Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                
Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 48 views

    Peer Review - Draft 1

    Uploaded by

    api-235371459
    This document provides guidelines for creative writers to get peer feedback on their narrative writing. The creative writer reads their narrative aloud and then asks the audience/responders a series of questions to get their opinions, suggestions for improvements, and ideas for additions. The questions address what was liked about the piece, any questions or unclear parts, topics that could be added or expanded on, ways to improve the introduction or organization, and thoughts on the ending. The creative writer is instructed to listen openly to the feedback while also using their own judgment on how to apply the suggestions to their narrative.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Peer Review - Draft 1

    Uploaded by

    api-235371459
    48 views2 pages
    This document provides guidelines for creative writers to get peer feedback on their narrative writing. The creative writer reads their narrative aloud and then asks the audience/responders a series of questions to get their opinions, suggestions for improvements, and ideas for additions. The questions address what was liked about the piece, any questions or unclear parts, topics that could be added or expanded on, ways to improve the introduction or organization, and thoughts on the ending. The creative writer is instructed to listen openly to the feedback while also using their own judgment on how to apply the suggestions to their narrative.

    Original Title

    peer review - draft 1

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    This document provides guidelines for creative writers to get peer feedback on their narrative writing. The creative writer reads their narrative aloud and then asks the audience/responders a series of questions to get their opinions, suggestions for improvements, and ideas for additions. The questions address what was liked about the piece, any questions or unclear parts, topics that could be added or expanded on, ways to improve the introduction or organization, and thoughts on the ending. The creative writer is instructed to listen openly to the feedback while also using their own judgment on how to apply the suggestions to their narrative.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    48 views2 pages

    Peer Review - Draft 1

    Uploaded by

    api-235371459
    This document provides guidelines for creative writers to get peer feedback on their narrative writing. The creative writer reads their narrative aloud and then asks the audience/responders a series of questions to get their opinions, suggestions for improvements, and ideas for additions. The questions address what was liked about the piece, any questions or unclear parts, topics that could be added or expanded on, ways to improve the introduction or organization, and thoughts on the ending. The creative writer is instructed to listen openly to the feedback while also using their own judgment on how to apply the suggestions to their narrative.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 2

    Name:__________________________

    Honors Seminar Week 2

    Peer Responding & Reviewing

    Directions: Creative writer read your narrative aloud to your group. Creative writer should ask
    the questions below. As the audience/responders answer the questions, take notes about their
    suggestions.
    1. What is something you liked about my piece of writing? Why?
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    2. What questions do you have? (Note: Take notes about questions, for you can add
    information that will help a reader to not have any unanswered questions.)
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    3. Is there something I did not consider or include that you would be interested in knowing
    more about? What do you think that I should change or add?
    What is something you wanted to know more about that I did not include?
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    4. What could I add or change about the introduction to draw you in as a reader?
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    5. What are your opinions and suggestions about the topic of my narrative?
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    6. What specific words, things, or events stand out to you?
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    7. Is there a point in my narrative that could benefit from more details, information, or that
    could be changed? Is there anything that is unclear, too wordy, confusing, etc.? Do I include
    enough details, imagery, and/or figurative language? If not, what suggestions do you have?
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    8. What are your thoughts and suggestions about how my narrative is organized?
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    9. What do you think about the ending and the message?
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    Peer Response Guidelines


    1. Creative WriterRead your personal narrative
    Creative Writer

    Audience/Responder

    Read your personal narrative aloud


    Trust yourself!
    Skip the apologies or disclaimers
    Be willing to be vulnerable!

    Listen actively
    Do not interrupt
    Give your full attention:
    Eye contract & Body language
    Think about the strengths of the
    work

    2. After the reading


    Creative Writer

    Audience/Responder

    Obtain feedback (use the handout)


    Solicit responses and suggestions
    Listen carefully
    Be open and accepting of the feedback
    Do not interrupt the responder

    Remember that this is your story


    You do not need to follow all of the
    suggestions. But listen with an open
    mind. You may use your judgment
    about how best to use the feedback
    that you get.

    Point out the writers strengths


    Provide positive and constructive
    feedback
    Be respectful!
    Be specific, concrete, and thorough
    in your responses
    AVOID: killer comments,
    automatically saying the narrative is
    good or approving of the narrative
    AVOID: Dominating the conversation

    You might also like