Nicolaitan: Lords of Hypocrisy

1 Discovery

Job 36:22, ESV. Behold, God is exalted in his power; who is a teacher like him?

On his last visit to Ephesus, Paul warns the congregation leaders about the future appearance of bad shepherds coming from within the congregation.

Acts 20:29–30, ESV. I know that after my departure fierce wolves will come in among you, not sparing the flock; and from among your own selves will arise men speaking twisted things, to draw away the disciples after them.

About 30 years after this, Jesus warns the Ephesians (and Pergamum) about Nicolaitans in Revelation chapter two. Obviously, Nicolaitans were some of those wolves about which Paul warned. Did the wolves disappear after John wrote the Revelation, or have they survived to populate modern congregations? Did believers get rid of false teachers, or have they spread out from Ephesus and Pergamum in the last 2,000 years and continue to speak twisted things? The Church identifies wolves as those who don't follow orthodox Church teachings. But what if those making that judgment are Nicolaitans in sheep's clothing? Could the orthodox teachings be unbiblical? How do we tell?

Jesus mentions the Nicolaitans in two of the letters He dictated to the seven congregations in Revelation 2 and 3. Their origin and exact teachings are not clear, but He groups them with other false teachers and those whose works He hates. This is important because Nicolaitans are, in fact, still around; just with different names. They might only be mentioned a couple of times in the Bible, but they have indeed spread throughout the Church/synagogue and have a lot of influence.

We need to understand their works and why Jesus hates those works, because they are causing a lot of harm and directing people away from God's Word. In this book I'm going to show that not only were Nicolaitans a problem in 95 A.D. when John wrote the book of Revelation, but have always been a problem. In the next chapter, I'll define them from the Bible. Then I'll define them by fruit, how they teach and what they teach. I offer further evidence for my case from history, and a comparison of the Bible with modern Church teachings.

One of the major tactics of people who want to hide truth is to change names and redefine words. Nicolaitans use different labels, and they all claim to be shepherds now, not wolves. Using labels such as shepherd disguises what they really are and what they are doing to the flock. The problem with that is the Bible also tells us about bad shepherds, and the descriptions match. They don't call themselves Nicolaitans, but wolves or bad shepherds are all over the place. I'll connect the dots and show their works, so believers realize who they are, avoid them, and turn to the Bible.

I could write this book two ways. One is the nice, sweet approach where I dance around the issues and try not to hurt feelings. The other way is to be blunt, and if I step on some toes so be it. I chose the blunt way for two reasons. The first is that Nicolaitans rob us of maturity, fruit of the Spirit and abundant life, and do a lot of other bad things too as Jesus says in Matthew 23. The second reason is the sweet way just doesn't work to rescue people from Nicolaitan teachings; hearts are hard and the Nicolaitans fight tooth and nail to defend their turf and their money. Jesus, Paul, Peter, Jude, Jeremiah, Ezekiel and others chose the blunt way, so I'm in good company.

I am a whole Bible Christian. I believe that the entire Bible, including The Law, Torah or the Law of Moses, is necessary in the believer's life - in contrast to those who teach most Christians that the Law is fulfilled and hence mostly eliminated. The entire Bible is filled with living oracles full of the love of Jesus, given to believers for discipleship and without error in what it teaches. The word Torah means instruction, and all of His Words instruct believers in how to live. My family follows God's instructions such as those for holidays, diet, and Sabbath. We've seen, through the simple reading of His Word, that Jesus did not eliminate the Law. He gave it to Moses, lived it, taught it, and confirmed it to His followers. More about whole Bible living is in my book Whole Bible Christianity, Blessings Pressed Down and Overflowing.

Whole Bible Christians believe that much of what God says of Himself, and what He requires of man, can be understood from simply reading and doing the Bible. The whole Book; not just our favorite 16 verses or Paul's letters. We also resist the tendency to only follow what we hear others say about the Bible, and read it ourselves. So I'm one of those the Church calls a false teacher. But am I false compared to the Bible, or compared to Church orthodoxy that may not be biblical? Find out in this book.

Jesus had a problem with Jewish bad shepherds because they grabbed authority but wrongly interpreted the Law and the Prophets. They made inaccurate rulings from the Law and sought earnestly for ways to implement more of their man-made laws. Many Jews regard these rulings and interpretations, called oral law or Mishnah, as on the same level as, (though they frequently override) the written Word. I'll show you that modern Nicolaitans have done the same thing for the Church. Church leaders too have developed a lot of oral law; interpretation and traditions that mostly override the Bible.

I arrived at the understanding that the whole Bible is a God-given lifestyle and discipleship method for all believers through a lot of searching and painful loss. It was sort of like wandering in the desert as I experienced fifteen Churches in ten different denominations by the time I was 40. These were Churches where I stayed for a while, not just visited a few times. I was baptized a Catholic and did the catechism and first Holy Communion thing early on. I was there in the '60's when folk masses first began to percolate and Vatican II was wrapping up. Assembly of God, Methodist, and Baptist were next. After getting married, we went to Calvary Chapel for three years. Then there was the Presbyterian, Wesleyan, another Calvary Chapel, an Evangelical Free, a Bible Church, and some Messianic synagogues, which turned out to be the Church in a prayer shawl.

In my extensive experiences with different Church governments and leaders, I saw a variety of approaches to Bible teaching and problem solving. That, along with decades of questions, self-teaching, some seminary classes and Bible study, gives me insight on the Nicolaitan issue. I also come at it from once upon a time being a Nicolaitan. Yep. I learned from them, and for a long while taught the same things in the same ways. But I kept trying to learn more and connect with Jesus better.

Around 1997 I made some big changes as I started to figure out that the whole Bible, Genesis to Revelation, was for all believers to follow. A believing Jewish friend helped by pointing out Bible teachings that are hijacked by non-believers. Problems arose when I tried to share the things I was learning with friends and leaders. They told me in many ways why I was wrong. Except they couldn't show me from the Bible; they had to resort to orthodox Church doctrine.

When I first began to read through the whole Bible and learn the principles of whole Bible Christianity, I was explaining some of it to a Nicolaitan. He asked if I thought I was a prophet, and if so what was my message. I was surprised by the questions, but it only took two seconds of thought to say my message was, Repent. I told him I don't think I'm a prophet in the class of, say, Isaiah or Jeremiah, but anyone who speaks God's Word is, in a sense, a prophet. Prophets have at least two functions. To forth-tell the Word so people repent, and to foretell what would happen if they didn't. All of us who live and speak God's living oracles are forth telling prophets or teachers. The message is not ours, but God's.

I continued to sort through my Nicolaitan brainwashing on my own, eliminating the wrong things and plugging in the new good things I was learning from the practice of the whole Word. Excellent teachers such as Tim Hegg and others from Torah Resource (on the web at www.torahresource.com) provided critical help. It was tough shedding my Nicolaitan thought processes contrary to the Word. It was also hard losing my Nicolaitan friends. I would rather they had seen the truth and repented.

On the upside, I had no position with a paycheck, so I didn't have to worry about losing income. I did lose a position as an unpaid elder and another as an unpaid youth leader (for teaching the truth), though. That's a problem for a lot of Nicolaitans: changing to biblical teaching will cost them everything. They risk it all if they start teaching the Bible instead of standard Church doctrine. Either the congregation slaps them down or the denomination will. Calvary Chapel calls it losing your dove. In that Church, you can't teach anything other than what is approved by Chuck Smith (may he rest in peace) and his disciples. If you do, then like a franchise they will make you give up the dove symbol and the name. The home office controls what you teach and how you sell it. Stray from their guidelines and you're out of business.

All franchises, er, Churches, have ways to control heresy and heretics. To the Church bureaucracy, a heretic is one who departs from orthodox teachings. Orthodox means accepted. Accepted means that a bunch of experts got together and decided what was right. Of course, the Church swamp dwellers want you to think that orthodox also means biblical, but in many ways, their dogma is not. Stick with the home office orthodoxy and your job is safe. Step outside of that and the paychecks disappear. They will call you a cult, which the dictionary says is a religion regarded as unorthodox or spurious. They overlook the fact that compared to Acts 2 all modern Churches fall into that category. On the one hand, the orthodox systems are there for a good reason; they keep nutcases from messing up the franchise. On the other hand, the systems frequently turn into self-perpetuating, hardened, bomb-proof bunkers that are almost impossible to change if they are wrong. It's not just a liberal or conservative or evangelical thing either. It's all through the Church.

What I hope for you with the writing of this book is to help you establish a better connection to God, show the truth in the Word, encourage you with life more abundant and assist you to become more mature (Hebrews 5:11-6:3). Modern Nicolaitans and their bureaucracies (the word means rule by desk) are misdirecting us and robbing us of life and freedom in Him. They have placed themselves in our way, offering a pseudo-relationship with an empty caricature of a Jesus and a false hope in a corrupted new covenant. You have a direct relationship with God and don't need any intermediary other than our High Priest Jesus. He tore the curtain in the Temple and is giving us the bread of heaven in the whole of His loving Word. Take it and eat. Circumcise your heart. Ignore the philosophies of men and go right to the source of life.

If I told you there was gold buried in your back yard, and you believed me, what would happen next? You wouldn't stop digging till you found it. That's the difference between people who say they believe Jesus, and those who really do. If you believe but don't dig, do you really believe?

When I question Nicolaitan teachings, I get all sorts of defenses. The backstop response is, That's the way we do things here. If you aren't being ministered to, then find a place where you are. This is the polite version of, If you don't like it, leave.

Almost all churches say this when questioned, because they don't want their kingdoms to fall apart. So I left the Church. But I didn't leave God or His Word. I have found a place where I can receive ministering directly from Jesus without interference. God and His Word are my Minister, my Teacher, and my life.

2 Lords of the Flock

2 Timothy 4:3–4, ESV. For the time is coming when people will not endure sound teaching, but having itching ears they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions, and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander off into myths.

As I said before, there are only two places in the Bible that mention Nicolaitans by name, both in Revelation chapter 2. That doesn't mean, though, it's the only place they are found. As I'll show, they are all through the Bible such as in Jeremiah 25:34-36. Nicolaitans made their homes in the cities of Pergamum and Ephesus, but they didn't stay there. There is also a person named Nicolaus in Acts 6 who might be the founder of the Nicolaitans.

We don't know much specifically about the ancient Nicolaitans, like who they are and where