Rice Bran and Its Main Components - Potential Role in The Management of Coronary Risk Factors
Rice Bran and Its Main Components - Potential Role in The Management of Coronary Risk Factors
Rice Bran and Its Main Components - Potential Role in The Management of Coronary Risk Factors
29-46, 2005
ISSN 1540-7535 print, Copyright 2005 by New Century Health Publishers, LLC
www.newcenturyhealthpublishers.com
All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
G. Descovich Atherosclerosis and Dysmetabolic Disease Study Center, Department of Clinical Medicine and
Applied Biotechnologies D. Campanacci, SantOrsola-Malpighi University Hospital, Via Masssarenti 9, 40138
Bologna, Italy, and 2 Internal Medicine and Therapeutics Department, Pavia University Hospital, P.le C. Golgi, 2 27100 Pavia, Italy.
INTRODUCTION
It is well known that cardiovascular death rate is lower
in Mediterranean countries than in Northern Europe and
North America. Conclusions from these studies acclaimed the
Mediterranean diet that is very rich in complex carbohydrates,
mono- and polyunsaturated fatty acids, fibres and antioxidants (fruits and fresh vegetables), poor in cholesterol, saturated and oxidised fatty acids, in association with moderate
alcohol consumption. The Far Eastern Asian dietary pattern
is also associated to a lower mortality rate because of cardiovascular events: it is poor in cholesterol and in fatty acid too,
and very rich in rice and soy-derived proteins. Unfortunately,
both Mediterranean and Far Eastern Countries are changing
their alimentary habit toward the Anglo-Saxon one much
more than Anglo-Saxon Countries are getting nearer to
Mediterranean or Asiatic diets.
However, studying both diets we can find some nutrients
that can be isolated and used as dietary supplements, useful to
supply dietary unbalances in order to reduce the cardiovascular disease risk. For instance, there is overwhelming evidence
that support the antihypercholesterolemic effect of vegetable
oils that are rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids, mainly -linolenic and linoleic acid.
Observational studies on distinct populations support the
existence of a linear relationship between plasma lipid levels
and cardiovascular disease induced death rate. This is sound
to be true even if elevated plasma cholesterol is just a borderline one (Durrington et al. 1999). While pharmacological
research has focused on energy in searching for new drugs able
to drastically decrease Low Density Lipoprotein Cholesterol
(LDL-C) and total triglycerides (TG) plasma level, Italian
(Ricci et al. 1997), European (Task Force 1998) and United
States of America (Adult Treatment Panel III 2001) guidelines underline the dietary and behavioural habit correction
as a first step for the hyperlipoproteinemic patient at risk for
cardiovascular events. It is only after this intervention fails to
sufficiently lower plasma lipid level, that the beginning of a
pharmacological treatment is admitted. Once this starts, it
30
fed with rice bran oil at 10% level for a period of eight weeks
showed significantly lower TC, LDL-C and VLDL-C plasma
levels, both on cholesterol-containing and cholesterol-free
diets. HDL-C was increased, while TG showed a non-statistically significant decrease. Liver cholesterol and triglycerides
were also reduced, while faecal excretion of neutral sterols
and bile acids was increased (Sharma et al. 1986, Sharma et
al. 1987). Moreover, the serum total, free esterified and nonHDL-C levels of rats maintained on a 10% refined rice bran
oil diet were significantly lower than those on a 10% groundnut oil diet; HDL-C showed a tendency to be higher. Liver
lipids of rats fed rice bran oil were also markedly lower than in
their groundnut oil fed counterparts. Addition of gamma-oryzanol at 0.5% level to the diet containing rice bran oil showed
a further significant decrease in serum TC, but not of liver
lipids (Seetharamaiah et al. 1988, Seetharamaiah et al.1989).
Feeding phytosterols, cycloartenol and 24-methylene-cycloartanol in amounts present in rice bran oil unsaponifiable
matter to hypercholesterolemic rats for 8 weeks indicated that
cycloartenol alone significantly reduced both plasma cholesterol and TG levels (Rukmini et al. 1991). Besides, the effects
of feeding two levels of rice bran oil (5% and 20% of the diet)
on growth, plasma and liver lipid parameters of Wistar rats,
were compared with those produced on animals which had
been fed by the same quantity of peanut oil. There was no significant difference with respect to the organ weights between
control and experimental groups. Animals, which received
rice bran oil in their diet, had, in general, comparatively
lower levels of TC, TG and PL. On the other hand, animals
receiving 20% rice bran oil in their diet, showed an increase
of 20% in HDL-C, within 18 weeks (p<0.05), when compared to the animals fed with peanut oil. Similarly, LDL-C
and VLDL-C were lower in rice bran oil fed groups, than in
the peanut oil fed groups. There was, however, no significant
difference in the plasma cholesterol/phospholipid ratio or in
the polyunsaturated/saturated fatty acids ratio, nor any in the
oleic/linoleic, oleic/stearic, palmitoleic/palmitic, oleic/palmitic, and oleic/palmitoleic ratios between the two groups
(Purushothama et al. 1995).
Having assessed the anthyperlipidemic property of rice bran
oil, it has been studied the possibility of increasing its cost/
efficacy ratio by mixing it with other less expensive vegetable
oils rich in polyunsaturated fatty acid has been examined.
Rats fed with rice bran oil plus safflower oil and sunflower
oil in 70:30 ratio for a period of 28 days showed significantly
(p<0.05) lower levels of TC, TG and LDL-C and increased
HDL-C in animals fed by a high cholesterol diet and cholesterol free diet. Liver cholesterol and TG were also reduced,
while faecal excretion of neutral sterols and bile acids was
increased with the use of rice bran oil blends. Moreover, the
high rice bran oil content of tocopherols and tocotrienols may
improve the oxidative stability of the blends. Thus, in addition to improving the plasma lipid profile, blending of rice
bran oil with other oils can result in an economic advantage
of lower prices (Sunitha et al. 1997). A somewhat contrasting
effect was recently observed by Koba et al. who studied the
31
32
33
Lp(a) plasma level when neither diet nor antihypercholesterolemic drugs are likely to have an impact on it. A combined
treatment with NCEP Step-1 diet and tocotrienol rich fraction of rice bran has also determined a 25% reduction in
LDL-C plasma level of hypercholesterolemic subjects in a
recent study carried out by Qureshi et al. (2002) . Finally,
we would like highlight a recent case involving a 9 year old
Caucasian patient. She is affected by IIb Fredrickson type of
dyslipidemia (TC>200mg/dl, TG>200mg/dl) that is genetic
based. After one-month of treatment with rice oil (20 g/day)
and polyunsaturated fatty acids (650 mg/day), the child
showed a significant decrease of TC, LDL-C, TG and Lp(a)
reaching her age standard values (Cicero et al.2001). We
resumed the main findings of studies carried out on the effects
of rice bran oil and its principal components on the lipid
metabolism in Table 1 and 2. It seems that rice bran oil and
its main components are able to safely improve the plasma
lipid pattern of hypercholesterolemic patients, however the
quality of the published studies is often poor and the number
of tested subjects really slight. Thus it would be necessary to
carry out new randomised clinical trials on more wide population to conclude definitively if rice oil could be considered
a safe and long-term efficacious treatment for mild-moderate
hyperlipoproteinemias.
MECHANISM OF ACTION: SOME HYPOTHESES
The mechanism of action of rice bran and the derived
oil on lipid metabolism is not yet completely evident. Its
specific content of polyphenols (gamma-oryzanol), phytosterols, tocopherols and tocotrienols is supposed to contribute
to antihyperlipidemic action, while the particular fatty acid
mono- and polyunsaturated composition seems not to be
fundamental in its activity (Rong et al.1992). Moreover, the
additional improvement on lipid metabolism improvement
by rice bran oil/safflower oil blends (Kobe 1997) can not be
easily explained by their fatty acids or plant sterols composition, because the blending of rice bran oil with sunflower oil
(a vegetable oil with a biochemical composition really similar
to the safflower oil) did not exerted the same antihypercholesterolemic property (Sugano et al. 1997). The fact that rice oil
isolable substances are altogether responsible for global effect
on plasma lipid, is the most probable hypothesis.
Gamma-oryzanol: Possible fundamental antiatherosclerotic
role rest on gamma-oryzanol (Kanbara et al. 1992) (Figure
1). In different animal models it was found hat rice bran oil
and its unsaponifiable matter significantly increase the faecal
excretion of acid and neutral sterols (Seetharamaiah et al.
1989). For example, gamma-oryzanols effect on biliary secretion and faecal excretion of cholesterol, PL and bile acids was
examined in male albino rats. Feeding gamma-oryzanol at
0.5% level with the control diet did not cause any change in
bile flow and composition. On feeding gamma-oryzanol with
high cholesterol diet, the bile flow and total bile acid output
were increased by 12% and 18% respectively, as observed by
the significant increase in the faecal excretion of cholesterol
(28%) and bile acids (29%), whereas cholesterol absorption
34
Table 1 Rice bran derived products effects on main lipid metabolism parameters of different animal species
Animal
species
Rice bran
Dose (mg/kg, or Administration Pharmacological effect
derived products % of dietary fats) route
Ref.
Rats
-oryzanol
0,5-2%
OS
Shinomiya, 1993
Rats
-oryzanol
10 mg/kg
IV
Sakamoto, 1997
-oryzanol
1%
OS
Seetharamaiah, 1988
Rats
Cycloartenol
ferulate
10 mg/kg
IV
Sakamoto, 1997
Rats
10%
OS
Sharma, 1987;
Seetharamaiah, 1989
-oryzanol
1%
OS
Hiramatsu, 1990
Hamsters -oryzanol
1%
OS
Rong, 1997
20-25%
OS
Nicolosi, 1991
Rabbits
Table 2 Rice bran derived products effects on main lipid metabolism parameters observed in clinical trials
Rice bran derived Daily
products
dose
-oryzanol
300 mg
StudyDesign
Number of subjects
(Studyduration)
RCT* (8 weeks) 40 Post-menopausal women
Pharmacological effect
300 mg
RCT (8 weeks)
300 mg
TC, LDL-C, TG
Yoshino,1989
300 mg
RCT (8 weeks)
20 Hypercholesterolemics
Sasaki, 1990
500 mg
RCT (9 weeks)
Fry, 1997
Rice-derived
Tocotrienols
200 mg
OS (12 weeks)
41 Hypercholesterolemics
Qureshi 1997
42 g
Cross-Over
(14 weeks)
TC, LDL-C
Suzuki, 1970
50 g
RCT (4 weeks)
23 Mixed
hyperlipoproteinemics
TC, LDL-C, TG
Raghuram, 1989
50 g
Cross-Over
(14 weeks)
HDL-C
Tsuji, 1989
50 g
Cross-Over
(5 weeks)
15 Hypercholesterolemics
TC, LDL-C
Lichtenstein,
1994
80 Post-menopausal women
Ref.
35
Figure 1. Main rice bran active components formulas: cycloartenyl-ferulate, -tocotrienol, -sitosterol
was lowered by 20% (Seetharamaiah et al. 1990). It is possible that gamma-oryzanols antihypercholesterolemic effect is
partially due to its sterol moiety, which is partly split off from
the ferulic acid part in the small intestine by cholesterol esterase (Swell et al. 1954, Sugano et al.1997). Anyway, in 1987
Sakamoto et al. underlined the fact that gamma-oryzanol and
cycloartenol ferulate have an antihyperlipidemic action and
this is more remarkable by intravenous than by oral administration (Sakamoto et al.1987), maybe due to a direct inhibition of lipid metabolism. Moreover, ferulic acid alone, that is
adsorbed and metabolised, has shown an intrinsic hypolipidemic effect in some studies (Sharma 1980, Seetharamaiah et
al. 1993). The pharmacological mechanism of the observed
effect is still unknown, because no direct inhibition on
HMGCoA-R was observed (Seetharamaiah et al.1989). Rice
bran oils antiatherogenic action could also be based on other
mechanisms, for example cholesterol-esterase inhibition by
cycloartenol, or by the inhibition of the accumulation within
macrophages of cholesterol-esters or by the modulation of
cholesterol acid esterase and acyl-CoA-cholesterol-acyltransferase by gamma-oryzanol (Rukmini et al. 1991).
Phytosterols:
Three groups of phytosterols are present in crude rice
bran oil: 4,4-dimethylsterols (1.2%), 4-monomethyl-sterols
36
Figure 2. Main possible effects of rice bran components on plasma lipid pattern
the rice bran oil antihypercholesterolemic effect. Tocotrienols
are naturally occurring farnesylated unsaturated analogues
of -, -, - and -tocopherol (Vitamin E) (Figure 1). In
contrast to corn, wheat, and soybean (contain mainly tocopherols), barley, oats, palm, and commercial rice brans and rice
bran oil contain until 70% tocotrienols, which consists of
-, -, - and -tocotrienols (Raghuram et al.1995). Their
hypocholesterolemic activity has been clearly demonstrated in
different animal species (Pearce et al.1992, Hood et al.1992)
and in humans (Lichtenstein et al.1994, Qureshi et al. 1991).
Intravenously administered, they are able to inhibit the
HMGCoA-R, a key enzyme in the endogenous synthesis of
cholesterol, through two post-trascriptional actions, increasing the controlled degradation of reductase protein and
decreasing the efficiency of the translation of HMGCoA-R
messenger RNA (Khor 1995, Parker 1993). On the other
hand, -tocopherol appears to induce HMGCoA-R activity (Qureshi et al.1996). Tocotrienols have also shown an
antithrombotic, antiproliferative and antioxidant activities
(Watkins et al.1993, Komiyama et al.1992). What is really
interesting is that tocotrienols appear to inhibit atherosclerotic lesions development in atherosclerosis prone mice because
of apolipoprotein E deficiency, at least partly independently
from plasma lipid reduction (Qureshi et al.2001). However,
not all clinical trials confirm the antihypercholesterolemic
activity of tocotrienols in humans and some Authors suggest
prudence in this claim (Kerckhoffs et al. 2002; Mustad et al.
2002).
In conclusion, at present it is not possible to fix an unequivocal mode of action for rice bran oil because of the heterogeneity of the available data (Figure 2). Nevertheless, there is no
doubt about the existence of an antihyperlipidemic action by
rice bran oil components (Sugano et al.1993).
NON-ANTIHYPERLIDEMIC EFFECTS OF MAIN
RICE BRAN OIL COMPONENTS.
Obviously, the acceptability of a nutraceutical potentially
useful for the prevention of cardiovascular disease is even
more relevant when possible effects on other apparatus are also
known. First studies about rice bran oil and its active components (especially gamma-oryzanol) pharmacological properties took place in the 1960s (Nakamura 1966). Therefore,
after the initial and rather ignored observation of Suzuki et
al. about rice bran oils effects on human lipid pattern versus
other fatty acids and comestible oils (Suzuki et al.1970b),
different researchers looked at potential neuroendocrinological, gastroenterological anabolic and dermatological effects of
gamma-oryzanol.
Neuroendocrinological studies: Different studies on a
modulating action on anterior pituitary hormone secretion
(Ishihama et al.1966, Yamauchi et al.1981, Takayanagi et
al.1981) have been run. The main results of these researches
maintain that gamma-oryzanol can be a LH, TSH, GH and
PRL secretion inhibitor. The inhibition of the LH secretion
after a single intravenous injection was significantly stronger
than PRLs one in normal male rats and ovariectomized female
rats (Yamauchi et al.1980). A decrease in TSH production was
observed in human patients affected by hypothyroidism both
acutely and chronically treated with gamma-oryzanol 300mg/
day (Shihomura et al.1980). A single subcutaneous (s.c.)
injection of gamma-oryzanol 20 mg/kg suppressed GH synthesis and PRL release one hour after the injection. Moreover,
it stimulated the tyrosine hydroxylase activity resulting in an
increase in the dopamine content of the medial basal hypothalamic nucleus (MBN), then reduced by a treatment with
-methyl-p-tyrosine, a selective tyrosine hydroxylase inhibitor. gamma-oryzanol did not alter norepinephrine synthesis,
while it significantly increased the norepinephrine release in
MBN. These results may explain the data concerning the
changes in GH and PRL serum levels by gamma-oryzanol and
also suggest that it can affect the synthesis and/or release of
at least two hypothalamic neurotransmitters, dopamine and
norepinephrine, resulting in alterations of anterior pituitary
hormone synthesis and/or release (Ieiri et al.1982). However,
norepinephrine content in different rat brains slightly but
significantly increased when 100 mg/kg gamma-oryzanol
was given s.c. once daily for 1, 5 or 10 days. The turnover
rate of brain norepinephrine tended to decrease with the
administration of gamma-oryzanol. From the results, it is
likely that successive doses of gamma-oryzanol increase brain
norepinephrine by inhibiting degradation or release of norepinephrine (Kaneta et al.1979). Finally, Hiraga et al. have
showed in a wide variety of tests that phytosterol cycloartenol
ferulic acid ester, a component of gamma-oryzanol, has a
suppressant effect on the central nervous system. Rats treated
with the higher dose of cycloartenol ferulic acid ester (1000
37
38
39
40
41
Ishihara, M., Ito, Y., Nakakita, T., Maehama, T., Hieda, S.,
Yamamoto, K., Ueno, N. (1982) Clinical effect of gammaoryzanol on climacteric disturbance -on serum lipid peroxides. Nippon Sanka Fujinka Gakkai Zasshi 34,243-251.
Itaya, K., Kitonaga, J., Ishikawa, M. (1976) Studies of
gamma-oryzanol (2). The antiulcerogenic action. Nippon
Yakurigaku Zasshi 72,1001-1011.
Itaya, K., Kiyonaga, J. (1976) Studies of gamma-oryzanol
(1). Effects on stress-induced ulcer. Nippon Yakurigaku Zasshi
72,475-481.
Itaya, K., Kiyonaga, J., Ishikawa, M., Mizuta, K. (1977)
Studies on gamma-oryzanol (3). Influence of gamma-oryzanol
on circadian rhythms of serum gastrin, 11-OHCS and gastric
secretion in rats. Nippon Yakurigaku Zasshi 73,457-463.
Hirose, M., Ozaki, K., Takaba, K., Fukushima, S., Shirai, T.,
Ito, N. (1991) Modifying effects of the naturally occurring
antioxidants gamma-oryzanol, phytic acid, tannic acid and
n-tritriacontane-16, 18-dione in a rat wide-spectrum organ
carcinogenesis model. Carcinogenesis 12,1917-1921.
Kim, K.M., Yu, K.W., Kang, D.H., Suh, H.J. (2002) Antistress and Anti-fatigue Effect of Fermented Rice Bran.
Phytotherapy Research 16, 700702.
42
43
Sayre, B., Saunders, R. (1990) Rice bran and rice bran oil.
Lipid Techology 2,72-76.
44
Sunitha, T., Manorama, R., Rukmini, C. (1997) Lipid profile of rats fed blends of rice bran oil in combination with
sunflower and safflower oil. Plant Foods in Human Nutrition
51,219-224.
Wang, H.X., Ng, T.B. (1999) Natural products with hypoglycemic, hypotensive, hypocholesterolemic, antiatherosclerotic
and antithrombotic activities. Life Science 65,2663-2677.
Watkins, T., Lenz, P., Gapor, A., Struck, M., Tomeo, A.,
Bierenbaum, M. (1993) -tocotrienol as a hypocholesterolemic and antioxidant agent in rats fed atherogenic diets.
Lipids 28, 1113-1118.
45
46