Nptel Lecture Notes 2
Nptel Lecture Notes 2
Module # 2
MECHANICAL DESIGN OF HEAT EXCHANGER: MECHANICAL DESIGN OF SHELL AND TUBE
HEAT EXCHANGER
1.
2.
2.2.
Materials of construction
2.3
Design components
2.3.1. Shell diameter and thickness
2.3.2.
Shell cover
Gaskets
SOLVED EXAMPLE
Page 1 of 21
Mechanical design of heat exchangers includes design of various pressure and nonpressure parts. The structural rigidity and satisfactory service of heat exchangers depends
on the appropriate mechanical design. Mechanical design is generally performed
according to the design standardsand codes. Some mechanical design standards used in
heat exchanger design are: TEMA (United States), IS:4503-1967 (India);BS: 3274
(United Kingdom) and BS: 20414 (United Kingdom). The design structure of IS: 45031967 is provided in Table 2.1 [1].
Most countries of the world follow the TEMA (Tubular Exchanger Manufacturers
Association) standards for the mechanical design of unfired shell and tube heat
exchangers. The TEMA standards are applicable for the maximum shell ID and wall
thickness of 60 and 2 inch, a maximum design pressure of 3000 psi and a maximum
nominal diameter (inch) design pressure (psi) of 60000 lb/in, respectively[2].
Three basic classes of TEMA standards are: C, B and R.
-
The class B specifies the standards of heat exchangers for chemical services.
The class R specifies the standards of heat exchangers for more severe
application in petroleum and related processes.
Seven types of shells are standardized by the TEMA. The TEMA standards also specify
the types of front-end, shell, and rear-end of shell and tube exchangers as shown in
Figure 2.1. For example, a fixed tube-sheet type BEM exchanger is illustrated in
Figure1. 2 of module #1.
Page 2 of 21
Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4
Part 5
Part 6
Part 7
Part 8
Part 9
Part 10
Part 11
Part 12
Scope
Types and nomenclature
Terminology
Classification and permitted pressures
Material of constructions
Design stress
General design
Corrosion and corrosion allowance
Shells
Tubes
Tube sheet
Shell covers
Part 13
Part 14
Part 15
Part 16
Part 17
Part 18
Part 19
Part 20
Part 21
Part 22
Part 23
Part 24
Page 3 of 21
Figure 2.1. Types of shells, front end and rear ends (TEMA classifications) [3].
Page 4 of 21
2.
DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
2.1.
Design pressure of a heat exchanger is the gage pressure at the top of the vessel. This
pressure is used to determine the minimum wall thickness of the various pressure parts.
The IS: 4503 species that the design pressure should at least 5% greater than the
maximum allowable working pressure. Usually a 10% higher value is used. The
maximum allowable working pressure is the gage pressure for a specified operating
temperature that is permitted for the service of the exchanger units. According the IS:
4503, the shell and tube sides pressure should be specified individually. The design
pressure specification is at 250, 120 and 65C for carbon steel, stainless steel and nonferrous metals respectively. The maximum permissible stresses for various heat
exchanger components should not be exceeded at the allowable pressure.
The design temperature is used to determine the minimum wall thickness of various parts
of the exchanger for a specified design pressure. It is normally 10C greater than the
maximum allowable temperature.
Page 5 of 21
2.2.
Materials of construction
All materials used construction of shell and heat exchangers for pressure parts must have
the appropriate specification as given in IS: 4503 Appendix C. The materials of
construction should becompatible with process fluids and others parts of materials and
also should be cost effective. The maximum permitted operating fluid temperatures
should not exceeds for the various pressure-retaining components as specified by IS:4503
given inTable 2.2 [1].High chrome-Mo-Ni alloys (Cr content 12-27%)can be used for
high temperature services upto 2100C. Useof any carbon or low alloy steel is not
recommended for the construction of heat exchangers forthe service below 0C.
Table 2.2. Materials of constructions [1].
Materials of construction
Carbon steel
C-Mo steel
Cr-Mo steel
Low alloy steel (< 6 % Cr)
Alloy steel (<17 % Cr)
Austenitic Cr-Ni steel
Cast iron
Brass
Page 6 of 21
Design components
The major mechanical design components of shell and tube heat exchangers are: shell
andtube-sheet thickness, shell cover, flanges, nozzles, gaskets, stress calculations and
design of supports.
= 0.6
+
(2.1)
=shell thickness
= design pressure
= Shell ID
=Maximum allowable stress of the material of construction
=Joint efficiency (usually varies from 0.7 to 0.9)
The minimum shell thicknesses should be decided in compliance with the nominal shell
diameter including the corrosion allowance as specified by IS: 4503. Usually the
minimum shell thicknesses are in order for various materials for the same service:Cast
iron> Carbon steel Al and Al-alloys (up to 700C)> Cu and Cu-alloys Ni
Austenitic stainless steel= Monel inconel.
Page 7 of 21
th
pRiW
c
(2 fJ 0.2 p )
(2.2)
1
R
W 3 i
4
ri
(2.3)
= Crown radius, =Knucle radius, =corrosion allowance
= 10
(2.4)
= diameter of the cover [mm] usually same as the outside shell diameter
1 = a factor which is 0.25 when the cover is bolted with fullfaced gaskets and 0.3 when
bolted with narrow faced or ring type gaskets
= design pressure in kgf/cm2and
= allowable stress value in kgf/mm2 at design temperature
Page 8 of 21
FG p
3
P
kf
(2.5)
Where, =1 for fixed tube and floating type tube sheet; =1.25 for U-tube tube sheet
=diameter over which pressure is acting (for fixed tube sheet heat exchanger = ,
shell ID; is port inside diameter for kettle type, for floating tube sheet shall be used
for stationery tube sheet).
= allowable stress for the tube sheet material
Mean ligament efficiency ():
=1
0.907
2
(2.6)
=1
0.785
2
(2.7)
Page 9 of 21
0.31
(2.8)
Where, =
is the perimeter measured by connecting the center to center of the outermost tubes of
tube layout.
=Total area enclosed by
The shear formula does not control the tube sheet thickness when:
< 1.6 1
(2.9)
The effective thickness of the tube sheets also can be calculated by the method given in
Appendix Eof IS:4503, by trial and error approach. IS:4503 specifies that the minimum
tube sheet thickness should be between 6 and 25.4 mm based on the outside tube
diameter.
shell
channel
shell
shell
channel
tube
tube sheet
a).
channel
tube
tube sheet
b).
tube
tube sheet
c).
Figure 2.2. Tube sheet connections: a) Integral construction on both sides, b). one side integral construction and other side
gasketed construction, c). both side gasketed construction.
Page 10 of 21
Page 11 of 21
(2.10)
( +1)
(2.11)
[The IS:4503 specifies that the minimum width of peripheral ring gaskets for
external joints shall be 10 mm for shell sizes up to 600 mm nominal diameter and 13
mm for all larger shell sizes]
Page 12 of 21
Table 2.4. Gasket factors and minimum gasket seating force [4].
Gasket materials
Gasket
factor
()
3.25
3.50
3.75
3.50
3.75
3.75
4.00
4.75
5.50
6.00
6.00
6.50
2.50
2.75
3.00
3.00
3.25
3.50
Flat
metal Soft Al
jacketed, asbestos Soft Cu or brass
fill
Iron or soft steel
Monel
Chrome 4-6%
Stainless steel
Soft Al
Solid flat metal
Soft Cu or brass
Iron or soft steel
Monel
Chrome 4-6%
Stainless steel
Corrugated metal Soft Al
with asbestos fill
Soft Cu or brass
Iron or soft steel
Monel
Chrome 4-6%
Stainless steel
(2.12)
The gasket is compressed under tight pressure. The required bolt load (2 ) is given by:
Wm 2
H H
2 bGmp
G2 p
(2.13)
+
2
(2.14)
inch (6 mm)
Page 13 of 21
(2.17)
(2.18)
Check for the minimum gasket width, = 2
(2.19)
2.3.10.
Design of flange
(2.20)
Where, is the centre line to centre line bolt-spacing can be taken same as outside shell
diameter)
Pressure force on the flange face, =
(2.21)
(2.22)
(2.23)
(2.24)
(2.25)
(2.26)
(2.27)
+
2
(2.28)
(2.29)
Page 14 of 21
( )
2
(2.30)
Calculate the flange thickness ( ) based on the maximum value for the gasket seating
condition or operating condition given by:
=
(2.31)
2.3.11.
Design of supports
The selection of the type of support for a pressure vessel depends on various parameters
like the vessel elevation from the ground, materials of construction, wall thickness,
operating temperature, external loads (such as wind loads, seismic condition
etc).Supports for The vertical pressure vessels units are supported generally by i). skirt
supports, ii). ring supports and iii).lug supports. Whereas, the horizontal pressure vessels
are supported by i). saddle supports, ii). leg supports and iii). ring supports. Saddle
supports are widely used in horizontal heat exchanger units.
IS:4503 specifies that the horizontal heat exchanger units shall be provided with at least
two supporting saddles with holes for anchor bolts. The holes in at least one of the
supports shall be elongated to provide for expansion of the shell. The vertical units shall
be provided with at least two supports of sufficient size to carry the unit in a supporting
structure of sufficient width to clear shell flanges.
Page 15 of 21
SOLVED EXAMPLE
Shell side and tube side passes: 1 shell pass and 6 tube passes.
b.
Number, type, size, and layout of tubes: Number of tubes 318; tube length 20
(6.096 m as per IS: 4503-1967 and IS:2844-1964 standards); tube OD 1
(25.4 mm); tube ID: 0.834 (21.2 mm); square pitch ( = 114 "); fixed tube
sheet.
c.
d.
e.
f.
Page 16 of 21
i.
= 0.6
+ ; = 0.8
(2.1)
=3.72 mm
Including corrosion allowance 6.72 mm, use 8 mm thickness
(This value is in accordance to IS:4503 corresponding to the shell diameter)
ii.
D
D
h R R s R s 2 ri
i i i 2 i 2
= 105.4 mm
pRiW
t
Page 17 of 21
iii.
= 10
(2.4)
=Outside shell diameter=803.4 mm; 1 =0.3; =3.88 kgf/cm2 (0.38 N/mm2)
=10.26 kgf/mm2 (100.6 N/mm2)
=8.5 mm; Use 12 mm including the corrosion allowance
iv.
The tube sheet thickness is calculated based on the bending and considering the design
pressure only. It is assumed that shear does not control the design. Carbon steel is used
for tube sheet material.
tts
FG p
3
P
kf
(2.5)
=1 for fixed tube sheet; =0.5 (square pitch)
=22.8 mm (satisfies the IS:4503 specification for 1 outside diameter tube)
v.
Impingement plate (refer to section 2.3.6)
The density (k) of the tube side fluid (kerosene) =0.8g/cm3 (800 kg/m3);mass flow rate (
.
Kerosene velocity, =
mk
2
18.91
0.2032 2
4
800
=0.73 m/s
Page 18 of 21
vi.
pDn
=0.48 mm
c
2 fJ p
(2.1)
Use 6 mm thickness including the corrosion allowance.
The pressures at the entry point of both shell side and tube fluid are same.
Therefore, the same nozzle specification can be used for tube side fluid also.
vii.
( +1)
(2.10)
Gasket factor =3.75, minimum design seating stress Y= 5.35 kgf/mm2 (for flat iron
jacketed, asbestos fill) (Table 2.4)
830 mm
Gasket width, = ( )/2=22 mm, Use 35 mm
(2.11)
Mean gasket diameter =
+
2
= 808 mm
(2.12)
The bolt load under tight pressure:
Wm 2
2 bGmp
(2.13)
Joint initiative of IITs and IISc Funded by MHRD
Page 19 of 21
278515
= 2769 mm2
100.6
(2.18)
M16 nominal thread diameter with bolt circle diameter ( ) of 860 mm, 32 bolts and 18
mm root diameter ( ) are selected from IS:4866-1968.
2
Corresponding actual bolt circle diameter, = 4
. =8143 mm2
(2.19)
8143 100.6
2769+8143 100.6
= 2 =
=548874 N
2
(2.28)
( )
529458 (860808)
=
=
=14270714 N-mm
2
2
(2.30)
ii.
=
803.42 0.38
4
(2.25)
= =5451570 N-mm
(=Outside shell diameter=787.4+16=803.4 mm)
= ; =
= 2
=
2
4
2
4
808 2 0.38
4
=194848; = 2 = 207870 N
(2.27)
=207870-194848=13022 N
Page 20 of 21
(2.31)
900
14270714 18
100.6803.4
=56.4 mm
Practice problem:Perform the mechanical design of the condenser and Kettle type
reboiler thermal design problem provided in the module #1.
References
[1].
[2].
[3].
[4].
Indian Standard (IS: 4503-1967): Specification for Shell and Tube Type Heat
Exchangers, BIS 2007, New Delhi.
Kuppan T. Heat Exchanger Design Handbook, Marcel Dekker, Inc. 2000, New
York.
Standards of the Tubular Exchanger Manufacturers Association (TEMA), Inc. 18
ed., 1999, New York.
Brownell L.E. and E.H. Young, Process Equipment Design, John Wiley and Sons,
Inc. 1959. New York.
Page 21 of 21