Change Management Toolkit
Change Management Toolkit
Change Management Toolkit
Management
Toolkit
Office of Organization Development & Training
INTRODUCTION
Managing change is a key component in achieving the organizations goals. For Leaders to be successful they
must effectively manage their employees and themselves through change. These changes can come in many
different forms and can be large or small. They include HopkinsOne, Chronos, new processes, new policies,
etc. Your ability to take concepts and make them reality will determine how successful you will be in your
career. This toolkit was designed to assist in helping you manage these changes.
How to Use This Document
This Change Management Toolkit serves two purposes. The first is to be a reference tool that you can use
when planning how to carry out changes in your organization. It provides much of the newest information in
change management and it provides a step-by-step process to walk you through implementing those changes.
The second purpose is that it gives you the actual tools you can use to plan, to work with your staff, or to work
with your change team. All of this in a one-stop booklet.
Every change does not necessarily need all the steps listed in the book. Many times the initial steps are completed by someone else and it is your job to implement those planned changes. If that is the case, you may enter the process at a later step. Using this toolkit, you may refer to the earlier steps and you will know what occurred to plan those changes. With reports stating anywhere from 50-80% failure rates for change efforts and
the fact that your career hinges on your ability to manage change, this booklet may be one of the most valuable
resources you own.
Appendix: HopkinsOne Background for Managers and Supervisors
Since HopkinsOne is upcoming, the Appendix contains a number of examples of these tools completed for the
HopkinsOne project.
The Strategic View of Change Leadership
Ninety-five percent of this Change Management Toolkit profiles specific tactics to use in managing successful
change. In the next three pages, however, we profile eight elements used by strategic leaders who desire successful strategic change.
Urgency
Coalition
Vision
3. Create a vision
Communication
Empowerment
Wins
Reinforcement
Anchoring
Change
Step
How
Keys to Success
Possible results
from not implementing the step
Establish a sense of
urgency
Complacency
Disowned
Forming a powerful
guiding coalition
Turf protection
Passivity
Creating a
vision
False starts
Misalignment
Communicating the
vision
Confusion
Rumors
Distortion
Empowering others
to act on the vision
Institutionalizing
new approaches
Articulating the connections between the new behaviors and corporate success
Developing the means to ensure
leadership development and succession that could sustain the change
Until change sinks deeply into a companys culture (5-10 years), new approaches are fragile and subject to
regression. Leaders of successful efforts use the credibility of short term
wins to tackle bigger problems.
Subtle sabotage
Half-efforts
Isolation
26
38
65
69
References
92
Section 1
Tool
When to Use
Page
SWOT Analysis Conduct a SWOT analysis when you are beginning a change or
Future State
Analysis
Current State
Analysis
Comparing the Current State with the Future State is the first
step in goal setting. Goals will provide the action steps for taking your organization from the Current State to the Future State.
For most internal changes that are driven from a higher authority, youll either be a part of that process or the current state will
already be determined and handed to you. If you find that is the
case, go to Step 4.
If you are conducting a change independent from a higher authority, you will want to determine your current state. In process changes this may include process diagrams and in other
changes it may involve a written description of the current situation. Dont spend too much time on this since it is based on
how you used to do business.
Tool
When to Use
The Case for Change helps you to clarify what youre hoping
to accomplish with a change initiative and helps provide
speaking points when others (including your employees) ask
why the change is necessary.
Page
Stakeholder
Analysis
Goal Setting
The result of Goal Setting shows how you go from where you
are now to where you want to be. It also provides alignment
for your organization and identifiable steps to get things
started.
Force Field
Analysis
Tool
When to Use
Change Success
Assessment
Page
For all changes, you will need to measure the employees perception of how things are going. You can use the Change
Success Assessment throughout the project.
10
Weaknesses
Opportunities
What developments could negatively affect the future of your department and/or the organization?
What obstacles do you face?
What is your competition doing?
11
STRENGTHS
WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITIES
THREATS
I
N
T
E
R
N
A
L
E
X
T
E
R
N
A
L
12
You develop the Future State first and then your Current State. This is to ensure that reality does not intrude
on your dream...if you have a outstanding idea of how to streamline processes, you surely dont want it budget
concerns to prevent it from even being considered. If an idea is good enough, organizations will find money
for it.
In developing your Current State, provide the reasons why the way things are done now hold the organization
back. In some cases, mapping the current process is quite helpful in illustrating the challenges with current
operations. However, dont spend a lost of time on the Current State since it is based on how you use to do
business.
Hints for developing a Current State:
13
Current State
14
15
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Information
What information do people need in order to see whats going on?
16
el 3
L ev
Emotional Reaction
What will help people feel a sense of urgency?
17
LEADERSHIP TIPS:
THREE LEVELS OF RESISTANCE
There are three levels of resistance that change agents can experience when moving employees through a
change process. The first results from a lack of understanding and may be a result of not having enough or any
information. The second is the emotional reactions employees experience when faced with a perceived loss
(power, job, respect, etc.). The third level, the most threatening to the successful completion of the change effort, results from a lack of trust and confidence in management. Depending on how well your organization
handles the change and the impact the change will have, you may see all, some or none of these levels of resistance.
Lack of information
Disagreement with the idea itself
Lack of exposure
18
Move quickly
Increase communication
Delegate
19
Stakeholder Analysis
Name of Individual or Group
Need for
Support
Likelihood
for
Support
Action Steps
20
Hospital/Health System
Unit Performance
Work Group Performance
Individual Performance
The diagram above illustrates how individual performance provides the foundation for organizational success. Unless you have a clear picture in your mind of the level of the individual performance required from
your employees to reach the organizations goals and objectives, you will be hard pressed to communicate
those expectations. An organization must identify key success factors and measure those factors using its
performance management system.
Goal setting at the individual level is important in achieving the goals of the organization. Specifically, goals
provide focus for the employees efforts. By having established goals, the employee and manager have a
benchmark to measure success.
In any organization, each level has a different set of goals. In a successful organization, all the different goals align to create a thriving
business.
21
S
M
A
R
T
Specific
Measurable
Attainable
Results-Oriented
Time-Oriented
Goals can be broken down into sub-goals or objectives. Attainment of individual objectives will lead to accomplishment of the overall goal. Specific goals state exactly what the organization intends to accomplish.
The following is an example of a non-specific goal:
Non-Specific: We will improve customer service.
This could be better written as:
Specific: We will increase our customer service scores by 5% over the next 12 months by increasing training for front-line staff and monitoring performance via customer satisfaction surveys.
Each specific goal must be evaluated to determine if it is measurable. The above example is a measurable
goal since the organization can track it. The following is a non-measurable goal:
Non-Measurable: We should talk to the employees about reducing expenses.
It could be better written as:
Measurable: We will reduce expenses by 10% by January 1st.
Goals must be attainable and realistic. Employees will lose their motivation in attempting to attain goals that
are set too high. On the other hand, goals set too low will not provide a challenge. The following is an example of a non-attainable goal:
Non-Attainable: We will improve our Employee Satisfaction Survey to 100% for all questions.
A related and attainable goal would be:
Attainable: We will increase our Employee Satisfaction Survey scores to 5% above the present organization average.
Goals that are result-oriented will create standards of performance for each job that impact the overall business objective. An example of a non-result oriented goal would be:
Non-Results Oriented: We will improve our leadership ability.
22
Develop goals for yourself and your employees using the SMART criteria.
1.
2.
3.
4.
23
Identify who will work on the negatives before the next staff meeting.
Follow up with staff to find our what support they need from you.
Prepare a simple report for next staff meeting.
Report on progress at next staff meeting.
24
Rating
(1 5)
1.
1.
2.
2.
3.
3.
Rating Key:
Total
Positive
Score
_______
minus
Rating
(1 5)
1 = weak;
Total
Negative
Score
5 = strong
_______
Overall
Score
_______
25
Workgroup: ________________________________________
Date: ______________
Strongly Disagree
Disagree
Not Sure
Agree
Strongly Agree
Comments:
26
Section 2
27
LEADERSHIP TIPS:
THE PSYCHOLOGICAL PROCESS OF CHANGE
Every individual goes through the following 4-stage process when dealing with change:
Stage 1:
Stage 2:
Stage 3:
Stage 4:
Denial
Betrayal
Search for Solutions
Acceptance
Commitment
Resistance
Denial
Acceptance
Betrayal
Anger!
Search for
Solutions
Ron Pound and Price Pritchett, authors of Business as Unusual, suggest the following tips to move all employees through the change process:
Provide your employees clear instructions and the direction you want them to go
Make sure each employee understands their job; provide the necessary training
Rebuild morale
Motivate! Motivate! Motivate! - Pass out psychological paychecks - These are the kind
that dont involve money but are valuable all the same (thank you notes, verbal compliments, etc.)
28
LEADERSHIP TIPS:
RECOGNITION IDEAS FOR MANAGERS
Question: How do you get anyone to try something different...something new?
Answer: You encourage them and recognize their efforts. You dont make the mistake of waiting for your
desired outcome to happen.
Encourage and recognize! The following pages identify simple ways for managers to encourage desired performance to support change and to recognize desired performance as well.
Here are some great ideas that you can do yourself:
Have someone in the chain of command deliver the paychecks and give every employee an
opportunity to talk one-on-one with management. It gives them the time to voice any concerns they have.
When paychecks are distributed, write a note on the envelope recognizing an employees
accomplishment.
Start the day with a brief meeting and review positive things that happened the previous
day.
Write a thank you note for employees who do something outstanding. It means more when
people take time to write their thoughts on paper.
Send thank you notes to the employees home.
Buy lunch for an employee as a form of thanks.
Arrange for the employee to have lunch with organization leadership.
Give the employee time off for excellence: half or full day; Friday
Personal phone calls from leadership
Letters from leadership
Candy bars
Have informal chats with employees
Use charts or posters to show how well an employee or group is performing.
Send a thank-you note to a spouse for their support during the employees overtime.
Make up a special caps, T-shirts, or jacket for your team and give to deserving employees.
Send each person, who went above-and-beyond the call of duty, a lottery ticket with a note
sending, I never gamble when I count on you.
Provide lottery tickets when the team achieves an important goal.
Laugh-a-Day challenge: each employee tries to make coworkers laugh every day with cartoons and jokes. Winners receive T-shirts and books containing the best jokes and cartoons.
Issue a Laugh-a-Day challenge to the staff to bring in a joke or cartoon every day for a
month.
Throw victory parties for major accomplishments
Thank people by giving chocolate kisses, balloons or other small items.
Hold occasional fun contests like Nerf basketball or volleyball, bubble-blowing competitions. Play cooperative games such as charades and treasure hunts.
Grill Your Boss cookout where managers dress up as chefs and cook hamburgers and hot
dogs for all employees.
29
LEADERSHIP TIPS:
RECOGNITION IDEAS FOR MANAGERS
30
Deteriorating communication
Drops in productivity
Less teamwork
Less focus on customers and competitors
Reduction in morale
Turnover
Many of these result from or result in resistance by employees to accept the change. Most view resistance
negatively when it applies to change, however, to the savvy leader it is seen as part of the ongoing process and
a metric on what is going well and what isnt. The successful leader uses the guidelines in the next section to
improve their probability of success in implementing change.
??
20%
60%
20%
31
20%
80%
When leaders focus their energy on the two groups that will move their organization forward, they create momentum. With 80% of the people moving in the right direction, most of the resistors will jump on the bandwagon so as not to be left behind. Those who are left will more than likely self-select to leave providing the
leader with the opportunity to hire new employees who are a better fit in the organization.
<10%
90+%
The Cost of Managing Change Poorly
Team size =
10 employees
Length of transition =
6 months
Average salary =
$30,000
4 hours
It must be considered that there is nothing more difficult to carry out nor more
doubtful of success nor more dangerous to handle than to initiate a new order of
things.
- Machiavelli, 1446-1507
Office of Organization Development & Training
32
Quick Criticism: Even before people hear all the details, they express their disapproval. It is as
if they have been there before and know exactly what to expect.
Malicious Compliance: People smile and appear to go along with the decision. They tell you
what you want to hear and do what they want behind the scenes.
Sabotage: People take strong actions that are specifically intended to stop you from proceeding. The positive side of this is that the resistance is so transparent.
Easy Agreement: People truly agree with you in the moment without much criticism. They
have swallowed your message whole, only to later realize what the changes mean. Intentions
are more honorable at the onset than malicious compliance, although the later actions may
look similar.
Deflection: People keep changing the subject. Meetings go from topic to topic without resolution. Like all other forms of resistance, this is a way people protect themselves.
33
34
LEADERSHIP TIPS:
DELEGATION TIPS
For every major change effort, leaders must delegate necessary tasks to others. In many cases, the more they
delegate the greater the chance they have for success. The effectiveness of their delegation will have a direct
impact on the final result. Follow these tips to enhance your delegation effectiveness:
A. Look for ways to involve staff to help you create successful change.
Describe the desired results and the reason the task needs to be accomplished. Be specific
and clear about what success will look like.
Whenever possible, when delegating work give the person an entire task to complete and
dont micromanage. Many employees will get energized if they think the delegated task is
under their complete control. Build pride and ownership and give them a chance to build
their skills and confidence.
Make sure your employee understands the task by asking an effective, open-ended question
such as Can you explain to me how you would go about handling this task?
Get buy-in from the employee that they are up to the task. If your employee doesn't feel
capable, you might consider coaching them.
Make your expectations crystal clear and ensure the employee knows what they are accountable for.
Identify the measurements/outcome you will use to determine that the project was successfully completed.
C. Follow-up
Support your employee by asking what resources will be needed and provide them. In addition, provide them the authority to get the job done.
Empower your employee -- let them do the work, but agree upon checkpoints along the way
so both of you will know how it's going.
Energize your employee -- when the task is complete, acknowledge your employee's effort
and provide accurate and honest feedback.
Determine, in advance, how you will thank and reward the staff person for their successful
completion of the task or project you delegated.
35
What am I losing?
My sense of safety.
36
Fears
Example: My position will become unnecessary and I
will lose my job.
Real or Imagined?
Imagined. Even though I will not have to do as much, there
will still be plenty for me to do.
1.
2.
3.
4.
37
Why did you choose this fear to eliminate? (Example: This will eliminate
the most amount of stress.)
How will eliminating this fear help you adapt to/ accept your current situation? (Example: When Im
not worrying about losing my job, I can focus on what I need to learn regarding my new job.)
What do you need to do to eliminate this fear? What steps do you need to take? (Example: Remind
myself that I am a valuable person to the team. I know the ins and outs of the processing work and without
me, this change will not be a smooth one.)
38
Section 3
39
40
41
42
Department: ______________________________
Strongly Disagree
Disagree
Not Sure
Agree
Strongly Agree
Hiring decisions are made very selectively resulting in employees who stay and
1
who are highly productive.
We have the right mix of knowledge, skills, and abilities for achieving the
team's goals.
The team uses its skills and abilities to effectively work together to accomplish
its goals.
Our team has a common goal that is understood by each team member.
The work of each team member is aligned with the teams goals.
Team members encourage, support, and reinforce one another to develop innovative ideas.
Directions: Use this assessment to assess your teams strengths and weaknesses. This
can be used at any time, but the sooner the better. This can be completed by the leader
and/or by all team members. Once completed, develop action steps to using the SMART
goal guidelines.
Capability
Clarity
Creativity
43
Agree
Strongly Agree
Continuous
Improvement
Not Sure
Commitment
Disagree
Communication
Strongly Disagree
Collaboration
The team has established methods for members to receive honest performance
feedback.
The team examines team and individual errors and weaknesses without making
personal attacks.
The team shares ideas and information with those outside of the team.
Team members feel mutually responsible for achieving the teams goals.
44
Action Steps
Develop your action steps for improving your Team Effectiveness Assessment by using the SMART criteria.
S
M
A
R
T
Specific
Measurable
Attainable
Results-Oriented
Time-Oriented
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
45
To be successful in creating change, you and your team members must demonstrate those characteristics of
change agents. Selecting the right change agents is a huge step towards being successful. Use this tool to assess change agent candidates, team members, or yourself on the characteristics below. For yourself or current
team members, list the areas for development and action steps on the next page.
Rate each characteristic on a scale of 1 to 5. Use the following rating descriptions in determining your assessment:
1Has great difficulty in exhibiting this characteristic
3Often exhibits this characteristic, but not always (80% of the time)
5Is an exemplary employee in this characteristic
Characteristic
Positive
Focused
be achieved
Description
Rating
2
3
4
5
2
3
4
5
Flexible
Adapts during times of
uncertainty
1
2
3
4
5
46
Characteristic
Description
Rating
Proactive
Organized
Area of Development
2
3
4
5
2
3
4
5
Action Plan
47
Commitment
Creativity
Focus
Responsibility
Truthfulness
Discipline
Courage
Humor
Perspective
3. Communications
How will the team ensure internal communications?
How will the team ensure external communications?
4. Team meetings
What are acceptable purposes for team meetings?
How often will the team meet? When? Where? For how long?
Does it have some standing agenda items?
Who can call a team meeting? How?
What are the legitimate topics for team meetings? Who sets the agenda and how is it set
and prioritized?
How does the team manage task and process at the meeting ensuring task focus on the
agenda but full process appropriate to the topic under discussion?
How will the team address consistent lateness or absentee behavior among team members?
How will the team ensure that absentees are informed of the outcomes of team meetings?
What is the follow-up system for commitments made at team meetings?
48
49
Team Authority:
Resource Limitations:
Time Table :
Goal
Measure
50
Measure
51
It can be overwhelming in times of change to know which project is most important. This impact analysis
can help you identify the impact that each project/task will have as well as the degree of difficulty to complete each project/task. Using this knowledge you can then prioritize those projects and begin them in a way
that will enable you some quick successes.
High
Impact
Low
Impact
Start these projects after you accomplished the ones that will have
a high impact. You may choose to
not even do these projects since
they wont have much of an impact.
Not Difficult
Very Difficult
52
Develop a measurement to
gauge success of your initiative
Low Impact
Analyze organization
policies
Not Difficult
Very Difficult
Determining Impact
Look at the list of projects you need to accomplish. Consider these questions when placing this project on the
impact continuum.
Determining Difficulty
Again look at the list of projects you need to accomplish and consider the following questions as you determine the degree of difficulty.
53
Long-standing problems
brought out in the open
2. Collaboration: Collaboration is characterized by a desire to satisfy all team members in a winwin situation. Appropriate when . . .
issues are interdependent and an integrative solution is needed.
you are seeking to learn or understand another position.
you are seeking to find an innovative solution to a complex problem.
you are seeking buy-in or commitment from others.
you want to build rapport or improve a difficult relationship.
54
55
56
Situation 2a
You have Johnny Jones as a student in your class this semester, and he is not doing very well. He is often
late and unprepared, and he doesnt seem especially interested in class. You arrange a meeting with his father. Mr. Jones initially pleased to hear of your concerns, later becomes defensive. His voice growing
louder, he says that you make unreasonable expectations of your students. Kids Johnnys age have other
things on their minds, he contends. You are at fault for not being more flexible or helpful when Johnny has
struggled.
57
58
Situation 3a
You are an administrator who feels overloaded with projects and paperwork. You work hard to keep things
balanced, trying to provide your secretary with clear information and adequate lead time. But you are often
unavailable, tied up in meetings. You recently gave him a report to type that you need today, as part of a
large project to be done with other administrators. But when you arrived at the office this morning, you saw
the report sitting on his desk, in a stack of work to be done, not looking anywhere near completion. Shortly
before 10:00 a.m., he tells you he has a 2:00 dental appointment.
59
60
61
In this situation, the outcome may not necessarily be Win/Win. What is important is the agreement to engage
in a process to try to resolve the conflict, in which underlying issues from all parties can be explored. The
Win/Win aspect is derived from the fact that each participants interests or needs (rather than just positions)
are discussed. That in its own right makes no one a loser.
62
" Identify forces driving toward change and forces restraining change.
Once the desired future state has been defined, the forces that are working for change
(driving forces) and those working against change (restraining forces) must be identified.
" Implement
Put your plan into action.
" Evaluate
In this final step, team members must evaluate the effectiveness of their plan. The objective is
to determine if the plan has achieved the desired team outcome. If the teams actions did not
product the desired results, they should reevaluate so that other action can be considered.
Office of Organization Development & Training
63
Always use I messages. You messages are guaranteed to make the situation worse.
Use an even, conversational tone. Maintain a neutral expression and a neutral tone. Show
confidence.
Use active listening until you really understand the other persons needs, wants and feelings.
If you listen, the other person will be more likely to listen to you.
" Dont interrupt.
" Acknowledge the persons viewpoint. Empathy builds relationships.
" Paraphrase: Restate what youve heard to avoid misunderstanding.
Indicate your willingness to help resolve the problem. You must have a concern for mutual
gain/strategic concern: Understand that helping others meet their interests can help you
meet your interests.
Do not label, accuse, or insult the other person. No zapping (name-calling, put downs, using
words like never, always, but, and you should have).
Treat the other person as you would want to be treatedwith respect, courtesy and appreciation. Remember that, like you, they have deep needs for such things as security, a sense
of belonging, recognition and control. Be soft on people and tough on the problem.
Agree not to accuse the other person of past wrongdoingstay in the present and future.
Realize that whats happening now isnt meeting your interests. Its worth trying something new.
64
Section 4
Managing Yourself
65
Flexibility
Innovativeness
Risk Tolerance
Stress Tolerance
Increasing Flexibility: Challenge yourself and your general approach to your work. What would you do differently?
"
"
"
Eliminate words such as should, shouldnt, right, and wrong and replace them with
words like meets objectives and solves problems.
Much can be done when you change the way you speak.
Change Your Focus
Focus only on the things that concern you...dont
waste time complaining about things that dont
Five Basic Attitudes of Sucmatter to you.
cessful Changers
Create a clear picture of the future and stay focused on short-term goals and objectives.
1. I am eager to learn some Find small winsyours and othersand celething in every situation.
brate those victories.
2. I am grateful for what I have
Forget Perfect
and where I am.
Expect things to change.
3. I have a clear picture of how
I want this change to turn
Plan and focus on the short-term.
out.
Realize that it is impossible to control things to
4. It is important to me to conbe perfect in the future.
tinually take action toward
Dont be afraid of making mistakes...that is
my positive outcome.
how you will get to the answer quicker.
5.
I
have something to learn
Do the Right Things
from and offer this experi Multi-task...do more than one thing at a time.
ence.
Take advantage of informal and impromptu
methods of communication with employees.
Expect changes in direction and that some avenues
will not reach completion.
Focus on finding the new right way to do the things.
66
"
"
"
"
Increasing Your Risk Tolerance: Go against your own grain! Think and act outside the box of yourself and
your work. What would you do differently?
67
"
Be the customers advocate and critique the way you do business now.
Practice Arguing
Be a devils advocate.
To increase your understanding, try defending the view you do not support.
Work to create win-win results.
Dont Believe Every Pronouncement
Question authority and become your employees advocate.
Try to understand what information they are trying to get across and what else you would
like to know.
Question whether this is the best way to do things.
"
Increasing Your Stress Tolerance: Cut yourself a break. You cant create a good environment for others
unless you take care of yourself. What would you do differently?
68
Appendix:
HopkinsOne
Background for
Managers and Supervisors
69
HOPKINSONE BACKGROUND
FOR MANAGERS AND SUPERVISORS
The Rationale for Moving to HopkinsOne
The purpose of this guide is to provide mangers and supervisors with the basic information explaining why the
university and health system are moving to enterprise-wide computer information system.
This information helps answer the basic why question asked by employees: Why are we doing this?
Page 2-6 show the results of interviews with some senior management from JHU and JHM. These pages provide the basic case for change.
The remaining pages are taken from the HopkinsOne website. Managers and supervisors should routinely
check the website to stay current with the implementation of HopkinsOne.
The website is: www.jhu.edu/hopkinsone.
Topic
HopkinsOne Examples:
SWOT Analysis
Future/Current State Analysis
Case for Change
Stakeholder Analysis
Frequently Asked Questions Concerning HopkinsOne
Force Field Analysis
Working Through Where You are Now
Identifying Your Real & Imagine Fears
Eliminating Your Fears
What You Need to Know About HopkinsOne
Page
70
STRENGTHS
I
N
T
E
R
N
A
L
WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITIES
E
X
T
E
R
N
A
L
Improved compliance capabilities for financial reporting requirements of government programs, bond
reporting, HSCRL requirements, ERISA, and Medicare Cost Reports.
Typically long time frames required to make decisions compounded by two organizational boundaries.
Pat negative expereiences with information technology projects, particularly with staffing JH personnel
to projects.
Lack of established processes across JH for issue
resolution.
Negative experiences with business process redesign
that has left many at JH and with a jaundiced view
of the potential for real change at the organization.
THREATS
ERP projects are notorious for being behind schedule and over budget
Government regulations and expectations for compliance have increased placing additional demands
on legacy systems.
Inadequate business systems challenge administrative and support staff of management, faculty, employees, sponsors, donors, governmental and regulatory agencies, and other external agencies.
71
HOPKINSONE EXAMPLE:
FUTURE/CURRENT STATE ANALYSIS
Future State
Supply Chain -
Finance -
Maintain the financial records of JHU, JHM and JHHS with a common financial
structure and infrastructure across the enterprise.
Payroll-
Ability to pay all employees in full compliance with federal, state, and local laws
nd statutes, collecting necessary time and labor reporting date required for
Financial, budgetary, and regulatory requirement utilizing a standard, fully
integrated, state-of-the-art payroll system with time and labor capability.
Human Resources-
Research-
Supply Chain-
Finance-
Payroll-
Inability to future data and perform effective data processing. Use of manual
systems to track state and local tax changes. Large volume of manual retro
paychecks at both JHHS and JHU due to processing errors.
Research-
72
73
Ensures future livelihood (last year delay in salary increases for the hospital; this year brought back)
For faculty: ease of purchasing, ease and quality of hiring, travel approvals
For administration: consistency in processes, single service centers
Responding to infrastructure and facility needs (HopkinsOne, medical campus redevelopment, etc.)
Need these investments today to ensure Hopkins for the long term
Puts managers, supervisors, and employees in a position to be more successful (career, salary, etc.)
Pride/image of Johns Hopkins
New set of skills that are current increase ones marketability and can translate into higher salary
Some jobs change more than others; most change little
Systems will do what theyre supposed to do, freeing up people to do what theyre supposed to do
reduce sneaker power & shadow systems
It will help get your job done in a more efficient manner
Provides accurate information around effort-reporting
Ensures best cost in securing supplies in a timely manner
74
75
HOPKINSONE EXAMPLE:
STAKEHOLDER ANALYSIS
Need for Support: Rate on a 3 to 5 Scale
Stakeholder Analysis
Name of Individual or Group
Need for
Support
Likelihood
for
Support
Action Steps
Bob
Phyllis
Joe
Ken
No Action Now
Barbie
No Action Now
Shelly
Rick
76
77
When the change is implemented, each person will be effected differently. In the end, how you react to the
change plays an important role in how the change will impact you.
6. What are my choices?
Your choices about how to respond to change will vary as the organization moves through the change process.
Think about the change in these time periods: When the change is first announced, but before the change is
implemented; during the change process, when the new solution is being deployed; and after the change is in
place, following the implementation of the solution.
Those individuals who take advantage of the training and resources provided, and who stay positive, focused,
flexible, organized and proactive throughout the change have the best opportunity for learning and growth.
7. What are the benefits of supporting the change?
The benefits of supporting HopkinsOne may include:
78
79
HOPKINSONE EXAMPLE:
FORCE FIELD ANALYSIS
H-1 Toolkit - Force Field Analysis
Rating
(1 5)
3
3
4
5
4
37
minus
3
1
3
1
3
4
4
37
Total
Positive
Score
Rating
(1 5)
Total
Negative
Score
20
20
5 = strong
Overall
Score
+17
80
HOPKINSONE EXAMPLE:WORKING
THROUGH WHERE YOU ARE NOW
Lets face it. A major problem when facing change is feelings. More specifically, there are feelings of loss
(we wont be doing things the old way), and feelings of fear (not understanding what challenges the new way
brings or having all of the information). Getting people to talk about their feelings around change serves to
diminish negative feelings.
Whenever any change happens, it is important to allow yourself to acknowledge your loss, and yet be aware
of what you have not lost.
In the table below, write a few words in each quadrant describing the losses you must relinquish, the losses
you must replace, acknowledge what you are not losing, and what losses you can rebuild.
What am I losing?
81
Fears
Example: My position will become unnecessary and I
will lose my job.
Real or Imagined?
Imagined. Even though I will not have to do as much, there
will still be plenty for me to do.
4.
82
Why did you choose this fear to eliminate? (Example: This will eliminate
the most amount of stress.)
How will eliminating this fear help you adapt to/ accept your current situation? (Example: When Im not worrying about losing my job, I can focus on what I need to learn regarding
my new job.)
I wont be as anxious and I will feel less stressed about this change. In
addition, it will help me focus on the proactive things I can do to learn
this system.
What do you need to do to eliminate this fear? What steps do you need to take? (Example: Remind
myself that I am a valuable person to the team. I know the ins and outs of the processing work and without
me, this change will not be a smooth one.)
1. Find out what the scope of the new duties will be.
2. Study the material available now (i.e. Momentums, website, etc.).
3. Talk with my Manager to see if there is anything I can do to participate.
4. Study any prep material thats available.
5. Study hard in class.
6. Ask questions.
Office of Organization Development & Training
83
References
American Management Association. 2005. Delegation Tips for New (and Not so New) Managers. As seen
on bizjournals.com.
Conner, D. 1992. Managing at the Speed of Change. Villard Books, New York, NY.
Heathfield, S. 2005. Delegation as a Leadership Style: Tips for Effective Delegation. As seen on
About.com.
Howard, I. 2004. Eight Steps to Transforming Your Organization. The University of Auckland Business
School, Auckland, New Zealand.
Kotter, J. 1995. Why Transformation Efforts Fail. Harvard Business Review, March-April 1995.
Kusmierek, K. 2001. Understanding and Addressing Resistance to Organizational Change. University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI.
Maurer, R. 2000. Building Capacity for Change Sourcebook, Maurer and Associates, Fairfax, VA.
Maurer, R. 2004. Making a Compelling Case for Change. Maurer and Associates, Fairfax, VA.
Mergal, B. 2000. Managing Change: Concepts and Approaches. InFo, April 2000.
Nelson, B. 1994. 1001 Ways to Reward Employees. Workman Publishing Company, Inc., New York, NY
Noble, S. 2003. Tall Ships. HRDQ, Kind of Prussia, PA.
Organization Development and Diversity Department. 2005. The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD.
Organization Development and Training. 2005. The Johns Hopkins Medical System, Baltimore, MD.
Prichett & Associates. 1991. Business as Unusual: Participants Guide. Pritchett & Associates, Inc., Dallas,
Texas.
Pritchett, P. & Pound, R. 1991. Business as Unusual. Pritchett, Dallas, TX.
ProSci & LaMarsh and Associates. 1999. Business Performance Series: Change Management Toolkit.
ProSci Research, Loveland, CO.
Scott, C. & Jaffee, D. 2004. Stages in Change Management. As seen on www.cabinet.gov.jm.
Southern Illinois University. 2005. Coping with Change and Stress. As seen on www.engr.siu.edu.
University of Wisconsin-Madison 2005. Situational Conflict Styles Assessment Exercise. As seen on
www.ohrd.wisc.edu.
84