Determining Sufficiency
Determining Sufficiency
Determining Sufficiency
Introduction
GMAT test writers use data sufficiency questions to test your ability to "reason quantitatively." This stands in sharp contrast to the problem solving section, which is designed to test how well you manipulate numbers. If you find yourself doing a lot of number crunching on the data sufficiency questions, you are doing something wrong.
process of elimination, that the correct answer choice is either D or E. A favorite ploy of GMAT testers is to mix ratios and percentages. Here is an example where Statement 2 simply states backwards the exact same information provided by Statement 1. 1. x is 50% of y 2. the ratio of y:x is 2:1 Make real-world assumptions where necessary. You must assume that, in certain abstract questions such as "What is the value of x?", that x might be a fraction and/or a negative number. Practice, practice, practice. The more time you spend practicing data sufficiency questions, the better able you will be to internalize the tips and strategies given above. You will also become very comfortable with the type of questions from this portion of the test, and will quickly realize if there are any math areas, such as geometry or algebra where you need to brush up your skills. When it comes time to sit for the GMAT, you will want to know key math formulas and data relationships off the top of your head.
D) EACH statement ALONE is sufficient. Statement (1) and (2) TOGETHER are NOT sufficient to answer the question E) asked, and additional data are needed. Hide Answer Correct Answer: A Hide Hint Try plugging in values for the variables and determining whether you can find a definitive value for the expressiona9 + b8 + c6. Hide Technique 1. In evaluating Statement (1), we know definitive values for a, b, and c. Consequently, we have sufficient information to find a definitive value for a9 + b8 + c6. 2. Note that we do not need to determine what the exact value of a9 + b8 + c6 is. We simply need to know definitively that one-and-only-one value for the expression a9 + b8 + c6 can exist given the information in Statement 1. Statement (1) is SUFFICIENT. 3. In evaluating Statement (1), we can perform the following algebraic substitutions: =(a)9 + b8 + c6 =(2)9 + 11,019,960,576 + c6 4. Since we cannot definitively determine that there will only be one value for c6, we cannot definitively determine that there will be only one value for the entire expression a9 + b8 + c6. (Note that we do not need to determine what the exact value is.) Statement (2) is NOT SUFFICIENT. How helpful was this explanation? Report Typo Report Content Error
2. x5 + 10 > 15 A) Statement (1) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not sufficient. B) Statement (2) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not sufficient. BOTH statements TOGETHER are sufficient, but NEITHER statement ALONE is C) sufficient. D) EACH statement ALONE is sufficient. Statement (1) and (2) TOGETHER are NOT sufficient to answer the question E) asked, and additional data are needed. Hide Answer Correct Answer: D Hide Hint Know that the question is asking whether x is positive or negative. Seek to determine quickly the answer sign. Hide Technique 1. When you raise an integer to an odd number, it does not change the sign of the expression. In other words, if x is negative, x3 will be negative. Likewise, if x is positive, x3 will be positive. 2. The question can be simplified to: "is x positive?" 3. If time is short and Statement (1) looks complicated, move on and evaluate Statement (2) first and rule out clearly wrong answers. 4. Evaluating Statement (2): x5 + 10 > 15 x5 > 5 x must be positive. Statement (2) is SUFFICIENT. 5. Since Statement (2) is sufficient, you can quickly rule out answer choices A, C, and E. You have now quickly improved your chances of choosing the correct answer from 20% to 50% (i.e., you are now choosing from 2 answer choices instead of from 5). 6. In evaluating Statement (1), begin by simplifying: x5 + x3 + x + 15 = 298 x5 + x3 + x = 283 7. Since raising a number to an odd exponent does not change the sign of the number, the sign of every term in Statement (1) must be the same (i.e., x5, x3, and x all have the same sign.) 8. Logically, x must be positive since it is impossible to add together only negative numbers and arrive at a sum that is a positive number. In other words, if you add any two negative numbers, you will have a negative number with a larger absolute value. Since x5 + x3 + x adds up to a positive number (i.e., 283), it is impossible for x to be negative (otherwise, x5 + x3 + x would be negative). x is positive and Statement (1) is SUFFICIENT. 9. It turns out that x = 3.0227, meaning Statement (1) is SUFFICIENT because the information in it produces one-and-only-one value for the expression above.
10. Note, however, that the test would never ask you to solve an equation such as the one in Statement (1). This complicated equation is used simply to elucidate the technique. How helpful was this explanation? Report Typo Report Content Error
A jar contains 10 marbles. If there are 4 red marbles in the jar, how many blue marbles are in the jar? Unwarranted Assumption: There are 6 blue marbles in the jar. There could be 5 blue marbles and 1 yellow marble. Do not assume that there are only two colors of marbles in the jar. If x > 10 and x < 12, what is the value of x? Unwarranted Assumption: x is 11. You cannot assume that x is an integer. Nothing in the given information said that x must be an integer. Consequently, x could be 10.5 or 11.5. If Ms. Watson's 4th grade class has 20 students and 50% of these students have blonde hair, how many girls in Mrs. Watson's class have blonde hair? Unwarranted Assumption: There are 10 students with blonde hair so 50% of these must be girls. Consequently, 5 girls have blonde hair. You cannot assume that the ratio of the number of boys to girls is 1:1, or 50%.
1. In evaluating Statement (1), many beginning and intermediate-level test-takers automatically assume that since x = 4, Statement (1) is sufficient because 4 + 1 is always 5. 2. However, Statement (1) is NOT SUFFICIENT because x also equals -4 since (-4)2 = 16. Consequently, x + 1 also equals (-4) + 1 = -3 3. In evaluating Statement (2), we find that Statement (2) is SUFFICIENT because there is only one possible value for x, 4. Negative four is not a possible value given the information in Statement (2) since (-4)3 is not 64 but -64. Therefore, there is only one possible value for x + 1, 5. 4. Since Statement (1) alone is NOT SUFFICIENT and Statement (2) alone is SUFFICIENT, answer B is correct. How helpful was this explanation? Report Typo Report Content Error
1. Since Statement (1) gives a single definitive value that can be plugged in to x2 + x - 12, Statement (1) is SUFFICIENT since we will be able to determine for sure the value of the expression. 2. To see this more clearly, plug in x = 3 and see that it produces one definitive answer to the question: x2 + x - 12 32 + 3 - 12 = 9 + 3 - 12 = 0 3. Evaluate Statement (2). At this point, some are tempted to say that since Statement (2) provides two values for x, Statement (2) is not sufficient because two different values of x (i.e., 3 and -4) will produce two separate values of the equation in the question. However, this is not always true. Two separate values of x can produce the same value. Evaluate x = 3 x2 + x - 12 32 + 3 - 12 = 9 + 3 - 12 = 0 Evaluate x = -4 x2 + x - 12 (-4)2 -4 - 12 = 16 -4 - 12 = 0 4. Since the information in Statement (2) provides one definitive value for the expression in the question (i.e., 0), Statement (2) is SUFFICIENT. 5. Since Statement (1) alone is SUFFICIENT and Statement (2) alone is SUFFICIENT, answer D is correct. How helpful was this explanation? Report Typo Report Content Error
Two Equations With Two Variables Does Not Necessarily Mean Sufficiency
In high school math, most students learned that if two equations have two separate variables, then a definitive solution exists. Although this is technically true, the GMAT plays upon this and seeks to trick test-takers by providing two equations that look different but are actually the same. The GMAT test writers hope that test-takers will assume that a solution exists for the equations. However, under the GMAT's scheme, there is only one unique equation with two variables, so a solution does not need to exist. Consider the following example: If x and y are integers, is x > 0 and y < 0? 1. 4x + y = 8 2. x - 2 = -y/4 A) Statement (1) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not sufficient. B) Statement (2) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not sufficient. BOTH statements TOGETHER are sufficient, but NEITHER statement ALONE is C)
sufficient. D) EACH statement ALONE is sufficient. Statement (1) and (2) TOGETHER are NOT sufficient to answer the question E) asked, and additional data are needed. Hide Answer Correct Answer: E Hide Hint Minuplate the equations in Statements (1) and (2) and see whether a unique equation exists. Hide Technique 1. Most test-takers realize that Statement (1) alone and Statement (2) alone are NOT SUFFICIENT. 2. However, the tests' authors hope that test-takers, when evaluating answer choice C, will assume that there are two unique equations with two variables and, as a result, there is a unique solution for x and y and the question can be definitively answered. 3. But, the above assumption does not hold in this question because there are not two unique equations. The equation in Statement (2) is the same as the equation in Statement (1). Start with: 4x + y = 8 Subtract 8 from each side: 4x - 8 + y = 0 Subtract y from each side: 4x - 8 = -y Divide each side by 4: x -2 = -y/4 So, there is only one unique equation with two variables. Consequently, it is impossible to solve for the value of x and y. Both Statements (1) and (2), even when taken together, are NOT SUFFICIENT.