Luxe Redux

Raising the Bar for the Selling of Luxuries

The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) is a global
management consulting frm and the worlds
leading advisor on business strategy. We partner
with clients from the private, public, and not-for-
proft sectors in all regions to identify their
highest-value opportunities, address their most
critical challenges, and transform their enterprises.
Our customized approach combines deep in sight
into the dynamics of companies and markets with
close collaboration at all levels of the client
organization. This ensures that our clients achieve
sustainable compet itive advantage, build more
capable organizations, and secure lasting results.
Founded in 1963, BCG is a private company with
77 ofces in 42 countries. For more information,
please visit bcg.com.
The Boston Consulting Groups Center for Con-
sumer and Customer Insight applies a unique,
integrated approach that combines quantitative
and qualitative consumer research with a deep
understanding of business strategy and competi-
tive dynamics. The center works closely with BCGs
various practices to translate its insights into
actionable strategies that lead to tangible econom-
ic impact for our clients. In the course of its work,
the center has amassed a rich set of proprietary
data on consumers from around the world, in both
emerging and developed markets. The Center for
Consumer and Customer Insight is sponsored by
BCGs Marketing & Sales and Consumer practices,
with support from the Global Advantage practice in
emerging markets. For more information, please
visit http://www.bcg.com/expertise_impact/
capabilities/center_consumer_customer_insight/
default.aspx.
Luxe Redux
Raising the Bar for the Selling of Luxuries
Jean-Marc Bellaiche, Michelle Eirinberg Kluz, Antonella Mei-Pochtler,
and Elmar Wiederin
June 2012
Luxe Redux 2
The worldwide market for luxury goods and services has proved to be very robust
despite the travails experienced by much of the global economy. But luxury provid-
ers cannot assume that past is precedent, according to new research from BCG.
The Shift to Experiential Luxury Is Accelerating
Spending on experiential luxury makes up almost 55 percent of total luxury purchas-
es worldwide and has grown 50 percent faster than gains in sales of luxury goods.
Fewer Consumers Value Luxury in the Old Ways
Considerations such as value, family, and wellness have become much more impor-
tant to consumers than traditional notions of luxury, such as status and wealth.
The Worlds Luxury Map Is Shifting
The market for luxury goods in BRIC countries will grow over the next couple of years.
Yet luxury players must not underestimate the opportunity in traditional locations.
The Digital Revolution Is Well Under Way
Many luxury players have not yet fully grasped the impact of digital media. They
still need to defne strategies that incorporate digital media.
AT A GLANCE
The Boston Consulting Group 3
T
he uncertainties and worries that characterize most of todays economic
headlines are nowhere apparent in recent reports on the worlds luxury players,
many of which are recording double-digit year-on-year increases and proft gains
that provoke the envy of business leaders in other sectors. The results are as eye
opening in luxury experiences as they are in personal luxury goods.
Overall, the worldwide luxury market has shown itself to be robust. The Boston
Consulting Groups latest studyon which we worked in 2011 with research
specialist Ipsos and the International Luxury Business Association to poll roughly
1,000 afuent individuals in eight mature countries (France, Germany, Italy, Japan,
South Korea, Spain, the U.K., and the U.S.) and the four emerging BRIC countries
(Brazil, Russia, India, and China)reveals that aggregate annual spending on what
those consumers describe as luxuries now tops $1.4 trillion. That fgure far outstrips
the sums usually cited for sales of luxury goods such as apparel, cosmetics, watches,
and jewelry. Sales of luxury cars account for close to $350 billion of that total
worldwide, and the business of luxury experiencesfrom art auctions to one-of-a-
kind travel adventuresis already worth well over $770 billion of the total.
However, BCG believes that many of the economic and behavioral trends highlight-
ed in our December 2010 global-luxury-market report are accelerating. As a conse-
quence, luxury providers will have to sharpen their adaptive-strategy skills if they
are to succeed over the long term. They must prepare themselves in particular for
four areas where change is most apparent: the defnition of luxury markets contin-
ues to evolve, consumer values are changing, new and very diferent markets are
materializing in rapidly developing economies, and social media (and the Internet
in general) are rapidly reshaping long-held perceptions of luxury and value.
The report elaborates on those four areas of change and reveals where luxury
providers leadership teams must put most of their efort in the future.
The Shift to Experiential Luxury Is Happening Fast
Perhaps the most signifcant area of change in the luxury market is consumers shif
in preference from owning a luxury to experiencing a luxury.
I love experiences that make me feel pampered, one luxury shopper told us. Our
research shows that experiential luxury now makes up almost 55 percent of total
luxury spending worldwide and, year on year, has grown 50 percent faster than
sales of luxury goods. Even in brand-obsessed China, where personal luxury goods
Luxury providers will
have to sharpen their
adaptive-strategy
skills if they are to
succeed over the long
term.
Luxe Redux 4
serve as a strong badge of status and success, with sales surging 22 percent annual-
ly, experiential luxury dominates, growing at 28 percent each year. (See Exhibit 1.)
The business of luxury experiences is by no means limited to exclusive safaris and
spas. More and more hospitals ofer deluxe accommodationswith butlers, special-
ty chefs, and marble bathswhile airlines ofer private suites, and luxury high-rise
apartment buildings feature movie-screening rooms and virtual-golf facilities.
Four forces are accelerating the move toward experiential luxury.
First and perhaps the most powerful of those forces is demographics. In developed
economies such as Europe, the U.S., and Japan, consumers who drove the luxury
boom in the 1990s are now beginning to retire. They are at a life stage in which
they do not need or want to own new things, so they are primary customers for
experiential-luxury oferings.
Second, consumption patterns are changing as consumers lifestyles mature. When
middle-class consumers in rapidly developing markets become more afuent and
frst buy into luxury, they are drawn to long-lasting goods with reputable brands.
But over time, they tend to move from accumulating material goods to buying new
experiencesand this is refected in recent growth rates for experiential-luxury
spending. (See the sidebar Meet Todays Luxury Shoppers.)
U.S. Japan Average Europe
35
Share of luxury spending (%)
100 60 40 20
0
14
80
60
40
80
100
China BRI
51
20
18
40
56
16
61
18
25
35
26
62
23
20
Experiential luxury Personal luxury goods Luxury cars
CAGR 20092011 (%)
Experiential luxury
Personal luxury goods
6
4
9
6
6
1
28
22
27
19
Share of 2011 luxury-market value (%)
Source: BCG survey.
1
Brazil, Russia, and India.
2
The total 2011 market value for the countries and regions included here is $1.3 trillion.
Exhibit 1 | Experiential Luxury Captures More Than Half of Luxury Spending in Most Countries
and Is Growing 50 Percent Faster Than Personal Luxury Goods
The Boston Consulting Group 5
The Experience Seekers
Barbara is a 34-year-old professionalan Ameri-
can living in Chicago on an income of more than
$100,000 a year. When Barbara (not her real
name) was in her twenties, she flled her days
with shopping, stocking her closet with the latest
lines from Yves Saint Laurent, Valentino, and
Gucci. She adored buying from boutique brands
such as Rick Owens and admits to wasting
hours poring over sites such as Net-a-Porter.com.
Today, Barbara defnes happiness not as acquir-
ing more luxury goods but as career, family, friends, and relationships in
general. Her main luxuries are now experiences with her friendsshe kite-
surfs, is involved with a local art institute, and volunteers in her spare time.
While she still splurges on luxury goodsmore than $5,000 worth in a recent
monththe balance of her luxury spending has shifed to experiences.
Like Barbara, Jessie shopped obsessively in her twenties. As a young invest-
ment banker, she was quickly swept up in the competitive attitude toward
luxury personal goods. Everybody wore Cartier, she recalls. Today, at age 39,
married with children and living in Westchester County, New York, Jessie (not
her real name) no longer feels the need to keep up with the Joneses. She
says, Im less materialistic now. My family is the most important thing to me.
Jessie still shops for personal luxury goods once a
week, but she spends more money on artwork
and experiences such as spa days and Pilates
classes. Vacations are now her biggest luxury. We
fy only business class noweven with the baby!
she says. Expensive hotels have displaced
designers in her mind: My luxury brands are the
Mandarin Oriental, the Four Seasons, the Ritz.
Its the decoration, the calmness, and cleanness
of the experience, she told BCG.
The Collector
Julie grew up and lives in Shanghai. She is self-
employed and married without children. She
describes herself as obsessed with luxury goods
and is slowly but steadily buying more and more
premium luxury brands. Her early luxury repertoire
was dominated by Burberry, a brand she sees as
having something in common with her personal-
ity. Julie (not her real name) began buying Burberrys small handbags and
MEET TODAYS LUXURY SHOPPERS
Luxe Redux 6
At the same time, members of Generation Ytodays late teens and twenty-some-
thingstend to defne themselves more by what theyve done and experienced
than by what they own. They are drawn to instant pleasure and lavish experienc-
eshelicopter snowboarding in Alaska or a weekend shopping spree in Paris, for
example.
The fourth point: consumers indicate that they are seeking a greater sense of
purpose and satisfaction, and luxury experiences ofen fulfll those wishes more
strongly than do purchases of luxury things. A recent study by Unity Marketing
shows that U.S. consumers are more than three times as satisfed with their luxury
experiences as they are with their purchases of personal luxury goods. That same
study shows a steep drop-of in consumers satisfaction with their purchases of
personal luxury goodsdeclines of 5 percent and 16 percent, respectively, in a
recent three-year periodwhereas the same consumers showed a 3 percent rise in
their contentment with their choices of luxury experiences. These fndings corrobo-
rate BCGs recent consumer research: Id rather spend more on experiences than
on clothes, one shopper told us. Although experiences are more intangible than
an item, theyre more memorable to me.
Leading providers of luxury goods are starting to catch onalbeit cautiously. One
example: LVMH is developing its Cheval Blanc hotel franchise; theres already one
Cheval Blanc hotel in Courchevel, a French ski resort, and another in the Maldives,
and LVMH plans to open locations in Oman and Egypt in 2012. LVMH is tiptoeing
into the hospitality business: it will run the hotels under contract but will not own
the real estate or fnance its construction.
Other players are adding experience and services to current oferings. BMW was
one of the frst high-end carmakers to turn the experience of waiting for delivery of
a new car from frustrating ordeal into fun-flled activity; buyers of BMWs Mini
Cooperbrand vehicles receive new-owner updates about the assembly of their car
and its journey from the factory. Similarly, Apple has turned shopping into enter-
tainment in its stores: customers get to interact with cool technology in spacious,
well-lit venues. In most Sephora stores, a beauty studio ofers 90-minute personal-
ized consultations as well as a wide range of core beauty services. And Swiss watch-
shirts and soon moved on to its more expensive blouses and wind coats, most
of which were bought through a friend in the U.K. and during travels to Hong
Kong.
Julies knowledge of luxury brands comes mainly from actual visits to stores
ofen outside China. She worked in Singapore for two and half years, where she
started to expand into Mont Blanc, Fendi, Ferragamo, Cartier, Bulgari, Mulber-
ry, and Tods. She loves shopping while on vacation: recently, she bought a
Loewe handbag and a Chopard ring while in Barcelona.
MEET TODAYS LUXURY SHOPPERS
(continued)
The Boston Consulting Group 7
maker IWC, which has a watch museum at its headquarters, promotes its Pilots
watches in its fagship store in Hong Kong by ofering customers a ride in a fight
simulator with an extra-large screen and surround sound.
Such initiatives are a good start. But if luxury-goods players are to capitalize on the
experience trend, they have to move quickly and forcefully. To date, very few of
them have been successful in adding experiential elements to their oferings,
websites, or in-store execution. While the lack of such elements may not yet be
hurting fnancial performance, it is a missed opportunity for enhanced fnancial
performance.
Consumers Values Are Not Standing Still
One of the most pervasive of the trends confronting luxury providers is the marked
shif in what consumers truly value. Of course, there is no single universal product
characteristic or service attribute around which global consumers rally. Tastes and
preferences vary signifcantly on the basis of location, age of consumer, and many
other factors. But traditional notions of luxuryrelated to factors such as status
and wealth, for exampleare in full retreat in the developed countries. In the
rapidly developing BRIC countries, status is still important, but luxury, as a value in
its own right, has declined in importance. In every country surveyed, factors such as
value, family, and wellness have become much more important to consumers. We
fagged the early stages of this shif in our December 2010 report. But now the
changes have real and sustained momentum.
Of course, the shif raises the question of why consumers would place little value
on luxury per se but still buy a lot of high-end goods and services. BCG believes, on
the basis of our consumer research, that most luxury buyers, particularly in the
mature markets, detest the old values conveyed by the word luxurythe idea of
ostentation or the evidence of conspicuous consumption, for instanceyet they do
want to treat themselves, to enjoy fne products and experiences for their own sake,
and to share those products and experiences with family and good friends. Said one
shopper with whom BCG spoke recently: I used to come home with a purchase
every dayexpensive stuf from high-end boutiques. But although I have a strong
personal style, I dont need to prove it or wear it anymore. I would love to bring all
my friends together in a luxury beach house.
No doubt the fnancial crisis caused most consumers to question the importance of
buying another handbag or pair of shoes versus saving money or spending quality
time with people who matter to thema shif from style to substance. But what
else might be driving this shif in consumers values? A crucial contributing factor is
the fading boundary between luxury and mass markets; its getting harder to
convince people that spending more on luxury goods is worthwhile.
Thats painfully true when some luxury goods, or close cousins of those goods, sell
for lesser amounts through diferent channels. One example: Costco, the bulk-sales
chain, is the worlds biggest retailer of many famous champagne brands. In a
similar vein, the president of a major fashion brand recently told us that her
company was facing a challenge because the quality of an accessory it was selling
Its getting harder to
convince people that
spending more on
luxury goods is
worthwhile.
Luxe Redux 8
for $195 in its retail stores was not sufciently greater than that of the related items
the company was selling for $79 in its outlet channel.
This trend has been exacerbated in recent years as name designer houses have
created capsule collections in collaboration with mass-market and fast-fashion retail
brands, sparking a proliferation of products that look similar to luxury labels but
can be purchased at more afordable prices.
Indeed, such capsule collections appear to be frmly embedded in the way that
mass-market and fast-fashion retailers now do business. Jimmy Choo and Versace
labels have been on the shelves at H&M, for instance, and Missoni was a sought-af-
ter label at Target for a while. A quick Google search for Karl Lagerfeld brings up
photos of the designer himself at the Chanel runway showand nearby photos of
him promoting his capsule line for Macys. Advertisements have further detracted
from the appeal of some high-end brands, with the same celebrities modeling for
both luxury and mass-market retailers.
Another challenge comes from some fashion magazines. For example, each month
Allure pits the hottest runway pieces against their more afordable look-alikes in its
Lust vs. Must section.
Also muddying the waters is the rise of new distribution channels for luxury goods
at discount prices. One of the best known in the United States is the T.J.Maxx retail
chain, which carriesand discountsmany premium labels found in full-price
luxury department stores and boutiques. Others, such as Gilt Groupe and Vente-
privee, create equally interesting serendipity shopping experiences, ofering the
thrill of the limited-time, limited-stock deal. The excitement engendered by this
kind of shopping is hard to match in traditional retail settings or on a conventional
retail website.
Many luxury providers have started to adapt their marketing messages to restore
clearer diferentiation relative to the mass-market players and to play to the new
consumer values. For example, we have observed over the last 18 months a shif of
communication away from primal factors such as sex, status, and assertive, showy
displays of wealth. Some luxury brands, like Patek Philippe, have published ads that
appeal to heritage, using images of a father and son with ad copy that describes the
father as the custodian of the watch for the next generation. Others have focused
on their roots to bolster the value of the product; still others point to the fact that
their products are hand crafed.
However, a change in marketing message, though important, is not sufcient by
itself to imbue luxury products and services with a new sense of purpose. If the
brand is to be believable, the message has to be authentic. Luxury brands must fnd
innovative ways to add more value to their products.
Reinforcing the value of luxury products is certainly a defensive play to blunt the ef-
fect of many of the messages coming from mass-market players. But it will also
provide major growth opportunities. Indeed, reinforcement of value may enable
signifcantly higher prices.
A change in market-
ing message is not
sufcient to imbue
luxury goods and
services with a new
sense of purpose.
The Boston Consulting Group 9
A benchmarking of price gaps between mass-market, masstige (a term that
means prestige for the masses and describes downward expansion of a high-end
brand), core-luxury, and ultraluxury segments showed very diferent pricing levels
across categories. In some categories, such as watches, providers have excelled at
articulating a sense of value and have generated a signifcant luxury business,
whose products are priced above $50,000, that coexists with a mass-market busi-
ness selling $50 watches. But in other categories, such as cosmetics, the typical price
diference between a luxury product and a mass-market product remains quite
small. (See Exhibit 2.)
In such narrow spaces lies opportunity for diferentiation and value creation to allow
price stretching. For instance, designer Tom Ford, leveraging his experience from his
turnaround of the Gucci brand to tap into the desires of afuent women who prize
top quality and exclusivity, has teamed with Este Lauder to make and sell products
that are priced several times higher than other luxury cosmetic brandsnever mind
mass-market products. A Tom Fordbranded lipstick is priced at $48 (compared with
$30 on average for core-luxury lipsticks), for example, and his Santal Blush fragrance,
at $475, costs four times what typical core-luxury-equivalent products cost.
139
Price multiplier
163
68
83
0
7
11
19
25
50 100 150 200
Price multiplier
0 50 100 150 200
7
5
5
4
6
11
25
36
107
2
2
2
3
4
Watches
Wine
Wine
Mobile devices
Mobile devices
Cocktail dresses
Cocktail dresses
Handbags
Handbags
Shoes
Shoes
Skin care
Skin care
Cars
Cars
Fragrances
Fragrances
Hotels Hotels
Makeup
Core-luxury versus mass-market segments Ultra-luxury versus core-luxury segments
Analysis of price multiplier between mass-market, core-luxury,
and ultra-luxury segments
Watches
Makeup
Source: BCG analysis.
1
Based on analysis of average gross retail prices in the European markets for 20 illustrative products for each category . For example, in the
fragrances segment, we looked at mass-market brands such as Adidas, Zara Basics, and Brut by Faberg; core-luxury brands such as JAdore by
Christian Dior, Chanel No. 5, and Trsor by Lancme; and ultraluxury brands such as Frederic Malle, LArtisan Parfumeur, Serge Lutens, and Clive
Christian No. 1.
Exhibit 2 | There Is Room to Add Value and Stretch Prices, Especially in Cosmetics, Shoes, and
Hotels
Luxe Redux 10
The distinctions are crucial, as BCGs interviews with high-end shoppers confrmed.
Ive always tried to get the best products; over-the-counter never appealed to me,
said one woman. The diference between shopping at luxury stores and mass
brands is the feeling of exclusivity and importance.
By providing value-added products that change the lives of consumers, Apple has
repeatedly demonstrated similar instincts about consumers desiresenabling
the company to achieve astonishing gross margins on products such as the iPad,
iPhone, and iPod. The companys top managers spend extreme amounts of time
and effort on the look and feel of the products and their buttons, on the user
experience delivered, and even on the design of the packaging. The outcomes
have been tangible in the midnight queues of consumers eagerly waiting for new
Apple product launchesand in the profit margins that Apple has been able to
sustain.
We strongly believe that there is more room for growth in the ultraluxury segment
because consumers today are longing for something special in a world of mass
production, and they place a greater premium on connoisseurship, quality, and
authenticity than on status.
The Worlds Luxury Map Is Changing
New metropolitan areas are rapidly emerging as recognized centers of luxury
consumption. Already, cities such as Shanghai and Dubai are known for their
high-end shopping. (In our 2009 report Chinas Luxury Market in a Post Land Rush
Era, we noted that Shanghais market for luxury goods was as saturated as that in
many other major international cities.) Most luxury players are expectingindeed,
planning forstrong growth in what today are called emerging markets. A BCG
evaluation of eight major luxury houses shows a 42 percent hike in the number of
stores in Asia from 2008 through 2011, a 28 percent rise in Europe in that time, a 31
percent increase in the rest of the world in those years, but only a 5 percent rise in
North America in the same period.
Of course, Chinas newly afuent consumers are making headlines for their avid
consumption of luxury goods. In fact, the business leaders of some major luxury
brands believe that as much as 40 percent of their global sales are already coming
from Chinese consumers. Perhaps in response to Chinas increasing importance,
Chanel has created a ParisShanghai collection in the past few years and has held
special runway events in China. Some luxury purveyors have focused eforts in the
big cities of Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangzhou, but some others, such as Dunhill
and Burberry, have expanded into tier 2 and lower-tier cities. The fact that luxury-
goods brands have presences outside the top cities is not surprising: we predict that
by 2020, more than 330 cities in China will have the same level of disposable
income that Shanghai had in 2010, and that by 2015, China will become the worlds
largest luxury market.
Big cities in the other BRIC nations are also becoming powerful luxury hubs.
Brazils afuent are making a big impact far beyond their own shores, bolstering
real estate markets in Florida and buoying luxury retailers in Miami and New York.
Consumers today
place a greater
premium on connois-
seurship, quality, and
authenticity than on
status.
The Boston Consulting Group 11
BCG estimates that about half the total luxury spending by Brazilian and Chinese
consumers comes from those traveling abroad.
Given the increase in outbound travel by citizens of emerging markets (26 percent
more Chinese came to the U.S. in 2011 than just four years earlier, according to U.S.
government statistics), global sales to customers from emerging markets will only
increase. Leading providers are positioning accordingly. The pandemic of luxury-
goods store openings has been well publicized; now some luxury companies are
making bolder moves. Prada, for instance, has listed on the Hong Kong Stock
Exchange.
But succeeding in the new regional luxury hubs over the long term requires more.
For instance, it is essential to consider how to tailor local in-store experiences and
how to adapt customer-relationship-management (CRM) tools and processes to
cater to local, as well as international, customers. Hiring staf with foreign-language
capabilities is an obvious in-store move, but efective CRM and afer-sales service
are also critical factors. Can your CRM systems capture Mandarin characters, for
instance, or identify and track people as they purchase across your global network?
Can you track your customers across all potential touch points? Can your stores
handle repairs, returns, or questions on purchases made in other countries?
Luxury companies should also be prepared to face new local competition. For
instance, Chinese jewelry retailer Chow Tai Fook is already making headlines in
Western media, drawing attention to its rapid growth and recent public ofering.
Serving fast-growing markets for luxury experience, the Jumeirah hospitality group,
a Dubai company, has put its name on premium hotels and spas in the West in the
last decade. And some high-end-services players are emerging in China: in the spa
sector, premium chains include Herborist and Dragonfy, for example, and, in the
hotel industry, Hong Kongbased Shangri-La is opening hotels all over the world.
Furthermore, there are questions about how best to organize and to get the right
talent to serve emerging markets. Many global luxury companies have not yet
adapted their management structure to suit the new markets; as part of our recent
research, BCG surveyed 25 global luxury players and found that more than 82
percent of Westerners are working in their home countries. (See Exhibit 3.)
Putting it another way, managers from rapidly developing economies (and even
Western managers who are based in emerging markets) are clearly underrepresented
in the top management teams of the global luxury providers. Concomitantly, many
luxury companies are overly centralized; their businesses are generally run from a
headquarters ofce in Europe or the U.S. To bolster their future success, luxury
companies must build and deploy truly international senior-management teams.
They must also evaluate functions and responsibilities to determine which could be
handed of to local teams in emerging markets or whether a centralized model would
work better. If the latter, then they must make sure that the specifc needs of
emerging markets are well integrated into the operations of the center.
Luxury providers should certainly not develop and implement their emerging-mar-
ket strategies in isolation. They have to address global markets in integrated ways,
Luxury companies
should be prepared
to face new local
competition.
Luxe Redux 12
and they must continue to explore the untapped potential in established markets.
That requires an understanding of defnitions of luxury that difer greatly. For
example, when consumers in the U.S. think luxury, they think cars. (See Exhibit
4.) A snapshot from BCGs study: relative to other countries, the size of their
2
5 0
9 0.5
0.5
0
82
0.5
Home
country
Other Western
country
Origin of executive (%)
Current
location
of executive
(%)
Rapidly developing
economy
Rapidly
developing
economy
Other
Western
country
Home
country
Review of 230 executive-committee members of 25 luxury companies
Source: BCG analysis.
Exhibit 3 | Senior Executives of Luxury Providers Are Not Evenly
Spread WorldwideBut Should Be
19
24
37
30
10
20
50
0
40
Luxury
cars
U.S. consumption as a percentage
of global consumption
Experiential
luxury
Personal
luxury goods
23
30
10
20
50
0
40
U.S. GDP
U.S. GDP as a percentage
of global GDP
Source: BCG analysis.
Exhibit 4 | In the U.S., Personal Luxury Goods Are Underweighted
Relative to Global Patterns
The Boston Consulting Group 13
15,000
Facebook fans (thousands)
10,000
5,000
0
May 2012 February 2010
Burberry LV Chanel Gucci Dior Chopard Cartier Bulgari Hermes Tiany Coach
Growth from
February 2010
to May 2012
405
19
383
152
553
235 26
1
33
44
600
690 697
2,194
183
577
12,637
3,330
6,566
7,423
7,838 7,840
21.1x 19.4x 306.2x 13.4x 17.2x 14.2x 14.4x 37.5x 20.7x 13.1x 140.8x
Sources: Facebook; BCG analysis.
Note: Numbers reflect fans of corporate pages; the May 2012 tally was as of May 1, 2012; numbers reflect rounding.
Exhibit 5 | Growth in the Number of Luxury Brands Facebook Fans Demonstrates the Increased
Focus on a Digital Strategy
economies, and the presence of high-net-worth individuals, the U.S. and Germany
spend far less on personal luxury goods, but both are home to committed luxury-
car buyers. (See the sidebar Rethinking U.S. Luxury Markets.)
The Digital Revolution Is Well Under Way
Many luxury brands have steadily built a digital presence over the past decade. And
weve seen the emergence of digital pure playsfull-price, for example, Net-a-Por-
ter.com, which ofers editorial content alongside the latest luxury fashions, and
of-price, for example, ruelala.com, which adds a sense of excitement with its
limited-time, get-them-before-theyre-gone ofers. Overall, particularly in the past
year, the focus on digital media has increased, with new integrated-media applica-
tions being launched. As a further example, the numbers of fans following luxury
brands on Facebook has increased dramatically, as BCG has observed by tallying
the Facebook fans of leading brands from February 2010 over more than two years.
(See Exhibit 5.)
One of the leaders in the multimedia space is Burberry. Its Facebook following
skyrocketed from 600,000 in February 2010 to more than 12 million more than two
years later. Following its highly successful Art of the Trench campaign, in which
users could upload their own photos, Burberry launched an iPad app that allowed
customers to preorder select items during the retailers spring-summer 2011 runway
Luxe Redux 14
showresponding to the way in which fast-fashion chains capture consumer
spending on fashion trends that start before runway items hit the stores.
Nordstrom is another technology-savvy player. The retailer has not only created
an iPad app for remote buying but also integrated iPad usage into the store,
complete with Wi-Fi and charging stations to create a seamless multichannel
experience.
In some cases, technology is enabling a new means of customer contact in the
retail setting: cosmetic tips and tricks (such as those ofered at Macys) or a person-
alized ftting-room mood (ofered by C. Wonder). Although some shoppers may be
put of by the self-service nature of some of these technologies, the president of a
major fashion label recently made a statement to the contrary: The younger
The Sunday newspaper supplements
regularly trumpet the newfound
afuence of consumers in Shanghai,
Rio, Moscow, and New Delhi. But they
rarely shine the spotlight on one of
the worlds largest markets: the U.S.
The U.S. represents 23 percent of
global GDP and is home to about 30
percent of the worlds millionaires
and roughly 40 percent of its
billionaires. The nations luxury
market is driven more by the
spending of millionaires than it is in
any other country, and their wealth is
focused along the coasts and in a
handful of other metropolitan
areas. The U.S. is also the worlds
biggest online-apparel-shopping
market and has a higher penetration
of social media than other countries.
Yet department stores remain an
incredibly important channel, despite
their difculties over the past decade.
A few other factors that distinguish
the U.S.: the countrys growing ethnic
diversity must be taken into account,
not only in terms of marketing but
also with regard to product develop-
ment in some categories. It is also a
market in which consumers are more
likely to be infuenced by peers or
opinion leaders, and, as a result,
advocacy marketing is more powerful
in the U.S. than anywhere else. And
the size of the U.S. means that it
comprises many regional markets;
the merchandising and format
strategies that work in New York City
are unlikely to work in St. Louis or
Austin.
At the same time, the U.S. is
becoming a primary destination for
more and more touristsparticularly
from South America and Asiawho
are starting to account for an increas-
ing proportion of luxury spending.
Yet spending on luxury goods in the
U.S. is distorted; asked to cite the top
luxury brands, Americans name
carmakers such as Lexus, BMW, and
Cadillac. Not only is the U.S. mindset
about luxury diferent from that in
other regions (there is strong
attention to price relative to other
countries, for instance, so value must
be clearly communicated) but actual
spending follows a diferent pattern:
the U.S. accounts for just 19 percent
RETHINKING U.S. LUxURY MARKETS
The Boston Consulting Group 15
generation not only has a lower need for service, but they sometimes are repelled
by it. The New York Times put it this way: For a generation of shoppers raised on
Google and e-commerce, the answer to Can I help you? is increasingly a frm no,
even at retailers like Nordstrom that have built their reputations around customer
service.
But while an integrated digital presence can help address ofine issues as well as
engage diferent customers, it can also raise tough questions for luxury brands. For
example, how should they adapt to the democratization introduced by social
media? How can a luxury brand be selective when it has more than 8 million fans
on Facebook? Perhaps even more important, how can a luxury provider control its
brand on the Web when context is so important to that brand? Imagine if a post for
a luxury apparel brand appears next to a picture of a high school friend whose
of the worlds spending on personal
luxury goods but 37 percent of global
high-end-car buying.
When combined, these factors point
to one realization: most global
providers of luxury goods and services
have a huge opportunity in North
America. If U.S. consumers were
purchasing the same volumes of
personal goods as Italians do, the
global market for luxury goods would
be 40 percent larger than it is today.
So an immediate priority is to
determine how best to re-educate U.S.
consumers about luxury. BCG has
found that success depends on the
following:
Persistence. There must be a
commitment to success over the
long term, with a willingness to
fund and learn from multiple
concurrent market experiments.
Appropriate Brand Presence. Leaders
will understand the appeal of their
brands in tier 2 and lower cities
and will adapt their assortments
and retail formats accordingly.
Better Customer Relationship
Management. It will be necessary
to augment CRM and
micromarketing initiatives to
better respond to demand from
multiple locations.
Multichannel Integration. Leaders
will sharpen their focus on
e-commerce and e-marketing,
putting particular emphasis on
advocacy marketing to steer
consumers toward their brands.
Rethinking American. U.S. markets
can now be segmented into
groups that include high-net-worth
women as well as Hispanic and
Asian-American categories.
Understanding the Tourist Market.
U.S. luxury brands have strong
appeal to growing numbers of
tourists from South America and
Asia (especially China), including
in those visitors home markets,
which speaks to the value of
establishing a global presence.
Luxe Redux 16
attire is more hobo than highbrow. Does that juxtaposition, however unintentional,
dilute the essence of that brand?
Although some brands have tried a whole range of digital experiments, the efforts
of most luxury companies still rely on a very bottom-up, test-what-works kind of
approach rather than being driven by a vision implemented through a solid,
well-prepared strategy. While the test-and-learn approach is still viable, providers
of luxury goods and services should do more to tie their Web presence, digital-
store concepts (such as blurring online and offline experiences for consumers),
location-based services, and other digital initiatives into a single commercial
platform.
Also, spending on digital and social media must be bolstered by effective market-
ing techniques and measurement tools. And luxury providers should identify who
will own digital in their organizations and then ensure that the digital opera-
tions, however nascent, are strongly supported with funding and executive
sponsorship. Digital has to be seen not as a sideline function but as a central
consideration around which in-store, merchandising, and other business decisions
are made.
Looking Ahead
We remain confdent that the luxury sector will continue to grow as long as key
players reinvent themselves in response to the trends we have outlined.
We project that global sales of personal luxury goods will grow at about 7 percent
annually from 2012 through 2014 (assuming no major new economic crises), with a
worst-case scenario of 3 percent annually that could ensue from a 1.5 percent drop
in GDP growth in Europe, the U.S., and Japan and a 3 percent GDP growth cutback
in emerging markets. For luxury experiences, we anticipate growth of 12 percent
per year over the next two years. Overall, the next few years will show slower
growth for luxury goods and services than the 20102011 period, which saw a
catch-up surge in sales following the 20082009 slump.
So what should be on the agenda at the next meeting of the senior-executive team?
Providers of luxury goods and services must prioritize the following actions:
Expand into the realm of experiential luxuryboost experiences as part of the
overall ofering, identify the emotional levers that matter, explore new experi-
ence segments, and develop and ofer rich, exciting, and consistently satisfying
experiences.
Explore and develop new ways to add value to the brand, products, and services;
communicate the brands distinctiveness powerfully and authentically; and then
set new price points that refect the brands higher value.
Build truly global management teamsseveral layers deepand give them
spans of authority and responsibility that extend beyond their native countries
and regions.
The luxury sector will
continue to grow as
long as key players
reinvent themselves
in response to trends.
The Boston Consulting Group 17
Explore, evaluate, and develop new delivery models such as licensing, cobrand-
ing, and exclusive arrangements with select retailers, and be sure to adapt those
models to diferent markets and nations. (See the sidebar Seeking Value in
Other Business Models.)
Develop a new marketing platform centered on CRM and advocacy marketing.
The platform should gauge all touch points with consumers, enabling the
organization to gain a deep understanding of consumer desires and to create
lasting intimacy with its customers. Properly planned and managed, micro-
CRM platforms can help to do this, furthering opportunities for natural brand
apostlesexisting fans of a product or serviceto spread the word to others in
their social networks.
Put digital at the heart of the company and rethink, in depth, the marketing and
commercial approach accordingly.
P
urveyors of luxury goods and services might be tempted to breathe a sigh of
relief every time there is an uptick in the global economy. But they cannot
must notassume that improvements in the economic vigor of the developed
world and surging growth in many rapidly developing economies will relieve them
of the need to do anything diferent.
Regardless of how successful they may be today, many players will have to sharpen
their adaptive-strategy skills if they are to succeed over the long term as consumer
values shif, as the nature of luxury buying changes, as new and very diferent
In retail, makers of luxury brands
have tended to control the brand
experience through their own directly
owned and operated stores, but we
believe that alternative models can
create signifcant value:
Licenses. Some brands, such as
Roberto Cavalli, have had great
success with licenses because they
maintain tight control of their
operations. For example, research
and development, design, market-
ing and communications, and
store-design functions are all kept
in-house.
New Concepts. Concept stores, such
as Collette in Paris, ofer luxury
lifestyle goods and services,
replete with many exclusive
designer collaborations, and
philanthropic stores, such as
Merci, ofer consumers a sense of
purpose through spending that
benefts the less advantaged.
New Retail Formats. Pop-up stores,
cobranded stores, and localized
stores take advantage of both local
architecture and local tastes when
creating merchandising plans.
Louis Vuitton at Comme des
Garons is a good example of a
cobranded store.
SEEKING VALUE IN OTHER BUSINESS MODELS
Luxe Redux 18
markets materialize in rapidly developing economies, and as social media and
digital in general reshape long-held perceptions of luxury and value.
These four trends are reshaping the business of luxury everywhere. They require
that luxury providers take a dispassionate look at their strengths and weaknesses
vis--vis the new markets they want to reach, the new demographics they now face,
and the new channels and platforms through which they can attract and retain
customers. They have to be able to determine, with certainty, the gaps between
their current practices and industry best practices.
They must act now. Afer all, time is a luxury they can no longer aford.
The Boston Consulting Group 19
About the Authors
Jean-Marc Bellaiche is a senior partner and managing director in the New York ofce of The Bos-
ton Consulting Group and the global leader of the luxury, fashion, and beauty topic area. You may
contact him by e-mail at bellaiche.jean-marc@bcg.com.
Michelle Eirinberg Kluz is a principal in the frms New York ofce and a core member of the lux-
ury, fashion, and beauty topic area. You may contact her by e-mail at kluz.michelle@bcg.com.
Antonella Mei-Pochtler is a senior partner and managing director in BCGs Vienna ofce. You
may contact her by e-mail at mei-pochtler.antonella@bcg.com.
Elmar Wiederin is a senior partner and managing director in the frms Geneva ofce. You may
contact him by e-mail at wiederin.elmar@bcg.com.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to ofer their sincere thanks to Dorit Hanisch (global marketing manager in
BCGs Vienna ofce); Gillian Moore, senior analyst; and other colleagues for their contributions.
They would also like to acknowledge John Kerr for his editing and writing assistance, as well as
Katherine Andrews, Gary Callahan, Catherine Cuddihee, Angela DiBattista, Kim Friedman, and
Sara Strassenreiter for their contributions to editing, design, and production.
For Further Contact
If you would like to discuss this report, please contact one of the authors.
To fnd the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcgperspectives.com.
Follow bcg.perspectives on Facebook and Twitter.
The Boston Consulting Group, Inc. 2012. All rights reserved.
6/12
Abu Dhabi
Amsterdam
Athens
Atlanta
Auckland
Bangkok
Barcelona
Beijing
Berlin
Boston
Brussels
Budapest
Buenos Aires
Canberra
Casablanca
Chennai
Chicago
Cologne
Copenhagen
Dallas
Detroit
Dubai
Dsseldorf
Frankfurt
Geneva
Hamburg
Helsinki
Hong Kong
Houston
Istanbul
Jakarta
Johannesburg
Kiev
Kuala Lumpur
Lisbon
London
Los Angeles
Madrid
Melbourne
Mexico City
Miami
Milan
Minneapolis
Monterrey
Montral
Moscow
Mumbai
Munich
Nagoya
New Delhi
New Jersey
New York
Oslo
Paris
Perth
Philadelphia
Prague
Rio de Janeiro
Rome
San Francisco
Santiago
So Paulo
Seattle
Seoul
Shanghai
Singapore
Stockholm
Stuttgart
Sydney
Taipei
Tel Aviv
Tokyo
Toronto
Vienna
Warsaw
Washington
Zurich
bcg.com