C H I N A’ S L O S T M U R A L PA I N T I N G S : A U S T R A L I A - C H I N A C O N S E R V AT I O N
RESEARCH TO REDISCOVER ANCIENT ART
Tonia Eckfeld, Caroline Kyi, Nicole Tse and Alex Xiaofei Duan
TOMB OCCUPANT WITH FEMALE FAMILY MEMBERS, MURAL PAINTING
IN THE YUAN DYNASTY LUOGETAI TOMB. PHOTO: COURTESY OF SPIA
ecent archaeological discoveries in
Shaanxi Province are providing new
evidence of China’s ancient tradition of
mural painting. In May 2014, the University
of Melbourne’s Grimwade Centre for
Cultural Materials Conservation (Grimwade
Centre) formally partnered with the Shaanxi
Provincial Institute of Archaeology (SPIA).
Through its focus on the materials and
techniques of wall paintings in Shaanxi
Province, this collaboration is revealing
information about the technical history of
Chinese mural painting, and providing new
data to inform mural painting interpretation
and conservation.
R
This bilateral project has seen the strengthening
of working relationships, the identification of
shared research questions, the development of
research approaches and preliminary outcomes
of analytical studies, as well as cross-cultural
exchange amongst conservation, archaeology
and art history professionals and students.
China’s lost mural paintings
As highlighted by Professor Zhou Tianyou at
the opening of the Second Qujiang Forum on
Mural Painting in Xi’an in 2015, the history of
Chinese ink brush painting is well known, but
there is a lack of equivalent scholarship about
Chinese mural painting. The problem is that
mural painting is integrally tied to architecture
and the demise of historical buildings through
fire, rot and ruin also destroys the mural
paintings that decorate them. In this way the
significant tradition of Chinese mural painting
in the pre-Ming period (pre-1368), recorded in
historical Chinese texts, has largely been lost
from the material record.
Historical textual records in which some of
these lost paintings are documented include
Zhu Qingxuan’s Tang chao minghua lu (Record
of Famous Paintings of the Tang Dynasty,
written c.840) naming artists and important
mural paintings in palaces, government
buildings, temples and elite mansions, and
Zhang Yanyuan’s Lidai minghua ji (Record
of Famous Paintings of All the Dynasties,
compiled c.847) describing important mural
paintings. Such documentary sources are
useful as a catalogue of paintings that have
been lost and a touchstone for contextualising
newly discovered paintings from historical
periods. From the early 1950s, such texts were
translated into English, making them more
accessible internationally.
4
The loss from the visual record of works by
masters such as Tang dynasty (618-907) Yan
Liben (c.600-673), Li Sixun (650-716), Wu Daozi
(680-c.760) or Han Gan (c.706-783) has left a
serious void. Late 19th century discoveries
of mural paintings in the Mogao Buddhist
cave temples at Dunhuang and at other sites
along the Silk Road have provided a large
corpus of 4th to 14th century mural painting
for appreciation and research. Grounded in
Buddhist tradition and at the periphery of
the Chinese empire, however, these stunning
works provide only a partial view of China’s
once immense and accomplished mural
painting repertoire.
Newly discovered evidence
Shaanxi Province is a key region for material
culture in China. It was a heartland for ancient
civilisation and home to the capital cities
of 13 dynastic states from the Zhou to the
Tang (c.1046 BCE – 907 CE). Archaeological
excavations in Shaanxi Province are revealing
important evidence of mural paintings at
major centres dating from all periods. Each
year since the early 1950s, important buried
mural painting sites have been discovered
with the total number of paintings running
into many hundreds. Since 2000 alone,
more than 20 tombs with paintings have
been excavated. Fresh discoveries provide
opportunities to study mural paintings in
their original locations and architectonic
contexts, alongside contemporaneous artifacts
and with associated textual inscriptions.
The provenance of discovery enables clearer
understanding of the artworks’ meaning and
significance through their historical, political,
philosophical and cultural contexts.
A few examples are worth naming to illustrate
their importance. The earliest known Chinese
mural paintings date from 2000 BCE, and
were recently found detached and on the
lower registers of stone gateway walls at the
ancient palatial city Shimao near Shenmu.
Underground tombs are like time capsules of
mural painting art. A Western Han dynasty
(206 BCE – 25 CE) brick underground tomb
on the campus of Jiaotong University reveals
a well-preserved complete classical Chinese
funerary mural program. Tang dynasty mural
paintings in royal and elite tombs represent a
technical and aesthetic high point in Chinese
mural painting tradition. Tang paintings
on plaster are exemplified by murals inside
the principal attendant tombs at Qianling
belonging to Princess Yongtai, Crown Prince
Zhanghuai and Crown Prince Yide (dating
from 706, excavated in 1960 and 1971-72) and
by those in the tomb of Tang Prime Minister
Han Xiu and his wife (762), excavated in 2014
in the southern suburbs of Xi’an. An intact
Song dynasty (960-1279) doctor’s brick tomb
completely lined with well-preserved murals
was excavated at Hancheng city in 2008 and is
one of a number being carefully preserved in
their entirety for study and technical analysis.
On a technical level, these discoveries are
facilitating innovative research approaches.
Conventionally, archaeologists, conservators,
TA A S A R E V I E W V O L U M E 2 5 N O. 4
WINE PREPARATION SCENE, MURAL PAINTING IN THE YUAN DYNASTY LUOGETAI TOMB. PHOTO: COURTESY OF SPIA
scientists, artists and art historians used
different methodologies for investigating
mural paintings, materials and techniques,
and contributed different information,
leaving some key questions unanswered. At
SPIA, broad integrated approaches are now
emerging under the Directorship of Professor
Wang Weilin so that multi-disciplinary teams
work together, sharing knowledge and
insights.
Employing this approach, examination of
the materials and techniques exhibited in
the mural paintings begins in situ at the
archaeology excavation site utilising standard
physical and chemical examination, scientific
instrumental analysis and technical art history
research. Furthermore, art historical and
conservation experts provide connoisseurs’
knowledge
supplementing
primary
archaeological research findings.
The Australia-China collaboration
The SPIA mural painting conservation team
has worked for many decades to protect these
treasures with significant success, mastering
both the detachment of the murals from their
original archaeological locations as well as
their conservation. Previous partnerships
have been important in supporting this
work, including between SPIA and the
Roman-German Central Museum of Mainz,
and individual scholars such as Australian
Tonia Eckfeld, working closely with SPIA
on archaeological site and mural painting
research since the mid-1990s.
In 2014, the Grimwade Centre began
participating in Chinese mural painting
conservation through expert exchanges,
symposia, fieldwork and joint research
in China and Australia. In 2015 these
activities expanded to include an internship
program with SPIA facilitating University of
Melbourne Masters level conservation interns
to work at SPIA’s laboratories for training
and to undertake practical conservation of
detached mural paintings. The involvement
of graduate students adds to the project’s
body of knowledge and provides interns
with an integrated cross-cultural professional
learning experience.
The SPIA-Grimwade Centre cooperation
is comprised of a multi-disciplinary team
with archaeologists, materials conservators
and art historians who begin studying the
mural paintings at the excavation site from
the point of discovery. There are a number
of challenging questions about Chinese
mural paintings that remain to be answered.
These include: the identity of the painters
and materials used; particular workshop
TA A S A R E V I E W V O L U M E 2 5 N O. 4
practices, techniques and styles; defining the
different mural painting traditions or schools,
and what this information tell us about the
lost corpus of above ground mural paintings.
To develop new insights, SPIA and the
Grimwade Centre are making reciprocal
visits to Shaanxi Province and the University
of Melbourne each year for scientific and
technical analysis, fieldwork, training,
expert symposia, lectures for conservation
professionals and teaching university
students. In this way, detailed knowledge
of particular materials and manufacturing
techniques is also informing new techniques
and approaches in the conservation of ancient
Chinese mural paintings.
Mural painting case studies
A key step in the project has been the
development of an historic mural painting
‘sample bank’ held at SPIA. The joint team
has developed approaches to the methodical
collection, archiving and analysis of detached
and fragmentary mural painting material,
including cross-referencing of data on mural
material from different sites.
Recent investigations in China and
Australia have centred on two large wall
paintings schemes from recently discovered
underground tombs. The first is from a Yuan
dynasty (1271-1368) tomb discovered in 2014
in Luogetai Village in Hengshan County
in north Shaanxi Province. The stone tomb
has a rectangular entrance and an octagonal
chamber with a domed roof. (Figure 1) The
whole tomb is 6.1m long and 2.8m high with
a 2.3m diameter dome. A complex scheme of
painted murals covers the tomb’s plaster-lined
walls. The scheme comprises celestial scenes
in the upper register, images of the tomb
owner surrounded by scenes of filial piety in
the middle and scenes of earthly pleasures
such as wine and tea preparation, and musical
performance in the lower register. In Xi’an
during 2015, intern masters students from the
Grimwade Centre worked with colleagues
at SPIA on a scene from the Luogetai tomb
depicting wine preparation. (Figure 2) The
interns were involved in the treatment testing,
treatment and general conservation of this
part of the mural painting scheme.
Scientific investigation at the University
of Melbourne focused on mural painting
pigments and binders from the Tang
dynasty tomb M68 discovered in 2014 at the
Taipingbao site, Jingyang County, Xianyang,
Shaanxi Province. Originally, a spirit road
lead to the tomb with a colossal 30m diameter
rammed earth mound marking the site.
Underground, the tomb extended 35m in
length and had a depth of 10m with a long
entry passage, five side niches for the storage
of burial goods, five ventilation shafts and a
single coffin chamber, all denoting it as a tomb
of exceptionally high status. Surviving mural
paintings on the tomb passage walls indicate
an extravagant pictorial program including
guards with halberds, a male civil official and
an attendant woman, two Indian Buddhist
monks, a horse and groom, a riderless horse
and three directional animals – dragon, tiger
and red bird. (Figures 3 and 4) The murals are
bright, richly coloured and skilfully painted
in a lively style indicative of a date in the first
half of the 8th century.
Scientific analysis
During excavations in 2014, SPIA experts
studied the Taipingbao tomb M68’s wall
paintings using a range of non-invasive
techniques including infrared examination,
5
INDIAN BUDDHIST MONK, MURAL PAINTING IN THE TANG
OFFICIAL, MURAL PAINTING IN THE TANG DYNASTY
DYNASTY TAIPINGBAO TOMB M68 (EAST WALL OF THE TOMB
TAIPINGBAO TOMB M68 (EAST WALL OF THE TOMB PASSAGE).
PASSAGE). PHOTOS: COURTESY OF SPIA
PHOTOS: COURTESY OF SPIA
prepared from materials of the previous
phases of scientific analysis.
The SPIA-Grimwade Centre approach to
research has been a consultative and iterative
process, accommodating revisions to research
hypotheses and research methodologies.
Continued research will yield more
information on the properties of Chinese
mural paintings, answer the big questions
outlined in this article, situate mural painting
tradition in its rightful place of importance
within art historical discourse, and support
optimal conservation methods to protect
these murals for future generations.
Professor Tonia Eckfeld is Principal Fellow and Project
Leader, School of Historical and Philosophical Studies,
University of Melbourne. Dr Caroline Kyi is a PostDoctoral Fellow, The Grimwade Centre for Cultural
Materials Conservation, University of Melbourne. Dr
Nicole Tse is Senior Lecturer, The Grimwade Centre
for
Raman spectroscopy and X-ray fluorescence
(XRF). Building on SPIA’s in situ investigations
of the tomb, laboratory analysis was
undertaken to further characterise materials
and investigate the mural painting techniques.
In 2015, fragments of the murals were brought
to the Grimwade Centre. Investigations
over 10 days employed laboratory-based
techniques including Fourier Transform
Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) in the
investigation of organic materials, and X-ray
fluorescence (XRF) and Inductively Coupled
Plasma Optical Emission Spectrometry
(ICP-OES) in the investigation of inorganic
materials.
Previous XRF analysis conducted by SPIA,
detected key elements: calcium, copper,
iron and lead. The presence of calcium, in
association with other signature elements, can
indicate the presence of calcium carbonate
used in fresco technique. Although fresco
painting technique is highly durable, the
palette is limited due to the alkaline conditions
created during production when certain
pigments become unstable and therefore
unsuitable for fresco application. These
pigments are more commonly combined with
a binder to form a paint mixture that is then
applied a secco - that is, to a dry plaster layer.
Therefore, in order to achieve a desired range
of colours and a measure of durability, artists
may combine fresco and secco techniques.
During investigations at the Grimwade
Centre using XRF and ICP-OES, elemental
iron, indicative of common iron-based
pigments, and red and yellow ochre, were
detected in areas of red polychrome. ICP-OES
supported quantification of the amount of
6
Cultural
Materials
Conservation,
University
iron in the samples and enabled researchers
to distinguish between iron present in the
pigment or in the soil adhering to the surface
as a result of burial.
of Melbourne. Dr Alex Xiaofei Duan is Academic
Samples of green pigment were also tested
using XRF and ICP-OES, and copper was
detected using both techniques. ICP-OES
analysis indicated that the levels of copper
were particularly high when compared to
other elements, excluding iron. This sensitive
investigative technique found low levels of
lead in a sample of green pigment as well as
in a sample of orange.
REFERENCES
Specialist, Trace analysis for chemical, earth and
environmental sciences, Faculty of Science, University
of Melbourne.
Acker, William, 1954. Some T’ang and Pre-T’ang Texts on Chinese
Painting, E.J.Brill, Leiden; and Vol.2, 1974.
Eckfeld, Tonia, 2005. Imperial Tombs in Tang China 618-907,
The Politics of Paradise, Routledge Curzon, London and New York
Shaanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology, 2009. Conservation
and Restoration of Murals from Tombs of the Han and Tang
Dynasties, San Qin Publishing, Xi’an
Zhu Zhanyun & Tonia Eckfeld, 2016. ‘The Development of
Conservation Practices in China from the 1980s to the Present’,
AICCM Bulletin, 37:1, pp. 26-34
While ochre pigments occur commonly in the
historical fresco palette, green, often derived
from copper-based pigments, and lead based
pigments such as lead white are less suitable
for fresco and are commonly applied with
a binder. The detection of copper and lead
in pigment materials from the samples
provides evidence to support the use of secco
technique in the painting of the Taipingbao
murals. Additional analysis using FTIR was
performed to look for the presence of organic
materials indicative of a binder, but the
findings were inconclusive. Compared with
inorganic materials, the analysis of organic
materials is compromised by their rate of
degradation
Due to the alteration of materials over time,
analytical challenges are often encountered
in developing scientific research approaches
for mural paintings. To support the ongoing
investigations into Chinese mural painting
techniques, in particular the study of
aged binders, the Grimwade is currently
researching the accelerated aging of samples
TA A S A R E V I E W V O L U M E 2 5 N O. 4