ACFIM Final Report
ACFIM Final Report
ACFIM Final Report
You may re-use this information (not including logos) free of charge in any
format or medium
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
On behalf of the Steering Committee of ACFIM and on my own behalf, I wish to
extend our most sincere gratitude to the Researchers, Research Assistants and
District Supervisors who endured difficult times and collected data on campaign
financing at constituency and national levels over an extended period of 10 months.
We thank all political party officials and campaign agents that volunteered vital
information to our Researchers and Research Assistants. Without you this report
would never have been. Special recognition goes to the Database Manager who
worked tirelessly in navigating the database, testing the quality and consistence of
data posted, following up with data entry clerks, cleaning and analysing the data to
be able to provide us with the information that makes this report unique.
I cannot forget to thank our development partners, the Democratic Governance
Facility (DGF) for trusting and believing in ACFIM to do what no other organisation
has successfully done in Africa. Without your financial support the dream of ACFIM
partners to come up with credible estimates of expenditure in 16 districts for
Presidential and Member of Parliament campaigns, would probably never have seen
the light of day.
To the National Democratic Institute (NDI) and National Endowment for Democracy
(NED) we thank you for your continued technical and financial support. The parallel
projects you supported produced synergy that strengthened the capacity of ACFIM
Secretariat and partner organisations to manage and coordinate a project of this
nature.
To the staff of ACFIM and the host organisation Transparency International Uganda
(TIU), thank you for the hard work you put into the project.
Last but by no means least, the Steering Committee of ACFIM and particularly the
Chairperson that worked hard to ensure the smooth running of the ACFIM Secretariat
in coordinating the implementation of this study. Your efforts are priceless.
Thank you very much every one.
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.................................................................................................v
LIST OF TABLES.............................................................................................................ix
LIST OF FIGURES...........................................................................................................xi
ABBREVIATIONS.......................................................................................................... xiii
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY................................................................................................xv
1.0
INTRODUCTION
5. 0
FINANCING OF
ELECTION CAMPAIGNS
2015/2016
ii
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
6. 0
OVERALL CAMPAIGN
SPENDING BY
PRESIDENTIAL
CANDIDATES
7. 0
GENERAL
OBSERVATIONS AT
CONSTITUENCY LEVEL
8. 0
ANALYSIS OF
DONATIONS TO
VOTERS
9. 0 VOTER TOURISM................................................................................................... 23
10. 0 MISUSE OF GOVERNMENT ADMINISTRATIVE RESOURCES FOR CAMPAIGNS.23
iii
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
11. 0
ANALYTICAL CASE
STUDIES ON FLOW OF
NATIONAL BUDGET
RESOURCES
iv
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1:
Table 2:
Table 3:
Table 4:
Table 5:
Table 6:
Table 7:
Table 8:
Table 9:
Table 10:
Table 11:
Table 12:
Table 13:
Table 14:
Table 15:
Table 16:
Table 17:
Table 18:
Table 19:
Table 20:
Table 21:
Table 22:
Table 23:
Table 24:
Table 25:
Table 26:
Table 27:
Table 28:
Table 29:
Table 30:
Table 31:
Table 32:
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Table 33:
Table 34:
Table 35:
Table 36:
Table 37:
Table 38:
Table 39:
Table 40:
Table 41:
Table 42:
Table 43:
Table 44:
Table 45:
Table 46:
Table 47:
Table 48:
Table 49:
vi
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2:
Figure 3:
Figure 4:
Figure 5:
Figure 6:
vii
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
viii
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
ABBREVIATIONS
ACCOB
ACCU
ACFIM
CEON-U
CIPDA
CODI
COG
CP
Conservative Party
DGF
DP
Democratic Party
EC Electoral Commission
FABIO
FDC
FY Financial Year
GDP
KICK
LC Local Council
MACCO
MDA
MIRAC
MONARLIP
MP
Member of Parliament
NDI
NRM
NTF
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
NUAC
PPOA
RA
Research Assistant
RAC
SMS
TAACC
TAC
TDA
TIU
UBOS
UGX
Uganda Shillings
UPC
WACSOF
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Introduction
Currently, money dominates Ugandas politics and as a result the gap between
elected politicians and their voters has widened substantially. This has created an
environment where the principles of political accountability are grossly undermined.
In November 2014 the Governor Bank of Uganda Emmanuel Tumusiime-Mutebile
was reported confessing that he had been misled by the government into indirectly
financing election activities in 2011, an action which plunged the countrys economy
into chaos. He promised not to repeat the same mistake in 2016. ACFIM observed
that during the campaign period of 2015/2016 Government spending was kept
within sector ceilings, so there was no extreme surges and no visible shocks in the
economy. This, however, is not the whole story.
This report is an outcome of a 10 month study conducted by the Alliance for Campaign
Finance Monitoring (ACFIM)1 on the financing of campaigns for the Presidential and
Member of Parliament Ugandan elections of 2016.
Campaign Spending
ACFIMs study has recorded that the total expenditure incurred by all political
parties and independent candidates that contested in the Presidential and Member
of Parliament races in the 16 districts combined is a minimum of UGX 435 billion (US$
128 million). If this figure is extrapolated in view of all the 112 districts of Uganda, it
ACFIM is a coalition of 16 local non-government organisations network that cane together in 2014 to foster transparency
and accountability in financing of political and electoral processes.
(for details visit: www.acfimuganda.org)
1
xi
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
can be estimated that at least UGX 2.4 trillion (US$ 716 million) was spent by political
parties and candidates on the elections campaigns of 2015/2016.
The majority of the recorded campaign spending in the 16 districts (76.6 per cent)
was done by the Incumbent National Resistance Movement (NRM) party to the
tune of at least UGX 333bn (US$ 98 million), followed by independent candidates. A
combined minimum of UGX 122.5 billion (US$ 36 million) is estimated to have been
spent by all the other presidential candidates combined during the campaign period
(November 3rd 2015 February 16th 2016).
Incumbent candidate Yoweri Museveni outspent the other candidates by 91.5 per
cent. The second biggest spender was candidate Amama Mbabazi (6.3 percent)
and third biggest, candidate Kizza Besigye (1.8 per cent). The lowest spender
amongst the presidential candidates was candidate Mourine Faith Walube Kyalya
representing 0.01 per cent of the observed combined expenditure by presidential
candidates. Other candidates spending was below 2 per cent namely: Venasius
Baryamureeba (0.18 per cent), Benon Biraaro (0.1 per cent), Abed Bwanika (0.1 per
cent) and Joseph Mabirizi (0.05 per cent).
Kampala district recorded the highest campaign spending at constituency level
with a share of 27.3 per cent, followed by Luweero District (16 per cent), Masaka
District (9.4 per cent), Iganga District (7.5 per cent) and Jinja District (7.2 per cent).
The districts in which presidential candidates spent the least was in the districts of
Nwoya (1.1 per cent), Hoima (1.6 per cent), Kanungu (2.1 per cent), Kabalore (2.3 per
cent) and Apac (2.6 per cent).
Recommendations
Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Affairs; and Parliament
xii
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
2 Purchase of control is when a private company used the power of its contribution to a political candidate to influence
business decisions in its favour.
3
Political Parties and Organisations Act (as amended) 2010, Section 14 (d), provides that the funds provided to political
parties and organisations under this Act, shall be subject to audit by the Auditor General.
xiii
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
xiv
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background and Context
There is a broad consensus within civil society, academia and in the political sphere
that the commercialisation of political and electoral processes is a major challenge
to Ugandas progression into a modern democracy. Ugandans often observe with
disbelief as elected politicians in parliament or local councils get co-opted and
sometimes bought to serve the interests of the one with biggest pockets, rather
than the one who will serve the people the best. The use of money to induce voters
during campaigns has given leeway for stained politicians to successfully compete in
elections at the expense of talented and well-intentioned but less resourced leaders.
Equally, when a political party or candidate resorts to paying for votes rather than
focusing on the quality of its campaign message, democracy suffers.
Covert party and candidate funding streams, influence peddling and leveraging state
resources for party campaign purposes serve to compromise the greatest asset of
democracy fair competition, faith and support of ordinary citizens in the political
process. Corruption in the financing of election campaigns damages democracy
because it undermines elections and distorts and inhibits political competition. But
the damage does not end there, it goes deeper to affect the quality of governance
when subsequent decisions by elected politicians are taken to pay back those who
funded their ascent to power, rather than for the benefit of the population as a
whole. Corruption in political finance erodes trust in the institutions of democracy,
when scandal after scandal reveals politicians sharing the spoils of power with their
financial backers.
Alliance for Campaign Finance Monitoring (ACFIM) has been promoting transparency
and accountability in financing of political and electoral processes since 2014.
From May 2015 to February 2016, the organisation embarked on the onerous task
of monitoring the financing of political party activities and campaigns in Uganda.
This research was conducted in order to investigate the means by which political
parties and candidates in Uganda raise financial resources and how they spend them
in election campaigns. This undertaking was implemented by 16 ACFIM partners
working in 16 sample districts where Research Assistants were deployed on the
ground to track campaign activities and used data collection tools to quantify the
amount of money political parties and candidates spend. No other organisation
in Africa had ever succeeded in doing this, and this task was made even harder as
Uganda is a country which has no legal provisions requiring candidates and political
parties to disclose campaign income and expenditure.
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
As elaborated in the subsequent chapters of this report, the playing field for
campaign financing between the incumbent political party and opposition parties is
uneven. Political parties and candidates that participated in the election campaigns
2015/2016 spent huge amounts of money, in what could turn out to be the most
expensive campaigns in the history of Ugandas multiparty democracy. The countrys
electoral laws4 have provisions requiring all political parties to disclose to the
Electoral Commission their annual income and expenditure and provide copies of
their annual audit report. There are also provisions against voter bribery and misuse
of government resources but these are not enforced.
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Forum for Democratic Change (FDC) party flag-bearer Kizza Besigye Kifefe came
second with 37% of the total votes casted. International election observers concluded
that while the results reflected the will of Ugandans that were able to vote,
there were serious irregularities and shortfalls. In particular, the Commonwealth
Observer Group (COG) noted that:
a) There was lack of a level playing field and a failure to ensure a distinction
between the ruling party and state.
b) The COG further observed harassment of Kizza Besigye, the lead
opposition candidate
c) The lack of balance in media coverage and the use of financial and
material handouts to induce voters.
Against that background, the Commonwealth Observer Group recommended
among other things the following:
a) More stringent and explicit regulations limiting the use of state resources
for campaign purposes should be introduced, thereby helping to create a
more level playing field for the elections.
b) Enforcement of legislation with respect to vote buying.
c) The Introduction of regulations stipulating expenditure ceilings on election
campaigns.
d) A requirement for political parties and candidates to provide more detailed
accounts of funding and expenditure for their campaign, which will help to
create a higher level of transparency and accountability. This would also
help to address the current misuse of money on political campaigns.
These recommendations were aimed at strengthening the regulatory framework for
campaign financing in Uganda with a view of equalizing the conditions for political
competition.
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Kizza Besigye in specific indicted President-elect Yoweri Museveni and the Electoral
Commission on several grounds, including voter bribery. Ultimately, three out of five
judges declared that although they had sufficient evidence to prove voter bribery
had taken place, it was not significant enough to alter the outcome of the elections.
Subsequently the use of money in political and electoral processes escalated to
unprecedented levels in 2011. Although information to back up this statement
remains largely anecdotal, a number of Members of Parliament ascertain that in
2011, candidates with more money are the ones that were largely voted into the
9th parliament.
Figure 1: Survey on Commercialization of Ugandas Political Culture
When asked about the sources of campaign financing, MPs said that most of their
campaign income (79 per cent) came from their personal resources. They indicated
that donations from their Party was their second most important source for financing
their election campaigns representing 39 per cent of their total campaign income.
In another survey conducted by ACFIM titled Shaking the Mango Tree5, in which
the citizens at the grassroots were targeted in February March 2015, revealed
among other things the following:
a) There is deep seated cynicism about the political processes in Uganda. People
do not trust politicians promises. Citizens do not believe that casting their
The study involved 64 focus group discussions attended by between 10-15 people. It was conducted at village level 13 Districts namely: Kabale, Kabalore, Bushenyi, Luweero, Masaka, Jinja, Iganga, Bukedea, Moroto, Apac, Lira, Arua and Hoima.
5
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
addressing the 10th annual meeting of the African Science Academies at the Lake
Victoria Serena Hotel in Kampala. In the reportage Tumusiime-Mutebile explained
that although the Central Bank did not directly print money for the elections, there
were indirect expenditures by the government into what he called areas that were
not transparent. The statements of the Central Bank Governor were consistent the
following month (December 2014) when he was reported accepting the mistake
he had committed in 2011 but noted that it was not his role to determine how the
government uses the money obtained from treasury bills. He however promised
Ugandans that the Central Bank would not print more money in 2016 for fear that
some of it may end up facilitating political campaigns or even worse, fuel inflation
such as the one that hit the economy after the 2011 elections.
The statements from the Central Bank Governor provided Ugandans with a clue
of what may have happened to some of their tax payers money budgeted for the
delivery of development and social services in FY 2010/2011. To the elite citizenry of
Uganda the Governors statement gave an insight into what was likely to happen
in 2016, the possibility of budgeted funds being diverted once again for campaign
financing ostensibly by the incumbent government. The discourse within the
citizenry about what may or may not happen to budget funds during the year of
campaigns increased public suspicion and speculation about the diversion of budget
funds to finance campaigns in favour of incumbent political party.
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Table 1: Sector Budget Allocations for FY 2014/15 and FY 2015-16 (UGX, Billions)
Sector
Security
FY 2014/15
Approved
Budget
FY 2015/16
Approved
Budget
Variance
% change
1,159.29
1,636.14
476.85
41%
Public Administration
554.84
753.651
198.81
36%
Legislature
331.92
371.30
39.38
12%
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
No. Seats
Budget Allocation
(UGX)
% Share
37
1,145,510,836
11%
259
8,018,575,851
80%
JEEMA
30,959,752
0%
Conservative Party
30,959,752
0%
10
309,597,285
3%
Democratic Party
15
464,396,285
5%
10,000,000,000
100%
Total
10
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Approximately, the NRM received a total of UGX 8.2 Bn (80.2%) of the total public
funding. The FDC received an approximate total of UGX1.14bn (11.5%), DP received
UGX 471 million, and UPC received UGX 309 million, while JEEMA and CP received
UGX 30.9 million. Out of a total of twenty nine registered political parties in Uganda,
only six qualified to benefit from the public resource distribution.
(ii). Sale of Party Membership Cards, T-Shirts, Badges, etc.
The second disclosed source of campaign financing is contributions from the sale of
party cards (mainly done by the parties in the opposition). Despite the disappointment
over ownership of political party cards (also because there are no alluring benefits
of members), a few parties such as the FDC, UPC and DP managed to sell cards
to potential members. However, this is not vigorously done as a mobilization and
recruitment tool. The NRM on the other hand which boasts to have registered a
total of 10.2 million members, carried out the registration and distribution of party
cards without charging any money. Thus in terms of funding, the majority of the
parties are losing income from this source rather than gaining.
(iii). Business Arm of the Party.
There is only one party in Uganda which can make reference to their own internal
sources derived from business contributions. UPC through the Milton Obote
Foundation; receives a monthly contribution of 5,000,000 (five million) shillings
to cover administrative costs. Although parties like FDC and JEEMA have political
homes with structures of their own, they do not generate additional resources from
them.
11
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
12
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
is higher in the opposition political parties partly for fear of economic repression or
retribution by the government in power. A report by Roger Tangri and Andrew Mwenda
indicates that the party in power - the NRM, always cashes into large sums of
financial support coming from the Asian Businesses and local businesses in Uganda
for its campaign activities in return for privileges and favors. The report mentions
business enterprises like the Mukwano group of companies, Sudhir Ruparelia and
his business empire that includes Crane bank and a chain of hotels; Karim Hirji,
Madhvani, Mehta, SWIPCO and Mandela of City Oil and City Tyres. In 2011 alone, the
NRM is alleged to have received USD 50m. All these business groups then reap the
rewards in terms of tax deductions or waivers, land giveaways, and government
contracts among others.
13
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
The MP aspirants all aim at ensuring that there is a campaign structure through which
mobilization can be realized. Below is an example of one of the Constituencies in
Western Uganda with 4 sub counties and 24 parishes in total.
14
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
on local print and electronic media as well as counter the negative publicity from
opponents.
15
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
The scope of this extensive study focused on answering questions on the following
five aspects:
1) Quantity of money spent by political parties and candidates contesting in
the presidential and Member of Parliament races.
2) The use of national budget funds during the financial year of 2015/2016 the
year of the general elections in Uganda
3) The extent and effects of vote buying on election outcomes
4) The misuse of government resources for political campaigns
5) If regulatory framework for financing of political parties and election
campaigns was enforced and if so, how it was done.
The study comprised two strands namely:
a) National level where analytical case studies were conducted pertaining to
the flow and use of funds from the national budget during campaigns;
b) Constituency level where the focus was put on monitoring campaign
activities on the ground in order to quantify the amount of money spent by
political parties and candidates during 2016 election campaigns in 16 districts.
16
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
events, use of government vehicles for campaign activities, and direct distribution
to voters of public funds or goods and services purchased with public funds. We also
analysed expenditure trends in selected government ministries, departments and
agencies. The studies were limited to the following budget votes:
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
Region
Direct
Constituencies
Woman MP
Constituencies
1.
Kampala
Capital City
2.
Masaka
Central
3.
Luweero
Central
4.
Jinja
Busoga
5.
Iganga
Busoga
6.
Kabale
Kigezi
7.
Kanungu
Kigezi
8.
Bushenyi
Ankole
9.
Kabalore
Rwenzori
10.
Hoima
Bunyoro
11.
Arua
West Nile
12.
Nwoya
Acholi
13.
Lira
Lango
14.
Apac
Lango
15.
Moroto
Karamoja
16.
Katakwi
Teso
58
74
TOTAL
17
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
In a country where there are no legal provisions that require political candidates to
disclose their campaign income and expenditure, the task of monitoring campaign
expenses is a difficult one. Because of these difficulties, the study set out to track
and record just minimum expenditures incurred by political parties and candidates
on campaign trail. The study monitored the following campaign events:
Consultative meetings
Campaign Events / Rallies
Publicity
Fundraising events
Outdoor advertising and promotional materials
Stipends for campaign agents
Transport and fuel expenses
Media expenses
Campaign donations and handout materials
Expenses on voter tourism and hospitality
Campaign Coordination and Administration expenses
Election day expenses on polling agents
Figure 6: Map Showing the Geographical Spread of the Districts
Covered Under this Study
18
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
3. METHODOLOGY
A preliminary / scoping study was conducted on campaign financing in Uganda.
The study interrogated the means by which campaign money is raised and spent by
political parties and candidates as well as the regulatory framework for campaign
financing in Uganda. Findings informed the process of defining the scope this
extended study and determining the type of tools and caliber of Research Assistants
that we needed to collect data.
Whereas the study is informed by data from primary and secondary sources, it
the analysis is mostly informed by primary data that was collected at constituency
level and from discreet interviews with officials in political parties and government
institutions. Secondary data was mostly used to support analysis of budget utilization
at national level.
19
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
trained long-term Research Assistants (RAs) that used their familiarity with the
local context and situational awareness to gather the required data. These men and
women kept their identity concealed but worked with a network of informers some
of whom were campaign agents of different political candidates. Each Research
Assistant was assigned one constituency in which they used skills obtained at their
training to observe and document campaign expenses directly or indirectly through
credible third party informers whom they identified using their familiarity with the
constituency. The RAs tracked observable spending on campaign events, outdoor
advertising and donations among others, and where possible, covert campaign
spending done by presidential and Member of Parliament candidates through
proxies.
Before an expense was entered into a form, the RA was required to verify the cost
from at least three different sources namely: the campaign agent, the supplier
and the ongoing market rate. The suppliers were skillfully approached to find out
how much they charged the candidates. In some constituencies the candidates or
their agents volunteered the information. Triangulation was also applied to the
data before it would be entered for analysis. This was achieved by interviewing the
suppliers of the goods and services, or a friendly member of the campaign team or
in some cases, the candidate itself. In cases where the suppliers declined to share
information and informers in the campaign camps also refused, we relied on the
average cost estimate form. Monitoring misuse of government vehicles and civil
servants for campaigns was also done through direct and indirect observation.
The district supervisors regularly visited the different constituencies to verify data
that had been submitted to the different forms as well as to ensure that the RAs
followed thoroughly the basic principles of quality data collection. In addition,
ACFIM secretariat made monthly field visits in order to speak to the RAs about their
experiences, challenges and lessons.
Data was entered into a central database by well-trained and closely supervised
Data Entry Clerks. The Database Manager at ACFIM secretariat examined entered
data for consistence and validity. Field visits were regularly made based on advice
from the Database Manager to test-retest the data. This was done by independently
interviewing some of the suppliers of campaign goods and services to establish the
validity of data collected. Data was cleaned of inconsistencies, stored and analysed.
Critical incidences were also transmitted to supervisors in real time through phone
calls or SMS text messaging. ACFIM observers/monitors were strongly advised
to collect photographic or video evidence to back up their data and reports. It is
important to note that the RAs improved their skills immensely throughout the
entire period which can be reflected in the improved quality of the data collected
and subsequently, the quality of the ACFIM progress reports.
20
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
3.4 Sampling
At the district level purposive sampling method was used to pick one districts in
the regions where ACFIM partners operate and cover all the constituencies in the
district. For the national level studies, sampling was used to select MDAs for review
and analysis. This approach was helpful because it took into account the mandate
and budgetary allocations of MDAs that were analysed. The selected MDAs here
within included; Office of the President, Ministry of Defence, Parliament of Uganda,
State House, and the EC. This was because these institutions play a key role in the
administrative section of government, and more importantly played a key role
during the 2016 general elections.
21
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
confidence level. That is to say, there is a 95 per cent probability that the expenses
in this report are real and not the result of sampling error.
22
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
23
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
24
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
record of a Statement of its accounts, showing the sources of its funds and the
name of any person who has contributed to the funds including contributions by
persons who are not citizens of Uganda, membership dues paid, donations in cash
or in kind and all the financial transactions of the political party or organisation
which are conducted through, by or with the head or national office of the political
party or organisation. As regards individual candidates, Sec 19 (6) of the Presidential
Elections Act provides that they should maintain records of all assistance obtained
during the campaigns.
Key Gaps in Legal Framework Pertaining to Election Campaign Financing
a) Amendment of section 25 of the Public Finance Management Act 2015 in
October 2015 (just 8 months after its enactment) that relaxed the principles
governing supplementary budgets. This created a loophole than can enable
manipulation of inflows of budget funds and its expenditure during the
year of election campaigns. In other words the amendment circumvented
the oversight of parliament and use the central bank and treasury to draw
money for supplementary budget without prior approval.
b) Section 27 (2) of the Presidential Elections Act (as amended) 2005 allows a
candidate who holds the office of President to continue using government
facilities attached to his/her office during campaigns. For election campaign
year 2015-2016 the incumbent president had the entire budgets of State
House and Office of the President to his disposal.
c) There are no provisions in the national laws that restrict private companies/
corporations (national and international) with running government contracts
or partial government ownership from making campaign contributions to
the incumbent party in government or other political parties participating
in the elections. This provides fertile grounds for a form of corruption in
campaign finance where private corporations make quid-pro-quo donations
to prospective political parties or candidates in return for favourable
treatment by elected representatives. This type of corruption often results
in finance scandals, particularly in the domain of public contracting.
d) There are no rules regulating campaign income and expenditure. Regulation
in this context includes disclosure of campaign income and expenditure; and
putting limits of campaign spending. Absence of restrictions on spending
can result in spiralling campaign costs, which, in turn, encourages parties
and candidates to engage in corrupt financing to meet ever-increasing
financial demands. The significance of this gap is premised on grounds that
election campaigns are one-off events that are subject to different financial
pressures. Political parties and individual candidates invest large amounts
of money. The lack of regulatory framework for campaign financing largely
25
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
26
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
5. FINANCING OF ELECTION
CAMPAIGNS 2015/2016
5.1 Anatomy of Campaign Expenditure
This section presents credible estimates of campaign expenses incurred by political
parties and individual candidates that contested in Presidential and Member of
Parliament races as monitored and documented by ACFIM over an extended preelection period of ten months. This period covers the months May 1st December
30th, 2015 and January 1st February 18th, 2016. Tracking and documenting campaign
spending for the first time in the political history of Uganda was as challenging as
had been anticipated due to a number of reasons.
First, politicians spend money not only through formal ways but also through proxies
and third parties, as well as at times even at night. Covert campaign spending was
difficult for ACFIM to track. Second, political parties and individual candidates do not
keep updated record of campaign expenditure. As such many of them may not be in
position to tell the correct amount of money they spent during the campaign period.
Third, some of the people who received money from political parties and individual
candidates were reluctant to reveal the correct information about the amounts
received. Fourthly, the lack of legal requirements for the disclosure of campaign
expenditure made the work to monitoring campaign spending much harder.
Nonetheless by exercising a high degree of cunningness and sustaining a network
of informers, ACFIM Research Assistants were to the extent possible able to obtain
credible data that has enabled us to quantify the minimum expenditure by political
parties and individual candidates contesting in the Presidential and Member of
Parliament races 2015-2016. The figures provided in relation to political party spending
include observable expenditure made at national and constituency levels. Some
of the national level expenses we observed include party delegates conferences,
party primary elections, contribution to party flag bearers, media expenses, office
administration and campaign coordination expenses.
27
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
28
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
29
132,000
UPC
23.46
Overall
Increase
Monthly
Month %
102,124,980
TOTAL
153,080
DP
OTHERS
327,900
1,512,000
100,000,000
May-2015 to
Oct-2015
(000s)
GO FORWARD
FDC
INDEPENDENTS
NRM
PARTY
11.40
49,625,169
127,170
184,342
429,480
849,120
1,293,965
2,327,800
44,413,292
Nov-2015
(000s)
77.5
20.23
34.4
27.18
118,348,132
599,326
160,543
321,682
2,964,231
4,432,770
42,543,780
67,325,800
Jan-2016
(000s)
-34.8
17.73
77,189,095
742,890
189,311
532,764
3,427,440
3,196,390
24,068,100
45,032,200
Feb-2016
(000s)
100.00
435,350,411
1,699,213
894,453
1,661,389
8,218,477
12,047,378
77,469,074
333,360,427
Combined
Spending
in 16 Districts
(000s)
88,063,035
229,827
228,257
224,383
649,786
1,612,253
8,529,394
76,589,135
Dec-2015
(000s)
11,894,491
5,469,171
10,711,243
55,561,937
75,259,646
542,283,518
100.0 2,434,702,995
0.4
0.2
0.4
1.9
2.8
17.8
716,089,116
3,498,380
1,608,580
3,150,366
16,341,746
22,135,190
159,495,152
509,859,703
76.6 1,733,522,989
Overall
%
30
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
31
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
15,000,000,000
19,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
TOTAL
6,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
30,000,000,000
100,000,000,000
Total Estimates
(UGX)
1.
2.
11,000,000
3.
4.
300,000,000
TOTAL
327,900,000
6,000,000
10,900,000
32
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
mates (UGX)
1.
2.
2.
3.
4.
350,000,000
100,000,000
409,000,000
70,000,000
583,000,000
1,512,000,000
1.
2.
Political Party
Delegates
Conference
Democratic Party
(DP)
Uganda Peoples
Congress (UPC)
153,000,000
3,000,000
156,000,000
132,000,000
132,000,000
33
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
34
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
Conferences/
Cash for
Flagbearers
80,250,139,000
18.4
Campaign
Managers/
Agents
58,912,025,000
13.5
Selected
Campaign
Materials
56,705,153,000
13.0
Donations &
Fundraisings
51,258,741,000
11.8
Campaign
Events/Rally/
Meetings
43,052,790,000
9.9
Transport
Expenses
Fuel & Hire of Buses, Lorries, BodaBodas, Helicopter, Van/Taxis, Cars etc
39,532,537,000
9.1
Advertising
27,743,133,000
6.4
Handout
Materials
21,237,412,000
4.9
Campaign
Offices
17,730,586,700
4.1
Electronic &
Print Media
9,678,243,000
2.2
Others
29,249,651,000
6.7
TOTAL
435,350,410,700
100.0
35
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
36
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
NRM Expenses on Billboards of Incumbent Yoweri Museveni. ACFIM Research Assistants reported that
some of the billboards were not directly finance by NRM candidate Museveni but by supporters and wellwishers of the party. Spending by well-wishers and supporters was excluded from the data collected.
37
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
38
6,039,612,000
38,727,545,000 14,069,190,000
28,300,320,000 11,520,340,000
27,308,622,000
42,038,709,000 13,070,907,000
13,119,530,000
78,248,032,000
27,282,632,000
333,360,427,000 77,469,074,000
Campaign Events/Rally/Meetings
Transport Expenses
Campaign Offices
Others
TOTAL
13,297,590,000
Hand-out Materials
1,224,072,000
3,673,450,000
8,896,288,000
3,049,381,000
6,548,800,000
8,944,430,000
41,293,770,000
6,472,216,000
INDEPENDENTS
17,704,065,000
NRM
Advertising
ITEM
12,047,378,000
245,138,000
1,506,327,000
405,112,000
2,122,549,000
1,856,442,000
1,235,210,000
1,443,030,000
216,040,000
455,848,000
532,568,000
2,029,114,000
FDC
8,218,476,700
236,710,000
384,596,700
1,125,774,000
946,869,000
1,483,800,000
1,541,288,000
357,811,000
673,984,000
357,203,000
1,110,441,000
GO FORWARD
4,255,055,000
261,099,000
495,780,000
147,898,000
554,086,000
524,316,000
513,120,000
924,100,000
15,399,000
261,190,000
130,770,000
427,297,000
OTHERS
435,350,410,700
29,249,651,000
80,250,139,000
17,730,586,700
58,912,025,000
39,532,537,000
43,052,790,000
56,705,153,000
9,678,243,000
21,237,412,000
51,258,741,000
27,743,133,000
TOTAL
EXPENSES
100.0
6.7
18.4
4.1
13.5
9.1
9.9
13.0
2.2
4.9
11.8
6.4
DESCRIPTION
Expense in UGX
Conferences/
Primaries/ Cash for
Flagbearers
78,248,032,000
23.5
Campaign Managers/
Agents/Mobilisation
12.6
Donations &
Fundraisings
41,293,770,000
12.4
Selected Campaign
Materials
38,727,545,000
11.6
Campaign Events/Rally/Meetings
28,300,320,000
8.5
Transport Expenses
27,308,622,000
8.2
Advertising
17,704,065,000
5.3
Handout Materials
13,297,590,000
4.0
Campaign Offices
Equipment/Furniture/Computer/ 13,119,530,000
Internet & Attendants/Drivers
etc
3.9
1.8
Others
27,282,632,000
8.2
TOTAL
333,360,427,000
100.0
39
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Mzee is Swahiri word for a respected older person or eminent elder in a society.
40
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
that was handed over together with the money to every constituency coordinator/
mobiliser. The break down is illustrated in the second table below.
Table 12: NRM Guidelines for Utilization of the 20m for Constituency Mobilisation
No.
ITEM
No.
UNIT COST
150,000
600,000
400
500
200,000
500,000
1,000,000
600
12,000
7,200,000
15
400,000
6,000,000
Media/Publicity (Local)
1,000,000
1,000,000
Central Coordination
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
Boda-bodas
500,000
500,000
10
Local Musicians
1,000,000
1,000,000
11
Brass Band
500,000
500,000
TOTAL
20,000,000
Most of the NRM money was spent by the party at 120.7 billion (36.2 per cent)
followed by money spent on Museveni at 112.1 billion (33.6 per cent) and money
spent by the NRM MPs at 100.5 billion (30.2 per cent).
Table 13: NRM Party Expenses - The Breakdown
WHO IS SPENDING?
OVERALL ESTIMATE
NRM Party
120,692,400,000
36.2
M7
112,080,144,000
33.6
MPs
100,587,883,000
30.2
TOTAL
333,360,427,000
100.0
Table 14: NRM Party Minimum Pre-Campaign Expenses (May October 2015)
NRM Party Minimum Expenses May October 2015
Expense Category
Observable
Minimum Cost
15,000,000,000
19,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
6,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
30,000,000,000
TOTAL
100,000,000,000
41
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Concerned
Number
Number
CountryWide
Amount
Total Spent
Villages
Village Facilitation
67,000
250,000
33,500,000,000
Parishes
Parish Supervisors
7,431
100,000
743,100,000
Sub counties
1,403
300,000
420,900,000
Constituencies
290
20,000,000
5,800,000,000
Polling Stations
Polling Agents
28,010
60,000
6,722,400,000
Total
47,186,400,000
Table 16: NRM Spending on Cash Campaign Contribution to Party Flagbearers for MP
Races
NRM EXPENSES ON FLAGBEARERS
AREA
CONCERNED
Number
Number
Country-
Amount
TOTAL SPENT
Wide
Constituencies
290
25,000,000
7,250,000,000
Districts
Woman MPs
112
30,000,000
3,360,000,000
Districts
LC 5 Chairpersons
112
30,000,000
3,360,000,000
TOTAL
13,970,000,000
42
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Minister of State for ICT, Hon. Nyombi Thembo (in army fatigue and eye glasses) was a key member of
candidate Musevenis Campaign Taskforce
ACFIM Research Assistants christened him: The Money Man. He is retired Lt. Gen. Henry Tumukunde,
one of the main campaign agents for incumbent presidential candidate Yoweri Museveni. He was handing
over a cash donation of UGX 20million to the Association of vendors in Entebbe Market in December 2015.
He was observed leading the advance party of candidate Yoweri Museveni. Observers in Arua reported
that he handed out UGX 50,000 to 400 voters who claimed to have converted from FDC they met him at
White Castle Hotel in Arua. In Apac he was observed meeting a group of Bodaboda cyclists in Judin Hotel
and donated notes of UGX 50,000 to each of them. The General always met supporters in a secluded place
and utilisation of phones and cameras was prohibited making it hard for Research Assistants to take a
photo of him in action. Lt. Gen. Tumukunde headed President Musevenis advance party and was always
observed arriving into a district five days ahead of candidate Museveni to soften the ground like he was
pictured doing here.
43
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Branded Aircraft was used as a mobilisation tool ahead of candidate Musevenis arrival for campaign rallies
in various constituencies. It started hovering in the Ugandan skies from in November 2015. The Aircraft
Number 5Y-HKK, Make: Bell 206l-4 Long-Ranger, was registered in Kenya by a private owner. ACFIM learnt
that the market rate for renting the aircraft is US 2,000 per hour. It was reportedly a campaign donation
offered by one of the East African presidents.
44
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
In addition to the branded Helicopter, the yellow buses were another symbol of campaigns for NRM
Presidential candidate at constituency level. These buses were a constituent of the candidate Musevenis
advance party in every constituency he visited. They were eleven in number, some would carry supporters
other would go empty. The buses are registered with private number plates (UAX series). Fuel of these
buses is included in the estimates of campaign expenses provided in this report. ACFIM continues to track
where the money that purchased these buses came from.
45
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Voter hospitality is a situation where a political candidate(s) hosts voters to a banquet or party or meal or retreat where
they are treated to a good meal, bull roasting, lots of drinks, music/disco or live entertainment and sometimes lodging in
a comfortable hotel, motel or lodge.
10
Voter tourism is a practice where political candidates provide voters with buses, trucks, minibuses or cars and driven
from their homes to campaign rallies or around the constituency as an inducement to voters in return for their support
come polling day.
9
46
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
ESTIMATES
Selected Campaign
Materials
14,069,190,000
18.2
Campaign Managers/
Agents/Mobilisers
13,070,907,000
16.9
Campaign Events/Rally/
Meetings
11,520,340,000
14.9
Donations, Fundraisings
8,944,430,000
11.5
Transport Expenses
8,896,288,000
11.5
Handout Materials
6,548,800,000
8.5
Advertising
6,472,216,000
8.4
Campaign Offices
Equipment/Furniture/Computer/Internet &
Attendants/Drivers etc
3,673,450,000
4.7
3,049,381,000
3.9
Conferences/Cash for
Flagbearers
Others
TOTAL
1,224,072,000
1.6
77,469,074,000
100.0
47
0.0
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Nomination of Member of aspiring Parliament candidates at the beginning of December 2015 was
characterised by splendour and opulence with independent candidates standing out as big spenders.
Buses, Minibuses, Commuter Vans and Trucks were hired to transport supporters that accompanied the
candidates in to nomination and thereafter attended the inaugural campaign rallies. Above are some of
the vehicles that escorted aspiring independent MP candidate Salongo Alfred Muwanga on nomination
day in Luwero District. ACFIM Research Assistants in all the 16 districts observed similar happening.
48
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
ESTIMATES
Campaign Managers/Agents/Mobilisers
2,122,549,000
17.6
Advertising
2,029,114,000 16.8
1,856,442,000 15.4
Conferences/Cash
for Flagbearers
1,506,327,000 12.5
1,443,030,000 12.0
Campaign Events/
Rally/Meetings
1,235,210,000 10.3
Donations
532,568,000 4.4
Handout Materials
455,848,000 3.8
Campaign Offices
Equipment/Furniture/Computer/Internet &
Attendants/Drivers etc
405,112,000 3.4
216,040,000 1.8
Others
245,138,000 2.0
TOTAL
12,047,378,000 100.0
49
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Table 19: FDC Party Minimum Expenses June 2015 February 2016
Expense Category
Total
Estimates (UGX)
200,000,000
2nd Party Delegates Conference for Pres. Frag Bearer elections 210,000,000
at Namboole
Contribution to TDA
70,000,000
142,500,000
Posters
120,000,000
379,240,000
164,245,000
66,500,000
20,000,000
10
15,000,000
11
801,000,000
12
300,000,000
13
Others
290,480,000
TOTAL
2,778,965,000
Source: ACFIM Database
OVERALL EXPENSES
FDC Party
2,778,965,000
23.1
Besigye
2,182,789,500
18.1
MPs
7,085,623,500
58.8
12,047,378,000
100.0
TOTAL
50
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
51
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Kizza Besigyes Campaign Stage & Rally in Kibiito (Banners were used throughtout the Campaigns by
most candidates)
Kizza Besigyes Opening up party offices on 17th Dec 2015 at Rwimi Town Council
52
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
were mostly rallies by candidate JPAM across the countrys 112 districts (18.1 per
cent. Remuneration of campaign managers, grass root mobilisers and polling agents
was the third most expensive category of campaign spending translating into 13.7
per cent. Advertising and transport expenses are 13.5 per cent and 11.5 per cent
respectively. ACFIM observers reported that spending by Go Forwards JPAM was
the most sophisticated of the eight Presidential candidates to monitor because he
mostly used mobile money to pay campaign agents, mobilisers, and make donations.
Table 21: Go Forward Expenses - The Breakdown
CAMPAIGN SPEMDING BY GO FORWARD
ITEM
DESCRIPTION
ESTIMATES
1,541,288,000
18.8
Campaign
Events/Rally/
Meetings
1,483,800,000
18.1
Campaign Managers/Agents/
Mobilisers
1,125,774,000
13.7
Advertising
1,110,441,000
13.5
Transport Expenses
Fuel & Hire of Buses, Lorries, Boda-Bodas, Helicopter, Van/Taxis, Cars etc
946,869,000
11.5
Handout Materials
673,984,000
8.2
384,596,700
4.7
357,811,000
4.4
357,203,000
Others
236,710,000
2.9
TOTAL
8,218,476,700
100.0
53
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
4.3
Go Forward Supporter with candidate Amama Mbabazi T-Shirt and Stickers. Bodaboda cyclists (like one
in the picture) received cash facilitation sometimes wired by mobile money to brand their motorcycles as
such especially on the day candidate Mbabazi was expected to hold campaign rally.
54
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Caption: Go Forward political group spent significantly on erecting metallic podiums at campaign rallies.
OVERALL ESTIMATES
UPC Party
132,000,000
14.8
MPs
762,453,000
85.2
TOTAL
894,453,000
100.0
55
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
OVERALL EXPENSES
153,080,000
9.2
MPs
1,508,309,000
90.8
TOTAL
1,661,389,000
100.0
56
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
57
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
Selected Campaign
Materials
924,100,000
21.7
Campaign Managers/Agents/Mobilisers
554,086,000
13.0
58
EXPENSES
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
Transport Expenses
524,316,000
12.3
Campaign Events/
Rally/Meetings
513,120,000
12.1
Conferences
495,780,000
11.7
Outdoor Advertising
427,297,000
10.0
Handout Materials
261,190,000
6.1
Campaign Offices
147,898,000
3.5
130,770,000
3.1
15,399,000
0.4
Others
261,099,000
6.1
TOTAL
4,255,055,000
100.0
59
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
60
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
61
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
62
12,543
14,532
11,571
3,710
5,950,153
Biraaro
Bwanika
Mabirizi
Kyalya
TOTAL
299
19.35
23,717,766
1,983
14,915
19,779
18,779
64,330
847,103
498,237
22,252,640
Estimates
(000s)
Dec-2015
-28
31.60
38,726,874
2,592
23,632
44,871
55,799
34,200
551,230
3,427,440
34,587,110
Estimates
(000s)
Feb-2016
100.00
122,544,515
10,361
62,881
118,945
125,997
224,367
2,182,790
7,739,031
112,080,144
Combined
Spending in 16
Districts
(000s)
128
44.19
54,149,722
2,076
12,763
39,763
38,876
94,435
654,900
2,964,231
50,342,678
Estimates
(000s)
Jan-2016
31,402
Balyamureba
Monthly Increase
129,557
Besigye
4.86
849,123
Amama
Overall Month %
4,897,716
Nov-2015
Estimates
(000s)
Museveni
CANDIDATE
PRESIDENTIAL
Table 25: Minimum Expenses by Presidential Candidates (Nov. 2015 Feb. 2016)
100.00
0.01
0.05
0.10
0.10
0.18
1.78
6.32
91.46
Overall
%
857,811,605
72,524
440,167
832,615
881,979
1,570,569
15,279,527
54,173,217
784,561,008
Projection for
All Districts
(000s)
252,297,530.88
21,330.44
129,460.88
244,886.76
259,405.59
461,932.06
4,493,978.38
15,933,299.12
230,753,237.65
Projection in
US Dollars
63
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
spending month was December 2015. The degrees of spending depended on the
volume of campaign activities that the candidate had in a particular month.
In contrast, the months were candidates spent the least were in the following:
Yoweri Kaguta Museveni (November 2015), Amama Mbabazi (December 2015), Kizza
Besigye (November 2015), Venasius Baryamureeba (November 2015), Benon Biraaro
(November 2015), Abed Bwanika (November 2015), Joseph Mabirizi (November
2015) and Maureen Kyalya (December 2015). Figure 7 below shows the presidential
candidates expenses (month by month).
Figure 25: Minimum Candidates Estimates per Month (Nov 2015 Feb 2016)
64
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
cent. In third position was transport expenses (fuel & hire of buses, lorries, bodabodas, helicopter, van/taxis, cars etc.) at 13.1 per cent. Facilitation of Campaign
Managers/Agents (Polling Station Agents, Village/Parish/Sub-county Supervisors &
Coordinators etc) accounted for 11.5 per cent followed by Campaign Events/Rally/
Meetings (Venue, Tents, Chairs, Public Address, Drinks, Entertainment, Security etc.)
at 8.8 per cent.
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
28,113,168,000
Donations &
Fundraisings
23,501,536,000
Transport Expenses
16,072,202,000
Campaign Managers/Agents
14,146,710,300
Campaign
Events/Rally/
Meetings
10,724,928,000
Advertising
Handout Materials
Electronic &
Print Media
65
%
22.9
19.2
13.1
11.5
8.8
9,728,901,000
7.9
8,120,902,000
6.6
5,674,970,000
4.6
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
Campaign Offices
3,469,644,200
2.8
Others
2,991,553,500
2.4
122,544,515,000
100.0
TOTAL
66
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
67
8,290,380
23,144,333
7,446,918
5,122,196
25,982,132
9,076,240
14,721,625
12,630,400
2,976,190
2,689,730
112,080,144
Handout Materials
Campaign Events/Rally/Meetings
Transport Expenses
Campaign Managers/Agents
Campaign Offices
Others
TOTAL
Museveni
Advertising
ITEM
7,739,031
236,710
384,597
1,146,328
946,869
1,283,800
1,341,288
357,811
673,984
357,203
1,010,441
Amama
224,367
6,048
9,495
38,160
21,825
28,800
62,500
16,100
41,439
Barya
125,997
2,580
5,460
18,340
16,926
9,681
29,510
17,320
26,180
Biraaro
2,182,790
52,624
85,820
272,257
340,220
297,822
662,050
139,727
332,270
Besigye
118,945
2,437
5,170
25,852
15,447
11,730
23,217
13,481
21,611
Bwanika
62,881
1,210
2,419
13,827
7,944
14,964
9,272
7,685
5,560
Mabirizi
2,991,554
3,469,644
14,146,710
16,072,202
10,724,928
28,113,168
5,674,970
8,120,902
23,501,536
9,728,901
TOTAL
10,361 122,544,515
215
494
1,546
1,346
1,891
3,199
650
1,020
Kyalya
100.0
2.4
2.8
11.5
13.1
8.8
22.9
4.6
6.6
19.2
7.9
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
Selected
Campaign
Materials
25,982,132,000
23.2
Donations
23,144,333,000
20.6
Transport
Expenses
14,721,625,000
13.1
Campaign
Polling Station & Campaign
Managers/Agents Agents, Village/Parish/Subcounty
Supervisors & Coordinators etc
12,630,400,000
11.3
Campaign
Events/Rally/
Meetings
9,076,240,000
8.1
Advertising
8,290,380,000
7.4
Handout
Materials
7,446,918,000
6.6
Electronic &
Print Media
5,122,196,000
4.6
2,976,190,000
2.7
Others
2,689,730,000
2.4
TOTAL
112,080,144,000 100.0
68
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Candidates spent significantly on branded T-shirts Branded such as these observed donned by supporters
of candidate Yoweri Museveni in this photograph.
69
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
70
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
ESTIMATES
Selected
Campaign
Materials
1,341,288,000
17.3
Campaign
Events/Rally/
Meetings
1,283,800,000
16.6
Campaign
Managers/
Agents
1,146,328,300
14.8
Advertising
1,010,441,000
13.1
Transport
Expenses
946,869,000
12.2
673,984,000
8.7
Campaign
Offices
Equipment/Furniture/Computer/Internet &
Attendants/Drivers etc
384,596,700
5.0
Electronic &
Print Media
357,811,000
4.6
Donations
357,203,000
4.6
71
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
Others
TOTAL
ESTIMATES
236,710,000
3.1
7,739,031,000
100.0
72
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
ESTIMATES
Selected Campaign
Materials
662,050,000
30.3
Transport Expenses
340,220,000
15.6
Advertising
332,270,000
15.2
Campaign Events/
Rally/Meetings
297,822,000
13.6
Campaign Managers/Agents
272,257,000
12.5
139,727,000
6.4
Campaign Offices
85,819,500
3.9
0.0
Handout Materials
0.0
Others
52,624,000
2.4
TOTAL
2,182,789,500
100.0
73
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
FDC spent on erecting metallic Campaign podiums and powerful Public Address Systems.
The campaign trail of candidate Kizza Besigye was characterized with images like this one where citizens
donated money towards his campaign expenses. ACFIM observers in Bushenyi District reported that
on Sunday the 20th of December 2015, candidate Kizza Besigye (pictured above) attended mass at
St Kagwa Parish church and later a service at All Saints Church. Christians in both churches made total
cash contributions of UGX 1.2million towards his campaign financing. The principles of transparency and
accountability demand that FDC party leadership come out to publicly declare the total of the campaign
income raised through grass root contributions such as the one seen in the photograph above and how
the money was utilised..
74
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
75
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
76
1,281,064,900
1,113,817,200
KABALE
APAC
Overall Month %
14.9
49,625,169,000
1,524,316,200
MOROTO
TOTAL
1,675,587,000
LIRA
708,302,000
2,130,552,200
ARUA
NWOYA
2,283,512,000
KATAKWI
826,031,600
2,975,282,000
BUSHENYI
HOIMA
3,296,972,800
JINJA
780,340,000
3,320,783,000
IGANGA
KANUNGU
4,417,323,100
MASAKA
807,675,000
8,874,592,000
LUWEERO
KABAROLE
13,609,018,000
Nov-2015
KAMPALA
District
26.4
88,063,034,700
1,128,108,000
1,259,060,000
1,997,027,500
1,890,503,400
2,125,504,200
2,575,309,000
2,841,009,000
2,322,366,200
3,721,684,000
4,263,801,000
5,593,768,000
6,241,036,000
6,153,370,900
8,491,767,000
14,599,592,500
22,859,128,000
Dec-2015
35.5
118,348,132,000
1,232,459,000
2,134,590,000
2,550,278,000
2,437,855,000
2,997,860,000
3,217,990,000
3,247,550,000
4,326,790,000
4,532,400,000
3,715,950,000
4,267,800,000
8,111,750,000
8,643,510,000
11,823,600,000
19,425,550,000
35,682,200,000
Jan-2016
Table 31: Minimum District Expenses per Month (Nov 2015 Feb 2016)
23.0
76,756,095,000
754,860,000
975,571,000
1,700,420,000
2,500,210,000
2,341,360,000
2,400,240,000
3,201,159,000
3,200,580,000
3,009,755,000
3,845,780,000
4,246,660,000
6,328,800,000
6,995,500,000
6,688,960,000
9,854,300,000
18,711,940,000
Feb-2016
100.0
333,225,430,700
3,823,729,000
5,195,252,600
7,028,065,500
7,636,243,400
8,578,541,400
9,474,603,900
10,814,034,200
11,525,323,200
13,394,391,200
14,109,043,000
17,083,510,000
23,978,558,800
25,113,163,900
31,421,650,100
53,187,034,500
90,862,286,000
OVERALL TOTAL
1.1
1.6
2.1
2.3
2.6
2.8
3.2
3.5
4.0
4.2
5.1
7.2
7.5
9.4
16.0
27.3
100.0
Overall %
Figure 30: Minimum District Expenses per Month (Nov 2015 Feb 2016)
Mobile Clinic donated by incumbent MP Makindye East, Kampala District, Hon. John Ssimbwa (NRM flag
bearer). He also provided commuter vans to transport voters from Makindye East to the central business
district. Despite this spending, Hon. Ssimbwa lost the election to FDC candidate Ibrahim Kasozi.
77
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Figure 31: Percentage Minimum District Expenses per Month (Nov 2015 Feb 2016)
78
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
7. GENERAL OBSERVATIONS AT
CONSTITUENCY LEVEL
7.1 Type of Event Observed
Table 32: Type of Event Observed (Nov 2015 Feb 2016)
TYPE OF EVENT
PERCENT
Campaign Rally
66.4
Campaign meeting
17.7
Consultative meeting
6.0
Other
9.9
TOTAL
100.0
The table and bar graph above show that several events were observed during the
campaign period (November 3rd 2015 February 16th 2016). These events included
campaign rallies (66 per cent), campaign meetings (18 per cent), consultative
meetings (6 per cent) and other events. Major spending items on a campaign rally
included public address systems, campaign platforms, facilitation of musicians, hire
of tents and plastic chairs, food and sodas/water. The most expensive campaign
rallies observed were those organised for presidential candidate Yoweri Museveni
which had a standard budget of UGX 20,000,000 (US$ 5,882). These were managed
by the constituency mobiliser and had a clear breakdown as was presented earlier
in this report. At Member of Parliament level the candidates were observed to have
spent on average UGX 2,337,267 on each campaign rally.
79
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
The drinks served to attendees on Candidate Museveni Rallies This particular consignment was in
observed in Usuk, Katakwi district.
PER CENT
0-1hr
45.4
1-2hrs
32.4
2-3hrs
12.3
Over 3hrs
TOTAL
9.9
100.0
The table shows that the majority of campaign rallies/events (45.4 per cent) were
held for one hour or less in the constituencies. Events held for 1-2 hours were the
80
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
second most common (32.4 per cent) while those that went beyond 3 hours were
the least observed. The following pie chart illustrates this further.
Figure 33: Duration of Events Observed (Nov 2015 Feb 2016)
PERCENT
42.6
33.8
17.3
6.3
100.0
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
PERCENT
19.96
19.33
18.87
16.67
10.43
7.86
5.52
1.07
0.29
100.00
82
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
PERCENT
T-Shirts
41.7
Posters
22.8
Fliers
7.8
Shirts
7.3
Banners
5.1
Capes
5.0
Billboards
3.3
Badges
3.3
Bandanas
0.5
Wrist Bands
0.2
Branded Kitenges
0.1
Others
2.8
TOTAL
100.0
83
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
PERCENT
Talk Shows
48.7
Radio Adverts/Jingles
29.0
9.7
DJ Mentions
5.9
SMS Blasts
2.9
Print media
2.3
Robbo calls
1.6
TOTAL
0.0
84
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Figure 37: Expenses on Electronic and Print Media (Nov 2015 Feb 2016)
PERCENT
Donation by candidate
39.27
31.81
9.81
Public Address
6.16
Food
4.01
Musicians/Entertainment
3.55
Soda
1.36
Security
1.01
Water
0.92
Tents
0.74
Venue
0.69
Chairs
0.29
85
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
RESOURCE/EXPENSE
PERCENT
Alcohol
0.24
Ambulance
0.15
TOTAL
100.00
Nomination day for Member of Parliament candidates in Luweero district: Above left is a state of the art
platform build by independent candidate Patricia Magara of Katikamu South constituency.
86
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
8. ANALYSIS OF DONATIONS
TO VOTERS
8.1 Donations by Candidates
The practice of candidates offering donations to voters was prevalent in all the
constituencies in the 16 districts of our geographical scope. Whereas at presidential
level it was just a few candidates that offered donations, all candidates in the
Member of Parliament races across all parties that contested in the campaigns were
observed donating to various groups of voters personally and on some occasions,
through campaign agents. The difference was in the degrees. These donations were
either in cash or in kind. In kind items included ambulances branded with candidates
photographs, solar powered lights, bicycles, iron sheets, cement, hoes, seeds,
football jerseys, source pans, plastic chairs, tents, mattresses, branded cloths,
T-shirts, and helmets for cyclists among others.
This generosity was a ploy to avoid being construed as engaging in voter bribery
which is an offense under the Presidential Elections Act (as emended) 2005 and the
Parliamentary Elections Act (as amended) 2005. Candidates hid under the cover of
livelihood improvement initiatives to donate cash and items with a clear purpose
of inducing voters to vote for them. This practice started as early as May 2015 and
continued throughout the months of October, November, December 2015 and
January 2016. In Arua district observers reported that donations to churches and
mosques were prevalent in all the eight constituencies (including district woman
MP). In Moroto district the incumbent woman MP donated branded kitenge cloth
materials to women. Incumbent MPs for Kwania constituency in Apac and Bugwere
in Iganga districts donated hoes and hybrid maize seeds and candidate Jack Sabiiti
(FDC) donated cash Ugx 1million to Kashambya Parents Primary School. In Rubanda
East Hon. Musasizi donated 30 bags of cement to Karagama Church of Uganda and
St.Thomas Aquinas Primary Schools.
The next table illustrates how churches were the major recipients of the donations
(41.9 per cent), followed by schools at 26.4 per cent. Other beneficiaries included
in women groups (17.7 per cent), mosques (3.7 per cent) and youth groups (3.1 per
cent).
87
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
ITEM
Churches
Schools
Women Groups
Mosques
Youth Groups
Others
TOTAL
PERCENT
41.9
26.4
17.7
3.7
3.1
7.3
100.0
Figure 39: Donations & Fundraising
88
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Bicycles donated by the incumbent candidate for Iganga District Woman MP Hon. Olivia Kabale. She lost
the seat to Hallat Kawuda who had donated fumigation services against bedbugs to every household in
the entire Municipality of Iganga and surrounding sub counties.
Cash Donation for livelihood improvement or Voter Bribery? The Race for Jinja East
Constituency Member of Parliament.
89
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
90
Bugongi
KANUNGU
Nabitambala
KABAROLE
Mafumbira/Wairaka
JINJA
Rutengye, Kazooha
Buwabe
Bulowoza
IGANGA
Central Ward
9/24/2015
Kyamukenda
KABALE
9/22/2015
Kidoma, Nyabunyira
HOIMA
10/21/2015
10/2/2015
10/24/2015
10/25/2015
9/16/2015
9/20/2015
10/10/2015
10/26/2015
10/22/2015
Kibaare
12/14/2015
Ryeishe, Kitabi
12/15/2015
BUSHENYI
12/11/2015
9/23/2015
Ayumi London
ARUA
9/7/2015
Awiri, Awiri
APAC
Date
Parish/Village
District
Namunye Mosque
Kashambya Parents P. S
Farmers
Pregnant Women
Community
Tugende Omumaiso
Appreciation of Supporters
Fundraising
Church
Organization
NRM
NRM
FDC
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
Independent
Independent
Go Forward
NRM
UPC
Party
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Maize Seeds
Mama Kits
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cement
Cement
Donation
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
100,000
14,000,000
100 Kits
1,000,000
300,000
300,000
400,000
1,500,000
100,000
300,000
1,000,000
40 Bags
2,250,000
Total Estimate
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
91
Wobulenzi
Kasana Kisaawe
Kyabakuza A
Kamuzinda, Bukunda
Kimanya, Kigamba
LUWEERO
MASAKA
9/20/2015
Ongongoja, Akwamor
NWOYA
11/9/2015
Northern Ward,Katanga
KATAKWI
9/26/2015
10/23/2015
11/1/2015
11/23/2015
10/10/2015
9/20/2015
10/20/2015
Katete
Date
Parish/Village
District
Community, Hospital
St Lucia
Teachers Day
Healthy Centre 5
Akwamor Village
Kirima Community S S
Organization
NRM
NRM
DP
DP
NRM
Independent
NRM
NRM
NRM
Party
Ambulance,
Basins & Boreholes
Desks
Beddings
Cash
Cash
Iron Sheets
Iron Sheets
Cash
Bursaries
Donation
102,200,000
2,000,000
880,000
1,000,000
2,500,000
2,000,000
3,640,000
10,000,000
1,000,000
Total Estimate
92
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
January
2,340,000,000
February
60,000,000
March
210,000,000
April
1,132,000,000
May
5,140,000,000
June
205,000,000
July
1,838,000,000
August
2,590,000,000
September
505,000,000
October
661,000,000
TOTAL
14,681,000,000
CASH/PLEDGE
PURPOSE
Sept 1
20 million
Sept 2
200 million
Sept 7
50 million
Sept 15
15 million
Sept 16
220 million
Total
Oct 2
20 million
Oct 7
230 million
Oct 7
1 million
Oct 11
10 million
Oct 16
400 million
Total
93
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Figure 40: Cash Donations by Pres. Museveni (January 2015 to October 2015)
HANDOUT MATERIALS
Material Items (in a pack)
Hoes
Sugar
Food
Sauce pans
Seeds
Salt
TOTAL
Percent
50.9
23.1
15.9
5.3
3.8
1.1
100.0
94
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Plastic chairs and NASECO maize seeds donated by incumbent Member of Parliament for Bukoto Central
in Masaka District and incumbent Vice President Edward Kiwanuka Sekandi. He was re-elected to the 10th
Parliament.
Mama Kit donated by incumbent Member of Parliament for Jinja Municipality East Constituency Hon. Paul
Mwiru (FDC Party flagbearer).
95
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Boxes of washing soap, sauce pans and other items awaiting distribution for supporters of the incumbent
Katikamu North MP (NRM flag bearer) Hon. Abraham Byandaala in Luweero district. He was re-elected to
the 10th Parliament.
96
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
97
Atik Owang
Nicu
Bushenyi Town
Katungu
Nyagabo
Lunju
Nyamundeija
Nsale/Nawansega
Butamila/Buyengo
Nyakabungo
Kabale Municipality
Rugyeyo
ARUA
BUSHENYI
HOIMA
IGANGA
JINJA
KABALE
KANUNGU
Parish/Village
APAC
District
Event
Date
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
FDC
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
Go Forward
NRM
UPC
UPC
Party
Cash
Bars of Soap
Salt Sachets
Iron Sheets
Borehole maintenance
Jericans of Kwete
Dozens of Plates
Boxes of Soap
Movit Products
Food
Cash
Cash
Cash
Handout/Donation
200,000
603,000
167,500
1,500,000
200,000
12,500,000
30000
250000
380000
6,290,000
3,004,000
100,000
1,150,000
1,200,000
Total Estimate
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
98
Acherer, Arengekeju
Alero/Panyabono
MWOYA
LIRA
Bwaliba/Lusanja
Lusanja/Bwaliba
LUWEERO
MOROTO
Agodingod,Okeriso
Kyabakuza, Kyabakuza B
Alogook,Wera
KATAKWI
Kirumba, Kirumba
Nakivubo
Kawempe 2
KAMPALA
MASAKA
Kambuga
Parish/Village
District
Event
Date
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
DP
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
FDC
NRM
NRM
Party
Cash
Transport Refund
Jerricans of Kwete
Bull
Tarpaulins
Plates
Loaves of Bread
Sugar
Cash
Handout/Donation
100,000
450,000
65,000
1,000,000
1,100,000
210,000
320,000
105000
30,000
132,000
51,000
64,000
900,000
Total Estimate
99
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
exceeding three years or both. Section 68 (2) incriminates the receiver as well. The
law however makes exception of refreshments or food provided by a candidate or
candidates agent. Section 64 (1 & 2) of the Presidential Elections Act also highlights
voter bribery as an illegal practice.
Reports by ACFIM Research Assistants/Observers show that voter bribery was
prevalent in all 16 districts. It was observed during party primaries of the NRM
party and throughout the campaign period November 3rd 2015 February 16th, 2016.
Candidates across political parties, political groups and independents were reported
to be complicity of providing money, gifts and other forms of inducements that
may be interpreted as what the law refers to as other consideration.
Whereas the chairperson of the Electoral Commission for the National Resistance
Movement (NRM) Dr. Tanga Odoi had strongly warned against voter bribery, the
practice was prevalent during the party primary elections. Observers reported an
escalation in voter bribery during the month of October targeting mostly women and
youth in all the 16 districts in which the study was conducted. Bribery was manifested
in form of cash and/or groceries, and even on some occasions in buying booze. The
practice of putting money in kaki envelopes and getting them delivered to groups
of youth and women during campaign rallies was prevalent. ACFIM observers saw
these envelopes being opened containing money in denominations of 1,000 and
2,000 totalling between UGX 100,000 (US$ 30) 500,000 (US$ 147) across districts.
The money would eventually be split so that every person present at the event got
Ugx 1,000 or 2,000. All candidates used a strategy of participating in village visits
where they would again leave money ostensibly for a drink or a bite. In Moroto
district one of the candidates for Tepeth and Metheniko constituencies bought bulls
that were slaughtered and then shared by voters. The Moroto Municipality NRM frag
bearer-elect bankrolled by the business community distributed groceries like sugar,
cooking oil and maize flour to voters. On the eve of the elections all candidates sent
their agents knocking on doors of voters between 6.00pm 11.00pm at night giving
out cash Ugx 5,000 or 10,000 per person of voting age in the household. In Iganga
district observers in Bugweri and Kigulu south constituencies reported agents of
candidates on polling day who stood near polling stations and were openly paying
out Ugx 5,000 to every voter that would promise to cast the ballot in favour of their
candidates.
100
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
One of the candidates for the race of Lira District NRM Chairperson Moses Ocip dishing out a 10,000/= note
to each of the voters that gathered at Lira Hotel to participate in the just concluded elections for NRM
grass root structures. The other voters that are looking on had already received their share of the money.
It is estimated that Mr. Ocip spent over 1,000,000 on that occasion alone. Three candidates competed for
this post. Ocip lost out to the incumbent and eventual winner Sam Engola who hosted voters in his Lira
Hotel on voting day where they enjoyed free food and drinks on the house. The former treasurer Agasaki
Abdu also dished out money in this style but also lost. However Sam Engola later lost the February 18th,
2016 MP election.
8.6 Acts of Voter bribery During the Final Five Days to Election Day
In the final five days that preceded Election Day we conducted a mini-survey where
we asked Research Assistants to observe and interview ten respondents per
constituency to tell whether they have received, heard or been informed of any of
the following acts taking place in their constituency.
a) Cash giveaways to voters including doing so at or near polling stations
b) Hand out materials / groceries
c) Voter incentives in form of intangible services like voter tourism, being
hosted to a banquet, a free disco dance, and free tickets to theatre or video
hall among others.
d) Misuse of government vehicles and
e) Turnout buying11.
Turnout buying is where voters stay in their homes or hand around major trading centres hesitating to vote until a candidate that wants their vote given them money to turnout any vote.
11
101
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
The next table shows that all these acts were prevalent during the final five days.
The majority of respondents (75 per cent) either received, saw or heard candidates
giving out cash to voters during this last stretch of the campaign. Handout materials
were received or witnessed by 68 per cent of the respondents. On elections day
(February 18th, 2016) 62 per cent of the respondents witnessed or heard about cash
being given away at or near polling stations and 65 per cent reported acts of turnout
buying. Misuse of government vehicles was minimal with less than half (42 per cent)
of the respondents attesting to it.
8.7 Donations and Voter Hospitality are akin to Voter Bribery
Whereas there is no provision in the electoral laws that stops political candidates
from offering donations to voters during election campaigns, it is the opinion of
ACFIM that donations whether made in cash or in kind, are clearly intended to induce
voters to vote for that particular candidate(s) rather than to extend generosity.
Voter hospitality is said to be where political candidates host voters to a banquet or
a party or retreat where they are entertained with food, bull roasting, lots of drinks
including booze, music or live entertainment among others things. Going by intent
and purpose, donations and voter hospitality are forms of voter bribery, which is an
offense under the Ugandan electoral laws. There is, however, no clear demarcation
line between what the electoral laws refer to as gifts, handout material or services
like voter tourism and/or voter hospitality, all of which were prevalent during the
campaign period (November 2015 February 16th, 2016). As ACFIM we strongly
believe donations of whatever kind should be understood as a form of voter bribery
and be condemned without qualification.
Hospitality: Food being prepared at a campaign event in Bukalasa for attendees who came for one of
the campaign rallies of independent candidate Patricia Magara one of the contestants in the race for
Katikamu South Member of Parliament Luweero District. She lost the election.
102
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
9. VOTER TOURISM
ACFIM defines voter tourism as the practice by candidates where voters are
provided with buses, trucks, minibuses or cars to drive them around the Sub-county
or constituency as they escort the candidates campaign entourage or mobilisation
team. Voter tourism was prevalent during election campaigns 2015/2016 as
candidates invested in hiring buses, mini-buses or trucks to transport voters from
their village to campaign rallies/events. ACFIM observers reported that during the
campaign period many voters were more than to enjoy a ride in any automobile
provided by the candidate.
Voter Tourism in Jinja District (above) and in Arua Municipality observed during the months of December
2015
103
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Voters observed being driven around in Hoima town in December 2015 (above) and in Bushenyi (below)
104
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Section 27 of the Presidential Elections Act (as amended) 2005 makes it illegal for any
candidate to use government resources for the purpose of campaigning for election.
Section 27 (1)The law however makes exception of the incumbent president who is
permitted to continue using state resources that are attached to and utilised by the
holder of that office.
ACFIM Research Assistants observed incidents of misuse of government vehicles in
different districts. On November 9th, 2015 a number of government vehicles were
used on candidate Musevenis rally held at Kasana Play Ground, Luweero. Some of
the vehicle registration plates observed in action at the rally include: UG2183C, UG
0178H, UG1427W, UG 0187D, UG 2688D, UG 2183C, UG 2043C, UG 2405C. UG 1832S,
UG1768C.
105
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Bus used by independent candidate Katikamu South, Luweero District, Patricia Magara to transport
attendees to her first rally at Bukalasa after being successfully nominated in Luweero on December
3rd, 2015. ACFIM Research Assistants observed the bus transporting campaign event attendees from
Wobulenzi, Bombo, Nyimbwa and other villages to Bukalasa all day. Patricia is a daughter to the late bush
war veteran Sam Magara. Here the bus was pictured at the venue of her nomination rally at Bukalasa.
106
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
107
Kamuzinda,Bulegeya
Bulubandi Central B
Omodoi, Atirir
Omot
IGANGA
KATAKWI
LIRA
Bukalasa
Zirobwe
Kyantale, Kyanamukaka
Luweero TC/Kasana
LUWEERO
12/3/2015
Omodoi,Atirir
KATAKWI
Kyantale, Kyanamukaka
12/3/2015
Nyaruhanga, Ntaranga
MASAKA
11/9/2015
Kashasha, Ndeego
KABALE
NRM
NRM
NRM
PARTY
11/3/2015
10/19/2015
12/3/2015
UP 4690
UG 2600E
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
9/14/2015
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Consultative Meeting
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
EVENT
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Meeting
Consultative Meeting
Consultative Meeting
NRM
NRM
UG0187D
BUS UG0187D
UG 2600E
UG 2253C
VEHICLE/GOVERNMENT OFFICE
USED FOR PARTY
9/14/2015
10/19/2015
10/14/2015
10/17/2015
PARISH/VILLAGE
DISTRICT
DATE
1) Ministry of Defence
2) Office of the President
3) State House
4) Ministry of Gender Labour and Social Development
5) Parliament of Uganda
6) Office of the Prime Minister
In each of these institutions the analysis was made on how funds disbursement
and extension arrangements (mainly supplementary budget) for FY 2016/17 were
handled, the nature of the requisition and for what these funds were earmarked.
108
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Budget
Estimates
FY 2014/15
%
Budget
Estimates
of
Budget FY 2015/16
%
of Budget
Recurrent Expenditure
7,948.5
50.2%
8,656.7
36.1%
o/w Wage
o/w NonWage(excluding
Statutory interest )
o/w Statutory Interest
Payments
Development
Expenditure
o/w GoU
o/w External Financing
2,904.3
18.3%
2,894.1
12.1%
3,961.4
25.0%
4,106.4
17.1%
1,082.9
6.8%
1,656.2
6.9%
7,037.0
4,362.7
44.5%
27.6%
9,654.7
4,057.0
40.3%
16.9%
2,674.3
16.9%
5,597.7
23.4%
14,985.6
80.0
139.2
94.7%
0.5%
0.9%
18,311.4
80.0
172.0
76.4%
0.3%
0.7%
56.3
0.4%
0.0%
4,787.5
20.0%
Sub-total
Domestic Arrears
Amortisation
Taxes
Domestic Debt
Repayment
Total Including Taxes,
Amortisation &
Arrears, Debt
Appropriation in Aid
(AIA)
Grand Total Including
Taxes on Imports,
Amortisation & Arrears
15,261.0
96.4%
23,350.9
97.4%
568.8
3.6%
621.4
2.6%
15,829.8
100.0%
23,972.3
100.0%
109
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Ministry of Defence had by the end of the first half year (by December 2015) 94.6 per
cent and 80 per cent respectively of the releases.
Table 3: Analysis of flows from the National Budget for Q1+Q2 of the FY 2015/16
VOTE AND
FUNCTION
Total
Revised
Budget
(Mn)
Total
Cash
Limits
(Q1+Q2)
(Mn)
Total WarTotal
rants
Payments
(Q1+Q2)
(Q+Q2)
(Mns)
(Mn)
%
% Payments
Warrant to Warrants
to Cash
limit
001Office
of The
President
117,132
66,545
64,545
47,042
96.99
72.88
002State
House
257,811
204,644
173,422
164,000
84.74
94.57
003Office
of The
Prime
Minister
127,032
79,148
79,148
29,821
100.00
37.68
1,003,174
572,753
572,753
458,762
100.00
80.10
018Ministry of
Gender, L
& S.D
79,599
25,079
25,079
18,913
100.00
75.42
102Electoral Commission
295,580
193,055
193,055
25,520
100.00
13.22
104Parliamentary
Commission
371,30
196,368
196,351
143,115
99.99
72.89
004Ministry of
Defence
The Office of the President as well as State House are directly under the MDAs that
are directly under the President. As Commander-in-Chief, the budget of the ministry
of defence which is for the most part classified, is also largely under the control
of the President as are other classified budgets for Internal and External Security
Organisations (ISO and ESO).
110
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
The money allocated for Office of the President in the FY 2015/2016 budget was UGX
117 billion of which UGX 40.27 billion went to paying wages and UGX 70.95 billion
was allocated to Non-Wages. The bar graph below this section shows that for FY
2015/16, the budget for the non-wage recurrent for the Office of the President shot
up astronomically from UGX 24.65 billion to UGX 40.57 billion; an increment of 64.6
per cent. Funds categorised as non-wage finance day-to-day activities of the office
of which the main beneficiary is the incumbent president.
In the absence of any new mandate or additional activities as adduced from both
Ministerial policy statements and Sector Budget Frame Work, it can be argued that
this noticeable increment may have been a direct response to the added needs and
pressures to the office of the President at a time of elections. By end of the first half
of the financial year (H1), the expenditure performance for the vote translated into
89.1 per cent.
111
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Table 47: Office of the President Budget Utilisation by First Half of FY 2015/16
Item
Budget
Outputs Provided
Classified
Expenditure
General Staff
Salaries
Pension for General
Civil Service
Gratuity Expenses
Travel inland
Allowances
Travel abroad
Fuel, Lubricants and
Oils
Workshops and
Seminars
Rent (Produced
Assets) to private
entities
Maintenance - Vehicles
Staff Training
Telecommunications
Contract Staff
Salaries (Incl.
Casuals,
Temporary)
Welfare and
Entertainment
Commissions and
related charges
Printing, Stationery,
Photocopying and
Binding
Maintenance
Machinery,
Equipment &
Furniture
Releases
Expenditure
%
% of
of budget
release
released
spent
17.65
61.6%
89.8%
5.3
134.5%
100.0%
31.89
3.94
19.66
5.3
10.3
5.75
4.13
55.8%
71.8%
1.89
1.42
1.45
75.1%
102.1%
2.98
2.27
1.36
0.85
0.74
1.34
1.08
0.66
0.41
0.38
1.22
1.07
0.65
0.39
0.38
45.0%
47.6%
48.5%
48.2%
51.4%
91.0%
99.1%
98.5%
95.1%
100.0%
0.87
0.38
0.36
43.7%
94.7%
0.9
0.35
0.35
38.9%
100.0%
0.98
0.47
0.33
48.0%
70.2%
0.65
0.53
0.41
0.29
0.27
0.21
0.29
0.27
0.2
44.6%
50.9%
51.2%
100.0%
100.0%
95.2%
0.33
0.16
0.16
48.5%
100.0%
0.6
0.15
0.15
25.0%
100.0%
0.33
0.15
0.12
45.5%
80.0%
0.24
0.09
0.09
37.5%
100.0%
112
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Item
Budget
Maintenance - Civil
Maintenance
Other
Cleaning and
Sanitation
Special Meals and
Drinks
Subscriptions
Computer supplies
and ICT
Guard and Security
services
Statutory salaries
Books, Periodicals
& Newspapers
Electricity
Water
Consultancy Services- Short term
Medical expenses
(To employees)
Incapacity, death
benefits and funeral
expenses
Advertising and
Public Relations
Small Office
Equipment
IFMS Recurrent
costs
IPPS Recurrent
Costs
Information and
communications
technology (ICT)
Uniforms, Beddings,Protective
Gear
Releases
Expenditure
0.19
0.17
0.08
0.08
%
% of
of budget
release
released
spent
0.08
42.1%
100.0%
0.08
47.1%
100.0%
0.16
0.07
0.07
43.8%
100.0%
0.15
0.07
0.06
46.7%
85.7%
0.12
0.14
0.06
0.07
0.06
0.05
50.0%
50.0%
100.0%
71.4%
0.1
0.05
0.05
50.0%
100.0%
0.09
0.06
0.04
0.05
0.04
0.04
44.4%
83.3%
100.0%
80.0%
0.09
0.08
0.07
0.04
0.03
0.03
0.03
0.03
0.03
44.4%
37.5%
42.9%
75.0%
100.0%
100.0%
0.04
0.02
0.02
50.0%
100.0%
0.05
0.02
0.02
40.0%
100.0%
0.04
0.02
0.02
50.0%
100.0%
0.05
0.02
0.02
40.0%
100.0%
0.05
0.02
0.02
40.0%
100.0%
0.03
0.01
0.01
33.3%
100.0%
0.03
0.02
0.01
66.7%
50.0%
0.01
0.0%
#DIV/0!
113
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Item
Budget
Class: Outputs
Funded
Transfers to other
govt. Units (Current)
Other Current grants
(Current)
Contributions
to Autonomous
Institutions
Class: Capital
Purchases
Transport
Equipment
Non-Residential
Buildings
Furniture and fittings
(Depreciatn.)
Machinery and
Equipment
Furniture & Fixtures
Taxes on Machinery,
Furniture & Vehicles
Releases
Expenditure
%
% of
of budget
release
released
spent
9.72
56.1%
88.9%
19.47
10.93
14.99
8.76
7.62
58.4%
87.0%
4.46
2.16
2.09
48.4%
96.8%
0.02
0.01
0.01
50.0%
100.0%
2.65
1.35
0.81
50.9%
60.0%
2.65
1.54
1.43
58.1%
92.9%
1.51
0.81
0.81
53.6%
100.0%
0.04
0.01
25.0%
0.0%
0.23
0.09
39.1%
0.0%
0.22
0.65
0.07
0.37
0
0
31.8%
56.9%
0.0%
0.0%
114
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
The following table further shows that the actual amount of money released for
State House for the first two quarters (half year) was UGX 217.93 billion out of which
UGX 213 was spent by December 2015, leaving a balance of just UGX 4.3 billion which
could not meet the office requirements for the month of January 2016. By the middle
of the financial year (December 2015) State House has exhausted the UGX 89 billion
budget for donations alongside the UGX 38 billion for classified expenditure. Travel
inland and abroad too had their budgets nearly exhausted (above 85 per cent).
All these items have a big bearing on the expenditure of the president, especially
donations.
Table 48: Half Year Budget utilization for State House for FY 2015/16
Vote Functions
VF:1611
Approved
Budget
Released
Released
Spent
217.93
213.55
217.93
213.55
254.43
Further analysis shows that the rise in budget allocation for State House was effected
three financial years back, in FY 2013/2015 when it rose from UGX 63.23 billion in FY
2012/2013 to UGX 205.23 in FY 2013/2014. By doing this government avoided surges
and shocks in the economy that would have happened if had been effected during
the campaign year. The bar graph below illustrates the trend in budget allocation
for State House over the past eight financial years.
115
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Figure 44: Budget Allocation Trends for State House over 8 Financial Years
116
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Figure 45: Flow of Funds in the Ministry of Defence for the FY 2015/16
117
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Approved
budget
Release
Expenditure
% of budget % of
released
release
spent
972.96
659.19
651.05
250
250
388.82
207.11
207.07
53.3%
100.0%
Classified Expenditure
372.48
107.04
106.61
28.7%
99.6%
37.61
18.81
18.48
50.0%
98.2%
18.98
16.8
16.01
88.5%
95.3%
Gratuity Expenses
35.31
10.66
10.65
30.2%
99.9%
34.77
10.38
8.38
29.9%
80.7%
Maintenance - Vehicles
14.81
8.19
6.11
55.3%
74.6%
Subscriptions
9.41
4.71
4.7
50.1%
99.8%
Staff Training
8.29
4.14
4.11
49.9%
99.3%
Travel inland
6.35
3.18
3.17
50.1%
99.7%
2.99
2.5
2.49
83.6%
99.6%
Electricity
7.47
3.74
2.06
50.1%
55.1%
Travel abroad
4.18
2.09
2.04
50.0%
97.6%
General Supply of
Goods and Services
118
67.8%
98.8%
100.0%
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Items
Approved
budget
Release
Expenditure
% of budget % of
released
release
spent
3.6
1.8
1.77
50.0%
98.3%
Water
3.68
1.84
1.77
50.0%
96.2%
Medical and
Agricultural supplies
3.19
1.6
1.5
50.2%
93.8%
Telecommunications
2.53
1.26
1.04
49.8%
82.5%
Commissions and
related charges
1.06
0.53
0.53
50.0%
100.0%
Carriage, Haulage,
Freight and transport
hire
1.13
0.57
0.53
50.4%
93.0%
1.01
0.5
0.5
49.5%
100.0%
Compensation to 3rd
Parties
0.4
0.3
0.28
75.0%
93.3%
Allowances
0.56
0.28
0.27
50.0%
96.4%
Maintenance - Civil
0.49
0.25
0.25
51.0%
100.0%
Rent (Produced
Assets) to private
entities
0.49
0.25
0.18
51.0%
72.0%
Incapacity, death
benefits and funeral
expenses
0.31
0.15
0.15
48.4%
100.0%
Printing, Stationery,
Photocopying and
Binding
0.49
0.25
0.15
51.0%
60.0%
0.22
0.11
0.11
50.0%
100.0%
Computer supplies
and ICT
0.12
0.06
0.06
50.0%
100.0%
Advertising and
Public Relations
0.09
0.05
0.04
55.6%
80.0%
Property Expenses
0.03
0.02
0.02
66.7%
100.0%
0.02
0.01
0.01
50.0%
100.0%
IPPS Recurrent
Costs
0.03
0.01
0.01
33.3%
100.0%
Uniforms, Beddings
and Protective Gear
12.04
0.0%
#DIV/0!
25.09
12.64
12.32
50.4%
97.5%
1.12
0.56
0.53
50.0%
94.6%
Information and
communications
technology (ICT)
Land
119
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Items
Approved
budget
Release
Expenditure
% of budget % of
released
release
spent
Residential Buildings
16.41
8.21
8.2
50.0%
99.9%
Transport Equipment
5.16
2.58
2.58
50.0%
100.0%
2.23
1.16
0.89
52.0%
76.7%
0.17
0.13
0.12
76.5%
92.3%
Class: Arrears
5.11
3.16
1.02
61.8%
32.3%
Domestic arrears
(Budgeting)
2.01
1.01
0.83
50.2%
82.2%
Telephone arrears
(Budgeting)
0.03
0.0%
Electricity arrears
(Budgeting)
3.07
2.15
0.19
70.0%
8.8%
120
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
From the figure above, the growth rate trend of currency in circulation shows that
the there is a positive trajectory of cash in circulation. Following the tight monetary
policy stance12 that was adopted by BoU since June 2015, one would expect that the
currency outside depository corporations would reduce. To the contrary, we notice
a steady increase in cash in circulation in the economy and this is not necessarily
backed by economic activity.
12
121
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
122
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Subsection (4) provides that a copy of the audited accounts provided in subsection
(3) shall be filed by the political party or organisation with the Electoral Commission
within six months from the end of its financial year. Subsection (5) permits among
others a member of the public to access these records upon request and payment
of a reasonable fee. Subsection (6) prescribes how the EC can proceed against a
political party or organisation that fails to comply. ACFIM noted that Political parties
and organisations are poor at keeping updated records of campaign income and
expenditure.
The Political Parties and Organisations (amendment) Act 2010 section 14 (1-9) puts
a limit on foreign donations but these limits are hardly followed by some of the
political parties and the Electoral Commission as the relevant institution is noticeably
reluctant to enforce them.
Submission of Audited Accounts to Electoral Commission
Political parties and organisations rarely comply with section 12 subsection (4) that
requires them to submit copies of audited accounts to the Electoral Commission.
Information accessed from the electoral commission shows that between 2011
and 2015, only three political parties complied with this requirement. These were:
National Resistance Movement (in 2014), Conservative Party (in 2014) and Forum
for Democratic Change (in 2013). The EC is yet to stamp its authority of these big
political parties to enforce compliance. However, in 2013 the Electoral Commission
took a decision to de-register eleven small parties that had failed to comply with
key provisions of the Political Parties and Organisations Act including failure to
submit an annual audit report and a declaration of assets and liabilities. Parties that
fell victim of this decision include among others: Social Democratic Party, Action
Party, Progressive Alliance Party, Reform Party, Uganda Mandate Party, Movement
for Democratic Change and Movement Volunteer Mobilisers Organisation.
Use of Public Resources for Political Party or Organization Activities
Section 14 (a-c) of the Political Parties and Organisations (amendment) Act 2010
appoints government to contribute funds or other public resources towards the
activities of political parties or organisations represented in Parliament in accordance
with the following principles:
a) Registered political parties or organisations shall be funded by Government
under this Act in respect of elections and their normal day to day activities;
b) In respect of elections, Government shall finance political organisations and
parties on equal basis;
c) In respect of normal day to day activities, funding shall be based on the
numerical strength of each political party or organisation in Parliament.
123
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Subsection-c above was enforced when the Electoral Commission released UGX 10
billion that was shared among the five political parties represented in parliament
namely, NRM, FDC, DP, UPC and JEEMA.
Provisions on Voter Bribery
In accordance with the Presidential Elections Act (as amended) 2005, section 64 and
Parliamentary Elections Act (as amended) 2005 Section 68, it is illegal for a person
either before or during an election to directly or indirectly influence another person
to vote, or refrain from voting for any candidate by, providing money, gifts or other
considerations to that other person. Committing these acts constitutes an offense
known as bribery. ACFIM observers reported that the provisions on voter bribery are
not followed by political parties and candidates, but furthermore, that the relevant
government enforcement institutions namely: Inspectorate of Government, Police
and Electoral Commission do not enforce them. For example, campaigns for NRM
primary elections, and presidential and parliamentary races were characterised by
candidates offering cash and gifts to the electorate under the guise of donations.
This report will examine these cases and furthermore as this report has exposed but
none of them was brought to book. The expressed view of the Inspector General of
Police was that the law falls short of drawing a clear line between voter bribery and
voter facilitation.
Provisions on Misuse of Public Resources for Campaigns
Presidential Elections Act 2005, Section 27 (1) and Parliamentary Elections Act
Section 25 (1-5), prohibits any political candidate from using government resources
for purposes of campaigning for elections. Under the parliamentary elections act
ministers and other candidates that hold political office are permitted to continue
using facilities attached to their office provided that the use is restricted to official
duties of that office. However during elections campaigns it is difficult to draw the line
between what is official duties and electioneering. Subsection (2) makes exception
to a candidate who holds the office of the president but shall use only those facilities
that are ordinarily attached and utilised by the holders of that office. Throughout
the campaign period there were incidences on misuse of government vehicles, fuel
cards, and personnel among others which relevant government institutions were
reluctant to interrogate the offenders.
124
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
13. RECOMMENDATIONS
In view of the findings discussed in this report, ACFIM makes the following
recommendations.
125
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
126
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
h. Amend relevant laws and where possible develop new legislations to prevent
private interests from subverting the democratic process through purchase of
control15 and favours. There should be a law that requires private companies
and business corporations to make quid pro quo campaign contributions/
donations to prospective political parties and/or candidates with a view of gaining
advantage to future government business/contracts or trade/tax concessions.
ACFIM identifies contributions to political/campaign finance as one of the highrisk areas where bribery takes place. Businesses should make donations within
the contribution limits specified in the electoral laws. The Companys Act 2012
should be amended to require companies to list all donations made to political
parties and candidates, and publish them on their websites.
Electoral Commission
a. Enforce on all major political parties the provisions requiring political parties
and organisations to maintain accurate and permanent record of donations,
sources of the funds and expenditure, and filing with the EC a copy of the audit
report within six months from the end of its financial year. Provisions against
voter bribery and misuse of public resources for campaigns should be enforced
as well.
b. Designate an office or officer to handle matters of campaign and political party/
organisation financing. This officer should be charged with reviewing financial/
audit reports filed by political parties and organisations including following up
on those that fail to comply. This report should be publicised in order to help
promote accountability.
Inspectorate of Government
a. The Inspectorate of Government (IG) should take a keen interest in cases of
corruption in campaign financing. One of the core functions of the inspectorate
is to eliminate and foster the elimination of corruption, abuse of authority and of
public office16. However experiences from the 2015/2016 campaigns reveal that
the IG does not take keen interest in corruption offenses related with campaign
financing. Voter bribery - which is a form of corruption was prevalent during
NRM party primaries in October and throughout the entire Presidential and
Parliamentary campaign period however to our knowledge no case was picked
up by the IG or followed up.
Office of the Auditor General
a. Review financial reports on budget utilisation and supplementary financing
for key Ministries, Departments and Agencies including Ministry of Defence,
Purchase of control is when a private company used the power of its contribution to a political candidate to influence
business decisions in its favour.
16
Inspectorate of Government Act 2002, Part III, Section 8 (1b)
15
127
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
Office of the President, Statehouse, and Office of the Prime Minister among
others during the campaign period (October 2015 February 2016). Among
other things, the use of government fuel cards for the above MDAs such as the
Ministry of Gender Labour and Social Development, Ministry of ICT, Parliamentary
Commission and Uganda National Roads Authority should be examined.
b. Audit the utilisation of government funding of UGX 10 billion to political parties
which was given on the basis of numerical strength in parliament and was shared
between NRM, FDC, DP, UPC, CP and JEEMA17.
Political Party Leaders
a) Leaders of political parties should take rigorous action against voter bribery
and the commercialization of politics in Uganda. ACFIM welcomes the robust
statements against voter bribery that were made by some NRM party leaders
including Chairman of Party Electoral Commission, Dr. Tanga Odoi during the
party primaries in October 2015 as did the incumbent president18. Unfortunately
most of the pronouncements were mere rhetoric as candidates continually
ignored them. Words without action are not enough. Party leaders should adopt
a No voter-bribery policy for all flagbearers during campaigns. Party leaders
should be seen to be taking disciplinary action against offenders including
sanctioning thorough investigation on cases of voter bribery highlighted in this
report.
b) Detailed disclosure of campaign income and expenditure. Notwithstanding
the absence of legal requirements for the disclosure of campaign income
and expenditure, political parties and flag bearers should voluntarily declare
campaign income and expenditure in respect of the election campaigns
2015/2016. Conversely, Candidates that were observed on campaign trails
receiving campaign contributions from the public including Kizza Besigye, Yoweri
Museveni, Abedi Bwanika and others, be it at presidential or parliamentary level,
should voluntarily disclose how much was collected and how it was utilised.
Civil Society
a) Revitalise the Advocacy for Electoral Reforms on areas highlighted by
international and domestic election observers as well as the court of appeal.
Critical to this are reforms around the regulatory framework for campaign
financing. ACFIM and partner organisations should engage with the 10th
Parliament, Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Affairs, and the Electoral
Commission for dialogue on areas of legal and institutional reform.
Political Parties and Organisations Act (as amended) 2010, Section 14 (d), provides that the funds provided to political
parties and organisations under this Act, shall be subject to audit by the Auditor General
18
Statement by President YK. Museveni while addressing the NRM National Delegates Conference, 15th December 2014:
They attempt to fundraise for this church, the other mosque, this other school, etc., etc. What is the result? Heavy
indebtedness by the leader to the extent of having their properties sold off.
17
128
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
b) Advocate for restoration in the Public Financial Management (PFM) Act 2015,
of the appropriation of supplementary funding to be approved by Parliament
with a two thirds majority vote. This is in respect to the amendment on the PFM
Act in October 2015 that thwarted budget prudency and could lead to abuse
of public resources in a manner that undermined oversight by parliament and
other state authorities.
c) Organise grass root based awareness interventions targeting voter attitudes
towards vote buying and levying unlimited financial demands on Members
of the 10th Parliament. Ugandans from all walks of life including religious
leaders, cultural leaders, the academia, civil society organisations, faith based
organisations and the media among others should take collective action
to curb vote buying/selling and the resultant commercialization of politics.
Commercialization of politics is a problem that requires Ugandans from all walks
of life to take collective action to reduce it. The practice of ordinary citizens
making campaign donations towards political candidates should be strongly
encouraged.
d) Build capacity of civil society monitors to track and document campaign
spending by political parties and candidates at constituency level. This will
include improving the quality of data collection tools and establishing a standard
data base to store and analyse data on campaign spending.
129
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
EXPENSE
1
15,000,000,000
19,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
30,000,000,000
Outdoor Advertising
6,000,000,000
a) Bill Boards
1,274,100,000
b) Posters
1,706,400,000
c) Banners
214,550,000
Media Advertising
a) Newspapers
132,370,000
b) Radio
439,962,000
c) Television
829,200,000
Yellow T-Shirts
15,806,630,000
10
Other Expenses
First Aid
7,350,000
Tents
2,400,000
Plastic Chairs
4,000,000
6,000,000
Cash to 400 FDC Converts that given by Lt. Gen. Henry Tumukunde at White Castle Hotel, Arua
42,000,000
7,000,000
140,000,000
5,000,000
28,800,000
20,000,000
1,200,000
130
12,000,000
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
OBSERVABLE
MINIMUM COST
EXPENSE
24,000,000
72,000,000
Allowance for 500 SFC men and women 20,000 per day for 30
days
300,000,000
Facilitation for at least 40 Journalists on 6 regional press conferences in Lango, W.Nile, Gulu, Karamoja, Kapchorwa and Soroti:
500,000/= per person
120,000,000
TOTAL MINIMUM
24,960,000
4,000,000,000
125,219,922,000
EXPENSE
Party Primary Elections
30,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
19,000,000,000
Yellow T-Shirts
15,806,630,000
15,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
6,000,000,000
4,000,000,000
Outdoor Advertising
3,195,050,000
Media Advertising
1,401,532,000
Other Expenses
816,710,000
TOTAL MINIMUM
125,219,922,000
131
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
APPENDIX III (M7s Cash Donations/Pledges Jan 2015 & Aug 2015)
JANUARY 2015
DATE
CASH/PLEDGE
PURPOSE
Jan 1
Shs 30 million
Jan 9
11 Mitsubishi Pajeros to
district khadis of Iganga,
Ntungamo, Kamuli, Masindi,
Tororo, Kanungu, Mayuge,
Hoima, Bushenyi, Nebbi and
Sebei
*Each Pajero costs about Shs
200 million)
Jan 10
Construction of Tunyi
Catholic church in Bulambuli
district
Jan 24
100 million
Jan 25
TOTAL (JANUARY)
SHS 2.275 BN
FEBRUARY 2015
Feb 4
Donation to KAWADISA
sacco at the Chieftaincy of
Mubende Rehabilitation
Centre
Feb 17
Shs 30 million
TOTAL (FEBRUARY)
40 MILLION
MARCH 2015
March 4
200 million
March 20
10 million
TOTAL (MARCH)
210 MILLION
APRIL 2015
132
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
JANUARY 2015
DATE
CASH/PLEDGE
PURPOSE
April 14
Construction of a
300,000-litre underground
tank at Mary Hill school,
Mbarara
April 17
April 17
Shs 50 million
Contribution to burial
expenses of Supreme Mufti
Zubair Kayongo
April 18
Shs 10 million
Contribution to burial
expenses of Canon Justina
Kabushenga in Kanungu
April 19
April 22
Development of an HIV/AIDS
orphans centre in Kiruhura
district
April 27
Shs 30 million
Contribution to veterans
savings group in Masaka
April 28
Shs 60 million
TOTAL (APRIL)
1.132 BN
MAY 2015
May 5
20 million
Completion of St Jane
Frances Catholic Church in
Nakabago, Mukono
May 6
10 million
May 11
100 million
To the construction of
Uganda Institute of Science
and Technology, a project
of St Peters cathedral,
Nyakatare, Kanungu
May 25
10 million
May 24
5 billion (pledge)
Construction of perimeter
wall around Makerere
university
TOTAL (May)
5.140 BN
JUNE 2015
133
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
JANUARY 2015
DATE
CASH/PLEDGE
PURPOSE
June 5
5 million
June 19
20 million
June 20
80 million
Towards construction of
library complex for City High
School
June 22
80 million
June 25
20 million
TOTAL
205 MILLION
JULY 2015
July 2
Shs 10 million
July 4
July 6
Shs 60 million
July 13
Shs 10 million
July 17
Shs 20 million
July 21
Shs 20 million
July 22
Shs 30 million
July 22
Shs 50 million
Completion of Riyadh
mosque in Obongi
134
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
JANUARY 2015
DATE
CASH/PLEDGE
PURPOSE
July 29
I billion (pledge)
July 30
TOTAL
1.838 BN
AUGUST 2015
August 3
August 5
60 million
Construction of Burora
Pastoral centre in Kibaale
August 9
August 11
640 million
August 13
50 million
August 18
20 million
August 20
400 million
Redevelopment of
Namugongo Martyrs shrine
August 26
200 million
August 26
300 million
To St Kaggwa Parish,
Bushenyi
August 26
60 million
August 31
60 million
Construction of parish
priests residence at St
Josephs catholic Church,
Lweza
TOTAL
2.590 BN
135
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
22,100,000
Fuel
28,100,000
Administration costs
15,800,000
120,200,000
101,100,000
Donation
T-shirts
32,500,000
2,800,000
10
31,500,000
11
35,800,000
12
56,000,000
13
7,300,000
4,600,000
TOTAL
457,800,000
Source: Eng. Mabiriizi Official Campaign Manager
DESCRIPTION
Advertising
EXPENSES
41,439,000
18.5
0.0
Handout Materials
0.0
16,100,000
7.2
Selected Campaign
Materials
62,500,000
27.9
Campaign Events/Rally/Meetings
28,800,000
12.8
Transport Expenses
Fuel & Hire of Buses, Lorries, Boda-Bodas, Helicopter, Van/Taxis, Cars etc
21,825,000
9.7
136
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
Campaign Managers/
Agents
38,160,000
17.0
Campaign Offices
9,495,000
4.2
Others
6,048,000
2.7
224,367,000
100.0
TOTAL
DESCRIPTION
Posters, Fliers, Banners & Billboards etc
EXPENSES
26,180,000
20.8
0.0
Handout Materials
0.0
17,320,000
13.7
Selected Campaign
Materials
29,510,000
23.4
9,681,000
7.7
Fuel & Hire of Buses, Lorries, BodaBodas, Helicopter, Van/Taxis, Cars etc
16,926,000
13.4
Campaign Managers/
Agents
18,340,000
14.6
Campaign Offices
5,460,000
4.3
Others
2,580,000
2.0
125,997,000
100.0
TOTAL
137
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
Advertising
EXPENSES
21,611,000
18.2
0.0
Handout Materials
0.0
13,481,000
11.3
Selected Campaign
Materials
23,217,000
19.5
Campaign Events/
Rally/Meetings
11,730,000
9.9
Transport Expenses
Fuel & Hire of Buses, Lorries, BodaBodas, Helicopter, Van/Taxis, Cars etc
15,447,000
13.0
25,852,000
21.7
Equipment/Furniture/Computer/
Internet & Attendants/Drivers etc
5,170,000
4.3
Others
2,437,000
2.0
118,945,000
100.0
TOTAL
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
Campaign Events/
Rally/Meetings
14,964,000
23.8
Campaign Managers/Agents
13,827,000
22.0
Selected Campaign
Materials
9,272,000
14.7
7,944,000
12.6
138
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
7,685,000
12.2
Advertising
5,560,000
8.8
Campaign Offices
Equipment/Furniture/Computer/Internet
& Attendants/Drivers etc
2,419,000
3.8
0.0
Handout Materials
0.0
Others
1,210,000
1.9
TOTAL
62,881,000
100.0
DESCRIPTION
EXPENSES
Advertising
0.0
Handout Materials
0.0
Selected Campaign
Materials
3,199,000
30.9
Campaign Events/
Rally/Meetings
1,891,000
18.3
Transport Expenses
1,346,000
13.0
Campaign Managers/Agents
1,546,000
14.9
Campaign Offices
Equipment/Furniture/Computer/Internet
& Attendants/Drivers etc
494,000
4.8
Others
214,500
2.1
TOTAL
1,020,000
650,000
10,360,500
139
Extended Study On Campaign Financing For Presidential And Member Of Parliament Races
9.8
6.3
100.0