Episode list

A respected police officer heads home after a late shift, and a young man who has just moved into his own place relaxes after watching football.

They head out into the night, full of youthful life and promise, but they never come back. Clues that come from behind bars could help solve the mysteries that surround the disturbing disappearances of these two women.

She is an innocent bride-to-be; he's a six-year-old schoolboy. Both are on the road, away from home, when they disappear. When her car and body are found, will the clues lead to her murderer? And will his family ever solve the mystery of his vanishing?

After he graduates second in his high school class and excels in college, Cole decides to take time off to work in Minnesota, far from his Florida home. When he vanishes, his parents are bewildered to learn he was last seen in Benson, North Carolina, on a mysterious trip with a pair of co-workers. His colleagues' stories keep changing, but it becomes clear that they were embarked on a very dangerous mission. Find Cole Thomas #JusticeForCole Then, in Jamestown, New York, Yolanda, a young mother of four disappears, her car the only trace left behind. When a massive search is undertaken, secrets rise to the surface, and the town discovers a clandestine tryst with one of the officers searching for Yolanda. @Justice for Yolanda Bindics.

STORY 1. Wilkes County, Georgia, September 23, 2012: A Georgia man, 35-year-old Jeffrey Gebhardt, suffers 17 stab wounds while on a deer hunting trip with his friend David Smith, and authorities rule his death a suicide, shocking his family. STORY 2. Pemberton, British Columbia, Canada: 26-year-old Marshal Iwaasa disappears on November 17, 2019 without warning. Six days later, his burned-out vehicle is found by hikers on November 23, 2019, 700 miles and 14 hours away from where anyone saw him last in Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada. Local law enforcement has closed the case and Marshal's family is desperate for answers.

13-year-old Abby Williams and 14-year-old Libby German go for a short walk on a popular hiking trail and then disappear. And then 13-year-old Dylan Redwine vanishes on Thanksgiving break, 2012, while visiting his dad in Vallecito, Colorado.

Two stories are outlined. 1. On September 28, 2015, 20-year-old Joseph W. Smedley II, a student at Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana, sends his sister Vivianne Bernas a cryptic message about leaving town to move overseas. Three days later on October 2, 2015, his body is found in Griffy Lake, weighted down by a backpack filled with 66 pounds of rocks. The authorities declare the case to be a suicide, but the family disagrees. The family has not had adequate access to the police files and are still looking for answers. 2. On July 6, 2004, 22-year-old Molly Laura Dattilo of Indianapolis, Indiana disappeared. She was last seen with John Shelton, a violent man with a prison record who is a person of interest, along with John's father, Edward Shelton. In October 2008, a caller to a tip line shared information that John Shelton told his father Edward Shelton that he had "accidentally" killed a girl. The family members sued John Shelton in civil court and won their case. However, they still do not have answers about what happened and the police do not have enough evidence to further the case. Molly Dattilo was legally declared dead, but the family still wants answers.

18-year-old Brookelyn Farthing disappears in 2013 after attending a party in the small town of Berea, Kentucky. And then, 24-year-old Lindsay Buziak, a young beautiful realtor, is found brutally killed after showing some new clients a million-dollar home.

In July, 2018, 25-year-old Danniella Vian, a young mother from Mobile, Alabama, disappears into thin air. And then 19-year-old Holly Moore's suspicious death still raises questions four years after her body is found hanging from her closet.

One young woman is found with a shotgun wound to her head shortly after moving in with her new boyfriend. Then, a couple planning their wedding are gunned down in their own backyard.