The Preventive System of St. John Bosco
The Preventive System of St. John Bosco
The Preventive System of St. John Bosco
PREVENTION
This system consists in making the laws and regulations of an institution known. Then the
Educator and his staff, like loving fathers, supervise students, converse with them, give advice
and correction in a charitable manner; in other words, this system minimizes the possibility of
committing faults. Based entirely on reason, religion, and charity, this system excludes all
violent punishment and tries to do without even the slightest chastisement. It seems preferable
for the following reasons:
(a) The primary reason for this system is seen in the thoughtlessness of youth, which in one
moment forgets the rules of discipline, and the punishments which they threaten.
Consequently, a child often becomes culpable and deserving of punishment which he had
no thought of, and which he quite forgot when heedlessly committing the fault which he
would certainly have avoided, had a friendly voice warned him.
(b) The pupil, being previously advised, does not remain downcast by the faults he has
committed, as is the case when they are brought to the notice of the Principal. Nor will
(c) The Repressive System may stop a disorder, but can hardly make the offenders better.
Experience teaches that the young do not forget the punishments they have received, but
often foster bitter feelings, along with the desire of throwing off the yoke and even of
revenging themselves. It sometimes appears that they do not heed it, but one who can
follow them in their future life knows that the reminiscences of youth are terrible, that
they easily forget the punishments of their parents, but with great difficulty those of their
teachers. There are cases of some who in later years have in a brutal manner taken
vengeance for certain chastisements received during the period of their education.
(b) The pupil will always be respectful towards his educators and will ever remember their
care with pleasure. He will look upon them as fathers and brothers. No matter where
they may be, these pupils are generally found to be the consolation of their families,
useful citizens and good Catholics.
Some may say that this system is difficult in practice. I reply that, for the pupils, it is easier,
more satisfactory and more advantageous. To the teacher it certainly does present some
difficulties, which, however, can be diminished if he applies himself to his task with zeal.
An educator is one who is entirely consecrated to the welfare of his pupils, and should,
therefore, be ready to face every difficulty and endure fatigue in order to attain his object,
which is the civil, moral and intellectual education of his pupils.
BASIC PRINCIPLES
The practice of this system is wholly based on the words of St. Paul who says: ‘Charity is patient,
is kind. It beareth all things, hopeth all things, endureth all things, (Cor. xiii: 4, 7). Hence only a
Christian can apply the ‘Preventive’ system with success. Reason and Religion are the means
which the educator ought to apply constantly, which he ought to teach, and which he himself
ought to practice, if he wishes to be obeyed and to attain his end.
Care should be taken that the pupils never remain alone. As far as possible, the teachers ought to
go beforehand to the place where the boys are to gather together, they should remain with them
until others come to relieve them, and the pupils should never be left unoccupied.
Let the boys have full liberty to run, skip and play as much as they please. Gymnastics, music,
reciting, acting and hikes are most efficacious means of promoting discipline and improving
good conduct and health; care, however, must be taken that the games, the persons who take part
in them, and the conversations held, are irreproachable. ‘Do anything you like,’ the great Saint
of youth, St. Philip, used to say, ‘as long as you do not sin.’
Frequent Confession and Communion and daily Mass are the pillars which must support the
edifice of education, from which we propose to banish threats and the rod. Never force the boys
A WORD ON PUNISHMENTS
What rules should be followed in inflicting punishments? If possible, never make use of
punishments; but when necessity demands it, let the following be borne in mind:
1. The educator must strive to make himself loved by his pupils, if he wishes to obtain their
respect. When he succeeds in doing this, the omission of some token of kind-ness is a
punishment which rekindles emulation, revives courage and never degrades.
2. With the young, punishment is everything that is meant as a punishment. Thus it is
known that a reproachful look is more effective than a blow. Praise of work well done,
and just blame when duties are neglected are themselves reward and punishment.
3. Except in very rare instances, corrections and punishments should not be given in public,
but privately and apart from the others; and the greatest prudence and patience must be
used to bring the pupil to see his fault, by aid of reason and religion.
4. To strike one in any way, to make him kneel in a painful position, to pull his ears, and
other similar punishments, must be absolutely avoided, because the law forbids them, and
they greatly irritate the boys and lower the reputation of the educator.
5. The educator must see that the laws of discipline, and the rewards and punishments
entailed, are made known to the pupil, so that no one can make the excuse that he did not
know what was commanded or forbidden.
6. All who hold office or have the care of the boys, whom Divine Providence has entrusted
to us, have the duty also of giving advice and counsel to any boy of the school every time
there is reason to do so, and especially when it is a question of preventing some offense
against God.
7. Every educator must make himself loved, if he wishes to be feared. He will attain this
great end if he makes it clear by his words, and still more by his actions, that all his care
and solicitude are directed towards the spiritual and temporal welfare of his pupils.
8. The teacher should be a man of few words but prompt action, and he should give his
pupils every opportunity to express their thoughts freely. Attention, however, must be
paid to rectifying and correcting all expressions, words and actions which are not in
accordance with Christian Education.
Boys soon begin to show one of the following characters: good, ordinary, wayward, or bad. It is
our bounden duty to study how to keep lads of these different characters together, so as to do
good to all, without allowing some to do harm to others.
For those who are naturally of a good disposition, a general supervision is sufficient, provided
that the rules of discipline are explained and their observance recommended.
The greater number consists of those who possess an ordinary disposition, somewhat inclined to
fickleness and indifference. These have need of short but frequent exhortations and advice. It is
necessary to encourage them to work, even by means of small rewards, and by showing them that
we have great confidence in them, without, however, neglecting our watchfulness.
But all our care and solicitude must be especially directed towards those in the remaining
categories: the wayward and the bad. The number of such boys can be averaged at about one in
every fifteen. The educator should obtain information regarding their past. Everyone in charge
of them should show himself their friend, should allow them to speak freely, but should limit
himself to few words, and these consisting mainly of short examples, maxims, episodes and the
like. These boys must never be allowed out of the teacher’s sight, but they must not be given to
understand that no confidence is placed in them.
Whenever blame, advice or correction has to be given to this class of boy, it should never be
given in the presence of companions. But use can be made of facts and episodes which have
befallen others, to point out thereby what praise or blame is likely to come to those of whom we
now speak. Remember, however, that all need patience, diligence and prayer, without which I
believe all rule is unavailing.
I have often been asked and begged by my Salesians to set down various norms regarding the
difficult matter of punishments.
In these times of ours you know that this is no easy problem in education, for in solving it even
the slightest imprudence may cause serious consequences. Very anxious, therefore, to comply
with your requests, I intend to give you some directions that will guide you. The education of the
young, though indeed a delicate task, is a holy vocation and, if properly carried out, is of the
greatest advantage to society. I am confident, therefore, that you will make very effort to put my
recommendations into practice.
The system in use in our schools, as you know, is the Preventive System, which consists
essentially in disposing the pupils to obey not from fear or compulsion, but from persuasion. In
this system all force must be excluded, and in its place, charity must be the mainspring of action.
If your first effort to correct the culprit has proved unsuccessful, find out if there is anyone in the
school who has gained the confidence of that lad. If so, let him try correcting him. In the
meantime you should pray that some good may result from his attempt. When the people of
Israel committed sin, Moses besought God not to wreak His vengeance on them. Like Moses,
the educator should endeavor to moderate his own just indignation, for a sudden chastisement
will rarely succeed where other means of correcting have not even been given a trial. Only moral
strength can win the human heart which, St. Gregory tells us, is like an impregnable fortress,
never to be conquered except by affection and kindness.
Be exacting when it is a matter of duty, firm in the pursuit of good, courageous in preventing
evil, but always gentle and prudent. God will surely reward you if you are persevering in these
virtues. He will make you the master of your pupil’s hearts even when they are stubborn and
rebellious. What I recommend is hard, I know, especially for young teachers, whose first
inclination in obtaining discipline is to act on the spur of the moment and inflict punishments.
But I assure you, real success can only be the result of patience. Impatience merely disgusts the
pupils and spreads discontent among the best of them. Long experience has taught me that
patience is the only remedy for even the worst cases of disobedience and irresponsiveness among
boys. Sometimes, after making, many patient efforts without obtaining, success, I deemed it
necessary to resort to severe measures. Yet these never achieved anything, and in the end, I
always found that charity finally triumphed where severity had met with failure. Charity is the
cure-all though it may be slow in affecting its cure.
At times a boy seems to reap no fruit from our corrections; yet down deep in his heart a
wonderful change is taking place. And this good effect would be entirely destroyed if we were to
inflict some severe punishment on him. Boys often commit faults through thoughtlessness. At
other times there are hidden motives for their misbehavior. On several occasions I have recalled
Experience is the best teacher. If you have enough courage and good will to put my suggestions
to the test, you will find that I am right. First of all, master your own character, and then you will
succeed in mastering those of your pupils. Show them that uncontrolled emotion plays no part in
your actions; they will respect you for that, and their respect will prompt their obedience. But
betray the least sign of weakness, of passion, of impatience, and your authority and prestige will
not long endure. Besides, your punishment will not be taken as a remedy for the boy’s fault, but
as a vent for your own passion. It can bear no fruit!
You are acquainted, no doubt, with the words Socrates addressed to a slave who had caused him
displeasure: ‘If I weren’t angry, I’d strike you.’
‘Even a slight flush of the countenance or a small change in the tone of the voice caused by anger
is betraying and incites the boys to lose their esteem and confidence in us. Then all punishment
is useless, because the boys feel that reason alone ought to be used in correcting them.
A second thing I would ask you to practice is never to correct a boy while he is still under the
influence of his own temper. A correction given at that time would only serve to embitter him all
the more and make things worse. Give him time to reflect, to enter into himself-he will realize
that he is in the wrong.
St. Francis of Sales, that meekest of Saints, never allowed his tongue to speak when his spirit
was disturbed. ‘I am afraid,’ he once said, ‘to lose in a quarter of an hour that little sweetness
that I have gathered up, drop by drop, like dew, in the vessel of my heart through the efforts of
twenty years. A bee works for months to make a little honey that a man consumes in one
swallow. Besides, what is the use wasting words on one that won’t understand them?’ On
another occasion, when he was reproached for having treated with too much kindness a young
man who had seriously offended his mother, he explained: ‘This young man was not in the mood
to profit from any good advice. His bad disposition completely overshadowed his better
judgment. A sharp correction would certainly have done him no good and would have brought
great harm to me. By becoming angry with him, I would have imitated a man who drowns
himself in an effort to save another.’
These admirable words of Saint Francis of Sales show that he was a wise and a meek master of
hearts. I would like you to impress them deep in your memory and often call them to mind.
CORRECTIONAL TECHNIQUES
Many times an indirect method in correcting is useful. For example, while in the presence of
one at fault, speak to another about the folly of those who so lose their self-respect and good
sense as to deserve punishment. Sometimes, to obtain the amendment of our pupils it is
enough to withdraw those marks of confidence and friendliness usually shown them, unless
some misfortune should befall them and you see they are in special need of consolation.
Many times, by the grace of God, this expedient has been of great assistance to me. Never,
except in very extreme cases, expose the culprit publicly to shame. Often make use of a third
person to talk well to your offender about you, to advise him, to tell him what you cannot
very well tell him yourself. Look for one who can more easily gain his heart. Perhaps the lad
has something to say which he is afraid to tell you directly. Or perhaps he does not care to
reveal it to you. Our Lord acted in a similar way-He sent His disciples before Him to prepare
the way for His own coming.
Let the one you correct understand that you act out of duty and according to reason. Try to
make him realize his fault, and that it deserves punishment. Then mitigate it. In this way he
will willingly accept it. One last thing: when once you have gained the boy’s heart, do not be
content with merely inspiring him with the hope of forgiveness, but assure him that by his
good conduct in the future he will make up for past failings.
Correction at times brings about anxiety and fear. A word of comfort can easily offset this. A
person who forgets, and helps the culprit to forget is a true educator. We are sure that Jesus
When the pupil is convinced that his superiors have high hopes for him, he is drawn back again
to the practice of virtue. A kind word or a glance does more to encourage than a severe
reprimand, which only serves to dampen youthful enthusiasm.
Applying these methods, I was able to draw many to God and to the Religious life. Any other
means would have been impossible. Just as we all had to undergo the trials of teen age, so, too, it
is with every boy. Woe to them, if they are not helped to pass these days quickly and without
reproach! Oftentimes to close an eye to their faults is the best means to prevent their falling in
the future. Again, at times, though they are really guilty, they wish us to believe them innocent.
We shall be indeed fortunate if we learn to apply these means in our educational endeavors.
Perhaps you think that what I am suggesting is too easy or not practical enough. Yet I assure you
that if you abide by what I say, you will be successful. You will see that by these means you will
win over those who in the beginning had not given the least cause for any hope.
But you might ask me here, just what punishments can we use? My dear friends, know that God
likens Himself to a ‘virga vigilans’ -- a watching rod -- in order to keep us from sin also by the
fear of punishment. We can, therefore, imitate God’s example in this respect and prevent
disorder by threatening punishments. But we should be prudent and sparing in our use of this
means for obtaining discipline. If we are also kind and use our good judgment in employing
punishments, we will obtain the desired effect-the betterment of our youthful charges.
Force, indeed, punishes guilt, but does not heal the guilty. No one cultivates a tender plant with
harsh treatment, much less with violence. Likewise, you ought not to expect to train the will of
the young by imposing a heavy yoke upon them.
FORMS OF PUNISHMENTS
A reproachful or severe look often serves as an excellent means of moral restraint over the
young. By it, the guilty person is moved to consider his own fault, to feel ashamed, and finally to
repent and turn over a new leaf. A fatherly word in private is worth much more than many
sentences of reproachful language. Instill in the young the desire of reward or the thought of
doing honor to their dear ones or of showing gratitude towards them. In this way they are at
times incited to acts of great generosity.
If they fall into the same faults repeatedly, without losing sight of charity warn them in more
serious terms, contrasting your own conduct towards them with theirs towards you. Show them
how concerned you are to save them from chastisements and how little they repay your leniency
towards them. Never stoop to humiliating expressions; on the contrary, make it clear that you
entertain high hopes for them and assure them that you are ready to forget their faults as soon as
the take a turn for the better.
What about written punishments? Unfortunately, this way of punishing is only too common.
As regards this point I have looked up the opinions of the best educators. Some approve it;
others criticize it as useless and dangerous both to the pupils and teachers. You may use your
own judgment; however, I would warn you that it is very easy to go to excesses. By an abuse
of punishment you acquire no advantage for yourselves. You will only afford the pupils an