B.F. by S.K As at 5 May 2005
B.F. by S.K As at 5 May 2005
B.F. by S.K As at 5 May 2005
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We gratefully acknowledge permission to quote from the past examination papers of the
following bodies: Kenya Accountants and Secretaries National Eamination !oard
"KASNE!#$ C%artered &nstitute o' Management Accountants "C&MA#$ Association
o' C%artered Certi'ied Accountants "ACCA#(
We also wish to express our sincere gratitude and deep appreciation to Mr( Geo''rey
Ngene M!A) !(COM "*inance#) C+A "'inalist#) C*A "East A'rica#( He is a senior
lecturer at Strathmore University, School of ccountancy! He has generously given his
time and expertise and skilfully co"ordinated the detailed effort of reviewing this study
pack!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
&nstruction 'or Student iii
&NST,.CT&ON *O, ST.DENTS
#his study guide is intended to assist distance"learning students in their independent studies! $n
addition, it is only for the personal use of the purchaser, see copyright clause! #he course has
been broken down into eight lessons each of which should be considered as approximately one
week of study for a full time student! Solve the reinforcement problems verifying your answer
with the suggested solution contained at the back of the distance learning pack! When the
lesson is completed, repeat the same procedure for each of the following lessons!
t the end of lessons %, &, ' and ( there is a comprehensive assignment that you should
complete and submit for marking to the distance learning administrator!
S.!M&SS&ON +,OCED.,E
)! fter you have completed a comprehensive assignment clearly identify each question
and number your pages!
%! $f you do not understand a portion of the course content or an assignment question
indicate this in your answer so that your marker can respond to your problem areas! *e
as specific as possible!
+! rrange the order of your pages by question number and fix them securely to the data
sheet provided! dequate postage must be affixed to the envelope!
&! While waiting for your assignment to be marked and returned to you, continue to work
through the next two lessons and the corresponding reinforcement problems and
comprehensive assignment!
,n the completion of the last comprehensive assignment a two"week period of revision should
be carried out of the whole course using the material in the revision section of the study pack!
t the completion of this period the final -ock .xamination paper should be completed under
examination conditions! #his should be sent to the distance"learning administrator to arrive in
/airobi at least five weeks before the date of your sitting the 0S/.* .xaminations! #his
paper will be marked and posted back to you within two weeks of receipt by the 1istance
2earning dministrator
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
i2
CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((ii
&NST,.CT&ON *O, ST.DENTS((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((iii
CONTENTS((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((i2
!.S&NESS *&NANCE CO.,SE DES,&+T&ON(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((2
!.S&NESS *&NANCE &NDE3(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((2i
LESSON ONE(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((4
/#U3. ,4 *US$/.SS 4$//5.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)
LESSON TWO((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((55
S,U35.S ,4 4U/1S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%%
LESSON T-,EE((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((66
-.SU3$/6 *US$/.SS 7.34,3-/5.: 4$//5$2 S##.-./#S
/28S$S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!&&
LESSON *O.,(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((78
57$#2 S#3U5#U3. /1 5,S# ,4 4U/1S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'9
LESSON *&/E(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((94
57$#2 $/:.S#-./# 1.5$S$,/S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!;)
LESSON S&3(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((44:
:2U#$,/ 5,/5.7#S $/ 4$//5.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!))<
LESSON SE/EN(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((45;
1$:$1./1 7,2$5$.S /1 1.5$S$,/S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)%(
LESSON E&G-T(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((468
W,30$/6 57$#2 -/6.-./#!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)&9
LESSON N&NE((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((479
-30.# 4,3 4U/1S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)';
LESSON TEN((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((499
3.:$S$,/ $1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!);;
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
!usiness *inance Course Descri<tion 2
!.S&NESS *&NANCE CO.,SE DES,&+T&ON
*usiness 4inance is an introductory course in finance a pre"requisite for financial -anagement
of section six finance managers makes four crucial decisions of the firm
4inancing decision concened with the sources of funds, cost of capital, mix of various
capital components and evaluation of capital markets for long and short term financing
$nvestment in long"term investment decisions involving derivation of future cashflows
and appraising pro=ects and how securities of the firm may be valued
Working capital management which involves management of current assets to meet
short termliquidity needs of the firm
1ivisions of earnings between payment of dividends and retention for the purpose of
financing future pro=ects!
*usiness 4inance course explore these four main decisions under conditions of certainty this is
in addition to evaluating the performance of the firm using ratio analysis !*asic tools of finance
are also introduced at this level!
#he overall place of the course in 5!7! Syllabus is a bridge between accounting and 4inance
functions within the organi>ation before critical evaluation of finance under condition of
uncertainty in financial management!
$t also gives an overview of how various stakeholders of the firm have divergent ob=ectives
which impact on the goal of shareholders wealth maxmisation this is covered
Under agency theory!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
2i !usiness *inance &nde
!.S&NESS *&NANCE &NDE3
2.SS,/ ): /ature of *usiness 4inance
3einforcing ?uestions
2.SS,/ %: Sources of 4unds
3einforcing ?uestions
5omprehensive ssignment )
2.SS,/ +: -easuring *usiness 7erformance: 4inancial Statements nalysis
3einforcing ?uestions
2.SS,/ &: 5apital Structure and 5ost of 4unds
3einforcing ?uestions
5omprehensive ssignment %
2.SS,/ 9: 5apital $nvestment 1ecisions
3einforcing ?uestions
2.SS,/ ': :aluation 5oncepts in 4inance
3einforcing ?uestions
2.SS,/ <: 1ividend 7olicies and 1ecisions
3einforcing ?uestions
5omprehensive ssignment +
2.SS,/ (: Working 5apital -anagement
3einforcing ?uestions
2.SS,/ ;: -arket for 4unds
3einforcing ?uestions
5omprehensive ssignment &
2.SS,/ )@: 3evision id: 0S/.* Syllabus! -odel answers to reinforcing questions!
Selected
past papers with model answers! Work through model answers ensuring they are
understood! ,n completion submit final assignment to the University!
*&NAL ASS&GNMENT
-ock .xamination 7aper
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson One 4
LESSON ONE
NAT.,E O* !.S&NESS *&NANCE
&NST,.CT&ONS
3ead 5hapter ) of 4inancial -anagement textbook by $!-! 7andey!
5omplete answers to rein'orcement questions at the end of the lesson!
5heck model answers given in lesson )@ of the study pack!
3einforcing 5omments
CONTENTS
3elationship between business finance and financial management!
Scope of 4inance functions!
6oalsA,b=ectives of the firm!
gency theory!
3isk"return #rade off!
#ypes of business organi>ation
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5 Nature o' !usiness *inance
,ELAT&ONS-&+ !ETWEEN !.S&NESS *&NANCE AND *&NANC&AL
MANAGEMENT
DE*&N&T&ON=
*usiness finance is the process by which a financial managerAaccountant provides finance for
business use as and when it is needed! #his provision has to be undertaken on the basis of the
needs of a company! ,n the other hand, 4inancial -anagement is a branch of economies
concerned with the generation and allocation of scarce resources to the most efficient user
within the economy Bor the firmC! #he allocation of these resources is done through a market
pricing system! firm requires resources in form of funds raised from investors! #he funds
must be allocated within the organisation to pro=ects that will yield the highest return!
4( Needs Conse>uent on t%e O<erations o' a Com<any "!asic Needs#
#hese have to be financed in so far as they arise out of the companyDs operations e!g! salaries!
5( S%ortages o' Cas% !roug%t A?out !y .n'oreseea?le Circumstances E(G Non
+ayment !y De?tors
#hese needs have to be financed by short term finances e!g! overdrafts, but this may be
against financial prudence rather such needs should be financed by revolving finances in the
circular flow! However, the financial manager must manage his finances using such tools as:
5ash budget E statement of expected receipts and payments over a pro=ected period
of time E a forecast!
4unds flow statement E BctualC!
:ariance between actual funds flow with cash budget! #he variance must be managed to
keep the company liquid! ,n the other hand a financial manager has to meet the companyDs
strategicAlong term needs Blong term investmentC are useful to the company because:
)! $t influences the company si>e BassetsC
%! $t influences its growth Bplough backC
+! 4inances incidental needs!
&! $t influences the companyDs long"term survival E this is through continuous
investment!
#hese investments will call for long term financing in form of owners finance B,rdinary
Share 5apital and 3evenue reservesC! #his is a base on which other finances are raised! #he
company will also use external financing e!g! debts, loans, debentures, mortgages, lease
finance etc! #hese finances have to be used in acceptableAreasonable financial mix! #his
implies that the companyDs gearing level is kept low i!e! the relationship between owners and
creditors finance! #his should be below '<F otherwise the company may be forced into
receivership and subsequently liquidation! .ven then, when using creditors finances a
company must consider:
)! #hat cost of finance is less than the 3eturn which implies the rate should not be less
than the bank interest G inflation G risk!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson One @
%! .conomic conditions prevailing E use debt under boom conditions!
+! 7resent gearing E if high this will lead to:
&! 2ow credit rating
9! 2owering of the companyDs share prices especially to less than 7ar value E this leads
to mass sale of shares E creditors rush to draw their finances and therefore
receivership!
'! 2ong term ventures have to call for independent feasibility studies before funds are
committed i!e!
<! ssessment of the return E at least should be greater than minimum return G risk G
inflation!
(! .conomic life E if uncertain, the return ought to be higher! Such life must allow the
company to pay off the loan!
#he financial manager must be guided by principles of financial prudence i!e!
)! He has to consult experts!
%! He has to involve investment committee
+! He has to ascertain whether everyone involved in the implementation of the venture
has not been left out either during the planning phase or implementation phase!
SCO+E O* *&NANCE *.NCT&ONS
#he functions of 4inancial -anager can broadly be divided into two: #he 3outine functions
and the
-anagerial 4unctions!
Managerial *inance *unctions
3equire skilful planning, control and execution of financial activities! #here are four
important managerial finance functions! #hese are:
a# &n2estment o' LongAterm assetAmi decisions
#hese decisions Balso referred to as capital budgeting decisionsC relates to the allocation of
funds among investment pro=ects! #hey refer to the firmDs decision to commit current funds
to the purchase of fixed assets in expectation of future cash inflows from these pro=ects!
$nvestment proposals are evaluated in terms of both risk and expected return!
$nvestment decisions also relates to recommitting funds when an old asset becomes less
productive! #his is referred to as replacement decision!
?# *inancing decisions
4inancing decision refers to the decision on the sources of funds to finance investment
pro=ects! #he finance manager must decide the proportion of equity and debt! #he mix of
debt and equity affects the firmDs cost of financing as well as the financial risk! #his will
further be discussed under the risk return trade"off!
c# Di2ision o' earnings decision
#he finance manager must decide whether the firm should distribute all profits to the
shareholders, retain them, or distribute a portion and retain a portion! #he earnings must also
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
6 Nature o' !usiness *inance
be distributed to other providers of funds such as preference shareholder, and debt providers
of funds such as preference shareholders and debt providers! #he firmDs dividend policy may
influence the determination of the value of the firm and therefore the finance manager must
decide the optimum dividend E payout ratio so as to maximise the value of the firm!
d# Li>uidity decision
#he firmDs liquidity refers to its ability to meet its current obligations as and when they fall
due! $t can also be referred to as current assets management! $nvestment in current assets
affects the firmDs liquidity, profitability and risk! #he more current assets a firm has, the
more liquid it is! #his implies that the firm has a lower risk of becoming insolvent but since
current assets are non"earning assets the profitability of the firm will be low! #he converse
will hold true!
#he finance manager should develop sound techniques of managing current assets to ensure
that neither insufficient nor unnecessary funds are invested in current assets!
,outine 'unctions
4or the effective execution of the managerial finance functions, routine functions have to be
performed! #hese decisions concern procedures and systems and involve a lot of paper work
and time! $n most cases these decisions are delegated to =unior staff in the organi>ation!
Some of the important routine functions are:
aC Supervision of cash receipts and payments
bC Safeguarding of cash balance
cC 5ustody and safeguarding of important documents
dC 3ecord keeping and reporting
#he finance manager will be involved with the managerial functions while the routine
functions will be carried out by =unior staff in the firm! He must however, supervise the
activities of these =unior staff!
T-E O!BECT&/ESCGOALS O* A !.S&NESS
4! +ro'it maimiDation E #his is a traditional and a cardinal ob=ective of a business! #his is
so for the following reasons:
#o earn acceptable returns to its owners! (i.e. Must not be less than bank rates +
inflation + risk)
So as to survive Bthrough plough backsC
#o meet its day to day obligations!
5! To maimiDe t%e net wort% i!e! the difference between total assets and total liabilities!
#his is important because:
$t influences companyDs share prices!
$t facilitates growth Bplough backsC!
$t boosts the companyDs credit rating!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson One 8
#his is what owners claim from the company!
@( To maimiDe wel'are o' em<loyees E Happy employees will contribute to the
profitability! #his includes:
3easonable salaries
#ransport facilities
-edical facilities for the employee and his family
3ecreation facilities Bsporting facilitiesC!
6( &nterests o' customers E the company has to provide quality goods at fair prices and have
honest dealings with customers!
8( Wel'are o' t%e society E the company has to maintain sound industrial relations with the
society:
void pollution
5ontribution to social causes e!g! Harambee contributions, building clinics etc!
7( *air dealing wit% su<<liers! company must:
@
@
)
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
:7 Ca<ital Structure and Cost o'
*unds
bC 5ost of perpetual preference share capital B0pC
3ecall, value of a preference share B43SC I 5onstant 17S
0p
#herefore: dp I 7reference dividend per share
7p I -arket price of a preference share
cC 5ost of perpetual debenture B0dC E 1ebentures pay interest charges, which an
allowable expenses for tax purposes!
3ecall, :alue of a debenture B:dC I $nterest charges p!a! in W
5ost of debt 0d
#herefore 0d I
( ) T
V
Int
d
)
!
Where: 0d I F cost of debt
# I 5orporate tax rate
:d I -arket value of a debenture
Cost o' ,edeema?le De?entures and +re'erence S%ares
3edeemable fixed return securities have a definite maturity period! #he cost of such
securities is called yield to maturity B8#-C or redemption yield B38C! 4or a redeemable
debenture 0d Bcost of debtC I 8#- I 38, can be determined using approximation method as
follows:
( ) ( )
( )
%
)
)
)
A A
d
d
d
V M
n
V M T Int
RY VTM K
+
+
+
,
_
+
,
_
V
D
T K
V
P
K
V
E
K
d p e
)
Where: 0e, 0p and 0d I 7ercentage cost of equity, preference share capital and debt capital
respectively
., 7 and 1 I -arket value of equity, preference share capital and debt capital
respectively!
/*: -arket value I -arket price of a security x /o! of securities!
: I #otal market value of the firm I . G 7 G 1!
&llustration
#he following is the capital structure of P8Q 2td as at +)A)%A%@@%!
,rdinary share capital Sh!)@ par value
3etained earnings
)@F preference share capital Sh!%@ par value
)%F debenture Sh!)@@ par value
Shs!-
&@@
%@@
)@@
%@@
;@@
Additional in'ormation
)! 5orporate tax rate is +@F
%! 7reference shares were issued )@ years ago and are still selling at par value -7S I
7ar value
+! #he debenture has a )@ year maturity period! $t is currently selling at Sh!;@ in the
market!
&! 5urrently the firm has been paying dividend per share of Sh!9! #he 17S is expected
to grow at 9F p!a! in future! #he current -7S is Sh!&@!
,e>uired
aC 1etermine the W55 of the firm!
bC .xplain why market values and not book values are used to determine the weights!
cC What are the weaknesses associated with W55 when used as the discounting rate,
in pro=ect appraisal!
a# i# Com<ute t%e cost o' eac% ca<ital com<onent
5ost of equity B0eC E Since the growth rate in dividends is given, use the constant
growth rate dividend model to determine the cost of equity!
d@ I Sh!9 7@ I Sh!&@ g I 9F
( ) ( )
F )+ ! )( )()%9 ! @ @9 ! @
&@
@9 ! @ ) 9 )
@
@
+
+
+
+
g
P
g d
K
e
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
:; Ca<ital Structure and Cost o'
*unds
5ost of perpetual preference share capital B0pC E preference shares are still selling at
par thus -7S I par value! $f this is the case, 0p I coupon rate I )@F!
-7S I 7ar value I Sh!%@
1p I )@F x Sh!%@ I Sh!%
F )@
%@ !
% !
Sh
Sh
P
d
MPS
DPS
K
p
p
p
5ost of debentures B0dC E the debenture has a )@ year maturity period! $t is thus a
redeemable fixed return security thus the cost of debt is equal to yield to maturity!
3edemption yield:
$nterest charges p!a! I )%F x Sh!)@@ par value
-aturity period BnC
-aturity value BmC
5urrent market value B:dC
5orporate tax rate B#C
I Sh!)%
I )@ years
I Sh!)@@
I Sh!;@
I +@F
( ) ( )
( )R
)
)
d
d
d
V M
n
V M T Int
RY YTM K
+
+
I
F )@ F ; ! ;
CR ;@ )@@ B
)@
)
C ;@ )@@ B C + ! @ ) B )% !
+
+ Sh
ii# Com<ute t%e market 2alue o' eac% ca<ital com<onent
-arket value of .quity B.C I -7S x /o! of ordinary shares
I
parvalue Sh
MDSC Sh
x Sh
)@ !
&@@ !
&@ !
I ),'@@
-arket value of preference share capital B7C
I 7ar value, since -7S I 7ar value per share I )@@
-arket value of debt B1C I :d x /o! of debentures
I
parvalue Sh
s Mdebenture Sh
x Sh
)@@ !
%@@ !
;@ !
I )(@
. G 7 G 1 I : I total -arket :alue I ),((@
iiiC 5ompute W!!5!5 using 0e I )(!)+F, 0p I )@F, 0dB)"#C I )@F
aC Using weighted average cost method,, W55 I
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
:9 Lesson *our
I
( )
,
_
+
,
_
+
,
_
V
D
T K
V
P
K
V
E
K
d p e
)
I
,
_
,
_
,
_
((@ , )
)(@
F )@
((@ , )
)@@
F )@
((@ , )
'@@ , )
F )+ ! )(
I )9!&+ G @!9+); G @!;9<&
I @!)';);+
X )'!;%F
bC *y using percentage method,
W55 I #otal monetary cost
#otal market value B:C
Where: -onetary cost I F cost x market value of capital
-onetary cost of . I )(!)+F x ),'@@ I %;@!@(
-onetary cost of 7 I )@F x )@@ I )@!@@
-onetary cost of 1 I )@F x )(@ I )(!@@
+)(!@(
#otal market value B:C ),((@
#herefore W55 I
)@@
((@ , )
@( ! +)(
x
I )'!;%F
bC $n computation of the weights or proportions of various capital components, the
following values may be used:
-arket values
*ook values
3eplacement values
$ntrinsic values
Market /alue E #his involves determining the weights or proportions using the current
market values of the various capital components! #he problems with the use of market values
are:
#he market value of each security keep on changing on daily basis thus market values can be
computed only at one point in time!
#he market value of each security may be incorrect due to cases of over or under valuation in
the market!
!ook 2alues E #his involves the use of the par value of capital as shown in the balance sheet!
#he main problem with book values is that they are historicalApast values indicating the value
of a security when it was originally sold in the market for the first time!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
;I Ca<ital Structure and Cost o'
*unds
,e<lacement 2alues E #his involves determining the weights or proportions on the basis of
amount that can be paid to replace the existing assets! #he problem with replacement values
is that assets can never be replaced at ago and replacement values may not be ob=ectively
determined!
&ntrinsic 2alues E $n this case the weights are determine on the basis of the realAintrinsic
value of a given security! $ntrinsic values may not be accurate since they are computed using
historicalApast information and are usually estimates!
e# Weaknesses o' WACC as a discounting rate
W55A,verall cost of capital has the following problems as a discounting rate:
$t can only be used as a discounting rate assuming that the risk of the pro=ect is equal to
the business risk of the firm! $f the pro=ect has higher risk then a percentage premium
will be added to W55 to determine the appropriate discounting rate!
$t assumes that capital structure is optimal which is not achievable in real world!
$t is based on market values of capital which keep on changing thus W55 will change
over time but is assumed to remain constant throughout the economic life of the pro=ect!
$t is based on past information especially when determining the cost of each component
e!g in determining the cost of equity B0eC the past yearDs 17S is used while the growth
rate is estimated from the past stream of dividends!
Note
When using market values to determine the weightAproportion in W55, the cost of retained
earnings is left out since it is already included or reflected in the -7S and thus the market
value of equity! 3etained earnings are an internal source of finance thus, when they are high
there is low gearing, lower financial risk and thus highest -7S!
Marginal cost o' 'inance
#his is cost of new finances or additional cost a company has to pay to raise and use
additional finance
is given by:
#otal cost of marginal finance x )@@
5ost of finance B5,4C
5ost of finance may be computed using the following information:
iC -arginal cost of each capital component!
iiC #he weights based on the amount to raise from each source!
aC $nvestors usually compute their return basing their figures on market values or cost of
investment!
bC $nvestors purchase their investment at market value and as such, the cost of finance to
the company must be weighted against expectations based on the market conditions!
cC $nvestments appreciate in the stock market and as such the cost must be ad=usted to
reflect such a movement in the value of an investment!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
;4 Lesson *our
)! -arginal cost of equity
-5. I
)@@
)
x
f P
D
o
Bfor >ero growth firmC
lso cost of equity
0e I
f P
D
o
)
Bfor normal growth firmC
Where: d) I expected 17S I d@B)GgC
7@ I current -7S
f I floation costs
g I growth rate in equity
%! 5ost of preference share capital:
0p I
)@@ x
f P
Dp
o
Where: 0p I 5ost of preference
1p I 1ividend per share
7o I -7S B-arket price per shareC
4 I 4lotation costs
+! 5ost of debenture
f V
T Int
K
d
d
C ) B
Where: 0d I 5ost of debt
$nt I interest
7o I -arket price for debenture Bat discountC
f I flotation costs
t I #ax rate
&! Nust like W55, weighted marginal cost of capital can be computed using:
iC Weighted average cost method
iiC 7ercentage method
Eam<le
P8Q 2td wants to raise new capital to finance a new pro=ect! #he firm will issue %@@,@@@
ordinary shares BSh!)@ par valueC at Sh!)' with Sh!) floatation costs per share, <9,@@@ )%F
preference shares BSh!%@ par valueC at Sh!)( with sh!)9@,@@@ total floatation costs, 9@,@@@
)(F debentures Bsh!)@@ parC at Sh!(@ and raised a Sh!9,@@@,@@@ )(F loan paying total
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
;5 Ca<ital Structure and Cost o'
*unds
floatation costs of Sh!%@@,@@@! ssume +@F corporate tax rate! #he company paid %(F
ordinary dividends which is expected to grow at &F p!a!
,e>uired
aC 1etermine the total capital to raise net of floatation costs
bC 5ompute the marginal cost of capital
Solution
aC Sh!D@@@D
,rdinary shares %@@,@@@ shares S Sh!)'
2ess floatation costs %@@,@@@ shares S
Sh!)
7reference shares <9,@@@ shares S Sh!)(
2ess floatation cost
1ebentures 9@,@@@ debentures S Sh!(@
4loatation costs
2oan
2ess floatation costs
#otal capital raised
+,%@@,@@@
%@@,@@@
),+9@,@@@
B)9@,@@@C
+,@@@,@@@
"YYYY
9,@@@,@@@
B%@@,@@@C
+,@@@
),%@@
+,@@@
&,(@@
)%,@@@
bC -arginal cost of equity 0e
g
f P
g d
K
e
+
+
@
@
C ) B
d@ I %(F x Sh!)@ par I Sh!%!(@
g I &F
f I Sh!)!@@
7@ I Sh!)'
#herefore marginal I @& ! @
) )'
C @& ! ) B (@ ! %
+
e
K I @!%+& I %+!&F
-arginal cost of preference share capital 0p
0p I dp
7@"f
dp I )%F x Sh!%@ par I Sh!%!&@
7@ I Sh!)(
f I 4loatation cost per shareI Sh!)9@,@@@ I Sh!%!@@
<9,@@@ shares
0p I %!&@ I @!)9 I )9F
)( E %
-arginal cost of debenture 0d:
0d I $nt B)"tC
:d"f
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
;@ Lesson *our
f I @
:d I Sh!(@
$nt I )(F x Sh!)@@ par I Sh!)(
# I +@F
0d I )(B)"@!+C I @!)9<9 I )9!<9F
(@
-arginal cost of loan 0d
0d I $nt B)"tC
:d"f
# I +@F
:d I Sh!9 million
f I Sh!@!% million
$nt I )(F x Sh!9- I Sh!@!;-
0d I @!; B)"@!+C I @!)+)%9I )+!)+F
9 E @!%
Source mount to
raise before f!
costs
Sh!D@@@D
F marginal
cost
-aturity cost
Sh!D@@@D
,rdinary shares
7reference shares
1ebenture
2oan
+,%@@
),+9@
+,@@@
9,@@@
)%,99@
%+!&F
)9!@F
)9!<9F
)+!)+F
<&(!(
%@+!9
&<%!9
'9'!9
%,@(@!+
Weighted marginal cost I %,@(@!+ x )@@ I )'!9(F
)%,99@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
;6 Ca<ital Structure and Cost o'
*unds
,E&N*O,C&NG J.EST&ONS
J.EST&ON ONE
#he following is the existing capital structure of 5ompany P8Q 2td!
,rdinary shares at Shs!)@ par
3etained
)%F preference shares Shs!)@ par
)'F loan Shs!)@@ par
#otal capital employed
Shs!
),@@@,@@@
(@@,@@@
&@@,@@@
+@@,@@@
%,9@@,@@@
#he companyDs ordinary shares have a dividend cover of + times and pays a dividend
of )@F on its ordinary share capital!
,rdinary shares sells at Shs!)(
7reference shares sell at Shs!)9
1ebentures are selling at par! #he tax rate is +@F
Com<ute
aC 6rowth in .quity! B)@ marksC
bC W!!5!5! B)@ marksC
J.EST&ON TWO
1istinguish between
5apital structure and financial structure!
1istinguish between *usiness risk and 4inancial risk!
What is the effect of introduction of debt capital on weighted average cost of
capital BW55C
1ifferentiate between marginal weighted cost of capital B-W55C and W55
J.EST&ON T-,EE
aC 1efine the term weighted average cost of capital! B+ marksC
bC What is meant by the marginal weighted average cost of capitalM B+ marksC
cC 5om"#ech 5ompany 2td! is in the #elecommunications $ndustry! #he companyDs
balance sheet as at +) -arch %@@@ is as below:
Lia?ility and Owners
E>uity S%(FIIIF
Assets
S%(FIIIF
5urrent liabilities
)(F debentures Bsh!),@@@ parC
)@F preference shares
,rdinary shares BSh!)@ parC
3etained earnings
)%,9@@
)',@@@
',%9@
)%,9@@
%(,)%9
<9,+<9
5urrent assets
/et fixed assets
+%,9@@
&%,(<9
YYYYY
<9,+<9
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
;8 Lesson *our
Additional in'ormation
#he debentures are now selling at Sh!;9@ in the market and will be redeemed )@ years from
now!
*y the end of last financial period, the company had declared and paid Sh!9!@@ as dividend
per share! #he dividends are expected to grow at an annual rate of )@F in the foreseeable
future! 5urrently, the companyDs shares are trading at Sh!+( per share at the local stock
exchange!
#he preference shares were floated in );;9 and their prices have remained constant!
-ost banks are lending money at an interest of %%F per annum!
#he 5orporation tax rate is &@F per annum!
,e>uired
iC 5alculate the market weighted cost of capital for this firm! B)%
marksC
iiC J#he book"value weights should be used discreetly when computing weighted cost of
capitalK! WhyK B% marksC
J.EST&ON *O.,
ssume that on +) 1ecember %@@) you are provided with the following capital structure of
Hatilcure 2td which is optimal!
Sh!D@@@D
2ong term debt B)'FC )+9,@@@
,rdinary share capital BSh!)@ parC ;@,@@@
3etained earnings <9,@@@
+@@,@@@
#he company has total assets amounting to sh!+'@ million but this figure is expected to rise to
Sh!9@@ million by he end of %@@%! 8ou are also informed that:
)! ny new equity shares sold will net ;@F after flotation costs!
%! 4or the year =ust ended the company paid Sh!+!@@ in dividends per share!
+! /ew )'F debt can be raised at par through the stock exchange!
&! #he past and expected earnings growth rate is )@F
9! #he current dividend yield is )%F
'! #he companyDs dividend payout ratio of 9@F shall be maintained in %@@%!
<! ssume marginal at rate of &@F
(! #he companyDs capital structure is optimal
,e>uired
aC 5ompanyDs net amount to the capital budget to be financial with equity if (9F of the
asset expansion is included in the %@@% capital budget! B+ marksC
bC How many shares must be sold to raise the required equity capitalM 3ound your
figure o the nearest thousand! B( marksC
cC What is the firmDs marginal cost of capitalM Show full workings! B)@ marksC
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
;7 Ca<ital Structure and Cost o'
*unds
C-ECK 0O., ANSWE,S W&T- T-OSE G&/EN &N LESSON 4I O* T-E ST.D0
+ACK
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
;: Lesson *our
COM+,E-ENS&/E ASS&GNMENT 5
TO !E S.!M&TTED A*TE, LESSON 6
To !e Carried Out .nder Eamination Condition and Sent to Distance learning
Administrator 'or marking ?y t%e .ni2ersity
Answer All Juestions Time Allowed= T%ree -ours
J.EST&ON ONE
aC How can the action of shareholders reduce the value of the bond held by
debenture holdersM B)@ marksC
bC State and explain the mechanism of resolving the agency problem
between shareholders and debenture holders! B)@
marksC
J.EST&ON TWO
aC .xplain the term LgearingD in relation to the capital structure of a limited liability
company! B& marksC
bC yet 2td! and *ayet 2td! are two small si>e companies operating in -ombasa,
0enya! #he following information has been provided for the year ended +@ pril
);;(:
yet 2td!
Shs!
*ayet 2td!
Shs!
,rdinary share capital Sh!)@ par
)@F preference shares of Sh!)@ par
3etained profits
)9F 1ebentures
5apital employed
'@@,@@@
'@@,@@@
),%@@,@@@
(@@,@@@
%,@@@,@@@
%,@@@,@@@
&,@@@,@@@
),(@@,@@@
"
),(@@,@@@
),%@@,@@@
+,@@@,@@@
),@@@,@@@
&,@@@,@@@
,e>uired
5alculate the gearing ratio of each company and state in each case whether the gearing is
high or low! B5alculate to % decimal placesC! B'
marksC
5alculate the maximum percentage dividend on ordinary shares which each company could
declare, without utili>ing, or adding to, accumulated retained profits if profits for the year
ended +@ pril );;( was:
yet 2td!
Shs!
*ayet 2td!
Shs!
/et profit Bbefore $nterest and
taxC
B5orporation tax rate is &@FC
9@@,@@@ ),@@@,@@@
B' marksC
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
;; Ca<ital Structure and Cost o'
*unds
5omment on the results of bBiiC above! B% marksC
J.EST&ONT-,EE
#he following information is provided in respect to the affairs of 7ote 2imited which
prepares its account on the calendar year basis!
);;9
Shs!
);;&
Shs!
Sales
7urchases
5ost of goods sold
Stock at +) 1ecember
1ebtors at +) 1ecember
5reditors at +) 1ecember
#otal assets at +) 1ecember
'@@,@@@
&@@,@@@
+'@,@@@
)@@,@@@
;(,@@@
&@,@@@
+@@,@@@
9@@,@@@
+9@,@@@
++@,@@@
'@,@@@
)@%,@@@
%9,@@@
)(9,@@@
Stock and debtors at ) Nanuary );;& amounted to Sh!<@,@@@ and Sh!;(,@@@ respectively!
,e>uired
aC 5alculate the rate of stock turnover expressed:
iC s a ratioO B+ marksC
iiC $n days, for each of the years );;& and );;9! B+ marksC
bC 5alculate the rate of collection of debtors, in days, for each of the years );;&
and );;9! B+ marksC
cC 5alculate the rate of payment to creditors, in days, for each year );;& and
);;9!
B+ marksC
dC Show the cash operating cycle for each year! B' marksC
eC 5omment on the results! B' marksC
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC *riefly explain the meaning of a Jfloating rateK bond! B& marksC
bC 4rom the point of view of a companyDs financial manager, outline the merits
and demerits, to the company, of issuing floating rate debt as a means of
raising capital!
B)' marksC
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
;9 Lesson *our
J.EST&ON *&/E
#he ltman formula for prediction of bankruptcy is given as follows:
Q score I )!%P) G )!&P% G +!+P+ G )P& G @!'P9
Where: P) I Working capitalA#otal assets
P% I 3etained earningsA#otal assets
P+ I .arnings before interest and taxA#otal assets
P& I SalesA#otal assets
P9 I -arket value of .quityA2iabilities
$n this model, a Q"score of %!< or more indicates non"failure and a Q"score of )!( or
less indicates failure!
8ou are provided with the following information in respect of four listed companies!
Workin
g ca<ital
S%(FIIIF
,etaine
d
earnings
S%(FIIIF
Earning
s ?e'ore
interest
and ta
S%(FIIIF
Market
2alue
o'
e>uity
S%(FIII
F
Total
assets
S%(FIIIF
Lia?ilitie
s
S%(FIIIF
Sales
S%(FIIIF
2td
*
2td
5
2td
1
2td
!
&,@@@
%,@@@
',@@@
&@,@@@
'@,@@@
%@,@@@
%@,@@@
%@@,@@@
)@,@@@
@
"+@,@@@
+@,@@@
%@,@@@
9,@@@
&(,@@@
)@@,@@
@
%@@,@@@
)@@,@@@
(@@,@@@
),(@@,@@
@
)%@,@@@
(@,@@@
<&@,@@@
),@@@,@@@
%@@,@@@
)%@,@@@
;@@,@@@
%,@@@,@@
@
,e>uired
aC #he Q"Score for each of the companies! 5omment on the results obtained! B)@
marksC
bC $t has been suggested that other ratios ought to be incorporated into ltmanDs
bankruptcy prediction model! What is your opinion on thisM B9
marksC
cC 2ist the indicators of possible business failure! B9
marksC
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
9I Ca<ital Structure and Cost o'
*unds
END O* COM+,E-ENS&/E ASS&GNMENT NO(5
NOW SEND TO D&STANCE LEA,N&NG *O, MA,K&NG
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
94 Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
LESSON *&/E
CA+&TAL &N/ESTMENT DEC&S&ONS
&NST,.CT&ONS
3ead 5hapters <, )) and )% of 4inancial -anagement text book by $!-! 7andey
5omplete answers to rein'orcement questions at the end of the lesson!
5heck model answers given in lesson )@ of the study pack!
3einforcing 5omments
CONTENTS
$mportance of investment analysis
-ethods of analysing Aevaluating pro=ects
5omparisons of the -ethods
3eplacement of ssets
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 95
&N/ESTMENT ANAL0S&S
ny company will invest finance for the sake of deriving a return which is useful for four main
reasons:
)! #o reward the shareholders or owners of the business for staking their money and by
foregoing their current purchasing power for the sake of current and future return!
%! #o reward creditors by paying them regular return in form of interest and repayment of
their principal as and when it falls due!
+! #o be able to retain part of their earnings for plough back purposes which facilitates not
only the companies growth present and the future but also has the implication of
increasing the si>e of the company in sales and in assets!
&! 4or the increase in share prices and thus the credibility of the company and its ability to
raise further finance!
Such a return is necessary to keep the companyDs operations moving smoothly and thus
allow the above ob=ective to be achieved!
financial manager with present investment policies will be concerned with how efficiently the
companyDs funds are invested because it is from such investment that the company will survive!
$nvestments are important because:
iC #hey influence companyDs si>e
iiC $nfluence growth
iiiC $nfluence companyDs risks
$n addition, this investment decision making process also known as capital budgeting, involves
the decision to invest the companyDs current funds in viable ventures whose returns will be
realised for long term periods in future! 5apital budgeting as financial planning is characterised
by the following:
)! 1ecisions of this nature are long term i!e! extending beyond one year in which case they
are also expected to generate returns of long term in nature!
%! $nvestment is usually heavy Bheavy capital in=ectionC and as such has to be properly
planned!
+! #hese decisions are irreversible and any mistake may cause the company heavy losses!
&m<ortance o' &n2estment Decisions
aC Such decisions are importance because they will influence the companyDs si>e Bfixed
assets, sales, and retained earningsC!
bC #hey increase the value of the companyDs shares and thus its credibility!
cC #he fact that they are irreversible means that they have to be made carefully to avoid
any mistake which can lead to the failure of such investment!
dC 1ue to heavy capital outlay, more attention is required to avoid loss of huge sums of
money which in the extreme may lead to the closure of such a company! However,
these decisions are influenced by:
i# +olitical 'actors E Under conditions of political uncertainty, such decisions cannot be
made as it will entail an element of risk of failure of such investment! #hus political
certainty has to be analysed before such decisions are made, such factors must be taken
into account such that the company forecasts the inflows and outflows within given
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
9@ Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
limitations such as the degree of competition, performance of economy, changing tastes
etc! which influence ability to generate sufficient return from a venture which will pay
not only interest but principal on such funds invested!
ii# Tec%nological 'actors E #hese influence the returns of the company because such
technology will affect the companyDs ability to utilise its assets to the utmost ability in
particular if such assets become obsolete and cannot generate good returns or the output
of such machines may be low with time and may not meet planned expectations which
in most cases will have an impact on inflows from a venture!
Met%ods o' AnalyDing &n2estment
Ca<ital !udgeting Met%ods(
#here are two methods of analy>ing the viability of an investment:
a# Traditional met%ods
7ay back period method
ccounting rate of return method
?# Modern met%ods "Discounted cas% 'low tec%ni>ues#
/7: E /et present value method
$33 E $nternal rate of return method
7$ E 7rofitability index method
4or the above two Ba H bC methods to be used, they have to meet the following:
iC #hey should rank ventures available in the investment market according to their
viability i!e! they should identify which method is more viable than others!
iiC #hey should rank a venture first if the venture brings in return earlier and in large
lumpsums than if a venture brought in late and less inflows over the same period!
iiiC Should rank any other pro=ects as and when it is available in the investment market!
Such methods should take into account that all returns BinflowsC, must be cash returns as
it is necessary to be able to finance the cost of the venture!
T,AD&T&ONAL MET-ODS
+ay ?ack <eriod met%od
#his method gauges the viability of a venture by taking the inflows and outflows over time to
ascertain how soon a venture can payback and for this reason 7*7 Bor payout period or payoffC
is that period of time or duration it will take an investment venture to generate sufficient cash
inflows to payback the cost of such investment! #his is a popular approach among the traditional
financial managers because it helps them ascertain the time it will take to recoup in form of cash
from operations the original cost of the venture! #his method is usually an important
preliminary screening stage of the viability of the venture and it may yield clues to profitability
although in principle it will measure how fast a venture may payback rather than how much a
venture will generate in profits and yet the main ob=ectives of an investment is not to recoup the
original cost but also to earn a profit for the owners or investors!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 96
5omputation of payback period:
4( .nder uni'orm annual incremental cas% in'lows E if the venture or an asset generates
uniform cash inflows then the payback period B7*7C will be given by:
7*7 I $nitial cost of the venture
nnual incremental cost
e!g! $f a venture costs +<,;)@AI and promises returns of )@,@@@AI per annum indefinitely
then the 7*7 I
@@@ , )@
;)@ , +<
I +!<; years
#he shorter the 7*7 the more viable the investment and thus the better the choice of
such investments!
5( .nder nonAuni'orm cas% in'lows=
Under non"uniformity 7*7 computation will be in cumulative form and this means that
the net cash inflows are accumulated each year until initial investment is recovered!
Eam<le
ssume a pro=ect costs Sh!(@,@@@ and will generate the following cash inflows:
Cas% in'lows Accumulated in'lows
$nflows year ) I )@,@@@ )@,@@@
$nflows year % I +@,@@@ &@,@@@
$nflows year + I )9,@@@ 99,@@@
$nflows year & I %@,@@@ <9,@@@
$nflows year 9 I +@,@@@ )@9,@@@
#he Sh!(@,@@@ cost is recovered between year & and 9! 1uring year 9 Bafter year &C
Sh!9,@@@ is B(@,@@@ E <9,@@@C is required out the total year 9 cash flows of +@,@@@!
#herefore the 7*7 I
@@@ , +@
@@@ , 9
& + yrs
I &!)< years
Eam<le
5edes limited has the following details of two of the future production plans! ,nly one
of these machines will be purchased and the venture would be taken to be virtually
exclusive! #he Standard model costs Z9@,@@@ and the 1eluxe cost Z((,@@@ payable
immediately! *oth machines will require the input of the following:
iC $nstallation costs of Z%@,@@@ for Standard and Z&@,@@@ for the 1eluxe
iiC Z)@,@@@ working capital through their working lives!
*oth machines have no expected scrap value at end of their expected working lives of &
years for the Standard machine and six years for the 1eluxe! #he operating pre"tax net
cash flows associated with the two machines are:
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
98 Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
8ear ) % + & 9 '
Standard
1eluxe
%(,9@@
+',@+@
%9,('@
+@,))@
%&,%)@
%(,+(@
%+,&)@
%9,;&@
"
+(,9@@
"
+9,)@@
#he deluxe machine has only been introduced in the market and has not been fully tested in the
operating conditions, because of the high risk involved the appropriate discount rate for the
deluxe machine is believed to be )&F per annum, %F higher than the rate of the standard
machine! #he company is proposing the purchase of either machine with a term loan at a fixed
rate of interest of ))F per annum, taxation at +@F is payable on operating cash"flows one year
in arrears and capital allowance are available at %9F per annum on a reducing balance basis!
,e>uired
4or both the Standard and the 1eluxe machines, calculate the payback period!
Solution
.stablish the cash flows as follows:
7re"tax inflows B.*1#C PP
2ess depreciation I capital allowance BPPC
.arnings before tax PP
2ess tax BPPC
.arnings after tax PP
dd back capital allowanceAdepreciation PP
,perating cash flows PP
Note
5apital allowanceAdepreciation is a non"cash item thus when deducted for tax purposes, it
should be added back to eliminate the non"cash flow effects!
5ash flows for standard machine:
8ear ) % + & 9
7retax inflow
2ess allowance BdepreciationC
#axable cash inflows
#ax S +@F ) yr in arrears
dd back capital allowance
,perating cash flows
dd working capital realised
#otal cash flows
%(,9@@
)<,9@@
)),@@@
"YYY
)),@@@
)<,9@@
%(,9@@
"
%(,9@@
%9,(9@
)+,)%9
)%,<+9
+!+@@
;,&+9
)+,)%9
%%,9'@
"
%%,9'@
%&,%)@
;,(&&
)&,+''
B+,(+)C
)@,9&9
;,(&&
%@,+(;
"
%@,+(;
%+,&)@
<,+(+
)',@%<
B&,+)@C
)),<)<
<,+(+
);,)@@
)@,@@@
%;,)@@
"
"
B&,(@(C
B&,(@(C
"
B&,(@(C
"
B&,(@(C
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 97
5ash flows for 1eluxe machine
8ear ) % + & 9 ' <
7retax inflows
2ess
BdepreciationC
#ax S +@F in
arrears
$nflows after tax
dd back capital
llowance
dd back
wAcapital
#otal cash flows
+',@+
@
+%,@@
@
&,@+@
"
&,@+@
+%,@@
@
"
+',@+
@
+@,))@
%&,@@@
',))@
B),%@;C
&,;@)
%&,@@@
%(,;@)
"
%(,9;;
%(,+(@
)(,@@@
)@,+(@
B),(++C
(,9&<
)(,@@@
%',9&<
"
%',9&<
%9,;&@
)+,9@@
)%,&&@
B+,))&C
;,+%'
)+,9@@
%%,(%'
"
%%,(%'
+(,9'@
)@,)%9
%(,&+9
B+,<+%C
%&,<@+
)@,)%9
+&,(%(
"
+&,(%(
+9,)@@
<,9;&
%<,9@'
B(,9+)C
)(,;<9
<,9;&
%',9';
)@,@@@
+',9';
"
"
"
B(,%9%C
B(,%9%C
"
B(,%9%C
"
B(,%9%C
Standard 1eluxe
5ost 9@,@@@ G %@,@@@ <@,@@@ ((,@@@ G &@,@@@
)%(,@@@
8ear 5ash flows ccumulate
d
5ash
flows
ccumulated
)
%
+
&
9
'
<
%(,9@@
%%,9'@
%@,+(;
%;,)@@
B&,(@(C
"
"
%(,9@@
9),@'@
<),&&;
)@@,9&;
;9,<&)
"
"
+',@+@
%(,;@)
%',9&<
%%,(%'
+&,(%(
+',9';
B (,%9%C
+',@+@
'&,;+)
;),&<(
))&,+@&
)&;,)+%
)(9,<@)
)<;,&&;
V 7ay back period for standard: $nitial capital of Sh!<,@@@ is recovered during year +!
fter year %, we require <@,@@@ E ;,@'@ I )(,;&@ to recover initial capital out of year + cash
flows of Sh!%@,+(;!
V pplying the same concept for 1eluxe, payback period would be:
(%( , +&
+@& , ))& @@@ , )%(
&
+
I &!+; years
Accounting ,ate o' ,eturn Met%od "A,,#
#his method uses accounting profits from financial status to assess the viability of investment
proposal by diving the average income after tax by average investment! #he investment would
be equal to either the original investment plus the salvage value divided by two or the initial
investment divided by two or dividing the total of the investment book value after depreciating
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
9: Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
by the life of the pro=ect! #his method is also known as financial statement method or book
value method! #he rate of return on asset method or ad=usted rate of return method is given by:
33 I verage income x )@@ or verage income E verage depreciation
verage investment $nitial investment
Unlike 7*7, this method will ascertain the profitability of an investment and it will give results
which are consistent with those given by return ratios e!g!
Shs!
7ro=ect P cost 9@@,@@@
Scrap value )@@,@@@
Stream of income before depreciation and taxes are as follows:
Shs!
8ear ) )@@,@@@
8ear % )%@,@@@
8ear + )&@,@@@
8ear & )'@,@@@
8ear 9 %@@,@@@
2et tax I 9@F and depreciation straight line! 5alculate the accounting rate of return!
Solution
1epreciation I 9@@,@@@ E )@@,@@@ I Shs!(@, @@@
9 years
8ear ) % + & 9
$ncome
2ess depreciation
.arnings before tax .*#
2ess tax S 9@F
.#
)@@,@@@
(@,@@@
%@,@@@
B)@,@@@C
)@,@@@
)%@,@@@
(@,@@@
&@,@@@
B%@,@@@C
%@,@@@
)&@,@@@
(@,@@@
9@,@@@
B+@,@@@C
+@,@@@
)'@,@@@
(@,@@@
(@,@@@
B&@,@@@C
&@,@@@
%@@,@@@
(@,@@@
)%@,@@@
B'@,@@@C
'@,@@@
verage income B.#C I +%,@@@
verage investment I B9@@,@@@ G )@@,@@@C R I +@@,@@@
,r 33 I verage income x )@@ I +%,@@@ x )@@ I )@!'<F
verage investment +@@,@@@
Note
#he best method of depreciation to use should be that which will produce larger depreciation
changes in the )
st
few years of the assets life and lesser changes in the later years because this
will produce a higher tax shield to the company with higher value of inflows! #hus reducing
balance is preferred as compared to sum of digits and straight line method!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 9;
T%e sal2age 2alue s%ould ?e treated as 'ollows=
$f the asset produces a salvage value at the end of the year, this will increase inflows for
payback period! #his value is only used to ascertain how much the company will reduce
original cost of investment to obtain average investment!
Acce<tance ,ule o' +ay?ack +eriod "+?<#
Using 7*7 method a company will accept all those ventures whose payback period is less than
that set by the management and will re=ect all those ventures whose 7*7 is more than that set by
the management! lternatively, 7*7 may be gauged against the term of the loan in which case
the 7*7 method will give a high ranking to all those ventures paying back before the term of the
loan and the highest ranking will be given to those pro=ects with shortest 7*7! However, in
assessing the viability of a venture it is also important to see which venture brings returns
earlier, other things being equal!
Ad2antages o' +ay?ack +eriod
)! Simple to use and understand and this has made it popular among executives especially
traditional financial managers in ascertaining the viability of a venture!
%! $deal under high"risk investments because it will identify which venture will payback
earlier thus minimising the risks with a venture!
+! dvantageous when choosing between mutually exclusive pro=ects because it will give
a clue as to which venture is viable if one considers the shortest 7*7 and the highest
inflow of a venture!
Disad2antages o' +ay?ack +eriod
)! 1oes not take into account time value of money and assumes that a shilling received in
the )
st
year and in the /th year have the same value so as to rank them together to
ascertain the 7*7 which is unrealistic given that a shilling now is valuable than a
shilling / years from now!
%! 7*7 method does not measure the profitability of a venture but rather measures the
period of time a venture takes to pay back the cost! #he method is outside looking
Blender oriented rather than owner orientedC!
+! 7*7 method ignores inflows after 7*7 and as such, it does not accommodate the
element of return to an investment!
&! #his method will not have any impact on the companyDs share prices because
profitability which is one of the most important factors in gauging the companyDs value
of shares is not a function of 7*7 and as such the method fall short of meeting the
criteria of investment appraisal!
Acce<tance ,ule o' Accounting ,ate o' ,eturn "Arr#
33 method will accept those pro=ects whose 33 is higher than that set by management or
bank rate and it will give highest ranking to ventures with highest 33 and vice versa!
Ad2antages
)! Simple to understand and use!
%! 3eadily computed from accounting data thus much easier to ascertain!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
99 Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
+! $t is consistent with profitability ob=ectives as it analyses the return from entire inflows
and as such it will give a clue or a hint to the profitability of venture!
Disad2antages
)! $t ignores time value of money!
%! $t does not consider how soon the investment should recover the cost Bit is owner
looking than creditor oriented approachC!
+! $t uses accounting profits instead of cash inflows some of which may not be realisable!
MODE,N MET-ODS O, DC* i(e( Discounted Cas% *low Tec%ni>ues
4( +resent /alue Conce<t
#his concept acknowledges the fact that a shilling losses value with time and as such if it is to
be compared with a shilling to be received in /th year then the two must be at the same values!
#his means that an investorDs analytical power is increased by hisAher ability to compare cash
inflows and outflows separated from each other by time! HeAshe should be able to work in the
reverse direction i!e! from future cash flows to their present values!
5( +resent /alue o' a Lum<sum
Usually an investor would wish to know how much heAshe would give up now to get a given
amount in year ), %, [ n! $n this situation he would have to decide at what rate of discount also
known as time preference rate, heAshe will use to discount the anticipated lumpsum using this
rate by applying the following formula:
( )
n
K
L
Pv
+
)
Where: 7v I 7resent value
2 I 2umpsum
0 I 5ost of finance or time preference rate
n I given year!
#his implies that if the time preference rate is )@F, the present value of )AI to e received at the
end of year ) is:
;@; ! @
) ! )
)
Pv
#he present value of inflows to be received in the %
nd
year to /th year, will be equal to:
( )
K
!
Pv
+
)
Where: I annual cash flows
/ I /umber of years
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 4II
lso, the present value of a shilling to be received at a given point in time can in addition to
using the above formula, be found using the present value tables!
Suppose that an investor can expect to receive:
&@,@@@ at the end of year %
<@,@@@ at the end of year '
)@@,@@@ at the end of year (
5ompute his present BvalueC if his time preference is )%F!
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( ' %
)% ! )
@@@ , )@@
Y
)% ! )
@@@ , <@
)% ! )
@@@ , &@
)
+
+
K
L
Pv
I 0shs!)@<,<&@!%'
Using tables:
I &@,@@@B@!<;;%C G <@,@@@B@!9@''C G )@@,@@@B@!&@+;C
I )@<,(%@
@( +resent /alue o' an Annuity
n individual investor may not necessarily get a lumpsum after some years but rather get a
constant periodic amount i!e! an annuity for certain number of years! #he present value of an
annuity receivable where the investor time preference is )@F equal to:
( ) "
!
! Pv
+
)
C B
$ I time preference rate
.!g! 7v of )AI to be received after ) year if time preference rate is )@F!
I
;@; ! @
) ! @ )
)
+
fter % years it will be:
( ) ( )
(%'& ! @
) ! )
)
)
% %
+"
!
)
st
year " @!;@;@
%
nd
year " @!(%'&
+
rd
year " @!<9)+
&
th
year " @!'(+@
#otal " +!)';<
6( +resent /alue o' .ne2en +eriodic Sum
$n investment decisions it is very rare to get even periodic returns and in most cases a company
will generate a stream of uneven cash inflows from a venture and the present value of those
uneven periodic sums is equal to:
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
4I4 Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
K
!
K
!
K
!
K
!
Pv
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+
)
!!!!!
) ) )
+
+
%
%
)
)
equation
( )
t
t
K
!
Pv
)
Where: t I Uneven cash inflows at time t
7v I 7resent value
0 I5ost of finance
company contemplates to receive Shs!:
%@,@@@ in year )
)(,@@@ in year %
%&,@@@ in year +
/il in year &
&@,@@@ in year 9
5ost of this finance is )%F
,e>uired
5ompute present value of that finance
Solution
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
9 + % )
)% ! )
@@@ , &@
)% ! )
@@@ , %&
)% ! )
@@@ , )(
)% ! )
@@@ , +@
+ + + Pv
I (@,;)9!@@&
8( Net +resent /alue Met%od
#he method discounts inflows and outflows and ascertains the net present value by deducting
discounted outflows from discounted inflows to obtain net present cash inflows i!e the present
value method will involve selection of rate acceptable to the management or equal to the cost of
finance and this will be used to discount inflows and outflows and net present value will be
equal to the present value of inflow minus present value of outflow! $f net present value is
positive you invest, $f /7: is negative you do not invest!
7vBinflowC E 7vBoutflowsC I /7:
Note
$nitial outflow is at period >ero and their value is their actual present value! With this method,
an investor can ascertain the viability of an investment by discounting outflows! $n this case, a
venture will be viable if it has the lowest outflows!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 4I5
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
C
K
!
K
!
K
!
K
!
PV
1
1
]
1
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+
)
!!!!!
) ) )
+
+
%
%
)
)
Where: I annual inflow
0 I 5ost of finance
5 I 5ost of investment
/ I /umber of years
Eam<les
5ost of investment I )@@,@@@AI, interest rate I )@F, inflows year ) I (@,@@@AI year % I
9@,@@@AI
/7: I
( )
@@@ , )@@
) ! )
@@@ , 9@
) ! )
@@@ , (@
%
+
I )&,@&; positive hence invest!
Eam<le
Neremy limited wishes to expand its output by purchasing a new machine worth )<@,@@@ and
installation costs are estimated at &@,@@@AI! $n the &
th
year, this machine will call for an
overhaul to cost (@,@@@AI! $ts expected inflows are:
Shs!
8ear ) '@,@@@
8ear % <%,'9@
8ear + +9,<%@
8ear & &(,9)@
8ear 9 ;),'+@
8ear ' (+,<)9
#his company can raise finance to purchase machine at )%F interest rate!
5ompute /7: and advise management accordingly!
Solution
Shs!
5ost of machine at present value )<@,@@@
$nstallation cost &@,@@@
%)@,@@@
,verhaul cost in the &
th
year I (@,@@@
1iscounting factor I B)!)%C
&
#herefore present value I (@,@@@ I Shs!9@,(&)!&&'
B)!)%C
&
#otal present value of investment I %'@,(&)!&9
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
4I@ Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
7: inflows I
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
' 9 & + %
)% ! )
<)9 , (+
)% ! )
'+@ , ;)
C )% ! ) B
9)@ , &(
)% ! )
<%@ , +9
)% ! )
'9@ , <%
C )% ! ) B
@@@ , '@
+ + + + +
K
I %'%,)&<!%(
#herefore: /7: I %'%,)&<!%( E %'@,(&)!&9
/7: I ),+@9!(+
#he /7: is positive and $ would advise the management to invest!
Eam<le
3esilou limited intends to purchase a machine worth Shs!),9@@,@@@ which will have a residue
value Shs!%@@,@@@ after 9 years useful life! #he saving in cost resulting from the use of this
machine are:
Shs!
8ear ) (@@,@@@
8ear % +9@,@@@
8ear + "
8ear & '(@,@@@
8ear 9 <<9,@@@
Using /7: method, advise the company whether this machine should be purchased if the cut
off rate is )&F and acceptable saving in cost is )%F of the cost of the investment!
Solution
8ear ) % + & 9
Saving
Scrap value
#otal
amount
(@@,@@@
"
(@@,@@@
+9@,@@@
"
+9@,@@@
"
"
"
'(@,@@@
"
'(@,@@@
<<9,@@@
%@@,@@@
;<9,@@@
/7: I
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
@@@ , 9@@ , )
)& ! )
@@@ , ;<9
)& ! )
@@@ , '(@
)& ! )
@@@ , +9@
)& ! )
@@@ , (@@
9 & % )
+ + +
I ),((@,@'<!) E ),9@@,@@@
I +(@,@'<!@<
3eturn I
)@@
@@@ , 9@@ , )
@ ! @'< , +(@
x
I %9!++<F U )%F hence invest!
N!= ssuming that the salvage will be realised!
Eam<le
section of a roadway pavement costs Z&@@ per year to maintain! What new expenditure of a
new pavement is =ustified if no maintenance will be required for the )
st
five years then Z)@@ for
the next )@ years and Z&@@ a year thereafterM ssume cost of finance to be 9F!
Solution
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 4I6
#otal present value of maintenance costs under the re"surfacing scheme!
-aximum expenditure I
@@@ , ( Z
@9 ! @
&@@
K
K
A P
n
)
)
)
Whereby: 7: is 7resent value
is annuity
0 is cost of finance
n is number of year
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
4I8 Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
7resent value of an annuity to perpetuity is given by the formula
7v I
K
A
Whereby: 7: is 7resent value
is annuity
0 is cost of finance
#herefore 7: maximum expenditure I @@@ , ( Z
@9 ! @
&@@
+
1
1
1
1
1
]
1
1
1
1
1
1
]
1
9 ! @
@9 ! )
)
&@@
9 ! @
&@@
9 ! @
@9 ! )
)
)
)@@
9 ! @
@9 ! )
)
)
)@@
)9
9 )9
PV
I Z&,&9+
N!: #he present value interest factors 7:$4 I
n
rC ) B
)
+
and present value
nnuity factors, 7:4 I
r
r
n
+ C ) B )
can be read from tables provided at the point of
interseption between the discounting rate and number of periods!
ACCE+T O, ,EBECT ,.LE O* N+/
Under this method, a company should accept an investment venture if /!7!:! is positive i!e! if
present value of cash outflows exceeds that of cash inflows or at least is equal to >ero! B/7:
^@C! #his will rank ventures giving the highest rank to that venture with highest /7: because
this will give the highest cash inflow or capital gain to the company!
Ad2antages o' N+/
$t recognises time value of money and such appreciates that a shilling now is more
valuable than a shilling tomorrow and the two can only be compared if they are at their
present value!
$t takes into account the entire inflows or returns and as such it is a realistic gauge of the
profitability of a venture!
$t is consistent with the value of a share in so far as a positive /7: will have the
implication of increasing the value of a share!
&! $t is consistent with the ob=ective of maximising the welfare of an owner because a
positive /7: will increase the net worth of owners!
Disad2antages o' N+/
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 4I7
$t is difficult to use!
$ts calculation uses cost of finance which is a difficult concept because it considers both
implicit and explicit whereas /7: ignores implicit costs!
$t is ideal for assessing the viability of an investment under certainty because it ignores
the element of risk!
$t may not give good assessment of alternative pro=ects if the pro=ects are unequal lives,
returns or costs!
$t ignores the 7*7!
&rr "&nternal ,ate O' ,eturn#
#his method is a discounted cash flow technique which uses the principle of /7:! $t is defined
as the rate which equates the present value of cash outflows of an investment to the initial
capital!
$33 I 7v Bcash inflowsC I 7vBcash outflowsC or $33 is the cost of capital when /7: I @!
$t is also called internal rate of return because it depends wholly on the outlay of investment and
proceeds associated with the pro=ect and not a rate determined outside the venture!
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
r
!
r
!
r
!
r
!
C IRR
+
+ +
+
+
+
+
+
)
!!!!!
) ) )
+
+
%
%
)
)
I inflow for each period
5 I 5ost of investment
#he value r can be found by:
iC #rial and error
iiC *y interpolation
iiiC *y extrapolation
i# Trial and error met%od
aC Select any rate of interest at random and use it to compute /7: of cash inflows!
bC $f rate chosen produces /7: lower than the cost, choose a lower rate!
cC $f the rate chosen in BaC above gives /7: greater than the cost, choose a higher
rate! 5ontinue the process until the /7: is equal to >ero and that will be the
$33!
Eam<le
pro=ect costs )',%@@AI and is expected to generate the following inflows:
Shs!
8ear ) (,@@@
8ear % <,@@@
8ear + ',@@@
5ompute the $33 of this venture!
Solution
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
4I: Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
4
st
c%oice 4IK
( ) ( ) ( )
+ % )
) ! )
@@@ , '
) ! )
@@@ , <
) ! )
@@@ , (
+ +
I )<,9'9!<& U cost, choose a higher rate!
5
nd
c%oice 46K
( ) ( ) ( )
+ % )
)& ! )
@@@ , '
)& ! )
@@@ , <
)& ! )
@@@ , (
+ +
I )',&9+!'&'
@
rd
c%oice 48K
( ) ( ) ( )
+ % )
)9 ! )
@@@ , '
)9 ! )
@@@ , <
)9 ! )
@@@ , (
+ +
I )',);&!'%9
$33 lies between )&F and )9F!
ii# &nter<olation met%od
1ifference
7: at rate of )&F I )',&9+!'&'
%9+!'&'
7: required I )',%@@!@@@
"9!+<9
7: at rate of )9F I )',);&!'%9
#herefore, r denotes required rate of return
#herefore, r I )&F G B)9F " )&FC x
+<9 ! 9 '&' ! %9+
'&' ! %9+
+
I )&F G @!;(F
I )&!;(F
Acce<tance ,ule o' &,,
$33 will accept a venture if its $33 is higher than or equal to the minimum required rate of
return which is usually the cost of finance also known as the cut off rate or hurdle rate, and in
this case $33 will be the highest rate of interest a firm would be ready to pay to finance a
pro=ect using borrowed funds and without being financially worse off by paying back the loan
Bthe principal and accrued interestC out of the cash flows generated by that pro=ect! #hus, $33 is
the break"even rate of borrowing from commercial banks!
Ad2antages o' &,,
$t considers time value of money
$t considers cash flows over the entire life of the pro=ect!
$t is compatible with the maximisation of ownerDs wealth because, if it is higher than the
cost of finance, ownersD wealth will be maximised!
Unlike the /7: method, it does not use the cost of finance to discount inflows and for this
reason it will indicate a rate of return of interval to the pro=ect against which various
ventures can be assessed as to their viability!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 4I;
Disad2antages o' &,,
1ifficult to use!
.xpensive to use because it calls for trained manpower and may use computers
especially where inflows are of large magnitude and extending beyond the normal
limits!
$t may give multiple results some involving positive $33 in which case it may be
difficult to use in choosing which venture is more viable!
+,O*&TA!&L&T0 &NDE3 "+(&(#
7!$! Bbenefit"cost ratioC I 7resent value of inflows
7resent value of cash outlay
$f 7!$! is greater than )!@, invest! $f less than )!@, re=ect!
Eam<le
#he following information was from P8Q feasibility studies! $t has studied two ventures:
aC 5ost )@@,@@@AI and )'@,@@@AI at the beginning of the &
th
year and it will generate
inflows )"+
rd
year (@,@@@AI and from &"'
th
year 9@,@@@AI per annum!
bC $nitial cost %@@,@@@AI and (@,@@@AI at the beginning of the &
th
year and it will generate
the following inflows:
)
st
E %
nd
year "U Shs!)@@,@@@ per annum
+
rd
E '
th
year "U Shs!<@,@@@ per annum
Using the cost of finance of )%F compute the 7!$! of these two ventures, advise the
company accordingly!
Solution
aC ,utflows:
( )
+
)% ! )
@@@ , )'@
)
@@@ , )@@
+
I )@@,@@@ G ))+,((< I %)+,((9
$nflows:
( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
' 9 & + % )
)% ! )
@@@ , 9@
)% ! )
@@@ , 9@
)% ! )
@@@ , 9@
)% ! )
@@@ , (@
)% ! )
@@@ , (@
)% ! )
@@@ , (@
+ + + + +
I Shs!%<<,'%'
7!$! I
((9 , %)+
'%' , %<<
7!$! I )!%;(
bC ,utflows: I
( )
+
)% ! )
@@@ , (@
)
@@@ , %@@
+
I %9',;&&
$nflows I
( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
' 9 & + % )
)% ! )
@@@ , <@
)% ! )
@@@ , <@
)% ! )
@@@ , <@
)% ! )
@@@ , <@
)% ! )
@@@ , )@@
)% ! )
@@@ , )@@
+ + + + +
I
Shs!++(,9@)
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
4I9 Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
7!$! I
;&& , %9'
9@) , ++(
I )!+%
Eam<le
company is faced with the following 9 investment opportunities:
5ost /7: 7!$ I #otal 7!vYYY
$nitial capital
7!$ 3anking
)!
%!
+!
&!
9!
9@@,@@@
)@@,@@@
&@@,@@@
%@@,@@@
)'@,@@@
)9@,@@@
&@,@@@
&@,@@@
)@@,@@@
;@,@@@
)!+
)!&
)!)
)!9
)!'
&
+
9
%
)
#his company has <9@,@@@AI available for investment pro=ects, + and & are mutually exclusive!
ll of the pro=ects are divisible! Which group should be selected in order to maximise the /7:!
$ndicate this /7: figure!
Solution
Using 7!$! to rank the pro=ects in order of preference 9, &, %, ), +!
$n order to maximise /7:, the following pro=ects combination should be selected:
Shs!
4unds available for investment <9@,@@@
5ost of pro=ect: 9 )'@,@@@
& %@@,@@@
% )@@,@@@
) %;@,@@@ B<9@,@@@C
/$2
/7: I ;@,@@@ G )@@,@@@ G &@,@@@ G
@@@ , )9@
@@@ , 9@@
@@@ , %;@
x
I +)<,@@@
Ad2antages o' <ro'ita?ility inde
aC Simple to use and understand!
bC #he element of /7: in the venture will indicate which venture is more powerful as the
most profitable venture will have the highest 7!$! as the difference or net 7!$! will
continue to the companyDs profitability!
cC $t acknowledges time value for money and at the same time the /7: of a venture at its
present value which is consistent with investment appraisal requirements!
Disad2antages o' <ro'ita?ility inde
aC $t may be useful under conditions of uncertain cost of finance used to discount inflows
and yet this cost is a complex item due to the implicit and explicit element!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 44I
bC $t may be difficult to ascertain if the economic life of a venture is long and it yields
large inflows because their discounting may call for use of computers that are
expensive!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
444 Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
COM+A,&SON O* MET-ODS
*oth traditional and modern methods will show or indicate strong weaknesses such that a
company cannot use either to select a viable venture and for this reason the selection of the
investment will depend on which method the company has identified it can meet its investment
needs! #he choice should not be limited to one method but at least % modern methods! $n all,
when ranking pro=ects, a conflict will rise between $33 and /7: especially under the following
conditions:
iC $f the lives of the pro=ects are different!
iiC Where the cash outlay is larger than the other!
iiiC When the cash flow pattern differs i!e the cash flows of one pro=ect may overtime
increase while those of the other decrease! $n this case /7: may give consistently
correct solution especially so because it does not yield multiple rates!
+!+ ,EC&+,OCAL
7*7 expresses the profitability of a pro=ect in terms of years! $t does not show any return as
measure of investment! #he 7*7 reciprocal has been utilised to rectify the situation, but it is
only of value where the pattern of cash flow is relatively consistent and where the life of the
asset is at least double the payback period of the asset! #he payback period is expressed as:
$nvestment
nnual cash flows
#his 7*7 reciprocal is often used as a guide to ascertain the discount factor in discounted cash
flow calculations i!e! to approximate $33!
7ayback period reciprocal I
)@@
)
x
P#P
,E+LACEMENT O* ASSETS
Eam<le
.state 1evelopers purchased a machine five years ago at a cost of Z<,9@@! #he machine had an
expected economic life of )9 years at the time of purchase and a >ero estimated salvage value at
the end of )9 years! $t is being depreciated on a straight line basis and currently has a book
value of Z9,@@@! #he 4inancial -anager has conducted a feasibility study aimed at acquiring a
new machine for Z)%,@@@ and is depreciated over its )@ years useful life! #he new machine will
expand sales from Z)@,@@@ to Z)),@@@ per annum and will reduce labour and materials usage
sufficiently to cut operating cost from Z<,@@@ to Z9,@@@! #he salvage value of the new machine
is Z%,@@@ at the end of useful life! #he current market value of the old machine is Z),@@@ and
tax is &@F! #he firms cost of capital is )@F! #he financial manager wishes to make a decision
on whether to replace the old machine with a new one and he seeks your held!
/!*! #he decision to replace takes into account the following:
aC .stimate the actual cash outlay attributable to the new machine
bC 1etermine the incremental cash flows!
cC 5ompute the /7: of incremental cash flows!
dC dd up the present value of the expected salvage value to the 7!:! of the incremental
cash flow!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 445
eC scertain whether the /7: Bnet present valueC is positive or whether the $33 Binternal
rate of returnC exceed the cost in which case invest if its positive!
Solution
aC $nitial capital for new machines Z
5ash price of new machine )%,@@@
2ess market value of old machine B),@@@C
2ess tax shield on sale of old machine:
-arket value ),@@@
2ess net book value 9,@@@
2oss on disposal &,@@@
#ax shield I &@F x &,@@@ B',@@@C
$ncreamental initial capital ;,&@@
bC 1epreciation of new machine I
yrs )@
@@@ , % @@@ , )%
I ),@@@
1epreciation of old machine I
yrs )@
@ @@@ , 9
I 9@@
$ncreamental depreciation 9@@
N!= #he /*: of old machine after 9 years is Z9,@@@! #his /*: will be depreciated over
the remaining )@ years!
Determine o<erating cas% 'lows=
$ncreamental sales I )),@@@ E )@,@@@ ),@@@
Savings in labour costs I 9,@@@ E <,@@@ %,@@@
$ncreamental .*1# +,@@@
2ess increamental depreciation Bnon"cash itemC B9@@C
$ncreamental .*# %,9@@
2ess tax S &@F ),@@@
$ncreamental .# ),9@@
dd back increamental depreciation 9@@
nnual cash flow %,@@@
#erminal cash flows at end of year )@ is equal to increamental salvage value!
/ew machine salvage value %,@@@
2ess old machine salvage value @
%,@@@
5ompute the /7: S)@F cost of capital:
7!: of cash flows I )&9 ! ' @@@ , % )@ , @@@ , %
)@ ! @
C ) ! ) B )
%@@@
F )@
)@
x xPV!$ x
)%,%;@
7!: of salvage value I
( )
+(' ! @ @@@ , % )@ , @@@ , %
) ! )
)
@@@ , %
F )@
)@
x xPVI$ x
<<%
)+,@'%
2ess increamental initial capital B;,&@@C
$ncreamental /!7!: +,''%
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
44@ Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
3eplace the old machine
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 446
,E&N*O,C&NG J.EST&ONS
J.EST&ON ONE
What are the advantages of discounted cash flows methodsM
J.EST&ONTWO
0iwanda 2imited is considering the purchase of a new machine! #wo alternative machines,
7esi #Q, and Upesi -,%, which will cost Sh!',@@@,@@@ and Sh!<,@@@,@@@ respectively are
available in the market! #he cash flow after taxation of each machine are as follows:
Cas% 'low
0ear +esi TNO
S%(
.<esi MO5
S%(
)
%
+
&
9
'@@,@@@
),(@@,@@@
%,@@@,@@@
+,@@@,@@@
%,&@@,@@@
),(@@,@@@
%,&@@,@@@
+,@@@,@@@
),(@@,@@@
),'@@,@@@
,e>uired
aC 5ompute the net present value of each machine! B( marksC
bC ssuming that each machine represents a pro=ect:
5ompute the return 0iwanda 2imited expects to earn from each of the two
pro=ects! B)@ marksC
5omment on the use of the results obtained in BaC and BbCBiC above in selecting
between the two pro=ects! B& marksC
"Total= 55 marks#
J.EST&ONT-,EE
#he Weka 5ompany 2td! has been considering the criteria that must be met before a capital
expenditure proposal can be included in the capital expenditure programme!
#he screening criteria established by management are as follows:
/o pro=ect should involve a net commitment of funds for more than four years!
ccepted proposals must offer a time ad=usted or discounted rate of return at least equal to the
estimated cost of capital! 7resent estimates are that cost of capital as )9 percent per annum after
tax!
ccepted proposals should average over the life time, an unad=usted rate of return on assets
employed Bcalculated in the conventional accounting method at least equal to the average rate of
return on total assets shown by the statutory financial statements included in the annual report of
the company!
proposal to purchase a new lathe machine is to be sub=ected to these initial screening
processes! #he machine will cost Sh!%,%@@,@@@ and has an estimated useful life of five years at
the end of which the disposal value will be >ero! Sales revenue to be generated by the new
machine is estimated as follows:
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
448 Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
8ear 3evenue BSh!D@@@DC
),+%@
),&&@
),9'@
),'@@
),9@@
dditional operating costs are estimated to be Sh!<@@, @@@ per annum! #ax rates may be
assumed to be +9F payable in the year in which revenue is received! 4or taxation purpose the
machine is to be written off as a fixed annual rate of %@F on cost!
#he financial accounting statements issued by the company in recent years shows that profits
after tax have averaged )(F on total assets!
,e>uired
7resent a report which will indicate to management whether or not the proposal to purchase the
lathe machine meets each of the selection criteria! "Total= 49
marks#
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC What are the features of a sound appraisal techniqueM B' marksC
bC What practical problems are faced by finance managers in capital budgeting decisionsM
B' marksC
cC 1escribe the features of long term investment decisions! B( marksC
J.EST&ON*&/E
00 2td has six pro=ects available for investment as follows:
+roEect &nitial cost S%(FMF N+/ O 48K cost
o' ca<ital
)
%
+
&
9
'
'@
)9
%@
99
+@
&@
%)
;
;
)9
%@
"%
#he firm has Sh!)@@ - available for investment!
$dentify which pro=ects should be undertaken! Using 7!$ and /7: ranking, comment on
your answer!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson *i2e 447
C-ECK 0O., ANSWE,S W&T- T-OSE +,O/&DED &N T-E LESSON 4I
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
44: Ca<ital &n2estment Decisions
LESSON S&3
/AL.AT&ON CONCE+TS &N *&NANCE
&NST,.CT&ONS
3ead 5hapter ( of 4inancial -anagement text book by $! - 7andey!
5omplete answers to rein'orcement questions at the end of the lesson!
5heck model answers given in lesson )@ of the study pack!
3einforcing 5omments
CONTENTS
*ases and importance of valuation
:aluation of ordinary shares
:aluation of bonds and 1ebentures
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson Si 44;
/AL.AT&ON O* !.S&NESS
business may be valued for different reasons such as for merger, takeover, acquisition, or
outright sale or liquidation! $n purchasing a business, a buyer will be interested in not only the
assets but also the future income this business is expected to generate!
!ASES O* /AL.AT&ON
)! T%eoretical 2alue E $n theory, if a purchaser buys a business, he is simply buying a
stream of future income flows and to arrive at the actual purchase price the buyer will:
aC 5onsider the estimated probable cash flows!
bC 1iscount cash flows to their present value!
cC dd together the separate amounts to give the present value of income stream!
Where future income flows are constant:
1
1
]
1
r
r
C PV
n
C ) B )
Where: 7: I 7resent value of income stream
c I $nflow per annum
r I 1iscounting rate
n I /umber of years the inflows will last
Eam<le
s a result of the purchase of an asset, the income stream will increase by Z),@@@ per annum for
%9 years! ssuming a discount rate of %@F, compute the maximum price to be paid for this
asset ignoring taxation!
Solution
-aximum price I 7resent value of all future cash inflows
-aximum price I Z)@,@@@ x 7:4%@F,%9
I Z)@,@@@ x
%@ ! @
C % ! ) B )
%9
I )@,@@@ x &!;&<'
I Z&;,&<'
$n practice the income streams are never uniform and have to be estimated from existing income
shown in the recent accounts!
%! Earning met%od E #he business is valued according to the total stream of income it is
expected to generate over its lifetime!
Determination o' maintaina?le earnings
aC #he first step in arriving at earning based valuation is to estimate the future
maintainable earnings and if the conditions in the future are expected to be similar to
those in the past, it is then prudent to face the forecast on the historical figures!
However, conditions do change and as such changes in cost and revenue! #herefore, a
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
449 /aluation Conce<ts in *inance
detailed examination of profits of the most recent profit and loss account will be
necessary to estimate the effects of the changes! While the information given will
depend upon the nature of the business the general principles to bear in mind must
include the trend of sales and gross profit!
bC nalysis of sales and gross profit percentage by:
iC 7roduct lines
iiC 1epartments
iiiC 6eographical areas
ivC 5ustomer type!
cC 5osts as a percentage of total sales!
dC Unusual fluctuations in the ratios!
eC /ecessity of expenditure in the business e!g! excessive remuneration on expenses
charged!
fC $nclusion of all costs!
gC .ffects of external conditions such as inflation or recession!
However, there are several ways of arriving at the value based on the earnings valuation!
iC .arnings yield valuation
iiC 7rice earnings ratio valuation
iiiC Super profits valuation
&# Earnings 0ield /aluation
.8 is given by the earnings made by the business expressed as a percentage of the market price
of the business i!e!
.8 I .arnings x )@@
-arket price of equity
.8 I .7S x )@@ I .arnings to Shareholders
-7S -arket value of equity
#herefore -arket :alue I .arning to shareholders
.arnings yield
Eam<le
.stimated maintainable earnings are Z%&@,@@@ per annum, rate of return required is %9F!
5ompute the value of the business!
:alue -:C I . x )@@
.8
I %&@,@@@ x )@@
@!%9
-!:! I Z;'@,@@@
#his method can be converted into the theoretical base, especially if the business is going
concern!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson Si 45I
( ) 1
1
]
1
"
C
PV
%9 ! @ )
)
)
Note
s / approaches W
7v I 5
r
I %&@,@@@ I Z;'@,@@@
@!%9
ii# +rice Earning ,atio /aluation
7A. ratio is traditionally used for valuation of shares but it is an important ratio in the valuation
of business! #he 7A. ratio is the measure of how may years earning would LpurchaseD the
market value of the business and is given by:
7A. ratio I -:
.
-: I 7A. x .
/*: #he value of the business can be calculated by taking estimated earnings x 7A. ratio!
/AL.AT&ON O* SEC.,&T&ES=
#he previous methods were ideal for valuing the entire business but it is also necessary to
ascertain the value of part of a business namely shares, or securities or a block of shares in a
limited liability company! #he valuation of securities and shares in particular is necessary in the
following aspects:
iC #o facilitate take"over bids
iiC #o allow for mergers!
iiiC #o facilitate for company accounts disclosure
ivC 4or purposes of acquisitions or disposal of blocks of shares!
vC 4or purposes of computing capital gains tax Bnot applicable in 0enya at presentC
viC 4or tax payers executors in assessing the capital transfers processes
viiC 4or ascertaining stamp duty payable!
However, a number of parties are interested in the value of shares and securities and such will
include:
aC 5ompany shareholders, directors and vendors of the company!
bC #he existing and prospective shareholders!
cC *uyers of a company!
dC #ransferee and transferor parties, in particular from the point of view of income
tax!
eC $ncome tax department!
$n this valuation, it is necessary to look at a company form:
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
454 /aluation Conce<ts in *inance
iC ?uoted company Bquoted sharesC
iiC Unquoted company Bunquoted sharesC
#he valuation of shares will also be influenced by ownership of the company! $f a company is
owned by ma=ority shareholders, its valuation will be different from if it was owned by minority
shareholders! $n addition, it is necessary to value shares because of:
aC $t is a requirement of the 5ompanyDs ct );&( in respect of quoted investments which
should state the investment book value, market value and stock exchange value where
this differs from market value! $n this case, the ct recognises the fact that the value of
shares may not always be reflected in the stock exchange price and for disclosure
purposes, it must be reflected!
iC $n respect of unquoted investments the company must state aggregate amount of the
book value and also state either the directors valuation which could be different from
investors own valuation! lso the company should give specifications of the earnings
and dividends attributed to these shares! #hese are necessary to enable interested
parties to make their own valuations!
iiC $n respect of both quoted and unquoted, shares the company should give details of the
shares so that they can assist in making a valuation of those shares =udged to be
significant for owning the company, namely, if individual investments exceed )@F of
the issued shares of a given class or where the book value of the investment exceeds
)@F of the companyDs assets!
bC 5apital transfer reasons i!e! the capital transfer requires a valuation of shares whether
from one person to another or even if they are transferred at the time of death!
:aluation date is important for valuation of companiesD properties!
#he main difficulties in valuation of shares are:
iC .xistence and method of valuation of goodwill!
iiC Succession of companyDs management
iiiC 6rowth in dividend
ivC 6rowth in equity!
!ASES O* S-A,E /AL.AT&ON
Share valuation can be done on the basis of income and asset values! However, on the basis of
income a share will be entitled to two forms of income! 4or this reason the bases of valuing
shares are:
iC .arnings method
iiC 1ividend method
iiiC ssets method
&# Earnings Met%od "Or Earning !asis /aluation#
Using the earning valuation method, a company will use its 7A. ratio to value its shares!
7A. I -:
.
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson Si 455
-: I . x 7A. "U value of ordinary share!
#he -: can be determined where the estimated earnings have been established by applying the
7A. ratio expected of this type of company!
Eam<le
5ompany P8Q is expected to generate post tax earnings of Sh!%@@,@@@ per annum and
companies in the same trade will generally have a 7A. ratio of eight B(C! ,n account of
company P8Q limited si>e, a ratio of six B'C is considered more appropriate! #he issued share
capital is ),@@@,@@@ordinary shares of Sh!9@ each!
,e>uired
:alue of shares I .7S x 7A.
I .arnings per share x 7A.
I %@@,@@@ x ' I Sh!)%!@@
),@@@,@@@
:alue of *usiness I .arnings x 7A. ratio
-: I . x 7A. I Sh!%@@,@@@ x ' I Sh!)!% million
ii# Di2idend !asis /aluation
,wnership of shares in entities E #he owner to receive a cash flow consisting of future
dividends and the value of a share should correspond to the present value of this future cash
flow! shareholder cannot expect cash flows in perpetuity as he will sell his shares at one time!
7o I 1o
0e
/ote: Where there is growth in equity, 7@ I
g K
g d
e
+ C ) B
@
Eam<le
5ompany P8Q pays a dividend of )@F on its Sh!'@ par value ordinary shares! #his company
uses a discount rate of )9F! ssuming no growth, compute the value of its ordinary share if
thereDs growth of 9F, what would be the value of this companyDs ordinary shares!
aC 7o I 1o 7o I ' I Sh!&@ Bno growthC
0e )9F
bC 7o I 'B)!@9C I Shs!'+ B9F growth rateC
@!)9"@!@9
iii# Asset !ased /aluation
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
45@ /aluation Conce<ts in *inance
#his method takes into account the entire business with reference to its assets and then divides
the resultant value by the number of shares in an issue to give the per share! #he principles are
the same as those in the valuation of businesses computed already! However, if a historical
dividend based on earning based valuation produces a figure which is less than the asset value
then there is a possibility that the buyer may be able to improve the management of the asset
being taken over! $n such a case, a buyer would be prepared to pay a price which though
excessive in terms of income might be =ustified by the underlying assets value!
Eam<le 4
$nformation extracted from the books of 0ent 2imited!
5urrent liabilities
*ank overdraft
Sh!
+@@,@@@
9@,@@@
+9@,@@@
2and
Stock in trade
Sh!
%9@,@@@
)@@,@@@
+9@,@@@
Stock has a realisable value of Sh!(@,@@@ and land Sh!+@@,@@@! #his company is assumed to be
have a share capital of %@,@@@ ordinary shares!
5ompute the value of its shares!
iC ssets method
ssets I 2 H * +@@,@@@
Stock (@,@@@
+(@,@@@
2iabilities \+9@,@@@]
+@,@@@
:alue of shares I +@,@@@ I Sh!)!9@
%@,@@@
Eam<le 5
0 H 0 5ompany 2imited is planning to absorb three other companies so as to realise its sales
records of Sh!9@@,@@@ per annum! $ts accountants have advised the company to maintain such a
si>e that it will enable its shares to sell at a minimum price of Sh!)'! #he companyDs last
published balance sheets indicate the following:
Sh!D@@@D
,rdinary shares of Sh!)@ each 9@,@@@
3eserves '9,@@@
5urrent liabilities &@,@@@
#otal )99,@@@
ssets: Sh!
4ixed assets (@,@@@
5urrent assets <9,@@@
#otal )99,@@@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson Si 456
7rofits for the last 9 years were as follows:
Sh!D@@@D
)! ;,@@@
%! ',@@@
+! )@,@@@
&! (,@@@
9! )<,@@@
7A. ratio applicable is )%:)
5ompute the value of the business indicating the lowest offer price and the highest offer price
and the share value thereof whether it would be viable to take on the three companies if its to
maintain this share value!
+CE ,AT&O MET-OD
7A. I )%:) verage profits I )@,@@@,@@@
#herefore :alue of business I )@,@@@,@@@ x )% I Sh!)%@,@@@,@@@
:alue of shares I Sh!)%@ million I Sh!%&
9 million shares
ASSETS MET-OD
Sh!D@@@D
ssets )99,@@@
2ess: 5urrent liabilities \ &@,@@@]
))9,@@@
:alue of shares I Sh!))9- I Sh!%+
9- shares
Where: 7o I 7rice of ordinary shares
d I 1ividend at the end of year one
7) I 7rice of the share at the end of one year!
/AL.AT&ON O* !ONDS AND DE!ENT.,ES
#his will depend on expected cash flows consisting of annual interest plus the principal amount
to be received at maturity! #he appropriate rate of capitalisation or discount rate to be applied
will depend upon the riskiness of the bond e!g! government bonds are less risky and will
therefore call for lower discount rates than similar bonds issued by private companies which
will call for high rate of discount!
/aluation o' ?onds wit% maturity <eriod
When a bond or debenture has reached maturity, its value can be determined by considering
annual interest payments plus its terminal or maturity and this is done using the 7!:! concept to
discount the cash flows and the result will be compared to the market value of the bond to
ascertain whether it has overvalued or undervalued!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
458 /aluation Conce<ts in *inance
+
+
+
n
t
n t
%d
M
%d
Int
)
C ) B C ) B
Where: $nt I nnual interest
0d I 3equired rate of return
- I #erminalAmaturity value
n I /umber of years to maturity
Eam<le
0 is contemplating purchasing a + year bond worth &@,@@@AI carrying a nominal coupon rate of
interest of )@F! 0 required rate of return is 'F!
What should he be willing to pay now to purchase the bond if it matures at parM
Solution
$nt I )@F x &@,@@@ I &,@@@ p!a!
n I + yrs
0d I 'F
- I &@,@@@
:d I
+ + % )
C @' ! ) B
@@@ , &@
C @' ! ) B
@@@ , &
C @' ! ) B
@@@ , &
C @' ! ) B
@@@ , &
+ + +
I &,@@@ x 7:4'F,+ G &@,@@@ x 7:$4'F,+ I B&@,@@@ x %!'<+C G B&@,@@@ x @!(&@C I &&,%;%
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Lesson Si 457
,E&N*O,C&NG J.EST&ONS
J.EST&ON ONE
aC P8Q 2td is expected to pay a 17S of Sh!' in one yearDs time! #he dividend payout
ratio is '@F and the 3eturn on .quity is )9F!
1etermine whether the share is overvalued if the -7S is Sh!&@! B' marksC
bC What is the significance of valuation securitiesM B9 marksC
cC *5 2td has issued a 9 year >ero coupon rate bond with maturity value of Sh!)@@,@@@!
#he bond is issued at a discount of +%F!
1etermine the rate of return of the bond! B9 marksC
dC What are the advantages of >ero coupon bondM B9 marksC
"Total= 49 marks#
J.EST&ON TWO
/yakua 2imited is contemplating acquiring U>a 2imited!
$ncremental cash flows arising from the acquisition are expected to be as follows:
A2erage o' years "in S%(FIIIF#
4A8 7A4I 44A
5ash flow after taxes
$nvestment required
/et cash flow
)@@
9@
9@
)9@
'@
;@
%@@
<@
)+@
U>a 2imited has an all equity capital structure! #he required rate of return of U>a
2imited is always 9 percent above the risk free rate! #he risk free rate is ; percent!
,e>uired
aC Using the information provided, compute the maximum price that /yakua 2imited
might pay for U>a 2imited! B)&
marksC
bC What other factors might influence the management of /yakua 2imited in their decision
to purchase U>a 2imitedM B'
marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
J.EST&ON T-,EE
aC ndreas 5ompany 2td! currently pays a dividend of Sh!% per share and this
dividend is expected to grow at an annual rate of )9F for the first + years then
at a rate of )@F for the next + years after which it is expected to grow at a rate
of 9F thereafter!
What value would you place on the stock if an )(F rate of return were
requiredM B<
marksC
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
45: /aluation Conce<ts in *inance
Would your valuation change if you expected to hold the stock for only +
yearsM .xplain! B9
marksC
bC #he stream of dividends of P8Q 2td for the past & years was as follows:
8ear );;; %@@@ %@@) %@@%
17S Sh! %!9@ %!'9 %!<' %!()
#he cost of equity is )&F! 1etermine the price of a share! B(
marksC
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC #he valuation of ordinary shares is more complicated than the valuation of bonds and
preference shares! .xplain the factors that complicate the valuation of ordinary
shares! B' marksC
#he most recent financial data for the 3are Watts disclose the following:
1ividend per share Sh!+!@@
.xpected annual dividend growth rate ' percent
5urrent required rate of return )9 percent
#he company is considering a variety of proposals in order to redirect the firmDs
activities! #he following four alternatives have been suggested:
)! 1o nothing in which case the key financial variables will remain unchanged!
%! $nvest in venture that will increase the dividend growth rate to <F and lower
the required rate of return to )&F!
+! .liminate an unprofitable product line! #he action will increase the dividend
growth rate to (F and raise the required rate of return to )<F!
&! cquire a subsidiary operation from another company! #his action will
increase the dividend growth rate to ;F and required rate of return to )(F!
,e>uired
4or each of the proposed actions, determine the resulting impact price and recommend the best
alternative!
"Total= 46
marks#
END O* COM+,E-ES&/E
C-ECK 0O., ANSWE,S W&T- T-OSE +,O/&DED &N LESSON 4I
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
45; Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
LESSON SE/EN
D&/&DEND +OL&C&ES AND DEC&S&ONS
&NST,.CT&ONS
3ead 5hapters %@ and %) of 4inancial -anagement text book by $! - 7andey!
5omplete answers to rein'orcement questions at the end of the lesson!
5heck model answers given in lesson )@ of the study pack!
3einforcing 5omments
CONTENTS
1ividend 7olicy and 1ecisions
lternative 1ividend 7olicies
1ividend #heories
-ode of paying 1ividends
4actors influencing dividend policies
1ividend ratios
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Se2en 459
D&/&DEND +OL&C&ES AND DEC&S&ONS
1ividend policy determines the division of earnings between payment to stock holders ad re"
investment in the firm! $t therefore looks at the following aspects:
iC! How much to pay E this encompassed in the four ma=or alternative dividend policies!
5onstant mount ,f 1ividend 7er Share
5onstant 7ayout 3atio
4ixed 1ividend 7lus .xtra
3esidual 1ividend 7olicy
iiC When to pay E paying interim or final dividends
iiiC Why dividends are paid E this is explained by the various theories which has to
determine the relevance of dividend payment i!e!:
3esidual dividend theory
1ividend irrelevance theory B--C
Signalling theory
*ird in hand theory
5lientele theory
gency theory
ivC How to pay: cash or stock dividends!
&m<ortance o' Di2idend Decisions
1ividends decisions are integral part of a firmDs strategic 'inancing decision! $t is therefore a
plan of action adopted by management e!g payment of high dividends means less retained
earnings and the firm may have to go to the market to borrow for investment purposes! #his
will increase its gearing level!
Solution to t%e Di2idend +uDDle
firms dividend decision may have some relevance to the firmDs share value! #he managers
therefore requires to formulate an optimal dividend policy which will maximi>e the wealth of
the shareholders Bvalue of sharesC!
i# -OW M.C- TO +A0= ALTE,NAT&/E D&/&DENDS +OL&C&ES
a# Constant <ayout ratio
#his is where the firm will pay a fixed dividend rate e!g! &@F of earnings! #he 17S would
therefore fluctuate as the earnings per share changes!
1ividends are directly dependent on the firms earnings ability and if no profits are made no
dividend is paid!
#his policy creates uncertainty to ordinary shareholders especially who rely on dividend income
and they might demand a higher required rate of return!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4@I Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
?# Constant amount <er s%are "'ied D(+(S(#
#he 17S is fixed in amount irrespective of the earnings level! #his creates certainty and is
therefore preferred by shareholders who have a high reliance on dividend income!
$t protects the firm from periods of low earnings by fixing, 17S at a low level!
#his policy treats all shareholders like preferred shareholders by giving a fixed return! #he 17S
could be increased to a higher level if earnings appear relatively permanent and sustainable!
c# Constant D+S <lus EtraCSur<lus
Under this policy a constant 17S is paid every year! However extra dividends are paid in years
of supernormal earnings!
$t gives the firm flexibility to increase dividends when earnings are high and the shareholders
are given a chance to participate in super normal earnings
#he extra dividends is given in such a way that it is not perceived as a commitments by the firm
to continue the extra dividend in the future! $t is applied by the firms whose earnings are highly
volatile e!g agricultural sector!
d# ,esidual di2idend <olicy
Under this policy dividend is paid out of earnings left over after investment decisions have been
financed! 1ividend will only be paid if there are no profitable investment opportunities
available! #he policy is consistent with shareholders wealth maximi>ation!
ii# W-EN TO +A0
4irms pay interim or final dividends! $nterim dividends are paid at the middle of the year and
are paid in cash! 4inal dividends are paid at year end and can be in cash or bonus issue!
iii# D&/&DENDS T-EO,&ES "W-0 +A0 D&/&DENDS#
#he main theories are:
4( ,esidual di2idend t%eory
Under this theory, a firm will pay dividends from residual earnings i!e! earnings remaining after
all suitable pro=ects with positive /7: has been financed!
$t assumes that retained earnings is the best source of long term capital since it is readily
available and cheap! #his is because no floatation cash are involved in use of retained earnings
to finance new investments!
#herefore, the first claim on earnings after tax and preference dividends will be a reser2e for
financing investments!
1ividend policy is irrelevant and treated as passive variable! $t will not affect the value of the
firm! However, investment decisions will!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Se2en 4@4
Ad2antages o' ,esidual T%eory
4( Sa2ing on 'loatation costs
/o need to raise debt or equity capital since there is high retention of earnings which requires
no floatation costs!
5( A2oidance o' dilution o' owners%i<
/ew equity issue would dilute ownership and control! #his will be avoided if retention is high!
high retention policy may enable financing of firms with rapid and high rate of growth!
@( Ta <osition o' s%are%olders
High"income shareholders prefer low dividends to reduce their tax burden on dividends income!
#hey prefer high retention of earnings which are reinvested, increase share value and they can
gain capital gains which are not taxable in 0enya!
ii# MM Di2idend &rrele2ance T%eory
Was advanced by -odiglian and -iller in );')! #he theory asserts that a firmDs dividend
policy has no effect on its market value and cost of capital!
#hey argued that the firmDs value is primarily determined by:
bility to generate earnings from investments
2evel of business and financial risk
ccording to -- dividend policy is a passive residue determined by the firmDs need for
investment funds!
$t does not matter how the earnings are divided between dividend payment to shareholders and
retention! #herefore, optimal dividend policy does not exist! Since when investment decisions
of the firms are given, dividend decision is a mere detail without any effect on the value of the
firm!
#hey base on their arguments on the following assumptions:
)! /o corporate or personal kites
%! /o transaction cost associated with share floatation
+! firm has an investment policy which is independent of its dividend policy Ba fixed
investment policyC
&! .fficient market E all investors have same set of information regarding the future of the
firm
9! /o uncertainty E all investors make decisions using the same discounting rate at all time
i!e required rate of return BrC I cost of capital BkC!
iii# !irdAinA%and t%eory
dvanced by Nohn 2itner B);'%C and furthered by -yron 6ordon B);'+C!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4@5 Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
rgues that shareholders are risk a2erse and prefer certainty! 1ividends payments are more
certain than capital gains which rely on demand and supply forces to determine share prices!
#herefore, one bird in hand Bcertain dividendsC is better than two birds in the bush Buncertain
capital gainsC!
#herefore, a firm paying high dividends BcertainC will have %ig%er 2alue since shareholders will
require to use lower discounting rate!
-- argued against the above proposition! #hey argued that the required rate of return is
independent of dividend policy! #hey maintained that an investor can reali>e capital gains
generated by reinvestment of retained earning, if they sell shares!
$f this is possible, investors would be indifferent between cash dividends and capital gains!
i2# &n'ormation signaling e''ect t%eory
dvanced by Stephen 3oss in );<<! He argued that in an inefficient market, management can
use dividend policy to signal important information to t%e market w%ic% is only known to
t%em(
Eam<le E $f the management pays high dividends, it signals high expected profits in future to
maintain the high dividend level! #his would increase the share priceAvalue and vice versa!
-- attacked this position and suggested that the change in share price following the change in
dividend amount is due to in'ormational content o' di2idend <olicy rather than dividend
policy itself!#herefore, dividends are irrelevant if information can be given to the market to all
players!
1ividend decisions are relevant in an inefficient market and the higher the dividends, the higher
the value of the firm! #he theory is based on the following four assumptions:
)! #he sending of signals by the management should be cost effective!
%! #he signals should be correlated to observable events Bcommon trend in the marketC!
+! /o company can imitate its competitors in sending the signals!
&! #he managers can only send true signals even if they are bad signals! Sending untrue
signals is financially disastrous to the survival of the firm!
2# Ta di''erential t%eory
dvanced by 2it>enberger and 3amaswamy in );<;
#hey argued that tax rate on dividends is higher than tax rate on capital gains!#herefore, a firm
that pays high dividends have lower value since shareholders pay more tax on dividends!
1ividend decisions are relevant and the lower the dividend the higher the value of the firm and
vice versa!
Note
$n 0enya, dividends attract a withholding tax of 9F which is final and capital gains are tax
exempt!
2i# Clientele e''ect t%eory
dvance by 3ichardson 7etit in );<<
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Se2en 4@@
$t stated that different groups of shareholders BclienteleC have different preferences for dividends
depending on their level of income from other sources!
2ow income earners prefer high dividends to meet their daily consumption while high income
earners prefer low dividends to avoid payment of more tax! #herefore, when a firm sets a
dividend policy, thereDll be shifting of investors into and out of the firm until an equilibrium is
achieved! 2ow, income shareholders will shift to firms paying high dividends and high income
shareholders to firms paying low dividends!
t equilibrium, dividend policy will be consistent with clientele of shareholders a firm has!
1ividend decision at equilibrium are irrelevant since they cannot cause any shifting of investors!
2ii# Agency t%eory
#he agency problem between shareholders and managers can be resolved by paying high
dividends! $f retention is low, managers are required to raise additional equity capital to finance
investment!.ach fresh equity issue will expose the managers financing decision to providers of
capital e!g bankers, investors, suppliers etc!-anagers will thus engage in activities that are
consistent with maximi>ation of shareholders wealth by making full disclosure of their
activities!
#his is because they know the firm will be exposed to external parties through external
borrowing! 5onsequently, gency costs will be reduced since the firm becomes self"regulating!
1ividend policy will have a beneficial effect on the value of the firm! #his is because dividend
policy can be used to reduce agency problem by reducing agency costs!#he theory implies that
firms adopting high dividend payout ratio will have a higher due to reduced agency costs!
-ow to <ay di2idends "mode o' <aying di2idends#
)! 5ash and *onus issue
%! Stock split and reverse split
+! Stock repurchase
&! Stock rightsArights issue Bto discuss in classC
4( Cas% and ?onus issue
4or a firm to pay cash dividends, it should have adequate liquid funds!
However, under conditions of liquidity and financial constraints, a firm can pay stock dividend
B*ank issueC
*onus issue involves issue of additional shares for free Binstead of cashC to existing shareholders
in their shareholding proportion!
Stock dividendA*onus issue involves capitali>ation of retained earnings and does not increase
the wealth of shareholders! #his is because 3! .arnings is converted into shares!
Ad2antages o' !onus &ssue
a# Ta ad2antages
Shareholders can sell new shares, and generate cash in form of capital gains which is tax exempt
unlike cash dividends which attract 9F withholding tax which is final
?# &ndication o' %ig% <ro'its in 'uture=
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4@6 Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
*onus issue, in an inefficient market conveys important information about the future of the
company!
$t is declared when management expects increase in earning to offset additional outstanding
shares so that .!7!S is not diluted!
c# Conser2ation o' cas%
*onus issue conserves cash especially if the firm is in liquidity problems!
d# &ncrease in 'uture di2idends
$f a firm follows a fixedAconstant 1!7!S policy, then total future dividend would increase due to
increase in number of shares after bonus issue!
Nournal entry in case of bonus issue
1r! 3! .arnings Bpar valueC
5r! ,rdinary share capital Bpar valueC
N!: firm can also make a script issue where bonus shares are directly from capital reserve!
5( Stock S<lit and ,e2erse S<lit
#his is where a block of shares is broken down into smaller units BsharesC so that the number of
ordinary shares increases and their respective par value decreases at the stock split factor!
Stock split is meant to make the shares of a company more affordable by low income investors
and increase their liquidity in the market!
&llustration
*5 5ompany has )@@@ ordinary shares of Sh!%@ par value and a split of ):& i!e one stock is
split into &! #he par value is divided by &!
)@@@ stocks x & I &@@@ shares
par value I &@ I Sh!9
9
,rdinary share capital I &@@@ x 9 I Shs!%@,@@@
reverse split is the opposite of stock split and involves consolidation of shares into bigger
units thereby increasing the par value of the shares! $t is meant to attract high income clientele
shareholders! .!g incase of %@,@@@ shares S Shs!%@ par, they can be consolidated into )@,@@@
shares of Shs!&@ par! $!e! B%@,@@@ x RC I )@,@@@ and Sh!%@ I x % I &@AI
@( Stock ,e<urc%ase
#he company can also buy back some of its outstanding shares instead of paying cash
dividends! #his is known as stock re<urc%ase and shares repurchased, Bbought backC are called
treasury Stock! $f some outstanding shares are repurchased, fewer shares would remain
outstanding!
ssuming repurchase does not adversely affect firmDs earnings, .!7!S! of share would increase!
#his would result in an increase in -!7!S! so that capital gain is substituted for dividends!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Se2en 4@8
Ad2antages o' Stock ,e<urc%ase
4( $t may be seen as a true signal as repurchase may be motivated by management belief
that firmDs shares are undervalued! #his is true in inefficient markets!
5( .tiliDation o' idle 'unds
5ompanies, which have accumulated cash balances in excess of future investments, might find
share reinvestment scheme a fair method of returning cash to shareholders!
5ontinuing to carry excess cash may prompt management to invest unwisely as a means of
using excess cash!
Eam<le
firm may invest surplus cash in an expensive acquisition, transferring value to another group
of shareholders entirely! #here is a tendency for more mature firms to continue with investment
plan even when . B0C is lower than cost of capital!
@( En%anced di2idends and E(+(S(
4ollowing a stock repurchase, the number of shares issued would decrease and therefore in
normal circumstances both 1!7!S! and .!7!S! would increase in future! However, the increase in
.!7!S is a bookkeeping increase since total earnings remaining constant!
6( En%anced S%are +rice
5ompanies that undertake share repurchase, experience an increase in market price of the
shares! #his is partly explained by increase in total earnings having less andAor market signal
effect that shares are under value!
8( Ca<ital structure
companyDs managers may use a share buy back or requirements, as a means of correcting
what they perceive to be an unbalanced capital structure!
$f shares are repurchased from cash reserves, equity would be reduced and gearing increased
Bassuming debt exists in the capital structureC!
lternatively a company may raise debt to finance a repurchase! 3eplacing equity with debt can
reduce overall cost of capital due to tax advantage of debt!
7( Em<loyee incenti2e sc%emes
$nstead of cancelling all shares repurchase, a firm can retain some of the shares for employees
share option or profit sharing schemes!
:( ,educed take o2er t%reat
share repurchase reduced number of share in operation and also number of Lweak
shareholdersD i!e shareholders with no strong loyalty to company since repurchase would induce
them to sell!
#his helps to reduce threat of a hostile takeover as it makes it difficult for predator company to
gain control! B#his is referred as a poison pillC i!e! 5o!Ds value is reduced because of high
repurchase price, huge cash outflow or borrowing huge long term debt to increase gearing
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4@7 Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
Disad2antages o' stock re<urc%ase
4( -ig% <rice
company may find it difficult to repurchase shares at their current value and price paid may
be too high to the detriment of remaining shareholders!
5( Market Signaling
1espite directorDs effort at trying to convince markets otherwise, a share repurchase may be
interpreted as a signal suggesting that the company lacks suitable investment opportunities!
#his may be interpreted as a sign of management failure!
@( Loss o' in2estment income
#he interest that could have been earned from investment of surplus cash is lost!
*actors to consider in <aying di2idends "'actors in'luencing di2idend#
4( Legal rules
aC /et purchase rule
States that dividend may be paid from companyDs profit either past or present!
bC 5apital impairment rule: prohibits payment of dividends from capital i!e! from
sale of ssets! #his is liquidating the firm!
cC $nsolvency rule: prohibits payment of dividend when company is insolvent!
$nsolvent company is one where assets are less than liabilities! $nsolvent
company is one where assets are less than liabilities! $n such a case all earnings
and assets of company belong to debt holders and no dividends is paid!
5( +ro'ita?ility and li>uidity
companyDs capacity to pay dividend will be determined primarily by its ability to generate
adequate and stable profits and cash flow!
$f the company has liquidity problem, it may be unable to pay cash dividend and result to paying
stock dividend!
@( Taation <osition o' s%are%olders
1ividend payment is influenced by tax regime of a country e!g in 0enya cash dividend are
taxable at source, while capital are tax exempt(
#he effect of tax differential is to discourage shareholders from wanting high dividends! B#his
is explained by tax differential theoryC!
6( &n2estment o<<ortunity
2ack of appropriate investment opportunities i!e! those with positive returns B/!7!:!C, may
encourage a firm to increase its dividend distribution! $f a firm has many investment
opportunities, it will pay low dividends and have high retention!
8( Ca<ital Structure
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Se2en 4@:
companyDs management may wish to achieve or restore an optimal capital structure i!e! if
they consider gearing to be too high, they may pay low dividends and allow reserves to
accumulate until a more optimalAappropriate capital structure is restoredAachieved!
7( &ndustrial +ractice
5ompanies will be resistant to deviation from accepted dividend or payment norms within the
industry!
:( Growt% Stage
1ividend policy is likely to be influenced by firmDs growth stage e!g a young rapidly growing
firm is likely to have high demand for development finance and therefore may pay low dividend
or a defer dividend payment until company reaches maturity! $t will retain high amount!
;( Owners%i< Structure
dividend policy may be driven by #ime ,wnership Structure e!g in small firms where owners
and managers are same, dividend payout are usually low!
However in a large quoted public company dividend payout are significant because the owners
are not the managers! However, the values and preferences of small group of owner managers
would exert more direct influence on dividend policy!
9( S%are%olders e<ectation
Shareholder clientele that have become accustomed to receiving stable and increasing div! Will
expect a similar pattern to continue in the future!
ny sudden reduction or reversal of such a policy is likely to dissatisfy the shareholders and
may result in a fail in share prices!
4I( Access to ca<ital markets
2arge, well established firms have access to capital markets hence can get funds easily
#hey pay high dividends thus, unlike small firms which pay low dividends Bhigh retentionC due
to limited borrowing capacity!
44( Contractual o?ligations on de?t co2enants
#hey limit the flexibility and amount of dividends to pay e!g! no payment of dividends from
retained earnings!
Di2idend ratios
)! 1ividend per shares B17SC I .arnings to ordinary shareholders
/umber of ordinary shares
$ndicate cash returns received fro every share holder!
%! 1ividend yield B18C I 17S
-7S
$ndicate dividend returns for every shilling invested in the firm!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4@; Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
+! 1ividend cover I 17S
17S
$ndicate the number of times dividends can be paid out of earnings of shareholders! #he higher
the 17S the lower the dividend cover!
&! 1ividend 7ayout 3atio I 17S
.7S
Shows the proportion of .arnings which was paid out as dividends and how much was retained!
,E&N*O,C&NG J.EST&ONS
J.EST&ON ONE
comparative study of the records of two oil companies, 2td and * 2td!, in terms of their
asset composition, capital structure and profitability shows that they have been very similar for
the past five years! #he only significant difference between the two firms is their dividend
policy! 2td! maintains a constant dividend per share while * 2td maintains a constant
dividend pay"out ratio! 3elevant data is as follows:
8ear .arnings
per share
Shs!
1ividend
per share
Shs!
7rice range
in stock
exchange
Shs!
.arnings
per share
Shs!
1ividend
per share
Shs!
7rice range
in stock
exchange
Shs!
);;'
);;<
);;(
);;;
%@@@
)!(;
)!9@
%!@@
%!'@
+!;@
@!&9
@!&9
@!&9
@!&9
@!&9
)' E )(
)% E )9
)& E %@
%) E %'
%' E &@
%!@9
)!&9
%!@<
%!99
&!@(
@!+9
@!%9
@!+'
@!&9
@!';
)) E )9
' " )&
< " )'
)9 E %+
%) E &&
,e>uired
aC 4or each company, determine the dividend pay"out ratio and the price earnings ratio
for each of the five years! B)%
marksC
bC * 2tdDs management is surprised that the shares of this company have not performed
as well as 2td!Ds in the stock exchange! What explanation would you offer for this
state of affairsM B&
marksC
5omment on the applicability of the Simple 7riceA.arnings B7A.C ratio to the typical
technology B$#C company with a high valuation and heavy losses!
B& marksC
J.EST&ON TWO
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Se2en 4@9
aC $n relation to the financing of a firm, differentiate the following terms:
iC 4inancial structure from capital structure! B9
marksC
iiC *usiness risk from financial risk! B9
marksC
bC What is meant by gearing as used in the capital structure of 2imited 2iability 5ompanyM
B% marksC
#he following information is on a company in the power generation business:
)@F preference shares BSh!)@ parC
,rdinary share capital BSh!)@ parC
3etained profits
)9F debentures
S%s(
&@@,@@@
&@@,@@@
(@@,@@@
<@@,@@@
),9@@,@@@
),%@@,@@@
%,<@@,@@@
,e>uired
iC 5alculate the gearing ratio for the above company! B%
marksC
iiC $f the companyDs net profit Bbefore interest and taxC is Sh!%,@@@,@@@,@@@ and assuming a
dividend payout ratio of '@F of the earnings, compute the dividend per share B17SC!
B' marksC
iiiC $f the market price per share now is Sh!(@, compute the dividend yield!
B% marksC
"Total= 55 marks#
J.EST&ON T-,EE
.xplain the reasons why firms in the same industry with equal earnings and share capital would
pay different amount of dividendsM
C-ECK 0O., ANSWE,S W&T- T-OSE G&/EN &N LESSON 4IO* T-E ST.D0
+ACK
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
46I Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
COM+,E-ENS&/E ASS&GNMENT NO(@
TO !E S.!M&TTED A*TE, LESSON ;
To !e Carried Out .nder Eamination Condition and Sent to Distance learning
Administrator 'or marking ?y t%e .ni2ersity
Answer All Juestions Time Allowed= T%ree -ours
J.EST&ON ONE
#he most recent balance sheet for Supremo 2td is presented here below:
Su<remo Ltd !alance S%eet M @I No2em?er 4998
Sh!
L@@@D
Sh!
L@@@D
5urrent ssets
4ixed ssets BnetC
(,(@@
)+,%@@
YYYY
%%,@@@
#rade creditors
ccrued expenses
5urrent liabilities
2ong"term debt
,rdinary shares
3etained earnings
%,%@@
%,%@@
&,&@@
(,(@@
%,%@@
','@@
%%,@@@
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Se2en 464
#he company is about to embark on an advertising campaign which is expected to raise sales
from their present level of Sh!%<!9 million to Sh!+(!9 million by the end of next financial year!
#he firm is presently operating at full capacity and will have to increase its investment in both
current and fixed assets to support the pro=ected level of sales! $t is estimated that both
categories of assets will rise in direct proportion to the pro=ected increase in sales!
4or the year =ust ended, the firmDs net profits were 'F of the yearDs sales but are expected to rise
to <F of pro=ected sales! #o help support its anticipated growth in assets needs next year the
firm has suspended plans to pay cash dividends to its shareholders! $n years past, a dividend of
Sh!'!'@ per share has been paid annually!
SupremoDs trade creditors and accrued expenses are expected to vary directly with sales! $n
addition, notes payable will be used to supply the added funds to finance next years operations
that are not forthcoming from other sources!
,e>uired
aC iC .stimate the amount of additional funds to be raised through notes
payable! B&
marksC
iiC What one fundamental assumption have you made in making your estimateM
B% marksC
bC 7repare pro"forma balance sheet of Supremo 2td! on +@ /ovember );;'!
B)+ marksC
cC iC 5alculate and compare Supremo 2td!Ds current and debt ratios before and after
growth in sales! B& marksC
iiC What was the effect of the expanded sales on these two dimensions of
SupremoDs financial conditionM B%
marksC
"Total= 58 marks#
J.EST&ON TWO
P8Q 2td is intending to raise capital to finance a new pro=ect! #he current -!7!S is Sh!&+ cum"
div of year %@@) declared but not yet paid! 4or the past 9 years, the company has paid the
following stream of dividends!
8ear );;< );;( );;; %@@@ %@@)
1!7!S )!;@ %!%9 %!'@ %!'@ +!@@
#he existing capital structure of the firm is as follows:
Sh!-
,rdinary share capital Sh!)@ par &@
3etained earnings +9
)%F 1ebenture Sh!)@@ par %9
)@@
#he debentures are currently selling at Sh!;9 ex"interest! #he corporate tax rate is +@F!
,e>uired
aC 1istinguish between cum"div and ex"div -!7!S! B& marksC
bC 5ompute the ex"div -!7!S! B% marksC
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
465 Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
cC 5ompute the overall cost of capital! Use dividend growth model
to determine the cost of equity!
B; marksC
dC #he company wants to raise additional Sh!%@ million as follows:
9@F from retained earnings
+@F from issue of debentures at the current market value
%@F from issue of new ordinary shares with )@F floatation costs
iC 5ompute the number of ordinary shares to issue to raise the amount required!
B% marksC
iiC 5ompute the marginal cost of capital! B' marksC
!
J.EST&ON T-,EE
#he 0itale -ai>e -ills is contemplating the purchase of a new high"speed grinder to replace an
existing one! #he existing grinder was purchased two years ago at an installed cost of
Sh!+@@,@@@! #he grinder was estimated to have an economic life of 9 years but a critical
analysis of its performance now shows it is usable for the next five years with no resale value!
#he new grinder would cost Sh!9%9,@@@ and require Sh!%9,@@@ in installation costs! $t has a five
year usable life! #he existing grinder can currently be sold for Sh!+9@,@@@ without incurring
any removal costs! #o support the increased business resulting from purchase of the new
grinder, accounts receivable would increase by Sh!%@@,@@@, inventories by Sh!)9@,@@@ and trade
creditors by Sh!%;@,@@@! t the end of 9 years the new grinder would be sold to net Sh!)&9,@@@
after removal costs and before taxes! #he company provides for &@F taxes on ordinary income!
#he estimated profit before depreciation and taxes over the five years for both machines are
given as follows:
8ear .xisting grinder
S%s(
/ew grinder
S%(
)
%
+
&
9
)+@,@@@
)%@,@@@
))@,@@@
)@@,@@@
;@,@@@
%)9,@@@
%)9,@@@
%)9,@@@
%)9,@@@
%)9,@@@
#he company uses straight line method of depreciation for both machines!
,e>uired
aC 5alculate the initial investment associated with the replacement of the existing grinder
with the new one! Show your full workings! B'
marksC
bC 1etermine the incremental operating cash flows associated with the proposed grinder
replacement! B)& marksC
cC 5alculate the terminal cash flow expected from the proposed grinder replacement!
B% marksC
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Se2en 46@
"Total= 55 marks#
J.EST&ON *O.,
1ereva and -akanga are considering purchasing the new +@ passenger Jwonder coachK to
engage in transport business! #hey have two alternatives of financing the purchase as shown
below:
*irst alternati2e
7urchase the vehicle whose current price is Sh!%,&@@,@@@ through a finance lease from
0enya -atatu 4inance 5ompany 2imited! #he terms of the lease will require four
equal payments per year for each of the three years! /o deposit is required!
Second alternati2e
,btain the vehicle through -wananchiDs *ank loan scheme being advertised in the papers!
1ereva and -akanga will be required to make a down payment of Sh!;@@,@@@ and then meet
four equal yearly payments of Sh!)9+,&+' each for the three years!
#he market rate of interest is currently )' per cent per annum!
1ereva and -akanga have been informed that as part of your social responsibility, you provide
free consultancy services to small scale businessmen!
,e>uired
aC #he finance lease payment to be made by 1ereva and -akanga if they opt for finances
from 0enya -atatu 4inance 5ompany 2imited! B& marksC
bC #he present value of the payment scheme of -wananchi *ank! B& marksC
cC #he interest expense charged by 0enya -atatu 4inance 5ompany 2imited on the third
instalment! B' marksC
6ive reasons why finance leases are referred to as Joff"balance sheetK finance!
B& marksC
eC iC Which of the two alternatives E 4inance 2ease or *ank 2oan scheme is
better in financial termsM B%
marksC
iiC 6ive one reason why the better alternative may not necessarily be
chosen by persons in 1ereva and -akangaDs circumstances! B%
marksC
"Total= 55 marks#
J.EST&ON *&/E
8ou are provided with the following information about -arco! 2td!
iC /umber of issued ordinary shares %9@,@@@
iiC -arket price per ordinary share Shs!+<!9@
iiiC #otal earnings for the year Sh!9,@@@,@@@ Bbefore taxC!
ivC 3ate of corporation tax +@F
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
466 Di2idend +olicies and Decisions
vC #he total ordinary dividend will be %9F of the earnings for the year after tax!
viC 7reference dividend will be Sh!+@@,@@@
4rom the above information, calculate:
iC .arnings per share
iiC 1ividend yield
iiiC .arnings yield
ivC 7rice earnings ratio B7A.C ratio
vC 1ividend cover!
END O* COM+,E-ENS&/E ASS&GNMENT @
NOW SEND TO D&STANCE LEA,N&NG *O, MA,K&NG
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 468
LESSON E&G-T
WO,K&NG CA+&TAL MANAGEMENT
&NST,.CT&ONS
3ead 5hapters %%, %+, %& and %9 of 4inancial -anagement text book by $! - 7andey!
5omplete answers to rein'orcement questions at the end of the lesson!
5heck model answers given in lesson )@ of the study pack!
3einforcing 5omments
CONTENTS
$ntroduction
4inancing of Working 5apital A5urrent ssets
1eterminants of Working 5apital needs
$mportance of working capital management
-anagement of Short term investment
Working capital cycle
-anagement of cash , stock and ccounts 3eceivable
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
467 Working Ca<ital Management
WO,K&NG CA+&TAL
aC Working capital Balso called gross working capitalC refers to current assets!
bC /et working capital refers to current assets minus current liabilities!
cC Working capital management refers to the administration of current assets and current
liabilities!
#arget levels of each category of current assets
How current assets will be financed
dC 2iquidity management involves the planned acquisition and use of liquid resources over
time to meet cash obligations as they become due! #he firmDs liquidity is measured by
liquidity ratio such as current ratio, quick Bor acid testC ratio, cash ratio, etc!
*&NANC&NG C.,,ENT ASSETS
5urrent ssets require financing by use of either current funds or long term funds! #here are
three ma=or approaches to financing current assets! #hese are:
a# Matc%ing A<<roac%
#his approach is sometimes referred to as the hedging approach! Under this approach, the firm
adopts a financial plan which involves the matching of the expected life of assets with the
expected life of the source of funds raised to finance assets!
#he firm, therefore, uses long term funds to finance permanent assets and short"term funds to
finance temporary assets!
7ermanent assets refer to fixed assets and permanent current assets! #his approach can be shown
by the following diagram!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 46:
?# Conser2ati2e A<<roac%
n exact matching of asset life with the life of the funds used to finance the asset may not be
possible! firm that follows the conservative approach depends more on long"term funds for
financing needs! #he firm, therefore, finances its permanent assets and a part of its temporary
assets with long"term funds! #his approach is illustrated by the following diagram!
3isk"3eturn trade"off of the three approaches:
$t should be noted that short"term funds are cheaper than long"term funds! BSome sources of
short"term funds such as accruals are cost"freeC! However, short"term funds must be repaid
within the year and therefore they are highly risky! With this in mind, we can consider the risk"
return trade off of the three approaches!
#he conservative approach is a low return"low risk approach! #his is because the approach uses
more of long"term funds which are now more expensive than short"term funds! #hese funds
however, are not to be repaid within the year and are therefore less risky!
#he aggressive approach on the other hand is a highly risky approach! However it is also a high
return approach the reason being that it relies more on short"term funds that are less costly but
riskier!
#he matching approach is in between because it matches the life of the asset and the life of the
funds financing the assets!
DETE,M&NANTS O* WO,K&NG CA+&TAL NEEDS
#here are several factors which determine the firmDs working capital needs! #hese factors are
comprehensively covered by #extbook of *usiness 4inance by -anasseh B7ages &@+ E &@'C!
#hey however include:
aC /ature and si>e of the business!
bC 4irmDs manufacturing cycle
cC *usiness fluctuations
dC 7roduction policy
eC 4irmDs credit policy
fC vailability of credit
gC 6rowth and expansion activities!
&M+O,TANCE O* WO,K&NG CA+&TAL MANAGEMENT
#he finance manager should understand the management of working capital because of the
following reasons:
a# Time de2oted to working ca<ital management
large portion of a financial managerDs time is devoted to the day to day operations of the firm
and therefore, so much time is spent on working capital decisions!
?# &n2estment in current assets
5urrent assets represent more than half of the total assets of many business firms! #hese
investments tend to be relatively volatile and can easily be misappropriated by the firmDs
employees! #he finance manager should therefore properly manage these assets!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
46; Working Ca<ital Management
c# &m<ortance to small 'irms
small firm may minimise its investments in fixed assets by renting or leasing plant and
equipment, but there is no way it can avoid investment in current assets! small firm also has
relatively limited access to long term capital markets and therefore must rely heavily on short"
term funds!
d# ,elations%i< ?etween sales and current assets
#he relationship between sales volume and the various current asset items is direct and close!
5hanges in current assets directly affects the level of sales! #he finance management must
therefore keep watch on changes in working capital items!
CAS- AND MA,KETA!LE SEC.,&T&ES MANAGEMENT
#he management of cash and marketable securities is one of the key areas of working capital
management! Since cash and marketable securities are the firmDs most liquid assets, they provide
the firm with the ability to meet its maturing obligations!
5ash refers to cash in hand and cash on demand deposits Bor current accountsC! $t therefore
excludes cash in time deposits Bwhich is not immediately available to meet maturing obligationsC!
-arketable securities are short"term investments made by the firm to obtain a return on
temporary idle funds! #hus when a firm realises that it has accumulated more cash than needed,
it often puts the excess cash into an interest"earning instrument! #he firm can invest the excess
cash in any Bor a combinationC of the following marketable securities!
aC 6overnment treasury bills
bC gency securities such as local governments securities or parastatals securities
cC *ankerDs acceptances, which are securities, accepted by banks
dC 5ommercial paper Bunsecured promissory notesC
eC 3epurchase agreements
fC /egotiable certificates of deposits
gC .urocurrencies etc!
CAS- C0CLE AND CAS- T.,NO/E,S
Cas% Cycle refers to the amount of time that elapses from the point when the firm makes a cash
outlay to purchase raw materials to the point when cash is collected from the sale of finished
goods produced using those raw materials!
Cas% turno2er on the other hand refers to the frequency of a firmDs cash cycle during a year!
&llustration
P8Q 2td! currently purchases all its raw materials on credit and sells its merchandise on credit!
#he credit terms extended to the firm currently requires payment within thirty days of a purchase
while the firm currently requires its customers to pay within sixty days of a sale! However, the
firm on average takes +9 days to pay its accounts payable and the average collection period is <@
days! ,n average, (9 days elapse between the point a raw material is purchased and the point the
finished goods are sold!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 469
,e>uired
1etermine the cash conversion cycle and the cash turnover!
Solution
#he following chart can help further understand the question:
$nventory 5onversion period B(9 daysC
3eceivable collection
7eriod B<@ daysC
#he cash conversion cycle is given by the following formula:
5ash conversion I $nventory conversion G 3eceivable collection E 7ayable deferral
5ycle period period period
4or our example:
5ash conversion cycle I (9 G <@ E +9 I )%@ days
5ash turnover I +'@
5ash conversion cycle
I
)%@
+'@
I + times
/ote also that cash conversion cycle can be given by the following formulae:
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
7ayable deferral
7eriod B+9 daysC
7urchase of
raw
7ayment for the
raw materials
Sale of
4inished goods
5ollection of
receivables
5ash conversion cycle I (9 G <@ " +9 I
48I Working Ca<ital Management
!ash conversion cycle "
1
]
1
+
+
s ingexpense Cashoperat
Accruals Payables
sales
s receivable
s costofsale
inventory
60 +
/*: $n this chapter we shall assume that a year has +'@ days!
SETT&NG T-E O+T&MAL CAS- !ALANCE
5ash is often called a non"earning asset because holding cash rather than a revenue"generating
asset involves a cost in form of foregone interest! #he firm should therefore hold the cash
balance that will enable it to meet its scheduled payments as they fall due and provide a margin
for safety! #here are several methods used to determine the optimal cash balance! #hese are:
a# T%e Cas% !udget
#he 5ash *udget shows the firmDs pro=ected cash inflows and outflows over some specified
period! #his method has already been discussed in other earlier courses! #he student should
however revise the cash budget!
?# !aumolFs Model
#he *aumolDs model is an application of the .,? inventory model to cash management! $ts
assumptions are:
)! #he firm uses cash at a steady predictable rate
%! #he cash outflows from operations also occurs at a steady rate
+! #he cash net outflows also occur at a steady rate!
Under these assumptions the following model can be stated:
"
bT
C
%
V
Where: CP is the optimal amount of cash to be raised by selling marketable securities or by
borrowing!
? is the fixed cost of making a securities trade or of borrowing
T is the total annual cash requirements
i is the opportunity cost of holding cash Bequals the interest rate on marketable securities or the
cost of borrowingC
#he total cost of holding the cash balance is equal to holding or carrying cost plus transaction
costs and is given by the following formulae:
b
C
T
C" TC +
%
)
&llustration
*5 2td! makes cash payments of Shs!)@,@@@ per week! #he interest rate on marketable
securities is )%F and every time the company sells marketable securities, it incurs a cost of
Shs!%@!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 484
,e>uired
aC 1etermine the optimal amount of marketable securities to be converted into cash every
time the company makes the transfer!
bC 1etermine the total number of transfers from marketable securities to cash per year!
cC 1etermine the total cost of maintaining the cash balance per year!
dC 1etermine the firmDs average cash balance!
Solution
aC
"
bT
C
%
V
Where: b I Shs!%@
# I 9% x %@,@@@ I Shs!9%@,@@@
i I )%F
)'' , )+ !
)% ! @
@@@ , 9%@ %@ %
V Sh
x x
C
#herefore the optimal amount of marketable securities to be converted to cash every time a sale is
made is Sh!)+,)''!
bC #otal no! of transfers I
V C
T
I
)'' , )+
@@@ , 9%@
I +;!9
X &@ times
cC b
C
T
C" TC +
%
)
I
)'' , )+
%@ @@@ , 9%@
%
)% ! @ )'' , )+ x x
+
I <;@ G <;@ I Shs!),9(@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
485 Working Ca<ital Management
#herefore the total cost of maintaining the above cash balance is Sh!),9(@!
dC #he firmDs average cash balance I R5
I
%
)'' , )+
I Shs!',9(+
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 48@
c# MillerAOrr Model
Unlike the *aumolDs -odel, -iller",rr -odel is a stochastic BprobabilisticC model which makes
the more realistic assumption of uncertainty in cash flows!
-erton -iller and 1aniel ,rr assumed that the distribution of daily net cash flows is
approximately normal! .ach day, the net cash flow could be the expected value of some higher
or lower value drawn from a normal distribution! #hus, the daily net cash follows a trendless
random walk!
4rom the graph below, the -iller",rr -odel sets higher and lower control units, H and 2
respectively, and a target cash balance, Q! When the cash balance reaches H Bsuch as point C
then H"Q shillings are transferred from cash to marketable securities! Similarly, when the cash
balance hits 2 Bat point *C then Q"2 shillings are transferred from marketable securities cash!
#he 2ower 2imit is usually set by management! #he target balance is given by the following
formula:
L
"
#
& +
1
1
1
]
1
+ A )
&
%
+
and the highest limit, H, is given by:
H I +Q " %2
#he average cash balance I
+
& L &
Where: Q I target cash balance
H I Upper 2imit
2 I 2ower 2imit
b I 4ixed transaction costs
i I ,pportunity cost on daily basis
_` I variance of net daily cash flows
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
486 Working Ca<ital Management
&llustration
P8QDs management has set the minimum cash balance to be equal to Sh!)@,@@@! #he standard
deviation of daily cash flow is Sh!%,9@@ and the interest rate on marketable securities is ;F p!a!
#he transaction cost for each sale or purchase of securities is Sh!%@!
,e>uired
aC 5alculate the target cash balance
bC 5alculate the upper limit
cC 5alculate the average cash balance
dC 5alculate the spread
Solution
aC L
"
b
& +
1
1
]
1
+ A )
&
` +
I
@@@ , )@
+'@
F ;
&
C` 9@@ , % B %@ +
+
1
1
1
1
]
1
x
x x
I <,%)) G )@,@@@ I Sh!)<,%))
bC H I +Q E %2
I + x )<,%)) E %B)@,@@@C
I Shs!+),'++
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 488
cC verage cash balance I
+
& L &
I
+
@@@ , )@ %)) , )< & x
dC #he spread I H E 2
I +),'++ E )@,@@@
I Shs!%),'++
/ote: $f the cash balance rises to +),'++, the firm should invest Shs!)&,&%% B+),'++ E )<,%))C in
marketable securities and if the balance falls to Shs!)@,@@@, the firm should sell Shs!<,%))B)<,%))
E )@,@@@C of marketable securities!
Ot%er Met%ods
,ther methods used to set the target cash balance are #he Stone -odel and -onte 5arlo
simulation! However, these models are beyond the scope of this manual!
CAS- MANAGEMENT TEC-N&J.ES
#he basic strategies that should be employed by the business firm in managing its cash are:
iC #o pay account payables as late as possible without damaging the firmDs credit rating!
#he firm should however take advantage of any favourable cash discounts offered!
iiC #urnover inventory as quickly as possible, but avoid stockouts which might result in loss
of sales or shutting down the Lproduction lineD!
iiiC 5ollect accounts receivable as quickly as possible without losing future sales because of
high pressure collection techniques! #he firm may use cash discounts to accomplish this
ob=ective!
$n addition to the above strategies the firm should ensure that customer payments are converted
into spendable form as quickly as possible! #his may be done either through:
aC 5oncentration *anking
bC 2ock"box system!
aC 5oncentration *anking
4irms with regional sales outlets can designate certain of these as regional collection
centre! 5ustomers within these areas are required to remit their payments to these sales
offices, which deposit these receipts in local banks! 4unds in the local bank account in
excess of a specified limit are then transferred Bby wireC to the firms ma=or or
concentration bank!
5oncentration banking reduces the amount of time that elapses between the customerDs
mailing of a payment and the firmDs receipt of such payment!
bC 2ock"box system!
$n a lock"box system, the customer sends the payments to a post office box! #he post
office box is emptied by the firmDs bank at least once or twice each business day! #he
bank opens the payment envelope, deposits the cheques in the firmDs account and sends a
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
487 Working Ca<ital Management
deposit slip indicating the payment received to the firm! #his system reduces the
customerDs mailing time and the time it takes to process the cheques received!
MANAGEMENT O* &N/ENTO,&ES
-anufacturing firms have three ma=or types of inventories:
)! 3aw materials
%! Work"in"progress
+! 4inished goods inventory
#he firm must determine the optimal level of inventory to be held so as to minimi>e the inventory
relevant cost!
!AS&C EOJ MODEL
#he basic inventory decision model is .conomic ,rder ?uantity B.,?C model! #his model is
given by the following equation:
n
o
C
DC
'
%
<9 ! );
9@ @@@ , % % x x
'
d
5n I )9 G )@F x &!<9 I Shs!);!<9
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 474
#he discount should be taken because the net savings is positive! #o determine the number of
units to order we recomputed ? with discount ?d!
I )@@!' units
1ecision rule:
$f ?d a minimum discount quantity, then order the minimum discount quantity!
$f ?d a minimum discount quantity, then order ?d!
.NCE,TA&NT0 AND SA*ET0 STOCKS
Usually demand requirements may not be certain and therefore the firm holds safety stock to
safeguard stock out cases! #he existence of safety stock can be illustrated by 4igure 9!<!
#he safety stock guards against delays in receiving orders! However, carrying a safety stock has
costs Bit increases the average stockC!
&llustration
5onsider illustration one and assume that management desires to hold a minimum stock of )@
units Bthis stock is in hand at the beginning of the yearC!
,e>uired
aC 1etermine the re"order level
bC 1etermine the total relevant costs
Suggested solution
aC 3 I S
DL
+
+'@
Where: S is the safety stock
I
)@ <
+'@
@@@ , %
+ x
I &; units
bC #he average inventory I R? G S
#5 I BR? G SC5n G 1A?5o
I \RB)@@C G )@]%@ G C 9@ B
)@@
@@@ , %
I ),%@@ G ),@@@
I Shs!%,%@@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
475 Working Ca<ital Management
MANAGEMENT O* ACCO.NT ,ECE&/A!LE
$n order to keep current customers and attract new ones, most firms find it necessary to offer
credit! ccounts receivable represents the extension of credit on an open account by a firm to its
customers! ccounts receivable management begins with the decision on whether or not to grant
credit!
#he total amount of receivables outstanding at any given time is determined by:
aC #he volume of credit sales
bC #he average length of time between sales and collections!
ccounts receivables I 5redit sales per day x 2ength of collection period
#he average collection period depends on:
aC 5redit standards which is the maximum risk of acceptable credit accounts
bC 5redit period which is the length of time for which credit is granted
cC 1iscount given for early payments
dC #he firmDs collection policy!
a# C,ED&T STANDA,DS
firm may follow a lenient or a stringent credit policy! #he firm following a lenient credit
policy tends to sell on credit to customers on a very liberal terms and credit is granted for a longer
period!
firm following a stringent credit policy on the other hand, sell on credit on a highly selective
basis only to those customers who have proven credit worthiness and who are financially strong!
lenient credit policy will result in increased sales and therefore increased contribution margin!
However, these will also result in increased costs such as:
)! $ncreased bad debt losses
%! ,pportunity cost of tied up capital in receivables
+! $ncreased cost of carrying out credit analysis
&! $ncreased collection cost
9! $ncreased discount costs to encourage early payments
#he goal of the firmDs credit policy is to maximise the value of the firm! #o achieve this goal, the
evaluation of investment in receivables should involve the following steps:
)! .stimation of incremental operating profits from increased sales
%! .stimation of incremental investment in account receivable
+! .stimation of incremental costs
&! 5omparison of incremental profits with incremental costs
?# C,ED&T TE,MS
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 47@
5redit terms involve both the length of the credit period and the discount given! #he terms %A)@,
nA+@ means that a %F discount is given if the bill is paid before the tenth day after the date of
invoice otherwise the net amount should be paid by the +@
th
day!
$n considering the credit terms to offer the firm should look at the profitability caused by longer
credit and discount period or a higher rate of discount against increased cost!
c# D&SCO.NTS
:arying the discount involves an attempt to speed up the payment of receivables! $t can also
result in reduced bad debt losses!
d# COLLECT&ON +OL&C0
#he firmDs collection policy may also affect our analysis! #he higher the cost of collecting
account receivables the lower the bad debt losses! #he firm must therefore consider whether the
reduction in bad debt is more than the increase in collection costs!
s saturation point increased expenditure in collection efforts does not result in reduced bad debt
and therefore the firm should not spend more after reaching this point!
&llustration
3iffruff 2td is considering relaxing its credit standards! #he firms current credit terms is net +@
but the average debtors collection period is &9 days! 5urrent annual credit sales amounts to
Sh!',@@@,@@@! #he firm wants to extend credit period net '@! Sales are expected to increase by
%@F! *ad debts will increase from %F to %!9F of annual credit sales! 5redit analysis and debt
collection costs will increase by Sh!&,@@@ p!a! #he return on investment in debtors is )%F for
Sh!)@@ of sales, Sh!<9 is variable costs! ssume +'@ days p!a! Should the firm change the credit
policyM
Suggested Solution
5urrent sales I Sh!',@@@,@@@
/ew sales I Sh!',@@@,@@@ x )!%@ I Sh!<,%@@,@@@
5ontribution margin I Sh!)@@ E Sh!<9 I Sh!%9
#herefore contribution margin ratio I )@@
)@@ !
%9 !
x
Sh
Sh
I %9F
5ost benefit analysis
5ontribution -argin
/ew policy %9F x <,%@@,@@@ I ),(@@
5urrent policy %9F x ',@@@,@@@ I ),9@@ I +@@
5redit analysis and debt collection costs B(&C
*ad debts
/ew bad debts I %!9F x <,%@@,@@@ I )(@
5urrent bad debts I %F x ',@@@,@@@ I )%@ B'@C
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
476 Working Ca<ital Management
1ebtors
/ew debtors I
days
per"od Cr
+'@
!
x cr! Sales p!a!
I
@@@ , %@@ , <
+'@
'@
x
I ),%@@
5urrent debtors I @@@ , @@@ , '
+'@
&9
x I <9@
$ncrease in debtors Btied up capitalC &9@
4orgone profits I )%F x &9@ B9&C
/et benefit BcostC )@%
#herefore, change the credit policy!
E/AL.AT&ON O* T-E C,ED&T A++L&CANT
fter establishing the terms of sale to be offered, the firm must evaluate individual applicants and
consider the possibilities of bad debt or slow payments! #his is referred to as credit analysis and
can be done by using information derived from:
aC #he applicantDs financial statement
bC 5redit ratings and reports from experts
cC *anks
dC ,ther firms
eC #he companyDs own experience
A++L&CAT&ON O* D&SC,&M&NANT ANAL0S&S TO T-E SELECT&ON O*
A++L&CANTS
1iscriminative analysis is a statistical model that can be used to accept or re=ect a prospective
credit customer! #he discriminant analysis is similar to regression analysis but it assumed that
the observations come from two different universal sets Bin credit analysis, the good and bad
customersC! #o illustrate let us assume that two factors are important in evaluating a credit
applicant the quick ratio and net worth to total assets ratio!
#he discriminant function will be of the form!
ft I a)BP)C G a%BP%C
Where: P) is quick ratio
P% is the network to total assets
a) and a% are parameters
#he parameters can be computed by the use of the following equations:
a) I S>> dx E Sx>d>
Sxx Sxx E Sx>`
a% I S>> dx E Sx>d>
S>> Sxx E Sx>`
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 478
Where: Sxx represents the variances of P)
S>> represents the variances of P%
Sx> is the covariance of variables of P) and P%
dx is the difference between the average of P)Ds bad accounts and P%Ds good accounts
d> represents the difference between the average of PDs bad accounts and PDs good
accounts!
#he next step is to determine the minimum cut"off value of the function below at which credit
will not be given! #his value is referred to as the discriminant value and is denoted by f#.
,nce the discriminant function has been developed it can then be used to analyse credit
applicants! #he important assumption here is that new credit applicants will have the same
characteristics as the ones used to develop the mode!
-ore than two variables can be used to determine the discriminant function! $n such a case the
discriminant function will be of the form!
ft I a)x) G a%x% G [ G anxn
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
477 Working Ca<ital Management
,E&N*O,C&NG J.EST&ONS
J.EST&ON ONE
Wema 2td has estimated that the standard deviation of its daily net cash flows is Sh!%,9@@! #he
firm pays Sh!9@ in transaction costs to transfer funds into and out of this money market! #he rate
of interest in the money market is <!&'9F p!a! Wema uses the -iller",rr Model to set its target
cas% ?alances(
,e>uired
aC What is WemaDs target cash balanceM
bC What are the lower and upper cash limitM
cC What are the WemaDs decision rulesM
dC 1etermine WemaDs expected average cash balance!
J.EST&ON TWO
-ama Star .nterprises is a distributor or air filters to retail shops! $t buys its filters from several
manufacturers! 4ilters are ordered in lot si>es of )@@ and each order costs Sh!&@@ to place!
1emand from retail shops is %@@,@@@ filters per month and the carrying cost is Sh!)@ per filter per
month!
,e>uired
aC What is the optimal order quantity with respect to so many lot si>esK
bC $f a safety stock of %,@@@ filters is desired what is the total relevant costsM
cC certain manufacturer offers a discount of %F for purchases of 9@ lot si>es or more!
Should the discount be takenM Bssume that each filter costs Sh!)@@C!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Eig%t 47:
J.EST&ON T-,EE
Willie 1istributors 2td! uses discriminant analysis in customer classification! good customer is
defined as one who pays on or before the due date while a bad customer is one who does not meet
this standard!
#he finance director believes that the two most important ratios in discriminating between a good
and bad customer are the current ratio and the returns on investment Bi!e! .arnings *efore $nterest
and taxes divided by total assetsC, 8!
1ata relating to %@ accounts Bconsisting of )@ good and )@ badeC is shown below:
)!)
)!9
)!%
@!;
)!'
%!%
@!;
)!@
)!+
)!+
)+
)9
)9
%)
<
(
)'
)+
(
%
@!<
@!;
@!(
)!+
)!)
@!9
@!+
)!&
@!;
)!)
))
"&
'
%
'
(
(
'
+
)&
,e>uired
.stimate the discriminant function using the above data!
Use the discriminant function to find the Q score for each of the twenty accounts
1etermine a Q score that minimises the number of misclassifications!
"C+A <ilot <a<er#
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC .xplain why proper working capital management is important for the financial success of
a company!
bC t a recent seminar on J6ender .mpowerment in *usinessD the invited financial
consultant, -adame Hesabu dvised the participants that extending credit is one of the
comerstone of modern business! -adame *iashara, the managing director of *iashara
2imited took note of this important fact! fter the seminar, she authorised a review of
the credit system of her company! #he following facts are relevant!
B( marksC
aC nnual sales of the company are Sh!9,@@@,@@@
bC 5redit sales are %9 per cent of all sales
cC *ad debts average %F of all credit sales
dC verage collection period for debtor is &@ days
eC #he companyDs cost of capital is )& per cent per annum
fC /et profit on sales is )9 per cent!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
Good accounts !ad accounts
47; Working Ca<ital Management
*ased on these facts, she is recommending a thorough revamping of the credit policy of the
company! #he expected outcome of this action will be:
aC $ncrease in total sales by +@ per cent
bC 5redit sales will be &@ per cent of all sales
cC verage collection period will decrease to +9 days
dC *ad debts will increase to + per cent of credit sales
eC n additional part time credit control assistant will be hired for Sh!9@,@@@ per annum!
,e>uired
#he effectiveness or otherwise of the proposed revamping of credit policy! BShow all your
workingsC! B( marksC
Who should determine credit policyM B% marksC
"Total= 4; marks#
C%eck your answers wit% t%ose gi2en in Lesson 4I o' t%e Study +ack
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Nine 479
LESSON N&NE
MA,KET *O, *.NDS
&NST,.CT&ONS
3ead the notes provided below!
5omplete answers to rein'orcement questions at the end of the lesson!
5heck model answers given in lesson )@ of the study pack!
3einforcing 5omments
#his chapter looks at the structure of financial markets in 0enya! #he money and securities markets
will be discussed!
CONTENTS
1efinitions
0enya 4inancial System
4inancial $ntermediaries
#he stock exchange Amarket
Stock market #erminologies
4actors influencing share prices
Stock -arket index
#iming of $nvestment at the stock exchange
dvatages and 1isadvatages of listing
3egulation of 5apital -arkets"#he 5apital market uthority
3ecent development E #he 5entral 1epository Systems B51SC
Speciali>ed and development financial $nstitutions
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4:I Market 'or *unds
Market 'or *unds and *inancial &nstitutions in Kenya
4inancial markets refers to an elaborate system of the financial institution and intermediaries
and arrangement put in place and developed to facilitate the transfer of funds from surplus
economic units BsaversC to deficit economic units BinvestorsC!
Savers include individuals, small businesses, family units savings through institutions such as
S55,s, banks, insurance firms, pension schemes etc!
$nvestors include government, companies, family units etc!
Note
7hysical or commodity markets deal with real assets such as tea, coffee, wheat, automobile etc!
*unctions o' *inancial MarketsC&nstitutions in t%e Economy
)! 1istribution of financial resources to the most productive units! Savings are transferred
to economic units that have channels of alternative investments! B2ink between buyers
and sellersC!
%! llocation of savings to real investment!
+! chieving real output in the economy by mobili>ing capital for investment!
&! .nable companies to make short term and long term investments and increase liquidity of
shares!
9! 7rovision of investment advice to individuals through financial experts!
'! .nables companies to raise short term and long term capitalAfunds
<! -eans of pricing of securities e!g /!S!.! index shares indicate changes in share prices!
(! 7rovide investment opportunities! Savers can hold financial instrument for investment
made!
Kenya *inancial System
4inancial markets are broadly classified into %:
)! 5apital -arkets
%! -oney -arkets
e!g! commercial banks, S55,S, foreign exchange market, merchant banks etc!
5apital markets are sub"divided into %:
aC Security markets e!g stock exchange dealing with instruments such as shares, debentures
etc!
bC /on"securityAinstrument market e!g mortgage, capital leases, security market is sub"
divided into %!
7rimary market
Secondary market
CA+&TAL MA,KET
#hese are markets for long term funds with maturity period of more than one year! .!g of
4inancial instruments used here are debentures, terms, loans, bonds, warrants, preference shares,
ordinary shares etc!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Nine 4:4
#he capital market serves as a way of allocating the available capital to the most efficient users!
Ca<ital market 'inancial institution includes=
)! Stock exchange
%! 1evelopment bank
+! Hire purchase companies
&! *uilding societies
9! 2easing firms
*unctions o' Ca<ital Markets are=
aC 7roviding long term funds which are necessary for investment decisions!
bC 7rovide advice to investors as to which investments are viable!
cC 2ong term investments are made liquid, as the transfer between shareholders is
facilitated!
dC 4acilitates the international capital inflow!
eC 4acilitating the liquidation and marketing of a long term
fC cting as a channel through which foreign investments find their way into the market!
MoneyCdiscount markets
re discount and acceptance financial institutions
#his is a market for S!# funds maturing in one year! -oney market works through financial
institutions! $t facilitates transfer of capital between savers and users!
#he transfer can be direct Bfrom saver to investorC and indirectly through an intermediaryC!
4oreign exchange market is also part of money market!
#he money market or discount market is the market for short term loans!
*inancial &nstruments in Money market include=
)! 5ommercial paper
%! #reasury bills
+! *ills of exchange
&! 7romissory notes
9! *ank overdrafts
'! *ankers certificate of deposit
#hese instruments are sold by commercial banks, merchant banks, discounting houses,
acceptance houses, and government!
+rimary Markets
#hese are markets that deal with securities that have been issued for the first time! #he money
flows directly from transferor Bsaver of moneyC to transferee Binvesting personC! #hey facilitate
capital formation!
Economic Ad2antage o' +rimary Markets
)! 3aising capital for business!
%! -obilising savings
+! 6overnment can raise capital through sale of #reasury bonds
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4:5 Market 'or *unds
&! ,pen market operation to effect monetary policy of the government i!e control of excess
liquidity in the economy
9! $t is a vehicle for direct foreign investment!
Economic Ad2antageC,ole o' Secondary Markets in t%e Economy
)! $t gives people a chance to buy shares hence distribution of wealth in economy!
%! .nable investors reali>e their investments through disposal of securities!
+! $ncreases diversification of investments
&! $mproves corporate governance through separation of ownership and management! #his
increases higher standards of accounting, resource management and transparency!
9! 7rivatisation of parastatals e!g! 0enya irways! #his gives individuals a chance for
ownership in large companies!
'! 7arameter for health economy and companies
<! 7rovides investment opportunities for companies and small investors!
#ypes of Stock -arkets
4( Organised Ec%ange and O2er t%e Counter "OTC# market
#his is where the buying and selling of securities is done by buyers and sellers are not
present but only the agents BbrokersC internet! #his system is called Jopen outcryK!
5( O2er t%e Counter Market "OTC#
7rovides an opportunity for unlistedAunquoted firms to sell their security
,tc is usually organi>ed by the dealers or stock brokers who buy securities themselves
and then sell them!
#hey maintain a reasonable balance between demand and supply and observe price
movements to determine profit margins on sale!
#rading may be done through telephones, computer networks, fax etc!
#he dealersAparticipants set the treading rules,#5 speciali>e in securities such as
corporate bonds, equity securities, #reasury bonds etc!
,#5 is underdeveloped in 0enya!
*eatures o' OTC Markets
)! 7rices are relatively low
%! Usually deal with new securities of firms
+! $s composed of small and closely held firms!
*&NANC&AL &NTE,MED&A,&ES
#hese are institutions which mediateAlink between the savers and investors:
Eam<les o' 'inancial intermediaries in Kenya(
4( Commercial !anks(
#hey act as intermediary between savers and users BinvestmentC of funds!
5( Sa2ings and Credit Associations
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Nine 4:@
#hese are firms that take the funds of many savers and then give the money as a loan in form of
mortgage and to other types of borrowers! #hey provide credit analysis services!
@( Credit .nions
#hese are cooperative associations whose members have a common bond e!g employees of the
same company! #he savings of the member are loaned only to the members at a very low interest
rate e!g! S55,S charge p!m interest on outstanding balance of loan!
6( +ension *unds
#hese are retirement schemes or plans funded by firms or government agencies for their workers!
#hey are administered mainly by the trust department of commercial banks or life insurance
companies! .xamples of pension funds are /SS4, /H$4 and other registered pension funds of
individual firms!
8( Li'e &nsurance Com<anies
#hese are firms that take savings in form of annual <remium from individuals and them invest,
these funds in securities such as shares, bonds or in real assets! Savers will receive annuities in
future!
7( !rokers
#hese are people who facilitate the exchange of securities by linking the buyer and the seller!
#hey act on behalf of members of public who are buying and selling shares of quoted companies!
:( &n2estment !ankers
#hese are institutions that buy new issue of securities for resale to other investors!
#hey perform the following functions:
)! 6iving advice to the investors
%! 6iving advice to firms which wants to
+! :aluation of firms which need to merge
&! 6iving defensive tactics incase of forced takeover
9! Underwriting of securities!
T-E STOCK E3C-ANGE MA,KET
T%e &dea and De2elo<ment o' a Stock Ec%ange
Stock exchange Balso known as stock marketsC are special Jmarket placesK where already held
stocks and bonds are bought and sold! #hey are, in effect, a financial institution, which provides
the facilities and regulations needed to carry out such transactions quickly, conveniently and
lawfully!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4:6 Market 'or *unds
Stock exchanges developed along with, and are an essential part of the free enterprises system!
B/o stock exchanges exist in the communist world outside Hong 0ong and -acao E which have
special status, and #aiwan which is also claimed by 5hinaC!
#he need for this kind of market came about as a result of two ma=or characteristics of =oint stock
company B7ublic 2imited 5ompanyC, shares!
)! 4irst of all, these shares are irredeemable, meaning that once it has sold them, the
company can never be compelled by the shareholder to take back its shares and give back
a cash refund, unless and until the company is winding up and liquidates!
%! #he second characteristic is that these shares are, however, very transferable and can be
bought and resold by other individuals and organi>ations, freely, the only requirement
being the filling and signing of a document known as a share transfer form by the
previous shareholder! #he document will then facilitate the updating of the issuing
companies shareholders register!
#hese two characteristics of =oint company shares brought about the necessity for an organi>ed
and centrali>ed place where organi>ations and private individuals with money to spare
BinvestorsC, and satisfy their individual needs! Stock exchanges were the result emerging to
provide a continuous auction market for securities, with the laws of supply and demand
determining the prices!
*unctions o' t%e Nairo?i Stock Ec%ange
#he basic function of a stock exchange is the raising of funds for investment in long"term assets!
While this basic function is extremely important and is the engine through which stock exchanges
are driven, there are also other quite important functions!
)! #he mobili>ation of savings for investment in productive enterprises as an alternative to
putting savings in bank deposits, purchase of real estate and outright consumption!
%! #he growth of related financial services sector e!g! insurance, pension and provident fund
schemes which nature the spirit of savings!
+! #he check against flight of capital which takes place because of local inflation and
currency depreciation!
&! .ncouragement of the divorcement of the owners of capital from the managers of capitalO
a very important process because owners of capital may not necessarily have the
expertise to manage capital investment efficiently!
9! .ncouragement of higher standards of accounting, resource management and public
disclosure which in turn affords greater efficiency in the process of capital growth!
'! 4acilitation of equity financing as opposed to debt financing! 1ebt financing has been
the undoing of many enterprises in both developed and developing countries especially in
recessionary periods!
<! $mprovement of access to finance for new and smaller companies! #his is futuristic in
most developing countries because venture capital is mostly unavailable, an unfortunate
situation!
(! .ncouragement of public floatation of private companies which in turn allows greater
growth and increase of the supply of assets available for long term investment!
#here are many other less general benefits which stock exchanges afford to! $ndividuals,
corporate organi>ations and even the government! #he government for example could raise long
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Nine 4:8
term finance locally by issuing various types of bond through the stock exchange and thus be less
inclined to foreign borrowing!
Stock exchanges, especially in developing countries have not always played the full role in
economic development!
T-E ,OLE O* STOCK E3C-ANGE &N ECONOM&C DE/ELO+MENT
4( ,aising Ca<ital 'or !usinesses
#he Stock .xchange provides companies with the facility to raise capital for expansion through
selling shares to the investing public!
5( Mo?ilising Sa2ings 'or &n2estment
When people draw their savings and invest in shares, it leads to a more rational allocation of
resources because funds which could have been consumed, or kept in idle deposits with banks are
mobili>ed and redirected to promote commerce and industry!
@( ,edistri?ution o' Wealt%
*y giving a wide spectrum of people a chance to buy shares and therefore become part"owners of
profitable enterprises, the stock market helps to reduce large income inequalities because many
people get a chance to share in the profits of business that were set up by other people!
6( &m<ro2ing Cor<orate Go2ernance
*y having a wide and varied scope of owners, companies generally tend to improve on their
management standards and efficiency in order to satisfy the demands of these shareholder! $t is
evident that generally, public companies tend to have better management records than private
companies!
8( Creates &n2estment O<<ortunities 'or Small in2estors
s opposed to other business that require huge capital outlay, investing in shares is open to both
the large and small investors because a person buys the number of shares they can afford!
#herefore the Stock .xchange provides an extra source of income to small savers!
7( Go2ernment ,aises Ca<ital 'or De2elo<ment +roEects
#he 6overnment and even local authorities like municipalities may decide to borrow money in
order to finance huge infrastructural pro=ects such as sewerage and water treatment works or
housing estates by selling another category of shares known as *onds! #hese bonds can be raised
through the Stock .xchange whereby members of the public buy them! When the 6overnment or
-unicipal 5ouncil gets this alternative source of funds, it no longer has the need to overtax the
people in order to finance development!
:( !arameter o' t%e Economy
t the Stock .xchange, share prices rise and fall depending, largely, on market forces! Share
prices tend to rise or remain stable when companies and the economy in general show signs of
stability! #herefore their movement of share prices can be an indicator of the general trend in the
economy!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4:7 Market 'or *unds
Ad2antages o' &n2esting &n S%ares
4( &ncome in 'orm o' di2idends
When you have shares of a company you become a part"owner of that company and therefore you
will be entitled to get a share of the profit of the company which come in form of dividends!
4urthermore, dividends attract a very low withholding tax of 9F only!
5( +ro'its 'rom Ca<ital A<<reciation
Shares prices change with time, and therefore when prices of given shares appreciate,
shareholders could take advantage of this increase and set their shares at a profit! 5apital gains
are not taxed in 0enya!
@( S%are Certi'icate can ?e used as a Collateral
Share certificate represents a certain amount of assets of the company in which a shareholder has
invested! #herefore this certificate is a valuable property which is acceptable to many banks and
financial institutions as security, or collateral against which an investor can get a loan!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Nine 4::
6( S%ares are easily trans'era?le
#he process of acquiring or selling shares is fairly simple, inexpensive and swift and therefore an
investor can liquidate shares at any moment to suit his convenience!
8( A2aila?ility o' &n2estment Ad2ice
lthough the stick market may appear complex and remote to many people! 7ositive advise and
guidance could be provided by the stockbrokers and other investment advisors! #herefore, an
investor can still benefit from trading in shares even though he may not be having the technical
expertise relevant to the stock market!
7( +artici<ating in Com<any Decisions
*y buying shares and therefore becoming a part"owner in an enterprise, a shareholder gets the
right to participate in making decisions about how the company is managed! Shareholders elect
the directors at the 5ompanyDs nnual!
6eneral meetings, whereby the voting power is determined by the number of shares an investor
holds since the general rules is that one share is equal to one vote!
STOCK MA,KET TE,M&NOLOG0
4( !,OKE,
dealer at the market who buys and sells securities on behalf of the public investors!
He is an agent of investors
He is the only authori>ed person to deal with the quoted securities! He is authori>ed by
5- and /S.
He obtains the suitable deal for his clientsAinvestors, gives financial advice and charges
commission for his services!
He doesnDt buy or sell shares in his own right hence he cannot be a market marker!
He must maintain standards set by the stock exchange!
5( BO!!E,SCS+EC.LATO,S
#his is a dealer who trades in securities in his own right as a principal!
He can set prices and activate the market through his own buying and selling hence he is
a market maker!
He engages in speculation and earns profit called NobbersD turn Bselling price E buying
priceC!
He does not deal with members of the public unlike brokers! However, brokers can buy
and sell shares through =obbers!
#here are + types of =obbers
a# !ulls
=obber buy shares when prices are low and hold them in anticipation that the price will
rise and sell them at gain!
When a market is dominated by bulls Bbuyers predominate sellersC, it is said to be bullish!
#he share prices are generally rising!
#herefore the market is characteri>ed by an upward trend in security prices!
$t signifies investors confidenceAoptimism in the future of economy!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
4:; Market 'or *unds
?# !ears
speculatorA=obber who sells security on expectation of decline in prices in future!
#he intention is to buy same securities at lower prices in future thereby making a gain!
When market is dominated by bears Bsellers predominate buyersC it is said to be bearish!
$t is characteri>ed by general downward trend in share prices! $t signifies investors
pessimism about the future prospects of the economy!
c# Stags
#his is a =obber found in primary markets
He buys new securities offered to the public and believes that they are undervalued!
He believes the price will rise and sell them at a gain to the ultimate investors
Stags are vital because they ensure full subscription of the share issue!
@) .nderwriting
#his is the assumption of risk relating unsubscribed shares
When new shares are issued, they may be underwrittenAunsubscribed! merchant banker
agrees, under a commission to take up any shares not bought by the public!
#hey therefore ensure that all new issues are successful
Underwriters are very important in pry markets and play the following roles:
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
547 ,e2ision Aid
iiiC #he stock turnover ratio can be improved as follows:
aC Selling on credit to customers who should pay within a short credit
period! #his can be achieved through offering of discount!
bC -aintenance of fast moving goods
cC .nsure timely delivery of goods by supplies especially if a delay in
delivery would lead to decline in turnover!
dC doption of =ust"in"time BN$#C of managing stock instead of the
.conomic",rder"?uantity B.,?C!
#he financial consequences of a high stock turnover are:
aC 3eduction in stock holdingAcarrying cost
bC $ncrease in stock ordering cost since stock is ordered frequently to meet
the
frequent customer demand!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 54:
LESSON 6
J.EST&ON ONE
aC 6rowth rate in equity!
#his can be determined using retention ratio method!
6rowth I 3,. x 3etention ratio
17S I )@F x par value I )@F x Sh!)@ I )!@@
1ividend cover I .7S I + times
17S
#herefore: .7S I +
Sh!)!@@
.7S I Sh!)!@@ x + I Sh!+!@@
3etention ratio I 3etained amount
.arnings to shareholders
3eturn on equity B3,.C I .arning to Shareholders
.quity
.arnings to ordinary shareholders I
.quity I Sh!),@@@,@@@ G (@@,@@@ I ),(@@,@@@
3,. I +@@,@@@ x )@@I )'!<F
)(,@@@,@@@
g I ''!<F x )'!<F I ))F
bC W!!5!5
5ost of equity
d@ I Sh!)!@@
g I ))F
7@ I -7S I Sh!)(!@@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
''!<F @!''<
Sh!+
) +
.7S
17S .7S
x+@@,@@@
Sh!)@par
@@ Sh!),@@@,@
Sh!+!@@x
g +
+
@
7
gC B)
@
d
0e
54; ,e2ision Aid
5ost of preference share capital 07 I
07 I dp
7@
dp I preference 17S I )%F x Sh!)@ I Sh!)!%@
7@ I -7S I Sh!)9
5ost of debt 0d
$nt! I $nterest I )'F x )@@ I Sh!)'
:d I :alue of debenture I Sh!)@@ I 7ar value
# I +@F
,r since par value I :d, then coupon rate I 0d
0dB)"#C I )'B)"@!+C I ))!%F
-!:alue of equity
. I Sh!),@@@,@@@ x )( I ),(@@,@@@
Sh!)@ par
-kt! :alue of preference share capital
7 I &@@,@@@ x 9 I '@@,@@@
Sh!)@ par
-!: of debenture I par value I +@@,@@@
#otal market value %,<@@,@@@
-arket :alue F 5ost -onetary cost
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
F % ! )< )<% ! @ )) ! @
)(
C )) ! ) B )
+ Ke
(F x)@@
)9
)!%@
p
0
( ) # )
d
:
$nt!
d
0
))!%F @!))% @!+C B)
)@@
)'
d
0
Lesson Ten 549
.quity
7!S! 5apital
1ebt
),(@@,@@@
'@@,@@@
+@@,@@@
%,<@@,@@@
)<!%F
(!@F
))!%F
+@;,'@@
&(,@@@
++,'@@
+;),%@@
W55 I +;),%@@ x )@@ I )&!&;FI )&!9F
%,<@@,@@@
J.EST&ON TWO
aC 1istinguish between capital structure and financial structure!
" 5apital structure is the mix or composition of long term and permanent
capital of the firm e!g! the mix of equity preference share capital an
debentures!
" 4inancial structure is the entire liabilities side of the balance sheet i!e
capital structure and current liabilities!
*alance Sheet
5urrent
liabilities
#rade creditors
ccruals
*ank overdraft
PP
PP
PP
33
,rdinary share
capital
3eserves
7ref! Share
capital
1ebentures
PP
PP
PP
PP
PP
bC *usiness risk and financial risk
" *usiness risk is the uncertainty inherent in the operations of the firms! $t
is the uncertainty in operating profits occasioned by the use of high level
of fixed operating expenses Coperating leverageC such as salaries, rent,
insurance, depreciation etc!
" 4inancial risk is the additional risk borne by ordinary shareholders when
the firm has to use additional debt capital to finance its assets! $t is thus
caused by high gearing i!e use of fixed charge capital such as debt and
preference share capital!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
F 9 ! )&
<@@ , %
+@@
% ! ))
<@@ , %
'@@
F (
<@@ , %
(@@ , )
F % ! )<
,
_
+
,
_
+
,
_
$A!!
5
a
p
i
t
a
l
S
t
r
u
c
t
u
r
e
4
i
n
a
n
c
i
a
l
S
t
r
u
c
t
u
r
e
55I ,e2ision Aid
" 4inancial risk leads to high fixed financing expenses Binterest charges
and preference dividendsC thus fluctuations in .7S of the firm and
eventually liquidity problems!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 554
cC .ffects of debt capital on W55
" t initial stages of introduction of debt capital, W55 will decline since
the tax shield associated with interest charges is higher than the
bankruptcy costs! #he value of the firm is maximi>ed at a point where
W55 is lowest!
" dditionally, debt capital have lower cost due to certainty of interest
income and the tax shield i!e! 0dB)"#C!
" However, as more debt is introduced, financial risk increase and
debenture holders and shareholders will demand high return leading to
increase in W55!
dC -W55 and W55
" W55 is the market value weighted cost of capital! $t is based on:
V market value of each capital component
V F cost of each capital component!
" Using market values, the cost of retained earnings B0rC is left out since it
is reflected in market value of equity!
" /o floatation costs are incorporated in W55
Where: 0e, 0d, 0p I F cost of equity, debt and preference share
capital!
., 1, 7 I -arket value of equity, debt and preference
share capital!
: I #otal market value I . G 1 G 7
" -W55
" #his is the overallAcomposite cost of additional or marginal
capital
" 4loatation costs are incorporated in each F cost of capital apart
from cost of retained earnings!
" #he amount to raise from each source is usually based on book
value capital structure which is considered to be optimal! #he
weights are based on the amount of capital raised from each
source!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
( )
,
_
,
_
,
_
+ +
:
7
p
0
:
1
# )
d
0
:
.
e
0 W55
555 ,e2ision Aid
" 0em, 0rm, 0dm, 07m I -arginal cost of equity, retained earnings,
debt
and preference share capital
" .m, 3m, 1m, 7m I mount of additionalAmarginal capital to raise
from ordinary shares, retained earnings, debt
and preference shares!
" # I #otal amount to raise I .m, 3m, 1m, 7m
J.EST&ON T-,EE
BaC and BbC E 3efer to ?%BdC above!
cC 5ompute the F cost of each capital component!
5ost of debentures 0d
" Since debentures are redeemable in )@ years time, the cost is called yield
to maturity B8#-C or redemption yield B38C!
" $f debentures are not redeemable BperpetualB 0d is called running or flat
yield!
" Using approximation method for yet 8#-,
$nt I $nterest charges I )(F x ),@@@ I Sh!)(@
# I #ax rate I &@F
- I -aturity or par value I sh!),@@@
:d I 5urrent market value I Sh!;9@
n I /umber of years I )@ years
5ost of equity
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
( )
,
_
,
_
,
_
,
_
+ + +
#
m
7
pm
0
#
m
1
# )
dm
0
#
m
3
r
0
#
m
.
em
0 -W55
( ) ( )
( )
%
)
A ) )
d
d
d
M
n M % &nt
K '( (%M
+
+
( ) ( )
( )
%
)
;9@ ),@@@
)@
)
;9@ ),@@@ @!& ) )(@
d
0
+
+
))!'F x)@@
;<9
))+
( )
g +
+
@
7
g )
@
d
e
0
Lesson Ten 55@
d@ I Sh!9!@@
7@ I -7S I Sh!+(
g I growth rate I )@F
5ost of preference share capital 0p
Since -7S I 7ar value, then 07 I 5oupon rate I )@F
/*: #he prices of preference shares have not changes since floatation
hence -7S I par value
5apital -arket :alue F 5ost -onetary
5ost
.quity %&!9 )),'+<!9
1ebt ))!'& ),<'+!%
7reference
share capital
I 7ar value ',%9@ )@
'%9!@
#otal '(,;9@ )&,@%9!<
cC iiC *ook value weights should be used discretely since they are historical!
#hey
relate o the past when the capital was initially raised!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
( )
%&!9F @!%&9 Y@!)@
+(
@!)@ ) 9
e
0
+
&<,9@@
Sh!)@
Sh!)%,9@@
Sh!+(x
)9,%@@
Sh!),@@@
Sh!)',@@@
Sh!;9@x
%@!+F
'(,;9@
)&,@%9!<
W55
%@!+F @!%@+
'(,;9@
',%9@
)@
'(,;9@
)9,%@@
))!'
'(,;9@
'&<,9@@
%&!9 W55 + +
,
_
,
_
,
_
( )
( )
%+!%F @!%+% @!)@
%9
)!)@ +
g
@
7
g )
@
d
r
0 + +
+
,
_
,
_
,
_
+ +
));
%;!<9
%+!%
));
+9!<
%&!<F
));
9+!99
;!'F -W55
557 ,e2ision Aid
LESSON 8
J.EST&ON ONE
3efer to the Study 7ack for advantages of /7:, $33 and 7!$ methods of pro=ect appraisal!
J.EST&ON TWO
aC 5omputation of /7:
#he discounting factor Bpresent value interest factor 7:$4C can be computed
using the formulae
( )
( )
n
n
r
r
+
+
)
)
)
.+ES& TNO
8ear 5ash flow
L@@@D
7:$4)%F,n 7!: 7:$4)<F,n 7!:
)
%
+
&
9
'@@
),(@@
%,@@@
+,@@@
%,&@@
@!(;+
@!<;<
@!<)%
@!'+'
@!9'<
9+(!9
),&+&!'
),&%&!@
),;@(!@
),+'@!(
@!(99
@!<+)
@!'%&
@!9+&
@!&9'
9)+!@
),+)9!(
),%&(!@
),'@%!@
),@;&!&
#otal present value
2ess initial capital
/et present value
',''+!%
',@@@!@
''+!%
9,<<+!%
',@@@!@
B%%'!(C
.+ES& MO5
8ear 5ash flow
L@@@D
7:$4)%F,n 7!: 7:$4)<F,n 7!:
)
%
+
&
9
),(@@
%,&@@
+,@@@
),(@@
),'@@
@!(;+
@!<;<
@!<)%
@!'+'
@!9'<
),'@<!&
),;)%!(
%,)+'!@
),)&&!(
;@<!%
@!(99
@!<+)
@!'%&
@!9+&
@!&9'
),9+;!@
),<9&!&
),(<%!@
;')!%
<%;!'
#otal present value
2ess initial capital
/et present value
<,<@(!%
<,@@@!@
<@(!%
',(9'!%
<,@@@!@
B)&+!(C
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 55:
bC #he rate of return for each pro=ect is the internal rate of return B#ime E ad=usted
rate of return of a pro=ectC!
Since both pro=ects are yielding a positive /7: at )%F discounting, rediscount
the cash flows again at a higher trial discounting to get a negative or >ero /7:!
#ry )<F \done in part BaC]!
+esi TNO .<esi MO5
/7: S )%F ''+!% <@(!%
/7: S $!3!3! @ @
/7: S )<F "%%'!( ")&+!(
$!3!3! for 7esi #Q, I
( ) )% )<
( ! %%' % ! ''+
@ % ! ''+
F )%
I
FC 9 B
(;@
% ! ''+
F )% +
I )9!<+F
$!3!3! for Upesi -,% I
( ) F )% F )<
( ! )&+ % ! <@(
@ % ! <@(
F )%
I
FC 9 B
(9%
% ! <@(
F )% +
I )'!)'F
bBiiC " *oth pro=ects have a positive /7: S )%F cost of capital! However
pro=ect
Upesi -,% has higher /7:!
" *oth pro=ects produce $!3!3! greater than cost of capital! However,
pro=ect Upesi -,% has higher $!3!3!
" #herefore, accept pro=ect Upesi -,%!
J.EST&ON T-,EE
1epreciation p!a! I %@F x %,%@@,@@@ I &&@,@@@
7repare a cash flow schedule:
8ear
)
Sh!D@@@D
%
Sh!D@@@D
+
Sh!D@@@D
&
Sh!D@@@D
9
Sh!D@@@D
Sales
2ess operating costs
.*,#
2ess depreciation
.*#
2ess tax S +9F
.# I accounting profits
dd back depreciation
),+%@
<@@
'%@
&&@
)(@
'+
))<
&&@
),&&@
<@@
<&@
&&@
+@@
)@9
);9
&&@
),9'@
<@@
('@
&&@
&%@
)&<
%<+
&&@
),'@@
<@@
;@@
&&@
&'@
)')
%;;
&&@
),9@@
<@@
(@@
&&@
+'@
)%'
%+&
&&@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
55; ,e2ision Aid
5ash flows 99< '+9 <)+ <+; '<&
Screening Criteria
)! #he net commitment of funds should not exceed & years i!e the payback period
should at least be & years! #herefore, compute the payback period!
8ear 5ash flows ccumulated 5ash flows
)
%
+
&
9
99<
'+9
<)+
<+;
'<&
99<
),);%
),;@9
%,'&&
+,+)(
#he initial capital of Sh!%,%@@,@@@ is recovered after year +! fter year + Bduring
year &C a total of Sh!%;9,@@@ B%,%@@ E ),;@9C is required out of the total year &
cash flows of Sh!<+;,@@@! #herefore payback period I yrs yrs & ! +
<+;
%;9
+ +
%! #he time ad=usted or discounted rate of return is the $!3!3 of the pro=ect!
1iscount the cash flows at )9F cost of capital given:
3ecall discounting factor B7:$4C I
( )
n
n
r
r
+
+
)
)
C ) B
8ear 5ash
flows
L@@@D
7:$4)9F 7!: 7:$4)&F,n 7!:!
)
%
+
&
9
99<
'+9
<)+
<+;
'<&
@!(<@
@!<9'
@!'9(
@!9<%
@!&;<
&(&!9;
&(@!@'
&';!)9
&%%!<)
++&!;(
@!(<<
@!<<@
@!'<9
@!9;%
@!9);
&((!&;
&((!;9
&()!%(
&+<!&;
+&;!()
#otal 7!:!
2ess initial capital
/!7!:!
%,);)!&;
%,%@@!@@
B(!9)C
%,%&'!+@
%,%@@!@@
&'!+@
Since the /7: is negative at )9F cost of capital rediscount the cash flows again
at a lower rate, say )&F, to get a positive /7:!
/7: S )&F I &'!+
/7: S $!3!3! I @
/7: S )9F I "(!9)
$!3!3! I
( ) F )& F )9
9) ! ( + ! &'
@ + ! &'
F )&
I
FC ) B
() ! 9&
+ ! &'
F )& +
I )&!(9F
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 559
+! #he unad=usted rate of return on assets employed is the accounting rate of return!
33 I verage accounting profits B.#C x )@@
verage investment
verage accounting profits I
yrs 9
%+& %;; %<+ );9 ))< + + + +
I %%+!' p!a!
verage investment I B$nitial capital G Salvage valueCR
I B%,%@@ G @CR
I ),)@@
!3!3 I
)@@
)@@ , )
' ! %%+
x
I %@!+F
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC #he features of a sound pro=ect appraisal technique are:
$t should consider the time value of money by discounting the cash flows!
$t should give a direct decision criteria on when to accept or re=ect a pro=ect!
$t should rank independent pro=ects in order of their economic viability
$t should distinguish between acceptance and unacceptable pro=ects which
are mutually exclusive!
$t should generally be applicable to any conceivable pro=ect available!
bC 7ractical problems faced by finance managers in capital budgeting:
2ack of information on viable investment opportunities!
2ack of adequate capital to undertake all viable independent pro=ects!
Uncertainty of future cash flows or benefits including methods of assessing
risk of a pro=ect!
#he appropriate pro=ect appraisal technique to use
.ffects of inflation, changes in cost of capital and their qualitative
information!
cC #he features of long term investment decisions are:
#hey involve significant amount of initial capital!
#hey are usually irreversible since reversing such decisions leads to loss
since some specialised assets already acquired may not have second hand
market!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5@I ,e2ision Aid
#hey involve risk and uncertainty with reference to economic life, cash
flows, cost of capital, inflation rate, political and technological changes etc!
#he benefits are received over a series of years!
#here is significant time lag between the time capital is committed and the
time benefitsAcash flows are received!
#hey require prioritisation of scarce financial resources hence the need to
evaluate independent pro=ects!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5@4
J.EST&ON *&/E
7!$ I #otal 7resent :alue
$nitial 5apital
*ut /7: I 7!: E $nitial cost
#herefore total 7!: I /7: G initial cost
Since pro=ect ' has a negative /7:, it should outrightly be re=ected! .valuate 9 pro=ects
remaining!
7ro=ect $nitial
5apital
/7: #otal 7: 7$ 3anking
) '@ %) () () I )!+9
'@
&
% )9 ; %& %9 I )!'@
)9
%
+ %@ ; %; %; I )!&9
%@
+
& 99 )9 <@ <@ I )!%<
99
9
9 +@ %@ 9@ 9@ I )!'<
+@
)
llocate the Sh!)@@- according to 7$ ranking!
7ro=ect 3ank $nitial capital /7:
9
%
+
)
)
%
+
& *alance
+@
)9
%@
+9 +9 x %)
)@@ )@@
%@
;
;
)%!%9
9@!%9
Using /7: 3anking
7ro=ect $nitial capital /7: 3anking
) '@ %) %
% )9 ; &
+ %@ ; 9
& 99 )9 +
9 +@ %@ )
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5@5 ,e2ision Aid
llocation on basis of /7: ranking
7ro=ect 3ank $nitial capital /7:
9 ) +@ %@
) % '@ %)
9A99 of & + *alance 9 9A99 x )9 @!(%
#otal /7: &)!(%
Using 7!$ ranking, /7: is higher since the 7!$ ignores the si>e of the pro=ect and rank
pro=ects in relative terms i!e according to 7!: profitability for every shilling of initial
capital!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5@@
LESSON 7
J.EST&ON ONE
aC .xpected 17S d@B)GgC I Sh!'!@@
5ost of equity 0e I )9F
? I 3etention ratio x cost of equity B3U.C
I B)"@!'C x @!)9 I @!@' I 'F
7@ I
@' ! @ )9 ! @
' C ) B
@
+
g K
g d
e
I Sh!''!<@
-7S I Sh!&@
#he share is undervalued!
bC Significance of valuation of securities:
" #o determine the price of a security incase of mergers and acquisitions
" Where a firm is floating shares for the first time
" Where a firm wants to sell its subsidiary to a third party
" When the firm is sold to a management buyout team as a going concern!
cC Qero coupon bond does not pay periodic interest charges!
7ar value I Sh!)@@,@@@ I lumpsum at end of year 9
$ssue price B7:C I )@@,@@@B)"@!+%C I '(,@@@
/umber of years I 9years
3ecall future value I 7: x B) G rC
n
)@@,@@@ I '(,@@@B) G rC
9
B)GrC
9
I
@@@ , '(
@@@ , )@@
I )!&<@'
) G r I
9
&<@' ! ) I )!@(
r I )!@( E ) I @!@( (F
dC dvantages of >ero coupon rate
#he firm is able to raise debt capital without fixed commitment to pay
fixed periodic interest charges
$t creates certainty on the amount of debt payable in future at maturity
#he borrower does not have to worry about changes in market interest rate!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5@6 ,e2ision Aid
J.EST&ON TWO
aC #he maximum price to pay is equal to the present value of all the expected future
net cash flows!
1iscounting rate I ;F G 9F I )&F
7: of year ) E 9 net cash flows p!a! Sh!D@@@D
9@ x 7:4)&F,9 I 9@ x +!&++ )<)!'9
7: of year ' E )@ net cash flows p!a!
I ;@B7:4)&F,)@ " 7:4)&F,9C
I ;@B9!%)' E +!&++C )'@!&<
7: of year )) " W net cash flows p!a!
I )+@B7:4)&F,W " 7:4)&F,)@C
I )+@B
,
_
@!(&(
@!<)(
@!'@;
@!9)'
@!&+<
@!+<@
@!+<@
)!;9
)!;@
)!(9
)!<+
)!')
)!9@
)%!)@
YYYY
#otal 7: I 7rice of a share %%!'&
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5@8
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5@7 ,e2ision Aid
7:$4 I
( )
n
r + )
)
aBiiC I bBiiC
#he value of a share will change if held for only + years since intrinsic value
shall be based on + year expected 17S only!
bC 5ompute the growth
d@B)GgC
n
I dn
Where: d@ I %!9@
n I number of years of growth I + years
dn I %!()
#herefore: %!9@B)GgC
+
I %!()
B)GgC
+
I
9@ ! %
() ! %
I )!)%&
) G g I
+
)%& ! ) I )!@&
g I @!@& X &F
7@ I
( )
g K
g d
e
+ )
@
I
( )
)@ ! @
;%% ! %
@& ! @ )& ! @
@& ! ) () ! %
I Sh!%;!%%
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC :aluation of ordinary shares is more complicated than valuation of bonds and
preference shares because of:
" Uncertainty of dividend unlike interest charges and preference dividends
which are certain
" #he data for valuation of ordinary shares is historical which may not reflect
future expectations!
" constant stream of dividends per share is assume
" #he growth rate is assumed constant and is computed from past dividends!
" #he cost of equityArequired rate of return on equity is assumed to be constant
though it changes over time!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5@:
bC iC $f they do nothing:
d@ I Shs!+!@@
g I 'F
0e I )9F
7@ I
@' ! @ )9 ! @
C @' ! ) B + C ) B
@
+
g K
g d
e
I
Sh!+9!++
iiC $nvest in a venture
d@ I Shs!+!@@
g I <F
0e I )&F
7@ I
@< ! @ )& ! @
C @< ! ) B + C ) B
@
+
g K
g d
e
I
Sh!&9!('
iiiC .liminate unprofitable product line
d@ I Shs!+!@@
g I (F
0e I )<F
7@ I
@( ! @ )< ! @
C @( ! ) B + C ) B
@
+
g K
g d
e
I
Sh!+'!@@
ivC cquire a subsidiary
d@ I Shs!+!@@
g I ;F
0e I )(F
7@ I
@; ! @ )( ! @
C @; ! ) B + C ) B
@
+
g K
g d
e
I
Sh!+'!++
#he best alternative is to invest in a venture since this option has the highest
impact price of Sh!&9!('!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5@; ,e2ision Aid
LESSON :
J.EST&ON ONE
aC 1ividend payout ratio I )@@ x
EPS
DPS
8ear 2td!
* 2td
);;'
);;<
);;(
);;;
%@@@
F ( ! %+ )@@
(; ! )
&9 ! @
x
F @ ! +@ )@@
9@ ! )
&9 ! @
x
F 9 ! %% )@@
@@ ! %
&9 ! @
x
F +@ ! )< )@@
'@ ! %
&9 ! @
x
F 9 ! )) )@@
;@ ! +
&9 ! @
x
F ) ! )< )@@
@9 ! %
+9 ! @
x
F % ! )< )@@
&9 ! )
+9 ! @
x
F & ! )< )@@
@( ! %
+9 ! @
x
F < ! )< )@@
99 ! %
+9 ! @
x
F ; ! )' )@@
@( ! &
+9 ! @
x
7rice E earning ratio I
EPS
MPS
8ear 2td! * 2td
);;'
);;<
);;(
);;;
( )
t"(es yrs A @ ! ;
(; ! )
R )( )'
+
( )
yrs @ ! ;
9@ ! )
R )9 )%
+
( )
yrs 9 ! (
@@ ! %
R %@ )&
+
( )
yrs @ ! ;
'@ ! %
R %' %)
+
( )
t"(es yrs A +& ! '
@9 ! %
R )9 ))
+
( )
yrs ; ! '
&9 ! )
R )& '
+
( )
yrs 9' ! 9
@( ! %
R )' <
+
( )
yrs &9 ! <
99 ! %
R %+ )9
+
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5@9
%@@@ ( )
yrs &' ! (
;@ ! +
R &@ %'
+ ( )
yrs ;< ! <
@( ! &
R && %)
+
bC #he shares of * 2td! are not performing well because of uncertainty of 17S compared to
certainty of 17S for 2td! #his uncertainty leads to higher required rate of return by ordinary
shareholders thus lower market value of a share!
cC $f a firm is making heavy losses, the .7S would be negative! With a positive 7A. ratio
the -7S would be negative i!e!
-7S I ".7S x 7A. ratio
negative -7S cannot be interpreted hence the 7A. ratio model collapses!
J.EST&ON TWO
aC 3efer to 2esson < on factors influencing dividend policies!
bC iC firm with a large proportion of high income individuals will pay low or
no dividends! Such shareholders prefer high capital to reduce their tax burden since capital gains
in 0enya are tax exempt!
iiC growth company with abundance of good investment opportunities!
Such a firm would pay low and retain more profits to finance its good investment opportunities!
iiiC company with ordinary growth and high liquidity!
Such a firm could pay high dividends and retain less! With high liquidity and much unused debt
capacity, the firm can easily borrow debt capital to achieve optimal debt capital! $t has access to
capital markets!
ivC dividend paying company that experiences an unexpected drop in earnings from trend!
Such a firm would pay medium dividends but if the drop in earnings persist in future it should
adopt payment of low dividends!
vC company with volatile earnings and high business risk!
#his firm should pay low dividends and retain more profits to finance its investments! With high
business risk, the firm does not have access to capital markets and it is difficult to raise secure
debt capital which would nevertheless increase the financial risk of the firm!
J.EST&ON T-,EE
Solution: 3efer to 2esson < for discussion of factors influencing dividend policy!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
56I ,e2ision Aid
LESSON ;
J.EST&ON ONE
aC #arget cash balance,
L
"
b
& +
1
1
]
1
+
)
%
&
+
Where: b I 9@
2 I )@,@@@
_ I %,9@@
i I
+'@
@<&'9 ! @
( )
@@@ , )@
+'@
@<&'9 ! @
&
` 9@@ , % 9@ +
+
)
+
1
1
1
1
]
1
x
x
&
I \)!)+%@<&' x )@
)%
]
)A+
I )@&)'!'&( G )@,@@@
I Sh!%@&)'!'&(
X Sh!!%@&)<
bC 2ower 2imit is given and is equal to Sh!)@,@@@
Upper 2imit H I +Q E %2
H I +B%@,&)<C E %B)@,@@@C
I Sh!!&),%9)
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 564
cC 1ecision 3ule:
Wema should hold a cash balance of between Sh!)@,@@@ and Sh!&),%9)! ny time the balance
reaches Sh!&),%9), then marketable securities should be bought amounting to Sh!%@,(+& B&),%9)
E %@,&)<C to return the balance to the target! When the cash balance reaches Sh!)@,@@@, then
marketable securities Bor borrowingsC should be sold worth Sh!)@,&)< to bring the balance to the
target level!
dC .xpected average cash balance I
+
& L &
I
( )
+
@@@ , )@ &)< , %@ &
I Sh!!%+,((;
J.EST&ON TWO
aC .,? I optimal amount to order I
n
C
DC
@
%
Where: 1 I annual demand I %@,@@@ filters x )% I %&@,@@@
5@ I Sh!&@@
5n I Sh!)@
f"lters
x x
E)' ' < ! +() , &
)@
&@@ @@@ , %&@ %
/o! of lot si>es I ()< ! &+
)@@
< ! +() , &
&& lot si>es
bC Without safety stock:
'
DC
'C TC
n
@
R +
( ) &@@
< ! +() , &
@@@ , %&@
)@ < ! +() , & R x x x +
%),;@; G %),;@; I Sh!&+,()(
$n presence of %@@@ filters per annual of safety stock then:
@
C RB C
'
D
C S ' TC
n
+ +
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
565 ,e2ision Aid
&@@
< ! +() , &
@@@ , %&@
)@ ! C @@@ , % < ! +() , & RB x Sh + +
+),;@; G %),;@; I 9+,()(
cC .ffects of the discount
$f the firm is to order 9@ lots, then filters I 9@ lots x )@@ filters per lot I 9,@@@
filters!
#hat is new .,? I ? I 9,@@@ filters
/ew buying price I ;(F x )@@ I Sh!;(
nalysis of savings
/et Savings
5urrent buying costs I %&@,@@@ filters x )@@ I %&,@@@,@@@
/ew buying costs I %&@,@@@ filters x ;( I %+,9%@,@@@ &(@,@@@
Ordering costs
5urrent I
&@@
< ! +() , &
@@@ , %&@
@
x C
'
D
I %),;@;
/ew I
&@@
@@@ , 9
@@@ , %&@
x
I );,%@@
%,<@;
-olding cost
5urrent R?5n I R x &,+()!< x )@ I %),;@;
/ew I R x 9,@@@ x )@ I %9,@@@ B+,@;)C
$ncreamental cost &<;,')(
,verall net benefits
#ake the discount since it yields positive overall net benefits!
J.EST&ON T-,EE
aC #he discriminant function of the form Q I ;)P) G ;%P%
Where a) I S>>dx E Sx>d>
S>>Sxx E BSx>C`
nd a% I Sxxd> E Sx>dx
S>>Sxx E BSx>C`
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 56@
/ote: the terms have been defined in the text!
We need to first compute dx and d>!
Good Accounts !ad Accounts
P
)!)
)!9
)!%
@!;
)!'
%!%
@!;
)!@
)!+
)!+
)!+
8
)+
)9
)<
%)
<
(
)'
)+
(
%
)%
P
@!<
@!;
@!(
)!+
)!)
@!9
@!+
)!&
@!;
)!)
@!;
8
))
"&
'
%
'
(
(
'
+
)&
'
dx I )!+ E @!; I @!&
d> I )% E ' I @!'
#he next step is to determine Sxx, S>> and Sx>
Use the scientific calculator to determine the variance of the PDsBSxxC and the variance of 8Ds
BS>>C!
We also use the following formula to determine Sx> Bth covariance between P and 8C
P
)!)
)!9
)!%
@!;
)!'
%!%
@!;
)!@
)!+
)!+
@!<
@!;
@!(
)!+
)!)
@!9
@!+
8
)+
)9
)<
%)
<
(
)'
)+
(
%
))
"&
'
%
'
(
(
P8
)&!+
%%!9
%@!&
)(!;
))!%
)<!'
)&!&
)+
)@!&
%!'
<!<
"+!'
&!(
%!'
'!'
&
%!&
Q
9!)&
'!9%
'!)%
'!@<
9!+&
<!@9
9!)<
&!(;
&!<9
+!'<
+!<'
)!9<
+!)%
+!'<
&!%&
%!<)
%!%@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
( )( ) [ ] ( ) ( ) ( * + * ( ( + + * !
+( o
566 ,e2ision Aid
)!& ' (!& &!'9
@!; + %!< %!(+
-ean )!) )& )9!& 9!+%
)!) ; ;!()9
` @!)'+ +&!'
5o:xy I ;!()9 E B)!)CB;C I "@!@(9
#herefore: dx I @!&
d> I @!'
Sxx I @!)'+
S>> I +&!'
Sxy I "@!@(9
a
)
I +&!'B@!&C " C"@!@(9CB'C
+&!'B@!)'+C E B"@!@(9C`
a
%
I @!)'+B'C E B"@!@(9CB@!&C
9!'+%
I )!@)% I @!)(@
9!'+%
#herefore the function will be given by:
Q I %!9&(B)!)C G @!)(B)+C
I 9!)&
#he Q scores are indicated in the above table!
#he Q score that minimi>es misclassification form can be easily identified from the Q score
computed above! 4rom these scores a Q score of &!<@ will have only % accounts being
misclassified!
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC 3efer to lesson ( in the study manual
bC iC nalysis
Since net profit margin is given, analyse the net benefits on the basis of
net profits
Current <olicy New <olicy
Sales
5redit sales
*ad debts
5redit period
/7 -argin
9,@@@,@@@
I %9Fx9@@@,@@@ I
),%9@,@@@
I %F of credit sales
I &@ days
9- x )!+@ I ',9@@,@@@
&@Fx',9@@,@@@I%,'@@,@
@@
+F of credit sales
+9 days
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 568
)9F )9F
nalysis
/et profits
/ew policy I )9F x %,'@@,@@@ I +;@,@@@
,ld policy I )9F x ),%9@,@@@ I )(<,9@@
/et benefit %@%,9@@
*ad debts
/ew policy I +F x %,'@@,@@@ I <(,@@@
,ld policy I %F x ),%9@,@@@ I %9,@@@
/et benefit BcostC
B9+,@@@C
1ebtors
/ew policy I
@@@ , '@@ , %
+'@
+9
x
I %9%,<<(
,ld policy I @@@ , %9@ , )
+'@
&@
x I )+(,((@
$ncrease in debtors I ))+,((;
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
567 ,e2ision Aid
4orgone benefits on tied up capital I )&F x ))+,((; I
B)9,;&9C
5redit controller salary
/ew policy 9@,@@@
,ld policy @
B9@,@@@C
/et benefits (+,999
bC iiC #he credit policy should be determined by the *oard of directors of the
firm with advise from finance manager and credit controller!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 56:
LESSON 9
J.EST&ON ONE
aC #he price of a share would change due to demand and supply forces in the stock
exchange which may be triggered by factors such as:
nnouncement of dividends
7ublication of financial statements showing profitability of the firm
nnouncement of mergers and acquisitions
7olitical stability in the country e!g! general elections
.conomic performance and policies such as fiscal and monetary policies
6rowth and investment opportunities of the firm
#he change in management team of the firm
5hanges in interest rates in the economy which will affect the cost of
capital and value of the firm!
bC iC 51 means 5um"dividends i!e! the firm has declared dividends and the
shareholders registered is not yet closed! 1uring this period shares are
selling cum"div!
iiC dash B"C means no shares were traded Bno shares were either bought or
soldC
iiiC company may be suspended from the stock exchange if:
$ts share price falls below the par value
#he firm Be!g a bankC is put under statutory management by 5*0
When the firm is insolvent i!e! total liabilities are greater than total
assets!
When its capital falls below the required capital base
When the firm fails to hold an 6- and publish its audited financial
statements
When a firm violates rules and regulations of 5apital -arket
uthority e!g failure to seek permission from 5- to make rights
issue!
ivC 5* means 5um"bonus or script issue or capitali>ation issue! #he firm
has declared a bonus issue which has not been given to shareholders!
vC ,rd! Sh!)@ indicates the parAnominal value of a share as indicated in the
capital clause of the firm! $t is the price at which shares were sold when
the firm was getting quoted on the stock exchange!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
56; ,e2ision Aid
J.EST&ON TWO
aC 4inancial markets E #here are markets which facilitate transfer of funds from
surplus economic units BlendersC to deficit economic units BborrowersC!
" $n these markets, financial assets and liabilities are created where
financial assets are held by lenders and liabilities are incurred by
borrowers!
" 4inancial markets consist of capital and money markets i!e! markets for
long term and short term instruments respectively!
Stock market is a form of capital market where long term securities such
as shares and debentures are traded through demand and supply forces
which determine security prices!
" #he buying and selling of securities is usually through a stock broker!
Stock market is a portion of financial markets!
bC iC 5entral 1epository System B51SC
#his is an automatedAelectronic or computeri>ed system of trading of
shares where a shareholder shall have a share account in the 51S which will
act as the prime facie evidence of shares ownership! #he share
certificate is thus not required since all share records are electronically
held!
#he share account is debited on purchase of shares and credited on sale
of shares!
iiC #he advantages of 51S are:
$t will facilitate fast trading of shares
#he transfer of shares between investors could take only + days
3educed transaction costs e!g! no need for stamp duty since share
certificates are not required!
$t will improve the liquidity of the stock exchange due to increased
share turnover
$t will lead to more efficient effective and transparent securities
market to achieve international standards!
$t leads to dematerialisation since no physical share certificate is
required! #he account at 51S is adequate evidence of share
ownership!
cC iC share price would be said to be unfair if:
$t is not determined by demand and supply forces
$f the price is not consistent with the activities of the firm e!g a firm
with high profits and good growth potential experiencing decline in
share price!
#he price is not compatible with the price of other similar shares of
firms in the same industry!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 569
$n case of insider trading!
iiC 7A. ratio indicates the payback period of an investment! #he shares of
/dege 2imited are preferable since payback is only %!9 years compared
to )@ years for 7iki 7iki 2td!
J.EST&ON T-,EE
aC iC 5ontango E interest paid by the investor for money borrowed by a stock
market to buy shares for the investor!
iiC *ackwardation E 5ommission paid to the lender of shares where a dealer
JborrowedK shares which he had to deliver immediately!
iiiC Stages:
" Speculatory who buy new securities believing they are
undervalued!
" #hey sell them when price rises to make a gain!
ivC 3ole of investment bankers
" dvising on issue price of new shares
" Underwriting
" 4inancing decisions of the firm
" 7ortfolio management
" 1efensive mechanism in case of acquisition
" :aluation of securities
bC Selling price
I Sh!)9@ x B)"@!%C I Sh!)%@ i!e %@F below the
highest price
*uying price
I Sh!;@ x B) G @!%C I Sh!)@( i!e %@F above the
highest price
5apital gains I Sh!)% per share
$nterim and final 17S I )!9@ G &!9@ I Sh! '
#otal returns from the share Sh!)(
$nvestment I *!7 I Sh!)@(
F return on investment I F < ! )' )@@
)@(
)(
x
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC Savings and 5redit 5o"operative Societies mobili>e savings and assist in investment
as follows:
" $ndividuals with surplus funds make voluntary savings with Saccos!
Saccos are thus vehicles of savings in the economy!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
58I ,e2ision Aid
" $ndividuals who need to make investments borrow from Saccos without
the need for collateral!
" #he interest rate charged on borrowers Bwho are also saversC is below the
market interest rate!
" #he borrowing is based on the savers savings! #he repayment terms are
very attractive! 3epayments are guaranteed by fellow Sacco members!
" SaccosD thus provide means of savings and sources of borrowing for
investment!
bC #he credit default for /6, that extend credit to informal businesses and small
traders is kept low in various ways such as:
" mount advanced is based on the borrowers ability to pay!
" Use of friendsAother traders as guarantors of the borrower
" 2ender has to do research and acquire knowledge on the conditions
surrounding the borrower!
" 2enders usually have follow"up mechanism to ensure effective use of
amount borrowed and provide support on effective use of debt!
" 7ressure is exerted by fellow borrowersAguarantors on the defaulting
borrower to pay!
cC /o! #his is because:
SaccoDs are not profit making firms and are strictly for serving members
interest!
$f they are converted into banks, the lending mechanism is formali>ed
which could frustrate the efforts of the Saccos and members!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 584
+AST C+A E3AM&NAT&ON +A+E,S
KEN0A ACCO.NTANTS AND SEC,ETA,&ES NAT&ONAL E3AM&NAT&ONS !OA,D
C+A +A,T && and C+A +A,T &&&
Bune 5II4 Time= @ -ours
nswer 22 questions in S.5#$,/ $ and ,/. question in S.5#$,/ $$! -arks allocated to
each question are shown at the end of the question! Show all your workings!
SECT&ON &
J.EST&ON ONE
aC State the circumstances under which it would be advantageous to lenders and to
borrowers from the issue of:
iC 1ebentures with a floating rate of interest! B& marksC
iiC Qero"coupon bonds! B& marksC
B$gnore taxationC
bC iC *riefly discuss the disadvantages of the constant growth dividend model as a
valuation model! B&
marksC
iiC #he dividend per share of -ava>i 2imited as at +) 1ecember %@@@ was Sh!%!9@!
#he companyDs financial analyst has predicted that dividends would grow at %@F
for five years after which growth would fall to a constant rate of <F! #he analyst
has also pro=ected a required rate of return of return of )@F for the equity market!
-ava>iDs shares have a similar risk to the typical equity market!
,e>uired
#he intrinsic value of shares of -ava>i 2td as at +) 1ecember %@@@! B( marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
J.EST&ON TWO
aC #he management of 4uraha 7ackers 2td! $s planning to carry out two activities at the
same time to:
iC determine the best credit policy for its customers
iiC find out the optimal level of ordering orange =uice from its suppliers
#he following data have been collected to assist in making the decisions:
)! nnual requirements of orange =uice are %,)@@,@@@ litres!
%! #he carrying cost of the =uice is Sh!( per litre per year!
+! #he cost of placing an order is She!( per litre per year!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
585 ,e2ision Aid
&! #he required rate of return for this type of investment is )(F after tax!
9! 1ebtors currently are running at Sh!'@ million and have an average collection
period of &@ days!
'! Sales are expected to increase by %@F if the credit terms are relaxed and to result
in an average collection period of '@ days!
<! '@F of sales are on credit!
(! the gross margin on sales is +@F and is to be maintained in future!
,e>uired
iC Use the inventory B*aumolC model to determine the economic order quantity and the
ordering and holding costs at these levels per annum! B( marksC
iiC 1etermine if the company should switch to the new credit policy! B& marksC
bC #he ppolo 5ollection 5ompany 2td! .mploys agents who collect hire purchase
instalments and other outstanding amounts on a door to door basis from -onday to
4riday! #he agents bank their collections at the close of business everyday from -onday
to #hursday! t the close of business on 4riday the weekDs bankings are withdrawn and,
together with 4ridayDs collections, are remitted to the head office! #he takings are evenly
spread daily and weekly! #he budget for the next year shows that total collections will
amount to Sh!%' million! #he bankings are used to reduce an overdraft whose interest
rate is );F!
#he collection manager has suggested that instead of banking collections, they be
remitted daily to the head office by the collectors!
,e>uired
1etermine the increase in annual interest if the collection managerDs suggestion was adopted!
B( marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 58@
J.EST&ON T-,EE
3afiki Hardware #ools 5ompany 2imited sells plumbing fixtures on terms of %A)@ net +@! $ts
financial statements for the last three years are as follows:
499;
S%FIIIF
4999
S%FIIIF
5III
S%FIIIF
5ash
ccounts receivable
$nventory
/et fixed assets
ccounts payable
ccruals
*ank loan, short term
2ong term debt
5ommon stock
3etained earnings
dditional information:
Sales
5ost of goods sold
/et profit
+@,@@@
%@@,@@@
&@@,@@@
(@@,@@@
),&+@,@@@
%+@,@@@
%@@,@@@
)@@,@@@
+@@,@@@
)@@,@@@
9@@,@@@
),&+@,@@@
&,@@@,@@@
+,%@@,@@@
+@@,@@@
%@,@@@
%'@,@@@
&(@,@@@
(@@,@@@
),9'@,@@@
+@@,@@@
%)@,@@@
)@@,@@@
+@@,@@@
)@@,@@@
99@,@@@
),9'@,@@@
&,+@@,@@@
+,'@@,@@@
%@@,@@@
9,@@@
%;@,@@@
'@@,@@@
(@@,@@@
),';9,@@@
+(@,@@@
%%9,@@@
)&@,@@@
+@@,@@@
)@@,@@@
99@,@@@
),';9,@@@
+,(@@,@@@
+,+@@,@@@
)@@,@@@
,e>uired
aC 4or each of the three years, calculate the following ratios:
cid test ratio, verage collection period, $nventory turnover, #otal debtAequity, /et
profit margin and 3eturn on assets! B)%
marksC
bC 4rom the ratios calculated above, comment on the liquidity, profitability and gearing
positions of the company! B( marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC .xplain fully the effect of the use of debt capital on the weighted average cost of capital
of a company! B' marksC
bC -illennium $nvestments 2td! wishes to raise funds amounting to Sh!)@ million to fiancd a
pro=ect in the following manner:
Sh!' million from debtO and
Sh!& million from floating new ordinary shares!
#he present capital structure of the company is made up as follows:
)! '@@,@@@ fully paid ordinary shares of Sh!)@ each!
%! 3etained earnings of Sh!& million!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
586 ,e2ision Aid
+! %@@,@@@, )@F preference shares of Sh!%@ each!
&! &@,@@@ 'F long term debentures of Sh!)9@ each!
#he current market value of the companyDs ordinary shares is Sh!'@ per share! #he expected
ordinary share dividends in a yearDs time is Sh!%!&@ per share! #he average growth rate in both
dividends and earnings has been )@F over the past ten years and this growth rate is expected to
be maintained in the foreseeable future!
#he companyDs long term debentures currently change hands for Sh!)@@ each! #he debentures
will mature in )@@ years! #he preference shares were issued four years ago and still change
hands at face value!
,e>uired
iC 5ompute the component cost of:
" ,rdinary share capitalO B% marksC
" 1ebt capitalO B% marksC
" 7reference share capital B% marksC
iiC 5ompute the companyDs current weighted average cost of capital! B9 marksC
iiiC 5ompute the companyDs marginal cost of capital if it raised the additional Sh!)@ million
as envisaged! B9 marksC
Bssume a tax rate of +@FC! "Total= 5I marks#
SECT&ON &&
J.EST&ON *&/E
aC #he 5- B5apital -arket uthorityC has put in place several tax incentives to encourage
investments in capital markets!
Highlight some of the tax incentives by the 5apital -arkets uthority! B& marksC
bC .xplain the benefits that are en=oyed by investors because of the existence of organi>ed
security exchanges! B( marksC
cC *riefly describe the benefits of the 5entral 1epository System B51SC to the following
stakeholders:
iC 6overnmentO B% marksC
iiC 5apital -arkets uthority and /airobi Stock .xchange! B% marksC
iiiC $nvestors! B% marksC
"Total= 4; marks#
J.EST&ON S&3
aC What are financial intermediaries and what role do they play in the economyM B; marksC
bC 4oreign 1irect $nvestment B41$C plays a crucial role in revamping less developed
economies,
,e>uired
Write brief notes on the obstacles to the flow of 41$ into the 0enyan economy! B; marksC
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 588
"Total= 4; marks#
KEN0A ACCO.NTANTS AND SEC,ETA,&ES NAT&ONAL E3AM&NAT&ONS !OA,D
C+A +A,T && and C+A +A,T &&&
Decem?er 5II4
nswer 22 questions in S.5#$,/ $ and ,/. question in S.5#$,/ $$! -arks allocated to
each question are shown at the end of the question! Show all your workings!
SECT&ON &
J.EST&ON ONE
aC Highlight four advantages and disadvantages to a company of being listed on a stock
exchange! B( marksC
bC $n relation to the stock exchange:
iC .xplain the role of the following members:
floor brokers B% marksC
market makers B% marksC
underwriters B% marksC
iiC .xplain the meaning of the following terms:
bull and bear markets B% marksC
bid"ask spread B% marksC
short selling B% marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
J.EST&ON TWO
-ulti"2ink, a trading company, currently has negligible cash holdings but expects to make a
series of cash payments totaling Sh!)9@ million over the forthcoming year! #hese payments will
become due at a steady rate! #wo alternative ways have been suggested of meeting these
obligations!
Alternati2e &
#he company can make periodic sales from existing holdings of short"term securities! #he
average percentage rate of return on these securities is )% over the forthcoming year! Whenever
-ulti"2ink 2td sells the securities! $t will incur a transaction fee of Sh!)9,@@@! #he proceeds
from the sale of the securities are placed on short"term deposit at <F per annum interest until
needed!
Alternati2e &&
#he company can arrange for a secured loan amounting to Sh!)9@ million for one year at an
interest rate of )(F per annum based on the initial balance of the loan! #he lender also imposes a
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
587 ,e2ision Aid
flat arrangement fee of Sh!9@,@@@ which would be met out of existing balances! #he sum
borrowed could be placed in a notice deposit at ;F per annum and drawn down at no cost as and
when required! -ulti"2ink 2td!Ds treasurer believes that cash balances will be run down at an
even rate throughout the year!
,e>uired
aC iC .xplain the weaknesses of the *aumol model in the management of cash!
B+ marksC
iiC dvise -ulti"2ink 2td! as to the better alternative for managing its cash!
B< marksC
bC 2ynx Services 2td!, a debt collection agency, has estimated that the standard deviation of
its daily net cash flow is Sh!%%,<9@! #he company pays Sh!)%@ in transaction cost every
time it transfers funds into and out of the money market! #he rate of interest in the
money market is ;!&'F! #he company uses the -iller",rr -odel to set its target cash
balance! #he minimum cash balance has been set at Sh!(<,9@@!
,e>uired
iC #he companyDs target cash balance! B+ marksC
iiC #he lower and upper cash limit! B% marksC
iiiC 2ynx Services 2td!Ds decision rules! B9 marksC
J.ST&ON T-,EE
-agharibi 5ane -illers 2td! is a company engaged in the pressing and processing of sugar can
=uice into refined sugar! 4or some time, the company has been considering the replacement of its
three existing machines!
#he production manager has learnt from a professional newsletter on sugar of the availability of a
news and larger machine whose capacity is such that it can produce the same level of output per
annum currently produced by the three machines! 4urthermore, the new machine would cut down
on he wastage of =uice during processing! $f the old machines are not replaced, an extraordinary
overhaul would be immediately necessary in order to maintain them in operational condition!
#his overhaul would at present cost Sh!9,@@@,@@@ in total!
#he following additional information is available:
)! #he old machines were purchased 9 years ago and are being depreciated over )9 years on
a straight line basis, with an estimated final scrap value of Sh!'@@,@@@ each! #he current
second hand market value of each of the machines is Sh!),@@@,@@@!
%! #he annual operating costs for each of the existing machines areO
3aw sugar cane
2abour Bone operatorC
:ariable expense
-aintenance Bexcluding overhaul
expenditureC
4ixed expenses
1epreciation
Shs!
<9,@@@
%,<@@,@@@
Shs!
'@,@@@,@@
@
),+9@,@@@
;%9,@@@
%,@@@,@@@
"
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 58:
4ixed factory overhead absorbed %,<<9,@@@
+! #he new machine has an estimated life of ten years and its initial cost will comprise:
Shs!
7urchase price Bscrap value in )@ years, Sh!&,9@@,@@@C (<,@@@,@@@
4reight and installation )+,@@@,@@@
)@@,@@@,@@@
&! #he estimated annual operating costs, if all the current output is processed on the new
machine are:
3aw sugar cane
2abour
:ariable expense
4ixed expenses:
1epreciation
4ixed factory overhead absorbed
-aintenance
Shs!
;,99@,@@@
<,(@@,@@@
Shs!
)'%,@@@,@@
@
+,;@@,@@@
%,%<9,@@@
)<,+9@,@@@
&,9@@,@@@
9! #he companyDs cost of capital is )@F!
'! 4or a pro=ect to be implemented, it must pass both the profitability test, as indicated by its
internal rate of return and also satisfy a financial viability test, in that it must pay back for
itself within a maximum period of five years!
,e>uired
aC iC /et present values of the proposed replacement decision using discount rates of
)@F and %@F! B( marksC
iiC #he estimated internal rate of return B$33C of the replacement decision using the
values determined in BiC above! B& marksC
iiiC dvise management on the proposal based on your answer in BiC above!
B% marksC
bC 1ecision as to whether the pro=ect meets the financial viability test! B&
marksC
cC 5omment on any other qualitative considerations that could influence this decision!
/*: $gnore taxation! B% marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
J.EST&ON *O.,
#hree years ago, -rs 3ehema Wa>iri was retrenched from the 5ivil Service! She invested
substantially all her terminal benefits in the shares of *5 2td! a company quoted on the stock
exchange! #he dividend payments from this investment makes up a significant portion of -rs!
Wa>iriDs income! She was alarmed when *5 2td, dropped its year %@@) dividend to Sh!)!%9
per share from Sh!)!<9 per share which it had paid in the previous two years!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
58; ,e2ision Aid
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 589
-rs Wa>iri has approached you for advice and you have gathered the information given below
regarding the financial condition of *5 2td! and the finance sector as a whole!
4999
S%FIIIF
5III
S%FIIIF
5II4
S%FIIIF
5ash
ccounts receivable
$nventory
#otal current assets
2and and buildings
-achinery
,ther fixed assets
#otal assets
ccounts and notes payable
ccruals
#otal current liabilities
2ong term debt
,rdinary share capital
3etained earnings!
)9,%9@
(@,+%@
;(,'@@
);&,)<@
%9,%+@
++,(@@
)&,;%@
%'(,)%@
+&,%%@
)9,<@@
&;,;%@
'@,(9@
))9,@@@
&%,+9@
%'(,)%@
)&,&@@
(<,(@@
)9(,(@@
%'),@@@
%<,'@@
+',&@@
)(,%@@
+&+,%@@
<+,<'@
+&,@@@
)@<,<'@
'@,(9(
))9,@@@
9;,9(%
+&+,%@@
(,@@@
)+&,&@@
%9&,@@@
+;',&@@
%9,@@@
+@,'@@
)',&@@
&'(,&@@
)+9,(&(
'<,@@@
%@%,(&(
(),<%@
))9,@@@
'(,(+%
&'(,&@@
A!C Ltd( &ncome Statement 'or t%e year ending
@4 Octo?er
4999
S%FIIIF
5III
S%FIIIF
5II4
S%FIIIF
Sales Ball on creditC
5ost of sales
6ross profit
6eneral administrative and selling
expenses
,ther operating expenses
.arnings before interest and tax B.*$#C
$nterest expense
/et income before taxes
#axes
/et income
/umber of shares issued
7er share data:
.arnings per share B.7SC
1ividend per share
-arket price BaverageC
(%<,@@@
B''),'@@C
)'9,&@@
B'+,'@@C
B%9,&@@C
<',&@@
B)%,(@@C
'+,'@@
B%9,&@@C
+(,%@@
&,'@@,@@@
Sh!(!+@
Sh!)!<9
Sh!&(!;@
(9(,@@@
B<)@,@@@C
)&(,@@@
B&<,%'&C
B+),(@@C
'(,;+'
B%',(@@C
&%,)+'
B)',(9&C
%9,%(%
&,'@@,@@@
Sh!9!9@
Sh!)!<9
Sh!%9!9@
(;@,@@@
B<)%,@@@C
)<(,@@@
B9),%@@C
B+(,%@@C
((,'@@
B'+,'@@C
%9,@@@
B)@,@@@C
)9,@@;
&,'@@,@@@
Sh!+!%'
Sh!)!%9
Sh!)+!%9
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
57I ,e2ision Aid
$ndustry 4inancial ratios
"5II4#
?uick ratio
5urrent ratio
$nventory turnover
verage collection period
4ixed asset turnover
#otal assets turnover
/et income to net worth
/et profit margin on sales
7rice".arnings B7A.C ratio
1ebtA.quity ratio
)!@
%!<
< times
+% days
)+!@ times
%!' times
)(F
+!9F
' times
9@F
Notes
)! $ndustry ratios have been roughly constant for the past four years!
%! $nventory turnover, total assets turnover and fixed assets turnover are based on the year"
end balance sheet figures!
,e>uired
aC #he financial ratios for *5 2td! for the past three years corresponding to industry ratios
given above! B)@ marksC
bC rrange the ratios calculated in BaC above in columnar form and summarise the strengths
and weaknesses revealed by these ratios based on:
iC #rends in the firmDs ratios! B' marksC
iiC 5omparison with industry averages! B' marksC
B#he summary should focus on the liquidity, profitability and turnover ratiosC!
"Total= 5I marks#
SECT&ON &&
J.EST&ON *&/E
aC 2ist and explain five factors that should be taken into account by a businessman in
making the choice between financing by short"term and long"term sources!
B)@ marksC
bC .numerate four advantages of convertible bonds from the point of view of the borrower!
B( marksC
"Total=4; marks#
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 574
J.EST&ON S&3
$n a company, an agency problem may exist between management and shareholders on one hand
and the debt holders Bcreditors and lendersC on the other because management and shareholders,
who own and control the company have the incentive to enter into transactions that may transfer
wealth from debt holders to shareholders! Hence the need for agreements by debt holders is
lending contracts!
,e>uired
aC State and explain any four actions or transactions by management and shareholders that
could be harmful to the interests of debt holders Bsources of conflictC!
B( marksC
bC Write short notes on any four restrictive covenants that debt holders may use to protect
their wealth from management and shareholder raids! B)@ marksC
"Total= 4; marks#
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
575 ,e2ision Aid
KEN0A ACCO.NTANTS AND SEC,ETA,&ES NAT&ONAL E3AM&NAT&ONS !OA,D
C+A +A,T && and C+A +A,T &&&
May 5II5
nswer 22 questions in S.5#$,/ $ and ,/. question in S.5#$,/ $$! -arks allocated to
each question are shown at the end of the question! Show 22 your workings!
SECT&ON &
J.EST&ON ONE
aC 1iscuss the drawbacks of using the following approaches in estimating a securityDs value!
iC *ook valueO B+ marksC
iiC 3eplacement valueO B+ marksC
iiiC Substitution valueO B+ marksC
ivC $ntrinsic value! B+ marksC
bC /gomongo Holdings 2imited has investment interests in three companies! 0irinyaga
:ideo 2imited B0:2C! 0ilgoris Hauliers 2imited B0H2C and #urkana 4isheries 2imited
B#42C! #he following financial data relate to these companies:
)! s at +) 1ecember %@@), the financial statements of two of the companies
revealed the following information:
5ompany 7rice of share
S%(
Earnings <er s%are
S%(
Di2idend <er
s%are
S%(
0irinyaga :ideo
2td B0:2C
0ilgoris Hauliers
2td! B0H2C
)'@
%<@
(
)(
(
;
%! .arnings and dividend information for #urkana 4isheries 2td! B#42C for the past
five years is given below:
0ear ended @4
Decem?er
499:
S%(
499;
S%(
4999
S%(
5III
S%(
5II4
S%(
.arnings per share
1ividend per share
9!@
+!@
'!@
+!@
<!@
+!9
)@!@
9!@
)%!@
9!9
#he estimated return on equity before tax required by investors in #urkana
4isheries 2td!Ds shares is %@F!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 57@
,e>uired
iC 4or 0irinyaga :ideo 2td! B0:2C and 0ilgoris Hauliers 2td! B0H2C, determine and
compare:
1ividend yields B% marksC
7riceA.arnings ratios B% marksC
1ividend covers B%
marksC
iiC Using the dividends growth model, determine the market value of ),@@@ shares held in
#urkana 4isheries 2td! B#42C as at +) 1ecember %@@)!
B& marksC
"Total= 55 marks#
J.EST&ON TWO
5lean Wash 2td! manufactures and markets automatic washing machines! mong the many
hundreds of components which it purchases each year from external suppliers for assembling into
the finished articles are drive belts, of which it uses &@@,@@@ units per annum! $t is considering
converting its purchasing delivery and stock control of this item to a Nust"$n"#ime BN$#C system!
#his will raise the number of orders placed but lower the administrative and other costs of placing
and receiving orders! $f successful, this will provide the model for switching most of its inwards
supplies into this system!
1etails of current and proposed ordering and carrying costs are given below:
,rdering cost per order
7urchase cost per item
$nventory holding cost Bas a percentage of the purchase costC
Current
S%(4I)III
S%(58
5IK
+ro<osed
S%(5)8II
S%(58
5IK
#o implement new arrangements will require a Lone"offD reorgani>ation costs estimated at
Sh!)&@,@@@ which will be treated as a revenue item for tax purposes! #he rate of corporation tax
is +%!9F and 5lean Wash 2td! can obtain finance at an effective cost of )(F! #he life span of the
new system is ( years!
,e>uired
aC iC #he economic order quantity with current and proposed arrangements!
B9 marksC
iiC /et 7resent :alue B/7:C of the new arrangement! $s the new arrangement
worthwhileM B)@ marksC
bC *riefly explain the nature and ob=ectives of N$# purchasing agreements concluded
between components users and suppliers!
B9 marksC
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
576 ,e2ision Aid
"Total= 5I marks#
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 578
J.EST&ON T-,EE
#he management of fro ?uatro 2td! want to establish the amount of external financial needs for
the next two years! #he balance sheet of the firm as at +) 1ecember %@@) is as follows:
/et fixed assets
Stock
1ebtors
5ash
#otal assets
4inanced by:
,rdinary share capital
3etained earnings
)%F long term debt
#rade creditors
ccrued expenses
S%(FIIIF
)%&,(@@
+&,&@@
%(,(@@
<,%@@
);;,%@@
(&,@@@
+9,%@@
%@,@@@
+',@@@
%&,@@@
);;,%@@
4or the year ended +) 1ecember %@@), sales amounted to Sh!%&@,@@@,@@@! #he firm pro=ects that
the sales will increase by )9F in year %@@% and %@F in year %@@+!
#he after tax profit on sales has been ))F but the management is pessimistic about future
operating costs and intends to use an after"tax profit on sales rate of (F per annum!
#he firm intends to maintain its dividend pay out ratio of (@F! ssets are expected to vary
directly with sales while trade creditors and accrued expenses from the spontaneous sources of
financing! ny external financing will be effected through the use of commercial paper!
,e>uired
aC 1etermine the amount of external financial requirements for the next two years! B<
marksC
bC iC proforma balance sheet as at +) 1ecember %@@+! B)@ marksC
iiC State the fundamental assumption made in your computations in BaC and b BiC
above!
B) markC
"Total= 4; marks#
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
577 ,e2ision Aid
J.EST&ON *O.,
7! -uli was recently appointed to the post of investment manager of -asada 2td! a quoted
company! #he company has raised Sh!(,@@@,@@@ through a rights issue!
7! -uli has the task of evaluating two mutually exclusive pro=ects with unequal economic lives!
7ro=ect P has < years and 7ro=ect 8 has & years of economic life! *oth pro=ects are expected to
hav >ero salvage value! #heir expected cash flows are as follows:
+roEect
0ear
3
Cas% 'lows "S%(#
0
Cas% 'lows "S%(#
)
%
+
&
9
'
<
%,@@@,@@@
%,%@@,@@@
%,@(@,@@@
%,%&@,@@@
%,<'@,@@@
+,%@@,@@@
+,'@@,@@@
&,@@@,@@@
+,@@@,@@@
&,(@@,@@@
(@@,@@@
"
"
"
#he amount raised would be used to finance either of the pro=ects! #he company expects to pay a
dividend per share of Sh!'!9@ in one yearDs time! #he current market price per share is Sh!9@!
-asada 2td! expects the future earnings to grow by <F per annum due to the undertaking of
either of the pro=ects! -asada 2td! has no debt capital in its capital structure!
,e>uired
aC #he cost of equity of the firm! B+ marksC
bC #he net present value of each pro=ect! B' marksC
cC #he $nternal 3ate of 3eturn B$33C of the pro=ects! B3ediscount cash flows at %&F for
7ro=ect P and %9F for 7ro=ect 8C! B' marksC
dC *riefly comment on your results in BbC and BcC above! B% marksC
eC $dentify and explain the circumstances under which the /et 7resent :alue B/7:C and the
$nternal 3ate of 3eturn B$33C methods could rank mutually exclusive pro=ects in a
conflicting way! B9 marksC
"Total= 55 marks#
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 57:
SECT&ON &&
J.EST&ON *&/E
aC What is meant by the term Jcapital flightKM B9 marksC
bC Why have frican economies been characteri>ed by much capital flight in the pastM
B( marksC
cC What is the impact of massive capital flight on the value of the domestic currencyM
B9 marksC
"Total= 4; marks#
J.EST&ON S&3
aC 1iscuss the main factors which a company should consider when determining the
appropriate mix of long"term and short"term debt in its capital structure! B' marksC
bC -alingi 2eisure $ndustries is already highly geared by industry standards, but wishes to
raise external capital to finance the development of a new beach resort!
,utline the arguments for and against a rights issue by -alindi 2eisure $ndustries!
B' marksC
cC .xamine the relative merits of leasing versus hire purchase as a means of acquiring
capital assets! B'
marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
57; ,e2ision Aid
,E/&S&ON J.EST&ONS
J.EST&ON ONE
#he following are the financial statements of 3ichardo 2td! for the year ended +) -arch );;9:
!alance S%eet as at @4 Marc% 4998
5ash
1ebtors
Stock
/et equipment
Shs!
&(@,@@@
'&@,@@@
%,@(@,@@@
),'@@,@@@
&,(@@,@@@
#rade creditors
/otes 7ayable ;BFC
2ong term debt B)@FC
Shareholders .quity
Shs!
('@,@@@
(&@,@@@
),'@@,@@@
),9@@,@@@
&,(@@,@@@
Sales
2ess: 5ost of sales
6ross profit
1educt: Selling expenses
dministrative and general
expenses
$nterest charges
7rofit before taxation
#axation
/et profit
Shs!
'@@,@@@
),)%@,@@@
%+9,'@@
Shs!
',@@@,@@@
+,'@@,@@@
%,&@@,@@@
),;99,'@@
&&&,&@@
)<<,<'@
%'','&@
ll sales are net and on credit!
#he following industry ratios are also provided to you!
$ndustry verages
5urrent ratio
cid test ratio
Stock turnover ratio
#otal assets turnover ratio
#imes interest earned ratio
/et profit margin
3eturn on investment
#otal assets to shareholders equity
3eturn on shareholders equity
%!9 times
)!) times
%!& times
)!& times
+!9 times
&!@ percent
9!' percent
+!@ times
)'!( percent
,e>uired
aC 5alculate the ratios shown above for 3ichardo 2td! and present them in columnar
form along the industry averages! B)&
marksC
bC 5omment upon the following about 3ichardo 2td! in relation to the industry
averages:
iC 2iquidity position! B+ marksC
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 579
iiC 4inancial risk B+ marksC
iiiC ,verall performance B+ marksC
"Total= 5@ marks#
J.EST&ON TWO
aC 1eni 2imited wishes to raise funds for expansion using corporate bonds!
iC What is a corporate bondM B% marksC
iiC State and explain two advantages in the use of corporate bonds! B%
marksC
iiiC What costs are associated with the issue of corporate bondsM B&
marksC
bC 1eni 2imited has issued Sh!)@,@@@, )'F bonds redeemable at par on ) Nune %@@;! #he
bonds are dated ) -ay );;;! #he bonds may however be redeemed at par on ) Nune
%@@)! Upon issue the bonds will be traded on the Stock .xchange! #he market rate of
interest on ) -ay was )&F!
,e>uired
iC #he issue price of the bond! B& marksC
iiC #he expected market price of the bond as at ) Nune %@@)! #he market rate
of interest is expected to be )@F! B&
marksC
iiiC Should 1eni 2imited redeem the bond on ) Nune %@@)M WhyM
B& marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
J.EST&ON T-,EE
3$#. 2td! maintains an average monthly balance of Sh!+%@,@@@ in accounts receivable
throughout the year! #he company is in need of additional working capital and is considering two
alternative methods of raising it!
-.#H,1 ) 4actoring accounts receivable
-.#H,1 % commercial bank loan secured by accounts receivable!
#he companyDs bankers have agreed to lend the firm (@F of its average accounts receivable at an
interest of +@F per annum! #he amount will be made available in a series of +@ day advances!
#he advances would be discounted and a 'F compensating balance will be required!
#he factor is willing to establish a factoring arrangement on a continuing basis! $t charges %F for
servicing the accounts and )9F per annum on any advances taken! *oth charges are made on
discount basis! $n addition, the factor requires a 9F reserve to cover returned items! 3$#. 2td!
sells its merchandise on terms of net +@!
,e>uired
aC 5alculate the amount of advances 3$#. 2td! can expect to have under each
alternative! B)& marksC
bC 5alculate the effective rate of interest for each financing alternative! B& marksC
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5:I ,e2ision Aid
cC Which alternative would you recommend and whyM B% marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5:4
J.EST&ON *O.,
5apital markets in 0enya have expanded over the last few years! #his expansion is due to:
iC #he initiatives of 5apital -arkets uthority
iiC #he introduction of new financial instruments
iiiC #he appreciation of the role and functions of the capital markets by 0enyans!
,e>uired
aC What are the roles of 5apital -arkets uthorityM B' marksC
bC .xplain the meaning of the term J4inancial $nstrumentK B& marksC
cC 1escribe the following investments which are available in the 0enyan -arket today:
iC #reasury *illO B& marksC
iiC 5ommercial 7aper B& marksC
"Total= 4; marks#
J.EST&ON *&/E
-r! Hesabu 0a>i is considering giving up his paid employment and going into business on his
own account! He is considering buying a quarry pit with a JlifeK of about +9 years! #o purchase
this business, he would have to pay Z%,+<9,@@@ now! -r! 0a>i wishes to retire in %@ yearsD time!
He predicts that the net cash operating receipts from this business will be Z'%9,@@@ per annum for
the first )9 years and Z9@@,@@@ per annum for the last 9 years! He thinks that the business could
be sold at the end of the %@ year period for Z<9@,@@@! dditionally, he estimates that certain
capital replacements and improvements would be necessary and this should amount to Z9@,@@@
per annum for the first 9 yearsO Z<9,@@@ per annum for the next 9 years, Z)@@,@@@ per annum for
the next < years and nothing for the last three years! #his expenditure would be incurred at the
start!
-r! 0a>i has excluded any compensation to himself from the above data! $f he should purchase
the business, however, he would have to leave his present =ob in which he earns Z%9@,@@@ a year!
#o finance the purchase of this business, he would have to reali>e his present savings which are
invested to yield a return of )@ per cent before tax, and have a comparable risk factor!
,e>uired
aC dvise -r! 0a>i as to whether or not it is advisable to purchase the business in the light of
the information given!
$gnore $ncome #ax! B)' marksC
bC $s there any additional information which you would have liked to have available to you
before giving advise to -r! 0a>iM B&
marksC
"Total= 5I Marks#
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5:5 ,e2ision Aid
S.GGESTED SOL.T&ONS M DECEM!E, 5II4
J.EST&ON ONE
a# De?enture wit% 'loating interest rate=
" debenture whose interest rate is variable and pegged to charges in interest rate
on #reasury bills e!g a debentureAbond may have a +F premium above interest
rate on #reasury bill such that:
$f interest rate on treasury bill is <F, interest rate on the bond is <F G
+F I )@F!
$f interest rate on #reasury bill rises to (!9F, the interest rate on the bond
rises to (!9F G +F I ))!9F!
" Such a bond is advantageous when market interest rates are volatile!
" $f market interest rate falls, the borrower pays lower interest charges and when it
rises, the lender receives more interest income!
" Since the coupon rate is matched to market interest rate, the intrinsic value of the
bond is usually stable and easy to determine!
bC Qero coupon bonds
" #he bonds do not pay periodic interest charges hence the words >ero coupon
bond! #hey are issued at a discount and mature at par!
" #herefore, interest is accumulated and accounted for in the redemption value of
the bond!
" #he lender is not locked into low fixed interest rate while the borrower does not
have fixed financial obligations of paying fixed interest charges!
" #he liquidity of the borrower is not affected until the redemption date!
Draw?acks o' di2idend growt% model
" $t is only applicable if the cost of equity, 0e is greater than growth rate, in
dividends i!e!
7@ I d@B)GgC
0e E g
$f gUke, then the model would collapse!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5:@
" $t is based on historical information where d@ is the past dividend per share, and
LgD is based on historical stream of dividends which may not represent the future!
" $t assume a constant stream of dividends in future, growth rate and cost of equity
all of which are not achievable in real world!
iiC 5ompute the expected 17S at end of each period and discount at )@F rate
.xpected 17S I d@B)GgC
n
End o' year E<ected D+S +/&*4IK)n 7!:
)
%
+
&
9
'"W
%!9@B)!%C
)
I +!@@
%!9@B)!%C
%
I +!'@
%!9@B)!%C
+
I &!+%
%!9@B)!%C
&
I 9!)(
%!9@B)!%C
9
I '!%%
d@B)GgC
0e " g
@!;@;
@!(%'
@!<9)
@!'(+
@!'%)
%!<+
%!;<
+!%&
+!9&
+!('
I
@< ! @ )@ ! @
C @< ! ) B %% ! '
+ +
+
&@ ! @
)&@ %%9 +(@
%;@ 9
+ +
+
verage
debtors
collection
period
1ebtors x +'@
5redit sales p!a!
%@@ x +'@ I )( days
&,@@@
%'@ x +'@ I %)!(
days
&,+@@
%;@ x %<!9 days
+,(@@
$nventory
#urnover
5ost of sales
verage stock
+,%@@ I ( times
&@@
+,'@@ I <!9@ times
&(@
+,+@@ I 9!9 times
'@@
#otal
debtAequity
#otal debt
.quity
(+@ I )!+( times
)@@ G 9@@
;)@ I )!&@ times
)@@ G 99@
)@&9 I )!') times
)@@ G 99@
/et profit
margin
/et profits x )@@
#otal ssets
+@@ x )@@ I <!9F
&@@@
%@@ x )@@ I &!'F
&+@@
)@@ x )@@ I %!'F
+(@@
3,# /et 7rofits x )@@
#otal assets
+@@ x )@@ I %)F
)&+@
%@@ x )@@ I )+F
)9'@
)@@ x )@@ I 9!;F
),';9
/*: #otal debt I 5urrent liabilities G long term debt!
bC 2iquidity 7osition
" #his is shown by acid test ratio
" #he ratio has fluctuated over the years between @!&@ and @!&'
" #his could be due to high level of inventories and increasing debtors
" #he firmDs ability to meet short term financial obligations is declining over time!
7rofitability position
" #his is shown by net profit margin and 3,# ratios
" *oth ratios are declining over time
" #his is particularly due to high operating and cost of sales expenses which are
increasing over time leading to low net profits! dditional sales of the firm are
declining!
" #he firm needs to control its costs of sales and operating expenses!
6earing position
" #his is shown by total debtAequity ratio
" #his ratio is increasing over time due to increasing accounts payable and accruals
while equity remains fairly constant!
" #he firm is thus relying more on short term financing Baggressive financing
approachC increasing financial risk and possibility of bankruptcy!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5:7 ,e2ision Aid
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC t initial stages of debt capital the W55 will be declining upto a point where the
W55 will be minimal! #his is because!
iC debt capital provides tax shield to the firm and after tax cost of debt is low!
iiC #he cost of debt is naturally low because it is contractually fixed and certain!
*eyond the optimal gearing level, W55 will start increasing as cost of debt increases
due to high financial risk!
bC iC 5ost of equity
0e I
g
P
g d
+
+
@
@
C ) B
d@B)GgC I Sh!%!&@
7@ I Sh!'@
g I )@F
0e I F )& )& ! @ )@ ! @
'@
&@ ! %
+
5ost of debt capital B0dC
Since the debenture has )@@ years maturity period then 0d I yield to maturity I
redemption!
0d I
CR B
)
C B C ) B
vd (
n
vd ( T Int
+
+
m I -aturityApar value I Sh!)9@
vd I market value I Sh!)@@
n I number of years to maturity I )@@
$nt I $nterest I 'F x Sh!)9@ I Sh!; p!a!
# I #ax rate I +@F
0d I
)@@
)%9
( ! '
CR )@@ )9@ B
)@@
)
C )@@ )9@ B C + ! @ ) B ;
x
+
+
I 9!&&)F
5ost of preference share capital 0p
0p I 5oupon rate I )@F since -7S I par value
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5::
iiC W55 or overall cost of capital 0o
Sh!D-D
-!: of equity I '@@,@@@ shares x Sh!'@ -7S +'
-!: of debt I &@,@@@ debentures x Sh!)@@ &
-!: of preference shares I %@@,@@@ shares x Sh!%@ &
&&
0e I )&F 0d I 9!&&F 0p I )@F
0o I W55 I
,
_
+
,
_
+
,
_
&&
&
F )@
&&
&
F && ! 9
&&
+'
F )&
I )%!('F
#he Sh!)@- will be raised as follows:
Sh!' - from debt
Sh!& - from shares!
Since there are no floatation costs involved then:
-arginal cost of debt I 9!&&F
-arginal cost of ordinary share capital I )&F
#herefore marginal cost of capital I
,
_
+
,
_
)@
'
F 99 ! 9
)@
&
F )&
I (!('F
J.EST&ON *&/E
aC #he tax incentives to encourage investments in capital markets are:
" 5apital gains are tax exempt
" /ew quoted firm with effect from )
st
Nanuary %@@+ will have a lower corporate
tax rate of %9F p!a! for the first 9 years of quotation!
" :enture capital firms en=oy a ten year tax holiday
" #he withholding tax on dividends is only 9F which is final tax
" 4loatation costs of newly quoted firms and tax allowable expenses
" #he transfer of securities is exempted from stamp duty and :#
" $ncome of collective investment scheme is tax free!
bC #he benefits that en=oyed by investors due to existence of organi>ed security exchanges
e!g /airobi Stock -arket are:
" #he firms are able to issue new shares and raise capital easily!
" #he exchange is a vehicle of mobili>ing savings in the economy!
" Since investors can buy new shares, this enable them to diversify their
investments and reduce risk
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5:; ,e2ision Aid
" $t is a means through which foreign direct investment B4,$C can flow into the
economy!
" $nvestors are able to know the price of their securities as determined by demand
and supply forces in the stock exchange!
" Since investors cannot buy or sell shares themselves, they interact with
stockbrokers and get investment advice!
cC #he benefits of central depository system B51SC to the:
iC 6overnment:
" #here will be greater mobili>ation of savings in the economy
" $t is a convenient way for 4,$
" $t reduces the cost of capital since transaction costs are significantly
reduced!
iiC 5apital -arket uthority and /S.
" $ncreased share turnover
" $ncreased stock market liquidity
" $mproved transparency of stock market
" *etter service delivery
iiiC $nvestors
" 3educed share transfer costs
" 4aster and more efficient settlement of deals
" $nvestments become more liquid
" 3educed share certificate is required BdematerialisationC
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5:9
J.EST&ON S&3
aC 4inancial $ntermediaries
" #hese are financial institutions which linkAintermediate between the surplus
economic units BsaversC and deficit economic units BborrowersC
" #hey can be either money market intermediaries e!g! commercial banks or capital
markets intermediaries e!g stock market
" #hey play the following roles:
#hey link the lenders and borrowers
#hey collect savings themselves and channel them to viable investments
#hey create liquidity of securities
#hey parcel up small savings from small scale savers and lend in form of bid
loans!
bC #he obstacles to 41$ are:
" 2ack of adequate legal framework and legislations
" $nadequate human resource capital
" 7olitical instability and general insecurity
" 5orruption and cases of bad governance!
" $nadequate tax and economic incentives
" Underdeveloped capital markets and financial system!
" High cost of capital due to relatively high interest rates and inflation rates!
" Unstable exchange rates which increases the cost of managing foreign exchange
risk!
DECEM!E, 5II4
J.EST&ON ONE
aC company is said to be quoted when its shares are traded on an organi>ed stock
exchange! #he advantages of being quoted are:
" $t is easier to obtain additional capital by issuing new shares!
" #he price of a share can be easily determined through demand and supply forces!
" #he ownership of the firm is spread among many shareholders creating stability
of
share prices!
" $t becomes very easy to transfer ownership from shares! #his is because no
authority is required from the firmDs shareholders!
" #he buying and selling activities creates liquidity and marketability of the share!
" #he acquisition of other firm or mergers with other firms becomes easy
especially
when there is a share for share exchange!
" 6reater prominent status and better credit standing is given to quoted firms thus
creating goodwill for the firm!
#he disadvantages of being quoted are:
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5;I ,e2ision Aid
" $t involves high floatation costs
" #he firm has to adhere to stringent stock exchange rules and regulations
" Stringent disclosure requirement thus public scrutiny and lack of privacy
" .xtra administrative burdens on the management due to the need to comply with
so
many regulatory authorities!
" #here is dilution in ownership and control from wide holding of shares!
bC iC 4loor brokers
" #hese are agents of investors who buy and sell securities on behalf of the
investors!
" #hey earn a commission for services rendered to the client!
" #hey deal with market makers who usually have the shares which stock
brokers want to buy for client!
iiC -arket makers
" Stock market dealers holding securities of selected firms! #hey thus
Jmake
a marketK for the firmDs shares!
" #hey are members of the stock market and will usually announce the
shares
they have and the price at which they are willing to sell them!
" #hey buy shares of new firms and sell them to stockbrokers thus making
profits which is the difference between buying price and selling price!
iiiC Underwriter
" #his is a financial intermediary Busually an investment bankerC who
performs the following functions!
*uying the shares not subscribed for by the public thus performs an
insurance function to ensure that the firm is able to raise targeted profits
from issue of all the shares!
-ight help in pricing of new security issues!
cC iC *ear and *ull market
" *ull market is a stock market characteri>ed by increase in share prices
whereby marginal increase in share prices is higher than marginal
declines in share prices!
" *ear market is characteri>ed by general decline in share prices! #he
marginal share price declines are higher than marginal share price
increases!
iiC *id E as spread
#his is the difference between the offer and the buying price of a share!
iiiC Short selling
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5;4
" #his is selling a share when prices are high believing that they will
decline Bbear marketC thus be bought again at a lower price!
" #he seller usually JborrowK such a share, deliver it to the client and on
purchase of the share at a lower price, it is returned to the JlenderK
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5;5 ,e2ision Aid
J.EST&ON TWO
aC iC Weaknesses of *aumol -odel
#he weaknesses of the *aumol B.,?C model are inherent in its assumptions which
are:
" #he annual cash requirement is known and constant
" #ransactionA#ransfer or conversion costs are known ad fixed!
" #he firm has a steady cash inflow and outflow!
" #he interest rate on short term marketable securities remain constant over cash planning
period!
*aumol model is a deterministic model which assumes certainty of parameters of the models!
ii# Alternati2e 4
1etermine the total cost of holding cash under this alternative!
V 2ost interest income I )%F x )9@m x R I ;,@@@,@@@
V ,ptimal cash balance,
"
TC
C
%
# I )9@m
5 I Sh!)9,@@@
i I )%F I @!)%
)% ! @
@@@ , )9 @@@ , @@ , )9@ % x x
C I ',)%+,<%&
V /umbers of conversion p!a! I
<%& , )%+ , '
@@@ , @@@ , )9@
C
T
I %&!9 I %9
V #otal conversion cost I b
C
T
I %9 x )9,@@@ I +<9,@@@
V $nterest income on short term deposit
I R5id
I R x ',)%+,<%& x <F I %)&,++@
Where id I interest rate on short term deposits!
Summary
2ost income ;,@@@,@@@
5onversion cost +<9,@@@
2ess interest income B%)&,++@C
/et cost ;,)'@,'<@
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5;@
Alternati2e &&
$nterest paid )9@m x )(F %<,@@@,@@@
2ess interest received I )9@m x ;F B)+,9@@,@@@C
dd arrangement fees 9@,@@@
#otal cost )+,99@,@@@
3ecommendation: #he policy of selling short term securities results in lower cost thus preferable!
bC 2ynx Services
iC #he firm should use the -iller",rr model which is a stochastic model!
,ptimal cash balance, Q I L
"
b
+
+
%
&
+
b I 5onversion costs I Sh!)%@
e` I 1aily variance of cash flows I BSh!%%,<9@C`
2 I 2ower cash balance I Sh!(<,9@@
i I 1aily interest rate on short term marketable
securities I
days +'@
@;)'9 ! @
I @!@@@%9&'
Q I 9@@ , (<
@@@%9&' ! @ &
C` <9@ , %% B )%@ +
+
+
x
x x
I 9',<<@ G (<,9@@ I Sh!)&&,%<@
iiC Upper 2imit H I +Q E %2
I B+ x )&&,%<@C E B% x (<,9@@C I %9<,()@
iiiC 2ower limit: #his is given in the question as Sh!(<,9@@
iiiC 1ecision rate:
V $f the cash balance increases from optional balance Q to upper limit H, buy short term
marketable securities worth H E Q i!e %9<,()@ E )&&,%<@ I ))+,9&@! #he returns to balance Q!
V $f the cash balance declines to lower limit 2, sell short term marketable securities equal to
Q E 2 i!e! Sh!)&&,%<@ E (<,9@@ I 9',<<@!
V #he firm should hold a cash balance with a spread between H and 2 BH E 2C i!e! %9<,()@
E (<,9@@ I )<@,+)@!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
5;6 ,e2ision Aid
J.EST&ON T-,EE
aC iC " 1etermine the increamental initial capital at year @
ShD@@@D
7urchase cost E new machine )@@,@@@
2ess proceeds from sale of + machines i!e!
Sh!),@@@,@@@ x + machines B+,@@@C
2ess savings in overhaul cost Bin p!vC B9,@@@C
$ncreamental initial capital ;%,@@@
" $ncreamental salvage value at end of year )@
sale of new machine! &,9@@
2ess sale of + machines S Sh!'@@,@@@ E foregone B),(@@C
%,<@@
" 1erivation of annual cash flows!
#he cash flows are equal to annual savings in operating costs! Since tax is ignored, increamental
depreciation Bnon"cash itemsC is irrelevant since there is no tax shield! #he annual cash savings
are as follows:
/ew
machine
+ existing machines /et
savings
3aw sugar cane
2abour
:ariable expenses
-aintenance
4ixed factory
overheads
)'%,@@@
+,;@@
%,%<9
&,9@@
'@,@@@ x + I )(@,@@@
),+9; x + I &,@9@
;%9 x + I %,<<9
%,@@@ x + I ',@@@
))%,<@@ x + I
(,)@@
)(,@@@
)9@
9@@
),9@@
+@@
.*# I .# 5ash flows p!a!
/7: analysis S)@F and %@F
%@,&9@
8ear 5! 4lows 7:S)@F,n 7!: 7:4S%@F,n 7!:
@
) E )@ p!a
)@
/7:
B;%,@@@C
%@,&9@
%,<@@
)!@@@
'!)&9
@!+('
BGveC
B;%,@@@C
)%9,''9!%9
),@&%!&9
+&,<@<!&9
)!@@@
&!);%
@!)'%
B"veC
B;%,@@@C
(9,<%'!&
&+<!&
B 9,(+'!%C
iiC $!3!3
/!7!: S )@F I +&,<@<!&9
/!7!: S %@F I "9,(+'!%
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 5;8
$!3!3! I
I
iiiC #he firm should replace the existing + machines with a new one since the /7: is positive
and $33 U )@F cost of capital!
bC 4inancial viability test
#his means that the payback should not exceed 9 years in case of annuities,
payback period I $nitial capital
nnual cA4lows
I ;%,@@@
%@,&9@
I &!9 years
#he pro=ect thus meets financial viability test
cC ,ther qualitative factors
#he need for training of staff to use the new machine
7ossibility of breackdown of the single machine which would halt the operations with + existing
machines, if one breaks down, production would still continue with the other two!
#echnological changes affecting the new machine
.ffects on staff morale due to laying off of some employees!
vailability of spare parts for the new machine
3iskness of the replacement decisions!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
( ) )@F %@F
9,(+'!%
+&,<@<!&9
+&,<@<!&9
)@F
+
( ) )(!9'F )@F
&@,9&+!'9
+&,<@<!&9
)@F +
,
_
,
_
+
)'+' ! @ % ! @
)'+' ! @ )
9 ! 9
-: I )<9!()('9
-arket value of )@@@ shares is Sh!)<9,();!
J.EST&ON TWO
aC iC .,? I
ost ha txun"tpur* Carry"ng
t der"ng xde(andxor
sec cos
cos %
*efore re"organisation I
%9 % ! @
@@@ , )@ @@@ , &@@ %
x
x x
.,? I &@,@@@ units
fter re"organisation I
%9 % ! @
9@@ , % @@@ , &@@ %
x
x x
.,? I %@,@@@ units
iiC $mplementation of the new system will affect both total ordering costs per annum and
stockholding cost under the existing system these costs are as follows:
@@@ , &@
@@@ , &@@
I )@
Ordering cost I /umber of orders per year
5ost per order I Sh!)@,@@@ per order
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
595 ,e2ision Aid
5osts per annum I )@,@@@ x )@ I )@@,@@@
Carrying cost I verage stock is %@,@@@
5ost is %@,@@@ x %9 x %@F I )@@,@@@
#otal costs I )@@,@@@ G )@@,@@@ I %@@,@@@
Under the proposed scheme the costs would become:"
,rdering costs: /umber of orders I
@@@ , %@
@@@ , &@@
I %@
5ost per order is Sh!%,9@@
#herefore total ordering cost I %@ x %,9@@ I Sh!9@,@@@
Carrying costs " verage stock is )@,@@@ units! #hus total carrying cost is:
" )@,@@@ x %9 x %@F I Sh!9@,@@@
#otal costs I Sh!)@@,@@@
#he annual tax saving is therefore B%@@,@@@ E )@@,@@@C I )@@,@@@
#his will give rise to an after tax cash flow of \)@@,@@@ x B)"@!+%9C] I Sh!'<,9@@
1iscounting the cash flows at )(F
8ear @\)&@,@@@ x B) E @!+%9C] x )!@ I ;&,9@@
8ear ) E ( B'<,9@@ x &!@<(C I %<9,%'9
/7: or re"organisation I )(@,<'9
bC N$# represents a complete management philosophy and is more than =ust a collection of
techniques! $t aims to manufacture to order for each customer and to eliminate idle resources in
all areas of the company! $t is a technique which enables management to order and buy what it
requires at that particular point in time!
$n terms of purchasing, a N$# system aims to ensure that components are delivered =ust
immediately prior to the need to use then in the production process! $t therefore requires a close
relationship to be built up between customer and supplier, the later being required to deliver
quality assured components to match production schedules! Suppliers in turn should benefit it
from fair long"term sales as the purchaser reduces its number of sources! #his should allow the
supplier to achieve scale economies and improved production planning! #he customer should
achieve a reduction in ordering costs and in stock levels and associated carrying costs!
J.EST&ON T-,EE
aC $tem directly varying with sales I F of %@@) sales
/et fixed assets I
)@@
@@@ , %&@
(@@ , )%&
x
I 9%F
Stock I
)@@
@@@ , %&@
&@@ , +(
x
I )'F
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 59@
1ebtors I
)@@
@@@ , %&@
%((@@
x
I )%F
5ash I
)@@
@@@ , %&@
%@@ , <
x
I +F
(+F
#rade 5reditor I
)@@
@@@ , %&
@@@ , +'
x
I )9F
ccrued expenses I
)@@
@@@ , %&@
@@@ , %&
x
I )@F
%9F
8ear %@@% sales I %&@,@@@,@@@ x )!)9 I %<',@@@,@@@
8ear %@@+ sales I %<,'@@,@@@ x )!%@ I ++)!%@@!@@@
#otal increase in sales I ++),%@@,@@@ E %&@,@@@,@@@ I B%%,(@@,@@@C
$ncrease in total assets I (+F x ;),%@@,@@@ I <9,';',@@@
2ess: increase in current liabilities I %9F x ;),%@@,@@@ I B%%,(@@,@@@C
2ess: retained earnings:
8ear %@@% /et 7rofit I (F x %<',@@@,@@@ I %%,@(@,@@@
2ess: (@F dividends I B)<,''&,@@@C B &,&)',@@@C
3etained earnings:
8ear %@@+ /et 7rofit I (F x ++),%@@,@@@ I %',&;',@@@
2ess: (@F dividends I B%),);',(@@C
3etained earnings B 9,%;;,%@@C
.xternal financial needs Bcommercial paperC &+,)(@,@@@
bC iC +roA'orma !alance S%eet as at @4 Decem?er 5II@
/et fixed assets
Stock
1ebtors
5ash
9%F x ++),%@@,@@@
)'F x ++),%@@,@@@
)%F x ++),%@@,@@@
+F x ++),%@@,@@@
)<%,%%&,@@@
9%,;;%,@@@
+;,<&&,@@@
;,;+',@@@
%<&,(;',@@@
*inanced ?y=
,rdinary share capital
3etained earnings +9,%@@,@@@ G &,&)',@@@ G
9,%;;,%@@
)%F long term debt
#rade 5reditors )9F x ++),%@@,@@@
ccrued expenses )@F x ++),%@@,@@@
5ommercial paper
(&,@@@,@@@
&&,;)9,%@@
%@,@@@,@@@
&;,'(@,@@@
++,)%@,@@@
&+,)(@,(@@
%<&,(;',@@@
iiC /o change in value of money BinflationC during the forecasting period!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
596 ,e2ision Aid
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 598
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC 5ost of equity BkeC I
( )
g
P
g d
+
+
@
@
)
I @< ! @
9@
9@ ! '
+
I %@F
bC +roEect 3
8ear 5ash flows +/&*5IK)n 7!:
)
%
+
&
9
'
<
%,@@@,@@@
%,%@@,@@@
%,@(@,@@@
%,%&@,@@@
%,<'@,@@@
+,%@@,@@@
+,'@@,@@@
#otal 7!:
2ess initial capital
/!7!:! BGveC
@!(++
@!';&
@!9<;
@!&(%
@!&@%
@!++9
@!%<;
),''',@@@
),9%',(@@
),%@&,+%@
),@<;,'(@
),)@;,9%@
),@<%,@@@
),@@&,&@@
(,''%,<%@
B(,@@@,@@@C
''%,<%@
+roEect 0
8ear 5ash flows +/&*5IK)n 7!:
)
%
+
&
&,@@@,@@@
+,%@@,@@@
&,(@@,@@@
(@@,@@@
@!(++
@!';&
@!9<;
@!&(%
+,++%,@@@
%,@(%,@@@
%,<<;,%@@
+(9,'@@
(,9<(,(@@
B(,@@@,@@@C
9<(,@@@
cC +roEect 3
/!7!: S %&F I "+@@,%<'
/!7!: S %@F I ''%,<%@
$!3!3! I %@F G
FC %@ F %& B
)%@ , %;' <%@ , ''%
<%@ , ''%
+
I %@F G %!( I %%!(F
+roEect 0
/!7!: S %9F I ";&,&@@
/!7!: S %@F I 9<(,@@@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
597 ,e2ision Aid
$!3!3 I %@F G
( ) F %@ F %9
&@@ , ;& @@@ , 9<(
@@@ , 9<(
,
_
+
%@G &!+ I %&!+F
dC " /!7!: method ranks pro=ect P as number one
" $!3!3 method ranks pro=ect 8 as number one
" #here is conflict in ranking of mutually exclusive pro=ects!
eC 5onflict between /!7!: and $!3!3
" $n case of difference in economic lives of pro=ects
" $n case of difference in si>e of the pro=ects
" $n case of difference in timing of cash flow
" $n case of non"conventional cash flows!
J.EST&ON *&/E
aC J5apital flightK is the smuggling of funds from a country through usually unofficial
channels overseas! $t is commonly found in economies that have foreign exchange
control laws BregulationsC where investments move from home country seeking higher
returns in other countries!
bC " 7olitical instability E -any members of the ruling elite unsure about their fate
should their regimes be overthrown E thus transfer wealth to more stable
countries!
" 2ower rate of return in home country
" Higher taxation of companies and individuals
" rtificially high local currency value encourages capital flight as those involved
reali>e much higher values of hard currencies on exchange!
" 7oor infrastructure
" 1ue to high levels of corruption among the ruling elite E they want to keep their
wealth out of reach of their local fellow citi>ens who would raise questions on
how wealth was created!
" High inflation rate
" 2egal framework e!g fiscal policies!
cC -assive capital flight forces a country to devalue local currency as they often have to run
to the multilateral finance institutions like World *ank and $-4 for salvation of the very
constantly worsening *alance of 7ayment problem!
J.EST&ON S&3
aC iC Matc%ing
#he traditional view is that fixed assets should be financed by long term sources of
finance and current assets by a mixture of long"term and short term sources!
iiC Cost E #he company may find it easier to raise short"term finance with low security than
long"term finance!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 59:
iiiC Security E #he company may find it easier to raise short"term finance with low security
than long"term finance!
,isk E $n opting for short"term debt, the company faces the risk that it may not be able to
renegotiate the loan on such good terms! 2ong"term loans are thus less risky!
*lei?ility E Short"term debt is more flexible since it allows the firm to react to interest rate
charges and avoid being locked into an expensive long"term fixed rule commitment when rates
are falling!
bC !ene'its o' a rig%ts issue to Malindi Leisure &ndustries=
#he company is highly geared as rights issue would reduce the level of gearing and reduce in the
level of financial risk!!
$f the issue is successful it will not significantly change the voting structure!
$f underwriters are raised then the amount of finance that will be raised in known and guaranteed!
$f the market is high, -alindi 2eisure $ndustries should be able to achieve a rights issue at a
relatively low cost since less shares will be issued! B2ower floatation costsC
2ess administrative procedures e!g no need for prospectus!
Draw?acks o' rig%ts issue
#he issue will need to be priced at a discount to the current share price in order to make it
attractive to investors! #hus will result in a diluter in earnings and a fall in share price!
$f the issue is not successful, a significant number of shares may be taken by underwriters thus
changing the voting structure!
dministration and underwriting costs are high!
Shareholders may be unable or unwilling to increase their investment in -alindi 2eisure
$ndustries!
cC Ad2antages o' leasing
/o risk of obsolescence in the lessee
2easing does not require a down payment to be made at the start of the contract unlike hire
purchase! B/o heavy initial capital outlay requiredC!
2ease finance can be arranged relatively, cheaply, quickly and easily!
2easing premiums are allowable against tax
,perating leases are off"balance sheet financing
Ad2antages o' %ire <urc%ase
Unlike leasing, hire purchase allows the user of the asset to obtain ownership at the end of the
agreement period!
#he interest element of the payments is allowable against tax!
#ax shield on depreciation of asset
5ash inflows on salvage value at the end of economic life of asset!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
59; ,e2ision Aid
,E/&S&ON ANSWE,S
J.EST&ON ONE
aC 3atios
5urrent ratio I 5urrent ssets t"(es (( ! )
('@ (&@
@(@ , % '&@ &(@
+
+ +
%!9
times
5urrent liability
cid test ratio I 5urrent ssets E stock
t"(es '' ! @
('@ (&@
'&@ &(@
+
+
)!)
times
5urrent 2iabilities
Stock turnover ratio I 5ost of sales
t"(es <+ ! )
@@@ , @(@ , %
@@@ , '@@ , +
%!&
times
verage stock
#otal assets turnover I Sales
t"(es %9 ! )
@@@ , (@@ , &
@@@ , @@@ , '
)!&
times
#otal assets
#imes interest earned ratio:
I ,perating profit B.*$#C
t"(es (; ! %
'@@ , %+9
'@@ , %+9 &@@ , &&&
+
+!9
times
$nterest expenses
/et profit margin I /et profit B.#C
F && ! &
@@@ , @@@ , '
'&@ , %''
&F
Sales
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten 599
3eturn on investment I .#
F 9' ! 9
@@@ , (@@ , &
'&@ , %''
9!'F
#otal investment
#otal assets to shareholders equity:
I #otal assets
t"(es % ! +
@@@ , 9@@ , )
@@@ , (@@ , &
+!@
times
SAH equity
3eturn on shareholders equity:
3,S.A3eturn networth
I .# and preference div!
F <9 ! )<
@@@ , 9@@ , )
'&@ , %''
)'!(F
.quity
bC 5omment on:
iC Li>uidity
" #his is shown by current and acid test ratios
" *oth ratios are lower than the industrial average
" #his could be attributed to poor working capital management policy,
defective credit policy and increase in current liabilities
" #he firmDs ability to meet its short term maturing financial obligations is
lower than the industrial average
iiC *inancial risks
" #his is shown by the gearing ratios
" 4or 3ichardo 2imited #$.3 B#imes interest earned ratioC is the indicator
of financial risk
" #he ratio is lower than the industrial average
" #his is due to high interest charges due to use of fixed charged capital
Eam<le= #he total capital of the firm consists of long term debt and equity
both totalling to +!)-!
6earing ratio I 4ixed 5harge capital
#otal capital
I
)@@
@@@ , )@@ , +
@@@ , '@@ , )
x
I 9)!'F
#he firm is highly gearing hence the high financial risk and high interest charges!
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
@II ,e2ision Aid
iiiC O2erall <er'ormance
" #his is indicated by profitability ratios
" $n case of 3ichardo 2td! this is shown by net profit margin, 3,$ and
return on equity ratios
" #he ratios are higher than the industrial average except return on
investment which is equal to industrial average
" #he firm is generating adequate returns from its investments more than
other firms in the market!
Note
#he firm has lower liquidity ratio hence high liquidity risks! #he firm is highly
geared hence high financial risks! #he firm is therefore using borrowed capital in
order to gear up or increase its profitability or returns which are higher than the
industrial average! $t is therefore a high risk, high return firm!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten @I4
J.EST&ON TWO
aC iC Cor<orate ?ond
long term debt instrument issued by a company to raise long term
capital! $t pays period interest charges and promises the payment of
principal at maturity!
iiC Ad2antages o' cor<orate ?ond
aC $nterest charges are tax deductible and hence provide interest tax
shield benefit!
bC $t enables a firm to raise long term capital without the lenders
gaining ownership of the firm!
cC #he lenders do not share in extra profits once they have a fixed
rate of return!
iiiC 5osts associated with issue of corporate bonds! #hese are called
floatation costs and are incurred in floatation of any new securities!
" 5ommissionAfee paid to underwriters e!g merchant banks or
investment bankers!
" 5osts of preparing bond certificate and prospectus
" 7rofessional fee paid to financial advisors, lawyers, auditors and
accountants
" 5ommission paid to sponsoring stock brokers
" 5ost of registering the bond with 5-
" dvertising and other floatation costs!
bC iC $ssue price I 7!: of expected interest income G 7!: of redemption value
3edemption value )@,@@@ payable only at end of )@
th
year
5oupon rate )'F
$nterest p!a! I
)@@
)'
@@@ , )@ x I ),'@@AI p!a! for )@ years
1iscounting rate I market rate of time of issue I )&F
7 : of period interest B),'@@ x 7!:!!4)&F,)@C
),'@@ x 9,%)' (,+&9!'
7!: of redemption value )@,@@@ x 7!:!!4)&F,)@
)@,@@@ x @!%<@ %,<@@!@
-arket value of a bond )),@&9!'
iiC :alue of the bond will be based on the remaining maturity period!
/umber of years elapsed I % years
/umber of years remaining B)@"%C I ( years
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
@I5 ,e2ision Aid
1iscounting rate I market rate E )
st
Nune %@@) I )@F
7eriodic interest income I ),'@@ p!a! for ( years
3edemption value I )@,@@@
7: of period interest I ),'@@ x 7!:!!4)&F,(
I ),'@@ x 9!++9 (,9+'
7: of redemption value I )@,@@@ x 7!:!!4)&F,(
I )@,@@@ x @!&'< &,'<@
-arket value of a bond )+,%@'
iiiC 8.Sf #his is because the firm can borrow new debt capital at a lower
interest rate! $f the market interest rate is lower than the coupon rate, the
firm can always redeem the debt capital after carrying out a bond
refunding decision analysis i!e repay the current debt capital with high
interest capital and borrow a new debt capital at a lower interest rate!
J.EST&ON T-,EE
aC MET-OD 4= *actoring
mount of debtors I Shs!+%@,@@@
5redit period I monthly I +@ days
Step ): 5ompute amount of service fee
Service fee I xdebtors
)@@
%
I @@@ , +%@
)@@
%
x I Sh!',&@@ within credit
period
Service fee with credit period I Sh!',&@@
Service fee within one year I
,
_
&@@ , '
'@
+'@
x
I Sh!<',(@@
Step %: 5ompute amount of reserves
I
@@@ , +%@
)@@
9
x
I )',@@@
Step +: 5ompute annual interest charges
$nterest charges p!a! I $!3 B1ebtors E 3eserveC
( ) @@@ , )' @@@ , +%@
)@@
)9
x
I Shs!&9,'@@
$nterest charges p!a! I &9,'@@
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten @I@
$nterest charges within a period I
'@@ , &9
+'@
+@
x
I Shs!+,(@@
mount to advance I 1ebtors E 3eserves E Service fee E $nterest charges
within a period within a period
MET-OD 5= +ledging
A line o' credits
bank may enter into a formal understanding or arrangement with the borrower to the effect that
the borrower will not take the lumpsum of loan!
" #he bank will create a loan account for the borrower where the amount
of loan required will be deposited!
" #his arrangement is called a line of credit!
#he borrower will be withdrawing the amount of cash heAshe requires
from the loan account as long as he does not exceed the amount agreed
with the bank and deposited with the loan account!
.very time the borrower withdraws a certain amount from the loan
account, he is said to be taking down a certain amount of money on the
line of credit! .!g! if the loan account has Sh!),@@@,@@@ and the borrower
withdraws Shs!)@@,@@@ he shall have taken down Shs!)@@,@@@ on the line
of credit!
,ften times the borrower may be required to maintain a minimum
balance in the loan account over and above what was borrowed!
#his amount should not be withdrawn but the bank will charge interest
on it! #his minimum balance is called compensating balance!
mount of loan to advance I (@F of debtors I @@@ , +%@
)@@
(@
x I
%9',@@@
2ess 'F compensating balance I
,
_
@@@ , %9'
)@@
'
x
I
B)9,+'@C
2ess interest charges p!a!
,
_
)@@
+@
@@@ , %9' x
I <',(@@
$nterest charges within +@ days I
(@@ , <'
+'@
+@
x
I
B ',&@@C
mount to advance %+&,%&@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
@I6 ,e2ision Aid
/ote: $nterest charges will be based on total amount including
compensating balance i!e! Shs!%9',@@@!
bC 4actoring I .ffective annual interest rate
I nnual interest charges G nnual service fees x )@@F
mount advanced
I
F )@@
(@@ , %;+
(@@ , <' '@@ , &9
x
,
_
+
I &)!<F
7ledging I .ffective annual interest rate I nnual interest charges x )@@F
mount dvanced
I
F )@@
%@@ , %+&
(@@ , <'
x
,
_
I +%!(F
cC 7ledging because it is cheaper!
J.EST&ON *O.,
,ole o' Ca<ital Market Aut%ority
iC $ssue rules, regulations and procedures of trading in capital markets!
iiC 2icensing of brokers and requiring them to have a minimum base capital for
operations!
iiiC 4air trading in stock exchange to prevent cases of insider trading and ensure
prices are determined by demand and supply mechanism on information supplied
in the market!
ivC $t operates compensation fund to indemnify an investor incase a broker fails to
fulfill his contractual financial obligations!
vC $mplementing government policies to ensure development of capital market
infrastructure in 0enya!
viC 5redit awareness for investment in long term securities!
*inancial &nstrument
4inancial instruments are financial securities held by investors BlendersC in form of
financial assets! #hey indicate the amount which is owed to the lender by the borrower!
#hey can be long term and short term financial securities!
Short term securities include: 5ommercial paper, #reasury bills, /otes payable,
promissory notes, bills of exchange etc!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten @I8
2ong term financial instruments will include debentures, mortgages, ordinary shares,
preference shares etc!
i# Treasury ?ill
" $t is a short term financial instrument used by the 6overnment to raise
money from the market!
" $t is issued at a discount and matures at par value!
" $t has a fixed interest rate during its maturity period
" $t is a riskless investment and its interest rate is called risk free rate!
" $ts maturity period can be ;) days or )(% days!
ii# Commercial <a<er
" short term financial instrument used by financially strong and sound
firms in the market!
" Used to raise short term capital
" #hey are unsecured Bthey =ust require a guarantorC
" #hey are issued at a discount and mature at par value
" #heir maturity period varies from +@, '@, ;@, )%@, )9@, %<@ days etc!
" #hey are cheaper source of short term finance compared to bank
overdrafts and short term bank loans!
J.EST&ON *&/E
aC 6o into business
$nitial capital B%,+<9,@@@C
7!: of year ) E )9 5ash flow
I '%9,@@@ x 7:4)@F,)9
I '%9,@@@ x <!'@' I &,<9+,<9@
7: of year )' E %@ cash flow
I 9@@,@@@B7:4)@F,%@ " 7:4)@F,)9C
I 9@@,@@@B(!9)& E <!'@'C I &9&,@@@
7: of salvage value
I <9@,@@@ x 7:4)@F,%@
I <9@,@@@ x @!)&; I ))),<9@
7: of costs Bannuity dueC
8ears ) E 9 I 9@,@@@ x 7:4)@F,9BlGrC
I 9@,@@@ x +!<;< x )!) B%@(,9@9C
8ear ' E )@ I <9,@@@B7:4)@F,)@ " 7:4)@F,9CB) G rC
I <9,@@@B'!)&9 E +!<;)C)!) B);&,%@9C
8ear )) E )< I )@@,@@@B7:4)@F,)< " 7:4)@F,)@CB)GrC
I )@@,@@@B(!@%% E '!)&9C)!) B%@',&<@C
#,#2 7: %,++9,+%@
3emain in =ob!
7 : I %9@,@@@ x 7:4)@F,%@ I %9@,@@@ x (!9)& I %,)%(,9@@
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
@I7 ,e2ision Aid
1ecision: 6o into business cost of higher 7: of %@',(%@
bC ,ther factors:
" 7ossibility of salary increament
" #ax effects
" $nclusion of salary to self in the analysis
" ccuracy of cash flow estimates
" ttitude to risk
" 5ost of capital E will it be constant for %@ years
" Salvage value E how accurate is it!
MOCK E3AM&NAT&ON
To ?e carried under eamination condition and sent to t%e Distance
Learning Administrator 'or making ?y t%e .ni2ersity(
Time Allowed= @ -ours Attem<t All Juestions
J.EST&ON ONE
aC 1escribe the characteristics of long term capital investment decisions! B&
marksC
bC *5* company is a manufacturer of bricks and concrete blocks! #he company is
considering replacing part of the current manual labour force by purchasing a small
tractor with a forklift for use in loading bricks and concrete blocks! #he purchase price
would be Sh!9<@,@@@! #he tractor will have an economic life of 9 years but would
require a Sh!%@,@@@ overhaul at the end of + years! fter 9 years the tractor could be sold
for Sh!))@,@@@!
#he company estimates it will cost Sh!%9@,@@@ per year to operate the tractor! $t will,
however, save Sh!)+@,@@@ annually on labour cost! *ecause of increase in handling
efficiency, losses caused by breakages will be cut by Sh!%%@,@@@ per year! Sales will also
go up by Sh!&9@,@@@! #he new sales level is expected to be maintained throughout the
tractorDs life! ssume the companyDs gross margin ratio is &@F, corporate tax rate +@F,
and cost of capital )'F! lso assume straight"line method of depreciation!
,e>uired
1etermine the /7: of the pro=ect and state whether the tractor should be purchased! B)+
marksC
cC $dentify + circumstances under which /7: and $33 will give conflicting results for
mutually exclusive pro=ects! B+ marksC
J.EST&ON TWO
United Steel has =ust been reorgani>ed to produce industrial machinery! #he company is in the
process of establishing a financial policy and the following two alternative plans have been
suggested!
7lan P: %,@@@,@@@ ordinary shares of Sh!)@ each!
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten @I:
Sh! )%,@@@,@@@ long term loan at )(F per annum!
7lan 8: %,9@@,@@@ ordinary shares at Sh!)@ each
Sh!<,@@@,@@@ long term loan at )(F per annum!
#he founders of United Steel have pro=ected the following .arnings *efore $nterest and
#axes B.*$#C!
Economic +%ase +ro?a?ility E!&T
Sh!D@@@D
@!% )',@@@
* @!' %(,@@@
5 @!% &@,@@@
#he companyDs marginal tax rate is &@F!
,e>uired
aC iC 5alculate the expected .arnings 7er Share B.7SC for each financial plan! B)@
marksC
iiC Which financial plan should be acceptedM WhyM B% marksC
bC 5alculate the level of .*$# where the .7S are equal for the two plans! B(
marksC
J.EST&ON T-,EE
aC What economic advantages are created by the existence of:
iC 7rimary markets B+
marksC
iiC Secondary markets B+ marksC
iiiC 7ortfolio management firms! B& marksC
bC .xplain how the 5apital -arkets uthority can ensure:
iC 4aster growth and development of the /airobi Stock .xchange or Stock
.xchange in your country! B' marksC
iiC 1evelopment of other stock exchanges in 0enya or in your country!
B& marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
J.EST&ON *O.,
aC What is meant by:
iC 5ost of equity capitalM B% marksC
iiC 5ost of preferred sharesM B% marksC
bC 7esa 2imited wishes to take advantage of the new commercial paper market now popular
in 0enya! $t wishes to issue two debenture papers! *oth bear coupons of )& percent, and
the effective yield required on each is %@ percent! 7aper has a maturity of )@ years and
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
@I; ,e2ision Aid
paper * a maturity of %@ years! *oth will be paying interest annually and Shs!)@@,@@@ at
maturity!
,e>uired
iC What is the price of each paperM B' marksC
iiC $f the effective yield on each paper rises to %& percent, what is the price of each paperM
B&
marksC
iiiC .xplain why the price of one paper falls more than the price of the other when the
effective yield rises! B%
marksC
cC .xplain the concept of weighted average cost of capital! B& marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
J.EST&ON *&/E
aC Write explanatory notes on:
iC 4lat yield and redemption yieldO B& marksC
iiC 7rice earnings rationO B% marksC
iiiC Significance of dividend cover! B+ marksC
bC #he nominal value of a companyDs share is Sh!&9 and the dividend for the year is )@F on
nominal value of the share! #he current market price of the share is Sh!;@! #he shareDs
earnings yield is )9F!
,e>uired
computation of:
iC 1ividend coverO B+ marksC
iiC .arningsO and B& marksC
iiiC 7riceA.arnings ratio B& marksC
"Total= 5I marks#
END O* MOCK E3AM&NAT&ON
NOW SEND 0O., ANSWE,S TO T-E D&STANCE
LEA,N&NG CENT,E *O, MA,K&NG
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK
Lesson Ten @I9
!.S&NESS *&NANCE
@4I ,e2ision Aid
ST,AT-MO,E .N&/E,S&T0 1 ST.D0 +ACK