Vol 11 R2 Eyelid
Vol 11 R2 Eyelid
Vol 11 R2 Eyelid
EYELID RECONSTRUCTION
Marlene Morales, MD Rajat Ghaiy, MD Kamel Itani, MD
Reconstructive
PLATINUM PARTNERS
facial aesthetics
SILVER PARTNER
www.SRPS.org
Editor-in-Chief Editor Emeritus
F. E. Barton, Jr, MD
W. P. Adams, Jr, MD S. M. Bidic, MD G. Broughton II, MD, PhD S. Brown, PhD J. L. Burns, MD J. J. Cheng, MD A. A. Gosman, MD K. A. Gutowski, MD R. Y. Ha, MD R. E. Hoxworth, MD K. Itani, MD J. E. Janis, MD R. K. Khosla, MD J. E. Leedy, MD J. A. Lemmon, MD A. H. Lipschitz, MD J. H. Liu, MD R. A. Meade, MD J. K. Potter, MD, DDS S. M. Rozen, MD M. Saint-Cyr, MD M. Schaverien, MRCS A. P. Trussler, MD R. I. S. Zbar, MD
Reconstruction Topics
Breast Reconstruction Cleft Lip and Palate Craniofacial Eyelid Reconstruction Facial Fractures Hand: Congenital Hand: Extensor Tendons Hand: Flexor Tendons Hand: Peripheral Nerves Hand: Soft Tissue Hand: Wrist, Joints, Rheumatoid Arthritis Head and Neck Reconstruction Lip, Cheek, Scalp, and Hair Restoration Lower Extremity Reconstruction Nasal Reconstruction Surgery of the Ear Trunk Reconstruction Vascular Anomalies Wounds and Wound Healing
Contributing Editors
Cosmetic Topics
Blepharoplasty Body Contouring: Excisional Surgery Body Contouring: Noninvasive, Liposuction, Fat Grafts Breast Augmentation Breast Reduction and Mastopexy Brow Lift Facelift Injectable Agents and Dermal Fillers Rhinoplasty Skin Care
Business Managers
Corporate Sponsorship
Dori Kelly
Selected Readings in Plastic Surgery (ISSN 0739-5523) is published approximately 5 times per year by Selected Readings in Plastic Surgery, Inc. A volume consists of 30 issues distributed over 6 years. Please visit us at www.SRPS.org for more information. Published as electronic monographs.
EYELID RECONSTRUCTION
Marlene Morales, MD Rajat Ghaiy, MD Kamel Itani, MD University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas, Dallas, Texas
INTRODUCTION When performing eyelid reconstruction, a thorough understanding of periorbital anatomy is critical. It is important to understand the function of each structure and its interplay. One must approach eyelid reconstruction with the goal of restoring the functionality of the structure while achieving an aesthetically pleasing result. ANATOMY In this section, we present summaries of the anatomy related to eyelid reconstruction. For further reading on eyelid anatomy, detailed descriptions can be found in the 2008 text, Eyelid & Periorbital Surgery, by McCord and Codner.1 Dimensions The palpebral fissure is the space between the upper and lower eyelid margins. Normally, the adult fissure is 27 to 30 mm horizontally and 8 to 11 mm vertically (Fig 1).2 Many conditions can affect the palpebral fissure measurement; it can be vertically increased in patients with Graves disease, decreased in patients with involutional ptosis, and variable in patients with myasthenia gravis. Horizontally, it can
be decreased in patients with blepharophimosis and in patients with laxity or disinsertion of the lateral or medial canthal tendon. Skin and Eyelid Crease The eyelid skin has only six to seven cell layers and averages <1 mm thick.3 The thin keratinizing epithelium is loosely attached to the underlying orbicularis muscle.4 The levator aponeurosis extends inferiorly to join the anterior surface of the tarsal plate 3 mm superior to the lid margin, where it forms its firmest attachment.2 When performing eyelid reconstruction, it is important to successfully recreate the eyelid crease for a better cosmetic result. The occidental upper eyelid crease is 8 to 9 mm superior to the eyelid margin centrally in men and 8 to 11 mm superior to the margin in women.5 The lid crease is a result of fascial bands from the levator aponeurosis extending anteriorly through the orbicularis oculi to the skin. The lid crease typically is higher in involutional ptosis and in levator dehiscence. In the Asian eyelid, the upper eyelid crease is 2 to 3 mm superior to the margin and usually poorly defined. Three morphological types of Asian upper
Figure 1. Landmarks of the external eye. The palpebral fissure is approximately 27 to 30 mm wide and 8 to 11 mm high in the adult. (Reprinted with permission from Cibis.2)
might help avoid relapse and complications associated with aesthetic and functional upper eyelid surgery. Upper Eyelid Retractors and Mller Muscle The upper and lower eyelids are analogous structures with their main difference being their respective retractors. In the upper eyelid, the levator palpebrae superioris and its aponeurosis comprise a distinct entity that evolved from the superior rectus muscle.20 The lower eyelid retractor is a fascial extension of the inferior rectus, which divides to encircle the inferior oblique muscle, called the capsulopalpebral fascia.
The levator muscle palpebrae originates under the lesser wing of the sphenoid just anterior to the optic foramen.3 It extends anteriorly for 40 to 45 mm and becomes tendinous in front of Whitnall ligament (Fig. 4). Whitnall ligament is a transverse band of fibrous condensation that attaches superiorly to the widening levator. It is the condensed fascial sheath of the levator muscle approximately 18 to 20 mm above the superior border of the tarsus. Medially, it attaches to the connective tissue around the trochlea and superior oblique tendon. Laterally, it attaches to the inner aspect of the lateral orbital wall, approximately 10 mm superior to the lateral orbital tubercle. It 5
Figure 4. Anterior view of the levator palpebrae superioris shows the relationship to the tarsal plate and Whitnall ligament.
Figure 5. Fat compartments and lacrimal gland in the upper and lower eyelids.
or baseline secretion is produced by approximately 50 small accessory glands of the Krause and Wolfring glands, mucin-secreting goblet cells of the conjunctiva, and oil-secreting meibomian glands and the glands of Zeiss at the eyelid margin. The main lacrimal gland is actually a reflex secretor and acts in response to physical and emotional triggers (i.e., from emotional or foreign body stimulus).22,28,35 The main lacrimal gland is divided into two parts by the lateral horn of the levator aponeurosis and is found superotemporally in the orbit. The upper or orbital lobe conforms to the space between the orbital wall and the globe, extending from the lateral border of the levator aponeurosis on which it rests, down to the frontozygomatic suture.22 The lower or palpebral lobe is located under the levator aponeurosis in the subaponeurotic space. This inferior lobe is mobile and often can be prolapsed into view in the conjunctival sac.35
Figure 7. Buried vertical mattress technique. A, Buried vertical mattress suture. B, Anterior tarsal sutures. C, Lash line suture. (Reprinted with permission from Ahmad et al.15)
11
The amniotic membrane is anatomically the innermost layer of the placenta and consists of a thick basement membrane and an avascular stroma. It commonly is used to replace damaged mucosal surfaces and has been effectively and extensively used for reconstructing corneal4651 and conjunctival5255 surfaces damaged by a variety of insults and in different ocular surface disorders.51,56 Solomon et al.51 showed that amniotic membrane transplant maintained a deep fornix and scar-free environment with complete or partial success in 14 of 17 eyes. In that study, preserved human amniotic membrane was obtained from Bio-Tissue, Inc. (Miami, FL). After thawing, the membrane was trimmed to correspond with the conjunctival defect, including the bulbar surface of the fornix and the deeper portion of the palpebral aspect of the fornix. The membrane was then secured to the recessed conjunctival edge. Alternatively, the membrane can be stabilized with tissue glue such as Tisseel tissue sealant (Baxter Corp., Mississauga, ON). The
Tarsal Plate For cases of eyelid reconstruction in which the posterior lamella has been lost, it is critical to use a material that simulates the tarsal-conjunctival complex in thickness, surface quality, and resilience. A wide variety of materials have been used, including autogenous, homologous, and synthetic grafts. Autogenous grafts that have been used include hard palate, ear cartilage, temporalis fascia, fascia lata, nasal septal cartilage, tarsus, dermis, and periosteum.5762 Homologous donor sclera and synthetic polytetrafluoroethylene grafts have also been used.6365 Some materials do not lend a permanent solution, and late problems can arise. Hard palate grafts and free tarsal grafts are commonly used as posterior lamella alternatives in 13
Because the procedure is simple and conducive to restoring a stable and long-lasting lower lid support, the authors claimed that it is widely applicable to various deformities of the lower lid. Although the grafted cartilage was slightly visible in some cases, none required removal. Two of the 34 cases required secondary operations during the early postoperative period because of detachment of the grafted cartilage from the point of fixation. This was considered the only complication of the technique; otherwise, there was good lid position during a follow-up period of as long as 15 years. Warping of the cartilage did not occur in any of the cases. A disadvantage of this procedure is that the lower lid becomes fixed postoperatively, and patients might experience partial disturbance in the visual field at the extreme down-gaze. Therefore, the authors recommend the procedure for patients with anophthalmic orbit or severe deformity. Patients with poor vision in the eye undergoing eyelid repair might not be bothered by the possible complication of the down-gaze disturbance and might therefore also be suitable candidates for the procedure. Scuderi et al.77 published the results of their 10-year experience with the nasal chondromucosal flap for large upper eyelid full-thickness defects. 15
With this technique, a skin graft is used for the anterior lamella. The nasal lining donor defect is repaired with direct closure using absorbable sutures 16
After the skin is incised for 2.5 cm along the border between the lateral nasal wall and the cheek from the inner canthus to the ala nasi, the periosteum is dissected from lateral to medial, up to and beyond the midline of the nose. Dissection is extended superiorly to the inner canthus and glabella and inferiorly to the lower margin of the nasal bones. Then, the subcutaneous tissue is dissected, always from lateral to medial, onto a line beyond the midline of the nose, where it joins the subperiosteal plane. The subcutaneous dissection is extended superiorly to the glabellar area and inferiorly to or beyond the lower margin of the upper lateral cartilages. Distally, the flap is harvested including the cranial portion of the upper lateral cartilage, depending on the size of the defect to repair, and the corresponding nasal mucosa. The flap is then transposed to reconstruct the posterior lamella of the missing eyelid, flap mucosa is sutured to the conjunctival margin (separating it from the fornix if necessary), and the levator muscle stump is inserted into the cartilaginous portion of the flap. This simulates insertion of the levator muscle into the tarsal plate.
Acellular human dermis (AlloDerm; LifeCell Corporation, Branchburg, NJ), is a cadaveric dermal graft that has been enzymatically processed to remove all cellular material to leave only an acellular and immunologically inert collagen matrix. The dermal framework promotes fibroblast immigration, neovascularization, and collagen deposition.57,74 In postoperative animal studies, the matrix is replaced by host cells.79 Li et al.74 compared 35 patients undergoing AlloDerm grafting with 25 patients undergoing hard palate grafting of the lower eyelid after postoperative cicatricial changes. The lower eyelid heights were measured. No statistically significant difference was found between the AlloDerm and hard palate groups, although a trend was observed that hard palate grafts resulted in both better elevation and a lower failure rate. Female patients in both groups were found to experience significantly greater eyelid elevation than male patients. Taban et al.57 evaluated the long-term efficacy of a thick AlloDerm graft in lower eyelid reconstruction compared with previous results for thin AlloDerm and hard palate grafts. The results showed similar rates of success and final eyelid height position.
An alternative material that can be used in place of tarsus is a product known as Enduragen, which is a porcine acellular dermal collagen matrix manufactured by Tissue Science Laboratories (Aldershot, United Kingdom). McCord et al.80 described the first experiences with Enduragen as a spacer graft in 69 patients and 129 eyelids
Figure 8. (Above) Tenzel flap for upper eyelid reconstruction. An inferior arching semicircular line is marked and incised from the lateral canthus, extending temporally. A lateral canthotomy is made, and a superior cantholysis is performed. The flap is rotated inward and sutured to the medial edge of the defect.
Figure 9. (Left) Classic Cutler-Beard bridge flap technique. A horizontal incision is made along the distal border of the lower tarsus. A full-thickness inferior eyelid flap is created. The remaining lower lid margin forms a bridge. After 4 to 8 weeks, the flap is cut. The pedicle slides back and is sutured to the distal border of the bridge.
20
Figure 10. With an upper lid defect that includes 3 to 4 mm of residual tarsus, the upper tarsus is mobilized on a conjunctival pedicle. Advancement of the tarsoconjunctival flap is shown. The tarsus is sutured in an advanced position, forming a new posterior lamella lid margin.
alone in the advancement flap spares dissection of the orbicularis, resulting in less disruption to the lower lid tissues. They suggested that the time required for the skin to stretch is less than that for a comparable myocutaneous flap, which is supported by their results showing the flap was divided at 2 weeks. The skin-only flap carries a sufficient blood supply, apparent during flap division at 2 weeks, which showed bleeding from the reconstructed tarsal margin and indicated good vascularity. Another advantage of this method is eye occlusion for only 2 weeks compared with the traditional 4 to 8 weeks. Only one patient developed mild ectropion and was noted to be the youngest patient needing the greatest vertical displacement to cover the upper lid defect. Dutton and Fowler102 presented a modification of the Cutler-Beard technique, which is valuable in cases in which the upper eyelid margin is spared. The technique is helpful for patients with cicatricial upper eyelid scarring and retraction of non-marginal tumor resection. A full-thickness horizontal incision is cut just above the tarsus of the upper lid (in cases of cicatricial retraction), or the non-marginal lesion is excised, conserving the upper lid margin. The remainder of the surgery consists of the traditional Cutler-Beard technique. After 2 to 3 weeks, the flap gains adequate blood supply from above. After 3 to 4 weeks, the flap is divided. The epithelium and scar tissue along the inferior border of the lower eyelid bridge and along the superior border of the upper 22
eyelid bridge are trimmed to expose all lamellae. The lateral and medial edges of the cheek incisions are undermined, and, if necessary, a portion of the stretched flap ends is excised. The conjunctiva and lower eyelid retractors are sutured to the inferior border of the lower tarsus with a running 6-0 fastabsorbing plain gut suture. The authors described performing the procedure in only two patients who were reported to have achieved excellent functional and cosmetic results, although a follow-up duration was not specified for the first patient described. The second patient subsequently underwent a frontalis sling procedure to correct residual ptosis 8 months postoperatively. Another less common technique is a pentagonal composite graft from the contralateral upper eyelid. Up to 30% of the contralateral upper eyelid can be harvested and transferred to the affected eyelid. The technique should be a last resort measure to avoid complications in the normal eye. One should consider this method if the contralateral eye is blind or has poor visual potential. A reconstructive ladder for upper eyelid defects is shown (Fig. 11).13 Lower Eyelid Direct Closure Lower eyelid defects involving 25% or less of the eyelid length in a young patient can be closed in a fashion similar to closure of the upper eyelid, with a direct end-to-end closure. In older patients
Figure 11. Reconstructive ladder for upper eyelid defect. A, Primary closure with or without lateral canthotomy or superior cantholysis. B, Semicircular flap. C, Adjacent tarsoconjunctival flap and full-thickness skin graft. D, Free tarsoconjunctival graft and skin flap. E, Full-thickness lower eyelid advancement flap (Cutler-Beard flap). F, Lower eyelid switch flap or median forehead flap. (Reproduced with permission from Kersten.13)
23
Figure 12. With the scissors pointed inferoposteriorly toward the lateral orbital rim, the inferior arm of the lateral canthal tendon is cut.
24
Figure 13. Tenzel flap in lower eyelid reconstruction. After a superior arching line is drawn and incised from the lateral canthus extending temporally, a lateral canthotomy incision is created and inferior cantholysis performed. The flap is then undermined, rotated nasally, and sutured.
Figure 14. Mustarde rotational cheek flap. Top, Shaded area shows inferior eyelid defect. Middle, Nasal chondromucosal graft is secured to the lateral orbital rim. The rotated flap is anchored to the external lateral orbital rim. Bottom, Defect is closed.
Tripier Flap In 1889, Tripier121 described the original Tripier flap for cases in which the posterior lamella is preserved but anterior lamellae lower eyelid restoration is required. It consisted of dissecting and elevating a bipedicled flap from the upper eyelid that was then transposed inferiorly into a lateral lower
28
29
Figure 16. Modified Hewes procedure. Dashed lines represent the flap site, which includes part of the superior peripheral arcade. The upper eyelid tarsoconjunctival flap is mobilized and transposed into the lower eyelid defect. An upper eyelid musculocutaneous flap is transposed to cover the tarsoconjunctival flap.
30
Figure 17. Reconstructive ladder for lower eyelid defect. A, Primary closure with or without lateral canthotomy or inferior cantholysis. B, Semicircular flap. C, Adjacent tarsoconjunctival flap and full-thickness skin graft. D, Free tarsoconjunctival graft and skin flap. E, Tarsoconjunctival flap from upper eyelid and skin graft (Hughes procedure). F, Composite graft with cheek advancement flap (Mustarde flap). (Reproduced with permission from Kersten.13)
31
Figure 18. Various steps of the one-stage sandwich technique for eyelid reconstruction are shown. a, Shallow lower eyelid defect after tumor excision. b, Width of the graft was 2 mm less than the horizontal defect size to ensure adequate horizontal tension. The horizontal width of the defect was measured with calipers. c, With straight Stevens scissors, the orbicularis oculi muscle was dissected from the skin anteriorly and from the orbital septum posteriorly to the orbital rim. d, Two vertical cuts were then made in the muscle to liberate it sufficiently to fill the eyelid defect without vertical traction. e, Contralateral or ipsilateral upper eyelid was everted, and a free tarsoconjunctival graft was harvested. f, Graft was sutured to the margins of the tarsal plate in the defect. g, Orbicularis oculi muscle flap was sutured to the margins of the orbicularis oculi muscle surrounding the defect. h, Free skin graft was harvested from the ipsilateral or contralateral upper eyelid. i, After careful removal of any remaining muscle fibers or subcutaneous tissue, the graft was sutured into the skin defect. (Reprinted with permission from Paridaens and van den Bosch.132)
33
Figure 19. Glabellar V-Y flap. Illustration on the top depicts the medial canthal defect with an inverted V originating from the apex of the defect. Incision and rotation of the flap into the defect result in an inverted Y as depicted in the illustration on the bottom.
Figure 20. Modified glabellar flap. Note the additional horizontal incision where excess glabellar tissue was incused, allowing the brows to rest in a more natural position.
Nasolabial and Melolabial Flaps Similar to glabellar flaps, tissue from the nasolabial region can be used as flaps in the same classically described V-Y configuration. The inverted V is created with the apex inferiorly oriented into the nasolabial tissue. The flaps are harvested from the nasolabial fold lateral to the nasolabial crease. That region has a rich blood supply from the perforating branches of the facial artery. Because of the rich vascularity, the flap can be based inferiorly or superiorly. This particular area contains the most redundant skin on the face and allows for sizeable flaps and relatively easy closure. The scar often can be hidden in or parallel to the nasolabial crease.139
Figure 21. Rhomboid flap. Note the creation of a rectangular flap that can be used to fill the medial canthal defect.
Figure 22. Medial myocutaneous flap. Note the attachment of the myocutaneous flap with the medial fat pad.
Figure 23. Medial pedicled orbicularis oculi flap. The pentagonal section represents the portion of the graft that has been deepithelialized and will reside tunneled beneath the nasal tissue.
37
43
1. McCord CD Jr, Codner MA. Eyelid & Periorbital Surgery. St. Louis: Quality Medical Publishing; 2008. 2. Cibis GW. Fundamentals and principles of ophthalmology: Section 2. In, Purdy EP (ed): American Academy of Ophthalmology Basic and Clinical Science Course. San Francisco: American Academy of Ophthalmology; 2006: 2129. 3. Thornton JF, Kenkel JM. Eyelid Reconstruction. Dallas: Selected Readings in Plastic Surgery, Inc.; 2005. 4. Rootman, J. Diseases of the Orbit: A Multidisciplinary Approach. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2003:2326. 5. Kikkawa DO, Lemke BN. Orbital and eyelid anatomy. In, Dortzbach RK (ed): Ophthalmic Plastic Surgery: Prevention and Management of Complications. New York: Raven Press; 1994:129. 6. Han MH, Kwon ST. A statistical study of upper eyelids of Korean young women. Korean J Plast Surg 1992;19:930935. 7. Jeong S, Lemke BN, Dortzbach RK, Park YG, Kang HK. The Asian upper eyelid: An anatomical study with comparison to the Caucasian eyelid. Arch Ophthalmol 1999;117:907912. 8. Hawes MJ, Dortzbach RK. The microscopic anatomy of the lower eyelid retractors. Arch Ophthalmol 1982;100: 13131318. 9. Lim WK, Rajendran K, Choo CT. Microscopic anatomy of the lower eyelid in Asians. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg 2004;20:207211. 10. Kakizaki H, Jinsong Z, Zako M, Nakano T, Asamoto K, Miyaishi O, Iwaki M. Microscopic anatomy of Asian lower eyelids. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg 2006;22:430433. 11. Narayanan K, Barnes EA. Epiphora with eyelid laxity. Orbit 2005;24:201203. 12. Becker BB. Tricompartment model of the lacrimal pump mechanism. Ophthalmology 1992;99:11391145. 13. Kersten R. Orbits, eyelids, and lacrimal system: Section 7. In, Purdy EP (ed): American Academy of Ophthalmology Basic and Clinical Science Course. San Francisco: American Academy of Ophthalmology; 2006:139. 14. Wulc AE, Dryden RM, Khatchaturian T. Where is the gray line? Arch Ophthalmol 1987;105:10921098. 15. Ahmad J, Mathes DW, Itani KM. Reconstruction of the eyelids after Mohs surgery. Semin Plast Surg 2008;22:
44
45
46
47
48
49
Ahmad J, Mathes DW, Itani KM. Reconstruction of the eyelids after Mohs surgery. Semin Plast Surg 2008;22: 306318. Burroughs JR, Soparkar CN, Patrinely JR. The buried vertical mattress: A simplified technique for eyelid margin repair. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg 2003;19:323324. deSousa JL, Leibovitch I, Malhotra R, ODonnell B, Sullivan T, Selva D. Techniques and outcomes of total upper and lower eyelid reconstruction. Arch Ophthalmol 2007;125: 16011609. Erdogmus S, Govsa F. The arterial anatomy of the eyelid: Importance for reconstructive and aesthetic surgery. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 2007;60:241245. Fagien S. Puttermans Cosmetic Oculoplastic Surgery. 4th ed. Philadelphia: Saunders Elsevier; 2008:4852. Hashikawa K, Tahara S, Nakahara M, Sanno T, Hanagaki H, Tsuji Y, Terashi H. Total lower lid support with auricular cartilage graft. Plast Reconstr Surg 2005;115:880884. Korn BS, Kikkawa DO, Cohen SR, Hartstein M, Annunziata CC. Treatment of lower eyelid malposition with dermis fat grafting. Ophthalmology 2008;115:744751. Leatherbarrow B, Watson A, Wilcsek G. Use of the pericranial flap in medial canthal reconstruction: Another application of this versatile flap. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg 2006;22: 414419. Leibovitch I, Malhotra R, Selva D. Hard palate and free tarsal grafts as posterior lamella substitutes in upper lid surgery. Ophthalmology 2006;113:489496.
50
We thank the Aesthetic Surgery Journal and Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery for their support.
Published by