P Patel - Trial
P Patel - Trial
P Patel - Trial
Negative
Student Names
Student Names
Name:___________________________________________
Lullabies For Little Criminals
Secondary 5 - English
Task:
For this assignment, you are asked to use the characters and events from the novel to
present a mock trial. Based on whether you are on the affirmative or negative team, you
must work with your group to prove your side of the argument. Each team must have:
Three arguments of support using textual details from the novel (you may use quotes
from the characters or events that occur)
Each argument should be a maximum of 2 minutes.
One witness (your witness will be a member from your own team whom you will use
to make your arguments)
No more than 5 questions may be asked to the witness
Once your arguments are formed, your team will chose two representatives to act as your
lawyers during the trial, or in other words, your spokespersons. They must address the
audience as real judges, witnesses and audience members, in addition to using formal
language and delivery of arguments.
Resolution: Jules should lose parental custody of Baby
Evaluation:
Following the trial, you will write a 350 word response on whether Jules should lose custody
of Baby, regardless of the arguments presented by your team in the trial. Use evidence from
the text to support your arguments. You must also indicate if your initial decision changed
after the trial and indicate which arguments persuaded you. You will also submit your notes
from the research phase to prove your active participation in the trial.
Read (English)
Criteria
Excellent
100-88%
Very Good
87-78%
Good
77-72%
Satisfactory
71-66%
Needs development
65% or lower
Transforms initial
readings into more
conscious
interpretations
Locates textual details
that support own
interpretations
Constructs
interpretations that
embody both own world
and the text
Total:
Argument # 2:
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Support:
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Argument # 3:
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Support:
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Additional Notes:
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________