200kg bridge weighing scale ® Global Universal England).
3. Morphometric traits measured at 56, 84, 112 and 140 days of age were estimated as follows:
i.
Ear length (EL) – Measured as the distance from the ear base to the tip of the ear,
using a tailor’s tape.
ii.
Tail length (TL) – The distance from the pin bone of the tail base to the tip of the
tail, using a tailor’s tape.
iii.
Heart Girth (HG) – Measured as the circumference of the animal body taken
immediately posterior to the shoulder, using a tailor’s tape.
iv.
Height at Withers (HW) – Measured as the distance from the highest point on the
dorsum of the animal to the ground surface, at the level of the front feet, using a tailor’s
tape.
v.
Body length (BL) - Measured as the distance from the point of the scapular to the
pin bone of the tail base, using a tailor’s tape.
vi. Snout length (SL) – The distance from the eye slit to the tip of the snout, using a tailor’s
tape.
Direct heterosis for each cross was estimated with the method of linear contrasts as outlined by
Dickerson (1992) in expression (4) below:
Direct heterosis for each cross = Mean of the cross – Mean of parental purebreds
... (4)
44
In addition, percentage heterosis was obtained separately for main and reciprocal crosses as quotient
between direct heterosis (expression 4) and mean purebred value multiplied by 100 as shown in
expression (5) below
Percentage heterosis = Direct heterosis
x
100
…
(5)
Mean of purebreds
1
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The distribution of litters of progeny according to breed of sire (Main cross) and breed of dam
(Reciprocal cross) is shown in Table 1. The resultant litter size totaled 72, comprising 27, 25 and
20 piglets from the Large White (LW), Landrace (LR) and West African Indigenous (WAI) sires
respectively while the dam breed (Reciprocal cross) produced 23, 25 and 23 piglets from LW, LR
and WAI, respectively. The cross between LW x LR produced the highest litter size, while NI x
LW produced the least litter size.
Table 1: Distribution of litters according to Breed of Sire and Breed of Dam
Breed of Sirea
Breed of Dam
LW
LR
WAI
TOTAL
LW
*
14
9
23
LR
15
*
11
25
WAI
12
11
*
23
TOTAL
27
25
20
72
a
LW = Large White LR= Landrace WAI= West African Indigenous.
*No purebred mating.
Bereskin and Hetzer (1986) reported an average litter distribution ranging from 6 to 10 in a diallel
cross to determine the genetic and maternal effects on pig weight, growth and probe backfat in high
and low fat lines of swine. Although this study was not a full diallel cross due to absence of
purebred litters, it was similar to the report by Obasi and Ibe (2008) who reported a total of 72 kits
in an experiment to determine the influence of additive and non-additive gene effects on body
measurements in domestic rabbits. In addition, Adebambo (1986) reported a higher litter number in
crosses involving LW x Hampshire (HA) breeds (8.25 to 8.75) than crosses involving LW x WAI,
HA x WAI and WAI x exotic breeds, which ranged from 7.8 to 8.3.
The estimates of direct and percentage heterosis for BW are presented in Table 2. At 56 days of
age, there was a positive heterosis for the reciprocal cross, LRxLW (16.21%) and main cross
LRxWAI (7.92%), while for other main and reciprocal crosses, heterosis was negative with
percentage heterosis ranging from 12.08% to 41.20%. At ages 84, 112 and 140days, there were
negative direct heterosis for all the crosses for BW, with values ranging from -1.32 to -10.00 and
percentage heterosis ranging from 3.59% to 55.91%.
45
Table 2: Estimates of Direct and Percentage Heterosisa for Body weight at 8-20 weeks
Cross 1
Cross 2
Cross 3
Age
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
(Days)
LWxLR
LRxLW
LWxWAI
WAIxLW
LRxWAI
WAIxLR
56
-1.28
0.94
-2.06
-0.97
0.42
-0.64
(22.07)
(16.21)
(41.20)
(19.4)
(7.92)
(12.08)
84
-3.05
-1.23
-5.20
-3.45
-1.87
-1.27
(28.24)
(11.39)
(55.91)
(37.10)
(19.08)
(12.96)
112
-2.52
-0.46
-5.61
-3.84
-1.26
-0.29
(19.69)
(3.59)
(50.09)
(34.29)
(10.59)
(2.44)
140
-3.55
-2.52
-10.00
-8.02
-3.29
-0.16
(16.82)
(11.94)
(55.87)
(44.80)
(17.98)
(0.87)
a
Percentage heterosis in parentheses.
The estimates of direct and percentage heterosis for EL and TL are presented in Tables 3 and 4. In
all crosses (main and reciprocal), there was positive heterosis for EL at 56 and 84 days of age.
Positive heterosis was also obtained at ages 112 and 140 days, except for LWxLR main cross in day
112, and LWxLR main and reciprocal cross and LRxWAI main and reciprocal cross in day 140.
For TL, except for LWxLR main crosses at 56, 84 and 112 days, and LRxWAI main cross at 56 and
84 days, heterosis was positive in all other situations. However, the percentage heterosis ranged
from 0 to 32.0% and 1.14 to 15.4% in EL and TL, respectively.
Table 3: Estimates of Direct and Percentage Heterosisa for Ear length between 56 -140 days.
Cross 1
Cross 2
Cross 3
Age
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
(Days)
LWxLR
LRxLW
LWxWAI
WAIxLW
LRxWAI
WAIxLR
56
0.54
0.25
1.79
0.50
0.86
1.25
(6.75)
(3.13)
(27.54)
(7.69)
(11.86)
(17.24)
84
0.19
0.75
2.32
0.86
0.97
1.38
(2.24)
(8.82)
(32.00)
(11.86)
(11.76)
(16.73)
112
-0.44
0.00
1.96
1.03
0.33
0.50
(4.51)
(0.00)
(25.29)
(13.29)
(3.67)
(5.56)
140
-1.96
-1.75
1.04
0.19
-0.69
-0.25
(17.04)
(15.22)
(11.24)
(2.05)
(6.73)
(2.44)
a
Percentage heterosis in parentheses.
46
Table 4: Estimates of Direct and Percentage Heterosisa for Tail length between 56 – 140 days
Cross 1
Cross 2
Cross 3
Age
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
(Days)
LWxLR
LRxLW
LWxWAI
WAIxLW
LRxWAI
WAIxLR
56
-0.22
0.18
0.84
0.66
-0.69
0.70
(3.41)
(2.79)
(15.41)
(12.11)
(12.55)
(12.73)
84
-0.44
0.13
0.43
0.22
-0.25
0.13
(5.68)
(1.68)
(6.14)
(3.14)
(3.45)
(1.79)
112
-0.26
0.57
0.64
0.83
0.11
0.47
(3.18)
(6.97)
(8.53)
(11.07)
(1.41)
(6.04)
140
0.10
0.63
0.86
1.11
0.64
1.13
(1.14)
(7.20)
(10.76)
(13.88)
(7.76)
(13.70)
a
Percentage heterosis in parentheses.
The estimates of direct and percentage heterosis for HG and HW are presented in Tables 5 and 6.
There was positive heterosis for HG in the crosses WAIxLW, WAIxLR, LWxWAI and LRxLW in
all ages studied, except at ages 112 and 140 days in LRxLW, ages 56 and 140 days in LWxWAI,
and age 56 days in WAIxLR crosses. The rest of the crosses (main cross) in cross 1 and 3 had
negative heterosis at all ages. For the HW, apart from the cross WAIxLR which had positive
heterosis in all the ages, the rest of the crosses had negative heterosis except for crosses LRxLW,
LWxWAI and WAIxLW which had positive heterosis at 56 days of age. Meanwhile, the
percentage heterosis ranged from 0.77% to 21.18% and 0.76% to 29.53% in HG and HW
respectively
Table 5: Estimates of Direct and Percentage Heterosisa for Heart Girth between 56 – 140 days.
Cross 1
Cross 2
Cross 3
Age
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
(Days)
LWxLR
LRxLW
LWxWAI
WAIxLW
LRxWAI
WAIxLR
56
-6.45
0.58
-1.79
0.10
-8.09
-4.50
(16.10)
(1.45)
(4.88)
(0.27)
(21.18)
(11.78)
84
-2.15
3.20
2.09
5.73
-3.81
2.75
(5.08)
(7.57)
(5.49)
(15.73)
(9.47)
(6.83)
112
-9.50
-1.25
0.66
4.20
-6.13
6.09
(18.81)
(2.48)
(1.50)
(9.57)
(12.79)
(12.71)
140
-9.20
-1.30
-2.79
4.83
-1.28
7.25
(17.02)
(2.41)
(5.75)
(9.96)
(2.64)
(14.95)
a
Percentage heterosis in parentheses.
47
Table 6: Estimates of Direct and Percentage Heterosisa for Height at Withers between 56 – 140
days
Cross 1
Cross 2
Cross 3
Age
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
(Days)
LWxLR
LRxLW
LWxWAI
WAIxLW
LRxWAI
WAIxLR
56
-2.32
3.10
3.93
3.44
-0.22
5.70
(7.30)
(9.75)
(14.15)
(12.38)
(0.76)
(19.66)
84
-9.66
-4.63
-0.84
-0.63
-8.08
5.95
(21.70)
(10.40)
(2.25)
(1.68)
(19.56)
(14.41)
112
-12.61
-11.47
-3.03
-3.65
-8.44
13.88
(24.47)
(22.26)
(6.58)
(7.93)
(17.96)
(29.53)
140
-11.06
-7.02
-2.29
-0.44
-5.64
12.38
(20.58)
(13.06)
(4.87)
(0.94)
(11.57)
(25.39)
a
Percentage heterosis in parentheses.
The estimates of direct and percentage heterosis for SL and BL are presented in Tables 7 and 8. SL
had positive heterosis in main and reciprocal crosses of cross 3 in all ages studied, while the rest of
the crosses had negative heterosis except at day 56 where no heterosis was recorded in LWxWAI.
For BL, all the crosses had positive heterosis in all the ages studied, except in ages 112 and 140
days for LRxLW and LWxWAI, and day 112 of WAIxLW crosses. The rest of the crosses had
negative heterosis in all the ages studied. Meanwhile, the percentage heterosis ranged from 0% to
13.59% and 0.76% to 19.66% in SL and BL respectively.
Table 7: Estimates of Direct and Percentage Heterosisa for Snout Length between 56 – 140 days.
Cross 1
Cross 2
Cross 3
Age
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
(Days)
LWxLR
LRxLW
LWxWAI
WAIxLW
LRxWAI
WAIxLR
56
-0.88
-0.15
0.00
-0.11
0.29
0.05
(13.23)
(2.26)
(0.00)
(1.83)
(4.72)
(0.81)
84
-0.49
-0.20
-0.33
-0.35
0.62
0.95
(6.16)
(2.52)
(4.78)
(5.07)
(8.79)
13.48
112
-1.33
-1.04
-1.12
-0.88
0.22
1.08
(13.59)
(10.62)
(13.10)
(10.29)
(2.54)
(12.46)
140
-0.90
-0.05
-0.73
-0.41
0.43
0.53
(8.96)
(0.50)
(7.85)
(4.41)
(4.60)
(5.67)
a
Percentage heterosis in parentheses.
48
Table 8: Estimates of Direct and Percentage Heterosisa for Body Length between 56 – 140 days.
Cross 1
Cross 2
Cross 3
Age
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
Main
Reciprocal
(Days)
LWxLR
LRxLW
LWxWAI
WAIxLW
LRxWAI
WAIxLR
56
-2.32
3.10
3.93
3.44
-0.22
5.70
(7.30)
(9.75)
(14.15)
(12.38)
(0.76)
(19.66)
84
-2.15
3.20
2.09
5.73
-3.81
2.75
(5.08)
(7.57)
(5.49)
(15.73)
(9.47)
(6.83)
112
-1.33
-1.04
-1.12
-0.88
-0.22
1.08
(13.59)
(10.62)
(13.10)
(10.29)
(2.54)
(12.46)
140
-9.20
-1.30
-2.79
4.83
-1.28
7.25
(17.02)
(2.41)
(5.75)
(9.96)
(2.64)
(14.95)
a
Percentage heterosis in parentheses.
The positive direct heterosis of BW reported for LRxLW and LRxWAI, implies that there was an
increase in BW as a result of the crossbreeding in favour of the cross performance. This indicates
that for the particular crosses, non-additive effects of genes could be exploited through
crossbreeding to bring about genetic improvement for BW at 56 days. This finding contradicts
existing knowledge that BW and conformation traits in farm animals are generally highly heritable,
implying that rapid genetic improvement could be brought about by selection and exploitation of
additive effects of genes, rather than crossbreeding (Ibe et al., 2005). The result obtained could be
due to maternal effects of LW and WAI sows, since the main and reciprocal crosses – LWxLR and
WAIxLR yielded negative heterosis for body weight at 56 days or could be due to influence of LR
as sire at this age. This result is similar to those presented by Young et al. (1976), who obtained
significant positive estimates of heterosis for litter weights at 42 days of 20.7% for Duroc(D) x
Yorkshire (Y), 20.40% for D x Hampshire (H) and 6.00% for H x Y crosses; and by Schneider
(1978) who found significant positive heterosis of 20.40% for litter weight at 56 days in
Chesterwhite (CW) x D crosses and of 25.70% for D x H crosses at 56 days. For litter weight at
154 days, he found heterosis rates of 21.20, 22.00 and 27.10% for CW x H, CW x Y and CW x D
crosses, respectively. According to Johnson (1981), heterosis estimates for litter weight at 21 days
are highly variable but part of this variation is because similar crosses produce different estimates in
independent experiments. Johnson (1980) reported a positive average heterosis of 9.4 and 2.5% for
ADG (age at 56 days) and carcass average back fat thickness (CABT), respectively. McLaren et al.
(1987) reported a highly significant (P<0.01) individual heterosis estimates for post-weaning
performance traits and reasonably consistent trend between crosses of Duroc x Yorkshire, Duroc x
Landrace, Duroc x Spotted breeds respectively; although the positive estimates reported in this
study is obtained at pre-weaning BW stage of growth.
The negative heterosis for BW in all other crosses from ages 56 to 140 days is expected and
indicates that for these crosses, additive effects of genes could best be exploited, through selective
breeding, for rapid genetic improvement in BW (Ibe et al., 2005). Heterosis could subsequently be
exploited by crossing different lines that had been improved by within-line selection. Medellin and
Lukefar (2001) reported negative heterosis of -9.3 for market weight in rabbits. Schneider (1978)
did not find a significant effect of heterosis on litter size from birth to the end of growth period,
although the estimated heterosis presented by Smith and King (1964), O’Ferrall et al. (1968),
Bereskin et al. (1974) and Young et al. (1976) was numerically higher than that found by Silva et al.
(1996). The total heterosis according to Silva et al. (1996) was not a significant source of variation
for the BW at 21, 35 and 77 days of age in crosses involving Duroc, Landrace, Yorkshire and Large
White breeds of pigs.
The implication of positive heterosis on morphometric traits is that exploitation of non-additive
gene action, through crossbreeding, could bring about more rapid genetic improvement for EL, TL,
49
HG, HW, SL and BL than selective breeding. The finding of positive heterosis in some cases
contradicts existing knowledge that body weight and conformation traits in farm animals are
generally highly heritable, implying that rapid genetic improvement could be brought about by
selection and exploitation of additive effects of genes, rather than crossbreeding (Ibe et al., 2005).
Ozimba and Lukefahr (1991) reported positive heterosis for linear body measurements in
Californinan x New Zealand White crossbred than for parental purebreds. Khan and Lukefahr
(1996) reported positive heterosis of 10.5% for post-weaning litter weight. Chineke et al., (2002)
reported that New Zealand White x Dutch-belted crossbred recorded best performance in heart
girth, height at withers and body length at pre-weaning ages of 7 and 21 days and at post-weaning
age of 56 days. However, the positive heterosis obtained for EL, TL, HG, HW, SL and BL could
not be explained based on maternal effects as is the case with BW, since the observed heterotic
effect was shown by crosses involving different breeds of dam.
CONCLUSION
Crosses LRxLW and LRxWAI exhibited positive heterosis while others recorded negative heterosis
for BW. The LBMs exhibited both positive and negative heterosis at different ages in different
crosses. It is therefore recommended that in a cross-breeding programme involving these three
breeds of swine – LW, LR and WAI breeds, the cross involving LR males and LW females will
give the best performance in terms of growth traits measured, followed by the cross involving WAI
males on LW females, and lastly using LR males on WAI females.
The WAI x LW and LR x WAI crosses had exhibited performance closest to exotic crosses which
shows the high level of performance attainable when the WAI germplasm with its adaptational
qualities is introduced into the exotic germplasm. The exotic breeds which are highly productive
with well developed characteristics, are highly susceptible to stress and diseases in the tropical
rainforest environment. Therefore, in a crossbreeding programme with the aim of improving the
WAI pigs; adopting the WAI x LW and LR x WAI crosses will ensure better performance in terms
of growth traits measured, thereby improving the genetic potential of the WAI pigs while
conserving its valuable adaptation characteristics
REFERENCES
Adebambo, O. A. (1986). Pig improvement and development in the tropics: the application of
breeding and genetics. Proceedings of the International Seminar on Pig Production in the
Tropics, University of Nigeria, Nsukka. February, 1986.
Almeida, E. Silva, M. , Sancevero, A. B., Rafael, G. O., Antonio, L. G., Paulo, S. L. and Robert,
A. A. (1996). Effect of type of cross on litter size and litter weight of purebred and
crossbred swine. Brazilian Journal of Genetics, 19 (2) 249-258.
Bereskin, B. and Hetzer, H. O. (1986). Genetic and Maternal effects on pig weights, growth and
probe backfat in Diallel crosses of High and Low-fat lines of swine. J. of Animal Science,
63: 395-408.
Bereskin, B., Hetzer, H. O., Peters, W. H. and Norton, H. W. (1974). Genetic and maternal effects
on pre-weaning traits in crosses on high and low-fat lines of swine. J. Anim. Sci., 39:1-10.
Buchanan, S. D., Luce, W. G. and Clutter, A. C. (2005). Swine breeding systems. Oklahoma
Cooperative Extension Service ANSI-3603.
Chineke, C. A., Agaviezor, B., Ikeobi C. O. and Ologun, A. G. (2002). Some factors affecting
bodyweight and measurements of rabbits at pre- and post-weaning ages. In: Proc. 27th
Annual Conf., Nig. Soc. for Anim. Prod. V. A. Aletor and G. E. Onibi (Eds.). Pp. 1-4.
Dickerson, G. E. (1992). Manual for evaluating breeds and crosses of domestic animals.
Publication DIV, FAO, Rome, Italy.
Durrant, A. (1965). Analysis of reciprocal differences in diallel crosses. Heredity 20: 573-607.
Griffing, B. (1956). Concept of general and specific combining ability in relation to diallel
crossing systems. Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 9: 465-493.
50
Ibe, S. N., Obasi, V. N., Ojewola, G. S, and Nwachukwu, E. N. (2005). Heterosis and reciprocal
effects for growth traits in crosses of New Zealand White, Dutch and Chinchilla breeds of
rabbits. Nig. J. Anim. Prod., 32(2): 191 – 197.
Johnson, R. K. (1980). Heterosis and breed effects in swine. North Central Regional Pub. 262.
Agr. Exp. Sta., Univ. of Nebraska, Lincoln.
Johnson, R. K. (1981). Crossbreeding in swine: Experimental results. J. Anim. Sci., 52: 906-923.
Khan, M. A. and Lukefahr, S. D. (1996). Breed-type comparisons for post weaning litter trait in
rabbits. In: Proc. 6th World Rabbit Cong. Toulouse, France, Pp. 299-304.
Mather, K. and Jinks, J. L. (1982). Biometrical Genetics. Chapman and Hall, London.
McLaren, D. G, Buchanan, D. S. and Johnson, R. K. (1987). Individual heterosis and breed
effects for post weaning performance and carcass traits in four breeds of swine. J. Anim.
Sci., 64: 83–98.
Medellin, M. N. and Lukefahr, S. D. (2001). Breed and heterotic effect on post weaning traits in
Altex and New Zealand White straight and crossbred rabbits. J. Anim. Sci., 79: 1173 –
1178.
O’Ferrall, G. J. M, Hetzel, H. D. and Gaines, J. A. (1968). Heterosis in preweaning traits of
swine. J. Anim. Sci., 27: 17-21.
Obasi, V. N. and Ibe, S. N. (2008). Influence of additive and non-additive gene effects on body
measurements in the domestic rabbits. Nigerian Journal of Animal Production 35(1): 1-8.
Okoro, V. M. O, Ogundu U. E., Kadurumba O., Iloeje M. U., Okoro C. L., Nosike R. J., and S. N.
Ibe (2012a). Genetic variations in locally adapted turkeys. 1. Additive and non-additive
genetic effects on growth traits. Genomics and Quantitative Genetics, 4: 1 – 7.
Ozimba, C. E. and Lukefahr, S. D. (1991). Comparison of rabbit breed-type for post weaning
litter growth , feed efficiency and survival performance traits. J. Anim. Sci., 69: 3494 –
3500.
Schneider, J. F. (1978). Individual and maternal heterosis estimated from single-crosses and
backcrosses of swine. Ph.D. Thesis, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa, pp. 128.
Smith, C. and King, J. W. B. (1964). Crossbreeding and litter production in British pigs. Anim.
Prod., 6: 265-271.
Topham, P. B. (1966). Diallel analysis involving maternal and paternal interaction effects.
Heredity, 21: 665-674.
Virk, D. S., Khehra, A. S., Virk, P. S. and Dhillon, B. S. (1985). Comparative genetic analysis of
metric traits using diallel and factorial designs in bread wheat. Theor. Appl. Genet., 69:
325-328.
Wearden, S. (1964). Alternative analyses of the diallel cross. Heredity, 19: 669-680.Young, L.
D., Johnson, R. K. and Omtvedt, I. T. 1976. Reproductive performance of swine bred to
produce purebred and two-breed cross litters. J. Anim. S
AGB02
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS (ELISA) OF DIFFERENT BREEDS OF ASF RECOVERED
PIGS AND THEIR OFFSPRING
Adeoye, A.A.1*, Rotimi, E.A.2, Ajayi, B.A.3, Olugasa, B.O.4, Ikeobi, C.O.N.5 and Adebambo,
O.A.5
1
Department of Biological Sciences, Ondo State University of Science and Tech., Okiti-Pupa,
Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Breeding and Physiology University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria.
3
Department of Animal Science Landmark University, Omuaran, Kwara State, Nigeria.
4
Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria.
51
5
Department of Animal Breeding and Genetics, Federal University of Agriculture, Abeokuta,
Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: adeomo@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Data on serological test were collected from eight sows and two boars, (4 Large White sows, 2
Large Black sows, 2 Duroc sows, 1 Large White boar and 1NigerHyb boar) which are survivors of
the African Swine Fever (ASF) outbreak in a farm at Abeokuta, Nigeria, in 2005). From these, fiftytwo (52) pigs were generated in the F1 and sixty (60) pigs in the F2 generation, respectively. The
pigs were used to determine the presence of ASF antibody. The serological test for determining the
presence of ASF antibody showed that all the ASF recovered pigs tested positive while 18.79% of
the F1 and 6.25% of the F2 pigs tested equally positive.
INTRODUCTION
African Swine Fever (ASF) disease can be confused with several other diseases. The differential
diagnosis of ASF is implicated in the following five diseases namely: Hog cholera, haemorrhagic
septicaemia encephalomycarditis of pigs, trypanosomosis and anthrax (FAO, 2000). The disease
can be confirmed and differentiated from other diseases by conducting virus isolation and
characterization detection of genuine DNA by PCR and serological test such as immunoblotting
assay and Enzyme link immunosorbent Assay (ELISA). ELISA is a serological procedure that
involves detection of antibodies in the serum of ASF infected or recovered pigs. Antibodies against
ASF are detectable in serum 7 – 12 days after clinical signs appear (Blood et al., 1995) and persist
for long periods, possibly for life in both domestic pigs and warthongs. Significant effect of breeds
of pig on both productive and reproductive parameters has been reported (Adeoye and Adebambo
2010 and Adebambo, 1983).
The objective of this study was to determine the presence of ASF antibody in the serum of different
breeds of pigs that recovered from the menace and in the subsequent generations produced from the
recovered pigs.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was carried out at the piggery Unit, Teaching and Research Farm, Federal University of
Agriculture Abeokuta, Ogun State, Nigeria. A total of eight sows [4 – Large White (LW); 2 – Duroc
and 2 – Large Black (LB) and 2 boars (1–Large White and 1–NigerHyb. (NH)] that recovered from
ASF outbreak in 2005 were used for the study. The husbandry was intensive system whereby the
animals were housed permanently in pens and daily routine management practices and mating
carried out to produce F1 and F2 generations. Serum samples were collected from the recovered
pigs, F1 and F2 and subjected to ELISA Test to determine the presence of ASF antibody.
1st Phase
Mating System
LW x LW – LW
NH x LB – LB NH
2nd Phase
52
LW x LB NH = LBNHLW
LW x DNU = DNHLW\
LW – Large White; D – Duroc, LB – Large Black
NH – Niger Hyb.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The ELISA results on the recovered pigs showed that the optical density of Large White were
greater than 0.50 while that for Duroc Large Black and Niger Hyb were lower than 0.50. Table 4
showed that ten animals that survived the outbreak tested positive to ASF while 18.75% of their
offspring tested positive, 56.25% tested negative and 25% ambiguous. Among the F2 individuals,
6.2% tested positive, 62.5% tested negative and 31.25% ambiguous.
Table 1: Differential diagnosis of pig sera
Animal
No tested
No Tv
No -V
No undecided
Total
Foundation stock
10
10
10
F1
32
6(18.75%)
18(56.25%) 8(25%)
32
F2
32
2(6.25%)
20(62.5%)
10(31.25%)
32
Total
74
18
38
18
74
No Tv= number positive; No –V= number negative
The higher optical density observed in Large White pigs compared with other breeds that survived
the disease can be compared with the difference observed in productive and reproductive
parameters among different breeds of pigs (Adeoye and Adebambo, 2010; Adebambo, 1983). The
reduction in the percentage of pigs infected from recovered pigs to F2 generation indicates a
decrease in the shedding of the virus from the recovered pigs into the environment and subsequently
a reduction in the prevailing rate of exposure of other pigs to the virus within the environment. This
is to be expected because recovered pigs do continue to trap the virus within their tissues by the
activities of macrophages (that eat up pathogens are infected tissues so that other parts will not be
affected) and mast cells in the tissues. Together with the activities of the complement fixation
antibodies (CFA), the engulfed ASF virus particles that are shared in the urine and faeces of the
older pigs, originally infected by the virus drop significantly. This result agrees with the findings of
Olugasa (2007) who reported that the level of infection is higher among the older stock (75.3% 96.8%) than in younger stocks (13.8% - 39.7%). The result is also similar to findings of Fasina et
al. (2010) who reported decrease in the percentage of infected animals from 2006 to 2007 to 2008
across Sixteen States of Nigeria through serological test.
CONCLUSION
The study revealed variation in response to ASF infection among breeds of pigs and decline in the
number of pigs infected down the generation.
REFERENCES
Adebambo, O.A. (1983). Comparative growth and carcass performance of progenies sired by
purebred Large White and crossbred local and exotic Boars. Niger. J. Anim. Prod., 10(2): 124139.
Adeoye, A.A and Adebambo, O.A (2010). Evaluation of Litter Traits of Pigs in an African Swine
Fever (ASF) Prone Environment. Proceeding of 1st Nigeria International Pig Summit, 22-25
November, 2010. Pp. 114-123.
53
Blood, D.C., Radostitis, O.M. and Gay, C.L. (1995). Veterinary Medicine. A textbook of the
Diseases of Cattle Sheep, Pigs, Goat and Horses, 8h edition, Bailere Tindall U.K. Pp. 101–155.
FAO (2000). Recognizing African swine fever. A field manual. Empress – TransboundyAnim. Dis
Bull, No 9.
Fashina, F.O., Lazarus, D.D., Shamaki, D., Makinde, A.A., Lombin, L.H. and the ASF PITT
(2010). Field Surveilance and Laboratory Diagnoses of African Nigeria. 1st Nigerian
International Pig Summit, 22-25 November, 2010. Pp. 168-179.
Olusaga, B.O. (2007). Serological Evidence of African Swine Fever Virus Infection in commercial
pig herds in South West Nigeria. African Journal of Livestock Extension., volume 5 Pp 61-64.
AGB03
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BODY MEASUREMENT AND CARCASS
CHARACTERISTICS OF MUSCOVY DUCKS USING CANONICAL CORRELATION
ANALYSIS
Babatunde, O.1*, Dim, N.I.1 and Ogah, D.M.2
1*
Department of Animal Breeding and Physiology, College of Animal Science, University of
Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria.
1
Department of Animal Breeding and Physiology, College of Animal Science, University of
Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Nasarawa State University, Keffi, ShabuLafia Campus, Lafia, Nigeria.
*Corresponding email: babatundetunji@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
One hundred and twenty (120) seven-day old Muscovy ducklings were collected around Lafia
metropolis for the experiment. The ducks were reared under semi-intensive system for 20 weeks.
Body measurements (body length, breast bone, chest width, shank length, shank circumference and
beak length) were taken at week 20, after which the ducks were slaughtered and carcass parameters
(slaughter weight, pluck weight, eviscerated weight, breast muscle weight, leg muscle weight, heart
weight, liver weight, spleen weight, gizzard weight and proventriculus) were taken. The data were
generated according to sex and subjected to Canonical Correlation Analysis. The result showed
significant (P<0.01) correlation between the two character sets having canonical correlation
coefficient of 0.88 representing 77.71% of the population.
Keywords: Muscovy ducks, body measurements, carcass, canonical correlation
INTRODUCTION
Poultry in Nigeria has been growing at an average annual rate of 1.6 percent compared to the
average human population growth of about 3 percent, while on the average Nigerians consume only
about 10 grams of animal protein in a day as against the recommended 35 grams estimated
requirement for normal healthy living (www.poultrysitenewsdesk.com, August, 2009). This implies
that Nigerians need to triple their animal protein intake.
In pursuance of the above, this research seek to evaluate carcass characteristics of Muscovy ducks
at 20 weeks of age and also to evaluate the canonical correlation amongst body measurement and
54
carcass characteristics of Muscovy ducks at 20 weeks of age. The results of this research provide
information which will serve as a frame work for the development of selection criteria for
improving the performance traits that will be needed in Muscovy duck production (growth and meat
yield).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The ducks were housed in open sided pens partitioned into 10 rooms to house 12 ducks per room.
Each room measured 250 x 400cm. The pens also have an extended run for the ducks to bask and
feed on green vegetation as prescribed by Nickolova (2004).
The ducklings were collected at a week old, irrespective of sex, randomly from different locations
and villages of Lafia Local Governments of Nasarawa State. 120 ducklings were collected thereby
making allowance for 5% mortality due to the shock of snatching from their mothers.
Kitchen residue, wet meal residue of beans, maize and other grains were collected while fresh and
immediately given to the ducks. Properly dried forms of the residues mentioned above were also
used when available.
The morphological data were generated at week 20 where linear body size measurements (body
length, breast bone, chest width, shank length, shank circumference and beak length) were taken
before slaughtering; while carcass data (slaughter weight, pluck weight, eviscerated weight, breast
muscle weight, leg muscle weight, heart weight, liver weight, spleen weight, gizzard weight and
proventriculus) were obtained when the animals were slaughtered. On the whole 19 variables were
generated for the two sets.
For better understanding of sex continuum, the data for drakes and hens were analysed separately.
The data were then subjected to Principle of Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA) developed by
Hotelling in 1935 (Wood and Erskine, 1976).
RESULTS
TABLE 1: CORRELATIONS BETWEEN BODY MEASUREMENTS AND CARCASS
CHARACTERISTICS AT 20 WEEKS OF AGE FOR MUSCOVY HENS
BL
1
0.48*
0.58**
BL
BB
BWD
LL
TWD
BKL
SWT
CCAS
DWT
HRT
EWT
SPLN
CCAS
LIVA
HRT
LINT
SPLN
GZD
LIVA
AWT
LINT
LWT
GZD
KDNY
AWT
LWT
KDNY
0.26*
0.92**
0.55*
CCAS
0.76*
1.00
0.99**
0.70*
0.61**
0.37*
0.39*
0.93**
0.93**
0.68**
0.38*
0.32*
0.70**
0.34*
0.27*
0.82**
0.64*
0.30*
0.39*
0.63**
0.41*
BB
BWD
1
0.30*
1
0.98**
0.95**
0.34*
HRT
0.82**
0.92**
1.00
0.88**
0.38*
0.85**
0.16*
0.98**
0.93**
0.46*
0.54*
0.79**
0.99**
0.58**
0.04*
0.49*
0.25*
0.42*
0.75**
0.82**
0.68*
0.67**
0.38*
SPLN
0.44*
0.74**
0.29*
1.00
0.27*
0.26*
0.2*
0.26*
0.97**
0.45*
0.42*
0.23*
0.83**
0.45*
0.43*
0.36*
0.22*
0.29*
0.91**
LL
TWD
BKL
SWT
DWT
1
0.46*
0.61**
LIVA
0.35*
0.29*
0.43*
0.34*
1.00
0.36*
0.26*
0.31*
0.37*
0.26*
0.97**
0.58**
0.82*
0.89**
0.31*
0.68**
0.35*
0.56**
1
0.58**
LINT
0.96**
0.99**
0.89**
0.88**
0.31*
1.00
0.43*
0.86**
0.26*
0.99**
0.27*
0.41*
0.37*
0.87**
0.45*
0.41*
0.27*
1
0.44GZD
0.57**
0.27*
0.03*
0.44*
0.64**
1.00
0.31*
0.20**
0.38*
0.34*
0.24*
0.78**
0.31*
0.02*
0.26*
1 AWT
0.98*
0.91*
0.86*
0.80*
0.78**
0.23*
0.26*
1.00
0.28*
0.46*
0.93**
0.42*
0.27*
0.05*
1
0.89*
0.83*
0.78*
0.58**
0.37*
0.29*
0.45*1.00
0.30*
0.92**
0.26*
0.41*
LWT
level ** = correlation is significance at the 0.05 level
BL = Body length
TWD = Thigh width EWT = Eviscerated weight
LIVA = Liver length LWT = Leg weight
BKL = Beak length CCAS = Carcass weight
LINT = Length of intestine
KDNY = Kidney weight
SWT = Slaughter weight
HRT = Heart weight GZD = Gizzard weight
LL = Length of leg
DWT = Dressed weight
SPLN = Spleen weight
AWT = Arm weight
EWT
KDNY
1
0.92*
0.62*
0.91**
0.39*
0.34*
0.32*
1.00
0.65**
0.32*
0.03*
*=
correlatio
n
is
significance
at the 0.05
BB = Body width
BWD = Body width
From table 1 above, the highest correlation between body measurement and carcass characteristics
for Muscovy hens was observed between thigh width and dressed weight; and between arm weight
and heart weight, both having the correlation value of 0.99 at 0.01 level of significance.
Table 2: Pearson Correlation Analysis of Body Measurements and Carcass Characteristics at Week
20 for Muscovy Drakes
BB
BWD
LL
TWD
BKL
SWT
55
DWT
EWT
BB
BWD
LL
TWD
BKL
SWT
DWT
EWT
CCAS
HRT
SPLN
LIVA
LINT
GZD
AWT
LWT
KID
CCAS
HRT
SPLN
LIVA
LINT
GZD
AWT
LWT
KID
1.00
0.62*
0.70**
0.59*
0.66*
0.21*
0.36*
0.47*
0.4*
0.42*
0.34*
0.13*
0.31*
0.13*
0.72**
0.32*
0.35*
1.00
0.67**
0.64**
0.38*
0.55**
0.53**
0.58**
0.80**
0.80**
0.77**
0.11*
0.32*
0.12*
0.52**
0.57**
0.54*
CCAS
1.00
0.94*
0.10*
0.30*
0.86**
0.46*
0.77**
0.89*
0.42*
1.00
0.73*
0.33*
0.86**
0.89**
0.82**
0.64**
0.50**
0.34
0.95**
0.95**
0.68**
0.95**
0.43
0.93**
1.00
0.47*
0.59**
0.87**
0.98**
0.80**
0.67**
0.43*
0.35*
0.96**
0.49*
0.62**
0.52**
0.60**
1.00
0.75**
0.83**
0.62**
0.77**
0.96**
0.96**
0.52**
0.97**
0.60**
0.31*
0.82**
0.78**
HRT
SPLN
LIVA
LINT
GZD
AWT
LWT
KID
1.00
0.15
0.32
0.74**
0.40*
0.59**
0.89*
0.53**
1.00
0.58**
0.37*
0.40*
0.34*
0.10*
0.95**
1.00
0.87**
0.30*
0.26*
0.29*
0.30*
1.00
0.2*
0.12*
0.42*
0.26*
1.00
0.48*
0.37*
0.71**
1.00
0.55**
0.27*
1.00
0.2*
1.00
1.00
0.89*
0.67*
0.79*
0.68**
0.57**
0.40*
0.66**
0.45*
0.56**
0.81*
0.12*
1.00
0.93*
0.95**
0.89*
0.35*
0.47*
0.94**
0.4*
0.75**
0.85*
0.49*
1.00
0.96**
0.92*
0.11*
0.37*
0.55**
0.57*
0.81**
0.78*
0.42*
From table 2
above, the highest correlation between body measurement and carcass characteristics in Muscovy drakes
First Set
Second Set
Cancorr. Coef.
Prop.
P.V.
is
Body
measurement
(7 Carcass characteristics (12
ʎ 1 = 0.881493
0.7771
0.0001
betwe
characters)
characters)
ʎ 2 = 0.705716
0.0865
0.4375
ʎ 3 = 0.632047
0.0925
0.6640
en
ʎ 4 = 0.599482
0.0097
0.8362
evisce
ʎ 5 = 0.532898
0.0098
0.9656
ʎ 6 = 0.342313
0.0099
0.9365
rated
ʎ 7 = 0.233568
0.0145
0.9509
weigh
t and
thigh width which is 0.97 at 0.01 level of significance.
TABLE 3: The Canonical Correlation Analyses between Body Measurement and Carcass
Characteristics at Week 20 for Muscovy Hens
Cancorr. Coef. = Canonical Correlation Coefficient represented by ʎ
Prop. = Proportion, it can be converted into percentage by multiplying directly with 100
P.V. = probability value
From table 3 above it can be observed that the highest canonical correlation coefficient between
body measurement and carcass characteristics is 0.881493 representing 77.71% of the total
population.
TABLE 4: Canonical Variants for Significant Correlation between Body Measurement and Carcass
Characteristics for Muscovy Hens
Character
Formation of Canonical Variant
Body measurement and carcass characteristics
V1 = 0.0043X1 + 0.20X2 + 0.18X3 – 0.0068X4 + 0.19X5 + 0.047X6 + 0.50X7
W1 = 0.013X8 – 0.024X9 + 0.0084X10 + 0.0052X11 – 0.56X12 + 0.025X13 –
0.0043X14 + 0.0034X15 + 0.037X16 – 0.021X17 – 0.011X18 + 0.0044X19
In table 4 above, the highest contributor to the canonical significance in the body measurement
set of variable was beak length while the least was thigh width. In the carcass character set, it
56
was observed that gizzard weight had the highest contribution while heart weight had the least
contribution.
TABLE 5: The Canonical Correlation Analysis between Body Measurement and Carcass
Characteristics for Muscovy Drakes
From table 5 above, it can be seen that the highest canonical coefficient between body
measurement and carcass characteristics for Muscovy drakes was 0.851171 representing 56%
of the total population while the least was 0.683582 representing 0.13% of the population.
TABLE 6: Canonical Variants for Significant Correlation between Body Measurement and
Carcass Characteristics for the Drakes
Character
Body measurement and carcass characteristics
Formation of Canonical Variant
V1 = -1.04X1 + 298.18X2 + 243.75X3
– 1365.78X4 + 13.61X5 –
93.86X6 - 3039.10X7
W1 = 1.90X8 – 13.76X9 + 29.92X10
–9.60X11 + 174.35X12 –
0.0022X13 + 0.011X14 – 0.081X15 – 0.13X16 + 0.07X17 + 0.95X18 +
0.85X19
From table 6 above, the highest contributor to the function as observed in the body
measurement data set was body length and the least was beak length, and for the carcass
characteristics set, heart weight had the highest contribution while heart weight had the least.
DISCUSSION
In drakes the canonical correlation coefficients for body measurements and carcass characteristics
had significance of 0.851171 and total correlation proportion of 56.00% of the character set at 0.01
level of significance. This is lesser to that obtained in the hens where body measurement and
First Set
Body
measurement
characters)
Second Set
(7 Carcass characteristics (12
characters)
Cancorr. Coef.
Prop
P.V.
ʎ 1 = 0.851171
ʎ 2 = 0.706813
ʎ 3 = 0.668522
ʎ 4 = 0.382935
ʎ 5 = 0.253045
ʎ 6 = 0.961266
ʎ 7 = 0.683582
0.5600
0.1728
0.0367
0.0146
0.2135
0.0011
0.0013
0.0001
0.9821
0.9995
0.9954
0.9541
0.0013
0.1103
carcass characteristics had higher significance, 0.881493 representing 77.71% of the total
population.
Canonical variants corresponding to canonical correlation coefficient between characters in
Muscovy hens was shown in Table 2. For the first pair (V1 W1) of canonical variants. In V1,
beak length had the highest contribution followed by body length while within W1 gizzard
weight and spleen weight had the highest and the next highest contribution respectively.
The canonical variants corresponding to the canonical correlation coefficients between
characters in Muscovy drakes were presented in Table 4. Significant correlation between
body measurement and carcass characteristics V1 and W1, the highest canonical correlation
coefficient for V1 in the analysis of characters was for body length followed by breast bone, and
for the corresponding W1 heart weight and eviscerated weight had the highest and the next
highest contributor to the correlation between the characters set respectively.
Significance of the Results
In the hens it was observed from the result that beak length and body length were the most
important predictors of the carcass characteristics. This differs from that obtained for the drakes
where body length and breast bones were the most important predictors. This may be as a result
of the usage and roles they play in each sex at this age. It also indicated that more attention
should be paid to sex when it comes to the Muscovy ducks.
57
The results obtained by canonical correlation analysis demonstrated the main contradiction
among the multitudinous correlation variables and has reflected the correlative essence of two
character sets that could not be settled by the simple correlation. This is because often times,
other factors can influence simple correlation such that it only reflects the exterior, nonessential correlation.
CONCLUSION
The following conclusions can be drawn from the results obtained;
- From the results of canonical correlation and coefficients of canonical variant, it is
clear that there is significant morphological dimorphism in Muscovy ducks.
- In body measurement, for drakes, it was body length and breast bone that were the
highest contributors while it was beak length and body length that were the highest
contributors for hens.
- Within the carcass characteristics, heart weight was the highest contributor in drakes
while it was gizzard weight in hens.
REFERENCES
Adedokun, S. A., and Sonaiya, E.B. (2001). Comparison of the Performance of Nigerian
Indigenous Chicken from Three Agro-Ecological Zones of Nigeria. LRRD,
http.www.cipar.org.co/irrd.13/21aded132htm.
Etuk, I.F., Abasiekong, S.F., Ojewola, G.S. and Akomas, S.C. (2006). Carcass and organ
characteristics of Muscovy ducks reared under three management systems in Southeastern Nigeria. Intern. J. of Poult. Sc. 5(5):474-476.
Hassan, W.A. and Aliyu, A.T. (1996). Reproductive performance of duck in an arid northern
Nigeria. ANRPD newsletter 6(1)4-6.
Hotelling, H. (1936). Relations between two sets of variable Fes. Biomatrika, 28:321-377.
Mtui, D. and Mbaya, S.H. (2001). Performance Characteristics of Muscovy Duck under
Improve Management. http://www.ihh.kvl.dk/htm/php/tsap.
Mustafa, Y., Ferda, K., Muzeyyen, K., Ebru, E., and Ockerman, H.W. (2008). Canonical
Correlation Analysis of body measurements, growth performance and carcass traits of
Red Karaman Lambs. J. Animal and Veterinary Advances, 7(2):130-136.
National Research Council (1994). Nutrient requirements of poultry, 9th revised edition,
National Academic Press, Washington D.C.
Ogah, D.M., Musa, I.S., Yakubu, A., Momoh, M.O., and Dim, N.I. (2009). Variation in
morphological traits of geographical separated population of indigenous Muscovy duck
(Cairina moschata) in Nigeria. In: Proceeding of 5th inter. Poult. Conf. Taba, Egypt.
pp.46-52.
Sonaiya, E.B. (1997). ANRPD progress reports November, 1989-June, 1995. In: sustainable
rural poultry production in Africa. Ed. Sonaiya, E.B. Proceedings of an International
workshop. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. ANRPD. pp.134-143.
Wood, D.A. and Erskine, J.A. (1976). Strategies in Canonical Correlation with Application to
Behavioural Data Educational Psychological Measure, 36: 861-878.
www.poultrysitenewsdesk.com (August, 2009). Global Economic Crisis Hits Nigeria’s Poultry
Industry.
Yang, Y., Mekki, D.M., Lu, S.J., Yu, J.H., Wang, L.V., Wang, J.Y., Xie, K.Z. and Dai, G.J.
(2006). Body weight, body measurement and carcass characteristics of Jinghai yellow
chicken. J. Animal and Veterinary Advances 5(11): 980-984.
58
AGB04
BREED AND PARITY EFFECTS ON REPRODUCTIVE PERFORMANCE OF RABBITS
IN ZARIA, NIGERIA
Kabir, M.1*, Akpa, G.N.1, Nwagu, B.I.2 and Adeyinka, I.A.2
1
Genetics & Animal Breeding Unit, Department of Animal Science, Ahmadu Bello University,
Zaria, Nigeria
2
National Animal Production Research Institute (NAPRI) Shika, Zaria, Nigeria
*Corresponding e-mail: mkabir@abu.edu.ng
ABSTRACT
This research work was conducted to investigate the effect of breed and parity on the reproductive
performance of rabbits. A total of 48 adults (12 bucks and 36 does) were used and the parameters
considered included litter size at birth (LSB) and weaning (LSW), litter weight at birth (LWB) and
weaning (LWW), individual kit weight at birth (IKWB) and weaning (IKWW) and gestation length
(GL). Three breeds were used namely Chinchilla (CHC), New Zealand White (NZW) and
California White (CAW) and only three parities (first, second and third) were considered. Weaning
was done at 35 days of age. The results obtained revealed that breed significantly (P<0.05) affected
all the parameters studied except GL and WM. Among the three breeds used, CAW produced the
largest LSB (7.33±0.19) while CHC had the smallest LSB (6.05±0.29). The CHC breed had the
highest LWB (163.68±5.76g) while NZW had the lowest LWB (149.25±3.92g). IKWB was higher
(27.05±2.14g) in CHC breed than in the other two breeds. Gestation length and weaning mortality
were unaffected by breed. Parity significantly (P<0.05) affected all the tested reproductive
parameters except GL and WM. The results revealed significantly (P<0.05) higher values in the
third parity than in the first and second parities. It was concluded that CHC breed produced kits that
were heavier at birth (IKWB) and at weaning (IKWW) while CAW and NZW breeds produced
more number of kits per litter (LSB) than the CHC breed. Furthermore, third parity is recommended
for rabbit farmers in Zaria, Nigeria due to its benefits in terms of improved LSB, LSW, LWB and
lowered mortality as observed in the present study.
Key words: Breed, Parity, Rabbit, Zaria.
INTRODUCTION
Rabbit farming is becoming more and more attractive due to high reproductive potentials (Kabir et
al., 2012b), high mothering ability (Lukefahr and Cheeke, 1990; Kabir et al., 2012a), adaptability in
wide range of climatic conditions, high genetic variability (Kabir et al., 2011c), high roughage
utilization potentials (Iyeghe-Erakpotobor et al., 2009) and low cost of production (Aduku and
Olukosi, 1990). Moreover, detailed information about the effect of breed, effect of parity and effect
of mating frequency on the reproductive performance of rabbit in the Northern Guinea Savannah
zone of Nigeria is not available for commercial rabbit farming. Hence, the need for this study.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted at the Rabbitry Unit of the Teaching and Research Farm of the
Department of Animal Science, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria. Zaria is located between latitude
11o 30’N and longitude 12o 33’E and on altitude of 686 meters above sea level. Detailed description
of Zaria had been given by Kabir et al., 2011a).
59
Three breeds of rabbit were used namely Chinchilla (CHC), New Zealand White (NZW) and
California White (CAW), each having 12 adult females (does) and 4 adult males (bucks). The 36
does were in the age group of 7–8 months and weighed 2.25 to 2.45kg, while the 12 bucks belong to
the age category of 8–9 months and weighed 2.3 to 2.6kg. The mating plan adopted was as
described by Kabir et al. (2011b). There were three parities. Mashed concentrate diet was given at
100g in the morning and green roughage was supplied ad libitum in the afternoon. Composition of
feed was similar for all experimental rabbits and in accordance with specifications of Aduku and
Olukosi (1990): maize - 40%, maize offal - 22%, groundnut cake - 12%, soya bean meal – 18%,
trace ingredients - 5%, vitamin and mineral mixture - 2.5%, common salt - 0.5%. The proximate
composition of the diet was DM - 93.04, CP - 14.08, Ash - 7.12, EE - 10.33, CF - 10.64, NFE 57.83 and OM - 92.88%, respectively. Other routine management was the same. Feed was analyzed
regularly once a month as per standard method described in A.O.A.C. (1980).
Total of 185 data on different reproductive parameters recorded over 18 months (June 2007–
December 2008) on 48 rabbits were considered. The parameters included litter size at birth (LSB),
litter size at weaning (LSW), litter weight at birth (LWB), litter weight at weaning (LWW),
individual kit weight at birth (IKWB), individual kit weight at weaning (IKWW), gestation length
(GL) and weaning mortality (WM). The weight measurements were obtained using a digital scale
calibrated in grams (g).
The experiment followed a completely randomized design (CRD). The general linear model of SAS
(SAS, 2002) computer programme was used for computing ANOVA. Means were compared for
significant difference using the Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT) (Duncan, 1955).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Breed significantly (P<0.05) affected the reproductive performance of the rabbits (Table 1). The
CAW produced the largest LSB (7.33±0.19) with a corresponding LWB of 155.94±4.34g. This
agrees with the earlier submissions of Kabir et al. (2012b). The NZW rabbits gave a LSB of
6.89±0.25 weighing 149.25±3.92g, while CHC rabbits gave a LSB of 6.05±0.29 which had the
heaviest LWB of 163.68±5.76g. CAW had significantly (P<0.05) higher LSB than the CHC and
NZW rabbits, respectively. This result agrees with the reports of Irekhore (2007), who stated that
California breed produced higher litter size at birth than New Zealand White, New Zealand Black
and Flemish Giant breeds. Liang (1996) reported much higher LSB (7.50) and LWW (3.32 kg) in
NZW rabbits in China than the value obtained in this study. However, Rastogi (1996) reported
lower LSB (5.20) and LSW (4.30) in NZW rabbits in Trinidad.
Similar to the present findings Das et al. (2006) reported significantly (P<0.05) higher LSW and
LWW in the NZW rabbit than the Soviet Chinchilla; while Das and Bujarbarua (2005) found no
effect of breed on LWB. Iraqi et al. (2006) corroborated with this finding in respect of LSB (6.60)
and LSW (4.80) but contradicted with this finding in respect of LWB (429 g) and LWW (2.97 kg)
in the New Zealand White in Egypt. Though the LSB obtained in this study compares with the
report of Patial et al. (1991), it was higher than the report of Odubote and Akinokun (1991). The
range of 6.05-7.33 for LSB obtained herein is higher than the LSB values of 4.4 (Iyeghe et al.,
1996), 4.77 (Fayeye and Ayorinde, 2003), 5.8-6.61 (Irekhore, 2007), 4.27-5.33 (Zalla et al., 2007)
and 5.69 (Akpa and Alphonsus, 2008). It is also higher than other reported values in literature
(Ayorinde, 1997; Oseni et al., 1999; Akanno et al., 2004). The differences in literature values with
those obtained from this study could be attributed to the combined effects of breed and
environment; study location, nutrition, management and diseases (Kabir et al., 2011a). The CAW
rabbits recorded the least WM (20%) while CHC rabbits had the highest WM (24%).
60
Parity had significant (P<0.05) effect on all the reproductive parameters measured except GL. Litter
size at birth (LSB), LSW, LWB, LWW, IKWB and IKWW were significantly (P<0.05) higher in
the third parity than in the first and second parities (Table 2). This observation agrees with the
earlier reports in literature (Kabir et al., 2012b; Das and Yadav, 2007). Reporting further, Das and
Yadav (2007) argued that in the third parity due to maturity of doe more ova were released from the
ovary, hence more chance of increasing litter size at birth in third parity than first and second. The
present findings however, contradict earlier submissions of Das and Bujarbarua (2005), who
reported significant (P<0.05) effect of parity on LWB. Variation in milk production has also been
implicated (Paufler, 1985) whereby the NZW females produce less milk in their first lactation than
subsequent lactations. This has been advanced as another reason for the low weaning weights
observed in the litter of first parity does (Lukefahr et al., 1981). Average milk yield of a medium
heavy doe on ad lib concentrate feed was 250g over a four week period of lactation (Paufler, 1985).
Maximum daily milk yield is attained between the 18th and 23rd day after kindling and by the 42nd
day it amounts to only 30–40% of maximum yield (Paufler, 1985). All kits in this study were
weaned at 35 days postpartum, which was regarded early as compared to the weaning practices in
other conventional and commercial setups. Fortun-Lamothe et al. (2001) observed that early
weaning provides higher viability and faster growth in the weaned rabbits. The peak of milk
production in the rabbits is considered to be at the third week of lactation following the reports that
lactation increases until the end of the third week of lactation (Kustos et al., 1996; McNitt and
Lukefahr 1996). Generally, differences in the results obtained from this study with other literature
reports could be attributed to differences in breed, management and method of data analysis used.
CONCLUSION
The CAW and NZW rabbits produced higher LSB with a corresponding higher LWB than the CHC
rabbits. The CHC rabbits on the other hand, produced the heaviest kits in terms of IKWB and
IKWW. Therefore, if the interest of the rabbit farmer is higher LSB and LSW, then CAW and/or
NZW should be exploited. Otherwise, CHC is the best breed for individual kit weight at birth and
weaning. Rabbit farmers in the Northern Guinea Savannah zone of Nigeria could take advantage of
maturity in the third parity does in terms of improved LSB, LSW, LWB and lowered mortality as
revealed by the present study.
REFERENCES
Aduku, A. O. and Olukosi, J. O. (1990). Rabbit Management in the Tropics: Production,
processing, utilization, marketing, economics, research and future prospects. Living Books
Series, Abuja, Nigeria.
Akanno, E. C., Ibe, S. N. and Ogundu, U. E. (2004). Reproduction and preweaning litter
performance of different genotypes of locally adapted rabbit breeds. In: Proc. 29th Ann. Conf.
Genetics Society of Nigeria, University of Abeokuta, Pp 104-106.
Akpa, G. N. and Alphonsus, C. (2008). Relationship of parity with litter size and gestation length
and their repeatabilities in rabbits. In: Proc. 13th Ann. Conf. Animal Science Association of
Nigeria (ASAN), September 15-19, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria. Pp 76-77.
Ayorinde, K. L. (1997). Effects of some genetic and non-genetic factors on the reproductive and
preweaning growth performance of rabbits in South-Western Nigeria. Nigerian J. Genetics,
12:37-45.
A.O.A.C. (1980). Official Methods of Analysis, 13th edition. Association of Analytical Chemists
Washington DC, USA.
Das, S. K. and Bujarbarua, K. M. (2005). Effect of breed, generation, parity, season of mating, age
of dam at mating and kindling interval on litter weight at birth of rabbit. Pan American Rabbit
Science, 9(2):35-37.
61
Das, S. K., Das, A. and Bujarbarua, K. M. (2006). Productive performances, reproductive
performances, and carcass traits of broiler rabbit in different generations under agroclimatic
condition of Meghalaya. Indian J. Anim. Res., 40(1):38-41.
Das, S. K. and Yadav, B. P. S. (2007). Effect of mating system, parity and breed on the
Reproductive performances of broiler rabbits under the agro-climatic conditions of Meghalaya,
India. Livestock Research Rural Dev. 19:25, http://www.lrrd19/2/das19025.htm Accessed:
August 26, 2012.
Duncan, D. B. (1955). New Multiple Range and Multiple F-test. Biometrics. II:1-42.
Fayeye, T. R. and Ayorinde, K. L. (2003). Correlations between some weaning traits in domestic
rabbits in Nigeria. Nigerian J. Genetics, 18:63-67.
Fortun-Lamothe, L., Gidenne, T., Chalaye, F. and Debray, L. (2001). Feeding strategy around
weaning: Effect of dietary starch/fibre ration. In: Proc. 9th Journees de Recherché Cunicoles,
Paris 195-198.
Iraqi, M. M., Ibrahim, M. K., Hassan, N. S. H. and Deghadi, A. S. E. (2006). Evaluation of litter
traits in purebred and crossbred rabbits raised under Egyptian conditions. Livestock Research
Rural Dev. 18(6):83. http://www.cipav.org.co/lrrd/lrrd18/6/iraq18083.htm Accessed: June 18,
2012.
Irekhore, O. T. (2007). Reproductive performance of four breeds of rabbit in the tropics. In: Proc.
32nd Ann. Conf. Nigerian Society for Animal Production (NSAP), March 18-22, Calabar.
32:120-122.
Iyeghe-Erakpotobor, G. T., Sekoni, A. A. and Esievo, L. O. (2009). Nutrient intake and digestibility
of rabbit does fed varying levels of concentrates and lablab during pregnancy. Nigerian J.
Anim. Prod., 36(2):275-287.
Iyeghe, G. T., Abdulmalik, M. E., Osinowo, O. A., Adeyinka, I. A. and Nwagu, B. I. (1996).
Genetic and environmental factors affecting litter size, gestation length and weaning weight in
rabbits. J. Anim. Prod. Res., 15 & 16:81-89.
Kabir, M., Akpa, G. N., Nwagu, B. I., Adeyinka, I. A. and Bello, U. I. (2011a). Effect of breed, age
and sex on haematological traits of rabbits in the Northern Guinea Savannah zone of Nigeria. J.
Anim. Prod. Res. (JAPR), 24: 70-80. Publication of the National Animal Production Research
Institute (NAPRI), Shika, Zaria, Nigeria.
Kabir, M., Akpa, G. N., Nwagu, B. I., Adeyinka, I. A. and El-Inguini, N. (2011b). Evaluation of
mating frequency and the effects on litter performance in California white breed of rabbit. In:
Proc. 46th Ann. Conf. Science Association of Nigeria (SAN), 24–28 July, 2011. Ahmadu Bello
University, Zaria, Nigeria.
Kabir, M., Akpa, G. N., Nwagu, B. I. and Adeyinka, I. A. (2011c). Estimates of general and specific
combining abilities for litter traits in 3 x 3 diallel crossing of rabbits. In: Proc. 36th Ann. Conf.
Nigerian Society for Animal Production (NSAP), NUC/Raw Materials Research and
Development Council (RMRDC), March 13–16, 2011, Pp 39–41 Maitama, Abuja, Nigeria.
Kabir, M., Akpa, G. N., Nwagu, B. I. and Adeyinka, I. A. (2012a). Estimating additive and
dominance variance for litter traits in purebred California White kits using different models.
Nigerian Vet. J., 33(2): 448–454.
Kabir, M., Akpa, G. N., Nwagu, B. I. and Adeyinka, I. A. (2012b). Litter traits in diallel crossing of
three rabbit breeds in Northern Guinea Savannah zone of Nigeria. In: Proc. 10th World Rabbit
Congress, World Rabbit Science Association (WRSA), September 2 - 6, 2012, Page 69–74
Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt.
62
Kustos, K., Szendro, Zs., Csapa, J., Biro, H., Raindai, I., Biro-Nemth, E. and Balint, A. (1996).
Effect of lactation state and pregnancy status on milk production. In: Proc. 6th World Rabbit
Congress. Toulouse, France, 187-190.
Liang, Q. (1996). Evaluation of litter size traits: In: Proceeding of 6th World Rabbit Congress,
Toulouse, France, July 9-12 vol. 2 p.315 - 318.
Lukefahr, S. D., Honenboken, W. D., Cheeke, P. R. and Patton, N. M. (1981). Milk production and
litter growth traits in straight bred and crossbred rabbits. J. Appl. Rabbit Res., 4(2):35-40.
Lukefahr, S. D. and Cheeke, P. R. (1990). Rabbit Project Planning Strategies for developing
countries (1) Practical considerations. Livestock Research for Rural Development, 2(3):2
http://www.cipav.org.co/lrrd/lrrd2/3/cheeke1.htm Accessed: April 16, 2012
McNitt, J. I. and Lukefahr, S. D. (1996). Genetic and environmental parameters for post-weaning
growth traits of rabbits using an animal model. In: Proc. 6th World Rabbit Congress, World
Rabbit Science Association, Toulouse, France. Pp 325.
Odubote, I. K. and Akinokun, J. O. (1991). Reproductive and body weight performance of the New
Zealand White rabbits in the humid tropics of Nigeria. Nigerian J. Anim. Prod., 18:61-65.
Oguike, M. A. and Okocha, N. L. (2008). Reproductive performance of rabbits re-mated at different
intervals post-partum. African J. Agric. Res., 3(6):412-415.
Oseni, S. O., Odubote, I. K. and Akinokun, O. (1999). Evaluation of purebred and crossbred rabbits
for fertility and preweaning litter performance in the humid tropics. In: Proc. 24th Ann. Conf.
Nigerian Society for Animal Production (NSAP), Ilorin, March 22-25, Pp 62-65
Patial, K. K., Manuja, N. K., Gupta, K. and Sanjeet, K. (1991). The effect of season on litter size of
broiler rabbits in Himachal Pradesh, India. Indian J. Anim. Sci., Pp 51-55.
Paufler, S. (1985). Reproduction: A compendium of rabbit production appropriate for conditions in
developing countries. Schriftenreihe der GTZ, No. 169. Eschborn, 1985, Pp. 115-130.
Rastogi, R. K. (1996). Rabbit Production in experimental Rabbitry in Trinidad. In: the Proc. 6th
World Rabbit Congress, Toulouse, France, July 9-12 Vol.2, p.415-418.
SAS (2002). Statistical Analysis System, Computer Software, Version 9: Statistics SAS Institute
Inc. Cary, NC 27513, NC 27513, USA.
Szendro, Z. and Barna, J. (1984). Some factors affecting mortality of suckling and growing rabbits.
3rd World Rabbit Congress–Rome, Italy. 11:166-173.
Zalla, I. L., Hassan, W. A., Maigandi, S. A. and Daneji, A. I. (2007). Breed effect on litter traits in
rabbits in semi-Arid zone of Nigeria: Preliminary results. In: Proc. 32nd Ann. Conf. Nigerian
Society for Animal Production (NSAP), Calabar, 134-137.
Table 1: Effect of breed on reproductive performance of rabbits
Breed performance
Parameter
CHC
NZW
CAW
c
b
Litter size at birth (LSB)
6.05±0.29
6.89±0.25
7.33±0.19a
c
b
Litter size at weaning (LSW)
4.58±0.24
5.39±0.23
5.86±0.22a
Litter birth weight (LWB) (g)
163.68±5.76a
149.25±3.92b
155.94±4.34b
Litter weaning weight (LWW) (g)
1596.93±66.31 1764.05±64.36 1838.40±66.
C
b
22a
a
b
Individual Kit birth weight (IKWB) 27.05±2.14
21.66±1.61
21.27±1.39b
(g)
Individual Kit weaning weight 348.67±2.77a
327.28±2.14b
313.72±2.55c
63
(IKWW) (g)
Gestation length (GL) (days)
30.00±0.04b
29.02±0.02a
30.00±0.04b
c
b
Weaning mortality (WM) (%)
24.30±0.11
21.80±0.06
20.00±0.05a
SEM = Standard Error of Means; Figures having different superscripts in a row differ significantly
(P<0.05)
Table 2: Parity effect on reproductive performance of rabbit
Parameter
Litter size at birth (LSB)
Litter size at weaning (LSW)
Litter birth weight (LWB) (g)
Litter weaning weight (LWW) (g)
First
5.82±0.13c
4.69±0.03c
154.26±1.36c
1460.56±52.52
Parity
Second
6.59±0.08b
5.12±0.17b
183.41±2.11b
1577.89±61.58
c
b
c
Third
7.42±0.16a
6.44±0.14a
242.96±2.38a
2065.53±74.
82a
32.74±0.08a
Individual Kit birth weight (IKWB) 26.50±0.09
27.83±0.07b
(g)
Individual Kit weaning weight 311.42±2.57b
308.18±2.10b
320.73±2.05a
(IKWW) (g)
Gestation length (GL) (days)
29.02±0.03
29.05±0.14
29.05±0.06
Weaning mortality (WM) (%)
19.41b
22.30c
13.20a
SEM = Standard Error of Means; Figures having different superscripts in a row differ significantly
(P<0.05)
AGB05
GENETIC PARAMETERS OF HYLA F1 NEW ZEALAND PUREBRED RABBITS USING
ANIMAL MODELS
Akinsola, O.M.1*, Nwagu, B.I.2, Orunmuyi, M.1, Shoyombo, A.J.1, Adeyinka, I.A.2, Abanikannda,
O.T.F.3 and Yakubu, A.4
1
Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Kaduna
State, Nigeria.
2
National Animal Production Reseach Institute, Shika, Kaduna State, Nigeria.
3
Department of Zoology, Faculty of Science, Lagos State University, Ojo, Nigeria
4
Department of Animal Science,, Faculty of Agriculture, Nasarawa State University, Keffi, ShabuLafia Campus, Lafia, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: dayoakinsola@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Data on kit weight at different ages of 74 F1 progeny Hyla purebred New Zealand White rabbits
were analyzed to provide estimates of genetic parameters such as heritability, repeatability, genetic
and phenotypic correlations. Genetic analysis was estimated using the least square mixed model
likelihood and mean weight procedure of Harvey algorithm programme. Heritability estimates of
0.53±0.32, 0.39±0.29, 0.64±0.35, 0.99±0.41, 1.30±0.44 and 0.89±0.39 were obtained for individual
kit weight at preweaning ages (birth, 7, 14, 21, 28 and 35 days, respectively). Repeatability
64
estimates were found to be generally moderate to high. Genetic and phenotypic correlations were
positive and moderate to high. The genetic trends for kit weights suggested that mass selection of
litters at preweaning ages will be more effective in the improvement of growth traits.
Keywords: Rabbit, kit, heritability, repeatability, correlations,
INTRODUCTION
Hyla rabbits are pedigree breed used to produce grandparent male and female lines for
multiplication farms or grand-parent pool in production farms. Estimation of genetic parameters are
primordial to the establishment of strategies to be used in Hyla rabbit breeding programmes and the
evaluation of response to selection for traits and genetic associations among traits. The
understanding of genetic architecture of traits such as growth and body composition has become a
primary focus for agricultural and biomedical research (Terčič and Holcman, 2008). The two main
tools for genetic improvement are selection and mating system. In order to employ these tools,
however, baseline information on genetic parameters -heritability, repeatability, genetic and
phenotypic correlations must be determined. The baseline information of the genetic parameters
will serve as a guide that enables breeders to decide on the best method of selection to achieve rapid
genetic progress. Khalil et al. (1988) reported that estimates of heritability for bodyweight were
highest at younger ages, declining to the lowest values after weaning and increasing again at older
ages in rabbits. Estimates of repeatability for growth traits were reported to be moderate at
preweaning ages (Ndjon and Nwakalor, 1998). However, without the knowledge of genetics of
imported exotic rabbits population such as Hyla New Zealand purebreds, planned improvement of
meat rabbits in Nigeria would be limited. Therefore, this study was undertaken to estimate the
heritability, repeatability, genetic and phenotypic correlations of Hyla New Zealand White purebred
rabbits under the tropical conditions of Zaria, Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted in the Rabbitry of the National Animal Production Research Institute
(NAPRI), Shika, Zaria. Shika is located in the Northern Guinea Savannah zone of Nigeria, on
latitude 110 12’ of the equator and longitude 70 33’ with altitude of about 610mm.
All the rabbits were housed in metallic cages and fed ad libitum with pelletized ration containing 20
% crude protein and 2800 kcal ME/Kg. Tridax procumbens was also fed as supplementary ration.
Vitamin C was added to the drinking water during the hot period. Matings were carried out early in
the morning. Inbreeding was avoided in the herd using pedigree information as a guide.
Data on F1 kit weight were collected at birth, 7, 14, 21, 28 and 35 days respectively using a
sensitive metallic scale. The data was analyzed using the least square mixed model likelihood and
mean weight procedure of Harvey (Harvey, 1990).
Yijkl = µ + B1 + Sj + eijk
Yijkl = Observation on Kth litter from jth sire in ith breed
µ = Overall population mean
B1 = effect of ith breed (i= New Zealand white purebred rabbits)
B:Sj = effect of jth sire of the ith breed
eijk = random error
Genetic analysis was computed using the sire variance:
Heritability model
4 s2
2
h
2
h
T
2
= heritability estimate
65
S2
2
T
= variance due to sire
= total variance
Repeatability was estimated as the ratio of variances by summing genetic and permanent
environmental variances to phenotypic variance:
t= σ2s + σ2pe
σ2s + σ2pe+ σ2e
2
σ s = variance due to additive effect
σ2pe = variance due to permanent environmental effect
σ2e = error variance
The repeatability model employed was as follows:
Yijkl = u + Bi+ Pl+ Dij+ eijk
Yijkl = animal record
µ = the population mean
Bi = random effect of ith sire
Pl = fixed effect of Ith parity (I = 3)
Dij = random effect of jth doe nested within ith sire
eijk = random deviation of kth litter of jth doe and ith sire, assumed to be independently and randomly
distributed (0, 1).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The least squares analysis for the bodyweight are shown in Table 1. The average bodyweight at
birth to weaning ranged from 57.97 ± 1.41 - 744.94± 16.66g. The heritability estimates were
moderate to high which ranged from 0.39 ± 0.29 - 1.30 ± 0.44. The repeatability estimates were also
moderate to high for all the traits (Table 2). Genetic and phenotypic correlation among the traits
were found to be generally positive and significant (P<0.01) (Table 3). Values of 57.97g reported in
this study was higher than the reported value of 55.6 g in France and 54.4g in Republic of Benin by
Chrystosome et al. (2001) in Hyla pure New Zealand rabbits. Yamani et al. (1994) reported kit
weight at birth of 46g in Sam Elgar project in Egypt for Hyla rabbits. Weaning weight of 744.94g
obtained in this study was heavier than the average weaning weight of 671.11g versus 646.58g of
California and New Zealand rabbits obtained by Ferraz and Eler (1994). Values obtained at different
ages were slightly lower than the values reported by Nizza and Moniello (2000) for Hyla rabbits
and also values reported by Italian hybrids. Moderate to high heritability estimates obtained at
different ages indicated high genetic influence. Thus selection for any of these traits should result in
genetic improvement of the traits. Heritability value of 1.30 which was above unity might be due to
smaller sample size (n = 74) used for this study. This also agrees with the report of Orunmuyi et al.
(1996) who obtained heritability estimates above 1. Khalil et al. (1986) reported that maternal
effects resulted in the high heritability estimates obtained for preweaning traits. The moderate to
high repeatability estimates showed that great reliability can be put on selection or culling of does
and sires based on 2 or 3 records, thus leading to improvement in the productivity of the herd. The
moderate to high genetic and phenotypic correlations obtained are consistent with the reports of
Garcia et al. (1982). In conclusion, genetic improvement of bodyweight could be achieved at rapid
rate by selection and culling strategies at early ages in Hyla New Zealand White purebred rabbits
under the Nigerian conditions.
66
Table 1: Least squares means and standard errors of preweaning bodyweight of Hyla purebred
rabbits
Period
N
Bodyweight
Birth
205
57.97±1.41
7
195
138.14±2.12
14
172
269.25±5.26
21
160
420.43±8.17
28
147
585.50±11.54
35
142
744.94±16.64
Table 2: Heritability and Repeatability estimates of preweaning bodyweight
Traits (Bodyweight)
h2
R
Birth
0.77±0.002
0.53±0.32
7
0.21±0.002
0.39±0.29
14
0.25±0.003
0.64±0.35
21
0.43±0.003
0.99±0.41
28
0.36±0.002
1.30±0.44
35
0.33±0.003
0.89±0.39
h2 = heritability, R = repeatability
Table 3: Genetic (below diagonal) and Phenotypic correlation (above the diagonal) of Hyla
purebred rabbits
TRAITS
BW
IK7
IK14
IK21
IK28
IK35
BW
0.61
IK7
0.79
IK14
0.63
0.60
0.28
0.40
0.71
0.30
0.36
0.54
0.71
0.67
0.63
0.75
0.67
67
IK21
0.39
0.42
0.69
IK28
0.20
0.25
0.51
1.00
0.85
0.96
0.91
IK35
0.09
0.15
0.37
0.68
0.87
R- Repeatability, H - Heritability, BW- Birth weight, IK- Individual kit weight
REFERENCES
Chrysostome, C.A.A.M., Gbangboche, A.B. and Houangni, M.S.M. (2011). Evaluation of
reproduction performance of Hyla rabbits in hot and humid region in Benin. Research
Opinion in Animal and Veterinary Science, 1(10), 669-672.
Ferraz, J.B.S. and Eler, J.P. (1994). Use of different animal models in prediction of genetic
parameters of 23 traits of Californian and New Zealand White rabbits raised in tropics and
suggestion of selection criteria. Proceedings of the 5th World Congress on Genetics Applied to
Livestock Production, Guelph, Canada, 08/94, 20:348-351.
Garcia, F., Blasco, A., Baselga, M. and Salvador, A. (1982). Genetic analysis of some reproductive
traits in meat rabbits. Proceedings of the 2nd World Rabbit Congress, April, Barcelona, Spain.
93-97.
Harvey, W.R. (1990). Mixed Model Least Squares And Maximum Likelihood Computer
Programme, Pp 91.
Khalil, M.H., Afifi, E.A. and Emara, M.E. (1986). Doe litter performance at weaning for two
breeds of rabbits with emphasis on sire and doe effects. Animal Production Research Institute,
University of Agriculture, Cairo. 12-18.
Khalil, M.H., Afifi, E.A., Emara, M.E. and Owen, J.B. (1988). Genetic and phenotypic aspects of
doe reproduction in four breeds of rabbit. Journal of Agricultural Science, 110(1): 191-197.
Ndjon, M.N. and Nwakalor, L.N. (1998). Estimates of genetic parameters in a mixed population of
purebred and crossbred rabbits.I: Repeatability. Proceedings of Silver Anniversary Conference
of the Nigeria Society for Animal production, Abeokuta. 24:498-499.
Nizza, A. and Moniello, G. (2000). Meat quality and caecal content characteristics of rabbit
according to dietary and botanical origin of starch. World Rabbit Science, 8 (1): 3-9.
Orunmuyi, M., Adeyinka, I.A, Ojo, O.A. and Adeyinka, F.D. (2006). Genetic parameters
estimates for pre-weaning litter traits in rabbits, Pakistan Journal of Biological Science, 9 (15):
2909- 2911.
Terčič, D. and Holcman, A. (2008). Long-term divergent selection for 8-week body weight in
chickens – A review of experiments. Acta Agriculturae Slovenica, 92: 131-138.
Yamani, K.A, El-Maghawry, A.M, Tawfeek, M.I, Soliman, A.M. and Farghaly, H.M. (1994).
Evaluation of performance of three meat rabbit breeds recently introduced in Egypt. 1- Litter
weight and related traits. Ist International Conference on Rabbit Production in Hot Climates,
Cairo, Egypt. Pp. 236-296.
68
AGB06
EVALUATION OF THE DAIRY POTENTIAL OF FRIESIAN, WADARA AND THEIR
CROSSBREDS IN BAUCHI STATE
Ogundipe, R.I.1*, Adeoye, A.A.2, Rotimi, E.A.3 and Dim, N.I.3
1
*Department of Animal Production and Health, Ladoke Akintola University, Ogbomoso, Oyo
State.
2
Department of Biological Science, Ondo State University Science and Technology, Okitipupa
3
Department of Animal Breeding and Physiology, University of Agriculture, Makurdi
*Corresponding e-mail: ogundiperiskat@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
A total of 244 lactation records of cows that calved from 1976 to 1989 were analysed to evaluate
the dairy potential of Friesian, Wadara and their crossbreds. The lactation records consisted of 120,
36 and 88 records of Friesian, Wadara and their crossbreds, respectively. The records were
subjected to least square means to determine the mean performance across the breeds. The
estimated 305-day milk yield for Friesian, Wadara and their crossbreds were 2,359kg, 879kg
and1,643.5kg, respectively. The lactation length for the crossbreds was longest (338 days)
compared to 324 days and 186 days obtained for Friesian and Wadara, respectively. 453, 436 and
374 days were obtained as average calving interval for the crossbreds, Friesian and Wadara,
respectively. However, the differences in the calving interval were not significant.
Keywords: Cow, breed, crossbreds, lactation, calving interval,
INTRODUCTION
In the tropics, dairying involves the use of indigenous breeds of cattle which are characterized by
low genetic potential for milk production. Thus, the production of milk and milk products in the
tropics are grossly inadequate and this has resulted in importation from temperate countries to
sustain the demand for these products, which entails a huge financial investment. Other constraints
to remarkable increase in milk production in the topics have been attributed to inadequate nutrition,
prevailing diseases and hot climate. However, improvement in the productivity of the animal dairy
inducing is needed to meet present and future demands for livestock production. This improvement
can be achieved through breeding programmes, nutrition, disease control and provision of
conducive environment.
The role of European breeds of dairy cattle in improving the dairy cattle potential of indigenous
breeds in the tropics is well known because of their high milk production potential adaptability to
modern milking practice and early maturity ability. Therefore, they have been introduced for pure
breeding and for crossing with the indigenous breed, in order to blend their high performance with
adapt ability in the indigenous tropical breeds (Buvandran et al., 1950). The progeny from such
cross breeding perform better than pure breed indigenous breeds in dairy production traits.
69
Attention is focused on increasing the milk yield of indigenous cattle (especially white Fulani) by
crossing them with exotic breed (Friesian). However, the number of these reports with respect to
other indigenous cattle in Nigeria is few. Thus, the present study involves the evaluation of the
dairy potentials of pure bred Friesian, Wadara and their crossbreds in Bauchi State, Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The data used for this study were obtained from records of milking cows kept at the Gubi Dairy
Farm of the Bauchi State Integrated Development Authority (BASIDA) Bauchi, Nigeria. The data
for the study consisted of a total of 244 lactation records. Out of these. 120 records of 53 cows were
from Friesian cross; 36 records of 21 cows from Wadara breed and 88 records of 26 cows were
from the crossbreds (Friesian x Wadara).
The Friesian cattle were maintained intensively while Wadara and crossbreds were managed semi
intensively. The animals were vaccinated yearly against prevalent diseases and exo-parasites were
also controlled by spraying the animals. The cows were hand milked twice daily (morning and
evening), with Wadara calves standing closely to their dams to induce milk let-down. Cows were
dried off 60 days prior to parturition.
Milk records were compiled weekly on the basis of daily milk weight (morning and evening). From
these record books, production records of each cow and for the different lactation numbers were
compiled. The total lactation yield and lactation length were calculated for each lactation, while the
305 day yield was estimated for each lactation. The calving intervals were computed from the
recorded dates of calving. The days dry were also computed. All these records were used to
evaluate the performance of the breed groups.
The records were subjected to least squares means to determine the mean performance across the
breeds.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The least square mean (Table 1) revealed that Friesian breed had the highest values of 2359kg for
estimated 305-day milk yield. The crossbred had 1643.5kg for estimated 305-day milk yield. The
lowest value was obtained for Wadara breed 879kg, for estimated 305-day yield. The crossbred had
the longest lactation length (338 day) compared to 324days and 186days obtained for Friesian and
Wadara, respectively, although, the differences were not significant. The calving interval averaged
453, 436 and 374 days for crossbred, Friesian and Wadara cattle, respectively. However, the
differences in their calving interval were not significant.
Table 1. Least Square Mean (LSM) SE of dairy traits across breeds of cattle
Lactation
Estimated 305-Day
Days Dry (Days)
Length (Days)
milk yield (kg)
Overall
Mean
Breed
Friesian
Wadara
No
244
LSM
No
244
318
120
324.4a 24.0 120
36
186.4b
27.3
36
LSM
1904.8
No
146
2359.3a 229.4 66
879.9c 261.4
70
15
LSM
117
60 33.4
117.7
39.5
Calving interval
(Day)
No
15
6
66
17
LSM
421
436 39
374 46.5
Friesian
Wadara
x 88
338.1a
27.2
88
1643.5b 250.0
65
98 31.5
70
453 34.6
The results of this study revealed that Friesian breed is better than the crossbreds and Wadara in
estimated 305-day yield, which was highly significantly ( P< 0.01) different. This is an indication
that dairy performance is a function of both the genetic composition of the animal and the
environment since Friesian breed is known for their high milk potential under good feeding and
management. The crossbred performed better in milk production than the indigenous Wadara cattle
which had the lowest lactation yield. This observation agrees with the findings of earlier researchers
(Kiwuwa et al., 1983 and Letenneur, 1983).
The average 305-day yield estimated for Friesian in this study is higher than that reported by
Ibeawuchi (1987), but lower than that reported by Maroof and Tahir (1990). The estimated 305-day
yield for Wadara was similar to that obtained for Bunaji (Knudsen and Sohael, 1990). The
estimated 305-day yield for the crossbreds is higher than the indigenous Wadara but lower than that
reported by Ibeawuchi (1987). The lactation length obtained for Friesian is similar to that reported
in Kenya (Meyn and Wikin, 1974) and Nigeria (Sohael, 1984), respectively.
The lactation length obtained for Wadara (186days) falls within 150-200 days reported by
Mahadevan (1958). The lactation length obtained for crossbreds is in agreement with that reported
by Wijeratue (1970), but higher than the value reported by Sohael (1984). The non-significant
difference between the lactation length of Friesian and crossbreds observed in this study is in
agreement with the findings of Alba and Kennedy (1985). The increased length of crossbreds over
the local breed Wadara in this study is in line with the findings of Sohael (1984).
REFERENCES
Abubakar, B.Y. (1985). Evaluation of the performance of Holsteins in Mexico and Colombia Ph.D
thesis, Cornell University Itchaca New York.
Adeneye, J.A. and Adebanjo, A.K. (1978). Lactational characteristics of imported British Friesian
cattle in Western Nigeria. J. Agric. Sci., 91: 645-651.
Alba, J. and Kennedy, B.W. (1985). Milk production and Latin American Milking criollo and its
crosses with Jersey. Anim. Prod., 41:143-150.
Buvanendran, V, Olayiwole, M.B, Protrowskiu, K.I. and Oyejola, B.A. (1981). A comparison of
milk production traits in Friesian x White Fulani crossbred cattle. Animal Prod., 32: 165-170.
Kiwuwa, G.H, Trail, J.C. M. Kurtu, M.Y, Worku, G, Anderson, F and Durkin, J. (1983).
Crossbreeds dairy cattle productivity in Arsi Region, Ethiopia. ILCA Research Report 11,
International Livestock Centre for Africa. Pp. 29.
Knudsen, P.B. and Sohael, A.S. (1970). The Vom herd: A Study of the performance of a mixed
Friesian/Zebu and herd in a tropical environment. Trop. Agric., 47: 189-203.
Letenneur, L. (1983). Crossbreeding N’dama and Jersey cattle in Ivory Coast. FAO. W. Anim. Rev.,
37:79.
Maarof, N.N. and Tahir, K.N. (1990). Studies on the performance of Friesian cattle in Iraq. I: Milk
yield. Anim. Bred. Abstr., 58:606.
Mahadevan, P. (1958). Dairy cattle breeding in the Tropics. Technical Communication No. 11,
Commonwealth Agricultural Bureauz Farnham Royal, Bucks, England.
Sohael, A.S. (1984). Milk production potential of cattle on the Jos Plateau. Nigerian Livestock
Farmer, 4: 13-14.
Wijeratne, W.V.S. (1970). Crossbreeding Sinhala cattle with Jersey and Friesian in Ceylon. Anim.
Prod., 12:473-483.
71
AGB07
DETERMINATION OF THE BEST
INDIGENOUS SHEEP IN NIGERIA.
NON-LINEAR
GROWTH
MODEL
FOR
Raji, A.O.1*, Okoro, V.M.O.2 and Aliyu, J.1
1*
Department of Animal Science, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri, Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Science and Technology, Federal University of Technology, Owerri,
Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: rajrazpearl@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
This study, aimed at determining the best non-linear model for indigenous sheep, was conducted at
the University of Maiduguri Livestock Teaching and Research Farm, Maiduguri. Weekly body
weights (1-20 weeks) obtained from 51 Yankasa crossbred lambs were fitted to three non-linear
models; Gompertz, Logistic and Monomolecular. The goodness of fit statistics; Coefficient of
determination (R2), Mean Square Error (MSE), Standard Deviation (SD) and Akaike Information
Criteria (AIC), in addition to model parameters were used for model comparison. The age at Point
of Inflection for the Gompertz and Logistic were 5.33 and 7.97 weeks, respectively with
corresponding weights of 8.53 and 9.87kg. The asymptote weights of the Gompertz, Logistic and
Monomolecular models were 23.191, 19.749 and 39.876kg, respectively with corresponding R2
values of 0.9907, 0.9909 and 0.9913. The Monomolecular had the least values (3.6596, 1.9130 and
238.73) of MSE, SD and AIC while the Logistic had the highest (3.6861, 1.9199 and 240.03).
Based on these statistics, the monomolecular fitted the data better than the other models. Generally,
residual variations were higher at early than later ages, though the Gompertz and Logistic models
overestimated the early weights more than the Monomolecular and predictions may be more
accurate at later than early ages. Monomolecular is thus the best model for describing growth of
indigenous sheep in Nigeria.
Key words: Growth, non-linear, models, crossbred Yankasa lambs
INTRODUCTION
The world population of sheep and goats increased from 1.35 billion in 1961 to 1.94 in 2006
(FAOSTAT, 2008). Africa has a population of over 205 million sheep representing more than 17%
of the world’s total (FAO, 1990). According to the Federal Department of Livestock, sheep
population estimate in Nigeria as at 2009 was 34.69 million (FDL, 2010). Sheep with their small
body size, high productive capacity and rapid growth rates are ideally suited to production by
resource-poor smallholders. It is thus a very important animal genetic resource in Nigeria.
Growth is one of the most important characteristics of farm animals and has been investigated for
many years (Topal et al., 2004; Lambe et al., 2006; Keskin and Daskiran, 2007; Kum et al., 2010).
It is an increase in body size of animals per unit time and influenced by genetic and environmental
effects (Kucuk, 2004). The scientific analysis of growth requires mathematical models running with
72
data obtained over periods (Ozdemir and Dellal, 2009). Growth has been measured at various
intervals; such as weekly (Kocabas et al., 1997), bi weekly (Kor et al., 2006), monthly (Akbas et
al., 1999; Tekel et al., 2005; Keskin and Daskiran, 2007) and once in three months (Bilgin et al.,
2004). A typical growth curve can be divided into two phases, an early phase where the weight gain
rate increases and a later phase where the weight gain rate decreases (Trangerud et al., 2007).
Growth curves have been used to estimate mature body weight and increase in live weight in goats
and sheep by many researchers (Topal et al., 2004; Kor et al., 2006; Lambe et al., 2006; Keskin and
Daskiran, 2007; Kum et al., 2010). They can also be used for early selection of animals as they
provide prediction of future growth at any age (Tekel et al., 2005). Linear and non-linear models
have been used to describe growth in animals. Non-linear models have commonly been preferred,
since animals reach asymptotic body weight at a certain age (Akbas et al., 1999; Topal et al., 2004;
Tekel et al., 2005; Kor et al., 2006; Keskin and Daskiran, 2007). Tekel et al. (2005) reported that
some non-linear models used in explaining lifetime weight and age relationship of animals are
Logistic and Gompertz, Richards, Weibull and Monomolecular. These authors observed that the
best growth models in predicting change of body weight of Awassi male lambs were Gompertz and
Logistic models with equal determination coefficients of 98%. Akbas et al. (1999) stated that
Gompertz growth model with coefficients of determination of 99.28 and 99.63% in Kıvırcık and
Daglic breeds was the best growth model. In contrast, Kucuk and Eyduran (2010) reported the best
model for determination of growth in the Akkaraman and its crossbred lambs to be Monomolecular.
Since sheep are among the most reared and consumed animals in Nigeria, it is important to
determine the best growth model, which can explain weight and age relationships. Growth models
have been use extensively in many regions and in different species to describe growth, but few are
in Nigeria. The aim of this study therefore was to determine the best growth model for crossbred
Yankasa lambs in Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted at the University of Maiduguri Livestock Teaching and Research Farm,
Maiduguri, Borno State. Maiduguri is located within the Sahelian region of West Africa on
Longitude 11.38 ͦ North and Latitude 32.77 ͦ East and 354 m above sea level (Alade et al., 2008).
Maiduguri experiences a short rainy season (2-4months) usually between June and September.
There is extreme dryness during the rest of the year. Average annual rainfall is estimated at 645mm
with monthly (July, August and September) estimates of 138.12mm, 198.6mm and 157.4mm,
respectively. Based on the temperature of this area, the months are grouped into three distinct
seasons; hot dry (February- May), wet (June-September) and dry cold (October-January). The state
has a relative humidity of 5-45%, which increases from dry to wet season. The hot dry season has a
temperature range of 39.8-40.7oC; during the wet season it can fall to 31.0oC.
The management of the experimental animals was generally semi-intensive. The animals were
allowed to graze twice daily (morning and evening) in a range of up to 86 ha though, local farmers
carried out seasonal cultivation of annual crops in some portions. Species of plants found in the area
included Acacia obtusifolia, Strigal asiatical, Ziziphus macronatal etc. Few days to lambing
pregnant ewes were isolated and housed in a well-littered lambing pen. After parturition, all
necessary cleaning and identification processes were observed. Newly born animals were housed
together with their ewes under close observation for 24 h to ensure colostrum feeding. Ewes were
allowed to graze leaving behind their lambs after two weeks
The data collected were for 51 Yankasa crossbred lambs. Body weight was recorded weekly for
each animal from 1 – 20 weeks of age. The data collected were analysed using non-linear regression
procedure of Statistix 9.0. The goodness of fit statistics, coefficient of determination (R2), Mean
Square Error (MSE), Standard Deviation (SD) and Akaike Information Criteria (AIC), in addition
to model parameters were used for model comparison. Growth curve functions were fitted
73
individually to the observed data by using Levenberg-Marquardt nonlinear least-squares algorithm
in Statistix 9.0. During the iteration procedure, when any parameter value at a current iteration did
not change in the successive iteration, the procedure stopped and it was assumed that the
convergence criterion of 1.0E-05 was attained.
The models fitted were as follows:
Gompertz :
W(t) = A*exp(− B*exp(− k *t))
Logistic:
W(t) = A*(1 + B*exp ( − k* t))-1
Monomolecular :
W(t) = A*(1 - B*exp ( − k* t))1
For each model, Wt is the body weight (kg) of sheep at t week(s) of age (t = 1, 2,…, 20); A, B and k
are model parameters: A is asymptotic weight when time goes to infinity; B is a scaling parameter
(constant of integration), which is related with initial values of W, and k is maturing rate.
Weight and age at the Point of Inflection (POI) were calculated as W = A/e and t = ln(B)/k,
respectively for Gompertz and W = A/2 and t = ln(B)/k for Logistic. e is base of natural logarithm
or Eulerian number (2.71828). The monomolecular model has no inflection point.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Growth parameters, derivatives and goodness of fit criteria for different models fitted to live weight
data of crossbred Yankasa lambs are presented in Table 1. The asymptote weights of the Gompertz,
Logistic and Monomolecular models were 23.191, 19.749 and 39.876 kg, respectively. Based on
asymptotic weight, the Monomolecular ranked first, followed by the Gompertz and then the
Logistic. The asymptote weights obtained from the models are attainable by crossbred Yankasa
lambs but lower than those reported by Lambe et al. (2006) and Kum et al. (2010) for Texel and
Scottish black face and, Norduz lambs. The difference could be because the mature weights of the
breeds may be higher than that of the Yankasa cross breeds. In addition, differences could be due to
genotype and environmental variations. The trend in terms of ranking of models based on
asymptote weights was however similar to that of Kucuk and Eyduran (2009) in Akkaraman
crossbreds.
Coefficients of determination have been used to evaluate the goodness of fit of models in some
studies (Lewis et al., 2002; Topal et al., 2004). Models with the highest R2 and lowest MSE values
have been accepted as best fitting (Tedeschi, 2006). The coefficients of determination (R2) for the
different growth models (Gompertz, Logistic and Monomolecular) were 0.9907, 0.9909 and 0.9913,
respectively. Kucuk and Eyduran (2009) and Kum et al. (2010) also reported high R2 values in
lambs using the same models. High R2 for all the models implied, they all fitted the data adequately.
This is buttressed by Figure 1, where the points on the curves for all models were very close at most
ages. All the growth models presented similar prediction patterns at the same stages of growth.
They under- or overestimated the body weight to a greater or lesser extent. However, they all
provided less accurate predictions at the beginning of the growth curve and predictions were more
accurate after 6 weeks of age. Forni et al. (2009) made similar observations.
When Mean Square Error (MSE), Standard Deviation (SD) and AIC were used for comparison, the
Monomolecular had the least values (3.6596, 1.9130 and 238.73) while the Logistic had the highest
(3.6861, 1.9199 and 240.03). Based on these statistics, the monomolecular fitted the data better than
the other models. Bilgin et al. (2004), Kor et al. (2005) and Kucuk and Eyduran (2009) also made
similar observation based on MSE for Morkaraman lambs, Akkeci kids and Akkaraman lambs,
74
respectively. The age and weight at POI for the Gompertz were 5.33 weeks and 8.53 kg
respectively, while the corresponding values for the Logistic were 7.97 weeks and 9.87 kg. These
values indicate the ages and weights where the estimated growth rate changed from an increasing to
a decreasing function.
The observed, predicted and residual weights for the different growth models of indigenous sheep
are presented in Table 2. The range of residuals for the Gompertz, Logistics and Monomolecular
from 2 - 20 weeks were 0.03 - 0.61, 0.02 - 0.66 and 0.00 - 0.56, respectively. The corresponding
values for percentage deviations were 0.21 – 6.59, 0.21 – 7.08 and 0.02 – 5.99%. Residuals and
percentage deviations were generally low except in the first week; an indication that the models
fitted the weight data adequately. Among the models, the monomolecular had a narrower range of
residual and percentage deviation, indicating that it might have a better fit than the other models. It
was also observed that no model described early periods of growth as adequately as the later ones.
However, the Gompertz and Logistic models overestimated the early weights more than the
Monomolecular. Generally, residual variations were higher at early than later ages. Brown et al.
(1976) made similar observations and concluded that predictions may be more accurate at later than
early ages.
CONCLUSION
It could be concluded from this study that the Gompertz, Logistic and Monomolecular models all
fitted the live weight data of the crossbred Yankasa lambs . However, the best model was the
Monomolecular based on higher coefficient of determination and lower MSE. This is followed by
the Gompertz.
Table 1. Growth parameters, derivatives and goodness of fit criteria for
different models fitted to live weight data of crossbred Yankasa lambs
Model
parameters
Gompertz
Logistic
Monomolecular
A
23.191
19.749
39.876
B
0.3731
0.9347
0.0179
C
0.070
0.1173
-7.7822
POI (age in
weeks)
5.33
7.97
POI (weight
in Kg)
8.53
9.87
2
R
0.999
0.999
0.999
MSE
3.6734
3.6861
3.6596
SD
1.9166
1.9199
1.913
AIC
239.4
240.03
238.73
A = Asymptotic weight, B = Integration constant, C = Maturing rate, R2 = Coefficient of
Determination, MSE= Mean Square Error, SD= Standard Deviation, AIC= Akaike Information
Criteria, POI = Point of inflection
75
18.00
16.00
Observed
Gompertz
Logistics
Monomolecular
14.00
Body weights (kg)
12.00
10.00
8.00
6.00
4.00
2.00
0.00
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Age (weeks)
Figure 1. Growth curves for indigenous sheep from the different models
Table 2. The observed, predicted and residual weights for the different growth models of crossbred
Yankasa lambs
Gompertz
Logistics
Monomolecular
Age
observed
(week)
Weights
P
R
D
P
R
D
P
R
D
5.12
5.95
0.83
16.14
6.06
0.94
18.40
5.80
0.68
13.28
1
6.40
6.48
0.08
1.19
6.54
0.14
2.25
6.41
0.01
0.15
2
7.36
7.02
-0.34
-4.66
7.04
-0.32
-4.34
7.00
-0.36
-4.84
3
7.97
7.56
-0.41
-5.09
7.56
-0.41
-5.20
7.59
-0.38
-4.80
4
8.44
8.12
-0.32
-3.85
8.08
-0.36
-4.22
8.16
-0.28
-3.31
5
9.28
8.67
-0.61
-6.59
8.62
-0.66
-7.08
8.72
-0.56
-5.99
6
9.19
9.22
0.03
0.33
9.17
-0.02
-0.21
9.28
0.09
0.94
7
9.80
9.77
-0.03
-0.31
9.72
-0.08
-0.80
9.82
0.02
0.20
8
9.99
10.32
0.33
3.26
10.27
0.28
2.84
10.35
0.36
3.64
9
10.51
10.85
0.34
3.27
10.82
0.31
2.99
10.88
0.37
3.50
10
11.31
11.39
0.07
0.66
11.37
0.06
0.51
11.40
0.08
0.75
11
11.93
11.91
-0.03
-0.21
11.90
-0.03
-0.23
11.90
-0.03
-0.27
12
12.31
12.41
0.10
0.84
12.43
0.12
0.94
12.40
0.08
0.69
13
12.88
12.91
0.03
0.24
12.93
0.05
0.42
12.88
0.00
0.02
14
13.52
13.40
-0.13
-0.92
13.42
-0.10
-0.71
13.36
-0.16
-1.16
15
13.56
13.86
0.30
2.24
13.90
0.33
2.47
13.83
0.27
2.01
16
14.26
14.32
0.06
0.42
14.35
0.09
0.60
14.30
0.04
0.25
17
15.07
14.76
-0.31
-2.06
14.77
-0.30
-1.96
14.75
-0.32
-2.13
18
15.47
15.19
-0.29
-1.84
15.18
-0.29
-1.89
15.18
-0.30
-1.91
19
15.67
15.59
-0.08
-0.49
15.56
-0.11
-0.70
15.63
-0.04
-0.23
20
P= Predicted weight, R= Residual weight, D = percentage deviation from observed weight
76
REFERENCES
Akbas, Y., Taskin, T. and Demiroren, E. (1999). Comparison of several models to fit growth curves
of Kivircik and Daglic male lambs. Turkish Journal Veterinary Animal Science, 23: 537-544.
Alade, N. K., Raji, A. O. and Atiku, M. A. (2008). Determination of appropriate model for the
estimation of body weight in goats. ARPN Journal of Agricultural and Biological Science, 3(4):
52-57.
Bilgin, O. C., Esenbuga, N. Macit, M. and Karaoglu, M. (2004). Growth curve characteristics in
Morkaraman and Awassi sheep. I: Comparison of non-linear functions. Wool Technology
Sheep Breed., 52(1): 1-7.
Brown, J. E., Fitzhugh (Jr), H. A. and Cartwright, T. C. (1976). A comparison of nonlinear models
for describing weight-age relationships in cattle. Journal of
Animal Science, 42:810-818.
FAO (1990). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Production Year book,
volume 44. Rome, Italy p.5.FAOSTAT. (2008).
Food
and
Agriculture
Organization
of
the
United
Nations.
Available:
http://faostat.fao.org/site/573/default.aspx. Accessed May 18, 2008.
FDL (2010). Federal Department of Livestock. National livestock estimates. Livestock sector –
disaggregated data on key development indicators. FDL, Ministry of Agriculture and Natural
Resources, Nigeria.
Forni,S., Piles, M., Blasco, A., Varona, L., Oliveira, H. N., Lôbo, R. B. and Albuquerque, L. G.
(2009). Comparison of different nonlinear functions to describe Nelore cattle growth. Journal
of Animal Science, 87:496-506.
Keskin, S. and Daskiran, I. (2007). Comparison of growth models in Norduz female kids. Indian
Veterinary Journal, 86:1066-1068.
Kocabas. Z., Kesici, T. and Elicin, A. (1997). Growth curves of Akkaraman, Awassi × Akkaraman
and Malya × Akkaraman lambs. Turkish Journal Veterinary Animal Science, 21: 267-275.
Kor, A., Baspınar, E., Karaca, S. and Keskin, S. (2006). The determination of growth in Akkeci
(White goat) female kids by various growth Models. Czech Journal of Animal Science, 51(3):
110-116.
Kucuk, M. ( 2004). Growth characteristics of Hamdani, Karakul and Morkaraman lambs in suckling
period. Indian Veterinary Journal, 81: 172-175.
Kucuk, M. and Eyduran, E. (2009). The determination of the best growth model for Akkaraman and
German Blackheaded mutton x Akkaraman crossbreed lambs. Bulgarian Journal of
Agricultural Science, 81: 172-175.
Kum, D., Karakus, K. and Ozdemir, T. (2010). The best non-linear function for body weight at
early phase of Norduz female lambs. Trakia Journal of Sciences, 8(2): 62-67.
Lambe, N. R., Navajas, E. A., Simm, G. and Bunger, L. (2006). A genetic investigation of various
growth models to describe growth of lambs of two contrasting breeds. Journal of Animal
Science, 84: 2642-2654.
Lewis, R. M., Emmans, G. C., Dingwall, W. S. and Simm, G. (2002). A description of the growth
of sheep and its genetic analysis. Animal Science, 74: 51-62.
Ozdemir, H. and Dellal, G. (2009). Determination of growth curves in young Angora goats. Tarim
Bilimleri Gergisi, 15:358-362.
Tekel, N., Sireli, H. D., Elicin, M. and Elicin, A. (2005). Comparison of growth curve models on
Awassi lambs. Indian Veterinary Journal, 82: 179-182.
Topal, M., Ozdemir, M., Aksakal, V., Yildiz, N. and Dogru, U. (2004). Determination of the best
point nonlinear function in order to estimate growth in Morkaraman and Awassi lambs. Small
Ruminant Research, 55: 229-232.
Trangerud, C., Grondalen, J., Indrebo, A., Tverdal, A., Ropstad, E. and Moe, L. (2007). A
longitudinal study on growth and growth variables in dogs of four large breeds raised in
domestic environments. Journal of Animal Science, 1:76-83.
77
AGB08
HERITABILITY ESTIMATES OF LITTER BODY WEIGHT IN A POPULATION OF
NON-DESCRIPT BREEDS OF DOMESTIC RABBITS RAISED IN A HUMID TROPICAL
ENVIRONMENT OF SOUTHERN NIGERIA
Sorhue, G.U.1*, Mmereole, F.U.C.2 and Irekefe-Ekeke, P.3
1
Deparment of Agricultural Education, Delta State College of Physical Education Mosogar, Delta
State, Nigeria
2
Department of Animal Science, Delta State University, Asaba Campus, Asaba, Delta State, Nigeria
3
Deparment of Agricultural Education, Delta State College of Education Warri, Delta State, Nigeria
Corresponding author; Sorhue Godstime Ufuoma
*Corresponding e-mail: gtsorhue@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Heritability of litter body weight traits at various ages were estimated in a population of domestic
rabbits raised in Asaba, Southern Nigeria using the paternal and maternal half-sib method. Litter
traits studied were litter bodyweight at birth (LBW), litter weight at 7days (7BW), litter weight at
14days (14BW), litter weight at 21days (21BW) and litter weight at weaning (42BW). The variance
components and heritability were obtained using standard expressions in a hierarchal design. The
data consisted of 224kits obtained from a mating involving fifteen dams and five sires in three
parities each from sires and dams. Variance components were higher from dam components than
sire components except for litter birth weight (LBW) and litter weaning weight (LWW). Heritability
of LBW, 7BW, 14BW, 21BW and LWW from sire (dam) components were 0.84(0.34), 0.28 (0.92),
0.90(0.96), 0.33(0.63) and 0.79(0.74), respectively. The moderate to high heritability estimates of
litter body weight suggest improvement of these traits by simple selection method such as one
based on individual performance or pedigree records.
Keywords: Heritability, hierarchal, litter, bodyweight, half-sibs
INTRODUCTION
Rabbits have a number of characteristics that would make them particularly suitable as meatproducing animals, especially when compared with other herbivores. Rabbits could contribute
significantly in solving the problem of meat shortage (Lebas, 1983). One of the pre-requisites for
genetic improvement is knowledge of genetic parameters for important economic traits (Akanno
and Ibe, 2005). As rabbits can be fed with forages and do not compete directly with humans for
grains, they can be a very important source of high quality animal protein in developing countries
(1raqi, 2003). Heritability is the proportion of the total phenotypic variance (VP) attributable to
effect of genes (Falconer, 1989). Heritability of litter traits for domestic rabbits in the humid tropics
have been reported to range from low, moderate to high when estimates are obtained using paternal
and maternal half-sib methods (Sorhue et al., 2013; Ibrahim et al., 2007; Akanno and Ibe, 2005).
Nofal et al. (2008) reported that estimate of variance is highest for litter weight at weaning (6
weeks) of age which may be due to mothering ability, which is continued to the end of suckling
period. There is need for more research in this area of animal breeding in other to predict selection
response. This study was therefore designed to estimate the variance components and heritability of
litter body weight traits in this rabbit population from birth to weaning.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
78
The study was conducted at the rabbitry unit of the Department of Animal Science, Delta State
University, Asaba Campus, Asaba, Nigeria. Asaba Campus is located at latitude 060 14’N and
longitude 060 49’E. It lies in the tropical rainforest zone, characterized by seven months of rainy
season between April and October punctuated by a short break in August with annual rainfall of
1500mm-1849mm (NIMET, 2005).
Kits obtained from a mating involving fifteen dams and five sires. The experimental stocks were
Non-descript breeds of domestic rabbits (commercial rabbit).The parental stock produced 224 kits
which were weaned at 42days of age.
There were five (5) pens of 90x60x65(cm) for the five (5) sires, five (5) pens of 90x80x65 for the
fifteen (15) dams with 3 dams per pen and three (3) pens of 100x60x65 for dams and litters after
kindling. The design was a balanced design with equal numbers of sub-class. It was a two way
nested classification, dams were nested between sires and litters were weaned at 6weeks (42days).
Feed and water were provided ad libitum throughout the period of the experiment. The rabbits were
raised in wooden cages with wire mesh. The feed used was commercial pellets with forages and
grasses supplied to meet the nutrient required by the experimental animals. Prior to the experiment,
the feed’s proximate composition was determined to ensure conformation with the NRC standard at
the Nutrition and Biochemistry Laboratory of the Department of Animal Science, Delta State
University, Asaba Campus.
Litter body weight traits were collected from progeny of a particular dam, mated to a particular sire
separately. The kits of a certain litter from a certain Dam mated to a certain sire were marked. The
litter traits were measured from birth to weaning at 42days of age. There were three parities per dam
with the same sire.
The following parameters were measured and data collected included:
1.
Litter birth weight (LBW)
2.
Litter weight at 7days (7BW)
3
Litter weight at 14days (14BW)
4
Litter weight at 21days (21BW)
5.
Litter weight at weaning (LWW).
Litter weight was collected with the aid of a weighing scale.
All data collected were subjected to analysis of variance using SAS (2001). Variance components
and Heritability were estimated using standard expressions given by Becker (1984).
The statistical model used for the analysis of variance was
Yijk = µ + Si + Dij + eijk
where:
Yijk
=
record of the k-th progeny of the Jth dam mated to the I-th Sire.
µ
=
the overall population mean
Si
=
the random effect of the i-th sire
Dij
=
the random effect of the jth dam mated to the
Eijk =
the error term.
Heritability was estimated from sire and dam components as follows:
h2s=42 s/ (2s + 2d +2w)
h2d= 42d / (2s + 2d + 2w)
where:
h2s
=
Heritability from sire
h2d
=
Heritability from dam
2
s
=
Sire variance component
79
i-th
sire.
2d
2w
=
=
Dam variance component
Within progeny variance component
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 2.
Proximate composition of experimental diets
Pelletized
Guinea grass
Tridax
commercial
procubens stem
growers mash
Moisture
66.20
84.30
Crude protein
15.4
12.30
36.04
Ash
9.4
14.50
5.17
Ether extract
4.5
3.15
1.05
CHO
62.0
52.20
42.40
crude fiber
8.7
18.04
16.91
Tridax procubens
leaf
87.55
35.16
2.49
5.02
52.12
5.88
Table 3. Means and standard errors for litter size and body weight traits of domestic rabbits
Traits
No of observation
Mean
S.E
LBW
195
0.05
±
0.04
7BW
187
0.10
±
0.07
14BW
181
0.19
±
0.12
21BW
179
0.28
±
0.13
42BW
174
0.59
±
0.02
LBW- litter-birth-weight, 7BW-7day bodyweight, 14BW - 14day body weight, 21BW -21day body
weight, LWW - 42 day body weight.
Table 4.Variance components for litter body weights traits of sire (s2), dam (d2), progeny (e2)
and total phenotypic variance (p2)
Traits
s2
d2
e2
p2
LBW
0.0020
0.0008
0.0068
0.0096
7BW
0.0027
0.0089
0.0271
0.0387
14BW
0.0040
0.0042
0.0094
0.0176
21BW
0.0003
0.0007
0.0032
0.0042
LWW
0.0022
0.0020
0.0067
0.0109
2
2
2
s - sire component of variance d –Dam component of variance e -progeny component of
variance p2- Total phenotypic variance.
Table 5. Heritability and standard errors of heritability for litter body weight traits
Traits
h2s + se
h2d+ se
LBW
0.84 ± 0.24
0.34 ± 0.64
7BW
0.28 ± 0.65
0.92 ± 0.13
14BW
0.90 ± 0.15
0.96 ± 0.07
21BW
0.33 ± 0.64
0.63 ± 0.48
LWW
0.79 ± 0.31
0.74 ± 0.19
2
2
h s – paternal half-sib heritability h d-Maternal half-sib heritability se-standard error of
heritability.
80
The proximate composition of the experimental diet is presented in Table 2. The crude protein level
ranged from 12.30% for guinea grass to 36.04% for the tridax procubens stem while the ash content
ranged from 2.49 for tridax procubens leaf to 14.50% for guinea grass. Crude fiber content varied
from 5.88 for tridax procubens leaf to 18.04 for guinea grass.
Means and standard errors for litter body weight traits are presented in Table 3. The mean values
ranged from 0.05±0.04 for litter birth weight (LBW) to 0.59±0.02 for litter weaning weight
(LWW). The variance components for litter body weight traits in this study ranged from 0.0003 to
0.004 (sire), 0.0007 to 0.009 (dam) and 0.003 to 0.027 (progeny) as shown in Table 4. Heritability
estimates for dam component were higher than the corresponding heritability from sire components
for the traits studied except for LBW and 42 BW, respectively. This may be due to the fact that Sire
components of variance were lower than the corresponding dam component of variance for those
traits except for LBW and LWW. Heritability estimates for dam component ranged from 0.34 for
LBW to 0.96 for 14BW. Heritability of LBW, 7BW, 14BW, 21BW and LWW from sire (dam)
components were 0.84(0.34), 0.28 (0.92), 0.90(0.96), 0.33(0.63) and 0.79(0.74), respectively. The
high standard errors obtained in the estimate of heritability could be due to the low accuracy of sire
and dam component of variance in the traits studied as well as the sample size.
The variance components obtained in this studied is comparable to earlier reports by Sorhue et al.
(2013) for litter size traits at birth and weaning. Litter Body weight traits using sire components and
dam component were moderate to high. Moderate heritability values of 0.37 and 0.34 were also
reported by Lukefahr et al. (1983) and Okoro et al. (2011) using paternal half sib method for litter
body weight (LBW) at birth. The values of 0.84, (0.34), 0.28 (0.92), 0.90 (0.96), 0.33 (0.63) and
0.79 (0.74) reported for LBW, 7BW, 14BW, 21BW and LWW for both sire and dam component are
higher than 0.01 reported by Youssef et al. (2008) using animal model.
The estimate of 0.34 for LBW obtained in the present study is the same with that reported by Okoro
et al. (2011) using the paternal half sib method. The moderate heritability of 0.28 for 7BW is lower
than 0.49 estimated by Ibrahim et al. (2007) using paternal half-sib method while the high
heritability estimate from maternal half-sib of 0.92 for 7day bodyweight was far higher than the
value of 0.17 reported by Ibrahim et al. (2007) using maternal half sib method.
Literature on 14BW heritability was scarce but high heritability values of 0.90 and 0.96 from sire
and dam components were recorded and are comparable to estimates of 0.94 (paternal half-sib
heritability) and 0.96 (maternal half-sib heritability) reported by Sorhue et al. (2013) for litter size
at weaning. The moderate to high values for 21BW heritability of 0.33 for sire and 0.63 for dam
component of variance is in line with values reported by Ibrahim et al. (2007) using paternal halfsib and maternal half-sib methods, respectively. However, these values are higher than estimates for
21BW reported by Rastogi et al. (2000), Iraqi (2008) and Youssef et al. (2008) with values of 0.08,
0.05 and 0.21 respectively using different animal models. The high values of heritability for LWW
of 0.79 and 0.74 for sire and dam component are similar to 0.66 obtained by Castellini and Panella
(1988) but far higher than reports from Youssef et al. (2008) and Niranja et al. (2010) with values
of 0.23 and 0.25 using single trait and multi-trait animal models, respectively. Values out of
heritability range of 2.10 using paternal half-sib method was recorded by Ibrahim et al. (2007)\ and
Okoro et al. (2011). Ibrahim et al. (2007) also reported very high value of 1.26 for LWW
heritability using maternal half-sib method which is higher than estimates in the present study.
Discrepancies between the estimates in this study and those reported in literature are expected since
heritability values depend on the genetic make up of the stocks, management and climatic
conditions and period of study as well as differences in data size and method of analysis (Khalil et
al., 1986) as well as the variance that exist in the population. Moderate to high heritability values
indicate strong contribution of additive genes in the expression of these traits and suggest possible
improvement of litter body weights in rabbits in the experimental population by use of either
pedigree or individual selection method.
CONCLUSION
81
The heritability estimates of litter body weight were moderate to high and were consistent.
Moderate and high genetic improvement is possible through selection on the basis of individual or
pedigree testing methods. Moderate to high heritability values imply that selection would be
efficient to improve these traits and the characters are susceptible to genetic influence.
REFERENCES
Akanno E. C., Ibe S. N., (2005). Estimates of genetic parameters for growth traits of domestic
rabbits in the humid tropics. Livestock Research for Rural Development, vol 17, article no. 86.
http://www.lrrd.org/lrrd17/7/akan17086.htm
Becker, W.A (1984). Manual of Quantitative genetics.4thedition, Academic Enterprises, Pullman
Washington. 188 pages.
Castelline, C. and Panella, F. (1988). Heritability of pre- and post-weaning weight in rabbits.
Proceedings of 4th World Rabbit Congress, pp. 112-119.
Ibrahim, T., Mbap, S.T., Russom, Z., Abdul, S.D., and Ahmed, M.S. (2007). Genetic analysis of
meat production traits of rabbits, Dwagom farms, Vom, Nigeria. Livestock Research for Rural
Development, Volume 19, Article no. 9. http://www.lrrd.org/lrrd19/1/ibra19009.htm
Iraqi, M.M. (2008). Estimation of heritability and repeatability for maternal and milk production
traits in NZW rabbits raised In hot climatic conditions. Livestock Research for Rural
Development, 20(8). http://www.lrrd.org/lrrd20/8/iraq20133.htm
Khalil M. H. E., Owen J. B., and Afifi E. A., (1986). A review of phenotypic and genetic
parameters associated with meat production traits in rabbits. Animal Breeding Abstracts
54(90):726-749.
Lebas, F. (1983). Small-scale rabbit production. Feeding and management systems. World Animal
Review, 46:11-17.
Lukefahr, S., Hohenboken, W.O., Checke, P.R. and Pattin, N.M. (1983). Doe reproduction and preweaning litter performance of straight bred and crossbred rabbits. Journal of Animal Science,
57:1090 – 1099.
NIMET (2005). Nigerian meteorological station Anwai Delta State University, Asaba Campus
Annual report.
Niranjan, .S.K, Sharna, .S.K. and Growane, G.R. (2010). Estimates of direct and maternal effects on
Growths in Angora rabbits Assian-Asut J. Anim. Sci., Vol23, No8: 981-986, August 2010.
Nofal, R., Hassan, N., Abdel-Ghany, A., Gyorgyi, V. (2008). Estimation of genetic parameters for
litter size and body weight traits in New Zealand Rabbits raised in Hungary. proc of 9th world
rabbit congress. June 10-13 Verona Italy
Okoro,V.M.O., Ogundu,U.E, Okoli, I.C and Anyanwu, G.A(2011). A note on heritabilities for preweaning and post-weaning litter weights of unselected domestic rabbits in southeastern Nigeria.
http://www.knoblauchpublishing.com/GQG-03-026Okoro.pdf.
Rastogi, R.K., Lukefahr, S.D., Lauckner, F.B., (2000). Maternal heritability and repeatability for
litter traits in rabbits, libest. Prof. sci., 67 (1-2): 123 – 128.
SAS, (2001). Statistical analysis software guide for personal computers. Release 8.1 S (TSIMO).
SAS Institute Inc, N. Carolina, USA
Sorhue, G. U., Akporhuarho, P. O., Udeh, I., Mmereole, F. U. C., (2013). Estimates of genetic
parameters of litter size traits at birth and weaning in domestic rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus)
raised in Anwai community, South Nigeria. Rabbit Gen., 3(1):7-14.
Youssef, Y.M.K., Baselga, M. Khalil, M.H. Gad-Alla, S. and Garcia, M.L. (2008). Evaluation of
litter traits in a crossing project of V-line and Baladi red rabbits in Egypt. Livestock research
for rural devpt., (20) (9).
82
AGB09
HERITABILITY AND REPEATABILITY ESTIMATES FOR GROWTH AND BODY
LINEAR MEASUREMENTS IN MALE AND FEMALE BROILER LINES
Badmus, K.A.1*, Kabir, M.1, Adeyinka, I.A.2 and Sekoni, A.A.2
1
Animal Breeding and Genetics Unit, Department of Animal Science, A.B.U., Zaria, Nigeria.
2
National Animal Production Research Institute (NAPRI), Shika, Zaria, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: alqasiminternational@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
A total of 350 broiler chickens, which consisted of 100 each for sire and dam line and 75 each for
sire control and dam control, , kept at the National Animal Production Research Institute (NAPRI)
Shika, Zaria were used. The parameters considered were body weight (BW), body length (BL),
Body girth (BG), Thigh length (TL), keel length (KL) and Shank length (SL) which were measured
fortnightly. The results of heritability (h2) estimates obtained for BW and body linear measurements
from 2 to 8 weeks ranged from low (0.05±1.63) to high (0.58±0.73) values. The estimate obtained
for TL at 8 weeks was high (0.81±1.27) in sire line while a range from low (0.04±1.50) to high
(0.90±0.11) values was obtained in dam line. The h2 estimates for sire control and dam control also
ranged from low to high values. The repeatability (R) estimates for BW were generally low for both
the selected lines and the control, ranging from 0.001 to 0.193 across all ages. The R for body linear
measurements were also low though moderate to high values for BG at 2 weeks (0.35) and BG at 4
weeks (0.25) for dam line, keel length at 6 week (0.27) for sire line and keel length at 6 weeks
(0.29) for dam line were obtained. The results obtained from this study were in line with literature
reported values for broiler chickens. Any observed variation in estimates of h2 and R could be
attributed to line effects, method of estimation and sampling error due to small data size. The results
finally indicated that the population of collapsed Anak and Hubbard broilers into sire and dam line
as well as sire and dam control, kept at NAPRI were stable. Furthermore, variations abound for
exploitation in the measured traits as interbreeding within and without lines continue.
Keywords: Broiler chickens, growth, genetic parameters, sire, dam, control line
INTRODUCTION
The performance of broiler birds is determined by its genotype and environmental factors
(Boukwamp et al., 1973; Edward and Denman, 1975). In animal breeding, it is imperative to
determine breeding value with the objective of classifying the best individuals that will be the
parents of the next generation, and quantifying its contribution to the genetic gain (Grosso et al.,
2010). Selection of better breeds or strains has gone a long way in producing quick and rapid
transformation in animal proteins supply (Nawathe and Lamorde, 1987). Some of the genetic
parameters used for selection by breeders are repeatability, heritability and genetic and phenotypic
correlations.
According to Falconer (1989), fewer records are required to realize a high expected response from
selection in traits with high repeatability estimates while those with low repeatability estimates will
require larger number of records. Gaya et al. (2006) had shown genetic correlation between body
weight at different ages and carcass traits and suggested that direct selection for body weight at 38
and 42 days of age could produce indirect genetic gain for breast muscle, leg and eviscerated body
weight. The authors further indicated that heritability estimate for body weight at different ages for
evaluation of genetic variability and considerable direct additive genetic effects seemed to exist in
the expression of body composition traits. Kabir et al. (2006) reported that mean values of body
weight at various ages showed good performance. They also noted that heritability estimates
observed for body weight and shank length decreases with increasing age of birds. The National
Animal Production Research Institute (NAPRI) Shika Zaria, recently collapsed the population of
83
Anak and Hubbard broilers, leading to the formation of two lines of sire and dam as well as two
control of sire and dam, respectively. This was due to exhaustion of the additive genetic variation.
Periodic evaluation of such population is pertinent and hence this study, which was designed to
estimate the genetic parameters (h2, R) for growth and body linear measurements in sire and dam
broiler lines.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The research was conducted at the Poultry Research Unit of National Animal Production Research
Institute (NAPRI) Shika, Zaria, Kaduna State. Shika lies between latitude 110 12`N, longitude 70
33`E and at altitude of 640m above sea level. The area falls within the Northern Guinea Savannah
having an average annual rainfall of 1100mm. Detailed description of the experimental site was
given by Kabir et al. (2010).
Total number of 350 broiler birds was used for this study, which comprised of 100 each of sire line
and dam line, 75 each of sire control and dam control, obtained from a collapsed population of
Hubbard and Anak broiler birds at the National Animal production Research Institute (NAPRI).
They were kept in deep litter system for a period of eight weeks. Feed and clean drinking water
were provided ad-libitum. Broiler starter mash containing crude protein of 24.96% and ME of
2767.62Kcal/kg was fed to the chicks for the first four weeks while broiler finisher mash with crude
protein of 23.23 and ME of 2839.64 Kcal/kg was fed for the last four weeks. All rations were
formulated and mixed at the feed mill of the Institute (NAPRI), the composition is as shown in
Table 1.
Table 1. Composition of the experimental diets
PERCENTAGE
Ingredients
Broiler Starter Broiler Finisher
Maize
45.00
52.00
Groundnut cake
30.00
30.00
Soyabean meal
15.00
10.00
Maize offal
4.60
2.50
Lime stone
3.00
1.50
Bone meal
1.50
3.00
Salt
0.30
0.30
Lysine
0.15
0.20
Methionine
0.15
0.20
Premix*
0.25
0.30
Total
100
100
Calculated analysis
ME Kcal/kg
2767.62
2839.64
Crude Protein
24.96
23.23
Crude Fibre
3.82
3.45
Ether Extract
5.16
5.22
Methionine
0.47
0.50
Methionine + Cysteine
0.85
0.86
Lysine
1.20
1.13
Calcium
1.75
1.74
Available Phosphorous
0.90
0.89
*The premix used in this study supplied the following nutrients (Kg/diet): Vit A: 20,000,00, IU
Vitamin E. 500 I, thiamin (B) 2,000mg, Riboflavin (B2) 3500mg, Vit (B3) 20000mg, Panthothenic
acid (B5) 6,600ml, Pyridoxine (B6) 3600mg, Vitamin (B12) 20mg, folic acid 400mg, Vitamin
20000mg, Methionine 10,000mg, antioxidant 12.5g, Ca 18%, P.Mn 8.0g, Zn ug Iodine 0.12g.
84
The weight of individual birds and other body linear measurements were taken every two weeks for
a period of eight weeks using a measuring scale in grams (g) and measuring tape in centimeter (cm).
The body linear measurements considered were body length (BL), body girth (BG), thigh length
(TL), keel length (KL) and shank length (SL). Data collected were subjected to variance
components of SAS (2002) and their heritability (h2) and repeatability (R) were estimated using the
expression described by Falconer (1989). The formulae used for h2 and R estimation are given
below:
Heritability:
h2 =
4δ2s
δ2T
Where; h2 = heritability estimates, δ2s = Variance due to sire, δ2T = Total variance
Repeatability:
Where;
= individuals variance component;
(
+ e)s = total phenotypic variance
e = variance due to error;
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Estimates of h2 and R for body weight and body linear measurements are presented in Tables 2 and
3. The h2 estimates ranged from low to moderate for body weight in sire line at 2 (0.07±1.67), 4
(0.18±0.41), 6 (0.19±0.36) and 8 (0.27±1.31) weeks of age, respectively. These estimates agreed
with the reports of Siripholvat et al. (1995) who reported low h2 estimates. Adeyinka et al. (2004)
however obtained moderate to high h2 estimates for body weight at different ages in naked neck
broilers. There was an increasing trend in the estimates of h2 for body weight with age in sire line,
which agreed with the reports of Chambers (1990). The h2 estimates for body weight in dam line
decreases with increasing age of birds (Table 2 and 3). This observation is in line with the report of
Kabir et al. (2006) who reported similar results in male and female lines of Rhode Island chickens.
Differences in h2 obtained could be attributed to method of estimation, strain or small sample size.
The h2 estimates for body linear measurements ranged from low to high for dam line, sire control
and dam control. This concur with the reports of Singh and Julvan (2007) who reported low to
moderate h2 for body linear measurements in van-cob broiler chickens. The low h2 estimates
obtained in this study for some of the body linear measurements from 2 to 8 weeks of age is in line
with the reports of Adeyinka et al. (2004) who reported similar results for naked neck broiler
chicken.
Low to moderate R estimates for the two lines and two control groups for body weight and body
linear measurements across all ages were obtained (Tables 2 and 3). The low to moderate estimates
of R obtained in this study disagreed with the earlier result of Kabir et al. (2010), who reported
higher R of 0.921 to 0.985 for body weight at 2 to 4 weeks of age in broiler chickens. The values for
body linear measurements are within the range for body linear measurements (0.170 to 0.962)
reported by Kabir et al. (2010). The values observed in this study also disagreed with reports of
Sola-Ojo et al. (2011), who reported high R for body weight ( 0.99) and body parts measured (0.61
to 0.99) at week 2, 4 and 6 for Arbor Acre broiler strain. The differences in the observed estimates
with literature values could be as a result of breed/or line difference and environmental effect.
Generally, low R estimates implies that larger numbers of records are required to retain or cull
parent chickens as opposed to fewer records required if the R estimates were high.
85
CONCLUSION
Variations observed in the estimate of h2 with respect to all the lines are indication of genetic
influence on these parameters. Low h2 obtained for body weight and body linear measurements
imply that high environmental effects could be responsible and it means that selection based on
individual performance alone may not be desirable. On the other hand, low R estimates implies that
lines used in this study have lower ability to repeat their present performance in the future and also
high numbers of records are required to realize expected response for selection.
REFERENCES
Adeyinka, I.A., Adejoh, E., Abubakar, B.Y., Sekoni, A.A. and Abeke, F.O. (2004). Genetic
parameter estimates of the body weights and linear measurements, in a population of naked
neck broiler chickens. In: Proceeding of the 29th Annual Conference of the Nigerian Society of
Animal Production, 29: 40-43
Boukwamp, E.L, Igbe, D.E. and Wabeck, C.J. (1973). Strains influenced on broiler part yield.
Poultry Science Journal, 2: 1517-1523.
Chambers J. R. (1990). Genetics of growth and meat production in chickens in Crawford R. D.
(Eds). Poultry Breeding and Genetics. Elsevier, Amsterdam, the Netherlands, 559-643.
Edward, H.M. and Denman, F. (1975). Carcass composition studies. Influence on of breed, sex, and
diet in gross composition of the carcass and fatty acid composition of the adipose tissue.
Poultry Science Journal, 52: 1230-1238
Falconer, D.S. (1989). Introduction to Quantitative Genetics, 3rd Editn. Longman Scientific and
Technical London.
Gaya, L.G., Ferraz, B.S., Balieiro, J.C.C., Mattos, E.C., Costa, M.A., Michelan F.T., Felicro, A.M.,
Rosa, A.F., Mourcio, G.B., Eler, J.P., Silva, M.E.B., Quieroz, L., Afaz, A.L.M., Longo, N.M.,
Garavazo, B.R. and Nakashima, S.H. (2006). Heritability estimates for meat quality traits in
male Broiler line. 8th World Congress on Genetics Applied to Livestock Production. August 1318, 2006, Belo Horizonto, MG. Brazil.
Grosso, J.I.B.M., Baliero, J.C.C., Eler, J.P., Ferraz J.B.S., Mattos, E.C. and Michelan, F.T. (2010).
Comparison of different models to estimate genetic parameters for carcass traits in a
commercial broiler line. Genetic and Molecular Research, 9(2):908-918.
Kabir, M., Nwagu, B.I. and Anthony, A.V. (2010). Comparative study of growth and linear body
measurements in Anak and Hubard Broiler breeds in the Northern Guinea Savannah Zone of
Nigeria. Journal of Agriculture, Forestry and Social Sciences (JOAFSS), 8(1):188–194.
http://www.ajol.info/index.php/joafss/article/view/64830
Kabir, M., Oni, O.O., Akpa G. N. and Adeyinka I.A. (2006) Heritability estimates and
interrelationships of body weight and shank length in Rhode island Red and White chickens.
Pakistan
Journal
of
Biological
Sciences,
9(15):
2892-2896.
http://scialert.net/abstract/?doi=pjbs.2006.2892.2896
Nawathe, D.R. and A.G. Larmorde (1987). Newcastle disease and poultry farming in Nigeria.
Nigeria Livestock Farmer. 7: 1- 4
SAS (2002). Statistical analysis system multiple incorporation. Users’ Guide Statistical version
Cary, NC. USA.
Siripholvat, V. Chansawang, S. and Sanguanphan, S. (1995). Heritability of the body weight of
crossbred broiler chickens selected in five generations. Kasetsart Journal of Natural Science,
29:28-37.
Singh, C. B. and Julvan M. H. (2007). Genetic and non genetic factors affecting body conformation
traits in Van-Cob broiler strain. Indian Journal of Animal Research. 41(2):29.
Sola-Ojo, F.E. and Ayorinde, K.L. (2011). Repeatability Estimates of some growth traits in four
broiler strains at different ages. Nigeria Journal of Genetics. 25, 118 – 123
86
Table 2: Estimates of h2 (±SE) and R for BW and body linear measurements at starter phase in
broiler chickens
Ages
BW
BL
BG
TL
(weeks) Line
R
h2s
R
h2s
R
h2s
R
h2s
R
2
Sire
0.018 0.07±1.67 0.119 0.48±0.94 0.129 0.52±0.87 0.102 0.41±1.06 0.112
Dam
0.069 1.27±0.42 0.190 0.76±0.37 0.350 1.40±0.44 0.194 0.78±0.33 0.079
S/C
0.084 0.34±1.25 0.021 0.08±1.75 0.045 018±1.56 0.005 0.02±1.86 0.063
D/C
0.100 0.4±1.14 0.108 0.43±1.08 0.165 0.66±0.91 0.098 0.27±1.39 0.029
4
Sire
0.050 0.18±0.41 0.145 0.58±0.73 0.013 0.05±1.63 0.083 0.31±1.19 0.107
Dam
0.193 0.77±0.36 0.188 0.75±0.39 0.251 1.00±1.12 0.227 0.91±0.14 0.039
S/C
0.030 0.12±1.90 0.021 0.09±1.96 0.006 0.02±2.11 0.032 0.13±1.88 0.015
D/C
0.001 0.01±1.89 0.040 0.16±1.59 0.065 0.26±1.84 0.064 0.26±1.84 0.089
BW=Body weight, BL= body length, BG=Body girth, TL= Thigh length, KL=keel length,
SL=Shank length, R=repeatability, h2=heritability, SE=standard error, S/C=sire control, D/C=dam
control.
KL
h2s
0.32±1.
0.31±1.
0.25±1.
0.12±1.
0.43±0.
0.16±1.
0.06±2.
0.36±1.
Table 3: Estimates of h2 (±SE) and R for BW and body linear measurements at finisher phase in
broiler chickens
Ages
BW
BL
BG
TL
KL
2
2
2
2
(weeks) Line
R
hs
R
hs
R
hs
R
hs
R
h2s
6
8
Sire
Dam
S/C
D/C
0.049
0.097
0.043
0.037
0.19±0.36
0.32±1.12
0.17±1.68
0.15±1.72
0.020
0.086
0.047
0.08±1.16
0.34±1.40
0.19±1.16
0.032
0.010
0.115
0.069
0.13±1.50
0.04±1.58
0.46±1.09
0.28±1.45
0.058
0.021
0.065
0.041
0.2±1.37
0.08±1.57
0.26±1.50
0.17±1.86
0.271
0.291
0.090
0.111
Sire
0.069 0.27±1.31 0.161 0.06±1.69 0.101 0.4±1.26 0.202 0.81±1.27 0.077
Dam
0.045 0.18±1.41 0.161 0.64±0.62 0.037 1.49±0.85 0.048 0.19±0.55 0.071
S/C
0.044 0.18±1.66 0.080 0.32±1.37 0.035 0.14±1.74 0.014 0.05±1.92 0.082
D/C
0.013 0.05±1.98 0.048 0.19±1.54 0.040 0.16±1.6 0.048 0.19±1.54 0.007
BW=Body weight, BL= body length, BG=Body girth, TL= Thigh length, KL=keel length,
SL=Shank length, R=repeatability, h2=heritability, SE=standard error, S/C=sire control, D/C=dam
control.
87
1.09±0.76
0.90±0.11
0.36±1.30
0.44±1.13
0.31±1.25
0.28±1.24
0.33±1.36
0.03±1.85
AGB10
SELECTION RESPONSE OF REPRODUCTIVE TRAITS AT DIFFERENT GENERATION
INTERVAL IN QUAIL UNDER THE TROPICAL CONDITIONS OF NIGERIA
Okuda E.U.1*, Adeyinka I.A.2, Orunmuyi, M.1, Akinsola, O.M. 1 , Shoyombo, A.J. 1, Yakubu, H. 2,
1,
Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Kaduna
State, Nigeria.
2
National Animal Production Reseach Institute, Shika, Kaduna State, Nigeria.
Corresponding email:eferomaokuda@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
A study was conducted to estimate genetic parameters of egg production and reproductive traits in
Japanese quail. A total of five hundred and twenty six Japanese quails, made up of three hundred
and ninety seven females and one hundred and twenty seven males were used to conduct the study.
The response to selection for egg production after two generations of selection was estimated. Egg
number (EGN), Egg weight at 12 weeks of age (EWT12), Age at sexual maturity (ASM) and Body
weight at 6 weeks of age (BWT6) averaged 46.04, 8.73gm, 39.73days and 163.28gm in generation
1 and the corresponding values for generation 2 are 45.36, 9.06gm, 39.86days and 163.70gm.
Percent fertility (Fert %) and percent hatchability (Hatch%) were recorded as, 80.43% and 77.99%
for the first generation and the corresponding values for the second generation were 82.05% and
67.14%. Heritability estimates of production traits ranged from low to high (0.05 - 0.96). Egg
number (EGN) had a negative correlation with Age at sexual maturity (ASM) (-1.21) but positively
correlated with Body weight (BWT) (0.14). Response to selection for egg number was 3.91. There
was a highly significantly (P<0.01) increase in egg number, from 36.55 at generation zero to 45.36
at the second generation of selection. In conclusion, selection in generation 0 based on egg number
to 12 weeks of age improved the egg number and BWT6 in generation 2.
Keywords: Egg number, Heritability, Age at sexual maturity, selection
INTRODUCTION
Poultry production is a fast means of meeting the ever-increasing demand for protein supply,
especially in Africa, where intake of protein is relatively low. This is because poultry production
has a rapid turnover rate. In other words, several tons of meat and eggs can be produced in a
relatively short interval of time. This prompted breeders to put more interest in the breeding of
quail, the laying performance of which is relatively high. Over six months laying period, the total
egg production in quails was ten times higher than female’s body weight, whereas in chicken such a
relation is reached only by the production gathered from 12 months (Richtrova, 1999).
88
The production of Japanese Quails has gained tremendous interest among Nigerian populace
especially because of the medicinal value of the egg. Japanese quails are also known for their low
caloric values in addition to having quality protein of high biological value (Haruna et al., 1997).
Studies using Japanese Quails in breeding experiments have demonstrated that this species offers
scientist several advantages in exploring breeding systems and certain applied problems of poultry
breeding. Improvement through selection requires estimates of genetic parameters. This study was
therefore designed to estimate the genetic parameters of egg production and reproductive traits in
Japanese quail.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The research was conducted at the Poultry Unit of the Animal Science Department, Ahmadu Bello
University, Samaru – Zaria. Zaria is geographically located between latitude 11012’N and longitude
7033’E, at an altitude of 610m above sea level. (Google Earth, 2011).
250 birds were bought from National Veterinary Research Institute Jos at two weeks of age. The
birds were raised together until four weeks of age before they were sexed. They were made up of
130 males and 120 females. The females were then put in individual cages and tagged according to
cage number. 40 sires were randomly selected to meet the mating ratio of 1:3. These formed the
base population. The dams were placed in individual cages with one sire mated to three dams by
introducing the sire into the cages, with the sire spending one night in each cage. The sires were
placed such that half-sib or full sib mating was completely avoided. The birds were fed with starter
diets of 2741 Kcal/Kg ME and 26% CP, for the first five weeks of age and then breeder diets of
2990Kcal/Kg ME and 23% CP (Dafwang, 2006). Water and feed were given ad libitum.
Fertile eggs were marked according to sire number over a seven-day period. The eggs were
incubated for a period of 16 days, 14 days in the setter and 2 days in the hatcher. The setter and
hatcher were equipped with separate boxes which were marked according to sire number in order to
pedigree hatch the chicks for the first generation. The hatched chicks were brooded in separate
boxes marked according to sire number, and then wing banded after 21 days.
Selection of females was based on each hen’s production plus the average of its full and half sibs,
while males were selected based on the performance of their female sibs. The selection procedure
was repeated to produce the second generation. Selection index constructed was based on the type
developed by Henderson (1963).
In notational form, the indexes can be written thus:89
I♀ = (P – x ) + b1 (D – x ) + b2 (S – x )
I♂ = b3 (D1– x ) + b4 (S1 – x )
Where x = population mean for the trait
P = a female breeding candidate’s own performance
D and D1 = average phenotypic values for the trait of full sisters of a female and male breeding
candidate, respectively.
S and S1 = average phenotypic values for the traits of half sisters of a female and male breeding
candidate, respectively.
b1, b2= regression coefficients of the trait on the index for females.
b3 and b4 = regression coefficients of the trait on the index for males.
2n 1 h 2
b1
4 n 2 h 2
nh
b2
2
b3
4 n 2 h
2
and
4 nd 1 h 2 2 h 2
4 n 2 h 2 4 n d 1 2 h 2
2 nd 1 h 2 2 h 2
b4
4 n 2 h 2 4 n d 1 2 h 2
Where
d = the number of dams; n = the number of offspring per dam
h2 = the heritability estimate
Body weight:
Individual body weights were recorded biweekly from hatch until 6 weeks of age to the nearest 0.1
gm. Body weights at two, four and six weeks of age were recorded ( BW2, BW4 and BW6).
Growth rate:
Individual absolute body weight gain during the different studied growth periods from two to four
and from four to six weeks of age were obtained according to (Brody, 1945) as follows:
G.R
W2 W1
1
W W1
2 2
100
Where,
G.R = Growth Rate
W1 = the weight at the beginning of the period.
W2 = the weight at the end of the period
Age at sexual maturity for females was individually recorded in days (ASM), total egg production
(numbers and weights) were recorded from the onset of lay till 12 weeks of production. However
daily egg mass was estimated as the average egg number multiplied by the average egg weight per
week (DEM).
90
Individual fertility and hatchability of each female were recorded accordingly. The hatched eggs
were recorded and the residual eggs in the hatcher were broken to determine the fertile eggs.
Percent fertility and percent hatchability were calculated as follows.
Percent Fertility
Total number of fertile eggs
100
Total number of egg set
Percent Hatchabili ty
Total number of chicks hatched
100
Total number of fertile eggs
Genetic parameter estimates
Genetic parameters were estimated using the sire model. The variance component was partitioned
into those due to sire or environment. The statistical model used was:
yij = µ + ai + eij
Where yij = the record of the jth progeny of ith sire.
µ = the common mean
ai = the effect of the ith sire
eij = the uncontrolled environmental and genetic deviations attributable to
the individuals. All error terms were random, normal and independent with expectation equal to
zero.
Heritability
Heritabilities of egg production, serum alkaline phosphatase activity and economic traits were
estimated using the formula
2
h
4 s2
T2
h2
=
heritability estimate
S2
=
Variance due to sire
T2
=
Total variance
Estimation of correlations
The coefficients of genetic correlation between different traits studied were computed from the sire
component of variance as follows:
rg =
4 cov s ( xy )
4 2 s ( x ) .4 2 s ( y )
S.E of rg =
1 2g
2
SEh 2 ( x ) xS .Eh 2 ( y )
h 2 ( x) h 2 ( y )
91
Estimating phenotypic correlation from sire component of variance
rp
cov w( xy ) cov s ( xy )
2 w ( x ) 2 s ( x ) . 2 w ( y ) 2 s ( y )
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 1 shows the least squares means (standard error) and coefficient of variation for growth
traits for generation 1 and 2. Body weight at 2, 4 and 6 weeks was averaged 39 gm, 96.66 gm and
163.29 gm respectively after two generation of selection. This is similar to what was reported by
AboulHassan (2000) who observed estimates of body weight at 2 weeks as 35.2 gm. Higher
estimates were reported by AboulHassan (2001) as 46.4 gm for the Brown strain of Japanese quail
and 40.2 gm for the White strain for body weight at two weeks of both sexes. For 4 weeks body
weight, Sharaf (1992) reported estimates ranging between 94.46gm and 100.45gm. For 6 weeks
body weight, El–Fiky (1991) reported an estimate of 128.1gm and 140.8 gm for males and females,
respectively. Body weight at 2, 4, and 6 weeks of age generally increased at the end of the first and
second generation after selection, when compared to the base generation. However body weight for
generation 1 was slightly higher than that of generation 2. Table 2 shows the least square means of
egg quality parameters of Japanese quails for generation 0, 1 and 2. The average EWT6, EWT8,
EWT12, EGN, and DEM were found to be 8.72gm, 9.04gm, 8.95gm, 46.04, and 8.61gm/day
respectively. These values are similar to what is found in literature. Abdul-Hasan (2004) reported
EWT and DEM as 10.56gm and 9.18gm/day respectively. Table 3 shows the heritability estimates
with standard error of heritability for generation 1 and 2. Heritability estimate obtained for EGN
(1.21), and ASM (1.63) were outside the parameter estimate. This could be due to low population
size. This is similar to what was reported by Wilhelmson (1979) and El-Fiky et al. (1994) who both
reported heritability estimates of 1.35 and 1.42 for ASM in Japanese quail. The heritability estimate
for EWT12 (0.56) differs from the findings of Abdel-Mounsef (2005), Saatci et al (2006) and Abou
Hassan (2001) who reported heritability of 0.12, 0.25, and 0.10 respectively. Estimates for other egg
production traits were low. Table 5 shows selection response for egg number and correlated
response for some economic traits. Egg number highly significantly (P<0.01) increased from 36.55
in generation zero to 45.36 at the second generation of selection. There was a slight decrease though
in the EGN recorded, from 46.04 in generation 1, to 45.36 in generation 2. The same trend was
reported by Aboul-Hassan (1997) and Aboul-Hassan (2001) when he selected Japanese quail for
increased BWT6 and EGN produced for the first ten weeks of laying. Other correlated responses
were observed as a result of selection for egg number. Negative response (-1.84) was observed in
ASM. This is so because the ASM reduced across the generation as EGN increased. Generally,
92
positive response of varying magnitude was observed for EWT12 (0.05), BWT6 (0.72) and DEM
(0.92).
CONCLUSION
From the results obtained in this study, selection in generation 0 based on egg number to 12 weeks
of age improved the egg number by 3.91, ASM by -1.84 days, EWT by 0.05gm, BWT6 by 0.72gm
and DEM by 0.92gm after two generations of selection.
93
Table 1. Least squares means (standard error) and coefficient of variation for growth traits
of Japanese Quails (Generation 1 and 2)
Gen 1
Gen 2
Traits*
LSM SE
C.V (%)
LSM SE
C.V (%)
BWT2
40.39 0.20
6.27
40.06 0.17
6.19
BWT4
97.17 0.22
2.86
96.88 0.19
2.93
BWT6
163.79 0.44
3.43
163.00 0.41
3.67
GR 4
80.96 0.77
11.98
83.02 0.41
7.15
GR 6
53.89 0.82
19.22
50.83 0.29
8.56
BWT2 =Body Weight at 2 weeks; BWT4= Body Weight at 4; BWT6= Body Weight at 6; GR4 =
Growth rate at 4 weeks; GR6= Growth rate at 6 weeks.
Table 2. Least Square Means (standard error) of Egg Quality parameters of Japanese quail for
generation 0, 1 and 2
Gen 0
Gen 1
Gen 2
Traits
LSMSE
CV%
LSMSE
CV%
LSMSEM
CV%
EGN
36.55±0.92b
24.72
46.04±0.29a
7.27
45.36±0.21a
6.29
b
10.80
a
9.16±0.07
9.54
b
8.56±0.06
10.07
EGW6
8.41±0.09
EGW8
8.89±0.06b
6.37
9.15±0.04a
5.32
9.04±0.04a
5.97
EGW12
9.02±0.09
10.09
8.73±0.18
23.59
9.06±0.06
9.86
AGW
8.77±0.06b
6.68
9.02±0.07a
8.77
8.87±0.04a
6.22
EGH6
2.19±0.01
5.79
2.14±0.05
27.07
2.14±0.03
23.00
EGD6
b
24.66
a
35.70
a
1.89±0.05
2.11±0.06
2.04±0.05
34.13
ALH6
0.11±0.00b
26.53
0.14±0.01a
93.50
0.13±0.01a
86.41
ALW6
4.04±0.06
15.14
4.02±0.05
14.47
3.98±0.04
16.49
YLH6
0.58±0.00b
10.37
2.16±0.51a
68.03
1.72±0.37a
89.06
YLW6
3.13±0.08
28.01
3.08±0.06
23.35
3.20±0.05
21.53
SHT6
22.22±0.51a
22.67
19.87±0.70b
39.67
20.59±0.53a
34.36
a
b
a
EGH12
2.69±0.01
4.71
2.52±0.06
28.60
2.57±0.04
24.11
EGD12
2.037±0.05b
24.18
2.27±0.07a
37.44
2.20±0.05a
35.45
ALH12
0.11±0.00b
30.54
0.15±0.01a
99.36
0.14±0.01a
92.30
ALW12
4.55±0.06
14.24
4.50±0.05
14.77
4.47±0.05a
16.28
YLH12
0.63±0.00b
9.49
2.29±0.54a
64.79
1.82±0.39
84.69
YLW12
3.22±0.09
29.19
3.01±0.08
33.39
3.18±0.06
28.25
94
SHT12
23.25±0.52
22.09
23.88±0.15
7.48
23.78±0.19
10.64
DEM
6.43±0.17c
26.99
10.07±0.47a
52.89
8.75±0.06b
9.26
HGU6
57.58±1.84a
2.68
58.99±1.24b
1.98
59.95±1.03b
1.92
HGU12
58.98±1.75a
6.55
59.88±2.05b
5.37
59.11±1.45b
2.02
YIN6
a
1.53±0.00
YIN12
0.12±0.01a
5.49
a
1.61±0.01
0.62
0.18±0.01a
6.86
b
0.61±0.01
1.85
0.15
0.20±0.01b
2.53
Means with different superscripts across the row are significantly different (P < 0.05)
EGW= Egg Weight; EGN= Egg Number; DEM= Daily egg mass. EGN=Egg number;
EGW=Egg weight, SHT= Shell thickness; ALP20= Plasma alkaline phosphatase activity at 20
weeks; HGU= Haugh Unit; YIN= Yolk Index; ALH=Albumen height; ALD= Albumen width;
EGD= Egg width; YLW=yolk weight
Table 3. Heritability Estimates (standard error) of Growth, Production and Egg
Quality Traits for Generations 1 and 2
Gen 1
Gen 2
Traits
Heritability±SE
Heritability±SE
EGN
1.20±0.42
0.05±0.15
ASM
0.29±0.28
1.63±0.44
EGW12
1.25±0.42
0.56±0.29
HGU6
0.64±0.35
0.22±0.20
YIN6
0.90±0.39
0.42±0.26
SHT6
1.55±0.44
0.33±0.23
HGU12
1.14±0.41
0.42±0.27
YIN12
0.96±0.39
0.16±0.18
SHT12
0.58±0.34
0.20±0.19
BWT6
0.39±0.25
0.20±0.20
+SEE TABLE 2 FOR MEANING
95
Table 4. Selection response of reproductive traits at different generation intervals
Traits
Response
Cumulative
Response±SE
G0
G1
G2
G1
G2
EGN
36.55
46.04
45.36
9.49
-0.68
3.91±0.35
ASM
43.97
39.73
39.86
-4.24
0.13
-1.84±0.17
EGW12
9.02
8.73
9.06
-0.29
0.33
0.05±0.08
SHT12
23.25
23.88
23.78
0.63
-0.1
-0.15±0.11
BWT6
162.09
163.30
163.02
1.21
-0.28
0.72±0.36
DEM
6.43
10.07
8.75
3.64
-1.34
0.92±0.21
EGN=Egg number, EGW= Egg weight, SHT= Shell thickness, ASM=Age at sexual
maturity, DEM= Daily egg mass
REFERENCES
Aboul- Hassan M.A (2001) Crossbreeding effects on some growth and egg productiontraits among
two strains of Japanese quail. Al–Azhar Journal of Agricultural Research ,34:41-57.
Abdul- Hassan M.A (2004) Selection for high egg production in Japanese quail : Direct and
correlated responses. Al–Azhar Journal of Agricultural Research, 34: 25-40.
Dafwang, I. I. (2006). Nutrient requirements and feeding regiment in Quail production. A paper
presented at the National Workshop on Quail Production for Sustainable Household Protein
Intake. National Agricultural Extension and Research Liason Services, Ahmadu Bello
University, Zaria. September 11th -13th pp 12-19.
El–Fiky, F. A. (1991). Genetic studies on some economic traits in Japanese quail. Ph.D. Thesis,
Faculty of Agriculture Al-Azhar University Egypt.
El-Fiky,F. A; Shamma, T. A. and El-Oksh, H. A. (1994). Genetic parameters of some productive
and reproductive traits in Japanese quail; Environmental Arid Land Agricultural Science, 5:
45-60.
El–Fiky, F. A; (1995). Effects of intensive inbreeding on some productive traits in Japanese quail.
Annals of Agricultural Science Moshtohor, 34: 189- 202.
F.A.O. (1992). Food and Agriculture Organization. Prof. A E. Bender. Meat Production, pp. 2.
Google Earth. (2011). Google location map; Google earth imagery date; December 3rd ,
2011.
Haruna, E.S., Musa, U., Lombin, I.H., Tat, D.B., Sharmaki, D.D., Okewole, D.A. and Molokwu,
J.V. (1997). Introduction of Quail production in Nigeria. Nigeria Veterinary Journal, 18:
104-107
Henderson, C.R. (1963). Selection index and expected genetic advance. Statistical genetics and
plant breeding, National Academy of Science, National Resources Council Publication
Washington. Pp. 982.
Richtrova A. (1999). Influence of male presence in cages with female on the parameters of egg
production of Japanese quails (Cortinix japonica). Zesyty Naukowe Przegl du Hodowlanego,
45:189 – 199.
96
Saatci, M., Omed, H and Ap-Dewi, I. (2006). Genetic parameters from univariate and bivariate
analyses of egg and weight traits in Japanese quail. Poultry Science 85:185-190.
Sharaf, M. M. (1992). Genetic and nongenetic estimates of some reproductive and productive traits
in Japanese quail. Egypt Poultry Science, 12: 211-231.
Sittman, K; Abplanalp, H. and Fraser, R. (1966). Inbreeding depression in Japanese quail. Genetics,
54: 371-379.
Tawefeuk, F. A. (2001). Studies in quails breeding using selection index for the improvement of
growth and egg production in Japanese quail. Ph.D. Thesis, Faculty of Agriculture Tanta,
University Egypt .
Wilhelmson, M. (1979). Breeding experiments with Japanese quail. The synthesis of random mated
population . Report 39, Swedish University of Agriculture.
AGB11
REPEATABILITY OF CLUTCH SIZE AND HATCHLING SIZE IN TRADITIONALLYMANAGED YORUBA AND FULANI ECOTYPE CHICKENS
Fayeye, T.R.*, Sola-Ojo, F.E., Ojo, V., Alagbe, O.F. and Owoeye, B.
Department of Animal Production, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Ilorin, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: fayetiro@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Progeny history of 408 and 350 traditionally-managed dam families of Yoruba and Fulani ecotype
chickens were used to estimate the repeatability of clutch size and hatchling size. Mean clutch size
and hatchling size for Yoruba ecotype chicken were 5.68 ± 5.37 eggs and 5.02 ± 4.86 chicks,
respectively. Corresponding mean values for the two traits in Fulani ecotype chicken were 4.13±
5.84 eggs and 2.94± 4.44 chicks, respectively. Clutch size and hatchling size were higher in Yoruba
ecotype than Fulani ecotype chicken. Generally, both clutch size and hatchling size declined in the
two ecotypes as the hatch number increased. Repeatability of clutch size and hatchling size in
Yoruba ecotype chicken were -0.41± 0.17 and -0.43± 0.01, respectively. Corresponding values for
the two traits in Fulani ecotype chicken were lower (-0.28±0.16 and -0.23±0.14, respectively). The
negative repeatability estimates obtained in the two flocks suggest that both clutch size and
hatchling size would likely decline with increasing hatch number per hen. The low mean
repeatability estimates obtained for hatchling size suggest that collection of additional records and
improvement of non-genetic factors are needed to improve the accuracy of characterizing bird’s
inherent transmitting ability for this trait.
Keywords: Clutch size, Hatchling size, Repeatability, Yoruba ecotype, Fulani ecotype
INTRODUCTION
Repeatability is the proportion total variation attributable to differences among individuals (Wolak
et al., 2012). It tells how an animal will repeat its performance in a given trait during its lifetime.
Statistically, it is the correlation between records from the same animal (Dalton, 1982).
Repeatability estimate of reproductive traits indicates the extent at which selection will influence
future animal reproductive performance (Ibe, 1995). Indigenous poultry population in Nigeria
include the Yoruba and Fulani ecotype chickens. Fulani ecotype chicken is one of the bestpreserved local chickens in Nigeria because of the cultural lifestyle of the Fulani keepers (Fayeye
and Oketoyin, 2006). These birds are important genetic resources because of their adaptability to
the stressful tropical environment. NRC (1993) recommended a study of the level of genetic
diversity in different populations as the first step to bring about improvement in the performance of
chicken in developing countries. Most of the works done on local chicken by animal breeders in
Nigeria have been limited to morphometric characterization (Olori, 1992, Fayeye et al., 2006,
97
Olawunmi et al., 2008) and their crossbreeding potential. For instance, Olori (1992) reported that
Fulani ecotype chicken has superior bodyweight and fleshing than the Yoruba ecotype chicken.
Clutch size and hatchling size are important reproductive parameters that influence sustainability of
flock size of smallholder poultry producers. Knowledge of these two basic reproductive parameters
is invaluable for adequate characterization and genetic improvement of both Yoruba and Fulani
ecotype chickens. No previous work is known on the repeatability of clutch size and hatchling size
in traditionally managed Yoruba and Fulani ecotype chickens. The present work is therefore aimed
at determining the repeatability of clutch size and hatchling size in traditionally managed Yoruba
and Fulani ecotype chickens.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Origin of flock: The Yoruba ecotype chickens were obtained from four Yoruba communities
(Ogbomoso, Igbon, Gambari and Gbede) in Oyo state. The last three communities have close
proximity with Ogbomoso (Longitude, 08:150 N; Latitude, 04: 150 E, Altitude 300-600 mm above
sea level, Temperature, 270C, Rainfall, 1247mm). The Fulani ecotype chickens were obtained from
eighteen (18) Fulani kraals (Table 1). All the kraals have close proximity with Ilorin (Longitude,
08: 290 N; Latitude, 04: 350 E, Altitude 305m, 1001', Temperature, 33-370C, Rainfall, 600-1200
mm). The two coordinates are 51.36km apart.
Animal genotypes and data collection: Progeny History Technique of the Participatory Rural
Appraisal (Kassaye et al., 1992; Iles 1994) was used to collect clutch size records and hatchling size
of 408 and 350 traditionally-managed dam families of Yoruba and Fulani ecotype chickens. The
animals were identified as Yoruba or Fulani ecotype chickens based on their phenotypic
characteristics and the information given by flock owners.
Statistics: Data on clutch size and hatchling size obtained from the two ecotype chickens were
subjected to Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) of the SPSS (SPSS, 1996) to obtain the required mean
square between and within class of the hens’ records. The clutch size and hatchling size per hen (i.e.
k1) were estimated as the harmonic mean of the records obtained from the dam families of Yoruba
and Fulani ecotype chickens. Mean squares obtained from ANOVA were equated to their expected
values and the resulting equation solved for the required variance components. Repeatability of
clutch size and hatchling size were obtained from between and within class variance components
using the formula below (Becker, 1992).
Repeatability (R) =
σ2I
σ2I + σ2e
Where σ2I =variance due to the effect of individual hen of either Yoruba or Fulani-ecotypes and
σ2e = variance due to within individual hen’s records or random error
The Standard Error of Repeatability or S.E (R) was obtained from the equation given by Swiger et.
al. (1964) as follows:
S.E (R) =√2 (M-1) (1-R) 2 [1 + (K1 – 1) R] 2
K12 (M-N) (N-1)
When M = total member of record for hen belonging to Yoruba or Fulani ecotype chickens
N = Numbers of hens
K1 = harmonic mean of the records obtained from the 408 and 350 traditionally-managed
98
Dam families of Yoruba and Fulani ecotype chickens, respectively
K1 was estimated as follows:
1
X
(M - ∑mk2)
N-I
Mk
Where Mk = numbers of records per ith hen
The statistical model for obtaining the variance components used in calculating repeatability was as
follows:
Yij = µ + αi + eij
where
Yij = record from the jth clutch or hatch by the ith hen
µ = population mean
αi = effect of the ith hen
eij = random error.
All the effects were assumed to be random, normal and independent with their expectation equals to
zero.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The mean clutch size and hatchling size for Yoruba ecotype chicken were 5.68 ± 5.37 eggs and 5.02
± 4.86 chicks, respectively. Corresponding mean values for the two traits in Fulani ecotype chicken
were 4.13± 5.84 eggs and 2.94± 4.44 chicks, respectively (Table 2). Clutch size and hatchling size
in the two ecotype chickens were influenced by hatch number. Generally, the clutch size and
hatchling size declined in the two ecotypes as the hatch number increased (Table 2). Repeatability
of clutch size and hatchling size in Yoruba ecotype chicken were -0.41± 0.17 and -0.43± 0.01,
respectively (Table 3). Corresponding values for the two traits in Fulani ecotype chicken were
lower (-0.28±0.16 and -0.23±0.14, respectively). Mean clutch size for Yoruba and Fulani ecotype
chickens were lower than 10.7 eggs reported by Gondwe (2005) for local Malawian chicken. Such
variation is common in laying performance of African village chickens (Gueye, 1998), perhaps due
to genetic and vagaries of environmental effects. The mean hatchling size observed in this study for
both Yoruba and Fulani-ecotypes were within the preponderance range (Adebayo et al., 2013) for
local chicken obtained from rural communities in Kwara state. Repeatability estimates obtained in
the present study for both Yoruba and Fulani-ecotypes fell within 0.05-0.85 reported for two
commercial layer strains by Udeh (2010). Negative repeatability estimates obtained in the two
flocks suggests that both clutch size and hatchling size will likely decline with increasing brooding
records. The low mean repeatability estimates obtained for the hatchling size suggest that collection
of additional records and improvement of non-genetic factors are needed to improve the accuracy of
characterizing the inherent transmitting ability of both Yoruba and Fulani ecotype chickens for this
trait.
REFERENCES
Adebayo, S.A., Ogunlade, I. and Fayeye, T.R. (2013). Scope and Common Diseases of Rural
Poultry Production by Rural Women in Selected Villages of Kwara State, Nigeria.
International Journal of Poultry Science, 12 (3): 126-129.
Becker W. A. (1992). Manual of Quantitative Genetics .5th edn. Academic Enterprises Pullman.
Fayeye, T. R. and Oketoyin, A. B. (2006). Characterisation of the Fulani ecotype Chicken for
Thermoregulatory Feather Gene. Livestock Research for Rural Development.Vol.18, Article
#45.
99
Gueye, E. F. (1998). Poultry plays an important role in African village life. Wld. Poulry Sci., 14:147.
Gondwe, T. N. P. (2005). Characterisation of Local Chicken in Low Input - Low Output Production
systems. Is there scope for appropriate production and breeding strategies in Malawi. Zugl,;
Gottingen: Cuvillier, 174 pp. ISBN 3-86537-354-2
Iles, K. (1994). Progeny history data collection technique: A case study from Samburu District
Kenya. Rural Rapid Appraisal (RRA) Notes, 20: 71-77.
Kassaye H., Mohammed Y. and Girmay T. (1992). Interviewing cows. Rural Rapid Appraisal
(RRA) Notes, 15, 52-53.
NRC
(1993).
National
Academy
of
Sciences,
Washington
D.
C.
Olawunmi, O.O.; Salako, A.E. and Afuwape, A. A. (2008). Morphometric differentiation
and assessment of function of the Fulani and Yoruba ecotype indigenous Chickens of
Nigeria. International Journal Morphology, 26(4): 975 – 980.
Olori, V. E. (1992). Evaluation of two-ecotype of the Nigerian indigenes chicken. M.Sc thesis,
Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile -Ife, Nigeria.
SPSS (1996). Statistical Package for Social Sciences SPSS inc., Michigan avenue, Chicago.
Swiger L. A., Harvey W. R., Everson D. O. and Gregory K. E. (1964). The variance of intraclass correlation involving groups within one observation. Biometrics, 20, 818.
Udeh, I. (2010). Repeatability of Egg Number and Egg Weight in Two Strains of Layer Type
Chicken.
International
Journal
of
Poultry
Science,
9
(7).
http://openagricola.nal.usda.gov/Record/IND44413638
Wolak, M. E, Fairbairn, D. J. and Paulsen, Y. R. (2012). Guidlines for estimating repeatability. In.
Methods in ecology and evolution. Volume 3 (1): 129-137.
Table 1: Communal distribution of sampled Fulani ecotype chicken
Location
ILORIN SOUTH
ILORIN EAST
IFELODUN
settlement
Bolunduro
Gaa Seriki Sambata
Gaa Mogaji
Gaa Mumiri
Aleniboro
Gaa Alhaji Baare
Gaa Atende
Gaa Atirun
Gaa Adire Hara
Gaa Gahara
Gida Idi
Gida Mogaji
Gida Idi Ose
Gaa Mubari
Gaa Oseri
No. of hens
24
11
3
6
6
28
24
39
13
14
15
6
40
39
42
100
No. Of chicks
310
193
65
117
98
347
247
364
219
179
130
48
424
385
464
3
Gaa Ibata
Gaa Mogaji
Gaa Aljaji Osere
18
16
12
12
350
244
104
154
4,092
Table 2: Mean (± SD) Clutch size and hatchling size in Yoruba and Fulani ecotype chickens.
No of eggs laid± SD
Hatch Number
Yoruba ecotype
Fulani ecotype
1
10.05±2.02
11.12±2.69
2
7.10±5.12
4.86±6.57
3
4.10±5.37
0.50±2.54
4
1.46 ±3.86
*
Overall
5.6789±5.37
4.13±5.84
*Records not used because of small sample size
No of egg hatched± SD
Yoruba ecotype
8.93±2.32
6.33±4.64
3.59±4.84
1.24±3.23
5.02 ±4.86
Fulani ecotype
7.86±3.00
3.54±5.11
0.36± 1.95
*
2.94±4.44
Table 3: Variance components and repeatability estimates of Clutch size and hatchling size in
Yoruba
and Fulani ecotype chickens
Characteristics
Egg laid
Egg hatched
Yoruba-ecotype
Fulani-ecotype Yoruba-ecotype Fulani-ecotype
Variance between
-7.54
-8.9
-6.31
-4.17
Variance within
25.75
40.41
21.07
22.64
Repeatability ± S.E
-0.41± 0.17
-0.28±0.16
-0.43± 0.010
-0.23±0.14
101
AGB12
HETEROSIS, GENERAL AND SPECIFIC COMBINING ABILITY OF TWO BREEDS OF
RABBIT AND THEIR CROSSES UNDER PREVAILING SOUTHERN GUINEA
SAVANNA ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS OF NIGERIA
Egena, S. S. A. 1*, Akpa, G. N. 2, Alemede, I. C1. and Aremu, A1.
1
Department of Animal Production, Federal University of Technology, P.M.B 65, Minna, Niger
State, Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Science, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Kaduna State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding author’s email address: acheneje.egena@futminna.edu.ng
ABSTRACT
An experiment was conducted to estimate heterosis, general combining ability (GCA) and specific
combining ability (SCA) of two breeds of rabbit. The rabbit breeds used for the experiment were
the New Zealand White (NZW) and Chinchilla (CH). Six breeding bucks (three/breed) and eighteen
breeding does (nine/breed) served as the foundation animals. Data were collected on litter size at
birth (LSB), litter body weight (LBW), gestation length (GL), kindling loss (KL), coefficient of
milking capacity (CMC), litter size at weaning (LSW), litter weight at weaning (LWW), litter
weight gain (LWG) and survival rate to weaning (SRW). Data were also collected on body weight
(BW), nose to shoulder length (NTS), shoulder to tail length (STL), heart girth (HG), trunk length
(TL) and length of ear (LE). Results revealed that, positive heterosis was estimated for LSB (11.89
%), LBW (13.51 %), GL (7.23 %), KL (22.22 %), CMC (5.13 %) and LSW (1.25 %) while
negative heterosis was observed for LWW (-3.69 %), LWG (-8.02 %) and SRW (-2.45 %).
Superiority percentage was positive only for LSB (2.60 %), LBW (5.00 %) and GL (5.88 %) while
the other parameters showed negative values. Significant GCA was observed only for IBW and
NTS in the CH breed while significant SCA was observed in the NZW x CH cross for STL, HG and
TL, and for HG, TL and LE in the CH x NZW cross, respectively. It was concluded that crossing
the two breeds of rabbit, led to hybrid vigour for LSB, LBW, GL, KL, CMC and LSW,
respectively. IBW and NTS could also be improved upon in the CH at the genetic level while STL,
HG and TL (NZW x CH), and HG, TL and LE (CH x NZW) could be improved upon by improving
the environment of the rabbits.
102
Key words: Heterosis, general combining ability, specific combining ability, breed, and rabbit.
Introduction
Breeding is an option towards increasing dietary protein supply through the production of animals
of high genetic merit. This is because genetic differences exist in animals even of the same breed.
These differences are important potential raw materials necessary for genetic improvement of
animals. Crossbreeding as a breeding system, exploits heterosis in animal breeding and it could be
fruitfully employed in rabbit breeding for increasing productivity (Reddy et al., 2003). Positive
effects of crossbreeding have been reported on growth traits in rabbits (Orengo et al., 2004; Abou
Khadiga et al., 2008). General combining ability (GCA) is a measure of the influence of additive
genes effects, while Specific combining ability (SCA) measures the effect of non-additive genes.
The performance of all crosses that derive from one breed is designated the general combining
ability of the breed while, specific combining ability, a joint attribute of two breeds signifies the
deviation of crosses from the sum of the general combining abilities of the crosses parents (RubioRubio et al., 2004). Analysis of diallel crosses enables the breeder to partition total genetic variation
into additive (GCA) and non-additive (SCA) genetic variance (Nagpure et al., 1991). Both additive
and non-additive genes have an impact on traits evaluated in rabbits (Obasi and Ibe, 2008).
Knowledge of the type of gene action operating in animals therefore will enable breeders to
formulate suitable breeding plans for the genetic improvement of characters of economic
importance in such animals. The objectives of this study therefore, are to estimate heterosis, general
and specific combining ability of two breeds of rabbit in a southern guinea savannah area of
Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was carried out at the Rabbitry section of the Teaching and Research Farm of the
Department of Animal Production, Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria.
Rabbits used for this study were NZW and CH breeds. The rabbits were housed in groups (i.e
according to breed) in well ventilated and shaded hutches. Feed (16 % CP; 2776 Kcal/Kg
formulated concentrate, Tridax procumbens as well as legume hay supplement) and water were
given ad libitum. Does were randomly assigned to one of the three bucks within their breed.
Thereafter, does from the second breed were mated to bucks from the first breed and vice versa to
obtain the crossbred. Mating began when the rabbits were between 4-5 months of age (i.e 120-150
days). Does were monitored for pregnancy through palpation of the abdominal region. Five days to
kindling, nesting boxes were placed in the doe’s hutch. The litter and weaning traits measured were:
103
LSB, LBW, GL, KL, CMC, LSW, LWW, LWG, and SRW. The body dimensions measured using
flexible tape rule were: NTS, STL, HG, TL and LE. Data obtained from the purebred and crossbred
matings were used to estimate heterosis and superiority percentages. Heterosis and superiority
percentages of crossbreds were calculated according to Abdel-Azeem (2007). The formulae are:
Heterosis % = [(MF – MP) / MP] X 100
1
Where MF = Mean of crossbred generation and MP = Mid-parent value. Mid-parent value is = 1/2
1
(MP +MP ) where P1 and P2 are parents 1 and 2 respectively.
1
2
Superiority % = [(MF – BP)/BP] X 100
1
Where MF = Mean of crossbred generation and BP = Better-parent value.
1
General and specific combining abilities were estimated using the statistical model below.
Yijkl = µ + gi + gj + sij + rij + 1/bc∑eijkl
Where Yijkl = the mean of the ith x jth genotype over
k
and l, µ = overall mean, gi = general
combining ability (GCA) effect of the ith parent, gj = general combining ability (GCA) effect of the
jth parent,
sij
= interaction i.e specific combining ability (SCA) effect, rij = reciprocal effect and
1/bc∑eijkl = random error effect. General combining ability (GCA) was estimated using the
expression
GCA = 1/2n (Yi. + Y.i) – 1/n2Y
Specific combining ability (SCA) was estimated using the expression
SCA = ½ (Yij + Yji) – 1/2n (Yi. + Y.i + Yj. + Y.j) + 1/n2Y
Where n = number of records considered or number of breeds involved in the cross; Y= the sum of
the observations Y1 + Y2 + Y3 + … + Yn for the respective breeds (i or j) of rabbit. The expressions
were fitted to a Microsoft Excel generated programme.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Estimate of heterosis and superiority of the crossbred in litter and weaning traits are presented in
Table 1. The positive heterosis observed for LSB, LBW, GL, KL, CMC and LSW as well as,
104
positive superiority of the crossbred over their parents in LSB, LBW and GL means that the
magnitude of non-additive gene effect (mainly dominance) for these traits is comparatively
substantial. This could be because the base population differ in the frequency of genes affecting the
traits. This means that the less the degree of genetic resemblance, the greater the magnitude of the
heterosis. Some of the traits however showed negative heterosis. This means that crossbreeding is
associated with negative effect or has little significance on these traits (although this is not
applicable to all the traits). Keambou et al. (2010) attributed strong negative heterosis to greater
genetic distance between tested breeds. The negative sign in no way invalidate the definition of
heterosis however as the nature of heterosis really is dependent on the nature of the measurement.
The negative heterosis and superiority effect observed for SRW is actually advantageous as it
indicates the positive effect of crossbreeding in diminishing the negative effect of the trait. This is
because a larger proportion of the crossbred litter will survive. This is of great economic importance
to rabbit farmers.
Estimates of GCA and SCA for body weight and linear body measurements are presented in Table
2. The significant GCA effect observed for IBW and NTS is indicative of the importance of
additive genes for the expression of these traits. The superior performance of the CH breed suggests
that it has the upmost preponderance of genes which impact additive gene effect on the growth
traits. This demonstrates that CH rabbits could possibly increase in growth performance because of
their higher GCA values. Reports by Rubio-Rubio et al. (2004) indicate that breed differences exist
for GCA in rabbits for litter and weaning traits. Maximum utilization of additive genetic variance
could be made therefore using CH rabbits for better body weight and nose to shoulder length. Kabir
et al. (2009) opined that this is because heritability values for these traits are expected to be
moderate to high.
The combination CH x NZW was superior for all the traits studied but there was no advantage
pertaining to the use of male or female lines for any of the breeds to exploit non-additive genetic
variance in IBW, NTS (both crosses), STL (CH x NZW cross) and LE (NZW x CH cross) since no
significant effect was observed for these traits. Significant SCA observed for some of the traits
however, is indicative of non-additive gene action. Such traits could therefore be improved upon
genetically through the utilization of non-additive gene effects such as dominance and epistasis, and
also by improved management of the environment. Kabir et al. (2009) also reported on the superior
performance of CH x NZW cross over those involving NZW x CH and California white x chinchilla
cross when they evaluated litter traits in three breeds of rabbit. The negative non-significant
105
(p>0.05) SCA observed for the NZW x CH cross is according to Nagpure et al. (1991), indicative
of such crossing resulting in the depression of such traits.
In conclusion, results from the study showed that crossing the two breeds of rabbit, led to hybrid
vigour for some litter and weaning traits (LSB, LBW, GL, KL, CMC and LSW respectively).
Individual body weight and NTS could be improved upon in the CH at the genetic level due to
significant and positive GCA attributable to additive genetic variance, while STL, HG and TL
(NZW x CH), and HG, TL and LE (CH x NZW) could be improved upon by improving the
environment of the rabbits.
REFERENCES
Abdel-Azeem, A.S., Abdel-Azim, A.M., Darwish, A.A. and Omar, E.M. (2007). Litter traits
in
four pure breeds of rabbits and their crosses under prevailing environmental conditions of
Egypt. The 5th International Conference on Rabbit Production in Hot Climate. Hurghada,
Egypt. Pp: 39 – 51.
Abou Khadiga, G.S.M., Saleh, K., Nofal, R. and Baselga, M. (2008). Genetic evaluation of growth
traits in a crossbreeding experiment involving line V and Baladi Black rabbits in Egypt.
Proceedings of the 9th World Rabbit Conference. 10-13th, June. Verona, Italy. Pp: 23-27.
Kabir, M., Akpa, G.N., Nwagu, B.I. and Adeyinka, I.A. (2009). Estimates of general and specific
combining abilities for litter traits in a 3 x 3 diallel crossing of rabbits. Proceedings of the
36th Annual Conference of the Nigerian Society for Animal Production. 13th – 16th, March.
Abuja, Nigeria. Pp: 39-41.
Keambou, T.C., Manjeli, Y., Boukila, B., Mboumba, S., Mezui Mezui, T. and Hako
Touko,
B.A. (2010). Heterosis and reciprocal effects of growth performances in F1 crosses
generations of Local x Hubbard chicken in the Western Highlands of Cameroon. Livestock
Research for Rural Development 22(1). http://www.lrrd.org/lrrd22/1/keam22011.htm
Nagpure, N.S., Kothekar, M.D., Gore, A.K. and Deshmukh, S.N. (1991). Estimation of general and
specific combining ability variances from a 4 x 4 diallel cross in rabbits. Journal of Applied
Rabbit Research, 14:38-43.
Obasi, V.N. and Ibe, S.N. (2008). Influence of additive and non-additive gene effects on body
measurements in the domestic rabbit. Nigerian Journal of Animal Production, 35(1):1-8.
Orengo, J., Gomez, E.A., Piles, M., Rafel, O. and Ramon, J. (2004). Growth traits in simple
crossbreeding among dam and sire lines. Proceedings of the 8th World Rabbit Congress. 7th10th, September. Puebla, Mexico. Pp: 114-120.
106
Reddy, V.G.K., Prabhakar Rao, V., Eswara Reddy, C., Prasad, V.L.K. and Ramesh Gupta, B.
(2003). Pre-weaning performance of 3-way cross rabbits. Indian Journal of Animal Science,
73(1): 97-99.
Rubio-Rubio, M., Torres-Hernandez, G., Martinez-Garcia, A., Mastache-Lagunas, A.A. and
Lagunas-Silva, M.G. (2004). Genetic components of litter performance in a diallel cross
involving four rabbit breeds. Proceedings of the 8th World Rabbit Congress. 7th-10th,
September. Puebla, Mexico. Pp:152-157.
Table 1: Estimates of heterosis and superiority of two breeds of rabbits and their crosses
Traits
Pure breed average
Crossbred average
Heterosis (%)
Superiority
%
Litter
LSB
4.585
5.13
11.89
2.60
185
210
13.51
5.00
32.585
34.94
7.23
5.88
KL (g)
135
165
22.22
-2.94
CMC
0.195
0.205
5.13
-2.38
LSW
3.60
3.645
1.25
-4.08
LWW (g)
1355
1305
-3.69
-8.74
LWG (g)
1185
1090
-8.02
-13.49
SRW (%)
83.145
81.11
-2.45
-11.84
LBW (g)
GL
Weaning
LSB= litter size at birth; LBW= litter body weight; GL= gestation length; KL= kindling loss;
CMC= coefficient of milking capacity; LSW= litter size at weaning; LWW= litter weaning weight;
LWG= litter weight gain; SRW= survival rate to weaning.
107
Table 2: Estimates of General (GCA) and Specific (SCA) combining ability for body
Weight and body linear measurements
Combining ability
IBW
NTS
STL
HG
TL
LE
NZW
-3.790
5.921
1.184
-1.776
-2.369
-5.921
CH
1.895*
1.184*
-1.184
2.961
5.921
-2.961
NZW x CH
-10.492
-0.035
-0.258*
-0.161*
-0.144*
-0.028
CH x NZW
18.321
0.093
0.090
0.128*
0.181*
0.106*
GCA
SCA
*Significant (p<0.05); IBW= Individual body weight; NTS=Nose to shoulder length; STL=
Shoulder
to tail length; HG=Heart girth; TL= Trunk length; LE=Length of ear; NZW= New Zealand White;
CH= Chinchilla; GCA=general combining ability; SCA=specific combining ability.
108
AGB13
GENETIC
RELATIONSHIP
BETWEEN
CLARIAS
ANGUILLARIS
AND
HETEROBRANCHUS BIDORSALIS FROM THREE ECOLOGICAL ZONES IN NIGERIA
Onyia, L. U.1*, Ladu, B.M.B.2 and Olufeagba, S.O.3
1
Department of Fisheries, 2Department of Biological Sciences,
Modibbo Adama, University of Technology, P.M.B. 2076, Yola, Nigeria.
3
Aquaculture and Biotechnology Centre, National Institute for Freshwater
Fisheries Research, P.M.B. 6006, New Bussa, Niger State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding author’s email address: uchelucky2005@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
The phylogenetic relationship among Clariidae species (Teleostei Siluriformes) from different
ecological zones in Nigeria were assessed using Histone 3 gene promoter. Two different species
form two different genera were examined namely, Clarias anguillaris and Heterobranchus
bidorsalis. The result showed that the species have a common ancestor though the distance in
relationship revealed variations among them. There were also variations in the sites of the
nucleotides in the different strains. Estimated genetic distances between populations were directly
correlated with geographical distances. The unweighted pair group method with averages
(UPGMA) dendrogram showed three clusters, the Maiduguri, Onitsha, Kainji, Yola C. anguillaris
and India C. gariepinus population forming one cluster. Kainji H. bidorsalis was alone on the
second cluster and Maiduguri H. bidorsalis and the Genbank AF416497.1 on the third cluster.
Genetic variation of C. anguillaris is a useful trait for developing a good management strategy for
maintaining genetic quality of the species.
Keywords: DNA Sequence, Phylogenetic relationship, Clarias, Heterobranchus, Nigeria.
INTRODUCTION
The Clariid catfishes, order Siluriformes, are distributed in Africa, Asia Minor and South-east Asia
and the Indian subcontinent (Teugels and Adriaens, 2003). Two genera of these, Clarias and
Heterobranchus, with the Cichlids are the most used in African aquaculture production (Agnese et
al., 1995). The Clarias (Teugels, 1982, 1986) made up of two valid species, Clarias gariepinus and
C. anguillaris that cannot be differentiated morphologically except by counting the number of gill
rakers on the dead fish dominate the Nigeria aquaculture production. C. gariepinus occurs
thoughout Africa, while C. anguillaris is geographically restricted to West Africa where they occur
sympatrically.
C. anguillaris (Linnaeus, 1758) like C. gariepinus is also of interest to aquaculture (Volckaer et
al., 1994). This species is used in aquaculture production systems in Africa (Sylla, 1994). It is
often used in place of C. gariepinus because of the close resemblance. Earlier researches have
been carried out on the growth performance of two strains of C. anguillaris from Niger and Bouake
(Da Costa, 1997), morphometric and meristic characters (Onyia and Iliya, 2008) and generic
characterization of sympatric populations of Clarias gariepinus and Clarias anguillaris from
Senegal (Agnese et al., 1997).
According to Olken (2002), phylogenetic trees are computed to understand evolutionary history,
map pathogen strains diversity for vaccines, assist in epidemiology of infectious diseases and
genetic defects, aid in the prediction of function of novel genes, biodiversity studies and
understanding microbial ecologies. C. anguillaris and H. bidorsalis are widely distributed in
Nigerian water bodies. It is therefore necessary to study the phylogenetic relationship of the strains
from different ecological zones in Nigeria having different hydrological characteristics. The
objective of the study described in the present paper was to assess the genetic variation and
relatedness in four strains of C. anguillaris and two strains of H. bidorsalis populations from
different ecological zones.
109
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Clarias anguillaris strains were collected form Jos (Montane Vegetation). Kainji (Guinea savanna),
Onitsha (Rainforest zone) and Maiduguri (Sahel savanna). Heterobranchus bidorsalis strains were
also collected form Kainji and Maiduguri, while Clarias gariepinus from India was also used.
Genomic DNA was extracted using phenol method from the blood of Clarias gariepinus and was
confirmed on 0.8% agarose TBE gel electrophoresis. The amount of DNA was determined using
Nano spectrophotometer.
The histone gene promoter was amplified using polymerase chain reaction approach; this was
achieved by using Histone 3 Forward and Histone 3 Reverse primers. The reaction volume was
25ul containing 2.5ul dNTPs, 16.5ul ddH20, 2.5 ul 10X PCR buffer, 5 pmol H3 Forward primer, 5
PMOl H3 Reverse primer, 1 ul of template (genomic DNA) and 0.5 ul Tag polymerase were used.
The reaction condition which was done using MJ Research Thermo Cycler 200 involved hot start
95oC for 5 mins, and 35 cycles of denaturaion at 94oC for 30 secs, annealing at 60oC for 30
seconds and extension at 68oC for 1 minute. A final extension at 68oC for 10 minutes was
included. (H3 forward primer: GAGAAAGGCCGTCAAAGCCAAGT and H3 reverse primer:
AAGAAGGAAGCTAGCTAGCGCC). PCR product was confirmed on 0.8% agarose gel using
100bp marker.
The PCR product was sequenced along with the sequence of other Histone 3 gene promoter
sequences derived from fish samples from Nigeria. A phylogenetic analysis was carried out. PCR
product was given chloroform treatment followed by pK treatment before lighting into pMOS Blue
vector for 20 hrs at 37oc. Clones were transformed in bacterial competent cells and the colonies
were culture overnight from where plasmid DNA were isolated and checked on 0.8% gel
electrophoresis to confirmed mobility ship due to presence of foreign DNA. The PCR product was
sequenced using dideoxy chain termination method with fluorescently labeled ddNTP in automate
DNA sequencer.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
From Table 1, the different nucleotide sites are shown. A close relationship among C. anguillaris
strains from Maiduguri, Onitsha and Yola was found at close observation on the sites of the
nucleotides. C. anguillaris from Kainji and C. gariepinus from India, differ from them in the
genus Clarias based on the sites of the nucleotides. C. anguillaris had consistently different sites
of the nucleotides in the analysis. H. bidorsalis from Maiduguri and Kainji also had variations in
the sites of the nucleotides.
A total of 500 sites were analysed to give eight sequences of the different strains of the species.
The total number of sites (including sites with gaps or missing data) was 485. The number of
variable sites was 17 while the total number of mutation was 18. From the phylogenetic tree, the
pattern among the lineages has the same homogenous pattern. There were uniform rates among the
sites (Table 1).
The values on the phylogenetic tree (Figure 1), revealed 71% for Clarias anguillaris strains form
Maiduguri, Onitsha, Kainji and Yola; 35% for C. anguillaris from Maiduguri and Clarias
gariepinus form India. All the different strains of C. anguillaris and H. bidorsalis from Kainji
were 99%. The pairwise genetic distance (Table 2), showed that the different samples are similar
and very close.
Table 1. Histone 3 gene Promoter variable sites and nucleotide changes in C. anguillaris and H.
bidorsalis form different ecological zones in Nigeria.
Strains of Histone 3 variable sites and nucleotides changes in Clariid strains
Clariids
1
2
3
4
5
7
9
10
6
8
Mai. C.a
A (49)
C(97)
G(147)
T(197)
T(247) G(297)
C(345) A(395)
A(445) C9496)
110
Ind. C.g
A(50)
C(98)
G(148)
T(198)
T(248)
G(298)
A(396) A(446) C(496)
Onit. C.a.
A(49)
C(97)
G(147)
T(197) T(247) G(297) C(345)
A(445) C(494)
Kainji C.a. A(47)
C(95)
G(145)
T(195) T(245) G(295) C(343)
A(443) C(496)
YolaC.a.
A(49)
C(97)
G(147)
T(197) T(247)
G(297 C(345)
A(445) C(495)
Kainji H. b. A(46)
C(96)
G(146)
T(196) T(246)
G(296) C(344)
A(444) C)495)
Mai. H.b.
A(49)
C(94)
G(143)
T(193)
T(243)
G(293) C(340)
A(438) C(489)
GenBank A(49)
C(94)
G(143
T(193)
T(243)
G(293) C(343)
A(441) C(492)
416497.1
Keys:
Mai. C.a. = Maiduguri Clarias anguillaris Ind. C.g. = Indian Clarias gariepinus
Onit. C. a. = Onitsha Clarias anguillaris
Kainji C.a. = C. anguillaris
Yola C.a. = C. anguillaris
Kainji H. b. = Heterobranchus bidorsalis
Mai. H. b. = Maiduguri H. bidorsalis
35
C(346)
A(395)
A(393)
A(395)
A(394)
A(389)
A(392)
Maidangui
Indiagar
71
99
Onitshaangui
Kainjangui
Yolaangui
Kainjibido
Maidbido
GenBankAF416497.1
Figure 1: Phylogenetic tree of Clarias anguillaris and Heterobranchus bidorsalis from four
ecological zones in Nigeria.
Table2: Correlation of C. anguillaris and H. bidorsalis from different ecological zones of
Nigeria
[
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8]
[1]
[2] 0.004
111
[3] 0.004 0.006
[4] 0.008 0.008 0.006
[5] 0.004 0.006 0.004 0.006
[6] 0.012 0.010 0.008 0.010 0.008
[7] 0.019 0.017 0.019 0.021 0.015 0.015
[8] 0.029 0.027 0.029 0.032 0.025 0.025 0.010
Key:
[1] Maidangui [2] Indiagar [3] Onitshaangui [4] #Kainjangui
[5] Yolaangui [6] Kainjibido [7] Maidbido [8] GenBankAF416497.1
A representative Unpaired Group method of Analysis (UPGMA) based on Nei’s genetic distance
(Nei, 1972) is shown in Figure 1. The dendrogram segregated three distinct clusters of Clarias
anguillaris and H. bidorsalis populations form three ecological zones in Nigeria. C. anguillaris
populations form Maiduguri, Onitsha, Kainji, Yola and C. gariepinus from India being the first
cluster while H. bidorsalis population form Maiduguri also alone on the third cluster.
The first cluster was further separated into two subgroups, Maiduguri C. anguillaris population and
C. gariepinus from India in one subgroup and C. anguillaris populations form Onitsha, Kanji and
Yola in the second subgroup. The estimation of genetic distance produced UPGMA dendrograms
with similar clustering patterns. It also detected correlations between genetic and geographical
distances for some population pairs, with large genetic distance being found between distantly
located populations. The three populations have a common ancestor from the phylogenetic tree
(Figure 1) but with genetic variations which led to their separation into different clusters and
subgroups.
Distinguishing valid species from geographic population of same species usually begins by studying
variability of good character among samples. Buth and Mayden (1981) stated that characters
variability often describe clines, which are directed changes in sample mean of character over
without
abrupt discontinuity between ranges of gradual change. Genetically based cline in
character means reflect an evolutionary response by means of natural selection, to geographically
varying environmental factor such as temperature. This is shown by frequency correlation between
clines in morphological characters.
Alhstrom (1957) and Ajado et. al. (2004) reported that partial or complete isolation of groups of
fish result in slight differences in body proportion. The differences might be due to environmental
or hereditary factors. It could be inferred that differences observed in the three strains of C.
anguillaris from different ecological ones may be due to environmental factors in the different
locations. Yola is located within the Sudan savannah and lies between latitude 70 and 110 N of the
equator and between longitudes 110 and 140 E of Greenwich meridian. The mean annual rainfall is
about 1000mm and an average maximum temperature of 400c (Adebayo, 1999). Kainji is located in
derived guinea savannah and lies between the latitudes100 11’ and 130 53’ N and longitudes 100 14’
and 14030’ E., the maximum temperature is above 410C in the hottest months. The estimation of
genetic distances produced UPGMA dendrograms with similar clustering patterns. It also detected
correlations between genetic and geographical distances for some population pairs, with large
genetics distance being found between distantly located populations. Geographical isolation of their
water bodies and may result from restricted intermingle and subsequent morphological
differentiation. This result is in line with the work of swaine et al. (1991), that environmental
changes and modification of morphology mitigate the effects of environmental variation. The
difference in the environmental conditions between the locations could be responsible for the
variations in the amino acid constitution.
Maiduguri samples were collected from Lake alau isolated in the Northeast of Nigeria, which is far
from the other three C. anguillaris populations from Onitsha, Kainji and Yola. Contrastingly, the
close relationship between Onitsha, Kainji and Yola C. anguillaris population could be due to the
connecting River Benue and Niger. Since River Benue is a major tributary of River Niger, there is
112
the possibility of intermixing of fish from the two rivers, likely leading to high levels of gene flow
and inter-population similarities between these riverine populations. These result agreed with the
study on catla catla from different rivers and geographical locations in Bangladesh (Islam and
Alam, 2004, Islam et al., 2005, Islam et al., 2007; Rahman et al.,2009 Volckaer et al.,1994).
The phylogenetic tree showed that the samples were divided into three distinct clusters. This result
agreed with Rahman et al., 2009 that worked on different populations of Indian major carp from
different rivers in Bangladesh. The result of this study could be attributed to their different
ecological locations and hydrological zones. The close genetic variation between Kainji, Onitsha
and Yola populations of C. anguillaris could be due to genetic mix between them, since there could
be interbreeding in the wild. The upper Benue River is a tributary of River Niger; there is the
likelihood that the C. anguillaris from the two river can interbreed. Maiduguri C. anguillaris
population was separated alone and this could be because of the ecological zone and nonconnectivity to any of the rivers the other populations were found. This also could be applicable to
H. bidorsalis population from kainji and Maiduguri in this study. The study also showed that wild
stocks of C. anguillaris and H. bidorsalis represented a diversified genetic resource which indicated
that in situ management practices, such as preventing the wanton capture of fish and creating
sanctuaries for protecting small stocks such as those from Maiduguri (Lake Alau), can help to
maintain and conserve the present diverse gene pool.
In conclusion, the phylogenetic tree of the samples in this study revealed three distinct evolutionary
linkages. The four strains of C. anguillaris belonged to the same ancestors through separated due to
ecological differences and rivers of collection. Crossbreeding of these different strains of C.
anguillaris will lead to the development of strain with better growth parameters for hatchery
managers. Furthermore, breeding between two genetically distinct and distance populations may
have a positive impact on aquaculture production.
REFERENCES
Adebayo, A. A. (1999). Climate ii in Adamawa State in Maps.EditionA1. Paraclete Publishers,
Yola, Nigeria.PP 11-13.
Ajado, E.O., Edokpai, C.A., and Williams, B. (2004). Morphometric, meristic and comparative
studies of Chrysicthys nigrodigitatus (lacepede) Lsgos Lekki and Badagry Lagoons State.
Proceeding of the 19th Annual Conference, Fisheries Society of Nigeria (FISON) Ilorin
November 29-December 3, 2004. PP 816-822.
Alhstron, E.N. (1957). A review of recent studies of sub-populations of pacific fishes. In
contribution to the study of sub-populations fishes. Special scientific Report-Fisheries
number 208 U.S. Department of Interior. Fish and Wildlife Service, USA.
Agnese, J.F., Oteme, Z.J. and Gilles, S. (1995). Effect of demonstration on genetic variability,
survival and growth rate in a tropical Siluriform Hereobranchus longifilis Valenciennes
1840. Aquaculture, 131:197-204.
Agnese, J.F., Teugels, G.G., Galbusera, P., Guyomard, R. and Volckaert, F. (1997). Morphometric
and genetic characterization of sympatric populations of Clarias gariepinus and C.
anguillaris from Senegal. Journal of Fish Biology, 50: 1143-1157.
Buth, D.G. and Mayden, R.L. ( 1981). Taxonomic status and relationships among population of
Notropis pilbris and N. zonatus. Copeia, 981:583-590.
Da Costa, S. (1997). Comparison of growth performances of the Niger and Bouake strains of
Clarias anguillaris. In: Genetic and Aquaculture in Africa. (Agnese, J.F. ED.). Pp. 259-255.
Islam, M.S. and Alam, M.A. (2004). Randomly amplified polymorphic DNA analysis of four
difference populations of the Indian major carp, Labeo rohita (Hamilton). Journal of
Applied Ichthyology, 20:407-412.
Islam, M.S., Ahmed, A.S.I., Azam, M.S. and Alam, M.S. (2005). Genetic analysis of three river
populations of Catla catla (Hamilton) using randomly amplified polymorphic DNA
markers. Asian-Aust Journal of Animal Science, 18:453-457.
113
Islam, M.N., Islam, M.S. and Alam, M.S. (2007). Genetic structure of different population of
walking catfish (Clarias batrachus L.) in Bangladesh. Biochem. Genetics, 45:647-662.
Nei, M. (1972). Genetic distance between populations. Am. Nature, 106: 283-292.
Rahman, S.M.Z., Khan, M.R., Islam, S. and Alam, S. (2009). Genetic variation of wild and
hatchery populations of the catla Indian major carp (Catla catla Hamilton 1822: Cyprinidea)
revealed by RAPD markers. Genet. Mol. Biol. 32 (1):
Olken, F. (2002). Phylogenetic tree computation Tutorial. Lawrence Berkeley National Lab.
Presentation to PGA course. May 3, 2002 Berkeley California.
Onyia, L.U. and Iliya, M. (2008). Comparison of morphometric and meristic characteristics of
Clarias anguillaris from two ecological Zones of Nigeria. Journal of Science, Engineering
and Technology, 15(3): 8491-8501.
Swaine, D.P., Ridell, B.E. and Murray, C.B. (1991). Morphological differences between hatchery
and wild populations of Coho salmon: environmental versus genetic origin. Fish. Aqua. Sci.,
48:1783-1791.
Teugels, G.G. (1982). Preliminary result of a morphological study of five African species of the
subgenus Clarias (Pisces Clariidae). Journal of Natural History, 16:439-464.
Teugels, G.G. (1986). A systematic revision of the African species of the genus Clarias (Pisces:
Clariidae). Annals du muse Royale de 1’ Afrique Centrale 247. Pp. 199.
Teugels, G.G. and Andriaens, D. (2003). Taxonomy and phylogeny of Clariidae: An overview In.
G. Arralia, BG Kapoor, M Chardon, R. Dogo(Eds). Catfishes Science Publishers, Inc.
Endfield (USA) 1: 465-487.
Volckaer, F.A., Galbusare, P., Sekkali, B., Belayew, A. and Ollevier, F. (1994). Replication,
expression and fate of foreign DNA during embryonic and larval development of the
African catfish (Clarias gariepinus). Molecular Marine Biology and Biotechnology, 3:5759.
114
AGB14
MULTIFACTORIAL ANALYSES OF MORPHOLOGICAL TRAITS OF HELMETED
GUINEA FOWLS NUMIDIA MELEAGRIS
Adedibu, I.I.1*, Ayorinde, K.L.2, Musa, A.A.3, Orunmuyi, M.1 and Kabir, M.1
1*
Department of Animal Science, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Production, University of Ilorin, Ilorin, Nigeria.
3
Department of Animal Science, Kogi State University, Anyigba, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: iiipinyomi@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
A cross-sectional design was used to study possible variations in a population of helmeted guinea
fowl (HGF). Data was collected on some qualitative and quantitative traits of morphologically
distinct HGF and were analysed using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) procedure and
cluster analysis. The study showed that the first two components accounted for 53.3% of the total
variations obtained in the entire study zones. Variations among the entire population was due to
quantitative traits such as body weight (BWT), body length (BOL), shank length (SKL), shank
circumference (SKC) and wing span (WGS). Qualitative traits such as neck colour (NKC),
wattle colour (WTC), eye colour (EYC), breast colour (BRC), beak colour (BKC) and shank
colour (SHC) that were positively and significantly related to body weight varied between the
entire populations of HGF. The study also indicated that there are five distinct varieties of HGF
in the study zone. Variations observed in some qualitative and quantitative traits would be useful
in selection and in breeding commercially improved strains of HGF for meat purposes at
genomic level.
Key words: breeding, helmeted guinea fowl, markers, selection
INTRODUCTION
Multifactorial analyses of morphological traits have proven to be suitable in assessing the
variation within a population and can discriminate different population types when
morphological variables are considered simultaneously (Yakubu and Ibrahim, 2011). Various
multivariate techniques such as PCA, cluster analysis, multivariate regression analysis, canonical
correlation analysis and others have been applied for multivariate variable data analysis in the
field of animal science and other related fields. PCA is designed to transform original variables
into new, uncorrelated variables (axes) called principal components (PCs) which are linear
combinations of the original variables (Shrestha et al., 2008). PCA has capacity to reduce the
original variables measured into few components/factors to provide information on the most
meaningful parameters which will describe a whole set affording data reduction with minimum
loss of original information (Helena et al., 2000). Independent factor scores derived from this
multivariate technique can be used to estimate body weight (Yakubu and Ayoade, 2009),
115
AGB15
THE EFFECTS OF GENOTYPE, PROXIMATE COMPOSITION AND
CHARACTERISTICS OF THREE STRAINS OF LAYER TURKEYS ON EGG QUALITY
TRAITS
Isidahomen, C.E.1*, Adomeh, E.E.1 and Raji, A.O.2
1
Department of Animal Science, Ambrose Alli University, Ekpoma, Edo State, Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Science, University of Maiduguri, Borno State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: ebicley2k@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
This study was conducted to determine the influence of egg genotype on internal, external and some
proximate composition on egg traits. Ninety (90) fresh eggs of the three genotypes (exotic,
crossbred and local strains) of layer turkeys were used. Genotype had significant effect (p <0.05)
on egg proximate composition and other egg traits. Egg quality trait in terms of crude protein highly
favoured exotic compared to others. The analysis of variance showed significant genotype effect on
egg weight and egg production traits. The mean weights of exotic turkey eggs (76.10g) were much
heavier than the crossbred and local turkey eggs (65.85g), respectively. The egg length and egg
width followed the same pattern. The proportion of shell weight to the egg weight was higher in
exotic turkey (7.40g) than the local turkey (6.15g). Similarly, the exotic turkey eggs showed highest
value in internal and external egg traits. The present study therefore indicates that genotype
significantly affect egg weight and egg quality traits. The implication is that the egg quality traits
are influenced by both genetic and non genetic factors.
Keywords: Local, crossbred, exotic, genotype, egg quality.
INTRODUCTION
In Nigeria, there are many varieties of poultry including Turkey. Turkeys are emerging as an
important source of animal protein and provide essential substances as other meat but has
comparatively low percentages of fat and high percentages of proteins (Nixey and Grey, 1985). The
productivity and quality of the breeding egg has an overall effect for poultry flock and for economic
breeding ( Isidahomen et al., 2011).Moreover, the external and internal quality traits are important
in poultry breeding because of their influence on the yield on the progeny generation. The egg
production of local turkeys can rose up to 99 eggs per hen per year with improved feeding, housing
and health care (Tadelle et al., 2000). The relationship between weight, length and width of eggs
has been reported by Danilov (2000) who also noted the proportion of yolk, albumin and shell that
contribute to the egg weight increase with hen’s age. Thus egg weight is one of the important
phenotypic traits which influences egg quality and reproductive fitness of the chicken parents
(Islam et al., 2001; Farooq et al., 2001). Egg quality is composed of those characteristics of an egg
that affects its acceptability to consumers such as cleanliness, freshness, egg weight, shell quality,
yolk index etc (Song et al., 2000). The assessment of proximate composition of different strains of
turkey has been given less attention. Hence, this study examines the quality characteristic of egg of
three strains. This study, therefore, was conducted to evaluate the proximate composition, egg
quality of different strains of local, crossbred and exotic turkey eggs.
116
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study was conducted at the Poultry Unit of the Teaching and Research Farm, Ambrose Alli
University, Ekpoma, Edo State, Nigeria. Ninety fresh eggs each from three strains namely: local,
crossbred and exotic turkeys were used to obtain the eggs quality traits of these turkeys. These
comprised 30 eggs from each genotype. The eggs collected were sorted and pedigreed along each
sire line. All hens were wing tagged for proper identification and subjected to the same management
practices throughout the experimental period. The birds were fed ad libitum with layer mash
containing 16% Crude Protein and 2800kcal/kg Metabolisable Energy.
Data were collected on:
Body Weight: This was taken on individual bird from each female turkey with the aid of a scale
balance in kg.
Egg Weight: This was taken on individual eggs from each layer with the aid of an electronic
balance having sensitivity of 0.01g.
Egg Length: A Venier caliper with an accuracy of 0.1mm was used to determine the egg length. It
was taken as the longitudinal distance between the narrow and the broad ends.
Egg Width: It was measured to the nearest 0.1mm with venier caliper. The egg width was taken as
the diameter of the widest cross-sectioned region.
Egg shell weight: This was taken on individual eggs from each layer with the aid of an electronic
balance having sensitivity of 0.01g.
Egg shell Thickness: It was measured to the nearest 0.1mm with micrometer screw gauge
Yolk weight: This was taken on individual eggs from each layer with the aid of an electronic
balance having sensitivity of 0.01g.
Yolk length: A Venier caliper with an accuracy of 0.1mm was used to determine the egg yolk
length. It was taken as the longitudinal distance between ends.
Yolk height: It was measured to the nearest 0.1mm with venier caliper. The egg height was taken
as the distance between the base and the height.
Proximate composition: The Proximate composition of eggs was determined according to the
method of AOAC (1980).
All data collected were subjected to Analysis of Variance using generalized linear model (GLM) of
SAS (1999). Significant differences were computed using New Duncan multiple range test (Gomez
and Gomez, 1984) to determine the significance of specific classes.
The data were analyzed using the model specified below:
The model is stated thus:
Yijk = + Gi + ij
Where,
Yijk = dependent Variable
= overall mean
Gi = effect of the ith genotype on egg traits
ij = random residual error
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Least square means and standard error of proximate composition as affected by genotype are
presented in Table 1. Genotype significantly affected (P< 0.05) proximate composition. The crude
protein value was highest in Exotic egg strain (22.03) while the least value was recorded in Local
egg strain (19.45), the ash content was highest in the Local egg strain (9.52%) and lowest in the
Exotic (3.79%). The Moisture content was highest in the Local egg strain (30. 68%) and lowest in
the Exotic egg strain (27.14%).
Least square means and standard error of egg weight as affected by genotype are presented in Table
2. Egg weight were found to have significant (P<0.05) effect in this study. Exotic egg strain had the
117
highest mean value (76.10) while the Local egg strain had the least (65.85). Egg length followed the
same trend with egg weight (6.27), while Local egg strain had the least mean value of egg width
(5.85). For albumin weight, yolk weight and yolk length and other parameters measured favoured
the exotic chicken when compared with their local and crossbreds.
Table 1: Least-squares means and standard error of means on turkey eggs proximate composition
as affected by genotype
Parameters
Local
Exotic
Crossbred
Either Extract (%)
33.77±0.09b
36.79±0.82a
34.54±0.01b
c
a
Crude Protein (%)
19.45± 0.00
22.03± 0.00
20.70±0.01b
Ash (%)
9.52±0.88a
3.79±0.40c
6.66±0.13b
c
a
Nitrogen Free Extract
6.98±0.19
12.06±0.09
9.11±0.01b
(%)
Moisture (%)
30.68±0.09a
27.14±0.00c
28.99±0.01b
a,b,c means in the same row with different superscripts are significantly different (P <0.05)
Table 2.Least square means and standard error of means of weight, external and internal egg
quality of turkey as affected by genotype
Parameters
Local
Exotic
Crossbred
c
a
Egg weight(g)
65.85±0,87
76.10±1.71
70.98±0.92b
Egg length(cm)
5.85±0.09b
6.27±0.16a
6.09±0.09ab
b
a
Egg length (cm)
4.04±0.05
4.32±0.07
4.14±0.06b
Shell weight(g)
6.20±0.09c
7.35±0.10a
6.55±0.15b
b
a
Shell thickness (%)
0.34±0.00
0.36±0.00
0.36±0.00a
Albumin weight (g)
43.70±0.47c
54.00±0.32a
47.45±0.39b
a
a
Yolk weight (g)
25.10±0.16
24.45±0.34
23.15±1.13a
c
a
Yolk length (cm)
3.90±0.02
4.32±0.06
4.13±0.04b
Yolk Height(MM)
0.82±0.02b
1.03±0.02a
1.01±0.01a
Means and in the same row with different superscript are significantly different (P<0.05)
Crude protein in this study were found to have significant (P<0.05) effect in this study. Exotic
genotype had the highest value while the local had the least value. This is in agreement with
findings of (Faga et al., 1989; Isidahomen et al., 2009) who observed that genotype significantly
affected crude protein irrespective of the size. Also the values fall within the range reported by
Babangida et al., (2006). Moisture content favoured the local turkey eggs showing the highest mean
value and the least value was observed among the exotic. The reason could be due to their genetic
make-up. However, the values recorded were lower compared to the report of Olomu (2003). Also
the values fall within the range according to Babangida et al., (2006) and Olomu (2003). The values
for ether extract was also highest in exotic genotype and the lowest was observed in local which
may also be due to their genetic make-up, which is in agreement with the report of Isidahomen et
al. (2013). Exotic birds also recorded the lowest ash value while the highest value was recorded in
local egg genotype. However, the value did not agree with the work of Babangida el al., (2006), but
in consonance with the report of Isidahomen et al. (2013) who reported that the exotic chicken eggs
had the highest value and the least value was recorded in the Normal local chicken. This could be
attributed to environment and the analytical procedure involved. Exotic birds also recorded the
lowest moisture value while the local had the highest value. However, the value did not agree with
the work of Babangida el al. (2006).
The exotic turkey weight was much higher than the crossbred and local. This is basically due to the
vast difference in size of this genotype (Isidahomen et al., 2011). The absolute weight of external
and internal egg characteristics were significantly (P<0.05) higher in exotic and crossbreds
compared to local turkeys. The differences were obviously due to much higher egg weight in the
118
turkeys. The effect of genetic group on egg weight were significantly (P<0.05) different. Exotic
turkey had higher egg weight than local turkey. The difference between the three might be
expected. In general, the egg weight of local turkey is low compared to exotic turkey. The reason
for the higher weight might be due to the fact that it is an improved genotype. (Sharma et al., 2006).
Egg weight variations in different genetic groups have been reported by many authors (Washburnn,
1990; Padhi et al., 1998; Chatterjee et al., 2007a). The effects of genetic group on egg length and
egg width were also significantly (P<0.05) different from each other. The exotic turkey showed
higher values in egg length and egg width than the local turkey. Shell weight was significantly
(P<0.05) affected by genetic group. The egg shell weights were significantly higher in exotic
turkeys than those of local turkeys (Padhi et al., 1998). Shell thickness varied significantly (P<0.05)
between genetic groups. The shells of exotic turkey eggs were thicker than their local counterparts.
The mean shell thickness was better for their suitability (Parmer et al., 2006; Padhi et al., 1998;
Wani et al., 2007; Chatterjee et al., 2007b). The albumin weight differed significantly (P<0.05)
between the genetic groups. Exotic turkey eggs had better albumin weight than the local and this is
in agreement with the report of Parmer et al. (2006) and Chatterjee et al. (2007b). The reason for
the higher weight might be due to the fact that it is an improved genotype. Yolk weight value were
significantly (P<0.05) influenced by genotype. The yolk weights were significantly higher in local
than exotic birds (Isidahomen et al., 2011). Parmer et al. (2006) also observed lower yolk weight
index for kadknult birds. However, higher yolk length and yolk height and were also observed in
this experiment. The values support the reports by Singh et al., 1993 and Sachdera et al., 2006).
CONCLUSION
The present study therefore indicates that genotype, significantly affect egg weight and egg quality
traits. The implication is that the egg quality traits are influenced by both genetic and non genetic
factors. The crossbred eggs were very close to the exotic, suggesting that eggs quality traits of
turkey could be improved by crossbreeding.
REFERENCES
AOAC (1980). Official Methods of Analysis. 13th edition. Association of official Analytical
Chemist. Washington D.C USA.
Babangida, S., Isidahomen, E.C and Igebuike J.U (2006) .A comparison of egg quality parameter
of some poultry species in Maiduguri, Nigeria, Journal of Research in Agriculture 3 (2) Pp
37 – 39.
Chatterjee,R.N; Rai,R.B; Kundu,A, Senani,S and Sundar, J (2007a). Egg quality traits in indigenous
breeds of chicken of Andaman; India Veterinary journal., 84 (2):206-208.
Chatterjee,R.N; Rai,R.B; Pramanik,S.C; Sundar,J; Senani,S and Kundu,A, (2007b). Comparative
growth, production, egg and carcass traits of different cross of brow Nicobari with White
Leghorn under intensive and extensive management systems in Andaman, India; Livestock
Research for Rural Development., 19 (12).
Danilov R.V (2000). Effect of hens’ age on quality of hatching eggs and embryonic development.
Proceedings 21st Worlds poultry Congress., Montreal, Canada.
119
Farooq, M; Mian, M.A; Ali,M;Durranim,F.R; Asquar,A and Muqarrab, A.K (2001). Egg traits of
Fayoumi birds under subtropical conditions. Sarad Journal of Agriculture, 17: 141-145.
Fraga, L.M, M. Valdivie, I Berrio, and P. Pertez, P.C, (1989). Naked neck genes are useful in the
tropics. Misset International Poultry. An International Magazine on Poultry, 5(94). Pp 26 –
27.
Gomez, A. K. and Gomez, A. A. (1984). Statistical Procedure for Agricultural Research. 2nd ed.
John Willy and Sons, New York, USA. pp 680.
Islam,M.A; Bulbul,S.M; Seeland, G and Islam, A.B (2001). Egg quality of different chickens’
genotypes in summer and winter .Pakistan Journal of Biological Science, 4 1411-1414.
Isidahomen, C.E., Ilori., B.M., Ozoje., M.O., Omoikhoje, S.O., Adeleke, M.A. and Akano, K.
(2009).Egg quality traits of indigenous and exotic chickens as influence by specific genes.
The 14th Annual Conference of the Animal Science Association of Nigeria. Ladoke
Akintola University of Technology, Ogbomoso, Oyo State, Nigeria. 14th-17th September,
2009. Pp 62-65.
Isidahomen, C.E., Ilori, B.M. and Ekuagbere, C.E. (2011). A comparative evaluation of weight,
internal and external quality of egg from local and exotic Turkey. The 16th Annual
Conference of the Animal Science Association of Nigeria (ASAN). Kogi state University,
Faculty of Agric Lecture Theatre, Kogi State, Nigeria. 12th-15th September, 2011. Pp 29-32.
Isidahomen, C.E., Njidda, A.A and Olatunji, E.A. (2013). Egg Quality traits of Indigenous
and Exotic Chickens AS Influenced by Specific Genes. Journal of Agriculture and
Healthcare, 3(1): 53-57.
Nixey, C. and Grey, T.C. (1985). Recent advances in Turkey Science. Poultry Science Symposium,
21: 231-233.
Olomu, J.M. (2003). Poultry Production. A practice Approach. Jachem publication, Benin city
Nigeria. Pp. 94 – 97.
Padhi, M.K., Rai, R.B., Senani, S. and Saha, S.K. (1998). Assessment of egg quality
characteristics in White leghorn Layers: India Journal of Poultry Science, 33: 113-115.
Parmar,S.N.S; Thakur,M.S; Tomar,S.S and Pillai,P.V.A (2006). Evaluation of egg quality trait in
indigenous Kadaknath breed of poultry; Livestock Research for Rural Development 18
(9).http://www.Irrd.org/Irrd18/9/parm18132.htm
Sachdeva, A.K., Sharma Deepak, Gopal Ram and Singh Harpreet (2006). Quality, composition and
genetics of guinea fowl egg. India Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics, 2 (1,2): 36-41.
SAS/STAT. (1999). SAS User’s guide; statistic released version 8.0. Statistical analysis system
institute Inc. Cary. NC.
Sharma, R.P., Chatterjee, R.N. and Niranjan, M. (2006). Poultry production under backyard
systems: Improvement approaches. In: National symposium on conservation and
improvement of animal genetic resources under low input systems; Challenges and
strategies, NBAGER, Karnal. Pp.72-77.
Singh, H., Pal, S.K., Raheja, K.L. (1993). Genetics and phenotypic parameters for egg production
and egg quality traits in guinea fowl. India Journal of Poultry Science, 28: 12-19.
Song, K.T., Choi, S.H., Oh, H.R. (2000). A comparison of egg quality of pheasant, Chukar, Quail
and Guinea fowl. Asian-Australian Journal of Animal Science,13 (7): 986-990.
Tadelle, D., Alemu, Y. and Peters, K.J. (2000). Indigenous chickens in Ethiopia; genetic potentials
and attempts at improvement. World Poult. Sci. J., 56: 45 – 54.
Wani, S. A., Malik, A.H., Bhat, G.A., Khan, A.A., Salahuddin, M., Pal, M.A. and Sofi, A.H.
(2007). In: Seminar on backyard poultry farming for woman empowerment and nutritional
security cum scientists- poultry Farmer Meet, Organized by Sher-e-Kashmir University of
Agricultural Sciences and Technology of Kashmir, Srinagar.
Washburn, K.W. (1990). Genetic Variation in Egg Composition. In: poultry Breeding and Genetics
pp 78-804. Crawford R.D(Ed), Elsevier Science publisher, B V, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands.
120
AGB16
RELATIONS BETWEEN AGE AND WEIGHT AT FIRST EGG AND EGG PRODUCTION
TRAITS OF JAPANESE QUAILS.
Raji, A. O.1*, Idahor, K.O.2 and Mohammed, G.1
1
Department of Animal Science, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri, Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Science. Nassarawa State University, Keffi, Shabu-Lafia Campus, Lafia,
Nigeria.
*Corresponding email: rajrazpearl@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
The relationship between age and weight at frst egg and egg production traits of the Japanese quail
were investigated. The study, carried out at the Poultry unit of the University of Maiduguri
Livestock Teaching and Research farm, involved 180 female Japanese quails housed individually in
cages. The age and weight at first eggs were 65.15 days and 148.44g, respectively. The total egg
number (52 weeks) was 275.69 with egg mass and hen day egg production of 2539.6g and 78.84%,
respectively, while the weight of first egg was 8.75g. Age at first egg significantly (P<0.05) affected
all the egg production traits while weight at first egg did not. Birds that matured earlier (8 weeks)
had significantly (P<0.05) higher total egg number, mass and hen day egg production. However,
they had lower first egg weight. Age and weight at first egg had low but positive correlation (0.11).
The correlation between age at first egg and egg production traits were high and negative (-0.4687
121
to -0.5167) indicating that early maturity results in higher egg production. Thus, selection for early
maturity in Japanese quail may result in higher egg production.
Keywords: Age, weight, first egg, egg production, Japanese quails
INTRODUCTION
The Japanese quail is gradually becoming a popular poultry species among Nigerians. It is the
smallest avian species farmed for egg and meat production in the world. Some of its distinct
characteristics include small body size, early sexual maturity, high rate of production (290 - 300
eggs/year), short generation interval, low maintenance cost and high resistance to common poultry
diseases (Hassan et al., 2003). Age and weight at sexual maturity and egg production are important
economic traits in the Japanese quail. Jadhav and Siddiqui (2007) observed that quails start to lay at
6 - 7 weeks of age and reach peak production at 13 – 14 weeks with a decline from 25 weeks. Ages
at sexual maturity of 65.6 (Sachdev and Ahuja, 1986), 48.9 - 49.6 (Thomas and Ahuja, 1988), 58
(Kocak et al., 1995), 39.8-51.1 (Inal et al., 1996), 45.9 (Gunes and Cerit, 2001) and 44.9 days
(Camci et al., 2002) have been reported. Similarly, weights at sexual maturity reported by some
authors were 181 – 200 g (Sachdev and Ahuja, 1986), 122.9 -128.2 g (Sreenivasaiah and Joshi,
1988), 145.2 g (El-Ibiary et al., 1966) and 202.2 g (Kocak et al., 1995). A number of authors
posited that age at sexual maturity was fairly related to body weight and that quails with higher
body weights at sexual maturity had higher egg production rate (Gunes and Cerit, 2001; Camci et
al., 2002). The report of Camci et al. (2002) indicated that birds that matured late (50-56 days) had
higher body weight and lower hen-day egg production than those that matured early (36-42 days).
Gebherdt-hendrich and Marks (1995) reported a correlation of 0.25 between age at sexual maturity
and body weight. While Kocak et al. (1995) reported a value of 0.29. Correlation values of 0.33 and
0.18 were reported by Camci et al. (2002) and Gunes and Cerit (2001), respectively. Eitan and
Soller (2001) observed that several factors contribute to variability in onset of egg production in
chickens, turkeys and quails. Oruwari and Brody (1988) observed that chronological age alone is
not a primary effector of sexual maturity rather there is a complex relationship between age, body
weight, body composition and sexual maturity. This is supported by Soller et al. (1984) and Zelenka
et al. (1984) who postulated that there are minimum ages, body weight and body composition
values for attainment of sexual maturity in female birds. Thus, to select for good egg producers, it is
important to establish the relationship between age and weight at first egg and egg production traits.
The aim of this study is to determine the relationship between age and weight at first egg and, egg
production traits of the Japanese quail.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was carried out at the Poultry Unit of the University of Maiduguri Livestock Teaching
and Research Farm, Maiduguri, Borno State, Nigeria. Maiduguri, the Borno State capital is situated
on latitude 1105’ N, longitude 13009’ E (Encarta, 2007) and at an altitude of 354 m above sea level.
The area falls within the Sahelian region of West Africa, which is noted for great climatic and
seasonal variations. It has very short period (3 – 4 months) of rainfall of 645.9 mm/annum with a
long dry season of about 8 – 9 months. The ambient temperature could be as low as 200C during the
dry cold season and as high as 440C during the dry hot season. Relative humidity is 45% in August
which usually lowers to about 5% in December and January. Day length varies from 11 to 12 hours.
One hundred and eighty (180) four-week old female Japanese quails housed in individual cages
(30x30x45 cm) fitted with improvised feeders and drinkers, were used for the study which lasted
60 weeks. They were fed commercial broiler starter ration containing 23% Crude Protein and 3000
kcal/kg of Metabolizable Energy (ME) to 6 weeks of age and breeder diet containing 18% Crude
Protein and 2800 kcal/kg of ME subsequently (NRC, 1994). They had access to the feed and water
ad libitum. Age at sexual maturity was taken as the age (days) when the bird laid its first egg. The
weight was also recorded as the weight at first egg and egg production then recoded for each hen till
the end of the experiment. For statistical analysis, hens were grouped according to their age at first
122
egg into 8 (56 – 62 days) and 9 (63 -70 days) weeks. They were also grouped according to body
weights into 120 – 140, 141 – 160 and 161 – 180 g with 20 g between groups. Data collected were
subjected to Analysis of Variance using Statistix 8.0 Software and significant means separated by
Least Significant Difference (LSD). The model used for the analysis was as follows:
Yij = µ +Si + Wj + eij
where
Yij = observation on individual measurement based on the i,j classification
µ = overall mean
Si = fixed effect of age at first egg
Wj = fixed effect of weight at first egg
eij = random error
Phenotypic correlation between variables was also calculated using the same software.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Descriptive statistics of egg production traits are presented on Table 1. Age at first egg was 65.15
days with a body and egg weight of 148.44 and 8.75 g. The total egg number was 275.69 with an
egg mass and hen day egg production of 2539.6 g and 78.8%. The age at first egg for birds in this
study was similar to 65.6 days reported by Sachdev and Ahuja (1986) but higher than 58, 45.9 and
44.9 days obtained by Kocak et al. (1995), Gunes and Cerit (2001) and Camci et al. (2002),
respectively. Similarly, weight at first egg was similar to 145.2 g reported by El-Ibiary et al. (1966),
higher than 122.9 -128.2g obtained by Sreenivasaiah and Joshi (1988) but lower than 202.2g
reported by Kocak et al. (1995). The total egg production obtained was close to 282 reported by
Cerit (1997) but lower than 287 and 290 obtained by Gunes and Cerit (2001) and Sundaram (1989).
It was however higher than 205.7 reported by Sachdev and Ahuja (1986). The variations in egg
production traits may have been due to differences in environment, nutrition and management.
The means of egg production traits as affected by age and weight at first egg are presented on Table
2. The effect of age at first egg was significant (P<0.05) on egg production traits while weight at
first egg did not affect them significantly. Birds that matured earlier (8 weeks), had higher total egg
number and mass and, hen day egg production. However, they had lower first egg weight. This may
be due to the fact that egg weight is more a function of body weight than age, and early maturing
birds had lower body weights than late maturing ones. Consequently, they laid smaller eggs.
However, egg mass was higher because they laid more eggs than late maturing quails. The non
significant effect of weight at first egg on egg production was also reported by Gunes and Cerit
(2001).
The phenotypic correlations between egg production traits are presented on Table 3. The correlation
between age and weight at first egg was positive and significant (P<0.05) but low. Positive
correlation indicates that early maturity results in lower body which was implicated in the
significantly (P<0.05) lower weight of first egg. Similar result was reported by Gunes and Cerit
(2001) though the magnitude of the relationship was higher (0.29 and 0.33) in the reports of Kocak
et al. (1995) and Camci et al. (2002), respectively. The correlation between age at first egg and total
egg number and mass, and hen day egg production was high, negative and significant (P<0.01).
This implies that early maturing quails had higher values for the egg production traits except weight
of first egg with which it had a positive relationship. Similar findings were reported by Kocak et al.
(1995) and Camci et al. (2002).
CONCLUSION
In this study, Japanese quails that matured early had higher egg production indicating that selection
for early age at first egg will lead to higher egg production.
REFERENCES
123
Camci, O., Erensayin, C. and Aktan, S. (2002). Relations between age at sexual maturity and some
production characteristic in quails. Archiv Geflugelk, 66(6):280-282.
Cerit, H. (1997). Genetic and phenotypic parameters of various traits in the Japanese quail
(Coturnix coturnix japonica). Ph.D. Thesis. Department of Animal Breeding and
Husbandry, Institute of Health Science, University of Istanbul, Istanbul, Turkey.
El–Ibiary, H. M., Godfrey, E. F. and Shaffiner, C. S. (1966). Correlation between growth and
reproductive traits in Japanese quail. Poultry Science, 45:463-468.
Encarta (2007). Microsoft Students Encarta Dictionary. Microsoft corporation Inc.USA.
Eitan, Y. and Soller, M. (2001). Effect of photoperiod and quantitative feed restriction in a broiler
strain on onset of lay in females and onset of semen production in males: A genetic
hypothesis. Poultry Science, 80:1397–1405.
Gebherdt-hendrich, S.G. and Marks, H.L. (1995). Effects of feed restriction on growth and
reproduction in randombred and selected lines of Japanese quail. Poultry Science, 74: 402406.
Gunes, H. and Cerit, H. (2001). Interrelation ships between age at sexual maturity, body weight and
egg production in the Japanese quail. Veteriner Fakultesi-Dergisi-Istanbul, 27:1, 191-198.
Hassan, S.M., Mady, M.E., Cartwright, A. L., Sabri, H. M. and Mobarak, M. S. (2003). Effect of
acetyl salicylic acid in drinking water on reproductive performance of Japanese quail
(Coturnix coturnix japonica). Poultry Science, 82:1174-1180.
Inal, S., Dere, S., Kiiriikcii, K. and Tepeli, C . (1996). The effects of selection for body weight of
Japanese quail on egg production, egg weight, fertility, hatchability and survivability.
Veteriner Bilimleri Dergisi, 12 :13-22.
Jadhav, N.V. and Siddiqui, M.F. (2007). Handbook of poultry production and management. 2nd ed.
Jaypee Brothers Medical publishers Ltd. New Delhi, India. 383pp.
Kalita, N. (1995). Effect of egg weight, storage period and position of eggs on hatchability. Animal
Breeding Abstract, 63: 812.
NRC (1994). National Research Council, Nutrient Requirements of Poultry. 9th Ed.National
Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C. USA.
Oruwari, B.M., and Brody, T. (1988) Roles of age, body weight and composition in the initiation of
sexual maturation of Japanese quail (Coturnix coturnix japonica). British Poultry Science,
29(3):481-489.
Sachdev, A.K. and Ahuja, S.D. (1986). Studies on the influence of body weight at sexual maturity
on production traits in Japanese quail. Indian Journal of Poultry Science, 21:66 – 68.
Soller, M., Brody, T., Eitan, Y., Agursky, T and Wexler, C. (1984). Minimum weight for onset of
sexual maturity in female chickens: Heritability and phenotypic and genetic correlations
with early growth rate. Poultry Science 63:2103–2113.
Sundaram, T. S. T. (1989). Comparative egg production efficiency of chickens, ducks and quails.
Poultry International, 28:60-68.
Thomas, P.C. and Ahuja, S.D. (1988). Improvement of broilers quails of Cari through selective
breeding. Poultry Guide, 25(10): 45-47.
Zelenka, D. J., Cherry, J. A., Nir, I. and Siegel, P. B. (1984). Body weight and composition of
Japanese quail (Coturnix coturnix japonica) at sexual maturity. Growth, 48:16–28.
124
Table 1. Descriptive statistics of egg production traits
Variables
Mean
SD
Age at first egg (days)
65.15
4.12
Weight at first egg (g)
148.44
14.39
Total Egg number
275.69
19.32
Total Egg mass (g)
2539.60
185.05
Egg weight (g)
8.75
0.49
Hen day egg production (%)
78.84
3.94
SE
0.72
2.54
3.41
32.71
0.088
0.697
CV
6.3233
9.6978
7.0109
7.2867
5.6854
5.0004
Table 2. Means and SE of egg production traits as affected by age and weight at first egg in the
Japanese quail
Total egg
Total egg mass
Hen day egg
number
Egg weight (g)
(g)
production (%)
Age at first egg
(weeks)
8
9
288.78 ± 5.26a
269.63 ± 4.28b
8.49 ± 0.12b
8.98 ± 0.10a
2680.0 ± 47.34a
2481.6 ± 38.61b
81.19 ± 1.11a
77.79 ± 0.90b
Weight at first
egg (g)
120 -140
141- 160
161-180
275.14 ± 5.29
278.15 ± 4.54
284.31 ± 7.87
8.54 ± 0.12
8.71 ± 0.11
8.95 ± 0.19
2505.7 ± 47.67
2573.9 ± 40.94
2662.8 ± 70.83
78.78 ± 1.12
79.23 ± 0.96
80.46 ± 1.66
Means within columns with different superscripts are significantly (P<0.05) different
Table 3. Correlation coefficients between egg production traits of the Japanese quail
Age at Weight at first
Total Egg
Egg
Total Egg
first egg
egg
number
weight
mass
Weight at first egg
0.1147*
Total egg number
-0.5167**
0.0490
Egg weight
0.4790**
0.3652*
-0.2218*
Total egg mass
-0.5056**
0.1842*
0.9382** -0.1936*
Hen day egg prod.
-0.4687**
0.0416
0.9539** -0.2210**
0.8957**
* P<0.05
** P<0.01
125
AGB17
TILAPIA GENETIC RESOURCE CONSERVATION IN NIGERIA
Megbowon, I.
Nigerian Institute for Oceanography and Marine Research, Victoria Island, Lagos
*Corresponding e-mail: iwalewamegbowon@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Tilapia aquaculture has experienced rapid development globally in recent years, which has made
China the largest tilapia producing country in the world. The paper reviews the major species of
tilapia in Nigerian water which include Oreochromis niloticus, Tilapia guineensis, T.zilli,
Sarotherodon galileaus and S. melanotheron. However, there are a number of unidentified cichlid
which could contribute significantly to national fish production among which is the ecotype cichlid
commonly called ‘wesafu’, with eco-fidelity to Epe lagoon, Lagos where it grows to 1,500g and
414mm in the wild. Previous studies have revealed that Nigeria has a pool of tilapia genetic
resources of great growth potentials yet to be exploited. The study of growth performance index of
natural populations of tilapia revealed that Oreochromis niloticus caught from Kainji Lake in
Nigeria had the highest growth performance index (3.11) when compared with other strains across
the globe. The high growth performance index may be an indication of better growth when brought
into captivity for domestication. Such information is important to the development of tilapia culture
in Nigeria. Genetic breeding and biotechnology have not been explored in Nigeria due to a number
of challenges which include poor funding of genetic research, poor manpower development,
inadequate research facilities as well as poor documentation of the genetic resources. For Nigeria to
benefit from the revolution in the tilapia industry globally, efforts should be made to assemble and
characterize our tilapia genetic resources and explore the knowledge of biotechnology and genetic
breeding to improve the stocks.
Keywords: Tilapia, genetic resource, conservation, Nigeria
INTRODUCTION
Throughout the world, aquaculture is being looked upon as a panacea for meeting the increasing
demand for fish, as catches from open waters are declining due to over exploitation and degradation
of fish habitats. Fish production from inland open waters declined due to over exploitation,
intensive agriculture, industrial development, erosion and siltation, reclamation of land for human
126
settlement, pollution, destruction of mangrove forests, e.t.c. Fish farming therefore appears to hold
the key for enhanced global fish production.
Among the numerous species of fish for culture, tilapia is widely recognized as one of the most
popular species for a wide range of aquaculture systems worldwide. It is an ideal candidate for
warmwater aquaculture (Tahoun et al., 2008). Tilapia generally differs greatly in size and
taxonomic group (Olojo, 2003). Essentially, there are three genera of Ttlapia based on reproductive
behaviour. They are; Oreochromis, Sarotherodon and Tilapia. Oreochromis species are maternal
mouthbrooders, Sarotherondon species are bi-parental mouthbrooders while Tilapia are substrate
spawner (Popma and Lovshin, 1996). In the early 1970s, all commercially important tilapias were
grouped under the genus tilapia. But by mid-1970, the mouth brooding species were separated from
the species that incubated their eggs externally and were placed in the genus Sarotherodon. About
1983, the maternal mouth brooders species of Sarotherodon were separated again, this time to the
genus Oreochromis. Consequently, an important aquacultural species such as Nile tilapia now
reported as Oreochromis niloticus was called Sarotherodon niloticus in 1980, and prior to that time,
was identified as Tilapia nilotica, the author reported.
Worldwide, Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) is the leading species accounting for over 80% of
tilapia production globally, with China as the leading producer. Production of this species increased
during the year, 2001-2006 from 1,113,737MT to 1,988,726MT representing a growth of 79%
(FAO, 2008), thus making it one of the fastest growing freshwater aquaculture production. Globally
tilapia production is growing at a very high rate, with a 12.2% average annual increase in
production during the past decade (El-Sayed, 2006).
TILAPIA PRODUCTION AND GENETIC RESOURCES IN NIGERIA
Nigeria was the largest producer of farm-raised tilapias in Africa, after Egypt a few decades ago
(El-Sayed, 2006). In 1950, there were only two countries in Africa that had record of tilapia
production, namely, Egypt with production figure of 700 Metric tons and Nigeria with production
figure of 208 Metric tons the author reported. It is sad however, to note that, while Egypt’s
production of tilapia is in excess of 500, 000 Metric tons, Nigeria produces less than 50,000 Metric
tons. In West Africa, Nigeria is one of the largest producer of tilapia (Table 1)
Table 1: A table of West African countries and tilapia production
Country
Inland fisheries Production(MT)
Tilapia Production(MT)
1.Benin
2.Burkina Faso
3.Cote d’Ivoire
4.Gambia
5.Ghana
6.Guinea
7.G. Bissau
8.Liberia
9.Mali
10.Niger
11.Nigeria
12.Senegal
13.Sierra Leone
14 Togo
Total
35,000.0
7,500.0
11,650.0
2,500.0
75,580.0
4,000.0
250.0
4,000.0
111,910.
4135.0
67,794.0
47,500.0
14,500.0
5,000.0
389 319.0
7,000.0
1,500.0
2330.0
500.0
14,716.0
800.0
50.0
800.0
22,382.0
827.0
13,558.0
9,500.0
2,900.0
1,000.0
60 578.0
127
Source: Abban and Agyakwa (2004).
The bulk of tilapia production in Nigeria is from natural population in rivers, lake and lagoons. In
Nigeria tilapias are cultivated in ponds, reservoirs and cages in Nigeria (Fagbenro et al., 2004) and
are suitable in low-tech farming systems. This is because of their relatively fast growth rate, ability
to convert low protein feed to flesh, resistance to environmental variables, ease of reproduction in
captivity and tolerance to wide ranges of disease conditions (Fagbenro, 1987). Tilapia farming in
Nigeria remained largely a subsistence level activity until 2000, when it began to expand rapidly
following the successful commercial farming of catfishes (Fagbenro, 2006; Afolabi et al., 2007).
There is a wide range of tilapia genetic resources in Nigeria. They include, Tilapia zillii, T.
guineensis (substrate spawners, macro-phytophagous (generally herbivorous), Sarotherodon
galilaeus, S. melanotheron (bi-parental mouth-brooders, micro-phytophagous (planktophagous),
Oreochromis niloticus and O. aureus (maternal mouth-brooders, omnivorous).
There are however a number of unidentified tilapia in our waters. Among this is the ecotype cichlid
commonly called ‘wesafu’ having eco-fidelity to Epe lagoon. This fish grows to 1,500g and 414mm
in the wild (Fashina-Bombata et al., 2006, 2007; Megbowon and Fashina- Bombatta, 2010). It has a
deep body that makes a candidate for filleting. Recent studies on ‘wesafu’ indicated that it is
maternal mouth brooder (Oreochromis) (Fashina-Bombata and Megbowon, 2012). The fish had
improved crude protein over other cichlid fishes of Epe lagoon where it is abundantly caught
(Bombata et al., 2013). DNA analysis using RAPD further showed ‘wesafu’ is unique in its band
when compared with known species. However, molecular studies on the fish using mtDNA, using
cytochrome oxidate sub unit 1 revealed that ‘wesafu’ could be one of the three known species
namely, Sarotherodon boulengeri (99.45% confidence), Oreochromis niloticus (99.36%) and
Oreochromis aureus (99.33% confidence) (Jayasaker et al., 2012). Considering the morphological
features of these species which is at variance with ‘wesafu’, it may be right to say that ‘wesafu’ is
the product of hybridization of any of these known species.
It is heartwarming to note that Nigerian waters have tilapia genetic resources of outstanding status.
The report of Moreau et al. (1986) who reported that O. niloticus obtained from Kainji, Nigeria had
the highest growth performance index of 3.11 when compared with other natural populations from
different continents of the world is remarkable. Today fishermen still catch tilapia weighing over
1.5kg from our waters. It is therefore necessary to first assemble information on the genetic status of
these fish for possible genetic improvement programme. The high growth performance index of this
strain of O. niloticus may be an indication of better growth when brought into captivity for
domestication. Such information is important to the development of tilapia culture in Nigeria.
PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS OF TILAPIA IN NIGERIA
Although the potential for tilapia culture is high, the production in Africa and more importantly,
Nigeria is very low; the draw-back being the precocious maturity, uncontrolled reproduction in
ponds leading to increased competition for food, reduction in growth rate which results in a
phenomenon referred to as stunting (Bombatta et al., 2005; Baroiller and Toguyemi, 1996). This
early maturation and frequent spawning are management challenges when working with tilapia.
However, the culture of monosex produces a better result. Male tilapia is preferred for culture
because of their faster growth. It is however usually difficult to differentiate male and female tilapia
when they are young (less than 3-4"). When the fish are larger, they can be separated by inspecting
the genital papilla on the ventral or underside of the fish. The papilla of the male tends to be
elongated with one opening. The papilla of the female tends to be wider, and has two openings, one
of which is a transverse slit.
Furthermore, we need to properly identify the genetic status of our tilapia and genetically improve
them. However, genetic improvement of tilapia in Nigeria is likely to face a major setback due to
lack of fish genetic research facilities, poor funding of genetic research, poor manpower
128
development, inadequate research facilities as well as poor documentation of the genetic resources.
Genetic resources are global assets (Megbowon, 2011). Information on tilapia genetic resources in
Nigeria is lacking. Many of tilapia species have high growth potential. The report of Moreau et al.
(1986) who reported that O. niloticus obtained from Kainji, Nigeria had the highest growth
performance index of 3.11 when compared with other natural populations from different continents
of the world is remarkable. Today fishermen still catch tilapia weighing over 1.5kg from our waters
(Megbowon et al., 2009). It is therefore necessary to first assemble information on the genetic
status of these fish for possible genetic improvement programme.
STRATEGIES FOR IMPROVED TILAPIA AQUCULTURE IN NIGERIA
Agricultural production is presently enhanced through genetic improvement of germplasm leading
to improved varieties (Megbowon et al., 2009). For improved tilapia production in Nigeria, there
must of necessity, be a program on the characterization of our tilapia genetic resources. The
resources should be assemble and characterize using modern tools such as molecular assays (DNA
analysis), considering the fact that many cichlid fishes are genetically similar. This should then be
followed with genetic improvement. Our genetic improvement program might begin with several
generations of selective breeding, as it is done in GIFT (Genetic Improvement of Farmed Tilapia).
Tilapia has great potential in Nigeria as an alternative and/or additional species of farmed fish. The
mud catfish (Clarias gariepinus) is presently experiencing glut in Nigeria market with attendant
poor market price, it become necessary to have an alternative species that command high market
acceptance. Tilapia is the first candidate for consideration as a scaly fish having no religious or
cultural resistance to consumption. Considering tilapia as one of the important and potential fish
species, the following developmental areas and strategies are identified for necessary consideration:
•There abounds hundreds and thousands of seasonal water bodies (>0.1 ha) in the form of ditches,
shallow ponds, road side canals and barrow pit that retains water for 4-6 months. These bodies of
water have great potential for the culture of fish species having short generation period and
characterized by faster growth rate requiring low input support (Hussain et al., 2000). In such cases,
tilapia can be a promising candidate for aquaculture in the suitable seasonal water bodies.
• Tilapia occupies an important position in rural aquaculture (Megbowon, 2010). Across the
country, there abound countless number of dams, rivers, lagoon and lakes where cages can be
installed. The installation of cages will fast track the production process as the cost of water
procurement/ pumping is eliminated. Furthermore, aeration is important to the culture and
profitability of tilapia farming. In such bodies of water, particularly flowing water (rivers and
lagoons) the cost of aeration will be reduced. In cage culture, tilapia prolific spawning is eliminated
as the egg released pass through the mesh of the cage and get lost thus preventing reproduction
which will in effect eliminate the phenomenon of stunting, a disincentive to tilapia farming.
• Furthermore, Nigeria must explore the knowledge of biotechnology and genetic breeding to
improve her stocks. Such biotechnology tools such as chromosomal manipulation through
polyploidy, transgenic and production of YY super male technology could be the future focus of our
tilapia genetic resources development.
CONCLUSION
Tilapia holds the key to rural aquaculture in Nigeria. However, its potentials will only be optimized
if adequate attention is given to its genetic resources and its development. This development will
boost food security, poverty eradication and sustainable livelihood of the rural dwellers.
REFERENCES
Abban, E. K. and Agyakwa, S. (2004). Socio-Economic Importance of Tilapiine Fishes (Teleostei,
Cichlidae). WorldFish Center | Biodiversity, Management and Utilization of West African
Fishes. p 1-3.
129
Afolabi, J.A., Imoudu, P.B. and Fagbenro, O.A. 2000. Peri-urban tilapia culture in homestead
concrete tanks: economic and technical viability in Nigeria. Proceedings of Fifth
International Symposium on Tilapia in Aquaculture (ISTA V), pp.575-581. (K. Fitzsimmons
and J.C. Filho, eds.). Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
El-Sayed, A-F. 2006. Tilapia Culture CABI Publications, Wallingford, UK. 275pp.
Fashina-Bombatta H.A, R.G Ajepe and A.M Hemmed (2006). Food and feeding habits of an
ecotype cichlid,wesafu from Epe lagoon, Lagos, Nigeria. World Aquaculture , 37: 62-66.
Fashina-Bombatta, H.A., Ajepe, R.G. and Hemmed, A.M. and Jimoh, A.A.
(2005).
Characterization of an ecotype cichlid commonly referred to as wesafu, endemic to Epe
lagoon, Nigeria. World Aquaculture, 36: 20-22.
Fagbenro, O.A., Akinbulumo, M.O. and Ojo, S.O. (2004). Aquaculture in Nigeria – pastM
experience, present situation and future outlook (history, status and prospects). World
Aquaculture, 35 (2): 23-26.
FAO (2008). FAO, Fisheries Department, Fisheries Information, Data and Statistics unit, 214-218.
Fashina Bombata, H. A, Ajepe, R.G., Hammed, A.M. and Jimoh, A.A. (2005). Characterization of
an ecotype cichlid commonly referred to as ―wesafuǁ endermic to Epe lagoon, Nigeria.
World Aquaculture, 36 (4)
Fashina-Bombata, H.A. and Megbowon, I (2012). Proximate composition and breeding description
of an unidentified cichlid of Epe lagoon, Lagos, South-West, Nigeria commonly called
‘wesafu’. International Journal of Nutrition and Metabolism, 4 (4): 57-63.
Fashina-Bombata, H.A., Megbowon, I., Okunade O.A, Ozor, P.O. Ibrahim, O.A and Kolade, O.Y .
(2013). Comparative study of the proximate composition of ome wild tilapiine fishes in Epe
lagoon, Lagos, Nigeria. Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic sciences 8 (1): 265-267.
Hussain, M.G., A.H.M Kohinoor, M.S. Islam, M.A Hossain, M.M. Dey and M.A Mazid. 2000.
Growth and production performances of GIFT strain of Nile tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus
L., in ponds and cages under different farming conditions in Bangladesh. J. Aqua. Trop., 15:
273-280.
Mareau, J. Bambino, C. and Paley, D. (1986). Indices of overall growth performance of 100 Tilapia
(cichlid) populations, In J.L.Mclean, L.B Sizon and L.V Hisllos (eds.). The first Asian
Fisheries Forum. Asian Fisheries Society, Manilla, Philippines. Pp. 201-206.
Megbowon, I., Fashina-Bombata, H.A., Mojekwu, T.O. and Okuade O.A. (2009). Genetic
Improvement of Tilapia: Challenges and Prospects in Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of
Fisheries, 6 (1&2): 21-30.
Megbowon, I. and Fashina-Bmbata, H.A. (2010). Tilapia: Fish for the Millenium. FISHNETWORK
Vol.iii. Fisheries Society of Nigeria Quarterly Publication (Supported by World Bank/
NSME Nigeria). Pp. 36-40.
Megbowon, I. (2011). Tilapia Production in Nigeria. FISHNETWORK Vol. iv. Fisheries Society of
Nigeria Quarterly Publication (Supported by World Bank/ NSME Nigeria). Pp. 18-22.
Jayasankar, P., Fashina Bombatta H.A and Megbowon I (2012). Biochemical characterization of the
cichlid, ‘wesafu’ from Epe lagoon, Nigeria. Proceedings of the 25th Annual Conference of
Biotechnology Society of Nigeria held 26th-31st August, 2012 at The National Open
University of Nigeria, Abuja, Pp. 276-279.
Olojo E. A. A., Olurin, K.B. and Osikoya O.J. (2003). Food and feeding habit of synodontis nigrita
from the Osun River, SW, Nigeria.
Popma, J.T. and Lorshin L.L. (1996). Worldwide prospect for commercial production of tilapia.
Research and development series. No. 41. International centre for aquaculture and aquatic
environments, department of fisheries and Allied Aquaculture, Areburn University
Alabama, 36849.
130
AGB18
POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION DETECTION OF ASFV GENOME IN NIGERIAN
INDIGENOUS PIGS
Oluwole, O.O.1* and Omitogun, G.O.2
1
Institute of Agricultural Research and Training, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Science, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria.
*Corresponding email: oluwafunmike@yahoo.co.uk
ABSTRACT
This study was carried out at the Piggery unit of the Institute of Agricultural Research and Training
(I.A.R&T.) Ibadan, Nigeria. Blood of pure Nigerian indigenous pigs (NIP) was collected from the
jugular vein and the DNA extraction was done by using DNA kit (Zymobeads). Diagnostic
Polymerase Chain Reaction for African Swine Fever Virus (ASFV) was performed according to the
Manual of Diagnostic Tests and Vaccines. The ASF primers [PAS 1 (Forward) and PAS 2
(Reverse)] were utilized. A single discrete and specific band was observed in NIP and the infected
samples collected from the University of Ibadan, Nigeria as positive control of the expected size
131
[278 base pairs (bp)]. The result showed that pure NIP was also infected with ASFV without it
showing any clinical symptoms.
Keywords: Nigerian Indigenous pigs, polymerase chain reaction, African Swine Fever, tolerance
INTRODUCTION
The population of pig in Nigeria increases from 2 million in 1984 to 7 million in 1997 before the
widespread of African Swine Fever (ASF) epizootic (Dafwang, 2010). The Nigerian Indigenous Pig
(NIP) is becoming extinct as livestock genetic resource due to the high rate of genetic erosion that is
caused by extensive indiscriminate and unplanned mating with exotic pig breeds. It has been
acknowledged that the NIP is resistant to ASF but it has not been scientifically investigated and
documented.
Disease is one of the factors that affect the livestock production in Nigeria (Abubakar, 2003).
Jovanoic et al. (2009) stated that diseases can have a significant impact on animal productivity and
production, human health and, consequently, on the overall process of economic development. Pigs
harbour a range of parasites and diseases some of which are zoonotic. One of these is the ASF that
is caused by a virus.
ASF is a highly contagious viral disease of pigs and of such concern that it is included among the
List A diseases by the United Nations Office International des Epizooties (OIE) (Owolodun et al.,
2010; Sánchez-Vizcaíno et al., 2009, 2010; OIE, 2008; Penrith, et al., 2004; FAO, 2010). It causes
a devastating haemorrhagic fever of pigs with mortality rates approaching 100 per cent with the
acute and peracute forms. It causes major economic losses, threatens food security and limits pig
production in affected countries. The disease causes significant economic losses in affected
countries due to the high mortality rates associated. The transmission of the disease, as it now
occurs in sub-Saharan Africa, is through the African soft tick (Ornithodoros moubata porcinus) and
Warthogs or domestic pigs. The transmission through the warthog and soft ticks does not occur in
West Africa, although ASF virus has been detected from Warthog in Nigeria (Luther, 2008), and
the presence of soft ticks has also been confirmed (Penrith et al., 2004). This study aimed at
screening pure NIPs in the piggery unit of Institute of Agricultural Research and Training (I.A.R.T)
in Ibadan to verify disease resistance of NIPs to ASF.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Blood sample (5ml) of the pure NIPs was collected from the jugular vein into anticoagulant
container. The DNA extraction was done by using DNA kit (Zymobeads). Diagnostic Polymerase
Chain Reaction (PCR) was performed according to the Manual of Diagnostic Tests and Vaccines
(OIE, 2008). ASF-specific primers (oligonucleotide primers) targeting the major capsid protein
(VP72 gene) amplifying a 278-bp fragment within the conserved region was employed: PAS1F: 5’ATG GAT ACC GAG GGA ATA GC-3’ and PAS2R: 5’-CTT ACC GAT GAA AAT GAT AC-3’
(Luther et al., 2007; OIE, 2008). The final reaction volume of 25 μl PCR master mix comprised 1·0
μl extracted DNA template, 10μl Nuclease Free Water, 1·0 μl oligonucleotide primers (for both
Forward and Reverse) and 12 μl of already prepared Master Mix. Each tube was placed in an
automated PCR thermal cycler (MG48+; MygeneTM Series) for amplification for 35 cycles as
follows: initial denaturation at 94°C for 3minutes for 35 cycles, with 3 steps of denaturation at 94°C
for 30 seconds, annealing at 57°C for 45 seconds and extension at 72°C for 30 seconds and final
extension at 72°C for 5 minutes. Amplification products were analyzed by electrophoresis on a 1%
agarose gel containing 0.5 μg of ethidium bromide per ml. The gel was visualized under Ultra violet
light and photographed.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
From the PCR for molecular investigation, a single discrete and specific band of the expected size
(278 base pairs (bp) was observed for NIP in lane 6 while discrete band was observed for infected
132
animals collected from university of Ibadan used as positive control in lane 5 and no band was
observed in lane 7 as negative control. The result showed that pure NIP was also infected with
ASFV without showing any clinical symptoms.
1
2
3 4
5
6 7
8
9 10 11
Amplification at 278bp of NIP in lane 5, infected sample from University of Ibadan as a positive
control in lane 6 and lane 7 showing the negative control without the DNA and molecular marker
(100bp) in Lane1.
The 278bp of ASFV observed in NIP was corroborated by the findings of Luther, et al. (2007),
where the same virus band was observed in Bush pigs and Warthogs tested at National Veterinary
Research Institute (NVRI), Jos. The resistance of NIP to ASFV for long period without any clinical
symptom or death was explained by Adeoye and Adebambo (2010) as the ability of host to trap
ASFV within their tissues by the activities of macrophages that eat up the pathogens and infected
tissues so that other parts and their mast cells in the tissues are not affected.
This observation was also explained by the work of Adeoye and Adebambo (2010) where
serological tests were carried out on ASF outbreak survivors, their offspring and F2 showed a
decline in antibody levels against ASF from 100% to 18.79%. This phenomenon was explained as
the ability of engulfed ASFV to be broken down easily and effectively by macrophages leading to
decreasing circulation of ASFV in the blood and other tissue. Thus, the amount of shed ASFV
particles observed in urine and faeces was seen to drop significantly in their offspring (Adeoye and
Adebambo, 2010). This observation was also corroborated by Olugasa (2007) who also reported
that level of infection in the serum dropped from 96.8% in the stock to 13.8% in young stock. The
ability of the virus to persist in one host while killing another genetically related host has been
established by Palgrave et al. (2011) where a particular sequence found in warthog and bush pigs
was absent in domestic pigs.
There is the question of defining NIP so called ‘resistance’ to ASFV as whether it is ‘resistant’ or
‘tolerant’? An animal as a host can only evolve two types of defense mechanism to increase its
fitness when challenged with pathogen which are resistance and tolerance (Doeschl-Wilson, 2012).
It is important to distinguish between these two defense mechanisms in NIP because they have
different pathological and epidemiological effects. An increased understanding of tolerance to
pathogen infection could lead to more efficient treatments for infectious diseases and a better
description of host–pathogen interactions. Jovanovic (2009) defines resistance as ability of an
animal to resist infection (which means that the virus will not be seen in the animal), while
tolerance signifies a condition in which the host is infected by the pathogen but displays very
limited adverse effects. By this definition, we can classify NIP as being tolerant.
133
Both host resistance and tolerance enhance host fitness but major difference between the two is
important in genetic improvement programme. The effects of resistance and tolerance can lead to
striking difference in epidemiological and evolutionary outcomes in affected animals.
Disease control strategy using genetic improvement to obtain host resistance is better than disease
control strategy using breeding to obtain host tolerance. This is because of their different
epidemiological and evolutionary consequences, meaning that the ASF eradication in a population
can only be achieved through increasing resistance while the tolerance will not constraint ASF
replication. It has been argued that selective breeding may be more evolution-proof than
manipulations in resistance because tolerance does not impose selection for pathogen countermeasures. FAO (2012) also stated that the breeding for increased resistance to ASFV may be
possible, but there are several factors to be considered before embarking on such a program. One
consideration is that resistant pigs that are unable to be infected by ASFV will be difficult to
achieve. It is more likely that pigs will express a phenotype that will not succumb to the clinical
effects of ASFV. While these type pigs may not express clinical disease, they may become infected
and could shed ASFV into the environment. As such, these pigs could pose a risk to susceptible
pigs in the area or undermine control strategies. Instead transcriptome analysis of ASFV-infected
macrophages using microarrays can be used which will provide new candidate genes that are
differentially regulated during infection. Such candidate genes could be used for development of
DNA marker tests for selection of animals with reduced susceptibility to disease. Therefore
conservation of resistant breeds is critical for progress in genetic resistance to ASFV.
CONCLUSION
From this study, it can be concluded that NIP has ASFV but do not exhibit any clinical sign.
REFERENCES
Abubakar, M.B., Ngele, D.J.N and Achaji, M.B. (2003). In: Problems of Annual livestock
production in Nigeria. A case study of Akko local government area of Gombe state.
Proceedings of the 28th conference of the Nigerian society for animal production.Pp 71-73.
Adeoye, A.O. and Adebambo, A.O. (2010). Proceedings of First Nigerian International Pig
Summit, by Nigerian Institute Animal science, Institute of Agricultural Research and
Training, Moor plantation. Pp.114-124
Dafwang, I.I., Adebambo, O.A and Adesehinwa A.O. K. (2010). Status of pigs Production and
Marketting in Nigeria: An Overview of Current Practises, Problems and Prospects. First
Nigerian international pig summit, 22-25 November, Institute of Agricultural Research
Institute, Ibadan. Pp 1-17.
Doeschl-Wilson, A. (2012).
“Should we aim for genetic improvement in host resistance or
tolerance to diseases, Google Books.,” n.d.) .Pp. 9-17.
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) (2010). The state capacities of
animal genetic resources management Rome.
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) (2012). Animal genetic resources
and resistance to disease. Rome. Pp. 108-110.
Jovanović, S.M., Savić1, D. and Živković, M. (2009). Genetic Variation In Disease Resistance
Among Farm Animals. Biotechnology in Animal Husbandry, 25 (5-6): 339-347.
Luther, N. J., Udeama, P. G., Majiyagbe, K. A., Shamaki, D., Antiabong, J., Bitrus, Y., Nwosuh
C.I. and Owolodun, O. A. (2007a). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) detection of the
genome of African swine fever virus (ASFV) from natural infection in a Nigerian baby
warthog (Phacochoereus aethiopicus). Niger. Vet. J., 28: 63–67.
OIE (2008). Manual of diagnostic tests and vaccines for terrestrial animals,5th Ed. OIE, Paris, pp
957. (http://www.oie.int/eng/en_index.htm:).
Olugasa (2007). Serological Evidence of African Swine Fever Virus infection in commercial pig
heard in South West Nigeria. African Journal of Livestock Extension, 5: 61-64.
134
Owolodun, O.A., Bastos A.S., Antiabong J.F., Ogedengbe M.E., Ekong P.S. and Yakubu B.,
(2010). Molecular characterisation of African swine fever viruses from Nigeria (2003–2006)
recovers multiple virus variants and reaffirms CVR epidemiological utility. Springer Science
Media.
Penrith, M.L. ,Thomson, G.R., Bastos, A.D.S., Phiri, O.C., Lubisi, B.A., Du Plessis, E.C., F.,
Macome, F., Pinto, F., Botha, B. and Esterhuysen, J. (2004). An investigation into natural
resistance to African swine fever in domestic pigs from an endemic area in southern Africa.
Review Science Technology of International Office Epizoonotic 23 (3): 965-977.
Palgrave, C.J., Gilmour, L., Lowden, S., Simon, G., Martha, L., Mellencamp, A. and Whitelaw,
C. A. (2011). Pathogenesis Potential Role in African Swine Fever Underlies Differences in
NF- kB Activity: a Species-Specific Variation in RELA. Journal of Virology., 85(12) pg
6008.
AGB19
PHYSIOLOGICAL EVALUATION OF PRE-WEANING GROWTH TRAITS IN NIP
CROSSBREDS
Oluwole, O. O.*, Tiamiyu, A.K., Olorungbounmi, T.O., Oladele, M.B. and Akintoye, N.A.
Institute of Agricultural Research and Training, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: oluwafunmike@yahoo.co.uk
ABSTRACT
The study was carried out at the Piggery unit of the Institute of Agricultural Research and Training
(I.A.R&T.) Ibadan, Nigeria. Forty-seven hybrid progenies from crossbreeding between the
Nigerian Indigenous Pig (NIP) and Large White pigs were used. Body measurements and live
weight were recorded weekly from first week of birth to their weaning date. Body measurements
taken were Body Weight (BW), Body Length (BL), Snout Length (SL), Ear Length (EL), Body
Height (BH), Heart girth (HG) and Rump circumference (RC) of crossbred progenies. The
correlation between the reproductive parameters and growth performance of hybrid pigs were
established with good management practice. The mean for weaning weight was 6.72±0.96, birth
weight 0.91±0.15, litter size at birth 5.36 ±1.87, litter size at weaning 5.29 ±1.97, litter weight at
birth 4.56 ±1.57, total litter weight at weaning 33.91±11.6, average daily weaning weight
0.73±0.12, average litter size at birth 0.93±0.11 and sex ratio 97.78±8.61%. The male and female
mean values for weight of animals were 6.96±1.0 and 6.52± 0.9 with males heavier in weight and
higher in morphometric traits such as BL, HG and RC, while the females exhibited higher SL, EL
and BH. The correlation matrix for BW against linear body measurements in pre-weaned NIP
crossbreds indicates that all the parameters could be used to select for BW. The linear equation
generated by regressing BW on SL, BH, RC, HG and BL could be used by resource poor pig
farmers in the estimation of BW of pre weaned crossbreds pigs if they cannot afford weighing
scales.
Keywords: Morphometric measurement, pig, hybrid, correlation, regression
INTRODUCTION
135
Crossbreeding is a successful management practice for improving litter productivity in swine
(Oseni, 2005). It is also an effective means of improving reproductive performance i.e. heterosis or
hybrid vigour that comes from an increase in heterozygosity, which leads to better average
genotypic values at dominant loci. Genetic improvement for reproductive and growth traits of
Nigerian Indigenous Pig can be brought about by crossbreeding and long term selection within the
existing population, provided additive genetic variance exists. This offers the opportunity to
increase genetic variation from which leaner and more efficient animals can be selected (Wheeler
and Campion, 1993). Evaluation of the performance of animals constitutes an essential part of
successful breeding plans for sustainable genetics improvement. In order to develop a very good
model for the genetic improvement of crossed pigs, it is important to measure the traits of interest.
Pigs are mostly kept for their meat and the most important trait of interest for their genetic
improvement is the body weight. According to Cam et al. (2010), body weight is a very important
characteristic in animal husbandry due to its effect on economical profit. Live weight might be
affected by different management, environment and enterprise feeding conditions. Proper
measurement of this trait on-farm is sometimes difficult because of unavailability of weighing scale
in the rural areas. Therefore use of simple linear body measurement parameters to predict live
weight will be appreciated by the farmers. Some traits are usually regulated by the same pair of
genes. Hence information on associations between traits is highly valuable in genetic
improvements. In pig production, growth and reproductive traits are important (Mungate et al.,
1999; Hermesch et al., 2000a; Zhang et al., 2000). According to Adeola (2005) and Oke et al.
(2006), age had been shown to have influence on morphological measurement of crossbred pigs.
According to Adebambo (1983), productivity of breeding stock depends majorly on the
reproductive efficiency, growth performance and feed efficiency. Many works have been carried
out on Nigerian indigenous crossbreds (LW 50% X NIP 50%) by Adebambo and Detmers (1979),
Adebambo (1981, 1983). They have reported superior values for exotic and crossbreds over the NIP
in body weight, weaning weight at 52 days of age, average daily gain and milk yield.
This study focused on age, reproductive parameters and the relationship between live weight and
morphological parameters such as snout length (SL), body length (BL), heart girth (HG), body
height (BH) and rump circumference (RC). It is also to determine the strength of relationship and
prediction of bodyweight from linear body measurements.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was carried out at the Southern Farm, Piggery Unit of the Institute of Agricultural
Research and Training (I.A.R&T.). Forty-seven hybrid progenies from crossbreeding between the
NIP and Large white pigs were used. Body measurements were recorded weekly from first week of
birth to their weaning date. Body measurements taken were Body Weight (BW), Body Length (BL),
Snout Length (SL), Ear Length (EL), Body Height (BH), Heart girth (HG) and Rump (RC) of the
progeny of crossed breed. Body Weight (BW), was measured with weighing scale, (BL), the length
of the animal from the last cervical to the lumbar vertebra (base of the tail), Heart Girth (HG), the
circumference of the chest region and rump circumference (RC) the circumference of the loin
region; were measured with a measuring tape in centimeter. The following parameters were taken
Litter size at birth (total number of piglets farrowed), Litter birth weight (Weight of all the piglets
farrowed), Average birth weight (total weight of the number born alive divided by the total weight
of the live litter size at birth), Litter size at weaning (number of piglets at weaning), Litter weaning
weight (total weight of the piglets in each litter) Average daily gain pre – weaning (ADGPW) (a
weakly difference of piglet weight). The data were analyzed using the general linear model (GLM)
procedures where the differences between the characteristics of the growth Data weren summarized
by using obtain variances for the estimation of morphometric traits and phenotypic correlations
among pre-weaning traits such as BW, WW, LSB, LSW, ADWG,, TBW, TWW, SR%.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
136
There was no significant effect of sex on the birth weight as shown below. This result was
corroborated with findings of Adeoye et al. (2012) where the pre-weaning weight of piglets from
ASF survivors parents were not affected by sex. The heavier weight of male than females with
6.94kg was in corroboration with Adeoye et al. (2012), where the male was heavier than female
with 7.13kg
Tables 1, 2 and 3 show the mean for reproductive traits, the morphometric traits .of hybrid pigs
from age 1 to 7 weeks and the morphometric traits of male and female. The mean for weaning
weight was 6.72±0.96, birth weight 0.91±0.15, litter size at birth 5.36 ±1.87, litter size at weaning
5.29 ±1.97, litter weight at birth 4.56 ±1.57, total litter weight at weaning 33.91±11.6, average daily
weaning weight 0.73±0.12, average litter size at birth 0.93±0.11 and survival rate 97.78±8.61%.
The values obtained are similar to those reported by Adeoye et al. (2012) in birth weight (1.05),
weaning weight (7.08), litter size at weaning (5.72), but lower in litter weaning weight (38.85);
while it was higher than that of Orheruata (2000) in weaning weight (4.87) and lower than is 14.50
reported by Ngere (1975). The litter size at birth is lower than that of Adebambo (1981) and
Nwakpu and Ugwu (2009).
Table 1. Mean for reproductive traits
Traits
Mean (kg)
WW
6.72±0.96
BW
0.91±0.15
LSB
5.36 ±1.87
LSW
5.29 ±1.97
TLWB
4.56 ±1.57
TLWW
33.91±11.6
ADWG
0.73±0.12
ALSB
0.93±0.11
S.R%
97.78±8.61
BW-Body weight, BW- Birth weight, WW-Weaning weight, LSB-Average Litter size at
birth, LSW- Litter size at weaning, ALSB-Average S.R-survival rate,
Table2: Mean for morphometric traits from week 1-7 weeks
Traits
WK
BW
SL
BL
BH
RC
HG
1
1.44 3.69±0.3 23.03±4.7 20.33±0.9 22.90±5.8 25.28±3.0
2
2.79 3.98±0.3 27.08±1.2 24.17±0.8 28.00±2.7 30.33±2.13
3
3.28 4.50±1.4 30.64±4.3 26.09±1.8 32.91±2.6 34.27±2.6
4
4.41 5.27±0.5 34.00±1.2 29.00±1.8 34.54±2.7 36.96±2.6
5
5.18 4.77±0.0 36.37±4.8 29.05±1.8 39.18±2.6 39.05±2.6
6
6.09 5.82±0.0 40.55±4.8 32.09±1.8 44.27±1.9 41.73±2.4
7
6.71 5.77±0.5 42.73±4.5 34.09±2.4 46.46±2.6 43.36±2.6
BW-Body weight, BL- Body Length, HG- Heart girth, NC- Neck circumference, SL- Snout
Length, SC, TL – Tail length, RC- Rump circumference, BL- Body length, BH-Body height
( Height at wither)
Male and female mean values for weight of animals were 6.96±1.0 and 6.52± 0.9 with male
heavier in weight and higher in morphometric traits such as BL, HG and RC, while the
female were high in morphometric traits such as SL, EL and BH.
137
Table 3: Mean (kg) for the morphometric traits of males and females
Traits
WT
SL
EL
BL
HG
BH
RC
Male
Female
6.96±1.0
6.86 ±0.8
9.21±1.2
44.33±5.7
41.10±3.7
34.19±3.1
39.95±6.2
6.52± 0.9
6.88± 0.6
9.39±1.2
44.18± 4.3
40.84±0.7
34.95 ±3.3
37.89±4.6
All the body parameters measured were positively and highly significantly (P< 0.001)
correlated with BW (Table 4). The correlation coefficient ranged between 0.74 and 0.85. RC
and BH had the highest correlation coefficient of 0.85 followed by HG and BH with values
of 0.81, respectively.
Table 4. Pearson correlation Matrix of body weight and linear body measurements in
preweaned NIP crossbreds.
Variables
WT
SL
BL
BH
RC
HG
WT
0.81
SL
0.74
0.68
BL
BH
RC
0.85
0.85
0.81
0.71
0.73
0.76
0.76
0.84
0.79
0.78
0.68
0.86
HG
WT= weight, BL=Body length, SL=Snout length, RC=Rump circumference, BH= Body height,
HG=Heart girth.
The best prediction equation for BW from body measurement variables is shown in Table 5. For
a unit increase in SL, BH, RC and HG, the BW of pre weaned hybrid pigs will increase by 0.66,
0.20, 0.01 and 0.11Kg, respectively.
138
Table 5. Linear regressions relating body weight to various body linear measurements in
preweaning NIP crossbreds.
Prediction Equations
Coefficient of determination (R²)
BW=-7.80-0.01BL+0.66SL+0.20BH+0.01RC+0.113HG
0.86
M=Body linear measurement, BW=Body weight, BL=Body length, SL=Snout Circumference,
RC=Rump circumference, HG=Heart girth.
There was low correlation between the weaning weight and other reproductive traits with
the exception of average daily weight gain ADWG as shown in table below.
Table 6 . Pearson correlation matrix for reproductive traits
Traits
WWT
BW
ADWG ALSB TLWTB TLWW
WWT
1.00
BW
0.23
1.00
ADWG
0.99
0.08
1.00
ALSB
0.21
0.99
0.06
1.00
TLWTB
-0.32
0.06
-0.33
-0.00
1.00
TLWW
-0.01
-0.26
0.03
-0.34
0.87
S.R%
0.37
0.48
0.41
-0.08
0.41
S.R %
1.00
-0.08
1.00
The high correlation observed between litter size at birth and at weaning (Table 6) is
expected because an increase in the number of piglet in a litter will cause an increment
in the total litter weight. The correlation between the litter size and weaning weight is
corroborated with the findings of Nwakwu et al. (2007) and Nwagu et al. (2000), that
there is positive and significant correlation between the liter size, weaning weight and
survival rate of piglets. The negative correlation observed between litter size and
average litter weight suggested that the factors that work for the increment of the litter
size also cause reduction of average weight of the piglets. A highly negative and
significant correlation between litter size and mean kit weight at birth of rabbit was
reported by Nwagu et. al. (2010). The relationship between average piglet weight and
liter size is however not invariable. Litter size has low heritability (Rico et al., 2000)
and crossbreeding has been found to improve it (Adebambo, 1986)
The superior weaning weights of the crossbred pigs in this study also mean that the
total litter weight at weaning was higher for the crossbred pigs. Such findings could
support the argument that crossbred pigs can be utilized under smallholder farming
systems. Whittemore (1993) suggested that the high weaning weights of crossbred pigs
could also have been a reflection of their higher birth weights. Ncube et. al. (2003)
reported that the heavier piglets of the crossbred were better able to compete for milk
139
because they were thriftier and hence had higher chances of surviving up to weaning.
One of the most common and most useful statistics that describes the degree of
relationship between two variables is the correlation (Cam et al., 2009). The estimation
of accurate BW from animal’s simple body measurements will make it easier for
farmers in the rural areas, who has little or no access to weighing scale. Due to
affordability of measuring tapes a producer can measure all the body measurements
easily from a live animal and can determine body weight approximately. Teghe and
Olorunda (1998) and Adeola (2009) reported similar results between BW and body
measurements in pigs while Afolayan et al. (2006), Salako (2006) and Cankaya et al.
(2009) reported same for sheep
According to the correlation modules, BW was found to be very highly correlated with
all body dimensional traits measured (0.74-0.85). Of the body dimensional characters,
Rump circumference and body height were the most related trait to weight and the
correlation between these two traits was 0.85. Variables such as heart girth, body
height, body length, which are directly related to the size and weight of animal, showed
moderate to very high positive correlations with each other (0.68-0.86). However, the
measure of snout length was lowly correlated with body length (0.68).The high
correlation coefficient observed between body weight and the linear body measurement
parameters shows that selection for these traits will result in correlated responses in
these traits.
In most studies HG was found to be highly correlated with BW in pigs (Teghe and
Olorunda, 1998), in sheep (Topal and Macit, 2004; Atta and khidir, 2004; Afolayan et
al., 2006), in cattle (Koenen and Groen. 1997; Goe et al., 2001; Heinrichs et al., 2007)
and in goats (Khan et al., 2006; Nsoso et al., 2003). The difference between this result
and the mentioned literature can be attributed to the differences in age, nutrition and
rearing conditions. Fattening status should be taken into consideration in order to
predict an animal’s BW from its body measurements. In this study, results suggest that
variables with high correlation coefficients might be used to predict BW of preweaned
NIP crossbreds. Khan et al. (2006) suggested that the highest relationship amongst
body measurements may be used as selection criterion in traditional production systems
in rural areas.
CONCLUSION
The correlation between the reproductive parameters and growth performance of hybrid
pigs were established with good management practice. The correlation matrix for BW
and linear body measurements in pre-weaned NIP crossbreds indicates that all the
parameters could be used to select for BW. The linear equation generated by regressing
BW on SL, BH, RC, HG and BL could be used by resource poor pig farmers in the
estimation of BW of pre weaned crossbreds pigs if they cannot afford weighing scales
REFERENCES
Adebambo, O. A. (1981). A comparison of indigenous and exotic purebred and crossbred sows in
Southern Nigeria: relationship between dam and litter performance. Nigerian Journal
Animal Production, 8: 67 - 74.
Adebambo, O. A. (1983). Comparative growth and carcass performance of progenies sired by
purebred Large White and Hampshire boars and their crosses with the Nigerian local breed.
Nigerian Journal of Animal Production, 10 (1 and 2): 124 - 133.
Adebambo, O.A. (1986). Pig improvement and development in the tropics: the applications of
breeding and genetics. Proceedings of the International Seminar on pig production in the
tropics, Nsukka, Nigeria, February, 1986.
140
Adebambo, O. A. (2003): Animal breeds: A nation’s heritage. Inaugural lecture, University of
Agriculture, Abeokuta. Pp. 20-40.
Adebambo, O.A. and Dettmer, A.E. (1979). Comparative performance of the indigenous and exotic
sows in Nigeria.1. Milk yield, persistency of production and utilization by litter. Nigerian
Journal of Animal Production., 6 (1 and 2): 26 - 32.
Adeola, A.C., 2009. Morphological and Genetic Characterization of Nigerian Indegenous pigs in
Southern-Western Nigeria. Unpublished M.Sc Thesis Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-ife.
Adeoye, A.O., Rotimi, E.A. and Njoku, C.P. (2012). Effect of Genotype and sex on the body weight
of progenies of pigs produced by ASF- recovered pigs. In:36th Annual Conference of Genetic
Society of Nigeria., Pp. 64-65.
Adeyinka, L.A. and Mohammed, I.D.(2006). Relationship of live weight and linear body
measurement in two breeds of goats of northern Nigeria. Journal of Animal and Veterinary
Advances, 5 (11): 891-893,
Afolayan, R.A., Adeyinka, I.A. and Lakpini, C.A.M. 2006. The estimation of live weight from body
measurements in Yankasa sheep. Czech J. Anim. Sci., 51: 343-348.
Atta, M. and El Khidir, O.A. (2004). Use of heart girth, wither height and scapuloischial length for
prediction of liweweight of Nilotic sheep. Small Rum. Res., 55: 233-237.
Cam, M.A., Olfaz, M. and Soydan, E. (2010). Possibilities of using morphometrics characteristics
as a tool for body weight prediction in Turkish hair goats (Kilkeci). Asian J. Anim. Vet. Adv., 5:
52-59.
Cankaya, S., Altop, A., Olfaz, M. and Erener, G. (2009). Canonical correlation analysis for
estimation of relationships between some traits measured at pre and post slaughtering periods
in Karayaka hoggets. Anadolu. J. Agric. Sci., 24: 61-66.
Duncan, D.B., (1955). Multiple range and multiple F-test. Biometrics, 11: 1-42
Ehiobu, N.G and Kyado, J.A. (2000). Performance characteristics of sows of large white,
hampshire, and their crosses. Book of proceedings, 25th annual NSAP conference. 19-23 March
2000, Umudike. Pp. 254-256.
Goe, M.R., J.R. Alldredge and D. Light, (2001). Use of heart girth to predict body weight of
working oxen in the Ethopian highlands. Levestock Prod. Sci., 69: 187-195.
Havey, W., (1988). Users guide for LSM LMW mixed model least squares and maximum Likehood
computer programme pp: 59.
Heinrichs, A.J., Erb, H.N., Rogers, G.W., Cooper, J.B. and Jones, C.M. (2007). Variability in
Holstein heifer heart-girth measurements and comparison of prediction equations for live
weight Preventive. Vet. Med., 78: 333-338.
Khan, H., Muhammad, F., Ahmad, R., Nawaz, G., Rahimullah and Zubair, M. (2006). Relationship
of body weight with linear body measurements in goats. J. Agric. Biol. Sci., 1: 51-54.
Koenen, E.P.C. and Groen, A.F. (1997). Genetic evaluation of body weight of lactating Holstein
heifers using body measurements and conformation traits. J. Dairy Sci., 81: 1709-1713.
Ncube, M.,Dzama, K., Chimonyo, M., Kanengoni, A and Hamudikuwanda, H. (2003). Effect of
boar genotype on reproductive performance of the local sows of Zimbabwe.
Livestock
Research for Rural Development, 15 (2).
Nsoso, B.S.J., Aganga, A.A., Moganetsi, B.P. and Tshwenyane, S.O. (2003). Birth weight, body
condition score and heart girth in indigenous Tswana goats during dry and wet season in
Southeast Botswenyane. Livestock Res. Rural Dev., Vol. 15.
Olfaz, M., Ocak, N., Erener, G., Cam, M.A. and Garipoglu, A.V. (2005). Growth, carcass and meat
characteristics of Karayaka growing rams fed sugar beet pulp, partially substituting for grass
hay as forage. Meat Sci., 70: 7-14.
Oke U.K, S.N. Ibe, F.I. Ologbose andK.U. Amaefula, (2006). Effect of Breed of Sire on Growth
Performance of Exotic Crossbred pigs in a Humid Tropical Environment .Anim. Vet. Adv., 5
(9): 744-748, 2006
141
Okendo, N.J., Aladi, N.O., Okoli and Akanno E.C. (2007).Comparative Study of the growth and
Carcass Characteristics of the Nigerian indigenous and Large White pigs. Asian Journal of
Animal Sciences, 1 (2): 57-66.
Oseni, S. (2005). Evaluation of the F1 and backcrosses of Nigerian local pigs and the Large White
for litter characteristics in Southwest Nigeria. Pigtrop.http://pigtrop.cirad.fr - Copyright CIRAD
2011.
Riva, J., R. Rizzi, S. Marelli and L.G. Cavalchini, (2004). Body measurement in Bergamasca sheep.
Small Ruminant Res., 55: 221-227.
SPSS, (1999). Headquarters, (Release 9.0.0) 233 S. SPSS Inc., Wacker Drive, 11th flor Chicago,
Illinois 60606, USA.
Salako, A.E., (2006). Application of morphological indices in the assessment of type and function
in sheep. Int. J. Morphol., 24: 13-18.
Sarti, F.M., L. Castelli, D. Bogani and Panella, F. (2003). The measurement of chest girth as an
alternative to weight determination in the performance recording of meat sheep. Ital. J. Anim.
Sci., 2: 123-129.
Tegbe, J.S. and S.A.S. Olorunju, (1988). The prediction of live weight of crossbred breed from
three body measurements. Nigerian J. Ani. Production, 15: 9-13.
Topal, M. and M. Macit, (2004). Prediction of body weight from body measurements in
Morkaraman sheep. J. Applied Anim. Res., 25: 97-100.
Wheeler, M. B. and D. R. Campion (1993). "Animal Production - a Longstanding Biotechnological
Success." American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 58(2): S276-S281.
AGB20
GROWTH PERFORMANCE
OREOCHROMIS NILOTICUS
OF
MONOSEX
AND
MIXED
Yisa, M. 1*, Osiki, S.2, Olufeagba, S.O.1, Adebayo, A.1 and Nwangwu, D.C.1
142
POPULATION
OF
1
Fish Biotechnology Improvement Laboratory, National Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research
(NIFFR), P.M.B. 6006, New Bussa, Niger State, Nigeria.
2
Federal College of Freshwater Fisheries Techonolgy, P.M.B. 1500, New Bussa, Niger State,
Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: mosrence@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Growth performance of hand-sexed: male mono-sex, female mono-sex and mixed-sex population of
tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) was conducted in six aquaria tanks (60cm×30cm×30cm). The
experimental tanks were stocked with 12 fingerlings per tank. Fish were cultured for 49days and fed
at a daily rate of 5% of their body weight, the results of the experiment showed that male mono-sex
tilapia showed significantly (P˂0.05) higher growth rate (weight, length, DWG, SGR) than female
and mixed sex group. Generally, male mono-sex fishes reached a larger final individual sizes
(24.33±0.2g) , and female mono-sex (18.66±0.6g) while (17.89±1.2g) for mixed population group.
The daily growth rate showed 0.23±0.2g for males, 0.1±0.01g for females and 0.09±0.02g for
mixed population tilapia, respectively. Based on this result, male mono-sex Oreochromis niloticus
grows faster than female mono-sex and mixed population.
Keywords: Monosex, Oreochromis niloticus, growth
INTRODUCTION
Tilapia have been successfully farmed under a wide range of environmental conditions and are
important group of cultured fish species in many parts of the world, particularly in developing
countries (El-sayad, 2006). Among the tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus was found to be suitable for
semi-intensive culture system because of its ability to utilize a wide range of feed stuff originating
from plants and animals (Liti et al., 2005). Oreochromis niloticus is an important tropical
freshwater fish because of its relative abundance due to their high fecundity, Oreochromis niloticus
can be recognized by the characteristic pattern of dark and light bands crossing the caudal fin. The
body is elongated and usually shows a number narrow bands on the back, it is one of the largest
tilapia; reaching the considerable length of 50cm. However, their breeding habit has undesirable
consequences. Some of the problems associated with the reproductive efficiency of Oreochromis
niloticus are prolific reproduction and stunted growth in pond culture system (Phelps and Popma,
2000). Within a few months of culture period, the ponds get packed with various sizes of fishes and
later, due to overpopulation the growth of the fish gets slower and the fish farmer virtually gets no
revenue.
There exist a number of methods to control reproduction in a mixed-sex population of Oreochromis
niloticus; one of these methods is the rearing of male mono-sex tilapia (Phelps and Popma, 2000).
There is significant sex specific difference in the growth of fish where males usually grow faster
and more uniform in size than females (Bwanika et al., 2007). This is mainly attributed to
reproduction which drains energy primarily for the production of eggs and offsprings (Eyualem and
Getachew, 1998; Tadesse, 1998). Notwithstanding, in a mouth brooder fish species like
Oreochromis niloticus, females fast during the early stages and probably throughout the brooding
period which causes inconsistent feeding and subsequently affects the body condition ( Tadesse,
1988; Demeke, 1994). Meanwhile, the culture of all male tilapia is well established for increased
production potential and low management requirements in semi-intensive culture system. Moreover
143
monosex culture of this species has been carried out by several authors to ascertain its advantage
over the usual practice of mixed sex culture of tilapia, which necessitates this study.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was carried out at the Fish Biotechnology Research Laboratory of the National
Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research (NIFFR), New-Bussa, Niger State, Nigeria.
Growth performance and survival rate of monosex ( males, females and mixed populations) of
Oreochromis niloticus were conducted for 49 days in aquaria tanks of 60cm×30cm×30cm. Seventy
two (72) Oreochromis niloticus fingerlings having average weight of (13.09±0.4) g were obtained.
Sexing was done manually by visual inspection of the external urogenital pores with the aid of
magnifying hand lens, after which twelve (12) fingerlings were randomly weighed using electronic
sensitive weighing balance OHAUS-LS-200g model, and was assigned to each of the experimental
tanks that was made of three treatments which were replicated using a Complete Randomized
Design (CRD).
The fish were fed twice daily with commercial feed (Coppens) 0.8mm-1.2mm at 5% body weight
from 6am-7am, and 7pm-8pm, in the morning and evening respectively for seven weeks. Each tank
was supplied with compressed air via rubber hose and air stones from air pump, siphoning of debris
from each aquaria was done daily, after which an equal volume of freshwater was added as
replacement. Sampling was carried out weekly to determine their growth rate. Dead fish were
removed and recorded as soon as observed indoor to evaluate the survival rate of the stocks.
Food conversion ratio was computed as follows:
FCR = Total feed given
Total weight gained
*Specific Growth Rate (SGR) as:
SGR = ( Inwf ̶ Inwi)
Time (days)
where: Wf = final weight (g), Wi = initial weight (g), In= natural logarithms, Time (days) =
duration of trial.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Data on the growth performance, feed conversion ratio, specific growth rate, daily growth rate and
survival rate of monosex (all males, all females) and mixed populations (male and female) of
Oreochromis niloticus are presented in Fig. 1 and 2. Significant variations were observed in growth
performance among male, female and mixed populations of Oreochromis niloticus reared under the
same conditions after 49 days (7weeks). The fish attained an average weight of 24.33±0.2g,
18.66±0.7g and 17.89±1.2g for male, female and mixed populations, respectively. The net weight
and daily weight growth per fish were 11.16 g and 0.23g/d for male, 5.12 g and 0.1g/d for female
and 4.58g and 0.09g/d for mixed population, respectively. The specific growth rate (SGR) per fish
for the male (0.6g) , 0.3g for the female and 0.3g for the mixed populations were recorded. The
survival rates for the fish were 83.33%, 83.33% and 79.17% for male, female and mixed
populations, respectively.
The mean value of water quality parameters of the experiment for dissolved oxygen 6.05mg/l, ph.
6.8, air temperature 26°c and water temperature 26.5°c, respectively. Based on the data obtained,
the water quality parameters; temperature, dissolved oxygen and pH. measured during the study
period were all within the optimum range for rearing tilapia (Boyd and Tucker, 1992; Xu et al.,
2005; Azaza et al., 2008).
144
Sampling Period (Weeks)
Figure 1: Growth curve of live body weight for monosex, and mixed population of
Oreochromis niloticus during the study period
145
Sampling period (Weeks)
Figure 2: Growth curve of live body length for monosex, and mixed population of Oreochromis
niloticus during the study period.
Although the growth performance of Oreochromis niloticus is highly influenced by genetics,
quality and quantity of food, stock management and environmental factors (El-sayad, 2006),
sex-specific differences in the growth of Oreochromis niloticus is apparent (Green et al.,
2007).
The results of the present study revealed that the growth performance between all male, all female
and mixed populations Oreochromis niloticus reared for 49days under the same conditions was
significantly difference (P˂0.05), where the male monosex attained a larger final individual size.
Several investigators have studied the sex-specific growth difference of Oreochromis niloticus
under semi-intensive culture system, for example, Chakraborty et al. (2011) documented the faster
growth of all male tilapia than females and mixed-sex, this might be attributed to sex-specific
growth ability, female mouth brooding behavior or the efficient feeding habits of males. In a mouth
brooding fish like Oreochromis niloticus females fast during the early stages and probably
throughout the brooding period which causes inconsistent feeding and subsequently affects the body
condition (Tadesse, 1988; Demeke, 1994). Pandian and Sheela (1999) and Green et al. (1997)
further reported similar result, where all male tilapia showed superior growth rate over the females
and mixed populations which are in agreement with the results of the present study.
They attributed this to the fact that energy is not utilized for reproduction and there exist no
competition with younger fish in all male tilapia culture.
CONCLUSION
The result of the present study revealed that the growth performance between male, female and
mixed population of Oreochromis niloticus reared under the same condition was significantly
different, where the male monosex fish grow faster and attained a larger size than the female
monosex and mixed populations. Therefore culturing of male monosex Oreochromis niloticus is
recommended to fish farmers for increased income.
REFERENCES
146
Azaza, M.S., Dhraief, M.N, and Kraiem, M.M. (2008). Effects of water temperature on the growth
and sex ration of juvenile Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) reared in geothermal waters in
south Tunisia. Journal of Thermal Biology, 33(2): 98-105.
Boyd, C.E. and Tucker, C.S. (1992). Water quality in ponds for aquaculture experiment station,
Auburn University, Alabama.U.S.A.
Bwanika, G.N., Murie, D.J. and Chapman, L.J. (2007). Comparative age and growth of Nile tilapia
(Oreochromis niloticus) in lakes Nabugabo and Wamala, Uganda, Hydrobilogia, 589(1):
287-301.
Chakraborty, S.E., Mazumdar, D. Chatterj, U. and Banerjee, S. (2001). Growth of Mixed sex and
monosex Nile tilapia in different culture systems. Turk. J. Fish. Aqua. Sci., 11: 131-138.
EL-Sayad, A.F .M. (2006). Tilapia culture, CABI Publishing, Wallingford Oxford Shine,UK. Pp.145.
Eyualan, A. and Getachew, T. (1992). Seasonal changes in the nutritional Status of Oreochromis
niloticus L (Pisces; cichlidae) in Lake Ziwag, Ethiopia. Arch. Hydrobiol., 124 (1): 109-122.
Green, B.N.W., Veverica, K.L. and Fitzpatrick, M.S. (1997). Fry and fingerlings Production, CRC
press, Boca, Ration, Florida. Pp. 215-430.
Jamu, D. (2001). Tilapia in Africa; Opportunities and challenges in suban singhes and Tarlocha
Tilapia production, marketing and technological develop Ment. International Technical and
Trade conference on Tilapia, 28 -36 May, 2001, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, Pp. 102 – 112.
Liti, D., Cherop L., Mungitti, J. and Chnom, L. (2005). Growth and economic
Performance of
Nile tilapia (Orechromis niloticus) fed on two formulated Diets and two locally available
feeds in fertilized ponds. Aquac. Res., 36(8): 746 – 752.
Pandian, T. J. and Sheela, S.G. (1995). Hormonal induction of sex reversal of tilapia. The
World
Aquaculture, 138: 1 – 22.
Phelps, R.P. and Popma, T.J. (2000). Sex reversal of tilapia. The World Aquaculture
Society,
Baton Rouge, Louisiana, USA, 2; 34 – 59.
Tadesse, Z. (1988). Studies on some aspects of the biology of Oreochromis niloticus L. (Pisces;
Cichlidae) in Lake Ziwag, Ethiopia. Msc Thesis, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa. Pp.
78.
Xu, J.Y., Miao, X.W., Lu Y. and Cui, S.R. (2005). Behavioural response of tilapia
(Orechromis
niloticus) to acute ammonia stress monitored by Computer vision, J. Zheijiang Univ. Sci.,
B., 6 (8): 812 – 816.
AGB21
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BODY WEIGHT AND LINEAR BODY MEASUREMENTS
IN JAPANESE QUAIL (COTURNIX COTURNIX JAPONICA)
Ojo, V.*, Fayeye, T.R., Ayorinde, K.L. and Olojede, H.
Animal Genetics and Breeding Unit, Department of Animal Production, University of Ilorin, Ilorin,
Nigeria.
147
*Corresponding e-mail: ojo_victoria@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
A total of 108 Japanese quail chicks (55 males and 53 females) were used to study the relationship
between body weight and linear measurements at 2, 4, 6, and 8 weeks of age and to predict body
weight (BW) from early linear measurements of body length (BL), body girth (BG), wing length
(WL), shank length (SL), shank diameter (SD) and drum stick (DS). Mean chicks’ body weight at
2nd, 4th, 6th and 8th week of age were 35.23g, 93.67g, 138.95g and 143.78g, respectively. Weekly
body weight gain was rapid between 2 and 6 weeks of age and thereafter decreased with age.
Female chicks were significantly (P< 0.05) heavier than their male counterparts at 6th and 8th weeks
of age. Correlations between BW and body measurements was significantly positive (P<0.01) at
2nd, 4th and 8th week of age. The best correlation was obtained between BW and BG at the 2nd week
of age (0.70). Estimates of Coefficient of Determination (R2) showed that the best two single
predictors of body weight of birds at 2 weeks of age were BG and BL. A combination of all body
measurements however enhanced the efficiency of prediction of BW at 2nd and 4th week of age. The
predictive equation showed that BW in Japanese quail is linearly related to body measurements
especially with BG and BL. Prediction of BW from these measurements is therefore possible as
early as 2 weeks of rearing. It is also possible for the breeder to use these easily measured parts as
criteria for assessment and early selection for BW.
Key words: Body weight, linear measurements, correlation and Japanese quail.
INTRODUCTION
Japanese quail is the smallest farmed avian specie for egg and meat (Minvielle, 1998) and it is
becoming increasingly important in the Nigerian poultry industry (Musa et al., 2008). Apart from
its conventional use as a laboratory animal (Odunsi et al. 2007 and Minviellie, 2010), Japanese
quail has the potential to serve as an excellent and cheap source of protein (Raji et al., 2008). The
high prolificacy and hardy nature of the bird (Robins, 1981; Annon, 1991) as well as the recent
discovery of the health benefits of its egg, have made rearing of Japanese quail suitable for the
resource poor tropical countries.
Body weight, body conformation and yield have been reported as important traits to poultry
breeders and processors (Adeniji and Ayorinde, 1990). Body weight plays an important role in
determining several other economic characteristics of the farm animals (Pesmen and Yardimci,
2008). It is an important attribute of farm animals as it forms the basis for assessing growth, feed
efficiency and also in making economic decisions (Momoh and Kershima, 2008). It is also
important in determining the market prices of animals especially in an organized market (Momoh
and Kershima, 2008). Maciejowski and Zeiba (1982) reported positive correlation between body
weight and a number of linear body measurements. These include shank length and diameter which
are regarded as indicators of leg development, body girth and length which are indicators of breast
development. Indirect method of estimating body weight using body measurements has been
reported to be practical, faster, easier, and cheaper approach, especially in the rural areas where the
resources are insufficient and the acquisition of expensive sensitive weighing scale is unaffordable
(Semakula et al., 2011). Estimates of the relationship between body weight and linear
measurements is not only important in developing predictive equations, it could also be employed
in genetic improvement strategies to achieve an optimum combination of body weight and good
conformation (Chineke et al. 2002).
148
This study therefore examined the relationship between body weight and linear body measurements
in the Japanese quail and also developed regression equations for predicting body weight from
linear measurements at different ages.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was conducted at the Poultry Unit of the Department of Animal Production, Faculty
of Agriculture, University of Ilorin, Nigeria. All experiments were implemented in accordance with
Institutional guidelines on the care and use of animals for scientific studies, and in compliance with
generally accepted rules of best practice worldwide.
A total of one hundred and eight (108) day old Japanese quail of mixed sex (55 males and 53
females) were obtained from a random-bred population that has been maintained in the department
for three generations (Ojo et al. 2011). These birds were initially developed at the National
Veterinary Research Institute (NVRI) station, Vom (Jos, Nigeria) from fertile eggs obtained from
the Republic of Benin in 1992. Day-old birds were tagged on their wings and kept in brooding pen.
Feed and water were supplied ad- libitum throughout the eight (8) weeks period of the experiment.
Standard prophylactic procedures were also followed.
Body Weight (BW): Body Weight in gram (g) was recorded to two decimal places using a sensitive
weighing scale (Scout II brand).
Body Length (BL): Body Length was taken in centimetre (cm) with a measuring tape stretched
from bird’s nasal opening, along its gently stretched neck and back, to the tip of its pygostyle.
Body Girth (BG): Body Girth was taken in centimetre (cm) when a measuring tape was looped
round the region of the breast under the Wing.
Wing Length (WL): Wing Length was measured in centimetre (cm) as the distance from the
humerus-coracoid junction to the distal tip of the phalange digits, using a measuring tape.
Shank Length (SL): The Shank Length was taken as the distance in centimetres (cm) between the
foot pad and the hock joint, measured by a set of Venier calipers.
Shank Diameter (SD): Shank Diameter was taken as the width of the shank in centimetres (cm),
measured by the use of a Venier calipers.
Drum Stick (DS): Drum stick was taken as the distance from the tip of hock to the ball joint of
femur, measured in centimetres (cm) by the use of a measuring tape.
Data were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) for a Completely Randomized Design (Steel
and Torrie, 1980) using SPSS (version 13). Significantly different means (P<0.05) were further
separated by the use of Duncan’s Multiple Range procedure option in SPSS 13 (SPSS IBM).
Correlation, linear and multiple regression analysis between BW and the various body size
parameters were also determined. The coefficient of determination (R2) for each parameter in the
regression equations was determined to show the relative contribution of each body measurement to
the BW of Japanese quail at different ages. The following linear regression equation was used to
predict BW from linear measurements.
Y = a + bx
Where Y = body weight or dependent variable, a = constant in the regression equation, b =
regression coefficient and, x = various body measurements
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 1 shows the means (±SEM) and the coefficients of variation of BW and linear measurements
taken on the Japanese quails at different ages. The data indicated a progressive increase in BW and
linear measurements over the eight weeks period. Mean BW increased from 35.23g at 2 weeks of
age to 143.78g at 8 weeks of age. The highest increase in BW occurred between two and four weeks
of age (58.44g). BL increased from 11.84cm at week two to 19.45cm at week eight. BG increased
149
from 8.02cm at week 2 to 13.67cm at week 8. SL, SD and DS increased from 2.31cm to 2.96cm,
0.32 to 0.44cm, and 3.04 to 5.16cm between weeks two and eight, respectively. This result agrees
with the reports of Sonaiya et al. (1986) and Ojedapo et al. (2012) who reported that age is a major
determinant of growth and physiological development. The estimates of coefficient of variation in
this study suggest that there was an increased uniformity in body size measurements as the birds
advanced in age.
There was no significant effect (P>0.05) of sex on most body measurements except for SD and BG
(Table 2). Female chicks had significantly higher (P<0.05) SD at the 2nd (0.33cm) and 4th (0.41cm)
weeks of age and a higher BG at the 6th week. Sex effect on BW was not significant (P>0.05) at the
2nd and 4th weeks of age, although female quails were nominally better in mean BW at these ages.
However, Females were significantly higher (P<0.05) than the males in BW at 6th (150.71g vs
127.62g) and 8th (157.98g vs 130.10g) weeks of age. The BW and linear measurements obtained in
this study are lower than values reported by other authors (Almeida et al., 2002; Reddish et al.
2003; Sezer et al., 2006 and Tulobaev et al. 2011). Ojo et al. (2012) had suggested that differences
in genetic sublineage and rearing environmental conditions may account for such differences.
Coefficient of variation for body measurements was higher in males than in females but decreased
with successive rearing age. This pattern suggests that there was an increasing uniformity in BW
and linear measurements of both sexes with age. Sexual dimorphism has previously been reported
in favour of the male in duck (Raji et al., 2009), pigeon (Hassan and Adamu, 1997), chicken
(Momoh and Kershima, 2008), guinea fowl (Ogah, 2006) and pheasants (Kuzniacka and Adamski,
2010). The growth pattern of male and female Japanese quails have been well documented
(Balcioglu et al., 2005; Sezer and Tarhan, 2005). The result of the present study agrees with the
pattern reported by Hort et al. (1999) and Sezer et al. (2006). Sezer et al. (2006) reported that there
were no sex differences in hatchling weight and that the degree of sexual dimorphism was low until
after 4 weeks of age.
Table 3 shows the correlation between BW and body measurements in Japanese quail. BW was
positive and significantly (P<0.01) correlated with all body measurements at 2nd and 4th weeks of
age except for WL (0.35) at week four. BG had the highest correlated value with BW at 2nd (0.70)
and 4th (0.68) weeks. At weeks six and eight, correlation coefficient had reduced for all body
measurement except for BG. Estimates obtained for WL, SL and diameter and DS at weeks six and
eight were between -0.01and 0.27.
These results are in agreement with earlier reports on correlation between BW and linear
measurements in poultry species. For instance, Ibe and Nwakalor (1987) reported high and positive
correlation between linear measurements and BW in the Nigerian local chicken. Adeniji and
Ayorinde (1990) also reported a linear relationship between BW and body measurements in broiler
chicken while Hassan and Adamu (1997) obtained a similar result in pigeon. Raji et al. (2009)
reported a positive and highly significant correlation between BW and zoometric body
measurements in local Muscovy ducks. These authors noted that chest girth had the strongest
correlation with BW followed by BL. Raji et al. (2009) opined that the higher association between
BW and CG was due to relatively large contribution to BW by chest girth which consists of bones,
muscles and viscera. The present study indicates that DS and WL are less strong compared with SL
and BG as indicators of BW in the Japanese quail. Maciejowski and Zeiba (1982) observed that SL
and SD were good indicators of leg development. The present result on correlation between BW
and WL contradicts the earlier report of Teguia et al. (2008) who reported highest correlation
between BW and WL in Muscovy duck.
Tables 4 and 5 show the linear and multiple regression equations and coefficient of determination
(R2) for predicting BW at different ages in the Japanese quail. Live BW had a significant (P<0.05)
simple linear relationship with all body measurement at all ages except with WL and the SD at
sixth week of age. R2 was highest for BG at 2nd (0.49) and 4th (0.46) weeks and lowest for DS (0.08)
at the 2nd and WL (0.12) at the 4th weeks. R2 values reduced as the birds advanced in age. The R2
values suggest that BG contributed 49 and 46%, BL contributed 44 and 20% to BW at 2nd and 4th
150
weeks, respectively. Conversely, WL contributed as little as 0.13 and 0.12% to BW at 2nd and 4th
week. This result supports the findings of Raji et al. (2009) in Muscovy duck where highest R2value
(0.728) was obtained when chest girth was used singly, followed by BL (0.704) and WL (0.704),
respectively. These authors explained that the high association of BW and chest girth was due to the
relatively large contribution of chest girth (which consists of bones, muscles and viscera) to BW. R2
value increased when all body measurements were combined in a multiple regression with the BW.
R2 value was 0.677, 0.572, 0.376 and 0.414 at 2nd, 4th, 6th and 8th week, respectively. This supports
the result of Momoh and Kershima (2008) who also reported an increase in coefficient of
determination when body measurements were combined in a multiple regression in the local
chicken. Raji et al. (2009) also reported similar findings in the Muscovy duck especially when chest
girth, body length and chest width were combined in a multiple regression equation.
CONCLUSION
This study shows that BW in Japanese quail is linearly related to body measurements, especially
with BG and BL. Prediction of BW from these measurements is therefore possible as early as 2
weeks of rearing. It is also possible for the breeder to use these easily measured parts as criteria for
assessment and selection for BW at this early age. Thus a breeding programme to achieve an
optimum combination of BW and good conformation for maximum economic returns in the
Japanese quail can be easily organized.
REFERENCES
Adeniji, F. O. and Ayorinde, K. L. (1990). Prediction of body weight from body measurements of
chickens. Nig. J. Anim. Prod., 17: 42-47.
Almeida, M.I.M., E.G. Oliviera, P.R. Ramos, N. Viega and Dias, K. (2002). Growth performance
of meat male quails (Coturnix sp) of two lines under two nutritional Environments.
Archiv. Vet. Sci., 7 (2):103-108.
Annon, J. (1991). Little known animal with promising economic future (micro livestock), Board of
Science and Technology for International Development , National Academic Press,
Washington DC: 147 –155.
Balcıoglu, M. S., Kızılkaya, K., Yolcu, H.I. and Karabağ, K. (2005). Analysis of Growth
Characteristics in Short-term Divergently Selected Japanese quail. S. Afr. J. Anim. Sci., 35,
83-89.
Chineke, C.A., Agaviezor, B., Ikeobi, C.O.N. and Ologun, A. G. (2002). Some factors affecting
body weight and measurements of rabbit at pre and post weaning ages. Proc. 27th Annual
Conf. Nig. Soc. Anim., Prod.:1-3.
Hassan, W. A., and Adamu, U. A. (1997). Pigeon genetic resources in semi-arid zone of Nigeria:
Initial results from characterization studies. Paper submitted at INFPD Workshop and
General Meeting 9-13 December, 1997, M’Bour Senegal.
Hort, J., Hyankova, L. and Knizetova, H. (1999). The Role of Sexual Dimorphism in the Onset of
Egg-laying in Japanese quail. Proc. Poult. Gen. Symp., 6 - 8 October 1999,
Mariencee/Germany.Pp. 120.
Ibe, S. N. and Nwakalor, C. N. (1987). Growth Pattern Performance in Broilers. Influence of
genotype and management on isometry of growth. Poultry Science, 66: 1274-1284.
Kuzniaka, J. and Adamski, M. (2010). Growth rate of body weight and measurements in pheasants
reared up to the 24th week of life. Archiv Tierzucht, 53 (3): 360-367.
Maciejowski, J. and Zeiba, T. (1982). Genetic and Animal breeding. Part B. Stock improvement
Methods. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam.
Minvielle, F. (1998). Genetic and breeding of Japanese quail for production around the world.
Proceedings 6th Asian Pacific poultry congress Nagoya, Japan.
151
Momoh, O. M. and Kershima, D. E. (2008). Linear body measurement as predictors of body weight
in Nigerian Local chickens. Asset Series A, 8 (2): 206-212.
Odunsi, A. A., Rotimi, A. and Amao, E. A. (2007). Effect of Different Vegetable Protein Sources
on Growth and Laying Performance of Japanese Quails (Coturnix coturnix japanica) in a
Derived Savanna Zone of Nigeria. World Applied Sci. Journal, 3 (5): 567-577.
Ogah, D.M. (2012). In vivo prediction of live weight and carcass traits using body Measurements in
indigenous guinea fowl. Biotechnology in Animal Husbandry, 28 (1): 137-146.
Ojedapo, L. O., Amao, S.R., Ameen, S.A., Adedeji, T.A., Ogundipe, R.I. and Ige, A.O. (2012).
Prediction of body weight and other linear body measurement of two commercial layer
strain chickens. Asian Journal of Anim. Sci., 6 (1):13-22.
Ojo, V., Ayorinde, K.L., Bolu, S.A.O. and Alli, O.I. (2011). Response to divergent selection for 35day body weight and realized heritabilities over two generations in Japanese quails.
Agrosearch, 11 (1&2):63-68.
Pesmen, G. and Yardimci, M. (2008). Estimating the live weight using some body measurement in
Saanen goats. Archiva Zootechnica, 11:4, 30-40.
Raji, A.O., Abdulkarim, A.J., Mohamed, B., Yunus, S.A., Ezuma, A.N. and Nkoloagu, P.U. (2008).
Regression equation for the estimation of breast and thigh weights from live body
measurements of Japanese quail (Coturnix coturnix japanica) Proc. 13th ASAN conf. Pp. 4042.
Raji, A. O., Igwebuike, J.U. and Usman, M. T. (2009). Zoometrical body measurements and their
relation with live weight in matured local Muscovy ducks in Borno State, Nigeria. ARPN J.
Agric. and Biol. Sci., 4 (3): 58-62.
Reddish, J.M., Nestor, K.E. and Lilburn, M.S. (2003). Effect of selection for growth on on-set of
sexual maturity in random bred and growth-selected lines of Japanese quail. Poult. Sci., 82:
187-191.
Robins, G.E.S. (1981). Quail, their breeding and management. World Pheasant Association (WPA)
. P1,9,10.
Sezer, M. and Tarhan, S. (2005). Model parameters of growth curves of three meat-type lines of
Japanese quail. Czech. J. Anim. Sci., 50, 22-30.
Sezer, M., Berberoglu, E. and Ulutas, Z. (2006). Genetic Association between Sexual Maturity and
Weekly Live-weights in Laying-type Japanese quail. South African Journal of Animal Sci.,
36 (2):142-148.
Semakula J., Lusembo, P., Kugonza, D.R., Mutetikka, D., Ssennyonjo, J. and Mwesigwa, M.
(2011). Estimation of live body weight using zoometrical measurements for improved
marketing of indigenous chicken in the Lake Victoria basin of Uganda. Livestock Research
for
Rural
Development.
Volume
23,
Article
#170.
http://www.lrrd.org/
lrrd23/8/sema23170.htm.
Sonaiya, E.B., Williams, A.R. and Oni, S.A. (1986). A biological and economical appraisal of
broiler production up to 16 weeks. J. Anim. Prod. Res., 691: 73-79.
Steel, R.G.D. and Torrie, J.H.(1980). Principles and procedures of statistics. Mcgrow-Hill book Co.
Inc. New York.
Teguia, A., MafouoNgandjou, H., Defang, H. and Tchoumboue, J. (2008). Study of the live weight
and body characteristics of the African Muscovy duck (Cairina moschata). Tropical Animal
Health and Production. Abstract.
Tulobaev, A., Alpak, H., Bektemirova, D. and Turdubaeva, A. (2012). Morphometric development
and changes in the growth and development dynamics of Japanese quail populations bred in
Kyrgystan. Turk. J. Vet. Anim. Sci., 36 (4): 357-361.
152
Table 1. Means of Body Weight and Linear Measurements at Different Ages in the Japanese quail
(sexes
combined)
2ndweek
4thweek
6thweek
8thweek
Traits
Means±S.E C.O.V Means±S.E C.O.V Means±S.E C.O.V Means±S.E C.O.V
BW(g)
35.23±0.61 17.85 93.67±1.18 13.09 138.95±1.81 13.54
143.78±1.82 13.14
BL (cm) 11.84±0.08 7.26
17.40±0.07 4.43
19.24±0.13 6.86
19.45±0.07 3.95
BG (cm) 8.20±0.07 9.27
11.92±0.08 6.96
13.70±0.06 4.82
13.67±0.06 4.75
WLcm) 5.95±0.08 13.45 8.79±0.05 6.26
8.70±0.05
6.44
8.90±0.46
5.43
SL(cm) 2.31±0.03 12.55 2.95±0.02 7.46
2.99±0.01
5.02
2.96±0.01
5.07
SD (cm) 0.32±0.004 12.50 0.41±0.002 4.88
0.43±0.003 6.98
0.44±0.003 6.82
DS (cm) 3.04±0.03 10.20 4.78±0.05 9.83
5.15±0.02
4.47
5.16±0.02
4.65
BW- body weight; BL- body length; BG-body girth; WL-wing length; SL-shank length; SD- shank
diameter; DS-drum stick. S.E- Standard error of mean; C.O.V- Coefficient of variation.
Trait
s
BW(
g)
BL(
cm)
BG(
cm)
WL(
cm)
SL(c
m)
SD(
cm)
DS(
cm)
Table 2. Effect of Sex on Body Weight and some linear measurements in the Japanese quail
2 weeks
4 weeks
6 weeks
8 weeks
Mal
Fem
Mal
Fem
Mal
Fem
Mal
Femal
e
ale
e
ale
e
ale
e
e
Mea CO Mea C. Mea CO Mea CO Mea CO Mea CO Mea CO Mean CO
n
V
n
OV n
V
n
V
n
V
n
V
n
V
V
34.5 19. 35.9 16. 92.2 13. 95.1 12. 127. 11. 150. 9.9 130. 9.2 157.9 8.54
1
12 8
48 2
27 7
84 62b
64 71a
2
10b
1
8a
11.7 7.2 11.9 7.3 17.3 4.7 17.5 3.9 19.2 4.0 19.2 8.8 19.3 4.0 19.55 3.84
8
2
0
9
2
9
1
3
0
6
7
7
5
3
8.09 8.6 8.31 9.0 11.8 6.9 12.0 6.8 13.4 4.4 13.9 4.3 13.4 4.9 13.90 3.81
6
3
0
5
4
9
2b
0
9a
6
5
1
5.83 16. 6.08 8.5 8.73 6.4 8.86 6.0 8.66 6.2 8.74 6.7 8.86 6.2 8.94
4.59
98
5
1
9
4
5
1
2.31 10. 2.32 15. 2.95 7.4 2.96 7.0 3.00 5.3 3.00 5.3 2.95 5.7 2.96
4.73
39
52
6
9
3
3
6
0.31 11. 0.33a 12. 0.40 5.0 0.41a 4.8 0.43 6.9 0.44 6.8 0.43 6.9 0.44
6.82
b
29
12 b
8
8
2
8
3.02 10. 3.06 10. 4.67 10. 4.78 9.6 5.15 3.8 5.16 4.8 5.13 4.4 5.20
4.62
23
13
06
2
8
4
8
a,b
Means in the same column having different superscript within the same week differs significantly
(P<0.05).COV-coefficient of variation. BW- body weight; BL- body length; BG-body girth; WLwing length; SL-shank length; SD- shank diameter; DS-drum stick
Table 3. Correlations between Body Weight and Body Measurements in the Japanese quail at
Different ages.
Body weight / Age
Traits
2 weeks
4 weeks
6 weeks
8 weeks
Body length
0.66**
0.45**
0.26**
0.39**
Body girth
0.70**
0.68**
0.57**
0.61**
Wing length
0.38**
0.35
0.12
0.25**
153
Shank length
0.45**
0.47**
Shank diameter
0.48**
0.36**
Drum stick
0.28**
0.42**
*, **significant at P<0.05 and P<0.01, respectively
0.25*
-0.01
0.20*
0.27**
0.19**
0.25**
Table 4. Linear Regression Equation for predicting Body Weight at Different Ages in the
Japanese quail
Age
Intercept (a)
Regression
Coefficient of Significance
Coefficient
Determination
(b)
(R2)
Body Length 2
-21.73
4.81
0.44
S
4
-31.44
7.18
0.20
S
6
68.42
3.67
0.07
S
8
-44.14
9.68
0.15
S
Body Girth
2
4
6
8
-11.84
-26.07
-81.96
-97.50
5.73
10.05
16.12
17.67
0.49
0.46
0.32
0.37
S
S
S
S
WingLength
2
4
6
8
18.10
24.96
103.88
52.64
2.88
7.82
4.03
10.30
0.13
0.12
0.01
0.06
S
S
NS
S
Shank Length
2
4
6
8
13.37
14.74
49.76
50.40
9.46
26.74
29.67
31.71
0.20
0.22
0.06
0.07
S
S
S
S
Shank Diam.
2
4
6
8
11.47
18.45
142.22
88.72
75.0
185.01
-7.53
127.03
0.23
0.13
0.00
0.04
S
S
NS
S
5.74
11.02
16.38
19.75
0.08
0.18
0.04
0.06
S
S
S
S
Drum Stick
2
17.76
4
41.62
6
54.53
8
42.21
S- significant, NS-Not significant.
154
Table 5. Multiple Regression Equations for estimating bodyweight at Different ages in the
Japanese quail.
Age
Predicting Equations
R2
Significance
(weeks)
2
Y= -38.02+2.31(BL)+3.51(BG)+0.85(WL)+5.15(SL)
0.677 **
+11.54(SD)+(-1.12)DS
SE
of
Estimate
3.68
4
Y= -106.20+2.49(BL)+7.35(BG)+1.81(WL)+9.49(SL)
+39.83(SD)+1.88(DS)
0.572
**
8.25
6
Y= -179.78+0.98(BL)+15.08(BG)+1.65(WL)+25.08(SL)
+1.04(SD)+0.63(DS)
0.376
**
15.30
8
Y= -171.18+1.89(BL)+16.78(BG)+6.45(WL)+14.68(SL)
+(-80.63)(SD)+(-3.14)(DS)
0.414
**
14.89
AGB22
GENETIC PARAMETERS OF WEEKLY BODYWEIGHT IN JAPANESE QUAIL
Daikwo, S.I.1*, Dim, N.I.2 and Momoh, O.M.2
1
*Department of Animal Production and Health, Federal University, Wukari,
Taraba State, Nigeria.
2
Department of Animal Breeding and Physiology, Federal University of Agriculture Makurdi,
Benue State. Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: daikwo2@yahoo.co.uk
ABSTRACT
The Harvey Mixed Model Least-squares and Maximum Likelihood Computer Programme was used
to estimate the heritability, genetic and phenotypic correlations of live body weight of 684 Japanese
quails. The results revealed that Japanese quails are sexually dimorphic for live body weight at all
ages. Heritability of live body weight ranged from 0.12±0.02 to 0.91±0.11. All genetic correlations
between live body weights were positive. Phenotypic correlations between live body weights at all
ages were positive and very high (P<0.001). It was concluded that selection for live body weight
within the first two weeks of age may lead to improvement of body weight at later stages of life.
Keywords: Body weight, heritability, genetic correlation, Japanese quail.
INTRODUCTION
155
Quail breeding offers excellent opportunity for diversification and early marketing age, hence
increasing activity in the production of Japanese quail in developing countries. Despite the small
body size of Japanese quail, its meat and eggs are widely consumed and therefore ameliorates the
problem of animal protein shortage.
The Japanese quail is a sexually dimorphic bird with females having a larger body size than males,
unlike other poultry species. Sexual dimorphism is believed to evolve under the pressure of natural
and sexual selection, which implies that genes controlling sexually dimorphic characteristics differ
between males and females (Mignon-Grasteau et al., 2004). Growth is the most important trait for
evaluating different livestock species, especially in meat producing animals and birds. Growth traits
such as bodyweight and bodyweight gain are affected by genetic and non-genetic factors and the
phenomenon of growth is usually measured by observing differences in bodyweight recorded at
different ages and/or bodyweight gain obtained during different growth periods (Chambers, 1993).
Growth traits in the Japanese quail have been estimated by several researchers (Marks, 1993, ELFull et al., 2001, Almeida et al., 2002, Abdel-Fattah, 2006). The genetic parameter estimates cited
in literatures for growth traits would be expected to differ in diverse genotypes and under different
environments.
Therefore the objective of this study was to estimate the genetic parameters of body weight in
Japanese quail in a tropical environment like Nigerian as a step towards genetic improvement.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted at the Poultry Unit of the Teaching and Research Farm of the Faculty of
Agriculture, Kogi State University, Anyigba Nigeria. Anyigba lies between longitudes 50 151 and 70
451 North and latitude 50 451 and 80 451 East with mean annual rainfall of 1,808mm. The Natural
day length of Anyigba is 12-13hrs with average monthly temperature that varies from 170c – 36.20c.
The relative humidity varies from an average of 65-85% throughout the year (Amhakian, 2009).
The foundation stock from which the birds used for the study were hatched consisted of 90 females
and 30 males maintained in the farm as separate non-pedigreed, unselected and unimproved
population. A mating ratio of 1(male) : 3 (females) generated 684 day old chicks in three hatches.
At hatching, the chicks were leg banded with small plastic bands to indicate individual and sire
identities. The chicks were brooded on a floor pen with wood shavings as litter materials. Brooding
temperature started with 37.50C for the first week after which the temperature was reduced by 2-30C
weekly until the end of 3 weeks of age when the birds were transferred to the rearing pens. In the
rearing pens, birds were managed on deep litter from the 4th week to 8 weeks of ages using standard
management procedures. Chicks were fed diet containing 24% crude protein and 2741/kcal/kg of
feed from hatch to 5 weeks of age, thereafter the birds were fed diet containing 18% crude protein
and 2707 kcal/kg of feed as recommended by Dafwang (2006). Both feed and water were provided
ad libitum.
Live bodyweight at hatch (0 week), 1-week, 2-weeks, 3-weeks, 4-weeks, 5-weeks, 6-weeks, and 7weeks of age were individually recorded to the nearest gram for all the quails using a sensitive
digital electronic weighing scale. Degree of sexual dimorphism in live weight was calculated using
the formula as applied by Sezer et al. (2006).
Degree of sexual dimorphism (DSD) =
Fwt - Mwt
x
100
FWt
1
where, FWt = the mean female live weight at time t
MWt = the mean male live weight at time t
Data obtained on bodyweight were analysed using the Generalized Linear Model (GLM) procedure
of SPSS 14.0 (2004). The model employed was:
156
Yijk = µ + S¿ + Bj + (SB)ij + e¿jk
where,
Yijk = Individual quail’s bodyweight,
µ = the population mean, S¿ = effect of sex (i = 1, 2), Bj = effect of the jth hatch (j = 1,..3),
(SB)ij = interaction effects of sex and hatch, eijk = residual random error.
The data were further subjected to genetic analysis using the mixed model least – squares and
maximum likelihood computer programme of Harvey (1990). The reduced sire model (Becker,
1992) was used to fit the data.
Yij = µ + a¿ + eij
where,
Yij = Observation on the jth progeny of the ¿th sire
µ = Population mean, a¿ = Random effect of the ¿th sire (¿ = 1,….30)
eij = Residual random error.
The Harvey programme computes estimates of genetic and phenotypic correlation as well as
heritability estimates of traits from sire variance components.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 1 presents the least-square means of weekly body weight and degree or sexual dimorphism in
Japanese quail. Regardless of sex, the mean bodyweights remarkably increased as the quails
progressed in age. The female chicks were significantly (P<0.05) heavier in body weight than the
males. The degree of sexual dimorphism estimates were 3.23, 3.73, 5.26, 3.58, 3.93, 5.54, 10.78 and
11.48% at 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 weeks of age. Degree of sexual dimorphism tend to increase with
increase in age.
The bodyweight at hatch obtained in this study is in agreement with Abdel-Fattah (2006) and
Abdel-Tawab (2006) who reported values that ranged between 6.0 and 9.3g. Bodyweight at 1, 2, 3,
4, 5, 6 and 7 weeks of age were lower than those reported by El-Full et al. (2001), Abdel-Fattah
(2006) and Abdel-Tawab (2006). The observed differences between the various estimates reported
at particular ages could be due to the differences in climate and managerial conditions under which
different flocks were reared and to the possible differences in genetic make-up of the different
flocks or to the differences in the statistical manipulation of the data obtained used to obtain the
estimates. Female quails were significantly (P<0.05) heavier than the males from 0 (hatch) week of
age up to 7 weeks of age. This observation is similar to those of Soltan et al. (1987), Oguz et al.
(1996) and Abdel-Fattah (2006). The degree of sexual dimorphism (DSD) reported in this study
follow the same trend with results presented by Hort et al. (1999) and Sezer et al. (2006). The
occurrence of sexual dimorphism in the Japanese quail indicates potentials for their possible
development as sire and dam lines in breed development.
Heritability from sire variance component, genetic correlation and phenotypic correlation among
bodyweights at different ages in Japanese quail are presented in Table 2. Heritability estimates
ranged from 0.12±0.02 at 6 weeks of age to 0.91±0.11 at 0 week (hatch) of age. All genetic
correlation estimates between bodyweights at different ages were positive. The genetic correlation
estimates of body weight ranged from 0.18 to 1.17. These were cases when genetic correlation
estimates were outside parametric range (1.01, 1.05 and 1.17, respectively). Generally, phenotypic
correlation between bodyweights at all ages were positive and very highly significant (P<0.001).
The heritability of body weight at hatch is in close agreement with the value reported by El-Fiky
(1991). The heritability estimate of 4-week body weight in this study generally fall within the range
of 0.17-0.60 reported by Bahie El-Deen (1994) for Japanese quail. Heritability tends to reduce with
age. This similar observation was earlier reported by Saatei et al. (2002) for Japanese quail. The
moderate to high heritabilities reported indicate that response to selection at 7, 4, 3, 2, 1 and 0
157
weeks of age could be rapid while the low heritabilities implies that response to selection at the 5th
and 6th week of age could be slow.
The genetic and phenotypic correlation estimates between body weights at different ages were
similar in magnitude and direction. Similar trends were reported by Sharaf (1992), Farahat (1998)
and Shalan (1998). Genetic correlations greater than 1 obtained between bodyweights at some ages
in this study were outside parametric range. El-Full et al. (2001) who used 3, 150 birds also
estimated genetic correlations among some growth traits with values greater than 1, in Japanese
quail in Egypt. Problems associated with small group data size, sampling errors and data imbalance
(unequal group sizes) could indicate very high genetic correlations between traits involved, which
sometimes can be outside the parametric range. The strong and positive genetic relationships
between bodyweights at different ages could be attributed to pleitropic and linkage effect of genes.
This means that the same genes were controlling the bodyweight traits at different ages with
increasing expressivity.
CONCLUSION
On the basis of heritability estimates obtained for bodyweights at various ages, selection for body
weight can start within the first two weeks of age due to high body weight heritability at this age.
The low to moderate heritability of body weight at older ages may indicate that environmental
deviations were more important in influencing body weight at these ages than additive genetic
variances. Greater attention should therefore be paid to optimal conditions of feeding and
management at these stages. The high and positive genetic correlation observed between
bodyweights at different ages revealed the same quantitative traits loci (QTL) acting to express
body weight at different ages. Selection for bodyweight at early stages of life would lead to
improvement of body weight at later stages of life in the Japanese quail.
REFERENCES
Abdel-Fattah, M.H. (2006). Selection for increased bodyweight and growth rate in Japanese quail.
Ph.D Thesis, Fac. Agric. Fayoum Univ. Egypt. 153 pp.
Abdel-Tawab, S.K. (2006). The effect of selection for egg weight on some productive traits in
Japanese quail. M.Sc Thesis, Fac. Agric. Al-Azhar Univ. Cairo, Egypt 66pp.
Almeida, M. I., Oliveira, E. G., Ramos, P. R., Veiga, P. R., and Dias, K. (2002). Growth
performance of meat male quails of two lines under two nutritional environments. Arch. of
Vet. Sci., 7(2): 103-108.
Amhakian, S.O. (2009). Evaluation of phosphorus status of some soils in Kogi State Nigeria. Ph.D
Thesis, Edo State Univ. Ekpoma, Nigeria. 161pp.
Bahie El-Deen, M. (1994). Selection indices and crossing as a tool for improving meat and egg
production in Japanese quail. Ph. D Thesis Fac. Agric. Alexandria Univ. Egypt. 138pp.
Becker, W. A. (1992). Manual of Quantitative Genetics. 5th Edition USA, Academic enterprise
Pullman, 189pp.
Chambers, J. R. (1993). Genetics of growth and meat production in chickens. In: Poultry breeding
and genetics (Ed: Crawford, R.D.). Elsevier Sci. Pub. Pp. 599-644.
Dafwang, I. I. (2006). Nutrient requirements and feeding regiment in quail production. A paper
presented at National workshop on quail production for sustainable household protein
intake. NAERLS, Ahmadu Bello University Zaria. Sept. 11-13. pp 12-19.
El-Fiky, F.A. (1991). Genetic studies on some economic traits in Japanese quail. Ph.D. Thesis, Fac.
Agric. Al-Azhar Univ. Cairo, Egypt. 156pp.
El-Full, E.A., Ali, A.A., El-Fattah, A. and Khalifa, M. A. (2001). Inheritance of some growth
characteristics of Japanese quail. Egypt. Poult. Sci. J., 21(3): 719-739.
158
Farahat, G.S. (1998). Estimation of some genetic and phenotypic parameters for growth and
reproductive traits of Japanese quail. M.Sc. Thesis, Fac. Agric. Fayoum, Cairo Univ. Egypt.
98pp.
Harvey, W.R. (1990). Mixed model least-squares and maximum likelihood computer programme.
Ohio State Univ. Columbus (Mimeo).
Hort, J., Hyankova, L. and Knizetova, H. (1999). The role of sexual dimorplism in the onset of egglaying in Japanese quail. Proc. Poult. Genetics Symp. Oct. 6-8, Marience, Germany. Pp.120.
Marks, H. L. (1993). Carcass composition, feed intake and feed efficiency following long-term
selection for 4-week bodyweight in Japanese quail. Poult. Sci. J., 72:1005-1011.
Mignon-Grasteau, S., David, J., Gilbert, P., Legout, H., Petavy, G., Moreteau, B. and Beaumont, C.
(2004). REML estimates of genetic parameters of sexual dimorphism for wing and thorax
length in Drosophila melanogaster. J. Genet., 83:163-170.
Oguz, I., Ahan, O., Kirkpinar, F. and Setter, P. (1996). Body weights, carcass characteristics, organ
weights, abdominal fat and lipid content of Liver and carcass in two lines of Japanese quail,
unselected and selected for 4-week bodyweight. Brit. Poult. Sci. J., 37:579-588.
Saatei, M., Dewi, I., Aksoy, R., Kirmizibayrak, T. and Ulutas, Z. (2002). Estimation of genetic
parameters for weekly live weight in one to one sire and dam pedigree recorded Japanese
quail. In: 7th world congress on Genetic applied to livestock prod. Paris, France. P-20.
Sezer, M., Berberoglu, E. and Ulutas, Z. (2006). Genetic association between sexual maturity and
weekly live weights in laying-type Japanese quail. South African J. Anim. Sci., 36(2): 142148.
Shalan, H. M. (1998). Independent culling levels, selection and crossing for improving meat and
egg production in Japanese quail. Ph. D. Thesis, Fac. Agric. Alexandria Univ., Egypt.
133pp.
Sharaf, M. M. (1992). Genetic and non-genetic estimates of some reproductive and productive traits
in Japanese quail. Egypt. Poult. Sci. J., 12: 211-231.
Soltan, M. E., El-Sayed, M.A. and Abou-Ashour, A.M. (1987). Development of European quail
under Egyptian conditions. I-Early response to selection for bodyweight at four weeks of
age. Minufiya J. Agric. Res., 11:1-20.
SPSS (2004). Statistical package for social sciences. Release 14.0 for Windows. IL 60611.Chicago.
Table 1. Least-squares Means ± SEM for weekly body weight and degree of sexual dimorphism
(DSD, %) in Japanese quail.
Age (weeks)
Sex
Bodyweight (g)
DSD (%)
O (Hatch)
Male
Female
6.60±0.07b
6.82±0.08a
3.23
Male
Female
13.42±0.19b
13.94±0.20a
3.73
Male
Female
27.74±0.44b
29.28±0.46a
5.26
Male
Female
50.93±0.76b
52.82±0.80a
3.58
1
2
3
159
4
5
6
7
Male
Female
72.11±0.92b
75±06.097a
3.93
Male
Female
95.95±1.05b
101.58±1.10a
5.45
Male
Female
117.39±1.13b
131.58±1.19a
10.78
Male
Female
124.49±1.11b
140.64±1.16a
11.48
a, b = Means within sex-subgroup with different superscripts are significantly different (P<0.05)
DSD = Degree of sexual dimorphism
160
Table 2. Heritability from sire variance component (on Diagonal), Genetic correlation (above
diagonal) and phenotypic correlation (below diagonal) among bodyweights at different Ages in
Japanese quail.
O
week
1
week
2
week
3
week
4
week
5
week
6
week
7
week
O
0.91±0.1
week 1
0.74
0.59
0.90
0.81
0.80
0.38
0.40
1
0.66***
week
0.88±0.2
7
0.93
0.82
0.75
0.89
0.72
0.23
0.61***
0.82***
0.50±0.0
2
0.85
0.97
1.17
0.92
0.61
3
0.47***
week
0.47***
0.69***
0.32±0.1
9
0.94
0.98
0.67
0.37
4
0.46***
week
0.52***
0.72***
0.92***
0.27±0.1
8
1.05
1.01
0.66
5
0.46***
week
0.47***
0.65***
0.79***
0.87***
0.18±0.0
6
0.95
0.34
6
0.30***
week
0.35***
0.51***
0.60***
0.68***
0.79***
0.12±0.0
2
0.18
7
0.19***
week
0.13***
0.28***
0.43***
0.49***
0.59***
0.83***
0.21±0.0
6
2
Wee
k
*** =
(P<0.001)
AGB23
GENETIC DISTANCE BETWEEN POPULATIONS OF THE TIV LOCAL CHICKEN
IN THE DERIVED GUINEA SAVANNAH ZONE OF NIGERIA
161
Gwaza, D.S.* and Chia, S.S.
*
Department of Animal breeding and Physiology, University of Agriculture, Makurdi
P.M.B. 2373, Nigeria.
*Corresponding email: chiasamuel2010@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
A total of 1378 body linear measurement and body weight were obtained at four locations of
about 30 kilometers minimum apart, from kastina-Ala local government area of Benue State. The
data were subjected to the general linear model procedure and a discriminant analysis to estimate
the effect of location and mahalanobis square (D2) distance between locations. There was
significant variation in body length, shank length, tail length, tail width and comb length due to
location. There were also large and significant genetic distances between the locations except
between location 4 and 2. There is a wide genetic diversity in body dimensions between isolated
populations of the local chicken ecotypes. Superior birds could be identified, selected and bred
for genetic improvementKEY WORDS:
Genetic distance, local chicken’s ecotypes and
population.
INTRODUCTION
Local chicken ecotypes are more adapted to local environmental conditions and diseases (ALAliyat, 2009). The local chickens contribute greatly to human supply of eggs and meat in
tropical and subtropical areas. They are the only livestock, which could be kept by the poorest
rural families (AL Aliyat, 2009). Horst (1989) considered the local chicken ecotypes as genes
reservoir, especially, there genes that have adaptive values in the tropical conditions.
Nigeria local chicken had been grouped on ecological zones on the bases of body size and body
weight as light and heavy ecotypes (Momoh et al., 2007). Olori (1992) noted two ecotypes
characterized as forest and savannah ecotypes. Nwosu (1979) reported three main strains among
the forest ecotype. Oluyemi et al. (1982) also reported variation in many traits of the local
chicken from southern region of Nigeria. Adebambo et al. (2009) however found no significance
differences in the genetic distance of local chickens from South west, North West and, Northeast
ecological zones of Nigeria. The cited literature indicated that there appeared to be no
consistency in literature about genetic diversity in the Nigeria local chicken ecotypes. However,
most literature accepts the existence of diversity in the Nigerian local chicken ecotypes.
Classification of genetic resources based on geographical location appeared to provide based
estimates of genetic diversity (Pimm and Lawton, 1988) of the local chicken genetic resources of
Nigeria. The genetic distinctiveness of an animal forms the base for distinguishing it among
different animal genetic resources and for assessing the available diversity (FAO, 1984). The
present and future improvement and sustainability of the local chicken’s production systems are
dependent upon availability of this genetic variation (Benitez, 2002). Therefore, the evaluation of
the local chicken population genetic resources includes the determination of genetic distance
between the available populations (Hammond, 1994).
The objective of this study was to assess the genetic distance between populations of the Tiv
local chicken ecotypes based on body linear measurements with the view of highlighting genetic
diversity within isolated populations of the ecotypes that can be selected and breed for genetic
improvement.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
162
The study was conducted at Kastina-Ala Local Government Area of Benue State at four
locations Weghgyina village, Kenvanger village, Kpuntgo village and Udende village that were
more than 30 Kilometers apart. These were rural farming communities that practiced
crop/livestock integration. Local chickens were the predominant poultry species owned. KastinaAla local government area is located between Latitude 7° 1111 3411 N and Longitude 9° 2011 2111
E. The mean annual rainfall was 11.75mm. There is two seasons (dry and wet seasons).
Temperature during the rainy season ranges from 21.7oC. The relative humadity is about 68%.
The local chickens were reared under the free range population system. The birds seek for their
own feed by scavenging kitchen waste, farm by-products and foraging for insects and worms.
Cereal grains were offered occasionally as feed supplement. Water was provided through not adlabium. Medication was never provided. Inhabitation, hatching and blooding were all by natural
processes.
Measurements were taken on 1,378 birds consisting of 360 at Kpuntgo, 400 at Kenvanger, 320 at
Weghyuia and 298 at Udende villages, respectively. Traits measured were body length, body
height, shank length, thigh length, tail length, tail width, comb length, comb height, wattle
length, wattle height and body weight.
The data generated were subjected to general linear procedure of SPSS, (2004) to estimate the
effect of location, sex and their interaction on body dimensions of the birds. The following
model was used.
Yijk = + Li + Sj + (LS) ij + eijk
where,
Yijk
= single observation
= population mean
Li = effect of the ith location (i = 1, 2, 3, 4)
Sj = effect of sex (j = 1, 2).
(LS)ij = effect of location by sex interaction
eijk = error variance component
The data were also subjected to a discriminant analysis to estimate the Mahalanobis distance
between the locations using the CANDISC procedure. The Mahalanobis squared distance (D2)
between locations was estimated by:
D2 (i/j) = (xi – xj) cov-1 (xi – xj) (SAS, 1990).
Where D2
= genetic distance between populations in a m-Dimensional space.
Ij
= the element of the ith row and jth column of the inverse matrix.
xi – xj = mean set of original variables
Cov = covariance of the original data set.
163
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The analysis of variance indicated significant (p>0.05) effect of location on body length, shark
length highly significant (p>0.001), thigh length (p>0.05), tail length (p>0.01), law width highly
significant (P>0.001), comb length (P>0.05), comb height (P<0.05) and wattle length (P<0.05).
Body weight and body height did not vary significantly (P>0.05) across the locations (Table 1).
Sex effect on body measurement was highly significant (P<0.001) for all the traits measured. The
effect of sex by location interaction significantly (P<0.05) affected only body height. The other
interactions were not significant (P>0.05). The significant (p<0.05) effect of body length, thigh
length, wattle length, comb length and comb height due to location indicated that these
parameters varied between the isolated populations to the Tiv chicken ecotypes. The univariate
test also indicated that shark length, tail length and width were most varied between the isolated
population’s Gwaza et al. (2012) also reported variation in there traits. These parameters
determine adaptation and fitness of the birds to their environment. The variation in there
parameters between the population would mean variation in the genetic resources of the local
chicken between the population (Yakubu, 2011).
Mahalanobis squared distance (D2) from location 1 to 2, 1to 3 and 4 were o.64854, 0.92750 and
0.54760 respectively. Location 2 to 3 and 4 were 1.20128 and 0.15311 and distance from
location 4 to 1, 2 and 3 were 0.54760, 0.15311, and 0.99809 respectively (Table 2). The highest
F statistic value were recorded for Mahalanobis squared distance between locations 1 and
2(7.10656) followed by that between location 1 and 4 (4.56086). This was followed by the
distance between location 2 and 3 (2.91620), location 1 and 3 (2.46385), location 3 and 4
(2.26458). The least F statistics was obtained for the squared distance between location 2 and 4
(0.98429) (Table 3). There were significant (p>0.0) differences in F statistics between location 1
and 2 (p<0.05), location 1 and 3 (p<0.02) and between location 1 and 4. Location 2 to 3 and
between location 4 to 3 different significantly (p>0.05) difference in the squared distance
between location 2 and 4 (Table 3). Although the univariate analysis revealed difference in body
dimensions between the isolated populations of the Tiv chicken ecotypes multivariate analysis
indicated that there was significant genetic distance between the isolated populations of the Tiv
local chicken ecotypes. This may be due to cultural practices, movement and settlement patterns
of the Tiv rural farming communities. As then rural farmer’s family size increases, some
members of the farming communities relocate to new settlements taking along with them a small
group of the local chicken from the original population to form a new population. The random
sample of alleles in the just formed new populations is expected to grossly misrepresent the
original population (Neil, 1996). When a new formed population is small, its founders can
strongly
affect
the
populations
genetic
make-up
far
into
the
future
(http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/evolution /library/06/3/1-063-03.html) .
The difference in the gene frequencies between the original and the new populations may also
trigger the groups to diverge significant over the course of many generations (small et al., 2007).
As the difference increases, the separated populations may become distinct, both genetically and
phenotypic ally with wide genetic distance as observed in this study. Natural and artificial
selection gene flow and mutation may have certainly contributed to this divergence.
164
TABLE 1:Analysis of variance result on effect of location, sex
and their interactions on
body linear measurement.
Sources of
degrees of
sum of
means
F value
Variation
freedom
squaressquares
Loc
bol
3
42.090 14.030
1.456*
boh
3
16.089 5.363
0.766ns
shl
3
36.555 12.185
12.355***
thl
3
7.588 2.529
1.670*
tal
3
48.522 16.174
5.333**
taw
3
60.186 20.062
6.570*
Comh
3
21.674 7.225
4.068*
Comh
3
2.222 0.741
1.242*
Wal
3
3.415 1.138
1.123ns
Wal
3
4.285 1.1428
3.027*
Bow
3
0.055 0.018
0.421 ns
Sex
bol
1
1386.483
1386.483
143.918***
Bol
1
1597.375
157.375
228.133***
Shl
1
242.961
242.961
246.347***
Thl
1
273.679
273.679
180.696***
Tal
1
518.721
518.721
171.049***
Taw
1
41.409
41.409
13.562***
Coml
1
978.114
978.114
550.768***
Coml
1
346.610
346.610
581.304***
Wal
1
153.011
153.011
150.939***
Wal
1
276.316
276.316
585.657***
Bow
1
8.518
8.518
195.747***
Bol
3
30.847
10.282
1.468*
Error
bol
721
6947.788
9.636
Boh
721
5048.414
7.002
Shl
721
711.092
0.986
Tal
721
1092.013
1.515
Tail
721
2186.497
3.033
Toilw
721
2201.489
3.053
Coml.
721
1280.431
3.053
Wal
721
429.905
0.596
Wal
721
730.897
1.014
Wah
721
340.172
0.472
Bow
721
31.373
0.044
*
Significant at 5 percent
*** Significant at 10 percent.
165
Table 2: Mahalanobin squared distance (D2) to location.
From location
1
2
3
1
0
0.649
0.928
2
0
1.201
3
0
4
0.548
0.153
0.998
Table 3: F statistic for squared Mahalanobin distance (D2)
to Location.
From location
1
2
3
1
0
7.107**
2.464*
2
0
2.916*
3
0
* Significant at 5 percent, ** significant at 10 percent.
4
4.561**
0.984ns
2.265*
CONCLUSION
There existed significant genetic diversity between isolated population of the Tiv local chicken
ecotypes. This diversity may have been induced by cultural practices, isolated settlement patterns
in addition to natural and artificial selection, gene flow and mutation. Superior birds could be
identified, selected and bred for genetic improvement of the Tiv local chicken performance.
There is need to conduct molecular characterization, that will provide, molecular data for
unbiased estimates of genetic diversity within this ecotype.
REFERENCES
Adebambo, A.O, Mwacharo, J.M and Hannote, O. (2009). Characterization of Nigerian
indigenous chicken ecotypes using microsatellite markers. Proceeding of the 3rd Nigeria
international poultry summit, February 22-26, SI, OCa, PP: 84-91.
AL-Aliyat, R. (2009). Diversity of chicken populations in Jordan determined using discriminate
analysis of performance traits. International of Agriculture Biology, 11: 374-380.
Benitez, F. (2002). Reasons for the use and conservation of Some local genetic resources in
poultry. In: Proc.7th World Congress on Genetics Applied to Livestock Production.
August 19-23, 2002. Montpellier, France.
FAO (1984). Animal Genetic Resource conservation by Management: Data Bank and Training
Food and Agriculture Organization, Rome Italy.
Gwaza, D.S., Dim, N.I. and Momoh, O.M. (2012). Genetic study of the Fulani and the Tiv local
chicken ecotypes in the derived guinea savannah region of Nigeria. PhD thesis submitted
to the Department of Animal Breeding and Physiology, University of Agriculture,
Makurdi. Nigeria.
Hammond, K. (1994). Conservation of domestic animal diversity: Global overview. Proc. 5th
World Congress on Genetics Applied to Livestock Production, 21: 423-439.
Hort, P. (1989). Native fowl as reservoir for genomes and major Gene’s with direct and indirect
effects on adaptability and their potential for tropical oriented breeding plans. Arch. Fur.
Guflugelk., 53: 93-101.
Momoh, O.M., Ehiobu, N.G. and Nwosu, C.C. (2007). Egg Production of two Nigeria local
chicken ecotypes Under improved Management. Proceedings 32nd Annual Conference of
166
Nigeria Society for Animal Production, March 18-22, University of Calabar, Nigeria, pp
278-281.
Neill, C. (1996). Biology; fourth edition. The Benjamin’s/Cummings Publishing Company 423p,
ISBN 0-8053-1940-9.
Nwosu, C.C. (1979). Characterization of the local chicken in Nigeria and its potential for egg
and meat production. Proceedings of the 1st National Seminar on Poultry Production,
Dec. 11-13, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria. Pp. 187-210.
Olori, V. E. (1992). An evaluation of two ecotypes of the Nigeria indigenous chicken. M.Sc.
thesis, OAU Ile Ife.
Oluyemi, J.A., Alonge, G.O. and Sunga, T. (1982). Requirements of the Nigerian fowl for
protein and amino acids. Ife J. Agric. ,4: 105-110.
Pimm, S.L. and Lawton, J.H. (1988). Planning for bio-diversity. Science, 279: 2068-2069.
SAS (1990). SAS Users Guide, Version 8,1. SAS institute Inc. cavy, NC, Pinto, U.S.A.
Small, K.S., Brudo, M., Hill, M.M. and Sidow, A. (2007). Extreme genomic variation in a
natural populatio (http;//www.pnas.org/content/104/13/5698.long). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.,
104 (13): 5698-5703.
SPSS, (2004). Statistical package for social sciences. SPSS Inc. Chicago IL.
Yakubu, A. (2011). Discriminant analysis of sexual dimorphism in morphological traits of
African Muscovy ducks. Arch. Zootec., 60 (232): 1115-1123.
167
AGB24
IMPROVING EGG PRODUCTION IN THE NORMAL FEATHERED NATIVE
CHICKENS OF NIGERIA USING THE NAKED NECK GENE
Egahi, J.O.*, Dim, N.I. and Momoh, O.M.
Department of Animal Breeding and Physiology, University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: egahijoseph@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Part period egg production was monitored in straight bred F1 progeny of two genetic groups of
Nigerian local chicken (normal feathered and naked neck) and their crossbred (using the naked
neck as the sire) to 280 days of age. Eggs traits considered during the part period were total egg
number, egg mass and average egg weight. The age at first egg (AFE) and the weight of first egg
(WFE) were also monitored in the genetic groups. The heritability and genetic correlations
between these traits were also evaluated. Part period egg number, egg mass and average egg
weight varied significantly (P<0.05) between the genetic groups. Similarly, AFE and WFE
varied significantly between the genetic groups. Though part period egg number was
significantly higher in the normal feathered (NF) genetic group, it did not translate to higher egg
mass due smaller egg size. The introgression of the naked neck gene (Na) into the normal
feathered significantly (P<0.05) improved egg mass in the crossbred over the straight bred
normal feathered birds. The study therefore recommends the exploitation of the Na gene in
improving egg production in the normal feathered native chicken of Nigeria.
INTRODUCTION
Native chickens are important in breaking the vicious cycle of poverty, malnutrition and disease
especially among the rural poor. These birds have been reported to have adapted well to the local
scavenging production system under which they are managed. Phenotypically, four genetic
groups of the Nigerian local chicken have been identified. These are the normal feathered, frizzle
feathered, naked neck and the dwarf chickens. The egg production characteristic of these genetic
groups is common expression in contemporary literature. In general, several workers (Hanzi and
Somes, 1993; Cahaner et al., 1994; Eberhart and Washburn, 1993) have demonstrated the
advantage of the naked neck (Na) birds over their normally feathered counterparts when reared at
constant high ambient temperatures (AT). Consequently, the Na birds have been variously
reported (Horst, 1988; Ibe, 1993) to have better productivity in terms of body weight gain, egg
number and egg size over the normal feathered and frizzled feathered birds under same stressing
conditions usually imposed by high AT in the tropics. However, there is a dearth in literature on
the production characteristics of the Na gene acting in concert with other genes of the native
168
chickens in Nigeria. The current study was therefore undertaken to evaluate the egg production
characteristics of the cross between the naked neck and the normal feathered birds.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Thirty parent stock dams of normal feathered (NF) and naked neck (Na) genotypes housed on
deep litter with a mating ratio of 1:10 sire to dam, respectively were used to generate the F1
pedigreed chicks used in the experiment. Similarly, a mating ratio of 1:10 naked neck sire to
normal feathered dams replicated three times was used to generate the crossbred genetic group.
The resulting chicks were brooded on deep litter under standard conditions. Twenty pullets from
each genetic group were randomly selected and reared to 280 days of age during which part
period egg production was measured. Parameters evaluated include part period egg number
(PPEN), part period egg mass (PPEM) and average part period egg weight (PPEW). The age at
first egg (AFE) and the weight of first egg (WFE) were also evaluated.
Data collected were analysed using the general linear model multivariate analysis as outlined in
SPSS (2004) statistical package. The model fitted was:
Yij = µ + a1 + eij
Where
Yij = single observation (egg number, egg weight)
µ
= overall mean
ai = effect of ith genetic group
eij = residual error.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 1 presents the summary of the part period egg production characteristics in the genetic
groups studied. The total part period egg number ranged from 88.8±1.98 in the Na straight bred
to 105.25±2.57 in the NF straight bred genotype. It varied significantly (P<0.05) between the
genetic groups with the NF genotype exhibiting a significantly (P<0.05) higher egg number
among the straight bred genotypes.
169
Mean part period egg weight ranged from 33.45±1.04 in the NF straight bred genotype to
38.86±0.95 in the Na straight bred genotype. There was significant variation between the
straight bred the cross bred genotypes for egg mean weight.
Part period egg mass was significantly higher (P<0.05) in the cross bred genotype than in
the respective straight bred genetic groups. The part period egg number for the genetic group
of the Nigerian local chicken in the current study is higher than those reported by Momoh
(2005) for the heavy and light ecotype chickens. The observed differences in the current
genotypes of the Nigerian local chicken may be a reflection of the true genetic diversity of
these birds or environmental differences. However, the observed significant (P<0.05)
differences between the genetic groups for egg number is at variance with the report of
Adedokun and Sonaiya (2001) who noted that the Nigerian indigenous chicken from three
agro-ecological zones did not differ significantly in egg production characteristics. The
range obtained in the current study for egg number during the part period are within the
range reported by Udeh and Omeje (2005) and Asuquo et al. (1992) for the Nigerian local
chicken.
The heritability estimates for part period egg characteristics are presented in Table 2. In
general, heritability estimate observed in the current study ranged from low to high. The
heritability estimates for short term egg number obtained in the current study are in
agreement with the values reported previously by Oni et al. (1991) for Nigerian local
chicken and Kiaani-Manesh et al. (2003) for Iranian native chickens. The low to moderate
heritability estimate for egg number observed in the current study is indicative that
improvement for egg number in the genetic groups may not be rapid through mass selection.
Thus, crossbreeding and other selection procedures (individual selection) may be profitable
in improving egg number in the genetic groups. The mean short term heritability estimate
for egg number, egg weight and egg mass in the crossbred genotype are marginally higher
than those of the respective straight bred genotypes. This is suggestive that genetic
improvement for these traits could be achieved through crossbreeding.
Tables 3 present the genetic correlation between the traits of interest. The range of values
obtained for genetic correlation in the current study is within the range reported by Momoh
(2005) for the light and heavy ecotypes of chicken of Nigeria.
170
CONCLUSION
In summary, based on the values for the genetic correlations obtained between the various
parameters, it may be concluded that any improvement in part period egg number would
lead to a concurrent improvement in egg mass and age at first egg in the genetic groups
because of the positive genetic correlation. Furthermore, selection for part period egg
number will lead to improvement in annual egg number. This is true since there is high
genetic correlation between part period egg number and annual egg number reported by
several authors.
REFERENCES
Adedokun, S.A. and Sonaiya, E.B. (2001). Comparison of the performance of Nigerian
indigenous chickens from three agro-ecological zones. Livest. Res. Rural Dev., 13:
Adeyinka, I. A. (1998). Short term response to selection in layer type chicken. PhD Thesis
submitted to Department of Animal Science ABU Zaria. 112pp.
Asuquo, B.O., Okon B.O. and Ekong, A.O. (1992). Quality parameters of Isa Brown and
Nigerian Local Chicken eggs. Nig. J. Anim. Prod., 19: 1-5.
Cahaner, A., R. Yunis, and Deeb, N. (1994). Genetics of feathering and heat tolerance in
broilers. Pages 67–70 in: Proceedings of the 9th European Poultry Conference. Vol. 2.
Glasgow, UK.
Eberhart, D. E., and Washburn, K. W. (1993). Variation in body temperature response of naked
neck and normally feathered chickens to heat stress. Poultry Sci., 72: 1385–1390.
Hanzl, C. J. and Somes, R.G. Jr., (1983). The effect of the naked neck gene, Na, on growth and
carcass composition of broilers raised in two temperatures. Poultry Sci., 62: 934–941.
Horst, P. (1988). Indigenous fowl as reservoir for genomes and major genes with direct and
indirect effects on productive adaptability and their potentials for tropically orientated
breeding plans. Proceedings of the 18th World's Poultry Congress, (Nagoya). Pp. 99-104.
Ibe, S. N. (1993). Growth performance of normal, frizzle and naked neck chickens in a tropical
environment. Nigerian Journal of Animal Production, 20: 25 - 31.
Kiani-Manesh, A. Neejati-Javareemi, A. and Saneei, D. (2003). Estimation of variance
component of economically important traits in Iranian native fowls. Proc. 7th World
Congress on Genetics Applied to Livestock Production. Montpellier France August 1923. Abstract.
Momoh, O.M. (2005). Genetic and phenotypic evaluation of the Nigeria heavy chicken ecotype
and its crossbreds with the light ecotype. Ph.D. thesis. Department of Animal Breeding
and Physiology. University of Agriculture Makurdi Nigeria, 164pp.
Oni, O O, Abubakar, B. Y. and Ogundipe, S. O. (1991). Genetic and phenotypic association of
juvenile body weights and egg production traits in two strains of Rhode Island chickens.
Nigeria Journal of Animal Production, 18: 66-70.
SPSS .(2004). Statistical Package for the Social Sciences. SPSS Inc., 444 Michigan Avenue,
Chicago.
171
Udeh, I. and S.I. Omeje (2005. Heterosis for egg production in native by exotic inbred chicken
crosses. Nig. J. Anim. Prod., 32: 7-20
172
Table 1. Summary of part period egg production characteristics in the genetic groups
Parameter
NF/NF
Na/Na
Na/NF
PPEN
105.25 ±2.57a
88.8 ±1.98c
100.5 ±2.04b
APPEW
33.45 ±1.04 c
38.86 ±0.95a
35.99 ±1.35b
PPEM (g)
3520.61 ±79.25b
3450.76 ±78.51c
3616.99 ±85.47a
AFE (days)
161.05±0.72a
180.05 ±1.36c
163.90 ±0.83b
WFE (g)
28.21 ±0.37b
30.40 ±0.27a
30.42 ±0.35a
a,b,c… means within the same row having different superscripts are significantly different (P<0.05)
NF-Normal feathered genotype.
Na- Naked neck genotype
PPEN = Part period egg number
APPEW = average part period egg weight
AFE = Age at first egg
WFE=Weight
of
173
PPEM = Part period egg mass
first
egg
Table 2. Heritability estimates for short-term egg production from sire variance components in the
genetic groups
Parameter
NF/NF
Na/Na
Na/NF
Egg number
0.31±0.26
0.27±0.21
0.32±0.23
Egg weight
0.45±0.14
0.44±0.21
0.51±0.21
Egg mass
0.17±0.12
0.31±0.22
0.35±0.15
AFE
0.42±0.11
0.28±0.18
0.26±0.17
NF-Normal feathered genotype.
FF- Frizzle feathered genotype.
Na- Naked neck genotype
1
AGB25
DIMORPHISM OF BODY WEIGHT IN TWO TYPES OF NIGERIAN INDIGENOUS
CHICKEN IN DERIVED SAVANNAH ZONE
Ige, A.O.1* and Salako, A.E.2
1
Department of Animal Nutrition and Biotechnology, Ladoke Akintola University of Technology
Ogbomoso Oyo State, Nigeria.
2
Animal Breeding and Genetics Unit, Department of Animal Science, University of Ibadan, Oyo
State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: igeazeemng50@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
The study sought to evaluate sources of variation of bodyweight in Yoruba and Fulani Ecotype
chickens on free range system. A total of 2,041 chickens from five different flocks were weighed
individually with the aid of weighing scale with sensitivity of 0.01 kg. Data generated were subjected
to T-Test statistics. It was revealed that within each ecotype sex significantly (P<0.05) influenced
bodyweight in favour of male chicken while ecotype significantly (P<0.05) influenced bodyweight in
favour of Fulani ecotype. Flock had no significant (P>0.05) effect on bodyweight in both ecotypes. It
can therefore be concluded that during selection to improve body weight of indigenous chickens,
male chicken should be given more preference than female and that Fulani ecotype may respond
positively to selection than Yoruba ecotype.
INTRODUCTION
Dimorphism is a natural phenomenon in all growing animals characterised by the manifestation of
visible differences between the male and female species. Various investigations in sexual
dimorphism in relation to body weight, feed and water intake of chicken have been made. In
domestic chicken, this was observed from the body weight gains, size, shape and behaviour of the
birds. It was reviewed by Laseinde and Oluyemi (1992) that male broilers were heavier than females
at hatching. The average body weight at day old for male was 40.31g and 36.6g for the female. At
the growing and finishing stages, also the males were heavier than the females. Musa et al. (2006)
reported that males had a significantly higher body weight and carcass weight, a better feed
conversion and less carcass fat than females. Garcia et al. (1993) found that the body weight at
slaughter and carcass yield were higher in male than in female. Kirchgessner et al. (1993) also
reported that females had a lower feed consumption and growth rate than the males and also had a
poorer feed efficiency by 3.4%
In the experiment conducted by Soarce et al. (1992) males had significantly higher body weight,
better feed conversion efficiency and less carcass fat than females. High significant differences were
evident between sexes of the commercial broiler stocks in an experiment conducted by Hamcock et
al. (1995), with respect to the mature weights. It was reviewed by Burke (1994) that male chick was
significantly heavier than females. Burke (1994) also noted significant sex differences in body
weight of turkey poults of one strain on the day of hatch, but in another strain, the difference was not
significant until 6 weeks of age. Akinokun (1990) reported that higher body weight values for male
in indigenous chicken than females in a non descript population.
This study was therefore designed to document sources of variation of bodyweight in Fulani and
Yoruba ecotype chickens in derived savannah zone of Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Data used for this study were generated from 2,041 Indigenous chicken comprising of 767 Fulani
Ecotype and 1,274 Yoruba ecotype chickens under free range system in the derived savannah zone of
Nigeria. These chickens were individually weighed with the aid of weighing scale with sensitivity of
0.01kg. The study was carried out at Ogbomoso, it was located in the derived savannah zone of
Nigeria. The climate is characterized by fairly high uniform temperature (36.20C) and Moderate to
2
high relative humidity (60% - 70%) (Oladuntan Oladimeji, 1999). The Nigeria indigenous chickens
in this study are Yoruba and Fulani ecotype, reared under traditional Animal Husbandry where they
scavenge for most feed resources that are no longer directly useful to man, such as crop residues and
kitchen waste with little or no grain supplement
Least square mean (x), standard deviation (S.D), standard error (S.E) and coefficient of variation
(C.V) associated with body weight were estimated using GLM procedure of Statistical Analysis
System (SAS, 1990) package. T – Statistics procedure was used to test the significance of the mean
differences between values of sexes and ecotype using the same statistical package.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 1 shows the descriptive statistics of body weight of Yoruba and Fulani ecotype flocks. In
Yoruba Ecotype, the result showed that mean live weight across location ranged from 0.98 0.22kg
to 1.210.1kg with 1.06 0.02 kg to 1.36 0.02kg for males and 0.88 0.02kg to 1.06 0.02kg for
females. Coefficient of variation ranged from 12.86% – 22.14% for males and 10.50% – 18.88% for
females. Males were significantly heavier than females (Table 2). In Fulani Ecotype, the result
showed that mean live weight across location ranged from 1.32 0.03kg to 1.77 0.04kg with 1.87
0.06kg to 1.75 + 0.05kg for males and 1.65 0.06kg to 1.27 0.03kg for females. Fulani Ecotype
had higher coefficients of variation (28.27% - 35.68%). Males were significantly heavier than
females. Generally, Fulani ecotype were heavier (1.77 0.04kg) than their Yoruba ecotype
counterpart (1.21 0.01kg). Highest value was recorded for male. Coefficient of variation and
standard deviation did not follow any definite pattern, thus live weight were variable in the
populations studied.
Table 1. Least Square Means(X), Standard deviation (S. D.), Standard Error (S. E.) and Coefficient
of Variation (C. V.) of Body Weight of Yoruba and Fulani ecotype Chicken.
Population
Ikoyi
N
X (kg)
S. D.
S. E.
C. V.
Yoruba Ecotype
Male
Female
131
122
1.06
0.88
0.24
0.17
0.02
0.02
22.14
18.88
Total
253
0.98
0.22
0.01
22.79
Fulani Ecotype
Male
Female
78
80
1.75
1.27
0.43
0.24
0.05
0.03
24.76
19.08
Total
158
1.32
0.43
0.03
28.27
3
Iluju
Iresaadu
Onipaanu
Ibaiyaoje
N
X (kg)
S. D.
S. E.
C. V.
N
X (kg)
S. D.
S. E.
C. V.
N
X (kg)
S. D.
S. E.
C. V.
N
X (kg)
S. D.
S. E.
C. V.
130
1.26
0.17
0.02
13.70
127
1.36
0.17
0.02
12.86
126
1.18
0.19
0.02
15.70
144
1.07
0.21
0.02
19.36
123
0.97
0.10
0.01
10.50
123
1.06
0.18
0.02
17.10
123
1.06
0.18
0.02
11.53
125
0.95
0.15
0.01
15.43
253
1.11
0.20
0.01
18.40
250
1.21
0.23
0.01
19.12
249
1.09
0.18
0.01
16.39
269
1.01
0.19
0.01
19.08
80
1.87
0.52
0.06
27.99
75
1.86
0.50
0.06
26.84
76
1.84
0.51
0.06
27.91
80
1.83
0.56
0.06
30.76
75
1.60
0.43
0.05
27.09
71
1.60
0.50
0.06
30.93
73
1.65
0.53
0.06
32.08
79
1.55
0.42
0.05
26.89
155
1.72
0.50
0.04
29.82
146
1.74
0.52
0.04
29.71
149
1.77
0.52
0.04
29.52
159
1.66
0.51
0.04
30.68
Table 2. Summary of T – Test of Mean Difference of Body weight between Sexes and Ecotype
FLOCK
YORUBA
MALE FEMALE
FULANI
MALE FEMALE
POOLED
YORUBA
FULANI
4
Ikoyi
1.06a
0.88b
1.75 a
1.27 b
0.98 a
1.52 b
Iluju
1.26 a
0.97 b
1.87 a
1.60 b
1.11 a
1.72 b
Iresaadu
1.36 a
1.06 b
1.86 a
1.60 b
1.21 a
1.74 b
Onipaanu`
1.18 a
0.99 b
1.84 a
1.65 b
1.09 a
1.77 b
Ibaiyaoje
1.07 a
0.95 b
1.83 a
1.55 b
1.07 a
1.66 b
Means with the same superscript along the same row within ecotype and body parameters are not
significantly different ( p>0.05 )
Body weight has been widely reported as the most common measure of size in domestic animal
populations. Akinokun (1990), Nwosu et al. (1985), Hossain and Ahmed (1993) and Gueye et al.
(1998) all reported the significance of body weight in local chickens. Gueye et al. (1998) reported
values of 1.367 0.3kg and 1.120 0.23kg for male and female indigenous chicken of Senegal
which were higher than value reported for Yoruba ecotype and lower than value reported for Fulani
ecotype chickens in this study. Within each ecotype, males were generally heavier than females
which may be due to sexual dimorphisms that exist in indigenous chicken populations. This agrees
with reports of Ngou Ngoupayou (1990) and Missohou et al. (1997) in indigenous chickens and
Hassan and Adamu (1997) in indigenous pigeons. The authors further explained that males were
generally more aggressive than females which consequently aid their ability in search of feeds during
scavenging as well as during feeding. Fayeye et al. (2006) reported values of 1.49 0.43kg and
1.130.29kg for male and female, respectively which agree with the values reported in this study and
Gonzalez et al. (2003) also reported that males were generally heavier than females in native chicken
of South Eastern Mexico. The present results also agree with the earlier submission of Adedokun and
Sonaiya (2001) in the study conducted on the effect of sex on body weight of indigenous chicken
population of Nigeria. The result of this study is also in line with the work of Morathop et al. (2007)
who reported values of 1.1kg and 0.85kg for males and female, respectively in decoy chickens in
upper North of Thailand. Islam and Nishebiri (2009) shared the same view of sex effect on native
chickens of Bangladesh. Oluyemi and Ogunmodede (1979) reported on the physical characteristics
of the indigenous fowl with matured body weight of 1.18 – 1.25kg for male and 0.9 – 1.02kg for
female.
Although, information on the age of the birds in this study could not be obtained because indigenous
chicken keepers were ignorant of it, even most indigenous chicken keepers did not know the exact
age of their bird so as to relate it to bodyweight. Sonaiya (1997) reported similar constraints in his
study. However, Olori (1992) observed sexual dimorphism in indigenous chickens under intensive
system at adult age of fifteen week and the differentiation became apparent with male being
significantly heavier.
Between ecotypes, Fulani ecotype were significantly heavier than Yoruba ecotype in this study and
this may be due to strain effect which plays a significant role in relation to genetic effect on
variation in body weight of chickens. Giordani et al. (1992) and Garcia et al. (1993) also reported
significant differences in the growth performance of different strains of birds in their studies. Edriss
et al. (1995) earlier reported that strain groups had significant effect on body weight in indigenous
chickens of Iran. Fulani Ecotypes chickens tend to have more access to crop residues and farm
wastes than Yoruba Ecotype chickens. Atteh (1990) and Olori (1992) observed that Fulani Ecotype
were heavier than other ecotypes in their various studies. Olori (1992) further concluded that Fulani
Ecotype Chicken grew faster than Yoruba ecotype chicken.
5
The values reported for Body Weight in this study was lower than literature values of exotic chicken
which thus indicates that indigenous chickens are small in body size. Nwosu and Asuquo, (1985),
Nwosu and Omeje (1985) all reported that indigenous chickens are characterised with small body
size and small egg size. Nwosu et al. (1985) opined that indigenous chickens belong to light breed
group. Conclusively, this study revealed that sex is a source of variation in indigenous chicken
population.
REFERENCES
Adedokun, S.A. and Sonaiya, E.B. (2001). Comparison of the performance of Nigerian indigenous
chickens from three agro-ecological zones. Livestock. Res. For Rural Dev. 13 (2).
http://www.cipav.org.co/lrrd13/2/adad 132 htm.
Akinokun, O. (1990). An evaluation of exotic and indigenous chicken as genetic material for
development of rural poultry. Workshop on rural poultry development in Africa held at
O.A.U., Ile-Ife Nig. Nov. 13-16, 59: 36-61.
Atteh, J.O. (1990). Rural poultry in Africa; Proceedings International Poultry Workshop: pp 211220.
Burke W.H. (1994). Sex difference in weight of Turkey. Poultry Sc. 73 No5: 749- 753.
Edriss, M.A., Pourreza, J. and Esaeilkhanian, (1995). The investigative of the genetic correlation
between fasting weight and abadominal fat in two groups of Native chickens. Seminar of
first Genetic and improvement the livestock, poultry and Aquatic Kara. Iran.
Fayeye, T.R., Adeshiyan, A.B. and Olugbami, A. A. (2005). Egg traits, Hatchability and early
growth performance of the Fulani Ecotype chicken. Livestock Research for Rural
Development, 17(8).
Garcia, E.A., Mendes, A.A., and Curi P.R. (1993). Effect on line on growth of broilers. Animal
Breeding Abstract, 93: 61.
Giordani, G., Meluzzi, A., Cristofori, C. and Calini, F. (1992). Study on the performance adiposity of
modern broiler comparison among strains. Anim. Breeding Abstract, 6(8) 581.
Gueye, E.F., Ndiaye, A. and Branckaert, R.D.S. (1998). Prediction of body weight on the basis of
body measurement in mature indigenous chickens in Senegal. Livestock Research for Rural
Development,10(3).http:.//www.cipaw.org.co/irrd10/3sene103.htm.
Hamcock, C.E., Bradform, G.D. and Emmans, G.C. (1995). Potential growth of males and females
of commercial broilers. British poultry Sci. 36:247-264.
Hassan, W.A. and Adamu, U.A. (1997). Pigeon genetic resources in semi-arid zone of Nigeria.
Initial results from characterization studies. Paper submitted at INFPD Workshop and
General meeting, 9-13 December 1997, M Bour Senegal.
Hossain, M.J. and Ahmed, S. (1993). Body weight of indigenous Rhode Island Red and Plymouth
rouh
chicken.
Animal
Breeding
Abstract
93:
61(8).
http://www.
Cipav.org.co/irid/irrd/irrd18/i/badu1800
Islam, M.A and Nishibori, M. (2009). Indigenous naked neck chickens: A valuable genetic resource
for Bangladesh. World’s Poult. Sci. J. 65:125-138.
Kirchgessner, M., Kreuzer, M. and Ristic, M. (1993). Expression of sex difference in growth of
broilers. Animal Breeding Abstract, 61 (8).
Laseinde E.A. O. and Oluyemi J.A. (1992). Sexual dimorphism in the growth pattern of broiler. Nig.
Journal of Animal Prod., 24(1):1-6.
Missohou, A., Sow, R.S. and Ngive-Assoumou, C. (1997). Carateristiques morphobiometriques da la
poule du Senegal paper presented at INFPD Workshop and General meeting, 9-13 December
1997, M’Bour, Senegal.
Morathop, S., Trimance, S., Leotargul, A. and Mahakanta (2007). Phenotypic characteristics, body
weights and body conformation of decoy chicken in upper North Thailand.vol.4:112-118.
6
Musa, H.H., Chen, J. H., and Meki, D.M. (2006). Study on carcass characteristics of chicken breeds
raised under intensive conditions. International Journal of Poultry Science, 5: 530-533.
Ngoupayou, J.D. (1990). Country report on small-holder rural poultry production in Cameroon. In:
CTA seminar proceedings volume 2, small holder Rural Poultry Production, Thessaloniki,
Greece. Pp. 39-47.
Nwosu, C. C and Omeje, S. S. (1985). Improved annual egg production from Nigeria Local Chickens
by Goldline cross progeny. Nig. Journal of Animal Production, 12:161-164.
Nwosu, C. C., Gowen, F. A., Obioha, F. C., Akpan, I. A. and Onuora, G. I. (1985). Biometrical
Study of the conformation of the native chicken. Nig. Journal of Animal Production, 12:141 –
146.
Olori, V.E. (1992). Evaluation of Two Ecotype of Nigerian Indigenous chicken. (Unpublished) M.
Sc. Thesis, Obafemi AwolowoUniversity, Ile-Ife, Nigeria.
Oluyemi, J.A. and Ognmodede, B.K. (1979). Some physical characteristics of the indigenous fowl
and duck of the Nigeria. Journal of Genetics, 53-60.
Oladuntan Oladimeji (1999). The evaluation of residents’ satisfaction of public utilities in
Ogbomoso North local Government Area. (An undergraduate project, unpublished. Ladoke
Akintola University of Technology Ogbomoso Oyo State Pp 20-23. SAS, (1990). Statistical
Analysis system (SAS) institute inc. (1990). SAS/STAT User’s guide version 6, 4th edn, vol.
2 SAS Inst. Inc., cary, NC 846PP.
Soarce, P.R., Fonseca, J.B. and Silva, M.A. (1992). Performance of broilers of 4 commercial strains.
Animal breeding Abstract, 34: 361-366.
Sonaiya, E.B. (1997). African network on rural Poultry development: Progree report November 1989
to June 1995. Proc. Afr. Netw. Rural Poult. Dev. Workshop, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Pp. 134143.
7
Table 3. Genetic correlations between egg production characteristics in the straight and
crossbred genetic groups
Parameter
NF
NF
PPEN
PPEN
Na
PPEM
AVPPEW
AFE
WFE
0.98***
-0.78***
0.17
0.14
0.82***
0.14
0.18
-0.15
0.11
PPEM
NF
APPEW
AFE
PPEM
APPEW
0.97***
-1.13***
0.95***
PPEN
0.87***
PPEM
-0.77***
0.17
0.13
0.86***
0.08
0.23
PPEW
-0.22
AFE
0.87***
0.85***
Na
Na
PPEN
*P<0.05
mass
** P<0.01
***P<0.001 PPEN-part period egg number
APPEW-part period egg weight.
PPEM-part period egg
AFE- age at first egg. WFE-weight of first egg
AGB26
ECOTYPES OF INDIGENOUS CHICKENS IN SOKOTO SOUTH LOCAL GOVERNMENT
AREA: VARIATION IN WEIGHTS OF BIRDS AND EGGS
Usman, B. and Hassan, W.A.*
Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Usmanu Danfodiyo University, Sokoto
Corresponding e-mail:akinola19@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Fifteen (15) flocks of domestic fowls comprising 83 birds (42 hens, 9 cocks and 32 chicks) and 60
eggs were monitored in Gagi village between August and November 2001. The aim of the study was
to characterize the traditionally-managed native domestic fowl diversity in terms of variation in live
weight of adult birds and weight of eggs. Monitoring visits were paid to the flocks weekly during
which live weights of birds and egg weights were taken. Results of the study revealed that the mean
live weight of hens was 1.10±0.25kg. Hens that belong to the Red (Ja) strain were-significantly
heavier (P<0.05} than those of White (Fari) of Black/white (Wake-wake) strain. Live weight of a
8
hen was significantly influenced by its current reproductive phase (P<0.05). As such, live weight of
hens that were laying, incubating, and brooding averaged 1.15±0.30kg, 1.16±0.29kg, and
1.19±0.26kg, respectively. The mean live weight of cocks was 1.07±0.13kg. This value varied
significantly due to strain (P<0.05). Cocks of the Black/white plumage (Wake-wake) were
significantly heavier than those with Black (Baki), White (Fari) or Red (Ja) plumage. The mean live
weight of chicks at about 34 days of age was 59.3±26.8g. This value also varied significantly
between flocks (P<0.05). Mean weight of egg of the native chickens was 41.6±4.5g. No significant
differences in the weights of eggs as a result of strain and flock effects were recorded. The observed
significant effects of strain and flock on the live weights of hens and cocks, haphazard though, point
to some level of variation in the performance potential of the various strains and husbandry of local
chickens in the area.
INTRODUCTION
The main types of domestic poultry in Nigeria are chickens, pigeons, ducks, guinea fowls and
turkeys. Chickens are by the far the most important poultry species numerically (FDLPCS, 1992). In
this country, there has been a substantial development of commercial enterprises complementing
village poultry production. Nevertheless, poultry production is still dominated by peasants, who own
the birds in small numbers and raise them under what was variously described as extensive, low or
zero husbandry system (Matthewman, 1977). Earlier studies on traditional poultry production in
Sokoto State reported some baseline information on husbandry practices and flock composition
(Eshiett et al., 1988; Hassan et al., 1989; Otchere et al., 1993) and species combination (Okoro et al.,
1990) and reproductive performance (Hassan and Aliyu, 1996). The present study set out to
characterize the domestic fowls kept under the traditional system of management. Specifically, the
study aimed at assessing the birds under their natural rearing conditions using live weight and egg
weight as criteria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The present study was carried out in a random sample of households in Gagi in Sokoto South Local
Government of Sokoto State, Nigeria. Geographically, Gagi is located about three kilometres East of
Sokoto, the state capital. Sokoto lies in the Sudan savannah (Goh et al., 1975). It is characterized by
alternate rainy and dry seasons. The average annual rainfall is about 800 mm. The monthly
temperature is between 21°C and 40°C. Hamattan season stretches from November to March, when
there is dry and ladden wind accompanied with dust (Udo, 1970). The people of Gagi are Sulubawa
(Fulani) from Rikina in the present-day Dange Shuni Local Government.
After securing the permission of the District Head of Gagi, weekly visits were paid to the study
households for about three months. Before the monitoring visits, questionnaires were administered to
know the actual number of birds owned by each selected household and gain the consent of the
household head for flock performance monitoring. With the aid of the pre-prepared format, random
samples of domestic fowls in each household were monitored. The format covered items like bird
identification number, flock number, source of bird, sex of bird, date of hatching, strain (ecotype),
colour of feathers of wings and tail, comb type, shank colour and reproductive phase. One to five
birds were monitored per household. Birds were marked on the legs for identification. Weighing of
the birds was done using a 5-kg scale. Eggs of the monitored hens were weighed using a 1-kg
weighing scale. Information was also collected on the husbandry (housing feeding, and health care)
of the birds. Photographs were taken to illustrate the various strains of domestic fowls found in the
monitored flocks.
9
The data collected were collated for statistical analysis. Frequency, mean, standard deviation,
minimum and maximum values were calculated. Data on live weight and egg weight were subjected
to analysis of variance on a PC version of the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS, 1997).
The fixed effects included in the final model were strain, flock, and reproductive phase. Statistically
significant subclass means were separated using the Duncan's Multiple Range Test of the same data
analytical package..
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The overall mean live weight of hens was 1.10±0.20kg (Table 1). This value is almost similar to the
1.04kg reported for mature local domestic hens under three rearing systems in Central Mali (Wilson
et al., 1987), but higher than 0.89 kg reported for mature Desi hens in Bangladesh (Sazzad et al.,
1986). In agreement with Wilson et al. (1987), there were significant differences between the
weights of the hens in different phases of reproductive process. Thus, the resting hens (1.06±0.23kg)
were lighter than those that were laying (1.15±0.30kg), incubating (1.16±0.29kg) or brooding
(1.19±0.26kg). Wilson et al. (1987) got a comparable weight (1.17kg) for laying hens as obtained
from the present study. However, they reported smaller weights for incubating hens (0.85kg) and
brooding hens (0.94kg).
Among the strains of native chickens encountered in this study, the White (Fari) and Red (Ja). hens
(Plates I and II, respectively) were significantly heavier (P<0.05) than the remaining ones (Table 1).
The flock effect on body weight of hens was also found to be significant (P<0.05). As such, the hens
in flock No. 2 recorded the highest value (1.54±0.25kg) while those in flock No. 10 recorded the
lowest value (0.90±0.10kg) (Table 2). This is an indication of the variation in the level of husbandry
practices adopted by the keepers of the birds.
Table 3 shows the overall mean live weight of cock as 1.07±0.13kg. This value was higher than
0.80kg reported for mature local cocks in the tropics (Anthony et al., 1986), but lower than 1.60kg
reported for local cocks in Central Mali (Wilson et.al., 1987). Cocks of the Wake-wake (Plate III)
recorded the highest value for live weight (1.24±0.08 kg). This value was significantly higher than
those values recorded for the other strains (P<0.001). Generally, the live weights of hens and cocks
obtained from the present work fall within 0.9±1.8kg reported for mature indigenous) domestics
fowls in the tropics (Payne, 1990).
Table 1: Means, standard deviations, minimum and maximum values for live weight of hens
(kg) according to strain and reproductive phase
Characteristic
No. of
values
Mean
S.D.
Min
Max
Overall
368
1.100
0.254
0.600
1.900
Black (Baki)
93
1.063*
0.196
0.800
1.650
White (Fari)
39
1.204c
0.328
0.800
1.800
Silver (Kankara)
20
1.039a
0.185
0.800
1.400
Strain of hen)
10
69
0.979a
0.175
0.600
1.400
147
1.161bc
0.276
0.800
1.900
Incubating
34
1.155b
0.293
0.800
1.800
Brooding
74
1.189+c
0.258
0.800
1.860
Laying
23
1.151b
0.304
0.800
1.800
Resting
237
1.059a
0.232
0.600
1.900
Black/White (Wake-wake)
Red (Ja)
Reproductive phase of hen
*Means in the same column with same letters are not significantly different (P<0.05)
Table 2: Means, standard deviation, minimum and maximum values for live weight of hens
(kg) according to flock number
Characteristic
No. of values
Mean
S.D.
Min.
Max
Overall
364
1.102
0.254
0.600
1.900
1
30
1.107*
0.209
0.800
1.500
2
18
1.543g
0.247
1.000
1.860
3
20
1.498g
0.246
1.075
1.800
4
16
0.919b
0.259
0.600
1.200
5
50
0.988b
0.102
0.800
1.200
6
30
1.037c
0.117
0.800
1.270
7
50
1.058c
0.101
0.900
1.300
8
50
0.991b
0.146
0.800
1.400
9
18
1.144d
0.271
0.800
1.650
10
10
0.895a
0.101
0.800
1.100
11
20
0.920b
0.108
0.800
1.175
12
36
1.311f
0.298
1.100
1.900
13
10
1.182e
0.128
1.000
1.400
14
6
0.967b
0.137
0.800
1.100
Flock No.
*Means in the same column with same letters are not significantly different (P<0.05)
11
Table 3: Means and standard deviation for live weight of cocks (kg) according to strain
12
and flock number
Characteristic
No.
Mean
S.D
Min.
Max.
Overall
64
1.069
0.128
0.800
1.400
Black (Baki)
32
1.073a 0.132
0.800
1.300
White (Fari)
10
0.980a 0.092
0.900
1.100
6
1.241b 0.080
1.200
1.400
16
1.050a 0.089
0.800
1.100
4
10
1.030
0.108
0.800
1.100
5
10
1.120
0.079
1.000
1.200
6
20
1.020
0.110
0.900
1.200
11
16
1.112
0.185
0.800
1.400
12
8
1.075
0.046
1.000
1.100
Strain of cock
Black/White (Wake-wake)
Red (Ja)
Flock number of cock
*Means in the same column with same letters are not significantly different (P<0.05)
Plate III: The Black/White (Wake-wake) hen in Gagi
The live weight of chicks averaged 59.3±26.8g at about 34 days of age (Table 4). It was impossible
to obtain the age of the chicks at day old due largely to variation in the ages of the chicks at the start
of monitoring. Nevertheless, the 28.6g obtained for chicks that were younger than one week was
13
lower than 35g reported for day old chicks in the humid zone of Nigeria (Oluyemi and Roberts,
1979), but higher than 21.7g reported for day old chicks of local domestic fowls in Central Mali
(Wilson et al., 1987). The observed increase in the live weight of chicks with age is normally
physiological. The observed significant differences in live weights of chicks caused by strain and
flock effects (Table 4) need to be interpreted with care, because the chicks in the various classes and
sub-classes were of varying ages. This caution applies to the chicks', growth pattern as depicted in
Figure 1, though the continuous increase in gain up to the last week agrees with the trend reported
for local chicks at Nsukka (Nwosu and Asuquo, 1985). On-station performance evaluation of the
chicks will help to ascertain the true trend of these environmental and physiological events.
The overall mean weight of eggs of local domestic hens was 41.6±4.5g (Table 5). Previous studies
gave average egg weight of local domestic fowls as 43.9g (Hill and Modebe, 1961), 42.8g (Trail,
1962), 33.4g (Hertrampf, 1979), 34.4g (Wilson et al., 1987), 40.6g (Wilson, 1979) and 32.7g
(Akinokun, 1990). The value got from the present study fell on the upper limit of the range of the
earlier reported values. It is noteworthy however that no significant differences were recorded in the
weights of the eggs as a result of differences in strain and flock (P>0.05).
Table 4: Means and standard deviations for weight of chicks (g) according to strain of hen,
flock number and age group of chick
Characteristic
No. of
values
Mean
S.D.
Min.
Max
Overall
210
59.3
26.8
25
100
Black (Baki)
21
64.0b
9.8
50
80
Black/White (Wake-wake)
41
49.9a
19.4
25
75
148
61.2ab
29.6
25
100
1
22
32.7ab
5.5
25
42
2
36
36.9b
10.3
25
62
4
13
29.2a
4.9
25
40
5
44
72.8c
12.9
50
100
6
24
29.2a
4.0
25
35
7
19
69.7c
5.1
60
75
9
7
73.6c
3.8
70
80
10
45
95.1d
5.6
80
100
Strain of hen
Red (Ja)
Flock No.
Age of chick (week)
14
Less than 1
14
28.6a
13.4
25
75
1-4
85
47.9b
18.5
25
80
4-8
82
64.8c
27.3
25
100
Above 8
29
91.9d
7.8
70
100
*Means in the same column with same letters are not significantly different (P<0.05)
CONCLUSION
The values obtained for live weights of the various categories of domestic fowls and weight of eggs
from the present study have added to the baseline information on the performance of the Nigerian
native chickens under the traditional rearing conditions in the semi-arid zone of Nigeria. The
observed significant effects of strain and flock on the live weights of hens and cocks, haphazard
though, point to some level of variation in the performance potential of the various strains and
husbandry of local chickens in the area. These findings can be exploited for stock genetic
improvement. Investigation of the feeding regimes and health care practices adopted under the
traditional production system will be helpful in this direction.
Table 5: Means, standard deviations, minimum and maximum values for weight of eggs (g)
according to strain and flock number of hen
Characteristic
No. of
values
Mean
S.D.
Min.
Max
Overall
60
41.6
4.5
30.0
47.2
Black (Baki)
11
42.5
4.8
30.2
47.0
White (Fari)
4
42.2
2.2
40.2
45.2
Black/White (Wake-wake)
35
40.8
4.5
30.0
46.2
Red (Ja)
10
42.9
4.8
30.2
47.2
1
9
42.4
2.2
40.2
46.2
3
11
40.0
5.2
30.0
45.5
5
5
40.0
6.0
30.2
45.0
6
4
40.1
7.0
30.2
45.4
7
5
43.1
2.4
40.5
45.5
9
12
40.0
4.9
30.3
45.5
Strain of hen
Flock No. of hen
REFERENCES
15
Akinokun, O. (1990). An evaluation of exotic and indigenous chickens as genetic materials for
development of rural poultry production in Africa. In: Sonaiya. E.B. (Eds). Rural Poultry in
Africa. Proceedings of an International Workshop on Rural Poultry Development in Africa,
African Network on Rural Poultry Development, c/o Department of Animal Science, Obafemi
Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria, pp 56-61.
Eshiett, N. O., Hassan, W. A., Duru, S. and Fajinmi, A. O. (1988). Guinea-fowl production in Sokoto
State: A case study of Dundaye District. A paper presented at the 24th annual conference of the
Agricultural Society of Nigeria held at the University of Benin, 4 - 7 September.
FDLPCS (1992). Federal Department of Livestock and Pest Control Service. Nigerian Livestock
Resources, Vol. II. National Synthesis. Resource Inventory Management Limited. UK., 287 pp.
Goh, C. L. and Oherwerei, A. (1975). Certificate Physical and Human Geography. Longman. UK.,
160 pp.
Hassan, W. A. and Aliyu, A. T. (1996). Reproductive performance of ducks in semi-arid northern
Nigeria, African Network for Rural Poultry Development (ANRPD) Newsletter, Vol. 6 No.1: 45.
Hassan, W. A., Pemida, O. F. and Fajinmi, A. O. (1989). Some aspects of poultry production at
village level in Northwest, Nigeria. In: Sonaiya, E.B. (Ed). Rural Poultry in Africa.
Proceedings of an International Workshop on Rural Poultry Development in Africa. African
Network on Rural Poultry Development, c/o Department of Animal Science, Obafemi
Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria, pp 205-209.
Hertrampf, J. (1979). Die Gefluegelwirtschaft Nigerias. Deutsche Gefluegelwirtschaft and
Schweineproduktion, 31, 40: 121-128 [FDLPCS, 1992].
Hill, D. H. and Modebe, A. N. A. (1961). Poultry production at the University College, Ibadan
(1950-1958) University of Ibadan, Faculty of Agriculture, Technical Bulletin No. 2, pp 35
[Akinokun, 1990].
Kuit, H. G., Traore, A and Wilson, R. T. (1986). Livestock Production in central Mali: Ownership,
management and productivity of poultry in the traditional sector. Trop. Anim. Hlth Prod., 18:
222-231.
Matthewman, R. W. (1977). A Survey of Small Livestock Production at village level in the Savanna
and Lowland Forest Zones of South West Nigeria. Study No. 24. Department of Agriculture
and Horticulture, University of Reading, pp 49 - 63.
Nwosu, C. C. and Asuquo, B. O. (1985). Live weight improvement in the local chicken. In: Olomu,
J. M., Osinowo, O. A., Ikhatua, U. J., Taiwo, B. B. A. and Jagun, A. G. B. (Eds.) (1985).
Revitalising Animal Production in Nigeria. Proceedings of the tenth annual conference of the
Nigerian Society for Animal Production, held at the University of Ife, Ile-Ife, March 24th 27th, pp 23 - 29.
Okoro, S. P. A., Hassan, W. A., Abubakar, M. M. and Abdullahi, A. (1990). Smallholder poultry
production in Sokoto State: Flock composition. Paper read at the 26th annual conference of the
Agricultural Society of Nigeria, University of Agriculture, Makurdi, September 2-5.
Oluyemi, J. A. and Roberts, F. A. (1979). Poultry Production in warm wet Climates (Revised ed.).
Spectrum Books Ltd, 244 pp.
Otchere, E. O., Hassan, W. A., Mohammed, A. K., Ndubuisi, A. H., Gefu, J. O. and Okoro, S. P. A.
(1992). Poultry production under village conditions: Case studies in Sokoto and Kaduna States.
16
In: Proceedings, Livestock Systems Research Workshop, National Livestock Projects Division,
July, Kaduna.
Payne, W. J. A. (1990). An Introduction to Animal husbandry in the Tropics (4th Ed.), Longman
Scientific and Technical, 881 pp.
Sazzad, M. H., Mamotazul, M. H. and Asaduzzaman, M. D. (1986). Growth pattern of Desi
(indigenous) and crossbred chicks under rural scavenging conditions. Proceedings of the first
annual seminar ofthe Livestock Research Institute, Saver, Bangladesh, 280 pp.
SPSS (1993). Statistical Package for the Social Sciences. SPSS for Windows, Version 6.1
Trail, I. C. M. (1962). The indigenous poultry of Uganda. I. Growth rate and food consumption
compared with European breeds. Empire J. Expt. Agric., 31: 317 [Akinokun, 1990].
Udo, J. A. (1970). Geographical Regions of Nigeria. Longman, 280 pp.
Wilson, R. T. (1979). Studies of the livestock in South Darfur, Sudan. VII. Production of poultry
under simulated traditional conditions. Trop. Anim. Hlth Prod., 11: 143-150.
Wilson, R. T., Traore, A, Kuit, H. G. and Slingerland, M. (1987). Livestock production in Central
Mali: Reproduction, growth and mortality of domestic fowl under traditional management.
Trop. Anim. Hlth Prod., 19: 229-236.
ENVIRONMENTAL GENETICS (EG)
EG01
BEHAVIOURAL RESPONSE OF INTENSIVELY MANAGED WEST AFRICAN DWARF
GOATS TO VARIATIONS IN DIURNAL TEMPERATURE
Popoola M.A.*, Bolarinwa, M.O., Aderinlewo, A.Y. and Ishola, M.A.
Federal College of Animal Health and Production Technology, P.M.B 5029, Moor Plantation,
Ibadan.
Corresponding e-mail: popoola_abiola@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Response of intensively managed West African dwarf goats at different daily ambient temperature
was evaluated. 12 goats were used for the study. Temperature and relative humidity in the goat pen
were monitored across seasons (rain and dry) and across day periods (minimum temperature in the
morning and maximum temperature in the afternoon) using thermo-hygrometer to compare
parameters in normal and heat stress conditions. Activities of the animals were observed and
classified as eating, ruminating, standing and lying. Data collected were analysed using inferential
statistics of Chi-square test. Summary statistics for climatic variations were also calculated within
each season. The animals were found lying more than standing during the cool hours of the day
17
while they were seen standing more during the hot hours of the day; the animals ate more during the
cool hours of the day and ruminated less during this period but during hot hours of the day, they ate
less and ruminated more The result obtained in this experiment support the hypothesis that goats
behavioural responses are useful indicators of heat stress in terms of changes in diurnal ambient
temperature.
Keywords: Behavioural response, climatic variation, diurnal temperature, seasons
INTRODUCTION
West African Dwarf (WAD) goats are found in large number in the Southern part of Nigeria, they
possess the widest margin of adaptation amongst the ruminants (Oni, 2003). They are small, hardy,
early maturing, prolific, non-seasonal breeders (Osuagwuh and Akpodje, 1982) and are
trypanosome-tolerant (Ozoje, 2002). However, WAD goats are exposed to stressful climatic
conditions in tropical regions, which influence their productivity and welfare. In such regions, high
temperature and relative humidity are major environmental factors that result in heat stress which in
turn influence the productivity and physiological development of animals (McNitt et al., 2000; Marai
et al., 2002a). This effect is aggravated when heat stress is accompanied by high ambient humidity
(Marai et al., 2000a; Abdel-Hafez, 2002). Climatic conditions in these regions are such that the
warm hot season is relatively long with intense radiant energy for an extended period of time
accompanied with high relative humidity. The environment surrounding an animal at any particular
instant influences the amount of heat exchange between it and the environment. It has been reported
that acclimation of domesticated ruminants to heat stress imposes behavioural, physiological and
metabolic adjustments to reduce the strain and enhances the likelihood of surviving the stress; it also
frequently reduces their performance and compromises their health (Bernabucci et al., 2010).
Although many animals have special heat loss mechanisms that enable them control their body
temperature, such as sweating or panting, these activities involve the use of stored energy and water.
Modifications of behaviour patterns or behavioral thermoregulation, however, may be adequate to
enable an animal to maintain acceptable comfort levels without involving these mechanisms
(Bradley, 2008). Animals respond to thermal stress in different ways, between species, breeds and
between individual within a breed. Therefore, there is a need to develop a simple, most practical,
easy and relatively trust worthy non- invasive means of assessing the potential of an animal that is
able to maintain expression of its inherited functional trait during when raised under hot conditions,
either when introduced to a new locality or for selection for heat tolerance. Thus, this study sought to
evaluate interaction of change in diurnal ambient temperature and behaviour of WAD goats under
hot humid conditions.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted at the Teaching and Research Farm of the Federal College of Animal
Health and Production Technology, Ibadan Nigeria, between December, 2012 and May, 2013.
Temperature and relative humidity in the goat unit were monitored across seasons (rain and dry) and
across day periods (minimum temperature in the morning and maximum temperature in the
afternoon) two to three days using a DeltaTrak thermo-hygrometer. As far as possible, this
instrument was hung on the wall inside the pen to provide a record of the temperature and relative
humidity experienced by the goats.
Based on the recordings of farm ambient temperature and relative humidity, the study was conducted
during rainy and dry seasons to compare parameters in normal and heat stress conditions. Months of
December, 2012 to February, 2013 were considered as the dry season, while the months of March,
2013 to May, 2013 were considered as the rainy season periods. Activities of the animals were
observed and classified on the basis of visual observation of animal behaviour as follows: eating,
ruminating, standing and lying. Behavioural observations were recorded for 3 hours during the cool
period of the day as well as during the hot periods of the day; this was done twice a week. The cool
part of the day for this study was considered to be 6:30 am, whilst the hot part of the day was
18
determined by taking ambient temperature readings at an hour intervals from 6:30am to 5:30pm daily
over three continuous days and the hot part of the day was found to be 1:00pm.
Data collected were analysed by the Statistical Analytical Software (SAS, 2004) using inferential
statistics test Chi-square test to test the hypotheses stated for the study (the association between
behaviour of WAD goats and variation in diurnal ambient temperature). The summary statistics for
climatic variations were also calculated within each season.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The average temperature and relative humidity in the pen during cool and hot hours of the day across
the two seasons of the study are presented in Table 1. The climatic data obtained in wet season
differed from the data obtained in the dry season. Values obtained for ambient temperature during
the cool period (AM) and hot period (PM) of the day in the rainy season were less than that obtained
during these periods in the dry season. However, relative humidity during cool and hot periods in the
rainy season was higher than that of dry season.
Table 1. Mean temperature and relative humidity in the pen during cool (AM) and hot hours (PM) of
the day across seasons
Farm ambient temperature (oC)
Farm ambient relative humidity (%)
Seasons
AM
PM
AM
PM
Rain
23.62 ± 0.56
28.88± 1.23
84.50 ± 0.95
55.80 ±1.12
Dry
25.63±0.97
31.70 ± 1.35
63.70 ±1.03
49.30± 0.56
Table 2 shows the results of the degree of relationship between the goats’ posture and rising diurnal
temperature. There was significant difference (P< 0.001) between the animals’ posture and change in
diurnal ambient temperature. The animals were found lying more than standing during the cool hours
of the day while they were seen standing more during the hot hours of the day. This result agreed
with report of (Nazan et al., 2009) in a comparative study between heat stress ability of pigmented
and unpigmented goats that unpigmented goats stood (0.8 vs. 1.2 h) less, but lay down (2.2 vs. 1.8 h)
more than pigmented goats.
Table 2. Degree of association between behavioral response (standing and lying) of WAD goats and
rising diurnal temperature
Behavioral responses
Diurnal
Standing N (%)
periods
Lying N (%)
Overall N (%)
P-value
0.001
Test
AM
201 (34.9)
375 (65.1)
576 (100)
PM
222 (38.5)
354 (61.5)
576 (100)
N=Number of observation, χ2=Chi-square, AM = cool hours, PM = hot hours
χ2
42.75
There was significant difference (P<0.001) between the goats eating pattern and change in ambient
diurnal temperature .The animals ate more during the cool hours of the day and ruminated less
during this period but during hot hours of the day, they ate less and ruminated more (Table 3).
Similar results were reported in earlier studies; that as temperature increased; less time was spent
consuming food, probably to minimize or curtail body heat production and to keep the body cool
(Ogebe et al., 1996) WAD goats have reduced rumination rates during rainy season when compared
to that of dry season due to smaller amount of forage ingested, inducing a smaller absorption of
nutrients. Hirayama, (2004) also reported that, time spent by goats eating in the heat treatment was
19
highest, while ruminating time was the lowest, indicating that stressed goats ate more but ruminated
less than non-stressed goats.
Table 3. Degree of association between behavioral response (eating and ruminating) of WAD goats
and rising diurnal temperature
N=N
Behavioral responses
umbe
Diurnal
Eating N (%)
Ruminating Overall N
Test
r of
periods
N (%)
(%)
2
obser
P-value χ
vatio
AM
357 (62.0)
219 (38.0)
576 (100)
0.001
54.05
n,
PM
250(43.4)
326 (56.6)
576 (100)
2
χ =C
hi-square, AM = cool hours, PM = hot hours
CONCLUSION
Exposure of goats to change in daily ambient temperature resulted in significant change in
behaviuoral responses in terms of their activities - standing, lying, change in feeding pattern (eating
and ruminating). Hence, these are useful indicators of heat stress as reflected in the animal behaviour
in response to changes in diurnal ambient temperature.
REFERENCES
Abdel-Hafez, M.A.M. (2002). Studies on the reproductive performance in sheep. Ph.D. thesis.
Faculty of Agriculture, Zagazig University, Zagazig, Egypt.
Bernabucci, U., Lacetera, N., Baumgard, L.H., Rhoads, R.P., Ronchi, B. and Nardone, A. (2010).
Metabolic and hormonal acclimation to heat stress in domesticated ruminants. The Animal
Consortium, 4: 1167–1183
Bradley, A.S. (2008). Comparison of thermoregulatory mechanisms in Heat sensitive and tolerant
breeds of bos Taurus Cattle. M.Sc. Thesis Faculty of the Graduate School, University of
Missouri – Columbia. Pp 11-13. Accessed online from http://mospace.umsystem.edu on 25th/
January 2013.
Hirayama, T. and Katoh, K. (2004). Effects of heat exposure and restricted feeding on behaviour,
digestibility and growth hormone secretion in goats. Asian-Aust. J. Anim. Sci., 17(5): 655658.
Marai I.F.M, Bahgat, L.B., Shalaby, T.H. and Abdel-Hafez, M.A. (2000). Fattening performance,
some Behavioural traits and physiological reactions of male lambs fed concentrates mixture
alone with or without natural clay, under hot summer of Egypt. Ann. Arid Zone, 39 (4): 449–
460.
Marai, I.F.M.., Habeeb, A.A.M. and Gad, A.E. (2002a). Rabbits’ productive, reproductive and
physiological performance traits as affected by heat stress: a review. Livest. Prod. Sci., 78:
71–90.
Mcnitt J.I., Pattton N.M., Lukefahr S.D. and Cheeke P.R. (2000). Rabbit production. Interstate
Publishers (seventh edition) Danville, IL pp 493.
Nazan K. D., Soner, C. and Serap, G.K. (2009). The Effects of Skin Pigmentation on Physiological
Factors of Thermoregulation and Grazing Behaviour of Dairy Goats in a Hot and Humid
Climate. Asian-Aust. J. Anim. Sci., 22 (5): 727 – 731.
Ogebe, P. O., Ogunmodede, B.K. and McDowell, L.R (1996). Behavioral and physiological
responses of Nigerian dwarf goats to seasonal changes of the humid tropics. Small Rumin
Res., 22: 213-217.
Oni, O.O. (2003). Breeds and genetic improvement of small ruminants (sheep and goats). A paper
presented at the training workshop on small ruminant production, NAPRI, ABU, Shikka,
Nigeria January 16-18th, 2003.
20
Osuagwuh, A.I.A. and Akpodje, J.U. (1982). West African Dwarf goat 1. Causes of early mortality.
Int. J. of Goat and Sheep Research. 1: 303-309.
Ozoje, M.O. (2002). Incidence and relative effects of qualitative traits in West African Dwarf goats.
Small Ruminant Research. 43: 97-100.
SAS (2004). Statistical analysis system user’s Guide (Release 8.03). SAS Institute, Cary North
Carolina, USA.
EG02
TOLERANCE MECHANISMS IN PTERIDOPHYTES (FERNS) AND THEIR USE AS
REMEDIATORS OF HEAVY METAL CONTAMINATED SITES
Akomolafe G. F.*, Dedeke, O. A. and Sirajo S. A.
Department of Botany, Federal University Lafia, PMB 146, Lafia, Nasarawa State, Nigeria
*Corresponding email: gfakomolafe@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Pteridophytes (ferns) are lower plants with no well developed vascular bundle, yet they have shown
high potentials in remediating heavy metals contaminated soils due to their inherent biological
characteristics. They have ability to hyperaccumulate heavy metals such as Arsenic, Lead, Nickel,
Chromium and Mercury in the soil and at the same beautify the contaminated site. Understanding the
tolerance mechanisms of ferns would be helpful for using them to remediate heavy metal polluted
sites (pterido-remediation). It is cost effective, environmental friendly and aesthetically pleasing
approach which makes it suitable for developing countries. Therefore, Pterido-remediation is an
effective tool or technology for cleaning up soil contaminated with heavy metals. Despite this, it is
yet to become a commercially available technology in Nigeria. This paper provides a review of some
ferns reported as excellent in removal of heavy metals from the soil and the molecular and
physiological mechanisms that enable them tolerate these heavy metals. Benefits, limitations and
factors influencing phytoremediation were also reviewed.
Key words: fern, heavy metals, hyperaccumulation, pterido-remediation, soil
INTRODUCTION
Ferns are non-flowering vascular plants which appeared in the fossil record around 400 million years
ago (Kenrick and Crane, 1997). They are a group of about 9000 – 12000 species of plants classified
in the Division Pteridophyta (Kartesz, 1994). Ferns are quite successful plants which grow as
perennial or annual herbs, trees, epiphytes, aquatic or terrestrial plants. They differ from primitive
thallophytes by having true leaves called megaphylls. Ferns also differ from gymnosperms and
angiosperms by being seedless. Like all other vascular plants, ferns exhibit alternation of generation
characterized by a diploid sporophytic and haploid gametophytic phases (Bierhorst, 1971). The
distribution of ferns is similar to that of the mosses. They occur almost in all habitats but are most
abundant in moist, montane forests, along streams and rivers most especially in the tropics (Agnew,
1974). Many ferns also grow within specific PH ranges; for instance the climbing fern Lygodium will
only grow in moist, intensely acid soils, while the bulblet bladder fern, Cystopteris bulbifera is only
found on limestone (Bierhorst, 1971). In Nigeria, ferns occur abundantly in rainfall belt of the south
(Odu and Opapeju, 1986).
Bioindicators are plant species, substances or chemicals used to monitor pollutants of an
environment or ecosystem. They are any biological species or group of substances whose functions,
population or status could be used to determine ecosystem or environmental integrity (Rasheed,
21
2010). The principle behind the bioindicator approach is the analysis of an organism heavy metals
contents and compared the metal concentration with the soil metal levels. However,
phytoremediation is the process of decontaminating or cleaning of soil and water by using plants to
absorb heavy metals or other pollutants. It is an emerging plant- based technology and has been
receiving increased attention. The pre-requisite for successful phytoremediation is the existence of
hyperaccumulator in some plants which are able to accumulate large amount of the metal
contaminants in their above ground tissues with a high biomass (Mrittunjai et al., 2005). Salt et al.
(1998) referred to the method of using green plants to detoxify or remediate heavy metals
contaminated soil sites as phytoextraction. The term ‘hyperaccumulator’ was first used to describe a
plant species that hyperaccumulate nickel (Jaffre et al., 1976). The term was later broadened to
characterize plants achieving metal concentration greater than 1000 mg/kg (Reeves and Baker,
2000).
In general, Mosses, liverworts and ferns are also capable of growing on metal-enriched substrates.
These plants possess anatomical and physiological characteristics enabling them to occupy unique
ecological niches in natural metalliferous and manmade environments. For example, groups of
specialized bryophytes called ‘copper mosses’ are found on Cu enriched substrates and come from
widely separated taxonomic groups. Other bryophytes are associated with lead and zinc enriched
substrates. Pteridophytes (ferns) are associated with serpentine substrates in various parts of the
world. Brake fern, Pteris vittata, a fast growing plant is reported to tolerate soils contaminated with
arsenic as much as 1500 ppm and its fronds concentrate the toxic metal to 22,630 ppm in 6 weeks
(Ma et al., 2001).
The objective of this paper is to provide a review of some pteridophytes that are found to be efficient
in remediating heavy metal contaminated sites, the molecular and physiological mechanisms of their
tolerance to heavy metals uptake, the benefits, limitations and factors influencing phytoremediation.
HYPERACCUMULATION AND PTERIDOREMEDIATION
Hyperaccumulation can be defined as uptake and sequestration of exceptional concentration of an
element in aboveground parts of a plant under field conditions (Pollard, 2000). Hence, the threshold
metal content used to define a hyperaccumulator depends upon the particular metal accumulated. For
instance, proposed thresholds on a dry weight basis are 100 µg/g for cadmium, 1000 µg/g for cobalt,
copper, nickel and lead while 10,000 µg/g is for manganese and zinc (Baker and Brooks, 1989).
Once the metals are taken up, they are concentrated in less sensitive locations such as vacuoles, cell
walls, epidermal cells and trichomes (Boyd et al., 2000). The key process of pteridoremediation is
the rate of metal removal that depends upon the biomass harvested and metal concentration in
harvested biomass. A large number of hyperaccumulators are known mostly for nickel, zinc and
selenium whereas most widespread and hazardous soil pollutants are arsenic, lead, cadmium often
occurring in combination with other metals (Kraner, 2000). The process of hyperaccumulation of
heavy metals by ferns is a complex phenomenon. It involves several steps, such as (a)
transport of metals across the plasma membrane of root cells; (b) xylem loading and
translocation; and (c) detoxification and sequestration of metals at the whole plant and
cellular levels (Lombi et al., 2002).
Unlike angiosperms, fern hyperaccumulators are equipped with inherent biological characteristics
that could be exploited in the phytoremediation strategies aimed at decontaminating polluted sites.
For instance, Asplenium adylterium is an indicator and hyperaccumulator of nickel (Vogt, 1942)
while Asplenium septentrionale is an hyperaccumulator of lead and copper (Page, 1988). Sela et al.
(1989) reported some aquatic ferns such as Azolla filliculoides which were able to hyperaccumulate
heavy metals in their shoots. Other ferns with metal accumulating capabilities include Salvinia
22
natans, for copper and S. minima for chromium (Sen and Mondal, 1990). Other than heavy metals,
ferns have also been known to concentrate large quantities of trace elements in their tissues
(Woolson et al., 1971). Hyperaccumulation of arsenic was discovered only recently, and the majority
of plants that hyperaccumulate arsenic are fern species. First was Pteris vittata L. (Ma et al., 2001);
followed Pityrogramma calomelanos L. (Francesconi et al., 2002) and many other species of the
Pteris genus such as P. cretica L., P. longifolia L., P. umbrosa L., P. argyraea L. (Zhao et al., 2002),
P. quadriaurita L., P. ryiunkensis L. and, P. biaurita (Srivastava et al., 2005).
The phylogenetic relationship of ferns has been established based on the ability to hyperaccumulate
arsenic. Plants that can hyperaccumulate arsenic were said to have arrived relatively late in fern
evolution and might have evolved in arsenic-rich environment (Meharg, 2002). Many plants have
been reported to accumulate more than 1000 mg/kg arsenic in their tissues (Porter and Peterson,
1975). However, they cannot be classified as hyperaccumulators since arsenic accumulation in these
plants occur very slowly over an extended period of time. In addition, a large portion of the arsenic is
sequestered in the roots. Most importantly, a lack of rapid growth, large biomass production and high
uptake capacity render these plants unsuitable for phytoremediation (Meharg, 2002). A plant that
accumulates a minimum arsenic concentration of 1000 mg/kg in the aboveground biomass and has a
higher concentration in the aboveground than in both roots and the soil is said to be arsenic
hyperaccumulator (Bombada and Ma, 2003).
Komar et al. (1998) reported the first known arsenic hyperaccumulating plant, Pteris vitata L. also
known as Chinese brake fern from a site that was contaminated from pressure – treating lumber
using chromated – copper- arsenate (CCA). P. vittata was also found to hyperaccumulate up to
60,000 mg/kg of arsenic in Nigeria which is more than the ones ever reported in literatures (Oloyede
et al., 2013). Ma et al. (2001) also reported three cultivars of Pteris cretica i.e albolineata, mayii and
parkerii as arsenic hyperaccumulators with concentrations ranging from 1114 to 2046 mg/kg.
Mrittunjai et al. (2005) identified additional new arsenic hyperaccumulating ferns (Pteris biaurita, P.
quadriaurita and P. ryukyuensis) and reconfirmed P. vitata as an hyperaccumulator. P. longifolia,
and P. umbrosa were also identified as hyperaccumulators by Ma et al. (2001).
SOURCES OF HEAVY METAL POLLUTION
Geological and anthropogenic activities are sources of heavy metal contamination (Dembitsky,
2003). Sources of anthropogenic metal contamination include industrial effluents, fuel production,
mining, smelting processes, military operations, utilization of agricultural chemicals, small-scale
industries (including battery production, metal products, metal smelting and cable coating
industries), brick kilns and coal combustion (Zhen-Guo et al., 2002). Arsenic is a major contaminant
of soil and water around the world. It is a by-product of many mining processes and has been used
extensively in pesticide industry and until recently, was widely used as a wood preservative (Azcue
et al., 1994). Man made sources of the world environmental arsenic production has been estimated as
follows: about 70% in the preservation of timber, 22% in agricultural chemicals / pesticides and the
remainder in pharmaceutical products, glass and non-ferrous alloys. Of these, mining, smelting of
non-ferrous metals and burning of fossil fuels are the major industrial processes that contribute to
anthropogenic arsenic contamination of air, water and soil (Jalal, 2008).
There are a variety of industrial processes that involve the use of lead such as mining, smelting,
manufacture of pesticides and fertilizers, dumping of municipal sewage and the burning of fossil
fuels that contain a lead additive. Many commercial products and materials also contain lead
including paints, ceramic glazes, television glass, ammunition, batteries, medical equipment (i.e., xray shields, fetal monitors), and electrical equipment. Lead battery recycling sites, of which 29 have
been labeled Superfund sites, and manufacturers use more than 80% of the lead produced in the
23
United States. On average, recycled lead products only satisfy half of the nation’s lead requirements
(Meagher, 1998).
Table 1: Summary of some ferns used as hyperaccumulators of heavy metals
S/N
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
SPECIES
Adiantum caudatum L.
A. philippense
Angiopteris erecta
Asplenium adylterium
A. septentrionale
Azolla filiculoides
Colysis pothifolia
Lindsea ensifolia
Pteridium aquilium
Pteris biaurita
P. venusta
P. vittata
P. cretica
P. longifolia
P. umbrosa
P. argyraea
P. quadriaurita
P. ryukyuensis
P. biaurita
P. mayii
P. parkerii
P. albolineata
Pityrogramma calomelanos
Lygodium spp
Tectaria impressa
T. herpetocaulos
SOURCE
Supaporn et al., 2008
Supaporn et al., 2008
Supaporn et al., 2008
Vogt 1942
Page 1998
Sela 1989
Supaporn et al., 2008
Supaporn et al., 2008
Supaporn et al., 2008
Supaporn et al., 2008
Supaporn et al., 2008
Ma et al., 2001; Komar et al.,
1998
Zhao et al., 2002
Zhao et al., 2002
Zhao et al., 2002
Zhao et al., 2002
Srivastava et al., 2005
Srivastava et al., 2005
Srivastava et al., 2005
Ma et al., 2001
Ma et al., 2001
Ma et al., 2001
Francesconi et al., 2002
Supaporn et al., 2008
Supaporn et al., 2008
Supaporn et al., 2008
MECHANISMS OF TOLERANCE OF HEAVY METALS BY FERNS
Understanding the effects of heavy metals on ferns and the tolerance mechanisms would be helpful
for using them to remediate heavy metal polluted sites. Plants growing on metal-contaminated sites
need to develop some degree of tolerance to metal toxicity in order to survive. Since all plants
contain at least some metal in their tissues, they clearly are incapable of completely excluding
potentially toxic elements, but simply of restricting their uptake and/or translocation. Ferns growing
on metal-contaminated sites need to develop some degree of tolerance to metal toxicity in order to
survive. Tolerance to metals can either be achieved by avoiding the metal stress, by tolerating it or
both (Levitt, 1980). Avoidance by exclusion is the most common mechanism of plant adaptation to
metal toxicity. It depends on various kinds of reduced metal uptake: (i) by deposition in cell wall
components; and (ii) by chelate secretion (Meharg, 2002). Tolerance to metal stress relies on plant
capacity to detoxify metals having entered cells. The mechanisms for metal tolerance proposed are:
(a) metal sequestration by specially produced organic compounds; (b) compartmentalization in
certain cell compartments; (c) metal ion efflux; (d) organic ligand exudation. Plant protection against
metal toxicity involves, with others, the control of root metal uptake and of long distance metal
24
transport. Inside cells, proteins such as ferritins, metallothioneins and phytochelatins and related
peptides, participate in excess metal storage and detoxification, together with low molecular weight
organic molecules, mainly organic acids and amino acids and their derivatives. When these systems
are overloaded, oxidative stress defense mechanisms are activated. The naturally tolerant ferns which
hyperaccumulate metals form the basis for investigations on the improvement of metal resistance
(Briat and Lebrun, 1999). The largest group of metal resistance systems function by energydependent efflux of toxic ions (Silver and Phung, 1996).
Metallothioneins are small proteins that sequester excess amounts of certain metal ions. Their
synthesis is transcriptionally activated by metal ions. Plant metallothioneins have received little
attention until it was reported that plants indeed contain functional metallothionein homologs. Two
Arabidopsis thaliana cDNAs, named MT1 and MT2, share all the structural characteristics of yeast
metallothioneins (Zhou and Goldsbrough, 1994). Since then, three protein bands, corresponding to
six MT genes, have been isolated from Arabidopsis, and the amino acids sequenced for nine
fragments (Rauser, 1999). The term phytochelatin (PC) have been given to a unique family of thiol
containing metal-binding polypeptides derived from glutathione (GSH) (Rauser, 1990). Maitani et al.
(1996) used root cultures of Rubia tinctorum and confirmed that arsenic, lead and mercury induced
PCs. The analysis of a PC-deficient mutant of Arabidopsis showed a detoxifying role for PCs against
mercury (Howden and Cobbett, 1992). Exposure to excess of arsenate and arsenite induced the
biosynthesis of phytochelatins in vivo and in vitro in ferns.
The rapid induction of the metal-binding PCs has been reported in cell suspension cultures of
Rauvolfia serpentina, in seedlings of Arabidopsis, and in enzyme preparations of Silene vulgaris. Gel
filtration studies and inhibition studies have demonstrated the complexation and detoxification of
arsenic by the induced PCs (Schmöger et al., 2000). Furthermore, activities of PC-deficient mutants
of Arabidopsis and Schizosaccharomyces pombe showed an increased sensitivity towards arsenate
(Ha et al., 1999). Conversely, the over expression of a plant PC synthase in S. pombe resulted in
increased resistance to arsenite and arsenate (Vatamaniuk et al., 1999). Mercury-stressed (1–10 mg/l)
plant cells showed increased activities of antioxidants like superoxide dismutase and catalase in
varying degrees and presented a positive endogenous protection effect. However, the protection
effect disappeared at higher levels (50 mg/l).
Ferns exhibit considerable constitutional tolerance to heavy metals and, in some cases, it reaches
levels of inducible tolerance (Wierzbicka, 1999). Constitutional tolerance to heavy metals shows that
after an initial phase in which lead is toxic to cells, defense processes appear. Lead in the root
symplast is detoxified in vacuoles, cell walls and dictyosomal vesicles. Initial cells of the meristem
(quiescent centre) which plays a basic role in root regeneration processes are protected against lead
penetration. This is in agreement with the absence of any symptoms of lead poisoning in ferns
growing in natural conditions, and suggests that there is a defense mechanism specific only to plant
cells (Wierzbicka, 1995). The mechanism of tolerance of ferns to heavy metals may involve one or
more of the several methods suggested for metal tolerance like binding of metal to cell wall material
(Cumming and Taylor, 1990); complex-formation with organic acids and then removal to the
vacuole (Godbold et al., 1984); and binding to specific thiol-rich proteins or phytochelatins
(Lolkema et al., 1984; Rauser, 1984).
INFLUENCE OF ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS ON PTERIDO-REMEDIATION
A variety of environmental factors affects or alters the mechanisms of pterido-remediation. Soil type
and organic matter content can limit the bioavailability of petroleum contaminants. Water content in
soil and wetlands affects plant/microbial growth and the availability of oxygen required for aerobic
respiration. Temperature affects the rates at which various processes take place. Nutrient
availability can influence the rate and extent of degradation in oil-contaminated soil. Finally,
sunlight can transform parent compounds into other compounds, which may have different toxicities
25
and bioavailability than the original compounds (Frick et al., 1999). Some of the environmental
factors are discussed briefly below.
Soil Structure, Texture, and Organic Matter Content
Soil type is defined according to various characteristics including structure, texture, and organic
matter content. In terms of the influence of soil structure, Alexander et al. (1997) identified that
phenanthrene may be trapped within and sorbed to the surfaces of nanopores (Soil pores with
diameters < 100 nm) that are inaccessible to organisms (i.e., not bioavailable). Soil texture can also
affect pterido-remediation efforts by influencing the bioavailability of the contaminant. For
example, clay is capable of binding molecules more readily than silt or sand (Brady and Weil, 1996).
As a result, the bioavailability of contaminants may be lower in soils with high clay contents. Soil
organic matter binds lipophilic compounds, thereby reducing their bioavailability (Cunningham et
al., 1996). A high organic carbon content (>5%) in soil usually leads to strong adsorption and,
therefore, low availability, while a moderate organic carbon content (1 to 5%) may lead to limited
availability (Otten et al., 1997).
Water and Oxygen Availability
Water and oxygen are important to the general health of plants and microbes (Eweis et al., 1998).
Water is not only a major component of living organisms, it also serves as a transport medium to
carry nutrients to biota and carry wastes away. If the moisture content of the soil is low, there will be
a loss of microbial activity and dehydration of ferns. Too much moisture results in limited gas
exchange and the creation of anoxic zones where degradation is dominated by anaerobic
microorganisms. Interestingly, oxygen may be provided to the rhizosphere as a plant exudate. The
extent of oxygen-transfer from the root depends on the type of plant (Vance 1996).
Temperature
Temperature affects the rates at which the various mechanisms of pterido-remediation take place. In
general, the rate of microbial degradation or transformation doubles for every 10 °C increase in
temperature (Eweis et al., 1998). In an experiment involving oil bioremediation in salt marsh
mesocosms, degradation of applied hydrocarbons averaged 72% during summer compared to 56%
during winter, even though the winter exposure was day’s longer (Wright et al., 1997). The seasonal
difference was thought to be the result of a difference in temperature between the warm summer and
cool winter periods.
Nutrients
Adequate soil nutrients are required to support the growth of ferns and their associated
microorganisms. This may be especially true during pterido-remediation efforts, when the
plant/microbe community is already under stress from the contaminant. Xu and Johnson (1997) have
shown that soil contaminants can significantly reduce the availability of plant nutrients in soil. Low
nutrient availability results from the fact that petroleum hydrocarbons have high carbon contents, but
are poor suppliers of nitrogen and phosphorus. As soil microorganisms degrade the soil organic
carbon, they use up or immobilize available nutrients (i.e. nitrogen and phosphorus) creating nutrient
deficiencies in contaminated soil. Biederbeck et al. (1993) found that, following initial applications
of an oily waste sludge to sandy soil, the soil had very low nitrate levels due to immobilization of
nitrogen by rapidly growing populations of bacteria as well as suppression of nitrogen-fixing
bacteria.
Weathering
Weathering processes include volatilization, evapotranspiration, photomodification, hydrolysis,
leaching and biotransformation of the contaminant. These processes selectively reduce the
concentration of contaminants, with the more recalcitrant compounds remaining in the soil. The
contaminants left behind are typically non-volatile or semi-volatile compounds that preferentially
partition to soil organic matter or clay particles, which limits their bioavailability and the degree to
which they can be, degraded (Cunningham et al., 1996). Carmichael and Pfaender (1997) noted that
contaminant bioavailability was a major factor limiting the degradation of contaminants.
26
BENEFITS AND LIMITATIONS OF PHYTOREMEDIATION
Direct Benefits of Phytoremediation
Phytoremediation is an in situ, solar driven technique, which limits environmental disturbance and
reduces costs (Shimp et al., 1993). Moreover, it is particularly well-suited to the treatment of large
areas of surface contamination, when other methods may not be cost effective (Schnoor, 1999). In
general, both the public and government regulators look favourably upon phytoremediation because
it involves exploiting the natural ability of the environment to restore itself (Cunningham et al.,
1996). Indeed, there was a high level of public support for the use of ferns in phytoremediation at a
series of public focus group meetings to gauge public perceptions and awareness of environmental
applications of biotechnology in Canada (McIntyre and Lewis, 1997). Pterido-remediation also is
considered to be more aesthetically pleasing than other remediation techniques (Shimp et al., 1993;
Cunningham et al., 1996).
Plant samples can be harvested and used as indicators of the extent of remediation or, conversely,
contamination (Shimp et al., 1993). Similarly, a field of plants may serve as a direct, visual bioassay
(Cunningham et al., 1996). There is also the potential to grow various fern species together on the
same site in an attempt to simultaneously remediate various contaminants, including salts, metals,
pesticides, and petroleum hydrocarbons. Plants help contain the region of contamination by
removing water from soil, thereby keeping the contaminants from spreading or confining them
within or near the root-system (Shimp et al.,1993). Finally, phytoremediation may be applied with
relative ease using existing agricultural practices at contaminated sites (McIntyre and Lewis, 1997).
Indirect Benefits of Phytoremediation
An indirect benefit of phytoremediation is improvement of soil quality by improving soil structure
(aggregates and peds), increasing porosity/aggregation and, therefore, water infiltration, providing
nutrients (nitrogen-fixing legumes), accelerating nutrient cycling, and increasing soil organic carbon
(Schnoor et al., 1995; Cunningham et al., 1996). The use of plants in a remediation effort stabilizes
the soil, thus preventing erosion and direct human exposure (i.e., by preventing the consumption of
contaminated soil by children and the inhalation of soil particles carried in the wind) (Schnoor et al.,
1995; McIntyre and Lewis, 1997). Likewise, phytoremediation has the potential to help reduce
greenhouse gas emissions.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
Conclusively, with all these tolerance mechanisms, a lot of fern species have been found to be very
effective in the hyperaccumulation and remediation of heavy metal contaminated sites as they can
also be easily propagated with other beneficial roles to the environment. However, more attention
should be paid to their use in Nigeria and further study be carried out on their phytovolatilization
ability i.e. the movement of a contaminant out of the soil, into, through and out of a plant, and then
into the atmosphere instead of bioaccumulation in the plant body. Phytovolatilization is a
mechanism to remove contaminants out of plant body by transforming toxic metal to volatile forms
that can easily transpire out of the plant body. This method will not only reclaim contaminant soil
but also clean up plant body.
REFERENCES
Agnew A. D. Q. (1974). A flora of the ferns and herbaceous flowering plants of upland
Kenya. Oxford University Press, Ely House, London W1. Pp. 1-63.
Alexander M., Hatzinger P. B., Kelsey J. W., Kottler B. D. and Nam K. (1997). Sequestration and
realistic risk from toxic chemicals remaining after bioremediation. Annals New York
Academy of Sciences. 829: 1-5.
27
Azcue J. M., Nriagu J. O. and Schiff S. (1994). Arsenic: historical perspectives, cycling and
characterization. John Willey and Sons, New York, USA. Pp. 1-80
Baker A. J. M. and Brooks R. R. (1989). Growing for gold, copper and zinc. New Scientist, 117: 4448.
Biederbeck V. O., St. Jacques R. M., Curtin D., Geissler H. J., Selles F. and Waddington J. (1993).
Use of Heavy Oil Waste Sludge for Protection and Improvement of Sandy Soil. Agriculture
and Agri-Food Canada, SK, and Environment Canada.
Bierhorst D. W. (1971). Morphology of vascular plants. London and New York Macmillan
Company. Pp. 1-78.
Bonbada B. R. and Ma L. Q. (2003). Tolerance of heavy metals in vascular plants. Pteridology in
new Millennium. The Netherlands- Kluwer Academy Publishers. Pp. 397- 420.
Boyd R. S., Wall M. A. and Watkins J. E. (2000). Correspondence between nickel tolerance and
hyperaccumulation in Streptanthus (Brassicaceae). Madrono, 47: 97- 105.
Brady N. C. and Weil R. R. (1996). The Nature and Properties of Soils. Prentice Hall: Upper
SaddleRiver, New Jersey.
Briat J. F. and Lebrun M. (1999). Plant responses to metal toxicity. Academy of Science Paris 322,
3–54.
Carmichael L. M. and Pfaender F. K. (1997). Polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbon metabolism in
soils: relationship to soil characteristics and preexposure. Environmental Toxicology and
Chemistry, 16 (4): 666-675.
Cumming J. R. and Taylor G. J. (1990). Mechanism of metal tolerance in plants: physiological
adaptations for exclusion of metal ions from the cytoplasm. In: Alscher, R.G., Cumming,
J.R. (Eds.), Stress Response in Plants: Adaptation, and Acclimation Mechanism. WileyLiss, New York, pp. 329–356.
Cunningham S. D. and Ow D. W. (1996). Promises and prospects of phytoremediation. Plant
Physiology, 110 (3): 715-719.
Cunningham S. D., Anderson T. A., Schwab A. P. and Hsu F. C. (1996). Phytoremediation of soils
contaminated with organic pollutants. Advances in Agronomy, 56: 55-114.
Dembitsky, V. (2003). Natural occurrence of arseno compounds in plants, lichens, fungi, algal
species, and microorganisms. Plant Science, 165: 1177-1192
Eweis, J. B., Ergas S. J., Chang D. P. Y. and Schroeder E. D. (1998). Bioremediation Principles.
McGraw-Hill, Inc.: Toronto.
Francesconi K., Visoottiviseth P., Sridokchan W. and Goessler W. (2002). Arsenic species in an
arsenic hyperaccumulating fern, Pityrogramma calomelanos: a potential phytoremediator of
arsenic-contaminated soils. Science of the Total Environment 284: 27-35
Frick C. M., Farrell R. E. and Germida J. J. (1999). Assessment of Phytoremediation as an In-Situ
Technique for Cleaning Oil-Contaminated Sites. Department of Soil Science University of
Saskatchewan Saskatoon, SK Canada S7N 5A8. Petroleum Technology Alliance of Canada
(PTAC) Calgary, AB
Ghosh M. and Singh S. P. (2005). A Review on Phytoremediation of Heavy Metals and Utilization
of It’s by Products . As. J. Energy Env. 6(4): 214-231
Godbold D. L., Horst W. J. H., Collins J. C., Thurman D. A. and Marschner H. (1984).
Accumulation of zinc and organic acids in roots of zinc tolerant and non-tolerant ecotypes
of Deschampisia caespitosa. Journal of Plant Physiology, 116: 59–69.
Ha S. B., Smith A. P., Howden R., Dietrich W. M. and Bugg S. (1999). Phytochelatin synthase genes
from arabidopsis and the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Plant Cell, 11: 1153-1164.
Howden, R., Cobbett, C.S., 1992. Cadmium-sensitive mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant
Physiology, 100: 100–107.
Jaffre T., Brooks R. R., Lee J. and Reeves R. D. (1976). Sebertia acuminata: A hyperaccumulator of
nickel from new Caledonia. Science, 193: 579-580.
28
Jalal S. (2008). Arsenic contamination – how safe are poultry products and drinking water in
Nigeria. Environmental Health Perspective, 116: 4-10.
Kartesz J. T. (1994). A synonymised checklist of the flora of the United State, Canada and
Greenland. Timber press. A product of the biota of North America program. Pp. 1-60.
Kenrick P. and Crane P. R. (1997). The origin and early evolution of plants on land. Nature, 389 (4):
33-39.
Komar K., Ma L. Q., Rockwood D. and Syed A. (1998). Identification of arsenic tolerant and
hyperaccumulation plants from arsenic contaminated soils in Florida. Agronomy Abstract,
343: 20-67.
Kraner U. (2000). Cadmium for all meals. Plants with an unusual appetite. New Phytology. 145: 1–5.
Levitt J. (1980). Responses of Plants to Environmental Stresses, vol. 2, second ed. Academic Press,
New York.
Lolkema P. C., Donker M. H., Schouten A. J. and Ernst W. H. O. (1984). The possible role of
metallothioneins in copper tolerance of Silene cucubalus. Planta 162: 174–179.
Lombi E., Tearall K. L., Howarth J. R., Zhao F. J., Hawkesford M. J. and McGrath S. P. (2002).
Influence of iron status on calcium and zinc uptake by different ecotypes of the
hyperaccumulator Thlaspi caerulescens. Plant Physiology, 128 (4): 1359–1367.
Ma L. Q., Komar K. M., Tu C., Zhang W., Cai Y. and Kennelley E. D. (2001). A fern that
hyperaccumulates arsenic. Nature, 409: 579
Maitani T., Kubota H., Sato K. and Yamada T. (1996). The composition of metals bound to class III
metallothionein (phytochelatin and its desglycyl peptide) induced by various metals in root
cultures of Rubia tinctorum. Plant Physiology, 110: 1145–1150.
Meharg A. A. (2002). Variation in arsenic accumulation : hyperaccumulation in ferns and their allies.
New Phytolologist, 157: 25-31.
Meagher, R.B. 1998. Phytoremediation: An Affordable, Friendly Technology to Restore Marginal
Lands
in
the
Twenty-First
Century.
Available
[Online]:
http://www.1sc.psu.edu/nas/Panelists/Meagher%20comment.html [12 June, 2000].
Mrittunjai S., Ma L. Q. and Jorge A. G. S. (2005). Three new arsenic hyperaccumulating ferns.
Science of the Total Environment, 304: 24-31.
Odu E. A. and Opapeju C. O. (1986). Reproductive phenology in the homosporous leptosporangiate
ferns. Nigerian Journal of Biological Science, 1 (1): 12- 18.
Oloyede F. A., Akomolafe G. F. and Odiwe I. A. (2013). Arsenic hyperaccumulation and
phytoremediation potentials of Pteris vittata and p. ensiformis (Ferns) in Nigeria. Acta
Botanica Hungarica, 55(3–4): 377–384, DOI: 10.1556/ABot.55.2013.3–4.12
Otten A., Alphenaar A., Pijls C., Spuij F. and De Wit H. (1997). In Situ Soil Remediation. Kluwer
Academic Publishers: Boston.
Page C. N. (1988). Ferns: their habitats in British and Irish landscape. New Naturalist series.
London: Collins. Pp. 1-45.
Pollard G. (2000). Metal hyperaccumulation: a model system for evolutionary studies. New
Phytologist, 146: 179-181.
Porter E. K. and Peterson P. J. (1975). Arsenic accumulation by plants on mining waste. Science of
Total Environment, 4: 365-371.
Rasheed M. N. (2010). Environmental bioindicators for monitoring heavy metals in ecosystem.
Aswan Faculty of Science, South valley University, Egypt. Pp. 1-67.
Rauser W. E. (1984). Copper-binding protein and copper tolerance in Agrostis gigantea. Plant Sci.
Lett. 33: 239–247.
Rauser W. E. (1999). Structure and function of metal chelators produced by plants: the case for
organic acids, amino acids, phytin, and metallothioneins. Cell Biochemistry. Biophysics, 31:
19–48.
Reeves R. D. and Baker A. J. M. (2000). Metals accumulating plants. Phytoremediation of toxic
metals using plants. New York. John Willey. Pp. 1-87.
29
Salt D. E., Smith R. D. and Raskin I. (1998). Phytoremediation. Annual Review of Plant Physiology
and Molecular Biology, 49: 643-648.
Schmöger M. E. V., Oven M. and Grill E. (2000). Detoxification of arsenic by phytochelatins in
plants. Plant Physiology, 122, 793–802.
Schnoor J. L. (1999). Organics – case studies in phytoremediation. IBC’s 4th Annual International
Conference on Phytoremediation, June 23-25, 1999. Toronto.
Sela M., Garty J. and Telor E. (1989). The accumulation and effect of heavy metals on the water
fern. Azolla filliculoides. New Phytologist, 112: 7-12.
Sen A. K. and Mondal N. G. (1990). Removal and uptake of copper by Salvinia natans from waste
water. Water, Air and Soil Pollution, 49: 1-16.
Silver S. and Phung L. T. (1996). Bacterial heavy metal resistance: new surprises. Annu. Rev.
Microbiol. 50: 753–789.
Srivastava M., Ma L. Q., Singh N. and Singh S. (2005). Antioxidant responses of hyper-accumulator
and sensitive fern species to arsenic. Journal of Experimental Botany, 56: 1335-1342.
Supaporn P., Savent P. and Nimit S. (2008). Heavy Metal Accumulation in Soil and Some Fern
Species at Phu Soi Dao National Park, Phitsanulok Province, Thailand. NU Science Journal,
5 (2): 151 – 164
Srivastava M., Ma L. Q. and Singh N. (2005). Antioxidant responses of hyperaccumulator and
sensitive fern species to arsenic. Journal of Experimental Botany, 56: 1335-1342
Vance D. B. (1996). Phytoremediation: enhancing natural attunation processes. National
Environmental Journal, 6: 30-31.
Vatamaniuk O. K., Mari S., Lu Y. P. and Rea P. A. (1999). AtPCS1, a phytochelatin synthase from
Arabidopsis: isolation and in vitro reconstitution. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 96: 7110–
7115.
Vogt T. (1942). Geochemical and geobotanical ore prospecting III. Selsk, 15: 21-24.
Wierzbicka M. (1995). How lead loses its toxicity to plants. Acta Soc. Bot. Pol. 64: 81–90.
Wierzbicka M. (1999). Comparison of lead tolerance in Allium cepa with other plant species.
Environmental Pollution, 104: 41–52.
Woolson, E. A., Axley J. H., and Kearney P. C. (1971).The chemistry and phytotoxicity of arsenic in
soils: 1. Contaminated field soils. Soil Science Society of America, 35: 938.
Wright A. L., Weaver R. W. and Webb J. W. (1997). Oil bioremediation in salt marsh mesocosms as
influenced by N and P fertilization, flooding, and season. Water, Air and Soil Pollution, 95:
179- 191.
Xu J. G. and Johnson R. L. (1997). Nitrogen dynamics in soils with different hydrocarbon contents
planted to barley and field pea. Canadian Journal of Soil Science, 77: 453-458.
Zhao F. J., Dunham S. J. Mcgrath S. P. (2002). Arsenic hyperaccumulation by different fern species.
New Phytologist, 156: 27-31
Zhen-Guo S., Xian-Dong L., Chun-Chun W., Huai-Man C. H. and Hong C. H.. (2002). Lead
Phytoextraction from contaminated soil with high biomass plant species. Journal of
Environmental Quality, 31: 1893-1900.
Zhou J. and Goldsbrough P. B. (1994). Functional homologs of fungal metallothionein genes from
Arabidopsis. Plant Cell, 6: 875– 884.
30
HUMAN GENETICS (HG)
HG01
SICKLE CELL ALLELLIC FREQUENCIES IN THE NORTHERN GUINEA- SAVANNAH
OF NIGERIA
Galadima, M.A.1*, Akpa, G.N.2, Nwagu, B.I.3, Adamu, A.K.1, Kabir, M.2, Shehu, D.M.1 and AdejoUbani, E.O.3
1
2
3
Department of Biological Sciences, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
Department of Animal Science, Ahmadu Bello University Zaria, Nigeria
National Animal Production Research Institute, Shika, Zaria, Nigeria
Corresponding e-mail: mogawal@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
A study, aimed at estimating the frequencies of sickle cell trait in 3 populations of Northern GuineaSavannah Nigeria was conducted. The population studied were ABUTH (Kaduna State), AKTHK
(Kano State) and IBBSH (Niger State). 675 homozygote dominants (wild types), 263 heterozygote
and 25 homozygote recessives (mutant types) genotypes were recorded in the ABUTH populations.
The allelic frequencies in this population were 0.84(84%) wild type and 0.16 (about 16%) mutant.
However in AKTHK population, the genotypes recorded were 837 homozygote dominant, 341
heterozygote and 31 homozygote recessives. The estimated allelic frequencies in these populations
were 0.83(83%) wild types and 0.17(about 17%) were mutants. While in the IBBSH population the
genotypes recorded were 350 homozygote dominant, 247 heterozygote and 23 homozygote
recessive. Allelic frequencies estimated in this populations were 0.76(76%) wild types and 0.24
(24%) mutant. To investigate whether the three populations conformed to Hardy-Weinberg principle,
the observed genotypes in the three populations were compared with expected genotypes under
Hardy-Weinberg principle. The calculated chi square values for the deviations between the
population and the idealised Hardy-Weinberg population at 20.05 level of significance was not
significant, (0.01) for ABUTH, (0.302) for AKTHK and for IBBSH 0.005 suggesting that none of
the Hardy-Weinberg assumptions (random mating, migration, mutation and selection) were violated
in the populations.
Keywords: Alleles, Sickle Cell, Genotype, ABUTH, AKTHK, IBBSH
INTRODUCTION
Sickle cell is a hereditary blood anomaly, depicted by erythrocytes that have rigid sickle shape.
Sickling decreases the cell flexibility and result in various serious complications. Under low oxygen
tension, the sickle cell haemoglobin polymerised (Betty Pace, 2007). The deoxy form of the
haemoglobin exposes a hydrophobic patch on the protein, which associates with the hydrophobic
residue of valine at position six of the beta chain, causing haemoglobin S molecule to aggregate and
polymerised. This polymerization , in the homozygote recessive individual distort the shape of red
blood cell from smooth and doughnut-like in normal individuals (homozygous dominant) , producing
blood cells that are sickle shaped, ragged and full of spikes, making it fragile and susceptible to
breaking within capillaries (Mary Louise, 2005). Heterozygote individuals, show symptoms only
31
under low oxygen tension. The trait is as a result of autosomal recessive inheritance resulting from
point mutation at position number six in the haemoglobin protein chain (146 amino acid long), where
valine, the mutant replaces glutamic acid , the wild type (Freeman and Herron, 2007). Individuals
heterozygotes for the trait have both normal and abnormal haemoglobin, a condition known as codominance. The first description of the haemoglobinopathy now known as sickle cell was reported
by Herrick in 1910, when he reported his observation of sickle-shaped erythrocytes in the peripheral
blood of a severely anaemic patient (Taiwo et al., 2011). Sickle cell disease occurs more commonly
among people who live in tropical and sub-Saharan regions as well as those whose ancestors
originated from these regions, where malaria is common(Austin, et al., 2007). According to
secretariat report (WHO, 2006) 200,000 infants are born with sickle cell disorder in Africa each year.
The prevalence of the trait (healthy carriers or heterozygous) ranges between 10% and 40% across
equatorial Africa.
Due to the morbidity and mortality that always ensue, as a result of sickling, it has become an area of
challenge to the health industries. Despite all these, there are no comprehensive literatures regarding
the distribution of the trait in the areas of the study. The interaction between the alleles at the
population level has not been elucidated. Such an undertaking would sound novel in an area that
hitherto remain untouched as far as population studies are concern.
The objectives of the present studies are to measure the diversity of sickle cell alleles in the Northern
Guinea-Savannah of this country, as well as to confirm if the population conformed with HardyWeinberg principles.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study was conducted in three states within the Northern Guinea- Savannah (Kaduna, Kano and
Niger). The subjects that participated in these study comprises 965 individuals from Ahmadu Bello
University Teaching Hospital Zaria (ABUTH), 1229 from Aminu Kano Teaching Hospital Kano
(AKTHK) and 620 from Ibrahim Badamasi Babangida Specialist Hospital Minna (IBBSH). The data
were of two types. Already genotyped record was obtained from the haematological units of the
various hospitals, the second data originated from information acquired in questionnaire completed
by voluntary participants. All the aforementioned hospitals are the largest and most densely
populated in terms of patients within the states that form the study areas. In the haematological
laboratories of the various hospitals where the data were collected, the genotyping was done as
follows;
A 2.5ml, blood sample was collected from antecubital vain of each subject that participated in the
study and stored in Ethylinediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) coated bottles prior to electrophoresis.
Blood sample was then haemolysed using saline solution. Little quantity of haemolysed blood from
each individual was placed on cellulose acetate membrane and then introduced into electrophoretic
container, containing Tris-EDTA borate buffer, PH 8.9. The electrophoresis was run for 20 min. at a
voltage of 160v. The resulting genotypes were compared with standard ladder for their identification.
In each of the three populations studied, genotypes were grouped into three columns; homozygote
dominant (AA), heterozygote (AS), and homozygote recessive (SS).
The allelic frequencies were calculated by multiplying the number of individuals tested in each
population by two, to get the total number of alleles ( remember that allelic frequency is twice the
number of genotype).The total number of alleles were then used to divide the number of copies of
the sickle cell alleles (one from the heterozygote plus two from the homozygote) as shown below.
AA=2 alleles
AS=1 allele
32
SS=2alleles
The genotypic frequencies (observed genotypic frequencies) are simply the number of individuals
tested that fall under each genotypic group divided by the total number of individuals in the
population;
AA/n,
AS/n,
SS/n
The expected genotypic frequencies under Hardy-Weinberg principle, given the allele frequencies
were estimated as follows; according to the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium principle, if the
frequencies of two alleles are p and q, then the frequencies of genotypes would be : p2 + 2pq + q2 ,
represented as;
(AA)
P2
(AS)
2pq
(SS)
q2
The expected number of individual genotypes in each population under Hardy- Weinberg
equilibrium is simply the expected frequency of each genotype, multiply by the number of
individuals in the population.
n(p2)
n(q2)
n(2pq)
The number of individuals observed (the number of genotypes in each population) were then
compared with the number of individuals expected to confirm if the population conformed to the
assumption of Hardy-Weinberg principle. The presence of discrepancy between the expected and the
observed number of individuals entails that the population is not in conformity with the principle;
one or some of the conditions in the principle are violated. A chi square test (Pearson, 1914) was
then used to test the significant level of the difference.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table1 provides information on allelic and genotypic frequencies of sickle cell traits in the tested
populations. The allelic frequencies for sickle cell in the studied populations were less than 20% for
ABUTH and AKTHK, while for IBBSH it was 24%. The homozygote frequencies for sickle cell in
the studied populations were low with SS ranging from 0.03 (ABUTH) to 0.04 (AKTHK and
IBBSH). The heterozygote condition was intermediate with AS ranging from 0.27 (ABUTH and
AKTHK) to 0.04 (IBBSH). Overall, in the northern guinea-savannah zone of Nigeria the allelic
frequency of sickle cell was 0.19, while the normal allele was 0.81. The genotypic frequencies in the
zone were 0.65(AA), 0.31 (AS) and 0.04 (SS).
Table 1. Allelic and Genotypic Frequencies of Sickle Cell Trait In The Tested Populations.
POPULATION
NO. Tested
Genotypic Frequencies
Allelic Frequencies
AA
AS
SS
A
S
ABUTH
AKTHK
IBBSH
963
1209
620
0.70
0.69
0.56
0.27
0.27
0.40
0.03
0.04
0.04
0.84
0.83
0.76
0.16
0.17
0.24
33
Table 2 depicts the variations between the observed and expected genotypes in the studied
populations. There was no significant (P> 0.05) difference in the observed and expected genotypic
distributions in the 3 studied populations in the northern guinea-savannah zone of Nigeria.
Table2:
Variation Between Observed and Expected Number of Individuals Across Genotypic Groups In The
Three Populations.
POPULATION
GENOTYPES
2
AA
AS
SS
LOS
values
ABUTH
observed
675
263
25
expected
675.4
262.1
25.42
0.01
ns
AKTHK
IBBSH
observed
expected
837
839.5
341
335.7
31
33.5
0.302
ns
observed
expected
350
349.9
247
246.8
23
22.9
0.005
ns
Both the estimated genotypic and allelic frequencies in this study are in conformity with an estimate
made earlier by World Health Organisation (WHO, 2006) for the sub-region. It is also within the
range estimated by Taiwo et al. (2011), for the Yoruba community in Lagos.
The low frequency of sickle trait in the population does not come as a surprise, studies on autosomal
recessive alleles example cystic fibrosis (Lyczak et al., 2003) , spinal muscular atrophy (Wirth et al.,
1997), Gaucher disease (Beutler, 1993) had revealed low frequencies in such alleles. Most recessive
mutant alleles are deleterious and therefore natural selection acts to eliminate such mutants from the
population. The effect of migration in changing allelic or genotypic frequencies in these populations
is negligible when one compares the rate of gene flow and the sizes of the populations. Mutation is
inconsequential in changing allelic frequencies in the populations due to their vastness, and the time
it takes for a mutant allele to be fixed by genetic drift. Selection (an important force in changing
allelic frequency) has limitation here in eliminating the mutant allele completely from the
populations, as the recessive mutant allele confer some degree of fitness, when it is in the
heterozygote form. The heterozygote is selected for, because of the resistance it bestows against
malarial infection.
The deviation of the observed number of individuals from the expected in the three populations is not
significant at 20.05 level. This is suggesting that none of the assumptions of Hardy-Weinberg
principle is violated in the three populations. This finding supports the fact that marriages among the
population is panmictic (non assortative). The vastness of the area covered by this study (Northern
Guinea-Savannah) and the heterogeneity of the population made it outstanding among similar studies
done previously (Taiwo et al., 2011) only for the Yoruba community in Lagos and (Bakare et al.,
2006) conducted in Ogbomosho only.
CONCLUSION
This work provides an opportunity for population genetic studies. The frequencies of alleles and
genotypes estimated may be valuable information to the health sector, for the purpose of budget
forecasting and planning, when the need to control the trait in these areas arises.
34
REFERENCES
Austin. H., N.S. Key, J. M. Benson (2007) Sickle cell trait and the risk of venous Thromboembolism
among Blacks. Journal Blood, 110(3): 908-912.
Bakare. A.A., Azeez, M.A. and Agbolade, J.O. ( 2006) Gene frequency of ABO and Rhesus Blood
Groups and Haemoglobin Variants In Ogbomosho, South-Western Nigeria. African Journal
of Biotechnology, 5(3): 224-229.
Betty, P. (2007) Renaissance of Sickle Cell Disease Research In The Genome Era. Imperial College
Press. Pp. 62.
Beuter. E (1993) Gaucher Disease as paradigm of current issues regarding single gene mutation of
human. Proceeding of The National Academy of Sciences USA, 90: 5384-5390.
Freeman.S and Herron, J. (2007). Evolutionary analysis . Fourth Edition. Pearson International .
ISBN 13:978-0-13-239789-6.Lyczak. J. B., C. L. Cannon and G. B. Pier ( 2002) Lung
infection Associated with cystic Fibrosis . Clinical Microbiology Review, 15: 194-222.
Mary, L. (2005). Clinical Haematology: Theory and Procedure . Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
PP.179-ISBN978-0-7817-5003-3
Pearson. K.(1914) Tables for Statisticians and Biometricians; Cambridge University Press, Editor
Taiwo. A. I., Oloyede, O.A. and Dosumu, A.O. (2011). Frequency of Sickle Cell Genotype Among
The Yoruba In Lagos : Implication For The Level of Awareness and Genetic Counselling
For Sickle Cell Disease In Nigeria. Journal of Community Genetics, 2(1): 13-15.
Wirth. B., T. Schmidt ( 1997) Denovo Rearrangement Found In Two Percent of Index Patients With
Spinal Muscular Atrophy; Mutation Mechanism, Parental Origin, Mutation Rate and
Implication For Genetic Counselling. American J. of Human Genetics, 61: 225-265.
World Health Organization (2006) Secretariat Report On Sickle Cell Anaemia. 59th Assembly .
P.114.
PGB01
VARIETAL RESPONSE OF POTATO (SOLANUM TUBEROSUM L.) TO IRRIGATION
REGIMES IN JOS PLATEAU, NIGERIA.
Acharreng, S1 and Kwon-Ndung, E.H2
1
Department of Plant Science and Technology, University of Jos, Nigeria.
2
Department of Botany, Federal University, Lafia, Nigeria.
ABSTRACT
A field experiment was carried out in Kuru (09044N, 08047E) and 1239 meters above mean sea level
in Jos, Plateau State of Nigeria during the dry season of 2012 /2013. The treatment consisted of four
irrigation regimes (once in fourteen days, once in ten days, once in seven days and once in three
days) and six potato varieties (Diamant, RC 7716-2, BR63-18, Nicola, Agria and Bertita) laid out in
a split-plot design with three replications. The study aimed to assess the varietal responses of the
different potato varieties to the variable irrigation regimes so as to get recommendations for low
water input for dry season potato production on the Jos Plateau. The varieties exhibited highly
significant variability (P<0.01) for most traits assessed. Significant differences (P<0.05) were
recorded in plant emergence, plant height, plant vigour, Stem girth, number of stems, number of
tubers, average tuber weight and tuber yield. The irrigation regimes affected the varieties
significantly (P<0.05) with plants that were irrigated once in three days producing the highest yields
in all varieties. The plants that were irrigated least produced the lowest yields. Agria and Diamant
performed better on receiving the least irrigation regimes compared to others. The interaction
between varieties and irrigation regimes were significant (P<0.05) for most traits assessed. Days to
35
maturity, number of tuber and average tuber weight had a positive significance (P<0.05) correlation
with tuber yield per plant. The inter-relationship between growth and yield components in this study
suggested that adequate shoot development (number of stem, plant height, number of leaves),
number of tubers/plant, average tuber weight/plant are the yield indicators for potato varieties which
suggest that both attributes are important criteria for selection for improved yield and drought
tolerance of potato.Diamant and Nicola Produced the highest tuber yield while irrigation regimes
once in three days produced the highest yield. The suggestions of these outcomes are further
discussed in line with the water use requirements for this crop on the Plateau.
INTRODUCTION
Yield response to irrigation of different crops is of major importance in production planning where
water resources are limited. The cultivated potato (Solanum tuberosun L.) varieties grown outside its
South American centre of origin evolved from only a few Andean potato genotypes (Hawkes, 1978,
Birhman and Kang, 1993). Potato rate fourth among the world’s various agriculture production
volume after wheat, rice and corn (Faberio, et al., 2001). It is a temperate crop that grows and yields
well in cool and humid climates. Production of potato takes a very important place in world
agriculture, with a production potential of about 327 million tons harvested and 18.6 million hectares
planted area (FAO, 2004).
Studies have shown that water is the most important limiting factor for potato production and it is
possible to increase production levels by well-scheduled irrigation program throughout the growing
season (Boujelbenet al., 2000; Deblonde and Ledent, 2001; Faberioet al., 2001; Chowdhunget al.,
2001; Panigrahiet al., 2001; Ferreira and Carr, 2002, Kashyap and Panda, 2003; Shocks et al., Yuan
et al., 2003 Onderet al., 2005). Because average rainfall and water resources are limited, research on
the relationship among yield, irrigation regimes and potato varieties is of great importance for the
selection of high yielding varieties that can tolerate water stress. This study aims to determine the
effect of different irrigations regimes on the growth and tuber yield of six potato cultivars, study the
inter- relationship between tuber yield and other yield related components and to suggest varieties
that show superiority in tuber yield and other agronomic attributes under different irrigations regimes
and could be utilized in a drought improvement programme.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Six potato varieties were evaluated under four different irrigation regimes in the research substation
of the National Root Crops Research Institute in Kuru ( Lat. 09o 44N, Long. 08o47E and 1239 masl)
on the Jos Plateau State of Nigeria between November 2012 to February 2013. The experiment was
laid out in a split plot design using three treatments. Gross plot size was 27m x 20m while the net
plot size was 6m2. Seed tubers were planted one per stand at a population density of 33,333 plants
per hectare. Galex® was applied as a pre-emergence herbicide at the rate of 5 liters product per
hectare to control weeds. Further weeding was done manually at six weeks after planting (WAP).
Fertilizer was applied at the rate of 100kg Nitrogen, 100kg Phosphorus as P2 O5 and 40kg potassium
as K2O at 3 WAP. Data was collected on the following plant attributes at different periods of
development of the crop ranging from 2 weeks after planting (2 WAP) to 12 WAP:Plant emergence,
Plant height (cm), Number of leaves per plant, plant vigour, number of stems per plant, stem girth
(cm), number of days to maturity, dry matter content (%), number of tubers per plant (kg), average
tuber weight (kg) and tuber yield per plant (kg). The data obtained were subjected to analysis of
variance (ANOVA) using SPSS computer software at P<0.05 and means compared with Duncan’s
new multiple range test (DNMRT). Pearson’s correlation analysis was also used to compare the
inter- relationships of yield with some growth related traits.
RESULTS
Plant emergence varied significantly between potato varieties (P<0.01, Table 1). The variation
ranged from 10 stands per plot in Agria, 13 stands per plot in RC 7716-2, 14 stands per plot in
Diamant, 15 stands per plot in Bertita, 16 stands per plot in BR68-18 and 17 stands per plot in Nicola
36
(Table 1). There were also significant differences (P<0.05). In the irrigation regimes means. Plants
that were irrigated once in 3 days produced significantly higher number of plant that emerged.
Irrigation regimes once in 14 days produced the least number of plant emergence. The irrigation
regimes once in 7 days and 10 days produced plant emergence that were not significantly different.
The interaction between irrigation regimes and varieties were not significant while the coefficient of
variation was 23%.
Variability in the height of the varieties was significant (P<0.05, Table. 1). In all the growth stages
Diamant had the tallest plants, while Bertita produced the shortest plant. Irrigation regimes were also
significant (P<0.05). The interactions between varieties and irrigation regimes were not significant.
The coefficient of variation (%) was 49.96.
Table 1 shows the effect of variety and irrigation regimes on number of leaves per plant. The means
number of leaves ranged from 661 in Nicola and 512 in Agria. The differences in this attribute
between the varieties were significant (P<0.05). There was also a significant difference (P<0.05) in
the treatments. Plants irrigated once in 3 days produced the highest number of leaves per plant (669)
while irrigation regimes once in 14 days produced the least number of leaves (460).
The interaction between varieties and irrigation regimes were not significant while the coefficient of
variation was 80.21%.
The means plant vigour is shown in Table 1. It ranged from 5.78 in Diamant to 2.89 in Agria. The
difference in this attribute between the varieties was highly significant (P<0.01). The means
irrigation regimes was also significant (P<0.05, Table 1). Irrigation once in 3 days produced the most
vigorous plant while irrigation regimes once in 14 days produced the least vigorous plants.
The interaction between irrigation regimes and varieties were also significant while the coefficient of
variation was 41.13%.
The mean number of stem per plant varied significant (P<0.05, Table 1) between the potato varieties.
Bertita produced the highest number of stem (3). This however did not differ significantly from the
stem number of 2 others varieties. RC7716-2, Diamant and Agria Produced the least number of stem
(2). The mean irrigation regimes also varied significantly (P<0.05, Table 1).
The interaction between varieties and irrigation regimes were also significant and the coefficient of
variation was 46.62%.
Variation between the varieties in the stem girth was significant (P<0.05, table 2). Stem girth was
highest in Diamant (4.75) while the least was BR68-18 (2.93) RC7716-2, BR68-18, Nicola and
Bertita produced stem girth that were not significantly different. The interaction between the
varieties and irrigation regimes were significant while the coefficient of variation was 29.36%.
The mean number of days from planting to maturity varied significantly amongst potato varieties
(P<0.01) ranging from 70 days in Bertita to 93 days in Diamant (Table 2). There was also a highly
significant difference (P<0.01) in the irrigation regimes means. The interaction was also significant
between the potato varieties and the irrigation regimes. The coefficient of variation was 11.49%.
Table 2 shows the mean dry matter content for the potato varieties. There were no significant
differences in the dry matter content in regard to the varietal means. The irrigation regime was not
also significant. However, the interaction between the varieties and irrigation regimes were
significant while the coefficient of variation was 12.77% (Table. 2).
There was a highly significant variability in the number of tubers produced by the varieties (P<0.01).
Nicola Produced highest tubers followed by Bertita (4). Diamant produced the least tubers but did
37
not differ in this regard from 2 other varieties. The mean irrigation regimes also differ significantly
with irrigation regime once in 3 days producing the highest tubers while once in 10 days produced
the least (Table 2). Interaction between variety and irrigation regimes was significant while the
coefficient of variation was 60.28%
The mean average tuber weight was not significantly different in terms of the varieties and also the
irrigation regimes. However, the interaction between variety and irrigation regime was significant
and the coefficient of variation was 65.52% (Table 2).
There was a significant variation between the varieties in their tuber yield (P<0.05). Diamant had the
highest tuber yield while RC7716-2 gave the lowest yield. Nicola and Bertita gave yields that were
not significantly different from each other. There was also a significantly different (P<0.05) in terms
of the irrigation regimes with irrigation regimes once in 3days producing the highest yields.
The interaction between varieties and irrigation regimes were significant while the coefficient of
variation was 47.87% (Table 2).
Table 3 shows the simple coefficient of correlation matrix between the traits studied. Tuber yield
correlated positively and significantly (P<0.05) with dry matter content. Tuber yield also correlated
positively and highly significantly (P<0.01) with average tuber weight (r=0.437), number of
tubers/plant (r=0.843), days to maturity (r=0.341), number of leaves/plant (0.391), stem girth
(r=0.191) and plant height (r=0.421). Plant emergence had a negative correlation with dry matter
content. Plant height had a positive and significant correlation with most traits assessed except
average tuber weight (r= -0.061) and dry matter content (r= -0.176) that were negatively correlated.
The attribute also showed significant association with one another. Stem girth had a highly
significant correlation with number of leaves (r=1.00), number of stems (r=1.00) Plant vigour
(r=1.00) while days to maturity had a significant but negative correlation (r= -0.102). Number of
tubers had a positive and significant correlation with average tuber weight (r=0.239).
38
Table 1 Effect of Varieties and Irrigation Regimes on Some Growth Parameters of Potato.
Treatments
Plant emergence
plant
Irrigation regimes(I)
Once in three days
Once in seven days
Once in ten days
Once in fourteen
days
Significance
SE ±
Varieties (V)
Diamant
RC7716-2
BR68-18
Nicola
Agria
Bertita
Significance
S.E ±
Plant heights (cm) Number of leaves
Plant vigour
No. of stem per
15.89a
14. 83ab
14.28ab
13.28b
53.11a
49.28ab
44.61b
47.37a
440. 88a
424.40a
403.67ab
316.97b
4.79a
3. 81b
4.00b
3.74b
2.54a
2.1ab
2.65a
1. 83c
*
0.55
*
5.70
*
74.94
*
0.28
*
0.20
14. 83bc
13.08c
16.00ab
17. 08a
10.08ab
15.58b
**
0.67
52.51a
48.21a
48.34a
52.43a
44. 88a
37.70b
*
6.98
369.17a
392.42a
397.27a
448.12a
341.22a
430.68a
*
91.79
5.78a
3.61c
4.28b
4.72b
2. 89d
3.22cd
**
0.35
1.97b
1.75b
2.64a
2.64a
1.97b
2. 81a
*
0.25
Ns
49.96
Ns
80.21
**
41.13
*
46.62
Interaction
I×V l
Ns
Coefficient
of 23.00
variation (CV)%
Means followed by the same letter(s) within the same column and treatment are not significantly
different at 5% level of probability.
*=significant at 0.05 level of probability
**= significant at 0.01 level of probability.
NS= not significant
SE= standard Error
C.V= Coefficient of variation (%)
39
Table 2 Effect of varieties and Irrigation Regimes on Some Potato Attributes
Treatment
Irrigation (I)
Once in three
days
Once in seven
days
Once in ten days
Once in fourteen
days
Significance
SE ±
Varieties (V)
Diamant
RC7716-2
BR68-18
Nicola
Agria
Bertita
Significance
S.E ±
Interaction
I×V
C.V (%)
Stem
girth
(cm)
Days to Number of Average
Maturity tubers/plant
Tuber
weight(kg)
3.59a
91.72a
4.22a
0.23a
0.39a
21.94a
3.63a
83. 89b
3.12ab
0.11a
0.23b
22.30a
3.34a
3.35a
80.61c
75.50d
2.74b
3.32ab
0.15a
0.12a
0.27b
0.25b
22.00a
21.78a
Ns
0.20
**
0.36
*
0.39
Ns
0.06
*
0.03
Ns
0.66
92.92a
83.03d
80.67d
83.33c
89.00b
70.83e
**
0.44
1. 87d
2.74d
3.73bc
5.28a
2.13d
4.35ab
**
0.48
0.28a
0.27a
0.10a
0.09a
0.13a
o.10a
Ns
0.07
0. 83a
0.26d
0.69ab
0.28d
0.56c
0.29d
*
0.04
22.39a
20.59a
22.11a
22.36a
22.70a
22.70a
Ns
0. 81
**
11.49
*
60.28
*
65.51
**
47. 87
*
12.77
4.75a
3.19c
2.93c
2.94c
3.96b
3.93c
*
0.17
*
29.36
Tuber
yield/plant(kg)
Dry
Matter
content (%)
Means followed by the same letter(s) within the same column and treatment are not significantly different
at 5% level of probability.
*=significant at 0.05 level of probability
**= significant at 0.01 level of probability.
NS= not significant
SE= standard Error
C.V= Coefficient of variation (%)
40
Plant Height
Stem Girth/pt.
Number of leaves/pt
**
.942
*
.297
**
1.000
**
.942
*
.297
**
1.000
**
1.0S00
Plant Vigour
**
.942
*
.297
**
1.000
**
1.000
**
1.000
-0.17
*
.280
**
-.102
-.102
-.102
Number of Stems/pt
-.102
Average tuber
Number of
tubers/pt
Days to
Maturity
Number of
stem/pt
**
0.942
*
.297
Plant vigour
**
.331
Number of
leaves/pt.
Stem girth/pt
Plant Emergence
Plant height
Traits
Table 3: Matrix for correlation coefficient of some growth and yield parameters of potato
in Jos, Plateau State, Nigeria.
**
.261
.
.104
*
.261
*
.261
*
.261
*
.261
-.
-.155
.
.
.
.
.
Days of Maturity
Number of Tubers/Pt
.
Average tuber weight
Tuber yield/pt
*= Significant at 0.05 level of probability
** = Significant at 0.01 level of probability
41
DISCUSSION
The Varieties exhibited significant variability (P<0.05) for most traits assessed. Variation
amongst potato genotypes for different attributes has been reported by various others (Birhman
and Kang, 1993; Jefferies, et al.,1993; Paterson et al., 1996; and Shock, et al., 1998). Highly
significant variability in plant attributes within a population suggests the existence of sufficient
variability upon which selection for improvement in these characters can be based.
Nicola and Diamant were observed to have recorded the highest number of plant emergence,
tallest plants and most vigorous plants. These growth parameters showed significant (P<0.05)
difference in their means. This could be attributed to the environmental influences.
Analysis of the association between days to maturity, number of tubers per plant and average
tuber weight with tuber yield in this study revealed a significant positive correlation. Amadi
(2005) showed Via a path analysis that the functional relationship between number of stem/plant
and yield is mainly indirect since it operated largely through the number of tuber/plant hence the
positive correlation between the number of stem/plant and number of tubers/plant (Table 3).
Correlation between tuber yield, number of tubers/plant and average tuber weight/plant were
positive and significant (P<0.05). potato tuber yield is a function of the number of tuber and
average tuber weight Birhman and Kang, 1993; Amadiet al., (2005). Amadi et al., (2005)
reported that compared with other attributes, tuber number and average weight were by far the
most important determinants of tuber yield as shown by their relatively high correlation
In this study, result revealed a significant (P<0.05) effects of irrigation regimes on most of the
growth and tuber yield parameters assessed. The irrigation regimes once in 3 days recorded the
highest means in all the traits assessed except; stem number per plant and days to maturity. This
could be attributed to the fact that water stress increases early maturity of crops. The differences
observed in the performance of the potato varieties with respect to the different irrigation
regimes were in agreement with the findings of (Shock, et al., 1994; Shae et al., 1999) who
reported that the capacity of water utilization varied with plant varieties.
The Yield parameters were observed to be highly significant in terms of the irrigation regimes
with plants that were water once in three days producing the most yields followed by once in
seven days, once in ten days and once in fourteen days producing the least yield. This showed
that the assimilation from the leave and nutrients in the soil were better utilized in the presence
of much moisture, thus increasing the sinking ability. Clarke, et al., (1992) and Hall, et al.,
(1997) reported that relative yield performance of genotypes in moisture stressed and nonstressed environment could be the starting point in identifying traits related to drought tolerance
and selection of desired genotypes. Comparison of the performance of the genotypes in well –
watered and moisture stressed conditions showed that some varieties performed well in both
environment. Diamant and Agria, performed better compared to others under irrigation regime
once in fourteen days. However Nicola required much water for optimal tuber yield. Yield both
increased with increases in irrigation regimes in all the varieties. Low yield recorded in irrigation
regime once in fourteen days suggest that potato needs relatively much moisture for optimal
yield as reported by Eldredge, et al., (1992).
Highly significant interactions were observed between variety and irrigation regimes for plant
height, days to maturity, stem girth, plant vigour, number of stems per plant, number of tuber per
plant, average tuber weight and tuber yield. Other authors have found strong potato-genotypes x
water stress interaction (Jeffreries and Mackerron, 1993b). Interactions between Diamant, Nicola
42
and irrigation regimes once in three days produced the highest yield. The interaction between
varieties and irrigation regimes shows that yield responded linearly to applied water. In arid
regions studies has shown that potato yield responded linearly to water supply (Hane and
Pumphrey , 1984; Martin, et al., (1992).
The insignificant interaction of variety and irrigation regime on plant emergence could be
attributed the fact that the initial moisture in the soil was better utilized by the plants.
The observed highly significant (P<0.01) correlation between tuber yield and three attributes
namely; days to maturity (r=0.341), number of tuber (r=0.843) and average tuber weight
(r=0.437) is similar to the result obtained by Lopez, et al., (1987). This result showed that any
positive increases in such traits with suffice the boost in tuber yield as reported by Galarreta, et
al., (2005).
CONCLUSION
Significant variability was observed for most attributes of the varieties evaluated suggesting the
existence of satisfactory variability upon which selection for improvement in these attributes can
be based. The irrigation regimes also differ significant with the potato varieties. Plant emergence,
number of stem per plant, average tuber weight, number of tubers and tubers yield were mostly
attributed to environmental influence while plant vigour and other traits were mostly genotypic.
The inter-relationship between growth and yield components suggested that adequate shoot
development (number of stem, plant height and number of leaves), number of tuber/plant and
average tuber weight per plant) were the yield indicators. All the varieties studied required
relative irrigation regimes once in three days for optimal yield. Maximum yields from potato
production on the Jos Plateau during the dry season therefore require relative irrigation regimes
of once in three days.
REFERENCES
Amadi, C.O(2005). Evaluation of potato genotypes for adaptation to heat
Stress. PhD Thesis,Michealokpara University of Agriculture umudike.
Amadi, C.O, Ene-Obong, E.E and Okonkwo, J.O (2005). Correlation and
regression analysis of yield components of potato in Jos Plateau Nigeria. In:Orheruta, et
al., edited. Proceedings of the 39th annual conference 364-367pp.
Birhman, R.K and kang, G.S(1993). Analysis of variation and inter
Relationships in potato germplasm.Euphytica 68:17-26
Boujelben, A.; Mbarek K.B; AID, A.B(2001). Comparative study of the drip
And furrow irrigation on seasonal potato crop. Tropicultura, 19:110-115pp.
Chowdhury,S.R; Anthony, E.; Singh, R.;Thakur, A.K.; Verma, H.N(2001).
Leaf area development and its relationship with tuber yield in sweet potato under
different irrigation regimes. Orissa Journal of Horticulture, 29:20-23.
Clarke, J.M; Ronald, M.D and Towley Smith, T.F(1992). Evaluation of
Methods for quantification of drought tolerance in wheat. Crop Science, 32: 723-728pp.
Deblonde, M.K, Harverkort, A.J. and Ledent, J.F.(1999). Response of early
and late potato cultivars to moderate drought conditions. Agronomic parameters and
carbon isotopes desimination. European Journal Agron, 11:91-105pp.
Eldredge, E.P.; Shock, C.C and Stierber, T.D (1992). Plot sprinkler for
research. Agronomy Journal, 84:1081-1084pp.
43
Faberio,C.; Olalla, F.M.S.; Juan, J.A (2001). Yield size of deficit irrigated
Potatoes Agriculture and Water Management, 48:255-266pp.
FAO.FOASTAT. Agriculture. Rome. 2006. Available in:
http://foastat.fao.org/faostat/collections: subset=agriculture.
Ferreira, T.C.; Carr, M.K.V(2002). Response of potatoes (Salanumtuberosum L.) to irrigation
and nitrogen in a hot, dry climate: I. water use.
Field Crops Research, 78:51-64pp.
Galarreta, J.I.R; Ezpelata, B.; Pascualena, J. and Ritter, E.(2006). Combining ability and
correlations for yield components in early generations of potato breeding.Plant Breeding,
125:183-186pp.
Hall, A.E.; Thiaw, S.; Ismail, A. and Ehlers, J.D.(1997). Water use efficiency and drought
adaptation of cowpea. In: Singh, B.B. et al., (edited).Advances in cowpea research. 141146pp.
Hane, D.C and Pumphrey, F.V. (1984). Yield evapo-transpiration relationshipsand seasonal crop
coefficient for frequently irrigation potato. American Potato Journal, 61:661-668pp.
Hawkes, J.G.( 1978). History of potato In: The potato crop: The Scientific
Basis for Improvement.2ndEdition(Edited by P.M Harris) Chapman and Hall,
London,909pp.
Jefferies, R.A and Mackerron, D.k.l.(1993a).Response of potato genotypes todrought 1.
Expansion of individual leaves and osmotic adjustment.Annals of Applied Biology,
122:93-94pp.
Jefferies, R.A and mackerron, D.K.L(1993b). Response of potato geneotypes to
drought II.Leaf area Index, growth and yield. Annals of Applied Biology, 122:105122pp.
Kashyap, P.S.; Panda,R.K.(2003). Effect of irrigation scheduling on potato crop
parameters under water stressed conditions. Agriculture and Water Management, 59:4966pp.
Lopez, D.F, Boe, A.A., Johansen, R.H. and Jansky, S.H.(1987).Genotype x
Environment interactions, Correlations and combining ability of six traits in
potato(abstract). American Potato journal 64:447pp.
Martin, R.J, Jemieson, P.D., Wilson, D.R and Francis, G.S (1992).Effect of soil
moisture deficit potatoes on yield and quantity of Russet Burbank potatoes. New Zealand
Journal of Crop and Horticulture Science,20:1-9pp.
Onder, S.; Caliskan, M.E.; Onder, D.; Caliskan, S (2005). Difference irrigationmethods and
water stress effects on potato yield and yield components.Agriculture and Water
Management, 73:73-86pp.
Panigrahi, B.; Panda, S.N, Raghuwanshi , N.S.(2001).Potato
water use and
24
yield under furrow irrigation. Irrigation Science, 20:155-163pp.
Petterson, P.E., King, B.A and Smathers, R.L(1996) Irrigation systems.; Hand
line, solid set and wheel line. University of Idaho cooperative extension system Bulletin.
Shae, J.B.; Stede, D.D and Gregory, B.L (1999). Irrigation scheduling methodsfor potato in
Northern Great Plains. American Society of Agricultural Engineers, 42:351-360pp.
Shock, C.C.; Zalewski, J.C, Stierber, T.D and Burnett, D.S(1994). Impact of
early season water deficit on Russet Burbank plant development ,tuber yield and
quantity. American Potato Journal 69:793-803pp.
Shock, C.C.; Feibert, E.B.G.; Saunders, L.D.(1998).potato yield and quantity
response to deficit Irrigation. Horticultural Science 33:655-659pp.
44
Shock, C.C.; Feibert, E.B.G, suanders, L.D.(2003). ‘Umatilla Russet’ and‘Russet Legend’ potato
yield and quality response to irrigation.Horticulture Science, 38: 1117-1121pp.
Yuan, B.Z.; Nishiyama, S., and kang, Y. (2003).Effects of different irrigation
regimes on the growth and yield of drip-irrigated potato. Agriculture and Water
Management, 63:153-167pp.
PGB02
EVALUATION OF CYTOGENOTOXIC AND ANTIMUTAGENIC POTENCY OF
WATER EXTRACT OF CENTELLA ASIATICA LINN. USING THE ALLIUM CEPA
ASSAY
Akeem Akinboro 1, Ida Baharudeen2 Kamaruzaman Bin Mohamed2, Mohd Zaini Asmawi3
1
Department of Pure and Applied Biology, Ladoke Akintola University of Technology, P.M.B.
4000, Nigeria.
2
School of Biological Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 11800, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia.
3
School of Parmaceutical Sciences, University Sains Malaysia, 11800, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia.
ABSTRACT
In this study, the toxicological safety and therapeutic assessments of water extract of Centella
asiatica Linn. were carried out in the Allium cepa (onion) cells for the evaluation of mutagenic
and antimutagenic activities, respectively. The mitotic index (MI) at 6.25% concentration of the
extract alone decreased significantly from 3.13 to 2.05 after 24 and 48 hours, respectively,
however, it was significantly increased by 60% and 400% at 12.5% and 50.0%, respectively.
There was total arrest of cell division at 100% after 24 and 48 hours. The percentage
chromosomal aberrations (CA) induced by the water extract alone decreased significantly
throughout the tested concentrations except at 50.0%. The mutagenic activity of
cyclophosphamide was significantly suppressed above 50% at the tested concentrations except
100% where there was no dividing cell. These results suggest the application of antimutagenic
potency of water extract of C. asiatica in anticancer chemotherapeutics.
INTRODUCTION
Herbs are usually consumed by humans because of their nutritive and medicinal values which are
functions of phytochemicals in them. Recent scientific reports have shown that some plant
extracts contained toxic phytochemicals which can interract with biomolecules in the cells to
cause mutagenic, cytotoxic and genotoxic effects in in vitro and in vivo assays (Schimmers,
1994; Akinboro and Bakare 2007 ; Akinboro et al., 2012). Centella asiatica is an important
medicinal herb recognized for its various healing activities such as the treatment of leprosy,
ulcer, asthma, eczemza, anxiety and elephantiasis (Siddique et al., 2008; Seema and Meena,
2012), because it contained various biochemical compounds such as alkaloids, flavonoids,
glycosides, triterpenoids and Saponins (Babu et al., 1995; Siddiques et al., 2007; Siddique et al.,
2009; Seema and Meena et al., 2012). So far, the available results of scientific experiments on
45
the genotoxic and antigenotoxic evaluations of the extract of C. asiatica were carried out using in
vitro assays, suggesting the validation of the reported results in in vivo experiments which better
mimic the normal human system. Thus far, the present study aimed at evaluating water extract of
C. assiatica for mutagenic and antimutagenic effects on cell division and chromosomes using
the in vivo Allium cepa assay.
MATERIALS AND METHOD
Centella asiatica plant was identified and given voucher specimen number 11268 at the
herbarium unit of the School of Biological Sciences, USM, Penang, Malaysia. Leaves were
dried at the room temperature and ground using an electric blender. The powdered plant material
(50 g) was added with 1000 ml distilled water and placed in a water bath at 40 ° C for 10 h. The
aqueous extract was seived with a filter paper and kept at 4 °C for cytological studies. The stock
aqueous extract of C. asiatica at 100% was diluted to 6.25% , 12.5 % , 25 % and 50 % for the
mutagenic evaluation after 24 and 48 hrs (Akinboro et al., 2011a & b).
The antimutagenic test was similar to the mutagenic evaluation except that 0.1 %
cyclophosphamide (CP) was added to the water extract. Distilled water and cyclophophamide
served as the negative and postive controls, respectively. Root tips were processed for the slide
preparation and scoring as previously described (Akinboro et al., 2011a & b; Akinboro et al.,
2012). Mitotic index (MI), CA percentage and reduction percentage of CP-induced CA were
calculated as follows:
MI = × 100
Where A = Number of dividing cells, B = Total number of counted cells.
CA =
× 100
Where A = Number of aberrant cells , B = Total number of counted cells.
Reduction of CP-induced CA (%) =
Where A = Proportion of CA in the MI induced by the positive control (CP) , B = Proportion of
CA in the MI induced by the mixture of CP and aqueous extract of C. asiatica, C = Proportion of
CA in the MI induced by the negative control (distilled water).
Data were analyzed for the level of significance set at P ≤ 0.05 using Duncan’s multiple range
comparison in One-way ANOVA using SPSS version 18.0.
RESULTS
The effects of water extract of Centella asiatica on cell division in the root tips of the exposed
onions for 24 and 48 hrs are shown in Figure 1. There was a significant reduction (p ≤ 0.05) in
the mitotic index (MI) at the tested concentrations when compared to the negative control. After
48 hrs., the water extract at 12.5 % produced highest MI of 3.69%, where as, there was a
complete arrest (0%) of cell division at 100% concentration. The MI values at 6.25% and 25%
concentrations after 24 hrs. were 3.13%, 2.52%, respectively which were more than those
obtained after 48 hrs. However, 1.62% MI obtained at 50.0% concentration after 48 hours was
46
lower than 0.35% MI recorded after 24 hrs. The positive control produced 2.30% and 1.93% MI
values after 24 and 48 hrs., respectively.
Figure 1. Mitotic indices induced by water extract of Centella asiatica in Allium cepa cells after
24 and 48 hours of planting. Asterisked MI values are significantly different from the negative
control (24 hrs. planting time) at p ≤ 0.05.
The water extract of Centella asiatica induced different types of chromosomal aberrations (CA)
such as disturbed spindles, laggard chromosome, anaphase bridge, sticky bridge polyploid and
fragmentations as presented in Figure 2. Highest CA percentage was 1.40% induced by 0.1%
cylophosphamide after 48 hrs. No CA was observed at 100% concentration. After 24 and 48 hrs.
of planting at 50.0% concentration, and after 48 hrs. of planting at 6.25% and 25.0%
concentrations, there was induction of significantly lower percentages of CA compared to the
negative control. However, the percentage CA at 12.5% concentration was not sigficantly
different from the negative control (p ≥ 0.05).
47
Figure 2: Chromosomal aberrations induced by water extract of Centella asiatica in Allium cepa
after 24 and 48 hours of planting. CA percentages with different alphabelt are significantly
different at p ≤ 0.05.
Table 1 has the reduction percentage of CP-induced chromosomal aberrations (CA). The highest
reduction percentage of 92.86% was recorded at 6.25% concentration, while the least percentage
reduction of CA was 53.57% recorded at 50.0% concentration. The percentage reduction of CA
at 100.0% could not be calculated because there was no dividing cells at this concentration. The
manner of reduction of CP-induced CA by the water extract of C. asiatica was inversely
proportional to the concentrations except at 25.0% concetration which caused 89.29% reduction.
Table 1: Antimutagenic activity of water extract of Centella asiatica against CP-induced
chromosomal aberrations in A. cepa cells.
Concentration (%)
Mitotic
(%)
index % Chromosomal CA/ MI
aberrations
% reduction of
CP-induced CA
Distilled water
3.93
0.58
0.15
-
Cyclophosphamide 2.31
1.00
0.43
-
6.25 + CP
3.13
0.52
0.17
92.86
12.5 + CP
2.22
0.52
0.23
71.43
25.0 + CP
2.52
0.46
0.18
89.29
50.0 + CP
0.33
0.19
0.58
53.57
100.0 + CP
0.0
0.0
0.0
TA
TA: Total arrest of cell division; CA: Chromosomal aberration; MI: Mitotic index; CP:
Cyclophosphamide.
DISCUSSION
The water extract of C. asiatica at the tested concentrations signficantly reduced the number of
dividing cells in the root tips of A. cepa compared to the MI values of distilled water group after
24 and 48 hrs of the treatment. This effect was mitostatic in A. cepa cells, and its total arrest of
48
cell division at 100% could mean cytotoxic through the induction of cell death. The results of
similar investigation (Seema and Meena, 2012) using the cultured human peripheral blood
lymphocytes in vitro assay was in contrary to our results of this in vivo Allium cepa assay. This
disperity could be due to the series of metabolic enzymatic reactions on the aqueous extract of C.
asiatica to produce cytotoxic metabolites that were capable of causing non continous
interferrence with the progression of cell cycle in the root tip of A. cepa. However, this
inconsistent increase and decrease in the MI values after 24 and 48 hrs of root growth at the
tested concentrations except at 100% was an indication of mitostatic effect, possibly to be
observed with the non continuous use of aqueous extract of C. asiatica as a food or medicinal
herb.
Aside the evaluation of the aqueous extract on the cell division in A. cepa cells, induction of
chromosomal aberrations was also used in this study to determine its mutagenic effect. The
frequency of aberrant cells observed in non-concentration dependent manner, and which were
not significantly different from the negative control except at 50% suggests lack of mutagenic
activities in the in vivo A. cepa assay. This was in accordance with the previous results of in vitro
genotoxic investigations of the extract of C. asiatica on; cultured human lymphocytes (
Siddique, 2008; Siddique et al., 2009) and human peripheral blood lymphocytes (Seema and
Meena, 2012). The antimutagenic activity of the aqueous extract against cyclophosphamideinduced mutagenicity was similar to the earlier reports. The suppression of mutagenicity of
cyclophosphamide above 50% at the tested concentrations, except 100%, ( where to total arrest
of cell dividion was observed) could be considered a strong antimutagenic effect. It is possible
that metabolic activation of cyclophosphamide to free radicals (that are mutagenic metabolites)
was perfectly inhibited by the aqueous extract of C. asiatica through its free-radcals scanvenging
phenolic compounds with antioxidant properties (Siddique et al., 2008; Siddique 2009).
CONCLUSION
This study revealed that the effect of water extract of C. asiatica on cell division in A. cepa was
mitostatic and not cytotoxic except at 100% concentration. Its activity on the chromosomes of
the treated cells was not mutagenic. However, it showed strong antimutagenic effectivness
against cyclophosphamide-induced chromosomal aberrations in the A. cepa cells, suggesting its
possible use as a promising anticancer chemotherapy.
REFERENCES
Akinboro, A., & Bakare, A. A. (2007). Cytotoxic and genotoxic effects of aqueous extracts of
five medicinal plants on Allium cepa Linn. Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 112(3), 470475.
Akinboro, A., Mohamed, K. B., Asmawi, M. Z., & Sofiman, O. A. (2011a). Mutagenic and
antimutagenic potentials of fruit juices of five medicinal plants in Allium cepa L.:
Possible influence of DPPH free radical scavengers. African Journal of Biotechnology,
10(51), 10520-10529.
Akinboro, A., Kamaruzaman, B.M., Zaini, M.A., Shaida, F.S. & Sofiman, O.A. (2011b).
49
Antioxidants in aqueous extract of Myristica fragrans (Houtt.) suppress mitosis and
cyclophosphamide-induced chromosomal aberrations in Allium cepa L. cells. Journal of
Zhejiang University-SCIENCE B (Biomedicine & Biotechnology), 12(11):915-922.
Akinboro, A., Kamaruzaman B. M., Mohd Zaini, A., Ahmad, S.O., Tang, H.Y. Siti Marina,
M. (2012). Mutagenic and antimutagenic assessment of methanol leaf extract of
Myristica fragrans (Houtt.) using in vitro and in vivo genetic assays. Drug and Chemical
Toxicology, Vol. 35 (4), 412-422.
Babu, T.D., Kuttar, G., & Padikkla, J. (1995). Cytotoxic and antitumour properties of certain
taxa of umbelliferae with special reference to Centella asiatica (L.) Urban. Journal of
Ethnopharmacology 48, 53-57.
Schimmer, O., Kruger, A., & Paulini, H. (1994). An evaluation of the 55 commercial plant
extracts in the Ames mutagenicity test. Pharmazie. 49(6): 448-451.
Seema, C.C., & Meena, V. (2012). Cytotoxic and genotoxic effects of Centella asiatica
extract in the cultured human peripheral blood lymphocytes. Research in Pharmacy, 2(4):
31-40.
Siddique, Y.H., Ara, G., Beg, T., Faisal, M., Ahmad, M., & Afzal, M. (2007). Protective role
of Centella asiatica L. extract against methyl methanesulphonate and
cyclophosphamide induced genotoxic damage in cultured human lymphocytes. Recent
Progress in Medicinal Plants 19, 369–381.
Siddique, Y.H., Beg, T., & Afzal, M. (2008). Antigenotoxic effect of ascorbic acid against
cypropterone acetate induced genotoxicity in cultured mammalian cells. In: Recent
Trends in Toxicology, YH. Siddique (Eds), Transworld Research Network, Trivandpuram,
Kerala, India. 85-94.
Siddique, Y.H., Beg, T., & Afzal, M. (2009). Effect of Centella asiatica L. Extract against
ethinylestradiol induced genotoxic damage on cultured human lymphocytes.
Biomedical Research, 20 (2): 141-147.
PGB03
INDUCED GENETIC VARIABILITY IN SESAME (SESAMUM INDICUM(L) USING
FAST NEUTRON IRRADIATION AND SODIUM AZIDE.
Gado, A.A1., Falusi O.A2., Muhammad,L.M2., Daudu, O.A.Y2 and Abejide,D.R2
1
Department of Biology, Federal College of Education, Kontagora,Niger State,Nigeria.
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Federal University of Technology,Minna,Niger state
Corresponding email:ayishatmoh@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
50
Induced Genetic variability’s in sesame was studied. Variety kenena-4 was exposed to fast
neutron irradiation (FNI) from an Am-Be source with a flux of 1.5×104 ncm-2 s-1, using doses of
0,4,8,12 and 16µsv and also treated with sodium azide using doses of
0.0%,0.2%,0.4%,0.6%,0.8%. Plant height, survival percentage, length of petiole, number of
leaves
per
plant
and
leave
surface
area
were
observed
for quantitative character .There were significant differences (at p<0.05) in kenana-4 at different
doses of fast neutron irradiation and sodium azide with most of the parameters used. Both
radiation and chemical showed negative correlation with most of the parameters used.
Key words: Mutagenesis, FNI, sodium azide, sesame.
INTRODUCTION
Sesame is considered to be the oldest oilseed crop known to man. The crop has been
domesticated well over 5000 years (Bisht et al.,1998). It belongs to the family Pedaliaceae and
genus Sesamum. The genus consist of about 36 species out of which the commonly recognized is
Sesamum indicum L. (Falusi, 2006). Sesamum indicum is very drought tolerant. It has been
called a survivor crop because of its ability to grow where most plants fail. The crop is believed
to have originated from Africa where the greatest diversity of the genus sesame and its family
Pedaliaceae is present (Falusi and Salako, 2003). Some of the local names of the crop in Nigeria
are (“Ridi” Hausa) (“Ishwa” Tiv), (“Gorigo” Igbira), (“Eeku” Yoruba) and (“Doo”Jukun) (Falusi
et al, 2001)
Currently it is cultivated in the tropical and sub tropical region of Africa, South America, North
America and Asia principally for its seeds which contains about 50-52 % oil, 17-19 % Protein
and 16-18 % carbon hydrate ( Falusi and Salako, 2003 ).It is an annual plant growing to 50 100cm (1.6 to 3.3 ft )tall, with opposite leaves 4 -14cm (1.6 - 55in) long with an entire margin
:they are broad lanceolate, to 5cm(2in) broad at the base of the plant, narrowing to just 1 cm
(0.4in) broad on the flowering stem . The flowers are yellow, tabular, 3 to 5cm (1.2 to 2.0m)
long, with four lobed mouths. The flower may vary in colour with some being white, blue or
purple. Sesame fruit is a capsule, normally pubescent, rectangular in section and typically
grooved with a short triangular beak. The length of the fruit capsule varies from 2 to 8 cm. Its
width varies between 0.5 to 2cm, and the number loculi from 4 to 12. The fruit naturally splits
opens (dehisces) to release the seed by splitting along the septa from top to bottom or by means
of two apical pores, depending on the varietal cultivar. Sesame seeds are small, about
3to4millimeter long by 2millimeter wide and 1millimeter thick. The seeds are ovate, slightly
flattened and somewhat thinner at the eye of the seed(helium)than the opposite end with the
weight of the seed between 20to 40 milligrams. Sesame is grown primarily for it’s oil-rich seeds.
The oil is used locally for cooking as well as for medicinal purposes such as the treatment of
ulcers and burns. The stem and the oil extracts are equally used in making local soup.The
products are locally processed and utilized in various forms. Principally among the products are
“KATUN RIDI” and “KANUN RIDI”. After oil has been extracted from the seeds, the cake is
made into “Kuli Kuli” which together with the leaves are used to prepare local soup known as
“MIYAR TAUSHE”. Artificial induction of mutation is of scientific and commercial interest as
it is one of the methods used in improving the growth and yield of economic plants. It provides
raw materials for the genetic improvement of economic crops (Adamu et al., 2004). Although
various mutagens were known to induce mutation in plants, this work has made use of fast
neutron and sodium azide in inducing genetic variability through mutagenesis to improve both
51
the quality and quantity of sesame. The aim of the present study is to induce mutation through
the use of various concentrations of sodium azide and fast neutron in sesame (S. indicum L. Var.
Kenana-4) to improve the quality and quantity of the plants.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was carried out at the experimental garden; Centre for Preliminary and Extra-mural
Studies, Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria.
The seeds were obtained at National Cereal Research Institute (NCRI)
Baddegi, Niger State.
The seeds were irradiated with fast neutron at the Centre for Energy and Research training
(CERT), Ahmadu Bello University Zaria, Kaduna state, Nigeria. Kenana 4 was subjected to
different doses of fast neutron. The variety was divided into five equal parts and exposed to 0,
4,8,12 and16µsv.
Sodium azide was used to treat the seeds, there were five different concentrations,
0%,0.2%,0.4%,0.6%,0.8%. Sodium azide was diluted to the required concentration by using
distilled H2O.Seeds were soaked in the H2O for six hours to initiate Biochemical reaction. The
chemical reaction is found to be affected by the frequency and spectrum of mutagens depending
on the type of cell division during the process of germination. If the chemical treatment is
synchronized with DNA synthesis stage (G1, s and G2) then we get better results.
The presoaked seeds were put in flask and Sodium azide was added and left for eight hours.
Usually the quantity of Sodium azide 10 times the volume of the seeds. Intermittent shaken was
given to ensure uniform exposure of the chemicals. The chemical was drained after the treatment
time is over. The seeds were washed immediately not less than 30mins.
Two factors were involved; the variety and irradiation for physical, variety and sodium azide for
the chemical. Factorial design was adopted with two (2) plants per pot with a total of 15
combinations per plot. The arrangement used was randomized block design with thirty (30) pots
per block (figure 1).The experiment was replicated in three making a total of 90 pots for physical
and 90 pots for chemical. Ten seeds were planted per pot (i.e. five per hole in a pot).Three weeks
after planting; each pot was thinned to two plants per pot. A total of eight (8) pots for each
treatment combination were used.
The following data were taken during the period of study;
Plant height at 2, and 4weeks after planting and at maturity: The distance from ground level up to
the terminal bud on main axis of a plant in cm using metre rule, length of petiole(cm) using
metre rule, leaf surface area in cm2.Survival rate 21 days after planting: this was taken in
percentage. The result of this research was subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) to show
whether there were significant differences among the morphological parameters and yield
parameters. Duncan multiple range was used to separate the means. The survival rate, flowering
percentage and the spearman rank correlation was used to show the relationship between the
treatments and parameters.
RESULTS
52
For the effect of fast neutron irradiation kenana 4 variety at 2 weeks, 0usv assumed the highest
with a mean of 6.87a, Followed by 8usv, 12usv, 16usv and the least was recorded in 4usv with
the mean of 5.67a and there were no significant difference observed in the various doses at
p<0.05, but there was a negatively very weak correlation(-0.148). At 4 week 12usv showed the
highest plant height with the mean of 25.73a, then 0usv, 4usv, 8usv, and the least was recorded
in 16usv with a mean of 20.93b. There were significant difference observed between 12usv and
all other doses at p<0.05. There was a negatively weak (-0.287) not significant correlation
between the doses and the plant height However, at 6 week 12usv assumed the highest height
(70.25a) than other doses, while the least was recorded in 16usv. With the mean of (53.60b).
There were significant difference observed between 12usv and the other doses (0usv, 4usv, 8usv,
16usv) at p<0.05. But there was a positively weak correlation (0.100) and not significant. For the
effect of sodium Azide on plant height at 2 weeks variety kenana 4 treated with 0.2% and 0.8%
were significantly different from 0.4%, 0.6% and 0.0% (controls) with the means of (6.45a and
6.20a) respectively while the lowest was 0.6% with the mean of (3.80b).The correlation was a
weak positive correlation (0.238) and not significant.At 4th week 0.6% recorded the least plant
height with the mean of 12.64c, while 0.0% (control) has the highest mean (23.78a) followed by
0.2%, 0.4% and 0.8%. 0.0% and 0.2% were statistically different with the other doses at p<0.05.
The correlation was a strong negative correlation (-0.757) and was not significant.At 6th week,
0.2% had the highest mean of (58.29a) followed by 0.0%, 0.8%, 0.6% and 0.4% recorded the
lowest mean of (45.36b). A modest negative correlation (-0.629) not significant was recorded.
0.2% and 0.0% were statistically different from the other doses at p<0.05.
For the effect of fast neutron irradiation (FNI) on the number of leaves per plant kenana 4, 16usv
assumed the highest (11.10a) and the least recorded 4usv(9.80a). But there were no statistical
difference in all the doses at p<0.05. There was a strong positive correlation and not significant
(0.827).
For the effect of sodium Azide on the number of leaves per plant in kenana 4, 0.2% has the
highest number of leaves (27.30a) and the least was recorded in 0.0% (control) with the mean of
(10.20c) 0.2% and 0.4% were statistically different from the other doses 0.8%, 0.6% and 0.0% at
p≤0.05. The correlation was a weak positive correlation (0.278).
Kenana 4, radiated at 12usv had the longest petiole (5.10a) followed by 4usv, 8usv, 0usv and the
least was 16usv with the mean of (2.18c). There were statistical difference between 12usv and
the other doses at p<0.05. The correlation was a negative weak correlation and not significant.
For the effect of sodium Azide, kenana 4 treated with 0.0% had longest petiole (2.90a) the least
was recorded in 0.6% with the mean of (1.11b). There were statistical difference between 0.0%
and the other doses at p≤0.05. The correlation was a negative modest correlation and not
significant.
For the effect of fast neutron irradiation (FNI) kenana 4, 0usv had the highest leave surface
area(42.18a) and the least was 16usv(25.61c). There were statistical difference in all the doses at
p<0.05. There was a weak negative correlation (-0.417) and not significant
For the effect of sodium Azide in kenana 4, 0.0% had the highest leave surface area (42.18a)
and the least was recorded in 0.6% with the mean of (27.11b) there were statistically different
53
between 0.0% and all the other doses at p≤0.05. The correlation was a weak negative correlation
(-0.315) and not significant.
For the effect of fast neutron irradiation on survival percentage, 16usv and 8usv in kenana 4
performed better (53% and 50%) than the control 0usv (45%). For the effect of sodium azide on
survival percentage in kenena 4 0.8%,0.2% and 0.6% (93%,73%and 50%)performed better than
the control(45%).
Table 1: Some morphological parameters of the Kenana-4 variety at different doses
TREATME
NT
FAST
NEUTRON
Ke0
Ke4
Ke8
Ke12
Ke16
SODIUM
AZIDE
Ke0
PLANT
HEIGHT
2
WEEKS
6.87±1.7
6a
5.67±1.4
2a
6.70±1.6
8a
6.63±1.3
5a
6.16±1.8
9a
4 WEEKS
6 WEEKS
23.78±1.74
ab
23.71±3.80
ab
21.22±2.83
b
25.73±3.45
a
20.93±2.57
b
57.30±14.99
ab
58.89±17.7a
b
61.50±17.10
ab
70.25±20.93
a
53.60±13.83
b
NO. OF
LEAVES
PER
PLANT
LENGTH
OF
PETIOLE
LEAVE
SURFACE
AREA
10.20±1.22a
2.90±0.96
bc
3.84±1.32
b
3.45±0.84
b
5.10±1.55
a
2.18±0.50
c
42.18±12.63
a
38.18±4.79a
b
37.43±23.57
ab
30.95±2.50a
b
25.61±9.84c
9.80±1.54a
10.90±1.59a
10.90±1.72a
11.10±1.37a
3.90±0.6 23.78±5.32 57.30±14.99 10.20±1.22c 2.90±0.96 42.18±12.63
8b
a
a
a
a
Ke2
6.45±1.3 22.60±5.39 58.29±15.47 27.30±7.74a 2.23±0.92 38.70±4.85a
7a
a
a
ab
b
Ke4
4.29±1.1 21.97±5.73 45.36±10.80 25.00±7.87a 1.09±0.16 39.93±22.63
8b
ab
b
b
a
Ke6
3.80±1.1 12.64±5.06 48.60±7.67a 16.60±10.37 1.11±0.32 27.11±2.93b
5b
c
b
bc
b
Ke8
6.20±1.1 17.80±3.88 51.05±13.07 21.60±11.22 2.39±3.37 32.05±8.56a
2a
b
ab
ab
ab
b
*Values are mean±SD. Values followed by the same letter(s) within the same row do not
statistically differ at the 5% level according to DMRT
54
Figure 4.1: Survival Percentages of Kenana-4 at different doses of FNI
Figure 2: Survival Percentages of kenana-4 at different concentration of sodium azide
DISCUSSION
Mutation induction through the use of different concentrations of sodium azide and fast neutron
irradiation has proved vital in inducing variability that could be exploited in the improvements of
sesame growth and yields. It is therefore the origin of genetic variability as suggested by
Tamarin (1999). The mean increase in plants heights at maturity of the sesame variety induced
55
by sodium was due to the alteration of their genome integrated by environmental signals as
reported by Uno et al. (2001); probably by increasing the rates of cellular division and expansion
at their meristematic regions. This is also in agreement with the findings of Hoballah (1999) who
reported increased in plant heights of sesame due to radiation mutagenesis; but is in contrast to
the findings of Anandakumar and Sree- Rangasamy (1995) and Maluszynski et al. (2001) who
independently reported decrease in plant height due to induced mutation in rice and other cereals.
The increase in leaf number and internodes length with decrease in the concentrations of
colchicines was in agreement with the findings of Hoballah (1999) who reported increased in
leaf number and internodes length among sesame mutants due to gamma irradiation. The
increase in the leaf area of sesame due to colchicines means an increase in the surface area for
gaseous ex-change which consequently affects the photosynthetic process. This agrees with the
work of Maluszynski et al. (2001) who reported increase in the leaf area among Zea mays
mutants due to irradiation. Artificial induction of mutation through the use of sodium azide
proves vital in the improvement of genetic variability in sesame. Certain concentrations of
sodium azide (0.2 through 2.0mM colchicines concentration) have the potentiality of inducing
variability that could be used in the improvement of the yield of sesame.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors wish to thank the Department of Biological Sciences, Federal university of
Technology Minna for the assistance rendered to perform the experiment
REFERENCES
Adamu, A. K., Chung, S. S., and Abubakar, S. (2004): The effect of ionizing radiation
(Gammarays) on tomato (s.n.). Nigerian Journal of Experimental Biology, 5(2):185-193
Anandakumar, C. R, and Sree-Rangasamy, S. R. (1995): Heterosis and selection indices in rice.
Egyptian Journal of Genetics and Cytology, 14:123-132.Bisht, I.S., Mahajan, R.K.,
Loknathan, T.R. &Agrawal, R.C. (1998). Diversity in Indian sesamecollection and
stratification of germplasmaccessions in different diversity groups. Genetic Resource and
Crop Evolution 45(4), 325-335.Falusi, O. A. (2006). Estimation of natural cross
pollination in two species of the genus Sesamum(pedaliacea), Production Agriculture
and Technology 2(2):61-65.ISSN:07945213.
Falusi, O.A. and Salako, E.A. (2003). Inheritance studies in wild and cultivated Sesamum L.
Speciesin Nigeria. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture.22 (3):75-90.
Falusi, O.A., Salako, E.A. and Ishaq, M.N. (2001). Interspecific hybridization between
Sesamumindicum L. and CerathothecasesamoidesEndl.Tropicultura, P.127.
Hoballah, A. A. (1999): Selection and Agronomic evaluation of induced mutant lines of sesame.
In: Induced Mutations for Sesame Improvement IAEA-TECDOC, IAEA,Vienna, pp 71#
84.
Maluszynski, M., Szarejko, I., Barriga, P., and Balcerzyk, A. (2001): Heterosis in crop mutant
crosses and production of high yielding lines, using doubled haploid systems.Euphytica,
120: 387-398.
Tamarin, R.H. (1999): Principles of Genetics, 6th ed, WCB/McGraw Hill.NY pp1-684.
Uno, G., Storey, R. and Moore, R. (2001): Principles of Botany. Mc Graw Hill New York 1
550pp.
56
PGB04
GROWTH
PUMPKIN
AND
REPRODUCTIVE CHARACTERISTICS OF INBRED FLUTED
(TELFAIRIA OCCIDENTALIS HOOK.)
Nwonuala, A. I.1* and Opukiri, S.B.2
1
Department of Crop /Soil Science, Rivers State University of Science and Technology,
NkpoluPort Harcourt, Nigeria
2
Department of Crop
Amassoma, Nigeria
Production Technology, Niger Delta University, Wilberforce Island,
*Corresponding email:opunemi@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Landraces from five states of Anambra (AN), Imo (IM), Abia (AB), Enugu (EN) and Rivers
(RV) in South Eastern Agro-ecology of Nigeria were collected and established ex-situ at the
Teaching and Research Farm in Federal University of Technology, Owerri between 2003 and
2004 cropping seasons. Selected plants of each parent landraces were selfed and the growth and
reproductive characteristics of individual inbreds assessed. The Abia inbred (AB/AB) performed
better than all other inbreds. They produced the longest vine length plant -1, highest number of
branches and nodes plant -1, internode length and leaf number plant -1 at 6 weeks after planting
(6WAP). The male (AB) inbred also flowered earlier (10WAP) than other inbreds while those of
(AN) flowered later (13 WAP) than the rest. The female Anambra inbreds flowered earlier
(12WAP) than other female inbreds while those of Rivers flowered last (16WAP). The highest
number of female flowers plant-1 (150) was obtained from Anambra inbreds and their fruits also
matured (13WAP) earlier than others while the female Abia inbreds had the least number of
flowers and fruits which also matured last (18WAP). Our findings showed potential for genetic
enhancement of fluted pumpkin of different landraces from this ecological zone.
INTRODUCTION
Telfairia occidentalis belongs to the genus Telfaira Hooker, Tribe Joliffeae, sub-family
Cucurbitoideae and family Cucurbitaceae (Jeffrey, 1980).
It is an important crop in Tropical West Africa, especially in Nigeria, Sierra Leone, Ghana and
Benin Republic where it is used as food and as commercial garden vegetable (Purseglove, 1968;
Irvine, 1969; Eziaba, 1982). In Nigeria, according to Akoroda, (1990) the largest diversity in
plant population of this crop can be found in the South-Eastern Agroecology encompassing Imo,
Anambra, Enugu, Ebonyi, Cross-River, Akwa-Ibom and Abia states of Nigeria. The edible parts
include the young vines or shoots, leaves, seeds and petiole and are important sources of
carbohydrate, protein vitamins and minerals (Achinewhu, 1993; Asiegbu, 1987). In a survey on
the pattern of consumption of leafy vegetables in Nigeria, Hart et al. (2005) gave the per capita
consumption as 91-130kg. This range was reported to be among the highest in Africa and fluted
pumpkin was also listed among the Regionally Consumed Indigenous and Traditional Leafy
Vegetables for West Africa, (Smith and Pablo 2007). The oily seeds apart from nutritional
57
properties also have lactating properties while the root extracts are used to kill rats, mice and fish
(Schipper, 2000). Now, the economic and nutritional benefits of blending fluted pumpkin seed
into wheat flour for bread because of its nutritional value has been revealed in Nigerian economy
(Giami et al.,2003).
The plant is dioecious having only staminate (male) flower or the pistilate (female) flower on
individual plants. This makes T. occidentalis 100% cross-pollinated and thus characterized by
high genetic variability. The land races of cross-pollinators are heterogeneous genetically and
form a relative continuum of agronomic types in the field (Heiser, 1981) According to
Thompson (1976) and Izumolu (1987), the agronomic problem encountered when growing T.
occidentalis is that the plants exhibit variations in many quantitative and qualitative characters.
These variations, they reported, are expressed in their differences in stem length, number of
leaves, length and size of pods, time of pod maturity and effective duration of vegetative growth.
The main benefit of hybridization is to eliminate variability and to produce seeds that produce
fairly uniform plants with high yields. (Kuckuch et al.,1991). In Cucurbita, demand for
uniformity and selection had resulted in high homozygosity and true breeding cultivars. Inbred
lines have been used to develop hybrids which were more uniform and homogenous, than openpollinated cultivars (Paris, 1989). Cucurbita like Telfairia belongs to the same family of
Cucurbitaceae. Very limited research has been targeted on the genetic enhancement of T.
occidentalis.
This work reports on the growth and reproductive characteristics of inbred
landraces targeted for use in hybridization of. T. occidentalis.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Two field experiments were conducted in 2003 and 2004 at the Teaching and Research Farm of
the Federal University of Technology Owerri, located at latitude 5.290 N and longitude 7. 020 E
and 17 meters above sea level. The rainfall pattern is bimodal with peaks in June and October
while the dry season falls within November and February. The mean annual rainfall varies and
ranges between 2000 and 2400mm while the annual mean temperature ranges between 25 and 28
0
C. Sunshine averages 4.2 hours per day, ranging from 2 hours in September to 6.1 hours in
February (FAO 1984).
The soils are generally classified as sandy ultisols (Vine, 1970 Hulugalle et al, 1990; Eshett and
Anyahucha, 1992.)
The treatment for the experiment consists of twenty fruits of traditional landrace morphotypes of
T.occidentalis obtained locally from selected home gardens within five states in South-Eastern
agro-ecological zones of Nigeria. Four fruits were obtained from each of the states which are
centers of genetic variability, which include Imo (IM), Abia (AB), Anambra (AN) Enugu (EN)
and Rivers (RV) and were characterized for length, width and circumference. These were split
open and the seeds scooped, processed, counted and bulked. The seeds were then weighed and
fairly uniform seeds of same weights (12 + 0.5g) were selected and used. These treatment lots
were randomized in plots and replicated four times in a Randomized Complete Block Design
(RCBD) according to the methods described by Wahua (1999) and SPSS (2006) for Randomized
Complete Block experiments. The seeds were planted on ridges at a rate of one seed per hole at
a depth of 5cm and with a spacing of 2 x 2m between and within rows. Selfing among selected
male and female plants from each treatment population was carried out in the field. In the
58
process, immature buds of the female parents were protected from foreign pollen with pollination
bags till they were matured and receptive. Pollen from the selected male parents were then
collected and shed on the receptive stigma. Parents were selected on the basis of superior growth
rate, early flowering and increase in leaf size. In addition the male parents were selected for
fewer number of tendrils and flowers.
The selfed plants were labeled accordingly and their fruits harvested at maturity as S1 (selfed)
progenies. The seeds of S1 progenies produced were planted out the following year (2004) and
evaluated to identify promising S1 families based on vegetative and reproductive yield.
characteristics. Data collated from the field were subjected to Statistical Analysis (descriptive
and bivariate statistics), using the SPSS 15.0., (2006) Evaluation version for windows.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
It is desirous that vegetable production be profitable during the early stages of growth therefore
growth characteristics and leaf yield within 6 weeks after planting T. occidentalis is important.
The result of the vegetative characteristics and leaf yield of inbred T. occidentalis at 6 WAP is as
shown in Table 1.
The AN/AN inbred had the longest vine length of 120cm which was not different from those of
AB/AB and IM/IM but differed significantly from those of EN/EN and RV/RV inbreds which
had the shortest vine length of 87.8 and 87.8cm at 6 weeks after planting (6WAP). The internode
was also significantly the longest (15.8cm) from AB/AB inbreds. Similarly, the number of
branches (6.3) which was produced by the AB/AB inbreds was significantly different from other
inbreds except EN/EN that had 4.2 branches at 6WAP. The lowest number of branches 2.3 was
produced by RV/RV which however, did not differ from IM/IM and AN/AN that had 3.0 and
3.3, respectively.
The number of nodes and leaves plant -1 at 6WAP also followed the same trend with AB/AB
being consistently the highest and RV/RV the lowest.
The leaf area per plant did not differ amongst the inbreds which is an indication that the gene
controlling leaf area is fairly constant in all the landraces. The highest leaf yield of 109.5 kg ha-1
was however obtained from AB/AB inbred which was significantly different from the yield of all
other inbreds. This can simply be adduced to the significantly higher number of leaves per plant
(50) produced by the AB/AB inbreds.
S1
Inbred
Vine
length
(cm)
Internode
length
(cm)
No.of
Branches
Plant -1
EN/EN
AN/AN
AB/AB
IM/IM
87.8
120.0
115.0
113.3
7.3
7.5
15.8
9.3
4.3
3.3
6.3
3.0
No.
of No.
of Leaf
Nodes
leaves
area
Plant -1
Plant _1
Plant-1
(cm2
)
32.0
38.3
79.0
31.3
36.0
94.8
42.3
50.0
82.0
32.3
38.0
99.7
Leaf
yield
(kg)
-1
ha
68.0
45.5
109.5
55.3
59
RV/RV 87.0
11.0
2.3
26.0
31.3
92.9
LSD
40.3
5.41
2.51
6.47
9.22
29.66
0.05
Table1: Growth and leaf yield characteristics of T. occidentalis inbreds at 6WAP
4.0
7.01
Growth characteristics and leaf yield at 6 WAP were consistently the highest with AB/AB
inbreds while the RV/RV had the lowest. The vigor in growth characteristics recorded for the
AB selfed plants may be due to the fact that only physiologically good plants were selfed, this
according to (Assman,1970) can result in favorable gene combination that hastened the
physiological process that enhanced faster and better growth as manifested in the AB/AB plants
at the early growth stage. These growth characteristics of the inbred lines grown under the same
condition which revealed that the AB/AB plants had the most desired growth characteristics and
leaf yield than the other inbreds therefore lends itself for use as the best material for any
improvement program for increased vegetable production of T. occidentalis in Southern Nigeria.
The result of flowering and fruit yield characteristics of inbred lines of T. occidentalis as
presented in. Table 2 shows that the number of days to 50% flowering differed amongst the male
and female plants. Between the male plants AB/AB flowered earlier (69DAP) than other inbreds
but did not differ from that of EN/EN (70DAP). It is generally known that, male plants flower
earlier than their female counterparts in T. occidentalis. The inbred AN/AN female plant
flowered earliest (82.3DAP) to 50% flowering but was not significantly different from EN/EN,
IM/IM and AB/AB inbreds. The highest was with RV/RV which attained 50% flowering at
109DAP and differed significantly from the rest inbreds. Percent male and female plants also
differed significantly amongst the inbreds (Table2) AB/AB and RV/RV had more males than
females,whereas IM/IM and AN/AN had more females than males. The highest percent of
female plants 55% was obtained with EN/EN and the lowest (36%) was with RV/RV while it
was observed that equal proportions of male and female plants (48%) were obtained with
AN/AN. Plants with more females are preferred because of expected high yields of both leaf and
seeds. The number of matured fruit harvested from the inbreds also differed significantly, IM/IM
inbreds had the highest number of fruits (84) per treatment and the lowest number (44) was with
RV/ inbred.
The low number of matured fruits obtained by RV/RV can be attributed to the delayed
fertilization of the female flowers of RV/RV inbreds as a result longer days to the attainment of
50% female flower, moreover the short anthesis period of the male and female flower coupled
with the low number of female plants will definitely cause decrease in number of matured fruits.
The result on Fruit weight indicated that IM/IM inbred had the highest fruit weight of 7.3kg fruit1
followed by AB/AB and RV/RV which had 6.8 kg fruit -1 both and did not differ significantly
from EN/EN inbred.
Table 2: Flowering and fruit yield characteristics of T. occidentalis Inbreds
S1
Number of DAP No. of Days to Percent (%) No.
of Fruit
Inbred
to
end
of of Treatment Matured
weight
50%
flowering
Male
fruits
kg fruit-1
flowering
Male
Female
treatment -
No.
seeds
No.
Fruit-1
of
60
EN/EN
AN/AN
AB/AB
IM/IM
RV/RV
LSD
0.05
Male
Female
Female
70.0
92.0
93.7
82.3
69.0
85.7
91.0
94.0
89.7
109.0
13.13
16.5
107.3
141.7
120.0
114.3
95.3
145.3
111.3
146.7
114.7
156.0
40.0
24.78
1
36.0
55.0
48.0
48.0
60.0
40.0
47.0
53.0
61..0
36.0
1.49
1.60
60
4.6
42
58
4.1
47
48
6.8
58
84
7.3
69
44
6.8
75
2.92
2.23
14.67
CONCLUSION
It is important to make recommendation based upon the result of this experiment when the target
of any hybridization program is for the enhancement of vegetable and or fruit production of T.
occidentalis that the AB/AB followed by IM/IM inbred families will be better materials because
of the desirable performance across various growth and reproductive characteristics assessed.
These families can form the basic unit for selection and recombination with any other landrace.
Our findings showed potential for genetic enhancement of fluted pumpkin from different
landraces of this ecological zone, having identified desirable traits in the inbreds.
REFERENCES
Achinewhu, S.C.,1983. Ascorbic content of some Nigerian local fruits and vegetables. Qual
Plant. Plant foods for Human Nutrition.33; 261-266.
Akoroda, M. O., 1990. Seed production and breeding potential of fluted pumpkin(Telfairia
occidentalis Hook). Euphytica 49; 25-32.
Asiegbu, J.E.1987.Some Biochemical Evaluation of fluted pumpkin seed. J. Sci. Food Agric.
40.151155
Assman, E.1970. The principles of yield study. Pergamon Press, Oxford.
Eziaba, R.O.1982. Cultivating the fluted pumpkin in Nigeria. World Crops (UK), 34(2):70-72
Eshette, E.T. and Anejahucha, C.N.1992. Effect of low lime rates application on nodulation and
grain yield of Cowpea(Vigna unguiulata L. walp) and selected biochemical properties of a
sandy ultisol in Owerri, South Eastern Nigeria. Agronomic Africaine 4(1):75-78
Giami, S.Y.,Mepba, H. D, Kiin kabari, D.B.and Achinewhu S.C.,2003.Evaluation of nutritional
quality of
breads prepared from wheat- fluted pumpkin (Telfairia occidentalis
Hook. )
seed flour blends.
Plant foods for Human Nutrition 58 (3): 1-8, 2003.
61
Hart, A.D, Ajubuike C.U, Barimalaa, I. S and Achinewhu S.C., 2005:
Vegetable
consumption pattern of
households in selected areas of the old
Rivers State of
Nigeria. African J.
of
Food Agriculture
Nutrition and Development Online 2005;
5(1)
Irvine, E.I.1969. West African Crops, Vol.2. Oxford University Press,Oxford.
Jeffrey, J.1980, A review of the Cucurbitaceae. J. Linn Soc. Bot. 81:233-247
Kuckuck, H.G., Kobabe, G. and G.Wenzel,1991.Fundamentals of plant Breeding. Berlin
Springer
verlag
Paris, H.S. 1989. Historical records and development of edible cultivar groups of Cucurbita
pepo.(Cucurbitaceae) Econs. Bot,43 (4) 423-443
Purseglove, J.W.1989. Tropical Crops. Dicotyledons. London : Lomgmans Green and Co. Ltd.
Schippers, R. R. 2000, African indigenous vegetables. Chartham, UK. Natural Resource
Institute/ACP-EU Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation.
SPSS 15.0 Command Syntax Reference 2006, Evaluation Version Production Mode Facility.
PSS Inc., Chicago Ill.USA
Taylor, O.O.A., Fetuga, B.L, Oyenuga, V.A. 1983. Accumulation of mineral elements in five
tropical
leafy vegetables as influenced by Nitrogen fertilization and age. Scientia
Hortic.18.313-322.
Thompson, B.1976. The agronomic problem on growing vegetables for specific
outlets,Bull.12,Scottish Hort. Res. Inst. Assoc. 24:77-79
Vine, H.1970.Review of work on Nigeria soils. Report to the National Research Council
Committee on Tropical Soils, London
Wahua, T.A.T.1999. Applied statistics for specific scientific studies. Africa-Link Books, Ibadan.
PGB05
GENOTYPIC POTENTIAL FOR GERMINATION CAPACITY, GROWTH AND YIELD
IN SUGARCANE (SACCHARUM OFFICINARUM L.) GERMPLASM ACCESSIONS IN
A SAVANNA ECOLOGY OF NIGERIA
Kwajaffa, A.M.1, Olaoye, G.2 and Zakari, T.3
1
Department of Agricultural Science Education, Federal College of Education (Technical), PMB
1013 Potiskum – Yobe State.
2
Department of Agronomy, University of Ilorin PMB 1515, Ilorin Kwara State.
3
Lake Chad Research Institute, PMB 1293, Maiduguri, Borno State.
*Corresponding e-mail: ammkwajaffa@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Assessment of germplasm materials is a prerequisite for their utilization either as cultivars per se
or as parents in hybridization programme aimed at the development of future varieties. This
62
study was therefore conducted to evaluate germination capacity, growth and yield potentials in
thirty exotic sugarcane germplasm accessions and six check varieties in a Savanna ecology of
Nigeria, with the aim to identify superior clones that will be suitable for cultivation on the estates
or in a hybridization programme aimed at development of high yielding sugarcane varieties for
cultivation on the estates. The study was conducted at the Research Farm of the Unilorin, Sugar
Research Institute, Ilorin, Kwara State for two cropping seasons using a Randomized Complete
Block Design (RCBD) with three replications. Data were collected on germination count, tiller
count, number of stalks/stool, stalk length, stalk girth, number of internodes/stalk, internode
length, number of millable canes, single stalk weight and cane yield. Results showed that the
genotypes differed significantly (P<0.01) for the characters studied, with many of the
introductions showing superiority for cane yield ( t/ha-1) over the existing cultivars. Notable
among the accessions were DB 851062, KNB 9252, B93638 DB 7867 B 78697 and B 881607
with cane yield between 75 and 81t/ha-1, indicating that they could be utilize in hybridization
schemes to evolve superior progenies which can eventually replace the current low yielding
varieties on sugar estates in Nigeria.
Corresponding email: ammkwajaffa@yahoo.com; GSM: 08067953846
INTRODUCTION
The primary goal in germplasm evaluation is to assess them for their yield potentials and general
adaptation to the ecosystems where they are likely to be utilized either as variety per se or as
parents in hybridization programme. However, a major factor militating against the attainment of
a faster goal in sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum L.) breeding and varietal development in
Nigeria is due in part to lack of access to germplasm with high yield potential. For example,
majority of the parental clones which are currently used in hybridization in the two institutes
involved in sugarcane varietal development in Nigeria {National Cereals Research Institute
(NCRI) Badeggi and Unilorin Sugar Research Institute (USRI), Ilorin}, are old. Recently, the
National Sugar Development Council (NSDC), Abuja, imported over 100 exotic sugarcane
varieties intended for evaluation and selection of high yielding (cane yield and sucrose content)
genotypes for industrial cultivation on the estates. Therefore, selection of superior genotypes
from among the new exotic germplasm accessions either directly as industrial sugarcane varieties
or as parents in the development of adapted sugarcane varieties for Nigeria’s sugarcane
63
plantations, will increase the productivity of the existing varieties (50 -75 t/ha-1) to as high as
>100 t/ha-1 obtainable in other sugarcane producing countries in Africa.
From the breeding perspective, germplasm materials are also assessed for their breeding
behaviour with the objective of utilizing them as parents in hybridization for evolving new and
superior progenies intended to replace the existing cultivars. For example, previous evaluation of
germplasm accessions (Olaoye and Agbana, 1987; Olaoye and Fatunla, 1991; Olaoye, 1995;
2006) has succeeded in identifying superior genotypes that have been used as parents in
hybridization programme. The study reported here was therefore carried out to assess yield
potential and breeding values of thirty (30) exotic sugarcane germplasm accessions representing
batch one (1) of the accessions imported from Barbados (West indies).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Thirty (30) exotic sugarcane germplasm accessions representing the first batch of genetic
resources from Barbados (West Indies) and six (6) check standard varieties (as checks) were
evaluated at the Research Farm of the Unilorin Sugar Research Institute (USRI), Ilorin, Kwara
State in a typical Southern Guinea Savanna agro-ecological zone of Nigeria ( latitude 80 29N and
longitude 40 35E). Three (3) of the check varieties Co957, Co62175 and B47419 are commercial
varieties, while the remaining three (3) (ILS-001, ILS-002 and USRI/85/31) were developed at
USRI, two (ILS-001 and ILS-002) of which have already been released.
The rainfall pattern of the ecology is bimodal with the highest peak in July and September with a
break usually from mid-July and late August every year. The average annual precipitation of the
area is 1250-1500mm with temperature ranging from 19-330C. The accessions were obtained
from Josepdam Sugar Company Estate Bacita, Kwara State. The experimental design used was a
Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with three (3) replicates. The genetic materials
were planted in single row plots measuring (5m x 1.6m) that is 5m long and 1.6m wide, with
inter and intra-row spacing of 0.5m and inter plot spacing of 1m during 2010/2011 growing
seasons. Three (3) budded sugarcane sets were cut and laid in furrows at a depth of 15cm and
covered with soil. Pre-emergence herbicide was applied immediately after planting to control
weeds. Supplementary weeding was thereafter carried out as necessary throughout the period of
the experiment.
Fertilizer application was carried out as split-dosage at the recommended rate of 150kgN/ha. The
first dose was applied immediately after planting while the second dose was applied six (6)
64
months after the initial application. The fields were irrigated from November, 2010 through
April, 2011 to ensure adequate moisture supply throughout the period of the dry season and also
after harvest in December, 2011 to May, 2012 to sustain the ratoon crop until rains became
steady. Data were collected on germination percentage, tiller counts, number of stalks/stool, stalk
length (cm), stalk girth (cm) number of internodes/stalk, stalk length (m), number of millable
canes/plots, single stalk weight (kg) cane yield at harvest (t/ha-1) and cane yield in tones/hectare.
Germination and tiller counts as well as the number of stalks/stool were done by physical
examination and counting the buds that sprouted and shoots that developed. Stalk length (m)
internode length (cm) and stalk girth (cm) were carried out by measurement, using meter tape.
These were carried out at specific growth and developmental stages beginning from fourteen
days after planting (14DAP) at two-weekly intervals up to 42 DAP (germination) and three
months after planting (3MAP) to 12 MAP (tiller count and brix content). Millable cane
population was based on counting the number of matured stalks in a plot while the weight was
determined by weighing them on weighing scale and recorded in kilograms. The single stalk
weight was also recorded in kilograms while cane weights were converted into tones/hectare
(t/ha-1). The estimate of sugar contents was obtained by extracting the sucrose in the juice of the
matured and ripened stalks using hand punch and values read as degree brix (oBrix) with the aid
of a hand refractometer. The data collected were subjected to the analysis of variance (ANOVA).
Pertinent means were thereafter separated with least significant difference (LSD) according to
Steel and Torrie (1980).
RESULTS
Means, ranges in the means and coefficient of variation (%CV) for germination count, growth
characteristics as well as cane yield and related traits are presented in Table 1. Germination
count increased with increasing days from planting with the largest variation among the
genotypes recorded at 42DAP. Tiller count also showed similar trend, increasing with maturity
in all the genotypes. Brix reading increased with maturity period until 12 MAP but decreased at
harvest. The highest variability among the genotypes was recorded for cane yield followed by
millable cane population while the least variation was recorded for stalk length and stalk girth
respectively.
65
Mean germination and tiller counts in the thirty (30) exotic sugarcane germplasm accessions and
six (6) check varieties are presented in Table 2. The results showed that there were significant
differences among the genetic materials (P ≤ 0.05) at all the periods of observation. Accession B
85106 consistently had the highest number of germinated buds followed by varieties ILS-001
and USRI/85/31. Some of the accessions (KNB9211, BT74209, B76251, KNB92101, B881607,
B62163, B93638 and varieties ILS-002, Co-62175, and B 47419) had low germination count,
while accessions B 79474 and B76621 failed to germinate even14 DAP. Many of the genotypes
with high germination count also had high tiller counts. Consequently, three genotypes - KNB
9252, USRI 85/31 and DB 85106 in that order had high tiller counts which were superior to
those of other genotypes. Differences in tiller counts in respect of these genotypes and accession
B 82233 with the lowest tiller count at harvest were 99, 96 and 79 respectively.
The genotypes also differed significantly (<P 0.05) for stalk characteristics (Table 3). Var.
USRI/85/31 had the highest number of stalks/stool, followed by accessions DB85106, B93638,
B63118, B76621, B88107 in that order. Accession DB7867 had the longest stalk length followed
by accession DB8113 while accession KWB9252 had shortest stalk length. Accession DB7867
also had the thickest stalk-girth while accession BT871646 and var. Co957 which had 3.1cm
each had the thinnest girth. Accession B78697 had the highest number of internodes/stalk,
followed by accession B63118, while variety B47419 had the least number of internodes/stalk.
Accession B881607 had the longest internode while accessions D8687 and KNB 9252 had the
shortest internodes respectively.
Means for cane yield and related traits (Table 4), revealed significant differences (P ≤ 0.05)
among the genotypes for number of millable canes/plot, cane yield and brix reading while
differences among them was not significant for single stalk weight. Accession BT74209 had the
heaviest single stalk weight followed by accession B82238.Accessions BR 8230 and B80689 had
the highest sucrose content followed by accession BT74209 while accession B62163 had the
least sucrose content. Fifteen (15) genotypes which included eleven (11) accessions, yielded
between 90.3 (var. Co 957) and 99.8t/ha-1 (i.e. Accession D 8415). The differences between the
highest yielding and the five (5) poorest yielding genotypes (BR 8230, B 76621, B 85266, B
93638 and Co 62175) which recorded yields that were below 50t/ha-1, were 72.7, 70.6, 61.8, 60.5
66
and 58.6t/ha-1 respectively. Var. USRI/85/31 with the highest number of millable canes was the
third highest yielding genotypes. All the high yielding genotypes except D8687 also had high
brix content.
DISCUSSION
The results from this study revealed that the genotypes differed from one another for almost all
the characters except stalk length and single stalk weight (kg). This is in consonant with earlier
report of Nair et al., (1998) who reported that stalk length, and stalk weight have no contribution
to genetic variation because the genes controlling height and weight may be identical at the loci.
Similarly Olaoye and Fatunla (1991) hypothesized that the observed negative genetic variance
estimates recorded for stalk length and leaf length in sugarcane in their own study may probably
be due to absence of genetic variability for the two traits among the genotypes tested.
The significant difference observed for number of stalks/stool, stalk girth, number of
internodes/stalk and stalk length is also in conformity with the reports of James (1971), Singh et
al., (1981) and Kang et al., (1983). Furthermore, the variation observed in the number of
millable canes/plot and cane yield could be as a result of inherent genetic variability among the
genotypes which also agreed with reports of Lawrence and Sunnel (1997) as well as Bakshi and
Hemaprabha (1998) who reported in their independent studies on estimate of genetic variance in
sugarcane populations, confirmed that additive genetic variance estimates were responsible for
cane yield and sucrose contents.
CONCLUSION
The results obtained from this study revealed that most of the accessions were found superior
and acceptable to the existing varieties for germination, growth and yield characteristics. This
suggests that there is possibility of finding replacement to existing varieties which are low in
yielding ability. However, the identified genotypes still need to undergo further testing in the
ratoon crops in order to make a definite pronouncement of their potential either as cultivar per se
or as parents in breeding programme.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This study was carried out with grants received from the National Sugar Development Council
(NSDC), Abuja. The Institute is grateful for past and present support received from the Council.
67
We are also grateful for the assistance of our technical staff in trial establishment, maintenance
and data collection.
REFERENCES
Bakshi R. and G. Hemaprabha: Genetive variance for five traits in twelve hybrid groups of
sugarcane (Saccharum spp) hybrid sugarcane No. 3, 1998 pp 9-12.
James N. I. (1971). Yield components in Random and selected sugarcane populations. Crop Sci.
II pp 916-918.
Kang M. S., F. D. Miller and P. Y. Tai (1983). Genetic and phenotypic path analysis and
heritability in sugarcane. Crop Sci 23:643-647.
Lawrence M. J. and H. K. Sunnel (1997). Quantitative genetics of sugarcane II. The inheritance
of eleven agronomically imported sugar No. 1 pg 15-22.
Nair N. V. R. Balakrishnan and T. V. Screenivasan (1998). Variability for quantitative traits in
exotic hybrid germplasm of sugarcane. Gen Res and crop Evolution 45 (5), 459-463.
Olaoye, G. (1995). Evaluation of local sugarcane germplasm accessions. I. Breeding values in
main and ratoon crops. Nigerian Journal of Genetics. X: 14-22.
Olaoye, G. (2006). Yield potential of non-irrigated sugarcane germplasm accessions in a
savanna ecology of Nigeria. Moor Journal of Agric. Research. 7(2):59-75.
Olaoye, G and Agbana, S.B. (1988). Effect of planting time on productivity of sugarcane
inoculated with smut. Bangladesh Journal of Sugarcane 10: 47-54.
Olaoye G. and Fatunla T. (1991). Variance components heritability and repeatability of some
quantitative characters in sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum L.) Nigerian Journal of
Genetics Vol. VIII: 31-38.
Singh H. N, Singh W, and Singh T. K. (1981). Selection parameters in sugarcane (Saccharum
spp). Indian Journal of Agric Sci. 8 pp 562-566.
Steel R. G. D. and J. H. Terrie (1980). Principles and procedures of statistics. A Biometrical
Approach 2nd Ed. McGraw-Hill Book Coy pp 633.
68
Table 1: Means (SE+) ranges and coefficient of variation (%CV) for
germination, growth parameters, cane yield and related traits in 30
exotic sugarcane germplasm accessions and six check varieties (Ilorin, 2011).
Trait
Mean (+SE) Range %CV
Germination count (no) 14DAP
2.40+1.07
6
78.0
Germination count (no) 28DAP
8.81+2.30
16
45.0
Germination count (no) 42DAP
20.06+4.08
31
35.0
Tiller count (no) 3MAP
36.56+5.15
64
24.0
Tiller count (no) 6MAP
45.82+6.44
79
24.0
Tiller count (no) 9MAP
52.39+7.07
84
23.0
Tiller count (no) 12MAP
61.94+7.90
99
22.0
o
Brix reading 8MAP
17.38+0.81
4
8.0
o
Brix reading 9MAP
17.85+0.77
5
8.0
o
Brix reading 10MAP
18.56+0.84
4
8.0
o
Brix reading 11MAP
18.67+1.05
4
10.0
o
11rix reading 12MAP
20.00+1.28
4
16.0
o
Brix reading at harvest
21.48+1.57
7
10.0
Stalks/stool (no)
9.39+0.65
13
29.0
Stalk length (m)
2.90+0.16
4
39.0
Stalk girth (cm)
2.77+2.26
1
9.0
Internodes/stalk (no)
27.7+1.14
16
14.0
Internode length (cm)
12.48+7.27
9
16.0
Millable canes (no)
48.44+1.11
86
26.0
Single stalk weight (kg)
2.18+15.57
7
88.0
Cane yield (t/ha-1)
65.14+15.57 124
40.0
DAP =Days after planting; MAP= Months after planting.
69
Table 2: Mean Germination and tiller counts in thirty exotic sugarcane germplasm
accessions and six check varieties (Ilorin, 2011)
Genotype
B77602
KNB9211
B82233
BT74209
B76251
B80689
BR8230
B991037
B85877
B74541
B93310
D8415
KNB9252
B85266
DB8113
DB85106
KNB92101
B881607
D8687
B78697
B62163
B93638
B79474
DB7867
BJ82112
B98653
B63118
B76621
B82238
BT871646
Co957
ILS-001
ILS-002
Co62175
B47419
USRI/85/31
Mean
LSD
%CV
Germination
14 DAP
28 DAP
3
9
1
7
2
3
1
6
1
6
2
8
2
7
2
9
5
16
2
6
3
7
5
14
3
17
3
5
4
11
6
18
1
10
1
9
2
13
4
9
1
2
1
4
0
5
2
9
2
9
3
16
2
11
0
2
3
8
2
11
3
8
6
12
1
9
1
2
1
7
4
14
2.4
8.8
3.006
6.497
78.49
45.26
48 DAP
19
25
7
22
20
17
18
23
27
11
16
28
25
15
26
34
22
25
26
22
3
9
15
26
25
28
26
6
23
21
11
19
24
8
21
30
21.1
11.497
30.20
3 MAP
44
33
14
38
46
37
34
48
55
19
46
35
36
22
31
61
27
38
36
39
9
15
36
42
33
50
44
13
29
26
48
55
41
16
37
73
36.6
14.582
24.39
DAP = Days after planting, MAP = Months after planting
Tiller Count
6 MAP
9 MAP
65
68
39
43
18
19
45
50
52
62
40
45
39
50
52
58
61
72
29
35
63
66
41
46
77
96
25
33
43
51
67
77
35
39
44
51
41
48
48
54
13
18
17
19
46
50
51
61
38
46
57
65
56
62
16
21
45
50
36
39
67
71
65
76
50
56
21
25
56
63
92
102
45.8
52.3
18.16
19.94
24.34
23.38
12 MAP
74
57
21
56
67
54
55
61
79
38
76
60
120
38
62
100
48
58
51
72
22
30
58
70
53
72
65
24
60
48
76
90
75
39
82
117
61.9
22.84
22.1
70
Table 3: Stalk characteristics in thirty exotic sugarcane germplasm accessions
and six check varieties (Ilorin, 2011)
Genotype
B77602
KNB9211
B82233
BT74209
B76251
B80689
BR8230
B991037
B85877
B74541
B93310
D8415
KNB9252
B85266
DB8113
DB85106
KNB92101
B881607
D8687
B78697
B62163
B93638
B79474
DB7867
BJ82112
B98653
B63118
B76621
B82238
BT871646
Co957
ILS-001
ILS-002
Co62175
B47419
USRI/85/31
Mean
LSD
%CV
Stalk/Stool
(no)
8
7
11
9
10
7
8
9
4
7
9
6
9
7
7
14
6
12
6
12
12
13
8
11
8
7
13
13
12
6
10
10
9
11
8
18
9.4
4.434
29.00
Stalk length
(cm) ns
2.8
2.8
2.4
2.6
2.3
2.8
2.3
3.0
2.8
2.7
2.8
3.1
2.1
4.1
3.3
2.5
2.9
2.9
2.5
3.3
3.1
3.0
2.3
6.0
2.9
3.2
2.8
2.5
3.1
2.8
2.7
3.0
2.9
2.9
2.5
2.4
2.9
1.815
38.62
Stalk girth
(cm)
2.6
2.9
2.9
3.0
2.9
2.9
2.5
2.7
2.9
2.6
2.9
2.9
2.1
2.9
3.0
2.6
2.8
2.9
2.9
2.8
2.7
2.7
2.5
3.3
2.6
2.7
2.7
2.7
2.7
3.1
3.1
2.7
2.7
2.8
2.5
2.2
2.8
0.4393
9.99
Internodes/Stalk
(no)
28
29
22
28
27
31
29
29
28
22
26
31
28
30
30
27
31
28
32
35
28
28
24
26
28
26
33
27
31
28
29
26
26
26
19
24
27.7
9.542
14.15
Internode
length (cm)
11.7
11.4
11.4
10.8
13.4
10.2
12.3
13.1
12.0
11.9
12.8
13.8
9.2
11.5
13.9
11.0
13.5
16.8
8.2
15.2
13.3
12.2
12.2
13.6
11.3
12.8
13.1
12.6
15.5
13.4
12.6
12.1
12.8
11.0
13.8
12.9
12.5
3.221
15.84
71
Table 4: Cane yield and related traits in thirty exotic sugarcane germplasm accessions and
six check varieties (Ilorin, 2011)
Genotype
B77602
KNB9211
B82233
BT74209
B76251
B80689
BR8230
B991037
B85877
B74541
B93310
D8415
KNB9252
B85266
DB8113
DB85106
KNB92101
B881607
D8687
B78697
B62163
B93638
B79474
DB7867
BJ82112
B98653
B63118
B76621
B82238
BT871646
Co957
ILS-001
ILS-002
Co62175
B47419
USRI/85/31
Mean
LSD
%CV
Millable canes
(no)
44
40
20
48
47
43
39
40
60
33
60
49
96
29
53
85
37
50
44
60
18
25
45
62
42
56
52
19
41
35
60
64
54
33
65
104
48.4
20.51
26.00
Brix at harvest
22.3
25.5
23.0
23.8
23.2
25.0
23.7
22.2
21.3
21.2
21.8
22.8
18.5
21.5
20.8
22.7
20.2
21.8
19.3
21.7
17.8
19.7
21.7
21.5
22.8
19.8
19.7
21.8
20.2
20.2
23.2
23.5
18.7
20.7
22.5
20.5
21.5
3.614
10.30
Single stalk
weight (kg)
1.6
1.9
2.1
8.5
2.0
2.0
1.3
2.4
2.3
1.4
1.9
2.3
2.2
2.6
1.5
1.3
1.7
2.0
1.6
2.0
2.1
2.0
1.5
2.8
1.6
1.8
2.3
1.6
4.6
2.8
1.8
1.6
1.8
1.9
1.6
1.7
2.2
3.128
88.65
Cane yield
(t/ha-1)
69.38
77.79
49.88
68.42
91.71
91.71
27.08
81.33
94.29
56.96
91.46
99.79
90.13
38.08
99.75
97.00
58.75
85.29
93.00
98.00
59.79
39.29
64.17
96.38
50.58
89.25
72.25
29.17
91.92
63.08
90.29
92.50
54.67
41.25
53.33
96.75
81.44
0.04391
0.04137
72
PGB06
RICE BLAST PATHOGENICITY AND ITS EFFECT ON SOME RICE CULTIVARS IN
NIGERIA.
Gana. A.S.1*, Dangana, D. S.2, Tsado, E.K.3 and Maji, E.A.4
1
Department of Crop Production, Federal University of Technology Minna, Niger State, Nigeria
2
Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Niger State, Green House, Minna,
Nigeria.
3
Department of Crop Production, Federal University of Technology Minna, Niger State, Nigeria.
4
National Cereals Research Institute (NCRI) Badeggi, Niger State, Nigeria
*Corresponding email: andrewganasaba@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Screen house experiment to compare the virulence of blast inoculum collected at various
locations in Nigeria and its effects on some rice cultivars were determined at a screen house
studies conducted at Badeggi Central Nigeria. The blast inoculum was collected from some
locations in North West, North East. North Central, South East and South West of Nigeria. The
experiment was laid out in a factorial design fitted into a split plot. There were 60 treatment
combinations. The rice cultivars serve as the main plot while the inoculum serves as the subplot.
The experiment was replicated three times. Inoculation was done at two weeks after sowing with
a control plot that was not inoculated. Leaf, neck and panicle blast were scored on all the
buckets. Also grain weight at harvest was scored. Result indicated that blast pathogen from
South west was most virulent. Blast pathogen from South East was the second most virulent on
all the varieties of rice tested. Blast pathogens from North East and North Central were almost
the same in terms of pathogenicity on all the varieties of rice tested. Blast pathogen from North
West was the least virulent on all the varieties of rice tested. There was a progressive increase in
pathogenicity from the day of inoculation to 4 weeks after inoculation across all the treatments.
The result showed that the local varieties used in the trial holds promise for blast control and for
breeding for blast resistant varieties.
Key words: Blast Pathogen, inoculum, Rice, Variety.
INTRODUCTION
Rice is a grass plant which belongs to the genus Oryza of the family poaceae (Vaughan, 1994).
Two species (Oryza sativa and Oryza glaberrima) are cultivated (Crawford and Lee, 2003). Rice
is the world’s most important food crop based on the cultivated area and serves as a major source
of calories for 40% of the world population (Heinrichs, 1992a). Most of the world rice
production occurs in tropical Asia in irrigated and rainfed lowland fields (Heinrichs, 1992a). In
Nigeria rice is produced in all agro-ecological zones from Sahel to coastal swamps of the country
(Singh et al., 1997). Nigeria produces about three million metric tons of rice annually, with
harvested area of about 1.7 million hectares. Rice per capital consumption is put at 21.2kg
annually (WARDA, 1996).
Rice blast caused by Pyricularia oryzae is now the most destructive fungal disease of rice in the
West African Subregion (Fomba and Taylor, 1994). The fungus produces spot or lesions on
73
leaves, nodes and different parts of the panicles and the grains (Ou, 1985). The leaf spots are
typically elliptical with more or less pointed ends. The centre of the spots is usually gray or
whitish and the margin is usually brown or reddish brown. Fully developed lesions reach 11.5cm long, 0.3-0.5cm broad and usually develop a brown margin. On resistant cultivars only
minute brown specks of pinhead size may be observed. Numerous spots may occur on the leaf,
which may soon be killed. This is followed by the drying up of the leaf sheath. Seedling or
plant at the tillering stage is often completely killed in the field.
MATERIALS AND METHOD
The experiment was conducted in the screen house of National Cereals Research Institute
(NCRI) Badeggi in 2011. Badegi is located in North Central Nigeria. The blast innoculum were
sourced from five locations across the agro ecology of Nigeria. North West (Wurno), North East
(Damarmari), North Central (National Cereals Research Institute Badeggi ) South East
(Abakaliki,) and South West (Ogbomoso,). The local varieties of rice used were collected from
various locations in Niger state. Also five rice blast differentials were collected form African
Rice Center. The Experiment was laid out in factorial arrangement fitted into a split plot design.
The experiment consists of 60 treatment combinations and replicated three times. Each of the
fungus (Magnaporthe grisea) collected from five different rice growing regions in Nigeria, was
Isolated from lesions on leaves of infected rice by conidial isolation technique (Shanta, 2000 and
Awoderu, 1990). Conidial suspensions (25×103 spores/ml) of monoconidial culture of blast
fungus, were used to inoculate the seedlings of 10 varieties of rice. Inoculation was done 2
weeks after planting (by spraying the conidial suspensions (25×103 spores/ml) on rice seedling).
Blast scoring was done at 2, 3 and 4 weeks after inoculation for leaf blast, and at 3 weeks after
heading for neck and panicle blast. Degree of infection was measured using a visual scale of 09 (0 = no infection, 1 = mild infection, 3 = moderate infection, 5 = high infection, 7 = severe
infection and 9 = very severe infection) IRRI disease evaluation scale (1996). Disease
progression was measured using the differences between the intervals of record taken (i.e, 2WKS
– 4WKS). To determine the stage (s) of rice growth in which the pathogens are more virulent.
Scoring was based on the number of plants and leaves infected, lesions and sizes of lesion on the
leaves, necks and panicles infested (WARDA, 1999). Also data on plant height at maturity, grain
weight at harvest were also taken
RESULT
Result from Table 1 shows the mean score for blast at 2, 3 and 4 weeks after inoculation. The
location result showed that South West had the highest value and was significantly different from
other locations at 2 WAI. The same trend was expressed at 3 and 4 WAI. Result at 3 WAI
showed the highest value of 6.0. Blast collected from North East and North Central were
significantly similar. They were higher that than the collection from North west and the control.
At 4 WAI significant differences were observed among the treatments. The control had the
lowest value of 1.60. The highest value was from the South west, followed closely by value
obtained from the South east. All the locations showed significant difference from each other.
Reaction of the varieties at 2 WAI showed that RAM 28 had the highest value but was not
significantly different from RAM 114 and OS6, it was however different from others. At 3
WAI, RAM 28 had the highest value but it was not significantly different from TOG 80711, OS
6 and Jina. Result at 4 WAI also showed that RAM 28 had the highest value and was
74
significantly different from others. The interaction between location and variety were not
significantly different.
Table 1: Blast mean score at 2, 3, 4 weeks after inoculation (WAI) for both location and
variety
Treatment
2WAI
3WAI
4WAI
North West
1.17b
2.40d
3.33e
North East
1.10b
3.07c
3.80d
North Central
1.27b
3.47c
4.33c
South East
1.77b
4.67b
5.07b
South West
2.67a
6.00a
6.13a
Control
0.13c
0.93e
1.60f
S E±
0.23
0.20
0.16
RAM 114
2.22ab
3.72cb
4.22bc
RAM 28
2.72a
4.67a
5.44a
TOG6711
0.61d
3.06cd
3.06e
TOG 80711
1.06cd
3.89ab
3.89dc
OS 6
2.11ab
4.33ab
5.22bc
Maitudunkurshi
0.56d
3.00cd
3.67edc
Jina
1.72cb
4.67a
4.78b
Yarkuma
0.44d
2.72d
3.78dc
Majalisa
1.06cd
2.44d
3.44ed
Zokwandami
1.00cd
1.72e
3.28f
SE±
0.30
0.26
0.21
NS
NS
NS
Blast Isolate From
Variety
Interaction
Blast Isolates x Varieties
NS=Not significant at 5%.
Means with the same letter (s) in a column are not significantly different by Duncan Multiple
range test
75
The result from table 2 indicates the mean values for neck and panicle blasts and the grain yield.
Neck blast result showed that South east had the highest value and was significantly different
from other locations. The control had the lowest value. The same trend showed also for the
panicle blast. The varieties showed a susceptible value for South west but resistant reaction for
the control. North West, North East and North central showed moderately resistant to moderately
susceptible reaction. The grain yield result showed that the control had the highest value and was
significantly different from others. Varietal reaction showed that RAM 28 had the highest value
for neck blast and was significantly different from others. The same variety had the highest value
for panicle blast also. The yield result were generally the same. However there were interaction
between blast isolates and the varieties for neck blast. The interaction result is as shown in table
3. Result from North west showed that RAM 28 had the highest value and was significantly
different from others. This trend was repeated in all the locations. However RAM 114 was
significantly the same with RAM 28 the North east and North central. Control result showed
lowest values in all the locations and the varieties.
Table 2: Mean Score of Neck and Panicle Blast 3 Weeks after Heading (WAH) and Grain
Weight (Kg/Ha)
Treatment
Neck Blast
3 WAH
Panicle Blast
3WAH
Grains Weight
at Harvest (Kg/Ha)
Blast Isolate From
North West
2.47d
3.67d
266.69b
North East
3.53c
4.67c
210.54c
North Central
4.03c
5.33c
183.63cd
South East
5.07b
6.20b
153.75d
South West
5.87a
7.45a
100.18e
Control
1.10e
1.43e
539.31a
S E±
0.20
0.27
16.23
RAM 114
5.56b
4.89bc
235.21ab
RAM 28
6.56a
6.89a
130.70d
TOG6711
2.61d
4.22dc
296.59a
TOG 80711
4.22c
4.78bc
267.36ab
OS 6
2.72d
4.39c
279.84ab
Maitudunkurshi
4.11c
5.67b
165.41cd
Jina
5.00b
5.56b
215.02cb
Yarkuma
1.78e
4.44c
281.48a
Varity
76
Majalisa
2.56d
3.22d
285.93a
Zokwandami
1.67e
3.89d
265.96ab
SE±
0.26
0.34
20.93
*
NS
NS
Interaction
Blast Isolates x Varieties
* = Significant at 5%.
Means with the same letter (s) in a column are not significantly different by Duncan Multiple
range test
The result of the interaction between variety and sources of innoculum is presented in table 3.
Across the variety RAM 28 had the highest value and was significantly different from others in
the North West. The same variety gave similar result across the locations but was significantly
similar to RAM 114 with innoculum collected at North East and North Central. Result of the
individual varieties across the innoculum sources showed that North West had the highest value
across the varieties and was significantly different from others except for Zokwandami at South
East. The overall highest value was obtained with RAM 28 (8.33), this gave a highly susceptible
value. This was significantly different from all the other values in the interaction. The control
had the lowest value across the varieties. Majilisa and Zokwandami (control treatment) had the
lowest value of 0.33 for all the treatment combinations. However it was significantly not
different from Yarkuma under the North West innoculum.
77
Table 3: Interaction of Blast Isolates and Variety of Rice on the Neck of Rice 3WAH
Variety
TREATMENT
Majalisa
Zokwandami
RAM 114
RAM 28
TOG 6711
TOG 80711
OS 6
Maitudunkurshi
Jina
Yarkuma
Blast Isolate
North West
1.33no
3.00ij
6.33d
1.67mn
North East
1.33no
7.00c
7.00c
1.00op
North Central.
7.00c
7.00c
3.67h
7.00c
3.00ij
7.67b
South East
South West
3.00ij
Control
0.67 pq
S E±
7.67b
0.33q
8.33a
1.67mn
0.33q
3.00ij
1.33no
3.00ij
3.76h
3.67h
3.00ij
2.00 lm
3.33no
7.00c
5.00f
2.67jk
5.00f
4.33g
7.67b 5.00f
0.67pq
3.67h
3.67h
4.33g
5.67e
1.00op
5.67e
7.00c
6.33d
1.00p 0.33q
7.67b
0.67pq
2.33kl
1.00op
3.67h
3.00ij
2.33kl
3.67h
1.33no
1.00p
3.00ij
4.33g
1.67mn
0.64
Means followed by the same letter (s) within treatment columns and between rows are not significantly different at 5% level of
probability using DMRT
78
DISCUSSION
The effect of blast pathogens on the ten varieties of rice confirmed the detrimental effect of this
disease to the rice production in Nigeria (Maji, 2000). The disease cycle is short and most
damage is caused by secondary infections (Jahn et al., 2007). The mark difference between the
control revealed the inability of these varieties to confer resistance to blast races across the
locations in the country
Several blasts resistant cultivars have been developed and traditional landraces including ROK
16, 63-83, Moroberakan, Lac 23 and OS6 which possess high level of stable resistance to blast
(Alluri et al., 1987). These traditional varieties are often cross with Asian semi dwarf to improve
yields. In a study on upland rice cultivars in Senegal, Mbodj et al., (1989b) observed high level
of quantitative resistance to blast in IRAT 10, IRAT 112 and IRAT 133 while Dj 8-14 and Dill509 were moderately resistant. Among the lowland rice cultivars studied TOX 103, ITA 123,
BKN 6986-38-1 and BR 51-46-5 showed high degree of partial or incomplete resistance, which
was stable in time and with rice cultivars (Mbodj et al., 1989b). In this study blast innoculum
collected from South west was more virulent. The control had better resistant reaction to blast.
The varieties showed a susceptible value for South west but resistant reaction for the control.
North West, North East and North central showed moderately resistant to moderately susceptible
reactions. The grain yield result showed that the control had the highest value and was
significantly different from others. Varietal reaction showed that RAM 28 had the highest value
for neck blast and was significantly different from others. The same variety had the highest value
for panicle blast also.
REFERENCES
Alluri, K., Masajo T.M. and John V. T. (1987). Breeding for resistance to rice blast IITA
Research Briefs 8 Pp1.
Awoderu, V.A. (1990) Yield loss attributable to neck-rot of rice caused by Pyricularia Oryzae
Cav.in Coted,lvoire Tropical pest management 36,394-396.
Crawford. G.W, Lee. G.A. (2003): "Agricultural Origins in the Korean Peninsula". Antiquity 77
(295) 87–95.
Fomba, S.N. and Taylor D.R.(1994). Rice blast in West Africa. It’s nature and control. In rice
blast disease edited by R.S. Zeigler, S.A. leong and P.S. Teng. IRRI Pp343-356
Heinrich, E.A (1992a). Host plant resistance In:Biology and management of rice insects Ed.
by E.A Heinnchs. Willey Eastern, New Delhi, India.
IRRI, (1996). Standard Evaluation system for Rice IRRI, Los Banos Philippines Pp52.
Jahn, GC, JA Litsinger, Y Chen and A Barrion. 2007. Integrated Pest Management of Rice:
Ecological Concepts. In Ecologically Based Integrated Pest Management (eds. O. Koul
and G.W. Cuperus). CAB International Pp. 315–366.
Maji. E.A. (2000): Effects of Two Growth Regulators on Yield, Drought Tolerance and
Susceptibility of Rice to Blast Disease. Ph.D Thesis. University of Jos.
Mbodj , Y., Gaye, A., Demay G., Coly J.P. and Meliu J. P. (1989b). Rice blast in Casamance,
Senegal pluriannual screening of lowland rice varieties for their resistance to diseases.
Agronomic Tropicale 44,51-57.
Shanta. P. (2000): Isolation of Cercospora personata, its Sporulation and growth in pure culture.
Proceedings, Indonisia Academy of science. 44:271-275.
78
79
Singh, B., S. Fagade., M.N Ukwungwu., C. Williams., S.S. Jagtap., O. Oladimeji., A. Efisue and
O.Okhiavebie (1997). Rice growing env. and biophysical constraint in rice agro. Ecological
zones of Nigeria. Met J. 2 (1) 35-44.
OU, S. H (1985). Rice diseases, 2nd edition common wealth mycological institute, Kew, UK
380pp.
Vaughan D.A. (1994) The wild relatives of rice, A Genetics Handbook. International Rice
Research Institute, Manila
WARDA, (1996). Rice trends in sub-Saharan Africa. Second edition, 1996. West Africa Rice
Development Association, Bouake, Coted’lvoire Pp8
WARDA, (1999). Rice Interspecific Hybridization Project: West Africa Rice Development
Association: Research Highlights Pp34
AGB07
GENOTYPE ASSESSMENT AND GROUPING OF MAIZE ON YIELD AND
STABILITY OF PERFORMANCE IN A SOUTHERN GUINEA SAVANNA
AGROECOLOGY OF NIGERIA
Opeyemi, A.S.
Department of Crop protection and Environmental Biology, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Oyo
Sate.
Corresponding e-mail: adebisi.opeyemi15@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Selection for high yield and consistency of crop performance in a particular environment are
major concerns to plant breeders. Five inbred lines and two local cultivars of maize were
evaluated on an experimental field across two (wet and dry) growing seasons in a Randomized
Complete Block Design with three replicates. Data were collected on average kernel yield and
analysed using Analysis of Variance and means were separated by Least Significant Difference
at p=0.05. Genotype yields in each season showed significant differences. The genotypes were
grouped on average yield performance and stability according to Francis and Kannerberg (1978)
using average mean yield and coefficient of variation. Genotype MG4 in group I gave best
performance with highest mean yield (3.48 t/ha) and low variability (8.08%) across growing
seasons. Genotypes MG5 and MG7 had poorest performance with respective mean yields (3.06
t/ha; 3.20 t/ha) and high variability (23.95%; 29.34%) showing low stability across seasons.
Genotypes gave higher yield average (3.92 t/ha) in dry season than wet season (2.73 t/ha).
Genotypes variability was higher in wet season (22.41%) than dry season (17.36%). Planting of
maize in late season from May to September is recommended in Ogbomoso due to better
performance of genotypes.
Key words: maize, genotype, variability, growing season, mean yield, agroecology.
INTRODUCTION
Maize is regarded as that which feed the nation in India, the golden crop in Mexico and a major
staple food for man and important source of animal feeds and industrial raw materials, including
power and energy (Borlaug, 1988; Kim, 1993). Environment constitutes complex structures and
79
80
functions of interactions involving biotic and abiotic factors resultantly affecting maize
production despite its tolerance to stress (Kim, 1993). Hence, there is need for genotype
screening for better performance in a particular location for ease of cultivation and enhancing
productivity. Climate as an important abiotic structure combining rainfall, temperature, humidity,
photoperiod, wind and sunshine, together in their distribution characterize a geographical
location differently from others. Ogbomoso in the southern guinea savanna agroecology of
Nigeria has 10 hours daylight, over nine months 1,000mm bimodal annual mean rainfall, 74%
humidity, 330C maximum and 280C minimum temperature, 9km/hr south-western wind trade and
101.3 kPa pressure (Idinoba, 2004). This climate favours maize cultivation in wet and dry
growing seasons. Objectives of this research study were aimed at: (i) studying selected maize
genotypes for yield performance across wet and dry growing seasons in Ogbomoso; (ii) grouping
the genotypes based on their average yield and stability of performance across the seasons.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was carried out at Teaching and Research Farm of Ladoke Akintola University
of Technology, Ogbomoso, Oyo state (Lat. 80 10’’N, Long. 40 10’’ E) during the 2007 cropping
season. Research materials (Table 1) used included five maize inbred lines sourced from
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, IITA, Ibadan and two local cultivars sourced from
agro-marketers in Ogbomoso. All seeds were sown in three replicate of Randomized Complete
Block Design in wet (April-July) and dry (May-September) seasons. Proper agronomic
operations were duly observed on the field and controlled pollination was done manually. Data
were collected on average kernel weight for each genotype and average yield per hectare were
calculated. Yields data were analyzed using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) and means were
separated where significant by Least Significance Difference (LSD) at p=0.05. Genotypes were
grouped into four classes according to Francis and Kernneberg technique, using average mean
yields and coefficient of variation, viz:
Group I genotypes with above average mean yield and below average coefficient of variation.
Group II genotypes with above average mean yield and above average coefficient of variation.
Group III genotypes with below average mean yield and below average coefficient of variation.
Group IV genotypes with below average mean yield and above average coefficient of variation.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Maize mean yields (Table 2) observed across wet and dry seasons for genotypes had respective
ranges 1.25t/ha to 3.55 t/ha and 2.85 t/ha to 5.99 t/ha with total mean yields 2.73 t/ha and 3.94
t/ha. Coefficient of variation (CV) expressed genotypes stability of performance, CV recorded
across wet and dry seasons had mean values range of 8.08% to 29.34% with average 19.89%;
and respective values of 22.41% and 17.36%. Effect of seasonal factors of the environment on
genotypes total average yields across the two seasons (Fig. 1) showed better performance and
good stability in dry season over wet season in the agroecology. Genotype grouping technique
(Table 3) had MG4 in group I with better average yield, low variability and high stability; MG2
and MG3 in group II expressed better yield, high variability and low stability; and MG5 and
MG7 in group IV expressed poor yield, low variability and high stability. These observations
established variation in performance of maize genotypes across seasons, due to wide genetic
divergence characteristics and influence of seasonal differential factors.
80
81
CONCLUSION
Breeding methods make better tools for screening high yielding and better stable genotypes for
particular environment. This study recommended planting of maize in dry season from May to
September in Ogbomoso agroecology due to better performance of genotypes. Maize growers
are advised to plant MG4 genotype across wet and dry seasons for better yield and stability of
performance, while other genotypes should be given further research attention to improve their
yield and stability to perform better in the agroecology.
AKNOWLEDGEMENT
I am highly indebted to Dr. (Mrs.) C. O. Aremu, Ladoke Akintola University of Technology,
Ogbomoso, for her advice and supervision; Dr. (Mrs.) M. Balogun, Environmental Biology Unit,
University of Ibadan, Ibadan, for her professional discussions and guidance on the manuscript
preparation. I appreciate Maize Breeding Unit of IITA, Ibadan,for the release of seeds used for
this study.
REFERENCES
Aremu, C. O., O. J. Ariyo and B. D. Adewale 2007. Assessment of selection techniques in
genotype x environment interaction in cowpea. African Journal of Agricultural Research:
2(8)- 352-355.
Borlaug, N. E. 1970. Feeding the world in the 21st century: the role of new science and
technology.
Borlaug, N. E. 1988. The role of maize in striving for peace: Past, present and future.
Francis, T. R. and L. W. Kernnerberg 1978. Yield stability studies in short-season maize, A
descriptive method for grouping genotypes. Can. J. Plant Sci. 58: 1029-1034.
Idinoba, M. E., P. A. Idinoba, A. S. Gbadegesin and S. S. Jagtap 2004. Water use and seasonal
differences in maize performance in the transitional humid zone of Nigeria. Journal of
Sustainable Agriculture: 24-37-5.
Kim, S. K. 1993. Maize improvement, production and utilization in Nigeria. Maize Association
of Nigeria (MAAN): 11-12.
Table 1:Maize genotypes description and sources
Genotype
Name
Source
Type
Maturity
MG1
TZUTSR-Y/W
IITA
Yellow
Intermediate
MG2
OBA./TZL
IITA
White
Late
MG3
POPSR/TUUTSR
IITA
Yellow
Intermediate
MG4
DMR-ESR
IITA
White
Early
81
82
MG5
ACR-SWAN
IITA
Yellow
Late
MG6
LOCAL VAR.
OPEN MARK.Yellow
Late
MG7
LOCAL VAR.
OPEN MARK.Yellow
Late
Table 2: Maize genotype yields and coefficient of variation (CV) recorded across wet and dry
seasons
Genotype
Wet Grain Yield (t/ha)
Dry Grain Yield (t/ha)
MG1
2.33
3.13
MG2
3.31
5.99
MG3
3.41
3.94
MG4
2.72
4.24
MG5
2.55
3.57
MG6
1.25
3.86
MG7
3.55
2.85
Total
19.12
27.58
Mean
2.73
3.94
CV (%)
22.41
17.36
LSD (P=0.05)
0.53
0.52
Table 3:Maize genotypes grouping based on average yields and stability of performance across
wet and dry seasons in Ogbomoso agroecology.
Genotype
Average mean yield (t/ha)
Average coefficient of variation (%)
Group
Above
Below
Above
Below
MG1
-
+
-
+
III
MG2
+
-
+
-
II
MG3
+
-
+
-
II
MG4
+
-
-
+
I
MG5
-
+
+
-
IV
MG6
-
+
-
+
III
MG7
-
+
+
-
IV
82
83
Mean
3.34
19.89
+ represents value recorded
- represents nil
Wet season
Dry season
Fig. 1: Maize genotypes total average yields performance in each wet and dry season in
Ogbomoso agroecology.
PGB08
83
84
CYTOTOXIC AND GENOTOXIC EVALUATION OF AQUEOUS LEAF, ROOT AND
SEED EXTRACTS OF CARICA PAPAYA L. USING ALLIUM TEST.
Abu, Ngozi E. and Nweze, Chinyere C.
Department of Plant Science and Biotechnology,
University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Nigeria
Corresponding e-mail: ngozi.abu@unn.edu.ng
Mobile phone: +234 8064664555
ABSTRACT
Cytotoxicity and genotoxicity of aqueous leaf, root and seed extracts of Carica papaya were
assayed using Allium cepa root tip meristems. The onion bulbs were sprouted over water before
transferring to the water extracts. The duration of treatment in diverse water extracts were 1 h, 6
h, 12 h and 24 h. The layout of the experiment was a 4 x 4 factorial in completely randomized
design (CRD). The results obtained showed that the extracts significantly reduced cell
reproduction. Cells entering into mitosis in all the treatments were significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower
than the control. The abnormalities observed included: clumped prophase, sticky and star
metaphase cells, anaphase with single and multiple bridges, precocious, lagging and sticky
chromosomes at anaphase and sticky telophase. Others include micronuclei and cytokinetic
failure leading to multiple nuclei. Treatment durations equally had adverse effects on the
dividing cells. All these abnormalities are pointers to the potential toxicity of these plant extracts
which has great benefits in ethno medicine. The implications of the results were discussed with a
concluding statement on the need to standardize the dosages of herbal medicine to maximum
benefit without adverse health effects.
Key words: Allium test, aqueous extracts, Carica papaya, cytotoxic, multiple nuclei
INTRODUCTION
Carica papaya L. belongs to the family Caricaceae. The common names are pawpaw, papaya,
papaw and others. Pawpaw is a herbaceous succulent plant with self supporting stems. It has a
weak soft wooden stem which is straight, cylindrical with prominent leaf scars (Purseglove,
1968). The pale green leaves are clustered near the apex of the trunk with large spiral petiole.
Pawpaw has a high level of natural self-defense compounds that makes it highly resistant to
insects and disease infestation. Pawpaw has been shown to be a source of vitamins like thiamine,
riboflavin, ascorbic acid and important minerals like calcium, magnesium, potassium, manganese
by various researchers (Ayoola and Adeyeye, 2010; Aravind et al., 2013). Aravind et al. (2013)
reported that pawpaw is a powerhouse of nutrients and is available throughout the year, being the
rich source of three powerful antioxidants, Vitamins A, C and E.
Pawpaw plant parts are used in many countries in herbal medicine to treat malaria, diabetes,
cardiovascular diseases, arthritis, wounds like sores and ulsers and as worm expeller (Ayoola and
Adeyeye, 2010). It has been reported that whole plant parts: leaves, fruits, roots, bark, peel,
seeds and pulp are all known to have medicinal properties (Aravind et al., 2013). The authors
went further to report that all the ingredients in papaya has been said to improve cardiovascular
system, protect against heart disease, heart attacks, strokes and prevent colon cancer. Pawpaw
contains many biological active compounds including chymopapain and papain which is the
ingredient that aids digestive system and help in the treatment of arthritis. The juice from
pawpaw roots is used in some countries like Asia to ease urinary troubles while the seeds have
84
85
anti-bacterial properties and are effective against E.coli, Salmonella and Staphylococcus
infections. The seeds also protect the kidney from toxin induced kidney failure, detoxify the
liver, cure piles and typhoid, has anti-helminthic and anti-amoebic properties (Aravind et al.,
2013).
The contraindication of this valued fruit and herbal medicine has also been reported, continued
consumption of the plant especially in pregnancy could have teratogenic (abnormalities of
physiological development) and abortifacient (can induce an abortion) effects. Papain could also
act as prostaglandin and oxytocin. Latex can cause marked oedema and hemorrhagic placentas
which leads to severe complications in pregnancy and could induce early delivery (Aravind et
al., 2013). Seed extracts have contraceptive effects. It has been reported that women in India,
Bangladesh, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and other countries have long used green papaya as an herbal
medicine for contraception and abortion.
Herbal medicine has several advantages to humanity, however, extracts of herbal plants have no
actual dosage in herbal medicine, and only a rough volume dosage is given by herbal
practitioners. Therefore the actual concentration is difficult to ascertain. In line with the above,
Amadi et al. (2011) reported that in Nigeria and many other developing countries, herbal
preparations are sold over the counter in general stores and not in pharmaceutical stores. The
indiscriminate use of such preparations might adversely affect fertility/reproductive health when
used over a long period of time or when used in high doses for the treatment of other human
diseases (Srivastava et al., 2005). Birdi et al. (2010) reported that toxicological evaluation of
medicinal plants has often been neglected since prolonged and apparently uneventful use is
usually considered as a testimony of its safety. People generally consider herbal medicines to be
safe because they are ‘natural’ inspite of the fact that there is dearth of information on the precise
nature of the constituents and on the likely effects. (Tyler, 1999; Srivastava et al., 2005; Amadi
et al., 2011).
Toxicity assessments are usually done using Allium test. Allium test has been accepted as
standard in monitoring and toxicity assessment of complex molecules. Medicinal plant parts
have been assessed by various authors using Allium test and other test systems, some of which
include; Water extracts of Pulicaria crispa (Shehab, 1979), Teucrium pilosum (Shehab, 1980),
Vernonia amygdalina and Boerhaeria diffusa (Ene-Obong and Amadi, 1987a), Vinca rosea and
Borrera filiformis (Ene-Obong and Osuala, 1990), Azadirachta indica (Akaneme and Amaefule,
2012) and a host of others. The aim of the present work is to assess the cytotoxicity and
genotoxicity of aqueous leaf, seed and root extracts of Carica papaya on Allium cepa root tip
chromosomes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Collection and preparation of the samples: Fresh leaves, roots and seeds of Carica papaya
(Pawpaw) were collected from Pawpaw trees within the University of Nigeria, Nsukka staff
quarters. The ripe pawpaw fruits were cut open and the seeds were collected. All the samples
were dried in the oven at 400C and the dried plant parts were ground into powdered form using
an electric grinder. The powdered samples were stored in polythene bags until use. Two hundred
grams of each of the powdered samples was weighed out for extraction into 1.5 litres of water.
The extraction process was by maceration and the set up was left for 24 hours before filtration,
with the aid of Whatman filter paper, peforation funnel and suction pump the filterate was
evaporated to dryness under reduced pressure. One gram of the aqueous extract of each of plant
85
86
parts (leaf, root and seed) was added to 100ml of distilled water. This stock was used in this
study.
Fresh and healthy onion (Allium cepa) bulbs of the purple variety were purchased from Nsukka
main market. The bulbs were sprouted over tap water in transparent plastic cups for about 6 days
to ensure adequate rooting. The well rooted bulbs were transferred from the transparent plastic
cups containing tap water to beakers containing the extract solutions of C. papaya leaves, roots
and seeds. The bulbs with poor rooting were discarded and a set of three well rooted bulbs were
left in the tap water to serve as control. The bulbs in the different extracts were treated for
different durations. The durations of treatment ranged from 9am – 10am (1 h), 9am – 3pm (6 h),
9am – 9pm (12 h) and 9am – 9am (24 h). At the end of each treatment duration 6 – 10 roots were
chopped off from each bulb. They were washed 3 times in tap water and fixed in Carnoy solution
(1:3 acetic acid to absolute alcohol). All the fixed root tips were stored in refrigerator for at least
24 h before use. The fixed roots of the different treatments were collected one after the other
from the refrigerator for hydrolysis and further studies. They were hydrolysed in 0.1 N
hydrochloric acid for 6 – 8 minutes at 60oC in a water bath. The hydrolsed root tips were washed
3 times with tap water and the milky portion was cut on a glass slide for squashing and
preparation.The stain used was acetic orcein. The slides were examined under the microscope
and good ones were sealed with nail varnish and photomicrographs were taken at oil immersion
(X100).
The experimental design was a 4 x 4 factorial in CRD with 3 replications (Table 1). Factor A
were extracts of C. papaya while factor B were the durations of treatment. Analysis of variance
(ANOVA) using GenStat discovery edition was used to analyse the data obtained on the number
of dividing cells at different mitotic phases and the number of cells with diverse abnormalities.
Mean separation was done using least significant difference (LSD) where the variance ratio is
significant.
RESULTS
The analysis of variance of the number of dividing cells at various mitotic phases showed
significant effects of the extracts, durations of treatment and the interaction on various mitotic
stages (Table 2). At prophase and metaphase, the extracts induced significant effects at 0.1%
probability level while at anaphase their effects were significant at 1% probability level. It could
be observed that the treatment duration affected all the mitotic stages significantly ranging from
P≤ 0.01 to P≤ 0.05. The interaction between the extracts and duration of treatment also affected
dividing cells at all the mitotic stages significantly at P≤ 0.01. In the actual number of cells at
different mitotic stages, it could be observed that there is significant reduction in the number of
cells that enter prophase (M phase of cell cycle) across the treatment extracts (Figure 1). As
mitotic division progressed from prophase to other stages, some of the extracts had higher
number of dividing cells than the control. For instance, at telophase stage the number of cells in
the control treatment was 2.3, while those induced by leaf, root and seed extracts were 11.3, 9.5
and 7.8 respectively. The seed extract had significantly the least number of cells at all stages
except at telophase. Treatment duration equally affected the mitotic stages significantly (Figure
1). Twenty four hours treatment duration had the least number of dividing cells in all the stages
except at prophase, however, the values did not differ significantly with that at 6 h in metaphase
stage.
86
87
The analysis of variance of abnormal nuclei and cytokinetic failure involved cells with
micronuclei, multiple nuclei and nuclear disintegration (Table 3). The analysis showed that the
extracts of C. papaya and durations of treatment had significant effects in the induction of
abnormal and multiple nuclei in A. cepa cells. In cells with micronuclei both the extract and
durations of treatment together with their interaction were significant at P≤0.001. In addition to
inducing micronuclei; cytokinesis failure signified by binucleate, trinucleate and tetranucleate
cells were also induced by the extracts at significant levels. The treatment duration and the
extract x treatment duration equally induced multiple nuclei in A. cepa cells at varying levels of
probability except at tetranucleate cells where the duration and the interaction was not
significant. Only the effects of the extracts were significant (P≤0.05) in causing nuclear
disintegration, the treatment durations and the interaction were not significant (Table 3).
It was equally observed that most of the dividing A. cepa cells treated with the extracts at
different durations were abnormal (Table 4 and Plates 1 - 3). Abnormalities were rated according
to their different forms as follows:
i). Prophase: clumped prophase – root extracts induced the highest value in this abnormality,
disturbed prophase – the leaf extract induced the highest abnormality.
ii). Metaphase: sticky metaphase – leaf extract followed by root extract induced the highest
abnormality, star metaphase was also observed (Plate 1).
iii). Anaphase: anaphase with single and multiple bridges and other forms of abnormalities –
anaphase with precocious chromosomes, lagging chromosomes, sticky late anaphase and
clumping chromosomes.
iv). Telophase: sticky telophase were also observed and the extracts and treatment duration had
significant effects.
v). Abnormal nuclei: micronuclei – seed extract and 24 h treatment duration had the highest
significant effect in inducing micronuclei (Table 4), the effect of 24 h was however, not different
from that of 12 h. Some nuclei were also observed appearing like the normal ones but on a closer
observation they are slightly smaller than the other normal ones (Plate 3).
vi). Cytokinetic failure: binucleate, trinucleate and tetranucleate cells were the observed effects
of cytokinesis failure. The seed extracts did not induce any multiple nuclei while leaf extract
induced the highest bi- and tri- nucleate cells. The effects of leaf and root extracts were not
significantly different in inducing tetranucleate cells. Twelve hour treatment significantly
induced the highest binucleate cells, however, the effects of treatment time was not significant as
regards tetranucleate cells. One hour treatment had the highest values in inducing the following
abnormalities – clumped prophase, disturbed prophase, sticky metaphase, abnormal anaphase
and anaphase bridge. However, these effects were not significantly different from 12 h treatment
in disturbed prophase, sticky metaphase and abnormal anaphase (Table 4 and Figure 4).
DISCUSSION
There are rising concerns over the safety of herbal medicines in many countries. The aqueous
extracts of C. Papaya and treatment duration affected the mitotic process at different stages. The
significant reduction of phase cells in all the extracts and durations of treatment as compared to
control seems to suggest the adverse effects of the extracts on the interphase cells, or probably an
87
88
arrest of the cells at the interphase nucleus. It seems that the extracts had inhibitory effects on
cells entering into M phase of the cell cycle leading to reduction in cell reproduction. EneObong, (1991) reported that the inhibitory effects of medicinal plants extracts at interphase stage
lowers cell reproduction. On the other hand, it could be possible that the extracts had effects on
the cell respiration and the cells could not generate enough ATP to enter into mitosis. Similar
reports include Epel, (1963) and Jain and Sarbhoy, (1987), who reported that the rate of mitosis
and chromosome movement are influenced by the resultant level of ATP in a cell. The length of
usage of these extracts could equally affect cell reproduction as 24 h treatment duration affected
mitotic stages of A. cepa more than the other durations, especially at metaphase to telophase
stages. The significance of treatment duration on phase index depicts the adverse effects of the
extracts at long term intake, especially as it has been reported that toxicological evaluation of
medicinal plants has often been neglected since prolonged and apparently uneventful use is
usually considered as a testimony of its safety (Birdi et al., 2010).
Most of the observed dividing cells in the extracts are abnormal. This is a pointer to cytotoxicity
and genotoxicty of these extracts. Abnormal dividing cells-clumped prophase, disturbed
prophase, sticky prophase, anaphase bridges and other observed anaphase abnormalities were
higher in 1hr duration of treatment. It could be that there is a cell recovery mechanism as the
duration of treatment increased. The first reaction of the cells in coming into contact with the
extract was to divide abnormally and gradually there seems to be a switch reducing or blocking
cells entering into mitosis or progressing to other stages and equally a recovery of the initial
shock. Rayburn et al. (2002) reported that tolerance as measured by reduced chromosome
stickiness did not occur until the plants were grown in very high soil aluminum saturation. This
implies that cells could develop tolerance as concentration increased and probably with
continued use.
Chromosome instability as triggered off by the C. Papaya extract lead to diverse abnormalities
observed in this work. Ayoola and Adeyeye (2010) reported the presence of saponins in C.
Papaya leaves while Okwu and Okwu (2004) in an earlier report stated that saponins are
cytotoxic causing permealization of the intestine. Rayburn et al. (2002) reported that
chromosome stickiness is defined as a chromosomal agglutination of unknown nature which
results in a pycnotic or sticky appearance of chromosomes. There are several reports on the cause
of chromosome stickness - chromosome stickiness could be caused by depolymerization of DNA
(Abraham and Kashy, 1979); DNA condensation (Osterberg et al., 1984); physical adhesion of
chromosomal proteins (Patil and Bhat, 1992). There is a general consensus that stickiness
reflects highly toxic and usually irreversible effect that probably leads to cell death (Liu et al.,
1992; El-Ghamery et al., 2000; Tipirdamaz et al., 2003; Akaneme and Amaefule, 2012 ). Liu et
al. (1995) in Rayburn et al. (2002) while testing aluminum toxicity reported severe cytological
abnormalities (such as anaphase bridges) in dividing cells of onion roots resulting from
chromosomal stickiness. Chromosome bridges and fragments are signs of clastogenic effects
resulting in chromosome and chromatid breaks (Evandri et al., 2000). Hall and Giaccia (2006)
equally reported that anaphase bridge is one of the 3 types of aberrations that are lethal to the
cell, the other two being dicentric and ring chromosomes. Bridges have been reported to cause
structural chromosome mutation (duplications and deletions in DNA double-strand) (Evandri et
al., 2000; El-Ghamery et al., 2000).
88
89
Star metaphase and associated anaphase abnormalities classified as disturbed anaphasemultipolar anaphase, precocious chromosomes at anaphase, chromosome clumping at anaphase
have been reported by other researchers on diverse medicinal plants and other complex
molecules (Amer, 1965; Mercy Kulthy and Stephen, 1980; Abu and Mba, 2011; Akaneme and
Amaefule, 2012). The precocious chromosomes have been attributed to unequal spindle
movement where some chromosome arms are pulled towards the extremity of the pole
(Stakykova et al., 2005; Bhatta and Sakya, 2008).
Cytokinesis is the final step in cell division. Cytokinetic failure leading to multinucleate cells
have been reported as a severe deleterious effect that can lead to cancerous cells in tissues and
play a major role in development of tumor cells (Normand and King, 2010). Cytokinesis is a
highly ordered process requiring an intricate interplay between cytoskelectal, chromosomal and
cell cycle regulatory pathways (Normand and King, 2010). The authors went further to report
that cytokinesis being a highly regulated complex process, it is surprising that cytokinesis
sometimes fail. The process of cytokinesis can be divided into 4 stages and each stage of
cytokinesis is dependent on the proper execution of the prior stage and thus interference with any
stage may result to cytokinesis failure. This explains the high level of cytokinesis failure in this
work; the extracts might have interfered with the cytokinetic process at one or more stages. The
interference of the extracts on the formation of cell plate (cytokinesis) could also explain the
significantly higher number of cells at mitotic telophase in all the extracts than the control.
Multinuclei could result in cells with different ploidy level or number of nuclei especially in a
previously uninucleate cells. Moreover, micronuclei in cells leads to aneuploidy conditions and
seed extracts induced the highest number of micronuclei. Leaf and root extracts induced both
micronuclei and multinucleate cells via cytokinetic failure. The inductions are higher at longer
durations of treatment. This calls for caution in the consumption of this extract especially as it
has been reported that Allium test has high correlation with other test system (Fiskesjo and
Levan, 1993). Moreover, Fiskesjo (1995) reported that a positive result in Allium test system
should be taken to indicate a potential biological hazard and that false negatives have been
shown to rarely occur in either the Allium test or other similar plant test. The potentially high
mutagenic effects of C. Papaya plant extracts are evidenced by the abnormalities observed in
this work. Several researchers working with similar and other test systems have reported the
adverse effects of Papaya plant extracts. Aravind et al. (2013) reported the use of green Papaya
as contraception and abortion drugs among women in India, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and
other countries. Seed extracts have been reported to cause contraceptive effects on rats and
monkeys, and equally causes toxicity-induced kidney failure (Aravind et al., 2013).
The acute toxicity of the leaf extracts on rat's hemoglobin (HGB), hemotocrit (HCT), red blood
cells and total protein was reported by Halin et al. (2011) while Tarkang et al. (2012) reported
liver and Kidney toxicity of leaf extracts on rats. All these evidences are pointers to the potential
toxicity of these plant extracts which also have great benefits in ethno medicine. The results of
this research, together with other similar results in plants and animal systems call for urgent need
to standardize the dosages of medicinal plants extracts for the treatment of different ailments.
This would go a long way in helping the maximization of their benefits with minimal side
effects.
89
90
REFERENCES
Abraham, S. and Kashy, M.P. (1979). Mutagenic potentials of green chilies in Allium cepa root
meristems. Cytology, 44:221-225.
Abu, N.E. and Mba, K.C. (2011). Mutagenicity testing of pharmaceutical effluents on Alliu
cepa root tip meristems. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health Sciences,
3(2): 44-51.
Akaneme, F.I. and Amaefule, C.C. (2012). Evaluation of the cytoxicity and genotoxicity of
aqueous leaf extracts of Azardiracta indica A.Juss using Allium test. Journal of
Medicinal Plants Research, 6 (22): 3898-3907.
Amadi, C.N., Siminialayi, I.M. and Orisakwe, O.E. (2011). Male infertility and herbal
supplements: An update. Pharmacology, 2 (11): 323-348.
Amer, S.M (1965). cytological effects of pesticides 1. Mitotic effects of N-methyl-1
naphthylcarbamate “sevin”. Cytology, 30:175-181.
Aravind, G., Debjit Bhowmik, Duraivel S. and Harish G (2013). Traditional and medicinal
uses of Carica papaya . Journal of Medicinal Plants Studies, 1 (1): 7 – 15
Ayoola, P.B. and Adeyeye, A. (2010). Phytochemical and nutrient evaluation of Carica papaya
leaves. IJRRAS, 5 (3): 325 – 328.
Bhatta, P. and Sakya, S.R. (2008). Study of mitotic activity and chromosomal behavior in root
meristem of Allium cepa L. treated with magnesium sulphate. Ecoprint, 15:83-88.
Birdi, T.J., Brijesh, S. and Daswani, P.G. (2010). Approaches towards the preclinical testing and
standardization
of
medical
plants.
http://www.aifo.it/english/resources/online/books/other/tradmedicine06/TradMedicine
birdi.pdf assessed on 15 July 2013.
Ene-Obong, E.E. (1991). Anti-DNA and anti-spindle effects of tropical medicinal plants. In:
Cheremisinoff PN, Ferrante LM (eds) Biotechnology Current Progress, Vol 1.
Technomic Publishing Co. USA, pp. 295-310.
Ene-Obong, E.E. and Amadi, O.C. (1987a). Contributions to the cytological effects of medicinal
plants 1. The mitodepressive effects of water extracts of Boerhaavia diffusa and Vernonia
amygdalina on Allium cepa root tip mitosis. Cytologia 52: 469-474.
Ene-Obong, E.E. and Osuala, C.L. (1990). Contributions to the cytological effects of medicinal
plant III. The mutagenic potentials of water extracts of Borreria filiformis (Hiern) Hutch
& Dalz and Vinca rosea Linn. Nigerian Journal of Botany 3: 35-40
El – Ghamery, A.A., Elnahas, A.I. Mansour, M.M. (2000). The action of atrazine herbicide as
an inhibitor of cell division on chromosomes and nucleic acid content in root meristems
of Allium cepa and vicia faba. Cytologia 55:209-215.
90
91
Epel, D. (1963). The effect of carbon monoxide inhibition on ATP level and the rate of mitosis
in sea Urchin eggs. J. Cell Biol. 17: 315-317.
Evandri, M.G., Tucci, P. and Bolle, P. (2000). Toxicological evaluation of commercial mineral
water bottled in polyethylene terephthalate: a cytogenic approach with Allium cepa. Food
Addit. Contam. 17 (1):1037-1045.
Fiskesjo, G. (1995). Allium test. In: in vitro toxicity testing protocols-methods in molecular
biology. Volume 43. (S.O Hare and C.K Alterwill, Eds). Human Presss Inc. Totowa N.J.
pp 119-127.
Fiskesjo, G. and Levan, A. (1993). Evaluation of the first ten MEIC chemical in the Allium test,
ATLA 21:139-149.
Halin, S.Z., Abdullah, A., Afzan, B.A., Abdul, R., Jonathan, I. and Ismali, Z. (2011). Study of
acute toxicity of Carica papaya leaf extract in sprague Dawley rats. Journal of medicinal
Plant Research 5(xx): 1867 – 1872.
Hall, E.J. and Garcia, A.I. (2006). Radiobiology for the radiologist. 6th Ed. Lippincott William &
Wilkins, Philadelphia. P. 656.
Jain, A.K. and Sarbhoy, R.K. (1987). Cytogenetical studies on the effect of some chlorinated
pesticides 1. Effects on somatic chromosomes of Lens and Pisum spp. Cytologia 52: 47
53
Liu, D., Jiang, W. and Li, M. (1992). Effects of trivalent and hexavalent chromium on root
growth and cell division of Allium cepa. Heriditas 117: 23 – 29.
Mercykutty, V.C. and Stephen, J. (1980). Adriamycin induced genetic toxicity as demonstrated
by Allium test. Cytology 45: 769 – 777.
Normand, G. and King, R.W. (2010). Understanding cytokinesis failure. Adv. Expt. Med. Boil,
676: 27-55.
Okwu, D.E. and Okwu, M.E. (2004). Chemical composition of Spondia mombin plants. J.
Sustain. Agric. Environ, 6: 140 – 147.
Osterberg, R., Persson, D. and Bjursell, G. (1984). The condensation of DNA by chromium (III)
ions. J. Biomol. Structure Dyam., 2: 285 – 290.
Patil, B.C. and Bhat, T.G.I. (1992). A comparative study of MH and EMS in the induction of
chromosomal aberrations on lateral root meristem in Clitoria termata L. Cytology, 57:
259 – 264.
Purseglove, J.W. (1968). Tropical crops – dicotyledon. Longman, New York pp. 719.
91
92
Rayburn, A.L., Wetzel, J.B. and Baligar, V.C. (2003). Mitotic analysis of sticky chromosomes in
aluminum tolerant and susceptible wheat lines grown in soils of differing aluminum
saturation. Euphytica, 127: 193 – 199.
Shehab, A.S. (1979). Cytological effects of medicinal plant extracts in Qatar 1: mitotic effects of
water extracts of Pulicaria crispa on Allium cepa. Cytologia, 44: 607-613.
Shehab, A.S. (1980). Cytological effects of medicinal plants in Qatar II. Mitotic effects of water
extract of Teucrium pilosum on Allium cepa. Cytologia, 45: 57 – 64.
Srivastava, S.R., Kesarwani, S., Keshri, G.and Singh M.M. (2005). Evaluation of contraceptive
activity of a mineralo-herbal preparation in Sparague Dawley rats. Contraception, 72:
454– 458.
Staykova, T.A., Ivanova, E.N. and Velcheva, I.G. (2005). Cytogenetic effect of heavy-metal and
cyanide in contaminated waters from the region of southwest Bulgaria. J. Cell Mol. Biol,
4: 41 – 46.
Tipidamaz, R., Gomurgen, A.N., Kolankaya, D. and Doya, M. (2003). Determination of toxicity
of pulp-mill effluents by using Allium test. Tarim Bilimleri Dergisi 9(1): 93 – 97.
Tyler, V.E (1999). Herbs of choice – The therapeutic use of phytomedicinals. Pharmaceutical
products press, New York. Pp 287.
Figure1. The main effects of extracts and treatment time on mitotic phase indices.
92
93
Table 2. The analysis of variance of the number of dividing cells at various mitotic stages
Sources
of
variation
D
F
Prophase
Metaphase
Anaphase
Telophase
SS
MS
VR
SS
MS
VR
SS
MS
VR
SS
MS
VR
Extracts
3
25931.
1
8643.
7
29.37**
*
721.64
240.5
5
10.63**
*
224.54
74.85
4.74**
542.2
180.7
3
2.13ns
Duration
s
3
3469.9
1156.
6
3.9**
684.11
228.0
4
10.07**
*
432.88
144.2
9
9.15**
*
1049.9
1
349.9
7
4.13*
Extracts
x
durations
9
8299.5
922.2
3.13**
619.85
68.87
3.04**
522.09
58.01
3.68**
3399.3
9
377.7
1
4.46*
*
Residual
32
9416.9
294.3
-
724.3
22.63
-
504.8
15.78
-
2708.8
9
84.65
-
Total
47
47117.
5
-
-
2749.9
1
-
-
1684.3
1
-
-
7700.3
8
-
-
DF: Degrees of freedom; SS: Sum of squares; MS: Mean square; VR: Variance ratio; *** Significant at 0.1% probability level; **
Significant at 1% probability level; * Significant at 5% probability level, ns: Not significant
93
94
Table 3. The analysis of variance of abnormal nuclei of A. cepa treated with C. papaya leaf, root and seed aqueous extracts at four
treatment durations
Sources
of
variation
DF
Micronuclei
SS
Extracts
3
Durations 3
MS
Binucleate cells
VR
SS
14992.92 4997.64 91.73*** 387.0
4462.92
MS
VR
Trinucleate cells
SS
MS
VR
Tetranucleate cells
SS
129.0 18.16*** 138.08 46.03 12.92*** 58.56
1487.64 27.31*** 221.17 73.72 10.38*** 65.75
21.92 6.15**
6.4
MS
VR
Nuclear
disintegration
SS
MS
VR
19.52 5.04* 12,25 4.08 4.26*
2.13
0.55
4.75
1.58 1.65ns
ns
Extracts
x
duration
9
27762.08 3084.68 56.62*** 249.5
Residual
32
1743.33
Total
47
48961.25
27.72 3.9***
224.08 24.90 6.99***
33.52
3.73
0.96
14.25 1.58 1.65ns
ns
54.48
227.33 7.1
114.0
1085.0
541.92
3.56
124
3.88
222.48
30.67 0.96
61.92
DF: Degrees of freedom; SS: Sum of squares; MS: Mean square; VR: Variance ratio; *** Significant at 0.1% probability level; **
Significant at 1% probability level; * Significant at 5% probability level, ns: Not significant
94
95
Table 4. Main effects of C. papaya extracts and treatment duration in the induction of diverse abnormalities in A. cepa mitotic cells.
Extracts
and
Treatment
Time
Clumped
prophase
Disturbed
prophase
Sticky
metaphase
Abnormal
anaphase Anaphase
bridge
Sticky
telophase
0
Binucleate Trinucleate Tetranucleate
cells
cells
cells
Control
0
0
0
0
Leaf
1.17±0.56
7.08±2.6
8.58±2.19
6.08±2.79 0.17±0.1
Root
11.58±2.84 3.75±1.48 4.5±1.19
1.67±0.8
0.08±0.04 0.5±0.2
Seed
0
3.08±1.64 3.5±2.0
0.58±0.3
0.5±0.2
LSD =
2.15***
3.3**
4.2*
3.7*
0.3*
(P = 0.01)
(P = 0.05) (P = 0.05)
(P
0.05)
0.58±0.36 13.0±5.24
1.0±0.41
0.25±0.18
0.58±0.42
1.58±0.66
1.5±0.85
1.25±0.83
(P = 0.001) (P = 0.01)
0
Micronuclei
0
0
0
6.5±1.8
4.08±1.6
2.25±0.88
4.5±1.41
2.08±0.68
2.17±0.68
0.33±0.23 49.7±14.98 0.0
0.0
0.0
1.9*
1.57***
1.6*
2.83±0.31 24.5±4.0
29.3±3.08
6.14***
=
(P
0.001)
2.21***
=
(P
0.001)
= (P = 0.001) (P = 0.05)
1 hour
6.25±3.36
6.92±2.57 6.33±2.23
4.42±2.7
6 hours
2.58±1.22
1.0±0.7
0.17±0.09 0.3±0.01
1.5±1.0
12 hours
3.0±1.6
5.33±1.98 4.5±1.89
1.17±0.75 0.0
0.17±0.11 34.5±11.5
6.4±2.19
1.0±0.77
1.58±0.73
24 hours
0.92±0.52
0.67±0.45 2.03±1.25
1.58±1.22 0
1.42±0.83 35.8±11.56 2.0±1.07
3.42±1.5
1.0±0.49
LSD =
2.15***
3.3***
3.79 NS
1.9NS
0.6NS
P = 0.001
(P
=
0.001)
2.42±1.6
4.2 NS
0.5±0.29
0
0.3**
(P=0.01)
20.2±6.55
6.14**
2.2**
1.57**
(P = 0.01)
(P = 0.01)
(P = 0.01)
95
96
Plate 1. Abnormal metaphase cells showing: a, star metaphase; b, sticky metaphase.
Plate 2. Abnormal anaphase cells showing: a, anaphase bridge – straight arrow, lagging
chromosome/chromatid – bold arrow, sticky chromosomes at late anaphase – bent arrow; b,
precocious chromosome – straight arrow, clumping chromosomes – bold arrow.
96
97
Plate 3. Cytokinetic failure showing: a, trinuclaete cell, note unequal size of the nuclei – arrowed,
b, binucleate cell – bent arrow and trinuclate cell – straight arrow, also note the smallness of the
centre nucleus in trinucleate cell.
PGB09
GENETIC STUDIES OF DURATION TO ANTHESIS IN SOME NIGERIA KENAF
(HIBISCUS CANNABINUS L.) COLLECTIONS.
Adeyinka, O.S and Balogun, M.O.
Department of Crop Protection and Environmental Biology, Faculty of Agriculture, University
Of Ibadan, Nigeria.
Corresponding e-mail: adeyinka.olawale@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Photoperiod sensitivity has been one of major constraint to kenaf production in Nigeria and
countries in the tropics, because it reduces vegetative growth and therefore leads to poor yield.
To understand the genetic architecture of days to flowering for kenaf, two early to mature Nigeria
kenaf accessions (NHC (12)1, NHC (3)2 and two late to mature (NHC (9)2, (NHC) were crossed
and F1 hybrid were planted out at a spacing of 20cm x50cm in Randomized Complete Block
Design with three replicates and 16 treatments (parents, F1 and Reciprocals). Data taken on days
to anthesis (DTA), height (HAH), girth (GAH), base diameter (BDAH) and fresh weight at
harvest (FWAH) were analyzed. The mean square of GCA and SCA are both significant for days
97
98
to anthesis, height and girth at harvest; these indicate that the gene actions for the characters are
controlled by both additive and non additive gene actions. However, fresh weight at harvest was
controlled mainly by non additive gene action. GCA/SCA ratio observed in HAH and GAH are
greater than 1 while it is less than 1 in DTA, BDAH and FWAH indicating that non additive is
most important for the DTA, BDAH, FWAH and additive gene action is most important for HAH
and GAH traits . Parent NHC (12)1, NHC (9)2 are the best general combiners (-7.47 and -6.25
respectfully) for earliness to maturity. Hybrid NHC (3)2 x NHC (9)2 are the best in combination
for early to maturity with positive fibre yield component. It should therefore be used for further
yield improvement in breeding programme.
Keywords: Photoperiod sensitivity, Hibiscus cannabinus anthesis, GCA/SCA ratio, kenaf
breeding.
INTRODUCTION
Kenaf (Hibiscus cannabinus L.) is a member of the Malvaceae family cultivated for the soft core
fiber in its stem. Kenaf originates from Africa (Chen et al., 2004). Kenaf is recently used for
energy and paper pulp production. Kenaf production is faced with constraints like lack of disease
resistant hybrid and poor yield compared to other developed countries, Africa produces about
2.91% of the global production (FAO, 2003). Xu (1994) found predominantly additive effects
determining the number of days from seedling emergence to first flowering. Liliana (2006)
revealed that some dominance effects also occurred in the form of a partial dominance for early
flowering. The onset of anthesis usually marks a reduction in vegetative growth which is the
economically important part of kenaf (Webber et al., 2002). Therefore, understanding the genetic
component of days to anthesis trait is important to develop cultivars that would produce
maximum fibre yield within a growing season. The objectives of these studies are; to estimate the
combining ability, additive and non-additive gene effects of days to anthesis and fibre yield in
selected accessions of kenaf from Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Matured F1 (hybrids) seed obtained from four parents (two early to mature and 2 late to mature)
crossed in all possible ways in the preliminary experiment were planted in the Crop Garden of
Crop Protection and Experimental biology, university of Ibadan located on latitude 7°34' and
98
99
longitude 3°54', altitude 220m, in a Randomized Complete Block Design with three replicates
and 16 treatments at a spacing of 20cm x50cm. Necessary agricultural management practices
were carried out when due. Data were taken on day to flowering and height, basal girth, diameter
and fresh weight at harvest at about 160 days after planting. Analyses of variance were done and
means were separated by least significant difference (Lsd < 0.05). Analysis of the combining
ability for the experiment was done following Griffing’s Method 1, where parents, F1’s and
reciprocals are included
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Mean squares for parents and their F1s (Table 1) revealed highly significant variations for all
Source
Df
DTA
HAH
BDAH
GAH
FWAH
characters. That may indicate a wide genetic variability for studied characters, which may
facilitate genetic improvement using such genetic pools of kenaf.
The means squares of GCA and SCA are both significant (Table 1), for days to anthesis, height
and girth at harvest. This indicates that the gene action in kenaf for these characters is controlled
by both additive gene and non- additive which was similar to what Su, (2004) reported. The
variance due to GCA, hence additive gene action, was more pronounced for height and girth at
harvesting. Meanwhile, variance due to SCA, as an indicator of non-additive gene action, was
greater for days to anthesis, basal diameter and fresh weight at harvesting.
Table 1: Mean squares from analysis of variance, general combining ability (GCA), specific
combining ability (SCA) for five characters in some selected Nigeria kenaf.
99
100
Treatment
15.00
1466.82*
3142.11*
0.46*
3.47*
38059.082*
REP
2.00
6.57
1006.24
0.10
1.95
6128.34
GCA
2.00
777.90*
1712.68*
0.14
2*
6604.09
SCA
6.00
1689.51*
1218.10*
0.24
1.5*
23184.54*
0.46
1.41
0.61
1.33
0.28
GCA/SCA
Reciprocal
6.00
118.30*
829.43**
0.10
0.73
6330.00
ERROR
30.00
18.64
317.89
0.07
0.56
3819.69
*- significant at 0.05, **- significant at 0.01.
REP = Replicate, GCA = General combining ability, SCA = Specific combining ability, DTA=
Days to anthesis, HAH=Height at harvest, GAH= Girth at harvest, FWAH= fresh weight at
harvest and BDAH= Base diameter at harvest
Table 2: Estimates of GCA on five characters in some selected Nigeria kenaf
Parents
DTA
HAH
BDAH
GAH
DWAH
NHC(12)1
-7.47*
4.41
0.10
0.41*
27.58*
NHC(3)2
5.16*
-3.15
-0.01
-0.03
NHC(9)2
-6.25*
13.48*
0.06
0.17
NHC 15
8.55*
-14.74*
-0.15*
-0.55*
-27.97*
SE
1.32
5.46
0.08
0.23
18.92
7.53
-7.14
*- significant at 0.05
Table 3: Estimates of SCA effect and reciprocal effect on five characters in selected Nigeria
kenaf genotypes.
100
101
Specific combining effects
DTA
HAH
BDAH
GAH
WAH
NHC(12)1xNHC(3)2
-8.88*
10.74
0.07
0.13
52.02
NHC(12)1xNHC(9)2
18.01*
16.17
0.18
0.32
83.49*
NHC(12)1 x NHC 15
-11.80*
16.30
0.13
0.41
21.55
NHC(3)2x NHC(9)2
-5.75*
12.58
0.33*
0.85*
91.46*
NHC(3)2x NHC 15
-18.07*
5.09
0.16
0.26
59.24
NHC(9)2x NHC 15
-13.09*
11.59
0.11
0.49
-17.76
Standard error
2.41
9.97
0.14
0.42
34.55
NHC(12)1xNHC(3)2
-0.40
7.89
-0.11
-0.32
17.22
NHC(12)1xNHC(9)2
-18.02*
-20.10*
-0.23
-0.61
-99.58*
NHC(12)1 x NHC15
0.44
21.09*
0.26
0.71
39.31
NHC(3)2x NHC(9)2
-4.71
14.19
-0.01
-0.28
-2.50
NHC(3)2x NHC 15
-2.03
-19.71
0.01
0.01
-65.28
NHC(9)2x NHC 15
-1.90
31.43*
0.41*
1.07*
54.44
Standard error
3.05
12.61
0.18
0.53
43.70
Reciprocal
Effects
*- significant at 0.05
101
102
Comparison between GCA effects associated with each parent (Table 2) revealed that
NHC(3)2 and NHC 15 showed positive and highly significant, effects for days to anthesis,
while it showed significant negative effect for height, base diameter and girth at harvest.
NHC (12)1 has positive significant GCA in girth and weight at harvesting and NHC (9)2 has
positive significant on height at harvest, Thus the negative estimates in days to anthesis and
positive estimates in girth and fresh weight at harvest for NHC (12)1, and the negative
estimates in days to anthesis and positive estimates in height at harvest for NHC (9)2
accessions can be used for development of hybrids with early days to maturity with high
yield.
Six crosses (NHC(12)1xNHC(3)2, NHC(12)1 x NHC 15, NHC(3)2x NHC(9)2, NHC(3)2x
NHC 15, NHC(9)2x NHC 15 and NHC(12)1xNHC(9)2) had negative significant SCA
effects for days to anthesis ( Table 3). However among all the crosses only NHC (3)2x
NHC (9)2 has a significant SCA effects in base diameter, girth and fresh weight at harvest
with significant negative SCA estimates for days to anthesis. In the reciprocal effect, only
NHC (9)2xNHC 15 gave negative significant SCA effects in days to anthesis and positive
significant values in height, girth, base diameter at harvest. Hybrids having significant
positive SCA are due to favourable combinations of dominance effects when those parents
are crossed
CONCLUSION
These crosses could further be explored to breed for kenaf hybrid that produce high fibre
yield despite the earliness to physiological maturity in country located in the low altitude.
Hybrid NHC (3)2x NHC (9)2 and NHC (12)1x NHC (9)2 was the best crosses combiners
for early to maturity and high fibre yield component. It is recommended that based on the
combining ability of the accessions for various traits studied, the selected accessions can be
used for further heterotic breeding research
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Authors are thankful to Department of Crop Production and Environmental Biology,
University of Ibadan for providing an enabling environment for the research.
102
103
REFERENCES
Charles, L., Webber III, and Bledsoe, V.K. (2002). Kenaf yield components and plant
components. In: Janick, J., Whipkey, A. (Eds.), Trends in New Crops and New Use.
ASHS Press, Alexandria, VA, pp. 348–357
Chen Jia-Kuan, Zhou, Bao-Rong Lu, Kazuhiko and Sameshima, Da-Xu Fu1 (2004).
Identification and genetic relationships of kenaf (Hibiscus cannabinus L.) germplasm
revealed by AFLP analysis Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution, 51: 393–401
FAO (2003): Consultation on Natural Fibers, the production and consumption of kenaf in
China.ESC-Fibers Consultation NO: 03/6
Liliana N. Gray, Norma G. Collavino, Graciela E. Simon, Jorge A. Mariotti (2006): Diallelic
analysis of genetic effects determining days to flowering in kenaf, Industrial Crops and
Products, Volume 23, Issue 2, Pages 194-200
Su, J., Chen, A. and Lin, J. (2004): Genetic diversity, evaluation and utilization of kenaf
germplasm in china. Plant Fiber and Products, 26(1): 5-9
Webber, C.L. III, H.L. Bhardwaj, and V.K. Bledsoe. (2002). Kenaf production: Fiber, feed,
and seed. p. 327–339. In: J. Janick and A. Whipkey (eds.), Trends in new crops and new
uses. ASHS Press, Alexandria, VA.
Xu, Z.L. (1994). Genetic analysis of growth rate rhythm and yield characters of kenaf, Acta
Agron.Sin., 20 (4): 411–418.
PGB10
DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SWEETPOTATO VARIETIES: EVALUATION OF
ADVANCE SWEETPOTATO BREEDING LINES AT THE UNIFORM YIELD
TRIAL STAGE IN CONTRASTING AGRO-ECOLOGIES IN NIGERIA.
Afuape, S.O., Njoku, J.C., Njoku, D. N. and Nwankwo, I.I.M.
Sweetpotato Programme, National Root Crops Research Institute, Umudike, PMB 7006,
Umuahia, Abia State, Nigeria.
Corresponding email: solomonafuape@yahoo.com
Mobile phone: +234 803 7777445.
ABSTRACT
In our quest to develop new sweetpotato varieties, fifteen selected promising sweetpotato
lines were evaluated in three contrasting locations for their yield and yield components. The
trials were established using randomized complete block design with three replications in
9m2 plots. Analysis of variance for genotype, location and genotype-by-location interaction
103
104
showed significant (<0.01 P<0.001) differences for number of marketable roots, marketable
roots weight (kg/plot), and total roots weight (kg/plot). Genotypes NRSP/E2 and NRSP/B3
had higher mean number of marketable roots of 40.00 and 35.67 respectively compared
tothe controls (TIS 87/0087 and Ex-Igbariam) with mean number of marketable roots of
32.11 and 30.33 respectively (P>0.05). Mean number of marketable roots were significantly
higher at Abuja than the other two locations, while genotypes NRSP/E2 and Ex-Igbariam
had the highest values for the trait at Abuja. , Line NRSP/C6 had the highest values of 12.12
and 12.40 kg/plot respectively for weight of marketable and total roots across locations.
Also, the highest weight of total roots of 20.53 kg was recorded by genotype NRSP/C6 at
Otobi, followed by TIS 87/0087 with 18.50 kg at the same location. The least total roots
weight of 0.93 kg was recorded by NRSP/B2 at Umudike. Abuja had the highest mean total
root weight across the genotypes (12.46kg/plot) while Umudike had the least total root
weight (3.35kg/plot). Otobi also supported the growth of sweetpotato with a total root
weight across genotypes of 11.44 kg. However, Otobi appears to correctly classified the
genotypes as the good lines gave high yields while the poor lines gave poor yields. The
significant (P<0.0001) correlation of mean number and weight of marketable roots with
weight of total roots support the fact that the two traits are important sweetpotato yield
components.
INTRODUCTION
Sweetpotato (Ipomoea batatas L.[Lam.]) is a dicotyledonous root crop and a member of the
family Convulvulaceæ (Woolfe, 1992). It is the only member of Ipomoea of major economic
importance (Woolfe, 1992). Globally, it is the 7th most important crop in terms of annual
production and the third most important root and tuber crop after cassava and yam in
Nigeria. China, with production figure of 75.6 million tonnes in 2011, is the largest producer
of sweetpotato in the world, while Tanzania and Nigeria with annual production figures of
3.57 and 2.73 million tonnes respectively (FAOSTAT, 2013) are the second and third largest
producers in the world.
Today in Nigeria, sweetpotato has become a more important root crop than it was in 1970s
and 1980s. A recent (July, 2013) sweetpotato-based agro-enterprise survey (data
unpublished) conducted in selected towns in Abia, Kwara, Lagos, Oyo and Plateau states
indicated emerging small-scale commercial utilization of sweetpotato in the fries, crisp,
chips, flour, fermented non-alcoholic beverage (Kunnu) and bread (in Ilorin alone)
enterprises. These are in addition to the popular boil and eat as well as portage forms of
consumption. However, cultivation of the crop in the country is still largely dominated by
landraces and unproductive cultivars. To enhance the growth of these emerging enterprises,
new sweetpotato varieties must dominate the production system. The development of new
varieties is in cycle and the uniform yield trial (UYT) is at the tail end of the selection cycle.
Yield has been identified as one of the most important farmer-preferred traits (Rees et al.,
2003). Any variety that will be acceptable to farmers must first be high yielding. This work
was carried out in order to identify high-yielding genotypes across locations at the uniform
yield trial stage.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Fifteen sweetpotato breeding lines in advanced yield selection stage were evaluated in three
locations (Umudike, Abuja and Otobi). The locations are situated within two distinct agro104
105
ecologies. The agro-meteorological characteristics of the three locations are presented in
Table 1.
Table 1: Agro-meteorological characteristics of the three locations involved in the
evaluation of the 15 sweetpotato genotypes at the uniform yield trial phase.
Agro-meteorological characteristics
Longitude Latitude
Altitude Soil
type
Location
0500291'N 122 m
Total
annual
rainfall
(mm)
Ultisol 2064.10
Average Agromonthly ecology
temp
(0C)
30.2
Rain
forest
belt
070696'N
141 m
Alfisol 914.30
31.8
09004'N
426 m
Alfisol 952.52
32.5
State
Umudike Abia
0700331E
Otobi
Benue 0800632E
Nyanya
Abuja
07037’E
Guinea
savannah
Southern
guinea
savannah
Sources: *Agro-meteorological Unit, National Root Crops Research Institute, Umudike,
Abia State.
The fifteen genotypes were laid out in a randomized complete block design with three
replications. The plot size was 9m2 containing 30 plants per plot with plant spacing of 1m x
0.3m, giving plant density of 33,333 stands per hectare. NPK 15:15:15 fertilizer was applied
at the rate of 400kg/hectare immediately after first weeding at four weeks after planting.
Data were collected, on plot basis, on number of large (roots > 150g) roots, weight (kg/plot)
of large roots, and total root yield (kg/plot). Combined analysis of variance was performed
on the data using the SAS GLM procedure (SAS, 1992). Means were separated by Fisher’s
LSD (0.05). The genotypes were compared against the checks (TIS 87/0087 and ExIgbariam). Principal component biplot was also used to show genotype – location
relationship.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
New sweetpotato varieties are often bred for varied attributes. Fresh sweetpotato root yield
is one of the most important traits for developing new sweetpotato varieties. The number of
roots (Gasura et al., 2008; Afuape et al., 2011) and weight of marketable roots (i.e. large
root size) (Afuape et al., 2011) are some of the most important root yield components.
However, the cultivation environment often influences the expression of most traits of the
crop. Table 2 shows that significant (P<0.01 to P<0.0001) genotypic and location variation
still existed among the fifteen genotypes for number and weight (kg/plot) for large roots, as
well as the total root yield (made up of weights of large and small roots). Genotypic and
location effects had been reported severally for root yield and number and weight of roots
among elite genotypes of sweetpotato (Islam et al., 2002; Afuape et al., 2011).
Crop performance is a function of the genotype of the crop and the nature of the
environment in which it is produced (Cooper and Byth, 1996). Table 3 shows that mean
105
106
number of large (>150g) roots of the advanced lines differed across and within locations.
Genotype NRSP/E2 had the highest mean number of large roots of 40.44, followed by
NRSP/B3 with 35.67 (P>0.05), and both were more than most of other lines. The Abuja
location supported the development of more large roots than the other two locations (Otobi
and Umudike). However, NRSP/E2 at Abuja had the highest mean number of large roots of
67.67 per plot.
High number of large roots seemed not to literally translate to high mean weight of the roots,
and this can be so only when mean weight of roots of each genotype differ. Genotype
NRSP/C6 had the highest combined mean weight of large roots of 12.12kg/plot, followed by
TIS 87/0087 with mean weight of 11.25 (P>0.05) (Table 4). Comparing the locations, the
Abuja location recorded the highest mean large root weight of 11.54 kg compared to 10.80
kg of Otobi (P>0.05) and 2.94 kg of Umudike (P<0.05). However, genotypes NRSP/C6 at
Otobi had the highest mean large root weight of 20.33 kg/plot.
Mean total root yield is made up of mean weight of both large (>150g) and small roots
(<150g). For total root yield (Table 5) across locations, genotype NRSP/C6 with yield level
of 12.40 kg had the highest root mean total root yield, followed by the check TIS 87/0087
with yield level of 12.03 kg (P>0.05). Overall, NRSP/C6 had the highest yield performance
of 20.53kg/plot at Otobi, followed by TIS 87/0087 with yield level of 18.50 kg. This
suggests that the Otobi production environment may be better suited for commercial
production of sweetpotato using specific genotypes. Both Abuja and Otobi locations were
not different in their overall mean yield level across the genotypes, but both recorded higher
yield than Umudike (P<0.05).
Figure 1 presents the biplot of the principal component analysis (PCA). The tool was used to
show which genotype(s) were more adapted to which location(s). This tool has been used by
Afuape et al. (2011) to show the relationship between genotypes and traits. Genotypes
NRSP/F8, Ex-Igbariam NRSP/E2 and NRSP/B2 were more adapted to Abuja in root
yielding ability. Genotypes NRSP/C6, TIS 87/008 and NRSP/A5 seem to be more adapted
to the Otobi location, while the yield of NRSP/B3 and NRSP/OP were better supported by
the Umudike location. Genotype NRSP/E3 seems to be the most stable genotype across the
three locations in term of yield, while NRSP/D10 and NRSP/C7 also showed relative
stability in the three locations.
CONCLUSION
The presence of genotype-by-environment interaction in the evaluation of the advanced
sweetpotato breeding lines in the three locations for important traits has shown the necessity
for multi-locations evaluation of breeding lines. It has afforded the opportunity for the
selection of location-specific and generally adapted breeding lines for further field
evaluations.
Table 2: Mean squares of the analysis of variance of yield and yield components of
advanced fifteen genotypes of sweetpotato.
Mean squares
Sources
of Degrees
of Number of large Weight (kg/plot) Total root yield
106
107
variation
freedom
(>150g) roots
of large roots
(weight/plot)
Genotype
14
406.8963**
40.3294**
41.2319**
Location
2
6658.0519***
1021.5407***
1121.8531***
Replication
2
42.8741ns
11.4029ns
16.4389ns
320.3158**
45.0908***
48.7743***
153.1923
11.2172
11.8417
Genotype
Location
* 28
Error
88
Total
134
Table 3: Genotype-by-location interaction means for number large roots of fifteen advanced
genotypes of sweetpotato evaluated in three locations.
Genotypes
Locations
Abuja
Otobi
Umudike
Mean Genotype)
TIS 87/0087
46.67
36.00
1.67
32.11
NRSP/A5
32.00
29.33
13.67
25.00
NRSP/B1
41.67
13.00
20.33
25.00
NRSP/B2
37.33
21.67
5.00
21.33
NRSP/B3
48.00
32.33
26.67
35.67
NRSP/C6
29.33
36.67
12.33
26.11
NRSP/C7
26.67
23.67
10.67
20.33
NRSP/D10
30.67
26.00
15.67
24.11
NRSP/D7
18.00
8.33
17.00
14.44
NRSP/E2
67.67
44.00
9.67
40.44
NRSP/E3
36.00
20.33
19.00
25.11
Ex-Igbariam
61.67
19.67
9.67
30.33
NRSP/F8
56.67
17.33
7.67
27.22
NRSP/OP
19.33
21.67
17.67
19.80
NRSP/OP5
24.33
21.67
13.33
19.78
Mean (Location)
38.40
24.78
14.12
FLSD0.05 for comparing the means of genotypes across locations = 11.60
FLSD0.05 for comparing the means of locations across genotypes = 5.19
107
108
FLSD0.05 for comparing genotype * location means = 20.08
Table 4: Genotype-by-location interaction means for weight (kg/plot) of large roots of
fifteen advanced genotypes of sweetpotato evaluated in three locations.
Genotypes
Locations
Abuja
Otobi
Umudike
Mean Genotype)
TIS 87/0087
13.53
17.70
2.53
11.26
NRSP/A5
11.73
15.40
2.67
9.93
NRSP/B1
11.80
3.85
4.60
6.75
NRSP/B2
13.50
10.97
0.67
8.38
NRSP/B3
13.00
12.20
5.83
10.34
NRSP/C6
11.93
20.33
4.10
12.12
NRSP/C7
9.93
13.47
2.07
8.49
NRSP/D10
9.73
11.00
3.44
8.06
NRSP/D7
3.60
2.40
4.30
3.43
NRSP/E2
15.00
10.93
1.13
9.02
NRSP/E3
14.33
9.00
4.90
9.41
Ex-Igbariam
14.47
4.37
1.53
6.79
NRSP/F8
16.00
3.60
1.13
6.91
NRSP/OP
5.2
14.87
3.33
7.80
NRSP/OP5
9.27
11.93
1.87
7.69
Mean (Location)
11.54
10.80
2.94
FLSD0.05 for comparing the means of genotypes across locations = 3.14
FLSD0.05 for comparing the means of locations across genotypes = 1.40
FLSD0.05 for comparing genotype * location means = 5.43
Table 5: Genotype-by-location interaction means for total root yield (kg/plot) of fifteen
advanced genotypes of sweetpotato evaluated in three locations.
Genotypes
TIS 87/0087
Locations
Abuja
Otobi
Umudike
Mean Genotype)
14.37
18.50
3.23
12.03
108
109
NRSP/A5
13.13
15.82
3.37
10.77
NRSP/B1
12.50
3.97
5.08
7.18
NRSP/B2
14.47
11.40
.93
8.93
NRSP/B3
13.87
13.00
6.33
11.07
NRSP/C6
12.37
20.53
4.30
12.40
NRSP/C7
10.13
14.20
2.25
8.86
NRSP/D10
10.60
12.27
3.67
8.85
NRSP/D7
4.40
2.80
4.63
3.98
NRSP/E2
17.07
12.97
1.40
10.48
NRSP/E3
14.80
9.32
5.20
9.77
Ex-Igbariam
16.57
4.93
1.97
7.82
NRSP/F8
17.20
4.36
1.34
7.64
NRSP/OP
5.53
15.22
4.00
8.25
NRSP/OP5
9.90
12.33
2.50
8.24
Mean (Location)
12.48
11.44
3.35
FLSD0.05 for comparing the means of genotypes across locations = 3.22
FLSD0.05 for comparing the means of locations across genotypes = 1.44
FLSD0.05 for comparing genotype * location means = 5.58
109
110
Figure 1: Principal component biplot of genotypes and locations showing genotypes that
perform best in each location.
REFERENCES
Afuape, S. O., Okocha P. I. and Njoku D. N. 2011. Multivariate assessment of the
agromorphological variability and yield components among sweetpotato (Ipomoea
batatas (L.) Lam) landraces. African Journal of Plant Science, Vol. 5 (2): 123-132.
Cooper, M. and Byth, D. E. 1996. Understanding plant adaptation to achieve systematic
applied crop improvement – a fundamental challenge. In: Plant Adaptation and
Crop Improvement. Cooper, M. and Hammer, G.L. (Eds). C.A.B. International,
Pp. 5-23.
FAOSTAT 2013. Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations 2011 Crop
Production Figures for Sweetpotato, released by FAO Statistics Division, February
10, 2013.
Gasura, E., Mashingaidze, A.B. and. Mukasa, S.B. 2008. Genetic variability for tuber yield,
quality, and virus disease complex traits in Uganda sweetpotato germplasm. African
Crop Science Journal, 16(2): 147 – 160.
Islam, M.J., Haque, M.Z., Majunder, U.K., Haque, M.M. and Hossain, M.F. 2002. Growth
and yield potentials of nine genotypes of sweetpotato. Pakistan J. Biol. Sci., 5(5):
537-538.
110
111
Rees, D., Van Oirschot, Q. and Kapinga, R. 2003. Sweetpotato Post–Harvest Assessment:
Experiences from East Africa. Chatham, UK.
SAS Instittute (1992). SAS System for Personal Computers 1002-SAS Institute Inc., Carry,
NC 27512-8000, USA.
PGB11
COMBINING ABILITY FOR MAIZE GRAIN YIELD, AGRONOMIC TRAITS AND
STRIGA HERMONTHICA RESISTANCE UNDER ARTIFICIAL STRIGA
INFESTATION
Haliru, B.S.1*, Abubakar, L.1, Ado, S.G.2, Shehu, K.3 and Singh, A.4
1
Department of Crop Science, Usmanu Danfodiyo University, Sokoto, Nigeria.
2
Department of Plant Science, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
3
Department of Biological Sciences, Usmanu Danfodiyo University, Sokoto, Nigeria.
4
School of Biosciences, Faculty of Science, The University of Nottingham, Malaysia Campus,
Jalan Broga, Semenyih 43500, Selangor, Malaysia.
*Corresponding email: bellosanihaliru@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
A study was conducted at Institute for Agricultural Research, Samaru Teaching and Research
Farm during 2011 rainy season to determine general and specific combining abilities for grain
yield, agronomic traits and Striga hermonthica resistance in maize. Nine Striga resistant maize
inbred lines were mated in design II fashion to produce F1 hybrids. The results revealed that
general and specific combining ability effects were low for grain yield and other morphological
traits. However, parent TZEEI 19 is a good general combiner for grain yield while hybrids
TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34 and TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19 are good specific combiners for grain yield.
Also, parents TZEEI 6, TZEEI 28, TZEEI 19 and TZEEI 78 are good general combiners for
earliness while hybrids TZEEI 1 x TZEE 34, TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19 and TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 28
are good specific combiners for earliness. Simlarly, general and specific combining ability
effects were low for Striga related traits with some parents (TZEEI 6, TZEEI 19 and TZEEI 78)
and F1 hybrids (TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34 and TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 28) recording negative estimates,
thus showing resistance to S. hermonthica. Therefore, these hybrids that showed good
performance for grain yield, agronomic traits and Striga hermonthica resistance may be further
tested for commercial maize production for S. hermonthica endemic areas of Northern Guinea
Savanna.
Keywords: Combining ability, grain yield, agronomic traits, Striga hermonthica.
INTRODUCTION
Maize is the third most important principal cereal food crop of the world after wheat and rice (Rafique et
al., 2004). It provides the bulk of raw materials for livestock and agro-based industries in the production
of starch, corn chips, corn bread, glucose and oil (Nuhu et al., 2008). It is cultivated both as rainfed and
under irrigation across the six agro-ecological zones of Nigeria, with Northern Nigeria accounting for
more than half of the total production (NAERLS, 1987). Despite great potential of maize, Striga
111
112
hermonthica (Del.) Benth. is one of the most serious production constraints to maize production by
small holder farmers in Sub-saharan Africa. Infestation results in substantial yield losses ranging from
10 to 100% depending on the variety and environmental conditions (Kroschel, 1999). The estimated
economic loss attributable to this parasitic weed has not been quantified in recent years (Badu-Apraku et
al., 2009), however, M’Boob (1986) reported an estimate of US $7 billion per annum. Previous research
effort identified control measures such as hand pulling, crop rotation, trap and catch cropping, higher
rate of fertilizer application, fallow, seed treatment, chemical control and breeding (Eplee, 1992;
Shaxson and Riches, 1998; Odhiambo and Ramson, 2000). However, for most African small holder
farmers, the most appropriate strategy would be one that requires limited financial outlay and could be
adapted to their farming systems. One such simple, control method, is the use of resistant/tolerant
variety (Badu-Apraku et al., 2004 and Badu-Apraku et al., 2005). The use of resistant variety is not only
compatible with low cost input requirement of small scale farmers but also environmental friendly as it
reduces the detrimental consequences of chemical sprays on non-target organisms and environment.
Many researchers have used combining ability to solve maize agronomic problems. Olaoye and Bello
(2009) using partial diallel to study the combining ability for grain yield among 45 maize hybrids in
Striga endemic and non-endemic environments, revealed that SCA effects for Striga related characters
such as Striga shoot count and flowering Striga shoot were generally low. In another study, Olakojo and
Olaoye (2005) using combining ability technique reported that GCA effects of the parent inbreds for
Striga shoot count and Striga syndrome rating were generally low with some parents recording negative
values. The objectives of this study were (1) to determine the general and specific combining abilities of
the parent inbreds for agronomic traits and resistance to S. hermonthica and (2) to identify maize hybrid
which combine Striga resistance with grain yield for possible use in commercial hybrid maize
production.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was conducted at Institute for Agricultural Research Teaching and Research Farm
Striga sick plot, Samaru during 2011 rainy season (Lat. 110 11’, Long. 70 38’ and 686m above sea
level). A design II mating scheme was used to intermate nine Striga resistant maize inbred lines to
produce 20 F1 hybrids. However, because of poor performance of the parents which resulted to seed
shortage only six parents and six hybrids were evaluated. The land was prepared by mechanical
ploughing, harrowing and ridging at onset of the rainy season before commencement of the research.
Entries which included six parents and six hybrids were made in a row plot of 3.0 x 0.75m each. The
trial was laid out in 4 x 4 partially balanced lattice design replicated thrice. Two maize seeds were sown
per hill. Spacing of 75 x 50cm was used to obtain plant population of about 55,333 plants per hectare.
Striga seeds were sourced from Institute for Agricultural Research, Samaru. Striga inoculum was
prepared by thoroughly mixing Striga seeds with sand at a ratio of 1:39 by weight to obtain
approximately 3000 germinable seeds per gram of sand to seed mixture (Berner et al., 1997). One gram
of sand to seed (1:1) mixture was placed in each sowing hole before maize seeds were sown on a hill.
Low fertilizer was applied at the rate of 50kg N ha-1, 30kg P2O5 ha-1 and 30kg K2O ha-1 (NPK 20:10:10)
in split doses, half of N and all of P2O5 and K2O were applied at two weeks after sowing (WAS) and the
remaining N was applied at 6 WAS to minimize the likelihood of N suppressing Striga emergence as
described by Olakojo and Olaoye (2005). Weeds other than Striga were removed by hand pulling at 4, 8
and 10 WAS to ensure survival of emerged Striga. Data were collected on Striga related traits such as
Striga count 1 (8WAS), Striga count 2 (10WAS) and number of flowering Striga plants. Other maize
agronomic traits included plant height, days to 50% anthesis, days to 50% silking, cob weight, 100-grain
weight and grain yield were measured. Data collected were subjected to design II analysis as described
by Hallauer et al. (2010). General and specific combining abilities (GCA and SCA) were computed
112
113
using Singh and Chaudhary (1985) for six parents and six hybrids with respect to Striga related and
maize agronomic traits.
RESULTS
General combining ability effects is presented in Table 1. Among the parents, TZEEI 78 recorded
desirable GCA effects for Striga count 1 and Striga count 2 and low GCA effects for number of
flowering Striga plants. TZEEI 1 revealed significant (P 0.05) positive GCA effects for Striga count 1
and Striga count 2 and low GCA effects for number of flowering Striga plants. On the other hand,
TZEEI 6 exhibited significant (P 0.05) negative GCA for Striga count 1 and Striga count 2 and
insignificant negative GCA effects for number of flowering Striga plants. TZEEI 19 revealed significant
(P 0.05) negative GCA effects for Striga count 1 and insignificant GCA effects for Striga count 2. It
also recorded low GCA effects for number of flowering Striga plants. Parent TZEEI 34 exhibited low
positive GCA effects for Striga count 1 and Striga count 2 and negative GCA effects for number of
flowering Striga plants. Specific combining ability effects for Striga related traits are presented in Table
2. The hybrid TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19 recorded positive SCA effect for Striga count 1, Striga count 2 and
number of flowering Striga plants. Hybrid TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34 revealed significant (P 0.05) negative
SCA effects for Striga count 1 and insignificant negative SCA effects for Striga count 2. It showed low
positive SCA effects for number of flowering Striga plants. TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 34 showed low positive
SCA effects for Striga count 1 and Striga count 2 and low negative SCA effects for number of flowering
Striga plants. The hybrid TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 28 recorded low negative SCA effects for Striga count 2
and positive SCA effects for Striga count 1 and number of flowering Striga plants. The hybrid TZEEI
78 x TZEEI 28 revealed negative SCA effects for Striga count 1, Striga count 2 and number of
flowering Striga plants. TZEEI 6 x TZEEI 19 exhibited positive SCA effects for Striga count 1 and
Striga count 2 and low negative SCA effects for number of flowering Striga plants.
General combining ability effects for grain yield and maize agronomic traits are presented in Table 3.
Parent TZEEI 78 recorded significant positive GCA effects for grain yield and desirable GCA effects for
the other traits. TZEEI 1 revealed significant (P 0.05) negative GCA effects for cob weight and grain
yield. The same parent recorded desirable GCA effects for number of leaves per plant, days to 50%
anthesis and days to 50% silking. TZEEI 6 exhibited negative GCA effects for plant height, days to 50%
anthesis, cob weight and grain yield. It also revealed desirable GCA effects for days to 50% silking and
100-grain weight. Parent TZEEI 19 exhibited highly significant (P 0.01) positive GCA effects for cob
weight and grain yield. It also recorded negative GCA effects for days to 50% anthesis and days to 50%
silking. TZEEI 34 depicted significant (P 0.05) negative GCA effects for days to 50% anthesis and
days to 50% silking. It recorded low positive GCA effects for plant height, cob weight, 100-grain weight
and grain yield. TZEEI 28 revealed highly significant (P 0.01) negative GCA effects for grain yield and
cob weight. It exhibited significant (P 0.05) negative GCA effects for days to 50% silking. It also
revealed desirable GCA effects for plant height, number of leaves per plant, days to 50% anthesis and
100-grain weight. Specific combining ability effects are presented in Table 4. The hybrid TZEEI 78 x
TZEEI 19 recorded significant (P 0.05) positive SCA effects for cob weight and grain yield. It also
showed desirable SCA effects for the other traits. Another hybrid TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34 revealed
significant positive (P 0.05) SCA effects for grain yield and significant (P 0.05) negative SCA for
days to 50% anthesis. It exhibited desirable performance for the rest of the traits. TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 28
exhibited desirable SCA effect for grain yield, 100-grain weight and cob weight. The hybrid TZEEI 78 x
TZEEI 34 recorded positive SCA effects for days to 50% anthesis and days to 50% silking. It also
exhibited negative SCA effects for the other traits. The hybrid TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 28 recorded desirable
SCA effects for all the characters except grain yield and cob weight. TZEEI 6 x TZEEI 19 exhibited
113
114
significant (P 0.05) negative SCA effects for grain yield with desirable SCA effect for the rest of the
traits except cob weight and 100-grain weight.
DISCUSSION
In breeding for Striga resistance, the lower the value obtained for Striga related traits the better the
genotypes. The significant GCA effects recorded for Striga count 1 and Striga count 2 among the
parents suggest differential reaction of the parents to S. hermonthica infestation. These results show that
additive gene effects played a major role in the inheritance of resistance to the parasite in the parental
lines. Low GCA effects exhibited for number of flowering Striga plants in some parents is \indicative of
high resistance to S. hermonthica emergence and survival, consequently, a reduction in the rate of Striga
seed multiplication in the soil. Parents TZEEI 1 with high positive GCA effects for Striga count 1 and
Striga count 2 could be regarded as S. hermonthica susceptible, while TZEEI 6 and TZEEI 19 recorded
high negative GCA effects, thus, indicating their resistance to S. hermonthica. The low negative GCA
effects recorded in parent TZEEI 78 for Striga count 1 and Striga count 2 and low GCA effects for
number of flowering Striga plants suggest its resistance to S. hermonthica infestation. In a similar study,
Kim (1994) reported low GCA effect for S. hermonthica emergence and host-plant response for most
tolerant maize inbreds and high GCA effects for the susceptible. The low negative and positive SCA
effects recorded for Striga related traits indicated differential response of the crosses to the Striga related
parameters. In other words, non-additive gene effects played a vital role in the inheritance of Striga
resistance in the crosses. The highly resistant crosses are TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19 and TZEEI 1 x TZEEI
34 which were both derived from different Striga resistant parents. Kim (1991) reported that the highest
level of tolerance to S. hermonthica was obtained from crosses involving two resistant parents while
most of the susceptible hybrids were from crosses involving susceptible x susceptible parents.
There were differential responses among the parent inbred lines for maize agronomic characters under S.
hermonthica infestation. The Low GCA effects recorded for maize grain yield in some of the parents
indicate poor combining ability in terms of grain yield under Striga infestation. However, parent TZEEI
19 exhibited highly significant positive GCA effects for grain yield and cob weight, while TZEEI 78
recorded significant GCA effects for grain yield. The results obtained indicate that these parents will be
suitable for yield improvement under Striga infestation. Badu-Apraku and Lum (2007) reported that
varieties differed significantly in grain yield under both Striga endemic and Striga free environments.
Similarly, Badu-Apraku et al. (2008) reported low grain yield for most of the parents used in their
studies under Striga infestation. The significant negative GCA effects for grain yield and cob weight
recorded by TZEEI 1 and TZEEI 28 under Striga infestation indicate susceptibility to Striga. This
further reveals poor combining ability of these parents with respect to these traits. Plant height is an
important trait to be considered in maize breeding especially since very tall maize plants could lodge
easily. An optimum plant height is required to prevent the crop from lodging and protect the cob from
rodent damage. Thus, TZEEI 1, TZEEI 6, TZEEI 28 and TZEEI 34 are potential parents which recorded
negative GCA effects for plant height. These findings corroborate Das and Islam (1994) and Hussain et
al. (2003) who adjudged that inbred lines are good general combiners for short plant height in their
studies. The significant positive GCA effects recorded for flowering traits (days to 50% anthesis and
days to 50% silking) in the parent TZEEI 34 indicates probable lateness to maturity. However, TZEEI
28 showed significant negative GCA effects for days to 50% silking reveals probable earliness to
maturity. Also, the negative GCA effects for flowering traits in the parents TZEEI 19, TZEEI 6 and
TZEEI 78 indicate possible earliness to maturity. This further reveals the potential importance of these
inbred lines in the improvement of these traits. Legesse et al. (2009) reported several parental inbred
lines with desirable GCA effects for days to 50% silking.
114
115
Specific combining ability effect is an index to determine the importance of a particular cross
combination in the exploitation of heterosis. Three hybrids (TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 34, TZEEI 78 x TZEEI
28 and TZEEI 6 x TZEEI 19) expressed negative SCA effects for grain yield which were considered
undesirable. However, out of the three hybrids that revealed negative SCA effects for grain yield, TZEEI
6 x TZEEI 19 recorded significant negative SCA effect which was considered as a poor specific cross
combination. The hybrid TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19 was the best specific cross combination because it
showed significant SCA effects for cob weight and grain yield. Similarly, TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34 recorded
significant positive SCA effects for grain yield. These hybrids appeared to be ideal specific combiners
for grain yield under Striga infestation. This further suggests that non-additive gene effects played a
major role in the expression of grain yield among crosses under S. hermonthica infestation. Olaoye and
Bello (2009) reported the importance of non-additive gene effects for grain yield among crosses under
Striga infestation in the Southern Guinea Savanna of Nigeria. Similarly, in a related study conducted in
the South-western ecological zone of Nigeria, Olakojo and Olaoye (2005) revealed that non-additive
gene effects played a significant role for grain yield among crosses under S. lutea infestation. Positive
SCA effects among the following hybrids: TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 28, TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 34 and TZEEI 6 x
TZEEI 19 for flowering traits indicated probable lateness to maturity of the hybrids, while those with
negative effects revealed probable earliness to maturity. These results show differential response of the
crosses with respect to these traits. The hybrids TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34, TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19 and TZEEI
78 x TZEEI 28 which showed negative SCA effects for flowering traits could be crossed with other
promising germplasm to generate populations with early maturity and high yield under Striga
infestation. Similar result was reported by Olaoye and Bello (2009). Three hybrids (TZEEI 1 x TZEEI
34, TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19 and TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 28) showed positive SCA effects for plant height
reflecting an increasing trend in plant stature. The other hybrids (TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 28, TZEEI 78 x
TZEEI 34 and TZEEI 6 x TZEEI 19) revealed negative SCA effects which is considered important for
lodging resistance. This result was similar to that of Sharma (2006). TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34 and TZEEI 1
x TZEEI 28 recorded desirable SCA effects for cob weight and 100-grain weight. The hybrid TZEEI 78
x TZEEI 19 also revealed desirable SCA effects for cob weight. This indicates the importance of nonadditive gene effects for yield related traits under S. hermonthica infestation. Dhaliwal and Sharma
(1990) reported similar findings.
CONCLUSION
The results obtained from this study indicated that the general and specific combining ability effects
were low for grain yield and most agronomic traits. Similarly, general and specific combining ability
effects were low for Striga related traits with some parents (TZEEI 6, TZEEI 19 and TZEEI 78) and F1
hybrids (TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34 and TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 28) and recording negative estimates, thus
indicating resistance to S. hermonthica. Also, the hybrids TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34 and TZEEI 78 x TZEEI
19 are good specific combiners for grain yield and could be adopted for improvement of grain yield and
Striga resistance for S. hermonthica endemic areas of Northern Guinea Savanna of Nigeria.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The inbred lines used in this study were developed by the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture
(IITA), Ibadan. We are grateful to IITA for the supply of the inbred lines. We are also grateful to the
Director, Institute for Agricultural Research, Samaru for providing land in the Striga- sick plot where the
trial was conducted.
115
116
116
117
Table 1: General combining ability effects for Striga related traits evaluated at Samaru
during 2011 rainy season under artificial S. hermonthica infestation.
Parents
Striga
count 1
(8WAS)
Striga
count 2
(10WAS)
Number of
flowering Striga
plants
TZEEI 1
6.389*
9.389*
0.222
TZEEI 6
-6.944*
-9.111*
-1.111
TZEEI 19
-5.278*
-6.944
1.222
TZEEI 28
4.222
6.556
-0.944
TZEEI 34
1.056
0.389
-0.278
TZEEI 78
-1.944
-3.222
0.222
SE (gca effects)
2.132
3.827
1.514
* refers to significant at 0.05 probability level
Table 2: Specific combining ability effects for Striga related traits evaluated at Samaru
during 2011 rainy season under artificial S. hermonthica infestation.
Hybrids
Striga
Striga
Number
of
count 1
count 2
flowering Striga
(8WAS)
(10WAS)
Plants
*
TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 28
2.444
-0.389
-0.944
TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34
-7.722*
-6.556
-0.278
TZEEI 6 x TZEEI 19
5.278
6.944
-1.222
TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19
3.611
5.389
2.111
TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 28
-6.889
-5.778
-1.389
TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 34
3.278
0.389
-0.722
SE (sca effects)
3.692
6.629
2.621
refers
to
significant
at
117
0.05
probability
level
118
Table 3: General combining ability effects for maize agronomic traits evaluated at Samaru during 2011 rainy season under
artificial S. hermonthica infestation.
Parents
Plant
height
Number
of leaves
per plant
Days to
50%
anthesis
Days to
50%
silking
Cob
weight
100-grain
weight
Grain
yield
TZEEI 1
-3.127
0.111
0.667
0.333
-0.094*
-1.444
-0.397*
TZEEI 6
-3.276
-0.389
-0.167
0.833
-0.037
0.889
-0.157
TZEEI 19
4.876
-0.056
-0.667
-0.333
0.173**
1.556
0.744**
TZEEI 28
-4.686
-0.222
-0.667
-1.167*
-0.164**
-0.444
-0.704**
TZEEI 34
-0.191
0.278
1.333*
1.500*
-0.009
-1.111
-0.041
TZEEI 78
3.177
0.056
-0.389
-0.500
0.075
0.667
0.317*
SE (gca effects)
3.839
0.199
0.514
0.568
0.039
1.697
0.154
*, ** refer to significant at 0.05 and 0.01 probability levels, respectively.
118
10
Table 4: Specific combining ability effects for maize agronomic traits evaluated at Samaru during 2011 rainy season under
artificial S. hermonthica infestation.
Hybrids
Plant
height
Number
leaves
per plant
100-grain
weight
Grain
yield
TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 28
-6.293
-0.278
1.167
1.000
0.044
0.111
0.184
TZEEI 1 x TZEEI 34
11.169
0.222
1.833*
-1.333
0.129
1.444
0.561*
TZEEI 6 x TZEEI 19
-4.876
0.056
0.667
0.333
-0.173
-1.556
-0.744*
TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 19
4.975
0.278
-0.111
-0.667
0.135*
0.000
0.584*
TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 28
6.243
0.111
-1.444
-0.833
-0.025
0.667
-0.104
TZEEI 78 x TZEEI 34
-11.218
-0.389
1.556
1.500
-0.110
-0.667
-0.481
SE (sca effects)
6.649
0.344
0.890
0.984
0.068
2.940
0.266
*
refers
to
of Days
to Days
50%
50%
anthesis
silking
significant
at
10
to Cob
weight
0.05
probability
level.
11
References
Badu-Apraku, B., Fakorede, M.A.B., Menkir, A., Kamara, A.Y. Akanvou, L. and Chabi, Y.
(2004). Sreening maize for drought tolerance in the Guinea Savanna of West
and
Central Africa. Journal of Genetics and Breeding, 58:119-130.
Badu-Apraku, B., Fakorede, M.A.B., Menkir, A., Kamara, A.Y. and Dapaah, S. (2005). Sreening
maize for drought tolerance in the Guinea savanna of West and Central
Africa. Cereals
Research Communication, 33:533-540.
Badu-Apraku, B. and Fontem Lum, A. (2007). Agronomic performance of Striga resistant early
maturing maize varieties and inbred lines in the savannas of West and Central Africa.
Crop Science, 47:737-748.
Badu-Apraku, B., Fontem Lum, A., Fakorede, M.A.B., Menkir, A., Chabi Y., The, C., Abdulai,
V., Jacob, S. and Agbaje, S. (2008). Performance of early maize cultivars derived from
recurrent selection for grain yield and Striga resistance. Crop Science, 48:99-112.
Badu-Apraku, B., Fakorede, M.A.B., Menkir, A. (2009). Recurrent selection for Striga resistance
in early and extra-early maize populations in West Africa. African Crop Science
Conference Proceedings, 9:415-424. African Crop Science Society.
Berner, D.K. Winslow, M.D., Awad, A.E., Cardwell, K.F., Mohan Raj, D.R. and Kim, S.K.
(1997). Striga Research Methods: A manual 2nd edition. IITA Ibadan, Nigeria. 5357pp.
Dhaliwal, T. S. and Sharma, H. L. (1990). Combining ability and maternal effects for agronomic
and grain characters in rice. Oryza, 27:122-128.
Das, U. R. and Islam, M. H. (1994). Combining ability and genetic studies for grain yield and its
components in maize (Zea mays L.). Bangladesh Journal of Plant Breeding and Genetics,
7(2):41-47.
Eplee, E.E. (1992). Witchweed (Striga asiatica): An overview of management strategies in
the U.S.A. Crop Protection (Oxford), II:3-7.
Hallauer, A. R., Carena, M. J. and Miranda Filho, J. B. (2010). Quantitative genetics in maize
breeding. Third edition. Springer Science+Business Media LLC. 663pp.
Hussain, S. A., Amiruzzaman, M. and Hossain, Z. (2003). Combining ability estimate in maize.
Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Research, 28(3): 435-440.
Kim, S.K. (1991). Breeding maize for Striga tolerance and development of a field infestation
technique. In: Kim S.K. (ed.) Combating Striga in Africa. Proceedings of the International
Workshop organized by IITA, ICRISAT and IDRC. IITA, Ibadan, Nigeria. 96-108pp.
Kim, S.K. (1994). Breeding maize for Striga hermonthica tolerant open pollinated maize varieties
in Africa. In: Menyonga et al (ed). Progress in food grains research production in semiarid Africa. Proceeding of the SAFGRAD inter-network conference, Niamey, Nigeria. 7th14th March, 1991. 263-273pp.
Kroschel, J. (1999). Analysis of Striga problem: The first step toward future joint action. In:
Kroschel, J. (ed.) Advances in Parasitic Weed Control at on Farm level. Vol. 1. Joint
action to control Striga in Africa. Margraf Verlag, Weikersheim, Germany. 326p.
11
12
Legesse, B.W., Pixley, K.V., Myburg, A.A., Twumasi-Afriyie, S. and Botha A. M. (2009).
Combining ability and heterotic grouping of highland transition maize inbred lines.
African Crop Science Society, 9: 487-491
.M’Boob, S.S. (1986). A regional programme for West and Central Africa. In: Proceedings of
FAO/OAU All African government consultation on Striga control, 20th – 24th October,
1986. Maroua, Cameroon. 190-194pp.
NAERLS (National Agricultural Extension and Research Liaison Services) (1987). Maize
production guide. Extension bull. no.11 NAERLS, A.B.U Zaria. 10pp.
Nuhu, A., Showemimo, F.A., and Aba, D.A. (2008).Combining ability studies in Quality Protein
Maize evaluated in two environments in Nigeria. Proceedings of the 32nd Annual
Conference of the Genetic Society of Nigeria, 9th – 12th November, Usmanu Danfodiyo
University, Sokoto. 36-43pp.
Odhiambo, G. D. and Ramson, J. K. (2000). Effect of organic and inorganic sources of nitrogen
on control of Striga hermonthica and soil fertility for high maize productivity in Western
Kenya. Phytoparasitica, 28:175.
Olakojo, S.A. and Olaoye, G. (2005). Combining ability for grain yield, agronomic traits and
Striga lutea tolerance of maize hybrids under artificial Striga infestation. African Journal
of Biotechnology, 4(9):984-988.
Olaoye, G. and Bello, O.B. (2009). Combining ability for maize grain yield in Striga endemic and
non-endemic environments of the Southern Guinea Savanna of Nigeria. Journal of Plant
Breeding and Crop Science, 1(4):072-079.
Rafique, M., Hussain, A., Mahmood, T., Alvi, A.W. and Alvi, M.B. (2004). Heritability and
interrelationships
among grain yield and yield components in maize (Zea mays L.).
International Journal of Agriculture and Biology, 6(6):1113-1114.
Singh, R.K. and Chaudhary, B.D. (1985). Biometrical methods in quantitative genetic analysis.
Kalyani Publishers, New Delhi, India. 219-223pp.
Sharma, R.K. (2006). Studies on gene action and combining ability for yield and its component
traits in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Indian Journal of Genetics, 66(3): 227-228.
Shaxson, L. and Riches, C. (1998). Where once there was grain to burn: a farming system in
crisis. Outlook Agriculture, 27:101-105.
PGB12
COMPARATIVE EFFECTS OF HORMONE-INDUCED SEEDS ON GERMINATION
AND
SEXUAL
EXPRESSION
OF
FLUTED
PUMPKIN
(TELFAIRIA
OCCIDENTALIS HOOK) IN THE HUMID TROPICS OF SOUTHERN NIGERIA.
Opukiri, B.S.1* and Nwonuala, A.I. 2
1
Department of Crop Production Technology, Niger DeltaUniversity, Wilberforce Island,
Amassoma, Nigeria
12
13
2
Department of Crop /Soil Science, Rivers State University of Science and Technology,
Nkpolu, Port Harcourt, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail:opunemi@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
A green house and field experiments were carried out to study the comparative effects of
seeds induced with different growth hormones on germination and sex expression of Fluted
Pumpkin (Telfairia occidentalis Hook) at the Teaching and Research Farm of the Rivers
State University of Science and Technology, Port Harcourt in 2010. Induction of seeds with
growth hormones was done by soaking in aqueous solutions of 0, 100, 200 and 300 parts per
million(ppm) each of Gibberellic acid ( GA3), Indole-3- acetic acid (IAA) , Naphthalene
acetic acids (NAA) and Ethrel (ET) before planting and exogenous foliar application on
young leaves during vegetative growth of fluted pumpkin. The treatments significantly
affected the number of days to 50% seed germination. Seeds induced with (GA3) germinated
earlier while those with NAA were the least. With 300ppm NAA significantly delayed
germination by the increase in the number of days to 50% seed germination. The effects of
IAA, NAA and GA3 were similar on sex expression of the plant, while that of ET differed
significantly from the rest. Induction with GA3300ppm significantly reduced number of
days before first male flower initiation (94days) after planting but increased the number of
days before first female flower initiation. Generally, the numbers of female and male flowers
vine-1 were significantly reduced by the hormones but GA3 200ppm gave the highest number
of 57 male flowers vine-1 .The highest number of 20.92 female flowers vine-1 obtained was
with NAA300ppm which was significantly less than that of the control (23) female flowers
vine-1. The lowest sex ratio (M/F) of 0.30:1 was obtained with IAA300ppm. This reduction in
sex ratio indicates favourable increase in the femaleness of induced fluted pumpkin with the
benefit of increase in yield.
INTRODUCTION
In Southern Nigeria, the production and utilization of fluted pumpkin as leafy vegetable is on
the increase more than ever before because of increased awareness of its nutritional and
economic values, In a survey on the pattern of consumption of leafy vegetables in Nigeria,
Hart et al. (2005) gave the per capita consumption as 91-130kg. This range was reported to
be among the highest in Africa and Fluted pumpkin was also listed among the Regionally
Consumed Indigenous and Traditional Leafy Vegetables for West Africa, (Smith and Pablo
2007). The seeds of fluted pumpkin are also nutritious and rich in fat (50%) making it a
potential raw material for the pharmaceuticals and soap-making industry (Okoli and
Mgbeogu, 1983). Furthermore, the economic and nutritional benefits of blending fluted
pumpkin seed into wheat flour for bread because of its nutritional value in a Nigeria economy
has been revealed (Giami et al.,2003).
Presently, the seeds which are the only means of propagation present some problems, which
include high cost and its scarcity at the time of planting, and poor storability (Akoroda,
1990). It is a common knowledge that female plants have more luxuriant leaves and is more
productive than the male plants; they also produce pods which bear seeds. The high
productivity of the female plant makes it more preferred to the male by farmers particularly
for seed production. It is however not yet possible to identify the sex of a seed before planting
in order to ensure increased leaf, fruit and seed production.
The difficulty to differentiate between male and female plants before flower initiation in the
crop also adds to the problem and limitation of fluted pumpkin production by local farmers
13
14
(Opukiri and Nwonuala, 2011). Various attempts have been made to find an alternative
method of propagation and preservation such as the use of vine cuttings and the in-vitro
culture of embryos of fluted pumpkin (Nwonuala, et al.2007). Recently, Ogbonna (2009)
studied portion and type effects on sex, growth and yield of fluted pumpkin and indicated no
significant differences in sex ratio. In all these cases, the desired result of identifying the
sexes in order to increase the production of fluted pumpkin per unit land area has not been
attained. Experimental modification of sex expression of flowering plants has been earlier
reported by Heslop-Harrison, (1957). The work of Rudich et al., (1972) suggest that ethylene
participate in the endogenous regulation of sex expression by promoting femaleness in
cucumber plant
Later, Michaele et al. (1977) indicated that exogenous Ethephon treatment on cucumber
increased the female tendency in monoecious plants, and decreased it in gynoecious ones.
According to the work of Kshirsagar et al. (1995), plant growth regulators were confirmed to
increase female flowers and yields in cucurbits. It is now well established that ethylene is the
main hormonal regulator of sexual expression in the Cucurbitaceae family, controlling not
only the sexual fate of individual floral buds, but also the female flower transition, that is, the
time at which the first female flower appears and therefore the number of female flowers per
plant (Susan et al., 2013).
The role of growth hormones on the growth and sex expression of Fluted pumpkin has not
been studied in details. This research will therefore, provide useful scientific information on
the effects of different plant hormones on Seed Germination and Sexual expression of fluted
pumpkin thus paving the way towards the increase in productivity of the female plant.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In 2009 and 2010, a Green House and field experiments were conducted at the Research and
Teaching farm of the Rivers State University of Science and Technology, Port Harcourt
located at latitude 4.510 N and longitude 7.010 E and 18 meters above sea level, the rain fall
pattern is bimodal with peaks in June and September and ranges between 2000mm to
2484mm per annum with an annual mean temperature of 250 C. Experimental materials are
four plant growth hormones and the seeds of fluted pumpkin obtained within four major
clusters of production in Rivers State of Southern Nigeria during the farming seasons.
The experimental design was a Randomised Complete Block (RCB) with 3 replicates. The
treatments consist of seeds from matured pods induced by soaking them in prepared aqueous
solution of the growth hormones: - Indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), Naphthalene acetic acid
(NAA), Gibberellic acid (GA3 ) and 2-Chloroethyl phosphonic acid (CEPA used in the
commercial form as Ethrel) each at 0, 100, 200, and 300 parts per million (ppm) for 60
minutes, drained and sundried for another 60 minutes before planting. Seeds induced with
hormones were planted at a rate of one seed per hole on the ridge and with a spacing of 1 x
1m (10,000 plant ha-1). Compound Fertilizer ( N:P:K 15:15:20 ) was applied at the rate of
150g vine-1 (750kg ha-1 ) by ring application on the ridge, four weeks after planting. Data
collated from the Greenhouse and field were subjected to statistical analysis (descriptive and
bivariate statistics), using the SPSS 15.0., (2006 ) Evaluation version for windows.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The results of effects of induction with different hormones and levels on germination in the
Green house and sexual expression of Fluted pumpkin in the field are presented in Figures 16. The effect of hormones on number of days after planting to 50% seed germination as
shown in Figure1 indicate that seeds from the control plots attained 50% germination 11days
14
15
after planting (DAP). The number of days to 50% seed germination was earlier and less than
11 DAP with GA3 treatment, while NAA had the highest and significantly above 12 DAP.
Fig1: Effect of Growth Hormones on seed germination. Fig.2: Effect of Levels of Hormone
on germination.
The effect of ET and IAA were similar and differed from that of control. This result indicates
that the growth hormones can delay or promote seed germination as shown by the effects of
NAA and GA3 respectively. In this experiment all the growth hormones except NAA
enhanced early seed germination by reducing the number of days to 50 % seed germination
below 11DAP.
The result of the effect of different levels of hormones presented in Table 2, shows that there
was no significant difference at a low level of 100ppm which did not differ with that of the
control. With increase in levels of hormones, however, the number of days to 50% seed
germination was significantly increased above 12 DAP with NAA at 200 and 300ppm. The
effects of GA3, and IAA were similar at 200ppm which enhanced seed germination by
reducing the numbers of days to 50% seed germination to less than 11DAP. At 300ppm NAA
significantly increased the number of days to 50% seed germination above 12 and half DAP
while GA 3 and IAA attained 50% germination in less than 11 DAP.
On sex of plant, it is basically the expression of male or female flower buds that reveals the
sex of the Fluted pumpkin plant. The effect of the growth hormones and their levels as
presented on Figure 3 show that the expression of male flowers occurred before the females
in all the hormone treated and control plots of the field experiment. The induction of
Hormones significantly increased the number of days before first the female flower
expression. The mean time for the initiation of first male and female flowers according to the
results of this experiment occurred 116 and 124 DAP respectively in the control plots (Fig 3).
The effect of GA3 significantly reduced the number of DAP to 106 before male flower
15
16
expression, but all the hormones significantly increased the number of DAP before the
Female flower (139-146 DAP).
Fig 3: Effects of Hormones and their levels on Days after Planting to the Expression of Male
and Female Flowers.* Ethrel is abbreviated as ET, a trade name for 2 chloroethyl phosphonic
acid (CEPA)
The results indicate that increase in the level of all the hormones caused a decline in the
number of DAP for both the male and female flowers, but were significantly higher than that
of the control at all levels. Hormone treatment significantly reduced the number of days
before first male flower initiation (94 DAP) with GA3300ppm. Conversely, the same
treatment significantly delayed the time before first female flower expression by increasing
the number to 139 DAP (Fig 3). The longest delay in the number of days to first female
flower initiation (155 DAP) was obtained with IAA300ppm.
The response by the reduction in the number of days before the first male flower initiation is
observed to be in agreement with the findings of Atsmon and Tabbak (1979) that GA3
induces staminate flower formation in cucumber plant. The response however, is of reverse
effect on the expression of female flower by the extension up to 7 days beyond that of the
control when compared with GA3200 and IAA 300ppm, female flowers were expressed 133
DAP. This result is in contrast to the response of cucumber when treated with similar
concentrations of Ethrel and NAA which resulted in delay in appearance of first male flower
and enhanced that of female flower (Kshiragar et al. 1995).
The effect of the hormones and their levels on Number of flowers per vine is shown in Fig.4.
Generally, the number of male flowers was more than that of female flowers at all levels of
treatment and the control . Hormone induction also significantly affected number of female
and male flowers vine-1. Induction with GA3200ppm produced 57 male flowers vine-1 which
was the highest followed by the control. Except for GA3200ppm, the number of male flowers
vine-1 obtained with other treatments was less than that of the control. The least number of 16
male flowers was obtained with Ethrel 200ppm while the control had 39 male flowers vine-1.
It is observed therefore, that the number of male flowers generally decreased as the days
before male flower initiation was reduced by the hormone treatments. There was also
significant reduction in the number of female flowers vine-1 as the control plot had 23 female
flowers as the highest number of flowers vine-1. The least number of female flowers vine-1
(12.71) was obtained with GA3 100ppm.The number of female flowers, decreased with
increase in the level of the hormones to 200ppm, but NAA300ppm produced the highest
number of female flowers for all the hormone treatment
16
17
Fig 4: The Effect of Hormones and their Levels on Number of Male and Female
Flower Expression
The effect of induced hormones also significantly influenced the sex ratio (M/F) of Fluted
pumpkin. The graphical representation of the comparative expression of male and female
plants observed in Figure 5 from the field experiment is as a result of treatment effect. The
control plot had a ratio of 1 female plant to 1.28 male plants (1.28:1). It was observed that
with seed induction and leaf treatment, all the hormones differ in their effect on sex ratio. The
highest ratio of 1.85:1 was obtained with GA3100ppm. Sex ratio however decreased with
increased levels of GA3, NAA, and IAA while the effect of Ethrel was contrary, ET300ppm
(1.83:1) i.e. increase in level of ET resulted in increase in sex ratio. The lowest but the best
sex ratio of 0.3:1 was obtained with IAA 300ppm which was not significantly different from
those of NAA and GA3 at 300ppm. The reduction in sex ratio indicates favourable increase in
the femaleness of fluted pumpkin as a result of induced hormones.
Figure 5: The effect of levels of Hormones on Sex ratio (M/F)
The ratio of male plants to female for a dioecious Fluted pumpkin plant is an indication of its
productive capacity since the female plants are responsible for seed and better vegetable
yields.
of Fluted Pumpkin.
CONCLUSION
The effects of GA, IAA and ET on seed germination are observed to be significant in
promoting seed germination although Fluted pumpkin does not have dormancy problem but
enhancement of germination has agronomic benefits. The similarity in the response to the
17
18
different hormones vary slightly, the trend however indicate similarity in the effects of GA3,
NAA, and IAA on sex expression as observed in the number of male and female flowers vine
-1
; and sex ratio. With increase in levels of treatment, the reduction in sex ratio indicates
favourable increase in the femaleness of Fluted pumpkin. The lowest and the best sex ratio of
0.3:1 obtained with IAA300ppm which was not significantly different from those of NAA
and GA3 at 300ppm.The response to Ethrel is contrary but is in conformity with the findings
Michaele et al. (1977) who indicated that exogenous Ethephon treatment on cucumber
increased the female tendency in monoecious plants, and decreased it in gynoecious ones.
The exogenous induction of plant hormones on the seeds and leaves of fluted pumpkin can be
regarded with all certainty to influence seed germination and sexual expression towards
femaleness. The implication is that the benefits of female Fluted pumpkin can be maximised
through the exogenous induction of Hormones which is in no doubt directly related to
increase in vegetable and pod yield.
REFERENCES
Atsmon, D. and Tabbak C. (1979). Comparative effects of gibberellin, silver nitrate and
aminoethoxyvinyl glycine on sexual tendency and ethylene evolution in cucumber
plant (Cucumis satilvus L,) Plant & Cell Physiol.20 (8): 1547-1555.
Akoroda, M. O. (1990). Seed production and breeding potential of fluted pumpkin(Telfairia
occidentalis Hook). Euphytica, 49: 25-32.
Giami, S.Y.,Mepba, H. D, Kiin kabari, D.B.and fluted pumpkin (Telfairia occidentalis Hook.
) seed flour blends. Plant Foods for Human Nutrition 58 (3): 1-8.
Hart, A.D, Ajubuike, C.U, Barimalaa, I. S. and Achinewhu, S.C. (2005) Vegetable
consumption pattern of households in selected areas of the old Rivers State of
Nigeria. African J. of Food Agriculture Nutrition and Development Online, 5(1)
Heslop-Harrision, J. (1957). The experimental Modification of sex expression in flowering
plants. Biol. Rev., 32: 38-90.
Kshirsagar, D.B., Desal’B, U.T., Patil, T. and Pawer, B.G. (1995). Effects of plant growth
regulators on sex-expression and fruiting in cucmbr cv. Himangi. Journal
Maharshira Agric Unv., 20 (30):473- 474 .
Michael, F., Dan, A. and Esra, G., 1977: Sexual differentiation in cucumber: The effects of
abscisic
acid and other growth regulators on various sex genotypes. Plant
and Cell Physiology, 1977, Vol. 18, No.1 261-269.
Nwonuala, A.I., Obiefuna J.C., Ofoh M.C. and Ibeawuchi I.I (2007). In-Vitro culture of
Fluted Pumpkin
(Telfairia occidentalis, Hook). Acta Agronomica Nigeriana,
8(1): 54-59.
Ogbonna, P. A. (2009). Pod portion and type effects on sex, growth and yield in Fluted
pumpkin.
African Crop Science Journal, 16 (30: 185-190.
Okoli, B. E. and Mgbeogu C.M. (1983): Fluted Pumpkin Telfairia occindentlis: West
African Vegetable Crop. Economic Botany , 37(2): 145-149.
Opukiri, S.B. and Nwonuala, A.I. (2011). Flowering Attributes And Sex Differentiation of
Hormone
Induced Fluted Pumpkin (Telfairia occidentalis) IN Humid Tropics Of
Southern Nigeria. Acta Agronomica Nigeriana, 11 (1&2): 85.
Rudich, J., Halevy, A.H. and Kadar, N. (1972). Ethylene Evolution from Cucumber Plants
as Related to sex Expression. Plant Physiology, 49: 998-999.
Susana Manzano, C. Martinez, Z. Megias, and Garrido.D. (2013). Involvement of Ethylene
Biosynthesis and Signalling in the Transition from Male to Female Flowering in the
Monoecious (Cucurbita pepo) Journal of Plant Growth Regulation
http://link.springer.com/journal/344
18
19
Smith, F.I. and Pablo E. (2007). African Leafy Vegetables: Their Role In The World Health
Organization’s Global Fruits And Vegetables Initiative Vol. 7, No. 3, 2007.
PGB13
STUDIES ON EXPLANTS OF PEPPER (CAPSICUM SP) TREATED WITH
DESIGNATED HORMONES.
Wachukwu, C.P.1 and Kwon-Ndung, E.H.1,2
1
Department of Plant Science and Biotechnology,
Nasawara State University Keffi.
2
Current address: Department of Botany, Federal University, Lafia.
ABSTRACT
A study was conducted in the Biotechnology Advanced Laboratory (BAL) of Sheda Science
and Technology Complex (SHESTCO) Abuja on the growth and yield of 4 pepper varieties
(Capsicum annum L.) cultured on Murashige and Skog (MS) basal medium supplemented
with different plant growth regulators (PGRs) at various concentrations. Regenerated plant
were obtained from cotyledon explants of pepper varieties by a culture procedure including
rate of germination, shoot elongation, rooting capacity and fruit yield.AgNo3 significantly
increased the frequency of germination rate in different pepper varieties.Gibberellic acid
(GA3) was the key factor in shoot elongation.MS basal medium with indole-3-butyric acid
(IBA) were easier to root for the highest numbers of root were obtained in MS with Nicotinic
acid and fruit yield. An efficient protocol for regeneration of pepper through economically
viable explants of indigenous pepper varieties was established.
INTRODUCTION
Pepper (Capsicum specie L.) an economically important vegetable and spice crop worldwide,
is the fruit of plants from the genus, Capsicum, member of the nightshade family, Solanaceae.
The genus Capsicum consists of approximately 22 wild species and 5 domesticated species
(Bosland, 1994), domesticated for vegetable and industrial (Oleoresin and Capsaicin)
purposes. Pepper is widely cultivated throughout the world, mainly in Asia, South and North
America and part of Africa According to Contreras Padilla(Yahia, 1998; Kumar et al.,2006).
The propagation of pepper through seeds is further restricted by short span of viability and
low germination rate. Since the plants also lack natural vegetative propagation, tissue culture
methods provide a novel way for the asexual multiplication of pepper plant (Morrison et al.,
19
20
2004). Tissue culture technique in pepper, one of the most important vegetable crops in the
world, lag behind most other vegetable crops, mainly due to its recalcitrance to regeneration
(Diaz et al., 2000). Low differentiation frequency, difficulty in shoot elongation, and low
response (Dabauza et al., 2001), are main barriers to the development of pepper gene
engineering. This study project describes the development of a simple and efficient procedure
for plant regeneration, in a PGRs medium, applicable to different cultivars of pepper. In
addition he study aimed to study the efficiency of selected hormones and create variability in
local varieties of pepper in Keffi through in vitro culture.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted in the Biotechnology Advanced Laboratory (BAL) of Sheda
Science and Technology Complex (SHESTCO), Abuja.
Local seeds of pepper varieties: Atarugu, Shumbo, Borkonu Kanana and Tatasai were
commercially, obtained from Keffi Market at Keffi Local Government Area of Nasarawa
State.
Plate 1: Local seed of pepper from Keffi market
1mg/ml of AgNO3 and 0.1mg/ml each of IBA, GA3 and Nicotinic acid were prepared for the
study. Murashige and Skoog (MS) basal media were prepared in four places using 1L
(1000ml) beaker each, about 500ml of distilled water was poured into each of the beaker and
placed on a magnetic stirrer with the magnetic bar inside the water. Four different media were
prepared for this study. 1L each of Murashigea and Skoog basal medium were prepared into
four places, 50ml/L of Macro salt + 5ml/L of micro salt + 30g/L of sucrose and 2.8g/L of
Agar (geltrite) were dissolved into each of the beaker one after the other. pH of 5.8 were
taken, using 1M hydrochloric acid (HCL) or 1M sodium hydroxide (NaOH). The media was
made up to 1L (1000ml) in a graduated measuring cylinder using distilled water, each of 1L
media prepared were divided into 4 (250ms each), different concentrations of the plant
growth hormones were added into each of the 250mls media as follows: 0.3ml, 1.3ml, 2.5ml
and 3.8ml of IBA were added into each of 250ml of the MS medium.
1.5ml, 2ml, 2.5ml and 3ml of Nicotinic acid were added into each of the 250ml of 1L MS
medium. 0.5ml, 1ml, 1.2ml and 2ml of AgNO3 were added into each of 250ml of the 1L MS
medium and 2.5ml, 3.8ml, 5ml and 6.3ml of GA3 were added into each of 250ml of the 1L
MS medium. Each 250mls medium were poured into culture bottles, the media were
20
21
sterilized by autoclaving for 15 minutes at 121oC and a pressure of 1.05kg/cm2 (Merck,
2005), and transferred into biosafety cabinate to cool for culturing.
Plate 2: Prepared media for study
Local seeds of pepper varieties were washed under running tap to remove dirts, using
morning fresh, seeds were soaked in worm water for 10 minutes due to its recalcitrance,
under the laminar flow hood, seeds were transferred into a sterile flask and soaked in 70%
ethanol for 10 seconds, the ethanol were decanted and the seeds were rinsed thoroughly, and
were immersed in 20% sodium hypochloride (NaOCl) for 10 minutes, 2 drops of tween 20
were added and rinsed three (3) times with sterile distilled water, the seeds were picked wit
autoclaved flamed forceps (sterile) and placed on the cutting board to dry.
Under the biosafety cabinate, my hands were sterilized with absolute ethanol and the whole
hood was swamped with absolute ethanol. The equipments used: blade holder, scalpel and
forceps all were in a dip containing 70% ethanol and kept always in the laminar flow hood.
The spirit lamp was lighted which further sterilized the laminar flow hood. Sterilized seeds
were cultured into the prepared medium (Murashige et al., 1962). Cultures were kept for 3
days under continuous dark, then transferred to 16 hours photoperiod per day at light
intensity of 17.7μ mol/m2/s were provided by cool white fluorescent tubes and temperature
were set at 25oC.
Cotyledons of seedlings after germination without petiole and apical parts were cut into small
parts say 0.25cm2. Explants were cultured into ordinary MS media (control) and MS
supplemented with each of the growth hormones (treatment) that is; IBA, GA3, AgNO3 and
Nicotinic acid at a specific concentration. Explants were subcultured at two weeks intervals
into the same medium (Dabauza and Pena, 2001). Explants with roots were acclimatized for
48 hours after washing off the Agar (gelrite) with deionized water to pots with a mixture of
substrate and perlite (5:1) in a screen house and transferred into green house, were they
developed into normal plants and bearing normal fruits.
21
22
Plate 3: Cultures kept in the dark
Plate 4: Geminated seeds after 2 weeks
of culture
Data was collected for g, after two weeks after planting in pots, Shoot elongation after six
weeks after planting in pots, Rooting capacity (number of roots) after four week after
planting in pots and fruit yield after eight weeks after planting in pots. Mean and mean effect
of the result were calculated and subjected to analysis of variance using (ANOVA), treatment
means were separated using the least significant difference (LSD) at p=0.05.
22
23
RESULTS
Table 1: Efficacy of PGRs (mg/ml) on germination of different pepper varieties (%).
Trt
MS MS+IBA
0.0
MS+GA3
0.3 1.3 2.5
3.8 2.5 3.8
MS+AgNo3
5.0
MS+Nicotinic acid
6.3
0.5
1.0
2.0 2.5
3.0
Ata 4.7
8.7 8.3 14.0 9.7 7.0 12.7 13.3 9.3
8.7
16.7 12.0 10.0 15.3 8.7 9.0
9.0
Bor 6.0
8.3 8.3 13.7 8.0 8.7 10.7 10.7 8.3
10.3 16.0 11.7 10.3 13.3 9.3 10.0 9.7
Sh
5.3
6.7 7.0 11.0 9.3 7.7 9.7
10.7 10.7 9.7
15.3 11.3 9.7
12.7 8.3 9.7
9.3
Ta
4.3
6.0 5.3 10.3 8.7 8.7 9.3
9.3
14.7 12.3 10.0 11.7 8.7 8.7
8.0
8.3
9.0
1.2
2.0
1.5
LSD0.05 =1.50
Trt= Treatment, Ata = Atarugu, Bor = Borkonu, Sh = Shombo, Ta = Tatashe
Any difference between a pair of treatment mean, that is higher than 1.50 is considered to be significant at
5% level.
The result showed that there is significant different among treatment among treatment means
Table 2: Efficacy of PGRs (mg/ml) on rooting capacity (number) of different
pepper varieties (%)
Trt
MS MS+IBA
MS+GA3
MS+AgNo3
MS+Nicotinic acid
0.0
0.3 1.3 2.5 3.8 2.5 3.8 5.0 6.3 0.5 1.0 1.2 2.0 1.5 2.0
2.5
3.0
Ata
3.0
6.3 6.0 7.3 5.7 6.0 6.7 7.0 9.7 5.0 6.3 7.3 7.7 5.3 6.7
7.7
6.0
Bor
3.0
5.7 5.7 6.7 5.0 5.0 5.0 9.0 9.3 4.0 4.7 4.3 5.3 4.7 5.0
6.0
6.0
Sh
3.0
4.0 4.7 5.0 4.7 4.7 6.3 8.0 8.7 4.7 5.0 5.3 6.0 4.3 5.7
7.3
6.7
Ta
4.0
4.3 5.3 6.3 4.3 7.0 8.0 8.0 6.3 4.0 6.0 5.3 7.0 3.7 5.7
7.0
7.3
LSD0.05 = 0.46
Trt= Treatment, Ata = Atarugu, Bor = Borkonu, Sh = Shombo, Ta = Tatashe
Any difference between a pair of treatment mean, that is higher than 0.46 is considered to be
significant at 5% level.
The result showed that there is significant different among treatment among treatment means.
Table 3: Efficacy of PGRs (mg/ml) on shoot elongation of different pepper varieties (cm)
Trt
MS
MS+IBA
0.0
0.3
1.3
MS+GA3
2.5
3.8
2.5
3.8
23
MS+AgNo3
5.0
6.3
0.5
1.0
MS+Nicotinic ac
1.2
2.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
24
Ata 17.7 26.6 27.9 28.3 24.5 32.0 32.8 57.7 39.7 42.9 54.0 39.3 31.9 25.4 27.2 28.9
Bor 17.7 25.4 26.3 29.5 26.5 35.8 46.7 62.6 52.6 42.0 56.0 39.7 33.5 34.2 30.5 30.5
Sh
17.7 26.7 21.8 31.8 29.1 46.4 49.5 57.3 50.3 36.3 52.7 39.7 33.5 32.6 24.7 25.9
Ta
17.7 20.7 23.3 20.0 30.7 32.7 39.8 32.9 39.2 51.7 41.3 26.9 24.2 20.1 22.3 22.3
LSD0.05 = 0.46
Trt= Treatment, Ata = Atarugu, Bor = Borkonu, Sh = Shombo, Ta = Tatashe
Any difference between a pair of treatment mean, that is higher than 0.46 is considered to be
significant at 5% level.
The result showed that there is significant different among treatment among treatment means.
24
25
Table 4: Efficacy of PGRs (mg/ml) on number of fruit yield per pepper variety (%)
Trt
MS MS + IBA
MS + GA3
MS + AgNo3
MS+Nicotinic acid
0.0
0.3 1.3
2.5
3.8
2.5
3.8
5.0
6.3 0.5
Ata 2.7
4.3 9.3
11.3 7.7
5.0
6.7
8.7
4.0 11.0 9.0 6.7 5.0 6.0 8.0 15.7 11.3
Bor 2.7
5.3 13.0 15.7 15.7 10.0 11.0 16.0 8.7 18.7 5.0 5.0 6.0 8.0 9.7 22.0 14.7
Sh
2.7
6.0 8.3
11.3 9.7
7.0
7.7
9.3
6.3 9.3
7.0 6.0 7.0 5.3 5.7 9.3
7.0
Ta
2.7
5.0 6.1
7.7
4.0
4.7
8.0
5.3 4.0
4.0 6.3 8.0 5.0 6.7 8.3
8.0
7.0
1.0 1.2 2.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
3.0
LSD0.05 =0.61
Trt= Treatment, Ata = Atarugu, Bor = Borkonu, Sh = Shombo, Ta = Tatashe
Any difference between a pair of treatment mean that is higher than 0.61is considered to be highly
significant at 5% level.
The result showed that there is significant different among treatment among treatment means.
25
26
DISCUSSION
The results of the study revealed that treatments significantly affected germination of pepper
varieties (p<0.05). IBA showed the highest number of germination at concentration of 2.5ml
in all pepper varieties, GA3 showed highest number of germination in concentration of 5ml in
Atarugu, 3.8ml concentration in Tatashi, Borkonu and Shumbo probably because of the
variation in pepper type. In Nicotinic acid, germination rate was highest in concentration of
1.5ml on Borkonu, Shumbo and Tatashi but showed highest yield of germination on Atarugu
at 2.5ml concentration and in AgNO3, the highest yield of germination rate of the four pepper
varieties was obtained in 1ml concentration of AgNO3.
The shoot elongation of pepper varieties was obtained in Basal medium supplemented with
different concentration of IBA but the highest yield of elongated shoots in IBA was obtained
in 2.5ml concentration in the four pepper varieties which is in accordance with those reported
in some studies (Dabauze and Pena, 2001; Peddaboina et al., 2006; Guadalupe et al., 2009).
GA3 also induced shoot elongation in all pepper varieties and the best result was obtained
with the medium supplemented with 5ml GA3 in all pepper varieties.
AgNO3 also promoted shoot elongation of the four pepper varieties at different
concentrations but the highest elongated shoot were obtained at concentration of 1ml AgNO3
in all the pepper types which is in agreement with (Chen Qin et al., 2005; Mezghani et al.,
2007; Ashrafuzzaman et al., 2009) that found Ms with GA3 or AgNO3 to be the best
elongation medium. Nicotinic and also showed significant variation in the promotion of shoot
elongation of the pepper varieties at different concentration, that is in Atarugu, the highest
yield of elongated shoot was obtained from concentration 3ml Nicotonic acidic, while inn
Borkonu, Shumbo and Tatashi, the highest shoot elongation was obtained from concentration
of 1.5ml Nicotinic acid (Chen Qin et al., 2005).
On the basis of rooting capacity, the four treatments significantly (p<0.05) promoted the roots
of the pepper varieties at different concentration though some concentrations showed highest
yield than others. The highest yield of roots were obtain in concentration 2.5ml IBA, 6.3ml
GA3 on Atarugu, Borkonu, Shumbo and 5ml GA3 on Tatashi, 2.5ml Nitotinic acid on
Atarugu and Shumbo, 3ml Nitotinic acid on Tatashi and Borkonu.
26
27
Plate 5: Roots of explants
Plate 6: Roots of explants
Plate 7: Elongated shoot of explants
Plate 8: Some explants with fruits
in screen house
AgNO3 on the other hand significantly promoted rooting (p<0.05) capacity in all pepper types
but the highest root was obtained on 2ml AgNO3 concentration.
On the basis of fruit yield, the four treatments significantly promoted (p<0.05) the yield of
pepper fruits in the pepper types though at some concentration, the yield was higher than
others. IBA gave the highest yield at concentration 2.5ml in all pepper types, in treatment
with GA3, the highest number of fruit was observed at 5ml GA3 concentration, in treatment
with Nicotinic acid, the highest number of fruit was observed at concentration 2.5ml in
Atarugu, Shumbo and Tatashi, and at 3ml concentration on Brokonu. AgNO3 also had the
highest number of fruit observed at concentration 0.5ml on Atarugu, Brokonu and Shumbo
and showed a difference at higher yield in Tatashi at 8ml AgNO3 concentration which could
be due to pepper type.
Overall findings of the present study are significant in obtaining the maximum regeneration
or yield with proper concentration of growth regulator.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, four the local pepper varieties were found to regenerate on proper medium, but
they have difference in differentiation rates and yields resulting from gene type, explants
type, seedling stage and ingredients in the media (Dong Zhaolong, 2003). The best formula
27
28
for all the medium used for germination test in this study is MS + 1ml AgNO3 which made
explants germinate and differentiate at high rates with good development.
Hyde et al., (1996) observed that AgNO3 influenced shoot induction of two cultivars.
Explants were not able to elongate at high rate in the medium containing only MS without
plant regulators, AgNO3 was optimum in all pepper varieties, in order to confirm whether the
action of AgNO3 is affected by gene type or not, AgNO3 was regarded as an induction
promotion factor added to the medium. According to (Van et al., 1989), AgNO3 was an
ethylene inhibitor. Ethylene suppresses callus to differentiate and AgNO3 climates the
ethylene action, which in return favours explants differentiation.
In the present study, GA3 promoted shoot elongation that is to say GA3 is an elongation –
promotion factor. Though work has been carried out on pepper treated with different growth
hormone, no work has been done on local peppers in Keffi, I therefore recommend that more
work should be carried out to improve on the invitro yield and propagation of local pepper
varieties in Keffi.
REFERENCES
Agrawal, S., Chandra, N., Kothari, S.L., (1989), Plant regeneration in tissue cultures of
pepper (Capsicum annum L.cv. Mathania), plant cell tissue organ culture, 16, 47-55.
Arous, S., Boussaid, M. and Marrakchi, M. (2001), Plant regeneration from zygotic
embryo hypocotyls of Tunisian chili (Capsicum annuum L.) Journal of Applied
Horticulture., 3 (1): 17-22.
Arrollo, R., Revilla, M.A. (1991), In vitro plant regeneration from cotyledon and hypocotyl
Segments in two bell pepper cultivars. Plant Cell Reproduction, 10, 414-416.
Ashrafruzzaman M, Hossain M.M, Razi ismail M , shahidul Haque M, Shahidullah S.M,
Shahin- Uz-Zaman (2009). Regeneration potential of seedling explants of chili (Capsicum
annuum L.). African Journal of Biotechnology Vol: 8(4) Pp.591-596.
Balland, R.E., McClure, J.W., Eshbaugh, W.H. and Wilson, K.G (1970), A chemosystematic
study of selected taxa of Capsicum American Journal of Botany 57; 225-233.
Barry, R. (2009), Plant mol. Biol. 473-488.
Berljak, J. (1999), In vitro plant regeneration from pepper (Capsicum annuum L. cv.
Soroksari) seedling explants. Phyton (Austria) 39:290-292/.
Borychowski, A., Niemirowics-Szczytt, K. and Jedraszko, M. (2002), Plant regeneration
From sweet pepper (Capsicum annuum L.) hypocotyls explants. Acta physiologiae
plantarum, 24 (3): 257-264.
Boseland, P.W. (1996). Capsicums: Innovative uses of an ancient crop. P. 479-487, Retrieved
23 Dec. 2010.
Bosland, P.W. (1994), chiles history, cultivation and uses in species, herbs and edible fungi,
charalambous, G (Ed) Elsevier pub. Pp. 347-366.
Chen Qin, Dong Zhao-long, Liu Wen-Xuan , Deng Zhi-rui, Tang Liang (2005). Effect of
exogenous plant growth regulators on in vitro regeration of cotyledonar explants in
pepper. Notulae botaniccae Horti Agrobotanici Cluj-Napocca 33(1). Pp 25-32.
Christopher, T. and Rajam, M.V. (1994), In vitro clonal propagation of Capsicum spp. Plant
Cell Tissue Organ Culture. 38:25-29.
Christopher, T., Rajam, M.V. (1996), Effect of genotype, explants and medium in In vitro
Regeneration of red pepper, Plant Cell Tissue Organ Culture, 46, 245-50.
Dabauza, M., Pena, L., (2001), High efficiency organogenesis in sweet pepper (capsicum
annuum L.) tissue from different seedling explants, plant growth regulator, 33, 221
229.
28
29
Murashige, T., Skoog, F. (1962), A revised medium for rapid growth and bioassay with
Tobacco tissue cultures, physio, Plant, 5, 473-497.
Peddabonia, V., Thamidal, C. and Karampuri, S. (2006), In vitro shoot multiplication and
Plant regeneration in four Capsicum species using thidiazuron. Scientia Horticulture
107:117 -122.
Perry, L. et al (2007), Starch fossils and the domestication and dispersal of chili peppers
(capsicum spp L.) in the Americas Science 315: 986-988.
Philips, G.C. and Hubstenberger, J.F. (1985), Organogenesis in pepper tissue cultures. Plant
Cell Tissue Organ Culture. 4:261-269.
Pickersgill, B. (1971), Relationships between weedy and cultivated forms in some species of
chili peppers (genus capsicum L.). Evolution 25:683-691.
Pozueta-Romero, J., Houlne, G., Canas, L. Schatz, R. Chamaro, J. (2001), Enhanced
regeneration of tomato and pepper seedling explants for Agrobacterium-mediated
transformation. Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture, 67: 173-180.
Ramirez-malagon, R. Ochoa-Alejo, N. (1996), An improved and reliable chilli pepper
(Capsicum annuum L.) plant regeneration method. Plant Cell Rep. 16:226-231.
Raven, Peter H., Evert, Ray, F. and Eichorn, Susan E. (1999), Biology of plants 6th edition.
Shapiro AD (2005) Nitric oxide signaling in plants. Vitamin hormone 72 .pp. 339-98
Simon J.E., A.F.Chadwick and L.E. Cracker, (1984), The scientific literature on selected
herbs, aromatic and medicinal plants of the temperate zone. Archon books, Hamden.
pp. 1971-1980.
Smith, P.G. and Heiser, C.B. Jr. (1957), Breeding behaviour of cultivated peppers 70: 286
290.
Srivastava, L.M (2002). Plant growth and development hormones and environment. Pp. 140
Steinitz, B., Wlof, D., Matzevitch-Josef T. and Zelcer, A. (1999), Regeneration of pepper
(Capsicum spp): The current state of the art, Capsicum and Eggplant Newsletter 18:9
15.
Thorpe, Trevor A. (1981), Plant tissue culture: methods and application in Agriculture.
Vain, P., Yeen, H., Flament. P. (1989), Enhancement of production and regeneration of
embryogenic type callus in Zea mays L. by AgNO3, Plant Cell Tissue Organ Culture,
18, 143-151.
Valera-Montero, L.L., Ochoa-Alejo, N. (1992), a novel approach for chili pepper (Capsicum
nnuum L.) plant regeneration shoot induction in rooted hypocotyls, Plant Sci., 84, 215
219.
PGB14
SCREENING OF COWPEA LINES FOR DROUGHT TOLERANCE
Bolarinwa K.A.1*, Ogunkanmi, L.A.1, Adetumbi, J.A.2, Akinyosoye, S.T.2, Akande, S.R.2 and
Amusa, O.D.1,
1
Department of Cell Biology and Genetics, Faculty of Science, University of Lagos, Lagos.
2
Grain Legumes Improvement Programme, Institute of Agricultural Research and Training,
Moor Plantation, Ibadan
*Corresponding e-mail: bolarinwakehinde85@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Thirty nine cowpea lines were screened for drought tolerance to provide information on
cowpea lines that can be used for genetic improvement of the acceptable varieties. The
experiment was carried out using wooden boxes filled with top soil. Cowpea lines were
29
30
planted in three replications and the seedlings were watered daily using a small watering can
of four litres for two weeks until partial emergence of the first trifoliate leaves of all the
varieties was observed. Thereafter, watering was stopped for thirty five days and wilted
plants in each variety were counted daily. Watering was resumed for fourteen days to
ascertain regeneration potentials of each variety. Significant differences were observed
among the cowpea lines for drought tolerance Stress effect was first noticed on the unifoliate
leaves twelve days after watering was stopped, followed by the emerging trifoliates and
finally the growing tip dried. Wilting percentage at different days after termination of
watering indicated TVx 3236, NG/SA/07/132 and IT95K-193-12 to be the most susceptible
to drought. The recovery percentage after watering ranged from 0% for NG/SA/01/09/004 to
100 % for IT81D-994 and Oloyin. All the cowpea lines were grouped into three. Group 1
comprises three lines (TVx 3236, NG/SA/07/130 and NG/SA/01/09/004) which are highly
drought susceptible while Group 2 and 3 comprise of 14 and 22 lines respectively that were
tolerant at varying degrees. The screening has provided information on cowpea lines that can
be used in breeding for drought tolerant cowpea varieties.
Keywords: Cowpea, drought tolerance, screen house.
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp) belongs to the family Fabaceae and sub family
papilionoideae. It is indigenous to West Africa where its cultivation was taken to other part of
the world such as Latin America, Europe and Asia. It is popularly known as beans and grows
best in dry area of the Northern part of West Africa (Thomas, 2005). It is one of the most
important food legumes in the tropic and sub-tropic regions of Africa because it is a major
source of protein, minerals and vitamins in daily human diets and are equally important as
nutritious fodder for livestock (Singh et al., 1997).
In spite of several research work conducted on cowpea improvement, cowpea production is
still low when compared to production potentials of the crop in Nigeria. Field research has
indicated that the potential yield of cowpea can go up to 3,000kg/ha if most of the production
constraints are addressed. Among the factors militating against cowpea production is low
yield caused by insect pests; diseases; parasitic flowering weeds and drought. Cowpea is
relatively sensitive to soil water deficit. Cowpea responds differently to water stress through
leaf area reduction, delay in reproductive cycle or by developing a deep root system
depending on timing and the magnitude of the water deficit (Gwathmey and Hall, 1992).
Recent global warming and climate change has been reported to cause reduction in the
potential yield of so many crops including cowpea. Drought tolerance is defined as the ability
of plants to live, grow and yield satisfactorily with limited soil water supply or under periodic
water deficiencies (Ashley, 1993). The development of cowpea cultivars with enhanced
levels of drought tolerance is necessary in Nigeria but only a few studies have been reported
in the selection of cowpea varieties regarding genetic variability for drought tolerance among
cowpea lines and cultivated varieties grown in Nigeria. It is based on this fact that this study
was set to screen some cowpea lines for drought tolerance using simple screening method for
shoot drought tolerance to identify cowpea lines that are drought tolerant and can be used for
genetic improvement of the acceptable varieties.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Thirty nine cowpea lines were collected from three Institutions namely: International Institute
of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), Institute of Agricultural Research and Training, Ibadan
(I.A.R. &T.) and National Centre of Genetic Resources and Biotechnology, Ibadan
(NACGRAB). The cowpea lines, according to the Institutions were collected from different
30
31
parts of the country. List of the cowpea lines, seed coat colour and their sources are presented
in Table 1.
Table 1: List of cowpea lines used for the experiment, their seed coat colour and sources
No Cowpea Lines
Seed coat colour
Source
1
1T93K-452-1
White
IITA
2
NG/SA/07/167
White
NACGRAB
3
IT90K-277-2
White
IITA
4
IT86D-719
White
IITA
5
IT98K-205-8
White
IITA
6
IT97K-499-35
White
IITA
7
NG/SA/07/159
White
NACGRAB
8
NG/SA/01/09/008
White
NACGRAB
9
NG/SA/07/089
White
NACGRAB
10 Cowpea-2
White
NACGRAB
11 NG/SA/07/155
White
NACGRAB
12 O311109
White
NACGRAB
13 NG/SA/01/09/009
White
NACGRAB
14 NG/SA/07/083
White
NACGRAB
15 NG/AO/11/08/084
White
NACGRAB
16 NG/AO/11/08/089
White
NACGRAB
17 NG/SA/07/141
White
NACGRAB
18 NG/SA/JAN/09/003
Brown
NACGRAB
19 TVx 3236
White and brown
IITA
20 IT8ID-994
Brown
IITA
21 IT89KD-288
Brown
IITA
22 NG/SA/07/135
Brown
NACGRAB
23 O304107
Brown
NACGRAB
24 NG/SA/JAN/09/004
Brown
NACGRAB
25 NG/SA/07/132
Brown
NACGRAB
26 NG/SA/07/130
Brown
NACGRAB
27 NGB/06/043
Brown
NACGRAB
28 NGB/06/110
Brown
NACGRAB
29 NA/SA/JAN/09/015
White
NACGRAB
30 IT84S-2246-4
Brown
IITA
31 NG/SA/01/09/011
White
NACGRAB
32 IFE BROWN
Brown
IAR&T
33 IFE BPC
Brown
IAR&T
34 IT82E-18
Brown
IITA
35 ERUSU
White
IAR&T
36 MODUPE
Brown
IAR&T
37 IFE 98-14
Brown
IAR&T
38 IT 95K-193-12
White
IITA
39 OLOYIN
Brown
Private Agro dealer
The screening was carried out in the screen house of I.A.R. &T, Moore plantation, Ibadan,
Oyo State, Nigeria between March and July, 2013 using a modified protocol of Singh et al.
(1999). Three wooden boxes of 240cm length, 116cm width, and 20cm depth each were
made from plank of 2.5cm thickness. Each box represents each replicate. The bottom and
sides of the boxes were lined with polyethylene to ensure even distribution of water. Top soil
collected from southern farm of I.A.R. &T, Ibadan was used to fill the boxes to 16cm depth,
31
32
leaving about 4cm space on the top for watering. Thereafter, the boxes were arranged on
concrete platform inside the rain-protected screen-house. The top soil was air-dried and
sieved. Equidistant holes were made in straight rows 10cm apart with a hill-hill distance of
5cm within the rows.
Two handpicked healthy seeds of the cowpea lines were sown in hole of 2cm deep and
thinned to one plant per stand after germination. Each box contained one row of each of 39
cowpea varieties with 6 plants and constituted one replication. The boxes were watered daily
using a small watering can of four litres for two weeks when partial emergence of the first
trifoliate leaf of all the varieties was observed. Thereafter, watering was stopped for thirty
five days (7 weeks). Wilted plants in each variety for each replicate were counted daily.
Atmospheric temperature and relative humidity of the environment (screen house) was also
taken daily throughout the period of the experiment. Watering was then resumed for fourteen
days (2 weeks) to ascertain regeneration percentage for each variety.
The percentage of wilted plants /day (% wp) was calculated using the formula:
Where Npw is number of plants wilted and Nps is numbers of plants standing.
1.
Percentage recovery was estimated after watering has resumed for fourteen days (two
week)
as:
:
Where Npr is the number of plant that recovered after water stress and Npw is the
total number of plants that wilted.
Data obtained were subjected to statistical analysis using SAS TM and based on the days taken
to wilt, the percentage recovery was used to construct dendogram, using PAST software.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The average temperature and relative humidity of the screen house in the morning and
afternoon during the experiment are presented in Table 2. The temperature in the morning
ranges between 26.5oC and 28.1oC while afternoon temperature was between 27.7oC and
33.5oC.
The relative humidity in the morning ranges between 73.1% and 87.2% while that of the
afternoon was 64.5% and 75.6%. The result indicates that the weather condition was
optimum during the experiment. However, the environment was generally cooler and has
high moisture in the morning than in the afternoon throughout the period of the experiment.
Table 2. Average temperature and relative humidity of the screen house on weekly basis
during the experiment.
Weeks
Morning
Afternoon
Temperature (oC)
Humidity (%)
Temperature (oC)
Humidity (%)
Week 1
27.3
87.2
34.2
64.5
Week 2
27.4
83.4
27.7
69.4
Week 3
27.3
84.3
32.7
70.6
Week 4
28.1
86.1
33.5
69.4
32
33
Week 5
26.7
73.1
32.6
73.0
Week 6
27.5
80.1
30.9
75.6
Week 7
26.5
81.4
32.3
72.3
The result from the analysis of variance for percentage wilting during water stress and
percentage recovery after water stress of the cowpea lines shows that there was significant
difference among the cowpea lines at 5% probability level. (Table 3) This result indicated
variation in drought tolerance among the cowpea germplasm lines Watanabe et al. (1997) has
also identified some cowpea lines with better drought tolerance than many improved breeding
lines. This result suggests that progress could still be made in the development of cowpea
varieties with enhanced levels of drought tolerance.
Table 3: Mean Square of percentage wilting at 35 days of water stress and percentage
recovery of cowpea lines.
Source of variation Degree of freedom % wilting at 35 % recovery after
days of water stress water stress
Cowpea lines
38
1041.76*
1501.96*
Error
78
40.99
16.32
*Significant at P<0.05 probability level
Drought tolerance ability of the cowpea lines are presented in Table 4. Seed germination and
initial growth of plants of all the thirty nine lines were normal. Stress effects started
appearing on susceptible varieties at twelve (12) days after the termination of watering while
differences among varieties became visible and progressively more pronounced with
advancing days of moisture stress (Figure 1). The stress effects were first noticed on the
unifoliate leaves which became wilted, followed by the emerging trifoliates, and finally the
growing tip dried (Figure 2) The data on wilting percentage at different days after termination
of watering showed that TVx 3236, NG/SA/07/132 and IT95K-193-12 were the most
susceptible to drought. The recovery percentage after watering ranged from 0% for
NG/SA/01/09/004 to 100 % for IT81D-994 and Oloyin.
Table 4: Relative drought tolerance of the cowpea lines.
S/N Cowpea lines
Percentage wilting after termination of watering (No of
days)
%
recover
y after
water
12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 35 stress
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
17
42
58
58
58
79
2
IT93K-452-1
NG/SA/07/167
(NAGRAB)
0
0
9
9
9
9
9
9
18
41
68
68
71
3
IT90K-277-2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
17
67
67
67
84
4
IT86D-719
0
0
12.5 12.5 12.5 12.5 25
25
50
50
62.5 75
78
5
IT98K-205-8
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
33
33
67
67
67
84
6
IT97K-499-35
0
0
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
67
67
67
74
7
NG/SA/07/159
0
8
37.5 37.5 37.5 37.5 37.5 62.5 62.5 62.5 62.5 71
75
33
34
(NAGRAB)
NG/SA/01/09/008
8 (NAGRAB)
0
NG/SA/07/089
9 (NAGRAB)
0
Cowpea
2
10 (NAGRAB)
0
NG/SA/07/155
11 (NAGRAB)
0
0
0
10
10
10
10
24
38
48
62
71
45
0
28
28
28
28
39
50
50
61
61
61
65
0
44
44
44
44
70
70
70
70
70
88
57
0
0
0
25
25
37.5 37.5 75
75
75
75
25
12 0311109
NG/SA/01/09/009
13 (NAGRAB)
NG/SA/07/083
14 (NAGRAB)
NG/AO/11/08/084
15 (NAGRAB)
NG/AO/11/08/089
16 (NAGRAB)
NG/SA/07/141
17 (NAGRAB)
NG/SA/01/09/003
18 (NAGRAB)
0
0
12.5 12.5 12.5 12.5 25
37.5 37.5 62.5 62.5 75
50
0
0
14
14
14
14
14
69
78
78
78
78
54
0
0
15
15
15
15
15
25
25
60
70
90
91
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
25
33
42
50
50
63
0
30
30
30
30
30
30
62
88
88
88
100 29
0
0
0
0
0
14
14
38
52
62
62
76
57
0
0
0
10
10
40
40
50
50
50
60
60
40
19 TVx 3236
8
8
8
20
20
20
20
33
67
67
67
92
2
20 IT81D-994
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
67
67
100
21 IT89KD-288
NG/SA/07/135
22 (NAGRAB)
0
0
0
11
11
11
11
11
56
56
56
72
80
0
0
22
39
39
50
50
50
61
78
78
78
27
23 0304107
NG/SA/01/09/004
24 (NAGRAB)
NG/SA/07/132
25 (NAGRAB)
NG/SA/07/130
26 (NAGRAB)
NGB/06/043
27 (NAGRAB)
NGB/06/110
28 (NAGRAB)
NG/SA/01/09/015
29 (NAGRAB)
0
0
12.5 12.5 12.5 44
57
57
57
89
89
89
30
0
0
50
50
50
50
100 100 100 100 100 100 0
17
33
33
33
50
83
83
83
100 100 100 100 67
0
0
25
25
33
42
42
75
75
83
83
92
2
0
17
17
33
44
61
61
61
72
89
89
89
61
0
12.5 31
31
31
44
62.5 62.5 75
87.5 87.5 87.5 57
0
0
21
21
31
45
67
67
67
76
76
76
47
30 IT84S-2246-4
NG/SA/01/09/011
31 (NAGRAB)
0
0
24
38
50
50
50
50
64
76
76
88
89
0
0
18
18
18
50
50
50
62
74
88
88
57
32 IFE BROWN
0
0
20
33
33
53
53
53
67
67
77
100 40
33 IFE BPC
0
11
11
44
44
44
44
61
72
72
89
89
34
61
35
34 IT82E-18
0
17
17
17
17
33
33
50
61
78
89
89
60
35 ERUSU
0
0
0
15
15
15
15
44
59
59
72
72
52
36 MODUPE
0
17
17
17
33
50
50
50
67
67
83
83
57
37 IFE-98-14
0
0
0
10
10
43
43
43
43
57
57
57
43
38 IT95K-193-12
17
17
17
17
17
50
50
67
67
67
83
83
58
39 OLOYIN
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
100 100 100
Figure 1: Cowpea varieties twelve days after water stress.
Figure 2: Cowpea varieties thirty-five days after water stress
The dendogram constructed based on percentage wilting at 35 days of water stress and
percentage recovery of the cowpea lines is presented in Figure 3. The dendogram revealed
that the 39 cowpea lines were majorly grouped into three. Group 1 comprises of three lines
(TVx 3236, NG/SA/07/130 and NG/SA/01/09/004) which are drought susceptible while
Groups 2 and 3 comprises of 14 and 22 lines respectively that were tolerant at varying
degrees.
35
36
Figure 3: Dendogram from Euclidan paired group based on % wilting on 35 days after water
stress and % recovery after water stress.
CONCLUSION
Traditional approach of studying drought tolerance on a whole plant basis makes the trait
very complex and therefore difficult to manipulate by plant breeders. The wooden box
screening for shoot drought tolerance as made it very simple to understand the mechanism
behind the trait thereby removing the influence of roots and vice versa. This screening
method have provided information on the cowpea lines that can be used in developing
drought resistant and tolerant cowpea lines which may lead to faster progress in breeding for
drought tolerance in cowpea.
REFERENCES
Ashley, J. (1993). Drought and crop adaptation. Pages 46–67 in Dryland farming in Africa,
edited by J.R.J. Rowland. Macmillan Press Ltd, UK. Pp. 46 – 47.
Ewansiha, S.U. and Singh, B.B. (2006). Relative drought tolerance of important herbaceous
legumes and cereals in the moist and semi-arid regions of West Africa. Journ. of
Food, Agric and Environ., 4: 188-190.
Gwathmey C. O. and Hall A. E. (1992). Adaptation to midseason drought of cowpea
genotypes with contrasting senescence traits. Crop Sci., 32: 773-778.
Nielsen, S, Ohler, T. and Mitchell, C. (1997). Cowpea leaves for human consumption
production, utilization, and nutrient composition. In Singh B, Mohan Raj D, Dashiell
K, Jackai L (eds) Advances in cowpea research. International Institute of tropical
Agriculture (IITA) and Japan International Research Center for Agricultural Sciences
(JIRCASS), Ibadan, Nigeria, pp 326-332.
Singh B.B., Mohan Raj, D.R., Dashiell, K.E. and Jackai, L. (1997). Advances in cowpea
research. IITA-JIRCAS, Ibadan, Nigeria.
Singh B.B. and Matsui, T. (1997). Cowpea varieties for drought tolerance. In Advances in
cowpea research. IITA-JIRCAS, Ibadan, Nigeria.
36
37
Singh, B.B., Mai-Kodomi, Y. and Terao, T. (1999): A simple screening method for drought
tolerance in cowpea. Indian J. Genet., 59: 211-220.
PGB15
EVALUATION OF TURMERIC (CURCUMA LONGA L) ACCESSIONS IN NIGERIA
Amadi, C.O.*, Olojede, O. A., Eleazu, C., Obasi, C., Nwokocha, C. and Ironkwe, A.
National Root Crops Research Institute Umudike, Abia State, Nigeria
*Corresponding e-mail: okeyamadi2003@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Fifteen promising accessions of turmeric selected from the germplasm held at National Root
Crops Research Institute Umudike, Nigeria were evaluated during the rainy season of 2012 at
4 locations - Kuru (8.3833° N, 7.1833° E, 1200m asl), Otobi (7.11667° N and 8.08333° E),
Umudike (5.4758° N, 7.5489° E), and Igbariam (6.4° N and 6.93333° E). The objective of the
trial was to select turmeric accessions with high yield across locations for release in Nigeria.
At each location, the experiment was laid out in RCBD in 3 replications. Plot Size was 9m2.
Data was collected on the following growth and harvest parameters: sprout count, plant
height, number of tillers, number of leaves, main stem girth, rhizome number and weight.
Analysis of variance was carried out on the combined data using genstat discovery edition
software. Results based on the combined data from 4 locations indicate that turmeric
accessions did not vary in percentage emergence and number of leaves. They however varied
significantly P<0.05 in height, main stem girth, tillering, number and yield of fresh rhizomes.
The effect of location on all attributes was significant (P<0.05) with Jos location giving
consistently the least values for all attributes thus suggesting that this location may not be
suitable for the commercial production of turmeric. Genotype environment interaction for
most attributes was not significant indicating that the accessions behaved in the same way
across the locations. Ten accessions viz UT39 (28.37 t/ha), UT44 (27.15 t/ha), UT46 (25.39
t/ha), UT58 (24.73 t/ha), UT50 (24.10 t/ha), UT14 (23.81 t/ha), UT41 (21.53 t/ha), UT6
(20.62 t/ha), UT38 (19.43 t/ha), and UT35 (18.64 t/ha) were identified as promising and
merits further evaluation preparatory for nomination as candidates for official release.
Keywords: Turmeric, Accessions, Variation, Rhizomes, Yield
INTRODUCTION
Turmeric (Curcuma longa Linn) is a monocot belonging to the family Zingiberaceae (Jilani
et al., 2012). It is an important spice used for centuries in food preparation and in medicines
to treat numerous diseases and conditions. (Ishimine, et al., 2003; Pari, et al., 2008;
Maheshwari, et al., 2006). Turmeric is valued for its underground rhizome which contain a
yellow coloured phenolic pigment called curcumin (Karim et al., 2010, Keith Singletary,
2010 ) which is used as natural colouring agent for food, cosmetics and dye (Olojede et al.,
2009). Curcumin the main active ingredient of turmeric functions as a medicine with antiinflammatory, anti-mutagenic anti-carcinogenic, anti-tumor, anti-bacterial, anti-oxidant, antifungal, anti-parasitic and detoxifying properties (Akanime et al., 2007). In addition to the
rhizome’s richness in curcuminoid pigments (6%) and essential oils (5%), it also contains
69.43% carbohydrate, 6.30% protein, 3.50% mineral and other important nutrients on dry
weight basis (Olojede, et al., 2005).
India is considered as the largest producer, consumer and exporter of turmeric in the world
and contributes about 50% of the world trade (Chaudhary, et al., 2006)). Other major
producers are China, Myanmar, Nigeria, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Sri-lanka, Taiwan, Burma and
37
38
Indonesia, etc., The increasing demand for natural products as food additives makes turmeric
an ideal produce for a food colorant. Additionally, anti-cancer and anti-viral properties of
turmeric may also increase its demand from the pharmaceutical industry.
Its production in Nigeria is mainly in small plots around homes (Olojede et al., 2005).
Turmeric can be found growing from low altitude (5m a.s.l.) in the Southern coastal plains of
the rainforest to the mid-altitude (823m a.s.l.) in the derived Savanna within Longitude 3'02'E
- 09'30'E and latitude 4'37'N - 10'04'N (Olojede and Nwokocha, 2011). No variety of turmeric
has been officially released in Nigeria. Official release of improved varieties of this crop is
likely to stimulate production thereby helping to unlock its potentials. The objective of the
trial is to select high yielding turmeric accessions for release in Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was carried out during the rainy season of 2012 in 4 locations - Kuru
(8.3833° N, 7.1833° E), Otobi (7.11667° N and 8.08333° E), Umudike (5.4758° N, 7.5489°
E), and Igbariam (6.4° N and 6.93333° E). Fifteen accessions were laid out in RCBD
containing 3 treatment replications. Plot size was 9m2. Method of cultivation was by means
of raised beds. Seed rate was 1 rhizome/stand. The plants were spaced 50cm x 30cm apart
between and within rows respectively. The beds were mulched soon after planting. Fertilizer
was applied at the rate of 400kg/ha NPK 15:15:15 at 8WAP. The experiment were kept weed
free by the application of pre-emergence herbicide followed by manual weeding. The plants
were harvested when leaves have dried.
Data was collected on the following growth and harvest parameters: sprout count (4 &
8WAP), plant height (8, 12, 16 and 20 WAP), number of tillers (8, 12, 16 and 20 WAP),
number of leaves (8, 12, 16 and 20 WAP), leaf area (8, 12, 16 and 20 WAP), main stem girth
(8, 12, 16 and 20 WAP), rhizome number and weight. Analysis of variance was carried out
on the combined data using genstat discovery edition. Means were separated using Standard
Error of the Difference of means (SED)
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Turmeric accessions did not vary in plant emergence. Percentage emergence was higher at
Umudike and Igbariam compared to Otobi and Jos (Table 1).
Plant height varied significantly with turmeric accession from 75 cm in UT39 to 54 cm in
UT16 (Table 2). In an experiment conducted in 2008 & 2009 cropping seasons at Umudike,
Nigeria, Njoku, et al., (2012) recorded maximum and minimum turmeric heights of 70.6 and
43.9cm respectively. Jilani et al., (2012) reported significant differences in plant height of
turmeric cultivars. Plant height was highest at Igbariam and lowest at Jos. The lowest heights
were recorded consistently in Jos location for all the genotypes (Table 2). The cold
temperatures of Jos plateau may have had an adverse effect on plant growth leading to
reduced height.
Most turmeric accessions did not differ in number of leaves per plant (Table 3). However,
significant variations in number of leaves in different turmeric cultivars have been reported
(Detpiratmongkol, et al., 2009; Jilani, et al., 2012). Effect of location on the leafiness of
turmeric was significant with the highest number of leaves for most accessions recorded at
Umudike (Table 3).
Main stem girth of UT58 (9.99 cm) and UT38 (9.91 cm) were significantly wider than most
other accessions while UT35 with a mean girth of 6.26 cm was lower than most accessions
(Table 4). Main stem girth varied significantly with location. Turmeric grown at Umudike
38
39
had the widest main stem girth (10.94 cm) while plant at Jos location had the least (4.23 cm)
(Table 4).
The effect of accession and location on tillering in turmeric is presented in Table 5. Mean
number of tillers per plant ranged from 4.62 in UT14 to 2.92 in UT39. UT14 with the highest
number of tillers did not differ significantly with eight other accessions in this attribute.
Tillering was highest at Igbariam compared to other locations. It was least in Jos. Hrideek et
al. (2006) did not find significant differences between turmeric accessions in number of
tillers per plant.
Turmeric accessions differed significantly in number of rhizomes (Tables 6). UT46 produced
a mean of 30 rhizomes per plant which was significantly lower than the number produced by
eight other accessions. Olojede, et al. (2009) also reported significant differences between 2
cultivars of turmeric in their rhizome number. The effect of location on rhizome number was
also significant (P<0.05). Rhizome number was highest at Umudike and lowest at Jos
location (Table 6).
Rhizome yield (t/ha) varied significantly with both accession and location (Table 7).
Accessions UT50 and UT46 gave the highest yield at Jos and Otobi respectively while UT39
gave the highest yield at both Umudike and Igbariam. UT39 also gave the highest yield and
UT16 the lowest yield across locations. Sisikumar et al., (1996) reported significant variation
in fresh rhizome yield of entries in a turmeric multilocation trial in India. Other authors
(Nayak et al., 2006; Rao, et al. 2004) have also reported significant variation in rhizome yield
among turmeric cultivars. Effect of location on rhizome yield was significant (P<0.05). Yield
was highest at Igbariam and least at Jos. The yield in Jos for most of the varieties was very
poor (Table 7). Chaudhary et al., (2006), suggested that the variation in rhizome characters,
fresh yield and recovery percentage among various turmeric varieties could be due to genetic
factors rather than the environmental conditions as reported by Subharayadu et al. (1976).
Genotype (Accession) x location interaction was not significant for most attributes including
rhizome yield of turmeric. This is because the accessions responded in the same manner
across the locations with Jos consistently giving the least values for all the attributes while
Umudike and Igbariam gave the highest values for most attributes.
CONCLUSION
Most of the turmeric accessions performed relatively well at Igbariam, Umudike and Otobi
but performed poorly in most attributes at kuru thus suggesting that this location may not be
suitable for the commercial production of turmeric. Ten accessions viz UT39 (28.37 t/ha),
UT44 (27.15 t/ha), UT46 (25.39 t/ha), UT58 (24.73 t/ha), UT50 (24.10 t/ha), UT14 (23.81
t/ha), UT41 (21.53 t/ha), UT6 (20.62 t/ha), UT38 (19.43 t/ha), and UT35 (18.64 t/ha) are
promising and merits further evaluation preparatory for nomination as candidates for official
release.
REFERENCES
Akanime, H., A. Hussain, Y. Ishinine, K. Yogi, K. Hokama, Y. Iraha and Y. Aniya, (2007).
Effect of application of N, P and K alone or in combination on growth, yield and
curcumin content of turmeric (Curcuma longa L.). Plant Prod. Sci., 10: 151-154.
Chaudhary, A.S. Sachan, S.K. and Singh, R.L. (2006) Studies on varietal performance of
turmeric (Curcuma longa L.) Indian J. Crop Science, 1(1-2): 189-190 (2006)
Detpiratmongkol, S., Ubolkerd, T., Yoosukyingsatapron, S. and Phakamas, N. (2009). Effects
of organic manures on growth and yield of turmeric. p. 473-480. In: Proc. 47th
Kasetsart Uni. Ann. Conf.: Plants, Bangkok, Thailand.
39
40
Hrideek, T.K., K.M. Kuruvilla, G.P. Bindumol, P.P. Menon, K.J. Madhusoodanan and J.
Thomas. (2006). Performance evaluation of turmeric (Curcuma longa L.) cultivars at
higher elevation of Western Ghats. J. Plant. Crops, 34:178-180.
Ishimine, Y., M.A. Hossain, Y. Ishimine and S. 15. Alam, M.K., Z. Islam, M.A. Rouf, M.S.
Alam and Murayama, (2003). Optimal planting depth for turmeric(Curcuma longa)
cultivation in dark red soil in Okinawa, Southern Japan. Plant Prod. Sci., 6: 83-89
Jilani, M. S., Waseem, K, Habib-ur-Rehman, Kiran, M., Ghazanfarullah and Ahmad, J.
(2012) Performance of Different Turmeric Cultivars in Dera Ismail Khan. Pak. J.
Agri. Sci., Vol. 49(1), 47-5
Karim, M. R., Abedul, H., Khairul, I., Nurshad, A., Kazi, A. S., Zahangir, A., Ekhtear, H.,
Abul, F., Anwarul, A., Seiichiro, H. and Khaled, H. (2010) Protective effects of the
dietary supplementation of turmeric (Curcuma longa L.) on sodium arsenite-induced
biochemical perturbation in mice. Bangladesh Med Res Counc Bull., 2010; 36: 82 88
Keith Singletary (2010) Turmeric: An Overview of Potential Health Benefits. Nutr Today.
45(5):216–225
Maheshwari R, Singh A, Gaddipati J, Srimal R. (2006) Multiple biological activities of
curcumin: short review. Life Sci., 78:2081-2087.
Nayak, S., N.P. Kumar, A.L. Kanta and P.A. Kumar. (2006). Detection and evaluation of
genetic variation in 17 promising cultivars of turmeric (Curcuma longa L.) using 4C
nuclear DNA content and RAPD. Cytolog., 71:49-55.
Njoku, S.C., A.O. Olojede, and A.A. Melifonwu (2012) Effect of the Critical Period of Weed
Interference on Optimum Performance of Turmeric at Umudike, Nigeria. Journal of
Agriculture and Social Research (JASR), Vol. 12, No. 1, 84-88
Olojede, A .O, Iluebbey, P, and Dixon, A.G.O (2005) IITA/NRCRI Collaborative
Germplasm and data collection on minor Root and Tuber Crops in Nigeria. In:
Annual report 2005 National Root Crops Research Institute, Umudike: 77-81
Olojede, A.O and Nwokocha, C. C. (2011) A Decade of Research on Minor Root and Tuber
Crops at NRCRI: The Contribution Towards Food Sufficiency and Economic
Empowerment in Nigeria. In: Root and Tuber Crops Research for Food Security and
Empowerment. Eds Amadi, C. O., Ekwe, K. C., Chukwu, G. O., Olojede, A. O. and
Egesi, C. N. Pp 387 - 396.
Olojede, A.O., Nwokocha, C. C., Akinpelu, A.O. and T. Dalyop (2009) Effect of Variety,
Rhizome and Seed Bed Types on Yield of Turmeric (Curcuma longa L) under a
Humid Tropical Agro-Ecology. Advances in Biological Research 3 (1-2): 40-42,
2009
Pari L, Tewas D, Eckel J. (2008) Role of curcumin in health and disease. Arch Physiol
Biochem., 114: 127-149.
Rao, A.M., P.V. Rao and Reddy, Y.N. (2004). Evaluation of turmeric cultivars for growth,
yield and quality characters. J. Plant Crops, 32: 47-49.
Sisikumar, B., George, J. K., Zachariah, T, J., Ratnambal, J. M., Babu, K. N. and Ravindran,
P. N. (1996) IISR Prabha and IISR Prathibha – two new high yielding and high
quality turmeric (Curcuma longa L.) varieties. Journal of Spices and Aromatic
Crops, 5 (1): 41-48
Subbarayudu M., Reddy R.K. and Rao M.R. (1976) Studies on varietal performance of
turmeric Andhra Agri J., 23: 195-198.
40
41
Table 1: Percentage Emergence of Turmeric Accessions across 4 location
Location
Accession Jos
Otobi
Umudike Igbariam
Mean
88.89
93.33
100.00
86.67
92.22
UT6
88.89
100.00
96.67
100.00
96.39
UT14
91.11
73.33
100.00
96.67
90.28
UT16
95.56
93.33
100.00
100.00
97.22
UT25
85.56
73.33
100.00
100.00
89.72
UT30
84.44
86.67
96.67
96.67
91.11
UT35
92.22
93.33
100.00
100.00
96.39
UT37
90.00
83.33
100.00
100.00
93.33
UT38
91.11
93.33
96.67
100.00
95.28
UT39
88.89
100.00
100.00
100.00
97.22
UT41
75.56
93.33
100.00
96.67
91.39
UT44
74.44
100.00
96.67
100.00
92.78
UT46
91.11
80.00
100.00
100.00
92.78
UT50
78.89
100.00
100.00
100.00
94.72
UT58
90.00
93.33
100.00
96.67
95.00
UT60
87.11
90.44
99.11
98.22
Mean
SED Accession - 3.58, SED Location - 1.85, SED Acn x Loc. - 7.16, CV% - 9.4
Table 2: Height (cm) of Turmeric Accessions across 4 Locations
Location
Accession Jos
Otobi
Umudike Igbariam Mean
34.06
64.67
57.06
75.50
UT6
57.82
34.06
75.00
64.44
82.92
UT14
64.10
34.94
47.00
61.33
74.08
UT16
54.34
36.72
70.00
73.17
85.67
UT25
66.39
32.06
59.33
66.17
78.92
UT30
59.12
31.86
56.67
55.22
82.00
UT35
56.44
34.81
69.33
102.50
74.83
UT37
70.37
33.75
70.33
55.44
74.83
UT38
58.59
35.36
89.00
88.17
87.33
UT39
74.97
35.22
87.33
62.44
110.58
UT41
73.90
29.22
74.67
75.67
88.25
UT44
66.95
29.03
95.33
90.28
76.03
UT46
72.67
36.03
79.00
65.61
84.50
UT50
66.28
30.06
83.00
83.61
99.50
UT58
74.04
34.25
79.67
72.50
75.33
UT60
65.44
Mean
33.43
73.36
71.57
83.35
SED Accession - 5.08, SED Location - 2.63, SED Acn x Loc - 10.17, CV% - 19.0
41
42
Table 3: Leafiness of Turmeric Accessions across 4 Locations
Accession
UT6
UT14
UT16
UT25
UT30
UT35
UT37
UT38
UT39
UT41
UT44
UT46
UT50
UT58
UT60
Mean
Location
Jos
7.38
9.77
9.03
8.88
8.64
10.87
8.28
7.86
11.45
9.08
9.32
6.33
9.43
6.45
8.03
8.72
Otobi
11.67
12.00
9.33
10.00
15.00
9.00
11.00
8.67
16.00
11.33
12.67
10.67
9.00
11.33
11.33
11.27
Umudike
20.94
25.33
18.89
20.22
20.61
22.17
13.56
20.39
21.00
20.67
23.89
20.22
21.67
21.78
20.17
20.77
Igbariam
9.25
9.67
9.25
9.92
8.83
9.42
9.50
9.25
8.92
9.25
9.17
9.67
9.67
9.33
9.33
9.36
Mean
12.31
14.19
11.63
12.26
13.27
12.86
10.58
11.54
14.34
12.58
13.76
11.72
12.44
12.22
12.22
SED Accession - 1.46, SED Location - 0.75, SED Acn x Loc - 2.91, CV% - 28.5
Table 4: Main stem girth (cm) of Turmeric Accessions across 4 locations
Accession
UT6
UT14
UT16
UT25
UT30
UT35
UT37
UT38
UT39
UT41
UT44
UT46
UT50
UT58
UT60
Mean
Location
Jos
3.56
4.71
3.83
5.03
5.16
3.99
3.98
3.77
5.25
4.73
3.70
3.56
5.17
3.28
3.78
4.23
Otobi
7.53
7.60
4.87
8.33
6.60
5.33
7.17
6.43
9.33
9.10
8.67
8.40
7.43
9.10
6.40
7.48
Umudike
9.39
9.94
9.50
9.28
10.78
8.33
14.06
9.11
13.67
9.89
13.56
13.50
9.06
14.28
9.78
10.94
Igbariam
7.80
8.43
7.84
9.21
8.17
7.39
7.62
8.30
11.38
11.86
10.99
9.21
9.23
13.31
7.55
9.22
Mean
7.07
7.67
6.51
7.96
7.68
6.26
8.20
6.90
9.91
8.90
9.23
8.67
7.72
9.99
6.88
SED Accessions - 0.53, SED Location - 0.27, SED Acn x Loc - 1.05, CV% 16.2
Table 5: Tillering ability of Turmeric Accessions across 4 locations
Accession
Location
Jos
Otobi
Umudike Igbariam
42
Mean
43
UT6
UT14
UT16
UT25
UT30
UT35
UT37
UT38
UT39
UT41
UT44
UT46
UT50
UT58
UT60
Mean
1.47
1.46
1.94
2.03
1.82
1.79
1.56
1.92
2.30
1.37
1.96
1.65
1.87
1.43
1.84
1.76
3.67
3.67
2.67
3.00
2.33
2.67
3.00
3.33
3.00
3.00
3.00
3.00
3.33
3.00
3.00
3.04
5.83
6.28
5.28
4.94
5.89
5.22
2.22
5.50
2.56
4.83
2.67
2.72
4.94
2.39
5.22
4.43
6.50
7.08
6.33
6.08
6.75
6.75
5.00
7.17
3.83
3.83
4.75
5.67
5.58
5.17
5.58
5.74
4.37
4.62
4.06
4.01
4.20
4.11
2.95
4.48
2.92
3.26
3.09
3.26
3.93
3.00
3.91
SED Accession - 0.38, SED Location - 0.20, SED Acn x Loc - 0.76, CV% - 24.8
Table 6: Rhizome Number of Turmeric Accessions across 4 locations
Location
Accession
Jos
Otobi
Umudike Igbariam Mean
8.55
46.62
89.13
64.54
52.2
UT6
11.34
70.12
54.30
65.17
50.2
UT14
11.11
25.04
88.70
58.80
45.9
UT16
14.47
45.19
69.93
82.70
53.1
UT25
12.85
51.25
69.97
51.13
46.3
UT30
14.12
27.82
81.51
74.42
49.5
UT35
9.34
47.88
88.80
53.53
49.9
UT37
9.27
43.94
68.60
54.80
44.2
UT38
12.57
49.91
84.01
47.83
48.6
UT39
9.39
46.22
71.03
32.63
39.8
UT41
8.81
61.00
79.50
62.90
53.1
UT44
10.68
14.33
36.03
58.30
29.8
UT46
19.34
33.57
67.07
65.97
46.5
UT50
7.90
53.68
70.57
50.90
45.8
UT58
10.16
51.56
52.93
50.04
41.2
UT60
11.3
44.5
71.5
58.2
Mean
SED Accession - 8.04, SED Location - 4.15, SED Acn x Loc - 16.08, CV% - 42.5
Table 7: Rhizome Yield (t/ha) of Turmeric Accessions across 4 Locations
Location
Accession
Jos
Otobi
Umudike Igbariam Mean
1.99
16.08
36.00
28.41
20.62
UT6
2.61
30.22
30.42
32.00
23.81
UT14
2.77
14.07
20.00
24.72
15.39
UT16
43
44
4.14
17.67
15.56
34.44
17.95
UT25
3.57
18.15
20.89
24.22
16.71
UT30
3.48
9.81
24.79
36.47
18.64
UT35
5.37
18.07
21.78
25.78
17.75
UT37
2.88
21.27
19.11
34.44
19.43
UT38
5.98
28.94
39.90
38.67
28.37
UT39
3.08
33.93
20.89
28.22
21.53
UT41
2.21
36.79
34.22
35.38
27.15
UT44
2.95
40.37
26.81
36.22
26.59
UT46
16.19
14.67
37.33
28.22
24.10
UT50
2.86
36.07
29.33
30.67
24.73
UT58
2.13
24.44
18.22
26.62
17.85
UT60
4.15
24.04
26.35
30.97
Mean loc
SED Accession - 4.21, SED Location - 2.18, SED Acn x Loc - 8.42, CV% - 48.3
PGB16
GENOTYPE × ENVIRONMENT INTERACTION OF DISEASE AND AGRONOMIC
TRAITS ON SIX CASSAVA GENOTYPES (MANIHOT ESCULENTA CRANTZ) IN
NIGERIA
Njoku, D.N.*, Obidiegwu, J.E., Afuape, S.O. and Nwankwo, I.
National Root Crops Research Institute (NRCRI), Umudike, PMB 7006 Umuahia, Abia State.
*Corresponding e-mail: njokudn2012@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
The study was carried out to quantify the genotype × environment interaction (GEI) on
cassava mosaic disease (CMD), harvest index (HI), fresh root yield (FRY), dry matter content
(DMC) and carotene content (CC) of six cassava genotypes in humid rainforest (Umudike)
and guinea savanna (Otobi) agroecologies in Nigeria. The study was laid out in a randomized
complete block design (RCBD) with three replications. Genotype main effect was significant
(P < 0.001) for harvest index, fresh root yield, dry matter content and carotene concentration.
Environment main effect was significant (P < 0.01) for cassava mosaic disease, harvest index
and fresh root yield, and G × E interaction effect was significant (P < 0.001) for dry matter
content and carotene content respectively. The high genotype and low environment effects,
and the relatively low interaction on dry matter content imply that evaluation and selection
can be effectively done in fewer environments to select genotypes with high performance for
the trait whiles fresh root yield requires multiple environments to identify clones with broad
and specific adaptation. Genotype x environment interactions (GEI) played a significant role
in this study and should be given considerable attention in cassava breeding program for
development of genetic materials adapted to a wide range of environments.
Keywords: Genotype, Environment, GEI, Cassava, Biofortification, carotenoids
INTRODUCTION
Cassava is an important energy staple in Nigeria. It provides over 70% of the energy
requirement for over 70% of Nigerian Population (Njoku et al., 2011). Cassava is the most
important of the root crops in the tropics and ranks fourth after rice, sugarcane and maize as a
source of calorie for human needs (FAO, 2010). The spread of cassava from its native land of
44
45
origin in Amazon in Brazil has been mainly due to its adaptability and predominant use as a
food crop for human nutrition, source of calorie for livestock feed, and lately as an industrial
crop. Cassava as a crop is widely adapted but an individual cultivar has very limited
adaptation because cassava cultivars are very sensitive to G x E interaction (Ssemakula and
Dixon, 2007). An improved genotype will have its maximum value in a particular
environment but may also represent an improvement for neighbouring environments (spillover effect). Also, the response of individual genotype to different environments follows a
diverse pattern due to the influence of the climate and soil variations. It is on this pattern that
selection for high root yield, pest and disease resistance, and stable root yield are based.
Quantitative traits such as those associated with root qualities for example carotene content,
dry matter content, starch and HCN content may show considerable interaction with the
environment. Therefore, the testing of new lines requires evaluation in different locations
(environment) to establish their genetic potential. When G x E interactions is present, the
breeder faces major problems in comparing the performance of cultivars across environments
between genotype, resulting in weak inferences from field data relevant to crop improvement
(Ngeve, 1993). Other factors such as uneven germination of seeds may also complicate the
work of a plant breeder (Collard et al., 2005). In addition to high mean yields, stability of a
genotype’s performance in different environments is necessary to assist breeders in selecting
superior cultivars to meet varying growing conditions. One approach is to reduce the number
of replications used in a single field trial, assuming that performance can still be evaluated
accurately.
Yellow-fleshed cassava genotypes have featured prominently in biofortification because they
have higher levels of micronutrient, such as carotenoids (Chavez et al., 2005) than the whitefleshed genotypes. Adoption of micronutrient biofortified genotypes will largely depend on
their agronomic, including fresh and dry root yield, resistance to major pests and diseases,
and the stability of these traits over time and space. Though cassava is widely adapted to a
variety of environmental conditions, usually the adaptability of most white fleshed varieties is
narrow and shows large GEI effects.
There were conflicting reports on G x E interaction on carotenoid concentration in cassava.
Ssemakula et al. (2007) in a trail with 26 yellow flesh cassava in 10 environments in Nigeria
had significant G x E interaction on total carotene content, dry matter content and cassava
mosaic disease. There is need to conduct extensive trails to confirm these reports. The
objective of the study was to study the G x E and to assess the CMD, HI, FRY and DMC of
six cassava clones at different carotenoid levels.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Six cassava genotypes (Table 1) at clonal yield stages were used for the study. The
environments were Umudike and Otobi which represent humid forest and guinea savanna
transition zones respectively. The soils for the trial sites were Umudike (Dystric Luvisol with
sandy loam top soil over sandy clay) and Otobi (Ferric Luvisol with sandy loam top soil).
Annual rainfall for the environments during the trial period was Umudike (2289 mm) and
Otobi (1500 mm). Plantings were done at different dates for the two environments. The
materials were grown under rainfed conditions in a randomized complete block design with
three replications.
Table 1: Description and sources of cassava genotypes used for the evaluation studies
Clone
Clone type
Origin
Root fresh colour
45
46
TMS 01-1368
TMS 05-1636
TMS 05-0473
TMS 97-2205
TMS 98-0505
TMS 98-0002
Released (2011)
Non-release
Non-release
Released (2005)
Released (2005)
Released (2005)
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
yellow
yellow
yellow
white
white
white
Planting was done using disease-free stakes planted on 4 row plots of 5 plants / row with a
plot size of 20m2. Weeding was done with both herbicides and manual methods when
necessary. Data were collected from the 10 inner plants within a plot. Severity ratings of
cassava mosaic disease were taken at 1, 2, 3, 4, 4 and 6 months after planting (MAP) using a
scale of 1 to 5 (1 = no symptoms; 5 = severe symptoms). At harvest (12 MAP), data were
collected from the 10 inner plants within a plot for harvest index, storage fresh root yield, dry
matter percentage and carotene concentration. Dry matter percentages of storage roots were
determined from a random bulk sample of four plants selected from the inner rows. The roots
were peeled and shredded after washing. Hundred grammes (100 g) of fresh root was taken in
the form of chips and dried at 65°C for 72 h in a forced air oven. The dried samples were then
reweighed to obtain the dry weighs, and the dry matter percentage was calculated as the ratio
of the dry weight over the fresh weight and multiplied by 100. Data collected were first
analyzed separately, then combined over environments using GenStat 14 edition.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Some notable significant interaction existed in this study. Umudike recorded the highest
grandmean for harvest index (HI) (0.6). Also, Umudike recorded the lowest score for cassava
mosaic disease severity (CMD) (1.6). However, Otobi recorded the highest grandmean for
storage fresh root yield (SFRY) and dry matter content (DMC) of 33.5 t/ha and 34.5 %
respectively. Both locations recorded the same grandmean values for carotene concentration
(CC) of 4.0 (Table 2). In the combined analysis (Table 3), storage fresh root yield ranged
from 13.7 t/ha to 37.8 t/ha with a mean of 25.7 t/ha. TMS 98-0002 had the highest root yield
of 37.8 t/ha, while the lowest value of 13 t/ha was recorded for TMS 05-0473. Dry matter
content ranged from 28.3% to 36.5% with a mean of 33.3%. Harvest index ranged from 0.4
to 0.6 with a mean of 0.5, and carotene concentration ranged from 1.3µg/g to 8.2µg/g with a
mean of 4.0µg/g (Table 3). However, the reaction of the clones to cassava mosaic disease
(CMD) across the two environments did not vary significantly.
Analysis of variance (ANOVA) showed that storage fresh root yield, harvest index, dry
matter content and carotene concentration varied significantly (P <0.001) among the
genotypes (Table 4). G x E accounted for 9.7% of the total sum of squares for storage root
yield, while environment accounted for 17.7% and genotype 32.0%. Similarly, genotype,
environment and G x E sources of variation also accounted for 20.5%, 0.2% and 66.7% of the
total sum of squares respectively, on dry matter content. Also, G, E and G x E accounted for
95.9 %, 1.1% and 1.9% on carotene concentration (Table 5).
The high genotype and low environment effects and relatively low G x E interaction for
storage fresh root yield, dry matter content and carotene concentration suggest that these
traits are not drastically influenced by environment and, therefore, that fewer environments
may be needed to distinguish clones with high and stable performance. This also suggests
good prospects for the improvement of the clones for these traits since simple phenotypic
46
47
recurrent selection will be needed. Ssemakula and Dixon (2007), and Benesi et al. (2004)
also reported higher genotype than environment effects on dry matter content in cassava. The
high genotype effects on mosaic disease has also been reported by Maroya et al. (2012) when
working on G x E interaction on cassava mosaic disease, storage fresh root yield and carotene
concentration of yellow-fleshed cassava in Nigeria. Also, this work is in agreement with the
work of Peprah et al. (2013) who reported greater genotype effect on fresh root yield than
environment effect.
Table 2: Performance of six cassava clones planted across two environments in Nigeria
Clone
CMD
s
98- 2.0
TMS
0002
TMS
050473
TMS
980505
TMS
011368
TMS
051636
TMS
972205
Grandmean
SED
CV (%)
LSD (0.05)
Umudike 2012
HI
SFR
DMC CC
Y
0.6 27.2 39.8
2.0
CMDs
Otobi 2012
HI
SFRY DMC CC
1.7
0.6
48.3
35.7
1.1
1.7
0.5
9.6
26.6
4.0
2.6
0.3
17.9
35.8
5.1
1.0
0.6
35.1
39.9
1.2
1.7
0.4
37.7
38.8
1.4
1.7
0.6
14.9
29.7
8.5
3.0
0.4
23.3
26.9
7.9
1.3
0.5
6.2
30.0
6.2
2.3
0.3
21.2
30.6
7.0
2.0
0.6
14.8
32.6
2.3
2.0
0.5
52.4
33.4
1.8
1.6
0.51
0.6
0.0
7
2.0
0.1
5
18.0
10.6
33.1
1.18
4.0
0.17
2.2
0.55
0.4
0.05
33.5
10.20
34.5
1.78
4.0
0.50
36.9
0.14
1.4
<.001
2.1
<.001
18.9
0.17
14.2
0.006
29.6
0.026
2.5
<.00
1
7.6
<.001
26.0
0.39
Table 3: Mean performance of six cassava clones evaluated across two environments
(combined data)
Clone
CMDs
HI
SFRY (t/ha)
DMC (%)
TMS 98-0002
TMS 05-0473
TMS 98-0505
TMS 01-1368
TMS 05-1636
TMS 97-2205
Grandmean
SED
CV (%)
1.8
2.2
1.3
2.3
1.8
2.0
1.9
0.2
19.0
0.6
0.4
0.5
0.5
0.4
0.5
0.5
0.1
5.5
37.8
13.7
36.4
19.1
13.7
33.6
25.7
12.0
57.3
36.5
31.2
39.3
28.3
30.3
33.0
33.3
1.5
5.5
47
Carotene
Conc
1.5
4.5
1.3
8.2
6.6
2.1
4.0
0.4
11.8
48
Table 4: Mean squares of fresh root yield, dry matter content, harvest index, cassava mosaic
disease and carotene concentration
Source
Genotype
Environment
Gen X Env
Df
5
1
5
CMDs
0.72ns
3.36*
0.63ns
HI
0.04***
0.24***
0.01ns
SFRY
783.7**
2167.4**
237.5ns
DMC
114.19***
1.80ns
33.52***
CC
49.7***
0.1ns
0.9**
Table 5: Combined ANOVA of the 5 traits of six cassava clones in two environments
Sour
ce
D
f
Gen
5
Env
1
G
E
x 5
CMDs
SS Variati
on
(%)
3.5 15.7
8
3.3 14.8
6
3.1 13.8
4
HI
SS Variati
on
(%)
0.1 30.5
8
0.2 40.7
4
0.0 3.4
2
FRY (t/ha)
SS
Variati
on (%)
DMC (%)
SS
Variati
on (%)
CC (ug/g)
SS
Variati
on (%)
3918. 32.0
3
2167. 17.7
4
1187. 9.7
7
570.
9
1.8
66.7
95.9
0.2
248.
3
0.01
167.
6
20.5
4.9
1.9
0.0
REFERENCES
Benesi,
I.R.M., Labuschagne, M.T., Dixon, A.G.O. and Mahungu, N.M. (2004).
Genotype x environment interaction effects on native cassava starch quality and
potential for starch use in the commercial sector. Afr. Crop. Sci. J. 12:205-216.
Chavez, A. L., Sanchez, T., Jaramillo, G., Bedoya, J. M., Echeverry, J., Bolanos, E .A.,
Ceballos, H. and Iglesias, C. A. (2005). Variation of quality traits in cassava evaluated
in landraces and improved clones. Euphytica 143: 125-133.
Collard, B. C. Y., Jahufer, M. Z. Z., Brouwer, J. B. and Pang, E. C. K. (2005). An
introduction to markers, quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping and marker-assisted
selection for crop improvement: the basic concepts. Euphytica, 142: 169–196.
FAO 2010. Food and agriculture organizations statistics database. FAO, Rome.
http://faostat.fao.org/. Accessed Oct 2012.
Maroya, N. G., Kulakow, P., Dixon, A.G.O. and Maziya-Dixon, B. B.( 2012). Genotype x
Environment interaction of Mosaic Diseases, root yield and Total carotene
concentration of yellow-fleshed cassava in Nigeria. International journal of
Agronomy, pp 8.
Ngeve, J. M. (1993). Regression Analysis of genotype x environment interaction in
sweetpotato. Euphytica, 71: 231 – 238.
Njoku, D. N., Vernon, G., Egesi, C.N., Asante, I.K., Offei, S.K., Okogbenin, E., Kulakow,
P., Eke-okoro, O. N.and Ceballos, H. (2011). Breeding for enhanced B-carotene
content in cassava: Constraints and Accomplishments. Journal of Crop Improvement,
25: pp 560-571.
Peprah, B.B., Ofori, K., Asante, I.K. and Parkes, E.Y. 2013. Performance of nine cassava
(Manihot essculanta Crantz) clones across three environments. Academic
journals/JPBCS, Vol. 5(4), pp.48-53.
48
49
Ssemakula, G. and Dixon A.G.O. (2007). Clone X environment interaction, stability and
Agronomic performance of carotenoid- rich cassava clones. Sci. Res. Essay, 2(9):390399.
PGB17
HORMONAL INDUCTION OF SEEDLINGS FROM LEAF SUBCULTURE IN SESAME SESAMUM
INDICUM L. GENOTYPES
Jayeoba, F.M.*, Awotoye, O.O. and Ogunbanjo, O.R.
Federal College of Forestry, Jericho, Ibadan, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: feyiropo@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Three Sesame genotypes, Alaede (N3), E8 (N5) and Ex Sudan (N9) obtained from NCRI,
Badeggi, Nigeria, were studied using tissue culture techniques to examine their responses in
vitro. Growth media with different concentrations and combinations of hormones were used
for shoot formation from callus subculture and seedling development from leaf subculture.
Ex Sudan recorded the highest shoot formation frequency on full strength MS media only and
produced the highest mean in seedling development from sub cultured leaves at 0.1mg*L-1
Kinetin + 0.2mg*L-1 NAA and 0.3mg*L-1 Kinetin + 0.1mg*L-1 2,4 D. The latter
concentration showed significant difference among the three genotypes. From the
experiments, Ex Sudan responded better than the other varieties therefore stands as a
candidate for improvement of the other varieties.
Keywords: callus subculture, growth hormones, in vitro, leaf subculture, seedlings
development, sesame, shoot formation
INTRODUCTION
Sesame belongs to the family Pedaliaceae and genus Sesamum (Hutchinson and Dalziel 1963;
Purseglove 1974). The genus consists of about 36 species of which 19 species are indigenous
to Africa (Weiss 1983; Uzo 1998). In Nigeria, three species, which include S. alatum
(Thonn), S. indicum L. and S. radiatum Schum & Thonn, are widely cultivated for different
purposes (Dabir 2000). The most popular species is S. indicum, which has hundreds of
varieties and strains with considerable variation in size, form, growth pattern, colour of
flowers, seed size, seed colour and composition.
Since antiquity, sesame has been used as a valued oil crop. Today it is grown mainly in the
tropics, although its cultivation reaches from 40oN to 40oS latitude. It is typically grown by
small holders with nearly all of its production in developing countries. China (825,531 MT)
and India (620,000 MT) are the world’s principal producers (FAO 2004). Myanmar (390,000
MT), Sudan (122,000 MT), Uganda (110,000 MT), Nigeria (75,000 MT), Pakistan (61,600
MT), Bangladesh (49,000 MT) and Thailand (40,000 MT) are other major sesame growing
countries. (IPGRI and NBPGR , 2004)
Sesame is grown for its seeds, prized oil, and oil paste. The oil paste, tahini, is obtained by
grinding the seeds. The seed is also used on breads and cakes. Sesame is useful as an extra
49
50
rich source of protein in many developing countries (Uzun, et al. 2002). Sesame seeds
contain 50-60% oil. Sesame is known as the queen of oil seeds because its oil not only has
nutritive value but also is of high quality and quantity (Bedigian 2000). According to
research, sesame has many beneficial effects for human health. For instance, scientists
showed that sesame leads to reduction of total serum cholesterol and low density lipoprotein
(LDL) cholesterol and improvement of antioxidant capacity in hypercholestrolemic patients
(Chen, et al. 2005). Sesame also increases vitamin E concentrations in plasma (Frank 2005)In
addition to its effects on animals, sesame has significant effects on microorganisms.
Nigeria has a great potential for sesame production for the domestic and export markets but
the yield of this valuable crop is relatively low and varies from one area to another, due to a
lack of improved varieties. Based on this, the National Cereals Research Institute (NCRI),
Badeggi, has been given the national mandate for the genetic improvement of sesame. A
number of studies have been carried out on various aspects of sesame development. Taskin,
et. al. (1997) studied the in vitro regeneration of sesame while George, et al. (1989) worked
on in vitro propagation and shoot tip culture of different cultivars. Sesame breeding work in
Nigeria is progressing. The need to evaluate materials for selection and subsequent use in
breeding programmes with the purpose of developing improved sesame varieties suited to
Nigerian conditions has been highlighted(Akpan-Iwo et al, 2006)
The aim of this study therefore is to determine the responses of these three varieties of
sesame to different types of growth hormones combinations and concentrations with a view
to developing seedlings from in vitro culture for the improvement of the crop.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Three genotypes of sesame seeds used for this study were obtained from the National Cereals
Research Institute, (NCRI), Badeggi, Niger State, Nigeria. The genotypes were designated
based on the genotype and NCRI name (the latter in parenthesis). These are N3(Alaede);
N5(E8) and N9(Ex- Sudan). The explants used for the study were calluses earlier obtained
from embryo culture of the three varieties. (Jayeoba, 2010)
The basal media used for the experiment was Murashige and Skoog (1962) modified with 3%
Sucrose, 0.1g*L-1 Inocitol and growth hormones concentrations. The growth hormones used
for the study were obtained from the National Center for Genetic Resources and
Biotechnology (NACGRAB) Ibadan, Nigeria. They are abbreviated as follows : 2,4 (2,4
dichlorophenoxyacetic acid);CM(Coconut Milk);K(Kinetin);BAP(6,benzylaminepurine) and
NAA(Napthalene-1-acetic acid). The forceps used was sterilized in glowing splint after
rinsing in ethanol and allowed to cool. The mouth of the medium test – tube was flamed in
the glowing splint and a piece of the callus was carefully placed on the medium. The media
bottle was closed with paraffin to prevent contamination, and the test tubes labeled and dated.
The culture was transferred to the growth room for incubation at 280 C ± 20 C with a 16/18
hour photoperiod from cool-light fluorescent lights with an intensity of 2000 lux. For each
treatment, three replications with 10 tubes per replicate were maintained. The cultured
calluses were scored for the appearance of shoot formation. The leaves from the shoots were
also sub cultured to produce more seedlings.
The data obtained was analyzed using ANOVA according to Steel and Torre (1980).
Significant means were separated using Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (Duncan, 1955).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 1: Mean of shoot formation from callus subculture in Sesame genotypes.
50
51
Treatment
Genotypes
N3
100ml*L-1 CM
N5
N9
0.3 + 0.14
0.4 + 0.15
0.4 + 0.15
+0.01mg*L-1 IAA
MS Only
0.1 + 0.09
0.3 + 0.14
0.5 + 0.16
Full strength
0.3 + 0.14
0.5 + 0.16
0.7 + 0.14
Half strength
0.5 + 0.16
0.5 + 0.16
0.6 + 0.16
0.05mg*L-1 BAP
Table 2: Mean of seedling development from leaf subculture in Sesame genotypes.
Treatment
Genotypes
N3
K(mg*L-1) + NAA(mg*L1
)
N5
N9
0.4 + 0.15
0.4 + 0.15
0.7 + 0.14
0.4 + 0.15
0.7 + 0.14
0.8 + 0.13
K(mg*L-1)+2,4 D(mg*L-1)
0.1+ 0.3
0.2+ 0.13
0.3+0.1
0.3 + 0.14b
0.1 + 0.14
0.6 + 0.16ab
0.2+ 0.15
0.8 + 0.13a
MS Only
Full strength
0.2 + 0.13
0.20 + 0.13
0.3 + 0.14
Half strength
0.1 + 0.9
0.2 + 0.13
0.2 + 0.13
0.1 + 0.01
0.1 + 0.02
51
52
ab
Means with different superscripts in the same row are significantly different.
There was significant difference in the responses of the three genotypes with N9 producing
the highest mean of 0.8 at the concentration of 0.3mg*L-1 2, 4D and 0.1mg*L-1 kinetin (Table
1, Fig I). The highest callus production was recorded at the combination of 0.08mg*L-1
kinetin and 0.25mg*L-1 2, 4D with N9 producing a mean of 0.9 and N5 and N3, 0.7 and 0.5
respectively. Full strength MS produced a significant difference (when subjected to statistical
analysis in callus production in the three genotypes). N9 produced the highest mean of 0.9
and N3 the lowest of 0.5.
The culture on MS only produced higher means in the three genotypes with N9 having the
highest mean of 0.7 and N3 the lowest mean of 0.3, the result was reduced with half strength
MS. Addition of 100ml*L-1 CM reduced the shoot production of N9 from 0.7 in MS to 0.4,
while N3 was not affected. Modifying the MS with 0.005mg*L-1 BAP plus 0.01 mg*L-1NAA
however reduced the rate of shoot production from 0.7 in N9, MS, to 0.5; and 0.3 in N3, MS
to 0.1.
The responses of the genotypes to MS only (full strength and half strength) for the production
of seedlings from leaves subculture was low compared to the modified Ms. N9 produced the
highest mean of 0.3 with full strength MS, while the least mean in the MS treatment was 0.1
produced by N3 at half strength MS treatment. N9 and N5 showed increase in mean of
seedling production as the concentration of NAA was increased from 0.1 to 0.2mg*L-1 but
N3 remained unaffected (Table 2, Fig II). Replacing NAA with 0.3mg*L-1 2, 4D reduced
shoot production drastically in the three genotypes. Increasing kinetin concentration to
0.3mg*L-1and reducing that of 2, 4 D to 0.1mg*L-1 produced a significantly different increase
in seedling production in the three genotypes with N9 producing the highest number of
seedlings.
As the calluses were sub cultured to produce leaves, even though N9 produced a higher mean
on MS in comparison with the others, the means were not significantly different when
subjected to ststistical analysis. The same applied to half strength MS. Reduction in the
means of the three genotypes when compared to full strength MS is as a result of the reason
given in callus production. MS modified with 0.05mg*L-1 BAP and 0.01mg*L-1IAA
produced higher mean in N9 and less in N3 and N5. Since the increment is not significantly
different, it can be deduced that BAP and Coconut Milk had the same effect on shoot
production in the three genotypes. The ratio of BAP: IAA (Cytokinin to Auxin) in this work
was 5:1; this is close to 5.5:1 obtained by Saravanan and Nadarajan (2005) in their shoot
multiplication experiment in in-vitro sesame culture.
In leaf subculture to produce seedlings, N9 responded best of all the three genotypes to all the
treatments they were subjected to. The responses were generally low with MS only; this
means that modifying the media was important for shoot production from leaves in these
genotypes. Increasing the ratio of cytokinin (K) to auxin (NAA) to 1:20 from 1:10 (i.e. from
0.1mg*L-1 K + 0.01mg*L-1 NAA to 0.1mg*L-1 K + 0.02mg*L-1 NAA) increased the
responses of N9 and N5 without any effect on N3 (Table 2). It can be deduced from here that
the three genotypes would produce seedlings from leaves at K:NAA ratio of 1:20, and that
the response of N3 is as a result of its genotype. The reduction in seedling production in the
52
53
three genotypes when NAA was replaced with 2, 4 D (Table 2) implies that hormones
belonging to the same class may not necessarily produce the same effect on the same plant
species. The significant difference observed in the means when K was increased to 0.3 and 2,
4 D reduced to 0.1 shows that seedlings could be regenerated faster from leaves at that
concentration and combination. It also showed that the three genotypes responded differently
to that treatment.
CONCLUSION
The response of N9 is higher in almost all the studies carried out when compared with other
two genotypes. This could be traced to its performance in the viability test in which it gave
the highest germination rate. The reason for this performance may have arisen from its
genetic constitution which confers an advantage on it. The seeds of N9 and N5 were also
relatively bigger than that of N3 (N9 was 2mm while N5 was 1.5mm in length). This could
have also contributed to the performances as N3 responded least in all the treatments. It has
been observed in this study that Kinetin is a better cytokinin for callus development in the
three genotypes under study than coconut milk. Also, BAP and coconut milk have been found
to produce similar effects on shoot production in the three genotypes. Seedling development
from leaf subculture was found to improve significantly when MS was modified with
hormones. Individual hormone rather than class produced different effects on the three
genotypes.
REFERENCES
Akpan-Iwo, G.; Idowu, A. A. & Misari, S. M. 2006.Collection and evaluation of sesame
(Sesamum spp.) germplasm in Nigeria. IGPR/FAO, 142:59-62.
Bedigian, D. 2003. Evolution of sesame revisited: domestication, diversity and prospects.
Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution. 50: 779 – 787.
Bedigian, D.,. Kiple, K.F and Ornelas-Kiple C.K. eds. 2000. ‘Sesame’ The CambridgeWorld
History of Food. New York. Cambridge University Press. 1: 411–421.
Chen, P.R., Chien, K.L.; Su, T.C.; Chang, C.J.; Liu, H. Cheng, T.L. and Tsai C. 2005.
Dietary sesame reduces serum cholesterol and enhances antioxidant capacity in
hypercholesterolemia. Nutrition Research. 25: 559–567.
Dabir J.D. 2000. Cytogenotical studies of interspecific hybrids between Sesamum indicum
and wild relatives. Unpublished MSc thesis, Botany Department, University of Jos,
Plateau State, Nigeria.
FAOSTAT data. 2004. URL http://apps.fao.org/faostat/collections?version=ext&hasbulk=0&
subset=agriculture
Frank, J. 2005. Beyond vitamin E supplementation: An alternative, strategy to improve
vitamin E status. Journal of Plant Physiology. 162: 834-843.
Hess, D.E. and Dodo H. 2004. Potential for sesame to contribute to integrated control of
Striga hermonthica in the West African Sahel. Crop Protection. 23: 515–522.
Hutchinson J. and Dalziel J.M. 1963. Flora of West Tropical Africa: II. Crown Agents,
London, UK.
53
54
IPGRI and NBPGR. 2004. Descriptors for Sesame (Sesamum spp.). International Plant
Genetic Resources Institute, Rome, Italy; and National Bureau of Plant Genetic
Resources, New Delhi, India.
Jayeoba F.M. 2010. Hormonal induction of calluses from Sesame embryo. CCSD
International Journal of Natural and Applied Sciences (1):1. 31-34.
Laurentin, H., Karlovsky. P. 2006. Genetic relationship and diversity in a sesame (Sesamum
indicum L.) germplasm collection using amplified fragment length polymorphism
(AFLP). BMC Genetics. 7/10: 1-13.
Purseglove J.W. 1974. Tropical Crops: Dicotyledons. Longman Group, London,UK. pp. 430–
435.
Uzo J.O. 1998. Beniseed: a neglected oil wealth of Nigeria. In: Proceedings of the First
National Workshop on Beniseed (Sesame), 3–5 March, 1998, Badeggi, Nigeria.
Uzun, B., Ülger S. and Çağıran M.İ. 2002. Comparison of Determinate and Indeterminate
Types of Sesame for Oil Content and Fatty Acid Composition. Turk J Agric For. 26:
269-274.
Weiss E.A. 1983. Oilseed Crops. Longman Group, London, UK.
PGB18
ASSESSMENT OF POLLEN FERTILITY, CANE YIELD AND ETHANOL CONTENT IN
SUGARCANE PROGENIES DEVELOPED BY THE MODIFIED POLYCROSS METHOD
Olaoye, G.1*, Olaoye, J.O.2, Takim, F.O.1 and Idris, A.M.1
1
Department of Agronomy/Unilorin Sugar Research Institute, P.M.B. 1515, Ilorin, Nigeria.
2
Department of Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering, P.M.B. 1515, Ilorin, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: debolaoye @gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Performance of breeding lines in advanced yield trials is prerequisite to identification of
superior genotypes intended as replacement to the existing cultivars. However, apart from
yield potential, sugarcane breeders also determine the sexuality of flowering genotypes that
are highly productive so that they can be used either as male or female in crosses aimed at the
development of future varieties. To this end, 10 advanced sugarcane lines from the Unilorin
Sugar Research Institute (USRI) breeding programme were assessed for their flowering
behaviour, sugar (cane yield and sucrose content) and ethanol yields, using a randomized
complete block design with four-replications during the 2011/2012 cropping season at the
institute’s research farm. Our results showed that all the progenies were highly fertile and so
could be utilized as males in crosses. On the basis of pollen morphology, the genotypes were
classified as either Sulcate or Colpate. Many of the progenies yielded significantly higher
(P<0.001) than some of the check varieties with Progeny USRI/08/63 recording the highest
cane yield but which was comparable to the yield of the best standard variety (var. Co6806).
Among the progenies, the highest ethanol yield was obtained from progeny USRI/08/03 with
15% ethanol followed by four other progenies (USRI/08/16, USRI/08/63, USRI/08/68 and
USRI/08/85) with 10% ethanol respectively. Since different genotypes were identified in
respect of cane yield and ethanol, a separate breeding programme can therefore be designed
for the development of high ethanol content sugarcane varieties.
54
55
Key words: Saccharum officinarum, pollen morphology, sugar yields, ethanol content,
polycross,
INTRODUCTION
Sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum L.) breeders routinely carry out hybridization procedures
which normally involve the use of highly fertile sugarcane genotypes as source of pollen
(males) in crosses with male sterile types (as females), followed by raising of the fuzz (true
sugarcane seeds). Although the degree of anther dehiscent when viewed with the hand lens
gives an indication of sexuality of a flowering variety, classification based on microscopic
examination of the pollen grains is a more realistic procedure for correctly classifying
flowering sugarcane varieties either as male or female. This is because the use of hand lens in
classifying flowering sugarcane varieties on the basis of degree of pollen shed has to be
carried out regularly during the breeding season in order to ensure success in pollination.
The occurrence of flowering under field conditions is variable and is also influenced by
variety as well as prevailing environmental conditions in a locality. Previous studies have
shown that flowering is a complex process consisting of multiple stages of development with
each stage having specific environmental and physiological requirements. The environmental
conditions may include a combination of factors such as diurnal temperatures, specific day
length, elevation, temperature and moisture requirements (Van-Breeman et al.,
1962;Clements and Awada 1967; Coleman, 1969; Gosnell, 1973; Moore, 1987; Moore and
Nuss, 1987; Araldi et al., 2010), rainfall amount and distribution (Olaoye, 1996), suboptimal photoperiod (Nayamuth et al., 2003; Berding,
2005), rising atmospheric
concentrations of CO2 (Rosenzweig et al., 1995) and pollution levels.
Furthermore, as the world demand for alternative source of fuel increases, attention has been
focused on non-fossil source of fuels which include crops such as sugarcane, cassava
(Manihot utilissima), jatropha (Jatropha cacus) among others. According to Deepland
(2005), sugarcane is one of the plants having the highest bioconversion efficiency of captured
sunlight through photosynthesis to fix around 55 tonnes of dry matter/ha of land on an
annually renewable basis. For example, the crop has been used in Mauritius as energy
conservation and efficiency measures to minimize cogenerated energy (steam and electricity)
utilized in cane processing and also export excess electricity to the grid. Similarly, Brazil has
diversified sugarcane breeding efforts to include development of varieties for ethanol
(biofuel) generation from the crop, as source of fuel for their automobile by transforming
sugarcane into about 12 x 109 litres, 1/5 of which is in anhydrous form (Gonzalez and
Galvez, 1998). A corollary is that sugarcane breeding efforts in other sugar producing
countries have been diversified into development of varieties for specific end uses such as
high sugar, high fibre, and ethanol content sugarcane varieties.
Secure, reliable and affordable energy supplies are fundamentals to global economic stability
and growth. The challenges of sustainable development are great and the importance of
energy in achieving sustainable development predicated upon search for sustainable
programme for generation of energy from biomass. Access to affordable energy services is
fundamental to human activities, development, and economic growth. Biomass is considered
to be one of the key renewable resources of the future at both small and large scale levels.
The development of biomass as a source of clean and renewable energy has been encouraged
because of its benefits especially environmental sustainability (Keeney and DeLuca, 1992).
55
56
Olaoye (2011) reported that production of biofuels has the beneficial effect in increasing a
sustainable fuel supply for the future. The activities through the production chains of biofuels
provide jobs and socio-economic developments in rural areas. The use of ethanol as fuel is
capable of reducing the adverse foreign trade balance. COLMAC (2009) and Van Gerpen et
al., (2007) in Olaoye (2011), noted that the cost benefit ratio of production of biofuels may be
higher compare to fossil fuel but biofuel does not contribute to greenhouse effect problem
which is a major problem with other known energy source.
Since the inception of sugarcane varietal development activities in Nigeria, breeding efforts
have concentrated on the development of high yielding (cane yield and sucrose content)
varieties without diversifying breeding efforts to the development of varieties for specific
end-uses such as high fibre (for coenergy generation) or high ethanol (biofuel) content
sugarcane varieties. Although previous studies ( Oworu, 1987; Fadayomi et. al., 1995), have
shown that flowering is not a desirable trait in sugarcane because of the diversion of photo
assimilates into flowering and seed production to the detriment of sucrose accumulation, it is
required in sugarcane breeding for varietal development. Consequent upon our interest to
diversify breeding efforts into the development of improved sugarcane varieties for other
specific end uses other than manufacturing of refined sugar, 10 of the 97 progenies from our
2007 modified polycross scheme which combined high cane yield with high sucrose in the
juice at the preliminary yield testing stage (which are also the flowering type), were selected
for further yield evaluation in the savanna ecologies. In this part of the study, the
performances of the progenies for cane yield and related traits under large plot size as well as
their ethanol contents were investigated. The fertility status of the flowering types was also
determined with the view to correctly classify them either as male or female for effective
hybridization purposes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The genetic materials used comprised 10 flowering sugarcane progenies which were selected
from among 97 progenies evaluated for their yield potential and other attributes at the
research farm of the Unilorin Sugar Research Institute (USRI), Ilorin in 2009 (Olaoye et al.,
2010). The progenies came out of the 2007 modified polycross breeding scheme which was
developed in the institute to generate planned crosses in recognition of lack of specialized
glasshouse and stock solution for effective hybridization under a controlled condition to
prevent contamination from unwanted pollen source. The details of the scheme have been
described in an earlier paper (Olaoye, 2001).
The study was conducted during 2012/2013 growing season at the USRI, farm, Ilorin in the
Southern Guinea Savanna (SGS) agro-ecological zone of Nigeria (Lat 80 29 and Long 40
35E). The rainfall pattern is usually bimodal with its highest peak in July and September and
a break between Mid-July and Late August. The average annual precipitation of the area is
1250 – 1500mm with temperature ranging between 190C and 330C. The 10 sugarcane
progenies were evaluated along with five commercial varieties as checks. The experimental
design was a randomized complete Block (RCBD) with three (3) replicates. The trials were
laid out in four row plots, 5 meters long with 1.5m between the plots and an alley of 1m
between plots. Three-budded sugarcane sets which were, used as planting materials were laid
in horizontally in the furrows and eight (8) sets were planted per row. All agronomic
56
57
practices including weed control and fertilizer application were carried out according to the
standard practices.
Data were collected from five (5) random stools selected from the two middle rows on yield
parameters of tiller count, stalks/stool, stalk length, stalk diameter, millable cane population,
internodes/stalk and length of internode. Data were also collected at harvest on cane yield,
single stalk weight and sucrose accumulation in the juice. For cane yield, all millable cane
stalks from the two middle rows were harvested and weighed on scale and recorded in
kilograms (kg). The weights were later converted into cane yield in tonnes per hectare. Single
stalk weight was measured as the weight of three (3) randomly selected single cane stalks per
plot and recorded in kg. oBrix which is the percentage by weight of the soluble solids in the
juice when squeezed from a matured or crushed sugarcane stalk with an extractor and
measured and read on a refractometer, were collected from three (3) randomly selected
millable stalks in a plot.
Arrows (sugarcane flowers) were collected from three stalks/plot and taken to the laboratory
of the Department of Plant Biology for microscopic examination of the pollen grains.
Matured anthers on the spikelets at shedding period were collected in sample bags and
examined for pollen morphology and viability tests using the light microscope. The anthers
were squashed on the microscope slide using a broad base material to remove the pollen grain
from the anthers. Few drops of stain Lacto-phenol (cotton blue) were added and covered with
cover slip to prevent the pollen grains from displacement. The prepared slides were then
examined under the light microscope. Viable (fertile) pollen grains appeared large, fully
round and dark in colour while inviable and (infertile) pollen grains appeared clear, empty
and colourless. The pollen grains were then counted and sorted into fertile and infertile pollen
grains and then expressed into percentage as
x 100
= percentage of fertile pollen
Based on the percentages of fertile and infertile pollen grains, the genotypes were classified
into males and females. Genotypes with high percentages (50 – 100%) were rated as males
and genotypes with lower percentages (0-49) were rated as females.
The structure and characteristic of the pollen grains were determined using the
photomicrographic scanning machine in the Department of Plant Biology, University of
Ilorin. On the basis of structure and characteristics, the pollen grains were characterized
either as inviable or viable while the viable pollen grains were further grouped as either
colpate (elongated aperture or furrow) or sulcate (many pores).
The biofuel component comprising of sugarcane juice extractor, fermenter and distillation
unit were designed and constructed in the Department of Agricultural and Biosystems
Engineering of the University of Ilorin. (Plate 1). Three (3) litres of sugarcane juice was
extracted from each of the progenies with the aid of the juice extractor. This was followed by
the addition of 1.2g of commercial Baker’s yeast, dry Saccaromyces cerevisiae to each of
the three (3) litres of sugarcane juice/progeny. The concentrate was fermented for a period of
48 hours in the fermenter with stirring under anaerobic conditions. The juice was later
distilled and bioethanol yield determined for each genotype using the hydrometer values.
Brix was determined with the hand refractometer while a viscometer was used to determine
the Kinematic Viscosity of the slurry after distillation at 27oC. The procedure was repeated
57
58
three times for each genotype. Other data collected included time of grating, weights of
grated canes, volume of juice, brix value and machine loss. Amount of juice yield was later
calculated using the formula:
Juice yield (%) = [Je/Je+ Wr] 100
Where Je = weight of extracted juice, Wr = weight of residue.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Means with standard errors attached (SE+) ranges in the means and coefficient of variation
(%CV) for pollen characteristics in (10) USRI progenies and four (4) check varieties are
presented in Table 1. The results showed that number of viable pollen grains were quite high
than the inviable pollen grains with a difference of greater than 95 percent (%). The range in
the means for the viable pollen grains among the genotypes which is an indication of
differences among them for this trait, as well as coefficient of variation (%CV) was also large
compared to the values obtained in respect of inviable pollen grains.
Plate 2 shows the different pollen characteristics encountered among the flowering
genotypes. The inviable pollen grains (top) had clear, collapsible, and colourless morphology
which failed to absorb the stain. This feature was observed in USRI/08/58 which had the
highest number of inviable pollen grains relative to total pollen count. Viable pollen grains
appeared round and took the blue colour of the stain (lactophenol or cotton blue) and majority
of the USRI progenies are in this category as they exhibit high percentage of pollen grains
which stained the cotton blue and therefore were characterized as viable. The viable pollen
grains were further classified as either Sulcate (middle) or Colpate (bottom). The sulcate type
were characterised by possession of numerous spores in ring when viewed under light
microscope while the colpate type is characterised by presence of two apertures in their
pollen after viability test is carried out. Three of the progenies (USRI/08/03, USRI/08/43 and
USRI/08/85) as well as the three standard varieties (ILS-001, ILS-002 and Co 6806) were
classified as colpate because they have aperture in their viable pollen grain while the others
could be classified as sulcate because they posses many spore in their viable pollen grain.
The mean values for pollen characteristics among the USRI progenies and check varieties are
presented in Table 2. Many of the progenies have higher percentage of viable pollen than the
check varieties with USRI08/85 having the highest pollen viability and USRI/08/58 having
the lowest percentage viable pollen. Sexuality based on pollen viability is usually used to
classify flowering sugarcane genotypes as either female (0-49%) or male (>50%). Since all
the test genotypes had high pollen fertility, they can be correctly classified as male fertile and
source of pollen in our hybridization programme. However, many of the genotypes with high
pollen count also had high % pollen fertility which is contrary to earlier reports (Olaoye,
1996) indicating inverse relationship between pollen production and fertility. Some of the
progenies used in this study as well var. ILS-002 were actually the non-flowering types,
either at the time of selection (progenies) or release (ILS-002). However, results from this
study showed that they now flower (and some of them profusely). This may not be
unconnected with the effects of climate change which tend to support recent observation from
our yield testing programme (Olaoye et al., 2010) and consistent with earlier reports that
flowering behaviour (flowering or non-flowering), its extent (profuse or shy) as well as
sexuality (male or female) in sugarcane do change relative to changes in climatic factors,
(Badalou, Personal communication).
58
59
Cane yield and associated traits in the progenies and check varieties are presented in Table 3.
There were significant differences among the genotypes for almost all the traits except stalk
length and stalk diameter. Single stalk weight and millable cane population jointly
contributed to overall cane tonnage as the high yielding genotypes (for example USRI/08/63,
Co 6806, USRI/08/08 and USRI/08/46) showed superiority for these two traits. Low yielding
genotypes on the other hand (Co 957, Local check and USRI/08/43) had high brix content
which also supports earlier findings (Smith and James, 1969; Miller and James, 1971) of an
inverse relationship between cane yield and sucrose in the juice and that different genes
probably code for each trait. All the progenies yielded significantly higher than the check
variety. Progeny USRI/08/63 had the highest cane tonnage which was comparable to the
yield of the best standard variety (var. Co6806). Two other progenies (USRI/08/03 and
USRI/08/46) also combined high cane yield with acceptable brix content. The difference in
cane yield between the two highest yielding genotypes (USRI/08/63 and progeny and the
check variety was 23t/ha-1 representing a yield advantage of 32.77%.
The ethanol yields in the progenies and those of three standard varieties are presented in
Table 4. Among the progenies, the highest ethanol yield was obtained from progeny
USRI/08/03 with 15% ethanol followed by progenies USRI/08/16, USRI/08/63, USRI/08/68
and USRI/08/85 with 10% ethanol respectively while the lowest value of 5% was recorded in
progenies USRI/08/46, USRI/08/58 and USRI/08/80 had 5% ethanol all after 48 hours of
fermentation. The slurry from progeny USRI/08/68 had the highest kinematic viscosity of 8.5
cm3/s while USRI/08/63 had the least of 1.0 cm3/s. The ethanol yield obtained in respect of
the progenies was low when compared to values obtained in the standard varieties. This may
be due to the fact that the determinations in 2011 was were carried out as soon as flowering
commenced while the activity in 2012 was carried out long after flowering process was
completed.
CONCLUSION
The results from the present study revealed that different genotypes exhibited superiority of
performance especially with respect to sugar and ethanol yields. This implies that
development of high ethanol content sugarcane varieties is also feasible using the current
genetic resources at our disposal. Furthermore, since these progenies are highly fertile, they
can serve as sources of genes for the development of high sugar and ethanol content
sugarcane varieties.
REFERENCES
Araldi, R. F.M.L. Silva, E.O. Ono and J.D. Rodrigues. 2010. Flowering in sugarcane. Cienc.
Rural [onLine] Vol. 40. No 3:694-702
Berding, N. 2005. Poor and variable flowering in tropical sugarcane improvement
programmes. Diagnosis and resolution of a major breeding impediment. XXV Jubilee
Congress of international society of sugarcane technologists. Guatemala. Jan 30-Feb
24, 2005 (Abstract).
Clements, H.F and M. Awada 1967. Experiments on the artificial induction of flowering in
sugarcane. Proceedings International Society of Sugarcane Technologists 12: 795812.
Coleman, R.E. 1963. Effect of temperature on flowering in sugarcane. International Sugar
Journal 65: 351-353.
COLMAC. 2009. Fuel from Ethanol. http://www.comalc.com/fuel_ethanol.htm.
59
60
Accessed on July 6, 2009.
Deepland, K. 2005: Sugarcane Bagasses Energy Cogeneration- Lessons from Mauritius.
Paper presented to the Parliamentarian Forum on Energy Legislation and Sustainable
Development. Cape Town, SA. 5th-7th October, 2005 18pp.)
Fadayomi, R.O., Y.A. Abayomi and G. Olaoye. 1995. Evaluation of etephon for the control
of flowering in sugarcane at the Bacita Estate, Nigeria. Sugarcane No. 1 Jan/Feb. 917.
Gonzalez, A.L. and L. Galvez. 1998. Mautice Paturau Memorial Lecture, Keynote Address:
Sugarcane, its by-products and co-products. Food and Agricultural Research Council,
Reduit, Mauritius. 13pp
Gosnell, J.M., 1973. Some factors affecting flowering in sugarcane. Proceedings of the South
African Sugarcane Technologist Association 47:144-147.
Keeney, D.R., and T.H. DeLuca. 1992. "Biomass as an Energy Source for the Midwestern
U.S." American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, Vol. 7 (1992), pp. 137- 143.
Miller, J.D. and N.I. James. 1975. Selection in six crops of sugarcane. I. Repeatability of
three characters. Crop Sci. 15: 23-25.
Moore, H. 1987. Physiology and control of flowering. Copersucar International Sugarcane
Breeding Workshop. Pp.102-127.
Moore, P. H and K. J. Nuss. 1987. Flowering and flower synchronization. Chapter 7 In: D. J.
Heinz ed. Sugarcane improvement through breeding, Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Naymuth, R., M. Mangar and R. Sopaya. 2003. Characterization of natural environment for
sugarcane flowering ability. AMAS Food and Agricultural Research Council, Reduit,
Mauritius. 179-187.
Olaoye, G. 1996. Studies on flowering in sugarcane in a savanna ecology of Nigeria. I.
Relationship between pollen fertility and seed set. Nig. J. Genetics XI: 60-65.
Olaoye, G. 1999. Quantitative assessment of flowering in sugarcane. Ife Journal of
Agriculture. Vol. 20 Nos. 1 & 2: 104-117.
Olaoye G. 2001. Genetics between and within sugarcane progenies developed by the
modified polycross methods at the seedling selection stage. Ghana Journal of
Agricultural Science 34: 109 – 117.
Olaoye, G, Y. A. Abayomi and S. O. Akinyemi. 2010. Contribution of maternal parents to
progeny selection in sugarcane (Saccahrum officinarum L.). proc. 34th Annual Conf.
of Genetics Society of Nigeria. 19th-24th September, 2010. National Institute of
Horticultural Research, Idi-Isin, Ibadan.
Olaoye, J. O. 2011. Design and Construction of a Reflux Column Distillation Unit for BioEthanol Production from Sugarcane Substrate. Nigeria Journal of Technological
Development (NJTD), Published by the Faculty of Engineering & Technology,
University of Ilorin, Ilorin. 8(1): 48 - 60.
Oworu, O.O. 1987. Effect of flowering on yield and quality in sugarcane. Bangladesh Journal
of Sugarcane 9: 53-59.
60
61
Rosenzweig, C., L.H. Allen Jr., L.A. Harper, S.E. Hollinger and J.W. Jones (eds.). 1995.
Climate change and agricultural analysis of potential international impacts. ASA
Apwcial Publication No. 59. American Society of Agronomy. Madison, WI. 382pp
Smith, G.A. and N.I. James. 1969. Association of characters within and repeatability between
years in progenies of four sugarcane crosses. Crop Sci. 9: 819-822.
Van-Breeman, J. F., Lii-lang Liu to Ellis and G. Arseneaux 1962. Effect of elevation on
arrowing and pollen fertility in sugarcane int. soc. Sugarcane technology proc. 11:
540 – 545.
Van Gerpen, J. H., C. L. Peterson and C. E. Goering. 2007. Biodiesel: An Alternative Fuel
for Compression Ignition Engines. ASAE Distinguished Lecture No. 31, 2007 for
Presentation at the 2007 Agricultural Equipment Technology Conference, Louisville,
Kentucky, USA 11-14 February 2007.
61
62
Table 1: Means with standard errors (SE ) for pollen fertility in ten sugarcane
progenies and four check varieties (Ilorin, 2012).
Trait
Mean SE
Min
Max
Range
%CV
Total Pollen count
582 174
88
1104
1016
53.0
No. of viable pollen grains
523 173
65
1026
961
63.4
No. of inviable pollen grains
26.6
8.7
44.0
35.3
12.9
% Viability
96.72 3.48
88.07
96.06
7.99
5.4
Table 2: Pollen characteristics and sexuality of 10 sugarcane progenies and two check
varieties (Ilorin, 2012).
Number of
Total pollen Viable
Inviable %
S/N Genotype
count
pollen
pollen
Viability Sexuality
1.
USRI/08/03
727
692
34.7
95.18
Male
2.
USRI/08/16
392
374
17.3
95.41
Male
3.
USRI/08/43
1104
609
35.0
55.16
Male
4.
USRI/08/46
826
788
37.7
73.86
Male
5.
USRI/08/58
88
65
23.3
98.65
Male
6.
USRI/08/63
592
584
8.7
92.84
Male
7.
USRI/08/68
489
454
35.7
93.10
Male
8.
USRI/08/80
449
418
31.7
98.84
Male
9.
USRI/08/85
1038
1026
16.0
95.45
Male
10. USRI/08/87
462
441
21.0
98.04
Male
11. CO6806
614
602
12.3
95.70
Male
12. ILS-002
396
379
16.7
94.55
Male
13. ILS-001
808
764
44.0
74.10
Male
14. Local Check
162
123
39.0
75.92
Male
SED
246.5
245.4
12.14
4.93
LSD(0.05)
506.6
504.4
ns
10.14
F-Test
**
**
ns
**
%CV
51.9
57.5
55.8
6.7
62
63
Table 3: Cane yield and associated traits in10 sugarcane progenies and five check varieties
(Ilorin, 2012)
Single
Stalks Tiller
Stalk
Stalk
Internode Internode Millable stalk
/stool count
length diameter length
/stalk
canes
weight
Genotype
(no)
(no)
(m)
(cm)
(cm)
(no)
(no)
(kg)
USRI08/03 30
167
1.50
1.93
8.65
12
74
0.70
USRI08/16 23
110
1.11
2.07
6.80
11
47
0.50
USRI08/43 9
83
1.34
2.20
9.59
10
39
0.60
USRI08/46 34
141
1.52
2.40
8.67
13
53
0.83
USRI08/58 10
73
1.38
2.53
7.65
14
25
0.80
USRI08/63 24
128
1.23
1.93
8.73
14
52
0.70
USRI08/68 9
85
1.05
2.38
8.52
13
36
0.77
USRI08/80 21
126
1.58
2.10
9.18
15
46
0.67
USRI08/85 6
74
1.03
2.03
9.54
9
32
0.33
USRI08/87 15
120
1.17
1.97
8.99
12
45
0.40
Co 6806
24
60
1.36
2.57
8.70
16
52
0.97
Co 957
10
68
1.15
2.15
8.54
16
38
0.47
ILS-001
12
70
1.23
2.97
9.40
11
16
0.50
ILS-002
18
94
1.17
2.13
7.79
14
43
0.50
Local
Check
25
158
1.10
1.97
8.64
11
61
0.40
Mean
18
104
1.34
2.22
8.63
12.73
43.93
0.61
Sed
4.64
27.16 0.23
0.28
0.64
1.79
23.26
0.269
63
Brix
20.3
19.6
20.1
20.4
20.0
20.0
19.7
20.4
19.7
19.9
20.4
20.9
19.7
19.6
Cane
yield
(t/ha-1)
68.9
58.4
58.6
67.5
56.1
71.6
62.8
62.5
55.4
63.0
71.0
57.6
54.4
60.4
20.0
20.05
0.69
8.14
61.09
9.24
o
64
Table 4: Ethanol content in sugarcane progenies and two check varieties (Ilorin, 2012).
Brix value
pH value
Kinematic
viscosity of
the
slurry
(cm3/s) @
o
Ethanol 27 C
(%)
Genotype
Before
fermentation
Before
fermentation
After
fermentation
Volume
of
distillate
(ml)
USRI/09/03
18.5
5.0
3.6
470
15
6.1
USRI/09/16
18.5
5.0
3.5
420
10
5.4
USRI/09/43
18.5
5.2
3.4
815
8
1.1
USRI/09/46
14.0
5.3
4.3
1060
5
1.2
USRI/09/63
14.5
5.4
3.4
925
5
4.5
USRI/09/68
16.0
4.8
3.6
500
10
1.0
USRI/09/80
15.0
5.2
3.5
750
10
8.5
USRI/09/85
16.5
4.8
3.5
680
5
5.3
USRI/09/87
15.0
5.0
3.5
650
8
2.5
USRI/09/18
14.0
4.8
3.6
410
8
2.3
Mean
ILS-001+
ILS-002+
Co 957+
18.0
18.0
18.0
4.7
4.8
4.8
4.3
4.1
3.5
1390
1460
3,200
51
46
26
2.1
5.0
6.1
+; Determination made in 2011 season.
64
65
65
66
Plate 2: Different types of pollen morphology in sugarcane genotypes: inviable pollen grains
(top), sulcate viable pollen grains (middle) and colpate
viable pollen grains (bottom).
Plate 1: View of sugarcane juice Extractor (left), Fermenter (middle) and Distillation unit
(right)
PGB19
FIELD PERFORMANCE AND SELECTION OF ADVANCED MUTANT LINES OF GINGER
Iwo.G.A.1* and Amadi, C.O.2
1
Department of Crop Science, University of Calabar, P.M.B.1115, Calabar, Nigeria.
2
National Root Crop Research Institute, Umudike, Abia State, Nigeria.
Corresponding e-mail:godfreyiwo@gmail.
ABSTRACT
Generation of useful genetic variability in ginger through induced mutation using gamma-ray
radiation was imitated at the National Root Crop Research Institute, Umudike in 2009 cropping
season. The objective was to develop improved ginger varieties with high yield potentials and
desirable agronomic characteristics considering the rhizome yield, oleoresin and resistance to
field diseases. The generated mutant clones of ginger derived from the gamma-ray radiation have
been subjected to recurrent selection based on the established selection criteria. In 2012, twenty
mutant lines of M3 generation were selected and advanced to M4 for further evaluation. Field
result showed that fifteen out of twenty mutant lines at M4 generation gave higher rhizome
yields ranging from 21 tons -37 tons/ha with corresponding high percentage of oleoresin. The
response of the M4 mutant lines to diseases showed that the mutants were resistant to nematode.
The mean gall index (MGI) recorded on each mutant line ranges from 0.02 -1.87. The leaf spot
infestation was high in some mutant lines such as UG2-5-52, UG2-5-47, UG2-5-04, and UG1-901 but the severity of infestation tend to have less effect on the rhizome yield. This shows that
some of the mutants are tolerant to the leaf spot disease. Fifteen promising M4 mutant lines
were selected and nominated for multilocational trial to ascertain the yield stability.
66
67
Keywords: Disease, ginger, irradiation, lines, mutation, Mutants, yield
INTRODUCTION
Ginger (Zingiber officinale Rosc) is a monocotyledonous perennial herb in the family
Zingiberaceae, grown mainly for its spicy and aromatic rhizomes. Ginger is a native of tropical
south or Southeast Asia (Peter et al, 2007). It is an important tropical horticultural plant valued
for it aroma, flavor and also medicinal properties. Ginger has basic antiseptic properties and is
used as carminative and stimulant (Singh and Singh, 2000). It is also used as veterinary medicine
(Islam et al 2008).
Ginger is an obligatory asexual species with narrow genetic base because gene introgression or
recombination through hybridization is almost impossible (Iwo and Ekaette, 2010). As a result
varietals development or improvement of ginger using conversional methods has become very
difficult. According to Oseni (1994) improvement of any crop depends on the magnitude of
genetic variability and yield related traits that can be exploited for efficient crop management
and yield enhancement. Ginger being a vegetative propagated crop can be improved through
induced mutagenesis. Induced mutagenesis serves as an important tool for creating usable
genetic variability in crops. Genetic variability is fundamental to successful breeding program in
vegetative propagated crops. The variation can occur naturally or can be induced through
mutation using physical mutagens such as Gamma ray irradiation. The main advantage of
mutation induction in vegetative propagated crops is the ability to change one or a few characters
without changing the remaining characters in the genotype. The ultimate purpose of the Research
work was to develop improved ginger varieties with high yield potentials and desirable
agronomic characteristics considering the rhizome yield, oleoresin and resistance to pest and
diseases. The generated mutant clones of ginger derived from the gamma-ray radiation have been
subjected to recurrent selection based on the established selection criteria. In 2012, twenty
mutant lines of M3 generation were selected and advanced to M4 for further evaluation for high
rhizome yield, oleoresin and resistance to field pest and diseases.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In 2012 cropping season, twenty promising M3 mutant lines of ginger were selected and
advanced to M4 generation based on their agronomic performance. The mutant lines including
the control were planted on the field in three replicates at Umudike. Each line was planted in 2rows plot of 0.8 x 5m with inter-row and intra-row spacing of 0.4 x0.4m respectively. Mulching
was carried out immediately after planting. The M4 mutant plants were evaluated using number
of tillers, rhizome fingers, oleoresin contents, rhizome yield and response to pest/diseases as the
selection criteria. The incidence of field diseases such as leaf spot and mean gall index (MGI)
were measured using a scale of 1-5. The determination of oleoresin was carried out using the
methods suggested by Onwuka, (2005)
RESULTS
67
68
The performances of the evaluated twenty mutant lines are shown in table 1. Generally the
performance of the mutant lines were tremendous considering the rhizome yields. Fifteen M4
mutants’ lines tend to be more promising with rhizome yields ranging from 21tons/Ha 37tons/Ha. These conformed to earlier report by Orkwor (1983) that yields of 30-34 tons/ha are
obtainable under well managed experimental farms and Purseglove (1987) reported that under
improved cultivation condition, yields as high as 38 tonnes/ha can be achieved. Each of the high
yielding mutant lines gave a commensurate percentage of oleoresin above the control.
The response of the evaluated advanced mutant lines to diseases showed that the mutants were
resistant to nematode. The mean gall index recorded on each line was very low ranging from
0.02-1.87 except the control with 3.02 MGI. This indicated that the gamma-ray irradiation also
assisted in inducing resistance gene against nematode (Table 2). Leaf spot infestation was high
in some mutants such as UGII-5-52, UGII-5-47, UGII-5-04, and UGI-9-01.The severity of
infection tend to have less effect on the rhizome yield of the mutants. This may be a case of
tolerance to the late leaf spot.
CONCLUSION
The agronomic performance and variations in yield components observed on the developed
mutant lines of ginger shows the effectiveness of induced mutation. Based on the observed
variability on yield potentials and oleoresin content, fifteen M4 mutant lines were selected and
nominated for multi-locational evaluation. The multi-locational evaluation across different
ecological zones known for ginger production will ascertain the yield stability of the selected
mutant lines. Integration of cultivar stability with yield is important for the purpose of selecting
high yielding and stable genotypes.
REFERENCES
Islam, K.M.A., Islam A. K. M. A., Rasul, M.G., Sultana, N. and Mian, M. A. J. (2008) Genetic
Variability and Character Association in Ginger. Ann. Bangladesh Agric. 12 (1):00-00.
Iwo. G.A and Ekaette. E.A (2010) Genetic component analysis of yield related traits in some
ginger genotypes. Nigerian journal of genetics,
vol.23:81-85
Oseni, H. E. and Khidir,M .O.(1994). Estimate of genetic and environmental variability in
Sesame. Experimental Agriculture: 10:105-122
Peter, K.V., Ravindran, P. N., Divakaran, M., Babu, K.N. (2007) Horticulture: Vegetable
Science. (Vegetable, Tuber and Spices Crops). Pp. 69
Onwuka.G(2005)Food analysis and instrumentation.Cappthali print.Lagos.
Orkwor, G.C (1983).Effect of spacing, land preparation and mulch on growth
and yield of
yellow and black ginger varieties in Umudike. NRCRI Annual Report,Umudike
Umuahia, Nigeria.
Peter,K.V, Ravindran P.N,Divakaran .M, and Babu, K.N (2007).Breeding of spice Crops.
Horticulture: (vegetable Science). Pp 1-69.
Purseglove,J.W(1987).Tropical Crops. Monocotyledon.Longmans,London.
68
69
Singh, V. V. and K. Singh 2000. Spices. New Age International (p) Limited 4835/34, Ansari
Road, Saryanany; New Delhi- 110002. 58p.
Table 1. Mean values of agronomic components of improved mutant lines (M4) of ginger
Mutant lines
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
UG2-5-31
UG2-5-03
UG2-5-52
UG2-5-35
UG2-11-07
UG2-5-48
UG2-5-49
UG2-5-38
UG2-5-18
UG2-5-22
UG2-5-47
UG2-5-04
UG2-7-24
UG2-13-02
UG2-7-25
UG1-9-01
UG1-11-10
UG1-5-24
UG1-11-03
UG1-9-05
Number of Total
Tillers
Rhizome
Fingers
21
8
17
15
11
16
12
18
14
18
8
17
10
17
18
17
15
17
9
16
8
19
17
16
13
19
11
15
10
14
8
18
8
17
14
16
11
17
4
13
21
Control
6
S/N
9
Mean
11.6
15.6
SE±
0.93
0.76
CV (%)
36
21
.
Key: *=The fifteen high yielding mutant lines
69
Oleoresin
(%)
7.2
6.5
6.0
6.2
5.6
7.0
5.7
5.8
7.2
6.1
6.2
6.6
6.0
5.7
5.6
5.3
5.4
6.4
5.2
5.6
Rhizome
yield
Tons/ha
33.8*
16.5
26.8*
27.5*
26.78*
21.6*
24.0*
23.0*
21.5*
30.0*
21.7*
17.3
25.0*
22.0*
37.5*
21.0*
9.8
18.9
27.0*
7.5
4.5
6.5
6.7
0.67
45
22.3
1.63
32
70
Table 2: Incidence of field diseases on M4 Mutant lines of ginger evaluated at Umudike in
2012
S/N
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Key:
Mutant lines
UG2-5-31
UG2-11-03
UG2-5-52
UG2-5-35
UG2-11-07
UG2-5-48
UG2-5-49
UG2-5-38
UG2-5-18
UG2-5-22
UG2-5-47
UG2-5-04
UG2-7-24
UG2-13-02
UG2-7-25
UG1-9-01
UG1-11-10
UG1-5-24
UG1-11-03
UG1-9-05
Control
Mean Gall index
Leaf spot
0.03
0.45
0.15
0.04
0.40
0.02
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.11
0.05
0.14
0.20
0.13
0.13
1.40
0.67
0.93
0.67
1.87
3.02
0
0
5
2
0
1
0
2
1
5
5
0
1
1
1
5
0
1
0
0
4
Rhizome yield
t/ha
33.8
16.5
26.8*
27.5
26.7
21.6
24.0
23.0
21.5
30.0*
21.7*
17.3
25.0
22.0
37.5
21.0*
9.8
18.9
27.0
7.5
6.5*
*=Susceptible but tolerant to late leaf spot disease
PGB20
CHARACTERIZATION OF MINI CORE COLLECTION OF COWPEA ACCESSION
FOR STRIGA RESISTANCE USING SSR AND AFLP-DERIVED SCAR MARKERS
G.I. Alunyo 1, L.O.Omoigui1 B.A. Kalu1, A.Y. Kamara2, and B. Ousmane2
1
Department of Plant Breeding and Seed Science, College of Agronomy, University of
Agriculture, P.M.B. 2373, Makurdi, Nigeria.
2
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture ( IITA) , Ibadan Oyo State, Nigeria.
Correspondence Email: gabrielisaiah79@yahoo.com)
ABSTRACT
S .gesnerioides (Willd) Vatke is a major biological constraint to cowpea production in the dry
Savannas of sub-Saharan Africa. Yield losses caused by S. gesnerioides in these regions are
estimated in millions of tons annually, and prevalence of Striga soil infestation is steadily
increasing. The use of resistant varieties remains the most economically and environmentally
70
71
friendly means of controlling the parasite. Striga resistance in cowpea is conferred by a single
dominant gene. The lack of broad resistance is one of the biggest problems when trying to
develop resistant cultivars across biotypes. Most of the cowpea cultivars with resistance to Striga
biotypes prevalent in Nigeria were developed using B301 or lines derived from it as sources of
resistance. There is therefore the need to identify additional sources of resistance other than
B301 in order to ensure sustainable control of the parasite. In the present study, one hundred and
ninety four mini core collections of cowpea accessions were screened for resistance to Striga
under artificial infestation of Striga in the screen house using pot culture technique. Six cultivars
with known Striga reaction were included as checks. There was high genetic variability among
accessions in terms of reaction to Striga. Out of the total 194 accessions screened, only three of
the accessions (Tvu-9343, Tvu-1272 and Tvu-16514) were completely and consistently free of
Striga attachment to the cowpea root. The three newly identified accessions were characterized
using three DNA markers to validate phenotypic data. Two out of the three accessions produced
polymorphic bands which were different from that of B301 band size, which indicates a different
resistance gene source. These new accessions are potential donor parents for breeding and
pyramiding of Striga resistance genes(s) into single genotype for horizontal resistance.
Keywords: Maker assisted selection, FTA technology, cowpea, Striga gesnerioides,
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp is an important grain legume grown in tropical and
subtropical region of the world, primarily in sub-Saharan Africa. Cowpea is of significant
economic importance worldwide with 24% protein and high mineral content. The relatively high
protein content of cowpea makes it an important supplement to the diet of many African people
(Emechebe et al., 1991), who consume cereals, roots, and tubers high in carbohydrate and low in
protein (Lambot, 2002). The crop provides cash income as well as fodder for livestock and is
frequently intercropped with cereals where crop mixtures with cowpea are beneficial in
maintaining soil fertility (Carsky et al., 1995; Noubissie et al., 2010). The estimated world
cowpea production is over 12 million ha with annual production estimated at about 4.99 million
tons (FAO, 2010). Out of this estimate, West and Central Africa (WECA) accounts for over 9
million ha of the area under cowpea cultivation with about 3 million tons of grain production.
Nigeria is the largest cowpea producer in West Africa, accounting for about 60% of the total
world production and also has the highest level of consumption, followed by Niger and Burkina
Faso which produces 10% (Pereira et al., 2001).
Despite the importance of cowpea, its production is constrained by several biotic and abiotic
stresses. Among the biotic stresses, the parasitic weed Striga gesnerioides (Willd) Vatke of the
Orabanceae family is one of the most important constraints to its production especially in the dry
savannas, where cowpea is an important crop. S. gesnerioides is an obligate root hemiparasite
that parasitizes cowpea plants leading to severe chlorosis, wilting, stunting and even death of the
susceptible host (Olmstead et al., 2001). Annual yield losses are estimated in millions of tons
(Kamara et al., 2008). Total crop failure on susceptible host has also been reported (Hibberd et
al., 1996). Control of S. gesnerioides is difficult to achieve because of the intimate association
between the parasite and its host. Several control strategies have been developed for parasitic
weeds including improved cultural practices, breeding using wild and cultivated germplasm as
71
72
sources of resistance, and the use of chemical control. Among these control strategies, the use of
resistant cultivar is probably the most economic and efficient method to control the parasite.
Over the last two decades several improved cowpea varieties have been developed for Striga
resistant. However, a recent study conducted by Omoigui et al., 2011in northern Nigeria showed
that some varieties that were classified as resistant to Striga in one region were found to be
susceptible when grown in another region and they speculated the existence of different races of
Striga in Nigeria. Studies by Botanga and Timko (2006) using molecular profile identified seven
different races of Striga that affect cowpea across West and Central Africa.
The lack of broad or horizontal resistance is a major problem when trying to develop resistant
cultivars across biotypes. Most of the cowpea cultivars with resistance to Striga biotypes
prevalent in Nigeria were developed using B301 or lines derived from it as sources of resistance.
There is therefore need to identify additional sources of resistance other than B301 in order to
ensure sustainable control of the parasite. The discovery of new sources of Striga resistant gene
would not only help in improving cowpea, but will help to develop strategies for pyramiding
resistance gene in cowpea. The study was initiated to screen a large germplasm collection to
identify new source of resistance to cowpea Striga using DNA profile and convention
approaches.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This experiment was conducted in two locations (Pot culture techniques screening was
conducted at IITA, Kano while the DNA analysis was carried out at the Molecular Biology
Laboratory of the University of Agriculture, Makurdi).
One hundred and ninety four cowpea accessions collected from IITA genebank were used for the
study. Six cultivars with known Striga history were included as checks. This comprised four
resistant cultivars: B301, IT97K-499-35, IT03K-338-1, and three Striga susceptible cultivars;
IT84S-2246-4S, TVx 3236, and Borno Brown (a local cultivar from Borno State),
Striga seeds were used as inoculums. .The plants were grown in plastic pots filled with a mixture
of sand and top soil in a ratio 2:1 and infested with 1000 Striga seeds per pot. After soil
infestation with Striga seeds, the soil was kept moist for 9 days to precondition Striga with seeds
to ensure optimum germination. Three cowpea seeds were sown in each pot and later thinned to
two plants at two weeks after planting. One gram of compound fertilizer (NPK: 15:15:15) was
applied at one week after planting. The pots were watered adequately, maintained at field
capacity. Weed was controlled by hand pulling to keep pots free of weeds.
Data were collected on plant height, day to Striga emergence, stem weight, Striga plant attached,
Striga height, plant shoot weight (biomass), plant root dry weight, Striga count at 7 and 8 weeks
after planting, Striga root weight and Striga houstorium weight. The experiment was terminated
at 70 days. Pots were washed and examined for Striga houstorium attachment. Plants which
support Striga houstorium attachment were classified as susceptible while those that were free of
Striga houstorium attachment were classified as resistant(see Fig. 1). Data collected were
analysed using the linear additive model for the CRD in SAS (Little and Hill 1999).
72
73
Fig. 1: Resistance was assessed by visual counting of emerged and underground S. gesnerioides
haustorial attachment on the accessions and cultivars
Following morphological characterization, DNA analysis was carried out to validate phenotypic
data. Genomic DNA was extracted from leaf tissue of two week- old plants using the FTA®
Plant saver cards for PCR analysis using the methodology of Whatman, (2002) and Omoigui et
al.(2009).
The secondary young leaf was excised from the plant and placed in a square of the FTA card.
The leaf sample was covered with a parafilm paper and a pestle was used to press the leaf sample
onto the FTA® paper until both sides of the FTA were soaked with the plant sap (Fig. 2). In
circumstances where the pestle was stained by the leaf sap as a result of parafilm paper
damage, a paper towel soaked in 70% ethanol was used to clean the pestle in between
samples to prevent cross- contamination. The FTA cards were allowed to dry for one hour; plant
material was brushed off with tissue paper. After air drying, FTA® cards were placed in a paper
pouch and stored at ambient temperature in a dry location.
Fig. 2: Genomic DNA extraction using FTA card and a pestle to press the leaf sample onto the
FTA card at IITA Lab, Kano Station
A disc from the dried FTA tissue print was removed using a clean Harris® micro- punch and the
disc was placed directly into a 1.5 ml eppendorf tube. The disc was washed twice with 200 μl of
70% ethanol, and incubated for 5 min between each wash. A repeat wash with 200 μl of FTA
73
74
reagent, was incubated for 5 min at room temperature. The liquid was discarded. The tubes were
inverted and drained on a paper towel tor air for approximately 1 h. After drying, the disc was
transferred to a PCR tube for PCR analysis.
PCR analysis was done with 3 primers SSR-1, MahSe2 and C42B. Accupower PCR premix tube
(BIONEER) was used for the PCR reaction to which 1 FTA purified disc containing the DNA
sample and 16µl of water-Molecular Biology Grade (Lonza) were added.
A 10μl of the final PCR product was electrophoreses on a 2% agarose gel with ethidium bromide
staining. The gels were run for approximately 1 h 20 min at 170 voltage in 1 X Tris acetic acid
(TAE) buffer (45 mmol L-1 glacial acetic acid, 0.5 mmol l-1 ethylenediaminetetra acetic acid
(EDTA), (pH, 8.4). 10µl of a 100bp DNA was ladder loaded in the first well for band size
determination of PCR products. The ethidium bromide-stained gel was visualized on an UV
transilluminator and photographed using a Polaroid camera.
RESULTS
Out of the total 194 accessions screened, three of the accessions (Tvu-9343, Tvu-1272 and Tvu16514) were completely and consistently free of Striga attachment to the cowpea root. Result
from the ANOVA revealed high genetic variability among the accessions for reaction to Striga
and other parameters measured. Among the parameters measured, plant height had the highest
mean (14.08) with a range 3.0-19.5. High variability was also observed for Days to Striga
emergence, Striga attachment, and Striga count at 56 days (Table 1). The lowest mean score was
recorded for Striga root weight. Out of the 89 accessions characterized using DNA markers, only
two showed polymorphic band (Fig. 3 and 4), while the one of the accessions (Tvu-9343) was
not amplified by the marker used (Fig.3, 4).
Table 1: Mean and Range Performance of Cowpea Accessions
Character Mean Range
PHT@wk 14.08 3.0-19.5
STMwt
2.42 1.5 to 3.8
Dstremg
9.45 0 to 51.5
Statt
3.27 0 to 35.0
STrHT
2.4
0 to 17.35
PLRTwt
2.35 0.1 to 7.6
PLShwt
6.75 1.2to 12.5
Scnt49D 0.93 0 to 9
Scnt56
1.25 0 to 15.0
STrwt
0.25 0 to 4.55
STRhwt
0.262 0 to 2.45
PHT@3wk= Plant height at 3 week, STMwt= Stem weight, Dstremg= Days to Striga
emergence, Statt= Striga attached, STrHT= Strigaroot height, PLShwt= Plant shoot weight,
PLRTwt= Plant root weight, Scnt49D= Striga count at 49 days, Scnt56D= Striga count at 56
days, STrwt= Striga root weight and STRhuwt= Striga haustorium.
74
75
100bp
ladder
DNA
Newly identified resistantaccessions
Susceptible
Fig. 3: A section of PCR reaction products of SSR-1 resolved in 2% Agarose gel
Fig. 4. PCR amplification of DNA based on the use of BIONEER Accupower PCR premix with
the SCAR( marker Mahse2 and C42B) in 2% agarose gel with ethidium bromide staining.
DISCUSSION
A total of 194 accessions collected from a mini core collection of the IITA cowpea germplasm
with six known genotype as checks were phenotype for resistance to S. gesnerioides in pot trials
carried out in screen house of IITA, Kano station . Of the 194 accessions screened in the
preliminary study, 89 were free from Striga attachment while the rest supported Striga
attachment and were classified as susceptible. Out of the total of 89 accessions screened, only
three of the accessions (Tvu-9343, Tuv-1272 and Tvu-16514) showed absolute resistance and
were confirmed by molecular assay except Tvu-9343 that was not amplified by the markers used.
The mechanism of resistance of the newly identified accessions may be antibiosis or antixenosis
(non preference) that prevent the germination of the Striga seeds or the penetration of the host
roots by the parasite radicle.
75
76
The ninety six accessions were genotyped to validate phenotypic data and determine the
relationships of the resistant accessions with the existing B301 using the three DNA markers. Of
the 96 accessions genotyped only two accessions (Tvu-1272 and Tvu-16514) produced
polymorphic bands ). It is interesting however, to note that the genotypic score did not fully
agree with phenotypic score in one of the accessions (Tvu-9343). It is very likely that the three
markers are not linked to the gene that confers the resistance in Tvu-9343. This result is similar
to the report of Timko et al. (2013) who reported that SSR-1 marker was found in GH2284
although this cowpea accession was not resistant. Since the marker is imbedded at the Cterminal end of the RSG3- B301 gene conferring SG3 resistance, it would appear that GH2284
may have picked up mutation that rendered it susceptible. This study also corroborate with the
report of (Ouedraogo J, Ouedraogo M, and Timko M P, unpublished data) which says analysis
has shown that a modified version of 61R termed MahSe2 is effective in identifying resistance to
Striga race SG3. However, this study is also slightly different with the finding of Omoigui et al
(2012) who reported that MahSe2 and C42B markers indicator was quite similar with the
phenotypic classification. Finally, this study could also suggest that Tvu-9343 is completely
susceptible but escape phenotypic characterization. It is also interesting to note that one of the
newly indentified accessions (Tvu-16514) has the same band size with the control checks B301
(Plate C and D). This is not full indicator that B301 and Tvu-16514 have the same gene that
confers their resistance. This therefore, can be ascertained in two ways. First, study of their
allelic relationship. The second option is the use of primers designed based on the variations
observed in their nucleotide sequences at this gene region. The resistant accession amplified
different band sizes indicating genetic variation or a new gene for Striga resistance.
CONCLUSION
This research work presents a report on the morphological and molecular characterisation of
mini core collection of cowpea accession for Striga resistance. The study revealed that three out
of 194 accessions screened, were absolutely free from Striga attachment on the cowpea roots.
SSR-1 and SCAR markers were used to validate the phenotypic data. It was interesting to note
that two of the three accessions (Tvu-1272 and Tvu-16514) produced polymorphic bands.
However, the amplified bands were different from that produced by B301, which suggests that
the Striga resistance gene(s) in the accessions may be different from resistance gene in B301.
These new accessions are potential donor parents for breeding and pyramiding of Striga
resistance genes(s) into single genotype for horizontal resistance.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors wish to thank IITA through the ISMA project for funding this research work. Our
appreciation also goes to the Molecular Biology Laboratory of the University of Agriculture
Makurdi, for providing the facility for the molecular work. The authors thanked Ayeni, D.F,
Adeola Azeez, Iyorkaa Nater, Daniel and Macsam Ugbaa for their technical assistance.
REFERENCES
Aaron T, Asare, Bhavani S. Gowda, Isaac K.A. Galyuon, Lawrence M. Aboagye, Jemmy F.
Takrama, Francis K. Padi and Michael P. Timko (2013).Identification of potential
sources of Striga resistance in cowpea [Vigna- unguiculata (L.)Walp.] accessions from
Ghana. J. Microbiol. Biotech., Res.,3(1): 14-22.
76
77
Botanga, C. J. and Timko, M. P. 2006.Phenetic relationship among different races of Striga
gesnerioides (Willd) Vatke from west Africa. Genome 49:1351-1356.
Carsky, R.J. and D.K. Berner. 1995. Benefits of crop rotation with soybean and cowpea in
savanna cereal-based systems. Pages 391–402 in Technology options for sustainable
agricultural production in sub-Saharan Africa, edited by T. Bezuneh, A.M. Emechebe, J.
Sedgo, and M. Ouédraogo. Semi-Arid Food Grain Research and Development
(SAFGRAD), Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso.
Emechebe A. M., Singh B. B., Leleji O. l., Atokple I. D. K., Adu J. K. 1991. Cowpea Striga
problems and research in |Nigeria in: Kim, S.K (Ed.). Combating Striga in Africa,
proceedings of an international workshop organised by IITA, ICRISAT and IDRE. August
22-24. 1988. IITA, Ibadan, Nigeria. Pp. 18-28.
FAOSTAT. 2010. www.faostat.org5th November, 2010.
Hibberd, J.M., Quick W.P., Press M.C. and Scholes J .D. 1996. The Influence of the parasitic
Angiosperm Strigagesnerioides on the growth and photosynthesis of its
host,Vignaunguiculata. Journal of Experimental Botany 47;507-512.
Kamara, A.Y, Chikoye D., Ekeleme F., Omoigui L.O. and Dugje I.Y. 2008. Field performance
of improved cowpea varieties under conditions of natural Infestation by parasitic weed
striga gesnerioides. International management 54(3): 189-195.
Lambot C (2002). Industrial potential of cowpea. In; Fatokun CA, Tarawali SA, Singh, BB,
Kormawa PA, Tamo M, (eds) 2002. Challenges and opportunities for Enhancing
Sustainable cowpea production. Proceedings of the World cowpea conference III held at
the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), Ibadan, Nigeria, 4-8 September
2002. IITA, Ibadan, Nigeria.
Noubissie, T. and Guissai,B.S. (2010). Screening of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp).
Varieties resistant to Strigagesnerioides(wild). Vatke at marova, Sudano-Sahelian zone of
cameroun. Master thesis, University of Ngaoundere Cameroun (In France).
Olmstead, R. G., C.W. DEPAMPHILIS. AD.WOLFE, N.D. YOUNG, W.J. ELISONS, AND
P.A. REEVES. 2001. Disintegration of the Scrophularieaceae. American Journal of botany
88; 348-361.
Omoigui, L.O., M.P. Timko,A.V. F.S. Ishiyaku, B. Ousmane, B.S. Muranaka, A.V. Kamara and
M.Y. Yeye (2009). Moleculer characterization of cowpea Breeding line for Striga
resistance using FTA technology, African Crop Science Conference, Uganda 9; 527-530.
Omoigui L. O., Ishiyaku M. F., Ousmane B., Gowda B. S. and Timko M. P. 2011.
Application of fast technology for analysis (FTA) for sampling and recovery of
deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) for molecular
characterization of cowpea breeding
lines for Striga resistance. Afr. J. of Biotech. Vol. 10 (85): 19681-19686.
Omoigui L.O., Mary Yeye, Boukar Ousmane, Bhavani S Gowda, and Micheal P. Timko (2012)
.Molecular characterization of cowpea breeding lines for Striga resistance using SCAR
markers.Journal of Agriculture Science and Technology. B2 362-367.
77
78
Payne, R. W., Murray, A. D., Harding, S. A., Baird, D. B., and Soutar, D. M. 2007. Genstatfor
Windows 10th edition. Introduction VSN International Hemel Hempstead.
Pereira, P.A. A., Del peloso, M.J., da Costa, J.G.C., Ferreira, C.M., Yokoyama, L.P. (2001).
Beans product; perspectives for production, Consumption and Genetic Improvement. Paper
presented at the Cowpea Research National Meeting. Embrapa Rice and Beans.Teresina,
PIAUI, Brazil.
Whatman, Inc. FTA protocols (2002). Collect, Transport, archive and access nucleic acid-all at
room temperature, WB 120047.
PGB21
ASSESSMENT OF GENETIC
MORPHOLOGICAL MARKERS
DIVERSITY
IN
NIGERIAN
SESAME
USING
Alege, G. O. 1* and Mustapha, O. T. 2
1*
Biological Sciences Department, Kogi State University, Anyigba, Kogi State, Nigeria.
2
Plant Biology Dept., University of Ilorin, Ilorin, Kwara State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: gbemilege7@yahoo.com).
ABSTRACT
The assessment of genetic diversity among 23 sesame genotypes (Sesamum indicum L.) obtained
from different locations in 10 states across Nigeria was carried out using evidences from
qualitative, quantitative growth and pod morphological traits. The plants were grown in 2008 and
2009 at the Research Garden of the Biological Sciences Department, Kogi State University
(KSU), Anyigba, Nigeria in Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) to characterize and
evaluate the sesame genotypes. Nine qualitative, eighteen growth and eight pod attributes were
studied. Data pooled on these attributes were subjected to Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) and
means with significant differences were separated using the Duncan Multiple Range Test
(DMRT). The results revealed that all the traits considered in this study showed significant
variation among the 23 different sesame genotypes which imply that high genetic diversity exists
among the 23 studied sesame accessions. Therefore, there is ample opportunity for sesame
breeders to develop improved varieties from the accessions considered in this study.
Keywords: Diversity, Sesame, Qualitative, Quantitative, Pod.
INTRODUCTION
The family Pedaliaceae, according to Zavareh et al. (2008) consists of 16 genera and about 60
species. Sesamum indicum (L.) like other plants that have been domesticated for a long time,
comprises many different varieties that differ considerably in size, form, growth habit, corolla
colour and seed characteristics such as size, colour and composition (Weiss, 2000). Tabatabaei et
al. (2011) reported that little is known about genetic variability of sesame in many possible hot
spot. One of these hot spots is postulated to be West Africa which includes Nigeria. Recently,
Ercan et al. (2002), Gidey et al. (2012), Kumar and Sharma (2011), Pham et al. (2010), Suhasini
(2006) and Tabatabaei et al. (2011) investigated the genetic diversity of sesame from Turkey,
78
79
Ethiopia, India, Viatem, Dharwad and Iran respectively using morphological markers. Olaoye
and Ishaq (2009) reported that information on genetic diversity among plant collections is
important in understanding the course of evolution in new varieties and in selecting desirable
parents for breeding. Therefore, accurate assessment of the extent of genetic diversity among
Nigerian sesame accessions will be useful for hybrid development. Alege and Mustapha (2013)
reported great genetic diversity among Nigerian sesame using proximate traits and recommended
the use of other markers like morphological study to substantiate the extent of genetic diversity
in Nigerian sesame. It is against this background that the present work was undertaken to assess
the genetic diversity among 23 sesame genotypes obtained from different locations across
Nigeria using morphological traits.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Twenty three accessions of sesame, comprising 18 traditional and 5 improved accessions were
collected from ten states in North-West, North-East, North-Central and South-West regions of
Nigeria between the months of September to November in 2008 when farmers were expected to
harvest the crop. Preliminary information on the plants was obtained from the farmers. A brief
description of the sesame accessions used for this study is shown in Table 1. Field trial was
conducted at the research garden of the Biological Sciences Department of Kogi State
University, Anyigba, Nigeria. The 23 sesame genotypes were laid out in Randomised Complete
Block Design (RCBD) with three replications for each genotype.
Thirteen qualitative, eighteen vegetative growth and eight reproductive yield (pod) attributes
were studied. The descriptions of qualitative traits studied were done according to the code of
International Plant Genetic Resources Institute (2004). All the linear measurements were carried
out according to the method of Akinyele and Adigun (2006). Weighing was carried out
according to Alege et al. (2011). Data pooled on the quantitative vegetative and yield
characteristics were then subjected to Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) and means were separated
using the Duncan Multiple Range Test (DMRT). The clustering of the 23 accessions was done
by average linkage method on the 18 vegetative growth and 8 reproductive yield traits using
SPSS V2 software.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
All the 23 sesame accessions grew developed well with virtually no clear differences between
their phenotypic appearance at the research site and their place of origin. However, qualitative
attributes like the habit of plant, shape and margins of the leaves on the upper and lower parts of
the plants are stable among the 23 different sesame genotypes studied. In contrary, leaves on the
middle part of the plants vary among the 23 sesame genotypes (table 2). This report is in
agreement with the findings of Robert (2002) who reported that sesame leaves vary widely in
shape and size, not only among different varieties, but also on the same plant. Traits like
hairiness of the stem, colour of the stem, maturity period and flower colour to some extent vary
among the 23 sesame samples. This indicates that each of the 23 sesame accessions is a distinct
genotype. The qualitative attributes considered in this study did not show much variation among
the 23 studied genotypes because qualitative traits are known to be controlled by single or few
genes with little or no environmental influence on their expressions (Elmund et al. 2004).
79
80
All the 18 quantitative (vegetative) traits studied showed significant differences among the 23
sesame genotypes using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) (table 3 and 4). This further revealed
that wide genetic diversity exists among the 23 sesame accessions for improvement. This report
agrees with the findings of Pham et al. (2010) who reported significant differences among 17
sesame varieties from different origins for all the morphological characters studied in Vietnam
and China. Also, Ozkan et al. (2012) reported significant variations in all the morphological
attributes studied on 12 local sesame genotypes from Kilis region in Turkey.
The number of loculi, number of stamens and numbers of styles were not analyzed statistically
(Table 5). The result shows that there are 4 loculi in each pod for all the accessions except
accession 19 which contains 6 loculi and all the studied sesame genotypes had 4 stamens and 1
style in their flowers. This indicates that the evolution of these attributes is along the same trend
and they are under strong genetic control in sesame. All the 8 yield characteristics showed
significant differences among the 23 sesame genotypes using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA)
(Table 5). Similarly Alege et al. (2011) reported the existence of genetic diversity among three
species of sesame for all the pod traits studied.
The sesame accessions studied were grouped into six diversity classes (table 6). Sesame
accessions in the same cluster are more closely related in terms of the 18 vegetative and 8 yield
characters analyzed than those accessions in different clusters. Clusters III and V were formed
by 2 accessions each while clusters I, II, IV and VI were formed by 11, 4, 3 and 1 accessions
respectively. Clusters V and VI comprised of the black seeded accessions (tables 1 and 5). The
clustering of the black seeded accessions 20 and 22 together in the same group is in conformity
with the earlier report of Alege and Mustapha (2013) for proximate composition of Nigerian
sesame. Also, the grouping of accessions 11, 12, 13 and 23 together was earlier reported by
Alege and Mustapha (2013) which further confirms their close genetic similarity This indicates
that sesame accessions from the same adaptation zones or geographical origins in Nigeria may be
closely related. Though the clustering of accessions 5, 6 and 8 together in this study contradicts
the report of Alege and Mustapha (2013) where the three accessions occupied separate groups
using proximate composition which indicates that genes controlling proximate traits differ from
those controlling morphological characters.
Generally, clustering of all the accessions reflects geographical affinity based on origin of the
accessions or place of collection (table 5) which is consistent with the report of Pham et al.
(2010) on sesame landraces from Turkey and Gidey et al. (2012) on sesame landraces from
Ethiopia. Varieties belonging to different clusters have maximum potential to generate variability
among progenies when used in crosses for the production of hybrid sesame. Gidey et al. (2012)
reported that crosses between parents with maximum genetic divergence would be more
responsive to improvement since they are likely to produce higher heterosis and desirable genetic
recombination among segregating populations.
CONCLUSION
There is high genetic diversity in Nigerian sesame to be considered for their improvement.
Accessions from different geographical origin may have different genetic background. The
genetic diversity reported in this study is therefore wide enough for the improvement of Nigerian
sesame.
80
81
REFERENCES
Akinyele, B.O and Adigun, A.B (2006). Soil texture and phenotypic expression of maize (Zea
mays L.). Res. J. Bot. 1(3):139 – 143.
Alege, G.O., Akinyele, B.O., Ayodele, S. M and Ogbode, A.V. (2011). Taxonomic importance
of the vegetative and pod characteristics in Nigerian species of sesame, African Journal of Plant
Science, 5 (3): 213-317.
Alege, G.O and Mustapha, O.T (2013) Assessment of Genetic Diversity in Nigerian Sesame
Using Proximate Analysis, Global Journal of Bio-science and Biotechnology, 2 (1): 57
62.
Elmund, W.S., Dunn, L.C and Dobzharisky, T. (2004). Principles of Genetics. 5th ed. Tata Mc
Graw Hill publishers,459pp.
Ercan, A.G., Taskin, M.K and Turgut, K. (2002). Analysis of genetic diversity in Turkish sesame
(Sesamum indicum L.) populations using RAPD markers. Genetic Resources Crop
Evolution, 51:599 – 601.
Gidey, Y.T and Kebede, S.A and Gashawbeza, G.T (2012) Extent and pattern of genetic diversity
for morpho-agronomic traits in Ethiopian sesame landraces (Sesamum indicum L.),
Asian Journal of Agricultural Research, 6 (3): 118-128.
IPGRI (2004). Descriptors for Sesame (Sesamum spp), International Plant Genetic Resources
Institute, Rome, Italy, 64Pp.
Kumar, M. A. and Sharma, P. (2011). Molecular and morphological characters: An appurtenance
for antagonism in Trichoderma spp., African Journal of Biotechnology, 10(22): 45324543.
Olaoye, G and Ishaq, M.N (2009) Multivariate Analyses of genetic diversity among local and
forein sugarcane germplasm accessions in Nigeria, Proceedings of the 33rd Annual
conference of Genetics Society of Nigeria, 29-34Pp.
Ozkan, A, Curat, D and Kulak, M. (2012). Morphological properties and chemical compositions of
some sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) populations cultivated in Kilis, Turkey, African
Journal of Agricultural Research, 7(19): 3029-3033.
Pham, T.D., Nguyen, T.T., Carlsson, A. S. and Bui, T. M. (2010) Morphological evaluation of
sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) varieties from different origins. Australian Journal of
Crop Science, 4(7): 498-504.
Robert, L.M. (2002). Sesame a high value oilseed: In Alternative crop guide, Published by the
Jefferson Institute, Columbia,78Pp.
Suhasini, K.S. (2006) Characterization of sesame genotypes through morphological, chemical and
RAPD markers, M sc. (Seed Science and Technology) thesis submitted to the
University of Agricultural Sciences, Dharwad, Indian.Pp83.
Tabatabaei, I, Pazouki, L, Bihamta, R. M, Mansoori, S, Javaran, M. J and Niinemets, U. (2011)
Genetic variation among Iranian sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) accessions vis-à-vis
exotic genotypes on the basis of morpho-physiological traits and RAPD markers,
Australian Journal of Crop Science, 5(11): 1396-1407.
81
82
Weiss, E.A. (2000). Oilseed crops. 2nd edition, Blackwell Science Ltd, Oxford 395Pp.
Zavareh, M., Hoogenboom, G., Mashhadi, R.H. and Arab, A. (2008). A decimal code to describe
the growth stages of sesame (Sesamum orientale L.). International Journal of Plant
Production, 2(3):193 – 206.
Table 1: Origin and brief description of the 23 Sesame accessions used for the study.
Acces
sion
Numb
ers
Accessio Sample Source
n Names s (States)
Geopolitical
Zones
Brief Morphological Description of Samples at their
Location
1
03M
Badeggi (Nige
r)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
2
E8
Badeggi
(Niger)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
3
01M
Badeggi
(Niger)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
4
02M
Badeggi
(Niger)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
5
EXSUD
AN
Badeggi
(Niger)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
6
IBA I
Ibadan (Oyo)
South West
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
dark brown seeds.
7
IBA II
Ibadan (Oyo)
South West
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
8
OKE I
Okene (Kogi)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
9
YOL I
Yola
(Adamawa)
North East
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
10
MAI I
Maiduguri
(Borno)
North East
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
dark brown seeds.
11
KAN III
Kano (Kano)
North West
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
white seeds.
12
KAN II
Kano (Kano)
North West
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
82
83
13
KAN I
Kano (Kano)
North West
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
14
MAK I
Makurdi
(Benue)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds.
15
OUT
Otukpo
(Benue)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds
16
ZAR I
Zaria (Kaduna) North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink with dark
brown seeds
17
ANY I
Anyigba
(Kogi)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds
18
ANY II
Anyigba
(Kogi)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
dark brown seeds
19
OKE II
Okene (Kogi)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, whitish pink flower with
dark brown seeds
20
ILO I
Ilorin (Kwara)
North
Central
Erect purple stem, branched, purple flower with black
seeds.
21
ILO II
Ilorin (Kwara)
North
Central
Erect purple stem, profusely branched, pink flower,
black seeds
22
OFF I
Offa (Kwara)
North
Central
Erect green stem, branched, pink flower, black seeds
23
JAL I
Jalingo
(Taraba)
North East
Erect greenstem, branched, whitish pink flower with
light brown seeds
83
84
Table 2: Qualitative Attributes of the 23 Sesame Accessions.
Accession Plant
Numbers habit
Branching
Pattern
Hairness
Of the
stem
1
Erect
Opposite
Absent
2
Erect
Opposite
Medium
3
Erect
Opposite
Sparce
4
Erect
Opposite
Medium
5
Erect
Opposite
Medium
6
Erect
Opposite
Sparce
7
Erect
Opposite
Medium
8
Erect
Opposite
Medium
9
Erect
Opposite
Sparce
10
Erect
Opposite
Medium
11
Erect
Opposite
Medium
12
Erect
Opposite
Medium
13
Erect
Opposite
Medium
14
Erect
Opposite
Medium
15
Erect
Opposite
Sparce
16
Erect
Opposite
Sparce
17
Erect
Opposite
Sparce
18
Erect
Opposite
Sparce
19
Erect
Opposite
Medium
20
Erect
Opposite
Profuse
21
Erect
Opposite
Profuse
22
Erect
Opposite
Medium
23
Erect
Opposite
Medium
KEY FOR THE QUALITATVE ATTRIBUTES :
Stem
colour
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Green
Purple
Green
Green
Green
Upper
leaf shape
and margin
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
LE
OS
OS
LE
OS-OVATE SHAPE DLEAF WITH SERRATED MARGINS
ENTIRE MARGINS SERRATED MARGIN AND WEAKLY LOBED
Middle leaf
shape
And margin
OSSL
OSSL
OSSL
OSWL
OSSL
OSSL
OSSL
OSWL
OSWL
OSWL
OSWL
OSWL
OSSL
OS(NO LOBED)
OSSL
OS(NO LOBED)
OS(NO LOBED)
OS(NO LOBED)
OS(NO LOBED)
OSWL
OS(NO LOBED)
OS(NO LOBED)
OSWL
Lower
leaf shape
And margin
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
OS(LOBED)
Maturity
Period
(days)
64
61
66
58
64
91
89
66
71
78
56
62
54
62
90
65
64
68
61
74
71
83
65
Flower
Colour
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
Purple
Pink
Whitish pink
Whitish pink
LE-LINEAR SHAPED LEAF WITH
84
85
TABLE 3: Some Quantitative Vegetative Traits for the 23 Studied Sesame Genotypes.
AC.N
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
SED
PHP
NLP
NBP
NSB
SGP
93.24 bcd
34.80 a
5.40 abc
2.40 a
2.34 bcd
86.24 bc
49.80 ab
3.60 abc
4.60 a
3.06 cd
bcdef
ab
abc
a
99.34
64.20
6.40
2.20
2.66 bcd
bcdef
ab
abc
a
98.50
48.80
5.20
2.00
3.12 d
bc
ab
abc
a
88.70
45.00
3.60
0.20
2.70 bcd
b
ab
abc
a
83.94
48.40
4.80
2.00
2.32 bcd
fg
b
cd
a
111.22
68.20
7.80
5.00
2.26 bc
bcdef
ab
bc
a
96.82
42.80
6.80
0.40
2.20 b
efg
ab
abc
a
109.10
65.00
5.60
0.60
2.54 bcd
bcd
ab
abc
a
91.90
48.60
4.40
0.60
2.18 b
bcdef
ab
a
a
98.66
49.00
2.40
1.20
2.72 bcd
bcd
ab
ab
a
92.80
40.60
2.80
1.20
2.48 bcd
bcdef
ab
a
a
96.16
50.80
2.40
1.80
2.50 bcd
bcde
ab
de
a
94.26
55.40
11.00
1.60
1.36 a
bcdef
b
bc
a
96.58
68.40
6.80
5.00
2.36 bcd
bc
ab
ab
a
88.68
47.60
3.00
1.00
2.10 abc
119.12g
51.00 ab
4.00 abc
5.20 a
2.28 bc
cdef
ab
abc
a
101.48
37.60
3.60
2.40
1.90 ab
bc
ab
ab
a
88.72
48.20
2.80
1.20
2.18 b
b
c
e
a
83.88
121.40
13.20
7.20
2.44 bcd
a
c
abc
c
66.00
146.60
7.80
24.40
2.54 bcd
bc
c
abc
b
87.26
146.60
7.80
15.40
2.06 ab
def
ab
abc
a
104.80
49.40
3.80
4.80
2.10 ab
0.96
1.96
0.26
0.59
0.05
SED- Standard Error of Deviation, AC.N-Accession numbers.
NNP
9.60 abc
9.40 abc
11.20 bcd
10.20 bcd
12.00 bcde
10.80 bcd
12.40 bcde
11.00 bcd
13.20 cde
11.80 bcde
10.60 bcd
10.60 bcd
10.80 bcd
14.40 de
14.00 de
6.00 a
15.40 e
8.20 ab
11.80 bcde
11.60 bcde
10.60 bcd
8.80 ab
8.80ab
0.26
LNP
12.04 defg
10.86 cdef
13.54 fg
15.56 g
12.74 efg
11.78 def
11.54 cdef
10.18 abcdef
9.42 abcde
10.82 cdef
13.62 fg
13.74 fg
10.90 cdef
10.90 cdef
11.82 def
8.66 abcd
9.16 abcde
7.66 abc
10.46 bcdef
6.74 ab
6.46 a
6.25 a
11.40 cdef
0.24
85
RLP
15.58 ab
19.34 abc
16.28 ab
20.32 abc
15.64 ab
17.40 ab
17.46 ab
20.90 bcd
16.92 ab
17.64 ab
16.84 ab
17.18 ab
18.42 abc
23.40 cd
19.46 abc
15.16 ab
19.98 abc
14.70 a
18.70 abc
25.94 d
23.62 cd
14.86 a
16.98 ab
0.35
FPH
166.86 i
173.38 i
167.78 i
167.58 i
159.14 i
112.26 bcde
121.16 cdefg
142.20 g
138.12 gh
121.30 cdefg
126.60 defgh
122.80 cdefg
132.50 fgh
108.08 bcd
106.68 bc
133.54 gh
126.30 efgh
108.46 bcd
100.32 b
114.46 bcdef
70.64 a
111.34 bcde
119.26 cdefg
8.89
Mean values with different
superscripts in the same
column are significantly
different from one another at
P<0.05
KEY: NNP-Number of
nodes, PHP-Plant height,
SGP-Stem girth, NSBNumber of secondary
branches, FPH-Final plant
height
LNP-Length
of internodes, NLP-Number
of leaves, RLP-Root length,
NBP-Number of secondary
branches
86
TABLE 4: Quantitative Vegetative Leaf Traits for the 23 Studied Sesame Genotypes.
AC.N
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
SIG.
BLL
7.16 bc
7.44 bc
7.34 bc
7.68 bc
7.70 bc
7.70 bc
10.00 de
7.24 bc
7.96 bc
8.42 cd
6.38 bc
7.12 bc
7.48 bc
8.12 cd
11.04 e
5.92 b
7.32 bc
7.58 bc
6.44 bc
6.98 bc
3.94 a
8.38 cd
6.48 bc
0.13
MLL
9.42 abcde
15.34 g
11.90 cdef
11.48 cdef
12.02 cdef
8.82 abc
12.58 efg
8.96 abc
12.04 cdef
12.44 defg
11.34 cdef
12.10 cdef
12.20 cdefg
8.92 abc
14.40 fg
9.18 abcd
10.12 bcde
11.58 cdef
12.02 cdef
10.06 bcde
6.76 a
7.16 ab
12.58 efg
0.21
TLL
8.34 efgh
8.72 fgh
9.38 h
9.32 gh
7.86 defgh
7.10 bcde
6.12 b
8.30 efgh
7.10 bcde
8.16 efgh
7.76 cdefg
6.94 bcdef
7.00 bcde
6.40 bcd
6.20 bc
7.24 bcdef
8.80 bcde
7.08 bcde
6.34 bcd
6.18 bc
3.20 a
7.20 bcdef
8.78 fgh
0.10
BLB
4.34 abc
5.10 c
4.82 abc
5.00 bc
5.20 c
5.22 c
7.34 d
4.38 abc
5.32 c
5.08 bc
4.32 abc
3.96 abc
4.40 abc
5.00 bc
7.84 d
3.52 ab
4.64 abc
4.38 abc
3.90 abc
4.50 abc
3.22 a
4.94 bc
3.90 abc
0.09
MLB
7.02 cdefg
8.34 fg
7.28 defg
8.90 g
7.40 efg
5.04 abc
6.84 bcdefg
5.98 abcde
5.40 abcde
6.86 bcdefg
7.48 efg
7.48 efg
8.42 fg
6.12 abcde
6.48 abcdef
4.58 a
6.50 abcdef
5.14 abcd
5.64 abcde
5.96 abcde
5.18 abcd
4.84 ab
7.38 efg
0.13
TLB
2.20 de
1.98 bcd
2.16 de
2.10 cde
1.74 abcd
1.84 abcd
1.68 abcd
2.14 de
1.20 a
2.26 de
1.70 abcd
2.06 cde
1.82 abcd
1.38 ab
1.94 bcd
2.30 de
1.74 abcd
1.68 abcd
1.46 abc
1.38 ab
2.60 e
2.34 de
1.94 bcd
0.04
BLA
31.50 abc
38.73 bc
35.97 dc
38.73 bc
40.20 bc
41.92 bc
74.26 d
33.31abc
44.17c
46.09c
28.11bcd
28.35 abc
33.07abc
42.69bc
86.61d
12.12 ab
34.44abc
33.96 abc
25.29 abc
33.07 abc
13.78 a
42.77 bc
26.35 abc
2.58
MLA
66.90 abcd
130.16e
86.23 bcd
102.83de
95.30 cde
44.52 a
86.52 bcd
54.26 abc
65.47 abcd
89.64 bcd
86.44 bcd
92.59 bcde
86.64 bcd
52.29 ab
93.26 bcde
43.22 a
66.23 abcd
60.00 abc
66.99 abcd
60.05 abc
35.44 a
34.41a
93.20 bcde
1.36
TLA
18.34def
17.35bcdef
20.28e
19.63ef
13.70abcde
11.50ab
10.08a
17.75cdef
8.55 a
18.48def
18.48def
14.64abcdef
12.81abcd
9.31 a
12.12abc
16.86bcdef
14.50abcdef
12.06abc
9.28 a
8.64 a
10.17a
16.78bcdef
17.48bcdef
0.38
Mean values with
different superscripts
in the same column are
significantly different
from one another at
P<0.05
KEY
MLB-Middle leaf
breadth, BLA-Basal
leaf area, TLA-Terminal leaf area, MLL- Middle leaf length, TLL-Terminal leaf length,
MLA-Middle leaf area, BLB-Basal leaf breadths, TLB-Terminal leaf breadth, BLL-Basal leaf length, SED- Standard Error of
Deviation, AC.N-Accession numbers.
86
87
TABLE 5: Means for the Quantitative Yield Characters in 23 Sesame Accessions.
ACCESSION NO.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
SED
PV
95.14fg
75.80b
97.20fg
97.04fg
98.60g
79.36bcd
96.60fg
96.46fg
88.86defg
90.58efg
82.26bcde
88.86defg
92.16efg
63.34a
88.34defg
87.48def
88.08defg
91.64efg
92.92efg
88.60defg
86.90cdef
91.98efg
77.18bc
0.67
PN
39.20efgh
38.60efg
42.00fghi
43.40fghi
49.00ghi
54.20i
52.40hi
26.40bcde
22.20abcd
13.20ab
28.20cde
25.80bcde
33.60def
21.60abcd
48.40ghi
16.40abc
21.20abcd
15.40abc
23.20abcd
50.80ghi
9.60 a
18.20abc
28.00cde
0.87
PL
2.02 b
2.44 bcdef
2.70 def
2.72 def
2.82 ef
2.34 bcd
2.88 f
2.68 def
2.50 cdef
2.76 def
2.86 f
2.46 bcdef
2.62 def
2.88 f
2.34 bcd
2.46 bcdef
2.54 def
2.40 bcde
2.62 def
2.36 bcd
1.32 a
2.06 bc
2.72 def
0.03
PG
2.08 abc
2.42 defg
2.62 ghij
2.56 fghi
2.70 ghij
2.12 abcd
2.66 ghij
2.46 efg
2.28 cdef
2.86 ji
2.94 jk
2.56 fghi
2.82 hij
3.22 k
1.92 ab
2.62 ghij
2.62 ghij
2.40 defg
2.50 efgh
2.12 abcd
1.84 a
2.22 bcde
2.44 defg
0.021
NS
57.80abc
62.20abcdef
76.60fgh
80.20h
76.20fgh
76.00fgh
68.20bcdefgh
77.60gh
65.40bcdefg
63.60abcdefg
73.60defgh
68.20bcdefgh
69.80cdefgh
78.00i
116.60 gh
72.20cdefgh
59.40abcd
55.20ab
60.60abcde
71.40cdefgh
50.40a
55.00ab
75.00efgh
0.90
SL
1.36bcd
1.38bcde
1.40cdefg
1.51i
1.59j
1.33b
1.45gh
1.34bc
1.35bc
1.25a
1.41defg
1.39cdef
1.35bc
1.58j
1.25a
1.35bc
1.43efg
1.44fgh
1.33b
1.45gh
1.49hi
1.33b
1.43efg
0.10
LS
1.28abc
1.33 abc
1.37bc
1.37bc
1.37bc
1.28abc
1.22ab
1.28abc
1.29abc
1.34bc
1.18a
1.40c
1.37bc
1.34bc
1.32abc
1.23ab
1.18a
1.35bc
1.28abd
1.56d
1.37bc
1.37bc
1.30abc
0.004
100SW
1.428hij
1.396efgh
1.402efghi
1.398efgh
1.458jk
1.396efgh
1.432hij
1.346bcd
1.348bcd
1.408efghi
1.442ij
1.384defg
1.380def
1.430hij
1.344bcd
1.424ghij
1.416fghi
1.370cde
1.492k
1.326b
1.270a
1.378cdef
1.338bc
0.01
Mean values with different superscripts in the same column are significantly different from one another at P<0.05
KEY
PV-POLLEN VIABILITY,
NS-NUMBER OF SEEDS
PN-POD UMBER
SL-STYLE LENGTH
PL-POD LENGTH
LS-LENGTH OF STAMENS
PG-POD GIRTH
100SW-WEIGTH OF 100 SEEDS
87
NO OF
LOCULI
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
6
4
4
4
4
NO OF
STAMENS
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
NO OF STYLE
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
88
Table 6: Grouping of the 23 sesame accessions into diversity classes.
Cluster
I
II
III
IV
V
VI
Number of Accessions
Genotypes
11
7 (IBAII), 9 (YOLI), 11 (KANI), 12 (KANI), 13 (KANI), 14 (MAKI),
15 (OTU), 17 (ANYI), 18 (ANYII), 19 (OKEII), 23 (JALI),
4
2 (E8), 3(01M), 10 (MAI), 16 (ZARI)
2
1 (03M), 4 (02M),
3
5 (EXSUDAN), 6 (IBAI), 8 OKEI),
2
20 (ILOI), 22 (OFFI),
1
21 (ILOII),
PGB22
PHYSICO-CHEMICAL AND PASTING PROPERTIES OF TUBERS IN SOME LESSER
KNOWN YAMS
Obidiegwu, J. E.1, Njoku, D.N.1*, Chilaka, C.A.1 and Asiedu, R.2
1
National Root Crops Research Institute (NRCRI), Umudike, PMB 7006 Umuahia, Abia State.
2
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) Ibadan, Nigeria
Corresponding e-mail: njokudn2012@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Yam (Dioscorea spp.) serves as one of the major staple food in West Africa. The variation in
physicochemical and pasting properties of yam species: Dioscorea bulbifera (8 varieties), D.
cayenesis (7 varieties), D. dumetorum (5 varieties) and D. esculenta (7 varieties) were
determined. Yam tubers were sampled from different yam growing regions in West Africa and
processed into flour for physicochemical analysis including mineral content, dry moisture
content, sugar, amylose, and starch and pasting properties. Results on the mineral content
showed that potassium (7983.50-31812.68mg/100g) was the most abundant while cobalt (0.010.88mg/100g) was the least abundant. Starch content ranged from 77.8% (D. bulbifera) to
58.37% (D. esculenta). Amylose value ranged between 24.71% (D. cayenensis) and 13.96% (D.
dumetorum). Peak viscosity ranged for 19.08-401.04RVU in the four species with D. cayenesis
having the highest mean (241.54±56.37 RVU) while D. esculenta had the least (43.02±8.04
RVU). A corresponding variation in trough (15.55-164.42 RVU) and final viscosity (26.34529.71 RVU) was observed in the studied species with D. cayenesis showing highest trough
(109.02±12.97 RVU) and final viscosity mean values (296.94±68.37 RVU) while D. esculenta
had the least trough and final viscosity mean value of 28.85±10.90 RVU and 42.27±9.37 RVU,
respectively. This study gives an insight in the extent of intra and interspecific variation in
respect to physicochemical and pasting potential of yam flours thus providing scope for
improvement through breeding
Keywords: Breeding, Physicochemical, Pasting, Yam
88
89
INTRODUCTION
Yams (Dioscorea spp.) are a major staple food source for millions of people in the tropics
especially in West and Central Africa where at least 60 million people depend on it (Hahn,
1995). Yams are also regarded as a major source of income and forms an integral part of sociocultural life of the people (Asiedu and Sartie, 2010). Yams constitute an important source of food
and income and play a major role in sociocultural life of a wide range of smallholder households.
They bring flexibility to the annual cycle of food availability through several species and
cultivars. The tubers have organoleptic qualities that make them preferred carbohydrate food
where yams are contributing up to 350 dietary calories per person each day for millions of people
in the major producing countries (Degras, 1993)
Yams fulfill a number of basic roles in the global food system, all of which have fundamental
implications for meeting food requirements, increasing food security, and reducing poverty. Lack
of information on the physico-chemical characteristics of the starches hinders utilization. Among
the priority breeding objectives are tubers with acceptable quality, i.e. appropriate dry matter
content, a good cooking texture, taste, and no oxidation (rate of enzymatic browning). The uses
of starches are determined by their physical and chemical characteristics, which also vary
between varieties. Physicochemical properties of yams significantly differ among genotypes
(Lebot et al., 2005). Identification of physico-chemical variation within germplasm is essential
for accelerated breeding for nutritional enhancement. Plant breeding can significantly improve
the diet of the rural population through the development and distribution of varieties of yams
which contain elevated levels of micronutrients. This may be a cost effective and sustainable
approach to alleviating nutrient deficiencies (Boius, 2002).
We aim to study the intra and interspecific variation of the physicochemical and pasting potential
of yam flours from species D. bulbifera, D. cayenesis, D. dumetorum and D. esculenta.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Four species of yam - D. bulbifera (8 varieties), D. cayenesis (7 varieties), D. dumetorum (5
varieties) and D. esculenta (7 varieties) were used for this study (Table 1). A total of twentyseven yam varieties were obtained from International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA),
Ibadan. The cultivars were originally collected different yam growing regions in West Africa
(Table 1)
Yam tubers were peeled and diced into cubes and dried in an oven drier (Fisher Scientific Co.
USA) at 50ºC for 72hours and then ground in a Kenwood portable mill into fine flour (250µm
mesh size) and stored in airtight sample bags for further analysis. The moisture content of the
samples were determined using AOAC (2005) method. In the study, iron (Fe), zinc (Zn),
calcium (Ca), manganese (Mn), copper (Cu), phosphorus (P), sodium (Na), magnesium (Mg),
potassium (K), aluminum (Al), molybdenum (Mo), cobalt (Co), cadmium (Cd), nickel (Ni), lead
(Pb) and selenium (Se) were determined using ICP-ES (2005). Reading was taken using an
‘’Inductively Coupled Plasma Atomic Emission Spectrometry (ICPAES) (Switzerland by ARL
model 3580 B).
The free sugars and starch content of the samples were determined as described by Dubois et al.
(1956). Hot ethanol was used for extraction from the sample and then centrifuged using Sorvall
89
90
centrifuge (Newtown, Conneticut, USA, model GLC-1). The supernatant was collected and used
for free sugar analysis, while the residue was used for starch analysis. To the supernatant made
up with distilled water, an aliquot was takenin which 5% phenol and concentrated sulphuric acid
was added. The sample was allowed to cool and the absorbance read on a spectrophotometer
(Milton Roy Company, USA), model spectronic 601 at 490nm wavelength. While for the starch
analysis, the residue was added perchloric acid and allowed to hydrolyze. It was diluted with
distilled water and filtered and the filtrate was made up to with distilled water, vortexed and
ready for color development as was described for standard glucose curve preparation. This was
determined using the method of Williams et al. (1970) was used. Absorbance (A) was read using
a Spectrophotometer at 620nm wavelength. A blank was used to standardize the
spectrophotometer at 620nm.
Pasting properties of the samples were determined with a Rapid Visco Analyser 3 C (RVA,
model 3C, Newport Scientific PTY Ltd, Sydney, Australia) according to Ross et al. (1987) and
Walker et al. (1988). Three grams (3.0g) of sample were weighed and mixed with 25ml of
distilled water in a test canister. The slurry was heated from 50 °C to 95 °C with a holding time
of 2 minutes followed by cooling to 50 °C with 2 min holding time. The rate of heating and
cooling were at a constant rate of 11.25°C/min. Peak viscosity, trough, breakdown, final
viscosity, set back, peak time, and pasting temperature were read from the pasting profile with
the aid of Thermocline for Windows Software connected to a computer (Newport Scientific,
1998).
RESULTS AND DICUSSION
The value of the minerals in the yam samples are presented in Table 2. Potassium (7983.5031812.68mg/100g) was the most abundant while cobalt (0.01-1.94mg/100g) was the least
abundant of the minerals determined. Magnesium (653-1578.54 mg/100g), calcium (72.621095.7mg/100g) and phosphorous (216.75-506.93mg/100g) were also observed to be high in the
yam samples when compared with the rest of the minerals analysed. In addition, it is worth
knowing that D. bulbifera (accession: TDb 3058) had the highest potassium, magnesium, iron
and sodium content in this study.
Table 3 shows that sugar content ranged between 1.76% for D. cayenesis (variety: TDc 2809)
and 7.2% for D. esculenta (variety: TDe 3036).
Starch content ranged from 77.8% (D.
bulbifera) to 58.37% (D. esculenta). Amylose value ranged between 24.71% (D. cayenensis) and
13.96% (D. dumetorum). Peak viscosity ranged for 19.08-401.04RVU in the four species with
D. cayenesis having the highest mean (241.54±56.37 RVU) while D. esculenta had the least
(43.02±8.04 RVU). A corresponding variation in trough (15.55-164.42 RVU) and final viscosity
(26.34-529.71 RVU) was observed in the studied species with D. cayenesis showing highest
trough (109.02±12.97 RVU) and final viscosity mean values (296.94±68.37 RVU) while D.
esculenta had the least trough and final viscosity mean value of 28.85±10.90 RVU and
42.27±9.37 RVU, respectively ( Table 3).
The high moisture content could be the possible reason yam tubers are prone to microbial attack
in the storage which often result to high postharvest losses. Similar range of moisture content has
been reported by Osagie (1992). Similar results on the abundance of potassium in yam have been
previously reported (Alinnor and Akalez, 2010; Kouassi et al. 2010; Senanayake et al. 2012).
90
91
Potassium plays an essential role in electrolyte regulation, nerve function, muscle control and
blood pressure in the human body. Bellows and Moore (2013) reported adequate intake of
potassium per day is 4,700 mg for males and females age fourteen through adulthood as well as
pregnant women. This study revealed that yam consumption may reduce the risk of potassium
deficiency in individuals.
Comparable sugar content in yam has been reported (Maziya-Dixon and Asiedu, 2003; Lebot et
al. 2005). The high starch content is one of the major properties that influence the suitability of
yam for different products because of its effects the textural, rheological and physiochemical
characteristics of the final product. Our observation in starch agrees with the findings of Tamiru
et al. (2008). Efforts will be made in future studies in understanding the nature of starch granule
size and molar masses. The amylose content we observed is in agreement with previous studies
of Farhat et al. (1999) and Amani et al. (2004). Consideration of amylose content during
breeding is important because it imparts definite characteristics to starch (Moorthy, 1994). It is a
very important parameter that influences starch pasting and retrogradation behaviour
(Zhenghong et al. 2003).
Higher viscosities of paste obtained in D. cayenensis suggest that they can form thick paste on
cooking. This can be attributed to higher swelling potentials of the starches as reported by
Otegbayo et al. (2006). D. cayenesis forms a complex with D. rotundata the most preferred
cultivar for pounded yam. Other species exhibited lower viscosity suggesting higher internal
bonding between the starch granules. D. cayenesis showed highest breakdown values in
viscosity. This suggest that there is less granule rupture for the starches as reported by Otegbayo
et al. (2006). The variations in the physicochemical and functional properties reveal that there is
scope for improvement in the long term by breeding.
REFERENCES
Alinnor I J , Akalezi CO (2010). Proximate and Mineral Compositions of Dioscorea rotundata
(White Yam) and Colocasia esculenta (White Cocoyam). Pakistan Journal of Nutrition 9
(10): 998-1001, 2010.
Amani NG, Buléon A, Kamenan A, Colonna P (2004). Variability in starch physicochemical and
functional properties of yam (Dioscorea sp) cultivated in Ivory Coast. Journal of the
Science of Food and Agriculture. 84: 2085-2096.
AOAC (2005). Official Methods of Analysis of the Association of Official Analytical chemists.
25th edition. The Association: Arlington, VA.
Asiedu R, Sartie A (2010). Crops that feed the world 1. Yams for income and food security.
Food Security 2: 305-315
Bouis, EH (2002) Plant breeding: A new tool for fighting micronutrient malnutrition. Journal of
nutrition. 132: 491-494.
Bellows L, Moore R (2013). Potassium and the Diet. Food and Nutrition Series. Fact Sheet No.
9.355.
Degras L (1993). The yam: a tropical root crop. The Macmillan Press Ltd, London.
Dubois, M. Gilles, K. A. Hamilton, J. K. Rebers, P.A. and Smith, F. (1956) Colorimetric method
for determination of sugars and related substances. Analytical Chemistry. 28: 350-356.
91
92
Farhat IA, Oguntona T, Neale RJ (1999). Characterisation of starches from West African yams.
Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture. 79 : 2105-2112.
Hahn SK (1995) Yams: Dioscorea spp (Dioscoreaceae). In: Smartt J, Simmonds NW (eds)
Evolution of crop plants, Longman Scientific and Technical Essex, pp 112-120.
Kouassi NK, Nindjin C, Tetchi AF, Amani GN (2010). Evaluation of Type of Process on
Functional Properties and on Nutritional and Anti-nutritional Composition of Yam
(Dioscorea cayenensis-rotundata). Journal of Food Technology. 8(4): 191-199.
Lebot V, Malapa R, Molisale T, Marchand JL (2005) Physio-chemical characterization of yam
(Dioscorea alata L.) tubers from Vanatu. Genetic Resource and Crop Evolution. 00:1
10.
Maziya-Dixon B, Asiedu R (2003). Characteirsation of physicochemical and pasting properties
of yam varieties- Project A Annual Report, International Institute of Tropical Agriculture
(IITA), Ibadan, Nigeria.
Moorthy, S. N. (2002). Physicochemical and functional properties of tropical tuber starches.
Starch.54:559-592.
Osagie AU (1992). The yam tuber in storage. Post-harvest research unit, University of Benin,
Nigeria pp. 107-173
Otegbayo B, Aina J, Asiedu R, Bokanga M (2006). Pasting characteristics of fresh yams
(Dioscorea spp.) as indicators of textural quality in a major food product- pounded yam.
Food Chemistry 99:663-669
Ross AS, Walker CE, Booth RI, Orth RA, Wrigley CW (1987) The Rapid Visco Analyzer: A
new technique for the estimation of sprout damage. Cereals Food World 32, 827 – 829.
Senanayake SA, Ranaweera KKDS, Bamunuarachchi A, Gunaratne A (2012). Proximate
analysis and phytochemical and mineral constituents in four cultivars of yams and tuber
Crops in Sri Lanka. Tropical Agricultural Research and Extension 15(1): 32-36.
Tamiru, M, Maass BL, Pawelzik Elke (2008). Characterizing diversity in composition and
pasting properties of tuber flour in yam germplasm (Dioscorea spp.) from Southern
Ethiopia. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture. 88:1675-1685
Walker CE, Ross AS, Wrigley CW, McMaster GJ (1988). Accelerated starch paste
characterization with the rapid visco analyzer. Cereals Food World. 33: 491 – 194.
Williams PC, Kuzina FD, Hlynka I (1970). A rapid colorimetric procedure for estimating the
amylose content of starches and flours. Cereal Chemistry. 47 (4): 411.
Zhenghong C, Schols HA, Voragen AGJ (2003). Physicochemical properties of starches
obtained from three different varieties of Chinese sweet potatoes. Journal of Food
Science 68: 431-437.
92
93
Table 1. D. bulbifera, D. cayenesis, D. dumetorum and D. esculenta species and their varieties
source and year of collection
Varieties
Source country
Year
D. bulbifera
3697
1455
3079
3046
3048
3029
4120
3085
TDb
TDb
TDb
TDb
TDb
TDb
TDb
TDb
Congo
Gabon
Ghana
Nigeria
Benin
Togo
Sierra Leone
Nigeria
1994
1992
1992
2003
1997
2002
2004
1992
2817
2790
2809
3839
2815
3935
3093
D. dumetorum
3779
4118
3100
3907
3778
D. esculenta
4149
3035
3033
3041
3039
2786
3036
TDc
TDc
TDc
TDc
TDc
TDc
TDc
CotedIvoire
Togo
Benin
Nigeria
Nigeria
Benin
Togo
1992
1997
1992
2004
1992
1994
1993
TDd
TDd
TDd
TDd
TDd
Nigeria
Togo
Togo
Nigeria
Nigeria
2002
2004
1993
2004
1998
TDe
TDe
TDe
TDe
TDe
TDe
TDe
Guinea
CotedIvoire
Togo
Togo
Togo
Nigeria
Ghana
2004
1993
1993
1993
1993
2004
2002
D. cayenesis
93
94
Table 2: Mineral contents (mg/100g) of the yam flours
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Accession
TDb 4120
TDb 3029
TDb 3048
TDb 3697
TDb 3079
TDb 3046
TDb 3085
TDb 1455
TDc 2817
TDc 2815
TDc 2809
TDc 2790
TDc 3839
TDc 3935
TDc 3093
TDd 3100
TDd 3779
TDd 4118
TDd 3907
TDd 3778
TDe 3041
TDe 3033
TDe 3039
TDe 3036
TDe 2786
TDe 3035
TDe 4149
Mean
Max
Min
Std
Al
1.27
6.83
1.87
0.58
0.74
5.81
1.45
0.21
2.44
1.63
2.54
8.18
5.74
1.68
1.31
2.66
1.39
0.56
1.8
1.63
1.85
2.03
0.85
0.06
1.67
0.2
2.31
2.20
8.18
0.06
2.05
Fe
23.65
27.16
17.63
23.94
19.34
35.25
35.49
29.4
13.15
15.32
17.06
11.61
8.46
25.83
19.71
15.9
19.75
17.64
25.24
15.14
19.77
19.88
21.5
24.22
18.22
17.72
21.96
20.74
35.49
8.46
6.36
Zn
12.28
14.78
9.56
29.98
8.82
20.01
20.77
25.6
11.14
11.96
11
9.76
11.62
17.34
19.76
12.41
16.25
21.65
16.43
18.58
15.55
15.42
17.66
19.81
14.19
12.93
14.46
15.92
29.98
8.82
5.03
Ca
504.14
638.44
196.52
263.15
254.69
339.24
490.93
456
72.62
362.33
189.71
171.26
324.26
1036.01
392.24
530.27
235.4
565.77
1019.95
1095.7
286.84
332.53
343.7
659.74
236.92
295.05
303.2
429.50
1095.7
72.62
265.36
Cd
0.1
1.21
0.07
0.15
0.01
0.1
0.14
0.17
0.1
0.1
0.08
0.13
0.21
0.11
0.14
0.07
0.12
0.07
0.02
0.06
0.17
0.18
0.1
0.06
0.05
0.12
0.08
0.15
1.21
0.01
0.22
Co
0.23
0.25
0.06
0.17
0.01
0.26
0.14
0.02
0.13
0.19
0.29
0.01
0.33
0.17
0.06
0.09
0.24
0.33
0.13
0.28
0.05
0.88
0.01
0.55
0.02
0.25
0.14
0.20
0.88
0.01
0.19
Cu
6.12
4.52
8.58
9.81
4.04
12.21
12.17
7.12
6.39
5.38
3.95
0.59
9.29
5.38
2.8
1.79
7.37
8.03
4.6
6.89
4.71
5.95
4.56
6.18
2.4
4.17
3.69
5.88
12.21
0.59
2.86
K
17497.92
14770.2
22934.78
22318.8
26924.54
26771.48
31812.68
28996
12633.86
14169.24
11350.48
7983.5
8459.19
11836.68
12517.53
9901.75
16442.45
11590.8
11029.44
9947.26
14239.73
14228.83
16547.61
13493.4
11656.54
9834.31
10672.49
15576.35
31812.68
7983.5
6634.34
Mg
852.69
950.87
736.95
823.98
653
1122.54
1578.54
1376
906.13
1311.08
1024.34
722.81
705.11
1240.26
861.65
937.4
1005.72
1366.86
1212.7
1173.04
1014.45
1102.6
1125.19
1036.12
945.76
923.74
1022.35
1027.11
1578.54
653
224.76
Mn
2.06
3.16
1.29
1.74
1.09
6.57
4.43
1.4
0.27
0.47
0.55
0.5
5.17
1.66
2.16
1.46
1.96
0.69
7.92
3.5
1.51
1.13
2.09
2.98
2.15
1.9
2.27
2.30
7.92
0.27
1.85
Mo
1.3
0.78
0.02
0.65
0.05
0.14
0.39
0.31
0.05
0.35
0.84
0.79
0.64
0.29
0.74
1.22
0.8
0.59
1.29
8.12
0.27
0.12
0.33
2.27
0.24
0.18
0.48
0.86
8.12
0.02
1.53
Na
20.95
55.24
55.86
42.7
37.53
89.76
162.57
84.6
61.34
147.55
107.71
29.95
39.6
106.8
154.75
72.62
45.21
102.63
108.95
125.03
52
45.5
43.77
58.61
37.59
36.08
40.03
72.78
162.57
20.95
40.78
Ni
0.06
1.68
0.04
0.03
0.86
0.71
0.01
0.12
0.77
0.45
0.59
0.3
0.7
0.03
0.11
1.27
1.21
1.01
0.01
0.85
1.01
0.27
0.16
0.49
0.65
0.62
0.15
0.52
1.68
0.01
0.46
P
394.19
387.14
334.78
435.72
340.86
384.98
483.38
444
329.5
348.03
415.7
371.17
216.75
506.93
422.25
462.41
427.5
368
404.23
315.82
454.75
374.09
430.1
501.83
370.08
313.2
404.27
394.14
506.93
216.75
64.40
Pb
2.42
27.84
0.61
0.34
1.69
0.65
1.21
0.01
0.46
1.09
1.99
1.12
71.16
0.15
2.18
1.6
1.97
2.77
0.73
2.38
1.17
1.29
0.12
2.4
0.44
0.48
1.39
4.80
71.16
0.01
14.24
Se
0.8
3.0
2.5
1.3
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.7
0.1
0.7
1.2
3.8
5.6
0.6
0.0
0.8
0.3
0.9
1.1
2.1
1.2
0.8
0.8
0.2
0.3
0.6
0.5
1.2
5.6
0.0
1.2
Table 3: Mean proximate and pasting characteristics of dried yam flour
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Accession
TDb 4120
TDb 3029
TDb 3048
TDb 3697
TDb 3079
TDb 3046
TDb 3085
TDb 1455
%
MC
7.62
7.52
7.59
7.8
7.82
7.43
7.53
7.85
%Sugar
5.8
7.03
5.16
6.06
6.99
4.22
3.9
5.69
%
Starch
63.4
69.42
60.61
68.55
74.61
70.97
77.8
65.59
% Amylose
21.99
22.77
23.22
22.38
21.46
23.49
23.69
19.55
Peak 1
110.2
112.79
90.42
49.33
101.67
187.25
97.25
43.67
94
Trough 1
112.3
107.09
77.42
41.75
91.33
162.05
74.17
35.88
Breakdown
9.44
5.71
13
7.58
10.33
14.54
10.5
7.79
Final
Visc
142.23
158.38
137.75
79.67
153.17
257.13
119.12
74.05
Setback
53.8
51.3
60.33
37.92
61.83
95.09
45.75
38.17
Peak
Time
7.1
7
7
7
7
8.98
8.99
7
Pas
Te
93.
93.
94.
94.
95
64.
94
93.
95
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
TDc 2817
TDc 2815
TDc 2809
TDc 2790
TDc 3839
TDc 3935
TDc 3093
TDd 3100
TDd 3779
TDd 4118
TDd 3907
TDd 3778
TDe 3041
TDe 3033
TDe 3039
TDe 3036
TDe 2786
TDe 3035
TDe 4149
Max
Min
Mean
Std
CV%
6.49
6.41
6.44
6.55
6.4
6.96
7.46
7.59
7.58
7.11
7.03
7.53
6.99
7.04
7.33
6.71
6.76
6.88
6.9
7.85
6.4
7.16
0.47
6.58
4.32
2.95
1.76
4.67
4.4
3.13
3.33
5.07
4.74
4.86
3.33
3.9
5.69
5.93
6.32
7.2
6.45
6.29
2.65
7.2
1.76
4.88
1.45
29.79
76.27
76.65
69.26
72.63
71.44
68.5
74.25
71.47
69.72
77.77
60.65
77.8
69.26
71.74
71.72
63.72
58.37
71.15
75.13
77.8
58.37
70.31
5.43
7.73
16.66
18.47
22.19
22.6
24.71
17
14.69
13.83
14.36
14.05
16.41
13.69
16.02
16.61
15.24
16.66
18.47
14.86
14.71
24.71
13.69
18.51
3.70
20.00
355.75
401.04
78.5
365.13
187,00
82.83
166
62.54
88.09
54.83
76.5
77.25
39.79
52
19.08
28.21
85.29
36.92
39.83
401.04
19.08
111.62
104.26
93.40
164.42
106.25
63.25
125.54
120.92
70.75
112
54.63
71.04
37.58
61.5
64.17
23
31
15.55
17.79
63.63
19.08
31.92
164.42
15.55
72.44
42.33
58.43
191.34
250.63
15.25
226.63
66.08
12.08
54
7.42
17.05
17.25
15
16.5
16.8
21
3.55
10.42
21.67
17.83
7.92
250.63
3.55
39.53
67.92
171.81
462.38
529.71
119.17
468.54
191.79
125.67
181.33
101.38
114.38
66.5
96.75
99.12
32.83
43
25,00
26.34
79.33
27.17
44.92
529.71
26.34
151.22
135.43
89.55
297.96
423.46
55.92
343
70.88
54.92
69.33
46.25
43.34
28.92
35.25
43.75
9.84
12
9.46
8.58
15.71
8.08
13
423.46
8.08
75.33
104.59
138.85
PGB23
PROVENANCE VARIATION FOR MORPHOLOGICAL TRAITS AND OIL CONTENT
IN SOME JATROPHA CURCAS L. GERMPLASM COLLECTIONS.
Usman, M.*, Echekwu, C.A., Yeye, M., Bugaji, S.M., Usman, A. and Yahaya, A.I.
Department of Plant Science, Institute for Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University,
Zaria, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: muhammadu709@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Twenty one provenances of Jatropha curcas L. collected from seven states of the Northwestern
Nigeria and established in a provenance trial at the Institute for Agricultural Research farm,
Ahmadu Bello University, Samaru, Nigeria were evaluated using principal component analysis
(PCA) to analyze their pattern of variation, determine the correlation among the morphological
traits and oil content, identify the major traits responsible for the variation and suggest
appropriate breeding material for the improvement of the crop. All the provenances showed
highly significant variation for all the traits studied except main stem height which was
significant at 5% level only. Three out of the ten principal components extracted had eigenvalue
greater than one and altogether accounted for 77.07% of the total variability. Principal
component 1 exhibited 34.77% while principal components 2 and 3 showed 24.48% and 17.83%
variability respectively among the provenances for the traits studied. Number of fruit bunch per
lateral branch, number of capsules per bunch and number of capsules per lateral branch had the
highest loadings on principal component 1 indicating their significance for this component. On
principal component 2, collar height and number of lateral branches were important. The third
principal component however, was more related to plant height (cm) and main stem height (cm).
Number of capsules per lateral branch, number of capsules per bunch, collar height and plant
height are found to be the major traits responsible for the variation in the Jatropha curcas
95
4.86
6.78
7
6.94
4.8
7
4.67
5.04
5
6.75
5.07
4.99
4.32
4.27
4.77
4.64
4.5
4.6
4.66
8.99
4.27
5.95
1.41
23.65
64.
64.
94.
64.
89.
89.
88.
93.
94.
64.
95
64
63.
65
93.
94.
93.
94.
94
95
63.
84.
13.
16.
96
provenances. Tsaki, Gwarzo and Kwanan maje provenances were identified as potential
materials for the improvement of Jatropha curcas L. in Nigeria.
Key words: Principal component analysis, Provenances, Provenance trial
INTRODUCTION
Jatropha curcas L. is a species of the flowering plants in the spurge family, Euphorbiaceae
containing about 170 known species (Heller, 1996). It is a rapidly emerging biofuel crop
currently attracting a lot of interest and investments (Wouter, 2010). The Jatropha plant is a
small tree or large shrub which can reach a height of 3-5m (Garg et al., 2011) with articulated
growth and a morphological discontinuity at each increment (Kumar, et al, 2008). It is resistant
to a high degree of aridity, allowing it to be grown in deserts. The crop is used as a hedge (living
fence) all over the world by farmers as it is not browsed by animals (Garg et al., 2011). Jatropha
has several industrial, pharmaceutical, environmental and other uses (Abubakar, 2002). The
plant, because of its numerous uses has potential to generate rural employment, reclaim
wasteland, earn foreign exchange, facilitate the establishment of rural based agro-industries,
improve the socio-economy of rural dwellers and lead to overall development of the country
(Abubakar, 2010). The seeds of Jatropha contain averagely 34.4% oil that can be processed to
produce a high quality biodiesel fuel usable in a standard diesel engine (Achten, 2008). Jatropha
is a new and very important crop in Nigeria. However, the crop is in its infancy as scientific
evidence for elite accessions and adequate breeding work on the crop in Nigeria are lacking. In
order to improve the crop for high yield and identify the best genotype for a particular location in
Nigeria, provenance research will be the quickest and simplest step to start considering the size
and lifespan of the crop. The objectives of this study are to; evaluate and determine the variation
pattern in the Jatropha curcas L. provenances, determine the correlation among the
morphological traits and oil content, identify the major traits responsible for the variation of the
provenances and suggest potential provenances that could be used in the improvement of the
crop in Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A survey and collection of Jatropha curcas L. germplasm from the Northwestern zone of
Nigeria was conducted in the year 2009. Twenty one (21) accessions were collected from the
seven states of the zone which spans across the Sahel, Sudan and Guinea Savannas and formed
the genetic materials for this research. The states were Sokoto, Kebbi, Zamfara, Katsina,
Kaduna, Kano and Jigawa. The eco-geographical characteristic of the survey area is presented in
Table 1. A provenance trial was established from these collections at Samaru (11º11'N, 07º38’E)
in 2009. Each accession, a representative of a provenance, contained 20±2 trees planted in single
row plots of 44m long with 3m inter- and intra-row spacing each stand taken as a replication.
All agronomic activities were carried out on the field in establishing the provenances.
Data were taken on ten randomly selected mother trees from each provenance. The
morphological traits of the plants and seeds assessed were specifically: Plant height (cm), seed
oil content, main stem height (cm), collar height (cm), collar thickness (cm),number of branches
on collar, number of lateral branches, number of fruit bunch per lateral branch, number of
capsule per bunch and number of capsule per lateral branch. The SAS statistical package (SAS
96
97
Institute Inc.2004) was used for all analyses, with P˂ 0.05 considered statistically significant for
all tests. Analyses of variance were carried out using the GLM procedure. Mean separation was
done by Duncan’s Multiple Range test (DMRT).
Table 1-Ecogeographical characteristics of the survey area in the Northwestern Zone of
Nigeria where Jatropha curcas L. germplasm were collected
State
Latitude Longitude Zone
Soil
Climate
(N)
(E)
type
Kaduna
9o11'11O22'
8021'7014'
NGS,
SGS
Alfisols Tropical
wet and dry
Katsina
11023'13007'
7o23'7o47'
SSS
Entisols Tropical
wet and dry
Kano
11o06'11o58'
9o-00'9o02'
SS
Alfisols Hot
and
semi-arid
Jigawa
11o00'11o33'
9o30'9o34'
SSS
Alfisols Hot
and
semi-arid
Zamfara 11o56'13007'
6o25'6o43'
SSS
Entisols Hot
and
semi-arid
Sokoto
12o03'13o10'
5o46'4o33'
SSS
NGS
Entisols Hot
and
semi-arid
Kebbi
12o05'12041'
4o07-4o26'
SSS
-
Hot
and
semi-arid
SS: Sudan Savannah, NGS: Northern Guinea Savannah, SSS: Sudano-Sahelian Savannah, SGS:
Southern
Guinea Savannah. (Source; Halilu et al (2011))
The model used for the analysis was: Yijkl k ijkl
Where;
µ
Yijkl = treel
combinationijk,
= the grand mean,
in
treatment
γk = provenancek
εijkl = residual error
Table 2: Mean Squares for each Character
Sources
of Df
MS
EMS
Variation
Replication
r 1
Mr
Provenance
p 1
Mp
e2 r 2p
Error
rp r 1
Me
e2
97
98
The contribution of each component of variance to the total phenotypic variation was calculated
by equating the appropriate mean squares to the expectation of mean squares (EMS) using the
method described by Singh and Chaudhary (1985) as follows:
σ2e
=
Me
σ2p
=
Mp - Me
σ²ph
=
Mp Me
r
=
σ2e + r σ2p - σ2e
= r σ2p
e2
Where, r = number of replications, σ2e = Error variance, σ2p= Genotypic variance, σ²ph =
Phenotypic variance, Me = Error means square, Mp = Provenance means square
Phenotypic correlation coefficients were estimated for all possible pairs of characters examined
using the standard procedure suggested by Miller et al. (1958) and Kashiani and Saleh (2010)
pxy
from the corresponding variance components using the equation: rpxy =
2
px 2 py
Where, rpxy = phenotypic correlation coefficient between characters X and Y
2 px = Phenotypic variance of character x
2 py = Phenotypic variance of character y
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The analysis of variance for the different traits (Table 3) showed that generally, there were
highly significant variation among the 21 provenances of Jatropha curcas for all the
morphological traits studied except main stem height which showed significant difference at 0.05
level of significance only. The existence of these differences suggests the presence of
considerable genetic variability among the provenances for these traits. This is most likely
because these provenances were sourced from different natural environments which might have
been affected by natural selection. These variations found in the morphological traits present us
with a viable selection alternative at a very early stage (germplasm collection) from base seed
material. This could be of use in improvement programmes especially considering the fact that
the Jatropha curcas is a new crop in which crop breeding is still in its infancy. Provenances
could be selected on the basis of distinguishable desirable traits and hybridized to obtain superior
genotypes. This is in agreement with Clausen et al. (1948) and Wattstein (1958) who are on the
view that hybrid from combining different provenances may result in hybrid vigor for many
characters. This also agrees with the report of Pryor (1963) that provenance selection is the
simplest and quickest means of improving trees. Traits such as high number of lateral branches,
high number of capsules per lateral branch and high number of fruit bunch per lateral branch
indicate high quantity of fruits and ultimately high quantity of seeds per plant. This suggests that
provenances with these traits can be selected for high seed yield per plant. Highly significant
98
99
correlation was found between number of fruits bunch per lateral branch and number of capsules
per bunch (r = 0.64839) and number of capsules per lateral branch (r = 0.67504). Highly
significant correlation was found between plant height and main stem height (r = 0.91432).
Highly significant correlation was also observed between number of lateral branches and number
of capsules per bunch (r = 0.69747) and between number of capsules per bunch and number of
capsules per lateral branch (r = 0.79802). Oil content has weak correlation with all the
morphological traits studied except collar height and number of lateral branches which showed
negative correlation with the oil content (r = -0.22377 and -0.11248 respectively). As number of
lateral branches has significant correlation with number of capsules per lateral branch as well as
highly significant correlation with number of capsules per bunch (Table 4), selection for one trait
leads to the improvement of the other trait in the same direction. Plant height and number of
lateral branches are important characters that can be looked upon as major selection indices when
the objective is to incorporate Jatropha curcas in an agroforestry system.
Number of lateral branches and number of capsules per lateral branch have higher genotypic
variances than error variances (Table 5) indicating little environmental influence in these traits.
However, these traits have no any significant positive correlation with the percentage of oil in the
seeds (seed oil content) as shown in Table 4 as to influence the total oil yield of the plant.
Number of capsules per bunch has highly significant correlation with number of lateral branches
as well as significant correlation with number of capsules per lateral branch. This indicates that
plants with good branching habit tend to develop more number of capsules. This is in agreement
with the work of Rao et al. (2008). The number of fruit bunch per lateral has highly significant
correlation with the number of capsules per lateral branch and number of capsules per bunch.
This result indicated that selection for any of these traits will indirectly results in high seed yield
obtainable from a tree. Plant height and main stem height have highly significant correlation with
each other showing that the two traits have strong association. The negative correlation observed
between plant height and number of lateral branches, number of capsules per lateral branch,
number of capsules per bunch and number of fruit bunch per lateral branch was in agreement
with the findings of Rao et al., (2008). The absence of any significant correlation between oil
content and all the morphological traits is in agreement with the work of Alireza et al. (2012) and
Freitas et al. (2011). However, the result is not in agreement with the findings of Rafii et al.
(2012) and Rao et al. (2008). This is most likely attributable to the fact that at three years the
yield of Jatropha plant has not reached its full potential.
Results from principal component analysis shows that three out of the ten principal components
extracted had eigenvalue greater than one and altogether explained 77.07% of the total variability
(Table 6). Principal components 1, 2 and 3 exhibited 34.77%, 24.48% and 17.83% variability
respectively among the provenances for the traits under study. Principal component 1 is
associated with number of fruit bunch per lateral, number of capsules per bunch and number of
capsules per lateral (Table 7). Collar height (cm) and number of lateral branches were important
for principal component 2. The third principal component however, was more related to plant
height (cm) and main stem height (cm).
CONCLUSION
Highly significant variation was found in all the morphological traits studied except main stem
height which was significant at 0.05 level of significance only. Highly significant correlations
99
100
were found between number of fruit bunch per lateral branch and number of capsules per bunch,
number of lateral branches and number of capsules per bunch and between number of fruit bunch
per lateral branch and number of capsules per lateral branches. The principal component analysis
identified number of capsules per lateral branch, number of capsules per bunch, collar height,
plant height and main stem height as the major traits responsible for the variation in the Jatropha
curcas L. provenances (Table 7). Tsaki, Kwanan maje and Soba provenances were identified as
potential materials that could be used in the improvement of Jatropha curcas L. in Nigeria
(Table 8).
Further research towards finding alleles for maximizing all desirable traits and pyramiding them
into highly productive Jatropha varieties through breeding and the use of the available techniques
is recommended.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The assistance rendered by the product development research labouratory of the Institute for
Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria especially in the oil content analysis is
acknowledged.
Table 3: Mean squares from the analysis of variance for nine traits in Jatropha curcas
Provenances established in IAR field 2012
Source
df
PH
MSH
CH
CT
BOC
LB
FBPL
Rep
9
261.85*
314.98* 1.77
109.77* 0.35
0.61
0.16
Provenance 20 1617.48** 1102.49* 29.06** 158.84** 7.95** 8.92** 2.92**
Error
180 131.54
148.07
3.29
57.01
0.50
0.69
0.43
Total
209
CPB
0.98
6.91**
0.70
CPL
3.03**
30.97**
1.31
PH=Plant height, MSH=Main stem height, CH=Collar height, CT=Collar thickness,
BOC=Number of branches on collar, LB=Number of lateral branches, FBPL=Number of fruit
bunch per lateral branch
CPB=Number of capsules per bunch, CPL=Number of capsules per lateral branch
Table 4: Phenotypic correlation coefficients between morphological traits and oil content
Jatropha curcas L. provenances
PH
MSH
CH
CT
BOC
LB
FBPL
CPB
CPL
OC
PH
1
MSH
0.91432**
1
CH
0.25374
0.1048
1
CT
0.04288
0.15269
-0.68394**
1
BOC
0.11999
0.16976
-0.46698*
0.59044**
1
100
LB
-0.06272
0.01194
0.14965
-0.46484*
-0.44137*
1
FBPL
-0.15725
0.01331
-0.31988
-0.08222
-0.06551
0.42216*
1
CPB
-0.29358
-0.07128
-0.05976
-0.25681
-0.26149
0.69747**
0.64839**
1
in
CPL
-0.33665
-0.13033
-0.36122
-0.00091
-0.1059
0.50534*
0.67504**
0.79802**
1
OC
0.23804
0.24341
-0.22377
0.25583
0.24816
-0.11248
0.04764
0.03433
0.00905
1
101
Table 5: Estimate of phenotypic, genotypic and error variances for morphological traits in
Jatropha
curcas L. provenances
2
2
2
Provenance Means
e
g
ph
PH
191.9
131.54
148.60
280.14
MSH
173.0
148.07
95.44
243.51
CH
9.0
3.29
2.58
5.87
CT
57.2
57.01
10.18
67.19
BOC
2.9
0.5
0.75
1.25
LB
5.4
0.69
0.82
1.51
FBPL
2.5
0.43
0.25
0.68
CPB
3.4
0.70
0.62
1.32
CPL
4.9
1.31
2.97
4.28
Table 6: Eigenvalues of the Correlation Matrix and the Proportion and Total Variance
Explained by the first three Principal Components
Eigen value
Difference
Proportion
Cumulative
Prin1
3.4767
1.0291
0.3477
0.3477
Prin2
2.4476
0.6646
0.2448
0.5924
Prin3
1.7830
0.8096
0.1783
0.7707
Table 7: Eigenvectors of Principal Components for Ten Characters in 21 Jatropha curcas L.
Provenances
Prin1
Prin2
Prin3
Plant Height
-.295417
0.198753
0.561951
Main Stem Height
-.188415
0.094050
0.675272
Collar Height
-.167114
0.530871
0.006323
Collar Thickness
-.091000
-.552975
0.140050
No. of Branches on Collar
-.112252
-.479458
0.238675
No. of Lateral Branches
0.394445
0.304822
0.167499
No. of Fruit Bunch per Lateral
No. of Capsules Per Bunch
0.433034
0.481361
-.050372
0.083240
0.213671
0.162208
No. of Capsules Per Lateral
0.468773
-.110308
0.135812
Oil Content
-.184008
0.140058
-.182018
101
102
Table 8: Standardized Principal component scores from the original data of 21 Jatropha
curcas provenances from the first three principal components representing 77.07% of the
variance from the original 10 characteristics
Provenance
Prin1
Prin2
Prin3
Bakin gada
0.605
0.208
0.457
Kakiyayi
0.516
0.92
-0.365
Soba
0.103
0.577
2.793
Gwarzo
1.447
-1.954
1.825
Rowan kanya
1.5
-1.998
1.813
Dirpindai
0.37
-0.487
-1.411
Masaya
-0.256
-1.273
-0.535
Kangire
-2.78
1.518
-1.441
Burum
2.233
2.241
0.204
Jega birni
0.008
0.308
0.575
0.814
0.745
Sabon
dabai
garin -0.402
Maga
0.571
-1.445
-0.721
Kwanan maje
-3.866
2.758
0.503
Take tsaba
-0.904
1.889
-0.53
Daki takwas
-5.011
-3.633
-0.043
Pompo
0.274
0.984
-0.251
Kajiji
0.664
-1.426
-2.52
Tsaki
2.87
0.203
-2.213
Danjanku
0.483
0.423
1.1
Dankama
0.642
-0.088
1.019
Karohi
0.934
-0.538
-1.004
REFERENCES
Abubakar, I.U. (2010). Jatropha curcas L.Cultivation for Biodiesel Production. In: Alabi, O. and
Misari, S.M. (Editors). Jatropha curcas L.: Sensitization lecture on the Jatropha curcas L.
102
103
held at the Institute for Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University (ABU) Zaria,
Nigeria on 30 July 2009, pp 24.
Abubakar, I.U. (2002). Jatropha curcas L. Cultivation for Biodiesel Production. In: Alabi, O.
and Misari, S.M. (Editors). Jatropha curcas L.: Sensitization lecture on the Jatropha
curcas L. held at the Institute for Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University (ABU)
Zaria, Nigeria on 30 July 2009
Achten, W.M.J., Verchot, L., Franken, Y.J., Mathijs, E., Singh, V.P., Aerts, R. and Muys
B.(2008).Jatropha biodiesel production and use. (A literature review) Biomass and
Bioenergy32 (12), 1063-1084.DOI: 10.1016/j.biombioe.2008.03.003.The Jatropha
Archives.
Alireza, B., Mohammed, Y. R., Ghizan, B. S., Mahmoodreza, S., Md, A. (2012). Phenotypic and
genetic variation of Jatropha curcas L. populations from different countries. Maydica vol.
57, no. 2 Biabani.
Freitas, R.G., Missio, R.F., Matos, F.S., Resende, M. D.V and Dias, L.A.S. (2011). Genetic
evaluation of Jatropha curcas: an important oilseed for biodiesel production. Genetic
and Molecular Research. 10 (3): 1490-1498 (2011).
Garg, P., Pankaj, K. and Divay G., (2011). Available on: www.imperialpharmajournals.com
Halilu, A.D., Misari, S.M., Echekwu, C.A., Alabi, O., Abubakar, I.U., Saleh, M. K., Adeyanju,
A.O. and Ogunwale, (2011). Survey and collection of Jatropha curcas L. in the
northwestern savannas of Nigeria. Biomass and Bioenergy 35: 4145-4148.
Heller, J. (1996). Physic nut, Jatropha curcas. Promoting the conservation and use of
Underutilized and Neglected Crops. International Plant Genetic Resources Institute
(IPGRI), Rome, Italy.
Kaiser, H. F. (1960). The application of electronic computers to factor analysis. Educational and
Psychological Measurement, 20, 141-151.
Kashiani, P., & Saleh, G. (2010). Estimation of genetic correlations on sweet corn inbred lines
using SAS mixed model. American Journal of Agricultural and Biological Science, 5 (3), 309314. http://dx.doi.org/10.3844/ajabssp.2010.309.314
Kumar, A., Sharma, S., An evaluation of multipurpose oil seed crop for industrial uses (Jatropha
curcas
L.):
A
review,
Industrial
Crops
Production.
(2008),
doi:10.1016/j.indcrop.2008.01.001
Miller, P.A., Williams, J.C., Robinson, H.F., & Comstock, R.E. (1958). Estimates of genotypic
and
environmental variances and covariances in Upland cotton and their
implications
in
selection.
Agronomy
Journal,
50,
126-131.
http://dx.doi.org/10.2134/agronj1958.00021962005000030004x
Rafii, M. Y., Arolu, I. W., Omar, M. H. H., and Latif, M. A. (2012). Journal of Medicinal Plants
ResearchVol.6
(11),
pp.2178-2183,
.Available
online
at
http://www.academicjournals.org/JMPR
Rao, G. R., Korwar, G. R., Shanker, A. K. and Ramakrishna, Y. S. (2008). Genetic associations,
variability and diversity in seed characters, growth, reproductive phenology and yield in
Jatropha curcas (L.) accessions. Trees 22: 697-709.
SAS Institute Inc (2004) SAS/STAT 9.1 user’s guide. SAS Institute Inc., Cary, 5121
Singh, R. K. and Chaudhary, B. D. (1977). Biometrical methods in quantitative genetic analysis.
Kalyanin Publisher, Ludhiana India, pp. 318.
103
104
Wouter, M. J.,
Achten, L. R., Nielsen, R. A., Ard, G. L., Erik D K., Antonio,
T.,Jon,K.H.,Wouter,H.M., Lars G., Festus K.A. & Bart M. (2010). Biofuels 1(1), 91–
107
PGB24
PHENOTYPIC VARIATION SHOWS 10 DISTINCT CLUSTERS OF WATER YAM (D.
ALATA ) GERMPLASM IN NIGERIA
Obidiegwu, J. E.1, Njoku, D.N.1 and Asiedu, R.2
1
National Root Crops Research Institute (NRCRI), Umudike, PMB 7006 Umuahia, Abia State.
2
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) Ibadan, Nigeria
Corresponding e-mail: njokudn2012@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
A pre-requisite for a sustainable D.alata (water yam) crop improvement in Nigeria is to
understand the state of variation in the phenotypes of present collection. 163 accessions
comprising of collections from different yam growing regions were evaluated using a total of 77
phenotypic descriptors. Multivariate analysis of quantitative and qualitative data resulted to 10
major distinct cluster groups with varying number of individual entries. Days to tuber
emergence, stem length, internode length and waxiness contributed to 54 % of total variation.
The findings suggest a narrow genetic base and buttresses that most of the collections from
different regions are duplicates. Proposal for efficient utilization of the inherent genetic
potentials in the cluster groups in breeding programmes complimented with more collections
within and outside the country should be encouraged and vigorously pursued.
Keywords: Breeding, Genetic, Phenotype, Water yam
INTRODUCTION
Yams (Dioscorea spp) are economically important starch staple in tropical and sub-tropical
regions of the world, particularly West Africa. D. alata ranks second to D. rotundata in terms of
production and consumption in Nigeria (Orkwor, 1998). D. alata is the most widely distributed
species in the world and has an advantage for sustainable cultivation especially when yam
production seems to be on the decline as a result of high cost of production, low yields and postharvest losses (Wireko-Manu, 2011)
Yam production has not kept pace with demand due to an ever increasing population and the lack
of varieties that combine high and stable yield of good quality tubers (Olojede et al., 2000).
Apart from these, other constraints to yam production include the occurrence of pests and
diseases that cause foliar and tuber problems in field and storage (Emehute et al., 1998). There
is, therefore, the need to breed cultivars that are high yielding, possess disease and pest
resistance, good storability and culinary quality.
The International Institute for Tropical Agriculture (IITA) Ibadan, Nigeria holds in trust
collections of D. alata from Nigeria. This germplasm collection was set up to preserve the
genetic diversity and for further use in the genetic enhancement of the crop. The diversity can
introduce useful new traits and create new heterotic combinations. These in turn can contribute
104
105
to more crop yields and enhance adaptability of finished varieties by providing appropriate and
useful genetic stocks for breeding program.
The objective of this study is to assess the genetic diversity among cultivars of D. alata
germplasm collected from different parts of Nigeria using morphological descriptors
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted in IITA yam field. One hundred and sixty three cultivars of D. alata
were grown from tuber setts (100 g) planted on ridges spaced 1 m x 1 m apart. Each cultivar was
represented by 3 plants, which were individually trained on to 2.0 m bamboo stakes when vines
were 30 – 50 cm long. No fertilizer was applied and plants were irrigated during periods of dry
weather. Agronomic practices were done based on recommendation of Orkwor (1998)
The plant descriptors used are those recommended by IPGRI/IITA (1997). Aerial vegetative
parts were monitored and described between March and October at juvenile and adult stages.
Plants were harvested after senesce. Harvested tubers were stored in a shaded yam barn and
described thereafter. 77 plant characters were measured and coded for analysis.
Table 1: List of 77 morphological descriptors and number of class categories
Descriptor
Young stem descriptors
Young stem color
Presence of wax on young stem
Presence of wings on young stem
Presence of spine on young stem
Presence of colored spot on the base of spine
Presence of barky patches
Class
3
2
2
2
2
2
Plant descriptor
Plant type
Plant vigor
Bearing type
Layering habit
Twining habit
Stem height at 8 weeks after planting
Stem color
Number of internodes at first branching
Presence of wax on older stems
Presence of wings on old stem
Presence of hair on old stem
Presence of spine on old stem
Spine shape
Presence of coalescent spines
Presence of color spot at spine base
Color of spots at spine base
Types of pigmentation
3
3
3
2
2
3
3
4
2
2
2
2
3
2
2
4
5
105
106
Hairiness of upper lower surface
Leaf arrangement
Leaf density
Leaf type
Leatheriness of leaf
Onset of leafing
Leaf color
Waxiness of upper/lower leaf surface
Leaf shape apex
Distance between lobes
Upward folding of leaf along main vein
Downward arching of leaf along main vein
Downward arching of leaf lobes to form a cup
Upward arching of leaf lobes
Position of the widest part of leaf
Leaf tip length
Leaf tip color
Petiole length
Petiole hairness
Petiole spot color
Presence of stipule
4
3
4
2
2
3
4
3
3
2
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
2
3
2
Qualitative descriptors for flower characteristics
Flowering
Presence of inflorescence smell
Sex
Inflorescence position
Number of inflorescence per plant
Inflorescence type
Average length of inflorescence
Number of flowers per inflorescence
Flower color at maturity
Female flower length
Male flower diameter
Fruit formation
2
2
2
2
3
3
4
3
3
3
3
2
Qualitative descriptors for tuber characteristics
Tuber growth
Tuber maturity at emergence
Number of tubers per hill
Relationship among tubers
Presence of corms on tubers
Corm size in relation to tuber size
Corm ability to be separated from tuber
Sprouting at harvest
Aerial tuber formation
3
3
3
3
2
3
2
2
2
106
107
Skin color
Surface texture
Bumps on tuber
Skin thickness
Tuber shape
Uniformity in tuber shape
Place where tuber branch
Tuber length
Spiny roots at tuber surface
Rootlets on tuber surface
Wrinkles on tuber surface
Cracks on tuber surface
4
2
2
2
4
3
3
2
2
2
2
2
Seventy seven morphological characters were measured on 163 cultivars. The scores for each
character were standardized to have a zero mean and unit variance. From this matrix, the
correlation coefficients between every pair of cultivars were computed. In order to assess the
variation among cultivars principal component analysis (PCA) were performed according to
Sneath and Sokal (1973) using statistical analysis software (SAS, 2003). The dendrogram was
based on the general relationship between any two units for comparison, which is expressed as a
measure of dissimilarity. The Euclidean distance coefficient d, was used where
d2 jk = ∑ 1 (Xji − Xki) 2
j and k denote any two cultivars being compared and i denotes characters.
The plot of canonical variables of the 163 cultivars was used to establish the clustering
RESULTS
The cultivars studied were separated between a distance coefficient of 0.4 and 3. This resulted
into 10 clusters. The clusters showed three distinct groups (Figure 1). Cluster 2 exhibited high
coefficient distance when compared to others. Clusters 5, 9, 7 and 10 formed a distinct grouping
and had majority of the entries and (Figure 2). Clusters 1, 3, 4, 6 and 8 where distinct showing a
coefficient distance of between 0.4 to 0.8. Clusters that had the highest entries were 1 and 9, and
both had 50 and 44 cultivars respectively. The least entries were observed in cluster 8 and 10
with both having 2 and 1 individuals respectively. Distance between cluster centroids shows that
cluster 7 exhibited highest variability when compared to other clusters (Table 2)
54% of the total variation resulted from days to tuber emergence, stem length, internode length
and waxiness (Table 3). Each cluster was peculiar to a specific trait though most of the traits
overlapped. Cluster 2 entries showed waxiness on the stem while cluster 3 was distinct with
purplish green leaf. Cluster 1 had dark green stem at maturity with cluster 4 having highly
107
108
shaped cylindrical tuber shape. Cluster 5 had dark maroon skin shape flesh while cluster 7 had
irregular shaped tubers. Stem length was high in cluster 10 while days to tuber emergence were
least in cluster 6. Cluster 9 gave shortest internode length while cluster 8 showed deep purplish
colour of leaf margin days after sprout emergence.
Figure 1: Dendrogram showing 10 clusters generated from 163 D. alata cultivars based on
morphological descriptors
108
109
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Figure 2: Plot of two dimensional canonical variables identified by clusters
109
9
10
110
1
75.78 23.24 128.41 45.45
2 75.78
53.84 54.13 34.85
3 23.24 53.84
105.96 24.44
4 128.42 54.13 105.96
85.49
5 45.45 34.85 24.44 85.49
6 24.57 57.05 15.01 109.28 25.18
7 216.87 141.76 194.33 88.81 173.37
8 98.59 24.81 76.13 31.34 55.48
9 33.84 42.06 13.05 94.90 16.64
10 24.49 52.49 8.17
105.19 23.90
Table 2: Distance between cluster centroids
24.57
57.05
15.01
109.27
25.18
216.87
141.76
194.33
88.81
173.37
197.12
98.59
24.81
76.13
31.34
55.48
79.51
118.72
197.12
79.51 118.72
19.23 183.22 65.18
15.89 193.52 74.95
33.84
42.06
13.05
94.90
16.64
19.23
183.22
65.18
24.49
52.49
8.17
105.19
23.90
15.89
193.52
74.95
12.61
12.61
Table 3: Factor scores of 4 major characters in the first four principal component axes with the
eigen-values and percent of total variation accounted for by each of the four
component axes used in the ordination of 163 yam cultivars of D. alata
Character
Date to tuber emergence
Stem length
Internode length
Waxiness
Eigen-value
Proportion of variation accounted
Cumulative
Principal component axis
I
II
0.141
-0.082
0.070
0.287
0.095
0.261
-0.144
-0.029
8.138
5.228
0.220
0.141
0.220
0.361
III
-0.111
0.077
0.034
-0.245
4.184
0.113
0.474
IV
0.030
-0.043
-0.116
0.095
2.684
0.066
0.540
DISCUSSION
IPGRI/IITA (1997) was useful in assessing variation among D. alata cultivated in Nigeria held
in trust by IITA. Seventy seven descriptors made up of qualitative and quantitative traits were
effective in appraising the morphological diversity.
The information generated is vital for breeding new cultivars with novel or improved
characteristics that are high yielding with good crop vigour, resistant to common pests and
diseases of yams especially potty virus, leaf blight, nematodes and anthracnose as well as yam
varieties that have high dry matter consumer acceptable food qualities such as pounding for fufu
and friability for chewing varieties which can store well, with good tuber aesthetic qualities of
shape and smooth skin. The dendrogram constructed in our study showed 10 distinct clusters of
D. alata in Nigeria. The allelic diversity within and across the 10 clustered group can be used in
breeding programmes for the development of novel cultivars. It provides basis for defining
heterotic groups which are informative for reciprocal recurrent selection and for further genomic
analyses.
It is obvious from our study that the genetic base of D. alata in Nigeria is narrow. The cultivars
collected from different regions with diverse local names probably might have resulted in
110
111
duplication of most of the few available cultivars. D.alata is Asiatic in origin and further
collection mission should target the region to avoid duplications which might be prevalent in
close countries to Nigeria. There is need to maximise genetic gains by embarking on more
collection.
Major contributing characters are days tuber emergence, stem length, internode length and
waxiness and followed by leaf colour, colour of stem at maturity, tuber skin colour, shape of
tuber and colour of leaf margin days after sprout emergence. These characters were highly
discriminatory among individual cultivars and may be useful in further studies differentiating D.
alata cultivars. Some of these descriptors have earlier been highlighted by Martin and Rhodes
(1977). These traits can be used as identification keys for cultivar groups which in turn can
expedite selection process.
REFERENCES
Emehute, J.K.U., Ikotun, T., Nwauzor, E.C., Nwokocha, H.N. (1998). Crop Protection. Food
yams: Advances in Research. GC Orkwor, R. Asiedu, IJ Ekanayake. Eds. International
Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) and National Root Crops Research Institute
(NRCRI), Nigeria. Pp. 143 – 186.
IPGRI/IITA (1997) Descriptors for Yam (Dioscorea spp). International Institute of Tropical
Agriculture, Ibadan, Nigeria/ International Plant Genetic Resources Institute, Rome,
Italy
Martin FW, Rhodes AM (1977). Intra-specific classification of Dioscorea alata. Tropical
Agriculture (Trinidad) 54: 1 – 13.
Olojede AO, Ikeorgu JEG, Ekwe KC (2000). Farmer participatory evaluation of IITA’s hybrid
yam clones in Southeast Agro-ecological zone of Nigeria. In: Biometry and
quality of life.
S. Nokoe (editor). Proceedings of the 6th Scientific Workshop of the
sub-Saharan Africa
Network (SUSAN) of the International Biometry Society (IBS), held at the International
Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), Ibadan, Nigeria, 23─ 27 August 1999. SUSAN-IBS,
Nairobi, Kenya. 105 – 110.
Orkwor, G.C. (1998). The importance of yams. Food yams: advances in research. GC Orkwor,R,
Asiedu, IJ Ekanayake (editors). International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, and
National Root Crops Research Institute, Umudike, Nigeria. 1 – 12.
SAS. (2003). SAS Institute User’s Guide. Version 9.1. SAS Institute, Cary, N.C., USA.
Sneath PHA, Sokal RR (1973). Numerical taxonomy: the principles and practice of numerical
classification. Freeman, W. H. and Company, San Francisco. 573 pp.
Wireko-Manu FD, Ellis WO, Asiedu R , Maziya- Dixon B (2011). Physicochemical and pasting
characteristics of water yam (D. alata) in Comparison with Pona (D.
rotundata)
from
Ghana. European Journal of Food Research and Review. 1(3): 149 158.
111
112
PGB25
GENETIC VARIABILITY OF STRIGA GESNERIOIDES (WILLD) IN NORTHERN
NIGERIA
Ibrahim, H.1*, Omoigui, L.O.2, Bello, L.L.2, Kamara, A.Y.3 and Mohammed, S.G.1
1
Department of Agronomy, Bayero University, Kano, Nigeria
2
Department of Plant Breeding and Seed Science, College of Agronomy, University of
Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria.
3
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), Ibadan Oyo State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: hassibonline@yahoo.com)
ABSTRACT
Cowpea is an important grain legume crop in Sub-Saharan Africa. Its production is constrained
by an obligate root parasitic weed, Striga gesnerioides. Crop yield losses due to this noxious
weed may be up to 100% depending on the extent of damage and level of infestation. In West
and Central Africa regions, seven races of Striga have been reported. The use of resistant
cultivars seems to be the cheapest and most effective method of controlling the parasite. Several
cowpea cultivars exhibiting resistance to the parasite have been developed during the last two
decades. However, most resistant cultivars show a differential response when grown in different
countries across West and Central Africa, suggesting that there are different races of S.
gesnerioides within or between countries. This study was undertaken to investigate the genetic
variability within and between 3 Striga populations collected from three different geographical
zones (Borno, Jigawa, and Kano) of Nigeria, where cowpea is a major crop. Five cowpea
cultivars with known history of reaction to Striga were used for the study. Results showed that
there was no differential response of the cowpea genotypes to the Striga seeds collected from the
three geographical areas, suggesting that there is no race variation in Striga population in
Nigeria.
Keywords: Striga, genetic variability, cowpea, northern Nigeria.
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea is the most important grain legume crop in Sub-Saharan Africa. It is a staple food in
more than 65 countries (Singh, 2006) due to its high nutritional value, plasticity, and ability to
adapt to a wide range of environments in tropical and subtropical regions of the world. It is
usually the first crop harvested before the cereal crops are ready and therefore is commonly
referred to as "hungry-season crop". The fruits are consumed at all stages of growth (e.g. green
pods, fresh or dry seeds) and the young leaves are often used for soups and stews [Quaye et al.,
2009]. Cowpea is an extremely resilient crop and cultivated under some of the most extreme
agricultural conditions in the world (Owolade et al., 2006; Muoneke et al., 2012.
Nigeria and Niger each cultivate well over 4 million ha and account for more than 45% and
nearly 15%, respectively of the total world production. Burkina Faso stands a distant third, with
6.1% of the world’s total production (Abate et al., 2012). Like most crops, cowpea growth and
grain yields are greatly reduced by a variety of biotic and abiotic constraints. Among the major
biotic constraints is parasitism by Striga gesnerioides commonly referred to as witch-weed of the
112
113
family Orobanchaceae. Witch weeds are noxious and persistent pests in farmer’s fields and yield
losses due to S. gesnerioides parasitism are extensive in the Sudano-Sahelian belt of West and
Central Africa (Parker, 2009). On susceptible cultivars, yield losses can reach 100% when S.
gesnerioides population is over 10/plant (Kamara et al., 2008). Omoigui et al. (2009) added that
yield losses caused by Striga in the dry savanna of sub-Saharan Africa are estimated in millions
of tons annually and the prevalence of the pest is steadily increasing.
The current knowledge of genetic diversity of S. gesnerioides has not been sufficiently evaluated
relative to their wide distribution. Genetic diversity is due to hybridization, clonal variation, local
adaptation and frequent colonization events. Colonization events of autogamous species formed
genetically uniform populations. The genetic diversity inherent in Striga is extremely important
for modelling its future dispersal in the light of global climate change. Limited information is
available on genetic variability of Striga population in Nigeria.The objectives of this work is to
identify whether there are different biotypes of Striga gesnerioides in Nigeria and to identify
cowpea lines that could be resistant across the different Striga biotypes if ever they exist.
MATERIALS AND METHOD
The experiment was conducted in the screenhouse at the International Institute of Tropical
Agriculture (IITA), Kano Station. Kano is situated at latitude 11°30'0" N, longitude 8°30'0" E in
DMS (Degrees Minutes Seconds) and altitude 518 m asl and lies in the Sudan savanna agroecology. Cowpea genotypes were selected based on their reactions to S. gesnerioides in a
previous screening in pot and field infested with S. gesnerioides. The genotypes are TVX-3236,
B301, IT97K-499-35, IT81D-994 and VYA (Cameroun).
Clean sterilized plastic pots measuring 10 inches in diameter were filled with a mixture of top
soil and sharp sand in the ratio 2:1 respectively, and infested with Striga seeds (0.025g about
5,000 seeds) at 5-7 cm deep. The pots were arranged in completely randomized design with three
replications in the screen house. Striga to be used was obtained from Kano, Jigawa and Borno
states. The infested soil was kept moist for 7–9 days to precondition the Striga seeds to ensure
optimum germination, based on adopted protocol of Striga infestation reported by Berner et al.
(1999). Three cowpea seeds were sown in each pot. The pots were watered adequately to field
capacity and kept weed-free by hand weeding. Compound fertilizer (NPK: 15:15:15) was applied
at 7 days after plant emergence. Cowpea seedlings were thinned to two plants per pot at 2 weeks
after planting (WAP). The cowpea plants were observed daily in order to determine the date of
flowering and Striga emergence.
RESULTS
The analysis of variance (ANOVA) for growth and Striga parameters are presented in Table
1.The cowpea genotype showed significant difference in terms of plant height and Striga count
at 49 days after planting (DAS) (P < 0.01 and 0.05, respectively, Table 1). IT97K-499-35
recorded the highest mean followed by IT81D-994, while B301 recorded the lowest mean
followed by VYA (Cameroun) (table 2). Striga count at 56 days after planting, plant shoot dry
weight, plant root dry weight and Striga dry weight has no significant difference (table 1).
Location for Striga seed collection has a significant effect on Striga dry weight (P < 0.05) but not
113
114
on growth parameters (figure 1). Genotype x location was not significant for all the parameters
taken (table 1). However, few Striga emerged in one pot of B301 and IT97K-499-35 (Table 3).
IT81D-994, which was previously identified as resistant supported Striga shoot when infested
with Striga seeds collected from the three locations (Table 3).
Table 1 Analysis of variance for plant height at 3 weeks after planting, Striga count at 49 and 56
days after planting, plant shoot dry weight, plant root dry weight and Striga dry weight.
SOURCE OF VARIATION
DF
MEAN SQUARES
PLTHGT3 STCNT@49 STCNT@56 SHTDRWT RTDRWT
STDRWT
GENOTYPE
56.47
3.741
4
66.69**
253.7*
432
22.276
STRIGA LOC
2
2.29
2.486*
396.1
428.1
2.54
35.61
GENOTYPE * ST LOC
8
66.8
119.5
3.389
8.89 1.243
RESIDUAL
1.54
14.33
15
13.37 129.3
* and **, Significant at 5% level of probability
114
297.9
6.314
19.75
115
Table 2: Effect of genotype on plant height at 3 weeks after planting, Striga count at 49
and 56 days after planting, plant shoot dry weight, plant root dry weight and Striga dry
weight.
Genotype
PLTHGT3 STCNT@49 STCNT@56 SHTDRWT RTDRWT
STDRYWT
VX-3236
2.49a
2.36a
B301
7.83a
28.93ab
1.06a
11.50ab
17.33a
23.56c
0.33b
0.01a
5.93a
32.25a
0.50b
3.67a
5.39a
0.00a
IT97K-499-35
6.64a 0.10a
IT81D-994
2.60a
29.26ab
1.41a 1.49a
VYA (Cameroun)
1.43a 1.71a
10.00ab
23.93bc
14.33a
18.17a
15.67a
1.59a
Means followed by the same letter (s) are not statistically significant using DMRT at 5%
level of probability.
a
ab
c
Figure 1: Effect of Striga location on Striga dry weight.
115
116
Table 3: Reaction of the cowpea genotypes to different Striga locations
STRIGA LOCATION
GENOTYPE
BO
KN
JG
PREVIOUS STUDIES
REACTION TO STRIGA
TVX-3236
Susceptible to all races
S
S
S
B301
Resistance to SG 1,2,3,4
R
R
S+/-
IT97K-499-35
Resistance to SG 1,3
R
R
S*
IT81D-994
Resistance to SG 1,3
S
S
S
VYA (Cameroun)
Susceptible to all races
S
S
S
R and S mean Striga resistant and susceptibility respectively
DISCUSSION
The cultivars TVX-3236 and VYA showed susceptibility to the Striga seeds collected from the
three locations, which is in conformity with the previous studies by Omoigui et al. (2011).
IT81D-994 was susceptible to Striga seeds collected from the three locations, which is in
conformity with the work of Muranaka et al. (2008) who reported its susceptibility to SG3.
B301 showed resistance to Striga seeds collected from Kano and Borno but supported few Striga
in one of the pots infested with Striga seeds collected from Jigawa State. Similar report by
Mellor et al. (2012) indicated some Striga attachment on B301 root in ex vitro germination
study.
Similarly, IT97K-499-35 was found to be resistant to the Striga collected from Kano and Borno
states but it allowed some Striga attachments from Striga seeds collected from Jigawa State. This
is also in conformity with the study of Omoigui et al. (2011), who found IT97K-499-35
supporting few Striga plants when tested in Borno State.
However, present results certainly do not suggest a new race, because one would have expected
to observe a certain high degree of differentiation between the populations. This was clearly not
the case in the S. gesnerioides populations studied here. The Striga shoots observed in B301 and
IT97K-499-35 probably could have resulted from physical seed admixture, which needs further
116
117
investigation. Consequently, the results of this study do not indicate the presence of a different
Striga race other than that race 3 of the Striga previously reported in Nigeria by Lane et al.
(1996). Apparently, there is need for further investigations to confirm the claims of the present
study.
REFERENCES
Abate, T., Alene, A.D., Bergvinson, D., Shiferaw, B., Silim, S., Orr, A. and Asfaw, S. (2012).
Tropical Grain Legumes in Africa and South Asia: Knowledge and Opportunities
Berner, D. K., Ikie, F. O., and Aigbokhan, E. I. 1996. Methods for soil infestation with
hermonthica seeds. Agronomy Journal 88:33-37
Striga
Kamara, A. Y., D. Chikoye, F. Ekeleme, L. O. Omoigui and I. Y. Dugje. (2008). Field
performance of improved cowpea varieties under conditions of natural infestation by
parasitic weed Striga gesnerioides. Int J. Pest Management 54(3):189-195.
Lane JA, Moore THM, Child DV & Cardwell KF (1996) Characterization of virulence and
geographic distribution of Striga gesnerioides in cowpea in West Africa. Plant Disease
80, 299–301.
Mellor, K.E., A. M. Hoffman and M. P. Timko. (2012). Use of ex vitro composite plants to
study the interaction of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) with the root parasitic
angiosperm Striga gesnerioides.
Muoneke, C. O., Ndukwe, O.M., Umana, P.E., Okpara, D.A. and Asawalam, D. O. (2012).
Productivity of vegetables cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) and maize (Zea mays L.)
intercropping system as influenced by component density in a tropical zone of
southeastern Nigeria International Journal of Agricultural Research and Development 15
(1):835-847.
Muoneke, C. O., Ndukwe, O.M., Umana, P.E., Okpara, D.A. and Asawalam, D. O. (2012).
Productivity of vegetables cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) and maize (Zea mays L.)
intercropping system as influenced by component density in a tropical zone of
southeastern Nigeria International Journal of Agricultural Research and Development 15
(1):835-847.
Muranaka, S.,H.P. Timko, N. Asse, M. Wade, C. Fatokun, A. Raji, D.J. Kim and O. Boukar.
(2008). ‘Marker Development and Marker assisted selection for Striga resistance in
cowpea’’ Research work presented at workshop organized by Agricultural Scientist of
International Institute in Japan.
Omoigui L. O., Ishiyaku M. F., Ousmane B., Gowda B. S. and Timko M. P. (2011a).
Application of fast technology for analysis (FTA) for sampling and recovery of
deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) for
molecular
characterization of cowpea
breeding
lines for Striga resistance. Afr. J. of Biotech. Vol.10 (85): 19681-19686.
Omoigui, L. O., A. Y. Kamara, M. F. Ishiyaku and O. Boukar (2011b). Comparative responses
of cowpea breeding lines to Striga and Alectra in the dry savanna of northeast
117
118
Nigeria. African Journal of Agricultural Research Vol. 7(5), pp. 747-754, 5 February,
2012
Omoigui, L. O., M. P. Timko, M. F. Ishiyaku, B. Ousmane, B. S. Muranaka, A. Y. Kamara
and M. Y. Yeye. (2009). Molecular characterization of cowpea breeding line for
Striga resistance using FTA technology. African Crop Science Conference, Uganda
9:527-530.
Owolade, O. F., Akande, M. O., Alabi, B. S. and Adediran, J. A. (2006). Phosphorus level
effects on brown blotch disease, development and yield of cowpea. World Journal
of
Agricultural Science 2(1): 105 108.
Parker, C. (2009). Observations on the current status of Orobanche and Striga problems
worldwide. Pest Manag. Sci. 65: 453-459.
Quaye, W., Adofo, K., Madode, Y., Abdul-Razak, A. (2009). Exploratory and multidisciplinary
survey of the cowpea network in the Tolon-Kumbungu District of Ghana: A food
sovereignty perspective. Afr J Agric Res. 4:311–320.
Singh, B. B. (2006). Cowpea breeding at IITA: highlights of advances and impacts. In:
Congresso Nacional de feijão-caupi, 1.; reunião nacional de
feijãocaupi,6., 2006,
Teresina. Tecnologias para o agronegócio: anais. Teresina:
Embrapa Meio-Norte.1
CD-ROM. (Embrapa Meio-Norte. Documentos, 121).
PGB26
HERITABILITY ESTIMATE IN SUGARCANE (SACCHARUM OFFICINARUM L.)
GENOTYPES FOR YIELD AND YIELD COMPONENTS.
Abubakar, L.1*, Ibrahim, N. D.1, Aliero, A. A.2, Bubuche, T. S.3 and Ibrahim, R.3
1
Department of Crop Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Usmanu Danfodiyo University,
P.M.B.2346, Sokoto State, Nigeria
2
Department of Biological Science, Faculty of Science , Usmanu Danfodiyo University,
P.M.B.2346, Sokoto State, Nigeria.
3
Department of Agricultural Education, College of Education, P.M.B. 1012, Argungu, Kebbi
State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding email:dr.lawaliabubakar@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Experiment was conducted in Sokoto State at Fadama land area, a spring behind Vice
Chancellor’s Quarters of Usmanu Danfodiyo University Sokoto in the Sudan Savanna agroecological zone of Nigeria, during 2011 and 2012 growing seasons. The experiment was laid out
in a Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD), replicated three times. Fourteen sugar cane
hybrids and a local check were evaluated; twenty two parameters were taken through the
procedure outlined in the IBGR/ICRISAT Sugarcane descriptor to measure each trait. The data
obtained were analyzed using Analysis of variance (ANOVA), result revealed high broad-sense
heritability (H2 > 45%) in almost all the traits measured, thus result suggests that selection for
these traits will be easy and as such the cultivars (those with H2 < 45%) could be used in
breeding programme for selections in favour of enhanced high cane yield, crack on stalk (20%)
and growth habit (8%). All these also showed low heritability estimate and are expected not to
118
119
respond to selection easily. However negative broad-sense heritability (H2) were observed in
sprout count at two weeks after planting (-26.32 %) and total cane yield (-16.19 %). Number of
stalk/stool, stalk length, stalk girth and final brix were recommended to serve as a breeding guide
for selection due to their high heritability estimate.
Key words: Heritability, yield, Sugarcane, yield components.
INTRODUCTION
Sugar cane (Saccharum officinarum L.) belongs to the grass family Poaceae, and is characterized
by segmented stems and blade-like leaves, and Reproduction can be by seed, or vegetatively by
cutting (“setts”) (Barnes, 1974). Sugarcane is a tropical plant, it has no adaptation to survive
freezing and it is dependent on abundant sunlight for healthy growth (Hussain, 2001). As a
tropical plant, sugarcane has a specific photosynthetic mechanism for fixing carbon into plant
sugar, in this adaptation, the first product of photosynthesis is four-carbon sugar (C4 plant) that is
fixed in specialized cells in the conductive tissue (stem) of the plant (Cox et al., 2000). Sugar
yield being a quantitative character, is the result of various characters working together during
the crop growth, which are interdependent in their development. It is, therefore, desirable to
study the association between yield and yield attributing characters since this would facilitate
effective selection for simultaneous improvement of one or more yield influencing components
(Olaoye, 2009). The purpose of selection is to identify seedlings which are genetically superior,
if that superiority is genotypic in nature, the seedlings will reproduce its value faithfully in other
environments, however if on the contrary, the value is mainly environmental, thus the degree of
genetic determination (DGD) which is the ratio of genotypic variance to phenotypic variance
(H2) is used to estimate yield, quality and other traits in a population (Olaoye, 2004).
Sugarcane is currently grown in over 110 countries in the world with 1,661,251,480 tonns were
produced worldwide, this is harvested from 23,777,743 hectares giving a yield of 698,658kg/ha,
the African total production for the year was 94,154,405 tonns harvested from 1,573,034
hectares at a yield of 59,853kg/ha, in Nigeria the total production being 1,412,070 tonns,
harvested from 17,890 hectares at the rate of 196,421kg/ha (FAOSTAT, 2009). But the top
fifteen Sugarcane Producing countries are Brazil 6.71 million/ha, India 4.90 million/ha, China
1.24 million/ha, Pakistan 1.03 million/ha, Thailand 1.01 million/ha, Mexico 0.68 million/ha,
Colombia 0.45 million /ha, Australia 0.42 million/ha, South Africa 0.42 million/ha, Cuba 0.40
million/ha, Philippines 0.40 million/ha, United States of America 0.36 million/ha, Indonesia 0.35
million/ha Argentina 0.29million/ha and Vietnam 0.29 million/ha (FAOSTAT, 2009). The study
objective was to determining broad sense heritability estimates for sugarcane characters to be
used in selection for high cane yield.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Field experiment was conducted at Fadama land, behind Vice Chancellor’s Quarters of Usmanu
Danfodiyo University Sokoto during 2011 and 2012 growing seasons. Sokoto is located in the
Sudan Savanna agro-ecological zone of Nigeria on latitude 130 08 N and longitude 50 15 E on an
altitude of about 350m above sea level (ASL). Mean annual rainfall is about 752 mm, the
minimum and maximum temperatures are 260C and 350C, respectively, and relative humidity of
119
120
23-41%. The area is characterized by long dry season with cool air during hammattan
(November – February), dry air during hot season from March – May followed by a short rainy
season (Bello, 2006). The experiment was laid out in a Randomized Complete Block Design
(RCBD), replicated three times. Fourteen sugar cane hybrids and a local check were evaluated.
The hybrids were: ILS-001, USRI/08/85, USRI/08/43, USRI/08/80, CO957, USRI/08/63,
USRI/08/03, USRI/08/87, USRI/08/68, ILS-002, CO6806, USRI/08/58, USRI/08/16,
USRI/08/46 and local cheek (Yar Ilela). The hybrids were sourced from University of Ilorin
Sugar Research Institute (USRI). One three-eyed cane sett was planted per stand and eight setts
per row. The gross plot was 17m x 45m (765m2), the plot had two-rows of 5m x 2m and 0.6m
intra-row and 1.5m inter-row.
Composite samples from the depth of 0-15cm and 15cm-30cm were taken at random, from the
experimental site. The samples were mixed in laboratory, air dried and sieved through 2mm
sieve and used for physical and chemical analysis. Soil pH was determined using pH meter, and
the particle size analysis was carried out using Bouyoucos hydrometer method (Bouyoucos,
1951), textural class was determined using textural triangle. Total nitrogen was determined by
macro-kjeldahl digestion distillation technique Page et al. (1982). Available phosphorous was
determined by Bray No.1 method (Bray and Kurtz, 1945), calcium, potassium, magnesium,
sodium, organic carbon and cation exchange capacity (C.E.C.) using a procedure prescribed by
Page et al. (1982). Result soil showed that the soil was clay-loam, the soil reaction was
moderately acidic and organic carbon was moderate. Total N. available, P. exchangeable K.
content were also moderate, CEC and exchangeable bases (Na, Ca and Mg) were moderate.
The land was prepared using hoe to make furrows on 10/11/2011. Transplanting, transplanting
was done at an intra-row spacing of 0.6m and inter-row spacing of 1.5m. Irrigation schedule,
irrigation was done weekly before the establishment of rain. Fertilizer application NPK fertilizer
at 150kg of N, 60kg of P2 05 and 90kgK2O was applied in equal halves (at split dose) at planting
and 10 weeks after planting. Weed control, pre-emergence herbicides 2,4-D amine and 2,4-D
ester were used and one supplementary hoe weeding was carried out at 15 weeks after planting.
Data were collected on sprout count, sprout count was taken at two, four and six weeks after
planting. Tiller count, tiller count was taken at three, six, nine and twelve months after planting.
Stalk length (cm), the sample of five stalks from the net plot were used to measure the length of
the stalk from the ground to the visible dewlap using a meter-rule. Number of stalks per stool,
this was done by counting the number of stalks per stool from five randomly selected stools per
net plot. Stalk weight (kg), five randomly selected stalks were cut at the base and each weight
was taken separately per net plot, using weighing scale. Millable stalk per plot, this was taken by
counting the total number of millable stalk per net plot (i.e. stalk >1.5cm diameter). Yield, the
yield of the net plot area was weighed and extrapolated to kg per hectare. Refractometer brix
(%), the final brix was taken before harvest, using a hand refractometer and Punch at 12 months
after planting. Data obtained were analyzed using the Statistical Analysis Systems (SAS) (2003).
Then the statistical model described by Bohren,et al.(1961) was used for the forms of general
analysis of variance.
120
121
Table 1: Showing form of Analysis of Variance (ANOVA)
SOURCE OF VARIATION
df
MS
EMS
Replication
(r-1)
M3
Genotype
(g-1)
M2
δ2g + r δ2g
Error
(g-1)(r-1)
M1
δ2e
Total
g(r-1)
Where: r = Number of replication
g =Number of genotypes
δ2g = Total genotypic variance among genotype
δ2e = error variance
M3=Replication mean square
M2=Genotype mean square
M1=Error mean square
EMS= Error mean square
Broad sense heritability were estimated using the formulae described by Fehr (1987)
h2 =δ2 g x 100
δ2ph
Where
δ2g =Genotypic Variance
δ2Ph= Phenotypic Variance
121
122
RESULTS
Estimate of broad- sense heritability (H2)
The result of broad-sense heritability of all the traits measured, revealed high heritability (H2 >
45%) for all characters under study, except for stalk crack with 20% and growth habit with very
low heritability of 8%.
Table 2. Genotypic, phenotypic variance and Broad sense heritability estimates for growth and
yield characters of 15 Sugarcane hybrids evaluated Usmanu Danfodiyo University, Sokoto
during 2011 and 2012 growing seasons.
Traits
Genotypic
variance
Phenotypic
variance
Heritability (%)
Sprout count at two weeks after planting
-0.005
0.019
-26.32
Sprout count at four weeks after planting
1.61
2.02
79.7
Sprout count at six weeks after planting
3.47
4.98
69.68
Tillers count at three months after planting
31.29
41.39
75.6
Tiller count at six months after planting
500.63
733.27
68.27
Tiller count at nine months after planting
501.27
665.72
75.3
Tiller count at 12 months after planting
456.28
619.65
73.64
Number of stalks per stool
15.35
15.74
97.52
Stalk length (m)
0.21
0.22
95.45
Stalk girth (cm)
0.11
0.12
91.67
Number of internodes per Stalk
4.71
5.24
89.89
Internode length
0.000022
0.000031
70.97
Smut
0.12
0.19
63.16
Root rot
0.26
0.48
54.17
Stalk crack
0.05
0.25
20
Number of milliable cane per plot
458.21
601.08
76.23
Final brix (%)
4.18
4.53
92.27
Single stalk weight (kg)
0.05
0.08
62.5
122
123
Total Cane weight per plot
-5487.86
33888.61
-16.19
Growth habit
0.02
0.25
8
Heritability (h2) ≥45 is significant (trait highly heritable)
Heritability (h2) ≤45 is not significant
Heritability ≤18 ( very low heritable traits)
DISCUSSION
Yield being a quantitative character, is the result of various characters working together during
the crop growth which are interdependent in their development, it is, therefore, desirable to study
the association between yield and yield attributing characters since this would facilitate effective
selection for simultaneous improvement of one or more yield influencing components because
the purpose of selection is to identify seedlings which are genetically superior, if that superiority
is genotypic in nature, the seedlings will reproduce its value faithfully in other environments,
however if on the contrary, the value is mainly environmental (Olaoye, 2009).
Broad sense heritability indicated that number of stalk/stool, stalk length, stalk girth and final
brix had high heritability estimates thereby suggesting that, selection for them will be relatively
easy. However, growth habit and crack on stalk had low heritability estimates which indicate that
selection for them will difficult. For sugarcane breeding programme to be successful it is
important to know which traits give the highest estimates of heritability, this is line with a
research conducted by Puri, et al. (1982) reported that if an estimate of broad-sense heritability
of a particular trait is high it indicates that environmental conditions have little impact on the
phenotypic differences observed in the population.
Stalk crack and growth habit had low heritability and would not respond to selection easily, as
reported by Obilana and Fakorede (1986) that, if a character is influenced by environment, its
heritability would be low in a population. However negative broad-sense heritability (H2)
estimate were observed in sprout count at two weeks after planting (-26.32 %) and total cane
yield (-16.19 %), this may be as a result of sampling error. This finding corroborates Gill (1968)
who reported that negative heritability estimate may be due to experimental/sampling error.
CONCLUSION
High broad-sense heritability indicated that four traits namely number of stalk/stool, stalk length,
stalk girth and final brix could serve as a breeding guide for selection.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We wish to acknowledge the Unilorin Sugar Research Institute (USRI) for producing the lines.
We also acknowledge Agricultural Research Council of Nigeria (ARCN), Abuja, for funding the
project.
123
124
REFERENCES
Barners, A.C. (1974). Sugarcane Plantation. John Wiley and Sons, New York, 145pp.
Bello M. S. (2006). Effect of spacing and Potassium on growth and yield of sweet Potato
(Ipomoea batatas (L.) LAM) in the Sudan savanna of Nigeria. Unpublished M sc. Thesis
Submitted to the Post graduate School of UsmanuDanfodiyo University Sokoto.85pp.
Bray, R. H. and Kurt, L. K. (1945). Determination of total organic and available forms of
phosphorous in the soils. Soil science, 69:39-45
Borhren, G.E., J. Eisner and A.M.Saxtion (1961).Genotype by environment interactions and
genetic correlation involving environment factors.Crops Science4:352-357.
Bouyoucos, G. H. (1951). A recalibration of the hydrometer for making chemical analysis of
soils. Agronomy Journal, 43:434-438.
Cox, M.; M. Hogarth; G. Smith, (2000). Cane breeding and improvement. "Manual of cane
growing", M Hogarth, P Allsopp, (Editors). Bureau of Sugar Experimental Stations,
Indooroopilly, Australia. 91-108.
FAOSTAT Data (2009) (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nation) Year book, I.
51,85pp.
Fehr, W. R. (1987). Principles of cultivator Development Theory and Technique1 Macmillan
Publishing Company New York,.U.S.A.536pp.
Gill, J. L. (1986) Probability of obtaining negative heritability. Biometrics vol.24, No.3 Dairy
Department, Michigan State University, East lansing , United State of America. 517pp
Hussain M.T. and Rehma F. (2001). Variability in sugarcane clones. Pakistan. Sugar Journal.
11(6), 27-31.
Obilana, A.T. and Fakorede, M.A.B.1986. Heritability: A Treatise. Samaru J. Agric. Res. 1: 72
82
Olaoye, G. (2004). Genetic variability between and within progenies of sugarcane crosses
developed by modified polycross method at seedling selection stage. Ghana Journal of
Agricultural Sciences 34:101-107.
Olaoye, G. (2009). Estimate of ratooning ability in sugarcane under conditions of low available
soil moisture in a savanna ecology of Nigeria. Moor Journal of Agriculture 6 (1):16-23
Page, A. L., Miller, R. H. and Keenney, D. R. (1982). Method of soil analysis: Agronomy
9, part-2, ASA, Madison, Wisconsin.
Puri, Y. P., Qualset, C. O., Williams, W. A. 1982. Evaluation of yield components as selection
criteria in barley breeding. Crop Sci. 22: 927-931
SAS (2003). Statistical Analysis System release 9.1 for Windows, SAS Institute. Inc. Carry, NC,
USA.
PGB27
ASSESSMENT OF PHENOTYPIC VARIATIONS IN FINGER MILLET (ELEUSINE
CORACANA(L) GAERTN) LANDRACES FROM NORTHERN NIGERIA.
Umar, I. D.1 and Kwon-Ndung, E. H.2
Plant Science and Biotechnology Unit, Deprtment of Biological Sciences, Nasarawa State University
Keffi. Nasarawa State.
1
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Abuja, Abuja, Nigeria.
2
Current Address: Department of Botany, Federal University, Lafia, Nigeria.
ABSTRACT
124
125
Germplasm identification and characterization is an important link between conservation and
utilization of plant genetic resources. The present study was conducted to assess the phenotypic
variation/diversity of 10 germplasm accessions of Finger millet (Eleusine coracana (L) Gaertn)
from diverse locations in the geographic region of Northern Nigeria during the 2008, 2009 and
2010 cropping seasons. Randomised Complete Block Design (RCBD) was used for a field study
in two locations Gwagwalada and Keffi and field data were analysed based on phenotypic
characters. Phenotypes were found to express significant diversity for plant height, 1000 seed
weight, leaf length and number of tillers. The results were analysed using ANOVA model and
showed that plant height in accession Ex-Kwi was significantly different from all the other nine
accessions while the highest leaf length which was recorded in Ex-Riyom was significantly
different (p<0.05) from accession Ex-Dantse. Similarly, significant variations were observed in
the number and length of fingers, and 1000 seed weight across all the accessions. Cluster
analyses revealed six distinct groups, with one landrace forming an independent colony. Our
results suggest a high phenotypic variability which could exist among the selected morphological
traits.
INTRODUCTION
In Nigeria, the finger millet plant is diverse and is popularly used without restriction in our
different multi-ethnic, multi-cultural and multi-religious groups. In various regions of the world
it is referred to as tamba (Nigeria), Ragi (India), Mandua Winbi (Swahili) bulo (Uganda),
kurakan (Sri Lanka), fingerhirse (German) (Dewet, 1976). Epidemiological evidence showed
that the plant is widespread and well adopted to diverse regions of the world. In East Africa, the
plant is known to originate from Ethiopia and then spread by geographic spatial pattern to
Southern African countries such as Namibia and Botswana. The plant is also well known and
grows well in Asian countries such as India and China, Middle East (Gupta, et al, 2010).
Germplasm identification in finger millet plant is an important link between conservation and
utilization of plant genetic resources. The usefulness of germplasm in the study of plant genetic
resources could play an important role in the generation of new hybrids and high yielding crop
varieties with disease resistant traits to cope with adverse challenges associated with biotic and
abiotic stress, (Murray, et al. 2008).
The problem of erosion of genetic diversity of finger millet in Nigeria as a result of large-scale
farming activities, urbanization and preferential land uses causes leaching, has gradually
destroyed the natural vegetation and transformed the farming systems and crop cultures and this
has positioned finger millet as threatened crop genetic resource (Fakrudin, et al., 2004). This
study was therefore conducted to assess the phenotypic properties of Nigerian finger millet crop.
The phenotypic characterization could also reveal the genetic relatedness within these species.
This will be useful in the conservation of new species and understanding of the genetic diversity
of the finger millet crop.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Field survey was conducted between November 2007 and February 2008. The 10 finger millet
(seeds) were randomly collected from local farmers in consultation with the Agricultural
Development Programme (ADP) in five states (Bauchi, Gombe, Nasarawa, Plateau and Kaduna)
125
126
and the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) Abuja, Nigeria. The Randomized Complete Block
Design (RCBD) was used to plant the finger millet seeds in the three cropping seasons in 2008 in
accordance with standard agricultural practices in two locations, Gwagwalada and Keffi. Each
plot consisted of 2m X 3m (6m2). Plant to plant spacing was maintained at 10cm in both
locations. A basal dose of NPK was applied 4 weeks after planting in both locations. Fertilizer
was applied at 100kg N (Nitrogen) 60kg K2O (Potassium) and 40kg, P2O5 (Phosphorus) in both
locations. Weeding was done at six weeks after planting in both locations. This field experiment
was repeated in the two locations in the 2009 and 2010 cropping seasons using the same
treatments and conditions and data were collected for all the seasons. Morphological traits such
as plant height, plant width, leaf length, leaf width, number of fingers, finger length and finger
width were determined and recorded in accordance with standard finger millet descriptors
(IBPGR/ICRISAT, 1985). The number of days to flowering was recorded for each plot as a
whole and the remaining characters were recorded on 10 randomly chosen plants per plot. The
number of fingers per panicle and number of productive tillers per plant were recorded. Mature
panicles or fingers were harvested, sundried and weighed to record panicle yield, and then
threshed to measure grain yield.
RESULTS
Table 1 shows the pooled means of morphological traits of finger millet accessions planted in
Northern Nigeria for the three cropping seasons. Plant height varied from 54.66cm in Ex-Dantse
to 64.96cm in Ex-Biliri with a mean value of 59.79cm across the ten accessions. Plant width
varied from 9.77cm in Ex-Andaha to 12.30cm in Ex-Tafawa Balewa with a mean of 11.07cm
across all the accessions. Leaf length varied from 49.02cm in Ex- Dantse to 58.20cm in ExRiyom with a mean of 53.53cm across the ten accessions. Leaf width varied from 1.30cm in ExTafawa Balewa to 1.94cm in Ex-Kwi and a mean of 1.51cm across all the accessions. Number of
fingers varied from 73.5 in Ex-Dantse to 171.5cm in Ex-Kwi and a mean of 105.1 across the ten
accessions. Finger length varied from 44.90cm in Ex-Gwagwalada to 99.25cm in Ex-Andaha
with a mean of 64.80cm across the ten accessions while the finger width ranged from 2.1cm in
Ex-Gura to 2.7cm in Ex-Riyom with a mean of 2.39cm across all the accessions. Number of ears
varied from 16.5 in Ex-Gwagwalada to 25.5 in Ex-Kwi with a mean value of 20.15 across the
accessions while 1000 seed weight varied from 150.9g in Ex-Gwagwalada to 275g in Ex-Andaha
with a mean value of 200.09g across the ten accessions.
Table 1: Pooled Means of Morphological traits of finger millet Accessions grown in
northern Nigeria in the three cropping seasons.
Accession
Ex-Dantse
Ex-Riyom
Ex-Bum
Ex-Gura
Plant
Heigh
t (cm)
54.66
60.33
56.33
59.16
Plant
width
(cm)
10.68
12.00
11.06
11.52
Leaf
Lengt
h (cm)
49.02
58.20
55.36
50.96
Leaf
width
(cm)
1.43
1.45
1.38
1.67
Number
of
Fingers
73.50
79.50
81.50
132.00
126
Finger
length
(cm)
61.30
79.35
60.95
64.65
Finger
width
(cm)
2.60
2.70
2.20
2.10
Number Seed
of Ears Weight
(1000)g
20.00
175.70
19.50
185.75
21.50
190.75
19.00
183.40
127
Ex-Kwakwi
Ex-Tafawa
Balewa
Ex-Biliri
ExGwagwalada
Ex-Andaha
Ex-Kwi
TOTAL
MEAN
S.E.
LSD(0.05)
CV (%)
58.28
59.05
10.42
12.30
55
54.29
1.57
1.30
115.50
102.50
61.15
51.65
2.30
2.20
20.00
21.00
210.95
200.80
64.96
60.47
11.78
10.15
54.32
53.16
1.38
1.50
77.50
85.00
54.00
44.90
2.40
2.60
19.00
16.50
180.90
150.90
58.26
62.50
567.9
59.79
3.38
6.48
11.54
9.77
11.39
110.74
11.07
0.32
0.48
6.85
50.24
54.15
535.3
53.53
3.37
7.61
6.05
1.57
1.94
15.50
1.51
0.106
0.184
3.064
132.50
171.50
1051.00
105.10
3.97
13.61
4.63
99.25
70.90
648.10
64.80
5.26
7.77
0.77
2.30
2.50
23.90
2.39
0.07
0.09
0.08
22.50
25.50
201.50
20.15
1.88
2.69
1.69
275.85
245.75
2000.0
200.09
3.38
32.54
16.55
Tree Diagram for 10 Variables
Single Linkage
Euclidean distances
70
Linkage Distance
60
50
40
30
Ex-Dantse
Ex-Biliri
Ex-Bum
Ex- Riyom
Ex-Kwakwi
Ex-Tafawa Balewa
Ex-Gura
Ex-Gwagwalada
Ex-Andaha
10
Ex-Kwi
20
Fig 1: Dendrogram of morphological characters showing the linkages among ten
accessions of finger millet grown in northern Nigeria for the three cropping seasons.
The lowest similarity was observed between Ex-Andaha and Ex-Gwagwalada (Fig.1). The
dendogram showed the highest genetic similarity between the germplasms Ex-Biliri, Ex-Bum
and Ex-Dantse. The population is divided into two germplasm which included a smaller
subgroup comprising of Ex-Kwi and Ex-Andaha. The other subgroup contains germplasm of
127
128
Ex-Gwagwalada and Ex-Gura; Ex-Tafawa Balewa and EX-Kwakwi; Ex-Riyom, Ex-Bum, ExBiliri and Ex-Dantse. Phenotypic relatedness was observed between Ex-Riyom, Ex-Bum ExBiliri and Ex-Dantse and maximum closeness was observed in Ex-Dantse, Ex-Biliri and ExBum, Ex-Riyom, Ex-Tafawa Balewa and Ex-Kwakwi Phenotypically, Ex-Tafawa Balewa, ExKwakwi, Ex-Riyom, Ex-Bum, Ex-Biliri and Ex-Dantse could constitute a specie where the
morphological differences amongst them are narrow or close.
DISCUSSION
Results of our assessments of 10 finger millet landraces using 9 morphological traits and weight
showed significant variations across all the 10 landraces of finger millet accessions within the
three cropping seasons (2008, 2009 and 2010) respectively. Our results agree with the earlier
findings of Mnyenyembe and Gupta (1998) and Upadhyaya, et al., (2007).
Evaluation of the phenotypic characters for the different accessions showed that the phenotype
could have genetic diversity for plant height, 1000 seed weight, leaf length and tillers than all the
other traits assessed in this trial.
Table 2 shows the genetic variability existing in the ten accessions used in this trial. Our research
concurs with Shahryani et al., (2011), Garavandi and Kabrizi (2010), who established genetic
diversity for plant height, 1000seed weight, spikelet in bread wheat genotypes and similar crops.
Kempana and Thirumalachar (1968), and Abraham et al. (1989) also found significant variation
for grain yield and number of productive tillers per plant. Josh and Mehra (1989) reported
significant genetic variation for days to flowering and other parameters as plant height, finger
length, number of fingers and phenotypic relatedness in finger millet accessions.
Upadhyaya et al. (2007) reported large phenotypic diversity in pearl millet germplasm especially
in terms of days to flowering, plant height, total tillers and 1000-seed weight which was also
observed in this work. Our findings also indicated that at the three year trials in both Keffi and
Gwagwalada locations, there were accessions that could flower as early as 60 days and others as
late as 120 days. Similarly, phenotypic variations were observed in plant diameter, leaf length,
number of fingers, number of ears and 1000seed weight. This exhibition of significant genetic
diversity observed in this report agrees with the work of Garavandi and Kabrizi, (2010) and
Shahryari, et al., (2011) who reported genetic biodiversity for plant height, 1000seed weight,
seed number, spikelet etc in bread wheat genotypes..
Table 2: Range of variation for important morphological characters in finger millet
accessions grown in Keffi and Gwagwalada, Northern Nigeria, for the 3 cropping seasons
Parameter
MIN
MAX
MEAN
VARIANCE
Time to flower (days)
60
120
97.67
11.43
Plant height (cm)
54.66
64.96
59.67±3.38
6.85
Plant diameter (cm)
9.77
12.30
11.07±0.32
6.08
Leaf length (cm)
49.00
55.30
53.50±3.37
6.05
128
129
Leaf diameter(cm)
1.30
1.94
1.51±0.11
3.06
Number of fingers
73.50
171.5
105.1±3.97
4.63
Length of fingers (cm)
44.90
99.25
64.80±5.26
0.77
Finger diameter (cm)
2.1
2.7
2.39±0.07
0.08
Number of ears
16.5
25.5
20.15±1.88
1.69
1000seed weight (g)
150.9
275.85 200.09±3.38 16.55
CONCLUSION
The objectives of this study have been modestly achieved. The results established the diversity
among the morphological traits and also determined the phylogenetic diversity of the plant using
cluster analysis. These results have clearly established the possibility of genetic variation and this
could be useful in ascertaining evolutionary diversion which occurs whenever mutation occurs.
Further studies should involve the identification of specific primers which could identify the
specific loci responsible for this diversity.
REFERENCES
Abraham, M. J., Gupta, A. S. and Sarma, B. K. (1989). Genetic variability and character
association of yield and its components in finger millet (Eleusine coracana) in an acidic
soil of Meghalaya. Indian journal of agricultural Sciences 59:579-581.
Fakrudin, B., Shashidhar, H., Kulkarni, R. and Hittalmani, S. (2004). Genetic diversity
assessment of finger millet, Eleusine coracana germplasm through RAPD analysis. Plant
Genetic Resources Newsletter, 138: 50–54.
Garavandi, M. and Kabrizi, M. (2010). Evaluation of genetic diversity of bread wheat genotypes
for phenologic and morphologic traits. The 11th Crop Science and Plant Breeding Congress
Iran. Pp537-541.
Gupta, R. , Krishan, V., Dinesh, Y. and Munna, S. (2010). Assessment of Genetic Relatedness
among Three Varieties of Finger Millet with Variable Seed Coat Color Using RAPD and
ISSR Markers. Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology Journal, 2
IBPGR. (1985). Descriptors for finger millet (Eleusine coracana (L.) Gaetn). Rome, Italy: Int.
Board for Plant Genetic Resources. 20pp.
Josh, H. C. and Mehra, H. S. (1989). Investigations on variation, heritability and genetic
advances in ragi germplasm from Uttar Pradesh hills. In: Proceedings of a National
Seminar on Finger Millet Genetics and Breeding in India, UAS, Bangalore, India.
Seetharam, A. and Gowda, B T S (Eds), pp73-75.
Kempana, C. and Thirumalachar, D. K. (1968). Studies on the genotypic variation in ragi
(Eleusine coracana). Mysore Journal of Agricultural Sciences 2:29-34.
McCune, B., and Grace, J. B., (2002). Analysis of Ecological Communities. MjM Software
Design: Gleneden Beach, Oregon, 300 p.
Mnyenyembe, P.H. and Gupta, S.C. (1998). Variability for grain yield and related traits in finger
millet germplasm accessions from Malawi. Africa Crop Science Journal, (6)3:317-322.
129
130
Murray, S. Sharma, A. Rooney, W. and Klein, P. (2008). Genetic improvement of sorghum as a
biofuel feedstock. Crop Sci. 48:2165-2179.
Shahryari, R., Behnam, M., Vahid, M. and Majid, K. (2011). Genetic Diversity in Bread Wheat
for Phenological and Morphological Traits under Terminal Drought Stress Condition.
Advances in Environmental Biology, 5(1): 169-172.
Upadhyaya, H.D, Gowder, C.L.L. and Gopal, V.R. (2007). Morphological diversity in finger
millet germplasm introduced from Southern and Eastern Africa Ejournal.icrisat.org. vol.
3(1).
PGB28
EVALUATION OF GENETIC VARIANCE AND HERITABILITY OF AGRONOMIC AND YIELD TRAITS IN
PIGEON PEA- CAJANUS CAJAN (L.) MILLSP. (FABACEAE)
Olawuyi, O.J.*, Fawole, I. and Babalola, B.J.
*
Department of Botany, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria. 2Department of Crop Protection
and Environmental Biology, University of Ibadan, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: olawuyiodunayo@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
The selection of useful traits is necessary to achieve any breeding objective. Therefore, plot trials
were carried out in research farm of the Department of Botany, University of Ibadan for two
years. The study aimed at evaluating the components of genetic variance and heritability of some
agronomic and yield related traits of some accessions in pigeon pea. The result showed
variations in mean values of traits ranging from 0.15 ± 0.00 to 166.34 ± 1.6. Accessions CL13
and 26 produced higher seed yield per pod (0.2g) compared to other accessions. CL 26 had the
highest stem length at maturity (179.5cm), while the highest number of plant per pod (85.5) was
recorded for CL 29. Stem length at maturity had the highest values of the phenotypic variance,
genetic variance and environmental variance. The heritability estimate of traits ranges between
54-99%.The accessions were highly significant (P<0.01) for most of the agronomic and yield
related traits.
Keywords: accessions, pigeon pea, traits, heritability
INTRODUCTION
Pigeon pea (Cajanus cajan L.) is one of the most important leguminous plants with high
nutritional, medicinal and economic values. It is widely used in improving the soil fertility
(Olawuyi and Fawole, 2005). The leaves are used in treatment of some skin and respiratory
infections, while an aqueous infusion of seeds mixed with leaves are also used in management of
genetic disorder (Dhar, 1968; Owere et al., 2000). The breeding of pigeon pea for early and
maturing traits, tolerance to drought, pests, diseases and characterization of morphological and
yield related traits have been attributed to the success of this crop (Odeny, 2000; Kimani et al.,
2000). The correlation coefficient, principal component analysis and character association of
some pigeon pea genotypes have been reported (Kharif et al., 1973; Kimani, 2000). But the
evaluation of the components of genetic variance has not been widely explored. The limited
improved varieties of pigeon pea also necessitate the selection of genetically influenced yield
components for germplasm improvement. Therefore, this study estimated the genetic parameters
of some agronomic and yield related traits in pigeon pea.
130
131
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A field experiment was conducted at the nursery farm of the Department of Botany, University
of Ibadan (latitude 7o 20’N and longitude 3 o 54’E, 200m above sea level), Nigeria for two years
(2002 and 2003). The four accessions ( CL 1, CL 13, CL 26 and CL 29) evaluated in this study
were the breeding products obtained from the collection maintained in the Department of
Botany, University of Ibadan. The accessions were grown on the field using randomized
complete block design with three replicates. Each plot consisted of three rows spaced at 0.75m
between and 0.5m within rows. Two seeds from each accession were planted at 2-3 cm depth
from the soil, but thinned to one three weeks after planting. Agronomic practices were duly
carried out.
Data were collected on Number of days from sowing to: emergence (DSE), production of
primary leaflets (DSP), production of first flower (DSF), production of first pod (DSP), number
of branches at production of first flower (NBF), number of flowers (NOF), stem length at
maturity (SLM), stem diameter at maturity (SDM), length of pods per plant (LPP), width of pods
per plant (WPP), number of seeds per pod (NSP), seed weight per plant (SWP), pod weight per
plant (PWP), number of pods per plant at maturity (NPM), Total number of pods per plant at
harvesting (NPP), leaf length at maturity (LLM), leaf width at maturity (LWM) and seed weight
per pod (SW). The data were subjected to analysis of variance with Statistical Analysis System
package (SAS, 1999). Genetic component of variation and broad sense heritability estimates
were determined according to the procedure of Johnson et al. (1955), Singh and Chaudhary
(1985).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The range, mean, standard errors of ten growth and yield traits are shown in Table 1. A wide
range was observed for most of the traits. The total number of pods per plant at harvesting (NPP)
had the highest range of 45- 85.5, while seed weight per pod (0.1-0.2) g was the least. The mean
values of all the traits were higher than their respective standard errors. The coefficient of
variation for the different traits ranged from 0.00% for seed weight per pod (SW) to 15.6% for
number of seeds per pod (NSP). The stem length at maturity (SLM) and NPP showed the highest
mean performance of 166.34cm and 60.63 respectively. Accessions CL13 and CL26 produced
higher seed weight per pod (0.2g) compared to other accessions. CL26 had the highest stem
length at maturity (179.5cm), while CL29 produced the highest number of pods per plant at
harvesting. CL26 also performed best for all the traits except seed weight per plant. The lower
values of coefficient of variation (CV) are indices of experimental reliability (Gomez and
Gomez, 1984). The range of CV which varies from 0 to 15.6% could be attributed to high
magnitude of genotypic variation found in most of the traits for different accessions.
The mean squares from the analysis of variance for agronomic traits are shown in Table 2.
Highly significant differences (p<0.01) were observed in six traits; number of days from sowing
to production of first pod (DSP), number of flowers (NOF), leaf length at maturity (LLM), leaf
width at maturity (LWM), stem length at maturity (SLM) and stem diameter at maturity ( SDM),
but significantly different (p<0.05) for three traits; number of days from sowing to production of
first flower (DSF), number of branches at production of first flower (NBF) and height at first
flowering (HFF), while number of days from sowing to emergence (DSE) and number of days
from sowing to production of secondary leaflets (DSS) did not show significant differences. The
significant variations could be as a result of genetic contribution of the accessions to the yield
131
132
components. This enhances selection of best accessions with quality morphological traits, and
contributes to their diversities.
The estimates of phenotypic variance, genotypic variance, environmental variance and
heritability of ten yield related traits are shown in Table 3. The genotypic variances were high in
stem length at maturity, number of pods per plant at maturity (NPM) and total number of pods
per plant at harvesting compared to other traits. The genotypic variances were higher than the
environmental variances in all the traits. The stem length at maturity had the highest value of
phenotypic variance (968.70), genotypic variance (957.10) and environmental variance (11.60).
The heritability of the traits ranged between 54-99%. High heritability estimates was observed
for most of the traits. The SDM, NPP, NSP and length of pods per plant (LPP) had the highest
heritability estimate of 99%, while seed weight per pod (SW) had the least (54%).
Higher phenotypic variance than genotypic variance could be due to the interaction of
environmental components as similarly observed by Oseni and Khadir (1994) and Nguru (1995).
The moderately high genotypic variance in some traits indicated that attention should be given to
the improvement of traits by combining other traits to enhance greater yield. The lower values of
environmental variance in the traits are an indication of little or no effect of environmental
factors as similarly conforms to the findings of Abubakar and Samarawira (1989). High
heritability estimates show high measure of variation which could be as a result of an additive
gene effect. This enhances effective selection of desirable accession for improvement of traits as
similarly reported by Pathak and Dikit (1992).
The result of mean square of eight yield related traits in Table 4 shows that five traits; NPM,
NPP, LPP, NSP and SW produced highly significant (p<0.01) effect, while significant
differences (p<0.05) were shown for three traits; width of pods per plant (WPP), seed weight per
plant (SWP) and pod weight per plant (PWP). This is in accordance with the report of Omoigui
et al. (2006).
CONCLUSION
From the results, highly significant effect produced by the accessions indicated genetic
variability that exist for most of the agronomic and yield related traits. The components of
variance and heritability estimates were models which could be considered in selection of
suitable traits and accessions for yield improvement.
REFERENCES
Abubakar, Y. and Samarawira, I. (1989). Contribution of male and female date palms (Phoenix
dactylifera L.) towards the genetic variance in fruit traits. Proceedings International
conference on palms and palm products NIFOR 1:104-110
Dhar, M.L. (1968). Phenotypic characterization of Pigeon pea. Indian Journal of Experimental
Biology 15: 208-210
Gomez, K.A and Gomez, A.A (1984). Statistical procedures for agricultural research 2nd Ed.
John Wiley& Sons, Chichester. UK 680pp.
Johnson, H.W., Robinson, H.P., Comstock, R.E. (1955). Estimates of genetic and environmental
variability in Soya beans. Agron. J. 47: 314-318
Kharif, O., Kumar, A., Hague, M.F. (1973). Variability and correlation studies in F2 population
of pigeon pea (Cajanus cajan L.) Millsp. Madras Agricultural Journal 7:174-183
Kimani, P.M. (2000). Pigeon pea breeding objectives, experiences and strategies for Eastern
132
133
Africa. In: Silim S.N, Mergeai, G and Kimani, A.G (eds), Pigeon pea. Status and potential
in Eastern and Southern Africa. Gembloux Agric Univ. and International Crop Research
Institute for Semi-arid Tropics pp 21-31.
Kimani, P.M., Mergeai, G., Baudoin, J.P., Rubaihayo, P.R., Janssens, M. (2000). New region
initiatives in pigeon pea improvement In: Silim S.N., Mergeai, G., Kimani, A.G (eds),
pigeon pea. Status and potential in Eastern and Southern Africa. Gembloux Agric Univ.
and International Crop Research Institute for Semi-arid Tropics pp 34-40
Nguru, M.I. (1995). Heritable relationships and variability of yield and yield components in
vegetable cowpeas. African Crop Science J. 3:23-28
Odeny, D.A. (2000). Inheritance of resistance to Fusarium wilts in pigeon pea. In Silim, S.N.,
Mergeai, G. and Kimani, P.M (eds), Pigeon pea status and potential in Eastern and Southern
Africa. Gembloux Agric Univ. and International Crop Research Institute for Semi-arid
Tropics pp 43-47
Olawuyi, O.J and Fawole, I. (2005). Studies on genetic variability of some quantitative and
qualitative characters in pigeon pea- Cajanus cajan (L.) Millsp. (Fabaceae). Acta SATECH
2(1): 30-36
Omoigui, L.O., Ishiyaku, M.F., Kamara, A.Y., Alabi, S.O., Mohammed, S.G (2006). Genetic
variability and heritability studies of some reproductive traits in cowpea (Vigna
unguiculata (L.) Walp). African Journal of Biotechnology 5(13): 1191-1195
Oseni, H.E and Khadir, M.O (1994). Estimate of genetic and environmental variability in
sesame. Experimental Agriculture 10:105-122
Owere, L., Rubaihayo, P.R., Osiru, D.S.O (2000). Cereal-pigeon intercropping systems: the
Uganda experience. In: In Silim, S.N., Mergeai, G. and Kimani, P.M (eds), Pigeon pea
status and potential in Eastern and Southern Africa. Gembloux Agric Univ. and
International Crop Research Institute for Semi-arid Tropics pp 84-89
Pathak, H.C and Dikit, S. K (1992). Genetic variability and inter-relation studies in black seeded
sesame (Sesamum indicum L.). Mandras Agric. Journal 79(1): 94-100
Statistical Analysis System (1999). Proprietary Software Release 8.2 (TS2M0), SAS users
Guide. Statistical Analysis Institute Inc., Cary, North Carolina, USA.
Singh, R.K. and Chaudhary, B.D. (1985). Biometrical methods in quantitative genetic analysis.
Kalyani publishers. Newdelhi pp 7-19
133
134
Table 1: Ranges, means and coefficient of variation of growth and yield traits in
pigeon pea
accessions
___________________________
Traits
CL 26 CL29
Range
Mean + S.E
C.V (%)
SLM (cm)
179.5 170
152- 179.5
166.34 ± 1.60
1.92
162
152
6.35- 7.40
6.86 ± 0.13
3.79
6.40
6.35
7.20-8.10
7.66 ± 0.10
2.61
7.20
7.60
0.85- 1.15
0.99 ± 0.04
8.10
4.60-5.50
5.00 ± 0.39
15.60
4.60
4.80
0.55-1.00
0.79 ± 0.03
7.60
0.55
0.65
0.60-1.10
1.03 ± 0.04
7.77
SDM (cm)
7.40
CL1
CL 13
7.30
LPP(cm)
8.10
7.75
WPP (cm)
1.15
1.00
NSP
5.50
5.10
0.95
1.00
1.65
1.10
SWP (g)
PWP (g)
NPM
0.85
0.75
0.95
0.60
15-25
19.38 ± 1.22
12.59
15
17
25
NPP
85.5
45-85.5
60.63 ± 1.12
3.70
48
45
64
SW (g)
0.1-0.2
0.00
0.1
20.5
0.2
0.15 ± 0.00
0.2
0.1
Stem length at maturity (SLM), stem diameter at maturity (SDM), length of pods per
plant (LPP), width of pods per plant (WPP), number of seeds per pod (NSP), seed weight
per plant (SWP), pod weight per plant (PWP), number of pods per plant at maturity
(NPM), Total number of pods per plant at harvesting (NPP) and seed weight per pod
(SW)
134
135
Table 2: Mean squares of eleven agronomic traits in pigeon pea
Source of variation df
LWM SLM SDM
NOF HFF
DSE
Entries
3
1.32* 1.47** 1.41*
0.13** 0.11** 1.59** 0.13**
0.54**
1.98* 0.64ns 1.04ns
Error
0.00
0.00 0.02 0.14
1
DSF
0.00
DSP
0.00
NBF
0.01
DSS LLM
0.07
0.03
0.01 0.00
Total
4
*, ** Significantly different at p<0.05 and p< 0.01 levels of probability respectively.
Number of days from sowing to: emergence (DSE), production of primary leaflets
(DSP), production of first flower (DSF), production of first pod (DSP), number of
branches at production of first flower (NBF), number of flowers (NOF), stem length at
maturity (SLM), stem diameter at maturity (SDM), leaf length at maturity (LLM), leaf
width at maturity (LWM).
Table 3: Phenotypic, genetic variance, environmental variance and heritability of
ten yield related traits in pigeon pea
Genetic parameters Phenotypic variance genotypic variance environmental
variance
heritability (H2b) %
SLM (cm)
968.70
957.10
11.60
0.48
0.479
0.001
2.51
2.507
0.003
0.04
0.033
0.007
0.02
0.018
0.002
98.0
SDM (cm)
99.0
LPP(cm)
99.0
WPP(cm)
83.0
SWP(cm)
90.0
PWP(g)
0.002
0.0015
0.001
75.0
SW(g)
10.54
5.69
4.85
1.06
1.058
0.002
60.68
53.75
6.93
712.39
706.68
5.71
54.0
NSP
99.0
NPM
89.0
NPP
99.0
135
136
Stem length at maturity (SLM), stem diameter at maturity (SDM), length of pods per
plant (LPP), width of pods per plant (WPP), number of seeds per pod (NSP), seed weight
per plant (SWP), pod weight per plant (PWP), number of pods per plant at maturity
(NPM), Total number of pods per plant at harvesting (NPP) and seed weight per pod
(SW)
Table 4: Mean squares of eight yield related traits in Pigeon pea
Source of variation df
NPM NPP
Entries
3
1.22** 1.12** 0.11** 0.14* 0.39** 0.30* 0.40* 0.10**
Error
1
0.00
Total
4
0.00
LPP
0.00
WPP NSP
0.00
0.00
SWP PWP SW
0.00
0.01
0.00
*, ** significantly different at p<0.05 and p<0.01 levels of probability respectively.
Length of pods per plant (LPP), width of pods per plant (WPP), number of seeds per pod
(NSP), seed weight per plant (SWP), pod weight per plant (PWP), number of pods per
plant at maturity (NPM), Total number of pods per plant at harvesting (NPP) and seed
weight per pod (SW)
PGB29
HERITABILITY ESTIMATES FOR BIOMASS PRODUCTION IN LOCAL
SORGHUM (SORGHUM BICOLOR L. MOENCH) OF SOME SELECTED
STATES IN NORTH-WESTERN NIGERIA
Abubakar, L.1* and Bubuche, T.S.2
1
Department of Crop Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Usman Danfodiyo University,
P.M.B. 2346, Sokoto State, Nigeria.
2
Department of Agricultural Education, College of Education, P.M.B. 1012, Argungu,
Kebbi State, Nigeria
Corresponding e-mail:dr.lawaliabubakar@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Ten local Sorghum varieties were evaluated at Usmanu Danfodiyo University, teaching
and research farm, Sokoto, Sokoto State during the 2010 rainy season and at Bubuche, in
Augie Local Government Area, Kebbi State during the 2011 rainy season, all in North
Western, Nigeria. The treatments were laid out in a Randomized Complete Block Design
(RCBD) with three replications. The study revealed that high narrow sense heritability
estimates of 90.67 % were observed on flag leaf area, leaf length 65.82%, straw weight
61.48%, plant height 52.95% and flag leaf length 51.54%. Leaf area index recorded
36.84% narrow sense heritability, while leaf number had 10%, 100- seed weight 15.93%
and total grain yield recorded 16.24%. The study therefore indicates that selection for
biomass related characters can easily be carried out among the local Sorghum germplasm
of North Western, Nigeria.
Key words: Biomass; Heritability; North-Western Nigeria; Production; Sorghum,
INTRODUCTION
Sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L. Moench) belongs to family Poaceae (Gramineae) with
Chromosome number 2n = 20 (Dogget, 1970). Origin and geographical distribution of
136
137
sorghum, in both cultivated and wild types found in north-eastern part of Africa (Biswas
et al., 2001). It is an important staple food crops and provide bulk of raw materials for
the livestock and many agro-allied industries in the world (Dogget, 1970). An estimated
55,721,588 tonnes were produced worldwide, harvested from 40,935,896 hectares in
2010, with an average yield of 13,612 kg/ha, the African total production for the year
2010 was 211,107,724 tonnes harvested from 24,837,754 hectares at an average yield of
8,498 kg/ha. In Nigeria the total production was 4,784,100 tonnes, harvested
from4,736,730 hectares at an average yield of 10,100 kg/ha (FAOSTAT, 2010).
The degree of correspondence between phenotype and genotype is measured by
heritability of the trait. Statistically heritability is a regression coefficient of genotype on
phenotype. Theoretically, heritability ranges from 0 to 1, but the extreme values are very
rare (Ferh, 1987). A particular heritability value is for a particular trait in a particular
population at a particular time. This is so because the gene frequency varies from
population to population. The diversity of Sorghum expresses a wide range of heritability
and adaptability to different conditions, including different genotypes from early to late
maturing, dwarf to tall, loose to compacted panicles, white and red seeded and plant
breeders are interested in developing cultivars with improved yield and other desirable
agronomic characters. In order to achieve this goal, the breeders should determine
heritability of the desirable traits for genotypes before selection (Puri, et al., 1982). The
selection criteria may be yield, or one or more of the yield component characters.
However, breeding for high yield crops require information on the nature and magnitude
of variation in the available materials, relationship of yield with other agronomic
characters and the degree of environmental influence on the expression of these
component characters, since grain yield in sorghum is quantitative in nature and
polygenically controlled, effective yield improvement and simultaneous improvement in
yield components are imperative (Bello and Olaoye, 2009). Heritability is a measure of
the extent to which observed phenotypic differences for a trait are due to genetic
differences. There are two commonly used measures of heritability, broad-sense (H2)
and narrow-sense (h2) heritability. Broad-sense heritability measures the proportion of
phenotypic difference (VP) that is due to variation in genetic factors for a single
population under the limits of the environment during the experiment. An estimate of
broad-sense heritability near 1.0 indicates that environmental conditions have little
impact on the phenotypic differences observed in the population; an estimate near 0.0
indicates that the environment is almost solely responsible for the differences (Puri, et
al., 1982). Broad-sense heritability is considered to be the sum of additive variance (VA),
dominance variance (VD) and interactive variance (VI); thus, H2=VA+VD+VI. Broadsense heritability estimates are less accurate than narrow-sense heritability ones in
estimating the selection potential of quantitative traits since calculations take into
account all forms of genetic variation, not just additive genetic effects. Conversely,
narrow-sense heritability excludes dominance and interactive variance, leaving only
additive variance; thus, H2=VA=VA/VP. Narrow-sense heritability estimates are useful
for predicting the phenotypes of offspring during selection procedures; the closer the
heritability to 1.0, the greater one’s ability to make an accurate prediction of the
phenotype of the offspring based on the knowledge of parental phenotypes There are two
major methods for estimating heritability; one uses correlation and regression among
related individuals to estimate heritability (Puri, et al., 1982).
137
138
The objective of the research was to determine narrow sense heritability estimates for
traits associated with biomass production in North Western, Nigeria, an area where crop
cultivation have become incorporated with livestock rearing.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Ten local sorghum landraces were evaluated during the 2010 rainy season at Usmanu
Danfodiyo University, teaching and research farm, Sokoto, Sokoto State and during the
2011 rainy season at Bubuche, in Augie Local Government Area, Kebbi State, all in
North-Western Nigeria. Sokoto is located in the Sudan Savanna agro-ecological zone of
Nigeria on latitude 130 01 N; longitude 50 15 E and altitude of about 350m above sea
level (ASL). Mean annual rainfall is about 752 mm. The minimum and maximum
temperatures are 260 and 350, respectively, and relative humidity of 23-41%. The area is
characterized by long dry season with cool air during Hammattan (November –
February), dry air during hot season from March – May followed by a short rainy season,
(Bello, 2006) and Bubuche is located in Augie local government area of Kebbi State on
latitude 130 05 N ; longitude 4012 E and altitude of 345m above the sea level,
temperature ranges from 270-340 and relative humidity of 24-44% with mean annual
rainfall of 6700-7600mm (Anon, 2009). The texture of the soil was loamy sand and the
soil is deep, loose and well drained, chemical analysis shows that the soil is slightly
acidic, low to medium in organic carbon, low total nitrogen, low exchangeable cat ions
low in cat ions exchange capacity (CEC), very low available P and K Ca and Mg
contents and low Bulk density.
The materials used in the study consisted of ten indigenous grain sorghum genotypes
representing the types widely grown in North-Western Nigeria, which were collected by
the National Center for Genetic Resources and Biotechnology (NACGRAB), Moor
plantation, Ibadan, Nigeria (Table, 1).
The experiment was laid out in a Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) in three
replications. Each pot size was 6m x 3m, 75cm as inter row spacing and intra-row
spacing of 30cm and a total of 240 plants per plot after thinning were used. Before
sowing, seeds were treated with Apron-plus 3g/kg seed against soil fungi and insects.
Sowing was on 10Th of June, 2010 and 2011. Five seeds were sown in each hole.
Seedlings were thinned to three plants per hole after three weeks from sowing. Hand
hoeing weeding practiced trice, the first one was two weeks after sowing and the
subsequent weeding were carried out at three weeks interval.
Data were collected on days to 50% flowering (DF), plant height (PH), and leaf
characteristics including leaf length (LL), leaf number (LN), leaf area index (LAI), flag
leaf area (FLA) and flag leaf length (FLL). At maturity, total grain yield (TGY), 100grain weight (HGW) and straw weight (STRAW-WT0 were recorded at both locations
and during both seasons in accordance with the procedure outlined in the
IBGR/ICRISAT sorghum descriptor (IBPGR and ICRISAT 1993). Leaf area (LA) per
plant was calculated on the basis of the length and width of the third top leaf multiplied
by the total number of leaves and a coefficient of 0.71 ( Krishnamurthy, et al., 1974).
Individual analysis of variance was performed for all traits on each location according to
the procedure described by Gomez and Gomez (1984) for the randomized complete
block design. The combined analysis of variance was done, for all traits, following the
138
139
method described by LeC lerg et al. (1962), based on a randomized complete block
design. For mean comparison, the means were separated using Duncans Multiple Range
Test (DMRT) at 0.05 level of significant, according to the procedure described by
Gomez and Gomez (1984).
Phenotypic and Genotypic Variances
Phenotypic (σ2ph) and genotypic (σ2g) variances were estimated using individual
analysis of variance as follows:
σ2g = M2-M3
r
σ2ph = σ2g + σ2e
Where: σ2e: is the error variance (M3) for RCBD.
Narrow sense heritability estimate
Narrow sense heritability will be estimated using the formulae described by Fehr (1987)
h2 =δ2 A
δ2ph
Where
δ2A = Additive Variance
δ2Ph= Phenotypic Variance
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
High narrow sense heritability values were observed on flag leaf area (90.67%), leaf
length (65.82%), straws weight (61.48%), plant height (52.95%) and flag leaf length
(51.54%) (Table 5). The result suggests that selection for these traits will be easy and as
such the cultivars used in the study are potentially useful in breeding programme for
enhanced biomass production. Similarly leaf area index recorded 36.84% narrow sense
heritability. Similar results were obtained by William et al. (1987), Khaliq et al. (2008)
in their study which revealed that, characters such as plant height, days to 50%
flowering, flag leaf area, flag leaf length and leaf length would respond positively to
selection when selected, because of their high heritability, this also agreed with the
findings of Eckebil et al. (1997), Totok (1997) and Biswas et al. (2001).
However, leaf number (10%), 100- seed weight (15.93%) and total grain yield (16.24%)
heritability were not significant and would not respond to selection easily because of
their low heritability estimates. Similar results were observed by Bello et al. (2001) and
Bello et al. (2007), when they reported low heritability estimates of grain yield is due to
the direct or indirect multiplicative effects of several yield components on grain yield.
Similarly Obilana and Fakorede (1986) reported that, if a character is influenced by
environment, its heritability would be low in a population in which plant environments
vary widely.
CONCLUSION
High narrow sense heritability estimates were observed for flag leaf area, leaf length,
straw weight, plant height and flag leaf length all of which are good determinants of
biomass production. The study therefore concludes that these traits will definitely
respond positively to selection, it also indicates that environmental conditions have little
139
140
impact on the traits. Breeding for high biomass production in the sorghum germplasm of
North Western, Nigeria is therefore possible.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We wish to acknowledge the National Center for Genetic Resource and Biotechnology
(NACGRAB), Moor Plantation, Ibadan, Nigeria for supplying the germplasm materials
for this research.
Table1. Sorghum landraces used in the study
S/No
Name
Area Collected
1
Zago.Ex-BATSARI
2
3
4
5
Major Use
Katsina State
Grain
Colour
Brown
NG/SA/07/005
NG/SA/07/125
NGB/06/001
NG/SA/DEC/07/0049
Niger State.
Zamfara State
Kaduna State
Niger State
White
White.
White
White
Food
Food
Food
Food
6
7
NG/SA/DEC/07/0108
NG/SA/DEC/07/0213
Niger State
Kaduna State
White
White
Food
Food
8
NG/SA/DEC/070123
Kano State
White
Food
9
NG/SA/DEC/07/0036
Niger State
White
Food
Food
10
EX-ARGUNGU (Kaura)
Kebbi State
Red
Food
Table 2: Narrow Sense Heritability estimate for Ten Sorghum Traits Evaluated during
2010 rainy season at Sokoto and during 2011 rainy season at Bubuche Combined.
Traits
Phenotypic variance
Genotypic variance
Narrow
Sense
Heritability (%)
LN
2.01
0.21
10
LL
58.05
38.21
65.82
PH
LAI
815.85
0.19
432.05
0.07
52.95
36.84
FLA
8133.7
7374.6
90.67
FLL
STRAWWT
18.49
9.53
51.54
2.44
1.5
61.48
100-GWT
11.11
1.77
15.93
TGY
731528.42
118795.75
2
Heritability (h ) ≥45 is significant (trait highly heritable)
Heritability (h2) between 18 and 35 is nearly significant
Heritability ≤18 is not significant (lowly heritable traits)
140
16.24
141
REFERENCES
Anon 2009. Kebbi State Diary. 218pp
Bello M. S. 2006. Effect of spacing and Potassium on growth and yield of sweet Potato
(Ipomoea batatas (L.) LAM) in the Sudan savanna of Nigeria. Unpublished M sc.
thesis Submitted to the Post graduate School of Usmanu Danfodiyo University
Sokoto.85pp.
Bello, D., Kadams, A.M. and Simon, S.Y. (2001). Correlation and Path Coefficient
analysis of grain yield and its components in Sorghum. Nig. J. Trop. Agric., 3: 49.
Bello, D., Kadams, A.M., Simon, S.Y. and Mashi, D.S. 2007. Studies on Genetic
Variability in Cultivated Sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L. Moench) Cultivars of
Adamawa State Nigeria. American-Eurasian J. Agric. & Environ. Sci. 2 (3):
297-302
Bello, O. B. and Olaoye, G. Combining ability for maize grain yield and other agronomic
characters in a typical southern guinea savanna ecology of Nigeria. Afr. J.
Biotechnol. 2009; 8 (11): 2518-2522
Biswas, B.K., M. Hasanuzzaman, F. Eltaj, M.S. Alam and Amin, M.R. 2001.
Simultaneous selection for Genetic variability for some physiological and fodder
and grain yield in sorghum. J. Biol. Sci., 1: agronomic traits in grain sorghum.
Crop Res. J., 319-320
Dogget, H. 1970. Sorghum. Longmans, London. P.403
Eckebil, J.P., Ross, M.W., Gardnerand, C.O. and Maranville, J.W. (1997). Heritability
estimates, genetic correlation and predicted gains from S . progeny test in
sorghum in three grain sorghum population. Crop Sci. J. ; 17: 373-377
Fakorede, M. A. B., Opeke, B. O. 1985. Weather factors affecting the response of maize
to planting dates in tropical rain forest location. Exp. Agric. 21: 31-40
FAOSTAT Data 2010. (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nation) Year
book I. 51-85.
Fehr, W. R. (1987). Principles of cultivator Development Theory and Technique1
Macmillan Publishing Company New York,.U.S.A.536pp.
Gomez, K. A. and Gomez, A. A. 1984. Statistical Procedures for Agricultural Research
.Second Edition, John Wiley and Sons, New York. P.1-250.
IBPGR and ICRISAT 1993. Descriptors for sorghum [ Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench].
International Board for Plant Genetic Resources, Rome,Italy. – ICRISAT,
Patancheru, India. P.1-26
Khaliq, I., A. Irshad and M. Ahsan, 2008. Awns and flag leaf contribution
towards grain yield in spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Cer. Res.
Commun., 36: 65–76
Krishnamurthy, K., Jagannath, M. K., Rajashekara, B. G. 1974. Estimation of leaf area in
grain sorghum from single leaf measurements. – Agron. J. 66: 544 – 545
Leclerg, E. L., Leonard, W. H. and Clark, A. G. 1962. Field plot technique .Second ed.
Burgass publishing Co., Minneapolis, Minnesota. 212pp
Obilana, A.T. and Fakorede, M.A.B.1986. Heritability: A Treatise. Samaru J. Agric.
Res. 1: 72-82
Puri, Y. P., Qualset, C. O., Williams, W. A. 1982. Evaluation of yield components as
selection criteria in barley breeding. Crop Sci. 22: 927-931
141
142
Totok, A.D.H. 1997. Estimating heritability values and genetic correlation, in several
agronomic. characters. Am. J. Bot. 87: 145
William, W.T., C.A.P. Boundy and Millington, A.J. 1987. The effect of sowing date on
the growth and yield of three sorg-hum cultivars. The component of growth and
yield. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 28: 381-387
PGB30
RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN NORMALIZED DIFFERENCE VEGETATION
INDEX (NDVI) AND OTHER TRAITS OF TROPICAL TESTCROSS MAIZE
HYBRIDS UNDER DROUGHT AND WELL-WATERED CONDITIONS
Adebayo, M.A.1, 2, Menkir, A.2, and Hearne, S.3
1
Department of Crop Production and Soil Science, Ladoke Akintola University of Technology
(LAUTECH),
Ogbomoso, Nigeria
2
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), Ibadan, Nigeria
3
International Centre for Maize and Wheat Improvement (CIMMYT), Mexico,
Corresponding e-mail: adebayovam@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) is a nondestructive measure of green
vegetation growth or aboveground biomass of a crop. NDVI may also be used to
evaluate traits such as early vigor and stay green which are important for adaptation to
drought stress. In the present study, the relationships between NDVI and grain yield as
well as other measured agronomic and drought-adaptive traits were examined under
drought stress and full irrigation conditions in a trial composed of testcross hybrids of
exotic and adapted maize inbred lines. NDVI had higher correlation coefficients with
grain yield under full irrigation than under drought stress, though the relationships were
generally weak. NDVI had stronger association with grain yield at 8-leaf stage than at 3leafed stage under full irrigation conditions. The R2 values of NDVI_1 with grain yield
and plant height under both irrigation treatments were ≤ 0.20. The R2 values of NDVI_2
with grain yield were 0.31 and 0.45 under drought and full irrigation environments,
respectively, while the values with plant height under drought and full irrigation
conditions were 0.48 and 0.38, respectively.
INTRODUCTION
Maize breeders have identified the urgent need to improve maize productivity through
the use of germplasm that have better adaptation to the climatic conditions of any
particular agro-ecology. This has necessitated the growing advocacy for precision
agriculture technologies as a vital component of crop breeding activities (Barker and
Sawyer, 2011). Applications of new remote-sensing tools based on the use of irradiation
to estimate green biomass status at field level are gaining more prominence in maize
breeding. One of such devices that has been proposed for high throughput phenotyping
in tropical maize adaptation under water stress (Lu et al., 2012; Araus and Hearne,
unpublished) is a spectroradiometer, otherwise known as Greenseeker handheld optical
sensor unit (NTech Industries, Inc., USA) which is used to measure normalized
difference vegetation index (NDVI). NDVI, a numerical indicator that is useful in
analyzing remote sensing measurements, has been reported to be highly correlated with
grain yield in maize and other crops (Cabrera-Bosquet et al., 2011; Lu et al., 2011; Lu et
al., 2012) and has been suggested as a secondary trait for evaluating maize germplasm
142
143
for drought tolerance (Hearne and Araus, unpublished). NDVI is computed using the
measurements of reflectance taken in the visible region and near infrared region of the
spectrum (Lu et al., 2012). The NDVI which provides a means of monitoring the vigor of
the green vegetation growth or biomass was found to be proportional to the leaf area of a
plant population and, therefore, a functional part of active photosynthesis which
ultimately determines final grain yield (Lu et al., 2011; Lu et al., 2012). Maize hybrids or
genotypes that accumulate abundant biomass under drought stress as revealed in high
NDVI values at the seedling stage of the crop would be expected to produce high grain
yields at harvest.
The use of NDVI as a valued trait in maize breeding for drought and low N tolerance in
both temperate and tropical germplasm is presently gaining prominence (Wu et al., 2011;
Lu et al., 2012; Winterhalter et al., 2012). In order to assess the value of NDVI in a new
hybrid maize breeding program, this study was conducted to examine the relationships
between NDVI and other measured traits of a set of newly developed testcross maize
hybrids.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A total of 41 hybrids, including 40 testcrosses and the hybrid formed by crossing two
inbred line testers, were developed at Saminaka (10°40’N; 8° 77’E; altitude 730 m) in
Nigeria in the main season of 2010 (Adebayo, 2012). A trial composed of the 41
testcrosses and 3 hybrid checks (Table 1) was planted under managed drought stress
conditions at Ikenne on November 24 in 2010 and on November 22 in 2011. Ikenne
receives little rainfall from November to March of every year, making the location
suitable for conducting drought stress tolerance evaluation during the dry season. The
soil at this site is eutric nitrosol (FAO classification) and the experimental fields are flat
and reasonably uniform, with high water-holding capacity (Menkir et al., 2009; BaduApraku et al., 2010). Experiments were planted in two adjacent blocks that received
different irrigation treatments. The first block (well-watered) received irrigation water
throughout the life cycle of the crop whereas the second block (drought stress) received
irrigation water for 28 days only, which is approximately two to three weeks before
anthesis.
The blocks were separated by four ranges (each 4.25 m wide) to restrict lateral
movement of water from the fully irrigated block to the drought stress block. The
testcross trial was planted in each block in 4x11 alpha (0,1) lattice design with three
replications. Different randomizations were used in the two treatment blocks.
Experimental plot consisted of a single 4-m row spaced 0.75 m apart with 0.50 m
spacing between hills. Three seeds were sown in a hill and later thinned to two plants
two weeks after planting (2WAP) to attain a plant population density of 53,333 plants
per hectare. Water was supplied with an overhead sprinkler irrigation system that
dispenses 12 mm of water per week. Except for the different irrigation treatments, all
field management practices were uniform for both the well-watered and drought stress
experiments. Basal application of a compound fertilizer was done immediately after
planting at the rates of 60 kg N, 60 kg P, and 60 kg K per hectare. An additional 60 kg
ha-1 N was applied in the form of urea as top dressing four weeks later. In each trial,
gramazone and atrazine were applied as pre-emergence herbicides at 5 l ha-1 each of
Paraquat and Primextra. Subsequently, manual weeding was done to keep the trials
weed-free.
143
144
Several traits were measured on plot basis in both water-stressed and fully irrigated
blocks at Ikenne in 2010 and 2011 (Adebayo, 2012) but data on normalized difference
vegetation index (NDVI), anthesis-silking-interval (ASI), plant height (PLHT), ear
aspect (EASP), number of ears per plant (EPP), and grain yield (GY) are presented in
this report. Normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) was measured using
Greenseeker Optical Sensor Unit (Ntech Industries, Inc.). Measurements were recorded
at 2 and 4 weeks after planting (WAP) when the plants were at 3- and 8-leafed stages,
respectively, in December 2010 and December 2011. The Greenseeker handheld optical
sensor unit was installed with red sensor, red waveband centered at 650 ± 10 nm, and
near infra-red (NIR) band centered at 770 ± 15 nm. The unit was held at a distance of
approximately 60 cm above the canopy while each plot was traversed, starting from the
beginning of the row to the end, and data were collected in log plots mode. A HP iPAQ
installed with NTech capture programme for pocket PC was used to measure, compute
and save NDVI directly from the Greenseeker. The device computes the NDVI
according to the following formula:
NDVI = (RNIR – RRED)/(RNIR + RRED)
where RNIR = the fraction of emitted NIR radiation returned from the sensed area
(reflectance), and RRED = the fraction of the emitted red radiation returned from the
sensed area (reflectance). The data were later transferred by syncing the iPAD to a
synchronized desktop computer for further processing.
Days to 50% anthesis (DTA) and days to 50% silking (DTS) were recorded as the
number of days from planting to when 50% of plants in a plot had shed pollen, and had
emerged silks, respectively. ASI was computed as the difference between DTS and DTA.
PLHT was measured in centimeters (cm) as the distance from the base of the plant to the
height of the first tassel branch. EASP was also visually rated on a scale of 1 to 5, where
1 = clean, uniform, large, and well-filled ears and 5 = rotten, variable, small, and
partially filled ears. During harvesting, the total number of plants and ears were counted
in each plot at the time of harvest. A cob was counted if it had at least one kernel set.
EPP was then computed as the proportion of the total number of ears at harvest divided
by the total number of plants harvested. All ears harvested from each plot were weighed
and shelled to determine grain weight. A representative sample was taken to determine
percent moisture. GY, measured in kg ha-1 and adjusted to 15% moisture content was
calculated from grain weight and percent moisture. The following equation was used for
estimating grain yield:
GY (kg ha-1) = (GWT (kg)/ 3 m2 x [(100 – MC) / (100-15] x 10,000 m2.
where GWT = Grain weight of harvested area in kg, MC = Moisture content of grains at
harvest, Moisture content for storage = 15%, 1 hectare = 10,000 m2, Plot area (area
harvested) = 3 m2.
Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was computed for the 44 entries for each year to
generate entry means adjusted for block effects according the lattice design (Cochran and
Cox, 1960; Menkir et al., 2003). The pooled error mean square was calculated for each
block ANOVA by dividing the sum of the error sums of square by the corresponding
sum of the error degrees of freedom. Combined analysis of variance was then computed
across years using the adjusted means. In the combined analysis, year, replications and
blocks were treated as random effects while testcrosses were considered as fixed effects.
All analyses were carried out with PROC GLM in SAS (SAS Institute, 2009) using a
RANDOM statement with TEST option. Pearson’s correlation coefficients were
calculated using the mean values of the measured traits. Although NDVI measurements
144
145
were taken at the same periods under both irrigation treatments, the values were
correlated with those of grain yield and other traits that were measured after moisture
stress has been imposed in the drought stress block. Also, linear regression models were
used to determine the relationships between GY and NDVI using Procedures in SAS
(SAS Institute, 2009).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Results of analysis of variance combined over two years (Table 2) revealed that year
effect was significant for all measured traits except for EPP under both irrigation
treatments and GY under well-watered conditions. Hybrids differed significantly for all
measured traits under both irrigation treatments except for NDVI_1 under drought stress.
Genotype x year (GxE) interaction was significant for GY under both environments and
also for NDVI_1 and NDVI_2 under well-watered conditions.
Results of correlation analysis between NDVI and every other trait under both irrigation
treatments are presented in Table 3. NDVI measured at 3-leaf stage had non-significant
and weak associations with GY under drought stress and well-watered conditions,
respectively. The relationships became stronger when NDVI was measured at 8-leaf
stage. Also, NDVI taken at 3-leaf stage had positive but weak associations with plant
height under both irrigation treatments. When NDVI was taken at 8-leaf stage, it
exhibited a strong association with plant height under drought stress and even stronger
relationship under full irrigation conditions (Table 3). The R2 values of NDVI_1 with
grain yield and plant height under both irrigation treatments was ≤ 0.20. The R2 values of
NDVI_2 with grain yield were 0.31 and 0.45 under drought and full irrigation
environments, respectively, while the values with plant height under drought and full
irrigation conditions were 0.48 and 0.38, respectively.
The significant and positive correlation between NDVI and grain yield in our study was
in agreement with the results of several other workers (Araus et al., 2010; Islam et al.,
2011; Lu et al., 2011). Though some of these workers reported a strong relationship, our
finding agreed more with Lu et al. (2011) who reported a weak genetic correlation
between NDVI and grain yield (0.38-0.49) in maize. A stronger relationship that existed
between NDVI and grain yield under full irrigation condition when compared with what
obtained under drought stress points to the predictive value of aboveground biomass for
grain yield in maize under optimum growing conditions. The relationship that became
stronger at 8-leaf stage (4WAP) under both irrigation regimes agreed with other results
which indicated that growth stage is a deciding factor in yield forecast in maize, and that
a strong relationship exit between NDVI and grain yield at 8-leaf stage (Teal et al., 2006;
Islam et al., 2011). The improved relationship between grain yield and NDVI at 8-leaf
stage was attributed to the maximum biomass which is accumulated later in seedling
stage in cereals (Cabrera-Bosquet et al., 2011). Hybrid maize genotypes that accumulate
higher aboveground biomass at the vegetative stage have the tendency of producing
higher grain yield when growing conditions are optimal than when there is drought
stress. In this study, less variation in GY was explained by NDVI at 8-leaf stage under
full irrigation compared to what has earlier been reported in wheat and maize,
respectively, when NDVI was normalized by the number of days of growth (Raun et al.,
2001, Teal et al., 2006).
145
146
Table 1: Line code, abbreviated pedigree, adaptation, breeding center, and maturity of 10 exotic and 10 adapted DT inbred lines along with 2
testers evaluated in testcrosses over two years at Ikenne in Nigeria.
No.
Line code
Pedigree
Adaptation
Center
Maturity
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
EXL09
EXL11
EXL12
EXL13
EXL18
EXL19
EXL20
EXL21
EXL22
EXL23
ADL25
ADL30
ADL32
ADL33
ADL34
ADL35
ADL36
ADL38
ADL42
ADL48
1368
9071
Cuba/Guad C3 F85-3-3-1-B*6
La Posta Seq C7-F103-2-2-2-1-B*5
La Posta Seq C7-F12-2-3-1-1-B*5
La Posta Seq C7-F152-1-1-2-1-B*3
La Posta Seq C7-F31-2-3-1-1-B*5
La Posta Seq C7-F32-2-1-1-2-B*4
La Posta Seq C7-F64-1-1-1-1-B*5
La Posta Seq C7-F64-2-6-2-2-B-B
La Posta Seq C7-F86-3-1-1-1-B*5
La Posta Seq C7-F97-3-1-1-2-B*5
P43SRC9FS100-1-1-8-#1-B1-13-B1-B*7
(TZMI501xKU1414x501)-1-4-3-1-B*7
161-B-B-B-B-B
ACR-86-8-1-2-1-1-1-B-1-B*6
TZL-COMP3-C2-S2-34-4-1-2-B*6
DTPL-W-C7-S2-7-1-1-1-1-B-5-B*6
DTPL-W-C7-S2-1-2-1-1-5-B-1-B*6
Babangoyo x MO17LPA x Babangoyo-23-4-3-4-B*8
(GT-MAS:Gk x BABANGOYO x GT-MAS:Gk)-1-1-3-1-B*6
GT-MAS:gk x 9450 x GT-MAS:gk -1-1-2-3- B*9
Across 7721 x TZSR
N28 x TZSR
Exotic
Exotic
Exotic
Exotic
Exotic
Exotic
Exotic
Exotic
Exotic
Exotic
Adapted
Adapted
Adapted
Adapted
Adapted
Adapted
Adapted
Adapted
Adapted
Adapted
Tester
Tester
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
CIMMYT
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
IITA
Intermediate
Intermediate
Intermediate/Late
Intermediate/Late
Intermediate/Late
Intermediate/Late
Intermediate/Late
Intermediate
Intermediate
Intermediate
Intermediate/Late
Intermediate/Late
Late
Late
Late
Late
Late
Intermediate/Late
Late
Intermediate
Intermediate/Late
Intermediate/Late
146
147
Table 2: Mean squares of traits from the analysis of variance combined over two years for 41 testcrosses and 3
hybrid checks under both well-watered and drought stress conditions at Ikenne in Nigeria
Source of
variation
Well-watered
Year (Y)
Rep (Y)
Genotype
Genotype x Y
Error
Drought stress
Year (Y)
Rep (Y)
Genotype
Genotype x Y
Error
Df
1
1
4
43
43
156
1
4
43
43
156
GY
ASI
PLHT
EASP
EPP
NDVI_1
NDVI_2
2539759
1520333
9050287.8***
1978806.7**
1001839
8.4**
1.2
2.6***
1
0.8
840.0*
1864.2***
882.8***
246.2
212.7
1.5**
0.2
0.6***
0.1
0.1
0.02
0.004
0.02**
0.01
0.01
0.2***
0.004***
0.001***
0.001***
0.0002
1.0***
0.03**
0.02***
0.01*
0.005
23218205.0***
2195454**
1877469.6***
914345.1**
543386
18.2*
11.0**
9.3***
3.0
3.0
58157.1***
1176.7**
1138.2***
326.6
322.1
11.3***
1.1**
0.8***
0.4
0.3
0.001
0.04
0.1*
0.04
0.03
0.02***
0.004***
0.0003
0.0002
0.0003
0.1**
0.03**
0.01**
0.004
0.01
*,**,*** Data significant at P < 0.05, 0.01, and 0.0001, respectively. 1GY=Grain yield measured in kg ha-1, ASI=
Anthesis-silking interval (d),
PLHT=Plant height measured in cm, EASP=Ear aspect (1-5) where 1=clean, uniform, large, and well-filled ears and
5=rotten, variable,
small and partially filled ears, EPP=Number of ears per plant calculated as ratio of plants harvested to ears harvested,
NDVI_1=NDVI
measured 2WAP; NDVI_2=NDVI measured at 4WAP.
147
148
Table 3: Correlation coefficients of NDVI_1 and NDVI_2 with other traits of the 41 testcrosses
and 3 hybrid checks under drought stress (DS) and well-watered (WW) environments over two
years at Ikenne in Nigeria.
DS
Trait
-1
Grain yield (kg ha )
Anthesis dates (d)
Silking dates (d)
Anthesis-silking-interval (d)
Plant height (cm)
Ear aspect (no)
Number of ears per plant
NDVI_2
NDVI_1
0.26ns
-0.32*
-0.20ns
0.08ns
0.35*
-0.07ns
0.20ns
0.54**
WW
NDVI_2
0.57***
-0.65***
0.52**
-0.04ns
0.70***
-0.47**
0.43**
-
NDVI_1
0.45**
-0.30*
-0.22ns
0.24ns
0.47**
-0.25ns
0.01ns
0.69***
NDVI_2
0.67***
-0.47**
-0.40**
0.25ns
0.63***
-0.49**
0.25ns
-
NDVI_1=NDVI measured at 3-leaf stage 2WAP, NDVI_2=NDVI measured at 8-leaf stage
4WAP. *, **, *** Data significant at P < 0.05, 0.01, and 0.0001, respectively; ns Data not
significant
REFERENCES
Adebayo, M.A. 2012. Genetic analyses of drought tolerance in crosses of adapted and exotic
maize (Zea mays L.) inbred lines. A Ph.D. thesis submitted to West Africa Centre for
Crop Improvement, University of Ghana, Legon.
Araus, J.L., C. Sanchez, and L. Cabrera-Bosquet. 2010. Is heterosis in maize mediated through
better water use? New Phytologist 187:392-406.
Badu-Apraku, B., A. Menkir, S.O. Ajala, R.O. Akinwale, M. Oyekunle, and K. Obeng-Antwi.
2010. Performance of tropical early-maturing maize cultivars in multiple stress
environments. Canadian Journal of Plant Science. 90:831-852.
Barker, D.W., and J.E. Sawyer. 2012. Using active canopy sensors to quantify corn nitrogen
stress and nitrogen application rate. Agronomy Journal 102(3):964-971.
Cabrera-Bosquet, L., G. Molero, A.M. Stellacci, J. Bort, S. Nogués and J.L. Araus. 2011. NDVI
as a potential tool for predicting biomass, plant nitrogen content and growth in heat
genotypes subjected to different water and nitrogen conditions. Cereal Research
Communications 39(1):147–159.
Cochran, W.G., and G.M. Cox. 1960. Experimental Designs. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New
York, USA.
Hearne, S., and J.L. Araus (Unpublished). Field phenotyping manual for evaluation of
performance under managed drought stress. CIMMYT/IITA.
Islam, M.R., S.C. (Yani) Garcia, and D. Henry. 2011. Use of normalised difference vegetation
index, nitrogen concentration, and total nitrogen content of whole maize plant and plant
fractions to estimate yield and nutritive value of hybrid forage maize. Crop and Pasture
Science 62:374-382.
148
149
Lu, Y., Hao, Z., Xie, C., Crossa, J., Araus, J., Gao, S., Vivek, B.S., Magorokosho, C., Mugo,
S.,Makumb, D., Taba, S., Pan, G., Li, X., Rong, T., Zhang, S., and Y. Xu. 2011. Largescale screening for maize drought resistance using multiple selection criteria evaluated
under water-stressed and well-watered environments. Field Crops Research 124:37–45.
Lu, Y., Xu, J., Yuan, Z., Hao, Z., Xie, C., Li, X., Shah, T., Lan, H., Zhang, S., Rong, T., and Xu,
Y. 2012. Comparative LD mapping using single SNPs and haplotypes identifies QTL for
plant height and biomass as secondary traits of drought tolerance in maize. Mol.
Breeding 30:407–418.
Menkir, A., B. Badu-Apraku, S. Ajala, A. Kamara, and A. Ndiaye. 2009. Response of early
maturing maize landraces and improved varieties to moisture deficit and sufficient water
supply. Plant Genetic Resources: Characterization and Utilization 7(3); 205–215.
Menkir, A., B. Badu-Apraku, C. The, and A. Adepoju. 2003. Evaluation of heterotic patterns of
IITA’s lowland white maize inbred lines. Maydica 48:161-170.
NTech Industries. 2007. Model 505 Greenseeker handheld optical sensor unit operating manual.
Available at http://www.ntechindustries.com/lit/gs/GS_Handheld_Manual_rev_K.pdf
(verified 18 Jan. 2013). NTech Industries, Ukiah, CA, USA.
Raun, W.R., Johnson, G.V., Stone, M.L., Solie, J.B., Lukina, E.V., Thomason, W.E., Schepers,
J.S. 2001. In-season prediction of potential grain yield in winter wheat using canopy
reflectance. Agronomy Journal 93:131-138.
SAS Institute. 2009. SAS Proprietary Software Release 9.2. SAS Institute, Inc., Cary, NC.
Sentek Pty Ltd. 2003. Sentek Diviner 2000 User Guide Version 1.2. Australia Sentek Pty Ltd,
Stepney, South Australia.
Teal, R.K., B. Tubana, K. Girma, K.W. Freeman, D.B. Arnall, O. Walsh, and W.R. Raun. 2006.
In-season prediction of corn grain yield Potential using normalized difference vegetation
index. Agronomy Journal 98:1488–1494.
Winterhalter, L., B. Mistele, S. Jampatong, and U. Schmidhalter. 2011. High-throughput sensing
of aerial biomass and above-ground nitrogen uptake in the vegetative stage of wellwatered and drought stressed tropical maize hybrids. Crop Science 51:479-489.
Wu, Y., W. Liu, X. Li, M. Li, D. Zhang, Z. Hao, J. Weng, Y. Xu, L. Bai, S. Zhang, and C. Xie.
2011. Low-nitrogen stress tolerance and nitrogen agronomic efficiency among maize
inbreds: comparison of multiple indices and evaluation of genetic variation. Euphytica
108:281-290.
PGB31
EVALUATION OF YIELD AND YIELD COMPONENTS OF CASTOR (RICINUS
COMMUNIS L.) GERMPLASM FROM RAIN FOREST AND SOUTHERN GUINEA
SAVANNAH AGRO-ECOLOGICAL ZONES OF NIGERIA
149
150
Gila, M.A.
Department of Biology, College of Education, Akwanga, Nasarawa State, Nigeria.
Corresponding e-mail: mangagila1@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Forty-two castor accessions were evaluated at the Teaching and Research Farm of the University
of Agriculture, Makurdi. Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with three replications
was used. Four-row plots of 5.5 m lengths were seeded to 11 hills of two seeds that were thinned
to single stand per hill .The rows were 1m apart and the hills were spaced 0.5 m intra-row. The
two middle rows of a total of 22 plants in a plot were used for observation. Variations existed
from the primary to the tertiary panicles in yield components per panicle types of the germplasm.
There were sequential per centage decreases in number of capsules, 100-seed weight and seed
yield per panicle types from primary to penterimary panicles. Over 85% of the seed yield
components each were captured from primary to quarternary panicles. From the stepwise
regression analysis, secondary panicle alone fitted into the yield equation contributed 57.6% of
the total seed yield. Primary to quarternary panicles yielded 88.4% of the total seed yield. This
implies that investigations, in this indeterminate crop, could be terminated after the harvest of the
quarternary panicles without distorting the yield trends of the crop.
Keywords: - equation, harvest, indices, panicle, regression, stepwise.
INTRODUCTION
To capture the natural variability that can be useful to breeding programmes, germplasm
collection is of paramount importance. The principal justification for plant collection is to obtain
natural variability that can broaden the germplasm pool for crop improvement (Bennett, 1979).
Castor plant varies greatly in its growth habit; colour of foliage and stem, seed size, seed colour
and seed oil content, so that varieties often bear little resemblance to each other (Weiss, 1971).
Kulkarni (1959) observed that the crop has diverse variability, which could be used for genetic
studies, yet not much work has been done on the genetics of the crop.
The yield characters include: panicles, capsules and 100-seed weight as well as seed yield.
Panicle number is a seed yield component. The panicles are borne terminally on the main and
lateral branches. They are designated as primary, secondary, tertiary, etc panicles. The main stem
ends in a primary panicle, usually the longest on the plant (Weiss, 1971; Brigham, 1980). There
are varietal differences in this character. Hooks et al. (1971) and Uguru (2000) recorded ranges
of 3.1 to 7.5 and 2 to 36 panicles per plant, respectively.
Capsule number depends on the proportion of pistillate flowers on the panicle. This is a function
of the variety. Uguru (2000) reported a range of 84 to 530 capsules per plant. Seed yield per
plant and 100-seed weight vary with variety and with the type of panicle. Kittock and Williams
(1967) reported that 100-seed weight from primary panicle was always the highest when
compared to the secondary, tertiary and quaternary panicles. Similarly, Kittock and Williams
(1968) reported percentage distribution of seed yield per panicle sequentially as: primary panicle,
25%; secondary panicle, 45%; tertiary panicle, 20%; quaternary panicle, 8%; and the penternary
panicle, 0.5%. Weiss (1971) reported the highest seed yield per panicle for primary panicle,
while successive panicles produced progressively lower seed yields. Uguru (2000) recorded
ranges of 90.2 to 507.2 g for seed yield per plant and 11.92 to 51.7 g for 100-seed weight. Gobin
et al. (2001) reported that the mean seed yield ranged as from 500 kg/hectare in India to 1000
kg/hectare in Thailand and 2500 kg/hectare under improved conditions in USA.
150
151
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A germplasm of 98 accessions, collected from the Rain Forest and Southern Guinea Savanna
agro-ecological zones of Nigeria was assembled in Makurdi. From this collection, forty-two
accessions were selected because they had sufficient seed for agronomic evaluation and
characterization.
The forty-two accessions were evaluated at the Teaching and Research Farm of the University of
Agriculture, Makurdi. Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) using three replications.
The land was ploughed and harrowed. With a Tractor, NPK 15-15-15 compound fertilizer was
broadcast before ridging at the rate of 300 kg/hectare. Four-row plots of 5.5 m lengths were
seeded to 11 hills of two seeds that were thinned to single stand per hill .The rows were 1m apart
and the hills were spaced 0.5 m intra-row. The two middles rows of a total of 22 plants in a plot
were used for observation. Weed control was manually done four weeks after planting. The same
type of fertilizer was used to top-dress after weeding at the rate of 150 kg/hectare. Data was
collected on the following characters: number of capsules, 100-seed weight and seed yield by
panicle type. The means of data by replicates were subjected to analysis of variance and stepwise
regression analysis was carried out to determine the panicle types that fitted into the yield
equation. SAS programme was used for the analyses
RESULTS
The mean square estimates of yield components in various panicle types are presented in Table
1. There was significant variation among the accessions with respect to the components from
primary to tertiary panicle except for seed yield in the tertiary panicle. The number of capsules
and 100-seed weight, among the accessions were highly significant (P< 0.01) from primary to
tertiary panicle, while on other hand, seed yield recorded significant (P<0.05) variation among
the accessions in primary and secondary panicles. The stepwise regression analysis in Table 2
revealed the relative contributions of the panicle variables in predicting the total seed yield of
castor. When only the secondary panicle was fitted in the yield equation, its contribution was
57.6%. Similarly, the quaternary panicle contributed 19.5%, quaternary and primary panicles
added 7.0%, whereas quaternary, primary and tertiary panicles contributed 4.3% when each was
fitted along with the secondary panicle in the regression equation. In essence, from primary
panicle to quaternary panicle, 88.4% of the total yield in castor was realized in this study. The
regression equations are listed in Table 3 as four selection indices. The use of secondary panicle
alone as a selection index would capture 57.6% of the total yield per plant, while the use of
secondary and quaternary panicles together, as a selection index would capture additional 19.5%
of the total yield per plant. Furthermore, the use of secondary, quaternary and primary panicles
as well as secondary, quaternary, primary and tertiary panicles would capture additional 7.0 and
4.3% of the total yield per plant, respectively.
DISCUSSION
The variation that existed in the yield components studied in the castor accessions showed that
castor seed yield could be improved upon through selection programmes if genetic information
on how these characters are inherited is known. Similar variations were reported on yield (Hooks
151
152
et al., 1971); 100- seed weight and seed yield (Giriraj et al., 1973); seed yield per plant (Bhatt
and Reddy, 1983); seed yield, and 100-seed weight (Bhardwaj et al., 1996); 100-seed weight
and seed yield (Uguru, 2000). The progressive decrease in percentage of sequential number of
capsules, 100-seed weight and seed yield per panicle type from primary to penternary panicles
agrees with earlier patterns reported by Kittock and Williams (1967) and percentage yield
decrease in seed yield per sequential panicle type agrees with the reports of Kittock and Williams
(1968) and Weiss (1971). The progressive decrease in sequential yield components might be as a
result of either mouldy or abortive nature of flowers during the cloudy and high rainfall months
(July to September) or some natural phenomena where panicle size decreased with more
branching. The sequential decrease in yield components with more branching could be attributed
to competition for photosynthates by the many numerous sites on many panicles as compared to
the primary and secondary panicles, with fewer storage sites. Furthermore, this could be
attributed to some environmental factors like low rainfall associated with drier months from
October to December where water stress could result in poor seed filling. The formation of
tertiary panicles usually coincides with this period of water stress, a possible reason for poor seed
filling.
Seed yield is a complex character and it is polygenic in inheritance (Singh and Bains, 1968).
Therefore, selection for seed yield per se may be difficult due to the low heritability of the
character (Allard, 1956). However, certain characters, which may be strongly related with seed
yield, may be more heritable than the seed yield. If such components are selected for, better
success may be achieved in seed yield improvement
CONCLUSSION
The study revealed considerable variability in most of the castor accessions for the characters
studied. The contribution to the yield components by panicle type decreased sequentially from
primary to penternary panicles. The stepwise regression analysis attributed 88.4% of the
variation in total seed yield to yield from primary to quaternary panicles. Therefore, harvest of
yield component data could be terminated after the quaternary panicles without distortion to
yield trend, thereby solving the problem of continuous harvest in the indeterminate plants.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I acknowledge the Department of Crop Production and the management of College of
Agronomy, University of Agriculture, Makurdi, for provision of the research plots in the
Teaching and Research Farm of the University of Agriculture, Makurdi. The tedious work of
unshelling the castor beans manually by Women Fellowship of Evangelical Reformed Church of
Christ (ERCC) Local Church Council (LCC) No.2 Akwanga, my dear wife Mrs. B.M. Gila, my
mother Mrs. Gimbiya Gila, and my lovely children is highly appreciated. Finally, assistance
from Professor M.I. Uguru and Dr. Ishaleku David is highly acknowledged.
REFERENCES
Allard, R.W. (1956). Estimation of prepotency from Lima bean diallel cross data.
Agronomy Journal, 48: 537-543.
152
153
Bennett, E. (1979). Adaptation in Wild and Cultivated Plant Population. In: Genetic
Resources in Plant, Their Exploration and Conservation. Eds. Frankel and Bennett.
Oxford and Edinburgh. Blachwell Scientific Publications.
Bhardwaj, H.I., Mohamed, A.I., Webber, III C.L. and Lovell G.R. (1996): Evaluation of
castor germplasm for agronomic and oil characteristics. p 342-346. In J. Janick
(ed.). Progress in New Crops. ASHS Press, Alexandris V.A.
Bhat, D. and Reddy T.P. (1983): Combining ability for flowering, capsule number and
yield in castor. Indian Journal of Agricultural Science, 53 (10): 873- 875.
Brigham, R.D. (1980): Castor. In: Hybridization of Crop Plants. Eds. W.R. Fehr and
H.H.Hadley. American Society of Agronomy and Crop Science Society of
America.Madison Wisconsin USA. 765pp.
Giriraj, K., Mensikai, S.W. and Sindagi, S.S. (1973). Combining ability of some
quantitative characters in 6 x 6 diallel crosses of castor (Ricinus communis L.).
Indian Journal of Agricultural Science, 43 (10): 319-322.
Gobin, A.M.I., Uguru, M.I. and Deckers J. (2001). Oil Crop. In: Crop Production in
Tropical Africa. Ed. By Romain H.Raemaekers.Brussels Belgium Director
General for International co-operation. pp. 725-733.
Hook, J.A., Williams, J.H. and Gardner C.O. (1971). Estimates of heterosis from a diallel
cross of inbred lines of castor (Ricinus communis L.).Crop Science, 11: 651 655.
Kittock, D.L. and Williams, J.H. (1967). Castorbean production as related to length of
growing season. II. Date of planting tests. Agronomy Journal, 59: 456-458.
Kittock, D.L. and Williams, J.H. (1968). Influence of planting date on certain
morphological characters of castorbeans. Agronomy Journal, 60: 401-403.
Kulkarni, L.G. (1959). Castor-Monograph Published by Indian Central Oilseed Comm
ttee, Hyderabad 1. India. 107 pp.
Singh R.B. and Bains S.S. (1968). Variability and correlation studies on ginning of
upland cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.). Indian Journal of Agricultural Science,
38 (2): 391-407.
Uguru, M.I. (2000). Genetic variability and breeding value of castor genotypes. Agronomy
Science, 1 (1): 130-135.
Weiss, E.A. (1971). Castor, Sesame and Safflower. London SWI, Leonard Hill. 901 pp.
TABLE 2. RELATIVE CONTRIBUTIONS OF SEED OF VARIOUS PANICLES
TO TOTAL SEED YIELD OF SECLECTED CASTOR ACCESSIONS
Variable
R2 Change
Constant
Reg.Coef.
R
Secondary panicle
6.828
2.443
0.759
0.576
39.500
Secondary panicle
1.792
1.751
0.878
0.195
47.092
0.917
0.070
47.364
Quaternary panicle
Secondary panicle
F
3.342
-1.206
1.361
Quaternary panicle
3.452
Primary panicle
0.858
153
154
Secondary panicle
2.933
1.099
Quaternary panicle
2.040
Primary panicle
0.941
Tertiary panicle
1.947
0.940
0.043
49.093
TABLE 3. REGRESSION EQUATIONS FOR THE PANICLE VARIABLES
Panicle Variables
Regression Equations
Secondary panicle
Ŷ = 6.828 + 2.443X2 + Σij.
Secondary and quaternary panicles
Ŷ = 1.792 + 1.751X2 + 3.342X4 + Σij.
Secondary, quaternary and primary panicles
Ŷ = 1.206 + 1.361 X2 + 3.452 X4 + 0.858X1 + Σij.
Secondary, quaternary, primary and tertiary
panicles
Ŷ = 2.933 + 1.099 X2 + 2.040 X4 + 0.941X1 + 1.949X3
+ Σij.
KEY:
X1 = primary panicle;
X2 = secondary panicle;
X3 = tertiary panicle;
X4 = quaternary panicle.
TABLE 1:
Sources of
variation
MEAN SQUARE ESTIMATES FOR YIELD COMPONENTS ON VARIOUS PANICLE TYPES OF
SOME SELECTED CASTOR ACCESSIONS.
Df
Primary panicle
Secondary panicle
Tertiary panicle
Quaternary pa
NC
SW100 (g)
SY (g)
NC
SW100 (g)
SY (g)
NC
SW100 (g)
SY(g)
NC
SW10
Rep
2
1251.38**
263.29
134.81**
768.13**
6.98
18.80
213.16**
226.00
24.96*
31.60
59.21
Entry
41
226.54**
940.55**
18.51*
213.60**
1066.29**
16.38*
57.80**
765.92**
5.49
25.35
191.04
Error ‡
82
114.94
139.96
12.07
88.09
7.62
11.42
27.59
107.12
5.14
23.13
121.39
*, ** Significant at probability levels of 0.05 and 0.01, respectively.
† Penternary panicle and above
KEY:
NC = number of capsule/panicle;
154
155
SW100 = 100 seed weight (g);
SY = Seed yield (g)/ panicle.
‡ Variations in degree of freedom (df) of error mean square for the three yield components by
panicle type are as follows:
NC
SW100
SY
Primary
-5
-14
-8
-10
-17
-18
-36
-39
-52
-56
-7
Secondary
-8
Tertiary
-13
Quaternary
-31
Penternary
-5
PGB32
DETERMINATION OF GENE ACTION OF FIVE YIELD AND YIELD RELATED
CHARACTERS OF SELLECTED CASTOR ACCESSIONS IN A 5X5 DIALLEL
CROSSES
Gila, M.A.
Department of Biology, College of Education, Akwanga, Nasarawa State, Nigeria.
Corresponding e-mail: mangagila1@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
From a germplasm of castor accessions assembled for character evaluation in the University of
Agriculture Makurdi Teaching and Research Farm, five selected castor accessions were crossed
in all possible combinations excluding reciprocals. An evaluation trial experiment was laid out at
155
156
Akwanga and Lafia in Nasarawa State and Makurdi in Benue State. The parents and the F1s were
evaluated in a randomized complete block design of three replications. The plots were made up
of three rows of 1.5 m in length spaced 1.0 m apart. The rows were sown to four hills of two
seeds each, spaced 0.5 m and thinned to single stand per hill. The consistency t 2 test values for
all the characters were non-significant. The regression coefficient b in all the characters has
fulfilled the additive-dominance model except seed yield/hectare, which implies epistasis. The
seed yield/hectare is controlled by predominantly recessive or minor-genes and is conditioned by
over-dominance gene action. While the four traits partial dominance gene action. Therefore,
hybrid seed production could be used to explore the over-dominancy.
Keywords: Additive-dominance, minor-genes, partial-dominance, over-dominance, epitasis.
INTRODUCTION
Hayman (1954) listed six assumptions as the basis for the application of additive-dominance
model. These assumptions were re-emphasized by Allard (1956), who further stated that if the
assumptions are valid, the points on the covariance (wr)/ variance (vr) graph are expected to fall
on a line of unit slope. Where the regression line is significantly different from unit slope epitasis
is implicated (Manga and Sidhu, 1979; Srivastava et al., 1979). The intercepts of regression lines
determine the levels of dominant gene action. Where the intercept is below the origin, at origin
or above the origin, the gene actions is over-dominance, complete dominance and partial
dominance, respectively (Hayman, 1954; Allard, 1956; Singh and Chaudhary, 1985). The
positions of the points of parental array in relation to the origin separate the parents into either
dominant or recessive parents (Hayman, 1954; Allard, 1956; Singh and Chahal, 1974; Sirohi and
Choudhury, 1983; Jolliffe and Arthur, 1993). However, the positions of the parental array in
relation to the sides of the regression line are used to determine the additive and non-additive
gene actions of the parents. Where the parent points lie above the regression line, they are said to
possess additive gene action whereas those below are said to possess non-additive gene action
(Manga and Sidhu, 1979; Kaw and Menson, 1983; Sirohi and Choudhury, 1983). Sirohi and
Choudhury (1983) went further to add that those arrays below the regression line implicated both
non-additive and epistatic gene actions. There is dearth of information in literature regarding
covariance (wr)/ variance (vr) graphs and additive-dominance model in castor. In the light of the
above, the current study is to highlight gene action using graphic method.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
From a germplasm collected from Southern Guinea Savannah and characterized in the
University of Agriculture Makurdi Teaching and Research Farm, five selected castor accessions
were crossed in all possible combinations excluding reciprocals. An evaluation trial experiment
was laid out at Akwanga and Lafia in Nasarawa State and Makurdi in Benue State. The parents
and the F1s were evaluated in a randomized complete block design of three replications. The
plots were made up three rows of 1.5 m in length spaced 1.0 m apart. The rows were sown to
four hills of two seeds each, spaced 0.5 m and thinned to single stand per hill.
156
157
Observations were made on four plants of the middle row of each plot. Eleven characters viz:
leaf area, leaf length, number of leaf lobes, number of nodes to primary panicle, height to
primary panicle, days to 50% flowering, days to 100% flowering, 100-seed weight, seed
yield/hectare and plant height.Hayman’s (1954) method was adopted for covariance (Wr) and
variance (Vr) estimates using the genotype means on MS Excel programme.
RESULTS
The covariance (Wr)/variance (Vr) graphical analyses are presented in Figures 1 to 5. The five
yield-related characters have non-significant consistency t 2 values. The number of days to 50%
flowering (D50F), number of days to 100% flowering (D100F), Number of days to maturity
(NDM) and 100-seed weight (SW100) have their regression coefficient b values fulfilling the
unit slope, while that of seed yield/hectare (SYH) is more than a unit slope. The four characters:
D50F, D100F, NDM and SW100 have their regression lines intercepted the covariance
(Wr)/variance (Vr) graphs above the origins as shown in Fig 1, 2, 3 and 4, respectively, a partial
gene action. The seed yield/hectare(Fig. 5) regression line intercepted the covariance
(Wr)/variance (Vr) graph below the origin, over-dominance.
Fig.1 and Fig. 2 show accession 3 closer to the origin and the rest of the accessions away from
the origin, exhibited dominance and recessive gene actions, respectively. Accessions 10 and 34
are additive while accession 9 non-additive in nature. Similarly, accession 3 exhibited dominance
gene action in Fig.3 compare to the rest of accessions. In the same vein accessions 10 and 6
exhibited additive gene actions while accession 9, non-additive gene action. Dominance gene
actions were displayed by accessions 6 and 9 in Fig. 4 while accession 3 was recessive. The five
accessions in Fig.5, are all controlled by recessive genes and non is either additive nor nonadditive.
DISCUSSION
Literature citations were not available on covariance (Wr) and variance (Vr) graphical analysis in
castor per se. However, from Hayman’s (1954) assumptions, the consistency t 2 values for all the
characters were non-significant. The regression coefficient b in all the characters has fulfilled the
additive-dominance model except seed yield ha-1 . Epitasis is implicated in this character with
regression coefficient b significantly different from unit slope (Manga and Sidhu, 1979;
Srivastava et al., 1979). The covariance (Wr) /variance (Vr) graphic analyses have shown that l
seed yield/hectare exhibited over-dominance gene action as indicated by the regression lines
intercepting the Wr coordinate below the origin, while partial dominance gene action was
exhibited by the rest of the characters as the regression lines intercepted the Wr coordinates
above the origins (Hayman, 1954; Allard, 1956; Singh and Chaudhary, 1985). The
overdominance in this trait as deduced from the Wr/Vr graphs, revealed that the characters might
be controlled by dominance or non-additive gene action. This agreed, in part, with the findings of
Uguru and Abuka (1998) of overdominance reported in seed yield. Regarding the positions of
the parental arrays on the graphs, Ac.3 tended to have predominantly dominant genes in the
characters for earliness (number of days to maturity and number of days to 50 as well as 100%
flowering) by occurring towards origin of the covariance (Wr) /variance (Vr) graphs. This agreed
157
158
with the assertion of Hayman (1954), supported by Allard (1967), Singh and Chahal (1974),
Sirohi and Choudhury (1983), Singh and Chaudhary (1985) and Jolliffe and Arthur (1993) that
the parents were either predominantly dominant or preponderantly recessive when they occur
close to or far away from the origin, respectively. Accession three (Ac. 3) possessed mostly
recessive genes for 100-seed weight and seed yield ha-1.
The genes controlling seed yield/hectare were mostly recessive genes, as parental points
occurred far away from the origin of covariance (Wr)/variance (Vr) graph. This showed that the
genes controlling seed yield/hectare were mostly recessive genes. This is an indication that the
inheritance of seed yield/hectare was governed mostly by minor genes. In conclusion, hybrid
seed production could be explored to capture dominant gene action existing in seed yield/hectare.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
My profound gratitude goes to Professors M.O. Adeyemo and L.L. Bello of University of
Agriculture, Makurdi for supervising this work. I acknowledge the Management of College of
Agronomy University Agriculture, Makurdi, the Management of College of Agriculture, Lafia,
and the Management of College of Education Akwanga for making research plots available for
the field work. The manual unshelling of the castor beans by the Women Fellowship of ERCC
(Evangelical Reformed Church of Christ) No.2, Akwanga, my wife (Mrs. B.M. Gila), Mother
(Mrs. Gimbiya Gila), and children (Mr. A.M. Gila, Mr. L.M. Gila and Miss A.M. Gila) is
appreciated. Professor M.I. Uguru of University of Nigeria Nsukka’s technical advice on how to
cross castor and making available some journal articles is highly acknowledged.
REFERENCES
Allard, R.W. (1956). Estimation of prepotency from Lima bean diallel cross data. Agronomy
Journal, 48: 537-543.
Hayman, B.I. (1954). The theory and analysis of diallel crosses. Genetics, 39:789-809.
Jolliffe T.H. and Arthur, A.E. (1993). Diallel analysis of bolting in sugar beet. Journal of Agricu
tural Science Cambridge, 121: 327-332.
Kaw, R.N., Menson P.M. (1983): Diallel analysis in soybean. Indian Journal of Agricultural
Scienc, 53 (12): 991-997.
Manga, V.K. and Sidhu, B.S. (1979): Combining ability and inheritance of yield and yield
Agricutural Science, 49 (5): 307-312.
Singh, T.H. and Chahal, G.S. (1974). Diallel analysis of yield and its components in Desi cotton.
Indian Journal of Genetics and Plant Breeding, 34 (3): 323-327.
Singh, R.K. and Chaudhary, B.D. (1985): Biometrical Methods in Quantitative Genetic 159.
Analysis. 3rd Ed. Ludhiana, New Delhi. Kalyani Publishers, 318 pp.
Sirohi P.S., Choudhury B. (1983): Diallel analysis for varieties in bitter-gourd. Indian Journal of
Agricultural Science, 53 (10): 880-888.
Srivastava, S.K., Pandey, B.P. and Lal, R.S. (1979). Combing ability and gene action estimates
in a six-parent diallel cross in Mesta. Indian Journal of Agricultural Science, 49 (9): 724
730.
Uguru, M.I., and gene action for two quantitative traits of castor plant (Ricinus communis
L.). Ghana Journal of Agricultural Science, 31: 81-86.
158
159
15
6
y = 0.9394x + 2.5358
10
34
9
5
10
Wr
0
0
2
4
6
3
-5
-10
-15
Vr
159
8
10
15
160
y = 0.894x + 2.9437
10
Wr
5
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
-5
-10
-15
Vr
FIG. 1: COVARIANCE (Wr)/ VARIANCE (Vr) GRAPHS FOR DAYS TO 50%
FLOWERING OF CASTOR IN SOUTHERN GUINEA SAVANNA OF
NIGERIA.
160
161
FIG. 2: COVARIANCE (Wr)/ VARIANCE (Vr) GRAPHS FOR DAYS TO 100% FLOWERING
OF CASTOR IN SOUTHERN GUINEA SAVANNA OF NIGERIA.
15
y = 0.7941x + 2.6926
10
5
Wr
6
0
0
1
2
10
3
4
5
-5
3
9
-10
-15
Vr
161
34
6
7
8
9
0.6
y = 0.9967x + 0.0349
162
3
0.4
34
10
Wr
0.2
0
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
0.5
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
Vr
FIG. 3 COVARIANCE (Wr)/ VARIANCE (Vr) GRAPHS FOR NUMBER OF DAYS TO
MATURITY OF CASTOR IN SOUTHERN GUINEA SAVANNA OF NIGERIA.
162
3000
163
2000
y = 0.061x - 217.82
Wr
1000
0
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
-1000
-2000
-3000
Vr
FIG. 4: COVARIANCE (Wr)/ VARIANCE (Vr) GRAPHS FOR 100-SEED
WEIGHT (G) OF CASTOR IN SOUTHERN GUINEA SAVANNA OF
NIGERIA.
163
6
9
164
FIG.5: COVARIANCE (Wr)/ VARIANCE (Vr) GRAPHS FOR SEED YIELD HA-1 (KG) OF
CASTOR IN SOUTHERN GUINEA SAVANNA OF NIGERIA.
PGB33
EFFECT OF GROUND AND UNGROUND PEPPER (CAPSICUM ANNUM) IN THE
CONTROL OF COWPEA WEEVILS (CALLOSOBRUCHUS MACULATUS) AMONG
SOME COWPEA VARIETIES (VIGNA UNGUICULATA L. WALP) DURING
STORAGE.
Ogbaji, M. I.1* and Adamu, I.2
1
Department of Crop Production, University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Benue State University, Makurdi, Nigeria
*Corresponding e-mail: ogbamosphd@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
The effect of ground and unground pepper (Capsicum annum) in the control of cowpea weevils
(Callosobruchus maculatus) among some cowpea varieties (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) during
storage was investigated. The treatments used were fine grounded pepper, marshed pepper and
ungrounded pepper, while the five varieties of cowpea used included. Iron Beans, Small White,
IAR48 (small brown), IT3629 (big white) and Ife brown. The experimental design used was a
factorial laid out in Completely Randomized Design (CRD) with three replicates. The results
obtained from the research indicated that there was significant difference (p<0.05) among the
cowpea varieties and treatments used. Among the treatments, fine grounded pepper preserved
cowpea best and gave the least weight reduction in the order: Small white <IAR48 (small
brown) < Ife brown < Iron beans < IT3529 (big white) or (12.94g, 23.19g, 25.80g 31.66g, and
33.78) respectively and marshed peppers was next to fine grounded pepper with a weight
reduction of 17.78g, 28.20g, 31.50g, 41.78g and 49.01g while ungrounded pepper gave a weight
reduction of (25.75g, 32.26g, 41.62g, 49.33g and 55.27g). The relative efficiency of all these
treatments showed that they can actually replace chemicals in the preservation of cowpea grains
which are expensive and can cause serious environmental and health hazards to human beings.
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) otherwise called the Southern pea belongs to the family
leguminasae and is a crop of high value which contributes significantly to farm income and
dietary protein of Africans (Ogbaji, 2002). It is a valuable warm season legume believed to have
West African as its centre of origin and greatest morphological diversity (Smart et al., 1985).
Cultivated cowpea is an herbaceous annual belonging to the substribe phaseolinae, the tribe
phasedese, the family papilionaceae (or Fabaceae) and the order Fabales.
164
165
Cowpea constitutes the cheapest source of protein for most people in the tropical world (Ogbaji
and Ndam, 2002) where per capital income and consumption of animal protein are both very
low (Rachie, 1985). The nutrient content of mature cowpea seed contains 24.8%, protein, 1.9%
fats, 6.2% fibre, 63.6% carbohydrates, 0.00074% thiamine, 0.00042% riboflavin and 0.00281%
niacin (Singh et al., 1985). Cowpea also serves as a quick cover crop for erosion control and
smothering of weed seeds in addition to its capacity in fixing up to 240 kg/ha to the soil after a
crop cycle (Rachie, 1985). The haulms and husk of cowpea serve as roughage for livestock
(IITA, 2002). It also increases soil organic content and improvement of soil structure after soil
incorporation (Valenzuala, 2002). Insect infestation is a major contributor to quality
deterioration of cowpea stored in warm and humid climates. Considerable physical and
nutritional loss are sustained by cowpea due to the infestation by weevils and results in
reduction of quality. However, most farmers and consumers of cowpea use synthetic chemicals
such as organo-chlorine and residual insecticide for cowpea grain storage. The chemicals are
not only expensive but can cause serious environmental and health hazards or even death to
livestock and human beings. In Nigeria, multi-tactic control methods have been developed to
reduce the menace of storage pest. Cultural methods entailed the manipulation of the
environment to make it unfavourable weevil growth and population build up but it has limited
or no remedial value in emergency situations. The use of plant materials for the protection of
crops and stored commodities against insect attack has a long history (Golob and Webley,
1980). It is quite safe and promising (Jilani et al., 1980). In years back, significant results have
been reported with the use of botanical insecticides in treating grains meant for storage. These
included the use of plant oils (Odunlami, 1992), Fagara, (Zanthoxylum spp) (Ogunwolu, 1996),
Neem (Azadirachta indica) (Ivibijaro, 1983), tobacco (Nicotiana tobacum) (Tooley, 1971),
pepper, (Capsicum spp) (Ivibijaro, 1983), ginger (Zinger officinale) (Olitodun, 2001), ash
(Murdock and Babalola, 1990) and bitterleaf (Vernorila amygdalina). Just recently, Ogbaji and
Osuman (2012) investigated and reported on the great efficiency of bitter pepper (Capsicum
annum) in the control of cowpea weevils, (Callosobruchus maculatus) during cowpea storage.
Another trial was therefore carried out to find out if marshing/grinding pepper will further
enhance its efficiency in the control of C. maculatus during cowpea storage.
Therefore, the broad objective of this study was to ascertain the effect of ground and unground
pepper (Capsicum annum) in the control of cowpea weevils (Callosobruchus maculatus) among
some cowpea varieties (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) during storage in Makurdi, a location in the
Southern Guinea Agro-Ecological Zone of Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHOD
The experiment was conducted in the Zoology Laboratory of Benue State University, Makurdi
between September and December, 2012. Makurdi, the capital city of Benue State lies between
latitude 7015’-70 45’N and longitude 80 15’-80 40’E in the Guinea Savanna vegetation Zone of
Nigeria. The five varieties of cowpea were all obtained from the Benue State Agricultural and
Rural Development Authority (BNARDA) Makurdi. These varieties had earlier been confirmed
to do very well in the Makurdi environment (Ogbaji and Ndam, 2002). The cowpea varieties
were Iron Bean, Ife Brown, Small White, IAR48 (small brown) and IT3629) (Big White). Dried
chilli pepper (Capsicum annum) was obtained from North Bank Market in Makurdi and forty
five (45) air tight plastic containers each with a depth of 7.5cm and diameter of 13cm attached
165
166
with the cover lid and one stainless pin were all obtained from the modern Market, Benue State,
Makurdi. The cowpea varieties were sundried for a period of six days to enable C. maculatus
escape. Sun drying continued until there was ceasation of reproduction of C. maculatus to ensure
that all the immature stages had been hatched. Thereafter, perforated, undersized seeds were
sorted out leaving behind the healthy seeds and all the good sorted cowpea were stored in the
tight plastic containers. The weights of the containers were all measured. Each contained 500g of
the cowpea seeds. Measurement was done using electric sensitive weighing balance called the
Adam’s scale. Each variety of cowpea had three (3) replicates and were then mixed with fifty
(50) g of chilli pepper (Capsicum annum) which served as the treatment. 50g of each of the
treatments (fine grounded state, marshed grounded state and ungrounded state), were admixtured
equally to the three (3) replicates of cowpea seeds each containing 500grams in each of the
containers. The cowpea seeds and pepper were mixed thoroughly to ensure uniform distribution
with a pinhole perforated covered lid at the centre to enable the circulation of air and breathing
of the insects. The set up was then stored in Laboratory at room temperature.
The data collection included the progressive weight loss of the cowpea varieties at two weekly
intervals. The weight loss was measured using a digital sensitive weighing balance. The weights
were determined as follows:
Initial Weight of cowpea
= X1g
Weight of chilli pepper + container
= X2g
Combined weight of cowpea + pepper + container
= X3g
Weight loss X3-X2 (g)
= X4g
Average weight loss
=
Also percentage (%) weight loss
= Wight loss of replicates (g)
3
X4 (g) x 100%
X1 (g)
1
The experimental design used was a factorial laid out in the Completely Randomized Design
(CRD) with three replicates while collected data were analyzed using Analysis of Variance
(ANOVA). Treatment means were separated using Fishers Least Significant Difference at 5%
level of significance.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Visual observation of the cowpea varieties in the containers indicated that in the first two weeks
of storage, IT3629 (Big White), Iron Beans and IAR48(Small Brown) were the first cowpea
varieties to be infested by Callosobruchus maculatus. This was manifested by the fact that by
hand feeling, the containers containing these varieties showed increased temperature rise.
Among the cowpea varieties, significant differences existed among them in their levels of
resistance (Table 1). The variability in level of resistance in the cowpea varieties to C. maculatus
attack during storage is most probably as a result of genetic differences among these lines as they
were developed from different pedigrees. This result agrees with studies done by Jackai et al.,
(1990) and Ogbaji and Osuman, (2012) who also reported genetic variability among some
cowpea lines in their resistance to C. maculatus. In the case of the treatments used, there were
also significant (P<0.005) differences among them. Among the treatments, finely grounded
pepper performed best in the control of cowpea damage by C. maculatus during storage. This is
most likely due to the fact that the very fine particles of pepper blocked all the available air
spaces in between the cowpea seeds thereby suffocating the insects to death and also stopping
the reproduction and subsequent multiplication of the insects. The significant seed weight
166
167
reduction among some of the cowpea varieties stored with the treatments may be as a result of
reduced oviposition and adult emergence of C. maculatus occasioned by the insecticidal effect of
pepper. The results corroborate earlier findings by Rhem et al., (1991) who reported that the
insecticidal effect of pepper fruits to C. maculatus was attributable to the its pungency which is
as a result of the capsicum present in them which was capable of also delaying the reproduction
and hence multiplication of C. maculatus. Schmuhener et al., (1984), while working on another
botanical also reported same results that the insecticidal activities of neem (Azadiradata indica)
was a result of the presence of highly oxidized tetrapenoids, azadirachtin, salanin and other
active products that posses repellant, antifectant and growth disruptive properties against various
insect species particularly C. maculatus.
The interactive effects of the cowpea varieties and treatment on actual weight loss of cowpea
seeds (Table 3) and the interactive effects of varieties and treatments on percentage weight loss
of cowpea seed during storage (Table 4) were all significant. These results indicated that all the
treatments used for the storage were effective but differed in their efficiency in the control of
cowpea weevils (C. maculatus) during storage. This result also implied that with the proper
combination between the cowpea varieties and the treatments, more efficiency in the control of
C. maculatus damage will be achieved. It is therefore recommended that cowpea farmers can
further enhance the already known efficiency of pepper (Capsicum annum) in the control of C.
maculatus during cowpea storage by mashing/grinding the pepper. Using this method can be
particularly beneficial because the pepper used has no harmful side effects, is environment
friendly and the pepper used for the storage can still be destructively sampled or consumed after
the cowpea storage.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We sincerely appreciate the cooperation and assistance of the Vice-Chancellor, Professor Charity
Ashimem Angya, University Management and all staff of the Department of Biological Sciences,
Benue State University, Makurdi, Nigeria.
REFERENCES
Golob, J and Webley, T. (1980). Objective and Achievements in the Improvement of Grain
Legumes. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 41, 27-37.
IITA (International Institute of Tropical Agriculture) (2002). Proceeding of World Cowpea
Conference III, Ibadan, Nigeria, 4-8 September.
Ivbijaro, M.F. (1983). Preservation of Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata) and Capsicum Species on
Cowpea (Collosobructus maculatus) (f). In Science and its Application of 7(4): 521-524.
Jackai, L.E.N, Singh, S.R., Dos Santos, J.H.R and Adalla, C.B. (1990). Insects of Cowpea in:
Singh S.R. (Ed). Proceeding of Insect Pest of Tropical Food Legumes. John Wiley and Sons,
Chichester London, pp. 43-90.
Jalani, G; Kabeh, J.D. and Malik, M. (1973). Studies on Neem Plant on Repellant Against Stored
Grain Insects. Pakistan Scientific and Industrial Research 16:6.
Murdock, L. and Babalola, O. (1990). Preservation of Post Harvest Cowpea by Subsistence
Framers in Cameroon. In: Proceeding of the International Research Meeting of the
Bean/Cowpea Collaborative Support Programme pp. 11-15.
Odunlami, A. T. (1992). Control of Cowpea Seed Bruchid (C. maculatus F.) with some Natural
plant materials. B. Agric. Thesis University of Agriculture. 58pp.
Ogbaji, M.I and Osuman, D. (2012). Insecticidal Action of some Botanicals on Storage Bruchid,
167
168
Callosobruchus Macullatus (F.) of Stgored Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. WALP).
Journal of Tropical Agriculture, Food, Environmental and Extension. 10(2). Pp. 29-34.
Ogbaji, M.I. (2002). Genetics of Resistance of Cowpea, Vigna unquiculata (L.) Walp to the Pod
Sucking Bug. Clavigralla tomentosticallis (Stal.) Hemipetera: Coreidacy. Journal of
Sustainable Tropical Agricultural Research, 3:28-32.
Ogbaji, M.I. and Ndam, O. (2002). Response of some Cowpea, (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp)
Varieties to Insect Pests in Makurdi, a Location in the Southern Guinea Savanna.
Nigerian Journal Sustainable Tropical Agricultural Research 3:28-32.
Ogunwolu, E.O. (1996). Suppression of Seed Bruchid (Collasobruchus maculatus) (F)
Development and Damage on Cowpea with Zanthoxyloids (Lam). Western Production,
15(7):663-607.
Olitodu, O.G. (2001). Six Plant Powders as Protectants of Stored Cowpea Against
Callosobructus maculates Fabirus (Coleoptera; Bruchidae), Nigeria Journal of Plant
Protection 19:1-30.
Rehm, S and Espigs, G. (1991). The Cultivated Plants of the Tropical and Subtropics. Varlag
Sosef Margrave Scientific Book Gottingers West Germany Pp. 552.
Singh, S.R and Rachie, K.O. (1985). Cowpea Research Production and Utilization John Willey
and sons Chichster, New York. Pp. 1-7.
Smart, J. and Hymontiz, T. (1985). Domestication and evolution of grain legume crops
(Summerfield, R. J and Roberts, E.H. eds), Colings, London: pp. 37-72.
Summerfield, R.J and Roberts, E.H. (1985). Grain Legume Crops Collins London pp. 1-6.
Tooley, T.A. (1971). Crop Production in: Food and Drug Chemistry in Industry Series John
Murray Publishers. Albermade Sheet London, Pp. 92-158.
Valenzuela, H. and Smith, J. (2002).cowpea College of Tropical Agriculture and Human
Resources University of Hawail at Monoa Honolulu, Hamwail. Pp 1-4.
Table 1: Main Effects of Varieties and Pepper Treatments on Actual Weight Loss (grams)
of Cowpea Seed During Storage
Varieties
Weeks of Storage
IAR48(big brown)
Iron bean
Ife brown
IT3629 (big white)
Small white
S.E (+ve)
C.V(%)
FLSD (0.05)
2
498.28
487.50
499.19
498.39
499.50
0.92
0.20
0.89
4
497.87
485.47
497.46
496.34
499.35
0.42
0.10
0.41
6
493.94
483.24
494.50
498.52
497.94
0.62
0.01
0.61
8
489.56
478.40
484.61
481.68
495.59
1.01
0.20
0.98
10
482.7
467.80
477.00
468.60
485.60
7.66
1.60
7.37
12
472.45
459.08
467.03
453.68
481.18
1.19
0.03
1.48
Treatments
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed grounded pepper
Ungrounded pepper
FLSD (0.05)
497.23
496.73
495.77
0.69
495.96
495.35
494.58
0.31
493.92
492.62
481.81
0.46
489.99
486.10
481.81
0.76
483.10
478.10
467.80
5.71
474.52
466.37
459.15
0.89
168
169
Table 2: Main Effects of Varieties and Treatments on Percentage Weight Loss (%) of
Cowpea Seed During Storage
Varieties
Weeks of Storage
IAR48(small brown)
Iron bean
Ife brown
IT3629 (big white)
Small white
S.E (tve)
C.V(%)
FLSD (0.05)
2
0.30
0.34
0.20
0.30
0.10
0.01
5.90
0.06
4
0.47
2.91
0.51
0.73
0.19
0.12
12.3
0.11
6
1.26
3.33
1.09
1.41
0.41
0.41
6.50
0.01
8
2.01
4.33
2.90
3.67
0.88
0.22
7.90
0.21
10
3.46
6.45
4.61
6.28
1.82
0.11
4.30
0.09
12
5.51
8.16
6.51
9.38
3.81
0.19
2.80
0.18
Treatments
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed grounded pepper
Ungrounded pepper
FLSD (0.05)
0.40
0.70
0.80
0.05
0.80
0.96
1.12
0.09
1.21
1.50
1.84
0.07
1.92
2.74
3.67
1.16
3.41
4.38
5.77
0.15
5.01
6.75
8.24
0.14
169
170
Table 3: Interactive Effects of Cowpea Varieties and Treatments on Weight Loss (grams)
of Cowpea Seeds During Storage
Varieties
Treatments
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
IAR48(small
brown)
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
499.32
498.93
496.60
498.52
498.30
496.79
496.13
493.68
492.00
493.19 486.80 476.84
489.26 485.00 471.80
486.24 476.30 467.74
Iron bean
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
488.10
487.54
486.87
486.23
485.28
484.90
483.98
483.37
482.36
481.45 473.60 468.34
478.49 467.90 458.22
475.27 461.80 450.67
Ife brown
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
499.35
499.37
498.84
498.46
497.94
496.37
496.16
495.34
491.91
491.19 486.60 476.20
485.14 476.90 468.50
477.54 467.40 458.38
IT3629(big
white)
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
499.46
498.36
497.36
497.08
496.31
495.62
494.68
492.51
490.36
487.53 475.40 466.22
482.44 463.70 450.90
475.06 461.80 444.70
Small white
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
499.93
499.40
499.16
499.51
499.34
499.21
498.63
498.20
496.91
496.65 493.20 487.06
495.18 491.90 482.22
494.95 471.70 474.25
0.54
0.70
1.05
1.69
FLSD (0.05)
170
1.28
1.99
171
Table 4: Interactive Effects of Cowpea Varieties and Treatments on Percentage Loss (%)
of Cowpea Seeds During Storage
Varieties
Treatments
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
IAR48(small
brown)
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
0.01
0.20
0.40
0.21
0.74
0.64
0.77
1.31
1.60
1.36
2.17
2.77
2.65
3.00
4.74
4.64
5.44
6.45
Iron bean
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
0.38
2.50
2.60
2.75
2.94
3.02
3.20
3.33
3.46
3.71
4.34
4.95
5.28
6.42
7.67
6.33
8.36
9.87
Ife brown
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
0.20
1.10
0.20
0.51
0.31
0.73
1.09
0.75
1.60
2.90
1.37
4.62
4.61
2.67
6.52
6.51
5.17
8.32
IT3629(big
white)
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
0.20
0.30
0.50
0.56
0.74
0.88
1.06
1.41
1.93
2.49
3.51
4.99
4.93
6.26
7.64
6.76
9.98
11.39
Small white
Fine grounded pepper
Marshed pepper
Ungrounded pepper
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.01
0.13
0.33
0.26
0.36
0.61
0.67
0.95
0.01
1.52
1.62
2.32
2.59
3.69
5.15
0.01
0.11
0.08
0.13
0.33
0.31
FLSD (0.05)
PGB34
EFFECTS OF DIFFERENT PEPPER VARIETIES IN THE CONTROL OF COWPEA
WEEVIL (CALLOSOBRUCHUS MACULATUS) IN SOME VARIETIES OF COWPEA
(VIGNA UNGUICULATA L.WALP)
Ogbaji, M.I.*1 and Fayinminu, A.O.2
1
Department of Crop Production, University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Benue State University, Makurdi, Nigeria
*Corresponding e-mail: ogbamosphd@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
A study was carried out to investigate the effect of some pepper varieties (Capsicum annum) in
the control of weevils (Callosobruchus maculates) during cowpea storage. Three pepper varieties
(hot pepper, moderately hot pepper and sweet pepper) were used for the study while the five
cowpea varieties used include: Small white, Big white, IAR48, Iron beans and Aloka. The
171
172
experimental design was a Completely Randomized Design (CRD) with three replications.
Results showed that there was a significant difference (P< 0.05) among the cowpea varieties and
the treatments applied. Aloka showed the least reduction in weight loss to Callosobruchus
maculatus indicating most resistance with 18.00g, followed by Big white 26.30g, IAR48 35.50g,
Small white 42.80g and lastly Iron beans with 65.50g. Among the treatments applied, hot pepper
gave the best protection against Callosobruchus maculatus giving overall weight reduction of
34.4g, next was moderately hot pepper 37.4g and sweet pepper with 41.1g. The interaction
between cowpea varieties and treatment applied were also significant. The relative efficiency of
these treatments indicated that they can be used to preserve cowpea against Callosobruchus
maculatus during storage more so that they have no negative side effects on human health.
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea, (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) belongs to the Family Leguminosae which is grown and
consumed for its high protein content (23-25%) and contributes significantly to farm income
(Ogbaji, 2002). In West and Central Africa, cowpea cultivation covers more than 8 million
hectares of which Nigeria is the largest producer at 4million hectares followed by Niger with
3million (Singh and Eaglesfied,2000). From its production, rural families derive food, animal
feed, and cash income. It provides nutritious grain and an inexpensive source of protein for both
rural poor and urban consumers. Cowpea grain contains about 25% protein, 64% carbohydrate,
1.9% fat, 6.35% fibre as well as some of the B- vitamins (Bressani, 1985) and therefore has a
tremendous potential to contribute to the alleviation of malnutrition among resource-poor
farmers. It does not require a high rate of nitrogen fertilization; its roots have nodules in which
soil bacteria called Rhizobia help to fix nitrogen from the air. Insect pest infestations are known
to be the major constraints to cowpea yield and its quality.The crop is severely attacked at every
stage of growth and insect pests such as cowpea aphid (Aphis craccivora), flower thrips
(Megalurothrips spp.) and pod sucking buds (Anoplocnemis curvipes). The weevil
Callosobruchus maculatus is the major pest that attacked stored cowpea.
Considering the importance of cowpea to world Agriculture and nutrition to man and losses in its
production as a result of its destructive activities of the weevil, the need to look into ways which
losses of cowpea annually can be brought to a minimal level cannot be over emphasized. The use
of conventional insecticides is mostly practiced worldwide in controlling cowpea pest which
pose threat to humans and environment. In Nigeria several methods of controlling stored cowpea
pest has been practiced which reduces the damage done by insect pest. The use of good storage
structures and use of plant materials has been effective by creating unfriendly environment thus
limiting the growth of the pests. The use of plant materials to control Callosobruchus maculatus
in stored cowpea has advantage in that it pose no threat to human compare to the use of
chemicals.
Recently significant results have been reported with the use of plant materials in preventing
grains from the damage done by insect pests. These included the use of neem (Azadirachta
indica) (Ivbijaro 1983; Schuhener and Ascher 1984), dried peels of orange, Ginger leaves of
onions (Ogbaji and Tyoga, 2010), Ginger, garlic and bitterleaf (Ogbaji and Osuman, 2011).
As a result, the objectives of this study were to determine the response of different varieties of
cowpea to various varieties of pepper such as hot pepper, moderately hot pepper and sweet
172
173
pepper. The study will help us to know which of the treatments has a higher pesticidal effect on
the cowpea against the stored cowpea weevil.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was conducted in the Botany Laboratory of the Department of Biological
Sciences, Benue State University, Makurdi. The five varieties of cowpea used were; Aloka
beans, Iron beans, IAR48 (Big brown), Small white and Big white. These were all obtained from
Benue State Agricultural and Rural Development Authority (BNARDA) (Plates 1 - 8). These
cowpea varieties were all sorted carefully to remove perforated seeds and sundried for 7 days to
allow Callosobruchus maculatus escape. After sundrying, the cowpea seeds were then stored in
air tight plastic containers. This was laid out in a Completely Randomized Design (CRD) with
three replications.
The pepper varieties used were the dried hot pepper, mild pepper and sweet pepper. All the
pepper varieties were obtained from Wurukum Market. Plastic airtight containers with a
transparent lid were used for the storage of the cowpea varieties. The central portion of the lid
was perforated using a stainless needle. This was done to allow the entrance of air and breeding
of the insects.
Using an electronic weighing balance, 50g of each dried pepper varieties (Hot pepper,
moderately hot pepper and Sweet pepper) and 500g of seeds of each of the cowpea varieties were
also measured and mixed together into the airtight plastic containers with three replications each.
They were then stored in the Laboratory for a period of 12 weeks between August and
November, 2012.
The weight of the containers was first taken and recorded and the weight of the seeds, container
and pepper were also taken together. The data collected were the progressive weight loss of the
cowpea varieties at two weekly intervals. The weight loss of the cowpea was determined by
simple subtraction of the final weight (b) from the initial weight (a).
Initial weight of cowpea = a
Final weight of cowpea = b
Weight loss = a-b
The mean weight of the cowpea varieties was also determined at two weekly intervals.
Percentage weight loss =
Data was analyzed using Analysis of variance (ANOVA) to show significance difference in
response of the cowpea to the treatment applied. Treatment means were separated using Fisher’s
Least Significance Difference at 5% level of significance.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The results obtained from the main effects of varieties and treatment on weight loss of cowpea
seeds (Table 1) showed that Aloka has the least reduction in weight loss to attack by
Callosobruchus maculatus with 18.00g followed by Big white (26.30g), IAR 48(35.50g), Small
white (42.80g) while Iron beans had the highest weight reduction to attack by Callosobruchus
maculatus during storage with a weight loss of 65.50g. In respect of the treatments applied, it
was recorded that hot pepper gave the best protection against cowpea weevil giving the overall
cowpea varietal a weight reduction of 34.40g, followed by mild pepper with 37.40g and then
sweet pepper 41.10g. Results on the main effects of varieties and treatment on percentage weight
173
174
loss Table 2. shows similar trend to the explanation above. Aloka gave the least percentage
weight loss of 3.62%, followed by Big white (5.25%) while Iron beans gave the highest
percentage weight reduction of (13.22%). The treatment applied shows that hot pepper gave the
best percentage protection against Callosobruchus maculatus during storage with 6.87%,
followed by mild pepper (7.57%) and sweet pepper (8.22%). The order of performance of the
treatment can be interpreted as hot pepper > mild pepper > sweet pepper. Tables 3 and 4 showed
that the interactive effects of cowpea varieties and treatments on actual weight loss of cowpea
seed during storage were all significant respectively.
The use of pepper plant in the control of Callosobruchus maculatus in this research relates to
other works that has been carried out in Nigeria and Africa as a whole using plant parts in
controlling Callosobruchus maculatus ( Ogbaji and Osuman 2011; Epidi et al., 2008; Udomporn
2009; Ogbaji and Tyoga 2010). From the results, Aloka has the least actual weight loss and
percentage weight reduction ( i.e giving the highest resistance to Callosobruchus maculatus)
while Iron beans gave the highest actual weight loss and percentage weight loss showing its high
susceptibility to C. maculatus attack. Resistance and susceptibility among these cowpea varieties
may have been due to nature or texture of the seed coat, since it has been shown by Carlos
(2004), that cowpea varies in seed coat and this plays a role in the penetration of the weevil. Also
the variability in the level of weight reduction in cowpea varieties to C. maculatus attack during
storage is most probably as a result of genetic differences among the lines as they were
developed from different pedigrees. Iron beans with the highest weight reduction in this study
agrees with the work of Ogbaji and Osuman (2011) which also gave the highest weight reduction
when treated with different plant materials.
In the treatments applied, pepper plants is made up of chemical constituent called capsicine
which gives pepper its strong taste. This varies in percentage at which it is found in pepper
varieties (Tindall 1965). This capsicine tends to reduce the emergence of weevil in cowpea and
the percentage composition of this capsicine determines the rate at which it will control C.
maculatus. The result indicates that different pepper varieties have insecticidal effects but some
are more efficient than others. Also the significant weight reduction in all the cowpea varieties
stored with different pepper varieties may be as a result of reduced oviposition and adult
emergence of C.maculatus This work agrees with the works of (Ebiamodon et al., 2011; Epidi
et al.,2008; Schmuhener and Ascher 1984) in which they all reported that the insecticidal effects
of botanicals on the control of weevil in grains was due to the presence of toxic factors in this
materials thus creating unsuitable habitat at which they can reproduce.
The results of this work has shown that pepper plant can be used as a good control measure to
reduce the damage done to cowpea by C.maculatus . Also having shown that some pepper
varieties show differences in their effectiveness to control C.maculatus in cowpea varieties, more
efficiency will be achieved with proper combination between the cowpea varieties and the
pepper varieties. It is therefore recommended that farmers across Nigeria and all over the world
should adopt the method of using pepper in controlling the damage done to cowpea by
C.maculatus. The benefits of using this method is that; it requires less skill, costs less and not
hazardous to humans in comparison with the use of chemicals which when not use in correct
proportion can pose great threats to human health.
174
175
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Sincere appreciation goes to the Vice chancellor, Benue State University, Makurdi, Professor
Charity Ashimem Angya and Management Staff and all staff of the Department of Biological
Sciences, Benue State University, for their support and encouragement.
REFERENCES
Bressani, R. (1985). Nutritive Value of Cowpea: Research, Production and Utilization, edited
By S.R. Singh and K.O. Rachie. John Wiley & Sons, New York, USA. Pp 353-360
Carlos, G. (2004). Cowpea: Post harvest Operations. Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations, Rome, Italy. Pp 1-70
Ebiamadon, A.B., Sophia, E.A., Uduak, E., Fradideh, B., and Glyn, M.F. (2011).
ControllingBruchid Pests of Stored Cowpea Seeds with Dried Leaves of Artemisia annua
and other common Botanicals. African Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (47):95869592.
Epidi, T.T., Nwani, C.D. and Udoh, S. (2008). Efficacy of some plant species for the contro
Of cowpea weevil (Callosobruchus maculatus) and maize weevil (Sitophilus
zeamais). Niger Delta University, Yenagoa, Nigeria. International. Journal of
Agricultural Biology 10:588-590
Ivbijaro, M.F. (1983). Preservation of cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp with Neem seed,
(Azadirachta indica) A. Juss. Protection Ecology 5: 177-182.
Ogbaji, M.I. and Osuman, D. (2011). Insecticidal Actions of some Botanicals on Storage
Bruchid,(Callosobruchus maculatus) of Stored Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata).
Makurdi, Nigeria. Journal of Tropical Agriculture, Food, Environment and Extension.
Vol.10(2):29-34
Ogbaji, M.I. (2002). Genetics of Resistance of Cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp to the
Pod Sucking Bug,Clavigralla tomentosicolis (Stal.) Hemiptera: Corcidae). Journal of
Sustainable Tropical Agricultural Resarch, 3:28-32
Ogbaji M.I. and Tyoga, K.M. (2010). Comparative Efficiency of Ginger Scale Leaves of
Onions and Dried Peels of Oranges in the Storage of Cowpea Against Cowpea weevil
(Callosobruchus maculatus). Journal of Tropical Agriculture, Food, Environmental
and Extension. Agro Science Vol 9(4):31-37
Singh, B.B. and Eaglesfield, R.P. (2000). Adoption and Impact of Dry season Dual Purpose
Cowpea in the Nigeria semi arid Region. Consultative Group on International
Agricultural Research (CGIAR) Kano, Nigeria. Pp 1-6
Schmuhener, H. and Ascher, K.R.S. (1984). Natural Pesticides from the Neem Tree and other
Tropical plants. Proc. 2nd Int. Neem Conference, Reuschotzhouzen, GTZ Eschborn,
Pp 7-10.
Tindall, H.U. (1965). Fruits and Vegetables in West Africa. and Agricultural Organization of the
United National Evans Brothers, London. Pp 146
Udomporn, P. (2009). Efficiency of Vetiver Grass Extracts Against Cowpea Weevil
(Callosobruchus maculatus). Faculty of Agriculture Natural Resources and
Environmental, Naresuan University Thailand. American Eurasian Journal Agric and
Environ.sci Vol.6(3):356-359
175
176
Table 1.
Main Effects of Varieties and Treatments on Actual Weight loss(grams) of
Cowpea seeds During Storage.
Cowpea
Varieties
Weeks of storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
Small white 498.50
496.16
490.18
481.30
471.80
457.20
Big white
495.06
492.37
490.55
482.12
478.20
473.70
IAR 48
498.51
499.09
498.55
487.63
480.20
464.50
Iron beans
491.66
483.85
474.37
491.66
450.30
434.50
Aloka
498.81
498.39
495.30
490.93
489.80
482.00
S.E
0.715
2.243
1.573
2.991
4.330
6.850
F.L.S.D0.05
1.46
4.58
3.21
6.11
8.84
14.00
Hot pepper
497.15
493.89
490.24
487.85
476.30
465.60
Sweet
pepper
496.69
493.79
489.37
487.26
472.10
458.90
Mild
pepper
495.69
494.23
489.76
485.08
473.70
462.60
F.L.S.D0.05
1.13
3.35
2.49
4.73
6.85
10.84
Treatment
176
177
Table 2.
Main Effects Of Varieties and Treatments on Percentage Weight Loss (%) of
Cowpea Seeds During Storage
Cowpea
Varieties
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
Small white 0.30
0.77
1.96
3.74
5.32
8.56
Big white
0.98
1.44
2.06
3.58
4.36
5.25
IAR 48
0.03
0.18
0.29
2.46
3.96
7.10
Iron beans
1.67
4.06
5.13
7.10
9.94
13.22
Aloka
0.25
0.32
0.94
1.37
2.99
3.62
S.E
0.12
0.20
0.30
0.58
0.90
1.39
F.L.S.D0.05
0.25
0.41
0.61
1.18
1.84
2.83
Hot pepper
0.58
1.22
1.95
3.38
4.74
6.87
Sweet
pepper
0.66
1.48
2.13
3.85
6.00
8.22
Mild
pepper
0.70
1.37
2.15
3.73
5.20
7.57
F.L.S.D0.05
0.1895
0.3156
0.4746
0.9160
1.4280
2.1920
Treatment
177
178
Table 3.
Interactive Effects of Varieties and Treatments on Actual Weight Loss
(grams) of Cowpea Seeds During Storage
Cowpea
Varieties
Pepper
Varieties
Small white
Big white
IAR48
Iron beans
Aloka
F.L.S.D0.05
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
Hot
498.44
496.45
490.59
482.82
474.20
468.10
Sweet
498.56
496.32
491.46
480.61
471.10
453.20
Mild
498.51
495.72
488.48
480.46
470.00
455.20
Hot
495.63
493.22
490.88
485.04
482.00
475.90
Sweet
495.79
493.86
492.29
488.93
486.60
483.70
Mild
493.75
490.04
488.48
472.39
466.00
461.60
Hot
499.74
498.66
498.08
486.46
479.40
466.40
Sweet
499.86
499.28
499.05
489.37
482.10
467.80
Mild
495.94
499.31
498.52
487.07
479.10
459.20
Hot
493.85
483.29
478.32
493.85
457.80
443.60
Sweet
490.14
480.96
467.98
490.14
431.00
407.5
Mild
490.99
487.31
476.82
490.99
462.00
452.40
Hot
498.10
497.84
493.33
491.08
488.20
479.10
Sweet
499.08
498.54
496.09
487.23
489.70
482.50
Mild
499.25
498.78
496.49
494.47
491.50
484.50
2.530
7.933
5.563
10.582
15.32
24.24
178
179
Table 4.
Interaction Effects of Varieties and Treatments on Percentage Weight Loss
(%) of Cowpea Seeds During Storage.
Cowpea
Pepper
Varieties
Varieties
Small white
Big white
IAR48
Iron beans
Aloka
F.L.S.D0.05
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
Hot
0.31
0.71
1.88
3.44
5.160
7.37
Sweet
0.29
0.74
1.71
3.88
6.44
9.35
Mild
0.30
0.86
2.30
3.91
4.34
8.97
Hot
0.89
1.36
1.82
3.00
3.61
4.81
Sweet
0.82
1.23
1.54
2.21
2.67
3.36
Mild
1.25
1.73
2.80
5.52
6.81
7.69
Hot
0.05
0.27
0.38
2.71
4.12
6.71
Sweet
0.03
0.14
0.19
2.26
3.58
6.44
Mild
0.01
0.14
0.30
2.42
4.18
8.15
Hot
1.23
3.34
4.34
5.96
8.45
11.29
Sweet
1.97
4.98
6.40
9.66
13.80
18.51
Mild
1.80
0.14
4.64
5.69
7.56
9.86
Hot
0.42
0.43
1.33
1.78
2.35
4.18
Sweet
0.18
0.29
0.79
1.22
3.51
3.51
Mild
0.15
0.24
0.70
1.11
3.10
3.17
0.43
0.71
0.52
2.05
3.19
4.90
179
180
Plate 1 Sweet Pepper
Plate 2 Hot Pepper
Plate 3 Moderately Hot pepper
Plate 4 Iron Beans
180
181
Plate 5 Aloka
Plate 6 Big White
181
182
Plate 7 IAR48
Plate 8 Small White
182
183
PGB35
SEARCHING FOR SSR MARKERS ASSOCIATED WITH ALECTRA VOGELII
RESISTANCE GENE IN COWPEA [VIGNA UNGUICULATA (L.) WALP] USING BULK
SEGREGANT ANALYSIS
Ugbaa, M.S.1*, Omoigui, L.O.1, Bello, L.L.1, Gowda, B.S.2 and Timko, M.P.2
1
Department of Plant Breeding and Seed Science, College of Agronomy, University of
Agriculture, P.M.B. 2373, Makurdi, Nigeria.
2
Department of Biology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia, 22903, U.S.A.
*Corresponding e-mail: macsamuelu@yahoo.com; macsesugh@gmail.com)
ABSTRACT
The obligate root parasitic weed Alectra vogelii (Benth.) is one of the more formidable biotic
constraints to cowpea productivity in the dry Savannas of West and Central Africa- which
accounts for over 64 % of world cowpea production. This parasite causes yield losses of
between70 to 100% in susceptible cultivars. The use of resistant varieties remains the
environmentally friendly and economically viable means of controlling the parasite. Molecular
markers have been identified that are associated with specific Striga resistance genes in cowpea,
at present no marker has been identified for Alectra resistance in cowpea. The availability of
molecular markers tightly linked to Alectra resistance genes will open up the possibility of
applying MAS to cowpea improvement in breeding programmes, focused on developing elite
cowpea lines that are resistance to Alectra . A study was designed to identify molecular markers
linked to Alectra resistant gene using SSRs and Bulk Segregant Analysis (BSA). F2 population
of a single cross, Banjar (susceptible parent) × B301 (resistant parent) was screened for reaction
to Alectra using pot culture technique. DNA was extracted from parental genotypes and F2 lines
at 14 DAP using FTA® plant saver cards. 50 SSR cowpea, 40 SSR rice bean and 50 SSR
asparagus bean primers were used to screen DNA from B301 and Banjar for polymorphism. 20
primers were polymorphic in B301 and Banjar and these were used in the technique of BSA
performed with DNA bulks of highly resistant and susceptible F2 lines to select those that cosegregated with the resistant gene. RB16 from rice bean and CLM0356 from asparagus bean
were selected and used to screen 150 F2 lines for marker segregation, association and linkage
analysis. Cluster analysis as depicted by dendogram showed a tight association (>0.75) between
these markers, suggesting that these markers can be explored in MAS targeting breeding for
Alectra resistance in cowpea.
183
184
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp.) is an important food legume grown in tropical and
subtropical regions of the world (Timko and Singh, 2008). It is a valuable source of protein
(23%) that supplements the high carbohydrate diet of many African people (Bressani, 1985).
Cowpea is widely grown in the savannas of West and Central Africa where the crop is of
high importance. Nigeria is the largest producer with production estimates of over 2.3 million
tons which accounts for over 50% of the total world production (Kamara et al.2008). Despite
its importance in sub-Saharan Africa and its wide spread high potential, cowpea growth and
yields are constrained by several biotic and abiotic factors (Omoigui et al. 2007). The more
formidable biological constraints to increased cowpea productivity in West and Central
Africa are attack by the witch weeds Striga and Alectra (Omoigui et al. 2012). Alectra
vogelii Benth. Of the Orobanchaceae family) is distributed across West Africa (Riches et al.
1992), and in Nigeria its prevalence lies between northern Guinea savanna and Sudan
savanna (Emechebe et al. 1991). Effect of A. vogelii parasitism on cowpea results in yield
losses which range between 70 and 100% (Kureh et al. 1999), estimated in the millions of
tons annually (Singh and Emechebe, 1997).
Chemical and cultural control strategies to combat the parasitic weeds are difficult and
expensive and, therefore the use of host plant resistance to control the parasitic weeds (Striga
and Alectra) appears to be preferable since it is affordable by resource poor farmers who lack
the financial means to use high input management practices and other options ( Omoigui et
al. 2012), and environmentally friendly. Diego et al. (2006) have also stated that other control
strategies developed for control of parasitic weeds have been without unequivocal success.
However, appropriate screening and effective selection indices are needed to ensure success.
Novel molecular biology techniques have been used by various researchers to identify
molecular (DNA) markers linked to different traits of interest in several crop plants. In
cowpea, employing these novel tools has aided the successful identification of markers linked
to different race-specific Striga gesnerioides resistance genes (Ouedraogo et al. 2001;
Ouedraogo et al. 2002). Application of molecular markers in breeding programs can help to
eliminate environmental factor, allow smaller populations to be used, reduce the number of
184
185
generations needed to reach a goal and increase the accuracy of evaluations (Timko et al.
2007a). Over the years the integration of marker assisted selection (MAS) into A. vogelii
resistance breeding has been hampered by the absence of molecular markers linked to the
resistance gene. Therefore the objective of this work was to identify molecular (DNA)
markers linked to A. vogelii resistance gene in cowpea using SSR mapping and Bulked
segregant analysis (BSA).
The SSR technique is simple, easily reproducible, requires little quantity of moderate quality
DNA and characterized by higher levels of detection of polymorphism at a given locus than
other molecular marker systems (Grivet and Noyer, 1999). Also Bulked segregant analysis is
a rapid procedure for identifying molecular markers in specific regions of organism’s genome
using a segregating population (Michelmore et al. 1991). Therefore, a combination of these
two techniques offered a good platform for marker identification.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
F2 progenies from a single cross between B301 and Banjar were used for this work. Genomic
DNA was extracted from leaf tissue of the first trifoliate leaves of 14 days old parental
genotypes along with the derived F2 population comprising 150 lines, using FTA® Plantsaver
cards and made PCR ready following the procedure outlined by Omoigui et al. (2012) with
slight modifications. 140 SSR primers used in this work were supplied by the Mike Timko
laboratory of the Department of Biology, University of Virginia, USA. All PCRs were
performed with AccuPower® PCR PreMix (Bioneer) (1 U Top DNA polymerase, 250 μL
each of DNTPs mix, 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH 9.0), 30 mM KCl, 1.5 mM MgCl2 and stabilizer
and tracking dye), using a heated lid thermal cycler (Bio-Rad MyCycler™). After
amplification, PCR products were separated on a 2% agarose gel stained with ethidium
bromide (10mg/ml of H20) using horizontal gel electrophoresis system (GALILEO
bioscience) and viewed on a Benchtop UV Transilluminator (M-26V). Gel images were taken
with a digital camera and subsequently scored prior to data analysis. DNA from parent
genotypes was screened for polymorphism using 140 primers- 50 SSR primers from cowpea
genome (Prefixed Cp), along with 40 SSR primers from rice bean (Prefixed RB) and 50 SSR
primers from asparagus bean (Prefixed CLM), developed and proven to give amplification
products in cowpea. 20 of these primers were polymorphic with respect to Alectra resistance
and these were used for bulk segregant analysis.
185
186
DNA bulks for bulk segregant analysis were obtained from highly resistant and susceptible
F2 lines. PCR was first performed using DNA extracted from the individual resistant and
susceptible lines selected for bulking. Aliquot of 5 μL was pipetted from the PCR product of
5 lines into a single PCR tube to make a single bulk. This procedure was followed to
construct all the DNA bulks. BSA was then performed by using primers that showed
polymorphism in the parental lines to screen the DNA bulks along with the parents (B301and
Banjar) as check.
L
RESULTS
The result of the BSA revealed two primers- RB16 from Rice bean and CLM0356 that cosegregated with the resistant gene (Plate 1). A close look at plate 1 shows the segregation
integrity of primer RB16 and CLM0356. For these primers, the susceptible bulks segregated
with the susceptible parent while the resistant bulks segregated with the resistant parent as
shown by band movement and pattern. Whereas RB32 primer, produced similar bands with
the resistant and susceptible bulks (Plate 1).
Plates 3 and 4 show agarose gel electrophoretic images of F2 lines screened with primers
RB16 and CLM0356. These primers were able to discriminate between resistance and
susceptibility. They were identified as likely linked to Alectra resistant gene based on the
BSA technique. For both primers, the banding pattern showed that the resistant band sits
above the susceptible band. The parents were included for ease of scoring. Homozygous
resistant lines had single band and were scored 'A', while susceptible band was scored 'B' and
heterozygous resistant lines had double band and were scored 'AB' (Plates 2 and 3).
186
187
Plate 1: Sample image of agarose gel electrophoretic analysis of PCR amplified product for
Bulk Segregant Analysis with Polymorphic Primers. L = 100 bp ladder, C = control without
genomic DNA template, P1 = B301 (resistant parent), P2 = Banjar (susceptible parent), S1=
Susceptible bulk 1, S2 = Susceptible bulk 2, R1= Resistant bulk 1, R2 = Resistant bulk 2.
Plate 2: Sample image of agarose gel electrophoretic analysis of PCR amplified product using
primer RB16 for the F2 progenies derived from B301 x Banjar. L = 100 bp ladder, C =
control without genomic DNA template. P1 = B301, P2 = Banjar.
187
188
Plate 3: Sample image of agarose gel electrophoretic analysis of PCR amplified product using
CLM0356 for the F2 progenies derived from B301 x Banjar. L = 100 bp ladder, C = control
without genomic DNA template. P1 = B301, P2 = Banjar.
Association analysis of the segregation data of the two markers, which co-segregated with the
resistant gene, was performed using the computer software (Figure 1). The cluster analysis
also revealed that RB 16 and CLM0356 were close with coefficient of association of 0.75
compared with PS score with degree of association of 0.5.
Figure 1: Dendogram showing the relationship of three cowpea markers based on segregation
with Alectra resistance gene in an F2 population. PS=Phenotypic marker. RO= molecular
marker (RB16). CLM=molecular marker (CLM0356)
DISCUSSION
The suitability of FTA PlantSaver Cards for collection, storage and recovery of cowpea
genomic DNA for molecular analysis has already been reported by Omoigui et al., (2001,
2012), this was also found to be suitable for analyzing bulk DNA. Electrophoretic gels
stained with ethidium bromide, viewed under UV light showed clear bands with little or no
smearing, which indicated that sufficient quantity of high quality DNA was trapped and
retained in the FTA paper matrix. Usually 20 ng of high quality DNA is sufficient to give
amplification product from PCR. The washing process to purify the DNA and make it PCR
ready was efficient and contributed to the resultant high quality DNA. According to Omoigui
et al. (2012), FTA® cards provide a simple alternative method for collection, storage and
retrieval of genomic DNA for molecular study especially when operating in developing
countries and regions remote from laboratory facilities.
All the 140 SSR primers screened for this work gave amplification products with cowpea
genomic DNA but not all were polymorphic. Generally, SSR markers were co-dominant,
188
189
except two of the markers that were dominant. The scoring of alleles at a specific locus
required careful examination of gel images particularly for F2 progeny to be able to
distinguish between dominant, susceptible, and heterozygous resistant alleles. The
ubiquitousness and even distribution of SSRs (Grivet and Noyer, 1999) is one of the
advantages that have made SSR marker system attractive to scientists. In the present work,
however, only 20 SSR primers out of the 140 primers screened were polymorphic with the
parental lines used (B301 and Banjar). This suggests that even though B301 is a land race
while Banjar is a domesticated variety, little genetic variation exists between them, hence the
low level of polymorphism. This may also be a pointer that there is low level of within-specie
variation in SSRs. Considering the fact that SSR primers from Asparagus and Rice bean gave
amplification products in cowpea, there seems to be a conservation of SSRs in the
unguiculata genome. This also implies that there is great potential for transferability of SSR
markers between the three species (asparagus bean, rice bean, and cowpea) for molecular
studies. According to Sharma (2008), microsatellite sequences are conserved over wide
ranges of organisms and non-specie specific. Conservation of sequences is a factor that aids
in primer design, and primers designed for a particular crop can be used for studies on
another crop. The fact that SSR primers from Asparagus and Rice bean were polymorphic
between cowpea genotypes with respect to Alectra resistance, also suggests a possible
conservation of resistant gene analogues between these 3 sub-species that can be explored for
identification and isolation of resistance genes.
The technique of bulk segregant analysis (BSA) is a powerful technique that has gained wide
acceptance in the few years since it was first described by Michelmore et al. (1991). BSA
which has become a popular technique in molecular breeding, has been combined with
various marker systems to identify markers linked to resistance genes in sorghum (Mutengwa
et al. 2005), apple (Yang et al. 1997), barley (Ardiel et al. 2002), wheat (William et al.
2002)etc. In a single study, Zhang et al. (2012) successfully used BSA in concert with
AFLPs, SSRs, COSs, ISSRs, and TRAPs to map molecular markers linked to NIRPT a
Downy mildew gesistance Gene in Nicotiana langsdorffii.
Previously BSA has been performed by bulking diluted genomic DNA before PCR
amplification. In the present study, bulking was done after PCR amplification of DNA of
individual lines selected for BSA i.e. post PCR DNA bulking. The result proved that BSA
technique is a fast and reliable method for the identification of markers as it enabled the
189
190
identification 2 putative markers- CLM0356 from Asparagus bean and RB16 from Rice bean
out of 20 polymorphic markers. This result also shows that post PCR bulking of DNA is a
unique novel approach for BSA using DNA collected with FTA Plant Saver Card.
Cluster analysis as depicted by dendogram also showed a tight association (>0.75) between
these markers and Alectra resistance gene showed a close linkage with the resistance gene..
Similar approach has been used to identify a range of marker–trait associations in hexaploid
wheat (Roy et al. 2006). Hence the association of these markers with the Alectra resistance
gene offers a unique opportunity for incorporation of marker assisted selection in local and
national breeding programs to fast track breeding and delivery of Alectra resistant varieties.
CONCLUSION
BSA technique identified two SSR markers - CLM0356 and RB16 as closely linked marker
to Alectra resistant gene. Cluster analysis showed a tight association between these markers
and Alectra resistance gene. Association of these markers with the Alectra resistance open up
the possibility of applying MAS to cowpea improvement in breeding programmes, focused
on developing elite cowpea lines that are resistance to Alectra .
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This research was funded by Kirkhouse Trust UK. We would like to appreciate the
contributions of staff of the Mike Timko Laboratory, Department of Biology, University of
Virginia USA and the Molecular Biology Laboratory, Department of Plant Breeding and
Seed Science, University of Agriculture Makurdi.
REFERENCES
Ardiel, G.S., Grewal, T.S., Deberdt, P., Rossnagel, B.G. and Scoles, G.J. (2002). Inheritance
of resistance to covered smut in barley and development of tightly linked SCAR
marker. Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 104: 457-464.
Bressani, R. (1985). Nutritive value of cowpea. In: Cowpea research, Production and
Utilization. Singh S. R. and Rachel K. O. (eds). pp. 353-360. Wiley and Sons,
Chester, UK.
Diego R., Alejandro P., Monica F., Josefina C. S., Belen R., Mohamed K., Shaban K., Daniel
M. J. and Charlie R. 2006. Screening techniques and sources of resistance against
parasitic weeds in grain legumes. Euphytica, 147: 187-199.
190
191
Emechebe, A. M., Singh, B. B., Leleji, O. I., Atokple, I. D. K. and Adu, J. K. (1991). Cowpea
Striga problems and research in Nigeria. In: Kim
SK, editor. Combating Striga in
Africa, Proceedings of an International Workshops, 1988 August22-24; August,
Ibadan, Nigeria.
Grivet, L. and Noyer, J. L. (1999). Les méthodes de marquage biochimique et moléculaire. In
:Hamon P., Seguine M., Perrier X. and Glaszmann J.C., (eds.) Diversité génétique des
plantes tropicales cultivées. CIRAD, pp.13- 41.
Kamara, A. Y., Chikoye, D., Ekeleme, F., Omoigui, L. O. and Dugje, I. Y. (2008). Field
performance of improved cowpea varieties under conditions of natural infestation by
parasitic weed Striga gesnerioides. Int J. Pest Management, 54(3): 189- 195.
Michelmore, R. W., Paran, I. and Kesseli, R. V. (1991). Identification of markers linked to
disease-resistance genes by bulked segregant analysis: A rapid method to detect
markers
in specific genomic regions by using segregating populations. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci., 88: 9828-9832.
Mutengwa, C.S., Tongoona, P.B. and Sithole-Niang, I. (2005). Genetic studies and a search
for molecular markers that are linked to Striga asiatica resistance in sorghum. Afr. J.
Biotechnol., Vol. 4 (12): 1355-1361.
Omoigui, L. O., Kamara, A. Y., Massawe, F. S., Ishiyaku, M. F., Boukar, O., Alabi, S. O. and
Ekeleme, F. (2007). Evaluation of cowpea genotypes for their reactions to Striga
gesnerioides in the dry savanna of northeast Nigeria. Afrc. Crop Sc. Conf. Proc. Vol.
8: 273-278.
Omoigui, L.O., Kamara, A.Y., Ishiyaku, F.S. and Boukar, O. (2012).Comparative responses
of cowpea breeding lines to Striga and Alectra in the dry savanna of northeast
Nigeria. Afri. J. of Agri. Res., 7(5): 747-754.
Ouédraogo, J.T., Maheshwari, V., Berner, D.K., St-Pierre, C.A., Belzile, F., and Timko, M.P.
2001. Identification of AFLP markers linked to resistance of cowpea (Vigna
unguiculata L.) to
parasitism by Striga gesneroides. Theor.Appl. Genet. , 102:
1029-1036.
Ouédraogo, J.T., Tignegre, J.B., Timko, M.P. and Belzile, F.J. (2002). AFLP markers
linked to resistance against Striga gesnerioides race 1 in cowpea (Vigna unguiculata
L.). Genome, 45(5):787–793.
191
192
Roy, J.K., Bandopadhyay, R., Rustgi, S., Balyan, H.S. and Gupta, P.K. (2006). Association
analysis of agronomically important traits using SSR, SAMPL and AFLP markers in
bread wheat. Current Science, 90: 683–389.
Sharma, A., Namdeo, A.G. and Mahadik, K.R. (2008). Molecular Markers: New Prospects
in Plant Genome Analysis. Phcog Rev., 2 (3): 23-24.
Singh B. B. (2002). Recent genetic studies in cowpea. In: Fatokun C. A., Tarawali S. A.,
Singh B. B., Kormawa P. M., Tamo M. (eds.) Challenges and Opportunities for
Enhancing Sustainable Cowpea Production. Intl Inst
Tropical Agric, Ibadan,
Nigeria, pp. 3–13.
Singh, B. B. (2002). Breeding cowpea varieties for resistance to Striga gesnerioides and
Alectra vogelii. In: Fatokun C. A. et al., (eds). Challenges and opportunities for
enhancing
sustainable cowpea production. IITA, Ibadan, Nigeria, pp. 154-166.
SP-IPM. (2003). IPM Research Brief No. 1.International Institute of Tropical Agriculture
(IITA), Cotonou, Benin. www.spipm.cgiar.org.
Timko, M. P., Ehlers J. D. and Roberts P. A. 2007a. Cowpea. In: Kole C. (ed.) Genome
Mapping and Molecular Breeding in Plants, Volume 3, Pulses, Sugar and Tuber
Crops, Springer Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg. pp. 49–67.
Timko, M.P. and Singh, B.B. (2008). Cowpea, a Multifunctional Legume. Moore P.H., Ming
R. (eds.), Genomics of Tropical Crop Plants. Pp. 227-258.
William, K.J., Taylor, S.P., Bogacki, P., Pallotta, M., Bariana, H.S. and Wallwork, H. (2002).
Mapping of the root lesion nematode (Pratylenchus neglectus) resistance gene Rlnn 1
in wheat. Theoretical and applied genetics 104:874-879.
Yang, H.Y., Korban, S.S., Kr¨uger, J. and Schmidt, H. (1997). The use of a modified bulk
segregant analysis to identify a molecular marker linked to a scab resistance gene in
apple. Euphytica, 94: 175–182.
Zhang, S. and Zaitlin, D. (2008). Genetic resistance to Peronospora tabacina in Nicotiana
langsdorffii, a South American wild tobacco. Phytopathology, 98: 519-528.
PGB36
192
193
EVALUATION OF MORPHOLOGICAL AND MICRONUTRIENT CONTENTS OF
THREE VARIETIES OF SWEET POTATO (IPOMOEA BATATAS L.) IN CALABAR,
NIGERIA
Edu, N.E.1, Ibiang,Y.B. 1*, Ekanem, B.E.2 and Ekpo, P.B.1,
1
Department of Genetics and Biotechnology, University of Calabar, PMB 1115, Calabar
Nigeria.
2
Department of Science Technology, Akwa Ibom State Polytechnic, Ikot Osurua, P.M.B.
1200, Ikot Ekpene, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail address: youngangale@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Morphological performance and nutrients content was evaluated in three varieties of sweet
potato; TIS 87/0087, TIS 8164, and Digitate, cultivated in Calabar. Vines were planted in
manually prepared beds in a complete randomized design, with three replicates. At maturity,
data on morphological parameters and micronutrients composition was collected and
subjected to one way analysis of variance (ANOVA). Digitate had significantly higher
(P<0.05) vine length than TIS 87/0087 and TIS 8164. Other morphological parameters
revealed no significant differences (P>0.05) between the cultivars. Digitate also had
significantly higher (P<0.05) Fe, Zn, and β-carotene than TIS 8164, which had a significantly
higher Mn than the other two cultivars. We conclude that on sandy-loam soil in Calabar,
Digitate variety of sweet potato had higher micronutrient content than TIS 87/0087 and TIS
8164, and is thus recommended for cultivation in this geo-ecological zone, especially where
increased quantity of the stated micronutrients is desired in the diet.
INTRODUCTION
The expansion of population in many countries of the world continues to place much demand
for improved varieties of crops to fill the dietary needs of humans. Much of the current
growth in global human populations takes place in developing nations of Africa, the Middle
East, and Asia; where adequate nutrition remains a great challenge to many low income
families (Diaz et al., 2003). Protein, vitamin, and mineral deficiencies are recognized to be at
the heart of the global disease burden Black (2003). According to Frossard et al. (2000),
vitamin A, iron, calcium, magnesium, and zinc, amongst others, are generally inadequate in
the diet, and have been implicated in poor cognitive development, and lower disease
resistance, especially in children. The strategy of regular in-take of pharmaceutical
supplements and “nutri-fortified” canned foods, could achieve good results, but are not
without notable costs; and so, are neither sustainable within many families nor on a global
scale (Bouis, 2003). This has prompted much interest in utilization of techniques in crop
genetics and biotechnology, in development of crops with enhanced nutrient content capacity
(Raven et al., 2005).
Sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas L.) is a dicotyledonous plant belonging to the family
Convolvulaceae (Tumwegamire, 2011). With an estimated annual production of 124 million
tons, it is the world’s 7th most important food crop, after wheat, rice, maize, potato, barley,
and cassava (FAOSTAT, 2007), and is a popular staple in many countries where it is
consumed by a great many folks. Nutritionally, sweet potato is rich in carbohydrate, soluble
sugars, vitamins, and nutrients (Senanayake, et al, 2013). In Nigeria, the National Root Crop
Research Institute (NRCRI), Umudike, has developed improved varieties of sweet potato,
193
194
especially those with resistance to common pests, increased starch content, and yields,
amongst others.
Interest in nutrient content of staples, such as sweet potato, yam, and cassava, has increased
in the intellectual and public domains; due to the realization of the fact that aside fulfilling
our energy needs, staples with increased nutrient content do have a great potential in the quest
for optimum nutritional status in poor families in developing countries, such as Nigeria. This
forms much of the underlying rationale of this study on three varieties of sweet potato
popular in Southeast Nigeria. Further justification of study is evident, in the light of the
variability in nutrient content of crops grown in different geo-ecological zones; as edaphic
factors such as soil physico-chemical characteristics have been known to affect performance
and nutrient content of food and/or feed crops (Venuto et al., 2002). Much of sweet potato
cultivation takes place in the “Middle belt” states of Nigeria. In the light of the
aforementioned, and as G×E studies in sweet potato have reported it to be sensitive to
soil/environment component (Tumwegamire, 2011), this study was conducted to determine
the micronutrient content of three varieties of sweet potato, grown on sandy loam soil of
Calabar, Cross River State, Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The three varieties of sweet potato used in this study were TIS 87/0087, TIS 8164, and
Digitate; all obtained from NRCRI, Umudike, Abia State, Nigeria.This experiment was
carried out in Department of Biological Science experimental farm, University of Calabar,
Calabar, on a plot of land measuring 10 × 10 meters, with a general sandy-loam soil nature.
The plot was divided into nine (2 × 2 m) beds; three for each sweet potato variety. Each
variety was randomly assigned to three beds, where they were planted. The beds were labeled
A, B, and C; for TIS 87/0087, TIS 8164, and Digitate respectively. Potato stem cuttings with
length of 15-20 cm were planted, two per stand (later thinned to one) on each bed, in a
slanting position, with minimum interspacing distance of 50 cm maintained. Each bed had 6
stands, giving a total of 18 replicates for each sweet potato cultivar. NPK 15:15:15 fertilizer
was applied once, by ring method, three weeks after planting, and hand weeding was
performed fortnightly, after every three weeks (Agbede and Adekiya, 2011).
After maturity, data were collected on leaf length, vine diameter, internodes length, leaf area,
and vine length. Harvested root samples were collected bed by bed, washed, air dried and
macerated, then oven dried for 6hrs at 120oC. Oven dried roots were ground into a fine
powder in a commercial electric blender . Laboratory analysis of micronutrients content of
roots powder was performed in Department of Biochemistry, University of Calabar, Calabar,
for β-carotene, iron, zinc, iodine, and manganese, according to the methods described by
AOAC (1997), and absorbance read in a spectrophotometer (Jenway 6405, Essex, England).
All data collected were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) to check for significant
differences between the cultivars at 5% probability level, and mean separation was achieved
using (least significant difference) LSD.
RESULTS
Table 1 show the morphological attributes of three varieties of sweet potato cultivated in
Calabar. Of all the attributes evaluated in this study, only vine length showed significant
(P<0.05), differences between Digitate (which had the highest value) and the other two. Leaf
length, leaf area, vine diameter, and internodes length revealed no significant (P>0.05)
differences between the cultivars.
194
195
Table 1: Morphological attributes of sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas L.) cultivars
Parameter (cm)
TIS 87/0087
TIS 8164
Digitate
a
a
6.87 ± 0.43
7.01 ± 0.82
7.13a ± 0.31
Leaf length
16.48a ± 0.25
17.30a ± 0.27
17.10a ± 0.33
Leaf area
a
a
0.95 ± 0.06
0.90 ± 0.18
0.83a ± 0.03
Vine diameter
71.33a ± 0.26
66.73a ± 0.34
81.60b ± 0.39
Vine length
a
a
3.48 ± 0.29
2.83 ± 0.28
3.10a ± 0.50
Internodes length
Values are mean ± SEM. abValues with the same superscript are not significantly different at
5% based on ANOVA.
Table 2 show the micronutrients content of three varieties of sweet potato cultivated in
Calabar. Digitate had a significantly (P<0.05) higher zinc content than TIS 87/0087 and TIS
8164. TIS 8164 had significantly (P<0.05) lower iron content than the other two cultivars.
TIS 8164 had the highest value for manganese, and this was significantly (P<0.05) higher
than that of Digitate, and TIS 87/0087 which had the lowest. While Digitate had significantly
(P<0.05) higher β-carotene content than TIS 8164, no significant (P>0.05) differences were
observed in iodine content among the three cultivars.
Table 2: Micronutrients content of sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas L.) cultivars
Parameter (mg/100g)
TIS 87/0087
TIS 8164
Digitate
a
a
0.20 ± 0.02
0.18 ± 0.02
0.34b ± 0.08
Zinc
1.66b ± 0.05
1.50a ± 0.03
1.70b ± 0.07
Iron
a
b
0.10 ± 0.01
1.13 ± 0.09
0.40a ± 0.04
Manganese
2.61a ± 0.10
2.47a ± 0.31
2.53a ± 0.27
Iodine
ab
a
0.34 ± 0.05
0.28 ± 0.03
0.41b ± 0.04
β-carotene
Values are mean ± SEM. abValues with the same superscript are not significantly different at
5% based on ANOVA.
DISCUSSION
The importance of micronutrients to the human body cannot be overemphasized. β-carotene
is converted to vitamin A in the human body, which plays a very important role in proper
vision and immune functioning, cell growth and differentiation, amongst others . Iron is an
essential mineral in the synthesis of haemoglobin, the oxygen carrying pigment in blood; zinc
is essential for growth, development, reproduction, sensory and immune functions, etc.; while
manganese is involved in activation of enzymes. Iodine is important in metabolism and
energy release rate, and deficiency can cause goiter (Cunnigham-Rundles et al., 2005; Insel et
al., 2010). As long as metabolism is to continue optimally, dietary intake of these nutrients
therefore, is a necessity.
With the exception of vine length, morphological attributes of the sweet potato varieties did
not reveal significant differences between them. This means, perhaps, that these cultivars are
almost equal with respect to growth attributes, in Calabar. With respect to micronutrients
however, there existed significant diversity between TIS 87/0087, TIS 8164, and Digitate,
going by the results of this study; Digitate performed much better than the other two, with a
higher zinc and iron, as well as β-carotene. Nutrient content is yet to be associated or
correlated with length of vine in sweet potato. We think therefore, that the higher vine length
in Digitate, might not just yet be associated with its better performance in nutrients content; at
least until sufficient experimental evidence points to such possibility; for example, by gene
195
196
linkage. This position is justifiable especially as TIS 8164 which had the shortest vine length,
had significantly higher manganese content than both Digitate and TIS/870087.
Differences with genetic basis (as is supposedly the case with these cultivars) in innate
attributes of plant varieties result in differences in overall plant physiology and performance,
and can account perhaps, for differences in nutrient content observed in many plant cultivars,
under similar environmental conditions (Høgh-Jensen et al., 2006). And even where much
morphological differences were not observed, significant differences in nutrient content of
plants could be noted, as is the case here; with Digitate performing better than the other two
in zinc and iron content. This potential is note-worthy, from a crop genetics viewpoint.
Comparatively, and on soil with a general sandy-loam nature, in Calabar, Digitate contained
higher zinc, iron, and β-carotene, than TIS 87/0087 and TIS 8164; but TIS 8164 showed a
higher manganese content than the other two. All three cultivars performed equally with
respect to iodine content.
CONCLUSION
Results of this study indicate that Digitate might be cultivated/consumed more, where
increased quantity of micronutrients such as zinc and iron, as well as β-carotene, is an overriding consideration; at least in Calabar and similar geo-ecological zones. As the quest for
genetic improvement of local crop varieties (in features of dietary and nutritional
significance) is one of continuing relevance, the results of studies such as this, in different
geo-ecological zones can result in increased utility of, and benefits from, peculiar cultivars, as
well as lend more impetus to local breeding programs.
REFERENCES
Agbede T. M. and A. O. Adekiya (2011). Evaluation of sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas
L.)performance and soil properties under tillage methods and poultry manure levels,
Emir. J.Food Agric. 23 (2): 164-177
AOAC (Association of Official Analytical Chemists International) (1997). Official Methods
of Analysis, 16th Ed., Arlington, VA.
Black, R. (2003). Micronutrient deficiency: An underlying cause of morbidity and mortality,
Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 81 (2): 79.
Bouis, H. (2003). Micronutrient fortification of plants through plant breeding; Can it improve
nutrition in Man at low cost? Proceedings of the Nutrition Society, 62: 403 – 411.
Cunningham-Rundles, S., McNeeley, D.F. and Moon, A. (2005) Mechanisms of nutrient
modulation of the immune response, J. Allergy Clin. Immun., (115): 1119-1128.
Díaz J.R., de las Cagigas A., and Rodríguez R. (2003). Micronutrient deficiencies in
developing
and affluent countries, Eur. J. Clin. Nutr. 57 Supp 1: S70-2.
FAOSTAT (2007). http://faostat.fao.org/ Retrieved, May 2012. Frossard, E., Bucher, M.,
Machler, F., Mozafar, A., and Hurrell, R. (2000). Potential for increasing the content and
bioavailability of Fe, Zn and Ca in plants for human nutrition. J. Sci. Food Agric. 80:
861 – 879.
196
197
Høgh-Jensen H., Myaka F.A., Kamalongo D., Rasmussen J., and Ngwira A. (2006). Effect
ofenvironment on multi-element grain composition of pigeon pea cultivars under
farmersconditions, Plant Soil, (285): 81-96
Insel P., R. Don, McMahan K., and Bernstein M. (2010). Nutrition, 4th ed., Jones and Bartlett
Publishers, p 507-520.
Raven P.H., Johnson G.B., Losos, J.B., and Singer S.R. (2005). Biology, 7th ed. McGraw Hill,
N.Y., p 337.
Senanayake A. S., K. K. D. S. Ranaweera, A. Gunaratne, & A. Bamunuarachchi, (2013).
Comparative analysis of nutritional quality of five different cultivars of sweet potatoes
(Ipomea batatas (L) Lam) in Sri Lanka, Food Science & Nutrition, 1(4): 284–291
Tumwegamire S. (2011). Genetic variation, diversity and genotype by environment
interactions of nutritional quality traits in East African sweet potato, Ph.D Thesis,
Department of Agric Production, Makerere University, Kampala Uganda.
Venuto, B. C., J. D. Ward & E. K. Twidwell (2002). Effects of Soil Type and Soil Chemical
Composition on Nutrient Content of Annual Ryegrass for Beef and Dairy Cow
Nutrition,
Journal of Plant Nutrition, 26 (9) : 1789-1799
PGB37
CYTOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF THE PLANT ROOT EXTRACTS OF TELFAIRIA
OCCIDENTALIS HOOKER FIL. ON ROOT TIPS OF CRINUM JAGUS (THOMPS)
DANDY IN NIGERIA
Nwakanma, N.M.C.1* and Okoli, B.E..2
1
Department of Biological Science, School of Science, Yaba College of Technology,
Yaba, Lagos, Nigeria.
2
Department of Plant Science and Biotechnology, Faculty of Science, University of Port
Harcourt, Port Harcourt, Nigeria.
*
Corresponding e-mail: nwakanmanmc@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
The mitotic effects of the plant root extracts of Telfairia occidentalis on the root tips of
Crinum jagus were investigated. The root extract of Telfairia occidentalis was used at
concentrations of 0.125%, 0.25% and 0.50% respectively and was found active as inhibitor of
mitosis. The results obtained showed several chromosomal abnormalities including stickiness
of chromosomes (both at metaphase and anaphase), c-metaphase, lagging chromosomes and
stickly bridges. The trend of the results showed that the higher the concentration of the
extracts for treatment, the more inhibitory the effect of mitosis with more pronounced
chromosomal aberrations. The root extract of Telfairia occidentalis (fluted pumpkin) was
found to promote the formation of aberrant chromosomes also and this information could
help in the elucidation of the mechanism of action in the light of its use as a local lethal
poisoning agent in traditional medical practice. The results are discussed in the light of the
possibility of using Crinum jagus as an alternative to Allium cepa and also the possibility of
using the extracts of Telfairia occidentalis as an alternative for the rather expensive
197
198
colchicine for cytological studies. The economic potentials of the observations made are
discussed.
Keywords: Allium cepa, chromosome, Crinum jagus, mitosis, Telfairia occidentalis.
INTRODUCTION
Telfairia occidentalis Hook. F (Cucurbitaceae). is a perennial plant with large fluted fruits.
The leaves, especially the tender ones, are commonly used in the southern part of Nigeria as
vegetable. The seeds are cooked and eaten as such or used in preparing soup. Telfairia
occidentalis, commonly called fluted pumpkin is a crop of commercial importance grown
across the lowland humid tropics in West Africa with Nigeria, Ghana and Sierra Leone being
the major producers (Nkang et al., 2003). In Nigeria, fluted pumpkin is cultivated mostly in
the southern and eastern parts of the country where it is fast becoming a crop of importance
for its palatable and nutritious leaves. T. occidentalis is a creeping vegetable shrub that
spreads low across the ground with large lobed leaves and long twisting tendrils (Horsfall and
Spiff, 2005). The leaves and shoots of the plant are frequently eaten as a potherb (Okoli and
Mgbeogu, 1983).
In Nigeria, herbal preparations of T. occidentalis have been employed in the treatment of
convulsion, ulcers, malaria, and anaemia (Gbile, 1988). Telfairia species have been found to
be rich in protein (21-37%), ash (14%), fat (13%) and fibre (13%) (Akoroda, 1990). The
essential amino acid contents compared favorably with those of important legumes (Asiegbu,
1987) and the high content of mineral and vitamin nutrients especially iron (Fe), magnesium
(Mg) and calcium (Ca) and vitamins C and B12 is remarkably making the leaves potentially
useful as food supplements (Adesanya, 2007). The roots are known locally as potent human
poison and there are reports of their use as fish and human poison (Hutchison et al., 1958).
The extract from the roots, administered intraperitonally, have been found to be lethal to rats
at a concentration of 10ml/kg body weight (Akubue et al., 1980). Again, these properties of
Telfairia occidentalis root extract necessitated its use in mitotic studies.
The genus Crinum is represented by so many species as pointed out by Sharma (cited in
Nwankiti, 1985). Two of these have been found in Nigeria and are classic ornamentals.
They decorate both the landscape and private gardens when in bloom. Like most members of
the family Amaryllidaceae, they flower by mid-dry season and bloom till the beginning of the
rains in May. The two species are C. ornatum and C. jagus (Nwankiti, 1985). Apart from C.
octabilis (2n = 33), 14 species investigated all had 2n = 22 (Sharma and Bhattacharya, 1956).
Crinum jagus was used for the purpose of this study. Crinum species and Allium cepa belong
to the same family Amaryllidaceae. In this research, the cytological effects of the root
extracts of Telfairia occidentalis on the root tips of Crinum jagus were investigated with a
view to finding some possible use of these extracts as chemicals for the modification of
mitosis in much the same way as colchicine (Levan,1938). Colchicine is a very expensive
drug which is not easily available for research work (Okoli and Russom, 1987).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Bulbs of Crinum jagus were used as test material for this experiment. They were dug up
from the Botanical garden at the University of Port Harcourt where they had been growing or
were cultivated. Different sizes were selected, the smaller bulbs having smaller roots than the
bigger ones which had roots many times that of Allium cepa. The root tips (between 1–2 cm
in length from the root apex) were cut off and sectioned to produce thinner longitudinal
198
199
sections which are amenable to cytological treatments. The roots of Telfaria occidentalis
were dug up when the plants were at anthesis in Gambi-Ama, at the University Park of the
University of Port Harcourt The roots were subjected to very good washing with water as
much as was necessary to remove all the attached soil and dirt. After this they were sliced to
expose a greater surface area and to facilitate drying. The sliced specimens were oven-dried
at a temperature between 40 oC – 60 oC. The dried materials were then crushed in a mortar to
a semi-powdered form. About 200g of the crushed specimen was weighed out into the
thimble of a soxhlet extractor and reflux extraction was carried out in a fume chamber. For
the extraction, two solvents were used successively. Firstly was petroleum ether. This was
mainly for the de-fattening of the specimen. After this, chloroform was used which effected
alkaloid extraction from the specimen. It took 14 – 16 hours for complete exhaustion of the
root with each solvent. The solvent was distilled off and the extract weighed. The fatty
components obtained after the extraction with petroleum ether were discarded while the
extract obtained after the extraction with chloroform was dried and weighed. It gave 0.12g
dry weight of Telfairia occidentalis and from this; various concentrations of the test solution
were made namely 0.8 per cent 0.4 percent, 0.2 per cent and 0.1 percent with water as the
control solution.
The roots of the Crinum jagus were randomly selected from the bulbs and sampled by cutting
them off the bulbs with a sharp razor blade. They were sliced to desirable sizes and placed in
a watch glass with water. They were then treated with the test substances in vials containing
about 2 mls of concentrations for 3 hours. This treatment is best from between 10.00 am and
1.00 pm in the day. This is because mitotic activities have been found to be at their best
within this time of the day. After this, fixing of the roots was done in a freshly prepared 1:3
glacial acetic acid/ 95 percent ethanol (V/V) for at least 24 hours and then stored away in 70
percent alcohol under refrigeration until required. For control purposes, another group of
randomly-selected roots were taken and treated with tap water instead of the test solutions
after they were cut and fixation was carried out as previously described. For each period of
collection, each root tip was later randomly selected for slide preparation. Hydrolysis of the
fixed roots in 8 per cent HCl for about five minutes was carried out. This is to facilitate the
disintegration of the middle lamella to ensure adequate staining. This treatment preceded
their stabilization before squashing was done. About 2mm opaque end of the root tip was
sectioned off with a sharp razor blade and used for slide preparation. For examination of
mitotic chromosomes, root tips were squashed in FLP-Orcein (2g of Orcein dissolved in
100ml of solvent, containing equal parts of formic acid, lactic acid, propionic acid and water),
following the method of Okoli, (1983). The materials were squashed directly by tapping with
the blunt end of a ball point pen, to cause the cells to spread out properly. Slides were viewed
at x400 magnification. The frequencies of mitotically dividing cells were scored by sampling
portions of slides which showed unambiguity in the configurations of mitotic cells. The
mitotic index was defined as the ratio of dividing cells to the total number of cells examined
for each treatment (Balog, 1982). The effect of different concentrations and duration of
treatment of the extract on the frequencies of the four phases of mitosis was determined.
Statistical analysis was carried out to determine the correlation between the concentration of
the test solution and the mitotic indices obtained. Microphotographs of chromosomal
aberrations were taken from temporary slides following the method of Okoli and Russom,
(1987).
RESULTS
199
200
The extract exhibited a strong depressive effect on mitosis of Crinum jagus roots. The
untreated root tips of Telfairia occidentalis showed mitotic index of 10.50 per cent. The
treated root tips showed mitotic indices lower than those of their respective untreated
counterparts. Inhibition of mitosis increased significantly with increase in the concentration
of treatment solution in Telfairia occidentalis root extract as shown by the fact that at
concentrations of 0.125%, 0.25%, and 0.50% mitotic indices of 3.2, 3.0 and 2.5 were
obtained respectively. This shows a very negative correlation between the concentration of
the extract and the mitotic indices produced by the observed action. Table 1 shows the mitotic
effects of the root extracts of Telfairia occidentalis on the root tips of Crinum jagus while
Table 2 shows chromosome aberrations of Crinum jagus root tip cells treated with different
concentrations of Telfairia occidentalis root extracts scored in this experiment. Other
significant observations made for the various concentrations and treatments are presented in
the form of microphotographs (Figures 1).
Table 1: Mitotic effects of the root extract of Telfairia occidentalis on Crinum jagus root tips
CONCENTRATIO
N
0%
MITOTIC
STATES
Prophas Metaphas Anaphas
e
e
e
16
9
9
0.125%
0.25
0.50%
2
2
1
2
2
2
2
1
4
Telophas
e
2
TOTAL
M. I
344
10.5
4
5
1
309
329
319
3.2
3.0
2.5
Table 2: Chromosome aberrations of Crinum jagus root tip cells treated with different
concentrations of Telfairia occidentalis root extracts.
Number Total
CVagrant Bridges/ Anaphase
Concentration of cells dividing Stickines mitosis
Fragme laggards
s
counted cells
s
nts
Control
0.125%
0.25%
0.50%
344
309
329
319
36
10
10
8
0
0
2
3
(a)
(d)
0
1
2
0
(b)
(e)
200
0
1
0
1
0
0
1
3
(c)
0
0
1
2
201
Fig. 1 Cytological effects of aqueous extracts of Telfairia occidentalis on Crinum jagus root
tips.
(a) Regular anaphase in control (x400)
(b) Regular metaphase and telophase in control (x400)
(c) Anaphase bridge in.5% T. occidentalis root extracts (x400)
(d) C- metaphase in 0.5% T. occidentalis extracts (x400)
(e) Lagging chromosome in anaphase caused in 0.5% T. occidentalis extracts (x400).
DISCUSSION
Akubue et al., (1980) reported that the root extract of Telfairia occidentalis exerted a lethal
poisoning action in rats. Moreover, it is widely reported that the roots of Telfairia
occidentalis is used as a human poison in the southern parts of Nigeria. In the light of the
results obtained in the present study, these observations above may be due to nucleotoxic
action of the extracts or the disturbance of the formation of spindle fibres during cell division
which leads to chromosomal aberrations.
Stickiness and clumping of chromosomes were some of the most common effects of these
extracts on the treated root tips. These abnormalities have also been reported for several
extracts and chemicals already investigated (Shehab, 1979, 1980; Badr and Elkington 1982;
Misra, 1982). Stickiness usually leads to the formation of anaphase and telophase bridges
and these end up inhibiting meta- and cytokinesis respectively and thus hampering cell
division.
Stickiness might be due to the ability of the extracts to cause DNA
depolymerization and partial dissolution of nucleoproteins, breakage and exchanges of the
basic folded units of chromatids and the stippling of the protein covering of DNA in
chromosomes (Onyenwe, C.N. University of Port Harcourt, Nigeria, personal
communication).
The consistently high frequency of interphase observed in all the concentration means was
expected since that stage lasts much longer than the other stages of mitosis. Even though
many aberrations were observed at metaphase in high concentration of the extract, the
frequency of prophase was still high enough to indicate that even the treated cells to some
degree, go through prophase of mitosis normally. This observation further suggests that these
extracts are potent spindle fibre inactivators and thus can supplement the use of colchicine or
hydroxyquinoline in pretreating materials for mitotic studies. This is in agreement with the
findings of some earlier workers (CN Onyenwe, University of Port Harcourt, Nigeria,
personal communication; Ilevbare, U.K. University of Port Harcourt, Nigeria, personal
communication).
Crinum jagus, which is in the same family as Allium Cepa (Amaryllidaceae), was used here
and gave very good results which are comparable to those obtained by other researchers who
have used Allium cepa root tips (El-Bayoumi et al., (1979); Kabarity and Malallah, (1980);
Nwakanma et al., (2009). The results obtained here are also similar to those reported by
earlier workers who have used Crinum jagus in other test systems (Nwakanma and Okoli,
2010). This innovation is particularly important against the background of the fact that Allium
cepa is an edible and hence economic plant. Crinum jagus on the other hand is not edible and
grows in the wild.
201
202
CONCLUSION
The results from this work strongly suggest that Crinum jagus can now be used as an
alternative to the hitherto-used edible and economic plants - Allium cepa for cytological
work. Furthermore, owing to the ability of the root extracts of Telfairia occidentalis to
accumulate metaphase and hence inhibit mitosis, it is possible to use these extracts as an
alternative for the rather expensive colchicine for cytological studies. Moreso, when after the
harvest of the Telfairia vines for consumption, the stem and roots are often discarded as
waste.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We wish to thank Dr. Shode - the Head of Department, Department of Chemistry, University
of Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria for allowing us use the Chemistry laboratory for the
soxhlet extraction aspect of the work.
REFERENCES
Adesina, OA (2007). The effect of water stress on the growth and nutritional content of
Telfairia occidentalis (fluted pumpkin). B.Sc. Research project submitted to the
Department of Botany, University of Lagos. 44pp.
Akoroda, MO (1990). Ethnobotany of Telfairia occidentalis (Cucurbitaceae) among Igbos of
Nigeria. Economic Botany 44: 29-39.
Akubue PI, Kar A and Nnachetta FN (1980). Toxicity of Extracts of Roots and Leaves of
Telfaria occidentalis. Planta Medica 383: 39 – 343.
Asiegbu, JE (1987). Some Biochemical Evaluation of Fluted Pumpkin Seed. Journal of
Science and Food Agriculture, 40: 151-155.
Badr A and Elkington TT (1982). Antimitotic and chromotoxic activities of Isoproturon in
Allium cepa and Hordeum vulgare. Environmental and Experimental Botany. 222: 65 –
270.
Balog, C. (1982). The mitotic index in diploid and triploid Allium roots. Cytologia 476: 89 –
697.
El- Bayoumi AS, Kabarity A and Habib.A (1979). Cytological effects of papaverine
hydrochloride on root tips of Allium cepa. L. Cytologia 447: 30 – 733.
Gbile, ZO (1988). Ethnobotany, Taxonomy and Conservation of Medicinal Plants in the start
of medicinal plant research in Nigeria, 191pp.
Horsfall M and Spiff IA (2005). Equilibrium sorption study of All, Co 3+, 2+ and Al+
aqueous solutions by fluted pumpkin (Telfairia occidentalis Hook.F.). Waste Biomass
52:174-181.
Hutchison JJ, Dalziel JM and Keay RWJ (1958). Flora of West Tropical Africa, Vol. 1.
London, SW. 1 Crown Agents for overseas Governments and Administration, Millbank,
211pp.
Kabarity A and Malallah G (1980). Mito-depressive effects of knot extract in the
meristematic region of Allium cepa root tips. Cytologia 45: 733 – 730.
Levan A (1938). The effect of colchicines on root mitosis in Allium Hereditas 24: 71 – 486
Misra MP (1982). Effect of calcium salts on Allium cepa chromosomes. Cytologia 47: 47 –
51.
Nkang A, Omokaro D, Egbe A and Amoke G (2003). Varations in fatty acid proportions
during desiccation of Tellfairia occidentalis seeds harvested at physiological and
agronomic maturity. African Journal of Biotechnology, Vol. II, 2:33-39.
Nwakanma NMC, Odeigah PGC and Oboh BO (2009). Genotoxic Effects of Gongronema
latifolium and Vernonia amygdalina using the Allium test. In: Book of Proceedings, 4th
UNILAG Conference and Fair, 72–81.
202
203
Nwakanma NMC, Okoli BE (2010). Cytological effects of the root extracts of Boerhaavia
diffusa on root tips of Crinum jagus. EurAsia J BioSci 4: 105-111.
Nwankiti OC (1985). Cytotaxonomic survey of some tropical ornamental species V.
Karyotype of two species of the genus Crinum and a related genus Hymenocallis.
Cytologia 50: 797 – 803.
Okoli BE (1983). Hybridization, polyploidy and apomixes in Andropogon tectorum. Schum
and Thonn. (Gramineae). New Phytol. 93: 5:91 – 597.
Okoli, BE and Mgbeogu CM (1983). Fluted pumpkin (Telfairia occidentalis): West Africa
Crop. School of Biological Science, University of Port Harcourt. Economic Botany, 37:
145-147.
Okoli BE and Rusom Z (1987). .Effects of an aqueous extract of Cassia alata L. on mitosis
of onion (Allium cepa) roots. Biologia Africana. 1-2: 31-37.
Sharma AK and Bhattacharya NK (1956). An investigation on the karyotype of the genus
Crinum and its phylogeny. Genetica 28: 263 – 296.
Shehab AS (1979). Cytological effects of medicinal plants in Qatar I. Mitotic effects of
water extracts of Pulicaria crispa on Allium cepa. Cytologia, 44: 607 – 613.
Shehab, A.S. (1980). Cytological effects of medicinal plants in Qatar II. Mitotic effect of
water extract of Teucrium pilosum on Allium cepa. Cytologia, 45: 57-64.
PGB38
GERMPLASM COLLECTION AND EVALUTION OF ROSELLE (HIBISCUS
SABDARIFFA L) GERMPLASM IN NIGERIA
Daudu, O.A.Y1, Falusi, O.A1. Kwon-Ndung, E.H2. Dangana, M.C1. Yusuf, L3. Gado, A.A4.
Yahaya, S.A1 and Abejide, D.R1, D.R1.
1
Department of Biological Science, Federal University of Technology, Minna
Department of Botany, Federal University Lafia
3
Department of Biological Science, Federal University of Technology, Akure
4
Federal College of Education, Kontagora.
2
ABSTRACT
In an attempt to assess the genetic diversity of Roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa L) in Nigeria, a
survey was undertaken to assemble the germplasm of the crop. The survey cut across 56
towns and 20 villages in 17 states including the Federal Capital Territory (FCT). 63 farmers
were interviewed and 60 accessions of Roselle were collected from them. Results showed
that 41.7% of these accessions were having green calyx, while 31.7% were with red calyx.
On the other hand, 20.0% of the accessions possessed deep red calyx while only 6.7% were
having light red and pink calyx. Collections from the North Central, North Eastern, North
Western and South Western parts were observed to be replications over states, towns and
villages. The highest number of Roselle accessions was collected from Kaduna state (8
accessions) followed by Niger state (6 accessions); Jigawa State (6 accessions) while FCT
and Bauchi State recorded four accessions each. These results tend to suggest that these areas
have the greatest diversity of this crop genetic resource in Nigeria. However, morphological
as well as molecular characterizations are required to properly catalogue and characterise the
Roselle accessions collected. The current results form a basis for scientific documentation of
roselle germplasm in Nigeria and also a gene bank for future Roselle improvement
programme in Nigeria.
203
204
Keywords: Genetic Diversity, Germplasm, Roselle Accessions, Improvement Programme
*Corresponding Author’s e-mail address: dauduoladipupoyusuf@yahoo.com
Phone Number: +2348062202142
INTRODUCTION
Roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa Linn.) is a shrub belonging to the Family Malvaceae
(Mahadevan et al., 2009; Anjah et al., 2012). It is thought to have originated from Asia (India
to Malaysia) or Tropical Africa. The plant is widely grown in the Tropics including
Caribbean, Central America, India, Africa, Brazil, Australia, Hawaii, Florida and Philippines,
as a home garden crop (Mahadevan et al., 2009). In Sudan, it is a major crop of export,
especially, in the western part where it ranks after pearl millet, and followed by Sesamum
(Leung and Foster, 1996; Gautam, 2004). The Genus consists of about 300 species some of
which are widely distributed as tropical herbs and shrubs (Heywood, 1978) or as annual erect,
bushy, herbaceous sub-shrub (Amin, 2008). Some of the species include: H. canabinus L., H.
asper (Hook.) F., H. tiliaceus L., H. acetosella Weiw ex Hiern, H. scotelli Bak. F.
The plant is about 3.5m tall and has a deep penetrating taproot system. It has a smooth or
nearly smooth, cylindrical, typically dark-green to red stems (Amin, 2008; Mahadevan, et al.,
2009). The leaves are alternate, 7.5-12.5cm long, green with reddish veins and long or short
petioles. Leaves of young seedlings and upper leaves are deeply 3 to 5 or even 7-lobed and
the margins are toothed. Flowers are borne singly in the leaf axils and are up to 12.5cm wide,
yellow or buff with a rose or maroon eye, that turn pink as they wither at the end of the day.
The typically red calyx, consist of 5 large sepals with a collar (epicalyx) of 8-12 slim, pointed
bracts (or bractioles) around the base. The fruit is a velvety capsule, 2-5cm long, which is
green when immature, 5-valved, with each valve containing 3-4 seeds which usually contain
high percentage of oil (Rice et al., 1993). The capsule turns brown and splits open when
mature and dry. Seeds are kidney-shaped, light-brown, 3-5mm long and covered with minute,
stout and stellate hairs (Julia, 1987).
The importance of this crop cannot be over emphasized; it is used for many different
purposes, the most common of which are its use as a fibre crop and the young leaves which
are eaten as cooked vegetables especially with soup (Fasoyiro et al., 2005). The seeds are
pounded into meal which is used as oily soup or sauce after roasting. Oil extracted from the
seed is a substitute for castor oil while the residue is used in a fermented form as soup or cake
(Aliyu, 2000).
The crop is used fresh for making wine, juice, jam, jelly, syrup, gelatin, pudding, cakes, ice
cream and also dried and brewed into tea as well as flavours and carbonated soft drinks, other
acidic foods, spice and used for butter, pies, sauces, tarts, and other desserts (Walford, 1984;
Qi et al., 2005). The grinded leaves and seeds are added to curries as seasoning. Roselle
contains an acid, rhubarb-like flavour. The red calyces contain anti-oxidants including
flavonoids, gossypetine, hibiscetine and sabdaretine (Qi et al., 2005). The fresh calyces are
also rich in riboflavin, ascorbic acid, niacin, carotene, Calcium, and Iron that are nutritionally
important (Mahadevan et al., 2009), as well as, amino acids and mineral salts (Cisse et al.,
2009).
They are also known for their unique flavour characteristics that make them appealing to
taste. Roselle drink had been improved nutritionally by producing fruit-flavoured Roselle
204
205
drinks, which are richer in vitamins and minerals by addition of different fruits with higher
consumption acceptability (Fasoyiro et al., 2004).
The crop is mainly grown as a vegetable from the savannah and semi-arid areas in Africa,
while its use as a fibre crop is mostly in southern Asia. Formerly, it was traditionally
cultivated in Nigeria for its leaves, seeds and stems; but is now being grown commercially for
its calyces (Babatunde, 2003). Roselle is widely grown in northern parts of Nigeria, where
the dried calyx is used for making a popular drink ‘zobo’ (Falusi, 2007).
Udom et al., (2001), reported that there are three common varieties of Roselle grown in
Nigeria. Two of these varieties have red calyces while one has green calyces. The green
variety is more predominant in the Southern parts of Nigeria while the other two red varieties
are predominant in the Northern parts of this country; however, the green variety is also
common in the Northern part of the country. The calyces from these varieties have a number
of uses and promising prospects for industrial purposes (Alegbejo, 2000). These popular uses
to which Roselle have been put had fuelled increasing demand for the crop thus, necessitating
corresponding increased supply of the products. Though attempts have been made to achieve
this increased supply through increased cultivation of the different varieties; the successes of
such attempts have been limited by challenges ranging from unfavourable environmental
conditions, as well as dwindling man-power and inadequate farming conditions. As the crop
continues to play important horticultural roles in Nigeria, its improvement will surely
enhance agricultural productivity, alleviate poverty and facilitate food security. But
unfortunately, very little research attention has been given to the improvement of the crop.
This background has made it necessary to collect and evaluate the germplasm of the crop, as
a basis for research into its development and promotion as a major crop in Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A survey of Hibiscus sabdariffa (Roselle) growers was conducted in south-western, northcentral, north-western and north-eastern parts of Nigeria, representing the major Roselle
producing areas of the country. The survey was conducted between October 2012 and
January 2013, when the farmers were expected to be harvesting the crops. The states visited
were Niger, Kogi, Nasarawa, Kwara, Ekiti, Ondo, Osun, FCT, Benue, Taraba, Plateau,
Kebbi, Gombe, Bauchi, Kaduna, Katsina, Jigawa, and Sokoto. Questionnaires were
administered through an interpreter in some cases and samples of available Roselle
accessions under husbandry were collected. The questions asked included local name of
accessions, source of seed supply, yield, Roselle seed preferences, constraints to cultivation
and economic importance.
The seeds were collected packed and sealed in thick paper envelopes each of which was
given an accession code, local name, and locality before they were finally stored in dry
containers. Ten seeds at random were selected from each of the accessions for the seed
diameter. The seed diameters were measured using meter rule and the mean value was
recorded as the average diameter.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The survey covered 56 towns and 20 villages in 17 states including the Federal Capital
Territory (FCT), Nigeria. 63 farmers were interviewed and 60 accessions of Roselle were
collected (Table 1). It was observed that most of the accessions were duplicated in most of
the towns and villages. The various calyx colours encountered were green, red, deep red, pink
and light red (Plate 1). Results showed that 41.7% of these accessions were having green
205
206
calyx, while 31.7% were with red calyx. On the other hand, 20.0% of the accessions
possessed deep red calyx while only 6.7% were having light red and pink calyx. Collections
from the North Central, North Eastern, North Western and South Western parts were
replicated over states, towns and villages in Nigeria. The highest number of Roselle
accessions was collected from Kaduna state (8 accessions) followed by Niger and Jigawa
States (6 accession each); FCT and Bauchi State on the other hand have 4 accessions each
(Table1). This is an indication that these states had the greatest diversity of the crop genetic
resource; it also showed that these regions might be the primary or secondary centre of origin
of Roselle. This is in line with the report of Mohamed et al., (2012) that the genus Hibiscus
has its centre of origin in Africa.
About 81.8% of the farmers preferred Roselle variety with dark red or red calyx because
apart from having medicinal value, it is widely used in the preparations of foods and drinks.
This variety is grown in commercial quantities in Jigawa, Kaduna, Bauchi, Niger States and
FCT. According to Stevels (1990), Roselle plants with anthocyanin pigmentation are able to
withstand the harsh environment and more tolerant than the green variety. Hence they are
common in the dry zones of the areas of the production in Nigeria.
The farmers in the south-western part of Nigeria gave more priority to their starchy stable
crops. 100% of them responded that they normally grow the green varieties of Roselle for
vegetable. They also attend to this vegetable only when their main food crop has been
established. The Roselle variety with green calyces is predominant in the south-western part
of Nigeria. In view of the popularity of Roselle as a crop of considerable economic
importance in Nigeria, there is a need to retain the diversity of the indigenous germplasm. A
scientific morphological and molecular characterization of the materials collected is therefore
necessary to ascertain the genetic diversity existing within the species in Nigeria.
A
B
C
D
Plate I: Roselle Accessions with different calyx colour. A: Accession with Green calyx; B:
Accession with Light red or Pink calyx; C: Accession with Deep red calyx; D: Roselle
accession with Red calyx.
Table 1: Sources and Description of Roselle Germplasm in Nigeria
S/N
O
1.
ACCESSION
NUMBER
NGR-OD-001
LOCAL NAME
LOCAL GOVT
STATE
ISHAPA
IKARE
ONDO
206
CALYX
COLOUR
GREEN
*SEED
DIAMETER
3.55mm
207
2.
3.
4.
5.
NGR-OD-002
NGR-OD-003
NGR-EK-004
NGR-EK-005
6.
NGR-EK-006
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
NGR-OS-007
NGR-OS.008
NGR-OS-009
NGR-KW-010
NGR-KW-011
NGR-NG-012
NGR-NG-013
OTATUPE
ISHAPA
ISHAPA OLOHO
ISHAPA
ISHAPA
TOROMOYAN
ISHAPA
TOROMOYAN
SAPA
ISAPA
ISAPA
ISHAPA
ISHAPA
EMAGI
EMAGI
14.
15.
16.
17.
NGR-NG-O14
NGR-NG-015
NGR-NG-016
NGR-NG-017
EMAGI
AMA
AMA
YAKUWA
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
NGR-KD-018
NGR-KD-019
NGR-KD-020
NGR-KD-021
NGR-KD-022
NGR-KD-023
NGR-KD-024
NGR-KD-025
NGR-JG-026
NGR-JG-027
NGR-JG-028
NGR-JG-029
NGR-JG-030
31.
32.
NGR-JG-031
NGR-GB-032
YAKUWA
BARKATATA
YAKUWA
ZOBORODO
ZOBO
ZOBO
TSENG
ZOBO
BAKIN ZOBO
JAN ZOBORODO
JAN ZOBO
FARIN ZOBO
FARIN
ZOBORODO
BAKIN ZOBO
BAKIN ZOBO
33.
NGR-GB-033
34.
35.
36.
NGR-GB-034
NGR-FCT-035
NGR-FCT-036
BARKATA/
GWATEN
JAN ZOBO
EMAGI ZURU
MEGI
37.
NGR-FCT-037
AMA
38.
39.
NGR-FCT-038
NGR-NS-039
ECHI
OGBOMWA
ZOBO
OGBESE/ AKURE
ONDO/IRELE
IJERO
ADO/ IJAN
ONDO
ONDO
EKITI
EKITI
GREEN
GREEN
GREEN
GREEN
3.55mm
3.65mm
3.30mm
3.65mm
OMUO/ ILASHA
EKITI
GREEN
3.55mm
IWO/ IBODE OSI
IKOYI/ IKIRE
ILAORANGUN
ORO
OFFA
BIDA
DABBAN/
LAVUN
MOKWA
BEJI/ BOSSO
PAIKO/PAIKORO
KONTAGORA
OSUN
OSUN
OSUN
KWARA
KWARA
NIGER
NIGER
GREEN
GREEN
GREEN
GREEN
GREEN
DEEP RED
RED
3.35mm
3.35mm
3.50mm
3.10mm
3.35mm
3.60mm
3.35mm
NIGER
NIGER
NIGER
NIGER
3.30mm
3.50mm
3.45mm
3.20mm
KUBAU
SANGA
JEMA'A
ZARIA
CHUKUN
KACHIA
JABA
KAGARKO
KAZAURE
GUMEL
KAUGAMA
KAZAURE
HADEJIA
KADUNA
KADUNA
KADUNA
KADUNA
KADUNA
KADUNA
KADUNA
KADUNA
JIGAWA
JIGAWA
JIGAWA
JIGAWA
JIGAWA
LIGHT RED
GREEN L.V
GREEN
PINKISH
G.L
RED
RED
GREEN
RED
RED
RED
GREEN
RED
DEEP RED
RED
RED
GREEN
GREEN
KAUGAMA
YAMALTUDEBA
DADIN KOWA
JIGAWA
GOMBE
RED
DEEP RED
3.34mm
3.31mm
GOMBE
GREEN
3.28mm
KWANI
YABA
KUCHI GORO
(AMAC)
DAKWA
(BWARI)
ZUBA
EDDO (DOMA)
GOMBE
FCT
FCT
RED
DEEP RED
RED
3.41mm
3.80mm
4.20mm
FCT
GREEN
2.90mm
FCT
NASARA
WA
DEEP RED
RED
3.70mm
4.00mm
207
3.33mm
3.25mm
3.32mm
3.27mm
3.48mm
3.29mm
3.36mm
3.31mm
3.24mm
3.21mm
3.29mm
3.16mm
3.48mm
208
40.
NGR-NS-040
ECHI ZOBO
41.
NGR-NS-041
YAKWAN MIYA
KIYI
(AKWANGA)
KEFFI
RED
3.00mm
GREEN
3.00mm
RED
3.90mm
GREEN
3.10mm
TORO
BAUCHI
NASARA
WA
NASARA
WA
PLATEA
U
PLATEA
U
BAUCHI
BAUCHI
42.
NGR-PL-042
YAKUWA
JOS
43.
NGR-PL-043
YAKUWA
JOS
44.
45.
NGR-BA-044
NGR-BA-045
46.
NGR-BA-046
47.
NGR-BA-047
FARIN ZOBO
YAKUWA/BAKI
N ZOB
YAKUWA/JANZ
OBO
FARIN ZOBO
GREEN
DEEP RED
3.00mm
3.48mm
TORO
BAUCHI
RED
3.34mm
GAMAWA/KATA
GUN
GBOKO
GBOKO
YANDEV
ARDO KOLA
KARIM LAMIDO
ARDO KOLA
BAUCHI
GREEN
3.31mm
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
NGR-BE-048
NGR-BE-049
NGR-BE-050
NGR-TR-051
NGR-TR-052
NGR-TR-053
BENUE
BENUE
BENUE
JALINGO
JALINGO
JALINGO
DEEP RED
RED
GREEN
GREEN
DEEP RED
DEEP RED
3.28mm
4.00mm
4.00mm
3.00mm
3.41mm
3.46mm
KOGI
KOGI
SOKOTO
SOKOTO
KATSINA
KATSINA
KEBBI
LIGHT RED
RED
DEEP RED
RED
DEEP RED
GREEN
DEEP RED
4.00mm
4.00mm
3.29mm
3.16mm
3.48mm
3.34mm
3.31mm
ASHWE
ASHWE
ASHWE
FARIN ZOBO
JAN ZOBO
YAKWA/BAKIN
ZOBO
54.
NGR-KG-054
AGOLO
ANKPA
55.
NGR-KG-055
AGOLO
ANKPA
56.
NGR-SK-056
YAKUWA
SOKOTO
57.
NGR-SK-057
JAN ZOBO
SOKOTO
58.
NGR-KT-058
YAKUWA
KATSINA
59.
NGR-KT-059
YAKUWA
KATSINA
60.
NGR-KB-061
YAKUWA
BIRNIN KEBBI
Note: * Values are means of the seeds measured in millimetre.
Table2: Predominant calyx colours among the accessions collected
Green
No.
of 25
Accession
Calyx
colour 41.7
(%)
Calyx colours
Red
Deep Red
19
12
Others
4
Total
60
31.7
6.7
100.1
20.0
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I hereby acknowledge those who supported this research during the challenging germplasm
collection, most especially: Shehu T., Aransiola T. B., Musa F., Aliyu S., Ichado N., Dangan,
208
209
M.C. and Agricultural Development Project (ADP) in Kwara, Ondo, Ekiti, Gombe and Kebbi
States.
REFERENCES
Alegbejo, M.D. (2000). Processing, utilization and nutritional values of Okra and Roselle.
Noma Magazine. 14: 43-45.
Aliyu, L., (2000). Roselle ( Hibiscus sabdariffa L.). Production as affected by pruning and
sowing date. J. Applied Agric. Technol., 6: 16-20.
Amin, I., Emmy, H.K.F., and Halimatul-Saadiah, M.N. (2008). Roselle (Hibiscus sabdariff
L) Seeds- Nutritional Composition, Protein Quality and Health Benefits. Food.
2(1):1-16.Barnabas, B. and Rajki, E. (1976). Storage of maize (Zea mays L.) pollen
at-196° C in liquid nitrogen. Euphytica. 25: 747-752.
Anjah, G.M., Ogunsanwo, O.Y., Jimoh, S.O., farjoh, J.N., and Tsombow, F.M. (2012)
Assessment of regeneration potential of Hibiscus sabdariffa L, under established
ecosystem in Cameroon. Journal of Horticulture and Forestry. 4(6): 96-102.
Asagba, S.O., Adaikhpoh, M.A., Kadiri, H. and Obi, F.O. (2007). Influence of aqueous
extracts of Hibiscus sabdariffa L petal on cadmium toxicity in rats. Biol Trace Elem
Res., 115(1): 47-58.
Babatunde, F.E. (2003). Intercrop productivity of Roselle in Nigeria. African Crop Science
Journal. 11(1): 43-47.
Cissé, M., Dornier, M., Sakho, M., N’Diaye, A., Reynes, M., and Sock, O. (2009). Le bissap
(Hibiscus sabdariffa L.): composition et principales utilisations. Fruits 64 (3): 179
193.
Falusi, O.A. (2007). Cultivation and Use of Roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa L) in Nigeria. PAT.
3(2): 129-134.
Fasoyiro, S.B., Babalola, S.O., and Owosibo, T. (2004). Chemical composition and sensory
quality of fruit-flavoured Roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa) drinks. Unpublished data, pp:
1-8.
Fasoyiro, S.B, Ashaye, O.A., Adeola, A., Samuel, F.O. (2005). Chemical and storability of
fruits flavored (Hibiscus sabdariffa) drinks. World J. Agric. Sci., 1: 165-168.
Gautum, R.D. (2004). Sorrel-A lesser known source of medicinal soft drink and food in
India. Nat. Prod. Rad., 3(5): 338-342.
Heywood, V.H. (1978). Flowering plants of the world. Oxford University press, Oxford,
London. Pp. 94-95.
Julia, F. (1987). Roselle, In Fruits of warm Climates. Edited by Morton, J. Miami. Pp 281
286 (Also available on http://www.hort.purdue.edu/newcrop/morton/roseele.html).
Leung, A.Y. and Foster, S. (1996). Encyclopedia of Common Natural Ingredients Used in
Food, Drugs and Cosmetics. 2nd Ed., John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Mahadevan, N., Shivali, A., and Pradep, K. (2009). Hibiscus sabdariffa Linn- An Overview.
Natural Product Radiance. 8(1): 77-83.
209
210
Mohamed, B.B., Sulaiman, A.A., and Dahab, A.A. (2012). Roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa L) in
Sudan, Cultivation and their uses. Bulletin of Environmental Pharmacology and Life
Science. 1(6): 48-54
Qi, Y., Chin, K.L., Fatemah, M., Berhane, M., and Gager, J. (2005). Biological
Characteristics, Nutirtional and Medicinal Value of Roselle, Hibiscus sabdariffa.
Circular Urban Forestry Natural Resources and Environment. No. 64: 1-2.
Rice, R.P., Rice, L.W., and Tindall, H.D. (1993). Fruit and Vegetable Production inWarm
Climates, Longmans, Green and Co. Ltd., Hong Kong. Pp.231.
Stevels, J.M.C. (1990). Legumes traditionnels du Cameron, une etude Agrobotanique.
Wageningen, Agricultural University, Wageningen.
Udom, O., Igwe, C.C., and Osinowo, F.A. (2001). Comparism of the Anthocyanin content of
two varieties of Red Roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa) from Nigeria. Nigeria Food
Journal 19: 101-105.
Walford, J.E. (1984): Development in Food Colours Vol.1 Applied Science Publishers,
London.
PGB39
GENOTYPES X TREATMENT X CONCENTRATION INTERACTION
AND CHARACTER ASSOCIATION OF MAIZE (ZEA MAYS L) UNDER
ARBUSCULAR MYCORRHIZAL FUNGI AND STRIGA LUTEA LOUR
Olawuyi, O.J.1*, Odebode, A.C.1 and Olakojo, S.A.2
1
Department of Botany, University of Ibadan. Ibadan, Nigeria.
2
Institute of Agricultural Research and Training, Obafemi Awolowo University (OAU),
P.M.B. 5029, Ibadan, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: olawuyiodunayo@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Screen house and field experiments were carried out between 2007/08 and 2008/09 in striga
endemic zones of Southern Guinea Savanna of Nigeria. The study aimed at estimating
genotype x treatment x concentration x mycorrhiza interaction and to assess the characters
association for four quality protein maize genotypes under striga artificial infestation and
arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi inoculation. A factorial combination was laid out in 4x6x4x4
arrangements with three replications. The striga and yield related traits were evaluated
according to the standard procedure. All the striga traits showed highly significant differences
at the genotypic (D), treatment (C) and CxD interaction level in three locations. The striga
emergence count at 8 and 10 weeks after planting (WAP), plant stand, stalk lodging and root
lodging were highly significant at the concentration (A), mycorrhiza (B) and at AxB
interaction level in screen house and Temidire. Where as, in Farm settlement, striga damage
rating at 10 WAP were non-significant at concentration, mycorrhiza, and AxB interaction
level, while stalk lodging was non-significant at the concentration level. The striga and yield
related traits were highly significant at the genotype, treatment, concentration, mycorrhiza
210
211
and their interaction levels for screen house and Farm settlement, but non-significant for
grain yield at AxBxCxD interaction and stalk rot at concentration level in Temidire.
However, genetic improvement of traits, selection based on characters association and high
yield genotype should be considered in breeding to improve maize production.
Key words: Maize genotypes, mycorrhiza, striga, traits.
INTRODUCTION
Maize is one of the world’s most widely grown cereals with every part including the grains,
leaves, stalks, tassels, roots of great economic value. It constitutes a major ingredient in home
cooking and many industrialized food products in many regions of the world (Edmeades et
al., 1992; Olawuyi et al., 2010). Several varieties of maize were grown by farmers with
different combinations of desirable traits. It is important to consider selection of distinct
maize varieties in breeding so as to satisfy their specific uses (Menkir et al., 2006).
The infestations of Striga parasitic weeds have caused a serious problem in maize production,
causing large crop losses in subtropics and tropics. The incidence and severity of Striga lutea
parasitizing maize are higher in the Southern Guinea Savanna (SGS) of Nigeria (Olakojo and
Olaoye, 2003). The daily lives of 100 millions of people in Africa are negatively affected by
their damaging effects (Olakojo and Kogbe, 2007; Sata et al., 2003). The small seed size,
viability within the soil over a long period of time and prolific reproductive capacity of striga
render elimination of established weeds very difficult (Parker and Riches, 1993).
Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) are bioinoculant and biocontrol agent which play major
role in nutrient cycling, plant growth and increase productivity without harming the
environment (Odebode, 2005; Olawuyi et al., 2012). It significantly reduced the number of S.
hermonthica infesting a tolerant sorghum variety and improved the growth (Weber et al.,
1993). AMF also reduced the cost of inorganic fertilizers which are expensive for farmers to
afford and discourages the application of chemical herbicides, some of which are nonbiodegradable and toxic to soil (Sunita et al., 2011; Olawuyi et al., 2011).
The genetics of agronomic related traits of different crops have been reported (Ajmal et al.,
2009; Adeniji et al., 2011), But the interactions of maize genotypes with treatments, AMF
and concentration under S. lutea infestation has not been studied. Also, there are paucity of
information on molecular approach to establish genomic relationship among the maize
genotypes and AMF. Therefore, this study aimed at investigating the effect of striga-host
plant interaction on some morphological and striga-related traits in maize under infestation of
S. lutea and AMF.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Four maize genotypes (ILEI-OB, ART-98-SW4-OB, ART-98-SW5-OB and ART-98-SW6OB) sourced from the germplasm collection of the Institute of Agricultural Research and
Training (IAR&T) Ibadan, Nigeria was used in this study. AMF species inoculated (Glomus
mosseae, G.clarum, G.deserticola and Gigaspora gigantea) were collected from soil biology
unit of the department of Botany, University of Ibadan, Nigeria. They were multiplied in a
screen house pot culture and identified based on spore size, hyphae, colour, different wall
211
212
types and reaction to Melzer’s solution according to the standard procedure. Viable S. lutea
seed obtained from harvested striga in IAR&T was prepared according to the method
described by Berner et al. (1997).
Screen house trials were conducted in IAR&T, while experimental field locations at Temidire
and Farm settlement, both in Eruwa are striga endemic zones in Southwestern Nigeria. The
treatments were factorially combined in a 4x6x4x4 arrangement with three replications.
Concentration levels represent the main plot, while infestation and genotypes represent subplots. A complete randomized design was used in screen house trials experiment, while
randomized complete block design was adopted in the field experiments.
The AMF multiplied in pot culture consisted of a mixture of soil, spores and root fragments,
and was applied at the rate of 12.5g, 25g and 50g per plant at the depth of 4cm in soil, while
the control were the untreated plants. Viable S. lutea seed obtained from harvested striga in
IAR&T was prepared according to the method described by Berner et al. (1997). 86g of
striga seed was mixed with 478.6g of sieved fine sand in order to enhance uniformity. Each
pot was infested with 10.4g of striga, two weeks before planting to allow pre-conditioning.
Two seeds of maize were planted per 10kg plastic pot (20 cm diameter and 30cm deep) filled
with sterilized soil, and each was thinned to one per pot after two weeks. Maize planted on
the field was done on four-row plots of 3m x 5m. Two maize seeds were planted per hill at a
spacing of 75 x 50cm under artificial infestation of about 44,000 germinable striga seed per
hill. This was done 14days before the planting of maize so as to allow striga, which is
endemic on the plot to condition itself to the new environment. Each entry was planted to a
corresponding uninfested plot as control experiment. The corresponding uninfested plot was
planted directly opposite the infested plot of about 1m in between the two. The infested plots
are those inoculated with striga seeds artificially, while uninfested plots were not inoculated,
but may be naturally infested by striga due to the endemic nature of the soil. All agronomic
practices were duly carried out.
PCR was used to assay the specificity of primers; ARCH1311, ACAU1660, LETC 1670,
GLOM1310, GLOM5.8R and GIGA 5.8R and were tested with the roots of the maize
genotypes colonized by G. mosseae, G. clarum, G. gigantea and G. deserticola. Set 1
comprised the reverse specific primers (GLOM 5.8R, GIGA 5.8R) in combination with
ITS1F, while set 2 contained the forward specific primers (ARCH 1311, ACAU1660,
LETC1670) combined with ITS4. The primers amplify DNA fragments from 5.8S, ITS and
18S ribosomal DNA genes deduced from selected reference sequences were obtained from
public data bases. A fragment of approximately 1200bp of rDNA was amplified with
universal primers NS5 and ITS4. Additional reactions with single primer pairs were
performed to determine which of the primers showed a true positive reaction so as to obtain
sufficient products for subsequent restriction analysis.
Data recorded for striga related parameters, growth, agronomic and yield characters of maize
include;. Striga damage ratings, striga emergence count, plant stand, stalk lodging, root
lodging, plant height, grain yield, field weight Data were analyzed with Statistical Analysis
System SAS(1992) to compute analysis of variance (ANOVA) using General Linear Model,
while means were separated using DMRT test at 5% level of probability.
212
213
RESULTS
The result of Table 1 shows that priming sites tested were found to match the respective
primer sequences of colonized fungi on maize genotypes. G. mosseae gave true positive
reaction + with GLOM1310, weak positive reaction (+) with GLOM 5.8R and too weak
positive (++) reaction with GIGA 5.8R. All the forward specific primers ARCH1311,
ACAU1660, LET1670, (control) produced negative reactions with all the AM Fungi (Table
4). Only G. clarum, for ILE1-0B showed true positive reactions with GLOM 5.8R and
GLOM1310 primers, while G. gigantea colonizing ILE1-0B, ART-98-SW4-0B, ART-98SW5-0B and ART-98-SW6-0B produced true positive reactions with GIGA5.8R primer.
LETC 1670 primer was found to produce true positive reaction with G. deserticola
colonizing ILE1-0B, ART-98-SW4-0B, ART-98-SW5-0B and ART-98-SW6-0B maize
genotypes. G. mosseae and G. clarum colonizing ART-98-SW4-0B, ART-98-SW5-0B and
ART-98-SW6-0B maize genotypes also produced true positive results with GLOM5.8R and
GLOM1310 primers compared to G. deserticola and G. gigantea (Table 1). Similar
observation was reported by Redecker et al. (1997) and Redecker (2000).
There were highly significant differences (P< 0.05) in growth and yield performance of maize
genotypes under striga and mycorrhizal interactions (Table 2). Highest plant height of
(117.85cm and 133.67cm) at 8WAP and 10WAP was produced by ART-98-SW5-0B maize
genotype under the inoculation of G. clarum, while uninoculated (control) was the least for
ILE1-0B genotype (66.95cm and 70.17 cm) at 8WAP and 10WAP respectively (Table 2).
The grain yield and field weight were highest in ART-98-SW5-0B genotype inoculated with
G. clarum (4.25 t/ha and 54.9 t/ha) respectively, while the lowest yield was produced by
uninoculated (control) (1.5l t/ha and 18.56t/ha). There are wide variations among the
genotypes for these agronomic characters. The genotype and treatment effects were highly
significant (P<0.01) for striga emergence count, striga syndrome rating at 8WAP and
10WAP, Plant stand, stalk lodging and root lodging in all the locations. In screen house
(Table 3) and Temidire Eruwa (Table 4) evaluations, first and second order interactions of
concentration x genotypes (AxD), concentration x treatment (AxC), concentration x
mycorrhiza (AXB), mycorrhiza x genotypes (BxD), mycorrhiza x treatment (BxC),
concentration x treatment x genotypes (AxCxD), concentration x mycorrhiza x genotypes
(AxBxD), concentration x mycorrhiza x treatment (AxBxC), mycorrhiza x treatment x
genotypes (BxCxD), concentration x mycorrhiza x treatment x genotype (AxBxCxD)
interactions were highly significant (p<0.05) for striga emergence count at 8WAP and
10WAP, plant stand, stalk lodging and root lodging except striga syndrome rating at 8WAP
and 10WAP at (P< 0.01). The treatment x genotype (CxD) interaction was significant for all
the striga related traits in Tables 3 and 4.
In farm settlement, the first and second interactions of treatment x genotype (CxD) and
mycorrhiza x genotype (BxD) differed significantly from one another with respect to striga
syndrome rating at 8WAP and 10WAP, plant stand, stalk lodging and root lodging, while
concentration x mycorrhiza (AXB) was significant for striga syndrome rating at 8 WAP,
striga emergence count at 8 WAP and 10WAP, plant stand, stalk lodging and root lodging.
Treatment x genotype (CxD) interaction was also significant (P≤0.05) for striga syndrome
rating at 8WAP and 10WAP, plant stand, stalk lodging and root lodging while, the interaction
was not significant for striga emergence count at 8WAP and 10WAP (Table 5). Mycorrhiza x
treatment (BxC) interactions was significant for plant stand, stalk lodging, striga count 8WAP
and root lodging, while interactive effects of concentration x genotype (AxD), concentration
213
214
x treatment (AxC) concentration x treatment x genotype (AxCxD), concentration x
mycorrhiza x genotype (AxBxD), concentration x mycorrhiza x treatment (AxBxC),
mycorrhiza x treatment x genotype (BxCxD) and concentration x mycorrhiza x treatment x
genotype (AxBxCxD) were significantly different for plant stand, stalk lodging and root
lodging (Table 5). The concentration (A) of inocula in Eruwa farm settlement was significant
for striga emergence count at 8WAP and 10WAP, plant stand, root lodging, and striga
syndrome rating at 8WAP, while the influence of mycorrhiza was significantly different
(P<0.05) for all the striga related characters except striga syndrome rating at 10 WAP (Table
5).
DISCUSSION
The positive response of ILE1-0B to G. clarum, showing true positive reactions with GLOM
5.8R and GLOM1310 primers confirms the excellent performance of G. Clarum as similarly
observed by Redecker et al. (1997) and Olawuyi et al. (2010). LETC 1670 primer which was
also found to produce true positive reaction with G. deserticola colonizing ILE1-0B, ART98-SW4-0B, ART-98-SW5-0B and ART-98-SW6-0B maize genotypes confirms its
performance. Reduction in plant height of ILE1-OB and ART-98- SW4-OB could be
associated with striga infestation as similarly reported by Olakojo et al. (2001) and BaduApraku et al. (2008) on other maize varieties. The highly significant level of both treatment
and genotype effects recorded for most of the traits considered contributed to good yield
components in all the three locations as earlier reported by Olakojo et al. (2001) and
Olakojo (2004), while significant differences in genotypic interactions could be an indication
of high genetic diversity in their backgrounds.
However, the positive influence of the mycorrhiza fungi and combination of all factors in the
treatment also contributed to the performance of striga and yield related traits especially in
Temidire which seems to be the most endemic area of striga infestation in the study. The
effects of concentration solely or in combined interactions with other factors were not
significant for striga damaged ratings in screen house and Temidire compared to Eruwa field
experiment.
CONCLUSION
For genetic improvement of traits, selection based on characters association and high yield
genotype should be considered in breeding to improve maize production.
214
215
Table 1: Variability in maize as influenced by AMF and specificity of primers assayed by nested PCR.
Maize genotypes
ILE 1 -0B
(+)(+)
AM fungi
ARCH1311
G. mosseae
ACAU1660
LETC1670
GLOM5.8R
GLOM1310
GIGA 5.8R
-
-
-
(+)
+
G. clarum
-
-
(+)
+
+
G. gigantea
-
(+)
-
(+)
+
G. deserticola
(+)
-
+
(+)
-
G. mosseae
-
-
-
+
+
G. clarum
-
-
(+)
+
+
G. gigantea
-
(+)(+)
-
(+)(+)
(+)
+
(+)
(+)
(+)
(+)(+)
ART-98.SW 4-0B
(+)
(+)
+
G. deserticola
(+)
215
-
216
(+)(+)
ART-98.SW 5-0B
(+)
G. mosseae
-
-
-
+
+
G. clarum
-
-
(+)
+
+
G. gigantea
-
(+)
-
(+)
(+)
G. deserticola
(+)
-
+
(+)
-
G. mosseae
-
-
-
+
+
G. clarum
-
-
(+)
+
+
G. gigantea
-
(+)
-
(+)
(+)
(+)
-
+
(+)
-
(+)
+
(+)
ART-98.SW 6-0B
(+)
(+)
+
G. deserticola
(+)
216
217
Reactions were counted positive when products of the expected size were consistently present. All forward primers were tested in combination
with ITS4, the reverse primers (R) with ITS1F.
(+) weak positive reactions, + positive reactions, (+)(+) two weak positive reactions
217
218
Table 2
Growth and yield performance of maize genotypes as influenced by mycorrhiza species.
Mycorrhiza
species
Maize Genotypes
ILE 1-0B
ART-98-SW4-0B
Plant
(cm)
Glomus
mosseae
Glomus
clarum
Gigaspora
gigantea
Glomus
deserticola
Control
ART-98-SW5-0B
Height Grai Fiel
n
d
Yiel Wei
8WAP
d
ght
10WAP
(t/ha
(t/ha
)
)
Plant
(cm)
Height Grai Fiel
n
d
Yiel Wei
8WAP
d
ght
10WAP
(t/ha (t/ha
)
)
Plant
(cm)
84.82d 92.30d
89.21d 108.61
d
108.46
a
117.23
a
93.72c
113.75
102.87
c
b
114.29
68.47e
b
2.80
b
38.1
2d
3.15
a
40.9
1
2.92
b
39.8
5c
110.35 112.21d
c
133.67a
117.85
125.43c
a
128.46b
113.28
b
83.54e
3.05
a
40.1
1b
75.02e
1.55
e
20.3
5e
101.26 111.12
a
a
88.36c
96.30s
95.48b 103.62
b
66.95e
70.17e
2.13
d
35.7
5d
3.00
a
39.9
7a
2.84
c
37.3
5c
2.91
b
37.8
4b
1.51
e
18.5
6e
218
Fiel
d
Wei
ght
Plant
(cm)
3.30
d
43.4
5d
102.32
d
117.93 3.10
d
c
40.1
8d
4.25
a
54.9
1a
112.52
a
122.44 3.43
a
a
44.6
3a
3.52
c
44.8
8c
106.75
c
106.75 3.23
c
b
41.8
4c
114.72
b
3.85
b
45.8
8b
110.94
b
110.94 3.36
b
b
42.5
0b
75.17d
2.00
e
25.8
7e
71.88e
71.88e
22.9
5e
8WAP
10WAP
Height Grai
n
Yiel
d
ART-98-SW6-0B
Height Grai Fiel
n
d
Yiel Wei
8WAP
d
ght
10WAP
(t/ha (t/ha
(t/ha (t/ha
)
)
)
)
1.88
d
219
Each value is the mean for 3 replicates. Means with the same letter in the same column are not significantly different at P< 0.05 using Duncan’s
Multiple Range Test
(DMRT).
WAP-Weeks after planting
219
220
Table 3: Interactions of Genotype x Treatment x concentration on striga related characters in maize genotypes as influenced by
mycorrhiza fungi under striga infestation in screen house experiment
Source of variation
Root
df
Striga
Striga
damage rating
Striga
Striga
Plant
Stalk
damage rating
emergence count
emergence count
10WAP
8WAP
10WAP
stand
lodging
16.65
20.34
lodging
8WAP
Replicate
2
1.98
2.54
Concentration (A)
11.04**
2
0.01ns
0.02 ns
Mycorrhiza (B)
34.35**
3
34.47**
12.35
10.69
71.41**
0.02ns
0.03 ns
53.95**
22.48**
Treatment ( C )
24.52**
5
27.34**
21.47**
27.29**
Genotype ( D )
49.95**
3
61.03**
5.93**
7.62**
25.00
17.46**
70.31**
37.06**
1.63**
21.74**
66.02**
32.07**
42.79**
74.99**
AXD
6
0.05ns
0.07 ns
2.74**
1.03**
1.44**
1.47**
A XC
10
0.01ns
0.01 ns
3.25**
4.76**
3.23**
2.05**
220
4.52**
0.89**
3.21**
221
AXB
6
0.01ns
0.01 ns
47.48**
38.20**
CXD
15
0.81**
1.28**
7.37**
6.40**
4.31**
2.16**
3.43**
BXD
9
0.06ns
0.06ns
1.28**
1.39**
2.71**
5.57**
2.45**
BXC
15
0.01ns
0.01 ns
2.45**
1.64** 3.75**
1.76**
AXCXD
0.57**
30
0.01ns
0.01 ns
0.52**
0.35** 0.50**
0.58**
AX BXD
18
0.05 ns
0.07 ns
AXBXC
30
0.01 ns
0.01 ns
BXCXD
45
0.01 ns
0.02 ns
1.83**
1.29**
2.22**
1.56**
A X B X C XD
0.46**
0.01 ns
86
Error
566
Total
849
*, **
0.19
1.23**
0.45**
0.02 ns
0.25
0.83**s
0.50**
1.20**
0.78**
0.27**
0.08
significant at P≤ 0.05 and P≤ 0.01 respectively
221
0.83**
0.34**
0.03
0.00
0.92**
0.69**
0.61**
0.89**
1.70**
0.79**
0.79**
0.73**
0.58**
0.75**
0.00
0.00
222
non – significant at P≤ 0.05 and P≤ 0.01 respectively
ns
WAP
Weeks after planting
Table 4: Interactions of Genotype x Treatment x concentration on striga related characters of maize genotypes as influenced by
mycorrhiza fungi under striga infestation in Temidire Eruwa
Source of variation
Root
df
Striga
Striga
Striga
Striga
Plant
damage rating
damage rating
emergence count
emergence count
8WAP
10WAP
8WAP
10WAP
Stalk
stand
lodging
lodging
Replicate
2
2.05
2.61
Concentration (A)
2
0.01ns
0.03 ns
10.46
1.39**
Mycorrhiza (B)
11.32**
3
7.04**
0.01ns
0.03 ns
Treatment ( C )
25.94**
5
30.44**
21.96**
27.96**
9.32
11.81
14.96
10.45
1.29**
2.82**
1.39**
0.14**
22.34**
60.56**
222
17.49**
13.92**
65.44**
25.79**
223
Genotype ( D )
31.34**
3
6.15**
7.84**
31.37**
27.96**
35.42**
42.48**
AXD
6
0.06ns
0.08 ns
0.41**
1.33**
0.41**
1.23**
0.09**
A XC
10
0.01ns
0.01 ns
0.45**
0.78**
1.87**
0.74**
0.87**
AXB
6
0.01ns
0.02 ns
0.55**
0.28**
1.28**
0.90**
0.62**
CXD
15
0.84**
1.29**
7.67**
6.29**
5.34**
4.27**
6.22**
BXD
9
0.06ns
0.08ns
2.20**
2.11**
1.54**
2.81**
1.71**
BXC
15
0.01ns
0.01 ns
5.04**
5.19**
3.48**
1.17**
1.98**
AXCXD
30
0.01ns
0.02 ns
0.28**
AX BXD
18
0.06 ns
0.08 ns
AXBXC
30
0.01 ns
0.01 ns
BXCXD
45
0.01 ns
0.02 ns
A X B X C XD
0.74**
0.01 ns
90
Error
576
Total
863
0.19
0.32**
0.25**
0.32**
0.79**
0.02 ns
0.25
0.40** 0.76**
0.42**
0.85**
0.24**
0.00
0.88**
1.17**
0.73**
0.34**
0.00
223
0.51**
0.65**
0.00
0.48**
0.78**
0.98**
0.73**
0.68**
1.16**
0.56**
0.60**
0.00
0.00
224
*, **
significant at P≤ 0.05 and P≤ 0.01 respectively
ns
non – significant at P≤ 0.05 and P≤ 0.01 respectively
WAP
Weeks after planting
Table 5: Interactions of Genotype x Treatment x concentration on striga related characters in maize genotypes as influenced
by mycorrhiza fungi under striga infestation in farm settlement Eruwa.
Source of variation
Root
df
Striga
Striga
Striga
Striga
Plant
damage rating
damage rating
emergence count
emergence count
8WAP
10WAP
8WAP
10WAP
Stalk
stand
lodging
lodging
Replicate
2
1.728
1.893
Concentration (A)
2
1.038*
0.177 ns
1.087
0.870
4.37**
224
5.320
3.52**
5.821
0.66**
2.677
0.09ns
0.39*
225
Mycorrhiza (B)
5.51**
3
3.124**
Treatment ( C )
5
24.553**
Genotype ( D )
17.46**
3
8.03**
5.185**
0.238 ns
9.67**
8.30**
6.55**
6.52**
25.459**
2.78**
5.68**
1.78**
5.48**
3.99**
3.55**
3.24**
2.61**
15.96**
AXD
6
0.05ns
0.02 ns
0.07ns
0.10ns
0.35*
0.60**
0.18*
A XC
10
0.14ns
0.12 ns
0.07 ns
0.07ns
0.43*
0.38**
0.99**
AXB
6
0.96*
0.20 ns
CXD
15
0.85**
0.97**
0.27 ns
0.34 ns
0.86**
0.90**
1.23**
BXD
9
0.73*
0.87*
0.26 ns
0.42 ns
0.93**
0.68**
0.77**
BXC
15
0.35ns
0.12 ns
0.60*
0.38 ns
1.10**
0.99**
0.86**
AXCXD
30
0.02ns
0.02 ns
0.07 ns
0.10 ns
0.36**
0.12*
0.30**
AX BXD
18
0.05 ns
0.02 ns
0.24 ns
0.31 ns
0.21*
0.30**
0.34**
AXBXC
30
0.13 ns
0.14 ns
BXCXD
45
0.12 ns
0.22 ns
A X B X C XD
0.02 ns
86
Error
566
Total
849
0.21
9.16**
0.21 ns
0.08 ns
0.01 ns
0.25
9.56**
0.15 ns
0.15 ns
0.10 ns
0.28
225
1.61**
0.55**
0.43**
0.12 ns
0.24
0.92**
0.51**
0.54**
0.26**
0.08
0.35*
0.33**
0.32**
0.24**
0.08
0.20**
0.07
226
*, **
significant at P≤ 0.05 and P≤ 0.01 respectively
ns
non – significant at P≤ 0.05 and P≤ 0.01 respectively
WAP
Weeks after planting
226
1
REFERENCES
Adeniji, O.T., Odo, P.E. and Ibrahim, B. (2011). Genetic relationships and selection indices for
cassava root yield in Adamawa State, Nigeria. African Journal of Agricultural Research
6(13): 2931-2934.
Ajmal, S.U., Zakir, N. and Mujahid, M.Y (2009). Estimation of genetic parameter and character
association in wheat. J. Agric. Biol. Sci: 1(1):15-18
Badu-Apraku, B.A Fontem-Lum, A., Fakorede, M.A.B; Menkir, A., Chabi, C.,
Abdulhai, M, Jacob, S., and Agbaje, S. (2008) Performance of early maize
cultivars derived from recurrent selection for grain yield and Striga resistance.
Crop Sci 48:99-112.
Berner D. K, Wilson, M. D, Awad, A. E. Cardwell, D. Mohan Raj and Kim S. K. (1997). Striga
Research Methods Manual, 2nded. June 1997, 1-15.
Duncan E.B (1955) Multiple Range and Multiple F – test. Biometrics 11:1-42.
Edmeades, G.O., Bolanos, J and Lafitte, H.R (1992). Progress in selecting for drought tolerance
in maize. In D. Wilkinson (ed), Proc. 47th Annual Corn and Sorghum Research
Conference, Chicago December 9-10, 1992. ASTA, Washington. Pp 93-111.
Menkir, A., Olowolafe, M.O., Ingelbrecht, I., Fawole, I., Badu-Apraku, B and Vroh, B.I. (2006).
Assessment of testcross performance and genetic diversity of yellow endosperm maize
lines derived from adapted and exotic backcrosses. Theor. Appl. Genet.113:90-99
Salami, A. O., Odebode, A. C and Osonubi, O. (2005). The use of Arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM)
as a Source of yield increase in sustainable alley cropping system. Archives of agronomy
and Soil science. 51(4): 385-390.
Olakojo S. A. (2004). Evaluations of maize inbreed lines for tolerance to Striga lutea in Southern
Guinea Savannah Ecology. Food, Agriculture and Environment 2(2):256-259.
Olakojo, S.A., and Olaoye, G., (2003). Effect of Striga lutea (Lour) infestation on tolerant maize
hybrids (Zea mays L.) in Southern Guinea Savanna. Ghana Journal of Agric Science
36:23-29.
Olakojo S A and Kogbe J O S (2007) Response of maize to different Nitrogen fertilizer
formulation under Striga lutea artificial infestation. Tropical and Subtropical Agro
Ecosystems 7:21-28.
Olakojo S A, Kogbe J O S, Olajide V Donhell (2001). Host parasite relationship of Striga
asiatica and maize (Zea mays L.) under varied moisture level sand Nitrogen. Nigeria
Journal of Weed Science 14:451-460.
1
2
Olawuyi, O.J., Odebode, A.C., Alfar-Abdullahi, A., Olakojo, S.A and Adesoye, A.I (2010).
Performance of maize genotypes and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi in Samara district of
South West region of Doha-Qatar. Nigeria Journal of Mycology 3(1): 86-100
Olawuyi, O.J., Odebode, A.C., Olakojo, S.A and Adesoye, A.I (2011). Host-parasite relationship
of maize (Zea mays L.) and Striga lutea (Lour) as influenced by arbuscular mycorrhizal
fungi. Journal of Science Research 10(2):186-198
Olawuyi, O.J., Ezekiel-Adewoyin, D.T., Odebode, A.C., Aina, D.A., and
Esebanenm, G (2012). Effect of arbuscular mycorrhizal (Glomus clarum)
and organomineral fertilizer on growth and yield of Okra (Abelmoschus
esculentus). African Journal of Plant Science 6(2):84-88
Parker C and Riches C.R (1993) Parasitic weed on the world. Biology and control CAB
International, Wallingford Partan cheru A.P. India International Crop Research Institute
For the Semi Arid Tropics Pp 20-25.
Redecker D, Their Felder H, Walker C, Werner D (1997) Restriction analysis of PCR –
amplified internal transcribed spacer of ribosomal DNA as a tool for species
identification in different general order glomales Appl. Environ Microbiol 63:1756-1761.
SAS Institute 1992. SAS Technical Report, SAS STAT software Changes and Enhancement
Release pp 289-359.
Sata D, Awadd A; Chae S H, Yokota T Sugimato (2003) Analysis of strigolactones, germination
stimulants for striga & orobanche be high performance liquid chromatography by
masspectrometry. J Agric Food Chem. 51:1162-1168
Sunita, K., Kumar, A., and Aggarwal, A.(2011). Influence of hosts and substrates on mass
multiplication of Glomus mosseae. African Journal of Agricultural Research 6(13):
2971-2977.
Weber, G., Elemo, K., Awad, A., Lagoke, S.T.O and Oikeh, S., (1993). Striga infestation in
farmers’ fields. In: Striga hermonthica in cropping Systems of the Northern Guinea
Savanna.Pp17-30
2
3
PGB41
VARIABILITY PATTERN OF MORPHOLOGICAL TRAITS AMONG SOLANUM
MACROCARPON L ACCESSIONS.
Adeniji, O.T.1*, Reuben, S.W.O.M. and Kusolwa, P.
Department of Crop Science and Production, Sokoine University of Agriculture, P.M.B. 3005,
Morogoro, Tanzania.
*
Corresponding e-mail: waleniji@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Morphological variation was investigated among 13 accessions of Solanum macrocarpon L.
sourced from Africa and Asia, to quantify variation, identify traits of high discriminatory ability
and donor parents for single or multiple traits and best performer for enhancement and
commercialization. Field experiments took place during 2009 thorough 2010. Two methods of
multivariate analyses (Principal Component Analysis and Cluster analysis) were used to analyze
the data set. The first principal component axis showed maximum variability and depicts high
variation for receptacle pigmentation (purple). Ordination on the biplot and grouping on the
phylogenetic tree correspond to moderate variability and phenotypic plasticity in this specie, and
geographic heterogeneity. Receptacle pigmentation (purple) contributed to cluster constellation.
There was no association between accessions and geographical origin. Pigmentation (purple) and
fruit colour distribution (stripped) could be used by potential (plant breeders and seed
companies) as morphological markers in breeding works. High heritability and heterosis should
be expected in hybridization in favour receptacle pigmentation and fruit colour distribution
(stripped) traits.
Keywords: Solanum macrocarpon, Receptacle pigmentation, Ordination, Diversity, Cluster
analysis,
INTRODUCTION
The common name eggplant includes three closely related cultivated species that belong to
subgenus Leptostemonum: Solanum melongena L., brinjal eggplant or aubergine, Solanum
aethiopicum L., scarlet eggplant; and Solanum macrocarpon L., gboma eggplant (Daunay et al.,
2001a). The latter two species result by domestication process that occurred in Africa, starting
from two wild ancestors, Solanum anguivi and Solanum dasyphyllum, (Lester, 1998; Lester and
Niakan, 1986). S. macrocarpon (2n = 24) (Gboma eggplant) is classified in the section
Melongena; series Macrocarpa Bitter, it is cultivated widely throughout tropical Africa,
especially in humid regions. The glabrous leaves are important green vegetables, and fruits are
consumed fresh. Many cultivars are robust, perennial with deeply lobed leaves; other cultivars
from West Africa are smaller and much branched with smaller and often simple leaves and
young shoots (Shippers, 2000). Fruits ranged from 3 to 12 cm in diameter, spherical or
depressed, usually green, whitish or purple or with lighter markings when ready for eating, but at
physiological ripeness they turn yellow or orange or brown, and the surface may crack (Duanay
et al., 2001a, b).
In diversity studies some morphological characters are more useful than others. Heywood (1967)
had noted that for a morphological trait to be of taxonomic importance they should meet at least
3
4
four criteria: (1) they should vary less within the supposed group than between groups; (2) they
should be genetically controlled; (3) their exposure should not be significantly modified by
environment; and (4) characters examined should exhibit a pattern that correlates with the pattern
of variation of other characteristics. Genetic architecture of a population is generally believed to
be the result of breeding system, gene flow within and between population, and prolonged
selection by various natural and artificial forces. Assessment of genetic diversity in germplasm
collections provides information useful for both germplasm management and breeding. It helps
to identify new genetic recombination, select inbred parents for maximum heterotic response and
identify materials that should be maintained to preserve maximum genetic diversity (Thormann
and Osborn, 1992). These allow for establishment of core, nonredundant germplasm collections
and help to guide future germplasm collection efforts.
S. macrocarpon is indigenous to Africa and has no known incompatibility with the norms and
belief of communities where it is grown. It is consumed fresh with spices or boiled in stews. The
importance of this crop makes it imperative to understand how much morphological variation
exist within this specie and how variation could assist in conservation strategies and use in crop
breeding through identification of promising accessions for enhancement and variety
development. Multivariate analyses (Principal component analysis and cluster dendogram) have
been used widely to measure diversity in the germplasm collections, and to assess the relative
contribution of characters to total variability in germplasm collection (Baatout, 1995). A
significant feature of this model is that it enables researchers to use specific attributes in gene
pool for crop improvement. In this study we evaluated the extent of genetic variability among
accessions of S. macrocarpon based on morphological traits and identify best performing
accessions as donor parents for single and multiple traits
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Entries evaluated comprised of 13 accessions of S. macrocarpon from locations in Africa and
Asia, maintained in the gene banks of AVRDC (The World Vegetable Center), Taiwan and
French Institute for Agricultural Research, (INRA) Monifavet, France. The genetic stocks are
homogenous for most genetic attributes. Field experiments took place at the research field of
Horticultural Training Research Institute (HORTI) Arusha (Lat. 4.8°S long 3.7°E; Alt. 1290 m)
with annual rainfall of 700 to 1000 mm. Soil type was clay loam with a pH of between 6.0 and
6.5. Experimental plots were laid out in a randomized complete block design with three
replications. Each plot consisted of a double row plot of 7 m long and 0.75 m between rows.
Seedlings were raised in multipot seedling trays for four weeks, thereafter transplanted to the
sides of the ridges at 0.45 m between plants. Plants were fertilized with NPK (20-10-10) at the
rate of 90 kg N/ha, 45 kg P2O5/ha and 45 kg K2O/ha. Urea fertilizer was applied at the rate of
120 kg N/ha in three splits, that is, one week after transplanting, at flowering and three weeks
thereafter. Ridomil WP (fungicide) was sprayed against damping off in the field at the rate of 20
g/15 L of water 12 days after transplanting. Selecron EC (insecticide) was applied 2 weeks after
transplanting at the rate of 20 ml/20 L of water to control insects. The experiment was furrowirrigated every two days for the first two weeks after transplanting, then once a week thereafter.
Weeding was carried out manually and frequently with hoes to maintain weed-free plots. Every
parts of the plant were sampled at all stages of growth, presumably because different parts of the
genome affect different suites of traits at different times. Two-state qualitative traits, for
example, presence or absence of pubescence/ prickles was coded as binary. Ordered multistate
4
5
qualitative traits were coded as series of discrete states. Morphological scoring was done
according to the AVRDC and biodiversity descriptors with modifications. Traits were scored at
flowering, during this time maximum development of vegetative parts ought to have taken place
(Purseglove, 1972; Karamura and Karamura, 1995). Morphological traits were measured on
fifteen plants (five plants per replicate). Traits related to colour (pigmentation gene) was scored
using the standard Royal Horticultural Society colour chart. Data was submitted for two methods
of multivariate analyses (Principal component analysis (PCA) and cluster analysis), using
PROC-PCA procedure of SAS (1998). Dendogram was constructed, based on distance matrix,
using the average linkage between group methods often aptly called unweighted pair group
method of analysis (UPGMA), with squared euclidean phenotypic distance option ward’s (Sokal
and Michener, 1958) as grouping criteria, using SPSS version 16. 0.
RESULTS
The pattern of variation among accessions of S. macrocarpon returned 6 out of 17 principal axes
to have recorded eigenvalues greater than 1.0. The first to third principal component axes had
eigenvalue greater than 2.0 and altogether accounted for 68% of variation (Table 1). The first
principal component axis had high eigenvalue (5.08) and accounted for 30% of total variation, it
depicts primarily variation associated with receptacle pigmentation, which marked moderate and
positive loading charged on leaf and petiole pubescence, the latter contributed negatively to
variability on PC1. Other traits, flower (Plate 1), sepal and peduncle pigmentation recorded equal
weights.. The second principal component axis illustrated that pigmentation on the leaf vein and
leaf midrib recorded negative coefficients, though positive on PC1. While stem pigmentation and
fruit apex shape showed moderate and positive weights on PC2. Interestingly, half of the total
variability observed among the population was explained by PC 1 and 2 The third principal
component axis accounted for additional 15% of variation unexplained by PC1 and 2, and
showed high contribution of petiole pigmentation, seed colour and fruit colour at commercial
ripeness to variability on this axis. They recorded moderate and positive weights, though
negatively related to fruit colour distribution. The fourth principal axis explained additional 8%
of the total variation, and showed discriminatory power of fruit colour at commercial ripeness
and fruit colour at physiological maturity.
The biplot of PC1 by 2 (Figure 1) showed the ordination of 13 accessions of S. macrocarpon into
four quadrants, the first quadrant accommodated four accessions (accessions 55, 53, 54 and 47)
sourced from Ghana, Zimbabwe, Mauritania and Burkina Faso. With exception of accession 55
which contributed moderately to dispersion in the first quadrant, other entries showed very low
contribution. Ordination in this quadrant is sequel to discriminatory ability of receptacle
pigmentation. Four accessions (accessions 50, 45, 51 56) were ordered into the second quadrant,
and are fairly equal distant from one another, the spread of accessions in this quadrant showed
discriminatory power of leaf lobbing and leaf mid rib pigmentation. Two accessions (accessions
46 and 56) from unknown location and Cameroun are located in the third quadrant, ordination in
this quadrant is associated with discriminatory power of petiole pigmentation and fruit colour at
physiological maturity (Plate 2). In the fourth quadrant accession 57 was widely separated from
the others, traits of discriminatory power in the fourth quadrant are fruit apex shape; fruit colour
at commercial ripeness and stem pigmentation.
5
6
Morphological traits were important in the assignment of entries into three distinct clusters at
20% distance (Figure 2). The phylogenetic tree showed that first and second clusters had 5 and 4
members each, while cluster 3 comprised 4 accessions. Cluster 1 was divided into two sub
clusters (‘a’ and ‘b’), sub cluster ‘a’ comprised accessions 53 and 54, accessions 50 and 51 to
sub cluster ‘b’, they are tightly grouped and linked to accessions 52. Members of cluster 1 are
related for purple pigmentation on the petiole, sepals, peduncle, flower colour and fruits colour
(purple) at commercial ripeness. On the other hand, accessions 50 and 51 are characterized by
strong leaf lobbing, pigmented (purple) leaf vein and petiole. In addition to that, fruits are
characteristically cream with uniform distribution at commercial harvest. The second cluster
comprised 4 accessions; accessions 47 and 48 are most related for lobed leaves and nonpigmented petiole, pigmented sepals (purple), pigmented fruits (purple) at commercial ripeness
and circular fruits. In general members of second cluster are similar for cream fruits at
commercial ripeness and are fairy grooved fruits. The third cluster comprised accession 56 and
57; they are similar for pigmented petiole (purple) and non-pigmented sepals, receptacle,
peduncle and circular fruits. The spread of accessions in the biplot is consistent with groupings
on the phylogenetic tree for accessions 45 and 55, 51 and 52, 47 and 48, and 56 and 57.
DISCUSSION
Within S. macrocarpon receptacle pigmentation showed high discriminatory ability, this
observation mirrored conclusion reached by Lester and Niaken (1998) and Prohens et al. (2005).
This trait could be of importance to curators to focus on greater part of their collection for this
trait. In addition, plant breeders and seed companies may use this trait as morphological marker
during selection purposes. Ordination on the biplot and grouping on the phylogenetic tree
correspond to low and moderate variability and phenotypic plasticity in this specie. Low
variability among S. macrocarpon lends weight to findings reported by Bukenya and Hall (1987)
and Polignano et al. (2009) based on agronomic and fruit quality traits. A low variability among
S. macrocarpon may be associated with genotypic difference and environmental factors. In
another study Bukenya and Caraso (1994) noted that accessions of S.macrocarpon are less
morphologically diverse compared to S. aethiopicum and S. melongena. Grouping on the
phylogenetic tree displayed geographic heterogeneity, entries from same or close geographical
locations are dispersed among others. The lack of clustering according to geographic provenance
implied that accessions from different locations in Africa and Asia are not significantly different.
A similar trend was recorded among Uganda, Indonesia and European Solanum scabrum (Olet,
2004). Variability and similarity among S. macrocarpon beyond geographical limit is similar to
previous reports of Polignano et al. (2009). For selection purposes emphasis should be at the
population level rather than geographical location. Phenotypic plasticity was evident among
accessions in this specie; this is consistent with overlapping morphological traits. In this
investigation twelve accessions were sourced from Africa and one accession (accession 45) from
Malaysia, though the latter grouped with accession 55 from Ghana. There is a possibility that
seeds of accession 45 might have been transported from West Africa during the transhumance
trade in the 19th century or during exchange of germplasm between Africa and Asia. However,
molecular marker technique (AFLP and SSR) may be required to substantiate this finding..
Reference to the grouping on the phylogenetic tree, accessions 53 and 54 showed relatedness for
brown seed colour, cream fruit colour at commercial harvest, pigmented (purple) stem and
receptacles and violet petals. These accessions could be selected as donor parents for single or
multiple traits in any breeding program, and as morphological marker for intellectual property
6
7
right. On the other hand strong leaf lobbing, violet petals and grey seed colour were best in
accessions 50, 51 and 52. Accessions 47 and 48 showed cream seed colour, this in contrast to
accessions 53 and 54. Accessions 45 and 55 are related for brown seed colour and nonpigmented stem and receptacle; they could be selected as a donor parent for these traits. Still in
cluster 3, accessions 46 and 49 had green fruit epidermis at commercial ripeness; they turned
orange in colour at physiological maturity. Fruit pigmentation (orange) is a noticeable trait
(among S. macrocarpon) that showed differences within Solanum species (Collonnier et al.,
2001; Kashyap et al., 2003; Nothmann, 1986; Daunay et al., 2001b; Frary et al., 2007). The
colour differences in the fruit epidermis is basically due to two color pigments’ and their effects
on appearance are controlled by more than one gene (Nothmann, 1986; Frary et al., 2007).
Pigmentation (purple) on the receptacle contributed to cluster constellation. In addition to
receptacle pigmentation (purple), fruit colour distribution (stripped) are located in different
clusters, high heritability and heterosis should be expected in subsequent generations provided
intraspecific hybridization was conducted targeting these traits. This study demonstrated
discriminatory power of receptacle pigmentation (purple) and ability to delimiting accessions in
the specie for morphological characterization and conservation.
Plate 1.
Flower pigmentation pattern in S. macrocarpon
7
8
Plate 2: Variation for fruit colour at commercial harvest (green, cream, purple) and
physiological maturity (orange or brown) and fruit cross section among S. macrocarpon.
REFERENCES:
Bukenya H (1987). Six cultivars of Solanum macrocarpon (Solanaceae) in Ghana. Euphytica
17(1): 91-95
Bukenya ZR, Carasco JF (1994). Biosystematic study of Solanum macrocarpon – S.
dasyphyllum complex in Uganda and relations with Solanum linnaeanum. East African
Agric. For. J. 59(3): 187-204.
Collonnier C, Fock I., Kashyap V., Rotino GL., Daunay MC, Lian Y Mariska IK, Rajam
MV, Servaes A, Ducreux G, and Sihachakr D, (2001) Applications of Biotechnology in
eggplant., Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture.65: 91-107.
Daunay MC, Lester RN, Gebhardt CH, Hennart JW, Jahn M, Frary A. and Doganlar S (2001).
Genetic Resources of Eggplant (Solanum melongena L.) and Allied Species: A New
Challenge for Molecular Geneticists and Eggplant Breeders (Solanaceae V edited by Van
Den Berg, R.G., Barendse, GW. and Mariani, Nijmegen University Press, Nijmegen, The
Netherlands), pp. 251–274 .
Daunay MC, Lester RN, Ano G (2001). Cultivated eggplants In: Tropical plant breeding.
Charrirer, A, Jacquot, M, Hamon, S. and Nicholas, D. (eds.), Oxford University Press,
Oxford: pp. 200-225.
Frary, A., Doganlar, S. and Daunay, MC., (2007). “Eggplant”, Genome Mapping and Molecular
Breeding in Plants. 5:.231-257.
Heywood, V. H. (1967). Plant taxonomy, 2nd Edition. Edward Arnold London 213pp.
Karamura DA, Kanamuna EB (1994). A provisional checklist for Bananas in Uganda. INIBAP
Montepellier, France.
Kashyap V, Kumar SV, Collonnier C, Fusari F, Haicour R, Rotino GL, Sihachakr D, Rajam MV,
(2003) “Biotechnology of eggplant”. Scientia Horticulture.97:1 - 25.
Lester RN (1998). Genetic Resources of Capsicum and Eggplants (X. EUCARPIA Meeting on
Genetics and Breeding of Capsicum and Eggplant), pp.25-30.
Nothmann, J., (1986). Eggplant (CRC Handbook of Fruit Set and Development edited by
8
9
Monselise, S.P.), pp. 145-152.
Polignano GB, Bisignano V, Della Gatta C, Uggenti P, Alba V, Perrino P (2006) Variabilita` di
caratteri morfo-agronomici in specie diverse di melanzana. Italus Hortus 13(2):516–521.
SAS (1997). SAS Users Guide: Statistics. Version 5 ed. SAS Inst. SAS institute, Gary, NC, pp
35.
Sneath PH, Sokal RR (1973). Numerical taxonomy. W.H. Freeman & Co. San Francisco. 573 pp.
Shippers RR (2000) African indigenous vegetables: an overview of cultivated species. Natural
resource institute, Chatham, UK. Pp 214.
Lester RN, Niakan L (1986). Origin and domestication of the Scarlet Eggplant Solanum
aethiopicum L. from S. anguivi Lam. In: D’Arcy WG (ed) Solanaceae: biology and
systematics. Columbia University Press, New York, pp 433–45
Table 1: Eigen values, variation and vectors for the first six principal components axes for 17
morphological traits among 13 accessions of Solanum macrocarpon in Tanzania
Traits
Stem pigmentation
Leaf pubescence
Leaf lobbing
Leaf vein pigmentation
Leaf mid rib pigmentation
Petiole pigmentation
Petiole pubescence
Flower pigmentation
Sepal pigmentation
Receptacle pigmentation
Peduncle pigmentation
Fruit apex shape
Fruit colour at commercial
ripeness
Fruit colour at physiological
maturity
Fruit cross section
Fruit colour distribution
Seed colour
Eigen value
Proportion
Cumulative (%)
Prin 1 Prin 2 Prin 3 Prin 4
0.17
0.39
0.02
0.02
0.07
0.08
0.11
-0.34
0.20 -0.14
0.25 -0.36
0.12 -0.46
0.13
0.07
0.13 -0.43
0.02 -0.04
-0.11 -0.13
0.54 -0.10
0.07
0.08
0.11
-0.34
0.31
0.04
0.14
0.19
0.20 -0.01
0.12
0.34
0.13
0.11
0.23
0.36
0.03
0.25
0.03
0.34
-0.10
0.09 -0.10
0.34
-0.18
0.10
0.43
0.39
Prin 5 Prin 6
-0.04
0.41
0.51
0.03
0.44
0.12
0.05
0.18
-0.06
0.42
-0.08 -0.24
0.51 -0.03
0.17 -0.28
0.14
0.43
0.21
0.22
0.27 -0.33
-0.06
0.12
-0.20
0.09
-0.13
-0.31
-0.08
0.51
-0.009
0.13
0.30
0.17
0.15
5.09
0.30
0.30
0.26
0.02
0.20
3.77
0.22
0.52
-0.20
-0.33
0.44
2.62
0.15
0.68
-0.11
0.48
0.17
1.63
0.10
0.77
0.04
0.22
-0.12
1.29
0.07
0.85
-0.08
-0.27
0.07
1.04
0.06
0.91
9
10
Figure 1: Plot of the first two principal components axes showing spatial distribution of 13
accessions belonging to Solanum macrocarpon based on morphological descriptors
Distances
0
5
10
15
20
25
Acc no Origin
+---------+---------+---------+---------+---------+
Acc 53 Zimbabwe
─┬───────────────────────────────┐cluster 1
Acc 54 Mauritania ─┘a
├─────────┐
Acc 50 Ivory Coast ─┬───────────┐b
│
│
Acc 51 Madagascar
─┘
├───────────────────┘
├─────┐
Acc 52 Chad
─────────────┘
│ │
Acc 47 Burkina Faso───────┬───────────────────┐cluster
2 │ │
Acc 48 Zaire
───────┘a
├───────────────┘ │
Acc 45 Malaysia ─────────────────┬─────────┘
│
Acc 55 Ghana
─────────────────┘b
│
Acc 56 Cameroun ─────────────┬─┐
│
Acc 57 Burkina Faso─────────────┘ ├─────┐cluster 3
│
Acc 46 Unknown
───────────────┘ ├───────────────────────────┘
Acc 49 Togo
─────────────────────┘
10
11
Figure 2: Phenogram produced for the 13 accessions from Solanum macrocarpon derived from
UPGMA clustering of correlation coefficients for 17 morphological descriptors by squared
Euclidean distance and Ward’s method
PGB42
CHARACTERIZATION OF FOUR NIGERIA SESAME (SESAMUM INDICUM L.)
LANDRACES USING AGRONOMIC AND MORPHOMETRIC TRAITS
Ogah O.G.1 and Ogah D. M.2* and S.E. Abimiku3
1Department of Plant Science and Biotechnology, Nasarawa State University Keffi.
2
Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture Nasarawa State University Keffi
3
National Agricultural Seed Council, Abuja
*Corresponding author’s email address: mosesdogah@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
A field experiment was carried out to characterize four sesame landraces EX, Ex Sudan, Boroko
local and NCRIBEN 01M in humid guinea savanna of north central Nigeria, between August
and October 2012 to ascertain the diversity of the landraces using multivariate analysis. Plant
height at flowering (PHF), Plant height at maturity (PHM), Height at first branch (H1B), Height
at first pod (H1P) and Plant length (PL) showed significant (P<0.001) correlation with each
other. The principal component analysis show that the first three principal component explained
about 87.24% of the total variation with Height at first branch 99% , height at first pod 99%,
plant height at flowering 98%, plant height at maturity 98%, number of day to maturity 95%,
leave length 94% and pod length 93% as characters that contribute significantly to variations
found in the sesame variaties, indicating a high variation among the sesame landraces.These
collections represent a rich diversity in form and can aid selection and improvement.
Keywords: Sasame, morphology, agronomic traits, principal component, variation.
INTRODUCTION
Sesame is known to be the most ancient oil seed crop dating back to 3050-3500 BC (Bedigian
and Harlan, 1986: Furat and Uzun, 2010). It is grown in tropical and subtropical areas of the
world. It can set seed and yield well under fairly high temperature, it can grow in stored soil
moisture without rainfall and irrigation. But continuous flooding or severe drought adversely
affect sesame plants and resulted in low yield (Mensah et al., 2009). Another major cause of
poor yield of sesame is due to low yielding cultivars. Development of improved plant cultivars is
restricted by mainly limited genetic variability. Due to narrow genetic pool it is not possible to
restructure the sesame crop. It has been suggested that sesame cultivation under such degradable
condition has caused serious genetic erosion for yield, where selections within the local varieties
fails to respond favorably to high input managements.
Sesame is an important crop to Nigeria agriculture, it is quite extensively cultivated, it yields in
relatively poor climatic condition, and it is widely used within Nigeria and is an important
component of Nigeria’s agricultural exports (Abubakar et al., 1998). It is however, given little
attention and there are relative few companies involved in the trade. As a smallholder crop, often
intercropped with others, the extent of cultivation is poorly known and there is little information
11
12
on yields or productivity. For the most part the surplus crop is commercialized bulked up and
exported with minimal processing limited to dry and cleaning (Azeez and Morakinjo, 2011).
The organic market for sesame is rapidly expanding. Therefore, there is the need to exploit the
potential of the forest savannah transition zone for the production of improved sesame variety
(Balusamy et al., 1996). Since its introduction to Nigeria after the Second World War, it has
been regarded as a crop of significant important compared to groundnut and other cash crop for
export. (Adeyemo and Ojo, 1993).
In Nigeria, sesame is widely grown in the northern and the central part of the country as a minor
crop. Since 1974, it has developed from being a crop of negligible importance to the one of the
major cash earner in it area of production (viz; Nasarawa, Borno,Gombe, Benue, Kogi, Kano,
Jigawa, Plateau, Yobe, Katsina state as well as the FCT Abuja (Abubakar et al., 1998).
The objective of the study was to assess the phenotypic variability and traits associated with the
diversity of the sesame landraces
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The four landraces were collected from National Cereal Research Institute (NCRI) Baddegi
Niger State. Some of these landraces are grown by local farmers in Nigeria. The experiment was
laid out in a Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with three replications during 2012
cropping season (July to December). The cultivated area is situated at 8 ̊ 32 ̍ N, 8 ̊ 18 ̍ E. It has a
tropical climate with moderate rainfall (annual mean rainfall of 1100 – 1300), the temperature
ranges from 20ᴼ to 34ᴼ. Data were collected on the plot basis; Number of days to flowering
(NDF): number of days from planting to 50% flowering. Number Of days to maturity (NDM):
number of days from sowing to the day when at least 50% plants had one brown pod. Plant
height at flowering (cm) (PHF): height from ground level to the peak of the stem when the plant
is at 50% flowering. Plant height at maturity (cm) (PHM): height from ground level to the peak
of the stem. Number of pods/plant (NPP): 5 plants were picked at random per plot, number of
pods counted and the average calculated. Number of branches/plant (NBPP): determined by
counting number of branches on the stem. Height to 1st branch (H1B): height from ground level
to the 1st branch on the stem. Height of 1 st pods (H1P): height from ground level to the 1st pods
on the stem. Weight of pods/plant (g) (W0P): 5 plants were picked at random per replicate, their
pods were removed, weighed and the average was calculated. Leaf length (cm) (LL): the length
of five leaves from the top of the plant was measured in centimetres at peak flowering stage.
1000 seed weight (g) (1000SW): 1000 seeds per replicate was counted and weighed. Seedling
length (SL): Five normal seedlings were selected at random from germination. The length
between the collar region and the tip of primary shoot was measured as shoot length and the
length between the collar region and the tip of primary root was measured as root length seedling
length = shoot length + root length. Pod length (PL): The length of five pods from top of the
Plant were measured at maturity.
First, the univariate normality was checked for 13 traits of each landrace using rank it plots. Inter
correlations among traits evaluated by correlation analysis. The resulting 13 x 13 correlation was
used as input for the PCA to remove the effects of scale (Johnson and Wichern, 1998).
SPSS.2004 statistical package was used for the analysis of correlation and PC.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Correlation analysis showed that many pairs of characters were correlated in these population
(Table 1.), plant height at flowering was positively correlated with plant height at maturity (r =
0.97**), height to 1st branch (r = 0.98**), height to 1st pod (r = 0.98**), weight of pod (r =
12
13
0.74**), pod length (r = 0.89**) and ngatively corelated with number of days to flowering( r = 0.71), number of days to maturity (r = -0.94), number of pods per plant (r = -0.63) and number
of branches per plant (r = -0.92). Most morphometric traits were positively correlated.This is
similar to what Ercan et al. (2002) reported in India sesame germplasm. Some negative
ccorrelation coefficients of seed yield (1000SW) and yield components observed in this study is
contrary to reports of (Khan et al., 2001; Uzun and Cagirgan, 2001 and Sumathi et al., 2007).
Suggesting the variability in the germplasm used.
Table 1.Correlation coefficient between morphological and agronomic traits of the sesame
genotypes
PHF
PHM H1B
H1P
NDF
NDM
NPP
NBPP
1000SW
WOP
LL SL
PHM
.97
H1B
.98
.98
H1P
.98
.98
NDF
-.71 -.74 -.72
.98
-.73
NDM
-.94
-.95
-.95
-.95
.73
NPP
-.63
-.63
-.57
-.63
.44
.73
NBPP
-.93
-.92
-.92
-.93
.62
.88
1000SW
-.13
-.12
-.05
-.07
-.03
.08
.40
WOP
.74
.76
.72
.71
-.59
-.73
-.50
LL
.14
.22
-.29
-.18
-.89
SL
-.66
.59
.50
.53
.56
-.42
-.49
PL
.09
.89
.88
.90
.90
-.72
-.80
.20
.23
.69
-.09
.32
.31
-.12
-.16
-.65
.25
-.48
-.89
.37
.38
.25
-.12
.62
.06
PHF=Plant height at flowering,PHM=Plant height at maturity, H1B=Height at first
branch,H1P=Height at first pod, NDF=Number of days to flower, NDM=Number of days to
maturity, NPP=Number of pod per plant, NBPP=Number of branch per plant, 1000SW=1000
seed weght, WOP=Weight of pod, LL=Leave length , SL=Seedling length , PL=Pod length
13
14
Table 2. Principal Component Analysis of sesame landrace using morphological traits .
PC1
PC2
Eigene value
Cumulative proportion of variation
Total variation
PC3
8.492
65.319
65.319
Characters
PHF
PHM
H1B
H1P
NDF
NDM
NPP
NBPP
1000SW
WOP
LL
SL
PL
1.599
12.298
77.617
1.251
9.623
87.241
Eigenvectors
.982
.983
.986
.986
-.768
-.949
-.682
-.939
-.102
.747
.153
.572
.932
-.021
-.034
.053
.034
-.060
.003
.478
.021
.904
-.125
.170
.648
.026
.011
.073
.078
.046
-.202
-.076
.199
.022
.213
.376
.937
-.413
-.109
PHF=Plant height at flowering,PHM=Plant height at maturity, H1B=Height at first
branch,H1P=Height at first pod, NDF=Number of days to flower, NDM=Number of days to
maturity, NPP=Number of pod per plant, NBPP=Number of branch per plant, 1000SW=1000
seed weight, WOP=Weight of pod, LL=Leave length , SL=Seedling length , PL=Pod length
Multivariate analysis of the sesame landraces (Table2.) reveals that the first three principal
components had eigen values greater than one and cummulatively accounted for 87.24% of the
variation.The first PC accounted for 65.32% total variation. The second PC account for 12.3%
and the third accounted for 9.62 % of the total variation.The cummulative variation of the three
PC accounted for 87.24%. The high degree of variation in the first three PC axes is an indication
of high degree of variation in these landraces. This is similar to the findings of (Furat and Uzun,
2010).
14
15
There are no guidelines to determine the significance or importance of a coefficient, that is,
Eigen-vector (Düzyaman, 2005). However higher coefficients for a certain trait indicate the
relatedness of that trait to respective PC axes (Sneath and Sokal, 1973). The variation in PC1 was
mainly associated with most of the traits except seed length, leave length and 1000 seed weight,
in PC2 seed length and 1000 seed weight were mainly associated while PC3 was associated with
leave length . The Principal component analysis shows that plant height at flowering and
maturity, height at first branch and at first pod, number of days to maturity, number of branch per
plant and 1000 seed weight were among the most important descriptors which accounted for
the highest phenotypic variation expressed in this germplasm collection. These descriptors were
therefore found to be most useful for studying the variability of populations. It is suggested that
the use of these characters will save considerable amount of time for identification of sesame
germplasm.
CONCLUSION
This study provides a morpho-agronomic based classification of genetic diversity that can help
breeders understand the genetic structure of Nigerian sesame landraces. The germplasm
represents a valuable source of genetic diversity that is expected to be highly useful for future
breeding programs. The success in genetic improvement of the crop, however, depends on the
availability of genetic resources and their diversity.
REFERENCES
Abubakar, S. S, J.E. Onlybe and E.B Tologbone.(1998). The role of extensionResearch and
information
dissemmnation in enhancing beniseed Production and marketing of
resource poor farmers in pre-conf.Proceeding. Busari, L. D, et al(eds) 1st National
workshop on Beniseed, march 3-5, 1998 NCRI baddegi Nigeria 217pp
Adeyemo, M.O. and A.A. Ojo.(1993). Evaluation of germplasm of sesame (sesamum indicum
L.) At Markurdi Nigeria. Trop. Oil seed journal 2:1-8
Azeez,M.A.and Morakinyo. J.A. (2011). Genetic diversity of fatty acids in sesame
and Its
relative in Nigeria. European Journal of Lipid science and Technology 113(2). 238-24
Balusamy,M,V.K. Ravichandran and B.R.Balasubramania(1996). Effect of zinc
Bedigian D. and Harlan J.R. (1986). Evidence for cultivation of sesame in the ancient world.
Econ Bot 40:137-154.
Bedigian, D. (1981). Origin, diversity, exporation and collection of sesame.In sesame status and
improvement. FAD plant production and Protection paper 29, pages 164-169
Düzyaman E. (2005). Phenotypic diversity within a collection of distinct okra (Abelmoschus
esculentus) cultivars derived from Turkish landraces. Genet. Resour. Crop Evol. 52:1019
1030.
Ercan A G., Taskin K M, Turgut K., Bilgen M and Firat M Z. (2002). Characterization of
Turkish sesame(sesamum indicum) landraces using agronomic and morphologic
descriptors. Akdeniz universitesi ziraat fakutesi Dergisi 15(2) 45-52
Furat S. and Uzun B. (2010). The use of agro-morphological characters for the assessment of
genetic diversity in sesame.Plant Omic Journal 3(3)85-91
15
16
Johnson. R.A. and Wichern. D.W.,(1998). Applied mutivariate statistical analysis 2nd.ed.
prentice-Hall, Englewood cliffs. NJ.
Khan, N.I., M. Akbar, K.M. Sabir and S. Iqbal. 2001. Characters association and path coefficient
analysis in sesame (Sesamum indicum L.). J. Biol. Sci., 1: 99-100.
Mensah J.K., Obadoni, B.O., Eruotor, P.G. and Onome-Irieguna, F. (2009). Simulated flooding
and drought effects on germination, growth, and yield parameters of sesame (Sesamum
Indicum.). African Journal of Biotechnology, 5, 1249-1253
Sneath P.H.A. and Sokal R.R. (1973). Numerical taxonomy. W.H. Freeman and Company, San
Francisco
Souza E. and Sorrels, M.A.(1991). Relationship Among 70 North American oat germplasm:
I.Cluster Analysis using quantitative characters. Crop sci. 31: 599-605 311-355
SPSS (2004) .Statistical package for Social Science 2004 13.0
Sumathi, P., V. Muralidharan and N. Manivannan. (2007). Trait association and path coefficient
analysis for yield and yield attributing traits in sesame (Sesamum indicum L). Madras
Agric.J., 94: 174-178.
Uzun, B. and M.I. Cagirgan. (2001). Path-coefficient analysis for seed yield and related
characters in a population of determinate and indeterminate types of sesame (Sesamum
indicum L.). Turk. J. Field Crops, 6: 76-80.
PGB43
EFFECTS OF SEED SIZE ON WEEVILS (CALLOSOBRUCHUS MACULATES F.) DAMAGE
DURING STORAGE OF COWPEA (VIGNA UNGUICULATA L.WALP)
Ogbaji, M. I.1 and Alye, J.N.2
1
Department of Crop Production, University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Benue State University, Makurdi, Nigeria
*Corresponding e-mail: ogbamosphd@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
The effects of seed size on Callosobruchus maculatus damage during storage of Cowpea(Vigna
unguiculata L.walp) was investigated. The five cowpea varieties used were Aloka, Ife brown,
Iron beans, Big white and Big brown. These cowpea varieties varied in size from small, medium
and big size. The experimental design used was a factorial laid out in Completely Randomized
Design (CRD) with three replicates. Results obtained showed that there was significant
difference (P<0.05) in the cowpea. Among the cowpea varieties, Aloka was the least susceptible
to C. maculatus attack with weight loss of 4.87%, the next was Ife brown with 5.79% then big
brown with 9.88%, followed by Iron Beans with 10.81% and lastly Big White with 11.65%. The
response of these cowpea to C. maculatus attack also showed that seed size significantly
contributed to varietal resistance as cowpea varieties with small seed sizes (Aloka and Ife brown)
were found to be more resistant to C.maculatus attack than the medium seed size (Big white and
Iron Beans) and Big seed size (Big Brown). The result of this research has indicated that small
seeded varieties of cowpea are more resistant to C. maculatus attack during storage and therefore
can be stored by cowpea farmers over a longer period of time.
Keywords: Damage, Effect, Size, Storage, Weevils.
16
17
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) is a pulse crop that can be grown successfully in extreme
environments such as high temperatures, low rainfall and poor soils with a few inputs.
Subsistence farmers in the semi-arid and sub-humid regions of Africa are the major producers
and consumers of cowpea. Cowpea grain is important to the incomes of resource poor farmers as
well as to the nutritional status and diets of people in West and East Africa, Latin America and
the Carribean basin (Shazia et al., 2006). (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp) has been cultivated in
many countries for many centuries. It is one of the important food legume crops in the tropical
and subtropical regions covering Asia, Africa, Southern Europe, Central and South America
(Motshwari et al., 2011). Cowpea is a crop of high valve which contributes significantly to
farmers’ income and dietary protein of Africans (Ogbaji and Usman, 2011). There are different
varieties of cowpea all of which are essential component of cropping systems in drier regions
and marginal areas of the tropics and sub-tropics. It is a drought tolerant and warm weather crop
well adapted to the drier regions where other food legumes do not perform well. It fixes
atmospheric nitrogen through its root nodules and grows well in poor soils with more than 85%
sand low organic matter and levels of phosphorous (Motshwari et al., 2011). Cowpea is a major
vegetable source of protein for human consumption especially in Africa. Its seeds contain about
25% protein, making it extremely valuable in areas where many people cannot afford protein
foods such as meat and fish. Cowpea is a unique dietary protein source for poor people, since
this protein is one of the cheapest (Sankie et al., 2012). In West Africa, cowpea is consumed in
many forms, young leaves, green pods and green seeds as vegetables whereas the dry seeds are
used in a variety of food preparations. The green and dry haulms are fed to livestock particularly
in dry seasons when animal feed is scarce.
Despite its above outlined great importance in tropical regions, cowpea yield potential and seed
quality is often reduced by insect pest damage. One of the major destructive post harvest pests of
cowpea worldwide is the cowpea weevil (Callosobruchus maculatus). The cowpea seed beetle,
C. maculatus is a cosmopolitan pest of stored grain legumes especially cowpeas (Vigna
unguicalata L. Walp) in the tropics and subtropics. Severely damaged seeds are disfigured with
egg covers and riddled with adult exit holes, and consequently have reduced weight and poor
germiability (Ofuya, 2010).
According to FAO study, World-wide cowpea loss in store approximates 10% of all stored grain,
i.e. 13 million tonnes of grain lost due to insects or 100milion tones to failure to store properly.
To these effects, there is every need to study the effects of seed size on weevil damage during
storage.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment to determine the effect of seed size on Callosobruchus maculatus in the storage
of cowpea was conducted in the Zoology Laboratory of Benue State University Makurdi, Nigeria
between August and December, 2012.
The five cowpea varieties used were; Aloka, IAR48 (big brown), IT362 (big white), iron Beans
and IT84E-124 (Ife brown). These were all obtained from Benue Agricultural and Rural
Development Authority, Makurdi (BNARDA). These varieties had earlier been confirmed to
grow and yield very well in the Makurdi environment (Ogbaji and Ndam, 2012).
17
The cowpea varieties were sun dried one week to allow the larvae in the seeds mature and
escape. Undersized and perforated seeds were handpicked and discarded. Transparent plastic
containers were also bought and used for the study. The plastic containers were perforated using
needle to allow adequate aeration and to prevent intrusion of any other living organisms. The
plastic containers were then weighed using a digital sensitive weighing balance. 500g of each of
the cowpea varieties were weighted and stored in the containers.
The experimental design used was a factorial laid out in a Completely Randomized Design
(CRD) with 3 replicates.
The data collected was the progressive weight loss of the cowpea varieties at two weekly
intervals. The weight loss was measured using a sensitive weighing balance.
The percentage weight loss was calculated as follows:
Initial weight of cowpea and container
=a
Final weight = b
Weight loss = a-b
Percentage weight loss = weight loss / initial weight x 100/1 = a-b/a x100/1
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Results on the 100 seed weight (g) of the cowpea varieties used for the investigation showed
significant differences (P<0.05) in their sizes (Table 1). This is most probably due to the inherent
genetic differences among them as the varieties were developed from different pedigrees. Many
researchers such as Jackai and Asante (2003), Ogbaji and Osuman (2012), Jason and Charles
(2003) had earlier studied and reported on the genetic variability among different cowpea lines.
Results of the study also indicated significant differences and variation in the levels of
resistance/tolerance among the different lines to C. maculatus. Small/medium sized lines were
more resistant to the insects when compared with the big sized lines in their actual weight losses
during storage (Table 2) indicating inverse relationship between big seed size and resistance to
C. maculatus damage. The same results were also obtained in the overall percentage seed weight
losses at the final duration of the cowpea seed storage (Table 3). Small sized seeds like Aloka
had the least overall percentage weight reduction of 4.8%, followed by medium seed sized
variety of Ife brown (5.79%) while the highest percentage weight loss was obtained from the big
white (11.65%) which had earlier been classified as big seeded (Table 1). The results obtained
here is most probably due to the fact that the small/medium sized varieties were more compact
together during storage and hence blocked most of the air spaces among them. The lack of air
spaces suffocated the adult C. maculatus insects to death and thereby presented the reproduction
and multiplication of the insects. The results obtained here are in complete agreement with
studies by Ogbaji and Tyoga (2010), Jason and Charles (2003); Shazia et al, (2012) Temesgen
and Waktole (2008); among other studies. For example, Jason and Fox (2003) reported that the
female C. maculatus insects were less ready to lay eggs on small seeded variaties of cowpea
while Temesgen and Waktole (2008); among other studies. For example, Jason and Fox (2003)
reported that the female C. maculatus insects were less ready to lay eggs on small seeded
varieties of cowpea while Temesgen and Waktole (2008) reported that small seeded varieties
were hard and too compact for C. maculatus insects and also contained less moisture and were
therefore more resistant to the weevils attack as the insects preferred to starve to death instead of
feeding on them. Similarly, Jason and Charles (2003) in their research showed that surface area
seed size of cowpea was important oviposition stimuli for C. maculatus with the insects
demonstrating greater preference for large seed size i.e. the big seed sized varieties.
Based on the results of this study, it is therefore concluded that small seeded cowpea varieties
resist C. maculatus attack during storage more than the large seeded ones. Cowpea farmers may
therefore make use of this vital information during their cowpea storage practices.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We sincerely appreciate the cooperation and assistance of the Vice-Chancellor, Professor Charity
Ashimem Angya, University Management and all staff of the Department of Biological Sciences,
Benue State University, Makurdi, Nigeria.
Table 1: 100 Seed weight (g) of the Different Cowpea Varieties.
Varieties
Aloka
Big white
Big brown
Ife brown
Weight
14.66
26.81
33.43
16.56
Seed Size Classification
Small
Medium
Big
Small
Iron Bean
FLSD (0.05)
27.70
3.15
Medium
Table 2: Main Effects of Cowpea Varieties on Actual Weight Loss (grams) of Cowpea Seed
during Storage.
Varieties
Aloka
Iron Beans
Ife Brown
Big Brown
Big White
FLSD (0.05)
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
499.53
497.03
498.19
499.66
499.55
2.18
491.40
477.20
486.60
487.90
478.60
9.68
483.90
470.40
483.60
473.20
473.50
9.69
478.10
457.20
476.50
462.80
456.50
10.13
475.70
415.90
445.00
460.60
441.80
11.18
496.02
485.99
493.56
498.32
495.71
3.497
Fig. 1: Effects of Variety on Percentage Weight Loss of Cowpea to Callosobruchus maculatus
During Storage.
Table 3: Main Effects of Varieties on percentage Weight Loss (%) of Cowpea Seed during
storage.
Varieties
Aloka
Iron Beans
Ife Brown
Big Brown
Big White
FLSD (0.05)
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
0.10
0.60
0.36
0.07
0.09
0.03
1.72
4.56
2.68
2.43
4.27
1.94
3.22
5.91
3.27
5.35
5.30
1.96
4.37
8.55
4.70
7.43
8.69
2.01
4.87
10.81
5.79
9.88
11.65
2.17
0.80
2.80
1.39
0.34
0.86
0.69
REFERENCES
Jason, M. Cope and Charles, W. Fox (2003). Oviposition decisions in the seed beetle,
Callosobruchus maculatus (Coleoptera: Bruchidae). Effects of seed size on super
parasitism. Journal of Stored Products Research, (39): 355-365.
Motshwari obopile, Keamogetse Masiapeto and Chiyapo Gwafila (2011). Variation in
reproductive and developmental parameters of Callosobruchus maculatus (F.) reared on ten
Botswana cowpea landraces. African Journal of Biotech., 10 (63): 13924-13928.
Ofuya, T.I, Olutuah, O.F and Akinyoade, D.O, (2010). The effect of storage on the efficacy of
Eugenia Aromatic (Baill) in
the control of Callosobruchus maculatus (Fabricius)
(Coleoptera: Bruchidae) pest. J.of Appl. Sci. Enviro. Mgt., 14(1): 97-100.
Ogbaji, M. I. and Ndam, O. (2002). `
Response of some Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L.
Walp.) varieties to insect pests in makurdi, a location`in the southern Guinea Savanna.
Nigerian Journal of Sustainable Agric. Research, 3: 28-32.
Ogbaji, M. I. and K. M. Tyoga (2010). Efficiency of Ginger, scale leaves of onions and dried
peels of oranges in the storage of cowpea against cowpea weevil (C. maculatus). Journal of
Tropical Agriculture, Food, Environment and Extension, Agro Science, 9(4): 31-37.
Ogbaji, M. I. and Usman, D. (2011). Insecticidal actions of some botanicals on storage bruchid
Callosobruchus maculatus (F.) of stored cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp).
Shazia Lephale, Abraham Addo-Bediako and Victoria Ayodele (2012). Susceptibility of seven
cowpea cultivars (Vigna unguiculata) to cowpea beetle Callosobruchus maculatus. Agric.
Sc. Research Journal, 2 (2): 65-69.
Temesgen Keba and Sori Waktole (2008). Differential Resistance of grain varieties. Research
Artc.
PGB44
EFFECT OF SEED COLOUR ON WEEVIL DAMAGE (CALLOSOBRUCHUS
MACULATUS) ON COWPEA (VIGNA UNGUICULATA L.WALP)
Ogbaji, M. I.1* and Kukwa Q. T.2
1
Department of Crop Production, University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria
Department of Biological Sciences, Benue State University, Makurdi, Nigeria
*Corresponding e-mail: ogbamosphd@yahoo.com
2
ABSTRACT
A field experiment was carried out to investigate the effect of cowpea seed colour on weevil
damage (Callosobruchus maculatus) during storage. The cowpea varieties used for the study
were Aloka, IAR48, Big white (IT3629), Ife brown (IT845E-124) and iron beans. Selection
of the cowpea varieties was based on their contrasting colours. The experimental design used
was a factorial laid out in a Completely Randomized Design (CRD) with three replications.
Storage was at room temperature. Results obtained showed significant differences (P<0.05)
in the weight losses during storage indicating varietal differences in their susceptibility/
resistance to Callosobruchus maculatus during storage but not colour related. Aloka had the
least resistance to Callosobruchus maculatus attack during storage and subsequently gave the
highest percentage weight reduction of 15.4%. Next was Ife Brown with 11.3%, followed by
Big White 10.9%, Iron Beans and lastly Big Brown with the highest resistance and least
percentage weight reduction of 6.2%. However, cowpea seed colour did not affect infestation
by Callosobruchus maculatus in storage. The discovery that cowpea colour does not play any
significant role in the resistance/susceptibility of cowpea varieties to Callosobruchus
maculatus during storage is a vital information to cowpea farmers in their effort to enhance
food security in Nigeria.
Keywords: Cowpea, Colour, damage, effect.
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L .Walp), a warm season annual herbaceous legume is one of the
most ancient crops known to man. It is of African origin and is widely grown in Africa with
Nigeria and Niger predominating. Cowpea has a number of common names, including
Crowder pea, black eyed pea, southern pea, lubia, niebe, coupe or frijole (Bressiani , 1985).
Cowpea is an important legume in West and Central Africa, providing an inexpensive source
of protein for both the Urban and Rural poor. According to Bressiani (1985), cowpea
contains23-25% protein, 50-67% carbohydrates,1.9% fats, 6.35%fibre and small percentage
of b-vitamins such as folic acid, thiamine, riboflavin and niacin as well as some
micronutrients such as iron, calcium and zinc(IITA,2001). The seed coat can either be smooth
or wrinkled and of various colours including: white, cream, green, buff, red, brown and black.
Seed may also be speckled, mottled or blotchy. In fresh form, the young leaves and
immature pods are used as vegetables, while the grains are utilized in a wide variety of local
dishes. The relative composition of carbohydrates and richness in protein make them
important components of the food ration of humans particularly where there is insufficient
protein of animal origin; a typical situation in many tropical developing countries (Singh and
Rachie, 1985).despite cowpea being a popular and nutritionally important crop in many parts
of the tropical world, it is very susceptible to insect infestation both in the field and in
storage; though the greatest damage occurs in storage (Murdock et al., 1997). The principal
storage pest of cowpea grains in sub Saharan Africa is the cowpea beetle (Callosobruchus
30
maculatus), commonly called weevil (Taylor, 1981). Weevils cause characteristic holes in
cowpea affecting seed weight and viability while enabling the introduction of pathogenic
fungi and bacteria into the seed. More so, it should be noted that infestations by cowpea by
Callosobruchus maculatus (on the field and in storage) causes both quantitative and
qualitative losses (Shade et al., 1990).
Research in Uganda and many parts of Africa have shown that there is variability in cowpea
damage by Callosobruchus maculatus but did not determine if the differences were due to
seed colour. Hence, the objective of the study was to assess and compare the response of five
different cowpea varieties with contrasting seed colour to the cowpea weevil (Callosobruchus
maculatus) damage during storage.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was conducted at the Botany Laboratory of the Benue State University,
Makurdi, between August and November 2012. The five untreated cowpea varieties used
were Aloka, Big Brown, Big White, Iron Beans, and Ife Brown. They were obtained from the
National Cereals Research Institute (NCRI) Yandev substation in Benue State, Nigeria. The
different varieties of cowpea were sundried for two weeks to allow the escape of
Callosobruchus maculatus and were then sorted out by hand picking to remove undersized
and perforated seed/grains. Sun drying continued so as to achieve cessation of reproduction
of the weevil and also ensure that all the immature stages had been hatched. Equal quantity
(500g) of seeds of each of the cowpea varieties were measured with a digital sensitive
weighing balance and put into airtight plastic containers. Each variety had three replicates
which were stored at room temperature in the laboratory. The weight loss was measured
using the digital sensitive weighing balance. The data collected were a progressive weight
loss of the cowpea varieties at two weekly intervals.
Percentage weight loss was calculated as follows:
i. e.
Collected data were analyzed using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA). Treatment means were
separated using Fishers Least Significant Difference (FLSD) at five percent level of
significance.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION.
Results showed that the susceptibility/resistant of the cowpea varieties; Aloka, Big Brown,
Big White, Ife Brown and Iron Beans to C. maculatus were statistically significant among the
cowpea varieties. Aloka with mottle colour showed the highest weight reduction while big
brown variety with dark brown colour showed the least weight reduction indicating more
resistance to C. maculatus during storage (Table 1).
The percentage weight loss of the cowpea seeds at various weeks of storage also showed
significant differences among the varieties (Table 2) and followed the same trend as above.
31
On a comparative scale however, Big Brown was the least susceptible with actual weight
loss/ percentage weight loss of 31g and 6.2% respectively while Aloka was the most
susceptible with an actual weight loss/ percentage weight loss of 76g and 15.4% respectively
(Fig 1 and Table 2).
The highest weight loss implied the least resistant and none of the five cowpea varieties was
observed to be completely resistant to Callosobruchus maculatus attack.
Fig 1: Actual Weight Loss of Cowpea Varieties at the end of the Experiment.
Cowpea seeds possess certain characteristics such as the nature and hardness of the seed coat
which make them suitable for oviposition by Callosobruchus maculatus. In general, varieties
with smooth seed surface are preferred for oviposition by Callosobruchus maculatus
compared to wrinkled varieties with rough seed surface. (Patil and Jadhav, 1985; Asiedu et
al, 2000). The weight and volume of the seed are two factors responsible for oviposition
preference (Patil and Jadhav, 1985). Hardness of the seed is due to the chemical composition
of the seed coat (Friends, 1981), which has an effect on the ability of Callosobruchus
maculatus to invade the seed (Asiedu et al., 2002). Differences in seed coat colour have been
associated with differences in the chemical composition of leguminous plant seeds. The
chemical compounds found in the seed coat of leguminous plants include tannins, lignin,
non-tannins and polyphenolic compounds. The concentration of these compounds may differ
depending on the level of colour pigmentation in the seed coat (Asiedu et al., 2002). Nozzolio
et al., (1989) reported that coloured seed coats contained 15 times more lignin than the white
seed coats. Morrison et al., (1995), observed twice more lignin in pigmented ones. Lignin has
the function of cementing and anchoring cellulose fibres together. It therefore gives
mechanical rigidity to plants and also protects them against chemical, physical and biological
attacks. In addition to tannins, lignin offers resistance to microbial and other attacks (Friends,
1981).
With respect to colour variation, Big brown and Ife- brown, are both dark brown, Aloka is
mottle, Big white and Iron beans are all white varieties. In this research, both Big brown and
Ife brown had same colour although Ife brown was much more susceptible than Big brown.
However, Morrison et al. (1995) reported high lignin and tannin levels in the pigmented
cowpea varieties. High lignin level which confers rigidity was not indicative of resistance
32
since these pigmented varieties recorded relatively high levels of susceptibility. This suggests
that other factors besides seed coat thickness affect resistance of cowpea to insect infestation.
According to Borchers et al. (1947) the presence of trypsin inhibitors in leguminous seeds
affect the ability of the bruchids to digest proteins contained in the seed. Thus, what confers
resistance to a variety should be an intrinsic property that combats development even after
Callosobruchus maculatus oviposition. Of the five varieties of cowpea studied Big Brown
recorded the longest developmental period and the least susceptibility. This might be due to
the fact that the food material in Big Brown could not be utilized efficiently, thus retarding
the development of Callosobruchus maculatus as found by Allotey and Oyewo (1993) on
soybean Glycin max (L) Merr.
It is important to note however that none of the five cowpea, varieties studied was immuned
to Callosobruchus maculatus attack. This finding agrees with that of Singh and Rachie
(1985) who reported that only one cowpea variety, TVu2027, has been found to have a high
level of seed resistance to Callosobruchus maculatus .Gatehouse et al, (1979) also reported
that TVu2027 has a higher level of trypsin inhibitor compared to other varieties and this may
be the main factor conferring resistance and not seed colour.
REFERENCES
Allotey, J. and Oyewo, A (1993). “Some Aspects of the Biology and Control of
Callosobruchus maculatus (F.)”.Proceedings of Ghana Science Association. 26: 1418.
Asiedu, E.A., Powell, A.A. & Stuchbury,T (2000). Cowpea seed coat chemical analysis in
relation to storage seed quality. African Crop Science Journal. 8 (3): 283-284.
Bressani, R. (1985). Nutritive Value of Cowpeas. John Wiley and sons: New York. Pp 355 360.
Borchers, K., Acherson,C. & Kimmet, L. (1947). “Trypsin Inhibitor IV Occurence in seeds of
leguminous and other seeds”. Arc Biochemistry. 13: 291-293.
Friends, J. (1981). “Plant Pherolics,
Phytochemistry. 7: 197-261.
Lignification
and
Diseases”.
Progress
in
Gatehouse, A.M.R., Gatehouse, J.A., Dobie, P., Kilminster, P. & Boulter, D. (1979).
“Biochemical basis of insect resistance in Vigna unguiculata”. Journal science for
Food Agriculture.30: 948-958.
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) Research (2001). Retrieved November,
2012 from website: www.iita.org/research/summaries/sumproj.8.htm
Murdock, L.L., Shade, R.E .,Kitch, L.W., Ntoukam, G., Lowenberg-De Boer, J.,
Huesing,J.E., Moar, W, Chamblis, O.L., Endondo, C. & Woltson, J.L. (1997). “Post
harvest Storage of Cowpea in Sub-Saharan Africa”. In Singh, B.B., D.R. Moha Raj,
K.E. Dashiell and L.E.N Jackai (Eds.).
Morrison,I., Asiedu, E.A., Stuchbury, T. & Powell, A.A (1995). “ Determination of Tanin &
Lignin in Cowpea Seed Coat.” Annals of Botany 76: 287-290
Nozzolillo, C., Ricciake, L. & Lattanazio,V. (1989). “ Flavonoid Constituents of Viciafaba in
Relation to Genetic Control of their Colour”. Journal of Botany (Canada). 67: 16001604.
33
Patil, S.M. & Jadhav, L.D. (1985). Studies on the Relative Susceptibility of of some
Promising Varieties of Pea to Pulse Beetle Callosobruchus maculatus in Storage.
Bulletin of Grain Techinology, 20:48.
Shade, R.E., Furgason, E.S & Murdock, L.L., (1990). “Detection of hidden insect infestation
by feeding generated ultrasonic signals”. U.S.A. 36:231-2
Singh, S.R. & Rachie, K.O., (1985). “Resistance to Pest of Cowpea in Nigeria”. Bulletin of
Grain Technology. 21(2): 267-297.
Taylor, T.A. (1981). “Distribution, Ecology and Importance of Bruchids attacking Grain
Legumes and Pulses in Africa”. In W. Labeyrie, & G. Junk, (Eds.), The Ecology of
Bruchids Attacking Legumes (pp. 199-203). Netherlands: The Hague.
Table 1: Actual Weight Loss of Cowpea Seeds at Various Weeks of Storage
Weeks of Storage
Varieties
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Aloka
Big Brown
Big White
Ife Brown
Iron Beans
FLSD (0.05)
497.40
498.93
498.95
497.70
499.47
1.72
496.04
498.69
494.46
497.34
495.43
5.43
492.39
494.58
492.48
496.01
490.75
5.80
485.20
491.60b
473.30
489.30
483.30
16.70
471.10
486.30
463.5
474.10
79.20
29.32
452.60
478.80
455.40
461.10
469.60
35.35
436.20
73.70
449.50
450.70
463.30
39.85
423.20
469.00
445.40
443.60
458.90
31.84
Along the columns, if the difference between two treatment means is greater than the FLSD
value, then those treatments aresignificantly different from each other.
Table 2: Percentage Weight Loss of Different Cowpea Varieties during Storage.
Weeks of Storage
2
Varieties
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Aloka
Big Brown
Big White
Ife Brown
Iron Beans
FLSD (0.05)
0.79
0.26
1.11
0.53
0.91
1.09
1.52
1.08
1.50
0.80
1.85
1.16
2.95
1.68
5.33
2.14
3.34
3.33
5.78
2.74
7.29
5.18
4.15
5.86
9.48
4.25
8.92
7.78
6.08
7.08
12.80
5.30
10.10
9.90
7.30
7.97
15.40
6.20
10.90
11.30
8.20
8.35
0.52
0.21
0.21
0.44
0.11
0.37
Along the columns, if the difference between two treatment means is greater than the FLSD
value, then those treatments are significantly different from each other.
34
PGB45
CLASSIFICATION OF REGISTERED CROP VARIETIES IN NIGERIA
Omokhafe, K.O., Nasiru, I., Emuedo, O.A., Uzuniugbe, E.O. and Ohikhena, F. U.
Rubber Research Institute of Nigeria, P.M.B. 1049, Benin City, Edo State, Nigeria.
Corresponding e-mail: kenomokhafe2001@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Crop varieties registered and published in 2009 were assembled into categories based on the
recommending institution in order to determine the contribution of the various categories into
the pool of registered varieties in Nigeria. The highest contribution of varieties was recorded
in institutions that have restricted crop mandate at 384 varieties compared to those who enjoy
academic freedom at 7 varieties. The implications of these results are discussed.
INTRODUCTION
The development of new varieties may provide a breeder with several opportunities such as
conservation of germplasm, exchange of germplasm, new experimental procedures,
publication of papers, registration/release of new varieties etc. Each of these opportunities has
benefits to the breeder with registration/release of varieties as a step that makes the new
varieties available to farmers, as coordinated by the National Committee on Registration and
Release of Crop varieties, Livestock breeds and Fishery (NCRRCLF). The national
committee has a technical subcommittee for crops (TSC), which considers requests for
registration/release of crop varieties and recommends to the NCRRCLF for possible
ratification, certification and publication (NACGRAB, 2004).
Crop varieties presented to the TSC, may be registered but not released. Such varieties are
often of restricted circulation and are typical of materials presented by companies for their
use or among their out-grower farmers only. Most often, materials presented by public
institutions, when registered and released will be in public domain.
The NCRRCLF, on registration of crop varieties, publishes an updated compendium of
registered/released varieties (NACGRAB, 2009). The objective of this study is to evaluate
registration of crop varieties, by various institutions, in Nigeria using the 2009 edition of
NCRRCLF.
MATERIALS AND METHOD
Institutions that presented the crop varieties registered and published in 2009 were listed and
categorized as follows:
A. Research Centres that have clearly defined mandate: these are mainly research institutes
that have restricted mandate. Examples are institutes defined as the National Agricultural
Research Institutes - NARI (Shaib et al, 1997) and a few under the Consultative Group on
International Agricultural Research. It is noteworthy that some institutes classified as
NARI are affiliated to Universities.
B. Universities: these are either the agricultural universities or faculties of agriculture of
multidisciplinary universities. These institutions virtually enjoy academic freedom in
agricultural research.
C. Mandate of some agencies may not be clear. These may be the old institutions that were
involved in agricultural research before stratification into the present structure of
35
agricultural research and training in Nigeria. Examples may be the moribund Federal
Department of Agricultural Research and Northern Nigeria Ministry of Agriculture and
Natural Resources. Some agencies are foreign collaborators whose mandate cannot be
well classified due to inadequate information.
Mean number of varieties registered by each of these groups was calculated and evaluated
using mean separation.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The range of registered varieties was one to ninety nine with a total of 427 varieties (Tables 1
and 2). Among categories, the group with restricted mandate (Category A) had the highest
figure at 384 varieties, followed by the non-classified group (Category C) at 36 varieties and
lastly the group enjoying academic freedom (Category B) with 7 varieties (Table 2). On the
basis of mean, registration of varieties was 11.29 for Category A, which was significantly
different from means obtained for Categories B and C at 2.33 and 3.60 varieties respectively
(Table 2). Within the Category A, institutes that are not affiliated to universities registered
212 varieties and 172 varieties for those affiliated to universities (Table 3).
These results suggest that institutions with restricted mandate have higher tendency to drive
their breeding work to the point of registration of varieties compared to institutions that have
academic freedom. The case of category B may be that the phase of research which leads to
paper publication is more attractive. It may also be that the last phase of on-farm trials, which
is a prerequisite for registration of varieties, is expensive and institutional support for it may
not be available. In this case, Category B institution may seek the assistance of the Category
A institution that has the national mandate for the crop. Grants from agencies may also be
available for farmer focused trials.
It is noteworthy that the potential to publish and also register varieties is there for Categories
A and B without compromising any aspect as evident in publications of breeders in Category
A (Omokhafe and Nasiru, 2005) with high number of registered clones as well as the
commendable effort of Faculties of Agriculture of Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife and
Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria (Table 1). In conclusion, breeders are encouraged to strike a
balance between paper publication and registration of new varieties.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Authors are grateful to the NCRRCLF for consistent compilation of registered crop varieties
in Nigeria. The effort of agencies that presented crop varieties for registration is hereby
acknowledged. The National Centre for Genetic Resources and Biotechnology, Ibadan, which
provides the secretariat for NCRRCLF is recognized for effective coordination. The support
of the Executive Director and Management of Rubber Research Institute of Nigeria (RRIN)
for participation of RRIN in activities of the NCRRLF is appreciated.
REFERENCES
NACGRAB (2004) Crop varieties released and registered in Nigeria, National Centre for
Genetic Resources and Biotechnology, Ibadan, 39p.
NACGRAB (2009) Crop varieties released and registered in Nigeria, National Centre for
Genetic Resources and Biotechnology, Ibadan, 42p.
36
Omokhafe, K. O., Nasiru, I. (2005) Genetic improvement of Hevea brasiliensis in Nigeria.
International Natural Rubber Conference, Cochin, India, pp. 13 – 17.
Shaib, B., Aliyu, A., Bakshi, J.S. (1997) Nigeria: Medium Term Research Plans, 1996 –
2000. Department of Agricultural Sciences, Federal Ministry of Agriculture and
Natural Resources, Abuja, 468p.
37
Table 1. Number of crop varieties released by various institutions in Nigeria as at 2009
Institution
S/No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
Name**
IAR, Samaru
IITA, Ibadan
FDAR/NCRI, Badeggi
NCRI, Badeggi
NIHORT
IITA, Ibadan/IAR, Samaru
IAR&T, Ibadan
NRCRI, Umudike
RRIN, Benin City
CRIN, Ibadan
FDAR
NRCRI, Umudike/IITA
IITA/IAR&T, Ibadan
MRP/IITA
Florida Experimental Station
NIFOR, Benin City
IAR, Samaru/ABU, Zaria
ILRI, Ibadan/NAPRI, Zaria
IAR, Samaru/ICRISAT, Kano
ICRISAT, Kano/IAR, SAmaru
LCRI, Maiduguri
ILRI, Ibadan
NCRI, Badeggi/IITA, Ibadan
WICSBS
Sugar cane breeding Institute, Coimbatora, India
Premier Seed Nig. Ltd.
FDAR/Moor Plantation
ILRI, Kano/ICRISAT, Kano/IAR, Samaru
WARDA, Ibadan/IITA, Ibadan
IAR, Samaru/NCRI, Badeggi
USRI, Ibadan
NCRI, Umudike/RMRDC, Abuja/IITA, Ibadan
IAR&T/Moor Plantation
NBPLC
IAR&T, Ibadan/Faculty of Agric., O.A.U.
Faculty of Agric., O.A.U.
Northern Region Ministry of Agric & Natural
Resources
NCRI, Badeggi/WARDA
LCRI, Maiduguri/ ICRISAT, Kano
IITA, Ibadan/WARDA, Ibadan/ NCRI, Badeggi
Sugar cane Breeding Institute Compos, Brazil
LCRI, Maiduguri/Saskawa Global 2000/IAR, Samaru
NRCRI, Umudike/RMRDC, Abuja
IITA, Kano/IAR, Samaru
IAR&T/IITA/NCRI, Badeggi
38
Category*
A1
A2
A2
A2
A2
A1
A1
A2
A2
A2
C
A2
A1
A2
C
A2
B
A1
A1
A1
A2
A2
A2
C
C
C
C
A1
A2
A2
C
A2
A1
C
B
B
C
Varieties
99
44
31
25
25
21
20
14
14
12
10
10
9
8
7
6
5
5
5
5
4
4
4
4
4
3
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
A2
A2
A2
C
A1
A2
A1
A1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
46. ILRI, Maiduguri/IAR, Samaru
A1
1
47. NCRI/WARDA
A2
1
*A: Institutions with clearly defined mandate;
A1: Institutions with clearly defined mandate but affiliated to universities;
A2: Institutions with clearly defined mandate that are not affiliated to universities;
B: Institutions that enjoy academic freedom (e.g. Universities);
C: Institutions of unknown status of mandate
**: Source of acronyms: NACGRAB, 2009
Table 2. Mean number of varieties registered by categories of institutions
No. of
Mean no.
Category* Institutions
varieties
of varieties
A
34
384
11.29a
B
3
7
2.33b
C
10
36
3.60b
Total
47
427
9.09a
*A: Institutions with clearly defined mandate;
B: Institutions that enjoy academic freedom (e.g. Universities);
C: Institutions of unknown status of mandate
**: Means followed by different letters are significantly different at p = 0.05 (t-test)
Table 3. Mean number of varieties registered by institutions with clearly defined mandate
No. of
Mean no.
Split category*
Institutions
Varieties
of varieties
A1
13
172
13.23
A2
21
212
10.10
Total
34
384
11.29
*A1: Institutions with clearly defined mandate but affiliated to universities;
A2: Institutions with clearly defined mandate that are not affiliated to universities;
39
Table 3: 100 Seed weight (g) of the Different Cowpea Varieties.
Varieties
Aloka
Big white
Big brown
Ife brown
Weight
14.66
26.81
33.43
16.56
Seed Size Classification
Small
Medium
Big
Small
Iron Bean
FLSD (0.05)
27.70
3.15
Medium
Table 4: Main Effects of Cowpea Varieties on Actual Weight Loss (grams) of Cowpea Seed
during Storage.
Varieties
Aloka
Iron Beans
Ife Brown
Big Brown
Big White
FLSD (0.05)
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
499.53
497.03
498.19
499.66
499.55
2.18
491.40
477.20
486.60
487.90
478.60
9.68
483.90
470.40
483.60
473.20
473.50
9.69
478.10
457.20
476.50
462.80
456.50
10.13
475.70
415.90
445.00
460.60
441.80
11.18
496.02
485.99
493.56
498.32
495.71
3.497
Table 5: Main Effects of Varieties on percentage Weight Loss (%) of Cowpea Seed during
storage.
Varieties
Aloka
Iron Beans
Ife Brown
Big Brown
Big White
FLSD (0.05)
Weeks of Storage
2
4
6
8
10
12
0.10
0.60
0.36
0.07
0.09
0.03
1.72
4.56
2.68
2.43
4.27
1.94
3.22
5.91
3.27
5.35
5.30
1.96
4.37
8.55
4.70
7.43
8.69
2.01
4.87
10.81
5.79
9.88
11.65
2.17
0.80
2.80
1.39
0.34
0.86
0.69
Fig. 1: Effects of Variety on Percentage Weight Loss of Cowpea to Callosobruchus maculatus
During Storage.
REFERENCES
Jason, M. Cope and Charles, W. Fox (2003). Oviposition decisions in the seed beetle,
Callosobruchus maculatus (Coleoptera: Bruchidae). Effects of seed size on super
parasitism. Journal of stored products Research (39): pp 355-365.
Motshwari obopile, Keamogetse Masiapeto and Chiyapo Gwafila (2011). Variation in
reproductive and developmental parameters of Callosobruchus maculatus (F.) reared on ten
Botswana cowpea landraces. African Journal of Biotech vol. 10 (63): pp 13924-13928.
Ofuya, T.I, Olutuah, O.F and Akinyoade, D.O, (2010). The effect of storage on the efficacy of
Eugenia Aromatic (Baill) in the control of Callosobruchus maculatus (Fabricius)
(Coleoptera: Bruchidae) pest. J.of Appl. Sci. Enviro. Mgt. Vol. 14(1) 97-100.
Ogbaji, M. I. and Ndam, O. (2002). Response of some Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp.)
varieties to insect pests in makurdi, a location in the southern Guinea Savanna. Nigerian
Journal of Sustainable Agric. Research 3:28-32.
Ogbaji, M. I. and K. M. Tyoga (2010). Efficiency of Ginger, scale leaves of onions and dried
peels of oranges in the storage of cowpea against cowpea weevil (C. maculatus). Journal of
Tropical Agriculture, Food, Environment and Extension, Agro science Vol. 9(4): 31-37.
Ogbaji, M. I. and Usman, D. (2011). Insecticidal actions of some botanicals on storage bruchid
Callosobruchus maculatus (F.) of stored cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp).
Shazia Lephale, Abraham Addo-Bediako and Victoria Ayodele (2012). Susceptibility of seven
cowpea cultivars (Vigna unguiculata) to cowpea beetle Callosobruchus maculatus. Agric.
Sc. Research Journal Vol. 2 (2) pp 65-69.
Temesgen Keba and Sori Waktole (2008). Differential Resistance of grain varieties. Research
Artc.
PGB46
GENETIC DIVERSITY OF POLLEN MORPHOLOGY AND POLLEN PRODUCTION
OF CORCHORUS OLITORIUS USING DIFFERENT CONCENTRATIONS OF STRONG
HYPOCHLORITE SOLUTION.
Olawuyi, P.O.*, Falusi, O.A., Kolo, J.T., Abubakar, A., Azeez, R. D. and Titus, S.D.
Department of Biological Sciences, Federal University of Technology,
Minna, Niger State, Nigeria
*Corresponding email: olapeter2013@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Mutations were induced in Corchorus olitorius using sodium hypochlorite. The Corchorus
olitorius seeds were treated with 0%, 25%, 50% and 75% solution of sodium hypochlorite so as
to assess their effects on pollen viability, pollen production and pollen diameter. Results showed
that the pollen parameters were significantly different (p ≤ 0.05). It was observed that as the
concentrations of sodium hypochlorite increases, the values of pollen viability, pollen production
and pollen diameter also increased. This may essentially affect productivity positively.
Therefore, sodium hypochlorite could be used to induced genetic variability in the pollen of
Corchorus olitorius, and this could be exploited for the improvement of the crop in Nigeria.
KEY WORDS: Corchorus olitorius, Sodium hypochlorite, Pollen parameters, and Genetic
variability
INTRODUCTION
Corchorus is a genus of about 40-100 species of flowering plants in the family Malvaceae, native
to tropical and subtropical regions throughout the world .The plants are usually annual herbs,
reaching a height of 4 m, unbranched or with only a few side branches and is an erect woody
herb, usually 0.5 - 1.2m high but may reach up to 2.5 m in cultivation and growing as tall 4m
(14Ft).The leaves are alternate, simple, lanceolate, 5-15 cm long, with an acuminate tip and a
finely serrated or lobed margin. The flowers are small (2-3 cm diameter) and yellow, with five
petals; the fruit is a many-seeded capsule. It thrives almost anywhere, and can be grown yearround. The local names of Corchorus olitorius in English are jute plant and bush okra,In many
West Africa Countries, the crop is referred to names similar to keren keren like krin krin, crain
crain or kelen kelen. Some Nigerian names for the crop include ewedu in Yoruba, ahuara in
Igbo, malafiya and ayoyo in Hausa. (Akoroda, 2008).
Corchorus leaves are consumed in the cuisines of various countries. It has a mucilaginous
texture, similar to okra, when cooked, the seeds are used as a flavouring, and a herbal tea is made
from the dried leaves. The leaves of Corchorus are rich in betacarotene, iron, calcium, and
vitamin C. The plant has an antioxidant activity with a significant α-tocopherol E. However,
despite all the tremendous benefits of jute to world economy, its diversity and uses are under
threat in Nigeria due to low yield. There is an urgent need as stressed to redesign the ongoing
breeding strategy to improve the yield of such economic plant (Roy et al; 2006).
Sodium hypochlorite solution is poisonous for water organisms and plants. It is mutagenic, very
toxic and corrosive in nature. The aim of this research is to study the effect different
concentrations sodium hypochlorite solution on the pollens viability, pollen diameter and pollen
production of Corchorus olitorius. Pollen studies is widely used in convectional plant breeding,
tissue culture, plant biotechnology and pollen is used in cultivated plants to increase crop yield
which is ultimate goal of most plant breeding programme (Beadle,2009). Nigeria has a great
potential for the production of Corchorus olitorius for domestic and export market and due
nutritional value and economical importances. The yield of the crop is still critically low as
compared to other vegetable crops. Increased production of the crop is hampered by several
factors one of which is inavailability of improved seed. But unfortunately, there has been little
research efforts on the crop therefore this research is designed to look at the effect different
concentrations of sodium hypochlorite on the pollen parameters (David,2010).
METHODOLOGY
The study was carried out at experimental field, Centre for Preliminary and Extra- mural studies
Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State in North central Nigeria between July –
November 2012. The area is located within longitude 6033’E and 90 37’, and the climate is
tropical, with mean annual temperature, relative humidity and rainfall of 30.200, 61.00% and
1334mm respectively. The vegetation is a typical Guinea Savannah type consisting majorly of
grassland with scattered trees ( Olayemi et al.,2009).
MATERIALS
One Kilogram of Corchorus olitorius seeds were obtained from the National Institute of
horticulture, (NIHORT) Ibadan, the seeds were kept separately in envelopes and tied in white
polythene bags. Healthy seeds were pre-soaked in distilled water by floatation method and
treated were with different concentrations (0%, 25%, 50% and 75%) of sodium hypochlorite
solution.
The planting of the seeds was done using the completely randomized block design. Ten seeds
were grown in each five litre size of pots filled with rich loamy soil and thinned to two per
pot in two weeks after planting. A total of sixteen pots per block used with three replicates and
the pots were kept in the experimental field of the Centre for Preliminary and Extra –Moral
Studies, Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State and nurtured to maturity.
The pollen production test was carried out using the method described by Mehmet. Twenty
flower buds for each treatment were used in the study. The flower buds were divided into two
groups, each group containing anthers from five flower buds in small vial bottles. The anther
were thoroughly crushed with a glass rod and then 1ml distilled water was added into each vial
bottle. A drop was placed on a two counting area containing Thoma (haemocytometric) slide
(0.1mm in depth) to where a special cover slip was replaced. The pollens were placed on
randomly chosen four large squares in each counted area with two replicates representing each
group of flowers in vials (Mehmet, 2011). The average pollen grain amount per flower:
(P/F) = Pollen count x 1000mm3/ 0.1mm3/5 flowers
IKI (0.5g iodine (I) and1g Potassium iodide (KI)) solution was prepared by dissolving I and KI
in 100ml distilled water (Eti et al 1996). The pollen viability counts were made within few
minutes in light microscope after pollens were placed on IKI solution. The pollen grains stained
Dark brown in colour were counted as viable while those with a light pinkish colour or not
stained at all were considered non-viable. Two microscope slides were used for each treatment.
Approximately 300 pollens were counted in each slide. Pollen viability test was performed the
same day when the flower buds were collected (Eti et al 1996). Pollen viability percentage was
gotten using the formular
Pollen viability percentage
No of viable pollens
x
100
No. of pollens counted
For each treatment, flowers were randomly sampled and used to determine the amount of pollen
produced and pollen diameter were determined by eye piece gravicle . Numbers of pollen grain
per flower will be determined using hemacytometric methods (Eti, 1996). The amount of pollen
per anther will be determined using following formular
Pa= Pf ∕
∕AF
where PA is the number of pollen grain per anther
pf is the number of pollen grain per flower
AF is the number of Anther per flower
The data collected were subjected to Analysis of variance (ANOVA) using statistical analysis
was used to test the significance of the effects of the different concentrations of sodium
hypochlorite solution on pollen per flowers, pollen viability and pollens diameter. It showed that
the pollen parameters (i.e were significantly different (p ≤ 0.05). Analysis of variance was used
to explain the relationship between the different concentration and the number of pollens
produced per flower, percentage viability, anther per flower and viable pollen grain.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The result recorded on the effect of sodium hypochlorite on pollen produced per flower , anther
per flower, pollen diameter, viable pollen grains and non –pollen grains in different
concentrations of Corchorus olitorius is represented in Table 1 below.
Result of pollen parameters on effect of different concentrations of sodium hypochlorite
solution in corchorus olitorius.
KEYS: PPF – pollen produced per flower, AFP –anther per flower, PD – pollen diameter,
VPG – viable pollen grain, and NPG – non –pollen grain
TABLE 1
Concentrations
(%)
PPF
AFP
PD
VPG
NPG
0
384952.38d
80.33d
0.0559d
90.47d
24.30d
25
151190.48a
30.24a
0.0355c
86.72c
15.24c
50
211428.57b
42.29b
0.0315b
85.22b
13.86b
75
299285.71c
59.86c
0.0312a
76.07a
09.96a
From Table 1, for PPF is the highest value was recorded at 0% (384952.38).This value is
statistically significant and different from all other values. Also, the lowest value was at 25%
concentration value (151190.48) was significantly different from all other concentrations. The
PPF Values obtained indicated that as the concentrations increases PPF values tend to increase.
For AFP is the highest number of anther per flower was observed at 0% (80.33) and lowest
concentration value (30.24) of anther per flower with higher anther per flower were statistically
significantly different. There was consistency in the trend of the anther per flower. The highest
number of pollens diameter in PD was also observed at 0% (0.0559mm) followed by 75%
concentration (0.0355mm) . In 50% concentration (0.0315) and 25% concentration (0.0312)
values are closely related respectively was significantly different. There was consistency in the
trend of the number of anther per flower in Corchorus olitorius.
For VPG, there was a corresponding increase in viable pollen grains with increasing in different
concentrations, although the 25% concentration had the lowest number of pollens per flower
(76.07 pollens grains). All the number of viable pollen grains in all the concentrations used is
statistically significant alike. For NPG, the highest value was observed at 0% (24.30) and the
lowest value was at 25% concentration (9.96), these values was significantly different from all
other concentrations. The NPG values observed indicated that as the concentrations increases as
well as NPG value increases. The ANOVA results for all the parameters studied (PPF, AFP, PD,
VPG and NPG) showed a significant different in Table 1 above.
The significant differences observed in pollen produced per flower, anther per flower, pollens
diameter, viable pollen grains and non – viable pollen grains in all the different concentrations
of sodium hypochlorite solution used in this study is an indication that sodium hypochlorite can
be used to induce genetic variability in the plant. The changes produced by sodium hypochlorite
solution could play a significant role in the improvement of the crop. The use of sodium
hypochlorite solution in this study could have induced genetic variation which favoured pollen
parameters. The concentration at 0% showed the highest value for all the pollen parameters
which is likely to be more productive than other concentration in the plants. This result is in line
with the results of Ashri (2008) and Kumar et al (2003)who observed that jute plant proved
less sensitive to chemical mutagens mainly ethyl methane sulphonate.
The significant differences observed in the pollen viability test may be due to the fact that the
pollen viability of the control were generally high hence there was significant increase in pollen
viability induced by sodium hypochlorite. The high pollen viability is in line with the result of
Falusi (2006) who observed that pollen viability were high in two species of Sesame, Sesamum
indicum and Sesamum radiatum which is similar to Corchorus olitorius.
CONCLUSION
This study has established the following:
(a) Sodium hypochlorite has the ability to induce genetic variability in corchorus olitorius
which can serve as a basis for selection for plant breeders.
(b)Sodium hypochlorite can also be used to improve the pollen diameter and pollen production
in Corchorus olitorius.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I bless the giver of knowledge and wisdom, ancient of the days whose love has turned my life
around for best. I wish to appreciate the fatherly role and selfless efforts of my able supervisor,
Prof. O.A. Falusi, Mr Oluwajobi, Mal.Daudu, Evans, Shalom, Mary and Ruth for their
constructive criticism during this study.
REFERENCES
Akoroda, M.O. (2008). Cultivation of Jute. (Corchorus olitorius). for edible leaf in Nigeria
Tropical Agriculture, 65 (4): 297-299
Ashri, A. (2008). Sesame breeding. Plant Breeding Reviews, 16: 179-228
Beadle , G.W. (2009).Gene in maize for pollen sterility. Genetics, 17:413 -431
Bhat, T.A., Sharma, M., and Anis, M. (2007).Comparative analysis of meiotic aberration
induced by chemical in broad bean (Vicia Fabal). Asian Journal of plant sciences6:1051
– 10571.
David, T. (2010). All you wanted to know about induced mutation in crop breeding. Bulletin of
Biofortified
Daniele, S.L. (2008).Sodium hypochlorite dosage for household and Emergence water treatment.
Electron journal Awwa 100 (8).
Eti, S., Paydas, S., Küden, A. B., Kaka, N., Kurnaz, S., Ilgin, M. (1996). Investigations
in the pollen viability, germination capability and the Growth of pollen tubes on
some selected almond types under experimental conditions. Acta. Horticulturae, 373,
225- 229.
Falusi, O.A. and Salako E.A. (2006). Meiotic and pollen studies on some F1
hybrid between Sesamum indicum and Sesamum radiatum. Nigerian Journal
of Genetics, 18 : 58 – 62
Kumar. G. and Singh, V. (2003). Comparative analysis of meiotic abnormalities chemical
mutagen and EMS in Corchorus olitorius. Journal Indian Botanical Science, 82:19-22.
Mehmet, S. (2011) Pollen quality, quantity and Fruit set of some self compatible Cherry
cultivars with artificial pollination. African Journal of Biotechnology, 10 (17)
3380-3386.
Olayemi,I. K., Ande,A.T., Isah,B. and Idris,A. R. (2009).Epidemiology of malaria in
relation to
Medical
climate variable in Minna, Nigeria. African Journal of
Sciences, 2(1) :5-10.
PGB47
INTROGRESSION OF ALLELES FROM MAIZE LANDRACES TO IMPROVE
DROUGHT TOLERANCE IN AN ADAPTED GERMPLASM
Meseka, S.1*, M. Fakorede, M.2, Ajala, S.1, Badu-Apraku, B.1 and Menkir, A.1
1
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, PMB 5320, Oyo Road, Ibadan, Nigeria.
2
Department of Crop Production & Protection, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria.
Corresponding e-mail: s.meseka@cgiar.org
ABSTRACT
Maize (Zea mays L.) landraces in the northern Guinea savanna and Sudan savanna in West and
Central Africa appear to have some drought adaptive traits. This study was initiated to assess the
level of improvement in grain yield and other agronomic traits achieved under drought stress
(DS) and in multiple locations (ML) after introgression of alleles from maize landraces into an
elite maize variety (AK9443-DMRSR) via backcrossing. Six backcross (BC) populations
together with recurrent parent (AK9443-DMRSR), a commercial hybrid (Oba Super2), and an
improved variety (TZLCOMP4C1) were evaluated under DS and full irrigated (FI) conditions
during the dry seasons of 1999 and 2000, as well as in seven ML trials. No significant
differences were observed among genotypes for grain yield and most of the traits measured
under DS and FI. Significant differences were recorded among genotypes for grain yield and
other agronomic traits measured in ML trials. Drought stress reduced grain yields of the BC1F2
populations by 64% and recurrent parent by 71%. In ML trials, at least half of the populations
were better than recurrent parent. The top three BC1F2 populations produced more grains than
the recurrent parent (258 – 360 kg/ha) and Oba Super2 (555–657 kg/ha) with introgression of
only 25% genome of the landraces. Our study demonstrated that backcross procedure was able to
transfer a quantitative trait of grain yield of an elite recurrent parent into maize landraces.
Additional backcross generations are needed for improved performance of the BC1 F2 populations
in water stressed environments.
INTRODUCTION
Farmers in drought prone areas frequently report low grain yields for improved varieties, as the
varieties produced may not have been specifically developed for drought tolerance. The farmers
are usually wary of adopting un-adapted varieties to minimize the risk of crop failure under
adverse conditions. New varieties targeted to drought affected areas should combine adaptation
to drought stress with high yield potential to allow them to compete with elite varieties under
optimum conditions (Bidinger et al., 1994). Progress in the development of drought tolerant
varieties depends on sources of alleles for improved performance under drought stress. The
choice of source population plays a critical role in a breeding program because it determines the
frequency of desirable alleles at the onset of selection (Hallauer, 1991). Drought tolerance alleles
from drought tolerant source germplasm can be transferred to adapted germplasm by
backcrossing using either conventional methods or marker assisted selection (Edmeades et al.,
1997a). Dudley (1982) suggested that at least one backcross to recurrent parent would enhance
the probability of transferring favourable alleles from donor to recurrent parent. The resulting
populations containing alleles derived from diverse sources should thus be evaluated under
controlled drought stress and in multiple locations to assess incorporation of drought tolerance
alleles.
Landrace varieties represent a reservoir of highly adapted genotypes that form essential
components of sustainable agriculture. Blum and Sullivan (1986) suggested that landraces of
sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L.) and pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum) collected from drought
affected environments could possess unique physiological attributes for drought tolerance that
may not be present in elite varieties that are not exposed to drought. Although landraces of maize
have not been used extensively by breeders because of their low yields and other undesirable
traits, they can serve as sources of desirable alleles to enhance performance of adapted
germplasm under drought stress (Beck et al., 1997). Introgression of alleles from local varieties
into adapted germplasm could also be beneficial to widen the germplasm base and combine high
yield potential with good levels of drought tolerance. Evidence from previous studies (BaduApraku et al., 1997) in WCA indicated that the probability of obtaining drought tolerance in a
population is significantly greater when the source population from which it was derived also has
a high level of drought tolerance.
The poor agronomic performance and narrow adaptability of improved maize varieties have been
formidable obstacles for farmers seeking to grow elite maize cultivars in the northern Guinea
Savanna and Sudan Savanna of WCA. A study was initiated at the International Institute of
Tropical Agriculture (IITA), Ibadan, Nigeria, to investigate the extent to which drought tolerance
from landraces could be effectively introgressed into elite germplasm of maize. The first step
was to collect the maize landraces germplasm, which was done by the Maize Association of
Nigeria (MAAN) in collaboration with IITA through a farm-level survey of maize activities
throughout the country in the early 1990s, during which over 400 farmers’ varieties were
collected. Analysis of the response of the varieties to the challenge of the maize streak virus
infection showed that many of the collections, particularly those obtained from locations far from
IITA-Ibadan, were truly landraces (Fakorede et al., 2003). The objective of the present study was
to assess the level of improvement in yield potential and other agronomic traits of backcross
(BC) populations containing alleles derived from six landrace accessions under water stress and
favourable conditions.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
More than 400 maize accessions collected by MAAN in collaboration with IITA across Nigeria
were evaluated for streak virus and abiotic stresses at IITA. After preliminary evaluations,
Menkir and Akintunde (2001) selected 20 of the landraces, screened them under water stress, and
identified six of them as potential sources of alleles for drought tolerance. They observed that the
six landraces expressed good levels of drought tolerance and recommended their use to expand
the genetic base of adapted elite germplasm. The six landraces were collected from Jigawa,
Kano, Katsina, and Yobe States in northern Nigeria. Characteristics of the environments in
which these landraces were grown are provided in Table 1. Rainfall in these states is highly
variable, with the main growing season starting late and ending early, depending on the northsouth movement of the intertropical convergence zone (ITCZ). The six landraces were crossed to
the elite OPV, AK9443-DMRSR, and the resulting F1s were backcrossed once to the same elite
recurrent parent to generate backcross (BC1F1) populations. The six BC1F1 populations were then
advanced to F2 by selfing to produce BC1F2.
Table 1. Some pertinent information for the six maize landraces and recurrent parent used in
producing backcross populations
Temperatur
e (Co)
Local accessions
Latitude
Longitud
e
Altitud
e
(m)
Min
Max
(mm)
JigawaAccNo.4(
Y)
Jigawa
12o N
9o 45' E
376
18
35
688
JigawaAccNo.11
Jigawa
12o N
9o 45' E
376
18
35
688
Kano
11o 30'
N
8o 30' E
530
19
33
907
KatsinaAccNo.3
Katsina
12o 15'
N
7o 30' E
547
19
33
819
YobeAccNo.2
Yobe
12o N
11o 30' E
372
17
33
619
YobeAccNo.3(Y)
Yobe
12o N
11o 30' E
372
17
33
619
AK9443DMRSR†
IITAIbadan
7o 30' N
3o 54' E
215
22
31
1294
KanoAccNo.10
†
Location
Annual
rainfall
Adapted open pollinated adapted variety used as recurrent parent in backcrossing.
Source: GIS unit –IITA, Ibadan. The temperature range and mean annual rainfall were obtained
from gridded climate surface (1951-2005) produced by University of East Anglia UK.
The BC1F2 populations along with their recurrent parent, an improved variety (TZLCOMP4C1),
and a single cross commercial hybrid (Oba Super2) were arranged in a randomized complete
block design (RCBD) with three replications and evaluated at Ikenne (6o52′ N, 3o43′ E, altitude
60 m) under water stress (DS) and well watered (FI) conditions during the dry seasons
(December – March) of 1999 and 2000. Planting was done during the first week of December
each year. Each entry was planted in a pair row plot 3 m long, with 0.75 m spacing between and
0.25 m spacing within rows. Two seeds were planted in a hill and thinned to one plant after
emergence. In both trials, two border rows were planted with a common check. A sprinkler
irrigation system was used to supply sufficient water every week to all treatments in the two
blocks during the first five weeks (35 days) after planting. Thereafter, FI block continued to
receive irrigation every week until physiological maturity, whereas irrigation was withdrawn in
the DS block to create drought stress at flowering and grain filling stages. Apart from the
targeted water stress, all other management practices were the same for the two irrigation
treatments.
The same BC1 F2 populations, together with their recurrent parent and two checks, were also
evaluated in multiple locations (ML) during the main rainy season (June – October) to assess
their yield potential under random drought at Bagauda (11◦50′ N, 8◦36′ E, altitude 448 m),
Ikenne, Saminaka (10◦25′ N, 8◦41′ E, altitude 762 m), and Zaria (11◦7′ N, 7◦43′ E, altitude 639
m) in 2000, and only at Ikenne, Saminaka, and Zaria in 2001. In each location, a RCBD with
four replications was used. Each entry was planted in four rows plot, 5 m long, with 0.75 m
spacing between rows and 0.5 m spacing between hills within a row. Three seeds were planted
per hill and thinned to two plants after emergence. Number of border rows and population
density were the same as in the DS and FI trials. In all trials, a compound fertilizer was applied at
the rate of 60 kg N, 60 kg P, and 60 kg K ha−1 at the time of sowing. An additional 60 kg N ha−1
was applied as top dressing four weeks later. Gramoxone (paraquat: 1, 1’-dimethyl-4,4’bipyridinium) was applied at 5 L ha−1 to control weeds. Subsequently, manual weeding was done
to keep the trials free of weeds.
Days to anthesis and silking were recorded as the number of days from planting to when 50% of
the plants in a plot were shedding pollen and had emerged silks, respectively. Plant and ear
heights were measured as the distance from the base of the plant to the height of the first tassel
branch and the node bearing the upper ear, respectively. Ears aspect was scored on a scale of 1 to
5, where 1 = well filled ear with uniform grain colour and 5 = poorly filled ear with varied grain
colours. All ears harvested from each plot were shelled and used to determine percentage grain
moisture and grain weight. Grain yield adjusted to 15% moisture was computed from the shelled
grain weight. Data from DS, FI, and ML trials were analyzed separately, using a mixed model in
SAS (SAS Institute, 2002), considering all effects as random except genotypes.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Under WS as well as WW, none of the sources of variation had significant effect on grain yield
(Table 2). In the ML, environment significantly affected all the traits (Table 3). The variance
among varieties was significant for all the traits, except number of ears per plant.
Variety x environment interaction was significant only for days to anthesis and silking (Table 3).
The lack of significant differences among genotypes for grain yield and other agronomic traits
under DS and FI could be attributed to large mean error variance for these traits.
Table 2. Mean performance from analysis of variance of backcross populations involving maize
landraces as non-recurrent parents tested under water stress and well watered treatments
for two years
Days to Days to
Plant
Ear
Ear
Grain
Source
DF
anthesis silking
height
height aspect
yield
a
(day)
(day)
(cm)
(cm)
(1-5)
(kg/ha)
Drought stress
Year
1
50.1*** 140.2*** 462.3
606.7*
5.15***
1509
Rep (Year)
4
2.6**
2.4
19.6
42.3
0.68*
87316
Variety
8
2.0**
1.4
314.0
275.3*
0.46
173585
Variety x
Year
8
0.7
2.2
86.9
115.1
0.21
121707
Error
32
0.4
1.5
161.7
104.3
0.26
118890
Full Irrigation
Year
1
0.7
1.2
5221.5** 109.8
0.02
192413
Rep (Year)
4
0.8
0.5
876.9
354.4
0.28
487301
Variety
8
3.0**
1.9**
878.1*
550.0*
0.29
1153566
Variety x
Year
8
1.0*
0.9
410.9
152.2
0.14
641235
Error
32
0.4
0.6
364.2
191.4
0.15
706737
*, **, *** significant at 0.05, 0.01 and 0.001 probability levels, respectively
a
Ear aspect on a scale of 1 to 5, where 1 = clean, well-filled ear, and 5 = ear with undesirable
features
These results indicated that the BC1F2 populations performed similar to their recurrent parent, a
commercial single-cross hybrid, and an elite variety under water stress and well watered
conditions throughout the growing season. Because the G x E mean squares in the ANOVA were
not significant for grain yield under DS and FI conditions, the BC1 F2 populations appeared to
have maintained their performance regardless of the variation in the environmental factors in
these ecologies.
Table 3. Mean performance from analysis of variance of backcross populations involving maize
landraces as non-recurrent parents tested in seven environments in Nigeria
Days to Days to Plant
Ear
Ear
Grain
Source
DF anthesis silking
height
height
aspect
yield
Environment
(E)
Rep (E)
Variety (V)
VxE
(day)
589.4**
6
*
21
1.9**
8
14.1***
48
1.3*
(day)
956.2**
*
2.0**
(cm)
19248.2**
*
(cm)
3330.9**
*
(1-5)a
470.9**
222.6
1331.6**
*
0.09
710783
0.08
1850683**
123.3
0.16**
14.6*** 2415.4***
1.9**
196.4
(kg/ha)
122026857**
1.51***
*
679342
Error
168
0.9
1.0
201.1
171.3
0.08
574169
*, **, *** significant at 0.05, 0.01 and 0.001 probability levels, respectively
a
Ear aspect on a scale of 1 to 5, where 1 = clean, well-filled ear, and 5 = ear with undesirable
features
However, differences in yield potential became obvious in ML trials conducted during the rainy
season, typically of farmers’ field conditions, indicating that the BC1F2 populations possess
alleles for yield potential expressed under random drought conditions (Table 4). It is apparent
that these BC1F2 populations have combined productivity traits of the elite recurrent parent and
traits for drought tolerance as well as other good characteristics of the landraces. These results
suggested that the donor landraces had favourable alleles for drought tolerance, which may not
have been present in their elite recurrent parent.
Means of the six BC1F2 populations, AK9443-DMRSR, Oba Super2, and TZLCOMP4C1 under
DS and FI are presented in Figure 1. All the BC1F2 populations performed essentially the same
as the recurrent parent and the two checks for grain yield and other agronomic traits under DS
and FI. On average, drought stress reduced grain yields of the BC1F2 populations by 64% and the
recurrent parent by 71%. The grain yields of Oba Super2 and TZLCOMP4C1 were also reduced
by 67% and 73%, respectively. Under DS conditions, the three top populations (BC1F2: 1, 2, and
3) took the same number of days to reach anthesis as their elite recurrent parent. They also
showed relative yield advantage (ranging from 290 to 481 kg/ha) over Oba Super2 and
TZLCOMP4C1 under DS conditions. Two of the top four populations (genotype 1 and 4)
involved landraces collected from Jigawa State, which is characterized by rainfall varying from
600 to 700 mm and high temperatures (35 Co) during the cropping season. Perhaps this and
similar ecologies should be surveyed for more landraces with adaptive alleles to drought. Blum
and Sullivan (1986) reported that races of sorghum and pearl millet evolved in dry regions within
a range of annual rainfall of 200–700 mm were more drought-tolerant than races that evolved in
areas with 800–1,100 mm of rainfall.
A. Grain yield
under drought
unde irrigation
Ear aspect (1 - 5)
7.0
6.0
B. Ear aspect
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
under drought
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
9
1
2
3
M a ize ge no t ype s
C. Days to anthe s is
under drought
unde irrigation
4
5
6
7
8
9
Maize genotypes
unde irrigation
55
D. Days to silking
under drought
unde irrigation
57
56
55
54
53
52
51
50
49
54
53
52
51
50
49
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
2
3
M a ize ge no t ype s
E. Plant he ight
under drought
4
5
6
7
8
9
M a ize ge no t ype s
unde irrigation
300
F. Plant height
under drought
unde irrigation
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
250
200
150
100
50
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
M a ize ge no t ype s
7
8
9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
M a ize ge no t ype
Figure 1. Means of grain yield (A), ear aspect (B), days to anthesis (C), days to silking (D), plant
height (E), ear height (F) of six BC1F2 populations (genotypes 1 – 6), recurrent parent (genotype
7), and two checks (genotype 8, single cross hybrid; and 9, open pollinated variety) evaluated
under drought stress and full irrigation averaged over two years.
Considering the diversity of origin of the six landraces used in this study, our results suggested
that the potential exists for combining favourable alleles from landraces and elite varieties in
developing varieties and parental lines of hybrids with superior performance under water stress.
Albrecht and Dudley (1987) introgressed alleles from an exotic maize composite into adapted
one and found that BC1-F2 had good performance as compared to the recurrent parent. Our data
indicated that BC1F2 populations were similar in grain yield and other agronomic traits to the
elite recurrent parent under DS and FI, suggesting that favourable quantitative traits not only
from the elite parent but also from the landraces have been integrated into a new population. The
increase in grain yield recorded in the top three of the six BC1F2 populations in multiple agroecologies with introgression of only 25% of the genome of the maize landraces may further be
enhanced by one or more generations of backcrossing to the elite recurrent parent.
Table 4. Mean performance of backcross populations involving maize landraces as non-recurrent
parents evaluated in seven environments under random drought
Days
Grain Days to to
Plant
Ear
Ear
yield
anthesis silking eight
eight aspect
Variety
(kg/ha) (day)
(day)
(cm)
(cm) (1-5)a
(AK9443DMRSR)2xYobeAccNo.2
5079
57
59
231
119
2.6
(AK9443DMRSR)2xJigawaAccNo.4(Y) 5035
57
59
234
128
2.5
(AK9443-DMRSR)2xJigawaAccNo.11 5022
57
58
238
125
2.4
(AK9443-DMRSR)2xKatsinaAccNo.3
4902
57
59
226
117
2.5
(AK9443-DMRSR)2xKanoAccNo.10
4813
57
59
232
121
2.6
(AK9443-DMRSR)2xYobeAccNo.3(Y) 4705
58
59
243
129
2.5
AK9443DMRSR
4918
57
59
230
115
2.6
OBA SUPER2
4550
57
59
212
109
2.4
TZLCOMP4C1
5213
59
60
229
117
2.5
Mean
4915.2 57.2
59.0
230.6 120.1 2.5
LSD (p<0.05)
514.6
1.5
1.7
24.1
20.9 ns
ns = not significant at p = 0.05 level
a
Ear aspect on a scale of 1 to 5, where 1 = clean, well-filled ear, and 5 = ear with undesirable
features
It was particularly striking that under several multilocation trials, the top three BC1F2 populations
were equal in yield to the productive variety (TZLCOMP4C1), while the other three BC1F2
populations produced about the same levels of grain yield as the two checks. Among the top
three BC1F2 populations, (AK9443-DMRSR2xJigawaAccNo.11) which ranked top under DS,
ranked second and third in ML trials. The improved yield performance observed across ML
could be attributed to similarity in frequencies of favourable alleles for grain yield present in the
recurrent parent and the donor parents transferred into BC1F2 populations. The ML trials reported
in this study were conducted in the agro-climatic zones, including rainforest, northern Guinea
savanna, and the semi-arid Sudan savanna, which are the major agro-ecologies of sub-Saharan
Africa. A modest increase in grain yields (at least 100 kg/ha) of farmers’ improved local varieties
would be an incentive, particularly for farmers growing maize in semi-arid ecologies of northern
Guinea Savanna and Sudan Savanna in WCA.
CONCLUSION
Our study demonstrated that selection of the donor parents under water stress and their use to
develop BC populations can be effective for exploitation of potentially useful alleles of drought
tolerance hidden in local maize landraces to improve performance of elite maize germplasm. The
top three BC1F2 populations identified in this study may offer opportunities for increasing gains
from selection. These populations could be subjected to additional backcrossing and recurrent
selection under controlled drought stress to further increase the frequency of favourable alleles of
drought tolerance and grain yield, mainly with additive effects. The resulting BC populations can
be invaluable sources of varieties and parental lines of hybrids that combine drought tolerance
with high yield potential for further testing under water stress and in multiple locations.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We acknowledge the contributions of Maize Association of Nigeria (MAAN) for collection of
maize landraces, and staff members of maize improvement program of IITA for participating in
various field operations. This research was funded by IITA.
REFERENCES
Albrecht, B., and J. W. Dudley. 1987. Evaluation of four maize populations containing different
proportions of exotic germplasm. Crop Sci. 27:480–486.
Badu-Apraku, B., A. O. Diallo, J. M. Fajemisin, and M. A. B. Fakorede. 1997. Progress in
breeding for drought tolerance in tropical early maturing maize for the semi-arid zone of
West and Central Africa. In Developing drought- andlow N-tolerant maize, proceedings of a
symposium, 25–29 March 1996, edited by G. O. Edmeades, M. Bänziger, H. R. Mikleson,
and C. B. Pena-Valdivia, 469–474. El Batan, Mexico: International Maize and Wheat
Improvement Center (CIMMYT).
Beck, D., F. J. Betran, M. Bänziger, M. Willcox, and G. O. Edmeades. 1997. From landraces to
hybrids: Strategies for the use of source populations and lines in the development of drought
tolerant cultivars. In Developing drought- and low N-tolerant maize, proceedings of a
symposium, 25–29 March 1996, edited by G. O. Edmeades, M. Bänziger, H. R. Mikleson,
and C. B. Pena-Valdivia, 369–382. El Batan, Mexico: International Maize and Wheat
Improvement Center (CIMMYT).
Bidinger, F. R., E. Weltzien, R. V. Mahalakshmi, S. D. Singh, and K. P. Roa. 1994. Evaluation
of landrace topcross hybrids of pearl millet for arid zone environments. Euphytica 76:215–
226.
Blum, A., and C. Y. Sullivan. 1986. The comparative drought resistance of landraces of sorghum
and millet from dry and humid regions. Ann. Bot. 57:835–846.
Dudley, J. W. 1982. Theory and transfer of alleles. Crop Sci. 22:631–637.
Edmeades, G. O., M. Bänziger, J. Bolaños, D. Beck, and A. Ortega. (1997a). Development and
per se performance of CIMMYT maize populations as droughttolerant sources. In
Developing drought- and low N-tolerant maize, proceedingsof a symposium, 25–29 March
1996, edited by G. O. Edmeades, M. Bänziger, H. R. Mikleson, and C. B. Pena-Valdivia,
254–262. El Batan, Mexico: International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center
(CIMMYT).
Fakorede, M. A. B., J. M. Fajemisin, J. L. Ladipo, S. O. Ajala, and S. K. Kim. 2003.
Development and regional deployment of streak virus resistant maize germplasm: an
overview. In Plant virology in sub-Saharan Africa. Proceedings of a conference organized
by IITA, 4–8 June 2001, edited by J. A. Hughes and B. O. Odu, 503–516. Ibadan, Nigeria:
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture.
Hallauer, A. R. 1991. Use of genetic variation for breeding population in crosspollinated species.
In Proceedings of symposium on Plant Breeding in the 1990s, North Carolina State
University, 10–14 March, Raleigh, edited by H. T. Stalker and J. P. Murphy, 1–4.
Menkir, A., and A. O. Akintunde. 2001. Evaluation of the performance of maize hybrids,
improved open pollinated and farmers’ local varieties under well watered and drought-stress
conditions. Maydica 46:227–238.
SAS Institute. 2002. Statistical analysis software (SAS), version 9.2. Cary, NC: SAS Institute.
PGB48
INDUCED MUTATION FOR IMPROVED YIELD ASSOCIATED TRAITS IN SESAME
(SESAMUM INDICUM L.)
*Nura, S.1*, Adamu, A.K.2, Mu’Azu, S.2, Dangora, D.B.2 and Shehu, K.3
1
School of Basic and Remedial Studies, Ahmadu Bello University, Funtua, Nigeria.
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
3
Kano State College of Arts, Science and Remedial Studies, Kano, Nigeria.
*Corresponding email: salisunura40@yahoo.com
.
ABSTRACT
Artificial induction of mutation through the applications of various concentrations of colchicine
on sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) was carried out with the aim of improving some agronomic
traits that are of economic interest. Seeds of sesame (Sesamum indicum var. Ex-Sudan) were
treated at five different colchicine concentrations (0.1Mm, 0.5mM, 1.0mM, 2.0mM and 0.0mM
as control) for two mutant generations (M1 and M2). The results obtained following colchicine
treatment in all the mutant generations revealed highly significant improvements (P≤0.01) in the
desirable agronomic characters among the mutants such as the percentage germination (1 WAP),
seedlings height, root length, height at maturity, number of leaves/plant, leaf area, number of
pods/plant and number of seeds/pod with decrease in colchicine concentrations. However, the
seedlings height and number of seeds/pod in M2 increased significantly (P≤0.05) with decrease
in the colchicine concentrations. But no significant difference was found in the effect of the
mutagen on germination percents (2 WAP) of the M1. Colchicine was therefore found to induce
beneficial mutation in sesame by improving some of its agronomic traits. We therefore
recommended the use of lower concentrations of colchicine (0.1mM and 0.5mM concentrations)
for improving sesame agronomic traits that are of significant interest.
Key words: Agronomic Traits, Colchicine, Ex-Sudan, Mutation.
INTRODUCTION
Sesame (Sesamum indicum) commonly called beniseed in Nigeria belongs to the plant family
Pedaliaceae (Purseglove, 1968; Pham et al., 2011; Abu et al., 2012). The name sesame is used in
literature worldwide. It is mentioned in the old Hebrew and Egyptian scripts and the ancient
Sanskrit literature. Some of the earliest references to sesame culture were made by the ancient
Greek writers Theophrastus (4th century B.C.) and Solon (7th century B.C.) (Yermanos et al.,
1964). It is also known as “simsim” in East Africa, “Till” in India and “Gingely” in Sri-Lanka.
The Hausa, Ibo and Yoruba major tribes of Nigeria called it “Ridi”, “Ekuku” and “Isasa”
respectively. Other tribes in Nigeria also have names for it (Abu et al., 2011, Busari et al., 2005).
Oplinger et al. (1990) indicated it to be highly prized oilseed crop in Babylon and Assyria about
4,000 years ago. It is ranked as sixth most important oilseeds crops in the world (Olowe et al.,
2010). Sesame is therefore an important oil seed crop which has been cultivated in tropical and
subtropical areas of Asia and Africa since 3050-3500 B.C (Bedigian and Harlan, 1986; Mondal
et al., 2010). Sesame is one of the most important oil-seeds crops that were of African origin
(Bedigian, 2003). A member of the family Pedaliaceae, sesame is grown all over the world for its
leaf (Mann et al., 2003) used as vegetable and oily seeds (Burkill, 1997). Sesame oil is a source
of vitamins, minerals and proteins (Pamplona-Roger, 1999).
Nigeria is among the major sesame exporting countries (Weiss, 1971) exporting 50,000 tons of
sesame annually (FAO, 2010). But despites all the tremendous benefits of sesame, its cultivation
and uses are not up to expectations. This is due to decreased in price coupled with high agronomic
in-puts needed for its cultivation that are attributable to lack of high yielding varieties. More so, the
cultivation of improved varieties is limited due to insufficient variety information. The farmers
continue to grow local varieties with low yields. These constraints contributed immensely to the
decline in sesame production in Nigeria. Therefore, efforts are needed to improve sesame varieties in
order to meet the needs of the world's growing population.
Mutation (a change in genetic material of an organism) induced both in seeds and vegetatively
propagated crops are of scientific and commercial interest to improve both the growth and yield
parameters of economic plants. It provides raw materials for the genetic improvement of economic
crops (Adamu et al., 2004). It facilitates the isolation, identification and cloning of genes which would
ultimately help in designing crops with improved yield, increased stressed tolerance, and longer life
span and reduced agronomic in-puts (Ahloowalia and Maluszynski, 2001). Induced mutations
facilitate the development of improved varieties at a swifter rate (Maluszynski, 1990). Besides
the vital roles in plant breeding programs, induced mutations have been used to induce beneficial
genetic modification that is utilized in improving yield components of various crops. Although
various mutagens are known to induce mutation in plants, this research made use of colchicine (a
poisonous alkaloid from autumn crocus plant (Colchicum autumnale) on sesame (Sesamum indicum L.
var. Ex-Sudan) to improve the quantitative traits that are of agronomic interest.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The research was conducted in the Botanical Garden of the Department of Biological Sciences,
Ahmadu Bello University Zaria (Lat110N, Long 70 421E) in 2007 and 2008 growing seasons.
The seeds of sesame (S. indicum L. Var. Ex-Sudan) were obtained from the Jigawa State
Agricultural and Rural Development Authority (JARDA) Ringim. The seeds were treated at five
different colchicine concentrations including control (0.1mM, 0.5Mm, 1.0mM, 2.0mM and
0.0mM) via soaking for four hours and washed thoroughly in running water for an hour. The
treated seeds were sown in a plot with three blocks in a Randomized Complete Block Design
(RCBD) with three replications. All cultural practices followed the protocols described in the
Kano State Agricultural and Rural Development Authority (KNARDA) crop production guide
(2005). Data were collected from the percentage germinations One Week After Planting (1WAP)
and Two Weeks After Planting (2 WAP), seedlings height, root length, height at maturity,
number of leaves/plant, leaf area, number of pods/plants, and number of seeds/pods. Analysis of
Variance was used to analyze the data obtained, while Duncan’s Multiple Range Test was used
to separate the treatment means.
RESULTS
The results obtained for the analysis of variance in the M1 generation following treatment of the sesame
seeds with various colchicine concentrations revealed highly significant difference (P≤0.01) in almost
all the selected agronomic traits except on the germination percents in two weeks after planting (Table
1).
Table1: M1 Mean Squares for the Effects of Colchicine on Sesame Agronomic Traits
Sources
of
Variatio
n
Df
%
Germin
ation (1
WAP)
%
Germin
ation (2
WAP)
Seedlin
gs
Height
(cm)
Root
Length
(cm)
Height
at
Maturit
y
(cm)
Number
of
Leaves /
Plant
Leaf
Area
(cm2)
Number
of
Pods/Pl
ant
Number
of
Seeds/P
od
Blocks
2
4.01**
0.02ns
18.66**
11.85**
85.96**
18.70 ns
33.36**
5.85**
21.10 ns
Concent
ration
4
9.70**
0.48ns
243.60*
*
8.02**
528.00*
*
334.34*
*
391.53*
*
61.73**
473.49*
*
Error
208
0.38
0.39
1.67
0.80
9.88
8.60
40.01
0.56
29.23
Keys: ns= No significant difference
**= Highly significant difference (P≤0.01)
* = Significant difference (P≤0.05)
The mean effects of the mutagen on the agronomic traits of sesame are presented in Table 2. The result
showed that 96-100% of the mutants germinated after one week of planting, but after two weeks,
77.83-88.83% of the mutants were found to be germinated. Similarly, the mutants at seedlings stage
attained a mean height of 33.54-36.85 cm, with a root length of 6.33-7.10 cm. More so, the mutants
attained a mean height of 76.33-82.67 cm at matured stage. Furthermore, the mutagen increased the
number and size of the leaves from 17 to 25 leaves and 39.67cm2 to 56.00 cm2 respectively. Similarly,
the pods number and seeds produced in each pod increased among the mutants from 3 to 5 pods with
57-67 seeds/pod. The effects of the mutagen increase with decrease in its concentration.
Table 2: M1 Mean Effects of Different Colchicine Concentrations on Sesame
%
%
Seedlings
Root
Height at Number
Leaf
Germinat
Germinat
Concentr
of
Height
Length
Maturity
Area
ion
ion (2
ation
Leaves/
(cm)
(cm)
(cm)
(cm2)
(1WAP)
WAP)
Plant
Number
of Pods/
Plant
Number
of Seeds/
Pod
0.0 mM
86.67c*1
72.17a
30.31e
5.67c
60.33c
17.40d
39.67e
3.00e
50.67c
0.1 mM
100.00a
88.83a
36.85a
7.10a
82.67a
25.40a
56.00a
5.40a
66.67a
0.5 mM
100.00a
83.33a
35.71b
7.00a
81.33a
23.00b
53.33b
4.27b
60.00ba
1.0 mM
95.50b
77.83a
34.43c
6.67ba
78.00ba
21.80b
51.00c
3.73c
58.33b
2.0 mM
95.50b
77.83a
33.54d
6.33b
76.33ab
20.00c
49.00d
3.40d
57.33b
95.53
79.99
34.17
6.55
75.73
21.52
49.80
3.96
58.60
2.47
2.82
1.11
0.26
4.01
1.35
5.57
0.42
2.56
MEAN
.S.E±
N.B: *1 Means within the columns with the same letter(s) are not significantly different (P≤0.05)
However, the results from the analysis of variance of the M2 generation following treatment of sesame
seeds with different colchicines concentrations are presented in Table 3. The result indicated highly
significant difference (P≤0.01) in the effect of different colchicine concentration on the selected
agronomic traits of sesame; except in the seedlings height and number of seeds/pod where the effect is
significant (P≤0.05).
Sources of
Variation
Df
Blocks
2
Table 3: M2 Mean Squares for the Effects of Different Colchicine Concentrations on Sesame Agronomic Traits
Seedlings
Root
Height at
%
%
Height
Length
Maturity
Germination
Germination
Number of
Leaf Area
Number of
(1 WAP)
(2 WAP)
(cm)
(cm)
(cm)
Leaves/Plant
(cm2)
Pods/Plant
1.07 ns
0.72 ns
2489.40**
71.00**
112453.00**
39918.10**
73765.40**
13442.00**
Number of
Seeds/ Pod
8615.10**
Concentration
Error
4
4.81**
1.38 ns
43.63*
7.00**
1357.60**
7342.80**
4416.30**
1200.00**
287.90*
208
0.32
0.62
9.97
0.99
55.51
135.37
293.80
51.04
87.85
Keys: ns= No significant difference
(P≤0.01)
* = Significant difference (P≤0.05)
**= Highly significant difference
However, the M2 generation results of the mean effect of different colchicine concentration on
the selected agronomic traits of Ex-Sudan are presented in Table 4. The results revealed that, 9398% of the mutants germinated after one week of planting which reduced to 68.83-73.33% after
two weeks. The mutants were found to attain a mean seedlings height of 17.13-18.20 cm. The
mutants’ roots were found to be 5.48-5.70 cm deep with a mean height of 72.87-82.93 cm at
maturity. More so, the mutants produced large number of leaves which are bigger than those of
the controls. Similarly, the mutants produced large number of pods that produced large number
of seeds than the controls. The effect of the mutagen is concentration dependent and decreases
with increase in concentration.
Table 4: M 2 Mean Effects of Different Colchicine Concentrations on Variety Ex-Sudan
%
%
Seedlings
Root
Height at Number
Leaf
Number
Germinat
Germinat
Concentr
of
Height
Length
Maturity
Area
of
Pods/
ion (1
ion (2
ation
Leaves/
2
(cm)
(cm)
(cm)
(cm
)
Plant
WAP)
WAP)
Plant
Number
of Seeds/
Pod
0.0 mM
84.50c*1
76.67a
14.93b
4.90c
65.73d
41.13c
41.07d
13.33c
40.47b
0.1 mM
97.83a
68.83b
18.20a
5.70a
82.93a
72.60a
66.47a
26.40a
45.53a
0.5 mM
95.50ba
71.17a
16.47ba
5.95a
75.60b
68.27a
52.13cb
25.80a
45.87a
1.0 mM
95.50ba
73.33ba
17.13a
5.60ba
73.27cb
61.47b
53.27b
19.67b
45.47a
2.0 mM
MEAN
S.E±
93.33b
72.17b
14.27b
5.48b
72.87c
58.53b
50.47c
18.67b
48.53a
93.33
72.43
16.20
5.53
74.08
60.40
52.48
20.77
45.17
2.33
1.28
0.72
0.17
2.76
5.41
4.66
2.42
1.30
N.B: *1 Means within the columns with the same letter(s) are not significantly different (P≤0.05)
DISCUSSION
Artificial induction mutation technique has provided the development of new genotypes with desirable
agronomic traits. The results obtained in this research implied that colchicine at various
concentrations can improve quantitative traits of sesame. The increased mean germination
percent after one week of planting due to colchicine revealed the effects of the mutagen in the
germination process. This was in agreement with the findings of Ulmalkar et al. (1998) who
reported high germination percentages in Capsicum annum due to Sodium Azide treatment but
was in contrast to the work of Bird and Neuffer (1988) who reported reduction in the
germinating rates in plants treated with mutagen. Germination been one of the critical stages
required by sesame for its optimal growth as reported by Uzo (1998) was improved through the
use of colchicines mutagenesis. Chemical mutagenesis through the application of colchicines
increases the germination potentiality of sesame seeds; probably by stimulating the rates of
enzymatic activities, facilitating the water absorption capacity of the seeds, by turning-on the
genes responsible for controlling the seeds germination or by a combination of both. More so,
the mean increase in height and roots length of sesame induced by colchicine at both seedlings
and matured stages were due to the alteration of their genome integrated by environmental
signals as reported by Uno et al. (2001); probably by increasing the rates of cellular division and
expansion at their meristematic regions. This was in agreement with the findings of Hoballah
(1999) who reported increased in plant heights of sesame due to mutagenesis; but was in contrast
to the findings of Anandakumar and Sree-Rangasamy (1995) who reported decreased in plant
height due to induced mutation in rice.
Leaves attributes such as size and number were also improved by colchicine. Increased leaf area
in the sesame mutants was in agreement with the findings of Maluszynski et al. (2001) who
reported increase in leaf area among Zea mays mutants. The increase in leaf area provides an
increase in the surface area for gaseous ex-change which has considerable effect on the process
of photosynthesis (Lockhart et al.,1996). The mutagen stimulated growth of the cells of the
lamina causing its remarkable expansion. This finding was in agreement with that of Nura et
al.(2011) who reported increase in the number of leaves among jute mutants due to chemical
mutagenesis.
The mean increase in the number of pods produced per plant in sesame was in agreement with
the work of Hoballah (1999) who reported increase in the number of capsules per plant among
sesame mutants. Similarly, Ulmalkar et al. (1998) reported induced variability in number of
seeds/pod in Capsicum annum due to induced mutation sodium azide. This was also similar to
the work of Lonnig (1982) who discovered similar result among X-rays induced mutants of pea.
CONCLUSION
Artificial induction of mutation using colchicines was found to have beneficial effects on sesame. It
was concluded that artificial induction of mutation through the application of different concentrations
of colchicine improves the quantitative traits of sesame that are of economic interests.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors acknowledge the assistance of the Department of Biological Sciences, Ahmadu
Bello University Zaria for the assistance in carrying out this research and appreciate the financial
assistance granted by the MacArthur Foundation, ABU,Zaria.
REFERENCES
Abu, G. A., Abah, D., and Adogwu, O. S. (2012): Analysis of cost and return for sesame
production in Nasarawa state: Implication for sustainable development in Nigeria.
Journal of Sustainable Development in Africa. 13 (3):238-249.
Adamu, A. K. 1992. Irradiation induced mutation in popcorn (Zea mays var. Praecoxsturt)
An M.Sc thesis (Unpublished) Dept. of Biol Sciences, ABU Zaria pp1-130.
Adamu, A. K., Chung, S.S., and Abubakar, S. 2004. The effect of ionizing radiation (Gamma
rays) on tomato (s.n.), Nig. Journal of Expt. Biol, 5(2):185-193
Ahloowalia, B.S. and Maluszynski, M. 2001. Induced mutation: A new paradigm in plant
breeding, Euphytica, 118:167-173.
Anandakumar, C. R. and Sree-Rangasamy, S. R. 1995. Heterosis and selection indices in rice.
Egypt J. Genet Cytol 14:123-132.
Bedigian, D., and Harlan, J.R. (1986): Evidence for cultivation of sesame in the ancient world.
Econ. Bot. 40(2): 137-154.
Bedigian, D. 2003. Evolution of sesame revisited: domestication, diversity and prospects.
Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution 50: 779–787.
Bird, R.M.C.K., and Neuffer, M.G. 1988. Induced mutations in Maize. Plant breeding
reviews 5: 141-178.
Burkill, H.M. 1997. Pedaliaceae In: The Useful Plants of West Tropical Africa: 2nd ed, Vol.
4, Royal Botanic Garden, Kew.
Busari, L.D., Olowe, V.I.O., and Idowu, A.A. 2005. Sesame. In: Idem N.U.A. and Showemimo
F.A. (Eds) Major Legumes and Oil-Seeds of Nigeria: Principles of Production and
Utilization. Institute for Agricultural Research, ABU Zaria, pp 136-167.
Food and Agriculture Organization/FAO 2010. Major Sesame Exporters In: World Status of Sesame.
Retrieved from: http://www.sesamegrowers.org/worldstatusofsesame.htm June 27,2010 pp1.
Hoballah, A. A. 1999. Selection and Agronomic evaluation of induced mutant lines of
sesame. In: Induced Mutations for Sesame Improvement IAEA-TECDOC, IAEA, Vienna, pp
71-84.
KNARDA, Kano state Agricultural and Rural Development Authority/KNARDA 2005. Crop
production guide for extension agents and farmers. pp1-2.
Lockhart, P.J., Steel, M.A., and Larkum, A.W.D. 1996. Gene duplication and the evolution of
photosynthetic reaction centre proteins. FEBS Letters, 385.
Lonnig, W. E. 1982. Dominance, overdominance and epistasis in Pisum sativum L. Theor
Appl Genet 63:255-264.
Maluszynski, M. (1990): Gene manipulation in plant improvement. Vol. 2.
Maluszynski, M., Szarejko, I., Barriga, P., and Balcerzyk, A. (2001): Heterosis in crop mutant
crosses and production of high yielding lines, using doubled haploid systems. Euphytica.
120:387-398.
Mann, A., Gbate, M., and Umar, A.N. 2003. Medicinal and economic Plants of Nupe land.
Jube-evans books and publications, Bida, Niger state pp 212.
Mondal, N., Bhat, K. V., and Srivastava, P. S. (2010): Variation in Fatty Acid Composition in
Indian Germplasm of Sesame. Journal of the American Oil Chemists’ Society 87(11):
1263-1269.
Olowe, V.I.O, Adeyemo, Y.A., and Adeniregun, O.O. (2010): Sesame: The Underexploited
Organic Oilseed Crop. Research and Development Centre (RESDEC), University of
Agriculture, Abeokuta, Nigeria. Pp 1-5.
Oplinger, E.S. Putnam, D.H. Kaminski, A.R. Hanson, C.V. Oelke, E.A. Schulte, E.E. and Doll,
J.D. (1990): Sesame. Alternative field crops manual. University of Wisconsin- Extension,
Cooperative Extension University of Minnesota; Center for Alternative Plant and Animal
Products and the Minnesota Extension Services.
Pamplona-Roger, G.D. 1999. Encyclopedia of medicinal plants, Education and health library;
editorial sofeliz, S.L. Madrid, Spain pp 611-612.
Pham, T. D. (2011): Analyses of Genetic Diversity and Desirable Traits in Sesame (Sesamum
indicum L., Pedaliaceae): Implication for Breeding and Conservation. Doctoral Thesis
(unpublished). Faculty of Landscape Planning, Horticulture and Agricultural Sciences
Department of Plant Breeding and Biotechnology, Alnarp, Swedish University of
Agricultural Sciences.
Ulmalkar,G.V., Yawhare, V., Kashikar, M.K., and Kashikar, S.G.1998. Sodium Azide
induced mutation for quality seed in Capsicum annum L. J. Sci. Food Agric. 66:55-60.
Uno, G., Storey, R., and Moore R. 2001. Principles of Botany. Mc Graw Hill New York 1
-550pp.
Uzo, J.O. 1998. Beniseed: A Neglected oil wealth of Nigeria. Keynote address delivered at the First
National workshop on Beniseed. In: Proc.. pp 1-17.
Weiss, E.A. 1971. Castor, Sesame and Safflower, Leanard Hill pub.London, pp 901.
PGB49
MORPHOLOGICAL EVALUATION OF SESAME (SESAMUM INDICUM)
GERMPLASM FROM FIVE STATES IN NORTHERN NIGERIA
Yahaya S.A.1*, Falusi, O.A.1, Gado, A.A.,2 Daudu, O.A.Y.1 and Abdulkarim, B.M .3
1
Department of Biological Sciences, Federal University of Technology, Minna Niger state.
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Federal College of Education, Kontagora, Niger State,
3
Department of Biological Sciences, Nassarawa State University, Keffi, Nassarawa State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding email: headboy4real004@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Twelve accessions of Sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) germplasm, collected from five states of
northern Nigeria (Kaduna, Niger, Nassarawa, Kogi, and Benue) were evaluated for
morphological characteristics during the cropping season of 2012 at the experimental field of the
Department of Biological Science, Federal University of Technology, Minna using a
Randomized complete Block Design (RCBD). Data WAS collected for Plant height, Length of
petiole, No of leaves/plant, Number of branches per plant and the Leaf surface Area per plant.
While accessions NG01 showed the highest plant height at 2 weeks after planting, accessions
KG01 and NA01 showed the least although all these were not significantly different. Several of
the accessions were identified as showing good attributes for characters such as number of leaves
and numbers of branches which are also yield indicators for both grain and oil. These accessions
are potential candidates for further selection and breeding objectives. The results achieved
therefore can be used for improvement of sesame in the north central part of Nigeria.
Keywords: Accessions; Morphological characteristics; Germplasm; Sesamum indicum L.
INTRODUCTION
Sesame (Sesamum indicum) is an annual plant which is considered one of the most important
and oldest oil crops that belong to the Pedaliaceae family (Noorka et al., 2011). It is considered
to be the oldest oil seed plant and has been under cultivation in Asia for over 5000 years (Bist et
al., 1998). The crop has early origins in East Africa and in India. Today, India and China are the
world's largest producers of sesame, followed by Myanmar, Sudan, Uganda, Nigeria, Pakistan,
Tanzania, Ethiopia, Guatemala and Turkey(Nayar and Mehra, 1970; Bedigian, 2003).
World production fluctuates due to local economic, crop production disturbance and weather
conditions. In Vietnam, sesame is known as the king of oil seeds due to the high oil content (50 –
60%) of its seed. It is widely cultivated as an oil crop in tropical and subtropical climate and it is
mostly grown under moisture stress with low management input by small holders (Cagrgan,
2006). Numerous wild relatives occur in Africa which is believed to be its origin and a small
number in India (Baydar, 1999). In Nigeria, it is often referred to as beniseed and it is widely
used and very popular in parts of north, where it is mostly grown.
The seeds which yield half of their weight in oil are most commonly used in soups while the
young leaves are used as soup vegetable while the stem and oil extracts are used in making local
soups. Traditionally, the seeds are roasted and mixed together with roasted groundnut or used as
soup thickening condiment. (Falusi and Salako, 2001). According to Kobayashi et al., (1990), 36
species have been identified out of which 22 are found in Africa, 5 in Asia, 7 in both Africa and
Asia, and one species each in Crete and Brazil. There are three cytogenetic groups of which
2n=26 consist of the cultivated S. indicum along with S. alatum, S. capense, S.schenckii,
S.malabaricum; 2n=32 consist of S.prostratum, S.laciniatum, S. angolense. S.angustifolium,
while S. radiatum, S. occidentale, S.schinzianum belong to 2n=64. In spite of the presence of
wide range of variability, selection within the local genotypes and hybridization had not resulted
in a considerable achievement towards sesame improvement. However, germplasm exploration
has the potential to increase sources of variability that would provide more genetic diversity for
sesame improvement.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) germplasm accessions used in this study were collected from
local farmers in the growing regions in collaboration with the Agric. Development Project (ADP)
of six states of Northern Nigeria namely Kaduna, Niger, Kogi, Benue, and Nassarawa, of
Nigeria. The materials were laid out in a randomized complete block design with thirty (36) pots
per block replicated three times, making a total of 108 pots. Ten seeds were planted per pot (i.e.
five per hole in a pot).Three weeks after planting; each pot was thinned to two plants per pot.
Data was collected for the following characters: Plant height at 2, and 4weeks after planting and
at maturity, distance from ground level up to the terminal bud on main axis of a plant in cm using
a metre rule, Number of branches per plant, Length of petiole(cm) using a metre rule, Leaf
surface area in cm2, Survival rate at 21 days after planting rated as percentage.
Table 1: Description and sources of sesame germplasm materials
S/N
Accession
lgth (mm)
Number
Local
source
seed
name
colour
colour
of flower
white
1
KD
Riddi
kafanchan/Kaduna
white
2
NG-01
Anufi
paiko/Niger
light brown
3
NG-02
Ishwa
saminaka/Niger
4
NG-03
Esso
5
NG-04
Anufi
6
NA-01
Riddi
katcha/Niger
mayaki/Niger
keffi/Nassarawa
Riddi
keffi/Nassarawa
8
NA-03
white
Riddi
2-3mm
Doma/Nassarawa
BE-01
10
BE-02
3.5mm
11
KG-01
12
KG-02
3mm
Ishwa
Ishwa
gogori
gogorigo
light brown
Black
7
NA-02
3mm
9
light brown
Guma/Benue
creamy white
Brown
Akogu/Kogi
white
white
purple
white
Creamy white
light brown
white
purple
white
plant Height (cm)
2wks
2-3mm
2-3mm
2-3mm
NIL
Table 2: Means of plant height of sesame accessions collected
Accessions
3 mm
2-
white
Creamy white
okpereke/Kogi
3-3.5mm
2-2.5mm
white
white
Guma/Benue
white
Seed
4wks
6wks
KD
4.41 ± 1.05ab
17.89 ± 4.75a
59.13 ± 16.34cd
NG-01
4.71 ± 1.49a
16.97 ± 5.44ab
56.16 ± 15.73cd
NG-02
2.50 ± 0.69ef
16.74 ± 4.99ab
63.40 ± 21.84bc
2mm
33 mm
2-
NG-03
4.11 ± 0.77ab
13.76 ± 4.40bc
54.37 ± 16.62cd
NG-04
2.32 ± 0.79f
7.65 ± 3.63f
46.40 ± 13.72e
NA-01
1.94 ± 1.13f
8.3 ± 2.70ef
73.27 ± 4.86ab
NA-03
3.75 ± 0.84bc
11.90 ± 6.68cd
48.90 ± 14.49cd
BE-01
3.13 ± 0.74de
12.67 ± 4.09cd
75.10 ± 9.56a
BE-02
3.49 ± 1.01cd
11.54 ± 3.96cd
48.90 ± 10.94de
KG-01
2.09 ± 0.7ef
11.02 ± 2.79de
61.50 ± 15.36c
KG-02
3.45 ± 0.92cd
14.67 ± 3.41ab
58.27 ± 17.78cd
*Values are mean±SD. Means followed by the same letter(s) within the same row do not
statistically differ at the 5% level according to DMRT, analyzed for the Accessions collected
Table 3: Means of some morphological parameters of sesame accessions
Accessions
Length of
petiole
No of
leaves/plant
No of branches
plant
Leaf
surface Area
KD
1.42 ± 0.56ab
59.00 ± 29.35bc
4.00 ± 1.89a
NG-01
1.54 ± 0.57a
52.00 ± 16.34bc
3.00 ± 1.16ab
18.77 ± 4.12ab
NG-02
1.32 ± 0.56ab
65.00 ± 31.04b
2.00 ± 0.98bc
19.43 ± 6.42ab
NG-03
1.24 ± 0.33ab
52.00 ± 25.45bc
3.00 ± 1.57ab
17.67 ± 6.42ab
NG-04
1.12 ± 0.27b
34.00 ± 17.95d
1.00 ± 1.26d
13.40 ± 4.97d
NA-01
1.24 ± 0.42ab
96.00 ± 32.88a
4.00 ± 1.38a
16.83 ± 5.39ab
NA-03
1.13 ± 0.40b
40.00 ± 16.45cd
1.47 ± 1.59cd
15.53 ± 8.53bc
BE-01
1.17 ± 0.47a
51.00 ± 16.62bc
2.00 ± 0.79bc
20.33 ± 6.01ab
14.40 ± 5.72cd
BE-02
1.48 ± 0.60ab
39.00 ± 15.84d
1.93 ± 1.48c
15.22 ± 6.99cd
KG-01
1.20 ± 0.51a
52.00 ± 26.30bc
2.18 ± 1.19bc
18.17 ± 5.31ab
KG-02
1.21 ± 0.41ab
52.00 ± 17.50bc
2.00 ± 1.00bc
20.67 ± 7.06a
*Values are mean±SD. Means followed by the same letter(s) within the same row do not
statistically differ at the 5% level according to DMRT, analyzed for the Accessions collected
Fig.1: survival percentages (%±SD) of the different Accessions Collected
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In the present investigation, different quantitative characters were studied to estimate the
variations in all the Sesame accessions collected. Parameters such as plant height, length of
petiole, number of leaves per plant, number of branches per plant, leave surface area and survival
percentage were studied. The Accession , NG01 showed the highest plant height (4.71) at 2
weeks after planting while the least was KG01 (2.32), and NA01 (1.94) respectively, no
significant differences were observed between KD and NG-03 with their means (4.41) and
(4.11). There were no significant differences among the Accessions (p<0.05) level of significant
statistically (Table 2). At 4th week (Table 2), the highest plant height was recorded at KD (17.89)
followed by NG-01 (16.97) and NG-02 (16.74) and KG-02 (14.67) while the least was observed
at NG-04 (7.65) but there are no significant differences among the other accessions at (p<0.05)
level of significance. However, at 6th week, (maturity), there were statistical differences observed
where the highest plant height was recorded at BE-01 (75.10) while the least was observed at
NG-04 (46.40) although there were no significant differences among KD (59.13) NG-01(56.16),
NA-03 (46.90) and KG-02 (58.20) at (p<0.05), significant level, respectively.(Table 2).
The length of petiole showed that NG-01 had the highest mean with petiole length of (1.54)
followed by NG-04 (1.12) and NA-03 (1.13), although there were no significant differences
statistically at p<0.05 level of significant level in other Accessions Table 3. The accession with
the highest number of leaves was observed at NA-01 (96.00) followed by NG-02 with the mean
(65.00) and there are no significant differences statistically among the remaining accessions at
(p<0.05) significant level (Table 3). The Accession NA-01 and KD had the highest number of
branches both having the mean 4.00, the least values for the number of branches was observed
in the Accession NG-04 (13.40) although there were no significant differences statistically at
(p<0.05) significant level among the remaining Accessions (Table 3).
The Result showed that KG-02 had the highest leaf surface area with the mean (20.67a) and the
least was observed from NG-04 (13.40d) but no significant difference was observed among the
remaining accessions at (p<0.05) level of significance(Table 3). The percentages of all the
accessions were taken. The accession NG01 had the highest percentage survival of 76.7% and
the accession NA02 and NG04 had the lowest survival percentage of 2.2% and 11.11%
respectively, although there were no statistical differences at p<0.05 level of significant but they
were different from all other accessions. However, the accession NA03 and NA01 were different
from all other accessions but they are not statistically different at p<0.05 with respect to their
survival percentage of 42.22% and 43.33% respectively. In addition, the Accessions NG02,
BE02, BE01, KG01, KD, KG02 and NG03 are not statistically different at p<0.05 level of
Significant Fig 1. The range of variations observed in some morphological parameters among the
studied accessions like in plant height, number of leaves/plant is in conformity with (Alege et al.,
2013). Alege et al., 2013 studied the morphological, proximate and mineral responses of sesame
to different nutrient sources and observed that only four out of the eleven morphological traits
studied showed significant differences across nutrient sources. These attributes are plant height,
number of leaves, stem diameter, and number of pod per plant. He concluded that these four
attributes are not under strong genetic influences and soil fertility status affects the expression of
these morphological traits because according (Akinyele and Temikotan, 2007). The factors that
may bring about variation in the original genome structure of a species include geographical
isolation, chromosome aberration, infection and variation in edaphic factors. Variations brought
about by infections and edaphic factors result in temporary phenotypic differences and as soon as
the infections and variation in soil conditions are addressed, the differences usually fade away.
E. T. Blay et al., (1999), also studied morphological and agronomic characterization of some
tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) germplasm in Ghana, They observed variations in plant
height among eight accessions collected and that plant height ranged from 28.8 to 41. 8 cm. They
concluded that plant height and other vegetative growth were suppressed probably due to the
harsh environmental conditions during the growth period. This is also in line with the work of
Messiaen (1992) who reported that tomato plant height may vary up to 2m tall. Seymus Furat
and Bulent Uzun (2010), also studied agro-morphological characters for the assessment of
genetic diversity in sesame (Sesamum indicum) and observed that there were variations in
morphological characters such as plant height, number of fruiting branches, and other
morphological characters. They reported that these characters also revealed a large genetic
diversity and that the accessions with a wide range of variation for agronomic characters had
potential to determine the best genotypes for different environments. Toan Duc Pham et al.,
(2010) also studied morphological evaluation of sesame varieties from different origins in
Vietnam and Cambodia. They showed a positive relationship between plant heights, numbers of
branches and seed production and concluded that the results achieved could be used for
improvement of sesame varieties in various regions. These results were in agreement with
previous observations of Varisai and Stephen (1964), Gupta and Gupta (1977), Pathak and Dixit
(1992) that reported a positive relationship between plant height, and other morphological
parameters.
CONCLUSION
The study on twelve sesame accessions collected from North central zones using evidence from
morphological parameters indicated that genetic variability exists among Nigerian sesame. The
diversity could mainly be attributed to diverse agro-climatic conditions in the different regions.
Accessions from different regions were sometimes closely related and accessions from the same
region had different genetic background. The intraregional diversity could be as a valuable
source as interregional diversity for sesame improvement. The germplasm represents a valuable
source of genetic diversity that is expected to be highly useful for future breeding programs.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors gratefully acknowledge Mr and MrS Yahaya I.B and family for their support and
advice, and Prof. O.A Falusi of the Dept of Biological sciences, FUT Minna for supervision.
REFERENCES
Baydar H, Turgut I, Turgut K (1999) Variation of certain characters and line selection for yield,
oil, oleic, and linoleic, acids in the Turkish sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) populations.
Turk J Agric For 23:431-441.
Bedigian D (2003) Evolution of sesame revisited:domestication, diversity and prospects. Genet
Resour Crop Evol. 50: 779-787
Bisht IS, Mahajan RK, Loknathan TR, Agrawal RC (1998) Diversity in Indian sesame collection
and stratification of germplasm accessions in different diversity groups. Genet Resour
Crop Evol. 45: 325-335
Cagrgan MI (2006) Selection and morphological characterization of induced determinate
mutants in sesame.Field Crops Res. 96: 19-24
Falusi AO, Salako EA (2001). Assemblage of sesame germplasm for conservation and genetic
improvement in Nigeria. Plant Genetic Resour. Newslett., 127: 25- 38.
Gupta VK, Gupta YK (1977) Variability, interrelationship and path-coefficient analysis for some
quantitative characters in Sesame. Indian Journal of Heredity 9(1): 31-37.
Kobayashi T, Kinoshita M, Hattori S, Ogawa T, Tsuboi Y, Ishida M, Ogawa S, Saito H (1990)
Development of the sesame metallic fuel performance code. Nucl Technol 89:183–
193
Nayar NM, Mehra KL (1970) Sesame - Its Uses, Botany, Cytogenetics, and Origin. Economic
Botany 24: 20-31
Noorka, I.R., S.I. Hafiz and M.A.S. EL-Bramawy, 2011. Response of sesame to population
densities and nitrogen fertilization on newly reclaimed sandy soils. Pak. J. Bot., 43(4):
1953-1958.
Pathak HC, Dixit SK (1992) Genetic variability and interrelationship studies in black seeded
sesame (Sesamum indicum L.). Madras Agricultural Journal 79: 94-100
Varisai Muhammad S, Stephen Dorairaj M (1964) Correlation studies in Sesamum indicum L.
association between yield and certain yield components in different groups of Sesamum
based on seed colour. Madras Agricultural Journal 51: 73-74
.
PGB52
SOME MORPHOLOGICAL AND REPRODUCTIVE CHARACTERS IN PHASEOLUS
VULGARIS L. AFTER TREATMENT WITH DOSES OF SODIUM AZIDE
Liamngee, S.1 and Kwon-Ndung, E.H.2*
1
Department of Plant Science and Technology, University of Jos, Nigeria.
2
Department of Botany, Federal University, Lafia, Nigeria.
*Corresponding email: kwon_ndung@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Four doses of sodium azide (0.1M, 0.04M, 0,03M and 0.02M) were used to induce mutation in
the seeds of three varieties of Phaseolus vulgaris to study response to induced mutation as well
as creating additional variability among genotypes of the crop using a randomized complete
block design.The following parameters were studied; plant height, number of nodes, number of
leaves, leaf length, leaf breadth, pod length, number of pods per treatment, number of pods per
peduncle and 100 seed weight. Significance was tested at 0.05 level of significance.The red
kidney 0.02M showed the highest mean number of nodes among the red kidney treatments, but
pinto 0.02M and 0.03M showed the highest mean number of nodes all in week 6.The pinto
0.02M showed the highest mean values for height in both weeks 4 and 6. Navy 0.1M on the
other hand showed the least mean values for heights among the treatments. At week 6 all the
pinto treatments surpassed the pinto control. All the navy treatments showed reduced leaf lengths
and leaf breadth. Leaf length in the red kidney 0.03M and 0.02M performed better than the red
kidney control. All the pinto treatments showed increased leaf lengths.The navy and red kidney
treatments showed reductions in their number of trifoliate leaves in week 6. The pinto on the
other hand showed all the pinto treatments increased in their mean number of trifoliate leaves
except the pinto 0.1M which performed below the control in week 6. Apart from pinto 0.02M
which showed the highest mean pod length, all the other pinto treatments performed lower than
the pinto control. Navy and red kidney treatments had reductions in their mean number of pods
per treatment, the pinto treatment had pinto 0.03M, 0.04M, 0.02M perform better than the pinto
control. navy 0.1M had the least number of pods.
INTRODUCTION
Phaseolus is the most important legume worldwide for direct human consumption (Gepts, 2001)
and a major protein and mineral source (Blair et al., 2007). It is a herbaceous annual which is
highly variable in terms of morphology (Purseglove, 1974) hence, its numerous names are based
on its use, growth habits or morphology. Erect bushy or twining types are observed (Liamngee,
2006) and germination is the epigeal type (Raven, et al., 1992). The leaves are alternately
arranged and divided into three oval acuminate and entire leaflets. The leaves are trifoliate,
petiolate and stipulate. The young leaves are used as a vegetable. The flowers are zygomorphic
and can be white pink or purple. Phaseolus is grown for its immature edible pods which show
colourations of green purple, yellow and black, for the dry ripe seeds and to a lesser extent for
the green shelled beans (Nasser, et al., 2010).
The medicinal uses of Phaseolus vulgaris are numerous and include a mild diuretic effect and
contains a substance which reduces blood sugar especially in the unripe pods. Also there is
research evidence that the regular consumption of beans reduces significantly blood cholesterol
levels and lowers the risk of heart disease by about 22% (Rosa et al., 1998). Also a bean diet has
significantly reduced the risk for chronic diseases such as coronary heart disease, diabetes
mellitus, obesity and cancer (Geil et al., 1994).
The alteration of gene sequencies may be targeted or non targeted disruptions (Tierney et al.,
2005). This variations could be in increased yield, enhanced fitness in the ability to resist pest or
disease, and to successfully endure both biotic and abiotic stress. Usually, both sporophytic
(vegetative) and gametophytic(reproductive) parts of the plant of concern could be treated with
the mutagen (Jain, 2010). Even though seeds have shown better results. The genetic
modifications of plants using various methods have been going on for well over 80 years. This is
loosely known as genetic engineering and it is critical for the understanding of the functions of
genes and also the biological nature of DNA damage and repair. It has been demonstrated that
genetic variability could be induced through mutations and it’s practical value in plant
improvement programmes well established (Kulthe, et al., 2011), as a result a large number of
plants useful to man have a developed by mutation breeding
Sodium azide acts by producing metabolites which initiate base substitutions (Alqurainy, et al.,
2009). The proteins hereafter produced does not have the same function as the original one
(Alqurainy, et al., 2009). The effect of sodium azide as mutagen on legumes and especially
Phaseolus vulgaris have been properly documented. It was used to successfully generate useful
economic traits such as days to maturity, number of pods per plant and number of seeds per
plant amongst others in Cicer arietenum (Kulthe, et al., 2011), in groundnut (Mensah, et al.,
2007) and many other crops. Considerable breeding work has already been done on Phaseolus
vulgaris seeking to by various breeding tools express various genes of interest already contained
in the genome of the plant. It is a self pollinating and posses limited variability. Because of its
small genome, its genetic variation has become easily exhausted. Creating desired genes where
and when they are needed has become the breeder’s most viable option. This study was therefore
designed to study the response of the plant to induced mutation while creating additional
variability among genotypes of the crop.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study was conducted at the Mista-Ali Fadama Experimental site located on the outskirts of
Jos, the Plateau state capital. The area has a mean annual temperature 26.810c and a mean annual
relative humidity of 82.29%, it is elevated above sea level by 1,220m and it is aligned along
longitude 8053’E and latitude 9057’N (Obigbesan, 1978).
The seeds used for this study were cultivars of Phaseolus vulgaris identified with respect to their
colour, shape and size of seeds were obtained from local seed merchants. They were tagged as
follows: Variety 1 (V1) = pinto (black in colour),Variety 2 (V2) = Red Kidney (red in colour) and
Variety 3 (V3) = Navy (white in colour). The experiment was laid out in a randomized complete
block design using a plot size of 14.8m X 8.5m, divided into three blocks. Each block had 1 row
of 15 plots making a total of 45 plots for the three blocks. Four doses of the mutagen were
applied in the following concentrations; Dose 1(D1) =
0.1M, Dose 2 (D2) =
0.02M,
Dose 3(D3) =
0.03M, Dose 4 (D4) =
0.04M, Control(D0) =
No treatment.
There were twelve treatment combinations and the experimental site was neatly cleared out and
the beds raised for planting of seeds. The seeds were planted 15 per plot, in 3 rows and 5
columns on the 12th of November, 2012. The seeds planted to a depth of 2.5m (Purseglove,
1974). The whole experimental site was weeded on week 4 and week 8. The plants were sprayed
with insecticides on the 46th and 47th Days After Planting (DAP) to kill insect pests. The plants
were watered 3 times weekly till harvest.
Pinto, Red kidney and Navy (Phaseolus vulgaris) seeds were pre-soaked in distilled water up to
ten times their volume, according to their varieties for 6 hours. While they were soaking, the
mutagen solutions were prepared for four doses (D1 = 0.1M, D2 = 0.02M, D3 = 0.03M, D4 =
0.04M) for each of the 3 varieties. After soaking, the seeds were air dried for 20 minutes then
soaked in the mutagen solutions according to their varieties for 11/2 hours.
After
the
treatment time was over (11/2hours) the seeds were washed under running water for 30 minutes
and immediately taken to the field for planting.
The heights of 6 randomly selected plants were measured. The measurement been from the
ground to the highest plant part above the ground were taken with an inextensible string and
related to a metre rule to obtain a numerical value in centimetres. The number of nodes of 6
randomly selected plants was counted for each treatment and the results recorded. All the leaves
for six randomly selected plants, for each treatment were counted for all the treatments and their
results were recorded. The length of the terminal leaflet of the trifoliate leaf at the fourth node
was measured for six randomly selected plants per treatment at the seventh week after planting.
The results were recorded. The breadth of the terminal leaflet of trifoliate leaf at the fourth node
was measured for six randomly selected plants per treatment at the seventh week after planting.
The results were recorded. The length of pods for 6 pods of 5 randomly selected plants per
treatment were measured and the results recorded. The total number of pods on 5 randomly
selected plants for each treatment were counted and the results recorded.
The number of pods on three peduncles were counted for 5 randomly selected plants per
treatment. The results were recorded. One hundred randomly selected seeds were weighed on an
electronic balance to determine the 100 seed weight of each treatment. This was done three times
for each treatment to obtain a mean value which was recorded.
RESULTS
Table 1: Some Morphological Characters of M1 Phaseolus vulgaris Plants
Number
of Mean
Nodes for week s
4
Navy 0.02M
2.33a
Number
Nodes
week 6
of Mean
for
Red
kidney 0.00a
0.04M
kidney 3.50ab
Heights(cm)
for week 4
Mean
s
Heights(cm)
for week 6
Mean
s
Navy 0.1M
12.00a
Navy 0.1M
19.50a
Red
0.1M
kidney 2.50a
Red
0.1M
Red kidney 12.12a
0.03M
Red kidney 20.75a
0.03M
Red
0.02M
kidney 4.71b
Red
kidney 4.00abc Red kidney 13.50a
0.03M
0.04M
Red kidney 23.25a
b
0.04M
Red
0.03M
kidney 5.00bc
Navy 0.1M
5.00abc Red kidney 14.50a
0.1M
Red kidney 24.00a
b
0.1M
Red
kidney 5.00bc
Pinto 0.1M
5.22abc Red
Red
kidney 15.00a
kidney 26.00a
0.04M
Navy 0.1M
5.50bcd Navy 0.04M
d
0.02M
9.16
Navy 0.02M
15.75a
Red kidney 30.35a
bc
control
9.25abc Navy 0.04M
16.16a
Navy 0.04M
0.02M
abcd
Navy 0.04M
5.83bcd Navy 0.03M
d
Pinto 0. 04M
Navy 0.03M
6.44bcd Pinto 0.04M
6.62bcd Navy control
Navy control
9.44abc Navy control
18.80a
d
b
10.06a
19.87a
Pinto control
Navy 0.03M
6.87bcd Pinto control
Pinto 0.03M
Red
control
7.00cd
kidney 7.14cd
Red
kidney 12.57b
cd
0.02M
Pinto 0.03M
14.44b
cd
Pinto control
7.33d
Navy 0.02M
Pinto control
d
Pinto 0.02M
7.66d
Pinto 0.02M
16.
33d
24.
16bc
Navy 0.03M
24.44b
Pinto 0.03M
64.50d
e
24.94b
Pinto 0.1M
65.77d
e
25.22b
Pinto 0.04M
68.
94de
Pinto 0.02M
91.38c
c
Pinto 0.02M
52.22c
d
c
14.88c
52.16b
cd
c
Pinto 0.1M
50.23b
cd
b
Pinto 0.04M
46.75a
bc
Navy control
6.66bcd Red
kidney 11.21b
cd
control
12.05b
Navy 0.02M
Red kidney 19.07a
b
control
cd
Pinto 0.1M
42.33a
bc
bcd
Pinto 0.03M
b
30.72c
* Mean(s) followed by the same letters are not significantly different from each other
Some Morphological Characters of M1 Phaseolus vulgaris Plants (Cont’d)
Leaf
length(cm)
Mean
s
Leaf
Width(cm)
Navy 0.02M
3.50a
Red kidney 3.25a
0.1M
Red
0.1M
kidney 4.50a
Navy 0.1M
4.75ab
Mean
s
Number of Mean
trifoliate
s
leaves for wk
4
Number
of Means
trifoliate
leaves for wk
6
Red kidney 0.50a
0.1M
Red
0.1M
Red
kidney 7.50ab
0.03M
Navy 0.02M
3.25a
Red kidney 2.33ab
0.04M
Navy 0.1M
4.75ab
Red kidney 3.00abc Red
0.03M
0.0M
kidney 3.00a
kidney 8.33abc
Navy 0.03M
7.37bc
Navy 0.04M
5.50abc Navy 0.03M
3.00abc Navy 0.1M
Navy 0.04M
7.41bc
Navy 0.03M
5.62bc
3.50abc Red
kidney 10.71abc
d
de
0.02M
Navy 0.1M
9.00abcd
Red
kidney 8.16cd
0.04M
Red kidney 6.33bc
0.04M
Red kidney 3.75abc Navy 0.03M
d
0.02M
11.57abc
8.55cd
Red kidney 6.50bc
0.03M
Navy 0.02M
5.00bc
12.00abc
Red kidney 6.71bc
control
Pinto 0.02M
Navy control
Pinto control
8.77cd
Red
kidney 9. 17cd Navy control
control
6.90bc
9.46cd
6.95bc
Pinto 0.1M
Navy 0.04M
d
de
de
6.00cde Navy 0.02M
14.44bcd
e
Navy control
6.00cde Pinto 0.1M
15.66bcd
e
Pinto control
Pinto 0.03M
6.500c
Pinto control
de
16.41bcd
e
Red
kidney 9.75cd
0.03M
Pinto 0.04M
7.30d
Pinto control
6.61cde Red
kidney 16.56bcd
e
control
10.50d
Pinto 0.03M
7.46d
Navy 0.04M
6.66de
Pinto 0.03M
Pinto 0.02M
16.77bcd
e
Pinto 0.04M
10.75d
Red
kidney 10.83d
0.02M
Pinto 0.02M
10.95d
Pinto 0.02M
7.65d
Red kidney 7.66d
0.02M
Pinto 0.1M
7.72d
Pinto 0.1M
6.70de
Pinto 0.04M
19.05cde
Pinto 0.04M
7.00de
Pinto 0.03M
19.61de
Navy control
20.25e
Red kidney 7.85e
control
* Mean(s) followed by the same letters are not significantly different from each other
Table 2: Some Yield Related Traits of M1 Phaseolus vulgaris Plants
Pods per Mea
peduncle
ns
Pinto 0.1M
Pod
Mean
lengths(cm) s
1.00a Red Kidney 10.83a
0.03M
Seeds
pod
per Mea
ns
Pinto 0.1M
Pods
per Mean
treatment
s
5.50a Navy 0.1M
8.66a
Red kidney 1.00a Red Kidney 11.56a
b
0.1M
0.02M
Pinto 0.04M 5.50a Red kidney 11.66a
0.1M
Red kidney 1.00a Navy
Pinto
11.70a
5.60a Red kidney 34.00a
100 seeds Mea
weight
ns
Navy
0.03M
14.9
4a
Navy
0.04M
15.2
6a
Navy 0.1M
15.3
0.02M
0.03M
b
control
b
0.03M
Red kidney 1.00a Red kidney 12.20b Pinto 0.02M 5.66a Navy
c
b
0.04M
0.04M
0.02M
b
39.00a
b
7a
Navy
0.02M
16.9
1b
Navy 0.1M
1.00a Red kidney 12.33b Pinto 0.03M 5.73a Red kidney 39.33a
cd
bc
b
0.1M
0.02M
Redkidney0
.04M
19.1
9c
Navy
0.02M
1.00a Red kidney 12.76b Navy
cde
control
0.04M
Redkidney
0.1M
19.2
7c
Navy
0.03M
1.00a Pinto 0.1M
13.04c
Navy
control
19.3
3c
Pinto
0.03M
1.03a Navy
0.04M
13.10c
Pinto
0.02M
1.03a Navy
control
13.23c
Navy
control
1.03a Pinto 0.04M 13.43c
Pinto
0.04M
1.04a Navy
0.02M
13.45c
Red kidney 1.05a Pinto
b
0.03M
0.03M
de
1.06a Navy 0.1M
Pinto
control
1.15a Pinto
b
control
b
Red kidney 54.00a
b
0.04M
6.50c Navy
d
0.03M
63.00a
b
Redkidney
control
19.5
0c
Navy
control
6.75
171.6
6abc
Redkidney0
.03M
20.3
1cd
Red kidney 6.78
d
0.1M
Red kidney 205.0
control
0bcd
Redkidney0
.02M
21.5
6d
Red kidney 6.86
de
control
Pinto 0.1M
de
277.3
3cde
Pinto 0.02M 38.3
7e
13.50c
Navy 0.1M
331.3
3cde
Pinto 0.03M 39.4
6e
de
de
13.50d Navy
e
0.02M
d
Navy
control
7.57e Pinto
f
control
7.83f
Pinto 0.02M 361.6
6de
Pinto 0.1M
13.80e
Red kidney 7.85f
0.02M
Pinto 0.04M 376.6
6de
Pinto 0.04M 41.3
0f
Pinto 0.02M 13.82e
Red kidney 7.95f
0.04M
Pinto 0.03M 391.3
3e
Pinto
control
b
Red kidney 1.20
b
control
Red kidney 6.39
bcd
0.03M
40.66a
Navy
0.03M
de
de
Navy
0.04M
6.17a Navy
bcd
0.04M
* Mean(s) followed by the same letters are not significantly different from each other
DISCUSSION
In the navy treatment, navy 0.02M had the least mean number of nodes in the week 4. By week
6, it had the second highest mean number of nodes, next to pinto 0.02M. The navy treatments
generally showed a reduction in their number of nodes as all of them performed below the navy
control. This reduction in the number of nodes in the navy treatments could be due to the
decrease in heights observed in the treatment as a result of the doses of sodium azide. In the
week 6, navy 0.02M surpassed the navy control in the number of nodes. All the red kidney
treatments also showed a reduction of the mean number of nodes in the week 4. In the week 6,
the red kidney 0.02M surpassed the red kidney control even though the difference was not
significant.
41.2
3f
43.4
2g
In the pinto treatments, the Pinto 0.02M surpassed the pinto control in height for both week 4
and week 6 and also showed the highest mean values for heights for both weeks. The navy 0.1M
on the other hand showed the lowest mean values for heights for both week 4 and 6.In week 4,
only the pinto 0.02M showed a statistically significant and positive shift over the pinto control.
By the week 6, all the other pinto treatments (pinto 0.03M,0.1M, pinto 0.04M, pinto 0.02M)
surpassed pinto control with pinto 0.02M showing the highest gains in height. Kulthe, et al.,
(2011) also reported that at 0.02% of sodium azide, Cicer arietenum showed significant and
positive increase in heights. This increase in heights could be due to the increase in the rates of
cellular division and expansion at their meristematic regions (Nura, et al., 2011).
Apart from week 4 where Navy 0.02M showed the maximum reduction in height, all the navy
treatments were all next to only red kidney 0.1M showing maximum reduction in heights without
the control. Kulthe, et al., (2011) also observed that maximum reduction in seedling heights was
obtained when sodium azide was used, comparatively. This suggests that sodium azide may be
used in the reduction in heights of certain varieties. Reduced seedling height at higher mutagenic
concentrations may occur due to gross injury caused at cellular level either due to acute
chromosomal aberrations or gene controlled biochemical processes or both (Kulthe, et al., 2011).
All the navy treatments showed reduced leaf lengths. In the red kidney treatments, red kidney
0.03M and red kidney 0.02M performed better than the control. All the pinto treatments showed
positive increase in their leaf lengths.In the leaf breadth all the pinto treatments also showed
positive and significant shifts. This may suggest that sodium azide can be used in successfully
increasing the leaf size and of the pinto variety of Phaseolus vulgaris.
The navy treatments also all showed reductions in their leaf breadths. It may be recalled that all
the navy treatments also showed reductions in their leaf lengths. Thus the use of sodium azide to
reduce leaf size in the navy variety of Phaseolus vulgaris where necessary may yield good
results.
Leaf length or width is usually associated with leaf area which is important for photosynthesis.
Generally, a larger leaf area corresponds to more exposure to sunlight which means more
photosynthetic activity in the plant for the production of more plant food. The number of
trifoliate leaves reduced for each of the red kidney treatments, the red kidney control showing the
highest mean number of trifoliate leaves in week 4. Red kidney 0.1M, 0.04M and 0.03M were
the least of the treatments with respect to their mean leaf numbers in week 4. By week 6, the
treatments with the least mean number of leaves did not change. Nevertheless, Navy control now
had the highest mean number of leaves for week 6.
All the red kidney treatments also showed a reduction in their number of leaves in week 6. The
navy treatments also performed less than navy control, while all the pinto treatments performed
better than the pinto control except pinto 0.1M which showed a mean number of leaves slightly
lower than the pinto control all in week 6. Generally the mutagen was effective in reducing the
number leaves per treatment. This was corroborated by Mensah, et al., (2007) when he reported
that in his study on the effects of sodium azide and colchicine treatments on morphological and
yield traits of sesame seeds that the number of leaves per plant indicated significant reductions at
higher doses.
The effect of sodium azide on the treatments was clearly minimal. The highest mean number of
pods per peduncle was 1.20 produced by red kidney control, closely followed by pinto control
with 1.15 mean numbers of pods per peduncle. The least mean number of pods per peduncle was
produced by pinto 0.1M. The difference between the highest and the lowest mean number of
pods per peduncle was not greater than 1. It may therefore be concluded that sodium azide did
not affect significantly the number of pods per peduncle in treatments of Phaseolus vulgaris.
Pinto 0.02M showed the highest mean length followed closely and also not statistically different
from pinto control. Navy 0.1M performed better than navy control. Navy 0.02M also performed
better than the navy control even though not significantly. All the red kidney treatments showed
reduced pod lengths. Red kidney 0.03M was observed to have the least mean pod length. All the
pinto treatments were observed to have reduced pod lengths except in pinto 0.02M which
performed better than the control, even though not statistically.
Both Navy and Red kidney treatments had drastic reductions in their mean number of pods per
treatment (Roopa, et al., 2011). The pinto treatment had pinto 0.03M, 0.04M and pinto 0.02M
showing higher mean number of pods then pinto control. Navy 0.01M had the lowest mean
number of pods while pinto 0.03M had the highest. The mutagen was effective in reducing the
number of pods per treatment in navy and red kidney varieties (Roopa, et al.,2011) as it can be
observed that the highest doses for both varieties (Navy 0.1M and Red kidney 0.1M) are the
observed to have the lowest number of pods per treatment. The pinto treatment however did not
follow this trend. The worst performing pinto treatment (pinto 0.1M) performed better than all
the navy and red kidney treatments. It is clear that at 0.1M, sodium azide reduces the number of
pods that can be produced from all the three varieties. However, the pinto treatments unlike the
other treatments had some treatments significantly performing better than the pinto control.
The pinto treatments all had their mean number of seeds per pod decreased significantly below
the control. Navy 0.1M and navy 0.02M showed significantly higher mean number of seeds per
pod. In the red kidney treatments, red kidney 0.02M and red kidney 0.04M performed better than
the control, significantly. The highest mean number of seeds per pod was produced by red
kidney 0.04M (7.95) closely followed by red kidney which produced 7.85 mean seeds per pod.
The pinto 0.1M showed the lowest mean number of seeds per pod, significantly performing
below the pinto control.
CONCLUSION
The observations from the verifications of this study indicate that sodium azide has a significant
effect on the morphological and reproductive characters of Phaseolus vulgaris. however the
doses used as treatments in this study were only weakly mutagenic without a buffer. The
treatment doses induced the most useful mutations in the pinto treatments and were most lethal
in the red kidney and navy treatments.
REFERENCES
Alqurainy, F., Khan, S. (2009). Mutagenic Effects of Sodium Azide and its Application in
Crop Improvement. World Applied Sciences Journal, 6(12): 1589-1601.
Blair, M.W., Porch,T., Cichy,K., Galeano,C.H., Lariguet,P.,Pankhurst,C. and Broughton,
W.(2007) Induced Mutants in Common Bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L) and their
potential use in nutrition quality breeding and gene discovery. Israel Journal of Plant
Sciences, 55 (2): 191-200
Geil, P. B., Anderson J.W. (1994) Nutrition and Health Implications of Dry Beans: A
Review. J. Nutr. 13(6):549-558
Gepts, P. (2001) Phaseolus vulgaris (Beans) Department of Agronomy and Range Science,
University of Califonia, Daris, USA. pp63
Jain, S.M. (2010) Mutagenesis in Crop Improvement Under the Climate Change. Romanian
Biotechnological Letters. 15(12):88-106
Kulthe, M.P., Kothekar, V.S. (2011) Effects of Sodium Azide on Yield Parameters of Chickpea
(Cicer arietenum). Journal of Phytology.
3(1): 39-42.
Liamngee, S. (2006) Genetic Variation of Characters in Twelve Mangu
Bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) Cultivars on the Jos Plateau. pp1-15. Unpublished
Mensah, J.K., Obadoni, B. (2007) Effects of Sodium Azide on Yield Parameters of Groundnut
(Arachis hypogaea L.) African Journal of Biotechnology,
6(6): 668-671
Nura,S., Adamu,A.K., Mu’Azu, S., Dangora, D.B., Mahamud, F.M. (2011) Mutational
Ratification Induced via Colchicine in Sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) International
Journal of Emerging Technologies in Science and Engeneering. 5(2) : 57-64
Obigbesan, G.O. (1978) Report on Potato Production in Nigeria. Repot of Participant
International Course on Potato Production. Wanengen, Netherland.pp64-71
Purseglove, J.W. (1974) Tropical Crops: Dicotyledons, Longman Group, UK
England. page90.
Limited,
Raven, P.H., Evert, R.F., Eichhorn, S.E. (1992) Biology of Plants.
Worth Publishers Incorporated . New- York US. page710.
Rosa C.O.B., Costa, N.M.B., Numes, R.M., Leal, P.F.G. (1998) The Cholesterol
Lowering Effect of Black Beans (P. Vulgaris L.) in hypocholesterolemic rats. Arch.
Latioam. Nutr. 48:306-310
Roopa, L.G., Leena, Y., Suresh, B.G., Jyoti,P.P. (2011) Sodium Azide Effect on Biological
Parameters and Induced Genetic Variability in Mungbean. Journal of Food Legumes. 24
(1) : 46-49
Tierney, M. B., Lamour, K.H. (2005) An Introduction to Reverse Genetic Tools
for
Investigating Gene Function. The Plant Health, DOI: 10. 1094/Phi-A- 2005- 102501. 1-8pp.
PGB56
CENTRE OF DIVERSITY OF TETRACARPIDIUM CONOPHORUM
Ajiboye, T.O.* and Aladele, S.E.
National Centre of Genetic Resources and Biotechnology (NACGRAB), Federal Ministry of Science and
Technology (FMST), Moor Plantation, P.M.B. 5382, Oyo State, Nigeria.
*Corresponding e-mail: ajiboyefemi2002@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Walnut, Tetracarpidium conophorum(Mull.Arg) Hutch and Dalziel (now Pluckennetia
conophora Mull. Arg) is from family Euphorbiaceae and is commonly referred to as African
walnut. Tetracarpidium conophorum is found in Nigeria and Cameroon while Coula edulis
(family olacaceae) which is also referred to as African walnut is found in Congo, Gabon and
Liberia. The greatest diversity of Tetracarpidium conophorum exist in Southwest Nigeria
especially in Ondo,Osun, Oyo,Ogun and Lagos states.Though they are found in other parts of
Nigeria. Based on our knowledge from Vavilov, the origin of Tetracarpidium conophorum is
South-West Nigeria.Most of the indigenous knowledge about planting, management, harvesting,
and uses are found in these areas.
INTRODUCTION
Walnut, Tetracarpidium conophorum (Mull. Arg) Hutch and Dalziel (now Pluckennetia
conophora (Mull .Arg) ) is from the family Euphorbiaceae and is commonly called Africa
walnut (GRIN 210, Babalola 2012). Although, walnut is a common name for small flowering
plants that are important for the nuts and timber most of them produce (Ayoola etal 2011).
Walnut comprises such families as Juglandaceae (English walnut), Euphorbiaceae (Africa
walnut) and Olacaceae (African walnut). Each family has its own peculiar characteristics but
they have some things in common such as the nuts. Juglandaceae is mostly found in the South
East Europe, to Japan and more widely in the New World. Tetracarpidium conophorum is found
in Nigeria and Cameroon while Coula edulis (family olacaceae) which is also referred to as
African walnut is found in Congo, Gabon and Liberia (Wikipedia 2008; Ayoola et al 2011).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Exploration and farm visit have been conducted in the areas
at one time or the other.
Information about the areas and Tetracarpidium conophorum were also gathered from the people
from the areas.
Nikoli Ivanovich Vavilov stands in the forefront of contributors to our knowledge of global
dispersal of crop plants and their wild relatives (Allard 1960). Vavilov proposed that the Centres
of origin of species coincide with the areas where the greatest diversity exists in the species
(Allard 1960).Whether or not such areas where the largest diversity exists are actually Centres of
origin or only topographically or otherwise suited for the preservation of variation has little
practical concern for plant explorations (Allard 1960). Vavilov also recognized the secondary
Centres of origin and was careful to point out that valuable forms are found far removed from the
primary area of origin (Allard 1960).
J. R. Harlan, during a plant exploration trip to turkey in 1948, was impressed with the
tremendous plant diversity found in small areas.
These areas Harlan referred to as microcenters since plant evolution appeared to proceed from
them at a more rapid rate than in other areas, particularly larger geographic regions. These
micro- centers seemed to offer an excellent opportunity, not only to collect valuable types, but
also to study evolution of cultivated types experimentally (Allard 1960).
If our knowledge gained from Nikoli Ivanovich Vavilov and J. R Harlan is anything to go by, the
Centre of diversity of Tetracarpidium conophorum is South West Nigeria i.e Lagos, Ogun, Oyo,
Ondo, Ekiti and Osun states in Nigeria. However not only that there are diversity of
Tetracarpidium conophorum found there, but much indigenous knowledge about planting,
management, harvesting and uses are found in these areas. The fruit is known as Awusa or Asala
in these areas. These are Yoruba speaking states.
Tetracarpidium is a perennial shrub climber found in moist forest zones of South West Nigeria.
It is cultivated principally for the nuts that are cooked and consumed as snacks along with boiled
corn (Oke 1995; Edem et al, 2009; Babalola 2012). This is just like African plums (Dacryodes
edulis). Both African walnut and African plums are boiled and consumed as snacks along with
boiled corn.The two become ripe for harvest around the time of early maize season in Nigeria
between April- July of the year. A bitter taste is usually observed upon drinking water
immediately after eating the nuts (Ayoola et al.2011). However, apart from boiling, just like
African plums, the people in this centre of diversity do roast walnut also for consumption though
this is usually practiced by children.
Tetracarpidium conophorum is usually planted in cocoa plantation in these areas. The farmers
version of cocoa plantation in these areas contain banana, plantation, guava, citrus species, oil
palm, bitter kola, yellow yam, white yam called “ dagidagi”, Theumatococcus daniella,
cocoyam, kolanut, sometimes Irvingia(bush mango), cashew tree, Vernonia armygdlina and
mango but cocoa tree normally constitute more than 80% of the plantation. The plant of
Tetracarpidium conophorum is normally planted under a tree that is not much of economic
importance on these farms ( Babalola 2012). The reason is that this support tree apart from
providing strong support for the heavy weight of climber when fully established on the crown of
the tree, walnut takes over the crown of the tree which is used as support. The walnut therefore
competes for sunlight with the “host tree” and also affects fruiting of the host tree (Babalola
2012). The farmer therefore do not normally use cocoa tree, or kolanut tree or citrus tree as the
support .If the walnut “stray” to the top of cocoa tree or kola nut tree, the farmers normally
prunes the branches or destroy the walnut shrub completely. The shield or canopy formed by the
walnut in cocoa plantation increased the humidity in the cocoa farm which is already a problem
in cocoa plantation and reduce the penetration of sunlight which is highly essential in cocoa
plantation. This leads to increased activity of Phytophtora palmivora and Phytophtora infestans
(the fungi) that cause black pod disease of cocoa.
Over 80% of the farm in these areas are owned by men, however about 20% of the women also
own cocoa farm. However, these women acquired the ownership either by inheritance of the
plantation from their late father or late husband or by purchase of the plantation. Many of the
women were not the ones who established the cocoa plantation.
However, it is the women and children that gather the fruits of walnuts that drops at maturity (
Babalola 2012). The larger percentages of fruits are normally allowed to rotten before removing
the seeds. The removal is done by knife and cutlass ( Babolola 2012 ) but preferably narrow
sharp knife for easy removal. The gathered fruits many at times are sold uncooked to “large scale
gatherers” who purchased in large quantities from house to house to go and sell to retailers. The
retailer normally boils the seed and packaged them in nylon usually four for #20.00 or six for
#50.00 as of year 2013, depending on the size of the seeds and the place of hawking or sale. The
farmers do not harvest the fruit from the shrub. It is the believe of the farmers that once you start
harvesting the fruit from the top of the tree, it will start aborting the immature fruits once the
fruits reach the stage in subsequent years. The physiology behind this is not known.
Walnuts are considered to be an herb in traditional Chinese medicine. They are said to tonify
kidneys, strengthen the back and knees, moisten the intestines and move stool. It is believed to
stop asthma and is prescribed to be taken between bouts of asthma, but not for acute asthma. It is
used as a constipation cure ( Ayoola et al 2011).The bark is used in tea as laxative and chewed
for toothache. It helps to prevent and control high blood pressure (Ajaiyeoba and Fadare 2006;
Babalola 2012). The leaf juices are also used for the treatment of prolonged and constant hiccups
(Onyenuga 1997; Ayoola 20011). However, in these centers of diversity the raw uncooked fruit
is also eaten to serve as first aid for the cure of snake bites. Also, walnut must be consumed
within two days after it has been cooked or else it will develop fowl odour and process of decay
will start which make the product unfit for sale or consumption (Babalola 2012). However, the
people in these areas normally roast any leftover on wire mesh after two days if not sold.
However, these roasted products are normally consumed by the family of the marketers because
they are not fit for sale any longer. At this point the fruit turn brown instead of white color and
fruit is no longer brittle as it used to be if consumed fresh after boiling. Also, it must be noted
that during consumption the hard shell are removed, followed by splitting of the seeds and
embryo is normally removed before consumption. The people in these centres call the emryo
removed as “oju iku” meaning “death eye”. Also, it should be mentioned that in these centre of
diversity various walnut trees have different sizes of fruits. However, from the same tree, though
the normal thing is for the fruits which are in pods to contain four seeds in shell separated by thin
layer of the pods, but some pods contain three seeds, some contain two seeds, while some
contain one. The fifth seeds in some cases are small and not fully developed and cannot be eaten.
Also in these centers of diversity, those who hawk the cooked seeds in villages in trays normally
group the seeds on broken shells of cracked palm kernels or sands, probably to drain water from
shells of walnuts to slow the process of decay and development of foul odor that render it
inconsumable.
Farmers sometimes also prefer to plant walnut close to the hedge of their farms where they have
land mark that demarcate their plantations from their neighbors probably because of the shade it
creates on the farm.
These centers of diversity in Nigeria where walnut is known in Yoruba language as Awusa or
Asala include Afijio Local Government Areas in Oyo state, Ogbomosho areas, Ido Local
Government Areas in Oyo state. Odeda Local Government areas in Ogun state, Ajebo areas in
Ogun state. Also, in Osun state, it include Ikire, Apomu, Ile-Ife areas, Iyanforogi, Abata Egba,
Aye Koka, Aba Joshua, Yekemi, Amodo, Ale-Amodu, Oke-Aba, Idi-Ogun Arode, Idi-Ako,
Atere, Ilaka, Aye Oba, Okerenbete, Adereti, Garage Olode, Omifunfun, mefoworade, Aba Ijesa,
Onigbodogi etc. In Ondo state, it include Ondo town, Ajue, Bagbe, Lasia, Asewele Korede,
Asewele Oja, Omifon, Odigbo, Ale otu, Ore, Sifawu village. Also it includes Oko Oba, Emure,
Ise-Ekiti in Ekiti state.
CONCLUSION
However, with the increased rate of deforestation and urbanization and due to the life span of the
walnut, the answer to preservation of the genetic diversity is extensive exploration and collection
program devoted to the assembling of as much of the germplasm and diligent maintenance of
ex-situ genebanks of the material once they are collected (Allard 1960). Work will commence
earnestly on conservation of the diversity if funds are available during next harvesting season.
Cameroun is probably the secondary center of diversity of Tetracarpidium conophorum.
Fig. 1
Fig. 3
Fig. 2
Fig. 4
REFERENCES:
Ajaiyeoba, E.O and Fadare, D.A., (2006). Antimicrobial potential of extracts and fractions of the
African walnut- Tetracarpidium conophorum. African Journal of Biotechnology vol 5 (22)
pp 2322-2325. Available online at http://www.academic journals.org/AJB.
Allard. R.W (1960). Principles of plant breeding pp 26-27
Ayoola P.B, Adeyeye A., Onawumi O.O and Faboya O.O (2011). Phytochemical and nutrient
evalution of Tetracarpidium conophorum (Nigerian walnut) root. IJRRAS vol 17 issue 2.
Babalola F.D (2012). Cultivation of African walnut (Tetracarpidium conophorum mull. Arg) on
agricultural plantation; an approach to conservation agriculture in Nigeria.
Edem Christopher, A. Dosunmu, Miranda I. and Bassey Francesca I. (2009). Determination of
proximate composition, Ascorbic Acid and heavy metal content of African walnut
(Tetracarpidium conophora). Pakistan Journal of Nutrition 8 (3) 225-226. ISSN 1680-5194.
GRIN (2010). Pluckennetia conophora mull. Arg. Germplasm Resources Information Network
(GRIN). Taxonomy for plants. United States department of Agriculture (USDA) and
Agricultural
Research
Service
(ARS).
Beltsville
Area.
http://www.arsgrin.gov/cgibin/npgs/html/taxon.pl?400342.
Oke, O.L., (1995). Leaf protein research in Nigeria. University of Ibadan press.
Oyenuga, V.A., (1997). Nigeria food and feed stuffs. University press, Ibadan.
Wikipedia (2008) .Walnut trees.
PGB58
HYBRID VIGOUR AND GENETIC CONTROL OF SOME QUANTITATIVE TRAITS
OF TOMATO (LYCOPERSICON ESCULENTUM)
Amaefula, C.1, Agbo, C. U.1* and Nwofia G. E.2
1
Department of Crop Science University of Nigeria Nsukka
2
Department of Agronomy, Micheal Okpara Univ. of Agriculture, Umudike
*Corresponding e-mail: christian.agbo@unn.edu.ng
ABSTRACT
The parental lines and the F1 generation of domesticated tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum)
namely; Petomech, Grosso and Insulata obtained from Naples, Italy and Lycopersicon
pimpinellifolium (the wild parent) were evaluated at the Teaching and Research Farm of the
Department of Crop Science, University of Nigeria, Nsukka. The experiment was laid out in a
randomized complete block design with three replications. Data were collected on; number of
flowers/truss (NFT), number of trusses/plant (NTP), number of fruits/truss (NFRT), number of
fruits/plant (NFP), fruit yield (FY), and average fruit weight (AFW). Better Parent Heterosis
(BPH) of the traits was estimated for the hybrids, genetic variances, gene effects and heritability
of the traits were also estimated. The result of the BPH showed that the cross, W x P had the
highest positive BPH of 358.36 % in fruit yield. The highest negative BPH of -95.59 % was
recorded for the hybrid, W x G in average fruit weight while the hybrid, In x G had the lowest
negative BPH of -16.27% in average fruit weight. Additive gene action and additive x additive
gene action (aa) were significantly in control of three crosses, W x P, W x In and W x G in fruit
yield. Additive variance was higher than dominance variance in fruit yield for all the hybrids
having the wild as one of its parents such as in W x In (7925.091), W x In (3610.39) and W x P
(9728.06). Hybrids with wild as one of its parent as, W x G, W x In, and W x P had the highest
narrow sense heritability in fruit yield (59.15 %, 51.69 %, 59.88 %, respectively). High level of
epistasis controlled some of the quantitative traits and hybridization was effective in developing
new tomato cultivars with heterotic effects in the fruit yield.
Keywords: hybrids, heterosis, gene effect, genetic variance and heritability
INTRODUCTION
The domestication and improvement of crops through breeding has been highly effective in
concentrating allelic variation that confers useful characteristics for cultivation and consumption
(Osborn et al., 2007). The objectives of hybridization in breeding self- pollinated crops, is to
combine in a single genotype genes that are found in two or more different genotypes (Allard,
1960). The ability to use a particular wild relative depends on the recovery of progeny from the
initial and subsequent crosses of tomato with the wild source, although all species can be crossed
with tomato, the ease of success varies greatly (Osborn et al., 2007).
Hybrid tomato usually produces higher yield, they generally matures earlier and more uniformly
(Shankara et al., 2005). Hybrid plants are usually heavy producers, and they combine the
character of the parent plants. Many hybrids have better fruit quality and disease resistance.
Resistance genotype should also possess other desirable economic traits to make them viable at
commercial level (Kumar et al., 2009). Previous studies have suggested that increasing genetic
distances (variability) between parents, increases heterosis (Moll et al., 1965; Mechinger, 1999).
Choudhary et al. (1965) emphasized the effective utilization of heterosis to step up tomato
production. Heterosis can be expressed when the parents of a hybrid have different alleles at a
locus and there is some level of dominance or epistasis among the alleles (Falconer and Mackay,
1996). It has been suggested that plant yield is a multiplicative trait that integrates variation from
several other traits and therefore it may be expected that the trait would exhibit higher level of
heterosis (Williams, 1959). Allard (1960) observed that the beneficial effect of crosses appear
immediately in the F1 exhibiting heterosis. When parents differ considerably in type, the yields of
the hybrids will be, with fewer exceptions, substantially greater than those of the better parent
(Allard 1960; Hossain et al., 1982). The increased yield of hybrids could be as a result of high
yielding parents selected for hybridization (Courtney and Peirce, 1979). Sharma et al. (2001)
observed negative better parent heterosis in average fruit weight. Generation mean analysis
(Mather & Jinks, 1982) is a useful technique that gives the estimation of main genetic effects
such as additive, dominance and their allelic interactions involved in the expression of
quantitative traits. The prevalence of any of the genetic effects will largely determine an
effective breeding method for further development of new cultivars. El- Agamy et al. (1975) had
suggested maximum progress in new cultivar development using pedigree selection in traits
where non – additive gene effect is prevalent where as hybridization will be effective in traits
dominated by dominance and epistatic gene effects. The need to develop tomato genotypes that
will replace the existing exotic and landrace types that are either not adaptable or poor in quality
motivated this study. The objective of this research was to develop new tomato genotypes
expressing heterosis in fruit yield and quality and investigate the genetic control of the main
quantitative traits controlling fruit yield in tomato. This information will be very useful in the
development of new cultivars with improved fruit quality and highly adaptable to the
environment by tolerance to the prevalent high temperature, rainfall and disease infestations.
MATERIALS AND METHOD
The experimental materials used for the study were three parental lines of domesticated tomato
(Lycopersicon esculentum) namely; Petomech, Grosso and Insulata obtained from Naples, Italy
and lycopersicon pimpinellifolium (the wild parent) obtained from Mbu in Isi- Uzo Local
Government Area of Enugu state. A 4 x 4 diallel analysis using Griffing’s 1956 model 1 method
2 was employed to produce 6 F1 hybrids. The parental lines and the F1 hybrids were evaluated at
the Teaching and Research farm of the Department of Crop Science, University of Nigeria,
Nsukka. The experiment was laid out in a randomized complete block design with three
replications. Each replication and plot was separated by a 1 meter wide path. Well cured poultry
manure was broadcast at the rate of 10 ton/ha a week before transplanting. Transplanting was
done at one month after planting with a spacing of I m x 0.6 m. NPK 20:10:10 was applied at the
rate of 300kg/ha one month after transplanting. Weeding and all cultural practices were carried
out as at when due. The parents were evaluated along with the hybrids on the following traits;
number of flowers/truss (NFT), number of trusses/plant (NTP), number of fruits/truss (NFRT),
number of fruit/plant (NFP), fruit yield (FY), average fruit weight (AFW). Heteriosis was
estimated as better parent heterosis (BPH) as put forth by (Allard, 1960; Uguru 2005) as follows;
F BP
BPH 1
100
BP
Where F1 is the mean of hybrid,
BP is the mean of the better parent
Test of significance was done as described by Kumar et al. (2011):
2 me
CD=
t
r
t= t tabulated at 5% probability;
r=number of replications
me = error mean square
2= a constant
Components of the generation means were evaluated using Hayman (1958) model as explained
by Singh and Chaudhary (1985) as follows;
a = B1 B 2
1
1
d = F1 4F2 P1 P2 2B1 2 B2
2
2
aa = 2 B1 2 B 2 4 F2
1
1
ad = B1 P1 B 2 P2
2
2
dd = P1 P2 2 F1 4 F2 4 B1 4 B2
t value of effect =
a = additive mean
d= dominance effect
aa = additive x additive
ad = additive by dominance
dd = dominance x dominance
B1 = mean of backcross to parent 1
B2 = mean of backcross to parent 2
P1 = mean of parent 1
P2 = mean of parent 2
F1 = mean of First filial generation
F2 = of mean second filial generation
SE= standard error
The estimate of the genetic variances of the quantitative traits was determined using the variance
estimate method as described (Acquaah, 2007; Uguru, 2005).
m = F2
P P2 F1
Ve = 1
3
Va = 2F2 – (BC1+BC2)
Vd =
BC1 BC 2 F2 P1 P2 F1
3
Vp = Ve +Va + Vd
Vg = Va + Vd
Vg
H b=
100
VP
Va
Hns =
100
Vp
Where;
Ve = environmental Variance
Va = additive variance
Vd= dominance variance
Vp= phenotypic variance
Vg= genotypic variance
Hb= broad sense heritability
Hns = narrow sense heritability
The variances of the parental lines, F1, F2, BC1 and BC2 population was used in determining the
additive variance, dominance variance, genotypic variance, phenotypic variance, environmental
variance, and heritability.
RESULTS
Estimates of Better Parent Heterosis (BPH) of the agronomic, yield, yield component traits
showed that, negative BPH was recorded in number of flowers/truss gave for all the crosses with
W x G having the lowest negative value of –35.6% while G x P had lower negative BPH value of
-4.82 % (Table 1). The cross, In x G had higher BPH of 19.42 % and 14.56 % in number of
trusses/plant, and fruits/truss, respectively than all the hybrids. The hybrid, In x P had the lowest
negative BPH in number of fruits/plant (-23.52 %). The cross, W x P had the highest positive
BPH of 358.36 % in fruit yield. All the hybrids had negative BPH in average fruit weight. The
highest negative BPH of -95.59 % was recorded for the hybrid, W x G for average fruit weight
while the hybrid In x G had the lowest negative average fruit weight of -16.27%.
The result of the genetic effects of the agronomic, yield and yield traits of the tomato varieties
studied showed that, significant additive gene effect was shown in W x P, W x In and W x G for
number of flowers/truss (Table 2a). The cross, W x P, had significant ad gene action in number
of flowers/truss. Dominance x dominance (dd) gene action was recorded in In x G, In x P, G x P
and W x In in number of flowers /truss. Additive gene action was significant in the crosses, In x
G, W x P, W x In and W x G (Table 2a). aa gene effect was also significant in In x G, In x P, W
x P, W x In and W x G in number of trusses/plant. The crosses, W x P, W x In, W x G had
significant additive gene effects on the trait (Table 2a). dd gene effects was significant in all the
crosses with the exception of In x P. Significant ad effect showed in W x P in number of
fruits/truss. It was observed that additive gene action was significant in four cross combinations
including; In x G, W x P, W x In and W x G in number of fruits/plant (Table 2b). Significant aa
gene effect was recorded in In x P, W x P and W x In. Also, the crosses, In x P, W x P, W x In
and W x G had significant ad effects in number of fruits/plant. In average fruit weight, the cross,
G x P had significant additive gene effect while aa gene effect was significant in W x G cross for
average fruit weight (Table 2b). Additive gene action was found to be significant in three
crosses, W x P, W x In and W x G. (Table 2b). Additive x additive aa gene action was also
significant in W x P, W x In and W x G crosses.
A decomposition of phenotypic variance into additive, dominant and component were carried out
for the different crosses (Tables 3- 8). Additive variance was higher than dominance variance in
fruit yield for all the hybrids having the wild as one of its parents that is W x In (7925.091), W x
In (3610.39) and W x P (9728.06). Dominance variance was higher than the additive variance in
fruit yield for hybrids of two exotic parents such as In x P (2725.24), In x G (3676.97) and G x P
(2272.85). Fruit yield had the highest environmental variance than all the traits in all the hybrids
studied. Hybrids with wild as one of its parent (W x G, 59.15%; W x In, 51.69%, and W x P;
59.88 %) had higher narrow sense heritability in fruit yield. The other hybrids had low narrow
sense (< 50) heritability in fruit yield.
DISCUSSION
The magnitude of heterosis depends on the accumulation of favourable dominant alleles in the F1
population. Negative BPH that occurred in all the crosses in number of flowers/truss, and
number of fruits/plant could be as a result of long distance in the traits between the exotic and the
wild parent. However, the results are in agreement with the findings of Sharma et al. (2001) who
observed negative heterosis in number of fruits/plant in tomato. In fruit yield, high positive BPH
was recorded in all the crosses having the wild as the mother plant (Pistillate parent) probably
because the wild had transferred traits for high yield to such crosses. When parents differ
considerably in type, the yields of the hybrids will be, with fewer exceptions, substantially
greater than those of the better parent (Allard 1960; Hossain et al., 1982). Tolerance of the wild
traits to high temperature and rainfall pattern of the study area coupled with high components of
yield are good indicators of higher yield in the wild variety. Also the increased yield of hybrids
could be as a result of high yielding parents selected for hybridization (Courtney and Peirce,
1979). Hence, the dominance of such traits of the wild in all the crosses where the wild was the
mother parent indicated the presence of maternal effect and BPH for fruit yield. This result is in
conformity with the report of Dharmatti et al. (2006) who showed a positive BPH for fruit yield
in tomato. Earlier, Sharma et al. (2001) had reported a negative BPH in fruit yield of tomato
hybrids. The negative BPH recorded in the average fruit weight for all the crosses studied
showed that none of the crosses had fruit weight that was bigger than the better parent. This
could be attributed to the dominating effect of the small fruit size over the larger fruit size. This
is in agreement with Sharma et al. (2001) who observed negative BPH in average tomato fruit
weight.
Narrow sense heritability is of great importance to the breeder. This is because it is the ratio of
additive variance to total variance. Additive variance is the variance that causes resemblance
among relatives (Acquaah, 2007). The high narrow sense heritability (>50) recorded in fruit
yield of W x G, W x In and W x P showed that these traits are highly heritable and should be
selected for further studies in those crosses. This result is in conformity to the findings of Ghosh
et al. (2010) who recorded high heritability and high genetic advances in trusses/plant,
fruits/plant, branches/plant, fruits/truss, fruit weight, and yield/plant of tomato hybrids. Wide
levels of variation in broad sense heritability and narrow sense heritability in number of
trusses/plant, fruit yield and average fruit weight in the crosses involving the exotic alone, In x P
and G x P as well as exotic by wild is suggestive of higher environmental influence in the
performance of such traits than other ones
Phenotypic variance was higher than the genotypic variance in all the traits showing that there
was an interaction of the traits with the environment. However, the low environmental variance
in most of the traits suggests that the differences observed were mainly genetic. Traits high in
narrow sense heritability and genetic variance indicated that they are controlled mainly by
additive genes that are heritable and thus transferred from one generation to another. Such
additive inheritance have been reported by Causse et al. (2003) in some traits in hybrids between
large-fruited and cherry tomato fruit lines.
Positive and significant additive gene effects occurred in all the crosses that had the wild as one
of its parent in number of flowers/truss, trusses/plant, fruits/truss, and fruits/plant. These traits
are therefore highly heritable. This agrees with Gamble (1962) that gene effect is positive if
better performing inbreds are used as P1. In number of fruits/plant, aa and ad were significant in
crosses between the wild and an exotic. Dominance x dominance effects was significant in all the
crosses except in number of fruits/truss in In x P. This result is in agreement with Zdravkovic et
al. (2011) who reported dd interaction in fruit weight. In fruit yield, additive, aa were significant
in all the crosses between wild and an exotic parent. This showed that these traits can be fixed
for possible selection of promising genotypes at early generation. Average fruit weight that
showed significant epistatic, additive x additive effect in only a cross (W x G) with wild as
parent is suggestive of the expression of linkage drag from the wild variety small fruit size that
dominated the F1. The wild variety is intended to transfer genes for resistance to disease,
adaptability to environmental conditions and high fruit number/plant. It goes on to transfer as
well as the genes that reduces the fruit size and that quality affects the fruit size of the F1 not
minding the fruit size of the better parent, even though the F1 in most crosses gave higher fruit
yield. The prevalence epistatic, additive x additive, and additive x dominance gene control in the
crosses with wild as a parent in number of fruits/plant could be the expression of high level of
fruit number on a plant in the wild which tends to dominate the exotic variety.
CONCLUSION
Better parent heterosis which is of great importance to farmers was found to be higher in crosses
having the wild as the pistilate parent, (W x G, W x P and W x In) for fruit yield. Hence, our
findings show that the wild tomato variety is a good donor of genes for improvement of
quantitative traits and yield in tomato. Also high narrow sense heritability was recorded in these
hybrids for these trait. High narrow sense heritability and genetic variance observed in some
traits indicated that they are controlled mainly by additive genes that are heritable and thus
transferred from one generation to another. The high level of epistasis in the control of number
of fruits/plant in those crosses with hybrid vigour in fruit yield indicated that the trait was very
important in determining high yield and hybridization was effective in developing new tomato
cultivars with heterotic effects in fruit yield
Table 1: Estimates of the Better Parent Heterosis (BPH) of the agronomic, yield and yield
component traits of the F1 hybrids of tomatoes used for the study
Variety
NFT(%)
NTP(%)
NFRT(%)
NFP(%)
FY(%)
AFW(%)
In x G
-14.03
19.42
14.56
-23.52
36.02
-16.27
In x P
-33.93
17.65
-30.93
-4.61
60.00
-37.06
W x In
-32.72
-54.14
-19.65
-61.51
215.38
-90.82
WxP
-7.95
-51.01
12.94
-38.19
358.36
-84.71
WxG
-35.60
-53.70
-25.45
-67.99
71.91
-95.59
GxP
-4.82
-19.08
-40.91
-56.18
-33.33
-61.49
std error
0.53
1.58
0.39
2.51
1.78
15.11
Cd ( P =0.05)
1.12
3.31
0.83
5.28
0.51
31.74
NFT = number of flowers/truss; NTP = number of trusses/plant; NFRT= number of fruits/truss;
NFP= number of fruits/plant; FY= fruit yield; AFW= average fruit weight; In x P= Insulata x
Petomech; In x G= Insulata x Grosso; W x G= wild x Grosso; W x In = Wild x Insulata; W x P=
Wild x Petomech; G x P= Grosso x Petomech; cd= critical difference
Table 2a: Gene effects of the agronomic, yield and yield traits of the crosses used in diallel
analysis of the tomato crosses used for study.
Traits
Crosses
m
a
d
aa
ad
dd
NFT
In x G
3.24
-0.49
-15.50
-3.85
0.01
7.88*
In x P
4.38
-1.61
-21.72
-6.32
-0.59
9.13*
GxP
3.92
-0.18
-19.92
-2.53
0.34
7.21*
WxP
6.25
4.13*
-34.69
1.43
1.51*
5.59
W x In 6.37
3.84*
-34.27
-3.46
0.20
7.87*
W x G 5.69
3.53*
-31.39
-0.73
0.39
5.52
NTP
In x G
In x P
GxP
WxP
W x In
WxG
6.88
6.61
10.46
27.67
27.64
26.06
2.65*
2.44
-1.76
65.93*
64.59*
65.97*
-39.69
-39.11
-58.02
-196.65
-196.07
-187.83
5.44
8.61
-7.47
93.48
89.15
93.71
2.31*
2.86*
-0.99
14.12*
12.35*
13.39*
3.18
1.11
9.49
-61.25
-60.46
-62.94
NFRT
In x G
1.33
0.15
-4.14
-3.15
0.25
7.65*
In x P
2.28
-1.01
-9.93
-3.24
0.13
7.49
GxP
2.49
-1.19
-11.07
-4.03
-0.16
7.71*
WxP
5.33
3.45*
-28.22
-0.42
1.55*
7.53*
W x In 5.08
3.49*
-25.83
-4.37
0.46
9.29*
W x G 5.02
3.21*
-25.63
-4.42
0.27
8.97*
NFT = number of flowers/truss; NTP = number of trusses/plant; NFRT= number of fruits/truss;
m = F2 mean; a = additive effect; d = dominant effect; aa = additive x additive effect; ad =
additive x dominant effect; dd = dominance x dominance effect; In x P= Insulata x Petomech; In
x G= Insulata x Grosso; W x G= wild x Grosso; W x In = Wild x Insulata; W x P= Wild x
Petomech; G x P= Grosso x Petomech;
Table 2b; Gene effects of the agronomic, yield and yield traits of the crosses used in diallel
analysis of the tomato crosses used for study.
Traits
NFP
FY
AFW
Crosses
m
a
d
aa
ad
dd
In x G
2.13
0.90*
-9.80
-1.26
0.35
5.96
In x P
GxP
WxP
W x In
WxG
3.41
2.45
37.06
35.03
43.15
-0.03
-2.06
551.44*
471.75*
445.23*
-18.70
-13.35
-539.70
-527.60
-567.65
4.32*
2.18
1039.95*
876.81*
805.35*
1.92*
0.44
200.64*
118.99*
91.93*
3.52
2.70
-634.68
-634.84
-617.50
In x G
In x P
GxP
WxP
W x In
WxG
2.85
85.03
2.06
4.39
3.27
4.32
0.86
0.95*
0.28
24.13*
18.39*
13.40*
-14.84
-14.57
-11.21
-27.50
-21.57
-27.12
1.73
2.23
2.34
45.37*
34.86*
23.92*
1.14
1.28*
0.32
19.51
13.45
8.76
4.54
4.32
2.31
-2.36
-3.95
-2.40
In x G
74.52
-16.16
-452.95 32.24
8.29
-11.66
In x P
43.35
10.77
-259.05 -3.75
-2.83
2.10
GxP
49.98
34.01*
-316.65 29.46
-4.04
-33.54
WxP
6.03
-16.37
-43.00
16.61
-0.52
-13.64
W x In
5.28
-29.34
-52.85 46.56
0.11
-42.34
WxG
5.78
-54.39
-79.80
93.26*
-0.49
-90.24
NFP= number of fruits/plant; FY= fruit yield; AFW= average fruit weight; m = F2 mean;, a =
additive effect; d = dominant effect; aa = additive x additive effect; ad = additive x dominant
effect; dd = dominance x dominance effect; In x P= Insulata x Petomech; In x G= Insulata x
Grosso; W x G= wild x Grosso; W x In = Wild x Insulata; W x P= Wild x Petomech; G x P=
Grosso x Petomech.
Table 3: Estimates of the Variance components, Broad and Narrow sense heritability of the cross
between Insulata and Petomech (In x P)
Traits
Ve
Va
Vd
VP
VG
Hbs
Hns
NTP
1.19
5.71
6.18
13.09
11.89
90.84
43.61
NFT
0.39
0.69
0.14
1.22
0.83
67.42
56.28
NFRT
0.22
0.58
0.31
1.10
0.89
80.17
52.42
NFP
0.89
0.90
0.06
1.85
0.96
51.96
48.79
FY
76.96
1894.78
2725.24
4696.98
4620.02
98.36
40.34
AFW
11.74
84.99
114.09
210.83
199.08
94.43
40.31
Ve= environmental variance; Va= additive variance; Vd= dominance variance; VP= phenotypic
variance; Vg= genotypic variance; Hbs= broad sense heritability; Hns= narrow sense heritability;
NFT = number of flowers/truss; NTP = number of trusses/plant; NFRT= number of fruits/truss;
NFP= number of fruits/plant; FY= fruit yield; AFW= average fruit weight
Table 4: Estimates of the Variance components, Broad and Narrow sense heritability of the cross
between Insulata and Grosso (In x G)
Traits
Ve
Va
Vd
VP
VG
Hbs
Hns
NTP
0.99
3.469
4.93
9.39
8.39
89.42
36.94
NFT
0.35
0.22
0.19
0.77
0.416
54.39
28.50
NFRT
0.08
0.05
0.06
0.19
0.11
57.89
26.54
NFP
0.62
0.53
0.14
1.29
0.68
51.93
40.87
FY
20.09
3623.19
3676.97
7320.25
7300.16
99.73
49.49
AFW
15.29
281.27
368.83
665.39
650.09
97.70
42.27
Ve= environmental variance; Va= additive variance; Vd= dominance variance; VP= phenotypic
variance; Vg= genotypic variance; Hbs= broad sense heritability; Hns= narrow sense heritability;
NFT = number of flowers/truss; NTP = number of trusses/plant; NFRT= number of fruits/truss;
NFP= number of fruits/plant; FY= fruit yield; AFW= average fruit weight.
Table 5: Estimates of the Variance components, Broad and Narrow sense heritability of the cross
between Wild and Grosso (W x G)
Traits
Ve
Va
Vd
VP
VG
Hbs
Hns
NTP
4.71
46.76
80.66
132.14
127.43
96.44
35.39
NFT
0.76
0.61
0.39
1.76
1.00
56.91
34.86
NFRT
0.22
0.46
0.27
0.95
0.73
76.91
48.28
NFP
4.65
153.62
364.75
523.01
518.36
99.11
29.37
FY
190.38
7925.09
5282.43
13397.91
13207.53
98.58
59.15
AFW
0.89
1.33
0.86
3.08
2.19
71.14
43.41
Ve= environmental variance; Va= additive variance; Vd= dominance variance; VP= phenotypic
variance; Vg= genotypic variance; Hbs= broad sense heritability; Hns= narrow sense heritability;
NFT = number of flowers/truss; NTP = number of trusses/plant; NFRT= number of fruits/truss;
NFP= number of fruits/plant; FY= fruit yield; AFW= average fruit weight.
Table 6: Estimates of the Variance components, Broad and Narrow sense heritability of the cross
between Wild and Insulata (W x In)
Traits
Ve
Va
Vd
VP
VG
Hbs
Hns
NTP
3.48
52.05
68.34
123.87
120.39
97.19
42.02
NFT
0.26
0.52
0.32
1.10
0.84
76.11
47.46
NFRT
0.21
0.18
0.19
0.58
0.37
64.21
30.77
NFP
12.80
89.90
88.88
191.58
178.78
93.32
46.93
FY
226.39
3610.39
3146.72
6983.49
6757.11
96.76
51.69
AFW
1.47
1.20
0.91
3.58
2.11
58.95
33.51
Ve= environmental variance; Va= additive variance; Vd= dominance variance; VP= phenotypic
variance; Vg= genotypic variance; Hbs= broad sense heritability; Hns= narrow sense heritability;
NFT = number of flowers/truss; NTP = number of trusses/plant; NFRT= number of fruits/truss;
NFP= number of fruits/plant; FY= fruit yield; AFW= average fruit weight.
Table 7: Estimates of the Variance components, broad and narrow sense heritability of the cross
between Wild and Petomech (W x P)
Traits
Ve
Va
Vd
VP
VG
Hbs
Hns
NTP
6.69
45.57
83.83
136.09
129.40
95.08
33.49
NFT
0.38
0.52
0.35
1.26
0.88
69.73
41.57
NFRT
0.41
0.66
0.15
1.22
0.81
66.27
54.02
NFP
10.99
186.85
146.24
344.08
333.09
96.81
54.31
FY
23.56
9728.06
6495.48
16247.09 16223.54 99.86
59.88
AFW
1.92
3.19
3.39
8.49
6.58
77.44
37.57
Ve= environmental variance; Va= additive variance; Vd= dominance variance; VP= phenotypic
variance; Vg= genotypic variance; Hbs= broad sense heritability; Hns= narrow sense heritability;
NFT = number of flowers/truss; NTP = number of trusses/plant; NFRT= number of fruits/truss;
NFP= number of fruits/plant; FY= fruit yield; AFW= average fruit weight.
Table 8: Estimates of the Variance components, broad and narrow sense heritability of the cross
Grosso x Petomech (G x P).
Traits
Ve
Va
Vd
VP
VG
Hbs
Hns
NTP
1.81
5.38
5.79
12.98
11.17
86.06
41.42
NFT
0.33
0.49
0.19
1.01
0.68
67.41
48.28
NFRT
0.15
0.21
0.31
0.66
0.51
77.08
31.18
NFP
0.45
3.65
6.94
11.04
10.58
95.88
33.02
FY
169.71
2199.62
2272.85
4642.18
4472.47
96.34
47.38
AFW
5.19
35.99
92.14
133.33
128.13
96.10
26.99
Ve= environmental variance; Va= additive variance; Vd= dominance variance; VP= phenotypic
variance; Vg= genotypic variance; Hbs= broad sense heritability; Hns= narrow sense heritability;
NFT = number of flowers/truss; NTP = number of trusses/plant; NFRT= number of fruits/truss;
NFP= number of fruits/plant; FY= fruit yield; AFW= average fruit weight.
REFERENCES
Acquaah, G. (2007). Principles of Plant Genetics and Breeding. Blackwell publishing USA
584pp.
Allard, R.W. (1960). Principles of Plant Breeding. John Willey and Sons Inc. New York. 485pp.
Causse, M., Buret M., Robini K. and Verschave P. (2003). Inheritance of nutritional and sensory
quality traits in fresh market tomato and relation to consumer preferences. J. Food Sci.
68:2342-2350.
Courtney, W. H., and Peirce, L.C. (1979). Parent selection information based on morphological
trait. Hort Science 14:458.
Choudhary, B., Punia, R. S., and Sangha, H. S. (1965). Manifestation of hybrid vigour in F1 and
its correlation in F2 generations of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill) Indian J.
Hort.22: 55- 59.
Dharmatti, P. R., Kulkarni, G. P., and Patil, R. V. (2006). Heterosis for yield and bacterial wilt
incidence in tomato. J. Asian Hort., 2(3):151-154.
El- Agamy, A. L., Eweida, M. H. T and Okaz, A. M. (1975). Studies of gene action for
agronomic characters in cotton. Al. Azhan Agric- Res. Bull, 9; 3-10.
Falconer, D. S., and Mackay, T. F. C. (1996 ). Introduction to Quantitative Genetics. 4th ed.
Essex, United kingdom.
Gamble, E. E. (1962). Gene effects in corn (zea mays L) relative importance of gene effects for
plant height and certain components attributes of yield Canadian J of Plant Science Vol
42: 349-358.
Ghosh, K. P., Islam, A. K. M. A., Main, M. A. K., and Hossain, M. M. (2010). Variability and
character association in F2 segregating population at different commercial hybrids of
tomato (Solanum Lycopersicon L). J . Applied . sci. Environ .manage. 14 (2) 91 – 95.
Griffings, B. (1956). Concept of general and specific combining ability in selation to diallel
crossing systems. Australian Journal of biological sciences 9: 463- 493.
Hayman, B. I. (1958). The separation of epistatic from additive and dominance variation in
generation means. Hered., 12: 371-390.
Hossain, M. A., Khan, M. R. I., and Shaikh, M. A. Q (1982). Morphological and genetics in the
hybrid derivatives of Oxheart and anobik Tomato cross. Bagledesh J Bot 11 (1) 37- 54
Kumar, Y. K. H., Patil, S. S., Dharmatti, P.R., Byadagi, A.S., Kajjidoni, S.T., and Patil, R. H.
(2009). Estimation of heterosis for Topovirius resistance in tomato. Karnataka J. Agric Sci.
22(5) 1073- 1075.
Mather, K., and Jinks, J. I. (1977). Introduction to Biometrical Genetics. Chapman and Hall,
London, UK. 231 pp.
Melchinger A E (1999). Genetic diversity and heterosis. In the genetics and exploitation of
heterosis and crop plants. Edited by J. G. Coors and J. E. Stuab 99-118. Madison , W I
Crop Science Society of America
Moll, R. H., Lonnquist, J.H., Fortuno, J. V. and Johnson, E. C (1965). The relationship of
heterosis and genetic divergence in maize. Genet 52: 139- 144.
Osborn, T. C., Chad, K., Elaine, G., and Carl, J. B. (2007). Insight and innovations from wide
crosses: examples from canola and tomato. Crop science society of America. USA.
Shankara, N., Joep, V. D. J., Marja, D. G., Martin, H., and Barbara, V. D. (2005). Cultivation of
Tomato: production processing and marketing. Agrodok 17. Agromisa and CTA 63- 64.
Sharma, D. K., Chaudhary, D. R., and Pandey, D. P. (2001) Studies on hybrid vigour in tomato
(Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.). Haryana J. Horti. Sci. 30 (3-4): 236-238.
Singh, R. K., and Chaudhary, B. D. (1985). Biometrical Methods in Quantitative Genetic
Analysis. Kalyani publishers. New Delhi- Ludhiana.236pp.
Uguru, M. I. (2005). Crop Genetics and Breeding. (2ed). Ephrata Press. Nsukka 113pp.
Zdravkovic, J., Pavlovic, N., Girek, Z., Milka, B. J., Savic, D., Zdravkovic, M., and Cvikic, D.
(2011). Generation mean analysis of yield component and yield in tomato (Lycopersicon
esculentum Mill). Pak J. Bot., 43 (3): 1575- 1580.
PGB60
APPLICATION OF CRY1AB/AC BT STRIP FOR SCREENING OF RESISTANCE FOR
MARUCA VITRATA IN COWPEA
Mohammed, B.S.*, Ishiyaku, M.F. and Sami, R.A.
*Department of Plant Science, Institute for Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University,
Zaria, Nigeria
Corresponding e-mail: binsaba@yahoo.co.uk
ABSTRACT
Maruca vitrata is a significant constraint to cowpea production in most cowpea growing areas of
sub-Saharan Africa. Yield losses caused by M.vitrata in these regions are estimated in millions
of tons annually and the prevalence of M. vitrata infestation is steadily increasing. Recombinant
DNA technollogy have led to development of some cowpea lines with Maruca resistance as well
as other important agronomic traits but it is time-consuming and difficult to screen for the
resistant trait especially in the segregating populations using conventional screening techniques,
which will lead to delay in the development of Maruca resistant cowpea varieties. The use of
allele-based selection tool will make it easier to select plant traits and reduce the time needed to
develop new Maruca resistant cowpea varieties. In this study, the efficacy of using Cry1Ab/Ac Bt
strip for detecting Maruca resistant transgene in transgenic cowpea was systematically
investigated for the first time through field derived progenies. The results showed that the
Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strip was effective for detecting the presence of the resistant gene in cowpea
genome. Maruca resistant plants were successfully screened from the segregating cowpea plants
and the genetics of the gene was monitored. The Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strip was found to be suitable for
genetic analysis of the Maruca resistant transgene in cowpea. This study has demonstrated the
precision of using Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strips as a screening tool of transgenic lines containing Cry1Ab
gene, this has an importance in the hybridization programme where genotypes having cry gene
can be distinguished at seedling stage at lesser time, with the potential of putting the breeding
process on a fast track and increase the efficiency of breeding activities.
Key Words: Bacillus thuriengiensis, Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strips, transgenic cowpea, Maruca vitrata
INTRODUCTION
Cowpea (V. unguiculata L. Walp) is considered the most important food grain legume in the dry
savannas of tropical Africa (NGICA, 2002). It is the most important indigenous African legume
for both home use and as a cash crop and especially important for the Sahel because of its
drought tolerance (Kushwaha et al., 2004). It is rich in quality protein and has energy content
almost equivalent to that of cereal grains, it is a good source of quality fodder for livestock and
also provides cash income (Davis et al., 1991). Nearly 200 million people in Africa consume the
crop (AATF, 2010; NGICA, 2002). Cowpea is consumed in many forms; the young leaves,
green pods, and green seeds are used as vegetables, dry seeds are used in various food
preparations, the haulms are fed to livestock as nutritious supplement to cereal fodder and being
a fast growing crop, cowpea curbs erosion by covering the ground, fixes atmospheric nitrogen,
and its decaying residues contribute to soil fertility (Singh et al., 2002).
The overall productivity of its existing traditional genotypes are low due to their prominent
susceptibility to insect pests (Darshana et al., 2007) and among the most damaging insects are
aphids, flower thrips, cowpea pod borer, pod sucking bugs and the cowpea weevils (Darshana et
al., 2007). The cowpea pod borer (Maruca vitrata) is a serious lepidopteran pest that inflicts
severe damage to cowpea on farmers’ fields (Figure 3). In severe infestations, yield losses of
between 70–80% have been reported (AATF, 2010). Control through spraying with insecticide
has not been fully adopted by farmers due to the prohibitive costs, causing resource-poor farmers
to opt for cheaper but more toxic alternatives that impact their health (AATF, 2010).
Breeding for insect resistance with the aid of phenotypic selection is time consuming, laborious
and relatively expensive (Xu and Crouch, 2008). In addition, most crops have a high level of
heterozygosity that makes visual selection difficult but selection based on allele composition will
avoid this problem (Ibitoye and Akin-Idowu 2010). Ability to select breeding progeny early at
the seedling stage is another advantage of using allele-based selection tools (Ibitoye and AkinIdowu 2010). The number of plants that are needed to be maintained in a crop breeding
programme can be reduced by eliminating progenies that do not carry the desirable allele at the
seedling stage, saving space, time, labor and other resources (Ibitoye and Akin-Idowu 2010).
The present study was designed and conducted in order to understand the efficacy of using
Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strips for detecting Maruca resistant transgene in transgenic cowpea through field
derived progenies.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The Research was conducted under the confined field trial site (CFT) between July, 2011 to
August, 2012 at the Institute for Agricultural Research (IAR), Samaru-Zaria, Nigeria. Two
genetically engineered cowpea lines: transgenic cowpea line TCL-709 and TCL-711, and three
non-transformed cowpea genotypes: IT97K-499-35, IT93K-693-2 and IT86D-1010, were used in
this study. Data were collected as scores of Cry1Ab Bt strip kits.
To establish the potency of Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strips as a screening tool for Maruca resistant
transgene, the inheritance of Cry1Ab gene was monitored with the aid of Bt strips in filial
generations. The transgenic cowpea lines TCL-709 and TCL-711 along with three nontransgenic genotypes: IT97K-499-35, IT93K-693-2 and IT86D-1010 (the original parent of the
transformed lines having the same genetic architecture except the Cry1Ab gene) were crossed
using biparental mating as described by Sharma (2006) to generate F1 population. Some F1 seeds
were advanced to second filial generation (F2) populations by self pollination. The following six
combinations of crosses were produced; IT97K-499-35 x TCL-709, IT97K-499-35 x TCL-711,
IT93K-693-2 x TCL-709, IT93K-693-2 x TCL-711, IT86D-1010 x TCL-709 and IT86D-1010 x
TCL-711.
The parents, F1 and F2 generations were evaluated under field conditions during the 2012 cowpea
growing season at CFT Samaru-Zaria between June to August, 2012. The trial was planted using
randomized complete block design with three replications. The plant to plant and row to row
spacing was kept at 30cm by 75cm respectively. The plot size was 3m x 5m for all entries except
F2 plants which were 6m x 5m. No insecticidal spray against lepidopteran insects was applied.
The screening was carried out with the aid of Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strips to check for the presence of
Cry1Ab gene in the genetic populations (P1, P2, F1, and F2) of transgenic cowpea. Detection of
Cry1Ab Proteins on cowpea involved assaying plant leaves for expression of the Cry1Ab gene. A
quick Bt strip test was used to confirm the expression of the Cry1Ab protein in cowpea
transgenic lines. This was achieved by placing leaf discs in test tubes containing buffer and then
slowly inserting Bt strips into the buffer. Then, formation of a single line in the test tube proved
that the test was working while the appearance of a second lower line showed that Cry1Ab
protein was present (Envirologix, 2008). Figure I and II illustrates a typical type of Cry1Ab Bt
strip test. In these plates, the appearance of two lines on the test membrane indicates the presence
of the Cry1Ab Bt gene, while the appearance of only the top (control) line indicates a negative
response.
The plants were screened with the aid of Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strips and the transfer of Cry1Ab gene
from a transgenic cowpea plant to a non- transgenic cowpea plant was checked. The number of
positive and negative plants indicating presence and absence of the transgene respectively, were
taken to infer the behaviour of the transgene whether dominant or recessive and establish the
efficacy of the Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strips.
Adequate sample size was taken from each F2 family and analyzed with the aid of Cry1Ab/Ac Bt
strips. Since the gene is expected to segregate in F2 generations, the plants were clearly classified
as Cry1Ab–positive or Cry1Ab-negative regarding the Cry1Ab expression where Cry1Ab positive
plants indicates resistance to M. vitrata while Cry1Ab negative plants indicates susceptibility to
M. vitrata. Envirologix (2008) procedures for Cry1Ab/Ac Bt strip test was carefully followed.
The data was subjected to chi-square goodness of fit test against the Mendelian ratio 3:1 for the
F2 generations (Kiani et al., 2009).
Data recorded for the genetic segregation of Cry1Ab transgene were analyzed with the help of
chi-square (X2) goodness of fit test, to determine whether the observed data conforms to the
expected Mendelian 3:1 ratios for F2 segregating populations of each cross. The following
formula was used using a Proc Frequency for a chi-square test of goodness of fit by Mcdonald
(2009).
2
(O E ) 2
E
Where: O = Observed value, E = Expected value and
= Summation.
RESULTS
The results of the six set of F1 plants analyzed with the aid of Cry1Ab Bt strips to study the
efficacy of Bt strips for detecting the transgene’s presence through transmission and expression
of the transgene have been given in (Table 1). It was found that all the F1 plants were positive to
Cry1Ab Bt strip test. It thus means that the gene was successfully transferred from Bt lines to
non-Bt lines and the Cry1Ab Bt strips were potent as detecting tool for the target gene.
The results are shown in Table 2. The results reveal that Mendelian segregation ratios (3:1)
existed in all the six cross combinations for the F2. The F2 populations of these crosses
segregated into plants with positive and negative Cry1Ab gene indicating the presence and
absence of the Maruca resistant gene respectively, with a good fit to the Mendelian ratio of 3:1
with non significant Chi-square values (X2) for F2 plants of the following crosses; IT97K-499-35
x TCL-709 (X2 = 0.18 ; P = 0.67), IT97K-499-35 x TCL-711 (X2 = 0.15, P = 0.70), IT93K-6932 x TCL-709 (X2 = 0.22 ; P = 0.64), IT93K-693-2 x TCL-711 (X2 = 0.31 ; P = 0.58), IT86D1010 x TCL-709 (X2 = 0.26 ; P = 0.61), IT86D-1010 x TCL-711 (X2 = 0.0041 ; P = 0.95) in
(Table 2). This has demonstrated the potency of the Bt strips for detecting the presence of the
transgene in the segregating populations of transgenic cowpea crosses. The strip screening
clearly grouped the F1 plants as resistant plants just like the transgenic parents and the
segregating progenies of F2 were seen clearly behaving as hypothesized into 3:1 Mendelian test
ratio.
DISCUSSION
The genetic segregation and pattern of inheritance of Cry1Ab gene in the genetically modified
cowpea were monitored in six crosses of cowpea involving transgenic and non-transgenic lines.
In the present study, the segregation of Cry1Ab gene was found to be in Mendelian fashion in all
the six cowpea crosses, the results indicated that the resistant trait was controlled by a single
dominant gene in the crosses that were examined. The transgenic lines carried the dominant gene
while the recessive allele resides in the susceptible genotypes. In the F1 generation studies,
the Cry1Ab gene was found to be successfully transferred from transgenic to non-transgenic and
it was dominant. These results are in agreement with earlier research works on genetically
modified Bt crops with Cry1Ab transgene: Cry1Ab transgene is inherited as single dominant
gene, in Bt corn where the Cry1Ab conferred resistance to stem borer (Ostrinia nubilalis)
(Murenga et al., 2012), in Bt Rice containing resistant gene to striped stem borer (Chilo
suppressalis) (Kiani et al., 2009, Wang et al., 2012), in crosses of transgenic Rojolele Rice
(Sulistyowati et al., 2008) and in Bt Cotton where Khan (2008) and Zhang et al., (2000) studied
the inheritance and segregation of foreign Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis toxin) and tfdA genes. The
ability to obtain 3:1 segregation in F2 generations using the Cry1Ab Bt strips means that these
tests could be employed for wide-scale studies in the field to enhance cowpea breeding for
resistance to Maruca vitrata.
The results obtained here indicate that it is possible to use this technology to select for Maruca
resistant genotypes in cowpea. Similar results have been reported in other crops (corn, soybean,
cotton and canola) using Bt strips technology to select plants carrying Cry1Ab transgene (Stave,
2002; USDA/GIPSA 2006) and had proven to be effective in detecting the presence of the
transgene in these crops. Cry1Ab Bt strip tests for genetically engineered crops are currently
being used on a large scale in the United States to manage the sale and distribution of grains that
are genetically transformed (Stave, 2002). In several of these applications, it is important to get a
result rapidly in the field, and in these situations strip tests are particularly useful.
Using the Cry1Ab Bt strips, the screening were done at seedling stage with good precision, this
saves time and resources. The use of Cry1Ab Bt strips as a screening tool of transgenic lines
containing Cry1Ab gene is strongly recommended, this has an importance in the hybridization
programme where genotypes having the transgene can be distinguished at seedling stage at lesser
time. The benefits of this technology have important implications for improving the efficiency of
the characterization of cowpea genotypes for resistance to Maruca in the laboratory, especially
when working in remote areas and in developing countries where access to laboratory facilities,
chemicals, and equipment for PCR procedures are limiting. The Cry1Ab Bt strip test was found
to be the most suitable in order to rapidly analyze large number of plants in lesser time and to
differentiate between the two groups. Elite and promising plants can be faithfully screened and
selected at seedling stage particularly during the development of backcross population, aimed
towards development of transgenic cowpea varieties. Results obtained from Bt strips sampled
materials were effective and reproducible in our hands from the six F2 populations used. The
studies described here that the Bt strips screening offers a simple, sensitive and specific tool
appropriate for identifying Maruca resistant transgene. We conclude that the application of this
technology has the potential to significantly enhance the Maruca resistant cowpea breeding
program, and the efficiency of breeders to speed-up the process of developing and deploying
Maruca resistant cowpea varieties to farmers. This study demonstrates that Bt strip is an
effective, economic and sensitive method for sampling and identifying resistant cowpea plants
using leaf tissues.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors sincerely acknowledge the financial support of African Agricultural Technology
Foundation (AATF Kenya), Maruca Resistant Bt Cowpea Project, Institute for Agricultural
Research, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria Nigeria.
REFERENCES
AATF (2010). Project2; cowpea productivity improvement- guarding against Maruca
infestation. African Agricultural Technology Foundation. Accessed on 05/05/2010
http://www.aatf-africa.org/userfiles/Cowpea-brief.pdf
Darshana, C., Seena, M., Ranjana, J., Raman, S., Ananda, P.K. and Pawan, P.K. (2007).
Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated high frequency genetic transformation of an
Indian cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. walp.) cultivar and transmission of transgenes into
progeny. Plant science. 172:92-700.
Davis, D.W., Oelke, E.A., Oplinger, E.S., Doll, J.D., Hanson. C.V. and Patnam, D.H.
(1991).
Alternative Field Crops Manual, University of Wisconsin-Extension,
Cooperative
Extension, University of Minnesota; Center for Alternative Plant and
Animal
Products and the Minnesota Extension Service. Accessed on 05/04/2012 from
http://www.hort.purdue.edu/newcrop/afcm/cowpea.html
Envirologix (2008). Quickstix kit for cry1Ab Corn leaf and Seed. Accessed on 01/08/2011 from
http://www.envirologix.com/library/as003crlsinsert.pdf
Ibitoye, D.O. and Akin-Idowu, P.E. (2010). Marker-assisted-selection (MAS): A fast track to
increase genetic gain in horticultural crop breeding . African Journal of Biotechnology 9
(52):8889-8895. Available online at http://www.academicjournals.org/AJB
Khan, G.A. (2008). Inheritance of Transgene(s) in Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum l.). A thesis submitted
to the University of the Punjabin complete fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of
Philosophy in Molecular Biology, University of the Punjab, Lahore. Retrieved on
30/06/2012 from http://www.scribd.com/doc/54536729/15/
Kiani, G., Nematzadeh, G.A., Ghareyazie, B. and Sattari, M. (2009). Genetic analysis of cry1Ab
gene in segregating populations of Rice. African Journal of Biotechnology. 8 (16): 37033707. Retrieved on 9/06/2012 from http://www.academicjournals.org/AJB.
Kushwaha, S., Musa, A.S., Lowenberg-DeBoer, J. and Fulton J (2004). Consumer
Acceptance of GMO Cowpeas in Sub-Sahara Africa. American Agricultural Economics
Association Annual Meeting August 3, 2004. Long Paper #119265. Accessed on
02/09/2012 from http://ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/20216/1/sp04ku01.pdf
Mcdonald, J.H. (2009). Handbook of biological Statistics (2nd ed.). Sparky hosue publishing,
Baltimore, Maryland. Available on http://udel.edu/~mcdonald/statchigof.html.pp39Murenga, M., Danson, J., Mugo, S., Githiri, S.M. and Wanjala, B. (2012). Quantification of Bt
δ-endotoxins in leaf tissues of tropical Bt maize populations. African Journal of
Biotechnology. 11(51):11181-11186. Retrieved on 01/05/2012 from
http://www.academicjournals.org/AJB
NGICA (2002). Report of workshop on the genetic transformation of Cowpea held in Capri,
Italy, October 31- November 2. pp18.
http://www.entm.purdue.edu/NGICA/reports/italy_proceedings.pdf
Sharma, J. R. (2006). Statistical and Biometrical Techniques in Plant Breeding. New Age
International publishers, New Delhi. PP:259.
books.google.com.ng/books?isbn=8122408885
Singh, B.B., Ehlers, J.D., Sharma, B. and Filho, F.R.F. (2002). Recent progress in cowpea
breeding. In; Fatokun CA, Tarawali SA, Singh BB, Kormawa PM, Tamò M (eds).
Challenges and opportunities for enhancing sustainable cowpea production. Proceedings
of the World Cowpea Conference III held at the IITA, Nigeria, pp396 available on
http://old.iita.org/cms/articlefiles/737-Cowpea%20proceedings%202002.pdf
Stave, J.W. (2002). Protein Immunoassay Methods for Detection of Biotech Crops:
Applications, Limitations, and Practical Considerations. Journal of AOAC International
85:3
Sulistyowati, S., Alex, H.Y., and Slamet-Loedinb, I. (2008). The Segregation Pattern
of Insect Resistance Genes in the progenies and crosses of transgenic Rojolele Rice.
Indonesian Journal of Agricultural Science 9(2), 2008: 35-43.
USDA/GIPSA (2006) Testing for the Presence of Biotechnology Events in Corn and Soybeans
Accessed on 24/06/2013 from
http://www.gipsa.usda.gov/fgis/biotech/quarterly_reports/october_2006_final_report.pdf
Xu, Y. and Crouch, J.H. (2008). Marker-assisted selection in plant breeding: from publications
to practice. Crop science 48:391-408.
Wang, Z., Yu, C. and Jiang, L. (2012). Segregation and Expression of transgenes in the
progenies of Bt transgenic Rice crossed to conventional Rice varieties. African Journal of
Biotechnology
11(31):
7812-7818.
Accessed
on
03/06/2012
from
http://www.academicjournals.org/AJB
Zhang, B.H., Guo, T.L. and Wang, Q.L. (2000). Inheritance and segregation of exogenous genes
in transgenic cotton. Journal of Genetics 79: 71-75
Table 1: Detection of Cry1Ab gene in Parents and F1 populations of transgenic cowpea
Genotype
No. of Plants Tested
Positive
Negative
Expected ratio
TCL-709
50
50
0
1:0
TCL-711
50
50
0
1:0
IT97K-499-35
25
0
25
0:1
IT93K-693-2
25
0
25
0:1
IT86D-1010
25
0
25
0:1
IT86D-1010 x TCL-709
23
23
0
1:0
IT86D-1010 x TCL-711
23
23
0
1:0
IT97K-499-35 x TCL-709
30
30
0
1:0
IT97K-499-35 x TCL-711
28
28
0
1:0
IT93 693-2 X TCL-709
25
25
0
1:0
IT93 693-2 X TCL-711
23
23
0
1:0
Positive: Cry1Ab gene is present i.e. resistant to M. vitrata, Negative: Cry1Ab is absent i.e.
susceptible to M. vitrata
Table 2: Detection of Cry1Ab gene in F2 populations of transgenic cowpea crosses
Cross
(Female x Male)
No. of Positive Negative
Plants
Tested
Expected ChiDF
ratio
square
Prob.(ns=not
significant at
p=0.05)
IT86D-1010 x TCL-709
105
81
24
3:1
0.26
1
0.61ns
IT86D-1010 x TCL-711
81
61
20
3:1
0.004
1
0.95ns
IT97K-499-35 x TCL-709
89
65
24
3:1
0.18
1
0.67ns
IT97K-499-35 x TCL-711
111
85
26
3:1
0.15
1
0.70ns
IT93 693-2 X TCL-709
75
58
17
3:1
0.22
1
0.64ns
IT93 693-2 X TCL-711
131
101
30
3:1
0.31
1
0.58ns
Positive: Cry1Ab gene is present i.e. resistant to M. vitrata, Negative: Cry1Ab is absent i.e.
susceptible to M. Vitrata
Figure 1: Cry1Ab/1Ac Bt strips showing positive, negative and invalid result (Envirologix, 2008)
Figure 2: Cry1Ab/1Ac Bt strips in test tubes showing positive results (Field Result 2012)
Figure 3: Showing larvae and Adult Maruca vitrata (Legume Pod Borer) pest
PGB61
CHARACTER RELATIONSHIP AND GENETIC CORRELATION FOR SELECTING
CHARACTERS FOR TUBER DRY MATTER YIELD IMPROVEMENT IN WHITE
YAM (DIOSCOREA ROTUNDATA).
Nwankwo, I.I.M.1*, Eka, M.J.2, Okocha, P.I.2, Nwaigwe, G.O.1 and Njoku, D.1
1
National Root Crops Research Institute, Umudike, P.M.B. 7006, Umuahia, Abia State, Nigeria
2
Michael Okpara, University of Agriculture, Umudike, P.M.B. 7267, Umuahia, Abia State,
Nigeria
Corresponding e-mail: nwankwomaxwell@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Yam is an important tuber crop in Nigeria where yield potential and quality attribute have not
been fully exploited due to limited breeding efforts and poor knowledge on the inheritance of
some of its agronomic traits. A study was conducted at the Western experimental field of
National Root Crops Research Institute - Umudike, Abia State, Nigeria to evaluate 12 hybrid
yam genotypes at the stage of Uniform Yield Trial (UYT) developedthrough intra-specific
crosses using three landraces of Dioscorea rotundata as checks. The specific objective was to
determine the character correlation and genetic relationship for selecting characters for
improving tuber dry matter yield. The experiment was carried out to achieve the following
specific objectives using a two factor experiment in RCBD. The result of genetic inter-character
association detected that pearson moment correlation coefficient was defective for selecting
genetically stable traits for character improvement. Multi-regression analysis projected number
of days to male flower buds emergence (46.83%) and number of days to female flower buds
emergence (15.12%), as the traits exerting the greatest influence on tuber dry matter yield. These
traits have high heritability estimates, high genotypic coefficient of variation and genetic
advance. The genes controlling the traits are positively linked/coupled on the same chromosome
and are inherited together. The characters are genetically stable over the years and contributed to
the observed genetic variations.
Keyword: character, genetic relationship, selection, tuber dry matter yield, genetic stability.
INTRODUCTION
The yam plant is a monocotyledonous and annual herbaceous plant. It has long climbing stems
which wind themselves around supports. A single plant produces between one and five tubers of
varying shapes, each may weigh up to 5kg. The yams are the most important staple food crops
in West Africa (Ekpe et al, 2005) except for cereals (Coursey, 1967, Onwueme, 1978). White
yam (Dioscorea rotundata Poir) is a prestigious and most preferred carbohydrate staple for
peoples of the tropics particularly in West Africa and the Caribbean (FAO, 1998).
Future increases in yam output will have to rely on higher yield and necessitate that constraints
to production be tackled (Manyong et al, 2001). Since tubers could be eaten boiled, roasted,
fried, mashed or pounded to provide important energy, variability in D. rotundata is almost the
only avenue through which local farmers and consumers can obtain yams of their desired traits.
It is believed that selection of resultant hybrid genotypes with higher tuber dry matter yield and
appealing tubers will contribute to high yielding genotypes of Dioscorea rotundata for
commercial production. Therefore the focus of this Study is character relationship and genetic
correlation for selecting characters for tuber dry matter yield improvement. The specific
objectives include: to select the character(s) that contributed to tuber dry matter yield of the intra
specific hybrids of Dioscorea rotundata, and to select the character(s) that genetically linked to
the tuber dry matter yield and genetically stable over the years
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was laid out in a randomized complete Block Design (RCBD) with 6 replicates.
Each of the 15 yam genotypes were each cut into setts with a mean weight of 40g from each
genotype. Each genotype was planted in each plot measuring 2.0 by 2.25m2. Spacing on the
ridges was 45cm within the row and 100cm between the ridges giving a total of 10 yam plants
per plot, 150 yam plants per block or replicate and 900 yam plants for the 6 blocks or replicates.
A total of 15 yam genotypes were used in the experiment. Bonds were made to check erosion
and separate the plots from one another. The experiment was carried out in two cropping
seasons with the first season crop established on April 16th 2009 and the second season crop
established on April 20th 2010.
The yam plants were individually staked with approximately 2 meters high bamboo stake for
support and for adequate exposure to sunshine for photosynthesis as well as for easy observation
and data collection. The experimental fields were kept weed-free manually with hand hoes. No
applications of herbicides or pesticides were carried out. Four hundred kilogram of NPK
20:10:10 per hectare of fertilizer was applied eight weeks after planting in each plot using band
method. All other agronomic practices were according to the farmer’s management practice.
The data collected were on Number of upright shoots that emerged from plant base, Plant
height, measured from the plant base to the top of the main vine, Number of leaves, Number of
primary branches, Leaf area obtained by grid method (Roderick, 1978), Leaf area index (Watson,
1982, Roderick, 1978).
LAI = leaf area per plant
Land area covered by plant at 2, 4 and 6 months after planting (MAP).
Days to tuber physiological maturity, all were collected at 2, 4 and 6 months after planting
(MAP). Fresh tuber yield per plant calculated at harvest. Number of tubers per plant, Tuber dry
matter obtained by measuring 100g of fresh tuber from each plot, dried in a ventilated oven at
80oC for hours until a constant weight is obtained to determine their dry matter yield.
Crop growth rate obtained according to Radford (1967) and a Roderick (1978). The formula
employed for calculation is:
CGR
=
logW2__-_ logW1
P (T2 – T1)
Where CGR= Crop Growth Rate, W2= Final dry weight of plant, W1= Initial fresh weight of
plant, T1= Initial time, T2 = Final time, P= ground area on which W2 and W1 were estimated.
Analysis of variance was used to analyze Tuber dry matter yield and other yield component
characteristics. Linear model for the analysis was: Xij = Ui + Bi + Ej + Ti + Tjk + Et Where Xij
= value of Observation, Ui = common mean
, Bi = block effect, Eji = Varietal effect, Ti
= Year effect, Tjk = Year x varietal effect, Et = error term.
Simple Correlation Coefficient (Pearson Moment Product Correlation Analysis) was used to
determine the relationships between: Tuber dry matter yield and other plant characters. The
formula use for the calculation was r12 = ∑x1x2
√ (∑x1)(∑x2)
Where
r12 = the correlation between character x1 and x2, ∑x1x2 = the covariance between
character x1 and x2, (∑x1) = the variance of character x1, (∑x2) = the variance of character x2 ,
Determination of genotypic coefficient of variation and phenotypic coefficient of variation was
estimated using the following formula suggested by Burton (1952), Warwick and Legate (1981),
Kumar et al (1985), Sharma (2004), Jawahar (2006) and Rangeswamy (2010).
Estimation of genotypic coefficient of variability:
GCV = √ VG x
100
X
1
Estimation of phenotypic coefficient of variability:
PCV =
√VP x 100
X 1
Where VG = Genotypic Standard deviation. VP = Phenotypic Standard deviation, X = Grand
mean of the character under consideration, Genotypic and phenotypic variations were used to
determine real heritable differences and environmental (non-heritable) factors.
Estimation of Heritability (in broad sense) according to Warwick and Legate (1981) and Sharma
(2004) was used to estimate the heritability of all the characters.
hbs = VG x 100
VP
1
Where hbs = Heritability in broadsense, VG = Genetic variance, VP = Phenotypic variance
Estimation of genetic correlations was done using the following formulae by Sharma (2004) and
Rangaswamy (2010).
Genotypic correlation (rg) =
Covg (x1 . x2)
√ (Varg x1) (Varg x2)
(ii) Phenotypic correlation (rp) =
Covp (x1. x2)
√ (Varp x1) (Varp x2)
This was used to determine characters that are repeatable from year to year and whether the
characters under consideration were linked on the same chromosome or located far apart on the
same chromosome or they are located on different chromosomes.
Multiple Regression Analysis according to Li (1981) was used to determine the degree of
contribution of each of the plant characters to Tuber dry matter yield. The following linear model
was used = a + b1 x 1+ b2x2+b3 x3+b4x4 ---bnxn + ei, Where Y = dependent plant character, a =
intercept (constant), b1 = regression coefficient, Xn = plant characters under consideration
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The analysis of variance showed high significant (P<0.01) and significant (P<0.05) genotypic
differences for all the characters that were evaluated in each season, indicating substantial
variations in plant characters among the yam genotypes. There were non-significant (P>0.05)
differences in certain plant characters indicating lack of variability in the plant characters.
However, the variability exhibited by the plant characters contributed to the variations in mean
performance of the tuber dry matter yield of the yam genotypes. The overall performance of a
crop in any environment depends on the variability in the genetic constitution of the genotypes
and its inter-character relationship.
The result of the Correlation of plant characters with tuber dry matter yield and other plant
characters in each of the years 2009 and 2010 are presented in Table 1. Tuber dry matter yield
positively and significantly (P<0.01) correlated with number of leaves in both years (r = 0.244**
in 2009 and r = 0.291** in 2010), and number of branches in both years (r = 0.324** in 2009 and
r = 0.325** in 2010). Selection and improving on these characters will increase the tuber dry
matter yield. If the branching of the yam plant is improved, it will increase the number of leaves
significantly. Higher number of leaves will lead to higher photosynthetic efficiency of the yam
crop and this will influence the dry matter accumulation of the yam tuber. Also, tuber dry matter
yield positively and significantly correlated with leaf area index (r = 0.342** in 2010) and crop
growth rate (r = 0.261**) in 2009. These two traits could be selected for the improvement of
tuber dry matter yield in yam plants. Developing yam crops with large canopy (leaf area index)
will lead to increasing planting distance of the yam plant.
The positive correlation of crop growth rate and tuber dry matter yield indicated that developing
yam plants with increased number of leaves and rapid growth rate due to high dry matter
accumulation will enable the crop escape diseases and pests and subdue weeds. The rapid dry
matter accumulation will be stored in the tubers for high yield. Tuber dry matter yield positively
and significantly (P<0.01) correlated with number of days to tuber maturity (r = 0.261**) in
2009 suggesting that as the number of days to tuber physiological maturity increases, more
carbohydrates are partitioned to the underground sink (tuber). This character could be selected
for the improvement of tuber dry matter yield of the yam plants. Tuber dry matter yield
positively and significantly correlated with number of days to male flower buds emergence and
number of days to female flower buds emergence (r = 0.392**) in 2010. Number of days to male
flower buds emergence and number of days to female flower buds emergence according to
Onwueme (1978) is the time for carbohydrate excess for the yam plant. This excess carbohydrate
is partitioned both to the sink (tuber) and to the leaf -axils for flower bud formation and for
flowering. T his trait could be selected for the improvement of tuber dry matter yield. Tuber dry
matter yield in both years positively and significantly (P<0.01) correlated with fresh tuber yield
in both years (r = 0.271** in 2009 and r = 0.365**), suggesting that this character could be
selected for the improvement of tuber dry matter yield.
The results in Table 2 are the estimation of genetic parameters for character selection.
According to Falconer (1981) high genotypic coefficient of variation, high heritability estimate,
high genetic advance and positive genetic correlation (Jawarha,2006) were used to select
characters for further improvement. These genetic parameters were used for selecting characters
for the improvement of tuber dry matter yield of the yam crop. According to Ibe (1998),
heritability below 20% will not give the desired result.
Genetic correlation is the association between the genotypic and the phenotypic variation of the
characters under consideration (Table 3). The phenotypic correlation determined the interaction
between the gene and the environment while the Environmental correlation determined the
influence of the environment on the genotypes. The phenotypic and genotypic correlations
observed among the plant characters in this study indicated an inherent association between
them. The phenotypic correlation incorporates both genotypic and environmental correlations. If
environmental correlation coefficients were lower than phenotypic correlation coefficients,
phenotypic correlation coefficients would be good index of genotypic correlations coefficients.
This is in accord with falconer (1981) who reported that two major causes of correlations
between characters were genetic and environmental (genetic plus environment = phenotype).
The positive high significant genotypic and phenotypic correlation between tuber dry matter
yield per plant with plant height, leaf area and crop growth rate in 2009 suggested that these
traits had genetic correlation with tuber dry matter yield indicating a correlated response which
indicated that the characters are being controlled by the same gene or different genes located
close to each other on the same chromosome, this could be concurrently selected for tuber dry
matter improvement. The genetic correlation between tuber dry matter yield and plant heights
was an indication where a gene controls two characters. In 2010, the positive high significant
genotypic and phenotypic correlation of tuber dry matter yield per plant with number of days to
physiological tuber maturity, number of shoots, plant height, number of leaves, number of
branches, number of days to male flower buds emergence and number of days to female flower
buds emergence also suggested that these plant characters genetically correlated with tuber dry
matter yield per plant (Table 3). It also suggested that these traits could simultaneously improve
tuber dry matter yield per plant. It was also observed in 2009 that there were high significant
positive genotypic correlation between tuber dry matter yield per plant and number of days to
male flower buds emergence and number of days to female flower buds emergence per plant.
Also in 2010, there were high positive significant genotypic correlations between tuber dry
matter yield and leaf area. These indicated a correlated genetic response that needed favourable
environmental conditions to express the phenotype (which is the visible characteristics of an
organism resulting from the interaction between its genetic make-up and the environment).
The negative significant genotypic correlation exhibited by tuber dry matter yield with number
of shoots per plant in 2009 and number of nodes per plant in 2010 showed that these plant
characters are under the influence of environmental factors, and cannot be used for the
improvement of tuber dry matter yield. The genes controlling these traits were repulsive and
were located on different chromosomes. These plant characters since they were not genetically
correlated could not be repeatable (Tables 3) Also, tuber dry matter yield per plant had
significant genotypic correlation with plant height (length of main vines), leaf area, number of
days to male flower buds emergence, number of days to female flower buds emergence, number
of nodes and crop growth rate in either or both years. The implication of this observation is that
these characters had the most significant influence on fresh tuber yield and tuber dry matter
yield. These characters significantly and genotypically correlated with one another, and by
implication selection for any of these characters will lead to a correlated response. (That is, if one
character that is genetically correlated is selected, invariably other genetically correlated
characters will be selected. This will ultimately lead to increase in yield, and consequent yield
status will be repeatable over the years. At the genetic level, Jawahar (2006) reported that such
positive significant genotypic (genetic) correlation occurs due to coupling phase of linkage.
Indicating that these two different characters can be controlled/influenced by the genes located
close on the same chromosomes. As mentioned by Jawahar (2006) genes do not come mixed
individually during the process of reproduction, they came “linked” with other genes in the
DNA.
Number of tubers per plant and number of branches per plant had a positive significant
association (product moment correlation) with fresh tuber yield in spite of their insignificant
genotypic (genetic) correlation with fresh tuber yield and tuber dry matter yield per plant.
Characters that were not genetically correlated will not be repeatable over the years (ie characters
that are not genetic). This demonstrates the defects of selecting only on the basis of intercharacter correlation using pearson product moment coefficient as such selection may not
produce the desired result which may be very disappointing.
Tuber dry matter yield was being positively influenced by number of branches, days to male
flower buds emergence and days to female flower buds emergence. Considering the association
of fresh tuber yield per plant with tuber dry matter yield per plant, fresh tuber yield per plant
appears to be the most reliable index of tuber dry mater yield per plant.
Wallace (1974) reported that tuber size contributed to most difference in tuber dry matter yield.
Therefore, emphasis should be placed on percent tuber dry matter when selecting for high
yielding yam genotypes. According to Thambura and Muthunisnan (1976) to get higher yields in
sweetpotato, number of roots (which contribute to fresh yield) is the most important yield
component which must be improved with reduction of number of leaves.
The multiple regression linear analysis identified the characters that contributed to tuber dry
matter yield were number of days to male flower buds emergence (25.31% in 2010), number of
days to female flower buds emergence (8.17% in 2010), number of leaves (38.90% in 2010),
number of branches (0.02%in 2010), leaf area (7.63% in 2010), number of tubers (2.69% in 2009
and 0.13% in 2010) and fresh tuber yield (74.44% in 2009 and 2.79 in 2010) (Tables 4 and 5).
In this study, selection criteria (Table 6) for characters for the improvement of tuber dry matter
yield were based on high heritability estimates, high genotypic coefficient of variation, high
genetic advance and positive significant genetic correlation (Burton, 1952; John et al., 1955;
Warwick and Legate, 1981; Jawahar, 2006). The multiple regression linear analysis(Tables 4a
and 4b) therefore strengthens the suggestions that while breeding yam genotypes for higher tuber
dry matter yields, attention to number of days to male flower buds emergence, number of days to
female flower buds emergence, number of nodes, crop growth rate, number of leaves, number of
branches, leaf area, number of tubers, and fresh tuber yield should be of utmost importance. If
selection of characters is carried out to deliberately increase tuber dry matter yield, these
characters should selected and improved to some extent. However, for the characters to be
genetically stable and repeatable over the years, the characters must be genetically correlated.
Therefore, the following characters were selected for the improvement of tuber dry matter yield
per plant: number of days to male flower buds emergence (25.31%) in 2010, number of days to
female flower buds emergence (13.67% in 2009 and 8.17% in 2010), crop growth rate (3.27% in
2009 and 4.50% in 2010), number of leaves 31.56% in 2009 and 38.90% in 2010), leaf area
7.63% in 2010, fresh tuber yield 2.79% in 2010 and number of nodes 3.35% as the factors
exerting the greatest influence directly upon tuber dry matter yield. For their effect to be
effective they must be genetically correlated to enable their effect be repeatable over the years.
Since heritability estimates in broad sense (h2bs) represent the proportion of heritable variation in
the total phenotypic variation is large, number of days to male flower buds emergence (26.37%)
in 2009, and 91.94% in 2010), should be selected. Selection of this character for tuber dry matter
yield might be highly reliable. Also selected were: number of days to female flower buds
emergence (39.00% in 2009 and 99.36% in 2010)(Table 6). These two characters had high
heritability estimates, high genotypic coefficient of variation and genetic advance, and were
significantly and genetically correlated (rg) and were selected to significantly improve the tuber
dry matter yield of the yam genotypes over the years (Table 6).
CONCLUSION
Therefore, to deliberately increase tuber dry matter yield, number of days to male flower buds
emergence and number of days to female flower buds emergence should be selected. The
traits selected have reliable selection criteria and would be repeatable over the years. The
genes controlling the traits are linked/coupled with other genes and were located on the same
chromosome and contributed to the observed genetic variations. Selection of characters based
on Pearson product moment correlation will be defective if the characters are not genetically
correlated. The characters may not be repeatable over the years.
REFERENCES
Ekpe, E.O,Chinaka, C.C., Otto, E, Okoko, E.S and Emah, V.E (2005). Comparative evaluation
of bubils and sett sizes on growth pattern and yield of water yam (Dioscorea alata L).
Nigerian Journal of Agriculture, Food and Environment 2 (1): 42 – 46 et al (1989)
Burton G.W (1952). Quantitative inheritance in grassland 6th Int. Grass Congress. Pennsylvia
State College U.S.A. 17 August 23, 1952 pp277-283.
Coursey D.C (1967). The role of yams in West Africa food economies, Tropical development
and Research Institute. Cali. Columbia p– 32.
FAO, (1998) Food and Agriculture Organization. Production yearbook volume 27 and 28 FAO:
Rome.
Falconer, D.S (1981). Introduction to Quantitative Genetics 1st edition, published by Longman
London. P.214.
Ibe, S.I (1998). An Introduction to Genetics and Animal Breeding. Published by Longman.
pp60-69.
Jawahar, R.S. (2006) . Statistical and biometical techniques in Plant Breeding. New Age
international p limited publishers p 5
John, L, Jackson, S and Kasela, B (1955), Method of plant growth analysis. In: Plant
photosynthesis Production. Manuals of Methods .W Junks Publishers. The Hague P 818.
Kumar, A, Misra, S.C, Singh, y.P and Chauhan, B.P.S (1985) Variability and correlation studies
in triticale. Journal of Maharashtra Agricultural University 10: 273 - 275.
Li, C.C. (1981) First course in population genetics. Boxwood, pacific
Manyoung, V.M; Asiedu, R. and Olaniyan C.O (2001). Farmers’ perception of and actions
resource management constraints in yam based systems of western Nigeria. In: Triennial
symposium of the international Society for Tropical Root Crops – Africa Branch 11 – 17
October 1998. pp 67 – 75.
Mangoon, M. L. krishnan, R and Lakshming (1972). Association of plant and tuber Characters
with yield of cassava. Tuber and tuber crops News letter (5), p29-30
Onwueme, I.C (1978). The Tropical tuber crops. Yam, Cassava, sweetpotato, cocoyam. John
Wiley and Sons. New York p. 234
Radford, D.J (1967). Growth analysis formulae. Their uses and abuse. Crop Science No. 7 pp
171 – 175.Ramanujam,Tand indira, (1983). Canopy structure on growth and development
of cassava Manihot esculenta Grantz). Turrialba (33),p321-326
Rangaswamy R (2010). A Textbook of Agricultural Statistics (2rd edition).
New
Age
International P limited P185
Roderick, H. 911978). Plant growth analysis. The Institute of Biology. Studies in Biology No
96 p10
Shanmugham, A, Thamburaj, S and Muthukrishnan, C. R (2002).
Effect of 2, 3, 5Thiodebenzoic acid on Tapioca (Manihot esculenta Crantz).Madras Agricultural
journal. J. 61: 1067- 1008
.Sharma, C.M, (2004). Genotypic and phenotypic variability in quantitative characters in Oats.
Indian J.Agric. Sci, 51. 480-482.
Spore, (2011). New Sweetpotatoes for hidden hunger. Spore 114. CTA publication. December
2011. p7
Thambura, H. and Mathuknisnan, M. B. (1976). Breeding for resistance to African cassava
Mossaic. Report of interdisciplinary workshop held at Muguga Kenya. IDRC-082 pp4449
Wallace, P.S. Hayes, K.H, and Smith, D.A (1974) Methods of breeding plants. 3rd ed. University
of Chicago Press p 481.
Warwick, E.J. and Legates J.E. (1979). Breeding and improvement of farm animals. 7th ed. L
Mc Craw Hill Publications in the Agricultural Sciences pp 287 – 289.
Watson, L.H. (1982). Growth analysis. Agronomy of Major Tropical Crops. Oxford University
Press pp 257 – 289.
Table1: Product moment Correlation of Tuber dry matter yield and other
character
Plant character
2009
Tuber dry matter yield x no, of days to tuber maturity
r =0.261**
Tuber dry matter yield x number of leaves
Tuber dry matter yield x number of branches
yield component
2010
r= 0.244**
r = 0.324**
Tuber dry matter yield x leaf area index
Tuber dry matter yield x number of male flower emergence
Tuber dry matter yield x number of days to female flower
bud emergence
r =0.324**
r = 0.350**
r = 0.392**
Table: 2 Estimation of genetic parameter
character
Tuber dry matter yield
year
2009
2010
Number of days 2009
to maturity
2010
Plant height
2009
2010
No. of leaves
2009
2010
Leaf area
2009
2010
Leaf area index
2009
2010
Days to male flower 2009
buds emergence
Phenotypic
Coefficient
of variation
%
23.41
22.9
0.58
ggenotypic
Coefficient
of variation
%
15.69
16.56
0.22
Heritability in
broadsense
%
Genetic
advance %
19.93
52.44
14.04
2.25
2.83
6.74
1.93
11.72
12.70
25.42
18.40
0.01
0.02
60.33
34.45
140.13
0.50
6.26
6.37
11.70
6.28
0.00
0.00
58.75
33.69
71.96
6.65
28.57
25.18
21.19
11.64
1.83
5.22
94.83
95.61
26.37
3.40
20.06
5.49
670.03
274.24
39.80
66.27
65.36
95.61
75.65
2010
Days to female flower 2009
buds emergence
2010
No.of nodes
2009
2010
No.of stamen
2009
2010
54.26
45.00
52.03
53.00
91.94
39.00
94.46
41.60
72.20
12.63
87.85
139.98
120.51
71.65
2.85
13.42
135.80
114.84
99.36
5.11
2.33
94.12
90.81
15.45
65.10
55.04
62.00
65.00
Table 3: Characters that have positive genetic correlation with tuber dry matter yield and other
plant characters
Plant characters
2009
2010
Genetic
Phenotypic
Genetic
Phenotypic
Correlation Correlation(rp) Correlation Correlation(rp)
(rg)
(rg)
Tuber dry matter yield x plant rg=0.243* 0.432*
height
Tuber dry matter x leaf area
rg=0.471** 0.890*
Tuber dry matter x crop growth rg= 0.615* 0.811*
rate
Tuber dry matter x no. of days to
0.291*
0.132**
tuber maturity
Tuber dry matter x no. of shoots
0.189**
0.112**
Tuber dry matter x no. of leaves
0.144*
0.040**
Tuber dry matter x no. of branches
0.145*
0.741**
Tuber dry matter x days to male
0.258*
0.113**
flower buds emergence
Table: 4 Multiple regression between tuber dry matter yield per plant and other component
characters in 2009.
R2
Plant characters
Regression
symbol
constant
(intercept)
BCoefficient
VR
R
Stand count at harvest
No. of shoots
Plant height
No. of leaves
No. of branches
Leaf area
Days male flower buds
emergence
Days to female flower buds
emergence
No. of nodes
Crop growth rate
Days to tuber maturity
N0.of tubers
Leaf area index
Fresh tuber yield
No. of staminate spike flowers
No. of pistillate spike flowers
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
0.199
0.00
-0.189
-0.035
0.126
-0.114
-0.114
0.174
0.00
2.559**
-0.0428*
1.643*
1.036*
-1.487*
2.051**
0.00
0.036
0.001
0.016
0.013
0.013
0.030
0.00
3.23
0.09
1.43
1.17
1.17
2.69
X8
0.046
0.505ns
0.002
0.18
X9
X10
X11
X12
X 13
X14
X15
X16
0.067
0.068
0.008
0.175
0.002
0.911
-0.092
-0353
0.847*
0.909*
0.101ns
2.297**
0.016ns
2.461**
-1.018*
1.531*
0.004
0.005
0.001
0.031
0.00ns
0.830
0.008
0.125
0.36
0.45
0.18
2.69
0.00
74.44
0.72
11.21
Table: 5 Multiple regression between tuber dry matter yield per plant and other component
characters in 2010.
R2
Plant characters
Regression
symbol
constant
(intercept
BCoefficient
VR
R
Stand count at harvest
No. of shoots
Plant height
No. of leaves
X1
X2
X3
X4
-11.696
0.000
-0.096
-0.395
3.026
0.000
0.009
0.156
9.157
0.00
0.04
0.66
38.90
No. of branches
Leaf area
Days male flower buds
emergence
Days to female flower
buds emergence
No. of nodes
X5
X6
X7
0.073
1.340
-0.827
0.000*
-1.320*
-2.461*
1.572*
*
1.138
5.570*
-4.798*
0.005
1.796
0.684
0.02
7.63
2.91
X8
2.441
1.690*
5.958
25.31
X9
1.387
1.924
8.17
Crop growth rate
X10
0.888
12.089
**
4.998*
0.789
3.35
Days to tuber maturity
N0.of tubers
Leaf area index
Fresh tuber yield
No. of staminate spike
flowers
No. of pistillate spike
flowers
Table 6:
X11
X12
X 13
X14
X15
1.029
0.008
0.175
0.810
0.656
7.790
0.101
2.297*
2.562*
9.948
1.059
0.000
0.031
0.656
0.430
4.50
0.00
0.13
2.79
1.83
X16
-0.942
-3.914*
0.887
3.77
Primary Trait (Tuber dry matter yield) and selection criteria
Plant
characters
Heritability %
R2
2009
Days to male
flower buds
emergence
Days
to
female
flower buds
emergence
No. of nodes
Crop growth
2010
2009
Genotypic
coefficient
variation
2010 2009
Genetic
of advance
Genetic
correlatio
n
2010
2.69
25.3
1
26.37
91.94
71.96
52.03
2009
2010
75.65
0.18
8.17
39.00
99.36
153.0
0
171.65
41.60
15.45
rg
0.36
0.45
3.35
4.50
5.11
24.39
2.33
22.55
2.85
37.97
13.42
32.73
65.10
9.02
55.04
2.21
rg
rg
94.46
rg
rate
No.of leaves
No.
of
branches
Leaf area
No. of tubers
Fresh tuber
yield
1.43
21.19
11.64
11.70
6.28
67.03
27.24
-
1.17
38.9
0
0.02
54.67
47.09
15.62
12.02
16.06
13.34
-
1.17
2.69
74.44
7.63
0.13
2.79
1.83
93.97
26.67
5.22
14.22
26.64
0.00
48.54
14.92
0.00
6.24
14.94
39.80
10.15
1.97
6.27
1.93
2.02
rg
-
PGB62
EVALUATION OF YIELD PARAMETERS OF SOME PEPPER (CAPSICUM SPP)
LAND RACES IN NIGER STATE
Onoja, B.E.1, Falusi, O.A.1, Yahaya, S.A.1 and Gado, A.A.2
1
Department of Biological Sciences, Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger-State
2
Department of Biology, Federal College of Education, Kontagora, Niger State
Corresponding e-mail: edibliz@gmail.com +2348062916563
ABSTRACT
Ten accessions of Pepper (Capsicum spp) landraces collected from the growing local
Governments of Niger state (Tafa, Zungeru, Bida, Munya, Paiko, Mokwa, Chanchaga,
Kontagora, Gwada,) were characterized and evaluated for yield parameters during the growing
season of 2012 at the Department of Biological sciences experimental field using a Randomized
Complete Block Design (RCBD). The aim of this study was to evaluate the performance of the
accession entries on yield parameters. The results showed that the pepper landraces were
significantly different (p<0.05) for No of Flowers/plant, No of Fruits/plant, No of seeds/fruit,
weight of Fruit/plant and Fruit length respectively. The landraces were found interesting for their
yield parameters and could serve as potential candidates for future breeding programmes.
Keywords: Capsicum spp, Yield parameters, Landraces, Breeding
INTRODUCTION
Pepper is a member of the family Solanaceae and the genus capsicum. The primary centre of
diversity was Mexico, but secondarily Gauatemala (Ado, 1990). Distribution of pepper is wide
spread especially in tropical and subtropical ecologies including America, either as wild or
cultivated forms (Ado, 1990). Nigeria happens to be the largest producer of pepper in Africa
covering about 50% of total African production. A total of about 100-200,000 ha is being
assigned to pepper production annually in Nigeria (Ado, 1988). In 1983, FAO estimate of pepper
production in Nigeria stood at 695,000 metric tons from a total area of about 77,000 ha.
Consumption of pepper in Nigeria accounts for about 40% of average daily in-take either in
soup, or as condiments for flavouring and colouring of meats, fish and other food materials. In
addition, Capsicum is a rich source of vitamins A and C (Ascorbic acid) (Gill, 1992; Ado,
1999).The genus consists of over one hundred (100) species and even more botanical varieties
(Ado, 1999; Falusi, 2007); including five domesticated species namely: Capsicum annum, C.
frutescens,C. baccatum, C. chinenseand C. pubescens; all believed to have originated from the
New World (Mcleodet al., 1982; Bosland, 1994). Pepper is generally called ata (yoruba), ose
(Igbo), borkonu (Hausa), yaka (Nupe), etc.
Yield improvement programmes of pepper have indicated that some genotypes performed better
than the other under certain environmental conditions (Mattei et al., 1971).In another evaluation,
trials conducted earlier revealed that a considerable variation exists in the Pepper Germplasm.
This variability will be useful in pepper improvement programmes especially for yield and fruit
quality. Niger state has been known to be one of the producing states of pepper in Nigeria.
Despite being one of the leading producing states, the yield obtained by the farmers is far from
their inputs (Anonymous, 1980), thus this research is designed to study, collect and characterize
the land races of pepper in Niger state.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study was carried out at the experimental garden; Centre for Preliminary and Extra-mural
Studies, Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria.
The fruits were collected fresh directly from local farmers during harvest from some of the local
governments growing Pepper in Niger state Tafa, Zungeru, Bida, Munya, Paiko, Mokwa,
Chanchaga, Kontagora, Gwada). After collection, their seeds were removed, dried and enveloped
then labeled with their accession numbers accordingly and kept in a cool and dry place before
planting. The experiment was arranged in a Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD)
The following data were taken during the period of study: fruit length in (cm) using meter rule,
fruit weight in (g), Number of fruit per plant, Number of seeds per fruit and Number of flowers
per plant. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used to analyze the data and Least Significant
Difference (LSD) was used to separate the means. The results are represented in Table 1 below.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The yield parameters were investigated during the period of study to estimate the variations in all
the ten (10) pepper accessions collected, (Table 1). Pepper accessions differed significantly from
one another (p<0.05) with respect to No of flowers/plant, No of fruits/plant, No of seeds/fruit,
weight of fruit/plant and fruit length. With respect to the Number of flowers/plant, the accession
MK2 had the highest with the mean (95.90) while the lowest was from Gwada with the mean
(27.80) but there were no statistical differences among the remaining accessions statistically at
(0.05). The number of fruit/plant was also recorded, where the accession TA had the highest
mean with (30.40) and the lowest was observed from PA, MK1 and CH. With the means 9.70,
10.50, and 10.00 and they were not significant statistically (0.05). The Number of seed/fruit was
found to be the highest from CH (116.50) which was statistically different from all other
Accessions and the lowest from MK2, KT, MU, and BD and are statistically the same but are
different from all other accessions. The highest weight of fruit was observed from BD (63.41)
followed by (51.93) but there were significant differences among the remaining Accessions at
(P<0.05) level of significant. The fruit length was also recorded and the Accessions ZU, PA, KT
and MK2 were statistically different the same although they are different from all other
accessions, however the highest fruit length was from BD. The statistical differences observed in
fruit length is in agreement with the findings of Adetula and Olakojo (2006) who studied
Genetic characterization and evaluation of some pepper (Capsicum frutense) and observed
significant differences among fruit positions, calyx margin, fruit length and fruit width
respectively. Eshbaugh et al. (1983) also recognized 20-30 species in the genus out of which four
were domesticated species. And observed that Fruit weight, though not statistically different,
varied markedly among the pepper accessions with a range of 14.6 to 58.5.
TABLE 1:
SAMPLE
NO OF FLOWER NO OF FRUITS
PER PLANT
PER PLANT
TA
56.10
13.63ab
30.40
ZU
BD
MU
PA
MK1
CH
KT
GW
MK2
67.80
38.90
54.40
43.60
44.10
39.20
47.50
27.80
95.90
12.9bc
6.29ab
13.50ab
7.08ab
8.22ab
5.96ab
8.85ab
4.69a
17.72c
20.40 3.65bed
14.90 1.71ab
24.90 4.81cde
9.70 1.61a
10.50 1.42a
10.00 1.47a
15.90 3.09abc
13.10 2,04de
28.20 4.33de
4.24e
NO OF SEEDS
PER FRUIT
WEIGHT OF FRUIT
76.80 4.11ab
32.25
1.39c
1.03
0.08a
40.66
63.41
17.50
38.35
24.29
16.98
51.93
34.37
42.86
2.22e
2.15g
.72a
2.61de
1.30b
1.17a
2.84f
1.84cd
1.43e
5.47
6.57
0.92
5.89
1.33
0.90
5.98
1.02
5.76
0.22b
0.21c
.12a
.23b
0.16a
0.11a
0.19b
0.08a
0.24b
106.60
90.60
89.30
108.00
74.20
116.50
102.40
78.30
101.00
11.45bcd
58abcd
4.01abcd
12.31cd
5.46a
18.56d
7.60abcd
6.34abc
7.67abcd
Values are means of ten replicate standard error of mean.
Values with the same superscript alphabets in a column are not significantly different at PL 0.05
FRUIT LENGTH
CONCLUSION
From the study, accessions Mk2, Zu and Bd were identified as good sources for pepper
improvement programme, for higher yield and fruit quality improvement.
REFERENCES
Adetula, O.A. and Olakoja, S.A. (2006). Genetic Characterization of some Pepper Asssesions
Capsicum frutescens (L.): The Nigerian ‘Shombo’ Collections. American-Eurasian
J. Agric. & Environ. Sci., 1 (3): 273-281, 2006
Ado, S.G. (1988). Evaluation of Capsicum in Nigeria.PGRC/E Newsletter. No., 17: 16-17.
Ado, S.G.(1990). Pepper Production Guide. Extension publication submitted to the
Horticultural crops Research Programme. I. A. R. Samaru, pp: 12.
Anonymous (1980), Production Year Book (1980). Rome, Italy; Food and Agricultural
Organization. 155pp
Bosland, P.W. (1994). Chiles: history, cultivation, and uses. In: Charalambous, G. (ed.),
spices, herbs and edible fungi. Elsevier Publ., New York, pp. 347-366.
Falusi, O.A. (2007). Germplasm collection of peppers (Capsicum spp.) in Nigeria.Res. on
Crops, 8(3): 765-768.
Eshbaugh,W.H., P. Smith and D.L. Nickrent, 1983. Capsicum touarii (Solanaceae), a new
speeces of pepper from Peru. Brittonia, 35: 55-60.
Mattei, F., Quaghetti, L.,BigottcP.G.&Dipietro, A.(1971). Effects of Different Solar
Radiation Levels as some Morphological Characters of Capsicum AnnuumL.
Eucarpia meeting on Genetics and Breeding of Capsicum, pp: 302-321.
111
PGB63
A REVIEW OF THE ADVANCES IN COTTON BREEDING TECHNIQUES
Yahaya, A.I.1*, Usman, M., Bugaje, S.M., Ibrahim, D.A. and Usman, A.
Institute for Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University Samaru Zaria- Nigeria
Corresponding email:abdulyahyu@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
The breeding achievements in cotton could be viewed from the perspectives of traits such as
yield, earlinesss and fibre quality. Conventional and unconventional techniques are
introduced in selection of these desired traits. Old techniques used include: Plant
introduction, pureline selection, mass selection, pedigree method, bulk method, single seed
descent method, backcross method, heterosis breeding, polyploidy breeding and distant
hybridization. New technologies include mutation breeding, biochemical and molecular
assisted breeding, genetic engineering and marker assisted selection have been used to realize
these objectives. Efforts have been made in cotton genome research, especially development
of genomic resources and tools for basic and applied genetics, genomics and breeding
research. These resources and tools include different types of DNA markers such as
restriction fragment length polymorphism, random amplified polymorphic DNA, Amplified
fragment Length Polymorphism, resistant gene analogues (RGA), sequence related amplified
polymorphism (SRAP), simple sequence repeats or microsatellites, DNA marker based
genetic linkage maps, quantitative trait loci and genes for the artificial chromosome (BAC)
and plant transformation– competent binary (BIBAC) libraries.
Key words: Advances; breeding; conventional; unconventional; genetics
INTRODUCTION
Cottons are not only a world’s leading textile fiber and oilseed crop, but also a crop that is of
significance for oil, energy and bio-energy production (Zhang et al., 2008). Although cottons
are native to tropics and subtropics naturally, including the Americas, Africa and Asia, they
are cultivated in nearly 100 countries. India, China, USA, and Pakistan are the top four cotton
growing countries, accounting for approximately 2/3 of the world’s cotton.
(http://www.ers.usda.gov/Briefing/Cotton/trade.htm).
According to the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations
(http://www.fao.org), the cotton planting area reached about 35 million hectares and the total
world’s cotton production had a record of about 23 million metric tons in 2004/2005. Cotton
products include fibers and seeds that have a variety of uses. Cotton fibers sustain one of the
world’s largest industries, the textile industry, for wearing apparel, home furnishings, and
medical supplies, whereas cottonseeds are widely used for food oil, animal feeds, and
industrial materials (such as soap). Cottonseed oil is ranked fifth in production and
consumption volume among all vegetable oils in the past decades, accounting for 8% of the
world’s vegetable oil consumption. The business stimulated by cotton is hundreds of billion
dollars in the world. In the USA alone, for instance, the annual cotton business revenue
exceeds $120 billion (Anon. 1999). Moreover, nearly a billion barrels of petroleum
worldwide are used in every year to synthesize artificial “synthetic” fibers. Further
improvement of cotton fibers in yield and quality will replace or significantly reduce the
consumption of fossil oil for synthetic fiber production, thus being saved for energy
112
production. Finally, cottonseed oil, the main by-product of cotton fiber production, could be
potentially used as biofuel.
Classical Breeding approach
Advancements in Seed Breeding
In the beginning, adapting to the introduced materials from other countries was the common
practice globally. Then, production of new cultivars was started by emphasizing on selection
and hybridization. Principal objectives of the cotton breeding program are improvement of
yield and fiber quality, precocious, adaptation for specific regional conditions and resistance
to pest and diseases. Lint yield and fiber quality have always been the primary importance to
the breeders because the major profit is usually realized from maximizing yield. Because of
the global phenomenon of climate change, rains set abnormally in most parts of the world and
this limits the vegetation period. Consequently, earliness is considered one of the most
important features of cotton cultivars. Earliness enables the cotton crop to develop during
periods of more favorable moisture and to be harvested before damage from unfavorable
weather conditions. In the 1970/80’s, bacterial blight was the most common cotton disease in
Nigeria causing substantial yield loss. Cotton research breeding programs focused on
developing cotton cultivars tolerant to bacterial blight. This resulted in development of
varieties such as Samcot 8-13 with higher levels of resistance to bacterial blight. In other
parts of the world, a lot of projects were carried out to develop new cotton varieties not only
to maintain or improve yield and fiber quality to levels acceptable to the spinners, but also to
improve colored cotton, resistance to major insect pests and pathogens.
Utilization of certified seeds
Nowadays, it is a common practice in most parts of the cotton producing countries of the
world to renew all of the cotton seeds every year. The rate of certified seeds utilization has
rapidly increased. Farmers are using seeds which are delinted, high quality, and high
germination rate and to which insecticides were applied in recent years. Moreover, delinted
seeds utilization has decreased hoeing and thinning costs. The major innovation in variety
development is the private sector involvement in breeding.
Glandless Cotton
Gossypol, which is a chemical substance normally present in cotton plants and seeds, limits
cotton seed consumption as food and feed. Cottonseed and cottonseed meal are widely used
as
protein supplements in animal feed. Gossypol is the major problem to use cottonseed meal in
the livestock industry as animal feed. The glandless cotton is normal cotton without gossypol.
Breeding studies still continue to develop better glandless cotton varieties.
Modified backcross is a tentative method for combining the effect of intermating and
backcrossing. It may be efficient in breaking the negative correlation between the economic
characters of cotton cultivars. Some results were obtained in the transference of Okra leaf and
frego bract traits into a high yielding cultivar of Cotton, Xu-Zhou 142 by modified backcross.
This method seems to be with an obvidus effect on increasing the lint yield and reducing the
contradictory relations between yield and early maturity of cotton. Besides, there might be a
change of direction in the correlation between yield and disease resistance of cotton. The
coefficient of correlation was change from negative value into a slightly positive one.
Advancements in seed breeding using biotechnology
Recently, biotechnology is used in cotton breeding. Sometimes very limited success has been
achieved using classical breeding methods; for example a variety resistant to wilting disease
caused by a soil-borne fungus (Verticillium dahliae) could not be developed by classical
113
breeding methods. This disease causes 20% reductions in cotton yield in Turkey. Currently,
there is no variety that combines high yield, superior fiber qualities and verticillium
resistance. The use of molecular markers and genome mapping in plant breeding and genetics
has opened new directions for cotton improvement.
Advances in cotton genomic research
According to Zhang et al. (2008), genome research has been demonstrated to be promising
for continued and enhanced crop plant genetic improvement. Therefore, efforts have been
made in cotton genome research, especially development of genomic resources and tools for
basic and applied genetics, genomics, and breeding research. These resources and tools
include different types of DNA markers such as restriction fragment length polymorphism
(RFLP), randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD), amplified fragment length
polymorphism (AFLP), resistance gene analogs (RGA), sequence-related amplified
polymorphism (SRAP), simple sequence repeat (SSR) or microsatellites, DNA marker-based
genetic linkage maps, QTLs and genes for the traits important to agriculture, expressed
sequence tags (ESTs), arrayed large-insert bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) and planttransformation-competent binary BAC (BIBAC) libraries, and genome-wide, cDNA-, or
unigene EST-based microarrays. Efforts are also being made to develop the genome-wide,
BAC/BIBAC-based integrated physical and genetic maps, and sequence the genomes of the
key cotton species. However, compared with other major crops, such as rice, maize, and
soybean, the genome research of cottons is far behind, mainly due to the limited funds
allocated to the species.
DNA Markers and Molecular Linkage Maps
As in most plant species, the early application of DNA markers in cotton genomic research
has been in the form of RFLPs. It is, therefore, not surprising that the first molecular linkage
map of the Gossypium species was constructed from an interspecific G. hirsutum G.
barbadense F2 population based on RFLPs [23]. The map contained 705 loci that were
assembled into 41 linkage groups and spanned 4,675 cM. This map later was further
advanced by Rong et al. (2004), that comprised 2,584 loci at 1.74-cM intervals and covered
all 13 homeologous chromosomes of the allotetraploid cottons, representing the most
complete genetic map of the Gossypium to date. Many of the DNA probes of the map were
also mapped in crosses of the D-genome diploid species G. trilobum G. raimondii Rong et al.
(2004) and the A-genome diploid species G. arboreum G. herbaceum (Desai, et al.,2006).
Detailed comparative analysis of the relationship of gene orders between the tetraploid ADsubgenomes with the maps of the A and D diploid genomes has revealed intriguing insights
on the organization, transmission and evolution of the Gossypium genomes.
Application of Genomic tools in Cotton Genetic Improvement
One of the major goals of genome research is to use the genomic tools developed to promote
or assist continued crop genetic improvement. In cottons, the development of the genomic
resources and tools has allowed addressing many significantly scientific questions that are
impossible to do so before. These include, but not limited to, construction of genome-wide
genetic maps ,identification and mapping of genes and loci controlling traits underlying
qualitative and quantitative inheritance, determination of mechanisms of cotton genome
evolution, and identification and determination of genes that are involved in cotton fiber
initiation, elongation, and secondary cell wall biogenesis. The genomic resources and tools
could be used to promote or facilitate cotton genetic improvement in numerous ways.
Marker-assisted selection (MAS) is likely one of the most important and practical
114
applications at present time and in near future. The MAS technology could offer many
potential benefits to a breeding program. For instance, DNA linked to a gene of interest could
be utilized in early generation of breeding cycle to improve the efficiency of selection. This
approach has a particular advantage when screening for phenotypes in which the selection is
expensive or difficult to perform, as is the case involving recessive or multiple genes,
seasonal or geographical considerations, and late expression of the phenotype. However,
application of MAS in cotton breeding programs is still in its infancy as the major effort of
cotton genome research in the past has been on the development of genomic resources and
tools for the eventual goal of enhanced cotton genetic improvement.
Fiber quality
Zhang et al. (2003) used a G. anomalum introgression line 7235 with good fiber quality
properties to identify molecular markers linked to fiber-strength QTLs. A major QTL,
QTLFS1, was detected at the Nanjing and Heinan field locations (China) and College Station,
Texas, (USA). This QTL was associated with eight markers and explained more than 30% of
the phenotypic variation. QTLFS1 was first thought to be mapped to chromosome 10,
however, further study showed that this QTL was located on LGD03 [67]. Guo et al. (2003)]
showed that the specific SCAR4311920 marker could be applied to large-scale screening for
the presence or absence of this major fiber strength QTL in breeding populations. The DNA
markers tightly linked to this QTL could be useful for developing commercial cultivars with
enhanced fiber length properties (Shen et al.2005). Wang et al. (2006) identified a stable
fiber length QTL, qFL-D2-1, simultaneously in four environments in Xiangzamian. The high
degree of stability suggests this QTL might be particularly valuable for use in MAS
programs. Chee et al. (2005)] dissected the molecular basis of genetic variation governing 15
parameters that reflect fiber length by applying a detailed RFLP map to 3,662 BC3F2 plants
from 24 independently derived BC3 families utilizing G. barbadense as the donor parent. The
discovery of many QTLs unique to each trait indicates that maximum genetic gain will
require breeding efforts that target each trait. Lacape et al. (2005) performed QTL analysis of
11 fiber properties in BC1, BC2, and BC2S1 backcross generations derived from the cross
between G. hirsutum “Guazuncho ” and G. barbadense “VH8.” They detected 15, 12, 21, and
16 QTLs for length, strength, fineness, and color, respectively, in one or more populations.
The results showed that favorable alleles came from the G. barbadense parent for the majority
of QTLs, and cases of co-localization of QTLs for different traits were more frequent than
isolated positioning. Taking these QTL-rich chromosomal regions into consideration, they
identified 19 regions on 15 different chromosomes as target regions for the marker-assisted
introgression strategy. The availability of DNA markers linked to G. barbadense QTLs
promises to assist breeders in transferring and maintaining valuable traits from exotic sources
during cultivar development.
Cytoplasmic male sterility
In cotton, cytoplasmic male sterility conditioned by the D8 alloplasm (CMS-D8) is
independently restored to fertility by its specific D8 restorer (D8R) and by the D2 restorer
(D2R) that was developed for the D2 cytoplasmic male sterile alloplasm (CMS-D2). Zhang
and Stewart (2001) concluded that the two restorer loci are nonallelic, but are tightly linked
with an average genetic distance of 0.93 cM. The D2 restorer gene is redesignated as Rf1, and
Rf2 is assigned to the D8 restorer gene. The identification of molecular markers closely
linked to restorer genes of the cytoplasmic male sterile could facilitate the development of
parental lines for hybrid cotton. Guo et al. (1998) found that one RAPD marker fragment,
designated OPV-15(300), was closely linked with the fertility-restoring gene Rf1. Zhang and
Stewart (2004) identified RAPD markers linked to the restorer gene and, furthermore,
converted the three RAPD markers into reliable and genome-specific sequence tagged site
115
(STS) markers. Liu et al. (2003) determined that the Rf1 locus is located on the long arm of
chromosome 4. Two RAPD and three SSR markers were identified to be closely linked to the
Rf1 gene. These markers are restorer-specific and should be useful in MAS for developing
restorer parental lines. Yin et al. (2006) further constructed a high-resolution genetic map of
Rf1 containing 13 markers in a genetic distance of 0.9 cM. They constructed a physical map
for the Rf1 locus and enclosed the possible location of the Rf1 gene to a minimum of two
BAC clones spanning an interval of approximately 100 kb between two clones, designated as
081-05K and 052-01N. Work to isolate the Rf1 gene in cotton is now in progress.
Resistance to diseases and insect pests
Breeding for disease resistance is of great importance in cotton breeding program. To
facilitate analysis, cloning, and manipulation of the genes conferring resistance to different
pathogens, including bacteria, fungi, viruses, and nematodes, He et al. (2004) isolated and
characterized the family of nucleotide-banding site-leucine-rich repeat (NBS-LRR)-encoding
genes or resistance gene analogues (RGAs) in the Upland cotton cv. Auburn 634 genome.
Genetic mapping of a sample (21 genes) of the RGAs indicated that the gene family resides
on a limited number of the cotton AD-genome chromosomes with those from a single
subfamily tending to cluster on the cotton genetic map and more RGAs in the A subgenome
than in the D subgenome. Of the 16 RGAs mapped, two happened to be comapped with the
cotton bacterial blight resistance QTLs previously mapped by Wright et al. (1998). Since
nearly 80% of the genes ( 40 genes) cloned to date that confer resistance to bacteria, fungi,
viruses, and nematodes are contributed by the NBS-LRR gene family, the cotton RGAs of the
NBS-LRR family have provided valuable tools for cloning, characterization, and
manipulation of the resistant genes to different pathogens and pests in cottons. Root-knot
nematodes (RKN), Meloidogyne incognita, can cause severe yield loss in cotton. Wang et al.
(2006) identified one SSR marker CIR316 on the linkage group A03 tightly linked to a major
RKN resistant gene (rkn1) in the resistant cultivar G. hirsutum “Aacla NemX.” In a
companion study, a bulked segregant analysis (BSA) combined with AFLP was used to
identify additional molecular markers linked to rkn1 (Wang and Roberts, 2006). An AFLP
marker linked to rkn1 designated as GHACC1 was converted to a cleaved amplified
polymorphic sequence (CAPS) marker. These two markers have potential for utilization in
MAS. Shen et al. (2006) identified RFLP markers on chromosome 7 and chromosome 11
showing significant association with RKN resistance from the Auburn 634 source, a different
source of resistant germplasm than Acala NemX. The association was further confirmed by
detection of a minor and a major dominant QTL on chromosomes 7 and 11, respectively,
using SSR markers. Ynturi et al. identified two SSR markers which together accounted for
31% of the variation in galling index. The marker BNL 3661 is mapped to the short arm of
chromosome 14 while BNL 1231 to the long arm of chromosome 11. The association of two
different chromosomes with RKN resistance suggests at least two genes are involved in
resistance to RKN.
Bacterial blight caused by the pathogen Xanthomonas campestris pv. malvacearum (Xcm) is
another economically important disease in cotton. Wright et al. (1998) and Rungi et al.
(2002) both used mapped RFLP markers to investigate the chromosomal location of genes
conferring resistance to the bacterial blight pathogen. The mapping data suggest that the
resistance locus segregates with a marker on chromosome 14 known to be linked to the
broad-spectrum B12 resistance gene originally from African cotton cultivars. AFLPs and
SSRs were also used to search for novel markers linked to the Xcm resistance locus to
facilitate introgression of this trait into G. barbadense through MAS.
CONCLUSION
116
A significant amount of genomic resources and tools has been available in cottons though
cotton genomics research is far behind those of other major crops such as rice, maize, wheat,
and soybean. These resources and tools have allowed identifying and mapping many genes
and QTLs of importance to cotton fiber quality, fiber yield, and biotic and abiotic stresses and
addressing several significant questions to plant biology in general and to cotton in particular.
Nevertheless, many efforts are needed to further develop the resources and tools and to make
the tools readily usable in applications in order to fully and effectively use them in cotton
genetic improvement and biology research. In particular, the following areas of cotton
genomics research should be emphasized.
(i) Development of whole-genome BAC/BIBAC-based, integrated physical maps of cottons.
There is no whole-genome, robust BAC/BIBAC-based, integrated physical/genetic map that
has been developed for cottons. The maps should be developed for at least two species of
Gossypium. One is the Upland cotton that produces 90% of the world’s cotton whereas the
other is G. raimondii, the species having the smallest genome among all Gossypium species,
thus likely having highest density of genes. This research is emphasized because it has been
proven in model and other species, including Arabidopsis, rice, Drosophila, human, mouse,
and chicken, that whole-genome integrated physical/genetic maps provide powerful platforms
and “freeways” for many, if not all, modern genetics and genomics research ;development of
the integrated physical maps will allow rapidly and efficiently integrating all existing genetic
maps, mapped genes and QTLs, and BAC and BIBAC resources and cotton unigene ESTs,
and accelerate the efficiency and reduce the cost of research in all areas by manifold.
(ii) QTL fine mapping. Many genes and QTLs that are important to cotton fiber yield fiber
quality, and biotic and abiotic stresses have been genetically mapped, but two problems are
apparent. The first one is that almost all of the QTLs were mapped using F2, BC1, or early
segregating generations in a single or a limited number of environments. Since quantitative
traits are readily subjected to environmental variation, the mapping results using the early
generations in a single or a limited number of environments would vary from experiments to
experiments. The other problem is that the genetic distances between DNA markers and most
of the QTLs are too far to be used for MAS. Therefore, it is of significance to fine map the
QTLs using large and advanced generation or homozygous populations, such as RILs and
DHs, in multiple environments, and closely linked DNA markers, for which advantage of
integrated physical maps could be taken. In addition to accurate mapping of the QTLs and
development of DNA markers that are well-suited (closely linked and user-friendly) for
MAS, fine mapping is also an essential step toward the final isolation of the QTL genes by
map-based cloning (Zang, 2007). The isolated genes are not only the sources for molecular
breeding via genetic transformation, but also the most desirable for marker development for
MAS because there is no recombination between the gene and its derived marker.
(iii) Sequencing of one or more key cotton genomes. While it is costly using the current
sequencing technology, whole-genome sequencing is a most-efficient method to discover and
decode all cotton genes and provides a most-desired and most-fine integrated physical and
genetic map of the cotton genome. Comparative genomics studies demonstrated that the gene
contents and orders are highly conserved among the genomes of Gossypium species even
they are significantly different in genome size (Desai et al. 2006 and Rong et al.2004). Based
on this result, G. raimondii is an excellent choice to be sequenced because it has the smallest
genome among all Gossypium species though it is not cultivated. If an integrated physical
map is available for the major cultivated cotton, G. hirsutum, that has a three-fold larger
genome than G. raimondii, the sequence information of G. raimondii could be readily
117
transferred to the cultivated cotton by using the BAC end sequences of its integrated physical
map as anchors.
(iv) ESTs from nonfiber and nonovary tissues and fibers at the secondary cell wall deposition
stage. As shown above, the number of cotton ESTs available in GenBank has been increased
significantly in the past few years; however, the distribution of the ESTs among tissue
sources are extremely biased. The numbers of ESTs from both nonfiber/nonovary tissues and
fibers at the secondary cell wall deposition stage (15–45 dpa), particularly after 20 dpa, are
especially small. The former set of expressed genes, despite of not directly contributing to
fiber yield and quality, is of significance to fiber yield and quality, whereas there is no doubt
that the later set of expressed genes directly contribute to the fiber strength.
(v) Profiling and identification of genes involved in individual biological processes and
conditions with emphasis on those involved in fiber development. Development and
availability of cDNA- or unigene EST-based microarrays have provided unprecedented
opportunities for research of molecular biology, functional genomics, and evolutionary
genomics, however, cotton research in these regards are very limited. Identifying and
characterizing genes that are involved in the processes of fiber development, plant growth
and development, and biotic and abiotic stresses will greatly facilitate our understanding of
underlying molecular basis of these processes in cottons, and thus, enhance breeders’ ability
to cotton genetic improvement.
(vi) Translating the gene activities or expressions at different tissues and stages into fiber
yield and fiber quality, thus assisting in cotton breeding. The genes that are involved in fiber
initiation (Wu et al. 2006), elongation (Arpat et al, 2004), and secondary cell wall deposition
have been identified from several genotypes of cottons, but it is unknown about what the upor down regulation, or active expression of fiber genes at a developmental stage and organ
means to final fiber yield and/or quality. For instance, does the active expression of a gene at
fiber elongation stage in fiber suggest longer fibers? Studies in this regard are essential to use
the gene expression data in cotton germplasm analysis and breeding.
REFERENCES
Anon. (1999). Agricultural Statistics Board 1999; National Cotton Council of America
http://www.cotton.org/news/releases/2003/cotton-trade.cfm).
Arpat, A., Waugh, M and Sullivan, J. P. (2004). Functional genomics of cell elongation in
developing cotton fibers. Plant Molecular Biology, vol. 54, pp. 911–929.
Chee, P., Draye, X. and Jiang, C. X.(2005 .Molecular dissection of interspecific variation
between Gossypium hirsutum and Gossypium barbadense (cotton) by a backcross-self
approach: III. Fiber length, Theoretical and Applied Genetics, vol. 111, pp. 772–78.
118
Desai ,A., Chee, P. W., Rong, J. May, O. L. and Paterson, A. H.(2006). Chromosome
structural
changes in diploid and tetraploid genomes of Gossypium..Genome, vol. 49, no. 4, pp.
336–345.
Draye, X., Chee, P. and Jiang, C.-X. (2005). Molecular dissection of interspecific variation
between Gossypium hirsutum and G. barbadense (cotton) by a backcross-self
approach: II. Fiber fineness. Theoretical and Applied Genetics, vol. 111, no. 4, pp.
764–771.
Dreher, K.., Morris, M. Khairallah, M., Ribaut, J.M., Pandey, S. and Srinivasan, G .(2000). Is
marker-assisted selection cost-effective compared to conventional plant breeding
methods? The case of quality protein maize,” in Proceedings of the 4th Annual
Conference of the International Consortium on Agricultural Biotechnology Research
(ICABR ’00), Ravello, Italy.Pp. 203–236.
He, L. C., Du, G. and Covaleda, L.(2004). Cloning, characterization, and evolution of the
NBS
encoding resistance gene analogue family in polyploid cotton (Gossypium hirsutmL.).
Molecular Plant-Microbe Interaction, vol. 17, pp. 1234–1241.
Lacape, J.-M. , Nguyen, T.-B., and Courtois, B. (2005). QTL analysis of cotton fiber quality
using multiple Gossypium hirsutum x Gossypium barbadense backcross generations.
Crop Science, vol. 45, no. 1, pp. 123–140, 2005.
Liu, L., Guo, W., Zhu, X. and T. Zhang(2003).Inheritance and fine mapping of fertility
restoration for cytoplasmic male sterility in Gossypium hirsutum L.,” Theoretical and
Applied Genetics, vol. 106, no. 3, pp. 461–469.
Reinisch, A. J., Dong, J.-M., Brubaker, C. L. Stelly, D. M., Wendel, J. F. and Paterson, A. H.
(1994). A detailed RFLPmap of cotton, Gossypium hirsutum x Gossypium
barbadense: chromosome organization and evolution in a disomic polyploid genome.
Genetics, vol. 138, no. 3, pp. 829–847.
Rong, J. K.., Abbey, C. and Bowers, J. E. (2004). A 3347-locus genetic recombination map
of
sequence-tagged sites reveals types of genome organization, transmission and
evolution of cotton (Gossypium),” Genetics, vol. 166, pp. 389–417.
Shen, X., Becelaere, G. V.,Kumar, P., Davis, R. F., May, O. L. and Chee, P.(2006). QTL
mapping for resistance to root-knot nematodes in the M-120 RNR Upland cotton line
(Gossypium hirsutum L.) of the Auburn 623 RNR source, Theoretical and
Applied Genetics, vol. 113, no. 8, pp. 1539–1549.
Shen, X., Guo, W. and Zhu, X.(2005). Molecular mapping of QTLs for fiber qualities in
three
diverse lines in Upland cotton using SSR markers, Molecular Breeding, vol. 15, no. 2,
pp. 169–181.
Shi, Y.-H., Zhu, S.-W. and Mao. X.-Z. (2006). Transcriptome profiling, molecular biological,
and physiological studies reveal a major role for ethylene in cotton fiber cell
elongation,” The Plant Cell, vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 651–664.
Wang, C. and Roberts, P. A.(2006). Development of AFLP and derived CAPS markers for
root
knot nematode resistance in Cotton. Euphytica, vol. 152, no. 2, pp. 185–196.
Wu, Y., Machado, A. C., White, R. G., Llewellyn, D. J. and E. S. Dennis(2006). Expression
profiling identifies gene expressed early during lint fiber initiation in cotton. Plant
Cell Physiology, vol. 18, pp. 651–664.
Wu, C., Sun, S., Lee, M.-K., Xu, Z. Y., Ren, C. and. Zhang, H.-B(2005). Whole genome
119
physical mapping: an overview on methods for DNA fingerprinting,” in The
Handbook of Plant Genome Mapping: Genetic and Physical Mapping, Meksem, K.
and Kahl, G.( Eds)., pp. 257–284.
Yin, J., Guo, W. Yang, L. Liu, L. and Zhang, T.(2006).Physical mapping of the Rf1 fertility
restoring gene to a 100 kb region in cotton, Theoretical and Applied Genetics, vol.
112, no. 7, pp. 1318–1325, 2006.
Zhang, H.-B. (2007). Map-based cloning of genes and QTLs: In Plant Molecular Mapping
and
Breeding, C. Kole and A. Abbott (Eds)., Springer, New York, NY, USA.
Zhang, J. F. and Stewart, J. McD. (2001). Inheritance and genetic relationships of the D8 and
D2-2 restorer genes for cotton cytoplasmic male sterility.Crop Science, vol. 41, no. 2,
pp. 289–294.
Zhang, H.-B. and Wu, C.(2006). BAC as tools for genome sequencing. Plant Physiology and
Biochemistry, vol. 39, no. 3-4, pp. 195–209.
Zhang,v and Wing, R. A. (1997). Physical mapping of the rice genome with BACs. Plant
Molecular Biology, vol. 35, no. 1-2, pp. 115–127.
Zhang,H., Yaning, L., Baohua, W. and Peng W. C.(2008). Recent Advances in Cotton
Genomics. International Journal of Plant Genomics, 2008:1-20.
PGB64
ASSESSMENT OF CONSUMPTION,
UTILIZATION AND NUTRIENT
COMPOSITION OF SPICES CONSUMED IN NORTH CENTRAL NIGERIA
Shailong, C.N. and Ugwuona, F.U.
Department of Home Science and Management, Faculty of Agriculture, Nasarawa State
University, Keffi.
Shabu-Lafia Campus, Lafia.
Corresponding email: amakashailong@gmasil.com/ ugwuonafu@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
This study evaluated the consumption pattern and nutrient composition of local spices used
by households of North Central Nigeria. A total of 150 respondents (68 adult males and 82
adult females) were interviewed using structured questionnaires in their native homes; and
samples of spices commonly consumed in the area analysed for nutrient composition. Spices
available and commonly consumed by the households include clove, cinnamon, basil leaf,
black pepper, Ethiopian pepper, garlic and ginger. Ginger and garlic were the most
commonly consumed. Most of the households (57.3%) valued these spices for their
120
flavouring properties while about 25.3% of the households valued them for medicinal uses
and the rest 17.3% valued them mostly for preservative properties. Also the type and
quantityof spice being used for food flavouring usually dependent mostly on the type of food
being prepared. The spices were rich in most food nutrients, including protein, fats and oil,
fibre and ash. The high fibre, oil and ash contents are good indication of their being good
source of phytochemical antioxidants, vitamins and minerals. These spices are thus excellent
sources of nutrients and valued, consumed and utilized by the people.
Key words: Consumption, utilization, nutrient composition, spices.
INTRODUCTION
A spice is a dried seed, fruit, root, bark or leaf or vegetative substance used in nutritionally
insignificant quantity as a food additive for the purpose of flavour, colour or as a preservative
that kills harmful bacteria or prevents their growth (Musa and Haydar, 2004). Different spices
and herbs have different degrees of nutrients or nutrient composition (Udeala, 1980). Spices
add flavour, relish, or piquancy to foods. Spices consist of rhizomes, barks, leaves, roots,
flowers, fruits, seeds and other parts of the plant while herbs are leaves of low-growing
shrubs. Common spices
include parsley, thyme, scent leaves, rosemary, savory, sage
and celery leaves (Parry, 1969).
Spices are indispensable components of cuisines used as accessory foods mainly for
flavouring food to improve palatability (Okafor, 1987; Okigbo, 1997). Spices have been
defined by the Food and Drug Administration as aromatic vegetable substances used for
seasoning of food and from them no portion of any volatile oil or other flavouring principle
has been removed and are free from artificial colouring matter, adulterants and impurities
(Farrel, 1990; Dorant and Brandt, 1993). Spices are used in small quantities and their
contribution to nutrient intake is very minimal but many are rich in food nutrients, including
protein, carbohydrate, fibre and minerals (Nielson, 2002). Spices are rich sources of vitamins,
especially vitamin A, C, and B, protein and mineral such as calcium, sodium, potassium and
iron. Spices of international trade used globally include sweet and red pepper, cinnamon,
mustard, nutmeg, marjoram, oregano, black pepper, ginger, garlic, rosemary, thyme and basil
leave (Kramlich et al.,1973).
In addition to adding flavour to foods and beverages, spices are valued for their nutritional,
antioxidant, antimicrobial, insect repellant and medicinal properties (Farrel, 1990). Spices
are used as flavour enhancers because of their health-protective phytochemicals which can
help to fight cancer and other degenerative diseases. Spices have tremendous importance in
being used as ingredients in food, alcoholic beverages, medicine, perfumery, cosmetics,
colouring and also as ornamental plants (Sharma, 2005). Spices when added to food can also
lead to complex secondary effects such as salt and sugar reduction, improvement of texture
and extension of shelf life. The basic effects of Spices in food and confectionary could be for
flavouring, aroma, deoxidizing, colouring and/or preservation. Spices
make food and
confectionary more appetizing and palatable (Ravindran et al., 2002).
Nigeria is endowed with many edible plants many of whose fruits and vegetable are used as
spices in many traditional homes. However many Nigerians do not value spices and ignore
121
their uses as food ingredients. Evidences have shown that many of these Nigerian spices apart
from their regular flavouring effects also improve nutrient content and shelf life of food.
Many are health promoting. This study was therefore poised to examine availability, food
uses and nutrient composition of commonly existing spices in North central Nigeria. The
study will be of great benefit to the society at large in providing information about
availability and nutrient composition of spices in the area for more practical application in
homes and industries.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The data for this study were obtained from a sample survey of 150 households in Lafia,
Nasarawa State of North central Nigeria between August and November, 2010. The survey
was designed to gather general information on the socio-economic status, availability and
consumption patterns of spices among households, for example, types, occurrence and
frequency of utilization of spices in the study area. The target population for the survey was
adults of ages 20 years and above with varied bio data. The subjects’ sex, age distribution,
religion, educational qualification and working experience were used as the criterion for their
socio-economic status.
Samples of spices commonly consumed in the area were also collected from the respondents
and analysed for nutrient composition.
Chemical analysis of spices: Each of the spice sample was milled into a homogenous blend.
Moisture, crude protein, crude fat, crude fibre and ash contents were determined in duplicates
by the method of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists (AOAC, 2000). Moisture
was determined as the loss in weight after heating 2g subsample of each spice in a vacuum
oven at 105OC for 4h. Nitrogen was determined by wet digestion analysis of the micro
Kjelhdal method, and nitrogen was multiplied by 6.25 to estimate crude protein content
(Pearson, 1976). Crude fat was estimated by exhaustive extraction of a subsample (5g) of
each of the spices with petroleum ether (boiling point, 40- 60OC) using a soxhlet apparatus.
The fat-free extract after ether extraction was digested alternatively with 1.25MH2SO4 and
with 1.25% NAOH under specified conditions. The loss in weight on ignition of the residue at
600OC was reported as crude fibre content while the remainder was reported as the ash
content. After wet-digestion of a subsample (5g), Calcium was determined using atomic
absorption spectrophotometer (AAS) while Phosphorus was determined using the
Vanadomolybdate method (AOAC, 2000)
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Demographic Characteristics of the respondents
Table 1 below shows that 54.7% of the respondents were females while 45.3% were males.
Majority of the respondents fall within the age range 40 years and above and were followed
by those of 30–39years (21.3%) and 20-29 years (12.0%). The table also show that about
60.0% of the respondents were Muslims while 40% of them were Christians. Thus the
people were predominantly Muslims and Christians intermingling freely among each other.
The education attainment of the people range from zero education (illiteracy) (14.7%),
122
primary school (58.7%), secondary school( 20%) and higher institution (6.7%) and 14.7%
that have been to secondary school, tertiary institution and never been to school respectively.
Table 1: Demographic characteristics of the respondents
Variable
Frequency
Percentage
Male
68
45.3
Female
82
54.7
Total
150
100
20-29
18
12.0
30-39
32
21.3
40 and above
100
66.7
Total
150
100
Christianity
60
40.0
Islam
90
60.0
Total
150
100
Never been to school
22
14.7
Primary school
88
58.7
Secondary school
30
20.0
Tertiary Institution
10
6.7
Total
150
100
Less than 1-5years
38
18.7
6-11years
84
56.7
12years and above
38
25.3
Total
150
Sex
Age of respondents
Religion
Level of education
Years of experience
123
Commonly available and frequently consumed spices
Table 2 shows the list of commonly available and utilized spices in the area. In all, 7 spices,
including cloves, cinnamon, basil leaf, black pepper, Ethiopian pepper, garlic and ginger
were very popular among the respondents. However, ginger and garlic were more frequently
used by most of the respondents. These spices were used as food ingredients in soups, sauce,
meal and meat. Ginger and garlic ranked high in utilization because of their high demand in
spicing smoked and grilled meat and fishes which are very popular in the area. Ginger and
garlic were also claimed to increase the shelf life of meat and local beverages such as” kunu
zaki” (a popular cereal based drink of the locality).
Table 2: Spices available and frequency of utilization in the study area
Occurrence
Freq.
Utilization
%
Freq.
%
Names of spices
Clove (Kalipari)
6
4.0
10
6.7
Cinnamon ( Fasokori)
8
5.3
4
2.7
Basil leaf
8
5.3
16
10.7
Black pepper (Masoro)
6
4.0
41
28.0
Ethiopian pepper (kimfer)
8
5.3
12
8.0
Garlic (Tarfarnwa)
43
28.7
27
18.0
Ginger (Chitta)
71
38.2
39
25.9
Total
150
100
150
100
Uses of Spices among respondents
Table 3 shows that more than half (57.3%) of the respondents use spices regularly mainly for
flavouring purposes. Out of the 150 respondents interviewed, only 17.3% use spices for
preservative purposes while 25.3% use spices for medicinal purposes. It is evident that most
of these people do not recognize or do not understand the preservative effects of spices in
food. Predominantly spices are used to give flavor, aroma and taste in food and this is in
agreement with Parry (1969) who opined that spice and herbs are used to give flavor, aroma
and taste in food. Interestingly, 25.3% of the respondents indicated that they use spices for
medical purposes which agrees with that of Ravindran et al (2002) who showed that spices
and herbs possess antimicrobial and pharmaceutical properties. These people should be made
to realize the importance of spices as flavouring, preservation and medicinal ingredients.
124
Table 3: Recognized functions and application of spices by respondents
Variables
Frequency of
Percentage
Applications
Preservative purpose
26
17.3
To give aroma, flavour and 86
57.3
taste in food
Medical purpose
38
25.3
Total
150
100
Table 4 summaries the most popular reasons and the influencing factors why people use
spices in the area. Seasons or ceremonies, type of food prepared and sometimes health
condition of the consumers determine the extent and the type of spice to use if at all in food
preparations. The type of food prepared most frequently determines the type and quantity of
spice to be used as indicated by their responses (56%). About 25.3% of the respondents agree
that their choice of spice dependent on the health condition of the consumers and health
promoting effect of the particular spice.
125
Table 4: Reasons for using and factors influencing choice and uses of spices in food
Reasons
Frequency
Percentage
flavouring
28
18.7
Aroma enhancing
30
20.0
Preservation
26
17.3
Flavoring, aroma enhancing 66
and preservation
44.0
Total
150
100
Influencing factors
Freq .of influence
Percentage
Ceremonies
28
18.7
Type of food consumed
84
56.0
Health promoting
38
25.3
Total
150
100
Nutrient composition of the commonly consumed spice in the study area
The moisture content of the spice samples ranged from 7.95% for cinnamon to 14.11% for
garlic. Ginger had 12.34% while black pepper had 11.92% and basil leaf had 10.76% of
moisture. Ethiopian pepper had moisture content of 10.98%. most of the spices except ginger
and garlic with moisture content higher than 12% are most likely to be shelf stable at ambient
condition with little or no microbial growth. However both ginger and garlic in this study are
likely to be susceptible to high load of bacteria and mould on long term storage. The spices
were high in crude protein, crude fibre, lipid and ash. Protein contents ranged from 6.75% for
cinnamon to 25.40% for garlic. Clove had 16.39% crude protein while basil leaf had 16.64%
crude protein. Crude fibre ranged from 7.69% in basil leaf to 41.06% in cinnamon while lipid
content ranged from 2.36% in cinnamon to 17.73% in ginger. The high content of crude fibre
is a good indication of likely high presence of most health-promoting phytochemicals while
the high lipid contents are likely to be good source of fat- soluble vitamins and natural antioxidants in the spices (Hirasa and Takemasa, 1998). The spices were also high in ash content,
indicating likely high presence of most vital minerals as indicated in calcium and phosphorus
contents of these spices. These spices are therefore good source of most food nutrient; thus
apart from their flavouring, preservative, and medicinal effects, they could also be sourced
for adequate nutrient intakes.
126
127
Table 5: Nutrient Composition of spices commonly consumed in the study area
(Weight (g) per 100 grams of sample)
Moistur
Crude
Crude
e
Protein
Fibre
Cloves
8.79
16.39
26.11
6.21
6.93
35.57
1.47
0.21
Cinnamon
7.95
6.75
41.06
2.36
7.89
33.99
0.79
0.23
Scent leaf
10.76
16.64
7.69
2.77
6.55
46.29
1.31
0.19
black 11.92
7.22
37.58
6.11
7.49
29.77
1.51
0.18
black 10.98
11.05
36.42
10.43
4.52
26.55
0.65
0.16
Sample
African
Lipids
Ash
Digestible
Calcium
Phosphor
us
Carbohydrates
pepper
Ethiopian
pepper
128
Ginger
12.34
10.45
26.19
17.73
13.05
20.24
0.45
0.44
Garlic
14.11
25.50
13.31
14.22
6.43
30.82
1.17
0.52
PGB65
MORPHOLOGICAL DIVERSITY OF ACHA (FONIO) (Digitaria exilis and Digitaria iburua)
GERMPLASM AND EVALUATION OF GENETIC VARIATIONS USING RAPD-PCR
TECHNIQUES IN NIGERIA
E. H. Kwon-Ndung and F. Odeyemi2
1
Department of Botany, Federal University Lafia. Nigeria.
2
National Biotechnology Development Agency, Abuja.
Corresponding email: kwon_ndung@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
This study evaluated thirty-five Acha or Fonio (Digitaria spp) accessions for morphological and genetic
characterization in order to unlock genetic potential of each variety for breeding purposes. The accessions were
planted in plots measuring 2m by 3m, and replicated three times in a randomized complete block design. Data
were collected using a 1m2 quadrant across plots in determining some morpho-agronomic parameters. RAPD
129
protocol was used in the molecular classification of the accessions. Data obtained was analyzed statistically
using ANOVA, correlation and cluster analysis. Morphological variations and growth performance of the
accessions were observed to have an influence on grain yield. Jakah variety had the highest yield of
176.24kg/plot which differed significantly (p<0.05) with other accessions while morphological features of
peduncle length, internodes length, spikelet per panicle number and plant height were observed to have
positive correlation (P<0.05) with grain yield. Also negative correlation was observed (P<0.05) between days
to 50% flowering and grain yield, portraying an inverse relationship between the two. On the other hand,
morphology and molecular cluster analysis gave different number of clusters which was indicative of the need
to use the two techniques for classification of fonio in Nigeria. Therefore the study has established the
existence of diversity in morphological/ traits of Acha accessions. Also, the study has also confirmed the use of
RAPD-PCR in unraveling the phylo-genetic diversity of Acha accession.
Keywords: accessions, breeding, genetic diversity, phylogeny, morpho-agronomic
INTRODUCTION
Acha (Digitaria exilis Kipp. Stapf and Digitaria iburua Stapf) is probably the oldest African cereal. It
is sometimes considered as “a small seed with a big promise” provides food early in the season when other
crops are yet to mature for harvest (Ibrahim, 2001). Acha grains are the tastiest and most nutritious of all grains
(NRC, 1996) and is said to contain 7% crude protein, which is high in leucine (19.8%), methionine and cystine
of about (7%) and valine (5.8%) (Temple and Bassa, 1991). It forms the staple food in some of the producing
areas where it is processed into various kinds of menus (Kwon-Ndung et al., 2001). In Nigeria, about 70,00
metric tons of the crop is produced annually (CBN, 1998) and that the economic returns of Acha when
computed showed that it is profitable to grow the crop compared to other crops like rice, sorghum and cowpea
(Dauda and Luka, 2003). Though the crop has been completely neglected in the past (Kwon-Ndung and Misari,
1999), it is now considered as an important crop for improvement as a cultivated species (Ibrahim, 2001,
Morales-Payan et al., 2002).
In Africa, Acha is known as a savannah plant, which does not prosper in soils with salinity problems. It
has low water demands, and survives strong droughts (Harlan 1993; Hilu et al., 1997). According to KwonNdung et al., (2001), the existence of different types of varieties under cultivation was a common feature in
Kaduna and Plateau States where the highest numbers of Acha accessions in Nigeria have been assembled. The
adult plant reaches about 50 cm in height, and flowering usually occurs about 6 to 8 weeks after emergence.
130
Bees are known to visit the flowers and apparently play a role in flower fertilization. There are many cultivars
with varying periods of maturity of 90-130 days (Purseglove, 1975).
Markers are identifiable DNA sequences found at specific location of the genome and transmitted by
the standard laws of inheritance from one generation to the next. There are many different kinds of molecular
markers including restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs), random amplified polymorphic DNA
(RAPDs), amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLPs), microsatellites, and single nucleotide
polymorphisms (SNPs) (Kumar et al., 2009). At present, among several molecular approaches employed to
assess genetic diversity and relationship in plant species, RAPD (random amplified polymorphic DNA)
analysis is the simplest and least laborious method. The information on genetic diversity and relationship
within and among crop species is essential for the efficient utilization of plant geneti resource collections
(Irwin et al., 1998). Diversity studies have been carried out in the Ethiopia/Eritrea area, which, like most areas,
is threatened by loss of landraces due to introduction of improved varieties from elsewhere (Edossa, et al.,
2010). Evaluating germplasm diversity can help to identify landraces with the greatest novelty and thus are
most suitable for rescue or incorporation into crop improvement programs. There is paucity of information in
the area of morphological characteristics of Acha and the genetic diversity. Therefore, there is need for
evaluation of some Acha or Fonio accessions for morphological and genetic characterization in order to unlock
genetic potential of each variety for breeding purposes. This study aimed at investigating this and developing
potential diagnostic tools through PCR analysis.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The thirty five Acha accessions were obtained from the out station of the National Cereals Research Institute,
(NCRI) Badeggi, Niger State, located in Riyom, Jos. Plateau State. The field work was done at the Research
and Experimental plot of the Plant Science & Biotechnology Unit of the Department of Biological Science
Nasarawa State University, Keffi (80 321N 80 181E). The molecular procedure was done at the Biotechnology
Laboratory of the Science and Technology Complex (SHESTCO) and Nigerian Institute of Science Laboratory
Technology (NISLT) Samonda, Ibadan. The accessions were planted in plots measuring 2m by 3m and
replicated three times in a randomized complete block design (RCBD). The trial was planted by uniform
broadcasting of weighted seeds across plots. Hand weeding was done at 6, 10 and 30 weeks after planting
(WAP) and basal application of fertilizer was carried out at 3 WAP using 20kg N per hectare, 30kg P 205/ ha
and 30kg K20/ha. Morpho-agronomic descriptions such as, physical characteristic of seed, germination
percentage, days to 50% flowering, tiller number per plant, leaf area, peduncle length, internode length, days to
maturity, grain yield, spike number per panicle and plant height at harvest were determined by collecting data
131
using a 1m2 quadrant across plots. The data were subjected to statistical analysis using Duncan Multiple Range
Test procedure to separate the cluster means. For genetic characterization, a total of thirty five accessions of
Acha were grown in the screen house in polythene bags containing topsoil. Young leaves were harvested from
3weeks old seedlings, put in a sealable plastic bag, labeled properly and were used immediately for DNA
extraction following the methods of Dellaporta et al., (1983). The extracted pure Acha DNA was quantified
using spectrophotometer before PCR analysis to obtain required concentration for the research work. PCR
amplification was performed according to Arunyawat (1997), using primers synthesized by Operon
Technologies (USA).
RESULTS
Variations in the physical characteristics of Digitaria spp accessions seed in this study showed that the thirty
five accessions have three main colours; White, Brown and Light Brown. Ampios, Napas, Kin, Gong-arandong, Chun-hoss 1, Jakah, Munsung, Suhn, Napiya, Sha’alak, Dinat, Jipel, Gotip, Shalak, Tsala, Gopantor
and Gwabi seed were of white colour. Gindiri 1, Kureep, Sheng, Tishi, Lalaku, Gindiri 2, Nkpwos, Ndat,
Namuruk, Nashileng and Badama had light brown coloured seed while Chun-hoss 2, Chisu, Nding, Gonghalla, Chunpyeng, Npyeng and Maan seed were brown in colour while seed weights for all the accessions
ranged between 0.013g and 0.093g. The morphology of the growing sections (Table 1) showed that there are
variatzions in the tiller number, plant height, peduncle length, Internodes length, spikelet number per panicle,
and leaf area among all the accessions.
Table 1: Morphological Variations of Growing Sections of Digitaria spp
NO ACCESSION
Tiller
no/plant
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
19.00cde
10.00klm
21.00c
21.00c
4.00o
18.00de
13.00hijk
19.00cde
14.00ghi
AMPIYOS
CHUN-HOSS 2
GINDIRI 1
CHISU
NDING
KUREEP
SHENG
NAPAS
GONG-HALLA
Peduncle
length
(cm)
33.15m
32.72m
38.66i
29.43pq
31.32mn
29.23q
38.71i
42.43g
32.40no
Internode
length
(cm)
5.00mno
5.00mno
5.66klm
5.66klm
3.70opq
4.33nop
3.50pq
3.07q
5.52lmn
132
Spiklvet
Leaf area
no/pannicle (cm)
4.00efg
8.00ab
4.00efg
4.00efg
4.00efg
4.00efg
3.00g
5.00cdef
6.00bcde
13.18c
11.66c
11.15c
13.18c
12.65c
12.67c
10.64c
10.64c
9.12c
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
TISHI
KIN
CHUNPYENG
NPYENG
MAAN
GONG-A-RANDONG
LALAKU
GINDIRI 2
NKPWOS
NDAT
NAMURUK
CHUN-HOSS 1
JAKAH
MUNSUNG
SUHN
NAPIYA
SHA’ALAK
NASHILENG
DINAT
JIPEL
GOTIP
SHALAK
TSALA
GOPANTOR
BADAMA
GWABI
Overall Mean
SE of x
11.00jkl
14.00ghi
20.00cd
13.00ghij
15.00fgh
11.00jkl
13.00ghij
18.00de
15.00fghi
17.00ef
20.00cd
14.00ghi
20.00cd
21.00c
9.00klm
8.00mn
7.00n
18.00de
12.00ijk
10.00klm
29.00a
13.00ghij
15.00fghi
15.00fg
27.00a
24.00b
15.83
5.47
35.77l
31.70no
30.99o
29.18p
29.44q
27.72r
39.46hi
50.03i
35.46l
36.54k
40.10h
39.80h
38.00j
47.96d
47.44e
37.86jk
27.43r
35.45l
37.43k
43.66f
51.15a
48.62cd
51.34ab
48.89cd
30.84o
49.00c
37.92
7.41
4.53mno
3.50opq
4.50mno
4.50mno
5.00mno
5.33mno
4.66mnop
4.50mno
4.33nop
4.66mnop
5.51jklm
5.52jklm
6.66hijk
6.66hijk
6.33ijkl
7.66efgh
6.70ghij
11.06b
8.33def
13.00a
9.63bc
8.66de
7.52efg
9.33cd
7.33fghi
12.26a
6.1
2.68
4.00efg
4.00efg
5.00cdef
4.00efg
4.00efg
4.00efg
5.00defg
5.00fg
6.00bcde
4.00efg
4.00efg
5.00cdef
7.00ab
7.00ab
7.00ab
5.00cdef
5.00cdef
8.00a
7.00ab
8.00a
7.00ab
7.00ab
7.00ab
6.00bcde
5.00cdef
7.00ab
5.31
1.79
12.16c
9.12c
12.16c
12.16c
12.16c
9.12c
12.16c
13.68bc
11.66c
12.67c
13.69bc
13.18c
3.04d
2.03d
1.52d
3.02d
1.52d
10.39c
3.04d
10.14c
23.83a
23.83a
19.77a
19.27ab
10.65c
19.77a
6.91
3.74
Growth and yield performance of Digitaria spp used for this experiment are shown in Table 2. The
germination percentage of 14 days after planting ranged between 20.44% and 94.62% in all accessions. The
lowest day to 50% flowering occurred in Dinat (77.15) accession while the fastest day to 50% flowering was
133
observed in Npyeng (91.53). ). In addition, value of day to 50% flowering observed in Kureep (91.17),
Chunpyeng (91.26), Npyeng (91.53), Maan (91.19), Gong-a- randong (91.19) and Lalaku (91.46) were
significantly different with the one obtained in Npyeng accession. This showed that Npyeng variety got to
flowering stage earlier than the other accessions. Also, days to maturity of the accession were relatively close;
this ranged between 113 days in Jipel and 128 days in Npyeng, Maan and Lalaku accessions. On the contrary,
the plant height ranged between 54.00cm and 131.66cm in Gong-halla and Tsala varieties respectively. There
was significant difference in the plant height of Tsala and other accessions. However, grain yield was on ebb in
most of the accessions. The highest 176.24 kg of yield was recorded in Jakah accession while the lowest
occurred in Maan (0.93kg) accession. The lowest yield observed in Maan accession was not significantly
different with the yield obtained from Gong-halla (2.90kg), Tishi (1.51kg), Kin (2.10kg), Npyeng (1.85kg),
Gong-a-randong, Lalaku (2.42kg), Nkpwos (0.96kg) and Ndat (1.34kg).
Table 2: Growth and yield traits of various Acha accessions
134
NO ACCESSION
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
AMPIYOS
CHUN-HOSS 2
GINDIRI 1
CHISU
NDING
KUREEP
SHENG
NAPAS
GONG-HALLA
TISHI
KIN
CHUNPYENG
NPYENG
MAAN
GONG-ARANDONG
LALAKU
GINDIRI 2
NKPWOS
NDAT
NAMURUK
CHUN-HOSS 1
JAKAH
MUNSUNG
SUHN
NAPIYA
SHA’ALAK
Germ%
14Days
After
Planting
80.62cd
40.40 h
59.60 f
59.85 f
70.52 e
70.28 e
50.85 g
40.60 h
51.16 g
60.94 f
71.63 e
50.36 g
31.01 i
30.05 i
50.75 g
Days to Days to Plant height Grain
50%
maturity (cm)
Yield (kg)
flowering
77.42 cd
83.92b
77.42 cd
84.15 b
84.25 b
91.17a
84.25b
84.11b
84.59b
84.56b
77.18cd
91.26a
91.53a
91.19a
91.19a
115.00f
123.00cde
115.00f
123.00cde
121.00e
127.00ab
121.00e
124.00bcde
126.00 abcd
124.00 bcde
115.00f
127.00ab
128.00ab
128.00a
127.00ab
67.66i
67.33i
72.33h
56.66klm
67.00i
58.33kl
75.00gh
100.40d
54.00m
57.00klm
57.00klm
57.00klm
55.66klm
58.66k
54.33lm
5.33opq
5.87o
13.96m
15.92m
15.14m
6.06o
4.42opqr
9.56n
2.90qrs
1.51rs
2.10rs
4.85opqr
1.85rs
0.93s
2.50rsq
33.14 i
41.31 h
40.79 h
30.93 i
40.45 h
30.22 i
70.79 e
50.63 g
31.10 i
30.84 i
21.03 j
91.46a
77.42cd
83.95b
91.61cd
84.34b
90.01a
84.42b
84.24b
84.63b
84.01b
77.65cd
128.00a
115.00f
123.00cde
126.00abc
121.00e
127.00ab
122.00de
122.00cde
124.00bcde
121.00e
115.00f
135
57.00klm
95.66e
75.33gh
75.66gh
77.66g
74.66gh
76.00gh
112.66c
100.66d
76.00gh
56.66klm
2.42rs
35.17i
0.96s
1.34s
30.83j
5.43op
176.24a
122.41b
84.87c
80.26d
49.40f
30.64 i
20.44 j
31.89 i
81.32 c
89.87 b
87.75 b
81.76c
78.61 d
94.62 a
50.57
20.13
77.65cd
77.15cd
76.84d
78.05cd
76.37d
78.72c
77.55cd
77.83cd
78.64c
82.8
5.50
115.00f
115.00f
113.00f
115.00f
114.00f
114.00f
114.00f
115.00f
115.00f
119.80
5.50
84.66f
77.00g
85.00f
120.66b
112.66c
131.66a
113.33c
62.66j
112.00c
77.07
21.85
Correlation
coefficient
of
morphologi
cal
and
growth
parameters
of
Digitaria
Species
with
the
grain yield
showed highly significant negative correlation (-0.198) existing between Grain Yield and Days to 50%
Flowering (P<0.05). It implied an inverse relationship between the grain yield and Days to 50% Flowering
while, 14 days after planting, Tiller Number Per Plant, Leaf Area, Peduncle Length, Internode Length, Days to
Maturity, Spikelet/panicle Number, as well as Plant Height had no significant correlation with the grain yield
(P<0.05).
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
NASHILENG
DINAT
JIPEL
GOTIP
SHALAK
TSALA
GOPANTOR
BADAMA
GWABI
Overall Mean
SE of x
33.49ij
33.85i
19.79l
33.26ij
40.51h
72.22e
42.41g
5.06opq
25.15k
28.23
38.10
Based on the morphological data obtained in the studies of thirty five accession of Acha, the phylogeny
relationship grouped the accessions into twelve distinct races as shown in fig. 1. Npyeng and Maan accessions
formed distinct race of Acha plant based on their growth and yield parameters. The other 32 accessions have
related phylogeny trait and can be traced to be of the same descent. The RAPD analysis showed that a total of
10 RAPD OPERON primers were screened using thirty five (35) of the Acha lines. Out of these, only eight of
the primers showed polymorphisms with all the thirty five line. The dendogram of the DNA cluster variations
of all the thirty-five accessions are shown in fig. 2 below.
136
Rescaled Distance Cluster Combine
C A S E
0
5
10
-+---------+---------+---------+
NPYEN
13
-+
Maan
14
-+
Lalaku
16
-+---+
Ndat
19
-+
|
Chun
21
-+
|
Chs
2
-+
|
15
20
137
25 Label
Num +---------+--------
NKPWOS
18
-+
|
SHENG
7
-+
+---+
Gong
9
-+
|
|
Gongr
15
-+
|
|
CHUNPYEN
12
-+
|
|
TISHI
10
-+-+ |
|
CHISU
4
-+ | |
|
KUREEP
6
-+ +-+
|
AMPIYOS
1
-+ |
|
Badama
34
-+-+
+---------------+
Kin
11
-+ |
|
|
GINDIRI
3
-+-+
|
|
NDING
5
-+
|
|
NASHILEN
27
-+
|
|
DINAT
28
-+
|
|
Jipel
29
-+-+
|
+-----------------------+
NAMURUK
20
-+ |
|
|
|
Gind
17
---+-----+
|
|
NAPAS
8
---+
|
|
|
Shalak
26
---------+
|
|
Shal
31
-+
|
|
GOPANTOR
33
-+-----+
|
|
GOTIP
30
-+
+-----------------+
|
138
Gwabi
35
-+
|
|
TSALA
32
-------+
|
Shun
24
---+-------+
|
Napiya
25
---+
|
MUNSUNG
23
-----------+
Jakar
22
-------------------------------+
+-------------------+
+-----------------+
Fig. 1 Hierarchical Clusters Dendrogram of Digitaria Species Morphological Variations in Nigeria
139
140
Fig. 2: Dendrogram of DNA Cluster Variations of Digitaria Species in Nigeria
KEY: 1.AMPIYOS, 2. CHUN-HOSS 2, 3.GINDIRI 1, 4. CHISU, 5. NDING, 6. KUREEP, 7. SHENG, 8. NAPAS, 9. GONG-HALLA, 10. TISHI,
11. KIN, 12. CHUNPYENG, 13. NPYENG, 14. MAAN, 15. GONG-A-RANDONG, 16. LALAKU, 17. GINDIRI 2, 18. NKPWOS, 19. NDAT, 20.
NAMURUK, 21. CHUN-HOSS, 22. JAKAH, 23. MUNSUNG, 24. SUHN, 25. NAPIYA, 26. SHA’ALAK, 27. NASHILENG, 28. DINAT, 29.
JIPEL, 30. GOTIP, 31. SHALAK, 32. TSALA, 33. GOPANTOR, 34. BADAMA, 35. GWABI
DISCUSSION
The smallness of the size of all the Acha accessions examined in this study conform with the report of Acha
being a small seed with big promise (NRC, 1996; Ibrahim 2001). This portrays Suhn accession as having
potential to contribute to serve as additional food source for human and their livestock. Morphological
difference of the various accessions in terms of growth sections performance can be associated with the
pedigree of each accession as well as the response of the Acha varieties to environmental and ecological
variables. Dinat accession had better adaptation to the growing climatic condition of the locality; as it had
delayed germination and got to 50% flowering earlier than other accessions; this is in line with Ibrahim (2001)
findings that Acha has capacity to survive when other grains are yet to mature.
Higher negative correlation of days to 50% flowering with grain yield implies that the days to 50% flowering
had influence in the performance of Acha in Nigeria. Thus, the lower the number of day to 50% flowering, the
higher the grain yield while the relative negativity of leaf area with grain yield also portray an inverse
relationship between the two. On the other hand, growth factors such as peduncle length, Internodes length,
spikelet/panicle number and plant height with relatively positive correlation can be ascribed to have slight
influence on grain yield. Lower yield of Acha accessions recorded confirmed earlier reports on the plant (CBN,
1998; Cruz, 2004). This could be linked with call for identification of accessions with high yield that can be
adopted for improvement program in Nigeria (Kuta et al., 2003). Jakah accession with the highest yield can be
adopted for such program.
The resultant eight morphoclusters obtained from the cluster analysis of the thirty five accessions conform to
classification of Sorghum based on morphological differences (Appa-Rao and Prasada-Rao, 1996; Dje and
Ater, 1998). Also, the use of genetic features in identifying the phylogeny relationship of plant was established
with the engagement of the RAPD-DNA procedure (Hashizume and Sato, 1993; McDonald et al., 1995; Zhang
and Kubelik, 1997). The polymorphism of Acha plant was shown with the banding of eight primers with the
141
plants extracted DNA. This confirms the reliability of use of molecular marker with small quantity of DNA for
plant identification (Welsh & McClelland, 1990; Williams et al., 1990; Cheng and Chang, 1997).
Contradiction that occurred in the morphology and molecular dendrogram plots with Chun-Hoss I forming a
distinct morphoclusters in the morphology cluster analysis might be attributed to the influence of
environmental conditions on phenotypes of crops (Sakdren et al., 1994). The dendrogram plot of molecular
classification gave multilinked single group, thus, showing that all accessions were of the same descent.
Conclusively, based on the findings of this study, the use of only morphologic features in classifying Acha
does not give the same result with the engagement of molecular techniques. However the study has established
the existence of diversity in morphological/ traits of Acha accessions. Also, the study has also confirmed the
use of RAPD-PCR in unraveling the phylo-genetic diversity of Acha accession. The study identified the
accessions that have the potential to be adopted in Acha selection and improvement programmes. It is hereby
recommended that Jakah accession with the highest yield should be improved by crop breeders. Other varieties
with closer morphology and yield variables to Jakah can also be adopted in improvement program.
Classification of the crop in the country should involve the use of both morphology and molecular techniques.
Also, further studies can be done on the nutritive values of these accessions in order to identify the accessions
with the best nutritive elements.
REFERENCES
Appa-Rao S. and Prasada-Rao K.E. (1996) Morphological diversity in Sorghum germplasm from India. Gen
Res Crop Evol. 43: 559-567.
Arunyawat, U. 1997. Random amplified polymorphic DNA technique for genetic analysis of Curcuma spp.
MS. Thesis. Chiang Mai University, Chiang Mai, Thailand. 70 pp.
Central Bank of Nigeria (1998). Annual report and statement of account pp. 84. Carter, P.R.; Hicks, D.R.;
Oplinger, E.S.; Doll, J.D.; Bundy, L.G.; Schuler, R.T.; and Holmes, B.J. 1989. "Grain Sorghum
(Milo)." Alternative Field Crops Manual. (Accessed May 18, 2006).
142
Cheng K.T. and Chang H.C. (1997) Identification of dried rhizome of coptis species using random amplified
polymorphic DNA. Bot Bull Acad Sin. 38: 241-244.
Cruz, J.F. (2004). Fonio: a small gain with potential. In: magazine on LEISA. Vol. 201, March 2004, P. 16-17
(Low external input and sustainable) Agriculture.
Dauda, A. and Luka, D. (2003) status of Acha (Digitaria exilis) production in Bauchi State, Nigeria. In
th
proceeding of the first National Acha Stakeholders workshop at PADP, Jos (9-11 March 2003. Kwon
– Ndung, E. H., Bright, E.O. and Vodouhe, R. (eds).
Dellaporta, S.L., J. Wood and J.B. Hicks, 1983. A plant DNA minipreparation: Version II. Plant Mol. Biol.
Rep., 1: 19-21.
Dje Y, and Ater M (1998) Pattern of Morphological and allozyme variation in Sorghum landraces of
Northwestern Morocco. Gen Res Crop Evol 45: 541-548.
Edossa Fikiru, Kassahun Tesfaye and Endashaw Bekele (2010). A comparative study of morphological and
molecular diversity in Ethiopian lentil (Lens culinaris Medikus) landraces. African Journal of Plant
Science Vol. 4(7), pp. 242-254.
Harlan, J.R. (1993). Genetic resources in Africa. In: J. Janick and J.E. Simon (eds.), New crops. Wiley, New
York p. 65.
Hashizume T. and Sato P., (1993) Determination of genetic purity of hybrid seed in water melon (citrullus
lantus) and tomato (Lycopersicon esclentum) using random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD). Jap
J Breed. 43(3): 367-375.
Hilu, K.W., M’Ribu, K. Liang H. and Mandelbaum C. (1997). Fonio millets:Ethnobotany,diversity, and
evolution. South African J. Bot. 63:185–190.
Ibrahim, A. (2001). Hungry rice (Fonio): A neglected cereal crop. NAQAS Newsletter, Vol. No. 4-5.
Irwin S.V., P. Kaufusi, K. Banks, R. de la Pena and J.J. Cho. (1998). Molecular characterization of taro
(Colocasia esculenta) using RAPD markers. Euphytica 99: 183-189.
Kumar P., Gupta V. K., Misra A.K., Modi D.R. and Pandey B. K. (2009) Potential of Molecular Markers in
Plant Biotechnology, Plant Omics Journal, 2(4):141-162.
143
Kuta D.D., Kwon-Ndung, S. Dachi, M. Ukwungwu, and E.D. Imolehin (2003) Potential role of biotechnology
tools for genetic improvement of “lost crops of Africa”; the case of fonio (Digiteria exilis; Digiteria
iburua).
African
Journal
of
Biotechnology2(12):580-58Available
at
http://www.academicjournals.org/AJB.
Kwon-Ndung, E.H. and Misari, S.M. (1999). Overview of research and devleopment of fonio (Digitaria exilis
Kippis Stapf) and prospect for improvement in Nigeria. In: Genetics and food security in Nigeria GNS
Publication, Nigeria, P. 71-76.
Kwon-Ndung, E.H.; Misari, S.M. and Dachi, S.N. (2001). Study on the production practices of Acha (Digitaria
Exilis Kippis Stapf) in Nigeria. Science Forum: J. Pure and Appl. Sci. Vol 4 (1)11-19.
McDonald MD (1995) Genetic purity: from protein electrophoresis to RAPDs Proceeding of the Fiftieth
Annual Corn and Sorghum Industry Research Conference, 1995: 256-271.
Morales-Payán, J.P., J.R. Ortiz, J. Cicero, F. Taveras. (2002). Digitaria exilis as a crop in the Dominican
Republic. Supplement to: Trends in new crops and new uses. J. Janick and A. Whipkey (eds.) ASHS
Press, Alexandra, VA.
NRC. 1996. Lost Crops of Africa Volume 1: Grains National Research Council. National Academy Press
Washington, DC, pp 59-75.
Purseglove, J.W. (1975). Tropical crops Monocotyledons 1: Longmans, London. 531p.
Sakdren N., Srifa P. and Rintjaichon W. (1994). Using of random amplified polymorphic DNA technique for
classification of the elephant grass varieties in Thailand. Progress report of developing of the elephant
grass to use in Royal Project, Kasetsart University, Thailand. 50 pp.
Temple, V.J, and Bassa J.D. (1991) Proximate chemical composition of fonio (Digitaria exilis) grain J. Sci.
food Agr. 56:561-564.
Welsh J. and McClelland M (1990) Fingerprinting genomes using PCR with arbitrary primers. Nucleic Acids
Res 18: 7213.
Williams J.G.K., Kubelik A.R., Lavak K.J., Rafaski J.A. and Tingey S.Y. 1990. DNA polymorphisms
amplified by arbitrary primers are useful as genetic markers.NucleicAcids Research 18:6531–6535.
144
Zhang J. and Kubelik A.R. 1997. Testing for genetic purity in petunia and cyclamen seed using random
amplified polymorphic DNA markers. Hort Sci 32(2):246-247.
145