IOSR Journal of Economics and Finance (IOSR-JEF)
e-ISSN: 2321-5933, p-ISSN: 2321-5925.Volume 3, Issue 2. Ver. II (Mar-Apr. 2014), PP 11-15
www.iosrjournals.org
World Trade Organization
Pankaj Shah
Assistant Professor,Srcc,Du,India
Abstract: This study argues that trade policies regarding financial services are an important—but typically
neglected—determinant of capital flows and financial sector stability. Financial services trade liberalisation
which promotes the use of a broad spectrum of financial instruments and allows the presence of foreign
financial institutions whilst not unduly restricting their business practices, results in less distorted and less
volatile capital flows, and promotes financial sector stability. The study finds significa nt evidence in favour of
this claim through an empirical analysis of GATS commitments in 27 emerging markets. Even countries where
the financial system is weak, and where immediate, full-fledged financial sector liberalisation is not advisable,
can open up certain types of financial services trade, as such trade strengthens the financial system without
provoking destabilising capital flows.
Keywords: GATT,GATS,TRIPS,Uruguay Round,Protectionism,
I.
Introduction
The World Trade Organization (WTO) is an organization that intends to supervise
and liberalize international trade. The organization officially commenced on January 1, 1995 under
the Marrakech Agreement, replacing the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), which commenced
in 1948.The organization deals with regulation of trade between participating countries; it provides a framework
for negotiating and formalizing trade agreements, and a dispute resolution process aimed at enforcing
participants' adherence to WTO agreements, which are signed by representatives of member governments:fol.910 and ratified by their parliaments. of the issues that the WTO focuses on derive from previous trade
negotiations, especially from the Uruguay Round (1986–1994).
The organization is attempting to complete negotiations on the Doha Development Round, which was launched
in 2001 with an explicit focus on addressing the needs of developing countries. As of June 2012, the future of
the Doha Round remains uncertain: the work programme lists 21 subjects in which the original deadline of 1
January 2005 was missed, and the round is still incomplete. The conflict between free trade on industrial goods
and services but retention of protectionism on farm subsidies to domestic agricultural sector(requested
by developed countries) and the substantiation of the international liberalization of fair trade on agricultural
products (requested by developing countries) remain the major obstacles. These points of contention have
hindered any progress to launch new WTO negotiations beyond the Doha Development Round. As a result of
this impasse, there has been an increasing number of bilateral free trade agreements signed.As of July 2012,
there are various negotiation groups in the WTO system for the current agricultural trade negotiation which is in
the condition of stalemate.
WTO's current Director-General is Pascal Lamy, who leads a staff of over 600 people in Geneva, Switzerland .
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
Objectives of the study are:
To evaluate the involvement of WTO in disputed countries
To study the factors affecting the trade
To create a knowledge base on various matter concerning various National and International Trade Laws
and Protocols, and their National and International implications and ramifications.
Increasing awareness amongst Domestic Industry, business, agriculture, service and other sectors on the
impacts of trade laws arising out of WTO agreement and other treaties as member of WTO.
Exploit all potential provisions of WTO agreement available to the developing nations and advising and
counseling the Government of India on all such issues of national importance.
To assist the Government in negotiating with the International Community in the perspective of the WTO
regime and to help strengthen the Indian position in these regards in all possible ways.
Identify areas of non-fulfillment of the WTO agreement which concern Indian interest and suggest line of
action and remedies open for fulfillment of these obligations.
www.iosrjournals.org
11 | Page
World Trade Organization
To develop a base of expertise amongst the members of the Institute on Intellectual Property Rights, TRIPS,
Anti-dumping laws, EXIM Policy matters etc., through Seminars, training programs and such other
methods as may be considered effective.
II.
Review Of Literature:
Bergstrand, Egger (2006); “Trade Costs and Intra-Industry Trade”
.
The study suggests that the
Anderson and van Wincoop (2004) have recently challenged
international trade economists to lend much more consideration to the importance of "trade costs" in the pattern
of international trade as well as international price disparities. Their work suggests that the average implied
markup attributable to the costs of international transaction may be approximately as high as 170 percenti
Despite this,international trade economists have devoted little attention to this important notion.In a large
cross-section of bilateral intra-industry trade shares based on OECD data,we investigate these hypotheses
empirically. The findings are strongly in support of our view. This illustrates how - as Anderson and van
Wincoop (2004) suggest - a more realistic treatment of transport costs in our standard models of trade could
help to put forward new and interesting hypotheses and could become a cornerstone for subsequent
empirical research in international economics.
Graz (2004); “Transnational Mercantilism and the Emergent Global Trading Order”. The study
suggests that the article has explored the problems encountered by the WTO in the shift from a trade
agenda focused on tariff reduction to the harmonisation of domestic regulations in consequence of their
impact on international ex- changes. It suggests that the WTO, as the core forum of the global trading
order, is now facing a fundamental crisis because of its failure to strike
an acceptable balance between market and non-market provisions on a comprehensive scope and worldwide basis. Although the mandate of the so-called 'Doha Development Agenda' includes provisions
giving a more balanced interpretation of the embeddedness of international trade in non- trade concerns,
it remains unclear whether this slight revision should be
seen as anything more than a pragmatic response to the tensions between developed and developing
countries, and growing domestic concerns re- garding the goals of the multilateral trading system. A
number of implications arise from this analysis.
First, the theoretical framework contrasts with the conventional analyses of the so-called 'new trade
agenda'. Most scholars are concerned with the harmonisation of an ever-increasing range of domestic
policies considered to have an impact on trade and the compatibility of these policies with major nontrade concerns such as human rights or the environment. This paper has focused, on the contrary, on
the contradictory nature of the global trading order and this impacts on the WTO. The concept of
transnational mercantilism makes explicit the problem- atic relationship between the transnationalisation
of capitalism and the economic and social roles of political authorities within a defined space. It is
clear that within classical mercantilist thinking the mediations shaping the specific configurations
between the economic and political realms of trade policy remain elusive. Put bluntly, Marx may have
been wrong in accusing mercantilists of succumbing to the fetishism of commodities, since use value
was one of their key concerns; he was right, however, to consider that the criteria for determining use
value did not take into account the social relations of production in a capitalist environment.15 Yet,
mercantilist thinking allows us to reconceptualise the politics of trade by reference to three major
claims: the articulation between the economic and political spheres, the intimate connection between
domestic and international realms, and the embeddedness of trade policy within broader political
economy concerns. The concrete manifestations of these categories and their relations are not given but
socially and historically produced.
Bastos,Cabral (2007);“The Dynamics of International Trade Patterns ”. The study suggests that
dynamics of international trade patterns in 20 OECD countries. Using new dynamic measures, we are able to
distinguish between three types of trade change: inter-industry flows that contribute to reinforce a country's
previous specialization, marginal intra-industry trade,and inter-industry flows that contribute to a decrease in a
country's previous specialization (that we name specialization shifts). Descriptive evidence for 20 OECD
countries over the 1980-2000 period indicates that specialization shifts represented a significant part of the
observed trade expansion,being often the dominant form of inter-industry trade change. Indeed, we find that in
many of the countries studied, the widely documented rise in intra- industry trade did not occur mainly
because of matched trade expansion but as a result of specialization shifts. This is an important finding as the
existence of specialization shifts cannot be explained in the context of static intra-industry trade models with
identical countries. Our results also indicate that trade liberalization did not induce a generalized increase in
www.iosrjournals.org
12 | Page
World Trade Organization
the degree of international specialization in the OECD. On the contrary, our results suggest that during the
periods 1 980-1 985 and 1 995-2000 most of the countries studied have experienced a decrease in the degree of
international specialization. The new measures of inter- industry trade dynamics are then used as the dependent
variable in regression analysis. Our main findings are as follows.
Firstly, in accordance with the predictions of the new economic geography models, our results indicate that
trade liberalization contributed to an increase in the previous specialization of larger economies in industries
with increasing returns to scale. Secondly, we find support to the hypothesis that Ricardian effects are an
important driver of changes in trade patterns in the OECD. Finally, we find some support to the hypothesis
that initial endowments of human capital are an important driver of trade expansion following trade
liberalization, but no evidence that changes trade patterns were explained by changes in factor endowments.
Although this may indicate that factor accumulation is not a strong force driving changes in trade patterns in
the OECD, it may also simply reflect the fact that changes in endowments only become an important driver of
specialization dynamics over relatively long time horizons
Srivastava(2007). “World Trade Organisation at the Crossroads: The Legitimacy Dimension ”.
The study suggests that All international organisations in contemporary international order must address
the crucial issue of legitimacy in their governance structure which depends on a complex set of democratic,
normative and functional criteria. The legitimacy crisis of the WTO emanates from a complex mix of factors
including democratic deficit, functional inertia, iniquitous fallout of its policies and most important of all,
ignoring the concerns of environment, labour, poverty, etc. In other words, the norm of trade liberalisation or
the principle of consent with the norm is the most challenging part of WTO's legitimacy, especially in the
wider international community. Also challenging is the task of balancing different aspects of legitimacy
which WTO has to grapple with on numerous occasions. The Seattle ministerial conference demonstrated a
low point in WTO's democratic legitimacy amongst developing countries and also the NGOs. While
developing countries felt alienated from the decision-making process due to repeated intransigence on market
access issues as also attempts to fusetrade and labour issue, the NGOs felt equally let down by WTO's inability
to respond to their con- cerns of transparency and accountability which contributed significantly to the
collapse of the Seattle ministerial conference. As far as NGOs are concerned, the demand of participation and
transparency remains largely unresolve
Kaushik (2008). “Dispute Settlement System at the World Trade Organisation ”.The study
suggests that Developing countries have increasingly started using the wto dispute settlement system to wrest
their market access rights from recalcitrant trading partners. Although there may be a lack of institutional
infrastructure, and perhaps capacity, to make the best use of the system, availability of legal advice from acwl
and domestic lawyers is increasingly adding comfort to the decision-makers in developing country
governments in taking disputes to the wto. There is now a need for research on actual market access wrested
open by developing countries through their legal forays, and whether the assumption that
smaller countries are intimidated by the clout of the larger, more powerful countries in taking disputes against
them or insisting on enforcement of dispute decisions is correct or not.
Anderson,Martin(2006). “Distortions to World Trade: Impacts on Agricultural Markets and
Farm Incomes ”.The study suggests that The potential gains from global trade reform are nontrivial,
including for developing countries, despite its adverse terms of trade impact on many developing countries.
Agriculture would enjoy the greatest gains from trade liberalization. Liberalization would cause farm output
and farm employment to rise in developing countries relative to the baseline, except in South Asia. The poorest
people appear most likely to gain from the global trade liberal- ization, namely farmers and unskilled laborers in
developing countries. Net farm income would be enhanced in all developing country regions other than South
Asia, where job growth would be greater in nonfarm activities
Murshed (2004).“When Will WTO Membership Signal Commitment to Free Trade by A
Developing Country
”
The study suggests that The analytical model in this paper has demonstrated that a
commitment to freer trade, even if optimal, is fraught with temptations to renege on pre-announced
commitments regarding freer trade by sovereign governments. For a developing country the attractiveness of
deviations from free trade lie in the potential revenue earnings from protection. In a developed country, trade
policy can act as a substitute for traditional counter-cyclical macroeconomic policies in an era when many
Northern governments have delegated some discretionary macroeconomic policies away to independent
bodies. The developing country's temptations to deviate from free trade may be restrained via
membership obligations in a rules based supra-national authority the WTO. But this commitment by
www.iosrjournals.org
13 | Page
World Trade Organization
delegation crucially depends on how it perceives its powerful Northern trade partners will behave in
connection with its own exports to countries in the North.
If the North continues to be protectionist, as is the case at present, then WTO membership will not be a
successful commitment device to freer trade in the South. This result is potentially important in the
context of world trade negotiations, and is not just academic curiosia. The North continues to shut out the
South from its markets in many important sectors such as textiles, agriculture and other areas where the
South is gaining comparative advantage. In many instances, the device of contingent protection is employed.
All of this occurs simultaneously as the North compels the South to open its markets to services and accept
the TRIPs agreements, which may hamper domestic technological progress in the South. Ultimately, free
trade should allow the South to access Northern markets, not just open up its markets to goods and
services from the North. Low-income developing countries need to grow, and export promotion is part of
the strategy of growth with macroeconomic stability and debt sustainability. Without greater access to
Northern markets, the proposed millennium development goals with regard to poverty reduction cannot be
reconciled with the needs formacroeconomic stability and debt reduction, which are also demanded
by donors. In the final analysis, asymmetric trade policy power relations do not bode well for free trade.
Countries in the South have in many instances unilaterally moved towards freer trade. Further developments
in this regard will, however, be hampered without an equal commitment by countries in the North to free
trade.
Gibb,Michalak (1996).“Regionalism in the World Economy ” The study suggests that A striking
feature of the international economic order unfolding in the 1990s is the growth of international
regionalism. However, regionalism is an extraordinarily diverse and complex phenomenon with a marked
level of heterogeneity evident between different trading arrangements. The sheer complexity of the
issues involved leaves room for widely differing interpretations of the costs and benefits of
multilateralism and regionalism to regional and national economies. There is a growing consensus,
supported by the evidence presented at the beginning of this paper, that international regionalism is on
the ascendency. The EU, NAFTA and ASEAN+ triad of regional trading arrangements dominate the
world economy, accounting for 67 per cent of all world trade. However, the resurgence of regionalism
does not necessarily imply a decline in the process of multilateral trade liberalisation. From a neoliberal
perspective, the analytical difficulty posed byT regionalism is that it can be simultaneously tradediverting and trade-creating for both participatory and non-participatory states. As a consequence,
international regionalism has the potential both to support and erode the multilateral free trade system.
In part, this ambiguity reflects both the theoretical and pragmatic difficulties
associated with the implementation and evaluation of the practical outcomes of the multilateral and
regional approaches to free trade.
The success of the Uruguay round of the GATT talks led a number of academics to suggest that
international regionalism does not really constitute an alternative approach to multilateralism (Cable
1994). There is little doubt that the new GATT/WTO regulations, if fully implemented, have the
potential to strengthen significantly the multilateral regulatory framework. However, it is a central conten
tion of this paper that the process of multilaterally opening international markets has in fact contributed
to the restructuring and ' post-Fordist ' pressures on many industrialised economies. The Uruguay Round
will therefore enhance further international competitive pressure on industry radically to restructure
uncompetitive industries. As a consequence, these developments may actually contribute to the
long-term erosion of the multilateral regime of regulation. It is therefore no coincidence that the
successful conclusion of the Uruguay Round coincided with increasing calls for protectionism and
regionalism in the world economy- (Munchau 1994). The evidence and analysis presented in this paper
support our principal argument: that the issue of international regionalism is part of what many
commentators believe to be a more fundamental transformation of ' industrial society ' and the '
capitalist system of production '. The nature of this change is best described as a transform ation in the
mode of production from Fordism to some more flexible system of production, organisation and
consumption. We suggest that multilateralism and regionalism are associated with different forms of
regulation and the resurgence of regionalism may be the result of this gradual change away from
Fordist production methods to more flexible modes of production. Therefore, the rationale under pinning
regionalism is regulation at an international scale, attempting to preserve the requirements of flexibility
at the same time as protecting domestic markets from outside competition. As a consequence,
international regionalism should be recog nised as a powerful force fundamentally transforming the
world economy and the relationships between the world's principal trading partners .
www.iosrjournals.org
14 | Page
World Trade Organization
III.
Conclusion:
With the establishment of the world trade organization and its powerful settlement mechanism in
1995,a new forum has been created for addressing international trade disputes.With its increased strength,the
dispute settlement body now possesses significant ability to coerce states into abiding by the international
agreements they have signed. A key purpose of this international organization is to remove the political aspect
from the process in which disputes are resolved.The WTO hopes to replace political maneuvers with the
structured dispute settlement process established by WTO agreements
Bibliography
Bergstrand J.H., Egger P.,2006. Trade Costs and Intra-Industry Trade . Review of World Economics Vol.
142(3), pp. 433-458 .
Graz J.C,2004.Transnational Mercantilism and the Emergent Global Trading Order . Review of
International Political Economy, Vol. 11(3) ,pp. 597-617
Bastos P,Cabral M,2007.The Dynamics of International Trade Patterns .Review of World Economics /
Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, Vol. 143(3), pp. 391-415
Srivastava J.World Trade Organisation at the Crossroads: The Legitimacy Dimension.Economic and
Political Weekly, Vol. 42( 40) , pp. 4075-4079
Kaushik A.Dispute Settlement System at the World Trade Organisation .Economic and Political Weekly,
Vol. 43(2), pp. 26-29
AndersonK,Martin W.Distortions to World Trade: Impacts on Agricultural Markets and Farm Incomes
.Review of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 28(2), pp. 168-194
Murshed S,When Will WTO Membership Signal Commitment to Free Trade by A Developing Country .
Journal of Economic Integration, Vol. 19(2), Developing Countries in the WTORegime: Selected Issues,
pp. 317-331
Gibb R,Michalak W.Regionalism in the World Economy . Area, Vol. 28(4), pp. 446-458
References
[1]. Ratan Tata Library,wikipedia
www.iosrjournals.org
15 | Page