Suicide Risk Assessment
Suicide Risk Assessment
Suicide Risk Assessment
Contents
Executive summary ........................................1
Introduction.....................................................3
Glossary ........................................................31
References ....................................................34
Components of a comprehensive
suicide risk assessment ................................7
Engagement ..................................................................7
Detection.......................................................................8
Figures
Figure 1: Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment
and Management for NSW Health staff ..........5
Figure 2: Assessment of suicide risk
(screening questions)......................................9
Tables
Related documents
Suicide Risk Assessment and Management: Emergency Department SHPN (MH) 040186
Suicide Risk Assessment and Management Protocols: General Hospital Ward SHPN (MH) 040185
Suicide Risk Assessment and Management Protocols: General Community Health Service SHPN (MH) 040187
Suicide Risk Assessment and Management Protocols: Community Mental Health Service SHPN (MH) 040182
Suicide Risk Assessment and Management Protocols: Mental Health In-Patient Unit SHPN (MH) 040183
Suicide Risk Assessment and Management Protocols: Justice Health Long Bay Hospital SHPN (MH) 040188
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
Engagement
Detection
Preliminary Suicide
Risk Assessment
Immediate
Management
Mental Health
Assessment
Assessment of
Suicide Risk
Corroborative
History
Determining Suicide
Risk Level
Management of
Suicide Risk
Re-assessment of
Suicide Risk
Discharge
ii
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Executive summary
The Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and
Management for NSW Health Staff is a key component
of the NSW Health Circular, Policy guidelines for the
management of patients with possible suicidal
behaviour for NSW Health staff and staff in private
hospital facilities1 and is relevant to all health settings.
It provides detailed information on conducting suicide
risk assessments and specific information on the roles
and responsibilities of generalist and mental health
services to guide the suicide risk assessment and
management process.
The framework has been developed to link with the
NSW Health Mental Health Outcomes and Assessment
Tools (MH-OAT) comprehensive mental health
assessment and management protocols (only applicable
to mental health services). It is also linked to the NSW
Health Discharge and Follow Up Protocols for NSW
Mental Health Services and Postvention guidelines
surrounding a suicide death for NSW Health staff and
staff in private hospital facilities.2
People with possible suicidal behaviour must receive
preliminary suicide risk assessment and, where
appropriate, a referral for a comprehensive mental
health assessment including a detailed suicide risk
assessment. The goal of a suicide risk assessment is to
determine the level of suicide risk at a given time and
to provide the appropriate clinical care and management.
Assessment is a continuing process occurring along a
pathway of care from the persons first presentation to
a health service, through to the provision of treatment
leading to discharge.
The assessment and management of suicide risk is
conducted within a collaborative partnership between
the relevant health services, the person at risk of suicide
and their family.
Suicide risk assessment generates a clinician rating
of the risk that the person will attempt suicide in the
immediate period. The persons suicide risk in the
immediate to short-term period can be assigned to one
of the four broad risk categories: high risk, medium risk,
low risk, no (foreseeable) risk. The level of changeability
of the person and the confidence of the clinician in the
assessment rating are also taken into account.
NSW Health
MEDIUM RISK
Significant but moderate risk of suicide.
The clinician ensures that a person at this level
of risk receives a re-assessment within one week
and contingency plans are in place for rapid
re-assessment if distress or symptoms escalate.
LOW RISK
Definite but low suicide risk. The clinician considers
a person at this level of risk requires review at
least monthly. The timeframe for review should
be determined based on clinical judgment. After
discharge from an in-patient unit, the review is
to be conducted within one week. The person
at risk should be provided with written information
on 24-hour access to suitable clinical care.
NO (FORESEEABLE) RISK
Following comprehensive suicide risk assessment
there is no evidence of current risk to the person.
There are no thoughts of suicide or history
of attempts and they have a good social
support network.
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
Executive summary
Changeability
Changeability of risk status, especially in the immediate
period, should be assessed and high changeability
should be identified. When high changeability is
identified the clinician recognises the need for careful
re-assessment and gives consideration as to when
the re-assessment should occur, eg within 24 hours.
More vigilant management is adopted with respect
to the safety of the person in the light of the identified
risk of high changeability.
Assessment confidence
of suicide risk
adopt a reflective practice style in which
the person.
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Introduction
Suicide prevention is the concern of all health workers
and the whole community. Health workers play a key
role in early detection and intervention with people
who are at risk of suicide.
Suicidal behaviour is complex and despite the best
available expertise and exemplary care, some individuals
will go on to suicide. There is no current rating scale
or clinical algorithm that has proven predictive value
in the clinical assessment of suicide.3, 4, 5 A thorough
assessment of the individual remains the only valid
method of determining risk. Assessments are based
on a combination of the background conditions and the
current factors in a persons life and the way in which
they are interacting. The aim of this document is to
assist health staff to make informed judgments about
risk by providing a framework and information on
good practices.
In general:
Team management is central to effective management
of a person at risk of suicide. In particular, transitions
in care can be highly vulnerable periods in the
management of a person at risk. Clear, concise
documentation of assessments, including observations
and clinical decisions, is the most helpful process to
assist in good team management. Where a clinician
remains uncertain after a clinical assessment, it is
important to consult with a senior colleague.
The Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and
Management for NSW Health Staff outlines a
comprehensive framework to guide the suicide risk
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
Introduction
suicide risk
adopt a reflective practice style in which clinicians
Risk detection
Documentation
A thorough, well-documented assessment and
management plan is essential to the effective
management of suicide risk and is to be documented
in the persons medical record. For mental health
services, documentation must be completed using
the Mental Health Outcomes and Assessment Tools
(MH-OAT) Clinical Modules. Care must be taken to
ensure the persons privacy and confidentiality with
respect to any sensitive information contained in the
documentation of the assessment.
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Introduction
Figure 1: Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
Engagement is crucial to detection,
Engagement
Preliminary Suicide
Risk Assessment
Immediate
Management
Mental Health
Assessment
Assessment of
Suicide Risk
Corroborative
History
Determining Suicide
Risk Level
Management of
Suicide Risk
Re-assessment of
Suicide Risk
Discharge
risk factors
Detection
a suicide attempt
It is important and safe to ask
Manner of presentation/referral
History of presenting problem
Brief psychiatric assessment
Collateral information
Assessment of suicide risk
consultation
assessment
Depression, psychosis,
personality disorder
motivation
At risk mental states: hopelessness,
despair, psychosis, agitation, shame,
anger, guilt
History of suicidal behaviour
Willingness/capacity of support
no (foreseeable) risk
Changeability of suicide risk status
actions, plans
Lethality, intent, access to means
Safety of person and others
Coping capacity, supports
Logic/plausibility, assessment
confidence
person/s
Assessment confidence
Consultation with team/senior
colleague
community
Allocation to a key worker/clinician
Inclusion of the person at risk, family
and other service providers in plan
arrangements
foreseeable risk
Discharge from hospital
Re-entry pathway
In practice, the progressive steps described in this framework might not necessarily be carried out in this order.
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
Introduction
Collaborative partnership
Suicide risk assessments should be conducted within a
collaborative partnership to maximise the involvement
of the person at risk, family and other care providers
including primary care services and general practitioners.
Information gathered from a single source should be
validated with other sources.
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Components of a
comprehensive suicide
risk assessment
Engagement
Engagement is crucial to detection, assessment and
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
Detection
Detection is about identifying risk factors
Most people seek help prior to a suicide attempt
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Collateral information
Assessment of suicide risk
Monday Afternoon):
General appearance (agitation, distress,
psychomotor retardation)
Form of thought (persons speech logical
and making sense)
Content of thought (hopelessness, despair,
anger, shame or guilt)
Mood and affect (depressed, low, flat or
inappropriate)
Attitude (insight, cooperation).
What collateral information is available,
harming yourself?
Are you thinking of suicide?
Have you ever tried to harm yourself?
Have you made any current plans?
Do you have access to a firearm? Access to
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
Immediate Management
Safety of person, clinician, others
Appropriate observation, supervision
assessment occurs.
The attending medical officer and relevant members
of the treating team are notified of the preliminary
suicide risk assessment and management plan.
10
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Personality style
Changeability of suicide risk status
disorders.9
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
11
Risk factors specifically associated with a higher risk of dying from suicide can be classified into three categories:
demographic factors, groups at higher risk and current personal risk factors (Table 1).
Table 1: Examples of demographic, group and personal risk factors for dying from suicide
Demographic factors
Male
Older people
Living in rural area
Members of minority groups
identity conflicts
Immigrants, refugees,
asylum seekers
Homelessness
or self-harm
particularly depression,
schizophrenia, other psychotic
illness, personality disorder
History of sexual or physical
abuse or neglect
First presentations of
mental illness
Victims of domestic violence
Alcohol and other substance
abuse; co-morbidity
Older immigrants from
non-English speaking
backgrounds
Immigrants from northern and
eastern Europe
Refugee victims of torture
and trauma
Serious physical illness
or disability
People in prison or police custody
12
anniversary
Alcohol intoxication
Drug withdrawal state
Chronic pain or illness
Financial difficulties, unemployment
Impending legal prosecution
Family breakdown,
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
loss, humiliation
at risk mental states especially
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
13
Meaning, motivation
commenced?
Can the person control them?
What has stopped the person from acting on their
thoughts so far?
Intent, lethality
What is the persons degree of suicidal intent?
previous attempt/s?
Are there similarities to the current circumstances?
Is there a history of suicide of a family member
or friend?
A history of suicide attempt or self-harm greatly
elevates a persons risk of suicide. This elevated risk is
independent of the apparent level of intent of previous
attempts. Suicide often follows an initial suicidal gesture.
14
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Safety of others
someone else?
Has the person harmed anyone else?
What is the persons rationale for harming
another person?
Is there a risk of murder-suicide?
shooting, jumping?
Has the person made a special effort to find out
NSW Health
financial issues?
Are the children safe?
therapeutic alliance/partnership?
Does the person recognise any personal strengths or
treatment plan?
Can the person acknowledge self-destructive
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
15
Self-harming behaviour
Self-harming behaviour usually occurs in one of
Assessment confidence
In some situations, it is reasonable for a clinician
to conclude that, on the available evidence, their
assessment is tentative and thus of low confidence.
Rating assessment confidence is a way a clinician can
reflect on the assessment in order to flag the need for
further review and psychiatric consultation.
The persons account of the events leading to their
contemplation of or attempt to suicide will need to
be considered by the clinician in terms of its logic and
plausibility. This is best achieved by asking the person
for a chronological account of events commencing
from before the onset of the suicidal thoughts.
It is important that the clinician gently probes apparent
gaps in the persons account and listens not only for
what is actually said, but what is implied and what is
omitted. The clinician needs to feel confident that the
person is providing an accurate and plausible account
of their suicide-related problems.
Another factor that might indicate a level of uncertainty
in the assessment is a lack of corroborative information,
or conflicting information. Reflecting on the quality of
their engagement and rapport with the person will also
assist the clinician in determining their confidence in
the assessment.
16
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Corroborative History
Corroboration of information: records, family, other sources
Availability of support system
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
17
Changeability
Changeability of risk status, especially in the immediate
period, should be assessed and high changeability
should be identified. Risk status is dynamic and
requires re-assessment. It is important to identify
highly changeable risk status because it will
guide clinicians as to the safe interval between
risk assessments.
High changeability: The clinician recognises the need
for careful re-assessment and gives consideration as
to when the re-assessment should occur, eg within
24 hours. When the person is identified as having high
changeability of risk status, a more vigilant management
is adopted with respect to the safety of the person.
18
Assessment confidence
Consultation with team/senior colleague
Assessment confidence
The clinician should consider the confidence he/she
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Information sharing
Information about the outcome of a suicide risk
assessment and the management plan may need
to be communicated to a range of other people
including family or carers (unless this is not appropriate),
the general practitioner, other members of the treating
team or other teams of a mental health service.
Information about a person may be passed to
someone else:
with the persons explicit consent, or
on a need to know basis when the recipient
Confidentiality
Documentation
a colleague
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
19
High risk
Medium risk
Command hallucinations or
delusions about dying;
Some sadness;
Preoccupied with
hopelessness, despair,
feelings of worthlessness;
Severe anger, hostility.
Low risk
Eg. Nil or mild depression,
sadness;
No psychotic symptoms;
Feels hopeful about the
future;
None/mild anger, hostility.
Repeated threats.
Substance disorder
current misuse of alcohol
and other drugs
Current substance
intoxication, abuse or
dependence.
Risk of substance
intoxication, abuse or
dependence.
Corroborative History
family, carers
medical records
other service
providers/sources
Lack of supportive
relationships / hostile
relationships;
Moderate connectedness;
few relationships;
Reflective practice
level & quality of
engagement
changeability of risk level
assessment confidence in
risk level.
No (foreseeable) risk: Following comprehensive suicide risk assessment, there is no evidence of current risk to the
person. No thoughts of suicide or history of attempts, has a good social support network.
No
Are there factors that indicate a level of uncertainty in this risk assessment? Eg: poor engagement, gaps in/or
No
conflicting information.
Low Assessment Confidence Yes
20
Highly Changeable
Yes
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Management setting
The first management decision in treating a person
MEDIUM RISK
Re-assess within one week
Significant but moderate risk of suicide.
The clinician ensures that a person at this level
of risk receives a re-assessment within one week
and contingency plans are in place for rapid
re-assessment if distress or symptoms escalate.
degree of impulsivity
degree of insight
safety of current situation
whether the person is willing and able to engage
with the treating team and other supports
identified protective factors such as supportive
family, friends.
LOW RISK
Re-assess within one month
After discharge from an in-patient unit,
re-assess within one week
Definite but low suicide risk. The clinician
considers a person at this level of risk requires
review at least monthly. The timeframe for
review should be determined based on clinical
judgment. After discharge from an in-patient unit,
the review is to be conducted within one week.
The person at risk should be provided with
written information on 24-hour access to suitable
clinical care.
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
21
that setting
there is good rapport with the person at risk
the mental health team has a management plan that
22
Management plan
The management plan is a record of interventions and
contingency plans. The management plan should clearly
articulate roles, responsibilities and timeframes for the
period between assessments. The management plan
should also include explicit plans for responding to
non-compliance and missed contact by the client.
Suicide risk assessment is not static and the management
plan should be updated with the most current
information available.
If an intervention that is indicated to reduce risk is
not available, this should be clearly recorded in the
management plan and/or the patients medical record
and discussed with the Service Manager. A realistic
management plan within the resources available still
needs to be made recognising that treatment options
may be limited. This should also be discussed with the
at risk person.
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
provided with:
the time and place for the re-assessment
interview
detailed information of the 24-hour availability
of the service and how to re-contact the service
if concern increases or the persons situation
changes and requires earlier re-assessment
a clear understanding of what response will be
provided by the health service should the person
need to access further help because their distress
or suicide risk has increased. This must also be
explained to the family member or support
person nominated in the management plan.
Information concerning the management of the
Contingency planning
Contingency planning requires the clinician and the
person at risk and/or their family or carer to anticipate
likely escalations of risk such as:
deterioration of family relationships
increase in symptoms (depression, insomnia,
acute team.
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
23
observation levels
Environmental safety
mental illness
eg depression
Treatment for substance misuse
Relapse prevention
interventions, eg problem-solving
Practical assistance with problems,
eg housing
protective factors
supports
relapse plans
Family assessment and/or ensuring
Instilling hope
If person is intoxicated, sobering
them up
(NSW) if necessary
Police involvement
De-escalation techniques
Use of medication
Advice on sleep, hygiene, exercise
24
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
of suicide.
Establish a team approach.
Actively treat all co-morbid conditions.
Carefully assess and appropriately address any
and medication.
Clarify problems.
Provide psychiatric crisis intervention.
Provide brief symptom-focused hospitalisations when
countertransference is important.21
Beyond crisis intervention and life-saving short-term
hospital admission, there is a need for effective
treatment methods for chronically suicidal persons
with personality disorders that can be applied within
community health settings.
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
25
26
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Discharge
Suicide risk is low or no foreseeable risk
Discharge from hospital
Re-entry pathway
When a person is discharged from a mental health
service, or discharged from a particular setting within a
mental health service there are precautions that should
be in place and documented in the discharge plan.
The person and their family or support person know
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
27
Appendix 1:
Special needs groups
Cultural sensitivity
A culturally sensitive approach to working within a
multicultural society requires health professionals to
be aware of their own cultural values and beliefs.
It is recommended that when working cross-culturally,
staff approach the person with sensitivity to and respect
for the social context of the clients problems and their
personal and social history. It is important to understand
the personal meaning of the illness and suffering for the
individual, their family and their community.
28
After hours
131 450
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
NSW Health
community.
Assess the familys capacity and willingness to
support the client.
Consider the quality/stability of the family
environment to be integral to risk assessment.
Seek advice from Aboriginal staff and the
Aboriginal Medical Service in the persons area on
cultural issues that may underlie elevated risk.
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
29
30
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Glossary
Affect
Changeability of risk
Anhedonia
impulsivity
Assessment confidence
The sense of confidence a clinician has about the
assessment of an individuals safety and level of suicide
risk in the short-term (12-24 hours). It is usually
expressed in terms of assessment confidence (high or
low), which is determined by:
the quality of the engagement and rapport with
the person
the consistency of the persons history
the availability of collaborative information necessary
information
the clinicians intuition, including the unspoken
or unknown information.
In some situations, it is reasonable for a clinician
to conclude that, on the available evidence,
their assessment is tentative and thus of low confidence.
It is important that low assessment confidence is
flagged as an indication for re-assessment as soon as
is appropriate. Suicide risk is complex, dynamic and
ultimately unknowable.
NSW Health
Personal factors
degree of depression
psychosis
vulnerable personality.
Environmental factors
impact of further (or impending) life events,
Cultural consultant
A relatively new concept is that of the cultural
consultant in medicine and psychiatry. In a sense the
cultural consultant serves as a bridge between the
medical model and the refugees or immigrants world
view. Ideally, the cultural consultant should have
experience and training in health care and should be
bicultural and bilingual. Awareness of ones own
identity, behaviour and biases is also important.
Ultimately the cultural consultants chief task is to
answer the question, Is this behaviour normal?.
This question lies at the heart of cross-cultural
psychiatry, which must determine normality in its
cultural context.27
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
31
Glossary
Delusions
Hallucinations
Malignant alienation
This term refers to a sequence of events, often related
to recurrent relapse and failure to respond to treatment,
in which certain patients who are suicidal experience
profound loss of sympathy and loss of support from
staff members and relatives who may view the
patients behaviour as provocative, unreasonable
or overdependent.
Suicide attempt
A suicide attempt is defined as an act of self-inflicted
harm that is intended to cause death.
Parasuicide
An act of self-inflicted harm that is intended to
communicate distress. It is similar to attempted suicide
in appearance, but it is not intended to cause death.
Parasuicide is important as it is much more common
than attempted suicide and may be repeated with fatal
consequences (intentionally or not).
Self-mutilation
An act of self-inflicted injury that is often ritualistic or
repetitive and is not intended to cause death or to
appear that way.
Psychosis
Negative therapeutic reaction
This term refers to the situation where a clinicians
(often well-intended and rational) therapeutic
endeavours are experienced as unempathic and
unhelpful by the patient who responds negatively.
The clinician may then respond defensively or
punitively and patient and clinician might join in
a counterproductive cycle of interactions.
Personality disorder
This term describes a range of disorders characterised by
a pattern of thoughts, feelings and behaviour which are
markedly different from those shown by other people in
32
Re-entry
When a person is discharged, they and their family,
partner or friend have a clear understanding of
pathways for re-entering specialist mental health care
at a later date if required. The Mental Health Service
has procedures in place to ensure that re-entry is
easy and effective.
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
Glossary
NSW Health
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
33
References
1
34
10 Goldacre
11 Zimmerman
12 Appleby
13 Rudd
14 NSW
15 White
16 Cantor
17 Lambert
18 Paris
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
NSW Health
References
19 Brodsky
20 Linehan
21 Mehlum
22 Hunter
23 Australian
NSW Health
24 Australian
25 Hunter
26 Department
27 Bulle
Framework for Suicide Risk Assessment and Management for NSW Health Staff
35