Topics of recent issues Sociology of literary creativity (vol. xix, n o . 4) Theory, training and practice in m a n a g e m e n t (vol. x x , n o .

1 ) Multidisciplinary problem-focused research (vol. x x , n o . 2) Motivational patterns for modernization (vol. x x , n o . 3)

Topics of forthcoming issues Innovation in public administration Problems of rural life Implantation of he social sciences

Opinions expressed in signed articles are those of the authors a n d d o not necessarily reflect the views of Unesco. Permission for the reproduction of articles appearing in this Journal can be obtained from the Editor. Correspondence arising from this Journal should b e addressed to: T h e Editor, International Social Science Journal, Unesco, Place de Fontenoy, 75 Paris-7e.

Editor: Peter Lengyel

Vol. X X , No. 4, 1968

International social science journal

Published quarterly b y U n e s c o

T h e arts in society
Alphons Silbermann Pierre Bourdieu Roger L . B r o w n Roger Clausse Vladimir Karbusicky Heinz Otto Luthe Bruce Watson Introduction. A definition of the sociology of art Outline of a sociological theory of art perception T h e creative process in the popular arts T h e mass public at grips with mass communications T h e interaction between 'reality - work of art society' Recorded music and the record industry O n the nature of art publics Select bibliography 567 589 613 625 644 656 667 681

T h e world of the social sciences

Research and training centres and professional bodies Hungary Italy Spain Venezuela N e w institutions and changes of n a m e and address 691 Centre for Afro-Asian Research, Hungarian A c a d e m y of Sciences 693 Istituto di Studi e Ricerche Carlo Cattaneo 694 Instituto de Estudios Laborales 695 Instituto de Investigaciones Econmicas y Sociales, Universidad Central 697 Meetings Approaching international conferences 700 Social science and urban development in Latin America (Jahuel, Chile, April 1968) by Ralph Gakenheimer and J o h n Miller 706 International appointments vacant 709

Documents and publications of the United Nations and Specialized Agencies 730 Books received
Unesco 1966

733

The arts in society

Introduction A definition of the sociology of art

Alphons Silbermann

Although, not so very long ago, a sociology of art, embracing the various forms of art, was u n k n o w n and indeed almost inconceivable as an independent branch of the social sciences, ever larger numbers of sociologists are n o w engaging in this steadily expanding discipline which is devoted to such special subjects as literature, music, the theatre and painting; centres concerned with the sociology of art are being set up; the sociology of art is being taught at the universities a n d is always included in the agenda of meetings devoted to questions of art. Furthermore, m a n y books o n this subject are n o w being published, so that the sociology of art m a y truly be said to have w o n virtual recognition as a branch of science. This development, however gratifying, creates two groups of problems which, at least latently, if not always manifestly, touch upon the basis of the sociology of art as an independent branch of science. Firstly, there is the question of the place of a sociology of the various forms of art within the corresponding sciencesliterature, music, the theatre and aesthetics; in this connexion, it is particularly important to determine whether the sociology of art is to be regarded as an independent science or merely as an auxiliary science. Secondly, w e must consider h o w the sociology of art can be integrated in the social sciences as a whole instead of being allotted a marginal role, which would be undesirable. Logically, these two groups of problems are very closely related to each other, for if there were no science of literature or of music, for instance, there would be no sociology of literature or music. Hence, in any history of the development of the sociology of literature there is constant reference to the ideas of M a d a m e de Stal;1 in that of the sociology of music, to Amiot 2 and Kiesewetter;3 in that of the fine arts, to Vasari,4 and so on.
i. In: De la littrature considre dans ses rapports avec les institutions sociales, 1800, and De l'Allemagne, 1810. 2. Father Jean Joseph Marie Amiot, Mmoire sur la musique des Chinois, Paris, 1779. 3. Raphael G . Kiesewetter, Die Musik der Araber, Leipzig, 1842. 4. Giorgio Vasari, Vies des plus excellents peintres, sculpteurs et architectes, 1542-50.

Int. Soe. Sei. J., Vol. X X , No. 4, 1968

568

Alphons Silbermann

Consequently, there is no alternative but to treat these two groups of problems in conjunction, particularly since our primary concern in this introductory article must be to systematize to some extent the progressive development of the sociology of art. It would otherwise be very difficult in the long run to survey and understand its meaning, aims and widely varying methods of investigation. T h e fact is that a branch of science must develop from the most varied starting-points, both tried and untried, theoretical and practical, purely intellectual and empirical, if it is not to be d o o m e d to an early death by self-adulation. Here, w e propose to m a k e such an attempt at systematization, though naturally without exploring every avenue of investigation to its extreme limit. T h e author, w h o is himself fully engaged in the subject and has for m a n y years been trying to m a k e his o w n contribution to the development of this discipline, can hardly be expected to carry out such a systematization without voicing any criticism. Being more inclined to empirical social science, he feels b o u n d to show a certain restraint in adopting the systematic approach, so as not to become involved in attempts to secure a scientific monopoly at all costs. For instance, whoever can write 'the establishment and development of the sociology of music depends on the extent to which it can adapt its methods and language to the field of music (and not, for instance, describe Bach as someone w h o produced music for consumers)', 1 or 'a sociological approach to m o d e r n art can be fully valid only if it takes a study of the arts in the past as its starting-point and vice versa'2 shows only too clearly that he is more concerned with the preservation of the traditional than with the pursuit of intellectual progress. But the science of music and the science of art and even the science of literature, with their search for the basic structures of the unities of meaning, the symbolizing functions of the literary work and so on, are not alone in insisting on certain priority rights, whichwe hasten to addare partly grounded on the fact that, in the process of exploration in depth, confusion concerning certain concepts has occurred, as is clear from the following: ' T h e sociology of music will, in any case, really find a method of its o w n only w h e n it has ceased to consider itself as a case to which that mathematical and linguistic symbolism which is wrongly held to be the criterion for every form of expression can be applied.'3
i. 'Die Begrndung und Entwicklung der Musiksoziologie hngt davon ab, wieweit sie sich in Methode und Sprache d e m Sachgebiet Musik anpasst (z.B. Bach nicht als Produzenten fr Konsumenten bezeichnet).'Walter Wiora, in: Die Musik in Geschichte und Gegenwart, Kassel, 1961, Vol. 9, p. 1215. 2. ' U n e approche sociologique de l'art actuel ne saurait tre pleinement valable qu' partir de l'tude des arts d u pass et rciproquement.'Pierre Francastel, La ralit figurative. lments structurels de sociologie de l'art, Paris, 1965, p. 15. T h e same tendency is also to be found in H a n n a Deinhard, Bedeutung und Ausdruck. Zur Soziologie der Malerei, Neuwied and Berlin, 1967. 3. 'Die Musiksoziologie wird jedenfalls erst dann ihre Arbeitsmethode wirklich gefunden haben, w e n n sie aufgehrt hat, sich als Anwendungsfall jenes mathematischen und sprachwissenschaftlichen Symbolismus zu betrachten, der zu Unrecht fr das Richtmass jeder Aus drucksform gehalten wird.' This is a quotation from Pierre Francastel's foreword to the German edition of Franois Lesure's Musik und Gesellschaft im Bild, Kassel, 1966, p. 7.

A definition of the sociology of art

569

In regard to the sociology of art, even sociologists are alarmed by an ambiguity which appears to them atfirstsight to result from linking the various forms of art and sociology, the sciences of art and sociology. Thus, until quite recently, there w a s a complete lack of manuals a n d textbooks dealing with the sociology of art in any detail,1 or else the sociological study of the arts was dismissed as follows: ' T h e arts, in s u m , are the least important a n d the most variable of the elements that enter into the social structure.'2 E v e n more recent, voluminous works emphasizing comprehensiveness, e.g., Georges Gurvitch's Trait de sociologie, do not devote so m u c h as one whole page to the sociology of music 3 and the other sociologies of art are presented mainly as a mixture of ethnology and philosophy. Rather than dwell o n this regrettable neglect, let us excuse it as the result of a lack of information and devote ourselves to our real task, that of systematization, designed to indicate as concisely as possible, though perhaps not completely in the limited space available to us, the various directions in which different schools of thought seek to practise the sociology of art, develop its theoretical side, apply it and provide it with a methodological foundation. First, w e must give a general outline, showing h o w the sociology of artfitsinto the general context of sociology. In the above-mentioned treatise b y the French sociologist Georges Gurvitchbut also in works by other writerswe find the sociologies of music, language, literature, the plastic arts, religion, etc., treated as problems of the sociologie des uvres de civilisation (sociology of works of culture)a phrase coined by Gurvitch to replace one which he had previously used in the same context, la sociologie de l'esprit (sociology of the m i n d ) .* Gurvitch says in this connexion that 'the sociology of the m i n d has no "imperialist" claims; it does not pretend to take the place of philosophy; it will, however, oblige the latter more and m o r e to take account of its sociological counterpart and the work that it is doing';6 but there still remain doubtsespecially w h e n w e have read other works by him 6 and b y one of this pupils7as to whether such a categorization m a y not lead to a distraction from realities, which, as has already been frequently pointed out, is most undesirable. Moreover, as is clear from the title, the various forms of art are treated, without any specification, as an activity of the individual or social mind and thus not only lose their o w n individual character, but are regarded

i. As, for example, in A r m a n d Cuvillier's otherwise excellent Manuel de sociologie, Paris, 1962, 4th ed. 2. Richard T . Lapierre, Sociology, N e w York and L o n d o n , 1946, p . 333. 3. Paris, i960, Vol. II, p. 297. 4. Georges Gurvitch, 'La vocation actuelle de la sociologie', in Cahiers internationaux de sociologie, Paris, 1946, Vol. I, p. 18. 5. 'La sociologie de l'esprit n'a aucune prtention " imprialiste ", elle ne veut pas remplacer la philosophie; mais de plus en plus elle va forcer cette dernire tenir compte de son vis-vis sociologique et de l'uvre qu'il accomplit.'ibid., p . 21. 6. See, for example, Dlerminismes sociaux et libert humaine, Paris, 1955. 7. Jean Duvignaud, Sociologie de l'art, Paris, 1967. This volume testifies, moreover, to an extraordinary ignorance of the relevant literature. In this connexion, see our article in the Klner Zeitschrift fr Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, 1968, Vol, 2, p. 387 et seq.

57

Alphons Silbermann

most questionably in our viewin a kind of uniform light along with m a n y other intellectual activities, despite the evident fact that individual or social intellectual activities cannot be reduced to a c o m m o n denominator, psychologically, sociologically, emotionally, cognitively, temporally or even physiologically. This unfortunate result of a lumping together, which is mainly the product of a system-bound view of society, can be seen very clearly in th article by the sociologist Paul Honigsheimwho has distinguished himself in particular in the sociology of musicpublished in Gottfried Eisermann's Lehrbuch der Soziologie.1 In this article, the sociology of art, the sociology of music and the sociology of literature are treated largely in conjunction, and it must be said that their treatment, as regards both the line of argument and the evidence, oscillates between the social history approach and the religious or symbolic approach. H o w e v e r , Honigsheim's contributionlike certain other studies by him on the subject2is exemplary inasmuch as he dissociates himself from the philosophy-of-art approach, as is m a d e quite clear in his conclusion: 'For w e are not concerned here with the philosophy of art, but with an experiment in the sociology of art, music and literature'.3 T h e sociology of art has also been classified under the speciality k n o w n as the 'sociology of knowledge', which is concerned 'to find out which type of thinking would be practised by m e n at this or that time'.4 This definition or another one which, for our purposes, says rather more clearly that, in Karl M a n n h e i m ' s view, the purpose of the sociology of knowledge is 'to ascertain the correlation between philosophical, intellectual "standpoints" on the one hand, and concrete social "currents" on the other6should appeal to anyone w h o in art only sees thought on the one hand and action on the other, each independent of the other. If w e delve into the writings of M a n n h e i m 8 and others w h o , although not expressly, relate to M a n n h e i m ' s w a y of thinking and sociology of knowledge, 7 w e find at best a quest for a high democratic ideal of culture capable of replacing the humanistic ideal. Lastly, as H . J. Lieber has put it, M a n n h e i m ' s work shows that 'in the central concept of knowledge bound u p with being, a special method of understanding the structure and nature of intellectual life was found'.8 O n
i. Stuttgart, 1958, p. 338 et seq. 2. See, for example, 'Musikformeti und Gesellschaftsformen' in: Die Einheit der Sozialwissenscha/ten, edited by W . Bernsdorf and G . Eisermann, Stuttgart, 1955. 3. ' D e n n nicht u m Kunstphilosophie handelt es sich hier, sondern u m den Versuch einer Soziologie der Kunst, Musik und Literatur.'Paul Honigsheim in: G . Eisermann (ed.), op.cit., P- 372. 4. Paul Kecskemeti in: Introduction to Karl Mannheim, Essays on the Sociology of Knowledge, London, 1952, p. 16. 5. ibid., p. 19. 6. In particular: 'Ideologische und soziologische Interpretation der geistigen Gebilde', in: Gustav Salomon (ed.), Jahrbuch fr Soziologie, Karlsruhe, 1926, Vol. 2, p. 424 et seq. 7. Examples are to be found in Klaus Peter Etzkorn, 'Musical and Social Patterns of Songwriters', Princeton University, 1959 (Ph.D. thesis), p. 234 et seq., and in Hans Norbert Fgen, Die Hauptrichtungen der Literatursoziologie, Bonn, 1964, p. 30 et seq. 8. 'dass im zentralen Begriff der Seinsverbundenheit des Wissens eine besondere Methode des Verstehens von Aufbau und Eigenart des Geisteslebens gefunden wurde'in: Wilhelm Bernsdorf and Friedrich Blow (ed.), Wrterbuch der Soziologie, Stuttgart, 1955, p. 633.

A definition of the sociology of art

5 7

this basis, however, w e find at worst naive attempts which, generally under some heading n o w in vogue, such as 'from the standpoint of the sociology of art', indiscriminately, and above all arbitrarily, mingle sociological, morphological and aesthetic approaches, leading to the absurdity of a theory of society derived from art. Both starting-pointsthe sociology of the mind as well as all the variants of the sociology of knowledgemust inevitably lead to an a priori w a y of thinking incompatible with an empirical approach to the sociology of art. T h e latter's a i m is to proceed from the same basic assumptions as general sociology: observation of the facts, generalizations based on factual investigation, a general interpretative theory. Here it is the factsand not feeling, the metaphysical or even the imaginary, to which the arts can all too easily lead usthat must always be our guiding rule. Neither of these schools of thought would appear to meet these requirements, unless the sociology of knowledge is expanded to cover 'a complex field of research with modern sociological methods and techniques, with a firm and, as far as logic is concerned, clearly defined place within a general theory of knowledge and science'.1 T h e next point to be considered is certainly whether the label 'sociology of culture' can lead to a satisfactory result in regard to the classification of the sociology of art, particularly if w e bear in mind that the term 'culture' in modern sociology has c o m e to embrace not only the theatre, painting, literature and music, but all patterns of behaviour and types of education that are socially acquired and transmitted. Although, by extension, the term 'culture' has, for m a n y approaches, become extremely imprecise and unwieldy, this should not hamper us in our discussion, since no one disputes that the various forms or expressions of art are integral and already defined parts of culture, taken in the narrow or in the broad sense of the term. T h e disadvantage of classifying the sociology of art under this research discipline,2 however, is that the label 'sociology of culture' can very easily lead to a marked emphasis o n the historical aspect, as for example in Pieter Jan B o u m a n ' s work (to mention only one work this kind). 3 This is due to the fact that, w h e n such outstanding thinkers as Alfred W e b e r or A . J. Toynbee, with their historical outlook, study the sociology of culture, they concern themselves not so m u c h with culture in the traditional sense of the term as with cultures, and so this term immediately assumes another meaning in addition to the various meanings already given to it. T h e resulting ambiguity, which is also linguistic in origin, can, as m a y be seen, for instance, from the cultural views of a writer like Andr Malraux, 4 lead to
i. 'zu einem komplexen Forschungsbereich mit modernen soziologischen Methoden und Techniken, mit einem festen und gegenber der Logik klar abgegrenzten Platz in einer generellen Wissens- und Wissenschaftstheorie'.Leopold Rosenmayr, M a x Scheler, 'Karl Mannheim und die Zukunft der Wissenssoziologie', in: Alphons Silbermann (ed.), Militanter Humanismus. Von den Aufgaben der modernen Soziologie, Frankfurt on the Main, 1966, p . 230. 2. See Ren Knig (ed.), Soziologie, Frankfurt on the Main, 1967, p . 159 et seq. 3. Kultur und Gesellschaft der Neuzeit, lten and Freiburg, 1962. 4. Les voix du silence, Paris, 1951; Muse imaginaire de la sculpture mondiale, Paris, 1952, et passim.

572

A l p h o n s Silbermann

considerable confusion and, above all, to non-factual ideological thinking as consistently practised by A . J. Toynbee, following upon the model of Oswald Spengler. A further doubt which has often been expressed is provoked by the study of a n u m b e r of examples of practical sociology of culture as applied to art; in this connexion, w e shall mention only Alfred von Martin's Soziologie der Renaissance,1 Frederic Antal's Florentine Painting and its Social Background," Curt Sachs's The Commonwealth of Art3 and Arnold Hauser's Sozialgeschichte der Kunst und Literatur* These and similar works o n the sociology of culture attempt not only to give individual artistic trends their appropriate place but also to develop such trends, whether in music, literature or the plastic arts, out of their particular context. All these works reflect the effort to break away from the constraints of primitive social history so often misleadingly passed off as sociology of art5and to recognize what was once merely social background as essential to the study of the social existence of the artist and his work. This is certainly to be regarded as progress if w e bear in m i n d that 'all individual adventures are founded in a more complex reality, namely the social reality or "interlaced" reality as it is called by sociology'.6 While not underestimating such views concerning the sociology of culture, the objection to them is 'that the development of sociology as a science depends on a progressive breaking a w a y from this kind of philosophy of history'7 as well as from the past itself, for otherwise the here and n o w as well as the existentially essential tomorrow m a y not find proper expression. It is striking h o w even the sociologically oriented art literature of Englishspeaking countries, in the m a i n , still produces works on the sociology of art in the past.8 Yet surely this cannot be the purpose of social science; for the latter, like the sociology of artif they are to have any right to existhas a twofold task:firstly,to analyse the processes of h u m a n behaviour, especially behavioural patterns and changes; secondly, to define norms in such a w a y as to open u p the possibility of practical action. For this m u c h more far-reaching task, the term 'sociology of culture' (embracing the sociology of art) is far too inadequate, as can be seen also
i. 2. 3. 4. 5. Frankfurt, 1949. London, 1947. London, 1955. Munich, 1947. M a n y examples of this are to be found in writings on literature. A m o n g recent examples of this tendency w e might mention Miklavz Presence, Die Dadaisten in Zrich, Bonn, 1967; Gustav Sichelschmidt, Hedwig Courths-Mahler, Eine literatursoziologische Studie, Bonn, 1967, etc. 6. 'toutes les aventures individuelles se fondent dans une ralit plus complexe, celle du social, une ralit, "entrecroise", c o m m e dit la sociologie'.Fernand Braudel, 'Les responsabilits de l'histoire', in: Cahiers internationaux de sociologie, Paris, 1951, Vol. X , p. 9. 7. 'Das die Entwicklung der Soziologie als Wissenschaft abhngig ist von einer immer tiefer reichenden Trennung von dieser Art Geschichtsphilosophie', Ren Knig (ed.), op. cit., p. 160. 8. See, for example, Wilfred Meller's, Music and Society, N e w York, 1950, and Diana Spearm a n n , The Novel and Society, London, 1966.

A definition of the sociology of art

573

from the fact the sociology of culture has been described elsewhere as the science concerning the social aspect of cultural life',1 a view which, under the influence of J. M . G u y a u ' s well-known work L'art du point de vue sociologique? is very frequently expressed. Its self-imposed limitation must always take the sociology of culture, as still represented after Wilhelm Dilthey by scholars such as H a n s Freyer, 3 Arnold Gehlen, 4 Marcel Belvianes,5 Pierre Francastel,6 and others, back to w h a t m a y rightly be called the social history of art, but which all too often is presented under the misleading a n d false guise of sociology of art. If, for instance, w e were to give the sociology of music such a vague a n d scientifically unstable definition as 'the theory of the relationship between music and society'7 the w o r d 'relationship' itself would imply that this branch of the sociology of art is something m o r e than a sociology of culture, that its scope extends m u c h further, even beyond culturealmost incorporating itand is to be treated at least as a sociology of cultural spheres of influence (Kulturwirkekreissoziologie). Since 'objective creations of the m i n d can never be opposed to w h a t happens in society, but only be seen in a functional relation with it in particular cultural spheres of influence',8 n o modern-thinking social scientist today can overlook the fact9 that the arts, like economics, law, religion, the State, etc., are ultimately expressions of culture and society, as is already clear from the fact that they can be viewed from such different angles as symbolic representation, communication processes or, in the last analysis, social processes. All thinking a n d research o n the sociology of artas Roger Clausse shows elsewhere in this issueinevitably leads to the spheres of influence of art and must embrace them all. That is w h y w e speak of a sociology of the cultural spheres of influence, though w e fully realize that it is an extremely clumsy term. If w e use the term it is not only because w e have not been able to find a better one, but especially because its precision enables us to see in the sociology of art something m o r e than just a study of the social history of the arts or of sociological aesthetics. W e must n o w turn our attention to the already m u c h apostrophized social history of art (or of the arts) and its relationship to the sociology of art,
i. 'die Wissenschaft von der Gesellungsseite des Kulturlebens', K . A . Fischer, Kultur und Gesellung, Cologne, 1951, p . 15. 2. Paris, 1930, 15th ed. 3. For example, Theorie des gegenwrtigen Zeitalters, Stuttgart, 1955. 4. Zeit-Bilder, Zur Soziologie und sthetik der modernen Malerei, Frankfurt on the Main, i960. 5. Sociologie de la musique, Paris, 1951. 6. Art et technique, Paris, 1956. 7. 'die Lehre v o m Zusammenhang zwischen Musik und Gesellschaft'.Hans F.ngel, Musik und Gesellschaft, Berlin, i960, p . 9. 8. 'die objektiven geistigen Gebilde d e m sozialen Geschehen niemals entgegengesetzt, sondern nur in Kulturwirkekreisen in einem funktionalen Zusammenhang mit ihm gesehen werden (knnen), Ren Knig (ed.), op. cit., p. 160. 9. See, for example, Harry C . Bredemeier and Richard M . Stephenson, The Analysis of Social Systems, N e w York, 1962, chapter 1, and David C . McLelland, The Achieving Society, N e w York, 1961.

574

Alphons Silbermann

particularly since the social history of art is often presented and defended especially by those w h o are not always well informedas one, if not indeed the only, valid trend in the sociology of art. It must be stressed in this connexion that the significance of the social history of art as such is just as incontestable as the coexistence and mutual enrichment of history and sociology. W e must therefore d e m u r w h e n w e hear so m a n y w h o are competent in this subject refer to themselves as art sociologists, whereas in actual fact they are sociologists of history. Generally, they attempt to approach the social aspect of the history of art, that is the social aspect of the past, only from a n historical and not at all from a sociological standpoint, and could thus at best present themselves and enrich the science as cultural historians, but not as art sociologists. T h e distinction w e have submitted m a y atfirstsight seem extremely dogmatic, yet it is not so if w e consider carefully where the claim that the social history of art represents the sociology of art has led in the course of the development of the empirical sociology of art. First of all, social historians are responsible for the fact that the confounding of the words 'social' and 'sociological'so easy to confuse owing to their linguistic similarity has deepened. Strangely enough, it is in French literature that this confusion is most c o m m o n , though it is also to be found in G e r m a n literature, despite the fact that it has frequently been pointed out that the term fait social (social fact), c o m m o n l y used in literature since Durkheim, can m e a n either 'sociological state of affairs', 'social fact' or even 'social p h e n o m e n o n ' , according to the context.1 But apart from this quite excusable ignorance, which is to be found even in the writings of specialists,2 there is a growing tendency a m o n g writers on social history to use expressions like 'the sociological stress', 'the sociological question', or 'the sociological arguments' in connexion with art, artists and their public, whenever suitable social explanations are lacking or whenever something that cannot be defined is to be left in mid-air. H e r e there is n o trace of any real sociological knowledge at all. Reference is m a d e to historical examples; the class struggle and classless music are discussed; reality and ideology are indiscriminately mixed u p in literary analyses and,finally,under the cover of art, shallow propaganda is m a d e for some predetermined direction which should never constitute the purpose of sociology. A serious and valid social history of art, such as has been pursued for some time past, very often focuses on the literary, musical or visual phenom e n o n in its socialized form. Artistic events are not merely catalogued, but are presented and analysed in their interdependent relationship with general events and major cultural developments, thereby, as a result of m o d e r n knowledge, showing h o w specific cultural p h e n o m e n a have become artistic criteria that, as abstractions, could later serve as the basis
i. For a full discussion, see Ren Knig's introduction to the new German edition of Emil Durkheim's Die Regeln der soziologischen Methode, Neuwied, 1961, p. 38 et seq. 2. For example, Jean Duvignaud makes no mention of the distinction in his booklet on Durkheim (Paris, 1955).

A definition of the sociology of art

575

for certain modern m o d e s of thought in art.1 But even here, where the a i m is to discover regularities, there are schools of thought which, though they claim to be pursuing the sociology of art, in fact support an incorrect conception of this field. W h a t w e would reproach them with is that they propound hypotheses derived from personal grudges and thus m a k e statements such as 'Music as a social function is a kind of swindle, a fraudulent promise of happiness that takes the place of happiness itself'.2 W o r s e still, they stick to these culturally pessimistic assumptions and completely disregard social roles, social stratification and even social changes, which any kind of sociological study must take into account and recognize. M a n y of these schools of thought submit that the entire historical development of art should be investigated from the standpoint of sociability which, they preposterously claim, makes it possible to deduce the economic and social conditions of entire communities o n the basis of their artistic production. There are m a n y examples which show h o w such thinking has led to the lumping together of historical social theory, social ethics, social pedagogics, epistemological considerations a n d concepts derived from economic history, to the exclusion of all sociological principles and methods, with the result that social history is presented in the guise of sociology of art and tendentious ideas take precedence over realities. T h e authentic art sociologist, however, must insist on realities; he must, to some extent, be a positivist or an undaunted pragmatist, just as the historian is rightly expected to be. This also applies to the history of art. If w e take, for instance, such concepts as group, institution, art policy, the economics of art, attitudes, etc., w e see that they are all sociological facts that can be examined equally from the standpoint of the sociologist as from that of the historian.3 A s soon as w e realize that the research worker a n d the observer must deal with two different kinds of historical facts, w e possess a key for determining the limits, and a further means of defining the position of the sociology of art. T h u s social history is concerned with those facts which stand in contrast with the social condition, possessing n o regular connexion or correlation with it, because they stem from the originality of great m e n . Their force and progress are neither constant nor regular. T h e sociology of art, o n the other hand, as a sociology concerned with cultural spheres of influence, inquires into those historical facts which are correlated to one another and to the progress of society. T h e y adapt themselves and develop in accordance with forces that it is one of the tasks of the sociology of art to analyse and describe. Although, at this stage, w e are still far from having defined a n d circumscribed the whole content of the sociology of art, it is precisely here
i. A n outstanding recent example of this is Robert Minder's Dichter in der Gesellschaft, Frankfurt on the Main, 1966. 2. 'Musik als soziale Funktion ist d e m N e p p verwandt, schwindelhaftes Versprechen von Glck, das anstelle des Glcks selber sich installiert'.Theodor \ V . Adorno, Einleitung in die Musiksoziologie, Frankfurt on the Main, 1962, p . 56. 3. Cf. Fernand Braudel, 'Histoire et sociologie' in: Georges Gurvitch (ed.). Trait de sociologie, Paris, i960, vol. I, page 83 et seq.

576

Alphons Silbermann

that a number of competent sociologists take their starting-point. O n e of the first to do so, as far as socio-musical p h e n o m e n a are concerned, was Georg Simmel, in an almost u n k n o w n work which appeared in 1887 in the Zeitschriftfr Vlkerpsychologie (Vol. 13) under the title of'Psychologische und ethnologische Studien ber Musik'. Briefly, Simmel regards music as an expression of the substance of a society, that is, as an aspect of the social relations between the individuals themselves and as an aspect of the relations between the latter and the patterns of communication that maintain, structure and restructure these relations.1 A n art form, in this case music, is thus placed in the context of social relations and in the centre of the communication contentan undertaking which, with increasing refinements, can be traced right u p to present-day trends in the sociology of art. Before going further into this matter, however, w e must mention Pitirim A . Sorokin's vast work Social and Cultural Dynamics,2 since here too, inter alia, an attempt is m a d e to examine forms and expressions of art in relation to other aspects of the social situation. In chapter 12 of this work, under the title of 'Fluctuation of Ideational, Sensate, and Mixed Forms of Music', and then in chapter 40 of his comprehensive study Society, Culture and Personality,3 under the title of 'Growth, Fluctuation, and Decline of M a i n Forms of Fine Arts', Sorokin considers the definition of various forms of art andof special interest to us herevariations in time and space in the m a i n styles of art. While Sorokin points out that what he is writing about is not the history of cultures but the sociology of their evolution,4 he stresses in particular the importance of the social environment in the creative process and the interdependence of social processes and forms of art. Since Sorokin's main aim is to incorporate theoretically in his system of general sociology the four main types of art p h e n o m e n a he defined (sensate, ideational, idealistic, eclectic)which are by n o m e a n s universally recognized together with their variations, it would lead us too far to analyse this system here. Suffice it to say that Klaus Peter Etzkorn is right w h e n he affirms that ' W i t h Sorokin's systematic concern with music, a landmark in the sociological study of music has been reached', because 'Sorokin concerns himself with the problems of analyses of the cultural and social integration of social system'.6 T h e path followed by the sociology of art since Simmel, Sorokin and others has led to the incorporation of knowledge relating to art in the context of social relations, that is, has brought it m o r e and more within the purview of sociology. O w i n g to this course of development which led from the essence of art and from its i m m a n e n t significance to the social context, and which took place neither inversely nor along parallel lines, and also

1. For a detailed analysis of Simmcl's study, see K . Peter Etzkorn, 'Georg Simmel and the Sociology of Music, in: Social Forces, 1964, N o . 43, p. 101 et seq. 2. N e w York, 1937, 1941, 4 vol. 3. N e w York, 1962, new edition. 4. Social and Cultural Dynamics, p. 9-10. 5. 'Musical and Social Patterns of Songwriters', op. cit., p. 251.

A definition of the sociology of art

577

owing to the philosophical stress characteristic of the writings ofto mention only a few examplesGeorg Lukcs and Lucien G o l d m a n n , Walter Benjamin and Theodor W . Adorno, Etienne Souriau, Arnold Gehlen and Jean Cassou,1 these thinkers saw a discrepancy between art and personality on the one hand, and between art consumption and the existing, constantly changing society on the other. O n c e this discrepancy had been recognized, it was felt necessary to overcome it; in most cases this is done through a return to sociology as social criticism and to cultural criticism, of which it can safely be affirmed that it is inspired by certain 'prophets of yesterday',2 including a m o n g others, Friedrich Hegel, Gustave L e B o n , Karl M a r x , Ortega y Gasset and Sigmund Freud. However, in order to attain the social context, without going beyond it, this trend in the sociology of art found itself compelled to abandon a pure sociological methodology close to reality and free of value judgements. There was a return to the methods of philosophical thought and of verification in order to study and explain the work of art in terms of cultural critique.3 These schools of thought did not, however, overlook the fact that the life of the work of art lies in its effect, in so far as this emanates from its very essence; they were therefore obliged to return to an approach aimed at a study of the essential character of the work of art, particularly as the m a i n task of such sociology consists, alongside of and parallel to cultural criticism, in discovering norms to determine the essential nature of the work of art and its effects. A sociologist can approve this trend in so far as it is the task of philosophical thought to determine, dogmatically or critically, psychologically or sociologically, at what point a creative work (a) becomes art, a n d (b) as such acquires permanent existence. W h a t w e are stressing here, and what has already been pointed out by m a n y distinguished sociologists, is that sociology and philosophy are not hostile brothers; that social philosophy for w e are n o w concerned with this step towards recognition in the sociology of artmust exercise its critical powers and empirical sociology must m a k e use of what it has to offer. That this is also the case in the sociology of art can be seen from the fact that, in connexion with the point just mentioned, it is precisely a philosopher, John D e w e y , w h o must be credited with having placed the constellation of concepts concerning the 'inherent significance of the work of art' in the centre of his reflections on the subject, especially in his book Art as Experience.* In doing so, he turned away, like m a n y others after him, 5 from what m a y roughly be described as a concept

i. For example, Georg Lukcs, Die Theorie des Romans, Berlin, 1920; Lucien Goldmann, Pour une sociologie du roman, Paris, 1964; Walter Benjamin, Illuminationen, Frankfurt on the Main, 1955; Theodor W . Adorno, Philosophie der neuen Musik, Tbingen, 1949; Etienne Souriau, Les deux cent mille situations dramatiques, Paris, r95o; Arnold Gehlen, ZeitBilder . . ., op. cit.; Jean Cassou, Situation de l'art moderne, Paris, 1950. 2. Prophets of Yesterday, title of a book b y Gerhard Masur, N e w York, 1961. 3. See our Study, 'Literaturphilosophie, soziologische Literaturaesthetik oder Literatursoziologie', in: Klner Zeitschrift fr Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, 1966, Vol. I, p. 139 et seq. 4. N e w York, 1934. 5. For example, Gregor Paulson, Die soziale Dimension der Kunst, Bern, 1955.

57

A l p h o n s Silbermann

of art according to which it is for society to discover the distinctive features of the aesthetic object, irrespective of the aesthetic experience through meditation on the object itself. A precise distinction between mere perception on the one hand and reaction on the other brings us close to the sociological viewpoint. For, if w h a t is social can exist only in and through c o m m u n i c a tion expressed in reactions, communication is the foundation of the work of art and not just an accessory or by-product. In other words, art and endeavour, art and nature, but above all art and every normal h u m a n experience are inseparable from one another. In practical terms, this means that, in the sociological analysis of artists and their works, 1 a careful distinction isfirstd r a w n between inherited instinctive talents, the nature of a creative artist and the socio-cultural unfolding of his personality, or, in other words, what is acquired. This raises the question which of the two is to be regarded as the predominant element. While D e w e y admitted that, from the biological standpoint, instinct is definitely paramount, although from the sociological standpoint 'habits' occupy the foreground and relegate instinct to a subordinate position 'in behaviour the original is what is acquired', it is claimedthe sociophilosophical approach to the sociology of art rejects communication a priori. T o illustrate, let us turn to Theodor W . Adorno w h o writes, for example, that the prime purpose of the sociology of music is 'the social deciphering of music itself'.2 Music itself must first 'burst asunder'. At the same time as communication is dismissed, however, the all-pervasiveness of the acquired is cast aside. This, to us, contradictory line of thought is due to the fact that, although, as with D e w e y , the inherent significance of the work of art, or as with Lucien G o l d m a n n and others holding similar views, the 'genetic structuralism' (structuralisme gntique) of the work of art (which largely comes to the same thing), forms the centre of reflection, the predominant view is the one in accordance with which art obeys the laws of h u m a n consciousness. T h u s , instinct, or the mindboth the m i n d 'in itself and the m i n d 'for itself-again becomes paramount. W h e n it is said that 'the higher the level of music, the m o r e possible and adequate is its sociological interpretation',3 it is assumed,firstly,in a m a n n e r that is contradictory from the empiricist's standpoint, that the p h e n o m e n a 'music', 'literature' and 'painting', in short the p h e n o m e n o n 'art', which as such does not represent any social process, can be interpreted sociologically and, secondly,

i. W e would refer to the following examples: Theodor W . Adorno, Gustav Mahler, Frankfurt on the Main, i960; Klaus Lankheit, Florentinische Barockplastik, Munich, 1962; Frederick Antal, Hogarth und seine Stellung in der europischen Kunst, Dresden, 1966; Flix Brun, 'Pour une interprtation sociologique du roman picaresque', in: Littrature et socit, Brussels, 1967; Alphons Silbermann, Introduction une sociologie de la musique, Paris, 1955; Leo Lowenthal, Literature and the Image of Man, Boston, 1957. 2. 'Die gesellschaftliche Dechiffrierung von Musik selbst, Ideen zur Musiksoziologie', in: Schweizer Monatshefte, Zrich, November 1958, p . 681. 3. 'Die soziologische Interpretation von Musik ist u m so adaequater moeglich, je hher die Musik rangiert.'ibid., p . 690.

A definition of the sociology of art

579

that a desired sociological interpretation can be linked with a potent value judgement; thirdly, as a concession to the ' m i n d ' in all its glory, an approach is adopted which primarily analyses a n d recognizes the work of art to the exclusion of factors that have influenced it and to the exclusion of its 'emanations'. Each of these two spheres of influence, one leading to the work of art and the other leading a w a y from it, is, of course, embraced with Adorno, for example, it is always capitalist-bourgeois society and with G o l d m a n n it is Jansenism 1 and Marxist societythough not as constantly changing social processes but rather as static labels transformed into artifacts. This is understandable if w e accept the fact that such schools of thought are in all honesty more concerned with transforming the work of art into a lesson about the ultimate matters concerning m a n and society than with helping the i m m a n e n t to be born. But if it is remembered that, after all, society can hardly be deduced from art, nor can it be determined ex cathedra what is to occupy a higher rank, and bearing in m i n d also that art p h e n o m e n a are often not observable because they disappear in space and are limited in time, or, to put it another w a y , that only the experience of art, i.e., experience of the theatre, literature, music, painting or sculpture, is a tangible and observable factor2 then w e begin to reflect. Thus, the task of the sociology of music for instance, can be s u m m e d u p as follows: 'Collection of all social facts relevant to the practice of music, classification of these facts according to their importance for the practice of music and the understanding of all the factors that determine changes in practice of music and the understanding of all the factors that determine changes in practice.'3 This obvious reference to Durkheim's fait social is combined, if not always expressly, with recourse to M a x Weber's line of reasoning. W e have in mind mainly Weber's fragmentary study Die rationelen und soziologischen Grundlagen der Musik, which though it is often quoted in connexion with studies on the sociology of artbecause of its significance, it has also strongly influenced the empirical sociology of artis nevertheless seldom understood in all its essence and implications.4 While Weber's study is devoted largely to pure reflection o n particular aspects of the increasing rationalization in the cultural fields and therefore adopts a formal approach, that is not all. W e b e r , like so m a n y art sociologists since
i. See his main work, Le dieu cach, Paris, 1955. 2. With regard to the problems concerning the experience of art as a social factor, see Alphons Silbermann's The Sociology of Music, London, 1963, and 'Theater und Gesellschaft' in: Martin Huerlimann (ed.), Das Atlantisbuch des Theaters, Zrich, 1966, p . 387 et seq., as well as the same author's article, 'Kunst', in: R e n Knig (ed.), op. cit., p . 164 et seq. 3. ' S a m m l u n g aller fr die musikalische Praxis relevanten gesellschaftlichen Tatbestnde, Ordnung dieser Tatbestnde nach ihrer Bedeutung fr die musikalische Praxis und Erfassung der fr die Vernderung der Praxis entscheidenden Tatbestnde'.Kurt Blaukopf, in: W . Bernsdorf and F . Blow (eds.), op. cit., p . 342. 4. The studyfirstappeared in Munich in 1921 and has since been published in the appendix to the second half-volume of the Grundriss der Sozialkonomik, III, in the section entitled 'Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft', Tbingen, 1925, 2nd ed. A n English editionThe Rational and Social Foundations of Musicprepared by D o n Martindale, Johannes Riedel and Gertrude Neuwirth, w a s published in 1958, Carbondale.

58o

Alphons Silbermann

his time, is also interested in comparing the p h e n o m e n a of musical or even general artistic behaviour of the past and those of today, so as to bring out the social character of music or art. It cannot therefore be maintained that 'in M a x Weber's study, which is extremely brilliant, both as regards individual points and his exposition as a whole, one thing unfortunately is almost misleading: his remarks concerning the sociological foundations of music', 1 for even the socio-economic factor is touched o n in the last part of the treatise.2 It is precisely because W e b e r , in the course of his study, inquires into the opposition between certain principles relating to the theory of music, between expediency a n d aesthetic requirements, a n d between the emotional and the rational in music, i.e., it is precisely because he thus shows that in musicand is also true of the other forms of art social behaviour never takes exclusively one direction or another that (unlike so m a n y art sociologists) he departs from absolute definitions of value. H e follows the s a m e path taken before h i m by George Simmel and opens the w a y which leads directly to the behaviour of socio-musical groups, to which J o h n H . Mller again referred recently w h e n distinguishing in this connexion between formalistic, institutional, hermeneutic and programmatic music. 3 T h e fact that W e b e r stuck to a strictly rational, that is logical or mathematical and scientific form of analysis, in order to give a sociological picturenever completed however; the fact that nowhere did he indulge in a n emotional or a n artistic-aesthetic line of argument, despite the quality of art and especially of music, which leads so easily to the emotional; and lastly, the fact that nowhere did he try to steep the subject of music or art in philosophical considerations, all m a k e this fragment a model for any study of the sociology of art, both as regards methodology and epistemology.4 O n n o occasion did W e b e r venture into the depths of 'understanding' (verstehend) investigation, but tried to find a happy m e d i u m between the scientific-sociological approach providing causal explanations and the 'understanding' and individualizing approach. In this connexion, W e b e r regarded historicism as an a priori assumption to be handled sceptically. Whenever possible, he regarded it as a methodological principle for the scientific writing of history, but not as an existential proposition. This, however, is still the guiding principle followed b y the science of art, even if it allegedly seeks to acquire a sociological orientation b y assuming either a socio-psychological garb or by directing its attention to comparative investigations and investigations relating to the psychology of art. Just as it is clear that, in these attempts at extension, the chief emphasis
i. 'an der im einzelnen wie im ganzen beraus geistreichen Schrift M a x Webers leider eins nahezu irrefhrend (ist): das Wort von den soziologischen Grundlagen der Musik'.Herm a n n Matzke, Musikkonomik und Musikpolitik, Breslau, 1927, p. 8. 2. See M a x Weber, op. cit., p. 862. (The quotation is from the text in: Wirtscliaft und Gesellschaft, Tbingen, 1925, 2nd ed.) 3. ' A Sociological Approach to Musical Behaviour', in: Ethnomnsicology, 1963, Vol. VII, N o . 3. 4. For a detailed analysis of Weber's study see our article ' M a x Webers musikalischer Exkurs', in: Special issue 7 of the Klner Zeitschrift fr Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, 1963, p. 448 et seq.

A definition of the sociology of art

581

is o n the historical, it is equally clear that the science of art in general will still not fully recognize that causal, historical thinkingthinking in terms of cause and effect, thinking in terms of eternal laws of nature, which is extremely useful for ordinary cataloguing workhas been superseded in so far as the weaknesses of these so-called 'eternal laws of nature' have long since been proven. Certain art scholars have undoubtedly recognized this, and so a sociological approach has been developed that has led to a sociological system of aesthetics, outstanding representatives of which are Charles Lalo, R a y m o n d Bayer and T h o m a s M u n r o . 1 T h e y attempted to introduce order into the study of the sociology of art in so far as a distinction was m a d e , as it were, between a 'direct' and an 'indirect' w a y of incorporating sociology in the history of art. Here 'direct' m e a n s the introduction and elaboration of a sociological theme in the sphere of the history of art, and 'indirect' the application of sociological criteria and methods of interrogation to the w o r k of art and to particular periods in the history of art. This distinction clearly shows the sociology of art as an 'auxiliary science', for, in the last analysis, nothing more is involved than sociological interrogation of the w o r k of art as such. This is the tendency of m a n y writings on the sociology of art, for they are constantly dealing with the aesthetics of the work of art, but n o longer as in the past, n o longer as in the writings of Vischer, Schelling, Wlfflin or Croce, whose interest was only in the individual; today, the community is also taken into account. Thus, even in the field of art, it was suddenly discovered that there existed an individu socialis (socialized individual), to use Lalo's expression, an individual w h o , long before the creation of the work of art, possesses a collective spirit with which he expresses himself and through which he addresses himself to the recipient groups. It w a s further discovered through this sociological-aesthetic approach to the work of art that artistic evolution and revolution are only the synthesis of isolated and independent attempts by numerous predecessors and that not everything was, so to speak, miraculously created from nothing b y a stroke of genius. Whether these 'discoveries' represent a step forward, making it necessary to call o n sociology, is a question w e should prefer not to discuss here. In this connexion, w e must draw attention to the one-sided view of the science of art according to which the production-consumption relationship is considered almost exclusively from the standpoint of production, from the standpoint of the individual. In reply to this criticism, it is said that there is n o intention whatsoever of inverting the social pyramid by devoting exclusive attention to the personality of the poet, composer or painter, as can be seen from the pursuit of w h a t is today k n o w n as social background researchan approach that undoubtedly represents one of the trends in the sociology of art. Indeed, remarkable w o r k has

1. Charles Lalo, Notions d'esthtique, Paris, 1948; R a y m o n d Bayer, Trait d'esthtique, Paris, 1948; Thomas Munro, Towards Science in Aesthetics, N e w York, 1956.

52

A l p h o n s Silbermann

been done a n d is still being d o n e in this field. W i t h the knowledge gained through psychology, psychoanalysis, statistics a n d a system of sociological aesthetics based o n Anthropologie structurale,1 developed b y G . Lvi-Strauss, research in depth w a s initiated, which, b y its scientific precision, has certainly achieved notable results but, as before, the m a i n emphasis is o n the producer, the product a n d the production process. In extreme cases, uncertainties arise as a result of this s o m e w h a t one-sided approach, with the sociology of art being referred to as a sociologie de l'imaginaire, a sociologie de la cration artistique, or a sociologie de l'art,2 just because those concerned are unwilling or unable to pay attention to all the multifarious m e m b e r s of the 'art-society', apart, of course, from the producers. T h e empirical art sociologist has never h a d a n y difficulty in recognizing that in all periodsand today m o r e than everart consumers form a n integral part of the world of art. In this connexion, J o h n H . Mller a p p o sitely writes that, in such studies, 'society is conceived as essentially a totalitarian unity; that all aspects of society are here manifestations of a primal spirit to w h i c h source they all converge'. 3 Undoubtedly bearing in m i n d works that seek to approach the 'soul of culture' (Kulturseele) b y m e a n s of the social background a n d thereby equate o n e with the other, Mller goes o n to say: 'This unitarian view leads to a desperate reliance o n the trivial parallelisms which speckle the whole of musicological history at the present time. N o social science, in whose province this problem actually falls, would ever sanction those overtly metaphysical fabrications of the organic theory w h i c h lie at the base of present musicological reasonings.' Far from reproaching the contemporary science of music or art with 'intellectual navet', Mller advocates 'the elimination of the survivals w h i c h clutter u p the current revisionary trends'.* A t this point w e can definitely assert that it is the spark produced b y the tension arising from contrasts that gives the w o r k of art its real life. This is a truism for m o d e r n art sociology, since with art or the arts it is confronted with a social p h e n o m e n o n that manifests itself as a social process, as a social activity, a n d consequently needs t w o partners: a giver a n d a receiver. Putting it in sociological terms, this process needs a producing a n d a consuming group within the 'art-society', w h i c h , whether through group contact, group conflict, group dynamics, group transformation, etc., c o m e into touch with each other. A n d this not necessarily as cause a n d effect only, but in a relationship of interdependence, interrelation a n d interaction relationships w h o s e ramifications, in so far as the producer groups are concerned, not only reveal n e w aspects, but also accord the consumer groups the importance d u e to t h e m as recipients a n d influencers of artistic creation. Let it not b e supposed that this relationship is overlooked, for as a n
i. Paris, 1958. 2. As, for example, by Jean Duvignaud in his Sociologie de l'art, op. cit. 3. 'Baroqueis it D a t u m , Hypothesis, or Tautology?', in: The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, June 1954, Vol. XII, N o . 4, p. 437. 4. ibid.

A definition of the sociology of art

583

indication of the interest taken in the consumers, w e can observe not only the continually renewed efforts to define the meaning and nature of art or the arts, but also the continually growing volume of works and commentaries which are addressed to the public and which, in scientific or popular terms, attempt to c o m m e n t o n , explain and m a k e different branches of the arts more accessible to the consumer groups. Qualified and unqualified persons here c o m m o n l y offer what they themselves k n o w about the arts, creators of art and perhaps also their interpreters, overlooking the fact that intimacy with art also makes it necessary to perceive the spectators, listeners or readers in their social structures, functions and attitudes, so that what the sociology of art is so intent o n studying, namely the experience of art, m a y c o m e about. For it is not the vague concepts 'art', 'painting', 'music', 'literature', etc., that are in the centre of the artistic life: it is characterized by the experience of art. It is this meetingresulting from conflict or contactbetween the producer and the consumer, these social processes and these social actions which concretize and assume a definite shape. A r o u n d them the art groups assemble; they alone, in accordance with the methods of empirical sociology, m a y and can, as sociological facts, be the centre and starting-point of observation and research. This finding and this requirement are by n o means peculiar to the methods used in the sociology of art. T h e y have long been acknowledged by all those w h o , either through a sufficiently widelybased analysis of form, through the arousing of a feeling for form, or through recognition of style, are striving to give expression to the living forces of art, i.e., its social action. Unfortunately, owing to the lack of sufficient sociological knowledge a n d over-emphasis on vague aestheticism, these and similar efforts still have limitations whenever they m o v e away from people, or at any rate, whenever social relations cannot play any role. It is on m a n , however, in his socio-artistic being, that the art sociologist focuses. While m a n remains a means for a n antiquated science and pseudosociology of art, he is the end in himself for the empirical sociology of art. In short, the spheres of influence of the arts must in all circumstances be seen in the light of the relationships of the individual or of the group, as shown in the various articles in this issue. H o w e v e r , w e should like to stress once again that there is only one thing that can help to establish these relationships, namely the experience of art, and this fact must be acknowledged, even if it m a y be considered to be self-evident, banal or trivial. Only the experience of art can create cultural spheres of influence, can be active and social. Only the experience of art can, as a social fact, be the starting-point and central hinge of the sociology of art ; for, as a fact, it can, to begin with, be established, defined and observed with the greatest precision through three fundamental social determinants: nature, variability and dependence. 1 1. For a more detailed discussion of this point see Alphons Silbermann, Wovon lebt die Musik Die Prinzipien der Musiksoziologie, Regensburg, 1957, chapter 3; Erwin Walker; Das musikalische Erlebnis und seine Entwicklung, Gttingen, 1927; Bruce Allsopp, The Future of the Arts, London, 1959.

584

Alphons Silbermann

O n c e this perfectly simple and by no m e a n s novel fact is realized, a direct connexion m a y be established between knowledge about art and knowledge about society. T h e experience of art n o w becomes the central point of study, and the aim of the empirical approach to the sociology of art is to apprehend the experience, i.e., actually to grasp it both in its socially organizing and disorganizing effect, its beneficial or functional andfor the individual or societypernicious or dysfunctional ramifications, and also to shed light on the imponderables surrounding it. H e n c e , studies of the sociology of art m a y just as often be a part of the sociology of leisure or the sociology of popular culture, the sociology of mass communications or ethnosociology, to mention only a few domains. Consequently, it is already clear that, in analyses of the sociology of art, apart from a clearly recognizable distinction between structural a n d functional elements, the latter must be recognized as taking place at two differentiated levels. O n the one hand, there are the aesthetic functions, through which producer and consumer, b y w a y of the artistic material and by w a y of the form and content, are brought together and, on the other hand, there are the social functions which establish the relationships between persons, ideas, cultural standards or patterns of behaviour, in regard to which aesthetic functions also play a role, though by no means a central one. If this distinction is recognized a n d also taken into consideration, whatever be the socio-artistic p h e n o m e n a concerned, then nothing sociological, nothing socially relevant or irrelevant will be tacked on to art m o r e or less hypothetically according to the w h i m of the observer. O n the contrary since the purpose of empirical sociology of art is neither to replace nor to complete, since it tries to avoid imperialist temptations, it refrains from formulating artistic standards and values. For the purpose of the study of the social ramifications of art is not to explain the nature and essence of the arts themselves. N o n e of the theoretical or practical studies of the sociology of literature,1 none of the similar studies of the sociology of music; 2 none of the mass communication studies dealing with the arts;3 none of the studies of the

1. For example, Leo Lowenthal, Literature, Popular Culture, and Society, Englewood Cliffs, 1961; Roy Pascal, Design and Truth in Autobiography, London, i960; Csar Grafa, Bohemian versus Bourgeois, N e w York, 1964; Walter Nutz, Der Trivialroman, Cologne and Opladen, 1962; Robert Escarpit, La rvolution du livre, Paris, 1965. 2. For example, Dennison J. Nash, 'Challenge and Response in the American Composer's Career', in: The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, September 1955, p. 116 et seq; M a x Caplan, Foundations and Frontiers of Music Education, New York, 1966; John H . Mller, The American Symphony Orchestra, Bloomington, 1951, and Fragen des musikalischen Geschmacks, Cologne and Opladen, 1963; Friedrich Klausmeier, Jugend und Musik im technischen Zeitalter, Bonn, 1963; Alphons Silbermann, La musique, la radio et l'auditeur, Paris, 1954. 3. For example, Duncan MacDougald, 'The Popular Music Industry', in: Paul F. Lazarsfeld and Frank N . Stanton (eds.), Radio Research 1941, N e w York, 1941, p. 65 et seq.; Wilbur Schramm, The Impact of Educational Television, Urbana, i960; Stuart Hall and Paddy Whannel, The Popular Arts, London, 1964; Joffre Dumazedier and Aline Ripert, Loisir et culture, Paris, 1966.

A definition of the sociology of art

585

sociology of the theatre;1 none of the sociological studies concerned with the fine arts2none of these or other similar studies devoted purely to the sociology of art, w e repeat, can replace the psychology of art, the history of art or even the theory of art. T h e y all steer clear of these disciplines, which are of n o interest to and are foreign to, sociology, as m a y be seen, for example, from the fact that the sociology of literature is not concerned with the study of semantics or with defining literature in terms of its nature and essence. T h e sociology of art will interveneand w e deliberately use the word 'intervene'only if observations indicate that the relationship between the ideal and the real are being confused; that is, if in writings allegedly on the subject of the sociology of art, but which have an exclusively politicoideological hue, leaning to the extreme right or the extreme left, historical facts are so over-spiritualized that the effects of reality vis--vis ideas are negitv ted and the ideas arefinallyrepresented as facts. W h o e v e r wishes to study the sociology of art must start from objective and impartial premisses and study the facts impartially. These facts constitute the raw material of the sociology of art, but are not in themselves its substance. T h e raw material mustfirstbe processed, analysed according to sociological method and reduced to abstractions; only then can laws be formulated and tested. Let us s u m u p , so as to have a clear idea of the present-day aims of a m o d e r n sociology of art. It starts from the assumption that music, literature, the theatre, painting and the w a y in which each is experienced together form a continuous social process, involving interaction between the artist and his socio-cultural environment and resulting in the creation of a work of some kind or other, which is in turn received b y the socio-cultural environs ent and reacts u p o n it. This process of reception and reaction m a y be described as [follows. O n the one hand, the work makes a certain impression on certain social groups of varying size, in the course of which the reactions of these groups determine the reputation of the work and its position within the cultural context as a whole. O n the other hand, reception and reaction appear w h e n they exert a certain influence o n the artist and to some extent determine and regulate his creative activity. This conception of the art process, which forms the basis of everyfieldof study of the sociology of art, illustrates the considerable extent to which the interaction of individuals, groups and institutions is involved and h o w this fundamental starting-point from m a n leads back to m a n . B y departing
1. For example, Georges Gurvitch, 'Sociologie du thtre', in: Les lettres nouvelles, Paris February 1956, p. 196 et seq.; Martin Holmes, Shakespeare's Public, London, i960; Raymond Ravar and Paul Andrieu, Le spectateur au thtre, Brussels, 1964; Alphons Silbermann, 'Theater und Gesellschaft', op. cit.; Adolf Beiss, Das Drama als soziologisches Phnomen, Brunswick, 1954. 2. For example, Barnard S. Myers, Problems of the Younger American Artist, N e w York, 1957; Bruce A . Watson, Kunst, Knstler und soziale Kontrolle, Cologne and Opladen, 1961; Bernard Rosenberg and Norris Fliegel, The Vanguard Artist, Chicago, 1965; Pierre Bourdieu and Alain Darbel, L'amour de l'art Paris, 1966; Willi Bongard, Kunst und Kommerz, Oldenburg, 1967.

586

Alphons Silbermann

from this complex chain of relationships, certain aspects of the art process can be examined; w e can undertake concrete studies of particular aspects of the total process, in which case they remain as before, within the context of the total socio-artistic process. T h efirstaim of the sociology of art, therefore, is to study total art processesthe interaction and interdependence of the artist, the work of art and the publicin regard to their importance as art forms. T h e next aim of the sociology of art that w e recognize as part of the total process is the study of the artist. This part of the art process is studied by the sociologist with a view to the description and analysis of the artist's social position and relationships, irrespective of whether the study concerns groups of creative or performing artists or the so-called highbrow or lowbrow artists. Here, such facts as the social origin of certain groups of artists are investigated; information concerning their ethnic, economic and educational background is collected and analysed, as well as data on their style of living, their residence, their leisure activities, their working habits, their social contacts and also their potential and actual attitudes. If a total picture is to be obtained, that is if the artist's contributions to the social order are also to be apprehended, then the sociology of art's next aim is the sociological understanding of the work of art, but, as w e have already pointed out, in carrying out this task it does not undertake any analysis of the work of art itself, but concentrates o n ascertaining the socioartistic process. T h e art sociologist is therefore not interested in analysing painting, music or literature as such, for he recognizes that it would b e attempting the impossible to try to apprehend the so-called irrational content of painting, music or literature as if it were a definite object, or a palpable fact. Art as the intimate concern of a poet, painter or musician has as little reality value for the the art sociologist, as, for example, the music produced by a m a n whistling to himself. It is only w h e n literature, painting and music are objectified, only w h e n they assume a concrete expression or a n atmosphere, that they have a sociological reality value; only then do they express something that is m e a n t to be understood or to produce a social effect. T h e intention of being understood is already an act involving two individual beings, while the social effect dynamically goes beyond this and produces an interaction, whichapart from exceptional casescan never arise between individuals simply through their experiencing the s a m e thing. O n l y w h e n an identical experienceeven if it is not mathematically identicaltakes definite shape and is communicated in a gesture, a word or a tone, can this supposed identical experience be proved and, consequently, verified. A m e m b e r of the philosophically and aesthetically oriented school of thought will object that the arts, those 'tender vibrations of the soul', the language through which 'the soul speaks to the soul', m a y indeed be socio-artistic action, but are certainly not observable, because, being spiritualized and therefore concealed, they d o not generally appear in visible

A definition of the sociology of art

587

form. It is certainly easier to do w h a t those w h o denigrate mass culture usually d o , that is to confine oneself to certain actions a n d to regard art in a n accusatory spirit as a mere product, the purchase and sale of which can be observed. In this connexion, however, it should be pointed out that art is surrounded b y so m a n y obvious actions closely linked to hidden ones that, as socio-artistic actions, they appear as essential facts in social relationships. T h e relation between the different artistic levels, which provoke certain social actions or situations, is not one of the subjects of inquiry of the sociology of art, a n d within this framework it carefully avoids any c o m m e n t o n the work of art itself a n d its structure. W h a t is of interest is the social process, that definite fact which is brought into play b y the work of art. T h e last aim of the sociology of art is the study of the art public. Sociological studies of various groups a m o n g the publicthe public of p o p singers like that of avant-garde writerswho receive, c o n s u m e and react to works of art, provide the art sociologist with important information o n the ways in which the social environment conditions the process of artistic creation and constitute a n intelligible and, w e might even say, a m o r e h u m a n approach to art than those endeavours to m a k e it accessible b y m e a n s of anecdotes, aesthetic juggling with words a n d technicalities. Individual behaviour during the consumption of art, art fashion, motives and patterns of behaviour during listening, beholding or reading, artistic taste, the economics of art, art policy a n d art education, collective behaviour during the consumption of art, social control, etc., these are some of the m a n y groups of problems the art sociologist seeks to investigate w h e n he turns his attention to the art public. If w e n o w combine the separate lines of inquiry so as to obtain an over all picture, w e see that the first aim of the empirical sociology of art is to illustrate the dynamic character of the social p h e n o m e n o n 'art' in its various forms of expression. For this purpose a n analysis of the forms of the world of art seen in their correlation is required, a n analysis which certainly cannot be oriented in accordance with the specific value judgements which the m e m b e r s of every society m a k e in respect of their o w n particular w a y of life, but which must be in accordance with the conception of structural and functional analysis. In this w a y , the sociology of art achieves its second a i m : a generally understandable convincing and valid approach to the w o r k of art, since it shows h o w things have b e c o m e w h a t they are while the changes that are taking place and have taken place are recognized. After this, the sociology of art can turn to its third a i m , which is that of any science: developing laws which m a k e it possible to predict that, if this or that happens, then this or that will probably follow. In our opinion, these aims can help not only to free antiquated, though traditional, approaches to art from their sterility, but also m a k e it easier to recognize m a n himselfthe end a n d m e a n s of all artin his artistic being in the right place a n d situation. In conclusion, let us again emphasize

588

Alphons Silbermann

that the art sociologist never separates art from reality; that h e never investigates social facts, social processes, their origins a n d nature in order to see w h a t they should b e ; that h e never d r a w s o n k n o w l e d g e that is inaccessible to h i m , o r e v e n develops attractive theories w h i c h are not based o n observed facts. T h e observation of facts gives discipline to the sociology o f art, indeed m a k e s it such that, while it acts as a link b e t w e e n sociology a n d the science of art, it is at the s a m e t i m e sociology in its purest form. [Translatedfrom German]

Alphons Silbermann is professor at the universities of Cologne and Lausanne and director of the Institut de Recherches des Communications de Masse of the University of Lausanne. He has published very widely in the general area of the sociology of the arts, especially music, including Introduction u n e sociologie d e la musique (1955), W o v o n Lebt die MusikDie Prinzipien der Musiksoziologie (1957), Vorteile u n d Nachteile des Kommerziellen Fernsehens (1968), Bildschirm u n d Wirklichkeitber Presse u n d Fernsehen in Gegenwart u n d Zukunft (1966, with Abraham Moles and Gerold Ungeheuer), as well as numerous articles in technical and general journals and contributions to dictionaries and encyclopaedias. A collection of his articles appeared under the title of K e t zereien eines Soziologen (1967).

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

Pierre Bourdieu

'

A n y art perception involves a conscious or unconscious deciphering operation: i. i A n act of deciphering unrecognized as such, immediate and adequate 'comprehension' is possible and effective only in the special case in which the cultural code which makes the act of deciphering possible is immediately and completely mastered by the observer (in the form of cultivated ability or inclination) a n d merges with the cultural code which has rendered the work perceived possible. In Rogier van der Weyden's picture, The Three Magi, w e perceive i m m e diately, observes Erwin Panofsky, the representation of an apparition, that of a child in w h o m w e recognize 'the Infant Jesus'. H o w do w e k n o w that this is an apparition? T h e halo of golden rays surrounding the child would not in itself be sufficient proof because it is also found in representations of the nativity in which the Infant Jesus is 'real'. W e c o m e to this conclusion because the child is hovering in mid-air without visible support, and w e do so although the representation would scarcely have been different had the child been sitting o n a pillow (as in the case of the model which Rogier van der W e y d e n probably used). But one can think of hundreds of pictures in which h u m a n beings, animals or inanimate objects appear to be hovering in mid-air, contrary to the law of gravity, yet without giving the impression of being apparitions. For instance, in a miniature of the Gospels of Otto III, in the Staatsbibliothek, M u n i c h , it is a whole town which is represented in the middle of an empty space, while the persons taking part in the action are standing on the ground: n o w this actually is a real town, the one in which the resurrection of the young people shown in the foreground took place. If, in a split second and almost automatically, w e recognize the aerial figure as an apparition, whereas w e see nothing miraculous about the cityfloatingin the air, it is because ' w e are reading what w e see according to the manner in which, under varying historical conditions, the objects and events are expressed by forms'; more precisely, w h e n w e decipher a miniature of c. iooo A . D . , w e unconsciously assume that the

Int. Soc. Sei. J., Vol. X X , N o . 4, 1968

590

Pierre Bourdieu

empty space serves merely as an abstract, unreal background instead of forming part of an apparently natural, three-dimensional space, in which the supernatural and the miraculous can therefore appear as such, as in Rogier van der W e y d e n ' s picture.1 Since he unconsciously obeys the rules which govern a particular type of representation of space w h e n he deciphers a picture constructed according to these rules, the educated or competent beholder of our societies can immediately apprehend as a 'supernatural vision' an element which, by reference to another system of representations in which the regions of space would be in some w a y 'juxtaposed' or 'aggregated' instead of being integrated into a single representation, might appear 'natural' or 'real': ' T h e perspective concept,' says Panofsky, 'makes it impossible for religious art to enter the realm of magic . . . but throws open to it a completely n e w realm, that of the "visionary" in which the miracle becomes an experience immediately perceived by the beholder, because supernatural events burst into the visible space, apparently natural, which is familiar to him, and by that means enable h i m truly to penetrate into the essence for the supernatural.'2 T h e question of the conditions which m a k e it possible to experience the work of art (and, in a more general way, all cultural objects) as at once endowed with meaning is absolutely excluded from this experience itself, because the recapture of the objective meaning of the work (which m a y have nothing to d o with the author's intention) is completely adequate and immediately effected in the caseand only in the casewhere the culture that the originator puts into his work is identical with the culture or, more accurately, the artistic competence which the beholder brings to the deciphering of the work: in this case, everything is a matter of course and the question of the meaning, of the deciphering of the meaning and of the conditions of this deciphering, does not arise. 1.2. Whenever these specific conditions are not fulfilled, misunderstanding is inevitable: the illusion of immediate comprehension leads to an illusory comprehension based on a mistaken code. 3 In the absence of perception that the works are coded, and coded in another code, one unconsciously applies the code which is good for everyday perception, for the deciphering of familiar objects, to works in a foreign tradition: there is no perception which does not involve an unconscious code and it is essential to dismiss the m y t h of the 'fresh eye', considered as a virtue granted to artlessness and innocence. O n e of the reasons w h y the less educated beholi. E . Panofsky, 'Iconography and Iconology: A n Introduction to the Study of Renaissance Art', Meaning in the Visual Arts, N e w York, Doubleday & Co., 1955, p . 33-5. 2. E . Panofsky, 'Die Perspektive als symbolische F o r m ' , Vortrge der Bibliothek Warburg: Vortrge 1024-25, Leipzig-Berlin, p . 257 et seq. 3. Of all misunderstandings involving the code, the most pernicious is perhaps the 'humanist' misunderstanding which, through negation, or rather, 'neutralization', in the sense of the phenomenologists, of everything which contributes to the specificity of the cultures arbitrarily integrated into the pantheon of 'universal culture', tends to represent the Greek or the R o m a n as a particularly successful achievement of ' h u m a n nature' in its universality.

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

591

ders in our societies are so strongly inclined to d e m a n d realistic portrayal is that, being devoid of specific categories of perception, they cannot apply to works of scholarly culture any other code than that which enables them to apprehend, as having a meaning, objects of their everyday environment. M i n i m u m , and apparently immediate, comprehension, accessible to the simplest observer and enabling h i m to recognize a house or a tree, still presupposes partial agreement (unconscious, of course) between artist and beholder concerning categories that define the representation of the real which a historic society holds to be 'realistic' (cf. 1.3.1 note). 1.3 T h e spontaneous theory of art perception is founded o n experience of familiarity and immediate comprehensionan unrecognized special case. 1.3.1 Educated people are at h o m e with scholarly culture. T h e y are consequently carried towards that kind of ethnocentrism which m a y be called class-centrism and which consists in considering as natural (in other words, both as a matter of course a n d based o n nature) a w a y of perceiving which is but one a m o n g other possible ways a n d which is acquired through education that m a y be diffuse or specific, conscious or unconscious, institutionalized or non-institutionalized. 'For one w h o wears glasses, which, in terms of distance, are close to h i m to the point of resting o n his nose, this appliance is, in terms of his surroundings, less "near" to h i m than the picture hanging o n the opposite wall. T h e proximity of the glasses is so great that in the ordinary w a y the wearer does not notice t h e m . ' Taking Heidegger's analysis in the metaphorical sense, it can be said that the illusion of the 'fresh eye' as a 'naked eye' is a n attribute of those w h o wear the spectacles of culture a n d w h o d o not see that which enables t h e m to see, any m o r e than they see w h a t they would not see if they were deprived of what enables t h e m to see.1 1.3.2 Conversely, faced with scholarly culture, the least sophisticated are in a position identical with that of the ethnologist w h o finds himself in a foreign society and is present, for instance, at a ritual to which he does not hold the key. T h e disorientation a n d cultural blindness of the less-educated beholders are a n objective reminder of the objective truth that art perception is a mediate deciphering operation: since the information presented by the works exhibited exceeds the deciphering capabilities of the beholder, he perceives t h e m as devoid of significationor, to be m o r e precise, of structuration and organizationbecause he cannot 'decode' them, or in other words reduce t h e m to a n intelligible form. 1.3.3. Scientific knowledge is distinguished from nave experience
1. This is the same ethnocentrism which tends to take as realistic a representation of the real which owes the fact that it appears 'objective' not to its concordance with the actual reality of things (because this 'reality' is never perceptible except through socially conditioned forms of apprehension) but to its conformity with rules which define its syntax in its social usage with a social definition of the objective vision of the world; in applying the stamp of realism to certain representations of the 'real' (in photography, for instance) the society merely confirms its o w n belief in the tautological assurance that a picture of the real in accordance with its representation of objectivity is truly objective.

592

Pierre B o u r d i e u

(whether this is shown by disconcertment or by immediate comprehension) in that it involves a consciousness of the conditions permitting adequate perception. T h e object of the science of the work of art is that which renders possible both this science and the immediate comprehension of the work of art, i.e., culture. It therefore includes, implicitly at least, the science of the difference between scientific knowledge and nave perception. ' T h e nave "beholder" differs from the art historian in that the latter is conscious of the situation.'1 Needless to say, there would probably be some difficulty in subsuming all the genuine art historians under the concept for which Panofsky proposes a definition that is obviously ideally normative.
2

A n y deciphering operation requires a m o r e or less complex code which has been m o r e or less completely mastered. 2.1 T h e work of art (like any cultural object) m a y disclose significations at different levels according to the deciphering stencil applied to it; the lower-level significations, that is to say the most superficial, remain partial and mutilated, and therefore erroneous, for such time as the higher-level significations which encompass and transfigure them, are lacking. 2.1.1 According to Panofsky, the most nave beholder first of all distinguishes 'the primary or natural subject matter or meaning which w e can apprehend from our practical experience', or in other words, 'the phenomenal meaning which can be subdivided into factual and expressional': this apprehension depends u p o n 'demonstrative concepts' which only identify the sensible qualities of the work (this is the case w h e n a peach is described as velvety or lace as misty) or the emotional experience which these qualities arouse in the beholder (when colours are spoken of as harsh or gay). T o reach 'the secondary subject matter which presupposes a familiarity with specific themes or concepts as transmitted through literary sources' and which m a y be called the 'sphere of the meaning of the signifcate' (rgion du sens du signifi), w e must have 'appropriately characterizing concepts' which go beyond the simple designation of sensible qualities and, grasping the stylistic characteristics of the work of art, constitute a genuine 'interpretation' of it. Within this secondary stratum, Panofsky distinguishes, on the one hand, 'the secondary or conventional meaning, the world of specific themes or concepts manifested in images, stories and allegories' (when, for instance, a group of persons seated around a table according to a certain arrangement represents the Last Supper), the deciphering of which falls to iconography; and, on the other hand, 'the intrinsic meaning or content', which the iconological interpretation can recapture only if the iconographical meanings and

i. E . Panofsky, 'The History of Art as a Humanistic Discipline', Meaning in the Visual Arts, op. cit., p. 17.

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

593

methods of composition are treated as 'cultural symbols', as expressions of the culture of an age, a nation or a class, and if an effort is m a d e to bring out 'the fundamental principles which support the choice and presentation of the motifs as well as the production a n d interpretation of the images, stories and allegories and which give a meaning even to the formal composition and to the technical processes'.1 T h e meaning grasped by the primary act of deciphering is totally different according to whether it constitutes the whole of the experience of the work of art or becomes part of a unitary experience, embodying the higher levels of meaning. Thus, it is only starting from a n iconological interpretation that the formal arrangements and technical methods a n d , through them, the formal and expressive qualities, assume their full meaning and that the insufficiencies of a preiconographic or pre-iconological interpretation are revealed at the s a m e time. In an adequate knowledge of the work, the different levels are linked up in a n hierarchical system in which the embodying form becomes embodied in its turn, a n d the signifcate in its turn becomes significant. 2.1.2 Uninitiated perception, reduced to the grasping of primary significations, is a mutilated perception. Contrasted with what might be calledto borrow a phrase from Nietzsche'the d o g m a of the immaculate perception', foundation of the romantic representation of artistic experience, the 'comprehension' of the 'expressive' a n d , as one might say, 'physiognomical' qualities of the work is only a n inferior and mutilated form of the aesthetic experience, because, not being supported controlled and corrected by knowledge of the style, types and 'cultural symptoms', it uses a code which is neither adequate nor specific. It can probably be agreed that inward experience as a capacity for emotional response to the connotation (as opposed to denotation) of the work of art is one of the keys to art experience. But M r . R a y m o n d Ruyer very discerningly contrasts the signification, which he defines as 'epicritic', and the expressivity, which he describes as 'protopathic, that is to say m o r e primitive, m o r e blurred, of the lower level, linked with the diencephalon, whereas the signification is linked with the cerebral cortex'. 2.1.3 Through sociological observation it is possible to reveal, effectively realized, forms of perception corresponding to the different levels which theoretical analysis frames b y an abstract distinction. A n y cultural asset, from cookery to dodecaphonic music by w a y of the Wild West film, can be a subject for apprehension ranging from the simple, actual sensation to scholarly appreciation. T h e ideology of the 'fresh eye' overlooks the fact that the sensation or affection stimulated b y the work of art has not the same 'value' w h e n it constitutes the whole of the aesthetic experience as w h e n it forms part of a n adequate experience of the work of art. It is
1. These quotations are taken from two articles published in German: 'ber das Verhltnis der Kungstgeschichte zur Kunsttheorie', Zeitschrift fr Aesthetik und allgemeine Kunstwissenchaft, XVIII, 1925, p. 129 et seq.; and ' Z u m Problem der Berschreibung und Inhaltsdeutung von Werken der bildenden Kunst', Logos, X X I , 1932, p. 103 et seq. The articles were republished, with a few amendments, in Iconography and Iconology', loc. cit., p. 26-54.

594

Pierre B o u r d i e u

therefore possible to distinguish, by abstraction, two extreme and opposite forms of aesthetic pleasure, separated by all the intermediate degrees, the enjoyment which accompanies aesthetic perception reduced to simple aistkesis, and the delight procured by scholarly savouring, and which presupposes, as a necessary but insufficient condition, adequate deciphering. Like painting, perception of painting is a mental thing, at least w h e n it conforms to the norms of perception i m m a n e n t in the w o r k of art or, in other words, w h e n the aesthetic intention of the beholder is identified with the objective intention of the work (which must not be identified with the artist's intention). 2.1.4 T h e most uninitiated perception is always inclined to go beyond the level of sensations and affections, that is to say aisthesis pure and simple: the assimilatory interpretation which tends to apply to a n u n k n o w n a n d foreign universe the available schemes of interpretation, that is to say those which enable the familiar universe to be apprehended as having meaning, becomes essential as a means of restoring the unity of a n integrated perception. Those for w h o m the works of scholarly culture speak a foreign language are condemned to take into their perception and their appreciation of the work of art some extrinsic categories and valuesthose which organize their day-to-day perception and guide their practical judgement. T h e aesthetics of the different social classes are therefore, with certain exceptions, only one dimension of their ethics (or better, of their ethos) : thus, the aesthetic preferences of the lower middle-class appear as a systematic expression of an ascetic disposition which is also expressed in other spheres of their existence. 2.2 T h e work of art considered as a symbolic asset (and not as a n economic asset, which it m a y also be) only exists as such for a person w h o has the means to appropriate it, or in other words, to decipher it.1 2.2.1 T h e degree of art competence of a n agent is measured b y the degree to which he masters the set of instruments for the appropriation of the work of art, available at a given time, that is to say the interpretation schemes which are the prerequisite for the appropriation of art capital or, in other words, the prerequisite for the deciphering of works of art offered to a given society at a particular time.
1. T h e laws governing the reception of works of art are a special case of the laws of cultural diffusion: whatever m a y be the nature of the messagereligious prophecy, political speech, publicity image, technical object, etc., reception depends upon the categories of perception, thought and action of those w h o receive it. In a differentiated society, a close relationship is therefore established between the nature and quality of the information transmitted and the structure of the public, its 'readability' and its effectiveness being all the greater w h e n it meets as directly as possible the expectations, implicit or explicit, which the receivers owe chiefly to their family upbringing and social circumstances (and also, in the matter of scholarly culture at least, to their school education) and which the diffuse pressure of the reference group maintains, sustains and reinforces b y constant recalls to the norm. It is o n the basis of this connexion between the level of transmission of the message and the structure of the public, treated as a reception level indicator, that it has been possible to construct the mathematical model of m u s e u m visiting (cf. P . Bourdieu and A . Darbel, with D . Schnapper, L'amour de l'art, les muses et leur public, Paris, d . de Minuit, 1966, p . 99 et seq.).

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

595

2.2.1.1 Art competence can be provisionally defined as the preliminary knowledge of the possible divisions into complementary classes of a universe oi representations: a mastery of this kind of system of classification enables each element ofthe universe to be placed in a class necessarily determined inrelation to another class, constituted itself by all the art representations consciously or unconsciously taken into consideration which d o not belong to the class in question. T h e style proper to a period a n d to a social group is none other than such a class determined in relation to all the works of the s a m e universe which it excludes a n d which are complementary to it. T h e recognition (or, as the art historians say w h e n using the actual vocabulary of logic, the attribution) proceeds b y successive elimination of the possibilities to which the class isnegativelyrelated and to which the possibility which has b e c o m e a reality in the work concerned belongs. It is straightway evident that the uncertainty concerning the different characteristics likely to be attributed to the work under consideration (authors, schools, periods, styles, subjects, etc.) can be removed by employing different codes, functioning as classification systems; it m a y be a case of a strictly artistic code which, by permitting the deciphering of specifically stylistic characteristics, enables the work concerned to be assigned to the class formed by the whole of the works of a period, a society, a school or a n author ('that's a Czanne'), or a code from everyday life which, in the form of previous knowledge of the possible divisions into complementary classes of the universe of significants and of the universe of significates, a n d of the correlations between the divisions of the one a n d the divisions of the other, enables the particular representation, treated as a sign, to be assigned to a class of significants and consequently m a k e s it possible to k n o w , b y m e a n s of the correlations with the universe of the significates, that the corresponding signifcate belongs to a certain class of significates ('that's a forest').1 In the first case the beholder is paying attention to the manner of treating the leaves or the clouds, that is to say to the stylistic indications, locating the possibility realized, characteristic of one class of works, by reference to the universe of stylistic possibilities; in the other case, he is treating the leaves or the clouds as indications or signals associated, according to the logic set forth above, with significations transcendent to the representation itself ('that's a poplar', 'that's a storm'). 2.2.1.2 Artistic competence is therefore defined as the previous k n o w ledge of the strictly artistic principles of division which enable a representation to be located, through the classification of the stylistic indications which it contains, a m o n g the possibilities of representation constituting the universe of art and not a m o n g the possibilities of representation constituting the universe of everyday objects (or, m o r e exactly, of implements) or the universe of signs, which would a m o u n t to treating it as a m e r e m o n u m e n t , in other words as a m e r e m e a n s of communication used to i. T o show that such a sequence really is the logic of the transmission of messages in everyday life, it is enough to quote the following exchange heard in a bar: 'One beer.' 'Draught or bottled?' 'Draught.' 'Mild or bitter?' 'Bitter.* 'Home-brewed or imported?' 'Home-brewed.'

596

Pierre Bourdieu

transmit a transcendental signification. T h e perception of the w o r k of art in a truly aesthetic manner, that is to say as a significant which signifies nothing other than itself, does not consist, as is sometimes said, of considering it 'without connecting it with anything other than itself, either emotionally or intellectually', in short of giving oneself u p to the work apprehended in its irreducible singularity, but of noting its distinctive stylistic features by relating it to the whole of the works forming the class to which it belongs, and to these works only. O n the contrary, the taste of the working classes is determined, after the m a n n e r of w h a t K a n t describes in his Critique of Judgement as 'barbarous taste', by the refusal or the impossibility (one should say the impossibility-refusal) of operating the distinction between 'what is liked' and 'what pleases' and, m o r e generally, between 'disinterestedness', the only guarantee of the aesthetic quality of contemplation, and 'the interest of the senses' which defines 'the agreeable' or 'the interest of Reason' : it requires that every image shall fulfil a function, if only that of a sign, this 'functionalistic' representation of the work of art being based o n the refusal of gratuitousness, the idolatry of work or the placing of value o n w h a t is 'instructive' (as opposed to w h a t is 'interesting') and also on the impossibility of placing each individual work in the universe of representations, in the absence of strictly stylistic principles of classification.1 It follows that a work of art which they expect to express u n ambiguously a signification transcendental to the significant form is all the m o r e disconcerting to the most unitiated in that (like the non-figurative arts) it does away m o r e completely with the narrative and descriptive function. 2.2.1.3 T h e degree of artistic competence depends not only o n the degree to which the available system of classification is mastered, but also o n the degree of complexity or subtlety of this system of classification, and it is therefore measurable by the ability to operate a fairly large n u m b e r of successive divisions in the universe of representations and, through that, to determine ratherfineclasses. For anyone familiar only with the principle of division into R o m a n e s q u e art and Gothic art, all Gothic cathedrals fall into the same class and, for that reason, remain indistinct, whereas greater competence makes it possible to perceive differences between the styles of the 'early', middle, a n d 'late' periods, or even to recognize, within each of these styles, the works of a school or even of a n architect. T h u s , the apprehension of the features which constitute the peculiarity of the works of one period compared with those of another period or, within this class of the works of one school or group of artists compared with another, or again, of the works of one author compared with other works of his school or his period, or even a particular work of a n author compared with his work as a
1. More than through opinions expressed on works of scholarly culture, paintings and sculptures, for example, which, by their high degree of legitimacy, are capable of imposing judgements inspired by the search for conformity, it is through photographic production and judgements on photographic images that the principles of the 'popular taste' are expressed (cf. P. Bourdieu, Un art moyen, Essai sur les usages sociaux de la photographie, Paris, d. de Minuit, 1965, p. 113-34).

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

597

wholesuch apprehension is indissociable from that of redundancies, that is to say, from the grasping of typical treatments of the pictorial matter which determine a style: in short, the grasping of resemblances presupposes implicit or explicit reference to the differences, and vice versa. 2.3 T h e art code as a system of possible principles of division into complementary classes of the universe of representations offered to a particular society at a given time is in the nature of a social institution. 2.3.1 Being an historically constituted system, founded on social reality, this set of instruments of perception whereby a particular society, at a given time, appropriates artistic wealth (and, more generally, cultural wealth) does not depend upon individual wills a n d consciousnesses and forces itself upon individuals, often without their knowledge, determining the distinctions which they can m a k e and those which escape them. Every period arranges art representations as a whole according to an institutional system of classification of its o w n , placing together works between which other periods drew a distinction, or distinguishing between works which other periods placed together, and individuals have difficulty in imagining other differences than those which the system of classification available to them allows them to imagine. 'Suppose', writes Longhi, 'that the French naturalists and impressionists, between 1680 and 1880, had not signed their works and that they had not had at their side, like heralds, critics and journalists as intelligent as Geffroy or Duret. Imagine them forgotten, as the result of a reversal of taste and a long period of decline in erudite research, forgotten for a hundred or a hundred andfiftyyears. W h a t would happen first of all, w h e n attention was again focused u p o n them? It is easy to foresee that, in thefirstphase, analysis would begin by distinguishing several entities in these m u t e materials, which would be more symbolic than historical. T h e first would bear the symbolic n a m e of M a n e t , w h o would absorb part of Renoir's youthful production, and even, I ' m afraid, a few works of Gervex, without counting all those of Gonzales, Morizot and M o n e t as a young m a n : as to M o n e t in later yearshe also having become a symbolhe would engulf almost the whole of Sisley, a good share of Renoir, and worse still, a few dozen works of Boudin, several of Lebour and several of Lpine. It is by no means impossible that a ew of Pissarro's works and even, unflattering recompense, more than one of Guillaumin, might in such a case be attributed to Czanne.' 1 Still more convincing than this kind of imaginary variation, Berne Joffroy's historical study o n the successive representations of the work of Caravaggio shows that the public image which the individuals of a specific period form of a work is, properly speaking, the product of the instruments of perception, historically constituted, and therefore historically changing, which are supplied to them by the society to which they belong: 'I k n o w well what is said about attribution disputes: that they have nothing to do with art, that they are petty and that art is great. . . . T h e idea that w e form of an artist depends on the
1. R . Longhi, quoted by Berne Joffroy, Le dossier Caravage, Paris, d. de Minuit, 1959, p. 100-1.

598

Pierre Bourdieu

works attributed to him and, whether w e would or no, this general idea of him colours our view of each of his works.' 1 Thus, the history of the instruments for perception of the work is the essential complement of the history of the instruments for production of the work, to the extent that every work is, so to speak, done twice, by the originator and by the beholder, or rather, by the society to which the beholder belongs. 2.3.2 T h e modal readability of a work of art (in respect of a particular society in a given period) varies according to the divergence between the code which the work under consideration objectively requires and the code as an historically constituted institution; the readability of a work of art for a particular individual varies according to the divergence between the more or less complex and subtle code required by the work, and the competence of the individual, as determined by the degree to which the social code, itself more or less complex and subtle, is mastered. Thus, as Boris de Schloezer observes, each period has its melodic schemes which cause the individuals to apprehend immediately the structure of the successions of sounds in conformity with these schemes: 'Nowadays w e need some instruction to appreciate the Gregorian chant, and m a n y mediaeval monodies seem no less baffling than a melodic phrase of Alban Berg. But w h e n a melody enters easily into frameworks to which w e are accustomed, there is no longer any need to reconstruct it, its unity is there and the phrase reaches us as a whole, so to speak, in the m a n n e r of a chord. In this case, it is capable of acting magically, again like a chord, or a gong stroke; if on the other hand it is a melody whose structure is no longer in conformity with the schemes sanctioned by traditionthe tradition of the Italian opera, that of W a g n e r or the popular songthe synthesis is sometimes difficult to m a k e . ' 2 2.3.3 Since the works forming the art capital of a particular society at a given time call for codes of varying complexity and subtlety, and are therefore likely to be acquired more or less easily and m o r e or less rapidly by institutionalized or non-institutionalized training, they are characterized by different levels of emission, so that the previous proposition (2.3.2) can be reformulated in the following terms: the readability of a work of art for a particular individual depends upon the divergence between the level of emission,3 defined as the degree of intrinsic complexity and subtlety, of
1. Berne Joffroy, op. cit., p. 9. A systematic study should be m a d e of the relationship between the transformation of the instruments of perception and the transformation of the instruments of art production, because the evolution of the public image of past works is indissociably linked with the evolution of art. As Lionello Venturi remarks, it was by starting with Michelangelo that Vasari discovered Giotto, and by starting with Caracci and Poussin that Belloni rethought Raphael. 2. B . de Schloezer, 'Introduction J. S. Bach', Essai d'esthtique musicale, Paris, N R F , 194.7, p. 3?. 3. Needless to say, the level of emission cannot be denned absolutely, because the same work m a y express significations of different levels according to the interpretation stencil which is applied to it (cf. 2.1.1): just as the Wild West film m a y be the subject of the naive attachment of simple aisthesis (cf. 2.1.3) or of scholarly reading, coupled with a knowledge of the traditions and rules of the genre, so the same pictorial work offers significations of different levels and m a y , for instance, satisfy an interest in respect of anecdotes or the informative content (especially historical) or retain the attention by its formal qualities alone.

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

599

the code required for the work, and the level of reception defined as the degree to which this individual masters the social code, which m a y be more or less adequate to the code required for the work. Each individual possesses a definite and limited capacity for apprehending the 'information' suggested by the work, a capacity which depends on his knowledge of the generic code for the type of message concerned, be it the painting as a whole, or the painting of a particular period, school or author. W h e n the message exceeds the possibilities of apprehension or, to be more precise, w h e n the code of the work exceeds in subtlety and complexity the code of the beholder, the latter loses interest in what appears to h i m to be a medley without r h y m e or reason, or a completely unnecessary set of sounds or colours. In other words, w h e n placed before a message which is too rich for him, or 'overwhelming' as the theory of information expresses it, he feels c o m pletely 'out of his depth' (cf. 1.3.2). 2.3.4 I* follows that to increase the readability of the work of art (or of a collection of works oftart such as those exhibited in a m u s e u m ) and to reduce the misunderstanding which results from the divergence, it is possible either to lower the level of emission or to raise the level of reception. T h e only w a y of lowering the level of emission of a work is to provide, together with the work, the code according to which the work is coded, in an expression (verbal or graphical), the code of which is already m a s tered (partially or completely) by the receiver, or which continuously delivers the code for his o w n deciphering, in accordance with the model of perfectly rational pedagogic communication. Incidentally, it is obvious that any action tending to lower the level of emission helps in fact to raise the level of reception. 2.3.5 I n each period, the rules defining the readability of contemporary art are but a special application of the general law of readability. T h e readability of a contemporary work varies primarily according to the relationship which the creators maintain, in a given period, in a given society, with the code of the previous period: it is thus possible to distinguish, very roughly, classical periods, in which a style reaches its o w n perfection and which the creators exploit to the point of achieving and perhaps exhausting the possibilities provided by an inherited art of inventing, and periods of rupture, in which a n e w art of inventing is invented, in which a n e w form-generative g r a m m a r is engendered, out of joint with the aesthetic traditions of a time or a n environment. T h e divergence between the social code and the code required for the works has clearly every chance of being less in classical periods than in periods of rupture, infinitely less, especially, than in the periods of continued rupture, such as the one w e are n o w living through. T h e transformation of the instruments of art production necessarily precedes the transformation of the instruments of art perception and the transformation of the modes of perception cannot but operate slowly, because it is a matter of uprooting a type of art competence (product of the interiorization of a social code, so deeply implanted in habits and memories that it functions at sub-conscious level) and of substituting another

6oo

Pierre Bourdieu

for it, by a n e w process of interiorization, necessarily long and difficult.1 In periods of rupture, the inertia inherent in art competences (or, if preferred, in habitus) m e a n s that the works produced by means of art production instruments of a n e w type are bound to be perceived, for a certain time, by means of old instruments of perception, precisely those against which they have been created. Educated m e n w h o belong to culture at least as m u c h as culture belongs to them, are always given to applying inherited categories to the works of their period and to ignoring for the same reason the irreducible novelty of works which carry with them the very categories of their o w n perception (as opposed to works which can be called academic, in a very wide sense, and which only put into operation a code, or, rather, a habitus which already exists). Everything opposes the devotees of culture, vowed to the worship of the consecrated works of defunct prophets, as also the priests of culture, devoted, like the teachers, to the organization of this worship, to the cultural prophets, that is to say the creators w h o upset the routine of ritualized fervour, while they become in their turn the object of the routine worship of n e w priests and n e w devotees. If it be true, as Franz Boas says, that 'the throught of what w e call the educated classes is controlled essentially by those ideals which have been transmitted to us by past generations',2 the fact remains that the absence of any art competence is neither a necessary condition nor a sufficient one for the adequate perception of innovative works or, with stornger reason, for the production of such works. Artlessness can here only be the supreme form of sophistication. T h e fact of being devoid of keys is in no w a y favourable to the understanding of works which require only that all the old keys be rejected so as to wait for the work itself to deliver the key for its o w n deciphering. A s w e have seen, this is the very attitude that the most uninitiated, confronted by scholarly art, are least inclined to take u p (cf. 2.2.1.2). T h e ideology according to which the most modern forms of non-figurative art are more directly accessible to the innocence of childhood or of ignorance than to the competence acquired by a training which is considered as deforming, like that of the school, is not only refuted by the facts;3 although the most innovative forms of art only yield their message first to a few virtuosi (whose avant-garde positions are always explained partly by the position they occupy in the intellectual field and, m o r e generally, in the social structure),4 the fact is that they d e m a n d a capacity for breaking with all the codes, beginning obviously with the code of everyday life, and that this capacity is acquired through association with works

1. This holds good for any cultural training, art form, scientific theory or political theory, the former habitus being able for a long time to survive a revolution of social codes and even of the social conditions for the production of these codes. 2. F . Boas, Anthropology and Modem Life, N e w York, Norton, 1962, p. 196. 3. A study of the characteristics of visitors to European museums shows that the museums which o f f e r modern works of art have the highest level of emission, and therefore the most educated visitors (cf. P . Bourdieu and A . Daubel, op. cit.). 4. Cf. P . Bourdieu, 'Champ intellectuel et projet crateur', Les temps modernes, November 1966, p. 865-905.

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

601

demanding different codes and through an experience of the history of art as a succession of ruptures with established codes. In short, a n ability to hold all the available codes in abeyance so as to rely entirely o n the work itself, and w h a t atfirstsight is the most unusual quality in it, presupposes an accomplished mastery of the code to the codes, which governs adequate application of the different social codes objectively required for the available works as a whole at a given m o m e n t of time.

3 Since the work of art only exists as such to the extent that it is perceived, or in other words deciphered, it goes without saying that the satisfactions attached to this perceptionwhether it be a matter of purely aesthetic enjoyment or of m o r e indirect gratification, such as the effect of distinction (cf. 3.3)are only accessible to those w h o are disposed to appropriate t h e m because they attribute a value to them, it being understood that they can d o this only if they have the m e a n s to appropriate them. Consequently, the need to appropriate wealth which, like cultural wealth, only exists as such for those w h o have received the means to appropriate it from their family environment and from the school, can appear only in those w h o can satisfy it, and it can be satisfied as soon as it appears. 3.1 It follows o n the one hand that, unlike 'primary' needs, the 'cultural need' as a cultivated need increases in proportion as it is satisfied, because each n e w appropriation tends to strengthen the mastery of the instruments of appropriation (cf. 3.2.1), and, consequently, the satisfactions attached to a n e w appropriation; o n the other hand, it also follows that the consciousness of deprivation decreases in proportion as the deprivation increases, individuals w h o are most completely dispossessed of the means of appropriating works of art being the most completely dispossessed of the consciousness of this dispossession. 3.2 T h e inclination to appropriate cultural wealth is the product of general or specific education, institutionalized or not, which creates (or cultivates) art competence as a mastery of the instruments for appropriation of this wealth, and which creates the 'cultural need' b y giving the m e a n s to satisfy it. 3.2.1 T h e repeated perception of works of a certain style encourages the unconscious interiorization of the rules which govern the production of these works. Like rules of g r a m m a r , these rules are not apprehended as such, and are still less explicitly formulated and formulatable: for instance, a lover of classical music m a y have neither consciousness nor knowledge of the laws obeyed by the sound-making art to which he is accustomed, but his auditive education is such that, having heard a dominant chord, he is induced urgently to await the tonic which seems to him the 'natural' resolution of this chord, and he has difficulty in apprehending the internal coherence of music founded o n other principles. T h e unconscious mastery of the instruments of appropriation which are the basis of familiarity with cultural works is

602

Pierre Bourdieu

acquired by slow familiarization, a long succession of 'little perceptions', in the sense in which Leibniz uses these words. Connoisseurship is an 'art' which, like the art of thinking or the art of living, cannot be imparted entirely in the form of precepts or instruction, and apprenticeship to it presupposes the equivalent of prolonged contact between disciple and master in traditional education, that is to say repeated contact with the work (or with works of the same class). A n d , just as the student or disciple can unconsciously absorb the rules of the artincluding those which are not explicitly k n o w n to the master himselfby giving himself up to it, excluding analysis and the selection of elements of exemplary conduct, so the art-lover can, by abandoning himself in s o m e w a y to the work, interiorize the principles and rules of its construction without their ever being brought to his consciousness and formulated as such, which makes all the difference between the art theorist and the connoisseur, w h o is usually incapable of explicating the principles o n which his judgements are based (cf. 1.3.3). In thisfieldas in others (learning the g r a m m a r of one's mother tongue, for instance), school education tends to encourage the conscious reflection of patterns of thought, perception or expression which have already been mastered unconsciously b y formulating explicitly the principles of the creative g r a m m a r , for example the laws of harmony and counterpoint or the rules of pictorial composition, and by providing the verbal and conceptual material essential in order to give a n a m e to differences previously experienced in a purely intuitive w a y . T h e danger of academicism is obviously inherent in any rationalized teaching which tends to mint, within one doctrinal body, precepts, prescriptions and formulae, explicitly described and taught, m o r e often negative than positive, which a traditional education imparts in the form of a habitus, directly apprehended uno intuitu, as a global style not susceptible to analytical breakdown. 3.2.2 Familiarization by repeated perceptions is the privileged m o d e of acquiring the means of appropriating works of art because the work of art always appears as a concrete individuality which never allows itself to be deduced from principles and rules defining a style. A s is seen from the facts in the case of the musical work, the most exact and best informed discursive translations cannot take the place of the execution, as a hic et nunc realization of the individual form, which is irreducible to any formula; the conscious or unconscious mastery of the principles and rules of the production of this form enables the coherence and the necessity of it to be apprehended by a symmetrical reconstruction of the creator's construction but, far from reducing the individual work to the general nature of a type, it renders possible the apperception and appreciation of the originality of each actualization or, rather, of each execution, in relation to the principles and rules according to which it was produced. Although the work of art always procures the twofold feeling of the unparalleled and the inevitable, the most inventive, most improvised and most original solutions can always be^understood. post festum, in terms^of the schemes of thought, perception

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

603

and action (rules of composition, theoretical problems, etc.) which have given rise to the technical or aesthetic questions to which this work corresponds, at the same time as they were guiding the creator in the search for a solution irreducible to schemes and, thereby, unpredictable yet nonetheless in accordance, a posteriori, with the rules of a g r a m m a r of forms. T h e ultimate truth of the style of a period, a school or an author is not contained as a seed in an original inspiration, but is defined and re-defined continuously as a signification in a state offluxwhich builds itself u p in accordance with itself and in reaction against itself; it is in the continued exchange between questions which exist only for and through a m i n d armed with schemes of a specific type and m o r e or less innovative solutions, obtained through the application of the same schemes, but capable of transforming the initial scheme, that this unity of style and of meaning emerges which, as least after the event, m a y appear to have preceded the works heralding the final outcome and which transforms, retrospectively, the different m o m e n t s of the temporal series into simple preparatory outlines. If the evolution of a style (of a period, a school or an author) does not appear either as the autonomous development of an essence which is unique and always identical with itself, or as a continuous creation of unpredictable novelty, but as a progress which excludes neither the leaps forward nor the turnings back, it is because the creator's habitus as a system of schemes constantly guides choices which, though not deliberate, are nonetheless systematic and, without being arranged and organized expressly in relation to afinalgoal, are nonetheless bearers of a kind offinalitywhich will be revealed only postfestum. This auto-constitution of a system of works united by a set of significant relationships is accomplished in and through the association of contingency and meaning which is m a d e , u n m a d e and remade unceasingly according to principles which are all the m o r e constant because they are completely unconscious, in and through the permanent transmutation which introduces the accidents of the history of techniques into the history of style while making them meaningful in and through the invention of obstacles and difficulties which are as if stirred up on behalf of the very principles of their solution and of which the short-term counter-finality m a y conceal a higher finality. 3.2.3 Even w h e n the educational institution makes little provision for art training proper (as is the case in France and m a n y other countries), even w h e n therefore it gives neither specific encouragement to cultural activities nor a body of concepts specifically adapted to plastic art works, it tends on the one hand to inspire a certain familiarityconferring a feeling of belonging to the cultivated classwith the world of art, in which people people feel at h o m e and a m o n g themselves as the appointed addressees of works which do not deliver their message to the first-comer: on the other hand, they tend to inculcate (at least in France and in the majority of European countries, as secondary education level) a cultivated disposition as a durable and generalized attitude which implies recognition of the value of works of art and ability to appropriate them by m e a n s of generic

6o4

Pierre Bourdieu

categories.1 Although it deals almost exclusively with literary works, in-school learning tends to create on the one hand a transposable inclination to admire works approved by the school and a duty to admire and to love certain works or, rather, certain classes of works which gradually seem to become linked to a certain educational and social status; and, on the other hand, an equally generalized and transposable aptitude for categorizing by authors, by genres, by schools and by periods, for the handling of educational categories of literary analysis and for the mastery of the code which governs the use of the different codes (cf. 2.3.5), gi v l n g a t least a tendency to acquire equivalent categories in otherfieldsand to store away the typical knowledge which, even though extrinsic and anecdotal, makes possible at least a n elementary form of apprehension, however inadequate it m a y be. 2 Thus, the first degree of strictly pictorial competence shows itself in the mastery of an arsenal of words making it possible to n a m e differences and to apprehend them while naming them: these are the proper names of famous paintersda Vinci, Picasso, V a n Goghwhich function as generic categories, because one can say about any painting or non-figurative object 'that suggests Picasso', or, about any work recalling nearly or distantly the m a n n e r of the Florentine painter, 'that looks like a d a Vinci'; there are also broad categories, like 'the Impressionists' (a school commonly considered to include Gauguin, Czanne and Degas), the 'Dutch School', 'the Renaissance'. It is particularly significant that the proportion ofsubjects w h o think in terms of schools is very clearly growing as the level of education rises and that, more generally, generic knowledge which is required for the perception of differences and consequently for memorizingproper names, and historical, technical or aesthetic conceptsare increasingly numerous and increasingly specific as w e go towards the m o r e educated beholders, so that the most adequate perception differs only from the least adequate in so far as the specificity, richness and subtlety of the categories employed are concerned. B y n o means contradicting these arguments is the fact that the less educated visitors to m u s e u m s are, the m o r e they tend to prefer the most famous paintings and those sanctioned by school teaching, whereas modern painters w h o have the least chance of being mentioned in schools are quoted only by those with the highest educational qualifications,

1. School instruction always fulfils a function of legitimation, if only b y giving its blessing to works which it sets up as worthy of being admired, and thus helps to define the hierarchy of cultural wealth valid in a particular society at a given time. (Concerning the hierarchy of cultural wealth and degrees of legitimacy, see P . Bourdieu, Un art moyen, op. cit., p . 134-8.) 2. L . S . Vygotsky has established experimentally the validity of the general laws governing the transfer of training in thefieldof educational aptitudes: ' T h e psychological prerequisites for instruction in different school subjects are to a large extent the same: instruction in a given subject influences the development of the higher functions far beyond the confines of that particular subject; the main psychic functions involved in studying various subjects are interdependenttheir c o m m o n bases are consciousness and deliberate mastery, the principal contribution of the school years' (L. S. Vygotsky, Thought and Language, published and translated from the Russian by E . H a n f m a n n and G . Vakar, Cambridge, M I T Press, 1962, p. 102).

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

605

living in the big cities. T o be able to form discerning or so-called 'personal' opinions is again a result of the education received: ability to throw off school constraints is the privilege of those w h o have sufficiently assimilated school education to m a k e their o w n the free attitude towards scholastic culture taught by a school so deeply impregnated with the values of the ruling classes that it accepts the fashionable depreciation of school instruction. T h e contrast between accepted, stereotyped and, as M a x W e b e r would say 'routinized' culture, and genuine culture, freed from school dissertations, has meaning only for a n infinitely small minority of educated people for w h o m culture is second nature, endowed with all the appearances of talent, and the full assimilation of school culture is a prerequisite for going beyond it towards this 'free culture'freed that is to say from its school originswhich the bourgeois class and its school regard as the value of values (cf. 3.3). But the best proof that the general principles for the transfer of training also;hold for school training lies in the fact that the practices of one single individual and, a fortiori, of individuals belonging to one social category or having a specific level of education, tend to constitute a system, so that a certain type of practice in any field of culture very probably implies a corresponding type of practice in all the otherfields;thus, frequent visits to m u s e u m s are almost necessarily associated with a n equal a m o u n t of theatre-going and, to a lesser degree, attendance at concerts. Similarly, everything seems to indicate that knowledge and preferences tend to form into constellations which are strictly linked to the level of education, so that a typical structure of preferences in painting is most likely to be linked to a structure of preferences of the s a m e type in music or literature.1 3.2.4 O w i n g to the particular status of the work of art and the specific logic of the training which it implies, art education which is reduced to a dissertation (historical, aesthetic or other) on the works is necessarily at secondary level:2 like the teaching of the mother tongue, literature or art education (that is to say 'the humanities' of traditional education) necessarily presuppose, without ever, or hardly ever, being organized in the light of this preliminary, that individuals are endowed with a previously acquired competence a n d with a whole capital of experience unequally distributed a m o n g the various social classes (visits to m u s e u m s or m o n u ments, attending concerts, lectures, etc.). 3.2.4.1 In the absence of a methodical and systematic effort, involving
1. A criticism of the ideology of the 'unevennesses' of taste and knowledge in the different art fields (music, painting, etc.) and of the widespread m y t h of the 'cultural breakthrough' (according to which, for instance, an individual would be able, in the absence of any pictorial culture, to produce works of art in photography), all representations which combine to strengthen the ideology of the gift, will be found in P . Bourdieu, Un art moyen, op. cit., part I. 2. This is true, in fact, of any education. Taking the mother tongue, for instance, it is k n o w n that logical structures, m o r e or less complex according to the complexity of the language used in the family circle, and which are acquired unconsciously, provide an unequal predisposition to the deciphering and handling of structures involved in a mathematical d e m o n stration as well as in the comprehension of a work of art.

6o6

Pierre Bourdieu

the mobilization of all available means from the earliest years of school onwards, to procure for all those attending school a direct contact with the works or, at least, an approximative substitute for that experience (by showing reproductions or reading texts, organizing visits to m u s e u m s or playing records, etc.), art education can be of full benefit only to those w h o owe to their family circle the competence acquired by slow and imperceptible familiarization, because it does not give explicitly to all what it implicitly demands from all. While it is true that only the school can give the continuous and prolonged, methodical and uniform training capable of mass production, if I m a y use that expression, of competent individuals, provided with schemes of perception, thought and expression which are prerequisites for the appropriation of cultural wealth, and endowed with that generalized and permanent inclination to appropriate this wealth which is the m a r k of devotion to culture, the fact remains that the effectiveness of this moulding action is directly dependent upon the degree to which those undergoing it fulfil the preliminary conditions for adequate reception: the influence of school activity is all the stronger and more lasting w h e n it is carried on for a longer time (as is shown by the fact that the decrease of cultural activity with age is less marked w h e n the duration of schooling was longer), w h e n those upon w h o m it is exercised have greater previous competence, acquired through early and direct contact with works (which is well k n o w n to be more frequent always as one goes higher up the social scale1) and finally w h e n a propitious cultural atmosphere sustains and relays its effectiveness.2 Thus, arts students w h o have received a homogeneous and homogenizing training for a number of years and w h o have been constantly selected according to the degree to which they conform to school requirements, remain separated by systematic differences, both in their pursuit of cultural activities and in their cultural preferences, depending upon whether they come from a more or less cultivated milieu and for h o w long this has been so; their knowledge of the theatre (measured according to the average n u m b e r of plays that they have seen on the stage) or of painting is greater if their father or grandfather (or a fortiori, both of them) belongs to a higher occupational category and, further, in respect of a fixed value of each of these variables (the category

i. Cf. P. Bourdieu and A . Darbel, op. cit., p. 90. 2. Belonging to a social group characterized by a good rate of practice helps to maintain, sustain and strengthen the cultivated inclination; but the diffuse pressures and encouragements of the reference group are more keenly f e l t when the disposition to receive them (linked with art competence) is greater. (On the effect of exhibitions and tourism, more strongly inserted into collective rhythms than the ordinary visit to the museum, and consequently more likely to recall the diffuse norms of practice to those who have the highest cultural ambitions, that is to say to those who belong or who aspire to belong to the cultivated class, see P. Bourdieu and A . Darbel, op. cit., p. 51 and 115-19.) Thus, for instance, i f the majority of students display a kind of cultural bulimia, i t is because the stimulation to practice exerted by the reference group is, in this case, particularly strong, and also above allbecause admittance to higher education marks their entrance into the cultivated world, and therefore their access to theright,and what amounts to the same thing, to the duty, to appropriate culture.

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

607

of the father or of the grandfather), the other tends, per se, to hierarchize the scores.1 B y reason of the slowness of the acculturation process, subtle differences linked with the length of time that they have been in contact with culture continue therefore to separate individuals w h o are apparently equal in respect of social success and even of educational success. Cultural nobility also has its quarterings. 3.2.4.2 O n l y an institution like the school, the specific function of which is methodically to develop or create the inclinations which produce an educated m a n and which lay the foundations, quantitatively and consequently qualitatively, of a constant and intense pursuit of culture, could offset (at least partially) the initial disadvantage of those w h o d o not receive from their family circle the encouragement to undertake cultural activities and the competence presupposed in any dissertation o n works, on condition and only on condition that it employs every available means to break d o w n the endless series of cumulative processes to which any cultural education is condemned. For if the apprehension of a w o r k of art depends, in its intensity, its modality and in its very existence, on the beholder's mastery of the generic and specific code of the work, that is to say on his competence, which he owes partly to school training, the same thing applies to the pedagogic communication which is responsible, a m o n g other functions, for transmitting the code of works of scholarly culture (at the same time as the code according to which it effects this transmission), so that the intensity and modality of the communication are here again a function of culture (as a system of schemes of perception, expression and historically constituted a n d socially conditioned thinking) which the receiver owes to his family circle and which is m o r e or less close to scholarly culture and the linguistic and cultural models according to which the school effects the transmission of this culture. Considering that the direct experience of works of scholarly culture and the institutionally organized acquisition of culture which is a prerequisite for adequate experience of such works are subject to the s a m e laws (cf. 2.3.2, 2.3.3 a n d 2-3-4)> it is obvious h o w difficult it is to break the sequence of the cumulative effects which cause cultural capital to attract cultural capital: in fact, the school has only to give free play to the objective machinery of cultural diffusion without working systematically to give to all, in and through the pedagogical message itself, w h a t is given to some through family inheritance, that is to say the instruments which condition the adequate reception of the school message, for it to redouble and entrench b y its approval the socially conditioned inequalities of cultural competence, by treating them as natural inequalities, or in other words as inequalities of gifts. 3.3 Charismatic ideology is based on parenthesizing the relationship, evident as soon as it is revealed, between art competence and education, which alone its capable of creating both the inclination to recognize a
1. Cf. P. Bourdieu and J. C. Passeron, Les tudiants et leurs tudes, Paris, The Hague, Mouton, 1964, p. 96-7 (Cahiers du CSE, N o . 1.)

6o8

Pierre Bourdieu

value in cultural wealth and the competence which gives a meaning to this inclination by making it possible to appropriate such wealth. Since their art competence is the product of an imperceptible familiarization and an automatic transferring of aptitudes, m e m b e r s of the privileged classes are naturally inclined to regard as a gift of nature a cultural heritage which is transmitted b y a process of unconscious training. But, in addition, the contradictions and ambiguities of the relationship which the most cultured a m o n g them maintain with their culture are both encouraged and permitted by the paradox which defines the 'realization' of culture as becoming natural: culture being achieved only b y negating itself as such, that is to say as artificial and artificially acquired, so as to become second nature, a habitus, a possession turned into being, the virtuosi of the judgement of taste seem to reach an experience of aesthetic grace so completely freed from the constraints of culture and so little marked by the long, patient training of which it is the product that any reminder of the conditions and the social conditionings which have rendered it possible seems to be at once obvious and shocking (cf. 1.3.1). It follows that the most experienced connoisseurs are the natural champions of charismatic ideology, which concedes to the work of art a magical power of conversion capable of awakening the potentialities latent in a few of the elect, and which contrasts authentic experience of a work of art as a n 'affection' of the heart or immediate enlightenment of the intuition with the laborious proceedings and cold comments of the intelligence, ignoring the social and cultural conditions underlying such an experience, a n d at the same time treating as a birthright the virtuosity acquired through long familiarization or through the exercises of a methodical training; silence concerning the social prerequisites for the appropriation of culture or, to be more exact, for the acquisition of art competence in the sense of mastery of all the m e a n s for the specific appropriation of works of art is a self-seeking silence because it is what makes it possible to legitimatize a social privilege b y pretending that it is a gift of nature.1 T o remember that culture is not what one is but what one has, or, rather what one has become; to remember the social conditions which render possible aesthetic experience and the existence of those beingsart lovers or 'people of taste'for w h o m it is possible; to remember that the work of art is given only to those w h o have received the means to acquire the m e a n s to appropriate it and w h o could not seek to possess it if they did not already possess it, in and through the possession of means of possession as a n actual possibility of effecting the taking of possession; to remember, lastly, that only a few have the real possibility of benefiting by the theoretical possibility, generously offered to all, of taking advantage of the works

1. It is the same autonomization of 'needs' or 'propensities' in relation to the social conditions underlying their production which leads some people to describe as 'cultural needs' the opinions or the preferences actually expressed and actually established by surveys of cultural opinion or accomplishment and, in the absence of a statement or a denouncement of the cause, to sanction the division of society into those w h o feel 'cultural needs' and those w h o are deprived of this deprivation.

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

609

exhibited in m u s e u m s , all this is to bring to light the hidden mobile of the effects of the majority of culture's social uses. T h e parenthesizing of the social conditions which render possible culture and culture become nature, cultivated nature, having all the appearances of grace or a gift and yet acquired, so therefore 'deserved', is the condition precedent of charismatic ideology which makes it possible to confer o n culture and in particular o n 'love of art' the all-important place which they occupy in middle-class 'sociodicy'. T h e bourgeoisie find naturally in culture as cultivated nature and culture that has b e c o m e nature the only possible principle for the legitimation of their privilege: being unable to invoke the right of birth (which their class, through the ages, has refused to the aristocracy) or Nature which, according to 'democratic' ideology, represents universality, that is to say the ground on which all distinctions are abolished, or the aesthetic virtues which enabled the first generation of bourgeois to invoke their merit, they can resort to cultivated nature and culture b e c o m e nature, to what is sometimes called 'class', through a kind of tell-tale slip, to 'education', in the sense of a product of education which seems to o w e nothing to education,1 to distinction, grace which is merit and merit which is grace, a n unacquired merit which justifies unmerited acquisitions, that is to say inheritance. T o enable culture to fulfil its primary ideological function of class co-optation a n d legitimation of this m o d e of selection, it is necessary and enough that the link between culture and education, which is simultaneously obvious a n d hidden, be forgotten, disguised, and denied. T h e unnatural idea of inborn culture, of a gift of culture, bestowed o n certain people by Nature, is inseparable from blindness to the functions of the institution which ensures the profitability of the cultural heritage and legitimizes its transmission while concealing that it fulfils this function: the school in fact is the institution which, through its outwardly irreproachable verdicts, transforms socially conditioned inequalities in regard to culture into inequalities of success, interpreted as inequalities of gifts which are also inequalities of merit.2 Plato records, towards the end of The Republic, that the souls w h o are to begin another life must themselves choose their lot a m o n g 'patterns of life' of all kinds a n d that, w h e n the choice has been m a d e , they must drink of the water of the river Lethe before returning to earth. T h e function which Plato attributes to the water of forgetfulness devolves, in our societies, on the university which, in its impartiality, though pretending only to recognize students as equal in rights and duties, divided only by inequalities of gifts and of merit, in fact confers on individuals degrees judged according to their cultural heritage, and therefore according to their social status. B y symbolically shifting the essential of w h a t sets t h e m apart from other classes from the economic field to that of culture, or rather, by adding to
1. It was understood thus by a very cultivated old m a n w h o declared during a conversation 'Education, Sir, is inborn.' 2. Cf. P . Bourdieu, 'L'cole conservatrice', Revue franaise de sociologie, VII, 1966, p. 325-47 and in particular p . 346-7.

6io

Pierre B o u r d i e u

strictly economic differences, namely those created by the simple possession of material wealth, differences created by the possession of symbolic wealth such as works of art, or by the pursuit of symbolic distinctions in the m a n n e r of using such wealth (economic or symbolic), in short, by turning into a fact of nature everything which determines their 'value', or to take the word in the linguistic sense, their distinctiona m a r k of difference which, according to the Littr, sets people apart from the c o m m o n herd 'by the characteristics of elegance, nobility and good form'the privileged m e m b e r s of middle-class society replace the difference between two cultures, historic products of social conditions, by the essential difference between t w o natures, a naturally cultivated nature and a naturally natural nature.1 T h u s , the sacralizating of culture and art fulfils a vital function by contributing to the consecration of the social order: to enable educated m e n to believe in barbarism and persuade their barbarians within the gates of their o w n barbarity, all they must and need d o is to m a n a g e to conceal themselves and to conceal the social conditions which render possible not only culture as second nature in which society recognizes h u m a n excellence or 'good form' as the 'realization' in a habitus of the aesthetics of the ruling classes, but also the legitimized predominance (or, if you like, the legitimacy) of a particular definition of culture. A n d in order that the ideological circle m a y be completely closed, all they have to do is to find in an essentialist representation of the bipartition of society into barbarians and civilized people, the justification of their right to conditions which produce the possession of culture a n d the dispossession of culture, an estate of 'nature' destined to appear based on the nature of the m e n w h o are cond e m n e d to it. If such be the function of culture and if it be love of art which really determines the choice which separates, as by an invisible a n d insuperable barrier, those to w h o m it is given from those w h o have not received this grace, it can be seen that m u s e u m s betray, in the smallest details of their morphology and their organization, their true function which is to strengthen the feeling of belonging in some and the feeling of exclusion in others.2 Everything, in these civic temples in which bourgeois society deposits its
i. It is impossible to show here that the dialectics of divulgence and distinction are one of the driving forces for the change of patterns of artistic accomplishment, the distinguished classes being constantly driven b y the divulgence of their distinctive qualities to seek elements of distinction in n e w symbolic accomplishments (cf. P . Bourdieu, Un art moyen, p. 73 et seq. and: 'Condition de classe et position de classe', Archives europennes de sociologie, VII, 1966, p. 201-23). 2. It is not infrequent that working-class visitors express explicitly the feeling of exclusion which, in any case, is evident in their whole behaviour. Thus, they sometimes see in the absence of any indication which might facilitate the visit, arrows showing the direction to follow, explanatory panels, etc., the signs of a deliberate intention to exclude the uninitiated. T h e provision of teaching and didactic aids would not, in fact, really m a k e up for the lack of schooling, but it would at least proclaim the right not to know, the right to be there in ignorance, the right of the ignorant to be there, a right which everything in the presentation of works and in the organization of the m u s e u m combines to challenge, as this remark overheard in the Chteau of Versailles testifies: 'This chteau was not m a d e for the people, and it has not changed.'

Outline of a sociological theory of art perception

611

most sacred possessions, that is to say relics inherited from a past which is not its o w n , in these holy places of art, in which the chosen few c o m e to nurture a faith of virtuosi while conformists and bogus devotees c o m e and perform a class ritual, old palaces or great historic homes to which the nineteenth century added imposing edifices, built often in the GraecoR o m a n style of civic sanctuaries, everything combines to indicate that the world of art is as contrary to the world of everyday life as the sacred is to the profane: the prohibition to touch the objects, the religious silence which is forced upon visitors, the puritan asceticism of the facilities, always scarce and uncomfortable, the almost systematic refusal of any instruction, the grandiose solemnity of the decoration and the decorum, colonnades, vast galleries, decorated ceilings, monumental staircases, both outside and inside, everything seems done to remind people that the transition from the profane world to the sacred world presupposes, as Durkheim says, ' A genuine metamorphosis', a radical spiritual change, that the bringing together of the worlds 'is always, in itself, a delicate operation which calls for precaution and a m o r e or less complicated initiation', that 'it is not even possible unless the profane lose their specific characteristics, unless they themselves b e c o m e sacred to some extent and to some degree'.1 Although the work of art, owing to its sacred nature, calls for particular dispositions or predispositions, it brings in return its consecration to those w h o satisfy its demands, to the small elite w h o are self-chosen by their aptitude to respond to its appeal. T h e m u s e u m gives to all, as a public legacy, the m o n u m e n t s of a splendid past, instruments of the sumptuous glorification of the great figures of bygone ages: this is false generosity, because free entrance is also optional entrance, reserved for those w h o , endowed with the ability to appropriate the works, have the privilege of using this freedom and w h o find themselves consequently legitimized in their privilege, that is to say in the possession of the means of appropriating cultural wealth or, to borrow a n expression of M a x W e b e r in the monopoly of the handling of cultural wealth and of the institutional signs of cultural salvation (awarded by the school). Being the keystone of a system which can function only by concealing its true function,
i. E . Durkheim, Les formes lmentaires de la vie religieuse, Paris, P U F , i960, sixth edition, p. 55-6. T h e holding of a Danish exhibition showing m o d e m furniture and utensils in the old ceramic rooms of the Lille M u s e u m brought about such a 'conversion' in the visitors as can be summarized in the following contrasts, the very ones which exist between a multiple store and a m u s e u m : noisesilence; touchsee; quick, haphazard exploration, in no particular orderleisurely, methodical inspection, according to a fixed arrangement; freedomconstraint; economic assessment of works which m a y be purchasedaesthetic appreciation of 'priceless' works. However, despite these differences bound u p with the things exhibited, the solemnizing (and distancing) effect of the m u s e u m n o less continued to be felt, contrary to expectations, for the structure of the public at the Danish exhibition was more 'aristocratic' (in respect of level of education) than the ordinary public of the m u s e u m . T h e mere fact that works are consecrated b y being exhibited in a consecrated place is sufficient, in itself, profoundly to change their signification and, more precisely, to raise the level of their emission; were they presented in a more familiar place, a large e m p o rium for instance, they would be more accessible (cf. P . Bourdieu and A . Darbel, op. cit., p. 73-4 and 118).

6l2

Pierre Bourdieu

the charismatic representation of art experience never fulfils its function of mystifying so well as w h e n it resorts to a 'democratic' language: 1 to claim that works of art have power to awaken the grace of aesthetic enlightenment in any one, however culturally uninitiated he m a y be, to presume in all cases to ascribe to the unfathomable accidents of grace or to the arbitrary bestowal of 'gifts' aptitudes which are always the product of unevenly distributed education, a n d therefore to treat inherited aptitudes as personal virtues which are both natural and meritorious. Charismatic ideology would not be so strong if it were not the only outwardly irreproachable means of justifying the right of the heirs to the inheritance without being inconsistent with the ideal of formal democracy, and if, in this particular case, it did not a i m at establishing in nature the sole right of the middle class to appropriate art treasures to itself, to appropriate t h e m to itself symbolically, that is to say in the only legitimate m a n n e r , in a society which pretends to yield to all, 'democratically', the relics of an aristocratic past.2 [Translated from French]
i. For this reason care should be taken not to attach undue importance to the differences of pure form between the expressions 'aristocratic' and 'democratic', 'patrician' and 'paternalistic' in this ideology. 2. In thisfieldof education, the ideology of the gift f u l f i l s the same functions of camouflage: it enables an institution such as literary education in France, which provides an 'awakening education', to use M a x Weber's words, assuming between the teacher and the pupil a c o m munity of values and culture which occurs only when the system is dealing with its o w n heirs to conceal its real function, namely that of confirming and consequently legitimizing the right of the heirs to the cultural inheritance.

Pierre Bourdieu is Director of Studies at the Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes, Paris, and Deputy Director of its Centre for European Sociology. He is the author of L ' a m o u r d e l'art les m u s e s et leur public ( ig66), co-author of Un art moyenessai sur les usages sociaux d e la photographie (1965) and, most recently (with Jean-Claude Passeron and Jean-Claude Chamboredon), of L e mtier d e sociologie (thefirstvolume of three appeared in ig68). He has previously contributed an article on 'Systems of Education and Systems of Thought' to this Journal (Volume XIX, No. 3 , 1967).

T h e creative process in the popular arts

Roger L . B r o w n

It is generally agreed that the development of the mass media of c o m m u n ication since 1900 has brought about radical changes in the cultural life of advanced, industrialized societies. Similarly, most social historians would agree that the growing importance of the forms of popular culture disseminated via the mass media has hastened the final demise of m a n y folk cultures, and perhaps, too, of those local autonomous cultures which developed in the nineteenth century a m o n g the working classes of great cities. Serious discord and dissension arise concerning the effects of popular culture on the 'serious', 'high' or 'fine' arts. A n d w h e n critics consider the quality of the newer forms of popular culture, the views expressed rapidly become polarized and apparently irreconcilable. N o doubt this is partly due to the very vagueness of the concepts employed, a n d to the fact that the majority of themthe Bauers' 'mass culture', for example, or Shils' trichotomy of 'superior', 'mediocre' a n d 'brutal' cultural levelsare often used at the same time as both heuristic tools and as evaluative labels.3 Various rejoinders have been m a d e to the laments of the m o r e pessimistic critics. TofHer and Berelson seek to produce data which indicate that the a m o u n t of serious art produced and enjoyed is already very considerable and is o n the increase.2 T h e Bauers argue that the pessimism of the critics can be accounted for b y the fact that the critics themselves are elitist intellectuals occupying somewhat marginal positions in society, though this attempt at a 'sociology of knowledge' analysis of the situation has itself been attacked.3 A n alternative line of inquiry seems to be offered by
1. See: Raymond A . Bauer and Alice H . Bauer, 'America, Mass Society and Mass Media', The Journal of Social Issues,Vol. 16, N o . 3, i960, p . 3-66; and Edward Shils, 'Mass Society and its Culture', in: Norman Jacobs (ed.), Culture for the Millions, N e w York, 1961. The Bauers paper does attempt a critical examination of the term 'mass culture', but the authors m a y be charged with confusing it with 'mass society'. 2. See: Alvin Toffler, The Culture Consumers, N e w York, 1964; and Bernard Berelson, 'In the Presence of Culture...', Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol. 28, N o . 1,1964, p. 1-12. These reports deal only with the situation in the United States. 3. See: Lewis A . Coser, 'Comments on Bauer and Bauer', The Journal of Social Issues, Vol. 16, N o . 3, i960, p. 78-84.

Int. Soc. Sei. J., Vol. X X , N o . 4, 1968

6i4

Roger L . Brown

an examination of the m a n n e r in which contemporary popular culture is produced, and of the creative personnel involved. T h e approach is in fact suggested by the n u m b e r of available critical characterizations of popular culture which m a k e some direct or implicit reference to this phase of the cultural process. T h u s van den H a a g , for example, suggests that 'unlike any other type of culture, popular culturea full-fledged style of living with a distinct pattern of feeling, thinking, believing and acting was m a d e possible and in the end necessary by mass production'.1 Fiedler argues that 'the articles of popular culture are m a d e , not to be treasured, but to be thrown away. . . . T h e sort of conspicuous waste once reserved for an lite is n o w available to anyone . . .', 2 while Arendt, too, posits an essential similarity between popular culture and more tangible products: ' T h e wares offered by the entertainment industry are indeed consumed by society just as are any other consumer goods'. 3 It is perhaps unnecessary to stress that these remarks, notably the last two, not only suggest descriptions of popular culture and the w a y it is produced, but implicitly condemn product and process at the s a m e time. In brief, then, it has been frequently argued that popular culture is bound to be of inferior quality because of the manner in which it is characteristically produced: but this proposition deserves considerably greater scrutiny than it usually receives. M a n y of the agencies which produce popular culture are rightly referred to as industries if judged by the scale of their operations, the technologies they employ, and the w a y they are organized. But the real question to be asked is the extent to which industrial techniques are applied to the actual creative process.4 In as far as they are engaged in w h a t Williams has referred to as the 'multiple dissemination' of works of popular art,5 the responsible agenciespublishing houses, film studios, record companies and (to a limited extent) broadcasting organizationsdo m a k e use of industrial mass production techniques. Indeed, these techniques provide the only means by which standard copies of products can be sent quickly and cheaply to vast markets. Printing, the oldest of the mass media, has always been a mass-production industry in this sense: the press makes it possible to run off a virtually limitless edition of the same sheet from one forme of type. In the cinema industry, m a n y exhibition copies of the same film can be m a d e from the one master negative, just as m a n y copies of a record can be pressed from the same mould. A s far as the broadcasting media are concerned, the situation is different, since a modulated carrier w a v e is itself the technical basis of dissemination,

i. Ralph Ross and Ernest van den Haag, The Fabric of Society, N e w York, 1957, p. 167. 2. Leslie A . Fiedler, 'The Middle against Both E n d s ' , in: Bernard Rosenberg and David M . White (eds.), Mass Culture, N e w York, 1957, p. 539. 3. Hannah Arendt, 'Society and Culture', in: Norman Jacobs (ed.), op. cit., p. 48. 4. A n extended discussion of the topic is provided b y Edgar Morin, L'esprit du temps, Paris, 1962, chapter 2, 'L'industrie culturelle'. The present paper is m u c h indebted to this analysis of the situation. 5. T h e term serves to underline the fact that the media are, as technical devices, essentially neutral.

The

creative process in the popular arts

615

but, of course, broadcasting itself sprang from the projected development of a receiver-manufacturing industry. H o w e v e r , the fact that mass production techniques (and the bureaucratic, formal organizations that go with them) play a vital role in the circulation of works of popular art need not necessarily have any effect on the quality of what is produced or o n the w a y in which creative artists go about their business.1 Yet it is often assumed that the creative process in the world of the popular arts is itself organized in ways closely analagous to those d e m a n d e d b y the technologies of mass dissemination and the sheer size of the producing corporations. T h e tendency to blur the line between the creative and disseminatory activities of popular culture agencies is seen clearly enough in Coser's account: ' T h e industries engaged in the production of mass culture share basic characteristics with other mass production industries. In both, the process of production involves a highly developed division of labour and the hierarchical co-ordination of m a n y specialized activities. In these industries n o worker, no matter h o w highly placed in the organizational structure, has individual control over a particular product. T h e product emerges from the co-ordinated efforts of the whole production team, and it is therefore difficult for an individual producer to specify clearly his particular contribution.'2 Coser is here, of course, leading u p to a discussion of the place of the writer within the Hollywood film industry, and it m a y be that this description fitted the major Hollywood studios fairly accurately in their heyday before the advent of television. But it would serve rather less adequately today as a characterization of the production sector of the American film industry, given the recent rise of a n u m b e r of smaller, essentially ad hoc production companies. Indeed, it is worth suggesting that our thinking about the w a y popular culture is produced has been far too highly coloured by the state of affairs prevailing in the film industry of one particular country at one stage of its development. 3 O n e of the arguments implicit in Coser's description merits particular attention. B y saying that the mass culture industries are marked by 'the hierarchical co-ordination of m a n y specialized activities', the idea is planted that formal organizations of this sort are inherently inimical to the creation of worth-while works of art. It would, however, in fact be misleading to suggest that the production of works of art within the framework of complex, and possibly bureaucratic organizations necessarily means that the works themselves will lack artistic merit. T h e world's great opera and ballet companies are themselves large organizations within which the division of labour is carried quite as far as within one of the major Hollywood film companies. Yet there are,
1. The point is discussed more fully by Richard Hoggart, 'Mass Communications in Britain', in: Boris Ford (ed.), The Modern Age, Harmondsworth, 1961, p. 4+8. 2. Lewis A . Coser, Men of Ideas, N e w York, 1965, p. 325. 3. There is a considerable literature on the topic. See, in particular: Hortense Powdermaker, Hollywood the Dream Factory, N e w York, 1950; and Leo Rosten, Hollywood, N e w York, 1941.

6i6

Roger L . Brown

of course, differences (including differences in cultural 'level') between what is produced by an opera or ballet company and the type offilmw e associate with Hollywood, particularly in the era prior to television, and the reasons for these are not hard to find. In the first place, the policies of the institution concerned are of major importance in determining what the end product shall be like. In the case of the opera or ballet company, the major aim is to present the best possible performances of established and n e w works in the relevant media. In the case of the film companies, the overriding objective was commercial, particularly following the Depression, w h e n Hollywood studios c a m e and more under the control of financial and banking interests. T h e policy differences between these two types of artistic agencies would inevitably be reflected in the role assigned to the musical director or choreographer in the case of the opera or ballet c o m p a n y as against the less c o m m a n d i n g role assigned to the film director. But it would seem just as possible to give effective control to an artistic director within a complex organization as it is to give effective control to an accountant. T h e same type of structure can lend itself to a wide range of objectives.1 Again, on the basis of the foregoing account, it might be assumed that the mass culture industries approached their creative problems in a c o m pletely rational w a y , and applied the full range of cost-conscious business techniques to the task of turning out a stream of n e w products. However, from Powdermaker's account of the w a y in which a major Hollywood studio went about the task of producing a shooting script it seems to have been approached in a n extremely disorganized fashion, while the techniques employed to pre-cost a production were far less sophisticated than those one would expect to be applied in a normal manufacturing industry.2 It is interesting, too, that the very looseness of the formal structure seems to have allowed studio heads, producers and directors a good deal of scope for the expression of their 'artistic' temperaments. O f course, the technologies of the newer mediafilm and television- do call into being a whole n e w range of craft skills (those of lighting technicians, c a m e r a m a n , scenery crews, and so on) and the individuals filling these roles d o have to be organized and managed if the job is to be done at all. But the same set of skills can bring to birth a Potemkin or a Kane, or alternatively a ' B ' Western. T h e type of organization m a y be dictated by the technology of the m e d i u m , but the artistic quality of the finished product will have a great deal more to do with the ability of those performing the major creative functions and with the general sociocultural milieu.3 It must also be admitted, however, that an organized team of technicians is an instrument that lends itself very readily to the assembly-

i. A n interesting collection of essays on the problem of encouraging creativity within various types of formal organization is contained in Gary A . Steiner (ed.), The Creative Organization, Chicago, 1965. 2 Powdermaker, op cit., especially chapter 8, 'Assembling the Script'. 3. A recent attempt to develop a theoretical account of h o w particular cycles of films came to be m a d e is contained in George A . Huaco, The Sociology of Film Art, N e w York, 1965.

The creative process in the popular arts

6,7

line fabrication of highly stereotyped artistic works. T h e drama and c o m e d y series which currently dominate American network television andfilla considerable proportion of the p r o g r a m m e time of the television services in other countries, are produced in just this fashion, m a n y by offshoots of the original Hollywood 'Big Five'. It is worth asking about the conditions which lead to this highly mechanized use of production resources, and raising a query about its implications for the quality of the end product. T h e mass media of communication are commonly said to have a voracious appetite for n e w material, but of course this state of affairs is partially the media's o w n responsibility. Particularly with those media closely involved in, and heavily dependent on, consumer advertising, novelty is at a premium and becomes a major selling point. T h e style of the short stories or programmes within which the advertissements are embedded can be rendered effectively obsolescent merely by the introduction of n e w fashions. M o r e important, the economics of the media m a k e a constant supply of n e w work a necessity. A magazine retains its audience and stays in business by offering something n e w each week or each month, while the paperback-book industry depends on a complex distribution network and the display of a wide range of titles at the point of sale. Despite market research, public taste is only crudely predictable, so that a large n u m b e r of n e w products must be released annually if an adequate number of bestsellers is to emerge. T h e products of a broadcasting company are in the obvious sense inherently evanescent, and in competitive situations there is little inducement to revise materials which have been stored on tape or film. In all the media nowadays some n e w work of popular art reaches its entire potential market if not instantaneously, then within a period of days or weeks. Multiple dissemination itself m e a n s that the production agencies face a chronic shortage of n e w artistic material. T h e usual answer to this problem, of course, has been to re-use the same, basic artistic elements again and again, refurbishing and re-combining them so as to lend the newer versions the required appearance of novelty. A n author sitting d o w n to write a short story for a particular w o m e n ' s magazine will have at his disposal a n u m b e r of stock characters, dramatic situations, locales and ways of resolving the plot. T h e creative task n o w becomes that offittingthese elements together (no doubt with the addition of some genuinely n e w components) into a satisfactory gestalt. T h e possibilities are perhaps rather similar to those offered the architect by a set of standardized, modular constructional components, or available to the technician in control of a car assembly line, where a range of chassis, engines and bodies can be combined together into a number of distinct models. Saleability m a y also, of course, be more easily guaranteed if story elements already tested in the market are employed. Today, television series and serials probably e m b o d y the principle in its most obvious form, though film westerns and some of the longer sequences of detective novels also illustrate it. Naturally enough, critics of popular culture have

6i8

Roger L . Brown

condemned the end results of these replaceable-part operations as inevitably lifeless and stereotyped.1 It is, however, all too easy to import value judgements into the discussion in clandestine fashion. B y saying that the plots of film westerns or of television series tend to be 'stereotyped', a negative note is struck i m m e diately. However, the fact that a number of the necessary elements are provided for the writer w h e n he comes to prepare the script for a n e w film or n e w p r o g r a m m e m a y potentially be an artistic advantage. In one sense, the creative task is m a d e simpler, since a n u m b e r of constraints are already present: but this m a y allow the writer to concentrate more on the remaining tasks. Again, over time, it m a y be possible to explore all the permutations and combinations which the elements provided permit, and to discover which are artistically effective and which failures. Perhaps the position of the mass media artist working with already provided artistic elements is not so dissimilar in this respect to that of m a n y hundreds of 'serious' artists w h o have worked within established traditions in the past. Most artists, in fact, m a k e use of established formulae, whether it is the structure of the Elizabethan sonnet, drawing in perspective, the sonata form, or the twelve-tone scale. O f course, art does have a history, and the great landmarks of art were set by those artists w h o put traditional forms to radically n e w uses, or legitimated significant departures from established technique. But even the innovative genius builds on what has gone before: Hamlet is a Revenge Play, as well as being m u c h m o r e than that, while Measure for Measure is in part a Morality Play, as well as being m a n y times m o r e complex than its mediaeval forerunners. A t a m u c h lower level, film westerns such as Shane or High Noon m a k e use of an established genre as well as going beyond it to m a k e n e w comments and explore n e w h u m a n perplexities. Popular culture has its traditions, just as m u c h as the 'high' arts: it is the w a y that the tradition is used which is all-important, not the fact that a tradition exists. A n d the popular work which explores beyond the bounds of the tradition perhaps gains force from the very tension set u p between the conventions and the departures from it. If the popular culture disseminated via the media of mass communication does tend towards standardization and sameness, this m a y spring from factors other than the assembly-line methods resorted to by particular media at particular times. Popular culture agencies which are in competition for the same audience, whether the competition springs from attempts to increase advertising revenue, by maximizing 'guaranteed sales', or from some other source, will inevitably tend to ape each other. A magazine that manages to boost sales by means of a novel content formula quickly finds its rivals producing their o w n versions of the same material; and the same holds true with competing television channels. In fact, increasing the number of popular cultural agencies does not necessarily m e a n that a

5. A n interesting analysis of stereotypes is given in T . W . Adorno, 'Television and the Patterns of Mass Culture', Quarterly of Film, Radio and Television, Vol. 8, 1954, p . 213-35.

T h e creative process in the popular arts

619

wider range of products becomes available: just the opposite m a y happen; but this has m o r e to do with the over-all structure of the industry than with the tactics adopted by one firm to cope jwith a threatened famine of artistic material. But what are the consequences of the w a y popular culture is produced as far as the creative individuals involved are concerned? H o w does being a performing or creative artist within cultural industry differ from playing the equivalent role within the world of the 'high' arts? Unfortunately, all too little research has been conducted into the beliefs and motivations of media personnel, a n d only a very small fraction of what published research does exist is concerned with specifically artistic and creative workers.1 A s with descriptions of the w a y the creative process is organized, however, a n u m b e r of generalizations about these matters are current in the critical literature and themelves deserve similar scrutiny. It has, for example, often been suggested that working in the popular culture industries places considerable strain on the truly creative individual. Critics of popular culture argue that agencies which produce this type of output necessarily adopt a n instrumental orientation towards works of popular art, while the creative personnel employed regard their task as essentially expressive.2 Yet it can surely be argued that m a n y creators of 'high' art in the past have demonstrated a combination of instrumental and expressive motivations. T h e audiences to be expected at the Globe, and later the Blackfriars, are reflected in Shakespearian drama; and Shakespeare was a working dramatist with shares in the c o m p a n y he wrote for. Again, m u c h of the finest of Baroque music was written o n commission, and composers' careers depended on the satisfaction of clients. Going further back in time, accounts of the extent to which m a n y artists of the Italian Renaissance were answerable to the w h i m s of chronically indecisive patrons suggest that the existence of instrumental and essentially extra-artistic pressures d o not necessarily inhibit creative activity. In the case of popular art, the w a y in which managers, administrators andfinanciersview their audiences seems more important than the mere fact that relatively very large audiences are required to m a k e the enterprise viable.3 Along the same line, it has been implied that the poor quality of 'mass' culture is due to the fact that the writers and artists responsible are characteristically forced to work under severe time pressures in order to meet
i. Researchers have experienced considerable difficulty in gaining access to the mass media institutions. Artistic personnel in particular m a y be unsympathetic to research, since it comes to be perceived as something which might replace their o w n artistic judgement of what will be artistically and otherwise successful. This attitude is, of course, particularly related to market research, but then this is what 'research' means for m a n y media personnel. 2. There is a danger in thisfieldof making over-confident assumptions about the artist's orientation to his work and to the larger society. T h e idea that art is 'expressive' dates largely from the Romantic period. See also, in this connexion, Cesar Grana, Bohemian versus Bourgeois, N e w York, 1964. 3. For an attempt to characterize the major types of mass media system, see: R a y m o n d Williams, Communications, Harmondsworth, 1962, p . 88-96.

620

Roger L . Brown

deadlines determined by the rational organization of marketing operations. But m a n y acknowledged works of art have been produced during very brief, intense periods of activity (music perhaps provides the best examples). as well as under pressure from patrons. Sir Walter Scott produced his later novels in a vain race to repay enormous debts, while Dickens produced novels which still receive critical attention against deadlines determined by serial publication. Given these sorts of examples, it seems very hazardous to claim that the best artistic work is produced only at a certain pace and under an exactly specifiable set of conditions. Related to the idea of an inevitable clash between instrumental and expressive orientations is the notion that popular artists are necessarily alienated from their work. Again, this warrants careful examination. M a r x pointed out that the industrial employee merely sells his labour in the market and has no control over thefinishedproducts on which he performs some limited and intermediate operation, arguing that the inevitable result is alienation. T h e adequacy of this analysis has, of course, been challenged in the case of mass production industry itself; its applicability to popular culture agencies also needs questioning. In thefirstplace, too, m u c h has probably been m a d e of the idea that the popular artist necessarily lacks effective control over what he creates. There appear to be two arguments here: first, that the, institution rather than the individual decides what is to be produced; second, that a radical division of labour within cultural industry results in a fragmentation of creative responsibility. O n thefirstpoint, it seems likely that m a n y popular artists successfully internalize the aims of the industry they work for, so that it becomes meaningless to speak of an unwilling compliance with external constraints. Perhaps artists w h o have never considered the possibility of working elsewhere than in a popular cultural agency are most likely to internalize the institution's aims, but this is again properly a subject for empirical research, and not a question to be settled by a priori speculation. In his Men of Ideas, Coser entitles the chapter most relevant to this discussion 'Intellectuals in the Mass Culture Industries'.1 But this rather begs the question. Surely, too little is k n o w n about the recruitment patterns of creative personnel in the popular culture industries for us to assume that such people are necessarily m e m b e r s of the intelligentsia, with all the characteristics (both in terms of ability and in terms of critical detachment from social institutions) which that term connotes. Further, although there undoubtedly are cases o n record of serious artists being drawn into working within the 'mass' culture industries and experiencing considerable tension and alienation, this is perhaps not the point within a society at which feelings of alienation o n the part of the artist characteristically arise today. N a s h has suggested, on the basis of a social-psychological study of some two dozen 'serious' American composers, that these artists (some of w h o m , it is true, wrote film music) felt marginal
i. Coser, Men of Ideas, chapter 24.

T h e creative process in the popular arts

621

to contemporary American society.1 T h e suggested sources of their feelings of alienation include the fact that society at large regards their work with little interest, provides few opportunities for it to be performed, and hence offers little in the w a y of financial reward. It can indeed be argued that it is the 'serious' rather than the popular artist w h o is likely to feel alienated from modern society: the public for the serious artist is relatively small, while that for the popular arts is, by definition, enormous. 2 Alienation m a y stem just as m u c h from the value which society in general places on a given type of expertise as from the frustrations of the work situation. But the contention that the popular artist feels alienated from his work because he is only partially responsible for the finished product again invites specification of the particular circumstances w h e n this is likely to occur, and in which media. In television, and particularly infilms,the w a y in which a p r o g r a m m e or n e w feature is m a d e is necessarily complex, involving as suggested a wide range of technical and craft skills; and given these types of organization it is no doubt easier to take final control out of the hands of the producer or director. T h e very large capital investment often involved in one production m a y also predispose senior managers to play a virtually continuous role within the production process. E v e n here, however, the achieved status of the producer or director and the policies of the broadcasting organization or film c o m p a n y can m a k e a considerable difference. A n d in other media the situation m a y be quite different. Indeed, the actual working conditions of m a n y writers w h o currently turn out novels and stories with a popular audience in mind are inevitably little different from those w e traditionally associate with the craft. T h e authors of stories destined for popular magazines, particularly w o m e n ' s magazines, are mainly freelances, so that they are not in a strict sense m e m b e r s of the formal organizations of the publishing house. While their o w n abilities and the audience they are working for determine the c o m plexity, originality and artistic value of what they write, the task itself can only be tackled in the s a m e w a y that the writer's task has always had to be tackled. Whether the finished product is to be a great and innovatory novel or a short story for some 'slick' or 'pulp' magazine, there is no escape from the pen or typewriter and the stack of blank sheets. T h e writer is in virtually complete control of the process (subject to editorial suggestion and the necessity to revise, constraints which m a y also be present in the case of the 'serious' novelist); and there seems little reason for the writer to become alienated from his work o n account of the w a y the production process itself is organized. Indeed, such testimony as is available from popular writers of fiction suggests just the opposite: they claim to derive a considerable degree of personal satisfaction from the work they d o . 3 T h e division of
1. Dennison Nash, ' T h e Alienated Composer', in: Robert N . Wilson (ed.)., The Arts in Society, Englewood Cliffs, 1964. 2. But see the works referred to in footnote 2, page 613. 3. In this connexion, the replies to Mrs. Leavis's survey of successful popular writers are worth studying. See: Q . D . Leavis, Fiction and the Reading Public, London, 1932, particularly chapter 3, 'Author and Reader'.

622

Roger L. Brown

labour m a y be carried a long w a y in the publishing house itself (and, of course, in the printing plant) but this m a y affect the specifically creative personnel very little.1 So far as the newer media are concerned, empirical researchers might well set themselves the task of analysing the situational factors affecting the degree of control which creative individuals can exercise over the finished product. A s suggested above, there are clear and obvious differences between media (notably perhaps between the print media and the others); but there are probably also important variations within a particular m e d i u m . A record of impressive successes at the box office, or a succs d'estime with one's colleagues, n o doubt provides an artist with considerable bargaining power, currency he can cash for an extra measure of control over what he produces. A n analysis of the biographies of creative personnel in different media might well furnish material for a more subtle analysis of this career variable. It seems possible, too, that the effects of a progressive division of labour within society m a y in one w a y bear m o r e heavily on the 'serious' artist than on the popular. N a s h has suggested that the lack of a feeling of genuine musical community in the United States at the present time is due to a n u m b e r of factors which serve to distance the composer from his audience.2 T h e fact that the mass media of communication n o w provide one of the major channels through which music is disseminated is put forward as one reason, but Nash places greater stress on the fact that roles within the musical world have n o w become intensively specialized, so that the composer is seldom the performer, while thosefillingthe specialized roles of entrepreneur, critic and teacher have important parts to play in structuring his relations with the consuming public. If w e argue that it is important for the serious composer to feel in close touch with his audience (particularly w h e n his position in society is highly marginal), then the proliferation of middlemen m a y be more damaging for the 'high' than the popular arts. Again, the critic is considerably less important as far as the popular arts are concerned, than in respect of the serious arts. It m a y be traditional for the theatre-going public to read (and take notice of) reviews of n e w plays on Broadway or in the West E n d : it is far less characteristic of the general cinema-going public to take equally serious notice of film reviews. W h a t G a n s has termed the 'creator-audience relationship' m a y present few problems for the successful popular artist, while for the m o r e avant garde composer or writer it can prove a constant source of unease.3 Yet even if it is admitted that the degree to which popular artists feel alienated from their work has probably been exaggerated, there are other possible sources of strain for creative personnel. Since only a small percentage
i. Becoming a free-lance writer, of course, and hence moving quite outside the immediate control of editors, is often regarded as a mark of achievement. 2. Nash, op. cit. 3. Herbert J. Gans, 'The Creator-Audience Relationship in the Mass Media: an Analysis of Movie Making', in: Bernard Rosenberg and David M . White (eds.), op. cit.

T h e creative process in the popular arts

623

of those w h o serve some form of artistic apprenticeship are able to earn an adequate living from 'high' art, the agencies responsible for the production of popular works are likely to contain a n u m b e r of individuals w h o feel that they are functioning at a lower level than their abilities justify. Their m o r e successful peers m a y still serve as an important comparative reference group, and consequent feelings of relative deprivation m a y engender chronic dissatisfaction: but again there is all too little empirical evidence about the existence and location of individuals of this type. Further, a n u m b e r of alternative reference groups exist for the popular artist. T h e esteem of colleagues m a y c o m e to be the most sought-after reward, while the camaraderie of the work situation (in films and television particularly) m a y effectively insulate an artist from those other worlds to which he once aspired. Even so, there no doubt still exist artists w h o feel that they are prostituting themselves by working within the domain of popular culture; yet Gans has suggested that even this situation m a y have its positively functional aspects: ' M u c h of our popular culture is produced by creators whose personal tastes are "higher" than those of their audiences. Although this relationship breeds problems of role, morale, and product quality, it m a y also provide the creator with enough emotional distance between himself and the audience to permit h i m to create for an audience of so m a n y different publics.'1 Here again, however, there are differences between the media: while the cinema industry has so far m o v e d only a short distance in the direction of catering to the tastes of specialized audiences, social differentiation (in terms of leisureand life-styles particularly) is increasingly reflected in the output of the magazine industry.2 W h e n minorities b e c o m e large enough to constitute markets worth catering to, the popular artist is given n e w inducements to specialize in a particular type of work. A writer m a y specialize not merely in short-story writing, but in the construction of romantic stories designed to appeal to w o m e n from a particular socio-economic background. So although the writer is in charge of turning out the story, and the division-of-labour principle is not applied to the creative task in the sense of fragmenting it, still the writer m a y have little chance to widen his or her scope. A n d it is possible to find examples of a similar degree of specialization within the performing arts, notably in the ' p o p ' music world, where a particular singer becomes identified with a characteristic type of song and style of presentation. Indeed, the product differentiation which springs from marketing considerations itself provides a spur towards creative specialization; and the expertise which springs from successful specialization m a y itself be a source of status and the ground in which a minor sort of professionalism m a y flourish.
1. ibid. 2. S o m e discussion of the current range of British periodicals is given in David Holbrook, 'Magazines', in: Denys T h o m p s o n (ed.). Discrimination and Popular Culture, Harmondsworth, 1964. Holbrook regards the highly specialized periodicals as the most worth while.

624

Roger L . Brown

But even if s o m e allowance is m a d e for the particular creative possibilities provided by situations in which the r a w materials are largely 'given', it can still be argued that constraints of this type are inimical to true creativity, rather than supportive of it. Yet the inbuilt 'dynamic obsolescence' of m u c h popular culture,1 the search for novelty, a n d the institutional need for product differentiation all m e a n that a considerable p r e m i u m is placed o n the invention or discovery of essentially n e w formulae, which will b e progressively re-worked in their turn until themselves supplanted. It m a y be at this point in the creative cycle that a particular, and n o doubt limited sort of originality reaps its highest rewards. M o r e generally, the fact that tastes change (or are changed) m e a n s that the popular culture industries cannot reduce their operations to the level w h e r e automatons b e c o m e adequate replacements for h u m a n beings. Specialization, whether or not this is accompanied b y fragmentation of the creative task, loss of control, or psychic withdrawal, is in fact o n e manifestation of a broader trend. In terms of style, m e d i u m , intended audience, level of seriousness a n d degree of innovation, the range of artistic products available today is far wider than a hundred years ago. Perhaps it is not surprising that social critics have tended to react to this situation by setting u p a simple set of categories which furnish both a m e a n s of bringing order out of chaos, and the starting point for a hostile critique of most sorts of majority culture. T o date, such schemata have perhaps been accepted too readily. B y looking at the differences between media, b y searching for similarities a n d differences between the w o r k a n d working conditions of popular and other artists, a n d b y studying the various constraints imposed by technology, marketing economics a n d institutional policy, it m a y b e possible to arrive at a less rigid analysis. 1. This phrase is made a key term in Vance Packard, The Waste Makers, New York, i960.

Roger L. Brown is a research officer at the Centre for Mass Communication Research, University of Leicester, England. He was formerly a staff member of the Institute for Communications Research at the University of Illinois. He is the author of Wilhelm von Humboldt's Conception of Linguistic Relativity (IQ6J).

The mass public at grips with mass communications

Roger Clausse

In the middle, the work created or produced, the substance of the message. O n the left, the message-sending mechanism, constructed and organized for mass coverage. O n the right, the public, the mass of the population, the target and recipient of the message. Such is the mass communication triptych. T h e final critical point (temporally) in a long and hazardous process: the audience reaction, which will vitalize, neutralize or kill the message. This crucial reaction is the central element of a specific form of sociology, the sociology of mass communications through the m e d i u m of the daily press, films, radio and television, for without it, without this response by the public, all the rest is annulled and meaningless: the message is lost, whatever its value, and the mechanism is useless, whatever its power. O f this 'public'with the 'work' and its vehicle, a component element of the communication phenomenonour knowledge is small and w e have it on the authority of a pioneer in onefield,Paul E . Lazarsfeld, that little progress is discernible in this respect. Richard Nixon goes still further with the statement that if some of our ideas based o n applied research have broken d o w n in recent years, it m a y be because they lacked a firm substratum of pure science. These assertions by competent scientists, and m y o w n observations not only in the course of a long career with the Belgian Radio and Television but also in m y capacity as director of the Centre d'Etude des Techniques de Diffusion Collective, have convinced m e that the reaction to the pressure of the mass media is a sociological phenomenon of which our knowledge is still small and poor and that the problem must be re-examined from its most generally accepted data and bases u p . In the present paper I shall deal broadly with two interrelated subjects: the basic typology of the mass public and the variations in the effect of messages.

Int. Sac. Sei. J., Vol. X X , N o . 4, 1968

6a6

Roger Clausse

Basic typology of the public

There is one fact which from the outset complicates the task of the sociologist looking into social communication. In the present age, as Girod points out, social evolution and technical progress have produced a n unprecedented phenomenonthe 'mass public' or, m o r e concretely, large-scale participation by a multitude of h u m a n beings in the same happenings, alike on the plane of thought and feeling and o n that of action. These multitudes, generally formless, b e c o m e , by the nature of the situation, the principal responders to the techniques of mass communication. It is with them that w e shall have to reckon, as regards the 'work' and the technique alike; it is on them that w e have to act, and no longer on single individuals, small personalized groups or homogeneous communities. The 'mass public' of the sociologist O n e of the fundamental characteristics of the public of today is that it is a 'mass public', a huge, inchoate socio-cultural compost in which everything is mixed u p together. M y colleague, the sociologist Henri Janne, describes this compost as follows in an article in the Belgian review Socialisme ( M a y 1960) : ' A social class, i.e., a social group distinguished by homogeneity of activity and status, a c o m m o n outlook and culture, group solidarity and a characteristic w a y of life, is a sociological category. . . . ' W h a t is tending to replace the class-based situation is a n emergent urban m o d e of living represented by what is called the "mass public". T h e trend is for this n e w social milieu to gather in the majority of the people in Western societies and it exerts a cultural influence, unconscious but real, on the whole of the society. . . . ' W e are witnessing the crystallization of a group which is a sociological monstrosity, inasmuch as the "mass public" is neither a crowd, nor a n e w social class, nor a stratum. . . .' This 'mass public' which the sociologists are studying, not without perplexity and confusion, is definable in terms of certain original attributes which I have abstracted from the relevant literature and which are outlined below: 1. Monstrous sociological grouping gradually crystallizing. 2. U r b a n m o d e of life in huge concentrations of population, imitated and widely current even in the countryside; high intensity-level of contact, physical closeness, sustained mingling; absence of community bonds, intimacy and primary connexions. 3. High intensity-level of intellectual communications, multiple pressures on the publicdiverse, incoherent and divergent, coherent and convergent, ephemeral and sustained; invasion of m e n ' s minds by the milieu (noise, images, entertainments, newspapers, radio, cinema, television, publicity, lighting, etc.).

The mass public at grips with mass communications

627

4. A standardized culture, superficial, psychologically penetrating, h o m o genizing, permeant, unremitting, pressuring, barring any turning back, brushing aside the barriers of the critical spirit, emotionally seductive, effective. 5. Predominance of tertiary activities, of 'organizations', of facelessness; fractionated work, dehumanized, without appeal or fixating force, complex-forming and constricting. 6. Loss of w a y of traditional ideologies which are replaced by concrete offers of service; depolitization; quest for functional efficiency per se situating it in a spiritual frame of reference; projection instead of myths, utopianism, shift from respect for persons (intrinsic signs) to respect for things (external signs). 7. Consumer societies, affluent societies, societies at grips with a growing excess of leisure (leisure societies), societies at grips with the democratization of education as a result of demographic pressure (study-centred civilization). The 'mass public' of the information media It is here, in this 'mass public', thus broadly defined, in this socio-cultural milieu of singular complexity in its incoherence, that w e get the primary beaten zone of the messages put out haphazardly by the mass c o m m u n i c a tion techniques. It is a m o n g that public that the mass media will acquire an audience as best they m a y and get a hearing, drawing in thousands, millions, of individuals of all classes, races, creeds, and ages and of either sex. A m o n g this 'mass public'diversified, formless, shifting, artificial which our civilization engenders and makes prosper, the information media will seek their o w n mass public, whose fundamental characteristic is likewise the isolation of every m e m b e r in consequence of the disruption of the primary links and of the profound and irremediable heterogeneity of the component groups a n d individuals. However, the audience thus built u p by the mass media acquires distinctive characteristics which differentiate iteven profoundlyfrom the 'mass public' of the sociologists. U n d e r the relentless pressure of the messages emitted by the press, the films, radio a n d television (the information media par excellence) this fundamentally heterogeneous audience becomes organizedat least at times, and under certain circumstancesinto a bona fide sociological category, even a kind of social class. In other words, at particular times and under particular circumstances, this fortuitous and ephemeral combination of separate individuals adopts a m o d e of living marked by similar ways of thinking and feeling, supports c o m m o n interests and aims, reacts as a h o m o geneous bloc to identical pressures or stimuli, starts off on the s a m e foot at the same pace, and calls with one voice for the satisfaction of the same needs. There is thus a p h e n o m e n o n of homogenizationbe it only m o m e n t a r y

628

Roger Clausse

of heterogeneous groups, which, without the techniques of mass c o m m u n i cation, would remain isolated and hermetically sealed off from one another. As a result of the persistent action of the major information media, a progressive crystallization of a sociological monstrosity (as Henri Janne calls it) is necessarily taking place by a fortuitous but effective cohesion and structuration of the heterogeneous multitudes. A community of needs, of aspirations, of intents, of cultural tastes and w h i m s is acquiring substance and structure. It gives unmistakable evidence of its existence in moments of tension and crisis, like panics, but it is also discernible daily in c o m m o n place conversations and exchanges of ideas or views where the messages of the information techniquesfigureconstantly and decisively. Consequently, with the prior aid of a collection of factors which create and perpetuate the 'mass public'demographic concentration, urbanization, functional isolation, anonymity, social conformism, leisure, etc.the mass information techniques are creating and maintaining a 'mass solidarity and mass processes of interaction' (R. Girod), which they would probably be powerless to create and develop alone. T h e y homogenize the mass public, at least intermittently and in certain circumstances. O n the plane of culture and civilization, where they reign supreme, they mould the formless masses and give them a framework. T h e y seek and exploit the masses' cultural 'highest c o m m o n factor' and provide them with a standardized, not to say vulgarized, pabulum which will satisfy the largest possible number. T h e y influence, excite and assuage. A n d all thiswe would supposewithout any concerted intention or systematic plan, but by a slow and continuous infiltration, with unbelievable wastage of messages and in an indescribable hurly-burly. Another fundamental characteristic of the mass communication techniques' public is directly visible even to the least experienced observer. That is its essential instability, evinced qualitatively in the varying intensity of each individual's participation in the totality, the ' W e ' , and quantitatively in the ever-shifting extent of the audience. T h e intensity of participation in the ' W e ' is in constant fluctuation between numerous states of differential linking and unlinking, participation and withdrawal, merging or dissociation by the individuals w h o form it. T o use Georges Gurvitch's terminology in a slightly different sense, these differing states of fusion boil d o w n to three fundamental notions: mass, community, c o m m u n i o n . M a s s , community and c o m m u n i o n do not signify physical groups or collectivities, but simply degrees of mental fusion in the ' W e ' (total public under consideration)to a m i n i m u m extent at the level of the mass, to a m e d i u m extent at that of the community and to a m a x i m u m extent at that of c o m m u n i o n . T h e techniques of information are a cause of intermittent fusion, to varying degrees according to the nature of the messages sent out, each of which has a different potential of attraction. T h e effect of the mass media on the public would be hard to understand if one did not take into account

The mass public at grips with mass communications

629

the fact that the cohesion and homogenization of a naturally heterogeneous audience fluctuate continually in strength and intensity between simple contact and very casual participation at one end of the scale and veritable fusion at the other. W h e n newspaper readers, radio listeners and television viewers are put into direct contact ('living the incident') with the great events which awaken and sharpen interest and sensibility, such as the brutal death of the head of a State, the splendours of a queen's coronation or a thrilling sporting event, a tremor runs from person to person through the discrete ' W e ' , a c o m m o n soul is born and takes shape, a c o m m o n impulse stirs and excites the whole audience. All these strangers, isolated or congregated, far or near, are wholly at one; contact is m a d e between them, overriding obstacles and distances. A c o m m u n i o n , a profound merging in the ' W e ' , buds, grows and flowers, making hearts beat as one, cancelling distance and obstacles, to unite the isolated individuals in a great expression of togetherness. W h e n these same persons turn their concerned and anxious attention to the news of the day, good or bad, pleasant or unpleasant, andwhen the announcement comesjoin together at the same times on the same incoercible impulse to learn what is happening in the vast, threatening world, the same interest and the same need which conjoin them at a c o m m o n time for a c o m m o n purpose m a k e t h e m into a bona fide community, scattered no doubt but coherent, where everyone feels he has his place with the rest. All of them have a feeling of togetherness, of being linked, and at that m o m e n t they form a coherent collectivity. However, it is a matter of observation that this immersion in the ' W e ' is precarious, at the mercy of the slightest distraction, and unlike the previous example does not procure for the individual the warmth of a contact physically sensed. Finally, w h e n the same newspaper readers, listeners or viewers turn as a matter of habit to 'their' mass m e d i u m in their hours of relaxation to pick out the varied fare their gluttony demands, to satisfy their hankerings for 'culture', and for amusement and release from the constraints of their daily lives, this vast assemblage, getting its homogeneity from a c o m m o n pabulum, is little more than a conglomeration of individuals, a fortuitous encounter where the association with the ' W e ' is weak, as is the pull exerted by the whole on the individual participants. This mass 'assembles' daily for its appointment with the information media, but its cohesion and even its coherence are slight; it is mere 'contact'. T h u s the audience shifts from state to statecommunion (with merging), community (with participation), and mass (with contact)under the impact of messages whose persuasiveness and efficacity vary constantly with the time and the day. T h e importance of this situation lies in the fact that the receivability and penetrating power of messages or communications are strictly dependent on the listener's degree of association with the ' W e ' : the more intense the latter, the m o r e efficacious the diffusion of the message and the greater its

630

Roger Clausse

significance. Here w e have a state of affairs taken into account by the 'sender', often unconsciously. B y increasing the 'receiver's' participation level, even artificially, the sender optimizes his communication's chances of being at once understood and m o r e effective. Hence the frenzied search for the sensational. T h e essential instability of the public is also apparent in the constant quantitative fluctuations of audiences, leading in some quarters to the postulation of 'publics' (for this or that), coupled with denial of the existence of the global 'mass public'. T h e fact is that, under the combined or c o m peting influence of two factors, the intrinsic nature of the communication and the distractive pressure of external circumstances, audiences increase, diminish, widen, shrink or thin out. T h e y vary from huge to large, large to small, small to non-existent. F r o m day to day, hour to hour, and minute to minute, the n u m b e r of mass media 'customers' or consumers varies enormously and twofold, tenfold or a hundredfold increases are attained without apparent effort. A glance a the curve of radio audiences (Fig. 1 ) provides concrete evidence of these quantitative variations under the combined or competing action of the two factors noted above, i.e., the nature of the communication and the surrounding circumstances. W e see that, on the one hand, according to the greater or lesser appeal, essentiality or utility of the messages grouped in programmes (functions), and, on the other, according to the moral, physical or emotional obstacles arising from constantly changing circumstances, audiences increase or shrink abruptly and massively. But this is not all; within the public reached or affected by the messages, there are constant variations, difficult to evaluate, in the distribution of the individuals by social categoriessocio-economic, socio-professional, or socio-cultural, age group, sex, etc. A n additional p h e n o m e n o n complicating the situation is that of the succession of drastic contractions or reductions from the extensive public (the total population or sociological universe) to the potential public (simply exposed to the action of the mass media), from the potential to the effective public (reachable at a given time and place), and from the effective public to the public reached b y the particular message and,finally,to the public affected (which retains an impress from the message). These observations themselves raise serious questions. For what is observed at one given time and place is not necessarily true at another time and place; what is true of one audience is not necessarily so of another differing quantitatively and qualitatively from the first. Consequently, the essential instability of the public involved is a major obstacle to sociological analysis which here encounters almost insoluble problems, inasmuch as social science is ill-equipped methodologically w h e n required to grasp the dynamics of reactions and situations. T o recapitulate: the mass information techniques, i.e., for our purposes, the press, films, radio and television, automatically and inevitably turn to

The mass public at grips with mass communications

631

Break fast music

' F ' w o m a n s mac azi ne (mixed programme)

Midday

news

(mixed programme)

25%

1 1

""**> T

1 1

i
2 c n 1 1 \

; weather, m
4 1

1
N e w s review Press review

Newsr

1
4 >

i>

of br oadca st

ltural events -

15%

J -

10%

1 *>

1 1 1 M

1
l/l

ii
">

0 V S
V ~7

* 2
0

) -r

z_ _

0 0

iPublic r e a c h e d ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ B

6h 6h30

7h

8h

r
9h

10h
*ork

llh
housework shopping

12h

13h
meal noon break

14

Rising and dressing, breakfast

work housework errands 'going out

Fio. I . Curve of variations in numbers of the 'public'. According to message (the programme) and situation (occupations). Numbers listening in to Belgian radio broadcasts; on one day selected at random in 1966between 6 a . m . and 2 p . m . the global 'mass public' of the sociologists for their o w n public, their specific audience. T h e latter, after the pattern of the mass public in general, is a socio-cultural agglomeration of heterogeneous groups. U n d e r the impact of the messages a n d the action of external circumstances and occurrences, the audience achieves organization a n d homogeneity, at least for a while a n d in certain situations. But its basic instability is high as regards both individual involvement in the whole and the nature of the whole's social content and in the quantitative extent of the whole.

T h e public and diffused 'culture'

Suppose w e set ourselves at a selected point in space and time. W e shall find a vast bulk of 'cultural' messages of every description, from all points

s pro

1
-

632

Roger Clausse

of the c o m p a s s , a n d w i t h a w h o l e r a n g e of vehicles (papers, films, radio w a v e s ) converging o n us, h e m m i n g us in a n d assailing us o n every side. It is f r o m this a b u n d a n t fall of m a n n a that w e shall d r a w out spiritual a n d intellectual sustenance, driven as w e are b y incoercible needs a n d subject as w e are to clamorous importunity. W h a t leaps to the eye is that it is a practical impossibility, both mentally a n d physically, for us to take, assimilate a n d retain everything that is offered to us. A b u n d a n t l y diffused in every direction a n d nicely p a c k a g e d to t e m p t o u r insatiable appetites, this cultural material will not a n d c a n n o t b e assimilated in its entirety. E a c h of us will grasp only a tiny fragment of it, differing quantitatively a n d qualitatively with the individual as his personal choice a n d the situations a n d circumstances determine. o f his life m a y

The quantitative aspect H e r e there is a n i m m e n s e purely m e c h a n i c a l wastage w h i c h is illustrated in Figure 2 .

F I G . 2 . T h e quantitative aspect.

Cultural messages offered

Receivable

Received Registered Internalized

Cultural messages offered: all the messages diffused by all the mass media at any time in any place. Receivable messages: all the messages put out by all the mass media at a given time in a given place. Messages received: all the m e s sages put out by a particular mass m e d i u m at a given time in a given place and received by a n individual. Message registered: a particular message diffused by particular information media at a given time in a given place, received by an individual and appropriated to himself. Message internalized: message registered, impressed o n the m e m o r y and taking its place in our cultural frames of reference.

If w e take 100 to represent the s u m o f the messages offered b y all the m a s s m e d i a at a given time in a given place, then, in this place a n d at the m o m e n t o f this writing, the total n u m b e r of messages received will b e

The mass public at grips with mass communications

633

represented by zero, and similarly for the messages registered and, a fortiori, for those internalized. This evening, at h o m e , the figure representing the n u m b e r of messages received will be 1 at any m o m e n t with a wastage of 99 for 100 messages offered. As regards messages registered, there will be a wastage, varying with the individual, from the succession of single messages received. This must be added to the over-all wastage and the p h e n o m e n o n will be repeated in aggravated form in respect of internalized messages. T h e picture is thus one of shameless extravagance with material, effort disproportionate to the results, prodigality rationally unjustifiable and shocking waste of substance and energy. The qualitative aspect O n this plane, that of the content of the messages diffused, there is also considerable loss of substance. Let us assume that the totality of the messages diffusedclassified according to function for the sake of simplicitygives us, at a given time and place, the representation shown below in the diagram of message structure (Fig. 3). At the 'registered' message level, w e getallowing for the unavoidable wastage already noted at the purely quantitative levela representation completely different both in the content of each function and in the distribution of the functions. But what w e have here is not only mechanical, but also 'psychological' wastage, as two psychological laws c o m e into play in the 'registration' and internalization of the messages diffused, whose effect is to reduce the n u m b e r and modify the nature of such messages. T h efirst,which is also most important as regards the effkacity of mass media, is the law of functional registering and the internalizing selectivity, whereby the registering in thefirstplace and then the internalization of external stimuli depends on the individual functional characteristics of each person. W e m a k e a systematic choice and deliberately exclude whatever does not accord with our needs, our tastes and even our m o m e n tary w h i m s . This law of selectivity has a corollary in which the conscious, m o r e or less organized act of choosing is renounced: this is an unconscious defence mechanism against external assaults o n the psyche, be they physicalnoise for instanceor mental, as is the case with the massive diffusion of messages. Here the individual defends himself by developing a strong barrier against all stimulations, whether favourable or unfavourable, good or bad. T h e effect of the aggressionsmessages in the present caseis kept within physically and psychically tolerable limits and sometimes suppressed altogether. U n d e r the threefold action of mechanical wastage, the law of selectivity and the defence mechanism, the representation of the messages registered

634

Roger Claussc

FIG. 3. Functional structures of messages diffused and messages registered (shaded) in a given place and at a given time. (and even m o r e the image of the messages internalized) will differ greatly from the representation of messages diffused, as Figure 3 shows. This situation, here illustrated childishly but eloquently, has extremely important consequences in the d o m a i n of sociological reflection. If, as s o m e critics affirm, there is an element of cultural levelling in the activities of the information media, it undoubtedly applies to the total mass of messages for diffusion b y reason of both the manifestly indigestible volume of communications a n d their ordering in the social functions which are systematizations of activities. H o w e v e r , our diagram shows that it is not necessarily true at either the 'registration' or the 'internalization' level. T h e characteristics observable at the emission levelmass orientation, standardization, vulgarization, 'snippets', distortion of cultural values, incoherence, etc.are not necessarily found at the registering and internalizing levels, thanks to the triple filter of external constraints, unconscious selectivity, and the defence mechanisms.

The mass public at grips with mass communications

635

A n d even if they do recur at these levels it is with neither the same force, the same meaning nor the s a m e consequences. Moreover, thanks to the aggregate action of the variations from person to person in message registration and internalization, the public exhibits a degree of imperviousness to the pressure of the mass media and safeguards the strongest and most intimate part of its personality without too m u c h difficulty. Its resistance to attempts at mass conditioning is greater than is c o m m o n l y believed, as the classical example of political elections clearly shows. It might be said that within the little-known processes of mass conditioning other still less k n o w n individualization processes are taking root which can be conceived of as safeguarding the essential part of individual and collective personality, notwithstanding the insistent pressure of an enormous mass of slanted messages. T o talk of 'mass culture', to write whole books about it, to pass judgem e n t on it as such, whether adverse or favourable, is a priori suspect and even reprehensible, unless what w e have seen to be an elementary precaution is taken, namely to begin by determining the level of observation. For, I repeat, what is true on the emission level is not necessarily true at the registering or internalizing levels.

Variations in the effect of communications on the public In the course of long professional experience in Belgian radio and television, and particularly in the course of 'explosive' events, both national and international (the panic of 1940, the Liberation, the abdication of the king, the Korean W a r , the Marcinelle mine disaster, etc.), m y o w n direct and unfettered observation m a d e it clear to m e that the reaction of the mass media public presents at least two very different phases, that there are two types of reaction, two intensity levels in the effect produced by the messages diffused. O nfirstbecoming abruptly aware of the event, the immediate reaction is generally violent, unreasoned, unidirectional, ephemeral, obsessing. Thereafter the diverse and often divergent pressures of the situational milieu m a k e the reaction less violent, less obsessing, more pondered, stabler and m o r e open to other influences, though sometimes with recrudescences of the first reaction. For any given message, then, there is likely to be a difference of intensity in the effect according to the social level and m o m e n t at which it strikes. However, message-effect has another characteristic involving its actual nature: it varies with the function of the message. For each of the social functions served by the mass media (information, training, artistic expression, 'pressuring', or psychotherapy) the effects are qualitatively different. For instance, the impact o n the learner and his reaction at learning the news (information) are highly characteristic and cannot be confused with other message effects; thus they are very different fromeven the reverse

636

Roger Claussc

ofthe impact of, a n d reaction to,firstacquaintance with artistic productions (expression). Let us examine this situation a little m o r e closely, considering successively the nature of the effect according to the function of the message a n d its intensity according to social level a n d m o m e n t in time set out in a bidimensional schema, a n d thereafter the consequences of this for the sociology of the mass media. Nature of the effect In Table i a face-to-face comparison is m a d e of the nature of the immediate impact and reaction produced first by news and secondly by an artistic programme. T h e considerable differences which are apparent here are also to be found, mutatis mutandis, in the effect on the public of messages governed by the other social functions of the mass media. This situation confirms the argument of those sociologists w h o maintain that it is impossible to define the action on the public of the press, radio, television and the films in global terms. T h e y have a specific action according to the function subserved. The intensity of the effect I have been led to re-think the sociology of the mass m e d i a in terms of a combination of t w o orders of considerations, those proper to the vertical perspective of the journalist-sociologist w h o is dealing with the public at the m o m e n t of emission, particularly w h e n it is a question of 'sensational and explosive' (F. Braudel) events; a n d , secondly, those of the historian pondering the phases of the p h e n o m e n o n in a horizontal perspective. V i e w e d schematically, there are three levels or stages of w h a t Gurvitch w o u l d call the 'social reality', indissolubly associated with successive temporal durations of three orders of magnitude. The 'occurrent' level. This is a superficial level of very brief duration covering the m o m e n t of shock caused b y the 'arrival' of the message (let us call it the primary shock) a n d the 'radiation' born of the 'immediate' version, the one which spreads b y w o r d of m o u t h , before the intervention, at the 'conjunctural' level, of the leaders of opinion, guides, key people a n d the 'mediate' version w h i c h the latter instigate a n d inspire. A t this 'occurrent' level a n d during the short space of time it occupies, the individual is relatively isolated; he is left to his o w n a n d his nearest neighbours' mercies; h e has neither support nor protection a n d is obliged to deal unaided with hisfirstreactions to the message. H e is not yet re-immersed in the situations a n d circumstances of the 'conjuncture'. The 'conjunctural' level. T h e conjuncture referred to, the shifting situation arising from a simultaneous a n d m o m e n t a r y concourse of circumstances and events, runs longer a n d slower and is also m o r e highly elaborated

T h e mass public at grips with mass communications

6.37

TABLE

I. Impact: dramatic work

Impact: news

Surprise factor T h e news item is a fortuity. N o prior choice. N o readying for its reception. Total surprise.

Choice factor Choice in regard to subject a n d content. Suitable predisposition. Expectation of w h a t has been deliberately chosen. Cushioned shock N o surprise. Uninvolved expectation. Pleasure-seeker's attitude.

Brusque shack Shock of the unexpected. 'Living' the incident. Attitude of participation, of involvement. Mentally disruptive force of repeated and random minor shocks Torrential flow. Electric shock of news. W a r of nerves even in time of peace. Disturbance of thought structures. Uncontrolled global reaction Reaction before apprehension. Difficulty in 'looking for the meaning'. Breaching of the defences of the perception. Collectivization of the message in mass milieux Penetration into vast, heterogeneous masses ill-defended against the affective reverberations of words or images. Non-slructuration of the messages in mental frames of reference General absence of mental frames of reference for immediate actualities. T h e message drifts at the level of sensibility. Instability. Crude reaction vis--vis the sender Reaction is lively, partial without qualifications, emotional.

No equivalent.

Prior readying of censorship functions Censorship functions fully operative. Meanings looked for normally.

Collectivization of the message in lite milieux Penetration of small homogeneous groups, well able to defend themselves against verbal or visual spellbinding. Structuration of messages in mental frames of reference Mental frames of reference created by the pursuit of education a n d culture. T h e message is automatically situated in the above frames of reference. Stability. Pondered reaction vis--vis the sender Reaction is controlled, reasoned a n d supported b y aesthetic references.

t h a n the contingent, unstable, e p h e m e r a l a n d unorganized occurrent set-up. T h e 'conjunctural' set-up is at all times 'restructuring itself, seeking or inventing fresh equilibria, mobilizing ingenuity, or at the least leaving it a free h a n d ' (F. B r a u d e l ) . It is f r o m the interweavings a n d combinations of the e c o n o m i c , the

638

Roger Clausse

political, the cultural, the social conjunctures, etc., that the total 'conjunctural' set-up arises, and the s a m e elements determine its organization and evolution. T h e pressures operative within itclashes of opinion, propaganda, the effort to spread education and culture, institutions and settings, circumstances, the action of reformist groups, the action of the leaders and mediate versions of events, the examples and symbols supplied by the behaviour of these, constraints and controls, etc.all these pressures, external to the mass media, become organized into powerful but diffuse interaction processes, by which all the forces of the society express their exigencies, explicitly or implicitly, bluntly or insidiously. T h e y act on the primary shock and the immediate version (of messages) at the occurrent level, modifying and diluting, assimilating them to control them and fit them forcibly into pre-established limits relatively impermanent in the perspective of historical duration. T h u s , for example, panics start at the occurrent level, but develop or peter out at the 'conjuncturaP level. The structural level. A structure is architecture and workmanship. It is also permanence, often more than secular. Here, after the screenings needed, w e are at the level of fixating in solid constructions which successfully challenge 'historical' time a n d show themselves sound, unshakable and u n m o v e d amid the effervescences of the occurrent level and the impermanence of the conjunctures. T h e structures stand like a back-drop for the stage of history. T h e y are like a girdle around the actions and reactions of the other levels, constraining, toning, accepting or annulling them. T h e execution of Louis X V I is of the occurrent level; the struggle to achieve the threefold separation of powers is of the level of conjunctures, the democratic frameworks of our society are 'structural'. Two-dimensional schema of the effects of the mass media A look at the effects of the mass media on a society shows that this effect can be dealt with by a two-dimensional study (P. F . Lazarsfeld). This conclusion was m y starting point for the preparation of a graphical representation (Fig. 4) in which the ordinate gives the complexity of the social functions (single-source functionplural-source functionsplural-source combination of functions) while the abscissa shows the radiation of the effect through the society (at the three levels in terms of the three basic durations). Between the 'conjuncturaP and the structural levels I have introduced an 'open potentiality' zone. Observation shows that not all effects register on the structures of the society. There is a period of variable length taken up by a screening process, a selection whose mechanism is wholly u n k n o w n to us. W h y d o some effects of the mass media leave an imprint on the structures while others, in appearance m o r e profound, disappear for ever? There must be a process which either matures or destroys them. Conceived on these lines, the schema describes the effect phenomenon graphically, and enables us to situate more adequately the m a n y and varied

The mass public at grips with mass communications

639

FIG. 4. Two-dimensional diagram of effects of mass media. Radiation of the effect in the society First impact: Transience in immediate effect. Longer duration: Relative instability in the short term. Indefinite duration: Screening: maturation or destruction. Long duration: Relative stability in the long term. problems posed b y the reaction of the public. A t the occurrent level (i), for instance, has a particular n e w s item onfirstimpact and at that m o m e n t only had an effect on behaviour a n d , if so, w h a t effect? A t the conjunctural level (2), has a particular political speech influenced opinion, a n d has it thereby introduced a n e w factor into the conjunction? W h a t pressures influence the effect? Is it stronger, weaker, distorted or negatived? In the zone of open potentiality (3), has the broadcast music which has in fact modified the needs a n d tastes of listeners done so in such a m a n n e r as to create the possibility of this essentially 'conjunctural' situation one day becoming part of the stable structures of the society? A t the structural level (4), are the modifications which the status of radio has brought about in the traditional freedom of information and expression part of the juridical structures of the liberal society? Sociological consequences In the communication of the messages put out b y this mass media, the most characteristic stage, perhaps the most efficacious and certainly the least distorted (inasmuch as it is subject to n o disturbing 'interferences'), is at the occurrent level (1), the instant of first reception, before the person 'hit' by the message c o m e s under the diverse and heterogeneous

640

Roger Claussfi

pressures enhancing, attenuating, neutralizing it at the 'conjunctural' level. A t this occurrent level, the consequences of message-impact on opinions, attitudes, behaviour and intellectual frames of reference are determined by the content and form of the message and the m e d i u m and m o m e n t of its dissemination. W e then get a specific pressure, limited in time and in depth, producing a characteristic, clearly discernible reaction which affects the mental structures in a w a y of its o w n . This reaction, even iffleetingor superficial in appearance, will, to an extent which could only be determined by systematic analysis, condition the subsequent reactions produced b y the pressures introduced b y the 'conjunctural' set-up into the process of communication and will in turn be conditioned and modified by them. Here w e are in the specific field of the sociology of the techniques of mass communication. A t the 'conjunctural' level, the sociology of the messages diffused by the mass media must to a large extent give w a y to another, different in purpose and more general. Here the sociologist will remain alert to the resurgences of the primary or occurrent shock occasioned by similar events or situations, for it is permissible to think that the hangover of the primary shock returns to the consciousness, if confusedly, and influences opinions, attitudes and behaviour w h e n , within a certain time limit, an event occurs or a situation develops which resembles the original one in certain particulars. Thus, there is every indication that the public's reactions at the time of the Korean W a r , for instance, were conditioned to an appreciable degree by the recollection of reactions during the panic of 1940, themselves conditioned by the events of 1914; they took the form of extreme irritability and nervousness, reckless and pointless buying, the search for a refuge at all costs, runs o n the banks, violent fluctuations o n the stock market, brusque and inconsistent retroactions on the message senders, etc. A t any rate, I myself, as a broadcasting professional at the time, was unmistakably conscious of the resurgence in the public of the earlier shock. Moreover, at the 'conjunctural' level, the sociology of the information techniques (within whose field study of the resurgence of primary shock properly lies) will m a k e w a y for a broader and different sociology, that of social communication and the propagation of culture. T h e latter will take as study and research subjects, within the complexity of the conjuncture, those sociological assemblages in which the information techniques are only elements and minor elements, media and minor media, a m o n g others equally efficacious (milieux, leaders of opinion, educational action, propaganda, etc.). Finally, at the structural level, the sociology of information techniques will disappear, and leave thefieldto history, which can then identify and describe the effects which have subsisted and entered into the structures of the society after the variable 'settling' period in the 'zone of free potentiality'.

The mass public at grips with mass communications

641

Variational factors
At the conclusion of this very general analysis, it remains for us to assemble, and thereby demonstrate the complexity of, the factors of variation in the registering and internalization of messages or, if the term be preferred, the factors tending to modify effects. W e have already m e t them, here a n d there, but it is of great importance to appreciate that they are numerous a n d that their action is not unidirectional. Here w e really have a sociological observational complexity, which must be kept well in mind at the inception of any study on research on the effects of social communication. It is for this reason that it is proposed to present the factors in the form of a synoptic diagram (Fig. 5) which, on the threshold of any research undertaking, will provide a mental frame of reference.

Conclusion
M y conclusion will be brief. It consists of two observations. First of all, the relationships existing between the mass media and the public constitute a sociological observational complex, i.e., an unordered but agglutinant collection of a diversity of sequences or series of social actions, of systematizations of activities (and hence of functions), which, starting from a specified source, or from several such sources, the same or different in nature, follow divergent lines for specific ends, with perturbing or distorting interferences b y one sequence with another. O w i n g to its heterogeneity, and despite its cohesion, it would be dangerous, at least at the start, to tackle this complex as it stands; it is necessary, for a clear view, to break it d o w n into homogeneous segments which I propose to call sociological observation perimeters, combinations of systematizations of activities which, starting from one specific source, or several such sources the same or different in nature, pursue a c o m m o n line for a c o m m o n end, with one systematization strengthening the efficacity of another, even if it happens that there is interference between the systematizations. For example, the news, sequences of messages aiming at making k n o w n what is happening in the world, is a sociological perimeter. For the sake of convenience, the sociological perimeter will be broken d o w n into sociological observation units, i.e., into particular systematizations from various sources, e.g., information on current events from the daily papers. In this w a y , the observation covers a coherent whole where the danger of confusion is practically non-existent. It is then possible to delimit a homogeneous field of research and devise methods adapted to the purpose of the research. Second conclusion: the largest possible n u m b e r of survey techniques must be used on a continuous basis and the results appraised and systematically cross-checked.

642

Roger Clausse

Tools of disseminata

Social functions

Written word

Spoken word

image

Information

Artistic emission

Psychotherapy

Social levels

Durations

Occurrent

' Conjunctival

Structural

Instantaneous

Short

Long

Passive concomitants

Personal ambience

Social situations

Events

Collective actions

FIG. 5. Synoptic diagram of modifying factors. Psychological law of functional selectivity of items registered and items internalized with its corollary (non-selective) mental defence mechanism against internal physical or mental aggressions. Nothing is m o r e dangerous than to w o r k on the result of a single survey effected b y a particular method. In isolation and taken by itself such a result is suspect, and the element of truth it contains cannot be determined with confidence: it is soon called in question by reason of the rapid evolution of situations and buried in the complexity of things. T h e only escape open to us is to adopt a policy of multiple surveys, to install our investigating machinery permanently on the research terrain, to use all the research techniques available concurrently, thereby to cumulate the results (synthesis of observations) and to cross-check them systematically after an appraisal process determining the elements of truth and their place in the whole.

T h e mass public at grips with mass communications

643

S u c h a n operation, slow, arduous a n d persevering, w h i c h I h a v e called running ' d o x o m e t r y ' b y intersection is obviously a severe test of patience. B u t it is the only w a y b y w h i c h it is possible to collect shards of truth a n d assemble t h e m in a n ordered a n d reliable w h o l e , to separate the essential from the accidental a n d the p e r m a n e n t from the contingent. [ Translated from French]

Dr. Roger Clausse is former director-general of French programmes of the Belgian national broadcasting system and is at present professor at the Faculty of Philosophy and Letters of the Universit Libre, Brussels, and director of its Centre d'Etude des Techniques de Diffusion Collective. He is a member of numerous boards of national and international associations and has undertaken work for Unesco in thefieldof mass communications. Among his works may be listed Education d e base pour u n h u m a n i s m e social (1935), L a radio, huitime art (1945), L a radio scolaire (Unesco, 1949), Synopsis d e l'information d'actualit ( 1961, translated into Spanish and German), L e journal et l'actualit (1967), as well as translations and radio adaptations of works by Plautus and Euripides.

T h e interaction between 'reality - work of art - society'

Vladimir Karbusicky

N o one can deny that a work of art stems from reality and that it has an influence o n society. There will be less agreement o n the actual nature of the interrelations between reality, a work of art, and society and o n the place and possible influence therein of social and cultural institutions and communication media. M a n y attempts have recently been m a d e to provide theoretical answers to these questions through the application of information theory. This is, in fact, such a c o m m o n approach that, before w e start analysing the various aspects of these interrelations, w e have to m a k e clear w h y w e are so 'out of date' as to be unwilling to adopt the language and methods of information theory. W e d o not, of course, wish to play d o w n the usefulness of information theory but, for historical reasons, its application is, for the time being, limited. W h a t interests us here is what this m e t h o d offers today, although w e do not wish to cast doubt o n the possibility that, in future, the experimental models which are at present incompatible with contemporary practice m a y lead to theoretical formulations o n a higher level of thinking in the context of information theory. It must also be mentioned that, in formulating theoretical models in aesthetics and the sociology of art, the mere fact of using the terminology of information theory has a noetic significance. For example, a convincing model of the extent of 'understanding of serious music' in relation to the degree of education, i.e., the acquired perception capacity of the individual (a correlation which has been empirically established in the sociology of music) can be constructed by using the concepts and terminology of information theory. But these are, at present, special cases, not valid for music or art as a whole. There are, for the time being, two m a i n difficulties in the general application of the theory of information. Firstly, the mathematical a n d statistical methods used to determine the a m o u n t of information a n d redundancy best express regular systems and structures with high probabilities, whilst art is naturally inclined to violate 'rules', and the very principle of aesthetics often lies in the artist's 'rebellion'.

Int. Soc. Sei. J., Vol. X X , No. 4, 196S

The interaction between 'reality - work of art - society'

645

For this reason, tedious mathematical analyses usually result, in the end, in a poor, abstract 'vocabulary' of recurring p h e n o m e n a . So far as music is concerned, for instance, this might be likened to reducing the language of Kafka's The Trial to basic English, used to describe where M r . K . went and what he did, so as to measure the 'information content' of Kafka's novel. Secondly, the influence of living art can scarcely be expressed through the classic pattern of the transmission of information. There are forms of art, such as music, which seemingly conform to such transmission: the score is the code, the performer is the transmitter, the m e d i u m of transmission is the channel, listening is the reception of the message, understanding is the decoding of information, etc. But what about other forms of art? W h e r e does transmission of information enter into architecture, non-representational art, the dance, etc.? A n d , as w e shall see, things are not quite so simple as they m a y seem even in the case of music and certainly not in the case of poetry or d r a m a . Is the obtaining of 'information' from the 'messages', which the artist 'encodes' for us, really the final effect and meaning of art? This question must b e asked even w h e n 'information' is very broadly interpreted. T h e over-simplified application to art of 'information transmission' schemes is mainly due to failure to understand the multifunctional character of art. M o s t of those applying these schemes completely forget that the communication function is only one of m a n y functions of art. T h e y m a k e abstractions regardless of what they are abstracting from, so that they are liable to overlook other functions (which they regard as 'inessential') which m a y sometimes be the very essence of a given work or genre. Let us consider, for example, what is the difference, in a 'communication' model of art, between the gnoseological, a n d the hedonistic a n d recreational functions. T h e more original a work of art, the less stereotyped, a n d therefore the less susceptible of treatment by information theory, the m o r e it has to teach us. T h e fewer stereotyped, 'alphabetical', stylized elements it comprises, the less will it b e 'comprehensible' in only one w a y . T h e wider the 'range of information', the greater the gnoseological significance. Conversely, a system of probabilities based o n stereotyped forms, with the redundancy required for o p t i m u m 'transmission of information', m a y show a very high value from the point of view of information content even though the value from the point of view of knowledge is almost nil. Nevertheless, it will be extremely functional from the hedonistic and recreational point of view: perception of such structures follows the regular paths of neurons without encountering any real resistance. T h e final effect is not the decoding of information but simply stimulation of the 'receiving apparatus'. A typical example is listening to a background of light music o n the radio, where the half-conscious perception of well-known tunes produces a sense of relaxation and pleasure. Another instance of the relations between a work of art a n d society in which the communication functionparadoxical as it m a y seemhas scarcely any place, is the so-called 'sociogenic' effect of art, which m a y take

646

Vladimir Karbusicky

various forms. It m a y , for example, be a subsidiary, adventitious effect of a genre associated with a quality akin to 'aesthetic enjoyment', which is influenced by a given environment (sculpture and painting, music and singing in church, etc.). O r it m a y be the function of art as a 'signal' for the introduction of social and psychological factors (cf. conventional, symbolic elements in national anthems, where the 'primary information', hidden in the anachronistic text, representing a 'petrification' of the nation's history, no longer matters a n d where, in most cases, people d o not even remember the words at all). A sociogenic effect m a y also be produced, however, w h e n , for example, a group refuses to accept a certain type of art. A n instance is a group of people w h o dislike modern art, representing a group of 'receivers' which will not 'decode the message transmitted'. This paradoxical situation where 'the social effect of art is inoperative' would provide material for a humorist. Art itself, in any case, resists the pressure of communication requirements. Certain trends in art, regarded by society as 'extreme', in fact represent non-communication or the absolutely 'non-obligatory' character of information. Aesthetically effective structures m a y be produced which merely provide a n impulse, representing a visual or auditory 'happening' (Stockhausen's Ereignis). T h e y stimulate the consciousness of the percipient but suggest only: 'choose w h a t you like, think what you like, react as you like'. This can be explained in several ways. It m a y be a non-institutional reaction by the individual against the totalitarian demands of industrial societyor an appeal to the individual to become a co-creator instead of being a purely passive receiver. But it m a y also be a reaction against the teaching still found in schools and institutes about the direct relations between reality, works of art and society. Most modern writings o n art teaching and interpretation suggest that the models described above, applying the theory of information in more or less popular form, provide the institutional and pragmatic conception of the meaning of art. T h e model m a y be expressed roughly as in Figure i. Thus, what was put into the work of art and encoded (that is, in explanatory terms, 'what the poet wanted to say') radiates from the work to the destination. T h e idea embodied in a work of art is simply released to act on the recipient and thus influence society. There is n o textbook which can resist quoting, as proof of this, the cases of suicide a m o n g readers of The Sorrows of Werther. T h e s a m e argument is also used by those w h o believe in the necessity of institutional and State censorship: m a y not a work of art lead to an undesirable m o v e m e n t in society (especially where youth is concerned)? There has probably never been a cultural Inquisition in the world which has not justified its action by reference to the interests of the young whose brilliant future that inquisition is in duty bound to protect with holy zeal. A s this model shows, the role of social and cultural institutions is, in general, very simple: it consists,firstly,in making a suitable 'choice' of educationally desirable works of art and, secondly, in directing them to the consumer in such a w a y as to promote perception of the 'content'. T h e

The interaction between 'reality - work of art - society'

647

FIG.

1.

important thing is that the work is m a d e available and appropriately 'presented' institutionally. F r o m this position it is logically only a step to simple intervention w h e n the model does not operate, w h e n the consumer does not 'understand' the work: as there cannot possibly be anything wrong with the institutional channels through which the work reaches the receiver, the fault must lie in the work itself, or in the artist whose creations are 'incomprehensible'. It is not fortuitous that in our century, w h e n the pressure of the economic systems of industrial society is bringing totalitarianism to m o r e and m o r e spheres of h u m a n activity, w e find the strongest tendencies towards control in art that history has ever seen. T h e main target of the aggressivity of society (and sometimes of the State) are those elements which are incompatible with the pragmatic, educational conception of art, which are 'good for nothing', art for art's sake, evidence of the 'irresponsibility' of the artist. In the nineteenth century, it was chiefly the subjective element in expression which infuriated respectable society; in the twentieth century, it is principally the essentially meaningless 'aesthetic play of materials' (colours, words, tones and sounds, shapes, movements, etc.), which is branded as undesirable, heretical 'formalism'. T h e w a y in which this sort of 'formalism' has been attacked on ideological grounds in our century will remain one of the most grotesque p h e n o m e n a in the history of art: the Nazis called it 'cultural bolshevism', the Stalinists, a 'product of the rotting decay of imperialism'in both instances with the consent of the mass of consumers w h o mistrust such art on principle, because of its 'incomprehensibility'. N o r can it be said that the various ideologies have even yet quite given u p hurling the accusation

648

Vladimir Karbusicky

of formalism at one another; it would be truer to say that it is n o w done in m o r e subtle ways. O n the other hand, there is a tendency to give greater prominence to elements which are capable of more definite meaning, and therefore of practical, ideological use: symbolic andfigurativeelements. B y 'figurative', w e m e a n showing direct correlations between the structure of the work and reality as it is familiar to the average consumerdescriptions in literary works, likeness of shape and colour in the visual arts, pleasant melodies which are easily remembered in music, spectacular film sets, etc. These totalitarian tendencieswhether apparent in the all-powerful 'consumer art' industry or in the support afforded by the Establishment are directly counter to real art or, in other words, to the natural dispersion of ideas. There is a perpetual psychological struggle against the normal h u m a n intentionality of perception, preventing the consumer from perceiving a work as he should and could. T h e mass consumer is not entided to choice: he will either react precisely as intended (take, for example, the well-ordered sequences of excitement and emotion in the film War and Peace, with their expurgated, reduced content) or else he will not react at allsitting in an armchair, eating his sandwiches, he will watch on the television screen, one after the other, the effects of the napalm b o m b , a scooter race, a helicopter crash, the birth of quintuplets, and the havoc caused by an earthquake, without being required, or indeed able, to react sympatheticallyto be afraid at what is frightening, to weep with those w h o weep, to laugh with those w h o are happy. Whenever n e w art emerges, institutions have to decide what to do with it, h o w desirable it is, h o w useful it m a y be. I shall quote one example from m y o w n country. In 1955, Czechoslovakia heard for the first time about the existence of electronic and concrete music. 1 T w o main institutions were to be expected to take a stand on the matter, being directly concerned: the monopoly institution, the Union of Composers, which might be expected to have a typical defence reaction against the u n k n o w n ; and the institutions making up the cultural industry, which were in a position to m a k e practical use of the theory and might therefore be expected to show interest. T h e Union of Composers indeed reacted in accordance with the ideological tone of those days and denounced this music as an 'invention of decadent bourgeois society'. T h e strong institutional resistance was maintained until about 1961. In spite of this ideological condemnation and denunciation electronic and concrete music was introduced into films and heard on the radio. T h efirstfilmwith electronic music, Invention of Destruction, based on a novel by Jules Verne, c a m e out in 1958, and was followed by a whole series of science-fiction films and sound-montage programmes on the radio. In 1965 a survey of response to musical forms w a s m a d e by playing to selected audiences a whole range of recorded music, from folk music to electronic. Only a small percentage confessed to liking electronic music (3-12 per T. J. Matejcek, 'Poznmky o elektronick a konkrtn hudbe' (Some notes on electronic and concrete music), Hudebni rozhledy (Musical review), N o . 6, Prague, 1965.

The

interaction between 'reality - work of art - society'

649

cent) but a relatively high percentage (40-70 per cent) had already heard electronic music. 1 T h e institutional influence of the cultural industry had thus marked up a considerable success in the space of five to eight years. T h e context in which electronic and concrete music had been used had obviously had a strong influence on the trend of listeners' imagination. T o the question ' W h a t images does this music evoke' the majority of replies mentioned: things connected with outer space (space flight, u n k n o w n galaxies, space, infinity, the twinkling of stars in the universe, meteors, other planets, a Martian landscape, great distances, emptiness, something ethereal, eternal silence) or terror and catastrophe (fear, cruelty, despair, anxiety, chaos, explosion of atomic b o m b , destruction of the world, death, approach of evil, foreboding, a tragic end, an accident) or phantasy and m o v e m e n t (supernatural, abstract, harmony of spheres, transparency, excursion into the future, the twenty-second century, Utopia, metamorphoses, beginning of m o v e m e n t , unfolding of shapes, wandering) or mystery (the u n k n o w n , the fabulous, supernatural beings, life after death, prehistoric creatures, heaven, shadows, darkness, haunted castles, darkness of the forest), etc. All these show a strong conventional influence, but there were also unconventional images (sunrise, sheep in the mountains, the underwater world, etc.) This is not the place for a full examination of the psychological problems involved in such a survey (e.g., the semantic influence of the word predstava2 used in the questionnaire; the association of the impulse imparted by this word with the impulse from the sound of the music, its structure; the influence of its concrete meaning on the listener's response to the question; the influence of the listener's o w n tendencies in observation, assimilation, etc.). W e simply wish to point out that these statistics confirm a notion already familiar in experimental aesthetics: that the images evoked by music (and by other 'semantically free' forms of art) are varying, and that it is only w h e n a number of associated conditions of perception are satisfied that the images suggested are sometimes identical or similar. This percentage of similarity (e.g., the conventional image of the universe) is the only foundation of c o m m o n 'comprehensibility' and similar representation, i.e., 'communicability' and therefore also the basis for possible use of a 'transmission of information' model. This is, however, not a special case; a typical, natural case, involves a whole range of images. For example, an excerpt from the composition of H . Eimert, 'Epitaf fr Aikichi K u b o y a m a ' , evoked the following contradictory images and recollections: 'I thought of the beautiful composition of Paul Klee and Piet Mondrian' (a student of architecture, age 25). 'It's like a circular saw outdoors in January and the m a n operating it has frozen hands and the belt is slipping' (a driver, age 24). 'This is not music. It reminds m e of the mediaeval Inquisition and the burning of witches. O r s o m e pictures of Picasso' (an office-worker, age 50).
1. Vyzkum soucasne' hudebnosti (Survey on contemporary musicality). N e w and enlarged edition, Prague, 1968. 2. Predstava m a y mean either 'image' or 'idea' (translator's note).

650

Vladimir Karbusicky

' A feeling of whirling m o v e m e n t , spirals in the air, an abstract impression of rhythm and m o v e m e n t , multitudes of colours' (a scientist, age 32). Here w e must again leave aside the problem of experimental aesthetics which consists of determining whether it is possible to deduce from the reactions of the consumers any opinion on the inherent 'content' of the work. W e have here w h a t is called an aesthetic experience, without any decoding of information. W h e n A . Silbermann began using the word Erlebnis (experience) in the sociology of art,1 he was criticized for introducing terminology from psychology. Experimental surveys (especially w h e n , as in Czechoslovakia, w e have available thousands of replies which can be used for statistical purposes and not merely samples of a few dozen, as has usually been the case in experimental aesthetics) rather confirm that, methodologically, experience, as the final effect on the consumer, is a valid approach. A further advantage is that recent developments in p h e n o m e nology have revealed other aspects of this concept and given it a subtler noetic significance. W h a t concerns us here is that experiment has really furnished evidence of the intentionality of perception which conditions the extreme qualitative dispersion of experiences, their 'content', the 'meanings' and emotions they call forth. T h e quality of an aesthetic experience m a y be influenced by social and psychological factors and by institutional pressures, but it is none the less the basis of the percipient's intellectual reaction. Aesthetic experience m a y thus be defined as a state of stimulation of the consciousness caused by the perception of the work of art at a given time and evoking from the 'traces' left by previous experiences (either artistic or outside art) varying reflexes involving emotion, imagination and meaning. A work of art conceived in this w a y (and this conception is not speculative but experimentally deduced) becomes an impulse setting off an individual intellectual process rather than a codification of 'information'. It m a y not be impossible to devise a mathematical model to cover this within the framework of information theory but it will not be the same model of interactions that w e have been presented with u p to n o w . In our experimental model w e naturally c o m e u p against the basic ontological problems of art. W e are aware of the fact that the series of interrelations 'reality - artist - work - institution - consumer - society' is extremely complex and that it varies not only from case to case but according to the form of art. In some arts, the work can serve only as a 'means of realization' (musical scores, plays, novels, poems); in others, the work is afinishedcreation, once and for all (a statue, painting, electronic music on tape, film). S o m e works of art are realized in privacy by a great number of scattered individual creations (reading a novel); others involve the effects of mass psychology (theatrical performances, concerts, films), etc. Another series of problems arises in connexion with the inspiration of the work, and here w e are faced with a basic theoretical question in the sociology of art: is the social reality (membership of a group, group relations and
1. A . Silbermann, Wovon lebt die Musik, chapter 3, 'Das Musikerlebnis und sein SozialBestimmendes', Regensburg, 1957.

The interaction between 'reality - work of art - society'

651

pressures, influence of institutions and of the State ideology on the creative process, pressure of historical events, prestige, ethics, etc.) only one of the realities to which the artist reacts (the others being natural, biological, psychological, intellectual realities together with existing art, the properties of the material the artist is working with the aesthetic standards and values of the given time and conditions), or is it the c o m m o n denominator of all these realities, on which their organization a n d interpretation depend? Is the social reality one of m a n y factors contributing to the creation of a work or does it determine all the other factors to such a degree that it can be regarded as the m a i n structural factor? W e cannot, of course, deny the social character of h u m a n consciousness, nor that sociability is essential in m a n ' s ontogenesisa real M o w g l i would be an animal in a h u m a n body. O n e cannot live in a society without being dependent on it. However, at a certain cultural level, it is possible to extricate oneself from this dependency. Science is the most obvious means for such liberation, as can be seen in the dialectic relation between science and ideology: an ideology can be m a d e scientific, but science cannot be m a d e into an ideology without ceasing to be science. T h e sentence ' W e cannot live in society without being dependent on it' means something quite different, depending on whether a psychologist or a politician is speaking. Institutions, and the lite of the ruling classes, will always tend to emphasize this dependence, whilst a scientist, a philosopher or an artist will seek emancipation from it. Science is the typical instrument of the critical attitude towards the sociability that evolution imposes, but art can also play the same role. It is, indeed, usually art whichfirstsucceedsand m o r e effectively than sciencein opposing the dependence required by the Establishment. There are important gnoseological elements in such an active attitude: a work deriving from opposition can offer society m u c h food for reflection and self-discovery. A s this is a problem which has not yet been studied experimentally but has been m o r e or less deduced from the needs of certain ideologies, w e are for the m o m e n t free to choose our w a y of formulating the model to show the relation between the social and other realities. Let us therefore consider the co-ordinated influence of realities dialectically as a thesis to be disputed. T h e spheres of reality affecting both the creation of the work a n d its perception ('consumption') m a y be set out as in Figure 2. W e scarcely need to point out that this is a model corresponding to the present historical stage of development. T h e case would be different, loi example, in a primitive society where 'art' is still at the syncretic stage (combined effect of words, dramatic a n d visual elements, dancing and music in ritual), where the aesthetic function is not yet isolated and where the utilitarian (mainly magical) functions predominate. In the subjective awareness of such a society (our model is also, of course, the product of a subjective awareness of our civilization), the pre-artistic creations are not regarded as the results of a creation to reality but, on the contrary, as a special means whereby the subject influences reality, which is then

652

Vladimir Karbusicky

u Ol

of ae stand and v

.y

Psyc and biolo

"S I

" 'S
<
^ o

t S "5
0

Ut
?
>
0

tic

al

ure

" 5

E X P E R I E N C E

\
Consumers, their social groupings

) .

1 1i FIG.

v 3 a

2.

T h e interaction between 'reality - work of art - society'

653

'compelled' to adapt itself as ritual requires. T h e conception of art in various types of society, considered as a whole, varies between models of the sort described above and the operation of 'pre-art' in pre-feudal society. Primitive utilitarian tendencies in artart used as a m e a n s of influencing realityare to be found, of course, even in relatively advanced societies organized as States. In scientific studies, it is always necessary to begin by artificially isolating certain p h e n o m e n a in order to analyse them. In the s a m e w a y , the sociology of art isolates from the autonomous series of interrelations 'reality - artist work - institution - consumer - society' everything which belongs to the sphere of its o w n experimental and theoretical interest in society: social and cultural institutions, social relationships, ideology, the artist's membership of social groupings, social consumption of art, social and ecological factors influencing the quality of aesthetic experience, etc. Very often, however, w e forget to reintegrate the isolated element afterwards. This is liable to give rise to 'pan-sociological' theories which explain the whole process, from the m o m e n t of creation to the experience, purely as the natural outcome of the social process. Psychology and aesthetics are disregarded; sociology solves everything. 'Short circuits' between society and the work of art are then typical p h e n o m e n a . W e could, for example, instance a m o n o graph on Purcell in which the victory of m o n o d y over counterpoint around 1600 is explained as reflecting the victory of absolutism over the balance of classes in the Elizabethan realm1or the argument that Goya's work simply represents the maturing of the Spanish revolution. Wagner's music, again, reflects ' T h e power [violence] of imperialism a n d the foreboding of catastrophe in a class which sees nothing before it but the ineluctable need for expansion', as w e read in a w o r k by a well-known sociologist and philosopher w h o was not able to avoid the snares of pan-sociologism.2 S o m e popular writers on Hegel have appropriated his noetic term 'reflection' ( Widerspiegelung) and begun to spread a definition which would m a k e art 'the reflection of reality' but, in their eyes, the only reality is the social reality of class, group and institution. T h e ancient dualism G o d - m a n , matter - soul, external world - subject, is thus mechanically transferred to :he relations 'society - w o r k of art'. N o attention at all is paid to the question of whether the structure of a work of art does not also derive from the inner forces of the artist, his psyche, his instincts ('hereditary codes of behaviour') the struggle of creative intent with material (colours, sounds, words charged with semantics, harmonics, stone, screen projection, etc.) or from biological factors (eroticism, youth, old age, etc.). T h e m e r e fact of saying 'reflects reality' instead of 'reacts to reality' reduces the artist to the role of a passive executant, just as the manipulating institutions would wish h i m to be. It is thus obvious that thefirststep for integrating sociological analysis into the series of interactions w e are considering is to include k n o w n social factors a m o n g the other realities to which the artist reacts. W e can then n o
1. R . Sietz, Henry Purcell. Zeil, Leben, Werk, Leipzig, 1955. 2. T h . W . Adorno, Dissonanzen, 3rd ed., 1963.

654

Vladimir Karbusicky

longer maintain that social reality is always a n d everywhere the 'ultimate determining principle' of artistic creation. T h e n , too, institutional intervention and its influence is seen to be m u c h m o r e modest than would often be liked. At the m o m e n t of creation, the influence of biological reality on a work of art m a y well outweigh that of social reality (the artist's age m a y represent a stronger impulse in the creation of a work than a revolution occurring at that point in time). Again, whilst the reality of knowledge (substance of matter, nature of the universe, historical events, etc.) is derived from socially neutral science, the reality of aesthetic standards is m o r e largely subordinated to ideology. T h e influence of social reality clearly varies from case to case, a n d consequently the value of a work for the purposes of social reflection also varies. Should w e then cease to ask as T h . W . A d o r n o does, that the sociology of art should be concerned with the 'social decoding of a work', 1 w h e n w e k n o w , in any case, that analysis of the social determining factors cannot m a k e a real contribution to the full analysis of the whole complex structure? It would, of course, be creditable to sociology if it could meet this requirement, provided that it bears in m i n d that its o w n particular m o d e of analysis is only one of the possible approaches likely to lead to an explanation of a work of art, and that only the reintegration of its results and their comparison with those of historical, aesthetic, psychological and other analyses can provide a fuller picture. W e must also consider, however, what are the methodsapart from the more or less 'intuitive short-circuits' to which w e have referredthat the sociology of art, in its present state, can offer for the analysis of a work's genesis. Its approach is piecemeal and unsystematic, adapting itself to the difficulties of its subject-matter (it is for this reason that the sociology of literature has so far been mainly a speculative 'sociology of literary creation' and not at all a sociology of consumption, which is extremely difficult to pin d o w n , owing to the fact that literary works are 'realized' in countless different places by individual reading) ; all w e have are statisticalfiguresfor the taste of various consumers, but very little else. Thousands of works of art are created daily and the empirical sociology of art still cannot suggest a single methodologically sound standardized experimental method for analysing the social conditions and environmental circumstances of their creation. It has not yet even occurred to the sociologists of art to take a look at the social processes associated with the entirely n e w p h e n o m e n a which are revolutionizing the structure of art's field of action, such as the electronic and concrete music referred to above. Vainglorious patrons, social and cultural institutions and the enlightened bureaucrats of the State machinery are thus constantly able to pass themselves off as the support and inspiration of art, without having to show h o w they contribute to the construction of the work for which they arrogate credit to themselves. T h e y can safely claim 'their part' in a w o r k even w h e n the artist's intentions in creating it are diametrically opposed. T h e institui. T h . W . Adorno, Einleitung in die Musiksoziologie, 19G2.

T h e interaction between 'reality - work of art - society'

655

tions concerned with the propagation of art are often ignorant o f their o w n position in the series of interrelations b e t w e e n reality, w o r k s of art a n d society; they are not even a w a r e of the possibilities they c o m m a n d with regard to the different forms of art a n d its m o r p h o l o g y ( w e h a v e only to think of the incessant struggle to o v e r c o m e the difficulties arising in presenting authentic art through the m e d i a of m a s s c o m m u n i c a t i o n , w h i c h are better suited for dealing with stereotyped formsin short, ' c o n s u m e r ' artwhereas art d r a w i n g o n the u n i q u e character of aesthetic experience is not generally a m e n a b l e to the present forms of presentation, although those working in the m a s s m e d i a are not a w a r e of this). W e h a v e tried, a b o v e , to see w h a t is the true position of social a n d cultural institutions a n d the m a s s m e d i a in the chain of interrelations b e t w e e n 'reality, w o r k of art a n d society'. W e are well a w a r e that this statement will not b e e n o u g h to enable those institutions deliberately to take u p the position w h i c h , in our opinion, should b e theirs. T o oblige t h e m to d o so, c o n vincing analyses of the sociology of art a n d culture are n e e d e d . Until w e h a v e proper m e t h o d s of analysis a n d convincing results of the empirical study of their effects, of course, w e shall h a v e to rely instead o n efforts m a d e in the ideological field, including in all probability those designed to ridicule neronic complexes or a w k w a r d attempts to 'guide' or 'direct' artistic creation, to decide w h e t h e r a m o v e m e n t in art is 'desirable' or not, to curtail artistic freedom b y political a n d ' m o r a l ' censorship, a n d to enlist the 'indignation' of g o o d citizens against the temerity of those w h o flaunt accepted standards. [Translatedfrom Czech] Note. T h e author has m a d e use of the findings of certain of his previous studies, listed below. (The conception and aesthetics of'light music'.) Hudebn veda, Prague, 1967, no. 1-3. (German summary.) Zur empirisch-soziologischen Musikforschung. Beitrge zur Musikwissenschaft, 1966, no. 3-4. (Survey of response to music.) (In collaboration with J. Kasan.) Prague, 1964; n e w and enlarged edition, Prague, 1968. (Summaries in G e r m a n , French, Russian and English.) (Social factors in aesthetic perception. Contribution to the relations between sociological and aesthetic experiment.) Estetika, Prague, 1967, no. 3. ( G e r m a n S u m m a r y . ) (Experiment in musical sociology. Methods of empirical and sociological research in art.) T w o contributions to the collection: Problems in the sociology of music. Prague, 1967. (Summaries in Russian, French, English and G e r m a n . ) (Realism. Content analysis of musical publications 1948-65.) Partially published in Hudebn rozhledy, 1966, no. 18.

Vladimir Karbusicky engaged in research on folk-music and studied musical culture in industrial communities and isolated groups of emigrants, where he was mainly concerned with cultural survivals from the past. With the new interest in sociology in Czechoslovakia, he embarked on a series of experimental surveys on response to music. He is a member of the Institute of Music, of the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences and also lectures on the sociology of art. Has published works on the history of folk music, on practice and theory in the sociology of music, on the relations between 'highbrow' and 'lowbrow' culture in an industrial society, and on social factors in aesthetic experience.

Recorded music and the record industry

A sector neglected by sociological research Heinz Otto Luthe

I Sociological research has finally succeeded, albeit tardily as w e k n o w , in unravelling to some extent the tangle of opinions and assertions surrounding discussion of the social effects of the mass mediacinema, press, radio and television. B y adopting an increasingly interdisciplinary approach to the study of the mass media, the social sciences have m a d e a late but nevertheless effective contribution to the institutionalization of such media. This contribution is effective in so far as it has m a d e it possible to overcome a series of obstacles which were hindering this institutionalization and the social integration of the n e w communication techniques. W e k n o w from studies on diffusion (Kiefer, 1967) that the introduction of technical innovations, that is, of n e w material contributions to civilization, always has a more or less strong impact o n existing immaterial elements of civilization. U n d e r the guise of a conscientious social criticism, supporters of the most varied ideologies m a k e use of this to advance unrealistic and self-seeking arguments which delay 'acceptance of technological innovations, that is, socio-cultural adaptation to n e w technological facts. It is in this connexion that one hears talk of the omnipotence of the media and their influence on a fractionalized and helpless public. Even today, the irrational m y t h of the almighty media does not appear to have lost its force, although it has been repeatedly subjected to scientific criticism and reduced to its residual ideological elements (Lazarsfeld and Merton, 1948, p . 95-118; Katz and Lazarsfeld, 1955, p . 16 et seq.; Bauer and Bauer, i960). A glance at some of the allegedly sociological writings concerned with individual media, or mass communication in general such as Marshall M c L u h a n ' s Understanding Media (1964, p . 20) confirms this impression. C o m m o n to all such discussions of mass communication problemsat best socio-philosophicalis a preponderantly mechanical conception of the effect of the media, as if it proceeded in a straight line from the m e d i u m direct to the recipient. Earlier sociological research demonstrated the falseness of this conception, describing it in striking terms as 'the hypodermic needle' (Berelson, Lazarsfeld and M c P h e e , 1954). It was above all socio-

Int. Soc. Sei. J., Vo!. X X , N o . .), 1968

Recorded music and the record industry

657

psychological research whichfinallyreduced this conception to absurdity. Such a conclusion is at any rate valid with regard to the effect of the mass media on the individual. But w e must not be over-hasty in extending it to society as a whole. Even if social psychology has helped to demythologize the mass media and introduce a more dispassionate approach to them, the fact remains that sociology itself has not so far m a d e its contribution. This is indeed the Achilles heel of sociological research and accordingly the arguments of social critics are directed m o r e against the social than the individual aspects of the matter. O u r statement that research must necessarily be interdisciplinary by n o m e a n s absolves any of the individual branches from making its contribution. T h e place which sociology should occupy in the discussion of the social effects of the mass media is still being occupied today, and to an evergreater extent, by social philosophy and self-satisfied social criticism. T h e 'long march' of sociology towards the above-mentioned goal has only just begun. II There is a long tradition behind the discontent of the majority of those observers of societyin this connexion the expression ' m e m b e r s of a society' can be used only in a very limited sense (Lazarsfeld, 1965)in other words, the so-called intellectuals w h o have adopted a critical attitude towards the developmental trends of our civilization. For Leo L w e n thai (1961), its meaning for today begins with Montaigne and Pascal, and continues with Goethe, Schiller, Lessing, de Tocqueville, Taine and M a r x . In fact, its origins can even be traced back to Plato (Lazarsfeld, 1965, p . 3). T h e reservations about the invention and use of writing expressed in the Phaedrus could well have inspired the ideas of Marshall M c L u h a n (1962, p. 23). Side by side with an ever-growing institutionalization of the mass media in modern societies, so-called social criticism has appreciably increased both in frequency and intensity. Regardless of the point of departure of the individual critics, they are all concerned with the same basic problems, namely: '1. T h e tension that exists between intellectuals, with their highly diversified preferences, and the relatively standardized and uniform programmes of radio and television; T h e reluctance of intellectuals to admit that a collective effort can result in a work of art; T h e growing tendency of an increasingly well-informed public to draw nearer to the position of the intellectuals and concern itself with contemporary cultural problems; T h e difficulties inherent in a social system in which there is competition between the interests of the State, the citizens and the commercialized mass media; T h e fear of the intellectuals (more in France than in America) that the

'2. '3.

'4.

'5.

65a

Heinz Otto Luthe

mass media will mislead and bewitch the working-class and finally remove its class consciousness.' (Lazarsfeld, 1965, p . 4). In recent years, the whole literary discussion outlined here has been reduced more and more completely to the dichotomy of 'culture for the lite versus culture for the masses', something which inclines one to suppose that here, too, it is a question of one of those famous problems, dichotomously and therefore falsely posed, of which Georges Gurvitch (1963, p . 31-65) gives a list of critically analysed examples. T h e idea of a continuum, whose extremes are occupied by cultural and social forms, namely culture for the masses and culture for the lite, although both are to be understood as ideal and typical rather than as real, seems to be a more apt representation of the problem than is the dichotomous formulation, however m u c h the latter m a y lend itself to the uses of committed criticism. Moreover, this is another proof of h o w frequently in social philosophy constructive thinking is supplanted by taxonomic preconceptions. T h e above-mentioned work of Lwenthal; a volume of the American A c a d e m y of Arts and Sciences' Daedalus ( 1960) which reproduces a work brought out by N . Jacobs in 1959; an issue of the magazine Communications (1965) published by Georges Friedmann and the Centre d'Etudes des Communications de Masse, Paris; the works of Harold L . Wilensky (1964) and Etienne Gilson (1967), as well as Bernard Rosenberg's and David M a n n i n g White's reader (1957), give a fairly complete idea of the stage reached in the discussion of this problem at the international level. A pessimistic note predominates in these writings, with the feelings playing a noteworthy part. T h e authors are only too ready to apply to cultural matters the monetary law formulated in 1550 b y Sir T h o m a s Gresham to the effect that bad m o n e y drives good out of circulation, thereby implying that culture for the masses (bad) drives out culture for the lite (good) (see also Mller, 1963, p . 127).

Ill
Finally, it has become clear that if sociology is to satisfy the demands m a d e upon it in regard to the analysis of the social consequences of the mass media, it mustfirstcarry out a goodly n u m b e r of preliminary tasks. A m o n g these, one which is as important as it is urgent is an ideological criticism which, by anti-critical reasoning, could reduce social criticism to its residual ideological elements. This would pave the w a y for subsequent empirical research. W e have seen that only very recently has empirical social research been focused upon the mass media. This is especially true of the record, the m e d i u m of communication with which w e are principally concerned in this inquiry. U p to n o w , it has been treated as the poor relation of the mass media by social scientists w h o , with a few exceptions (Silbermann, 1965), have not even taken the trouble to investigate whether, and to what extent, the record possesses the characterics of a mass m e d i u m . O f course

Recorded music and the record industry

659

the record, too, can be squeezed into the Procrustean bed of attempts which, in any case, are disputableto define 'mass communication' and 'mass communication media' (Silbermann and Luthe, 1968), but it should be observed that in regard to production and distribution, and above all the market conditions to which it is subject, the record differs considerably from the other mass communication media. A m o n g the essential structural differences w e m a y here note: 1. T h e spatial independence of record listeners. In this respect the record is akin to the radio, and also to s o m e extent television, but differs considerably from the cinema. 2. T h e temporal independence of record listeners. This distinguishes recordings from radio, television and the cinema but relates them to the paperback, which is occasionally regarded as a mass m e d i u m . For instance, it can never be said that a record, at any given m o m e n t , is being listened to by a large, mass audience. 3. T h e limit imposed on the repeated playing of a record by the fact that it wears out. Here too the complete spatial and temporal freedom of the listener is to be emphasized; this also applies, as was mentioned in paragraph 2, to the paperback or the newspaper. T h u s it would appear that one of the essential, identifying characteristics of the mass media is mass production and distribution together with mass consumption, even though the latter m a y be staggered. This makes it clear that a discussion of the structural characteristics of the record might well re-animate the terminological discussion of what is represented by mass communication or mass media. 4. Moreover, the record, in contrast to the other mass media, can only be institutionalized with the help of another m e d i u m . Only through close association with the radio has it been possible for the record to become a socio-cultural institution. With regard to its production, record manufacturing has almost from the beginning been a branch of the electronics industry. Records reach the public not only by means of the radio, but also through the retail shops and innumerable clubs which ensure their distribution. Thus it can be said that the record is economically and technologically dependent on the permanent support of other mass media. T h e fact that the record has developed in the shadow of other economically and technologically powerful media is perhaps one of the reasons w h y its discovery by social scientists, a n d especially those concerned with the study of the mass media, has occurred at so late a stage. Here, too, sociological research has been replaced by observant, pessimistic social criticism, displaying particular aggressiveness towards the record. Although, from a structural point of view, the record m a y not represent a fully-developed, independent mass m e d i u m , it nevertheless exerts an influence which is formidable in scope. In conjunction with the radio, which multiplies, accelerates and intensifies its effectiveness, the record is one of the most

66o

Heinz Otto Luthe

evil agencies for executing the fatal curse which has lain on our culture since the invention of the mass media. O r so, at least, say the social critics w h o are here dealing with the prototype of the m e d i u m whose ability to reproduce works of art perfectly is constantly increasing. A fatal tendency to generalize is manifest in this interest-motivated philosophy which hides behind the m a s k of exaggerated intellectualism: the record, as an integral part of our musical culture, is a threat to the latter, without there being any possibility of compensating influences making themselves felt. It plainly leads to 'auditive regression', 'a lack of perceptual concentration' (Adorno, 1956, p. 31) andfinallyto the 'liquidation of the individual' (ibid., p . 16). W h a t can sociology oppose to such assertions? First of all the fact that here critical, even radically critical social theoryan acceptable concept of the Marxistshas been abandoned in favour of a fascistic cynicism, all the expressions of which, whether they c o m e from the left or the right, bear a striking resemblance to one another. Polemics instead of analysis, aggression instead of criticism, characterize this tardy form of philosophical discussion of the p h e n o m e n o n of so-called mass culture. Whenever it is a case of the mechanical reproduction of a work of art, the critical attack becomes especially bitter and humourless, and far m o r e aggressive than radical, as can be seen, for example, in the writings of T h . W . Adorno. T h e vocabulary of this author, as a textual analysis of this writings easily shows, is drawn mainly from psycho-pathologyan undoubtedly interesting fact from the sociological point of view. In spite of his mannered style and bewildering vocabulary, the impression inevitably develops that there is a great deal of rationalization here, that incongruities are analysed only so that they m a y be projected into the surrounding world. But more interesting than this socio-psychological interpretation of the style of modern social criticism and its excesses would seem to be the indications of its growing sterility, which automatically averts the danger of a 'self-fulfilling prophecy' that w e are sometimes inclined to associate with committed social criticism. T h e elegance and intelligibility of its pronouncements are unfortunately in inverse proportion to each other; its language becomes more and more a m e a n s of demonstration and less and less one of communication. At the same time, developments in the very opposite direction can also be observed; they are discussed in Walter Benjamin's often quoted study of'Das Kunstwerk im Zeitalter seiner technischen Reproduzierbarkeit' (1955) (works of art in an age w h e n they can be mechanically reproduced). While works of art, according to Benjamin, lose their 'aura' w h e n mechanically reproduced and so leave the magic circle of art, they nevertheless gain as far as availability is concerned and so fulfil n e w social functions. M o d e r n social criticism, o n the other hand, is losing m o r e and m o r e with regard to availability and is becoming something reserved for the initiated, creating its 'aura' for itself with the help of a carefully chosen vocabulary and glamorously incomprehensible phrases. W h a t in Adorno conveys an impression of originality, in his followers and imitators borders on the ridiculous.

Recorded music and the record industry

661

IV Benjamin's constantly quoted ideas have been used up and worn out by his followers. His committed attitude, his w a r against 'cultural fascism', the seriousness of his arguments, have become facile datum points for selfcomplacent social critics. Although his statements are subject to certain historical limitations, their importance for the social scientist begins with his completely non-polemic and non-belligerent discussion of the 'change of function' of the mechanically reproduced work of art. This idea brings Benjamin very close to M a x W e b e r in the latter's reflections on the rational and sociological bases of music, 'Die rationalen und soziologischen Grundlagen der Musik' (1956). T h e functional study of recorded music will be mainly concerned, in conformity with the study's objectives, with its social, cultural and economic functions. A s to the aesthetic functions of recorded music, these are rather a subject for research b y musicologists, physiologists and psychologists. Moreover, it is clear at this point that mass communication research, sociology a n d social anthropology interpret the concept of function in a manner suited to their o w n needs, just as biology does. T h e question thus arises as to whether and h o w far the record assists in the formation, regulation or alteration of a social, cultural or economic system (Merton, 1964, p. 21 et seq.). T o begin with, the record has m a d e use of a whole branch of industry characterized by a steadily increasing rationalization of techniques (Coeuroy and Clarence, 1929; Gelatt, 1954; H a a s and Klever, 1959; R e a d , 1959; Gilotaux, 1962). Yet the precision product which it manufactures and distributes has never, with one exception (Reichardt, 1962), been the subject of an economic discussion. Only fairly recently has the record begun to crop u p in discussions of what is k n o w n as consumer society, which bear a great deal, too, on the problem of leisure and mass communication in the highly developed industrial nations (Zahn, 1964). Accordingly, the social critics only too gladly apply the term 'commodity' to the record, as they once applied it to the film (Bchlin, 1946) as a pretext for carrying on an irrelevant controversy. T h e drawbacks attendant on the fact that political economy and sociology have failed to co-operate with each other in making an exhaustive study of the problems of the 'culture industry', are especially apparent in regard to the record. In any case, the latter would be a rewarding subject for research in such a n e w discipline. At a time w h e n recording techniques have been brought almost to perfection by the 'sound magician' John Culshaw (Fierz, 1965), and have revolutionized concert, and particularly opera, production methodswhich has led the pianist Glenn Gould to predict the supplanting of the concert hall by the recording studio and technically sophisticated record-playing equipment (Culshaw, 1966)at a time w h e n so-called 'discogenic' music is apparently becoming a reality, the disadvantages arising from the lack of any theory applying to the record industry are particularly apparent. T o be sure, the industry has succeeded

66z

Heinz Otto Luthe

in embracing the whole range of so-called 'classical' music, from Seikilos' Drinking Song to the electronic music of Karl-Heinz Stockhausen, as well as the folk music of the entire world, in addition to providing the public every day with light popular music; but even though protected by the powerful electronics industry, it has still failed to rationalize the production and distribution phases of its activity. T h e marketa form of rational organization of economic relationsremains a sealed book for it; at least, it is only in recent years, under the pressure of an economic situation which threatened to introduce cut-throat competition into an oligopolistic industry, that an awareness of the market has developed (Dnuzire, 1968; Peschler, 1968). Disregarding price wars, which are confined to distributors, the records industry gives the impression of proceeding in a completely uneconomic manner in regard to the establishment of prices, a factor of prime importance in all economic activity. T h e most diverse musical performances are offered for sale at the same price: a record of a Bruckner symphony costs exactly as m u c h as does one of a piano sonata. T h e need for greater rationalization is being impressed on the record industry from two different quarters, and eventually it will m a k e itself felt in regard to the establishment of prices as well. Production has become, from the point of view of technical equipment and performing artists alike, one of the industry's major items of expense. Moreover, recording companies, from the outset, have always m a d e a practice of securing the most prominent artists by means of exclusive contracts, which has also contributed towards increasing their operating costs. A regrettable consequence of this same practice is that it is the record industry itself which decides h o w and by w h o m an orchestra is to be m a d e up. At this point, however, and although w e are more interested in the effects of recorded music than in h o w it is m a d e , it must be emphasized that, if such practices are carried to an extreme the industry would endanger the quality of its products, by presenting musical groups of incongruous composition or placing well-known orchestras under conductors with w h o m they are unfamiliar. In regard to the consumer market, the record industry is exposed on the one hand to the p h e n o m e n o n of changing tastes (Mller, 1963, p. 102 et seq.) and, on the other, to that of the increasing technical perfection of the recordabove all the development of stereophonic recordingswhich has m a d e such expensive record-playing equipment necessary that m a n y consumers have become price-conscious in this respect. These high costs have appreciably restricted the above-mentioned unlimited freedom of the record-listening public. It is also to be observed with regard to popular music that it is subject to the constantly changing w h i m s of the public's taste (Knig, 1962, p. 103 et seq.) and that with the increase and diversification of leisure activities, particularly for the young, the a m o u n t of time devoted to listening to recorded music, whether classical or popular, has decreased. This fact has prompted certain business-minded singers, the Beatles or Sheila for instance, to open their o w n boutiques in order to divert for their o w n benefit another branch of the mighty stream of youthful buying power.

Recorded music and the record industry

663

This points to the absolute need for a carefully planned p r o g r a m m e of research on production and distribution in the record industry, if the latter is not to become dependent on the so-called ' T o p of the pops' in regard to its products and prices, and completely lose an over-all view of the highly diversified consumer market. Only on the basis of such market strategy will the record industry be able to widen and diversify the spectrum of its social and cultural functions as the other mass communication media have already done. In any case it would seem, in view of what has been said here, that the five principal points laid d o w n by Lazarsfeld as dominating the current discussion of mass culture cannot be applied unreservedly to developments in thefieldof records and in the record industry. T h e product offered to the market by the record industry is not h o m o geneous, and even in those instances where it appears to be more or less so, there are still considerable variationsthe fifty different recordings m a d e of Beethoven's Fifth S y m p h o n y will suffice as an example. E v e n artists concede that as a result of teamwork the record is a quasiwork of art, or at least consider it as the m e d i u m par excellence for transmitting musical performances. Let us recall at this point Glenn Gould's remark, and at the same time call attention to the fact that conductors such as Georg Solti and Otto Klemperer do m o r e and more of their work in the recording studio. It would almost look as though they return to the concert hall for the sole purpose of resolving the intellectual and emotional discords created by social criticism. Conditions of work and remuneration have m a d e the recording studio attractive to the working musician and compensated for the lack of contact with a live audiencesomething which for Walter Benjamin was still a prerequisite for fruitful artistic activity. T h e remaining points of departure for a discussion of mass culture as set forth by Lazarsfeldnamely, competing cultural needs, different uses of free time andfluctuationsof the consumer market or purchasing power- are but little affected by the record. It is apparent that a different point of view is more than necessary here, but before it could be adopted a systematic study of the record and the record industry, theoretical as well as empirical, would have to be conducted.

V Alphons Silbermann, in his work 'Schallplatte und Gesellschaft' (records and society) (1965), a kind of secondary analysis, based on his conception of the sociology of art, of existing 'leisure studies' and of previous investigations in the field of mass communication, is thefirstto have attempted to lay d o w n the lines along which an analysis of the social functions of the record could be carried out. At the same time, in his theoretical explanations he aims at a convergence of consumer and cultural sociology. As regards the functions of the record in the domain of the h u m a n personality, Silbermann, with reference to M a x Kaplan (i960), indicates that record

664

Heinz Otto Luthe

consumption, as an individual or collective experience, with symbolic significance, representing a value or being simply an incidental occurrence, can fulfil the functions of relaxation, recreation or cultural development. Let us here introduce several other points of view from which theoretical and empirical sociological research on records and the record industry m a y profitably be conducted, thusfillingthe gaps in such research mentioned earlier. i. It might be interesting to ascertain whether and h o w far records as well as bookssince both provide material for the two mass media, radio and televisionhave contributed to a polarization of culture into what is k n o w n as lite and mass culture. F r o m its beginnings, the record industry has produced and helped to diffuse both classical and popular music. It therefore remains to discover to what extent the broadcasting of music of varying aesthetic value has contributed to the lite and mass polarization of culture, or m a d e people aware of such polarization and the problems therein involved. It would also be desirable in this connexion to see whether this process of polarization, at least as Talcott Parsons (1966) interprets it, although without of course dealing explicitly with the type of polarization w e are discussing here, is an effective, or even a completely determining, factor in the creation, regulation and evolution of a society. 2. A n additional task of theoretical interest would be to ascertain whether and to what extent recorded music, even though more or less faultlessly reproduced, leads to a kind of banishment from Utopia, that is, if and h o w far recorded music reduces cultural aspirations and produces symptoms of surfeit or even apathy. If this be so, w e can, without further ado, speak of the dysfunctional effect of the record. Likewise, it would be perfectly correct to describe recorded music as 'music of the lonely crowd' (Sonstevold and Blaukopf, 1968). 3. Also of interest would be a study of the extent, if any, to which the record has led to a kind of cultural centralization, in other words has devitalized the various provinces of music. 4. In connexion with the recorded transmission of the musical work of art, the problem of the educational functions of recorded music should also be thoroughly investigated (Alt, 1959). It would seem particularly important here, in making a critical analysis, to take the traditionally conservative attitude of m a n y educators into account. 5. Finally, a study of the motives for record consumption would also seem to be necessary. So m a n y different assertions have been m a d e in this respect that it is high time to determine if and h o w far, and through which personality traits, hedonistic proclivities predominate, or the desire for enhanced social statusin this case record collectingwould amount to a potlatch, or a predisposition to escapism, orfinallythe desire tofleesocial reality. [Translatedfrom German']

Recorded music and the record industry

665

BIBLIOGRAPHY A D O R N O , T h . W . 1956. Dissonanzen. Gttingen, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht. A L T , M . 195g. Die Schallplatte im Musikunterricht. Musik-Erziehung, Vienna, vol. 12, no. 4, June, p. 224-9. B C H L I N , P. 1946. Der Film als Ware. Basel. B A U E R , R . A . ; B A U E R , A . 1966. America, 'mass society' and mass media. In: Ch. S. Steinberg (ed.), Mass media and communication, p. 429-46. N e w York, Hastings House. BENJAMIN, W . 1955. Das Kunstwerk im Zeitalter seiner technischen Reproduzierbarkeit. In: T h . W . Adorno and G . Adorno (eds.), Walter Benjamin-Schriften, p. 366-405. Frankfurt, Surkamp.
B E R E L S O N , B . R . ; L A Z A R S F E L D , P. F.; M C P H E E , W . N . 1954. Voting. Chicago, Uni-

versity of Chicago Press. CoEUROY, A . ; C L A R E N C E , G . 1929. Le phonographe. Paris, Simon Kra. ; J A R D I L L I E R , R . 1931. Histoire de la musique avec l'aide du disque. Paris, Delgrave. Communications, Paris. Seuil, 1961. C U L S H A W , J. 1966. T h e mellow knob, or the rise of records and the decline of the concert hall as foreseen by Glenn Gould. Records and recording, vol. 10, 2 N o v . , p. 26-8. D N U Z I R E , M . 1968. L a troisime face du disque. Le Monde, Paris, 21/22-25 January. F I E R Z , G . 1965. Der Klangmagier von Londonoder: von der W r d e der Schallplatte, Fono forum, vol. 10, 3 March, p . 92-4. G E L A T T , R . 1954. The fabulous phonograph. Philadelphia. G I L O T A U X , P . 1962. L'industrie du disque. Paris, Presses Universitaires de France. (Collection: Q u e sais-je? 971.) G I L S O N , E . 1967. La socit de masse et sa culture. Paris, J. Vrin. G U R V I T C H , G . 1963. La vocation actuelle de la sociologie, 3rd d. 2 vols. Paris, Presses Universitaires de France. H A A S , W . ; K L E V E R , U . 1959. Die Stimme seines HerrnEine Geschichte der Schallplatte. Frankfort, Ullstein. J A C O B S , N . 1959. Culture of the millions? Princeton, Princeton University Press. K A P L A N , M . i960. Leisure in America. N e w York. K A T Z , E . ; L A Z A R S F E L D , P . F . 1955. Personal influence. Glencoe, Free Press. K I E F E R , K . 1967. Die Diffusion von Neuerungen. Tbingen, J. C B . M o h r . K N I G , R . 1962. Die M o d e in der menschlichen Gesellschaft. In: R . Knig and P . W . Schuppisser (eds.), Die Mode in der menschlichen Gesellschaft, p . 101-221. Zrich, Modebuch-Verlagsgesellschaft. L A Z A R S F E L D , P . F . 1965. Les intellectuels et la culture de masse. Communications, 5. P-3-12; M E R T O N , R . K . 1948. Mass communication, popular taste and organized social action. In: L . Bryson (ed.), The communication of ideas, p. 95-118. N e w York, Harper. LIST, K . 1968. Zur Soziologie der Schallplatte. Oesterreichische Musikzeitschrift, Vienna, vol. 23, p. 140-5. L W E N T H A L , L . 1961. Literature, popular culture and society. Englewood Cliffs, N . J . , Prentice Hall. M C L U H A N , M . 1962. The Gutenberg galaxy. London, Routledge & K e g a n Paul. . 1964. Understanding media. London, Routledge & Kegan Paul. M E R T O N , R . K . 1964. Social theory and social structure. London, Collier-Macmillan. M L L E R , J. H . 1963. Fragen des musikalischen Geschmacks. Cologne, Westdeutscher Verlag. P A R S O N S , T . 1966. Die Bedeutung der Polarisierung fr das Sozialsystem: Die Hautfarbe, das Polarisierungsproblem. In: A . Silbermann (ed.), Militanter Humanismus, p . 64-83. Frankfurt, Fischer.

666

Heinz Otto Luthe

P E S C H L E R , E . A . 1968. W a r u m mssen Schallplatten so teuer sein? Die Weltwoche, Zrich, 31 M a y , p. 37. R E A D , O . 1959. From tinfoil to stereo, evolution of the phonograph. Indianapolis. R E I C H A R D T , R . 1962. Die Schallplatte als kulturelles und konomisches Phnomen. Zrich, Polygraphischer Verlag. R O S E N B E R G , B . ; W H I T E , D . M . 1957. Mass culture. Glencoe, Free Press. S I L B E R M A N N , A . 1965. Schallplatte und Gesellschaft. In: A . Silbermann (ed.), Ketzereien eines Soziologen, p. 165-87. Dsseldorf, Econ. ; L U T H E , H . O . 1968. Massenkommunikation. In: R . Knig (ed.), Handbuch der empirischen Sozialforschung, vol. II. Stuttgart, Enke. S O N S T E V O L D , G . ; B L A U K O P F , K . 1968. Musik der 'einsamen Masse'. Karlsruhe, Braun. V U I L L E R M O Z , E . (ed.). 1951. Almanack du disque. Paris, Horay. W E B E R , M . 1956. Die rationalen und soziologischen Grundlagen der Musik. In: M . W e b e r , Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft, 4th ed., vol. II, p. 877 et seq. Tbingen,

Mohr.
W I L E N S K Y , H . L . 1964. M a s s society and mass culture: interdependence or independence. American sociological review, vol. 29, no. 2, p. 173-97. Z A H N , E . 1964. Sociologie der Prosperitt. M u n i c h , Deutscher Taschenbuchverlag.

Dr. Heinz Otto Luthe is Privatdozent at the University of Lausanne and research officer at its Institut de Recherches des Communications de Masse. He has published several articles and a book, Interpersonale Kommunikation u n d Beeinflussung (ig68).

O n the nature of art publics

Bruce W a t s o n

Although the sociology of the visual arts, taken as a whole, possesses a venerable tradition, research within the field has not been consistently fertile.1 Largely European in origin, research has emphasized stylistic a n d value changes, 2 and psychoanalytic explorations into the role of the artist and the creative process.3 Such concerns c o m e close to, a n d even overlap, the territory of the art historian, thus frightening off m a n y sociologists from this area of specialization. However, if research is re-oriented towards those social structures relevant to art, then sociologists do have both the training and perspective necessary for undertaking research in the sociology of art. O n e area which the sociologist is uniquely equipped to assess is that of the art public.4 T h e phrase 'art public' is used frequently in the singular in both the history and the sociology of art. Three different meanings have been attached to it. First, art public has been used in a singular a n d indefinite sense to refer to all those w h o c o m e into contact with art in any w a y . 6 Often applied to discussions of nineteenth-century art, this is a viewpoint that dichotomizes society into the artist, o n the one side, a n d the public, o n the othera public seen, more often that not, as antagonistic, u n s y m p a thetic and sometimes rude. T h e press is viewed as the mouthpiece of the public, providing it with critical clichs. T h e near-mob scenes at the
i. For an assessment o research needs see J. Barnett, 'The Sociology of Art', in: R . K . Merton et al. (eds.), Sociology Today, p. 197 ff., N e w York, Basic Books, 1959. 2. P . Sorokin, Fluctuations of Art Forms, Vol. I of Social and Cultural Dynamics, N e w York, American Books, 1937-41; A . Hauser, The Social History of Art, N e w York, Knopf, 1951, 2 vols. 3. A . Hauser, Philosophy of Art History, N e w York, Knopf, 1959, p. 41 ff. The greater number of contributions properly belong to the history of art. One of the most provocative is O . Benesch, The Art of the Renaissance in Northern Europe, Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1947. 4. This paper is an extension and revision of remarks which originally appeared in m y study Kunst, Knstler und soziale Kontrolle (Art, artists and social control), p. 63-70, CologneOpladen, Westdeutscher Verlag, 1961. 5. See: S. Hunter, Modern French Printing, N e w York, Dell, 1956; and M . W . Smith, The Artist in Tribal Society, N e w York, Free Press, 1961, p. ix.

Int. Soc. Sei. / . , Vol. X X , No. 4, 1968

668

Bruce Watson

French Salon exhibits of the nineteenth century, illustrated in the humorous prints of Honor Daumier, have lent an air of authenticity to this dichotomy. A second, and m o r e sophisticated, notion of 'art public' was advanced by A n d r e w Carduff Ritchie.1 H e used the phrase to refer to those w h o are interested in, and collect the works of one particular artist. T h u s , reference can be m a d e to Matisse and his public, Picasso and his public, and so o n . In this sense, the phrase 'art public' would be synonymous with a following. A third use has restricted the phrase to the aesthetic lites of society: artists, patrons, collectors, m u s e u m and gallery officials, and some critics.2 This usage stems from the realization that there are m a n y people in society w h o get along quite well without ever looking at a work of art. It restricts the meaning to those w h o are most continually and intimately involved in the processes of art, and often implies that the rest form an amorphous mass. It is obvious that there has been no agreement regarding the use of the the phrase 'art public'. E a c h meaning attempts to describe a different aspect of the same form of behaviour. T h efirstmeaning, perhaps useful in describing a certain time a n d place in French art, is not necessarily applicable to an entire universe of study for it does not discriminate sufficiently between various types of responses and values. T h e second meaning is, perhaps, too restrictive. Although it is useful to pinpoint the following of any artist in order better to understand systems of patronage, purchasing, and the politics of m u s e u m and gallery showing, it is a viewpoint which does not adequately account for overlapping loyalties and the less committed a m o n g art viewers. T h e third viewpoint exaggerates one aspect of society to the exclusion of others, becoming an over-generalization. T h e problem in this article, therefore, is to find a w a y through the terminological confusion. It is hoped that in doing so a heuristic spur will be provided with which a so-far reluctant body of sociologists m a y be urged into a most challenging area of research. It is also hoped that a reliable set of descriptive categories will be developed so that sociologists and art historians alike can m o r e accurately assess the relationship between art, artists, and society.

The Armory Show

A n empirical study of a contemporary art public is a rare undertaking. Therefore, as for the sociology of culture in general, this inquiry into the nature of an art public will rely upon historical data. O n e of the most thoroughly documented events from which some meaningful generalizations can be d r a w n w a s the exhibition of late
i. A . C . Ritchie, Matisse, his Art and his Public, N e w York, Museum of Modern Art, 1951. See also Read Bain's definition of an 'appreciate public' in: J. Gould and W . Kolb (eds.). Dictionary of the Social Sciences, N e w York, Free Press, 1964, p. 558. 2. Kenneth Clark, 'Art and Society', Harper's, Vol. 223, August 1961, p. 74-82. For further comment on the nature of aesthetic lites see Watson, op. cit., p. 57-63.

O n the nature of art publics

669

nineteenth- and early twentieth-century art held in 1913 in the armoury of the 69th Regiment of the N e w York National Guard. It is best k n o w n as the Armory S h o w , 1 and was promoted by a group of four American artists Walt K u h n , Elmer M a c R a e , Jerome Myers and Henry Taylor. Soon thereafter, the names of Arthur Davies and of the lawye ernd art collector John Quinn were to become prominent w h e n the young artists organized themselves into the Association of American Painters and Sculptors. W h a t m a d e the Armory S h o w historically significant is that it was the first time that contemporary European painting was exhibited in America. Although the purpose of the exhibition was to bring contemporary American art to the attention of America and although a historical perspective was given by including works of Ingres, Delacroix, G o y a , Courbet and the Impressionists, these came out second-best. Attention was chiefly attracted by Czanne, Matisse, Picasso, Picabia and the Duchamps-Villon family. T h e show opened with a preview for the press on Sunday evening, 16 February, which was attended b y approximately 1,000 people. A reception was held the next evening with about 5,000 in attendance.2 W h e n the show closed a month later on 15 M a r c h , the estimated total attendance was 87,62o. 3 It was, as the numbers suggest, a heterogeneous collection of viewers. Walter K u h n wrote, 'Actors, musicians, butlers, and shop girls . . . the exquisite, the vulgar from all walks of life' came to see the exhibition.4 T h e Armory S h o w became a fashionable place for the socially prominent to be seen. Enrico Caruso drew caricatures of the paintings and gave them away to his admirers. School teachers brought their classes. Art students came to study the n e w movements. Prostitutes and procurers came to see the 'dirty pictures'.6 W h a t is usually remembered about the Armory S h o w is the condemnation heaped upon it. Three forms of negative response can be distinguished. T h e first major negative response was a simple aesthetic argument : the paintings and sculpture were bad art, or, worse, not art at all. Knoedler's gallery in N e w York refused to advertise the exhibition because it was felt that radical tendencies in art were being fostered. T h e critic, Royal Cortissoz, writing in various periodicals of the time, was the unofficial leader of negative opinion. H e considered Czanne a sincere amateur w h o did not k n o w his trade. H e thought V a n G o g h to be moderately competent but heavy-handed, with the result that m u c h canvas had been spoiled
1. The most comprehensive work on the Armory S h o w is M . VV. B r o w n , The Story of the Armory Show, N e w York, Hirshhorn Foundation, 1963. This contains a complete bibliography. See also Russell Lynes, The Tastemakers, N e w York, Harper, 1955, chapter 12; and O . W . Larkin, Art and Liie in America, N e w York, Rinehart, 1949, chapter 28. 2. B r o w n , op. cit., p . 95. 3. loc. cit. Lynes, op. cit., p. 207, gives afigureof 100,000; however, he did not have at his disposal the papers of Elmer M a c R a e , w h o acted as treasurer; these were only found in 1957. 4. Quoted in Lynes, op. cit., p. 206. 5. W h e n the show was sent to Chicago it was subjected to an inquiry by the Illinois State Vice Commission. Apparently nothing came of this, but it added to an already inflamed situation (ibid., p. 219).

670

Bruce Watson

with unimportant pictures. Another critic, K e n y o n Cox, saw in the paintings of Czanne the work of a hopeless incompetent. In Henri Rousseau he found an inept innocence. T h e anatomical distortions, the vivid colours, and the abstraction of it all was anathema to those weaned on American academic art. T h e second, and most damaging, response to the exhibition was one of h u m o u r . M a n y of those w h o c a m e to the exhibition found it only a huge joke. Julian Street, writing in Everybody's, a popular magazine of the period, described Marcel D u c h a m p s ' ' N u d e Descending a Staircase' as 'an explosion in a shingle factory', an oft-quoted c o m m e n t which set the tone for this type of criticism. Brancusi's 'Mile Pogany' was viewed by another critic as a hard-boiled egg balanced on a cube of sugar. Various m o c k exhibitions were held, such as the one for the benefit of the Lighthouse of the N e w York Association for the Blind at which afirstprize was given to a painting by a girl 10 years old. T h e jury of another m o c k exhibition gave a prize to a painting allegedly done by a chimpanzee. Americans lampooned what they did not understand.1 T h e third major response to the Armory S h o w was one of moral indignation. T h e nudes of Gauguin and of Matisse were considered grotesque and indecent. A minor American poet, Mrs. Carey Sheffield, was quoted as saying that the show was a menace to morals, a degrading, degenerate, and evil influence composed out of the excrescence of art.2 T h e critic K e n y o n Cox saw in the exhibition a call to anarchy and called d o w n upon it this most bitter criticism: it was thoroughly un-American. W h a t is sometimes forgotten about the Armory S h o w is that, despite the avalanche of adverse criticism and the controversy generated by it, there were those critics w h o found m u c h that was good. However, as Milton B r o w n has so well pointed out, the essential merit of the exhibition was rooted in philosophical, rather than aesthetic reasoning.3 T h e natural, and even biological, evolution of art was stressed. Thus, the sweep of nineteenth-century painting was seen to be but a natural predecessor to Matisse and the Cubists. A more traditional defence, one perhaps calculated to meet countercharges that the show was un-American, was m a d e in the n a m e of individualism. Alfred Stieglitz, writing" in the Sunday Times (New York) of 26 January, captured the essence of the argument w h e n he wrote, 'Individual independence, both in expression and in acceptance or rejection of whatever is expressedthat is the first principle of those w h o are trying to inject some life into the decaying corpse of art.'4 Individualism was thereby equated with creativity and artistic genius. Even the maniacal tendencies seen in the exhibition by those opposed to it were used in defence of the show. T h e critic Christopher Brinton saw an
1. 2. 3. 4. For these and other negative c o m m e n t s about the exhibit see B r o w n , op. cit., chapter 7. bid., p. 138. ibid., p. 156 ff. ibid., p. 152.

O n the nature of art publics

671

elemental savagery, an optical music, and an emotional mathematics that reflected the subjective experiences and feelings of the artists. Joel Springarn, of Columbia University, found a further triumph of an intellectual revolution through which the artists had 'the courage to express themselves without equivocating with their souls'.1 Whether or not such positive commentary had any effect is difficult to assess. It is a fact, none the less, that those w h o organized the show considered it to be an enormous success. Not only did thousands of people come to see the exhibition, but sales were brisk. Total sales amounted to #44,148.75, 2 the works of Odilon R e d o n selling best. Thirteen paintings and pastels and twenty of his prints were sold. Paradoxically, in view of the criticism they received, the m e m b e r s of the Duchamps-Villon family also sold well. R a y m o n d Duchamps-Villon sold all but one of his sculptures, Jacques Villon sold all nine of his paintings, and Marcel D u c h a m p s sold all four of his, including ' N u d e Descending a Staircase', which was purchased unseen by a collector in San Francisco for $324. T h e consensus about the effects of the A r m o r y S h o w is that, despite the cries of insanity and degeneracy, the exhibition profoundly changed American attitudes to art. Certainly, the show brought modern art to America and, in the long run, helped form the core of m a n y fine collections, such as that of Lillie Bliss w h o contributed m u c h to the N e w York M u s e u m of M o d e r n Art.

The nature of art publics

T h e word public m a y be defined as 'an amorphous social structure whose members share a community-of-interest, which has been produced by impersonal communication and contact. . . . They are not groups but they are more structured than those w h o m a y be placed together in an aggregate. W h e n the members of a public meet each other or communicate in writing or by telephone, they have a "fellow-feeling" and "talk each other's language". This is what makes them a social structure, though obviously a very amorphous one, rather than a logical category or term in a classification'.3 A public, then, is a more-or-less informal type of structure. In contrast to more highly organized groups, a public, to use Karl M a n n h e i m ' s terminology, is diffuse.4 Through the A r m o r y S h o w three factors can be examined which contribute to the diffuse or amorphous character of art publics.

1. 2. 3. 4.

Quoted in Brown, op. cit., p . 156. ibid., p . 97. Read Bain, op. cit., p. 558. Systematic Sociology, London, Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1957, p. 107. See also R . H . Turner and L . M . Killian, Collective Behavior, Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall, 1957, chapters 12 and 13.

672

Bruce Watson

i. O n e factor, as noted, which contributes to the formation of a public is impersonal communication. This does not m e a n that face-to-face contact is totally absent. It does imply that opinions, sentiments and beliefs m a y be conveyed by media of communication to which people have little or no direct access except as consumers. This is exemplified in the arena of politics in which the various mass media of communication function to disseminate information and mould opinion. A work of art is an exaggeration of this principle. A painting or a sculpture is a silent third party to the act of communication. Thus, the viewers mustfirstattempt to interact with the work, not with the artist, then with one another. This situation allows for a variety of possibilities. T h e work m a y be so esoteric that no one understands it. T h e work m a y be understood by some and not by others. O r , the work m a y communicate to everyone w h o sees it. In this last instance, the work can be said to be exoteric. Thus, a range of responses to the work of art is possible, extending from the nave (viewing the work, often dogmatically, as if it were an object elevated to the perceptual level) to the informed or disciplined (viewing the work as a special kind of creation and from the standpoint of the principles and elements of composition). T h e range of responses implied by the dichotomy strongly suggests that communication m a y not be present between the viewer and the art work, m u c h less the artist. Certainly this occurred in the Armory S h o w as illustrated by the ill-intentioned h u m o u r directed against it and in the more abstruse commentary in favour of it. Moreover, if someone has difficulty in understanding a work of art then there is a possibility that communication between viewers m a y be impeded. It is true that viewers in a similar situation m a y share a c o m m o n response, such as humour or rage or consternation, but such c o m m o n experience does not result in any better understanding of the work that stimulated those responses. Furthermore, communication m a y be impeded by the viewers' falling into the fallacy of intention. Rather than reading meaning from the symbolic content of the work, the viewer projects upon the work, and, by implication, upon the artist, his o w n feelings and thoughts. Thus, what is communicated between viewers is not the content of the art work but their o w n often unconscious, mental states. That this is mistaken for the content of the work leads to confusion because of the variability of responses possible in this situation. Finally, another factor which m a y impede communication is that, in art publics, as in other areas of life, there is no necessary relationship between the overt response and the covert feeling. There is no reason to believe that those collectors w h o purchased so m u c h from the Armory S h o w had any better understanding of the works, per se, than those w h o came to jeer and sneer. A s noted, ' N u d e Descending a Staircase' was purchased unseen. Thus, the tasteless h u m o u r , on the one side, and the glib pseudo-intellectual explanations of a work, on the other, m a y be no more than superficial veneers disguising feelings that are difficult, if not impossible to articulate.

O n the nature of art publics

673

2. Art publics are initially heterogeneous and unselected in composition.1 Those w h o participate in such a public do so because they believe that such participation will provide them with the means of attaining the kinds of values or satisfactions they desire. Therefore, some w h o attended the A r m o r y S h o w m a y have done so out of a certain aesthetic desire to become acquainted with n e w movements in European art, as in the case of the collectors and the more positive critics. It is just as possible that m a n y more attended the exhibition out of a desire to satisfy recreational needs. T h u s , the show became a place in which to be entertained. Others found in the show a means to enhance their social prestige as attendance became 'the right thing to do' and the Armory the 'right place to be seen'. It can be said, then, that a variety of motives lie behind participation in art publics. Whatever motivations m a y induce participation in art publics, m e m bership, in general, is unselective. O n e merely has to pay a small fee at special exhibitions, such as the A r m o r y S h o w , or walk through the doors of a public m u s e u m or gallery. T o d a y , in the United States, attendance records indicate that approximately sixty million people annually visit m u s e u m s . Free community art festivals further increase the n u m b e r of participants. Although general membership is unselective, the quality of participation engaged in by the m e m b e r s begins to establish differentiations. This, to a large measure, is related to the kinds of values which inspired participation in thefirstplace. It would appear that what begins as a heterogeneous collectivity is soon divided into various kinds of publics. Beyond the bond of satisfaction, there appears to have been little or n o relationship between those w h o attended the Armory S h o w simply as an entertainment and those w h o ^ c a m e to study or collect. 3. T h e lack of communication between viewers, as a whole, and the heterogeneous nature of the composition of art publics leads to another element that contributes to diffusiveness. Art publics do not represent one 'community of interest' but, instead a number of such 'communities'. Both the 'fellow-feeling' and the 'talking each other's language' that Bain indicated as necessary to the creation of the rather amorphous structure of a public are generally absent. Three factors impede the development of a general community of interest. First, by the nature of their composition, art publics do not allow for a fluent expression and counter-expression of sentiments, attitudes, and opinions. A s Louis Wirth once noted, it is afluentcommunication process that aids in the creation of the ' W e ' feeling that, in turn, allows a n u m b e r of persons to act as a unit.2 But the over-all level of interaction in art publics is simply too diffuse for a general sense of community to develop. Second, if a sentiment, an attitude, or an opinion is expressed, there is no w a y of
1. See R . T . La Piere, Collective Behavior, N e w York, McGraw-Hill, 1938, p. 276. 2. Louis Wirth, 'Consensus and Mass Communication', American Sociological Review, Vol. 13, February 1948, p. 1-15.

674

Bruce Watson

ascertaining whether the overt expression is a direct reflection of a covert feeling. It is possible, therefore, that m a n y of those w h o laughed at the paintings at the A r m o r y S h o w did so simply because others were doing so. It is also within the realm of possibility that a m o n g those viewers w h o expressed a favourable response some did so simply because they wished to display more knowledge than they actually possessed. Hence, any response to a work of art m a y , in principle, be a disguise for bewilderment or essential ignorance. T h e third factor impeding the development of an embracing community of interest is the nature of the art object. It is a single artefact, often displayed a m o n g a large n u m b e r of similar artefacts. This raises the question of whether a viewer's response is to a general category of works or to a particular work within the category. W e r e those shocked by the display of Matisse paintings at the A r m o r y S h o w repelled by a confrontation with a galleryfilledwith colours they had seen, or w a s it a response to each successive work, or was the experience of one painting extended to the whole collection? There is, as yet, no certain measure of this. N o r is the purchase of any particular work a measure of fellow-feeling. Whereas a book public m a y manifest such feeling through sales and library circulation, the sale of a work of art indicates nothing except that someone was willing to pay the price. O f course, people m a y read a book for a variety of reasons: information, entertainment, or because others are reading it. Similar motivations m a y be behind the purchase of a painting, yet purchasing a painting is still an individual, rather than a collective, act. A n over-all community of interest amongst those attending an exhibition seems to be improbable. Yet, as the visitors differentiate themselves into various levels of publics, as suggested above, the problem of 'community' assumes a n e w dimension. T h e following proposition can be advanced: a lack of community will be characteristic of an art public the interaction of which is of secondary character, but a community of interest m a y be attained in an art public whose interaction is primary in character. T h u s , a m o n g those w h o attend an exhibition for purely recreational purposes, there is little probability that unanimity of opinion will be obtained. In contrast, a m o n g those w h o are themselves artists, patrons or collectors, there is a distinct possibility that a fellow-feeling m a y develop as a consequence of the more intimate and frequent interaction between such persons.

The typology
In the description of the A r m o r y S h o w it was indicated that critical positions towards the exhibition could be divided into the negative and the positive. In the discussion of the diffuse nature of art publics, it was implied that a variety of values motivated attendance at the exhibition. T h e critical positions m a y be viewed as a dichotomy of attitudes in the sense that they represent internally aroused, but socially acquired, predispositions of an individual towards class of objects. Such predispositions usually generate

O n the nature of art publics

675

some form of action which, in the case of art publics, takes the form of verbal gestures. Values differ in relation to the kind of activities pursued by those w h o attend an exhibition. Those w h o formed the committee which created the A r m o r y S h o w a n d certain collectors and critics viewed the art as an end in itself. T h e values held by such persons could be described, therefore, as intrinsic in nature. In contrast, there were those w h o attended the exhibition as a means of attaining values that had nothing to do with art as such. Such values would be extrinsic in nature and exemplified, for instance, by recreational aims. It is also possible for persons to participate in an art public with a dualism of values. T h u s , an intrinsic-extrinsic category of values is possible. This is exemplified b y persons w h o attend an exhibition as a means of attaining educational values but, at the same time, are capable of developing a deep commitment to art. T h e categories of attitudes and values provide a basis distinguishing between six types of art publics (Table 1).
T A B L E I . A typology of art publics Attitude dimension Value dimension Positive Negative

Intrinsic Intrinsic-extrinsic Extrinsic

Art-for-art's-sake Educational Recreational

Pseudo-critical Didactic Status-seekers

This typology is at some variance with the kinds of publics discussed by Bernard Rosenberg and Norris Fliegel.1 T h e y list four types of publics: friends; buyers and collectors; viewers; a n d critics.8 A s with the typology presented herein, the Rosenberg and Fliegel list of publics is suggestive. However, it does raise certain difficulties in relationship to any further analysis of the connexion between artists and their publics. Perhaps the greatest difficulty is that it does not discriminate enough within and between the various categories. For example, critics are discussed as a single type; yet it appears from the evidence of the A r m o r y S h o w that a m o r e careful distinction must be m a d e between those w h o give support to the artists' endeavours a n d those w h o are characteristically critical of almost any innovation in the arts. Essentially the s a m e criticism can be m a d e of the buyer and collector category. Obviously, from the evidence Rosenberg and Fliegel present, there are buyers a n d collectors w h o are motivated by different attitudes to art: s o m e are genuine connoisseurs; others are merely interested in prestige or the investment potential of art. A second problem of the Rosenberg and Fliegel categories is that they are based on the
1. The Vanguard Artist, Chicago, Quadrangle Books, 1965, chapter 6. 2. This l i s t bears a similarity to the relationships between authors and society described by H . D . Duncan. See Language and Literature in Society, Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1953, p. 68-74. See also Watson, op. cit., chapter 6.

676

Bruce Watson

perceptions of artists. This approach is valuable if interest is focused on the artists' observations of society and its sub-structures; o n the other hand, artists m a y not be definitive enough in their observations to m a k e accurate assessments of the nature of their publics. There m a y be distinctions that elude them. For example, m u s e u m s and dealers are not considered as elements of an artist's public.1 It will be seen in the following interpretation of the typology presented in Table 1 that there are a few areas of agreement with the Rosenberg and Fliegel categories. H o w e v e r , as implied, more distinctions are m a d e within and between categories. 1. Intrinsic valuepositive attitude. This category m a y be described as an art-for-art's-sake public. It somewhat parallels the category of 'friends' discussed by Rosenberg and Fliegel, but is broader in membership than they indicate.2 Composed of artists, collectors, patrons, and connoisseurs, this public is closest to the creative act. Frequently well-known to each other within a given community, as was the case with those associated with the A r m o r y S h o w , and today k n o w n to one another internationally, this public has the most intimate pattern of interaction of all. It is an intimacy born of a high degree of commitment to art; indeed, for m a n y , it is a w a y of life. It is in this sense that one might agree with Kenneth Clark that art is created by a minority for a minority.3 A s is well k n o w n , the greater part of the history of art has been characterized b y a very close relationship between painters and their patrons. In contemporary society, as the artist has freed himself from the traditional bonds of patronage, the somewhat romantic assumption has been m a d e that he is s o m e h o w a free spirit. W h a t has happened is that the artist n o w finds himself to be another participant in the market system. O n e artist interviewed by Rosenberg and Fliegel exemplified this point w h e n he said that it w a s immaterial w h o bought his paintingsit was just another anonymous person.4 Within this market system, the contact by the artist with galleries, m u s e u m s , collectors, agents, and other artists w h o m a y foster such contacts becomes both artistically desirable and economically necessary since these are the persons w h o foster artists, purchase their works, and enhance reputations. Nevertheless, these concerns are organized around and oriented towards art as a means of advancing the artistic enterprise. 2. Extrinsic valuepositive attitude. This category is represented by what can be termed the recreational art public. Its origins are found in pleasurable pastime activities. Such activity is not an end in itself but is a means of establishing or maintaining congenial relationship, such as those a m o n g a
1. 2. 3. 4. Rosenberg and Fliegel, op. cit., chapter 7. ibid., p. 193-4. Clark, op. cit., p. 75. op. cit., p. 197. See also B . S. Myers, Problems of the Younger American Artist, N e w York, McGraw-Hill, 1957.

O n the nature of art publics

677

group of friends or within a family. T h a t visiting an art exhibition is a means of satisfying such ends is often fortuitous : a science m u s e u m , an aquarium, or the cinema might equally have been chosen. T h e factor of chance contributes to the conditions that m a k e this public the most diffuse of all, and the least likely to achieve a m o n g its general membership a sense of fellow-feeling. There is n o need to articulate covert feelings nor is there a need to appear articulate about the art works. Indeed, visiting an exhibition m a y result in m e m b e r s of this public looking at m a n y works but seeing very few. Visits are simply a m e a n s of using time in a socially approved manner. Another factor contributing to the diffuse nature of recreational art publics is size. It seems plausible, based on the numbers attending, to assume that most viewers at the A r m o r y S h o w belonged to this category of art public. Thus, the size and transient nature of their contact would diminish the possibility of more intimate forms of interaction and c o m m u nication. T h e recreational art public most parallels what Rosenberg and Fliegel simply term 'viewers', but they include under that rubric literally everyone not in their other three categories.1 This is too inclusive, for the term 'viewers' does not distinguish between varying motivations for exhibition attendance. This is demonstrated in the analysis of the next type. 3. Intrinsic-extrinsic valuepositive attitude. This form is typified by those interested in the educational aspects of art. Such persons are included by Rosenberg and Fleigel in the 'viewer' category. Although a similarity exists with respect to attitudes, between the recreational art public and what might be termed the educational art public, their value orientations are somewhat different. T h u s , some of those w h o visited the A r m o r y S h o w c a m e neither to scoff nor praise but to study and learn; hence, art for these persons was a means of attaining an educational goal but, at the same time, this did not preclude developing a high degree of commitment to art. Membership in the educational art public often results from some preexisting association. College and university art classes as well as classes of schoolchildren are often members of this type of public simply by virtue of their membership in an educational institution. Sometimes membership in the educational art public is stimulated by m u s e u m s . Educational lectures are frequently offered in conjunction with current exhibitions. S o m e m u s e u m s offer regular classes in studio work, art appreciation, and elementary art history. It is at this point that some anomalous features of the educational art public appear. Membership m a y be a disguise for other values and attitudes. It is possible that formal study of the history or appreciation of art or of studio work are a means of achieving recreational satisfactions. Also, there are persons w h o would prefer to belong to the aesthetic lite yet, in order to avoid being labelled snobs, associate themselves with educational art publics. Again a disguise is put up behind which
1. op. cit., p . 203 fi.

678

Bruce Watson

other values can be satisfied. In any case, the patterns of interaction and the bonds of feeling that m a y emerge from them are, in educational art publics, less a consequence of involvement with art and m o r e a result of interactions established in the pre-existing association. 4 . Intrinsic valuenegative attitude. Throughout the nineteenth century in Europe, and especially in France, this category of art public would have been disciples of 'the A c a d e m y ' . Conservative in their opinions, art for them was that which conformed to preconceived standards of taste. It was against this public that m a n y French artists from Courbet to Gauguin reacted. In the United States, at the time of the A r m o r y S h o w , there w a s no formal academy of nation-wide reputation to preach a gospel of conservatism. Rather, there were individual critics, such as Royal Cortissoz, w h o expounded a similar aesthetic philosophy. Realistic drawing, historical and allegorical subjects, and precise brushwork were a m o n g the distinguishing features supposed to m a k e great artin short, art was supposed to be an imitation of nature. Such a position is viewed in this typology as pseudocritical. It has an intrinsic value stemming from a high degree of commitm e n t to a particular kind of art.1 It is accompanied by a negative attitude, however, because any work that deviates from this m o d e of art is considered to be bad art or not art at all. Such a public is far from being a relic of the past. It is exemplified in the United States, at least, by numerous associations of artists and would-be artists, such as the Association of Western Artists, w h o regularly denounce any innovations in art. T h e falsity of their critical position lies in their refusal or inability to understand the nature of artistic experimentation, and their misreading of the history of art, in as far as they consider themselves to be the inheritors of the classical standards of Greece, seventeenth-century France, and the neo-classical tradition. Because of the intense emotional appeal of their criticism, utilizing as in the case of the Armory S h o w such expressive language as 'degenerate', 'corrupt', and 'un-American', members of this public m a y develop a fellow-feeling second only to that of the art-for-art's-sake public. Again, the category 'critics' used by Rosenberg and Fleigel seems over-simplified.2 Thus, a m o d e r n critic such as Clement Greenberg, one of the earliest and staunchest defenders of Jackson Pollock and abstract-expressionism, can hardly be placed in the same category as the members of the pseudocritical public.3

1. Essentially the same critical position has been taken on occasion with respect to the contemporary architect. See Lucio Costa, 'The Architect in Contemporary Society', in: International Conference of Artists, 1952, The Artist in Modern Society, Paris, Unesco, 1954, p. 90.
2. op. cit., p . 208 ff.

3. It should be noted that accusations have been made as often that contemporary, non-objective art is becoming clich-ridden, repetitious, and supported by a conspiracy of critics whose manoeuvrings are as devious as those of the academies of the past. For an assessment of the situation see E . C. Baker, 'Is There a N e w Academy?' in: T . B . Hess and J. Ashbery (eds.), The Academy, Art News Annual XXXIII, p. 141-8, N e w York, Macmillan, 1967.

O n the nature of art publics

679

5. Extrinsic valuenegative attitude. T h e interest in art as far as this public is concerned is patently a disguise for attaining values that have nothing to do with art. M e m b e r s m a y seek to associate with artists and m a y even collect their works; yet neither the artists nor their works are in fact the ends pursued. It is, instead, the feeling of status that they feel can be gained from such associations and activities and for this reason, such people are called 'status-seekers'. T h e negativism of this public is derived from their lack of commitment to art: their concern is to be a m o n g the avant garde of taste. In consequence, there is a perpetual need to change artistic loyalties as n e w artists and n e w art movements manifest themselves. It is this public which, perhaps, is responsible for the negative feelings towards buyers expressed by those artists interviewed by Rosenberg and Fliegel.1 'Today's collector', said one artist, 'is engaged in self-uplift; he can't live without it.'2 A s John Canaday put it, such buyers, searching for instant culture, find gratification in 'the pseudo-esoteric item for general prestige consumption'. 3 6. Intrinsic-extrinsic valuesnegative attitude. T h e last category is exemplified by the quotation from M r s . Sheffield w h o found the A r m o r y S h o w to be a threat to morals. H e r reaction was, of course, negative, and it w a s widely shared at the time, even a m o n g sociologists. E . A . Ross, several years earlier, had written that art should be a beacon light of moral progress and condemned what he considered to be decadent movements of self-expression created by ego-maniacs. 4 This attitude is still occasionally expressed. For example, in 1953, in D u b u q u e , Iowa, The Pocket Book of Old Masters was seized from bookstands as obscene and offensive to public morality because of the paintings of nudes reproduced in it.5 T h e negative attitudes expressed by the m e m b e r s of this art public are a reflection of their belief that art should portray only certain kinds of subjects. Because of their commitment to this particular kind of art, their values can be considered intrinsic to a degree and supportive of the endeavours of the pseudo-critical art public. H o w e v e r , that commitment is intensified by the extrinsic value that art is a means of attaining a higher morality. For this reason the term didactic is applied to this form of art public.

Conclusion A n u m b e r of concepts pertinent to the analysis of art publics have been discussed. These are of value in understanding historical situations, but the question remains whether or not they can be m a d e operational for the
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. op. cit., p. 194 ff. ibid., p. 200. Quoted in Rosenberg and Fliegel, op. cit., p . 200. 'Social Control, VII: Art', American Journal of Sociology, Vol. VIII, N o . 1, July 1897, p . 74. David D e m p s e y , ' T h e Revolution in Books', Atlantic Monthly, Vol. C X C I , January 1953, p. 76.

68o

Bruce W a t s o n

analysis of contemporary situations. T o that end the typology that is offered must be considered suggestive. T h u s , viewed as a heuristic device, the typology m a y be helpful in formulating hypotheses, as the following preliminary conceptualizations suggest. There is no direct relationship between value and attitude orientations and the sense of community of interest felt by m e m b e r s of art publics. T h e sense of community of interest will be greater within those art publics whose members develop a high degree of commitment to art, irrespective of value and attitude orientations. T h e greater the sense of community and commitment to art, the greater will be the possibility of a more formal organization emerging from the amorphous structure of the public. There is not necessarily any relationship between satisfaction of goals and the value and attitude orientations of art publics. If a public emerges for the satisfaction of immediate goals, such as recreation, the degree of fellow-feeling felt by its m e m b e r s will be very low. H o w e v e r helpful these conceptualizations m a y prove to be, one point does seem certain. T h e use of the phrase 'the art public' is an oversimplification that has little bearing upon social reality. This conclusion is significant for two reasons. T h e first is substantive. If the notion of a single art public is incorrect, then the assumptions based thereon of the relationship between art, artists, and society are also incorrect or, at least, open to question. W h a t is needed to correct the situation are more empirical studies, as noted above, such as have already been done on the sociology of literature.1 T h e second point of significance is theoretical. T h e sociology of the visual arts has been dominated by a rather organic view of art and society. Literature in thefieldhas typically discussed the public and the artist w h e n w e want to k n o w about a public and an artist.2 This is a consequence of the imposition u p o n the subject-matter of general theoretical schemes which, in expounding their generalities, purport to explain particulars.3 T h e result is an illusion of verification of the theoretical schema with n o greater insight into the subject. It isjno longer an adequate approach.
i. For example, see Leo Lowenthal, Literature, Popular Culture, and Society, Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall, 1961. 2. See page 667 of the present paper, notes 2 and 3. The work of A . C . Ritchie, op. cit., was a step in the direction of a greater empiricism, as is the recent volume by Harrison White and Cynthia White, Canvasses and Careers, N e w York, John Wiley, 1965. 3. For a complete discussion of this issue see John Dewey, Reconstruction in Philosophy, N e w York, Henry Holt, 1920, chapter VIII.

Bruce Watson teaches the history of art and sociology at Diablo Valley College in Concord, California. He is the author o/"Kunst, Knstler u n d soziale Kontrolle ( ig6i), co-author (with W. E. Tarr) of T h e Social Sciences a n d American Civilization (1964) and contributed an article on artists' associations to the forthcoming comparative encyclopaedia T h e Soviet System a n d Democratic Societies.

Select bibliography

General
B A R N E T T , J. H . Research areas in the sociology of arts. Sociology and social research, vol. 42, no. 6, 1958, p. 401-5. . T h e sociology of art. In: R . K . Merton, L . Broom, L . S. Cottrell, Jr. (eds.), Sociology today, problems and prospects, p. 197-214. N e w York, 1959. D E W E Y , J. Art as experience, N e w York, 1934. D O R N B U S C H , S. M . Content and method in the study of the higher arts. In: R . N . Wilson (ed.), The arts in society, p. 363-72. Englewood Cliffs (N.J.), 1964. D U N C A N , H . D . Sociology of art, literature, and music. Social contexts of symbolic experience. In: H . Becker and A . Boskoff (eds.), Modern sociological theory in continuity and change, p. 482-500. N e w York, 1957. D U V I G N A U D , J. La sociologie de l'art, Paris, 1966. . Problmes de la sociologie des arts. Cahiers internationaux de sociologie, vol. 26, 1959. P- I37-48G U Y A U , J . - M . L'art au point de vue sociologique. Paris, 1889. H O N I G S H E I M , P . Soziologie der Kunst, Musik und Literatur. In: G . Eisermann (ed.), Die Lehre von der Gesellschaft, p. 338-73. Stuttgart, 1958. K A Z I N , A . T h e function of criticism today. Commentary, vol. 30, no. 5, i960, p. 369-78. K N I G , R . ; S I L B E R M A N N , A . Der unversorgte selbstndige Knstler. ber die wirtschaftliche und soziale Lage der selbstndigen Knstler in der Bundesrepublik. Cologne and Berlin, 1964. L A L O , C h . L'art et la vie sociale. Paris, 1921. L A N G , K . Mass, class, and the reviewers. Social problems, 1958, p. 11-21. L O W E N T H A L , L . ; FisKE, M . T h e debate over art and popular culture in eighteenthcentury England. In: M . Komarovsky (ed.), Common frontiers of the social sciences. Glencoe (111.), 1957. M E N D I E T A Y N U N E Z , L . Sociologa del arte. Revista mexicana de sociologa; vol. 18, no. i, 1956, p. 9-18; vol. 19, no. 1, 1957, p . 67-84; vol. 19, no. 2, 1957, p . 405-21; vol. 20, no. 2, 1958, p. 317-35; vol. 21, no. 1, 1959, p. 9-30. M U E L L E R , J. H . T h e folkways of art: an analysis of the social theories of art. American journal of sociology, vol. 44, 1938-39, p. 222-38. M U K E R J E E , R . T h e sociological approach to art. Sociology and social research, vol. 30, 1945-46, p . 177-84. . The social function of art, N e w York, 1950. P L E K H A N O V , G . V . Art and society. N e w York, 1953. . Art and social life. London, 1953. R O S E N B E R G , B . ; W H I T E , D . M . (eds.). Mass culture; the popular arts in America. N e w York, 1962.

Int. Soc. Set. J., Vol. X X , No. 4,

1968

682

Select bibliography

S A C H S , C . The commonwealth of art. Style in thefinearts, music, and dance. London, 1955. S I L B E R M A N N , A . Kunst. In: R . Knig (ed.), Soziologie. Frankfurt on M a i n , 1958. T O M A R S , A . S. Introduction to the sociology of art, Mexico City, 1940. U N E S C O (ed.). The artist in modem society. N e w York, 1954. W I E S E , L . V . Methodologisches ber den Problemkreis einer Soziologie der Kunst. Verhandlungen des 7. deutschen Soziologentages. Tbingen, 1931, p. 121-32. W I L S O N , R . N . (ed.). The arts in society. Englewood Cliffs (N.J.), 1964.

The

plastic arts
R . T . ;S H A R P , L . M . T h e use of art in international communication: a

BOWER,

case study. Public opinion quarterly, vol. 20, no. 1, 1956, p . 221-9. C o L L i N G W O O D , R . G . The principles of art. London, 1938. E I S E N M A N N , R . Birth order and artistic creativity. Journal of individual psychology, vol. 20, no. 2 , 1964, p . 183-5. F R A N C A S T E L , P . Peinture et socit. Naissance et destruction d'un espace plastique de la Renaissance au Cubisme. Lyon, 1951. . Art et technique aux XIXe et XXe sicles. Paris, 1956 (Collection L ' h o m m e et la machine, d. by G . Friedmann, vol. 7.) H U S E R , A . Sozialgeschichte der Kunst und Literatur. M u n i c h , 1953. K A V O L I S , V . Art content and social involvement. Social forces, vol. 42, no. 4 , 1964, P- 467-72. . Abstract expressionism and puritanism. Journal of aesthetics and art criticism, vol. 21, no. 3, 1963, p . 315-19. . Economic correlates of artistic creativity. American journal of sociology, vol. 70, no. 3, 1964-65, p . 332-41. K U H N , H . Wesen und Wirken des Kunstwerks. Munich, i960. M A R T I N , A . von. Soziologie der Renaissance. Stuttgart, 1932 (2nd ed. Frankfurt on M a i n , 1949). M Y E R S , B . Problems of the younger American artists. N e w York, 1957. M O R R I S , R . E . W h a t is sociology of art? American Catholic sociological review, vol. 4 , I958> P- 310-21. R E A D , H . Art and society. London, 1937. . The grass roots of art. Lectures on the social aspects of art in an industrial age. Cleveland and N e w York, 1961 (ist ed. 1946). R O S E N B E R G , B . ; F L I E G E L , N . The vanguard artist: portrait and self portrait. Chicago, 1965S M I T H , M (ed.). T h e artist in tribal society. Proceedings of a symposium held at the Royal Anthropological Institute. London, 1961. S W E E N E Y , J. J. T h e m u s e u m in a mass society. Daedalus, vol. 89, no. 2, i960, p . 354-8. T H I E L E , E . (ed.). Die Situation der bildenden Kunst in Deutschland. Stuttgart and Cologne, 1954. V A N D E N H O U T E , P . J. Beschouwingen over het T h e m a Kunst en Maatschappij. Tijdschrift voor sociale Wetenschappen, vol. 5, no. 1, i960, p. 3-26. W A T S O N , B . A . Art and communication. Sociology and social research, vol. 43, no. 1, 1958, p . 28-33. . Kunst, Knstler und soziale Kontrolle. Cologne and Opladen, 1961.

Music
A D O R N O , T h . W . Dissonanzen. Musik in der verwalteten Welt, Gttingen, 1956. . Kunst- und Musiksoziologie. Soziologische Exkurse, Frankfurter Beitrge zur Soziologie. Frankfurt on M a i n , 1956, p . 93-105.

Select bibliography

683

. Einleitung in die Musiksoziologie, Frankfurt on M a i n , 1962. B A R Z U N , J. Music in American life. N e w York, 1956. B E C K E R , H . S. T h e professional dance musician and his audience. American journal of sociology, vol. 57, no. 2, 1951, p. 136-44. B E L V I A N E S , M . Sociologie de la musique. Paris, 1951. B E R N A R D , Y . L a chansonphnomne social. Revue franaise de sociologie, vol. 5, no. 2, 1964, p . 166-74. B L A U K O P F , K . Musiksoziologie. St. Gallen, 1950. -. Musik. In: W . Bernsdorf and F. Blow (eds.), Wrterbuch der Soziologie. Stuttgart, 1955. B C H E R , K . Arbeit und R h y t h m u s . Sitzungsberichte der Kgl. Schsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaft. 1896. E T Z K O R N , K . P . Social context of songwriting in the United States. Ethnomusicology, vol. 7, no. 2, 1963, p . 96-106. . Georg Simmel and the sociology of music. Social forces, vol. 43, no. 1, 1964, p. 101-7. F A R N S W O R T H , P . R . Tlie social psychology of music. N e w York, 1958. F E L L E R E R , K . G . Soziologie der Kirchenmusik, Materialien zur Musik- und Religionssoziologie. Cologne and Opladen, 1963. G N T H E R , S. Musik in der verwalteten Welt. Die gesellschaftliche Situation der Musik in Deutschland seit d e m Ende des ersten Weltkrieges. Klner Zeitschrift fr Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, vol. 16, n o . 3, p . 491-506. . Die Musik in der pluralistischen Massengesellschaft. ber die soziale Moblitt im deutschen Musikleben des 20. Jahrhunderts. Klner Ze^tschrift fr Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, vol. 19, no. 1, 1967, p. 64-86; vol. 19, no. 2, 1967, p. 28335H U G H E S , C h . W . The human side of music. N e w York, 1948. J A G E R , H . de. D e Sociologische Benaderingswijze van de Musiekgeschiedenis. Mens en Maatschappij, vol. 32, no. 1, 1957, p. 22-31. -. D e Componist in Sociologisch Perspectief. Mens en Maatschappij, vol. 39, no. 2, 1964, p. 107-16. K L A U S M E I E R , F . Jugend und Musik im technischen Zeitalter. B o n n , 1963. L E O N A R D , N . Jazz and the white Americans: the acceptance of a new art form. Chicago, 1962. M A C K E R N E S S , E . D . A social history of English music. L o n d o n , and Toronto, 1964. M A T Z K E , H . Musikkonomik und Musikpolitik. Grundzge einer Musikwirtschaftslehre. Ein Versuch. Breslau, 1927. M E R R I A M , A . P . Music in American culture. American anthropologist, vol. 57, no. 6, 1955, P- 1173-81. M U E L L E R , J. H . Methods of measurement of aesthetic folkways. American journal of sociology, vol. 51, 1945-46, p. 276-82. . T h e social nature of musical taste. Journal of research in music education, vol. 4, no. 2, 1956, p. 113-22. -. Fragen des musikalischen Geschmacks. Cologne and Opladen, 1963. N A S H , D . J. T h e socialization of an artist: the American composer. Social forces, vol. 35, no. 4, 1957, p. 307-13. NiEziNG, J. Overwinning van de Drempelvrees. Mens en Maatschappij, vol. 39, no. 2, 1964, p. 117-22. Radio, musique et socit. Actes d u congrs international sur les aspects sociologiques de la musique la radio, Paris, 27-30 octobre 1954. Cahiers d'tudes de radio-tlvision, 1955, vols. 3-4, p . 259-575. R E I C H A R D T , R . Die Schallplatte als kulturelles und konomisches Phnomen. Ein Beitrag zum Problem der Kunstkommerzialisierung. Zrich, 1962. R Y S E R , C . P . T h e student dancer. In: R . N . Wilson (ed.), The arts in society, p. 95121. Englewood Cliffs (N.J.), 1964. S A L M E N , W . Der fahrende Musiker im europischen Mittelalter. Kassel, i960.

684;

Select bibliography

S I L B E R M A N N , A . Introduction aune sociologie de la musique. Paris, 1955. . Wovon lebt die Musik. Die Prinzipien der Musiksoziologie. Regensburg, 1957. . Musik, Rundfunk und Hrer. Cologne and Opladen, 1959. (Fr.: La musique, la radio et l'auditeur, Paris, 1954.) Supiere, I. Problmes d e la sociologie musicale. Cahiers internationaux de sociologie, vol. 37, 1964, p . 119-29. U N E S C O (ed.). Music in education. International Commission on the Role and Place of Music in the Education of Youth and Adults, Brussels, 29 June-9 July I953> Paris, 1955. W E B E R , M . Die rationalen und soziologischen Grundlagen der Musik. M u n i c h , 1921. Z A N Z I G . A . D . Music in American life. N e w York, 1932. Z W E E R S , W . Muziekale Differentiatie en Sociale Stratifikatie. Mens en Maatschappij, vol. 39, no. 2, 1964, p . 90-106.

Literature

A B B E , D . M . van. Image of a people. Modern German writing in its social context. N e w York, 1964. A L B R E C H T , M . C . T h e relationship of literature and society. American journal of sociology, vol. 59, no. 5, 1954, p . 425-36. . Does literature reflect c o m m o n values? American sociological review, vol. 21, no. 6, 1956, p . 722-9. B A I N , R . Poetry and social research. Sociology and social research, vol. 12, no. 1, 1927, P- 35-49B A R N E T T , J. H . ; G R U E N R h . Recent American divorce novels, 1938-45. A study in the sociology of literature. Social forces, vol. 26, 1947-48, p . 322-7. B E J A , M . It must be important: Negroes in contemporary Americanfiction.Antioch review, vol. 24, no. 3, 1964, p . 323-36. B E N J A M I N , W . Z u m gegenwrtigen gesellschaftlichen Standort des franzsischen Schriftstellers. Zeitschrift fr Sozialforschung (Paris), vol. 3, no. 1, 1934, p . 54-78. B E R E L S O N , B . ; S A L T E R , P . J. Majority a n d minority Americans. A n analysis of magazinefiction.Public opinion quarterly, vol. 10, 1946, p . 168-90. B L O O M , A . D . Cosmopolitan m a n and the political community: a n interpretation of Othello. American political science review, vol. 54, no. 1, i960, p . 130-57. B O N A L D , L . de. uvres compltes de M. de Bonald. Paris, publ. by M . l'abb M i g n e , 1859B R I G H T F I E L D , M . F . T h e coming of the railroad to early Victorian England, as viewed by novels of the period 1840-70. Technology and culture, vol. 3, no. 1, 1962, P- 45-73B R U F O R D , W . H . Chekov and his Russia. A sociological study. L o n d o n , 1948. C H A S E , R . Radicalism in the American novel. Commentary, vol. 23, no. I, I957> p. 65-71. . Neo-conservatism and American literature. Commentary, vol. 23, no. 3, I957> p. 254-61. C O U S I N S , A . T h e sociology of the war novel. Indian journal of social research, vol. 2 , no. 2 , 1961, p . 83-90. D A I C H E S , D . Literature and society. L o n d o n , 1938. D A V I S , A . P . Integration and race literature. Phyton, vol. 17, no. 2 , 1956, p . 141-6. D E E G A N , D . Y . The stereotype of the single woman in American novels. N e w York, 1951. D U N C A N , H . D . Language and literature in society. A sociological essay on theory and method in the interpretation of linguistic symbols with a bibliographical guide to the sociology o literature. Chicago, 1953; N e w York, ig62. E L I Z A L D E , I. L a novela social contempornea en Espaa. Fomento social, vol. 16, no. 63, 1961, p . 255-71. . L a novela social en Italia. Fomento social, vol. 16, no. 6 4 , 1961, p . 365-77.

Select bibliography

685

E S C A R P I T , R . Das Buch und der Leser. Entwurf einer Literatursoziologie. Cologne and Opladen, 1961. (Fr: Sociologie de la littrature, Paris, 1958.) . The book revolution, Paris, 1965. F I S K E , M . Book selection and censorship: a study of school and public libraries in California. Berkeley, 1959. F G E N , H . N . Die Hauptrichtungen der Literatur-Soziologie und ihre Methoden. B o n n , 1964. (ed.). Wege der Literatursoziologie. Neuwied a m Rhein and Berlin, 1968. G H I S E L I N , B . Automatism, intention, and autonomy in the novelist's production. Daedalus, vol. 92, no. 2 , 1963, p . 297-311. G O L D M A N N , L . Le Dieu cach. tude sur la vision tragique dans les Penses de Pascal et dans le thtre de Racine. Paris, 1955. . Problmes d'une sociologie d u r o m a n . Cahiers internationaux de sociologie, vol. 9, no. 32, 1962, p . 61-72. . Pour une sociologie du roman. Paris, 1964. G O S S M A N , N . J. Political and social themes in the English popular novel (18151832). Public opinion quarterly, vol. 20, no. 3, 1956, p . 531-41. G R A N A , C . El anlisis social de la literatura: posibilidades y limitaciones. Revista de ciencias sociales, vol. 6, no. 2, 1962, p . 215-38. . Bohemian versus bourgeois. French society and the French man of letters in the nineteenth century. N e w York, 1964. G U R A R D , A . Literature and society. Boston, 1935. H O G G A R T , R . The uses of literacy. Changing patterns in English mass culture. Fair L a w n (N.J.), 1957K A Z I N , A . Writing for magazines. Commentary, vol. 30, no. 1, 1960, p . 57-9. K E S T E L O O T , L . Les crivains noirs de langue franaise. Brussels, 1963. K O F L E R , L . Zur Theorie der modernen Literatur. Der Avantgardismus in soziologischer Sicht. Neuwied a m Rhein, 1962. L A R S E N , C . E . T h e family in Norwegian fiction. Sociology and social research, vol. 36, '95'-52>P-97-101. T h e race problem in contemporary American Negro poetry. Sociology and social research, vol. 38, no. 3, 1954, p . 162-7. L E O N A R D , F . G . Cozzens without sex; Steinbeck without sin. Antioch review, vol. 18, no. 2 , 1958, p . 209-18. Littrature et socit. Problmes de mthodologie en sociologie de la littrature. Colloque organis conjointement par l'Institut de Sociologie de l'Universit Libre de Bruxelles et l'cole Pratique des Hautes tudes (6e section) de Paris. Bruxelles 1967. L O W E N T H A L , L . Literature and the image of man. Boston, 1957. . Literature, popular culture, and society. Englewood Cliffs (N.J.), 1961. . T h e reception of Dostoevski's work in G e r m a n y : 1880-1920. In: R . N . Wilson (ed.), The arts in society. Englewood Cliffs (N.J.), 1964, p . 124-47. L U K C S , G . Schriften zur Literalursoziologie. Neuwied a m Rhein, 1963. . L a forme intrieure du roman. Revue de l'Institut de sociologie (Bruxelles), vol. 36, no. 2 , 1963, p . 243-61. M A R X , K . ; E N G E L S , F . ber Kunst und Literatur. Eine Sammlung aus ihren Schriften. Berlin, Michail Lifschitz, 1950, 1953. M E M M I , A . Cinq propositions pour une sociologie de la littrature. Cahiers internationaux de sociologie, vol. 6, no. 26, 1959, p . 149-63. . Problmes de la sociologie de la littrature. In: G . Gurvitch (ed.), Trait de sociologie, tome II, p . 299-314, Paris, i960. M E R R I L L , F . E . Stendhal and the self; a study in the sociology of literature. American journal of sociology, vol. 66, no. 5, 1961, p . 446-53. M I L L E R , W . The book industry. N e w York, 1950. M o N G U i o , L . Nationalism and social discontent as reflected in Spanish-American literature. Annals of the Academy of Political and Social Science, 1961, no. 334, p . 63-73. N U T Z , W . Der Trivialromanseine Formen und seine Hersteller. Cologne and Opladen, 1962.

686

Select bibliography

P A R K E R , E . B . T h e effects of television on library circulation. Public opinion quarterly, vol. 27, no. 4, 1963, p. 578-89. PoRTERFiELD, A . L . S o m e uses of literature in teaching sociology. Sociology and social research, vol. 41, no. 6, 1957, p . 421-6. R O U C E K , J. S. T h e sociology of literature. Indian journal of social research, vol. 2, no. 2, 1961, p. 22-30. . L a sociologa de la literatura. Revista mexicana de sociologa, vol. 21, no. 2, 1959 P- 691-701. S C H C K I N G , L . L . Die Soziologie der literarischen Geschmacksbildung. Leipzig and Berlin 1931. (Bern and M u n i c h , 1961). . Die puritanische Familie in literatursoziologischer Sicht. Bern, 1964. S C O T T , N . A . Jr. Modem literature and the religious frontier. N e w York, 1958. S H E L T O N , A . J. African realistic commentary on culture hierarchy and racistic sentimentalism in the Yemassee. Phylon, vol. 25, no. 1, 1964, p. 72-8. S N E L L , B . Poetry and society. Bloomington (Ind.), 1961. S T A E L - H O L S T E I N , A . L . G . de. De la littrature considre dans ses rapports avec les institutions sociales. Paris, 1800. T A I N E , H . History of English literature. N e w York, 1886. T H O R N D I K E , A . H . Literature in a changing age. N e w York, 1921. W A R R E N , A . Literature and society. In: Twentieth century English, p. 304-14. N e w York, 1946. W A T T , I. Literature and society. In: R . N . Wilson (ed.), The arts in society, p. 299314. Englewood Cliffs (N.J.), 1964. W H I T E , D . M . ; A B E L , R . H . (eds.). The funnies: an American idiom. N e w York and L o n d o n , 1963. W I L L E N B O R G , G . Autoritre Persnlichkeitsstrukturen in Courths-Mahler-Romanen. Klner Zeitschrift fr Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, vol. 14, no. 4, 1963, p. 706-33. W I L S O N , R . N . Man made plain: the poet in contemporary society. Cleveland, 1958. . T h e poet in American society. In: R . N . Wilson (ed.), The arts in society, p. 1-34. Englewood Cliffs (N.J.), 1964. Z H D A N O V , A . A . , On literature, music, and philosophy. L o n d o n , 1950.

Theatre and films

A D L E R , K . P . Art films and eggheads. Studies in public communication, 1959, no. 2, p. 7-15B A B , J. Das Theater im Lichte der Soziologie. Leipzig, 1931. BEISS, A . Das Drama als soziologisches Phnomen. Ein Versuch. Braunschweig, 1954. B R U F O R D , W . H . Theatre, drama, and audience in Goethe's Germany. L o n d o n , 1950. D I E N S T F R E Y , H . T h e n e w American cinema. Commentary, vol. 33, n o . 6, 1962, p . 495-54D U M A Z E D I E R , J. Loisir cinmatographique et culture populaire. Diogne, vol. 31, i960, p. 112-22. D u v i G N A U D , J. Reflections sur l'volution thtrale a u X I X e sicle. Cahiers internationaux de sociologie, 1961, n o . 30, p . 75-82. . Sociologie du thtre. Essai sur les ombres collectives. Paris, 1965. . L'acteur. Esquisse d'une sociologie du comdien. Paris, 1965. F E A R I N G , F. Influence of the movies on attitudes and behavior. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, vol. 254, 1947, p. 70-9. G U I L L O T , A . Les aspects politiques du cinma amricain. Anne sociologique, i960, P- 109-57G U R V I T C H , G . Sociologie du thtre. Lettres nouvelles, vol. 4, no. 35, 1956, p. 196210.

Select bibliography

687

H O L L A N D , N . N . T h e puzzling movies: three analyses and a guess at their appeal, Journal of social issues, vol. 20, no. 1, 1964, p . 71-96. K R A C A U E R , S . From Caligari to Hitler: a psychological history of the German film. Princeton, 1947. M O W N , E . Le cinma ou l'homme imaginaire. Essai d'anthropologie sociologique. Paris, 1956M U L L I G A N , R . A . ; D I N K I N S , J. C . Socioeconomic background and theatrical preference. Sociology and social research, vol. 40, no. 5 , 1956, p . 325-8. R A V A R , R . ; A N R I E U , P . Le spectateur au theatre. Brussels, 1964. S H O B E N , E . J. A clinical view of the tragic. Journal of social issues, vol. 20, 1964, p. 26-36. S I L B E R M A N N , A . Theater u n d Gesellschaft. Atlantisbuch des Theaters, p . 387-406. Zrich, 1966. U N E S C O (ed.). The influence of the cinema on children and adolescents. A selective annotated bibliography. 1958. W E I D E N F E L D , D . Der Schauspieler in der Gesellschaft. Beitrag zur Soziologie des Schauspielers. Cologne and Berlin, 1959. W O L F E N S T E I N , M . ; L E I T E S , N . A n analysis of themes and plots in motion pictures. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, vol. 254, 1947. ; . Movies: a psychological study. Glencoe (111.), 1950.

The world of the social sciences

Research and training centres and professional bodiesI

Contributions to this section are invited. Statements not exceeding 1,500 words should be submitted in two double-spaced typewritten copies, in English, French, Spanish, Russian, German or Italian. Particular emphasis on current or planned research activities is desirable.

N e w institutions and changes of name and address

N e w institutions
International Consejo Latinoamericano d e Ciencias Sociales, Florida 142, B u e n o s Aires. United Nations Social Defence Research Institute, V i a Giulia, 5 2 , 0 0 1 8 6 R o m e . Italy Associazione degli Africanisti Italiani, Istituto di Storia ed Istituzioni dei Paesi Afroasiatici, Universit di Pavia, Palazzo Centrale dell'Universit, Via Strada N u o v a , 65, 27100 Pavia. Centro di Studio e di Documentazione Sul Vietnam ed il Terzo M o n d o , Via B . Barbiellini Amidei, 00168 R o m e . Comitato per le Scienze Politiche e Sociali (Co.S.Po.S.), Via Mazzini, 88, 00195 R o m e . Movimento Sviluppo e Pace, Via Magenta, 12 bis, 10123 Turin. Istituto di Scienza Politica, Facolt di Scienze Politiche 'Cesare Alfieri', Universit degli Studi, Piazza San M a r c o 4 , Florence. Istituto Superiore di Sociologia, Societ Umanitaria, Via Daverio, 1, 20122 Milan. Istituto Superiore di Studi Economici 'Adriano Olivetti', Facolt di Economa e Commercio, Universit di Urbano, Palazzo degli Anziani, 60100 Ancona. Jamaica African Studies Association, University of the West Indies, M o n a , Kingston 7. 1. For cumulative index to this section, see Vol. X V I (1964), N o . 1, p . 117.

Int. Soc. Sei. J., Vol. X X , N o . 4, IQ6S

692

The world of the social sciences

Togo Centre d'tudes et de Recherches de Kara ( C E R K ) , Piya, par Lama-Kara, or: Assih N'Djame, 12, rue R . Verlomme, 75 Paris-3e, France. United States of America Center f o r Comparative Studies in Technological Development and Social Change, International Programs, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455Center f o r Haitian Studies, Research Institute f o r the Study of M a n , 162 East 78th Street, N e w York, N . Y . 10021. Center f o r Science and the Future of H u m a n Affairs, State University of N e w York, 8 Thurlow Terrace, Albany, N e w York 122201. Research Center for the Language Sciences, Indiana University, Patton House, 516 East Sixth Street, Bloomington, Indiana 47401.

Changes of name and address

International Institut International de Droit d'Expression Franaise (IDEF), 28, rue SaintGuillaume, B . P . 26/07, 75 Paris-7e (France). [Formerly: Institut International de Droit des Pays d'Expression Franaise.] Sociedad Interamericana de Psicologa (SIP)/The Interamerican Society of Psychology, 1801 Lavaca, Suite 11 E , Austin, Texas 78701 (U.S.A.). [Formerly: 2104 Meadowbrook Drive, Austin, Texas 78703 (U.S.A.).] W a r Resisters' International/Internationale de Rsistants la Guerre, 3 Caledonian Road, London N.i (United Kingdom). [Formerly: Lansbury House, 88 Park Avenue, Anfield, Middlesex (United Kingdom).] India Indian School of International Studies, 35 Ferozeshah Road, N e w Delhi 1. [Formerly: Sapru House, Barakhamba Road, N e w Delhi 2.] Italy Istituto Servizio Sociale Case per Lavoratori (ISSCAL), Via C . Celso N . 6, 00161 R o m e . Netherlands Vereniging voor Staathuishoudkunde, p/a De Nederlandsche Bank N . V . , Westeinde 1, Amsterdam. [Formerly: p/a Oude Turf markt 127-129, Amsterdam.] Uganda Makerere Institute of Social Research, Makerere University College, University of East Africa, P . O . Box 16032, Kampala. [Formerly: East African Institute of Social Research.]

Research and training centres and professional bodies

693

Hungary
Centre for Afro-Asian Research Hungarian Academy of Sciences
I X . Dimitrov tr 8 , B u d a p e s t

T h e Centre for Afro-Asian Research of the Hungarian A c a d e m y of Sciences was established in mid-1963, under the direction of Professor Jzsef Bognr, as an autonomous organization in order to bring together Hungarian researchersin the first instance, economists interested in the analysis of the problems of the third world, particularly those of Asia and Africa. Professor Bognr is supported by the following: M r s . Elizabeth Hosszu, as deputy director, and Messrs. Peter M a n d i and Egn K e m e n e s as directors of research. T h e total staff numbers five administrative, seven scientific and aroundfiftyexternal research workers. T h e centre is concerned with the growth problems of the economy of the developing countries, m o r e particularly of the African and Asian countries. Its work embraces questions connected with the conditions of economic growth, the subject and methods of planning, economic policy, international trade a n d generally the current economic problems of the developing countries as well as their relations with the socialist countries, a n d more specifically with Hungary. In pursuing its objectives the centre distinguishes two types of activities and is organized on that basis. O n the one hand, its scientific staff carries out independent research work which centres o n problems connected with economic growth. O n the other, with the participation of outside workers (partly the m e m b e r s of the Working G r o u p of African Studies of the Hungarian A c a d e m y of Sciences), it performs the role of initiator, organizer, co-ordinator and publisher where non-economic researches on the developing countries are concerned. T h e Hungarian Centre for Afro-Asian Research maintains working contacts with similar institutions in all socialist countries a n d has worked out a suitable division of research work with the latter. It also has contacts with the institutions dealing with such problems in several advanced countries. These contacts are maintained through conferences, personal visits and study tours, all of which provide opportunities to exchange experiences. T h e director of the centre regularly participates in the most important conferences on subjects pertaining to developing countries and has lectured o n the related problems not only in the countries concerned but also in several European capitals. T h e research workers of the centre have given lectures and outlined the results of the centre's research activitiespartly at scientific conferences and partly on the occasion of personal visitsin M o s c o w , Prague, Berlin, Leipzig and Paris. T h e research work carried out by die centre is backed by extensive information and documentation contained in the library and archives of the institution. T h e centre has established direct contacts with the statistical and economic institutions of most developing countries a n d regularly receives their publications. T h e rich documentation enables the centre to ofTer advisory a n d information services to the great variety of institutions which contact it. T h e centre takes part in preparing a n d instructing the specialists to be sent to the developing countries on the basis of bilateral and multilateral agreements as well as in giving scientific support to the relations formed between H u n g a r y and the developing countries. It produces a series of publications containing the main results of its research work.

694

T h e world of the social sciences

Italy
Istituto di Studi e Ricerche Carlo Gattaneo
Via Santo Stefano, 6, Bologna

ORIGIN

A N D PURPOSE

T h e Carlo Cattaneo Institute is a non-profit organization created for the purpose of conducting research in the political and social sciences, with particular regard to problems that significantly affect the development of democracy and civil society in Italy. T h e institute had its origin in a political and cultural association n a m e d after Carlo Cattaneo, and w a s established by law in Bologna in September 1956 by the editors of the magazine / / Mulino. Its objective was to assemble the groups and study committees which h a d c o m e to constitute an auxiliary staff of / / Mulind's editorial office for conducting research into problems singled out as crucial for the development of the social life of the country, or problems which II Mulino's editors considered as having particular importance in the cultural and political spheres. Between 1956 and 1964 the association either directly or through its committees promoted studies and research on the prospects for full employment in several small communities, on electoral behaviour, on political propaganda a n d political participation in general in Italy, on the problems of Italian schools a n d universities, on the prospect of realizing a system of social security in Italy, on ethnic prejudice in the country and on the attitude of the lay press in comparison with that of the Church in the post-war period. In January 1965, the association was reorganized in order to realize m o r e fully the purposes for which it had been created. It was transformed into a full-fledged institute for study and research, and with its n e w organizational structure it continues to carry on the type of work undertaken during the previous eight years of its existence. O n the basis of this reorganization, the institute at present: 1. Conducts research in areas which its sponsors consider particularly important for contemporary Italian social, political, and cultural conditions. Within these areas it also carries out research commissioned by other organizations and institutions. 2. Assists researchers a n d scholars in the research activities of the institute by arranging discussions, seminars, and courses of lectures. 3. Promotes meetings, debates, and conferences designed to interest a wide public in the activities of the institute and thus to exercise a m o r e enlightened influence on the formation of public opinion. Financial support for these activities c o m e from public or private organizations, both Italian and foreign. T h e institute itself has a small nucleus of permanent researchers, to which is added a large n u m b e r of grant-supported scholars and foreign collaborators w h o are engaged in individual research. Moreover, the institute aids Italian and foreign scholars w h o are engaged in their o w n personal research projects. ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE

T h e institute is administered by a Board of Directors, appointed annually by the political and cultural association of 'II Mulino' (in which the II Mulino group is

Research a n d training centres and professional bodies

695

institutionally organized). T h e Board of Directors has an Executive Committee which consists of a president, secretary-general, treasurer, and auditor. T h e president represents the institute legally and is responsible for the implementation of its programmes. T h e secretary-general directly supervises the execution of the prog r a m m e s as well as the general administration of the institute. In carrying out his duties, the secretary-general m a y call u p o n other technically qualified persons, and together these officials constitute the secretariat of the institute. T h e auditor has charge of the bookkeeping, and reports on finances to the Board of Directors. T h e Board of Directors is presently composed of Giovanni Evangelisti, Giorgio Galli, Giuseppe Federico Mancini, Nicola Matteucci, Luigi Pedrazzi, Alfonso Prandi, a n d Gerardo Santini. T h e president of the institute is Nicola Matteucci. T h e secretary is Giovanni Evangelisti, a n d the treasurer, Luigi Pedrazzi. T h e secretariat of the institute is composed of Giovanni Evangelisti, Marzio Barbagli, and Paola de Vito Piscicelli. RESEARCH FACILITIES

T h e institute has its o w n offices, a periodicals library (which receives m o r e than 800 Italian a n d foreign periodicals), a n d a specialized library in the field of the social and political sciences. In addition, it has archives containing all the documentation collected in the course of its earlier research projects, and extensive documentation on the development of the social sciences in Italy. PUBLICATIONS T h e results of the research projects conducted by the institute are published in book form by the II Mulino Publishing H o u s e . Periodically, the institute publishes its Quaderni, which include contributions from scholars working both in a n d out of the institute on themes emphasized b y the p r o g r a m m e of the institute. Its researchers collaborate in the editorial w o r k of the Rassegna Italiana di Sociologa (Italian sociological review).

Spain
Instituto de Estudios Laborales
A v d a . d e la Victoria, 6 0 - 6 2 , Barcelona-17

T h e establishment of the Instituto de Estudios Laborales c a m e as a result of a realization of the position that the study of social problems, more particularly labour problems, occupies in the amelioration of Spanish society. Through it, it is hoped in a measure to solve the problem of scientific research in Spain, which is virtually non-existent. Additionally, if there were isolated studies, it would try to bring them together into a clear, integrated p r o g r a m m e a n d put their results into focus for effective utilization. T h e institute w a s constituted on 1 M a y 1967 with a well-defined objective: to study socio-labour problems scientifically, applying social science, judicial and historical methods to the problems of labour and of industrial society. Within its fields of interest the institute proposes specially: (a) to study labour relations on the level

696

T h e world of the social sciences

of both public a n d private enterprises; (b) to analyse scientifically tendencies manifested in the world of labour, in whatever socio-economic or ideological contexts; (c) to study and examine labour legislations, both national and foreign, in the light of agreements and recommendations of the International Labour Organisation (Geneva); (d) to promote the study of labour relations in Spain and Latin America, through courses, seminars, conferences, round tables and publications. In developing its activities the institute directs itself to three principal groups of people or institutions in accordance with the criterion followed by the International Institute for Labour Studies (Geneva) with which it collaborates in tasks of research and teaching: (a) to n e w potential leaders of distinct social groups as well as to employers and workers; (b) to university professors and research workers desirous of acquiring deeper insights into labour questions and labour-management relationships; and (c) to people responsible for making decisions on labour matters w h o are anxious to have information o n ideas relative to the formulation and application of policies in an atmosphere of objective study, free from pressures which characterize executive functioning. O n 5 August 1967, the institute became a m e m b e r of the International Industrial Relations Association (Geneva). T h e said association held itsfirstWorld Congress in Geneva in September 1967 a n d the institute, through its director, chaired the section on 'Critical analysis of the right to strike'. T h e following studies are currently being undertaken in the institute: 1. T h e participation of labour in the m a n a g e m e n t of enterprises. This study w a s entrusted to it by the International Institute for Labour Studies (Geneva). Sixteen countries are participating in this project, including India, Poland, United Arab Republic, Japan, United States of America, and Yugoslavia. In executing this project, inquiries have been directed to 100 enterprises throughout Spain. T h e questionnaire was d r a w n u p in accordance with criteria specified by the International Institute of Geneva. T h e study will be completed by the end of 1968. 2. T h e accomplishment of self-management in a co-operative enterprise: Construcciones Industriales y Agropecuarias, S.C.I. ( C I A P ) . This study analyses historically the development of the said co-operative and, above all, intends to show to what point the economic, labour and social objectives proposed within the context of self-management have been achieved. 3. Industrial conflicts in Spain: study-seminar on the principal collective conflicts which have taken place in the last two years. 4. Dynamics of labour relations in Spain since 1939: a study-seminar dealing with historical and documentary sources which m a y m a k e possible a subsequent detailed study of the period. 5. Integration of rural labour into industrial society: a study of socio-cultural actuations of emigrants resident in the satellite city of San Ildefonso (Cornelia). Collaborating in the above-mentioned studies are thirty members of the institute. T h e director of the institute is M r . Juan N . Garca-Nieto.

Research and training centres and professional bodies

697

Venezuela
Instituto de Investigaciones Econmicas y Sociales
Facultad d e E c o n o m a d e la Universidad Central d e V e n e z u e l a , C i u d a d Universitaria, Edificio d e la Biblioteca, Piso 11, Caracas

OBJECTIVES T h e Institute of Economic and Social Research of the Faculty of Economics of the Central University of Venezuela was established in 1947 under the aegis of the University Council with the following as part of its aims: T o undertake special research and studies on problems relevant to the scientific disciplines which are of interest to the faculty. T o establish solid bases for the effective participation of graduates of the universal task of advanced research, thus contributing to the achievement of the primordial function of the university. T o study the country's past and present ideas and problems in the fields of the faculty's competence, analysing diverse trajectories and potentialities for future development. T o train collaborators for research purposes and co-operation in the preparation of future professors for the faculty. T o co-operate in the preparation of doctoral or professorial theses. Towards that end, the institute will guide aspirants and organize research seminars in order to develop their critical judgement. T o obtain sources of information and tools of investigation from interested persons and organizations. T o exchange documentation and information with other related centres. T o direct and develop the library of the faculty. T o create, through courses, conferences, round-table sessions, conventions and publications, an atmosphere conducive to the development of scientific disciplines within the competence of the faculty. T o be familiar with the research projects submitted for consultation with the Faculty Council and to collaborate towards their completion. T o draw u p , jointly with the schools, a p r o g r a m m e of seminars which will be conducted each academic term and to place them before the Faculty Council for consideration. T o be familiar with the revision of the programmes of study submitted for consultation with the Faculty Council. T o co-operate with the schools, at their request, regarding the scientific orientation of teaching with a view to a better professional training. T o conduct research proposed by third parties with the authorization of competent university bodies. T o edit the Review, bulletins and other periodical publications of the institute and such works as m a y be useful to the scientific development of the faculty. T o carry out such other tasks as m a y be in line with its character as a n institute for research.

698

T h e world of the social sciences

PRINCIPAL ACTIVITIES Research. In thefieldof research, the institute covers, in principle, the scientific and humanistic disciplines which are the subjects of systematic study of the faculty of Economics of the Central University of Venezuela. T h e projects under study a n d those planned for the future are oriented towards the scientific knowledge of the economic and social problems of Venezuela as well as towards the creation of theoretical bases and instruments of analysis for the study of underdevelopment. Extension. T h e Institute's responsibilities include activities of the Faculty of Economics related to forums, conferences, round tables, special seminars, publications and small courses of professors and alumni. RESEARCH PROGRAMME

Research completed between ig6o and ig6$. 'Presupuestos familiares en el area metropolitana de Caracas' (Family budget in the metropolitan area of Caracas), started in 1959. Stage completed: incidence of house rentals in family earnings. Results: a three-volume mimeograph publication entitled Incidencia del alquiler en el ingreso. Researches in progress. 'Bases de una teora econmica del sub-desarrollo' (Bases of an economic theory of underdevelopment). 'Relaciones econmicas exteriores c o m o determinantes del uso y la formacin de recursos y factores de la produccin en Venezuela' (External economic relations as determinants of use and formation of resources and factors of production in Venezuela). ' L a estructura agraria de Venezuela' (The agrarian structure of Venezuela). 'Costo de alimentacin en el area metropolitana de Caracas' (Cost of food in the metropolitan area of Caracas). 'Proceso de formacin de la propiedad territorial agraria en Venezuela' (The formation process of territorial agrarian property in Venezuela). 'Estudio de Caracas (Study on Caracas). 'Diagnstico socioeconmico de Venezuela, con vistas al planeamiento del desarrollo de la Universidad Central' (Socio-economic diagnosis of Venezuela with a view to to the planning of development of the Central University). Planned projects ( IQ6J-68) . 'Desarrollo econmico de Venezuela durante el periodo 1917-1948' (Economic development of Venezuela during the period 1917-1948). Projects of the Departamento de Investigaciones Administrativas y Contables. 'Instrumentos contractuales de la integracin econmica latinoamericana' (Contractual instruments of Latin American economic integration). 'Estudio y evaluacin de la enseanza del servicio social en el pais' (Study and evaluation of the teaching of social services in the country). T h e institute has a n u m b e r of projects which are being planned for execution in coming years. PUBLICATIONS T h e institute produces the quarterly Economa y Ciencias Sociales and the bimonthly Boletn bibliogrfico. It also produces works of interest to students and scholars of the social sciences.

Research and training centres and professional bodies

699

ORGANIZATIONAL

STRUCTURE

T h e institute is divided into six research departments: Economics; Commercial Administration and Accounting; Sociology and Anthropology; International Studies; Statistics and Actuarial Sciences; a n d Social W o r k . Each department is further subdivided into specialized sections besides the sections on General Services (Administrative), Bibliography and Documentation, Computation and Statistics, Publications and Library. T h e Council of the Faculty of Economics, after prior consultations with the C o u n cil for the Scientific and Humanistic Development of the University, passes the prog r a m m e of study submitted to it by the institute to the Technical Council (Consejo Tcnico) which elaborates the p r o g r a m m e of the institute a n d its budget, co-ordinates and evaluates its research activities and decides on publications. T h e present director of the institute is D r . D o m i n g o Felipe M a z a Zavala (economist).

Meetings

Approaching international conferences1

1969

Netherlands

European Committee for Rural L a w : Fifth European Symposium g, rue de VArbalte, 75 Paris-5e (France) Institute of International L a w : session (theme: international law, public and private) 88, rue de Grenelle, 75 Paris-?* (France) Inter-Parliamentary Union: Conference Place du Petit-Saconnex, 1211 Geneva ig (Switzerland) International Association for Research in Income and Wealth: Eleventh General Conference Box 2020, Tale Station, New Haven, Conn. 06520 (U.S.A.)

United Kingdom India

Athens

International Association of Southeast European Studies: Second International Congress of Balkan and Southeast European Studies Mr. N. Tondorov, 32, Dondukov, Sofia (Bulgaria) International Association of Penal L a w : Tenth International Congress of Criminal L a w Mr. Pierre Bouzat, Secretary-General, 43, avenue Aristide-Briand, 35 Rennes (France) International Association of Students in Economics and Commercial Sciences: International Conference on the International Transfer of M a n a g e m e n t Skills 28, avenue Pictet-de-Rochemont, 1207 Geneva (Switzerland)

Europe

France ( ?)

International Conference of Sociology: Tenth International Conference for Religious Sociology Professor Emile Pin, General Secretary, Piazza della Pilotta 3, Rome (Italy)

1. N o further details concerning these meetings can be obtained through this Journal.

Int. Soc. Set. J., Vol. X X , N u . t , loOS

Meetings

701

Unesco: Conference o n Models of Nation-building Unesco, SHG'jSS, Place de Fontenoy, 75 Paris-?1* (France) East Germany United T o w n s Organization: Sixth World Conference o n Intercommunal Co-operation (theme: popular education in the era of the scientific and technical revolution) 13, rue Racine, 75 Paris-6e (France) W a r Resisters' International: Thirteenth Triennial Conference (in conjunction with Gandhi Centenary Year) 3, Caledonian Road, London N.i (United Kingdom) Third World Religionists' Conference for Peace Japanese Religionists' Council/or Peace, Shickiken-cho, Ueno-Ikenohata, Taito-ku, Tokyo (Japan) International Union of Local Authorities: Nineteenth Congress Paleistraat 5 , The Hague (Metherlands) Universities and the Quest for Peace: World Conference Dr. Raga S. Elim, Director and Secretary-General, c/o University of Rome, 00100 Rome (Italy) Third P a n American Congress for Psychoanalysis Dr. Marcel Heiman, Committee on Liaison with Latin American Colleagues, 1 East 57th Street, Mew York, M.r. 10022 (U.S.A.) Institute of M a n a g e m e n t Sciences: American Meeting Harold H. Cauvet, P.O. Box 273, Pleasantville, N.Y. 10570 (U.S.A.) Inter-University Consortium for Political Research: International Data Confrontation Seminar Professor Warren Miller, Executive Director, P.O. Box 1248, Ann Arbor, Mich. 48106 (U.S.A.) Inter-American Society of Psychology (Sociedad Interamericana de Psicologa, SIP) : Twelfth InterAmerican Congress of Psychology (theme: education, training and research in psychology) Dr. Sherman Ross, American Psychological Association, 1200 17th Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036 (U.S.A.) World Union of Organizations for the Safeguard of Youth: Fourth Conference (theme: psycho-social family aid with a view to preventing juvenile maladjustment in a rapidly developing world) 28. blace Saint-Georges, 75 Paris-ge (France)

U.S.A.

India

Athens

13-17 Jan.

Rome

23-27

N e w York

Feb.

Spring

Atlanta Georgia

March

A n n Arbor Mich.

30 M a r c h - Montevideo

6 April

31 M a r c h - Tunis 4 April

702

The world of the social sciences

April

Paris

International Social Science Council: General Assembly and R o u n d Table on the Policy of Social Science Research 6, rue Franklin, 75 Paris-16e (France) Inter-Parliamentary Union: meeting Parlamentsdirektion, Dr. Karl Renner-Ring 3, Vienna (Austria) United Nations, E C L A : thirteenth session Mr. Jos A. Mayobre, avenida Providencia 871, Santiago de Chile European Cultural Foundation: Congress (theme: urbanization, 'City and citizen in the year 2000') Emmastraat 30, Amsterdam (Metherlands) European Association for Personnel Management: Quatrime Journes Internationales d'tude Mr. D. Perret, Honorary Secretary, 20, rue des FosssSaint-Jacques, 75 Paris-5e (France) Asociacin Latinoamericana de Sociologa: Ninth Congress Professor P. Gonzalez Casanova, Director del Instituto de Investigaciones Sociales, Torre de Humanidades50 piso, Villa Obregn, Mexico 20, D.F. Institute of Management Sciences: European Meeting Mr. Harold H. Cauvet, P.O. Box 273, Pleasantville, N.r. 10570 (U.S.A.) Inter-American Bar Association: Sixteenth Conference Mr. W. R. Vallante, Secretary-General, 704 Federal Bar Building, 1815 H Street, M W , Washington, D.C. 20006 (U.S.A.) Netherlands Universities Foundation for International Co-operation: Seventh International S u m m e r Course on Industrialization NUFFIC, 27, Molenstraat, The Hague (Netherlands) International Union of Psychological Science: Seventh International Congress on Scientific Psychology British Psychological Society, Tavistock House South, Tavistock Square, London, W.C.i (United Kingdom) International Psycho-Analytical Association: Twenty-sixth Congress Dr. L. Z- Gairinger, via Salaria 237, ooigg Rome (Italy) International Association of Gerontology: Eighth Triennial International Congress Professor N. W. Shock, 5650 Rockville Pike, Bethesda, Md. 20014 (U.S.A.)

7-13

Vienna

April
15-26 April Lima

A-IOIO,

May or June

Rotterdam

22-26 June

Munich

Summer

Mexico

Summer

Europe

7-12 July

Rio de Janeiro

14 July22 A u g .

The Hague

27 July2 Aug.

London

30 July-

Rome

3 Aug-

24-29 Aug.

Washington

Meetings

703

Sept.

Paris

International Social Science Council: Symposium on the Ethnology of Industrialized Complex Societies Professor Jean Cuisenier, Matre de recherches CNRS, 15, quai Anatole-France, 75 Paris-J* (France) European Society for Opinion Surveys and Market Research: Twenty-second Congress 17, rue Berckmans, Brussels 6 (Belgium) International Multi-disciplinary Federation of Social Psychiatry: Conference on the Healthy Community Dr. H. B. Wright, 10 Belgrave Square, London S.W.i (United Kingdom) International Union for the Scientific Study of Population: Sixteenth Congress and General Assembly Mr. E. Grebenik, Department of Social Sciences, The University, Leeds 2 (United Kingdom) World Peace through L a w Center: Fourth World Conference 75, rue de Lyon, 1S03 Geneva (Switzerland) Institute of M a n a g e m e n t Sciences: Sixteenth International Meeting Mr. Harold H. Cauvet, P.O. Box 373, Pleasantville, N.T. 10570 (U.S.A.) Society for International Development: Eleventh Conference Secretariat, 1346 Connecticut Avenue, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036 (U.S.A.) World Conference on religion and Peace Mr. R. R. Diwakar, Gandhi Peace Foundation, ssi Rouse Avenue, New Delhi-i (India) East-West Center: Gandhi Centennial Symposium East-West Center, University of Hawaii, Honolulu, Hawaii g68ss (U.S.A.) International Council for Scientific Management: Fifteenth triennal International M a n a g e m e n t Congress c/o International Management Association of Japan, Nihon Seisanei Building, 3-1-1 Shibuya, Shibuya-ku, Tokyo (Japan) Econometric Society: North American Winter Meeting P.O. Box 1264, Tale Station, New Haven, Conn. 06520

i Sept.

Amsterdam

2-5 Sept.

Edinburgh

4-11 Sept. London

7-12 Sept. Bangkok

Autumn

Europe

October

N e w Delhi

2 Oct. approx.

N e w Delhi (?)

October

Honolulu

Late Oct.- Tokyo late N o v .

December N e w York

'970 Asia United Nations Economic Commission for Asia and the Far East: Asian Population Conference Sala Santitham, Rajadamnem, Bangkok (Thailand)

74

The world of the social sciences

Spain

European Society for Opinion Surveys and Market Research: Twenty-third Congress 17, rue Berckmans, Brussels 6 (Belgium) International A c a d e m y of Comparative L a w : Congress Professor Wagner, University of Indiana, School of Law, Bloomington, Ind. 47401 (U.S.A.) International Association for Social Progress: Congress Rue Louvrex 47, Lige (Belgium) International Committee for Historical Sciences: Thirteenth International Congress 270, boulevard Raspail, 75 Paris-14^ (France), or: Comit National des Historiens Sovitiques, ig U. Dimitri Ulianova, Moscow B-36 (U.S.S.R.) International Humanist a n d Ethical U n i o n : Fifth Congress Oudegracht 152, P.O.B. 114, Utrecht (Netherlands) International Industrial Relations Association: Second W o r l d Congress 154, rue de Lausanne, CH-isu, Geneva 22 (Switzerland)

Athens

Switzerland Moscow

New

York

Spring

Hawaii

Institute of M a n a g e m e n t Sciences: Seventeenth International Meeting Mr. Harold H. Cauvet, P.O.B. 273, Pleasantville, N.T. 10570 (U.S.A.) International Society of Criminology: Sixth International Congress o n Criminology (theme: 'Scientific research in criminology', the link between theory and practice) Dr. Georges Fully, Secrtaire-gnral, 2, place Mazas, 75 Paris-12e (France) International Council o n Social Welfare: International Conference of Social W o r k Mr. J. R. Hoffner, 22 West Gay Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215 (U.S.A.) International Economic History Association: Fifth Congress Professor J. F. Bergier, Facult des Sciences Economiques et Sociales, Universit de Genve, Geneva (Switzerland), or: Professor Frederic C. Lane, c/o Department of History, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Md. 21218 (U.S.A.) International Bar Association: Thirteenth Congress Japan Federation of Bar Associations, Hoso Kaidan Building, 1-1 Kasumigaseki, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo (Japan)

2nd semester

Madrid

Aug. or Sept.

Manila

Aug.Sept.

Leningrad

24-28

Tokyo

Aug.

Meetings

705

Autumn

Washington

Institute of Management Sciences: American Meeting Mr. Harold H . Cauvet, P . O . B . 273, Pleasantville, N.T. 10570 (U.S.A.) United Nations: Fourth Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders New Ohtemachi Building, Room 411/412, 4 2-chome, Ohtemachi, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo (Japan) International Sociological Association: Seventh World Congress Professor Angelo Pagani, Secretary-General, Via Daverio 7, 20122 Milan (Italy) International Political Science Association: Eighth World Congress 43, rue des Champs-Elyses, Brussels 5 (Belgium) Public Personnel Association: International Conference Mr. Kenneth O. Warner, 1313 East 60th Street, Chicago, III. 60637 (U.S.A.) Econometric Society: Annual Regional Meeting Box 1264, Tale Station, Mew Haven, Conn. 06520 (U.S.A.)

Autumn

Tokyo

14-19

Sept.

Varna (Bulgaria)

Sept. (3rd week)

18-22

London

Boston

Oct. Detroit

27-30

Dec.

1971 8-13 M a y Vienna

International Social Security Association: World Congress on Prevention of Occupational Accidents and Diseases 154, rue de Lausanne, CH-1211, Geneva-22 (Switzerland) Public Personnel Association: International Conference Mr. Kenneth 0. Warner, 1313 East 60th Street, Chicaho, III. 60637 (U.S.A.)

17-21

Oct.

San Francisco

197^ Oct.?

St. Louis, Mo.

Public Personnel Association: International Conference Mr. Kenneth 0. Warner, 1313 East 60th Street, Chicago, III. 60637 (U.S.A.)

7o6

T h e world of the social sciences

Social science and urban development in Latin America 1

Jahuel (Aconcagua), Chile 22-25 April 1968 R a l p h G a k e n h e i m e r a n d J o h n Miller

Social scientists, whether concerned with the academicfieldof teaching and research or engaged directly in the application of theory and practical knowledge, have become increasingly preoccupied with the use of the social sciences, not only for understanding but also for guiding the processes of urbanization and national modernization which parallel urban growth. T h e dual phenomena of a tendency towards accelerated urbanization, and a rapid population growth rate in Latin America have drawn particular attention to this geographic area. Current statistics, e.g., on the rate of growth among Latin American nations indicate the highest continental growth rate (2.9 per cent) encountered anywhere, and there is no evidence that this rate m a y be decelerating to any significant degree.2 T o this fact of population growth must be added another: growth has been increasingly and almost exlusively concentrated in the urban sectors of each country. Although the total increase was 32.a per cent between 1950 and i960, the urban zones increased by 56.0 per cent while only 16.8 per cent was added in the rural areas. S o m e 14 million persons migrated to urban areas during the decade and there is evidence of a continuing high urban birth ratecontrary to the experience in most other parts of the urbanizing world. These two facts have been instrumental in pushing the urban population in Latin America from 39 per cent of the total population in 1950 to 46 per cent in i960.3 T h e problems and potentials generated by this rapid urbanization have given rise to a number of international conferences, all of which have treated this process as an important theme of theoretical and pragmatic interest. O n e recent conference, on 'The Role of the City in the Modernization of Latin America', sponsored by Cornell University in 1965, focused on the positive functions performed by the city in the modernization process; and three international conferences on urbanization in Latin America have been held in Chile in the past decade aloneat Santiago ('957)> a t the Catholic University of Chile (1967), a n d at Jahuel, Aconcagua Province (April 1968). 4 T h e Jahuel Seminar o n Social Science and U r b a n Development in Latin America was co-sponsored b y the Interdisciplinary Center of U r b a n Development ( C I D U ) of the Catholic University of Chile a n d b y the Ford Foundation. Unlike prior 1. Seminar co-sponsored by the Centro Interdisciplinary de Desarrollo Urbano y Regional of the Catholic University of Chile and the Ford Foundation. 2. Hernn Mendoza Hoyos, 'Poblacin vs. Desarrollo: La Sobrepoblacin Impide el Progreso en los Pases en Desarrollo', Programas Internacionales de Poblacin, 1967. 3. Robert O . Carleton, Crecimiento de la Poblacin y Fecundidad Diferencial en Amrica Latina, Santiago, C E L A D E , 1967. 4. Results of the Cornell conference were published as The Urban Explosion in Latin America, Glenn H . Beyer (ed.), Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 1967. Papers presented at the 1957 Santiago conference were published as Philip M . Hauser (ed.), Urbanization in Latin America, Paris, Unesco, 1961. Proceedings of the 1967 conference are in press. Results of the Jahuel Seminar are proposed for publication during 1969.

Meetings

707

conferences which were more exclusively concerned with the Latin American city and with its problems and internal functions perse, the Jahuel Seminar was planned to place emphasis upon the national significance of urban growth, upon nationwide urban systems, the socio-economic and political integration of the urban and surrounding national and international areas, and the role of the social sciences in suggesting (a) national policies, and (b) areas of research which would assist the complementary processes of urbanization and modernization to advance national development. D r . John Friedmann was chairman of the p r o g r a m m e committee; Messrs. Ernest Weissman, Gino Germani and Fernando Aguirre Tupper served as session chairmen. Rapporteurs for work groups were Messrs. Gino Germani, Ricardo Jordn, Eduardo Neira Alva, and Jos A . Silva Michelena. Synthesizer for the Seminar at the final session was Professor K a i m a n H . Silvert. Commentaries on the papers presented were m a d e by Messrs. Richard Morse, Jorge Hardoy, Antoni Kuklinski, William M a n g i n , Gideon Sjoberg, Glaucio Soares, Anbal Quijano, Carlos Fortn, Julio Cotler, A r m a n d o M e n d e s , Albert Hirschman, Brian Berry, Leo Klaassen, Guillermo Geisse, and Lloyd R o d w i n . T h e five papers presented were devoted to various policy issues related to urban development at international, national and local levels and reflected different social science discipline positions. At the international level, a research paper written by Walter Sthr and Poul Pedersen tackled the economic and transportationcommunication links between urbanization and regional development within the context of South American integration. Basic policies for growth poles, and transportation-communication were suggested for a 'staged area consolidation' strategy. Auxiliary policies for inter-metropolitan and corridor development, resource complexes, depressed and border areas, river development and preventive integration were also advanced. T h efieldof national policy was covered by three papers. J o h n Friedmann, in a paper on ' T h e Role of Cities in National Development', set forth a preliminary contribution to urban policy for underdeveloped countries and proposed a set of six leading issues which he considered necessary for serious reflection on this topic: (a) the optimum rural-urban balance for successive phases in a process of national development; (b) the optimal rate of urbanization at successive phases of the development process; (c) the optimal patterns of spatial organization at successive phases in the development process; (d) the optimal transformation paths in shifting from one type of spatial organization to another; (e) the criteria for determining the proper timing in shifts from one kind of urban development strategy to another; and (f) the criteria to be applied in determining the optimal balance between centralization and decentralization in administrative and political decisions for urban development. In a paper on 'Urbanization Policy and Political Development in Latin America', Robert T . Daland argued that policy planners should consider the political development implications of urban growth policies. H e based his argument upon the belief that 'the failure to do so m a y prejudice the achievement of plan goals' and that 'it is desirable to prevent negative effects on political development insofar as the latter is as legitimate a goal as economic, social, or urban development'. Certain issues of political development which are raised by urbanization were identified and an attempt was m a d e to link the 'evidence' in social science as regards these issues to a model of the relationship between urbanization and political development, primarily as a means of suggesting urban policies consistent with political development goals. A lively discussion ensued a m o n g the participants with respect to the premises of Daland's paper and provided the basis for remarks about political divergences a m o n g the participants by K a i m a n Silvert during his synthesis of the seminar. T h e final paper at the national policy level, presented by H . J. Cole, outlined Brazilian efforts to create national urban development policies. T h e single paper devoted to urbanization within the city proper was by Carlos Delgado and was devoted primarily to the formulation of criteria for systematically

7o8

T h e world of the social sciences

describing and analysing problems which have their origin in the accelerated rate of urbanization in L i m a , Peru. Principal focus was placed on a classification of 'marginal' residential settlement types as a n initial step in research leading to the development of policies for improving the quality of the communities considered. Limited time and multiple divergences in points of view resulted in work groups operating at less than the desired level of efficiency. T h e y were, none the less, able to advance a n u m b e r of constructive suggestions in the following areas: (a) necessary social science research contributions to urbanization policies in Latin America; (b) training and education p r o g r a m m e needs for urban and regional development in Latin America; (c) experimental p r o g r a m m e in urban and regional development: identification of projects and action-research possibilities; and (d) improved c o m munications in urban and regional development: international, inter-American and university-government. A keen synthesis of the seminar, provided by K a i m a n H . Silvert, touched on the sociology of conferences and illustrated the confrontations and divergences encountered in the sessions and work groups. These confrontations centred about the difference in positions, ideologies and experiences as demonstrated b y various opposites including: the polarization between practitioners and theorists and, a m o n g theorists, between the macro- and micro-theorists; the divergence between political left and right; the divergence between the elitist and the populist, with shades of elitist populists and pluralistic populists; a break between those w h o are political and those w h o pretend to be apolitical; divisions on the basis of continentalcultural backgroundsEuropean, Latin American and North American; a n d divisions between those w h o believe in idealistic planning and those w h o believe in pragmatic planning. Clearly, the possible permutations surrounding these opposite and intermediate positions a m o n g those present were numerous and demonstrated in the seminar what Silvert ascribed to the urban society at large'the great variability of h u m a n response to the fact of simple ecological organization'. In summation, K a i m a n Silvert suggested that, a m o n g all the intellectual currents in the discussions, there was a series of dialectical confrontations at the policy level between the urban and rural life styles, between urban and regional organization, between local and national organization, between the national and the international scene, and between national organization, defined as including local and Latin American integration, with endless combinations a m o n g these. A second issue, he suggested, was the sociological role of cities and divergences about that role between the view that 'the mere facts of an urban agglomeration m e a n a specific set of things for the persons w h o live in that agglomeration' and, a more probabilistic viewpoint, 'that urban conglomerations in any part of the world can lead to a very broad variability of h u m a n reactions'. A third issue singled out concerned the range of effective choice open under any particular set of given situations. Other issues dealt with the relationship between the order and the quality of change and with the immediate and urgent problem matrix versus that of the future. T h e results a n d the intensity of discussion during the seminar would seem to indicate that once the process of urbanization and national modernization through urban growth are dealt with as a policy area, both theoreticians and practitioners of the social sciences are presented with a base o n which each has almost equal footing, not always sound but showing signs of strengthening, a n d in which each are deeply and intellectually involved, although from different angles. T h e differences in perspective, however, rather than subduing, tend to whet the desire for a greater understanding about the processes, an understanding which is improved by knowledge from vantage points other than those of the given individual. It is precisely this cross-fertilization in the approach to the practical problems a n d the theory of urbanization that is enriching and expanding the separate disciplines of social science. It is also creating within the action-oriented, problem-solving institutions, a greater appreciation for a wider interdisciplinary approach to policies and solutions.

International appointments vacant

This section is open, free of charge, to international or national institutions or organizations seeking to recruit social scientists at the international level. The language in which notices appear indicates the chief linguistic requirement for the post in question, but other desirable languages may also be mentioned. Summary notices for insertion, in two double-spaced typewritten copies, including appropriate details and full contact address, should reach the Editor, International Social Science Journal, Department of Social Sciences, Unesco, Place de Fontenoy, 7 5 Paris-?0, no later than 10 November, 10 February, 10 May and 10 August for publication, respectively, in the March, June, September and December issues of this Journal. Where deadlines for the receipt of applications arefixed,due account should be taken of the delays in reaching an international readership. Under no circumstances should applicants address themselves to this Journal, but always directly to the contact specified.

Unesco
Applications a n d inquiries should b e directed to the Recruitment Division, B u r e a u of Personnel, U n e s c o , Place d e Fontenoy, 75 Paris-7 e , France, quoting the reference code a n d this Journal as the source. T h e levels indicated are the international civil service gradings to w h i c h the post is assimilated. Gross salaries, net of national i n c o m e tax, corresponding to these grades are as follows: P3: $11,270 P4: $13,900 P5: $17,400 D i : $20,000 Travel costs, installation a n d repatriation grants as well as other benefits are also offered.

Senior h u m a n resources analyst

Reference, R E G / L A / C H I L S T A T / I . Location. Santiago, Chile. Functions. U n d e r the authority a n d guidance of the Chief of the Division of H u m a n Resources Analysis, the i n c u m b e n t will represent U n e s c o in the working t e a m to b e established b y I L O in Santiago for the preparation of the O t t a w a Plan

Int. Soc. Sei. J., Vol. X X , No. 4, 1968

710

T h e world of the social sciences

for d e v e l o p m e n t of h u m a n resources in Latin A m e r i c a . H e will b e excepted to perform the following functions: (a) U n d e r t a k e a n d organize possible analytical studies o n prospective m a n p o w e r needs a n d the d e v e l o p m e n t a n d utilization of h u m a n resources in Latin A m e r i c a , including w o r k o n initiating n e w a n d / o r adapting existing m e t h o d o logical tools in this field. (b) M a i n t a i n contacts with other units of the Secretariat concerned, in particular with the D e p a r t m e n t of Educational Planning a n d Finance, so as to provide t h e m with the results reached b y the I L O w o r k i n g t e a m , especially with a v i e w to d r a w i n g their attention to desirable U n e s c o action. (c) P r e p a r e periodical reports to the Division of H u m a n Resources a b o u t progress in the preparation o f the O t t a w a P l a n . (d) U n d e r t a k e short-term missions in Latin A m e r i c a n States if required. Qualifications. Doctorate in economics, or equivalent. T h o r o u g h experience of h u m a n resources analysis, a n d educational planning. Close knowledge of econ o m i c development problems a n d first-hand experience of developing countries. Ability to w o r k as a m e m b e r of a team. S o m e experience of w o r k in U n e s c o . Language qualifications. G o o d knowledge of Spanish a n d English or French; working knowledge of the other language. Duration of appointment. E i g h t e e n m o n t h s .

Level. P5. Educational planning

Reference, I N D O N E D 15. Location. Djakarta, Indonesia. Functions. T h e expert to b e appointed to the educational planning post will b e assigned to the Ministry of Education a n d Culture, w h e r e h e will set u p a n educational planning structure to cover all aspects of the national educational system within the c o m p e t e n c e of the Ministry, a n d will act as co-ordinator of the U n e s c o t e a m of educational advisers. In addition, o n e of the essential responsibilities of the expert will b e the training of counterparts capable of continuing the w o r k after his departure. In close collaboration with these counterparts a n d with the U n e s c o t e a m the expert will: (a) Co-ordinate the w o r k of the m e m b e r s of the U n e s c o advisory t e a m in relation to its over-all objectives, assuring as necessary the integration of e a c h m e m b e r ' s activities with those of the g r o u p as a whole; (b) Participate w i t h the expert in educational research in the Creation or i m p r o v e m e n t of the technical a n d research services w h i c h are indispensable for the elaboration of a p l a n ; (c) A d v i s e the G o v e r n m e n t in the definition of areas for priority action as well as the integration of a n educational p l a n into the national over-all d e v e l o p m e n t plan; (d) Assist in developing the necessary links between the planning services a n d other departments in the Ministry of Education, with the regional a n d local authorities responsible for education a n d with other multilateral a n d bilateral programmes; (e) Assist the G o v e r n m e n t in the choice of candidates for U n e s c o fellowships in educational p l a n n i n g . Qualifications. University d e g r e e , preferably in education, e c o n o m i c s or sociology. Substantial experience in educational administration. Familiarity w i t h over-all d e v e l o p m e n t p r o b l e m s a n d preferably direct experience in developing countries or regions. Ability to w o r k in a t e a m . Duration of appointment. O n e y e a r . Level. P 5 .

International appointments vacant

711

Adviser in economic and social studies

Reference. CEYLETs/sF/13. Location. Ceylon College of Technology, C o l o m b o , Ceylon. Functions. U n d e r the guidance and supervision of the Chief Technical Adviser, and in co-operation with the Ceylonese counterpart, the adviser will have to devote himself to a variety of tasks. T h e following list will give an idea of the work involved: 1. Preparing and delivering a lecture course on economic, social, industrial, psychological and general subjects, a m o n g which m a y be mentioned: (a) general economics, including problems of special importance for the economic development of Ceylon, especially in the fields of industry and agriculture; (b) m a n a g e m e n t , organization, planning, costing, accountancy, pay schemes, including instruction on practical matters such as duplicating equipment, calculating machines, payroll calculations, etc.; (c) industrial relations, growth of trade unions, etc; conciliation machinery, international labour organizations, a. In close co-operation with the other advisers, the local teaching staff, the local authorities and the industries concerned, taking an active part in developing a n d supervising the students' industrial training, which should be of the sandwich type with a total duration of 12 months for each student. T h e industrial period should give the students industrial discipline, the feeling of industrial 'atmosphere', respect for manual labour, first-hand experience of labour relations, manufacturing methods and machines, materials testing, inspection, etc. 3. Training of counterpart. Qualifications. Master's or, preferably, doctor's degree in economics, business administration, industrial economics, or the like. Extensive industrial experience indispensablewith emphasis on personnel m a n a g e m e n t , planning, industrial training, work study, and the like. Candidates with teaching experience at technical university or technical college level will be preferred. Theoretical and practical knowledge of economic, industrial, a n d social conditions in an Asian country would be very valuable. Duration. Twelve months. Level. P 4 .

Expert in teaching commercial subjects

Reference, N I G E R E T S / S F / 8 . Location. National Technical Teachers' Training College, Lagos, Nigeria. Functions. U n d e r the guidance and with the co-operation of the head of the team, and in co-operation with the Nigerian counterpart, the expert will: (a) be responsible for the formulation and implementation of programmes and curricula in his speciality; (b) lecture on matters related to his field of specialization for not less than 10 hours per week; (c) prepare lists of equipment for his speciality, including lists of books and other teaching material. Qualifications. Qualified teacher in the teaching of commercial subjects with experience in thisfieldwill be useful. Academic qualifications: M . A . level. Duration of appointment. The initial appointment is for two years, with the possibility of an extension for the project's duration. Level. P 4 .

712

T h e w o r l d of the social sciences

Professor in educational planning specializing in comparative education and educational administration

Reference, R E G / A S / I N D I E D / I . Location. Asian Institute of Educational Planning and Administration, N e w Delhi (India) (travel in the region). Functions, (a) Teaching comparative education and educational administration in the courses given at the institute. T h e teaching of comparative education should be essentially practical in aim, demonstrating the connexions found between educational systems and geographical, demographic, economic, social and cultural factors; helping to identify type situations a n d standard strategies for each; and illustrating the danger, in a given situation, of imitating the educational system designed for a wholly different situation. Through the study of experience elsewhere, this teaching should help to avoid starts and errors. In the teaching of educational administration, the emphasis will be on adapting the administration to the conditions in the particular country and to the structure and size of the educational system, and on the practical execution of the educational plan. T h e appointee's teaching duties also involve the organization a n d conduct of group discussions a n d activities, a n d the supervision of the students' individual work. (b) Discussing with the other professors in the institute h o w to fit the teaching of comparative education a n d educational administration into the general context of die teaching provided b y the institute, that is to say, h o w to avoid a discrete treatment of t h e m w h e r e b y their relations with the different aspects of the p r o b l e m of educational planning w o u l d not b e clearly apparent. (c) Participating within the limits of his special field or fields in the studies a n d researches u n d e r t a k e n b y the institute o n questions relating to educational administration a n d planning, a n d helping in the drafting a n d publication of studies, articles a n d miscellaneous d o c u m e n t a t i o n o n questions c o m i n g within the purview of the G r o u p . (d) Undertaking short-term missions at the request of Asian M e m b e r States to study the organization of existing educational planning services, give technical advice for the improvement of these services or in s o m e instances for their establishment, and help organize training courses for the staff of such services as well as seminars on educational planning, administration and inspection. Qualifications. University degree of doctoral level, or equivalent; studies a n d papers on comparative a n d familiarity with the sociology of education. Practical experience in educational administration and of educational planning problems in developing countries. Acquaintance with the major problems of education and educational administration in developing countries. Co-operative attitude, aptitude for team work, experience of university teaching, preferably in the field of comparative education or educational administration. Duration of contract. T w o years (renewable). Level. P 3 .

Expert in general pedagogy

Reference. N I G E R E D / S F / 7 I . Location. L a g o s , Nigeria. Functions, (a) D r a w u p p r o g r a m m e s for selecting candidates for the National T e c h nical Teacher's Training College, w h o will b e the future trainers of technical teachers throughout Nigeria. This will involve evaluations covering m e n t a l testing, biological a n d social factors, aptitude testing a n d educational history. (b) Lecture o n the role of a teacher in technical education a n d h o w to give guidance to students in selecting particularly suitable specializations.

International a p p o i n t m e n t s v a c a n t

713

(c) L e c t u r e o n the v a l u e of adult e d u c a t i o n to industry. (d) Orient students in the value a n d usage of libraries, p r o g r a m m e d instruction, g r o u p discussions a n d report writing. (e) T e a c h the practical applications o f p s y c h o l o g y in the f o r m o f the f u n d a m e n t a l principles of learning, covering educational m e t h o d s , m e t h o d o l o g y a n d assessment of future trends. (/) M a i n t a i n close liaison w i t h the expert in psychology a n d sociology ( N I G E R E D / S F / 7 3 ) , particularly o n the implications o f industrial p r o b l e m s , a n d especially in-service training. (g) P r e p a r e lists of relevant e q u i p m e n t , b o o k s a n d teaching materials. (h) G e n e r a l l y p r o m o t e the e c o n o m i c aspects o f technical e d u c a t i o n a n d give g u i d a n c e counselling. Qualifications. Qualified teacher in general p e d a g o g y with teaching experience in responsible positions. R e s e a r c h experience in this field a n d teaching experience in technical subjects w o u l d b e a r e c o m m e n d a t i o n . A record o f vocational g u i d a n c e a n d experience w i t h parent/teacher organizations. A c a d e m i c qualifications: M . A . level. Duration of appointment. T w o years, w i t h the possibility of a n extension for the project's duration.

Level. P4. Lecturer in h o m e economics

Reference, N I G E R E D 29. Location. Zaria, North Central State, Nigeria. Function. T h e incumbent, u n d e r the authority of the Chief Technical Adviser, will perform the following functions: (a) Assist as requested with the organization of the D e p a r t m e n t of H o m e Economics. (b) T e a c h courses in foods a n d nutrition a n d related subjects as required. (f) H e l p in the preparation of the curricula for s e c o n d a r y schools a n d ordinary teacher-training colleges in co-operation w i t h the Ministry of E d u c a t i o n . (d) Organize in-service training courses for those w h o are teaching h o m e economics in schools but w h o d o not h a v e the requested qualifications. (e) C a r r y out such duties as m a y b e assigned to h i m , o n a n ad hoc basis, b y the Secretariat (Headquarters) a n d the Chief Technical Adviser, a n d w h i c h are considered necessary for the execution of the project. Qualifications. A d v a n c e d level training, at least a n M . A . or the equivalent, with nutrition a n d education as major parts of the training. Experience of teacher training as well as curriculum development a n d supervision of h o m e economics teachers. Duration of appointment. O n e year. Level. P 4 .

Lecturer in h o m e

economics

Reference. NiGERED/sF/85. Location. Zaria, North Central State, Nigeria. Functions. T h e incumbent, u n d e r the authority of the Chief Technical Adviser, will perform the following functions: (a) Organize the D e p a r t m e n t of H o m e E c o n o m i c s a n d start a three-year post secondary course in h o m e economics. (1) Prepare the integration of the subject at full course level at the Training College giving d u e consideration to the problems of the families in Northern Nigeria.

714

The

w o r l d o f the social sciences

(c) T e a c h courses in h o m e e c o n o m i c s e d u c a t i o n a n d related subjects as m i g h t be required a n d acquaint students w i t h s i m p l e m e t h o d s for studies a n d research in h o m e e c o n o m i c s education. (d) Organize in-service training courses for those w h o are teaching h o m e economics in schools but w h o d o not have the required qualifications. (e) C a r r y out such duties as m a y b e assigned to him, o n a n ad hoc basis, b y the Secretariat (Headquarters) a n d the Chief Technical Adviser, a n d w h i c h are considered necessary for the execution of the project. Qualifications. A d v a n c e d level training; at least a n M . A . or the equivalent, with general h o m e e c o n o m i c s a n d education as m a j o r parts of the degree. Experience of teacher training as well as curricula d e v e l o p m e n t a n d supervision of h o m e e c o n o m i c s teachers. Duration of appointment. E i g h t e e n m o n t h s .

Level. P4. Directeur scientifique d u Centre africain de formation et de recherche administratives pour le dveloppement ( C A F R A D )
Rfrence, R E G / M O R O S O C / I . Lieu d'affectation. T a n g e r , M a r o c . Attributions. S o u s le contrle d u directeur d u centre, les tches principales d u directeur scientifique consistent : (a) Organiser des sminaires et stages d'tudes sur des p r o b l m e s d ' a d m i n i s tration publique l'intention des fonctionnaires et autres cadres suprieurs des tats africains; (b) Organiser des runions scientifiques consacres a u x p r o b l m e s a d m i n i s tratifs et a u x m t h o d e s des sciences administratives, ainsi q u ' l'adaptation des structures et rgles administratives a u x problmes c o n o m i q u e s , sociaux et culturels d e l'Afrique; (c) C o o r d o n n e r , stimuler et effectuer d e s recherches et des tudes c o m p a r a t i v e s sur les p r o b l m e s administratifs considrs d a n s leur rapport a v e c le d v e l o p p e m e n t c o n o m i q u e , social et culturel d e l'Afrique; (d) Organiser et dvelopper u n centre d e documentation spcialis dans les domaines numrs aux points a, b, et c ci-dessus; (e) P r o m o u v o i r l'change des informations et d e l'exprience acquises d a n s le d o m a i n e d e l'administration publique africaine, a u m o y e n d e publications et autres instruments d e c o m m u n i c a t i o n . Titres et aptitudes reguis, (a) P h . D . , doctorat o u titre quivalent e n sciences a d m i n i s tratives, avec d e b o n n e s connaissances e n sciences sociales; (b) exprience d e l'enseignement et d e la recherche a u niveau universitaire; (c) exprience e n matire d'administration d ' u n e institution scientifique et capacit d e diriger les travaux d e groupes d e chercheurs, y c o m p r i s les assistants et les stagiaires; (d) exprience d u travail e n Afrique souhaitable. Connaissances linguistiques. Excellente connaissance d u franais et b o n n e connaissance de l'anglais. Dure. U n a n , avec possibilit d e renouvellement. Niveau. P 5 .

Directeur d u Centre de documentation

Rfrence, M O R O S O C 4 . Lieu d'affectation. Centre africain de formation et de recherche administratives pour le dveloppement ( C A F R A D ) , Tanger, M a r o c . Attributions. L e Centre de documentation de C A F R A D a c o m m e n c fonctionner en 1965. Il dispose d'une bibliothque spcialise qui possde quelque 5 000

International appointments vacant

715

volumes et est abonne 150 priodiques environ (ces ouvrages priodiques ayant trait aux problmes administratifs d u dveloppement socio-conomique de l'Afrique). Les tches de l'expert seront les suivantes : 1. Aider le directeur d u C A F R A D tablir des programmes court et long terme en matire de documentation. 2. Diriger le dveloppement du centre, en s'occupant : (a) de mettre au point les mthodes d'acquisition, de classement, d'analyse et de diffusion des documents; (b) d'quiper le centre de manire rpondre ses besoins croissants en matire de fiches, de rayonnages, de matriel de reproduction, etc.; (c) de faire excuter les travaux de secrtariat ncessaires au fonctionnement du centre. 3. tablir, l'usage d u directeur d u C A F R A D et de ses collaborateurs, des dossiers spciaux sur des sujets de recherche prcis, en se servant cette fin des ressources de la bibliothque et, ou en obtenant par correspondance le concours d'autres centres de documentation spcialiss dans le domaine considr et situs tant en Afrique que dans d'autres parties du m o n d e . 4. Maintenir et dvelopper les contacts et les changes de documents organiss entre le C A F R A D et les centres susmentionns, ainsi qu'avec les imprimeries officielles des pays africains. 5. Rdiger la section bibliographique de la revue d u C A F R A D , tudes administratives africaines. Titres et aptitudes requis. Titres d'un niveau lev et exprience suffisante dans le domaine de l'administration publique o u des sciences sociales en gnral. Il est indispensable que l'expert soit titulaire d'un grade en bibliothconomie. Connaissances linguistiques. Excellente connaissance d u franais et de l'anglais ncessaire. Connaissance de l'arabe souhaitable. Dure. U n an, avec possibilit de renouvellement. Niveau. P 4 .

Spcialiste de l'valuation
Rfrence. M A D A G A S C E D / S F / I 6 . Lieu d'affectation. Tananarive, Madagascar. Attributions. L e spcialiste de l'valuation sera responsable devant le conseiller technique principal, qui est le chef de l'quipe d'experts internationaux. Il devra : prparer et effectuer l'valuation d u projet exprimental d'alphabtisation fonctionnelle, en collaboration avec les spcialistes nationaux de l'valuation et avec tous les autres spcialistes internationaux dsigns par l'Unesco, et conform m e n t au projet condens de guide pour l'valuation des projets exprimentaux du P r o g r a m m e mondial d'alphabtisation (Unesco/Lit/Ex/65/8); former des spcialistes de l'valuation et des auxiliaires capables de le seconder; se tenir en rapport troit avec les organismes d'valuation qui s'occupent des projets de dveloppement excuts dans le pays; organiser et diriger les travaux de l'quipe nationale charge des tches d'valuation et de tout le personnel charg d'valuer les sous-projets exprimentaux d'alphabtisation, afin d'assurer l'application d'un p r o g r a m m e d'valuation efficace et permanent; donner des avis au conseiller technique principal et, par son intermdiaire, au sige de l'Unesco, sur toutes les mesures propres assurer une valuation objective et efficace des projets d'alphabtisation. Titres et aptitudes requis. Grade universitaire ou titre quivalent en sciences sociales; bonne connaissance des mthodes statistiques et des plans de recherche; exprience de l'valuation des recherches et des projets; dans la mesure d u possible, une certaine exprience ou des connaissances en matire de pdagogie et de dveloppement, d'conomie de l'ducation, et, plus particulirement, d'ducation et de formation des adultes, de prfrence dans les pays en voie de dveloppement, en particulier en milieu rural.

7i6

T h e world of the social sciences

Connaissances linguistiques. Bonne connaissance du franais; connaissance de l'anglais souhaitable; connaissance d u malgache utile. Dure. D e u x ans. Niveau. P 5 .

Professeur de statistiques mathmatiques

Rfrence. ALGEREs/sF/27. Lieu d'affectation. cole nationale polytechnique, Universit d'Alger, Rpublique algrienne dmocratique et populaire. Attributions. E n consultation avec le conseiller technique principal d u projet, le professeur de statistiques mathmatiques devra n o t a m m e n t : (a) tablir le p r o g r a m m e d'tudes, mettre sur pied, organiser et assurer les cours de statistiques mathmatiques, en collaboration avec les titulaires des autres chaires de l'cole ; (b) guider et coordonner le travail d u personnel enseignant local qui contribuera l'excution d u p r o g r a m m e entrepris et la poursuivra aprs le dpart de l'expert. Titres et aptitudes requis. Doctorat en mathmatiques et plusieurs annes d'exprience de l'enseignement universitaire de la spcialit, de prfrence dans une cole d'ingnieurs. Dure. U n an. Niveau. P 5 .

Spcialiste de statistiques scolaires

Rfrence, A L G E R S O C / I . Lieu d'affectation. Alger, Rpublique algrienne dmocratique et populaire. Attributions. L e dveloppement quantitatif d u systme d'enseignement algrien ncessite, d'une part, la prvision des effectifs d'ge prscolaire en vue de la dmocratisation de l'enseignement, d'autre part, la prvision de l'afflux des diplms dans les diffrents ordres d'enseignement, en vue d'une estimation des besoins en locaux et en personnel enseignant. Par ailleurs, l'aspect qualitatif de cette expansion scolaire doit tre galement interprt, n o t a m m e n t en ce qui concerne le calcul des abandons et cours d'tudes et des redoublements. Il s'agit donc de runir et d'interprter les donnes numriques fondamentales d u systme d'enseignement, qui doivent permettre une amlioration d u rendement de l'ducation. L e spcialiste des statistiques scolaires sera donc charg, en consquence : (a) de donner son avis sur le recueil des statistiques scolaires ; (b) de prter son concours pour le calcul et l'interprtation des dperditions d'effectifs ; (c) de collaborer l'valuation des besoins court terme en locaux et en personnel enseignant. L'expert travaillera en collaboration avec le spcialiste de la planification. Titres et aptitudes requis. Grade universitaire ou titres quivalents ; exprience en matire de statistiques scolaires, n o t a m m e n t dans les pays en voie de dveloppement. Connaissances linguistiques. Connaissance d u franais ncessaire, connaissance de l'arabe souhaitable. Dure. U n an. Niveau. P 4 .

Experto en planeamiento de la educacin

Referencia, H O N D U R E D 12. Lugar de trabajo. Tegucigalpa, Honduras.

International appointments vacant

717

Funciones. (a) Investigar y determinar las distinctas necesidades en el c a m p o de la educacin, as c o m o los recursos disponibles y proyectos existentes en este rea. Ib) Estudiar los proyectos existentes y emitir recomendaciones generales sobre los proyectos a presentarse, tomando en cuenta investigaciones de la m a n o de obra especializada en las diferentes ramas y niveles, de acuerdo a las exigencias del desarrollo econmico del pas. (c) Asesorar y prestar asistencia tcnica en la ejecucin de los programas existentes y en el entrenamiento del personal nacional en la formulacin de programmas educativos. l d) Evaluar y disear sistemas de control para la evaluacin fsica y financiera de la ejecucin de los programas de educacin. () Coordinar sus actividades con las de planificacin del Consejo Superior de Planificacin Econmica. (f) Asesorar al gobierno en la eleccin de los oficiales llamados a beneficiar de u n a beca Unesco en el c a m p o de la planificacin de la educacin. El experto realizar sus labores en estrecha coordinacin con el personal de la Oficina de Planificacin de la Educacin. Debera trabajar siempre con el personal de contraparte. Requisitos. Ttulo universitario correspondiente, de preferencia en educacin, economa o sociologa, con amplia experiencia en la organizacin de planes de enseanza tcnica y profesional. Tener amplia experienca en programacin educativa, n o menor de 5 aos en tareas de planificacin de la educacin. C o n o cimiento de las caractersticas del desarrollo educativo en pases de Amrica Latina. Capacidad para trabajar en equipo y para realizar investigaciones educativas. Duracin del contrato. U n ao. Grado. P 5 .

Experto en planeamiento de la educacin

Referencia, C O L O M E D 17. Lugar de trabajo. Bogot, Colombia. Funciones. El experto desempear las siguientes funciones: {a) Asesorar a las autoridades docentes sobre cualquier reorganizacin de los servicios de administracin e inspeccin escolar que sea necesaria para la ejecucin eficaz de los programas de educacin. (A) Participar al perfeccionamiento de los servicios tcnicos y de investigacin indispensables a la buena marcha de la Oficina de Planeamiento Educacional del Ministerio de Educacin Nacional. (c) Asesorar e n el establecimiento d e las lneas sistemticas d e coordinacin entre la Oficina de Planeamiento, la Divisn de Planeacin de la Asociacin Colombiana de Universidades - F o n d o Universitario Nacional y la Division de Recursos H u m a n o s y Planeacin del Servicio Nacional de Aprendizaje (los tres centros de planeamiento de la educacin en Colombia). (d) A y u d a r en la preparacin de proyectos educativos que el gobierno pueda eventualmente utilizar para pedir ayuda exterior. (e) Asesorar al gobierno e n seleccionar funcionarios p a r a las b e c a s d e la U n e s c o . Requisitos. Ttulo universitario o d e nivel equivalente, d e preferencia e n e d u c a c i n , sociologa o economa. A m p l i a experienca en administracin y planeamiento de la educacin en general. Conocimiento de los sistemas educativos de Amrica Latina. Capacidad para trabajar en equipo. Duracin del contrato. U n ao (renovable). Grado. P 5 .

7.8

T h e world of the social sciences

International B a n k for Reconstruction a n d D e v e l o p m e n t

(World B a n k ) Applications are invited for the following positions in the Education Division of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development located in Washington, D.C., U.S.A. Letters of application should be addressed to: Personnel Division, International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, 1818 H Street, N . W . , Washington, D . C . 20433, U . S . A . T h e appointments are of indefinite duration with career prospects. Candidates should be aged between 35 and 50 and must be able and willing to travel extensively. Salary will be commensurate with qualifications and experience and is free of income tax. Family passages to Washington and transportation of household effects are paid. Functions. T h e incumbents of these posts will be required to analyse and evaluate n e w educational project applications submitted for financing, with a view to determining feasibility in so far as theirfieldsof specialization are concerned; this will entail participation in project appraisal and survey missions; duties will also include supervision of projects for which loans have already been m a d e ; and responsibility for keeping the Education Division informed on developments in their particular fields. Qualifications. For all positions, ability to write clear and concise reports in English is essential. A working knowledge of either French or Spanish and a k n o w ledge of underdeveloped countries and characteristic development problems would be an advantage.

Specialist in agricultural education

Qualification requirements. University degree in agriculture, preferably at postgraduate level. Experience in teaching agriculture and in the administration of agricultural education institutions and programmes. Familiarity with planning for education and training in agriculture. Experience in curriculum development, teaching materials and aids, staff organization and training, budgeting and finance, accommodation and equipment requirements.

Specialist in general secondary education

Qualification requirements. G o o d university degree and a teaching qualification. Experience in teaching at secondary and teacher training levels and in responsible posts in educational administration. Familiarity with educational planning at the national level. Experience in curriculum development, teaching materials and aids, staff organization and training, budgeting and finance, accommodation and equipment requirements.

Specialist in technical education and vocational training

Qualification requirements. G o o d university degree in engineering. Training and industrial experience in one of the major branches of engineering. Should have had teaching experience in trade and technical institutions and have held a responsible position in the administration of technical training and education. Should also be familiar with planning in these fields.

International appointments vacant

719

Experience in curriculum development, teaching materials and aids, staff organization and training, budgeting a n d finance, accommodation and equipment requirements.

Economistmanpower Economistpublic finance

Qualification requirements. A good university degree in economics combined with several year's practical experience in the respective field.

Architect (school buildings)

Qualification requirements. University degree in architecture. Practical degree in architecture. Practical experience in the planning a n d design of educational buildings.

Documents and publications of the United Nations and Specialized AgenciesI

General, population, health, food, housing

DEMOGRAPHIC A N D HOUSING STATISTICS

Demographic and housing statistics. Progress report on improvement in demographic statistics. January 1968. 5 4 p . ( O N U / E / C N . 3/377-) Measures taken in 1965-67. Standardization of classification systems. Collection and dissemination of data. Technical assistance. Demographic and housing statistics. Progress report on the igyo World Population and Housing Census Programmes. J a n u a r y 1968. 42 p . , including annexes, ( U N / E / C N . 3/378.) Measures taken in 1965-67 to facilitate future population a n d housing censuses. I m p r o v e m e n t a n d harmonization of census methods. W o r l d standards. Preparation of methodological a n d technical m a n u a l s . Plans for personnel training in various countries. Present m e a n s of disseminating the results of population a n d housing censuses. Future plans in this connexion. Demographic and housing statistics. Progress report on improvement in housing statistics, 1g64-1g67.Janua.Ty 1968. 23 p . ( U N / E / C N . 3/379.) This report was d r a w n u p in order to m e e t the Statistical Commission's request that closer ties should b e established between social a n d economic statistics (particularly national accounts statistics). In this connexion, it refers to the measures adopted in regard to housing statistics. Asian recommendations for the ig70 housing censuses. 1967. v + 43 p . , tables; $1; 4.30 Sw.fr. ( U N / E / C N . 11/772.) D o c u m e n t based o n the w o r k of a W o r k i n g G r o u p w h i c h held t w o sessions in B a n g k o k (2-8 D e c e m b e r 1964 a n d 7-12 M a r c h 1966). Definitions, classifications, tabulation. A n n e x e d are m o d e l tables.

1. A s a general rule, no mention is made of publications and documents which are issued more or less automaticallyregular administrative reports, minutes of meetings, etc. Free translations have been given of the publications and documents which we were unable to obtain in time in English. The following conventional abbreviations have been used: Bl. = Contains a particularly interesting bibliography. St. = Specially important or rare statistics.

Int. Soc. Set. /., Vol.

X X , No. 4, 1968

Documents and publications

72t

Progress report on computerization of demographic statistics. January 1968. 18 p . , including annex, ( U N / E / C N . 3/380.) Progress m a d e with regard to each of the aspects of the project for the computerization of data by the United Nations Secretariat (data bank; generalized p r o g r a m m e allowing prompt tabulation, b y computer, of demographic data from various countries, according to national as well as international standards; system for disseminating statistics as and w h e n stored; bibliography of official sources of demographics, o n tape). HEALTH The second tenyears of the World Health Organization, ig^8-ig6y. Geneva, 1968. 413 p.; $8.75; 26 Sw.fr. ( W H O . ) [Bl.] Inventory of the work done b y W H O . Future activities. World health statistics report. 1968. Vol. 21, no. 1 (121 p . ; $3.25; 10 Sw.fr.; vol. 21, nos. 2-3 (125 p . ; $3.25; 10 Sw.fr.; vol. 21, no. 4 (49 p . ; $1.75; 5 Sw.fr.). ( W H O . ) [St.] T h e title of this publication has changed. U p to volume 21, it was entitled Epidemiological and vital statistics report. Sections of a continuing (world) c o m p e n d i u m of statistics on the incidence of diseases. Apart from the regular tables, each studies a specific topic, e.g., no. 1 contains world-wide data o n the death-rate for 1964-66; nos. 2-3 contain tables devoted to in-patients in 1964; and no. 4 contains data on diabetes. HUMAN GENETICS

Research on human population genetics. 1968. 35 p.; $0.60; 2 Sw.fr. ( W H O , Technical report series, no. 387.) Guiding principles concerning the data to be collected within the framework of the studies relating to primitive groups. Population groups likely to be studied. Organization offieldresearch. T h e necessary m e a n s . Data processing. Training of research workers. Relations between the research team and the population studied. FOOD International action to avert the impending protein crisis. 1968. 106 p.; S 1.50, 6.45 Sw.fr. (uN/E/4343/rev. 1.) Report to the Economic and Social Council by the Advisory Committee o n the Application of Science and Technology to Development. Policy and p r o g r a m m e of action to be d r a w n u p in order to cope with the shortage of proteins, taking account of the increase in world population. The world food problemits relationship to international trade, export earnings and economic development of developing countries. Report by F A O . January 1968. 34 p . , including
annex, (UN/TD/22.)

Food production a n d economic development. International action to solve the world food problem. Present situation. Relationship to international trade. Future prospects. Measures to be taken in the developing countries. Assistance to be given to the latter by the developed countries.

722

T h e world of the social sciences

Social structures, economics, social service

STATISTICS, NATIONAL ACCOUNTS December 1967.

Integrated statement of international statistical programmes, 1968-1972.

107 p . ( U N / E / C N . 3/373.)

W o r k programmes, in the matter of international statistics, of eight United Nations organizations (United Nations, I L O , F A O , Unesco, I C A O , W H O , I B R D , I M F ) and of the Inter-American Statistical Institute (IASI). Planning and organization of work. Theoretical and practical training of statisticians. Improvement of techniques for public opinion polls and surveys. Dissemination and exchange of information. Statistics of world trade in steel, 1966. 1967. 61 p . $1; 4.30 Sw.fr. ( U N / S T / E C E / S T E E L / 2 5 . ) [St.] Exportation of steel manufactures or semi-manufactures, by region and by country of destination. Foreign trade statistics of Kuwait, 1960-1963.
8.65 Sw.fr. (UN/ST/ESA/BEIRUT/5.)

N e w York, 1967. xiv + 116 p.; $2;

[St.] Reclassified according to the United Nations Standard International Trade Classification. This work, which contains some fifty tables, shows the control and value of the exchanges. There is a special analysis of the petroleum trade. Foreign trade statistics of Saudi Arabia, 1960-1963.
(UN/ST/ESA/BEIRUT/6.)

1967. xvi + 126 p. $2; 8.65 Sw.fr.

[St.] Reclassified according to the United Nations Standard International Trade Classification. T h e work, which contains some sixty tables, shows the control and value of the exchanges.

Report of the Fifth Conference of African Statisticians, Addis Abada, 30 October-10 November 1967. ii + 78 p . , including annexes, ( U N / E / C N . 14/405.) T h e report deals with the following subjects: development of statistics in Africa; personnel training; national accounts; demographic statistics; housing and industrial m a n p o w e r statistics; information processing; work done in the region in connexion with sampling methods and public opinion polls; work programme. Yearbook of national accounts statistics, 1966. 1967. 734 p.; $10; 43.25 S w . fr. (uN/E.67. xvii/14.) This yearbook covers 140 countries and territories and contains data on: the c o m p o sition and distribution of the national product and national revenue; capital structure; private consumption. National accounts and balances. December 1967. 55 p . , including annex, ( U N / E / C N . 3/357-) D o c u m e n t presented by an expert group. Recommendations concerning the modifications to be m a d e in the national accounts system of 1952. Purpose and structure of the system. National accounts and balances. The revision and extension of the SNA, 195s. December 1967. 12 p . (uN/E/cN.3/358.) Progress of the work done since the fourteenth session of the Statistical Commission with a view to revising and enlarging the S N A . Additional work which seems desirable in regard to national accounts.

Documents a n d publications

733

National accounts and balances. Progress in relating the SNA and MPS. January 1968. 44 p . , including annexes. (uN/E/cN.3/362.) W o r k done in order to obtain greater concordance of concepts, dfinitions a n d classifications between the S N A (System of National Accounts) a n d the M P S (Material Product System of Balances). Points c o m m o n to the S N A a n d the M P S . N e w theoretical framework of co-ordination. National accounts and balances. A complementary system of statistics of the distribution of income and wealth. January 1968. 46 p . , including annex. (uN/E/cN.3/363.) Meetings a n d studies devoted to this subject. Guiding principles which emerge from them. W o r k to be undertaken to improve statistics of the distribution of income and wealth. Report of the Working Group on National Accounts, Santiago, Chile, 30 October-10 November 1967. N o v e m b e r 1967. 38 p . ( U N / E / C N . 12/801.) T h e revised national accounts system. Its adaptation in Latin America. T h e establishment of national accounts in the countries of that region. Sources a n d techniques. PLANNING, FORECASTS

Macro-economic models for planning and policy-making. 1967. 190 p.; $2.50; 10.80 Sw.fr. (uN/E/ECE/665.) Survey by the Economic Commission for Europe. State of the mathematical methods of economic planning in East a n d West European countries. Special study of certain models. M o d e l tables. Sectoral aspects of long-term economic projections with special reference to Asia and the Far East. 1967. 349 p . , charts, tables. $4; 17.30 Sw.fr. ( U N / E / C N . 11/774.) N e w projection methods. Study of the elasticity of growth. Macro-economic models. Sectoral projections on a m o r e detailed scale. Complexity of long-term sectoral projections. L a c k of data in Asia and the Far East. Practical proposals. Planning and plan implementation. 1968. vi + 245 p . , including annexes;
19.45 Sw.fr. (UN/ST/ECA/IO2.)

$4.50;

Papers presented to the C o m m i t t e e for Development Planning at its last session (Santiago, Chile, 10-20 April 1967). Problems raised by the implementation of plans. Experience gained at the regional a n d national levels. Local participation in development planning. 1968. iii + 6 4 p . ; $1; 4.30 Sw.fr. ( U N / S T / soA/77.) Relationship between c o m m u n i t y development a n d national planning. Local participation a n d the necessary administrative arrangements for its promotion. A n n e x e d are data concerning the machinery in operation in Nigeria, Tanzania and Yugoslavia. Report on the world social situation. Planning for balanced social and economic development in France. April 1967. 103 p . ( U N / E / C N . 5 / 3 4 6 / A D D 14.) Principal tensions which reveal themselves in the French e c o n o m y a n d which must be overcome in order to achieve a m o r e regular growth. Developments in French planning during the last twenty years. Sociologie aspects of growth factors. Standard of living. I n c o m e . Regional development. Report on the world social situation. Some aspects of planning for social development in Bulgaria. September 1967. 54 p . , including annexes. ( U N / E / C N . 5 / 3 4 6 / A D D 15.) This document is one of a series of m o n o g r a p h s o n the planning of economic

724

T h e world of the social sciences

development and social balance. It deals with the following subjects: economic and social development of Bulgaria since the war; characteristics of the planning system; organization of social development planning; education: public health; social security; housing construction; financing of social and cultural activities. LIVING CONDITIONS, SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

Report on the world social situation, 1967. January 1968. 7 p. (uN/E/cN.5/417.) Preface to the report on the world social situation in 1967. T h e main trends in the evolution of living conditions and social programmes during thefirsthalf of the United Nations Development Decade. Report on the world social situation, 1967. December 1967. 19 p . (UN/E/cN.5/417/ SUMMARY.) S u m m a r y of conclusions of the two addenda (E/CN.5/417/ADD. 1 and 2). Report on the world social situation, 1967. N o v e m b e r 1967. 258 p . (uN/E/cN.5/417/
ADD.

1.)

Evolution of the world population. Evolution of family planning between i960 and 1966. Health. Food and nutrition. T o w n planning. Housing and construction. Education. Employment, m a n p o w e r and income. Social security and social services. C o m m u n i t y development. Rehabilitation of the disabled. Crime and delinquency. Variations in the rate of social development in the different parts of the world. Report on the world social situation, 1967. December 1967. 248 p . (UN/E/cN.5/417/ A D D . 2.) Special analysis, by regions, of die social situation and social development in Asia, Latin America, Africa, Middle East, East European socialist countries, Soviet Union, Western Europe, North America. Work programme of the Commission for Social Development. Report of the Group of Experts on Social Policy and the Distribution of Income in the Nation. N o v e m b e r 1967. 35 p . (UN/E/CN.5/420/ADD. 1.) Relationship between the distribution of income and social policy. Recommendations by the Group of Experts. Background of the problem. Evaluation of the vital m i n i m u m . M e a n s of redistributing income. Statistics concerning the standard of living, income and wealth. Work programme of the Commission for Social Development: social aspects of industrialization. November 1967. 25 p . , including annex, ( U N / E / C N . 5 / 4 2 1 . ) Proposals relating to a concerted p r o g r a m m e ( U N I D O , Unesco, F A O , I L O , W H O , regional economic commissions, regional offices) bearing on the social aspects of industrialization. Implementation of United Nations social development programmes during the year 1967. December 1967. 47 p . , including annexes, ( U N / E / C N . 5 / 4 2 3 . ) T h e period under review marks an important phase in the social development programme, not only because of the reorientation of activities, but also because of the decisions adopted by the general Assembly and the Economic and Social Council, which will strongly influence future work. Study of the principal aspects of the activities carried out in 1967. Progress m a d e with regard to various items in the work programme. Report of the Working Party on the Draft Declaration on Social Development. February 1968. 24 p . , including annexes. (UN/E/CN.5/L.340.) T h e Working Group met from 22 January to 2 February 1968. It drew u p for the

Documents and publications

725

Commission for Social Development a draft declaration o n social development principles, aims and methods of action. WOMEN'S EMPLOYMENT

International Labour Office activities related to repercussions of technological change on employment and conditions of women workers. D e c e m b e r 1967. 58 p . , including annexes.
(UN/E/CN.6/500.)

Nature of this influence. I L O programmes. PUBLIC E C O N O M Y Organization and administration of public enterprises: selected papers. 1968. iv + 218 p . ; $3; 13 Sw.fr. (uN/sT/TAo/M/36.) Introduction to the problem as a whole, followed b y studies devoted to: public enterprise and national development; the role of public enterprise in the economic development of countries with centralized planning; organization and m a n a g e m e n t of State industries in the U . S . S . R . ; control of public enterprise; its financing. TRADE AND DEVELOPMENT, FLOW OF CAPITAL, ECONOMIC AID

Review of international trade and development, ig6y. Part 1 : Review of recent trends in trade and development. N o v e m b e r 1967. iii + 50 p . (uN/TD/5.) [St.] Report b y the Secretary-General of U N C T A D . Trend of economic growth in developing countries. Outline of world trade by large regions. Incidences for developing countries. Review of international trade and development, ig6y. Part 2 : Trade policy developments.
August 1967. iii + 70 p . ( U N / T D / 5 / A D D . I.)

Trade policy of various countries. Primary products. Manufactures and semimanufactures. Financing of trade and development. Invisible receipts, including shipping. Growth, developmentfinanceand aid (synchronization of international and national policies) : issues and proposals. October 1967. 32 p . ( U N / T D / 7 . ) S u m m a r y of proposals. Balance to be established between internal resources and external aid. Mobilization of internal resources. Supply of external assistance. Aid from multilateral institutions. A i d conditions. Problems of indebtedness. Tying of aid. Aid administration programmes. Trade credits. Private capital. Compensatory finance. Growth and external developmentfinance.October 1967. 36 p . ( U N / T D / 7 / S U P P . I . ) [St.] Relations between growth and external resources. Current contributions of external financial resources. Objectives of aid for development. Proposals. The terms offinancialflowsand problems of debt-servicing. October 1967. 20 p . ( U N / T D / 7 / supp.3.) Rcents trends in aid conditions. M e t h o d s for solving the principal problems. Necessity of fixing n e w objectives in the matter of aid and modifying the conditions. The tying of aid, by Jagdish N . Bhagwati. N o v e m b e r 1967. 70 p . , including annexes.
(UN/TD/7/SUPP.4.)

Methods by which aid is tied to a source of supply. Tendency to the generalization of aid tied to such a source. Cost of this aid to the beneficiary countries. Advantages for the supplying countries. M e a n s of reducing the real cost.

726

The

world of the social sciences

Progress report on compensatoryfinancingof exportfluctuations.N o v e m b e r 1967. 70 p . , including annexes ( U N / T D / 7 / S U P P . 6 . ) This note explains, in general outline, the decisions adopted by the International Monetary F u n d a n d the revised system of financing. Progress report on international monetary reform. N o v e m b e r 1967. 21 p . , including s u m mary. (UN/TD/7/SUPP.7.) Developments u p to the annual meeting of the International Monetary Fund, held at Rio de Janeiro in 1967. Insufficient growth of world reserves. Intervention arrangements. Nature and form of the n e w instrument. Carrying into effect. Ties with the financing of development. Costs and benefits of aid; an empirical analysis, by J o h n Pincus. October 1967. 59 p., including annex, ( U N / T D / 7 / S U P P . I O . ) Cost of foreign aid, between 1962 a n d 1966, for thirteen supplying countries, calculated o n the basis of data supplied b y O E C D . Similar estimates for thirty-nine beneficiary countries. Views of the beneficiary countries with regard to the desirability of m o r e flexible aid conditions. Question of improving the techniques for measuring the effects of aid. The Horowitz proposal. December 1967. iii + 17 p. ( U N / T D / 7 / S U P P . I 1.) This proposal includes three essential elements: recourse to the capital markets as a source for the financing of loans for development granted b y a n international institution; system of guarantees as surety for the debts contracted by that institution; system of interest rebates. T h e questions raised b y this proposal are dealt with in this study, presented by the U N C T A D Secretariat. The development of an international commodity policy. October 1967. 4 3 p . ( U N / T D / 8 . ) This document, which is concerned with all international policies relating to c o m modity markets, deals in particular with exports from developing countries. M e a n s of action available to the international community; proposed measures. Recent developments and long-term trends in commodity trade. N o v e m b e r 1967. 28 p .
(UN/TD/9.)

Report by the U N C T A D Secretariat. Short-term a n d long term trends in commodity trade. Factors influencing the evolution of commodity exports in developing countries. Future prospects. Programme for the liberalization and expansion of trade in commodities of interest to developing countries. D e c e m b e r 1967. iii + 56 p . , including annex, (UN/TD/II/SUPP.I.) [St.] Measures which could be taken to liberalize trade. Reminder of the recommendations formulated by U N C T A D in 1964. Developments since then. Obstacles to commodity trade. Prospects as regards the establishment of a n e w p r o g r a m m e of action. Trade barriers and liberalization possibilities in selected commodities. D e c e m b e r 1967.
iii + 91 p . ( U N / T D / I I / S U P P . 2 . )

Principal commodities in which trade is impeded: bananas, beef and veal, citrus fruits and citrus juices, cocoa, coffee, cotton, rubber, sugar, tea, tobacco, wool, bauxite, alumina and aluminium, copper, lead petroleum, tin, zinc. Trade expansion and economic integration among developing countries. N o v e m b e r 1967. 40 p., (UN/TD/15.) Concise presentation of problems concerning the creation a n d functioning of groupings a m o n g developing countries. Results obtained in thisfield.Reasons w h y such projects are difficult. M e a n s of overcoming the difficulties.

Documents and publications

727

Special measures to be taken in favour of the least developed among the developing countries aimed at expanding their trade and improving their economic and social development. N o v e m ber 1967. ii + 20 p . , including annex. (uN/TD/17.) General statement of the problem. S u m m a r y of suggestions concerning the special measures to be taken in favour of the least developed countries. M e a n s of determining which countries are the least developed. Trends and problems in world trade and development. Review of trade relations among countries having different economic and social systems including problems of East- West trade. N o vember 1967. 4 4 p . ( U N / T D / I 8 . )

Report by the U N C T A D Secretariat. Outline of the economic growth a n d export trade of socialist countries. Trade between socialist countries, developing countries and developed countries with a market economy. Programme for the liberalization of non-tariff barriers in developed countries on products of export interest to developing countries. N o v e m b e r 1967. iii + 23 p . ( U N / T D / 2 O / S U P P . I . ) Report by the U N C T A D Secretariat. Principal points which should be taken into consideration. Definition of the methods of applying an ad hoc p r o g r a m m e . A possible programme for the promotion of exports of manufactures and semi-manufactures from the developing countries. N o v e m b e r 1967. i + 59 p . , including annexes, ( U N /
TD/21/suPP.i.)

Problems confronting developing countries in the field of the promotion of exports and commercialization. Measures to be taken. Reports of the Meeting of Experts on United Nations Technical Assistance relating to Exports of Manufactures a n d Semi-Manufactures from Developing Countries (Geneva, 24-28 October 1966) and of the Joint U N C T A D / U N I D O Meeting of Experts o n Government Policies for Export Promotion ( N e w York, 26-30 J u n e 1967). The role of private enterprise in investment and promotion of exports in developing countries. N o v e m b e r 1967. xiv + 250 p . , including annexes, ( U N / T D / 3 5 / S U P P . I . ) Report prepared b y Dirk U . Stikker. Private enterprise and development. M e a n s of promoting the flow of foreign private 'investments. Development of exports of manufactures and semi-manufactures from developing countries. Annexed are extracts from a declaration o n development in Africa, b y M . T . J. M b o y a , Minister of Planning, K e n y a , at the opening of the eighth session of the Economic C o m m i s sion for Africa, and the Agreement on double taxation, established by the C o m m o n wealth Federation of C h a m b e r s of C o m m e r c e . Notes o n the profitableness of various public and private enterprises in India, in 1963-64 and in 1964-65. Consideration of measures leading to the improvement of the international division of labour. Some labour implications of increased participation of developing countries in trade in manufactures and semi-manufactures. December 1967. 17 p . , including annex. (uN/TD/46.) Report b y the International Labour Office. Preliminary study of the consequences which the increase in imports of industrial products from the developing countries could have on the volume of employment in North America and in Europe. Methods of evaluating and forecasting these consequences. Activities of GATT in thefieldof trade and development ig4-ig6y. January 1968. 48 p . , including annexes. (uN/TD/50.) Nature of G A T T . Activities in 1964-67. Legal a n d institutional development. Measures taken as regards parity. W o r k of the Committee on Trade a n d Developm e n t . Trade negotiations. Trade promotion. Technical assistance. Future prog r a m m e of work. Relationship between G A T T and U N C T A D .

7a8

T h e world of the social sciences

The externalfinancingof economic development. Internationalflowof long-term capital and official donations, ig6s-ig66. 1968. xi + 144 p . ; $2; 8.65 Sw.fr. (uN/E/4438.) [St.] Recent information concerning the m o v e m e n t of capital a n d donations. Statistical analysis of the nature a n d a m o u n t of the resources transferred during the last ten years. Information concerning the return flow of resources. Imbalances. Programme of work of UNIDO
(UN/ID/B/20.)

for ig68. October 1967. 57 p . , including annexes.

[Bl.] Outline of the activities included in the United Nations Industrial Developm e n t Organization's p r o g r a m m e for 1968. Synoptic tables with annotations. Field work projects. Meetings. Research. REGIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSIONS

Compendium of resolutions adopted by the Economic Commission for Africa from the first to the eighth sessions, igs8-ig6y. August 1967. 265 p . ( U N / E / C N . I 4 / D O C / 2 / A D D . I 2 . ) Integral text of the resolutions relating to all fields of the Commission's activities. Economic Commission for Asia and the Far Easttwenty years of progress. 1967. 176 p . ,
m a p s , ( U N / E / C N . I I / 7 6 o / R E V . I .)

C o m m e m o r a t i v e report. First steps a n d development of E C A F E . Present activities. Economic analysis. Planning. Statistics. Promotion of production and exchanges. ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION A N D REGIONAL INTEGRATION

Planning and policy aspects of economic co-operation in Eastern Africa. October 1967. 47 p . , including annex. ( U N / E / C N . I 4 / E A / E C 3 . ) T h e situation in the subregion. Evolution of economic co-operation. Trends towards parallel and competitive development. Various methods of economic co-operation. Influence of these methods on national development policies. Institutional problems.

The economically relatively less developed countries and Latin American integration: approache and proposals. October 1967. 37 p . ( U N / S T / E C L A / C O N F . 2 9 / L . 2 . ) T h e policy of integration in Latin America. Imbalances. Recommendations. Measures to be taken: policy measures, agreements by sectors, multinational projects, frontier /development programmes,fiscalincentives,financialco-operation, technical assistance, internal decisions. Report of the Second Ministerial Conference on Asian Economic Co-operation and report on the Asian Development Bank. 1966. iii + 114 p . ; $2.; 8.65 Sw.fr. ( U N / E / C N . 11/716/ R E V . 1.) The conference was held in Manila from 29 November to 2 December 1965. Economic co-operation. Harmonization of development plans. Industrialization. Trade liberalization. Problems raised by the creation of the Asian Development Bank. MINES, FUELS

Consumption of solid fuels in the domestic sector. 1967. v + 76 p . , including tables a n d figures; $1; 4.30 Sw.fr. ( U N / S T / E C E / C O A L / 3 3 . ) Study b y the Economic Commission for Europe. Past a n d future trends in the delivery of solid fuels to the domestic sector. General outline of the trends o n a European scale. Analysed by countries. Mining developments in Asia and the Far East. 1967. ix + 136 p . , tables; $2.50; 8.65 Sw.fr. ( U N / E / C N . 11/751.) [St.] Review to c o m m e m o r a t e the twentieth anniversary of E C A F E . Development of mining production in the countries of the region.

Documents and publications

729

The coal situation in Europe in 1966 and ils prospects. 1967. iv + 59 p., including tables; #-75; 3- 2 5 Sw.fr. ( U N / S T / E C E / C O A L / 3 2 . ) Recent developments in the d e m a n d for coal a n d the factors determining this d e m a n d . Deliveries to the principal consumption sectors. Developments in coal production, productivity a n d m a n p o w e r . Changes which have occurred in the international trade of solid fuels. Long-term trends in the coal supply and d e m a n d in Europe. AGRICULTURE, FISHING

National grain policies, 1967. 1968. 136 p.; $2; 8.65 Sw.fr. ( F A O . ) Official reports from forty-four countries of the measures in force during the 1966-67 campaign. Information concerning all cereals, with the exception of rice. The state of worldfisheries.1968. 49 p.; $0.80; 3.45 Sw.fr. ( F A O . ) N e e d for dividingfishingresources. Problems raised by the world increase in catches. Forms of regulation. Future prospects. A n n e x e d is a table listing the intergovernmental bodies concerned with fishing. AGRICULTURAL WORKERS

Labour inspection in agriculture. Geneva, 1967. 8 4 p.; $154 Sw.fr. ( I L O . ) Report prepared for the International L a b o u r Conference (52nd Session, G e n e v a , 1968). Historical account of the question. Basic ideas. Field of action and methods of labour inspection in agriculture. Organization of inspection systems. Questionnaire addressed to governments. SOCIAL PROBLEMS OF T H E TEXTILE INDUSTRIES

General report: recent events and developments in the textile industry. 1968. 128 p. ( I L O . ) Trends in production for the industry as a whole and for different sectors of it. E m p l o y m e n t . Salaries. Collective negotiations. Social problems resulting from fluctuations in the international textile trade. Technical co-operation between

ILO and U N I D O .
The effects of structural and technological changes on labour problems in the textile industry. 1968. 113 p . (ILO.) Recent changes in the situation and structure of the textile industry. Effects o n salaries. M a n p o w e r surpluses. Changes in the field of training and readaptation. Professional relations. Labour problems in the textile industry in developing countries. 1968. 103 p. (ILO.) The textile industry in developing countries. Problems concerning the development of h u m a n resources a n d professional training. Working a n d living conditions. Development of social institutions. Case studies illustrating the solution of these problems at the level of the enterprise. SOCIAL SERVICES Organization and administration of social welfare programmes: A series of country studies. Jordan. 1968. iv + 38 p . ; $0.75; 3.25 Sw.fr. (uN/sT/sOA/78.) Study prepared before the w a r in J u n e 1967. Organization of social services in Jordan. Problems. Recommendations.

73

T h e world of the social sciences

Legal and political questions, h u m a n rights

HUMAN RIGHTS

Human rights: a compilation of international instruments of the United Nations. 1967. vi + 94 P-; $2; 8.65 Sw.fr. ( U N / A / C O N F . 32/4.) Texts of the conventions, declarations and certain recommendations adopted by the United Nations up to 31 December 1966, a n d the texts of certain instruments adopted by I L O and Unesco. In addition to the International Declaration of H u m a n Rights, this publication is concerned with instruments dealing with selfdetermination, discrimination, genocide, slavery, nationality, freedom of information, freedom of association, employment policy, w o m e n ' s political rights, marriage and the family, infancy, the right to culture and cultural co-operation at the international level. Status of multilateral agreements in thefieldof human rights concluded under the auspices of the United Nations. January 1968. 55 p . , including annex. (uN/A/cONF.32/7.) Text of multilateral agreements. Information received u p to 31 January 1968. State of ratifications. Periodic reports on humanrights. N o v e m b e r 1967.97p., including annex. (uN/E/cN.4/951.) Measures taken between 1 July 1964 and 30 J u n e 1967 by the M e m b e r States of Unesco, in order to give effect to that organization's recommendations and to the provisions of the Declaration of H u m a n Rights, for the purpose of improving the means of information, promoting the free flow of informants and news and raising the standard of information. Commission on Human Rights: information submitted by the Secretariat General of the Council of Europe. N o v e m b e r 1967. 20 p . , including annexes. (UN/E/CN.4/AC.23/3.) Functions of the European Commission on H u m a n Rights. Rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Convention for the Protection of H u m a n Rights and F u n d a mental Freedoms, signed in R o m e , 4 N o v e m b e r 1950. Machinery adopted for the protection of these rights. Subsidiary organs of the Economic and Social Council in thefieldof human rights. December
1967. 22 p . ( U N / E / C N . 4 / A C . 2 3 / 4 ) .

Composition a n d terms of reference of the technical committees of the Economic and Social Council operating in thefieldof h u m a n rights. Technical subcommittees and other subsidiary organs. The ILO and human rights. 1968. 124 p.; $1; 4 Sw.fr. (ILO.) I L O report to the International Conference on H u m a n Rights (1968). I L O ' s methods of action in the field of h u m a n rights. Measures already taken. M a i n objectives of the I L O from the standpoint of the Philadelphia Declaration. Some economic foundations of human rights. February 1968. 23 p. ( U N / A / C O N F . 3 2 / L . 2 . ) Economic barriers which still prevent the complete enjoyment of h u m a n rights in the developing countries. Measures to be taken to overcome these barriers. APARTHEID A N D RACIAL DISCRIMINATION

Study of apartheid and racial discrimination in Southern Africa. N o v e m b e r 1967. 173 p . (uN/E/cN.4/949.) This report, devoted to South Africa, forms part of a series of studies of the legal measures and practices in force in South Africa, South West Africa and Rhodesia.

D o c u m e n t s a n d publications

731

Study of apartheid and racial discrimination in Southern Africa. N o v e m b e r 1967. 100 p .

(UN/E/0N.4/949/ADD.1.)

Continuation of the preceding document, devoted to South W e s t Africa. Study of apartheid and racial discrimination in Southern Africa. D e c e m b e r 1967. 126 p .
(UN/E/CN.4/949/ADD.2.)

Study devoted to Southern Rhodesia. Study of apartheid and racial discrimination in Southern Africa: survey of United Nations past action in its efforts to eliminate the policies and practices of apartheid in all its forms and manifestations. D e c e m b e r 1967. 93 p . ( U N / E / C N . 4 / 9 4 9 / A D D . 3 . ) Measures taken in regard to South Africa, South W e s t Africa a n d Rhodesia. DISCRIMINATION IN E M P L O Y M E N T

Fighting discrimination in employment and occupation. A workers' manual. 1968. 218 p . ; $0.75; 3 Sw.fr. ( I L O . ) This m a n u a l , containingfifteenlessons, deals with various forms of discrimination in e m p l o y m e n t a n d occupation, a n d with international action in this field. FORCED LABOUR

Forced labour. General survey on the reports concerning the Forced Labour Convention, 1930 (No. eg) and the Abolition of Forced Labour Convention, 1957 (No. 105). ig68. $1; 4 Sw.fr. ( I L O . ) Evolution of the practice of forced or obligatory labour in regard to production or service, a n d forced labour for political a n d rehabilitation purposes. STATUS OF W O M E N Status of women in Trust Territories. January 1968. 23 p . , including annex, ( U N / E / c.N.6/491.) This report covers the 'period 1965-66. N e w developments. R e m i n d e r of the Trust Council's discussions o n the subject. List of relevant documents. Status of women in private law. January 1968. 25 p . (uN/E/cN.6/492.) Account of the w o r k done in the field of private law, since 1946, b y the Commission on the Status of W o m e n . Proposab concerning the Commission's future w o r k . National commissions on the status ofwomen. January 1968. 21 p . ( U N / E / C N . 6 / 4 9 4 / A D D . I . ) S u m m a r y of the replies from twenty-four countries concerning the establishment of national commissions o n the status of w o m e n , or similar bodies. Family planning and the status of women. January 1968. 27 p . (uN/E/CN.6/497.) P r o g r a m m e s recently formulated b y the United Nations. Outline of national p r o g r a m m e s of family planning. Relationship between family planning a n d the status of w o m e n . FAMILY CODE

Parental rights and duties, including guardianship. 1968. 114 p . ; $1.25; 5.40 Sw.fr.
( U N / E / C N . 6 / 4 7 4 / R E V . I .)

Parental rights a n d duties in normal circumstances a n d w h e n the family is divided. Cases in which the mother remains the sole parent, owing to w i d o w h o o d or desertion or s o m e other reason.

732

The

world of the social sciences

Education, science
UNESCO ACTIVITIES

Draft programme and budget for ig6g-igyo. 1968. 378 p . (UNESC0/15C/5.) Working document intended for thefifteenthsession of the General Conference of Unesco (1968). Very detailed plan of the activities envisaged for 1969-70. MASS MEDIA A N D ADULT EDUCATION

Meetings of experts on mass media in adult education and literacy. 25 M a r c h 1968. 15 p . , including annex. (uNESCo/cOM/cs/169/8.) Final report of this meeting (Paris, 13-20 N o v e m b e r 1967). Study of the ways in which the radio, television, films, the press and low-cost books can contribute to the needs of adult education and literacy teaching. Detailed conclusions. List of participants. EDUCATION OF W O M E N

Access of girls and women to technical and vocational education. January 1968. 183 p . , including annexes. (uN/E/cN.6/4g8.) Study presented b y Unesco. Historical aspects of the question. Quantitive data. Economic and social factors. Attempt to analyse the obstacles and favourable factors. Seminar on civic and political education of women, Helsinki, Finland, 1-14 August 1967.
1968. iii + 49 p . (UN/ST/TAO/HR/30.)

Limitations on equality between w o m e n and m e n in the exercise of civic and political responsibilities. A i m s of civic and political education. Role of public institutions and private organizations in the civic and political education of w o m e n . Techniques and methods. TRAINING OF W O R K E R S A N D CADRES

Development and utilization of human resources. Creation of job opportunities and trainin of cadres in countries undergoing rapid modernization. N o v e m b e r 1967. 66 p. ( U N / E / C N . 5 /
422.)

Report presented b y the International Labour Office. Prospects of employment and unemployment in the countries considered. Shortage of qualified personnel as an obstacle to development. Measures taken to balance employment. Role of the planning of h u m a n resources. Priority problems. Outline of a p r o g r a m m e for the development of h u m a n resources. SCIENCE POLICY IN AFRICA

Symposium on science policy and research administration in Africa. 16 October 1967. 32 p . , including annexes. (uNESCO/sc/cs/91/1.) [Bl.] Final report of the Yaounde S y m p o s i u m (10-21 July 1967), which considered the problems arising in intertropical Africa in regard to the organization of scientific research. Conclusions. List of participants and working documents.

Books received

General or methodological works

G E O M A N S , K . A . Statistics for the social scientist. Harmondsworth, Penguin Books, 1968. 2 vol.,fig.,tabl., index. Vol. I: Introducing statistics. 258 p . , 15s.; Vol. II: Applied statistics. 397 p., 21s. (Penguin education studies in applied statistics, 5, 6.) M U K E R J E E , Radhakamel. Man and his habitation. A study in social ecology. B o m b a y , Popular Prakashan, 1968. ix + !95 P-> tabl., bibl., index. Rs.24.00. PlGANiOL, Pierre. Matriser le progrs. Paris, Laffont-Gonthier, 1968. 346 p . , tabl., 15.90 F . (Collection 'Inventaire de l'avenir'.) TiTMUSS, Richard M . Commitment to welfare. L o n d o n , Allen and U n w i n , 1968. 272 p . , index. 30s.

History
R E S N I K , G . J . Indonesia's history between the myths. T h e H a g u e , Hoeve, 1968. xviii + 457 p . , m a p , bibliogr., index. 36.50 H.fl. (Selected studies on Indonesia, volume 7 published for the Royal Tropical Institute, Amsterdam.)

L a w , criminology
G L A S E R , Edwin. Regulile de interpretare a tratalelor internationale. Bucuresti, Editura Academiei Republicii Socialiste R o m a n i a , 1968. 274 p . 15 lei. L E G A , Carlo. Diritto e deontologia medica. R o m e , Istituto Italiano di Medicina sociale, 1968. 540 p . , index. 6.500 lire. P E C A R , Janez; V O D O P I V E C , Katja; U D E R M A N , Boris; K R O F L I C , Marjan. Poravenalni Sveti. Ljubljana, Institut za Kriminologijo pri Pravni Fakultati v Ljubljani, 1968. 198 p . , tabl., multigr. ('Reconciliation boards', s u m m a r y in English.) (Publikacija Stev. 11.) R E U C K , A . V . S.; P O R T E R , R u t h (eds.). The mentally abnormal offender. A Ciba Foundation symposium. L o n d o n , Churchill, 1968. xii + 260 p . , fig., tabl., index. 60s. S C H W A R Z E N B E R G E R , Georg. International law as applied by international courts and tribunals. Vol. II: The law of armed conflict. L o n d o n , Stevens, 1968. lv + 881 p . , bibl., index. 8.8s.od.

Int. Soc. Sei. J., Vol. X X , N o . 4, 1968

734

T h e world of the social sciences

Economics, demography

A C A D E M I A R E P U B U C I I SOCIALISTE R O M A N I A . Creare sistemului monetr national la i86y. Bucharest, Editura Academiei Repblica Socialiste R o m a n i a , 1968. 125 p., tabl., pi., bibl. 4.50 lei. (Bibliotheca oeconomica, V . ) A R R I A G A , Eduardo E . New life tables for Latin American populations in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Berkeley, Calif., Institute of International Studies, University of California, 1968. vii -f 324 p., fig-, tabl. $2.75. (Population monograph series, no. 3.) B E A N , Lee L ; K H A N , Masihur R a h m a n ; R U K A N U D D I N , A . Razzaque. Population projections for Pakistan, ig6o-sooo. Karachi, Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, 1968. 93 p., fig., tabl. Rs.5; $2. (Monographs in the economics of development, no. 17.) B I R N B A U M , Eugene A . Gold and the international monetary system: an orderly reform. Princeton, N . J . , International Finance Section, Princeton University, 1968, 52 p . (Essays in international finance, no. 66.) C E V O L L O S , Gonzalo. L'intgration conomique de l'Amrique latine. Geneva, Droz, 1968. 276 p . , fig., tabl., bibl. (Travaux de droit, d'conomie, de sociologie et de sciences politiques, no. 68.) Cooperativas de produccin. Santiago de Chile, Consejeria de Promocin Popular, 1968, n o p., tabl. (Coleccin estudios.) F L E M I N G , J. Marcus. Guidelines for balance-of-pqyments adjustment under the par-value system. Princeton, N . J . , International Finance Section, Princeton University, 1968. 31 p. (Essays in international finance, no. 67.) FouRASTi, J.; C o u R T H o u x , J. P . La planification conomique en France, deuxime dition refondue. Paris, Presses universitaires de France, 1968. 314 p., tabl. 14 F . (Collection: S U P L'conomiste.) H A L L A I R E , Jean. L'emploi temps partiel. Paris, Organisation de coopration et de dveloppement conomiques, 1968. 116 p . , tabl. n F; D M . 9.20; 19s.; $2.80. (Emploi des groupes spciaux.) H O W E N S T I N E , E . Jay. Programmes d'emplois compensatoires, version abrge. Paris, Organisation de coopration et de dveloppement conomiques, 1967. 52 p . , multigr. (Dveloppement des possibilits d'emploi.) I B A R R O L A , Jesus. Structure sociale et fortune mobilire et immobilire Grenoble en 1847 Paris, T h e H a g u e , M o u t o n , ig68. ix + 124 p . , tabl. (Publications de la facult de droit et des sciences conomiques de Grenoble, Srie histoire sociale, vol. 1.) K A I N Z B A U E R , Werner. Der Handel in Tanzania. Berlin, Heidelberg, N e w York, Springer, 1968. Fig., tabl., m a p s , bibl. (Ifo-Institut fr Wirtschaftsforschung, M n c h e n , Afrika-Studien 18.) K I S E R , Clyde V . (ed.). Estudios de demografa. Translated by Nuria Cortada de K o h a n , revised by Jorge Arevalo. N e w York, Buenos Aires, Milbank Memorial Foundation, with the collaboration of the Fundacin de Bibliotecologia Franklin, 1967- 5 2 7 P-> %> tabl., m a p s . K L O P S T O C K , Fred H . The Euro-dollar market: some unresolved problems. Princeton, N.J., International Finance Section, Princeton University, 1968. 28 p . (Essays in international finance, no. 65.) K R A S S O W S K I , Andrzej. The aid relationship. London, Overseas Development Institute, ig68. 124 p . , tabl., index. 25s. L E V I N , Sar A . Antipoverty work and training efforts: goals and reality. A n n Arbor, Detroit, Washington, D . C . A joint publication of the Institute of Labor Relations, T h e University of Michigan, W a y n e State University and the National M a n p o w e r Policy Task Force, 1967. m p . , tabl., index. (Policy papers in h u m a n resources and industrial relations, no. 3.) M A L I N S C H I , V . Studii economice. Bucharest, Editura Academiei Repblica Socialiste R o m a n i a , 1967. 288 p., tabl. 14 lei.

Books received

735

M A R B A C H , G . Amnagement des postes de travail pour les travailleurs gs: tude pilote et enqute dans les huit pays membres, avec une introduction de B. Metz. Paris, Organisation de coopration et de dveloppement conomiques, 1968. 79 p., ill. 5 F; D M 4.20; 9s; $1.20. (Emploi des travailleurs gs, 5.) M A R M O R A , Lelio. Migracin al sur. Buenos Aires, Ediciones Libera, 1968. 113 p . fig., tabl. Pequea industria y artesana en Chile. Santiago de Chile, Consejera Nacional de Promocin Popular, 1968. 124 p., tabl. (Coleccin estudios.) P O P E S C U , Oreste. Desarrollo y planeamiento en el pensiamiento econmico colombiano. Bogot, Tenis, 1968. 83 p . R E I N H A R D , Marcel R . ; A R M E N G A U D , Andr; D U P A Q U I E R , Jacques. Histoire gnrale de la population mondiale, 3rd d. Preface by Alfred Sauvy. Paris, Montchrestien, 1968. ix + 708 p.,fig.,tabl., maps. 90 F . S C H I C K E L E , Rainer. Agrarian revolution and economic progress. N e w York, Washington, London, Praeger, 1968. xix + 411 p., tabl., bibl. $15. (Praeger special studies in international economics and development.) S Z A B A D Y , Egon (ed.). World views of population problems. Budapest, Akadmiai Kiado, 1968. 447 p.,fig.,tabl. $15.
THE A M E R I C A N F O U N D A T I O N O N A U T O M A T I O N A N D E M P L O Y M E N T , I N C . International

Conference on automation, full employment and a balanced economy, Rome, Italy, i$6j. N e w York, T h e American Foundation on Automation and Employment, Inc., 1967. $2.50. T Y E R M A N , Donald; P A R S O N S , Ernest. The business of development. Foreword by Lord Aldington. London, Overseas Development Institute, 1968. 18 p . 10s. W O L F F , Jrgen H . Zur Frage der idealen Produktionsfaktorenintensitt. Freiburg-imBresgau, 1967. 45 p., bibl. (Materialien des Arnold-Bergstraesser-Instituts fr kulturwissenschaftliche Forschung.) World peace through world economy. Sixth International Study Conference, Youth and Student Division of the W o r l d Association of World Federalists. Assen, V a n G o r c u m , 1968. 147 p.

Political science
C A P E C C H I , V ; P O L A C C H I N I , V . Cioni; G A L L I , G . (ed.); SIVINI, G . / / comportamento

elettorale in Italia. Bologna, II Mulino, 1968. 474 p . , fig., tabl., maps, bibl. 10,000 lire. (Istituto di Studi e Ricerche 'Carlo Cattaneo', Ricerche sulla participazione politica in Italia, 1.) F O U G R E , Louis. Civil service systems. Translated by Ruth M u r p h y and Robert North. Brussels, International Institute of Administrative Sciences, 1967. 354 p . , bibl. S B I H , Missoum. La fonction publique. Paris, Hachette, 1968. 255 p., tabl., index. 16 F . S K I D M O R E , T h o m a s E . Politics in Brazil iggo-igf. N e w York, Oxford University Press, 1967. xviii + 446 p . , m a p , bibl., index. 69s. S N Y D E R , Glenn H . (ed.). Studies in international conflict. Buffalo, State University of N e w York at Buffalo, 1968. vii + 132 p.,fig.,tabl. (Buffalo studies, volume IV, no. 1.) S T E G E N G A , J a m a s A . The United Nations force in Cyprus. With a foreword by Inis L . Claude, Jr. Columbus (Ohio), Ohio State University Press, 1968. viii + 227 p., tabl., maps, bibl., index. $6.25.

736

T h e world of the social sciences

Sociology

B O U R D I E U , Pierre; C H A M B O R E D O N , Jean-Claude; P A S S E R O N , Jean-Claude. Le mtier de sociologue. Livre I. Paris, M o u t o n Bordas, 1968. 431 p . , bibl., index. 29 F . (cole pratique des hautes tudes-Sorbonne. Les textes sociologiques, 1.) C A M P O , Salustiano del. Cambios sociales y formas de vida. Barcelona-Caracas, Ariel, 1968. 282 p . , tabl. (Coleccin D e m o s . ) C A V A L L I , Luciano. Max Weber: religione et societ. Bologna, Il Mulino, 1968. 505 p . , index, 5,000 lire. (Saggi 68.)" C H A T T E R J E E , Bishwa B ; S R I V A S T A V A , H a n u m a n Prasad. Challenge qffamine. Varamasi (India), Amitabh, 1968. iii + 39 p . , fig-, tabl., pi. R s . 4 ; $1.50; 6s. El hombre, sujeto del cambio. Santiago de Chile, Concejeria Nacional de Promocin Popular, 1968. 75 p . , fig., tabl., pl. (Aspectos sociales de una poltica de gobierno. F A L L E R S , L . A . (ed.). Immigrants and associations. T h e H a g u e , Paris, M o u t o n , 1967. 187 p . , tabl., m a p s , pl. 13.50 H.fl. H E N R Y O N , C ; L A M B R E C H T S , E . , (under the direction of P . de Bie). Le manage en Belgique. Brussels, E v o , 1968. 259 p . , fig., tabl. 250 Belg. fr. K A R B U S I C K Y , V ; M O K R Y , L . (eds.). Otazky hudebni sociologie. Sbernik prispevkii hudebne sociologickeho seminare Svazu ceskoslovenskych skladatelii 6-8 d u b n a 1966. (Questions of musical sociology. Contributions to thefirstseminar of the U n i o n of Czechoslovak composers, 6-8 April 1966). Prague, 1967. 310 p . , fig., tabl., multigr. 300 kopeks. Summaries in Russian, French, English and G e r m a n . L E E D S , Anthony (ed.). Social structure, stratification and mobilityEstruktura, estratificac y movilidad social. Washington, D . C . , P a n American Union, 1967. 373 p . , multigr. (Studies and monographs, VIH/Estudios y monografas, X X . ) M A T T E L A R T , A . y M . La mujer Chilena en una nueva sociedad. Santiago de Chile, Editorial del Pacifico, 1968. 227 p . , tabl. Q U A D R I , Goffredo. L'antagonismo come oggetto di una sociologa speculativa. Siena, Circolo, Giuridico dell'Universit, 1967. 23 p . (Estratto dagli 'Studi Senesi' III, serie X V I , 1967, fase. III.) S H A N A S , Ethel et al. Old people in three industrial societies. N e w York, Atherton Press, 1968. x + 478 p . , fig., tabl., index. $15. Z G H A L , Abdelkader. Modernisation de l'agriculture et populations semi-nomades. T h e H a g u e , M o u t o n , 1967. 186 p . , fig., tabl., m a p s , pl. (Publications of the Institute of Social Studies, series maior, vol. XIII.).

Anthropology
B O U R G U I G N O N , Erika; G R E E N B A U M , Lenora. Diversity and homogeneity: a comparative analysis of societal characteristics based on data from the ethnographic atlas. C o l u m b u s , Ohio, Ohio State University Research Foundation, 1968. viii + 142 p . , tabl., multigr. (Occasional papers in anthropology, no. 1.) C Z E K A N O W S K I , Jan. W glob losow aruwimi. W r o c l a w , Polskie Towarzystwo L u d o z nawcze, 1958. 461 p . , fig., ill., m a p , index. (Prace etnologiczne, T o m V I . ) P U M A R I N O , V . R a m o n ; S A N G U E Z A , Arturo. Los bailes chinos en Aconcagua y Valparaiso. Santiago de Chile, Consejera Nacional de Promocin Popular, 1968. 63 p . , fig., musical scores. S I N G E R , Milton; C O H N , Bernard S. (eds.). Structure and change in Indian society. Chicago, Aldine, 1968. xvi + 507 p . , fig., tabl., m a p s , bibl., index. $10. V R E E D E - D E S T U E R S , Cora. Parda. A study of Muslim women's life in Northern India. Assen, G o r c u m and Prakke & Prakke, 1968. xii + 128 p . , fig., m a p s , pl., bibl. 18.50 H.fl. (Series non-European societies, no. 8.)

Books received

737

Philosophy, psychology
A P T H E K E R , Herbert (ed.). Marxism and Christianity. N e w York, Humanities Press, 1968. xii + 240 p . , bibl. B U N G E , William. The dialectics of Marxist theory. N e w York, T h e American Institute for Marxist Studies, 1968. 4 9 p . , multigr. (Occasional paper, n o . 7.) C A S S I E R S , L . Le psychopathe dlinquant. Brussels, Dessart, 1968. 180 p . , fig., tabl., bibl. (Dossiers de psychologie et de sciences humaines.) D U I J K E R , Hubert C ; J A C O B S O N , Eugene H . International directory of psychologists exclusive of the U.S.A., and ed. Prepared b y the Committee o n Publication a n d Communication of the International U n i o n of Psychological Science. Assen, V a n G o r c u m , 1966. xxiv 4 - 577 pH I N S T , H a n s . Das Verhltnis zwischen Westdeutschen und Flchtlingen. Bern and Stuttgart, H u b e r , 1968. 149 p . ,fig.,tabl., index. (Schriften zur Sozialpsychologie, nr. 6.) K E T T L E , Arnold; H A N E S , V . G . Man and the arts: a Marxist approach. N e w York, American Institute for Marxist Studies, 1968. 33 p . $ 1 . (Occasional paper, no. 8.) La criminologie clinique: orientations actuelles. Colloque organis par l'Institut D r . E . D e Greeff avec la collaboration d u sminaire d e criminologie de l'Universit catholique de Louvain. Brussels, Dessart, 1968. 302 p . ,fig.,tabl. (Dossiers de psychologie et de sciences humaines.) W O R D E N S T A M , G u n n a r . Den sino-sovjeliska konflikten: ideologifaktorn. Stockholm, Beredshapsnmnden fr psykologist frsvar, 1968. 45 p . , fig., tabl., multigr. (Psykologiskt frsvar, n o . 39.)

Education
A N D E R S O N , C . A . Le contexte social de la planification de l'ducation. Paris, UnescoInstitut international de planification de l'ducation, 1968. 41 p . $1; 6s.; 3.50 F . (Principes de la planification d e l'ducation, 5.) B U R G E S S , Tyrrell; L A Y A R D , Richard; P A N T , Pitambar. Manpower and educational development in India ig6i-ig68. Edinburgh a n d L o n d o n , Oliver and Boyd, 1968. xii + 89 p . , tabl., index. 63s. (Unit for Economic a n d Statistical Studies o n Higher Education, L o n d o n School of Economics a n d Political Science, report no. 3.) Educational planning: a directory of training and research institutions, 2nd ed. Paris, UnescoInternational Institute for Educational Planning, 1968. 234 p . $3; 18s.; 10.50 F . K A Y E , Barrington; R O G E R S , Irving. Group work in secondary schools and the training of teachers in its methods. L o n d o n , Oxford University Press, 1968. xiii + 146 p . , bibl., index. 8s.6d. M E N G , Heinrich. Contrainte et libert dans l'ducation. La sanction dans la relation ducative. Toulouse, Privat, 1968. 221 p . 16.20 F . N o z H K O , K . ; M O N O S Z O N , E . ; Z H A M I N , V . ; S E V E R T S E V , V . Educational planning in the U.S.S.R. W i t h observations of a n I I E P mission to the U . S . S . R . headed by R a y m o n d Poignant. Paris, Unesco-International Institute for Educational Planning, 1968. 295 p . , tabl. $6; 36s.; 21 F . P E A C O C K , Alan; G L E N N E S T E R , H o w a r d ; L A V E R S , Robert. Educationalfinance:its sources and uses in the United Kingdom. Edinburgh a n d L o n d o n , Oliver a n d B o y d , 1968. vii + 82 p . , fig., tabl., index. 55s. (Unit for Economic and Statistical Studies o n Higher Education, L o n d o n School of Economics a n d Political Science, report no. 4.)

738

T h e world of the social sciences

Mass communications
I R V I N G , James; S T . L E G E R , F . Y . Report on an investigation into the attitudes of a sample of male residents of the City of East London, Cape Province, towards the Daily Despatch and other newspapers in the area. Grahamstown, C . P . Rhodes University Institute of Social and Economic Research, 1967. vii + 161 p . , tabl., multigr. 6 rand.

Area studies
G H A R A T C H E H D A G H I , Cyrus. Distribution of land in Varamin: an opening phase of the agrarian reform in Iran. Apiaden, Leske, 1967. 179p., tabl., m a p , bibl., multigr. (Publications of the G e r m a n Orient Institute.) L E A C H , Richard H . (ed.). Contemporary Canada. D u r h a m , N . C . , D u k e University C o m m o n w e a l t h Studies Centre, 1967. xii + 328 p . , tabl., index. $10.

Miscellaneous
L A N C A S T E R , H . O . Bibliography of statistical bibliographies. Edinburgh and London, Oliver and Boyd, 1968. viii + 103 p., index. 84s. M E A D , Margaret; B Y E R S , Paul. The small conference. Paris, T h e H a g u e , M o u t o n , 1968. vii + 126 p . , pi., bibl. 20 F . (Publications of the International Social Science Council, g.) O W E N , David (ed.) A unified health senke. Oxford, London, Edinburgh, N e w York, Toronto, Sydney, Paris, Braunschweig, Pergamon Press, 1968. vii + 148 p . , fig., tabl. 30s. P L E S S E N , Jacques. Promenade et posie: L'exprience de la marche et du mouvement dans l'uvre de Rimbaud. T h e H a g u e , Paris, M o u t o n , 1967. 348 p., tabl., bibl., index. 18 H.fl. (Publications de l'Institut d'tudes franaises et occitanes de l'Universit d'Utrecht, I.) W O R T H , C . Brooke. A naturalist in Trinidad. Illustrated by D o n R . Eckelberry. Philadelphia and N e w York, Lippincott, 1967. 291 p., ill., m a p , index.

sociometrv
Genuinely interdisciplinary in the presentation of works of both sociologists and psychologists

A journal of research in social psychology

Recent issues have contained reports of empirical research dealing with: bargaining behaviour a n d coalition formation, the role of social n o r m s a n d leadership in risk-taking, interpersonal exchange in isolation, biased indoctrination and selectivity of exposure to n e w information, the perception a n d evaluation of behaviour change. T h e A m e r i c a n Sociological Association
1001 Connecticut A v e n u e , N . W . Washington, D . C . 20036.

Published by

$9.00 per year for four issues

Special rate to members of the American Sociological Association$4.50

Periodical of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences Volume 3. Number 3 I. Vajda J. Tinbergen I. Hetnyi G y . Szakolczai, P. Vsrhelyi K. Forges

ACTA (ECONMICA
ACADEMICE SCIENTIARUM HUNGARICiE The problems of East-West trade The optimal international division of labour Problems of long-term planning and the international coordination of national plans within the C M E A Extrapolated matrices of input-output coefficients The role and status of the family farms in West Germany [in German] Reviews Ten years of the development of economics in Hungary Scientific research into the problems of h o m e trade Book reviews

I. Schweitzer LSzabo

Acta (Econmica s published in four Issues making up a volume of some 400 pages a year. Size: 17 24 c m . Subscription rata per volume: $12.00; D M . 4 8 ; 5 . Distributors: Kultura, Budapest 62, P . O . B . 149. Akadmiai Kiad, Publishing House of the Hungarian A c a d e m y of Sciences, Budapest 502, P . O . B . 2 4

International review of administrative sciences

Contents of Vol. XXXIVJ1968), No. 2
G. A. G. L. M. M . de Molenes K . Asmal Fitzgerald E . de la Villa Weiss
Benjamin Constants Bicentenary* Administrative law in Ireland State-sponsored Bodies in Ireland Social security for Spanish civil servants* S o m e observations of the D y n a m i c s of change in the Israel G o v e r n m e n t organisation

J. F. Noubel E . N . Gladden S. L . S. Danurcdjo

T h e administrative reform of the R o m a n Curia* Churchill as administrator: s o m e sidelights o n public administration in wartime. T h e declining trend of legal a n d administrative performance in Indonesia: s o m e remedial actions suggested * Article written in either French or Spanish, with an extensive summary in English Schools' section. Articles. Technical co-operation. N e w s graphy, a selection. Chronicle of the Institute. in brief. Biblio-

Annual subscription: $ i o Single copy: $ 3

International Institute of Administrative Sciences, 25, rue de la Charit, Brussels 4 , Belgium.

International Y e a r b o o k for the Sociology of Religion _ _ Internationales Jahrbuch fr Religionssoziologie]

Edited by Professor Joachim Matthes, D o r t m u n d , in co-operation with D r . N o r m a n Birnb a u m , Straburg, Professor Friedrich Frstenberg, Clausthal-Zellerfeld, Professor Dietrich Goldschmidt, Berlin, D r . Norbert Greinacher, W i e n , Professor R e n Knig, Kln, Professor Jacob B . Kruijt, Utrecht, Professor Gerhard Lenski, Chapel Hill, Professor Helmut Schelsky, Mnster and D r . Jean Sguy, Paris. Volume I Religious Pluralism and Social Structure Religiser Pluralismus und Sozialstruktur 1965. 254 pages. Paperbound D M . 33 Sociology of Religion: Theoretical Perspectives (I) Theoretische Aspekte der Religionssoziologie (I) 1966. 256 pages. Paperbound D M . 36.50 Sociology of Religion: Theoretical Perspectives (II) Theoretische Aspekte der Religionssoziologie (II) 1967

Volume 2

Volume 3

T h e yearbook contains articles in English and G e r m a n , each with a brief s u m m a r y of its contents translated into the other language. It is open primarily to studies on theoretical problems, to summarizing descriptive studies, and to sociological essays o n religious phenomena.

Westdeutscher Verlag Kln und Opladen

Bimestral Sumario del n. 159-160 mayo-agosto 1968

B - C ^X\T1 G " " JL1.C/ V XlC*.

Director : Jess Fueyo Alvarez Secretario : Jos Ma Caitan Vazquez

d e estudios polticos

Estudios Juicios de valor, ideologas y ciencia social. Proceso al humanismo. La influencia de la informacin sobre las masas. La situacin del Parlamento en las sociedades industriales. Rasgos socio-militares de Europa occidental. ohn Stuart Mill. El liberalismo como ideologa, a herencia de un trono (Historia y poltica de una poca). La masa federal : romnticos, regionalistas y proletarios (1868-1873). Notas U n legado pontificio en la Espaa de Fernando V I . Dostoiewski en Espaa. Mundo hispnico El control de la legalidad de los actos comunitarios : proyectos y posibilidades en el Mercado Comn Centroamericano. Crnicas Reunin de primavera de la Unin interparlamentaria en Dakar Seccin bibliogrfica Recensiones. Noticias de libros. Revista de revistas. Libros recibidos. Bibliografa.

Lus Gonzalez Seara Jorge Uscatescu uan Benevto orge Esteban lerman Oehling Dalmacio Negro o s * Martn Lopez uan Ferrando Badia Antonio Peconi Jorge Sile Salinas Emilio Maza

Luis Gomez de Aranca

Precio de suscripcin anual

Espaa, 400 ptas. Portugal, Hispanoamrica y Filipinas, 556 ptas. Otros pases, 626 ptas. Nmero suelto, Espaa, 100 ptas. Nmero suelto, extranjero, 139 ptas.

Instituto de Estudios Polticos, plaza de la Marina Espaola, 8Madrid-13 (Espaa).

The Journal of

conflict resolution
A quarterly for research related to w a r and peace March 1968 issue (XII, I): Theodore Caplow and Kurt Finsterbusch T h o m a s C . Schelling Daniel Druckman France and other countries: a stud/ of international interaction G a m e theory and the study of ethical systems Ethnocentrism in the inter-nation simulation Other articles; gaming section; book reviews

$7 per year for individuals, $8 for institutions; $3 per issue Published by T h e Center for Research on Conflict Resolution, The University of Michigan, A n n Arbor, Michigan 48104

Vol.

VII, No. 3, Autumn

196B

The Pakistan Development Review

Contents Symposium on Planning Experience in Pakistan Planning experience in Pakistan C o m m e n t s o n Professor H u d a ' s conference address 'Planning experience in Pakistan' Capital expenditure, recurring expenditure a n d development planning: c o m m e n t s o n D r H u d a ' s address 'Planning experience in Pakistan': s o m e c o m m e n t s a n d reflections C o m m e n t s o n 'Planning experience in Pakistan* S o m e reflections on 'Planning experience in Pakistan' S o m e c o m m e n t s on 'Planning experience in Pakistan' A few c o m m e n t s on Professor H u d a ' s conference address /Planning experience in Pakistan' S o m e notes o n the 'Planning experience in Pakistan' Articles Prospects for the Pakistan tea industry T r e n d of real income of the rural poor in East Pakistan, 1949-66 A g e at marriage in Pakistan in other currencies; individual copies: R s . 3 or U . S . $ i . 5 0 addressed to the editor of the Pakistan Development Karachi-1. Style instructions for guidance in preparing request to the Editor. Books for review should be sent

Quarterly journal of the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, Karachi (Pakistan) M a n a g i n g editor: D r Azizur R a h m a n K h a n ; Editorial Advisory B o a r d : Professor Nurul Islam, D r Taufiq M . K h a n , D r Sultan S . H a s h m i , Professor Frank G . Child; Book review editor: D r Syed N a w a b Haider Naqvi

M . N . Huda
Md. M. Anisur R a h m a n Akhlaqur R a h m a n

A . K . M . Ghulam Rabbani Nurul Islam Taufiq M . Khan Syed Nawab Haider Naqvi S. R . Bose Azizur R a h m a n K h a n I. D . Carruthers, G . D . Guyer S. R . Bose Syed Iqbal Alam

Book reviews Subscription: R 3 . 1 2 or U . S . $ 5 per a n n u m or equivalent each. Manuscripts a n d editorial correspondence should be R e v i e w , O l d Sind Assembly Building., B u n d e r R o a d , manuscripts in acceptable form will be provided u p o n to the Book R e iw Editor.

Sociological Review Monograph N o . 13

Editor: Paul Halmos

Jay G . Blumler Asa Briggs Roger L . Brown T o m Burns James W . Carey George Gerbner James D . Halloran Hilde T . Himmelweit Denis McQuail John Scupham Colin Shaw Malcolm Warner E. G . Wedell Lord Windlesham

The sociology of moss medio communicators

Producers' attitudes towards television coverage of an election c a m p a i g n : a case study Prediction a n d control: historical perspectives S o m e aspects of mass m e d i a ideologies Public service and private world T h e communications revolution a n d the professional communicator Institutional pressures u p o n m a s s communicators Introduction Educational television, the educational system a n d the social sciences Uncertainty about the audience a n d the organisation of mass communications T h e control and conduct of educational broadcasting Television a n d popular morality: the predicament of the broadcasters A m e r i c a n T . V . political n e w s T h e objectives of the controllers Television : s o m e problems of creativity and control Forthcoming: December ig68 Price: 3 0 / - plus i/ad. post. U . S . A . : $4.60 plus 20c. post.

Copies obtainable from:

T h e Secretary to the M o n o g r a p h Editor University of Keele, Keele, Staffordshire, England.

International Organization
Volume 22, Number 4 Autumn ig68 the quarterly journal of the World Peace Foundation offering the most inclusive a n d up-to-date account of the activities of international organizations
Articles John W . Holmes Henry C . Wallich Walter R . Sharp Joseph S. N y e Oran R . Y o u n g Fearful symmetry: the dilemmas of consultation and coordination in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization T h e United States and the European Economic C o m m u n i t y : a problem of adjustment Decisionmaking in the economic and social council Comparative regional integration: concept and measurement T h e United Nations and the international system Recent activities of the United Nations, the United Nations Specialized Agencies, and the principal political, regional, and functional international organizations Recent books and articles, both United States and foreign Selected bibliography

Comprehensive summaries

World Peace Foundation $7.50 a year 40 M t . Vernon Street $19.00 for three years Boston, Mass. 02108 $2.50 a copy

QUADERNI DI SOCIOLOGA
Sommario del N . 4, 1967
Articoli L . Gallino A . Pizzorno L. Levi G r a m s c i e le scienze sociali Sul m t o d o di G r a m s c i (Dalla storiografia alla scienza poltica) Legittimit e Stato Documentazioni A . Cavalli, A . Martinelli e ricerche

11 profilo sociale dell'attivista di Berkeley Note critiche

V.

Torneo

Potere, conflitto e integrazione nell'opera di D u v e r g e r S c h e d e . P a n o r a m a dlie riviste

Comitate Direttivo NicoU Abbagnano Franco Ferrarotti Luciano Gallino Angelo Pagan!

Alessandro Pizzorno Pietro Rossi TulUo Tentori Renato Trerei

Direttore Responsabile Franco Ferrarotti Redattore Luciano Gallino Redaeione e Amministraziom: Casa Editrice Taylor - Via Valeggio, 26 - Torino Telef. 584.155 C / C Postale 2/34389 Reduzierte Romana : c/o Prof. Franco Ferrarotti, Via Appenninl 42 R O M A Tel. 846.770

Abbonamtnli
Ordinario. L . 4.000 Soitenitore. L . 20.000 Estero. L . 6.000 U n fascicolo separato. L . z.200 Fatcicoli arretrati dall'l al n. 42 L . 1.000 Fatcicoli arretrati dal 1962 (nuora serle). L . 2.000

conomie applique
T o m e X X I , n 3-4 (juillet-dcembre 1968)
Sommaire L'AUTOFINANCEMENT Marcel Malissen Jean de Lapparent Leopold Jeorger Henri C h a m b r e Pirrre-Yves Henin Jean-Franois Echard Daniel Vitry Raymond Courbis Pierre Le Brun Jean-Marie W e y d e r t Pierre Esteva Raymond Magny Marcel Malissen Marc Guillaume Prsentation Dfinition et mesure de l'autofinancement brut dans la comptabilit nationale tude compare du financement des entreprises dans six pays industrialiss L'autofinancement en Union sovitique L'autofinancement dans la thorie amricaine du financement de l'entreprise L'apprciation du rle de l'autofinancement : tude de quelques modles conomtriques Amortissement et autofinancement Le comportement d'autofinancement des entreprises U n e rforme sinon un contrle de l'autofinancement sont-ils concevables La fiscalit et le financement des investissements des entreprises La notion d 'autofinancement dans la pratique financire La participation des salaris aux fruits de l'expansion Synthse et commentaires L ' V A L U A T I O N D U T A U X D ' A C T U A L I S A T I O N ASSOCI A L A CROISSANCE FRANAISE

Institue de science conomique applique, I I, boulevard de Sebastopol, Paris- ! ' . Directeurs : Franois Perroux, Pierre Tabatoni, Giovanni Busino

Chief editor: K, Ishwaran, York University, Toronto, Canada Guest editor: David Buxbaum, University of Washington, Seattle, U.S.A.

Journal of Asian and African Studies

January/April I 9 6 7 , Volume II, N o s . I & 2

A quarterly publication, edited by an international board of scholars, which is devoted to the study and analysis of social structures and processes in the developing nations of Asia and Africa and draws contributions from anthropology, sociology, and related social sciences. T h e m e : Traditional and modern legal institutions in Asia and Africa Contente D . F. Henderson Simon Ottenberg Shuzo Shiga Jerome Alan Cohen Bernard Gallin Marc Galanter Cornellius J. Peck Promulgation of Tokugawa statutes Local government and the law in Southern Nigeria S o m e remarks on the judicial system in China: historical development and characteristics Mediation in Chinese law: traditional attitudes and practices Mediation in changing Chinese society in rural Taiwan Group membership and group preference in India Nationalism, 'race', and developments in the law of Philippine citizenship N e w s and notes; Book reviews

J . A . A . S . welcomes contributions by social scientists. Manuscripts, research notes and news, and other editorial correspondence should be addressed to the editor, K . Is h w a ran, Department of Sociology, York University, Toronto 12, Canada. Books for review (Africa) should be addressed to P. C . W . Gutkind, Department of Anthropology, McGill University, Montreal, Canada, and (Asia) to J. O'Neill, Department of Sociology, York University, Toronto, Canada. Business correspondence, renewals, advertising, change of address, reprints, subscriptions, and all remittances should be sent to: E. J. Brill, Leiden, Netherlands. Annual subscription: U . S . $ 1 2 , or the equivalent in other currencies. Order from: E . J. Brill, Leiden, Netherlands.

revue tiers-monde
Croissance { D v e l o p p e m e n t | Progrs
Tome IX, n 33 (janvier-mars 1968)

L'conomie ostentatoire

tudes sur l'conomie du prestige et du don publies sous la direction de Jean Poirier.

Jean Poirier Jacques Fauble Jacques Binet G u y Nicolas Jean-Claude Rouveyran, avec la collaboration de A h m e d Djabiri Grard Althab

Les fonctions sociales de l'ostentation conomique. N o t e sur l'conomie ostentatoire. Activit conomique et prestige chez les Fangs du G a b o n . Processus oblatifs l'occasion de l'intronisation de chefs traditionnels en pays Hausa (Rpublique du Niger). Rflexions sur le Dola N ' K o u ou Grand Mariage comorien.

Problmes socio-conomiques des communauts villageoises de la cte orientale malgache.

Documentation M . Eslami V . Cosmao Henri Laugier Albert Finet Recherche scientifique et pays en voie de dveloppement. L'encyclique Populorum Progressio : Lignes de forces d'une encyclique. A propos d'une encyclique. Rflexions intempestives sur l'encyclique Progressio.

Populorum

bibliographie

Direction-Rdaction

Institut d'tude du dveloppement conomique et social, 58, boulevard Arago, Paris-13 (402-28-01).

Abonnements et vente

Presses universitaires de France, 12, rue Jean-de-Beauvais, Paris-S' (033-64-10). France : 50 F ; tranger : 55 F.

Review of the International Statistical Institute

Articles S . A . Rice A . Sauvy B . G . Greenberg T. E. Dalenius, 0 . Frank P. Thionet C . W . J . Granger, H . R . Neave A Naddeo

Contents of Vol. 36, N o . 3 , 1 9 6 8

Toward ' O n e world in statistics' Masculinit des derniers-ns d'une famille et distribution de familles selon les sexes Evaluation of social programs Control of classification Contribution h l'tude des applications statistiques du problme du scrutin A quick test for slippage Confidence intervals for the frequency function and the cumulative frequency function of a sample drawn from a discrete random variable Stochastic competition graphs Statistical organization and administration. Statistical training and research. Statistical societies

O . Frank Communications Calendar of meetings Book reviews

The Review of the ISI is published three times per year. The annual subscription is $11.50 post free. Orders should be sent to: International Statistical Institute. 2 Oostduinlaan, The Hague, Netherlands

LA REVUE DE DROIT INTERNATIONAL

DE SCIENCES DIPLOMATIQUES ET POLITIQUES (THE INTERNATIONAL L A W REVIEW) fonde Genve en 1923 par ANTOINE SOTTTLE
est la S E U L E revue paraissant en Suisse en matire de droit international, de sciences diplomatiques et politiques. Elle prconise la rnovation du droit international, la renaissance de la justice mondiale, la souverainet effective du droit, la solidarit internationale, la morale dans la politique internationale, le dveloppement de l'esprit international, le rglement pacifique des conflits internationaux, la dfense des droits des petits tats pour autant que la soi-disant libert de presse et les devoirs de neutralit le consentent. Paraissant au sige europen de l'Organisation des Nations Unies, la R E V U E D E D R O I T I N T E R N A T I O N A L est m m e de faire rapidement connatre et apprcier avec sret les rgles que stipule la communaut des nations. L a Revue de droit international parat tous les trois mois, en livraisons de 90 135 pages. Les articles sont publis dans la langue de leurs auteurs. Numro spcimen (arrir) contre envoi de 5,90 F S net. A B O N N E M E N T : Union postale, 72,50 F S net. Suisse, 71,50 F S net. Tous les abonnements sont annuels et partent du numro de janvier. Toute c o m m a n d e faite par l'intermdiaire de librairies peut tre augmente de 20 %. (La revue est honore de souscriptions de gouvernements.) Directeur : D ' Juris Antoine Soltile c. d. Envoy extraordinaire et ministre plnipotentiaire, consul, lie. en philos., anc. docent de droit international l'Universit de Genve, m e m b r e de la Socit amricaine de droit international, de l'Association internationale de droit pnal et de l'Acadmie diplomatique internationale.

Rivista Italiana di Scienze Politiche

IL POLITICO
Fondata da Bruno Leoni Direttore: Carlo Emilio Ferri Redattore capo: Pasquale Scaramozzino X X X I I I , N . 2, Giugno 1968 Luigi Bagolini L a crisi dello Stato Charles Aikin T h e role of dissenting opinions in American courts Note e discussioni Marek Sobolewski D e la notion de la souverainet du peuple Carlo Emilio Traverso L a genesi storico-politica della disciplina dei partiti nella costituzione italiana Francesco Trassari Dieci anni di attivit della Corte Costituzionale. Lineamenti del giudizio costituzionale in via incidentale Louis Loss The functioning of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States E. G. West Freedom to m o v e and the propriety of migration controls Sergio Della Pergola Caratteristiche demografiche della minoranza ebraica in Italia Lawrence Whitehead T h e incomes policy in the United Kingdom. T h e Prices and Incomes Board in the first year Joseph S. Roucek Britain's retreat from A d e n and East of Suez Attivit degli istituti Corso di preparazione al concorso per la carriera diplomtica Associazione laureati e studenti di scienze politiche Recensioni

Direzione, redazione, amministrazione : Istituto di Scienze Politiche dell'Universit di Pavia Abbonamento annuo (4 fascicoli) : Italia L . 5 000 ; estero L . 6 500.

Ajournai of Asian demography

Population Review
Vol. n , N o . 2 July-December 1967 Contents Progress of public health in the U . S . S . R . , 1917-1967 S o m e aspects of the family planning programme in India Indonesian attitudes toward birth control Migration streams in India A prospective study of the fertility of a group of married w o m e n in rural Indiadesign and findings of thefirstround of enquiry F r o m the press cuttings Book reviews Publications received

E d . : S. Chandrasekhar

Professor Boris Petrovsky Professor S. Chandrasekhar D r . R . Murray T h o m a s Dr. Ashish Bose K . Srinivasan

Published twice a year by Edited and published by Printed at the

Population Review, P O Box N o . 3030 N e w Delhi 3 D r . S. Chandrasekhar National Printing W o r k s , 10 Daryaganj, Delhi 6

V o l u m e I X N u m b e r 2 April-June 1968

Rassegna Italiana di Sociologa

N u m e r o speciale dedicato alla sociolinguistica A cura di Pier Paolo Giglioli Pier Paolo Giglioli, Introduzione. A. Julien Greimas, Per una sociologa del senso comune. Aaron V. Cicourel, L'acquisizione della struttura sociale. Verso una sociologa evolutiva del linguaggio e del significato. Note e dibattiti Paolo Fabbri, Linguaggio sociolgico e semntica strutturale. Richerche William Labov, II meccanismo dei mutamenti linguistici. Jan-Pelter Blom e John J. Gumperz, Fattori sociali determinanti del comportamento verbale Rassegne Pier Paolo Giglioli, Direzioni di ricerca in sociolinguistica Susan Ervin-Tripp e Dan I. Slobin, Recenti orientamenti in psicolinguistica. Published four times a year by the Societ ditrice il Mulino, Via S . Stefano 6, Bologna (Italy). Annual subscription: Lit. 6 000 or the equivalent in other currencies.

H eft 2 1968

die Verwaltung
Zeltschrift fr Verwaltungswissenschaft Herausgegeben von Ernst Forsthoff, Klaus von der Groeben, Reinhard Koselleck, Franz Mayer, Franz Ronneberger, R o m a n Schnur Zur historischen und gedanklichen Entwicklung der LandesPlanung Der Rechtsschutz der Gemeinden gegen Massnahmen der Staatsaufsicht Geschichte des Siedlungsverbandes Ruhrkohlenbezirk Die Entwicklung der ffentlichen Verwaltung Jugoslawiens. Dargestellt auf d e m Hintergrund der neuen jugoslawischen Gesellschaftsordnung Das Institut der Verwaltungsstrafe im sowjetischen Recht Die Zeitschrift erscheint viermal jhrlich, jedes Heft im U m fang von ca. 128 Seiten. Abonnementspreis halbjhrlich DM36. D U N C K E R (r H U M B L O T / B E R L I N - M N C H E N Hans-Gerhart Niemeier Hans H . Klein Heinz G . Steinberg Lado Vavpetic

Walter Meder

Director : D . r Pablo Gonzlez Casanova Secretario : Lie. Jorge Moreno Collado

Revista Mexicana de Sociologa

Vol. XXX, n. 1,1968 Gino Germani ndice

2.a poca

rgano oficial del Instituto de Investigaciones Sociales de la Universidad Nacional Autnoma de Mxico, 5. piso, Torre de Humanidades, Ciudad Universitaria, Mxico 20, D . F .

Hacia una teora del fascismo. Las Interpretaciones cambiantes del totalitarismo.

MoissGonzlezNavarro El mestizaje mexicano en el perodonacional. Jorge Giusti Manuel MaldonadoDenis Georges Friedmann Jorge Ucros Johan Galtung Alessandro Pizzorno Rasgos organizativos en el poblador marginal urbano latinoamericano. Hacia un esbozo de las oligarquas en el Caribe hispano-parlante. Televisin y democracia cultural. El revolucionarismo en la Universidad Colombiana. Despus del Proyecto Camelot. Sobre el mtodo de Gramsci (De la historiografa a la ciencia poltica). Secciones : Documental y Bibliogrfica

Suscripcin anual : MNS60.00 ; US$5.00 Nmeros atrasados : M N S 2 0 . 0 0 ; US$1.80 Nmeros sueltos (del ao) ; MN$15.00 ; US$1.30

Vol. VIII N.o 3

Revista trimestral publicada por El Colegio de Mxico

Foro internacional
Irving Louis Horowitz : La legitimidad poltica y la institucionalizacin de la crisis en America latina. Robert F . Lamberg : La formacin de la lnea castrista desde la Conferencia Tricontinental. Roque Gonzlez Salazar : Ideologa y economa : la reforma econmica de la U R S S . Francisco Lpez Ortiz : El Mercado C o m n , un reto para America latina. James D . Cochrane : America latina y Europa oriental : algunas notas y estadsticas sobre comercio. William P . Tucher : La representacin de Estados Unidos en Amrica latina. Critica de libros Libros recibidos

Suscripcin anual: U S S5.00 (franqueo incluido). Ejemplar suelto: US$1.25 (franqueo incluido). Coleccin completa : vol. I-VII U S $35.00. Suscripcin y correspondencia a : Foro Internacional, El Colegio de Mxico, Guanajuato 125, Mxico 7, D . F .

Universit libre de Bruxelles Institut de sociologie (fond par Ernest Solvay)

Revue de l'Institut de sociologie

Revue trimestrielle

Science politique, conomie politique, conomie sociale, sociologie du travail,sociologie africaine, psychologie sociale.sociographie, etc. Chronique du m o u v e m e n t scientifique. Notices bibliographiques : notes et documents, comptes rendus critiques. Acquisitions d e la bibliothque. Chronique de l'institut. Informations.
Rdaction Institut de sociologie, 4 4 , avenue Jeanne, Bruxelles 5. Tl. (02) 4 8 81 5 8 Administration et abonnements ditions de l'Institut de sociologie, parc Leopold, Bruxelles 4 . Tl. (02) 3 5 01 86 Abonnement: Belgique: 6 0 0 F B ; autres pays: 7 0 0 F B . Le numro: 2 0 0 F B ; le numro double: 4 0 0 F B

L'Institut royal des relations internationales publie tous les deux mois, sur environ 120 pages

Chronique de politique trangre

Cette revue d'une objectivit et d'une indpendance renommes, assemble et analyse les documents et les dclarations qui sont la base des relations et institutions internationales. Septembre 1966 Novembre 1966 Janvier 1967 Mars 1967 Les accords d'association avec les tats africains et malgache associs. 156 p., 150 F B . La Turquie et ses relations avec l'Union sovitique, 116 p., 150 F B . Congo de janvier 1965 mars 1966. 102 p., 150 F B . La Roumanie et la scurit europenne ; L'Iran et le monde arabe ; L'puration en Rpublique populaire de Chine ; Le soutien australien et no-zlandais la politique amricaine en Asie ; Le protocole de Rio de Janeiro de 1942 : un litige pruano-quatorien latent ; La Confrence des Nations Unies sur le commerce et le dveloppement : deux ans d'activit. 131 p., 150 F B . La Grande-Bretagne, le Canada, la France et le Danemark en 1966. 129 p., 150 F B . La crise de Locarno la lumire des documents diplomatiques belges ; Essai de coopration politique entre les six, 1960-1962, et chec des ngociations pour un statut politique ; Le financement du dveloppement conomique : aspects politiques, juridiques et conomiques ; L'organisation de la dtente : nouvelle tche de l ' O T A N ; La lgislation sociale norvgienne ; La Californie du Sud. 115 p. Les tats-Unis, l'Espagne, l'Algrie et le Maroc en 1966. 137 p., 150 F B . La non-prolifration des armes nuclaires ; Les objectifs du trait de R o m e peuvent-ils encore tre atteints ? ; L'Institut de formation et de recherche des Nations Unies Unitar ; L'intgration europenne et le problme allemand ; L'alliance anglo-portugaise : histoire et situation actuelle ; Les ngociations diplomatiques c o m m e un moyen de rgler les diffrends internationaux ; La Rhodsic ; Le problme de Hong-kong. 148 p., 150 F B . Consciences tribales et nationales en Afrique noire. 1960, 465 p., 400 F B . Fin de la souverainet belge au Congo : documents et rflexions. 1963, 679 p., 400 F B . Le rle prominent du Secrtaire gnral dans l'opration des Nations Unies au Congo. 1964, 249 p., 300 F B . Les consquences d'ordre interne de la participation de la Belgique aux organisations internationales. 1964, 354 p., 400 F B . Payable aux numros de C . C . P . de l'Institut royal des relations internationales, 88, avenue de la Couronne, Bruxelles 5 : Bruxelles : 0.20 ; Paris : 0.03 ; R o m a : 1/35590 ; Kln : 160.180 ; 's-Graven'nage : 82.58 ; Berne : III 19585 ; Kinshasa : C . C . P . B.201 de la Banque du Congo (compte 954.915).

Mai 1967 Juillet 1967

Septembre 1967 Novembre 1967

Autres publications

Abonnement annuel : 500 FB Numro spar ; 150 FB

Revue internationale de recherches et de synthses sociologiques

L ' h o m m e et la socit
N 8 avril, mai, juin 1968 Essais thoriques Jean-Paul Charnay : Tuez les sociologues. Profil prospectif du sociologue. Dbats Table ronde : Pourquoi les tudiants ? Serge Jonas : Problmatique d'une sociologie de la Jacques Berque, Frdric Bon, Emile Bottigelli, crativit. Jean Chesneaux, Bernard Conein, Henri Fournie, Recherehes Christiane Glucksmann, Lucien Goldmann, Serge Maria Isaura Pereira de Queiroz : Mouvements Jonas, Henri Lefebvre, Ren Lourau, Jean-Pierre messianiques dans quelques tribus sud-amricaines. Peter, Jean Pronteau, Jean Sanvoisin, Jean-Marie Vincent, Comptes rendus Herbert Marcuse : L ' h o m m e unidimensionnel Synthses (Emmanuel Hrichon). Henri Lefebvre : L'irruption, de Nanterre au sommet Lon Trotsky : Ecrits militaires. Tome I (Jean Norman Birnbaum : Le colosse qui vacille. Sanvoisin). Enqutes Serge Doubrovsky : Pourquoi la Nouvelle Critique ? Y. L. (professeur au lyce Pasteur) : Le mouvement (Gilbert Tarrab). de mai au lyce Pasteur Neuilly. Stephan Strasser : Phnomnologie et sciences de Gilbert Tarrab : Qu'est-ce que le S. D . S. ? interview l'homme (Andr Jacob). de Karl Dietrich Wolff, prsident du S. D . S. Ramon Losada Aldana : Dialctica del Subdesarollo (Rgine Rodriguez). tudes Camillo Torres : Ecrits et paroles (K. Jaouiche). R. Kalivoda : Marx et Freud. Henri Lefebvre : Le droit la ville (Colette Durand). Andras Hegedus : Contribution l'tude des alterJeanne Hersch et Ren Poirier : Entretiens sur le natives de l'volution sociale. Alessandro Pizzorno : A propos de la mthode de temps (Eddy Treves). Gramsci, de l'historiographie de !a science politique. Martin Kolinski : L'Etat et la classe dominante. H. Wolpe : Structure de classe et ingalit sociale principes thoriques de l'analyse de la stratification sociale. Rodolfo Stavenhagen : Classes sociales et stratification Revue des revues Livres reus. Sommaire

Rdaction, administration, abonnements : Editions Anthropos, 15, rue Racine, Paris-6e. Tl. : D A N . 99-99.

Revue franaise de sociologie

N u m r o spcial double 1 9 6 7 - 1 9 6 8 Sociologie de l'ducation Le n u m r o double : I 5 francs Vol. Hans Zeisel Klaus Liepelt Vladimir N . Choubkine G u y Michelat et J.-P. T h o m a s Haroun Jamous IX, N' I, janvier-mars 1968 L'cole viennoise des recherches de motivation Esquisse d'une typologie des lecteurs allemands et autrichiens Le choix d'une profession. Rsultats d'une enqute sociologique auprs de jeunes de l a rgion de Novosibirsk Contribution l'tude du recrutement des coles d'officiers d e l a marine (I 9 4 5 - 1 9 6 0 ) lments pour une thorie Vol. IX. n' 2, avril-juin sociologique des dcisions politiques

1968

Travaux de l'Institut de sociologie urbaine

Rdaction Abonnement

Centre d'tudes sociologiques, 8 2 , rue Cardinet, Paris-17* ditions du C N R S , 15, quai Anatole France, Paris-7' A b o n n e m e n t : 4 numros trimestriels et I n u m r o spcial France : 3 5 F. tranger : $ 7 (tarif 1969 : respectivement 4 0 F et $ 8 ) . ditions du Centre national de l a recherche scientifique - C C P Paris 9061-1 I

S o m e Unesco publications in thefieldof social sciences

The teaching of the social sciences In higher technical education. A n international survey (The university teaching of social sciences) The object of this volume is to describe representative trends in the teaching of those social sciences which find a place in advanced technical education, whether for engineering itself, or for professions of a technological character such as architecture, town and country planning, and others which have important social and economic ramifications. 1968 165 p. $4.50 23/- 16 F Newspapers and other periodicals; Paper consumption; Film and cinema; Radio broadcasting; Television. Bilingual : English/French 1968 519 p. $20 6 70 F The social sciences: problems and orientations. Selected studies A collection of 32 studies dealing with specialized themes, recent or unpublished research or questions of a multi-disciplinary nature and indicating trends in research and methods. Thefirstsection of the volume is entitled 'Problems and points of view' and the relevant contributions are grouped according to themes around three disciplines: anthropology, economics and sociology. The second section, 'Methods', deals with the theory of systems, models, methods of simulation and comparative and interdisciplinary research. Composite : English/French 1968 507 p . 13 77/- 45 F Co-edition Unesco/Mouton, The Hague. Readings in the economics of education Presented here are the writings of economists, past and present, on the role of education in economic development. T h e y will be of interest to educators, economists and sociologists. The texts have been selected by M a r y Jean B o w m a n (University of Chicago), Michel Debeauvais (University of Paris), V . E . K o m a r o v (Institute of World E c o n o m y , Moscow) and John Vaizey (Oxford University). Composite: English/French 1968 2nd imp. 1968 945 p . $3.50 21/- 12.50 F

Methods of long-term projection of requirements for and supply of qualified manpower, by H . Goldstein and S . Swerdloff (Statistical reports and studies, 12) A number of emerging developments have contributed to a widening interest during the past twenty years in manpower requirement projections, especially for scientific, technical and professional occupations. T h e authors, members of the staff of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, United States Department of Labor, examine the approaches that have been m a d e in thisfieldand explore various methods of projection. 1967 48 p. $1 5/- 3.50 F

Unesco statistical yearbook 1967 Fifth issue, prepared with the co-operation of the national statistical services and the National Commissions for Unesco, and with the help of the Statistical Office and the population Branch of the United Nations. Statistics relate to: Populations; Education; Libraries and m u s e u m s ; Book production;

UNESCO PUBLICATIONS: NATIONAL DISTRIBUTORS

F R A N C E : Librairie de l'Unesco, place de Fontenoy, 75 PARIS-7. C C P 12598-48. F R E N C H W E S T INDIES: Librairie J. Bocage, rue Lavoir, B.P. 208, F O R T - D E - F R A N C E (Martinique). G E R M A N Y ( F E D . R E P . ) : R. Oldenbourg Verlag. Unesco-Ver trieb fr Deutschland, RosenheimerA U S T R I A : Verlag Georg Fromme & co., Spengerstrasse 145, M N C H E N 8. gasse 39, W I E N 5. G H A N A : Methodist Book Depot Ltd., Atlantis House, B E L G I U M : All publications: Editions 'Labor', 342 rue Commercial Street, P . O . Box 100, C A P E C O A S T . Royale, B R U X E L L E S 3; N . V . Standaard. WetensG R E E C E : Librairie H . Kauffmanii, 28, rue du Stade, chappelijke Uitgeverij, Belgilei 147, A N T W E R P E N I. Librairie Eleftheroudakis, Nikkis 4, For 'The Courier' and slides only: Jean De Lannoy, A T H E N A I ; 112, rue du Trne, B R U X E L L E S 5. ATHENAI. BOLIVIA: Comisin Nacional Boliviana de la Unesco, G U A T E M A L A : Comisin Nacional de la Unesco, Ministerio de Educacin y Cultura, casilla de correo 6. calle 9.27, zona 1, G U A T E M A L A . n 4107, L A P A Z . Librera Universitaria, Universidad HAITI: Librairie 'A la Caravelle*, 36, rue Roux, B . P . ni, San Francisco Xavier, apartado 212, S U C R E . B R A Z I L : Fundaao Getlio Vargas, 186 praia de Botafogo, Ro D E J A N E I R O , G B zc-02. B U L G A R I A : Raznoznos, 1 Tzar Assen, SOFIA. C A M B O D I A : Librairie Albert Portail, 14, avenue Boulloche, P H N O M - P E N H . CAMEROON: Papeterie moderne, Maller et C l e ,
PORT-AU-PRINCE.

A F G H A N I S T A N : Panuzai, Press Department, Royal Afghan Ministry of Education, K A B U L . A L B A N I A : N . Sh. Botiraeve Nairn Frasheri, T I R A N A . A L G E R I A : Institut pdagogique national, n , rue Ali-Haddas (ex-rue Zatcha), A L G E R . A R G E N T I N A : Editorial Sudamericana S.A., H u m berto I - 545, T . E . 30.7518, B U E N O S AIRES. A U S T R A L I A : Retail: Dominie Pty. Ltd., Box 33, Post Office, Brookvale 2100, N . S . W . Wholesale: Educational Supplies Pty. Ltd., Box 33, Post Office, Brookvale 2100, N . S . W . Sub-agent: United Nations Association of Australia, Victorian Division, 4th Floor, Askew House, 364 Lonsdalo Street, M E L B O U R N E (Victoria) 3000.

E L S A L V A D O R : Librera Cultural Salvadorea, S.A., Edificio San Martin, 6.* calle Oriente n. 118, S A N
SALVADOR.

E T H I O P I A : International Press Agency, P . O . Box 120,

ADDIS ABABA.

F I N L A N D : Akateeminen Kirjakauppa, 2 Keskuskatu,

HELSINKI.

H O N D U R A S : Librera Cultura, apartado postal 568,

TEGUCIGALPA D.C.

H O N G K O N G : Swindon Book Co., 64 Nathan Road,

KOWLOON.

H U N G A R Y : Akadmiai Knyvesbolt, Vci u. 22, B U D A P E S T V ; A . K . V . Konyvtrosok Boltja, NpkozB . P . 495, YAOUNDE. trsasg utja 16, B U D A P E S T VI. I C E L A N D : Snaebjrn Jonsson & Co., H . F . , HafnarC A N A D A : The Queen's Printer, O T T A W A (Ont.). straeti 9, R E Y K J A V I K . C E Y L O N : Lake House Bookshop, Sir Chittampalam INDIA: Orient Longmans Ltd.: Nicol Road, Ballard Gardiner Mawata, P . O . Box 244, C O L O M B O 2. Estate, B O M B A Y I; 17 Chittaranjan Ave., C A L C U T T A 13; C H I L E : All publications. Editorial Universitaria S . A . , 36A Mount Road, M A D R A S 2; 3/5 Asaf Ali Road, casilla 10220, SANTIAGO. For 'The Courier' only: N E W D E L H I I. Comisin Nacional de la Unesco, Mac-Iver 764, Sub-depots: Oxford Book and Stationery Co., 17 Park dpto. 63, SANTIAGO. Street, C A L C U T T A 16, and Scindia House, N E W D E L H I ; C H I N A : The World Book Co. Ltd., 99 Chungking Indian National Commission for Unesco, att.: The South Road, Section 1, T A I P E H (Taiwan/Formosa). Librarian, Ministry of Education, ' C Wing, R o o m no. 214, Shastri Bhawan, N E W D E L H I I. C O L O M B I A : Librera Buchholz Galera, avenida JimI R A N : Commission nationale iranienne pour l'Unesco, nez de Quesada 8-40, B O G O T A ; Ediciones Tercer avenue du Muse, T H R A N . Mundo, apartado areo 4817, B O G O T A ; Distrilibros Ltd., IRAQ: McKenzie's Bookshop, Al-Rashid Street, Pi Alfonso Garca, carrera 4*, n.OB 36-119 y 36-125, B AGHDAD; University Bookstore, University of C A R T A G E N A ; J. Germn Rodriguez N . , oficina 201, Baghdad, P . O . Box 75, B A G H D A D . Edificio Banco de Bogot, apartado nacional 83, G I R A R D O T , C U N D I N A M A R G A ; Librera Universitaria, I R E L A N D : The National Press, 2 Wellington Road, Universidad Pedaggica de Colombia, T U N J A . Ballsbridge, D U B L I N 4. C O N G O (Democratic Republic of the): La Librairie, I S R A E L : Emanuel Brown, formerly Blumstein's BookInstitut politique congolais, B , P . 2307, K I N S H A S A . stores, 35 Allenby Road, and 48 Nahlat Benjamin Street, T E L A V I V . C O S T A RICA: AU publications. Librera Trejos, S.A., apartado 1313, telfonos 2285 y 3200, S A N JOS. I T A L Y : Librera Commissi onar i a Sansoni S.p.A., via For 'The Courier' only: Carlos Valerin Senz & Co. Lamarmora 45, casella postale 552. 50121, F I R E N Z E ; Ltda., 'El Palacio de las Revistas', apartado 1294, S A N Librera Internazionale Rizzoli, Galeria Colonna, JOS. Largo Chighi, R O M A ; Librera Zanichelli, piazza Galvani, i/h, B O L O G N A ; Hoepli, via Ulrico Hoepli 5, C U B A : Instituto del Libro, Departamento Econmico, MILANO; Librairie franaise, piazza Castetlo < * , Ermita y San Pedro, Cerro, L A H A B A N A . T O R I N O ; Diffusione Edizioni Anglo-Americane. via C Y P R U S : ' M A M ' , Archbishop M a karis 3rd Avenue, Lima 28, 00198 R O M A . P . O . B . 1722, NICOSIA. C Z E C H O S L O V A K I A : S N T L , Spalena 51, P R A H A I I V O R Y C O A S T : Centre d'dition et de diffusion afri(Permanent display); Zahranicni literatura, n Soukecaines, bote postale 4541, A B I D J A N P L A T E A U . nicka, P R A H A I. J A M A I C A : Sangster's Book Stores Ltd., P . O . Box 366, D E N M A R K : Ejnar Munksgaard Ltd., 6, Norregade, 101 Water Lane, K I N G S T O N .
1x65 K O B E N H A V N K.

D O M I N I C A N R E P U B L I C : Librera Dominicana, Mercedes 49, apartado de correos 656, S A N T O D O M I N G O . E C U A D O R : Casa de la Cultura Ecuatoriana, Ncleo del Guayas, Pedro Moncayo y 9 de Octubre, casilla de correo 3542, G U A Y A Q U I L .

J A P A N : Maruzen Co. Ltd., 6 Tori-Nichome, Nihonbashi. P.O. Box 605, Tokyo Central, T O K Y O . J O R D A N : Joseph I. Bahous & Co., Dar-ul Kutub, Salt Road. P . O . Box 66, A M M A N . K E N Y A : E S A Bookshop P . O . Box 30167, N A I R O B I .

KOREA:
P.O.

Korean

National Commission f o r Unesco,

PHILIPPINES: POLAND:

The

Modern Book

Co., 928

Riza

Box 64, S E O U L .

Avenue, P . O . Box 632, M A N I L A . Osrodek, Rozpowszechniania Wydawnictw Naukowych P A N , Palac Kultury i Nauki, W A R S Z A W A . P O R T U G A L : Dias & Andra de Lda., Livraria Portugal, rua do Carino 70, LISBOA. P U E R T O R I C O : Spanish English Publications, Eleanor Roosevelt 115, apartado 1912, H A T O R E Y . SOUTHERN R H O D E S I A : Textbook Sales (PTV), Ltd., 67 Union Avenue, S A L I S B U R Y . R O M A N I A : Cartimex, P . O . Box 134-135, 126 calea Victorici, B U C U R E S T I . (Telex: 226.) SENEGAL: DAKAR. La Maison du Livre, 13, avenue Roume,

K U W A I T : The Kuwait Bookshop Co. Ltd., P . O . Box 2942, K U W A I T . L E B A N O N : Librairies Antoine, A . Naubal et Frres,
B.P. 656, BEYROUTH.

L I B E R I A : Cole & Yancy Bookshops Ltd., P . O . Box 286,

MONROVIA.

L I B Y A : Orient Bookshop, P . O . Box 255, TRIPOLI. LIECHTENSTEIN: SCHAAN. LUXEMBOURG. Eurocan Trust Reg., P . O . B . 5

LUXEMBOURG: L i b r a i r i e Paul Brck, 22 Grand-Rue.

MADAGASCAR: All publications. Commission natioSINGAPORE: See Malaysia. nale de la Rpublique malgache. Ministre de l'ducation nationale, T A N A N A R I V E . For 'The Courier' only: Service des uvres post et pri-scolaires, Ministre de l'ducation nationale, T A N A N A R I V E . M A L A Y S I A : Federal Publications Berhad, Times House, River Valley Road, S I N G A P O R E 9. Pud Building (3rdfloor),n o Jalan Pud, K U A L A L U M P U R . M A L I : Librairie populaire du Mali, B . P . 28, B A M A K O MALTA:Sapienza's Library, 26 Kingsway, V A L L E T T A . M A U R I T I U S : Nalanda Co. Ltd.,
PORT-LOUIS.

S O U T H A F R I C A : Van Scnaik's Bookstore (Pty) Ltd., Libri Building, Church Street, P . O . Box 724, P R E
TORIA.

S P A I N : All publications. Librera Cientfica Medinaceli, Duque de Medinaceli 4, M A D R I D 14. For 'The Courier' only: Ediciones Iberoamericanas S.A., calle de Oate 15, M A D R I D . S U D A N : Al Bashir Bookshop, P . O . Box 1118. K H A R TOUM. S W E D E N : All publications. A / B C . E . Fritzes Kungl. Hovbokhandel, Fredsgatan 2, S T O C K H O L M 16. For 'The Courier' only: The United Nations Association of Sweden, Vasagatan 15-17, S T O C K H O L M C . SWITZERLAND: Europa Verlag, Rmistrasse 5, Z R I C H ; Librairie Payot, 6, rue Grenus, 1211, G E N V E

30 Bourbon Street, Marisca 41,

MEXICO:

Editorial

Hermes,

Ignacio

MXICO D.F.

M O N A C O : British Library, 30, boulevard des Moulins,

MONTE-CARLO.

11. M O R O C C O : AU publications. Librairie ' A u x belles SYRIA : L i b r a i r i e Sayegh, Immeuble Diab, rue du images', 281, avenue M o h a m m e d V , R A B A T (CCP Qt 1 68-74). F 'The Courier {for teachers) only: C o m - Parlement, B.P. 704, D A M A S . mission nationale marocaine pour l'Unesco, 20, Zenkat TANZANIA: Dar es Salaam Bookshop, P.O. Box 9030, Mourabitine, R A B A T . (CCP 307-63.) D A R ES SALAAM. M O Z A M B I Q U E : Salema and Carvalho Ltda., caixa THAILAND: Suksapan Panit, Mansion 9, Rajdamnern postal 192, B E I R A . Avenue, B A N G K O K . NETHERLANDS: N . V . Martinus Nijhoff, Lange Voorhout 9, ' S - G R A V E N H A G E . N E T H E R L A N D S A N T I L L E S : G . C. T . Van Dorp and Co. (Ned. Ant.) N . V . , W I L L E M S T A D (Curaao, N.A.). N E W C A L E D O N I A : Ieprex, avenue de la Victoire, Immeuble Painbouc, N O U M A . TUNISIA: Socit tunisienne de diffusion, 5, avenue de Carthage, T U N I S . TURKEY: Librairie Hachette, 469 Istiklal Caddesi, Beyoglu, I S T A N B U L .

U G A N D A : Uganda Bookshop, P . O . Box 145, K A M P A L A . U N I T E D A R A B R E P U B L I C : Librairie Kasr El Nil, 38, rue Kasr El Nil, C A I R O . Sub-depot: La Renaissance d'Egypte, 9 Sh. Adly Pasha, C A I R O (Egypt). U N I T E D K I N G D O M : H . M . Stationery Office, P . O . Box 569, L O N D O N S . E . I ; Government bookshops, London, Belfast, Birmingham, Cardiff, Edinburgh, Manchester. U N I T E D S T A T E S O F A M E R I C A : Unesco PubliN I C A R A G U A : Librera Cultural Nicaragense, calle cations Center (NAIP), 317 East 34th St., N E W 15 de Septiembre y avenida Bolivar, apartado n. 807, Y O R K , N . Y . 10016. MANAGUA. U R U G U A Y : Editorial Losada Uruguaya, S.A., Mado nado 1902, M O N T E V I D E O . Telfono 8-75-71. N O R W A Y : All publications. A . S . Bokhjornet, Akersgt. 41, O S L O I. For 'The Courier' only: A . S . Narvesens U . S . S . R . : Mezhdunarodnaja Kniga, M O S K V A G-200. Litteraturjeneste, Box 6125, O S L O . V E N E Z U E L A : Distribuidora de Publicaciones Venezolanas Dipuven, avenida Libertador, dif. La Linea, P A K I S T A N : The West-Pak Publishing Co. Ltd., local, A , apartado de correos 10440, C A R A C A S . Tel.: Unesco Publications House, P . O . Box 374. G . P . O . , 72.06.70-72.69.45. L A H O R E . Showrooms: Urdu Bazaar, L A H O R E ; and N E W Z E A L A N D : Government Printing Office, Government Bookshops: Rutland Stieet P . O . Box 5344i A U C K L A N D ; 130 Oxford Terrace, P . O . Box 1721, C H R I S T C H U R C H ; Alma Street, P . O . Box 857 H A M I L T O N ; Princes Street, P . O . Box 1104, D U N E D I N ; Mulgrave Stieet, Private Bag, W E L L I N G T O N . 57-58 Murree Highway, G/6-I, I S L A M A B A D . PARAGUAY: AsuNcin. Melchor Garca, Eligi Ayala 1650, VIET-NAM (REPUBLIC O F ) : Librairie-papeterie Xun-Thu, 185-193 rue Tu-Do, B . P . 283, S A I G O N . Y U G O S L A V I A : Jugoslovenska Knjiga, Terazije 27, B E O G R A D ; Drzavna Zaluzba Slovenje, Mestni Trg.
26, LJUBLJANA.

P E R U : Distribuidora I N C A S . A . , Emilio Althaus 470, apartado 3115, L I M A .

UNESCO

COUPONS

Unesco Book Coupons can be used to purchase all books and periodicals of an educational, scientific or cultural character. For f u l l information please write to: Unesco Coupon Office, Place de Fontenoy, 75 Paris-7*. France. [76]

In the preparation of certain issues and the compilation of some of its regular features the International Social Science Journal collaborates with the following organizations: International Association of Legal Science International Committee for Social Sciences Documentation International Economic Association International Political Science Association International Sociological Association International Social Science Council International U n i o n of Psychological Science International Union for the Scientific Study of Population W o r l d Association for Public Opinion Research ( W A P O R )

Selected articles from this Journal are also appearing in Spanish in Amrica Latina, the quarterly review of the Latin American Centre for Research in the Social Sciences (Rio de Janeiro)

Price and subscription rates [A] Single issue: $2; 12/- (stg.); 7 F Yearly subscription: $7; 41/- (stg.); 24 F A n y of the distributors listed will be pleased to accept subscriptions; rates in currencies other than the above will be supplied on application to the distributor in the country concerned. W h e n notifying change of address please enclose last wrapper or envelope.

SHC.68/1.85/A

Printed in France by Imp. Crete, Paris