This document is the final report of the Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi, Kenya. It provides an analysis of Nairobi's current socioeconomic, urban, institutional, and infrastructure conditions. It examines the city's population and demographics, land use, urban services, related laws and regulations, existing master plans, and infrastructure projects by development partners. It also identifies constraints and planning issues facing the city in areas like land use, transportation, infrastructure, governance, socioeconomics, and environment. The report aims to inform the development of Nairobi's future vision, structure plan, and land use plan to guide its sustainable growth and development.
This document is the final report of the Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi, Kenya. It provides an analysis of Nairobi's current socioeconomic, urban, institutional, and infrastructure conditions. It examines the city's population and demographics, land use, urban services, related laws and regulations, existing master plans, and infrastructure projects by development partners. It also identifies constraints and planning issues facing the city in areas like land use, transportation, infrastructure, governance, socioeconomics, and environment. The report aims to inform the development of Nairobi's future vision, structure plan, and land use plan to guide its sustainable growth and development.
This document is the final report of the Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi, Kenya. It provides an analysis of Nairobi's current socioeconomic, urban, institutional, and infrastructure conditions. It examines the city's population and demographics, land use, urban services, related laws and regulations, existing master plans, and infrastructure projects by development partners. It also identifies constraints and planning issues facing the city in areas like land use, transportation, infrastructure, governance, socioeconomics, and environment. The report aims to inform the development of Nairobi's future vision, structure plan, and land use plan to guide its sustainable growth and development.
This document is the final report of the Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi, Kenya. It provides an analysis of Nairobi's current socioeconomic, urban, institutional, and infrastructure conditions. It examines the city's population and demographics, land use, urban services, related laws and regulations, existing master plans, and infrastructure projects by development partners. It also identifies constraints and planning issues facing the city in areas like land use, transportation, infrastructure, governance, socioeconomics, and environment. The report aims to inform the development of Nairobi's future vision, structure plan, and land use plan to guide its sustainable growth and development.
The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Final Report (Draft) LOCATION MAP EXECUTIVE SUMMARY TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES LIST OF FIGURES ABBREVIATIONS
TABLE OF CONTENTS Page PART-I : The Current Conditions CHAPTER 1 BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE ....................................................... 1-1 1.1 Background.............................................................................................................................. 1-1 1.2 Outline of the Project ............................................................................................................... 1-1 1.3 Project Area ............................................................................................................................. 1-2 1.4 Organizational Arrangements .................................................................................................. 1-3 1.4.1 Overall Organizational Arrangements ................................................................................ 1-3 1.4.2 Individual Organizational Arrangements ............................................................................ 1-4 1.4.3 List of Members for J CC, Working Group and Secretariat .............................................. 1-13 CHAPTER 2 SOCIO ECONOMIC AND URBAN CONDITIONS .............................. 2-1 2.1 Review of Current Natural and Socioeconomic Conditions .................................................... 2-1 2.1.1 Current Natural Conditions ................................................................................................ 2-1 2.1.2 Population and Demography .............................................................................................. 2-2 2.1.3 Socio-economy ................................................................................................................... 2-7 2.1.4 Current Environmental Status of Nairobi ......................................................................... 2-20 2.2 Review of Urban Conditions ................................................................................................. 2-26 2.2.1 Analysis of Present Land Use ........................................................................................... 2-26 2.2.2 Urban Services.................................................................................................................. 2-31 CHAPTER 3 INSTITUTION AND REGULATORY CONDITIONS .......................... 3-1 3.1 Review of Related Laws and Regulations ............................................................................... 3-1 3.1.1 Urban Planning ................................................................................................................... 3-1 3.1.2 Environment ..................................................................................................................... 3-12 3.1.3 Economy and Investment ................................................................................................. 3-14 3.1.4 Infrastructure .................................................................................................................... 3-17 3.2 Roles and Tasks of Related Organizations ............................................................................ 3-24 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. i Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 3.2.1 Urban Planning ................................................................................................................. 3-24 3.2.2 Environment ..................................................................................................................... 3-27 3.2.3 Economy and Investment ................................................................................................. 3-28 3.2.4 Infrastructure .................................................................................................................... 3-31 3.3 Review of Existing Urban Master Plans ................................................................................ 3-35 3.3.1 History of Nairobi ............................................................................................................. 3-35 3.3.2 History of Urban Planning of Nairobi .............................................................................. 3-36 3.3.3 Nairobi City Development Ordinances and Zones ........................................................... 3-42 3.3.4 Strategy and Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region ....................... 3-44 3.4 Human Resources Development ........................................................................................... 3-53 3.4.1 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 3-53 CHAPTER 4 INFRASTRUCTURE CONDITION AND DONOR ACTIVITIES .......... 4-1 4.1 Review of Related Projects by Development Partners ............................................................ 4-1 4.1.1 Multi-Sector Programme .................................................................................................... 4-1 4.1.2 Urban Transport .................................................................................................................. 4-4 4.1.3 Railway ............................................................................................................................. 4-13 4.1.4 Airport .............................................................................................................................. 4-15 4.1.5 Water Supply .................................................................................................................... 4-19 4.1.6 Storm Water Drainage and Sewerage ............................................................................... 4-20 4.1.7 Power Supply.................................................................................................................... 4-25 4.1.8 Solid Waste Management ................................................................................................. 4-26 4.1.9 Telecommunications ......................................................................................................... 4-27 4.2 Review of Current Infrastructure Conditions ........................................................................ 4-29 4.2.1 Urban Transport ................................................................................................................ 4-29 4.2.2 Railway ............................................................................................................................. 4-36 4.2.3 Airport .............................................................................................................................. 4-41 4.2.4 Water Supply .................................................................................................................... 4-44 4.2.5 Storm Water Drainage and Sewerage ............................................................................... 4-48 4.2.6 Power Supply.................................................................................................................... 4-53 4.2.7 Solid Waste Management ................................................................................................. 4-62 4.2.8 Telecommunications ......................................................................................................... 4-69 CHAPTER 5 CONSTRAINTS AND PLANNING ISSUES ........................................... 5-1 5.1 Overview of Constraints and Planning Issues ......................................................................... 5-1 5.2 Issues of 1973 Nairobi Strategic Plan ...................................................................................... 5-4 5.3 Sector Constraints and Planning Issues ................................................................................... 5-5 5.3.1 Constraints and Planning Issues for Land Use and Settlements ......................................... 5-5 5.3.2 Constraints and Planning Issues for Urban Transport ........................................................ 5-7 5.3.3 Constraints and Planning Issues for Infrastructure ........................................................... 5-10 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. ii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 5.3.4 Constraints and Planning Issues for Governance and Institution ..................................... 5-20 5.3.5 Constraints and Planning Issues for Socio-economy........................................................ 5-21 5.3.6 Constraints and Planning Issues for Environment ............................................................ 5-22 CHAPTER 6 DEVELOPMENT VISION, STRUCTURE PLAN AND LAND USE PLAN ............................................................................................................ 6-1 6.1 Socioeconomic Framework ..................................................................................................... 6-1 6.1.1 Future Population of Kenya, Nairobi City and its Environs ............................................... 6-1 6.1.2 Future Day-time Population of Nairobi City ...................................................................... 6-5 6.1.3 Future GDP per Capita of Kenya and Nairobi City ............................................................ 6-7 6.2 Development Visions ............................................................................................................... 6-7 6.2.1 Development Vision Formulation Procedure ..................................................................... 6-7 6.2.2 Development Visions in the Related Plans and Strategies ................................................. 6-8 6.2.3 Stakeholder Discussions on Development Vision ............................................................ 6-10 6.2.4 Vision for Nairobi City County 2030 ............................................................................... 6-12 6.3 Proposal and Discussion of Alternative Structure Plans........................................................ 6-13 6.3.1 Structure Plan Formulation Procedure ............................................................................. 6-13 6.3.2 Discussion of Alternative Prototypes of Structure Plans .................................................. 6-13 6.3.3 Stakeholder Discussions on Structure Plan ...................................................................... 6-14 6.3.4 Proposed Structure Plan ................................................................................................... 6-15 6.4 Formulation of Land Use Policy ........................................................................................... 6-18 6.4.1 Present Land Use and Buildings ....................................................................................... 6-18 6.4.2 Demand for Land Use ...................................................................................................... 6-18 6.4.3 Urban Characteristics and Zonal Considerations ........................................................... 6-22 6.4.4 Principal Policy for Land Use Plan 2030 ......................................................................... 6-26 6.4.5 Central Business District Development ............................................................................ 6-29 6.4.6 Sub-Centers Development Concept.................................................................................. 6-39 6.4.7 Priority Projects ................................................................................................................ 6-51
PART-II: The Master Plan CHAPTER 7 URBAN TRANSPORT DEVELOPMENT PLAN ................................... 7-1 7.1 Urban Transport ....................................................................................................................... 7-1 7.1.1 General ............................................................................................................................... 7-1 7.1.2 Outline of Traffic Surveys .................................................................................................. 7-2 7.1.3 Zoning and Survey Points .................................................................................................. 7-3 7.1.4 Person Trip Survey ............................................................................................................. 7-8 7.1.5 Formulation of Future Transport Demand ........................................................................ 7-12 7.1.6 Formulation of Future Transport Network ....................................................................... 7-16 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. iii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 7.1.7 Ideas for Additional Priority Project for Urban Transport ................................................ 7-47 7.2 Railway .................................................................................................................................. 7-52 7.2.1 Demand and Gap Analysis ................................................................................................... 7-52 7.2.2 Development Policy ......................................................................................................... 7-52 7.2.3 Priority Projects .................................................................................................................... 7-53 CHAPTER 8 URBAN INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY ........... 8-1 8.1 Water Supply ........................................................................................................................... 8-1 8.1.1 Demand and Gap Analysis ................................................................................................. 8-1 8.1.2 Development Policy ........................................................................................................... 8-7 8.1.3 Priority Project.................................................................................................................... 8-8 8.2 Storm Water Drainage and Sewerage .................................................................................... 8-10 8.2.1 Demand and Gap Analysis ............................................................................................... 8-10 8.2.2 Development Policy ......................................................................................................... 8-19 8.2.3 Priority Projects ................................................................................................................ 8-19 8.3 Power Supply......................................................................................................................... 8-24 8.3.1 Demand and Gap Analysis ............................................................................................... 8-24 8.3.2 Development Policy ......................................................................................................... 8-33 8.3.3 Priority Projects ................................................................................................................ 8-33 8.4 Solid Waste Management ...................................................................................................... 8-37 8.4.1 Demand and Gap Analysis ............................................................................................... 8-37 8.4.2 Development Policy ......................................................................................................... 8-41 8.4.3 Priority Projects ................................................................................................................ 8-44 8.5 Telecommunications .............................................................................................................. 8-51 8.5.1 Demand and Gap Analysis ............................................................................................... 8-51 8.5.2 Development Policy ......................................................................................................... 8-54 8.5.3 Priority Projects ................................................................................................................ 8-56 CHAPTER 9 CROSS CUTTING ISSUES....................................................................... 9-1 9.1 Governance and Institution ...................................................................................................... 9-1 9.1.1 Policy and Strategy for Institutions .................................................................................... 9-1 9.1.2 Capacity Development Plan ................................................................................................... 9-4 9.1.3 Priority Projects ................................................................................................................ 9-10 9.2 Industry Development ........................................................................................................... 9-11 9.2.1 Industrial Development Vision of Kenya for 2030 ........................................................... 9-11 9.2.2 Industrial Development of Nairobi toward 2030 .............................................................. 9-13 9.2.3 Prospects of Industrial Development in the Environs ...................................................... 9-29 9.2.4 Required Policy Measures and Expected Functions of Nairobi City County ................... 9-30 9.3 Urban Facilities ..................................................................................................................... 9-32 9.3.1 Demand and Gap Analysis ............................................................................................... 9-32 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. iv Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 9.3.2 Development Policy ......................................................................................................... 9-37 9.4 Geographic Information System (GIS) .................................................................................. 9-38 9.4.1 Background of the Issues .................................................................................................. 9-38 9.4.2 Situation of Nairobis GIS ................................................................................................ 9-38 9.4.3 Current Status of the GIS Data under NIUPLAN ............................................................ 9-42 9.4.4 Current Status of Database under NIUPLAN ................................................................... 9-45 9.4.5 The Management Proposal of GIS Data ........................................................................... 9-47 9.4.6 The Management Proposal of an Integrated GIS ............................................................. 9-47 9.4.7 Management Proposal for an Open policy on GIS data ....................................................... 9-49 CHAPTER 10 SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONSIDERATION .................. 10-1 10.1 Social and Environmental Consideration for Master Plan Formulation ................................ 10-1 10.1.1 Basic Policy for Social and Environmental Considerations for NIUPLAN ..................... 10-1 10.1.2 Requirement of Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) ............................................ 10-1 10.1.3 Framework of SEA Study for NIUPLAN ......................................................................... 10-2 10.2 SEA (Fundamental Version) .................................................................................................. 10-3 10.2.1 Development of Terms of Reference reflecting SEA Guideline ....................................... 10-3 10.2.2 NCC Internal Preparatory Meeting................................................................................... 10-5 10.2.3 Preliminary Stakeholder Meeting ..................................................................................... 10-5 10.3 County Government Act and Public Participation................................................................. 10-6 10.3.1 Development of Terms of Reference reflecting County Government Act ....................... 10-6 10.3.2 Public Advertisement ........................................................................................................ 10-7 10.3.3 Public Meeting.................................................................................................................. 10-8 10.3.4 Web Site Management ........................................................................................................ 10-9 10.3.5 Civic Education .............................................................................................................. 10-12 10.4 Analysis on Planning Alternatives (structure plan) ............................................................. 10-13 10.5 Integration of Public Comments in the Master Plan ............................................................ 10-17 10.6 Priority Project for Urban Environmental Sector ................................................................ 10-19 CHAPTER 11 PRIORITY PROGRAMS OF NIUPLAN ............................................. 11-1 11.1 J ustification of Priority Programs .......................................................................................... 11-1 11.2 Urban Development Program ................................................................................................ 11-4 11.2.1 CBD development program .............................................................................................. 11-4 11.2.2 Sub-centre Development Program (priority area) ............................................................ 11-5 11.2.3 Eastlands Urban Renewal Project..................................................................................... 11-5 11.3 Urban Transport Development Program ................................................................................ 11-6 11.3.1 Road network development program ............................................................................... 11-6 11.3.2 Public transport development program ............................................................................. 11-9 11.3.3 ITS development program .............................................................................................. 11-10 11.4 Infrastructure Development Program ................................................................................... 11-11 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. v Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 11.4.1 Water Supply ................................................................................................................... 11-11 11.4.2 Power .............................................................................................................................. 11-12 11.4.3 Telecommunications ....................................................................................................... 11-12 11.5 Environment Improvement Program ................................................................................... 11-13 11.5.1 Storm water drainage and sewerage ............................................................................... 11-13 11.5.2 Solid waste management ................................................................................................ 11-14 11.5.3 City-wide Air Quality Management Program ................................................................ 11-15 11.6 Urban Development Management Strengthening Program ................................................. 11-16 CHAPTER 12 CONCLSION AND RECOMMENDATION FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF THE MASTER PLAN ...................................................................... 12-1 12.1 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................. 12-1 12.2 Recommendation ................................................................................................................... 12-1
PART-III: Appendix
APPENDIX 1 CONTRACT AND MINUTES OF MEETING FOR INCEPTION MEETING APPENDIX 2 REVIEW OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT IN NEIGHBORING COUNTRIES APPENDIX 3 RESULTS OF TRAFFIC SURVEYS APPENDIX 4 FORMULATION OF FUTURE TRANSPORT DEMAND APPENDIX 5 PROGRESS OF ROAD DEVELOPMENT AFTER 2006 APPENDIX 6 STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT APPENDIX 7 TYPICAL CROSS SECTION
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. vi Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1.3.1 Location Map ............................................................................................................... 1-2 Figure 1.3.2 Greater Nairobi Boundary ............................................................................................ 1-3 Figure 1.4.1 Project Organization Chart Based on 1st RD ............................................................... 1-4 Figure 1.4.2 Project Organization Chart based on Revised RD ..................................................... 1-4 Figure 1.4.3 Tiers of Discussion Structure ....................................................................................... 1-5 Figure 2.1.1 Rainfall and Temperature in Nairobi City .................................................................... 2-2 Figure 2.1.2 Population Density per Hectare of Nairobi City in 2009 ............................................. 2-3 Figure 2.1.3 Average Annual Population Growth Rate of Nairobi City and its Environs in Greater Nairobi from 1999 to 2009 (%) .................................................................................... 2-3 Figure 2.1.4 Age Structure of Population of Kenya Showing Nairobi in 2009 ................................ 2-4 Figure 2.1.5 Age Structure of Population of Nairobi in 2009 .......................................................... 2-4 Figure 2.1.6 Nairobi's Age Structure Shifted by 10 Years from 1999 and Corresponding Actual Population in 2009 ....................................................................................................... 2-5 Figure 2.1.7 Percentage of Households of Ownership by Household Asset .................................... 2-7 Figure 2.1.8 Share of Individuals below Poverty Line ..................................................................... 2-8 Figure 2.1.9 Households by Main Source of Water and District ...................................................... 2-9 Figure 2.1.10 Households by Main Mode of Human Waste Disposal and District ............................ 2-9 Figure 2.1.11 Households by Main Type of Lighting Fuel and District ........................................... 2-10 Figure 2.1.12 Percentage of Households by Ownership of Household Assets and District ............. 2-10 Figure 2.1.13 Population and GNI per Capita in 2011 ..................................................................... 2-11 Figure 2.1.14 Wage Employment by Industry in 2011 (provisional) ............................................... 2-13 Figure 2.1.15 Estimated Distribution of Employees of Business Establishments Registered in the NCC ........................................................................................................................... 2-14 Figure 2.1.16 Comparison of GDP per Capita and Typical Labour Cost ......................................... 2-15 Figure 2.1.17 Gap Structure of Industries of Nairobi ....................................................................... 2-16 Figure 2.1.18 Doing Business Ranks of Kenya in 185 Economies in 2013 ..................................... 2-19 Figure 2.1.19 Creation of Urban Wind Path through Design of Sustainable Urban Land Use Pattern ............................................................................................. 2-25 Figure 2.2.1 Land Use Map Done by Columbia and Nairobi University. ...................................... 2-27 Figure 2.2.2 Satellite Image of Ridgeways Area ............................................................................ 2-27 Figure 2.2.3 Satellite Image of Kasarani, Dandora Area ................................................................ 2-28 Figure 2.2.4 Satellite Image of Kilimani Area................................................................................ 2-28 Figure 2.2.5 Satellite Image of Eastleigh South to Uhuru Estate ................................................... 2-28 Figure 2.2.6 Typical Development Pattern ..................................................................................... 2-30 Figure 3.1.1 Structure of Concerned Laws and Plans ...................................................................... 3-2 Figure 3.1.2 Land Control Scheme................................................................................................. 3-10 Figure 3.2.1 Organization Chart of NCC (Old system) .................................................................. 3-25 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. vii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Figure 3.2.2 NCC Land, Housing and Physical Planning Sector organogram (tentative) .............. 3-26 Figure 3.3.1 First Plan of Nairobi by A. F. Church in 1898 ........................................................... 3-37 Figure 3.3.2 Plan for Settler Capital in 1927 .................................................................................. 3-38 Figure 3.3.3 Master Plan for a Colonial Capital in 1948 ................................................................ 3-39 Figure 3.3.4 Recommended Distribution of Population in 2000 .................................................... 3-40 Figure 3.3.5 Nairobi Metropolitan Growth Strategy 1973 ............................................................. 3-42 Figure 3.3.6 Zone Map by J ST ....................................................................................................... 3-43 Figure 3.3.7 Hill Area Zoning Plan ................................................................................................ 3-43 Figure 3.3.8 Proposed Urban Settlements Pattern .......................................................................... 3-48 Figure 3.3.9 Location of New Town ............................................................................................... 3-48 Figure 3.3.10 Development Pattern, Settlement/Build Up 2009 & 2030 ......................................... 3-50 Figure 3.3.11 CBD of Nairobi City County ..................................................................................... 3-52 Figure 3.3.12 CBD and Its Linkage to Railway, Upper Hills ........................................................... 3-52 Figure 3.4.1 Relevance of Capacity Development Method ............................................................ 3-55 Figure 3.4.2 Capacity Development Issues .................................................................................... 3-59 Figure 3.4.3 Comparison between No Specific Target Groups and Specific Target Groups .......... 3-60 Figure 4.1.1 Location of Study Sections for A104 ........................................................................... 4-5 Figure 4.1.2 Typical Cross Section J KIA Haile Selassie Section .................................................. 4-5 Figure 4.1.3 Typical Cross Section from J ust Before Haile Selassie J unction to J ust after University Way J unction ................................................................................................................ 4-6 Figure 4.1.4 Typical Cross Section J ames Gichuru J unction Uthiru Section and Gitaru - Rironi Section.......................................................................................................................... 4-6 Figure 4.1.5 Proposed Stations in NRS-Ruiru Section ..................................................................... 4-7 Figure 4.1.6 Proposed Stations in NRS-Kikuyu Section .................................................................. 4-7 Figure 4.1.7 Nairobi-Thika Highway Improvement Project Location Map ..................................... 4-8 Figure 4.1.8 MRTS Corridors ......................................................................................................... 4-10 Figure 4.1.9 Road Network in Urban Area (Nairobi City) in 2005 ................................................ 4-11 Figure 4.1.10 Automated Ticket Gate (left) High Platform Construction (right) .......................... 4-14 Figure 4.1.11 Proposed Standard Gauge Railway Corridor from Nairobi to Dagoretti (Blue line) . 4-15 Figure 4.2.1 Road Network in Nairobi City ................................................................................... 4-31 Figure 4.2.2 Number of Lanes of Existing Roads .......................................................................... 4-33 Figure 4.2.3 The Road Length Density by Area of the Target Road Network ............................... 4-34 Figure 4.2.4 The Road Length Density by Population of the Target Road Network ...................... 4-34 Figure 4.2.5 Comparison of Travel Mode by Trip Purpose between 2004 Survey and 2013 Survey ................................................................................................................................... 4-36 Figure 4.2.6 Existing Track Condition (left), Existing Ruiru Station (right).................................. 4-36 Figure 4.2.7 KRC Existing and Planned Lines ............................................................................... 4-37 Figure 4.2.8 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of MRT on Thika Road ...................................... 4-38 Figure 4.2.9 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of MRT on J uja Road ......................................... 4-38 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. viii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Figure 4.2.10 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of LRT on J ogoo Road ....................................... 4-39 Figure 4.2.11 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of MRT on Ngong Road ..................................... 4-39 Figure 4.2.12 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of LRT on the Outer Ring Road ............................ 40 Figure 4.2.13 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of LRT on the Waiyaki Way ............................... 4-40 Figure 4.2.14 View of J KIA Terminal Area from Control Tower ..................................................... 4-41 Figure 4.2.15 View of J KIA Terminal Area from Control Tower ..................................................... 4-42 Figure 4.2.16 View of Wilson Airport Airlines Hanger and Taxiway from Control Tower ............. 4-43 Figure 4.2.17 Outline of Map of Water Supply to Nairobi City ....................................................... 4-45 Figure 4.2.18 General Layout of the Zones ...................................................................................... 4-47 Figure 4.2.19 Power Sector in Kenya ............................................................................................... 4-54 Figure 4.2.20 Classification of Power Plants by Installed Capacity ................................................. 4-56 Figure 4.2.21 Incidences per 1,000 Customers as on 29th April, 2013 ............................................ 4-58 Figure 4.2.22 Countermeasure for Vandalism .................................................................................. 4-58 Figure 4.2.23 Demand Forecast from 2010 to 2031 ......................................................................... 4-60 Figure 4.2.24 Least Cost Expansion Plan and Peak Demand ........................................................... 4-61 Figure 4.2.25 Solid Waste Flow in Nairobi County (2009) .............................................................. 4-62 Figure 4.2.26 Facilities related to Solid Waste Management ........................................................... 4-62 Figure 4.2.27 Organization Structure of Department of Environment ............................................. 4-63 Figure 4.2.28 Physical Composition of Water in Nairobi ................................................................. 4-64 Figure 4.2.29 Number of Fixed and Mobile Users in Kenya ........................................................... 4-70 Figure 4.2.30 Proportion of Fixed and Mobile Telephones in Kenya .............................................. 4-70 Figure 4.2.31 NOFBI coverage ........................................................................................................ 4-74 Figure 4.2.32 Percentage of Mobile Subscriptions among 4 Countries ........................................... 4-77 Figure 4.2.33 Percentage of Individual Internet Use among 4 Countries......................................... 4-77 Figure 4.2.34 Percentage of Fixed-telephone Subscriptions among 4 Countries ............................. 4-78 Figure 4.2.35 Penetration Ratio of Mobile Subscriptions in Kenya in a Global Comparison .......... 4-78 Figure 4.2.36 Penetration Ratio of Individual Internet Use in Kenya in a Global Comparison ....... 4-78 Figure 4.2.37 Penetration Ratio of Fixed-telephone Subscriptions in Kenya in a Global Comparison ................................................................................................................................... 4-79 Figure 4.2.38 Percentage of Household with Radio and Television among 4 Countries ................. 4-79 Figure 4.2.39 Price of Mobile-broadband Services, Early 2013 ...................................................... 4-81 Figure 5.1.1 Urban Planning Issues of Nairobi City ........................................................................ 5-2 Figure 5.1.2 Urban Transport Issues of Nairobi City ....................................................................... 5-3 Figure 5.1.3 Socio-Economic Issues of Nairobi City ....................................................................... 5-4 Figure 5.3.1 Existing Passenger Train Operation by RVR (left), Sample Photo of DMU (right) .... 5-9 Figure 5.3.2 Preliminary Identified Issues through the First Survey (Power Supply) .................... 5-15 Figure 5.3.3 Identified Issues through the Preliminary Identified Issues (Solid Waste Management) ................................................................................................................................... 5-16 Figure 5.3.4 Pull-based and Push-based Information Dissemination ............................................. 5-17 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. ix Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Figure 5.3.5 Constraints and Planning Issues for Telecommunications ......................................... 5-19 Figure 6.1.1 Estimation of Population of Kenya .............................................................................. 6-1 Figure 6.1.2 Alternative Scenarios of Population Estimation of Nairobi City ................................. 6-2 Figure 6.1.3 Area and Population Density of Selected Cities .......................................................... 6-4 Figure 6.2.1 Proposed Vision for Nairobi City County 2030 ......................................................... 6-12 Figure 6.3.2 Discussion Results ..................................................................................................... 6-15 Figure 6.3.3 Sub Centre System ..................................................................................................... 6-15 Figure 6.3.4 Road Network and Nodes .......................................................................................... 6-16 Figure 6.3.5 Railway and Road Transit Interchange ...................................................................... 6-16 Figure 6.3.6 Proposed Structure Plan for Nairobi .......................................................................... 6-17 Figure 6.4.1 Current Land Use ....................................................................................................... 6-18 Figure 6.4.2 Land Availability in Some Areas ................................................................................ 6-21 Figure 6.4.3 Cross-Sectional Profile of Nairobi ............................................................................. 6-22 Figure 6.4.4 Basic Urban Character ............................................................................................... 6-23 Figure 6.4.5 Land Availability in Some Areas ................................................................................ 6-23 Figure 6.4.6 CBD and Sub-centres ................................................................................................. 6-27 Figure 6.4.7 Ecological Environment in Nairobi ........................................................................... 6-28 Figure 6.4.8 Industrial Land Use Restructuring ............................................................................. 6-29 Figure 6.4.9 Boundaries of the CBDs ............................................................................................ 6-30 Figure 6.4.10 Survey Area (the Expanded CBD without Railway City) .......................................... 6-30 Figure 6.4.11 Floor Use Distribution ............................................................................................... 6-31 Figure 6.4.12 Consuming Plot Ratio of Each Zone in the Expanded CBD ...................................... 6-32 Figure 6.4.13 Low-utilized Open-Air Parking and Roadside Parking in the CBD .......................... 6-34 Figure 6.4.14 Development Vision of CBD ..................................................................................... 6-35 Figure 6.4.15 Area of the Greater CBD ........................................................................................... 6-36 Figure 6.4.16 Road Network of the Greater CBD ............................................................................ 6-37 Figure 6.4.17 Land Use Concept of the Greater CBD ...................................................................... 6-38 Figure 6.4.18 Spatial Development Plan for the Greater CBD ........................................................ 6-39 Figure 6.4.19 Key issues in Upper Hill South .................................................................................. 6-41 Figure 6.4.20 Proposed Urban Function Structure in Upper Hill South........................................... 6-42 Figure 6.4.21 Key issues in Upper Hill South .................................................................................. 6-43 Figure 6.4.22 Proposed Urban Function Structure in Upper Hill South........................................... 6-43 Figure 6.4.23 Key issues in Upper Hill South .................................................................................. 6-44 Figure 6.4.24 Proposed Urban Function Structure in Upper Hill South........................................... 6-45 Figure 6.4.25 Key issues in Dandora................................................................................................ 6-45 Figure 6.4.26 Suitable land for development in Dandora ................................................................. 6-46 Figure 6.4.27 Proposed Urban Function Structure in Dandora ........................................................ 6-46 Figure 6.4.28 Key issues in Imara-Daima ........................................................................................ 6-47 Figure 6.4.29 Proposed Urban Function Structure in Imara-Daima ................................................. 6-48 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. x Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Figure 6.4.30 Key issues in Makadara ............................................................................................. 6-49 Figure 6.4.31 Proposed Urban Function Structure in Makadara ...................................................... 6-49 Figure 6.4.32 Key issues in Kasarani ............................................................................................... 6-50 Figure 6.4.33 Key issues in Ruai ...................................................................................................... 6-51 Figure 6.4.34 Development Image of Railway City ......................................................................... 6-52 Figure 6.4.35 Implementation Framework for the Railway City Project ......................................... 6-52 Figure 6.4.36 Conversion of the Development Right ....................................................................... 6-53 Figure 7.1.1 Procedure for Urban Transport Development Plan ...................................................... 7-1 Figure 7.1.2 Traffic Survey Schedule ............................................................................................... 7-3 Figure7.1.3 Zone Map inside the City of Nairobi ........................................................................... 7-4 Figure7.1.4 Zone Map around the City of Nairobi .......................................................................... 7-4 Figure 7.1.5 Zone Map outside the City of Nairobi ......................................................................... 7-5 Figure 7.1.6 Traffic Survey Point in Nairobi Urban Area ................................................................ 7-6 Figure 7.1.7 Traffic Survey Point in Nairobi Urbanised Area .......................................................... 7-6 Figure 7.1.8 Location of Public Transport User Survey ................................................................... 7-7 Figure 7.1.9 Routes of Travel Speed Survey .................................................................................... 7-7 Figure 7.1.10 Trip Rate per Person by Car-ownership ....................................................................... 7-9 Figure 7.1.11 Trip Rate per Person by Occupation ............................................................................ 7-9 Figure 7.1.12 Comparison of Trip Rate between 2004 and 2013 ....................................................... 7-9 Figure 7.1.13 Trip Generation by Trip Purpose in 2004 and 2013 ................................................... 7-10 Figure 7.1.14 Person Trip Movement in a Wider Area in 2004 and 2013 ........................................ 7-10 Figure 7.1.15 Person Trip Desire Line inside Nairobi City in 2004 ................................................. 7-10 Figure 7.1.16 Person Trip Desire Line inside Nairobi City in 2013 ................................................. 7-11 Figure 7.1.17 Travel Mode Composition by Trip Purpose ............................................................... 7-11 Figure 7.1.18 Comparison of Number of Trips by Travel Mode between 2013 and 2004 ............... 7-12 Figure 7.1.19 Comparison of Composition of Travel Mode between 2013 and 2004 ..................... 7-12 Figure 7.1.20 Flow of Four-Step-Method ........................................................................................ 7-13 Figure 7.1.21 Vehicle Assignment Result in Existing Case (2013) .............................................. 7-15 Figure 7.1.22 Vehicle Assignment Result in Do-Nothing Case (2030) ........................................ 7-15 Figure 7.1.23 Recommended Road Development by the 2006 M/P (NUTRANS) .......................... 7-18 Figure 7.1.24 Progress of Road Development after 2006 M/P......................................................... 7-19 Figure 7.1.25 Future Road Network (2030) ..................................................................................... 7-20 Figure 7.1.26 Classification of Future Road Network (2030) .......................................................... 7-21 Figure 7.1.27 Railway Network in Alternative 2.............................................................................. 7-25 Figure 7.1.28 Public Transport Network in Alternative 3 ................................................................ 7-30 Figure 7.1.29 Vehicle Assignment Result of Alternative 0 in 2030 .............................................. 7-31 Figure 7.1.30 Railway Passenger Assignment Result of Alternative 2 in 2030 ............................ 7-31 Figure 7.1.31 Vehicle Assignment Result of Alternative 3 in 2030 .............................................. 7-32 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xi Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Figure 7.1.32 Public Transport (Railway, BRT and LRT) Passenger Assignment Result of Alternative 3 in 2030 .............................................................................................. 7-32 Figure 7.1.33 Modal Share by Alternatives in 2030 ......................................................................... 7-33 Figure 7.1.34 Road Length Distribution by VCR in Nairobi City ................................................... 7-34 Figure 7.1.35 Road Network in Short Term (2018) .......................................................................... 7-36 Figure 7.1.36 Road Network in Medium Term (2023) ..................................................................... 7-38 Figure 7.1.37 Public Transport Network in Medium Term (2023) ................................................... 7-38 Figure 7.1.38 Road Network in Long Term (2030) .......................................................................... 7-40 Figure 7.1.39 Public Transport Network in Long Term (2030) ........................................................ 7-40 Figure 7.1.40 Vehicle Assignment Result of Short Term Plan in 2018 ............................................ 7-41 Figure 7.1.41 Vehicle Assignment Result of Medium Term Plan in 2023 ....................................... 7-42 Figure 7.1.42 Public Transport (Railway and BRT) Passenger Assignment Result of Medium Term Plan in 2023 ............................................................................................................... 7-42 Figure 7.1.43 Vehicle Assignment Result of Long Term Plan in 2030 ............................................ 7-43 Figure 7.1.44 Public Transport (Railway, BRT and LRT) Passenger Assignment Result of Long Term Plan in 2030 ............................................................................................................... 7-43 Figure 7.1.45 Modal Share in Short, Medium and Long Term ........................................................ 7-44 Figure 7.1.46 Road Length Distribution by VCR in Short, Medium and Long Term Nairobi City . 7-45 Figure 7.1.47 Rotes of Viaduct-1 and Viaduct-2 .............................................................................. 7-48 Figure 7.1.48 Route of Widening of Enterprise Road ...................................................................... 7-49 Figure 7.1.49 Supposed Route of Northern Part of Circumferential Road C-2 ................................ 7-50 Figure 7.1.50 Project Area of Creation of ITS City.......................................................................... 7-51 Figure 7.2.1 Commuter Train Operation by RVR .......................................................................... 7-52 Figure 7.2.2 Planned MRTS Corridors ........................................................................................... 7-53 Figure 7.2.3 Existing KRL Lines and Planned MRT/LRT Lines ................................................... 7-54 Figure 7.2.4 Ring Line circulating CBD and Sub-Centres ............................................................. 7-55 Figure 8.1.1 General Layout of the Existing and Planned Facilities ................................................ 8-5 Figure 8.1.2 Comparison of the Water Demand and Capacity of Water Supply .............................. 8-6 Figure 8.2.1 River and Localized Drainage Network ..................................................................... 8-12 Figure 8.2.2 Comparison of Population Projections ....................................................................... 8-12 Figure 8.2.3 Comparison of Water Demand Projections ................................................................ 8-13 Figure 8.2.4 Comparison of Sewerage Generation Estimates ........................................................ 8-13 Figure 8.2.5 Comparison of Required Sewerage Treatment Capacity Estimates ........................... 8-14 Figure 8.2.6 Development of Sewerage Treatment Works ............................................................. 8-15 Figure 8.2.7 Planned Development of Dandora Estate STW ......................................................... 8-15 Figure 8.2.8 Existing and Planned Development of Trunk Sewers ................................................ 8-17 Figure 8.2.9 Estimate of Present Sewerage Generation, Collection and Conveyance ................... 8-18 Figure 8.3.1 Demand Forecast of Kenya by 2030 .......................................................................... 8-25 Figure 8.3.2 Demand Forecast of NCC Compared with the Project and the LCPDP .................... 8-26 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Figure 8.3.3 The Land around Dandora Station ............................................................................. 8-27 Figure 8.3.4 The Definition of Wayleaves ...................................................................................... 8-28 Figure 8.3.5 Comparison of Wayleaves between Kenya and J apan ............................................... 8-28 Figure 8.3.6 Comparison of Side Clearance ................................................................................... 8-29 Figure 8.3.7 GIS data of Kenya Power ........................................................................................... 8-31 Figure 8.3.8 Combination of GIS data of Kenya Power and J ST ................................................... 8-32 Figure 8.3.9 The data of Power Facilities in Embakasi .................................................................. 8-32 Figure 8.3.10 Current Wayleaves of Transmission Line .................................................................. 8-35 Figure 8.3.11 The Latest LCPDP ..................................................................................................... 8-35 Figure 8.3.12 Proposed Industry area along the Kangundo Road in Dandora ................................. 8-36 Figure 8.4.1 Projected Waste Generation Amount based on Population ........................................ 8-37 Figure 8.4.2 Map of Each Collection Zone .................................................................................... 8-38 Figure 8.4.3 Estimated Solid Waste Projection .............................................................................. 8-38 Figure 8.4.4 Estimated Solid Waste Projection .............................................................................. 8-40 Figure 8.4.5 Estimated Solid Waste Projection in 2023 ................................................................. 8-41 Figure 8.4.6 Estimated Solid Waste Projection in 2030 ................................................................. 8-41 Figure 8.4.7 Candidate Sites of New Landfill Site and Restriction Area ....................................... 8-46 Figure 8.4.9 Image of Landfill Operation Options ......................................................................... 8-46 Figure 8.4.8 Image of Cell Method Operation ............................................................................... 8-46 Figure 8.4.10 Layout Plan of Decommissioning of the Dandora Dump Site ................................... 8-47 Figure 8.4.11 Image of Operation of MRF ....................................................................................... 8-48 Figure 8.4.12 Collection Zone and Proposed Four Areas for Transportation System ...................... 8-49 Figure 8.4.13 Proposed Collection Methods and Equipment ........................................................... 8-50 Figure 8.4.14 Image of Future Institutional System for SWM ......................................................... 8-51 Figure 8.5.1 Mobile Phone Penetration Ratio of African Countries ............................................... 8-52 Figure 8.5.2 Penetration of Internet Use of Developed Countries ................................................. 8-53 Figure 8.5.3 Penetration of Internet Use of Nordic Countries ........................................................ 8-53 Figure 8.5.4 International Communication Bandwidth Capacity Demand .................................... 8-54 Figure 8.5.5 Conceptual Diagram of the Telecommunications Network ....................................... 8-57 Figure 8.5.6 Network Construction Plan ........................................................................................ 8-57 Figure 8.5.7 Network Construction Plan ........................................................................................ 8-59 Figure 8.5.8 Conceptual Diagram of a Dedicated Government Network for Government Offices8-60 Figure 8.5.9 Conceptual Diagram of the Disaster Information Gathering and Dissemination System ................................................................................................................................... 8-61 Figure 8.5.10 Cyber Security ........................................................................................................... 8-62 Figure 8.5.11 Upgraded National Addressing System ..................................................................... 8-64 Figure 8.5.12 Framework on Construction Supervision and Maintenance Works ........................... 8-66 Figure 9.1.1 Institutional Framework to be Developed .................................................................... 9-1 Figure 9.1.2 Overview of Development Control Mechanism .......................................................... 9-2 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xiii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Figure 9.1.3 Image of Land Re-adjustment Project .......................................................................... 9-3 Figure 9.1.4 Framework of Capacity Development Plan ................................................................. 9-5 Figure 9.1.5 Relation between Goal and Approaches of Capacity Development Plan ..................... 9-7 Figure 9.2.1 Correspondence between Priorities of Kenya and Nairobi ........................................ 9-15 Figure 9.2.2 Expected Structure of Industries of Nairobi in 2030 ............................................................. 9-16 Figure 9.2.3 Expected Scenario of Employment Distribution by Type of Industry ................................... 9-17 Figure 9.2.4 Market Locations ................................................................................................................... 9-21 Figure 9.2.5 School Locations .................................................................................................................... 9-25 Figure 9.2.6 Location-specific Agenda for Industrial and Tourism Development ..................................... 9-28 Figure 9.2.7 District Demarcation in the Environs of Nairobi City within Greater Nairobi ...................... 9-29 Figure 9.3.1 Map Showing Shortage of Primary Schools .......................................................................... 9-33 Figure 9.3.2 Map Showing Shortage of Secondary Schools in Nairobi ..................................................... 9-34 Figure 9.3.3 Map Showing Distribution of Universities in Nairobi ........................................................... 9-35 Figure 9.3.4 Map Showing Proposed Fire Stations .................................................................................... 9-36 Figure 9.3.5 Map Showing Shortage of Community Facilities .................................................................. 9-37 Figure 9.4.1 The Difference between the Satellite Image .......................................................................... 9-39 Figure 9.4.2 Topographic GIS Map (1:5000) ............................................................................................. 9-40 Figure 9.4.3 Census Map 2009 ................................................................................................................... 9-41 Figure 9.4.4 Land Use Map from Columbia University............................................................................. 9-41 Figure 9.4.5 Cadastral Map (held by Nairobi City) .................................................................................... 9-42 Figure 9.4.6 Aerial Photos of Nairobi ........................................................................................................ 9-43 Figure 9.4.7 Fair Consistency between the Imagery and Land Use, the Buildings, Roads Shape File ...... -944 Figure 9.4.8 Land Use Map ........................................................................................................................ -944 Figure 9.4.9 Image of Integrated GIS ......................................................................................................... 9-48 Figure 9.4.10 Cooperation with External OrganizationsSharing Data ............................................... 9-48 Figure 9.4.11 Image of an Open Type GIS ................................................................................................. 9-49 Figure 10.1.1 SEA Implementation Framework ......................................................................................... 10-2 Figure 10.3.1 Website Architecture .......................................................................................................... 10-10 Figure 10.3.2 Front Page of Website of NIUPLAN ................................................................................. 10-10 Figure 10.3.3 Monthly Website Visit Numbers ........................................................................................ 10-12 Figure 10.3.4 Photo Records of Civic Education ..................................................................................... 10-12 Figure 10.3.5 Daily Visitors Number of Civic Education ........................................................................ 10-13 Figure 11.1.1 Priority Program Structure ................................................................................................... 11-2
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xiv Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya LIST OF TABLES
Table 1.3.1 Greater Nairobi (Division list) ..................................................................................... 1-3 Table 1.4.1 J CC Meeting Record .................................................................................................... 1-5 Table 1.4.2 Thematic Working Group............................................................................................. 1-6 Table 1.4.3 Technical Working Group Meeting Record ................................................................. 1-6 Table 1.4.4 Secretariat Meeting Record ........................................................................................ 1-13 Table 1.4.5 J CC Members ............................................................................................................. 1-13 Table 1.4.6 NIUPLAN Secretariat ................................................................................................ 1-14 Table 1.4.7 Technical Working Group Members .......................................................................... 1-15 Table 2.1.1 Population, Area and Density of Nairobi and its Environs in 2009 ............................. 2-2 Table 2.1.2 Distribution of Enrolment of Primary Schools, Pre-Schools, Special Units and Secondary Schools in Nairobi City by Division in 2012 (Preliminary) ....................... 2-6 Table 2.1.3 Position of Nairobi in Comparison with Kenya ........................................................... 2-7 Table 2.1.4 References and their Implications ................................................................................ 2-8 Table 2.1.5 Definitions of Four Districts in Nairobi according to 2009 Census ............................. 2-9 Table 2.1.6 GDP Shares in 2011 (provisional) .............................................................................. 2-12 Table 2.1.7 Real GDP Growth Rates in 2011 (provisional) .......................................................... 2-12 Table 2.1.8 Shares in Export in 2011 (provisional) ...................................................................... 2-12 Table 2.1.9 Growth Rates in Export in 2011 (provisional) ........................................................... 2-12 Table 2.1.10 General Issues and Directions for Improvement of Industries in Nairobi City (1/2) . 2-14 Table 2.1.10 General Issues and Directions for Improvement of Industries in Nairobi City (2/2) . 2-15 Table 2.1.11 Some Causes for Lack of Public Safety and Candidate Measures ............................. 2-16 Table 2.1.12 Gini Index of Selected Countries ............................................................................... 2-17 Table 2.1.13 Doing Business Ranks of Kenya in 185 Economies in 2013 ..................................... 2-20 Table 2.1.14 Environmental Issues of Nairobi ................................................................................ 2-21 Table 2.1.15 Top Ten Major Causes of Mortality in Nairobi (1998- 2000) .................................... 2-24 Table 2.2.1 Land Use by Land Hold in Nairobi ............................................................................ 2-26 Table 2.2.2 Land Use Composition............................................................................................... 2-26 Table 2.2.3 Number of Schools and Students in Primary Schools in Nairobi, 2012 .................... 2-31 Table 2.2.4 Percentage of Type of Schools by District in Nairobi, 2012 ...................................... 2-31 Table 2.2.5 Type of Health Care Providers Preferred by Sick Population in Nairobi ................... 2-32 Table 2.2.6 Number of Major Health Facilities by District .......................................................... 2-32 Table 2.2.7 Beds/1,000 people for All Health Facilities by District ............................................. 2-32 Table 2.2.8 Stadiums and Sport Facilities ..................................................................................... 2-33 Table 2.2.9 Public Playgrounds .................................................................................................... 2-33 Table 2.2.10 Community Centers by District and Capacity ........................................................... 2-33 Table 2.2.11 Types and Capacity of City Council Markets by Ward .............................................. 2-34 Table 3.1.1 Management of Urban Development ........................................................................... 3-3 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xv Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.1.2 Maximum Permissible Noise Levels (Leq) ................................................................ 3-13 Table 3.2.1 Ministries Related to Urban Planning (Old Structure) ............................................... 3-25 Table 3.2.2 Ministries Related to Urban Planning (New Structure) ............................................. 3-25 Table 3.2.3 Tasks of Sections in City Planning Department ......................................................... 3-26 Table 3.3.1 Historical Change of Population of Nairobi ............................................................... 3-36 Table 3.3.2 Part of Nairobi City Development Ordinances and Zones ......................................... 3-44 Table 3.3.3 Delineation of the Nairobi Metro Boundary .............................................................. 3-45 Table 3.3.4 Population of NMR .................................................................................................... 3-47 Table 3.3.5 Settlement Hierarchy of NMR ................................................................................... 3-47 Table 3.3.6 List of New Towns Proposed ..................................................................................... 3-49 Table 3.3.7 Proposed Land Use Classification ............................................................................. 3-50 Table 3.3.8 Proposed Urban Land Use Classification for NMR and Distribution for Nairobi City County ........................................................................................................................ 3-51 Table 3.4.1 Number of Officials and Training Needs ................................................................... 3-54 Table 3.4.2 Number of Employee in City Planning Dept. CCN ................................................... 3-54 Table 3.4.3 Critical Skills Identified in Sample Survey ................................................................ 3-55 Table 3.4.4 Overview of Capacity Assessment Results ................................................................ 3-56 Table 3.4.5 Strong and Weak Category of Skills by Section ........................................................ 3-57 Table 3.4.6 Strong and Weak Skills by Section ............................................................................ 3-57 Table 3.4.7 Fundamental Skills to be Acquired ............................................................................ 3-61 Table 4.1.1 Studies Conducted on A104 by KeNHA ...................................................................... 4-5 Table 4.1.2 Results of Economic Evaluation ................................................................................ 4-10 Table 4.1.3 The Staging Plan Proposed in the Master Plan and its Current Progress. .................. 4-12 Table 4.1.4 Chinese Assistance of Road Development in Nairobi ............................................... 4-13 Table 4.1.5 On-going Projects Relevant to Infrastructure Development for Storm Water Drainage and Sewerage in Nairobi City .................................................................................... 4-20 Table 4.1.6 Major Infrastructure Developments for Wastewater and Sanitation Facilities in Nairobi City under the WaSSIP ............................................................................................... 4-21 Table 4.1.7 Major On-going Infrastructure Developments in Nairobi City under the Sewerage Improvement Project .................................................................................................. 4-25 Table 4.1.8 Power Sector Projects ................................................................................................ 4-25 Table 4.2.1 Summary of Road Classification in Kenya Road Classification Manual................... 4-29 Table 4.2.2 Classified Roads in Nairobi and Their Functions ...................................................... 4-30 Table 4.2.3 Major Facilities of J KIA ............................................................................................ 4-42 Table 4.2.4 Major Facilities of Wilson Airport ............................................................................. 4-43 Table 4.2.5 Existing Water Resources of Water Supply for Nairobi City ..................................... 4-44 Table 4.2.6 Existing Facilities of Sasumua System ...................................................................... 4-44 Table 4.2.7 Existing Facilities of Ruiru System............................................................................ 4-44 Table 4.2.8 Existing Facilities of Mwagu System ........................................................................ 4-45 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xvi Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.2.9 Existing Facilities of Kikuyu System ......................................................................... 4-45 Table 4.2.10 Zones of the Distribution System in Nairobi City...................................................... 4-46 Table 4.2.11 Operating Conditions of Existing Major STPs in Nairobi City ................................. 4-51 Table 4.2.12 Power Demand and Supply in Kenya ........................................................................ 4-55 Table 4.2.13 Power Demand and Supply in Nairobi Region .......................................................... 4-55 Table 4.2.14 Sales for Type of Customers Covered by Tariff ......................................................... 4-56 Table 4.2.15 Power-Generating Facilities ....................................................................................... 4-57 Table 4.2.16 Daily Monitoring of Blackout Incidence ................................................................... 4-58 Table 4.2.17 Underground Cable Projects ...................................................................................... 4-58 Table 4.2.18 Retail Electricity Tariffs Structure ............................................................................. 4-59 Table 4.2.19 Number of Staff in each Section ................................................................................ 4-63 Table 4.2.20 Amount of Waste Generation ..................................................................................... 4-64 Table 4.2.21 Collection System in Nairobi county ......................................................................... 4-65 Table 4.2.22 Collected Waste in Nairobi ........................................................................................ 4-65 Table 4.2.23 Amount of Recyclable ............................................................................................... 4-66 Table 4.2.24 Dumping Sites in Nairobi County .............................................................................. 4-67 Table 4.2.25 Financial Condition of CCN and DOE ...................................................................... 4-68 Table 4.2.26 Subscriptions of Internet Users .................................................................................. 4-71 Table 4.2.27 Subscriptions of Broadband Services ......................................................................... 4-71 Table 4.2.28 Penetration Ratio of Telecommunications in Nairobi City and the Provinces ........... 4-71 Table 4.2.29 Major Operator ........................................................................................................... 4-72 Table 4.2.30 Number of Licensed Postal and Courier Operators ................................................... 4-73 Table 4.2.31 Number of ICT equipment and Computer User ......................................................... 4-74 Table 4.2.32 Minimum Broadband Speed ...................................................................................... 4-75 Table 4.2.33 Broadband Penetration Targets .................................................................................. 4-76 Table 4.2.34 Key Outputs and Outcomes ....................................................................................... 4-76 Table 4.2.35 Number of Licensed Posta and Courier Operators among 4 Counties ....................... 4-80 Table 5.3.1 Major Telecommunications Indicators ....................................................................... 5-17 Table 6.1.1 Alternative Scenarios of Population Estimation of Nairobi City ................................. 6-3 Table 6.1.2 Comparison of Nairobi Citys Annual Average Growth Rate and Population Density in 2030 ............................................................................................................................. 6-4 Table 6.1.3 Estimation of Cross-border Commuters in 2013.......................................................... 6-6 Table 6.1.4 Estimation of Employees and J obs in Nairobi City ................................................... -6-6 Table 6.1.5 Estimation of Day-time Population in Nairobi City ..................................................... 6-7 Table 6.1.6 Alternative Cases of Future GDP per Capita of Kenya and Nairobi City .................... 6-7 Table 6.3.1 Comparison of Types of Structure Plan ..................................................................... 6-13 Table 6.4.1 Conditions for Capacity Estimation ........................................................................... 6-19 Table 6.4.2 Employment Estimation for 2030 .............................................................................. 6-20 Table 6.4.3 Zonal Considerations of Large Land Occupants ........................................................ 6-21 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xvii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 6.4.4 Obstacle Lands for Urban Planning ........................................................................... 6-24 Table 6.4.5 Zonal Considerations ................................................................................................. 6-24 Table 6.4.6 Principal Policy for Nairobi Land Use Plan ............................................................... 6-27 Table 6.4.7 GC and PR in the Expanded CBD ............................................................................. 6-31 Table 6.4.8 Comparison between Development Ordinance and Ground Situation ...................... 6-32 Table 6.4.9 Remaining Developable Floor Area ........................................................................... 6-32 Table 6.4.10 Estimation of Value at Real Estate Market for Rent in the CBD ............................... 6-33 Table 6.4.11 Estimation of the Number of the Parking Spaces in the CBD ................................... 6-34 Table 6.4.12 Comparison between J apanese and Kenyan Parking Regulation ............................... 6-34 Table 6.4.13 Process of Discussion about Development Visions in Thematic Working Group...... 6-35 Table 6.4.14 Priority of Sub-Centres Development ........................................................................ 6-40 Table 7.1.1 Summary of Traffic Survey .......................................................................................... 7-2 Table 7.1.2 Total Number of Traffic Zones..................................................................................... 7-3 Table 7.1.3 Interview Items in Household Interview Survey.......................................................... 7-8 Table 7.1.4 Increase in Population, Household and Trip Generation from 2004 to 2013 ............... 7-9 Table 7.1.5 Number of trips by Trip Purpose by Travel Mode ..................................................... 7-12 Table 7.1.6 Primary Indices by Vehicle Assignment Results in Existing Case and Do-Nothing Case ................................................................................................................................... 7-14 Table 7.1.7 Road Classification and Definition ............................................................................ 7-21 Table 7.1.8 Summary of Existing Public Transport Network Plan ............................................... 7-22 Table 7.1.9 Summary of Alternative Case .................................................................................... 7-24 Table 7.1.10 Evaluation of Priority of MRTS Corridors ................................................................. 7-26 Table 7.1.11 Selection of Mode for MRTS Corridors ..................................................................... 7-28 Table 7.1.12 Number of Trips by Mode by Alternative Case in 2030 ............................................ 7-33 Table 7.1.13 Major Indices by Vehicle Traffic Assignment ............................................................ 7-34 Table 7.1.14 Road Length Distribution by VCR in Nairobi City ................................................... 7-34 Table 7.1.15 Strategy for Staging Plan of Urban ............................................................................ 7-35 Table 7.1.16 Road Development Length in Sort Term (-2018) ...................................................... 7-36 Table 7.1.17 Road Development Length in Medium Term (-2023) ................................................ 7-37 Table 7.1.18 Road Development Length in Long Term .................................................................. 7-39 Table 7.1.19 Number of Trips by Mode in Short, Medium and Long Term ................................... 7-44 Table 7.1.20 Major Indices by Vehicle Traffic Assignment in Nairobi City ................................... 7-44 Table 7.1.21 Road Length Distributions by VCR in Short, Medium and Long Term in Nairobi City ................................................................................................................................... 7-45 Table 7.2.1 Existing condition of Planned MRT/LRT Routes ...................................................... 7-54 Table 8.1.1 Population Projection of Nairobi City.......................................................................... 8-1 Table 8.1.2 Basis of the Residential Water Demand from the WRMA Guidelines ......................... 8-1 Table 8.1.3 Ratio of the High, Medium and Low Class Housing ................................................... 8-2 Table 8.1.4 Ratio of the High, Medium and Low Class Housing ................................................... 8-2 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xviii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 8.1.5 Residential Unit Demand without Water Loss ............................................................. 8-2 Table 8.1.6 Industrial Demand ........................................................................................................ 8-3 Table 8.1.7 Water Demand of Nairobi City .................................................................................... 8-3 Table 8.1.8 Water Demand of FSMPDNS ...................................................................................... 8-4 Table 8.1.9 Recommended Water Resources Development Plan of Nairobi City .......................... 8-4 Table 8.1.10 Summary of Demand Projections and Capacity of Water Supply ................................ 8-6 Table 8.2.1 Comparison of Population Projections ....................................................................... 8-12 Table 8.2.2 Comparison of Water Demand Projections ................................................................ 8-13 Table 8.2.3 Comparison of Sewerage Generation Estimates ........................................................ 8-13 Table 8.2.4 Comparison of Required Sewerage Treatment Estimates .......................................... 8-14 Table 8.2.5 Estimate of Required Sewerage Treatment Capacity (2030) - Summary ................... 8-14 Table 8.2.6 Existing Trunk Sewers (Separated Sewers) in Nairobi City ...................................... 8-16 Table 8.2.7 Planned Development of Trunk Sewers under NaRSIP ............................................. 8-16 Table 8.3.1 Demand Forecast of Kenya by 2030 .......................................................................... 8-25 Table 8.3.2 Existing Demand Forecast of the LCPDP .................................................................. 8-26 Table 8.3.3 The Project Demand Forecast of NCC and Kenya .................................................... 8-26 Table 8.3.4 Features of Underground Cable ................................................................................. 8-30 Table 8.3.5 Priority Projects ......................................................................................................... 8-34 Table 8.4.1 Projected Population in Each Collection Zone .......................................................... 8-37 Table 8.4.2 Current Situation of Solid Waste Management and its Gap between Desirable Situation ................................................................................................................................... 8-39 Table 8.4.3 Target Indicators for Future Waste Stream ................................................................. 8-40 Table 8.4.4 Responsibility of Relevant Organizations and Stakeholders...................................... 8-42 Table 8.4.5 Merit and Demerit of Each Technical Options for Treatment and Disposal .............. 8-44 Table 8.4.6 Outline of New Sanitary Landfill Structure ............................................................... 8-45 Table 8.4.7 Outline of the Decommissioning of Dandora Dump Site .......................................... 8-47 Table 8.5.1 Penetration Ratio of Developed Countries ................................................................. 8-52 Table 8.5.2 Mobile Telephone Demand ........................................................................................ 8-52 Table 8.5.3 Internet Use Demand ................................................................................................. 8-53 Table 8.5.4 International Communication Bandwidth Capacity Demand .................................... 8-54 Table 8.5.5 Current Operator Who has own Infrastructure ........................................................... 8-59 Table 8.5.6 Countermeasures against Cyber Security ................................................................... 8-63 Table 8.5.7 Basic ICT Literacy Education .................................................................................... 8-65 Table 8.5.8 Evaluation of Project .................................................................................................. 8-67 Table 9.1.1 Activities and Methods on Capacity Development ...................................................... 9-9 Table 9.1.2 Image of Plan of Operations for Capacity Development Activities (Sample) ........... 9-10 Table 9.2.1 Major Investment Projects of Kenya Vision 2030 ..................................................... 9-12 Table 9.2.2 Other Project Proposals related to Kenya Vision 2030 and presented by Kenya Investment Authority.................................................................................................. 9-12 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xix Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 9.2.3 Expected Scenario of Employment Distribution by Type of Industry ....................... 9-17 Table 9.2.4 Correspondence between Categories in Person Trip Survey and Industrial Classification .............................................................................................................. 9-18 Table 9.2.5 Number of Primary and Secondary Schools .............................................................. 9-25 Table 9.2.6 Estimation of Population and Employment of the Environs in Greater Nairobi ........ 9-30 Table 9.3.1 Number of NCC Health Centers and Dispensaries by District .................................. 9-32 Table 9.3.2 Types and Capacity of City Council Markets by Ward .............................................. 9-32 Table 9.4.1 Contents of Geodatabase .......................................................................................... 9-40 Table 9.4.2 Specification of Satellite Imagery (WorldView-2) ..................................................... 9-42 Table 10.2.1 Main Tasks of SEA, specified by SEA Guideline of Kenya ...................................... 10-3 Table 10.2.2 Three Preparatory Meetings ....................................................................................... 10-5 Table 10.2.3 Schedule of 18 Preliminary Stakeholder Meetings .................................................... 10-5 Table 10.2.4 Meeting Program of Preliminary Stakeholder Meeting held at Dagoretti District..... 10-6 Table 10.3.1 Newly Added Task to Previous SEA .......................................................................... 10-6 Table 10.3.2 Main Tasks of SEA, specified by both SEA Guideline of Kenya and CGA .............. 10-7 Table 10.3.3 Summary of Public Advertisement ............................................................................ 10-7 Table 10.3.4 Summary of 1st Stakeholder Meeting (Detailed SEA Study) .................................... 10-8 Table 10.3.5 Summary of 2nd Stakeholder Meeting (selected sectoral group, Detailed SEA Study) ................................................................................................................................... 10-8 Table 10.3.6 Summary of 3rd Stakeholder Meeting (Detailed SEA Study) ................................... 10-9 Table 10.3.7 Website Operation Policy ......................................................................................... 10-11 Table 10.3.8 Summary of Approved Contents for Website Updating ........................................... 10-11 Table 10.3.9 Summary of Website Management Meeting ............................................................ 10-11 Table 10.4.1 Summary of Proposed Development Structure Alternative Plan ............................. 10-13 Table 10.4.2 Evaluation Factors for SEA (draft) .......................................................................... 10-14 Table 10.4.3 Compound Matrix for Selected Development Structure Alternatives ...................... 10-15 Table10.4.4 Environmental Risk and Opportunity Matrix for Selected Development Structure Alternative................................................................................................................ 10-15 Table 10.5.1 Schedule of NCCs 23 Public Consultation Meetings ............................................. 10-17 Table 10.5.2 Major NIUPLAN Remarks obtained from Public Consultation (Urban Transport) 10-18 Table 10.5.3 Major NIUPLAN Remarks obtained from Public Consultation (Urban Infrastructure) ................................................................................................................................. 10-18 Table 10.5.4 Major NIUPLAN Remarks obtained from Public Consultation (Land Use, Resettlement and Social Service) ............................................................................. 10-18 Table 10.5.5 Major NIUPLAN Remarks obtained from Public Consultation (Governance, Legislation and Institutional Aspects) ...................................................................... 10-18 Table 10.5.6 Major NIUPLAN Remarks obtained from Public Consultation (Cross Cutting Issues) ................................................................................................................................. 10-19 Table 11.1.1 List of All Priority Programs ...................................................................................... 11-2 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xx Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya ABBREVIATIONS AAK Architectural Association of Kenya ADA Austrian Development Corporation ADC Austrian Development Corporation AFD Agence Francaise Developpement (French development agency) AfDB African Development Bank AMRF Africa Medical and Research Foundation APL Adaptable Program Lending ASAL Arid and Semi-Arid Land ASCAS Accumulated Savings and Credit Associations AWSB Athi Water Services Board BADEA Arab Bank for Economic Development in Africa BOD Biochemical Oxygen Demand BPO Business Process Outsourcing BPO Business Process Off-shoring BRT Bus Rapid Transit C/R Circumferential/Radial CAA Civil Aviation Authority CBD Central Business District CCK Communications Commission of Kenya CCN City Council of Nairobi CFAs Community Forest Associations CGA County Government Act CMA Capital Market Authority COD Chemical Oxygen Demand COK Constitution of Kenya CPD City Planning Department CSUD Centre of Sustainable Urban Development CWSB Coast Water Services Board DANIDA Danish International Development Agency DC Development Control DCG Donor Coordination Group DESTW Dandora Estate STW DfID UK Department of International Development DFIs Development Finance Institutions DGIS Netherlands Ministry of Foreign Affairs (of Netherland) DID Department of International Development (of UK) DMU Diesel Multiple-Units DOE Department of Environment DRSRS Department of Resource Surveys and Remote Sensing DSL Digital Subscriber Line EA Environmental Audit EAC East African Community EC European Commission ECM Executive Committee Member EEPCO Ethiopia Electric Power Corporation EIA Environmental Impact Assessment EMCA Environment Management Coordination Act EOI Expressions of Interest EPZA Export Processing Zones Authority ERC Energy Regulation Commission ERSWEC Economic Recovery Strategy for Wealth and Employment Creation EU European Union FAO Food and Agriculture Organization FSMPNWS Feasibility Study and Master Plan for Developing New Water Sources for Nairobi and Satellite Towns Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xxi Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya GC Gross Coverage Ratio GCCN Government Common Core Network GDC Geothermal Development Company GDP Gross National Product GIS Geographical Information System GNI Gross National Income GOK Government of Kenya GRDP Gross Regional Domestic Product HAC Harmonization Alignment and Coordination ICB International Competitive Bidding ICT Information Communication Technology IDA International Development Association IPP Independent Power Producers ITCZ Inter Tropical Convergence Zone ITS Intelligent Transport System J CC J oint Coordinating Committee J DA J oint Development Agreement J ICA J apan International Corporation Agency J KIA J omo Kenyatta International Airport J KUAT J omo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology J ST J ICA Study Team KAA Kenya Airport Authority KAM Kenya Association of Manufacturers KBC Kenya Broadcasting Corporation KCAA Kenya Civil Aviation Authority KDN Kenya Data Network KDN Kenya Data Network KEBS Kenya Bureau of Standards Ken Gen Kenya Power Generating Company KeNHA Kenya National Highways Authority KENIC Kenya Network Information Center KENSUP Kenya Slum Upgrading Program KEPSA Kenya Private Sector Alliance KETRACO Kenya Electricity Transmission Company KFS Kenya Forest Service KfW Kreditanstalt fr Wiederaufbau (German government-owned development bank) KIA Kenya Investment Authority KIE Kenya Industrial Estate Ltd KIP Kenya Institute of Planners KIPI Kenya Industrial Property Institute KIPPRA Kenya Institute of Public Policy Research an Analysis KIRDI Kenya Industrial Research and Development Institute KISIP Kenya Informal Settlements Improvement Project KMP Kenya Municipal Program KNCC&I Kenya National Chamber of Commerce and Industry KPC Kenya Pipeline Corporation KPDA Kenya Property Developers Association KPLC Kenya Power and Lighting Company KPPRA Kenya Institute of Public Policy Research an Analysis KPTC Kenya Post and Telecommunication Companys KRC Kenya Railways Corporation KTB Kenya Tourist Board KTDC Kenya Tourist Development Corporation KURA Kenya Urban Roads Authority KWS Kenya Wildlife Service LCPDP Least Cost Power Development Plan LPDP Local Physical Development Plan Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xxii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya LRT Light Rail Transit MAF Mission Aviation Fellowship MEMR Ministry of Environment and Mineral Resources MEWNR Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources MFIs Microfinance Institutions MLH&UD Ministry of Lands, housing and Urban Development MNPDV2030 Ministry of National Planning and Vision 2030 MODP Ministry of Development and Planning MOE Ministry of Energy MOE&P Ministry of Energy and Petroleum MOH Ministry of Health MOIC Ministry of Information and Communication MOICT Ministry of ICT MOL Ministry of Land MOLG Ministry of Local Government MOLHUD Ministry Of Lands, Housing And Urban Development MONMD Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development MOPHS Ministry of Public Health and Sanitation MOR Ministry of Roads MORPW Ministry of Roads and Public Works MOTI Ministry of Transport and Infrastructure MOW&I Ministry of Water and Irrigation MRF Material Recovery Facility MRTS Mass Rapid Transit System MSD Medium Speed Diesel MSEA Micro and Small Enterprises Authority MSMEs Micro Small and Medium Enterprises MSL Mean Sea Level MWI Ministry of Water and Irrigation NaMSIP Nairobi Metropolitan Service Improvement Project NaRSIP Nairobi Rivers Rehabilitation and Restoration Program: Sewerage Improvement Project NASP National Airports System Plan NBS National Broad Band Strategy NCBA Nairobi County Business Association NCBDA Nairobi Central Business District Association NCC Nairobi City County NCWSC Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company NEMA National Environment Management Authority NES National Environment Secretariat NESC Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company NHC National Housing Corporation NIUPLAN Nairobi Integrated Urban Development Master Plan NMR Nairobi Metropolitan Region NMT Non-Motorized Transport NOFBI National Optic Fiber Backbone Infrastructure NRS Nairobi Rail Station NSSF National Social Security Fund NTSA National Transport and Safety Authority NUTRANS The Study on Master Plan for Urban Transport in the Nairobi Metropolitan Area in the Republic of Kenya, March 2006 NUTRIP National Urban Transport Improvement Project O&M Operation and Maintenance OD Origin Destination OJ T On-the-J ob Training OPM Office of the Prime Minister PCU Passenger Car Unit PDF Project Demand Forecast Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xxiii Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya PDP Project Development Plan PHPDT Peak Hour Peak Direction Traffic PID Project Information Document PIDG Private Infrastructure Development Group Trust PIS Policy Implementation Section PMU Project Management Unit PPCSCA Permanent Presidential Commission on Soil Conservation and Afforestation PPP Public-Private Partnership PR Plot Ratio PS Permanent Secretary PSP Private Service Provider PT Person Trip PVSs Public Service Vehicles QCBS Quality- and Cost-Based Selection RD Record of Discussion REA Rural Electricity Authority RFC Regional Financial Centre ROSCAs Rotating Savings and Credit Associations ROW Right of Way RTA Research Triangle Africa RVR Rift Valley Railways SACCOs Savings and Credit Cooperative Societies SEA Strategic Environmental Assessment SECE Swiss State Secretariat for Foreign Affairs SHM Stakeholder Meetings SIDA Swedish International Development Cooperation SMEs Small and Medium Enterprises SOK Survey of Kenya SSL Salary Scale Level STI Science, technology and innovation STP Sewerage Treatment Plant STRADA System for Traffic Demand Analysis STW Sewerage Treatment Work SWM Solid Waste Management SWPC Solid Waste Public Corporation TOD Transit Oriented Development TSS Total Suspended Solids TWG Technical Working Group UfW Unaccounted for Water UNDP United Nations Development Programme UNEP United Nations Environment Programme UN-HABITAT United Nations Human Settlements Programme UNHCR Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees UON University of Nairobi USAID United States Agency for International Development VCR Vehicle Capacity Ratio VRC Volume Capacity Ratio WASP Wien Automatic Simulation Package WaSSIP Water and Sanitation Service Improvement Project WATSAN Kibera Integrated Water, Sanitation and Waste Management Project WB World Bank WRMA Water Resources Management Authority WSB Water Service Board WSP Water Service Providers WSRB Water Service Regulatory Board WTP Water Treatment Plant WVK World Vision Kenya Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xxiv Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. xxv Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya CHAPTER 1 BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE 1.1 Background Nairobi is the capital city and the largest city of Kenya as well as one of the most important economic centres in East and Central African Regions. The Nairobi city accounts for 50 % of formal employment in Kenya and generates over 50 % of GDP. The VISION 2030, which shows long term national development strategy of Kenya, aims at becoming a middle income country by 2030 and provides the base line of the economic, social, and political frameworks, and also shows action to be taken to achieve the development goals such as MDGs. Nairobi city plays an important role not only as a political centre but also as a model for economic development and social development. Urban development plan of Nairobi city, on the other hand, has not been updated since 1973 and the direction of urban development is not clearly defined. Population of Nairobi city was 800,000 in 1980. Due mainly to population migration from rural area, population has grown to 3.1 million in 2009 and is expected to grow further. In addition, urban problems such as perennial traffic congestion, expansion of slum area, and environment deterioration have been left unsolved for a long time and are already causing negative impact on the economic activities and daily lives of the people in Nairobi city. In order to accelerate sound and sustainable development, an integrated urban master plan has to be prepared, and thus transport network, water supply and sewerage, solid waste management, and living environment have to be improved. In response to the request of the Government of Kenya, the Government of J apan has dispatched Study Team for the Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi (hereafter the Project) in J uly, 2012 and signed the Record of Discussion with the Ministry of Local Government and City Council of Nairobi for the implementation of the Project. (City Council of Nairobi had been changed to Nairobi City County because of restructuring of the organization.) 1.2 Outline of the Project (1) Objectives of the Project (overall goals) The objective of the Project is to review and develop concepts on sustainable urban development and improvement of living condition based on integrated urban development plan for Nairobi city. (2) Expected Outputs: (i) To formulate an integrated urban development master plan for 2030, (ii) To formulate an implementation and management program, (iii) To select priority areas and priority projects, (iv) To review and formulate policies, rules and guidelines for local government, and (v) To conduct technical transfer to the counterparts in the course of the Project. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 1 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (3) Concerned Agency (i) Responsible Agency: The Ministry of Local Government (MOLG) (ii) Implementing Agency: The Nairobi City County (NCC) (4) Acronym of the Project Acronym of The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya is NIUPLAN. 1.3 Project Area (1) Nairobi City The Project Area is the entire area of the City County of Nairobi (Approximately 700km 2 ) with population of 3.1 million (2009 Kenya Population and Housing Census).
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 1.3.1 Location Map (2) The Greater Nairobi Area Since urbanization of Nairobi city county is expanding outside the city boundary and the condition of the surrounding area has to be considered, Greater Nairobi is set at about 20 km from the City of Nairobi, which based on The Master Plan and Feasibility Study to alleviate Traffic Congestion and improve Traffic safety in the Nairobi Metropolitan Area prepared by J ICA in 2006 and recent urbanization trend, and the census data in 2009. Traffic survey and population analysis have being conducted based on Greater Nairobi. Following figure and table show the coverage of Greater Nairobi area. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 2 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 1.3.2 Greater Nairobi Boundary Table 1.3.1 Greater Nairobi (Division list) Division Area(km 2 ) Division Area(km 2 ) City of Nairobi (i) Central 695.1 South-eastern KIAMBU County 801.5 (ii) Makadara (iii) Kasarani Southern KIAMBU County 706.6 (iv) Embakasi (v) Pumwani Northern KAJ IADO County 1,050.9 (vi) Westlands (vii) Dagoretti Western MACHAKOS County 1,598.0 (viii) Kibera Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) 1.4 Organizational Arrangements For implementation of the Project, following organizational setting is established. 1.4.1 Overall Organizational Arrangements Stakeholders of the Project are composed of J ICA Study Team, Ministry of Local Government as Responsible Agency, City County of Nairobi as Implementing Agency and stakeholders from central government and concerned agencies. Figure 1.4.1 shows Project Organization Chart according to the Record of Discussion signed on J uly 2012. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 3 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: Record of Discussion (RD) signed among Ministry of Local Government and City Council of Nairobi and J apan International Cooperation Agency on 23 J uly, 2013 Figure 1.4.1 Project Organization Chart Based on 1 st RD Due to the changes in the ministerial structure in early part of 2013, the J CC and working group have been realigned, and the revision of the Record of Discussion is in progress. The new organizational chart is shown in Figure 1.4.2 as per the revised RD signed on September 2013.
Source: Record of Discussion signed among Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development, Nairobi City County, Ministry of Devolution and Planning and J apan International Cooperation Agency on 24 September, 2013 Figure 1.4.2 Project Organization Chart based on Revised RD 1.4.2 Individual Organizational Arrangements For execution of the master plan formulation, J oint Coordinating Committee (J CC), Technical Working Group, and Secretariat Meeting are organized. Following chart shows the outline of the organizational arrangements. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 4 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 1.4.3 Tiers of Discussion Structure (1) J oint Coordinating Committee (J CC) J CC is a high level decision making body composed of national government agencies represented by Permanent Secretary Level. Function of J CC is shown below: To steer and advice the project team To appraise the results of the Project To facilitate the necessary endorsement procedure of the Project outputs To coordinate and give policy direction to existing and on-going sector plans The first J CC was held on December 11, 2012 to discuss Inception Report. The contents of the Inception Report were approved by the J CC. Table 1.4.1 JCC Meeting Record Date Discussion Topic Participants December 11, 2012 Topics: Inception Report discussion Remarks from Ministry of Local Government, Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development, Town Clerk of NCC, J ICA Kenya Office Brief on integrated urban development master plan (NCC) Explanation of Inception Report Discussion NCC (Town Clerk, Directors, and staff) Ministry of Local Government (PS, Director of Urban Planning) MOH (Ministry of Health) MNPDV2030 (Ministry of National Planning and Vision 2030 MONMD (Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development) MOW&I (Ministry of Water and Irrigation) OPM( Office of the Prime Minister) Ministry of Finance MEMR (Ministry of Environment and Mineral Resources) J ICA Kenya Office J ICA Study Team Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Because of the organization restructure both at national government level and Nairobi City County level, structure of J CC will be changed to represent new government structure. New J CC structure will be proposed at the next J CC for approval. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 5 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (2) Technical Working Group Technical Working Group is organized as: To carry out surveys and analyze the current situation of the project area To prepare reports for presentation to the J CC To harmonize the presented reports To coordinate the working team To anticipate challenges of sectoral plans with a view to ensure horizontal co-ordination among agencies. Six Thematic Technical Working group was proposed in the first Technical Working Group in J anuary, 2013 for sector discussion. Six groups are shown in the table below: Table 1.4.2 Thematic Working Group Thematic Working Group (i) Land use & human settlements (ii) Governance & institution (iii) Population and social system/urban economy (iv) Urban transport (road, railway, airport) (v) Environment (vi) Infrastructure (water supply, wastewater, power, solid waste and disaster prevention, ICT & telecommunication) Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Technical working group conducted until March 2014 is shown in the table below: Table 1.4.3 Technical Working Group Meeting Record Date Discussion Topic Participants J anuary 30, 2013 Topics: Introduction of the Project and group discussion Brief on preparation of the Integrated Urban Development Plan (Ms. Rose K. Muema, Director of City Planning, Secretary of Technical Working Group Presentation of the Inception Report for the Integrated Urban Development Master Plan (J ICA Study Team) Formation of Thematic Working Group (Mr. Adolwa, Deputy Director, Urban Development Department (Chairman of the Technical Working Group), J ICA Project Team Thematic group discussion on activity and presentation NCC (concerned departments) Ministry of Agriculture Ministry of Local Government NEMA (National Environment Management Authority) Kenya Railway Corporation NHC (National Housing Corporation) KURA(Kenya Urban Roads Authority) KPPRA(Kenya Institute of Public Policy Research an Analysis) Kenya National Bureau of Statistics National Economic & Social Council (NESC) Athi Water Services Board NCWSC (Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company) Communications Commission of Kenya (CCK) Research Triangle Africa (RTA) University of Nairobi Kenya Institute of Planners (KIP) Architectural Association of Kenya (AAK) Urban Designer Consultant World Bank UNEP (United Nations Environment Programme) UN-HABITAT MOPHS (Ministry of Public Health and Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 6 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Date Discussion Topic Participants Sanitation) J KUAT (J omo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology) KETRACO (Kenya Electricity Transmission Company) April 24, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Urban transport (road, railway, airport) Infrastructure (water supply, waste water, drainage) Population and social system/urban economy Environment MoH (Ministry of Health) NEMA (National Environment Management Authority) AWSB (Athi Water Services Board) KURA (Kenya Urban Roads Authority) KETRACO (Kenya Electricity Transmission Company) KIP (Kenya Institute of Planners) GIBB (Consultant) NCC Nairobi City County April 30, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land use & human settlements (development vision, structure plan) Governance & institution Infrastructure (solid waste management) RTA (Research Triangle Africa) J ST (J ICA Study Team) NCC (Nairobi City County) AAK (Architectural Association of Kenya) UON (University of Nairobi) May 6, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Infrastructure (telecommunication, power) Nairobi City County KETRACO (Kenya Electricity) May 8, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land use & human settlements (development vision, structure plan, CBD) Land use & human settlements (GIS database: confirmation of boundary, data require, issues) KRC (Kenya Railways Corporation) J ST (J ICA Study Team) NCC (Nairobi City County) MONMED (Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development) MOL (Ministry of Lands, Department of Physical Planning) The GODOWN Arts Centre SOK (Survey of Kenya, Ministry of Lands) UON (University of Nairobi) May 16, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Infrastructure (Power) Ministry of Energy Ministry of Local Government KETRACO-Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Ltd GDC-Geothermal Development Company NCWSC-Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company KAM-Kenya Association of Manufacturers KPLC-Kenya Power and Lighting Company NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team May 21, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Infrastructure (Solid Waste Management) NEMA-National Environment Management Authority KCAA-Kenya Civil Aviation Authority World Bank REDI International UoN-University of Nairobi GIBB Africa Ltd NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 7 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Date Discussion Topic Participants May 28, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land use & Human Settlements (Vision) Ministry of Lands Ministry of Roads Ministry of Local Government Ministry of Agriculture KeNHA-Kenya National Highways Authority KRC-Kenya Railways Authority NMK-National Museums of Kenya KRB-Kenya Roads UN-HABITAT Urban Design Consultant Townscape Consultants Planners Ltd NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team J une 7, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Governance & Institution (Capacity Development Plan and Technology Transfer) NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team J une 19, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Governance & Institution (Capacity Development Plan and Technology Transfer) Planning Systems SNI-Safer Nairobi Initiative RTA-Research Triangle Africa Triscope NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team J une 20, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land Use & Human Settlements (District Plan for CBD and Land Use Plan for NCC, and GIS Data requirements) Ministry of Lands KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation NMK-National Museums of Kenya UoN-University of Nairobi ISK-Institute Surveyors of Kenya AAK-Architectural Association of Kenya KIP-Kenya Institute of Planners ESRI Eastern Africa Geomaps Triscope Planning Systems Dakar Services KPDA-Kenya Property Developers Association Renaissance Planning NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team J uly 4, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land use & Human Settlements (Development Vision for CBD) KIPPRA-Kenya Institute of Public Policy Research and Analysis KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation NCWSC-Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company UoN-University of Nairobi KPDA-Kenya Property Developers Association Triscope ESRI Eastern Africa GIBB Africa Ltd Urban Design Consultant NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team J uly 25, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land use & Human Settlements (Land demand forecast, Structure Plan, discussion on sub centres. UN-HABITAT J KUAT-J omo Kenyatta University of technology KURA-Kenya Urban Roads Authority AAK-Architectural Association of Kenya UoN-University of Nairobi Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 8 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Date Discussion Topic Participants Spatial Collective Muungano Support Trust/slumDwellers International Townscope Consulting Planners NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team J uly 26, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Urban transport (road, railway, airport)-Urban Transport Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development Ministry of Transport and Infrastructure KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation KURA-Kenya Urban Roads Authority UNHABITAT NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team August 16, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Governance and Institutions RTA-Research Triangle Africa NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team August 20, 2013 ITR Presentation Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development KeNHA-Kenya National Highways Authority KURA-Kenya Urban Roads Authority KETRACO-Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Ltd NCWSC-Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company NEMA-National Environment Management Authority KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation World Bank UoN-University of Nairobi AAK/NEOPOLITANS-Architectural Association of Kenya Godown Arts Centre RTA-Research Triangle Africa Planning Systems GIBB Africa Ltd Townscope Consultants Ochieng Abuodha Consulting Engineers Oakas Services Ltd NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team August 23, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Environment (Air Pollution and SEA Progress) UNEP-United Nations Environment Programme NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team August 27, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land Use and Human Settlements (Sub centres and GIS data update) KIPPRA- Kenya Institute of Public Policy Research and Analysis UON-University of Nairobi Renaissance Planning UN-HABITAT KRB-Kenya Roads Board Muungano Support Trust KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 9 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Date Discussion Topic Participants September 5, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land Use and Human Settlement Ministry of Lands, housing and Urban Development KURA-Kenya Urban Roads Authority KeNHA-Kenya National Highways Authority KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation UoN-University of Nairobi World Bank ESRI EA AAK/NEOPOLITANS-Architectural Association of Kenya RTA-Research Triangle Africa Planning Systems Mwacharo and Associate Architects September 5-7, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: (Retreat at Nyeri Outspan hotel) Urban Transport Infrastructure Environment Population, urban Economy and Socio-Cultural Issues Governance and Institutions Land Use and Human Settlements
MLH&UD-Ministry of Lands, housing and Urban Development MOD&P-Ministry of Devolution and Planning MOICT-Ministry of ICT MOE-Ministry of Energy MEW&NR-Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources NEMA-National Environment Management Authority SOK-Survey of Kenya KAA-Kenya Airports Authority CCK-Communications Commission of Kenya KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation KURA-Kenya Urban Roads Authority NCSWC-Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company KPLC-Kenya Power and Lighting Company KIPPRA-Kenya Institute of Public Policy, Research and Analysis WVK-World Vision Kenya NYC-National Youth Council RTA-Research Triangle Africa KIP-Kenya Institute of Planners AAK-Architectural Association of Kenya ITEC Engineering Company Mwacharo and Associate Architects Townscope Consultants NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team September 11, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Environment (Solid Waste Management) NEMA-National Environment Management Authority KFS-Kenya Forest Service RTA-Research Triangle Africa NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team September 18, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land Use and Human Settlements (Building Survey Result and District Plan) Transportation (Railway) Ministry of Lands, Housing, and Urban Development KURA-Kenya Urban Roads Authority KIPPRA-Kenya Institute of Public Policy Research and Analysis UN-HABITAT KPDA-Kenya Property Developers Association University of Tsukuba Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 10 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Date Discussion Topic Participants Mwacharo and Associate Architects NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team September 20, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Infrastructure (Water Sector-Water Supply, Sewerage and Drainage) Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources WRMA-Water Resource Management Authority NCWSC-Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team September 23, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Infrastructure (Power)-Power forecast and recommendations Ministry of Energy and Petroleum NCWSC-Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company KPLC-Kenya Power and Lighting Company (Kenya Power) NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team September 26, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Infrastructure (Telecommunication)-current condition of telecommunication sector and draft master plan
CCK-Communication Commission of Kenya J amii Telcoms Wananchi Group Iway Africa Frontier optical Networks TelkomKenya Ltd Virtual City MTN Business Simbanet Access Kenya J ST-J ICA Study Team NCC-Nairobi City County October 31, 2013 Thematic Working Group J oint Infrastructure (Solid Waste Management) and Land Use and Human Settlements Technical Working Group (cross-cutting issue on location of new sanitary land-fill site discussions) KAA-Kenya Airports Authority KCAA - Kenya Civil Aviation Authority GIBB Africa Ltd NEMA ITEC Engineering Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development Kenya Roads Board Survey of Kenya University of Nairobi Kenya Railways Corporation Kenya Property Developers Association Townscape Consultants REDI Pleng Ltd Renaissance Planners RTA - Research Triangle Africa Real Plan Consultants UN-HABITAT Kenya Forest Services J ST-J ICA Study Team NCC-Nairobi City County November 13, 2013 Thematic Technical Working Group: Urban transport (road). Contents of the presentation include: Progress of the study Future Transport Network Plan Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development MOTI-Ministry of Transport and Infrastructure University of Nairobi KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation KeNHA - Kenya National Highways Authority Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 11 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Date Discussion Topic Participants Transport Demand Forecast Result Analysis and Evaluation of Traffic Demand Forecast Preliminary Ideas or Staging Plan UN-HABITAT J ST-J ICA Study Team NCC-Nairobi City County December 3, 2013 Stakeholders Workshop: Presentation and Review of the Progress Report KAA-Kenya Airports Authority AAK-Architectural Association of Kenya NCWSC-Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company Ministry of Energy and Petroleum Ministry of Devolution and Planning Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development KURA-Kenya Urban Roads Authority Survey of Kenya KIPPRA-Kenya Institute of Public Policy Analysis Kenya Railways Corporation J ST-J ICA Study Team NCC-Nairobi City County March 25- 28, 2014 Thematic Technical Working Group: (Retreat at Naivasha Great Rift Valley Hotel)- Review of Draft Final Report and feedback fromPublic Consultations) Urban Transport Infrastructure Environment Population, urban Economy and Socio-Cultural Issues Governance and Institutions Land Use and Human Settlements
MLH&UD-Ministry of Lands, housing and Urban Development MOICT-Ministry of ICT MEWNR-Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources MOE&P- Ministry of Energy and Petroleum NEMA-National Environment Management Authority SOK-Survey of Kenya KAA-Kenya Airports Authority CCK-Communications Commission of Kenya KRC-Kenya Railways Corporation NCSWC-Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company UON- University of Nairobi KIPPRA-Kenya Institute of Public Policy, Research and Analysis UN HABITAT WVK-World Vision Kenya NYC-National Youth Council RTA-Research Triangle Africa Godown Arts Centre KIP-Kenya Institute of Planners AAK-Architectural Association of Kenya ITEC Engineering Company Townscope Consultants NCC-Nairobi City County J ST-J ICA Study Team April 2, 2014 Thematic Technical Working Group: Land Use and Human Settlements (Urban Structure Plan and Draft SEA Report)
SOK- Surveys of Kenya UON-University of Nairobi GIBB Africa Ltd AAK- Architectural Association of Kenya NCC- Nairobi City County Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) (3) Secretariat Meeting In addition to J CC and Technical Working Group agreed in the RD, Secretariat Meeting was organized in the Nairobi City County for the purpose of coordinating relevant departments, carrying out daily Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 12 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya activity with the J ICA Study Team and coordination with agencies outside Nairobi City County. Secretariat meeting is conducted prior to Technical Working Group confirm Nairobi City County and the J ICA Study Team can share views have mutual understanding of Nairobi urban development. After organization of Technical Working Groups have become routine work and counterpart started to be aware of each task, Secretariat Meeting was conducted routinely instead of conducted ad hoc basis. Table 1.4.4 Secretariat Meeting Record Date Discussion Topic Participants J anuary 21, 2013 Topics: Introduction of the Project Introduction of the members Update on Master Plan (Director, City Planning Department) Outline of the Study and activity until March NCC (Nairobi City County) NEMA (National Environment Management Agency) KAA (Kenya Airports Authority) NCWSC (Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company) J ICA Sturdy Team February 6, 2013 Topics: Follow up of the Technical Working Group Confirmation of activity and data needed Thematic working group activity discussion NCC (Nairobi City County) NCWSC (Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company) J ICA Study Team April 18, 2013 Topic: Confirmation of activity until May and working group schedule Explanation of activity (land use, urban transport infrastructure, environment) Confirmation of thematic working group topics and schedule NCC (Nairobi City County) NCWSC (Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company) NCC (ICT) GIBB (consultant) Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) 1.4.3 List of Members for JCC, Working Group and Secretariat The list member for J CC, Thematic Working Group and Secretariat is summarizing in the following members. When the modification of J CC an working group is modified as mentioned in Sub-Section 1.4.1, some of the memberships shall also be modified. Table 1.4.5 JCC Members JCC Organization 1 st (OLD) JCC (REFER 1 ST RD) 1 Permanent Secretary (PS), MOLG 2 PS, Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development (MONMD) 3 SLAA MOLG 4 Town Clerk, City Council of Nairobi 5 Ministry of Health 6 Ministry of National Development & Vision 2030 7 D/ Director, UDD, MOLG 8 Director, CPD 9 AMP&E, MONMD 10 D/Director W&S 11 Secretary Infrastructure, OPM 12 Dep Director, CPD 13 Chief Economist, MOLG 14 Dep AS, Pacif, Treasury 15 J ST, Deputy TeamLeader 16 J ST 17 J ICA Representative 18 Planner, CPD 19 Infrastructure Expert 20 SPSE, (M) 21 Senior Rep, J ICA 22 MEMR Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 13 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya JCC Organization NEW JCC (Refer to Revised RD) Members 23 Chair: Governor, Nairobi City County 24 Co-chair : Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development 25 Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development 26 Ministry of Devolution and Planning 27 Ministry of Transport and Infrastructure 28 Ministry of Energy and Petroleum 29 Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resource 30 Chair of the Technical Working group 31 Chair of the secretariat 32 J ICA 33 Other organizations can participate in J CC if necessary Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Table 1.4.6 NIUPLAN Secretariat Organization Position NCC 1 Director, CPD 2 Deputy Director, CPD 3 Assistant Director, DC/ CPD 4 Assistant Director FP/ CPD 5 Planner, CPD 6 Planner, CPD 7 Planner, CPD 8 Planner, CPD 9 Planner, CPD 10 Planner, CPD 11 Planner/ CPD 12 Assistant Director UDD/ CPD 13 Deputy City Engineer 14 City Engineers 15 City Engineers 16 City Engineers 17 Social Services 18 Assistant Director PIS/ CPD 19 Environment JICA STUDY TEAM (JST) 20 TeamLeader, Land Use Expert 21 Deputy TeamLeader, Urban Planning Expert 22 Urban Transport Expert 23 Traffic Survey Expert 24 Environment Expert 25 Urban Planning Expert 26 Industrial Promotion/ Socio-economic Expert 27 Capacity Development Expert 28 Water Supply Planning 29 Solid Waste Management 30 District Planning Expert 31 Traffic Demand Projection Expert 32 Sewerage/ Drainage SystemExpert 33 GIS/ Traffic Condition Survey (DBM) Expert 34 Telecommunication Planning Expert 35 Power Planning Expert 36 Railway Planning Expert 37 Airport Planning Expert 38 Planner 39 Planner 40 GIS Analyst Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 14 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 1.4.7 Technical Working Group Members TWG DESIGNATION/ ORGANIZATION OVERALL JOINT CHAIRMEN 1 MLH&UD 2 NCC Executive Committee Member (L,PP & H) 3 Deputy TeamLeader J ST LAND USE AND HUMAN SETTLEMENTS 4 University of Nairobi 5 J ST Expert 6 J ST Expert 7 Kenya Railways Corporation 8 Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development 9 Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development 10 Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development 11 ESRI East Africa 12 Muungano support trust 13 Pleng ltd 14 Real plan consutants 15 The Godown Arts Centre 16 The Godown Arts Centre 17 Kenya railways 18 Planning systems 19 Oakas services ltd 20 World bank 21 J ST 22 J ST 23 Townscape consultants SOCIO-ECONOMIC 24 University of Nairobi 25 J ST - Industrial Promotion/ Socio-economic Expert 26 NCC Social Services 27 NCC City Education URBAN TRANSPORT 28 University of Nairobi 29 NCC - CPD 30 NCC - CPD 31 NCC - City Engineers 32 NCC - City Engineers 33 NCC- City Engineers 34 NCC - City Engineers 35 NCC - City Engineers 36 KeNHA 37 Kenya Railways Corporation 38 Kenya Railways Corporation 39 KURA 40 MOTI 41 KRC 42 J ST 43 J ST 44 J ST 45 J ST 46 UN-HABITAT - SUSTRAN CAPACITY DEVELOPMENT 47 Capacity Development Expert 48 RTA 49 J ST 50 NCC Human Resources 51 NCC - CPD 52 World Vision INFRASTRUCTURE 53 Sewerage/ Drainage SystemExpert 54 Water Supply Planning 55 NCC - CPD 56 NCC - CPD 57 NCC - CPD 58 NCC - CPD 59 J ST 60 I-Way Africa Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 15 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya TWG DESIGNATION/ ORGANIZATION 61 TelkomKenya 62 CCK 63 NCC - ICT 64 J ST 65 SafaricomLtd 66 IWAY Africa 67 SafaricomLtd 68 Wananchi/ Zuku 69 Media Council of Kenya 70 J amii Telcom 71 MTN Business 72 MTN Business 73 MTN Business 74 SafaricomLtd 75 TelkomKenya 76 Access kenya 77 Solid Waste Management 78 Nairobi water ENVIRONMENT 79 Environment Expert 80 Planner 81 NEMA 82 NCC 83 UN-HABITAT 84 UON, GEOGRAPHY 85 KCAA 86 J ST 87 NCC 88 NCC - ENVIRONMENT 89 UNEP Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST)
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 1 - 16 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya CHAPTER 2 SOCIO ECONOMIC AND URBAN CONDITIONS 2.1 Review of Current Natural and Socioeconomic Conditions 2.1.1 Current Natural Conditions (1) Geography The Republic of Kenya is located on the east coast of Africa, with the equator running almost straight through the middle of the country, and borders with Somalia, Ethiopia, and South Sudan in the north, Uganda in the west, Tanzania in the south and the Indian Ocean in the east. The total area of the country is 610,000km 2 comprising land areas of 590,000 (approximately) km 2 and water surface areas of 20,000 km 2 . A major part of the inland water surface areas is covered by a portion of Lake Victoria and Lake Turkana. Of the land areas, approximately 510,000 km 2 (more than 85% of the land area) is classified as arid and semi-arid land (ASAL). The remaining area of about 80000 km 2 is classified as non-arid and arable lands, sustaining a substantial portion of the Kenyan economy and providing shelter to the human population. The city of Nairobi with its administrative area of approximately 700 km 2 is the capital of the Republic of Kenya and also a centre of administration, politics, economy and culture of Kenya. The city is bounded by Kajiado County on the South and south west, Kiambu County on the north and north west and Machakos county on the east and south east. Such adjacent areas are now absorbing increasing population and economic activities. (2) Topography The territory of Kenya is characterized by a wide topographical diversity, ranging from glaciated mountains to deserts. The elevation varies from the sea level at the Indian Ocean to 5,199 m at the Batian Peak of Mount Kenya. The city of Nairobi is characterized by undulating hilly topography with an elevation in a range of 1,460 m to 1,920 m. Lowest elevation occurs at the Athi River at the eastern boundary of the city and highest at the western rim of the city. It is unique that the city has the Nairobi National Park with the area of 117 km 2 within its administrative area, extending along the western boundary and attracting a large number of international and domestic tourists annually. (3) Climate The climate in Kenya is primarily influenced by the movement of the Inter-Tropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) and by a topographic relief, especially various elevations. The rainfall in Kenya is affected by large water bodies like Lake Victoria, complex topography with the Great Rift Valley and high mountains; Mt. Kenya and Mt. Elgon. A relatively wet but narrow tropical belt lies along the Indian Ocean coast. Behind the coastline stretches large areas of semi-arid and arid lands. Mean annual rainfall over the country is 680 mm and varies from about 200 mm in the ASAL zone to about 1,800 mm in a humid zone. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 1 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Division Population Area in km 2 Density per km 2 Nairobi City excluding Nairobi National Park (117 km 2 ) Central/Starehe 274,607 11 25,640 Kamukunji/Pumwani 261,855 12 21,623 Makadara 218,641 23 9,481 Dagoretti 329,577 39 8,532 Kasarani 525,624 86 6,081 Embakasi including Njiru 925,775 204 4,546 Langata/Kibera 355,188 106 3,346 Westlands 247,102 97 2,538 Nairobi City 3,138,369 578 5,429 Outside Niarobi City 1,877,652 4,206 446 Greater Nairobi 5,016,021 4,784 1,049 Kenya 38,610,097 581,313 66 Kenya generally experiences two seasonal rainfall peaks in most places. The first peak or a season termed as the long-rains in the East African region occurs from March to May, while the second peak or a season termed as the short-rains is observed from October to December. The climate in Nairobi City is usually dry and cool between J uly and August but hot and dry in J anuary and February. The average annual rainfall in Nairobi is about 900mm. The first peak of monthly rainfall occurs in April and the second peak takes place in November. The mean daily maximum temperature by month ranges from 28 o C to 22 o C and the minimum ranges from 14 o C to 12 o C. 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 J A N F E B M A R A P R M A Y J U N J U L A U G S E P O C T N O V D E C T e m p e r a t u r e
( o C ) R a i n f a l l
( m m ) Rainfall Temperature (Max) Temperature (Min)
Source: KMD Figure 2.1.1 Rainfall and Temperature in Nairobi City 2.1.2 Population and Demography (1) Night-time Population According to Kenya Population and Housing Census conducted in 2009, the total population of Kenya was approximately 38,610,000, and that of Nairobi City was approximately 3,138,000, accounting for 8.1% of the national population. The average population density excluding Nairobi National Park, which occupies 117km 2 or 16.8% of the citys total area, is 5,429 per km 2 . The Central Division and Kamukunji Division located at the centre have a much higher density than others in excess of 20,000 per km 2 . Table 2.1.1 Population, Area and Density of Nairobi and its Environs in 2009
Source: 2009 Census The population growth rate of the Greater Nairobi has been considerably higher than that of Kenya. The average annual growth rate of the Greater Nairobi was 4.2% from the 1989 census to the 1999 census and 4.0% from the 1999 census to the 2009 census, while that of Kenya was 3.0% in both periods. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 2 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya In the Greater Nairobi, Nairobi City had grown faster in the period from 1989 to 1999, when the city grew at 4.9% and the environs outside the city at 3.0%. But from 1999 to 2009, the environs grew faster as it grew at 4.1%t and the city at 3.9% as detailed in Chapter 3.3. The change seems to be a sign of urban expansion of Nairobi City . In the city, Embakasi Division has the highest growth, while out of the city in the Greater Nairobi, Ruiru area to the north of the city and Mavoko and Kitengela areas to the south are fastest growing.
Source: 2009 Census Figure 2.1.2 Population Density per Hectare of Nairobi City in 2009
Sources: 1999 Census and 2009 Census Figure 2.1.3 Average Annual Population Growth Rate of Nairobi City and its Environs in Greater Nairobi from 1999 to 2009 (%) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 3 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The age structure of the population of Kenya in 2009 forms a pyramid while that of Nairobi City has a pair of wings with a large share of population around the twenties. It is noted in the figures that the apparent larger population at every 5 years of age indicates the limited precision of the responses to the census questionnaire. 800,000 600,000 400,000 200,000 0 200,000 400,000 600,000 800,000 0 7 14 21 28 35 42 49 56 63 70 77 Male Female Age Structure of Population of Kenya Showing Nairobi in 2009 Source:2009 Census
Note: Thick parts of lines represent Nairobi Citys population. Source: 2009 Census Figure 2.1.4 Age Structure of Population of Kenya Showing Nairobi in 2009 60,000 40,000 20,000 0 20,000 40,000 60,000 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 or over Male Female Age Structure of Population of Nairobi in 2009 Source: 2009 Census
Source: 2009 Census Figure 2.1.5 Age Structure of Population of Nairobi in 2009 Population growth of an area depends on the births, deaths, in-migration and out-migration. The population growth rate can be expressed as follows. Population growth rate =Natural growth rate +Social growth rate =(Birth rate Death rate) +(In-migration rate Out-migration rate)
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 4 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The population growth rate of Nairobi City has been higher than that of Kenya. For example, during the 19992009 period, the rate of the city was 3.9% while that of Kenya was 3.0%. The dominant reason for the difference is thought to be the high in-migration rate of the city. In Figure 2.1.6, the age structure of population of Nairobi City in the 1999 Census is shifted upwards by 10 years and overlaid with the population over 10 years of age in the 2009 Census. The shifted 1999 data shows the maximum possible population without migration in each sex and age group in 2009, because no death is assumed. If the actual 2009 population is greater than the shifted 1999 data, the difference is the minimum possible net in-migration of the group. The in-migration between 15 years old and 30 years old as of 2009 is remarkably large. This means that between 1999 and 2009 the net in-migration of an age cohort between 5 years old, the age of people in 1999 who are 15 years old in 2009, and 30 years old is large. At least some 700,000 people in this age group migrated to the city during the decade. 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 100,000 200,000 300,000 0-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 80 or over Male Female Male 2009 Female 2009 Male shifted from 1999 Female shifted from 1999
Sources: Kenya Censuses 1999 and 2009, and J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 2.1.6 Nairobi's Age Structure Shifted by 10 Years from 1999 and Corresponding Actual Population in 2009 (2) Day-time Population The number of pupils and students at schools and the number of workers at work places are studied as follows. 1) School Enrolment According to the 2009 census, the number of children attending pre-primary schools was 155,936, which was 71.4% (gross enrolment rate) of the 3 to 5 age cohort population. Similarly, that of primary schools was 490,314 or 111.3% of the 6 to 13 age cohort population, while that of secondary schools was 176,837, or 93.8% of the 14 to 17 age cohort population. On the other hand, according to the 2011 data of the Education Department of the NCC and Ministry of Education, the total enrolment of pre-primary schools was 72,165 indicating that the gross enrolment rate was less than 33.0%, because of the population increase since 2009. That of primary schools was 336,723 with the rate of less than 76.5%, and that of secondary schools was 69,314 with the rate of less than 36.8%. The gaps between the home based data and school based data can be interpreted as follows. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 5 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya i) The census data of children attending schools may be overestimated, as the respondents tend to think that actual situation may appear to be inappropriate to disclose. ii) The school data of enrolment may be underestimated, as some schools do not reply properly or some private schools present understated figures because they think that the enrolment is linked to taxation. iii) Some children study at boarding secondary schools out of Nairobi City. In this case, the children living outside the city during their school periods may be enumerated in Nairobi City. Therefore, it is assumed that the enrolment rates were 50% for the pre-primary schools, 90% for the primary schools and 65% for the secondary schools in 2009. Then the total number of pupils and students including the tertiary education data of the 2009 census is estimated at 780,000. Although a number of pupils and students schooling across the city boundaries are observed, they are neglected for the net movement is thought to be marginal compared to the total enrolment. Table 2.1.2 Distribution of Enrolment of Primary Schools, Pre-Schools, Special Units and Secondary Schools in Nairobi City by Division in 2012 (Preliminary) Division Primary, etc Secondary Total 1Dagoretti 46,181 10,507 56,688 2Embakasi including Njiru 104,566 13,236 117,802 3Kamukunji/Pumwani 18,825 4,905 23,730 4Kasarani 87,791 6,337 94,128 5Langata/Kibera 38,050 8,037 46,087 6Makadara 26,489 7,898 34,387 7Central/Starehe 44,685 9,220 53,905 8Westlands 42,301 9,174 51,475 Total 408,888 69,314 478,202
Note: As of J uly 2013, the total enrolment of pre-primary and primary schools is 442,074, instead of 408,888. However, its breakdown into the divisions is not fully available. Sources: City Education Department, City Council of Nairobi and Department of Education, Nairobi Count Unit: Number of pupils and students 2) Work Places Based on the business registration data of the NCC in 2013, the total number of formal workers is estimated approximately at one million. On the other hand, based on the 2009 census, the number of active employees who live in the city is estimated at 1,648,000 in 2013. By assuming a net in-flow of 165,000 commuters from outside the city based on the cordon line survey, the total number of jobs in the city is estimated at 1,813,000 and the number of informal workers is estimated at 813,000. The basic definitions of the formal workers and the non-formal workers are as follows. Formal workers are those working at businesses registered as formal in NCC and wage workers in agriculture and forestry, electricity and water, and in the public sector. Non-formal workers are those working at businesses registered as informal in NCC and unregistered workers except the wage workers mentioned above. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 6 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 3) Day-time Population Assuming the above mentioned commuters from outside the city boundary, the day population of Nairobi City is estimated approximately at 3,280,000 in 2009 and 3,766,000 in 2013. It is noted that much higher day population than night population of the citys central areas is largely attributed to the commuters from the suburban areas inside the city boundary. 2.1.3 Socio-economy (1) Nairobis Position in Kenya 1) Social Indicators In most social indicators, Nairobi City is positioned higher than the average of Kenya. Table 2.1.3 Position of Nairobi in Comparison with Kenya Social Indicators Kenya Nairobi City Main source of water Share of spring/well/borehole is the highest (35.4%). Share of piped water is the highest (52.3%). Main Mode of Human Waste Disposal Share of pit latrine (covered/ uncovered) is the highest (69.6%). Share of main sewer is the highest (47.7%). Main Type of Lighting Fuel Share of tin lamp is the highest (38.5%). Share of electricity is the highest (72.4%). Ownership of Household Assets Kenya has higher ownership in bicycle and motorcycle. Nairobi City has higher ownership in radio, TV set, mobile phone, landline, computer, and car/truck/tuk tuk. Source: 2009 Census
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 % Kenya Nairobi
Source: 2009 Census Figure 2.1.7 Percentage of Households of Ownership by Household Asset 2) Gross Regional Domestic Product per Capita Although estimated GRDP per capita of Nairobi City varies on sources of data, it is assumed to be 3.0 times the national GDP per capita, because it is the average of the collected estimates excluding an exceptionally high figure. The assumption means for 2009 that the GDP share of Nairobi is 24.4% of Kenya. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 7 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya In 2011, GDP per capita of Kenya is estimated at 73,988KSh at current prices of 2011 and GRDP of Nairobi City is estimated at 221,965KSh. Table 2.1.4 References and their Implications Reference Implications Labor Force Analytical Report based on the Kenya Integrated Household Budget Survey 2005/06 In mean monthly household expenditure per capita, Nairobis level is 3.1 times Kenyas level. Basic Report on Well-being in Kenya based on the Kenya Integrated Household Budget Survey 2005/06 In mean monthly food and non-food consumption per capita, Nairobis level is 2.5 times Kenyas level. Statistical Abstract 2012 In earnings per capita, Nairobis level is 3.7 times Kenyas level. Global City GDP Rankings 2008-2025 Pricewaterhouse Coopers In GDP at PPP per capita, Nairobis level is 2.5 times Kenyas level. Appraisal Document of Kenya Municipal Program, World Bank, April 2010 In GDP/GRDP per capita, Nairobis level is more than 6.2 times Kenyas level. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) (2) Socioeconomic Conditions in Nairobi City The Kenya Integrated Household Budget Survey 2005-2006 estimated the poverty line at KSh 2,913 per person per month for urban households. According to the survey, the share of individuals below the poverty line was the highest at 29.8% in Makadara Division and the lowest at 15.3% in Westlands Division. As a very broad trend, a larger number of relatively high income households are found to the west of the CBD than to the east, although there are a number of low income informal settlement areas in the western areas such Kibera and Kawangware.
Source: Kenya Integrated Household Budget Survey 2005-2006 Figure 2.1.8 Share of Individuals below Poverty Line Socioeconomic characteristics of households in the 4 districts of Nairobi City can be compared based on the 2009 Census Volume 2 Population and Household Distribution by Socioeconomic Characteristics. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 8 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 2.1.5 Definitions of Four Districts in Nairobi according to 2009 Census District Division Remarks Nairobi West Dagoretti, Langata/Kibera Kibera here means a division, not a location. Nairobi East Embakasi including Njiru, Makadara Nairobi North Central/Starehe, Kasarani, Kamukunji/Pumwani Westlands Westlands Westlands here is a district and also a division. Sources: 2009 Census and J ICA Study Team(J ST) Regarding water supply, the piped water supply system is the most common source in all the districts. Westland has the highest rate (34.5%) of the system of piped into dwelling, while Nairobi East and Nairobi West have the highest rates (22.2% and 19.8%) of water from vendors. Regarding human waste disposal, Nairobi East and Nairobi North have the highest rates (58.0% and 55.7%) of the main sewer system, while Nairobi West has the highest rate (68.6%) of the pit latrine system. Regarding main type of lighting fuel, Westlands has the highest rate (79.0%) of electricity, while Nairobi West has the highest rate (18.3%) of tin lamp. In Nairobi City, mobile phones, radios and TV sets are common in this order. The ownership of computer, car/truck/tuk tuk and bicycle is 13.4%, 12.2% and 11.4% respectively. The ownership of landline and motorcycle is less than 5%. In all the cases, the shares of Westlands are the highest. 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Nairobi West East North Westlands Pond/dam Lake Stream Spring/well/borehole Piped into dwelling Piped Jabia/rain/ harvested Water vendor Others
Source: 2009 Census Figure 2.1.9 Households by Main Source of Water and District 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Nairobi West East North Westlands Main sewer Septic tank Cess pool VIP pit latrine Pit latrine (covered/ uncovered) Bucket Bush Others
Source: 2009 Census Figure 2.1.10 Households by Main Mode of Human Waste Disposal and District Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 9 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Nairobi West East North Westlands Electricity Pressure lamp Lantern Tin lamp Gas lamp Fuel wood Solar Others
Source: 2009 Census Figure 2.1.11 Households by Main Type of Lighting Fuel and District 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 % Nairobi Nairobi West Nairobi East Nairobi North Westlands
Source: 2009 Census Figure 2.1.12 Percentage of Households by Ownership of Household Assets and District Safety and security issue has been raised as priority social concerned during stakeholder meetings. Various socio-economic factors can be attributed to the increasing insecurity in Nairobi City County. Such factors including increasing population leading to congestion in some residential areas, unemployment, poverty, poor living standards, lack of education and civic responsibility have overtime made safety and security a key issue of concern in Nairobi City County. Poor planning, design and management are some of the numerous factors that give rise to crime and violence in cities. (3) Position of Nairobis Industries In the East African Community (EAC), Kenyas Gross National Income (GNI) is the largest accounting for 40.5% while the second largest Tanzanias share is 28.8% in 2011. Kenyas GNI per capita is also the highest at US$ 820 in the same year as shown in Figure 2.1.12, although it is still below the threshold of the lower middle income countries of US$ 1,026 at 2011 prices.
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 10 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Gross Regional Domestic Product (GRDP) per capita of Nairobi City is estimated at 3 times the Kenyas average Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita, and its GRDP is estimated at 24.4% of Kenyas GDP. The GRDP is larger than Rwandas GDP. 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 0 10,000,000 20,000,000 30,000,000 40,000,000 50,000,000 G N I
p e r
C a p i t a
( U S $ ) Population Kenya Tanzania Uganda Rwanda Burundi
Source: World Development Indicators website (2013) Figure 2.1.13 Population and GNI per Capita in 2011 The EAC started a common market system in 2010 and moving toward further integration, while issues remain in harmonization of domestic systems to the EAC rules, elimination of non-tariff barriers, and relations with other international communities. Integration of the EAC member countries provides Kenya with an opportunity for expansion of its industries while requires their competitiveness. (4) Outline of Kenyas Industries As shown in Tables 2.1.6-2.1.9, agriculture and forestry has the largest share of 24.0% in GDP, followed by wholesale and retail (10.6%), transportation and communications (9.7%), and manufacturing (9.4%) in 2011. In terms of growth rate, financial business is fastest growing at 7.8% per annum followed by wholesale and retail (7.3%) and mining and quarrying (7.1%) in the same year. Two top export earners are tea (21.2% of the total export value) and horticultural produce including cut flowers (17.3%). The fastest growing export commodities are tobacco and tobacco products (76.4% per annum), leather products (71.9%), and soda ash (70.3%) but the share of each of them is less than 4%. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 11 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 2.1.6 GDP Shares in 2011 (provisional) Rank Sector Share (%) 1 Agriculture and forestry 24.0 2 Wholesale and retail 10.6 3 Transportation and communications 9.7 4 Manufacturing 9.4 5 Financial business 6.4 6 Education 5.8 Source: Economic Survey 2012 Table 2.1.7 Real GDP Growth Rates in 2011 (provisional) Rank Sector Growth rate (%) 1 Financial business 7.8 2 Wholesale and retail 7.3 3 Mining and quarrying 7.1 4 Hotels and restaurants 5.0 5 Education 4.9 6 Transportation and communications 4.5 Source: Economic Survey 2012 Table 2.1.8 Shares in Export in 2011 (provisional) Rank Sector Share (%) 1 Tea 21.2 2 Flowers 17.3 3 Garments and accessories 4.6 4 Coffee 4.0 5 Tobacco and tobacco products 3.9 6 Steel 3.8 Source: Economic Survey 2012 Table 2.1.9 Growth Rates in Export in 2011 (provisional) Rank Sector Growth rate (%) 1 Tobacco and tobacco products 76.4 2 Leather products 71.9 3 Soda ash 70.3 4 Steel 49.8 5 Essential oil 43.6 6 Organic oil 43.2 Source: Economic Survey 2012 (5) Overall Situation and General Issues of Industries of Nairobi City 1) Overall Situation of Industries Among the wage employment in 2012, the community, social and personal services sector has the highest share (52.1%), the agriculture and forestry sector has the second share (24.1%), and the wholesale and retail trade, restaurants and hotels section has the third share (7.2%) according to the Statistical Abstract 2012. The manufacturing sector accounts for only 3.0%. It seems that the total wage employment of 538,571 is too small, the share of agriculture and forestry is too large, and that of manufacturing is too small. However the apparent incompatibility of the data may be due to the definition of the wage employment. (Figure 2.1.14) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 12 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Agriculture & forestry, 129,695 Mining & quarring, 421 Manufacturing, 16,110 Electricity & water, 560 Construction, 33,232 Wholesale & retail, restaurants & hotels, 38,782 Transport & communications, 22,144 Finance, insurance, real estate & business services, 17,277 Community, social & personal services, 280,350
Source: Statistical Abstract 2012, KNBS Figure 2.1.14 Wage Employment by Industry in 2011 (provisional) The estimated distribution of employees of business establishments registered in NCC reflects the concentration of commercial and service businesses in the relatively small area of the CBD and that of manufacturing businesses in Makadara Division, as well as an overall dominance of the services sector. (Figure 2.1.15) In addition, the informal employments are thought to be distributed partly according to the formal employment and partly to the population distribution. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 13 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Note: Agriculture includes forestry and fishing, industry comprises mining, manufacturing, construction, electricity and water, and services means the rest, as in the World Development Report. Businesses not registered in the NCC are not included. Source: Business Registration Data of the NCC Figure 2.1.15 Estimated Distribution of Employees of Business Establishments Registered in the NCC 2) General Issues and Directions for Improvement of Industries General issues and directions for improvement of industries in Nairobi City are summarized in Table 2.1.10. Table 2.1.10 General Issues and Directions for Improvement of Industries in Nairobi City (1/2) General Issues Directions for Improvement (i) Industrial structure Lack of competitive skills Skill levels vary a lot. The informal light manufacturing (J ua Kali) is yet to improve their product quality, otherwise they cannot maintain the market share. Nairobi needs a larger number of highly skilled and specialized small enterprises. Improve the skills mainly through business linkages and by responding to market needs. High cost structure Extra costs are incurred by costly power, traffic congestion, and insecurity in addition to not-so-low labour costs. (Figure 2.1.16) Improve efficiency of the economic system including efficiency of labour, infrastructure and utilities. Lack of linkages Due to mismatch of quality, costs, etc, inter-business linkages are weak. Figure 2.1.17 shows gaps between large, medium, small, and micro/individual businesses. It also shows general supporting organisations and their major targets. Line agencies and the NCC should support directly or indirectly businesses in various sizes. Deepen inter-business linkages as well as linkages with major buyers such as government organizations and super markets. Weak competitiveness Freer importation including in-flow of counterfeits is dominating the market and destroying local businesses. Overall efforts to strengthen competitiveness and to find areas with relative advantages, so that protectionismis not necessary. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 14 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 2.1.10 General Issues and Directions for Improvement of Industries in Nairobi City (2/2) (ii) Basic and socio-economic conditions Lack of available land Given the current land use and transportation conditions, land of Nairobi appears to be mostly saturated, although a lot of spaces are underutilized. Efficient land use at selected locations and relocation of space-intensive functions to the environs. Open up new spaces for various business activities by such means as vertical mixed use. Lack of public safety Lack of safety and its reputation are destroying Kenya's tourismpotential. It also incurs extra costs and impedes many business activities. A full set of measures ranging fromimmediate counter measures to longer-term socio-economic bottom-up strategies. (Table 2.1.11) (iii) Infrastructure Traffic congestion Traffic congestion wastes a huge amount of time cost and fuel cost, deteriorating Kenya's business climate. A full set of measures ranging fromimmediate counter measures including traffic management by ICT to longer-termstructural measures such as shift to multi-centric urban structure. Unreliable and costly power supply Unreliable power supply necessitates generators of each business incurring additional investment and operation costs. Power development can be regarded as a private business opportunity as PPP. Develop new large and small energy sources and optimize energy operation. Insufficient waste management service Coupled with lack of public safety, wastes have invaded many potentially attractive streets. Clean Nairobi campaign linked with safe tourismdevelopment. (iv) Institutional system Lack of finance Small enterprises in need of financial support such as ICT entrepreneurs have difficulties in obtaining loans with concern about unpredictable outcome. Open up various financial channels at various levels ranging fromintegration of loan provision and consulting services for MSMEs (Micro Small and MediumEnterprises) to PPP schemes for larger enterprises. Inefficient administrative procedure "An Investment Guide to Kenya" (2012) points out that investors may face delays of refunds of VAT, withholding taxes and customs clearance. Doing Business Rank of Kenya in 2013 is 121 in 185 economies. Improve the doing business rank by efficient administrative, tax and customprocedures, and also smooth inter-agency collaboration to support businesses. NCC can play expanded roles in an efficient way. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST)
0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 U S $ Low range of 12 month payment of general factory worker (city) GDP per capita in 2011 (country)
Sources: World Development Indicators website (2013) and J apan External Trade Organization (J ETRO) website (2013) Figure 2.1.16 Comparison of GDP per Capita and Typical Labour Cost Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 15 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Enterprise Sizes General supporting organizations - > International and national large enterprises Kenia Investment Authority (KenInvest) gap Medium size enterprises gap Kenya Industrial Estates Ltd. (KIE) < - Small size enterprises gap Micro and Small Enterprise Authority (MSEA) Micro and individual businesses Nairobi City County Line agencies F o r m a l
s e c t o r
1 m i l l i o n
j o b s < - I n f o r m a l
s e c t o r
0 . 8
m i l l i o n
j o b s - >
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Note: MSEA under Ministry of Industrialization and Enterprise Development is the former Department of Micro and Small Enterprise Development (DMSED) of Ministry of Labour. Figure 2.1.17 Gap Structure of Industries of Nairobi Table 2.1.11 Some Causes for Lack of Public Safety and Candidate Measures Causes Candidate Measures Remarks Lack of safety services and equipment - Insufficient police service and police posts. - Lack of street lights. - Lack of CCTV. - Public facilities without safety considerations. - High fences of parks. - Enhance police activities, police posts and community policing. - Increase street lights. - Enhance CCTV system. - Equip public toilets with safety measures, eg CCTV and siren. - Establish safe public transport system. - Lower fences of parks.
Exclusion of people frompublic facilities, amenities and services - Worsened access to public facilities, amenities and services, eg social/community halls, open spaces and parks, etc. - Improve public facilities, amenities and services and access to themincluding temporary pedestrian or play zones. - Involve the youth and the community in improving and sustaining them.
Socio-economic conditions - Unemployment, underemployment, working poverty. - Gap between rich and poor (privileged and under-privileged). - Incidence of corruption. - Lack of hope. - Lack of family care and education at home, schools and communities. - Generate employment. - Seek inclusive and bottom-up development (as well as top-up). - Strengthen anti-corruption measures. - Shift fromvested interest to meritocracy. - Enhance community care and safety campaigns. Kenya ranks at 107 out of 134 countries in Gini Index that shows inequality in income or expenditure within each country (Table 2.1.12). External conditions - Domestic and international in-migration of under-privileged people.
- Balance support measures and enforcement of rules to address such migration.
Note: Accidents, pollution, disasters and terrorismare not explicitly considered here. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on interviews with Nairobi County Business Association (NCBA) (2013) and Mr. Elijah Agevi (2013) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 16 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 2.1.12 Gini Index of Selected Countries Rank Country 2000- Rank Country 2000- 1 Sweden 25.0 68 Israel 39.2 2 Norway 25.8 69 Guinea 39.4 3 Finland 26.9 70 Kyrgyz Republic 39.5 4 Afghanistan 27.8 71 Burkina Faso 39.6 5 Belarus 27.9 72 Chad 39.8 6 Bulgaria 28.2 73 Djibouti 40.0 7 Ukraine 28.2 74 Sri Lanka 40.3 8 Germany 28.3 75 Nicaragua 40.5 9 Croatia 29.0 76 United States 40.8 10 Austria 29.2 77 Morocco 40.9 11 Ethiopia 29.8 78 Georgia 41.1 12 Slovak Republic 29.8 79 Qatar 41.1 13 Hungary 30.0 80 Mauritania 41.3 14 Montenegro 30.1 81 Tunisia 41.4 15 Kazakhstan 30.8 82 Gabon 41.5 16 Luxembourg 30.8 83 Cote d'Ivoire 41.5 17 Iraq 30.9 84 Cambodia 41.9 18 Slovenia 31.2 85 Thailand 42.4 19 Pakistan 31.2 86 China 42.5 20 Romania 31.6 87 Sierra Leone 42.5 21 Egypt, Arab Rep. 32.1 88 Turkey 42.6 22 Canada 32.6 89 Uganda 42.6 23 Belgium 33.0 90 Angola 42.7 24 Albania 33.0 91 Ghana 42.8 25 Bangladesh 33.2 92 Nigeria 42.9 26 Burundi 33.3 93 Central African Republic 43.6 27 India 33.4 94 Nepal 43.8 28 Serbia 33.4 95 Niger 43.9 29 Tajikistan 33.6 96 Philippines 44.0 30 Switzerland 33.7 97 Congo, Dem. Rep. 44.4 31 Azerbaijan 33.7 98 Jamaica 45.5 32 Indonesia 34.0 99 South Sudan 45.5 33 Greece 34.3 100 Uruguay 45.9 34 Ireland 34.3 101 Fiji 46.8 35 Togo 34.4 102 Mozambique 47.1 36 Spain 34.7 103 Madagascar 47.2 37 Poland 34.9 104 Gambia, The 47.3 38 Sudan 35.3 105 Congo, Rep. 47.3 39 Guinea-Bissau 35.5 106 Costa Rica 47.6 40 Latvia 35.7 107 Kenya 47. 7 41 Vietnam 35.8 108 Argentina 49.3 42 Bosnia and Herzegovina 35.8 109 Venezuela, RB 49.5 43 Syrian Arab Republic 35.8 110 El Salvador 50.3 44 Lithuania 35.8 111 Cape Verde 50.5 45 Estonia 36.0 112 Swaziland 50.7 46 Italy 36.0 113 Sao Tome and Principe 50.8 47 Armenia 36.2 114 Dominican Republic 51.1 48 Moldova 36.3 115 Peru 51.1 49 Mongolia 36.5 116 Mexico 51.2 50 Uzbekistan 36.7 117 Chile 51.8 51 Lao PDR 36.7 118 Paraguay 52.5 52 Maldives 37.4 119 Lesotho 52.5 53 Russian Federation 37.5 120 Rwanda 53.1 54 Tanzania 37.6 121 Panama 54.0 55 Yemen, Rep. 37.7 122 Ecuador 54.1 56 Jordan 37.7 123 Zambia 54.6 57 Malaysia 37.9 124 Guatemala 55.9 58 Bhutan 38.1 125 Colombia 56.1 59 Liberia 38.2 126 Brazil 57.4 60 Iran, Islamic Rep. 38.3 127 Bolivia 57.8 61 Benin 38.6 128 Haiti 59.2 62 West Bank and Gaza 38.7 129 Honduras 59.7 63 Cameroon 38.9 130 Micronesia, Fed. Sts. 61.1 64 Mali 39.0 131 Namibia 63.9 65 Malawi 39.0 132 Comoros 64.3 66 Macedonia, FYR 39.1 133 Seychelles 65.8 67 Senegal 39.2 134 South Africa 67.4
Source: World Development Indicators website (2013) Note: Gini index in 2005 or in the 2000s. Gini index measures inequality of income or consumption expenditure among individuals or households within an economy. A Gini index of 0 represents perfect equality, while an index of 100 implies perfect inequality Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 17 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (6) Current Situation of Industries in the Environs Based on the District Development Plans (2008-2012), industries of the surrounding districts of Nairobi City can be outlined as follows. It is noted that the description of each district is for the whole district and not limited to the part within the Greater Nairobi. 1) Thika District (Gatanga Division, Githurai Division, Kakuzi Division, Ruiru Division, Thika Municipality) Outline Around the urban centre of Thika and Ruiru along Thika Highway, a number of factories are located as well as J omo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology (J KUAT). Historically, Thika District is one of the leading industrial districts in Kenya besides undertaking agricultural activities on both large and small scales. Proximity to Nairobi City provides a ready market to the agricultural produce. Primary industry The main cash crops are coffee, tea, pineapples and macadamia while the main food crops are maize, beans, Irish potatoes and pigeon peas. Most of the farming in the district is rain-fed except for the large scale pineapple production by the multinationals and the coffee estates. Besides crop farming, livestock farming is undertaken in the district. The main livestock are dairy cattle, dairy goat, meat goat, poultry and beekeeping. The cooperative sector is central in marketing of agricultural produce and products. It also assists in provision of credit and farminputs. Secondary & tertiary industries There are small, mediumand large scale businesses including 16 chemical and 15 engineering industries. 2) Kiambu East District (Githunguri Division, Kiambu Municipality, Kiambaa Division) Outline Due to close proximity to Nairobi City and jobs at coffee and tea estates among others, the district is well populated and the land has been fragmented into small and inefficient pieces. Primary industry The main food crops grown are maize, beans, Irish potatoes and vegetables whereas the major cash crops are coffee, tea and horticultural crops. Due to the emphasis on cash crops, the district is importing food from neighbouring districts. Several agro-processing factories can be accessed and so production of livestock and livestock products has been increasing. Secondary & tertiary industries The industries are mostly operated by the informal sector. The districts tourist attractions include the house of the first president J omo Kenyatta. 3) Kiambu West District (Limuru Division, Kikuyu Division, Lari Division, Ndeiya Division) Outline The growing population working in the district or commuting to Nairobi City is leading to reduction of arable land. Primary industry The district has been predominantly agricultural. The main food crops are maize, beans, Irish potatoes and vegetables whereas the major cash crops are coffee, tea, pyrethrum, horticultural products and flowers. Several agro-processing factories can be accessed and so production of livestock and livestock products has been increasing. Secondary & tertiary industries The district has agro-industries such as milk processing firms and large tea factories. 4) Kajiado District (Ngong Division, Central Division, Magadi Division, Isinya Division, Namanga Division, Mashuru Division, Ewaso Kendong Division) Outline With the change from group ranches to the individual land tenure systemand owing to either agricultural potential or proximity to Nairobi City, immigration has increased to some locations such as Ngong and Kitengela. Primary industry Kajiado is an arid and semi-arid lands (ASAL) district and livestock keeping has been the dominant economic activity although there has been a reduction in livestock population due to droughts. Secondary & tertiary industries The vast mineral deposit around Lake Magadi is a main source of soda ash. The largest deposits at Mile 46 and Loodikalani area can be exploited for commercial purposes. Proximity to Athi River Export Processing Zone is an advantage. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 18 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 5) Machakos District (Athi River/Mavoko Division, Central Division, Kalama Division, Kathiani Division) Outline The district has relatively high population density along the hills in Kathiani Division, in Athi River, along Mombasa Road and in Machakos Town due to fertile soils and high rainfall for agriculture. Low plains where ranching and dairy farming are carried out are sparsely populated. Primary industry Agriculture contributes a majority of the household income. Livestock rearing is generally practiced on a small scale. Secondary & tertiary industries Athi River Export Processing Zone was established in 1990. Besides that, the sector is not well developed due partly to over reliance on rain-fed agriculture. 6) Kangundo District (Matungulu Division, Kangundo Division) Outline Agriculture, livestock production and informal sector businesses are major economic activities. Primary industry The production of the main crops in the district, including maize, has been fluctuating over the years due to low, unpredictable, erratic and inadequate rainfall. This has created food insecurity among the general population. Other key issues affecting farmers in the district include declining soil fertility and high percentage of post harvest crop losses. All these factors have been influenced by the use of poor quality seeds, inadequate farminputs, frequent droughts, and poor storage as well as lack of market, transportation, and processing. The major cash crops grown in the district are coffee and horticultural products in some parts. Of forests, the district has a total of 7,420 ha of gazetted forests. The major threat is the forest destruction for timber and firewood. The revitalization of Kenya Meat Commission (KMC) has provided a ready market for livestock. Secondary & tertiary industries Most retail and wholesale traders are small scale and in the informal sector. Ndonyo Sambuk National Park has tourismdevelopment potential. (7) Doing Business Procedures According to "Doing Business 2013" International Finance Corporation 2013, Kenyas aggregate ranking on the ease of doing business is 121 out of 185 countries. Kenya ranks high at 12 in getting credit for strong legal rights and deep credit information, while low at 164 in paying taxes mainly for time taken for the procedure. (Figure 2.1.18) NCC is related to starting a business, dealing with construction permits, getting electricity, registering property, and paying taxes. It is required to raise the aggregate ranking by concerted efforts of the responsible agencies. (Table 2.1.13) 185 165 145 125 105 85 65 45 25 5 Rank Kenya Sub- Saharan Africa Average
Source: "Doing Business 2013" International Finance Corporation 2013 Figure 2.1.18 Doing Business Ranks of Kenya in 185 Economies in 2013 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 19 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 2.1.13 Doing Business Ranks of Kenya in 185 Economies in 2013 Topic Kenya Sub- Saharan Africa Average Tasks of CCN Department of NCC in charge Major factors of low ranking Aggregate ranking in 185 economies in 2013 121 140 1 Starting a business 126 123 Issuing business permits Business licensing Department 2 Dealing with construction permits 45 117 Approval of architectural plans Technical Committee Approval of structural plans and final building permits City Planning Department (Development Control Section) and City Engineer Department (Structural Section) Inspection after construction City Planning Department (Enforcement Section) Occupancy certificates City Planning Department (Enforcement Section) Water and sewerage connection Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company 3 Getting electricity 162 127 Excavation permits City Engineer Department Typical total time taken is 146 days. 4 Registering property 161 123 Issuing rates clearance certificates Ministry of Lands (National Land Commission) is in charge but Nairobi City County (Department of Legal Affairs) facilitates the procedure. Typical total time taken is 73 days. 5 Getting credit 12 109 6 Protecting investors 100 115 7 Paying taxes 164 123 Property tax/Rents Privately-owned land : Ground rates annually paid to Niaorbi City County (City Treasurery) Ground rents annually paid to Ministry of Lands (National Land Commission) NCC-owned land : Rents monthly paid to Nairobi City County (Department of Social Services and Housing) Typical time taken per year is 340 hours. 8 Trading across borders 148 137 Time and cost for trade are burdens. 9 Enforcing contracts 149 120 Typical number of procedures is 44. 10 Resolving insolvancy 100 128
Source: "Doing Business 2013" International Finance Corporation 2013 2.1.4 Current Environmental Status of Nairobi (1) Baseline Descriptions of Current Nairobi Nairobi City, located at 1,600 to 1,850 m above sea level, covers an area of about 700 km2 at the south-eastern end of Kenyas agricultural heartland, and has tolerable climate throughout the year. The western part of the city is the highest, with a mountainous topography, while the eastern side is lower and generally flat terrain. The Nairobi, Ngong, and Mathare Rivers run through the city area, and most of household and industrial effluents are directly discharged into those rives without any proper treatments. Minor earthquakes and tremors occasionally shake the city since Nairobi exists next to the Rift Valley, which is active due to the tectonic movement therein. In 1901, there were only 8,000 people living in Nairobi. By 1948, the population number had grown to 118, 000 and reached 343,500 habitants by 1962. Currently, that number is projected to be 3.8 million by 2015. Much of Nairobis urban area is classified as the unplanned settlement, driven by the rapid population growth and the urban poverty. Sprawling informal settlements hamper the spreading of citys baseline social services and eventually leading to deterioration of the quality of life therein. In the early 1990s, it was reported that over half of the citys population lived in those unplanned settlements. Recently, this large and rapid growing population of Nairobi City has begun to trigger environmental degradations and cause some negative impacts on the human health and the economy. (2) Major Environmental Issues Followings are summary of recent environmental issues raised for the entire city [NCC, 2007]. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 20 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 2.1.14 Environmental Issues of Nairobi 1. Rapid Urbanization Nairobis physical expansion has come at expense of natural environment. Urban sprawl and construction of roads and other city infrastructure has led to loss of forests and other natural areas. As a result, forest coverage was receded and was replaced by coffee plantations. Later, demand for food for growing population led to transformation of the citys outskirts to other agricultural uses, which in turn were threatened by further urban growth. 2. Protected Ecosystem/or Green Spaces Nairobi has managed to retain a number of green spaces within and close to city, which provide its residents with shady recreation areas and visitors with glimpse of Kenyas wildlife and vegetation. They also help to maintain biodiversity, filter pollutants from air, and act as minor water catchments within and on outskirts of city. Although these green spaces have been protected, much of natural vegetation surrounding Nairobi was lost as citys boundaries were extended numerous times to accommodate growing population and3zxssss associated need for more land. As city expanded after its founding, much of new settlement was unplanned. 3. Informal Settlement Nairobis rapid growth increased demand for land and led to inappropriate land allocation, forcing poor to settle in fragile and unsavory areas where they face hardships due to lack of proper housing and public services and where they are vulnerable to environmental change. Urban poverty, lack of employment opportunities, and inadequate urban planning also conspired in gradual growth of informal settlements in Nairobi since citys founding. People living in Nairobis informal settlements, particularly slums, usually find themselves in citys most fragile areas, such as flood plains, steep slopes, river valleys, or adjacent to sewers or dump sites. Dandora Municipal Dumping site, which receives most of citys solid waste, is only about eight (8) kilometers from Nairobis centre and is surrounded by low-income residential area. This situation exposes slum residents to floods, land-slides, and health risks from contaminants. In addition, they live in overcrowded conditions with poor sanitation, inadequate and unsafe water, make-shift shelters, and unstable social networks. They also face high degree of tenure insecurity since most of these settlements are illegal, exposing them to constant threat of harassment and eviction. 4. Air Pollution Main sources of atmospheric pollution are vehicles, industries, emissions from use of charcoal and firewood, and other municipal sources such as open burning of waste. Increasing number of cars in city intensifies traffic and pollution problems. Vehicles emit significant levels of air pollutants, including greenhouse gases and precursors of smog. Charcoal burning, very prevalent energy source in city, emits methane (CH4) and carbon monoxide (CO) and sends tiny particulates into air. Air pollution adversely affects human health and environment. Particulates are associated with respiratory and eye diseases such as asthma, lung cancer, and conjunctivitis, especially in young and elderly who are more vulnerable. Air pollution is also major contributor to effects such as acid rain, which has been responsible for much damage to soil, fish resources, and vegetation, often very far from the emission sources. 5. Water Pollution Citys wastewater management has not kept up with increasing demands from growing population and is inadequate to treat amount of industrial and municipal effluent entering Nairobi River and other surface waters. Nairobi has changed from a place of cool waters to one in which the water is no longer potable or fit for many other useful purposes. Numbers of factories in Nairobis industrial area discharge waste directly into Ngong River, making it most polluted river in Kenya. Industrial waste effluents include petro-chemicals and metals from micro-enterprises and J ua-kali. As well, oil and grease from busy roads Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 21 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya run off into adjacent waters. Nairobi River also receives improperly treated effluents from Dandora Sewage Treatment Plant and several drainage channels that gather storm water from Nairobi City. Domestic garbage from informal settlements that have no public waste collection services also finds itself into river as does sewage from pit latrines and other on-site sewerage-disposal methods. Sanitation facilities are very basic in many informal settlements, consisting of earth drains, communal water points, pit latrines shared by many people, and no systematic solid-waste disposal. Improperly treated sewerage and uncollected garbage have contributed to vicious cycle of water pollution, water-borne diseases, poverty, and environmental degradation. Water pollution carries environmental and health risks to communities within Nairobi, especially poor who may use untreated water in their homes and to irrigate their gardens. Farmers along Nairobi River and its tributaries commonly use polluted waters and raw sewage for irrigation, exposing both farm workers and customers who consume the food crops to potential health problems. Almost half of the vegetables consumed in city of Nairobi are grown on banks of polluted rivers. All these impacts affect human health and productivity and challenge Kenyas ability to reach targets under Millennium Development Goals. 6. Sanitation Nairobi faces enormous challenges in providing adequate public sanitation facilities, sewage disposal, and refuse collection, problem that is compounded as the population increases. Improperly treated sewerage and uncollected garbage have contributed to vicious cycle of water pollution, water-borne diseases, poverty, and environmental degradation. 7. Solid Waste Management Waste management is growing problem in Nairobi. Increasing urbanization, rural-urban migration, rising standards of living, and rapid development associated with population growth have resulted in increased solid waste generation by industrial, domestic, and other activities. This increase has not been accompanied by equivalent growth in capacity to address the problem. Proper management of waste has thus become one of most pressing and challenging environmental problems in city. Among of them, listed in above table,Issues 1 (rapid urbanization), 3 (informal settlement), 5 (water pollution), 6 (sanitation) and 7 (solid waste management) are addressed by other sections of this study report. So, main focuses are addressed to Issues 2 (protected ecosystem/or green spaces) and 4 (air quality) within the environmental sector of this proposed MP study, and specific issues to be addressed for the selection of the priority project within the environmental sector are summarized in Chapter 5 of this proposed MP study. (3) Recent Air Quality Degradation of Nairobi Currently, some parts of Nairobi, with heavy traffic volumes, are facing severe urban air quality degradation, and current reports and/or available data indicate that the local air quality along several major roads has been rapidly deteriorated. These are mainly the result of human activities in the transport as well as energy and industrial sectors. The situation is getting worse with the increasing population and relevant growth in vehicle number, growing industrial area, deforestation on the citys fringes and increased construction works. The impacts of air pollution range from the ecological to the socio-economic one. These include loss of the biodiversity; damages to the vegetation, buildings and animal health due to the acid rain; and eventually lead to the climate change in the long term. It also affects not only the human health but also the visibility which may result in increased traffic accidents or create unpleasant living environments. The growing incidence of the pollution is thus creating new challenges for the environmental integrity. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 22 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (4) On-Site Urban Air Quality Survey In the past, several on-site roadside air quality studies were conducted around the CBD of Nairobi. Followings are major results of those studies, Air Quality Survey 1 (Odhiambo et. al, 2010). Survey Period: Feb-April 2003 Survey Results Lead (0.051 - 1.106 g/m3) NO2 (0.011-0.976 ppm) NO (0.001-0.2628 ppm) PM10 (66.66 - 444.45 g/m3) Remarks Study results show strong correlation between fine (0.4 m) particulates, NOx, and motor vehicle density, indicating urban traffic as major source for both fine particulates & NOx air quality. It is noted that specific description of this survey program was not provided, so that direct comparison with WHO Guideline values are not possible but comparable for this preliminary evaluation. WHO Air Quality Guideline PM10: 20 g/m3 Annual mean 50 g/m3 24-hour mean
Air Quality Survey 2 (Kinney et.al., 2012) PM2.5 is of Concern Survey Period: J uly 2009 Survey Results Measured values ranging between 128.7 and 18.7 g/m3 were observed at 100 m downwind of major intersections in Nairobi. WHO Air Quality Guideline PM2.5: 10 g/m3 Annual mean 25 g/m3 24-hour mean Remarks Vertical dispersion experiment revealed decrease from 119.5 g/m3 at the street level to 42.8 g/m3 on 3rd-floor rooftop in CBD. It is noted that specific description of this survey program was not provided, so that direct comparison with WHO Guideline values are not possible but comparable for this preliminary evaluation. It is noted that no long-term continuous air quality survey and/or monitoring work has not been conducted across the Nairobi City, yet [Gato, personal communication, 2013]. However, the total number of vehicles circulating inside of the city has been increased continuously, and the entire traffic condition such as the local traffic jams is getting worse without any significant change of the city infrastructure. So, it is highly likely that current city-wide air quality condition is getting deteriorated further than the time when those two air quality studies were conducted. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 23 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Currently, Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development (former Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development) is preparing for the study report in collaboration with the University of Nairobi (Gota, personal communication, 2013). (5) Vehicle Inspection and Maintenance (I/M) System 1) Current Vehicle I/M Framework In Kenya, the vehicle inspection and maintenance is administrated by the National Transport and Safety Authority (NTSA), the Ministry of Transport and Infrastructure after October 2013 (note: it was organized by Motor Vehicle Inspection Unit of Kenya Police previously). According to Traffic Act, Chapter 403 Law of Kenya, owners of public service vehicles (PVSs) and/or commercial vehicles have to take inspection every year for the renewal of their registrations. However, the legal enforcement of this law does not seem to be appropriate and most of PVSs and commercial vehicles circulating across the city are ill-conditioned, and emitting black smokes frequently. It is noted that there is no specific regulation for I/M for passenger cars, yet. 2) Vehicle I/M for Imported Used Vehicles In Nairobi, certain amount of vehicles circulating are imported used vehicles. Those imported used vehicles are inspected before the shipping from designated countries such as J apan, UAE, UK, Singapore and South Africa under Kenya Bureau of Standards (KEBS) Regulation (Legal Notice 78 of 15/07/2005). KEBS has signed contracts with several overseas inspection organizations such as Auto Terminal J apan Ltd (ATJ ), J apan Export Vehicle Inspection Center Co. Ltd (J EVIC) and Quality Inspection Services Inc J apan (QISJ ) for pre-export verifications of the conformity to standards for used vehicles. Basically, those international inspection companies are paying respect KEBS rules, so that most of just imported used vehicles are relatively well-conditioned in the beginning, but tend to be ill-conditioned after the long-term vehicle usage with improper vehicle inspection and maintenance [Toyotsu, personal communication, 2013] due to the weak legal enforcement of the current vehicle inspection law. (6) Air Pollution and Human Health Good health is a basic component of the sound human society and a necessity for earning a livelihood. The main health issues in Nairobi include the access to health facilities, the child and the maternal mortality and the incidences of certain diseases such as HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis and malaria, and others, and most of these diseases are closely related to the state of the natural and social environment. Recent data shows that the leading cause of the mortality is respiratory ailments. In 2000, the respiratory disease and the malaria accounted for over 50 per cent of all deaths in the city. The five most important causes of the mortality in children under five include the acute respiratory infection (ARI), diarrhea, measles, malaria, malnutrition and anemia (see Table 2.1.15). All these are closely related to the living environment. Table 2.1.15 Top Ten Major Causes of Mortality in Nairobi (1998- 2000) 1998 1999 2000 Respiratory symptoms 37.0 27.0 35.5 Malaria 23.1 18.8 14.7 Accident - 14.2 10.0 Skin disease 14.4 6.6 7.7 Diarrhea 9.3 8.3 9.5 Urinary tract disease 4.6 Not indicated 6.0 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 24 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 1998 1999 2000 Intestinal worms 4.1 Not indicated Not indicated Disease of puerperium and child birth 3.9 7.3 Not indicated Eye infections 3.2 7.9 6.7 Ear infections - 9.4 0.8 Source: City of Nairobi Outlook, 2007 (7) Heat Island and Green Space Importance of the conservation of several ecosystems such as forest reserves and the national park is already mentioned in several prominent study reports [e.g., UNEP, 2009], so that the interaction between the urban infrastructure and the green spaces/or green belt are mainly focused in order to achieve the sound urban environment in this section. The urban geometry is one of the important factors leading to the modification of the local urban climate. Specifically, the urban land use pattern and its building/or housing complex geometry that relates to the urban canopy layer (UCL) influences aspects such as increased substrate heat storage due to the greater thermal admittance of the surface materials and decreased latent heat fluxes arising from the replacement of the soil and vegetated surfaces such as the green spaces with impervious materials. It also leads to increase in the solar radiation absorption due to the lower albedo of urban materials and reduced wind speeds caused by the aerodynamically rougher urban fabric. There is also the release of human activity-related heat from domestic, commercial, industrial and transport energy sources and increased atmospheric radiation absorption from green house gases. According to the current report [Makokha and Shisanya, 2010], it is reported that the thermal behavior of the several urban landscapes showed noticeable differences in their cooling and warming rates over the four different climatic periods of Nairobi city. The largest cooling and warming rates were generally found during the hot-dry period while the lowest during the cool-dry period. Except for the cool-dry period, all the remaining three periods had the urban canyon and the urban park and green space sites record lower cooling rates than the suburban site. Also, it is reported that the highest cooling rates were recorded at the suburban site while the lowest at the urban site. The reduced cooling rates at the urban site were attributed to increased heat absorption by the urban fabric. Generally the urban park sites and/or green spaces show relatively moderate cooling and warming rates, due to the moderating effects of those vegetations. Therefore, to reduce excessive nocturnal heat loads and increase nocturnal cooling, the urban landscape shall have adequate open and green spaces, which will enhance the air circulation and less radiation absorption during the day. Furthermore, it would be beneficial to establish wind path through the appropriate location of urban green spaces leading to establishment of a smooth citywide air circulation that would sweep away the accumulated pollutants inside of CBD, mentioned in previous section (Figure 2.1.19).
Strategies to Improve (10) Wind Path and Green Belt (Land Use) Keep space for wind passing through city. Wind Building Complex Dispersion of accumulated Pollutants or Heats Wind Blowing through planned Building Complex Area
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 2.1.19 Creation of Urban Wind Path through Design of Sustainable Urban Land Use Pattern Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 25 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (8) Summary From this review, it can be said that the current environmental and social issues Nairobi City faces is regarded as the compound one, so that, those issues shall be addressed through the comprehensive, integrated approach addressing not only environmental factors but also other relevant aspects such as city-wide land use, transport policy, energy, the social system, governance and enforcement. 2.2 Review of Urban Conditions 2.2.1 Analysis of Present Land Use (1) Land hold and land tenure A land hold (land ownership) and a land tenure are distinguished clearly in Kenya. About 80% of lands in Nairobi is owned by the Government, but those lands are held by several types of users. About 41% of government lands (33% of total land) were alienated to private and other parties. Table 2.2.1 Land Use by Land Hold in Nairobi Category Sub category Area(sq.km) % Government land 1) Forest reserve 21 3.1 2) Other government reserve 77 11.3 3) Township 93 13.6 4) Alienated land 225 32.9 5) Un-alienated land 16 2.3 6) National parks 117 17.1 7) Open water - - Sub total 549 80.3 Freehold land 8) Smallholder schemes - - 9) Other 135 19.7 Sub total 135 19.7 Grand total 684 100.0 Source: Statistics Abstract 2005 (2) Land use Land use surveys for the whole area of Nairobi city were conducted by Centre of Sustainable Urban Development (CSUD) of Colombia University in collaboration with Nairobi University in 2005 and 2010. The land use map was developed from a combination of analysis o satellite images and ground surveys. The composition of land use is summarised below. Table 2.2.2 Land Use Composition Land Use Area (sq. km) Residential 105.2 15.1% Commercial 5.9 0.8% Industrial 22.2 3.2% Mixed Commercial & Industry 3.6 0.5% Mixed Residential & Commercial 4.2 0.6% Institutional 39.8 5.7% No structures 0.3 0.0% Open space 332.0 47.8% Recreational 8.7 1.3% Res slum 7.8 1.1% Transportation 15.5 2.2% Unknown 42.3 6.1% Water 10.9 1.6% Total 598.2 86.1% National Park 96.9 13.9% Grand total 695.1 100.0% Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 26 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 2.2.1 Land Use Map Done by Columbia and Nairobi University. The J ICA Study Team obtained the satellite images of Nairobi in 2012, and updated the land use map of Colombia University. (3) Land use change during last decade A lot of changes have taken place between 2003 and 2012. Typical land use change in Nairobi is summarised as below. 1) Soil rich farm land to residential area Ridgeways area in 2003 Ridgeways area in 2012
Source: Google Earth Pro Figure 2.2.2 Satellite Image of Ridgeways Area Northern and eastern parts of Nairobi have rich red soil utilised for tea/coffee plantation or other agricultural activities. These plantations have been recently developed into residential areas. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 27 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 2) Grassland to residential area Kasarani, Dandora area in 2003 Kasarani, Dandora area in 2012
Source: Google Earth Pro Figure 2.2.3 Satellite Image of Kasarani, Dandora Area Eastern part of Nairobi is mainly lower grassland and is also changed into residential areas. 3) Detached house to apartment or office Kilimani area in 2003 Kilimani area in 2012
Source: Google Earth Pro Figure 2.2.4 Satellite Image of Kilimani Area Highland in western area of Nairobi was developed as estates for European settlers before the independence. Recently low rise detached houses for single families are converting into high rise apartments or offices. 4) River bank to informal settlements Eastleigh south to Uhuru estate (Nairobi River) in 2003 Eastleigh south to Uhuru estate (Nairobi River) in 2012
Source: Google Earth Pro Figure 2.2.5 Satellite Image of Eastleigh South to Uhuru Estate Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 28 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Informal settlements on river banks are still spreading rapidly. A research paper indicated that half of increased population during last decade settled in so-called slum areas. (4) Typical development pattern and population density These satellite images below show relationship between typical development patterns at different population densities in Nairobi. Karen and Muthaiga area show lowest density in Nairobi of 5 persons/ha, Lavington and Kilimani area show about 20 to 30 persons/ha respectively. Mathare and Huruma area show a highest density over 1,000 persons/ha. European average population density is from 50 to 100 person/ha and United States average is around 10 to 20 persons/ha. The Nairobi Metropolitan Growth Strategy 1973 recommended average density 15 persons per acre (equivalent to 37.5 person/ha). 5 person/ha (2 person/acre) Karen, Muthaiga area
20 person/ha (8 person /acre) Lavinton area
30 person/ha (12 person /acre) Kilimani area
70 person/ha (28 person /acre) Highridge area
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 29 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 100 person/ha (40 person /acre) Kangemi area
300 person/ha (120 person /acre) Kawangware area
500 person/ha (200 person /acre) Eastleigh North
700 person/ha (280 person /acre) Kibera
1,200 person/ha (480 person /acre) Mathare, Huruma area
Source: Google Earth Pro Figure 2.2.6 Typical Development Pattern Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 30 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 2.2.2 Urban Services (1) Educational Services According to the Nairobi City County Department of Education, the total number of enrolled primary schools students in 2011 was 336, 723 compared to 408, 888 in 2012, underscoring either a sharp increase in primary school attendance or inconsistency in the data. Among public primary schools in Nairobi City, the Embakasi-Njiru district has the largest number of schools while Langata and Kamukunji districts have the fewest. Districts such as Starehe and Westlands have almost as many schools as Embakasi and Njiru, a district with almost 2.5 times more primary school students. In addition, there are almost as many non-formal schools as public schools in Nairobi, especially in the Embakasi district and in Kasarani, where there are more non-formal schools than public. Embakasi also covers 35% of the total land area of Nairobi and has the highest rate of growth among all districts. The data suggests evidence of a general discrepancy between the school capacity in Nairobi East and Nairobi West, and an indication of possible overpopulation in Eastland schools. Future planning of educational facilities should concentrate on increasing the number of schools in Nairobi East, in order to minimize overpopulation and align with population growth trends. Table 2.2.3 Number of Schools and Students in Primary Schools in Nairobi, 2012
District Students in Primary School # of Schools 1 DAGORETTI 46,181 25 2 EMBAKASI and NJ IRU 104,566 39 3 KAMUKUNJ I 18,825 16 4 KASARANI 87,791 25 5 LANG'ATA 38,050 15 6 MAKADARA 26,489 30 7 STAREHE 44,685 36 8 WESTLANDS 42,301 30
Total 408,888 216 Source: City Education Department, City Council of Nairobi and Department of Education, Nairobi City County Table 2.2.4 Percentage of Type of Schools by District in Nairobi, 2012
Total 48.2 14.2 37.6 100.0 Source: City Education Department, Nairobi City County (2) Health Services Among the sick population of Nairobi, approximately 47% prefer private health care providers, including private dispensary hospitals and private clinics. Only 8% prefer major public facilities such as public health care centres and district hospitals, though 13% prefer public dispensaries. This infers that private health care facilities may be more appealing for sick, perhaps for reasons of reliability, quality or accessibility or others. Kamukunji and Embakasi have the highest number of major health facilities. Similar to schools, there are almost as many health facilities in Embakasi as in Kasarani and Westlands, though the population of Embakasi is more than both districts combined. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 31 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 2.2.5 Type of Health Care Providers Preferred by Sick Population in Nairobi Source: KNBS Table 2.2.6 Number of Major Health Facilities by District Type of Facility Kamukunji Makadara Dagoretti Langata Starehe West. Kasarani Embakasi Medical Clinic 25 37 12 46 54 63 63 101 Dispensary 13 17 31 24 22 17 41 11 Health Center 7 2 17 7 2 10 16 24 VCT Centre 2 3 9 4 11 2 11 7 Other Hospital 2 3 2 6 4 8 10 5 Nat. Referral Hospital 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 District. Hospital 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 2 Medical Center 1 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 Total Facilities 50 62 73 87 94 103 141 150 Source: E-Health Kenya Facilities According to the World Bank, the Kenyan national average of beds/1,000 people from 2003-2007 was 1.4. However, there is no global target for the number of beds per country, since impatient services vary by several factors, including burden of disease and demographics. Density of beds per population may not be as accurate at assessing adequate health services as health care affordability. Calculations show that the average number of beds per 1,000 people in Nairobi is .74, a significant decrease from the estimated Kenya national average of 1.4. However, as the capital city is expected to have more health facilities than its surrounding cities, there may be some inconsistencies in the data. Similar to schools and major health facilities, Embakasi has as many beds per 1,000 people as Dagoretti, which has a 1/3 the population of the Eastlands district. Table 2.2.7 Beds/1,000 people for All Health Facilities by District Source: E-Health Kenya Facilities (3) Community Facilities Community facilities can be conduits for social activity such as recreational parks, channels for social services such as fire stations or childrens homes, and can also have positive economic benefits for an area, including stadiums and markets. There are 45 markets in Nairobi, owned by Nairobi City County and 26 community halls. Health Care Provider % Private dispensary hospital 23.8 Private clinic 22.8 Pharmacy/chemist 14.1 Public Dispensary 13 Missionary hosp. /disp. 8.4 Referral Hospital 7.9 Public Health Centre 5.1 District Provincial hospital 3.3 Other 0.8 Kiosk 0.8 Traditional Healer/Herbalist N/A District Total # of beds Total Population Beds/1,000 people WESTLANDS 1,093 247,102 0.23 STAREHE 848 274,607 0.32 MAKADARA 332 218,641 0.66 LANGATA 748 355,188 0.47 KASARANI 350 525,624 1.50 KAMUKUNJ I 1,061 261,855 0.25 EMBAKASI 737 925,775 1.26 DAGORETTI 1,845 329,577 1.26 Average #of beds/1,000 people 0.74 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 32 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 1) Temporary Community Facilities It is also important to recognize temporary community facilities, predominantly those that utilize open air parking lots for recreational areas and markets. In the Central Business District, these include skating facilities at Aga Khan Walk and Masaai Market located in the parking lot of the Nairobi Supreme Court. These uses are approved by the City Council, however, due to their temporary nature, may be overlooked among other recreational facilities or more permanent markets. These cultural and recreational areas can serve to provide mixed and changeable uses which stimulate the local economy and social activity within the city. Table 2.2.8 Stadiums and Sport Facilities Name of Facility Location Division Seating Capacity City Stadium J ogoo Road Kaloeleni 15, 000 Moi Stadium Thika Highway Kasarani 60, 000 Nyayo Stadium Uhuru Highway Nairobi West 35, 000 J oseph Kangethe Mini Stadium Woodley Kibera ~10, 000 Kamukunji Kamukunji ~10, 000 J ericho Lumumba J ericho Makadara ~10,000 Desert California ~1,000 Source: NCC 2) Stadiums and Playgrounds There are 7 stadiums in Nairobi, which range in capacity from less than 1,000 spectators at Desert Stadium to 60,000 spectators at Moi Stadium. There are only 18 registered public playgrounds throughout the city which indicates a severe undersupply of recreational and open spaces for the more than 400,000 primary school age children in the city. Table 2.2.9 Public Playgrounds Name of Playground Location Capacity 1. Hamza Makadara J ogoo Road 2. Uhuru Makadara 3. Shauri Moyo Kamukunji 4. Bahati Kamukunji 5. Kaloleni Nxt to Kaloleni Social Hall 6. Buruburu flats (BBF) Buruburu opp. police station 7. Umeme Ziwani 8. Huruma Huruma 9. Ngong road City inspectorate Grounds 10. Canon Apollo Mbotela 11. Kariobangi Next to Kariobangi Social Hall 12. Kawangware Dagoretti behind BP 13. Kinyago Biafra slums, Kamukunji 14. Soweto Kahawa west, Kasarani 15. Bomas Next to Bomas of Kenya 16. Kibera DO Next to DO office, Kibera 17. Soweto High Ridge tts College grd 18. Lungalunga Star of hope primary school, Lungalunga slums Source: NCC Table 2.2.10 Community Centers by District and Capacity Name of Community Halls District Capacity 1 Mbotela Community Center Makadara 200 2 J ericho Community Center Makadara 1,200 3 Lumumba Community Center Makadara 100 4 Bahati Community Center Kamukunji 200 5 Shauri Moyo Community Center Kamukunji 100 6 Mathare North Kasarani 700 7 Kariokor Community Center Starehe 1,200 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 33 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Name of Community Halls District Capacity 8 Pumwani Community Center and Hall Kamukunji 1,600 9 Muthurwa Community Center Kamukunji 1,100 10 Kaloleni Community Center Makadara 1,600 11 Kariobangi Community Center Kasarani 150 12 Dandora Sports Complex Embakasi 30 13 Dandora I Embakasi 100 14 Dandora II Community Center Embakasi 100 15 Kayole I Community Center Embakasi 700 16 Kayole II Community Center Embakasi 700 17 Embakasi Community Center Embakasi 130 18 Soweto Community Center Embakasi 250 19 Ruai Community Center Embakasi 120 20 Kariobangi South Community Center Kasarani (under construction) 21 Karen Community Center Langata 110 22 Ngong Road Community Center Dagoretti 70 23 Waithaka Community Center Dagoretti 130 24 Kangemi Community Center Westlands 90 25 J oseph Kangethe Community Center Dagoretti 90 26 Ziwani Sports Center Starehe 600 Source: NCC 3) Markets The population of market traders are mostly low income earners, who venture into micro enterprises activities. This economic sector plays an important role in the city economy in terms of employment generation and delivery of urban services, accounting for about 60% of working population and 20% of GDP. The markets also serve as alternative trading spaces for hawkers, offers a wide variety of choices of goods effectively lowering the prices of common goods and are often more conveniently located to traders and buyers than formal stores. However, a number of the Nairobi City Council markets were constructed during the colonial era and the market conditions have dilapidated over time. Further, the number of traders and buyers has increased considerably, putting pressure on the infrastructure and capacity of existing facilities. These facilities require upgrading and expansion to remain viable. Table 2.2.11 Types and Capacity of City Council Markets by Ward Type of Market Name # of Stalls Owner Location/Ward A. Wholesale Markets Wakulima Market 8 CCN Kamukunji B. Hawkers Markets Muthurwa Hawkers Market 10,000 (traders) NCC Kamukunji C. Rental Markets Landhies Road 72 NCC Kamukunji Shauri Moyo 308 NCC Shauri Moyo J ogoo Road 450 NCC Maringo Umoja I 320 NCC Umoja Westlands 109 NCC High Ridge Westland Curio 300 NCC High Ridge Quarry Road 274 NCC Pumwani/Bondeni Ngara 319 NCC Ngara Karen 83 NCC Karen Githurai 298 NCC Githurai New Pumwani 44 NCC Eastleigh South Dandora A-F 392 NCC Dandora Kariokor 206 NCC Ziwani City Market 143 NCC Central D. Development Tenant Purchase Markets Kenyatta 608 NCC Kenyatta Golf Course Kayole 159 NCC Kayole Kahawa West 335 NCC Kahawa Mathare North 53 NCC Mathare A Umoja II (A & B) 72 NCC Umoja Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 34 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Type of Market Name # of Stalls Owner Location/Ward E. Self-constructed Markets Kibera 678 NCC Kibera J ericho 476 NCC Hamza Lumumba Kariobangi North 696 NCC Kariobangi North Kariobangi South 156 NCC Kariobangi South F. Open Air Markets New Ngara open air NCC Ngara Kiamaiko (Goats) open air NCC Mathare Maasai open air NCC Central Sunken (High Court) open air NCC Central Yaya open air NCC Kibera City Stadium open air NCC Kaloleni Maziwa open air NCC Shaurimoyo J ericho open air NCC Uhuru Kahawa open air NCC Kahawa Mutindwa open air NCC Harambee City Park open air NCC Parklands Toi open air NCC Kibera Kangemi open air NCC Kangemi Kawangware open air NCC Kawangware Korogocho open air NCC Korogocho Gikomba open air NCC Pumwani Kayole Soweto open air NCC Kayole Westgate open air NCC Westlands Woodley open air Dandora Terminus open air NCC Dandora Source: NCC (4) Planning Implications A main feature of the 1927 Master Plan for Nairobi was the segregation of racial classes into various zones throughout the city. Particularly, Nairobi East was restricted to African residents, while the Western regions, for European settlers. The current data on the distribution of social services and facilities throughout Nairobi citys 9 districts suggests that inequalities between facilities in Nairobi East and West may be reflective of the disproportionality of resources caused during this earlier period. Though the Embakasi district constitutes 35% of the countys total land area and has the highest growing population of any district, it has as many schools, major health facilities, and hospital beds as districts with one half to one third of its population, including Starehe, Westlands, Dagoretti and Kasarani, respectively. The Embakasi district is also home to Nairobi Countys largest informal settlement areas, including Mathare and Mukuru slums. The rising population growth trends in the informal settlements and in the Eastlands area exacerbates the inadequacy of sufficient social services. It is also important to consider the role of community facilities as a generator of employment and activity and in creating nodes and destinations within the city. Markets, which play a large role in supplying low cost goods to a multitude of residents and employment for a majority of workers, require upgrading and infrastructure improvements while recreational facilities such as playgrounds, stadiums and others must be strategically planned within the urban fabric. In considering the benefits of socio-economic and cultural assets to urban development, the NIUPLAN will strategically distribute necessary social services according to the current and anticipated population growth areas, specifically in Nairobi East and plan for social, recreational and commercial facilities which promote activity, employment and destinations within the city.
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 2 - 35 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya CHAPTER 3 INSTITUTION AND REGULATORY CONDITIONS 3.1 Review of Related Laws and Regulations 3.1.1 Urban Planning (1) The Constitution of Kenya (2010) The Constitution of Kenya (2010) is the current constitution of Republic of Kenya now in force, which replaced the 1969 constitution, that itself had replaced the 1963 independence constitution. The constitution was presented to the Attorney General of Kenya in April, 2010, officially published in May, 2010, and was subjected to a referendum in August, 2010. The constitution provides that there shall be a county government for each county, consisting of a county assembly and a county executive. With regard to land, the constitution provides that Land in Kenya shall be held, used and managed in a manner that is equitable, efficient, productive and sustainable, and in accordance with the following principles (i) equitable access to land; (ii) security of land rights; (iii) sustainable and productive management of land resources; (iv) transparent and cost effective administration of land; (v) sound conservation and protection of ecologically sensitive areas; (vi) elimination of gender discrimination in law, customs and practices related to land and property in land; and (vii) encouragement of communities to settle land disputes through recognised local community initiatives consistent with this Constitution. (2) Outline of the laws and regulations for urban planning After the issuance of the Constitution of Kenya 2010, laws and regulations have being revised to adjust to the new Constitutions. Laws related to urban development can be classified into: (i) the laws concerning government management, (ii) the laws concerning urban and physical development, and (iii) the laws concerning environment. County Government Act 2012 and National Government Coordination Act 2013 define the role and function of county government and coordinating function of national government, respectively. The National Urban Development Policy (draft), which is considered as an umbrella policy, aims at strengthening development planning, urban governance and management, and promote urban investment and delivery of social and physical infrastructure in urban areas throughout the country. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 1 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Urban Areas and Cities Act 2011 states the definition and management of urban areas and cities. Physical Planning Act 1996 defines the urban development management. National Land Commission Act, 2012 describes the function of National Land Commission and objects and principles of devolved government in land management and administration. Building Code, which specifies condition of building construction, supplements the development control mentioned in the Physical Planning Act in technical aspects. Environment Management Coordination Act (EMCA) provides for the establishment of an appropriate legal and institutional framework for the management of the environment (This Act is also described in the section 2.2.2 Environment). Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi (NIUPLAN) will be prepared chiefly under the framework of the County Government Act with specification of the Urban Areas and Cities Act, because the entire area of Nairobi City County is urban area. Following figure shows the relationship of laws.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 3.1.1 Structure of Concerned Laws and Plans Following table shows the laws and regulations related to urban development management and their characteristics. Constitution of Kenya 2010 Urban Areas and Cities Act 2011 (Give effect to Article 184 of the Constitution) Physical Planning Act 1996 (Provide or preparation and implementation of physical development plans, to be replaced by Spatial Planning Act) County Government Act 2012 (Give effect to Chapter 11, Devolved Government of the Constitution) National Urban Development Policy (draft) National Government Coordination Act 2013 (Give effect to Article 131 (1) (b) & 132 (39 (b) of the Constitution Environmental and Management Coordination Act 1999 Building Code (1968) (Under revision) National Land Commission Act 2012 (Provide functions and power of the National Land Commission, to give effect to objects and principles of the devolved government) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 2 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.1.1 Management of Urban Development Policy, Act Coverage Relation with Urban Planning County Government Act 2012 County Part XI County Planning: Governance National Government Coordination Act, 2013 National government responsibility and county government To establish and administrative and institutional framework for coordination of national government functions at the national and county level of governance. Chapter IV: Collaboration and dispute resolution between the national and county governments on issues of apparent concurrent mandate National Urban Development Policy Urban area management Chapter 5: County urban planning Governance Urban Areas and Cities Act, 2011 Urban areas and cities management Planning Part V Integrated development planning Controlling Integrated development plan will be basis for development control (36, (1), (g) Physical Planning Act, 1996 Physical development for the selected area and selected purpose for the concerned an administrative unit Planning Part IV Physical development plans Controlling Part V Control of development: physical development: building construction control, development control (change of users, extension of user, subdivision) National Land Commission Act, 2012 Land management mechanism Land management by the National Land Commission and devolved government in land management and administration Building Code, 1968 Building construction control Supplement the control of development stated in the Physical Planning Act, 1996 Environmental Management and Coordination Act, 1999 Environment management Describes the legal and institutional framework of environment management. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) 1) County Government Act 2012 (former Local Government Act Cap 265) The County Government Act 2012, which essentially defines the roles and management of a county government, was newly stipulated to replace the former Local Government Act Cap 265. The Act aims at giving effect to chapter 11 (Devolution) of the Constitution of Kenya (COK) 2010, and more specifically to provide for the county government powers, functions and responsibilities in the delivery of services and for connected purposes. After the county government is in place, the administration of Kenya has two pillars, namely National Government and County Government at local level. The County Government Act 2012 is composed of fifteen parts and states the management of county government from assembly, executive, public service, citizen participation, to county planning. Among them, Parts VIII and IX provide fundamental principles regarding the citizen participations and public communication and access to information, respectively. Also, Part X mentions the importance of the civic education. Contents of the Act are summarized below. Contents Part I Preliminary Part II County governments Part III County assembly Part IV Electoral wards Part V County executive Part IV Decentralized units Part VII County public service Part VIII Citizen participation Part IX Public communication and access to information Part X Civic education Part XI County planning Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 3 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Contents Part XII Delivery of county public services Part XIII Procedure for suspension of county government Part XIV Miscellaneous Part XV Transitional Provision Some key elements of the County Government Act 2012 in regard to the urban management are summarized below. 104.(1) A county government shall plan for the county and no public funds shall be appropriated outside a planning framework developed by the county executive committee and approved by the county assembly. This means that the county government must have a master plan to receive funds from the national government for project implementation. 107.(1) To guide, harmonize and facilitate development within each county there shall be the following plans. (a) county integrated development plan; (b) county sectoral plans; (c) county spatial plan; and (d) cities and urban areas plans as provided for under the Urban Areas and Cities Act. NIUPLAN is considered as cities and urban areas plans. 2) National Government Coordination Act, 2013 This Act is to establish an administrative and institutional framework of governance for the coordination of government functions at the national and county levels. The object of this Act is to: (i) facilitate the exercise of executive authority pursuant to Articles 131(1)(b) (Authority of the President) and 132 (3) (b) and (c) (direct and coordinate the function of ministries and government departments, decision published in the Gazette) of the Constitution; (ii) provide for the effective co-ordination and administration of the national government functions prescribed in the Constitution, this Act or any other written law; and (iii) provide for the establishment of an administrative and institutional framework at the national, county and decentralised units to ensure access to national government services in all parts of the Republic Contents of the Act are summarized below. Contents Part I Preliminary Part II National government coordination framework Part III Appointment, roles and responsibilities of national government administrative officers Part IV Collaboration and dispute resolution between the national and county governments on issues of apparent concurrent mandates Part V General provision 3) Urban Areas and Cities Act, 2011 The Urban Areas and Cities Act, 2011 is effective for urban areas and cities. The objective and purpose of the Act is to establish a legislative framework for: Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 4 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (i) Classification of areas as urban areas or cities (ii) Governance and management of urban areas and cities (iii) Participation by the residents in the governance of the urban areas and cities and (iv) Other matters for the attainment of the objectives Contents Part I Preliminary Part II Classification and establishment of urban areas and cities Part III Governance and management of urban areas and cities Part IV Delivery of services Part V Integrated development planning Part IV Financial provisions Part V Integrated development planning Part VI Financial provisions Part VII Miscellaneous provisions Part VIII Transitional provisions Since Nairobi City County is categorized as an urban area, formulation of NIUPLAN has to follow this Act, which specifies that the integrated development planning shall be the basis for: (i) The preparation of environmental management plans (ii) The preparation of valuation rolls for property taxation (iii) Provision of physical and social infrastructure and transportation (iv) Preparation of annual strategic plans for a city or municipality (v) Disaster preparedness and response (vi) Overall delivery of service including provision of water, electricity, health, telecommunications and solid waste management, and Preparation of a geographic information system for a city and municipality 4) Physical Planning Act Cap 286, 1996 (revised in 2010) Physical Planning Act Cap 286, 1996 (revised in 2010) provides for preparation and implementation of physical development plans and for connected purposes. In regard to urban development management this Act is a base for physical planning and development control (building construction permit and land development permit). Since Physical Planning Act was in effect before the new Constitution was in effect, new law, namely, Spatial Planning Act is under preparation. Physical Planning Act is expected to be repealed after the Spatial Planning Act comes to effect. Contents of the Act are summarized below. Contents Part I Preliminary Part II Administration Part III Establishment and Composition of Physical Planning and Liaison Committee Part IV Physical Development Plans Part V Control of development Part VI Miscellaneous Some key elements of the Physical Planning Act 1996, in regard to urban management are summarized below. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 5 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Two types of plans are specified in the Act as shown below. Regional physical development plan is prepared for the administrative unit within local authority. Local physical development plan is prepared for a functional purpose such a plan includes zoning policy for 20 zones in Nairobi or redevelopment of railway city. Regional Physical Development plans: A regional physical development plan may be prepared by the Director with reference to any Government land, trust land or private land within the area of authority of a county council for the purpose of improving the land and providing for the proper physical development of such land, and securing suitable provision for transportation, public purposes, utilities and services, commercial, industrial, residential and recreational areas, including parks, open spaces and reserves and also the making of suitable provision for the use of land for building or other purposes. Local Physical Development Plan: land, trust land or private land within the area of authority of a city, municipal, town or urban council or with reference to any trading or marketing centre, a local physical development plan. A local physical development plan may be a long-term or short-term physical development or for a renewal or redevelopment. Part V Control of Development shows powers of local authorities in development permission including application and approval of development. In addition, forms for development application and for approval (P.P.A.1, P.P.A.2) are attached. Permission will be required for four cases of land development. (i) Change of use: change in the use of land (ii) Extension of use: adding other use to the land (20% of the total land) (iii) Amalgamation: combination of the plot or use of land (iv) Subdivision: separating the use of the land Building construction control is also based on the Physical Planning Act but execution of building construction permit is done mainly based on Building Code. 5) National Land Commission Act, 2012 This Act makes provision as to the functions and power of the National Land Commission, qualification and procedures for appointments to the Commission, and gives effect to the objects and principles of devolved government in land management and administration,. The object and purpose of this Act is to provide: (i) for the management and administration of land in accordance with the principles of land policy set out in Article 60 of the Constitution and the national land policy; (ii) for the operations, powers, responsibilities and additional functions of the Commission pursuant to Article 67 (3) of the Constitution; (iii) a legal framework for the identification and appointment of the chairperson, members and the secretary of the Commission pursuant to Article 250 (2) and (12) (a) of the Constitution; and (iv) for a linkage between the Commission, county governments and other institutions dealing with land and land related resources. The contents of the Act are summarized below.
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 6 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Contents Part I Preliminary Part II Functions and powers Part III Composition and administration Part IV Financial provisions Part V Transitional provision Part IV Miscellaneous provision 6) Environment Management and Coordination Act, 1999 This Act describes the legal and institutional framework of environment management. General principles of the Act are that every person in Kenya is entitled to a clean and healthy environment and has the duty to safeguard and enhance the environment. The entitlement to a clean and healthy environment includes the access by any person in Kenya to the various public elements or segments of the environment for recreational, educational, health, spiritual and cultural purposes. The contents of the Act are summarized below. Contents Part I Preliminary Part II General principles Part III Administration Part IV Environmental planning Part V Protection and conservation of environment Part IV Environmental Impact Assessment Part VII Environmental audit and monitoring Part VIII Environmental quality standards Part IX Environmental restoration orders, environmental conservation and environmental easements Part X Inspection, analysis and records Part XI International treaties, conventions and agreements Part XII National environment tribunal Part XIII Environmental offices (3) Policies, Rules and Regulations 1) National Land Use Policy (Concept Paper) In March 2011, Ministry of Lands issued a concept paper for the National land Use Policy. This concept paper is said to prove a roadmap for a National Land Use Policy in Kenya, as the importance of the land use in the social and economic activities makes it imperative that such a policy is formulated to effectively provide guidelines for managing land as a valuable resource To address the issues of optimal utilization of land-relate resources, the concept paper says that the policy should be guided by objects that includes, among others; (i) provide guidelines for land-use planning, resource allocation, and resource management, (ii) provide principles to promote optimal utilization of land resources to meet governance, social-economic, political and cultural obligations of the people of Kenya, (iii) develop and strengthen coordinated institutional linkage, and (iv) provide framework for the preparation of a national spatial plan and review of various land use plans. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 7 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The concept paper states that a national land use policy will be delivered by mid-2011. The status of the policy needs to be confirmed. 2) National Urban Development Policy (Concept Paper) In December 2008, the Office of Deputy Prime Minister and the Ministry of Local Government jointly issued a concept paper for a National Urban Development Policy. Department of Urban Development is in charge of the preparation of the paper. The concept paper that marks a starting point for this process laid out for developing a robust roadmap to guide and encourage meaningful participation and ownership of the whole process and the outcome from therein by all key stakeholders in the sector. The paper says that a clear, comprehensive, well-articulated and coherent urban development policy will be developed within the stipulated time frame and based on a predictable and structured engagement framework for all the various stakeholders. The process will be guided by among others, the following: (i) Stakeholder-centeredness and driven and sensitive to gender, youth and people with disabilities and equality of stakeholders (ii) Meaningful consultation, participation and networking (iii) Long-term perspective, comprehensiveness and sustainability (iv) Public-Private Partnerships; (v) Focus on value addition: Process will pay special attention on value for the common good or intended beneficiaries. The concept paper states that they have set in motion a process that will yield a National Urban Development Policy by J une 2009. 3) National Urban Development Policy (draft) The National Urban Development Policy, which is under discussion at the parliament, is the basic policy of urban development in Kenya, which provides a framework under which cities, towns and metropolitan regions will play a critical role in national socio-economic development. The Policy aims at strengthening development planning, urban governance and management, promote urban investment and delivery of social and physical infrastructure in urban area under a devolved system of governance. The key themes addressed by this Policy are: urban economy; urban finance, urban governance and management, national and county urban planning, land, environment and climate change, social infrastructure and services, physical infrastructure and services; urban housing, urban safety and disaster risk management, marginalized and vulnerable groups, cross cutting issues, and implementation framework. The contents of the Policy are summarized as shown below. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 8 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Vision Kenyas vision is to have secure, well governed, competitive and sustainable cities and urban areas that contribute to the achievement of the broader national development goals articulated in the Constitution and Vision 2030. Mission NUDPs mission is to facilitate sustainable urbanisation through good governance and delivery of accessible and efficient infrastructure and services. Principles NUDPs guiding principles are: a. Participatory urban planning, development and governance; b. Equity in access to resources and opportunities; c. Efficiency in resource use and service provision; d. Social, economic and environmental sustainability; e. Inclusivity: cities and urban areas that cater for all segments of urban residents including maginalised and vulnerable groups; f. Good governance; g. Connectivity: Urban areas that have synergy between national and county urban areas and their hinterlands and global urban systems. h. Livability: Cities and urban areas that have adequate quality services and infrastructure, and are secure, clean and green. Overall Objectives The overall objective of the Policy is to provide a framework for sustainable urban development in Kenya. Specific objectives The specific objectives are to: a. Mainstreamgood governance, gender, environment, and HIV/AIDS in all aspects of urban development; b. Foster timely, and adequate delivery/management of land for urban development; c. Promote integrated environmental planning and management; d. Promote technological innovation leading to more effective mitigation and adaptation to climate change; e. Facilitate accessibility to the full range of social services that improve the health, education, skills development, and recreational needs of citizens in urban areas; f. Foster safe, secure and liveable urban areas; and g. Ensure adequate housing for all urban income groups. (4) Building Code, 1968 In addition to Physical Planning Act,Building Code 1968 is used for development permission of building construction. Contents are shown below. Contents Part I Introductory Part II Site and space about buildings Part III Building materials Part IV Advertisement Part V General Since the existing building code is outdated, a new building code is under preparation. A new building code, namely Planning and Building Regulations, is under preparation and to be approved by the Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development and plan to be finalized by the end of 2013. A main change in the building code is to include the aspects ofoutdoor advertisement, painting, andurban design. (5) Development permit Regarding development control, there are mainly three types of permit: construction permit, certificate of occupancy, and development permit, all of which are executed under the Physical Planning Act. Development permit is required for the land development which requires change in use of land, which is responsibility of Policy Implementation Section of Nairobi City County. Construction permit is for Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 9 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya building construction for which Development Control Section of Nairobi City County is responsible. Certificate of occupancy is issued when the building construction is completed and is ready for use, which is under the responsibility of the Enforcement Section of Nairobi city county. These permits are conducted separately but there is a plan to combine under NIUPLAN.
Source : J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 3.1.2 Land Control Scheme 1) Development permit Policy Implementation Section (PIS) is responsible for land development permit. Permission is required for four cases of land development. Change of use: change in the use of land Extension of use: adding other use to the land (20% of the total land) Amalgamation: combination of the plot or use of land Subdivision: separating the use of the land A development application is reviewed from the point of view of zoning plan, types of facility, minimum plot size required in the zoning policy although it is outdated. The process is the same for the process for construction permit, all application have to go through Technical Committee to receive an approval. There are several constraints to development permit: An application is checked with archive data of each land plot record and changes are made manually. The data are still in hard copy, which has a risk of losing documents and takes longer time to process because the data is stored in the other section and have to find from a pile of documents. Zoning policy is outdated so there is often mismatch of demand and regulation. Because of high demand for land development, zoning policy has to be reviewed to accommodate the growing demand. In order to improve the process, E-permit is expected to be installed as Phase 3 of IFC support. Utilizing E-permit and GIS database to clarify the zoning policy makes the process more efficient. Organization capacity in terms of the number and skills of the staff are weak. Permit process requires checking application documents and field survey to examine the conditions at sites. The number of field surveyor, in particular, is not enough to follow Construction Permit Certificate of Occupation Application for Building Construction (Check any change in use of land. If any change, require land development permit) Review of Application (Check for architecture) Development Permit (Check for change in use of land) Inspection of construction Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 10 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya up the process, which can also be applied to construction permit. Monitoring of construction has not being executed due mainly to lack of field surveyors. 2) Construction permit Development Control Section of City Planning Department is executing construction permit. Even though building construction permit is required for all building construction, most buildings are constructed without permit. It is said that 70 % (or more) of construction is without permit in the east part of the city where houses for low income household are dominant. The rate is lower (40%~50%) in the Upper Hills area where houses for high income household exist. The cause of the illegal construction can be summarized as follows: Slow permit process: Between 2004 and 2006, since permit process was slow (2 to 3 month), the number of applications was low. After the process was improved, the number of application has increased. Residents and some architects do not know the rule or requirement: Residents and some architects are not even aware of that permit is required for construction. Incentive to cut the cost of construction: In order to receive permit, buildings have to meet building codes in terms of materials and safety, which imposes additional cost for the developer. In order to reduce the cost of construction, developers have incentive not to apply for permit. Outdated land use policy: Since urban master plan has not been updated, land use and zoning policy is also outdated and not matching the development needs. Many areas where urbanization and commercialization are progressing are still designated as low rise residential area. This makes developer to avoid permit. As a result, many residential areas are converted to commercial use without permit. In order to reduce the number of illegal construction, Nairobi City has been trying to improve the permit system including change in evaluation process by establishing Technical Committees and re-organizing the office for efficient process since 2006. Technical Committee, composed of departments in Nairobi City and professionals (Architect Association of Kenya, Kenya Institute of Planning, Nairobi Water Supply Company, etc.), is now held every two weeks to discuss and approve application. Office was also renovated to improve working environment. These efforts enable the process duration to be less than 30 days. Before, on average it took 2~3 months, sometimes more than six months. Nairobi City is receiving support from IFC of the World Bank Group to install an E-Permit system, which is composed of three phases: Phase 1: E-permit. Electric building permit system (Development Control Section) Phase 2: Inspection (monitoring and certificate of occupancy) (Enforcement Section) Phase 3: Development permit (Policy Implementation Section) Implementation of the system for Phase 1 has started in 2012. Along with continuous system improvement, introduction of E-permit system has increased the number of applications drastically. Before the improvement the number of applications was 400 to 600 per year. After the improvement, the number of applications has jumped to more than 3,000 a year. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 11 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 3) Certificate of occupancy Certificate of Occupancy (Certificate of Compliance) is required after the completion of construction, issuance of which is under the responsibility of Enforcement Section. A main task of the Enforcement Section is monitoring and inspection of construction by checking the construction following the instruction by the construction permit. Developer is also responsible to report the progress of construction to the city but it hardly happens for the same reasons as for construction permit. Monitoring and inspection part of the process is considered weak and need improvement. Nairobi City has a right to demolish illegal building but demolition hardly happens because of a financial and security reason. For some cases, developers may organize demonstration to protest demolition. IFC is planning to install E-permit for monitoring and inspection (Phase 2 of the assistance): 3.1.2 Environment The Environment Management and Co-ordination Act (EMCA) of 1999, and the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) and Audit Regulations that followed in 2003, are the core environmental frameworks in Kenya. Based on these laws and regulations, relevant rules such as a series of environmental criteria were developed. Besides, County Government Act of 2012 plays an important role for public participation and information disclosure regarding any activities of county planning processes. Outlines of major environmental laws and regulations are described as follows: (1) Environment Management and Coordination Act (EMCA), No. 8 of 1999 This Act consists of 13 parts. The importance of nationwide environmental planning is described in Part IV and methods of protection and conservation of the environment are specified in Part V. The enactment of EMCA is 1999 was a milestone in promoting the sustainable environmental management in Kenya. This Act provides for the harmonization of about 77 sectoral statutes. EMCA provides an institutional framework and procedures for the environmental management, including provisions for conflict resolution. (2) Environmental Impact Assessment and Audit Regulations (EIA/EA), No.121 of 2003 An EIA is a critical examination of potential effects to be caused by a project which is to be implemented on the environment. The goal of an EIA is to ensure that decisions on proposed projects and its relevant activities should be environmentally sustainable with proper environmental management program. An EIA is conducted in order to identify potential impacts of a project on the environment, predict likely changes on the environment as a result of the development, evaluate the impacts of various alternatives on the project and propose mitigation measures for significant negative impacts of the project on the environment. An Environmental Audit (EA) is a systematic documentation and a periodic and objective evaluation of activities and processes of an on-going project. The goal of an EA is to establish whether proponents are complying with environmental requirements and enforcing legislation. The purpose of an EA is to determine the extent to which the activities and programs conform to the approved environmental management plan. A comprehensive EA ensures safe and healthy environment at all stages of project operations until decommissioning. Regulation 42 of this EIA/EA Regulations vests the responsibility for carrying out Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA), and the lead agencies shall work closely with NEMA for SEA implementation. Regulation 42(3) commits the Government and all lead agencies to incorporate principles of SEA in the development of sector or national or regional policy and/or master plan. The objective of the SEA is to systematically integrate environmental considerations into policy, planning Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 12 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya and decision-making processes, such that environmental information derived from the examination of proposed policies, plans, programs or projects are used to support decision. According to series of preliminary discussions with NEMA, conducted in J anuary 2013, it is likely that the proposed urban development MP needs to conduct SEA study, based on SEA Guideline, to be described later in Section 4.3. (3) Noise: Environment Management and Co-ordination (Noise and Excessive vibration Pollution Control) Regulations, No. 61 of 2009) Table 3.1.2 summarizes the noise standard, specified within the Environment Management and Coordination (Noise and Excessive vibration Pollution Control) Regulation of 2009 in Kenya. Table 3.1.2 Maximum Permissible Noise Levels (Leq) Day Night A. Silent Zone B Places of worship C. Residential : Indoor Outdoor D. Mixed residential (with some commercial & places of entertainment) E. Commercial 40 40 45 50 55
60 35 35 35 35 35
35 Note: Day: 6:01 a.m. 8:00 p.m., Night: 8:01 p.m. 6:00 a.m. Source: Environment Management and Co-ordination (Noise and Excessive vibration Pollution Control) Regulations, No. 61 of 2009 (4) Water Quality: Environment Management and Co-ordination (Water Quality) Regulations, No. 120 of 2006) The objective of this regulation is to protect human health and the aquatic environment. The effective enforcement of the water quality regulations will lead to a marked reduction of water-borne diseases and hence a reduction in the health budget. This water quality regulation apply to water used for domestic, industrial, agricultural, and recreational purposes; water used for fisheries and wildlife purposes, and water used for any other purposes. Different standards apply to different modes of the usage. These regulations provide for the protection of lakes, rivers, streams, springs, wells and other water sources. This regulation also provides guidelines and standards for the discharge of poisons, toxins, noxious, radioactive waste or other pollutants into the aquatic environment in line with the Third Schedule of the regulation. This regulation has standards for discharge of the effluent into the sewerage and the aquatic environment. While it is the responsibility of the sewerage service providers to regulate discharges into sewerage lines based on the given specifications, NEMA regulates the discharge of all effluent into the aquatic environment. Also, it is specified that any development activities to be planned at riverbanks of tributaries running through Nairobi City need an environmental permit by conducting EIA from NEMA for the water quality protection. Basically, six (6) meters to thirty (30) meters from the highest water level (flood event) are defined as the protected river bank. Exact configuration of this protected area depends on development natures, surrounding land use, environmental importance and others. (5) Waste Management: Environment Management and Co-ordination (Waste Management) Regulations, No. 69 of 2006) Waste Management Regulations are meant to streamline the handling, transportation and disposal of various types of waste. The aim of this Waste Management Regulation is to protect the human health and the environment. Currently, various types of waste are dumped haphazardly, posing serious Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 13 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya environmental and health concerns. This regulation places emphasis on the wastes minimization, cleaner production and the segregation of waste at source. (6) Wet Land, Lake and Sea: Environmental Management and Co-ordination (Wetlands, River Banks, Lake Shores and Sea Shore Management) Regulations, No. 19 of 2009 This regulation, consisting of three parts, specifies that any wetland adjacent to rivers, lakes as well as riverbanks and lake shores shall be protected. If some development works are planned to be conducted inside such a wetland, a special permit shall be obtained from Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) by conducting appropriate study such as EIA, as described later. (7) Forest Act of 2005 The Forests Act 2005, enacted in 2007, provides for the establishment, development and sustainable management, including conservation and rational utilization, of forest resources for the socio-economic development of the country. This Act recognizes the importance of forests for the benefits of soil conservation, ground water regulation and agriculture, and provide for their role in absorbing greenhouse gases. The key elements of the Forests Act are 1) the inclusion of management of all types of forests 2) involvement of adjacent forest communities and other stakeholders in forest conservation and management 3) an ecosystems approach to forest management planning 4) provision of appropriate incentives to promote sustainable use and management of forest resources 5) development of a framework for a forest legislation and 6) establishment of Kenya Forest Service. This Act also recognizes Community Forest Associations (CFAs), who shall participate in forest conservation and management under the Kenya Forest Service (KFS). This Act has specific provisions related to access rights and benefit sharing arrangements which provide a role for communities in the utilization of forest resources and protection of forests. This Act has four priority areas related to the management of forests, including: 1) reducing pressure to clear forests for agriculture and other uses, 2) promoting the sustainable utilization of forests, 3) improving governance in the forest sector, and 4) the enhancement of carbon stocks and reforestation of degraded lands. (8) Wildlife Conservation and Management Act of 1989 This Act, consisting of nine (9) Parts, is to strengthen the wildlife conservation and management policy and support relevant activities in Kenya. The legislation of nature conservation began to develop in 1945 in Kenya with National Park Ordinance. This and the Wild Animal Protection Ordinance of 1953 were not very effective. In 1976, the Wildlife Conservation and Management Act replaced the former ordinances, which brought about some changes in the conservation policies. The 1976 act was also unable to achieve efficient conservation measures fully. Reforms were made mostly in policies and legislation but there were no major impact on the real world. Credit to the act was that wildlife and natural resources were mentioned to have relevant economical potential. In 1989, when the weakness of existing legislation was finally realized, the Kenya Wildlife Service (KWS) was established by a new act. KWS replaced all the former conservation-aimed organizations and it was secured to have a more independent position on its own field. 3.1.3 Economy and Investment (1) Companies Act The Companies Act (Chapter 486, Laws of Kenya) was commenced in 1962 based on the United Kingdom's Companies Act 1948. The act was to regulate all aspects of companies including the following: Incorporation of companies Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 14 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Share capital Registration Management and administration Winding up Companies incorporated outside Kenya General provisions as to registration Insurance companies, Societies, partnerships, etc. Due to the need to reform the act according to the governments policy objectives such as Vision 2030, the Companies Bill 2010 was proposed as a follow-up of the Companies Bill 2008. The bill 2010 repealing the act aims to modernize Kenya's business sector by easing investment of domestic and foreign companies in Kenya toward a competitive economy in the East African Community and in the globalizing world. The bill has gone through parliamentary reading stages. (2) Employment Act The Employment Act published in 2007 defines the fundamental rights of employees in order to provide basic conditions of employment of employees, to regulate employment of children, and to provide for matters connected with the following: Employment relationship Protection of wages. Rights and duties in employment Termination and dismissal Protection of children. Insolvency of employer. Employment records Employment management Foreign contracts of service Disputes settlement procedure Enforcement of the act is supervised by the Ministry of Labour, Social Security and Services, which is also to maintain industrial peace, industrial training and promote safety and health of employees. (3) Public Private Partnerships Act The Public Private Partnerships Act 2013 was published in J anuary 2013. It is to provide for the participation of the private sector in the financing, construction, development, operation, or maintenance of infrastructure or development projects of the government through concession or other contractual arrangements; the establishment of the institutions to regulate, monitor and supervise the implementation of project agreements on infrastructure or development projects and for connected purposes. The act was in line with Vision 2030, which is a vision to transform Kenya into a middle income country by 2030. To this end, a number of key projects are required. However, they cannot be funded and implemented by the government alone. Therefore this act has been proposed to involve the private sector in such projects. The act includes the detailed procedure of projects in public private partnerships and the following institutional arrangement: (i) Establishment of the public private partnership committee for ensuring that each project agreement is consistent with the provisions of this act, formulating policy guidelines on public private partnerships, and ensure that all projects are consistent with the national priorities, etc. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 15 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (ii) Establishment of the public private partnerships units for serving as the secretariat and technical arm of the committee, and for providing technical, financial and legal expertise to the committee and any node established under this act. (iii) Establishment of public private partnership nodes for identifying, screening and prioritizing projects based on guidelines issued by the committee, preparing and appraising each project agreement to ensure its legal, regulatory, social, economic and commercial viability, ensuring that the parties to a project agreement comply with the provisions of this act, and undertaking the tendering process in accordance with this act, etc. (4) Tourism Act The Tourism Act is to develop, manage, market and regulate sustainable tourism and tourism-related activities and services by changing the management and structure of related institutions. The act passed the parliament in 2011 includes a total of 124 clauses including establishment of various organizations together with formulation of the national tourism strategy as follows: National tourism strategy Establishment of Authority Establishment of the Tourism Protection Service Establishment of the Kenya Tourism Board Establishment of Kenyatta International Convention Centre Establishment of Tourism Research Institute Establishment of Tourism Fund Establishment of Corporation (5) Banking Act The Banking Act revised in 2010 is for regulating the business of banking and for protecting the industry in Kenya. The banking act covers a wide area in the banking business such as follows: Licensing of institutions Prohibited business Reserves and dividends Accounts and audit Information and reporting requirements Inspection and control of institutions The deposit protection fund Representative offices of foreign institutions Based on the act, the Central Bank of Kenya stipulates guidelines, which include: Governance and risk Management, Financial reporting requirements, Business continuity management, Bank services, and Bank data reporting. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 16 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 3.1.4 Infrastructure (1) Kenya Roads Act No 2 of 2007 The Kenya Roads Act No 2 of 2007 is an Act of Parliament to provide for the establishment of the Kenya National Highways Authority, the Kenya Urban Roads Authority and the Kenya Rural Roads Authority, to provide for the powers and functions of the authorities and for connected purposes. Section 3, 4 and 5 of the Kenya Roads Act (2007) provide for the establishment and functions of the Kenya National Highways Authority (KeNHA) which is responsible for the management, development, rehabilitation and maintenance of national roads. Functions of KeNHA are discussed in Section 3.2.4. Sections9, 10, 11 and 12 of the Roads Act provide for the establishment, functions and composition of KURA which is the body corporate in charge of management, development, rehabilitation and maintenance of all public roads in the cities and municipalities in Kenya except where those roads are national roads. The role of KURA is discussed in Section 3.2.4. (2) Public Roads and Roads of Access Act Cap 399 This is an Act of Parliament to provide roads of public travel and access to public roads. According to Section 8 (1) of this act, whenever it is made to appear to the Minister that requirements exist for the establishment, alteration or cancellation of a line of public travel or for the conversion of a road of access into a line of public travel, the Minister may, by order published in the Gazette, dedicate, alter or cancel such line of public travel or convert such road of access into a line of public travel. For the purposes of the act, Article 8 (3) provides that where an order under this section dedicates a line of public travel or converts a road of access into a line of public travel, such line of public travel shall be absolutely dedicated to the public as a public road within the meaning of any law now or hereafter in force relating to public roads. However, this act also provides for the procedure for construction of private roads of access. Section 9 (1) provides that where any owner or occupier of land is in respect of his land so situated in relation to a public road which is passable to vehicular traffic, or to a railway station or halt, that he has not reasonable access to the same, he may make application to the board of the district in which such land is situate for leave to construct a road or roads (hereinafter called a road of access) over any lands lying between his land and such public road or railway station or halt. Section 13 provides for the right of way, responsibilities of the owner, including direct orders in 13 (5) on responsibility of the owner to keep the road in good state of repair at all times to the satisfaction of the board responsible (District Roads Board in this case or any other body as the case may be in the new constitutional dispensation/ order). (3) Wayleaves Act Cap 292 In Kenya the Wayleaves Act Cap 292 allow for ROW of transmission lines. The Wayleaves Act provides that a wayleave as a right of way (ROW) over any lands whatsoever but MAY NOT in so doing interfere with any existing buildings. In this Act, private land does not include any land sold or leased under any Act dealing with Government lands. KETRACO defines a wayleave as a right of way (ROW) over the land of another. This ROW is for carrying sewer, drain, power line or pipeline into, though, over or under any lands but in so doing may interfere with the existing buildings. (www.ketraco.co.ke). This is contrary to the Wayleaves Act Cap 292 which consider utilization of ALL land for any such functions as outlined above. Wayleaves Act Cap 242 in general provides for the power to carry sewers, drains and pipelines through land, guidelines for legal notification on the intention to use any land, and on the procedures Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 17 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya as to lodge objections by owners or occupiers of private land that may be used for ROW. Further, the act provides Section 7 of the Wayleaves Act provides in whole that any person in the service of the government and any contractor executing any work for the Government, together with his agents and servants, may at any time enter upon any land for the purpose of surveying, setting out and marking the line of any intended sewer, drain or pipeline, or for the purpose of inspecting, repairing, removing, re-laying or cleansing any sewer, drain or pipeline the property of the Government, or for any other purpose under this Act. Article 9 lays the penalty for unauthorized building over sewers, drains or pipelines. Wayleaves are important in regard to location of the various trunk utilities. For the purposes of NIUPLAN: (i) There are various areas of trunk utilities to be considered in the NIUPLAN whose location should be secured, including, but no limited to powerlines (both overhead and underground), sewerage reticulation networks, storm-water drains, water-mains, telephone lines, fibre-optic cables, railway wayleaves, road reserves, etc.; (ii) The use of wayleaves currently is not properly regulated as different utilities companies, some serving competing interests digging up road reserves, posing dangers to human and the quality of the roads and other existing infrastructure; (iii) There is need to open up additional wayleaves for newly proposed trunk utilities, adding to the existing lines and opening new lines in new areas; (iv) There is need to limit restrict the use of the wayleaves to optimize the use of the existing and future wayleaves. Case in hand is through proposed utilities tunnel to be shared by all trunk utilities to limit destruction of roads and existing utilities; (v) There is need to propose the use of some of the secured wayleaves for other allowable urban uses in some of the larger wayleaves. 1) Gaps in the Wayleaves Act The various gaps in the Wayleaves Act that may constrain implementation of the NIUPLAN include, that the Wayleaves Act: (i) Is mostly outdated and needs to be extensively reviewed to cater for modern development scenarios; (ii) Is less detailed on the definition of wayleaves, especially in regard to the types of trunk utilities, users, actors (sectoral bodies that have/ use/ need wayleaves) (iii) Is silent on most types of infrastructure that require wayleaves, but is particular on power, drains and pipelines; (iv) The act is silent on the use, management and protection of the existing wayleaves; (v) Does not recognize the role of private actors in the use of the wayleaves, which leads private sector actors to destroy the amenity of the wayleaves as well as the quality of roads; (vi) Lays a small penalty on contravention of the Wayleaves Act, seeing as to the importance of the wayleaves for the development of the city as well as the value of public good/ public interest they carry/ possess; (vii) Does not provide inter-sectoral linkages on the use of wayleaves, including the competing interests of Roads, Power, Telecommunication, Water, Municipal and other such sectoral interests for the purposes of harmonization of functions Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 18 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (viii) Does not give the actual measurements of the wayleaves, and the relationship with adjacent land users; (ix) Does not stipulate allowable temporary users (if any) of the wayleaves. (x) Recommendations for Wayleaves Act The main recommendation on the Wayleaves Act include is that the Act should be overhauled and drafted afresh to take into accounts current glaring omissions including: (i) Definition of wayleaves; (ii) Examples of wayleaves; (iii) Examples of the land in which the wayleaves operate; (iv) Inter-sectoral relationships on the use of wayleaves; (v) Dimensions of wayleaves; (vi) Use of wayleaves/ allowable users of the wayleaves; (vii) Non-allowable users of wayleaves; (viii) Mixed use of wayleaves, including allowable temporary users; (ix) Management plan of wayleaves; and (x) Optimization of the use of wayleaves, among others. (4) Energy Act No. 12 of 2006 The Energy Act is an Act of Parliament to amend and consolidate the law relating to energy, to provide for the establishment, powers and functions of the Energy Regulatory Commission and the Rural Electrification Authority, and for connected purposes. The provisions of this Act shall apply to every person or body of persons importing, exporting, generating, transmitting, distributing, supplying or using electrical energy; importing, exporting, transporting, refining, storing and selling petroleum or petroleum products; producing, transporting, distributing and supplying of any other form of energy, and to all works or apparatus for any or all of these purposes. The Energy Act stipulates conditions for granting licenses for generation, importation, exportation, transmission or distribution of electrical energy, including certain provisions that are particular to the well-being of the environment. Section 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53 and 54 provide for procedures for acquisition (whether through willing surrender or compulsorily) of and the use of wayleaves. Specifically, Section 53(1) provides that for the purpose of the conveyance, transmission, or supply of electrical energy, a licensee may erect, fix, install or lay any poles, wires, electric supply lines, power or other apparatus in, upon, under, over or across any public streets, road, railways, tramways, rivers, canals, harbours or Government property, in the manner and on the conditions as provided in this Act. 53(2) stipulates that notwithstanding the provisions of any other written law, but subject to the provisions of this section, a licensee may break up any street within his area of supply, and may erect posts and lay or construct power lines or electric supply lines along, under or over any such street, and may, from time to time, repair, alter or remove any posts or lines so erected, laid or constructed: Provided that the person having the control of such street shall have a prior right to break up and repair such street with reasonable despatch upon payment to him of a reasonable charge by the licensee. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 19 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Having completed works on the wayleaves, an operator is obligated under section 53 (5) to he shall comply with the by-laws, if any, of the local authority concerned and shall complete that work with reasonable despatch and reinstate the street broken up and remove any debris or rubbish occasioned thereby and shall, while the street is broken up or obstructed, cause the works to be, at all times, fenced and guarded and during the night, adequately lit. The Energy Act also provides for siting of petroleum installations. Section 90 provides that Any person intending to construct a pipeline, refinery, bulk storage facility or retail dispensing site shall, before commencing such construction, apply in writing to the Commission (ERC) for a permit to do so. Such applications must be accompanied by an EIA report. Section 98 provides for compliance with environmental, safety and health standards for any person engaged in petroleum business. 98(2) stipulates that in the event of a fire, explosion, oil spill, injury or fatality occurring in the course of operating a petroleum facility or transportation of petroleum, either by accident or through negligence, the operator or person transporting petroleum shall forthwith clean up the polluted or damaged environment, at his own expense, to the satisfaction of the Commission and other relevant authorities: Provided that any person engaged in the transportation of petroleum and petroleum products shall have an oil clean-up plan in compliance with the national oil policy. Important to note for NIUPLAN is the provision of Section 99 which provides that a local authority shall designate a place or places exclusively reserved for parking of petroleum tanker vehicles. Section 99(2) provides that a local authority that contravenes subsection (1) commits an offence and shall be liable, on conviction, to pay a fine of fifty thousand shillings for each day or part thereof that the offence continues. Among the conditions highlighted for the granting of permits are compliance to relevant government policies (which the NIUPLAN will be one of), as well compliance with the demands of EMCA (1999). Part V of the Energy Act provides for use of renewable energy, energy efficiency and conservation. Section 103, provides, inter alia promotion of the development and use of renewable energy, including, but not limited to: (i) research in renewable energy; (ii) efficient and sustainable energy; (iii) use of municipal waste for energy production; (iv) development of appropriate capacity for manufacture, installation, maintenance and operation of such technologies as bio-digesters and solar systems; (v) International cooperation programmes focussing in renewable energy. 1) Application of the Energy Act to NIUPLAN For purposes of the NIUPLAN, the ERC mandates and responsibilities touch on the various aspects of the city of Nairobi in the following manner: i) Energy is an important component of urban life and a citys wellbeing, tied closely to matters of security and safety, urban transport, economic development (including to a very major extent, industrialization), power sector, telecommunications sector, utilities and services availability etc.; Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 20 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya ii) Energy components are a major consumer of urban space and land, including: a. Power wayleaves; b. Pipeline wayleaves; c. Petrol/ service stations d. Petroleum storage/ bulk storage facilities; e. Road transport of petroleum products; f. Petroleum pipeline, etc. iii) Energy wayleaves are important contributor of the amount and quality of open spaces within the urban landscape; iv) Security, safety and health concerns with respect to energy installations in an urban settings are important considerations in planning; v) The Energy Act is one of 2 Acts that clearly stipulate the protection, use and management of wayleaves; vi) The Master Plan provides for various land use guidelines and approval standards which call for implementation of various guidelines and enforcement thereof, including, but not limited to granting of approvals, insistence of environmental impact assessments and NEMA licenses for approvals, etc. with the intention of ensuring environmental friendliness of activities/ developments related to energy; vii) Most proposals in the NIUPLAN are directly and indirectly tied to energy availability and tariffs, including on the cost of doing business, cost of transport, cost of setting up industries, location of major business districts, etc; viii) In compliance with section 99, NIUPLAN needs to come with a place(s) exclusively dedicated for parking of petroleum tanker vehicles. ix) Need for NIUPLAN to suggest strategies of integration of renewable energy into the energy plan of the city with the suggestion of ensuring energy sufficiency and efficiency, including the use of municipal waste for energy production. 2) Weakness of the Energy Act to NIUPLAN The promotion, installation and use of solar water heating systems by the act is a positive move towards renewable energy use in Kenya. However, provisions of Energy (Solar Water Heating) Regulations, 2012 may be deemed too harsh considering the provisions of Section 3(3) and 11(1) among others. Premises may fail to install solar water heating mechanisms because of the incapability of the owners/ occupiers, and that should not be a weakness for which to send people to prison. Rather than use threats to encourage people to use renewable energy, the Energy Act Regulations should instead use actual incentives, for example zero-rating of taxes on solar water-heating equipment and other such hardware that will entice people to use the technology. (5) The National Land Commission Act No. 5 of 2012 This is an Act of Parliament to make further provision as to the functions and powers of the National Land Commission, qualifications and procedures for appointments to the Commission; to give effect to the objects and principles of devolved government in land management and administration, and for connected purposes. In relation to the NIUPLAN, this Act provides for the: Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 21 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (i) for the management and administration of land in accordance with the principles of land policy set out in Article 60 of the Constitution and the national land policy; (ii) a linkage between the National Land Commission, county governments and other institutions dealing with land and land related resources. Section 18 provides for the establishment of the County Land Management Boards in consultation and cooperation with the national and county governments establish county land management boards for purposes of managing public land. Section 19(1) provides that the commission shall, subject to the physical planning and survey requirements, process applications for allocation of land, change and extension of user, subdivision of public land and renewal of leases. This statute is important in that all infrastructure is located on land. Sometimes infrastructure and utilities are located on contested land, or land in which acquisition o wayleaves may be done through compulsory acquisition. This may require the role of THE National Land Commission. (6) Survey Act Cap 299 This Act provides for the establishment of the Director of Surveys and such other officers as may be deemed to be necessary for the purposes of this Act. The act provides for the sole role of the surveying works by the Director of Surveys and his agents, and the sole power to authenticate survey plans prepared by any private registered surveyor. This overreaching mandate spans to issues like aerial photography. In terms of infrastructure provision, the survey act is important to help in production of reliable spatial data, now and in the future. Maps may be prepared by the various sectoral bodies in conjunction with the Survey of Kenya but validation needs to be done by the Survey of Kenya. For purposes of the NIUPLAN, there is need for cooperation between the Director of Survey with the NIUPLAN team for production of accurate maps and plans for the purposes of planning. The Director of Surveys also has the powers to furnish the team with up-to-date aerial images for preparation of maps. The Director of Surveys will help in authenticating maps, accuracy of maps produced for the reference and use by the NIUPLAN team. (7) Urban Areas and Cities Act Number 3 of 2011 Urban Areas and Cities Act is an Act of Parliament to give effect to Article 184 of the Constitution; to provide for the, classification, governance and management of urban areas and cities; to provide for the criteria of establishing urban areas, to provide for the principle of governance and participation of residents and for connected purposes. Subject to subsection 3 of this Act, an urban area may be classified as a city under this Act if the urban area satisfies the following criteria (i) has a population of at least five hundred thousand residents according to the final gazetted results of the last population census carried out by an institution authorized under any written law, preceding the application for grant of city status; (ii) has an integrated urban area or city development plan in accordance with this Act; (iii) has demonstrable capacity to generate sufficient revenue to sustain its operation; (iv) has demonstrable good system and records of prudent management; (v) has the capacity to effectively and efficiently deliver essential services to its residents as provided in the First Schedule; (vi) has institutionalised active participation by its residents in the management of its affairs; (vii) has infrastructural facilities, including but not limited to roads, street lighting, markets and fire stations, and an adequate capacity for disaster management; and (viii) has a capacity for functional and effective waste disposal. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 22 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Section 6 provides for the establishment of Nairobi as the Capital City, and its roles and responsibilities. Following stipulations of Section 5(1)(b), Nairobi is in the process of preparing an integrated urban plan the NIUPLAN, which, among others, will provide for the functions outlined in sub-section 3, including improvement of the efficiency of the transport network as well promotion of commerce and industry. Part III provides for the governance and administration of cities. Some of the principles outlined for governance and management include institutionalisation of active participation by its residents in the management of the urban area and city affairs, efficient and effective service delivery and clear assignment of functions which the NIUPLAN is to provide for. Part V provides for Integrated Development Planning. Section 36 stipulates the objectives of the plans which include formation of basis for preparation of environmental management plans, valuation rolls, provision of physical and social infrastructure, preparation of annual strategic plans for the city as well as overall delivery of services and infrastructure. Such an integrated urban plan shall also be the basis for development control. It further highlights the contents, adoption, approval and provides for annual reviews for development. (8) Companies Act Cap 486 Several Kenyan State Corporations are established generally by the Companies Act Cap 486. Some of these institutions with relation to the NIUPLAN including the Kenya Pipeline Corporation (KPC), the Kenya Power and Lighting Company (KPLC) and the Kenya Electricity Transmission Company (KETRACO) which are important infrastructure providers in Nairobi: Petroleum pipeline, and electricity respectively. (9) Kenya Railways Corporation Act Cap 397 This is an Act of Parliament for the establishment of the Kenya Railways Corporation, to be simply called Kenya Railways. The Act provides for the Powers of Kenya Railways Corporation being generally, without prejudice, to construct railways, development of roads to access the railways, development of parking, provision of train services, determination of tariffs and train fares. The other roles include responsibilities to buy and sell property, provision of housing to its employees and all such related services. (10) Intergovernmental relations Act The Intergovernmental Relations Act of Parliament to establish a framework for consultation and co-operation between the national and county governments and amongst county governments; to establish mechanisms for the resolution of intergovernmental disputes pursuant to Articles 6 and 189 of the Constitution, and for connected purposes. The objects and purposes of this Act are to (i) provide a framework for consultation and cooperation between the national and county governments; (ii) provide a framework for consultation and cooperation amongst county governments; (iii) establish institutional structures and mechanisms for intergovernmental relations; (iv) provide a framework for the inclusive consideration of any matter that affects relations between the two levels of government and amongst county governments; (v) give effect to Articles 187 and 200 of the Constitution, in respect of the transfer of functions and powers by one level of government to another, including the transfer of legislative powers from the national government to the county governments; and (vi) provide mechanisms for the resolution of intergovernmental disputes where they arise. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 23 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya It is to be noted that some of the disputes may be in the area of infrastructure provision, including cross-boundary utility mains like roads, petroleum pipelines, railway lines, water pipelines, etc. (11) The Water Act Cap 372 No 8 of 2002 The Water Act No 8 of 2002 is an Act of Parliament to provide for the management, conservation, use and control of water resources and for the acquisition and regulation of rights to use water; to provide for the regulation and management of water supply and sewerage services; to repeal the Water Act (Cap. 372) and certain provisions of the Local Government Act; and for related purposes. Being important inter-county resources and important for life, every water resource is hereby vested in the State, subject to any rights of user granted by or under this Act or any other written law. Section 7 establishes the Water Resources Management Authority. Powers and functions of the Authority are outlined in Section 8, and include regulation of allocation of water resources, monitoring and assessment of the national water resources management strategy, determination of applications for permits for water use, protection of water resources from adverse use, management of water catchments, among other water resource management needs/ strategies. Section 51 provides for the establishment of Water Services Boards. The role of these Boards include planning for improvement in provision of water supply and sewerage services, appointment and contracting water service providers as well as being asset holder of central government facilities. The Athi Water is one of the eight Water Boards under the Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources created to bring about efficiency, economy and sustainability in the provision of water and sewerage services in Kenya. Athi Water is created under Section 51 of the Water Act 2002 serving a population of over 4.5million in Nairobi and its environs. 3.2 Roles and Tasks of Related Organizations 3.2.1 Urban Planning The Government of Kenya, including national government and local government, is in the transitional stage based on the Constitution 2010 and subordinate legal framework such as the Local Government Act 2012, as well as the new Presidents policy. The number of Ministries will be reduced from forty four in the previous government to reportedly eighteen in the new government. The President has been nominating the cabinet members in April and job description of each ministry will be announced later. Local government structure has shifted from a variety of status (city, municipality, town) to a county government. Nairobi City County is also under transition based on the County Government Act and the policy of the new governor. (1) National Government Main ministries related to Nairobi urban development in the old structure were the Ministry of the Local Government, the Ministry of Lands, and the Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development. Functions of each ministry are summarized in the following table. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 24 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.2.1 Ministries Related to Urban Planning (Old Structure) Organizations Functions Ministry of Local Government (Urban Development Department) Responsible for managing local government matters (policy, assist local authority for planning) Urban Development Department is responsible for urban development (main organization for preparing National Urban Development Policy) Ministry of Lands (Physical Planning Department) Responsible for land management Physical Planning Department is responsible for physical planning and implementation Approval of urban master plan Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development (Metropolitan Planning and Environment) Responsible for providing technical support and resources in areas of planning and implementation of projects (based on Local Government Act (Cap 265 which was repealed in 2012). Prepared Metro Strategy 2030 and Spatial Plan for 2030. Source: Thematic Working Group The new government structure has been complied based on the government announcement and input from Thematic Working Group. Most of the functions and responsibilities for urban development have been put together in the Ministry of Land, Housing, and Urban Development. Since the national government is still in a transition stage, detail of the national government structure is yet to be announced, so some of the information in the table is still tentative. Table 3.2.2 Ministries Related to Urban Planning (New Structure) Old Government New Government Ministry of Local Government (Urban Development Department) Mostly shift to Ministry of Devolution Urban Development Department shifts to Ministry of Lands, Housing, and Urban Development Ministry of Lands (Physical Planning Department) Ministry of Lands, Housing, Urban Development Combining Ministry of Lands, Ministry of Housing, and Urban Development sections of other Ministries Integrated urban development section of Ministry of Local Government and Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development (Metropolitan Planning and Environment)) Dissolved Integrated into the Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development Source: government announcement, Thematic Working Group (2) Nairobi City County (City Council of Nairobi) Nairobi City changed from the City Council of Nairobi to Nairobi City County, through which seventeen departments were restructured to ten departments. City Planning Department of Nairobi City County became Department of Planning and Development, which is an integration of City Planning Department, City Engineers, and Housing Development.
Source : J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 3.2.1 Organization Chart of NCC (Old system) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 25 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 3.2.2 NCC Land, Housing and Physical Planning Sector organogram (tentative) City Planning Department is composed of eight sections. The following table shows the tasks of sections in City Planning Department. Table 3.2.3 Tasks of Sections in City Planning Department Section Job Description (1) Forward Planning Section Responsible for policy formulation and supporting permit process. (2) Research Section Responsible for supporting section by conducting survey and provide information regarding urban condition, housing, and infrastructure, renew land lease, register private schools, designating street names and designating physical address. (3) Central Administration Responsible for administrative matter, including staff evaluation, organization re-structure, and other supporting matters. (4) Development Control Section Responsible for building construction permit management (5) Policy Implementation Section (PIS) Responsible for land development permit management. Permit is required for change in land use, division of land plot, extension (adding) of new and use. (6) Urban Design Development Section Responsible for development of landscape (greenery, bench, bus shelter) and management of advertisement (7) Enforcement Section Responsible for inspection and monitoring of development approved by Development Control Section and Policy Implementation Section. (8) Land Survey Section Responsible for conducting land survey that belongs to Nairobi city an develop GIS database. Source: Official organization chart, Interview with Assistant Directors. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 26 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 3.2.2 Environment (1) Ministry of Environment and Mineral Resources (MEMR) Ministry of Environment and Mineral Resources (MEMR) (Currently Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources (MEWNR) since April 2013) is the environmental administrative body of Kenya. Main vision of MEWNR is to promote, monitor, conserve, protect and sustainably manage the environment and mineral resources across the nation for national development. MEMR has several departments and state corporations, and National Environmental Management Authority (NEMA) is one of MEMRs departments. In April 2013, the restructuring plan of central government was released, and this ministry is going to be Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources. (2) National Environmental Management Authority (NEMA) The National Environment Management Authority (NEMA) is established under EMCA, No. 8 of 1999, as the principal instrument of the government in the implementation of all policies relating to the environment. This authority became operational on 1st J uly 2002 following the merger of three government departments, namely: the National Environment Secretariat (NES), the Permanent Presidential Commission on Soil Conservation and Afforestation (PPCSCA), and the Department of Resource Surveys and Remote Sensing (DRSRS). However, following government restructuring, conducted in March 2003, DRSRS reverted to its departmental status under MEMR. Kenya is divided into 8 main administrative provinces, i.e., (i) Central, (ii) Coast, (iii) Eastern, (iv) North Eastern, (v) Nyanza, (vi) Rift Valley, (vii) Western, and (viii) Nairobi, which is also the capital city. Concerning environmental management, each of these provinces has an office of NEMA. Environmental administration and its legal framework of Kenya are described in following sections. (3) Department of Environment, City Council of Nairobi/NCC The Department of Environment (DOE) of City Council of Nairobi was established in 1996 and still exists under NCC. Main mission of this department is to conduct a sustainable environmental management across Nairobi City, aiming at creating a healthy, clean and aesthetically pleasant environment to the residents of Nairobi and to formulate and implement suitable policies and tools for the effective management of the environment. This department comprises of following four (4) sections such as (i) Cleansing Section, (ii) Parks Section, (iii) Environmental Management and Planning Section, and (iv) Administration Section. Its key responsibilities include: (i) Garbage collection, transportation, and disposal (ii) Street/road sweeping, litter picking and drains clearing (iii) Grass cutting and bushes clearing in public parks, open spaces and road reserves (iv) Urban reforestation and beautification (v) Management of parks and open spaces (vi) Management of the solid waste disposal sites (vii) Formulation and implementation of effective environmental management policies (viii) Creation of public awareness on environmental issues (ix) Establishment of public/private partnership in environment management. (4) Kenya Forest Service (KFS) Kenya Forest Service (KFS) is a state corporation, established in February 2007 under the Forest Act of 2005. Its main mission is to conserve, develop and sustainably manage forest resources for Kenya's social-economic development. The KFS management structure comprises 10 conservancies that are ecologically demarcated, 76 Zonal Forest Offices, 150 forest Stations. 250 divisional forest extension Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 27 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya offices are working across the country and play critical roles in the forest management and relevant surveillance. To make the forest management more effective, forest adjacent communities have formed registered forest management bodies with assistance from KFS. Those registered groups are currently working with KFS to sustainably manage forest resources. In total, there are 325 community forest associations. In Nairobi, there are several forest reserves such as (i) Karura Forest Reserve (1,063 ha) and (ii) Ngong Forest Reserve (638.4 ha), supervised by KWS. Besides, the Nairobi Arboretum (25.0 ha) is also under KFSs supervision. (5) Kenya Wildlife Service (KWS) The Kenya Wildlife Service (KWS) conserves and manages Kenyas wildlife for the Kenyan people and the world. It is a state corporation established by an Act of Parliament Cap 376 with the mandate to conserve and manage wildlife in Kenya, and to enforce related laws and regulations. KWS undertakes the conservation and the management of wildlife resources outside protected areas in collaboration with stakeholders. The community wildlife program of KWS in collaboration with others encourages communities, located near and/or within important wildlife conservation areas, such as wildlife corridors and dispersal lands outside parks and reserves for the biodiversity conservation. KWS manages about 8 per cent of the total landmass of the country. Kenya has 22 National Parks, 28 National Reserves and 5 National Sanctuaries. Also under KWS management are 4 Marine National Parks and 6 Marine National Reserves on the Coast. In addition, KWS manages 125 field stations outside protected areas. Nairobi National Park (11,640 ha), located within Nairobi City, some 7 km away from the city centre, is conserved and supervised by KWS. (6) Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) The Water Resource Management Authority (WRMA) is a state corporation under the Ministry of Water and Irrigation (Now under MEWNR), established under the Water Act 2002. WRMA is the lead agency in nation-wide water resources management. Wetlands located along the tributaries running through Nairobi City are protected. If some development works are planned to be conducted inside of those wetlands, a special permit shall be obtained from this organization. 3.2.3 Economy and Investment (1) New Ministries Ministry of Commerce and Tourism and Ministry of Industrialisation and Enterprise Development are particularly related to the economic activities and investment promotion in Nairobi City. In addition, Ministry of Mining may have relevance to quarrying businesses in the city and Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Fisheries may play certain roles for the farms in the suburban areas in the city. (2) Other Public and Private Organisations The following are organisations and their major roles particularly relevant to businesses. 1) Investment Promotion, Industrial Infrastructure Provision and Business Promotion i) Kenya Investment Authority (KenInvest or KIA) Pre-Investment Services Assistance in obtaining any necessary licenses and permits, Assisting in obtaining incentives or exemptions under the Income Tax Act, the Customs and Excise Act, the Value Added Tax Act or other legislation, Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 28 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Providing information to investors on the business climate, operating rules, investment opportunities and sources of capital, and Liaison with other government agencies for the issuance of additional licenses and approvals not directly handled by the Authority. Post Investment Services Issuance of Investment Certificate, that facilitates immediate start of a business, Provision of After Care services ii) Export Processing Zones Authority (EPZA) EPZA operate EPZs at Athi River and Mombasa. It is noted that development of a new strategic plan became necessary to enable the Authority transform to the SEZ environment. iii) Kenya Industrial Estate Ltd (KIE) KIE was established in 1967 to provide development of industrial estates/sheds, financial support and entrepreneurship development. It became an independent state corporation in 1978, with the government as the sole shareholder. KIEs products and services are as follows. - Industrial estates development and incubation services - Industrial shed rehabilitation - Financial support services - Credit facilities - Special credit facilities for marginalized areas - Top up loan facilities - Bid bond facility - Performance bond facility - J itahidi group loans (group guarantee scheme) - Agency banking - Business advisory services - Facilitating inter firm linkages - Special government projects iv) Micro and Small Enterprise Authority (MSEA) MSEA is a newly established authority under Ministry of Industrialization and Enterprise Development in order to upgrade micro and small enterprises to small and medium enterprises. MSEA is to coordinate and harmonize all activities for MSE development. MSEAs specific tasks are a) financing, b) training, c) infrastructure development, and d) policy development. MSEA is a successor to Department of Micro and Small Enterprise Development (DMSED) of Ministry of Labour. DMSED was responsible for the formulation of policies and coordination of implementation strategies for the development of the MSE sector. 2) Multi-sectoral Private Sector Groups i) Kenya Private Sector Alliance (KEPSA) KEPSA seeks private sector development through advocacy, projects and partnerships both local and international, as well as through policy formulation and implementation. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 29 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya ii) Kenya National Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KNCC&I) An umbrella organization of businessmen and industrialists in Kenya. iii) Nairobi County Business Association (NCBA) NCBA is a rebranded successor of Nairobi Central Business District Association (NCBDA). Its target area is the whole Nairobi County and no longer limited to the Central Business District. Its mandate is to be an intermediary between the government and the private sector. It is an umbrella of many private sector organizations. Its core functions are (1) improvement of security of businesses, (2) improvement of environment and beautification, and (3) request and proposals for improvement of the transportation system. Such functions are fulfilled by project implementation, advocacy and campaigns in collaboration with government organizations, particularly with NCC. One of the active members of NCBA is United Business Association (UBA). It is to support all types of SMEs. 3) Manufacturing i) Kenya Industrial Property Institute (KIPI) KIPI is a parastatal with the following functions. To administer Industrial Property rights; Provision of technological information to the public; Promoting inventiveness in Kenya and Provision of training on Industrial Property ii) Kenya Industrial Research and Development Institute (KIRDI) To promote industrialization in Kenya by undertaking industrial research, development and disseminating findings that have a positive impact on national development. iii) Kenya Association of Manufacturers (KAM) A representative organization for manufacturing with a wide range of services in advocacy, business services and communication. 4) Tourism i) Kenya Tourist Development Corporation (KTDC) KTDC is facilitating and providing affordable development funding and advisory services for long-term investment in Kenyas tourism industry. ii) Kenya Tourist Board (KTB) To market the country, sensitize the industry players and monitor the standards of the facilities accommodating tourists in Kenya. 5) ICT i) Kenya ICT Board Marketing (positioning and promoting Kenya as an ICT destination (locally and internationally), especially promoting Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and Offshoring) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 30 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Advisory (advise the government on all relevant matters pertaining to the development and promotion of ICT industries in Kenya) Capacity Building (providing government and other stakeholders with skills, capacity and funding for anchor implementation of ICT projects for development) Project Management (coordinating, directing and implementing anchor ICT projects in development) 6) Financial i) Capital Market Authority (CMA) Licensing and supervising all the capital market intermediaries Ensuring proper conduct of all licensed persons and market institutions. Regulating the issuance of the capital market products (bonds, shares etc ) Promoting market development through research on new products and institutions. Promoting investor education and public awareness Protecting investors interest 3.2.4 Infrastructure This section presents an analysis of the key institutions that relate to the infrastructure provision. These institutions are established by Acts of Parliament which provides for their funtions, roles and operation. The analysis also highlights how the NIUPLAN will help the specific institutions in meeting and executing their specific mandates and vise-versa. (1) Kenya National Highways Authority (KeNHA) Section 3, 4 and 5 of the Kenya Roads Act (2007) provide for the establishment and functions of the Kenya National Highways Authority (KeNHA) which is responsible for the management, development, rehabilitation and maintenance of national roads. Functions of KeNHA are as follows: (i) constructing, upgrading, rehabilitating and maintaining roads under its control; (ii) controlling national roads and road reserves and access to roadside developments; (iii) implementing road policies in relation to national roads; (iv) ensuring adherence to the rules and guidelines on axle load control prescribed under the Traffic Act (Cap. 403) and under any regulations under this Act; (v) ensuring that the quality of road works is in accordance with such standards as may be prescribed by the Minister; (vi) in collaboration with the Ministry responsible for Transport and the Police Department, overseeing the management of traffic and road safety on national roads; (vii) collecting and collating all such data related to the use of national roads as may be necessary for efficient forward planning under this Act; (viii) monitoring and evaluating the use of national roads; (ix) planning the development and maintenance of national roads; (x) advising the Minister on all issues relating to national roads; Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 31 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (xi) preparing the road works programmes for all national roads; (xii) liaising and co-ordinating with other road authorities in planning and on operations in respect of roads; and (xiii) Performing such other functions related to the implementation of this Act as may be directed by the Minister. There needs to be evolved a clear framework for cooperation between KeNHA and the NIUPLAN team for formulation of the Urban Transport Plan since the 2 main highways (Thika Superhighway and Mombasa Highway) that pass through the heart of Nairobi are under the care of KeNHA. The 2 roads contain large volumes of traffic passing through Nairobi, and the major problems associated with them is that they carry both local and through traffic. It is indeed worth noting that key urban transport strategies are to take the two highway corridors. (2) Kenya Urban Roads Authority (KURA) Sections9, 10, 11 and 12 of the Roads Act provide for the establishment, functions and composition of KURA which is the body corporate in charge of management, development, rehabilitation and maintenance of all public roads in the cities and municipalities in Kenya except where those roads are national roads. KURA has the following powers and duties: (i) constructing, upgrading, rehabilitating and maintaining roads under its control; (ii) controlling urban road reserves and access to roadside developments; (iii) implementing roads policies in relation to urban roads; (iv) ensuring adherence by motorists to the rules and guidelines on axle load control prescribed under the Traffic Act (Cap. 403) and under any regulations under this Act; (v) ensuring that the quality of road works is in accordance with such standards as may be defined by the Minister; (vi) in collaboration with the Ministry responsible for transport and the Police Department, overseeing the management of traffic and road safety on urban roads; (vii) monitoring and evaluating the use of urban roads; (viii) planning the development and maintenance of urban roads; (ix) collecting and collating all such data related to the use of urban roads as may be necessary for efficient forward planning under this Act; (x) preparing the road works programmes for all urban roads; (xi) liaising and co-ordinating with other road authorities in planning and on operations in respect of roads; (xii) advising the Minister on all issues relating to urban roads; and (xiii) Performing such other functions related to the implementation of this Act as may be directed by the Minister. Urban Transport is an important component of any integrated plan for urban development. In the preparation of the NIUPLAN, there needs to be strong collaboration between KURA and the NIUPLAN team. KURA is currently engaged in development of all urban roads in Nairobi with involvement in most roads, including the new ones like the by-passes and the missing links. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 32 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (3) Energy Regulatory Commission The Energy Act establishes the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) which is an independent body corporate with the objects and functions to: (i) Regulate - a. importation, exportation, generation, transmission, distribution, supply and use of electrical energy; b. importation, exportation, transportation, refining, storage and sale of petroleum and petroleum products; c. production, distribution, supply and use of renewable and other forms of energy; (ii) protect the interests of consumer, investor and other stakeholder interests; (iii) maintain a list of accredited energy auditors as may be prescribed; (iv) monitor, ensure implementation of, and the observance of the principles of fair competition in the energy sector, in coordination with other statutory authorities; (v) provide such information and statistics to the Minister as he may from time to time require; and (vi) collect and maintain energy data; (vii) prepare indicative national energy plan; (viii) Perform any other function that is incidental or consequential to its functions under this Act or any other written law. The Energy Act stipulates conditions for the ERC for granting licenses for generation, importation, exportation, transmission or distribution of electrical energy, including certain provisions that are particular to the well-being of the environment, including such provisions as to: (i) the impact of the undertaking on the social, cultural or recreational life of the community; (ii) the need to protect the environment and to conserve the natural resources in accordance with the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act of 1999 (No. 8 of 1990; (iii) land use or the location of the undertaking; (iv) economic and financial benefits to the country or area of supply of the undertaking; (v) the economic and energy policies in place from time to time; (vi) the cost of the undertaking and financing arrangements; (vii) the ability of the applicant to operate in a manner designed to protect the health and safety of users of the service for which the licence or permit is required and other members of the public who would be affected by the undertaking; (viii) the technical and financial capacity of the applicant to render the service for which the licence or permit is required; (ix) any representations or objections made under subsection (4) of section 28 (which provides for the procedures for making representations and/ or objections to applications seeking permits); (x) the proposed tariff offered; and Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 33 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (xi) any other matter that the Commission may consider likely to have a bearing on the undertaking. (4) Kenya Pipeline Corporation (KPC) Kenya Pipeline Corporation (KPC) is the state corporation in charge of the only pipeline network in Kenya. KPC, alongside KRC has high controlling stakes in the City of Nairobis wayleaves. One key aspect that needs to be considered is the fact that a large chunk of the KPC wayleaves is occupied other land uses like informal settlements. KPC needs to contribute to NIUPLAN in order to help with information on identification and use of its facilities, networks and wayleaves to avert any possible disasters like the Sinai fire tragedy, as well as improve efficiency of the use of the land surrounding them. In the future, management of the wayleaves will need to be done in a manner consistent with the vision of Nairobi 2030 as is outlined in the NIUPLAN. (5) Kenya Power and Lighting Company (KPLC) KPLC is the body mandated to supply electricity in Kenya. KPLC buys the powers from generator KENGEN and sells on their behalf. For purposes of NIUPLAN, KPLC plays a critical role of enhancing connectivity, distribution and availability of electricity to consumers. Thus KPLC involvement in the NIUPLAN preparation is key as they control a large chunk of wayleaves in the city in addition to the role reliable electric power plays in development. (6) Kenya Electricity Transmission Company (KETRACO) Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Limited (KETRACO) was incorporated on 2nd December 2008 and registered under the Companies Act, Cap 486 pursuant to Sessional paper No. 4 of 2004 on Energy. KETRACO is 100% Government owned and being a state corporation, it is regulated under the State Corporations Act, Cap 446. The Company was established to develop new high voltage electricity transmission infrastructure that will form the backbone of the National Transmission Grid, in line with Kenya Vision 2030. In relation to the NIUPLAN, KETRACO is an important organization in laying of the infrastructure for electric power. Some of the infrastructure is sub-standard and needs to be upgraded. For purposes of the NIUPLAN, if the large power wayleaves are properly utilized by KETRACO, especially through construction of high quality towers, the wayleaves could be utilized safely for some significant urban functions that have limited land. (7) Kenya Railways Corporation This is an Act of Parliament for the establishment of the Kenya Railways Corporation, to be simply called Kenya Railways. The Act provides for the Powers of Kenya Railways Corporation being generally, without prejudice, to construct railways, development of roads to access the railways, development of parking, provision of train services, determination of tariffs and train fares. The other roles include responsibilities to buy and sell property, provision of housing to its employees and all such related services. Relating to the NIUPLAN, the KRC remains an important player in delivering sustainable urban transport framework for the whole of Nairobi. The current train system is not fully integrated with the city of Nairobi, and is not helping the City to develop effectively. However, the various MRTSN NUTRIP plans have the KRC facilities at the core of their development. The Urban Transport Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 34 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Strategies are themselves built around those studies, in addition to the current primary studies that have been conducted for NIUPLAN urban strategies. Further, the massive land holdings that the KRC holds around the current CBD are an important component in the land use planning of the CBD. The proposed Railway City is just one of the components of this NIUPLAN. (8) Athi Water Services Board Section 51 provides for the establishment of Water Services Boards. The role of these Boards include planning for improvement in provision of water supply and sewerage services, appointment and contracting water service providers as well as being asset holder of central government facilities. The Athi Water is one of the eight Water Boards under the Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources created to bring about efficiency, economy and sustainability in the provision of water and sewerage services in Kenya. Athi Water is created under Section 51 of the Water Act 2002 serving a population of over 4.5million in Nairobi and its environs. Under the Act, water service providers are licensed by water service boards to retail water in their jurisdictions. Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company is one such water service provider, which has been appointed by the Athi Water Service Board to provide water and sewerage services to the residents of Nairobi and its environs. The Nairobi Water Company is committed to ensuring that all stakeholders receive water regularly and efficiently and that the water reaching the customers is of highest quality. According to www.nairobiwater.co.ke, currently, of the three million residents of Nairobi, only 50 per cent have direct access to piped water. The rest obtain water from kiosks, vendors and illegal connections. Of the existing customers, about 40 per cent receive water on the 24-hour basis. This is a weakness that the NIUPLAN will look to solve to increase water availability to all the residents of Nairobi. 3.3 Review of Existing Urban Master Plans 3.3.1 History of Nairobi History of Nairobi City traces back to the last decade of the 19 th century, when the British started the Mombasa Uganda Railway. When the railway was started to be laid a camp for workers and a depot for construction materials and equipment was established in an elevated land, which later became Nairobi. The first plan of Nairobi was made in 1989, and the population reached 11,000 in 1906. In 1919, Nairobi became a Municipality, and the population started to grow. In 1927, the second plan of Nairobi for a Settle Capital was prepared by professionals. In 1948, shortly after the World War II, a new plan for Nairobi as a colonial town was prepared. The population at this time was 119,000. Then, Nairobi grew as a regional economic centre, and when Kenya achieved her independence in 1963, Nairobi became the capital city of Republic of Kenya. The population of Nairobi at the time of independence was 342,000. In 1969 National Census was started in Kenya. The population of Kenya in 1969 at the time of the 1 st
Census was 509,000, but the population reached the one million mark in the 3 rd Census in 1989, exceeded the two million mark in the subsequent Census in 1999, and then the three million mark in the most recent Census in 2009. In terms of the population growth, the annual average growth rates of Nairobi population have been more than 6% since its birth until the first Census in 1969. The annual growth rates has subsided to a 4% per annum since then until 1999, and now it falls below the 4% per annum mark. This means that the population in Nairobi is going through a process of rapid growth to a stable one recently. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 35 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.3.1 Historical Change of Population of Nairobi Year Population (1,000) Average Annual Growth Rate (%) Remark 1906 11 1 st Master Plan (1898), 2 nd Plan for Settler Capital (1927) 1948 119 6.84 3 rd Master plan(1948) 1963 342 7.29 Independence (1963), Capital of Kenya 1969 509 6.85 1 st Census 1979 828 4.99 4 th Master plan (1973), 2 nd Census 1989 1,325 4.81 3 rd Census 1999 2,143 4.93 4 th Census 2009 3,138 3.89 5 th Census, New Constitution (2010) Source: Nairobi City County 3.3.2 History of Urban Planning of Nairobi (1) First Plan of Nairobi in 1898 The first plan of Nairobi was drawn by a young assistant railway engineer by the name of Arthur Frederick Church in 1898. Church was only 30 years old when he was dispatched here to assist Chief Engineer George Whitehouse, and was instructed to prepare a town layout for the railway depot at Nairobi. Churchs plan had the following features: (i) Nairobi Station was just about the same location today, and the railway was laid out where the Uhuru highway is today, (ii) A main street from the railhead, which was called Station Road (todays Tom Mboya Street), was laid out from the station to north, with a design to be wide enough for three-axled oxcart wagons to turn, (iii) Another street parallel to Station Road, called Victoria Street (renamed as Government Street in 1901, and todays Moi Avenue) was laid out with the same width as the Station Road, along which were thirteen commercial plots called European Bazaar, (iv) Off Victoria Street were ten streets along which houses for railway workers were built. (v) Along the rise that bordered the flat land were a half dozen sites for upper grade houses for senior railway men, which is todays railway golf course, and (vi) The Nairobi river was dammed up to create a impounding pond. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 36 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: S. Mills, Railway to Nowhere The Building of the Lunatic Line, Nairobi, 2012 Figure 3.3.1 First Plan of Nairobi by A. F. Church in 1898 The first town plan was approved by Chief Engineer Whitehouse on 30 th November, 1898 and dispatched to London for approval. The spelling of the town was changed by Whitehouse from Nyrobi to Nairobi as is used today before his approval. The first plan strikingly resembles the town layout of Nairobi CBD and its environs today. (2) Plan for a Settler Capital in 1927 The Plan for a Settler Capital was drawn by F. Walton J ames and planned by Eric Dutton in 1927 under the British East African rule. The city area was expanded to 77 km 2 to accommodate the growing population. The plan focused on improvement of drainage and clearing of swamps and regulating building and density. The plan introduced traffic regulations to reach the expanded land for residence, though the residential area was generally segregated by racial groups. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 37 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: ETH Studio Basel, History of Urban Planning in Nairobi, 2008 Figure 3.3.2 Plan for Settler Capital in 1927 (3) Master Plan for a Colonial Capital in 1948 The new plan was an experiment in town planning for the colonial city of Nairobi, prepared by L. W. T. White, architect and town planner and Head of Department of Architecture, University of Cape Town and others. The master plan was funded by Municipal Council of Nairobi and the Railway Authorities. In this plan, a zoning scheme was introduced with zones for official buildings, business and commercial, industry, railway, residential, official housing, open space, forest reserve and parks. One of the goals of the plan was to establish neighbourhood units for the working class for segregation. Also the plan was expected to make Nairobi more attractive for industrial investments. It is noteworthy that the alignment of the railway had been changed to the present one along the western part of the town, which gave way for the expansion of the Uhuru highway today. The area to the south of the railway station was converted to an extensive industrial zone. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 38 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: ETH Studio Basel, History of Urban Planning in Nairobi, 2008 Figure 3.3.3 Master Plan for a Colonial Capital in 1948 (4) Nairobi Metropolitan Growth Strategy 1973 In 1971, the United Nations assisted the formulation of Metropolitan Growth Strategy in collaboration with the UN experts, urban planners in the City Council of Nairobi and urban planning consultants to form a Nairobi Urban Study Group. In 1973, Nairobi Metropolitan Growth Strategy was published. The Team Leader was Charu Gupta (1971-72) and Donald Monson (1972-73). The Metropolitan Strategy set the ultimate target year of 2000, and an intermediate target of 1985. The population of Nairobi was about 590,000 in 1971, and the population of Nairobi was projected to be 2.88 million in 2000, which was composed of 1.94 million for NCC and the remaining balance in adjoining area outside of NCC, including Ruiru and western Shamba. The actual population of NCC was 2.20 million in 2000, so the target was slightly surpassed. The recommended strategy of the 1973 plan contains 6 parts listed below: (i) Regional Strategy (ii) City Strategy (iii) Description of the Strategy by area (iv) Phasing of Development (v) The Recommended Transport Policy (vi) Implementation Resource Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 39 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya In the section of phasing of development, a distribution of the projected population in 2000 is shown below. Estimated population of Nairobi city was 1,945,000 and urban population including Ruiru and Western Shamba was 2,883,000.
Source : Nairobi City County Figure 3.3.4 Recommended Distribution of Population in 2000 For the 1973 development plan proposals to be realised, the following were required among other factors and conditions:- (i) The 1973 plan was essentially a long-term structure planning policy recommendation of broad long-term policy directions, strategies, possibilities and guidelines for the development of Nairobi City. The plan was thus required to be translated into short-term detailed implementable development programmes and projects, appropriate for each local zone or area of the city (ii) The plan also required the availability of financial capability and skilled professional personnel resources within the City Council of Nairobi and the Government of Kenya to facilitate the process of detailed planning and implementation of the planned actions at the local level (iii) This also required a significant strengthening and streamlining of the City Council of Nairobi and the Government of Kenya institutional decision-making and enforcement machinery and instruments for effective implementation and realisation of the goals and objectives of the 1973 plan. It is observed with regret that the above stated conditions was hardly met in the process of its subsequent implementing phase the 1973 development plan for the city of Nairobi. As a result and with direct relevance to the planning area:- (i) Development has continued without the guidance of a detailed localized zonal system; i.e. Physical Development Plan (ii) The forces of speculation and private investment that desire to maximise profit have driven the process of development in these areas with minimum control or guidance from the authorities concerned Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 40 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (iii) This development has also taken place without regard to the limitations of the existing infrastructural, transport and utility facilities to support increased development in the planning area (iv) The existing extreme shortage of housing generally prevailing in the whole city of Nairobi has only helped to fuel the speculative development process In the 1973 Strategy, a variety of proposals were made in relation to the urban planning of Nairobi, major part of which are given below: (i) Central Business District (CBD) was already congested, and it was proposed to supplement some of the functions of CBD in some suburban sub-centres to avoid excessive concentration in reference to experiences in some of the major metropolitan areas in the world. For Nairobi, a wide road surrounding CBD was proposed with bus ways to connect to residential and industrial areas, and use of private cars was to be curtailed so that an increasing number of population would shift to public transport. (ii) The industrial area close to CBD was providing a large number of employments, but was already heavily concentrated. Excessive concentration was to be avoided. When necessary the expansion may be limited to capital-incentive, urban industry type with limited employments. For other existing industries, expansion of production shall be recommendable in suburban locations. (iii) The northern part of the City, which then had mostly been taken in as coffee plantation and estates, was expected to be urban area by the turn of the century. As some areas were steep-sided hills that were not easy to convert to high to medium density housing area or industrial area, they were to be used mainly for low density housing development. (iv) The southern part of the City, which includes Kibera and Wilson Airport was to be used chiefly as residential area for low to medium income population. Wilson Airport was to be relocated to a site outside of Nairobi. The site after the relocation may be suited for industrial area. (v) Karen and Langata area continued to be used for middle to high income population. (vi) Dagoretti was an area in the west of the City, which was expected to have rapid population growth. In order to absorb employments within the zone, provision of industrial area and commercial centres would be necessary. (vii) The eastern part of the city would continue to serve for low to middle income population except in a few of high end estates. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 41 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: ETH Studio Basel, History of Urban Planning in Nairobi, 2008 Figure 3.3.5 Nairobi Metropolitan Growth Strategy 1973 3.3.3 Nairobi City Development Ordinances and Zones This subsection looks into some of the practices in Nairobi Citys regulation on the zoning systems, though the system itself is not complete and systematic.. (1) Old Zoning Systems A preliminary land use zoning was designated for the 1948 master plan in smaller Nairobi boundary in 8,315sqkm with 20 zones. Then a new scheme based on the expanded to existing Nairobi County boundary was introduced in 1968. This zoning system tried to regulate land use and minimum plot size by th zones established as below. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 42 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source : Nairobi City County Figure 3.3.7 Hill Area Zoning Plan
Source : J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 3.3.6 Zone Map by JST (2) Revision of Zoning for Upper Hill Area in 1993 The City Council of Nairobi in conjunction with the Physical Planning Department of Ministry of Lands engaged in a joint study and formulated the Upper Hill rezoning plan in 1993. This revision was motivated by the rapid developments in the area and the infrastructure services remained mostly unmatched particularly for the roads. In the meanwhile, a number of modern office buildings come up in the Upper Hill area. One of the challenges that was faced by the City Council of Nairobi in implementation of the revised plan was the level of infrastructure in place vis-a-vis the magnitude of development being realized. Although the 1993 rezoning plan provided for widening and expansion of the roads serving the area, this had not been implemented much afterwards. (3) Nairobi City Development Ordinances and Zones The last zoning review was carried out in 2004 and resulted in subdividing 20 zones into smaller zones and prescribed ground coverage ratios(GC) and plot ratios (PR), and definition of the minimum plot size for each zone. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 43 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.3.2 Part of Nairobi City Development Ordinances and Zones
Source : Nairobi City County
This revision allowed developers a maximum of four floors for apartments in Westlands, Parklands, Woodley, Kilimani and Kileleshwa. However, it just followed the situation in those areas and the current development activities are did not seem to follow the revised regulation much. There can be observed in incidents of high rise building of more than 5 floors and land use mixture in residential areas. Actual regulation may seem to be more ad-hoc than the adopted scheme. Maps indicating the standing regulations were planned for public reference, but have not been realized. Thus the zoning itself lacks discipline and strength to control the day to day development activities appropriately. (4) Revision of existing zones and regulation NCC conducted two studies on Land Use Study and Policy Plan for Zones 3, 4 & 5 and Zones 6, 13 & 20B in 2012. And also another study was conducted for Upper Hill area with stakeholder forums in 2008. These revisions are not authorised yet for waiting the outcome of this master plan study. 3.3.4 Strategy and Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Nairobi Metro 2030 (prepared in 2008) and Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region (prepared in 2013) are considered umbrella plans for the present the Nairobi Integrated Urban Development Master Plan (NIUPLAN). Some of the recommendations and proposals in the Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region will be integrated in NIUPLAN. The components related to formulation of NIUPLAN were reviewed hereafter. (1) Nairobi Metro2030 Nairobi Metro 2030 is a part of an overall national development agenda for Kenya towards 2030 and aims at optimizing the role of Nairobi Metropolitan Region (NMR) in the national development context. The Nairobi Metro 2030 is composed of: (i) growth and development framework, (ii) Metropolitan Nairobis strategic challenges, (iii) vision and goals, (iv) growth management structure, the goals, strategies and actions, (v) strategic vision to reality: employing class metropolitan governance systems. Outline of the plan is summarized below. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 44 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Delineation of the Nairobi Metro Boundary NMR is much larger area than Nairobi City. Population of NMR is 6.64 million (2009 Kenya Population and Housing Census) and the area is 32,000km 2 , while the population of Nairobi is 3.1 million and the area is 695.1 km 2 . The following table shows the local authorities included in the Nairobi Metropolitan Region. Local authorities included in the NMR are listed in the table below. Table 3.3.3 Delineation of the Nairobi Metro Boundary Groups Local Authorities Core Nairobi City Council of Nairobi The Northern Metro Municipal Council of Kiambu, Municipal Council of Ruiru, Municipal Council of Karuri, Town Council of Kikuyu, County Council of Kiambu The Southern Metro Town Council of Kajiado, County Council of Olkejuado The Eastern Metro Town Council of Tala/Kangundo, Municipal Council of Machakos, Municipal Council of Mavoko, County Council of Masaku Source : J ICA Study Team(J ST) Vision, goals, and strategies set in the Nairobi Metro 2030 are summarized below. Vision Metropolitan Vision 2030: To be a world class African metropolis, supportive of the overall national agenda articulated in Kenya Vision 2030 Four principal: (1) A world class working environment (2) A world class living environment (3) A world class business environment (4) World class metropolitan governance Key foundation for Metropolitan Vision 2030 (1) Building internationally competitive and inclusive economy for prosperity (2) Deploying world class infrastructure and utilized for the region (3) Optimizing mobility through effective transportation (4) Enhancing the quality of life and inclusive in the region (5) Delivering a unique image & identity through effective place branding (6) Ensuring a safe and secure region (7) Building world class governance system Goal, strategies and actions Goals Strategy and action Building and internationally competitive inclusive economy for prosperity Building a regional and global financial services, regional trade and business services hub Regional manufacturing, industrial technology parks initiative Building the Jomo Kenyatta International Airport city Diplomatic initiative Bringing the world to Nairobi Metropolitan Region: a tourisminitiative Regional and global research and education hub Enhancing service culture in work organizations Deploying world class infrastructure and utilities for the Region Service level mapping exercise and benchmark nationally, regionally and globally Energy demand management initiative Water master plan Integrated waste management project A comprehensive stormwater drainage and flood water mitigation plan A metropolitan wide strategic environment assessment Integrated information communication technology infrastructure plan Smart city/villages strategy Develop and integrated metropolitan infrastructure master strategy and plan Optimizing mobility and accessibility through effective transportation Metropolitan road transport infrastructure measures Metropolitan mass rapid transit program Traffic management strategies Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 45 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Goals Strategy and action Central business district access strategies Demand management Logistics and supply chain management Land use measures Information and communication technology in transport measures Coordination of institutional interventions Metropolitan road safety program Enhancing quality of life and inclusiveness in the Region Housing and elimination of slumprogram Environmental management strategy Enhancing access to medical services strategy Enhancing access to and performance of education Enhancing food safety and security Ethnic and race relations Integrated spatial strategy for the Nairobi Metropolitan Region Delivering a unique image and identity through effective branding Branding and promoting the Nairobi Metropolitan Region A Nairobi Metropolitan Region heritage and culture strategy An identity building urban design and landscaping strategy Ensuring a safe and secure Nairobi Metropolitan Region An effective metropolitan policing strategy Street light program Building an effective metropolitan emergency service Metropolitan street addressing program (2) Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region was prepared by the Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development and approved in March 2013. According to the staff of the Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development, despite the fact that the Ministry Nairobi Metropolitan Development does not exist in the new government structure, the plan is still valid and NIUPLAN has to be in line with the Spatial Plan Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region. Some important contents of the Plan, such as population framework, settlement pattern (build up area and new town), settlements hierarchy, land use/land cover, design intervention of Nairobi City County, which will be a base for NIUPLAN, are summarized from the Plan as shown below. 1) Population Framework The population size of Nairobi City County is forecast under the following assumptions: Gradual containment of Nairobis growth to be within acceptable, optimum city density. Disincentives for location of activities within Nairobi such as heavy industries, which require large extent of land, cause major environmental pollution and generate heavy goods traffic. Promotion of activities and investments in the other parts of the region through incentives. These policies would include favourable land policies, improved accessibility and connectivity, higher levels of physical and social infrastructure, fiscal incentives, differential pricing of services, etc. The gross density of Nairobi City County, by 2030, is proposed to be limited to 75 persons per ha increasing from 52 persons per ha in 2009. The assigned population size of Nairobi City County, by size, is 5.21 million and housing demand is forecasted at 1,303,125 in 2030. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 46 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.3.4 Population of NMR Sr. No. Spatial Units 2009 2030 1 NMR Urban Rural 6,658,000 4,924,286 1,733,714 15,131,435 13,073,459 2,057,976 2 Nairobi City 3,138,369 5,212,500 3 ONMR Urban Rural 3,519,631 1,785,917 1,733,714 9,918,935 7,860,959 2,057,976 4a Northern Metro Urban Rural 1,786,879 991,852 795,027 4,971,173 4,187,315 783,859 4b Eastern Metro Urban Rural 1,045,440 511,343 534,097 2,962,187 2,376,206 585,981 4c Southern Metro Urban Rural 687,312 282,722 404,590 1,985,575 1,297,438 688,137 Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region (2) Settlements Hierarchy of Settlements Proposed Settlement Hierarchy for NMR in 2030 is summarized below. Nairobi city county is classified in theRegional Complex. Table 3.3.5 Settlement Hierarchy of NMR Level Settlement Hierarchy Settlements Characteristics I Regional Complex Nairobi-Ngong-Ongata Rongai-Ruiru Complex Highest administrative functions Specialised and world class facilities Tertiary activities II Sub-Regional Centre Thika, Kikuyu, Kiambu, Machakos, Tala/Kangundo, Kajiado Administrative functions / County headquarters Higher level infrastructure Secondary and tertiary activities Strong industrial base IIA Priority Town New Towns Planned to decongest Nairobi and developments in the surrounding regions. Designed with specialised facilities on the basis of world class norms To be planned as special packages and special focus for development III Growth Centre Limuru, Karuri, Juja, Mavoko, Kitengela, Loitoktok Intermediary towns Important role in promoting rural development and in achieving a balanced distribution of urban population Provide functional linkages between the smaller towns and Sub-Regional Centre IV Market Centre Gatundu, Githunguri, Kathiani, Kiserian, Namanga, Isinya, Bissil, Sultan Hamud Magadi Small town having linkages with immediate rural hinterlands. Is the higher order village having central location and potential for development within its catchment area, with relatively better services and facilities in terms of education, health, communication, accessibility and has the capacity to serve a group of Basic villages. V Central Village Centre To be identified as part of sub-regional plans Would cater to the rural hinterland as agro service centre in the collection and distribution of agricultural goods and services with processing, marketing, warehousing and storage facilities. VI Basic Village All villages Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 47 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Figure 3.3.8 Proposed Urban Settlements Pattern 3) New towns Six New Towns proposed within the NMR such that each County has two New towns. The six proposed New Towns are as follows.
Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Figure 3.3.9 Location of New Town Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 48 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.3.6 List of New Towns Proposed No New Towns Characteristics 1 Aerotropolis Function The Aerotropolis will comprise aviation-intensive businesses and related enterprises. Aerotropolis typically attract industries related to time-sensitive manufacturing, e-commercefulfillment, telecommunications and logistics; hotels, retail outlets, entertainment complexes and exhibition centres; and offices for business people who travel frequently by air or engage in global commerce. Clusters of business parks, logistics parks, industrial parks, distribution centres, information technology complexes and wholesale merchandise marts locate around the airport and along the transportation corridors radiating fromthem. An air transport oriented SEZ to be part of the proposed Aerotropolis. Location The Aerotropolis is proposed near Thika municipality, north of Garissa Road in between proposed regional orbital and Greater Eastern By-pass extension to Thika at a distance of approximately 40 kmfromCBD, Nairobi. 2 Knowledge-cum-Health City (Nairobi) Function The Knowledge-cum-Health City would comprise agricultural research centres, technological university, management institutes, agro-based health centres and hospitals, and other institutions. Location The Knowledge-cum-Health City is proposed north of Limuru Road, coffee and tea plantations at a distance of approximately 20 kmfromCBD, Nairobi. 3 Cyber City Function: The Cyber City would comprise service oriented industries in the field of information technology and information technology enabled services (IT/ITeS) for the region. Location: The Cyber City is proposed at the junction of Greater Eastern By-pass and Kangundo road in Machakos County at a distance of approximately 30 kmfrom CBD, Nairobi. 4 Transport New Town Location: The Transport New Town is proposed along the regional orbital near the transport-cumlogistic hub near Kajiado in Kajiado County at a distance of approximately 60 kmfromCBD, Nairobi. Population and Density It has been envisaged that by 2030 the Transport New Town will accommodate a population of 100,000 with a population density of 50 ppha 5 Sports City Function: The Sports City would incorporate world-class sporting venues and sports academies, as well as residential and commercial properties and all related amenities such as hotels, entertainment outlets, schools, medical facilities and retail opportunities. It is envisaged that the main sports complex will have a multi-purpose outdoor stadiumof a capacity of 60,000 seats. The stadiumcould be used for athletics, cricket and football. Also a 25,000 seat cricket ground, a 10,000 seat indoor arena and a 5,000 seat field hockey stadiumare proposed apart fromsports academies and institutes. Location: The Sports City is proposed on a relatively flat land at the junction of the Mombasa road and the regional orbital in Machakos County at a distance of approximately 60 kmfromCBD, Nairobi. 6 Amboseli New Town. Function: Amboseli New Town would comprise of the hospitality industry to boost tourismin the area. It would comprise of hotels, resorts, entertainment outlets, gaming arcades, outdoor activities with plush green landscaped gardens. Location: The new town is proposed adjacent to the Amboseli National Park at a distance of approximately 150 kmfromCBD, Nairobi. Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 49 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4) Land cover/land use Following land use classification is proposed for NMRs. Table 3.3.7 Proposed Land Use Classification No Land use classification Characteristics 1 Settlement Zone: Settlement zone is the spatial built up area within the region and covers both urban and rural areas. 2 Transport Zone: The transport zone includes area under road, rail and airports within the region. 3 Forest Zone: It includes all environmentally sensitive areas which are meant to be protected. It includes existing areas under forest, national parks; conservation zone; and open shrubs, plantation and riverine trees. 4 Water Bodies: The water bodies in the region are divided into 3 categories: rivers, drainage; swamps and sand; and other water bodies. 5 Agriculture and Rangeland: It includes land used for agriculture and related activities such as grazing, etc. Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region
Settlement zone is proposed as follow. All of Nairobi City County and Six New Towns are classified as settlement zones.
Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Figure 3.3.10 Development Pattern, Settlement/Build Up 2009 & 2030 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 50 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Land use classification for urban centres of NMR and distribution for Nairobi city county have been proposed as follow. Table 3.3.8 Proposed Urban Land Use Classification for NMR and Distribution for Nairobi City County No. Land use categories Area / Activities included within the land use Area (ha) (%) 1 Residential Areas - Primary residential - Mixed residential - Unplanned / informal residential 27,800 40 2 Commercial Area - Retails shopping - General business and commercial district/centres - Wholesale, godowns, warehousing / regulated markets 2,780 4 3 Public and semi-public - Govt./semi govt./public offices - Govt. Land - Educational and research - Medical and health - Social, cultural and religious - Utilities and services - Cremation and burial grounds. 5,560 8 4 Industrial area: - Service and light industry - Extensive and heavy industry - Special industrial, hazardous, noxious and chemical. 6,950 10 5 Transport: - Roads - Railways - Airport - Seaports and dockyards - Bus depots/truck terminals and freight complexes - Transmission and communication. 12,510 18 6 Open spaces -Playground / stadium/ sports complex -Parks and gardens-public open spaces -Special recreational restricted open spaces -Multiple-purpose open spaces 13,900 20 Total
69,500 100 Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region 5) Design Interventions for Nairobi Urban design and regional landscape is also proposed in the Spatial Planning Concept, particularly in CBD of Nairobi City County. Following interventions are recommended in the Plan: (i) Establishment CBD as a City Precinct (ii) Redevelopment of Moi Avenue (iii) New Square development in the CBD Area. (iv) Air force Station area reorganization (v) Industrial area reorganization & linkages (vi) Capitol Complex development (vii) Nairobi riverfront development Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 51 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The figures shown below illustrate one of interventions proposed for urban design and regional landscape for CBD. Figure 3.3.11 illustrates the necessity of delineation of boundary of CBD based on collective strategies, for development of entire area (intervention (i) establishment CBD as City Precinct). The main objective is proposed to make CBD as a City Precinct to Create a vibrant commercial centre. Figure 3.3.12 shows the idea for(v) industrial area recognition & linkages and illustrates importance of land use upgrading of the industrial area which allows for the CBD peripheral development for commercial and industrial activities.
Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Figure 3.3.11 CBD of Nairobi City County
Source: Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region Figure 3.3.12 CBD and Its Linkage to Railway, Upper Hills Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 52 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 3.4 Human Resources Development 3.4.1 Introduction (1) Background of Capacity Development As seen in earlier parts of the report, i) uncontrolled urban development, ii) insufficient infrastructure, iii) poor living condition, iv) lack of social facilities, and v) transport problems have been identified as major urban problems in Nairobi city. These problems are caused by (i) demand side, which is categorized by a large share of low and middle income group and extensive in-migration from the rural area, and by (ii) public sector/supply side, which is categorized into lack of updated urban development plans, lack of comprehensive development management system, and insufficient capacity of urban development management. Among these causes, insufficient capacity of urban development management is addressed as a human resources management and capacity development issue. For effective management of urban development, capacity development is a crucial instrument for improvement. To sustain the organization in the long run, it is also very important to address capacity development. (2) Output of Capacity Development in the Project The following outputs for capacity development are to be attained in the Project in order to cater for effective urban management. To formulate mid-long term capacity development plan To formulate technology transfer plan during the project Technology transfer will be conducted between Kenyan counterparts and J apanese experts in the course of the Project. Capacity development plan as a management tool for strengthening of urban management will be formulated through discussion with Working Group members during the Project. The capacity development plan is a part of the urban master plan, so the capacity development plan covers not only the short-term capacity development scheme during the project but also extends to mid-long term after the project. It should be noted that the City Council of Nairobi (CCN) is in transition to Nairobi City County (NCC), and the following basically pertains to the situation under CCN. In the transition some changes may occur in relation to human resources development and management, which are yet to be observed. 3.4.2 Current Situation of Human Resources Management Human Resources Development Department of CCN is in charge of human resources development. For the department level, administration section of each department plays an important role to execute human resources management and capacity development. With the cooperation of the administration section of the City Planning Department, the Project Team conducted an interview survey and literature survey to grasp the current situation of capacity development. (1) Interview Survey Project team had interviews to the chiefs of the sections in the City Planning Department of CCN. Table 3.4.1 shows the results of training needs by each section. Most of the sections see GIS as the most important skill to execute the works. GIS is seen to make works easy and efficient. ICT is also effective not only in document preparation and data analysis but also in retrieving information from database. However, the number of computers and software is too small to meet the needs. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 53 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.4.1 Number of Officials and Training Needs Section Number of Officials Necessary Skills Policy Implementation 11 (Technical 4, Admin. 7) GIS Enforcement 18 (Technical 6, Admin. 12) Building Control Development Control 40 (Technical 15, Admin. 25) ICT Auto CAD Research 18 (Technical 14, Admin. 4) ICT GIS Forward Planning 14(Technical 8, Admin. 6) GIS Land & Survey 40 (Technical 15, Admin. 25) GIS Urban Design 18 (Technical 6, Admin. 12) GIS Source: J ICA Study Teambased on Interview to City Planning Dept. CCN The current grading structure in CCN comprises 18 grades altogether, made up of eight management and 10 non-management grades. The following table shows staff numbers per grade in the City Planning Department. The share of supporting staff is the largest and about 70% of the staff members of the department. Supporting staff include drivers and cleaning staff, who are not engaged in planning works. Table 3.4.2 Number of Employee in City Planning Dept. CCN Salary Scale Level Staff Level Number of employees within the grade Scale 1-4 Senior Management 1 (0.5%) Scale 5-8 Middle level management 21 (9.7%) Scale 9-10 Non-management 48 (22.1%) Scale 11-18 Support 147 (67.7%) Total 217 (100%) Source: City Planning Dept. CCN The officials have taken training courses in universities, poly techniques, training schools by Government of Kenya, or technical colleges. Taking the course is the main method of capacity development in the department. An internal training programme such as the lecture by senior staff is not frequently conducted. The cost of taking the course at external organizations is shouldered by CCN, but the officials have to pay tuition first by themselves and submit the completion certificate of the courses to CCN after the trainings. CCN reimburses the tuition after checking the certificate. It is difficult for the officers who cannot afford to pay tuition first to take the training courses at external organizations. Also, the risk of non-completion is totally on the staff, which makes it more difficult for the staff to enrol. (2) Literature Survey 1) Skills and Competency Needs Assessment Baseline Survey Human Resources Management Department is conducting Skills and Competency Needs Assessment Baseline Survey by outsourcing to a private consultant every year. CCN sees employee trainings as the most important factor to provide better administrative services to the public. The government recruitment and training policy (2005) which the council uses together with the councils policy on training requires that all trainings to be based on comprehensive training needs assessment. In addition, the performance contract for the year 2011/2012 for the council requires that periodic surveys be conducted to determine the skill level. This periodical survey should be highly evaluated to grasp the status of capacity development in CCN. However, it should be note that this is not a survey targeting all employees but a sample survey. From the target population of 11,433 employees of CCN, a sample of 653 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 54 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya respondents was selected using simple random sampling across all departments of the CCN. In all 25 out of 653 respondents are the officials belonging to City Planning Department. The following skills were assessed as shown in Table 3.4.3. The skills are general and mixed between administrative skills and technical skills. Table 3.4.3 Critical Skills Identified in Sample Survey No. Critical Skill 1 Record keeping/info management 2 Revenue mobilization 3 Financial planning & management 4 Management of public transportation & terminal 5 Urban research/studies/surveys 6 Management & implementation of urban development plans, projects & program 7 Computer skills/IT 8 Expenditure, planning and control 9 Slumupgrading and management 10 Strategic planning 11 Knowledge of government policies 12 Preparation of urban development strategies and guidelines 13 Efficient use of resources 14 Litigation and prosecution 15 Analyzing customer feedback and customer care skills 16 Planning and designing for urban housing renewal projects Source: Skills and Competency Needs Assessment Baseline Survey (2012) The survey also analyzes the style of capacity development. Four functions were listed for rating by the employees and all had high score of more than 60% (both very relevant and relevant). Workshops had the highest score in terms of relevance from the respondents with a score of 81.8%, followed by seminars at 79.3%, trainings at 75.6% and conference at 71.8%, as indicated in the graph below. Workshops are worth considering as the effective method of capacity development.
Source: Skills and Competency Needs Assessment Baseline Survey (2012) Figure 3.4.1 Relevance of Capacity Development Method 2) Human Resources Consultancy Phase 2 City Council Nairobi Pricewaterhouse Coopers prepared a report of human resources in April 2012. The report is an output of the following activities: Review and appraisal of the Councils strategic plan Proposal of a new organization structure Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 55 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Repositioning the Councils human resources plan, and Develop a staff rationalization plan The report targets all departments of CCN including City Planning Department. The report also performed a skills assessment. In the study, academic qualifications were taken as an indicator for acquired skills. The highest academic qualifications of officials in all department of CCN were analyzed with eight levels: i) no qualification, ii) primary, iii) high school, iv) trade test, v) certificate, vi) diploma, vii) higher national diploma, viii) degree. Academic qualifications were more or less correlated with skills, but having qualifications do not always mean having skills. A directly measurement if the officials have the required skills in his/her daily works or not should be more valued in the capacity assessment. (3) Capacity Assessment Capacity of necessary skills for NIUPLAN from planning stage to management stage has been assessed in October 2013. The target group of the assessment was the officials of Salary Scale Level 1 to 12 in the City Planning Department of NCC. The assessment sheet consists of 51 skills divided into five categories: 1) Planning, 2) Implementation, 3) Development, 4) Control, and 5) Management. These categories are consistent with a project cycle of project management. Among the target officials, 50 officials answered with the scale of one to five for each skill for the five categories. The highest scale is five (5) showing Very Well, followed by four (4) for Well, three (3) for Fair, and two (2) for Little. The lowest scale is one (1) showing Not at all. Table 3.4.4 shows the overview of the capacity assessment results. Among the five categories, the average score of Control is the highest. The average scores of Development and Management are the lowest and the second lowest respectively. NCC officials as a whole are strong in skills for Control and weak in skills for both Development and Management. The table also shows the strength and weakness for each category. The officials well understands the procedures and processes of planning, EIA, land acquisition, etc., but they are weak in ICT related skills such as GIS, web site, database, and funding related knowledge. Table 3.4.4 Overview of Capacity Assessment Results Category Average Score/Scale Strength Weakness 1. Planning 3.16 Procedure of planning formulation Knowledge of necessary information for planning Production of GIS maps Knowledge of possible funding schemes 2. Understanding of Master Plan 3.07 Understanding of Master Plan Formulation of civic education program 3. Development 2.94 Knowledge of EIA process Knowledge of land acquisition Fund raising Conducting of public procurement 4. Control 3.86 Development permission Respond to applicant Control illegal sign/outside advertisement 5. Management 2.95 Project evaluation Database management Update of web site Source: Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on Capacity Assessment to City Planning Dept of NCC
Table 3.4.5 shows strong and weak category of skills by section. Seven sections have strength in Control. Six sections have weakness in Management. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 56 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.4.5 Strong and Weak Category of Skills by Section Section Number of Respondents Average Score/Scale Strong (S) and Weak (W) Category Planning Und. Of MP Develop -ment Control Manage -ment (1) Forward Planning Section 5 3.27 3.70 3.15 3.56 2.89 (S): Und. of MP (W): Management (2) Research Section 4 2.25 2.50 1.84 3.09 1.89 (S): Control (W): Development (3) Central Administration 1 3.47 4.50 3.38 4.27 3.14 (S): Und. of MP (W): Management (4) Development Control Section 5 2.65 2.60 2.59 3.98 2.20 (S): Control (W): Management (5) Policy Implementation Section (PIS) 5 3.44 3.50 3.00 4.05 2.91 (S): Control (W): Management (6) Urban Design Development Section 10 3.00 2.90 2.98 4.16 2.80 (S): Control (W): Management (7) Enforcement Section 6 3.37 3.25 3.18 4.35 3.52 (S):Control (W): Development (8) Land Survey Section 11 3.54 2.95 3.19 3.54 3.53 (S): Planning/Control (W): Und. of MP Total/Average 47 3.16 3.07 2.94 3.86 2.95
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on Capacity Assessment to City Planning Dept of NCC Table 3.4.6 shows strong and weak skills by section. This table shows more specific strong and weak skills than Table 3.4.5. Table 3.4.6 implies fairly strong correlation between strong skills and tasks for each section. For example, Land Survey Section, responsible for land survey and development of GIS database, has strength in production of GIS thematic maps and updating information with GIS software. On the other hand, most of the sections have common weakness in production of GIS thematic maps, fund raising, understanding of possible funding schemes. Table 3.4.6 Strong and Weak Skills by Section Section Job Description Strong Skills Weak Skills (1) Forward Planning Section Responsible for policy formulation and supporting permit process. Execution of EIA Acquaintance of development permission procedure Production of GIS thematic maps Conducting of public procurement Project management (2) Research Section Responsible for supporting section by conducting survey and provide information regarding urban condition, housing, and infrastructure, renew land lease, register private schools, designating street names and designating physical address. Understanding of planning procedure Checking of compliance of development/constructio n at sites Responding to land use change application Understanding of procedure of availing funds Fund raising for project implementation Conducting of public procurement (3) Central Administrat ion Responsible for administrative matter, including staff evaluation, organization re-structure, and other supporting matters. Explanation of master plans Coordination among the related organizations Fund raising for project implementation Web update
(4) Developme nt Control Section Responsible for building construction permit management Acquaintance of development permission procedure Responding to land use change application Understanding of urban issues Production of GIS thematic maps Understanding of possible funding schemes Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 57 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Section Job Description Strong Skills Weak Skills (5) Policy Implementa tion Section (PIS) Responsible for land development permit management. Permit is required for change in land use, division of land plot, extension (adding) of new and use. Understanding of approval process of master plans Acquaintance of development permission procedure Responding to land use change application Production of GIS thematic maps Understanding of procedure of availing funds Updating information with GIS software (6) Urban Design Developme nt Section Responsible for development of landscape (greenery, bench, bus shelter) and management of advertisement Checking of compliance of development/constructio n at sites Responding to land use change application Acquaintance of sign control and outside advertisement Production of GIS thematic maps Fund raising for project implementation Web update (7) Enforceme nt Section Responsible for inspection and monitoring of development approved by Development Control Section and Policy Implementation Section. Acquaintance of development permission procedure Control illegal development Check compliance of sign control Understanding of possible funding schemes Coordination among the related organizations Fund raising for project implementation (8) Land Survey Section Responsible for conducting land survey that belongs to Nairobi city an develop GIS database. Production of GIS thematic maps Execution of land acquisition Updating information with GIS software Acquaintance of development permission procedure Fund raising for project implementation Conducting of public procurement Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on Capacity Assessment to City Planning Dept of NCC (4) Analysis of Current Situation As a result of an interview survey, literature survey, capacity assessment, the following characteristics in the current capacity development were identified. The concerned government officials are keen to capacity development. Target groups of capacity development are not clarified Capacity assessment items are fairly general. Take trainings conducted by external organizations such as universities has been more encouraged than internal trainings conducted by senior officials The needs for GIS/ICT skills are high in most of the sections. The strength of City Planning Department of CCN is that the officials are motivated to develop their capacity. The weakness is that the method of capacity development is not balanced as seen in high share of external trainings, high need to GIS/ICT skills, etc. Thus this project should enhance the strength and improve weakness to formulate a capacity development plan by solving the following issues. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 58 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (5) Issues of Capacity Development Through analysis of the current situation including strength and weakness in above (3), the issues to be tackled for improving capacity development in NCC are identified as shown in Figure 3.4.2. To solve the issues is the basic direction of capacity development plan.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 3.4.2 Capacity Development Issues 1) To keep momentum of capacity development in NCC Momentum of capacity development in NCC should be kept in Capacity Development Plan. NCC sees the capacity development as very important for better urban management. NCC (former CCN) already has had special function for human resources management such as Human Resources Department, as well as the administration section in City Planning Department. The assessment to the concerned NCC officials has been also conducted periodically. An official of Human Resources Department was appointed as a Secretariat Meeting member and Working Group member. These existing functions as well as mechanism for the assessment of capacity development should be fully utilized in not only planning but also implementation of capacity development. 2) To identify target groups of capacity development The merits of setting target groups are i) to be able to focus on the activities for important and prioritized stakeholders, ii) to be able to efficiently use available resources and monitor/evaluate activities, iii) to be able to attain outputs more effectively. Figure 3.4.3 schematically compares no specific target groups to specific target groups. Capacity Development Issues 1. To keep momentum of capacity development in NCC 2. To identify target groups of capacity development 3. To encourage internal trainings including On-the-Job Training (OJT) 4. To acquire fundamental skil ls of urban development Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 59 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 3.4.3 Comparison between No Specific Target Groups and Specific Target Groups 3) To encourage internal trainings including On-the-J ob Training (OJ T) Internal trainings including On-the-J ob Training (OJ T) and lectures by senior officials should be encouraged more. As a result of an interview to NCC official, the capacity for the concerned government officials has been developed mainly through the trainings conducted by outside organizations such as university, technical school, etc. Under the current system, only limited officials can burden the tuition, and thus can take part in the trainings outside. It is because NCC is applying the system to reimburse the tuition of the trainings upon the submission of the certificates of the trainings. This system discourages some officials to take part in the trainings outside. 4) To acquire fundamental skills of urban development The target officials should acquire fundamental skills of urban management, including information collection and analysis, planning, implementation of infrastructure development, and inspection and monitoring. The officials are required to develop GIS and ICT skills based on the capacity assessment, so that the output produced through GIS and ICT in the context of urban planning and management should be understood better. Knowledge of possible funding schemes and skills of fund raising are also to be strengthened. As such, the capacity development should address the development of the fundamental skills first. Table 3.4.7 shows the fundamental skills to be acquired by the officials. No Specific Target Groups - wider range of monitoring/evaluation targets - more dispersed resource allocation and results in smaller output - risks of more inappropriate resources allocation Specific Target Groups - clearer monitoring/evaluation targets - more concentrated resources allocation and results in larger output - leading more appropriate resources allocation Provider Receivers (All are targets) Provider Receivers (Target Groups)
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 60 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 3.4.7 Fundamental Skills to be Acquired
Topics for Capacity Development Explanation (i) Planning skills Objective of urban development plan (development oriented plan, control or conservation oriented plan) Planning technique: selection of scales, land use category, urban facility allocation( parks, green-open space, schools, hospitals), road network (urban planning road) to be included, urban design) Possible funding schemes (government budget, aid, loan, private funds, PPP schemes) (ii) Development control: land development control, building control Objective of development permit (why permit is necessary, how permit is related to urban development plan) Relationship between land permit and urban plan (iii) Implementation of urban development project examination of zone development mechanism, PPP Zoning development in the urban plan Implementation for infrastructure (project approval, fund raising, implementation organization)
(iv) Socialization and citizen participation Public awareness to citizens to deepen their understanding of urban plan, development control, etc Collaboration between civil society and government through community participation (v) Management Check consistency between actual development situation and related government policies Database management Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST)
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 3 - 61 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya CHAPTER 4 INFRASTRUCTURE CONDITION AND DONOR ACTIVITIES 4.1 Review of Related Projects by Development Partners 4.1.1 Multi-Sector Programme (1) Kenya Municipal Program (KMP) The Ministry of Local Government (MOLG, now under MOLHUD) is implementing the phase 1 of the Kenya Municipal Program (KMP) with the financial assistance by the World Bank, AFD and SIDA. The development objective of phase 1 is to strengthen local governance and improve service delivery in 15 selected municipalities through a combination of institutional reforms, capacity building, and investment in infrastructure. The phase 1 of the KMP is scheduled to be implemented from 2010 to 2015. The funding for this project consists of World Bank (IDA) US$100 million, Agence Franaise de Dveloppement (AFD) US$ 45 million, and Swedish International Development Cooperation (SIDA) and Government of Kenya US$1 million each, with the total amount of US$ 165 million. The 15 selected municipalities (major cities and towns) are (1) Nairobi, (2) Mombasa, (3) Kisumu, (4) Nakuru, (5) Eldoret, (6) Malindi, (7) Naivasha, (8) Kitui, (9) Machakos, (10) Thika, (11) Nyeri, (12) Garissa, (13) Kericho, (14) Kakamega, and (15) Embu. The project comprises the following three components. (i) Component 1: Institutional Strengthening (ii) Component 2: Participatory Strategic Urban Development Planning (iii) Component 3: Investment in Infrastructure and Service Delivery (iv) Component 4: Project Management, Monitoring and Evaluation Of the above, the Component 3 consists of the infrastructure developments considered as eligible for financing under the KMP; motorized and non-motorized transport facilities (including bus parks, access roads, sidewalks, and paved paths), street lighting, markets, solid waste management, storm water drainage, disaster management and prevention facilities and equipment, public parks and green spaces. The investments by the Component 3 are phased into two: (a) year 12 investments for implementing the infrastructure developments during 2010-2013; and (b) year 35 investments for implementing the infrastructure developments during 2013-2015. The selection of infrastructure developments belonging to the year 12 or year 35 investments is performed on the basis of the criteria established in the process of the project design of the KMP as described in the project appraisal report (World Bank, April 2010). Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 1 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The procurement plan has been developed for project implementation during the period J uly 2012 to J une 2013 which approved by the World Bank in August 2011. This plan includes 33 works projects, 23 goods procurement and 72 consultancy services. According to the Implementation Status & Result Report in November 2012, there was considerable risk towards meeting the projects development objectives, due primarily to the very slow implementation of the projects. Only one project, which was the Mombasa Storm Water Drain work, was implementing in September 2012. (2) Kenya Informal Settlements Improvement Project (KISIP) The Ministry of Housing (MOH) (currently under MOLHUD) is implementing the Kenya Informal Settlement Improvement Project (KISIP) with the financial assistance by the World Bank. The project development objective is to improve living conditions in informal settlements in 15 selected municipalities as below in Kenya. The KISIP is scheduled to be implemented from 2011 to 2016. The funding for KISIP is the same scheme as KMP, with the total funding of US$ 165 million. The 15 selected municipalities (major towns and cities) are (1) Nairobi, (2) Mombasa, (3) Kisumu, (4) Nakuru, (5) Eldoret, (6) Malindi, (7) Naivasha, (8) Kitui, (9) Machakos, (10) Thika, (11) Nyeri, (12) Garissa, (13) Kericho, (14) Kakamega, and (15) Embu. The KISIP comprises the following four components. (i) Component 1: Strengthening Institutions and Program Management This component will support institutional strengthening and capacity building of the MoH (now under MOLHUD), the MOLG (now partly under MOLHUD and MODP), and the participating municipalities (MAJ OR TOWNS AND CITIES). It will also support development of policies, frameworks, systems, and guidelines for slum upgrading. (ii) Component 2: Enhancing Tenure Security This component will directly support implementation of the new national land policy in urban informal settlements through refinement, systematization and scale-up of ongoing efforts to strengthen tenure security in slums. (iii) Component 3: Investing in Infrastructure and Service Delivery This component will support investment in settlement infrastructure, and, where necessary, extension of trunk infrastructure to settlements. (iv) Component 4: Planning for Urban Growth This component will support planning and development of options that facilitate delivery of infrastructure services, land and housing for future population growth. The objective is to provide an alternative to the current chaotic practice of informally establishing settlements on any open land. Of the above, the Component 3 supports investment in settlement infrastructure, and, where necessary, extension of trunk infrastructure to settlements. The infrastructure developments considered as eligible for financing under the KISIP are roads, bicycle paths, pedestrian walkways, street and security lighting, vending platforms, solid waste management, storm water drainage, water and sanitation systems, electrification, public parks and green spaces. The selection of infrastructure developments is performed on the basis of the criteria established in the process of the project design of the KISIP as described in the project appraisal report (World Bank, February 2011). (3) Nairobi Metropolitan Service Improvement Project (NaMSIP) Nairobi Metropolitan Services Improvement Project (NaMSIP) is a five years project which approved by the Board of the World Bank in May 2012. The Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 2 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (MONMD) (now under MOLHUD) is the responsible agency to implement the Project with the financial assistance by the World Bank. The project development objective is to strengthen urban services and infrastructure in the Nairobi metropolitan region. The total funding for this project is USD 330 million. (USD 300 million by World Bank (IDA), 30 million by government of Kenya).The Level of funding from this programme is US $28 Million for Nairobi City County which include projects in planning, transportation, disaster management ,GIS development, security lighting. The project comprises the following four components. (i) Component 1: Institutional reform and planning (US$15 million) This component will assist existing local authorities within the Nairobi metropolitan area, as well as new entities and authorities that will be created once the devolved government aspect of the new constitution takes effect. These new entities possibly include county governments, metropolitan authorities, and agencies, and other units of administration. This component will support the capacity enhancement and planning activities of these entities. (ii) Component 2: Local government infrastructure and services (US$60 million) This component will finance on a grant basis priority urban infrastructure in 13 selected urban areas in the Nairobi metropolitan area. The 13 selected urban areas are Nairobi, Ruiru, Kikuyu, Kangundo/Tala, Thika, Mavoko, Karuri, Ngong, Limuru, Kiambu, Kitengela, J uja, Ongata Rongai. The investments to be financed under this component are relatively small-scale local projects. The investments to be selected by the local authorities can include drainage systems, local streets, bicycle and foot paths, street and security lighting, public parks, public markets, solid waste management and street cleaning, and fire fighting equipment and facilities. (iii) Component 3: Metropolitan infrastructure and services (US$250 million) This component will assist in providing large-scale metropolitan infrastructure in the areas of solid waste, transport, and sewerage services. In contrast to those financed under component 2, these investments will be large-scale which is crucial for the development and integration of the metropolitan area as a whole. (iv) Component 4: Project management, and monitoring and evaluation (US$5 million) This component will finance the management activities associated with project implementation, including establishing and implementing a comprehensive monitoring and evaluation (M&E) system and training of the implementing agencies in environmental and social management. This component will also provide funds to undertake feasibility studies and prepare designs for implementation under a potential follow-on project in the urban sector in Kenya, and for other studies identified and agreed during implementation. (4) Kenya Infrastructure Finance/PPP project The objective of the first phase of this Adaptable Program Lending (APL) initiative is to improve the enabling environment to generate a pipeline of bankable PPP projects. The project comprises the following four components. (i) Component 1: Technical Support to PPP Institutions for PPP Legal, Regulatory and PPP Financing Environment. (ii) Component 2: Support for Preparation of Individual PPPs. (iii) Component 3: Improvements to Fiscal Risk Management Framework. (iv) Component 4: Support for Program Management. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 3 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4.1.2 Urban Transport In Kenya, the Roads and Transport Sector Donor Group created the Harmonisation Alignment and Coordination (HAC) initiative consists of 12 donors (AfDB, AFD, BADEA, China, DANIDA, EC, J ICA, KfW, SIDA, USAID, UNDP, World Bank). Under this framework, transport sector issues are discussed by DCG (Donor Coordination Group) regularly. Progress has been made recently towards a new perspective of sector and donor coordination with the Ministry of Roads (currently under MOTI) chairing a joint GOK/Donor meeting under its new policy and regulatory role. Review of related projects by other development partners in urban transport sector is described by donors. (1) World Bank (WB) The WB issued two projects regarding urban transport. 1) National Urban Transport Improvement Project (NUTRIP, J uly 9, 2012) In 2007, WB and Government of Kenya (GOK) proposed the concept of Nairobi Urban toll Road Project (NUTRP) This project was to offer a section of the Northern Corridor to the private sector for expansion and tolling, through concession. Unfortunately, this offer attracted limited interest from the private sector, and circumstances changed significantly, leading the GOK to cancel the project. In 2011, Consultancy Services for Feasibility Study and Technical Assistance for Mass Rapid Transit System for the Nairobi Metropolitan Region (MRTS) was issued by MOT (Currently MOTI) assisted by AfDB. Therefore one aspect of NUTRIP is to enhance the realization of NMRTS. The objectives of the project are: (a) improve the efficiency of road transport along the Northern Corridor; (b) improve the institutional capacity and arrangements in the urban transport sub-sector; and (c) promote the private sector participation in the operation, financing and management of transport systems. The components of the project are: A Support to Kenya National Highways Authority (KeNHA) to upgrade the urban road transport infrastructure, B. Support to Kenya Urban Roads Authority (KURA) and Kenya Railways Corporation (KRC) to develop selected mass transit corridors and C. Institutional strengthening and capacity building. Total project cost is estimated to be US$ 413.11million, and among the total cost, US$ 300.00 million is WB financing through International Development Association (IDA). Project component A: Support to KeNHA to upgrade the urban road transport infrastructure includes the following projects: (i) Expanding and upgrading the Northern Corridor road section through Nairobi from J KIA turnoff to Rironi road, as well as associated service roads and access roads; all through provision of goods, works and services. (ii) Constructing the Kisumu northern bypass road. (iii) Constructing and rehabilitating non-motorized transport facilities, including foot paths, cycle tracks, pedestrian bridges and underpasses. (iv) Strengthening the capacity of KeNHA Regarding the upgrading the Northern Corridor (A104), three studies were conducted by KeNHA. Table 4.1.1 shows the name, the location and the length of the studies. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 4 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.1.1 Studies Conducted on A104 by KeNHA No. Title of the Study Time of Publication Section and Length 1 Consultancy Services for Preliminary and Detailed Engineering Design for J KIA Turnoff - Likoni Road (A104) and Link Roads February 2013 J KIA Likoni Road J unction (8km) plus adjoining roads 2 Consultancy Services for Upgrading the A104 from Likoni Road to J ames Gichuru Road May 2012 Likoni Road J unction J ames Gichuru Road J unction (12km) 3 Preliminary Design for the Rehabilitation and Capacity Enhancement of A104 fromJ ames Gichuru Road J unction to Rironi (A104/ B3 J uncction) November 2012 J ames Gichuru Road J unction to Rironi (25km) Source: KeNHA Locations of the study sections are shown in Figure 4.1.1. Numbers shown in the figure correspond to the numbers of the study given in Table 4.1.1.
Source: KeNHA Figure 4.1.1 Location of Study Sections for A104 Figure 4.1.2 - 4.1.4 shows the typical cross section of three studies.
Source: Overview of the Capacity Improvement of J KIA Rironi Road, KeNHA Figure 4.1.2 Typical Cross Section JKIA Haile Selassie Section Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 5 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: Overview of the Capacity Improvement of J KIA Rironi Road, KeNHA Figure 4.1.3 Typical Cross Section from Just Before Haile Selassie Junction to Just after University Way Junction
Source: Overview of the Capacity Improvement of J KIA Rironi Road, KeNHA Figure 4.1.4 Typical Cross Section James Gichuru Junction Uthiru Section and Gitaru - Rironi Section Component B of Supporting KURA and KRC to develop selected mass transit corridors include Sub-component B1 for Kura and Sub-component B2 for KRC. Sub-component B1 includes the following projects: (i) Carrying out a range of feasibility studies, including detailed designs, and preparing bidding documents for selected Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) road corridors through provision of technical advisory services. (ii) Providing public transport and associated services through provision of technical assistance. In Annex 2: Detailed Project Description, the following concepts for BRT are shown: (i) The MRTS has identified nine BRT corridors which, if developed, will serve the most densely populated and low income parts of the larger Nairobi. The eastern part of Nairobi is one such area. (ii) The J ogoo road corridor with a length of about 21 km has the densest traffic and passenger demand in Nairobi, with a forecast travel demand of 424,680 persons in 2030; and it is connected to the J uja Road corridor, Outering and Thika corridors in Nairobi. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 6 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (iii) The other key corridors include Mombasa road, which would partly serve J omo Kenyatta International Airport (J KIA) and the southern part of Nairobi, the key growth pole for greater Nairobi (iv) The BRT corridors that will be considered under this project include J uja road and Mombasa-Uhuru Highway-Waiyaki Way road segment. NUTRIP will support the preparation of the first comprehensive BRT route and will involve carrying out feasibility and detailed (engineering) design and studies. Source: Project Appraisal Document on a Proposed Credit to the Republic of Kenya for a National Urban Transport Improvement Project, WB and Project Information Document (PID) Concept stage Nairobi metropolitan Services Improvement Project (NaMSIP, May 10, 2012) NaMSIP, already described in 4.1.1 (3) is deeply related to transportation in its component 3 Investing in Infrastructure and Service Delivery. Document named Nairobi Metropolitan Leadership issued at meeting held by WB and NCC on 2 J uly 2013 focuses on synergies of commuter train and land development around the stations. Since the document is in its conceptual stage, detailed method of improvement and operation of the commuter train is not studied, but the number and the location of stations are described. The proposed development/improvement of twelve stations along NRS-Ruiru section and nine stations along NRS-Kikuyu section is shown in Figures 4.1.5 and 4.1.6.
Source: NaMSIP, Nairobi Metropolitan Leadership (Presentation document for 2 J uly 2013 meeting) Figure 4.1.5 Proposed Stations in NRS-Ruiru Section Figure 4.1.6 Proposed Stations in NRS-Kikuyu Section (2) African Development Bank (AfDB) 1) Nairobi - Thika Highway Improvement Project The Nairobi-Thika highway is a dual-carriageway road of about 45 km. The road is part of the international trunk road classified as A2 which originates in downtown Nairobi and extends to Moyale at the Ethiopian border. To accommodate the existing and future traffic, the highway needed substantial improvements to increase its capacity which would entail the construction of additional lanes and the removal of up-grade intersections at several locations to be replaced by interchanges. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 7 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The project was implemented by the Roads Department of Ministry of Roads and Public Works (MORPW) (currently under MOTI). The project started from J anuary 2008, and opened November 2012.
Source: Appraisal Report, Nairobi-Thika Highway Improvement Project, September 2007, ADF Figure 4.1.7 Nairobi-Thika Highway Improvement Project Location Map The construction between downtown Nairobi and Kenyatta University was financed by AfDB and the Kenyan Government for the amount of US $260 million. AfDB financed the project with a package of US $180 million through its concessional window, the African Development Fund, including a loan of US $175 million (civil works and related consultancy services) and a grant worth US $5 million (feasibility study and detailed design of a mass rapid-transit system for the Nairobi Metropolitan area). The Kenyan Government contributed US $80 million towards the road project. The project still has one major drawback in that, the connectors to the Nairobis City Centre and Uhuru Highway (A104) are still congested during the peak hours. The section from Kenyatta University to Thika Road that is part of Nairobi-Thika Highway Improvement Project is being implemented at a cost of KSh10.6 billion. It involves the construction of extra lanes from Kenyatta University to Thika town with an intention to improve the traffic flow along the route. The Exim Bank of China financed US $100 million for the upgrading between Kenyatta University and Thika. 2) Mass Rapid Transit System for the Nairobi Metropolitan Region (MRTS), J une 2011 (Consultancy Services for Feasibility Study and Technical Assistance for Mass Transit System for the Nairobi Metropolitan Region) i) Study Area and Study Components The study area of MRTS corresponds to the area of Nairobi Metro 2030, and the target year is also 2030. The major study components are described as follows: (i) Preparation of an integrated multi-model transport plan for NMR which complements the Nairobi Urban Transport Master plan proposals covering a period of 20 years (2010-2030). Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 8 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (ii) Formulation of a comprehensive Public Transport Policy for Nairobi Metropolitan Region (NMR). (iii) Recommendation of an appropriate Legal, Institutional and Regulatory framework for facilitating the implementation of the MRTS in NMR. (iv) National Road Transport and Safety Authority which has been established to deal with road transport issues and concerns (v) Nairobi Metropolitan Transport Authority (to be established) which will be responsible for licensing, regulating public transport and traffic management in the Nairobi Metropolitan Region. ii) MRTS Corridors Evaluating existing corridors in Nairobi, the study considers appropriate mass rapid transport system along the nine corridors leading to the CBD of Nairobi. These corridors are as follows: (i) Nairobi Rail Station (NRS)- Ruiru - Thika (ii) NRS - J uja Road Kangundo (iii) NRS J ogoo Road Komorock (iv) NRS J K Airport Athi River (v) NRS Langata Road Karen (vi) NRS Upperhill Ngong (vii) NRS Kabete Kikuyu (viii) NRS Gigiri Limuru (ix) Outer Ring Road iii) Selection of Modes The selection of modes between Metro, Bus Rapid Transit System (BRT), Light Rail Transit System (LRT) or Monorail depends mainly on forecasted passenger demand presented peak hour peak direction traffic (PHPDT). BRT or Monorail has been considered where the PHPDT is in excess of 5,000 passengers. LRT has been considered where the PHPDT is in excess of 12,000 passengers, and Metro Rail in corridors where PHPDT is in excess of 30,000 passengers. The proposed network on nine corridors in Nairobi is shown in Figure 4.1.8. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 9 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: Mass Rapid Transit Systemfor the Nairobi Metropolitan Region (MRTS), J une 2011, Chapter 8. Figure 4.1.8 MRTS Corridors iv) Economic Viability The annual cost and benefit streams for each MRTS corridor were analysed to derive the net cash flows. The EIRR and NPV at the 12% discount rate were determined using the discounted cash-flow technique. The results of the economic evaluation are summarized in Table 4.1.2. Table 4.1.2 Results of Economic Evaluation Corridor EIRR(%) NPV@12% (mill Ksh) MRTS 1: Waiyaki Way 11.09% (-)2,255 MRTS 2: Thika Road 25.52% 97,057 MRTS 3: J uja Road 16.53% 17,598 MRTS 4: J ogoo Road 19.80% 18.654 MRTS 5: Outer Ring Road 20.81% 22.198 MRTS 6: Ngong Road 18.99% 18,431 MRTS 7: Limuru Road 22.31% 8,537 MRTS 8: Langata Road 28.98% 6,775 MRTS 9: Mombasa Road/Athi River 14.23% 2,598 All Corridors Together 19.88% 189,592 Source: Mass Rapid Transit Systemfor the Nairobi Metropolitan Region (MRTS), J une 2011, Chapter 10 The results indicate that all the corridors, except Waiyaki Way, are economically viable, as the EIRRs are greater than 12 percent. BRT corridors have higher EIRRs because of their relatively lower costs compared with LRT costs. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 10 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (3) Government of J apan / J ICA The Study on Master Plan for Urban Transport in The Metropolitan Area in the Republic of Kenya, 2006, J ICA The Study was commenced in J uly 2004 and completed in J anuary 2006. The objectives of the Study were: 1) To formulate a master plan for urban transport in the Nairobi Metropolitan Area for the target year 2025, 2) To conduct a Pre-feasibility study on the priority projects under the master plan, and 3) To carry out relevant and appropriate technology transfer to Kenyan counterpart personnel in the course of the Study. Components of recommended master plan are as follows: (i) Radial and Circumferential (R/C) Road Network (2) including Planned Projects (ii) Bus Incentive and priority measures (iii) Upgrading of existing rail as commuter rail (iv) Improvement of Uhuru Highway, Stage I as Expressway. The road network of the master plan in 2025 is shown in Figure 4.1.9.
Source: The Study on Master Plan for Urban Transport in The Metropolitan Area in the Republic of Kenya, Final Report Executive Summary, March 2006 Figure 4.1.9 Road Network in Urban Area (Nairobi City) in 2005 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 11 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.1.3 The Staging Plan Proposed in the Master Plan and its Current Progress.
Short term (2006-2010) Medium-term (2011-2015) Long Term (2016-2025) Progress 1. Bypass and Link Roads Bypass roads
Link roads Link roads extension Eastern bypass completed Northern bypass completed Western bypass under construction Western Link Road under construction 2. Missing Link Missing links (arterial) Missing links (collector) Missing links (local) Missing link 6, 7 under construction Refer to (4) EU assistance 3. Radial Roads Radial roads within C-3 Radial roads outside C-3 (north & east) Radial roads outside C-3 (south & west) New Radial Roads Ngong road under design Langata road under construction 4. Circumferential Arterial Roads Circumferential arterial roads C-3 Circumferential roads C-1 & C-2
Source: The Study on Master Plan for Urban Transport in The Metropolitan Area in the Republic of Kenya, Final Report, and J ICA Study Team Nairobi Western Roads Nairobi western roads are referred to as the missing link which connects Kileleshwa Police Station to Westlands roundabout, Ole Dume Road and J ames Gichuru Road to Ngong Road. The construction of roads was derived from the master plan as the priority roads by the grant aid project from the Government of J apan. Connecting of the 3 missing link roads is to create a network in the area, which is currently separated by rivers, and to alleviate the congestion and contribute to smooth and safe transport of people and goods between Westlands and Kilimani areas. Total road length is 8.36km, and the grant amount is J PY 2.54 billion. The construction was commenced J une, 2011 and completed in J une, 2013. Nairobi Dagoreti Corner Road C60/C61 The Preparatory Survey on the Project for Dualling of Nairobi-Dagoretti Corner Road C60/C61 in the Republic of Kenya was conducted from J une 2010 to March 2011. Proposed road improvement section was from Adams Arcade intersection to Ngong Road/ Kenyatta Avenue intersection, and improvement measure is to widen from current 2 lanes into 4 lanes. Total length is 4.7km. After the completion of the preparatory survey, the MRTS project by MOT selected Ngong road as one of the nine corridors for MRTS. Investigation of the cross section for the proposed road was carried out to make a space for MRTS. And in conclusion, mode of the MRTS was decided as LRT, and detailed design will be conducted under this precondition. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 12 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (4) EU EU assists the road development in Nairobi by a project named KENYA/ACP/Regional Economic Integration by means of Transport Infrastructure - Urban Roads. The project, which is under Kenya Urban Roads Authority (KURA), comprises technical assistance for MOTI, the relevant road authorities and MOT, and construction of Nairobi missing link roads and Non-Motorised transport facilities. The construction project is 10.5 km of new road links plus pedestrian footpaths and cycle tracks in Westlands/Parklands area and the industrial area. Design for the missing link No. 6 is ready. Tendering for construction of the roads is on-going. The roads are: (i) Accra Road to Ngara Road: 0.7km (Missing Link No. 1) (ii) (Muratina St) General Warungi St to J uja Road: 3.0km (Missing link No. 5) (iii) Likoni Road Extension): Enterprise Road to Mombasa: 1.8km (Missing link No. 10) (iv) Ring Road Parkland (Westlands Roundabout-Limuru Road): 4.0km (Missing link No. 15a) (v) Ring Road Parkland Extension: (Limuru Road to Thika road): 1.6km (Missing link No. 15b) (vi) Quarry Road Extension: (Ladhies Road to Quarry Road): 2.5km (Missing link No. 16) Source: Showcasing the status of roads in Nairobi, August, 2012, MOR (Ministry of Roads) (5) China China assisted the Government of Kenya by four large road projects, of which three projects were completed. Extent of assistance is shown in Table 4.1.4. Table 4.1.4 Chinese Assistance of Road Development in Nairobi Length Cost Financer Progress Thika Road (Kenyatta University-Thika) Ksh 10.6billion Eximbank of China Completed in November 2012 Northern Bypass 31km Ksh 8.5billion Kenya Govt 15% China Govt 85% Completed Eastern Bypass 39km Ksh 4.2billion Kenya Govt 15% China Govt 85% completed Southern Bypass 28.8km Ksh 16.9billion Kenya Govt 15% Eximbank of China 85% Construction period 3years fromMarch, 2012 Source: Megaprojects Kenya website 4.1.3 Railway (1) The Nairobi Commuter Railway Project Kenya Railways Corporation has a national railway network, including a network within and around Nairobi city which is capable of providing reliable commuter services affordably. In order to utilize the existing railway infrastructure, the Government of Kenya authorized Kenya Railways Corporation to enter into a J oint Development Agreement (J DA) with InfraCo Limited (INFRACO) to develop the new commuter rail system jointly on the basis of a Public-Private Partnership. Kenya Railways Corporation and InfraCo signed the J DA on 15 th April, 2009. InfraCo is a company owned by the Private Infrastructure Development Group Trust (PIDG), which is supported by several development partners including: (i) Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (SIDA); Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 13 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (ii) UK Department of International Development (DfID); (iii) Swiss State Secretariat for Foreign Affairs (SECE); (iv) Netherlands Ministry of Foreign Affairs (DGIS); (v) Austrian Development Corporation (ADA); and (vi) The World Bank The project development is to be undertaken in two phases as stipulated in J oint Development Agreement (J DA). The purpose of Phase 1 is to create the Project Development Plan (PDP), which includes a proposed funding and commercial structure: (i) Detailed market forecast; (ii) Engineering designs; (iii) Development of bankable project documents; (iv) Competitive procurement of contractors, suppliers and operator(s); and (v) Identification and procurement of debt and equity financing through to financial close and start of constructions. The system has been designed with a capacity to move 43 million passengers per year, which means 172,000 passengers per day compared with the current capacity of 25,000 passengers per day. KRC is continuing the station improvement project between Syokimau and Nairobi stations, providing automated ticket gates and high platforms for commuter train operation. The following photos showing Makadara station improvement.
Figure 4.1.10 Automated Ticket Gate (left) High Platform Construction (right) INFRACO is now planning to provide a DMU train set, consisting of 5 cars, for commuter train operation on this line. Automatic fare collection system will be provided at Nairobi, Syokimau and Makadara stations. Kenyan Government has agreed with Chinese Government for the finance and construction of a standard gauge track between Mombasa and Nairobi stations. When the standard gauge track is constructed, all the freight trains will be shifted to the new track, and the existing meter-gauge track will be dedicated for passenger services. The following photo indicates the planned alignment of the standard gauge track from Nairobi to Dagoretti. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 14 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: KRC Figure 4.1.11 Proposed Standard Gauge Railway Corridor from Nairobi to Dagoretti (Blue line) 4.1.4 Airport Kenya Airports Authority (KAA) conducted several airport development projects. Some of the projects were implemented through foreign assistance. The recent projects of J KIA and Wilson airport are as shown below. (1) J KIA KAA announced expansion plan for terminal area (Terminal 4) including aircraft apron on October 2005. The expansion project aimed at improvement of J KIA aviation services such as terminal area and related apron and taxiways. The passenger capacity increased from 25,000 m 2 to 55,000 m 2 and the apron space expanded from 200,000 m 2 to 300,000 m 2 . The project cost was approximately US$ 204 million funded by World Bank (WB) and national budget. The first phase of the project was completed in mid 2008, and consisted of civil work of terminal building including aircraft apron and taxiway and fuel hydrant system. The second phase was construction of terminal 4 building with car parks. On the other hand, KAA conducted National Airports System Plan (NASP) in 2010. This plan consisted of 10 Airports Master plans for J KIA, Wilson, Mombasa International, Eldoret International, Kisumu, Ukunda, Malindi, Lamu, Lokichogio, and Wajir Airports. A huge fire damaged main airport building of J KIA on August 7, 2013. Investigations have concluded it was due to an electrical fault that started from the power distribution box where some wires in the box overheated and sparked. This resulted in complete destruction of the terminal building and especially the entire arrivals section of the main airport building forcing shutdown of the runway and cancellation of flights. Within days, a huge tent was put up to act as makeshift terminal which was later (September, 2013) replaced by a temporary terminal in what used to be the main parking garage. KAA is in the process of bringing down the damaged international arrival terminal to pave way for its reconstruction, alongside the redesign for terminals 1, 2 and 3. Plans are also underway to complete the new terminal, terminal 4 to house international arrivals and departures until J KIA expansion plans are fully implemented. Construction of the Greenfield terminal, with a handling capacity of 20 million passengers per year has also kicked off. 1) J KIA Expansion Plan As part of Vision 2030 flagship project, KAA intends to enhance its passenger handling capacity and improve on the efficiency of hub operations at J KIA through construction of new Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 15 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya passenger terminal complex. The floor area is around 178,000 m 2 on four levels. The associated facilities of the passenger terminal building are shown below: (i) 50 international check in positions (ii) 32 contact and 8 remote gates (iii) Associated apron with 45 aircraft stands and liking taxiways 2) National airports system plan (NASP) In the last ten years both passenger and goods traffic through Kenyas main airport has increased substantially. In order to handle growth in its international and domestic air traffic and maintain its status as an important hub in the region, Kenya faces several challenges. The airport development plans of NASP consists airside facilities, landside facilities and public utilities. The facilities development has three phases such as Phase I for target year 2015, Phase II for target year 2020 and Phase III for target year 2030. The detailed facilities requirements are shown below. i) Phase I Development Airside facilities The taxiway is extended to the end of Runway Displacement of 572 m of Runway 24 threshold Three new runway exits A holding bay near Runway 06 end Isolated parking stand Remote parking positions Landside facilities A cell phone parking lot A new lane arrival curb Public utilities New electrical equipment to supply the new domestic passenger terminal area. Expand the telephone system. Complementary equipment in the existing substations ii) Phase II Development Airside facilities A parallel runway and a full length taxiway Taxiway connectors to the new runway system Two holding bays New ARFF facilities ILS and Navaids for the new runway Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 16 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Landside facilities New arrival and departure building BHS system New cargo terminal building iii) Phase III Development Airside facilities Expansion of the general aviation apron Expansion of cargo apron Two rapid exit taxiways to the new runway Parallel taxiway to taxiway G Landside facilities Expansion of the primary access roads Additional lanes in the arrival curb Public utilities New electrical equipment to supply the new domestic passenger terminal area. Expand the telephone system. Complementary equipment in the existing substations (2) Wilson Airport Wilson airport is the busiest airport in Kenya and the third busiest in Africa. The daily aircraft frequency recorded 160 flights in 2012. KAA is currently undertaking Airport development based on the NASP of 2010. The development phases are scheduled in the short, medium and long term and by target year 2015, 2020 and 2030 respectively. The airport development plans are shown below. 1) Phase I Development (2015) Airside facilities Full parallel taxiway to Runway 07-25 and a partial 275 m long taxiway to Runway 14. Additional aircraft position of Apron 1, 2 and Apron 3. New engine run-up apron A new control tower and ARFF facility Terminal Temporary terminal building Landside facilities Parking lot expansion 165 spaces Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 17 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Utilities Upgrading existing generator including mechanical equipment, electrical equipment and cable network IP Telephony 2) Phase II Development (2020) Airside facilities New apron for new terminal building Parallel taxiways to both runways New calibration taxiway and pad Terminal New terminal building Landside facilities New access road Utilities New standby generator including mechanical equipment, electrical equipment and cable network 3) Phase III Development (2030) The phase III development is considered for passenger terminal building, if the forecasts are exceeded. In regard to the re-location of Wilson airport, each organization has different views. NASP includes Wilson Airport development plan, and Spatial Planning Concept for Nairobi Metropolitan Region proposed redevelopment of Wilson airport area as government office complex. Position of Wilson airport will be further discussed and confirmed with stakeholders through working group discussion. (3) Airport development in Nairobi city Both J KIA and Wilson Airport are operated and managed by KAA who are also in the process of implementing the Airports future development plan. The future plan of J KIA was announced by Vision 2030 as Airport City and Wilson Airport has already undergone improvement works under NASP. This could illustrate KAA reluctance to approve relocation of both Airports at the moment. However, Airports sometimes may have negative impacts when social and environmental factors are considered. Recently, it seems that there is no Airport operation related complaint or impact such as Aircraft noise and pollution, even though a number of housing developments are being implemented around the Airports .Wilson Airport is particularly affected in this regard. J KIA will not be able to relocate from present location where it has been incorporated in Nairobi development plan. On the other hand, Wilson Airport Area is the most strategic in Nairobi city. Therefore, it must be required to relocate to another area from the standpoint of city planning and citizens. However, Airports in many cities in the world are located in the city centre for general aviation for business executives. And some Airport relocation plans have been postponed in the world. So it is not easy to promote the relocation of Wilson Airport. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 18 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4.1.5 Water Supply (1) World Bank Water and Sanitation Services Improvement Project is on-going for supporting Athi Water Service Board (AWSB), Coast Water Service Board (CWSB), Lake Victoria North Water Service Board and thier Water Service Providers (WSP) for improvement of water supply and sanitation system. Area covered by AWSB and its WSP includes Nairobi City. In the project, the Feasibility Study and Master Plan for Developing New Water Sources for Nairobi and Satellite Towns (FSMPNWS) was carried out co-financed by AFD. Its contents were projection of population and water demand until 2035, preparation of six scenarios of water resource development and preliminary design of water resource development and water supply system. (2) Agence Francaise Developpement (AFD) In addition to FSMPNWS, AFD financed two projects for rehabilitation of water supply facilities including a barrage for Nairobi City and development of water supply system in the informal settlement of Nairobi City. The projects financed by AFD are presented below; (i) Nairobi Water & Sewerage Emergency Physical Investment Project, and (ii) Complementary Support to the Nairobi and Kisumu Water and Sanitation Project (3) J apan International Cooperation Agency (J ICA) The Development of The National Water Master Plan 2030 in Republic of Kenya (NWMP) was completed. In the project, a comprehensive plan for water resources is discussed for water supply, sanitation, irrigation, hydropower generation, food and drought management and environmental management. The project carried out the projection of population and water demand, proposal of water allocation plan, development plan of water resources and strategy of water supply system for the Athi Catchment Area including Nairobi City. (4) African Development Bank (AfDB) To support the institutional activity of AWSB and the development activity in Kibera of Nairobi City, AfDB financed the Water Service Boards Support Project. The project is on-going as of April, 2013. (5) European Commission (EC) EC supported the projects of water supply for anti-poverty program. On-going projects financed by EC are presented below: (i) Nairobi Informal Settlement Water and Sanitation Improvement Programme, and (ii) Micro Finance for Community managed Water Projects. (6) Other Partners A few of bilateral development partners are active in Nairobi City for the development of water supply system in informal settlement and reform of water sector. Following projects financed by bilateral partners were listed below; (i) Water Sector Reform Program financed by German Technical Cooperation, (ii) Water Supply and Sanitation for the Urban Poor financed by German Technical Cooperation, Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 19 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (iii) Water Supply and Sanitation for the Urban Poor Phase II financed by German Technical Cooperation, (iv) Support to Water Service Trust Fund financed by Finland, and (v) Kenya Water and Sanitation Program financed by Swedish International Cooperation Agency,
Besides the above, there are two projects financed by UN-HABITAT. (vi) Kibera Water and Sanitation Project financed by UN- HABITAT, and (vii) Kibera Support Programme financed by UN-HABITAT. 4.1.6 Storm Water Drainage and Sewerage Major on-going projects relevant to the infrastructure development for storm water drainage and sewerage in Nairobi City are listed in Table 4.1.5. Each of the projects covers a wider scale in terms of the objectives and target areas. Brief descriptions of each project and on-going activities relevant to the infrastructure development for storm water drainage and sewerage in Nairobi City are identified from the published documents and summarized hereunder in this sub-section. Table 4.1.5 On-going Projects Relevant to Infrastructure Development for Storm Water Drainage and Sewerage in Nairobi City Project Implementing Agency Donor Water and Sanitation Service Improvement Project (WaSSIP) AWSB, CWSB, LVNWSB World Bank Kenya Municipal Program(KMP) MOLG World Bank Kenya Informal Settlement Improvement Project (KISIP) MOH World Bank Nairobi Metropolitan Services Improvement Project (NaMSIP) MONMD World Bank Nairobi Rivers Basin Rehabilitation and Restoration Program: Sewerage Improvement Project (NaRSIP) AWSB AfDB Source: Project Appraisal Documents (1) Water and Sanitation Service Improvement Project (WaSSIP) The Water and Sanitation Service Improvement Project (WaSSIP) is financed by the World Bank and aims at increasing access to reliable, affordable and sustainable water supply and sanitation services; and improvinge the water and wastewater services in the areas served by Athi Water Services Board AWSB, CWSB and Lake Victoria North Water Services Board (LVNWSB). The period of the project implementation was scheduled originally for 2008-2012 and is further extended with an additional finance by the World Bank. The project comprises the following three components. (i) Component 1: Support to the Athi Water Services Board (ii) Component 2: Support to the Coast Water Services Board (iii) Component 3: Support to the Lake Victoria North Water Services Board Of three components, the Component 1 comprises the sub-components of; (i) Rehabilitation and Extension of Water Supply Facilities; Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 20 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (ii) Rehabilitation and Extension of Wastewater and Sanitation Facilities; and (iii) Institutional Strengthening Program. Of a series of the infrastructure developments for wastewater and sanitation facilities under the sub-component (ii) above, major works implemented in Nairobi City are listed as shown in Table 4.1.6 below Table 4.1.6 Major Infrastructure Developments for Wastewater and Sanitation Facilities in Nairobi City under the WaSSIP Works Procurement Information Description Construction of Gatharaini Trunk Sewers including Rui-Rwaka, Gatharaini North and Gatharaini South Contract No. AWSB/WaSSIP/Comp.1/W-6/2009
Contract Signed on 24 March 2010
Construction Period: 24 months Construction of approximately 49 kmof pre-cast concrete sewers of various sizes ranging from300 to 1200 mmdiameter Construction of box culvert (1400 x 1400), manholes and other auxiliary works Construction Period: 24 months Construction of Lavington - Riruta Trunk Sewers Extensions Contract No. AWSB/WaSSIP/Comp.1/W-7/2009
Contract Signed on 9 J une 2009
Construction Period: 12 months Extension of approximately 8 kmtrunk sewers of various sizes ranging from750 mmDN to 225 mm DN spigot and socket concrete pipes covering Lavington, Riruta North and Riruta South areas, in Nairobi City Rehabilitation of Dandora Sewerage Treatment Works and Reconstruction of Ngong River Trunk Sewers Contract No. AWSB/WaSSIP/Comp.1/W-9/2009
Contract Signed on 20 May 2009
Construction Period: 20 months Desludging of existing facultative and maturation pond series 7 & 8 including removal of approximately 550,000 m 3 of sludge (at Dandora STP) Construction of six anaerobic ponds prior to series 1 & 2 and series 7 & 8, each dimensions 120 mby 90 mby 4.5 mdeep including earthworks of approximately 200,000 m 3 (at Dandora STP) Construction of associated reinforced concrete works of approximately 3,000 m 3 and ancillary 3No penstocks 1400 mmby 100 mmand 1 No. 1000 mmby 1000 mm(at Dandora STP) Rehabilitation and reconstruction of 24,000 mof Ngong trunk sewers including cleaning, unblocking, repairing and replacement of short sections and manhole covers and associated works. Source: Procurement Plan for the WaSSIP (World Bank, J anuary 2010) and the updates shown in the website of the World Bank as of April 2013 In addition, the procurement plan for the WaSSIP during J uly 2012 to December 2013 indicates a recruitment of consultants to carry out the consulting services for Updating the Nairobi City Sewerage Master Plan and Preparation of Master Plan for Selected Satellite Towns. As of the procurement plan, the submission and opening of proposals had been planned on 30 October 2012. (2) Kenya Municipal Program (KMP) The Ministry of Local Government (MOLG) is implementing the phase 1 of the Kenya Municipal Program (KMP) with the financial assistance by the World Bank. The development objective of phase 1 is to strengthen local governance and improve service delivery in 15 selected municipalities through a combination of institutional reforms, capacity building, and investment in infrastructure. The phase 1 of the KMP is scheduled to be implemented from 2010 to 2015. The selected municipalities (major cities and towns) are (1) Nairobi, (2) Mombasa, (3) Kisumu, (4) Nakuru, (5) Eldoret, (6) Malindi, (7) Naivasha, (8) Kitui, (9) Machakos, (10) Thika, (11) Nyeri, (12) Garissa, (13) Kericho, (14) Kakamega, and (15) Embu. The project comprises the following three components. (i) Component 1: Institutional Strengthening Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 21 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (ii) Component 2: Participatory Strategic Urban Development Planning (iii) Component 3: Investment in Infrastructure and Service Delivery (iv) Component 4: Project Management, Monitoring and Evaluation Of the above, the Component 3 consists of the infrastructure developments considered as eligible for financing under the KMP; motorized and non-motorized transport facilities (including bus parks, access roads, sidewalks, and paved paths), street lighting, markets, solid waste management, storm water drainage, disaster management and prevention facilities and equipment, public parks and green spaces. The investments by the Component 3 are phased into two: (a) investments for implementing the infrastructure developments during 2010-2013; and (b) investments for implementing the infrastructure developments during 2013-2015. The selection of infrastructure developments either (a) or year 35 investments(b) is performed on the basis of the criteria established in the process of the project design of the KMP as described in the project appraisal report (World Bank, April 2010). The investments by the Component 3 cover the infrastructure developments for storm water drainage in the municipalities (major towns and cities) concerned. The procurement plan for the phase 1 of the KMP (World Bank, J uly 2012) shows the scheduled procurements relating to the infrastructure developments for storm water drainage in Mombasa, Malindi, Nyeri, Naibasha and Kitui. Besides, the updated list of the procurement notices (the website of the World Bank, as of April 2013) shows the request for expression of interest (EOI): the Preparation of a Master Plan, Detailed Designs, Tender Documents and Operations and Maintenance Manuals for Storm Water Drainage Works in the City of Nairobi (Contract No. MOLG/KMP/COMP3/SWD-02C), which was announced by the MOLG on 11 March 2013. The period of the assignment for the consultancy service is expected to be nine (9) months. The request for EOI was closed on 26 March 2013. (3) Kenya Informal Settlement Improvement Project (KISIP) The Ministry of Housing (MOH) (currently under MOLHUD) is implementing the Kenya Informal Settlement Improvement Project (KISIP) with the financial assistance by the World Bank. The project development objective is to improve living conditions in informal settlements in 15 selected municipalities as below in Kenya. The KISIP is scheduled to be implemented from 2011 to 2016. The selected municipalities (major towns and cities) are (1) Nairobi, (2) Mombasa, (3) Kisumu, (4) Nakuru, (5) Eldoret, (6) Malindi, (7) Naivasha, (8) Kitui, (9) Machakos, (10) Thika, (11) Nyeri, (12) Garissa, (13) Kericho, (14) Kakamega, and (15) Embu. The KISIP comprises the following four components. (i) Component 1: Strengthening Institutions and Program Management (ii) Component 2: Enhancing Tenure Security (iii) Component 3: Investing in Infrastructure and Service Delivery (iv) Component 4: Planning for Urban Growth Of the above, Component 3 supports investment in settlement infrastructure, and, where necessary, extension of trunk infrastructure to settlements. The infrastructure developments considered as eligible for financing under the KISIP are roads, bicycle paths, pedestrian walkways, street and security lighting, vending platforms, solid waste management, storm water drainage, water and sanitation systems, electrification, public parks and green spaces. The selection of infrastructure developments is performed on the basis of the criteria established in the process of the project design of the KISIP as described in the project appraisal report (World Bank, February 2011). Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 22 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Form the procurement plan of the KISIP during December 2012 to December 2013 and the updated list of the procurement notices (the website of the World Bank, as of April 2013), following procurements relating to the infrastructure developments for storm water drainage and sewerage in Nairobi City are identified. 1) Extension of Services to Informal Settlements in Nairobi, Lot 4: Kayole Soweto Sewerage Contract No. AWSB/KISIP/W-1/2013 Bid Submission & Opening (NCB): 14 May 2013 Construction Period: 16 months Major Components: (i) Excavation, laying, jointing and backfilling of trenches for 4 km of precast concrete sewer pipes of diameter 300 mm to 375 mm (ii) Excavation laying, jointing and back filing of trenches for 26 km of PVC Class 41 sewer pipes of diameter 160 mm to 225m m and (iii) Construction of 164 manholes and 3,760 inspection chambers. 2) Socio-economic surveys, settlement upgrading plans and bidding documents for infrastructure improvement in informal settlements in Nairobi, Naivasha and Machakos Contract No. MH/KISIP/CS/004/2011-2012 Singing Date: 22 August 2012 Period of Consulting Service: August 2012 - October 2013 Key objective: to prepare settlement upgrading plans for selected informal settlements. Major tasks: (i) Carrying out a socio economic survey; (ii) Preparing a preliminary settlement upgrading plan, including preliminary designs and feasibility studies for proposed infrastructure investments; and (iii) Preparing a final upgrading plan as well as detailed engineering designs and bid documents for the agreed infrastructure investments. (4) Nairobi Metropolitan Services Improvement Project (NaMSIP) The Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development (MONMD) is the responsible agency to implement the Nairobi Metropolitan Services Improvement Project (NaMSIP) with the financial assistance by the World Bank. The project development objective is to strengthen urban services and infrastructure in the Nairobi metropolitan region. The project comprises the following four components. (i) Component 1: Institutional reform and planning (ii) Component 2: Local government infrastructure and services (iii) Component 3: Metropolitan infrastructure and services (iv) Component 4: Project management, and monitoring and evaluation. Under Component 3, the project will invest the development of local infrastructure (roads, markets, street lighting, bicycle and pedestrian pathways, drainage, etc.) as well as solid waste management and sewerage collection/disposal. The procurement plan for the NaMSIP during December 2012 to December 2013 (World Bank, December 2012) describes a series of procurements for the implementation of the NaMSIP. Of these, the following procurements are found to be directly relevant to the infrastructure development for Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 23 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya storm water drainage and sewerage in and around Nairobi City. 1) Construction of Nairobi storm water drainage works Procurement Method: International Competitive Bidding (ICB) Bid Submission & Opening: 1 August 2013 (Planned) 2) Preparation of feasibility studies, final designs and bidding documents for storm water drainage in Nairobi City (Dagoretti, Langata, CBD and Embakasi), Thika (CBD and west of CBD), Mavoko and Ongata Rongai township Contract No. Procurement Method: QCBS (Quality- and Cost-Based Selection) RFP submission & Opening: 23 November 2012 (Actual) (5) Nairobi Rivers Basin Rehabilitation and Restoration Program: Sewerage Improvement Project (NaRSIP) The Nairobi Rivers Basin Rehabilitation and Restoration Program provides the comprehensive framework for the water environment management in Nairobi City. The comprehensive framework was elaborated by the former Nairobi River Basin Program (NRBP, 1999-2008). The Sewerage Improvement Project is part of the Nairobi Rivers Basin Rehabilitation and Restoration Program. The project has been elaborated in the Nairobi Sewerage Master Plan study (1998), and further detailed in the feasibility study completed in J une 2010. The Athi Water Services Board (AWSB) is the responsible agency to implement the project with the financial assistance by the African Development Bank (AfDB). The project has three main components. (i) Wastewater Infrastructure (ii) Sanitation, Hygiene and Social Environmental Support (iii) Institutional Development Support Of the above, (i) Wastewater Infrastructure consists of the following works as described in the project appraisal report (AfDB, J uly 2010). (i) Rehabilitation of the Kariobangi conventional sewerage treatment plant currently operating at about 30% of its design capacity to the full capacity of 32,000 m 3 /day (ii) Construction of two additional series of waste stabilization ponds at Dandora to increase the capacity by 40,000 m 3 /day from 120,000 to 160,000 m 3 /day, (iii) Rehabilitation and laying of new trunk lines at an overall length of 54 km in addition to 40 km of reticulation lines, and (iv) Duplication of inlet works at the Dandora for the increased wastewater flow. (v) Construction of 100 ablution blocks in various informal settlements where the trunk sewer lines are proposed to go through. The procurement notices issued by AWSB in relation to the above are listed in the website of the AfDB as shown in Table 4.1.7 below. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 24 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.1.7 Major On-going Infrastructure Developments in Nairobi City under the Sewerage Improvement Project Contract Description Procurement Information Works Lot 1: Construction of Kiu River and Dandora Estate Trunk Sewers and Expansion of Dandora Waste Water Treatment Plant.
Contract No. AWSB/NaRSIP/W/01/2012 Bid Submission & Opening 24 May 2012 Works Lot 2: Construction of Mathare, Nairobi, Ngong Rivers Trunk sewers and Reticulation Network Contract No. AWSB/NaRSIP/W/01/2012 Bid Submission & Opening 11 J une 2012 Works Construction of Dandora, Kangundo Road, Kibera, Upper Hill and, Kirichwa Dogo Trunk Sewers
Contract No. AWSB/NaRSIP/W03/2013 Bid Submission & Opening 2nd August, 2013 Consultancy Services Design and supervision of works. Expressions of Interest (EOI) Submission: 3 J anuary, 2011 Consultancy Services Community mobilization and sensitization, design and supervision and works coordination for implementation of the Ablution blocks Expressions of Interest (EOI) Submission: 25 May 2012 Source: Relevant documents listed in the website of the AfDB as of September 2013 4.1.7 Power Supply Power sector in Kenya has many kinds of projects such as distribution, transmission and generation projects and rural electrification projects. Among the projects, the section reviews projects with a focus on Nairobi city. Table 4.1.8 is ongoing projects related to the project. Table 4.1.8 Power Sector Projects No. Project Loan Amount ( million) Status Implementing Agency Donor 1 Electricity Expansion Project USD 330.00 Ongoing (2010-2015) MOE, Kenya Power, REA KenGen, WB, IDA 2 Energy Sector Recovery Project Additional Financing USD 80.00 Ongoing (2009-2013) MOE, Kenya Power, REA KenGen, WB, IDA 3 Nairobi Ring EUR 78.50 Ongoing (2012-) MOE, KETRACO, Kenya Power AFD 4 Ethiopia-Kenya Electricity Highway Project UA 760.00 Ongoing (2012-2017) EEPCO, KETRACO WB, AfDB, AFD MOE : Ministry of Energy KPLC : Kenya Power and Lighting Company Limited, WB : World Bank REA : Rural Electrification Authority KenGen : Kenya Electricity Generating Company Limited AFD : French Development Agency AfDB : African Development Fund IDA : International Development Association EEPCO : Ethiopia Electric Power Corporation Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) (1) Electricity Expansion Project The objectives of the World Bank assisted Electricity Expansion Project are to increase electricity access in urban, peri-urban and rural areas and to improve the efficiency, reliability and quality of services to consumers. The project has five components, of which the component of distribution upgrading and infilling project is related to this survey. This component includes upgrading of distribution substations and reinforcement and extension of networks in an area including Nairobi region. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 25 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (2) Energy Sector Recovery Project Additional Financing The World Bank assisted Energy Sector Recovery Project Additional Financing enables to the original project to meet unanticipated cost overruns and financing shortfalls. The original project had four components; such as (i) institutional and capacity building component, (ii) studies and engineering services component, (iii) generation component and (iv) distribution component. The additional financing project is for (iii) and (iv). The original distribution component (iv) was to provide upgrading of existing substations, constructing new substations, reinforcing and extending distribution system, supplying energy meters and upgrading SADA/EMS system. The additional financing for the distribution component includes expanding distribution network to un-electrified areas in Nairobi, Western, Central, and Coast provinces. This activity is to cater to 40,000 applicants for connection. (3) Nairobi Ring Project The objective of AFD assisted Nairobi Ring Project is to support the countrys economic growth by providing reliable, economical and low-carbon energy. The objective is divided to three sub-objectives. (i) Improve the security of supply of the city of Nairobi and encourage social and economic development of the city and of the country. (ii) Allow transmit the energy generated by Olkaria geothermal plants, wind power plant of Lake Turkana, and thermal power plant near Monmabasa to Nairobi. (iii) Allow interconnection with Ethiopia and Tanzania under the East African Power Pool. In order to realize the objective, the project sets following components. (i) The construction of 400 kV transmission line, approximately 100 km, from the Suswa to Isinya. (ii) The construction of 220 kV substations in Suswa, Isinya, Thika Road, Koma Rock, Athi River and Ngong, as well as switching and monitoring devices at the existing substation ad Dandora. (iii) A spur line to Ngong substation and an underground cable between Dandora and Komarock substation. (4) Ethiopia-Kenya Electricity Highway Project The project co-financed by the World Bank, AfDB and AFD involves the construction of an electricity highway between Ethiopia and Kenya consisting of about 1,068 km of 500 kV transmission line and associated substations. The demand for electricity in the East African region has steadily increased. The region has a great variety of natural resources, in particular hydro power, mainly concentrated in Ethiopia. The project seeks to position Ethiopia as the main powerhouse and Kenya as the main hub for power trade in the East African Region. Power sector in Kenya has a plan to import electricity from Ethiopia to Nairobi region, so the project is important for Nairobi city to avoid electricity shortage. 4.1.8 Solid Waste Management There are some development partners implementing study, programs and projects. Main development partners are UNEP, UN-HABITAT and World Bank (WB). Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 26 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (1) UNEP UNEP has supported small scale and medium sized projects related to solid waste management. These projects are related to waste, sanitation an poverty reduction sectors. One of main project is Integrated Solid Waste Management Plan for Nairobi. The project was commenced in March 2009. A national task team was formed and a local university teams took hundreds of samples of wastes during 2009 to determine origins, compositions and to estimate amounts. In the plan, some action plans were proposed. Several training sessions were run. Stakeholders were consulted on matters of concern in early December 2009, and a strategic approach to the integrated waste management plan was presented by the National Task Team. In the plan, some action plans such as 1) Strategic alignment, 2) recognition of partner, 3) Continual monitoring and research of waste character, quantities and related solid waste information to aid future planning, 4) End-of-life levies on problematic wastes, 5) Source separation of recyclable and pure organic wastes with incentives, 6) Streamlined (weight-based) collection fees, 7) Awareness campaigns and education, 8) Zoning of waste collection, 9) Formalized waste collection contracts, 10) Development of material recovery and transfer facilities, 11) Derivation of value from the organic waste fraction, 12) Strengthening of specific recycling strategies, 13) Development of new engineered Landfill Site, 14) Rehabilitation of Dandora landfill site. (2) UN-HABITAT The Kibera Integrated Water, Sanitation and Waste Management Project (WATSAN) assists low cost community-based demonstrations in the Soweto village of Kibera slums. The project aims at contributing towards improving the livelihoods of the urban poor in Soweto East, by supporting small-scale community-based initiatives in water, sanitation and waste management. The activities related to solid waste is to implement small-scale door-to-door waste collection and recycling demonstrations. The Kenya Slum Upgrading Program (KENSUP) is also related to solid waste management and main objective is to improve the livelihood of people living and working in slums and informal settlements in Kenyas urban areas. The program started with selected slums within the statutory, regulatory and legal boundaries of the CCN, the Kisumu Municipal Council and the Mavoko Municipal Council. (3) World Bank World Bank (WB) implements the Kenya Municipal Program in 2010 to 2015 which includes the part of solid waste management through the cooperation of Ministry of Metro Development. However the area of the solid waste management sector of this program is outside of Nairobi county. WB currently considers the possibility of assistance for SWM in Nairobi Metropolitan Area. 4.1.9 Telecommunications The telecommunications projects are as listed below. Projects for the overhaul of the telecommunications infrastructure of Kenya were sponsored by the World Bank and were implemented in 1979, 1982 and 1985, consecutively. (1) World Bank Project in 1979 The project in 1979 overhauled telecommunications services by expanding local services and by providing high quality long-distance circuits, as well as basic telecommunications facilities to rural areas which were poorly served at the time. Major components included the installation of: (a) a total of 46,200 additional lines of local automatic exchange equipment with associated cables and subscribers' plant, a total of 46,000 additional connections; (b) long distance public call centres to Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 27 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya provide services in 200 urban, rural, and market areas without telephone services; (c) eight microwave radio systems, each with a capacity of 960 channels, three UHF radio systems with a total of 540 channels, 190 UHF/VHF channels and multiplex equipment to provide 3,100 additional channels; (d) long distance automatic exchanges with a total of 3,600 terminations and extensions to existing exchanges by 1,800 terminations; and (e) buildings to house equipment. (2) World Bank Project in 1982 The second World Bank telecommunications project in 1982 comprised the installation of: (a) a total of 80,900 additional lines of local automatic exchange equipment with associated cables and subscribers' plant to connect 75,000 additional main lines; (b) a total of 7,100 terminations in long distance exchanges; (c) three microwave and radio systems and 1,270 additional channels; (d) rural carrier systems to provide 200 additional channels; (e) two telex systems with a total of 3,000 additional lines and connection of 500 additional subscribers; and (f) buildings to house equipment. The project also included consulting services and training in association with the above installations. (3) World Bank Project in 1985 The third telecommunications project in 1985 comprised: (a) expansion of telephone and telex switching facilities, associated cable networks and subscriber plants, and expansion of international and long distance facilities; (b) overhaul of workshops and repair facilities and provision of spare parts; (c) support for the Kenya Post and Telecommunication Companys (KPTC) training programs and procurement of laboratory equipment; and (d) overhaul of KPTC's management system and consulting services for studies, including a review of the telecommunications tariff structure. (4) USAID Project in 2011 In 2012, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) provided technical assistance that covered the development of a national broadband strategy to underpin the deployment of modern broadband infrastructure to meet the needs of businesses, the government and the entire economy.
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 28 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4.2 Review of Current Infrastructure Conditions 4.2.1 Urban Transport (1) Road network 1) Road Classification and J urisdiction Roads in Kenya are classified by Kenya Road Classification Manual (J uly 2009, Ministry of Roads). The manual classifies rural roads into eight categories (S-G) and urban roads into seven categories (H-P). The summary of categories is shown in Table 4.2.1. Table 4.2.1 Summary of Road Classification in Kenya Road Classification Manual Categor y Function al Class Road Class Functiona l Class Alternative Descriptive Term Description Indicative Design Standards Carriage-wa y Width in Meters Design Speed (kph) Rural Road Arterial or Trunk S Super Highway Auto route, Motorway, Expressway Highways connecting two or more cities and designed to carry safely large volumes of motor vehicle traffic at high speeds Dual carriageway of min 2 lanes 90-120 A Major Arterial Trunk Road Roads forming strategic routes and corridors, connecting international boundaries and international terminals. 7-14 70-110 B Minor Arterial Trunk Road Roads forming important national routes, linking Province headquarters or other important centres to the capital, to each other or to Class A roads. 7 (-14) 70-110 Collector C Major Collector District Roads linking district headquarters and other major designated towns to the higher level network or to each other. 6.5 60-110 Urban Road Arterial H Major Arterial Highway Major arterials provide for through traffic and for relatively long distance movements between widely separated parts of the town or city. 3.5mper lane, 4-6 lanes 70-90 J Minor Arterial Principal Arterial Minor Arterials provide the main means of moving between different zones of the urban area. 3.5mper lane, 2-4 lanes 50-60 Collector K Major Collector Primary Distributor Major Collectors provide the link between Arterials and Local roads, distributing traffic to residential and other defined zones. 7 30-50 L Minor Collector District Distributor These performa similar function to major Collectors, but generally serve a smaller area, with lower traffic levels. 7 30-50 Local M Major Local Shopping / Local street These roads include the main shopping and business streets in the urban CBD or suburbs of larger towns and cities. 5-7 30-50 N Minor Local Non-resident ial access Roads providing direct access to individual or groups of properties, other than residential areas. 5 30-50 P Local Access Residential access Roads providing direct access to groups of residential properties. 3-5 30-50 Source: Kenya Road Classification Manual J uly 2009, Ministry of Roads Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 29 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Among the classified rural roads, class S, A, B and C are national roads under the jurisdiction of Kenya National Highway Authority (KeNHA). Other rural roads are mainly under the jurisdiction of Kenya Rural Roads Authority (KeRRA). Urban roads are under jurisdiction of Kenya Urban Roads Authority (KURA) and are currently in the process of devolution to municipality. Nairobi is the capital city of Kenya and the economic, social, and cultural centre of Kenya. There are two international roads (Class A) forming the major arterial road in the Nairobi City. One is the Northern Corridor (A109/104) that includes Mombasa Road, Uhuru Highway, Chiromo Road, Waiyaki Way and Naivasha Road as the trunk road. A104 then extends from Nairobi City Centre to the south thorough Kajiado and Namanga towards the Tanzanian Border. Further, A109 extends to the east and connects to Mombasa, the second largest city in Kenya, and to the west to the border with Uganda, and forms the logistic axis for the inland countries. The second international trunk road is Thika Road (A2) that was constructed and improved currently by the assistance of AfDB and China. The road connects in the northeast direction from Nairobi City Centre to Thika and to the A2, which connects further to Ethiopia. Figure 4.2.2 shows the road network and road classification in Nairobi City. Functions of major road of Class B, C and H are described in Table 4.2.2. Recently constructed Bypasses such as H6 and H7 are also included in the table. Table 4.2.2 Classified Roads in Nairobi and Their Functions Road Number Name Function Covering Area B10 Airport North Road Principal Arterial Airport north C58 Magadi Road Minor Arterial Langata, Kajiado C59 Outer Ring Road Principal Arterial Embasaki, Makadara, Kamukunji and Kasarani C60 Ngong Road Principal Arterial Dagoretti, Langata to Kajido C61 Naibasha Road Minor Arterial Dagoretti to Langata (Partly missing) C62 Limuru Road Principal Arter1al Westlands C63 Langata Road, Dugoretti Road, Kiambu Road and Ruiru Road Principal Arterial Langata, Kajiado, Kiambu C64 Kamubu Road Minor Arterial Kassarani, Westlands C98 Komarock Road Principal Arterial Embakasi, Kjiru, Kathiani H6 Eastern Bypass Principal Arterial Embakasi, Njiru H7 Northern Bypass Principal Arterial KIambu, Kasarani, Westlands Source: J ICA Study Team, Road functions are based on The Study on Master Plan for Urban Transport in the Nairobi Metropolitan Area, J ICA 2006 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 30 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
S o u r c e :
J I C A
S t u d y
T e a m
F i g u r e
4 . 2 . 1
R o a d
N e t w o r k
i n
N a i r o b i
C i t y
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 31 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The structure of road network in Nairobi City is described as follows: (i) The international roads go through Nairobi City and function as the most crucial radial road in the study area. (ii) The importance of northern corridor as the citys trunk road as well as an international trunk road is emphasized, and traffic flow of the northern corridor is apparently given more priority than other crossing roads. Therefore the northern corridor becomes a kind of barrier for the local traffic flow in the west-east direction. (iii) As the densely populated area of Nairobi city mainly stretches to the west and east, the traffic demand of west-east is larger than north-south. Therefore, roads of west-east direction across the northern corridor are always congested. (iv) The present land use structure of Nairobi City is centralized around the CBD. Hence radial roads are predominant in the network system. This network system attracts most of traffic into the city centre including vehicles which do not have the destination in the City Centre. (v) In the suburban area, where housing developments are in progress, not only the access roads and collector roads but also arterial roads which collect the generating traffic are insufficient. (vi) The urban transport master plan by J ICA emphasized on forming radial and circumferential road system, and a staging plan is proposed based on this policy, but currently the road development has not implemented based on the proposed staging plan. 2) Number of Lanes Number of lanes of existing road class A to J and roads more than 4 lanes are shown in Figure 4.2.2. Roads with more than 4 lanes are major trunk roads and roads in the city centre area. Most of the roads with south-north direction are 2 lanes, consequently traffic demand concentrates to A 104. According to the traffic analysis, traffic with east-west direction will increase in the future. Roads with east west direction also require to be strengthened. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 32 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.2 Number of Lanes of Existing Roads 3) Road Density The road length density of the road network is shown in Figure 4.2.3. Road length density is 0.98 km/km 2 in overall Nairobi City, which includes some low population density area. The J apanese standard density of the trunk road in the urban area is 4.0 km/km 2 , and only the centre of Nairobi City is in this range. Next, the road length density by population is shown in Figure 4.2.4. The road length density by population of overall Nairobi City is 0.22km/1000 people. The western part of Nairobi City has a high road length density by population. However, the east side of Thika Road has low road length density; it indicates that there are not enough roads where the rapid increase in population is taking place. (Refer to Figure 2.1.3 Average Annual Population Growth Rate of Nairobi City and its Environs) In general, development/improvement of roads in Nairobi City concentrates to trunk roads, and development/improvement of small roads in residential area is left behind. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 33 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.3 The Road Length Density by Area of the Target Road Network
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.4 The Road Length Density by Population of the Target Road Network Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 34 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (2) Non-Motorized Transport Since Kenyan people walk a lot along the arterial roads and in the urban streets, walking occupies a large proportion among the travel modes. Therefore NMT facilities for safe, comfortable and easy movement is necessary especially in traffic congested areas. In this viewpoint, the followings are pointed out: (i) Sideway is narrow (ii) Marking for pedestrian crossing is not sufficient. (iii) Pedestrian crossing signals are insufficient, sometimes not working and are neglected by drivers and passengers. (iv) Along some roads, sideways are provided, but still are not formulating pedestrian network. (v) No dedicated lane for bicycles is available in urban area. (3) Public Transport Most of bus and matatu terminals are located around the Nairobi railway station, but are not systematically located by direction or destination. Outside the city centre, lay-bys for bus stop are prepared on the trunk roads, but along minor roads, matatus and buses often stop at roadsides or intersections for picking up passengers, which cause obstable in traffic flow of the roads. According to the interview to the public transport passengers, three major requirements of bus/matatu passengers were 1) Improvement of bus stop facility/Information, 2) Improvement of accessibility, and 3) Improvement of regularity/punctuality. As a result of the screen line survey, total number of matatu was 72,000 and large bus was 23,000. Applying the average number of passengers of 10 passengers per matatu and 27 passengers per a large bus, total passengers crossing screen line by matatu is 720,000 and 620,000 by bus. Figure 4.2.5 also shows that modal shift to the public transport was not much in progress. Considering the traffic condition in Nairobi, use of public transport should be encouraged more. To this end, conditions and quality of public transport operation shall be improved in such a way as higher operation speed, punctuality, better accessibility to terminals and convenience for passengers. 34.8% 27.7% 46.7% 50.4% 5.8% 6.6% 4.1% 4.6% 13.9% 18.6% 5.7% 11.4% 33.0% 35.2% 26.7% 24.8% 12.0% 11.3% 15.3% 8.4% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% To Home To Work To School Others Modal Share by Trip Purpose 2013 Walking Two-wheel Mode Private Car/Taxi/Truck Matatu Bus Railway Others
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 35 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 47.3% 28.8% 58.0% 65.3% 1.1% 1.9% 0.4% 0.8% 14.4% 21.5% 6.6% 14.0% 29.6% 39.3% 22.6% 17.1% 7.1% 7.4% 12.2% 2.6% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% To Home To Work To School Others Modal Share by Trip Purpose 2004 Walking Two-wheel Mode Private Car/Taxi/Truck Matatu Bus Railway Others
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.5 Comparison of Travel Mode by Trip Purpose between 2004 Survey and 2013 Survey 4.2.2 Railway The main line of the KRC is the line from Mombasa to Uganda through Nairobi. Many railway commuters are using this line from Athi River (South-East direction) to Nairobi, and from Kikuyu, (North-West direction) to Nairobi. Many passengers are also commuting from Ruiru, (North-East direction) to Nairobi, on a branch line towards Thika city. A short branch line towards Embakashi Village is also used for commuting purpose. The existing meter-gauge track is composed of 85/90 lb/yard rail with steel sleepers. Rails are welded at some sections, however mainly fish-plate joints are used. Ballast is heavily contaminated with soil. Turnouts are operated manually without any type of signal equipment. Train operation is controlled by telephone between stations. Instead of a tablet, paper sheet is used to confirm the track occupancy. Except few stations, the existing station buildings are small and not well maintained. Generally, access roads to stations are in poor condition as shown on the following photos.
Figure 4.2.6 Existing Track Condition (left), Existing Ruiru Station (right) KRC is now planning to strengthen commuter train services by providing new lines as indicated in red lines on the following map. The planned new line from Nairobi to Kikuyu shown on the map is overlapping with the planned LRT line proposed in the MRTS report in 2011. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 36 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: KRC Figure 4.2.7 KRC Existing and Planned Lines Due to the increasing severe traffic congestion in the city, the needs for mass transit system are widely recognized. There are two approaches for the development of rail based mass transit system in Nairobi, namely; 1) Utilization of existing Kenyan Railways Corporation (KRC) facilities, and 2) construction of new LRT/MRT lines. (1) Utilization of Kenya Railways Corporation Facilities Although the Nairobi Commuter Railway Project, as described in the clause 4.2.3, is ongoing, there is no other specific operation has been achieved than Nairobi-Syokimau commuter service. The existing commuter train service on the following lines is operated by Rift Valley Railways (RVR), the concessionaire of train operation since 2006. RVR is now operating commuter train services on the following sections; (i) NRS (Nairobi Railway Station) Ruiru Section (32km) Operating 22 coaches train, 2 trains/day, total 6,900 passengers/day in 2010, total 7,450 passengers/day in 2011, and 5,350 passengers/day in 2012. (ii) NRS Kahawa Section Operating 16 coaches train, 2 trains/day, total 6,900 passengers/day in 2010. From 2011, 8trains/day, 7,500 passengers/day in 2011, and 3,950 passengers/day in 2012. (iii) NRS Embakasi Section Operating 10 coaches train, 2 trains/day, total 2,300 passengers/day in 2010. From 2011, 8 trains/day, 4,960 passengers/day in 2011 and 3,030 passengers/day in 2012. (iv) Nairobi Kikuyu Section Operating 10 coaches train, 2 trains per day, total 4,200 passengers/day in 2010, 1,100 passengers/day in2011, and 1,910 passengers/day in 2012. Operating 7 coaches train, 5 R.T. per day, total 2,500 passengers. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 37 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (2) Planned Alignments of MRT/LRT Feasibility Study and Technical Assistance for Mass Rapid Transit System for the Nairobi Metropolitan Region has been prepared by Indian and Kenyan consultants in 2011. MRT and LRT lines are planned on the following six major roads. 1) Thika Road (EL: NRS Githurai): 15.04km Thika road has enough overall width for the construction of elevated structures for MRT line. However, if the MRT structure is constructed at the centre of the road, the width of the existing median strip (central reservation) is not enough for the construction of viaduct piers because at least 2.5m width is required for the construction of pier and its protective structure for collision of vehicles.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.8 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of MRT on Thika Road Although the first priority of MRT construction is given to this alignment, the construction schedule shall be planned carefully considering the capacity of the existing Thika Road and future demand forecast. 2) J uja Road (UG: NRS Pangani +EL: Pangani Njiru): 4.37km +9.45km =13.82 km There seems no difficulty in the construction. Location of the transition section from the underground structure to the elevated structure shall be carefully selected in order not to block the vehicles on the surface road. Prior to the construction of MRT, the road shall be widened with a wide median strip for the piers construction.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.9 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of MRT on Juja Road Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 38 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 3) J ogoo Road (EL: NRS Kayole Crossing): 12.79km J ogoo road has a wide median strip enough for the construction of LRT piers up to the crossing with the Outer Ring road. R.O.W. is also reserved enough space for the proposed LRT construction. However, from the Outer Ring road crossing up to Kayole Crossing, there is no median strip at all. Reservation of R.O.W. is not enough at some locations.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.10 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of LRT on Jogoo Road 4) Ngong Road (UG: NRS Hilton Hotel +El: Hilton Hotel Dagoretti/Thompson Estate): 0.66km +7.87km =8.53km The description of Hilton Hotel seems wrong. The alignment will go through Railway Club which is located at the west side of NRS. As shown on the Figure 4.2.11, there is a steep slope between Railway Golf Course and Upper Hill area. The slope of the existing ground is 5.5% approximately. Since the maximum applicable gradient of MRT system using steel wheel on steel rail is 3.5%, it is impossible to climb this steep slope by the planned alignment. Except for the section between NRS and Upper Hill, there is a wide median strip where piers of viaduct structure can be constructed. Condition of the existing road is very good.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.11 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of MRT on Ngong Road Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 39 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 5) Outer Ring Road (EL: Thika Road Crossing Airport Road): 12.93km As shown on the Figure 4.2.12 below, there are three river crossings along this alignment. In order to avoid flooding during rainy season, the rail level shall be set higher than the highest level of the record flood. Condition of the existing road is generally fair except in some locations where pavement is severely damaged. ROW. for future widening seems to be reserved already, however, existing pavement width is very narrow. Therefore, prior to the construction of LRT, the road shall be widened with a median strip for future pier construction.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.12 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of LRT on the Outer Ring Road 6) Thika Road-2 (EL: Githurai Ruiru): 9.71km The condition of this section is similar to that of the section between NRS Githurai. However, widening of the median strip may not be required because of the wider existing median than the section between NRS Guthurai. (Refer to the Figure 4.2.8.) 7) Waiyaki Way (EL: NRS Kabete): 12.4km Waiyaki Way consists of four lane road with wide median strip. Condition of the pavement is very good. Therefore, there will be no difficulty in the construction of LRT along this road, except the section between NRS Waiyaki Way.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.13 Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of LRT on the Waiyaki Way Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 40 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4.2.3 Airport Airport sector have the shared responsibility of air transport mode. Air transport plays a significant role in economic growth of developing country. In Kenya, it is the main transport mode for tourism, high value export and import and perishable good. Also Kenya occupies a strategic position as an Aviation centre in the Eastern and Central Africa region. In the last ten years air traffic through Kenyas airports has increased substantially from 4,748 thousand to 8,584 thousand annual passengers Nairobi has two civil airports which are; J omo Kenyatta International Airport (J KIA) and Wilson Airport. J KIA is conveniently located 18 km from city centre to serve as a domestic hub and International gateway in Kenya. J KIA is the 7th busiest airport in Africa and a major hub in East and Central Africa for tourist and cargo movement. Wilson Airport is located 5 km south of the city and neighbours Nairobi National Park. Wilson Airport is used mostly for both domestic and international general aviation traffic. This Airport lies approximately 18 kilometres west of JKIA. The location of the two airports is shown in Figure 4.2.14 below
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.14 View of JKIA Terminal Area from Control Tower (1) J KIA J KIA serves as the gateway for international air traffic and hub for domestic airports in Nairobi City in Kenya. J KIA is situated at an altitude of 1,624.5 m MSL with one runway, two passenger terminal buildings which are separated for departure and arrival, cargo terminal and related airport facilities. Table 4.2.3 describes major facilities at the Airport whereas Figure 4.2.15 shows the image of J KIA passenger terminal area. KAJ IADO Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 41 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.2.3 Major Facilities of JKIA Item Name Description Principal Feature Name J omo Kenyatta International Airport (J KIA) Operation International and domestic Code ICAO: HKJ K IATA: NBO Location Latitude: 0119'09.267"S Longitude: 03655'39.992"E Access to airport 18 kmfromNairobi city centre, approx. 30 min. by vehicle Reference ground elevation 1,624.5 m+MSL Temperature Average 21C Operation 24 hours (Air Traffic Services: ATS) Operator Airport facility: KAA, Navigation system: KCAA Runway No. Dimension PCN Slope/max Strip Dimension 06/24 4,117 m45 m 65/F/A/W/T 0.5365% 4,361 m300 m Taxiway width PCN surface 23 m 65/F/A/W/T Concrete, Asphalt Aircraft Parking PCN surface Apron 65/F/A/W/T Concrete Approach and Runway RWY06: PALS, LIL/ PAPI Left side of RWY Lighting RWY24: SALS, LIL/ PAPI Left side of RWY Source: AIP
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.15 View of JKIA Terminal Area from Control Tower J KIA is projected to grow with the growth of Kenyas economy, as well as increase in foreign currency income. In 2011, J KIA had more than 80 % of its total passenger traffic from international flights and around 40 % from domestic flights. Moreover, J KIA had 65 % of the total flights in Kenya in 2011. (2) Wilson Airport Wilson Airport is used mostly by general aviation traffic for both domestic and international. The domestic flight is extensively for tourism, health care and agriculture. The safari is the most popular Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 42 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya tourism attraction in Kenya i.e. Maasai Mara, Mombasa, Kilimanjaro, Amboseli, Eldoret and Lamu are all just a short flight away by Air Kenya, Aero Kenya and Safarilink. Other flight operations are Humanitarian agencies such as Africa Medical and Research Foundation (AMREF), Mission Aviation Fellowship (MAF) as well as flight training. Wilson Airport is also the major international flight commonly used by business executives. Table 4.2.4 Major Facilities of Wilson Airport Item Name Description Principal Feature Name Nairobi/ Wilson Operation International and domestic Code ICAO: HKNW IATA: WIL Location Latitude: 0119'16.578"S Longitude: 03648'53.881"E Access to airport 5 kmfromNairobi city centre, approx. 10 min. by vehicle Reference ground elevation 1,687 m+MSL Temperature Average 23C Operation 0330 1730/ 14 hours (Air Traffic Services: ATS) Operator Airport facility: KAA, Navigation system: KCAA Runway No. Dimension PCN Slope/max Strip Dimension 07/25 1,463 mx 24 m 18/F/B/X/U 1.42 % 14/32 1,560 m23 m 13/F/A/W/T 1.0% Taxiway width PCN surface 23 m 15/F/B/X/U Bitumen Aircraft Parking PCN surface Apron 15/F/B/X/U Bitumen Approach and Runway RWY07: SALS/ PAPI Left side, RWY25: NIL Lighting RWY14: PAPI Both side, RWY 32: NIL Source: AIP
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.16 View of Wilson Airport Airlines Hanger and Taxiway from Control Tower Wilson Airport had mainly domestic flight operation and around 13 % of its total passenger traffic from domestic flights. However, aircraft movement of Wilson Airport is the highest operation in Kenya historically. In 2011, the number of aircraft movement was 76,388 times. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 43 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4.2.4 Water Supply (1) Water Resources The existing water resources for the water supply system to Nairobi City were Sasumua Dam, Thika Dam, Ruiru Dam and Mwagu Intake on the Chania River, Kikuyu Springs and boreholes of ground water. The capacity for the water supply was summarized in Table 4.2.5. The outline map of water supply to Nairobi City was presented in Figure 4.2.17. Table 4.2.5 Existing Water Resources of Water Supply for Nairobi City Name Capacity for Water Supply (m 3 /day) Remark Sasumua Dam 63,000 549,500 Chania River Thika Dam-Mwagu Intake 460,000 Thika River Ruiru Dam 21,700 Ruiru River Kikuyu Springs 4,800 Two springs are mainly supply raw water to Nairobi City. Ground Water 45,000 Due to the shortage of water, private boreholes were developed in Nairobi City. Nairobi City Water Supply & Sewerage Company (NCWSC) owns 30 boreholes and 13 of those are in operation. The Figure is total expected by NCWSC in 2010. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) (2) Existing Facilities of Water Supply There are four water supply systems to Nairobi City as per its water resource, namely the Sasumua system, Ruiru system, Mwagu system and Kikuyu system. Some of the facilities of the systems, such as raw/treated water transmission pipelines of Sasumua WTP (Water Treatment Plant) and Ngethu WTP exist outside of Nairobi City as presented Table 4.2.5. Thus, countermeasure for complaints from the users in the area needs to be considered in rehabilitation/expansion of facilities, some of which may be located outside of Nairobi. In fact, NCWSC supplies bulk water from the systems to the WSP of the area. The existing facilities of the Sasumua system, Ruiru system, Mwagu system and Kikuyu system were presented in Table 4.2.6, 4.2.7, 4.2.8 and 4.2.9, respectively. Outline of connection among the facilities was presented in Figure 4.2.17 titled the Outline Map of Water Supply to Nairobi City. Table 4.2.6 Existing Facilities of Sasumua System Name Capacity or Size Raw Water Transmission Total length fromthe damto WTP is 686m. D800 pipeline started fromthe damwas diverted to two pipelines of D600 and D450. Before inlet of WTP, hydropower generators were installed. Sasumua WTP 63,000 (m 3 /day) Treated Water Transmission FormSasumua damto Ruiru chamber. Two parallel pipelines of D462.5 and 318.75 were installed. From Ruiru chamber to Kabete and Kyuna reservoirs, pipeline of D600 was installed. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Table 4.2.7 Existing Facilities of Ruiru System Name Capacity or Size Raw Water Transmission Three pipelines of D225, D300 and D400 were installed Kabete WTP 21,700 (m 3 /day), Treated water is transmitted to Kabete Reservoirs Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 44 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.2.8 Existing Facilities of Mwagu System Name Capacity or Size Raw Water Transmission Tunnel with diameter of three meter connected fromMwagu intake to Mataara chamber. Fromthe chamber to Ngethu WTP, two parallel pipelines of D1,400 and D1,200 were installed. Ngethu WTP 460,000 (m 3 /day) Treated Water Transmission Three parallel pipelines of D700, D1,000 and D1,000 - D1,400 connected fromNgethu WTP to the Gigiri and Kabete Reservoirs. The pipelines were inter-connected for bulk water supply to Ruiru, Gatundu and Kiambu, which are environs of Nairobi City. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Table 4.2.9 Existing Facilities of Kikuyu System Name Capacity or Size Raw Water Transmission Pipeline of D300 connected Kikuyu spring no.1 to Kabete WTP via tank no.1 with volume of 150m 3 . Pipeline of D200 connected Kikuyu Spring no.2 to Kabete WTP via tank no.2 with volume of 150 m 3 . The capacity is 4,800 (m 3 /day) in total. Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST)
Source: JICA Study Team (JST) Figure 4.2.17 Outline of Map of Water Supply to Nairobi City Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 45 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The distribution network of Nairobi City receives treated water from four reservoirs named Kabete, Kyuna, Kiambu and Gigiri reservoirs and the distribution area is segmented to 13 zones based on the reservoir supplying the water to the zone. The distribution network is installed with high density in the western area of Nairobi City and low in the eastern area. The zones of the distribution system in Nairobi City are summarized in Table 4.2.10 and the general layout of the zones is presented in Figure 4.2.18. Table 4.2.10 Zones of the Distribution System in Nairobi City Zone Number Reservoir Supplying Water Capacity of Reservoir (m 3 ) 1 Kikuyu tank no.1 250 Kikuyu tank no.2 250 2N Kabete 42,000 2S Kabete PS- Dagoretti 11,000 3N Kabete PS- Uthiru 11,000 3S Kabete PS- Dagoretti 11,000 4 Kyuna PS - Loresho Tower 450 5 Kyuna 9,000 6 Kiambu 59,000 7 Kabete PS - Hill Tank 18,000 8 Gigiri 61,000 9 Gigiri - Karura 9,000 10 Gigiri - Ring Road Tower 450 11 Kiambu - Kasarani 11,000 Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) (3) Water Supply Services in Nairobi City 1) Produced/Served Water and Unaccounted for Water (UfW) According to the performance report of Kenya's water services sub-sector, the produced water in 2008 was estimated 423,000(m 3 /day) and the served amount of the water was estimated 255,000(m 3 /day). The UfW in Nairobi City was approximately 40%. In reference to FSMPNWS, the water demand in 2010 considering the 40% of UfW was 578,643(m 3 /day). This estimate was in accordance with the practical manual of water supply issued by Ministry of Water and Irrigation (MWI). As presented in the Table 4.2.5, the total capacity of the facilities for water supply to Nairobi City is 549,500(m 3 /day). Thus, the capacity of the facilities is of little shortage as compared with the requirement of MWI. On the other hand, the difference between the produced water and the total capacity is 126,500(m 3 /day). The main reason was that the inlet flow rate of Ngethu WTP was 360,000(m 3 /day) as referred FSMPNWS, while its capacity is 460,000(m 3 /day). On this issue, discussion is necessary about the further allocation of water resource and the rehabilitation of the facilities to fill the gap. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 46 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc.
N i p p o n
K o e i
C o . ,
L t d
4
-
4 7
F i n a l
R e p o r t ( D r a f t )
I D C J
I n c .
E J E C
I n c
T h e
P r o j e c t
o n
I n t e g r a t e d
U r b a n
D e v e l o p m e n t
M a s t e r
P l a n
f o r
t h e
C i t y
o f
N a i r o b i
i n
t h e
R e p u b l i c
o f
K e n y a
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.18 General Layout of the Zones
Boundary of Zone Main Load WTP, Reservoir Legend FromKiambu Reservoir FromNgethu WTP FromSasumuaWTP FromRuiru Dam Kikuyu Springs Kasarani Reservoir Ring Road Water Tower Wilson Reservoir KyunaReservoir KabeteWTP & Reservoir Gigiri Reservoir Karen Reservoir Dagoretti Reservoir Hill Tank KaruraReservoir Uthiru Reservoir Main Distribution Pipeline
The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 2) Coverage Ratio The served population of Nairobi City in 2008 was 2,157,826 as mentioned in the performance report. The total population of the Nairobi City in 2008 was 3,138,369. The ratio of the served population is approximately 67% . On the other hand, actual figure is expected higher than the reported. Water supply projects for informal settlement were implemented as mentioned in Sub-section 2.6.5. Few of the beneficiaries by these projects were reflected to the figure described above, because water kiosks and yard taps were provided by the projects and its customers were not fixed due to the style of the facilities. 3) Water Tariff Water tariff in Nairobi City is issued by AWSB under approval of WSRB (Water Service Regulatory Board) pursuant to Water Act 2002 and is conducted by NCWSC. Water tariff composes of water fee, rental fee of water meter, refundable deposits, connection fee and penalty of illegal connection. NCWSC has managed his O&M works of the water supply system with the revenue of the water tariff. (4) Rehabilitation of Facilities On the rehabilitation of facilities for raw water transmission, water treatment plants and transmission mains, projects financed by AFD are on-going as of April, 2013. The projects cover Sasumua system and Mwagu system. For the distribution network, as UfW is targeted to decrease from 40% to 20% in the practical manual of water supply issued by MWI, the plan and schedule of rehabilitation/improvement of distribution network need to be established. (5) Existing Development Plan In FSMPSNWS, the development plan of water resources was proposed as per the projection of population and water demand in Nairobi City based on the practical manual of water supply in force in Kenya. In this study, the urban development plan of Nairobi City including the projection of the population and study of land use is carried out. Based on the projection, review of the plan will be carried out. 4.2.5 Storm Water Drainage and Sewerage (1) Storm Water Drainage 1) Drainage System The city of Nairobi is located in the uppermost of the Athi Catchment Area. The Nairobi River belongs to the Athi River system and its catchment area includes the majority of the land area of the city. The northern and central areas of the city are drained by the tributaries of the Athi River, namely the Gitathuru, Rui Ruaka, Nairobi and Ngong rivers. The south of the city, mostly occupied by the Nairobi National Park, belongs to another catchment that is drained by the Mbagathi River and associated streams. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 48 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya In Nairobi City, the existing storm water drainage system is developed mainly in the central business district (CBD) and part of neighbouring areas, and is composed of roadside drains associated with the existing urban roads, storm sewers and canalized trunk drains to collect storm water from the catchment areas and discharge storm water to the tributaries mentioned above. Because of the topography generally sloping from west to east, the storm water is drained by gravity. In the suburbs of Nairobi City, it is observed that storm water is collected and discharged through roadside drains and small streams which are not well-developed as a whole. 2) Drainage Development Works The Regional Office of Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) is in charge of the management of water resources in the Nairobi river basin. The tasks of the Regional Office include the river training works and canal works for the development of storm water drainage system. The Kenya Urban Road Authority is responsible for the development of urban roads including roadside drains, which comprise a majority of the storm water drainage facilities in Nairobi City. The City Engineering Department of NCC is in charge of checking the design of storm water drainages in the appraisal of road construction works and their maintenance. The main task of the Department is to clean the roadside drains and canalized open channels. It was reported that the Department carried out cleaning roadside drains along 700 km of existing roads out of the total of 2,400 km in the year 2010 but any identification and repair of deteriorated location was not undertaken 1 . At present, the Department has prepared a map of the existing storm water drainage system in Nairobi City and making efforts to identify problematic locations that need to be improved. The Department is faced with the difficulty in managing the storm water drainage system as previous maps and records for the storm water drainage system were destroyed by fire that engulfed City Hall in 2004 and most of the data was in hard copy with no back up of soft copies available elsewhere. At present, the Department through the consultancies under the KMP and NaMSIP is initiating preparation of a map of the existing major storm water drainage system in Nairobi City besides the existing roadside drains and making efforts to identify problematic locations that need to be improved. 3) Primary Observations In April 2013, the J ICA study team has initiated the infrastructure development planning for storm water drainage in Nairobi City and made primary observations of present situations of storm water drainage during the rainy season. The main points of the observations are described below. Problems: (i) It is suggested that the city of Nairobi were suffering repeatedly from the localized inundation at many locations during the rainy season. (ii) During a rainstorm, the inundation on the main roads causes heavy traffic jam in the city centre. (iii) A number of roads are washed and pitted with puddles even a day after the rainstorm. 1 Preparatory Survey on Nairobi Urban Development Programme, J ICA, October 2011 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 49 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc.
The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (iv) Storm water stagnation is attributed to the degradation of living environment in housing areas, e.g. the informal settlements formed in the lowlands. Causes Suggested: (i) Roadside drains are not functioning effectively due to improper design and/or construction, structural deterioration, and lack of removal of sediment and garbage. (ii) Storm water drainage network are not functioning effectively. Many drainage sections and/or outfalls remain blocked/clogged, due mainly to the difficulty in identifying such locations in densely built-up areas (e.g. informal settlements). (iii) In general, there are no systematic identification of problems on the storm water drainage system, and localized works on ad-hoc basis are done only to create another problem elsewhere. (iv) Urbanization in higher areas increases bare / concreted ground surfaces with less infiltration capacity and results in the rapid concentration of storm water to the downstream areas. (v) Developed areas where land topography forms a centralized low point (basin-like) with zero natural drainage for any generated storm water without introduction of a significant storm water drain to carry the water out of the low point (e.g. in Runda Estate). 4) Status of Planning Meanwhile, any usable planning document for the storm water drainage in Nairobi City is unknown. It was reported that a document of storm water drainage plan in Nairobi City had been prepared in 1980s with a support by the World Bank and GTZ but such a document was neither available nor used in the City Engineering Department of NCC 2 . Under the Kenya Municipal Program (KMP), it is expected that the Ministry of Local Government (MOLG) will initiate the preparation of a master plan, detailed designs, tender documents and operations and maintenance manuals for storm water drainage works in the City of Nairobi within the year 2013. The MOLG issued a procurement notice on 11 March 2013 regarding the request for expressions of interest (EOI) by 26 March 2013. It is presumed that the MOLG would proceed with the process of the selection of consultants as of April 2013. As suggested in the published information by the World Bank regarding the Nairobi Metropolitan Services Improvement Project (NaMSIP), the Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development (MONMD) would be carrying out the preparation of feasibility studies, final designs and bidding documents for storm water drainage in Nairobi City (Dagoretti, Langata, CBD and Embakasi), Thika (CBD and west of CBD), Mavoko and Ongata Rongai township in 2013. Afterward, bid submission and opening of construction of Nairobi storm water drainage works is scheduled on August 2013. (2) Sewerage System 1) Sewerage Treatment Plants There are 24 existing sewerage treatment plants (STPs) in Nairobi City, but most of them are localized STPs with a small capacity less than 2,000 m 3 /day. The major STPs are the Dandora 2 Preparatory Survey on Nairobi Urban Development Programme, J ICA, October 2011 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 50 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc.
The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya STP (capacity 120,000 m 3 /day) and the Kariobangi STP (32,000 m 3 /day). A report by the Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company (NCWSC) indicates that these STPs are not well-functioning in terms of actual sewerage treatment volume and water quality of treated outflow as shown in Table 4.2.11 below. In particular, the Kariobangi STP suffers from the deterioration and mechanical troubles and is not operational substantially 3 . Table 4.2.11 Operating Conditions of Existing Major STPs in Nairobi City Type, Capacity, Inflow and Outflow STP Type Capacity (m 3 /day) Sewerage Inflow (m 3 /day) Treated Outflow (m 3 /day) Dandora Lagoon 120,000 90,870 69,941 Kariobangi Conventional biological aerated filter 32,000 11,933 (N/A)
Treatment STP Item Water Quality (mg/L) Sewerage Inflow Treated Outflow Effluent Standard Dandora BOD 375 66 30 COD 924 245 50 TSS 500 113 30 Kariobangi BOD 340 194.8 30 COD 774.7 373.1 50 TSS 306.5 77.3 30 Source: NCWSC Quarterly Report, J uly-September 2011 2) Sewers The majority of existing sewers are the combined sewers, collecting both storm water and wastewater, and are developed in the central business district (CBD) and in other recent development areas. The total length of existing trunk sewers is about 162 km which collect wastewaters from the sewerage service areas totalled about 208 km 2 , which accountings for approximate 40% of the total area covered by the water supply service. But some of the sewerage service areas, however, still need some reticulation lines (secondary sewers) locally and an actual percentage of service coverage is not clear yet accordingly 4 . Wastewater collected from the sewerage service areas are conveyed to STPs located in the east of Nairobi through the trunk sewers constructed along the rivers running west to east. 3) Sanitation Nairobi Sanitation Status on the website of IWA Water Wiki 5 summarizes existing situations of sanitation in Nairobi City as described below. (i) About 10% of the population are served by sewers while 20% have septic tanks and the remainder use latrine, although these appear to be very crude data (UN-HABITAT, 2003). (ii) Business/institutional centre and wealthy/middle-income residential districts mostly are served by the sewerage system or septic tanks. (iii) About 60% of the population live in informal settlements. Of these population, 24% are estimated to have a latrine (improved or unimproved) or a flush toilet, while 68% use public toilets (mostly over-crowded low-quality latrines), and 6% resort to open defecation or defecation in plastic bags so called flying toilets (NCWSC/AWSB 2009). 3 Preparatory Survey on Nairobi Urban Development Programme, J ICA, October 2011 4 - ditto - 5 http://www.iwawaterwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Articles/34)+NAIROBI+(Kenya)+3 (as of April 2013) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 51 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc.
The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4) Sewerage Development Works i) The Athi Water Services Board: The Athi Water Services Board (AWSB) is the responsible agency for planning, design and implementation of projects for sewerage development works in the Athi Catchment Area where the city of Nairobi is located. In Nairobi City, the AWSB has been implementing the following sewerage development works recently under the Water and Sanitation Service Improvement Project (WaSSIP). (i) Construction of Gatharaini Trunk Sewers including Rui-Rwaka, Gatharaini North and Gatharaini South (Contract No. AWSB/WaSSIP/Comp.1/W-6/2009) (ii) Construction of Lavington-Riruta Trunk Sewers Extensions (Contract No. AWSB/WaSSIP/Comp.1/W-7/2009) (iii) Rehabilitation of Dandora Sewerage Treatment Works and Reconstruction of Ngong River Trunk Sewers (Contract No. AWSB/WaSSIP/Comp.1/W-9/2009) Besides, the AWSB has initiated the following sewerage development works under the Nairobi Rivers Rehabilitation and Restoration Program: Sewerage Improvement Project. (iv) Lot 1: Construction of Kiu River and Dandora Estate Trunk Sewers and Expansion of Dandora Waste Water Treatment Plant (Contract No. AWSB/NaRSIP/W/01/2012) (v) Lot 2: Construction of Mathare, Nairobi, Ngong Rivers Trunk sewers and Reticulation Network (Contract No. AWSB/NaRSIP/W/01/2012) In addition to the above, the rehabilitation of the Kariobangi STP is also scheduled within the Sewerage Improvement Project. ii) Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company: The Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company (NCWSC) is a service provider appointed by the AWSB. The NCWSC takes charge of the provision of the water and sewerage services including the operation, maintenance and management of the sewerage system consisting of the sewers and STPs. 5) Status of Planning The current sewerage development works are implemented on the basis of the Nairobi Sewerage Master Plan study (1998) and Nairobi Sewerage Master Plan Validation report (2009). The AWSB plans to carry out Updating the Nairobi City Sewerage Master Plan as listed in the procurement plan of the WaSSIP during J uly 2012 to December 2013. The AWSB and NCWSC, with the support of the Water and Sanitation Program, prepared jointly the Strategic Guidelines for Improving Water and Sanitation Services in Nairobis Informal Settlements (2009). The guidelines articulate the priorities and overarching principles adopted by AWSB and NCWSC to improve water and sanitation services delivery in Nairobis informal settlements. These principles have been used to develop a framework that provides NCWSC with the practical tools to apply on a settlement-by-settlement basis: The guidelines consist of six main parts: (i) context, relevance, and objectives; (ii) socio-economic, institutional, and legal issues; Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 52 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (iii) general technical guidelines; (iv) finance and ownership issues; (v) the overarching principles for service provision in informal settlements; and (vi) an action model guiding NCWSCs work in informal settlements. 4.2.6 Power Supply (1) Power Companies in Kenya The electric power sector of Kenya is under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Energy (MOE). The sector comprises of Kenya Power Generating Company (KenGen), Kenya Power, Independent power producers (IPP), Kenya Electricity Transmission Company (KETRACO), Geothermal Development Company (GDC), and Rural Electricity Authority (REA). As an independent regulatory body, Energy Regulation Commission (ERC) is supervising the sector. 1) MOE MoE is responsible for establishing the national energy policy and rural electrification plan and set the direction for the growth of the electrical power sector and makes a long term vision for the sector. 2) KenGen KenGen, as well as other IPPs, generate electricity and sell it to Kenya Power. While KenGen is a state corporation, IPPs are basically private sector investments. IPPs currently provide about 20 % of the whole demand and are expected to continue to play a significant role in power generation and KenGen will remain as a dominant power generation player in a long term. KenGen is listed at the Nairobi Stock Exchange, with 70 % of shareholder being GoK and 30 % of shareholders private. 3) Kenya Power Kenya Power is renamed from the Kenya Power and Lighting Company (KPLC) in 2011. It is responsible for electricity transmission and all distribution systems in Kenya. The transmission system is composed of 220 kV, 132 kV and 66 kV transmission lines. The National Social Security Fund (NSSF) and GoK own 50.1 % of the stocks, whereas private shareholders own 49.9%. 4) IPPs IPPs are essentially private investors in the power sector for generation. Among the active IPPs, there are IberAfrica, Tsavo, Or-power, Rabai, Imenti and Mumias. They account for about 28 % of the countrys installed capacity. 5) KETRACO KETRACO was founded in 2008 with a full capital investment by GOK. KETRACO has responsible to plan, design, construct, own, operate and maintain new 132 kV and above voltage electricity transmission infrastructure. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 53 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 6) GDC GDC is a state corporation owned 100 % by GOK. GDC is tasked with developing steam fields to reduce upstream power development risks so as to promote rapid development of geothermal electric power. GDC will underwrite any dry wells sunk by private developers selected through competitive bidding processes. 7) REA REA was established in 2007 to accelerate the implementation pace of the Rural Electrification Programme, which is one of the most important challenges of the government. The rural customers have increased from 133,047 in 2007 to 251,056 in 2010. 8) ERC ERC is responsible for establish both technical and economical regulations of the energy sector. ERC settles disputes between stakeholders, sets tariff system of Kenya Power, coordinates energy plan and monitors the sector regulations. The Ministry of Energy (MOE) The Energy Regulatory Commision (ERC) Rural Electrification Authority (REA) The Kenya Electricity Generating Company (KenGen) Independent Power Producers (IPPs) Kenya Electricity Transmission Company (KETRACO) Kenya Power Geothermal Development Company (GDC) Makes energy policies and provides a long term vision Electricity Generation Electricity Transmission Electricity Distribution Sets tariff system, coordinates energy plans and monitors regulations
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.19 Power Sector in Kenya Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 54 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (2) Power Demand and Supply 1) Power Demand and Supply in Kenya During the 2011/12 financial year, the number of customers for Kenya Power has exceeded 2,000,000. This was achieved by an increase of customers in 2011/12 of about 285,000, or 16 % from the previous year. Kenya Power aims at connecting new 300,000 customers every year, so the record was close to the target, although it was not achieved to the target. Electricity total sales increased every year as well as the number of customers. This is because of increased number of customers and electricity consumption despite the increased system losses. Especially, system losses of 2011/12 financial year rose by 1.1 % from previous year. The cause of the rise depends on large area expansion of the electricity distribution networks and increased transmission of electricity from the newly constructed Kipevu III generation plant in Coast area. System peak demand increased to 1,236 MW in 2011/12 financial year. According to an official of Kenya Power, system peak demand exceeded 1,350 MW in March, 2013. Table 4.2.12 Power Demand and Supply in Kenya 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 Number of Customers 924,329 1,060,383 1,267,198 1,463,639 1,753,348 2,038,625 % increase of Number of Customers 15.2% 14.7% 19.5% 15.5% 19.8% 16.3% SALES - Kenya Power System(GWh) 4,771 5,036 5,155 5,318 5,785 5,991 - Rural Electrification Programme (REP) System(GWh) 221 240 250 279 307 308 - Export to Uganda (GWh) 73 46 27 26 30 41 - Export to Tanesco (GWh) 0 0 0 1 1 1 TOTAL SALES (GWh) 5,065 5,322 5,432 5,624 6,123 6,341 SystemLosses (GWh) 1,104 1,062 1,057 1,068 1,180 1,329 Sales % of Energy Purchased 82.1% 83.4% 83.7% 84.0% 83.8% 82.7% Losses as % of Energy Purchased 17.9% 16.6% 16.3% 16.0% 16.2% 17.3% System Peak Demand (MW) 987 1,044 1,072 1,107 1,194 1,236 Source: Kenya Power Annual Report and financial Statements 2012 2) Power Demand and Supply in Nairobi Region Table 4.2.13 shows number of customers, total sales and maximum demand in Nairobi city. The number of customers in Nairobi has increased by more than 100,000 annually from 2009/10 financial year. Moreover, according to New Connections Report 2012 to 2013 of Kenya Power, the number of customers in Nairobi recorded 1,062,329 in April, 2013. On the other hand, the latest data of total sales in Nairobi region experienced a slight decrease from the previous year. This is probably because poor rainfall resulted in a reduction in hydro generation in the first half of 2011/12 financial year, and thus suppressed the sales. Table 4.2.14 shows the sales by tariff type. From the table, the sale for domestic in 2011/12 financial year decreased from previous year. Also the sales for small commercial and large commercial and industrial road (11 kV) decreased. Table 4.2.13 Power Demand and Supply in Nairobi Region Nairobi Region 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 Number of Customers 445,595 505,414 595,010 669,128 814,251 921,548 Total Sales (GWh) 2,595 2,782 2,950 3,071 3,332 3,290 MaximumDemand (MW) 522 548 568 588 623 662 Source: Kenya Power Annual Report and financial Statements 2012 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 55 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Hydro 46.9% Geothermal 12.5% Wind 0.3% Thermal 38.8% Cogeneration 1.5% Source: Kenya Power Annual Report and financial Statements 2012 Figure 4.2.20 Classification of Power Plants by Installed Capacity Table 4.2.14 Sales for Type of Customers Covered by Tariff Tariff Type of Customers Covered by Tariff (GWh) 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 DC Domestic 800 804 888 841 SC Small Commercial 400 402 435 426 CI1 Large Commercial and Industrial Load ( 415V) 757 752 760 760 CI2 Large Commercial and Industrial Load ( 11kV) 598 652 736 727 CI3 Large Commercial and Industrial Load ( 33kV) 0 3 4 3 CI4 Large Commercial and Industrial Load ( 66kV) 272 326 368 384 CI5 Large Commercial and Industrial Load ( 132kV) 20 31 30 34 IT Off-peak 40 34 36 41 SL Street Lighting 11 11 12 11 R.E.P. Schemes 52 55 63 63 TOTAL 2,950 3,071 3,332 3,290 Source: Kenya Power Annual Report and financial Statements 2012 (3) Power-Generating Facilities Figure 4.2.20 shows the composition of power-generating facilities in Kenya. The ratio is for installed capacity of the facilities and is composed of only total interconnected system. As shown in the Figure, hydro-power occupies 46.9 % of total generation capacity for the main network system. Because of the large portion of hydro-power, seasonal variation of power generation occurs due to amount of rainfall. Table 4.2.15 shows a breakdown of power generating facilities. As shown in the Table, total generation capacity of main network system is 1,680.4 MW as installed capacity and 1,253 MW as actual output capacity. Besides the interconnected system, there are isolated systems mainly in northern part of Kenya. The off-grid installed capacity is totally 10.1 MW. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 56 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.2.15 Power-Generating Facilities Type Name Installed capacity (MW) Effective capacity (MW) Hydro KenGen Tana 20.0 20.0 Kamburu 94.2 90.0 Gitaru 225.0 216.0 Kindaruma 44.0 44.0 Masinga 40.0 40.0 Kiambere 164.0 164.0 Turkwel 106.0 105.0 Sondu Miriu 60.0 60.0 Sangoro 21.2 20.0 Small Hydros 13.7 10.9 Total Hydro 788.1 (46.9%) 769.9 (48.0%) Geothermal KenGen Olkaria I (KenGen) 45.0 44.0 Olkaria II (KenGen) 105.0 101.0 Eburru Hill 2.5 2.2 Olkaria Wellhead OW37 5.0 4.4 IPP OrPower 4 Geothermal 52 48 Total Geothermal 209.5 (12.5%) 199.6 (12.5%) Wind KenGen Ngong 5.3 5.1 IPP Imenti Tea Factory 0.3 0.3 Total Wind 5.6 (0.3%) 5.4 (0.3%) Thermal KenGen Kipevu I Diesel 75.0 60.0 Kipevu III Diesel 115.0 115.0 Embakasi Gas Turbines 60.0 27.0 Garissa & Lamu 8.7 7.3 IPP Iberafrica 108.5 108.5 Tsavo 74.0 74.0 Rabai Power 90.0 90.0 Emergency Aggreko energy to Kenyan Market 120 120 Total Thermal 651.2 (38.8%) 601.8 (37.5%) Cogeneration IPP Mumias Cogeneration 26 (1.5%) 26 (1.6%) Total Interconnected System 1,680.4 (100%) 1,602.7 (100%) Off-grid Stations KenGen Thermal 9.4 8.5 Solar 0.6 0 Wind 0.1 0 Total Off-grid Capacity 10.1 8.5 Gross Capacity 1690.5 1,611.2 Source: Kenya Power Annual Report and financial Statements 2012 (4) Power Transmission and Distribution Networks 1) Reliability of Power in Nairobi city Nairobi region is one of areas with unreliable electricity. Table 4.2.16 shows blackout incidence by sub region. The column of target as on 29 th April, 2013 in the Table shows objective number of incidences from 1 st to 29 th April, 2013. Incidences per 1000 customers as on 29 th April, 2013, shows the comparison; Nairobi North and Nairobi West are particularly higher than other regions, as well as Nairobi South is high. According to the Table, the current condition of power quality in Nairobi is the worst of the regions. In many cases, blackout occurred when a tree touches a distribution line or an uprooting tree makes disconnecting. Based on this, Kenya Power has been making effort to deliver adequate and reliable power to Nairobi and other regions. During 2011/12 financial year, under the Energy Sector Recovery Project, Kenya Power installed modern equipment. Moreover, Kenya Power has been struggled to implement underground cable project as shown in Table.4.2.16. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 57 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Source: J ICA Study Team Figure 4.2.22 Countermeasure for Vandalism Table 4.2.16 Daily Monitoring of Blackout Incidence Sub Region Target Actual (All Incidences) Incidences per 1000 Customers % Variance Nairobi North 1,236 6,256 14.68 -406.1 % Nairobi West 773 3,025 11.35 -291.3 % Nairobi South 1,072 2,323 6.29 -116.8 % Coast 700 1,023 4.24 -46.1 % Central Rift 536 409 2.21 23.7 % North Rift 369 541 4.25 -46.4 % West Kenya 729 1,774 7.06 -143.4 % Mt. Kenya North 610 764 3.63 -25.3 % Mt. Kenya South 444 844 5.51 -90.0 % TOTAL 6,469 16,959 7.60 -162.1 % Source: Kenya Power (As on 29 th April, 2013)
0.00 2.00 4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 Nairobi North Nairobi West Nairobi South Coast Central Rift North Rift West Kenya Mt. Kenya North Mt. Kenya South
Source: Kenya Power Figure 4.2.21 Incidences per 1,000 Customers as on 29 th April, 2013 Table 4.2.17 Underground Cable Projects Description Cost (Million US $) Nairobi CBD overhead lines 7.99 Nairobi Upper Hill & Westlands 15.98 Kileleshwa & Kilimani areas 26.63 Nairobi Industrial & Lavington areas 53.27 Nairobi Eastlands 66.58 Mombasa Island Converl all o/h lines & secondary transformers 18.64 Kisumu city Centre 13.32 Thika town 21.31 Nakura city centre 10.65 Nyeri city centre 10.65 TOTAL 255.68 Source: Project Proposal for Possible Funding by Financing Institutions (KPLC) 2) Securing Distribution Networks In Nairobi city, vandalism to the electricity system such as stealing electricity, stealing oil or copper from transformers and eventually stealing transformers themselves sometimes happen. As countermeasures for vandalism, Kenya Power has been executing some preventive measures such as police patrols, spot-welding, reinforcement and relocation of transformers to safe areas, and installation of electronic burglar alarms. Figure 4.2.22 is a picture of a countermeasure for vandalism for a transformer. A ring-shaped 11 kV naked Ring of 11 kV Naked Electric Wire Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 58 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya electric wire is installed above the transformer. Moreover during 2011/12 financial year, penalty for the vandalism became strict i.e., a jail term of 10 years, and/or a fine of Shs.5 million. At present, underground cable projects for distribution line have been proceeding, therefore these project contribute to restrain vandalism. (5) Tariff System Table 4.2.18 shows the tariff system of Kenya Power, which was revised in J une 2008 and has been applied to date. Besides the tariff system, customers need to pay for new connection. For example, low voltage connection for customers within 600 meters from transformer costs Ksh. 35,000 for single phase and Ksh. 45,000 for three phases. In order to connect customers more easily, Kenya Power sets loan funding option called stima loan. As well as stima loan, Equity Bank operates loan for electricity connection. Table 4.2.18 Retail Electricity Tariffs Structure Tariff Type of Customer Supply Voltage (V) Consumption (kWh/month) Fixed Charge (KSh/month) Energy Charge (KSh/kWh) Demand Charge (KSh/kVA/month) DC Domestic Consumers 240 or 415 0 - 50 120.00 2.00 - 51 - 1,500 8.10 Over 1,500 18.57 SC Small Commercial 240 or 415 Up to 15,000 120.00 8.96 - CI1 Commercial/ Industrial 415 - 3 phase Over 15,000 No limit 800.00 5.75 600.00 CI2 11,000 2,500.00 4.73 400.00 CI3 33,000 / 40,000 2,900.00 4.49 200.00 CI4 66,000 4,200.00 4.25 170.00 CI5 132,000 11,000.00 4.10 170.00 IT Interruptible Off-Peak supplies 240 or 415 Up to 15,000 120.00 4.85 - 240.00 when used with DC or SC SL Street Lighting 240 - 120.00 7.50 - Source: Updated Retail tariffs Application to Energy Regulatory Commission Updated Version Dated 7th Feb, 2013 (ERC) (6) Relationship between Kenya Power and Nairobi city In the power sector, Kenya Power has the closest relationship to Nairobi city. From an interview to an official of Kenya Power, following arrangement are said to be in existence as some examples between Kenya Power and Nairobi city. (i) Kenya Power can cut a branch of a tree if the branch is within 3 meter from a distribution line. However, it has to pay Ksh. 1,000 to Nairobi city. (ii) When distribution network connects to customers, Kenya Power has to pay Ksh 1,000 to Nairobi city. (iii) If distribution facilities need to remove for the road maintenance and improvement, Nairobi city pay has to pay the removal cost for Kenya Power. On the other hand, if Kenya Power installs them in Nairobi city, Kenya Power needs to pay to Nairobi city. Besides this arrangement, if Nairobi city has a plan of constructing a new road, it needs to inform Kenya Power of the plan. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 59 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (7) Existing Demand Forecast and Existing Future Plan The Kenyan power sector has been preparing the Least Cost Power Development Plan (LCPDP) as the power sector planning for 20 years. Kenyas power generation and transmission system planning is undertaken on the basis of LCPDP which is in consideration of Kenya Vision 2030. 1) Existing Demand Forecast LCPDP describes demand forecasts from 2010 to 2031, as shown in Figure 4.2.23. The three scenarios depend on some factors. These are calculated by using Model for Analysis of Energy Demand (MAED). Kenya Vision 2030 assumes some projects as vision 2030 flagship projects such as special economic zones, light rail for Nairobi and suburbs and resort cities. Besides calculation of MAED, the demand forecasts are added to the demand of vision 2030 flagship projects. Among the three scenarios, most of the assumptions adopted for the reference case and the reference scenario demand were used for analysis of future plan in LCPDP. In the case of the reference scenario, the peak demand at 2030 is about 12 times of 2011/12 financial year. 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 2 0 1 0 2 0 1 2 2 0 1 4 2 0 1 6 2 0 1 8 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 2 2 0 2 4 2 0 2 6 2 0 2 8 2 0 3 0 P e a k
L o a d
F o r e c a s t
( M W ) Year High Scenario Reference Scenario Low Scenario
Source: Updated Least Cost Power Development Plan Study Period: 2010 - 2031 Figure 4.2.23 Demand Forecast from 2010 to 2031 Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 60 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 2) Existing Demand Forecast 0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 2 0 1 0 2 0 1 2 2 0 1 4 2 0 1 6 2 0 1 8 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 2 2 0 2 4 2 0 2 6 2 0 2 8 2 0 3 0 Year Future Generation Capacity and Peak Demand (MW) Import MSD Coal Gas Turbine Cogeneration Wind Geothermal Nuclear Hydro Peak Demand
Source: Updated Least Cost Power Development Plan Study Period: 2010 - 2031 Figure 4.2.24 Least Cost Expansion Plan and Peak Demand LCPDP has the generation planning until 2031 as the least cost expansion plan. This planning is simulated by using Wien Automatic Simulation Package (WASP) and presumes the demand of reference scenario. Figure 4.2.24 shows the future generation capacity as the least cost expansion plan in the country. In the Figure, the reference scenario demand is also shown. The plan in 2031 indicates 5 % from hydro plants, 19 % from nuclear plants, 26 % from geothermal plants, 11 % from gas turbines, 12 % from coal plants, 9 % from medium speed diesel (MSD) and 9 % from imports. (8) Future Issues Technical Working Group held a meeting concerning the power sector on 6 th May, 2013. In accordance with the meeting, Technical Working Group plans: (i) To discuss what information is shared, who share the information and how to share the information. This is because that power sector is closely related to other sectors such as road, railway, airport, water supply, wastewater and telecommunication. Therefore NCC hopes that information of power sector need shall be shared among the concerned sectors. (ii) To get GIS data of the distribution facilities for grasping the situation and for future land use plan. NCC is notable to overview the current condition of distribution facilities in Nairobi city. (iii) To study electricity cost to save it. NCC is not satisfied with the relatively high electricity cost for street lighting, because the lighting is not for commercial activities but for the safety of citizens. (iv) To discuss the possibility that NCC owns its own facilities to generate electricity power for sale as IPP with cooperation of Kenya Power or other companies of power sector. (v) To identify a gap between existing demand forecast and proposed demand forecast based on the master plan of this project. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 61 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4.2.7 Solid Waste Management (1) Overall Waste Management in Nairobi County The County Council of Nairobi (CCN) has the responsibility of Solid Waste Management (SWM) in Nairobi county. Department of Environment (DOE) in CCN collects the solid waste by themselves or contract out with private company. On the other hand, private company collects the solid waste through the contract with households or public or private enterprises. The collected waste is transported into Dandora landfill site or other dumping sites. Some of the collected waste is illegally dumped. There are some area cannot be collected by CCN or private company due to not enough wide access road. In this area, CBO collected the waste. The waste flow from generation source to final disposal site is shown in Figure 4.2.25. Household waste 1318 t/day Commercial waste 439 t/day Market waste 90 t/day Self disposal 175 t/day Collected 609 t/day Final disposal 603 t/day Illegal dumping Diverted 85 t/day 73 t/day 6 t/day 990 t/day
Source: J ICA Survey Team(J ST) prepared based on the data of J ICA Preparatory Survey for Integrated Solid Waste Management (2010) Figure 4.2.25 Solid Waste Flow in Nairobi County (2009) The facilities related to solid waste management and management situation are shown in Figure 4.2.26.
Source: J ICA Survey Team(J ST) Figure 4.2.26 Facilities related to Solid Waste Management Dandora landfill site Kayole temporary dumping site Maintenance workshop of CCN Parking space of collection vehicle Candidate landfill site in J uja Candidate landfill site in Ruai Candidate landfill site in Mavoko Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 62 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (2) Legal Framework 1) Policy Kenya Vision 2030 provides the development direction toward 2030 including the necessity of sustainable growth in Kenya. In the vision, the Solid Waste Management System Initiative as flagship project is raised and relocation of Dandora dump site and the development of solid waste management systems in 5 leading municipalities have been proposed. 2) Law and Regulation Environmental Management Coordination Act (EMCA, 2006) is an Act of parliament to provide for the establishment of an appropriate legal and institutional framework for the management of the environment including solid waste management. The Local Government Act (Cap 265 of Laws of Kenya) is one of the Acts in Kenya that establishes and governs Local Authorities. The Act spells out responsibility, jurisdiction, powers and functions of local authorities. Most functions related to SWM are undertaken by local authorities such as collection, transportation and disposal of solid waste. According to this Act, decision making powers rest with council members as policy makers. Basic by-law of solid waste management in CCN is City Council of Nairobi (Solid Waste Management) By-law of 2007. The by-law describes the role and responsibility of CCN for solid waste management. 3) Guideline There are guidelines related private sector participations and license application of the company related to solid waste management including transportation, incinerator, landfill, recycling, transfer station, etc. However, there is no technical guideline for solid waste management or facility operation. (3) Organization Structure National Environmental Management Authority has the regulatory body of SWM in national level. The Department of Environment (DOE) in CCN is in charge of the implementation of SWM in Nairobi County. The cleansing section in DOE has the responsibility of SWM. In addition, the DOE also has the responsibility of EIA auditing and environmental conservation in CCN. The section of park section has the responsibility of conservation of green area and maintenance of park recreation and nurseries. The section of environmental management and planning has the responsibility of public awareness and environmental management and monitoring. The organization structure of DOE is shown in Figure 4.2.27 and Table 4.2.19.
Source: DOE Figure 4.2.27 Organization Structure of Department of Environment Table 4.2.19 Number of Staff in each Section Administration office Environment Management & Planning Cleansing Park Total 25 39 465 117 648 Source: DOE Director of Environment
Deputy Director of Environment (Operation)
Deputy Director of Environment (Policy &Planning) Administration Office Assistant Director (Parks Section) Assistant Director (Cleansing Section) Assistant Director (Environment Management &Planning Section) Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 63 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (4) Waste Generation J ICA Preparatory Survey for Integrated Solid Waste Management in Nairobi City (2010) (hereafter J ICA SWM Survey in 2010) implemented solid waste amount and characterization survey in the area of CCN. 1) Amount of waste generation The latest data related to the amount of waste generation is survey data in 2009 as shown in Table 4.2.20. According the data, the total amount of solid waste is estimated as 1848 t/day and more than 60% of the total waste is generated from residential source. Table 4.2.20 Amount of Waste Generation Generation source Number [person or establishment] Unit generation rate [kg/day/number] Total [kg/day] Residential High income 397.362 0.621 246,635 Middle income 1,066,393 0.474 505,076 Low income 1,576,245 0.360 566,670 Commercial Shop 47,941 0.5 23,970.5 Restaurant 1,582 38 60,116 Standard hotels 140 350 49,000 Lodging house 586 100 58,600 Public facilities 500 137 68,500 School 2,847 32 91,104 Industrial plant 501 150 75,150 Other establishment 27,077 0.5 13,538 Market 44 2045 90,000 Street 563.3 106 (60,000) Total 1,848 t/day Source: J ICA Preparatory Survey for Integrated Solid Waste Management in Nairobi City (2010) 2) Characterization of waste As the waste characterization in Nairobi county, the survey data in 2009 is latest one. The most recent data of physical composition in Nairobi county is the shown in Figure 4.2.28. According to the figure, more than 60% of total waste is food waste which occupies the high portion in the solid waste. As for three contents including moisture contents, ash, combustible, high value of moisture content was confirmed like 65 to 80% residential, restaurant, hotel or market except the generation sources such as shop or public facilities. 63.80% 13.80% 10.50% 0.60% 1.40% 0.90% 0.80% 1.50% 0.90% 4.70% 1.10% Food waste Paper Plastic Rubber and leather Textile Yard waste Woods Glass Metal Stone, sand Others
Source: J ICA SWM Survey (2010) Figure 4.2.28 Physical Composition of Waste in Nairobi Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 64 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (5) Collection and Transportation The collection and transportation of solid waste is implemented by DOE, the private companies contracted with DOE, Private Service Providers (PSPs) and Community Based Organizations (CBOs). As for the collection service provided by CCN, the operation method is basically station type collection. The operation team being composed of 1 supervisor, 3 collectors and 1 diver collects the waste. The maintenance activity to repair the collection vehicle is carried out in CCN transport depot. Regarding the service provided by the private companies contracted with CCN, most of companies have 3 to 5 collection vehicles and a half of vehicles have tipping function and they collect the waste from station including the collection points transported by CBO which collect by hand cart as primary collection. Regarding the service by PSPs, operation scale is different from each PSP. Some PSP only is small company which has only one collection vehicle but other PSPs are large companies which have more than 20 collection vehicles. Some of collection vehicles of PSPs do not have tipping function, and this causes inefficient unloading activity. The collection time is 24 hours for CCN, and 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. for private contractors with CCN and Private Service Providers (PSPs) to prevent their illegal dumping activities. Therefore, they have to transport solid waste during daytime when road is congested. Overall collection system in Nairobi county for each organization is envisaged as Table 4.2.21. Table 4.2.21 Collection System in Nairobi county Organization Service area Collection method Equipment CCN CBD, Districts Station type: common Door to door: very rare Trucks with tipping function Private company contracted with CCN Districts Station type Trucks with / without tipping function Private service provider Middle and high income residential area Door to door Trucks without tipping function CBOs and local youth group Slum and low income areas Door to door Handcart Source: J ICA Survey Team(J ST) based on the field survey and hearing fromDOE The total amount of collected waste is shown in Table 4.2.22. Table 4.2.22 Collected Waste in Nairobi Year CCN Contractor PSP Total 2008 9.4 t/day 398.0 t/day 121.9 t/day 529.3 t/day 2009 29.6 t/day 446.5 t/day 132.2 t/day 608.4 t/day Source: DOE The collection rate of solid waste is approximately 33% in 2009 according to DOE and the remaining waste is presumed to be illegally dumped or self-disposed at generation source. There are many illegal dumping sites in Nairobi county. In the area where waste is not collected such as low income area or Waste picking activity during unloading of waste fromcollection vehicle Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 65 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya no access road area, illegal dump occurs. As another case, even though CBO collects the waste to collection points where CCN or the private company contracted with CBO will collect, the situation is sometimes similar to illegal dumping due to improper discharge manner, low frequency collection or no containers in collection points. There is another case that private company such as the company contracted with CCN or PSP is illegally dumped. To prevent such illegal dumping, it is necessary to enforce the institutional system, to implement inspection and monitoring, to prepare suitable collection points and system and to implement environmental education for staffs related to SWM as well as for waste dischargers such as residents and business establishment. (6) Reduce, Reuse and Recycle (3R) As for reduction of waste, the campaign for environmental education for waste reduction is rare. Waste reduction is naturally carried out through daily life in low income area. However, it is necessary to set up the campaign for environmental education for waste reduction activities by CCN to promote waste reduction. As for reuse of waste, there are some secondhand shops which handle secondhand clothes, shoes or electrics. Some people use the secondhand shops. In addition, the people living of low income carry out reuse as normal daily activity. As for recycle of waste, the collection of recyclable waste in Nairobi mainly has three major flows. First is the flow that discharged waste is collected by waste pickers in town and sold to junk buyers. Second is the flow that waste collection workers collect recyclable material during waste collection vehicles. Third is the flow that recyclable waste is collected by waste pickers in dumping sites including Dandora landfill site. There is no separate collection system or sorting facilities in Nairobi. 3R activity is operated in unofficial basis but so many waste pickers are engaged in waste picking activities. In addition, there are many CBOs which implement the collection of recyclable during the waste collection activities with some environmental education related to the separation of recyclable. In the J ICA SWM Survey (2010), they tried to identify the flow of recyclable waste and compostable waste. The amount of recyclable estimated in the Study is shown in Table 4.2.23. Table 4.2.23 Amount of Recyclable Recyclable material Recyclable material handled by Junk buyer / brokers [t/day] Recyclable material handled by Recyclers/Factory [t/day] Recyclable 6.07 23 Plastics 4.99 8 Glass 2.27 50 Scrap metal 6.45 67 Others 0.41 - Total 20.19 148 Source: J ICA SWM Survey (2010) However, as shown in above the table, the amount of recyclable handled in junk buyer is less than the amount of recyclable handled in factories, which indicates that it is so difficult to identify the recycling flow in Nairobi county, especially the condition of the recyclable handled in junk buyer. There is no monitoring system for this activity. Illegal dumping site in low income area and waste pickers who collect recyclables Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 66 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (7) Final Disposal Main treatment and disposal method in Nairobi is final disposal and there is a official landfill site in Dandora currently. However, there are many illegal dumping sites where the private contractors contracted with CCN and PSPs sometimes dispose. The information of current official landfill site and temporary dump site are shown Table 4.2.24. Table 4.2.24 Dumping Sites in Nairobi County Name Zone Area [ha] Planed service period Present condition Dandora landfill site Embakasi 46 1981- Open dumping and no supervision of waste pickers. Bad access and inland road Kayole temporary dumpsite Embakasi 4 2009- Area is historical quarry area. Currently open dumping and there are some waste pickers. Source: J ICA Survey Team(J ST) based on the information fromDOE Dandora dumping site is only the official landfill site in Nairobi currently. However, the operation of disposal in Dandora dumping site is open dumping, which means that there is no soil covering. This is located in 7.5 km away toward northeast side from city center. The operation of the landfill site began at 1981 and the total area is approximately 46 ha. Total amount of disposed waste is approximately estimated as 3,550,000 t/day, according to DOE. There are many waste pickers who carry out waste picking activities during unloading operation from collection vehicles such as the following picture and spreading activities by landfill equipment. The condition of access road is muddy and bad condition, especially in rainy season. Therefore, the unloading area is different from climate condition, and collection vehicles are pulled by bulldozers when they get stuck in muddy area in the access road during rainy season.
The management of Dandora dumping site is carried out by the cleansing section in DOE. The landfill operation is carried out by 2 bulldozers and 1 excavator through the contract with a private company. Due to the unsanitary operation condition of Dandora dumping site, CCN considers the development of new landfill site in or near Nairobi county. Though J ICA preparatory study for Nairobi Solid Waste Management Project (2012) has been conducted for Ruai candidate landfill site for landfill but due to the issue of bird strike to airplane, the location of Ruai for new landfill site has been opposed by Civil Aviation Authority (CAA). Currently, DOE also consider the other options such as another location of landfill site or other technical options. Waste picking activity during unloading of waste fromcollection vehicle Waste picking activity during spreading of waste by excavator Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 67 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya (8) Financial Aspect 1) Financial condition Currently, the revenue and expenditure of DOE was based on the system of general budget in CCN. Based on J ICA SWM Survey (2010) proposed the special budget for SWM as well as the establishment of Solid Waste Public Corporation (SWPC). According to DOE, the budget for SWM is 10% to 50%, which is fluctuated in the situation of county budget. Generally, the budget for SWM is not prioritized in comparison with other sectors. This causes no payment for the private contractors for collection and transportation and landfill operation. The latest data of financial condition provided by DOE is shown in Table 4.2.25. Table 4.2.25 Financial Condition of CCN and DOE Year Revenue (CCN) [KSh] Expenditure (CCN) [KSh] Expenditure (DOE) [KSh] Expenditure (Solid Waste Management) [KSh] 2009/2010 8,612,928,000 9,951,002,000 544,217,000 356,091,000 Source: DOE 2) Waste collection service charge i) CNC Regarding business establishments, they are categorized into around 80 groups and the rates of charges per ton are classified into 5 classes like 100, 200, 320, 420, 500 KSh. In addition, 1000 KSh is set for supermarkets and 1500 KSh is set for post offices, banks and courts and 3000 KSh is set for other institutions and 5000 KSh is set for hotels. In fact, the collection rate is less than 35%. The collection and transportation service will be suspended in case of no payment by them, it might cause illegal dumping. Regarding households, 10 KSh of waste collection service charge had been previously collected with the water supply service. After the privatization of water supply service to the Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company Limited (NCWSC) in 2003, the collection was suspended. In this moment, DOE provide the service for households by the revenue from general budget. ii) Private Service Provider (PSP) The licensed PSPs collect the waste collection service charge directly from waste generators such as households or business establishments. They mainly collect solid waste in high income and middle income areas which is efficient to obtain the profit. The rates are not fixed in Nairibi County and depend on the business strategy of PSP. Then, the waste generators in low and middle income areas cannot receive the collection service from PSPs. 3) Supervision of PSPs and CBOs DOE have responsibilities of supervision of PSPs and CBOs. There are the lists of supervision of PSPs and CBOs related to SWM registered by National Environment Management Authority (NEMA). However, there is no comprehensive information of contract condition with waste discharger of PSPs and CBOs as well as their financial conditions. Then, it is so difficult to supervise the activities of PSPs and CBOs. It might cause the illegal activities by PSPs. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 68 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 4.2.8 Telecommunications (1) Regulatory Bodies and Their Roles The Telecommunications policy in Kenya is formulated by the Ministry of Information, Communication and Technology (MOICT), with the Communications Commission of Kenya (CCK) acting as its overseeing body (established in 1998, following the Kenya Information Communications Act). Also, Kenya Vision 2030 stipulates the strategic guidelines for the ICT sector, with a target to raise Kenyas GDP to the world average. CCKs scope of authority is as follows: i) granting operating licenses, ii) controlling service changes, iii) assignment of frequencies and telephone numbers, iv) managing the universal service fund, v) protection of end users and vi) issuing technical standards and equipment type approvals. The Kenya Information Communications Act (1998) regulates the establishment of CCK and sets the regulatory framework for the telecommunications sector and the license application procedures. In 2008, following global trends, CCK made a decision to issue telecommunications licenses in three categories: i) telecommunications infrastructure, ii) application services and iii) contents services. As of 2012, there were 29 licensed operators for infrastructure, 92 for application and 140 for contents. The Kenyan governments telecommunications policy features privatization, interoperable connections (interconnection), and mobile number portability. In 2007, Telkom Kenya, a state owned operator was privatized by the Consortium of France Telecom and Alcazar Capital Limiteds acquiring 51% of its stock shares. The above policy is one of the measures to create a competitive environment in the telecommunications sector. Since 2009, fixed and mobile operators have been required to provide interoperable domestic connections. In 2011, Telekom Kenya and Safaricom were designated by CCK as major operators. In 2010, CCK carried out a 50% reduction in interoperable connection charges and a further cut of 40% is scheduled by 2014. In 2011, Kenya Network Information Center (KENIC), controlled by Porting Access Kenya, started its mobile number portability service. The number of service users stood at 36,224 for the first quarter of 2012. Another notable feature of the telecommunications policy targets information and communication technology (ICT). In line with the Kenya Vision 2030 objective to raise GDP to the international average by the year 2030, MOICT announced its ICT Policy Guideline in 2011, with the aim of providing broadband connection to last one mile users and ICT services at schools and public institutions nationwide by 2015. (2) Current Condition of Telecommunications This section describes current conditions of fixed/mobile telecommunication, broadcast and postal/ courier services. 1) Fixed/mobile telecommunications/Internet Figure 4.2.29 shows the number of fixed and mobile users. In 2011/12, there was a rapid growth of mobile users against a decline of 30% in the number of fixed subscribers from the previous fiscal year. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 69 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 12,934 17,362 20,119 25,280 29,703 527 697 460 379 263 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 N u m b e r
o f
U s e r s
( 1 0 0 0
u s e r s ) Year number of mobile users number of fixed users
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on CCK Annual Report 2011/12 Figure 4.2.29 Number of Fixed and Mobile Users in Kenya A clear contrast is observed in Figure 4.2.30 indicating the fixed-telephone and mobile penetration ratio per 100 inhabitants. Between 2007 and 2011, the fixed-telephone penetration ratio was close to 1% and had a year on year decreasing tendency. On the other hand, mobile penetration increased from 30% up to 65% in the same period, which leads to the conclusion that most telephone users in Kenya are mobile users. 30.3 42.4 49.1 61.6 67.5 1.2 1.7 1.7 0.9 0.7 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 P e n e t r a t i o n ( % ) Year mobile penetration fixed penetration
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on ITU (International Telecommunication Union) statistics Figure 4.2.30 Proportion of Fixed and Mobile Telephones in Kenya Over 98 % of the internet subscribers have been mobile users since 2009/10 and over 50% of the internet users accessed the internet through their mobile handsets in 2011/12 as shown in Table 4.2.26. On the other hand, fixed line internet users make up less than 1 % of the internet subscribers even as the number of fiber optic users is increasing rapidly. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 70 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.2.26 Subscriptions of Internet Users Fiscal Year 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 May 2013 Terrestrial Mobile Data/Internet Subscription 1,562,065 3,059,906 4,189,720 7,655,576 9,589,851 Terrestrial Wireless Data/Internet Subscription 8,602 22,134 29,979 21,709 24,011 Satellite Data/Internet Subscription 26 953 960 519 727 Fixed Digital Subscriber Line(DSL) Data/Internet Subscription 7,822 9,631 15,168 11,682 10.390 Fixed Fiber Optic Data/Internet Subscription 851 4,303 22,460 49,371 55,007 Fixed Cable Modem(Dial Up) Data/Internet Subscription 21 25 - 25 25 Total Internet Subscription 1,824,203 3,096,952 4,258,287 7,738,882 9,680,011 Estimated Internet Users* 3,648,406 7,832,352 12,538,030 14,032,366 16,444,861 Note:* The number of Internet users is estimated by multiplying the number of mobile data/internet subscriptions by 1, the terrestrial wireless subscriptions by 10, and the fixed DSL, fiber optic and satellite subscriptions by 100. There is no scientific method of estimating internet users; for the purpose of this report, the methodology adopted is borrowed from the ITU recommendations and those of the Internet Market Study 2006 carried out by the Commission. Source: CCK Annual Report 2011/12, CCK Sector Statistics Report (3 rd quarter 2012/13)
Broadband subscriptions, with a bandwidth of over 256kbps, are expanding dramatically as shown in Table 4.2.27, although the broadband subscriptions for 2012 represented only about 1.8 % of the population of Kenya. Table 4.2.27 Subscriptions of Broadband Services Fiscal Year 2010/11 2011/12 May 2013 Fixed Broadband (DSL, Satellite and Fiber) 6,552 35,265 N/A Wireless (Wimax) 5,646 17,282 N/A Mobile 108,928 674,255 N/A Total 121,126 726,802 1,178,077 Source: CCK Annual Report 2011/12, CCK Sector Statistics Report (3 rd quarter 2012/13) The penetration ratio of telecommunications per province is presented in the National ICT Survey Report by the Kenya National Bureaus of Statistics and CCK (Table 4.2.28). Fixed-telephone and internet users are concentrated in Nairobi City. The regional gap in the penetration ratio between Nairobi City and the provinces is well recognized. Table 4.2.28 Penetration Ratio of Telecommunications in Nairobi City and the Provinces Province Fixed-telephone (%) Mobile Phone (%) Internet (%) Nairobi 11.9 76.2 28.3 Central 1.4 74.0 7.1 Coast 6.3 50.7 8.4 Eastern 2.0 64.2 4.9 North Eastern 1.2 41.1 3.6 Nyanza 1.8 57.3 5.8 Rift Valley 2.3 58.0 4.7 Western 1.2 49.5 1.5 Source: National ICT Survey Report 2011 J une by Kenya National Bureaus of Statistics and CCK Like almost all developing countries in the field of telecommunications, the rapid growth of mobile users is in stark contrast to the number of fixed line users. Safaricom, Airtel, Telcom Kenya (a.k.a. Orange) and Essar Telecom are major mobile operators in Kenya, covering in all 90% of the population in 2011. In March 2013, the number of mobile users reached 29.8 million nationwide, with a penetration ratio of 69%. More than 99% of mobile users utilized prepaid services. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 71 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Mobile money services called M-Pesa were provided first by Safaricom in 2008 to transfer small amounts of money by mobile phones. The same service is now provided by Orange and Airtel as well. As of March 2013, 23.2 million users which account for 78% of total mobile subscribers used this service. The transaction amount between April and J une 2012 reached 192.7 billion Kenyan Shillings (2.3 billion USD). Regarding internet services, fixed connections are provided by Wananchi Telecom. Kenya Data Network (KDN), Access Kenya and Telkom Kenya, meanwhile mobile connection is provided by Safaricom. The above carriers provide ADSL, FTTx and WiMAX as local access connection. In May 2013, the number of internet users reached 16 million, and 99% of them are accessing mobile internet services through 3G network. In actual reality however, 3G services do not seem to meet specified speed requirements, with less than 10% of mobile internet users being able to access with the maximum speed of 256kbps. Table 4.2.29 Major Operator Category Operator Market Share as of March 2013 Fixed phone subscription TelkomKenya (Orange) N/A Mobile phone subscription M-Pesa Safaricom Airtel Network Kenya Essar TelecomKenya TelkomKenya (Orange) 65.1% 16.9% 10.9% 7.1% Internet subscription (Mobile Data/Internet) Safaricom Airtel Network Kenya TelkomKenya (Orange) Essar TelecomKenya 74.4% 11.2% 8.0% 6.4% Internet subscription (Other Fixed / Wireless Internet) Wananchi Telecom Kenya Data Network (KDN) Access Kenya TelkomKenya Safaricom 35.4% 23.7% 12.9% 11.5% 7.2% Source: J ST based on CCK Sector Statistics Report (3rd Quarter 2012/13) 2) Broadcast i) Radio Kenya Broadcasting Corporation (KBC), the government-managed broadcaster, operates FM radio broadcast and middle-wave radio broadcast throughout the nation in English and Kiswahili for 24 hours. Over 100 FM broadcasters including local broadcasting are also licensed to broadcast. ii) Television KBC broadcasts a nationwide TV program at Channel 1 in English and Kiswahili for averagely 19 hours a day. 17 broadcasters are licensed for commercial broadcasting. Digital terrestrial broadcast commenced in 5 cities including Nairobi on J anuary 2010. Analogue terrestrial broadcast was supposed to be shut off all over the country by 2012. However, the government made a decision to delay the shutoff until 2015 since digital terrestrial broadcast could cover up to 80% of the population as of the end of 2012. For Nairobi area, it was announced to be shut off on December 2013. The operators of digital terrestrial broadcast are Mutlichoice and KBC. Multchoice provides over 50 programs on its fee-TV service named "GOTv". Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 72 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya iii) Satellite Broadcast Multichoice Kenya, a joint venture established by KBC and Multichoice, delivers 13 packages of TV programs through Ku band on Eutelsat W4 which is operated by the European Telecommunications Satellite Organization. It reached 120 thousand subscribers by the end of 2011. iv) Cable Television In October 2010, Wananchi Group launched 10 packages of TV programs and reached 50 thousand subscribers as of May 2011. 3) Postal and Courier Services As of 2012, CCK licenses 190 postal/courier operators, an increase of 14 new postal/courier operators compared with the previous year. This was due to a successful public awareness campaign on postal and courier services regulatory requirements. The postal/courier operators are categorized into 7 types as shown in Table 4.2.30 Table 4.2.30 Number of Licensed Postal and Courier Operators Category of Operators 2007 /08 2008/ 09 2009 /10 2010 /11 2011 /12 Remarks Public Postal Licensee 1 1 1 1 1 Charged with the responsibility of ensuring provision of universal postal services as an obligation (USO) and has the widest international and domestic coverage. International Operators 14 15 12 14 14 Operate internationally with both worldwide and domestic networks. International In-bound Operators 11 11 9 11 13 One-way operators; receiving items fromoverseas for local delivery. Regional Operators 10 11 12 13 13 Major operators within Kenya and within the East African network Intra-country Operators 75 87 91 99 109 Operators within Kenya Intra-city Operators 36 38 33 37 39 Operate within a city/town boundary Document Exchange Operators 1 1 1 1 1 Operate a document mail exchange point for a particular clientele Total 148 164 159 176 190 Source: CCK Annual Report 2011/12, CCK website As shown above, intra-country postal/courier operators remain the largest category of operators, accounting for 57.3% of the total number of licensed operators. This is followed by the intra-city operators that account for 20.5%. Furthermore, the postal and courier market segment continues to register positive growth in respect to network development and this brings the operators into further competition. (3) Spread of ICT equipment in government offices 1) Nairobi City County (NCC) According to a computer inventory list in 2011 prepared by ICT department of the city county, the total number of computers is 668. Among them, desktop computers account for 627 and laptop computer for 41. The number of printers and copiers are 387 and 32 respectively. The number of officers who are recognised to use a computer based on personnel inventory in the human resources department is 4,010, which is more than the number of computers. Thus it is Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 73 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya obvious, that there is a lack of computers in the city county. The computers are for stand-alone use, with no intranet or data server. This makes enhancing information sharing among the offices difficult. Table 4.2.31 Number of ICT equipment and Computer User Equipment Number of sets Officers Number of persons Desktop computer 627 Total Number of Officers (approximately) 11,000 Laptop computer 41 Clerical Officers 1,115 Printer 387 Technical Officers 309 Copier 32 Officers recognised to use a computer 4,010 Source: Computer Inventory List (ICT dept. of NCC), Hearing Survey (Human Resource dept. of NCC) Communication among officers is primarily conducted through the officers' private mobiles. The NCC headquarters internal line system have not worked for internal communications for about 5 years. Most officers started to get their mobile sets at that time for internal use. The only fixed telephones to be found in the offices are broken. Significant business communications are made through letters and some officers use e-mail. Each department has site offices for administrative management purposes. Correspondence between the NCC headquarters and the site offices by letters is prevalent. There are especially few officers using a computer in the site offices. 2) National Government Network The Government Common Core Network (GCCN), the national governmental network, is operated and maintained by the operator Telkom Kenya. The GCCN connects 32 buildings and is shared by national government offices, and is set to be linked with counties through the NOFBI (National Optic Fiber Backbone Infrastructure). The NOFBI is a countrywide fiber optic network implemented by the government and operated and maintained by the operator Telkom Kenya. It connects 29 county headquarters, including Nairobi, in phase I of the project. The government has also formulated an expansion plan for NOFBI in phase II to cover the remaining 18 counties. (4) Strategy 1) Kenya Vision 2030 Kenya Vision 2030, launched in 2008, presents a roadmap for Kenyas transformation into a newly industrializing middle-income country. The Vision is built upon a tripod of economic, social and political pillars. As the ICT regulator for the country, CCK lays out the economic framework through the projects highlighted below; Source: National Broadband Strategy 2013 Figure 4.2.31 NOFBI coverage Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 74 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya i) Migration from analogue to digital broadcasting The government initiative to migrate from analogue to digital broadcasting is a result of the Regional Radio Conference decision (2006, Geneva, Switzerland <RRC-06>) requiring all countries to migrate to the digital platform by 2015. CCK is on the Digital Television Committee that brings together various government bodies for implementation. ii) Information security Cyber security is a key factor in the growth of the ICT sector. CCK established the Kenya Incident Response Team Coordination Centre that serves as the national coordination and collaboration centre for Cyber security management. iii) Facilitate universal access to ICT services CCK is responsible for ensuring that everyone in Kenya has access to affordable communications services. To address the gaps in ICT access across the country, CCK has undertaken pilot projects in certain parts of the country. The projects include the establishment of 16 school-based ICT Centers, four tele-centers and eight centers for persons with disabilities. iv) Fiber Optic Cables CCK has provided licenses for landing four undersea cables into the country. The cables have had a positive impact on internet access speed in the country. CCK, in collaboration with the Kenya ICT Board, developed an informative documentary for public information. 2) National Broadband Strategy for Kenya MOICT, in collaboration with CCK, advocated the development of the National Broad Band Strategy (NBS) with technical assistance from USAIDs Global Broadband Initiative Program. The vision of this Broadband Strategy is to transform Kenya to a knowledge-based society driven by a high capacity nationwide broadband network. NBS cites the following five issues as key to national broadband development: (i) Infrastructure, Connectivity and Devices (ii) Content, Application and Innovation (iii) Capacity Building and Awareness (iv) Policy, Legal and Regulatory Environment (v) Financing and Investment NBSs strategy and its implementation plan for the 5 years from 2013 through 2017 are based on the above fundamentals. As for connectivity, NBS minimum broadband speed forecast targets to meet Kenya Vision 2030 are indicated in Tables 4.2.32 and 4.2.33. Table 4.2.32 Minimum Broadband Speed
2013-2017 2018-2022 2023-2027 2028-2030 Urban 40Mbps 300Mbps 1024Mbps 2048Mbps Rural 5Mbps 50Mbps 100Mbps 500Mbps Source: NBS Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 75 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.2.33 Broadband Penetration Targets
Baseline Target by 2017 % of penetration by households 6.3% 35% % of penetration by schools 43.4% 100% % of penetration by health facilities n/a 100% Source: NBS 3) Strategic Plan for 2008-2013 CCK implemented its first three-year (2005-08) Strategic Plan in line with the 9th National Development Plan (2002-08) and the Economic Recovery Strategy for Wealth and Employment Creation 2003-07 (ERS/ERSWEC). The first Strategic Plan ended on 30th J une, 2008 and the Commission has developed its successor - a comprehensive five-year Strategic Plan that draws from the experience of the first Strategic Plan and takes into account rapid global developments in the sector. The preparation of the 2008-2013 Strategic Plan was carried out in a participatory manner that brought together all departments and units. The previous vision of CCK was to enable access to reliable communications services by all Kenyans. This was re-defined in order to align it with the mission statement and the core function of CCK of facilitating access to communications services. The redefined vision is time-bound in line with the countrys vision to be a middle income state by the year 2030. The communications sector is expected to play a key role in the realization of Vision 2030. Key outputs and outcomes are shown in Table 4.2.34. Table 4.2.34 Key Outputs and Outcomes Outputs Performance indicators Outcomes Mobile operators licensed Broadcasting networks licensed Number of equipment type approved Numbers assigned Frequencies assigned Postal/courier operators licensed Number of licenses issued Timely standard & type approval Number of type approval cases handled Ranges of numbers and access codes assigned Increased access to all varieties of communications services Equipment compatibility and seamless services Better consumer experience Increased investment opportunities. Policies, laws and regulations enforced Tariffs regulated Guidelines issued Timely enforcement of license conditions and regulation of tariffs Fair play License compliance Clear rules Governance improved Reliability Better consumer experience Improved access and connectivity Universal access promoted Levels of penetration New services to the community which result in creation of job opportunities Better consumer experience Interconnection agreements approved Consumer education programs implemented Internal efficiency and effectiveness Quality service Improved and competitive business environment Informed customers Improved image Source: CCK (5) Comparative Position of Kenya 1) Fixed/mobile telecommunication Figure 4.2.32 to Figure 4.2.34 show the percentage of mobile subscriptions, individual internet use and fixed-telephone subscriptions among neighboring countries with Kenya in comparison. Percentage of mobile subscriptions in Kenya is the highest among the countries (Figure 4.2.32) while fixed subscriptions show a decreasing trend (Figure 4.2.34). Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 76 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on ITU statistics Figure 4.2.32 Percentage of Mobile Subscriptions among 4 Countries The increase in internet users in Kenya is particularly notable. With the number of fixed (wired) internet subscribers at 13,959 (ca. 0.04%), and internet use at 14% in 2010, most internet users are, therefore, mobile users. As for the number of broadband subscriptions, although fixed-broadband subscriptions in Kenya jumped from 6,552 in 2011 to 35,265 in 2012, their share per 100 inhabitant is no more than 0.01% in 2010 and 0.10% in 2011, respectively. Most Internet users, therefore, have little choice but to use narrow band internet.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on ITU statistics Figure 4.2.33 Percentage of Individual Internet Use among 4 Countries Fixed-telephone subscription is evidently becoming marginal for communications in Kenya. There will be demand for fixed-telephones in private offices, public institutions - schools, hospitals, police stations, public government etc. However, local access by FTTx optic fiber cable should be developed within the frame of the current plan in order to maintain a certain level of system reliability. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 77 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on ITU statistics Figure 4.2.34 Percentage of Fixed-telephone Subscriptions among 4 Countries Figure 4.2.35 to Figure 4.2.37 compare Kenya globally, as well as with other developed and developing countries 6 on mobile subscriptions, individual internet use and fixed-telephone subscriptions in 2011. Mobile phone ownership and internet access in Kenya closely line up with the global average and that of the developing countries.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on ITU statistics Figure 4.2.35 Penetration Ratio of Mobile Subscriptions in Kenya in a Global Comparison The penetration ratio for individual internet use in Kenya is close to the global ratio and that of the developing countries. A favorable network environment available to users will therefore bring itself a sharp rise in subscribers.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on ITU statistics Figure 4.2.36 Penetration Ratio of Individual Internet Use in Kenya in a Global Comparison 6 The developed/developing country classifications are based on the UN M49, referable URL: http://www.itu.int/ITU-D/ict/definitions/regions/index.html. 0 20 40 60 80 % Developed Developing World Kenya 0 50 100 150 % Developed Developing World Kenya Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 78 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc.
The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya The low penetration ratio of fixed-telephone subscriptions in Kenya stands out compared with the rest of the world. Since this is, however, a result of national policy by Kenya which emphasizes mobile rather than fixed telephones, the low figure does not directly mean vulnerability in the telecommunications infrastructure classified as local access network in outside plant.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on ITU statistics Figure 4.2.37 Penetration Ratio of Fixed-telephone Subscriptions in Kenya in a Global Comparison 2) Broadcast Figure 4.2.38 shows the percentage of households with radio and television in 2009 among neighboring countries with Kenya in comparison. The percentage of households with radio and television of Kenya is the highest among the countries. However, two thirds of all households in Kenya don't own a television.
Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on ITU statistics Figure 4.2.38 Percentage of Household with Radio and Television among 4 Countries 3) Postal and Courier Services Although the number of licensed postal/courier operators in Kenya marks approximately 200 as previously described, those in Tanzania and Uganda respectively account for less than one third of the number of operators in Kenya as shown in Table 4.2.35. In comparison with a difference of population among those counties, there is a great difference of the number of licensed postal/courier operators among neighboring countries. This means that the Kenyan postal/courier services market is more competitive than that of neighboring countries. 0 10 20 30 40 50 % Developed Developing World Kenya N/A Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 79 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya Table 4.2.35 Number of Licensed Posta and Courier Operators among 4 Counties Category of Operators Kenya Tanzania Uganda Ethiopia Public Postal Licensee 1 1 1 1 International Operators 14 5 8 N/A International In-bound Operators 13 - - N/A Regional Operators 13 3 7 N/A Intra-country Operators 109 7 13 N/A Intra-city Operators 39 31 - N/A Document Exchange Operators 1 - - N/A Total 190 47 29 N/A Source: J ICA Study Team(J ST) based on CCK Annual Report 2011/12, Uganda Communications Committee Website, Tanzania Communications regulatory Authority Website and Ethiopian Postal Service Enterprise Website (6) Global Trend of Telecommunications The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) published ICT Facts and Figures which shows continued and almost universal growth in ICT uptake in 2013. Some remarkable topics in this publication are shown below for comparison with the directions of Kenya Vision 2030. 1) In total, 6.8 billion mobile-cellular subscriptions in 2013 The world population in 2013 will be 7.1 billion and the number of mobile subscriptions will be 6.8 billion. Mobile penetration ratios stand at 96% globally, 128% in developed countries and 89% in developing countries. In 2013, mobile penetration ratio in Kenya is estimated at about 80% , which exceeds the total African penetration ratio of 63.5%. 2) In total, 2.7 billion people, almost 40% of the worlds population, are online in 2013 In 2013, over 2.7 billion people are using the Internet, which corresponds to 39% of the worlds population. In the developing world, 31% of the population is online, compared with 77% in the developed world. In Africa, 16% of the population uses the internet, which is only half the penetration ratio of Asia and the Pacific. In 2013, internet penetration in Kenya will reach 70% , far over the African figure and almost at the level of the developed world. 3) Continuous growth of mobile broadband is expected Mobile broadband subscriptions have climbed from 268 million in 2007 to 2.1 billion in 2013. This reflects an average annual growth rate of 40%, making mobile broadband the most dynamic ICT market. In developing countries, the number of mobile broadband subscriptions more than doubled from 2011 to 2013 (from 472 million to 1.16 billion) and surpassed those in developed countries in 2013. Africa is the region with the highest growth rates over the past three years and mobile-broadband penetration has increased from 2% in 2010 to 11% in 2013 which trend is followed by Kenya as well. Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 80 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc. The Project on Integrated Urban Development Master Plan for the City of Nairobi in the Republic of Kenya 24.7 18.8 15.7 11.3 17.7 12.7 11.4 7.5 2.2 1.4 1.3 1.2 Prepaid computer-based (1GB) Postpaid computer-based (1GB) Prepaid handset-based (500MB) Postpaid handset-based (500MB) Price of service as a % of GNI per capita Developed World Developing Source: ITU Figure 4.2.39 Price of Mobile-broadband Services, Early 2013
4) Mobile broadband is much more expensive in developing countries By early 2013, the price of an entry-level mobile-broadband plan represents between 1.2-2.2% of monthly GNI p.c. in developed countries and between 11.3-24.7% in developing countries, depending on the type of service. However, in developing countries, mobile broadband services cost considerably less than fixed-broadband services: 18.8% of monthly GNI p.c. for a 1 GB postpaid computer-based mobile-broadband plan compared to 30.1% of monthly GNI p.c. for a postpaid fixed-broadband plan with 1 GB of data volume. Among the four typical mobile-broadband plans offered in the market, postpaid handset-based services are the cheapest and prepaid computer-based services are the most expensive, across all regions. A regional comparison highlights, that mobile-broadband services remain largely unaffordable in Africa, where the price of a computer-based plan with 1GB of data volume represents on average more than 50% of GNI p.c. This situation can be applied to Kenya as well.
Nippon Koei Co., Ltd. 4 - 81 Final Report (Draft) IDCJ Inc. EJEC Inc.