Chogay Trichen Rinpoche - The History of The Sakya Tradition
Chogay Trichen Rinpoche - The History of The Sakya Tradition
Chogay Trichen Rinpoche - The History of The Sakya Tradition
SAKY A TRADITION
( Gangs-ljongs mdo-sngags kyi bstan-pa'i
shing-rta dpal-Idan sa-skya-pa'i
chos-'byung mdor-bsdus skal-bzang
yid-kyi dga' -ston)
His Holiness the Sakya Trizin Ngawang Kunga Thegchen Pal bar Thinley Samphel
Wang Gi Gyalpo The Forty-First Patriarch of the Sakya Order
THE HISTORY OF THE SAKY A TRADITION
A Feast for the Minds of the Fortunate
CHOGAY TRICHEN RINPOCHE
Translated from Tibetan into French
by
Yen. Phende Rinpoche and Jamyang Khandro
Translated from French into English
by
Jennifer Stott
Introduced and Annotated by
David Stott
1983
GANESHA PRESS
BRISTOL
Ganesha Press
Sakya Thinley Rinchen Ling
27 Lilymead A venue
Knowle BRISTOL BS42BY
Copyright c 1983 Ganesha Press
No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by
any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any
information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without
permission in writing froll) the publisher, except by a reviewer who wishes to
quote brief passages in connection with a review written for inclusion in a
magazine, newspaper or broadcast.
British Library Cataloging in Publication Data
Thubten Legshay Gyamtsho, Chogay Trichen
The History of the Sakya Tradition
1. Sa-skya-pa (SectrHistory
I. Title
294.3'923 BQ7666
ISBN 0 9509119 0 9
Printed in the United Kingdom
by The Manchester Free Press.
List of Illustrations
Introduction
Translators Preface
CONTENTS
CHAPTER I
The Coming of the Great Sakyapa
CHAPTER II
The Revelation of Countless Sutra and Tantra.
Teachings to the Great Lamas
Sachen KungaNyingpo
SonamTsemo
Drakpa Gyaltshan
Sakya Pandita
ChogyalPhakpa
Dromgon Channa
Dharmapala
CHAPTER ill
The Succession of the Great Holders of the
Doctrine
Influence of the Sakya Tradition
Ngor Ewam Choden and Ngorchen Kunga Zangpo
Nalendra and Rongton Sheja Kunzig
TbeTshar Tradition
Other Important Monasteries
CHAPTER IV
The Outstanding Characteristics of this
Tradition
Chogay Trichen's Bibliography
Notes for the English Translation
Glossary
viii
ix
xii
1
5
7
16
16
17
20
21
21
25
25
28
30
33
37
41
44
47
59
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
His Holiness Sakya Trizin iv
The Five Masters 4
Yirupa 9
His Eminence Sakya Dagchen Rinpoche 23
Arya Manjushri 24
Yen Phende Shabdrung Rinpoche 29
Yen Chogay Trichen Rinpoche 35
Yen Karma Thinley Rinpoche 37
ShakyrununiBuddha 40
Arya Avalokiteshvara 57
Une drawings by
Jean Veasey and Sarah Bushman
viii
Introduction
The publication of this English translation of Chogay Trichen Rin-
poche's The History of the Sakya Tradition se.rves as an introduction to
the Sakyapa school, hitherto the tradition of Tibetan Buddhism least
well-known in the West.
1
The Author is eminently qualified for this
task, being not only the Head of the Tshar branch of the tradition but,
in a renowned tantric master, scholar and Indeed, Cho-
gay Trichen Rinpoche is recognized as one of the greatest tantric mas-
ters alive today.
The Sakyapa tradition takes its name from the monastery founded in
1073 at Sakya ('the place of grey earth') in south-western Tibet by Kon-
chog Gyalpo, a member of the Khon clan. This influential family had
previously owed allegiance to the Nyingmapa tradition but Konchog
Gyalpo studied the theories and methods of the new diffusion of tantras
current in eleventh century Tibet. The most important of the teachings
which he received from his teacher Drokmi Lotsava, a disciple of the
Indian scholar Gayadhara, was the meditational system known as the
Path and Its Fruit (Lam- 'bras).
In the twelfth and centuries, the Sakya tradition rose to
a position of prominence in the religious and .cultural life of Tibet. This
was due largely to the endeavours of the five great masters: Sachen
Kunga Nyingpo (1092-1158); Sonam Tsemo (1142-1182); Drakpa Gyalt-
shan (1147-1216); Sakya Pandita (1182-1251)i and Chogyal Phakpa
'
(1235-1280). Since that time the tradition and its two principal sub-
sects, the Ngor sub-sect founded by Ngorchen Kunga Zangpo (1382-
1457) and the Tshar sub-set founded by Tsarchen Losal Gyamtsho
(1502-1556) have been adorned by the labours and spiritual blessings
of numerous illustrious yogins and scholars. Now the Sakya tradition
under the compassionate guidance of His Holiness Sakya Trizin (b.
1945), magnificent incarnation of the Khon line, is putting down roots
outside Tibet in India, Sputh-East Asia, North America and Europe.
The most important doCtrinal and meditational cycle of the Sakyapa
tradition is The Path and Its Fruit (Lam- 'bras) orginally enunciated by
Virupa, a ninth century Indian tantric saint. The Path and Its Fruit rep-
resents a systematization for practice of the entire range of sutra and
tantra teachings given by Lord Buddha. Its most profound spiritual
methods derive from the H evajra Tantra. From the time of the fifteenth
century master M_uchen onwards, two differing presentations of the
Path and Its Fruit have been transmitted side-by-side. The Tshogshay
(Tshogs-bshad) is the exoteric presentation of the teaching while the
Lobshay (sLob-bshad) is the esoteric preseqtation, containing very de-
tailed and secret points of instruction.
The philosophical viewpoint which informs the Path and Its Fruit is
the notion of the inseparability of samsara and nirvana (Khorday Yer-
may "khor- 'das dbyer-med). It is said: 'By abandoning samsara one
will not realize nirvana. Mind itself, the union of luminosity and emp-
tiness, is the root of samsara and nirvana. When obscured it takes the
form of samsara and when freed of obscurations it is nirvana. The key
to Buddhalfood, the ultimate source of benefit for all beings, lies in this
realization.
The History of the Sakya Tradition is a work of the chos- 'byung
genre-that is to say, a history dealing with the origins and develop-
ment of a particular branch of Buddhism-in this case, the Sakyapa
school. The fundamental theme that underlies this present work and all
:works of this genre is the importance of transmission. The Sakyapa tra-
dition, its sub-sects and its array of textual and meditational lineages
are the structures through which the transmission of the liberating
teachings flow.
This transmission is the movement of knowledge, in the form of an
immense variety of techniques for direct insight into reality, from
teacher to student in unbroken succession. It is precisely this uninter-
rupted nature ofthe transmission that guarantees its spiritual efficacy.
With this point in mind one can quite easily understand the reason why
so much attention is paid in this history to details such as each master's
receipt of empowerments, textual transmissions, oral instructions and
so on. However, this testimony to the unbroken transmission of the
teaching is only one of the values present in a work such as this.
In this history we are confronted by the magnificent example provi-
ded by the masters of the tradition, whose lives were irradiated by the
X
insight, compassion and power derived from the practice of the self-
same teachings that are now our inheritance. In contemplating their
example we are inspired to emulate them. Perhaps most importantly of
all, when we read this history with intelligence and devotion, we re-
ceive the spiritual blessings of the Sakyapa tradition. Through the re-
ceipt of such blessings our confidence is strengthened, our meditation
is empowered, and our life is transfigured.
David Stott (Ngakpa Jampa Thaye)
Spiritual Representative of
Karma Thinley Rinpoche at
dharma centres in ~ United Kingdom/
Honorary Lecturer in Tibetan Religions
University of Manchester.
Sakya Thinley Rinchen Ling .
September 1983.
xi
Translator's Preface
This English edition of Chogay Trichen Rinpoche's History of the Glo-
rious Sakya Tradition-a Feast for the Minds of the Fortunate has been
translated from the French version of the book prepared by Ven.
Phende Shabdrung Rinpoche, one of the four heads of the Ngor branch
of the Sakya tradition, and his wife Jamya,ng Khandro. The French ed-
ition was published by Rinpoche's centre, E-wam Phende Ling, in 1978
and it was at Rinpoche's suggestion that work was begun on transla-
ting tlle history into English.
I would like to thank Ven. Phende Shabdrung Rinpoche and Ven.
Karma Thinley Rinpoche, head of Sakya Thinley Rinchen Ling, for
their blessings and encouragement in the preparation of this text.
I would also like to thank my husband .David Stott for writing the
notes to the English text and for checking the English with the Tibetan
edition; and Mr. Cyrus Stearns of Sakya Thegchen Choling (Seattle) for
providing a copy of the Tibetan edition of the history.
J.M.S.
xii
THE HISTORY OF THE SAKY A TRADITION
A Feast for the Minds of the Fortunate
The Coming of The Great
Sakyapa
It is said that in ancient times three divine brothers came down to the
land of Ngari Tod, to the north of the King of Sheltsha's territory . in
order to bring merit to beings. The five generations which.follow from
Yuring,the second brother, to Yapang Che are known as the Divine
Line of Clear Light. Yapang Che, after vanquishing the bloodless vam-
pire Charing, married Yadruk Silima who bore him a son named Khon
Barche meaning: 'he who is born in the midst of the The son of
this latter, Khon Palpoche, became minister to King Trison in the
eighth century C. E. Another son, Khon Nagarakshita, was a close stu-
dent of acharya Padmakara and one of the seven Tibetan 'proba-
ten generations which stretch from Khon. Palpoche to the
brother Sherab Tsultrim and Khan Konchog Gyalpo were skilled in the
'Ancient' (Nyingma) tantras and obtained realization through the prac-
tices of the meditational deities Shri Vishuddha and
Konchog Gyalpo studied the 'New' (Sarma)
4
dissemination of the tan-
tras and founded the Sakya monastery.
The Buddha Shakyamuni had prophesied in the Manjushri Tantra
that a Sakya monastery would cause the teachings to flowerin Tibet.
Another prophesy, by the precious guru Padmakara had concerned the
location of this monastery and the disciples it would attract. Before the
monastery was built, four stupas were erected in the ten directions to
purify the site and make it an auspicious one. Passing this spot on his
way from India to Tibet in 1040 C.E., Lord Atisha (982-1053)
5
is reputed
to have prostrated many times and -made offerings. He subsequently
perceived the syllable Hri, seven Dhi syllables and the syllable Hum on
the side ofthe mountain and prophesied that the place would witness
one Avalokiteshvara incarnation, seven Manjushri incarnations and
one 'Vajrapani incarnation, proving a source of happiness for all be-
ings. It was here, in the Waterbuffalo year of the f1rst cycle (1073) that
khan Konchog Gyalpo founded the Sakya monastery, and it is from this
time that one speaks of 'the Sakyapas . The fame of the lineage with
1
the three excellent names, the Divine Line of the Khon Sakya family,
subsequently spread in every direction.
Khon Konchog Gyalpo's son, Sachen Kunga Nyingpo, was revealed
as an incarnation of A vaJokiteshvara in accordance with prophecies
made by Namkha' upa and'others. He was born into this excellent line-
age in the male Water Monkey of the second cycle (1092). From his
birth, he displayed a great love for all beings and, while still young, he
appeared to a from Kham in the form of the one-thousand-
armed A valokiteshvara. His fame as an incarnation of Virupa spread
far and wide.
He possessed the ten powers
6
and was able to carry the weight of the
teachings. He was the supreme bodhisattva, lord of the three realml
and the guide of those searching for liberation. The master of those
who had undertak7n to follow the path, he was possessed of an indomi-
table resolve to liberate all beings, a complete understanding of all the
objects of knowledge and was capable of extinguishing all doubt. He
received an immense ocean of teachings from his own school and from
others. He was able to clarify all obscurities through practice and de-
bate and, skilled in differentiating the dharma from false doctrines, he
in leading students on the pure path.
2
The Five Masters
4
The Revelation of Countless
Sutra and Tantra Teachings to
the Great Lamas
The key to happiness in all worlds lies in the presence of the noble
dharma. Correct dharma is that which conforms to the teachings of the
Buddha. Sakya Pandita said:'--
There is nobody in the three realms who is more all-knowing than
the perfectly accomplished Buddha. It is therefore necessary to
adhere faithfully to the sutras and tantras which are the words of
the Buddha. To add anything false to the sutras and tantras ren-
ders one liable to criticism from the exalted ones. Thus spoke Lord
Maitreya in the Uttara Tantra. '
1
The perfectly accomplished Buddha taught 84,000.teachings at Vara-
nasi, Vultures Peak, Shravasti and other places and prescribed reme-
dies to 84,000 types of bad disposition exhibited in the temperaments
and inclinations of ordinary students. It is stated in the Abhidarmak-
osha As an antidote to bad dispositions, the Buddha
has articulated various teachings.' These teachings comprise:
21 ,000 teachings of the Vinaya Pitaka training in
morality as an antidote to the dispositions of greed and desire;
21,000 teachings of the Sutra Pitaka emphasizing training in medi-
tation as an antidote to the dispositions of hate and anger;
21,000 teachings of the Abhidharma Pitaka emphasizing training
in wisdom as an antidote to ignorance;
21,000 teachings of the Profound Pitaka as an antidote to all of
these three poisons.
These teachings can be discussed with reference Hinayana for
those who aspire to the narrow path and the Mahayana for those who
aspire to the greater path. What are the respective characteristics of
these two In the Hinayana, mind aspires to personal peace and
happiness and attains _realization through adherence to the path of tJte
three In the Mahayana, mind aspires to Buddhahood in or-
der to benefit all beings and attains perfect enlightenment through ad-
5
herence to the path of the six paramitas. 4
The superiority of theM a hay ana path over the Hinayana path is due
to the five causes which are: practice, motive, primordial wisdom, ef-
fort and skillful means; and the two fruits of perfect realization and
Buddha-activity . .Within the Mahayana path itself, the Paramitayana,
which adopts the causes as the path, is for those who aspire to the
causes and the Mantrayana, which adopts the fruit as the path, is for
superior students who aspire to the causes and to the fruit.
It is said in the Manjushri Mayqjala Tantra: 'This profound and sec-
ret Vajrayana was formulated for exceptional students by all the bud-
dhas of the three times'. The Lord of Beings therefore taught the great
tantras in this troublesome age possessing the five certainties
5
in the
blissful form of His essential nature never differed from the
dharmaka)Ja? However his form was perceived in different ways accor-
ding to the disposition of individual students. He taught these tantras
in Oddiyana, at Shri Dhanakatyaka, at the summit of Mount Meru and
many places surrounded by an assembly of advanced tantric
practitioners.
In the tantras one achieves self-benefit by visualizing oneself as the
deity. The benefit of others is achieved through rituals of consecration
, .
and empowerment. Although in the sutras and tantras the view to be
realized, the fruit to be obtained and the motive, which is bodhichitta?
are similar, the tantric path is distinguished by:
Its possession of the Profound View9
The means its provides for achieving this realization
The ease with which it leads to enlightenment
Its suitability for students of acute intelligence.
According to the panditas and sages, there are numerous different
disseminations of the tantras. The Salcya lineage follows the tradition
of the explanatory tantra of Hevqjra. the Vajra Panjara. In this tradition
the tantras are divided into four groups: Kriya, Charya, Yoga and An-
uttara yoga tantra.
10
In summary, all the teachings on the Hinayana and Mahayana by the
arhdts, by Maitreya, Manjushri, Vajrapani and others were
by the writers, taught by the panditas and practised and carried out by
the great sages.
6
Sachen Kunga Nyingpo
The great Sakyapa Kunga Nyingpo (1902-1158) mastered all the sutra
and tantra teachings originally transmitted by the sages and siddhas in
India and current in Tibet in his time. In particular he received the lin-
eages of the Arya Nagarjuna and of the Mahasiddha Virupa.
When he was twelve years old, following the instructions of his guru
Bari Lotsava, he performed six months of one-pointed practice until
Manjushri appeared to him directly and gave him the following .injunc-
tions:
Son of a noble family,
If you cling to this life, then you are not a dharma practitioner
If you cling to the Wheel of Existence, then you do not possess re-
nunciation
If you look onlyto your own interests, then you do not possess
bodhichitta
If clinging ensues, then you do not possess the
Sachen Kunga Nyingpo then realized in an instant that all the points
of the Path of the. Perfections were contained in these teachings.
From his teachers Chung Rinchen Drak, Bari Lotsava, Lama Nam-
kha'upa (a disciple of Nyen Lotsava), Mal Lotsava Lodro Drakpa, Puh-
reng Lochung, Vajrasana, two Nepali panditas, Khon Gyichuwa and
his own father, Konchog Gyalpo, he received teachings on Abhidhar-
ma, Pramana, Madhyamaka, the Five Dharmas
trilogy
of Sems- 'grel, treatises on medicine, sutras and sastras, the four ot-
ders of tantras and their explanatory tantras and received the cycles of
empowerrnents and teachings of the dharmapalas Panjaranatha and
Dharmamitra's direction he
perfected the disciplines of study and meditation and, having been in-
structed in the immense ocean of teachings, he quickly became the
pride of Nalanda and great abbot of this monastic university. During
the day he performed an acharya 's three duties of debate, teaching and
composition and during the night he practised meditation on Cakra-
samvara ( 'khor-lo bDe-mchog).
However, when after 70 years of one-pointed practice he had at-
tained no siddhid
8
and negative events were in fact happening to him,
he decided that he had no karmic connection with Vajrayana. In this
state of mind he threw his rosary into the toilet and ceased deity medi-
tation on the twenty-second day of the last month of spring. On the
evening of the same day Nairatmya (bDag-med-ma) appeared to him
and spoke thus:
'Noble son, do not act in this way. Pick up your rosary, clean it',
8
The Indian Siddha Virupa
9
and take up your practice again. I am the deity with whom you
have a karmic connection and I will bestow my blessings upon
you'.
The following evening, Vajra Nairatmya appeared to him again in
her own mandala of fifteen goddesses. She bestowed the four em-
powerments19upon him and he then attained the first bhumlgnd the
of
Since he had received the four empowerments the
stream of initiation was unbroken. Since, at the time of the empower-
ment, he had obtained primordial wisdom, the lineage of blessings was
unbroken. This was the result of the teaching of Vajra Nairatmya.
Virupa then understood that because he had forgotten the teachings
of his lama he had mistaken for bad omens those events which in real-
ity signalled the development of
to thousands of lesser
monks. Due to his unique understanding those who listened to his
words developed immense faith in him and, from that time, he was
termed 'the Noble One' (phags-pa). He had numerous spiritual
friends, chiefofwhom was Manjushri Sakya Pandita. He mastered the
inner and outer vehicles, the Kalachakra, and the majority of the teach-
ings known in Tibet at that time, becoming a precious well of know-
ledge.
Sechen, the Mongol Emperor, invited him to China where he carried
out great works for the benefit of dharma and the welfare of sentient
beings. He ordained thousands of monks each year and in China while
he was giving a teaching to 70,000 monks, he handed out gold and
other material riches. Through his skill in debate he defeated the non-
Buddhist views of the seven masters of Zin-shing, who had previously
criticized the Buddha's teaching, and converted them to Buddhism. He
also compiled a Mongol alphabet in response to the persistent requests
of the king, Gose.
In response to entreaties by his Chinese students that he perform a
miracle to display the power of the Sakya teachings, he took a sharp
weapon and cut off his head and limbs. These five pieces were trans-
formed into the five Buddha families and were seen to send out count-
less rays of light. On encountering his moral perfection and the works
of his body, speech and mind, the king and his retinue developed im-
mense faith in him and he became the formost recipient of religious of-
ferings. He also became the religious and temporal ruler of the three
parts of Tibet, as the Buddha had prophesied in the Manjushri mula
tantra. He was the first Tibetan lama to become king .and he governed
20
impartially as far as the different schools of Buddhism were concerned.
Among his disciples were Khang, Nyon and Zhang who held the
lineage of his teaching; Ganden and u n d ~ a y who held the lineage of
tantric revelation; Zhang atid kun who held the lineage of revelation of
the oral instructions; four disciples who carried out his words and
wishes faultlessly; two powerful kings, and six great disciples, one of
whom was Dukhorwa. All the Tibetan masters of this period such as
Narthang Gyadpa heid him in great esteem and. begged him to give
the.m the nectar of his teaching. He excelled in teaching, composition
and debate and succeeded in spreading the doctrine.
Once in Tsang province as he was giving a teaching to 70,!)00 monks,
several thousan4 pitakadharas and 100,000 other disciples, he handed
out gold to each person from a cereal bowl. He also gave bodhisattva
vows in such a way that the significance of the commitment was unmis-
takeable. In the Manjushri mula tantra it was prophesied that Chogyal
Phakpa would 'illuminate the Buddha's teaching like the sun'.
Dromgon Channa
Dromgon Channa, Chogyal Phakpa's brother, subsequently became
the religious and secular ruler of Tibet. He was able to resurrect the
dead and demonstrated this power on several occasions. He could
place religious robes upon a sunbeam as if upon a table and he once
shot an arrow into a rock, penetrating it and causing water to flow. He
was an emanation of Vctjrapani ..
Dharmapala
Dromgon Channa's son Dharmapala (b. 1268) was also the religi()us
and secular ruler of Tibet but he died at a very early age. After his cre-
mation many relics were found in the ashes and these served as an ob-
ject of religious faith in Tibet and China.
Dharmapala had no descendents. However the guru Yesh_e Jungnay,
son of Zangtsha, Sakya Pandita's brother, had flfteen grandsons as
Tara had prophesied when he was in China. Tishri Kunlo (1299-1327),
the eldest of these grandsons, founded four dynastic houses
(bla-brang): Zhicho, Rinchen Gang, Lhakhang and Dunchod of which
the last two sub-dynasties have survived. The saintly lama Sonam Gy-
21
altshan (1312-1375) came from the Rinchen Gangpa dynasty. He per-
fected the triple activity of study, reflection and meditation and there .
was not a single sage in all Tibet who had not studied with him. Among
his descendants were numerous scholars and sages such as Sherab Gy-
altshan and Dagch(m Lodro Gyaltshan (b. 1332). The Lhakhang dynas-
ty also contained numerous scholars and sages.
The surviving dynasty is the Dunchod dynasty which possesses nu-
merous scholars and sages such as the great Kunga Rinchen (1349-
1414) who restored both the temporal power arid the spiritual lineage of
the Sakyapas, laid down monastic rules and initiated and developed the
different methods of textual instruction and meditattion practice. His
accomplishments were of great practical benefit to the Sakya doctrine.
His Eminence Sakya Dagchen Rinpoche (b1929) Head of the Phuntshok
Phodrang branch of the Khon d1nasiy of Sakya and founder of Sakya Thegchen
Choling in the United States
22
In the fifteenth century at the time ofthe master Jamgon Arne Zhab
the Dunchod dynasty divided into two sub-dynasties, or palaces (Phod-
rang): the Dolma Phodrang and thePhuntshok Phodrang. The present
descendants of these two sub-dynasties are Dagtri Rinpoche, the cur-
rent Sakya Trizin and his sons, and Dagchen Rinpoche, his brother
and his sons. They possess scholarly qualities and the marks of realiza-
tion. The dharmapalas are their servants and they are able to transform
apparent phenomena into the nine desireable qualities as they wish.
In their prophecies, the Precious Guru Padmasambhava and Atisha
testify to having seen Sachen Kunga Nyingpo surrounded by emana-
tions of Manjushri, signifying that all authentic descendants of this line
would be sai'1tly beings.
23
Arya Manjushri
24
The Succession of the .Great
Holders of the Doctrine
Influence of the Sakya Tradition
The Five Venerable Masters, having estaolished this new spiritual tra-
dition, . attracted numerous students. These students continued the
lineage as sacred gurus who had received all the injunctions of scholar-
ship and practiCe. Subsequently, all those in the succession of the Div-
ine Line have been lords of learning, moral discipline and wisdom. As
numerous as the sands of the Ganges they have continued to spread
the teaching throughout the Northern Country right up until the pres-
ent time. This accords with the Buddha's prophecy which stated that
the dharma would be very strong in the northern land of Tibet. The
numerous students of the five lords of dharma taught in both eastern
and western Tibet. The recipients of the nectar of their teaching in-
clude the descendants of the Nyingma lines of So, Zur and Nub, Guru
Chowang, as well as many great figures of both the oral (bKa '-rna) and
treasure (gTer-ma)
1
lineages of the Nyingma tradition. In the Kadam
School Jayulpa, Chim Namkha Drak and Chomden Rigpe all received
their teaching. Lama Chawa Chokyi Sengge, the master of the Prajna-
paramita, received the profound maturing and liberating teachings
from the father and son transmission of Sachen Kunga Nyingpo.
Dromgen Phagmo Drupa (1110-1170), one of the founding fathers of
the Kagyu tradition, spent twelve years serving Sachen Kunga Nying-
po and studying with him. He received the profound teachings and
composed the mDzod-mar commentary on the Path and Its Fruit. Kar-
mapa Dusum Khyenpl(lll0-1193) received teachings on the Path and
Its Fruit from Pal Gallo and Aseng, disciples of Sachen Kunga' Nying-
po. Mochogpa and Nyenton Bepe Naljor from the Shangpa Kagyu
served Aseng and Drakpa Gyaltshan with their body, speech and mind
for a long period of time. The omniscient Buton Rinpoche
3
(1290-1364)
founder of the Bu. tradition, received all the teachings on the mantra
practice and philosophy from the Sakyapa lamas Tishri Kunlo and the
25
sacred guru Sonam Gyaltshan. The omniscient Choku Ozer from the
Jonangpa
4
school held the teachings of Sakya Pandita. Dolpopa Sherab
Gyaltshan
5
(1292-J361), the great Jonangpa master studied Sakya phil-
osophy iu its entirety.
The members of the lineage which originates from Shongton Dorje
Gyaltshan, a disciple of Chogyal Phakpa, and ends with Zhalu Lochen
and Bodong Cholay Namgyal niay also be viewed as Sakyapa masters.
If there is any doubt about which school Bodong Cholay Namgyal be-
longs to, one should refer to his autobiography in which he identifies
himself as a Sakyapa. The mahasattva Gyalsay Thogrne Zangpo
6
(1245-
1369), Kunchen Longchenpa
7
(1308-1363), the greatest master of the
Nyingma tradition, and Desri Phagdru all received the Path and Its
Fruit teaching from the sacred lama Sonam Gyaltshan. Thongwa Don-
den?the sixth Karmapa (1416-1453) received all the teachings ofthe
great treatises from Rongton Chenpo.
Je Rinpoche
9
(1357-1419) and his two chief disciples, Gyaltshab Dar-
rna Rinchen and Khedrupje, were students of the great Sakyapa Ren-
dawa, being three of seven students to hold the title
rupje was also one of ten of Rendawa's students to possess the title
Master of Ten Texts (bKa '-bcu sMra-wa). Je Rinpoche also received
many teachings from the omniscient Rendawa and from Sazang Mati
Panchen, both of whom were Sakyapas.
Ts<?ngkhapa's biography indicates that his philosophical tradition
originates from the Sakyapa school and that his tantric learning has its
roots in the Bu tradition. Most Tibetan scholars and sages have, either
directly or indirectly, been; students of Sakyapa lamas and this is rec-
ognized as fact by all impartial scholars.
As far as the explanations of the five divisions of the great topics of
philosophy are concerned, Sakyapa and Gelukpa philosophers say that
the section on the Paramita (perfections) derives from Yag Mipham, on
Madhyamaka (Middle Way), from Rendawa, on Ptamdna (Logic and
Epistemology) from Nya Darma Nyingpo, on Vinaya (Monastic Rules)
from Ja and on Abhidharma (Further Dharma) from Drangti and Chim
Namkha Drak.
Most of these great masters are holders of the lineage of Sakyapa.
dharma. It is because of their benevolence that the triple activity of
26
teaching, debate and composition has flourished in the colleges of all
schools up until the. present time. Furthermore, it is noteworthy
that those masters known as the six ornaments of Tibet were Sakyapa
scholars. These were Yakde and Rongton who were learned in the sut-
ras, Ngorchen Kunga Zangpo and Kunga Namgyal who were learned
in the tantras. Go ram Sonam Sengge and Pandita Shaky a the
fifteenth century masters, learned in both the sutras and tantras. All
these 'scholars, and others numerous as stars in the sky t_ogether with
countless students shook the body of knowledge to its very foundations
in the Land of Snows.
The Sakyapas divide the explanation and study ofthe treatises on the
Tripitaka into the following six sections:
PO.ramiui (The Way of the Peifections) which comprises The Five
Dharmas ofMaitreya viz. theAbhisamayaLankiira, the Sutra-Lankiira.
the Madhyanta Vibhaga, the Dharma-Dharmata Vibhanga and the Ut-
tarantantra and, in addition, the Bodhisattvacarya-aviitara of Shanti-
deva.
Pramana (Logic and Epistemology) which comprises the Pfam?ina
Samuccaya of Dignaga, the Pramlina Viirttika of Dharmakirti, the Pra-
mlina Viniscaya of Dharmakirti and the Pramiina Yuktinidhi of Sakya
Pandita.
Vinaya (Monastic Law) which comprises the Priitimoksa Siitra and
the Vinay; Sutra.
Abhidharma ('Further Dharma') which comprises the Abhidharma
Kosa ofVasubandhuand theAbhidharma Samuccaya of Asanga.
Madhyamaka (Middle Way) which comprises the Mulamadhyamaka
K'lirikii of Nagarjuna, the Madhyamakavattira of Candrakirti and the
CatuhSataka of Aryadeva.
Trisamvaraprabheda (Discrimination of the Three Vows) which com-
prises the Discrimination of the Three Vows of Sakya Pandita.
These eighteen topics, known as the Eighteen Famous Topics are
studied in the monastic universities. On graduation one can either ob-
tain the degree of Kazhipa, Kachupa or Rabjampa. It has been possible
to study this ocean of textual tradition up until the present time in all
the great monastic universities of Tsang, U and Kham within the Sakya
school. Similarly in the Ngor, Dzong, and Tshar schools, every effort
27
was made to keep the banner of practice flying and, to this end, many
different empowerments, textual transmissions and oral instruction of
the four orders of"tantra were given. Many practitioners consequently
obtained great powers such as the rainbow body. These practitioners
include Sonam Tsemo, the mahasiddha Thangtong Gyalpo and other
siddhas, as numerous as a flock of migrating birds, al.l of whom dis-
played the marks of realization. These great beings who held the teach-
ing concentrated all their thoughts on the Buddhadliarma and founded
countless monasteries which shone like jewels upon the ocean and
whose monks preserved the pitakas.
Ngor E-Wam Choden and Ngorchen Kunga
Zan gpo
The principal seat of tantric learning, Ngor E-wam Choden was found-
ed in the Earth Bird year of the seventh cycle (1429) by Ngorchen Vaj-
radhara Kunga Zangpo, one of the 'two Kungas learned in tantra'. The
coming of this great Kunga was prophesied by the Buddha in the
'phags-pa dGe-ba 'i rTsa-wa sutra and in tlie Yongs su 'dzin-pa 'i sutra.
Ngorchen Kunga Zangpo was born in the Water Dog year of the
sixth cycle (1382). His incomparable wisdom of hearing, reflecting and
meditating led him to develop the triple activity of teaching, debate
and composition in the manner of a second Buddha. He gave the pre-
cious word of the Path and Its Fruit eighty times and the Vajra Mala
teaching sixty times. The empowerments, teachings and oral instruc-
tions he gave are beyond enumeration. His moral discipline was such
that he was asked to dispense monk's vows and more than ten thou-
sand times, and he is known as 'the Vajradhara of our era of discord'.
He had countless students who attained realization and in whom the
qualities of scholar and sage were united. The upper and lower regions
of Tibet swarmed with the many monasteries he had established.
The first holder of the throne of Ngor E-wam Choden was Muchen.
From the time of the first abbot Muchen to the present when the heads
of'the four palaces share the t ~ r o n e there have been 69 abbots. The
Path and its Fruit has been transmitted every year without exception.
by the lama holding the throne. The Ngor monastery comprised ap-
proximately five hundred monks in permanent residence and num-
28
erous others who came to receive the teaching on the Path and Its Fruit
from all areas of Tibet.
Another Ngorpa seat was Tsedong, founded by Jamyang Namkha
Tashi in the female Earth Bird year of the eighth cycle (1489). Control
Yen. Phende Shabdrung Rinpoche (b. 1934) one of the four heads of the Ngorpa
branch of the Sakya tradition, and founder of E-wam Phende Ling in France
of this monastery was assumed by the Dunchod Dynasty. Great beings
such as Trichen o ~ a m Lhundrup visited it from time to time. Vajra-
dhara Ngawang Lodro Zhenphen Nyingpo Dampa Rinpoche, the great
twentieth century a b b ~ t of Ngor, gave the teaching on the sLob-bshad
of the Precious Word there.
29
Nalendra and Rongton Sheja Kunzig
The Nalendra monastery in Phenyul was founded by the omniscient
Rongtonpa Sheja Kunzig, one of the six of Tibet, in the
Wood Hare year of the seventh cycle (1435). This great lama was born
in the eastern country of Gyalmo Rong in 1367. He is recognized as an
authentic emanation of Ayra M aitreyanatha by the various prophecies
made about him and because he gave teachings in a way which re-
sembled Maitreya. He is also recognized as- the incarnation of num-
erous panditas from India and Tibet, including
having
said that he recalled this particular incarnation. He was learned in
numerous texts, his main teachers being Yak Mipham Choje, various
Tibetan scholars and Indian panditas. From the age of 22 until the age
of 84, dispensed the teaching with a clarity that delighted scholars.
His students included four pillars of the doctrine, eight ornaments of
the doctrine, three students whose level of understanding equalled that
of their teacher, seventeen students who clarified the doctrine, four
students, who achieved great fame and about six thousand students
who were guardians of the tripitaka.
In debate, he never lost the thread of the argument and he brought
great powers of profound teaching and logic to any discussion. Of the
many scholars in Tibet at that time, he was the most skilled in debate
and. could not be faulted. He was a 'liberating mine of wisdom'. He
his skill in the triple activity of teaching, debate and
composition in the numerous monastic universities such as that of
Sang-phu and the entire assembly of scholars and sages in the Land of
Snows honoured him with the name Rongton 'the Lion of Speech'. He
composed numerous treatises on practice, extraordinary commentaries
on forty great works as well as eulogies, explanations of various teach-
ings, commentaries on the tantras, and resumes on the significance of
sixty treatises. He was the author of more than 300 works, and embel-
Jished the Buddha's teaching with the garlands of his composition. He
manifested the truth of the dharmat1J by his power of emanation and
resurrection of the dead and his ability to fly like a bird. It is made clear
in his biography that he possessed all the marks of one who has rea-
lized the sixth bhumi. At the age of 84, he departed for the paradise of
30
Tushita as he had previously prophesied. His body was subsequently
mummified.
His heart-son, the onniscient Tashi Namgyal, gave teachings 32
times a day to different groups. He taught spontaneously, not finding it
necessary to prepare any explanations the night before. In debate, he
'pitted his wits' against numerous scholars and always emerged vic-
torious. He possessed the qualities of both scholar and siddha.
From the great Rongton to the seventh abbot, a period of twenty
years, there were approximately two to three thousand monks in the
forty-five houses at Nalendra. After this first period, numerous obsta-
cles arose and the number of monks fell to a thousand. When the mon-
astery reached its lowest ebb, Dagchen Lodro Gyaltshan invited Khy-
enrab Choje Rinpoche, an eminent sage who possessed the direct line-
age of the Kalachakra empowerment from Vajra Yogini to become the
eighth abbot of the monastery. From that time until the present day the
number of monks has never dropped below four hundred. This was a
college where the sutras and tantras were both taught and practised.
From Khyenrab Choje Rinpoche to Rinchen Khyentse Wangpo there
have been eighteen holders of the Nalendra throne, all from the divine
family of Che. The teaching lineage comprises twenty-six in all. Khy-
enrab Jampa's brother, the ninth in the line of the eighteen holders of
the throne, was the fourth incarnation in the Zimog
At Nalendra there was a college devoted to debate and a college dev-
oted to the practice of the tantras. There were many who displayed
signs of realization as a result of their tantric practices. This monastery
remained the most important seat of sutra and tantra studies right up
until the modern era. It contained a great assembly hall large enough
for 700 monks, two monks' colleges, five houses and three palaces; Its
affiliated monasteries, were numerous and ranged from Tsang to Am-
do.
The Tsang Deyul Kyetshal monastery was founded in the Earth Ser-
pent year ofthe eight cycle (1449) by Jamchen Rabjampa Sanjay Phel a
disciple of the great Rongton. It became a great centre for the teaching
of and had a college devoted to the three bases run by
Jamyang Kunga Chozang, a disciple of Jamchen. Thus the great as-
sembly of his students spread in all directions.
31
Among this great assembly of students was the omniscient Gorampa
Sonam Sengge the great sage learned in the sutras and tantras. In the
Earth Mouse year of the eighth cycle (1478), he restored the Tanag
Thubten Namgyal Ling monastery in Tsang to prosperity. This great
Lord of Dharma was born in the Earth Bird year of the seventh cycle
(1428). His teachers were the great Rongton and his students and
Ngorchen Kunga Zangpo. He reached the of knowledge,
spread the writings of the venerable patriarchs of the Sakyapa, estab-
lished a college at the great temple monasteries of Sakya and a great
many other monastic universities in addition to this.
One of Gorampa's principal disciples, Thuje Palzang founded the
Zay Thubten Yangchen monastery which was directed by Yangchen
Palzang an1 Panchen Ngakcho. Pandita Bumtrak Sumpa, one of Jam-
chen Rabjampa's principal students, founded the Nyengo Jago Shong
monastery. Ngodrup Palbar, one of Jamyang Kunga Chozang's prin-
cipal students, founded the Chokhor Lhunpo monastery. Panchen
Lhawang Lodro founded the Zhayri Kyetshal Ogma monastery. This
was a great college of metaphysics which had six subsidiaries, each of
which flourished in turn. Donyod Palway founded the Selung monas-
tery which was directed by Panchen Shakya Chogden one of Rongton's
principal students. Selung developed a great college of metaphysics
which became known as Thubten Serdochan. Panchen Shakya Chog-
deit restored the monastery of Langri Thangpa, the twelfth century
Kadampa master in the Phenyul area. The Zangden Chode monastery
in Tsang was founded by the venerable Kunpang Chodrak and it con-
tained numerous abbots who Pitaka-dharas. Each year this mon-
astery and its subsidiaries met for practice and teaching on the sutras
and tantras. thereby preserving the old tradition.
The monasteries of Muchen Khorlo Dompa in thearea of Mu were
Samling Takmo Ling and others. The Tsang Myangtod Shelkar Gy-
antse dharma centre in Tsang was founded by Rabten Kunzang. It con-
tained sixteen different colleges and flourished up until the present
era. In the same region were the morasteries of Rendawa, Sazang Ma-
ti, Tagtshang Lotsava and Sherab Rinchen. The Gangkar Dorjeden
monastery in the U province was founded by the Master of Tantra,
Kunga Namgyal in 1464. This master, born in 1442 was an unparallel-
32
Jed scholar and saint. At Gangkar Dorjedan he established the tradition
of recitation of different mandala rituals in accordance with the four or-
ders of tantra and the tradition of religious dance. He was protected by
the dharmapalas and was famed for his magical power. The Sakya
Dzong lineage has been uninterrupted and their tradltion of liberation
teaching remains unbroken in the present era.
The glorious Samye monastery was established by the abbot Shanta-
rakshita, the acharya Padma and the monarch Trisong. Detsun in the
eighth century and subsequently restored by Sakya Pandita, Sonam
Gyaltshan and Ngakchang Sakya Chenpo. The abbot of Samye was cus-
tomarily chosen by the Sakyapas. The Kyid Shong Rawa monastery
was directed by Tak Kunga Paljor. This monastery had two branches,
the Dophud Chokhor and the Shelgong branches which were both es-
tablished by Shelgrong Panchen Lodro Chokyi Gyalpo, student of the
great Rongton. The omniscient Tashi Namgyal founded the college at
Dakpo. Khyenrab Choje founded the Nyemo Cham monastery and Gazi
Shakya Lodro founded the Namgyal Serkhand monastery. At the Dath-
ang monastery where the great Uttaratantrashastra master, Dapa
Ngonshe resided in the twelfth century, Khaywang Tenzin. Phuntshok
later developed the Sakya, Ngorpa and Tsharpa streams of dharma.
Khache Panchen founded the Dachi Tshongday centre. Many other
monasteries, too numerous to mention, were established in the U and
Tsang provinces. These monasteries were 'like garlands of suns,
moons and stars', rejoicing in the Buddha's teachings.
The Tshar Tradition
The Dar Drangmochen monastery in Tsang was the residence of the
Tsharchen Vajradhara Losal Gyamtsho (b. 1494). Great beings 'mas-
ters of the ocean of sutra and tantra' directed this monastery from the
time ofTsharchen himself to the great abbot Ngawang Losal Phuntsok.
The abbot Yolwo Zhonnu Lodro, student of Tsharchen, founded the
Yarlung Tashi Chode Directed by unparallelled incarna-
tions, it became a great college of study and practice.
The Tsharpa tradition was famed for its transmission of the Thirteen
Teachings of Gold (gSer-chos teachings on the greater
and lesser Mahakala. The teachings had been through
33
Ngorchen and his principal disciples and through the divine Khon line.
They were passed on without interruption until Vajradhara Lodro Gy-
altshan gave them to Doringpa Kunpang Chenpo who received them in
the manner of a vase 'without holes'. He 'held aloft the banner of vic-
tory in practice' whilst in solitary retreat at Kha'u Drakdzong and ob-
tained the summit of realization.
Among Doringpa's numerous disciples, the Tsharchen dharmaraja,
Losal Gyamtsho was the tree of life of the doctrine of the oral lineage.
He was born in 1494 and came to possess all the virtues of scholar and
saint. He took monk's vows from the omniscient Gendun Gyamtsho,
the third hierarch of Drepung, and studied courses in at
the great monastery ofTashi Lhunpo where his.flawless understanding
resembling that of Shantideva, exhausted the other scholars. Through
dint of prayer he saw Vajra Yoginiwho commanded him to go to Kha'u
Drakdzong where he would receive the oral lineage of the esoteric
teachings from Doring Kunpang Chenpo. Tsharchen also subsequently
received countless other profound precepts. Through his practice he
obtained the signs of warmth of the Path of Application. Since Vajra
Yogini was his guardian, he obtained high levels of realization at Trop-
hu, Srinpori and in Phenyul. At Zhalu he ascended the throne of Buton
Rinpoche. He studied with sixty-three masters of the 'Ancient'
(Nyingma) and 'New' (gSar-ma) traditions without sectarian bias and
received all the profound teachings on practice that existed in the Land
of Snows at that time.
Tsharchen became the second 'Vajradhara of our age of discord',
having countless students in all schools. His two principal students
were Khyentse Wangchuk and the omniscient Ludrup Gyamtsho who
maintained the Tsharpa lineage. Furthermore, many of his students
obtained the siddhi of 'co-incidence' (gzung 'jug). In this way they held
the uninterrupted stream of precepts of the Tsharpa tradition.
Gonpo Sonam Chogden was the spiritual son of Wang-
chuk Rabten who was himself a direct student of Tsharchen. His two
principal students were Khyabdag Zhaluwa and the great fifth Dalai
Lama, Ngawang Lozang Gyamtsho (1617-1682). This was an epoch of
degradation for Tibet. After a difficult period, however, the great fifth
Dalai Lama was established as ruler and was able to govern during a
34
period of restored peace. He received detailed teachings on the slob-
bshad of the Precious Word and related works of the Cycle of the Path
(Lam-skor). The slob-bshad of the Path and Its Fruit then became his
principal practice. He composed a guide to it and compiled and pub-
lished biographies on the four Tibarpa lamas. In order to spread the
profound teachings of the slob-bshad, the fifth Dalai Lama invited
Zhalu Khenchen to come and teach it while he furnished provisions and
Ven Chogay Trichen Rinpoche (b.I920) Head of the Tsharpa Branch oftheSakya
Tradition
offerings for the teacher and students. He contributed much towards
the dissemination of this teaching, especially in the South.
Chogay Khenrab Jampa, the abbot of Nalendra, and Sachen Kunlo,
two of the four principal lamas, were among the students who received
35
the teaching on this occasion. It is as a result ofthe religious activity of
these four masters that the oral lineage of the sLob-bshad of the Path
and Its Fruit still survives today. It is as a result of the efforts of the
great fifth Daiai Laina that the Sakya and Ngorpa teachings have also
flourished within the different schools in Tibet.
Other Important Monasteries
Lhundrup Teng, a monastery in the Dege region of Kham was founded
by the great siddha Thangtong Gyalpo and the dharmaraja Tashi Chad-
yon. This great monastery included famous colleges of practice and
teaching as well as an important library and printing press where the
bKa - 'gyur. bsTan- 'gyur and various collected works were published.
Approximately 1700 monks lived there in permanent residence, Lhund-
rup Teng was the spiritual ct:adle of numerous scholars, amongst whom
was the great Zhuchen Mahapandita Tshultrim Rinchen. The Sakya,
Ngorpa and T:sharpa traditions oftextual recitation were all maintained
there.
Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo (1811-1892), the 'second Munindra of
this period of defilemen(, brought together the different sadhanas in
'The Collection of Sadhana (sGrub-thabs Kun-btus). In general, he
propagated the non-sectarian (ris-med) teachings of all schools laying
particular emphasis on the teachings of the Sakya. Ngor and Tshar. His
student Sangdag Lotcr Wangpo received all the teachings on Pramana,
Madhyamaka. Paramita, Abhidharma, Vinaya and the Trisanzvara
from the great abbot ofTanag, Mipham Sengge Rabgyay and Ngawang
Lekdrup Ponlop, the master of ceremonies at Ngor Ewam Choden, thus
following the tradition of the venerable patriarchs of the Sakya lineage.
He compiled the commentaries on the five groups of treatises and con-
tributed much to their dissemination: Loter Wangpo also brought to-
gether the secret teachings on all the texts on the great empower-
ments, guides, textual transmissions, oral traditons and commentarial
explanations of the tantras. These works were united in thirty-two vol-
umes under the title 'Collection of PreCious Tantras (rGyud-sde Rin-
po-che K un-ht us) and the survival of the tradition, intact, was thus en-
sured. He also compiled seventeen volumes oh the sLob-bshad of"the
36
Path and Its Fruit and did much to spread these teachings throughout
Tibet.
Loter Wangpo's chief student was the saintly being, Lord of the
Mandala, the Vajradhara Ngawang Lodro Zhenphen Nyingpo. He
taught the Path and Its Fruit in Tsang and had a great following of stu-
dents, many of whom are active at the present time.
Ven Karma Thinley Rinpoche (b. 1931) MasteroftheSakya.and Kagyu Traditions
of Tibetan Buddhism and Head of Sakya Thinley Rinchen Ling in the United
Kingdom
The Khyentse incarnation Chokyi Lodro (1894-1959) founded a col-
37
lege at Dzongsar Tashi Lhartse in the Dege area. The teachings of the
ighteen Famous Treatises of Sakya were studied here. In the context
of the non-sectarian (ris-med) movement, he founded a retreat centre
whose tradition was mainly Tsharpa. There were many monasteries in
the Dege area. The Tromdogon monastery in the Trom region was
founded by Gyalway Jangchub and housed more than one thousand
monks. The Dondrup Ling monastery known as 'the second Ewam' in
the Ga region was founded by Jampal Dorje. Its teaching and practice
colleges were well-known for their flawless discipline. Approximately
fifteen hundred monks resided at this monastery.
Jamgon Ngawang Lekpa (1864-1941) the student of Jamyang Khy-
entse, Jamgon