Market Risk
Market Risk
Market Risk
Page 1 of 26
Confidentiality statement
This document should not be carried outside the physical and virtual boundaries of TCS and
its client work locations. The sharing of this document with any person other than TCSer
would tantamount to violation of confidentiality agreement signed by you while joining
TCS.
Notice
The information given in this course material is merely for reference. Certain third party
terminologies or matter that may be appearing in the course are used only for contextual
identification and explanation, without an intention to infringe.
Page 2 of 26
Contents
Chapter 4 Basics of Market Risk..........................................................................................4
4.1 Market Risk.................................................................................................................. 5
4.2 Market Risk Management ...........................................................................................9
4.3 Market Risk Measurement ......................................................................................... 13
4.4 Risk limits ..................................................................................................................22
Summary ........................................................................................................................ 25
Page 3 of 26
Learning Objective
After reading this chapter you will:
To understand the basics of major financial risks i.e. market risk and credit risk
Page 4 of 26
Equity risk
ii.
Currency risk
iii.
iv.
v.
i.
Banks try to maximize their Net Interest Income (NII); the long-term objective of a
commercial bank is maximization of the market value of its net worth (which is the
difference between its assets and liabilities, both priced at the market value). The
immediate impact of interest rate changes is on the NII and the long-term impact is on the
Market Value of Equity (MVE) of the bank.
Asian Crisis of 1997-98 saw short-term Thai Baht interest rates exponentially increase, as
the authorities tried to prevent speculators who wanted to sell the Baht (which was pegged
at a fixed exchange rate to the US Dollar). Companies with huge loan liabilities were
adversely affected because of this sudden increase in interest rates.
a) Mismatch risk or Repricing risk: In a situation when short term deposit of say one
year maturity have been utilized for investment in long term Government securities
of say 5 years would result in a mismatch. In case interest rates on deposits increase
while the interest income on term loans and government securities remain same,
the interest spread would get reduced having adverse impact on banks interest
income.
b) Basis Risk: Basis risk or spread risk is the result which arises due to the change in
the relationship between the yields or yield curves of long and short positions with
the same maturity in different financial instruments.
Page 6 of 26
c) Yield-curve risk or Price risk: Banks value of investments at a specific interest rate
may suffer a set back or may depreciate if there is increase in market interest rates.
However, any decline in interest rate may result in banks portfolio. The change in
value of investments is on account of present value of the cash flows when
discounted by the new interest rates.
d) Option Risk: Option risk arises due to the change in assets and liabilities durations
when change occurs in interest rates. It also arises from the prepayment, cap, floor
and other options embedded in underlying mortgages, term deposits & other
products.
ii.
This risk is caused as a result of fluctuating exchange rates. These risk impacts businesses
indulged in exports and imports. An investment denominated in different currencies
attracts currency risk. Fluctuations in exchange rates affect investments. Emerging market
currencies exhibit more volatility in comparison to developed markets, thus exposing it to
higher currency risks.
During the Asian financial crisis, firms in the affected countries had taken loans from
western banks. Repayment of loans were agreed to be in foreign currency. As a result these
firms were exposed to foreign exchange risk, as there was no proper risk hedging in place.
As the domestic currency started to fall against the foreign currency, the amount of
domestic currency required making payments increased thus leading to bankruptcy of such
firms.
FOREX risk may include three types of commonly understood risks such as Transaction
Exposure, Translation Exposure and Economic Exposure which are briefly explained as
under:
a) Transaction Exposure: The risk arises due to adverse movement of the exchange
rate from the time the transaction is budgeted till the exposure is extinguished by
sale or purchase of foreign currency against the home currency.
b) Translation Exposure: it arises from the need to translate foreign currency assets
and liabilities into the home currency for the purpose of finalizing the accounts for
any given period. It can thus be defined as the risk which will alter the domestic
Page 7 of 26
currency value of assets and liabilities in the balance sheet, which arises when
translated at a foreign exchange rates, resulting in a reported gain or loss.
c) Economic Exposure: It can be defined as change in future earning power and cash
flow as a result of adjustment of the currencies. It is the sensitivity of the real
domestic currency value of Assets and Liabilities, or future operating incomes to
unanticipated changes in exchange rates.
The three important issues that need to be addressed in this regard are:
o
iii.
Equity Price Risk is the standard deviation of a securitys price over a number of periods.
This risk arises due to potential of the banks to suffer losses on its exposure to capital
markets from adverse movements in prices of equity. Banks use VaR models for
management of equity position risk.
iv.
v.
Liquidity Risk
Liquidity risk is caused due to mismatch in maturity of banks assets and liabilities.
Commercial bank deposits generally have a much a shorter contractual maturity than loans
and liquidity management needs to provide cushion to cover anticipated deposit
withdrawals. This risk may arise when a bank is unable to fund liabilities as these become
due for payment or may be able to fund the same at cost much higher than market cost.
The key ratios which need to be analyzed may include the following:
o
Total Liquid Assets to Total Assets ratio (the higher the ratio, more liquid is the
bank)
Page 8 of 26
Total Liquid Assets to Total Deposits Ratio (Ratio helps in measuring the banks
ability to meet withdrawals)
ii.
What is the quantum how much could the price change? What would be the effect
On profit and loss?
iii.
iv.
Management processes for market risk management are designed essentially to answer
these questions. Accordingly, management processes are sub-divided into following four
parts:
Risk Identification
All products and transactions should be analyzed for risks associated with them. The
various risks associated with standard products stand analyzed while that associated with
new or non-standrdized products need to be analyzed. Therefore, the approach for both
differs. Products approved at corporate levels shall provide for screening procedures,
Page 9 of 26
appropriate safeguards, product wise limit on exposure, and necessary guidelines in taking
risks. Any new product or any deviation from the directed procedures and safeguards add to
the risk content of exposure and need a clearance at the corporate level where risk return
characteristics and risk quantification forms the basis of decision-making.
Risk measurement
Market risk management framework is heavily dependent upon quantitative measures of
risk. The market risk measures seek to capture variations in market value arising out of
uncertainties associated with various market variables. These provide an objective measure
of market risk in a transaction or of a portfolio. Market risk measures are based on:
Basis Point Value (BPV): This is the change in value due to 1 basis point (0.01%)
change in market yield. This is used as a measure of risk. The higher the BPV of a
bond, higher is the risk associated with it. The computation of BPV is very simple.
For example, a 5 year 65 semi-annual bond @ market yield of 8% has a price of Rs
92, which rises to Rs 92.10 at a yield of 7.95 %. So, for one BP fall in yield, market
price changes by Rs 0.02 or gains by Rs 2000 per Rs 1 crore face values. BPV of the
bond is, therefore, Rs 2000 per crore face values.
Page 10 of 26
number. This is equivalent to time, on average, that the holder of the bond must
wait to receive the present value of the cash flows. It implies that if a 5 year 6%
bond face value of Rs 100 with semi-annual interest has McCauleys duration say 3.7
years, then total cash flow to be received over the five year period of Rs 130 from
the bond would be equivalent to receiving Rs 130 at the end of 3.7 years as a bullet
payment.
Duration or Modified duration is McCauleys duration discounted by 1 period yield
to maturity. The longer the duration of a security, the greater will be the price
sensitivity to yield changes and higher would be the risk associated with the bond.
Bond price changes can be estimated using modified duration using the following
relationship:
Approx % change in price = - Modified duration * Yield change
Risk mitigation
Risk mitigation arises due to volatility of financial instruments. The volatility of financial
instruments is instrumental for both profits and risk. Risk mitigation in market risk i.e.
reduction in market risk is achieved by adopting strategies that eliminate or reduce the
Page 11 of 26
volatility of the portfolio. However, there are a couple of issues that are associated with risk
mitigation measures.
Strategies using Sensitivity Measures: Say a portfolio has two bonds A and B of Rs
675 and Rs 205 respectively. The BPV of the portfolio would be the weighted
average of the BPVs of all the bonds in the portfolio. The portfolio BPV will be
(675+205)/2 = 440. Now, if we intend to reduce the risk of this portfolio, we may add
another bond in the portfolio such that its BPV is less than 440. Say we add one
more bond B in the portfolio. BPV of the portfolio will get reduced to 361.7.
Similar strategies are possible using other sensitivity measure- duration. Portfolio
duration may be increased by adding higher duration instruments or by reducing
lower duration instruments. Similarly, portfolio duration can be reduced by selling
higher duration instruments or by adding low duration instruments.
Page 12 of 26
Financial instruments take their price from the market and that depends upon
interaction of market variables. Hence, market risk management processes do not have
a risk pricing process. But, management of market risk needs an organization structure
in place that can carry out the functions required for the purpose.
Usually, the Market Risk Management organization would consist of:
-
The alternative methodology, which is subject to the fulfillment of certain conditions and
the use of which is therefore conditional upon the explicit approval of the banks supervisory
authority,
Page 13 of 26
This method allows banks to use risk measures derived from their own internal risk
management models, subject to sets of conditions, namely:
guidelines for specifying an appropriate set of market risk factors (i.e. the
market rates and prices that affect the value of banks positions);
rules for banks which use a mixture of models and the standardized approach
The standardized methodology uses a building-block approach in which specific risk and
the general market risk arising from debt and equity positions are calculated separately.
The focus of most internal models is a banks general market risk exposure, typically leaving
specific risk (i.e. exposures to specific issuers of debt securities or equities) to be measured
largely through separate credit risk measurement systems. Banks using these models
should be subject to capital charges for the specific risk not captured by their models.
i.
i.
Scenario Analysis
ii.
Value at risk
Page 14 of 26
historical event. It considers symmetric way of measure (up and down). A typical
procedure, often called stress testing, is to use a scenario based on a historically adverse
market move.
ii.
Value at Risk- Value at Risk (VAR) is generally accepted and widely used tool for
measuring market risk inherent in trading portfolios. Var is a tool for measuring an
entitys exposure to market risk. It is a quantitative measure of market risk at the
portfolio level. The use of Var as a risk indicator has become more proliferated since the
late 1980s, with the increased use of derivative instruments and tremendous volatility in
exchange rates; many firms had started to have portfolios that include large amounts of
cash and derivative instruments.
It follows the concept that reasonable expectation of loss can be deduced by evaluating
market rates, prices observed volatility and the correlation. VAR summarizes the
predicted maximum loss (or worst loss) over a target horizon within a given confidence
level.
The well-known proprietary models that use VAR approaches are JP Morgans Risk
metrics, Bankers trust Risk Adjusted Return on Capital, and Chases Value at risk.
Page 15 of 26
Var =
Expected change in
the portfolio value
-1.65
SD of change in
portfolio value (P)
In the graph given above the standard deviation of the portfolio is given and confidence
level = 95%. At this confidence level of 95% the critical value is 1.65 as mentioned above so
we calculate Var as std*1.65= 16.5.
The outcomes less than or equal to 1.65 below the mean, i.e. -1.65 occurs only 5% of the
times.
Page 16 of 26
This method relies on the assumption that the portfolios value changes linearly or
quadratically with the changes in the market risk, while this might not be the case always.
For instruments like options and option-like instruments, this method fails, especially if the
holding period is not very short (like 1 day). This is because the Delta-Normal method
typically incorporates options by linearizing the option positions or replacing the non-linear
functions that give their values with linear approximations.
b) Historical simulation- This method, forecasts for the influence of market changes can
be made. The method includes the use of historical changes in risk factors and
parameters observed over a particular period-extract. Usually, for that purpose the
banks go one year back, yet some banks use longer periods of 4 or more years. Here are
included all the interest rates, currency and exchange rates movements.
The Historical Simulation method values the portfolio using a series of historical price
data (of the assets in the portfolio) that is available. Under this method, the distribution
of profits (or losses) on the portfolio is constructed based on data from the past. The
current portfolio is subjected to the actual changes in the market factors experienced
during the last N periods.
The changes in portfolio value are sorted from the lowest value to the highest value and
the series is ranked according to the percentiles. This percentile scale represents the
confidence level scale, i.e., the loss at the 99th percentile will be the portfolios potential
price change calculated at a 99% confidence level. VAR is determined based on the
desired confidence interval. The Var is equal to the product of the value change at the
required percentile (confidence limit) and the current value of the portfolio.
Page 17 of 26
Date
% Change
% Change
12/10/1997
108
98
12/9/1997
100
8.00%
100
-2.00%
12/8/1997
98
2.04%
100
0.00%
9/2/1997
108
-4.91%
95
3.08%
9/1/1997
108
0.00%
93
-2.15%
Page 18 of 26
Date
Modeled
Value
% Change
12/9/199
Modeled
Portfolio
Value
Value
% Change
8.00%
116.64
-2.00%
96.04
212.68
2.04%
110.20
0.00%
98
208.20
7
12/8/199
7
9/2/1997
-4.91%
102.70
3.08%
101.01
203.71
9/1/1997
0.00%
108.00
-2.15%
95.893
203.89
Date
Portfolio Value
9/3/1997
200.71
12/4/1997
201.32
10/5/1997
202.31
3/6/1997
203.89
9/2/1997
203.71
99
4/7/1997
210.00
100
12/9/1997
212.68
Page 19 of 26
One of the advantages in the use of historical scenarios is that these scenarios have already
taken place. On the other hand, it is unlikely that in future historical events will happen
exactly the same way.
c) Monte Carlo method- Monte Carlo simulation got its name from Monte Carlo, Monaco,
the place of which the main attractions are casinos containing games of chance. The
random behavior in these games of chance is similar to Monte Carlo simulation which
selects variable values at random to simulate a model. Only the range for any variable is
known but these variables have an uncertain value for any particular time or event.
These variables can be interest rates, stock prices etc.
Monte Carlo simulation of VaR begins with a random draw on all the distributions
describing price and rate movements taking into account the correlations among these
variants. Mark-to-model and maturation values for all portfolio components at the VaR
horizon are determined based on that price/rate path. This process is repeated enough
times to achieve significance in the resulting end-of-horizon portfolio values. Then the
differences between the initial portfolio value and these end-of-horizon values are
ranked and the loss level at the Yth centile is reported as the VaR of the portfolio
Under it very large number of hypothetical scenarios on the basis of the measured
movements in the various market variables during the last year. On the basis of a 250day scenario used for the historical VaR, we create a countless number of possible
scenarios. Each historical result for an individual variable is combined with each possible
historical results combination for all the other market variables. As scenarios are
randomly drawn out of that large number of scenarios created by the model, the
analysis is called the Monte Carlo simulation.
Page 20 of 26
An example of how Monte Carlo simulations are carried out: The spot price of a
GBP/USD FX transaction is 1.25. Let the price of a one-year out-of-money call option be
1.25 too. The simulations are carried out by randomly changing the spot prices, to see
how the price of the option changes. Let the underlying asset for the option be worth
10million USD.
a) The time horizon (period) to be analyzed i.e. holding period (length of the time
to hold the assets in the portfolio)- This depends upon the objectives of the
portfolio and its liquidity positions. The shortest feasible holding period is one day.
Although it is theoretically possible for institutions to have time horizon less than a
day. The holding period in any market is, ideally, the length of time it takes to
ensure orderly liquidation of positions in that market.
b) The confidence level for the estimate-The confidence level/interval defines the
percentage of time the firm should not lose more than the Var amount. Most
commonly used confidence levels are 99% and 95%.
c) The Data Series- Var is fairly data intensive. The choice of historical, implied or
other types of data to determine various relationships is important, but typically
there is very little choice.
e) The currency unit which will be used to denominate the value at risk (Var)- With
the mentioned terms it can be defined as: Value at risk is the maximum amount that
Page 21 of 26
can be lost from an investment under normal market conditions for a holding period
and at a particular confidence level.
General criteria
The supervisory authority will only give its approval if at a minimum:
It is satisfied that the banks risk management system is conceptually sound and is
implemented with integrity;
The bank has in the supervisory authoritys view sufficient numbers of staff skilled in
the use of sophisticated models not only in the trading area but also in the risk
control, audit, and if necessary, back office areas;
The banks models have in the supervisory authoritys judgment a proven track
record of reasonable accuracy in measuring risk;
For interest rates, there must be a set of risk factors corresponding to interest rates
In each currency in which the bank has interest-rate-sensitive on- or off-balance
Sheet positions.
For exchange rates (which may include gold), the risk measurement system should
incorporate risk factors corresponding to the individual foreign currencies in which
the banks positions are denominated. Stress testing is used for exchange rate risk.
For equity prices, there should be risk factors corresponding to each of the equity
markets in which the bank holds significant positions.
For commodity prices, there should be risk factors corresponding to each of the
commodity markets in which the bank holds significant positions.
Page 22 of 26
i.
Gap Limits: The gap limits expressed in terms of interest sensitive ratio for a given time
band aims at managing potential exposure to a banks earnings / capital due to changes
in interest rates. Setting such limits is useful way to limit the volume of a banks
repricing exposures and is an adequate and effective method of communicating the risk
profile of the bank to senior management. Such gap limits can be set on a net notional
basis (net of asset/ liability amounts for both on and off balance sheet items) or a
duration-weighted basis, in each time band. (Duration is the weighted average term to
maturity of a securitys cash flow. For instance an Rs100 5 year 8% (semi Annual)
coupon bond having yield of 8% will have duration of 4.217 years as already explained in
the footnotes).
ii.
Factor Sensitivity Limits: The factor sensitivity of interest rate position is calculated by
discounting the position using current market interest rate and then using the current
market interest rate increase or decrease by one basis point. The difference in the two
values known as factor sensitivity is the potential for loss given one basis point change
in interest rate. Banks may introduce such limits for each time band as well as total
exposure across all time bands. The factor sensitivity limit measures the change in
portfolio present value given one basis point fluctuation in underlying interest rate.
Be independent from the risk-taking and operational units (e.g., trading unit and
settlement unit) that it reviews
Page 23 of 26
Have direct access to information from risk-taking and operational units in order for
it to carry out the market risk management and control function
Ensuring that all relevant market risks of the bank are identified, well understood,
and adequately measured and assessed
Page 24 of 26
Summary
Market risk is caused due to the variations in the market variables having
undesirable and unfavorable impact on earnings of a bank or on its capital.
The various risks associated with market risk are Interest rate risk, Foreign
exchange (FOREX) Risk, Equity Price risk, Commodity Price risk and Liquidity risk.
Management processes for risk management are sub-divided into following four
parts: Risk Identification, Risk Measurement, Risk Monitoring and Control, Risk
Mitigation.
Historical simulation method , assumes that asset returns in the future will have the
same distribution as they had in the past (historical market data),
Variance-covariance (VCV) method assumes that risk factor returns are always
(jointly) normally distributed and that the change in portfolio value is linearly
dependent on all risk factor returns.
Monte Carlo simulation method, where future asset returns are more or less
randomly simulated.
The liquidity risk in banks manifest in different dimensions like funding risk, time
risk and call risk.
Rating migration is the change in the rating of a borrower over a period of time
when rated on the same standard or model.
Page 25 of 26
Page 26 of 26